year,geo_code,geo_name,geo_short,geo_system,value,instrument_era,indicator,dimension,subdimension,level,total_method 2011,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.26411,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.914581,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.714875,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.8689144,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.76248,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.566878,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.889205,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.537545,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.993628,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.660269,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.085445,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.982788,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.728503,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.118291,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.585172,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.6428216,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.652779,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,4.999064,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.583421,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.869782,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.623258,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.787709,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,6.86417,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.746413,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.645679,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.996759,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.668323,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,7.057175,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,36.40502,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.937742,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.755304,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.502331,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.6808273,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,4.876205,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.688166,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.694797,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.446219,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,4.829181,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.933776,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.443151,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.630147,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,5.007073,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.338472,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.632161,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.824716,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.425359,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,5.220708,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.499651,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.710305,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.326345,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.912416,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,6.448717,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.627907,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.342051,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.312513,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.58895,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,5.871421,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,32.253305,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.085203,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.145658,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.47375,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.6046797,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,5.309291,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.444922,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.712191,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.359177,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,5.516291,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.752172,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.544819,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.50193,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,4.798923,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.8312734,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.425056,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.4630081,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.334643,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,4.05398,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.50152,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.819966,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.528709,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.738738,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,6.588932,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.866179,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.557192,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.197825,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.634879,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,6.256076,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,32.523493,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.313012,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.9661,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.653428,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.6694564,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.601996,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.213166,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.847122,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.7128,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.773088,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.905725,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.871862,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.947661,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.725249,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.541285,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.788792,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.8071529,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.747857,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.885087,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.819549,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.816267,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.623094,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.938614,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,7.197525,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.953417,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.539845,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.474143,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.51293,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,6.480335,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,36.66328,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.134707,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.73558,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.473989,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.8837959,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,5.228072,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.384736,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.733005,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.423933,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,5.541674,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.852681,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.634758,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.884345,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,5.371785,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.45074,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.67484,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.9547899,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.715453,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,5.795823,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.589116,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.864233,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.408184,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.863673,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,6.725205,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.895485,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.634307,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.46568,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.601351,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,6.596823,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,35.259382,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.156216,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.04512,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.635505,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.7091023,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.545943,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.243659,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.030288,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.556832,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.830779,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.863893,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.948498,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.761027,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.573418,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.270756,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.579288,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.9665759,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.667452,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.484072,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.526646,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.631131,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.397199,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.895192,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,6.450169,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.964216,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.363128,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.226304,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.674888,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,6.228536,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,35.112917,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.072177,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.929369,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.339069,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.4938953,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,4.83451,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.574818,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.704393,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.449443,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,5.728653,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.982322,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.767379,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.71251,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,5.462211,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.064244,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.684429,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.6986302,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.621935,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,5.069239,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.603676,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.812025,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.532695,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.76048,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,6.708876,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.778447,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.739415,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.229232,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.596752,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,6.343846,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,34.147335,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.130781,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.810195,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.505103,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.7204039,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,5.166482,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.963,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.701136,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.420602,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,5.084737,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.897817,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.699368,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.60138,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,5.198565,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.12144,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.676862,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.9493663,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.558947,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,5.306615,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.614654,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.727552,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.45953,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.873553,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,6.675288,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.947526,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.533959,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.412175,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.60202,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,6.49568,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,33.927367000000004,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.455008,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.278709,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.853783,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.054626,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,6.642126,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,3.13873,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.063211,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.334458,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,6.536399,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.865604,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.023913,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.953496,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,5.843012,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.147152,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.902262,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.7164018,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.916704,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,6.682519,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.562504,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.866294,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.461389,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.794482,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,6.684669,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.949221,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.675617,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.480877,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.722771,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,6.828486,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,39.217211,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.163362,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.76574,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.428602,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.7995335,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,5.157237,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.847545,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.58309,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.619202,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,6.049838,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.205921,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.761312,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.728938,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,5.696171,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.443037,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.706833,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.8484327,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.771057,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,5.769361,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.765875,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.849602,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.566388,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.907289,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,7.089154,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.826724,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.39318,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.267583,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.495453,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,5.98294,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,35.744701,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.278834,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.213502,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.605172,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.051716,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,6.149224,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.378661,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.91998,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.688595,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.987236,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.180379,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.037127,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.836251,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,6.053757,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.626067,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.774414,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.7457112,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.571184,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.717377,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.644816,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.677904,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.558698,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.796141,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,6.677558,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.763243,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.634093,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.563725,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.686381,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,6.647443,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,37.232595,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.185967,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.839579,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.511477,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.7494633,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.286486,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.392725,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.974229,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.58828,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.955234,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.93931,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.900402,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.695541,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.535253,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.384347,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.712312,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.8180987,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.577295,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.492052,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.861583,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.855418,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.390202,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.855536,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,6.962739,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.709864,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.433503,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.594471,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.557111,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,6.29495,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,35.526714,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.355599,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.053136,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.774319,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.8217499,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,6.004803,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.57583,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.165573,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.638906,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,6.380309,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.732241,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.130826,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.001225,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,5.864292,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.639141,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.987092,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.9887426,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.748347,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,6.363323,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.789799,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.603916,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.625919,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.731796,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,6.75143,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.964107,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.665111,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.728882,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.661427,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,7.019526,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,38.383683,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.206601,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.060618,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.458159,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.7815524,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,5.50693,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.22621,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.820749,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.516925,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,5.563884,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.021885,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.999327,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.960703,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,5.981915,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.036586,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.404891,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.5537671,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.586577,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,4.581821,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.542487,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.576541,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.812184,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.6643,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,6.595512,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.911922,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.615705,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.605819,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.545118,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,6.678566,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,34.908628,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.119716,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.783275,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.683685,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.041122,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,5.627799,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.145835,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.849319,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.493433,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,5.488588,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.67367,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.866268,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.904743,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,5.444681,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.123605,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.606852,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.5339329,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.71231,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,4.976701,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.497521,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.850174,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.516025,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.979447,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,6.843168,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.761473,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.656613,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.450779,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.653546,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,6.52241,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,34.903347000000004,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.19956,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.893927,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.717226,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.8603357,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,5.671049,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.287191,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.451507,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.285915,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,5.024613,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.92909,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.045003,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.891918,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,5.86601,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.355716,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.789468,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.877461,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.655218,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,5.677862,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.628848,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.918087,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.556781,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.799096,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,6.902812,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.837313,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.643893,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.524915,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.572237,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,6.578358,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,35.720704,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.174406,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.005409,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.439916,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.839729,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,5.45946,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.174773,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.720148,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.481834,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,5.376756,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.660405,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.885831,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.116065,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,5.662301,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.501827,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.691183,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.6603413,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.77436,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,5.627712,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.599931,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.753652,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.535557,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.838974,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,6.728115,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.632794,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.906807,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.784158,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.606156,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,6.929915,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,35.784259,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.257221,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.09271,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.63501,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.9605521,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.945492,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.195421,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.698996,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.405834,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.300251,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.5617,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.072768,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.902229,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.536696,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.102233,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.495684,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.5190073,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.639753,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,4.756677,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.569583,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.877422,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.588114,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.838352,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,6.873471,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.705368,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.599736,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.916204,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.51045,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,6.731758,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,35.144345,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.248137,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.039742,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.458032,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.9345444,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,5.680454,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.418834,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.715071,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.758857,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,5.892763,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.923713,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.355387,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.991783,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,6.270883,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.284879,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.632258,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.728332,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.862783,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,5.508252,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.6927,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.608283,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.538153,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.694246,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,6.533383,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.79077,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.731229,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.970555,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.521419,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,7.013973,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,36.899708,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.200067,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.806136,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.471469,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.7009497,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,5.178622,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.24493,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.813251,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.248933,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,5.307114,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.833465,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.53481,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.404968,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,4.773243,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.9597398,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.299524,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.7224222,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.613581,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,4.595267,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.582784,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.891877,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.657522,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.878082,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,7.010265,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.602297,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.590012,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.463895,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.676292,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,7.332496,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,34.197007,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.110931,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.788916,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.535405,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.6721683,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.107419,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.072737,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.541832,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.416884,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.031453,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.381748,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.938794,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.824585,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.145127,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.146326,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.460338,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.7665384,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.56894,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,4.942143,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.667432,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.886836,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.333895,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.922558,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,6.81072,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.624987,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.506494,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.777475,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.552336,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,6.461293,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,33.498155,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.08398,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.849156,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.474351,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.9268028,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,5.334291,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.996194,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.94576,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.903074,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,5.845027,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.87314,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.214227,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.334648,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,6.422015,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.285195,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.530757,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.675328,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.614797,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,5.106078,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.700614,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.62396,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.660699,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.826657,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,6.811929,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.872604,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.630213,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.553579,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.57401,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,6.630406,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,36.149746,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.160259,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.926099,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.513176,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.7533945,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,5.352929,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.286245,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.897212,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.387031,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,5.570489,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.033296,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.170094,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.045687,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,6.249077,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.42735,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.641311,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.7678518,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.744038,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,5.580551,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.502029,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.760347,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.639879,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.800545,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,6.702801,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.61088,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.604445,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.423261,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.577848,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,6.216433,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,35.67228,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.201967,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.901551,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.547008,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.7288134,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,5.379339,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.652982,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.25561,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.743038,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,6.65163,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.037496,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.220913,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.037506,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,6.295915,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.382032,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.628443,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.020144,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.882057,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,5.912676,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.909247,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.827344,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.68044,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.957025,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,7.374056,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.49491,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.712442,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.884642,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.678445,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,6.770439,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,38.384055,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.9678025,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.494569,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.558276,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.86163,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,4.882277,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.225426,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.56312,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.442897,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,5.231442,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.623312,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.629696,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.825659,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,5.078667,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.048167,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.502831,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.6024257,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.777969,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,4.931393,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.790365,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.768103,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.550767,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.907918,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,7.017153,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.598306,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.626386,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.689263,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.545099,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,6.459054,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,33.599986,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.225473,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.803354,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.631065,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.8831248,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,5.543016,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.635071,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.779795,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.549795,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,5.964661,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.036047,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.100137,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.806999,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,5.943183,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.336618,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.785536,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.9287286,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.684691,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,5.735574,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.848236,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.825822,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.647932,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.938167,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,7.260157,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.822714,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.824911,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.527471,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.606906,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,6.782002,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,37.228593,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.199325,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.927152,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.569641,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.7091422,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.40526,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.426854,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.847646,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.66301,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.93751,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.225247,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.107531,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.98558,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,6.318358,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.211005,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.658282,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.7932842,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.709659,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.372231,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.79462,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.681017,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.491632,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.869244,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,6.836513,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.832831,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.659538,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.381928,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.539208,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,6.413505,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,36.283377,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.143853,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.067013,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.584533,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.8336529,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,5.629052,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.740739,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.130146,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.813707,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,6.684592,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.216776,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.223412,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.071119,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,6.511307,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.550958,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.625067,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.7740997,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.968387,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,5.918511,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.880874,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.769476,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.492613,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.008465,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,7.151428,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.05709,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.467056,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.682432,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.647701,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,6.854278,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,38.749168,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.492693,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.085098,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.657284,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.058009,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,6.293084,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.400568,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.148382,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.801826,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,6.350776,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.031462,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.354032,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.185417,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,6.570911,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.802433,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.884704,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.9872204,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.777449,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,6.451807,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.909684,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.842756,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.725845,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.987229,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,7.465513,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.900747,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.710275,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.071185,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.537622,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,7.21983,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,40.351921,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.329225,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.155398,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.701187,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.6973785,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,5.883188,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.143367,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.173276,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.778917,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,6.09556,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.346846,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.236401,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.401149,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,6.984396,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.515205,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.757952,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.7522734,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.768891,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,5.794321,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.918899,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.871518,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.554831,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.966458,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,7.311706,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.916895,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.664385,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.879989,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.57958,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,7.040849,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,39.11002,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.164056,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.938235,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.456187,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.718454,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.276932,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.287637,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.620077,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.446656,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.354371,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.942854,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.639482,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.748281,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.330616,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.388417,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.857406,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.7457396,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.71452,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.706082,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.639512,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.693197,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.477675,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.834014,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,6.644399,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.811087,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.652263,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.790975,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.716573,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,6.970898,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,35.283298,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.15187,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.808665,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.454136,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.863815,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,5.278487,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.119093,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.752099,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.584949,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,5.456141,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.153575,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.736791,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.900048,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,5.790415,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.46272,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.883751,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.022878,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.71422,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,6.083569,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.882197,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.867341,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.642887,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.939682,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,7.332107,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.924405,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.698668,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.271634,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.535334,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,7.430041,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,37.37076,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.041314,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.896631,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.662096,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.7294171,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,5.329458,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.207768,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.820638,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.688254,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,5.71666,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.839117,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.793886,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.776332,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,5.409335,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.553515,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.852507,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.211298,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.674437,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,6.291757,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.598343,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.648747,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.410586,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.789705,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,6.447381,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.101797,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.663322,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.411495,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.661569,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,6.838182,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,36.032773,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.054932,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.893188,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.3434,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.7571567,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,5.048677,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.682621,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.071519,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.551626,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,5.305767,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.073755,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.727345,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.777024,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,5.578123,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.267076,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.659106,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.7314517,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.695802,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,5.353436,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.509032,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.550641,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.523483,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.825997,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,6.409153,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.742429,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.44261,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.505322,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.61597,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,6.306332,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,34.001488,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.273893,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.220003,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.651635,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.7387066,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,5.884237,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.324452,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.584242,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.773192,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,5.681886,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.814422,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.272174,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.917939,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,6.004536,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.750072,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.019128,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.196722,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.979309,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,6.945232,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.687673,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.816987,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.438016,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.959572,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,6.902247,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.949929,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.698044,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.675656,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.689755,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,7.013384,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,38.431522,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.041196,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.714552,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.382869,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.6240537,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,4.76267,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.938665,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.551974,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.52839,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,5.019029,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.890625,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.696886,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.624422,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,5.211934,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.091746,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.620994,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.6328751,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.747994,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,5.09361,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.521978,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.626737,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.63551,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.794469,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,6.578695,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.595418,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.633089,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.476064,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.559743,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,6.264314,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,32.930251999999996,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.028085,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.940445,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.538349,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.8469094,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,5.353788,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.291712,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.789282,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.452279,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,5.533273,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.009572,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.667803,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.600314,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,5.277689,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.265796,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.587704,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.7378942,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.671651,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,5.263045,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.542023,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.807669,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.278537,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.805628,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,6.433857,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.728944,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.552033,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.824296,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.558504,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,6.663778,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,34.52543,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.007585,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.904975,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.446779,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.7029309,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,5.06227,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.642776,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.518414,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.48029,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,4.641479,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.253194,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.533161,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.73565,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,5.522005,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.051244,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.709218,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.6505885,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.720691,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,5.131741,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.704036,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.853964,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.536127,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.968871,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,7.062998,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.910865,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.5556,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.891233,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.565335,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,6.923033,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,34.343526,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.9571708,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.674447,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.26443,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.4248174,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,4.320866,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.713879,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.623659,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.544281,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,4.881819,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.895938,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.771995,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.768906,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,5.43684,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.374367,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.855147,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.003147,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.584996,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,5.817658,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.558517,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.712428,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.531883,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.854811,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,6.65764,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.653316,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.71868,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.887484,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.223232,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,6.482713,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,33.597536,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.14102,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.930581,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.358428,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.8299435,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,5.259974,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.006649,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.882398,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.274637,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,5.163684,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.246154,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.808088,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.579168,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,5.63341,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.202823,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.706858,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.7614272,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.662261,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,5.333369,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.773854,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.847913,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.640845,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.88583,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,7.148442,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.852007,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.680024,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.674572,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.531258,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,6.737861,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,35.27674,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.276153,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.865576,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.753239,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.5793139,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,5.474282,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.534854,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.84204,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.625369,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,6.002263,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.865179,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.805821,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.764134,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,5.435134,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.29373,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.715039,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.7904376,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.851623,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,5.65083,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.069058,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.682231,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.57171,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.761663,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,7.084662,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.623713,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.651915,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.445896,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.595941,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,6.317464,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,35.964635,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.09526,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.889932,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.524278,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.5889276,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,5.098397,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.430263,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.902539,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.468946,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,5.801748,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.976871,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.767324,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.78836,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,5.532555,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.166014,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.504646,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.6887829,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.669289,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,5.028733,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.676823,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.839702,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.505704,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.985861,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,7.00809,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.774989,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.65178,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.583009,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.562673,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,6.572452,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,35.041975,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.194472,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.917892,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.709512,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.9040996,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,5.725976,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.436305,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.01491,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.441143,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,5.892358,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.993769,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.800236,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.75929,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,5.553295,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.539413,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.647649,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.7876168,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.775901,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,5.75058,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.96981,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.721244,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.618382,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.889864,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,7.1993,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.535444,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.9367915,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.609884,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.598707,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,5.680825,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,35.802334,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.092079,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.960733,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.387981,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.8103676,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,5.251161,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.57821,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.60392,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.421848,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,4.603978,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.110162,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.695506,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.725585,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,5.531252,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.17199,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.581788,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.5384798,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.733123,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,5.025381,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.76481,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.711889,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.752226,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.945764,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,7.174689,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.46875,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.645809,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.976076,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.540068,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,6.630703,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,34.217164,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.119501,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.828548,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.473577,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.012159,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,5.433785,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.39256,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.11008,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.518213,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,6.020853,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.062173,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.984067,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.801444,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,5.847684,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.365229,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.62907,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.8755134,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.64301,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,5.512823,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.874924,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.727643,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.556572,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.970686,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,7.129824,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.492307,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.264849,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.544779,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.617107,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,5.919043,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,35.864012,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.8176692,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.561858,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.219549,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.8040305,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,4.403107,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.69545,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.350398,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.581076,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,4.626924,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.003385,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.705557,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.480449,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,5.189391,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.330984,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.61134,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.053099,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.245587,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,5.24101,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.609283,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.759511,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.499915,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.847027,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,6.715736,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.679758,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.652788,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.397421,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.636101,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,6.366068,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,32.542236,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.065071,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.745766,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.240267,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.032542,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,5.083646,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.090189,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.857452,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.528056,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,5.475698,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.072939,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.694716,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.617919,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,5.385574,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.823155,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.087957,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.425409,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.847071,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,7.183592,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.817847,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.777597,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.73523,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.815652,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,7.146326,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.729505,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.62787,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.806595,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.690482,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,6.854453,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,37.129289,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.166712,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.813504,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.431862,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.045746,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,5.457825,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.143747,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.674462,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.569175,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,5.387383,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.827014,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.652421,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.664681,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,5.144117,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.407616,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.754398,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.0032,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.700531,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,5.865746,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.847195,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.80192,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.589253,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.906408,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,7.144776,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.619817,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.720916,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.778363,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.541232,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,6.660327,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,35.660174,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.387805,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.131415,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.483022,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.9609783,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,5.96322,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.786321,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.297411,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.765307,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,6.849039,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.911893,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.932437,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.68693,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,5.53126,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.836011,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.118121,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.266284,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.670074,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,6.890491,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.916925,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.86088,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.654956,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.99492,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,7.427681,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.771637,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.69522,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.233707,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.592134,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,7.292699,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,39.95439,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.100973,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.897464,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.347482,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.7971049,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,5.143024,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.363126,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.10259,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.539997,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,6.005712,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.778108,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.750954,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.711281,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,5.240344,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.489532,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.825625,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.05625,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.776546,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,6.147952,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.87522,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.771966,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.66542,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.768029,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,7.080636,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.754726,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.678336,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.12218,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.59283,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,7.148072,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,36.76574,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.363052,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.023687,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.311521,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.071353,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,5.769613,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.356336,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.942362,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.850304,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,6.149002,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.166481,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.963702,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.127236,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,6.257419,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.919238,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.048708,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.426269,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.966103,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,7.360318,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.851104,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.614536,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.724489,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.994893,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,7.185021,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.881669,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.064651,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.559018,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.611064,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,7.116402,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,39.837775,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.239897,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.20189,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.370432,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.9219993,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,5.734218,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.340391,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.844124,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.703921,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,5.888436,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.956596,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.860356,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.972758,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,5.78971,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.945137,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.103244,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.478413,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.346482,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,6.873276,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.689053,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.650825,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.652765,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.932064,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,6.924706,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.831757,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.674849,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.261625,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.691031,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,6.459263,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,37.669609,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.352068,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.10804,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.47646,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.8509104,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,5.787479,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.322259,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.821999,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.786838,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,5.931097,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.474959,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.709157,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.937699,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,5.121816,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.582084,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.972142,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.134388,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.839215,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,6.52783,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.617074,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.651548,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.665578,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.868174,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,6.802374,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.944048,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.649952,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.684163,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.677215,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,6.955378,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,37.125974,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.8473492,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.922188,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.228435,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.6899119,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,4.687884,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.649931,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.35888,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.426545,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,4.435356,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.849697,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.640482,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.620355,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,5.110535,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.339569,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.610036,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.9992815,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.9754014,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,4.924287,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.411406,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.707618,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.493774,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.746805,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,6.359602,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.805328,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.645014,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.311062,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.6482,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,6.409603,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,31.927267,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.9291893,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.825806,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.53814,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.949614,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,5.242749,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.094966,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.341124,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.644425,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,5.080515,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.982476,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.627506,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.78542,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,5.395402,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.530559,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.841205,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.9406866,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.685027,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,5.997477,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.845792,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.775788,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.486078,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.967666,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,7.075324,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.918089,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.689451,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.753472,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.652098,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,7.01311,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,35.804577,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.8742159,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.80039,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.345135,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.163044,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,5.182785,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.087648,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.838437,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.550253,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,5.476338,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.929068,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.200966,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.811399,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,5.941434,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.728041,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.04059,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.471231,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.520791,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,6.760653,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.701292,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.795936,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.915427,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.781441,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,7.194096,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.649468,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.741338,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.629269,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.64621,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,6.666285,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,37.221591,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.9934983,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.802847,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.232308,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.8409326,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,4.869586,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.873526,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.594972,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.490441,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,4.958939,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.814792,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.412714,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.507732,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,4.735237,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.184035,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.77438,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.9065182,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.675374,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,5.540307,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.55632,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.764913,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.495508,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.650821,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,6.467561,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.732087,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.67341,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.797593,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.602222,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,6.805312,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,33.376942,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.053262,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.899963,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.263792,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.8749431,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,5.09196,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.637765,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.786493,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.342901,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,4.767159,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.842943,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.654449,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.793106,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,5.290498,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.367535,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.596329,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.13556,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.638474,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,5.737898,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.56618,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.862933,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.638857,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.798774,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,6.866744,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.727113,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.692685,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.955261,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.619164,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,6.994224,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,34.748483,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.268982,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.808011,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.620718,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.019212,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,5.716923,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.960652,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.804607,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.72548,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,5.490738,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.128985,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.612361,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.80566,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,5.547006,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.442254,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.892582,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.07791,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.538432,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,5.951178,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.476052,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.64985,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.475877,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.751663,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,6.353442,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.798383,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.404664,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.748512,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.598685,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,6.550245,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,35.609532,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.029694,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.748022,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.525313,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.6668645,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,4.969893,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.877535,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.435414,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.476686,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,4.789634,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.854458,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.943508,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.473347,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,5.271314,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.532455,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.85081,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.104249,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.278091,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,5.765605,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.690855,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.759294,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.576172,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.76024,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,6.786561,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.740993,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.642484,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.619754,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.712622,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,6.715853,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,34.29886,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.8241658,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.790606,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.510649,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.7744985,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,4.899919,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.009997,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.432871,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.479298,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,4.922166,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.76098,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.728151,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.663082,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,5.152213,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.922185,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.251206,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.305248,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.465753,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,6.944393,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.37815,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.808648,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.510209,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.87828,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,6.575285,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.743388,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.64372,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.660067,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.588087,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,6.635262,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,35.129238,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.9148911,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.702556,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.340459,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.6794755,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,4.637381,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.956814,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.402096,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.315614,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,4.674524,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.676138,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.66443,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.722756,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,5.063324,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.527133,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.949369,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.15242,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.67269,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,6.301612,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.454472,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.885903,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.676616,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.841896,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,6.858888,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.613356,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.737585,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.765749,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.627965,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,6.744656,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,34.280385,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2011,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.049867,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.661893,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.454409,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.6462086,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,4.812378,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2011,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.099819,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.465394,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.890981,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,5.456194,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2011,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.826627,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.836437,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.516998,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,5.180061,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2011,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.586057,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.884188,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.326866,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.064025,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,6.861135,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2011,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.56009,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.72493,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.559025,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.003697,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,6.847742,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2011,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.752527,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2011,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.526726,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2011,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.403378,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2011,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.637646,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2011,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,6.320277,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2011,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,35.477787,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.187747,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.818143,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.662915,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.8378373,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.506642,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.682247,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.966404,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.614339,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,6.262991,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.876521,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.069296,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.111242,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,6.057058,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.209253,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.4994,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.705013,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.764811,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.178477,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.726166,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.783883,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.552957,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.804534,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,6.86754,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.676689,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.640168,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.055675,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.647945,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,7.020477,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,36.893185,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.021124,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.994788,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.49726,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.7665197,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,5.279693,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.346021,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.787134,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.531534,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,5.664689,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.253114,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.083983,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.128112,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,5.465209,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.274836,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.822512,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.8285423,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.590867,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,5.516757,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.545255,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.780389,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.526374,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.822424,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,6.674441,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.062771,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.784477,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.379484,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.581934,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,6.808666,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,35.409455,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.0793,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.934277,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.725274,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.8013953,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,5.540246,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.226231,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.380345,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.67319,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,6.279766,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.12875,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.644344,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.750423,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,5.523517,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.282347,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.403488,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.8017719,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.25754,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,4.745146,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.627121,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.742256,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.547403,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.948218,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,6.864997,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.947916,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.566431,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.281377,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.592231,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,6.387956,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,35.341628,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.103446,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.902829,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.745397,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.8559472,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.607619,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.172025,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.803178,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.798813,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.774017,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.310497,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.985231,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.942334,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,6.238062,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.66209,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.014534,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.9970666,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.863696,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,6.537386,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.810032,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.800681,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.534025,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.969194,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,7.113933,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.0365,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.683506,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.519479,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.52993,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,6.769415,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,38.040432,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.012754,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.696557,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.450964,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.8795671,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,5.039843,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.167849,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.962761,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.545448,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,5.676058,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.790789,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.917094,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.883888,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,5.591772,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.611057,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.786084,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.9513937,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.749114,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,6.09765,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.686329,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.804213,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.490161,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.006974,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,6.987677,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.890183,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.822155,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.523193,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.555288,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,6.79082,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,36.18382,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.267483,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.007265,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.61422,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.070301,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.959269,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.420967,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.937232,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.554179,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.912377,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.052878,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.989443,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.945598,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.987919,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.422167,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.602887,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.7843921,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.813442,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.622889,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.875141,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.923456,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.667348,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.002907,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,7.468852,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.146648,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.440349,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.333309,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.598552,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,6.518858,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,37.470164,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.9046277,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.827201,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.351839,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.5061557,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,4.589823,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.713675,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.848991,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.291619,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,5.854285,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.973279,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.772405,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.459868,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,5.205552,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.905188,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.263393,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.484932,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.584855,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,4.238368,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.708924,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.964161,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.611565,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.87054,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,7.155191,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.89924,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.805234,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.411307,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.647614,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,6.763395,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,33.806614,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.8776609,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.789105,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.35542,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.5402663,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,4.562452,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.357222,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.671808,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.284528,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,5.313558,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.849073,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.707931,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.735578,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,5.292583,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.031698,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.622528,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.5310512,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.484943,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,4.67022,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.554733,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.535438,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.446841,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.82597,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,6.362981,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.963419,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.910651,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.349549,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.643724,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,6.867343,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,33.069137,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.139031,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.864772,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.536027,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.7330846,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,5.272914,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.5577,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.806618,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.537501,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,5.901819,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.205375,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.026346,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.920822,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,6.152543,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.693968,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.945966,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.052058,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.678092,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,6.370084,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.748879,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.785379,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.557624,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.975571,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,7.067453,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.786011,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.578835,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.471603,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.596709,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,6.433158,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,37.197971,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.129671,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.828741,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.620125,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.92633,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,5.504867,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.421564,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.785697,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.494913,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,5.702175,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.840271,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.805895,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.792247,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,5.438413,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.180249,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.63272,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.5687228,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.689235,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,5.070926,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.997288,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.947353,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.610493,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.999631,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,7.554765,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.90189,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.605936,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.279226,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.529866,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,6.316918,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,35.588064,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.094698,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.87894,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.72587,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.8513235,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.550831,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.659134,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.653496,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.51572,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.82835,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.935398,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.667841,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.948824,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.552064,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.450768,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.77827,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.9349177,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.687856,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.851812,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.629788,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.862777,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.498251,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.940815,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,6.931631,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.760872,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.887853,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.545578,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.655886,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,6.850189,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,36.564877,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.167979,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.781628,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.735487,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.8726228,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.557717,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.603202,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.797168,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.641654,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,6.042024,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.885839,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.111716,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.796145,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.793701,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.494029,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.689236,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.6829439,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.551937,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.418146,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.675895,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.763066,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.617542,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.963685,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,7.020188,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.717204,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.701887,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.744574,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.490971,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,6.654637,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,36.486413,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.024974,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.75842,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.712914,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.5678458,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,5.064154,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.210345,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.261532,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.597772,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,6.069649,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.170417,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.100049,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.032804,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,6.30327,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.659864,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.913721,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.9836901,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.751505,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,6.30878,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.838118,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.617953,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.678906,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.882772,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,7.017749,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.917831,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.679991,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.801799,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.603084,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,7.002706,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,37.766308,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.093057,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.004892,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.584646,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.7259095,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,5.408504,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.298782,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.031873,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.568204,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,5.89886,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.974894,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.189547,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.814748,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,5.979188,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.266223,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.686702,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.7887294,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.689128,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,5.430783,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.665578,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.709615,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.181283,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.725869,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,6.282346,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.89154,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.31787,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.704097,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.596082,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,6.509588,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,35.509269,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.192169,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.989089,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.684542,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.8704544,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,5.736254,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.361781,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.665678,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.450205,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,5.477664,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.491655,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.974051,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.9133,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,5.379006,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.593863,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.860031,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.9435908,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.856669,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,6.254153,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.568053,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.697597,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.649616,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.867956,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,6.783223,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.759106,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.650812,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.655115,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.516185,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,6.581217,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,36.211517,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.239561,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.898056,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.801411,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.9762269,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,5.915255,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.655907,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.91839,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.539382,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,6.113678,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.056516,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.935927,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.890995,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,5.883438,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.645828,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.916951,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.067922,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.800837,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,6.431537,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.02994,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.673403,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.467053,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.055998,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,7.226393,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.824443,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.658854,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.514625,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.59094,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,6.588862,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,38.159163,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.193259,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.787297,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.576755,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.9004997,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,5.457811,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.226733,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.971527,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.519174,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,5.717434,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.75253,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.902218,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.212936,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,5.867685,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.627412,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.819323,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.130581,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.558345,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,6.135661,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.66691,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.89088,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.573217,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.899737,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,7.030745,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.805231,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.611686,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.894392,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.482798,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,6.794108,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,37.003444,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.175068,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.742567,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.783322,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.022115,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.723071,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.149009,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.524941,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.44222,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.11617,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.595717,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.777637,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.984846,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.3582,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.414046,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.638866,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.8668827,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.702264,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.622058,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.535763,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.749876,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.568464,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.723455,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,6.577559,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.650394,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.772678,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.963383,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.530589,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,6.917044,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,35.314102,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.228265,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.954231,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.504117,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.747223,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,5.433835,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.343393,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.718807,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.529266,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,5.591466,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.134592,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.396819,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.245267,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,6.776677,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.360299,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.70005,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.8415249,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.892194,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,5.794068,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.697469,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.704094,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.64876,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.940646,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,6.990969,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.780153,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.617,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.147164,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.59913,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,7.143447,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,37.730462,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.276875,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.835815,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.589792,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.6618101,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,5.364292,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.781133,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.888875,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.466293,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,6.136301,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.035694,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.913783,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.429564,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,5.379041,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.047773,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.482899,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.6248205,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.677345,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,4.832838,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.694967,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.900838,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.793025,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.927216,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,7.316046,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.688208,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.649328,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.457927,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.643625,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,7.439088,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,36.467606,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.108822,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.801459,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.586918,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.101449,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.598649,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.602686,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.67719,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.506391,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.786267,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.791785,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.060132,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.01646,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.868378,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.461752,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.657227,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.9026434,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.772822,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.794444,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.710106,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.79752,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.453074,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.761197,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,6.721897,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.755989,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.596847,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.85048,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.611829,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,6.815145,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,36.58478,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.441644,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.005833,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.589426,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.083506,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,6.120409,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.604575,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.222238,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.94478,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,6.771593,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.005983,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.66941,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.287047,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,6.96244,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.610839,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.686161,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.9084442,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.932673,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,6.138117,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.961671,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.738137,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.461968,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.936292,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,7.098068,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.874163,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.849984,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.553456,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.604402,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,6.882005,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,39.972632,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.250951,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.08253,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.643114,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.011905,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,5.988501,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.711476,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.102877,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.910159,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,6.724512,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.871355,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.53083,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.980427,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,6.382612,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.730663,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.878118,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.9509172,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.930944,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,6.490642,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.65372,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.832597,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.72234,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.912553,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,7.121209,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.826301,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.657396,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.476357,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.648777,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,6.608832,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,39.316308,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.196913,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.863555,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.492545,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.8460799,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,5.399093,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.620269,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.196222,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.859705,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,6.676195,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.913247,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.48577,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.165896,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,6.564913,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.554709,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.66002,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.042742,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.95523,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,6.2127,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.848755,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.709018,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.755432,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.898455,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,7.21166,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.84215,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.674698,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.049843,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.764029,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,7.33072,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,39.395281,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.009445,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.459829,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.554753,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.8929385,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,4.916965,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.409333,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.558112,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.664427,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,5.631872,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.826669,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.720816,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.912958,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,5.460443,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.645911,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.855569,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.9262961,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.654662,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,6.082438,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.652292,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.735916,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.759058,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.962659,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,7.109926,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.61445,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.622583,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.948683,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.592622,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,6.778338,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,35.979982,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.130282,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.909883,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.624865,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.724771,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,5.389802,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.484316,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.929165,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.67905,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,6.092532,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.948061,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.940401,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.740867,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,5.629329,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.402318,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.786485,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.026131,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.690102,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,5.905036,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.696309,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.87923,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.692193,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.98027,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,7.248003,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.966283,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.684932,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.770584,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.604111,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,7.025909,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,37.290611,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.156623,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.900315,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.6769,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.7533237,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.487162,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.373717,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.094867,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.663264,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,6.131847,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.012468,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.038596,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.099705,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,6.150769,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.500465,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.687225,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.8422204,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.755879,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.785789,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.846,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.795213,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.457718,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.925228,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,7.024158,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.791965,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.578622,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.593994,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.5888,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,6.553382,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,37.133107,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.377694,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.050627,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.558763,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.9779221,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,5.965005,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.385289,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.186408,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.610657,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,6.182355,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.582486,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.205079,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.211625,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,5.999191,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.536125,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.760588,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.7317952,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.842155,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,5.870663,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.887239,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.890671,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.394926,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.956411,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,7.129248,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.784983,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.548088,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.62732,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.585514,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,6.545905,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,37.692367,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.266848,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.920767,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.648002,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.8726242,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,5.70824,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.78653,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.244119,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.918283,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,6.948932,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.38581,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.264007,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.237157,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,6.886974,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.626513,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.667244,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.7730718,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.99243,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,6.059259,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.997141,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.879127,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.585607,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.982856,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,7.444731,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.982815,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.846238,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.184391,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.558905,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,7.572349,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,40.620485,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.077002,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.873452,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.605813,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.61858,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,5.174848,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.780159,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.174185,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.922672,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,6.877017,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.113739,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.999982,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.303406,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,6.417126,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.937432,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.940666,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.8595713,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.954089,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,6.691759,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.742158,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.812725,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.610298,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.864205,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,7.029386,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.865558,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.70853,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.951108,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.630411,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,7.155606,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,39.345742,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.029061,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.760795,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.59012,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.7687659,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.148741,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.364355,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.715383,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.578766,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.658504,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.969991,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.674399,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.89094,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.53533,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.487259,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.990629,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.8329315,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.805079,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,6.115899,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.914428,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.876196,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.638058,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.908514,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,7.337197,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.751369,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.583236,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.032628,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.678077,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,7.04531,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,36.840981,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.294113,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.83277,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.477844,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.8613569,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,5.466084,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.761203,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.786147,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.557178,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,6.104527,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.91341,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.021278,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.101196,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,6.035883,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.731163,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.081282,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.9904962,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.019367,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,6.822308,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.053627,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.796535,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.623085,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.996869,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,7.470115,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.885362,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.710224,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.405786,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.648631,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,7.650003,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,39.54892,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.11044,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.049737,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.636173,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.7354385,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,5.531788,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.450642,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.745685,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.624927,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,5.821253,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.934216,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.817651,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.93491,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,5.686777,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.598931,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.922221,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.214055,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.772774,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,6.50798,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.707696,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.866724,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.474026,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.957953,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,7.006399,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.05586,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.698351,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.533935,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.667168,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,6.955315,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,37.509512,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.155525,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.74387,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.490934,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.8137333,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,5.204063,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.162576,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.078127,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.749853,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,5.990557,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.022959,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.907988,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.81617,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,5.747117,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.345888,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.586171,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.051629,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.855911,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,5.839599,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.636603,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.783854,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.678396,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.757122,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,6.855974,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.76938,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.558803,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.589956,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.66794,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,6.586078,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,36.223388,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.340286,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.019303,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.691286,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.137455,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,6.18833,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.49963,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.888463,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.728413,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,6.116506,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.975182,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.295761,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.029368,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,6.300311,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.771937,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.942981,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.254932,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.016119,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,6.985969,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.818312,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.901001,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.44106,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.950705,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,7.111078,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.027544,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.706309,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.704112,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.67221,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,7.110175,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,39.812369,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.9944391,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.612437,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.435027,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.4949843,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,4.536886,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.591307,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.70152,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.780073,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,6.0729,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.721714,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.971847,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.896362,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,5.589923,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.555692,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.865636,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.029706,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.834696,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,6.285729,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.499892,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.815844,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.462814,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.856122,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,6.634672,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.781255,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.689012,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.572936,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.638011,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,6.681214,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,35.801324,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.9355717,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.726234,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.277219,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.6952457,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,4.634271,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.915856,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.621724,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.443419,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,4.980999,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.732434,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.485997,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.452083,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,4.670515,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.9544516,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.365407,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.5586446,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.612515,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,4.491018,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.604868,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.740141,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.309458,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.772444,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,6.426911,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.832768,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.544469,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.674697,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.575663,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,6.627596,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,31.83131,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.9311156,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.794596,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.447229,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.8132619,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,4.986203,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.794025,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.71297,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.723578,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,5.230573,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.867489,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.62498,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.821883,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,5.314352,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.130437,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.649587,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.5963555,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.330834,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,4.707213,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.587652,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.837571,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.556224,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.785627,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,6.767073,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.925086,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.827528,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.049467,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.531964,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,7.334046,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,34.33946,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.089757,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.72676,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.462299,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.6971076,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,4.975924,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.514952,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.456945,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.610508,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,4.582405,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.897251,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.708113,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.853256,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,5.458621,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.421222,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.834253,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.046387,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.671692,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,5.973555,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.658703,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.746369,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.608375,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.860162,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,6.87361,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.689016,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.661865,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.143613,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.494068,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,6.988561,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,34.852676,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.131302,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.961744,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.549504,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.6949357,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,5.337486,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.302748,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.855003,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.529659,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,5.68741,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.239545,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.684024,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.774679,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,5.698249,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.233811,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.623837,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.8734784,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.452858,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,5.183984,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.828458,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.883585,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.661689,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.040904,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,7.414637,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.832261,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.056837,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.551466,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.499959,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,6.940522,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,36.262288,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.187947,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.925428,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.5574,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.5938203,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,5.264595,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.309741,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.117128,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.69741,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,6.12428,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.06859,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.026739,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.762088,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,5.857416,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.561047,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.825003,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.048377,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.665777,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,6.100203,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.913531,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.853179,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.595088,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.891547,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,7.253346,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.647363,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.628384,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.467275,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.525944,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,6.268966,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,36.868806,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.7503694,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.565899,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.37177,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.4868182,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,4.174857,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.998641,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.660534,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.261434,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,4.92061,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.931984,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.696057,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.839271,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,5.467312,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.236517,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.628927,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.7091372,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.602868,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,5.177449,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.663157,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.75727,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.664045,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.9381,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,7.022571,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.933686,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.578492,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.592527,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.589114,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,6.69382,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,33.456619,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.149101,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.795584,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.756065,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.8105717,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,5.511321,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.188696,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.846347,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.635432,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,5.670475,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.953678,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.87011,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.921022,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,5.74481,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.233484,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.700786,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.6974377,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.829991,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,5.461699,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.070739,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.815885,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.51528,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.908453,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,7.310357,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.697639,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.155599,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.546722,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.553401,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,5.953362,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,35.652024,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.151886,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.810896,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.520061,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.077518,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,5.560361,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.102053,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.988557,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.473857,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,5.564467,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.823083,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.823345,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.956955,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,5.603383,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.501728,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.799324,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.8708867,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.771419,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,5.943358,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.646373,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.863124,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.689799,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.925215,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,7.12451,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.563567,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.631947,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.191978,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.606155,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,6.993646,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,36.789725,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.352369,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.053711,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.621386,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.006751,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,6.034218,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.385862,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.390714,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.774901,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,6.551477,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.984287,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.165955,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.15736,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,6.307601,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.627237,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.752665,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.8231728,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.880811,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,6.083885,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.641506,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.799512,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.681725,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.773921,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,6.896664,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.625616,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.53696,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.635847,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.575224,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,6.373647,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,38.247492,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.9982465,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.781081,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.335457,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.000511,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,5.115296,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.908295,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.669052,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.632419,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,5.209766,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.627317,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.639857,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.843262,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,5.110436,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.571213,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.8024,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.117827,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.545419,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,6.036859,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.584461,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.838456,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.477369,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.758435,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,6.658721,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.664798,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.118943,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.491202,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.640842,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,5.915785,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,34.046863,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.051087,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.928398,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.456637,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.070413,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,5.506535,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.464221,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.9779,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.742024,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,6.184144,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.899107,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.761462,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.766729,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,5.427299,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.438415,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.849542,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.089139,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.036111,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,6.413208,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.664113,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.622976,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.575359,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.854312,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,6.71676,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.802613,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.852088,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.036592,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.55113,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,7.242423,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,37.490369,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.9853225,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.705071,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.418847,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.6198559,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,4.729096,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.983266,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.597924,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.420967,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,5.002157,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.905715,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.598887,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.630637,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,5.135239,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.102295,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.694457,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.7233326,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.920869,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,5.440953,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.580264,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.816455,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.507914,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.838674,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,6.743308,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.704247,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.82601,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.902766,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.487168,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,6.92019,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,33.970943,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.183673,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.993236,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.445115,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.5454987,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,5.167522,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.584518,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.306295,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.777275,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,6.668087,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.051358,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.035916,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.628816,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,5.716091,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.533456,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.827742,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.297636,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.868659,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,6.527493,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.671166,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.557085,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.578481,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.760255,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,6.566987,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.769342,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.590349,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.322835,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.587343,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,7.269868,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,37.916048,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.9201217,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.862779,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.4156,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.5440262,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,4.742527,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.278128,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.983111,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.537018,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,5.798257,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.987917,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.548375,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.607782,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,5.144074,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.508928,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.923198,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.188773,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.746559,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,6.367458,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.885617,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.81565,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.396959,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.977304,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,7.075529,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.600133,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.968659,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.372853,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.575652,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,7.517297,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,36.645142,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.097504,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.941067,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.246112,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.659743,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,4.944427,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.488728,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.123753,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.811288,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,6.423769,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.801883,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.948249,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.006854,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,5.756987,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.669601,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.963783,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.311969,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.915034,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,6.860387,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.782759,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.57842,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.760417,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.82898,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,6.950576,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.762325,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.804965,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.76897,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.672616,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,7.008876,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,37.945022,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.9930281,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.033157,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.479269,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.8219002,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,5.327354,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.30207,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.431512,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.795074,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,5.528656,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.84766,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.500002,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.854497,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,5.202159,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.899037,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.153556,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.319494,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.804753,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,7.176839,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.628183,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.815005,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.732146,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.950679,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,7.126012,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.821885,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.695858,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.540609,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.682244,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,6.740596,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,37.101616,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.088837,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.045989,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.306343,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.8442035,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,5.285373,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.271555,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.735175,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.798984,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,5.805714,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.919994,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.785594,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.737201,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,5.442789,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.534348,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.959941,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.152451,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.899841,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,6.546582,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.758308,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.569094,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.658138,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.931675,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,6.917214,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.944659,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.647993,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.751293,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.61443,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,6.958375,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,36.956047,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.973754,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.936769,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.585895,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.834165,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,5.330583,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.52586,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.397054,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.636865,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,4.559778,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.063933,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.877283,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.306363,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,5.247579,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.61077,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.679262,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.09264,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.319298,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,5.70197,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.701,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.88961,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.683596,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.656617,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,6.930822,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.973629,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.615138,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.332754,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.638759,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,6.560279,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,34.331011000000004,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.064773,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.986561,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.581604,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.7477214,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,5.380659,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.281364,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.869388,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.571495,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,5.722248,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.978834,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.963215,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.883685,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,5.825734,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.699174,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.991152,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.244717,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.622099,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,6.557142,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.711392,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.876866,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.818995,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.863496,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,7.270749,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.948371,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.640853,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.034917,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.61003,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,7.234171,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,37.990703,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.7256224,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.522265,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.109708,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.9862399,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,4.343835,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.004582,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.602634,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.70271,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,5.309925,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.812559,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.074464,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.737033,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,5.624056,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.595907,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.795127,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.083429,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.698938,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,6.173401,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.569174,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.840708,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.764356,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.896724,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,7.070961,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.767664,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.672097,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.583523,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.650174,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,6.673457,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,35.195635,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.9473052,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.703807,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.225485,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.8144752,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,4.691073,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.065955,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.505764,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.50515,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,5.076869,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.760527,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.701919,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.567074,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,5.02952,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.234566,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.614011,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.9279525,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.642712,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,5.419241,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.586152,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.6525,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.446103,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.853331,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,6.538087,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.822525,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.589897,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.826279,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.631114,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,6.869814,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,33.624604,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.9126628,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.768451,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.444742,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.8859126,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,5.011768,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.982118,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.331952,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.462835,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,4.776906,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.535832,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.425023,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.456417,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,4.417272,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.131926,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.468665,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.8127034,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.733457,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,5.146751,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.520038,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.722203,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.644594,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.755815,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,6.642651,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.702147,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.632628,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.071707,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.635453,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,7.041935,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,33.037283,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.314137,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.040028,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.30359,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.157007,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,5.814761,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.168083,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.693382,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.59163,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,5.453095,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.992759,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.848323,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.811022,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,5.652103,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.545229,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.785266,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.080672,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.806113,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,6.21728,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.629497,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.741088,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.610438,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.870464,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,6.851487,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.849781,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.378008,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.911001,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.627585,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,6.766375,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,36.755101,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.9592278,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.627059,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.37732,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.9875597,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,4.951166,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.102988,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.623549,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.819919,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,5.546455,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.824172,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.026253,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.918515,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,5.76894,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.665433,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.893736,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.059226,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.798314,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,6.41671,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.544649,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.753206,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.750568,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.762392,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,6.810816,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.822121,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.823523,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.590482,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.698981,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,6.935107,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,36.429194,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.954188,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.773677,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.213928,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.6368409,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,4.578633,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.994514,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.49844,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.708007,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,5.200961,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.019076,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.979763,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.918097,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,5.916937,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.827198,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.119858,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.279483,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.77886,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,7.0054,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.520621,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.533336,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.492877,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.877347,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,6.424181,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.724281,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.680562,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.670558,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.66926,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,6.74466,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,35.870772,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.8436542,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.71549,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.17551,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.8083247,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,4.542979,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.711946,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.408799,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.534723,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,4.655468,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.820433,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.460587,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.459805,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,4.740825,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.296424,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.769286,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.9478416,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.607902,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,5.621454,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.519426,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.854442,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.502138,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.930294,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,6.8063,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.789991,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.704355,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.802937,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.687713,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,6.984996,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,33.352022,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2012,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.9303862,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.499217,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.221591,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.9001547,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,4.551349,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2012,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.623182,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.643157,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.780238,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,5.046576,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2012,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.99281,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.543848,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.800415,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,5.337072,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2012,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.513086,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.819048,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.013146,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.827569,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,6.17285,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2012,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.533986,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.838521,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.406731,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.798993,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,6.578232,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2012,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.7541,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2012,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.366502,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2012,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.339128,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2012,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.674574,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2012,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,6.134304,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2012,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,33.820383,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.150341,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.678745,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.663632,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.9640624,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.45678,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.463055,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.137113,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.729239,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,6.329407,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.739393,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.208542,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.995829,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.943764,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.525351,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.630049,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.7905406,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.694473,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.640414,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.673378,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.762357,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.631935,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.778763,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,6.846432,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.592731,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.609984,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.125697,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.617452,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,6.945865,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,37.162662,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.009181,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.862972,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.606338,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.6299011,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,5.108392,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.099417,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.771568,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.358875,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,5.22986,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.603988,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.673467,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.6897,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,4.967155,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.187037,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.646064,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.6897331,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.647893,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,5.170728,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.058517,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.781987,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.426797,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.999441,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,7.266743,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.986525,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.56075,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.432773,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.491477,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,6.471526,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,34.214404,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.045935,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.005013,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.427826,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.7037437,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,5.182518,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.526977,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.943722,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.55496,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,6.02566,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.000292,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.617142,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.650722,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,5.268156,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.768031,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.801133,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.8292924,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.652553,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,6.05101,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.775575,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.730764,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.075621,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.019601,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,6.601561,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.826375,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.580589,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.35193,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.659814,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,6.418707,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,35.547612,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.250716,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.893363,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.682934,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.5599223,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.386935,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.379338,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.84909,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.842502,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,6.07093,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.819123,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.010453,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.753482,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.583058,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.891358,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.924753,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.927949,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.670879,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,6.414939,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.998839,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.674397,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.566127,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.03031,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,7.269672,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.97083,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.606112,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.569577,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.551781,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,6.6983,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,37.423834,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.22313,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.988115,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.675133,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.6874085,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,5.573787,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.695205,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.925085,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.6418,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,6.26209,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.865486,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.183916,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.983265,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,6.032667,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.541446,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.742674,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.071619,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.803686,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,6.159425,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.841476,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.828566,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.626098,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.93069,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,7.22683,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.991238,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.573764,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.586011,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.635737,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,6.78675,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,38.041549,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.072556,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.718382,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.594448,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.7231174,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.108504,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.107729,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.72987,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.508925,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.346524,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.237252,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.77495,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.809545,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,4.821747,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.48481,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.708473,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.6187158,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.675987,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.487986,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.717223,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.824085,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.478784,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.837246,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,6.857337,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.061213,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.657344,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.461201,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.59558,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,6.775338,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,34.397436,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.010081,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.87106,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.318883,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.4721959,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,4.67222,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.394009,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.830338,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.570661,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,5.795008,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.877391,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.932245,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.878751,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,5.688387,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.58892,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.905009,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.8945928,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.584609,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,5.97313,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.659983,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.779112,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.724891,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.890179,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,7.054165,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.907236,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.604482,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.651216,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.592037,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,6.75497,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,35.93788,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.8633131,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.536313,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.310951,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.6120212,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,4.322599,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.251535,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.678898,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.3014,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,5.231833,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.513493,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.695119,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.729735,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,4.938347,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.157447,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.545864,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.664293,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.619463,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,4.987067,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.646672,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.633758,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.50586,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.882368,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,6.668658,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.001702,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.747844,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.427345,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.57619,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,6.753081,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,32.901585,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.052154,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.045056,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.814947,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.6609244,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,5.573081,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.258192,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.883729,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.274568,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,5.416489,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.088083,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.994764,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.089641,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,6.172488,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.83567,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.920899,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.7396244,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.884328,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,6.380521,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.756401,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.877059,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.540435,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.049695,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,7.22359,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.747838,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.611433,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.379322,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.614164,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,6.352757,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,37.118926,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.125784,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.842164,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.780317,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.9612644,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,5.709529,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.500499,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.107701,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.43941,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,6.047609,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.204463,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.894619,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.856524,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,5.955606,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.745088,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.845138,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.08426,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.640895,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,6.315381,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.752636,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.816003,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.65792,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.92672,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,7.153278,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.89106,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.642039,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.307252,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.568786,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,6.409137,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,37.59054,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.143061,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.776938,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.818569,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.7068514,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.44542,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.608759,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.63369,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.65814,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.900589,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.105187,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.00824,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.018826,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,6.132254,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.45142,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.719023,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.7987348,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.737739,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.706917,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.75703,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.857637,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.696099,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.931525,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,7.24229,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.085369,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.870986,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.602644,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.636293,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,7.195291,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,37.622761,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.142534,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.670333,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.864854,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.8940846,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.571805,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.860067,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.125681,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.554224,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,6.539973,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.980772,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.264245,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.85395,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,6.098966,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.702395,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.899501,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.8577135,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.613491,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,6.073101,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.713734,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.500427,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.579241,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.842666,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,6.636068,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.784,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.660062,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.544624,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.538564,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,6.52725,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,37.447163,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.150675,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.861646,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.622136,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.7982625,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,5.43272,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.550639,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.072054,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.67191,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,6.294604,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.076415,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.947966,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.734603,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,5.758984,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.767506,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.984379,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.8737212,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.766144,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,6.39175,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.719401,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.595553,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.558605,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.875123,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,6.748682,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.051826,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.676303,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.814753,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.625423,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,7.168305,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,37.795045,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.9701215,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.484007,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.545817,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.5499142,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,4.54986,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.051375,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.917837,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.507393,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,5.476605,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.84457,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.691842,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.973159,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,5.50957,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.315724,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.646721,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.705844,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.68122,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,5.349509,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.520921,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.654819,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.399208,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.747205,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,6.322154,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.82624,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.628512,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.621412,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.609306,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,6.685469,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,33.893167,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.8372888,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.536184,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.444364,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.8304134,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,4.648251,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.774712,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.570137,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.538916,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,4.883765,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.563001,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.710619,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.353664,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,4.627284,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.9910697,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.676876,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.6929334,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.316738,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,4.677617,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.322692,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.676575,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.722128,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.669733,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,6.391128,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.599139,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.700146,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.629948,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.63058,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,6.559813,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,31.787858,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.012159,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.724165,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.680348,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.7523266,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,5.168999,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.551666,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.710119,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.564932,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,5.826718,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.064987,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.828421,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.041188,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,5.934596,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.648037,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.9155,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.033026,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.693971,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,6.290534,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.815857,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.794839,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.620775,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.848722,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,7.080192,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.890022,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.281517,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.587057,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.700795,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,6.459391,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,36.76043,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.228253,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.711987,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.585939,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.7384639,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,5.264643,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.281467,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.951211,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.707093,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,5.939771,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.964118,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.303029,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.460328,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,6.727475,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.480388,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.722662,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.711085,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.79263,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,5.706765,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.010221,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.769228,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.480159,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.996152,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,7.255759,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.702483,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.575583,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.026127,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.564865,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,6.869059,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,37.763472,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.053785,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.663501,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.532987,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.8378383,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.088111,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.464903,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.823916,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.560625,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.849444,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.854191,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.987053,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.269849,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,6.111093,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.599772,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.638232,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.8307202,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.83856,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.907283,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.589598,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.650872,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.639984,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.864356,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,6.74481,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.65932,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.986037,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.955639,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.627137,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,7.228134,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,36.928875,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.210717,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.934858,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.556495,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.234402,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,5.936472,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.372256,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.124829,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.848509,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,6.345593,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.040341,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.690928,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.099045,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,6.830314,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.58308,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.777889,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.8793591,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.838664,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,6.078991,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.778627,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.826432,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.597262,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.759944,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,6.962264,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.70143,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.686111,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.835577,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.638945,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,6.862063,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,39.015697,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.017295,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.564183,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.567515,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.5745186,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,4.723511,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.421412,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.064606,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.575876,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,6.061895,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.735375,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.649913,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.793454,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,5.178742,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.277233,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.532722,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.7222818,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.703523,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,5.235758,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.642765,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.869131,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.488096,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.846135,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,6.846126,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.503184,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.822445,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.462208,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.642343,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,7.43018,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,35.476212,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.004272,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.602072,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.661337,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.14955,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.417231,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.379467,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.750236,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.869025,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.998728,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.655813,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.115736,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.864313,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.635862,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.479045,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.713677,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.8591363,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.737876,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.789735,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.650209,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.82726,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.369692,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.82789,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,6.67505,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.743818,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.001636,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.889747,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.611414,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,7.246616,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,36.763222,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.38647,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.882493,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.624266,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.150378,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,6.043607,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.565636,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.975496,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.813617,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,6.354749,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.210503,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.680492,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.26049,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,7.151485,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.561485,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.581838,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.8249845,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.700989,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,5.669296,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.891664,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.867977,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.508829,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.943067,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,7.211536,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.8304,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.69694,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.767296,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.586526,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,6.881163,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,39.311836,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.326294,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.849036,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.684546,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.7713449,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,5.631222,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.475052,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.880261,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.740813,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,6.096126,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.947588,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.152755,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.013351,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,6.113694,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.469184,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.798515,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.8201535,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.734875,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,5.822727,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.751949,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.661257,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.934098,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.831799,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,7.179103,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.733836,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.349009,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.636588,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.593565,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,6.312998,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,37.15587,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.082725,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.640435,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.497017,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.8043089,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,5.024486,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.603215,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.028661,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.76431,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,6.396187,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.48667,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.388685,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.199603,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,6.074957,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.594798,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.756062,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.122793,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.79392,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,6.267573,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.035808,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.91743,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.704452,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.907619,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,7.565309,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.745584,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.693886,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.074619,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.678408,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,7.192498,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,38.52101,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.913659,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.479608,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.607596,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.334995,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,5.335857,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.389712,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.62726,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.448897,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,5.465869,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.80894,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.647668,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.530985,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,4.987593,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.323207,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.703665,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.9690942,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.612364,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,5.60833,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.631676,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.908563,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.78464,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.795972,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,7.120852,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.623213,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.580527,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.93844,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.558857,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,6.701037,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,35.219538,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.202334,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.843329,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.719718,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.8289169,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,5.594298,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.79743,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.15001,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.659378,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,6.606818,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.728163,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.234378,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.007052,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,5.969592,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.949573,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.036608,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.164778,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.767606,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,6.918564,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.607629,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.722282,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.546676,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.848969,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,6.725555,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.876835,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.565678,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.747847,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.62609,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,6.81645,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,38.631277,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.029191,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.714155,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.67301,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.7889726,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.205329,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.326599,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.797711,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.648229,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.77254,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.785483,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.996948,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.08707,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.869501,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.54122,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.656566,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.8206852,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.748296,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.766767,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.745556,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.840181,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.683489,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.950593,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,7.219819,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.829064,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.765964,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.442734,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.594471,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,6.632232,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,36.466188,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.367581,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.924489,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.679706,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.8211784,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,5.792954,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.601558,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.075105,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.573395,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,6.250058,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.361844,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.149462,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.308219,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,6.819525,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.819591,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.891622,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.7953721,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.838201,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,6.344786,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.256644,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.797174,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.486726,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.973484,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,7.514029,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.87334,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.563419,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.58356,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.551005,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,6.571324,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,39.292676,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.591156,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.939961,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.657754,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.286771,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,6.475642,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.560775,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.466139,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.846933,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,6.873847,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.255407,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.427228,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.140697,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,6.823332,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.825361,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.727416,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.097627,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.793068,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,6.443473,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.861717,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.953837,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.898793,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.854697,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,7.569044,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.006806,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.770213,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.212733,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.543656,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,7.533407,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,41.718745,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.365989,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.860618,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.561901,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.7334372,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,5.521946,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.687977,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.971246,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.910793,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,6.570016,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.00543,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.260783,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.366508,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,6.632721,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.856092,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.92768,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.79971,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.532847,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,6.116329,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.985142,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.946868,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.858954,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.998531,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,7.789495,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.965144,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.631736,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.932947,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.588449,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,7.118277,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,39.748784,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.144541,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.914952,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.567579,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.5424005,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.169472,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.704041,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.718422,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.650994,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,6.073458,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.855217,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.694933,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.730151,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.280302,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.452507,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.871207,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.8202105,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.677588,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.821513,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.604708,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.880868,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.310241,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.927794,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,6.72361,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.873764,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.558784,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.197048,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.658737,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,7.288333,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,36.356688,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.261896,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.61569,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.573597,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.7781031,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,5.229287,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.826739,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.070485,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.771897,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,6.669121,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.142803,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.876972,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.921946,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,5.941721,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.526991,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.878235,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.9437695,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.985152,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,6.334148,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.80711,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.937592,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.808512,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.962275,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,7.515488,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.974336,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.291231,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.434489,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.67409,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,7.374146,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,39.063911,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.124544,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.970416,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.729195,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.990275,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,5.81443,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.461944,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.937582,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.612134,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,6.01166,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.9616,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.804794,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.076721,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,5.843115,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.656688,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.866045,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.041279,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.816837,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,6.380849,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.552669,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.758362,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.519789,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.953566,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,6.784387,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.123799,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.640066,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.537068,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.665192,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,6.966125,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,37.800566,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.134599,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.802621,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.52597,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.9150891,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,5.378279,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.399177,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.872154,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.503183,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,5.774514,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.847377,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.947443,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.736719,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,5.531539,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.334664,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.640387,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.9274717,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.438158,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,5.34068,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.524858,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.602103,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.332937,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.789056,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,6.248955,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.829235,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.602681,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.697302,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.666152,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,6.79537,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,35.069337,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.20347,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.836412,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.46355,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.090588,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,5.594021,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.482391,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.938071,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.610521,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,6.030983,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.741141,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.011967,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.913791,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,5.666899,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.818877,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.897277,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.198112,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.587525,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,6.501791,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.688578,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.913898,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.523329,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.952406,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,7.078212,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.99635,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.619671,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.005968,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.704284,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,7.326274,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,38.19818,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.176813,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.814138,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.290801,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.8120071,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,5.093759,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.341398,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.585486,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.650907,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,5.577791,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.826383,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.864899,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.145508,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,5.83679,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.598029,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.843336,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.073379,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.77526,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,6.290004,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.515722,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.725278,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.537252,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.954379,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,6.73263,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.763868,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.338712,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.889836,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.617889,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,6.610305,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,36.141279,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.9313983,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.652649,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.407365,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.4718445,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,4.463257,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.041374,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.846253,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.634327,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,5.521955,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.923329,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.809735,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.857439,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,5.590503,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.639959,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.834786,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.9524216,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.660351,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,6.087518,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.822317,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.780037,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.4041,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.973457,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,6.979913,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.885652,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.817443,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.826484,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.628795,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,7.158373,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,35.801519,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.7849512,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.728301,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.324887,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.7357248,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,4.573864,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.20723,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.795051,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.567145,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,5.569426,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.840686,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.86761,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.919571,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,5.627867,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.503225,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.786376,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.8233027,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.605047,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,5.717951,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.57385,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.940271,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.339316,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.790943,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,6.64438,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.978133,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.716478,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.885251,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.609174,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,7.189035,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,35.322523000000004,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.8394461,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.703578,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.373996,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.5765045,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,4.493525,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.15965,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.745951,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.62263,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,5.528231,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.561523,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.805541,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.999541,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,5.366606,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.509941,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.777592,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.106126,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.801865,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,6.195524,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.827295,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.801768,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.737664,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.01973,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,7.386457,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.892065,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.681696,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.237766,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.547946,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,7.359473,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,36.329816,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.9516234,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.715982,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.580611,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.116249,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,5.364465,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.163566,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.585565,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.55206,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,5.301191,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.766804,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.702289,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.654528,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,5.123622,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.021952,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.516329,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.6036804,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.595968,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,4.737928,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.829222,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.768248,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.577076,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.882012,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,7.056559,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.768265,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.917772,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.594957,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.543405,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,6.824399,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,34.408164,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.041446,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.663285,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.734163,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.01413,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,5.453024,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.314214,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.902675,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.640742,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,5.857631,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.816279,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.875407,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.117815,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,5.809501,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.67432,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.010338,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.413158,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.731039,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,6.828855,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.007897,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.727183,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.570707,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.873994,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,7.179781,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.5459,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.600925,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.458546,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.578349,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,6.18372,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,37.312512,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.934439,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.800261,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.48175,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.5057213,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,4.72217,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.402019,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.820296,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.678389,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,5.900704,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.788231,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.877841,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.896263,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,5.562335,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.573,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.823963,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.04121,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.815024,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,6.253196,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.781274,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.792963,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.6534,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.934066,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,7.161703,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.96451,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.744714,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.652479,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.55578,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,6.917483,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,36.517591,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.127349,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.770775,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.605448,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.7831317,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,5.286704,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.518629,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.185702,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.535075,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,6.239407,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.874101,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.171971,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.989485,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,6.035557,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.392457,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.846076,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.7803353,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.780516,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,5.799385,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.011692,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.65056,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.61358,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.83971,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,7.115542,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.713729,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.411426,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.743492,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.603284,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,6.471931,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,36.948526,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.044401,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.838293,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.550048,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.7409721,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,5.173715,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.883842,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.733604,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.559486,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,5.176931,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.496613,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.763845,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.903271,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,5.163729,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.406164,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.853448,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.7852418,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.729699,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,5.774553,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.919518,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.941388,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.514808,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.886995,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,7.262709,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.579292,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.608196,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.165303,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.583469,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,6.93626,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,35.487897,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.9554513,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.770673,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.634469,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.8492305,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,5.209824,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.35443,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.876353,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.578299,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,5.809082,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.008585,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.857432,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.742894,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,5.608911,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.398679,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.59095,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.7646543,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.830297,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,5.58458,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.756946,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.743444,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.635236,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.91551,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,7.051136,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.575925,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.340282,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.588095,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.615243,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,6.119544,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,35.383077,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.014852,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.739666,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.346041,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.6899356,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,4.790494,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.169874,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.708657,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.772672,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,5.651204,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.564045,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.723441,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.870192,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,5.157679,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.716275,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.002501,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.096567,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.483302,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,6.298645,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.576616,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.695048,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.469446,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.754399,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,6.49551,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.603836,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.683591,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.498749,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.710406,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,6.496582,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,34.890114,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.072271,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.957049,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.418233,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.7529544,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,5.200507,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.505352,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.879884,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.749306,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,6.134542,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.918085,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.891727,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.99101,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,5.800822,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.645904,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.969251,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.501201,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.736255,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,6.85261,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.844746,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.794417,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.58319,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.784572,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,7.006926,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.874745,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.606433,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.966556,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.56014,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,7.007874,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,38.003281,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.9830315,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.754294,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.727806,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.0181,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,5.483231,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.110625,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.894858,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.692756,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,5.698238,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.642629,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.880269,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.752185,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,5.275082,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.161838,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.808866,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.8310795,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.735377,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,5.53716,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.708771,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.732226,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.570125,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.909737,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,6.920859,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.721908,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.599946,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.864575,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.582015,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,6.768444,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,35.683014,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.291843,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.809442,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.527417,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.6086039,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,5.237306,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.670865,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.859565,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.823832,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,6.354262,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.765918,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.080676,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.967717,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,5.814311,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.581329,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.891928,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.165929,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.888675,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,6.527862,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.806597,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.635209,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.738329,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.875994,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,7.056129,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.797378,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.691263,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.331948,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.609056,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,7.429646,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,38.419516,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.8853819,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.756901,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.386791,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.7634803,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,4.792554,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.630033,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.922717,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.724945,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,6.277695,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.104488,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.70624,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.831708,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,5.642437,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.509159,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.883404,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.067316,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.846576,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,6.306455,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.939593,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.800851,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.524351,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.809301,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,7.074094,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.626867,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.693538,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.305171,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.607601,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,7.233176,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,37.326411,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.158541,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.883946,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.47898,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.9842381,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,5.505705,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.481214,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.838865,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.683786,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,6.003865,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.077358,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.03134,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.009137,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,6.117835,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.957755,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.1363,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.538059,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.874416,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,7.506531,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.89501,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.885487,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.672181,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.972987,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,7.425664,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.938018,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.666448,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.893177,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.678311,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,7.175954,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,39.735554,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.030637,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.896525,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.583381,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.9645586,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,5.475101,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.220661,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.735355,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.834365,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,5.790381,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.154115,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.658459,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.940743,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,5.753316,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.960102,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.108115,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.634944,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.897907,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,7.601068,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.808163,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.936027,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.702069,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.890333,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,7.336592,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.83878,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.642992,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.518769,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.689333,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,6.689875,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,38.646333,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.057247,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.948622,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.501253,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.8656877,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,5.372809,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.321745,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.730429,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.751526,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,5.8037,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.923152,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.904332,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.982424,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,5.809909,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.649595,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.878302,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.189849,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.787129,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,6.504875,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.804603,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.77558,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.695047,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.007004,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,7.282234,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.848441,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.707884,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.681644,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.643098,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,6.881066,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,37.654593,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.9864879,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.024682,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.366489,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.816169,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,5.193829,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.341695,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.794566,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.827601,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,5.963862,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.834619,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.255895,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.902769,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,5.993282,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.682342,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.927878,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.238628,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.644684,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,6.493532,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.442737,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.708236,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.415191,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.85316,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,6.419325,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.215325,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.61007,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.433919,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.641081,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,6.900395,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,36.964225,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.006674,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.88507,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.317868,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.7743115,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,4.983923,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.219738,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.898713,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.601217,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,5.719668,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.542696,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.83284,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.788672,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,5.164208,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.658482,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.956004,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.197073,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.056714,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,6.868273,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.534765,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.935423,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.636264,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.944481,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,7.050932,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.962962,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.775746,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.399116,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.621603,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,7.759428,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,37.546432,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.8573583,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.460803,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.375175,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.9429646,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,4.636302,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.889024,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.549038,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.590668,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,5.02873,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.868577,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.967978,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.655968,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,5.492524,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.46382,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.77476,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.037618,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.755774,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,6.031972,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.558229,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.631367,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.798301,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.744744,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,6.732641,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.750137,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.597655,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.609572,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.631999,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,6.589362,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,34.511531,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.9262313,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.668019,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.164293,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.033922,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,4.792465,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.858597,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.700969,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.737751,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,5.297317,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.143371,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.83951,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.655433,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,4.638314,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.658409,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.975656,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.163844,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.737379,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,6.535287,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.574574,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.766893,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.592628,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.745157,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,6.679251,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.853979,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.668244,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.931745,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.647488,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,7.101456,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,35.04409,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.8839229,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.682581,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.216851,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.8031934,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,4.586549,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.854111,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.896101,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.419749,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,5.169961,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.763164,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.86037,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.732516,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,5.35605,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.522036,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.753778,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.082941,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.849319,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,6.208075,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.517339,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.750573,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.626056,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.841498,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,6.735466,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.720582,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.125665,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.960316,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.652619,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,7.459181,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,35.515282,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.178299,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.99721,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.230814,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.9841202,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,5.390443,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.422265,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.85036,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.773143,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,6.045768,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.574277,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.76625,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.82763,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,5.168157,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.868739,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.036347,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.423021,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.846532,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,7.174639,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.67316,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.783321,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.554078,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.834641,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,6.845201,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.80427,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.602454,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.690928,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.655111,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,6.752762,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,37.37697,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.240918,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.732711,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.637508,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.11498,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,5.726117,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.168446,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.708235,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.679646,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,5.556327,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.892703,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.315178,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.890424,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,6.098305,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.760692,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.94421,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.064691,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.719599,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,6.489192,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.530421,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.856135,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.599245,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.907358,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,6.89316,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.918687,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.863511,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.588311,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.680613,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,7.051122,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,37.814223,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.915201,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.663949,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.372015,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.6701635,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,4.621329,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.158314,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.6678,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.611397,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,5.437511,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.995175,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.847259,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.058768,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,5.901202,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.808698,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.059413,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.463269,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.621867,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,6.953246,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.665636,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.369513,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.485555,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.847447,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,6.368151,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.909736,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.660079,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.60929,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.688989,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,6.868094,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,36.149533,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.8373067,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.720866,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.457244,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.8214825,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,4.8369,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.833109,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.834833,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.571265,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,5.239207,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.220523,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.909238,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.860096,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,4.989858,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.581774,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.832206,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.150007,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.819131,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,6.383119,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.504745,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.579815,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.413894,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.872401,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,6.370854,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.801839,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.65612,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.859819,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.619642,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,6.93742,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,34.757357999999996,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2013,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.8844905,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.342246,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.439048,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.7834706,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,4.449255,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2013,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.978102,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.758722,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.678326,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,5.41515,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2013,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.913294,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.695151,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.897009,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,5.505454,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2013,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.694235,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.892832,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.15326,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.85686,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,6.597187,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2013,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.419528,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.790379,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.536625,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.839806,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,6.586338,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2013,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.619,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2013,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.466744,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2013,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.288843,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2013,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.650339,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2013,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,6.024926,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2013,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,34.57831,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.116523,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.58729,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.787355,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.8156608,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.306829,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.39554,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.751596,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.859081,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,6.006218,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.612384,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.031403,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.992194,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.635981,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.306766,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.564298,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.647094,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.710903,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.229061,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.669221,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.823578,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.525226,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.784379,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,6.802405,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.512394,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.594277,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.112982,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.6017,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,6.821354,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,35.801848,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.7774035,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.421538,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.531599,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.6138523,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,4.344393,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.928292,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.587842,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.42033,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,4.936464,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.483328,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.52691,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.661238,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,4.671476,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.293344,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.747764,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.6576143,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.621172,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,5.319895,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.533525,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.68867,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.499572,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.697145,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,6.418913,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.924574,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.581289,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.303057,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.526267,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,6.335187,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,32.026328,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.8228062,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.751118,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.560621,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.7023806,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,4.836926,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.079489,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.778567,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.574869,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,5.432925,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.977208,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.545101,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.694427,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,5.216737,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.240716,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.603409,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.837314,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.721379,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,5.402818,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.617679,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.640424,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.292106,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.993459,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,6.543669,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.92538,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.451442,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.386916,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.636647,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,6.400385,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,33.83346,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.248881,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.796926,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.714895,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.5705543,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.331256,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.343071,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.011766,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.850701,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,6.205537,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.84108,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.93073,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.709645,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.481455,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.659814,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.899419,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.6707847,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.824758,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,6.054775,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.70319,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.685798,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.482831,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.838293,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,6.710112,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.992696,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.596913,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.616771,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.598612,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,6.804992,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,36.588127,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.098964,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.545435,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.750016,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.9461243,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,5.340539,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.586442,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.093617,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.749295,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,6.429354,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.859686,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.9927,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.112985,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,5.965372,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.67315,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.874953,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.119691,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.869096,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,6.53689,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.836439,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.722635,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.429861,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.817757,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,6.806693,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.988003,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.57728,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.616878,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.594679,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,6.77684,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,37.855688,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.243696,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.632006,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.559146,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.9772961,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.412144,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.591928,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.220129,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.812885,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,6.624942,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.508657,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.002848,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.020997,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.532502,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.184089,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.63379,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.7651365,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.795203,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.378219,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.808482,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.782447,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.482177,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.808616,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,6.881722,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.066978,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.606624,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.426309,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.686955,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,6.786867,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,36.616396,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.8395184,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.605446,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.403186,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.7243056,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,4.572456,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.529601,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.750796,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.549119,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,5.829515,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.857141,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.661362,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.794806,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,5.31331,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.136264,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.511186,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.6075823,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.592,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,4.847033,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.600451,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.811258,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.485806,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.857296,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,6.75481,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.723776,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.562318,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.708964,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.661811,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,6.656869,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,33.973993,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.8015648,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.510812,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.448673,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.8151888,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,4.576239,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.898547,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.661094,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.243132,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,4.802773,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.705868,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.810326,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.660987,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,5.177181,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.314967,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.79596,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.9156507,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.586507,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,5.613084,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.472218,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.737187,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.515931,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.827925,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,6.553261,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.776795,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.800444,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.451175,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.653136,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,6.681549,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,33.404087000000004,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.8835616,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.750787,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.528126,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.6268914,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,4.789366,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.104341,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.23354,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.327073,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,5.664955,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.805481,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.876911,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.006742,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,5.689134,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.470031,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.814957,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.8623384,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.879056,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,6.026382,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.784394,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.522879,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.45279,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.876386,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,6.636449,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.675163,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.485549,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.450204,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.625758,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,6.236675,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,35.042961,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.186981,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.558068,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.651718,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.7971146,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,5.193882,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.499627,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.077059,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.740352,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,6.317038,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.895009,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.966852,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.63134,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,5.4932,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.345065,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.691016,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.5799037,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.778568,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,5.394553,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.674763,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.80607,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.602148,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.918207,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,7.001187,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.926675,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.630346,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.47159,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.644753,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,6.673364,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,36.073224,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.165775,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.609686,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.790928,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.9118158,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.478205,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.697155,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.094166,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.710123,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,6.501444,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.725241,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.243716,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.971205,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.940162,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.609228,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.830702,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.021118,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.811865,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,6.272914,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.620974,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.865592,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.646757,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.87225,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,7.005573,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.051847,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.715706,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.601563,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.664566,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,7.033682,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,38.23198,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.082001,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.546564,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.768992,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.124352,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.521908,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.303587,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.783356,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.732411,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.819355,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.803428,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.039289,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.890095,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.732812,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.518792,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.523847,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.6620539,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.703298,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.40799,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.769035,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.761613,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.665951,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.969981,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,7.166579,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.63804,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.524647,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.93257,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.620629,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,6.715886,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,36.36453,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.9651303,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.576425,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.645151,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.8039106,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,4.990617,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.464042,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.33175,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.826647,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,6.622439,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.821546,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.047064,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.987695,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,5.856305,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.659599,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.799698,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.9926242,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.814829,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,6.26675,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.641134,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.910388,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.686594,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.827818,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,7.065934,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.943931,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.646275,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.809906,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.706003,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,7.106116,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,37.908161,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.000992,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.709147,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.61654,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.022286,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,5.348964,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.121216,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.670491,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.682326,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,5.474033,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.808092,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.877595,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.752722,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,5.438408,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.397141,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.783823,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.7957842,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.645915,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,5.622664,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.568674,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.585299,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.495829,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.753194,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,6.402996,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.826394,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.532025,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.639758,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.562455,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,6.560633,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,34.847698,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.012689,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.538673,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.628768,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.8577812,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,5.037911,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.549765,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.76511,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.470346,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,5.785221,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.028869,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.183187,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.93899,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,6.151046,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.758886,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.908103,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.017618,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.692922,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,6.37753,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.809784,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.895544,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.3611,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.91482,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,6.981248,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.817198,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.315942,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.638512,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.711802,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,6.483455,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,36.816411,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.144984,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.603712,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.535094,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.032546,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,5.316336,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.001785,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.183155,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.824312,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,6.009252,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.244509,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.052151,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.076178,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,6.372838,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.507548,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.683466,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.7433249,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.818097,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,5.752437,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.826697,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.868077,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.621006,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.92529,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,7.24107,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.785375,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.638929,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.845907,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.586661,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,6.856871,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,37.548804,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.136037,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.692856,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.670408,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.7653447,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.264646,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.258579,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.443472,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.51593,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.21798,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.581579,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.986691,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.936402,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.504672,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.355598,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.619119,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.6398927,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.721014,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.335624,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.748232,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.633271,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.565184,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.878984,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,6.825671,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.660939,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.800003,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.012104,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.627524,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,7.10057,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,35.249163,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.161199,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.702371,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.501173,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.8867286,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,5.251472,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.082187,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.931138,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.7444,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,5.757725,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.558981,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.274715,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.232292,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,6.065988,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.299501,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.597941,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.6333613,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.797159,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,5.327963,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.775977,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.749238,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.538145,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.723197,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,6.786558,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.833581,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.660481,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.949082,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.577696,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,7.02084,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,36.210546,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.043842,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.632011,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.460442,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.6179404,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,4.754235,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.639233,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.895257,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.50712,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,6.04161,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.697659,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.47857,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.329323,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,4.505553,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.006604,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.567718,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.6182843,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.724114,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,4.916721,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.783762,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.728582,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.695793,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.875312,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,7.083448,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.535393,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.026866,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.462493,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.645418,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,7.67017,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,34.971737,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.9370561,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.435187,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.514026,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.016857,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,4.903127,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.332239,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.558184,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.828274,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.718697,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.154151,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.269182,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.237199,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.660532,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.533166,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.830194,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.8125086,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.811423,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.987293,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.557058,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.826335,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.353277,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.781612,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,6.518282,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.879277,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.665097,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.88046,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.650501,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,7.075335,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,35.863265999999996,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.219899,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.781379,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.590487,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.089867,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,5.681632,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.703969,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.254909,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.840787,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,6.799665,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.309805,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.298977,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.003622,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,5.612403,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.746786,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.781368,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.9396941,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.831876,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,6.299724,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.928289,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.7435,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.27538,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.865049,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,6.812218,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.869042,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.658506,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.798244,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.660286,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,6.986079,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,38.191721,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.144375,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.52752,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.660862,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.056632,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,5.38939,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.211663,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.972044,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.556498,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,5.740205,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.081697,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.153097,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.128633,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,6.363427,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.791325,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.80975,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.9136043,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.666609,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,6.181289,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.645665,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.605458,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.603154,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.85425,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,6.708529,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.88406,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.61509,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.782335,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.640192,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,6.921676,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,37.304516,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.098435,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.561022,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.484633,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.9200302,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,5.06412,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.76008,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.23076,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.831581,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,6.822421,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.002837,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.235605,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.056417,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,6.294858,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.665064,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.67627,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.8240498,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.031391,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,6.196775,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.862098,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.810017,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.772036,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.79401,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,7.23816,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.784765,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.747619,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.10495,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.629484,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,7.266819,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,38.883153,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.9458287,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.443045,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.615415,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.9624891,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,4.966778,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.734568,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.753105,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.645486,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,6.13316,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.68809,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.81634,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.963318,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,5.467748,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.828568,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.879985,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.8993763,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.706954,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,6.314884,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.71314,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.94073,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.559503,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.917601,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,7.130974,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.578796,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.638804,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.009564,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.679174,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,6.906337,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,36.919881,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.090805,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.549867,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.7611,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.8820046,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,5.283776,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.362128,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.963607,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.641547,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,5.967282,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.777426,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.015217,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.00128,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,5.793922,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.664965,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.778746,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.9389955,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.754239,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,6.136946,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.66442,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.798369,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.616141,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.747552,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,6.826482,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.91553,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.528097,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.805286,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.622426,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,6.871338,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,36.879746,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.001716,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.622556,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.648273,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.7170672,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,4.989612,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.308261,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.996586,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.81291,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,6.117757,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.110689,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.898518,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.207845,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,6.217053,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.397933,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.623095,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.8014219,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.713902,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.536351,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.740608,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.79212,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.51193,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.989186,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,7.033844,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.803185,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.658563,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.64427,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.595726,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,6.701743,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,36.59636,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.139681,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.772268,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.711778,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.045769,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,5.669497,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.370142,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.710817,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.731911,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,5.812871,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.8191,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.930765,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.973319,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,5.723183,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.833585,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.814986,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.9034631,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.920038,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,6.472073,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.84357,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.882468,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.654685,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.786162,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,7.166885,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.85316,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.610589,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.639189,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.622012,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,6.724951,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,37.56946,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.108727,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.609907,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.606228,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.9418815,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,5.266743,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.352641,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.964953,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.874239,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,6.191833,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.984795,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.340368,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.226347,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,6.55151,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.763711,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.99672,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.9537324,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.927949,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,6.642113,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.830537,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.840773,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.699915,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.960702,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,7.331928,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.907972,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.601773,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.174871,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.57336,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,7.257976,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,39.242103,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.410795,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.822679,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.687144,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.9731182,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,5.893736,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.660199,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.227805,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.788152,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,6.676156,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.296137,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.006636,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.364731,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,6.667504,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.708158,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.882729,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.9980311,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.920293,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,6.509211,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.013875,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.643794,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.401279,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.923274,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,6.982222,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.958056,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.652316,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.920097,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.585422,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,7.115891,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,39.84472,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.129656,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.723766,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.635534,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.6564907,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.145447,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.449888,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.983604,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.585446,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,6.018938,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.897819,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.802397,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.074912,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.775127,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.481349,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.879182,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.9419765,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.812812,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,6.11532,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.735529,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.641454,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.397388,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.899469,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,6.67384,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.924232,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.34304,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.332565,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.690154,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,7.289992,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,37.018664,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.052394,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.447604,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.650567,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.6815903,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,4.832156,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.372602,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.975365,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.812272,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,6.160239,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.328705,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.846522,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.866375,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,6.041602,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.167975,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.628801,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.765531,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.071047,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,5.633354,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.013021,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.879717,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.69,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.030766,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,7.613504,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.00225,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.652701,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.437837,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.637765,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,7.730553,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,38.011408,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.045547,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.588698,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.590703,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.7579802,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,4.982928,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.247615,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.747203,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.603139,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,5.597957,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.064876,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.674806,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.028081,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,5.767764,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.762337,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.962448,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.028947,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.786377,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,6.540109,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.323638,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.798146,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.593203,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.840979,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,6.555966,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.113342,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.613765,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.525669,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.700287,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,6.953062,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,36.397786,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.077813,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.738936,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.44077,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.806971,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,5.064489,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.730528,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.056426,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.86655,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,6.653504,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.956968,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.04927,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.178756,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,6.184994,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.854411,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.935534,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.098035,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.91669,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,6.80467,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.789129,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.681221,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.481546,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.804569,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,6.756465,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.036493,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.579466,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.849785,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.721012,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,7.186755,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,38.650877,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.100521,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.773733,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.701793,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.196777,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,5.772822,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.573617,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.86849,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.852982,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,6.295089,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.79781,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.166809,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.964624,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,5.929243,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.831825,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.900664,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.9986715,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.842161,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,6.573321,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.51671,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.653627,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.689168,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.842167,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,6.701671,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.974485,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.612736,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.090803,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.669299,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,7.347323,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,38.619469,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.8846517,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.401194,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.306788,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.8539456,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,4.446579,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.132488,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.578928,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.466723,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,5.178139,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.805852,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.927903,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.984067,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,5.717823,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.253027,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.710149,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.8354964,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.482172,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,5.280844,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.494083,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.739003,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.324145,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.871252,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,6.428483,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.536745,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.785757,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.089779,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.65751,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,7.06979,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,34.121658,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.8134013,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.710782,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.348594,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.7674477,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,4.640225,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.910278,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.617776,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.654193,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,5.182248,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.073024,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.682914,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.676461,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,5.432399,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.278096,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.660782,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.8663407,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.529194,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,5.334412,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.666646,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.758224,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.326343,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.957238,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,6.708451,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.822591,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.548686,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.82014,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.617984,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,6.8094,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,34.107135,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.6304474,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.406354,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.220217,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.7061424,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,3.963161,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.919094,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.543358,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.619373,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,5.081825,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.825452,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.460708,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.752328,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,5.038487,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.621799,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.872327,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.120647,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.599751,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,6.214525,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.627323,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.776442,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.506574,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.799499,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,6.709838,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.966019,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.975427,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.829051,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.583471,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,7.353967,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,34.361803,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.9423616,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.687349,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.445218,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.5981023,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,4.673031,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.243669,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.921824,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.569424,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,5.734916,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.665046,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.724101,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.899039,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,5.288186,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.585582,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.862057,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.027739,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.751005,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,6.226382,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.585038,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.872622,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.73884,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.908173,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,7.104673,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.786438,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.826254,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.270662,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.611732,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,7.495085,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,36.522273,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.981983,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.486586,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.438022,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.8443308,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,4.750922,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.136602,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.630937,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.641246,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,5.408784,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.001061,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.60947,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.907387,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,5.517918,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.228606,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.538159,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.7797514,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.582868,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,5.129385,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.680985,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.890788,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.561478,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.888501,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,7.021752,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.834028,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.62181,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.722394,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.522984,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,6.701216,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,34.529977,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.128595,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.703696,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.681415,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.9998502,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,5.513556,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.978514,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.613437,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.753161,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,5.345113,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.932634,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.8243,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.983802,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,5.740736,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.504874,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.800506,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.8842123,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.706593,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,5.896186,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.922452,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.837208,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.570657,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.977027,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,7.307343,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.642122,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.627712,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.609085,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.566099,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,6.445019,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,36.247953,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.8304308,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.518385,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.427679,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.5936839,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,4.370178,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.376946,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.278235,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.738321,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,6.393502,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.741685,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.780621,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.738966,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,5.261272,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.555078,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.774705,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.119942,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.710338,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,6.160064,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.655524,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.822539,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.537685,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.831903,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,6.847652,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.00289,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.506344,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.555763,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.578156,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,6.643153,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,35.675821,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.16187,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.546053,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.847357,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.080276,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,5.635555,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.505166,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.905607,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.610984,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,6.021757,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.806571,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.938267,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.896754,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,5.641593,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.482574,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.714769,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.9147216,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.878206,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,5.99027,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.009823,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.691533,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.489585,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.877701,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,7.068642,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.746257,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.281426,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.937357,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.601326,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,6.566365,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,36.924182,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.9974633,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.732308,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.522816,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.807282,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,5.05987,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.255694,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.833625,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.656429,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,5.745748,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.059228,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.816835,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.735676,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,5.61174,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.625139,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.841961,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.9601378,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.816922,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,6.244159,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.85538,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.734912,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.311279,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.835655,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,6.737226,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.624327,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.620972,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.183503,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.700817,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,7.12962,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,36.528363,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.9987115,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.713718,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.521355,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.7112466,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,4.945031,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.36518,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.783198,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.563563,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,5.711942,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.56426,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.858666,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.853395,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,5.27632,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.489878,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.866016,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.9130995,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.625141,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,5.894135,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.786993,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.748155,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.635685,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.967757,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,7.138591,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.631583,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.264674,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.552353,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.560476,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,6.009086,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,34.975105,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.9441587,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.707349,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.104731,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.6708076,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,4.427047,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.843539,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.603941,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.63393,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,5.08141,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.923772,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.977265,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.879047,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,5.780083,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.571267,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.914039,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.130661,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.818405,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,6.434372,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.630763,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.834695,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.629502,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.922765,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,7.017725,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.692449,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.359907,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.604763,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.691412,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,6.348532,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,35.089169,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.060519,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.920902,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.382683,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.7522158,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,5.116319,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.469709,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.653274,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.994743,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,6.117727,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.75211,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.873728,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.115088,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,5.740925,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.866347,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.098479,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.49108,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.769775,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,7.22568,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.879169,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.767364,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.600723,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.803899,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,7.051156,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.929735,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.794073,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.258627,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.662036,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,7.644472,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,38.896279,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.8834293,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.773977,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.391537,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.6999633,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,4.748907,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.993272,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.621124,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.805695,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,5.42009,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.941981,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.788864,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.794969,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,5.525814,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.111795,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.661525,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.8581015,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.810883,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,5.442304,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.916042,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.802094,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.58212,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.971944,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,7.2722,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.676809,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.571091,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.956587,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.609487,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,6.813975,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,35.22329,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.096706,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.876325,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.472547,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.120672,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,5.56625,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.704042,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.10774,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.773656,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,6.585437,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.91744,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.243452,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.612379,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,5.773271,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.324531,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.717548,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.918754,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.781806,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,5.74264,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.655121,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.712886,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.602886,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.87276,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,6.843654,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.804642,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.818262,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.333789,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.638226,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,7.594919,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,38.106171,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.9245473,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.734673,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.428451,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.6061628,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,4.693834,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.509831,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.768678,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.5669,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,5.84541,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.888784,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.887204,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.006179,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,5.782167,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.577074,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.896577,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.096407,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.827456,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,6.397514,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.938102,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.699868,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.426244,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.783001,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,6.847215,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.69158,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.912948,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.341245,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.590598,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,7.536371,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,37.102511,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.115111,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.916334,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.191744,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.7123387,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,4.935528,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.734982,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.109479,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.884002,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,6.728463,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.156617,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.913216,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.109761,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,6.179594,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.698375,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.941327,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.199439,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.830713,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,6.669854,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.809309,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.733519,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.704032,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.962797,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,7.209657,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.751119,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.684138,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.001058,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.691061,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,7.127376,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,38.850472,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.8997563,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.662035,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.381922,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.6050462,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,4.548759,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.078046,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.500074,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.810091,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,5.388211,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.985737,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.671828,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.876091,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,5.533657,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.582267,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.886615,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.22093,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.78468,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,6.474493,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.788357,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.585116,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.67574,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.890742,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,6.939955,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.796031,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.655824,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.636165,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.647043,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,6.735062,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,35.620137,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.9819107,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.687149,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.24777,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.6343327,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,4.551163,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.260193,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.741092,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.784864,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,5.78615,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.122972,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.910889,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.08188,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,6.115741,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.528827,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.881759,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.160185,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.884021,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,6.454791,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.691863,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.510256,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.734442,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.830422,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,6.766984,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.852946,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.649804,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.753438,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.637598,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,6.893786,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,36.568615,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.9039618,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.758859,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.093594,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.612945,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,4.369359,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.115713,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.701184,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.802862,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,5.619759,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.091514,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.789282,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.924828,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,5.805624,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.791563,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.907378,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.217733,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.532334,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,6.449008,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.596946,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.858927,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.619266,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.802519,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,6.877658,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.027212,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.554963,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.420995,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.697359,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,6.700529,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,35.821937,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.9543979,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.676995,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.526526,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.6171553,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,4.775074,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.654999,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.832553,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.811608,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,6.299161,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.184907,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.243129,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.111616,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,6.539651,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.824256,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.045187,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.437852,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.965506,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,7.272801,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.766366,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.834381,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.416909,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.968827,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,6.986482,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.042477,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.984887,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.158042,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.674577,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,7.859983,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,39.733152,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.01986,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.528777,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.297022,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.9112383,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,4.756897,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.099566,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.673446,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.81055,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,5.583562,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.877349,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.960846,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.894129,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,5.732325,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.774554,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.008676,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.34903,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.884905,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,7.017166,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.682781,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.722656,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.603811,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.880095,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,6.889343,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.9033,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.578104,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.014369,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.668919,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,7.164692,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,37.143985,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.9246721,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.58723,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.245552,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.6237678,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,4.381222,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.992711,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.531488,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.545069,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,5.069269,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.106278,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.689743,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.905294,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,5.701316,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.404708,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.721065,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.06569,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.800418,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,5.99188,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.440762,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.822784,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.77537,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.870664,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,6.909579,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.776276,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.81269,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.017121,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.6561,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,7.262187,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,35.315453,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.039529,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.535226,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.411182,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.8447956,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,4.830733,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.847596,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.467112,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.745777,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,5.060485,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.883821,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.63267,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.586184,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,5.102675,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.485719,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.829932,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.9359076,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.676017,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,5.927576,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.573058,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.726464,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.468276,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.827154,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,6.594952,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.779673,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.556927,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.750029,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.621059,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,6.707688,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,34.224109,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.9374065,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.630904,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.173903,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.637832,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,4.380045,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.481286,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.993933,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.588942,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,6.064161,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.953545,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.160643,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.880191,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,5.994379,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.599134,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.876012,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.217613,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.923769,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,6.616528,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.792343,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.68757,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.46081,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.839117,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,6.77984,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.007694,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.507727,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.533126,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.701081,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,6.749629,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,36.584582,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.8167498,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.646662,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.294567,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.8899919,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,4.647972,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.984405,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.69758,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.765775,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,5.447761,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.034715,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.915387,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.800009,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,5.750111,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.722165,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.995277,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.149355,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.812303,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,6.679101,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.408276,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.555158,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.648603,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.81316,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,6.425196,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.921754,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.665431,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.567574,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.675079,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,6.829839,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,35.77998,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.9178493,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.737519,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.314703,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.7930118,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,4.763083,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.851426,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.742423,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.778163,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,5.372011,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.064814,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.754172,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.809039,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,5.628025,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.710481,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.928985,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.177379,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.776209,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,6.593053,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.601619,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.704233,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.482109,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.92143,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,6.709391,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.775495,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.637336,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.843909,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.6853,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,6.942039,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,36.007602,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2014,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.9948081,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.59051,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.56509,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.056317,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,5.206726,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2014,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.362535,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.639676,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.793097,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,5.795309,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2014,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.829788,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.841934,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.941537,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,5.613258,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2014,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.988206,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.057911,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.250274,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.989387,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,7.285778,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2014,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.462636,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.860449,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.536254,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.955472,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,6.814811,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2014,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.728192,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2014,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.656279,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2014,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.305881,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2014,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.768724,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2014,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,6.459076,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2014,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,37.174958,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.073683500289917,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.458857774734497,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.5953840017318726,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.9260817170143129,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.054007053375244,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.8116023540496824,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.7275700569152832,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.680769681930542,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.219942092895508,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.7681338787078855,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.782759428024292,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.0328807830810547,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.583774089813232,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.1506277322769165,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.5336798429489136,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.6288788318634033,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.67983078956604,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,4.993017196655273,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.350815773010254,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.8045222759246824,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.5571794509887695,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.817862629890442,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,6.5303802490234375,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.5972145795822144,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.5966283082962036,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.9309985637664795,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.5959354639053345,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,6.7207770347595215,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,34.10189771652222,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.6185468435287476,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.312865138053894,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.237740397453308,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.7557183504104614,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,3.924870729446411,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.2025976181030273,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.477974772453308,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.4574579000473022,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,5.138030052185059,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.5306466817855835,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.611419439315796,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.562479019165039,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,4.704545021057129,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.090052366256714,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.5316776037216189,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.5817696452140808,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.5528695583343506,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,4.756369113922119,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.3902215957641602,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.7671105861663818,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.5156522989273071,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.6701029539108276,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,6.343087196350098,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.10050368309021,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.8053131103515625,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.3024309873580933,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.6522663831710815,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,6.860514163970947,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,31.727416276931763,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.872063159942627,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.478097677230835,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.3739567995071411,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.8103294372558594,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,4.534447193145752,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.6178126335144043,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.82157301902771,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.4795113801956177,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,5.9188971519470215,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.6735566854476929,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.5300699472427368,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.6082944869995115,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,4.811921119689941,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.3238849639892578,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.649717926979065,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.7967025637626648,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.633889079093933,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,5.404194355010986,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.4938650131225586,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.74896240234375,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.5030959844589231,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.763537049293518,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,6.50946044921875,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.0311038494110107,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.6431779861450195,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.381303071975708,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.6271628141403198,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,6.682747840881348,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,33.8616681098938,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.947906255722046,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.422228217124939,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.593719482421875,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.7593705654144287,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,4.723224639892578,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.3581290245056152,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.7687908411026,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.7250310182571411,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.8519511222839355,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.809084415435791,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.6586018800735474,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.8435516357421875,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.311237812042236,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.4964101314544678,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.5679092407226562,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.6390699744224548,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.7806012630462646,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.483990669250488,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.731249213218689,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.6394838094711304,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.4433385133743286,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.9422801733016968,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,6.756351947784424,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.014418363571167,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.644331455230713,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.4569991827011108,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.6661972999572754,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,6.781946182250977,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,34.90870237350464,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.0123518705368042,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.4762609004974363,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.714349627494812,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.9236319661140442,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,5.126594066619873,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.599515914916992,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.8733618259429932,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.660449743270874,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,6.133327484130859,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.420488953590393,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.8689424991607664,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.6982781887054443,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,4.9877095222473145,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.478987216949463,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.798163890838623,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.0795152187347412,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.7533280849456787,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,6.109994411468506,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.5091118812561035,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.7465418577194214,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.7386592626571655,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.962852120399475,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,6.957165241241455,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.9537307024002075,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.8791823387145996,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.674747109413147,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.7295695543289185,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,7.237229824066162,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,36.55202054977417,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.8393560647964478,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.3776308298110962,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.4504791498184204,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.8302891850471497,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,4.49775505065918,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.238903760910034,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.0070085525512695,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.6957416534423828,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.941654205322266,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.9313437938690183,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.8670654296875,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.193037748336792,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.9914469718933105,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.2105364799499512,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.4796737432479858,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.854396641254425,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.6524603366851809,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.1970672607421875,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.6394097805023191,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.7951878309249878,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.6151714324951172,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.932259440422058,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,6.982028484344482,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.028064489364624,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.852151870727539,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.5108673572540283,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.7286590337753296,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,7.119742393493652,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,35.72969436645508,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.9424705505371094,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.6424391269683838,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.5197198390960691,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.503338634967804,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,4.607968330383301,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.633373022079468,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.7653228044509888,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.4501079320907593,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,5.848803997039795,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.81718909740448,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.022508144378662,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.883366942405701,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,5.723063945770264,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.4454158544540403,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.6729625463485718,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.7460847496986389,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.5564948320388794,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,5.420958042144775,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.5537468194961548,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.728063941001892,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.5257445573806765,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.92814302444458,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,6.735698223114014,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.922221541404724,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.6546142101287842,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.6992785930633545,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.6452919244766235,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,6.921406269073486,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,35.257898807525635,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.6782186627388,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.1871894598007202,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.375920295715332,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.5095248222351074,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,3.7508530616760254,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.8071770668029783,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.6297059059143066,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.4554060697555542,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,4.892289161682129,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.6082992553710938,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.041926145553589,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.9660398960113523,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,5.616265296936035,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.256794571876526,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.5744155645370483,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.814916729927063,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.3959378004074097,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,5.042064666748047,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.6451168060302734,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.9297337532043457,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.6599327325820925,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.8816683292388916,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,7.116451740264893,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.012425661087036,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.347650408744812,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.2701679468154907,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.706445574760437,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,6.336689472198486,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,32.754613399505615,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.9377366900444032,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.5557929277420044,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.581203818321228,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.7328541874885559,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,4.807587623596191,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.2298083305358887,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.855063557624817,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.157725214958191,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,5.2425971031188965,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.8449995517730713,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.082754611968994,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.0372085571289062,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,5.964962959289551,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.4934937953948977,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.7441824674606323,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.0031967163085938,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.6273043155670166,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,5.86817741394043,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.608114242553711,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.7834728956222534,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.4529186487197876,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.9186419248580933,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,6.763147830963135,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.0010297298431396,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.652431607246399,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.5034382343292236,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.7056738138198853,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,6.862573623657227,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,35.50904655456543,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.8321595788002014,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.2401416301727295,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.2593735456466677,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.825524091720581,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,4.157198905944824,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.632761836051941,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.684967875480652,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.6539263725280762,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,4.971656322479248,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.931902289390564,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.8124500513076784,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.8024322986602783,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,5.5467848777771,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.273423433303833,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.509965181350708,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.6360111236572266,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.541202187538147,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,4.960601806640625,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.5470463037490845,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.7661824226379397,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.6379764080047607,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.9162347316741943,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,6.8674397468566895,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.765161633491516,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.59837806224823,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.55130934715271,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.534224510192871,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,6.449073791503906,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,32.95275545120239,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.0937550067901611,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.5574105978012085,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.707472562789917,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.3862366676330566,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.744874954223633,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.26560378074646,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.65655517578125,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.598209023475647,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.5203680992126465,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.889458417892456,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.026647567749023,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.9505534172058103,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.866659164428711,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.409875988960266,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.6482242345809937,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.8551734685897827,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.69134521484375,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.604619026184082,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.6165767908096311,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.8304955959320068,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.5518059730529783,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.8834697008132937,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,6.88234806060791,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.8347431421279907,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.8436120748519895,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.7366793155670166,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.6279665231704712,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,7.043001174926758,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,36.66187047958374,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.9992258548736572,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.4694254398345947,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.719800353050232,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.184552788734436,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.37300443649292,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.478850841522217,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.8758432865142824,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.602036952972412,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.956730842590332,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.6393996477127075,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.8558235168457031,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.8835325241088867,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.378755569458008,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.705588459968567,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.7439696788787842,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.7376872897148132,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.6915470361709597,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.8787922859191895,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.808159589767456,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.7209426164627075,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.729974389076233,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.923784852027893,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,7.182861328125,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.010910987854004,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.5613123178482056,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.721324443817139,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.6739505529403689,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,6.967498302459717,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,36.737642765045166,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.867231547832489,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.325093150138855,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.4662871360778809,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.5854542255401611,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,4.24406623840332,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.351954698562622,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.7280888557434082,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.5920753479003906,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,5.672119140625,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.8564722537994385,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.5941587686538696,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.8835690021514893,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,5.334199905395508,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.7171683311462402,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.9269527196884155,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.6857594847679138,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.7110778093338013,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,6.040958404541016,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.7213460206985474,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.8039313554763792,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.5300745964050293,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.8054224252700808,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,6.860774517059326,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.9202722311019895,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.5915319919586182,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.6323919296264648,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.6643548011779783,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,6.808550834655762,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,34.96066904067993,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.0873435735702517,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.4947082996368408,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.6882237195968628,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.9276615977287292,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,5.197937488555908,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.9323110580444336,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.807301640510559,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.586776852607727,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,5.326389312744141,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.9343457221984863,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.7254678010940552,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.030369281768799,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,5.690183162689209,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.443821668624878,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.796712040901184,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.8791058659553528,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.5995548963546753,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,5.719194412231445,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.6128231287002563,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.7338411808013916,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.6106140613555908,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.8321833610534668,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,6.789462089538574,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.971835970878601,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.5462080240249634,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.4702152013778689,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.6946479082107544,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,6.6829071044921875,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,35.406073570251465,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.127739429473877,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.4042842388153076,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.5377317667007446,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.3353729248046875,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,5.405128002166748,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.1761534214019775,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.458735466003418,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.7736382484436035,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,5.408527374267578,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.6801297664642334,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.930260419845581,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.8575459718704224,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,5.467936038970947,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.696025848388672,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.0313196182250977,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.9209482669830322,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.5631922483444214,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,6.211485862731934,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.5361337661743164,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.8219653367996216,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.786228060722351,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.887035131454468,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,7.031362533569336,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.82136070728302,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.7562272548675537,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.615833759307861,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.7012933492660522,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,6.894714832305908,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,36.41915464401245,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.20138680934906,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.6025505065917969,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.6678396463394165,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.3700708150863647,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,5.8418474197387695,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.405522584915161,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.6862266063690186,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.7592278718948364,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,5.850976943969727,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.099433183670044,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.413463830947876,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.4336347579956055,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,6.946531772613525,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.750640630722046,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.956821322441101,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.201611876487732,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.7399739027023315,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,6.6490478515625,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.5282264947891235,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.8375593423843384,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.653216004371643,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.874677062034607,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,6.893678665161133,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.921493649482727,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.6914334297180176,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.5873448848724363,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.676152586936951,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,6.876424789428711,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,39.058507442474365,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.922751486301422,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.3453015089035034,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.6399450302124023,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.788975179195404,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,4.6969733238220215,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.2055909633636475,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.6292884349822998,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.798735499382019,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,5.633615016937256,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.7204804420471191,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.734679937362671,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.8409548997879028,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,5.296114921569824,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.5838934183120728,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.8938151597976685,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.9649666547775269,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.6746962070465088,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,6.117371559143066,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.6472731828689575,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.6795752048492432,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.547282338142395,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.8326208591461184,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,6.706751346588135,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.729361057281494,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.882685899734497,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.8154480457305908,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.6877057552337646,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,7.115200519561768,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,35.56602668762207,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.3320753574371338,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.621148943901062,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.6778318881988523,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.1133986711502075,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.744454860687256,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.2170581817626953,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.529524803161621,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.9106849431991575,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.6572675704956055,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.9749135971069336,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.3660051822662354,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.486359119415283,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,6.827278137207031,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.5135616064071655,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.746979832649231,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.7293199896812439,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.6864906549453735,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.676352024078369,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.866595983505249,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.852133512496948,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.7528986930847168,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.035250663757324,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,7.506878852844238,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.9238216876983645,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.9524893760681152,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.0580554008483887,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.6933479309082031,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,7.62771463394165,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,39.03994607925415,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.1384726762771606,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.438531517982483,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.5968154668807983,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.3420367240905762,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,5.5158562660217285,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.1802055835723877,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.626684069633484,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.8412994146347048,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,5.648189067840576,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.7123404741287231,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.352259397506714,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.1402688026428223,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,6.204868793487549,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.4755580425262451,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.7360237836837769,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.9339771270751952,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.794985294342041,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,5.940544128417969,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.6112968921661377,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.8349180221557615,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.7539680004119873,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.9910370111465456,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,7.191219806671143,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.80317223072052,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.661980152130127,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.8781222105026243,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.5740844011306765,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,6.917358875274658,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,37.41803693771362,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.0351403951644895,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.345232605934143,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.525574803352356,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.5996939539909363,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,4.505641460418701,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.9352811574935913,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.5337690114974976,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.7054784297943115,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,5.1745285987854,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.6418205499649048,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.7190946340560913,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.536983609199524,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,4.897899150848389,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.344274401664734,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.660991907119751,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.8734850883483887,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.6444083452224731,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,5.523159503936768,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.5475205183029177,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.9593350887298584,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.654273271560669,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.8281280994415283,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,6.989257335662842,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.43783700466156,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.5769731998443604,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.3878061771392822,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.6524630784988403,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,7.055079460144043,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,34.14556550979614,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.9654330611228944,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.34088933467865,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.5484907627105713,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.306686282157898,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.161499500274658,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.117452383041382,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.3565348386764526,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.60720956325531,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.0811967849731445,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.5561434030532837,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.0406839847564697,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.993499755859375,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.59032678604126,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.3448352813720703,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.5339747667312622,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.6574190855026245,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.594624638557434,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.130853652954102,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.5752733945846558,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.637869119644165,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.5306015014648438,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.8460043668746948,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,6.589748382568359,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.836794137954712,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.816053867340088,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.224611520767212,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.6154191493988037,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,7.492878437042236,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,35.04650354385376,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.170338153839111,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.5515979528427124,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.6389081478118896,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.4386030435562134,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,5.799447059631348,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.2142698764801025,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.9001907110214231,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.8257756233215332,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,5.9402360916137695,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.7951878309249878,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.080063819885254,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.097156047821045,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,5.972407817840576,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.5942169427871704,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.7513313293457031,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.7951745986938477,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.822792649269104,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,5.963515281677246,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.7466270923614502,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.700317144393921,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.4787578582763672,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.8744218349456787,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,6.800124168395996,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.960994005203247,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.6281267404556274,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.660685896873474,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.6893904209136963,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,6.939197063446045,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,37.41492748260498,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.033764362335205,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.4236905574798584,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.6213657855987549,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.8507543802261353,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,4.929574966430664,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.329578399658203,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.6731996536254885,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.7669986486434937,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,5.769776821136475,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.5842939615249634,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.872584581375122,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.965567946434021,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,5.422446250915527,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.588805913925171,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.704419493675232,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.8922977447509766,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.656790018081665,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,5.842313289642334,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.6271613836288452,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.764128804206848,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.6617664098739624,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.8715238571166992,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,6.9245805740356445,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.7827259302139282,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.6595032215118408,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.7999801635742188,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.66610848903656,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,6.908318042755127,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,35.79700994491577,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.2286864519119265,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.4619665145874023,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.614161252975464,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.0582561492919922,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,5.363070011138916,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.3888895511627197,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.855269193649292,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.8774445056915283,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,6.121603012084961,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.9811877012252808,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.3944525718688965,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.195155382156372,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,6.57079553604126,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.541327953338623,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.6637861728668213,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.8097394108772278,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.870980978012085,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,5.885834693908691,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.7280398607254028,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.9525059461593628,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.6413074731826782,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.8578976392745972,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,7.179750919342041,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.7680397033691406,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.633922815322876,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.91617214679718,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.685667872428894,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,7.00380277633667,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,38.12485694885254,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.9025797843933104,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.2549078464508057,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.679027795791626,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.1208181381225586,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,4.957333564758301,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.2810637950897217,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.6042548418045044,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.5963144302368164,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,5.481633186340332,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.738025188446045,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.8048081398010256,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.125524520874023,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,5.668357849121094,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.561484694480896,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.7455899715423584,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.1051722764968872,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.8570765256881712,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,6.269323348999023,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.621290683746338,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.918237328529358,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.7843232154846191,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.8746581077575684,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,7.198509693145752,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.8677690029144287,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.6451900005340576,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.2516462802886963,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.6882100105285645,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,7.452815055847168,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,37.02797269821167,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.1172939538955688,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.5534793138504028,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.7157732248306274,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.7722645401954651,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,5.158811092376709,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.3319156169891357,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.7825329303741455,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.827411413192749,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,5.941859722137451,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.5600605010986328,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.011362791061402,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.1727423667907715,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,5.744165420532227,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.6315646171569824,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.9466177225112915,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.0537961721420288,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.7838428020477295,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,6.415821075439453,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.7036291360855105,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.8369972705841064,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.68374764919281,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.9602108001708984,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,7.184585094451904,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.9221949577331543,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.6193417310714722,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.8707606792449951,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.674525499343872,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,7.086822986602783,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,37.53206539154053,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.009906530380249,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.4961280822753906,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.669625759124756,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.113638162612915,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.2892985343933105,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.319674015045166,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.8490136861801147,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.7306526899337769,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.899340629577637,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.8141273260116575,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.1632256507873535,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.075765371322632,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,6.0531182289123535,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.4404139518737793,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.6172337532043457,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.7841961979866028,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.6731382608413696,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.514982223510742,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.648568868637085,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.8905766010284424,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.5106425285339355,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.8647490739822388,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,6.914536952972412,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.774452567100525,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.593827247619629,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.6529203653335571,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.6661412715911863,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,6.687341690063477,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,36.35861825942993,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.478602647781372,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.8423551321029663,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.7718379497528076,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.351245641708374,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,6.4440412521362305,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.888942241668701,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.256596088409424,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.0940029621124268,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,7.239541053771973,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.1062402725219727,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.6565775871276855,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.742871046066284,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,7.5056891441345215,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.8036786317825315,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.0352375507354736,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.015319585800171,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.812303900718689,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,6.666539669036865,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.7581782341003418,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.8824546337127688,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.700049638748169,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.961697697639465,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,7.302380084991455,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.039369583129883,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.7261205911636353,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.6914918422698977,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.7146289348602295,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,7.1716108322143555,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,42.3298020362854,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.1413894891738892,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.3618329763412476,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.6681843996047974,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.6974514126777649,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,4.868858337402344,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.077385902404785,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.6176122426986694,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.580047845840454,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,5.275045871734619,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.7820056676864624,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.2910573482513428,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.0670077800750732,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,6.140070915222168,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.6681718826293943,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.7450361251831057,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.7575612664222717,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.7688274383544922,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,5.939596652984619,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.6877049207687378,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.8905088901519775,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.674377202987671,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.9530656337738037,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,7.2056565284729,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.038525104522705,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.6148061752319336,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.912895917892456,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.5567173957824707,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,7.1229448318481445,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,36.552173137664795,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.1705843210220337,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.634582757949829,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.5150405168533323,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.9666606187820436,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,5.286868095397949,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.3103318214416504,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.9458826780319216,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.764101505279541,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,6.020316123962402,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.022303342819214,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.0941240787506104,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.288942575454712,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,6.405369758605957,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.8533546924591064,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.0625624656677246,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.9576956033706664,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.816641926765442,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,6.6902546882629395,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.675695300102234,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.665742039680481,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.4676060676574707,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.9296520948410032,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,6.7386956214904785,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.0239744186401367,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.6547727584838867,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.710894227027893,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.6348775625228882,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,7.024518966674805,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,38.16602325439453,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.9332727193832396,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.5438839197158811,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.5538181066513062,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.8482433557510376,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,4.879218101501465,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.314767599105835,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.6231582164764404,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.4576987028121948,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.39562463760376,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.8730090856552124,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.7499901056289673,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.959274172782898,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.582273483276367,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.4910625219345093,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.8245936632156372,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.9214065670967102,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.7832006216049194,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,6.020263195037842,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.3333700895309448,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.944164752960205,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.5228012800216677,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.911747932434082,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,6.7120842933654785,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.9350324869155884,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.3740184307098389,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.3643200397491455,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.6828570365905762,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,7.356227874755859,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,35.94569158554077,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.1343868970870972,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.4986213445663452,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.6971030235290527,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.7382640242576599,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,5.068375110626221,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.7577390670776367,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.027198076248169,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.6917667388916016,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,5.476704120635986,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.291252851486206,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.9446862936019895,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.6190073490142822,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,5.854946613311768,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.2671306133270264,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.7002859115600586,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.9034554958343506,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.7119615077972412,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,5.582833290100098,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.7916407585144043,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.7995667457580566,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.6760581731796265,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.9078853130340576,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,7.1751508712768555,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.8207027912139893,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.7205218076705933,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.3592946529388428,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.6297537088394165,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,7.530272960662842,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,36.68828296661377,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.2983248233795166,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.8117709159851072,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.7398515939712524,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.014850616455078,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,5.864798069000244,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.308147668838501,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.6002020835876465,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.6361192464828491,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,5.544468879699707,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.985723853111267,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.6825662851333618,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.8512669801712036,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,5.519556999206543,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.6693532466888428,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.9930282831192017,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.9877046942710876,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.863131761550903,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,6.513217926025391,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.5363872051239014,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.545124888420105,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.3824667930603027,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.9545795917510984,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,6.418558120727539,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.0748538970947266,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.370213508605957,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.5759137868881226,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.6442008018493652,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,6.665182113647461,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,36.525782108306885,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.7738878726959229,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.2805527448654177,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.3169001340866089,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.7086624503135681,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,4.080003261566162,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.6652413606643677,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.3438942432403564,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.5954288244247437,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,4.604564666748047,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.9634798765182495,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.8052983283996584,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.6228564977645874,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,5.391634464263916,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.2285212278366089,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.6252248287200928,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.873139500617981,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.6511040925979614,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,5.377989768981934,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.3647792339324951,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.374477744102478,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.3949562311172483,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.7608931064605713,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,5.895106315612793,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.7248315811157229,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.38625168800354,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.68533456325531,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.6152743101119995,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,6.411692142486572,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,31.760990619659424,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.029831051826477,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.4311634302139282,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.4400928020477295,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.89812171459198,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,4.799209117889404,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.224445104598999,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.5430830717086792,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.878123760223389,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,5.645651817321777,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.7427830696105957,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.111084461212158,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.087306022644043,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,5.941173553466797,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.4468498229980469,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.901103377342224,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.9860748648643494,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.7774509191513062,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,6.111478805541992,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.4690552949905396,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.9013556241989136,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.4342716932296753,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.8888357877731323,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,6.693518161773682,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.836555004119873,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.5949403047561646,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.790637493133545,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.6796722412109375,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,6.9018049240112305,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,36.09283638000488,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.932928502559662,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.4721002578735352,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.330017328262329,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.9026347994804382,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,4.637680530548096,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.978409767150879,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.5355439186096191,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.7005410194396973,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,5.214494705200195,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.781972050666809,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.798174262046814,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.7400685548782349,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,5.320215225219727,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.234891653060913,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.5749715566635132,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.8402090668678284,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.6310360431671145,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,5.281108379364014,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.4900044202804563,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.7620941400527954,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.1061227321624756,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.9253202676773071,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,6.283541679382324,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.8686035871505735,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.7644987106323242,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.7721222639083862,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.643854737281799,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,7.049079418182373,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,33.78611993789673,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.9799759984016418,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.563185214996338,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.3624604940414429,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.5642865896224976,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,4.469908237457275,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.5236632823944092,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.577748417854309,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.5937516689300537,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,4.695163249969482,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.8524266481399536,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.5776677131652832,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.7699854373931885,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,5.200079917907715,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.390500783920288,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.6381524801254272,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.8726378679275513,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.6452816724777222,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,5.546573162078857,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.4035507440567017,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.665951371192932,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.5729774236679075,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.89844274520874,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,6.540922164916992,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.8706271648406985,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.6134324073791504,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.9373109340667725,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.5207144021987915,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,6.942084789276123,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,33.394731521606445,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.8084057569503784,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.4917950630187988,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.3857988119125366,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.7445856928825378,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,4.430584907531738,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.7549382448196411,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.243521809577942,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.4961140155792236,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,4.494574069976807,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.6927884817123413,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.7324916124343872,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.7454614639282229,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,5.170741558074951,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.512792706489563,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.8018255233764648,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.061078429222107,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.6122357845306396,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,5.987932205200195,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.338727355003357,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.564886212348938,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.7485793828964231,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.764481544494629,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,6.416674613952637,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.9922921657562256,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.5942226648330688,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.0831832885742188,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.702226638793945,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,7.371924877166748,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,33.872432231903076,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.845297634601593,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.5479848384857178,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.4748613834381104,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.8634353876113892,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,4.731579303741455,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.7862602472305298,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.4029486179351809,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.5173920392990112,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,4.706601142883301,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.024383306503296,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.613686203956604,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.9312005043029783,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,5.569270133972168,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.3076813220977783,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.7456223964691162,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.9638903141021729,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.5674231052398682,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,5.5846171379089355,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.7640272378921509,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.7570078372955322,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.527176856994629,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.8928312063217163,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,6.941042900085449,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.701096534729004,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.6555414199829102,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.234292507171631,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.5413157939910889,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,7.132246017456055,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,34.66535663604736,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.8421579599380493,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.3871697187423706,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.408176064491272,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.7430626153945923,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,4.380566120147705,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.7806179523468018,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.622478723526001,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.5203160047531128,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,4.923412799835205,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.0439682006835938,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.753886103630066,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.9535318613052368,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,5.7513861656188965,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.3043746948242188,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.5177546739578247,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.7108466029167175,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.5739706754684448,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,5.10694694519043,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.4380708932876587,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.626228094100952,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.4824248552322388,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8225618600845337,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,6.369285583496094,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8150546550750732,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.7565220594406128,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.667183518409729,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.5368818044662476,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,6.775641918182373,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,33.3072395324707,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.0835765600204468,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.4271048307418823,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.418926239013672,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.9094061255455016,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,4.839014053344727,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.010377883911133,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.6590497493743896,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.6624324321746826,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,5.331860065460205,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.85405695438385,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.7564703226089478,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.8696907758712769,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,5.480217933654785,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.3875995874404907,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.7674015760421753,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.740139901638031,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.5714209079742432,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,5.466561794281006,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.4892313480377195,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.8173624277114868,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.7157223224639893,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.879189372062683,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,6.901505470275879,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.5945301055908203,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.589296579360962,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.7532951831817627,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.5772409439086914,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,6.514362812042236,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,34.53352212905884,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.8620948791503906,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.514962077140808,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.490919828414917,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.7323463559150696,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,4.60032320022583,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.8915973901748655,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.6098483800888062,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.7768999338150024,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,5.278345584869385,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.9760351181030271,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.763733983039856,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.6953343152999878,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,5.435103416442871,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.231161117553711,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.5875358581542969,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.5770494937896729,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.6735981702804563,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,5.069344520568848,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.6668485403060913,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.8048862218856812,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.6867109537124634,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.8630646467208865,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,7.021510124206543,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.9014418125152588,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.8719568252563477,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.691165328025818,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.6662646532058716,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,7.130828857421875,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,34.53545570373535,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.0679092407226562,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.514301061630249,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.6248310804367063,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.6341170072555542,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,4.841158390045166,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.7603360414505005,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.4985568523406982,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.660840630531311,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,4.91973352432251,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.6580979824066162,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.505781650543213,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.8492592573165896,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,5.013138771057129,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.3664857149124146,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.771438717842102,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.9384045004844666,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.8640929460525513,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,5.9404215812683105,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.4514724016189575,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.7557634115219116,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.384608268737793,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.7844438552856443,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,6.376287937164307,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.7183326482772827,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.161729335784912,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.8582091331481936,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.5804076194763184,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,6.318678855895996,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,33.40941905975342,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.9462344646453856,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.5345748662948608,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.4303752183914185,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.764484703540802,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,4.675669193267822,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.7810003757476809,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.5758607387542725,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.5628373622894287,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,4.919698715209961,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.0175182819366455,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.605173945426941,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.9462920427322388,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,5.568984031677246,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.220332384109497,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.574793815612793,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.8079291582107544,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.6128590106964111,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,5.215914249420166,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.5104955434799194,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.9078247547149656,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.515756607055664,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.825147271156311,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,6.759223937988281,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.884414553642273,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.5811727046966553,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.9901230335235596,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.6176443099975586,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,7.073354721069336,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,34.21284484863281,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.9855176210403442,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.459241509437561,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.523992896080017,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.7930241227149963,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,4.761775970458984,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.277651071548462,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.812738060951233,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.556515336036682,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,5.646904468536377,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.0829620361328125,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.811859369277954,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.8039963245391848,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,5.698817729949951,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.3600598573684692,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.7427077293395996,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.7677443027496338,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.8016811609268188,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,5.6721930503845215,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.8767895698547363,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.8111392259597776,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.652430534362793,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.9440475702285769,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,7.284407138824463,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.5616475343704224,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.2083417177200315,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.918943762779236,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.6349496841430664,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,6.323882579803467,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,35.387980937957764,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.9320140480995178,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.6887818574905396,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.4785761833190918,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.7394692301750183,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,4.838841438293457,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.5841370820999146,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.278390884399414,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.87579607963562,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,4.738324165344238,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.9613362550735471,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.796576976776123,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.848676323890686,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,5.6065897941589355,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.5667132139205933,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.893416404724121,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.3672960996627808,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.7453478574752808,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,6.572773456573486,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.635623812675476,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.7589610815048218,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.5811351537704468,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.8267427682876587,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,6.802462577819824,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.8166418075561523,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.633650302886963,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.006269693374634,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.7220098972320557,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,7.178571701049805,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,35.737563133239746,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.8177825212478638,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.2504534721374512,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.4421805143356323,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.7203040719032288,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,4.230720520019531,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.4364569187164307,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.6543350219726562,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.2960816621780396,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,5.386873722076416,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.52397358417511,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.601440191268921,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.6717487573623655,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,4.7971625328063965,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.9849113821983336,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.552344560623169,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.7572630643844604,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.5745630264282229,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,4.869081974029541,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.7094846963882446,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.6958762407302856,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.3910893201828003,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.9194304943084717,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,6.715880870819092,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.4348328113555908,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.5911844968795776,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.220785140991211,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.618364691734314,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,6.865167140960693,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,32.86488676071167,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.920564830303192,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.4841766357421875,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.3297353982925415,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.0428658723831177,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,4.777342319488525,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.018953800201416,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.5553922653198242,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.5097906589508057,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,5.084136962890625,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.8012681007385254,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.8956694602966309,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.9073466062545776,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,5.604284286499023,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.3502591848373413,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.7577673196792605,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.9972866773605348,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.7939453125,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,5.899258613586426,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.703184962272644,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.7378414869308472,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.4252119064331057,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.9008766412734983,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,6.767115116119385,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.806404948234558,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.8237242698669431,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.2142012119293213,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.6583747863769531,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,7.502705097198486,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,35.63484239578247,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.8196397423744202,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.452376365661621,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.4624614715576172,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.6392960548400879,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,4.373773574829102,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.0840117931365967,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.440569281578064,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.659424066543579,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,5.184005260467529,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.8517717123031616,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.7732738256454468,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.546657681465149,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,5.171703338623047,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.4430278539657593,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.771949291229248,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.8821954131126404,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.5957733392715454,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,5.692945957183838,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.6504402160644531,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.5491797924041748,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.7476059198379517,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.880837559700012,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,6.828063488006592,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.7121421098709106,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.63479483127594,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.238819360733032,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.634186625480652,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,7.219943046569824,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,34.47043466567993,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.9376253485679626,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.489079236984253,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.3081480264663696,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.5311905145645142,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,4.266043186187744,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.069021463394165,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.9012362957000732,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.444279432296753,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,5.41453742980957,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.8804367780685425,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.4782536029815674,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.610260248184204,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,4.9689507484436035,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.0204761028289795,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.6603108644485474,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.7108739614486694,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.748624563217163,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,5.140285491943359,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.8748304843902588,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.72646963596344,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.6433134078979492,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.8048025369644165,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,7.0494160652160645,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.5587153434753418,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.8698424100875857,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.3814337253570557,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.5741255283355713,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,7.384117126464844,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,34.223350048065186,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.1446675062179563,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.78385591506958,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.297717809677124,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.7174304127693176,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,4.943671703338623,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.662111759185791,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.87828528881073,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.7157840728759766,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,6.256181240081787,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.0833539962768555,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.8176658153533936,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.128314733505249,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,6.029334545135498,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.813210606575012,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.0912585258483887,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.3698498010635376,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.7548412084579468,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,7.029160022735596,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.864749312400818,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.6799181699752808,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.8982274532318115,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.0135889053344727,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,7.456483840942383,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.8234336376190183,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.713996171951294,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.9827022552490232,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.713760256767273,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,7.233892440795898,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,38.948723793029785,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.7840230464935303,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.5998650789260864,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.045743703842163,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.9319232702255248,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,4.361555099487305,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.8164154291152952,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.5033338069915771,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.6259185075759888,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,4.945667743682861,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.8062959909439087,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.5156967639923096,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.8995214700698853,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,5.2215142250061035,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.4516335725784302,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.82703697681427,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.1483726501464844,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.7263213396072388,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,6.153364658355713,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.5793131589889526,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.8411110639572144,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.7421317100524902,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.7952824831008911,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,6.957838535308838,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.739213943481445,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.701998949050903,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.3635032176971436,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.614051342010498,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,6.41876745223999,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,34.05870771408081,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.0773719549179075,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.6917047500610352,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.3986506462097168,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.9560347199440002,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,5.123762130737305,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.4222357273101807,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.592785358428955,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.8013129234313965,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,5.816333770751953,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.003594875335694,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.7856037616729736,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.8668559789657593,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,5.656054496765137,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.547078251838684,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.8840360641479492,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.2614201307296753,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.6686069965362549,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,6.361141204833984,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.6402461528778076,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.8470734357833865,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.6453957557678225,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.8769910335540771,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,7.009706497192383,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.773184895515442,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.677215337753296,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.803201675415039,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.6320981979370115,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,6.885700225830078,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,36.85269832611084,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.8863838315010071,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.4104303121566772,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.2843480110168457,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.0514178276062012,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,4.632579803466797,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.7218387126922607,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.3986589908599854,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.6827802658081057,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,4.803277969360352,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.07810640335083,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.722667932510376,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.6363608837127686,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,5.437135219573975,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.9822673797607424,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.143176317214966,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.452013611793518,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.6932387351989746,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,7.27069616317749,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.1373926401138306,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.894083023071289,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.7088313102722168,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.9427393674850464,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,6.683046340942383,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.8535728454589844,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.450363278388977,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.3991755247116089,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.722177505493164,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,6.425289154052734,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,35.25202465057373,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.8963095545768738,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.5824205875396729,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.365615963935852,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.6917575597763062,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,4.53610372543335,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.305528163909912,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.544912815093994,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.6298996210098269,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,5.480340480804443,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.8615256547927856,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.135646104812622,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.7709228992462158,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,5.768094539642334,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.6415146589279177,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.9647003412246704,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.26105797290802,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.6936771869659424,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,6.56095027923584,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.5136734247207642,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.730463624000549,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.6829798221588137,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.710100531578064,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,6.6372175216674805,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.8567132949829104,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.0225658416748047,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.191089868545532,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.6856271028518677,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,7.755996227264404,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,36.73870277404785,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.12611186504364,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.473135471343994,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.451282620429993,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.1115477085113523,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,5.1620774269104,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.376645565032959,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.538099765777588,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.8149449825286863,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,5.7296905517578125,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.9454772472381592,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.2292120456695557,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.0671119689941406,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,6.2418012619018555,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.8129111528396609,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.0117499828338623,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.267603635787964,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.5904346704483032,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,6.682699680328369,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.4787509441375732,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.886220932006836,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.8669875860214231,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.8051533699035645,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,7.037112712860107,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.9035258293151855,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.656744122505188,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.864596247673035,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.6324138641357422,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,7.05728006362915,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,37.910661697387695,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.9009008407592772,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.3626103401184082,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.3392024040222168,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.7819949984550476,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,4.384708404541016,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.7804464101791382,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.4621766805648804,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.580436110496521,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,4.82305908203125,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.9786200523376465,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.5980849266052246,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.708216905593872,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,5.284921646118164,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.375763177871704,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.7366790771484375,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.0149198770523071,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.7253063917160034,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,5.852668285369873,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.468951940536499,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.760448336601257,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.615757703781128,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.807333707809448,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,6.652491569519043,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.8235626220703125,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.7355105876922607,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.078256607055664,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.653112769126892,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,7.29044246673584,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,34.288291454315186,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.841941237449646,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.5664821863174438,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.4660053253173828,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.7432339787483215,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,4.61766242980957,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.755216121673584,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.4419575929641724,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.621051549911499,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,4.818225383758545,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.8397812843322752,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.4584922790527344,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.526434063911438,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,4.824707508087158,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.613186001777649,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.8661595582962036,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.2160567045211792,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.709893822669983,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,6.405296325683594,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.457203984260559,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.6369675397872925,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.6642988920211792,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.7712007761001587,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,6.5296711921691895,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.874545335769653,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.6667964458465576,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.070248603820801,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.6362478733062744,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,7.247838497161865,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,34.44340133666992,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.2646126747131348,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.674849271774292,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.2133184671401978,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.9607176780700684,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,5.113498210906982,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.446584463119507,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.828406572341919,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.8614972829818728,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,6.13648796081543,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.2841920852661133,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.922498106956482,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.058673620223999,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,6.265363693237305,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.0376980304718018,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.0757744312286377,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.3069329261779783,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.8037642240524292,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,7.224169731140137,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.740436553955078,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.8596888780593872,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.752065896987915,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.034259080886841,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,7.38645076751709,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.828168511390686,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.6678999662399292,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.964574933052063,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.7575267553329468,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,7.218170166015625,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,39.34414052963257,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.9706695675849916,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.5061837434768677,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.1841353178024292,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.6876311898231506,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,4.3486199378967285,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.8270620107650757,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.5087034702301023,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.6411259174346924,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,4.97689151763916,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.6897515058517456,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.7915211915969849,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.8375887870788576,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,5.318861484527588,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.6331695318222046,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.8929818868637085,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.084332823753357,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.685381293296814,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,6.295865058898926,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.1642379760742188,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.6264526844024658,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.562930941581726,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.7985609769821167,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,6.152182579040527,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.6829338073730469,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.6059348583221436,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.6785558462142944,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.702627182006836,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,6.670051574707031,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,33.76247215270996,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.8547423481941223,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.4660367965698242,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.4055423736572266,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.1613420248031616,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,4.8876633644104,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.9115747213363647,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.2623062133789062,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.056997060775757,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,5.230877876281738,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.9295995235443115,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.5307220220565796,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.7008620500564575,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,5.1611833572387695,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.695008397102356,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.9797452688217163,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.200664758682251,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.714969038963318,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,6.590387344360352,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.3930922746658323,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.7475991249084473,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.5015116930007937,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.7995672225952148,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,6.441770553588867,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.829978346824646,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.6907368898391724,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.7361395359039309,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.7010568380355835,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,6.957911491394043,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,35.26979398727417,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.9254435300827026,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.5055177211761477,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.3752574920654297,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.9089530110359192,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,4.715171813964844,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.762177348136902,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.3101428747177124,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.7067302465438845,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,4.779050350189209,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.8985929489135744,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.6975374221801758,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.944283127784729,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,5.5404133796691895,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.6496678590774536,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.9143846035003664,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.058409333229065,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.7778676748275757,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,6.40032958984375,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.5831871032714844,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.669208288192749,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.5462247133255005,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.779837727546692,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,6.578457832336426,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.807344913482666,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.6841999292373655,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.7827366590499878,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.6758533716201782,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,6.950134754180908,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,34.963557720184326,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2015,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.8368128538131714,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.3122735023498535,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.5093553066253662,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.9471094608306884,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,4.605551242828369,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2015,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.1637942790985107,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.5836074352264404,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.7500600814819336,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,5.497461795806885,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2015,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.8410769701004028,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.855069279670715,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.9808588027954104,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,5.677005290985107,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2015,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.6407898664474487,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.0386478900909424,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.0869914293289185,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.63250732421875,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,6.3989362716674805,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2015,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.5547815561294556,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.7233226299285889,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.7168540954589844,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.8370211124420168,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,6.831979274749756,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2015,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.013746738433838,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2015,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.7327048778533936,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2015,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.4027782678604126,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2015,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.6611180305480957,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2015,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,6.810348033905029,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2015,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,35.82128190994263,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.0910601615905762,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.6815980672836304,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.5221357345581057,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.042904496192932,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.337698459625244,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.8039751052856443,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.5758347511291504,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.6963711977005005,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.076180934906006,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.040111541748047,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.045026421546936,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.1762458086013794,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,4.261383533477783,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.245376467704773,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.6484603881835938,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.6987099647521973,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.646397829055786,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.2389445304870605,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.700334548950195,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.8483803272247312,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.6706535816192627,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.867864966392517,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,7.087233543395996,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.670218586921692,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.6189393997192385,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.8622163534164429,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.6531459093093872,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,6.804520130157471,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,33.80596113204956,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.2230267524719238,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.860975980758667,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.492925763130188,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.7624737620353699,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,5.339402198791504,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.122415065765381,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.665579080581665,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.486491560935974,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,5.274486064910889,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.6855618953704834,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.5266430377960205,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.1914823055267334,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,4.403687000274658,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.373964548110962,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.93964159488678,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.8865813612937927,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.6229482889175415,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,5.823135852813721,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.6176340579986572,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.780930757522583,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.4522011280059814,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.784501314163208,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,6.63526725769043,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.954637050628662,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.6339749097824097,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.2571693658828735,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.6356182098388672,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,6.4813995361328125,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,33.957377910614014,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.913960099220276,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.9262397289276123,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.3877652883529663,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.9795814156532288,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,5.207546234130859,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.295886516571045,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.5795388221740725,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.6239734888076782,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,5.499398708343506,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.2694220542907715,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.1229370832443235,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.0498099327087402,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,4.442169189453125,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.4495145082473757,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.7171038389205933,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.6720308065414429,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.6908118724822998,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,5.52946138381958,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.736375331878662,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.7939484119415283,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.6243094205856323,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.864325761795044,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,7.018959045410156,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.0193521976470947,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.647397518157959,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.319492220878601,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.6400800943374634,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,6.626322269439697,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,34.323856830596924,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.1241601705551147,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.9022563695907593,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.5290192365646362,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.7960538864135742,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.351490020751953,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.154538631439209,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.5196349620819092,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.7721736431121826,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.446347236633301,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.148721933364868,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.5493546724319458,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.353779673576355,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.05185604095459,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.4506720304489136,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.861552357673645,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.8570989966392517,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.7276719808578491,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.896995544433594,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.9108991622924805,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.8122715950012207,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.5740525722503662,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.889675259590149,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,7.186898231506348,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.9919017553329468,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.5930920839309692,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.4242805242538452,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.6691224575042725,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,6.678396701812744,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,35.61198377609253,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.0605382919311523,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.7877044677734375,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.6076552867889404,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.1288148164749146,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,5.584712982177734,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.274367570877075,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.644238829612732,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.7091035842895508,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,5.627709865570068,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.0303006172180176,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.6619675159454346,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.3247092962265017,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,5.016977310180664,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.399438977241516,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.778283953666687,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.8554690480232239,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.6568729877471924,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,5.690064907073975,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.879928469657898,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.833880066871643,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.6790428161621094,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.984565496444702,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,7.377416610717773,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.074906826019287,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.8791195154190063,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.6578437089920044,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.6471863985061646,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,7.259056091308594,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,36.55593776702881,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.195569634437561,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.9342063665390017,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.613942265510559,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.9890958070755004,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.732814311981201,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.292301654815674,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.8685697317123413,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.7331173419952393,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.893988609313965,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.066012144088745,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.5527044534683228,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.2761576175689695,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,4.894874095916748,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.2962323427200315,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.688260793685913,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.7287406325340271,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.6224507093429563,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.335684299468994,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.704732894897461,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.7359070777893066,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.459644079208374,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.9310264587402344,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,6.831310272216797,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.888489842414856,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.8751479387283323,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.5816630125045776,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.6887391805648804,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,7.0340399742126465,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,35.72271156311035,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.2013864517211914,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.0935566425323486,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.5583287477493286,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.6957181096076965,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,5.548989772796631,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.5553016662597656,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.830936074256897,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.663235425949097,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,6.049473285675049,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.116706132888794,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.1595746278762815,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.479056477546692,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,4.755337238311768,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.634885311126709,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.0441572666168213,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.8320633172988892,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.6653004884719849,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,6.176406383514404,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.6596825122833252,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.9200010299682615,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.760610818862915,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.7857272624969482,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,7.126021385192871,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.9941452741622925,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.6017340421676636,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.5649820566177368,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.6252068281173706,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,6.786068439483643,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,36.442296504974365,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.9225051999092102,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.9634361267089844,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.4580166339874268,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.7471101880073547,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,5.091068267822266,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.176245927810669,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.6829813718795776,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.5099033117294312,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,5.369130611419678,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.932008981704712,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.3003512620925903,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.0978307723999023,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,4.330191135406494,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.490164875984192,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.6256976127624512,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.9073716402053832,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.372411608695984,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,5.395645618438721,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.7429511547088623,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.9247839450836184,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.699899196624756,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.860668063163757,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,7.228302478790283,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.833353042602539,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.5750463008880615,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.4007289409637451,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.6526923179626465,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,6.461820602416992,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,33.876158714294434,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.026188611984253,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.814425706863403,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.6172784566879272,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.0250377655029297,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,5.482930660247803,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.9737961292266848,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.7743302583694458,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.7297430038452148,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,5.477869510650635,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.062518835067749,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.0540220737457275,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.4113945960998535,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,4.52793550491333,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.6604034900665283,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.7917245626449585,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.0401240587234497,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.6359792947769165,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,6.128231525421143,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.8309106826782229,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.8356853723526,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.553279995918274,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.8848087787628176,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,7.104684829711914,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.931308627128601,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.698744535446167,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.5003330707550049,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.6966280937194824,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,6.827014446258545,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,35.54866647720337,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.048785924911499,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.9182007312774656,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.4694947004318235,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.0611969232559204,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,5.497678279876709,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.042912006378174,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.6359599828720093,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.4804902076721191,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,5.159362316131592,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.3081114292144775,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.2432953119277954,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.3218039274215698,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,4.873210430145264,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.32169508934021,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.7032122611999512,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.7245849370956421,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.4150569438934326,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,5.164548873901367,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.779072403907776,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.9271084070205688,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.6722184419631958,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.9224690198898315,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,7.300868034362793,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.8866511583328247,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.6717660427093506,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.5409103631973269,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.5807040929794312,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,6.680031776428223,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,34.67569971084595,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.1604015827178955,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.0209619998931885,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.6830859184265137,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.837150514125824,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.701600074768066,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.564361810684204,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.6987736225128174,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.6924386024475098,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.955574035644531,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.075460910797119,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.4770723581314087,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.521650314331055,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.074183464050293,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.4758409261703491,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.6731141805648804,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.7556308507919312,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.6213499307632446,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.525936126708984,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.8135085105895996,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.8976943492889404,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.425204157829285,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.9319924116134644,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,7.068399429321289,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.9424159526824951,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.6430026292800903,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.722531795501709,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.6286410093307495,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,6.936591148376465,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,36.26228427886963,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.273445725440979,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.939663648605347,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.867960810661316,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.0976548194885254,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,6.178724765777588,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.3891115188598633,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.9389841556549072,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.901542067527771,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,6.229637622833252,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.170449495315552,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.8269057273864744,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.176379919052124,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.17373514175415,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.4029632806777954,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.6973804235458374,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.6883571147918701,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.650833010673523,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.439533710479736,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.817469835281372,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.6497864723205566,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.6151381731033323,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.9006047248840332,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,6.982999324798584,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.787910223007202,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.7844527959823608,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.7051701545715332,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.7048838138580322,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,6.982417106628418,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,36.98704767227173,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.131864309310913,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.7234257459640503,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.526305079460144,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.7046743631362915,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,5.086269378662109,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.051665782928467,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.5825910568237305,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.53384530544281,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,5.168102264404297,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.930248141288757,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.702051281929016,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.0914314985275269,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,4.72373104095459,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.6144846677780151,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.7681550979614258,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.8544994592666626,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.6240417957305908,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,5.861180782318115,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.836369514465332,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.5548022985458374,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.5319910049438477,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.838908553123474,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,6.76207160949707,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.971376895904541,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.677949070930481,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.7805931568145752,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.5699594020843506,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,6.999878406524658,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,34.60123348236084,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.9108173847198486,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.842460870742798,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.512906789779663,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.5928609371185303,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,4.85904598236084,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.752017617225647,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.6347464323043823,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.5579959154129028,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,4.944759845733643,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.190861701965332,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.7126702070236206,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.0213799476623535,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,4.924911975860596,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.041365146636963,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.6138817071914673,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.6738072633743286,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.5589442253112793,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,4.887998104095459,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.6640177965164185,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.9331045150756836,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.585637092590332,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.755718231201172,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,6.938477516174316,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.8186122179031372,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.5194945335388184,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.4264799356460571,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.6588366031646729,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,6.4234232902526855,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,32.97861671447754,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.4982725381851196,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.9984350204467771,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.6649198532104492,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.2378911972045898,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,6.3995184898376465,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.5992672443389893,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.9035900831222536,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.8396203517913816,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,6.342477798461914,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.7260198593139648,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.295679211616516,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.2653992176055908,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,4.287097930908203,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.8810585737228391,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.0754661560058594,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.1906992197036743,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.309936285018921,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,6.457160472869873,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.7316728830337524,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.8756208419799805,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.6903687715530396,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.9824179410934448,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,7.280080318450928,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.9442790746688845,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.649981141090393,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.7682920694351196,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.6459449529647827,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,7.00849723815918,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,37.774832248687744,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.1416316032409668,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.8821566104888916,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.6199198961257937,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.9675315022468568,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,5.611239433288574,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.6884233951568604,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.9104512929916384,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.8788689374923704,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,6.477743625640869,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.113187551498413,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.0313096046447754,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.446984052658081,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,5.5914812088012695,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.7808390855789185,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.9890971183776855,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.1630319356918335,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.7404922246932983,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,6.673460483551025,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.856317400932312,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.9575309753417969,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.6579461097717283,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.891308069229126,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,7.363102436065674,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.9951659440994265,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.6028199195861816,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.5757415294647217,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.6423320770263672,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,6.816059589385986,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,38.5330867767334,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.0073482990264893,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.798051118850708,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.634047269821167,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.2014132738113403,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,5.640860080718994,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.2936387062072754,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.6547446250915527,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.6845238208770752,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,5.632906913757324,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.038604736328125,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.0203423500061035,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.1132291555404663,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,4.172176361083984,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.4791040420532229,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.7434219121932983,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.9367468953132628,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.665759801864624,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,5.825032711029053,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.8224037885665896,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.8401730060577393,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.5631951093673706,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.929957151412964,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,7.155728816986084,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.799233317375183,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.7987759113311768,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.7430059909820557,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.64857280254364,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,6.989587783813477,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,35.416292667388916,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.3699307441711426,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.133822202682495,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.810237169265747,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.4065828323364258,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,6.7205729484558105,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.7655465602874756,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.8587961196899416,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.8635241985321045,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,6.4878668785095215,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.9073909521102903,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.1626659631729126,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.5624176263809204,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,4.632474422454834,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.5191024541854858,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.6369632482528689,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.801102340221405,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.7629449367523191,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.7201128005981445,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.8313994407653809,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.791653394699097,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.4766263961791992,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.9417351484298704,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,7.041414260864258,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.1099116802215576,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.7115730047225952,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.942582964897156,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.6620763540267944,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,7.426144123077393,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,38.02858543395996,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.3029406070709229,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.9022119045257568,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.415269136428833,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.323603630065918,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,5.944025039672852,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.340909481048584,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.9429988861083984,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.8581688404083252,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,6.1420769691467285,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.1600520610809326,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.8715393543243408,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.649351954460144,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,5.680943489074707,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.656562566757202,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.8146371841430664,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.9641379714012146,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.7477328777313232,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,6.183070659637451,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.7213847637176514,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.704488754272461,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.6055737733840942,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.9320991039276123,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,6.963546276092529,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.975555419921875,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.719385266304016,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.809712052345276,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.6104336977005005,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,7.115086555480957,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,38.028748989105225,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.9441735744476318,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.8286501169204712,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.469362735748291,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.6854920387268066,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,4.92767858505249,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.9769294261932373,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.6075990200042725,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.8257155418395996,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,5.410243988037109,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.1781580448150635,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.082021713256836,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.0364141464233398,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,5.29659366607666,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.8797707557678223,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.4320005178451538,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.7576048970222473,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.7262643575668335,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,4.795640468597412,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.7616151571273804,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.9760167598724363,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.773702621459961,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.7918469905853271,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,7.303181648254395,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.6932812929153442,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.95751953125,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.430765390396118,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.73250150680542,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,7.814067840576172,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,35.54740619659424,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.0650690793991089,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.9586131572723389,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.7196167707443235,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.2727105617523191,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,6.01600980758667,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.389096736907959,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.7494122982025146,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.7782422304153442,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.916751384735107,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.2930989265441895,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.493956446647644,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.4879558086395264,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.2750115394592285,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.445899248123169,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.727805495262146,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.9004768133163452,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.6525132656097412,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.726694583892822,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.863006830215454,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.6893960237503052,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.6453717947006226,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.9483747482299805,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,7.146149158477783,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.909099817276001,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.8746939897537231,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.9716973304748535,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.6204742193222046,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,7.375965118408203,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,37.456581592559814,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.1643269062042236,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.067981481552124,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.8227388858795168,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.18651020526886,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,6.241557598114014,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.595027208328247,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.0104494094848633,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.6849764585494995,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,6.29045295715332,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.9321688413619995,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.1026228666305542,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.3919048309326172,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,4.42669677734375,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.6659648418426514,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.9979369640350344,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.9439915418624878,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.751087665557861,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,6.358981132507324,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.827768087387085,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.6910626888275146,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.6427627801895142,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.855655550956726,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,7.01724910736084,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.0268476009368896,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.9944193363189695,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.669186234474182,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.7007451057434082,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,7.39119815826416,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,37.72613573074341,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.131677746772766,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.80393648147583,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.6039785146713257,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.9859448671340942,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,5.525537490844727,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.12496566772461,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.6803416013717651,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.6807299852371216,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,5.486037254333496,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.2986292839050293,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.9145587682724,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.45954430103302,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,5.672732353210449,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.5553348064422607,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.880866527557373,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.917129933834076,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.7693729400634766,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,6.122704029083252,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.754500150680542,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.8288408517837524,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.7444777488708496,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.9323464632034304,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,7.260165214538574,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.8283168077468872,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.686616063117981,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.8158928155899048,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.6134450435638428,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,6.944270610809326,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,37.011446952819824,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.358840823173523,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.8612494468688965,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.4148759841918943,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.2199786901474,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,5.854945182800293,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.4231677055358887,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.0430917739868164,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.8668408393859863,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,6.333100318908691,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.296372175216675,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.0582733154296875,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.5489541292190552,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,5.903599262237549,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.4370285272598269,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.673671007156372,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.847759485244751,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.717814803123474,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,5.676273822784424,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.8868156671524048,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.765106439590454,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.5242788791656494,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.9201796054840088,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,7.096380710601807,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.891226291656494,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.6493761539459229,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.6677595376968384,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.6914112567901611,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,6.899773597717285,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,37.76407289505005,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.1462914943695068,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.9615567922592163,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.6286823749542236,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.0977872610092163,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,5.834318161010742,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.528438091278076,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.8241446018218992,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.9894018173217771,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,6.341984272003174,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.350170612335205,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.2162213325500488,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.31069815158844,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,4.877089977264404,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.5896180868148804,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.8076547384262085,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.906737744808197,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.7580283880233765,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,6.062038898468018,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.7974940538406372,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.6911183595657349,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.586265206336975,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.9236286878585815,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,6.99850606918335,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.0720958709716797,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.6723790168762207,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.907968521118164,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.644939661026001,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,7.297382831573486,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,37.411320209503174,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.0693378448486328,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.9361988306045532,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.6522115468978882,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.8148490786552429,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,5.472597599029541,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.5599453449249268,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.649383306503296,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.8058549165725708,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,6.015183448791504,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.052189588546753,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.0600917339324951,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.245256781578064,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,4.357538223266602,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.658531665802002,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.8635646104812624,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.8711498975753784,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.659545660018921,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,6.052792072296143,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.722245216369629,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.91555655002594,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.675376534461975,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.8865684270858765,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,7.199746608734131,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.0105605125427246,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.6303895711898804,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.8623521327972412,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.6761802434921265,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,7.179482460021973,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,36.27734041213989,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.1895277500152588,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.966709017753601,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.6088613271713257,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.1185134649276731,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.88361120223999,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.9714113473892212,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.7051329612731934,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.6670106649398804,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.343554973602295,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.186835765838623,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.4400495290756226,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.3541951179504397,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,4.981080532073975,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.3593589067459106,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.749860167503357,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.7293070554733276,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.6601507663726809,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.498676776885986,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.9245386123657229,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.8221831321716309,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.5582422018051147,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.946467041969299,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,7.251430988311768,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.838587999343872,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.6224737167358398,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.5510568618774414,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.6002771854400637,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,6.612395763397217,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,35.57075023651123,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.4762954711914062,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.134479284286499,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.7796435356140137,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.4188681840896606,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,6.809286594390869,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.426792621612549,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.8945550918579104,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.817489743232727,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,6.1388373374938965,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.1410722732543945,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.1312955617904663,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.6333389282226562,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,4.905706882476807,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.9695574045181272,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.020043134689331,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.01002836227417,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.725018858909607,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,6.7246479988098145,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.9915673732757568,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.827402114868164,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.7115483283996582,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.9841948747634888,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,7.514712333679199,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.1686456203460693,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.7230223417282104,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.66717791557312,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.664418339729309,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,7.223264217376709,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,39.316455364227295,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.3790996074676514,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.9809279441833496,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.6946138143539429,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.1068332195281982,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,6.161474704742432,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.5773122310638428,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.8366628885269165,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.8584705591201784,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,6.2724456787109375,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.0281336307525635,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.3578063249588013,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.518538475036621,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,4.904478549957275,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.7205500602722168,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.9725103378295896,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.8152686953544617,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.7752342224121094,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,6.283563137054443,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.056511640548706,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.8442856073379517,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.6793434619903564,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.089433431625366,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,7.669573783874512,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.1270008087158203,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.6366750001907349,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.6659015417099,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.6851569414138794,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,7.114734172821045,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,38.406270027160645,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.276674509048462,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.0633654594421387,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.6317671537399292,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.9939408302307128,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,5.965747833251953,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.3309390544891357,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.84788179397583,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.900460124015808,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,6.079280853271484,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.3025503158569336,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.7868664264678955,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.392333984375,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,5.481750965118408,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.8190373182296753,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.028656005859375,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.9594829082489014,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.752463698387146,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,6.559639930725098,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.8230136632919312,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.6811312437057495,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.6790944337844849,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.9253164529800415,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,7.108555793762207,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.0109217166900635,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.2729151248931885,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.876498818397522,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.709552526473999,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,6.8698883056640625,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,38.06486368179321,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.1329034566879272,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.7729483842849731,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.4235903024673462,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.773117184638977,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.1025590896606445,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.160886526107788,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.5353020429611206,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.443521499633789,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.139710426330566,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.0831029415130615,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.072812557220459,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.0889956951141355,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.244911193847656,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.3108086585998535,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.7764347791671753,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.7646567225456238,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.76213538646698,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.614035606384277,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.7620351314544678,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.6327334642410278,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.4372642040252686,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.9192925691604616,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,6.751325607299805,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.9857933521270752,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.5585302114486694,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.225907325744629,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.7153573036193848,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,7.485588073730469,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,35.33812999725342,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.0144479274749756,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.9458258152008057,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.5848909616470337,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.7297235727310181,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,5.274888515472412,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.212559223175049,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.7386984825134275,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.0726158618927,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,6.023873329162598,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.5615475177764893,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.0410842895507812,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.2140018939971924,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,5.816633701324463,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.5111818313598633,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.7978311777114868,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.8695195913314819,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.921884059906006,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,6.100416660308838,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.023685932159424,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.882752776145935,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.5591018199920654,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.871006965637207,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,7.336547374725342,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.030912160873413,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.0217840671539307,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.3453197479248047,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.6296746730804443,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,8.027690887451172,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,38.580050468444824,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.316959023475647,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.9652541875839231,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.6585768461227417,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.9706812500953674,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,5.911471366882324,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.8166618347167969,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.8913819789886477,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.7283917665481567,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,5.436435699462891,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.2911288738250732,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.5500911474227903,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.277316927909851,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,5.118536949157715,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.5575547218322754,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.8502395153045657,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.8673678040504456,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.6411166191101074,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,5.916278839111328,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.656672477722168,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.8019819259643557,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.4771844148635864,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.880997896194458,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,6.816836357116699,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.034231185913086,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.6490598917007446,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.5016542673110962,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.6074925661087036,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,6.79243803024292,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,35.99199724197388,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.0162789821624756,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.938527226448059,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.5273832082748413,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.8538464307785034,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,5.33603572845459,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.4380407333374023,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.6270867586135864,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.821587324142456,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,5.886714935302734,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.4983222484588623,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.1970903873443604,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.271570086479187,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,5.966982841491699,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.6393178701400757,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.8949134349823,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.9904761910438538,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.2182574272155762,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,5.742964744567871,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.88616406917572,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.9043910503387451,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.6889210939407349,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.956017017364502,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,7.435492992401123,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.029432535171509,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.2187817096710205,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.4959661960601809,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.677983283996582,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,6.422163963317871,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,36.79035520553589,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.0620931386947632,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.9356491565704343,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.4930049180984497,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.1099157333374023,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,5.600662708282471,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.3844923973083496,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.8221534490585327,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.8993080854415896,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,6.105953693389893,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.392390489578247,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.168333649635315,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.3689266443252563,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,4.929650783538818,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.829527497291565,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.9582945108413696,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.0928633213043213,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.7616521120071411,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,6.642337322235107,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.7634929418563845,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.8316165208816528,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.5347940921783447,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.883265495300293,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,7.013169288635254,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.9466707706451416,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.6813569068908691,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.858705997467041,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.743494987487793,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,7.230228424072266,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,37.52200222015381,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.921679139137268,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.63193941116333,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.3936598300933838,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.7098268866539001,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,4.657105445861816,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.2409636974334717,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.6315590143203735,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.7329113483428955,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,5.605433940887451,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.0931849479675293,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.3113363981246948,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.234017252922058,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,4.638538837432861,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.5482693910598757,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.825689673423767,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.0346884727478027,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.6983779668807983,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,6.107025623321533,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.627253770828247,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.852549433708191,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.742030382156372,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.8170603513717651,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,7.038894176483154,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.9182573556900024,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.5021944046020508,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.6446374654769895,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.627153396606445,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,6.692242622375488,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,34.739240646362305,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.9168220162391664,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.7713916301727295,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.46222186088562,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.681835949420929,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,4.832271575927734,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.6698957681655884,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.5331392288208008,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.737172245979309,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,4.940207004547119,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.2468886375427246,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.9532056450843812,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.2355060577392578,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,4.435600280761719,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.471717119216919,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.7668297290802002,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.0834743976593018,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.6726375818252563,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,5.994658946990967,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.586709976196289,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.9292789697647097,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.619570016860962,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.81773841381073,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,6.9532976150512695,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.8436075448989868,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.8112910985946655,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.9421557188034055,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.4926190376281738,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,7.0896735191345215,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,34.24570894241333,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.0392628908157349,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.9632190465927124,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.5049331188201904,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.9695373773574828,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,5.476952075958252,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.133427619934082,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.8956328630447388,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.7831424474716189,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,5.8122029304504395,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.2760560512542725,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.1402652263641355,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.2780027389526367,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,4.694324016571045,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.7415534257888794,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.9195705652236936,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.102575421333313,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.7340587377548218,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,6.497757911682129,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.8092069625854492,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.8129161596298216,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.7719415426254272,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.9223628044128416,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,7.316427230834961,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.06990647315979,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.6674290895462036,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.9957263469696045,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.691328048706055,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,7.424389839172363,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,37.22205400466919,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.9985097050666808,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.7412232160568235,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.4370633363723757,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.8440167903900146,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,5.02081298828125,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.878222942352295,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.6496127843856812,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.5742934942245483,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,5.102128982543945,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.0832839012145996,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.8661566972732544,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.2510781288146973,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,5.200518608093262,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.395639181137085,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.6961524486541748,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.9338910579681396,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.384594202041626,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,5.410276889801025,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.7184704542160034,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.832151770591736,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.7082053422927856,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.8128342628479004,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,7.071661949157715,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.8132874965667725,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.6445913314819336,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.896675705909729,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.6210122108459473,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,6.975566864013672,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,34.78096628189087,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.9718377590179444,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8623900413513184,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.532221794128418,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.8239322304725647,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,5.19038200378418,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.820295572280884,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.7168747186660769,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.6167501211166382,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,5.1539201736450195,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.2643933296203613,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.9848912954330444,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.1651864051818848,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,5.41447114944458,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.2227174043655396,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.685599446296692,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.7617490291595459,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.6963576078414917,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,5.366423606872559,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.6127008199691772,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.76553475856781,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.595644474029541,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.825175166130066,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,6.799055099487305,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.9882785081863403,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.6531113386154177,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.7352683544158936,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.502269268035889,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,6.878927707672119,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,34.80317974090576,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.2254393100738523,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.8446348905563352,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.5500386953353882,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.8450824022293091,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,5.465195178985596,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.0837204456329346,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.3934749364852903,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.615315556526184,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,5.092511177062988,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.0028247833251953,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.779330134391785,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.0715252161026,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,4.85368013381958,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.249286651611328,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.8063039779663088,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.7648136615753174,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.619340181350708,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,5.439744472503662,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.791684865951538,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.7505649328231812,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.651265263557434,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.765317678451538,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,6.958832740783691,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.7050819396972656,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.637399673461914,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.6731635332107544,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.635417342185974,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,6.651062488555908,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,34.461026191711426,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.0534919500350952,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.099529266357422,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.6126258373260498,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.0242464542388916,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,5.789893627166748,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.1153876781463623,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.717463493347168,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.6570104360580444,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,5.489861488342285,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.3038251399993896,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.3616050481796265,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.1674407720565796,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,4.832870960235596,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.45844829082489,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.700255274772644,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.7800139784812927,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.658870816230774,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,5.597588539123535,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.8013414144515991,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.7832365036010742,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.6805830001831057,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.9019001722335815,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,7.1670613288879395,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.9157918691635132,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.5920467376708984,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.6877673864364624,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.58017897605896,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,6.775784969329834,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,35.65306091308594,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.0454190969467163,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.8684375286102295,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.688077688217163,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.8273752331733704,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,5.429309368133545,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.121288537979126,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.848094820976257,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.6413124799728394,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,5.610695838928223,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.2701711654663086,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.7083126306533811,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.2269206047058103,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,5.205404281616211,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.57621169090271,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.7727497816085815,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.9040172696113586,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.6824853420257568,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,5.935463905334473,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.5950849056243896,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.905463695526123,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.4897688627243042,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.7860844135284424,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,6.776401519775391,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.9326263666152952,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.593786120414734,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.826688289642334,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.575222373008728,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,6.928323268890381,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,35.88559818267822,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.0927228927612305,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.0399043560028076,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.4833598136901855,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.777444064617157,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,5.393431186676025,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.8992855548858645,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.691815733909607,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.7320491075515747,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,5.323150157928467,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.237507581710815,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.6747814416885376,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.2532646656036377,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,5.165553569793701,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.2812789678573608,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.65788996219635,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.9154131412506104,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.6410454511642456,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,5.495627403259277,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.7099101543426514,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.843595027923584,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.4730992317199707,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.7744427919387815,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,6.801047325134277,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.87422776222229,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.6541433334350586,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.8291494846343992,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.6630772352218628,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,7.0205979347229,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,35.19940757751465,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.1808171272277832,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.7903971672058103,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.518634557723999,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.851037323474884,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,5.340886116027832,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.395920991897583,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.1113767623901367,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.4337743520736694,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,5.9410719871521,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.209372043609619,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.1901603937149048,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.415564775466919,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,4.815097332000732,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.2877074480056765,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.639211893081665,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.7747389674186707,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.7897272109985352,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,5.491385459899902,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.7008062601089478,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.7857604026794434,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.6897974014282229,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.8695979118347168,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,7.045961856842041,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.7555513381958008,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.6672321557998655,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.8602592945098877,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.6125136613845823,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,6.895556449890137,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,35.529959201812744,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.0111922025680542,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.9178606271743777,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.4457658529281616,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.8715347647666931,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,5.246353626251221,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.0813376903533936,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.7133128643035889,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.8160306215286257,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,5.610681533813477,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.3476767539978027,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.6446428298950195,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.3424152135849,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,5.334734916687012,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.6301286220550537,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.9358668327331543,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.2708815336227417,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.6699233055114746,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,6.506800651550293,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.6877859830856323,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.6717134714126587,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.773971438407898,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.867108702659607,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,7.000579833984375,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.9059371948242188,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.685790777206421,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.880144476890564,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.6913803815841677,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,7.163252830505371,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,36.86240339279175,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.8144721388816833,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.5995250940322876,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.2661123275756836,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.790411651134491,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,4.470521450042725,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.1303272247314453,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.5678250789642334,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.5800049304962158,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,5.2781572341918945,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.180373430252075,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.2102924585342407,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.0564229488372805,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,4.447088718414307,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.7040421366691589,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.3249099254608154,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.6339024901390076,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.6494605541229248,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,4.312314987182617,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.6357831954956057,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.8192672729492188,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.654361605644226,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.844355583190918,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,6.953767776489258,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.6403884887695312,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.723455786705017,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.060985803604126,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.7056033611297607,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,7.130433082580566,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,32.59228324890137,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.9751121997833252,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.923859477043152,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.427038550376892,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.7020027041435242,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,5.028012752532959,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.204337358474731,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.6759554147720337,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.766759157180786,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,5.64705228805542,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.028165340423584,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.9745095372200012,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.2400553226470947,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,4.242730140686035,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.409563064575195,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.8435577154159544,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.9091373682022096,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.7479907274246216,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,5.910248756408691,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.8469938039779663,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.8532001972198489,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.5611293315887451,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.922621250152588,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,7.1839447021484375,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.908400535583496,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.597665548324585,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.7289494276046753,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.6148840188980105,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,6.849899768829346,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,34.86188840866089,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.9637757539749146,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.8596657514572144,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.4079875946044922,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.6486344933509827,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,4.880063533782959,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.0587849617004395,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.684458613395691,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.7618974447250366,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,5.505140781402588,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.322204351425171,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.1046302318573,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.22627854347229,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,5.65311336517334,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.2432481050491333,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.589600920677185,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.8741766810417175,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.760248064994812,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,5.467273712158203,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.6611690521240234,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.8413515090942385,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.660994052886963,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.8119934797286987,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,6.975508213043213,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.835510730743408,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.0464060306549072,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.2324609756469727,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.7024900913238523,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,7.816867828369141,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,36.29796743392944,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.9236669540405272,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.7944825887680054,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.2295995950698853,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.7521623969078064,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,4.699911594390869,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.172309637069702,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.9412100315093992,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.638741374015808,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,5.752261161804199,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.1025500297546387,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.815117359161377,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.9991157054901124,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,4.916783332824707,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.9136009216308594,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.5854185819625854,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.7330884337425232,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.799378752708435,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,5.031486511230469,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.7487727403640747,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.805397868156433,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.628894329071045,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.8128353357315063,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,6.9959001541137695,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.6578102111816406,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.9227776527404783,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.3407747745513916,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.5886049270629885,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,7.509967803955078,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,34.90631055831909,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.019521951675415,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.9759708642959597,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.5599889755249023,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.030198335647583,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,5.58568000793457,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.378063440322876,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.7727900743484497,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.695852518081665,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,5.846705913543701,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.2592294216156006,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.0140398740768433,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.2571840286254885,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,4.530453205108643,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.7351304292678833,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.9628955125808716,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.1318902969360352,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.729219675064087,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,6.559135913848877,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.765132188796997,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.897646427154541,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.6703734397888184,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.8998985290527344,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,7.23305082321167,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.818035364151001,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.666881442070007,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.7754122018814087,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.6908090114593506,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,6.951138019561768,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,36.70616388320923,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.9449958205223083,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.896032214164734,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.300406575202942,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.9216572642326356,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,5.06309175491333,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.332763433456421,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.6688889265060425,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.7992310523986816,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,5.8008832931518555,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.4282872676849365,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.3741384744644165,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.135974407196045,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,4.938399791717529,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.7842942476272583,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.0276432037353516,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.4516913890838623,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.729038119316101,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,6.992666721343994,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.824217677116394,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.772978663444519,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.6612331867218018,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.9927870035171509,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,7.251216411590576,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.900633692741394,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.698216676712036,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.2548171281814575,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.661693453788757,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,6.5153608322143555,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,36.56161880493164,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.9231302738189696,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.942360520362854,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.415514588356018,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.8587971925735474,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,5.1398024559021,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.1114583015441895,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.812426209449768,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.851405382156372,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,5.775290012359619,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.47023606300354,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.9510886669158936,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.2621690034866333,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,5.6834940910339355,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.886080622673035,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.047363042831421,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.2536215782165527,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.7902826070785522,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,6.9773478507995605,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.9932193756103516,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.7801166772842407,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.7305550575256348,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.9528067111968992,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,7.456697463989258,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.9200890064239504,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.9212074279785156,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.8832199573516848,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.6088076829910278,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,7.333323955535889,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,38.36595582962036,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.7888911962509155,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.6517387628555298,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.216131567955017,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.7723067402839661,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,4.429068088531494,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.7654815912246704,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.5451722145080566,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.508678913116455,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,4.819333076477051,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.194024085998535,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.095583438873291,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.123679518699646,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,4.413287162780762,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.4883029460906982,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.8742202520370483,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.1744049787521362,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.624263048171997,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,6.161190986633301,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.5581084489822388,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.813546657562256,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.7291752099990845,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.8586704730987549,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,6.959500789642334,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.906262755393982,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.6751182079315186,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.5467767715454102,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.713988184928894,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,6.842145919799805,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,33.624526023864746,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.9322637915611268,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.8679121732711792,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.477340579032898,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.8471155166625977,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,5.124631881713867,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.079601526260376,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.6526238918304443,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.796438694000244,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,5.5286641120910645,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.2739970684051514,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.1189862489700315,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.127645492553711,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,4.520628929138184,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.616159200668335,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.9363187551498413,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.0170037746429443,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.7964421510696411,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,6.365923881530762,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.76094651222229,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.9028708934783936,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.8431603908538816,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.920666217803955,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,7.4276442527771,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.8424443006515503,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.6406456232070925,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.0110881328582764,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.6151082515716553,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,7.109286308288574,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,36.07677936553955,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.1030946969985962,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.642626166343689,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.4383299350738523,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.0989474058151243,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,5.282998561859131,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.205831527709961,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.6075032949447632,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.788119196891785,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,5.601454257965088,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.4242959022521973,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.87133264541626,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.1718807220458984,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,5.4675092697143555,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.7681986093521118,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.0906777381896973,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.2720906734466553,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.6392216682434082,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,6.770188331604004,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.8755091428756712,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.958458423614502,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.8943458795547483,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.9351011514663696,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,7.66341495513916,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.0355300903320312,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.5895404815673828,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.8510531187057495,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.6144311428070068,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,7.090554714202881,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,37.87612009048462,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.8740135431289673,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.5517698526382446,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.1453419923782349,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.9095529317855836,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,4.480678081512451,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.292091608047486,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.4498811960220337,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.859399437904358,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,5.601372241973877,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.1386044025421143,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.788679599761963,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.1121127605438232,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,5.0393967628479,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.4713482856750488,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.8526540994644165,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.034730315208435,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.4054850339889526,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,5.764217853546143,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.771098017692566,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.8753920793533323,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.6545263528823853,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.906766653060913,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,7.207783222198486,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.914387583732605,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.8041170835494995,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.1483254432678223,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.6736023426055908,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,7.540432453155518,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,35.633880615234375,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.8564214110374451,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.698047161102295,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.3305766582489014,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.6889948844909668,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,4.574040412902832,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.9342340230941772,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.4597434997558594,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.6634466648101809,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,5.057424068450928,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.9558336734771729,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.1250993013381958,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.0528507232666016,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,4.13378381729126,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.403416872024536,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.8292652368545532,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.9995020031929016,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.423806071281433,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,5.655990123748779,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.6700448989868164,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.6982243061065674,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.580167531967163,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.7708768844604492,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,6.719313621520996,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.6826171875,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.6872400045394895,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.989325761795044,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.6968860626220703,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,7.0560688972473145,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,33.19662094116211,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.245832443237305,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.0386455059051514,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.4443097114562988,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.064491868019104,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,5.793279647827148,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.268336772918701,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.8323882818222048,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.8399791717529297,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,5.940703868865967,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.5936269760131836,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.6868034601211548,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.410750389099121,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,5.69118070602417,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.8479890823364256,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.0656373500823975,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.3093057870864868,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.9131304025650024,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,7.1360626220703125,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.8609572649002075,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.8789273500442505,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.7584962844848633,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.908332586288452,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,7.406713485717773,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.132922649383545,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.6798454523086548,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.999734878540039,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.791682481765747,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,7.604185581207275,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,39.57212591171265,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.0497764348983765,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.738646149635315,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.4185651540756226,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.9777133464813232,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,5.184700965881348,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.705066800117493,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.530514359474182,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.7232568264007568,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,4.958837985992432,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.364842653274536,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.9700611233711244,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.2346398830413818,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,4.569543361663818,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.7269543409347534,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.9136011600494385,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.0756651163101196,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.6831779479980469,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,6.399398326873779,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.840230941772461,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.70139479637146,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.5292378664016724,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.8917500972747805,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,6.962613582611084,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.9566855430603027,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.283380150794983,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.6386995315551758,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.6764378547668457,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,6.555202960968018,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,34.63029718399048,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.9221324920654296,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.7397550344467163,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.5619131326675415,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.8209244012832642,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,5.044724941253662,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.6153624057769775,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.5103334188461304,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.6958987712860107,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,4.821594715118408,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.4109292030334473,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.5496058464050293,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.2530887126922607,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,5.213624000549316,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.2896374464035034,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.8591744899749756,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.990488827228546,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.6151405572891235,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,5.754441261291504,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.7331328392028809,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.9351153373718264,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.832647442817688,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.933609962463379,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,7.434505939483643,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.112875699996948,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.7484170198440552,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.697429656982422,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.6518456935882568,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,7.210567951202393,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,35.479458808898926,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.8484998345375061,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.6276288032531738,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.615206241607666,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.7136427760124207,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,4.804977893829346,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.7566906213760376,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.4140198230743408,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.6406370401382446,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,4.811347484588623,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.120856761932373,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.3654102087020874,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.0779119729995728,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,4.564178943634033,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.1712247133255005,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.7931504249572754,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.7982490062713623,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.6208020448684692,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,5.383426189422607,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.711039662361145,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.7119966745376587,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.564555525779724,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.828301191329956,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,6.815893173217773,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.947636127471924,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.6704826354980469,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.706341028213501,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.634722113609314,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,6.959181785583496,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,33.33900547027588,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2016,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.8935070037841797,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.610992670059204,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.3594831228256226,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.7415347099304199,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,4.605517387390137,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2016,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.7640297412872314,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.3276715278625488,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.7205429077148438,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,4.812243938446045,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2016,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.216677665710449,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.7854208946228027,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.107633352279663,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,5.109731674194336,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2016,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.4192838668823242,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.923013687133789,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.061442732810974,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.7142988443374634,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,6.118039131164551,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2016,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.7950828075408936,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.6773966550827026,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.5739216804504397,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.9641695022583008,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,7.010570526123047,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2016,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.9147424697875977,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2016,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.6615839004516602,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2016,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.329714059829712,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2016,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.6605660915374756,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2016,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,6.566606521606445,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2016,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,34.22270917892456,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.0389890670776367,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.6836295127868652,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.5790913105010986,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.9492427110671996,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.25095272064209,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.88295578956604,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.6841750144958496,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.6979423761367798,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.265072822570801,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.150012254714966,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.1735007762908936,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.2885421514511108,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,4.61205530166626,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.35535991191864,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.728419542312622,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.7665802836418152,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.6714987754821775,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.5218586921691895,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.7272449731826782,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.819974660873413,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.5630446672439575,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.8550852537155151,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,6.9653496742248535,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.7903523445129397,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.6887609958648682,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.896805763244629,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.6400952339172363,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,7.016014575958252,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,34.631303787231445,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.8244731426239014,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.6080491542816162,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.5303020477294922,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.0605863332748413,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,5.023410797119141,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.1338603496551514,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.7414321899414062,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.6968315839767456,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,5.572124004364014,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.9157756567001345,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.45187246799469,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.228637456893921,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,4.596285820007324,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.3315013647079468,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.6381436586380005,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.845628559589386,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.4872580766677856,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,5.302531719207764,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.683126449584961,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.650102138519287,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.677507758140564,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.7828600406646729,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,6.793596267700195,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.0265140533447266,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.6454070806503296,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.405795693397522,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.6066290140151978,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,6.684345722198486,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,33.972294330596924,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.9394036531448364,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.849956512451172,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.4990899562835691,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.9012648463249208,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,5.1897149085998535,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.3381216526031494,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.840355634689331,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.5984009504318235,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,5.776878356933594,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.1988930702209473,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.0165820121765137,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.2123013734817505,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,5.427776336669922,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.6490991115570068,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.8970375061035156,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.8433617949485779,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.5687884092330933,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,5.958286762237549,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.6966379880905151,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.631245255470276,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.6253669261932373,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.8249367475509644,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,6.778186798095703,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.0422074794769287,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.7040661573410034,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.3589739799499512,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.6105557680130005,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,6.715803146362305,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,35.846646308898926,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.0161243677139282,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.7421854734420776,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.7102456092834473,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.926003634929657,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.394558906555176,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.0807766914367676,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.5500257015228271,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.6643731594085691,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.295175552368164,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.9122412204742432,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.297696232795715,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.1136481761932373,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,4.323585510253906,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.63211190700531,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.7054861783981323,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.8368695378303528,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.431242823600769,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.605710506439209,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.73463237285614,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.737044095993042,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.618929386138916,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.716902732849121,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,6.80750846862793,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.068650484085083,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.634609341621399,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.5167644023895264,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.6916193962097168,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,6.9116435050964355,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,34.33818244934082,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.0777156352996826,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.7896007299423218,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.6500959396362305,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.170650839805603,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,5.688063144683838,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.511934280395508,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.8042396306991575,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.8182318210601809,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,6.134406089782715,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.3382179737091064,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.654496431350708,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.396682858467102,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,5.389397144317627,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.6958073377609253,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.8811630010604856,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.0559818744659424,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.5546529293060305,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,6.187605381011963,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.7928931713104248,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.7782540321350098,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.5590239763259888,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.9092730283737185,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,7.0394439697265625,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.0313026905059814,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.616115927696228,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.725987434387207,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.6847373247146606,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,7.058143138885498,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,37.4970588684082,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.91460919380188,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.7718876600265503,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.462902545928955,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.0628390312194824,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.212238311767578,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.3372011184692383,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.819719076156616,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.7186191082000732,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.875539302825928,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.3449273109436035,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.002443790435791,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.214887619018555,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.562258720397949,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.695771336555481,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.9983294010162351,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.095271110534668,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.7446765899658203,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,6.534048080444336,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.6643621921539309,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.791293382644653,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.5066428184509275,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.847421169281006,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,6.809719562530518,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.0013134479522705,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.6996582746505735,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.6118695735931396,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.6901179552078247,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,7.002959251403809,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,36.99676322937012,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.953511357307434,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.9050740003585815,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.516538381576538,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.6133297681808472,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,4.988453388214111,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.371990203857422,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.7218122482299805,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.5336635112762451,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,5.627466201782227,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.235459089279175,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.656484842300415,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.1694294214248655,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,5.061373233795166,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.694882869720459,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.060774803161621,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.947865903377533,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.5461907386779783,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,6.249714374542236,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.739203929901123,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.727800726890564,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.665747880935669,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.856019377708435,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,6.988771915435791,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.042311191558838,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.530064821243286,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.573649764060974,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.7227061986923218,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,6.86873197555542,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,35.78451108932495,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.827802836894989,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.6475715637207031,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.4707072973251345,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.9110413789749146,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,4.857123374938965,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.0053482055664062,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.4908344745635986,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.643758773803711,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,5.139941215515137,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.7380683422088623,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.157843828201294,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.2012666463851929,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,4.097178936004639,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.4477121829986572,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.5593955516815186,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.8225092887878418,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.4940513372421265,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,5.323668479919434,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.617847919464111,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.8237273693084717,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.5889161825180054,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.858312964439392,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,6.8888044357299805,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.7775113582611084,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.6698013544082642,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.5866045951843262,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.7559746503829956,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,6.789891719818115,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,33.09660816192627,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.9964923858642578,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.7400596141815186,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.7941192388534546,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.8198023438453674,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,5.350473403930664,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.044555187225342,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.8224774599075315,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.5889458656311035,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,5.4559783935546875,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.9555230140686035,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.7656227350234983,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.4187164306640625,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,5.139862060546875,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.6282222270965576,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.8636943101882937,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.0214496850967407,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.5684916973114014,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,6.081858158111572,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.7075562477111816,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.8013187646865845,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.6052305698394775,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.8209004402160645,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,6.935006141662598,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.9493529796600344,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.5688934326171875,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.4536356925964355,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.694931149482727,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,6.666813373565674,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,35.62999153137207,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.0580118894577026,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.6417961120605469,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.462649703025818,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.8623478412628174,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,5.024805545806885,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.1351876258850098,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.581954002380371,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.4798802137374878,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,5.197021961212158,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.297563314437866,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.0143688917160034,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.2343307733535769,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,4.546262741088867,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.4732747077941897,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.925467848777771,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.7336927056312561,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.6714739799499512,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,5.8039093017578125,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.7377254962921145,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.8462995290756223,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.6422535181045532,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.823109030723572,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,7.049387454986572,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.932158350944519,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.6513724327087402,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.510878324508667,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.6605881452560425,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,6.754997253417969,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,34.376384258270264,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.0124380588531494,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.8524034023284912,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.7673267126083374,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.1655282974243164,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.797696590423584,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.38822340965271,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.7572327852249146,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.6746127605438232,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.820068836212158,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.225625514984131,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.6649514436721802,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.4060876369476318,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.296664714813232,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.6450309753417969,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.826027512550354,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.9069029092788696,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.599694848060608,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.977656364440918,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.9092042446136477,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.8319844007492063,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.4634320735931396,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.924997091293335,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,7.129617691040039,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.9714909791946411,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.8308628797531128,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.7399654388427734,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.7003543376922607,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,7.242673397064209,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,37.26437759399414,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.142249584197998,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.917522430419922,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.8376457691192627,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.194249153137207,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,6.091667175292969,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.4993832111358643,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.860003113746643,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.845165014266968,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,6.2045512199401855,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.1546928882598877,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.8035063743591309,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.3671162128448486,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.325315475463867,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.5008102655410769,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.7149720191955566,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.7652128338813782,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.6989675760269165,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.679962635040283,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.8603041172027588,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.803284764289856,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.560319900512695,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.9393434524536133,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,7.163252353668213,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.881425380706787,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.679884433746338,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.8196091651916504,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.682738184928894,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,7.063657283782959,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,37.52840614318848,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.8628880381584167,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.6953593492507937,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.5217288732528689,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.158352971076965,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,5.2383294105529785,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.029061794281006,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.6162129640579224,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.6330955028533936,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,5.278370380401611,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.0879788398742676,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.6317644119262695,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.0441997051239014,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,4.763943195343018,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.6089396476745603,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.7973790168762207,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.963196873664856,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.454028606414795,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,5.823544025421143,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.7233601808547974,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.8570966720581057,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.6539411544799805,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.6989845037460327,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,6.933382511138916,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.8342597484588623,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.5824514627456665,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.8649762868881223,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.644327998161316,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,6.926015377044678,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,34.963584899902344,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.1458745002746582,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.879251480102539,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.75632905960083,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.12742817401886,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,5.908883094787598,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.119163274765014,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.9566304683685305,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.775006890296936,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,5.850800514221191,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.0886878967285156,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.207766890525818,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.5206702947616575,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,4.81712532043457,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.6520785093307495,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.9651395082473757,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.0409952402114868,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.6239244937896729,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,6.282137870788574,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.7343889474868774,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.8295519351959229,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.5851160287857056,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.8816847801208496,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,7.0307416915893555,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.9470473527908323,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.613372564315796,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.6149274110794067,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.6547338962554932,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,6.830080986022949,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,36.71976947784424,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.1326106786727903,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.5936968326568604,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.8518112897872925,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.4591981172561646,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,6.037316799163818,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.1916234493255615,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.7660160064697266,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.8567548990249632,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,5.814394474029541,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.053035020828247,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.5717675685882568,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.3266024589538574,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,4.951405048370361,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.6056432723999023,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.9735236167907717,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.9772499799728394,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.592562556266785,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,6.148979663848877,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.7373113632202148,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.8510229587554932,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.6205248832702637,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.9517608880996704,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,7.160620212554932,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.9182533025741575,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.6938886642456057,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.693068504333496,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.7506451606750488,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,7.055855751037598,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,37.16857194900513,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.0931715965270996,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.770835518836975,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.632357835769653,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.8675249218940735,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,5.363889694213867,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.482774019241333,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.8349592685699463,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.8725610971450808,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,6.19029426574707,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.3529884815216064,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.1768869161605835,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.4363130331039429,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,4.966188430786133,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.8312218189239504,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.020725965499878,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.9495376944541932,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.7589011192321775,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,6.560386657714844,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.8411197662353516,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.906531810760498,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.7597917318344116,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.911482334136963,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,7.418925762176514,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.9307523965835571,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.6078004837036133,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.5774937868118286,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.6661903858184814,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,6.7822370529174805,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,37.28192186355591,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.047360062599182,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.6840577125549316,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.6210734844207764,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.925381362438202,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,5.277872562408447,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.0246007442474365,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.6382063627243042,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.6524349451065063,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,5.315241813659668,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.042546510696411,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.4647730588912964,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.2844353914260864,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,4.791754722595215,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.770155429840088,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.883958339691162,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.052354335784912,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.6330476999282837,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,6.339515686035156,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.77175772190094,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.873800277709961,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.6081204414367676,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.90445077419281,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,7.1581292152404785,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.8797322511672976,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.6584055423736572,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.806839942932129,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.6579465866088867,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,7.002923965454102,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,35.885437965393066,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.4309874773025513,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.026608467102051,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.6848158836364746,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.2500855922698977,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,6.392497539520264,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.5551459789276123,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.862729549407959,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.8756288290023804,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,6.29350471496582,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.123581647872925,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.302157282829285,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.6617714166641235,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.087510585784912,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.767916560173035,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.9152967929840088,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.8247201442718506,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.8278502225875857,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,6.3357834815979,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.8549283742904663,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.900368094444275,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.6506304740905762,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.9352375268936155,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,7.341164588928223,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.095377206802368,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.978114128112793,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.0145304203033447,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.6658315658569336,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,7.75385332107544,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,39.20431423187256,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.0770431756973269,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.725048542022705,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.6842293739318848,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.7958484888076782,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,6.282169342041016,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.609652042388916,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.90867280960083,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.8989282846450808,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,6.417253017425537,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.3213906288146973,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.9918079376220704,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.6305441856384275,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,4.943742752075195,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.8754688501358032,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.9635168313980105,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.075328350067139,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.6995471715927124,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,6.613861083984375,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.8083243370056152,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.808566331863403,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.6443626880645752,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.9138959646224976,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,7.175149440765381,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.0623950958251953,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.645874261856079,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.9717422723770144,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.6160115003585815,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,7.296023368835449,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,38.72819900512695,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.9694982171058656,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.7698545455932615,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.6410841941833496,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.8358021378517151,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,5.216238975524902,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.2790751457214355,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.9772775173187256,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.8551743030548096,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,6.111526966094971,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.3485755920410156,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.724206566810608,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.0707858800888062,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,5.14356803894043,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.901041567325592,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.175309181213379,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.6271858811378479,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.6588587760925293,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,4.362395286560059,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.818723201751709,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.9093666076660156,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.905817627906799,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.8404507637023928,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,7.474358081817627,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.7633041143417358,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.6706757545471191,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.399662494659424,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.6660984754562378,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,7.4997406005859375,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,35.807827949523926,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.0593547821044922,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.761473298072815,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.788192629814148,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.2527610063552856,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.861781597137451,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.101992607116699,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.5923856496810913,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.6717203855514526,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.366098880767822,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.973678469657898,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.8615624904632568,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.2577357292175293,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.0929765701293945,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.2693922519683838,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.4966838359832764,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.7745372653007507,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.607207179069519,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.147820472717285,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.7397829294204712,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.8627475500106812,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.4815285205841064,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.8470234870910645,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,6.931082725524902,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.821834683418274,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.0592598915100098,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.9862371683120728,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.5952273607254028,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,7.462559223175049,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,35.862319469451904,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.1664118766784668,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.8433942794799805,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.7363152503967283,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.3713370561599731,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,6.117458343505859,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.013335943222046,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.8393768072128296,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.07051157951355,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,5.923224449157715,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.3485045433044434,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.8484972715377808,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.5431817770004272,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,5.740183353424072,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.7509595155715942,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.8038067817687988,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.9693881273269652,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.718271255493164,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,6.242425441741943,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.7761996984481812,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.7661477327346802,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.5351239442825315,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.9918644428253176,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,7.0693359375,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.009138584136963,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.6171510219573977,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.8337377309799192,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.7572556734085083,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,7.217282772064209,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,38.3099102973938,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.1189264059066772,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.9139286279678345,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.6790199279785156,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.2516852617263794,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,5.963560104370117,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.1795432567596436,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.8418612480163576,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.6323240995407104,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,5.653728485107422,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.2955009937286377,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.3265905380249023,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.4565964937210083,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,6.078688144683838,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.4325841665267944,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.83504319190979,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.8761078119277954,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.6901274919509888,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,5.833862781524658,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.850350260734558,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.6538840532302856,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.617884874343872,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.8205736875534055,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,6.94269323348999,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.9888516664505005,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.6122522354125977,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.8707002401351929,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.634503722190857,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,7.1063079833984375,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,37.57884073257446,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.0570638179779053,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.8296064138412476,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.691956639289856,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.2329397201538086,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,5.811566352844238,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.210419178009033,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.9585627317428589,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.9109094142913816,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,6.079891204833984,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.229528427124023,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.3276708126068115,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.6904230117797852,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,6.247622013092041,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.859251379966736,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.8812068700790403,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.0803589820861816,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.6845319271087646,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,6.505349159240723,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.8878024816513064,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.990290880203247,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.623321294784546,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.9717763662338257,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,7.473191261291504,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.9888739585876465,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.803110957145691,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.71655011177063,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.688679814338684,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,7.1972150802612305,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,39.31483507156372,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.974233329296112,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.6944568157196045,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.7345688343048096,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.2889095544815063,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,5.692168712615967,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.365504741668701,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.9365684986114504,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.9250431060791016,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,6.227116584777832,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.162230968475342,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.5646615028381348,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.4642953872680664,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,5.191187858581543,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.6742398738861084,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.8687688112258911,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.9039350748062134,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.6511913537979126,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,6.098134994506836,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.91425883769989,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.8951621055603027,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.673966884613037,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.8842837810516355,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,7.367671489715576,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.04575514793396,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.6564772129058838,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.8311978578567505,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.6382921934127808,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,7.171722412109375,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,37.74800205230713,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.9744825959205629,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.7284157276153564,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.6362611055374146,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.9607951641082764,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,5.299954891204834,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.3310413360595703,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.7014658451080322,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.813210606575012,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,5.845717906951904,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.2160210609436035,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.71221661567688,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.3242002725601196,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,5.252438068389893,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.734052658081055,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.9677172899246216,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.180963397026062,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.7157472372055054,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,6.598480701446533,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.8746179342269895,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.8114768266677856,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.68645179271698,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.9029059410095217,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,7.275452613830566,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.9460980892181396,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.6362123489379885,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.85916006565094,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.6340428590774536,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,7.0755133628845215,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,37.34755754470825,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.9995840191841124,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.845335841178894,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.8453450202941897,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.9432879090309144,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.6335530281066895,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.167747259140014,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.6987382173538208,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.644344687461853,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.510829925537109,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.207545042037964,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.4703830480575562,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.3448805809020996,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.02280855178833,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.500418782234192,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.727636694908142,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.0266271829605105,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.6009143590927124,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.855597019195557,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.8764432668685913,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.8450928926467896,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.4533885717391968,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.8750250339508057,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,7.049949645996094,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.823153614997864,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.673832893371582,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.5456746816635132,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.6384963989257812,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,6.68115758895874,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,35.75389575958252,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.469118356704712,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.9370508193969729,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.7457270622253418,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.2539759874343872,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,6.405872344970703,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.539026975631714,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.866076946258545,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.9534739255905151,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,6.358577728271484,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.786664366722107,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.21320641040802,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.6542683839797974,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,4.654139041900635,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.7476224899291992,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.999006986618042,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.1320860385894775,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.6779812574386597,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,6.55669641494751,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.8008650541305542,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.8720502853393557,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.5397740602493286,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.9019348621368408,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,7.114624500274658,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.0947797298431396,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.7198511362075806,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.6263625621795654,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.6657967567443848,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,7.106790065765381,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,38.19670009613037,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.1127684116363523,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.7874574661254885,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.7857539653778076,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.122174859046936,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,5.808154582977295,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.4778666496276855,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.947335124015808,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.0460221767425537,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,6.471224308013916,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.2421908378601074,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.45134437084198,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.7244914770126345,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,5.418026447296143,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.033785581588745,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.0841848850250244,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.1852211952209473,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.8472365140914917,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,7.150428295135498,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.913763642311096,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.8307745456695557,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.6651099920272827,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.0443315505981445,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,7.453979969024658,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.1263062953948975,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.7075543403625488,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.7356383800506592,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.6560949087142944,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,7.2255940437316895,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,39.5274076461792,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.1719872951507568,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.7720011472702026,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.7009999752044678,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.9698825478553772,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,5.614871025085449,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.123713731765747,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.8167376518249512,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.980374813079834,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,5.920825958251953,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.33590316772461,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.880873441696167,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.2957336902618408,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,5.512510299682617,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.6763898134231567,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.9867924451828003,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.9675952792167664,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.691066861152649,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,6.321844100952148,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.761483907699585,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.6240005493164062,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.6028611660003662,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.8999749422073364,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,6.888320446014404,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.017568588256836,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.6638621091842651,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.044386386871338,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.649280309677124,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,7.375097274780273,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,37.633469104766846,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.003157138824463,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.7323535680770874,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.6218465566635132,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.8200936913490295,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.177451133728027,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.220348834991455,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.498387098312378,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.7781802415847778,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.4969162940979,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.2334866523742676,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.3156863451004028,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.190054416656494,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,4.739227294921875,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.5959761142730713,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.8947534561157229,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.0973410606384275,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.623984456062317,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,6.212055206298828,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.8187332153320312,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.7209595441818235,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.6634695529937744,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.879938721656799,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,7.08310079574585,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.969438910484314,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.4632766246795654,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.223877429962158,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.6666845083236694,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,7.323277473449707,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,36.03202819824219,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.0555227994918823,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.825102925300598,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.6166925430297852,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.662025511264801,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,5.159343719482422,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.262749671936035,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.681412696838379,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.5666821002960205,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,5.5108442306518555,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.3855981826782227,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.1190849542617798,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.208337426185608,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,4.713020324707031,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.790794849395752,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.0906169414520264,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.118045449256897,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.9607245922088623,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,6.960181713104248,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.7770873308181765,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.958580493927002,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.7226186990737915,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.951528549194336,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,7.409815311431885,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.001295566558838,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.4055795669555664,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.375483751296997,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.67029869556427,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,7.452657699584961,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,37.2058629989624,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.1885755062103271,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.877696633338928,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.7629605531692505,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.138454794883728,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,5.967687129974365,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.007594108581543,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.7104740142822266,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.7409042119979858,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,5.458972454071045,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.188399076461792,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.590368151664734,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.2021076679229736,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,4.980875015258789,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.756986379623413,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.040034055709839,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.1496776342391968,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.7838850021362305,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,6.730583190917969,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.6610888242721558,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.9074592590332031,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.4863402843475342,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.9211392402648928,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,6.976027965545654,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.082176446914673,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.652698636054993,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.5827521085739136,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.6447553634643557,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,6.9623823165893555,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,37.07652807235718,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.0085266828536987,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.5889405012130735,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.3813986778259275,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.959136426448822,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,4.938002109527588,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.8593670129776,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.648526668548584,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.7570958137512207,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,5.264989376068115,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.398962020874023,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.749659538269043,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.3061282634735107,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,5.454750061035156,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.830775499343872,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.0198380947113037,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.0218397378921509,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.7490272521972656,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,6.621480464935303,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.802574872970581,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.8580559492111208,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.7063606977462769,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.9568705558776855,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,7.323862075805664,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.0110762119293213,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.4622838497161863,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.5137373208999634,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.66272234916687,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,6.649819850921631,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,36.25290393829346,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.9723879098892212,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.6624799966812134,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.6007033586502075,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.276466965675354,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,5.512038230895996,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.4402990341186523,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.6317963600158691,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.6517966985702517,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,5.7238922119140625,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.2556490898132324,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.6100314855575562,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.4947911500930786,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,5.360471725463867,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.9835951328277588,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.090142250061035,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.3049654960632324,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.811490774154663,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,7.1901936531066895,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.8810861110687256,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.8247021436691284,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.605725884437561,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.940309762954712,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,7.251823902130127,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.0751500129699707,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.707746148109436,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.8512272834777832,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.6751155853271484,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,7.309238910675049,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,38.34765863418579,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.9763356447219848,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.6346298456192017,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.5382260084152222,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.9372788071632384,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,5.086470603942871,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.0109715461730957,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.6205068826675415,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.8873586654663088,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,5.518836975097656,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.0888166427612305,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.8824775218963623,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.3321315050125122,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,5.303425312042236,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.61757230758667,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.000675678253174,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.0273966789245603,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.586544394493103,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,6.232188701629639,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.7024036645889282,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.9325319528579712,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.582242488861084,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.905908703804016,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,7.123086929321289,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.0615761280059814,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.6923712491989136,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.6397377252578735,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.6196991205215454,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,7.0133843421936035,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,36.277392864227295,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.9115626215934752,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.678138256072998,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.5456202030181885,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.0749174356460571,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,5.210238456726074,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.1000659465789795,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.5731312036514282,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.7494356632232666,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,5.422632694244385,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.3413422107696533,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.117539644241333,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.3842885494232178,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,4.843170166015625,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.5785714387893677,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.8672364950180056,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.9544256329536438,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.574853539466858,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,5.9750871658325195,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.7587809562683103,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.7736375331878662,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.5272244215011597,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.83458411693573,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,6.894226551055908,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.965327739715576,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.6216375827789309,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.9990118741989136,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.6440564393997192,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,7.23003339767456,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,35.57538843154907,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.974132001399994,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.82967209815979,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.3978458642959597,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.8822246789932251,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,5.083874702453613,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.1324286460876465,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.666397213935852,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.6863324642181396,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,5.485158443450928,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.089712381362915,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.8063297271728516,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.2477262020111084,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,5.143768310546875,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.8340182304382324,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.0435800552368164,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.031179904937744,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.7305082082748413,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,6.639286518096924,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.711011290550232,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.0327212810516357,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.6168689727783203,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.942432641983032,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,7.30303430557251,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.031742572784424,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.5879192352294922,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.9547735452651975,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.7016794681549072,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,7.2761149406433105,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,36.93123722076416,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.8919058442115784,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.707397222518921,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.2870597839355469,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.9701266288757324,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,4.856489658355713,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.999390244483948,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.561012625694275,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.56255042552948,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,5.122953414916992,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.125216484069824,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.1197056770324707,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.3195494413375854,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,4.56447172164917,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.5722572803497314,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.065680503845215,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.0448460578918457,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.6690800189971924,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,6.351863861083984,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.7913106679916382,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.7937513589859009,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.6453146934509275,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.834228515625,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,7.064605236053467,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.83379590511322,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.6436913013458252,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.8726454973220823,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.5316379070281982,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,6.881770610809326,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,34.84215450286865,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.0106865167617798,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.79147469997406,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.5331432819366455,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.8539290428161621,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,5.189233779907227,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.7623299360275269,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.7271043062210083,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.5961790084838867,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,5.085613250732422,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.250737190246582,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.0011205673217773,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.1488438844680786,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,5.400701522827148,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.3852044343948364,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.6326690912246704,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.8277382254600525,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.5825899839401243,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,5.428201675415039,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8975770473480225,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8021650314331057,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.5597965717315674,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8523128032684328,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,7.111851215362549,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.9990546703338623,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.6151984930038452,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.7833824157714844,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.5046886205673218,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,6.902324199676514,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,35.1179256439209,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.9607487916946412,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.7141363620758057,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.558952569961548,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.0528579950332642,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,5.286695957183838,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.0771501064300537,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.534384846687317,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.8626949787139893,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,5.47422981262207,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.094282627105713,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.947298228740692,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.236789584159851,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,4.278370380401611,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.4854899644851685,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.8203896284103391,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.8633512854576111,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.5414371490478516,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,5.710668087005615,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.693825125694275,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.8658214807510376,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.6560583114624023,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.7777228355407717,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,6.993427753448486,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.7891660928726196,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.6925486326217651,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.687322974205017,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.631231665611267,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,6.80026912689209,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,34.54366111755371,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.9626996517181396,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.7101858854293823,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.5150500535964966,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.0230097770690918,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,5.2109456062316895,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.9020872116088867,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.532523274421692,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.735143542289734,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,5.1697540283203125,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.078176259994507,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.490869164466858,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.246471881866455,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,4.815517425537109,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.3145843744277954,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.5283552408218384,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.7444357872009277,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.6154680252075195,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,5.20284366607666,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.8421982526779177,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.9149765968322752,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.6692763566970823,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.815032720565796,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,7.24148416519165,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.98572301864624,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.62708580493927,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.7387065887451172,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.6514146327972412,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,7.002930164337158,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,34.64347505569458,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.0015352964401243,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.7163913249969482,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.6908546686172483,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.8391395211219788,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,5.247920989990234,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.205714702606201,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.7588638067245483,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.6420812606811523,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,5.606659889221191,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.1473100185394287,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.1335830688476562,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.1165063381195068,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,4.397399425506592,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.2379580736160278,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.5909688472747805,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.6334829926490784,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.6284010410308838,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,5.090810775756836,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.7791777849197388,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.7801440954208374,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.6815611124038696,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.9393924474716189,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,7.1802754402160645,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.9930495023727417,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.5995635986328125,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.7857897281646729,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.6677861213684082,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,7.046188831329346,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,34.569255352020264,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.109713077545166,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.8868794441223145,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.4303865432739258,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.1535192728042605,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,5.580498695373535,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.0118534564971924,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.670857548713684,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.6500815153121948,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,5.33279275894165,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.155919313430786,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.1167925596237185,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.239128351211548,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,4.511840343475342,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.5069669485092163,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.7975353002548218,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.9591901898384094,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.6965363025665283,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,5.96022891998291,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.6867979764938354,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.7333954572677612,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.5478225946426392,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.8453612327575684,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,6.813377380371094,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.854009032249451,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.6644811630249023,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.8501150608062744,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.6403733491897583,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,7.008978366851807,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,35.20771646499634,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.989355444908142,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.8110549449920657,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.610223650932312,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.8559016585350037,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,5.266535758972168,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.335263729095459,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.9159520864486697,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.67729651927948,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,5.928512096405029,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.48579740524292,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.4258437156677246,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.5233492851257324,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,5.434990406036377,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.4673298597335815,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.8154224157333376,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.9342445135116576,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.7236924171447754,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,5.9406890869140625,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.8934390544891355,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.83426034450531,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.7207932472229004,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.0998380184173584,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,7.548330783843994,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.8478121757507324,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.620987057685852,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.8239058256149292,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.5846391916275024,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,6.877344131469727,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,36.99640226364136,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.7623386979103088,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.7569658756256104,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.359893560409546,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.0425043106079102,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,4.9217023849487305,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.0734145641326904,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.6145793199539185,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.903016209602356,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,5.591010093688965,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.1738531589508057,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.9678765535354616,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.257288098335266,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,5.399017810821533,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.848379611968994,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.040773391723633,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.3001691102981567,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.699520230293274,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,6.888842582702637,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.7029269933700562,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.8916754722595217,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.815192937850952,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.9766243696212769,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,7.386419773101807,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.8736377954483032,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.7731139659881592,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.8337279558181765,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.6669974327087402,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,7.147477149963379,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,37.33446979522705,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.699342668056488,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.632254123687744,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.2672452926635742,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.7344458103179932,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,4.333288192749023,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.0948803424835205,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.7060571908950806,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.7393040657043457,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,5.540241718292236,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.1356120109558105,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.6564563512802124,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.2539666891098022,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,5.046035289764404,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.1566574573516846,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.525966763496399,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.7003685235977173,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.608753323554993,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,4.991745948791504,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.6260958909988403,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.778403639793396,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.7231755256652832,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.841660499572754,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,6.969335556030273,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.6924002170562744,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.2345608472824097,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.048387289047241,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.6305716037750244,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,6.60591983795166,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,33.4865665435791,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.8992440104484558,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.698250412940979,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.5507681369781494,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.1458728313446045,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,5.294135093688965,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.1236684322357178,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.6600115299224854,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.9079229831695557,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,5.69160270690918,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.261014461517334,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.722323298454285,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.2270547151565552,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,5.210392475128174,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.54925274848938,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.9896275997161863,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.0917575359344482,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.7154396772384644,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,6.346077919006348,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.92837655544281,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.8565846681594849,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.6693896055221558,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.970742464065552,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,7.425093173980713,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.879844069480896,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.6536535024642944,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.8006311655044556,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.5981601476669312,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,6.932289123535156,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,36.899590492248535,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.054602026939392,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.869457721710205,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.5567831993103027,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.1098301410675049,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,5.590672969818115,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.685153007507324,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.7510007619857788,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.9012715816497805,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,6.337425708770752,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.3639068603515625,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.5339436531066897,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.281188726425171,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,5.179039478302002,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.730211853981018,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.0523431301116943,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.214453101158142,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.7562671899795532,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,6.753275394439697,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.7954779863357544,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.7773562669754028,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.7349177598953247,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.921198844909668,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,7.22895097732544,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.985954761505127,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.8530175685882568,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.328298807144165,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.6584558486938477,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,7.8257269859313965,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,38.9150915145874,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.9598470330238342,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.7053126096725464,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.2581837177276611,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.7729002833366394,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,4.6962432861328125,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.243691682815552,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.9453635215759275,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.744398593902588,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,5.933453559875488,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.1884799003601074,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.870090126991272,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.0907297134399414,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,5.149299621582031,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.2299528121948242,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.69701886177063,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.8175654411315918,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.7201138734817505,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,5.464651107788086,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.80613911151886,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.7988907098770142,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.5734037160873413,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.861660718917847,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,7.040094375610352,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.7691006660461426,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.925950527191162,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.334043264389038,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.570575475692749,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,7.599669933319092,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,35.88341188430786,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.0634242296218872,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.9491626024246216,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.3103337287902832,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.101348042488098,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,5.42426872253418,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.4417591094970703,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.8801794052124023,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.855136156082153,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,6.177074909210205,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.2687344551086426,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.3605462312698364,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.2973313331604004,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,4.92661190032959,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.981512665748596,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.1001551151275635,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.3297083377838137,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.813742756843567,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,7.225118637084961,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.842192530632019,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.7176930904388428,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.735012769699097,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.96856689453125,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,7.263465404510498,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.9304661750793457,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.749001383781433,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.8853180408477783,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.7179795503616333,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,7.282764911651611,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,38.299304485321045,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.800000786781311,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.4868431091308594,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.504401683807373,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.0353965759277344,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,4.826642036437988,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.075828313827514,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.3988864421844482,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.738675236701965,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,5.213389873504639,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.3336997032165527,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.2044565677642822,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.1815496683120728,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,4.719706058502197,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.9307239055633545,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.121385335922241,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.2552670240402222,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.652802586555481,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,6.960178852081299,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.6622841358184814,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.870034456253052,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.842345714569092,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.926101565361023,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,7.3007659912109375,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.910521864891052,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.6887742280960083,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.3694065809249878,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.649394989013672,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,6.61809778213501,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,35.63878059387207,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.7867562770843506,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.809841871261597,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.6447365283966064,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.3628617525100708,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,5.604196548461914,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.2581899166107178,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.0058321952819824,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.728689193725586,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,5.992711544036865,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.506538152694702,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.473318338394165,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.4144632816314695,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,5.394319534301758,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.861022710800171,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.194396495819092,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.299671292304993,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.80717670917511,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,7.162267208099365,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.8873941898345947,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.962842583656311,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.8881136178970337,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.9541414976119995,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,7.6924920082092285,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.016162157058716,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.003286361694336,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.9455848932266235,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.705708146095276,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,7.670741558074951,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,39.51672840118408,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.8708258271217346,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.6908026933670044,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.489139437675476,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.222458839416504,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,5.273226737976074,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.8671908378601072,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.5549747943878174,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.7897878885269165,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,5.211953639984131,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.2615692615509033,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.951120138168335,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.2126960754394531,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,4.425385475158691,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.7627664804458618,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.1303017139434814,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.1473551988601685,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.6711163520812988,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,6.7115397453308105,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.8075907230377195,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.893793702125549,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.8601422309875488,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.8663289546966553,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,7.427855968475342,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.920111298561096,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.9665886163711548,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.659268140792847,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.7363663911819458,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,7.282334327697754,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,36.3322958946228,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.7659065127372742,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.6420001983642578,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.5270917415618896,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.9798490405082704,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,4.914847373962402,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.9234870672225952,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.7003353834152222,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.7983781099319458,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,5.422200679779053,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.292046546936035,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.976858139038086,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.2910733222961426,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,5.559978008270264,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.7446470260620115,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.9281164407730105,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.300658106803894,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.703161120414734,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,6.6765828132629395,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.7203906774520874,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.969619631767273,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.8192585706710815,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.7940975427627563,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,7.303366184234619,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.9537205696105957,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.9458420276641848,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.117372512817383,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.7650753259658811,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,7.782010078430176,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,37.65898513793945,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.06561541557312,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.592111110687256,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.4020479917526243,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.1272833347320557,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,5.187057971954346,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.104853391647339,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.890066623687744,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.8067681789398191,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,5.801688194274902,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.3882133960723877,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.6589064598083496,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.2978335618972778,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,5.344953536987305,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.64721417427063,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.8862227201461792,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.1910231113433838,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.5961087942123413,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,6.320568561553955,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.8603785037994385,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.97037410736084,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.9022033214569092,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.866532325744629,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,7.599488258361816,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.9419909715652464,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.6645994186401367,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.8184579610824585,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.6581004858016968,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,7.083148956298828,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,37.33690547943115,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.9844220280647278,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.6098990440368652,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.477972388267517,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.172252178192139,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,5.2445454597473145,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.438052177429199,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.6979312896728516,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.749805212020874,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,5.885788440704346,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.267451286315918,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.049564242362976,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.2392834424972534,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,4.556298732757568,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.8433760404586792,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.0142712593078613,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.382070779800415,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.7079366445541382,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,6.947654724121094,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.7768938541412354,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.903308987617493,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.715864658355713,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.8673994541168213,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,7.263466835021973,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.081556797027588,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.686307668685913,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.152461528778076,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.6938835382461548,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,7.614209651947021,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,37.51196384429931,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.9986209869384766,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.8380447626113892,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.4984064102172852,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.8550392985343933,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,5.1901116371154785,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.1469154357910156,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.5708099603652954,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.5431678295135498,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,5.26089334487915,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.269385814666748,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.1116458177566528,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.0758335590362549,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,4.456865310668945,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.654096245765686,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.8845808506011963,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.230769157409668,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.500054121017456,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,6.269500255584717,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.6695412397384644,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.764404058456421,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.8424036502838137,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.7906653881072998,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,7.067014217376709,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.8303810358047483,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.9826722145080569,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.9663254022598269,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.6892811059951782,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,7.4686598777771,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,35.7130446434021,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.0214132070541382,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.7682840824127195,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.5998793840408323,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.1658424139022827,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,5.555418968200684,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.477095603942871,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.8669034242630005,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.7741456031799316,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,6.118144512176514,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.324554920196533,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.4974247217178345,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.2181344032287598,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,5.040114402770996,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.9741064310073853,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.051508665084839,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.3397499322891235,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.789800047874451,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,7.155165195465088,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.78793203830719,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.751047968864441,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.577854871749878,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.83599591255188,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,6.952830791473389,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.9463266134262085,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.7262086868286133,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.072052478790283,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.7350940704345703,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,7.479681968688965,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,38.301355838775635,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.8263334035873413,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.5326426029205322,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.3667691946029663,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.8228278756141663,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,4.548573017120361,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.2074341773986816,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.465245008468628,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.7804027795791626,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,5.453082084655762,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.496548652648926,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.5956885814666748,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.341728448867798,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,5.433965682983398,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.789032220840454,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.9240516424179075,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.2000088691711426,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.7001471519470217,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,6.613239765167236,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.726814866065979,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.8804373741149905,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.6538927555084229,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.8836528062820437,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,7.1447978019714355,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.9565056562423704,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.7044997215270996,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.6608493328094482,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.659138560295105,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,6.980993270874023,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,36.17465162277222,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.755025327205658,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.6419928073883057,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.3265360593795776,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.0792622566223145,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,4.802816390991211,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.754411697387695,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.4421052932739258,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.7916910648345947,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,4.988207817077637,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.168994188308716,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.2156436443328855,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.272077560424805,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,4.656715393066406,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.698222041130066,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.8928892612457275,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.1871261596679688,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.6678458452224731,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,6.446083068847656,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.6419001817703247,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.876329779624939,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.728775978088379,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.909454107284546,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,7.156459808349609,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.9649909734725952,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.6721906661987305,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.7155014276504517,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.7009165287017822,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,7.0535993576049805,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,35.1038818359375,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.9171739816665648,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.6518040895462036,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.5772314071655271,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.6458065509796145,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,5.79201602935791,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.3223233222961426,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.0038604736328125,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.0070176124572754,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,6.3332014083862305,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.5123209953308105,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.1722824573516846,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.23357093334198,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,4.9181742668151855,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.8313722610473633,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.084816217422486,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.4199508428573608,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.5135555267333984,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,6.849694728851318,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.8732198476791384,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.9019980430603027,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.8050153255462649,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.823785185813904,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,7.404018402099609,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.0431556701660156,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.7026087045669556,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.9849270582199097,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.6956841945648191,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,7.426375865936279,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,38.72348070144653,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2017,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.8112592697143555,classic_6,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.4307886362075806,classic_6,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.5460437536239624,classic_6,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.8595812916755676,classic_6,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,4.647672653198242,classic_6,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2017,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.1148681640625,classic_6,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.527011156082153,classic_6,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.6807233095169067,classic_6,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,5.322602272033691,classic_6,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2017,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.1923828125,classic_6,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.7578743696212769,classic_6,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.2188808917999268,classic_6,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,5.169137954711914,classic_6,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2017,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.526089429855347,classic_6,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.9296495914459229,classic_6,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.0832799673080444,classic_6,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.7221375703811646,classic_6,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,6.2611565589904785,classic_6,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2017,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.8270715475082395,classic_6,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.8055726289749143,classic_6,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.6046868562698364,classic_6,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.031714916229248,classic_6,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,7.269045829772949,classic_6,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2017,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.925902247428894,classic_6,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2017,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.0591322183609009,classic_6,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2017,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.6261029243469238,classic_6,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2017,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.6693390607833862,classic_6,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2017,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,6.2804765701293945,classic_6,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2017,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,34.95009183883667,classic_6,papi_total,,,aggregate,sum_of_6_dimensions 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.9631823301315308,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.510028839111328,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.599778175354004,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.1426290273666382,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.215618133544922,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.7838578820228577,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.7224832773208618,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.2931103706359863,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.2874383926391602,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.086889743804932,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.8465492725372312,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.8075522780418396,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.957152724266052,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,4.6112542152404785,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.491485834121704,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.7875447273254397,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.9001170992851257,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.89675772190094,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,6.0759053230285645,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.808744430541992,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.9430402517318728,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.8133727312088013,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.934288024902344,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,7.49944543838501,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.870561480522156,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.6163069009780884,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.000347375869751,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.4398689270019531,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,6.927084445953369,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.493840575218201,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.688917875289917,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.4009871482849121,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,3.5837457180023193,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.5997591018676758,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.7197656631469727,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,3.3195247650146484,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,42.3194694519043,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,42.3194694519043,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.000649333000183,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.5888735055923462,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.6431792974472046,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.0285192728042605,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,5.261221408843994,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.9312430024147034,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.7014743089675903,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.4103034734725952,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.3021031618118286,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,5.345123767852783,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.7330374717712402,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.0591517686843872,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.0245208740234375,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,4.816709995269775,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.435951828956604,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.8998459577560425,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.9934393763542176,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.8325881958007812,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,6.161825180053711,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.9116063117980957,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.8090561628341677,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.754244685173035,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.8224647045135496,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,7.297371864318848,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.012423276901245,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.6900300979614258,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.7880460023880005,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.3680744171142578,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,6.858573913574219,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.755073070526123,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.069203615188598,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.7407733798027039,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,4.56505012512207,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.6501597762107849,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.7725400924682617,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,3.4226996898651123,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,43.72857666015625,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,43.72857666015625,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.207990646362305,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.6591627597808838,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.5806779861450195,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.9167985320091248,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,5.364629745483398,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.8475306630134583,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.732389211654663,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.402926325798035,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.3113409280776978,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,5.294187068939209,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.915290594100952,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.4584295749664309,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.7801889181137085,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,5.153909206390381,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.6036261320114136,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.034005880355835,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.9552509784698486,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.9008280038833616,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,6.493710994720459,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.791476845741272,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.6994798183441162,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.5609726905822754,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.902911901473999,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,6.954841136932373,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.9917200803756712,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.6432416439056396,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.8285752534866333,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.2623528242111206,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,6.725889682769775,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.732582926750183,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.9608005285263064,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.222092866897583,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,4.915476322174072,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.7190364599227905,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.45430850982666,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,3.17334508895874,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,44.07598876953125,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,44.07598876953125,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.1656535863876345,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.5515978336334229,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.603571534156799,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.9803876876831056,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.301210880279541,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.8239107131958008,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.783822774887085,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.3570406436920166,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.4008240699768066,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.365598201751709,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.9025752544403076,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.193317174911499,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.9495786428451536,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.04547119140625,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.717780351638794,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.9506701231002808,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.9225292801856996,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.8541783094406128,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,6.445158004760742,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.881816029548645,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.9369934797286987,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.7130975723266602,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.8635059595108032,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,7.395413398742676,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.9883596897125244,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.611616611480713,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.9590777158737185,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.4440065622329712,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,7.003060340881348,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.9594846963882449,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.1666297912597656,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.7603676915168762,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,4.886482238769531,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.6241937875747681,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.2959721088409424,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.920166015625,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,44.3625602722168,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,44.3625602722168,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.2722593545913696,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.6572617292404177,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.6334418058395386,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.2166032791137695,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,5.779566287994385,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.906976282596588,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.7318049669265747,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.4081939458847046,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.3278740644454956,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,5.374849319458008,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.9478832483291624,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.2413253784179688,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.950208306312561,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,5.139416694641113,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.5255820751190186,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.880182862281799,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.9852094650268556,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.857137680053711,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,6.248112201690674,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.897379994392395,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.725077986717224,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.750603199005127,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.9684025049209597,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,7.341463565826416,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.0092344284057617,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.6765857934951782,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.0125672817230225,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.485241413116455,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,7.183629035949707,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.9352037906646729,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.9427316188812256,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.4917357563972473,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,4.36967134475708,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.6057016849517822,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.8672263622283936,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,3.472928047180176,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,44.909637451171875,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,44.909637451171875,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.0246399641036987,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.554165601730347,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.5818989276885986,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.2515146732330322,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.412219047546387,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.8719525933265686,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.8702336549758911,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.408601999282837,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.2972313165664673,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.448019504547119,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.8719778060913088,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.0045400857925415,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.0173757076263428,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,4.893893718719482,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.5610716342926023,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.0213139057159424,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.9271230101585388,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.8666633367538452,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,6.376172065734863,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.932066559791565,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.7797377109527588,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.661863923072815,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.9517009258270264,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,7.325369358062744,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.9789880514144895,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.6479123830795288,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.0374486446380615,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.5079625844955444,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,7.172311782836914,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.6141886711120603,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.0797760486602783,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.6095255613327026,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,4.303490161895752,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.5780500769615173,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.8635990619659424,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,3.4416489601135254,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,44.37312316894531,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,44.37312316894531,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.0518019199371338,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.7255194187164309,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.5592536926269531,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.6145612001419067,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,4.951136589050293,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.8838841319084167,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.853368878364563,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.416053056716919,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.2449867725372314,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,5.3982930183410645,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.897553324699402,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.0659456253051758,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.8081451654434204,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,4.771644115447998,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.5827937126159668,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.0130929946899414,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.9310396909713744,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.9305129051208496,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,6.457439422607422,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.915849685668945,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.8002862930297852,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.6357418298721311,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.8431733846664429,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,7.195051193237305,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.9985721111297607,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.589781641960144,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.943226218223572,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.4267374277114868,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,6.958317279815674,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.811315417289734,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.3325071334838867,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.7042588591575623,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,4.848081588745117,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.619695782661438,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.1914303302764893,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.811126232147217,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,43.391090393066406,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,43.391090393066406,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.8847847580909729,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.531006932258606,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.6669442653656006,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.1785169839859009,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,5.2612528800964355,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.99284565448761,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.54822838306427,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.4549016952514648,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.23530912399292,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,5.2312846183776855,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.9748845100402832,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.0885335206985474,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.8060110807418823,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,4.869429111480713,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.689257025718689,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.0540146827697754,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.0955363512039185,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.848291039466858,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,6.687098979949951,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.854590892791748,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.8899470567703247,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.8901128768920896,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.9047093391418457,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,7.539360046386719,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.8518872261047363,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.7122129201889038,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.978394865989685,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.4680951833724976,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,7.010590076446533,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.9669320583343504,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.069744825363159,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.6790957450866699,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,4.71577262878418,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.6812674403190613,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.4226925373077393,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,3.103959798812866,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,44.41875076293945,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,44.41875076293945,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.0338342189788818,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.4833247661590576,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.7246956825256348,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.063099384307861,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,5.3049540519714355,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.8472710251808167,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.7371771335601809,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.3051764965057373,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.2714160680770874,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,5.161040782928467,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.914361834526062,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.2581117153167725,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.9397655725479128,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,5.112239360809326,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.5238029956817627,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.944501876831055,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.1348226070404053,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.919780135154724,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,6.522907257080078,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.872242450714111,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.9242273569107056,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.7893890142440796,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.9056092500686648,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,7.49146842956543,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.0489463806152344,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.669359564781189,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.762007474899292,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.4728987216949463,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,6.953212261199951,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.9288805723190308,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.0746731758117676,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.4891484677791595,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,4.492702007293701,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.5949282050132751,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.1460182666778564,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.7409462928771973,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,43.77947235107422,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,43.77947235107422,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.1733238697052002,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.6379541158676147,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.6066046953201294,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.1045866012573242,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,5.522469520568848,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.9394537806510924,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.661691427230835,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.2749402523040771,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.382691740989685,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,5.258777141571045,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.027122259140014,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.0777336359024048,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.9133679866790771,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,5.018223762512207,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.5239198207855225,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.939380168914795,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.00751793384552,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.7924203872680664,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,6.263238430023193,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.9877687692642212,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.972112774848938,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.691289305686951,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.0051519870758057,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,7.656322956085205,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.053464889526367,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.6609611511230469,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.968490719795227,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.475214958190918,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,7.1581315994262695,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.8400049209594729,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.124701738357544,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.5501090884208679,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,4.514815807342529,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.6715213060379028,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.732438802719116,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,3.4039599895477295,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,44.79594039916992,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,44.79594039916992,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.368768334388733,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.6588513851165771,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.8143515586853027,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.0334147214889526,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.8753862380981445,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.942379593849182,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.8608587980270384,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.3209834098815918,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.2950116395950315,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.419233322143555,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.801929712295532,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.20334792137146,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.8494811058044431,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,4.8547587394714355,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.6054317951202393,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.749619483947754,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.8625533580780029,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.9171749353408811,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,6.134779453277588,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.8456000089645384,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.912447452545166,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.6669642925262451,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.8955286741256712,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,7.320540428161621,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.946289300918579,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.8071190118789673,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.078247547149658,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.4810878038406372,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,7.312743663787842,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.570788860321045,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.7729551792144775,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.5463324189186096,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,3.8900763988494873,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.6332721710205078,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,3.023996114730835,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,3.6572682857513423,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,44.464786529541016,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,44.464786529541016,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.4100946187973022,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.6351085901260376,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.7960056066513062,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.9624224305152892,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.80363130569458,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.021257996559143,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.9717886447906496,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.6136056184768677,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.3887033462524414,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.995355606079102,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.931600332260132,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.5673065185546875,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.102360248565674,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.601266860961914,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.583657145500183,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.8741472959518433,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.9143462181091307,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.835371017456055,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,6.207521438598633,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.877739429473877,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.9109983444213867,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.8721896409988403,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.9366552829742432,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,7.597582817077637,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.9304934740066528,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.6634103059768677,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.9618269205093384,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.4739364385604858,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,7.029666900634766,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.6224910020828247,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.6687612533569336,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.3652597069740295,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,3.6565120220184326,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.6888325214385986,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,3.075641632080078,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,3.7644741535186768,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,45.656009674072266,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,45.656009674072266,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.2033056020736694,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.662401795387268,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.5604993104934692,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.1154862642288208,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,5.541692733764648,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.9781007170677184,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.8274550437927248,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.670177340507507,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.375177025794983,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,5.850910186767578,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.0832865238189697,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.2156736850738523,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.8648252487182615,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,5.163785457611084,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.834267258644104,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.031942844390869,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.1896653175354004,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.0108983516693115,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,7.066773414611816,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.0428929328918457,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.9238523244857788,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.7565335035324097,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.9383238554000857,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,7.66160249710083,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.0491833686828613,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.6505860090255735,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.9243074655532837,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.5208317041397097,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,7.144908428192139,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.379847526550293,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.089905261993408,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.7251928448677063,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,5.194945812225342,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.7327699661254883,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.695941686630249,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,3.4287116527557373,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,47.05332946777344,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,47.05332946777344,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.2407923936843872,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.6927473545074463,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.7318323850631714,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.190308928489685,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,5.8556809425354,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.8919858932495115,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.2742811441421509,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.9385753870010376,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,5.104842185974121,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.9655739068984983,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.0066120624542236,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.9756040573120115,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.9992369413375857,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,7.94702672958374,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.11487078666687,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.6526762247085571,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.1309194564819336,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.5386366844177246,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,7.437103271484375,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.4658000469207764,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.444195032119751,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.0238641500473022,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,5.933859348297119,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.6758183240890503,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,3.028862476348877,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,3.704680919647217,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.2173280715942385,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.652017593383789,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.855275273323059,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.1147363185882568,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,5.839357376098633,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.9503026008605956,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.848843693733215,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.5724608898162842,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.3901506662368774,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,5.761757850646973,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.845667600631714,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.1347836256027222,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.927071452140808,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,4.907522678375244,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.5315049886703491,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.0075089931488037,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.1502621173858645,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.8842716217041016,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,6.573547840118408,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.8395546674728391,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.9653059244155884,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.924027681350708,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.9732394218444824,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,7.702127456665039,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.9805172681808472,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.67296302318573,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.1617445945739746,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.5519955158233645,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,7.367220401763916,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.008944034576416,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.15735125541687,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.7145328521728516,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,4.880828380584717,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.6430695652961731,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,3.1582744121551514,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,3.80134391784668,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,46.83370590209961,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,46.83370590209961,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.1345592737197876,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.583255648612976,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.6335119009017944,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.1103636026382446,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,5.461690425872803,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.8053016066551208,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.9200893640518188,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.3376573324203491,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.348793864250183,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,5.411842346191406,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.9566125869750977,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.113240361213684,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.8767914772033691,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,4.946644306182861,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.8934760093688965,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.028238534927368,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.1983528137207031,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.9578113555908203,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,7.077878475189209,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.8326170444488523,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.897018313407898,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.7616649866104126,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.969238519668579,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,7.460538864135742,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.9406431913375857,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.6033132076263428,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.8816169500350952,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.4423365592956543,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,6.867909908294678,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.0922510623931885,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.033876419067383,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.5158483982086182,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,4.6419758796691895,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.5478119254112244,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.2994508743286133,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.8472628593444824,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,44.71574401855469,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,44.71574401855469,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.0962412357330322,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.628245830535889,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.7374624013900757,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.4983385801315308,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,5.960288047790527,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.7674042582511902,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.751192569732666,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.297717809677124,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.3428380489349363,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,5.159152507781982,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.9717897176742551,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.1624611616134644,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.919682860374451,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,5.053933620452881,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.772527813911438,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.115556001663208,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.202867031097412,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.973276734352112,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,7.06422758102417,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.9092588424682615,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.7793563604354858,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.7592427730560305,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.015216112136841,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,7.463074207305908,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.9282002449035645,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.588914394378662,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.944769024848938,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.454102635383606,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,6.915986061096191,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.9363255500793457,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.7057920694351196,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.4406380355358124,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,4.0827555656433105,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.6316158175468445,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.7359957695007324,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,3.3676116466522217,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,45.0670280456543,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,45.0670280456543,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.1913381814956665,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.5975570678710938,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.6604431867599487,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.1978347301483154,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.6471734046936035,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.903018057346344,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.854670524597168,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.3918185234069824,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.3656049966812134,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.515111923217773,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.8690814971923828,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.336213231086731,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.9461338520050049,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.15142822265625,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.7102998495101929,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.0096614360809326,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.0630172491073608,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.83856201171875,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,6.621540546417236,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.796542048454285,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.7963671684265137,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.8035513162612915,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.9594199657440183,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,7.355880260467529,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.0576303005218506,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.7164714336395264,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.1408402919769287,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.446384072303772,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,7.361326217651367,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.0096938610076904,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.147675037384033,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.3409081995487213,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,4.498277187347412,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.5564028024673462,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,3.030182123184204,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,3.5865848064422607,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,45.73732376098633,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,45.73732376098633,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.3450956344604492,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.6008049249649048,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.4706188440322876,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.4117398262023926,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,5.828259468078613,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.7928116321563721,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.868483543395996,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.3419190645217896,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.3401951789855957,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,5.343409538269043,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.8533772230148315,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.9579780101776124,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.9050922393798828,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,4.716447353363037,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.6544755697250366,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.8062976598739624,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.8848536014556885,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.879658579826355,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,6.225285530090332,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.8757373094558716,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.9161797761917112,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.5812803506851196,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.8839675188064575,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,7.25716495513916,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.9959813356399536,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.6679482460021973,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.1032907962799072,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.402276635169983,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,7.169497013092041,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.662509799003601,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.937540054321289,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.5951087474822998,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,4.1951584815979,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.5778624415397644,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.444248914718628,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,3.022111177444458,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,43.75733184814453,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,43.75733184814453,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.2505682706832886,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.5601060390472412,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.5297363996505735,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.1019306182861328,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,5.442341327667236,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.847537636756897,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.7040820121765137,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.3592617511749268,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.1725132465362549,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,5.083394527435303,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.008523941040039,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.953096568584442,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.9097607135772705,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,4.8713812828063965,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.1045300960540771,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.6954280138015747,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.7981691956520081,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.9186478853225708,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,5.516775131225586,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.9235039949417112,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.8197007179260256,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.7474652528762815,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.912183403968811,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,7.402853488922119,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.6011223793029783,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.783166527748108,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.311124801635742,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.4400941133499146,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,7.135508060455322,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.4384706020355225,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.878032088279724,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.3799639642238617,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,3.69646668434143,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.5614835023880005,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,3.090248107910156,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,3.6517317295074463,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,42.80045318603515,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,42.80045318603515,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.135511875152588,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.5679376125335691,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.636318922042847,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.3128739595413208,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.652642250061035,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.7068069577217102,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.6022590398788452,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.3254294395446775,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.3316593170166016,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,4.966155052185059,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.9323086738586424,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.0612049102783203,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.941875696182251,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,4.935389041900635,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.7074556350708008,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.899356245994568,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.9523715972900392,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.9745078086853027,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,6.53369140625,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.7623330354690552,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.865687608718872,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.7841038703918457,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.941914677619934,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,7.354039192199707,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.9783165454864504,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.880443334579468,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.0196471214294434,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.4613564014434814,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,7.339763164520264,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.6221497058868408,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.5144628286361694,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.3998411893844604,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,3.5364537239074707,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.5666080713272095,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.695768117904663,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,3.262376308441162,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,43.580509185791016,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,43.580509185791016,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.34420645236969,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.7393617630004885,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.8626487255096436,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.2177956104278564,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,6.164012432098389,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.9285287857055664,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.7533413171768188,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.5744034051895142,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.479004979133606,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,5.735278606414795,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.7905142307281494,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.2557995319366455,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.9134221076965332,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,4.959735870361328,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.7314709424972534,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.8583208322525024,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.998727023601532,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.9048292636871336,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,6.493348121643066,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.841529369354248,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.8304561376571655,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.639771819114685,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.9720683097839355,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,7.283825397491455,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.079493999481201,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.6848173141479492,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.018557548522949,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.4407237768173218,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,7.223592758178711,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.7210752964019775,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.0703864097595215,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.4251084923744201,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,4.216569900512695,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.6021360754966736,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.443739891052246,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,3.0458760261535645,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,45.12223815917969,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,45.12223815917969,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.2059011459350586,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.7095047235488892,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.6444787979125977,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.9537757635116576,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,5.513660430908203,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.8862293362617493,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.7560009956359863,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.347492218017578,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.3639202117919922,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,5.35364294052124,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.9586797952651975,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.0782126188278198,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.7977279424667358,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,4.834619998931885,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.4818800687789917,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.73484468460083,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.820677638053894,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.9465105533599856,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,5.983912944793701,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.8699284791946411,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.9222806692123413,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.8515509366989136,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.945534348487854,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,7.58929443359375,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.990977883338928,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.1228582859039307,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.0096356868743896,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.4072129726409912,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,7.530684947967529,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.446152925491333,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.496180534362793,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.6478567123413086,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,3.5901901721954346,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.6003434658050537,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.5432889461517334,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,3.143632173538208,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,43.53963851928711,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,43.53963851928711,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.0707342624664309,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.6007683277130127,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.4798696041107178,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.249783992767334,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,5.401156425476074,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.8056139349937439,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.9886621236801147,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.4604390859603882,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.376611828804016,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,5.631327152252197,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.8078683614730835,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.9432622790336608,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.987735152244568,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,4.738865852355957,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.6757971048355105,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.8413426876068115,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.1124351024627686,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.948585629463196,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,6.578160762786865,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.8296542167663576,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.936042308807373,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.7497555017471311,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.9743218421936035,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,7.489773750305176,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.04111909866333,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.8725677728652952,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.0189530849456787,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.5130367279052734,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,7.445676803588867,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.8717808723449707,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.0801939964294434,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.5144811272621155,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,4.466455936431885,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.5919970870018005,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.2849950790405273,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.8769922256469727,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,44.62841033935547,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,44.62841033935547,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.0941187143325806,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.5795947313308716,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.6891087293624878,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.1071335077285769,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,5.4699554443359375,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.7780743837356567,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.919408679008484,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.486740231513977,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.3682059049606323,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,5.55242919921875,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.8104802370071411,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.257514238357544,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.025449275970459,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,5.093443870544434,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.785183072090149,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.028613567352295,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.1929467916488647,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.9288952350616455,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,6.935638427734375,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.8722213506698608,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.910927414894104,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.7670868635177612,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.0183393955230713,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,7.568574905395508,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.0351970195770264,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.7315539121627808,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.047665596008301,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.5345379114151,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,7.348954200744629,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.9821609258651731,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.040534496307373,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.6035829782485962,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,4.626278400421143,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.6155312657356262,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.596759080886841,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,3.2122902870178223,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,45.80756378173828,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,45.80756378173828,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.18647301197052,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.6081676483154297,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.6970537900924685,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.0805245637893677,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,5.572218894958496,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.8872924447059631,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.9519705772399905,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.4756486415863037,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.3872528076171875,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,5.702164649963379,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.8417515754699707,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.453219294548035,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.0207760334014893,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,5.315746784210205,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.564731240272522,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.8484678268432615,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.9884465336799622,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.9551421403884888,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,6.35678768157959,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.7765721082687378,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.9030840396881104,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.828277826309204,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.9857054948806765,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,7.493639469146728,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.9833984375,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.6582810878753662,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.078312635421753,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.4534584283828735,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,7.173450469970703,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.8293386697769165,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.1207005977630615,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.6682567000389099,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,4.618295669555664,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.5632121562957764,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.891392230987549,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,3.454604387283325,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,45.68690872192383,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,45.68690872192383,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.2426841259002686,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.6858031749725342,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.7713032960891724,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.2851872444152832,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.984977722167969,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.959971010684967,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.8245034217834473,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.4404175281524658,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.4488669633865356,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.6737589836120605,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.0224058628082275,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.4084755182266235,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.046476125717163,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.477357387542725,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.6596015691757202,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.914646029472351,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.05543315410614,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.897118091583252,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,6.526798725128174,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.9317365884780884,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.916039228439331,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.7177637815475464,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.9620587825775144,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,7.52759838104248,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.0161349773406982,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.7456234693527222,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.00046706199646,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.438390851020813,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,7.200616359710693,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.9751352071762085,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.9347606897354128,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.5686208605766296,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,4.478516578674316,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.6903119683265686,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,3.012424945831299,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,3.702736854553222,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,46.57236099243164,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,46.57236099243164,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.4133223295211792,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.7079858779907229,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.6758828163146973,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.1517783403396606,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,5.94896936416626,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.009375810623169,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.8205469846725464,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.4011597633361816,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.4446063041687012,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,5.675688743591309,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.8806185722351072,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.6934446096420288,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.966546893119812,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,5.540610313415527,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.6918869018554688,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.0370962619781494,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.2523424625396729,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.6199747323989868,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,6.6013007164001465,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.9327151775360107,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.8466740846633911,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.886136770248413,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.960047721862793,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,7.625574111938477,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.066226005554199,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.6184698343276978,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.841640830039978,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.4405391216278076,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,6.966876029968262,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.864985942840576,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.839779496192932,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.684287965297699,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,4.3890533447265625,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.6429759860038757,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.6796517372131348,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,3.3226277828216553,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,46.070701599121094,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,46.070701599121094,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.1319149732589722,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.6841131448745728,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.6365866661071775,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.1123796701431274,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,5.5649943351745605,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.917339026927948,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.8937939405441284,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.4737814664840698,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.4218415021896362,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,5.706756114959717,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.917884826660156,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.5785472393035889,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.0701863765716553,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,5.5666184425354,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.762488842010498,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.9787087440490725,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.0808123350143433,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.972056269645691,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,6.794066429138184,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.9858883619308472,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.873881220817566,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.7613662481307983,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.027888536453247,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,7.649024486541748,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.10476016998291,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.8992204666137695,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.8805359601974487,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.3951903581619265,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,7.279706954956055,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.026334047317505,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.8888260126113892,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.8432695865631104,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,4.758429527282715,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.6520220041275024,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.3012497425079346,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.9532716274261475,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,46.27286911010742,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,46.27286911010742,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.1293563842773438,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.6691139936447144,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.753175973892212,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.0649991035461426,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,5.616645336151123,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.9091972708702089,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.766080617904663,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.4558954238891602,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.3939533233642578,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,5.5251264572143555,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.065640687942505,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.4445360898971558,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.9954469203948977,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,5.505623817443848,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.0105884075164795,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.131946325302124,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.1798582077026367,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.0471465587615967,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,7.369539260864258,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.816271185874939,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.7251205444335938,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.6778368949890137,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.975424885749817,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,7.194653511047363,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.019310712814331,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.635140299797058,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.9915412664413452,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.4157224893569946,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,7.0617146492004395,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.3342573642730713,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.9348373413085935,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.4928269386291504,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,4.761921405792236,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.5474765300750732,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.5007317066192627,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,3.048208236694336,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,46.08343124389648,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,46.08343124389648,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.8865971565246582,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.5140197277069092,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.6609872579574585,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.7906202673912048,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,4.852224349975586,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.808677077293396,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.8322376012802124,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.4822990894317627,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.276579737663269,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.39979362487793,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.7741823196411133,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.6897026300430298,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.9203073978424072,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,4.38419246673584,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.7960649728775024,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.0298635959625244,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.0797337293624878,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.850358486175537,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,6.756020545959473,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.758283019065857,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.874080777168274,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.8355422019958496,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.9032652378082275,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,7.371171474456787,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.051154375076294,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.2758804559707642,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.1586360931396484,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.515573501586914,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,7.00124454498291,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.0959632396698,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.912278175354004,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.7802368402481079,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,4.788478374481201,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.5595753192901611,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.0923426151275635,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.6519179344177246,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,43.20504379272461,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,43.20504379272461,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.2200934886932373,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.5195823907852173,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.627999186515808,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.7650187611579895,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,5.132693767547607,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.0486527681350708,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.7939826250076294,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.4229844808578491,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.3879613876342771,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,5.653581142425537,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.953930377960205,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.7966452836990356,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.8012593984603882,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,4.551835060119629,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.5121248960494995,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.8746870756149292,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.0824459791183472,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.040755271911621,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,6.510013103485107,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.8941316604614256,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.844665050506592,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.8569438457489016,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.8991671800613403,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,7.494907855987549,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.9542200565338137,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.9218350648880005,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.3035500049591064,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.4972517490386963,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,7.676856994628906,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.8523774147033691,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.9025975465774536,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.3486371040344238,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,4.103611946105957,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.7650860548019409,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,3.4725728034973145,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,4.237658977508545,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,45.36116027832031,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,45.36116027832031,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.9945255517959596,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.681132197380066,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.7004860639572144,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.8952844738960266,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,5.271428108215332,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.8073028326034546,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.5449386835098269,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.2955477237701416,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.4013657569885254,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,5.049155235290527,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.933223009109497,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.26496684551239,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.7903813123703003,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,4.9885711669921875,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.671475529670715,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.955532431602478,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.0167200565338137,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.9972645044326784,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,6.640992641448975,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.7358262538909912,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.7588212490081787,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.5788494348526,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.942298173904419,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,7.0157952308654785,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.985695004463196,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.642614245414734,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.8880671262741089,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.505986213684082,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,7.02236270904541,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.056683301925659,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.902071833610535,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.7227636575698853,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,4.681519031524658,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.5362768173217773,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.9290271997451784,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.465304136276245,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,43.135128021240234,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,43.135128021240234,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.9264780282974244,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.6114211082458496,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.5323333740234375,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.2958694696426392,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,5.3661017417907715,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.7198619842529297,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.7017971277236938,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.1759364604949951,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.2213175296783447,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,4.818912982940674,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.8860808610916135,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.2434381246566772,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.8954347372055056,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,5.024953842163086,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.641753077507019,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.7482008934020996,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.031748652458191,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.6575888395309448,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,6.079291343688965,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.7001831531524658,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.868308424949646,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.6176401376724243,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.861495852470398,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,7.0476274490356445,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.0961928367614746,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.4364171028137207,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.6587319374084473,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.5276705026626587,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,6.719012260437012,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.8517271280288696,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.9496636390686035,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.5421432852745056,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,4.343533992767334,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.5088368654251099,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.424079656600952,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.932916522026062,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,41.33235168457031,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,41.33235168457031,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.9354406595230104,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.4214004278182983,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.4419127702713013,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.0724425315856934,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,4.871196269989014,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.7188593745231628,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.6732454299926758,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.2004046440124512,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.240691900253296,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,4.8332014083862305,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.6107547283172607,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.0552312135696411,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.852657914161682,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,4.518643856048584,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.5326619148254397,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.7651578187942505,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.0233919620513916,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.9127665758132937,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,6.233978271484375,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.7677041292190552,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.7089532613754272,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.5394175052642822,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.8819465637207031,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,6.898021697998047,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.876949906349182,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.666120529174805,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.9476089477539065,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.444894552230835,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,6.935574054718018,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.769579529762268,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.7247133255004885,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.5239534378051758,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,4.018246173858643,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.5764392018318176,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.157045841217041,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.733484983444214,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,41.0423469543457,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,41.0423469543457,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.8516820073127747,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.3575338125228882,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.564887523651123,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.0299700498580933,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,4.804073333740234,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.7358666658401489,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.581204533576965,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.2177815437316897,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.3992953300476074,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,4.93414831161499,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.0008296966552734,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.9376583695411682,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.015164375305176,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,4.953652381896973,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.651766061782837,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.954651117324829,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.0714259147644043,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.8823988437652588,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,6.56024169921875,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.6845009326934814,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.8911267518997192,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.6690843105316162,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.8923085927963257,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,7.137020587921143,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.1102757453918457,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.605818748474121,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.7423712015151978,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.489986538887024,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,6.948452472686768,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.0510754585266113,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.044483423233032,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.8377520442008972,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,4.9333109855651855,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.5224448442459106,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.6348029375076294,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.15724778175354,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,42.42814636230469,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,42.42814636230469,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.8481445908546448,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.3173418045043943,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.458903431892395,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.7848700881004333,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,4.409259796142578,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.7503916025161743,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.5227395296096802,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.2100824117660522,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.109846115112305,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,4.593059539794922,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.8921968936920168,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.7528849840164185,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.0594799518585205,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,4.704561710357666,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.5335854291915894,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.9297003746032717,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.1497657299041748,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.87390661239624,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,6.486958026885986,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.6673346757888794,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.958390951156616,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.7544476985931396,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.9077234268188477,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,7.287897109985352,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.9692938327789309,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.12711501121521,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.998069167137146,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.3894716501235962,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,7.483949661254883,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.928189754486084,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.9049367904663088,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.595974862575531,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,4.429101467132568,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.5379098653793335,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.238468647003174,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.776378631591797,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,42.171165466308594,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,42.171165466308594,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.9556463956832886,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.609267234802246,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.6341692209243774,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.189633846282959,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,5.388716697692871,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.8004444241523743,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.7418904304504397,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.3749982118606567,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.4450173377990725,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,5.3623504638671875,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.0326719284057617,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.0020986795425415,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.9817092418670657,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,5.016479969024658,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.6935361623764038,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.10732102394104,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.1685163974761963,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.9431211948394775,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,6.912494659423828,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.86391282081604,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.9423049688339231,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.7691214084625244,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.951486349105835,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,7.526825904846191,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.09755539894104,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.9417333602905271,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.107623338699341,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.52825129032135,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,7.675163269042969,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.116180181503296,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.110893726348877,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.6443343758583069,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,4.871408462524414,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.5327765345573425,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.135627031326294,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.668403387069702,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,45.421844482421875,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,45.421844482421875,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.8508172035217285,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.4191778898239136,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.3768619298934937,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.4062615633010864,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,5.053118705749512,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.7535991668701172,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.4284552335739136,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.2175014019012451,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.236647367477417,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,4.636203289031982,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.7178986072540283,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.861128032207489,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.9028370380401611,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,4.481863498687744,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.5350139141082764,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.000696182250977,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.063770055770874,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.890364646911621,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,6.489844799041748,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.8265773057937624,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.905697464942932,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.7478095293045044,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.893518328666687,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,7.373602390289307,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.94719660282135,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.5702804327011108,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.9951778650283811,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.359204888343811,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,6.871859550476074,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.8125710487365725,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.9065437316894531,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.3528739809989929,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,4.071988582611084,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.5653209686279297,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.0607247352600098,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.6260457038879395,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,41.60452651977539,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,41.60452651977539,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.1880850791931152,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.6214337348937988,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.704999327659607,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.4271284341812134,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,5.941646575927734,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.7936261296272278,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.6305452585220337,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.4188361167907717,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.4147907495498655,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,5.257798194885254,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8737826347351072,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.1030387878417969,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.9780911207199097,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,4.9549126625061035,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.467251181602478,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8499269485473633,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.8418140411376953,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.874112010002136,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,6.033104419708252,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8499163389205933,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8522329330444336,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.681649684906006,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8689504861831665,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,7.252749443054199,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.0151522159576416,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.6166973114013672,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8327019214630127,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.2771282196044922,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,6.741679668426514,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.609443187713623,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.925216794013977,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.4441156685352325,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,3.9787755012512207,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.596936821937561,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.4645328521728516,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,3.061469554901123,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,43.222137451171875,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,43.222137451171875,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.9891728162765504,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.5155949592590332,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.572126865386963,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.058287262916565,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,5.135181903839111,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.8907008171081543,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.5968689918518066,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.3749240636825562,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.3326044082641602,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,5.195098400115967,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.019394874572754,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.9119168519973756,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.9832024574279783,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,4.914514064788818,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.634846329689026,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.993446946144104,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.992885947227478,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.7317311763763428,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,6.35291051864624,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.649828553199768,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.9110296964645384,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.7038921117782593,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.874446153640747,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,7.139196395874023,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.866133689880371,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.6325640678405762,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.8242045640945437,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.398231029510498,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,6.721133232116699,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.8098968267440796,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.9967774152755735,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.3897906541824341,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,4.196465015411377,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.5927659273147583,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.7000021934509277,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,3.2927680015563965,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,42.947265625,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,42.947265625,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.0370265245437622,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.5434207916259766,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.5664405822753906,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.8370561599731445,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,4.983943939208984,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.8104782104492188,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.6152231693267822,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.3496702909469604,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.329305648803711,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,5.104677200317383,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.9409633874893188,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.2326325178146362,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.808091640472412,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,4.981687545776367,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.3885447978973389,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.7612706422805786,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.8126529455184937,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.850146532058716,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,5.812614917755127,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.8565912246704104,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.9552289247512815,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.6676431894302368,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.8638947010040283,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,7.343358039855957,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.8950241804122925,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.7009044885635376,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.9294146299362185,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.4496954679489136,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,6.975039005279541,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.6691052913665771,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.9721550941467283,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.4156164228916168,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,4.0568766593933105,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.5816313028335571,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.486945867538452,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,3.0685770511627197,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,42.32677459716797,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,42.32677459716797,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.272565484046936,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.6418794393539429,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.6146847009658811,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.0109277963638306,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,5.540057182312012,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.9175471067428588,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.7823400497436523,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.5034823417663574,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.325257420539856,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,5.528626918792725,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.9266455173492432,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.485684156417847,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.9144572019577024,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,5.326786994934082,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.727049469947815,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.9928884506225584,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.0929418802261353,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.870816707611084,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,6.683696269989014,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.8657323122024536,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.858538031578064,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.829748511314392,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.8373150825500488,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,7.391334056854248,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.0785508155822754,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.241270661354065,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.8892529010772705,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.3715075254440308,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,6.5805816650390625,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.00545883178711,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.942196488380432,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.4096820652484894,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,4.357337474822998,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.6455602645874023,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.533628225326538,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,3.1791884899139404,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,44.587608337402344,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,44.587608337402344,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.0755555629730225,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.776857614517212,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.5598478317260742,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.4240413904190063,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,5.836302280426025,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.8751250505447388,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.495595932006836,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.4528396129608154,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.2130725383758545,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,5.036633014678955,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.0671777725219727,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.2181951999664309,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.8546465635299685,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,5.140019416809082,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.4752932786941528,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.9046483039855957,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.9830239415168762,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.8846046924591064,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,6.247570514678955,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.7872185707092283,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.6997239589691162,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.593243956565857,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.8331358432769775,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,6.913322448730469,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.856034755706787,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.5170704126358032,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.002746343612671,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.4511830806732178,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,6.8270344734191895,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.5175094604492188,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.8702632188796997,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.4598990976810455,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,3.8476717472076416,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.6018744111061096,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.4277334213256836,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,3.0296077728271484,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,42.8781623840332,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,42.8781623840332,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.3473552465438845,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.4514607191085815,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.641700267791748,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.4174529314041138,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,5.857969284057617,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.8806523680686951,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.7580806016921997,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.4710032939910889,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.2678580284118652,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,5.377594470977783,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.9922839403152464,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.2163976430892944,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.0119595527648926,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,5.220641136169434,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.486572504043579,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.907912850379944,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.0798569917678833,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.824493646621704,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,6.298835754394531,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.7403311729431152,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.9482667446136477,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.8148959875106812,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.916442394256592,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,7.419936180114746,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.8436014652252195,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.3879512548446655,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.015155076980591,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.46934974193573,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,6.716057777404785,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.7410027980804443,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.8589515686035156,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.4329760372638702,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,4.032930374145508,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.5833336114883423,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.897061586380005,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,3.4803953170776367,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,44.40435791015625,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,44.40435791015625,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.8745415806770325,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.4950100183486938,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.4491527080535889,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.0628403425216677,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,4.881544589996338,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.708419680595398,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.6011850833892822,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.2362183332443235,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.2449380159378052,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,4.7907609939575195,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.9208009243011477,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.8239803314208984,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.011350154876709,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,4.756131649017334,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.8294354677200315,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.0308997631073,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.4055984020233154,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.9784373044967651,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,7.244370937347412,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.824101805686951,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.9524818658828735,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.7590978145599363,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.9746559858322144,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,7.510337352752685,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.025675058364868,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.4869403839111328,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.020097255706787,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.480043888092041,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,7.012756824493408,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.511867046356201,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.078047037124634,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.3473767340183258,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,4.937291145324707,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.5479514002799988,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.902495265007019,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.450446605682373,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,43.583641052246094,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,43.583641052246094,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.1519819498062134,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.6194889545440674,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.481113076210022,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.024606704711914,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,5.277190685272217,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.7806740403175354,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.8366618156433103,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.4295388460159302,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.1852757930755615,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,5.232150554656982,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.7170380353927612,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.257361888885498,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.8900901079177856,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,4.864490032196045,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.6869014501571655,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.9113584756851196,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.2653303146362305,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.9531687498092651,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,6.81675910949707,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.780234456062317,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.869094729423523,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.8609249591827393,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.926996111869812,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,7.437250137329102,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.8636314868927,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.197360873222351,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.0734617710113525,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.4424728155136108,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,6.576927185058594,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.9108352661132812,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.9281631708145144,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.3769069015979767,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,4.21590518951416,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.608484148979187,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.4683871269226074,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,3.076871156692505,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,43.49754333496094,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,43.49754333496094,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.1010801792144775,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.5116597414016724,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.5912412405014038,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.1109081506729126,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,5.314889430999756,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.7985444664955139,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.5305726528167725,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.2747440338134766,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.2717149257659912,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,4.875576019287109,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.9196159839630127,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.078364372253418,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.9860069751739504,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,4.983987331390381,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.506572961807251,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.9083776473999023,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.0971596240997314,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.7706042528152466,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,6.282714366912842,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.877629280090332,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.901553750038147,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.7271102666854858,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.8673126697540283,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,7.373606204986572,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.8568780422210691,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.6032010316848757,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.9980944395065308,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.348375678062439,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,6.806549072265625,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.8477989435195925,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.9892730712890625,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.4241276085376739,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,4.261199474334717,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.5774490237236023,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.611953020095825,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,3.1894021034240723,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,43.08792495727539,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,43.08792495727539,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.1106970310211182,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.6588668823242188,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.626686930656433,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.7540430426597595,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,5.150293827056885,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.8798547387123108,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.9147522449493408,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.403255820274353,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.4284154176712036,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,5.626278400421143,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.005699396133423,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.2286962270736694,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.9685767889022827,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,5.202972412109375,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.5260858535766602,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.847182035446167,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.1612145900726318,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.7166340351104736,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,6.2511162757873535,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.805631160736084,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.827354431152344,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.7574397325515747,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.9707289934158323,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,7.361154079437256,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.9186557531356812,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.6027923822402954,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.314362049102783,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.454825758934021,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,7.29063606262207,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.7826818227767944,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.0662319660186768,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.368997186422348,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,4.2179107666015625,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.5552017688751221,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.6394481658935547,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,3.1946499347686768,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,44.295013427734375,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,44.295013427734375,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.0981061458587646,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.3871500492095947,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.400060534477234,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.9504477977752686,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,4.835764408111572,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.771683394908905,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.7623307704925537,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.4022942781448364,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.292245626449585,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,5.2285542488098145,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.963754653930664,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.889514148235321,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.8036234378814695,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,4.6568922996521,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.3010848760604858,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.7727739810943604,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.9894294738769532,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.8829716444015503,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,5.94625997543335,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.800515055656433,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.8477705717086792,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.6624441146850586,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.8326376676559448,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,7.143367290496826,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.7923423051834106,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.574057936668396,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.2484889030456543,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.316120147705078,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,6.931009292602539,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.5883041620254517,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.7306755781173706,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.3533783257007599,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,3.67235803604126,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.6175689101219177,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,3.369226455688477,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,3.986795425415039,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,42.4010009765625,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,42.4010009765625,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.1898497343063354,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.529468297958374,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.5887200832366943,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.8723093271255493,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,5.180347442626953,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.7322626113891602,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.7466349601745603,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.2774657011032104,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.3537369966506958,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,5.110100269317627,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.0024304389953613,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.8983522057533264,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.811123728752136,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,4.711906433105469,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.7072386741638184,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.9895968437194824,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.2582972049713137,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.9496536254882812,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,6.904786586761475,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.819232940673828,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.761863112449646,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.6698410511016846,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.886977195739746,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,7.137914180755615,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.8989633321762085,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.673351764678955,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.05666446685791,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.4955501556396484,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,7.124529838562012,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.124117374420166,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.014533758163452,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.4896675050258636,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,4.628318786621094,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.5617533922195435,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.2320237159729004,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.7937769889831543,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,43.591678619384766,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,43.591678619384766,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.8850395083427429,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.448820948600769,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.4544326066970823,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.1672651767730713,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,4.9555583000183105,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.7121852040290833,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.5046316385269165,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.1785657405853271,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.4078572988510132,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,4.803239822387695,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.7993052005767822,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.8208959698677063,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.694572687149048,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,4.314774036407471,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.831869125366211,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.076283693313598,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.30135977268219,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.88107168674469,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,7.0905842781066895,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.7075204849243164,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.8774820566177368,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.7467045783996582,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.8789987564086912,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,7.210705757141113,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.085312843322754,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.6516598463058472,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.669190764427185,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.4163377285003662,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,6.822501182556152,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.156592607498169,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.897678017616272,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.748979389667511,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,4.803250312805176,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.5402593016624451,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.5604240894317627,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.1006834506988525,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,42.101295471191406,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,42.101295471191406,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.098166823387146,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.5688399076461792,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.4444853067398071,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.0985301733016968,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,5.21002197265625,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.7590242028236389,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.9284369945526123,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.4784070253372192,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.329543948173523,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,5.495412349700928,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.9918603897094729,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.1266019344329834,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.077016830444336,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,5.195478916168213,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.921513557434082,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.188427209854126,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.387539267539978,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.1117398738861084,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,7.609220027923584,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.894938588142395,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.9963858127593992,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.8820207118988037,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.968868374824524,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,7.742213249206543,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.046440839767456,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.7493022680282593,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.086092233657837,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.4276225566864014,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,7.309458255767822,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.4477996826171875,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.956356644630432,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.0048691034317017,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,5.4090256690979,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.5382784605026245,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.541053295135498,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,3.079331874847412,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,47.05016326904297,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,47.05016326904297,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.8491388559341431,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.4023802280426023,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.169141411781311,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.053260087966919,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,4.4739203453063965,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.7701427340507507,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.410670518875122,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.1594630479812622,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.3116201162338257,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,4.6518964767456055,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.986999750137329,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.815778911113739,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.9453446865081787,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,4.7481231689453125,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.6396706104278564,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.0118632316589355,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.2139673233032229,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.972804069519043,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,6.838305473327637,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.8824174404144287,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.9043596982955933,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.9332654476165771,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.0522892475128174,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,7.772331714630127,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.852576732635498,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.6685820817947388,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.035360813140869,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.505468249320984,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,7.06198787689209,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.137176275253296,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.0656638145446777,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.6264845728874207,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,4.829324722290039,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.5847145915031433,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.0981898307800293,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.6829042434692383,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,43.05879592895508,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,43.05879592895508,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.0115716457366943,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.364543318748474,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.1732823848724363,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.9043781161308287,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,4.453775882720947,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.8144700527191162,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.6738709211349487,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.2300420999526978,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.298841118812561,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,5.017224311828613,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.9482299089431765,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.9376652836799622,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.8122748136520384,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,4.698170185089111,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.774983286857605,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.0435569286346436,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.2251299619674685,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.9667822122573853,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,7.0104522705078125,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.7589664459228516,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.8830097913742063,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.8404475450515747,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.998107433319092,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,7.480531215667725,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.092491865158081,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.5234785079956057,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.2396981716156006,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.4679033756256104,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,7.323572158813477,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.086456298828125,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.2037594318389893,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.4598757028579712,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,5.750091552734375,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.5647494792938232,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.3516931533813477,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.916442632675171,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,44.65026092529297,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,44.65026092529297,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.9957128763198853,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.589774489402771,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.5686511993408203,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.2745002508163452,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,5.428638935089111,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.1317498683929443,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.9068002700805664,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.9500646591186523,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,4.988615036010742,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.84846031665802,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.8630812168121336,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.8529057502746584,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.9889541864395144,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,7.553401470184326,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.203097105026245,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.7034324407577517,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.952775239944458,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.4996562004089355,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,7.35896110534668,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.7729527950286865,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.1372838020324707,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.8305208683013916,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,6.740757465362549,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.5992723703384399,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.1938788890838623,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.793151378631592,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.7743093371391296,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.3413540124893188,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.28473699092865,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.1594200134277344,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,4.559820652008057,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.7489911317825317,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.677539944648743,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.3201032876968384,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.400601506233215,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,5.147235870361328,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.9907065629959104,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.8010801672935486,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.928456425666809,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,4.720242977142334,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.7256948947906494,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.055086612701416,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.2183401584625244,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.9337599277496336,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,6.932881832122803,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.7832064628601074,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.8562780618667605,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.8124548196792605,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.8792399168014529,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,7.331179618835449,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.018920421600342,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.7000579833984375,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.330198287963867,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.4430595636367798,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,7.492236137390137,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.254305124282837,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.1886353492736816,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.2261648178100586,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,5.669105529785156,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.5698753595352173,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.007701873779297,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.5775773525238037,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,44.43027877807617,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,44.43027877807617,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.9561805129051208,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.5199860334396362,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.4168760776519775,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.7738938331604004,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,4.66693639755249,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.8073334693908691,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.4614273309707642,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.2576311826705933,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.3397475481033323,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,4.8661394119262695,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.9581722021102903,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.8529938459396362,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.8418774604797363,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,4.653043270111084,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.662206768989563,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.944928526878357,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.223615646362305,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.515610694885254,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,6.3463616371154785,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.8408052921295168,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.931282877922058,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.869754433631897,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.9553256034851072,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,7.59716796875,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.9917811155319216,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.2759665250778198,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.131561040878296,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.4826624393463137,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,6.8819708824157715,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.3296825885772705,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.1587886810302734,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.5016879439353943,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,4.990159034729004,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.5573914647102356,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.2123353481292725,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.7697267532348633,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,42.771507263183594,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,42.771507263183594,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.0040866136550903,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.4812527894973757,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.4190964698791504,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.1305309534072876,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,5.034966945648193,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.851936936378479,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.7852977514266968,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.421942949295044,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.470152735710144,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,5.529330253601074,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.148299217224121,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.9411514401435852,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.721607685089111,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,4.811058044433594,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.8567290306091309,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.0177714824676514,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.1728869676589966,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.9371310472488403,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,6.984518527984619,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.8532716035842896,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.9061304330825808,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.783750057220459,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.015781879425049,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,7.558934211730957,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.072266101837158,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.678522706031799,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.1140849590301514,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.5392227172851562,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,7.404096603393555,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.251465320587158,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.2106618881225586,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.367801070213318,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,5.829928398132324,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.567249059677124,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.3406944274902344,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.9079434871673584,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,46.06077575683594,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,46.06077575683594,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.8520482182502747,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.3454738855361938,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.4051882028579712,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.9168039560317992,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,4.519514083862305,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.6687828898429871,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.4713348150253296,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.1603745222091677,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.247919678688049,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,4.548411846160889,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.0166327953338623,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.0835751295089722,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.7364659309387207,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,4.836673736572266,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.569433093070984,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.8043804168701172,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.0500447750091553,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.7886271476745603,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,6.212485313415527,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.7581764459609983,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.730622410774231,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.7843176126480105,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.008874893188477,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,7.281991481781006,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.033205509185791,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.364121913909912,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.0769219398498535,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.4777255058288574,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,6.951974868774414,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.1030921936035156,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.1551122665405273,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.3784809112548828,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,5.636685371398926,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.5175735950469971,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.550171971321106,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.0677454471588135,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,42.05548095703125,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,42.05548095703125,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.9008401036262512,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.3669066429138184,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.3174669742584229,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.3140201568603516,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,4.899233818054199,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.7963410019874573,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.5173360109329224,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.3453956842422483,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.363627791404724,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,5.022700786590576,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.0198006629943848,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.9720029830932616,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.8411873579025269,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,4.832991123199463,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.6178044080734253,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.015885829925537,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.1968895196914673,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.9647780656814575,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,6.795357704162598,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.7668792009353638,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.9224227666854856,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.8369970321655271,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.915251851081848,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,7.441550731658936,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.0171899795532227,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.6497119665145874,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.885292649269104,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.4808671474456787,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,7.033061504364014,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.0682179927825928,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.1278672218322754,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.8194745779037476,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,5.015559673309326,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.5842069387435913,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.7490127086639404,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.333219528198242,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,43.37367630004883,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,43.37367630004883,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.8910101056098938,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.374012470245361,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.452440857887268,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.0815526247024536,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,4.799015998840332,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.7162833213806152,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.4636040925979614,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.1960889101028442,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.2832365036010742,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,4.659213066101074,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.993003487586975,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.049773335456848,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.7974292039871216,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,4.840205669403076,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.5815708637237549,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.8554974794387815,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.0690579414367676,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.792820692062378,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,6.298946857452393,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.8943971395492551,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.9044564962387085,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.675307273864746,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.925398826599121,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,7.39955997467041,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.0461525917053223,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.6429283618927002,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.145336866378784,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.4380697011947632,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,7.272487640380859,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.9973490238189695,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.9919875860214231,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.5884981155395508,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,4.577834606170654,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.6490269899368286,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.7498886585235596,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.3989157676696777,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,42.24617767333984,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,42.24617767333984,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.0808203220367432,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.4769099950790403,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.6165895462036133,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.227863073348999,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,5.4021830558776855,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.9065757393836976,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.576618790626526,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.2488620281219482,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.3362330198287964,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,5.068289756774902,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.082082509994507,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.2492985725402832,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.7983461618423462,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,5.129727363586426,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.616432785987854,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.9810518026351929,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.1390527486801147,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.9891318082809448,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,6.7256693840026855,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.8516087532043457,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.9089086055755615,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.773859620094299,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.9892092943191528,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,7.523586273193359,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.0436043739318848,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.4580332040786743,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.8422372341156008,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.4470906257629397,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,6.790965557098389,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.1871612071990967,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.214056968688965,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.6931371092796326,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,5.09435510635376,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.6487632393836975,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.425325393676758,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,3.0740888118743896,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,44.80886459350586,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2018,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,44.80886459350586,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.7362544536590576,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.4875388145446775,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.5802466869354248,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.2346962690353394,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.038736343383789,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.7859320640563965,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.6179265975952148,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.2804800271987915,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.302383303642273,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,4.986721992492676,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.771095871925354,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.8414039015769958,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.961866021156311,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,4.574366092681885,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.4806712865829468,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.830734133720398,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.8714869022369385,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.9437981843948364,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,6.12669038772583,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.766487717628479,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.801255226135254,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.6862058639526367,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.877737283706665,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,7.131686210632324,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.8729743957519531,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.7075344324111938,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.0598886013031006,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.4581940174102783,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,7.098591327667236,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.8270735740661621,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.5019378662109375,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.3888904154300689,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.7179019451141357,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.3676276803016662,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.0155043601989746,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.475195050239563,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,3.8583269119262695,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,41.53302001953125,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,41.53302001953125,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,43.52419662475586,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.78658527135849,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.5581841468811035,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.571871042251587,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.3152453899383545,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,5.23188591003418,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.9289273619651794,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.6967781782150269,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.4943029880523682,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.3001888990402222,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,5.420197486877441,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.751546859741211,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.967149019241333,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.0182456970214844,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,4.736941337585449,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.554577112197876,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.9863972663879397,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.8167183995246887,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.6931662559509275,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,6.050858974456787,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.9095180034637451,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.8524209260940552,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.8114465475082395,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.8281571865081787,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,7.401542663574219,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.124708890914917,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.6336735486984253,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.9266018867492676,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.4305710792541504,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,7.115555286407471,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.8268132209777832,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.1833126544952393,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.7776293158531189,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,3.787755250930786,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.476742535829544,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.863080382347107,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.3339999914169311,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.67382287979126,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,42.41856002807617,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,42.41856002807617,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,45.65199661254883,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.7758383750915527,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.614975929260254,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.4712750911712646,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.9248207211494446,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,4.786910057067871,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.849472165107727,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.9238895177841189,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.4997233152389526,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.3272724151611328,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,5.600357532501221,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.035019636154175,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.227802038192749,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.897694706916809,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,5.160516262054443,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.685132622718811,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.0676655769348145,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.0569946765899658,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.7655473947525024,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,6.575340270996094,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.842171311378479,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.8647406101226809,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.646980881690979,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.8862351179122925,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,7.240128040313721,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.0024619102478027,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.7066490650177002,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.7653579711914062,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.3965708017349243,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,6.871039867401123,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.8922785520553589,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.0663342475891113,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.6038802862167358,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,4.562493324279785,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.4338264167308807,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.623325228691101,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.958409070968628,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,4.015560626983643,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,44.81234359741211,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,44.81234359741211,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,47.883209228515625,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.8346912860870361,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.643875002861023,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.6233336925506592,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.137191653251648,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.239091396331787,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.8261154294013977,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.872905135154724,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.615569233894348,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.3193745613098145,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.633964538574219,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.8124345541000368,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.1616748571395874,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.9375172853469849,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,4.911626815795898,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.793050765991211,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.119689702987671,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.1103549003601074,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.7769421339035034,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,6.800037384033203,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.8913816213607788,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.79588520526886,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.7393189668655396,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.9127644300460815,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,7.33935022354126,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.109874963760376,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.775031566619873,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.9779820442199707,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.47550630569458,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,7.338395118713379,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.933801531791687,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.1320855617523193,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.7590600848197937,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,3.8249471187591553,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.3907709121704101,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.565394163131714,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.2672582864761353,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,3.2234232425689697,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,44.31083679199219,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,44.31083679199219,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,47.97953414916992,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.8565061092376709,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.5235438346862793,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.6313462257385254,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.2271132469177246,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,5.238509654998779,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.8514726758003235,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.7465723752975464,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.5073637962341309,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.4629452228546145,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,5.568353652954102,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.9528599977493288,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.192448973655701,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.8911885023117063,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,5.036497592926025,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.6142244338989258,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.800430178642273,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.0751570463180542,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.9288692474365232,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,6.4186811447143555,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.8981839418411257,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.862979769706726,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.728877067565918,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.8836517333984375,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,7.373692512512207,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.0357630252838135,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.71797513961792,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.0406041145324707,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.4628843069076538,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,7.257226467132568,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.8505786061286926,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.8015884160995483,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.5506957173347473,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,3.2028627395629883,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.4007315337657928,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.1399879455566406,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.3339999914169311,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.8747193813323975,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,42.97054290771485,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,42.97054290771485,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,46.201114654541016,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.8069093823432922,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.5274264812469482,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.6647931337356567,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.3124035596847534,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.311532497406006,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.846326470375061,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.7916148900985718,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.470350980758667,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.3511899709701538,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.459482192993164,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.8949568271636963,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.04844331741333,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.0365922451019287,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,4.979992389678955,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.6403061151504517,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.092841148376465,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.070432424545288,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.9612390995025637,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,6.7648186683654785,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.9348104000091553,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.888711214065552,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.6687313318252563,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.9685136079788208,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,7.460766315460205,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.0658087730407715,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.7507773637771606,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.9808390140533447,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.4870569705963137,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,7.284482479095459,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.9506531357765198,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.046164035797119,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.5771326422691345,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,3.5739498138427734,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.469840794801712,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.8869850635528564,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.8632104396820068,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,4.220036029815674,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,45.05506134033203,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,45.05506134033203,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,47.60107421875,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.7473992109298706,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.5718629360198977,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.5422284603118896,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.1287319660186768,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,4.990222454071045,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.9382184147834778,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.882133960723877,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.3668521642684937,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.3258023262023926,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,5.513007164001465,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.9283897876739504,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.012461543083191,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.906986951828003,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,4.847838401794434,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.6754871606826782,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.0662496089935303,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.898522675037384,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.95015811920166,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,6.590417861938477,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.7695730924606323,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.8180338144302368,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.6655747890472412,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.767661452293396,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,7.020843029022217,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.9212558269500732,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.8405637741088867,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.8577287197113037,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.455433964729309,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,7.074982166290283,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.0645512342453003,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.42807674407959,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.697041928768158,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,4.189670085906982,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.3863905966281891,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.7514207363128662,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.3639538288116455,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,3.501765012741089,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,43.72874450683594,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,43.72874450683594,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,47.18836975097656,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.6606175899505615,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.5584112405776978,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.5681318044662476,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.9526382088661194,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,4.7397990226745605,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.809843122959137,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.5854034423828125,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.3156336545944214,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.3247729539871216,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,5.035653114318848,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.8453396558761597,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.9094997048377992,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.7419456243515017,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,4.496784687042236,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.5783265829086304,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.8501362800598145,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.9178223609924316,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.82927668094635,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,6.175561904907227,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.9584687948226929,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.9512064456939695,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.7622883319854736,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.8394217491149905,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,7.511385440826416,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.8376978635787964,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.7235933542251587,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.8998401165008545,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.481176495552063,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,6.942307949066162,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.8571929931640625,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.212502956390381,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.6685527563095093,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,3.738248825073242,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.4540857374668121,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.6341804265975952,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.2419260740280151,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,3.3301923274993896,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,41.969932556152344,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,41.969932556152344,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,44.8658332824707,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.7806506156921387,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.583918571472168,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.7848740816116333,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.0778532028198242,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,5.227296352386475,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.9192497730255128,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.9000802040100095,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.4056316614151,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.4099022150039673,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,5.63486385345459,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.9716644287109375,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.4171555042266846,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.924147129058838,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,5.312967300415039,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.723210692405701,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.001866340637207,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.1157879829406738,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.0416719913482666,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,6.882536888122559,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.8168492317199707,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.9192125797271729,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.6755095720291138,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.930578112602234,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,7.34214973449707,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.058457136154175,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.7081948518753052,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.7335164546966553,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.5747772455215454,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,7.074945449829102,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.0077648162841797,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.075889825820923,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.6456148624420166,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,3.7292697429656982,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.3965165019035339,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.664428949356079,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.8431050777435305,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,3.904050588607788,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,45.10807800292969,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,45.10807800292969,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,48.0542106628418,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.7986615300178528,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.5116034746170044,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.4407178163528442,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.9561165571212769,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,4.707099437713623,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.9632601141929626,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.5875473022460938,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.5303748846054075,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.3436691761016846,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,5.424851417541504,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.847148895263672,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.1958999633789062,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.8458547592163088,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,4.888903617858887,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.4586702585220337,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.891538381576538,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.8870156407356262,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.8063215017318728,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,6.043545722961426,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.934248685836792,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.905972957611084,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.761855959892273,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.896354913711548,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,7.498432636260986,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.101740598678589,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.0323503017425537,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.9813002347946167,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.4384044408798218,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,7.55379581451416,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.769302248954773,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.8270255327224731,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.752626895904541,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,3.348954677581787,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.4270766973495483,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.194424629211426,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.3339999914169311,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.955501079559326,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,42.421085357666016,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,42.421085357666016,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,45.521236419677734,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.8799121975898743,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.7108595371246338,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.8124752044677737,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.252396821975708,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.655643939971924,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.9909019470214844,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.883134126663208,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.2893556356430054,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.4508270025253296,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.614218711853027,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.9742008447647097,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.4578677415847778,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.9930518865585327,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.4251203536987305,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.6115195751190186,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.9709513187408447,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.0039304494857788,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.744478464126587,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,6.3308796882629395,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.820223689079285,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.0087928771972656,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.6108418703079224,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.8460036516189575,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,7.285861968994141,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.9581462144851685,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.6949915885925293,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.0859429836273193,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.4472973346710205,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,7.186378479003906,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.7418236136436462,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.698078751564026,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.5619275569915771,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,3.0018298625946045,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.4051803946495056,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.1685855388641357,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.9929254055023191,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,4.5666913986206055,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,45.06662368774414,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,45.06662368774414,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,46.43349075317383,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.7765007019042969,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.6088463068008425,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.570889949798584,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.1213423013687134,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.077579021453857,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.951919972896576,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.8650202751159668,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.3847609758377075,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.4716498851776123,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.673351287841797,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.869909644126892,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.2718340158462524,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.8888376951217651,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.030581474304199,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.589785099029541,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.8741774559020996,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.990429699420929,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.909018278121948,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,6.363410472869873,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.878603219985962,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.7428362369537354,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.738969802856445,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.9276305437088013,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,7.2880401611328125,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.8456546068191528,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.6992263793945312,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.9639577865600584,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.4208980798721311,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,6.929737091064453,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.730974555015564,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.53243887424469,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.4428020119667053,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.7062153816223145,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.4452129900455475,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.411759853363037,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.2707163095474243,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,4.127688884735107,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,43.19660568237305,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,43.19660568237305,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,45.30622100830078,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.7937432527542114,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.5384609699249268,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.6312484741210938,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.0725373029708862,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,5.035989761352539,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.8610121011734009,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.777894139289856,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.569928526878357,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.2729071378707886,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,5.481741905212402,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.8089500665664673,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.7696260213851929,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.9942911863327024,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,4.572867393493652,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.7835322618484497,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.136500835418701,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.1335318088531494,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.9173816442489624,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,6.970946788787842,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.913186192512512,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.901089072227478,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.7951079607009888,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.8722383975982664,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,7.481621742248535,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.9741958379745483,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.2638362646102903,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.070835590362549,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.4954674243927002,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,6.804335117340088,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.019210934638977,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.831603765487671,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.7325429916381836,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,3.583357572555542,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.3919174373149872,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.867567777633667,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.8832734823226929,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,4.142758369445801,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,44.0736198425293,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,44.0736198425293,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,47.144283294677734,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.8310277462005615,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.5919181108474731,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.5970118045806885,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.5127975940704346,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,5.532755374908447,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.8952314853668213,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.1026041507720947,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.7657742500305176,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.523906946182251,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,6.287517070770264,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.8723180294036863,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.0090373754501345,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.010641574859619,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,4.89199686050415,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.9484001398086548,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.1783077716827393,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.5077661275863647,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.0036449432373047,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,7.638119220733643,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.7723790407180786,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.9643584489822388,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.7997723817825315,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.7680470943450928,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,7.304556846618652,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.005833625793457,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.9954642057418823,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.092407703399658,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.560864806175232,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,7.65457010269165,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.1498829126358032,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.296942234039306,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.3008095026016235,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,4.747634410858154,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.3761423230171203,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.8954992294311523,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.3339999914169311,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.6056413650512695,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,46.66279220581055,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,46.66279220581055,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,52.30018997192383,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.8472051024436951,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.5616217851638794,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.7392686605453491,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.4326502084732056,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,5.580745697021484,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.91915100812912,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.693796157836914,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.4993436336517334,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.5286602973937988,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,5.640951156616211,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.7893837690353394,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.2329586744308472,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.9592554569244385,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,4.981597900390625,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.7415341138839722,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.071807384490967,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.193884253501892,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.0074880123138428,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,7.014713764190674,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.8977705240249632,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.8805547952651975,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.809622049331665,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.946188807487488,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,7.5341362953186035,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.066549062728882,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.8747713565826416,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.1339526176452637,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.4616117477416992,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,7.536884784698486,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.8654626607894897,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.179027795791626,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.8215792775154114,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,3.866069793701172,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.4128551483154297,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.116131067276001,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.3586927652359009,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,3.887678861618042,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,46.04277801513672,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,46.04277801513672,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,49.209007263183594,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.7264240384101868,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.5701130628585815,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.5853670835494995,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.0876091718673706,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,4.969513416290283,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.8377392292022705,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.914582371711731,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.4051270484924316,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.322617769241333,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,5.480066776275635,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.9316729307174685,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.2212398052215576,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.001307964324951,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,5.154221057891846,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.7320806980133057,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.056903123855591,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.0440905094146729,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.971675395965576,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,6.804749965667725,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.9101078510284424,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.9390124082565308,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.7926419973373413,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.989175796508789,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,7.630938053131104,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.9778646230697632,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.7232158184051514,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.9215563535690308,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.4510539770126345,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,7.073690891265869,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.9208058714866638,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.831457495689392,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.4660908579826355,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,3.2183542251586914,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.3990645408630371,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.7295504808425903,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.4230873584747314,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.5517022609710693,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,42.88323593139648,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,42.88323593139648,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,46.70668029785156,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.8066948652267456,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.5857352018356323,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.6267682313919067,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.4479238986968994,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,5.467122554779053,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.8253368139266968,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.6783149242401123,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.3436827659606934,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.391045331954956,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,5.238379955291748,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.786656618118286,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.1505975723266602,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.967623949050903,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,4.90487813949585,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.7280830144882202,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.0226876735687256,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.2349073886871338,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.9232373237609863,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,6.9089155197143555,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.936655044555664,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.8087774515151975,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.779005765914917,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.8893659114837649,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,7.413804054260254,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.0192296504974365,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.723013997077942,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.894927144050598,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.4265897274017334,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,7.063760757446289,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.9947516918182372,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.7735285758972168,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.4944559633731842,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,3.2627363204956055,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.4222481250762939,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.0008742809295654,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.838156580924988,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,4.261279106140137,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,44.5208740234375,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,44.5208740234375,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,46.88205337524414,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.7592880129814148,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.5936644077301023,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.6203758716583252,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.2186777591705322,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.1920061111450195,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.8242037296295166,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.8807179927825928,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.315995693206787,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.4117612838745115,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.432678699493408,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.79084312915802,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.226704478263855,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.9932494163513184,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.010797023773193,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.518257975578308,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.7954343557357788,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.8084504008293152,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.9474775791168213,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,6.069620132446289,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.706594944000244,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.840332627296448,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.8051964044570925,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.8428523540496824,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,7.194976329803467,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.0800931453704834,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.7322160005569458,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.0923635959625244,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.4770816564559937,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,7.381754398345947,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.7260531783103943,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.9205528497695925,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.3622702360153198,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,3.008876323699951,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.3661551475524902,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.089151620864868,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.3339999914169311,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.789306640625,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,42.08001708984375,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,42.08001708984375,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,44.976593017578125,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.781773567199707,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.6213399171829224,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.6389622688293457,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.5111331939697266,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,5.55320930480957,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.7614907622337341,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.963397979736328,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.595466375350952,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.5352452993392944,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,5.855600357055664,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.9501965045928955,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.9958093166351318,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.038144588470459,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,4.984150409698486,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.9258478879928589,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.964353919029236,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.1526483297348022,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.8348722457885744,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,6.877722263336182,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.6935176849365234,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.897611618041992,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.8118079900741575,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.9696179628372192,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,7.372555255889893,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.0632073879241943,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.744478464126587,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.124222993850708,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.4615391492843628,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,7.393447875976563,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.891616702079773,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.0066840648651123,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.7339574098587036,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,3.632258415222168,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.3720745146274566,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.8568557500839231,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.845322608947754,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,4.074252605438232,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,45.743194580078125,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,45.743194580078125,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,48.68935012817383,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.7692140936851501,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.446074604988098,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.4812099933624268,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.1055786609649658,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,4.802077293395996,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.7596195936203003,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.7030073404312134,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.3318477869033811,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.2229951620101929,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,5.017469882965088,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.9440399408340456,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.5333974957466125,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.9434539079666135,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,4.420891284942627,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.1693165302276611,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.7024487257003784,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.7392889857292175,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.927980899810791,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,5.539035320281982,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.784658670425415,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.751107931137085,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.7148213386535645,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.8843683004379272,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,7.134955883026123,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.760653734207153,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.6322394609451294,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.3314332962036133,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.5158653259277344,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,7.24019193649292,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.7312621474266052,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.829997420310974,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.3424227237701416,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.903682231903076,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.3809740245342254,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.222867488861084,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.8741356134414673,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,4.4779767990112305,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,41.53628158569336,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,41.53628158569336,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,42.71949768066406,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.6580410003662109,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.456203579902649,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.7498793601989746,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.2042170763015747,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.068341255187988,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.7222116589546204,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.6113595962524414,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.2966299057006836,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.248976230621338,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,4.879177093505859,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.7596688270568848,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.0155835151672363,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.7458107471466064,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,4.521062850952148,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.7283015251159668,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.8896785974502563,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.1574254035949707,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.8600871562957764,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,6.63549280166626,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.7280572652816772,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.8216677904129028,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.786237120628357,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.90821373462677,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,7.244175910949707,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.91024112701416,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.061511516571045,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.95528507232666,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.424855351448059,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,7.351892948150635,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.7465576529502869,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.6662993431091309,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.3596630692481994,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.772520065307617,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.3767889440059662,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.0640857219696045,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.3339999914169311,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.774874687194824,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,41.24753952026367,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,41.24753952026367,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,44.6153450012207,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.7759745121002197,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.658263087272644,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.730165958404541,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.1886624097824097,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,5.3530659675598145,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.8388333916664124,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.8133769035339355,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.5601915121078491,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.397516846656799,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,5.609918594360352,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.9004552364349363,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.3846464157104492,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.8151984214782717,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,5.100300312042236,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.7418279647827148,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.9162722826004028,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.0692704916000366,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.7839667797088623,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,6.511337757110596,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.8619805574417112,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.5510337352752686,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.7378110885620115,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.922862648963928,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,7.07368803024292,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.029426336288452,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.734343647956848,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.1396842002868652,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.436306715011597,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,7.339761257171631,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.8892102241516113,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.8556952476501465,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.5329284071922302,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,3.277833938598633,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.4290737211704254,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.905271291732788,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.1003849506378174,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,3.434729814529419,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,43.70063400268555,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,43.70063400268555,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,46.62582778930664,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.8715639710426331,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.606534719467163,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.7240328788757324,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.3348546028137207,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,5.536985874176025,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.8596050143241882,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.969183325767517,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.603933334350586,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.402539849281311,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,5.835261344909668,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.8737378120422363,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.1608675718307495,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.8625885248184204,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,4.897193908691406,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.9277105331420896,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.0227718353271484,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.2372891902923584,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.9587844610214231,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,7.1465559005737305,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.818244695663452,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.9916108846664429,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.8868920803070068,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.9408349990844729,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,7.637582778930664,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.057908058166504,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.9558359384536743,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.006009578704834,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.4270261526107788,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,7.446779727935791,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.8643162846565247,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.2941887378692627,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.6382742524147034,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.796779155731201,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.3617937266826629,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.914326786994934,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.88271164894104,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,4.15883207321167,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,45.45597076416016,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,45.45597076416016,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,48.3198356628418,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.767629086971283,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.5417956113815308,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.582906723022461,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.102435827255249,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,4.994767189025879,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.884250819683075,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.9553452730178833,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.465615153312683,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.4291167259216309,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,5.734328269958496,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.0559375286102295,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.10221266746521,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.9224406480789185,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,5.080590724945068,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.887198805809021,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.873516082763672,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.0900461673736572,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.9822953939437864,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,6.833056449890137,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.9264785051345823,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.821277379989624,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.6490702629089355,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.98038911819458,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,7.377215385437012,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.022306203842163,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.8124643564224243,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.0473878383636475,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.4614485502243042,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,7.343606948852539,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.8425764441490173,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.010565996170044,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.4780377447605133,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,3.3311803340911865,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.4158636629581451,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.8143666982650757,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.496633768081665,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,3.726864099502563,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,44.421607971191406,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,44.421607971191406,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,47.64801406860352,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.6621787548065186,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.5925328731536863,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.5347799062728882,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.4153021574020386,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,5.204793453216553,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.8149490356445312,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.8596464395523071,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.3018730878829956,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.3583191633224487,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,5.334787845611572,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.943586349487305,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.172579050064087,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.057272434234619,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,5.17343807220459,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.8483847379684448,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.086021900177002,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.0473681688308716,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.9314029216766355,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,6.913177967071533,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.7663538455963137,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.8284600973129272,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.706981539726257,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.9715269804000857,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,7.273322582244873,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.059648036956787,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.7280542850494385,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.130174160003662,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.446713089942932,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,7.364589214324951,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.9777825474739076,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.008951187133789,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.5982816219329834,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,3.5850155353546143,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.3632639348506927,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.848553776741028,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.8558669686317444,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,3.0676846504211426,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,43.91680908203125,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,43.91680908203125,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,47.48833465576172,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.718457043170929,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.5351614952087402,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.5965090990066528,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.063412070274353,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,4.913539886474609,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.838732898235321,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.885546326637268,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.5301964282989502,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.421048641204834,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,5.6755242347717285,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.8517545461654663,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.142070770263672,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.0093111991882324,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,5.00313663482666,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.7817164659500122,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.9958691596984863,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.1221100091934204,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.9898208379745483,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,6.889516353607178,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.719022274017334,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.9286304712295532,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.849050998687744,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.8918609619140625,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,7.388564586639404,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.0489442348480225,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.7134488821029663,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.100286960601806,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.4446829557418823,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,7.307363033294678,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.0011199712753296,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.119565725326538,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.6474478244781494,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,3.768133401870727,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.37071293592453,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.8429034948349,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.7310889959335327,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.9447052478790283,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,43.89048385620117,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,43.89048385620117,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,47.97843551635742,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.7847312688827515,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.6357836723327637,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.6368329524993896,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.3732404708862305,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.430588245391846,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.8925063610076904,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.8007729053497314,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.465986728668213,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.3768951892852783,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.536161422729492,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.87078058719635,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.3885759115219116,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.999846339225769,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.25920295715332,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.7871278524398804,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.9991554021835327,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.0856012105941772,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.769564151763916,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,6.641448497772217,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.854212522506714,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.8837778568267824,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.7659683227539062,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.8900166749954224,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,7.393975257873535,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.0055203437805176,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.6962155103683472,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.998231291770935,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.4172557592391968,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,7.117223262786865,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.9670085310935974,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.9324413537979128,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.5862184762954712,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,3.485668420791626,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.4305705428123474,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.9330774545669556,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.4874958992004397,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,3.8511438369750977,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,44.71541213989258,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,44.71541213989258,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,47.23994445800781,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.9437148571014404,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.7936712503433228,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.60879385471344,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.4604519605636597,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,5.806632041931152,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.866702139377594,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.8598287105560305,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.4320634603500366,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.4270524978637695,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,5.585646629333496,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.011781692504883,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.2444372177124023,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.9676709175109863,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,5.2238898277282715,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.9347569942474363,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.1557977199554443,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.2756909132003784,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.9242781400680544,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,7.290523529052734,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.9278318881988523,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.9571982622146609,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.850577473640442,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.9137040376663208,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,7.649311542510986,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.0757687091827393,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.7835689783096311,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.8139278888702393,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.4494348764419556,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,7.122700214385986,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.045850396156311,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.819334864616394,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.7808865308761597,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,3.646071672439575,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.380497395992279,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.7586575746536257,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.3339999914169311,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.473154783248902,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,44.79793167114258,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,44.79793167114258,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,48.94826889038086,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.93392413854599,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.5660995244979858,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.592076301574707,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.3084633350372314,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,5.4005632400512695,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.8948032259941101,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.8468533754348757,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.4142130613327026,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.3915503025054932,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,5.547420024871826,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.9598875045776367,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.4660906791687012,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.9611724615097048,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,5.387150764465332,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.9468470811843872,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.0533287525177,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.1681979894638062,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.8287391662597656,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,6.99711275100708,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.8562862873077393,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.8701950311660769,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.6796098947525024,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.9067707061767576,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,7.312861919403076,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.1509768962860107,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.949168086051941,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.9208693504333496,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.346532940864563,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,7.367547512054443,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.101978063583374,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.9662452936172483,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.6706098318099976,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,3.73883318901062,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.4342147409915924,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.8676701784133911,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.7879464626312256,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,4.089831352233887,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,45.8413200378418,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,45.8413200378418,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,48.64957427978515,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.7347564101219177,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.6118743419647217,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.569393515586853,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.1709222793579102,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,5.086946487426758,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.9891175627708436,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.6182665824890137,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.432539701461792,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.441056728363037,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,5.480980396270752,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.981547474861145,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.5105340480804443,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.7853851318359375,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,5.277466773986816,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.907111406326294,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.16241192817688,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.1053788661956787,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.8709723949432373,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,7.04587459564209,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.7875539064407349,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.8934682607650757,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.675869107246399,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.953622579574585,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,7.310513973236084,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.0778205394744873,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.7067463397979736,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.9670112133026123,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.4447240829467771,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,7.1963019371032715,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.075643539428711,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.9645553827285769,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.5661474466323853,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,3.606346368789673,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.4526276290416717,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.8605395555496216,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.3339999914169311,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.647167205810547,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,43.65159606933594,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,43.65159606933594,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,47.75674057006836,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.7868393659591675,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.5540921688079834,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.6269700527191162,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.2752270698547363,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.243128776550293,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.8713420629501343,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.7838109731674194,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.369205355644226,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.270378589630127,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.294737339019775,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.056689977645874,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.361191749572754,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.044829845428467,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.462711334228516,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.6575205326080322,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.1260530948638916,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.0103250741958618,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.921949028968811,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,6.715847969055176,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.8213889598846436,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.726506590843201,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.755123257637024,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.894558906555176,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,7.197577953338623,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.0983431339263916,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.7229429483413696,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.2379813194274902,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.4628254175186155,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,7.522092819213867,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.9702121019363404,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.1677069664001465,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.9744117856025696,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,4.112330913543701,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.4330778121948242,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.9511200189590456,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.9263296127319336,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,4.310527324676514,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,45.85895538330078,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,45.85895538330078,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,48.27566909790039,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.8521132469177246,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.685530424118042,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.575024127960205,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.6584399342536926,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,4.7711076736450195,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.9197224974632264,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.8266019821166992,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.4126646518707275,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.3242491483688354,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,5.483238220214844,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.0654237270355225,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.8602541089057922,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.8516279458999632,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,4.777306079864502,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.5010404586791992,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.9881057739257812,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.1024383306503296,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.024672746658325,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,6.616257190704346,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.8913013935089111,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.861162781715393,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.8137218952178955,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.9377549886703491,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,7.503941059112549,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.0418570041656494,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.9620252847671509,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.3519647121429443,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.525417685508728,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,7.881264686584473,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.844038724899292,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.7425497770309448,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.363116979598999,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.9497056007385254,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.4263774156570434,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.7287774085998535,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.8473124504089355,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,5.002467155456543,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,44.98528671264648,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,44.98528671264648,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,47.017818450927734,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.7404211759567261,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.490564465522766,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.6828796863555908,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.9632793664932252,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,4.877144813537598,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.8185226917266846,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.868735074996948,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.396326184272766,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.393875241279602,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,5.477458953857422,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.9370596408843992,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.0990248918533323,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.0386855602264404,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,5.074769973754883,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.9030691385269165,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.2172482013702393,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.3276546001434326,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.0478973388671875,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,7.495869159698486,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.7979358434677124,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.9010388851165771,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.568463921546936,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.893784999847412,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,7.161223411560059,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.0707736015319824,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.974284052848816,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.858938455581665,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.5248417854309082,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,7.428837776184082,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.1504448652267456,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.8718503713607788,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.846851110458374,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,3.8691463470458984,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.3918447494506836,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.280908465385437,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.274620771408081,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.947373867034912,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,44.331825256347656,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,44.331825256347656,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,49.01963424682617,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.5640031099319458,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.406552791595459,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.5771591663360596,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.0395259857177734,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,4.587241172790527,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.7143009305000305,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.8176954984664917,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.2460975646972656,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.2844274044036863,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,5.062521457672119,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.9893444776535032,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.5617069005966189,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.043375015258789,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,5.594426155090332,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.754770278930664,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.0269503593444824,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.1114013195037842,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.828279733657837,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,6.721401691436768,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.6399188041687012,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.804917335510254,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.5777276754379272,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.9489948749542236,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,6.971558570861816,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.1007072925567627,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.6312665939331057,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.6421480178833008,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.5079381465911863,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,6.8820600509643555,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.9661813378334044,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.7908090353012085,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.552217960357666,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,3.309208393096924,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.3463374674320221,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.354222297668457,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.3543075323104858,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.0548672676086426,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,41.18328475952149,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,41.18328475952149,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,45.206321716308594,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.6229355335235596,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.4065876007080078,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.3724417686462402,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.007174372673035,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,4.409139156341553,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.7706146240234375,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.7256749868392944,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.1683855056762695,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.2187985181808472,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,4.883473873138428,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.0421388149261475,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.0552922487258911,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.865072011947632,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,4.962502956390381,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.8193261623382568,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.035937547683716,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.0823582410812378,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.891008138656616,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,6.828629970550537,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.7177826166152954,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.838333010673523,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.6050992012023926,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.9188268184661863,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,7.080041885375977,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.9890958070755005,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.690361738204956,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.922162413597107,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.533151149749756,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,7.13477087020874,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.959413766860962,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.9016427993774416,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.51968914270401,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,3.380745649337769,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.3880011141300201,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.4351673126220703,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.3339999914169311,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.157168388366699,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,40.83647155761719,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,40.83647155761719,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,45.2141227722168,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.6024453639984131,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.293337106704712,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.4518733024597168,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.7670962810516357,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,4.114752292633057,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.6987820863723755,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.534170389175415,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.5359238386154177,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.3213322162628174,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,5.090208530426025,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.8260645866394043,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.0171141624450684,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.8352596759796145,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,4.678438663482666,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.6655923128128052,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.9361350536346436,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.0548561811447144,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.8070998191833496,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,6.463683605194092,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.7184395790100098,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.7889273166656494,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.6742600202560425,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.9305853843688965,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,7.112212181091309,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.041449546813965,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.6576517820358276,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.7390589714050293,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.4715977907180786,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,6.9097580909729,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.9675064086914062,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.8271663188934328,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.8385547995567322,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,3.633227586746216,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.3620149195194244,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.345520257949829,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.8717198371887207,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,3.5792548656463623,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,41.58153533935547,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,41.58153533935547,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,44.878387451171875,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.6561459302902222,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.2918633222579956,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.2917280197143557,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.3014373779296875,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,4.54117488861084,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.7204515933990479,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.4595438241958618,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.220272183418274,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.351327657699585,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,4.751595497131348,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.0024960041046143,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.8281354308128357,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.9627412557601929,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,4.793372631072998,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.6633328199386597,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.9174344539642336,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.1277332305908203,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.7998161315917969,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,6.508316516876221,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.6407698392868042,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.7873256206512451,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.6211724281311035,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.7936967611312866,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,6.8429646492004395,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.9853482246398928,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.7940669059753418,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.0475809574127197,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.3803380727767944,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,7.207334041595459,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.0402034521102903,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.916551113128662,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.7094002962112427,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,3.6661548614501953,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.3872815668582916,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.6143033504486084,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.8517264127731323,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,3.85331130027771,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,42.16422271728515,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,42.16422271728515,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,44.957374572753906,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.7474270462989807,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.5915154218673706,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.4620555639266968,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.5117157697677612,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,5.312713623046875,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.8303935527801514,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.8495261669158936,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.365397334098816,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.255853295326233,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,5.301170349121094,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.776703953742981,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.7694403529167175,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.9401029348373413,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,4.486247539520264,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.8970942497253416,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.14579176902771,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.2386583089828491,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.897976994514465,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,7.179521083831787,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.7122431993484497,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.9700605869293213,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.7721261978149414,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.8477007150650024,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,7.302130699157715,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.0506656169891357,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.0559773445129395,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.11124587059021,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.4461212158203125,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,7.664010047912598,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.0727118253707886,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.1436500549316406,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.5807923674583435,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,3.797154426574707,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.3598066568374634,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.5224355459213257,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.3339999914169311,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.2162423133850098,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,43.25918960571289,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,43.25918960571289,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,48.155303955078125,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.6228379011154175,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.345054268836975,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.4281015396118164,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.935302197933197,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,4.331295967102051,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.735926628112793,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.399065375328064,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.4085252285003662,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.2232953310012815,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,4.766812324523926,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.9661816358566284,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.722698986530304,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.9303616285324097,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,4.619242191314697,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.5895514488220217,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.986372470855713,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.1443977355957031,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.8039329051971436,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,6.52425479888916,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.71505606174469,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.8565905094146729,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.683451533317566,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.823022961616516,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,7.078121185302734,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.9938757419586184,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.66218900680542,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.0064635276794434,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.3419111967086792,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,7.004439353942871,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.0786247253417969,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.9318381547927856,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.4380263090133667,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,3.448489189147949,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.347487211227417,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.6687304973602295,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.840830683708191,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,3.857048273086548,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,41.62970352172851,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,41.62970352172851,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,44.466339111328125,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.7303915023803711,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.5585529804229736,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.5944222211837769,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.8532558679580688,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,4.736622333526611,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.8095268607139587,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.5394151210784912,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.201270341873169,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.2069816589355469,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,4.7571940422058105,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.9922622442245483,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.1116037368774414,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.960724115371704,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,5.064589977264404,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.497706651687622,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.846644639968872,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.8351679444313049,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.849985957145691,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,6.029505252838135,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.775528907775879,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.9005188941955569,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.6516236066818235,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8049124479293823,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,7.1325836181640625,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.0909860134124756,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.662601351737976,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8724151849746704,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.3691115379333496,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,6.995114326477051,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.8429327607154846,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.9642080068588257,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.4202215671539306,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,3.2273623943328857,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.3365691304206848,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.7346665859222412,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.841466188430786,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,3.9127018451690674,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,41.855674743652344,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,41.855674743652344,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,43.63758850097656,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.7816829681396484,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.6111830472946167,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.668611764907837,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.0445318222045898,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,5.106009483337402,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.7927002906799316,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.6089950799942017,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.5853497982025146,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.3038663864135742,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,5.290911674499512,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.8733172416687012,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.9532122611999512,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.041893243789673,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,4.868422985076904,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.5294378995895386,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.9768341779708865,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.068624496459961,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.880279302597046,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,6.455175876617432,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.6321768760681152,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.8876692056655884,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.6869192123413086,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.920790433883667,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,7.127555847167969,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.901362061500549,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.761704683303833,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.8808809518814087,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.3567233085632324,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,6.900671005249023,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.83613520860672,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.9932159185409544,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.48408243060112,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,3.3134336471557617,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.3709180951118469,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.7815042734146118,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.3339999914169311,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.486422300338745,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,41.54860305786133,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,41.54860305786133,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,45.14088821411133,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.6796488761901855,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.545759677886963,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.558049559593201,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.1466928720474243,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,4.930150985717773,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.7511764168739319,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.6754300594329834,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.2928136587142944,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.2831895351409912,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,5.002609729766846,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.9209812879562376,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.0360171794891355,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.9555004835128784,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,4.912498950958252,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.5451645851135254,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.9896466732025144,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.865029513835907,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.7692142724990845,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,6.169054985046387,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.6817576885223389,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.9041521549224856,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.6391264200210571,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.881084680557251,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,7.106120586395264,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.0082082748413086,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.9302140474319456,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.9859498739242551,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.5154376029968262,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,7.439809799194336,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.784430205821991,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.036509275436402,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.4891097545623779,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,3.310049295425415,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.3570101261138916,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.511274814605713,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.3339999914169311,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.202284812927246,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,41.07257843017578,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,41.07257843017578,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,44.59873580932617,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.8270700573921204,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.646831512451172,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.6337246894836426,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.1844086647033691,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,5.292035102844238,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.8409780263900757,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.8328344821929932,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.2804150581359863,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.2820501327514648,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,5.2362775802612305,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.9456641674041748,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.3345093727111816,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.9048651456832888,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,5.1850385665893555,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.5976275205612185,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.9447871446609497,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.8706033229827881,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.9283231496810913,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,6.341341018676758,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.8072774410247805,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.8510510921478271,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.7858048677444458,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.880108118057251,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,7.324241638183594,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.0491204261779785,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.4415868520736694,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.9090123176574707,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.4304285049438477,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,6.830148220062256,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.7992109656333923,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.100111722946167,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.3664930164813995,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,3.2658157348632812,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.3949656784534454,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.9227997064590456,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.048234462738037,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,4.365999698638916,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,43.84089660644531,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,43.84089660644531,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,45.466434478759766,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.7820337414741516,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.5601582527160645,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.4844048023223877,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.167849898338318,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,4.994446754455566,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.8187360763549805,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.5784355401992798,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.391573429107666,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.3137894868850708,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,5.102534294128418,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.108581066131592,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.9326906204223632,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.8737436532974243,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,4.91501522064209,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.4902726411819458,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.8763043880462649,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.8370357155799866,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.812942385673523,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,6.016554832458496,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.770723581314087,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.775736689567566,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.6700135469436646,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.860039472579956,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,7.076513290405273,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.8576695919036863,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.059043884277344,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.987036943435669,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.399443745613098,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,7.303194046020508,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.884828507900238,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.7237703800201416,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.5927133560180664,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,3.2013120651245117,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.3489765524864197,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.747159719467163,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.2628813982009888,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,3.3590176105499268,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,41.96858978271485,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,41.96858978271485,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,44.383541107177734,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.8022261261940002,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.451388597488403,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.4984490871429443,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.213107943534851,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,4.965171813964844,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.7873048782348633,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.7946208715438845,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.6623663902282717,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.374696135520935,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,5.618988037109375,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.8776034116744995,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.2025011777877808,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.9569822549819944,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,5.037086486816406,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.668434739112854,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.007463216781616,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.9349554181098938,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.6734288930892944,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,6.284282207489014,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.9044889211654663,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.9204044342041016,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.859217643737793,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.9532643556594849,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,7.637375354766846,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.7071117162704468,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.7770781517028809,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.0157198905944824,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.4256080389022827,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,6.925518035888672,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.7257938385009766,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.807651162147522,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.4195521771907806,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.9529972076416016,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.3607410490512848,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.084669828414917,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.9551753997802737,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,4.400586128234863,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,43.82200622558594,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,43.82200622558594,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,45.652191162109375,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.6823621392250061,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.4718676805496216,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.328190803527832,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.9002079963684082,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,4.382628917694092,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.7127061486244202,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.6767600774765017,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.3453484773635864,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.426926612854004,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,5.161741256713867,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.9956384897232056,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.7957424521446228,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.860678434371948,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,4.652059555053711,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.6543195247650146,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.068695068359375,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.271458387374878,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.8815453052520752,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,6.876018047332764,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.7917736768722534,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.814058542251587,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.8238581418991089,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.9295868873596191,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,7.359277248382568,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.9073160886764529,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.962108373641968,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.9821553230285645,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.4584290981292725,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,7.310009002685547,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.954977810382843,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.001790761947632,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.380876362323761,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,3.3376448154449463,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.3410298824310303,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.7084156274795532,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.2541121244430542,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,3.3035576343536377,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,42.3829345703125,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,42.3829345703125,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,46.164283752441406,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.8426505923271179,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.4340102672576904,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.5308297872543335,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.9912052750587464,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,4.798696041107178,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.9080700874328612,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.943645477294922,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.4803513288497925,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.3204666376113892,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,5.652533531188965,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.924988865852356,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.7475070357322693,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.9124482870101929,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,4.584944248199463,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.726966142654419,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.0433502197265625,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.165952444076538,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.958739638328552,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,6.895008563995361,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.8180185556411743,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.8334416151046753,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.694149613380432,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.9119232892990112,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,7.257533073425293,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.9407387971878052,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.6614048480987549,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.0962255001068115,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.4933534860610962,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,7.191722393035889,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.8944677114486694,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.9850929975509644,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.3979101479053497,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,3.277470827102661,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.4099019765853882,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.0240578651428223,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.878968358039856,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,4.312928199768066,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,43.9708366394043,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,43.9708366394043,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,47.05713653564453,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.792299211025238,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.4260284900665283,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.4724102020263672,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.1459378004074097,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,4.836675643920898,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.7530788779258728,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.8251261711120603,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.3623675107955933,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.365916728973389,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,5.30648946762085,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.002932548522949,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.0768094062805176,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.064616441726685,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,5.144358158111572,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.75024676322937,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.070481777191162,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.3032864332199097,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.9556798934936523,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,7.079694747924805,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.8508200645446775,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.839395523071289,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.787713646888733,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.960455060005188,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,7.438384532928467,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.9477319717407229,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.9839487075805664,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.009559392929077,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.4557040929794312,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,7.396944046020508,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.075191855430603,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.049379348754883,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.4642177522182464,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,3.5887887477874756,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.3906297981739044,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.9102039337158203,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.844567596912384,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,3.1454012393951416,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,43.936737060546875,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,43.936737060546875,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,47.76364517211914,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.882423460483551,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.5845736265182495,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.5889893770217896,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.2665438652038574,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,5.322530269622803,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.7458491325378418,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.1224377155303955,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.4595959186553955,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.452564358711243,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,5.780447006225586,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.1510744094848633,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.8846037983894348,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.014528512954712,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,5.050206661224365,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.6729367971420288,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.0198326110839844,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.234201192855835,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.9582104682922363,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,6.885180950164795,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.7904396057128906,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.862505555152893,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.819385051727295,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.8938957452774048,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,7.3662261962890625,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.9791817665100095,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.9948365688323977,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.322864294052124,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.4298113584518433,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,7.726694107055664,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.9926389455795288,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.930282711982727,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.3505372405052185,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,3.273458957672119,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.3686890602111816,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.1155154705047607,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.358257532119751,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,3.842462062835694,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,45.24720764160156,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,45.24720764160156,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,48.36811065673828,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.8388193845748901,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.386972188949585,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.49499773979187,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.139270305633545,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,4.86005973815918,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.8359906077384949,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.871917724609375,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.453343152999878,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.3324456214904783,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,5.493697166442871,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.038703203201294,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.9988518953323364,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.0036215782165527,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,5.0411763191223145,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.429302453994751,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.9337998628616333,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.0492503643035889,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.961006999015808,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,6.373359680175781,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.8823531866073608,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.8135682344436648,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.7829362154006958,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.9123754501342771,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,7.391232967376709,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.896613359451294,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.9536868333816528,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.2637150287628174,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.356010913848877,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,7.470026016235352,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.8738058805465698,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.610188603401184,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.3453433811664581,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.8293378353118896,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.4057995080947876,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.5511226654052734,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.3693355321884155,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,4.326257228851318,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,43.78514862060547,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,43.78514862060547,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,45.858795166015625,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.7393922805786133,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.4029088020324707,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.4018346071243286,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.9378277063369752,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,4.481963157653809,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.698246419429779,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.7096556425094604,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.3349534273147583,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.338031530380249,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,5.0808868408203125,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.0597572326660156,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.6591213941574097,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.688813090324402,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,4.407691955566406,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.825757384300232,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.0864853858947754,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.310443878173828,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.8735905885696411,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,7.096277236938477,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.818053722381592,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.9586732387542725,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.7406848669052124,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.9386653900146484,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,7.4560770988464355,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.875672459602356,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.7040399312973022,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.0373289585113525,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.4032249450683594,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,7.020266056060791,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.10665762424469,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.9118086099624632,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.3932185173034668,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,3.41168475151062,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.3603111505508423,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.2759740352630615,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.1106297969818115,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.746915102005005,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,41.70176315307617,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,41.70176315307617,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,46.12447738647461,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.6705933809280396,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.4163271188735962,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.448874592781067,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.0667774677276611,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,4.602572441101074,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.7102595567703247,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.704715609550476,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.198359131813049,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.4709242582321167,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,5.084258556365967,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.006828546524048,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.7249525189399719,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.790833592414856,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,4.522614479064941,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.904229998588562,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.102226734161377,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.3185348510742188,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.7456071376800537,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,7.070598602294922,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.8101673126220703,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.9384784698486328,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.893073558807373,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.9775489568710327,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,7.619268417358398,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.0711145401000977,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.7287365198135376,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.6605018377304075,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.4151794910430908,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,6.875532627105713,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.0825207233428955,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.913348913192749,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.6140703558921814,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,3.6099400520324703,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.3354427814483642,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.1807559728622437,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.310553550720215,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,3.826752185821533,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,43.2115364074707,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,43.2115364074707,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,46.63412857055664,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.8167137503623962,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.5984017848968506,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.4633734226226809,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.6979292631149292,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,5.576417922973633,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.8935320973396301,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.9472949504852295,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.6731857061386108,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.4590057134628296,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,5.973018169403076,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.181628704071045,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.0392903089523315,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.920551300048828,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,5.141470432281494,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.1993443965911865,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.3049306869506836,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.718981385231018,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.966983675956726,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,8.190239906311035,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.9151614904403689,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.8833714723587036,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.884389281272888,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.938563346862793,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,7.621485710144043,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.1261801719665527,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.7855947017669678,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.1055400371551514,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.4108577966690063,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,7.428172588348389,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.3069041967391968,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.9077221155166624,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.1239250898361206,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,4.3385515213012695,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.3784818351268768,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.7609301805496216,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.3339999914169311,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.473411798477173,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,46.742767333984375,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,46.742767333984375,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,52.4837646484375,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.6049734354019165,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.3289878368377686,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.277438998222351,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.051151156425476,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,4.262551307678223,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.720269501209259,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.4458715915679932,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.2891607284545898,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.4668970108032229,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,4.92219877243042,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.8756260871887207,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.8965167999267578,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.93478524684906,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,4.706928253173828,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.7764205932617188,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.1523449420928955,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.2585713863372805,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.875392198562622,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,7.062729358673096,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.7657774686813354,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.0145792961120605,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.929497241973877,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.9569644927978516,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,7.666818618774414,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.151758909225464,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.0152792930603027,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.0862605571746826,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.53140127658844,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,7.7846999168396,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.1124353408813477,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.973956823348999,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.5409405827522278,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,3.6273326873779297,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.3830068111419678,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.2229294776916504,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.8621630668640137,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,3.468099355697632,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,43.50135803222656,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,43.50135803222656,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,47.34843444824219,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.6555290222167969,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.302551031112671,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.304170846939087,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.9106833934783936,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,4.172934055328369,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.7171993255615234,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.594079613685608,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.215233325958252,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.260806679725647,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,4.787319183349609,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.762192964553833,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.7210791707038879,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.8180450201034544,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,4.30131721496582,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.9645423889160156,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.1262691020965576,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.4518449306488037,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.8538739681243896,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,7.3965301513671875,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.844573736190796,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.910486340522766,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.9551726579666135,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.8754111528396609,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,7.585643768310547,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.9835819005966189,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.541484832763672,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.2702765464782715,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.5041007995605469,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,7.299444198608398,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.272489070892334,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.089630126953125,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.182971715927124,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,4.545090675354004,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.3525489866733551,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.450176477432251,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.3339999914169311,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.136725425720215,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,42.225006103515625,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,42.225006103515625,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,47.87245559692383,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.7685990929603577,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.5069353580474854,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.5227606296539309,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.4979751110076904,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,5.296270370483398,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.841835618019104,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.0838615894317627,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.4308927059173584,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.4288018941879272,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,5.785391807556152,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.9932146072387695,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.919325590133667,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.833801746368408,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,4.746342182159424,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.937301516532898,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.165187358856201,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.5503729581832886,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.059828519821167,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,7.712690353393555,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.761879324913025,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.8012620210647583,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.878063082695007,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.9107171297073364,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,7.351921558380127,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.1084132194519043,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.672362208366394,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.0524864196777344,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.4593149423599243,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,7.292576789855957,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.1023868322372437,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.1211156845092773,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.716261863708496,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,4.939764499664307,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.3717466592788696,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.475000500679016,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.7474713325500488,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,3.5942184925079346,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,46.71917724609375,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,46.71917724609375,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,51.52465057373047,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.6121315360069275,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.2214300632476809,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.1369528770446775,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.250065565109253,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,4.220580101013184,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.7694119215011597,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.783425211906433,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.1716562509536743,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.3389796018600464,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,5.063473224639893,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.9639461040496824,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.6813481450080872,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.9885287284851072,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,4.633822917938232,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.7633010149002075,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.094749212265014,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.3310773372650146,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.5969465970993042,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,6.786074161529541,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.8163114786148071,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.0048110485076904,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.858727216720581,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.9044147729873655,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,7.584264278411865,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.040221691131592,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.932099223136902,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.313138246536255,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.5162498950958252,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,7.801708698272705,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.1443500518798828,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.088217258453369,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.3694967031478882,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,4.60206413269043,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.3597561419010162,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.6771830320358276,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.6458613872528076,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,3.682800531387329,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,44.374786376953125,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,44.374786376953125,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,48.246612548828125,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.6845688223838806,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.257308006286621,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.56089985370636,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.8519831299781799,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,4.354759693145752,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.7082197070121765,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.7270358800888062,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.2156699895858765,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.3473116159439087,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,4.998237133026123,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.7597894668579102,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.8668314218521118,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.988437294960022,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,4.615057945251465,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.880976915359497,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.0781664848327637,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.3377313613891602,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.9415079355239868,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,7.238382816314697,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.7432725429534912,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.982099652290344,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.7918766736984253,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.9120535850524905,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,7.42930269241333,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.8829799890518188,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.574773907661438,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.167102575302124,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.434360384941101,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,7.0592169761657715,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.1838197708129885,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.0337018966674805,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.5816161036491394,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,3.799137830734253,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.3607226610183716,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.5328134298324585,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.0993781089782717,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.9929141998291016,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,42.48701095581055,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,42.48701095581055,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,46.91747283935547,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.8095674514770508,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.5686737298965454,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.549330711364746,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.1972806453704834,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,5.124852657318115,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.8165709972381592,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.841737985610962,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.6368063688278198,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.4238282442092896,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,5.7189435958862305,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.019860029220581,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.1540733575820925,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.8488849401474,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,5.022818088531494,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.952241897583008,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.2051022052764893,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.3281023502349854,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.0550873279571533,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,7.540533542633057,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.807834267616272,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.9150744676589968,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.8641434907913208,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.9997992515563965,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,7.586851596832275,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.1004390716552734,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.663895845413208,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.1648495197296143,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.5304137468338013,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,7.459598064422607,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.1444807052612305,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.147411823272705,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.077243685722351,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,4.369136333465576,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.3901212215423584,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.7688900232315063,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.7307456135749817,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.889756679534912,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,45.71249008178711,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,45.71249008178711,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,50.60662841796875,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.7529828548431396,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.424475908279419,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.2117871046066284,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.0738540887832642,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,4.463099956512451,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.7444186210632324,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.7379626035690308,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.2785195112228394,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.293315887451172,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,5.054216384887695,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.061990737915039,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.179224729537964,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.861416935920715,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,5.102632522583008,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.8025333881378176,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.085254907608032,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.3384358882904053,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.9202083349227903,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,7.146432399749756,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.7693275213241575,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.8585865497589111,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.8445769548416135,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.933250069618225,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,7.405741214752197,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.035563707351685,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.2770410776138306,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.0486278533935547,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.4861719608306885,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,6.847404479980469,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.3073221445083618,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.035613536834717,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.3421251773834229,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,4.685060501098633,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.3958319425582886,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.1842598915100098,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.20155930519104,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,3.781651020050049,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,44.48624038696289,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,44.48624038696289,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,48.20069885253906,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.7338829040527344,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.3518093824386597,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.0754421949386597,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.1453109979629517,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,4.306445598602295,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.8113722205162048,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.5431418418884275,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.2590000629425049,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.379793405532837,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,4.993307590484619,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.9246238470077517,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.8990483283996582,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.030442237854004,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,4.854114532470703,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.8228068351745603,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.126983642578125,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.2835928201675415,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.9615919589996336,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,7.19497537612915,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.7752339839935305,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.9470441341400144,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.7823485136032104,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.900339126586914,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,7.404965877532959,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.9160794019699097,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.7158757448196411,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.9542001485824585,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.410146713256836,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,6.996302127838135,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.1343514919281006,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.9824122190475464,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.6015501022338867,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,3.7183139324188232,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.3482671678066253,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.3053656816482544,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.8522404432296753,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,3.505873203277588,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,42.97429656982422,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,42.97429656982422,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,46.82539367675781,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.7081674337387085,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.3068886995315552,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.2751550674438477,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.184529185295105,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,4.474740505218506,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.6705828905105591,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.3593319654464722,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.268735408782959,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.4746471643447876,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,4.773297309875488,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.999007225036621,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.8102918863296509,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.0178840160369873,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,4.827183246612549,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.834675908088684,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.0792980194091797,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.2789340019226074,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.978221774101257,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,7.1711297035217285,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.6733309030532837,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.8344258069992063,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.7051351070404053,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.8637748956680296,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,7.076666831970215,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.011754274368286,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.6971731185913086,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.1537389755249023,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.5300509929656982,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,7.392717361450195,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.2046750783920288,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.1284215450286865,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.6994098424911499,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,4.032506465911865,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.3721456825733185,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.5779743194580078,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.858577847480774,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,3.8086979389190674,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,43.55693817138672,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,43.55693817138672,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,47.19704055786133,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.6822271347045898,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.396788477897644,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.4539508819580078,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.8750671744346619,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,4.408033847808838,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.7464157342910767,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.8203771114349363,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.3221964836120603,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.357316493988037,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,5.2463059425354,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.046714782714844,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.129646062850952,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.0843446254730225,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,5.260705471038818,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.9352011680603027,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.1751763820648193,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.311603307723999,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.0015783309936523,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,7.423559188842773,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.8155782222747805,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.0069613456726074,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.7493592500686646,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.008578300476074,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,7.580477237701416,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.9891862869262695,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.5484251976013184,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.9440351724624632,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.588775873184204,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,7.070422649383545,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.1483629941940308,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.136120319366455,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.7300379872322083,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,4.01452112197876,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.3481272161006927,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.4094165563583374,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.3339999914169311,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.091543674468994,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,43.0955696105957,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,43.0955696105957,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2019,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,48.28814697265625,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.7379792332649231,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.4999457597732544,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.663578748703003,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.1574523448944092,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.058956146240234,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.7642925977706909,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.6866106986999512,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.5153981447219849,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.2777950763702393,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.244096755981445,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.932881236076355,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.8727741837501526,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.0060887336730957,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,4.811744213104248,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.616569757461548,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.96259605884552,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.995566427707672,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.0235002040863037,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,6.598232269287109,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.799160122871399,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.8420764207839968,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.6770339012145996,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.8510074615478516,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,7.169277667999268,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.9423763751983645,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.387720823287964,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.025458335876465,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.51417076587677,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,6.869726181030273,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.9205560684204102,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.6148842573165894,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.4233739078044891,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.9588141441345215,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.3916786313056946,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.1000306606292725,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.4260437488555908,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.917752981185913,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,41.62860107421875,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,41.62860107421875,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,43.69869613647461,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.8208528161048889,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.5462993383407593,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.5992721319198608,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.0046321153640747,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,4.9710564613342285,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.019652009010315,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.697822332382202,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.440774917602539,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.277759313583374,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,5.436008453369141,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.8864585161209104,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.227136492729187,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.937509059906006,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,5.0511040687561035,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.4153690338134766,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.044785976409912,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.9557504653930664,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.9975528717041016,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,6.413458347320557,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.8336334228515625,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.9322547912597656,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.9816436767578125,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.8632049560546875,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,7.610736846923828,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.0182864665985107,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.35185968875885,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.832352876663208,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.4198700189590454,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,6.622368812561035,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.9648444652557372,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.108790636062622,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.6563735008239746,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,3.730008602142334,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.432898610830307,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.0625596046447754,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.3456155955791473,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.841073751449585,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,42.67581558227539,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,42.67581558227539,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,44.74134826660156,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.819222629070282,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.4684464931488037,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.5614902973175049,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.0425347089767456,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,4.891694068908691,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.933272123336792,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.7094335556030271,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.4912850856781006,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.365478277206421,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,5.49946928024292,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.0380232334136963,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.2265325784683228,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.9907441139221191,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,5.255300045013428,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.874236822128296,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.075068473815918,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.105024814605713,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.946767210960388,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,7.001097202301025,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.8942251205444336,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.9515568017959597,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.624462366104126,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.9506707191467283,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,7.420915126800537,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.0565197467803955,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.353926181793213,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.765255570411682,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.342854142189026,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,6.518555641174316,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.0296363830566406,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.9093865156173704,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.2852625846862793,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,4.22428560256958,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.4367601871490478,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.681421399116516,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.4450445473194122,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.5632259845733643,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,43.374542236328125,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,43.374542236328125,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,46.43421936035156,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.7946877479553223,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.556452393531799,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.5604307651519775,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.310889720916748,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.222460746765137,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.8441265225410461,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.7780169248580933,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.6499452590942385,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.319865584373474,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.591954231262207,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.9465514421463013,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.9646812081336976,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.9703450202941897,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,4.881577968597412,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.6712712049484253,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.059619426727295,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.013569951057434,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.7169004678726196,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,6.461360931396484,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.8644564151763916,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.768021583557129,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.7015094757080078,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.9333149194717407,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,7.267302513122559,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.1324801445007324,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.4096206426620483,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.9564735889434817,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.5101826190948486,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,7.0087571144104,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.959642767906189,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.083091974258423,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.6333390474319458,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,3.6760737895965576,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.3732672929763794,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.8326196670532229,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.4075193405151367,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.613406181335449,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,42.72289276123047,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,42.72289276123047,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,45.16868591308594,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.8668187260627747,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.6174720525741575,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.6775552034378052,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.1495845317840576,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,5.31143045425415,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.874317467212677,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.968441605567932,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.541111946105957,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.464837670326233,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,5.848708629608154,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.052129030227661,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.8598595261573792,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.00711727142334,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,4.919105529785156,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.8922476768493652,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.1733291149139404,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.2415215969085691,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.0334391593933105,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,7.3405375480651855,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.9525296688079832,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.9753875732421875,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.7646095752716064,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.9450645446777344,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,7.637591361999512,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.123205184936523,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.415600299835205,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.9733341932296753,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.5394525527954102,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,7.0515923500061035,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.050936222076416,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.7192400693893433,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.5215465426445007,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,3.2917227745056152,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.4567350745201111,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.066003799438477,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.4726160168647766,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.9953548908233643,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,44.39604187011719,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,44.39604187011719,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,47.30126953125,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.8136197328567505,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.4906508922576904,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.651115894317627,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.1940021514892578,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.149388790130615,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.953861117362976,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.749428153038025,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.577893614768982,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.3279093503952026,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.6090922355651855,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.77734637260437,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.1677595376968384,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.034265518188477,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,4.979371547698975,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.6642154455184937,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.0953123569488525,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.0730259418487549,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.882713794708252,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,6.715267658233643,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.9645901918411257,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.8950921297073364,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.8526214361190796,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.8529897928237915,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,7.565293788909912,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.0177786350250244,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.3366755247116089,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.9079970121383667,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.4788309335708618,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,6.741281986236572,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.9115855097770692,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.8045964241027832,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.6409468650817871,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,3.357128620147705,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.4442209005355835,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.046152830123902,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.3434057235717773,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.833779573440552,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,42.95060348510742,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,42.95060348510742,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,45.289119720458984,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.6540201902389526,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.47904634475708,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.5704810619354248,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.7185280323028564,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,4.4220757484436035,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.8064295649528503,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.892849326133728,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.3978567123413086,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.149266242980957,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,5.246402263641357,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.8707867860794067,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.8344417810440063,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.876574993133545,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,4.581803321838379,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.7180523872375488,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.047194719314575,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.066144943237305,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.9879635572433472,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,6.819355487823486,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.79299795627594,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.7646952867507937,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.6568758487701416,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.8287357091903689,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,7.043304920196533,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.9766952991485596,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.407860279083252,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.918299674987793,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.44915509223938,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,6.752010345458984,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.0534629821777344,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.1023974418640137,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.8290691375732422,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,3.9849295616149902,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.3875555992126465,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.4990321397781372,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.4124601483345032,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.2990477085113525,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,41.148929595947266,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,41.148929595947266,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,44.61556625366211,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.6456232666969299,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.2897052764892578,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.599609613418579,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.8175690174102783,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,4.3525071144104,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.871646523475647,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.5666637420654297,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.3004798889160156,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.289815068244934,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,5.028604984283447,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.9112483263015747,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.9499321579933168,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.702580809593201,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,4.563761234283447,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.5817654132843018,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.867536783218384,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.9601165652275084,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.9709712266921997,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,6.38038969039917,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.8403874635696411,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.9043725728988647,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.7440789937973022,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.7739322185516355,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,7.262771129608154,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.81497061252594,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.91486918926239,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.8355302810668943,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.4986990690231323,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,7.0640692710876465,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.87163907289505,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.8826513290405271,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.886598527431488,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,3.6408889293670654,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.4563388526439667,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.6139707565307615,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.4965122938156128,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.566821813583374,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,40.85981369018555,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,40.85981369018555,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,43.42579650878906,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.6465319395065308,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.46608567237854,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.7183629274368286,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.0641891956329346,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,4.895169734954834,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.7435829043388367,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.7831190824508667,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.49590802192688,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.3286046981811523,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,5.35121488571167,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.013174295425415,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.25232994556427,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.7333537340164185,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,4.9988579750061035,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.8289557695388792,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.028637647628784,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.0860872268676758,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.975217580795288,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,6.918898582458496,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.7855523824691772,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.0099170207977295,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.6944457292556765,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.8685439825057983,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,7.358458995819092,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.867512345314026,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.347908616065979,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.8612812757492063,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.4622799158096311,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,6.538981914520264,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.059342384338379,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.9606877565383911,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.728191614151001,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,3.748221874237061,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.4065206348896026,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.576360106468201,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.3614146411418915,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.3442952632904053,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,42.15409851074219,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,42.15409851074219,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,45.21994400024414,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.7025269865989685,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.567119002342224,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.5063635110855105,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.0897338390350342,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,4.865743160247803,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.8671319484710693,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.9477109909057615,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.5840870141983032,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.320335030555725,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,5.719264984130859,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.7722851037979126,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.214213252067566,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.8424121141433716,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,4.8289103507995605,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.7994171380996704,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.2039592266082764,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.0717430114746094,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.9577127695083616,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,7.032832145690918,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.8575421571731567,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.9697827100753784,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.8584346771240232,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.9130399227142336,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,7.598799705505371,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.073786735534668,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.4125739336013794,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.9020555019378664,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.5336605310440063,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,6.92207670211792,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.9208738803863524,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.8319902420043943,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.5669105648994446,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,3.319774627685547,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.4221056997776031,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.0689754486083984,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.3348122537136078,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.8258931636810303,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,43.11329650878906,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,43.11329650878906,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,45.990535736083984,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.8702037334442139,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.7594016790390017,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.8970767259597776,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.217655897140503,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.744338035583496,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.952934741973877,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.9706077575683592,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.484695553779602,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.4902989864349363,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.898536682128906,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.884410381317139,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.2654948234558103,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.0149502754211426,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.164855480194092,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.7670774459838867,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.0285897254943848,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.0952860116958618,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.8973761796951296,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,6.788329124450684,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.8368624448776243,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.8957339525222776,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.6564275026321411,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.9433445930480957,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,7.33236837387085,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.0053558349609375,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.429241180419922,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.102699041366577,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.5691696405410769,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,7.106465816497803,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.9324268102645874,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.7261439561843872,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.6620961427688599,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,3.320666790008545,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.4500836431980133,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.283078908920288,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.5149809122085571,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,3.248143196105957,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,44.60370635986328,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,44.60370635986328,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,46.59224319458008,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.0462090969085691,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.8092275857925415,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.7463873624801636,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.6142727136611938,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,6.2160964012146,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.0386970043182373,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.038615465164185,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.6848020553588867,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.5594079494476318,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,6.3215227127075195,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.7194678783416748,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.615925669670105,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.9998620748519895,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.3352556228637695,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.8856384754180908,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.115497350692749,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.330535650253296,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.9463855028152464,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,7.278057098388672,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.9496699571609497,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.95588481426239,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.809769868850708,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.940839409828186,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,7.656164169311523,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.0227341651916504,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.418873906135559,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.041576385498047,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.5472368001937866,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,7.030421257019043,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.0401146411895752,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.742799162864685,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.3879134953022003,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,3.1708273887634277,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.4689491391181946,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.5039799213409424,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.489917129278183,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,3.462846279144287,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,46.47119140625,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,46.47119140625,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,48.61993408203125,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.8757608532905579,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.4730631113052368,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.6104902029037476,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.9613946676254272,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,4.920708656311035,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.7994112372398376,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.7194424867630005,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.4657918214797974,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.29835045337677,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,5.28299617767334,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.8664988279342651,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.7420250177383423,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.024104595184326,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,4.632628440856934,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.7374461889266968,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.1429572105407715,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.0647881031036377,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.543373465538025,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,6.488564968109131,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.854560613632202,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.8907701969146729,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.8264832496643064,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.8567824363708496,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,7.428596496582031,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.9969782829284668,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.4275697469711304,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.0560972690582275,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.5074102878570557,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,6.98805570602417,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.1243164539337158,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.8893290758132937,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.671306848526001,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,3.6849524974823,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.4360860884189605,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.136467456817627,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.3740417659282684,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.9465951919555664,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,42.37309646606445,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,42.37309646606445,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,44.604888916015625,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.7996049523353577,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.622511863708496,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.828366756439209,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.5548131465911863,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,5.805296421051025,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.8481396436691284,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.161947250366211,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.8751238584518433,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.6135578155517578,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,6.498768329620361,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.932671904563904,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.8980109095573425,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.962237238883972,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,4.792920112609863,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.1677796840667725,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.3557324409484863,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.6434112787246704,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.1188247203826904,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,8.285748481750488,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.884900689125061,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.927996039390564,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.9128628969192505,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.8857371807098389,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,7.611496925354004,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.1434521675109863,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.8938250541687012,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.044677495956421,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.631040096282959,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,7.712994575500488,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.281826138496399,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.3459250926971436,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.3363723754882812,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,4.964123725891113,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.4363862574100494,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.282114267349243,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.4215337932109833,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,3.1400341987609863,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,48.81138229370117,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,48.81138229370117,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,53.29575729370117,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.8300149440765381,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.5476220846176147,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.7419987916946411,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.3598356246948242,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,5.479471683502197,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.8663119077682495,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.7889821529388428,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.43211567401886,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.4217644929885864,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,5.509174346923828,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.9289278984069824,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.2803800106048584,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.9433749914169312,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,5.152682781219482,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.7675294876098633,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.116318702697754,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.3586688041687012,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.7373157739639282,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,6.979832649230957,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.8364121913909912,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.9817456007003784,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.837791919708252,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.951118230819702,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,7.607068061828613,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.0778515338897705,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.389722228050232,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.08697509765625,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.5765042304992676,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,7.1310529708862305,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.782420814037323,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.7984495162963867,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.6890103816986084,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,3.269880771636963,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.4536633491516113,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.381004810333252,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.3533509969711303,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,3.188019037246704,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,44.31718063354492,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,44.31718063354492,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,46.36662673950195,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.6469606757164001,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.5851120948791504,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.6749801635742188,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.4309271574020386,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,5.337979793548584,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.7085155248641968,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.9124938249588013,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.4502973556518557,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.2804642915725708,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,5.351771354675293,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.745962381362915,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.034987211227417,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.8889789581298828,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,4.669928550720215,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.7943964004516602,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.0916316509246826,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.0886112451553345,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.934045672416687,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,6.908684730529785,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.7746565341949463,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.9686338901519775,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.7940255403518677,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.9451948404312136,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,7.482511043548584,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.047128438949585,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.420274257659912,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.9716061353683472,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.520274996757507,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,6.959283828735352,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.8838337063789368,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.6396639347076416,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.4677267372608185,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.991224527359009,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.3984691202640533,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.8711798191070557,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.369051069021225,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.638700008392334,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,42.340084075927734,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,42.340084075927734,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,44.894649505615234,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.7838811278343201,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.496164321899414,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.6682777404785156,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.5496872663497925,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,5.498010635375977,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.8073852062225342,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.8141359090805056,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.4010895490646362,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.3686364889144895,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,5.391247272491455,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.0181753635406494,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.9345381259918212,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.924594521522522,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,4.877307891845703,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.8602882623672483,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.142226457595825,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.2640321254730225,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.0579757690429688,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,7.324522495269775,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.852946400642395,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.95341956615448,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.9501370191574097,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.009291172027588,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,7.765794277191162,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.110523223876953,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.419457197189331,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.8466129302978516,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.531490445137024,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,6.908083915710449,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.0509508848190308,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.7206101417541504,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.4377169907093048,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,3.209278106689453,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.4282152056694031,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.9335869550704956,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.4298566281795501,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.791658639907837,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,43.76590347290039,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,43.76590347290039,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,46.48080062866211,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.8889245390892029,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.6172250509262085,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.6148682832717896,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.3023806810379028,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.423398494720459,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.0181206464767456,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.8255112171173096,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.580551028251648,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.4725710153579712,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.896753787994385,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.0425660610198975,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.2222493886947632,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.003514528274536,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.268330097198486,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.8055667877197263,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.0797739028930664,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.1945781707763672,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.097008466720581,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,7.17692756652832,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.9239861965179443,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.98668372631073,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.757647156715393,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.975650191307068,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,7.643967151641846,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.054722309112549,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.5602965354919434,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.158986806869507,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.5049418210983276,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,7.278947353363037,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.9215227961540222,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.8871270418167112,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.3594792485237121,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,3.168128967285156,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.4924706220626831,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.4928576946258545,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.4696195721626282,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,3.454947710037231,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,45.3114013671875,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,45.3114013671875,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,47.47110748291016,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.7798765301704407,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.4611656665802002,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.5627431869506836,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.3526508808135986,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,5.156436443328857,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.7575600147247314,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.9036673307418823,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.30679452419281,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.4629064798355105,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,5.4309282302856445,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.9853672981262207,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.9039816856384276,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.9659461975097656,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,4.855295181274414,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.852170467376709,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.0907692909240723,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.1406912803649902,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.984155297279358,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,7.067786693572998,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.73640775680542,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.7030109167099,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.8903294801712036,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.8391584157943728,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,7.168906211853027,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.9258646965026855,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.3926544189453125,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.121577739715576,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.5010685920715332,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,6.941165447235107,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.082472562789917,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.9308732748031616,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.6736275553703308,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,3.6869733333587646,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.352675050497055,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.776861548423767,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.3623548448085785,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.491891384124756,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,42.79938125610352,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,42.79938125610352,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,45.951416015625,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.979208767414093,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.4814181327819824,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.5279312133789062,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.2844914197921753,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,5.273049354553223,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.7633076906204224,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.8941020965576172,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.528872847557068,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.2739992141723633,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,5.460281848907471,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.9503315687179563,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.5975695848464966,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.026796579360962,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,4.574697494506836,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.3097693920135498,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.896427869796753,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.0049819946289062,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.050931692123413,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,6.262110710144043,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.7527607679367063,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.9488492012023928,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.795976996421814,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.8245326280593872,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,7.32211971282959,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.7777103185653689,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.3508871793746948,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.338236093521118,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.542577862739563,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,7.009411334991455,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.804734468460083,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.9360989332199097,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.3548548817634582,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,3.0956883430480957,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.4015891849994659,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.4489264488220215,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.4452419877052307,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,3.295757532119751,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,42.29311752319336,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,42.29311752319336,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,43.853614807128906,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.7710683345794678,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.425783395767212,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.6449992656707764,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.468956470489502,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.310807228088379,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.810205340385437,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.6422088146209717,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.3993170261383057,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.3393486738204956,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.191080093383789,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.8462815284729004,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.9396243095397948,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.935871958732605,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,4.72177791595459,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.7218730449676514,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.0011773109436035,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.1347116231918335,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.9648919105529783,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,6.822653770446777,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.8057881593704224,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.960664749145508,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.8216755390167236,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.8450350761413576,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,7.433163642883301,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.987844944000244,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.5288479328155518,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.0023739337921143,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.530118703842163,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,7.049185752868652,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.9233917593955994,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.4592955112457275,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.3416761457920074,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.724363327026367,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.348911851644516,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.1474497318267822,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.4204226732254028,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.916784286499023,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,42.16981506347656,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,42.16981506347656,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,44.25479888916016,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.7599011659622192,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.4623717069625854,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.7753633260726929,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.2609657049179075,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,5.258601665496826,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.8731436729431152,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.7450882196426392,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.4538652896881104,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.4365487098693848,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,5.508646011352539,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.9971346855163576,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.311669945716858,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.9539334774017336,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,5.262738227844238,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.719316005706787,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.9599061012268064,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.130767583847046,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.0079469680786133,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,6.817936897277832,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.9012924432754517,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.8490666151046753,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.654066562652588,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.916596293449402,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,7.321022033691406,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.947552800178528,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.4847356081008911,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.034971237182617,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.499603509902954,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,6.96686315536499,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.9356822371482848,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.9306466579437256,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.4352335929870605,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,3.301562547683716,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.3864138424396515,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.1266777515411377,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.4201931357383728,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.9332847595214844,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,43.37065505981445,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,43.37065505981445,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,45.572811126708984,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.8573657274246216,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.5100395679473877,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.639118790626526,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.3591541051864624,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,5.365678310394287,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.7788081169128418,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.8039952516555784,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.4780380725860596,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.3933380842208862,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,5.454179286956787,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.9914758205413816,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.222487449645996,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.808062434196472,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,5.0220255851745605,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.7456506490707395,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.9728175401687624,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.195371389389038,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.9622856378555296,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,6.876125335693359,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.8018312454223633,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.9509007930755615,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.8051389455795288,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.9580109119415283,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,7.515881538391113,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.9528573751449585,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.907281756401062,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.0403707027435303,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.4859461784362793,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,7.38645601272583,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.9318774342536926,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.5039490461349487,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.6506282091140747,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,3.0864546298980713,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.3865976333618164,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.041945219039917,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.3622119724750519,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.790754556655884,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,43.497554779052734,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,43.497554779052734,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,45.80430603027344,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.6806641221046448,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.493838906288147,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.6064610481262207,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.1193073987960815,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,4.900271415710449,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.7619374990463257,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.9931390285491943,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.4949816465377808,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.6140902042388916,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,5.8641486167907715,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.0332109928131104,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.8257609605789185,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.932265281677246,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,4.7912373542785645,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.906690239906311,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.016152858734131,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.1869968175888062,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.018167495727539,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,7.128007411956787,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.7386826276779177,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.9427804946899416,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.8327745199203491,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.9540836811065672,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,7.468321323394775,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.1077301502227783,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.8889952898025513,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.075714111328125,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.4858462810516355,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,7.558285713195801,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.0041720867156982,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.9000738859176636,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.5145084857940674,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,3.4187543392181396,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.3513670563697815,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.8819687366485596,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.415964663028717,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.649300336837769,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,43.77832794189453,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,43.77832794189453,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,47.04634475708008,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.7046257853507996,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.4577559232711792,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.716766595840454,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.4964323043823242,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,5.375580787658691,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.8561202883720398,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.8729413747787476,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.4549710750579834,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.3238879442214966,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,5.507920742034912,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.022471189498902,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.937920331954956,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.84721839427948,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,4.807610034942627,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.5016744136810305,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.892892599105835,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.993471622467041,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.9353631734848025,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,6.323401927947998,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.8103545904159544,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.9378979206085205,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.805253863334656,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.9305284023284912,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,7.484035015106201,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.076061964035034,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.3936355113983154,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.089364528656006,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.567320466041565,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,7.126382827758789,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.8135346174240112,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.909543514251709,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.6349437832832336,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,3.358021974563598,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.4161420166492462,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.209083795547486,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.4784041047096252,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,3.1036298274993896,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,43.08658218383789,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,43.08658218383789,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,44.7812614440918,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.7728315591812134,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.4821864366531372,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.6112654209136963,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.9755772352218628,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,4.841860771179199,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.7459737062454224,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.833682656288147,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.5469424724578855,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.309615135192871,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,5.436213970184326,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.8533097505569456,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.9289610981941224,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.9596519470214844,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,4.741922855377197,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.8675144910812376,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.1366164684295654,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.1557402610778809,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.027259349822998,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,7.187130451202393,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.728795886039734,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.904282808303833,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.8207944631576536,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.9075771570205688,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,7.3614501953125,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.0608556270599365,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.3748314380645752,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.095020532608032,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.4865576028823853,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,7.017265319824219,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.0677998065948486,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.0130560398101807,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.7092800140380859,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,3.7901358604431152,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.397053599357605,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.9640092849731443,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.4194291830062866,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.780492067337036,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,43.156471252441406,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,43.156471252441406,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,46.345062255859375,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.8131647109985352,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.4684805870056152,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.7295547723770142,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.0822057723999023,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.093405723571777,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.8713464736938477,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.797585368156433,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.5248653888702393,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.361366868019104,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.555164337158203,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.086564540863037,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.3686712980270386,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.9127976894378664,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.3680338859558105,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.6512364149093628,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.9554513692855835,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.0346280336380005,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.0127038955688477,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,6.654019832611084,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.8848352432250977,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.888572573661804,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.6577117443084717,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.8867114782333376,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,7.317831039428711,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.0215659141540527,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.733084797859192,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.0199124813079834,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.442845106124878,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,7.217408180236816,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.0073602199554443,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.889094352722168,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.6016333103179932,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,3.4980878829956055,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.4493404626846313,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.2629990577697754,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.4329565763473511,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,3.145296096801758,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,43.849246978759766,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,43.849246978759766,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,45.81119918823242,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.8756240606307983,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.66749107837677,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.664423584938049,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.4632190465927124,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,5.67075777053833,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.8989921808242798,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.7904459238052368,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.6485313177108765,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.4358689785003662,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,5.773838520050049,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.0452470779418945,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.5293257236480713,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.839695930480957,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,5.414268970489502,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.895387887954712,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.148674249649048,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.1617389917373655,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.9895492792129517,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,7.195350170135498,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.8868894577026367,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.9317848682403564,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.7211849689483645,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.977945327758789,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,7.517804622650147,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.116307020187378,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.4217743873596191,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.832082986831665,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.468713402748108,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,6.838878154754639,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.054062843322754,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.821367144584656,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.6634608507156372,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,3.538890838623047,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.4813520014286041,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.9947782754898071,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.5793267488479614,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,3.0554568767547607,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,45.005245208740234,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,45.005245208740234,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,47.42869567871094,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.8414862155914307,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.527635931968689,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.7183489799499512,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.3954308032989502,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,5.4829020500183105,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.8532755970954895,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.7306597232818604,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.4522641897201538,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.629287838935852,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,5.665487289428711,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.0996060371398926,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.6484111547470093,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.070793390274048,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,5.81881046295166,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.9316238164901731,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.1640608310699463,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.1915690898895264,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.903501033782959,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,7.1907548904418945,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.819863557815552,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.8708921670913696,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.65577232837677,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.916433572769165,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,7.2629618644714355,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.0562870502471924,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.4174884557724,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.006199836730957,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.4491379261016846,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,6.929113388061523,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.1762460470199585,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.8626041412353516,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.7256675362586975,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,3.764517784118652,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.4130560457706451,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.8010592460632324,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.3799571692943573,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.5940723419189453,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,44.7086181640625,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,44.7086181640625,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,47.46699523925781,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.8199962973594666,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.5674535036087036,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.5983343124389648,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.4920953512191772,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,5.477879524230957,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.8846977949142456,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.7128502130508425,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.429431438446045,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.4196938276290894,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,5.446673393249512,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.1199238300323486,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.533195972442627,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.991034150123596,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,5.644154071807861,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.087993860244751,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.2172253131866455,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.2765657901763916,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.8496378660202024,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,7.431422710418701,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.7823878526687622,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.7564178705215454,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.7207684516906738,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.9664535522460935,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,7.226027965545654,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.09700345993042,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.3961700201034546,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.0491275787353516,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.5329331159591677,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,7.075234413146973,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.1053531169891355,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.853074550628662,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.5598349571228027,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,3.5182626247406006,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.3997691571712494,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.055830717086792,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.4903798103332519,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.945979595184326,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,44.76563262939453,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,44.76563262939453,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,47.40056228637695,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.8066675066947937,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.4819326400756836,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.6949584484100342,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.0562301874160769,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.039788722991943,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.8405236005783081,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.8407994508743288,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.364052414894104,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.4222559928894043,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.4676313400268555,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.9230796098709104,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.0657634735107422,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.0424554347991943,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.031298637390137,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.8571091890335083,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.1595985889434814,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.291227102279663,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.0148251056671143,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,7.322759628295898,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.8902939558029177,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.8669735193252563,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.7174440622329712,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.9355524778366089,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,7.410264015197754,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.0750977993011475,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.34929621219635,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.3121960163116455,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.5923957824707031,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,7.328985691070557,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.1725823879241943,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.9428634643554688,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.82267165184021,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,3.938117504119873,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.4666336476802826,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.019179582595825,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.5068050622940063,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.9926183223724365,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,44.531463623046875,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,44.531463623046875,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,47.53953170776367,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.8669897317886353,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.4196722507476809,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.5381274223327637,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.6792675256729126,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,4.504056930541992,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.926193118095398,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.492180109024048,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.293315291404724,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.3237892389297483,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,5.035477638244629,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.993784546852112,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.6724917888641357,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.9322024583816528,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,4.5984787940979,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.615741729736328,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.0468082427978516,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.046407699584961,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.9821566343307495,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,6.69111442565918,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.9026614427566528,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.8318142890930176,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.717243790626526,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.8857579231262207,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,7.337477207183838,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.9609109163284304,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.715828537940979,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.382641315460205,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.5440316200256348,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,7.60341215133667,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.9934430718421936,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.7774986028671265,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.3704631924629211,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,3.141404867172241,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.422133207321167,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.7373385429382324,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.4416429996490478,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,3.6011147499084473,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,42.51253890991211,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,42.51253890991211,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,44.34108352661133,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.9088440537452698,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.4895873069763184,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.5206624269485474,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.0871649980545044,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,5.006258964538574,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.8922953009605408,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.6202784776687622,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.2491477727890017,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.3739029169082642,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,5.135624408721924,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.9001617431640625,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.3086848258972168,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.8379156589508057,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,5.046761989593506,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.8947569131851196,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.2573208808898926,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.404407978057861,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.006086587905884,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,7.562572479248047,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.8205926418304443,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.828819274902344,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.7185771465301514,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.899136662483215,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,7.267125606536865,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.9890587329864504,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.7008322477340698,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.9627938270568848,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.5046370029449463,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,7.157321453094482,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.1711797714233398,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.922431230545044,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.5931038856506348,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,3.6867148876190186,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.4395267069339752,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.5337378978729248,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.4266881942749023,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.3999526500701904,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,43.262332916259766,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,43.262332916259766,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,46.7933464050293,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.6595726013183594,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.3327075242996216,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.5366681814193726,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.772386372089386,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,4.301334857940674,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.8167534470558167,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.6096233129501345,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.289751410484314,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.2034755945205688,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,4.9196038246154785,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.057130813598633,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.9098080992698668,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.7798951864242554,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,4.7468342781066895,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.6882470846176147,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.9418013095855713,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.177605390548706,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.7162431478500366,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,6.523897171020508,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.718364119529724,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.8597944974899292,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.7186797857284546,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.8109248876571655,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,7.107763290405273,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.919190049171448,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.1107853651046753,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.8338593244552612,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.4783120155334473,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,6.342146873474121,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.1281390190124512,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.8429208993911743,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.8057094216346741,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,3.776769399642944,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.4462019205093384,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.592495322227478,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.3343376219272613,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.373034715652466,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,40.09138488769531,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,40.09138488769531,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,42.9151496887207,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.6776463389396667,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.3736876249313354,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.509015440940857,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.1362954378128052,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,4.6966447830200195,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.7607956528663635,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.962348699569702,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.4637184143066406,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.3340376615524292,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,5.520900726318359,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.1110424995422363,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.980208694934845,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.8415024280548096,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,4.932753562927246,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.8251334428787231,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.147141933441162,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.2646585702896118,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.972279071807861,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,7.209212779998779,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.7231566905975342,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.919327974319458,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.7563461065292358,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.9241713285446167,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,7.323002338409424,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.063450336456299,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.938194274902344,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.9902288913726809,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.5949004888534546,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,7.586773872375488,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.1579269170761108,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.9044147729873655,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.503180980682373,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,3.5655226707458496,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.3531164824962616,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.6531459093093872,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.4082895219326019,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.4145519733428955,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,43.24936294555664,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,43.24936294555664,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,46.71226119995117,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.7006906270980835,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.2195078134536743,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.2899008989334106,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.915706217288971,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,4.125805377960205,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.795643150806427,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.5101556777954102,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.4069442749023438,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.327771782875061,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,5.040514945983887,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.9807614088058472,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.9831790924072266,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.8485411405563352,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,4.812481880187988,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.6965909004211426,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.047179698944092,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.0418332815170288,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.8673523664474487,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,6.652956008911133,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.7060619592666626,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.8769675493240356,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.478365421295166,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.8884128332138064,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,6.949807643890381,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.0520009994506836,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.3407657146453855,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.7629051208496094,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.4559341669082642,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,6.611606121063232,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.9601223468780518,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.9028451442718504,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.7401639223098755,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,3.6031315326690674,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.3317418098449707,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.711079716682434,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.3526009619235992,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.3954224586486816,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,40.19172668457031,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,40.19172668457031,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,43.21870803833008,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.6486067175865173,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.3635926246643066,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.3040120601654053,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.6790274381637573,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,3.995238780975342,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.7883248329162598,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.2842084169387815,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.2012200355529783,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.2639950513839722,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,4.537748336791992,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.9830247163772583,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.6577741503715515,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.7629032135009766,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,4.403702259063721,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.4029721021652222,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.8472498655319216,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.9717869758605956,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.888024926185608,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,6.110033988952637,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.694355010986328,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.615381956100464,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.676689386367798,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.8617384433746336,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,6.848165035247803,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.9535348415374756,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.1369848251342773,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.0512142181396484,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.5157414674758911,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,7.657475471496582,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.8335664868354797,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.7502778768539429,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.6045441031455994,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,3.1883883476257324,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.3577563166618347,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.6766369342803955,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.3654364347457886,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.399829626083374,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,39.14058303833008,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,39.14058303833008,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,41.50613784790039,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.6833565831184387,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.3767420053482056,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.374248743057251,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.3693439960479736,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,4.803691387176514,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.8002898097038269,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.5886348485946655,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.3949381113052368,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.3545712232589722,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,5.138433933258057,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.971226453781128,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.8088775277137756,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.8148293495178225,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,4.59493350982666,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.540701150894165,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.9101781845092771,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.1130729913711548,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.984221577644348,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,6.548173904418945,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.7553393840789795,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.7833188772201538,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.6387550830841064,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.817282795906067,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,6.994696140289307,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.0097992420196533,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.3400822877883911,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.0683863162994385,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.470134973526001,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,6.888402938842773,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.9742382764816284,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.87747323513031,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.595229983329773,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,3.446941614151001,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.3658212423324585,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.6113771200180054,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.3535563945770263,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.3307547569274902,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,40.74602890014648,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,40.74602890014648,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,43.56644058227539,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.7332187294960022,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.4243930578231812,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.2951345443725586,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.8867699503898621,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,4.3395161628723145,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.7241836786270142,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.5950689315795898,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.2655079364776611,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.4839359521865845,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,5.06869649887085,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.0207595825195312,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.8536978363990784,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.8672325611114504,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,4.741689682006836,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.59552800655365,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.9896925687789917,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.2144315242767334,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.95641827583313,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,6.756070137023926,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.771074652671814,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.9348094463348389,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.8274219036102295,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.9134446382522583,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,7.446750640869141,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.9630287885665896,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.5651772022247314,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.952162742614746,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.373140811920166,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,6.853509426116943,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.0212697982788086,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.856371283531189,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.3657421767711639,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,3.2433834075927734,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.392650842666626,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.788997769355774,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.3471834361553192,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.528831958770752,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,40.97844696044922,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,40.97844696044922,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,43.73169708251953,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.8220903277397156,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.480563044548035,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.4835959672927856,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.1439290046691897,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,4.930178642272949,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.8498923182487488,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.5988932847976685,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.413263916969299,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.3237292766571045,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,5.185778617858887,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.9377323389053345,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.960534930229187,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.809377670288086,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,4.707644939422607,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.4891945123672483,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8870474100112915,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.0319852828979492,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.6519352197647097,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,6.060162544250488,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8775743246078491,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8344417810440063,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.7337127923965454,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8188079595565796,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,7.2645368576049805,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.0962395668029785,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.9501090049743652,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.968028903007507,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.3783425092697144,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,7.392719745635986,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.8540086150169373,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.727431058883667,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.5807453989982605,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,3.162184953689575,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.4267998933792114,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.079911708831787,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.4170396625995636,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.9237513542175293,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,41.626956939697266,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,41.626956939697266,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,43.24506759643555,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.7398802638053894,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.4566715955734253,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.5592992305755615,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.0949007272720337,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,4.850751876831055,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.8040885925292969,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.5632508993148804,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.326630473136902,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.3712950944900513,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,5.06526517868042,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.001246452331543,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.9793866276741028,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.000760078430176,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,4.981393337249756,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.58357036113739,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.005251407623291,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.0143476724624634,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.8552485704421997,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,6.458417892456055,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.763627052307129,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.874789118766785,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.6587162017822266,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.8285115957260132,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,7.125643730163574,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.9066256284713743,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.957783818244934,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.9342390298843384,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.459054946899414,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,7.2577033042907715,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.002218246459961,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.9997034072875977,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.4937913417816162,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,3.495712995529175,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.3612950146198272,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.2479701042175293,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.3525743782520294,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.961839437484741,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,42.19672775268555,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,42.19672775268555,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,44.17594146728515,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.8279852271080017,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.4301137924194336,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.619168758392334,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.0823087692260742,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,4.959576606750488,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.8306013941764832,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.7530803680419922,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.3942302465438845,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.3666660785675049,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,5.344578266143799,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.985224723815918,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.0412838459014893,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.9998509883880615,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,5.026359558105469,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.5337457656860352,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.9336788654327393,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.0082619190216064,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.909135341644287,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,6.384821891784668,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.743532657623291,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.8142069578170776,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.5287715196609497,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.9115124940872192,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,6.998023986816406,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.0109994411468506,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.3143000602722168,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.97734797000885,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.5295543670654297,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,6.832201957702637,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.8608469367027283,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.8520997762680056,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.5022798180580139,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,3.215226411819458,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.3839157521724701,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.01477575302124,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.370530217885971,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.769221544265747,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,41.53001022338867,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,41.53001022338867,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,43.61188125610352,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.85764080286026,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.5067026615142822,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.5235594511032104,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.0364216566085815,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,4.9243245124816895,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.847445547580719,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.5026038885116575,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.3946937322616575,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.204479455947876,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,4.949222564697266,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.944057822227478,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.034590721130371,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.9631376266479492,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,4.941786289215088,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.540693283081055,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.9406629800796509,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.0648539066314695,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.9334958791732788,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,6.479706287384033,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.793474555015564,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.898255705833435,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.8285319805145264,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.9215381145477295,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,7.441800117492676,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.0510427951812744,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.3562630414962769,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.8703227043151855,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.4274345636367798,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,6.7050628662109375,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.9054542779922484,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.8421050310134888,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.5546439290046692,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,3.3022031784057617,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.4001424014568329,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.0842487812042236,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.4019701480865478,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.8863613605499268,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,41.63046646118164,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,41.63046646118164,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,43.4721794128418,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.6785308122634888,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.415336012840271,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.3845041990280151,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.9539660215377808,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,4.432337284088135,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.8058008551597595,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.3540441989898682,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.3056453466415403,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.221910834312439,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,4.687401294708252,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.9793332815170288,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.9583651423454284,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.0070056915283203,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,4.944704055786133,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.283005952835083,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.8281317949295044,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.9688795208930968,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.6391853094100952,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,5.719202518463135,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.6153080463409424,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.767985701560974,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.6154882907867432,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.7874492406845093,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,6.786231517791748,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.6990035772323608,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.6184076070785522,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.0164198875427246,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.434577703475952,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,6.76840877532959,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.7967526316642761,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.6088687181472778,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.4087165892124176,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.814337968826294,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.3603053987026214,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.7484138011932373,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.3618441820144653,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.4705631732940674,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,38.62318801879883,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,38.62318801879883,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,40.09600067138672,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.8731210827827454,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.5551162958145142,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.5708656311035156,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.7543628811836243,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,4.75346565246582,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.8255536556243896,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.879954218864441,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.5304759740829468,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.2643030881881714,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,5.500287055969238,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.0240745544433594,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.0756982564926147,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.9700182676315308,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,5.069790840148926,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.6857755184173584,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.029093027114868,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.0943245887756348,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.9435759782791135,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,6.7527689933776855,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.8206826448440552,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.8875967264175415,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.8470168113708496,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.8557592630386353,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,7.411055564880371,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.866357684135437,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.33182954788208,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.0562705993652344,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.4497215747833252,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,6.704179286956787,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.8756212592124939,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.7182925939559937,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.4424850642681122,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,3.0363988876342773,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.3985019028186798,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.240927457809448,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.3706158697605133,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,3.010045051574707,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,42.23799133300781,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,42.23799133300781,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,44.46638870239258,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.7231629490852356,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.3322969675064087,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.4743913412094116,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.993867814540863,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,4.523719310760498,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.7743546366691589,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.658865213394165,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.3623069524765017,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.263319969177246,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,5.058846950531006,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.1119654178619385,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.001109957695007,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.8184560537338257,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,4.9315314292907715,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.619925022125244,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.0108678340911865,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.2780888080596924,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.6651819944381714,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,6.574063777923584,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.8121792078018188,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.766382932662964,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.819384813308716,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.927310824394226,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,7.325257778167725,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.919999122619629,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.680263876914978,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.956401824951172,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.5102524757385254,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,7.0669169425964355,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.032640814781189,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.8382995128631592,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.3755888640880584,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,3.2465293407440186,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.3590412437915802,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.9005454778671265,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.3544028401374817,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.6139895915985107,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,41.34085464477539,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,41.34085464477539,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,43.720176696777344,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.7846113443374634,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.2638654708862305,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.4240403175354004,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.8176024556159973,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,4.290119647979736,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.8743214011192322,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.6833347082138062,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.1510214805603027,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.380175232887268,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,5.088852882385254,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.150210380554199,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.6726464033126831,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.8314645290374756,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,4.654321193695068,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.5554094314575195,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.949342131614685,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.0844597816467283,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.010098695755005,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,6.599310398101807,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.8365378379821775,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.9367001056671145,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.8960585594177248,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.8544766902923584,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,7.523773193359375,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.8491296768188477,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.3667736053466797,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.0912461280822754,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.4345663785934448,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,6.741715908050537,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.8766165375709534,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.832821011543274,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.3568493723869324,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,3.06628680229187,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.4024266600608825,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.037038803100586,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.3585357666015625,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.798001289367676,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,40.76238250732422,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,40.76238250732422,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,43.12986373901367,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.7658825516700745,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.4051570892333984,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.5388058423995972,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.9371297359466552,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,4.646975040435791,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.7936334013938904,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.7481578588485718,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.3215529918670654,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.3492131233215332,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,5.212557315826416,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.9225337505340576,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.9945032000541688,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.0563278198242188,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,4.97336483001709,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.6302655935287476,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.130359649658203,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.185396671295166,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.9708718061447144,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,6.916893482208252,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.8469319343566897,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.907248377799988,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.8325419425964355,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.9352620840072632,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,7.521984577178955,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.967345118522644,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.3431209325790403,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.965471625328064,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.4302620887756348,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,6.706199645996094,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.9974545836448668,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.824491262435913,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.4291846454143524,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,3.2511305809020996,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.395463079214096,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.4102132320404053,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.4697475731372833,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,3.275423765182495,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,42.5045280456543,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,42.5045280456543,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,44.66221237182617,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.809597909450531,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.441146731376648,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.5624383687973022,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.3544135093688965,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,5.167596340179443,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.8430328965187073,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.0485355854034424,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.428146481513977,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.4782112836837769,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,5.79792594909668,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.1221725940704346,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.98262619972229,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.0600101947784424,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,5.164809226989746,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.7712223529815674,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.0466644763946533,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.2442420721054075,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.0116567611694336,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,7.073785781860352,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.8583585023880005,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.9724675416946411,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.8101906776428225,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.9116675853729248,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,7.552684307098389,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.9486831426620483,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.910465121269226,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.306974411010742,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.464759349822998,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,7.630882263183594,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.016923904418945,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.8497426509857176,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.3603675067424774,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,3.227034091949463,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.4171964824199676,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.0308399200439453,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.3932735621929168,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.8413097858428955,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,44.45602798461914,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,44.45602798461914,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,47.137699127197266,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.9017622470855712,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.2940359115600586,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.3848062753677368,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.8647074699401855,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,4.445312023162842,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.8362493515014648,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.7353044748306274,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.5087214708328247,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.3013181686401367,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,5.381593227386475,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.0368683338165283,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.7761256694793701,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.9888052940368652,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,4.801799297332764,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.4229552745819092,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.9262036085128784,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.063145875930786,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.9509152173995972,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,6.36322021484375,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.8910408020019531,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.8773341178894043,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.718406081199646,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.8539392948150637,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,7.340720176696777,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.8117703199386597,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.896189570426941,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.262423276901245,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.3971433639526367,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,7.367526531219482,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.8808982372283936,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.5943092107772827,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.3448712825775146,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.8200788497924805,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.411783218383789,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.656917095184326,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.3957236409187317,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,3.464423656463623,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,41.98467254638672,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,41.98467254638672,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,43.58500671386719,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.7664510011672974,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.294563055038452,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.4198859930038452,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.4600861072540283,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,4.940986156463623,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.7235264778137207,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.6694611310958862,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.336557388305664,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.3416993618011477,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,5.071244239807129,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.104834794998169,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.7617679238319397,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.796369194984436,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,4.6629719734191895,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.8963912725448608,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.1811118125915527,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.4686986207962036,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.0860891342163086,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,7.632290840148926,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.8256877660751345,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.8880897760391235,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.8703088760375977,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.0131616592407227,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,7.597248077392578,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.978911519050598,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.3824485540390017,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.018594741821289,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.5230714082717896,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,6.903026103973389,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.1010075807571411,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.7438679933547974,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.4110637009143829,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,3.255939245223999,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.3734495043754577,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.8104451894760132,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.427600234746933,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.611494779586792,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,42.675201416015625,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,42.675201416015625,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,46.04851913452149,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.7161063551902771,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.326724886894226,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.5565804243087769,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.0752984285354614,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,4.674709796905518,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.7676705121994019,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.849772810935974,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.3090755939483645,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.371339201927185,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,5.297858238220215,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.203068971633911,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.8621365427970886,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.8564815521240232,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,4.921687126159668,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.8995898962020872,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.127159118652344,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.346649408340454,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.9723799228668213,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,7.345778465270996,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.780401587486267,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.5675593614578247,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.87008798122406,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.878794550895691,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,7.096843242645264,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.007366418838501,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.9622337818145752,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.765154242515564,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.3921858072280884,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,7.1269402503967285,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.095574975013733,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.9244858026504517,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.6125600934028625,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,3.6326210498809814,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.353136271238327,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.4624409675598145,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.3832480609416961,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.1988253593444824,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,42.295265197753906,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,42.295265197753906,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,46.049930572509766,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.9436757564544678,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.446543574333191,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.4397947788238523,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.0466426610946655,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,4.876657009124756,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.8413645625114441,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.7794407606124878,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.5727007389068604,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.4256964921951294,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,5.619202613830566,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.1858954429626465,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.3083491325378418,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.9632208347320557,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,5.457465171813965,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.029282808303833,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.176337957382202,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.5697472095489502,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.0498881340026855,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,7.82525634765625,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.8940566778182983,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.8983725309371948,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.912027359008789,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.9432458877563477,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,7.647702693939209,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.013160467147827,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.1364957094192505,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.1393966674804688,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.4509954452514648,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,6.740047931671143,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.2073681354522705,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.7775276899337769,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.8907467126846313,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,3.8756425380706783,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.3461112976074219,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.869486689567566,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.3717139661312103,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.5873119831085205,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,44.6292839050293,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,44.6292839050293,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,48.32609558105469,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.6594679951667786,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.2326103448867798,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.2240912914276123,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.941620111465454,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,4.0577898025512695,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.7870270609855652,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.4461605548858645,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.1630682945251465,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.3004759550094604,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,4.696732044219971,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.1336781978607178,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.7988176345825195,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.9347807168960571,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,4.867276668548584,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.913017511367798,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.1450726985931396,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.383297562599182,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.7140264511108398,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,7.15541410446167,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.9065020084381104,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.918362021446228,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.9726194143295288,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.042612791061402,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,7.8400959968566895,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.927197813987732,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.884994387626648,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.115804672241211,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.4114285707473757,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,7.339425086975098,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.2410138845443726,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.850656509399414,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.6042985916137695,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,3.6959691047668457,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.3561639487743377,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.770427703857422,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.5015278458595276,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.628119468688965,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,42.28082275390625,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,42.28082275390625,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,45.25869369506836,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.7015842199325562,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.318209171295166,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.1116749048233032,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.0466558933258057,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,4.178123950958252,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.7859315276145935,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.6131386756896973,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.271395206451416,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.201288819313049,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,4.871754169464111,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.017666816711426,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.8490140438079834,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.8660311698913576,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,4.7327117919921875,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.7621746063232422,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.146461248397827,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.393915772438049,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.9853535890579224,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,7.287905216217041,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.7063971757888794,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.960404872894287,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.824142336845398,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.881745219230652,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,7.372689723968506,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.080862522125244,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.3869470357894895,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.2750144004821777,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.4558706283569336,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,7.198694705963135,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.144820213317871,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.7654364109039309,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.6176855564117432,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,4.527942180633545,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.4329074025154114,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.140937566757202,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.4558456540107727,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,3.029690742492676,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,43.19951248168945,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,43.19951248168945,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,46.47503280639648,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.8285191059112549,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.3734900951385498,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.344794988632202,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.1737841367721558,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,4.720588207244873,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.8815099596977234,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.8173624277114868,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.6719850301742554,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.5345666408538818,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,5.905424118041992,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.162201404571533,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.0136432647705078,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.9619044065475464,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,5.137749195098877,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.0579867362976074,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.248745918273926,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.7241759300231934,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.084207057952881,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,8.11511516571045,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.9189985990524292,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.0055856704711914,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.9326272010803225,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.921542286872864,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,7.778753757476807,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.206566333770752,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.716434359550476,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.0889482498168945,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.4823260307312012,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,7.494274616241455,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.3154324293136597,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.8985888957977295,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.987622857093811,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,5.201643943786621,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.4431707262992859,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.7598918676376345,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.4044748246669769,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.6075375080108643,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,46.96108627319336,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,46.96108627319336,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,51.654998779296875,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.7095633149147034,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.191517949104309,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.3036516904830933,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.4122557640075684,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,4.616988658905029,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.6880912780761719,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.8009430170059204,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.2537850141525269,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.3714104890823364,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,5.114229679107666,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.0423758029937744,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.7297829389572144,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.99115252494812,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,4.76331090927124,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.8270601034164429,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.1226933002471924,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.428833246231079,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.029758930206299,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,7.408345699310303,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.765233039855957,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.7654669284820557,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.8693150281906128,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.9166463613510132,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,7.316661357879639,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.9937373399734497,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.8569360971450808,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.3085145950317383,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.472384333610535,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,7.631572246551514,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.210201859474182,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.9898821115493777,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.358704924583435,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,4.558788776397705,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.351000964641571,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.71400249004364,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.3775084912776947,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.442511796951294,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,43.85240936279297,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,43.85240936279297,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,47.702362060546875,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.7895235419273376,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.3352187871932983,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.347827434539795,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.7818813323974609,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,4.254451274871826,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.7409114241600037,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.4956361055374146,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.2402775287628174,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.3335704803466797,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,4.81039571762085,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.013620376586914,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.9289060831069946,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.898193597793579,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,4.840720176696777,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.6525609493255615,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.992276906967163,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.2210816144943235,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.007202386856079,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,6.873121738433838,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.798078179359436,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.8750388622283936,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.9016627073287964,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.887682318687439,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,7.462461948394775,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.8728010654449463,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.004008412361145,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.1635830402374268,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.4762965440750122,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,6.516689300537109,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.9632104635238647,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.90576171875,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.5579125285148621,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,3.426884651184082,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.3680731952190399,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.877474308013916,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.3732916712760925,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.6188392639160156,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,40.80356216430664,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,40.80356216430664,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,43.50883865356445,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.7665003538131714,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.3621723651885986,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.2662684917449951,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.316218614578247,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,4.711159706115723,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.7831494212150574,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.912919998168945,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.3355486392974854,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.3232667446136477,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,5.354885101318359,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.0903708934783936,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.7176229953765869,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.8905500173568728,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,4.698544025421143,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.771547555923462,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.030297040939331,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.3776694536209106,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.9906951189041135,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,7.1702094078063965,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.7782161235809326,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.880665302276611,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.6193519830703735,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.8141127824783323,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,7.09234619140625,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.9803348779678345,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.33336079120636,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.1065258979797363,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.5022536516189575,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,6.9224748611450195,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.077388048171997,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.7721431255340576,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.3208082914352417,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,4.170339584350586,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.3690904080867767,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.0004920959472656,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.3959557116031647,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.765538215637207,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,42.885498046875,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,42.885498046875,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,46.28231048583984,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.754503607749939,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.1993224620819092,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.339712381362915,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.1779634952545166,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,4.47150182723999,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.7932168841362,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.7012660503387451,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.4085798263549805,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.278124451637268,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,5.181187152862549,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.043729543685913,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.8831244707107544,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.9622180461883545,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,4.889071941375732,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.8655377626419067,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.1710665225982666,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.3185162544250488,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.753383755683899,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,7.108504295349121,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.80552875995636,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.9354002475738523,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.8003041744232178,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.8905413150787351,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,7.431774139404297,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.065744161605835,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.3391594886779783,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.0888655185699463,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.4790054559707642,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,6.972774505615234,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.1494790315628052,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.7581934928894043,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.500997543334961,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,4.408669948577881,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.3743917047977447,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.8327937126159668,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.4059816896915436,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.6131670475006104,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,43.07665252685547,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,43.07665252685547,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,46.42339324951172,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.6258389949798584,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.2529783248901367,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.0525349378585815,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.014688491821289,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,3.9460408687591553,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.7872902154922485,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.4221519231796265,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.0168226957321167,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.263190984725952,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,4.489455699920654,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.0041351318359375,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.5799363851547241,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.8140509128570557,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,4.398122310638428,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.8395875692367551,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.1567819118499756,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.2745692729949951,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.715777039527893,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,6.986715793609619,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.6419143676757812,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.8898334503173828,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.8419314622879028,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.8566430807113647,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,7.230322360992432,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.000683546066284,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.3691829442977903,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.909911036491394,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.455054759979248,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,6.734832286834717,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.1558024883270264,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.7135616540908811,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.731218695640564,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,3.6005828380584717,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.3545036017894745,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.345533013343811,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.390356570482254,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.09039306640625,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,39.47646713256836,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,39.47646713256836,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,42.99208068847656,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.6730191707611084,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.1730248928070068,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.346348524093628,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.0738592147827148,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,4.266252040863037,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.8054020404815674,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.5214227437973022,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.1243088245391846,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.3206419944763184,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,4.771775722503662,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.122709035873413,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.9206947684288024,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.95455801486969,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,4.99796199798584,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.5922834873199463,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.02443265914917,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.2186689376831057,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.9566547870635984,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,6.79203987121582,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.8203591108322144,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.8208829164505005,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.686285138130188,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.847229242324829,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,7.1747565269470215,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.0639636516571045,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.2861287593841553,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.122748613357544,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.4339478015899658,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,6.9067888259887695,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.0683374404907229,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.7603672742843628,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.549090564250946,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,3.377795457839966,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.3783375024795532,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.8783323764801023,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.3696344792842865,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.6263041496276855,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,40.913673400878906,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,40.913673400878906,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,43.50593948364258,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.7651944756507874,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.2080916166305542,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.5067518949508667,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.3591301441192627,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,4.839168071746826,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.7937422394752502,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.6915924549102783,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.3272310495376587,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.5402400493621826,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,5.352806091308594,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.165424108505249,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.7747606039047241,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.065162420272827,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,5.005346775054932,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.926313877105713,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.054149389266968,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.3673101663589478,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.016064405441284,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,7.363837718963623,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.741056203842163,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.942586064338684,papi8,d5_2_construction_permits,5.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.830455660820007,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.875424027442932,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,7.389522075653076,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.9367921352386477,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.0214085578918457,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.91597843170166,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.4804872274398804,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,6.354666709899902,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.233000874519348,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.874119758605957,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.5528966784477234,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,3.660017490386963,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.3706762194633484,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.0830495357513428,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.3542145490646362,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.8079402446746826,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,42.7733039855957,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,42.7733039855957,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2020,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,45.90592575073242,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.837394654750824,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.6157854795455933,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.5674337148666382,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.9893440008163452,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.009957790374756,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.949576199054718,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.9241316318511963,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.6740727424621582,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.385524034500122,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.933304786682129,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.8905308246612549,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.4604173302650451,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.9783321619033811,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,4.329280376434326,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.7164506912231443,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.0522594451904297,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.2244590520858765,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.0825355052948,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,7.075704574584961,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.5486443042755127,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.473710775375366,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.514841079711914,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,7.537196159362793,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.8658742904663088,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.7382572889328003,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.1657440662384033,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.024657964706421,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,7.794533729553223,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.0398125648498535,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.75900399684906,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.3621059954166412,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,3.1609225273132324,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.5223737955093384,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.589386224746704,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.4938907325267792,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,3.6056506633758545,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,44.44655227661133,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,44.44655227661133,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,48.23727798461914,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.6179083585739136,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.6184710264205933,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.4700456857681274,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.1221282482147217,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,4.828553199768066,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.8367171883583069,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.8818027973175049,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.4210513830184937,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.2067793607711792,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,5.34635066986084,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.844554781913757,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.4853744208812713,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.9608545303344729,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,4.290783882141113,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.64518404006958,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.0970518589019775,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.071752429008484,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.945154309272766,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,6.7591423988342285,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.490520715713501,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.256211042404175,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.5235424041748047,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,7.27027416229248,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.0675501823425293,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.7260905504226685,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.8720201253890991,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.9802993535995483,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,7.645960330963135,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.0202915668487549,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.9107048511505127,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.7682512998580933,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,3.6992475986480713,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.4294524788856506,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.0581135749816895,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.4740340411663055,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.9616000652313232,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,42.801910400390625,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,42.801910400390625,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,46.58797073364258,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.5932753682136536,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.5483452081680298,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.4461474418640137,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.9636305570602416,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,4.551398754119873,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.6671496629714966,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.7286479473114014,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.3577888011932373,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.06509530544281,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,4.818681716918945,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.63369619846344,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.4347341954708099,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.76990807056427,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,3.8383383750915527,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.4737344980239868,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.8855741024017336,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.1441622972488403,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.811858296394348,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,6.315329074859619,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.3715710639953613,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.0578784942626953,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.421447515487671,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,6.850897312164307,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.899945855140686,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.84630286693573,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.658085584640503,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.8157304525375368,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,7.220064640045166,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.9849242568016052,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.546317458152771,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.033863544464111,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,3.5651051998138428,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.3740459680557251,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.294764280319214,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.3625604212284088,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.0313706398010254,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,39.191184997558594,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,39.191184997558594,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,43.2766227722168,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.6571390628814697,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.6815677881240845,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.5611995458602903,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.9582085013389589,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,4.858114719390869,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.8377511501312256,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.8471873998641968,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.2923325300216677,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.2304600477218628,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.207731246948242,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.8993756771087649,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.5702365636825562,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.7796458005905151,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,4.249258041381836,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.684887409210205,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.073636770248413,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.2121057510375977,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.888943672180176,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,6.8595733642578125,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.517364025115967,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.106455087661743,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.3292222023010254,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,6.953041076660156,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.135953664779663,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.8797032833099363,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.8748904466629028,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.9057884216308592,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,7.796335697174072,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.050623893737793,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.801341891288757,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.7932454347610474,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,3.6452112197875977,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.457168847322464,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.6896361112594604,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.4369063377380371,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.5837113857269287,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,42.152976989746094,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,42.152976989746094,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,46.349239349365234,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.7243382334709167,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.582449197769165,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.5421689748764038,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.0881385803222656,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,4.9370951652526855,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.8753212094306946,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.9875675439834597,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.5008559226989746,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.2513223886489868,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,5.615067005157471,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.9109030961990356,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.4946397542953491,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.9822609424591064,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,4.387803554534912,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.8143630027770996,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.0872302055358887,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.2148643732070925,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.9662853479385376,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,7.082743167877197,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.4882683753967285,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.169172525405884,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.4700334072113037,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,7.127474308013916,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.096057176589966,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.7170279026031494,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.9643800258636477,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.0043795108795166,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,7.781844615936279,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.1493234634399414,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.9227478504180908,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.6565610766410828,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,3.72863245010376,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.428440511226654,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.906572699546814,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.4066015183925628,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.741614580154419,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,43.40227508544922,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,43.40227508544922,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,47.8547248840332,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.5887339115142822,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.6403603553771973,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.5252833366394043,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.6091517806053162,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,4.363529205322266,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.8146217465400696,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.7966129779815674,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.4408773183822632,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.1606614589691162,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.21277379989624,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.9155497550964355,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.4844609200954437,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.6652675867080688,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,4.065278053283691,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.3387746810913086,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.8135132789611816,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.977682888507843,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.825267672538757,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.9552388191223145,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.4846103191375732,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.2312068939208984,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.3721489906311035,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,7.087966442108154,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.8939672708511353,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.645825982093811,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.9276577234268188,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.944111943244934,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,7.411562919616699,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.7993184924125671,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.7227694988250732,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.7066261172294617,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,3.2287142276763916,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.5108452439308167,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.855479717254639,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.4600142538547516,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.8263392448425293,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,40.15140151977539,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,40.15140151977539,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,43.4713249206543,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.4947770535945892,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.3933109045028689,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.4971100091934204,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.7911125421524048,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,4.1763105392456055,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.7770643830299377,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.4256408214569092,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.2342182397842407,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.2439416646957395,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,4.680865287780762,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.014951705932617,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.4563925266265869,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.3763024806976318,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,3.847646951675415,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.193023681640625,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.6557502746582031,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.7351217865943909,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.83370041847229,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,5.417595863342285,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.4853625297546387,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.290807008743286,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.3378922939300537,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,7.1140618324279785,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.9388163089752195,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.017850637435913,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.6233800649642944,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.7757841348648071,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,6.355831146240234,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.7027490139007568,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.8250035047531128,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.0912896394729614,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,3.619042158126831,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.4300852417945862,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.1920444965362549,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.3895189464092254,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.011648654937744,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,37.22300338745117,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,37.22300338745117,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,40.43730926513672,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.7261810302734375,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.5776617527008057,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.5765507221221924,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.9941480755805968,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,4.874541759490967,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.8877558708190918,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.647335171699524,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.3197516202926636,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.1850318908691406,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,5.03987455368042,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.8770065307617188,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.5511391758918762,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.8552234172821045,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,4.283369064331055,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.4917832612991333,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.8898797035217283,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.9852388501167296,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.9378670454025269,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,6.3047685623168945,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.4781429767608643,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.4343717098236084,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.446443557739258,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,7.358958244323731,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.9383174180984497,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.9252876043319704,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.8187205791473389,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.9236421585083008,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,7.605967998504639,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.8573011159896851,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.0269649028778076,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.1279044151306152,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,4.012170791625977,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.4884730279445648,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.9249017238616943,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.4427135586738586,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.856088399887085,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,42.33573913574219,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,42.33573913574219,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,45.52452087402344,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.611294150352478,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.644232988357544,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.4753820896148682,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.0672587156295776,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,4.798167705535889,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.771615743637085,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.5614070892333984,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.2355693578720093,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.1293455362319946,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,4.697937488555908,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.8525348901748655,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.5044920444488525,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.7221925258636477,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,4.079219341278076,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.5971407890319824,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.835207462310791,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.0074381828308103,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.8801171779632568,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,6.319903373718262,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.4112112522125244,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.0412440299987793,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.453893661499023,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,6.906348705291748,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.953136920928955,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.6857964992523191,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.799193024635315,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.8962560892105105,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,7.3343825340271,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.962291181087494,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.9066473245620728,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.9367754459381104,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,3.805713891983032,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.3972117602825165,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.417530536651611,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.3854843974113464,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.2002265453338623,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,40.14189910888672,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,40.14189910888672,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,43.84703826904297,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.7062947154045105,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.544094443321228,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.6854287385940552,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.9424430131912231,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,4.878261089324951,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.8038226962089539,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.610568284988403,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.4303297996520996,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.313219666481018,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,5.15794038772583,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.0052742958068848,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.5716100335121155,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.9738203287124632,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,4.550704479217529,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.646175980567932,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.0488016605377197,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.1956357955932615,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.034464120864868,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,6.92507791519165,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.505620241165161,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.1448378562927246,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.4646782875061035,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,7.11513614654541,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.985576033592224,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.6250555515289309,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.8511837720870972,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.9818562269210815,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,7.443671703338623,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.1951974630355835,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.81184983253479,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.6541770696640015,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,3.661224365234375,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.3958582878112793,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.842617154121399,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.3836723268032074,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.622147798538208,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,42.35416412353515,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,42.35416412353515,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,46.45631790161133,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.6322588324546814,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.7874165773391724,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.7608280181884766,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.0629204511642456,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.243423938751221,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.8077155947685242,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.8430155515670776,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.3441412448883057,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.3093621730804443,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.304234504699707,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.928477168083191,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.529159665107727,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.992578625679016,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,4.4502153396606445,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.993307113647461,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.17826247215271,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.3861145973205566,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.9886728525161743,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,7.546357154846191,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.3879177570343018,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.2195661067962646,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.4299726486206055,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,7.037456035614014,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.091102600097656,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.7753642797470093,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.767715334892273,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.0203957557678223,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,7.65457820892334,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.2146846055984497,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.9126707315444944,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.6924758553504944,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,3.819831132888794,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.3426278531551361,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.722570776939392,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.3595617711544037,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.424760341644287,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,43.480857849121094,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,43.480857849121094,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,48.32275390625,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.7440564632415771,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.6360094547271729,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.6073814630508425,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.9995322227478028,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,4.9869794845581055,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.782137393951416,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.9344415664672852,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.4605867862701416,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.2651981115341189,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.44236421585083,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.8806477785110471,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.5287758708000183,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.9610083103179932,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,4.370431900024414,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.7658058404922483,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.06788969039917,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.1051102876663208,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.9447569847106936,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,6.8835625648498535,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.479872465133667,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.3016884326934814,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.505218982696533,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,7.286779880523682,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.937508463859558,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.0333874225616455,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.0570549964904785,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.9985584020614624,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,8.026509284973145,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.990252673625946,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.7225006818771362,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.5241249799728394,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,3.2368783950805664,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.4239645302295685,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.2954554557800293,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.4093888103961944,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,3.1288084983825684,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,43.36231231689453,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,43.36231231689453,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,47.14202880859375,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.7510576844215393,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.7811509370803833,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.6489534378051758,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.3355289697647097,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,5.516691207885742,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.8841391801834106,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.047956943511963,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.6606179475784302,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.4503881931304932,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,6.043102264404297,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.9673657417297363,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.5369811058044434,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.0063817501068115,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,4.510728359222412,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.051081895828247,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.281299591064453,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.5030673742294312,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.7035173177719116,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,7.538966178894043,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.6193501949310303,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.2970175743103027,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.533766031265259,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,7.450133800506592,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.051290988922119,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.74090576171875,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.9268031120300293,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.0107853412628174,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,7.729785442352295,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.2596391439437866,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.948641061782837,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.9224998354911804,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,4.130780220031738,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.492898017168045,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.002772331237793,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.4222062826156616,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.917876720428467,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,45.83806228637695,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,45.83806228637695,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,50.498069763183594,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.8216164708137512,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.7433180809020996,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.6054383516311646,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.371058225631714,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,5.541430950164795,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.8140232563018799,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.1392836570739746,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.555155634880066,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.3334524631500244,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,5.841915130615234,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.051894426345825,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.482077032327652,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.9392178058624268,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,4.473188877105713,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.9206078052520752,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.196625232696533,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.3494349718093872,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.0152060985565186,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,7.481873989105225,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.470783948898315,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.38165545463562,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.5344085693359375,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,7.386848449707031,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.0411853790283203,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.7372336387634275,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.1036622524261475,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.0138742923736572,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,7.895955562591553,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.1764386892318726,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.8790069818496704,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.5897402167320251,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,3.645185947418213,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.4412524104118347,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.2660417556762695,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.3695646524429321,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,3.0768587589263916,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,45.343257904052734,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,45.343257904052734,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,49.70521545410156,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.8352386355400085,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.569742202758789,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.5703749656677246,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.7491074800491333,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,4.724462985992432,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.8718600869178772,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.6278023719787598,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.332904577255249,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.3612889051437378,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,5.193856239318848,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.0483293533325195,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.5373998880386353,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.8312891721725464,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,4.417018413543701,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.5140323638916016,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.8710904121398928,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.9409605264663696,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.918560028076172,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,6.244643688201904,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.7174270153045654,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.4721145629882812,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.5757484436035156,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,7.765289783477783,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.987046718597412,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.9781367778778076,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.2269763946533203,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.9210748672485352,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,8.113234519958496,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.8685387969017029,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.6810048818588257,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.4725692868232727,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,3.022113084793091,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.5807393193244934,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.2458691596984863,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.5171650648117065,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,3.343773603439331,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,42.82439041137695,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,42.82439041137695,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,45.67393112182617,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.6794513463973999,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.656692385673523,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.5488156080245972,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.9471225738525392,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,4.832082271575928,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.7972784042358398,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.8076034784317017,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.3435001373291016,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.5036721229553225,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,5.452054023742676,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.7889219522476196,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.4455908536911011,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.8971781730651855,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,4.131690979003906,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.8126928806304932,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.026639699935913,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.1340447664260864,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.9607830047607424,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,6.934160232543945,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.4781370162963867,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.3667678833007812,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.496295690536499,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,7.341200828552246,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.0548007488250732,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.8338583707809448,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.006619453430176,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.9068127870559692,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,7.802091598510742,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.0594555139541626,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.4318251609802246,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.6472808122634888,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,3.138561487197876,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.4092709422111511,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.2070157527923584,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.4428723752498626,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,3.0591588020324707,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,42.69100189208984,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,42.69100189208984,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,46.66397857666016,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.6457681059837341,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.639401912689209,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.4615815877914429,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.1575069427490234,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,4.904258728027344,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.7734715938568115,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.878323316574097,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.4779205322265625,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.2896181344985962,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,5.419333457946777,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.009874105453491,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.4806236326694488,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.9225397109985352,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,4.413037300109863,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.8353444337844849,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.136831760406494,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.403732419013977,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.0483388900756836,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,7.424247741699219,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.575262546539306,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.2846505641937256,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.60245680809021,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,7.462369918823242,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.0580930709838867,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.704912543296814,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.192761182785034,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.9554922580718992,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,7.911259174346924,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.1628730297088623,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.9242099523544312,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.5910144448280334,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,3.678097486495972,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.4103286862373352,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.9527268409729004,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.4288428127765655,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.791898250579834,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,44.00450134277344,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,44.00450134277344,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,48.57471466064453,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.789799690246582,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.7306971549987793,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.6283715963363647,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.254440188407898,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.403308391571045,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.8841380476951599,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.037187099456787,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.564930081367493,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.3730101585388184,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.859265327453613,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.0127439498901367,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.559551477432251,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.8463741540908811,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,4.418669700622559,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.050342559814453,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.172934055328369,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.3457014560699463,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.9710062742233276,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,7.539984226226807,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.497417688369751,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.4757466316223145,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.5312633514404297,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,7.504427433013916,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.17039155960083,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.736873745918274,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.0580551624298096,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.03341007232666,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,7.998730659484863,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.111924409866333,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.82560133934021,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.7135218977928162,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,3.651047706604004,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.4721370637416839,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.116441011428833,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.4018757939338684,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.9904537200927734,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,45.36588668823242,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,45.36588668823242,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,49.92890548706055,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.7447482347488403,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.6390784978866575,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.679207682609558,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.884116530418396,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,4.947151184082031,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.8503734469413757,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.9934052228927612,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.5920270681381226,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.342125654220581,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,5.777931213378906,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.096210241317749,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.5118846297264099,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.9488461017608645,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,4.556941032409668,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.8569241762161257,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.105745315551758,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.2703983783721924,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.0181894302368164,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,7.251257419586182,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.4701130390167236,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.2926509380340576,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.519151210784912,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,7.281915187835693,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.135615825653076,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.890244960784912,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.2557151317596436,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.95570170879364,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,8.23727798461914,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.138840675354004,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.892196774482727,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.5263832211494446,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,3.5574207305908203,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.4146113097667694,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.011425495147705,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.4058297276496887,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.831866502761841,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,44.4417610168457,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,44.4417610168457,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,49.07176971435547,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.6833580732345581,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.5242425203323364,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.5288985967636108,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.0146397352218628,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,4.751139163970947,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.8193669319152832,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.720465898513794,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.32736337184906,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.4535703659057615,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,5.320766448974609,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.0404717922210693,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.4533903002738952,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.91020929813385,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,4.40407133102417,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.8127833604812624,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.9916579723358152,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.1658004522323608,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.0448734760284424,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,7.015115261077881,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.431180238723755,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.471177339553833,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.5907018184661865,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,7.493059158325195,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.9654269218444824,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.657833695411682,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.85106360912323,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.0130836963653564,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,7.487407684326172,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.006889820098877,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.7646009922027588,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.7300701141357422,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,3.501560926437378,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.4619079530239105,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.3486745357513428,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.5017572045326233,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,3.312339782714844,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,43.28546142578125,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,43.28546142578125,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,46.96335220336914,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.7238475680351257,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.6786500215530396,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.5831413269042969,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.2543377876281738,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,5.23997688293457,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.7698041796684265,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.973321318626404,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.4037781953811646,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.5268886089324951,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,5.673792362213135,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.006553888320923,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.4701728820800781,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.8019949197769165,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,4.278721809387207,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.8022595643997192,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.045372247695923,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.211413025856018,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.9390411376953125,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,6.998085975646973,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.521822690963745,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.366929054260254,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.5300991535186768,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,7.418850898742676,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.9881385564804075,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.8948631286621096,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.0403501987457275,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.9911844730377195,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,7.914536476135254,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.087214708328247,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.9163100719451904,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.6118205785751343,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,3.6153454780578618,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.4324800968170166,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.8247592449188232,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.4159554243087768,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.673194646835327,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,43.812503814697266,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,43.812503814697266,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,48.12137985229492,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.7915184497833252,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.607676982879639,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.583967685699463,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.2677514553070068,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,5.250914573669434,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.8447895646095276,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.9229612350463867,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.5227292776107788,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.4224764108657837,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,5.712956428527832,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.0823512077331543,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.4959120452404022,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.973739743232727,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,4.552002906799316,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.6386271715164185,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.004758596420288,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.1821717023849487,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.8809809684753416,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,6.706538200378418,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.555682420730591,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.598085403442383,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.4773080348968506,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,7.631075859069824,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.956476807594299,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.9935309886932373,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.0090861320495605,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.031911849975586,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,7.991005897521973,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.9868560433387756,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.767993450164795,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.7599820494651794,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,3.51483154296875,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.4671457409858703,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.40346097946167,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.4526756405830383,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,3.323282241821289,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,44.68260955810547,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,44.68260955810547,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,48.0802116394043,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.8537590503692627,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.7982882261276243,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.684593677520752,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.5181115865707395,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,5.854752540588379,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.845943033695221,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.104030132293701,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.7669273614883425,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.4864925146102903,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,6.20339298248291,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.9880281686782837,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.5859327912330627,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.985735297203064,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,4.559696197509766,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.0619771480560303,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.222524881362915,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.5245476961135864,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.000589609146118,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,7.8096394538879395,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.407827138900757,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.3057291507720947,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.5852901935577393,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,7.298846244812012,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.1831016540527344,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.7836016416549685,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.047363758087158,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.055802583694458,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,8.069869995117188,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.272966742515564,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.108184337615967,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.7576523423194885,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,4.138803482055664,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.4494607150554657,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.2718255519866943,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.4453005194664001,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,3.166586637496948,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,47.101585388183594,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,47.101585388183594,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,51.78852462768555,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.7306329607963562,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.6006708145141602,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.5778368711471558,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.9179032444953918,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,4.8270440101623535,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.8512576222419739,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.915807604789734,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.3874355554580688,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.290676832199097,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.4451775550842285,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.048250913619995,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.5550500750541687,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.8658732175827024,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,4.469174385070801,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.830237865447998,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.0786986351013184,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.2028398513793943,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.0356335639953613,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,7.147409915924072,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.490352153778076,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.229221820831299,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.53413987159729,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,7.253713607788086,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.9942917823791504,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.816027283668518,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.9882028102874756,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.934121370315552,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,7.732643127441406,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.0750702619552612,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.0140671730041504,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.6727527379989624,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,3.761890411376953,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.4663459658622741,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.2113513946533203,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.5065785050392151,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,3.1842758655548096,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,43.821327209472656,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,43.821327209472656,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,47.83111953735352,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.7566648721694946,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.582785964012146,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.5880634784698486,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.1416634321212769,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,5.069177627563477,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.8469223976135254,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.9722000360488892,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.6687105894088743,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.1858689785003662,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,5.673701763153076,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.135302782058716,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.6098468899726868,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.9518494606018064,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,4.6969990730285645,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.8977165222167969,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.0549888610839844,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.2322475910186768,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.0323522090911865,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,7.2173051834106445,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.502577066421509,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.3643624782562256,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.5444142818450928,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,7.411353588104248,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.1249632835388184,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.04723858833313,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.063581943511963,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.987001657485962,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,8.222784996032715,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.2091100215911863,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.196906566619873,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.5910726189613342,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,3.997089147567749,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.5064631104469299,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.8717615604400637,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.4689801037311554,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.8472046852111816,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,45.135616302490234,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,45.135616302490234,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,49.53632736206055,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.7490915656089783,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.5451710224151611,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.5155060291290283,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.0489509105682373,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,4.858719348907471,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.846537709236145,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.8344526290893557,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.509178638458252,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.2360626459121704,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,5.426231861114502,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.0345823764801025,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.6176908016204834,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.8990254402160645,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,4.55129861831665,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.8227168321609497,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.0452892780303955,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.2106046676635742,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.045194387435913,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,7.123805046081543,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.451237201690674,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.310218334197998,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.2654011249542236,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,7.026856422424316,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.075794219970703,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.0098631381988525,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.982140302658081,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.9205524921417236,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,7.9883503913879395,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.136019587516785,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.8738057613372805,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.7594513297080994,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,3.769276857376098,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.4345986247062683,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.9868533611297607,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.3983083367347717,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.819760322570801,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,43.564300537109375,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,43.564300537109375,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,47.90769958496094,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.6970274448394775,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.5962189435958862,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.5035974979400637,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.1720991134643557,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,4.968943119049072,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.8560556769371033,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.504788875579834,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.3758246898651123,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.3161863088607788,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,5.052855491638184,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.1359570026397705,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.5734544992446899,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.7046254873275757,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,4.414036750793457,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.6699472665786743,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.019939422607422,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.146021008491516,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.7768278121948242,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,6.612735271453857,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.497197389602661,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.334733009338379,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.440586805343628,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,7.272517204284668,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.0526909828186035,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.736139893531799,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.944154977798462,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.8956706523895264,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,7.628656387329102,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.0223608016967771,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.650999903678894,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.91071754693985,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,3.584078073501587,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.4892204701900482,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.899313807487488,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.4705329537391662,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.85906720161438,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,42.39289093017578,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,42.39289093017578,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,45.86590576171875,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.8548682332038879,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.621909260749817,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.6912519931793213,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.3067632913589478,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.474792957305908,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.0397578477859497,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.968161702156067,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.6642115116119385,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.5309027433395386,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,6.203033924102783,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.150089740753174,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.5588138699531555,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.8662303686141968,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,4.575133800506592,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.052237033843994,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.223137855529785,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.447590470314026,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.0489752292633057,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,7.7719407081604,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.694361925125122,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.4016127586364746,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.6454977989196777,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,7.741472721099853,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.1968915462493896,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.0181124210357666,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.217465400695801,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.0316128730773926,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,8.464081764221191,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.2606959342956543,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.1830079555511475,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.0157861709594729,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,4.4594902992248535,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.5534685850143433,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.277545690536499,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.5381199717521667,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,3.3691341876983643,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,48.05908203125,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,48.05908203125,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,52.62757873535156,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.749940812587738,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.2566604614257812,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.4077558517456057,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.6502795815467834,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,4.064636707305908,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.8449913859367371,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.5415648221969604,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.2225561141967771,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.452099084854126,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,5.061211585998535,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.9137789011001587,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.430115133523941,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.9309459924697876,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,4.274839878082275,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.588544845581055,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.9621598720550537,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.164159893989563,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.066633701324463,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,6.781498432159424,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.409371852874756,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.4594531059265137,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.456335067749023,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,7.325160026550293,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.0012850761413574,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.928725004196167,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.310756206512451,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.013477087020874,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,8.254242897033691,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.0374399423599243,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.7995413541793823,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.3948452770709991,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,3.2318265438079834,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.4852227568626404,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.661466360092163,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.4166861474514007,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,3.563375234603882,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,42.556793212890625,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,42.556793212890625,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,46.02144241333008,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.7113731503486633,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.528662919998169,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.472449779510498,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.7634919881820679,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,4.475977897644043,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.8088945746421814,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.6325995922088623,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.4000152349472046,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.2094361782073977,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,5.050945281982422,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.904478669166565,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.521473228931427,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.792929768562317,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,4.218881607055664,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.742512822151184,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.0125722885131836,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.142578363418579,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.9343819618225095,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,6.832045555114746,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.4348738193511963,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.990052342414856,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.505690336227417,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,6.93061637878418,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.042088508605957,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.017502546310425,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.0666515827178955,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.9941527843475344,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,8.12039566040039,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.0963940620422363,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.9128339290618896,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.5227289199829102,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,3.5319571495056152,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.4096204042434692,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.15423583984375,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.3809062242507934,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.9447624683380127,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,42.10558319091797,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,42.10558319091797,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,46.04523849487305,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.6401499509811401,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.3451929092407229,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.4727790355682373,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.6902299523353577,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,4.148352146148682,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.8409944772720337,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.610501050949097,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.2273142337799072,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.1644710302352903,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,4.843280792236328,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.81869375705719,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.480528861284256,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.6808786392211914,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,3.980101346969605,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.6155288219451904,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.8967788219451904,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.1619116067886353,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.934980511665344,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,6.609199523925781,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.3975589275360107,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.440634250640869,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.365148544311523,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,7.203341960906982,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.036036252975464,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.9747487306594849,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.8680654764175415,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.9719523191452024,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,7.850802898406982,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.967809557914734,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.6874281167984009,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.7143986225128174,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,3.369636297225952,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.3819155693054199,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.222060441970825,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.3714245855808258,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.975400686264038,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,40.9801139831543,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,40.9801139831543,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,44.6539421081543,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.6632478833198547,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.5085850954055786,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.3557990789413452,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.0933774709701538,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,4.621009349822998,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.8087170124053955,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.5051167011260986,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.2596813440322876,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.3395534753799438,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,4.913068771362305,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.000380277633667,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.4895820617675781,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.6710587739944458,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,4.1610212326049805,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.591754674911499,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.062992572784424,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.2159090042114258,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.9240081310272217,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,6.79466438293457,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.27107834815979,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.2247798442840576,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.4684159755706787,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,6.964273929595947,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.076364040374756,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.9605302810668943,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.9046509265899656,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.972842574119568,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,7.9143877029418945,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.057247281074524,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.7818580865859983,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.7867551445960999,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,3.6258604526519775,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.4283471405506134,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.093003749847412,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.4284360706806183,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.949786901473999,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,41.94407272338867,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,41.94407272338867,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,45.667327880859375,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.6252278685569763,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.397710204124451,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.498759150505066,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.076596736907959,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,4.598293781280518,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.7351027727127075,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.5914857387542725,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.271453857421875,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.3140746355056765,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,4.912117004394531,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.8029407262802124,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.4666552543640136,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.6458072662353516,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,3.915403127670288,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.6639108657836914,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.057837963104248,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.2151700258255005,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.9730433225631712,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,6.909962177276611,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.158259868621826,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.078115701675415,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.5123021602630615,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,6.748677730560303,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.048757314682007,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.6569092273712158,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.9515303373336792,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.8878310918807983,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,7.545027732849121,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.9502040147781372,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.8243213891983032,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.7155375480651855,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,3.490062952041626,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.3764092922210693,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.8315305709838867,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.3936175405979156,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.60155725479126,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,40.72110366821289,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,40.72110366821289,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,44.92924499511719,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.7827772498130798,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.323807716369629,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.4810489416122437,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.625,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,4.212634086608887,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.7930509448051453,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.6234315633773804,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.369346022605896,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.352553367614746,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,5.1383819580078125,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.002377986907959,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.3997386693954468,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.9007422924041748,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,4.302858829498291,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.516094446182251,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.9082995653152464,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.1628262996673584,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.9586597681045532,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,6.545880317687988,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.2627899646759033,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.372058153152466,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.4727869033813477,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,7.107635021209717,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.8585755825042725,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.020688772201538,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.1945207118988037,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.924838304519653,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,7.998623371124268,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.0129022598266602,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.7479591369628906,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.5203485488891602,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,3.281209945678711,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.4264256358146667,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.276270627975464,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.3987846970558166,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,3.1014809608459473,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,41.68870544433594,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,41.68870544433594,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,45.352317810058594,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.7775523066520691,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.5507086515426636,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.6501754522323608,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.4209305047988892,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,5.399366855621338,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.8256527185440063,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.8369914293289185,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.4393683671951294,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.3572099208831787,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,5.459222793579102,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.0679402351379395,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.5227315425872803,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.792422890663147,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,4.383094787597656,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.7328591346740725,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.0573253631591797,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.3839399814605713,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.010401725769043,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,7.184526443481445,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.4425711631774902,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.2625770568847656,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.405409097671509,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,7.1105570793151855,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.0302183628082275,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.9881073236465456,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.1171581745147705,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.9558444023132324,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,8.091328620910645,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.1562979221343994,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.9175561666488647,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.4819830358028412,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,3.5558371543884277,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.389713853597641,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.8833489418029783,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.3732114732265472,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.6462743282318115,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,43.83020782470703,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,43.83020782470703,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,48.18581771850586,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.7898809909820557,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.5049220323562622,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.543969988822937,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.545454502105713,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,5.384227275848389,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.8537619113922119,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.6895641088485718,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.5482991933822632,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.4306882619857788,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,5.522313594818115,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.025453805923462,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.4520550668239593,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.9322673082351685,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,4.409776210784912,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.816449761390686,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.11936616897583,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.4770609140396118,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.9860605001449585,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,7.398937225341797,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.291966676712036,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.3562469482421875,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.3212156295776367,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,6.969429016113281,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.8686453104019165,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.013446092605591,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.058757066726685,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.921007513999939,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,7.861855983734131,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.1739760637283323,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.830461502075195,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.5129614472389221,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,3.5173990726470947,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.4002144336700439,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.251709461212158,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.4349530935287475,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,3.08687686920166,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,44.15081405639648,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,44.15081405639648,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,48.36483383178711,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.6239746809005737,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.3929017782211304,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.4572087526321411,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.018160700798035,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,4.492245674133301,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.7840203642845154,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.4459892511367798,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.204491376876831,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.3173422813415527,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,4.751842975616455,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8709288835525513,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.4831285178661346,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.7409580945968628,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,4.095015525817871,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.451734185218811,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8524878025054932,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.025996446609497,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.853284478187561,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,6.183502674102783,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.2188894748687744,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.252957344055176,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.381910800933838,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,6.853757858276367,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8599565029144287,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.9709413051605225,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8414617776870728,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8861244916915896,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,7.558484077453613,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.8206764459609985,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8385220766067505,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.6509270071983337,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,3.3101255893707275,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.3947323262691498,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8748464584350584,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.380538135766983,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.6501169204711914,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,39.89509201049805,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,39.89509201049805,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,43.27525329589844,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.694267749786377,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.4592885971069336,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.5193743705749512,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.9688976407051086,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,4.6418280601501465,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.8272053599357605,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.6380188465118408,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.2848193645477295,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.095421552658081,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,4.845465183258057,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.97762930393219,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.4871087670326233,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.7129157781600952,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,4.177653789520264,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.3852075338363647,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.8284066915512085,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.9335548877716064,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.7888013124465942,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,5.935970306396484,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.323704242706299,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.180636405944824,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.3978023529052734,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,6.9021430015563965,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.89791476726532,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.9032232761383057,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.8460181951522827,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.8812922239303589,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,7.528448581695557,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.838878870010376,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.8199779987335205,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.5749973654747009,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,3.233854293823242,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.3852012455463409,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.9006428718566897,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.3984363079071045,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.6842803955078125,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,39.94964218139648,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,39.94964218139648,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,43.03976821899414,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.7094863057136536,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.4772182703018188,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.4822839498519895,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.5263824462890625,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,5.195371150970459,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.7566164135932922,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.5488793849945068,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.368163824081421,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.3300896883010864,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,5.003749370574951,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.9602372646331787,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.519332766532898,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.6832287311553955,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,4.162798881530762,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.593570113182068,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.8948420286178589,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.1579618453979492,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.93285071849823,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,6.579224586486816,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.1429460048675537,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.3524603843688965,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.305694341659546,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,6.801100730895996,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.9852570295333865,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.912647366523743,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.674094796180725,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.9361056089401243,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,7.508104801177979,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.0485494136810305,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.7283319234848022,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.4417421221733093,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,3.218623399734497,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.4482684433460235,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.129965305328369,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.4765710830688476,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,3.054804801940918,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,41.52377700805664,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,41.52377700805664,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,44.76332473754883,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.7016211748123169,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.479961633682251,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.5425870418548584,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.4503380060195925,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,5.1745076179504395,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.8122062683105469,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.3482424020767212,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.2058207988739014,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.167120337486267,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,4.533389568328857,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.9154603481292725,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.491157978773117,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.634815335273743,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,4.041433811187744,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.4689228534698486,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.9206823110580444,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.0010815858840942,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.8772780895233152,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,6.267964839935303,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.225260019302368,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.3176019191741943,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.378598690032959,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,6.9214606285095215,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.838052988052368,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.614651441574097,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.7615448236465454,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.9290353059768677,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,7.143284320831299,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.9178270697593688,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.7518304586410522,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.6514973044395447,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,3.321154832839966,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.4100549221038818,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.8384910821914673,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.3926918506622314,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.641237735748291,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,40.04443359375,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,40.04443359375,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,43.02449798583984,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.7627155184745789,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.6459251642227173,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.552747130393982,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.418107271194458,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,5.379495143890381,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.8479892015457153,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.7168062925338743,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.4749102592468262,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.2170573472976685,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,5.256762981414795,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.0217018127441406,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.523749053478241,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.8972495794296265,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,4.442700386047363,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.5048828125,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.9427722692489624,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.171880841255188,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.014476776123047,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,6.634012699127197,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.3670835494995117,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.4582161903381348,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.501793146133423,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,7.327093124389648,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.81013822555542,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.9934780597686768,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.8848297595977783,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.9645142555236816,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,7.652960300445557,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.960734486579895,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.8443273305892944,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.4988915622234344,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,3.3039534091949463,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.4702391624450683,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.6822509765625,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.3894849419593811,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,3.5419750213623047,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,43.5389518737793,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,43.5389518737793,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,46.35471725463867,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.7275014519691467,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.4961103200912476,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.4177868366241455,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.7698933482170105,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,4.41129207611084,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.7805675864219666,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.5473295450210571,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.2626831531524658,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.2415906190872192,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,4.8321709632873535,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.9085497856140137,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.5179973244667053,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.7483073472976685,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,4.174854278564453,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.4518959522247314,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.97049343585968,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.1100424528121948,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.9022260904312136,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,6.434657573699951,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.349940061569214,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.264459133148194,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.5125112533569336,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,7.12691068649292,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.7518292665481567,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.6917495727539062,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.9091297388076784,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.908614993095398,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,7.26132345199585,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.8252013325691223,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.5263508558273315,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.5349991321563721,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.8865511417388916,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.4568259716033935,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.4506497383117676,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.3583036363124847,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,3.2657792568206787,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,40.39353942871094,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,40.39353942871094,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,43.48528671264648,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.7240516543388367,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.415425419807434,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.3441897630691528,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.7374218106269836,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,4.221088409423828,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.8167656660079956,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.8246208429336548,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.5225958824157717,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.375391721725464,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,5.539374351501465,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.0133392810821533,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.4640103578567505,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.7230300903320312,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,4.200379848480225,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.7302637100219729,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.099001407623291,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.4072574377059937,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.9800678491592407,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,7.216590404510498,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.2384283542633057,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.3189697265625,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.452533006668091,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,7.009931564331055,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.8174773454666135,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.0351672172546387,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.9848729372024536,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.941300630569458,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,7.778818130493164,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.0668647289276123,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.9110125303268433,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.4964245855808258,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,3.474301815032959,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.3516360521316528,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.0331249237060547,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.3777965605258941,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.7625575065612793,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,42.20304107666016,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,42.20304107666016,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,47.09073257446289,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.0126924514770508,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.6732146739959717,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.5388410091400146,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.059920072555542,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,5.284668445587158,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.9839279651641846,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.028273582458496,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.6748769283294678,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.5642874240875244,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,6.251365661621094,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.233553886413574,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.5478518009185791,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.9406756162643433,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,4.722081184387207,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.0603559017181396,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.250458002090454,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.6855082511901855,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.1496124267578125,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,8.14593505859375,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.5247082710266113,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.507671594619751,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.598233699798584,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,7.630613803863525,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.9253344535827637,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.938019633293152,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.2526190280914307,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.9566270112991333,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,8.072600364685059,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.2909588813781738,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.91205370426178,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.4714719355106354,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,3.6744844913482666,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.4843781292438507,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.390608549118042,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.5210239291191101,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,3.396010637283325,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,47.177757263183594,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,47.177757263183594,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,52.2186279296875,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.8041389584541321,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.3113447427749634,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.3546172380447388,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.928396701812744,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,4.398497581481934,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.782689094543457,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.634153127670288,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.2737622261047363,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.1791609525680542,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,4.869765281677246,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.0687320232391357,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.4576430320739746,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.928841233253479,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,4.455216407775879,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.3667337894439695,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.9017515182495115,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.0960075855255127,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.9781689643859863,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,6.3426618576049805,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.279144763946533,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.437269687652588,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.442286729812622,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,7.158701419830322,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.7577900886535645,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.826250672340393,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.1007347106933594,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.9032127857208252,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,7.587988376617432,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.8590256571769714,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.5844978094100952,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.4090684652328491,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.8525919914245605,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.4103222787380218,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.496234178543091,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.3813139200210571,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,3.287870407104492,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,40.95329284667969,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,40.95329284667969,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,43.957637786865234,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.7330779433250427,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.3014682531356812,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.4174071550369265,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.8213749527931213,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,4.2733283042907715,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.7965877652168274,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.7017353773117063,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.2967138290405271,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.2400764226913452,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,5.035113334655762,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.0271060466766357,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.4794578552246094,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.738147854804993,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,4.244711875915527,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.4817850589752195,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.9093577861785889,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.1756097078323364,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.896426558494568,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,6.463179111480713,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.9647741317749023,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.3195278644561768,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.4627015590667725,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,6.747003555297852,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.844263792037964,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.991960287094116,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.264561176300049,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.901500582695007,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,8.002285957336426,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.922974705696106,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.7244888544082642,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.4343600273132324,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,3.0818235874176025,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.362835019826889,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.0348384380340576,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.3695275485515594,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.7672009468078613,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,40.614646911621094,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,40.614646911621094,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,44.487979888916016,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.7071225643157959,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.2002638578414917,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.230168104171753,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.9187374711036682,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,4.0562920570373535,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.8285778760910034,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.59238600730896,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.364279866218567,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.2029963731765747,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,4.9882402420043945,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.062304973602295,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.4054223299026489,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.8555601835250857,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,4.323287487030029,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.4054527282714844,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.9076000452041624,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.0943937301635742,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.9196110963821411,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,6.327057838439941,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.3302431106567383,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.1517651081085205,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.42154312133789,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,6.90355110168457,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.794371247291565,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.8164255619049072,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.2701685428619385,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.869603395462036,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,7.750568866729736,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.8795455098152161,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.6770862340927124,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.3384490609169006,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.895080804824829,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.3856772780418396,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.6282169818878174,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.4185682535171509,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,3.432462453842163,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,40.67654037475586,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,40.67654037475586,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,43.83198165893555,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.6995598077774048,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.378368616104126,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.226718187332153,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.9769822955131532,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,4.2816290855407715,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.7531551122665405,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.6475868225097656,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.385046124458313,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.2755807638168335,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,5.061368942260742,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.890867829322815,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.4318697154521942,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.8453404903411863,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,4.1680779457092285,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.7330915927886963,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.113889217376709,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.4260151386260986,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.9578748941421509,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,7.230870723724365,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.3794214725494385,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.443225383758545,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.421182870864868,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,7.243829727172852,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.9191532135009768,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.921671986579895,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.028575897216797,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.8618940114974976,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,7.731295108795166,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.1019701957702637,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.8050986528396609,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.5362061858177185,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,3.443274974822998,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.4159125983715057,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.138902187347412,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.3900490999221802,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.944863796234131,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,42.10520935058594,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,42.10520935058594,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,46.454341888427734,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.6351594924926758,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.2045871019363403,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.2544251680374146,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.7991258502006531,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,3.893297672271729,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.7046979665756226,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.256374716758728,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.1186130046844482,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.207622766494751,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,4.287308692932129,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.9074347019195557,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.4370768070220947,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.7286149263381958,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,4.073126316070557,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.4724279642105105,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.913730263710022,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.1030669212341309,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.8583866357803345,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,6.347611904144287,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.1728436946868896,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.0678818225860596,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.4013314247131348,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,6.642056941986084,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.8550597429275513,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.687129020690918,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.0908756256103516,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.876386284828186,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,7.509450912475586,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.929871380329132,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.7237919569015503,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.0466758012771606,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,3.7003390789031982,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.3859845101833343,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.8953624963760376,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.3553943932056427,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.6367411613464355,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,39.08993148803711,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,39.08993148803711,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,42.62102890014648,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.6640320420265198,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.3136117458343506,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.2842365503311155,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.0427147150039673,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,4.304594993591309,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.7527049779891968,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.479740023612976,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.1391820907592771,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.090136170387268,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,4.461763381958008,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.101982593536377,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.4520615935325622,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.548210382461548,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,4.102254390716553,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.6181590557098389,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.8713693618774416,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.1662691831588743,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.8840032815933228,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,6.539801120758057,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.3044180870056152,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.30753493309021,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.3751490116119385,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,6.9871015548706055,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.954923391342163,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.4472507238388062,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.9424010515213013,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.8493770360946655,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,7.1939520835876465,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.0056442022323608,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.6792529821395874,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.6811383962631226,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,3.3660354614257812,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.3546686768531799,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.8993161916732788,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.3791102766990661,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.6330950260162354,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,39.58859634399414,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,39.58859634399414,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,43.17046356201172,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.6007072925567627,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.227310061454773,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.2293667793273926,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.7411751747131348,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,3.798559427261353,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.7536619305610657,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.4957815408706665,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.1465622186660769,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.2592666149139404,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,4.655272483825684,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.989097237586975,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.4559974074363708,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.5388407707214355,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,3.9839353561401367,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.4948259592056274,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.860965132713318,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.1857725381851196,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.9209730625152588,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,6.462536811828613,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.3429131507873535,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.308938980102539,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.5092949867248535,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,7.161147117614746,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.873232364654541,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.9665327072143557,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.165205717086792,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.954806923866272,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,7.959777355194092,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.988180935382843,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.6845346689224243,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.5510633587837219,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,3.2237789630889893,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.366392970085144,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.75188410282135,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.4485617280006408,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.5668387413024902,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,39.81184768676758,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,39.81184768676758,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,43.7761344909668,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.7148780822753906,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.304840326309204,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.3680356740951538,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.8503526449203491,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,4.238106727600098,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.7745068073272705,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.4260149002075195,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.2089704275131226,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.3262580633163452,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,4.735750198364258,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.9752321243286133,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.436237096786499,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.6506648063659668,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,4.062134265899658,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.6193572282791138,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.992292881011963,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.262623906135559,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.9465173482894895,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,6.820791244506836,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.3347396850585938,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.3115394115448,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.4218127727508545,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,7.068091869354248,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.04410719871521,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.983777403831482,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.259145975112915,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.894171953201294,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,8.18120288848877,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.046497106552124,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.72439706325531,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.336917757987976,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,4.10781192779541,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.3437644839286804,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.810361385345459,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.464769184589386,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.6188950538635254,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,41.83278274536133,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,41.83278274536133,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,45.92766952514648,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.7611980438232422,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.2682236433029177,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.4143309593200684,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.125696063041687,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,4.569448947906494,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.7780393958091736,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.4976569414138794,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.223984956741333,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.3514115810394287,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,4.85109281539917,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.0199129581451416,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.4469610452651977,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.8548943996429443,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,4.321768283843994,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.531092882156372,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.024812936782837,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.2786563634872437,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.9310444593429563,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,6.765606880187988,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.333641767501831,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.2652883529663086,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.5127272605895996,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,7.111657619476318,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.9307295083999632,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.6188045740127563,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.1021265983581543,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.901287317276001,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,7.552947998046875,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.9778680801391602,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.6955064535140991,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.0521774291992188,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,4.725552082061768,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.3886381089687347,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.7646722793579102,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.3809687495231628,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.534279108047486,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,42.43235397338867,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,42.43235397338867,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,46.37621307373047,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.6263337135314941,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.304058074951172,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.2294024229049685,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.8727880120277405,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,4.0325822830200195,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.7228270769119263,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.687291383743286,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.3035647869110107,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.341031789779663,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,5.054715156555176,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.0312771797180176,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.3836024105548858,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.534129977226257,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,3.949009656906128,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.7092022895812988,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.049696683883667,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.4428367614746094,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.0531885623931885,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,7.254924297332764,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.380940198898315,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.4063706398010254,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.4622693061828613,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,7.249579906463623,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.934666633605957,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.696446418762207,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.340927839279175,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.892911076545715,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,7.8649516105651855,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.1434727907180786,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.862053632736206,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.2580910921096802,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,4.263617515563965,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.4054953753948211,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.7078001499176023,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.4195801019668579,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.5328755378723145,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,42.20225524902344,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,42.20225524902344,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,47.05166244506836,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.6427084803581238,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.2406563758850098,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.3498531579971311,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.6791366934776306,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,3.912354707717895,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.6965396404266357,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.47911536693573,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.1584141254425049,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.8634809255599976,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,4.197550296783447,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.9530985355377195,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.425298810005188,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.7157440185546875,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,4.094141483306885,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.57982075214386,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.9425228834152224,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.1313177347183228,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.971058964729309,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,6.624720096588135,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.3286380767822266,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.177924871444702,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.5170435905456543,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,7.023606300354004,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.9125232696533203,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.574367642402649,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.9822640419006348,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.8716089725494385,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,7.340764045715332,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.0068988800048828,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.670520901679993,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.1573009490966797,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,3.8347208499908447,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.340824156999588,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.7987545728683472,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.3559106886386871,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.4954893589019775,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,39.523345947265625,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,39.523345947265625,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,43.297943115234375,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.585256814956665,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.206660509109497,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.0908164978027344,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.3299517631530762,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,4.212685585021973,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.7263666391372681,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.3496149778366089,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.2206425666809082,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.2986079454421997,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,4.595232009887695,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.9981273412704468,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.4087103903293609,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.6956498622894287,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,4.102487564086914,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.6349891424179075,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.9925849437713623,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.2618316411972046,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.881386995315552,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,6.770792484283447,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.2789039611816406,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.3578991889953613,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.4679126739501953,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,7.104715824127197,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.8961105346679688,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.7093188762664795,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.005276679992676,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.9387998580932615,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,7.549505710601807,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.1302722692489624,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.7528969049453735,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.3899191617965698,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,4.273088455200195,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.3785764276981354,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.83773410320282,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.4054462015628814,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.6217567920684814,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,41.23026657104492,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,41.23026657104492,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,45.134178161621094,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.7345872521400452,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.3170548677444458,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.2522821426391602,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.8783789873123169,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,4.182303428649902,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.6404306888580322,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.8146493434906008,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.3072429895401,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.9933909177780152,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,4.755713939666748,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.0667014122009277,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.4494655430316925,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.9432997703552248,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,4.459466457366943,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.61444354057312,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.99957811832428,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.3643566370010376,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.955613136291504,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,6.933991432189941,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.3471314907073975,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.217837333679199,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.568246841430664,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,7.13321590423584,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.003901958465576,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.5384702682495115,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.055565595626831,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.888023018836975,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,7.485960960388184,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.1397788524627686,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.6204968690872192,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.6922801733016968,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,4.452556133270264,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.3876936435699463,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.9680144786834717,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.4050873517990112,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.7607953548431396,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,42.16400146484375,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,42.16400146484375,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,46.16642761230469,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.6190856099128723,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.3247501850128174,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.1594732999801636,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.17137348651886,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,4.274682521820068,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.6716842651367188,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.4383043050765991,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.066494107246399,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.314546823501587,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,4.491029262542725,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.872691035270691,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.4219095706939697,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.6834546327590942,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,3.978055238723755,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.6553001403808594,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.9017900228500368,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.2322508096694946,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.9569244384765625,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,6.746265411376953,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.327897787094116,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.504892110824585,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.59529185295105,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,7.42808198928833,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.7517485618591309,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.7631165981292725,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.142191171646118,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.8940141201019287,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,7.551070213317871,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.0199772119522097,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.68410062789917,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.6771811842918396,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,3.381258964538574,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.3589670658111572,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.489805817604065,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.3368639051914215,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.1856367588043213,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,40.03607940673828,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,40.03607940673828,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,44.21961212158203,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.93724924325943,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.420189619064331,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.209126353263855,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.9962006211280824,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,4.562765598297119,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.9386225342750548,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.820488452911377,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.4089312553405762,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.3722567558288574,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,5.540298938751221,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.2975218296051025,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.5175004601478577,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.7736068964004517,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,4.588629245758057,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.9004088640213013,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.1243762969970703,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.3281168937683103,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.1085615158081055,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,7.461463451385498,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.428072452545166,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.4271888732910156,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.540363073348999,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,7.395624160766602,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.0013203620910645,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.985601782798767,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.0930426120758057,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.943699836730957,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,8.023664474487305,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.2013227939605713,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.843074917793274,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.6208287477493286,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,3.665226459503174,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.4039778411388397,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.2146449089050293,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.4704848229885101,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,3.0891075134277344,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,44.3267822265625,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,44.3267822265625,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,48.89776992797851,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.7539870738983154,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.3955847024917605,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.3353625535964966,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.84916752576828,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,4.334101676940918,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.8668395280838013,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.6839300394058228,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.2498369216918943,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.340700626373291,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,5.141307353973389,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.1727218627929688,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.5285106897354126,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.8880120515823364,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,4.589244842529297,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.7752554416656494,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.0778791904449463,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.2262550592422483,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.2679493427276611,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,6.347339153289795,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.390892744064331,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.5183558464050293,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.5447440147399902,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,7.4539923667907715,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.9175693988800049,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.5903443098068235,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.062344551086426,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.91995370388031,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,7.4902119636535645,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.0546317100524902,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.8017641305923464,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.7714027166366577,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,3.627798557281494,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.3633028864860534,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.041715383529663,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.3805668652057647,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.7855851650238037,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,41.76958084106445,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,41.76958084106445,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2021,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,45.34395980834961,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.2902536392211914,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.6858891248703003,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.57,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.28,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.8254475593566895,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.8727957010269165,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.928919553756714,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.6344366073608398,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.3408194780349731,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.776971340179443,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.9230015277862549,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.460113525390625,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.987553596496582,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,4.370668411254883,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.642737865447998,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.97211229801178,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.124035120010376,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.061859369277954,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,6.800744533538818,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.500190019607544,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.3353848457336426,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.4745140075683594,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,7.310088634490967,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.7344385385513306,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.4109086990356443,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.13028335571289,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.9537707567214968,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,7.229401111602783,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.898277997970581,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.6826380491256714,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.3529277145862579,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.9338438510894775,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.4992937743663788,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.6395814418792725,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.5188880562782288,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,3.6577632427215576,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,43.904930114746094,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,43.904930114746094,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,45.47676086425781,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.8524284958839417,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.6748725175857544,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.4906291961669922,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.9794062972068788,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,4.997336387634277,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.9269992113113404,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.7282161712646484,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.387966513633728,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.26397442817688,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,5.307156085968018,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.87463641166687,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.4441271424293518,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.79958176612854,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,4.118345260620117,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.4828202724456787,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.0222949981689453,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.9475719928741456,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.0224881172180176,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,6.475175380706787,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.4748642444610596,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.2494912147521973,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.4600114822387695,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,7.184366703033447,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.0005133152008057,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.404863715171814,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.780265212059021,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.8855080604553225,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,7.071150302886963,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.8814436197280884,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.99940824508667,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.5261824727058411,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,3.407034397125244,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.4235429167747497,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.6458333730697632,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.5170451998710632,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.586421489715576,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,41.14698791503906,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,41.14698791503906,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,43.437522888183594,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.8510449528694153,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.4802312850952148,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.3542999029159546,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.805117666721344,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,4.49069356918335,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.7303141951560974,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.7122195959091189,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.2900136709213257,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.1638511419296265,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,4.896398544311523,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.9430040121078491,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.4457795023918152,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.7183762788772583,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,4.107159614562988,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.4215035438537598,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.8232070207595823,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.95054292678833,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.889060854911804,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,6.084314346313477,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.4116997718811035,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.2790231704711914,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.3706743717193604,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,7.061397552490234,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.8266651630401611,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.3714556694030762,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.632235050201416,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.859418869018555,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,6.689774513244629,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.7728300094604492,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.8497158288955688,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.6848906874656677,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,3.30743670463562,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.3624375164508819,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.447987079620361,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.3561374843120575,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.166562080383301,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,38.80373764038086,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,38.80373764038086,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,41.01155853271485,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.0590184926986694,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.7379497289657593,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.5870527029037476,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.00448477268219,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.388505458831787,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.932215690612793,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.8995425701141355,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.4218885898590088,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.2377914190292358,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.491438388824463,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.0441956520080566,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.493135541677475,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.8182859420776367,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,4.355617046356201,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.5775601863861084,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.993400812149048,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.0611379146575928,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.8019102811813352,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,6.434009075164795,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.573563814163208,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.3453352451324463,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.4585464000701904,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,7.377445220947266,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.077965259552002,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.4149250984191897,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.7925642728805542,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.8635988235473633,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,7.149053573608398,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.7965587973594666,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.8375442028045657,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.7236796021461487,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,3.3577826023101807,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.4864757359027862,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.0337941646575928,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.3628244698047638,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.883094310760498,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,42.43694686889648,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,42.43694686889648,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,44.3139762878418,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.9204832911491394,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.4591823816299438,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.6415494680404663,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.2247974872589111,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,5.2460126876831055,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.8180692195892334,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.9677878618240356,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.413190245628357,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.3082391023635864,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,5.507286071777344,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.9316078424453735,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.5368627905845642,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.938069462776184,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,4.4065399169921875,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.704620122909546,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.04331636428833,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.1079201698303225,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.009066581726074,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,6.864923000335693,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.5161044597625732,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.099972724914551,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.5195016860961914,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,7.1355791091918945,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.020263671875,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.2808796167373655,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.983461618423462,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.02325701713562,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,7.307861804962158,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.9852091670036316,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.9636963605880735,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.5748075842857361,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,3.5237131118774414,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.4247526228427887,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.2658908367156982,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.4265940487384796,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,3.1172375679016113,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,43.109153747558594,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,43.109153747558594,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,45.33961486816406,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.9200786352157592,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.5429831743240356,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.5213792324066162,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.0431187152862549,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.027559757232666,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.8089593648910522,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.5961205959320068,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.5216680765151978,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.113166570663452,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.039914608001709,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.8640562295913696,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.4787458181381225,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.8721188306808472,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,4.214920997619629,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.3484166860580444,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.7569867372512815,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.8001583814620972,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.877540946006775,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.783102512359619,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.4963574409484863,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.401865720748902,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.3737971782684326,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,7.27202033996582,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.8228981494903564,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.5015063285827637,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.908400058746338,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.8759266138076784,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,7.108731269836426,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.7258174419403076,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.8921533823013303,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.4794952571392059,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,3.097465991973877,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.4138148128986358,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.0108935832977295,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.4290845394134521,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.853792667388916,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,40.39750671386719,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,40.39750671386719,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,41.52584457397461,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.6702637076377869,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.4482297897338867,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.5614796876907349,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.7583198547363281,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,4.438292980194092,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.7854902744293213,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.629313826560974,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.4445983171463013,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.3245363235473633,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,5.183938503265381,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.9812419414520264,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.4831345677375793,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.7194886207580566,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,4.183865070343018,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.3699029684066772,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.7763068675994873,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.8418470025062561,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.724076509475708,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,5.712133407592773,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.495533227920532,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.2172038555145264,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.2998862266540527,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,7.012623310089111,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.976102352142334,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.3366025686264038,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.614294409751892,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.9523000717163088,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,6.879299163818359,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.7520853281021118,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.112977981567383,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.942467987537384,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,3.807531356811523,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.4177664816379547,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.5408519506454468,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.4923588037490845,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.450977325439453,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,39.668663024902344,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,39.668663024902344,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,41.644569396972656,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.1388193368911743,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.6255340576171875,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.657256007194519,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.158920407295227,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,5.580529689788818,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.8856757879257202,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.7447216510772705,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.427921175956726,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.2836722135543823,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,5.341990947723389,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.9272472858428955,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.514677107334137,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.8751516342163088,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,4.317075729370117,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.5257805585861206,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.8683273792266848,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.9057148694992064,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.85620641708374,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,6.156029224395752,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.438805103302002,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.338667392730713,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.4076125621795654,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,7.185085296630859,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.881203770637512,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.963278651237488,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.8135931491851809,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.8683407306671145,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,7.526416301727295,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.8317338228225708,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.069680690765381,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.8010923862457275,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,3.7025070190429688,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.4089016318321228,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.9819639921188352,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.4901469349861145,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.881012439727783,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,42.69064712524414,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,42.69064712524414,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,44.26850128173828,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.8984073996543884,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.491834044456482,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.5888326168060305,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.7978324890136719,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,4.776906490325928,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.771804690361023,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.672128200531006,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.3069612979888916,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.3138316869735718,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,5.064725875854492,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.003776788711548,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.5918071269989014,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.62316632270813,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,4.21875,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.63045072555542,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.996732234954834,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.0467501878738403,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.9489704370498655,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,6.622903347015381,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.451280117034912,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.4523892402648926,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.477726936340332,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,7.381396293640137,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.881569027900696,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.4099735021591189,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.8391205072402952,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.9437782764434817,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,7.074441432952881,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.879494309425354,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.8511958122253416,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.6713802814483643,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,3.4020705223083496,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.3725241720676422,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.5725866556167605,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.3830522298812866,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.328163146972656,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,40.86935806274414,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,40.86935806274414,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,43.2875862121582,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.9314716458320618,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.4510060548782349,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.5982706546783447,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.9736566543579102,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,4.954405307769775,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.7950214743614197,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.711509346961975,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.4281456470489502,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.4187250137329102,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,5.3534016609191895,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.005035877227783,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.4777874648571014,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.8731826543807983,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,4.356005668640137,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.622908353805542,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.963447093963623,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.0737450122833252,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.9921208620071411,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,6.652221202850342,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.589322805404663,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.118068218231201,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.501666784286499,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,7.209057807922363,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.931523084640503,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.423374891281128,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.7324806451797483,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.9820832014083865,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,7.069461822509766,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.9636802077293396,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.9312019348144531,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.5299224257469177,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,3.424804449081421,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.4449357390403747,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.921222448348999,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.4460044801235199,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.8121626377105713,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,41.831520080566406,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,41.831520080566406,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,44.08566665649414,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.8828229904174805,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.6131387948989868,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.667836308479309,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.9251683354377748,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.088966369628906,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.8015766739845276,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.675330400466919,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.3597289323806765,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.2783207893371582,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.114956855773926,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.002065420150757,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.5033026337623596,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.809710144996643,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,4.315078258514404,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.6920859813690186,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.9701967239379885,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.0211066007614136,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.7577552795410156,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,6.4411444664001465,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.3912980556488037,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.014273166656494,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.2412309646606445,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,6.6468024253845215,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.044586658477783,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.6833490133285522,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.7100588083267212,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.9493649005889893,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,7.387359142303467,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.912308394908905,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.916650891304016,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.596542477607727,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,3.425501823425293,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.4222555458545685,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.779934287071228,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.3857769072055816,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.5879666805267334,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,41.007774353027344,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,41.007774353027344,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,43.22751998901367,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.1097712516784668,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.646662950515747,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.5258307456970217,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.0993419885635376,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.3816070556640625,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.8994802236557007,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.7506120204925537,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.4530423879623413,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.387164831161499,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.490299701690674,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.891130805015564,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.527580201625824,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.992575526237488,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,4.411286354064941,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.589565396308899,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.966586947441101,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.0468209981918335,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.9558637142181396,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,6.558836936950684,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.4963390827178955,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.3557252883911133,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.3521485328674316,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,7.2042131423950195,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.8976337909698489,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.8088802099227903,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.9867088794708252,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.9175695180892944,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,7.610792636871338,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.9109458923339844,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.738593339920044,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.3929437398910522,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,3.04248309135437,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.4751823544502258,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.4301700592041016,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.4113728106021881,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,3.316725015640259,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,43.01624298095703,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,43.01624298095703,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,44.59907150268555,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.0883382558822632,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.8705708980560305,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.627851486206055,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.2296795845031738,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,5.816440105438232,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.8344306349754333,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.8262614011764529,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.4665930271148682,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.211283564567566,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,5.338568687438965,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.0125181674957275,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.4997426271438598,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.967496037483215,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,4.479756832122803,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.6225063800811768,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.0346786975860596,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.1394810676574707,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.9509071111679075,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,6.747573375701904,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.5001235008239746,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.3156163692474365,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.4469680786132812,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,7.262708187103272,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.900079607963562,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.9722753763198853,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.916491985321045,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.0014450550079346,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,7.790291786193848,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.9628946781158448,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.9024653434753416,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.571174681186676,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,3.4365346431732178,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.4460156261920929,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.138688087463379,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.3909366130828857,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.975640296936035,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,43.84751510620117,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,43.84751510620117,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,45.63966369628906,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.3968126773834229,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.7197328805923462,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.688469171524048,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.9425615668296814,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,5.7475762367248535,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.9456174969673156,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.2533493041992188,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.7769604921340942,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.398565411567688,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,6.374492645263672,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.0563600063323975,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.4654050767421722,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.060321569442749,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,4.582086563110352,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.0447356700897217,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.31551194190979,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.6837660074234009,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.383372187614441,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,7.4273858070373535,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.636192321777344,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.4906156063079834,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.5282680988311768,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,7.655076026916504,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.07523250579834,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.0022544860839844,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.057328462600708,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.123624086380005,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,8.258439064025879,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.2234944105148315,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.474050760269165,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.4238232970237732,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,4.121368408203125,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.5296456813812256,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.792384624481201,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.3878465592861175,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,3.709876775741577,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,47.87630081176758,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,47.87630081176758,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,50.40899658203125,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.962916135787964,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.5269322395324707,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.9068787097930908,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,4.396727085113525,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.14590835571289,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.893425464630127,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.0311203002929688,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.0145294666290283,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,8.084983825683594,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.3215136528015137,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.27689528465271,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.6037153601646423,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,4.20212459564209,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.4739281833171844,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.5570833683013916,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.4032614827156067,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,3.4342727661132812,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.1729801893234253,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.688754677772522,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.6228774785995483,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.2670700550079346,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,5.751682281494141,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.8064340353012085,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.1071267127990723,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.500889778137207,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.3106608390808103,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,5.725111484527588,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.7504445314407349,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.4991412162780761,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.9763154983520508,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,4.2259016036987305,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.7991437911987305,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.116649389266968,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.1697230339050293,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.9636212587356567,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,7.049137592315674,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.4944777488708496,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.313584566116333,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.4669432640075684,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,7.275005340576172,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.988848328590393,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.483832597732544,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.0601871013641357,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.004793167114258,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,7.537661075592041,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.9655047059059144,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.9206689596176147,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.5041999816894531,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,3.390373706817627,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.4334955215454101,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.4595158100128174,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.398874968290329,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,3.291886329650879,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,44.24675750732422,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,44.24675750732422,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,46.432029724121094,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.1823511123657229,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.5847506523132324,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.5597567558288574,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.1092987060546875,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,5.4361572265625,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.854546070098877,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.879887580871582,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.4387433528900146,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.42317533493042,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,5.596352577209473,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.978255271911621,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.4485697150230407,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.0783679485321045,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,4.505192756652832,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.6784499883651731,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.0763800144195557,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.126208782196045,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.9125839471817017,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,6.793622970581055,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.445274591445923,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.233322858810425,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.4793384075164795,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,7.157936096191406,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.084694147109986,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.0378551483154297,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.1780142784118652,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.0142176151275635,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,8.314781188964844,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.9331648945808412,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.7318150997161863,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.3722060620784759,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,3.0371861457824707,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.4490734040737152,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.577883243560791,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.4402168095111847,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,3.467173337936402,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,44.30840301513672,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,44.30840301513672,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,45.966896057128906,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.3509466648101809,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.6553537845611572,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.5488507747650146,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.262264609336853,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.817415714263916,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.553287982940674,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.4212143421173096,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.607586622238159,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,7.582088947296143,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.1088063716888428,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.787302017211914,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.1365749835968018,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.052344799041748,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,8.085028648376465,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.1697560548782349,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.085000514984131,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.5103498101234436,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,3.765106439590454,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.0244767665863037,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.5862804651260376,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.437035322189331,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.286683201789856,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,5.334475994110107,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.7577916383743286,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.6584974527359009,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.3826731443405151,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.348254680633545,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,5.147216796875,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.825230598449707,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.445070743560791,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.0170154571533203,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,4.287316799163818,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.5527125597000122,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.8728355169296265,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.0343693494796753,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.9081133604049685,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,6.368030548095703,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.388167142868042,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.397284984588623,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.474404573440552,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,7.259856700897217,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.9172227382659912,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.826646089553833,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.078040838241577,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.9829500913619995,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,7.804859638214111,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.8397912383079529,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.569998264312744,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.4096630215644836,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.8194525241851807,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.4001428186893463,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.3609063625335693,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.3612625002861023,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,3.122311592102051,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,42.14352035522461,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,42.14352035522461,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,43.412132263183594,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.9929195046424866,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.6587525606155396,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.7062480449676514,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.0359441041946411,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,5.393864154815674,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.7420271635055542,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.980457425117493,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.4545494318008425,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.561754822731018,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,5.738788604736328,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.9939992427825928,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.4696415066719055,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.0403025150299072,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,4.503942966461182,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.6469416618347168,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.046221971511841,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.1924903392791748,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.003999948501587,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,6.889654159545898,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.5148863792419434,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.0579934120178223,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.538665533065796,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,7.111545085906982,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.968579649925232,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.4605032205581665,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.188075304031372,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.9469059705734253,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,7.564064025878906,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.0749346017837524,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.844326376914978,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.4548368752002716,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,3.3740978240966797,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.3847823441028595,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.2413907051086426,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.4014008641242981,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,3.027573823928833,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,43.60353088378906,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,43.60353088378906,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,45.983154296875,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.126837968826294,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.7242151498794556,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.463469386100769,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.179573655128479,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.494096279144287,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.8975849151611328,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.9071494340896609,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.5548374652862549,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.4504557847976685,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.810027599334717,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.9649109840393064,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.4799067676067352,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.842888116836548,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,4.287705898284912,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.7508747577667236,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.025979995727539,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.123729586601257,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.9758063554763792,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,6.8763909339904785,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.6078004837036133,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.466593980789185,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.5531680583953857,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,7.627562522888184,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.9800204038619995,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.4236644506454468,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.0971784591674805,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.007301568984986,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,7.508164882659912,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.9098909497261048,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.9606162309646609,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.4693924486637115,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,3.3398995399475098,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.3953531980514526,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.391350030899048,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.4525656104087829,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,3.2392687797546387,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,44.1831169128418,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,44.1831169128418,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,46.24998092651367,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.1201975345611572,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.658276081085205,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.6134048700332642,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.9952410459518432,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,5.387119770050049,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.7676383852958679,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.8374212980270384,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.5086512565612793,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.3483805656433103,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,5.462091445922852,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.9209442138671875,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.4500605165958404,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.965050458908081,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,4.336055278778076,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.8261433839797976,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.04557204246521,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.048730492591858,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.8928512334823608,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,6.813297271728516,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.40959095954895,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.240461826324463,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.433016777038574,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,7.083069801330566,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.017397880554199,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.0413150787353516,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.2495288848876953,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.9301048517227173,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,8.238346099853516,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.8479880094528198,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.8433159589767456,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.3867767751216888,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,3.078080892562866,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.3676512539386749,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.3462576866149902,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.4020751714706421,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,3.1159839630126953,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,43.51404571533203,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,43.51404571533203,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,45.47096252441406,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.991198182106018,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.3520112037658691,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.5275014638900757,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.1924055814743042,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,5.063116550445557,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.7928917407989502,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.7699528932571411,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.4730736017227173,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.2537689208984375,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,5.289687156677246,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.0132269859313965,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.4724960327148437,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.9340521097183228,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,4.419775009155273,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.813045859336853,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.039480209350586,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.185549020767212,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.963613748550415,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,7.001688480377197,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.4674272537231445,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.3223798274993896,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.450691938400269,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,7.240499019622803,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.90123987197876,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.575487494468689,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.856285572052002,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.9957367181777952,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,7.328749656677246,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.9583552479743958,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.778484582901001,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.6361114978790283,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,3.3729515075683594,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.3547090291976928,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.2825703620910645,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.3793774247169494,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,3.0166566371917725,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,42.733123779296875,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,42.733123779296875,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,44.98403549194336,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.0403043031692505,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.8323445320129397,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.7182655334472656,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.038941740989685,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,5.629856109619141,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.7740136981010437,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.814831018447876,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.528162956237793,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.2349032163619995,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,5.3519110679626465,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.0096182823181152,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.4982512295246124,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.827062726020813,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,4.334932327270508,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.6060432195663452,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.9962091445922852,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.1793100833892822,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.9822306632995603,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,6.763792991638184,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.4781394004821777,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.3751635551452637,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.5113072395324707,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,7.364610195159912,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.0351624488830566,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.4566601514816284,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.9034264087677,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.0154573917388916,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,7.410706520080566,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.8738289475440979,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.061561584472656,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.4639631807804107,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,3.3993537425994873,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.4169831573963165,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.070887565612793,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.4094606935977936,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.8973312377929688,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,43.15249252319336,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,43.15249252319336,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,45.1165771484375,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.0206526517868042,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.594620704650879,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.8106496334075928,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.832810640335083,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,5.258733749389648,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.7723525762557983,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.8396120071411133,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.4979904890060425,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.413421869277954,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,5.523376941680908,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.922540545463562,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.4522222280502319,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.824803352355957,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,4.199565887451172,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.5954861640930176,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.030381917953491,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.1718894243240356,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.9408210515975952,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,6.7385783195495605,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.513949155807495,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.5146231651306152,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.4075188636779785,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,7.43609094619751,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.9793684482574463,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.397477149963379,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.9683910608291624,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.9831421375274656,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,7.328378677368164,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.9701430797576904,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.9587191343307495,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.543338418006897,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,3.472200632095337,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.412022590637207,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.408064365386963,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.3875405490398407,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,3.207627296447754,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,43.164554595947266,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,43.164554595947266,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,45.13770294189453,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.293510675430298,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.8365793228149416,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.681170105934143,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.2961041927337646,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,6.107364177703857,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.8433995246887207,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.0367608070373535,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.6586756706237793,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.4352660179138184,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,5.974101543426514,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.925123929977417,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.5938706994056702,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.005295515060425,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,4.524290084838867,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.9225183725357056,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.1550467014312744,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.20189368724823,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.002995491027832,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,7.282454013824463,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.567255973815918,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.3642401695251465,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.507763147354126,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,7.4392595291137695,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.0697262287139893,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.8869117498397827,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.9615596532821655,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.0254886150360107,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,7.943686008453369,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.0357593297958374,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.089202880859375,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.5286656618118286,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,3.653627872467041,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.4317387342453003,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.278305768966675,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.3805385828018188,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,3.090583086013794,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,46.01536560058594,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,46.01536560058594,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,48.5219841003418,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.1703758239746094,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.6218816041946411,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.6509941816329956,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.16609787940979,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.609349250793457,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.7519442439079285,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.8774073123931885,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.4206211566925049,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.3872953653335571,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.437268257141113,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.8374037742614744,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.5442496538162231,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.9312527179718015,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,4.312906265258789,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.697471022605896,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.003495454788208,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.0510454177856443,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.8477439880371096,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,6.599755764007568,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.378833293914795,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.2424135208129883,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.441939353942871,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,7.063186168670654,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.9809277057647705,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.7524404525756836,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.9180744886398315,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.9331841468811035,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,7.5846266746521,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.053169846534729,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.980873942375183,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.5405516624450684,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,3.5745954513549805,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.4062282145023346,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.264761209487915,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.3972994983196258,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,3.068288803100586,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,43.249977111816406,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,43.249977111816406,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,45.14588928222656,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.016948699951172,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.5555830001831057,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.5570337772369385,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.2461912631988523,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,5.375756740570068,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.8164787888526917,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.8572221994400024,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.624923825263977,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.2827407121658323,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,5.581365585327148,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.0507962703704834,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.5689026713371277,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.9344290494918823,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,4.5541276931762695,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.7092307806015017,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.9267669916152952,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.0591851472854614,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.0098509788513184,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,6.705033779144287,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.5374319553375244,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.3886466026306152,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.462134599685669,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,7.388213634490967,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.987227201461792,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.1278157234191895,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.0195658206939697,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.928753137588501,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,8.063362121582031,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.9367111325263976,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.117467164993286,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.4006886780261993,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,3.454867124557495,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.5126974582672119,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.2484874725341797,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.4299128651618957,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,3.1910977363586426,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,44.31382369995117,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,44.31382369995117,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,46.13795852661133,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.9764145016670228,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.4092005491256714,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.589312195777893,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.9447717666625975,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,4.919699192047119,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.8368438482284546,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.9926398992538452,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.5237882137298584,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.3533414602279663,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,5.706613540649414,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.9529178142547607,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.6569560766220093,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.664375901222229,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,4.274250030517578,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.927392601966858,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.155222177505493,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.1850544214248655,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.9391077756881712,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,7.20677661895752,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.370885848999023,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.37024450302124,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.389387607574463,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,7.130517959594727,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.0263359546661377,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.4708094596862793,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.8500369787216189,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.884967803955078,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,7.232150077819824,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.075929880142212,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.88710618019104,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.5616498589515686,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,3.524685859680176,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.4373176395893097,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.8904908895492551,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.4389356672763824,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.7667441368103027,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,42.761436462402344,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,42.761436462402344,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,45.87373733520508,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.9394224882125854,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.6192209720611572,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.5230404138565063,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.8924424648284912,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,4.97412633895874,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.8095172047615051,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.538793683052063,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.538500428199768,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.3720402717590332,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,5.258851528167725,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.012031078338623,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.5681475400924683,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.7511258125305176,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,4.331304550170898,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.6366479396820068,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.9568896293640137,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.05784273147583,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.8818438053131104,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,6.533224105834961,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.335752487182617,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.292921781539917,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.364694118499756,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,6.993368625640869,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.978013038635254,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.5499125719070437,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.8793889284133911,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.820213794708252,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,7.22752857208252,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.9506805539131165,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.7185611724853516,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.7544964551925659,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,3.4237380027770996,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.4441170990467071,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.0267839431762695,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.5611575245857239,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,3.0320584774017334,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,41.774200439453125,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,41.774200439453125,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,43.742774963378906,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.1248074769973757,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.757871150970459,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.6185718774795532,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.2708672285079956,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.772118091583252,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.9704539775848388,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.8875986337661743,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.615579605102539,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.3740181922912598,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.847650527954102,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.043917179107666,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.5328540205955505,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.7495150566101074,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,4.326286315917969,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.787097692489624,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.0537819862365723,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.2247871160507202,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.9701193571090696,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,7.035786151885986,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.529489755630493,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.36466646194458,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.399677276611328,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,7.2938337326049805,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.10840368270874,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.7664910554885864,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.0959928035736084,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.9848809242248535,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,7.955768585205078,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.0827826261520386,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.0033040046691895,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.9479222297668456,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,4.034008979797363,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.4787643849849701,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.2754406929016113,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.3648077547550201,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,3.1190128326416016,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,45.384464263916016,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,45.384464263916016,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,47.8497200012207,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.1115047931671145,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.224572777748108,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.518226146697998,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.6392135620117188,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,4.4935173988342285,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.746813952922821,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.4291903972625732,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.3568071126937866,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.3793917894363403,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,4.912203311920166,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.884727954864502,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.4077367186546325,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.9098403453826904,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,4.202304840087891,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.5355780124664309,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.01186466217041,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.137129306793213,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.9107297658920288,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,6.595301628112793,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.427236557006836,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.436826229095459,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.442159414291382,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,7.306221961975098,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.989223837852478,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.9475895166397097,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.3017189502716064,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.961504340171814,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,8.200037002563477,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.944154977798462,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.83652925491333,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.3859797716140747,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,3.166664123535156,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.454028844833374,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.842644453048706,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.3974321782588959,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,3.694105386734009,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,42.57035446166992,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,42.57035446166992,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,43.72237014770508,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.1121009588241575,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.4838569164276123,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.5303782224655151,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.6549292802810669,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,4.7812652587890625,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.7349799871444702,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.6690384149551392,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.411963701248169,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.3803600072860718,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,5.1963419914245605,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.9635727405548096,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.4843330979347229,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.9161380529403689,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,4.364043712615967,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.5146230459213257,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.993033528327942,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.1290332078933716,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.8549295663833616,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,6.491619110107422,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.3328802585601807,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.2860217094421387,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.498920202255249,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,7.117822170257568,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.9720717668533323,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.9804396629333496,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.1385340690612793,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.967066526412964,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,8.058112144470215,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.9672964811325072,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.8676143884658811,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.3833402693271637,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,3.2182512283325195,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.3966803550720215,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.2320854663848877,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.3814802169799804,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,3.0102460384368896,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,42.237701416015625,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,42.237701416015625,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,44.02537155151367,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.100264549255371,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.3661905527114868,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.535237193107605,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.0419068336486816,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,5.0435991287231445,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.9279558062553406,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.7741682529449463,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.350438952445984,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.3233911991119385,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,5.3759541511535645,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.0623252391815186,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.4754306077957153,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.8577792644500732,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,4.395534992218018,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.6280142068862915,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.05267596244812,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.2190483808517456,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.8843656778335571,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,6.784104347229004,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.4362337589263916,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.37835431098938,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.3636722564697266,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,7.178260326385498,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.8975759744644165,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.9330029487609863,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.7275117635726929,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.961554765701294,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,7.519645690917969,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.0392613410949707,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.8388779163360596,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.5624179244041443,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,3.4405572414398193,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.4668314456939697,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.2468461990356445,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.4770265817642212,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,3.190704107284546,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,42.92835998535156,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,42.92835998535156,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,44.945220947265625,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.8820630311965942,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.2528047561645508,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.2414790391921997,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.9601966738700868,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,4.336543560028076,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.7420560717582703,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.6025313138961792,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.3552780151367188,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.3406842947006226,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,5.0405497550964355,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.9619832038879397,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.4428628385066986,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.7367361783981323,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,4.141582489013672,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.8412050008773804,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.1074955463409424,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.2051435708999634,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.9112714529037476,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,7.065115451812744,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.386637926101685,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.1849822998046875,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.4642319679260254,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,7.035851955413818,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.9961612224578855,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.9835939407348633,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.842829346656799,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.9832892417907717,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,7.805873870849609,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.065814733505249,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.8660192489624023,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.4325263202190399,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,3.3643603324890137,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.4135088324546814,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.0815322399139404,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.3751709163188934,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.8702120780944824,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,41.66008758544922,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,41.66008758544922,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,44.23515701293945,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.8719592094421387,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.2769681215286257,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.368632197380066,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.8700526356697083,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,4.3876118659973145,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.7599694132804871,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.5124163627624512,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.481860876083374,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.2263654470443726,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,4.980612277984619,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.9620602130889893,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.4726318120956421,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.6537433862686155,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,4.088435649871826,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.4227900505065918,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.9607033729553225,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.0098581314086914,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.858800768852234,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,6.252152442932129,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.369901418685913,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.279613256454468,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.3677666187286377,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,7.017281532287598,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.9355987310409544,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.99566912651062,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.832829833030701,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.9331841468811035,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,7.697281837463379,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.9247831106185912,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.9788576364517212,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.6056925654411316,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,3.509333372116089,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.3914208710193634,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.0206539630889893,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.397544264793396,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.8096189498901367,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,40.74232864379883,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,40.74232864379883,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,42.64814376831055,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.0463155508041382,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.2934740781784058,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.4414080381393433,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.7170870900154114,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,4.498284816741943,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.9213966131210328,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.6160967350006104,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.5376298427581787,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.4206914901733398,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,5.495814800262451,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.111626625061035,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.4296064674854278,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.9031670093536377,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,4.444400310516357,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.6202503442764282,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.0025346279144287,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.2857811450958252,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.0328128337860107,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,6.941379070281982,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.422943592071533,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.4584341049194336,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.461390256881714,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,7.34276819229126,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.8538877964019775,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.9863438606262207,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.0508110523223877,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.9161394834518433,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,7.807182312011719,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.9937422275543212,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.9801521301269531,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.4545336663722992,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,3.4284279346466064,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.4464330971240997,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.557284355163574,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.4749062359333038,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,3.478623628616333,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,43.43688201904297,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,43.43688201904297,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,45.528865814208984,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.2066787481307983,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.5693753957748413,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.4235345125198364,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.2052446603775024,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,5.4048333168029785,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.9389256834983826,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.8114742040634155,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.6732827425003052,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.439038634300232,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,5.8627214431762695,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.048145532608032,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.4857082068920135,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.8223470449447632,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,4.356200695037842,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.8528465032577517,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.128679037094116,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.5062322616577148,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.03243637084961,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,7.520194053649902,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.5028789043426514,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.5092215538024902,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.517437219619751,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,7.529537677764893,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.9930185079574585,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.0168325901031494,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.0430948734283447,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.009190797805786,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,8.06213665008545,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.0626693964004517,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.0658960342407227,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.6034920811653137,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,3.732057571411133,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.4402624070644378,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.6763687133789062,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.415906548500061,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,3.5325374603271484,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,46.00021743774414,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,46.00021743774414,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,48.521751403808594,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.953891396522522,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.4772862195968628,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.4136414527893066,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.583074688911438,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,5.42789363861084,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.8404393196105957,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.7996869087219238,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.8404228687286377,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.481670618057251,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,5.962219715118408,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.134463310241699,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.4954487383365631,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.7957956790924072,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,4.425707817077637,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.638588309288025,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.0309109687805176,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.29684317111969,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.9773175716400144,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,6.943660259246826,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.5449676513671875,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.3823463916778564,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.511446237564087,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,7.438760280609131,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.008978843688965,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.8158670663833616,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.9650084972381592,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.9084172248840332,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,7.698271751403809,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.010027289390564,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.9476909637451172,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.3958333432674408,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,3.3535516262054443,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.4658563137054443,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.4122307300567627,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.4116008281707763,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,3.2896878719329834,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,44.53975296020508,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,44.53975296020508,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,46.78810501098633,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.8308988213539124,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.2758796215057373,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.4477218389511108,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.1932834386825562,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,4.747783660888672,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.7740132808685303,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.4328820705413818,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.323152780532837,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.1262835264205933,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,4.656331539154053,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8910651206970217,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.486648291349411,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8013951778411863,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,4.179108619689941,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.4167574644088743,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.907181739807129,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.9453082084655762,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.930670976638794,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,6.199918270111084,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.3141446113586426,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.2058308124542236,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.3740320205688477,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,6.894007682800293,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8528509140014648,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.949077844619751,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.760209321975708,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8737856149673464,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,7.4359235763549805,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.7907612323760986,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.878249168395996,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.582823634147644,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,3.2518341541290283,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.3708999454975128,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8686060905456543,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.3711919784545898,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.6106979846954346,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,39.97560501098633,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,39.97560501098633,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,41.62677764892578,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.9051889777183532,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.37796950340271,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.608351707458496,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.1337742805480957,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,5.025284290313721,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.8103147149085999,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.611682653427124,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.3396323919296265,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.271087884902954,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,5.032717704772949,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.7098203897476196,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.4792525172233581,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.7275758981704712,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,3.9166488647460938,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.4346705675125122,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.923564314842224,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.0099636316299438,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.8602060079574585,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,6.228404521942139,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.2610373497009277,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.1442172527313232,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.233233690261841,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,6.638488292694092,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.8769270181655884,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.3734829425811768,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.7457574605941772,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.8553966283798216,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,6.851564407348633,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.7700657248497009,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.8902587890625,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.4313063621520996,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,3.0916309356689453,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.4417513608932495,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.0704848766326904,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.3766527771949768,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.8888888359069824,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,39.67362976074219,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,39.67362976074219,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,41.49851989746094,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.99547278881073,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.294077754020691,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.4718841314315796,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.377352595329285,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,5.138787269592285,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.7395911812782288,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.5768834352493286,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.281341791152954,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.2410820722579956,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,4.838898658752441,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.8803080320358276,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.4361705482006073,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.8312636613845823,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,4.14774227142334,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.5390113592147827,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.9594173431396484,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.1590430736541748,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.732364535331726,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,6.389836311340332,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.4104037284851074,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.329190254211426,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.505455493927002,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,7.245049476623535,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.8938504457473757,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.9617375135421753,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.733687162399292,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.9018833637237549,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,7.491158485412598,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.909849226474762,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.7059074640274048,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.367634505033493,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.983391284942627,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.3858710825443268,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.128332138061523,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.3732689023017883,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.887472152709961,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,41.122337341308594,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,41.122337341308594,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,42.534637451171875,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.963083028793335,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.3254146575927734,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.4108942747116089,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.092951416969299,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,4.792343616485596,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.8148502111434937,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.5245698690414429,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.300498604774475,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.230866551399231,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,4.870785236358643,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.9366908073425293,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.5236751437187195,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.863490104675293,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,4.323855876922607,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.390234112739563,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.924939513206482,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.9324120283126832,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.831185221672058,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,6.078771114349365,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.4284472465515137,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.401548147201538,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.4241223335266113,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,7.254117488861084,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.8794499635696411,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.2039531469345093,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.6315338611602783,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.905882716178894,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,6.620819568634033,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.8777596950531006,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.066706657409668,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.5203968286514282,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,3.4648630619049072,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.4462869763374328,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.2741315364837646,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.4014579951763153,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,3.1218764781951904,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,40.52743148803711,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,40.52743148803711,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,41.75934600830078,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.0140576362609863,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.6073617935180664,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.518144607543945,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.921088457107544,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,5.060652256011963,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.8167882561683655,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.565592646598816,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.406569242477417,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.1451849937438965,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,4.9341349601745605,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.0588905811309814,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.460234671831131,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.6561590433120728,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,4.175284385681152,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.5008704662322998,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.9999865293502808,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.1051383018493652,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.9176090955734253,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,6.523604393005371,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.354398012161255,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.3808791637420654,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.474165439605713,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,7.209442615509033,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.876991629600525,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.030984878540039,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.8753570318222048,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.8765957355499268,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,6.659929275512695,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.8920474052429199,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.74659264087677,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.4152176678180694,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,3.0538578033447266,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.3818505406379699,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.305539131164551,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.4054194092750549,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,3.092808961868286,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,40.709712982177734,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,40.709712982177734,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,42.27494430541992,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.047622561454773,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.4291592836380005,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.5657416582107544,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.984729826450348,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,5.0272536277771,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.8085106611251831,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.6117866039276123,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.5114706754684448,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.2125728130340576,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,5.144340515136719,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.8506265878677368,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.4567031562328338,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.6941567659378052,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,4.001486301422119,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.4096461534500122,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.019727945327759,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.0811949968338013,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.460029125213623,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,5.970598220825195,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.4267749786376953,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.124016761779785,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.527092695236206,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,7.077884674072266,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.7696183919906616,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.9157982468605042,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.831947922706604,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.8958709239959717,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,6.413235664367676,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.9679858088493348,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.5268620252609253,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.4067684412002563,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.901616334915161,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.4065212607383728,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.4968223571777344,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.4946691393852234,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,3.398012638092041,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,39.93442916870117,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,39.93442916870117,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,41.018829345703125,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.8574197292327881,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.3203039169311523,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.320792555809021,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.773492157459259,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,4.272008419036865,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.7406905293464661,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.4115160703659058,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.2420216798782349,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.1621215343475342,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,4.556349754333496,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.9577521085739136,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.4027868211269378,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.6593186855316162,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,4.019857406616211,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.4790061712265017,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.923631191253662,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.146155834197998,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.855204701423645,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,6.403997898101807,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.2091338634490967,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.9856302738189695,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.38127064704895,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,6.576035022735596,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.781774878501892,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.9430941343307495,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.880970358848572,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.9130433797836304,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,7.518882751464844,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.8287951350212097,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.7529282569885254,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.3997759521007538,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.981499433517456,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.3652170300483703,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.2494425773620605,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.4737481772899627,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,3.0884077548980713,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,39.41703796386719,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,39.41703796386719,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,41.041954040527344,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.256569504737854,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.6840083599090576,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.5259820222854614,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.4828119277954102,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,5.949371814727783,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.8631659150123596,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.025534152984619,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.7467631101608276,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.5743919610977173,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,6.209855079650879,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.1368610858917236,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.4676637649536133,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.9377868175506592,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,4.542311668395996,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.9696948528289795,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.2011935710906982,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.6763715744018557,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.092723608016968,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,7.93998384475708,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.584961414337158,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.391223430633545,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.4996938705444336,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,7.475878715515137,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.976566195487976,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.0143511295318604,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.22114896774292,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.9944062232971191,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,8.206472396850586,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.212091326713562,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.903021454811096,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.3534081280231476,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,3.4685208797454834,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.4559816718101501,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.8112072944641113,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.389217346906662,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,3.656406164169311,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,47.44879913330078,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,47.44879913330078,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,50.228214263916016,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.0599448680877686,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.2321833372116089,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.3610219955444336,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.1236087083816528,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,4.776759147644043,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.8300865292549133,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.4800055027008057,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.3895775079727173,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.262251377105713,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,4.961920738220215,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.942332983016968,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.432777851819992,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.805769443511963,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,4.180880069732666,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.4520734548568726,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.037043333053589,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.1230117082595823,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.9266704320907593,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,6.538798809051514,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.3292365074157715,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.3982622623443604,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.436630964279175,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,7.164129734039307,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.7566142082214355,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.9411081075668335,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.0638444423675537,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.9003217220306396,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,7.661888599395752,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.8527143597602844,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.6156975030899048,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.3615927398204803,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.8300046920776367,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.3824144303798675,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.3881680965423584,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.3781985342502594,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,3.148781061172486,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,41.26316452026367,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,41.26316452026367,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,42.78512191772461,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.1245033740997314,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.156220555305481,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.4413326978683472,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.6014156341552734,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,4.323472499847412,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.7804942727088928,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.699569821357727,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.434466004371643,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.2689719200134275,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,5.183502197265625,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.973721623420715,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.473524659872055,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.8032925128936768,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,4.2505388259887695,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.7335540056228638,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.050448417663574,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.2871462106704712,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.8818103075027464,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,6.952959060668945,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.4058656692504883,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.2861616611480713,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.387591600418091,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,7.07961893081665,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.793134331703186,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.9040751457214355,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.2294814586639404,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.9311609268188477,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,7.857851982116699,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.0330663919448853,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.7255966663360596,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.4386742115020752,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,3.1973371505737305,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.4061238765716553,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.384312391281128,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.3572230637073517,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,3.1476590633392334,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,41.99293899536133,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,41.99293899536133,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,44.27579116821289,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.9263118505477904,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.1008694171905518,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.354425072669983,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.1866391897201538,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,4.5682454109191895,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.7567188143730164,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.467621684074402,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.369601130485535,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.2721726894378662,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,4.866114616394043,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.0186238288879395,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.402775764465332,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.88105571269989,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,4.302455425262451,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.4115493297576904,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.8679890632629397,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.1115449666976929,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.930484175682068,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,6.321567535400391,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.420888185501098,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.3369643688201904,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.3967361450195312,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,7.15458869934082,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.8233405351638792,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.6378493309020996,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.1668522357940674,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.889246940612793,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,7.517289161682129,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.9004843235015869,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.7309117317199707,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.3423149883747101,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.9737110137939453,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.4122441112995147,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.5142571926116943,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.3899080157279968,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,3.3164093494415283,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,41.020381927490234,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,41.020381927490234,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,42.23397064208984,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.9038102030754088,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.232064723968506,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.3185577392578125,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.3578896522521973,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,4.812322616577148,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.7147590517997742,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.372207522392273,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.3710728883743286,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.2857365608215332,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,4.743775844573975,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.93994140625,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.4447060525417328,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.6107903718948364,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,3.995437860488891,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.4514957666397097,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.886538863182068,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.0574514865875244,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.8481576442718504,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,6.243643760681152,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.3953356742858887,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.3745594024658203,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.449413776397705,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,7.219308853149414,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.7664878368377686,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.310291051864624,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.8977806568145752,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.8602426052093504,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,6.834802150726318,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.8682353496551514,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.8446975946426392,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.438929796218872,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,3.151862859725952,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.362823486328125,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.066446304321289,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.3788144290447235,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.808084011077881,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,39.80923843383789,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,39.80923843383789,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,41.337684631347656,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.8406041264533997,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.018795371055603,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.1143624782562256,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.0894062519073486,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,4.063168048858643,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.7188159227371216,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.203824520111084,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.271153450012207,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.2164220809936523,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,4.410215854644775,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.040470838546753,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.4204014539718628,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.6960761547088623,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,4.156948566436768,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.928212523460388,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.164017677307129,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.3796473741531372,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.9310717582702637,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,7.402949333190918,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.299164295196533,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.39689302444458,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.4969210624694824,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,7.192978382110596,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.8679795265197752,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.4146884679794312,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.1360650062561035,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.8517671823501587,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,7.270500183105469,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.2097439765930176,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.9576057195663452,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.0124711990356443,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,4.179821014404297,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.3485487401485443,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.6112685203552246,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.3403997123241424,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.3002169132232666,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,40.97679901123047,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,40.97679901123047,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,44.0848503112793,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.7469398975372314,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.2090013027191162,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.1160730123519895,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.153964281082153,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,4.225978374481201,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.7113913297653198,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.549091339111328,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.3653132915496826,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.1688446998596191,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,4.79464054107666,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.8536423444747925,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.4504546821117401,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.6661463975906372,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,3.970243453979492,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.574042558670044,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.972127676010132,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.2688376903533936,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.8111437559127808,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,6.6261515617370605,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.4416346549987793,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.444390773773194,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.4976189136505127,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,7.383644580841064,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.9493021965026855,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.9603936672210691,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.8980640172958376,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.90035617351532,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,7.708116054534912,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.007599949836731,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.6849719285964966,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.5631952881813049,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,3.2557671070098877,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.3323502540588379,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.909886598587036,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.3903721868991852,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.6326088905334473,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,40.59715270996094,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,40.59715270996094,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,42.718894958496094,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.8655945062637329,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.022661566734314,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.3639845848083496,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.8638851642608643,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,4.116125583648682,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.73499596118927,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.4121886491775513,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.4040240049362185,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.2869025468826294,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,4.838111400604248,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.919735074043274,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.4735308885574341,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.600173830986023,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,3.9934396743774414,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.627227544784546,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.9679017066955569,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.0680510997772217,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.936688542366028,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,6.5998687744140625,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.3737308979034424,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.405240535736084,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.5061793327331543,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,7.285150527954102,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.9364694356918335,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.040260076522827,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.155714273452759,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.927021861076355,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,8.059465408325195,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.9466984272003174,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.7737312316894531,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.4369127154350281,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,3.1573424339294434,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.361630916595459,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.941473603248596,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.3646179735660553,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.667722463607788,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,40.717227935791016,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,40.717227935791016,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,42.83510971069336,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.0388256311416626,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.2073088884353638,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.275753140449524,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.061409592628479,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,4.583297252655029,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.8046738505363464,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.4943331480026243,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.47267484664917,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.3593324422836304,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,5.131014347076416,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.051851749420166,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.4971784949302673,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.866111397743225,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,4.415141582489014,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.671377182006836,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.986672043800354,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.1601847410202026,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.9393696784973145,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,6.757603645324707,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.477628231048584,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.358419179916382,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.443517684936523,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,7.27956485748291,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.9988871812820437,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.9675650596618652,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.279672384262085,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.025662660598755,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,8.271787643432617,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.9803165197372437,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.8710626363754272,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.8021305799484253,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,3.6535098552703857,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.4110182225704193,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.139997959136963,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.3817773163318634,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.932793378829956,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,43.02471160888672,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,43.02471160888672,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,45.124385833740234,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.7963542938232422,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.0155619382858276,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.5323896408081057,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.985205888748169,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,4.329511642456055,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.7371534109115601,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.350194811820984,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.1992502212524414,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.3153939247131348,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,4.601992607116699,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.174261569976806,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.4447551071643829,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.6211824417114258,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,4.240199089050293,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.573134183883667,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.9413198232650757,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.2434505224227903,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.876736044883728,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,6.634640693664551,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.490729808807373,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.5448386669158936,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.5454180240631104,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,7.580986499786377,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.022435188293457,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.342565417289734,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.106667995452881,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.9031001329421997,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,7.37476921081543,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.9874655604362488,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.8892940282821655,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.7496120929718018,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,4.62637186050415,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.4033910036087036,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.941986918449402,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.4159354567527771,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.7613134384155273,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,42.149784088134766,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,42.149784088134766,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,44.182762145996094,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.7543039321899414,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.1896966695785522,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.3957666158676147,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.112024188041687,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,4.451791286468506,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.7493822574615479,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.3813599348068235,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.2172623872756958,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.2488902807235718,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,4.59689474105835,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.9035793542861936,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.3851356506347656,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.8696693181991575,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,4.158384323120117,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.5598976612091064,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.9865127801895144,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.1523358821868896,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.727230429649353,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,6.425976753234863,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.315816879272461,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.2580647468566895,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.4879813194274902,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,7.061862945556641,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.9392154216766355,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.4152387380599976,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.3245551586151123,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.9347922801971436,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,7.6138014793396,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.9785481691360474,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.939272165298462,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.1833330392837524,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,4.101153373718262,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.37631356716156,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.8149951696395872,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.400962769985199,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.592271327972412,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,41.00213623046875,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,41.00213623046875,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,43.02626419067383,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.7657064199447632,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.0306090116500854,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.1265089511871338,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.8526545166969299,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,3.775478839874267,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.6935229301452637,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.428419828414917,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.3041101694107056,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.331081748008728,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,4.757134437561035,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.9492110013961792,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.4344353079795837,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.901890993118286,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,4.285537242889404,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.542649745941162,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.945326805114746,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.0434216260910034,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.8823119401931765,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,6.413710117340088,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.3677494525909424,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.2031288146972656,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.615161657333374,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,7.186039924621582,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.9228136539459229,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.3925349712371826,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.8961840867996216,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.935734748840332,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,7.1472673416137695,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.0127719640731812,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.840445041656494,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.0246611833572388,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,3.877878189086914,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.3641377389431,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.8120684623718264,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.4208345711231231,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.59704065322876,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,40.04008865356445,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,40.04008865356445,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,42.31573867797851,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.7099675536155701,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.935276448726654,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.0979491472244265,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.9679338335990906,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,3.7111270427703857,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.7148258090019226,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.421707272529602,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.2898048162460327,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.3288084268569946,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,4.755146503448486,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.0000336170196533,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.4121626913547516,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.5886255502700806,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,4.000822067260742,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.517295241355896,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.8905489444732664,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.2144079208374023,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.9149771928787231,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,6.537229061126709,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.3218441009521484,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.2722513675689697,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.482593297958374,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,7.076688766479492,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.8861147165298464,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.4127250909805298,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.0042102336883545,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.895033359527588,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,7.198083400726318,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.0167237520217896,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.9332188367843628,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.1217374801635742,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,4.071680068969727,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.373081773519516,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.8748230934143064,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.3760669231414795,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.623971700668335,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,39.97474670410156,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,39.97474670410156,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,42.50227737426758,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.9327773451805116,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.0808249711990356,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.2464674711227417,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.0104784965515137,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,4.270548343658447,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.810391366481781,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.6386921405792236,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.3820922374725342,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.2721989154815674,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,5.103374481201172,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.093693256378174,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.4481798410415649,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.6866964101791382,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,4.228569507598877,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.784968018531799,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.05626916885376,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.399598240852356,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.95838463306427,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,7.199220180511475,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.393470048904419,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.397710084915161,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.4736404418945312,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,7.264820575714111,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.0232555866241455,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.212882399559021,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.0249781608581543,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.9445886611938477,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,7.205704689025879,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.1482001543045044,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.794749140739441,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.4289870262145996,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,4.371936321258545,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.4350491166114807,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.0382297039031982,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.4741518199443817,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.9474306106567383,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,42.59160614013672,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,42.59160614013672,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,45.45695114135742,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.8811314702033997,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.0260127782821655,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.3379437923431396,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.2469751834869385,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,4.492063045501709,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.7484623789787292,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.5907598733901978,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.376350998878479,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.3728290796279907,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,5.088402271270752,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.0959300994873047,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.4156619608402252,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.846832036972046,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,4.358424186706543,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.894495725631714,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.175182819366455,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.408308982849121,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.9218157529830933,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,7.399803161621094,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.404147148132324,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.3645215034484863,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.6434214115142822,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,7.412090301513672,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.906895637512207,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.378053069114685,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.014209270477295,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.9752192497253416,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,7.274377346038818,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.228639006614685,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.974237084388733,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.6090891361236572,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,3.811965227127075,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.4093422591686249,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.1639297008514404,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.445508748292923,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,3.0187807083129883,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,42.85590744018555,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,42.85590744018555,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,45.542118072509766,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.1367943286895752,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.3811184167861938,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.2676732540130615,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.2533687353134155,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,5.038954734802246,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.870704710483551,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.8420041799545288,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.4973061084747314,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.533752202987671,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,5.743767261505127,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.1971137523651123,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.5161260366439819,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.803714156150818,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,4.516953945159912,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.9359023571014404,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.1434030532836914,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.4170445203781128,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.0111849308013916,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,7.507534980773926,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.5663864612579346,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.3279213905334473,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.579606294631958,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,7.47391414642334,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.008382558822632,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.7965576648712158,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.054677248001098,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.009340286254883,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,7.86895751953125,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.1242616176605225,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.9399925470352173,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.611528217792511,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,3.675782442092895,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.4292941689491272,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.238718032836914,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.4175435602664947,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,3.0855555534362793,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,44.91142272949219,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,44.91142272949219,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,47.80388641357422,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.9812285900115968,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.092078447341919,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.3707789182662964,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.7337178587913513,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,4.177803993225098,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.818206787109375,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.5611172914505005,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.4066790342330933,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.361221432685852,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,5.147224426269531,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.113899946212769,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.5310782790184021,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.8187386989593504,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,4.463716983795166,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.769412875175476,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.021650552749634,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.248725652694702,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.9137386083602903,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,6.953527927398682,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.4191136360168457,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.423907995223999,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.4938066005706787,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,7.336828231811523,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.87238347530365,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.4505795240402222,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.0038328170776367,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.9243777990341189,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,7.251173496246338,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.039597511291504,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.7652716636657717,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.6699958443641663,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,3.474864959716797,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.4348947703838348,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.2294983863830566,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.4050544202327728,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,3.0694475173950195,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,41.87458801269531,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,41.87458801269531,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2022,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,44.21089172363281,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.3239250183105469,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.6226574182510376,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.470848798751831,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.0101029872894287,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.427534103393555,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.9836836457252502,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.8164230585098269,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.4431440830230713,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.4274965524673462,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.67074728012085,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.9001423120498655,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.4157090485095978,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.9601484537124632,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,4.275999546051025,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.5994679927825928,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.9140727519989016,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.150484561920166,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.0707457065582275,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,6.734770774841309,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.415735960006714,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.3497579097747803,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.3956151008605957,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,7.16110897064209,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.702908635139465,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.9570213556289673,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.2547800540924072,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.9338712692260744,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,7.848581314086914,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.8995798826217651,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.6225031614303589,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.3467278182506561,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.8688108921051025,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.5520822405815125,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.917801856994629,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.5028674006462097,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,3.9727511405944824,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,43.960304260253906,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,43.960304260253906,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,44.76447677612305,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.0216374397277832,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.709966778755188,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.5104107856750488,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.0410887002944946,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,5.2831034660339355,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.017069935798645,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.9034663438796997,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.43266761302948,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.4588115215301514,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,5.812015533447266,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.0766139030456543,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.52128666639328,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.7874950170516968,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,4.385395526885986,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.790676832199097,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.208045721054077,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.233224391937256,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.9431082010269165,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,7.175055027008057,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.6252570152282715,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.285557270050049,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.4835031032562256,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,7.394317626953125,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.053114652633667,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.438712477684021,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.737166166305542,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.941401124000549,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,7.170394420623779,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.0963821411132812,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.099820137023926,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.7651297450065613,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,3.961332082748413,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.6843309998512268,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.8883357048034668,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.4936468601226806,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,3.0663135051727295,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,44.247928619384766,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,44.247928619384766,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,46.437992095947266,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.9374423623085022,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.4928678274154663,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.459062099456787,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.883605420589447,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,4.772977828979492,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.7732658386230469,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.6276850700378418,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.2969491481781006,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.2878352403640747,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,4.9857354164123535,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.943915009498596,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.4302958548069,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.9477370977401731,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,4.321948051452637,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.589181900024414,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.0618021488189697,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.137994647026062,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.9564096927642824,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,6.745388507843018,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.328368663787842,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.105674982070923,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.3952114582061768,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,6.829255104064941,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.9008218050003052,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.967658281326294,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.7318540811538696,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.879753351211548,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,7.480087757110596,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.9813185930252076,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.045976161956787,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.6530464291572571,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,3.680341243743897,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.4061766266822815,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.054677724838257,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.3785606026649475,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.8394150733947754,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,41.655147552490234,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,41.655147552490234,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,43.44868850708008,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.0847785472869873,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.80809223651886,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.5726832151412964,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.9828376770019532,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.448391437530518,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.0041447877883911,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.7250772714614868,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.314362406730652,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.352257490158081,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.3958420753479,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.9080135822296145,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.4650941789150238,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.8243331909179688,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,4.197441101074219,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.695018649101257,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.0421929359436035,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.2079592943191528,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.9085369110107424,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,6.853707790374756,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.5720791816711426,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.249284267425537,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.430858373641968,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,7.252222061157227,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.993341088294983,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.4147523641586304,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.8535704612731936,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.8662270307540896,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,7.1278910636901855,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.950634777545929,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.9886430501937864,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.8748731017112732,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,3.8141510486602783,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.5218880772590637,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.3036186695098877,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.4331519305706024,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,3.258658647537231,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,43.34830474853515,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,43.34830474853515,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,44.897335052490234,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.0041286945343018,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.4500329494476318,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.5183987617492676,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.9954758286476136,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,4.96803617477417,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.7920724153518677,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.6334165334701538,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.2455549240112305,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.3527047634124756,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,5.023748397827148,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.9380099773406985,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.4542312324047088,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.8533294200897217,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,4.245570659637451,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.7571243047714231,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.091644763946533,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.211592674255371,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.802584171295166,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,6.862946033477783,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.5151875019073486,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.0892539024353027,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.4615468978881836,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,7.065988063812256,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.947497844696045,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.2584500312805176,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.7667393684387207,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.9398105144500732,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,6.912497520446777,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.0128690004348757,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.9715023040771484,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.425734281539917,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,3.4101057052612305,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.4644367098808288,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.0586538314819336,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.4819637537002563,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,3.005054235458374,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,41.49394607543945,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,41.49394607543945,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,43.12509536743164,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.9571110010147096,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.5245263576507568,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.456942439079285,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.0627464056015017,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.001326560974121,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.881550669670105,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.8245139122009275,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.3258365392684937,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.3253265619277954,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.357227802276611,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.9072751998901367,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.4968948662281036,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.821594715118408,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,4.225764751434326,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.535272479057312,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.9260571002960205,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.076978087425232,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.8422523736953735,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,6.380559921264648,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.5744497776031494,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.3887476921081543,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.504664897918701,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,7.467862606048584,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.940139412879944,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.4335880279541016,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.873508095741272,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.919812798500061,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,7.167048454284668,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.8919308185577393,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.9435539245605469,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.5388268828392029,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,3.374311685562134,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.530979335308075,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.18196964263916,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.4204510748386383,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,3.1333999633789062,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,42.10750198364258,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,42.10750198364258,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,43.28861618041992,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.8473427295684814,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.454095482826233,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.6434977054595947,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.7515040040016174,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,4.69644021987915,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.9192954301834106,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.6699810028076172,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.2625610828399658,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.3995825052261353,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,5.251420021057129,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.0493617057800293,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.5158270597457886,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.86356782913208,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,4.4287567138671875,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.632807374000549,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.9611719846725464,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.079725980758667,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.953386306762695,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,6.627091407775879,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.459710121154785,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.3381314277648926,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.397245168685913,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,7.195086479187012,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.9826990365982056,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.398401975631714,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.6847290992736816,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.8675490617752075,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,6.933379173278809,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.0272634029388428,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.2149083614349365,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.7049782276153564,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,3.947149991989136,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.4961670339107513,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.9477641582489016,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.4971755743026733,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.9411067962646484,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,42.02043151855469,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,42.02043151855469,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,43.821651458740234,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.9262071251869202,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.6663204431533811,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.4588613510131836,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.914963960647583,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,4.966352939605713,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.0099163055419922,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.753146052360535,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.4205291271209717,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.2820147275924685,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,5.465606212615967,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.983582854270935,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.4950830042362213,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.0344462394714355,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,4.5131120681762695,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.572731852531433,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.980423927307129,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.054812788963318,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.8745888471603391,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,6.48255729675293,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.4568073749542236,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.532679319381714,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.40521240234375,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,7.394699096679688,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.0168519020080566,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.9161555767059328,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.9380234479904177,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.8491144180297852,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,7.720145225524902,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.9292423129081726,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.2546403408050537,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.622667133808136,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,3.8065500259399414,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.5565100312232971,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.3461973667144775,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.370525985956192,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,3.27323317527771,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,43.622257232666016,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,43.622257232666016,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,44.911903381347656,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.9472290873527528,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.50767719745636,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.5470775365829468,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.8898224234580994,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,4.891806125640869,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.8717617392539978,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.6603140830993652,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.2561920881271362,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.3151507377624512,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,5.103418827056885,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.9983634948730469,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.4784826636314392,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.8513377904891968,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,4.328184127807617,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.631712555885315,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.9493554830551147,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.0998432636260986,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.9278573989868164,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,6.608768463134766,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.4456865787506104,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.4830899238586426,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.38443374633789,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,7.313210487365723,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.8383936882019043,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.961888313293457,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.9060800075531008,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.884274125099182,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,7.590636253356934,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.8914679884910583,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.984890341758728,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.5547179579734802,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,3.4310762882232666,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.4243517816066742,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.3333704471588135,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.3717325031757355,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,3.1294548511505127,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,42.39655685424805,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,42.39655685424805,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,43.66067886352539,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.9820540547370912,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.3822418451309204,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.5250968933105469,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.8453786373138428,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,4.734771251678467,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.9178008437156676,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.5791635513305664,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.3370729684829712,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.325550198554993,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,5.159587383270264,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.8675544261932373,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.5183260440826416,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.9496716260910032,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,4.335552215576172,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.6729661226272583,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.0684354305267334,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.108994483947754,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.9110288619995115,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,6.761425018310547,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.5311286449432373,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.3279566764831543,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.3397915363311768,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,7.198876857757568,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.0376250743865967,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.7437087297439575,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.907754182815552,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.8935973644256592,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,7.582685470581055,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.0487507581710815,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.0326342582702637,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.5425003170967102,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,3.6238853931427,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.5792177319526672,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.1112005710601807,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.403559535741806,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,3.093977928161621,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,42.490760803222656,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,42.490760803222656,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,44.0885124206543,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.917741358280182,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.6940237283706665,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.6287660598754885,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.9171225428581238,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.15765380859375,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.92180997133255,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.660021424293518,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.2978109121322632,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.247777819633484,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.127419948577881,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.033651351928711,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.514826774597168,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.913644552230835,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,4.462122440338135,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.8205070495605469,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.123387336730957,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.2987910509109497,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.988248348236084,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,7.230933666229248,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.5333070755004883,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.3791353702545166,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.433804512023926,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,7.34624719619751,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.993267059326172,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.4121118783950806,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.8074109554290771,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.9744399785995483,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,7.187229633331299,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.0277907848358154,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.116591215133667,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.7413213849067688,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,3.8857035636901855,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.4752301871776581,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.2185254096984863,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.4582113325595855,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,3.1519668102264404,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,43.549278259277344,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,43.549278259277344,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,45.3433837890625,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.206579089164734,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.7005133628845217,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.6115672588348389,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.3894450664520264,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.90810489654541,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.0120770931243896,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.9090983867645264,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.4461323022842407,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.4760044813156128,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.8433122634887695,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.8353132009506223,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.5240330696105957,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.9968137741088867,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,4.356159687042236,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.8450144529342651,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.130141258239746,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.2633709907531738,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.965989351272583,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,7.2045159339904785,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.4841556549072266,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.4725348949432373,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.4853012561798096,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,7.441991806030273,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.9684343338012695,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.0427846908569336,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.0250632762908936,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.965923547744751,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,8.002205848693848,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.0442852973937988,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.8731414079666135,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.4265169203281402,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,3.3439435958862305,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.5905449390411377,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.668396472930908,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.4283482134342193,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,3.687289714813232,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,45.78752517700195,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,45.78752517700195,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,47.09736251831055,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.9272311925888062,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.8494466543197632,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.4256181716918943,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.106857180595398,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,5.309153079986572,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.8327104449272156,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.750017762184143,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.3610589504241943,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.349914312362671,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,5.293701648712158,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.9396147727966309,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.4445024132728576,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.9560177326202393,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,4.340134620666504,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.7979446649551392,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.139965057373047,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.2440301179885864,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.9170362949371336,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,7.098976135253906,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.5043370723724365,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.3261642456054688,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.4574944972991943,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,7.2879958152771,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.892198085784912,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.4529457092285156,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.0457160472869873,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.9628229141235352,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,7.353682994842529,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.0691248178482056,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.9617037773132324,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.5395990014076233,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,3.570427656173706,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.501744270324707,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.3150479793548584,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.4069039821624756,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,3.223695993423462,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,43.47776794433594,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,43.47776794433594,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,45.09580993652344,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.1565877199172974,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.6618051528930664,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.5368077754974363,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.223464012145996,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,5.578664779663086,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.9376299977302552,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.8964600563049316,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.3836934566497805,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.4692305326461792,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,5.687014102935791,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.9206703901290896,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.5301474928855896,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.9367133378982544,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,4.387531280517578,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.820060133934021,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.141608953475952,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.224527359008789,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.96525776386261,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,7.151453971862793,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.4238929748535156,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.3665497303009033,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.509639024734497,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,7.300081729888916,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.9547046422958376,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.415662169456482,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.15179705619812,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.9063923358917236,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,7.428556442260742,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.950806200504303,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.8635603189468384,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.490191638469696,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,3.304558038711548,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.5450972318649292,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.537312269210815,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.4000984728336334,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,3.4825079441070557,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,44.320369720458984,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,44.320369720458984,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,45.835933685302734,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.033613204956055,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.721675157546997,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.5110975503921509,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.0591565370559692,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,5.325542449951172,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.8218798041343689,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.8651777505874632,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.309306263923645,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.3144084215164185,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,5.310771942138672,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.996744394302368,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.4523590207099914,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.908830165863037,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,4.357933521270752,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.731098771095276,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.125094413757324,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.0972435474395752,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.939075231552124,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,6.89251184463501,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.481610059738159,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.359398603439331,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.4313037395477295,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,7.272312164306641,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.920085310935974,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.4125884771347046,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.9704465866088867,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.9338761568069456,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,7.236996650695801,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.8957237601280212,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.8696495294570925,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.4563689231872558,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,3.2217421531677246,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.4543922543525696,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.5470011234283447,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.3765044808387756,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,3.3778977394104004,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,42.99570846557617,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,42.99570846557617,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,44.255489349365234,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.169229507446289,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.618400812149048,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.4967341423034668,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.0890647172927856,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,5.373429298400879,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.9102710485458374,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.7630890607833862,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.2917619943618774,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.3185707330703735,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,5.283692359924316,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.029475212097168,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.497580885887146,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.9535852670669556,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,4.4806413650512695,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.5542970895767212,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.076565742492676,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.1486213207244873,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.889366865158081,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,6.668850898742676,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.423131227493286,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.396571397781372,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.49056339263916,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,7.310266017913818,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.949780821800232,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.9764102697372437,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.160810947418213,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.9437087774276731,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,8.03071117401123,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.8890734910964966,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,1.843845248222351,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.3992263674736023,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,3.1321451663970947,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.6040458679199219,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,2.613090753555298,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,0.4557384550571441,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,3.672874927520752,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,43.95261001586914,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,43.95261001586914,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,26,Vinh Phuc,VP,historical_63,44.66438674926758,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.2673004865646362,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.579396367073059,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.5867877006530762,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.0999228954315186,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.533407688140869,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.8805407285690308,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.0129711627960205,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.4534357786178589,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.4764918088912964,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.823439598083496,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.9886366128921509,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.555683434009552,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.0023484230041504,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,4.546668529510498,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.8069514036178589,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.1320674419403076,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.2318572998046875,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.9879655838012695,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,7.158841609954834,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.366296768188477,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.4089348316192627,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.4994969367980957,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,7.274728298187256,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.0065386295318604,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.0623083114624023,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.220083475112915,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.9678438901901243,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,8.256773948669434,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.0067954063415527,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.954669952392578,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.4203770458698272,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,3.3818423748016357,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.5239576101303101,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.7799458503723145,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.4251042604446411,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,3.7290077209472656,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,45.7047119140625,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,45.7047119140625,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,47.080596923828125,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.01321542263031,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.6146624088287354,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.313116192817688,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.00345778465271,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,4.944451808929443,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.7660118937492371,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.760326623916626,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.248278260231018,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.2651466131210327,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,5.039763450622559,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.647480845451355,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.4294333755970001,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.818597435951233,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,3.8955116271972656,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.730670690536499,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.0565593242645264,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.226452350616455,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.983006477355957,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,6.9966888427734375,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.195734739303589,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.163813829421997,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.4197890758514404,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,6.7793378829956055,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.9186437129974363,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.4626729488372805,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.1742143630981445,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.9286577701568604,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,7.484188556671143,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.985423982143402,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.7225977182388306,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.5021930932998657,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,3.210214853286743,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.4053779542446136,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.6258578300476074,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.3721110820770263,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,3.4033467769622803,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,41.75350189208984,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,41.75350189208984,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,43.30523681640625,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.0128175020217896,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.5803728103637695,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.5755808353424072,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.806961178779602,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,4.975732326507568,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.8844390511512756,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.599735140800476,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.2406193017959597,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.3824679851531982,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,5.107261657714844,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.8659988641738892,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.4107105731964111,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.8771576881408691,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,4.153867244720459,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.439544677734375,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.864131450653076,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.0808475017547607,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.942169427871704,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,6.326693058013916,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.3515307903289795,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.1908113956451416,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.3927578926086426,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,6.935100078582764,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.7685593366622925,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.955099105834961,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.3302488327026367,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.9372315406799316,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,7.991138935089111,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.9081605076789856,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.841628670692444,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.4858048856258392,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,3.2355940341949463,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.4623023569583893,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.430581569671631,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.4960418939590454,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,3.388925552368164,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,42.11431121826172,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,42.11431121826172,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,43.02372360229492,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.0396078824996948,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.6674660444259644,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.6477665901184082,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.1004669666290283,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.455307483673096,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.8666000366210938,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.7603861093521118,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.3485996723175049,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.5204060077667236,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.495992183685303,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.9539587497711184,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.5119757056236267,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.9355902671813965,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,4.401524543762207,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.8915553092956543,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.1029574871063232,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.1683629751205444,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.894087314605713,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,7.056962966918945,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.4643099308013916,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.5267837047576904,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.5684022903442383,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,7.55949592590332,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.033149480819702,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.4480869770050049,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.115384578704834,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.0151164531707764,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,7.611737728118896,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.0172137022018433,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.9464261531829832,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.4639849364757538,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,3.4276247024536133,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.4363791048526764,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.407331705093384,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.3758464753627777,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,3.219557285308838,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,44.22820281982422,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,44.22820281982422,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,45.70707321166992,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.1920907497406006,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.640458345413208,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.533990502357483,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.9976090788841248,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,5.3641486167907715,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.9015144109725952,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.838658094406128,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.5041395425796509,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.4283078908920288,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,5.672619819641113,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.0254721641540527,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.4798780977725982,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.0187838077545166,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,4.524134159088135,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.512803077697754,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.8750176429748535,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.0719263553619385,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.79254150390625,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,6.252288341522217,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.4000749588012695,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.2709991931915283,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.4256174564361572,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,7.096691608428955,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.99552059173584,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.904986262321472,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.2961618900299072,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.921561598777771,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,8.118229866027832,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.805332601070404,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.7520402669906616,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.6885963082313538,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,3.245969295501709,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.5480768084526062,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.499629497528076,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.4366694688796997,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,3.4843757152557373,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,43.75845718383789,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,43.75845718383789,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,44.58878326416016,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.00409197807312,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.468469262123108,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.4955209493637085,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.0998926162719729,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,5.067975044250488,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.8003299236297607,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.646569848060608,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.2672818899154663,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.3093496561050415,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,5.023531436920166,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.932109236717224,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.4809878468513489,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.7980996370315552,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,4.2111968994140625,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.671764254570007,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.9687397480010984,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.005573034286499,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.9624440670013428,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,6.608521461486816,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.5142807960510254,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.351135015487671,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.5917794704437256,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,7.457195281982422,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.9649029970169067,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.37456476688385,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.7704675197601318,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.9804084300994873,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,7.090343475341797,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.8373231291770935,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.8210426568984983,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.4100123643875122,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,3.068378210067749,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.417911171913147,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.2410597801208496,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.3719705641269684,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,3.0309414863586426,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,41.558082580566406,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,41.558082580566406,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,42.6857795715332,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.099501371383667,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.764059066772461,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.525887966156006,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.046839714050293,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,5.436288356781006,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.8670286536216736,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.744225025177002,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.305569410324097,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.297520399093628,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,5.214343547821045,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.9904472827911377,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.4977449476718902,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.775052189826965,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,4.263244152069092,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.694962501525879,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.971928119659424,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.1348638534545898,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.7643500566482544,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,6.566104412078857,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.375560998916626,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.320788621902466,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.4931986331939697,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,7.189548492431641,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.9532302618026731,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.9119338989257812,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.070465564727783,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.9228721857070925,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,7.85850191116333,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.9572166204452516,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.9523446559906008,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.4102346897125244,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,3.319796085357666,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.4711337983608246,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.4613196849823,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.3979410231113434,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,3.330394506454468,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,43.17822265625,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,43.17822265625,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,44.13594436645508,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.1996331214904783,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.632390022277832,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.6074470281600952,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.0587704181671145,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,5.4982404708862305,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.8620244264602661,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.7534544467926023,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.3501914739608765,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.4338723421096802,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,5.399542808532715,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.057056188583374,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.4544544219970703,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.8527982234954832,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,4.364308834075928,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.54602313041687,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.9374624490737915,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.0852118730545044,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.8251992464065552,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,6.393896579742432,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.51081919670105,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.4665260314941406,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.538407564163208,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,7.51575231552124,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.004730224609375,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.212885618209839,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.020972967147827,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.0539283752441406,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,8.29251766204834,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.884629487991333,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.8589973449707031,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.5497303009033203,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,3.2933571338653564,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.4400083124637604,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.498924732208252,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.375574916601181,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,3.314507961273194,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,44.07212448120117,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,44.07212448120117,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,44.80891036987305,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.148495316505432,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.785367131233215,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.5885882377624512,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.2470049858093262,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,5.769455432891846,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.8479669690132141,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.8647750616073608,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.3487411737442017,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.4300487041473389,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,5.491531848907471,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.7630757093429563,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.5199744701385498,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.0142269134521484,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,4.297276973724365,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.791983723640442,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.0781519412994385,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.1965808868408203,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.901929259300232,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,6.9686455726623535,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.356220006942749,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.3035831451416016,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.530873537063598,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,7.190676689147949,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.0305802822113037,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.7583023309707642,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.979066252708435,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.9972047805786133,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,7.765153884887695,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.0014433860778809,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.087420701980591,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.6026772260665894,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,3.6915414333343506,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.432801753282547,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.2420051097869873,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.3551304340362549,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,3.029937267303467,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,44.204219818115234,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,44.204219818115234,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,45.836761474609375,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.0418964624404907,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.539425492286682,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.45066237449646,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.053571343421936,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.085555553436279,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.7937198281288147,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.826587200164795,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.2718446254730225,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.3967992067337036,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.2889509201049805,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.932600021362305,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.4933063983917236,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.8918031454086304,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,4.317709445953369,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.728935718536377,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.0134754180908203,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.1155214309692385,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.820999026298523,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,6.678931713104248,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.338322401046753,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.3162589073181152,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.4214773178100586,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,7.076058387756348,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.9711774587631223,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.940445065498352,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.979572057723999,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.8945977687835691,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,7.785792350769043,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.0410915613174438,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.9910438060760496,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.6022850275039673,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,3.634420394897461,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.4233972728252411,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.1651387214660645,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.3913380801677704,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.9798741340637207,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,42.847293853759766,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,42.847293853759766,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,44.43247604370117,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.274264574050903,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.624636173248291,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.644173264503479,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.2204504013061523,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,5.763524532318115,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.9612962603569032,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.9272629022598269,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.447520732879639,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.4129732847213743,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,5.749053001403809,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.0630393028259277,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.5421780347824097,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.8990103006362915,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,4.504227638244629,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.7875539064407349,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.0959157943725586,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.195737361907959,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.974354267120361,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,7.053561210632324,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.6007003784179688,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.382805347442627,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.552271604537964,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,7.535777568817139,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.1403870582580566,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.662931203842163,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.9535523653030396,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.951016306877136,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,7.707887172698975,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.0336426496505735,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.120091438293457,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.5070489048957825,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,3.660783052444458,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.5222154855728149,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.4601664543151855,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.4719523787498474,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,3.454334259033203,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,45.42914962768555,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,45.42914962768555,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,46.83240509033203,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.1799299716949463,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.5359623432159424,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.5432342290878296,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.0686135292053225,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,5.32774019241333,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.8934585452079773,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.772998332977295,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.3375622034072876,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.2425487041473389,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,5.246567726135254,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.99858820438385,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.6396210789680481,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.7702380418777466,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,4.408447265625,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.6493120193481443,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.8739091157913208,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.9542126059532166,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.7551615238189695,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,6.232595443725586,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.252925157546997,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.135084390640259,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.4389560222625732,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,6.82696533203125,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.9651682376861572,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.37568461894989,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.829227924346924,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.9257808923721311,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,7.095861911773682,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.9149087071418762,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.877868890762329,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.4965853095054626,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,3.289362907409668,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.4762701690196991,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.2889516353607178,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.4070512652397156,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,3.1722729206085205,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,41.59981155395508,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,41.59981155395508,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,42.60888671875,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.0140684843063354,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.655242919921875,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.4907445907592771,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.937085747718811,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,5.097141742706299,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.8785497546195984,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.5157737731933594,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.3029968738555908,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.3102573156356812,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,5.007577896118164,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.9180864095687864,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.6130148768424988,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.7499158382415771,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,4.281017303466797,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.9317119121551511,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.15309476852417,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.2114100456237793,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.869933843612671,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,7.1661505699157715,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.37638521194458,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.312041759490967,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.4158239364624023,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,7.104250907897949,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.034246921539306,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.432889461517334,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.920391082763672,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.9106229543685913,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,7.298150539398193,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.1045734882354736,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.8608522415161133,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.5807785987854004,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,3.5462043285369873,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.4463280141353607,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.3336007595062256,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.4900289475917816,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,3.2699577808380127,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,42.770450592041016,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,42.770450592041016,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,44.39398193359375,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.043508529663086,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.7716422080993652,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.6196787357330322,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.9086301326751708,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.343459606170654,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.9306787252426147,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.027316093444824,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.527680516242981,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.3499295711517334,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.835605144500732,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.9837419986724856,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.5082843899726868,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.876803636550903,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,4.368829727172852,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.1043505668640137,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.2619967460632324,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.4411412477493286,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.7665517330169678,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,7.574040412902832,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.526642322540283,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.3760874271392822,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.4390735626220703,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,7.341803073883057,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.1333701610565186,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.005601644515991,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.1515276432037354,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.013617038726806,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,8.304116249084473,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.1491955518722534,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.0971643924713135,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.7227814197540283,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,3.9691414833068848,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.5165812373161316,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.3550963401794434,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.4328661561012268,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,3.3045437335968018,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,46.04153823852539,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,46.04153823852539,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,48.301231384277344,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.2502927780151367,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.3120797872543335,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.524820327758789,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.8431979417800903,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,4.93039083480835,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.8229649662971497,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.582141995429993,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.311035394668579,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.2425990104675293,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,4.958741188049316,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.9332942962646484,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.4262396693229675,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.9854284524917605,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,4.344962120056152,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.5925133228302002,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.045058250427246,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.1087491512298584,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.88262140750885,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,6.628942012786865,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.3540282249450684,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.4090569019317627,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.4743235111236572,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,7.237408638000488,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.9112969636917112,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.711816668510437,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.25398325920105,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.9360719919204712,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,7.813169002532959,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.9865771532058716,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.8107268810272217,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.3486929535865783,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,3.1459970474243164,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.478302001953125,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.720853328704834,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.4080101549625397,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,3.6071653366088863,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,42.666778564453125,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,42.666778564453125,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,43.44245529174805,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.9612939357757568,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.5824426412582395,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.437941551208496,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.8213158249855042,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,4.8029937744140625,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.8058832883834839,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.4190444946289062,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.2026185989379885,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.1351629495620728,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,4.562709331512451,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.81448495388031,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.4824568033218384,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.5617235898971558,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,3.858665227890014,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.5557923316955566,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.045898914337158,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.1453572511672974,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.7987068891525269,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,6.545755386352539,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.3790104389190674,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.9841184616088867,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.537851572036743,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,6.900980472564697,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.9024896621704104,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.961638569831848,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.8867696523666384,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.9448117017745972,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,7.695709705352783,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.8567051291465759,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.8009850978851318,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.6516206860542297,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,3.3093109130859375,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.4513673484325409,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.043346881866455,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.4251528978347778,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.919867038726806,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,40.59599304199219,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,40.59599304199219,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,41.86162185668945,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.9568436741828918,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.3084295988082886,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.4430091381072998,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.9989123940467834,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,4.707194805145264,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.7704888582229614,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.5668810606002808,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.2789459228515625,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.2955206632614136,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,4.911836624145508,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.7392683029174805,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.5082895159721375,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.811665415763855,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,4.059223175048828,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.6365103721618652,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.9351892471313477,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.1791927814483645,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.1054537296295166,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,5.856346130371094,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.2639620304107666,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.5319085121154785,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.466783285140991,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,7.262653827667236,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.9458541870117188,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.8822174072265625,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.7056716680526731,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.8943727016448977,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,7.428115844726563,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.0381829738616943,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.7661062479019165,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.5810559988021851,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,3.385345220565796,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.4585375785827636,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.960376977920532,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.4594546854496002,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.8783693313598633,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,40.48908615112305,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,40.48908615112305,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,41.357513427734375,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.0445244312286377,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.3281896114349363,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.415006160736084,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.7703772783279419,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,4.558097839355469,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.8542302846908569,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.7245302200317385,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.4171030521392822,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.460452437400818,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,5.456315994262695,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.8427705764770508,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.4899873435497284,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.9126460552215576,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,4.245404243469238,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.9134552478790283,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.148430347442627,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.4570157527923584,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.9341230392456057,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,7.453024387359619,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.399354934692383,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.4646155834198,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.3660888671875,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,7.230059623718262,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.930145502090454,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.9723817110061648,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.8869224786758425,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.97288978099823,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,7.7623395919799805,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.222453236579895,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.8811005353927612,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.4749690592288971,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,3.5785229206085205,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.4573121964931488,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.3949739933013916,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.4357726871967315,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,3.2880587577819824,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,43.57182312011719,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,43.57182312011719,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,45.80813980102539,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.826984703540802,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.2976555824279783,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.3466699123382568,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.903775990009308,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,4.375086307525635,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.7580177187919617,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.44302499294281,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.246678590774536,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.1938090324401855,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,4.6415300369262695,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.8330621719360352,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.4642028510570526,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.7047712802886963,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,4.002036094665527,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.682613492012024,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.059894323348999,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.1771652698516846,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.8890585899353027,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,6.808731555938721,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.2090694904327393,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.1516315937042236,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.3186426162719727,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,6.679344177246094,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.863524794578552,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.971170425415039,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.9060239791870115,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.9637104272842407,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,7.704429626464844,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.065486192703247,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.018404483795166,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.4306651055812835,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,3.5145559310913086,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.3914423882961273,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.9331510066986084,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.3698694407939911,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.694462776184082,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,40.4201774597168,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,40.4201774597168,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,42.35567855834961,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.0837464332580566,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.3148282766342163,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.4060198068618774,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.093315839767456,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,4.897910118103027,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.954043447971344,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.9022140502929688,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.5072616338729858,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.5125796794891355,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,5.876099109649658,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.0421342849731445,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.4504978954792022,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.825441598892212,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,4.318073749542236,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.9245446920394895,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.1570451259613037,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.4000647068023682,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.8917642831802368,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,7.373418807983398,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.409390926361084,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.3637466430664062,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.4038736820220947,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,7.177011013031006,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.9686753749847412,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.019432544708252,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.13784122467041,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.9530409574508667,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,8.07898998260498,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.1911135911941528,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.0787513256073,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.4725480079650879,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,3.742412805557251,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.4771378934383392,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.5265066623687744,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.474376767873764,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,3.4780213832855225,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,44.94193649291992,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,44.94193649291992,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,47.1339225769043,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.100015640258789,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.5720256567001345,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.44439959526062,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.2184756994247437,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,5.334916591644287,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.9134997725486756,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.838576078414917,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.4769694805145264,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.3547959327697754,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,5.583841323852539,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.123328924179077,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.4608711004257202,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.8397191762924192,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,4.423919200897217,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.8459826707839968,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.1346664428710938,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.411373496055603,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.968917727470398,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,7.360940456390381,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.457411766052246,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.5685019493103027,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.5339531898498535,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,7.559866428375244,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.9950345754623413,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.150517463684082,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.1063711643218994,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.9767194986343384,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,8.228642463684082,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.1128551959991455,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.2209174633026123,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.5694580674171448,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,3.903230905532837,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.5112971067428589,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.1903538703918457,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.4083738625049591,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,3.110024690628052,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,45.5053825378418,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,45.5053825378418,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,47.48037338256836,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.955145537853241,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.4239768981933594,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.366111159324646,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.4412240982055664,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,5.186457633972168,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.8509324789047241,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.4330246448516846,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.3693910837173462,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.3432667255401611,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,4.996614933013916,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.07796311378479,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.4282763302326202,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.710330605506897,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,4.216569900512695,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.55146324634552,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.0148963928222656,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.254262924194336,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.9393980503082275,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,6.760020732879639,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.360351085662842,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.4149329662323,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.5113565921783447,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,7.286640644073486,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.9330469369888303,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.761599898338318,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.0586342811584473,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.888033747673035,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,7.64131498336792,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.9965752363204956,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.9507060050964355,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.4347327947616577,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,3.382014036178589,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.4404251277446747,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.1625330448150635,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.4014365673065185,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,3.00439453125,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,42.474029541015625,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,42.474029541015625,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,43.78327941894531,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.8759796619415283,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.2435202598571775,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.6300715208053589,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.153398513793945,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,4.902969837188721,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.7727189064025879,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.5091768503189087,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.225170373916626,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.203259825706482,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,4.710326194763184,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8996813297271729,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.4526863992214203,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.734095573425293,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,4.086463451385498,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.4474185705184937,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.934751272201538,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.0086004734039309,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8709670305252075,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,6.26173734664917,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.247180700302124,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.345383644104004,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.281524181365967,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,6.874088764190674,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.804357647895813,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.9204210042953491,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.658982276916504,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8983354568481443,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,7.282096385955811,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.8288174271583557,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8400481939315796,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.4837053418159485,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,3.152570962905884,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.399397611618042,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.9298549890518188,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.3617899119853973,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.691042423248291,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,39.96129608154297,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,39.96129608154297,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,41.15180587768555,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.0539761781692505,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.3894984722137451,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.4893585443496704,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.8143330216407776,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,4.747166156768799,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.8176614046096802,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.5920350551605225,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.2341989278793335,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.2054681777954102,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,4.849363803863525,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.8528544902801511,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.5163150429725647,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.7806140184402466,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,4.149783611297607,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.578315019607544,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.9977482557296753,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.023220419883728,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.8913086652755735,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,6.4905924797058105,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.291513204574585,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.3193254470825195,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.3118736743927,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,6.9227118492126465,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.8718628883361816,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.899902105331421,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.69978129863739,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.9126356840133667,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,7.384181976318359,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.8093262314796448,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.8492387533187864,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.378876656293869,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,3.0374417304992676,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.4026363790035248,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.964949131011963,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.3690305352210998,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.7366158962249756,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,40.31785583496094,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,40.31785583496094,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,41.72359085083008,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.9923099279403688,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.382575511932373,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.5368067026138306,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.8444758653640747,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,4.756167888641357,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.8404546976089478,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.6777405738830566,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.2791240215301514,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.511596918106079,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,5.308916091918945,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.8715821504592896,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.4615647494792938,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.87592875957489,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,4.209075450897217,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.6858569383621216,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.977000951766968,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.1633241176605225,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.7911571264266968,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,6.617339134216309,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.4634273052215576,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.376081943511963,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.387432336807251,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,7.2269415855407715,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.867582082748413,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.8950825929641724,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.8336389064788816,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.94585120677948,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,7.542154788970947,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.92379492521286,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.9478015899658203,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.3773061335086822,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,3.2489027976989746,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.4584129452705383,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.566256046295166,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.3923632204532623,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,3.417032241821289,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,42.32653045654297,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,42.32653045654297,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,43.58141326904297,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.8193839192390442,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.330105543136597,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.5146498680114746,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.9870248436927797,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,4.6511640548706055,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.8258358836174011,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.3900797367095947,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.0322014093399048,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.0611814260482788,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,4.309298515319824,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.7926253080368042,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.4773446917533874,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.7898913621902466,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,4.059861183166504,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.3036777973175049,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.7989259958267212,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.9776427149772644,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.8786205053329468,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,5.958867073059082,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.3717615604400635,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.3244051933288574,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.401495933532715,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,7.097662448883057,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.8523941040039065,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.3791775703430176,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.739361047744751,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.8677939176559448,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,6.83872652053833,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.8171188831329346,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.8370301723480225,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.4915179908275604,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,3.14566707611084,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.4309897422790527,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.073718547821045,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.4051478207111358,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.909855842590332,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,38.97110366821289,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,38.97110366821289,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,39.60064697265625,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.0276368856430054,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.5768494606018066,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.5604652166366575,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.8229116797447205,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,4.987863063812256,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.901138722896576,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.3956373929977417,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.228970646858215,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.1760228872299194,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,4.701769828796387,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.025470495223999,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.4415461719036102,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.8454235792160032,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,4.312440395355225,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.4532133340835571,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.9432129859924316,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.9983693361282348,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.7981404066085815,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,6.192935943603516,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.3450121879577637,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.2962646484375,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.4324116706848145,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,7.073688507080078,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.7216660976409912,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.967500686645508,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.821550130844116,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.9064303636550903,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,7.417147159576416,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.8764965534210205,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.7516320943832395,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.3630830645561218,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.9912116527557373,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.4934950768947601,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.332953453063965,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.400920957326889,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,3.227369546890259,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,40.90442657470703,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,40.90442657470703,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,41.46586227416992,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.8642971515655518,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.381286382675171,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.5355693101882937,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.7468546032905579,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,4.528007507324219,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.9032830595970154,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.3794866800308228,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.178028583526611,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.102346897125244,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,4.563145160675049,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.9404581785202024,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.4355553984642029,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.81193745136261,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,4.18795108795166,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.3791356086730957,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.9111573696136477,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.946561872959137,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.872836351394653,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,6.109691143035889,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.3806231021881104,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.332834005355835,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.3163180351257324,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,7.029775142669678,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.6508089303970337,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.9455859661102295,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.8612372875213623,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.8661588430404663,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,7.323791027069092,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.8007369637489319,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.7918964624404907,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.4022017419338226,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.994835138320923,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.5527384877204895,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.2106523513793945,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.4520129263401031,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,3.2154037952423096,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,39.952598571777344,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,39.952598571777344,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,40.59712600708008,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.8102756142616272,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.3078340291976929,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.1395429372787476,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.6715931296348572,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,3.929245710372925,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.7038314342498779,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.3491852283477783,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.1488274335861206,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.175196886062622,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,4.377040863037109,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.8741908073425293,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.4097090065479278,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.7266777753829956,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,4.01057767868042,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.6431719064712524,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.00351619720459,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.2999894618988037,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.8821449279785156,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,6.828822612762451,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.332533597946167,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.4009745121002197,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.4624087810516357,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,7.195917129516602,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.6654894351959229,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.342074990272522,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.9004619121551511,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.8605531454086304,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,6.768579483032227,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.9422956109046936,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.8377435207366943,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.4193216562271118,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,3.1993608474731445,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.4029533863067627,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.164374351501465,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.3594813942909241,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.926809072494507,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,39.23635482788086,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,39.23635482788086,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,40.85237121582031,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.9336302876472472,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.1962870359420776,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.2767231464385986,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.9298039674758912,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,4.33644437789917,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.8380733132362366,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.345802903175354,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.1799774169921875,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.227151870727539,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,4.591005325317383,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.973840594291687,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.4258195757865906,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.737960934638977,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,4.13762092590332,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.438942313194275,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.9889776706695557,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.131455659866333,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.924586534500122,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,6.483962059020996,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.372161865234375,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.2945966720581055,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.3595690727233887,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,7.026327610015869,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.724682092666626,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.3716099262237549,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.018188714981079,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.8841639757156372,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,6.998644828796387,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.8812516331672668,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.7155849933624268,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.3946978449821472,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.991534471511841,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.4719287455081939,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.4586970806121826,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.41519895195961,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,3.345824718475342,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,39.9113655090332,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,39.9113655090332,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,40.89415740966797,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.114878535270691,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.2170499563217163,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.3366124629974363,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.9721587896347046,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,4.640699863433838,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.9279751777648926,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.78483247756958,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.4882255792617798,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.441980481147766,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,5.643013954162598,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.051267147064209,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.4328159987926483,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.785559892654419,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,4.269643306732178,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.7788599729537964,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.1227774620056152,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.403227686882019,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.9132260084152224,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,7.218091011047363,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.479449987411499,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.4784183502197266,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.4936015605926514,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,7.451469898223877,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.955244541168213,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.972705602645874,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.2858638763427734,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.9487831592559817,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,8.162596702575684,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.0705063343048096,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.0642549991607666,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.3980022966861725,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,3.532763719558716,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.5927050709724426,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.5705461502075195,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.4930788874626159,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,3.656329870223999,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,44.574607849121094,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,44.574607849121094,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,46.327449798583984,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.107041835784912,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.099928617477417,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.3515177965164185,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.047380447387695,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,4.605868339538574,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.8775226473808289,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.5948351621627808,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.402856469154358,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.277624487876892,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,5.152838706970215,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.001251220703125,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.4330044686794281,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.8699238300323489,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,4.3041791915893555,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.521195888519287,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.9457696676254272,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.1848666667938232,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.981664776802063,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,6.6334967613220215,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.4135172367095947,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.2247817516326904,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.4127023220062256,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,7.05100154876709,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.7523330450057983,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.719157338142395,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.185147285461426,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.8771705627441408,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,7.53380823135376,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.900631308555603,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.6962060928344729,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.3673203885555267,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.964157819747925,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.4670343101024627,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.6848955154418945,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.3780778646469116,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,3.5300076007843018,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,41.775360107421875,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,41.775360107421875,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,42.8826904296875,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.9891223907470704,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.347639560699463,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.1779717206954956,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.058013081550598,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,4.572746753692627,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.8760306239128113,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.4369157552719116,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.3037115335464478,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.1871013641357422,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,4.8037590980529785,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.8271220922470093,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.4038595259189605,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.635090470314026,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,3.866071939468384,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.6175798177719116,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.017942190170288,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.2194620370864868,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.853830099105835,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,6.7088141441345215,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.3636624813079834,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.387000799179077,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.47455096244812,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,7.22521448135376,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.853222131729126,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.021947741508484,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.994540095329285,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.8887425661087036,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,6.758452415466309,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.9123002290725708,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.7258638143539429,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.7657434940338135,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,3.403907537460327,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.5225199460983276,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.5421946048736572,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.4292718768119812,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,3.4939863681793213,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,40.83295440673828,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,40.83295440673828,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,42.075645446777344,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.7654528021812439,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.0622648000717163,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.0186316967010498,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.8415884971618652,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,3.6879377365112305,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.6955493688583374,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.3902804851531982,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.2405704259872437,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.1888413429260254,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,4.515241622924805,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.9220324754714968,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.3957596123218536,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.6186879873275757,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,3.936480045318603,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.6373320817947388,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.9412345886230469,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.314907789230347,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.743772268295288,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,6.637246608734131,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.375845432281494,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.4503865242004395,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.45505428314209,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,7.281286239624023,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.8282506465911863,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.397249460220337,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.0983502864837646,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.818087577819824,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,7.141937732696533,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.115942120552063,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.944137454032898,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.7332199811935425,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,3.793299674987793,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.392009973526001,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,1.950658679008484,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,0.3545328974723816,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,2.6972014904022217,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,39.69063186645508,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,39.69063186645508,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,82,Tien Giang,TG,historical_63,41.616004943847656,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.9794927835464478,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.2122832536697388,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.298257827758789,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.1809674501419067,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,4.671001434326172,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.7418904900550842,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.4200047254562378,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.228587031364441,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.2013884782791138,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,4.5918707847595215,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.8621331453323364,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.4189735054969787,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.5261832475662231,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,3.8072898387908936,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.725137710571289,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.0249528884887695,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.2937132120132446,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.739610195159912,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,6.783414363861084,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.3777847290039062,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.34765362739563,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.408306837081909,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,7.133745193481445,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.9110347032546997,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.4331976175308228,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.9120216369628904,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.9020427465438845,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,7.158296585083008,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.9943485260009766,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.859458565711975,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.6505423188209534,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,3.50434947013855,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.3882661759853363,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.8164324760437012,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.3581440150737762,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.562842607498169,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,40.21281051635742,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,40.21281051635742,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,42.01248550415039,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.8033496141433716,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.9257954359054564,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.343803644180298,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.8618809580802917,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,3.9348294734954834,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.71625155210495,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.3009097576141355,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.173350811004639,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.215731501579285,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,4.406243324279785,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.8929036855697632,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.3885193467140198,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.727294921875,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,4.008718013763428,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.5940378904342651,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.9040560722351072,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.2313636541366575,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.8942341804504397,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,6.623692035675049,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.4610657691955566,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.4197607040405273,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.4595391750335693,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,7.340365886688232,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.905035376548767,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.9319956302642824,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.099597454071045,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.874439358711243,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,7.811067581176758,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.079617977142334,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.9322073459625244,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.4485867321491241,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,3.4604122638702393,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.3928152620792389,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.7635231018066406,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.4016578495502472,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.5579960346221924,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,40.14332580566406,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,40.14332580566406,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,41.79460525512695,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.0601624250411987,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.1755212545394895,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.1259982585906982,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.8166700005531311,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,4.178351879119873,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.7862372398376465,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.3241214752197266,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.223111867904663,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.3676583766937256,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,4.701128959655762,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.9368053674697876,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.4096307456493377,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.643652081489563,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,3.9900882244110103,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.5355727672576904,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.9414218664169312,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.1395081281661987,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.7631292343139648,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,6.379631996154785,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.339008331298828,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.192824125289917,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.458444356918335,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,6.99027681350708,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.860180377960205,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.8945319652557373,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.215015649795532,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.886142611503601,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,7.855870723724365,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.954071581363678,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.963498830795288,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.8834296464920044,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,3.8010001182556152,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.4362496733665466,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.136993885040283,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.3534921109676361,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.9267356395721436,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,40.82308578491211,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,40.82308578491211,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,42.343482971191406,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.7264720797538757,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.0085877180099487,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.047071933746338,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.1428571939468384,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,3.9249887466430664,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.8124455213546753,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.3356282711029053,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.209619402885437,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.3089962005615234,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,4.666689395904541,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.991901993751526,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.4692974686622619,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.5420067310333252,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,4.003206253051758,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.7130433320999146,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.026158094406128,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.3455817699432373,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.8730504512786863,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,6.957833766937256,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.390836477279663,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.451714277267456,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.4672048091888428,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,7.309755802154541,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.8871636390686035,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.3994570970535278,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.09179949760437,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.875068426132202,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,7.253488540649414,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.0549976825714111,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.82344913482666,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.41107439994812,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,4.289521217346191,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.4745918810367584,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.0190536975860596,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.4234998226165771,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.917145252227783,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,41.322628021240234,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,41.322628021240234,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,43.47574615478515,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.8549238443374634,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.1553467512130735,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.1445649862289429,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.1833093166351318,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,4.338144779205322,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.7330348491668701,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.4789583683013916,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.111384391784668,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.26127028465271,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,4.5846476554870605,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.9297404289245603,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.410490870475769,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.720551371574402,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,4.0607829093933105,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.7034515142440796,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.0389840602874756,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.3190582990646362,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.8246002197265625,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,6.886094093322754,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.281405210494995,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.318971633911133,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.403404235839844,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,7.003781318664551,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.8495290279388428,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.973822832107544,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.313960075378418,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.909790635108948,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,8.047102928161621,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.1658583879470823,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.973552942276001,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.8294059038162231,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,3.968817234039306,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.3956183195114136,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.205209970474243,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.3552528917789459,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.9560811519622803,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,41.84545135498047,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,41.84545135498047,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,43.63382339477539,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.8053914904594421,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.1275511980056765,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.2394028902053833,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.7764012813568115,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,3.948746681213379,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.8196715116500854,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.3714537620544434,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.3196946382522583,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.2925148010253906,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,4.803334712982178,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.1224167346954346,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.4438353180885315,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.6845760345458984,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,4.250828266143799,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.6668187379837036,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.0458340644836426,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.2887142896652222,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.8879486322402952,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,6.889316082000732,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.3678829669952393,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.276266574859619,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.498992681503296,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,7.143142223358154,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.956139326095581,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.4323081970214844,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.8441945314407349,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.9344321489334104,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,7.167074203491211,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.0172274112701416,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.8910150527954104,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.8815180659294128,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,3.78976058959961,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.4066323637962341,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.182267904281616,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.4081277847290039,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.99702787399292,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,40.98923110961914,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,40.98923110961914,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,42.961280822753906,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.8464595675468445,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.859338641166687,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.156206727027893,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.0022433996200562,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,3.864248275756836,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.8058520555496216,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.3996765613555908,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.2558974027633667,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.2910451889038086,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,4.752470970153809,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.075347900390625,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.4250112175941467,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.5886940956115725,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,4.089053153991699,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.6220544576644895,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.907278299331665,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.2190945148468018,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.6747525930404663,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,6.423180103302002,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.356595039367676,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.3024117946624756,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.414228677749634,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,7.073235511779785,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.716636300086975,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.0524941682815552,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.16003155708313,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.8780674934387207,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,6.807229518890381,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.1041700839996338,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.8630839586257937,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.9922647476196288,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,3.9595186710357666,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.4389365613460541,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.274103879928589,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.4924620985984802,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,3.2055022716522217,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,40.1744384765625,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,40.1744384765625,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,41.78469467163086,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.7362840175628662,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.0559221506118774,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.3152443170547483,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.2313132286071775,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,4.33876371383667,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.7346734404563904,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.3737400770187378,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.122390866279602,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.217655062675476,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,4.448459625244141,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.9948021173477173,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.458152174949646,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.475865125656128,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,3.928819417953491,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.6750495433807373,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.993256688117981,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.3435461521148682,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.989106297492981,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,7.0009589195251465,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.340928792953491,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.3280766010284424,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.4524147510528564,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,7.121419906616211,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.8784233331680296,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.365981101989746,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.0140485763549805,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.8791162967681885,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,7.137568950653076,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.068210244178772,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.812182903289795,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.2904090881347656,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,4.170802116394043,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.4315201044082641,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.120018243789673,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.3708613812923431,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.922399520874023,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,41.069190979003906,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,41.069190979003906,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,43.025352478027344,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.0300759077072144,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.1362208127975464,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.4152047634124756,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.3772618770599363,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,4.958763599395752,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.8481411337852478,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.778520941734314,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.4539116621017456,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.403851866722107,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,5.484426021575928,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.0748655796051025,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.4869094789028168,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.9315959215164185,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,4.49337100982666,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.074101448059082,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.3003361225128174,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.712097406387329,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.060458183288574,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,8.146993637084961,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.509155035018921,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.4169557094573975,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.5099124908447266,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,7.436023235321045,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.9568361043930056,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.9001033306121824,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.072800397872925,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.9683579206466677,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,7.898097515106201,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.2984007596969604,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.1053545475006104,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.6309323310852051,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,4.034687519073486,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.515913724899292,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.2640318870544434,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.3873040676116943,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,3.1672496795654297,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,45.61961364746094,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,45.61961364746094,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,48.35774230957031,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.2459152936935425,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.3132787942886353,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.3384279012680054,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.1236851215362549,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,5.021306991577148,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.053009033203125,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.550562858581543,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.3746681213378906,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.5236059427261353,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,5.501845836639404,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.2390003204345703,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.5195425748825073,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.898697018623352,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,4.65723991394043,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.9604754447937012,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.157879590988159,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.457821488380432,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.08236312866211,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,7.658539772033691,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.6335034370422363,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.4353179931640625,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.5709407329559326,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,7.639761924743652,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.0857388973236084,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.4314814805984497,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.1037707328796387,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.9953651428222656,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,7.616356372833252,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.2555410861968994,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.9647186994552612,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.7239883542060852,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,3.94424819946289,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.5619492530822754,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.552847385406494,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.4243160784244537,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,3.5391125679016113,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,45.57841110229492,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,45.57841110229492,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,47.56047058105469,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.818681538105011,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.0692410469055176,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.1826140880584717,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.7343650460243225,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,3.804901838302612,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.7428715229034424,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.2560688257217407,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.1747082471847534,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.2382664680480957,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,4.411915302276611,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.0438547134399414,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.4373671114444732,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.590629816055298,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,4.07185173034668,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.6895573139190674,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.0131444931030273,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.2115378379821775,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.9435139894485471,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,6.857753276824951,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.3992435932159424,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.2151505947113037,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.51296329498291,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,7.127357482910156,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.7532631158828735,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.2393593788146973,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.0530598163604736,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.855948567390442,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,6.901630878448486,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.1742175817489624,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.9674172401428225,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.6527591943740845,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,3.794394016265869,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.4543299376964569,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.2268288135528564,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.4544796347618103,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,3.1356382369995117,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,40.10544204711914,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,40.10544204711914,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2023,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,41.853485107421875,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.4257158041000366,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.5310219526290894,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.4599671363830566,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.9755644798278807,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.392269611358643,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.016435980796814,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.8037734031677248,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.4837327003479004,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.407409906387329,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,5.7113518714904785,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.0179762840270996,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.4129387736320495,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.9316860437393188,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,4.362600803375244,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.5657137632369995,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.9307907819747925,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.139920711517334,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.061826705932617,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,6.698252201080322,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.399049758911133,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.2795724868774414,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.444528341293335,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,7.123150825500488,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.686252236366272,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.7133384943008425,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.212019681930542,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.957370638847351,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,7.568981170654297,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.9618303775787354,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,1.5691405534744265,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.3416027426719665,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.8725736141204834,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.5808869004249573,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,2.960507869720459,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,0.5041409730911255,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,4.045535564422607,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,43.774715423583984,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,43.774715423583984,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,1,Ha Noi,HN,historical_63,44.03913497924805,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.9793400168418884,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.583221673965454,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.527546763420105,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.124616622924805,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,5.214725017547607,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.9326367974281312,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.7882733345031738,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.4614174365997314,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.2983437776565552,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,5.480671405792236,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.024729013442993,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.4653269648551941,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.7849955558776855,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,4.275051593780518,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.6915342807769775,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.175649404525757,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.2446478605270386,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.02840256690979,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,7.140233993530273,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.5190188884735107,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.294581174850464,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.413377523422241,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,7.226977348327637,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.9292864799499512,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.447035312652588,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.7304250001907349,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.9695913791656496,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,7.076338291168213,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,1.1128484010696411,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.2611448764801025,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.6667243838310242,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,4.040717601776123,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.609218418598175,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,2.2110910415649414,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,0.4538806676864624,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,3.2741899490356445,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,43.728904724121094,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,43.728904724121094,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,2,Ha Giang,HG,historical_63,45.405540466308594,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.0567079782485962,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.3801809549331665,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.315114140510559,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.8883151412010193,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,4.640318393707275,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.9086573719978333,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.626177191734314,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.3255198001861572,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.2666665315628052,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,5.127020835876465,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.989776849746704,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.4447023570537567,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.7771902084350586,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,4.211669445037842,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.5536061525344849,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.985324740409851,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.9589940309524536,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.7254772186279297,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,6.22340202331543,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.402329921722412,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.0604825019836426,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.3513779640197754,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,6.81419038772583,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.960015058517456,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.9481947422027588,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.749573826789856,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,1.9262959957122805,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,7.584079742431641,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.9411005973815918,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.1296777725219727,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.7183908820152283,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,3.7891693115234375,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.4585265517234802,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.0717506408691406,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,0.4123497009277344,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,2.942626953125,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,41.33247756958008,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,41.33247756958008,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,4,Cao Bang,CB,historical_63,42.33494567871094,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.178650140762329,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.6320921182632446,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.4993678331375122,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.0196858644485474,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.329796314239502,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.9618834853172302,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.8625731468200684,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.3061200380325315,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.3667513132095337,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,5.497328281402588,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.83626389503479,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.508605420589447,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.9675623178482056,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,4.312431812286377,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.7704404592514038,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.116323947906494,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.2787461280822754,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.914156913757324,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,7.079667568206787,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.4941275119781494,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.3642749786376953,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.5082387924194336,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,7.366641521453857,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.075728178024292,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.402186155319214,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.8465983867645264,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.896220088005066,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,7.220732688903809,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.9910886287689208,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,1.9474724531173704,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.7441214919090271,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,3.682682514190674,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.5570501685142517,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,2.621312141418457,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,0.4285872280597687,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,3.6069495677948,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,44.096229553222656,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,44.096229553222656,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,6,Bac Kan,BK,historical_63,45.23184585571289,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.0092356204986572,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.356796145439148,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.498416781425476,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.2887167930603027,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,5.153165340423584,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.8251240849494934,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.683613657951355,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.37165367603302,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.2871148586273191,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,5.167506217956543,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.832352638244629,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.5366787910461426,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.920849323272705,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,4.289880752563477,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.6029154062271118,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.9753732681274416,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.1491867303848269,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.026473045349121,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,6.753948211669922,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.506258726119995,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.181663751602173,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.396277666091919,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,7.084200382232666,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.055995464324951,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.4052268266677856,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.8563051223754885,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.9758813381195068,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,7.293408393859863,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.9685823321342468,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,1.919867753982544,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.5371289253234863,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,3.425579071044922,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.455259770154953,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,2.5517964363098145,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,0.3720334470272064,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,3.379089593887329,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,42.54677963256836,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,42.54677963256836,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,8,Tuyen Quang,TQ,historical_63,43.38179016113281,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.0364036560058594,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.4965909719467163,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.412882685661316,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.9858862161636353,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,4.931763648986816,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.8212771415710449,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.800695538520813,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.3402106761932373,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.2500195503234863,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,5.212203025817871,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.828925609588623,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.502494215965271,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.8886741399765017,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,4.220093727111816,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.6058357954025269,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.9637839794158936,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.011804223060608,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.0196683406829834,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,6.601092338562012,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.3060498237609863,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.2550125122070312,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.286005973815918,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,6.8470683097839355,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.896303415298462,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.4170349836349487,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.9493049383163452,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.933848023414612,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,7.196491241455078,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.985761284828186,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,1.8713442087173464,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.5466859936714172,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,3.4037914276123047,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.5034068822860718,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,2.4150588512420654,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,0.4179311096668243,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,3.3363969326019287,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,41.7489013671875,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,41.7489013671875,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,10,Lao Cai,LCA,historical_63,42.72059631347656,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.9408271312713624,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.3816125392913818,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.424857497215271,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.8842385411262512,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,4.631535530090332,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.8350481390953064,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.551103949546814,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.29329252243042,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.3115153312683103,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,4.990960121154785,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.02420425415039,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.5024546384811401,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.6950055360794067,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,4.2216644287109375,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.6339402198791504,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.0528581142425537,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.9574185609817504,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.9714778661727903,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,6.615694999694824,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.5069615840911865,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.2792208194732666,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.407139301300049,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,7.193321704864502,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.8459222316741943,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.2356866598129272,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.7279441356658936,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,1.9329711198806765,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,6.742524147033691,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.9429067969322203,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.0582966804504395,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.8911327719688416,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,3.892336368560791,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.5381909608840942,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,2.040645122528076,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,0.5089544653892517,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,3.0877904891967773,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,41.37582778930664,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,41.37582778930664,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,11,Dien Bien,DB,historical_63,42.71091079711914,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.033711314201355,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.4924695491790771,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.4092788696289062,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.3008201122283936,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,5.236279487609863,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.9157601594924928,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.6528030633926392,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.4385045766830444,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.4240549802780151,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,5.431122779846191,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.945608139038086,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.442234992980957,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.8311890363693235,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,4.219032287597656,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.6096341609954834,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.9952729940414429,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.1210405826568604,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.9093594551086424,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,6.635307312011719,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.512898206710815,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.2660889625549316,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.352231979370117,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,7.131218910217285,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.90176784992218,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.97781765460968,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.9303011894226072,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,1.9118119478225708,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,7.721698760986328,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.9434880018234252,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.0613584518432617,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.6767908930778503,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,3.681637525558472,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.5886533260345459,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,2.418868064880371,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,0.4157491028308868,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,3.4232704639434814,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,43.47956848144531,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,43.47956848144531,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,12,Lai Chau,LC,historical_63,44.28400039672851,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.1391441822052002,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.4664212465286257,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.5294194221496582,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.0694830417633057,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,5.2044677734375,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.8224684000015259,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.7546043395996094,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.4273370504379272,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.3566312789916992,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,5.361041069030762,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.112396240234375,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.4866434037685394,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.863240957260132,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,4.462280750274658,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.8574397563934328,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.062661409378052,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.1746119260787964,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.9680941104888916,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,7.062807083129883,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.455998659133911,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.2208259105682373,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.4621622562408447,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,7.138986587524414,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.9664840698242188,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.6269279718399048,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.89447283744812,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.9722166061401367,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,7.46010160446167,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,1.153797626495361,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.089784622192383,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.5708325505256653,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,3.8144147396087646,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.4805700778961181,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,2.495426893234253,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,0.407454252243042,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,3.383451223373413,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,43.887550354003906,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,43.887550354003906,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,14,Son La,SL,historical_63,45.16046905517578,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.8811476826667786,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.3278011083602903,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.6168400049209597,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.9909032583236694,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,4.816691875457764,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.8606665730476379,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.617728590965271,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.2821240425109863,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.2984713315963743,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,5.058990478515625,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.8485894203186035,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.4695602357387543,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.836569905281067,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,4.154719352722168,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.7256008386611938,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.059460163116455,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.0897520780563354,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.9728034734725952,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,6.847616672515869,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.410508155822754,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.219254732131958,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.446031093597412,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,7.075794219970703,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.9749133586883545,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.4422544240951538,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.8588716983795168,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,1.8995585441589355,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,7.17559814453125,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.895743191242218,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.001919984817505,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.6421769261360168,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,3.53983998298645,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.5270034074783325,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,2.3288586139678955,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,0.4139401912689209,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,3.2698020935058594,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,41.93905258178711,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,41.93905258178711,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,15,Yen Bai,YB,historical_63,43.15535354614258,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.0031384229660034,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.6236674785614014,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.5279152393341064,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.0760033130645752,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.230724811553955,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.8432465195655823,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.7504043579101562,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.3673945665359497,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.3712127208709717,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,5.332258224487305,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.9737606048583984,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.4976195693016052,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.792410373687744,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,4.263790607452393,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.7047348022460938,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.004934072494507,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.183166742324829,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.050480842590332,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,6.943316459655762,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.413900852203369,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.1915364265441895,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.36377477645874,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,6.969212055206299,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.076045274734497,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.4517334699630735,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.853895664215088,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.002880573272705,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,7.384554862976074,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,1.0174943208694458,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.1458024978637695,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.8853133916854858,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,4.048610210418701,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.5238630175590515,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,2.3527586460113525,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,0.4287010133266449,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,3.3053226470947266,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,43.47779083251953,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,43.47779083251953,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,17,Hoa Binh,HB,historical_63,44.88034439086914,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.3960152864456177,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.6686197519302368,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.590688943862915,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.1792844533920288,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,5.834608554840088,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.0527983903884888,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.9901481866836548,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.520050048828125,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.499950289726257,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,6.062946796417236,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.091853618621826,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.5477790832519531,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.9588769674301147,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,4.598509788513184,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.8315945863723757,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.1054556369781494,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.2149150371551514,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.02105712890625,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,7.173022270202637,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.6272969245910645,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.347883462905884,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.420039653778076,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,7.3952202796936035,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.9872448444366455,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.9523004293441772,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.012882709503174,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.9914686679840088,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,7.943896770477295,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.9590133428573608,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,1.9860433340072632,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.4086968302726745,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,3.3537535667419434,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.6129001975059509,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,2.9545488357543945,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,0.4192442297935486,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,3.986693143844605,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,46.34865188598633,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,46.34865188598633,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,19,Thai Nguyen,TNG,historical_63,47.02469253540039,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.035178542137146,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.7768661975860596,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.6496707201004028,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.0639082193374634,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,5.525623798370361,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.9064255952835084,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.8817648887634275,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.4881044626235962,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.3680135011672974,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,5.644308567047119,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.96668004989624,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.4574363529682159,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.9791258573532104,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,4.403242111206055,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.880927801132202,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.072702407836914,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.2443914413452148,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.9353346824645996,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,7.133356094360352,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.5574748516082764,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.513235092163086,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.4147627353668213,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,7.485472679138184,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.9595654010772705,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.033733367919922,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.92136812210083,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.9471811056137085,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,7.861847877502441,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.1268095970153809,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,1.88516366481781,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.5956003069877625,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,3.6075735092163086,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.5337100028991699,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,2.391233205795288,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,0.4172545969486236,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,3.342197895050049,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,45.003623962402344,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,45.003623962402344,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,20,Lang Son,LS,historical_63,46.06496047973633,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.2948182821273804,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.8830872774124143,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.519393801689148,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.1766319274902344,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,5.873931407928467,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.8851020336151123,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.022160053253174,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.518026351928711,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.4055036306381226,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,5.830792427062988,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.9697656631469729,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.4170969128608703,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.9579507112503052,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,4.344813346862793,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.981800436973572,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.2598326206207275,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.5780574083328247,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.169365167617798,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,7.989055633544922,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.3980305194854736,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.4595513343811035,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.53006649017334,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,7.387648582458496,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.8891291618347168,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.1140215396881104,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.3444454669952393,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.0722436904907227,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,8.419839859008789,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,1.2509254217147827,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.3521358966827393,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.4301081895828247,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,4.033169746398926,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.5656289458274841,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,2.9516122341156006,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,0.4247448742389679,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,3.941986083984375,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,47.82123565673828,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,47.82123565673828,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,22,Quang Ninh,QN,historical_63,49.410606384277344,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.168114185333252,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.930249571800232,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.4881047010421753,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.3681765794754028,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,5.954645156860352,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.8340359330177307,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.9175077676773071,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.346362829208374,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.2880693674087524,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,5.3859758377075195,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.8512670993804932,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.5038495063781738,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.031313419342041,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,4.386430263519287,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.73033607006073,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.0753707885742188,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.2625184059143066,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.0690550804138184,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,7.137280464172363,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.390127658843994,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.37740421295166,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.46673846244812,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,7.234270095825195,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.9376211166381836,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.878644585609436,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.1055054664611816,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.9358919858932495,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,7.857663154602051,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.0068109035491943,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,1.7003029584884644,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.4844586849212646,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,3.191572666168213,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.4334859251976013,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,2.7550055980682373,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,0.349077045917511,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,3.5375683307647705,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,44.68540573120117,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,44.68540573120117,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,24,Bac Giang,BG,historical_63,45.20132827758789,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.9491413831710817,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.6528273820877075,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.3896942138671875,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.24280846118927,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,5.234471321105957,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.9484804272651672,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.9343061447143557,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.450077772140503,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.4402340650558472,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,5.773098468780518,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.0086095333099365,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.4809895157814026,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.8374831676483152,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,4.32708215713501,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.7688430547714231,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.2047529220581055,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.2148288488388062,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.9595082998275757,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,7.147933483123779,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.4457461833953857,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.273573398590088,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.5413355827331543,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,7.260655403137207,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.9466525316238403,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.9704900979995728,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.920146942138672,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.9440405368804932,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,7.781330108642578,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.9871668815612792,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,1.9459515810012815,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.4045849144458771,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,3.3377034664154053,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.5020299553871155,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,2.6751902103424072,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,0.3750083744525909,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,3.5522284507751465,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,44.41450119018555,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,44.41450119018555,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,25,Phu Tho,PT,historical_63,45.61083984375,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.105770707130432,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.6278295516967771,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.5805543661117554,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.2876921892166138,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.601846694946289,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.7870041131973267,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.9177610874176023,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.3970996141433716,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.3755714893341064,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,5.477436542510986,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.9182374477386477,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.5003798604011536,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.9384262561798096,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,4.357043743133545,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.7144299745559692,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.010232448577881,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.102326512336731,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.050250291824341,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,6.877239227294922,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.436340808868408,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.5178277492523193,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.581315517425537,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,7.535484313964844,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.015512704849243,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.0994927883148193,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.292014837265014,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,1.9939450025558472,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,8.400965690612793,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.9761556386947632,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.007899045944214,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.4466087222099304,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,3.430663585662842,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.4883385002613067,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,2.8889434337615967,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,0.4277061522006988,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,3.804988145828247,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,45.48566818237305,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,45.48566818237305,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,27,Bac Ninh,BN,historical_63,45.6937370300293,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.2178382873535156,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.5117427110671997,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.358924388885498,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.277366042137146,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,5.365871429443359,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.8056740164756775,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.640420913696289,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.293824553489685,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.2718324661254885,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,5.011752128601074,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.9552388191223145,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.4323101341724396,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.9317013025283811,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,4.319250106811523,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.580908179283142,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.9735857248306272,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.0906901359558103,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.9195170402526855,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,6.564701080322266,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.339637517929077,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.19427752494812,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.551168203353882,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,7.085083484649658,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.9795578718185425,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.3964954614639282,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.172033309936523,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.963034510612488,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,7.5111212730407715,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.8167719841003418,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,1.862725853919983,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.4914626777172088,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,3.1709604263305664,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.4873248934745788,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,2.700174331665039,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,0.3785452544689178,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,3.566044330596924,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,42.594783782958984,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,42.594783782958984,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,30,Hai Duong,HD,historical_63,42.7746696472168,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.2586705684661863,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.6143234968185425,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.619656324386597,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.7350531816482544,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,5.22770357131958,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.8374723196029663,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.7981692552566528,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.376090168952942,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.318343162536621,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,5.330074787139893,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.9656046628952024,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.4460862278938293,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.7160788774490356,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,4.127769947052002,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.4402803182601929,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.8966606855392456,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.1108083724975586,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.0360584259033203,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,6.4838080406188965,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.385173082351685,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.270256996154785,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.431962490081787,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,7.087392330169678,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.8423713445663452,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.4507731199264526,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.347490072250366,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.9478652477264404,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,7.588500022888184,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.9788293242454528,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,1.832677125930786,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.5015428066253662,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,3.31304931640625,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.5121157765388489,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,2.6377713680267334,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,0.3954655826091766,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,3.5453526973724365,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,42.703651428222656,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,42.703651428222656,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,31,Hai Phong,HP,historical_63,43.15913772583008,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.2528188228607178,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.5737327337265017,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.4834544658660889,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.1420321464538574,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.452038288116455,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.8535088896751404,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.777578353881836,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.4041147232055664,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.4810198545455933,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,5.516221523284912,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.0611720085144043,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.492840439081192,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.815131664276123,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,4.369144439697266,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.8118473291397097,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.0561861991882324,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.2826308012008667,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.045274496078491,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,7.195939064025879,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.486635446548462,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.3711986541748047,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.4518635272979736,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,7.30969762802124,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.024733543395996,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.4352178573608398,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.099599599838257,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.9902937412261963,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,7.549844741821289,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,1.0268337726593018,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.092180013656616,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.4656680226325989,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,3.584681987762451,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.43849977850914,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,2.563326358795166,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,0.4248488247394562,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,3.4266748428344727,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,44.40424346923828,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,44.40424346923828,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,33,Hung Yen,HY,historical_63,45.58747482299805,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.0533400774002075,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.581723690032959,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.5421992540359497,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.0065572261810305,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,5.1838202476501465,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.92611825466156,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.80133056640625,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.4466087818145752,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.4582525491714478,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,5.632309913635254,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.1875646114349365,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.5114989876747131,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.9110738039016724,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,4.610137462615967,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.6854183673858645,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.023946523666382,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.2971974611282349,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.040611505508423,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,7.047173976898193,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.3936753273010254,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.3840537071228027,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.4765467643737793,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,7.254275798797607,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.028174877166748,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.9515010118484497,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.186351537704468,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.9674187898635864,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,8.13344669342041,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.915124237537384,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,1.8892087936401367,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.6603327989578247,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,3.4646658897399902,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.4848990738391876,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,2.4757049083709717,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,0.4514774680137634,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,3.412081480026245,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,44.737911224365234,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,44.737911224365234,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,34,Thai Binh,TB,historical_63,45.752296447753906,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.1557817459106443,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.452453851699829,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.6109589338302612,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.479936122894287,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,5.699130535125732,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.7104356288909912,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.839552879333496,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.4675875902175903,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.243170976638794,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,5.260746955871582,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.0260026454925537,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.4881390631198883,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.8972749710083008,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,4.411416530609131,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.7202188968658447,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.942673921585083,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.233810544013977,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.0076591968536377,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,6.904362678527832,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.375285387039185,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.332324266433716,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.507103443145752,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,7.214712619781494,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.9309591054916384,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.4295662641525269,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.8589876890182495,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.9371685981750488,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,7.156681537628174,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.1045948266983032,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,1.8395386934280396,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.3657468557357788,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,3.309880495071411,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.3865812718868255,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,2.6654341220855713,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,0.3737876117229461,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,3.4258029460906982,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,43.38273620605469,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,43.38273620605469,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,35,Ha Nam,HNA,historical_63,44.01243591308594,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.2675167322158811,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.6742089986801147,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.3885935544967651,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.2845017910003662,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,5.614820957183838,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.7987066507339478,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.801113486289978,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.4110099077224731,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.4102424383163452,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,5.421072483062744,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.023057699203491,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.4768705666065216,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.758111834526062,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,4.258040428161621,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.7592759132385254,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.017341136932373,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.2214590311050415,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.929975628852844,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,6.928051948547363,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.433009147644043,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.318369626998902,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.5831823348999023,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,7.334561347961426,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.9893475770950315,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.8438032865524292,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.993897795677185,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.014061212539673,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,7.8411102294921875,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,1.0550397634506226,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.04089617729187,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.4717926681041717,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,3.5677287578582764,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.4743330478668213,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,2.447849988937378,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,0.4699402153491974,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,3.392123222351074,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,44.35750961303711,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,44.35750961303711,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,36,Nam Dinh,ND,historical_63,45.1014404296875,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.1387693881988523,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.5242667198181152,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.4241158962249756,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.3438704013824463,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,5.431022644042969,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.7655020952224731,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.817149996757507,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.38691508769989,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.556309700012207,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,5.525876998901367,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.9309169054031372,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.4535099864006042,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.9549002647399905,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,4.339326858520508,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.693225979804993,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.06309175491333,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.1442114114761353,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.9784704446792605,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,6.878999710083008,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.423207521438598,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.348093032836914,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.5377798080444336,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,7.309080600738525,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.9657232761383057,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.451772928237915,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.9831080436706543,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.030763864517212,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,7.431368350982666,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,1.1129729747772217,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.1080052852630615,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.4735500812530517,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,3.694528341293335,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.4473966956138611,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,2.479988813400269,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,0.4144228994846344,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,3.341808319091797,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,43.95201110839844,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,43.95201110839844,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,37,Ninh Binh,NB,historical_63,44.96975326538086,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.1432130336761477,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.6749478578567505,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.5263433456420898,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.344063401222229,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,5.688567638397217,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.7933470606803894,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.8826864957809448,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.4737282991409302,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.3158200979232788,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,5.465581893920898,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.8793033361434937,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.5243767499923706,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.081146478652954,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,4.484826564788818,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.8661251068115232,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.097083806991577,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.2492092847824097,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.0789237022399902,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,7.291342258453369,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.446967124938965,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.285837411880493,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.513991117477417,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,7.246796131134033,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.026193618774414,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.471292495727539,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.9692680835723877,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.0006954669952393,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,7.46744966506958,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,1.171436071395874,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.213029623031616,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.5554402470588684,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,3.939906120300293,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.4232150912284851,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,2.481074571609497,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,0.3819918930530548,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,3.2862813472747803,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,44.870750427246094,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,44.870750427246094,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,38,Thanh Hoa,TH,historical_63,46.23418426513672,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.09967839717865,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.5289608240127563,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.5853731632232666,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.1043694019317627,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.3183817863464355,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.7372246384620667,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.8455586433410645,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.401586890220642,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.274448275566101,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,5.258818626403809,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.9651199579238892,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.547804594039917,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.770074486732483,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,4.282999038696289,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.769673466682434,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.0152390003204346,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.1630233526229858,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.9513561725616455,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,6.8992919921875,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.4038493633270264,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.241919755935669,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.5129165649414062,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,7.158685684204102,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.9863258600234983,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.427535057067871,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.921102285385132,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.9426134824752808,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,7.277576446533203,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,1.1397676467895508,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.053513288497925,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.5988756418228149,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,3.792156457901001,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.4408295154571533,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,2.2147789001464844,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,0.4263687133789062,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,3.081977128982544,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,43.06988906860352,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,43.06988906860352,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,40,Nghe An,NAN,historical_63,44.308589935302734,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.2613788843154907,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.521315574645996,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.546060562133789,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.5124579668045044,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,5.841213226318359,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.8236202001571655,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.035574197769165,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.543204426765442,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.55339515209198,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,5.955793857574463,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.109903573989868,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.5144799947738647,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.9398860931396484,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,4.564269542694092,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.834789752960205,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.050163507461548,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.254418134689331,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.0499000549316406,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,7.189271450042725,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.440361261367798,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.4364442825317383,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.482048988342285,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,7.358854293823242,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.1914496421813965,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.4686400890350342,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.924936294555664,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.9269697666168213,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,7.511995792388916,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,1.1074479818344116,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.164703845977783,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.4510902762413025,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,3.723242282867432,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.5400437116622925,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,2.4158475399017334,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,0.4525543451309204,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,3.4084455966949463,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,45.55308532714844,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,45.55308532714844,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,42,Ha Tinh,HT,historical_63,46.782859802246094,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.200704574584961,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.4840712547302246,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.5823684930801392,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.2112995386123655,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,5.478443622589111,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.8878865838050842,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.8824113607406616,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.4418193101882937,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.3585611581802368,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,5.570678234100342,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.9161635637283323,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.6105639338493347,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.9656680822372437,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,4.492395401000977,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.7665104866027832,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.0008013248443604,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.05364990234375,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.913363337516785,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,6.734324932098389,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.1438581943511963,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.081089496612549,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.395310878753662,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,6.620258808135986,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.054696798324585,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.9820168018341064,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.9249937534332275,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.946339726448059,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,7.908047199249268,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.0466868877410889,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,1.975990891456604,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.4709469377994537,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,3.493624687194824,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.446399837732315,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,2.624934434890747,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,0.4356926083564758,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,3.5070269107818604,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,43.80480194091797,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,43.80480194091797,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,44,Quang Binh,QB,historical_63,44.60997772216797,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.2344014644622805,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.602687120437622,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.493139624595642,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.1507651805877686,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,5.480993747711182,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.9229696989059448,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.764141321182251,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.4976863861083984,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.462064504623413,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,5.646862030029297,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.8027002811431885,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.575314998626709,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.9363044500350952,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,4.314319610595703,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.9442020654678345,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.1309657096862793,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.2896090745925903,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.9842796325683592,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,7.349056720733643,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.37825345993042,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.4002537727355957,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.5039281845092773,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,7.282435417175293,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.0218048095703125,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.4722298383712769,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.9849655628204343,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.9755712747573853,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,7.45457124710083,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.126172661781311,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,1.9060989618301392,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.6588894128799438,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,3.691161155700683,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.5229389667510986,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,2.531609058380127,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,0.473320871591568,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,3.5278687477111816,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,44.74726867675781,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,44.74726867675781,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,45,Quang Tri,QT,historical_63,46.17646408081055,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.2008336782455444,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.6325206756591797,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.4913218021392822,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.064501404762268,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.3891777992248535,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.86960768699646,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.822047233581543,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.446833252906799,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.366797924041748,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,5.50528621673584,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.8860782384872437,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.4872943758964538,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.9295597076416016,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,4.302932262420654,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.7880198955535889,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.149488687515259,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.2848303318023682,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.0023398399353027,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,7.224678993225098,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.375209331512451,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.2964773178100586,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.513920307159424,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,7.185606956481934,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.117727756500244,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.9143372774124143,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.1207056045532227,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.984667181968689,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,8.13743782043457,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,1.1458663940429688,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.140549898147583,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.7520612478256226,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,4.038477420806885,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.51746666431427,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,2.4294445514678955,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,0.3645379543304443,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,3.3114490509033203,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,45.09504699707031,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,45.09504699707031,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,46,Thua Thien Hue,TTH,historical_63,46.50787734985352,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.3126862049102783,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.26282000541687,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.5576400756835938,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.6572511792182922,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,4.790397644042969,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.8959353566169739,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.6167290210723877,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.2574986219406128,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.2475261688232422,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,5.017689228057861,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.9996639490127563,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.4790199697017669,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.9076333045959473,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,4.386317253112793,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.589610934257507,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.02272891998291,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.0290740728378296,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.9762178659439087,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,6.617631912231445,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.4369399547576904,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.4552972316741943,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.4975697994232178,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,7.389806747436523,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.9230057001113892,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.9962610006332395,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.2282016277313232,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.0165605545043945,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,8.164029121398926,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.9743239283561708,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,1.7669347524642944,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.3496203124523163,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,3.090878963470459,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.4832803606986999,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,2.820960521697998,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,0.4510739147663116,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,3.755314588546753,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,43.212066650390625,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,43.212066650390625,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,48,Da Nang,DNA,historical_63,43.31547164916992,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.8681191802024841,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.3764996528625488,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.2010618448257446,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.9113624691963196,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,4.357043266296387,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.7451825737953186,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.6215165853500366,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.2659703493118286,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.231194019317627,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,4.863863468170166,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.7149726152420044,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.4955741167068481,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.7659891843795776,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,3.9765357971191406,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.6456750631332395,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.9537030458450315,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.1699726581573486,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.9626154899597168,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,6.731966018676758,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.257476806640625,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.9168115854263303,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.5241379737854004,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,6.698426246643066,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.0089635848999023,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.951043725013733,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.888552188873291,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.947586178779602,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,7.796145439147949,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.9949758052825928,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,1.8905028104782104,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.7924874424934387,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,3.6779661178588863,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.3972432315349579,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.049433946609497,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,0.4558356404304504,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,2.902512788772583,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,41.00445938110352,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,41.00445938110352,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,49,Quang Nam,QNA,historical_63,42.53672790527344,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.04455828666687,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.3043386936187744,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.41140878200531,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.0083616971969604,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,4.768667697906494,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.8562481999397278,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.7557393312454224,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.325028896331787,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.492596983909607,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,5.4296135902404785,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.0300521850585938,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.5195483565330505,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.8401405811309817,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,4.389740943908691,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.762699007987976,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.059051513671875,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.2160948514938354,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.9646673202514648,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,7.0025129318237305,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.3427510261535645,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.319542169570923,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.456112861633301,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,7.118405818939209,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.9228565692901611,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.98149573802948,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.743330478668213,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.962339162826538,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,7.610022068023682,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,1.0796916484832764,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.077254295349121,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.5771344304084778,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,3.7340803146362305,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.5029752254486084,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,2.0698697566986084,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,0.4431943893432617,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,3.0160393714904785,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,43.06908416748047,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,43.06908416748047,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,51,Quang Ngai,QNG,historical_63,44.70928192138672,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.1114546060562134,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.286045789718628,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.1336201429367063,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.0033739805221558,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,4.534494400024414,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.8268502354621887,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.781803846359253,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.4751863479614258,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.486254334449768,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,5.570094585418701,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.897260665893555,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.4719433486461639,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.7486367225646973,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,4.117840766906738,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.8485041856765747,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.11258316040039,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.3120461702346802,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.9132663011550903,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,7.186399936676025,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.3213627338409424,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.1375882625579834,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.477203369140625,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,6.936154365539551,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.0090625286102295,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.024327278137207,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.928235650062561,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.9782803058624268,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,7.939905643463135,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,1.1842143535614014,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.019185781478882,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.5692166686058044,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,3.772616863250733,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.5165359377861023,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,2.413475751876831,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,0.4805663228034973,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,3.4105777740478516,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,43.46808624267578,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,43.46808624267578,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,52,Binh Dinh,BDI,historical_63,45.35004806518555,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.9981499910354614,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.17840313911438,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.340628981590271,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.7863459587097168,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,4.30352783203125,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.7847829461097717,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.421445608139038,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.2861328125,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.194310426712036,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,4.686671733856201,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.021775722503662,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.474271148443222,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.6347026824951172,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,4.130749225616455,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.7301405668258667,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.0897955894470215,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.3132575750350952,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.9778481721878052,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,7.111042022705078,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.2492775917053223,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.984608054161072,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.521725654602051,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,6.755611419677734,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.0165271759033203,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.4365519285202026,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.8696978092193604,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.9408800601959229,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,7.263657093048096,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.1185849905014038,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,1.9281448125839231,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.4814995229244232,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,3.5282294750213623,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.4214152693748474,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.0354437828063965,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,0.4320870339870453,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,2.888946056365967,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,40.668434143066406,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,40.668434143066406,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,54,Phu Yen,PY,historical_63,42.51127243041992,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.1890573501586914,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.2834491729736328,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.3163392543792725,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.5563960075378418,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,4.345241546630859,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.8780637979507446,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.7750195264816284,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.4175291061401367,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.3509749174118042,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,5.4215874671936035,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.0830912590026855,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.4508154988288879,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.7841566801071167,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,4.318063259124756,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.782978892326355,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.082639217376709,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.329046607017517,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.0103542804718018,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,7.205018997192383,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.3449671268463135,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.414076089859009,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.3591182231903076,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,7.118161678314209,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.992863416671753,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.0193347930908203,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.154686689376831,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.9514145851135256,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,8.11829948425293,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,1.1231818199157717,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.153400182723999,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.5145792961120605,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,3.791161298751831,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.4813518524169922,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,2.6082804203033447,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,0.3991897702217102,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,3.4888219833374023,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,43.80635452270508,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,43.80635452270508,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,56,Khanh Hoa,KH,historical_63,45.51811218261719,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.1990883350372314,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.4640761613845823,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.3610438108444214,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.037481427192688,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,5.061689853668213,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.9117138981819152,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.7986739873886108,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.541137456893921,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.3040380477905271,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,5.555563449859619,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.10779070854187,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.4907549917697906,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.878969430923462,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,4.47751522064209,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.9372527599334717,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.19446063041687,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.422923922538757,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.9948852062225344,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,7.549522399902344,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.470738649368286,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.490840196609497,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.550360202789306,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,7.51193904876709,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.9949535131454468,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.056061267852783,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.097368001937866,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.0088984966278076,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,8.157280921936035,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,1.1708265542984009,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.1623456478118896,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.5953556895256042,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,3.92852783203125,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.5397071242332458,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,2.4653987884521484,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,0.4851422905921936,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,3.490248203277588,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,45.7322883605957,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,45.7322883605957,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,58,Ninh Thuan,NT,historical_63,47.34195327758789,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.178273320198059,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.3485615253448486,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.6902822256088257,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.415170431137085,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,5.632287502288818,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.0322831869125366,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.870353102684021,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.7367300987243652,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.5916002988815308,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,6.230966567993164,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.220085859298706,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.5229725241661072,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.6086961030960083,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,4.351754665374756,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.9174344539642336,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.2182199954986572,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.584827542304993,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.99393367767334,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,7.714415550231934,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.572354316711426,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.466855049133301,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.505189895629883,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,7.544399261474609,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.1116585731506348,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.0320169925689697,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.0513651371002197,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.976536989212036,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,8.171577453613281,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,1.2596101760864258,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.091449022293091,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.471133828163147,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,3.822193145751953,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.6943305134773254,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,2.476487398147583,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,0.4882346093654632,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,3.65905237197876,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,47.12664794921875,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,47.12664794921875,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,60,Binh Thuan,BTH,historical_63,48.866790771484375,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.7712994813919067,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.2288163900375366,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.5338441133499146,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.0022052526474,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,4.536165237426758,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.7968161106109619,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.380012273788452,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.1194746494293213,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.27247953414917,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,4.568782806396484,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.846135139465332,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.4412000775337219,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.6035839319229126,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,3.890918970108032,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.51013445854187,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.9291839599609375,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.0195796489715576,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8961269855499268,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,6.355025291442871,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.461731433868408,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.360667943954468,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.4228386878967285,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,7.245238304138184,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.894789457321167,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.920718550682068,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.717060685157776,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.903280019760132,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,7.435848712921143,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.8867862224578857,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,1.8384279012680056,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.5626142024993896,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,3.287828207015991,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.4867007732391357,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.053419589996338,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,0.448333591222763,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,2.9884538650512695,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,40.30826187133789,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,40.30826187133789,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,62,Kon Tum,KT,historical_63,40.90346908569336,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.0046836137771606,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.248511791229248,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.4060449600219729,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.147829532623291,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,4.807069778442383,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.7550389170646667,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.6880104541778564,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.257457971572876,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.301733374595642,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,5.0022406578063965,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.9151195287704468,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.4926808178424835,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.7699614763259888,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,4.177762031555176,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.5821393728256226,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.049600601196289,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.0903116464614868,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.926186203956604,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,6.648237705230713,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.26886248588562,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.2062621116638184,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.4280481338500977,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,6.903172969818115,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.7874999046325684,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.9495152235031128,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.7390470504760742,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,1.9138773679733276,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,7.389939308166504,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.9995419383049012,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.0307631492614746,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.4760878086090088,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,3.5063929557800293,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.3972066938877105,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.076165199279785,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,0.3777125477790832,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,2.8510842323303223,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,41.2859001159668,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,41.2859001159668,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,64,Gia Lai,GL,historical_63,42.50479507446289,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.001594305038452,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.3116474151611328,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.513744831085205,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.9416619539260864,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,4.768648624420166,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.8185592889785767,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.6957446336746216,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.3575968742370603,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.3872286081314087,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,5.259129047393799,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.976329326629639,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.4788862764835357,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.874242067337036,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,4.329457759857178,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.7390213012695312,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.0431652069091797,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.2401965856552124,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.9874286651611328,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,7.009811878204346,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.4954094886779785,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.461972236633301,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.471602439880371,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,7.42898416519165,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.948530912399292,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.4434136152267456,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.8862090110778809,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.9824235439300537,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,7.260577201843262,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.0522123575210571,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,1.9899131059646609,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.362176775932312,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,3.4043023586273193,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.5400360226631165,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,2.601557970046997,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,0.4077228903770447,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,3.549316644668579,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,43.01022720336914,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,43.01022720336914,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,66,Dak Lak,DLK,historical_63,44.11125946044922,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.955710470676422,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.1872092485427856,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.402418851852417,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.0505393743515017,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,4.5958781242370605,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.7877359390258789,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.4713159799575806,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.1953235864639282,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.2584161758422852,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,4.712791442871094,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.8607443571090696,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.4547471106052398,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.9178262948989868,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,4.233317852020264,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.4162999391555786,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.9675109386444092,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.040008306503296,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.8981294631958008,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,6.321948528289795,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.379523754119873,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.2408595085144043,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.4430606365203857,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,7.063444137573242,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.0265934467315674,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.3592023849487305,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.7682369947433472,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.8748712539672852,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,7.028903961181641,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.886778712272644,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,1.9148595333099363,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.5112662315368652,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,3.312904357910156,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.4345051050186157,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,2.4288065433502197,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,0.4048822224140167,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,3.26819372177124,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,40.537384033203125,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,40.537384033203125,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,67,Dak Nong,DNO,historical_63,41.080352783203125,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.9802204370498656,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.5242958068847656,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.3552591800689695,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.8838473558425903,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,4.743622779846191,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.7980775237083435,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.2985929250717163,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.3075391054153442,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.2623066902160645,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,4.666516304016113,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.077855348587036,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.4292353987693786,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.858703374862671,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,4.3657941818237305,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.4094648361206057,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.8527953624725344,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.045304298400879,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.8429388999938965,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,6.150503635406494,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.3104159832000732,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.2122063636779785,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.3947956562042236,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,6.917418003082275,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.825681447982788,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.024432420730591,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.8872700929641724,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.8705997467041016,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,7.607983589172363,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.919640064239502,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,1.821052074432373,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.4516146183013916,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,3.1923067569732666,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.4716743528842926,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,2.4183623790740967,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,0.4837481379508972,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,3.37378454208374,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,41.01792907714844,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,41.01792907714844,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,68,Lam Dong,LD,historical_63,41.06000900268555,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.870945394039154,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.3564523458480835,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.3086286783218384,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.9944770336151124,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,4.530503273010254,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.8190912008285522,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.5166738033294678,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.2537566423416138,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.2540818452835083,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,4.843603610992432,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.9336336851119995,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.4511247873306274,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.911247730255127,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,4.296006202697754,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.588945746421814,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.9401947259902952,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.0941107273101809,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.9548499584198,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,6.57810115814209,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.4195523262023926,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.2732999324798584,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.4314284324645996,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,7.1242804527282715,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.83987557888031,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.7404614686965942,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.8776588439941408,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,1.923531174659729,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,7.381526947021484,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.8577135801315308,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.0323312282562256,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.4260664284229278,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,3.3161113262176514,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.5244914293289185,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,2.596073865890503,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,0.4387323558330536,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,3.559297561645508,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,41.629432678222656,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,41.629432678222656,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,70,Binh Phuoc,BP,historical_63,42.24660873413086,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.2671078443527222,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.3289340734481812,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.4693844318389893,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.3005342483520508,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,5.365960597991943,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.9600882530212402,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.994484782218933,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.622058987617493,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.5491878986358645,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,6.125819683074951,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.096017837524414,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.4674720168113708,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.9184812307357788,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,4.481971263885498,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.0225670337677,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.2852017879486084,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.7514821290969849,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.14467191696167,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,8.203923225402832,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.5106308460235596,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.4996323585510254,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.5304343700408936,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,7.5406975746154785,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.924453854560852,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.9762051105499268,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.908316731452942,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.0128958225250244,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,7.821871280670166,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,1.300171136856079,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.1195859909057617,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.5080004334449768,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,3.927757501602173,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.6843452453613281,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,2.7360596656799316,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,0.4568394720554352,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,3.877244234085083,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,47.345245361328125,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,47.345245361328125,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,72,Tay Ninh,TN,historical_63,49.61824035644531,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.212477684020996,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.5107243061065674,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.2807841300964355,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.8638915419578552,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,4.86787748336792,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.9165126085281372,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.8986629247665403,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.5166243314743042,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.55107843875885,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,5.882878303527832,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.953912138938904,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.4260950684547424,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.876363754272461,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,4.256371021270752,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.9642099142074585,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.1767821311950684,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.598012089729309,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.9010177850723269,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,7.640021800994873,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.469956398010254,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.485881090164185,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.449057340621948,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,7.404895305633545,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.8082518577575684,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.7651058435440063,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.1992809772491455,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.98319673538208,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,7.75583553314209,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.1935784816741943,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,1.9566669464111328,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.3730649352073669,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,3.523310422897339,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.6810339093208313,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,2.800804376602173,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,0.5781176686286926,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,4.059956073760986,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,45.391143798828125,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,45.391143798828125,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,74,Binh Duong,BD,historical_63,47.08932876586914,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.0835635662078855,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.1561932563781738,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.3234868049621582,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.9958779215812684,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,4.559121608734131,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.8366602063179016,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.538029432296753,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.2406768798828125,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.3056567907333374,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,4.921023368835449,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.959544658660889,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.4076425433158874,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.902345299720764,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,4.269532203674316,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.5050572156906128,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.009380340576172,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.2296627759933472,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.9694337844848633,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,6.713534355163574,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.329336643218994,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.358307361602783,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.4470484256744385,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,7.134692668914795,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.7637659311294556,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.721476435661316,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.0842199325561523,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.9074740409851072,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,7.476936340332031,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.992436945438385,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,1.836564540863037,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.3903745710849762,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,3.2193760871887207,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.4597916305065155,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,2.670668840408325,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,0.3997794389724731,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,3.5302398204803467,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,41.82445526123047,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,41.82445526123047,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,75,Dong Nai,DN,historical_63,42.56004333496094,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.27237069606781,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.1235674619674685,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.4318645000457764,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.778773844242096,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,4.606576442718506,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.944362998008728,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.759089112281799,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.3969866037368774,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.4019004106521606,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,5.502338886260986,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.0798096656799316,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.4392509758472442,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.844629168510437,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,4.36368989944458,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.8876854181289673,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.2580692768096924,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.4299099445343018,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.0471158027648926,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,7.6227803230285645,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.4695608615875244,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.5018792152404785,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.573477983474731,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,7.544918060302734,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.0016653537750244,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.02347993850708,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.27307391166687,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.025155782699585,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,8.32337474822998,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,1.1968021392822266,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.2185463905334473,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.4079034924507141,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,3.823251962661743,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.6182684898376465,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,2.511763334274292,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,0.6151352524757385,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,3.745167016983032,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,45.53209686279297,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,45.53209686279297,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,77,Ba Ria - Vung Tau,VT,historical_63,47.21232604980469,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.1695162057876587,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.073913335800171,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.5203059911727903,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.0424811840057373,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,4.806216716766357,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.8964165449142456,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.6158185005187988,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.4109594821929932,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.2734076976776123,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,5.1966023445129395,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.9550327062606812,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.4032723307609558,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.8163354396820068,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,4.174640655517578,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.5723910331726074,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.0049095153808594,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.3430789709091189,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.0339930057525635,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,6.954372882843018,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.3666903972625732,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.155496597290039,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.403057336807251,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,6.925244331359863,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.7586145401000977,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.9315736293792725,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.1991395950317383,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.922996401786804,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,7.812324047088623,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.0206611156463623,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,1.7988888025283811,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.3496759235858917,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,3.1692259311676025,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.4875854551792145,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,2.836414337158203,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,0.4505419731140136,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,3.7745416164398193,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,42.81316757202149,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,42.81316757202149,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,79,Ho Chi Minh City,HCM,historical_63,43.68138885498047,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.920560896396637,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.2139790058135986,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.2420836687088013,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.3301575183868408,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,4.706781387329102,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.8075560927391052,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.619933009147644,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.3153424263000488,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.3419392108917236,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,5.084770679473877,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.0633959770202637,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.4182825982570648,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.778006911277771,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,4.259685516357422,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.6777606010437012,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.074047088623047,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.3354321718215942,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.9568452835083008,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,7.0440850257873535,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.3513336181640625,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.4621739387512207,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.4109721183776855,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,7.224479675292969,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.806907057762146,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.9969016909599304,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.9904863834381104,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.8976595401763916,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,6.691954612731934,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.0461419820785522,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,1.923928380012512,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.6498869061470032,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,3.619957208633423,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.4820852875709533,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,2.7429847717285156,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,0.4362997412681579,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,3.661369800567627,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,42.29308319091797,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,42.29308319091797,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,80,Long An,LA,historical_63,43.62220764160156,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.0100916624069214,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.137837052345276,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.2356362342834473,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.9511237144470216,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,4.334688663482666,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.7820729613304138,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.6167004108428955,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.3406347036361694,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.0517338514328003,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,4.791141986846924,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.0327768325805664,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.4398919641971588,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.8341628313064575,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,4.3068318367004395,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.6438270807266235,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.024017810821533,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.2220237255096436,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.9461606740951536,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,6.836029052734375,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.4251434803009033,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.3540894985198975,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.424257516860962,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,7.203490257263184,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.9179580211639404,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.3125981092453003,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.891059398651123,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.9098879098892212,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,7.031503677368164,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.1385762691497805,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,1.927623391151428,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.6463915705680847,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,3.712591171264648,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.4317287504673004,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,2.20725679397583,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,0.3942880034446716,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,3.033273458480835,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,41.249549865722656,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,41.249549865722656,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,83,Ben Tre,BT,historical_63,42.70032501220703,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.7541835904121399,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.0236798524856567,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.3666383028030396,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.9628159403800964,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,4.107317924499512,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.7553168535232544,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.517048478126526,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.2388241291046145,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.3387997150421145,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,4.84998893737793,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.0350253582000732,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.4285371303558349,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.692263960838318,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,4.155826568603516,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.634719729423523,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.0269267559051514,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.2914119958877563,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.9512426853179932,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,6.904301166534424,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.205864667892456,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.3457071781158447,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.3649916648864746,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,6.916563510894775,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.8560278415679932,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.6011875867843628,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.0126638412475586,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.8907082080841064,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,7.3605875968933105,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,1.0540120601654053,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.110776901245117,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.4152828156948089,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,3.5800719261169434,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.3835585713386535,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.000601053237915,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,0.3574813306331634,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,2.74164080619812,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,40.61629867553711,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,40.61629867553711,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,84,Tra Vinh,TV,historical_63,42.46232223510742,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.0698308944702148,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.1359853744506836,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.2636626958847046,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.9218150973320008,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,4.391294002532959,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.7844939827919006,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.6969778537750244,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.2764298915863037,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.27238130569458,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,5.030282974243164,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.7735490798950195,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.4333687722682953,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.7459532022476196,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,3.952871084213257,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.722314953804016,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.0714125633239746,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.3925455808639526,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.9329243898391724,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,7.119197368621826,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.3968992233276367,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.460165023803711,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.4326891899108887,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,7.289753437042236,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.9235388040542605,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.9804810285568235,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.2334678173065186,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.8816232681274416,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,8.019110679626465,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.1610002517700195,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.9603461027145384,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,1.0981924533843994,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,4.219538688659668,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.4355892837047577,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,2.3482508659362793,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,0.3900599777698517,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,3.1738998889923096,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,43.19594955444336,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,43.19594955444336,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,86,Vinh Long,VL,historical_63,44.9881591796875,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.9690349102020264,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.0346633195877075,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.2502268552780151,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.3361793756484983,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,4.590104579925537,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.8549774885177612,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.6287832260131836,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.347781538963318,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.3754558563232422,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,5.206998348236084,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.1030988693237305,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.4507365226745605,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.854211688041687,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,4.408047199249268,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.762657642364502,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.036436080932617,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.4850623607635498,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.996220588684082,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,7.280376434326172,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.4470643997192383,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.564234733581543,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.548664093017578,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,7.559963226318359,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.9401392936706543,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.231074571609497,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.177220106124878,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.9612518548965456,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,7.309685707092285,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.097636103630066,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.956757664680481,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,1.3578150272369385,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,4.412208557128906,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.468608021736145,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,2.208411455154419,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,0.3913078308105469,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,3.0683271884918213,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,43.83571243286133,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,43.83571243286133,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,87,Dong Thap,DT,historical_63,45.86805725097656,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.9171549677848816,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.162115454673767,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.2248716354370115,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.9677943587303162,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,4.271936416625977,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.7315012216567993,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.740626335144043,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.301558494567871,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.3827277421951294,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,5.156413555145264,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.8429330587387085,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.425909548997879,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.7278623580932615,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,3.9967048168182377,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.8465557098388672,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.1593246459960938,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.5221452713012695,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.0329253673553467,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,7.560951232910156,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.2676637172698975,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.4596221446990967,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.4618568420410156,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,7.18914270401001,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.9106088876724243,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.4339137077331543,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.2102839946746826,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.9411437511444092,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,7.495950222015381,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.2663137912750244,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.027089834213257,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,1.0005658864974976,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,4.293969631195068,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.3898099660873413,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.171947956085205,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,0.3648582398891449,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,2.9266161918640137,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,42.89168548583984,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,42.89168548583984,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,89,An Giang,AG,historical_63,45.57263946533203,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.8327421545982361,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.955512762069702,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.2955738306045532,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.0347713232040403,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,4.118599891662598,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.7785571217536926,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.2574431896209717,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.2067943811416626,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.1722264289855957,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,4.415020942687988,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.9550689458847048,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.438127189874649,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.5065613985061646,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,3.899757623672486,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.449955940246582,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.8615012168884275,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.1705262660980225,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.6047204732894895,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,6.086703777313232,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.3683037757873535,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.4756524562835693,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.4177258014678955,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,7.261682033538818,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.9338029623031616,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.9462472200393677,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.9527302980422976,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.8536239862442017,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,7.686404228210449,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.9482487440109252,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,1.78848135471344,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.7237043976783752,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,3.460434675216675,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.4231199920177459,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.0779128074645996,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,0.482551097869873,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,2.983583688735962,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,39.91218566894531,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,39.91218566894531,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,91,Kien Giang,KG,historical_63,40.377681732177734,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.8087710738182068,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.8518335819244385,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.1516764163970947,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.793249249458313,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,3.605530261993408,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.8466195464134216,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.2144030332565308,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.2233433723449707,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.1654244661331177,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,4.4497904777526855,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.89361834526062,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.3884462118148803,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.704239845275879,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,3.98630428314209,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.69549822807312,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.0156502723693848,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.269539713859558,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.84197998046875,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,6.822668075561523,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.427626848220825,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.274301528930664,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.434453010559082,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,7.136381149291992,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.6978578567504885,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.3956255912780762,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.169581890106201,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.9221704006195068,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,7.185235977172852,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.0885950326919556,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,1.916019916534424,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.8705584406852722,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,3.875173568725586,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.4818741083145141,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,2.4593615531921387,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,0.4403437376022339,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,3.3815793991088867,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,40.442665100097656,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,40.442665100097656,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,92,Can Tho,CT,historical_63,42.01357650756836,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.9334174990653992,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.160590648651123,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.0709612369537354,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.255446434020996,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,4.420415878295898,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.826120138168335,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.6966971158981323,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.307459831237793,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.275530457496643,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,5.105807781219482,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.0197901725769043,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.4953326880931854,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.782354474067688,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,4.2974772453308105,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.8617041110992432,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.0972137451171875,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.5024408102035522,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.9496710300445557,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,7.411029815673828,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.557981491088867,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.5499777793884277,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.4848098754882812,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,7.592769145965576,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.981595754623413,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.4660385847091677,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.1217544078826904,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.943151593208313,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,7.512540340423584,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.125133991241455,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.899001121520996,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,1.2973748445510864,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,4.321509838104248,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.5015986561775208,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,2.3815460205078125,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,0.4619154036045074,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,3.345060110092163,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,44.00661087036133,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,44.00661087036133,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,93,Hau Giang,HGI,historical_63,45.97507095336914,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.097209095954895,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.1252483129501345,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.2241754531860352,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.5228767395019531,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,4.969509601593018,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.8008526563644409,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.8479143381118777,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.5052169561386108,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.4119455814361572,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,5.565929412841797,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.0243823528289795,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.4301943480968475,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.7353487014770508,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,4.189925193786621,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.138533115386963,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.2523791790008545,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.615451455116272,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.82219135761261,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,7.828555107116699,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.380812168121338,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.5996124744415283,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.4350271224975586,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,7.415451526641846,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.0477073192596436,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.0001416206359863,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.0669305324554443,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.0413267612457275,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,8.156105995178223,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,1.3301060199737549,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.048099994659424,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.5182976126670837,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,3.8965036869049072,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.4423192143440246,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,2.306222677230835,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,0.4158960580825805,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,3.164438009262085,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,45.18642044067383,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,45.18642044067383,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,94,Soc Trang,ST,historical_63,47.40657424926758,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.2022769451141355,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.2326244115829468,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.1929179430007937,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.9738678336143494,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,4.601686954498291,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.88755202293396,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.6058255434036257,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.3481303453445437,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.4654474258422852,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,5.306955337524414,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.110393524169922,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.48427614569664,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.8022483587265017,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,4.396917819976807,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.8998661041259768,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.1546080112457275,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.4885056018829346,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.0293307304382324,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,7.572310447692871,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.4687445163726807,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.38360333442688,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.486048460006714,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,7.338396549224853,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.9269695281982424,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.458430528640747,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.1116654872894287,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.0061841011047363,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,7.503249645233154,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,1.164435863494873,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.117760181427002,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.6507335305213928,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,3.932929754257202,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.5023741722106934,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,2.5171406269073486,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,0.428422063589096,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,3.447936773300171,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,44.10038375854492,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,44.10038375854492,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,95,Bac Lieu,BL,historical_63,46.10089492797851,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.1060794591903689,papi8,d1_1_civic_knowledge,1.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.1447700262069702,papi8,d1_2_opportunities,1.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.3003740310668943,papi8,d1_3_elections_quality,1.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.0991815328598022,papi8,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,1.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,4.650404930114746,papi8,d1_participation,1.0,,dimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.8660814166069031,papi8,d2_1_access_to_information,2.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.7844198942184448,papi8,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,2.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.433403253555298,papi8,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,2.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.441075086593628,papi8,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,2.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,5.524979591369629,papi8,d2_transparency,2.0,,dimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.153724193572998,papi8,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,3.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.5258755683898926,papi8,d3_2_complaint_resolution,3.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.9074424505233765,papi8,d3_3_access_to_justice,3.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,4.587042331695557,papi8,d3_vertical_accountability,3.0,,dimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.9760758876800537,papi8,d4_1_corruption_in_government,4.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.1780693531036377,papi8,d4_2_corruption_in_services,4.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.449931025505066,papi8,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,4.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.987181544303894,papi8,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,4.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,7.5912580490112305,papi8,d4_control_of_corruption,4.0,,dimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.466587781906128,papi8,d5_1_certification_services,5.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.482837915420532,papi8,d5_3_land_use_certificates,5.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.508237838745117,papi8,d5_4_commune_admin_services,5.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,7.457663536071777,papi8,d5_public_admin_procedures,5.0,,dimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.8880945444107056,papi8,d6_1_public_health,6.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.6068888902664185,papi8,d6_2_primary_education,6.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.0902109146118164,papi8,d6_3_basic_infrastructure,6.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.9154719114303589,papi8,d6_4_law_and_order,6.0,4.0,subdimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,7.500666618347168,papi8,d6_public_service_delivery,6.0,,dimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.175387978553772,papi8,d7_1_environmental_protection,7.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,1.9981218576431272,papi8,d7_2_air_quality,7.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.5933443307876587,papi8,d7_3_water_quality,7.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,3.766854286193848,papi8,d7_environmental_governance,7.0,,dimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.5422536134719849,papi8,d8_1_egov_portals,8.0,1.0,subdimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,2.4553253650665283,papi8,d8_2_internet_access,8.0,2.0,subdimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,0.4452116787433624,papi8,d8_3_egov_responsiveness,8.0,3.0,subdimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,3.4427905082702637,papi8,d8_e_governance,8.0,,dimension, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,44.52165985107422,papi8,papi_total,,,aggregate,official_unweighted 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,44.52165985107422,papi8,papi_unweighted,,,aggregate, 2024,96,Ca Mau,CM,historical_63,46.47710037231445,papi8,papi_weighted,,,aggregate,