year,n_provinces,instrument_era,total_method,n_indicators,source_file,source_sheet,layout,dropped_all_na_provinces,partial_na_provinces,weighted_from_sheet,note
2011,63,classic_6,sum_of_6_dimensions,29,PAPI-2011-Du-lieu-1.xlsx,2012PAPI- Bảng tổng hợp kết quả,,,,,Audited before clean. year from filename when set; sheet title may disagree.
2012,63,classic_6,sum_of_6_dimensions,29,PAPI-2012-Du-lieu-1.xlsx,2012PAPI- Bảng tổng hợp kết quả,,,,,Audited before clean. year from filename when set; sheet title may disagree.
2013,63,classic_6,sum_of_6_dimensions,29,PAPI-2013-Du-lieu-1.xlsx,2013PAPI- Bảng tổng hợp kết quả,,,,,Audited before clean. year from filename when set; sheet title may disagree.
2014,61,classic_6,sum_of_6_dimensions,29,PAPI-2014-Du-lieu-1.xlsx,2014PAPI- Bảng tổng hợp kết quả,,Bắc Giang; Đồng Tháp,,,"Audited before clean. year from filename when set; sheet title may disagree. Dropped all-NA source rows: ['Bắc Giang', 'Đồng Tháp']."
2015,63,classic_6,sum_of_6_dimensions,29,PAPI-2015-Du-lieu-1.xlsx,2015PAPI- Bảng tổng hợp kết quả,,,,,Audited before clean. year from filename when set; sheet title may disagree.
2016,63,classic_6,sum_of_6_dimensions,29,PAPI-2016-Du-lieu-1.xlsx,2016PAPI- Bảng tổng hợp kết quả,,,,,Audited before clean. year from filename when set; sheet title may disagree.
2017,63,classic_6,sum_of_6_dimensions,29,PAPI-2017-Du-lieu-1.xlsx,2017PAPI- Bảng tổng hợp kết quả,,,,,Audited before clean. year from filename when set; sheet title may disagree.
2018,63,papi8,official_unweighted,38,PAPI2018_ProvincialScores_ByIndicators_VIE.xlsx,ProvincialIndicators_VIE,vie_names_only,,"Quang Ninh:papi_unweighted,d2_transparency,d2_1_access_to_information,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,d4_control_of_corruption,d4_1_corruption_in_government,d4_2_corruption_in_services,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness; Dong Thap:papi_unweighted,d2_transparency,d2_1_access_to_information,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,d4_control_of_corruption,d4_1_corruption_in_government,d4_2_corruption_in_services,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness",,"Matrix format (indicator×province). Official unweighted total stored as papi_unweighted and aliased to papi_total. KCDL/blank → NA. Partial NA kept: ['Quang Ninh:papi_unweighted,d2_transparency,d2_1_access_to_information,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,d4_control_of_corruption,d4_1_corruption_in_government,d4_2_corruption_in_services,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness', 'Dong Thap:papi_unweighted,d2_transparency,d2_1_access_to_information,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,d4_control_of_corruption,d4_1_corruption_in_government,d4_2_corruption_in_services,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness']."
2019,63,papi8,official_unweighted,40,2019_PAPI_Provincial_indicators2019_VIE_ENG.xlsx,2019PAPI_Indicators_VIE,vie_codes,,,,Matrix format (indicator×province). Official unweighted total stored as papi_unweighted and aliased to papi_total. KCDL/blank → NA.
2020,63,papi8,official_unweighted,40,2020PAPI_ProvincialIndicators_BangChiTieuCapTinh-1.xlsx,2020_VIE_ENG,bilingual,,,,Matrix format (indicator×province). Official unweighted total stored as papi_unweighted and aliased to papi_total. KCDL/blank → NA.
2021,60,papi8,official_unweighted,39,1.2021PAPI_ProvincialIndicators_BangChiTieuCapTinh.xlsx,2021_VIE_ENG,bilingual,Quảng Ninh; Bắc Giang; Bắc Ninh,,,"Matrix format (indicator×province). Official unweighted total stored as papi_unweighted and aliased to papi_total. KCDL/blank → NA. Dropped all-NA provinces: ['Quảng Ninh', 'Bắc Giang', 'Bắc Ninh']."
2022,63,papi8,official_unweighted,39,2022PAPI_ProvincialIndicators_BangChiTieuCapTinh.xlsx,2022_VIE_ENG,bilingual,,"Bac Giang:papi_weighted,papi_unweighted,d1_participation,d1_1_civic_knowledge,d1_2_opportunities,d1_3_elections_quality,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,d2_transparency,d2_1_access_to_information,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,d4_control_of_corruption,d4_1_corruption_in_government,d4_2_corruption_in_services,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,d5_public_admin_procedures,d5_1_certification_services,d5_3_land_use_certificates,d5_4_commune_admin_services; Bac Ninh:papi_weighted,papi_unweighted,d2_transparency,d2_1_access_to_information,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,d3_vertical_accountability,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,d3_2_complaint_resolution,d3_3_access_to_justice,d4_control_of_corruption,d4_1_corruption_in_government,d4_2_corruption_in_services,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,d8_e_governance,d8_1_egov_portals,d8_2_internet_access,d8_3_egov_responsiveness",2022_PAPI_Indicators,"Matrix format (indicator×province). Official unweighted total stored as papi_unweighted and aliased to papi_total. KCDL/blank → NA. Score-cell literal 0 treated as missing (2022 sentinel). Weighted filled from 2022_PAPI_Indicators. Partial NA kept: ['Bac Giang:papi_weighted,papi_unweighted,d1_participation,d1_1_civic_knowledge,d1_2_opportunities,d1_3_elections_quality,d1_4_voluntary_contributions,d2_transparency,d2_1_access_to_information,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,d4_control_of_corruption,d4_1_corruption_in_government,d4_2_corruption_in_services,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,d5_public_admin_procedures,d5_1_certification_services,d5_3_land_use_certificates,d5_4_commune_admin_services', 'Bac Ninh:papi_weighted,papi_unweighted,d2_transparency,d2_1_access_to_information,d2_2_poverty_list_transparency,d2_3_commune_budget_transparency,d2_4_land_use_plan_transparency,d3_vertical_accountability,d3_1_interaction_with_authorities,d3_2_complaint_resolution,d3_3_access_to_justice,d4_control_of_corruption,d4_1_corruption_in_government,d4_2_corruption_in_services,d4_3_equity_in_public_employment,d4_4_anti_corruption_willingness,d8_e_governance,d8_1_egov_portals,d8_2_internet_access,d8_3_egov_responsiveness']."
2023,61,papi8,official_unweighted,39,2023PAPI_ProvincialIndicators_BangChiTieuCapTinh..xlsx,2023_VIE_ENG,bilingual,Quảng Ninh; Bình Dương,,2023_PAPI_Indicators,"Matrix format (indicator×province). Official unweighted total stored as papi_unweighted and aliased to papi_total. KCDL/blank → NA. Weighted filled from 2023_PAPI_Indicators. Dropped all-NA provinces: ['Quảng Ninh', 'Bình Dương']."
2024,61,papi8,official_unweighted,39,PAPI-2024-ProvincialIndicators.xlsx,2024_PAPI_VIE_ENG,bilingual_dual34,Vĩnh Phúc; Tiền Giang,,2024_PAPI_Indicators,"Matrix format (indicator×province). Official unweighted total stored as papi_unweighted and aliased to papi_total. KCDL/blank → NA. Score-cell literal 0 treated as missing (2022 sentinel). Weighted filled from 2024_PAPI_Indicators. Dual geo header: scores are pre-merger historical_63; geo_code_new34 / geo_name_new34_raw carry publisher new-34 labels when set. Dropped all-NA provinces: ['Vĩnh Phúc', 'Tiền Giang']."