diff --git a/q0/random_k2/question.json b/q0/random_k2/question.json
index 54170932f5279b99ea4e767d8ac4b7c65df9e08f..e03ff76a92bce7ee3707f9c85b50a3e8327e70da 100644
--- a/q0/random_k2/question.json
+++ b/q0/random_k2/question.json
@@ -15,8 +15,8 @@
],
"original_filenames": [
"PH_2016.06.08_Economy-Final.pdf",
- "web_24c4662e4f9e6338.pdf",
- "web_d455d7d1e8416aea.pdf"
+ "web_3cd8fd0905eadfd3.pdf",
+ "web_4af2298618127c8a.pdf"
],
"modality": "markdown"
}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/q0/random_k2/random_1.md b/q0/random_k2/random_1.md
index 132a7a3a1eb856bf1ac3b2a8f7f839b34c78bc6d..0157c79493366431cd66d8105491fdfb94260f43 100644
--- a/q0/random_k2/random_1.md
+++ b/q0/random_k2/random_1.md
@@ -1,1593 +1,663 @@
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
+Thursday April 9
-About the National Science and Technology Council
+Topics for this Lecture:
+•Thermal Physics
-The National Science and Technology Council (NSTC) is the principal means by which the Executive
-Branch coordinates science and technology policy across the diverse entities that make up the federal
-research and development enterprise. A primary objective of the NSTC is to ensure science and
-technology (S&T) policy decisions and programs are consistent with the President’s stated goals. The
-NSTC prepares research and development strategies that are coordinated across federal agencies
-aimed at accomplishing multiple national goals. The work of the NSTC is organized under committees
-that oversee subcommittees and working groups focused on different aspects of science and
-technology. More information is available at www.whitehouse.gov/ostp/nstc.
+• Temperature & Heat
+• Temperature measurement
+• Thermal expansion
-About the Office of Science and Technology Policy
+•Thermal Physics
-The Office of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP) was established by the National Science and
-Technology Policy, Organization, and Priorities Act of 1976 to provide the President and others within
-the Executive Office of the President with advice on the scientific, engineering, and technological
-aspects of the economy, national security, homeland security, health, foreign relations, the
-environment, and the technological recovery and use of resources, among other topics. OSTP leads
-interagency S&T policy coordination efforts, assists the Office of Management and Budget with an
-annual review and analysis of federal research and development in budgets, and serves as a source of
-scientific and technological analysis and judgment for the President with respect to major policies,
-is available at
-plans, and programs of
-www.whitehouse.gov/ostp.
+• Phases & Latent Heat
+• Calorimetry
-federal government. More
+• TF = (9/5)(TC) + 32
+• “Temperature” is not “Heat”
+• Thermal linear expansion:
-information
+• ΔL = αL0ΔT [α] = K-1
-the
+• Heat energy flow:
+• Q=c*m*ΔT
+• Qlost = Qgained
-About the NSTC Subcommittee on Research and Development Infrastructure
+See the course webpage for slides,
+video links, and google docs Q&A links
+• Assignment 11 due Friday
+• Pre-class due 15min before class
+• Help Room: via Teams, 6-9pm
+Wed/Thurs, also via email on Wed/Thurs
+• SI: via Teams
+• Office Hours: via email
+(meisel@ohio.edu)
-The Subcommittee on Research and Development Infrastructure (RDI) coordinates federal investments
-in infrastructure supporting research and development (R&D) across the nation under the auspices of
-the NSTC’s Committee on Science and Technology Enterprise. This coordination ensures that U.S. R&D
-infrastructure and the scientific and engineering workforce it supports remain preeminent, relevant,
-and ready to address the nation’s economic and national security priorities.
+• Phase changes:
-About this Document
+Q=m*L
-Consistent with Section 1007 of the America Creating Opportunities to Meaningfully Promote
-Excellence in Technology, Education, and Science (COMPETES) Act, the National Science and
-Technology Council is required to “produce a report identifying and prioritizing the deficiencies in
-research facilities and major instrumentation located at federal laboratories and national user facilities
-at academic institutions that are widely accessible for use by researchers in the United States.” This
-document fulfills that requirement by providing an assessment of issues facing the United States’
-research and development infrastructure (RDI) and their impact on the nation’s status as a global leader
-in S&T. It aims be a tool for agencies to assess and address RDI concerns based on individual needs and
-resources. The assessment identifies four major issues affecting U.S. RDI: aging and inadequate
-research infrastructure; cascading impacts from substandard facilities; a widening gap in global S&T
-outcomes; and challenges in recruiting and retaining top talent. This assessment also offers four
-opportunities for agencies to meet future S&T needs: strategic planning, identifying gaps,
-benchmarking, and interagency collaboration).
+*If your circumstances
+hinder your completion of
+any of this class’s
+assignments, please let
+me know
+*These slides are
+recorded and posted in
+advance for your
+convenience.
+Administrative details
+may be out of date. Keep
+an eye on your email
+please.
-– i –
+Thermal Physics
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
+Why can we only see
+warm things in infrared
+and not cold objects?
-Copyright Information
+Why do bridges have
+these sorts of joints?
-This document is a work of the United States government and is in the public domain (see 17 U.S.C.
-§105). Subject to the stipulations below, it may be distributed and copied with acknowledgment to
-OSTP. Copyrights to graphics included in this document are reserved by the original copyright holders
-or their assignees and are used here under the government’s license and by permission. Requests to
-use any images must be made to the provider identified in the image credits or to OSTP if no provider
-is identified. Published in the United States of America, 2024.
+How much
+energy does it
+take to bring
+water to a boiling
+temperature?
-– ii –
+Temperature & Heat
+• Temperature:
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
+– A measure of the internal kinetic energy of atoms & molecules within an object.
+– This is a property of an object.
-NATIONAL SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY COUNCIL
+• Heat:
-Chair
+– A measure of the transfer of energy between two objects.
+– This is a property of an interaction, not of a single object.
+– Heat is the energy moving from a high temperature object to a low temperature object.
-Arati Prabhakar, Assistant to the President for
-Science and Technology; and Director, Office
-of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP)
+Temperature Scales
-Executive Director
+• A few common units are used for temperature:
-Kei Koizumi, Principal Deputy Director for
-Science, Society, and Policy, OSTP
+– Fahrenheit, Celsius, & Kelvin
+• Fahrenheit is related to Celsius by:
+ TFahrenheit = (9/5)TCelsius + 32
+ ΔTFahrenheit = (9/5)ΔTCelsius
+• Celsius is related to Kelvin by:
+ TKelvin = TCelsius + 273.15
-NSTC SUBCOMMITTEE ON RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT
-INFRASTRUCTURE
+20C is about
+room
+temperature.
-Co-Chairs
+Zero C is
+freezing,
+10C is cold,
+20C is nice,
+30C is hot.
-Executive Secretary
+• Zero Kelvin is “absolute zero” (lowest possible T)
+• Zero Celsius is the freezing point for water,
+which is 32 Fahrenheit and 273.15 Kelvin.
-Harriet Kung, Department of Energy
+• 100 Celsius is the boiling point for water,
-Mariam Elsayed, Department of Energy
+which is 212 Fahrenheit and 373.14 Kelvin.
-Linnea Avallone, National Science Foundation
+Thermal Expansion of Solids: Linear expansion
-Jagadeesh Pamulapati, Department of
+• Objects expand when their temperature increases.
+• The amount of expansion depends on the material
+properties and is known as
+the expansion coefficient: α
+• α depends on the particular material
+(and one the phase of matter). SI unit: K-1
+• α describes how much an object expands
+in a linear dimension for a given temperature
+increase
-Defense
+ ΔL = αL0ΔT
-Cole Donovan, Office of Science and
+• The fractional change in length is:
-Technology Policy
+ ΔL/L = αΔT
+ ΔT must be in Celsius or Kelvin
-Members
+• Typical α values are (at 20 degrees C):
-Aliya Iftikhar, Office of Science and
+–Aluminum, Copper, Silver: ~2x10-5 K-1
+–Concrete, Glass, Steel : ~1x10-5 K-1
+–Diamond: ~0.1x10-5 K-1
-Jason Boehm, National Institute for Standards
+This is why you need special
+joints for, e.g. bridges
-Technology Policy
+An 0.5m-long rod with a thermal expansion coefficient of α ~ 10-5 K-1 is heated
+from room temperature (~293K) to the boiling temperature for water (~373K).
+How much extra length does the rod have after heating?
-and Technology
+2
-Gordon Hengst, Department of Defense
+(A) 4x10-6 m
+(B) 4x10-4 m
+(C) 4x10-2 m
+(D) 4 m
-Gary Matlock, National Oceanic and
+1. ΔL = αL0ΔT
+2. ΔL = (10-5 K-1)(0.5m)(373K - 293K)
+3. ΔL = (10-5 K-1)(0.5m)(80K)
+4. ΔL = 0.0004m = 400μm This is ~4 human hair widths.
-Atmospheric Administration
+A bi-metallic strip is composed of one metal sandwiched together with
+another, so one metal is on top and another metal is on the bottom.
+If the metal on the top half has a smaller thermal expansion coefficient
+than the metal on the bottom half, which picture best represents what
+happens after the bi-metallic strip is heated?
-Terence Lynch, National Oceanic and
+3
-Atmospheric Administration
+(A) 1
+(B) 2
+(C) 3
-Bob McDonald, National Institutes of Health
+1. ΔL = αL0ΔT
+2. The top strip has a
+smaller α and so it
+will expand less than the
+bottom strip.
-Angela Hadley, Environmental Protection
+3. To achieve the extra
+length on the bottom,
+without lengthening the
+top-half by the same
+amount, the strip is
+forced to bend upwards.
-Agency
+Leonard G.
-Kartik Sheth, National Aeronautics and Space
+This is how some of the
+older spring-based
+thermostats work.
+Temperature changes cause
+the spring to bend,
+ultimately completing a
+circuit to turn on/off the
+heat/AC.
-Administration
+Heat
-Scott Miller, Smithsonian Institution
+ Sect 14.1
-Alexander Kurien, General Services
+• Heat is thermal energy that flows from a high-
-Administration
+temperature object to a low-temperature object.
-Paul Strang, Department of Homeland
+• Heat depends on parameters of a process.
-Security
+These are so-called “state variables”
+– Internal energy (U) of the objects,
-Joon Park, Department of Agriculture
+i.e. the kinetic energy of atoms/molecules inside
-Mike Villarreal, Department of Agriculture
+– Temperature (T) of the objects
-Geoff Plumlee, U.S. Geological Survey
+• Your body radiates heat to the surrounding
-Dan Hayba, U.S. Geological Survey
+environment as light.
+• We see that light in the
+infrared wavelengths.
-Esha Mathew, State Department
+Which of these processes will require the most thermal energy?
-– iii –
+6
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
+(A) Raising 1kg of water by 10K
-Acknowledgements
+(B) Raising 2kg of water by 10K
-OSTP and the NSTC thank the members of the Writing Team for their time, expertise, and significant
-contributions to the report: Michelle Buchanan, Shelby Walker, Skip Vaughn, Gordon Hengst, Mariam
-Elsayed, Aliya Iftikhar, and Cole Donovan. OSTP and the NSTC also thank the Oak Ridge National
-Laboratory science writing team—Betsy Sonewald, Holly Haun, Marissa Mills, and Jackie Kerr—for their
-efforts in shaping and finalizing the report, and the Institute for Defense Analysis, Science and
-Technology Policy Institute team—Walter Valdivia, Gifford Wong, Kush Patel, Skandan Ananthasekar,
-and Matthew Diasio—for their literature review and contributions.
+(C) Raising 2kg of water by 20K
-– 1 –
+(D) All the same
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
+1. More heat will be required to create a larger temperature change.
+2. The more material you have to heat-up, the more energy it will take.
-Table of Contents
+Heat: Heat-energy required to change an object’s temperature
-Executive Summary ........................................................................................................... 4
+• More heat is required to raise the temperature of a larger object.
+• More heat is required to induce a larger temperature change.
+• The exact amount of heat will depend on properties of the material.
-Introduction ...................................................................................................................... 7
+– These are described the the “specific heat capacity”, c
+– c is the amount of energy required to raise the temperature of a given
-Status and Outlook for U.S. Federal Research and Development Infrastructure ....................... 10
+mass of a particular material by a certain temperature change
-Aging and Inadequate Research Infrastructure .................................................................................... 11
+– The SI unit of c is: J/(kg*K)
+– Typical values of c are ~100J/(kg*K)
-Cascading Impacts from Substandard Facilities .................................................................................. 15
+Aluminum is 10X higher than this
+(which is atypically large for a solid).
+Meaning it is hard to heat-up.
+Though, liquid water is even higher.
-Widening Gaps in Global S&T Outcomes ............................................................................................... 18
+• In a formula:
-Challenges in Recruiting and Retaining Top Scientific and Engineering Talent .................................. 20
+ Q=c*m*ΔT
-Opportunities ................................................................................................................... 22
+• If the temperature of an object decreases,
+it will release heat into an environment
-Strategic Planning .................................................................................................................................. 23
+• This does not describe phase changes (e.g. liquid water to solid ice)
-Identification of Gaps ............................................................................................................................. 23
+You want to heat a 1kg block of aluminum and 0.5kg of water by 20K.
+Which of these processes will require the most thermal energy?
-Benchmarking International RDI and Identifying Collaborations ........................................................ 24
+7
-Sharing RDI Strategies ........................................................................................................................... 24
+(A) the aluminum block
-Maintaining Strong and Integrated RDI Planning and Coordination ................................................... 25
+(B) the water
-Ensuring RDIs Support a Flexible and Agile R&D Enterprise ................................................................. 25
+(C) both the same amount of heat
-Advancing RDI Capabilities to Support the Convergence of Disciplines and Sectors ......................... 26
+1. Q= mcΔT
+2. Qal= malcalΔT = (1kg)(900J/(kgK))(20K) = 18,000J
+3. Qwater= mwatercwaterΔT = (0.5kg)(4000J/(kgK))(20K) = 40,000J
+4. The water will require more heat.
-Balancing RDI Openness with Security Needs ...................................................................................... 26
+caluminum ≈ 900 J/(kg*K)
+cwater ≈ 4,000 J/(kg*K)
-Conclusion ....................................................................................................................... 26
+Calorimetry: Measuring heat-energy transfer via temperature changes
-– 1 –
+• Suppose I want to measure how much heat-energy a chemical reaction
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
+dumps into a fluid. How do I do it?
-Abbreviations and Acronyms
+• By measuring the temperature before and after the reaction, we get ΔT.
+• If we measure the mass of our fluid and know the specific heat,
-AI
+then the heat energy is given by Q= mcΔT
-Artificial Intelligence
+• The energy “lost” by the chemical reaction is gained by the surrounding
-ALMA
+environment:
-Atacama Large Millimeter-Submillimeter Array
+ Qlost = Qgained
-AOML
+• A key detail is that the stuff you care about (the system),
+e.g. the chemical reaction stuff + the water in this picture,
+must be thermally isolated from the surrounding environment
+(here by coffee cups)
-NOAA Atlantic Oceanographic and Meteorological Laboratory
+ Sect 14.2
-ARS
+Two liters of water at 353K is added to 1.5-liters of water at 293K.
+No energy is lost to the surroundings.
+What is the final equilibrium temperature of the water?
+Note, 1liter of water has a mass of 1kg.
-Agricultural Research Service
+8
-CERN
+(A) 293 K
-European Organization for Nuclear Research
+(B) 323K
-DoD
+(C) 327K
-DOE
+(D) 353 K
-Department of Defense
+1. Qlost = Qgained
+2. (mcΔT)2liters = (mcΔT)1.5liters
+3. (2kg)(353K - Tfinal) = (1.5kg)(Tfinal - 293K)
+4. 706kg*K - (2kg)Tfinal = (1.5kg)Tfinal - 439.5kg*K
+5. 1,145.5kg*K = (3.5kg)Tfinal
+6. Tfinal = (1,145.5kg*K)(3.5kg) ≈ 327K
-Department of Energy
+cwater ≈ 4,000 J/(kg*K)
-ECMWF European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasting
+You have two beakers of water, each with 1kg of water (c=4186J/(kgK)) at 293K.
+You drop one 353K block of 1kg of metal into each beaker, but one block is made
+of aluminum (c= 900J/(kgK)) and the other is made of copper (c= 386J/(kgK)).
+Once each beaker reaches thermal equilibrium with the block, which beaker of
+water has a higher temperature?
-EIC
+9
-EOP
+(A) beaker with aluminum
-EPA
+(B) beaker with copper
-Electron-Ion Collider
+(C) both reach same equilibrium temperature
-Executive Office of the President
+cwater ≈ 4,000 J/(kg*K)
-Environmental Protection Agency
+1. Aluminum has a larger specific heat capacity than copper.
+2. This means it takes more energy to change the temperature of aluminum.
+3. It also means that more energy is deposited by a change in temperature of the
-FAST
+aluminum block, relative to copper.
-Five-hundred-meter Aperture Spherical radio Telescope
+Math answer:
+1. Qlost = Qgained
+2. (mcΔT)block = (mcΔT)water
+3. mblockcblock(Tblock - Tfinal) = mwatercwater(Tfinal - Twater)
+4. mblockcblockTblock - mblockcblockTfinal = mwatercwaterTfinal - mwatercwaterTwater
+5. mblockcblockTblock - mwatercwaterTwater = (mwatercwater + mblockcblock)Tfinal
+6. Tfinal = (mblockcblockTblock - mwatercwaterTwater)/(mwatercwater + mblockcblock)
-FY
+Thermal Energy Storage
-fiscal year
+• Large objects can be used as energy reservoirs
-FFRDCs
+by storing energy as heat.
-federally funded R&D centers
+• Excess energy can be stored as heat to be
+released later, or to smooth-out the power
+distribution from a different energy source.
+• E.g. store extra solar energy from the day or
+wind energy from a windy day to use later
+during the night.
-NIST
+• The earth itself is a large hot object
-National Institutes of Standards and Technology
+(where the heat comes from radioactive decays
+inside the earth’s core).
+This heat forms the basis of geothermal energy.
-IT
+A 1kg block of aluminum (c=900J/(kgK)) has an initial temperature of 300K.
+The block is placed over an electric heater which provides 150W of power
+for 300 seconds.
+After this heating episode, what is the temperature of the aluminum block?
-information technology
+10
-JWST
+(A) 50K
-James Webb Space Telescope
+(B) 300K
-LBNF
+(C) 350K
-Long Baseline Neutrino Facility
+(D) 450K
-NAIRR National AI Research Resource
+1. Q = mcΔT
+2. ΔT = Q/mc
+3. Q = P*t = 150W*300s = 45,000J
+4. ΔT = (45,000J)/(1kg*900J/(kgK)) = 50K
+5. Tfinal = Tinitial + ΔT = 300K + 50K = 350K.
-NASA
+1W = 1J/s
-National Aeronautics and Space Administration
+Phases: Definitions
-NASEM National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine
+• Solid: Stays the same shape
+• Liquid: Takes the shape of the container*, but preserves volume
+• Gas: Fills the volume of the container
-NIH
+*To be clear,
+cats are not liquids
-National Institutes of Health
+Phase Changes
-NIST
+• Latent heat describes the amount of energy that needs to be absorbed to change phases
-National Institute for Standards and Technology
+or the amount of energy that is released upon a phase transition
+due to breaking/forming molecular bonds
-NMNH
+• Energy must be absorbed (“endothermic”) for solid->liquid or liquid->gas
+• Energy is released (“exothermic”) for gas->liquid or liquid->solid
+• Latent Heat of Fusion, LFusion: solid ↔ liquid
+• Latent heat of Vaporization, LVaporization: liquid ↔ gas
-Smithsonian National Museum of Natural History
+Latent Heat
-NOAA
+• Latent heat adds/removes heat during a phase transition:
+• Following the heat added to bring water from ice to water-vapor:
+𝑄𝑄 = 𝑚𝑚𝑚𝑚
+Water:
+Lfusion = 33.5x104 J/kg
+Lvapor = 22.6x105 J/kg
+cice = 2090 J/kg ºC
+csteam = 2010 J/kg ºC
+cwater = 4186 J/kg ºC
-National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration
+QA QB QC
-NSF
+QD
-National Science Foundation
+QE
-NSTC
+QA=mciceΔT
+QB=mLfusion
+QC=mcwaterΔT
+QD=mLvaporization
+QE=mcsteamΔT
-National Science and Technology Council
+How much energy is required to melt 0.5kg of ice?
-OSTP
+1
-Office of Science and Technology Policy
+(A) 1045 J
-PRC
+(B) 2090 J
-R&D
+(C) 2093 J
-RDI
+(D) 16.7x104 J
-People’s Republic of China
+1. This is a phase transition: use Q=mL
+Ice to liquid transition: Lfusion = 33.5x104 J/kg
+2.
+3. Q=(0.5kg)*(33.533.5x104 J/kg) = 16.7x104 J
-research and development
+Calorimetry
-research and development infrastructure
+• Qlost-from-hot-object = Qgained-by-cold-object
+• T is positive in this definition; i.e. subtract
+the higher temperature from the lower one
-RDT&E
+• The calorimeter is a classic tool to take
-research, development, test, and evaluation
+advantage of this
-SC
+• For the example on the right,
-DOE Office of Science
+mwatercwaterΔTwater + mcupccupTcup =
+mobjectcobjectTobject
-– 2 –
+Consider 1kg of material A (Blue) and material B (Green).
+Which requires the most energy to change from the liquid to the
+gas phase?
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
+2
-S&T
+(A) A (B) B (C) They require the same amount
-science and technology
+A longer horizontal stretch
+corresponds to more added heat
+to achieve a phase transition
-STEM
+C
-science, technology, engineering, and math
+º
-USDA
+p
+m
+e
+T
-U.S. Department of Agriculture
+B
-– 3 –
+A
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
+gas
-Executive Summary
+liquid
-President Biden is delivering an "Infrastructure Decade" that will unlock access to economic
-opportunity, create good paying jobs, boost domestic manufacturing, and grow America's economy
-from the middle out and bottom up. As the President has said, “To have the best economy in the
-world…you have to have the best infrastructure in the world.” That starts with investing in America and
-building on our leadership in American research and development (R&D).
+Solid
-The America Creating Opportunities to Meaningfully Promote Excellence in Technology, Education, and
-Science (COMPETES) Act of 2007 (“the Act”) requires that the National Science and Technology Council
-(NSTC) produce an annual report “identifying and prioritizing the deficiencies in research facilities and
-major instrumentation located at federal laboratories and national user facilities at academic
-institutions that are widely accessible for use by researchers in the United States.”1
+Heat
-This report focuses on the Act’s charge to address the growing deficiencies at federal and national
-laboratories. This report provides an overview of those deficiencies and (short of additional
-appropriations) makes suggestions about practices that could be more widely adopted throughout
-government agencies. The report builds on the 2021 National Strategic Overview for Research and
-Development Infrastructure,2 which provided a broad overview of the management and policy tools
-used in the development and management of federal research and development infrastructure (RDI).
+A 500g aluminum cylinder at T=20C is heated using steam at T=140C.
+What is the minimum mass of the steam required to raise the
+temperature of the aluminum cylinder by 40C?
-In spite of the challenges facing the federal RDI ecosystem, since the last report was written there have
-been several major developments in U.S. research and development infrastructure. For example, on
-December 25, 2021, the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) launched and has sent back unparalleled
-insight into exoplanets, the origins of our universe, and more. The National Ignition Facility announced
-that on December 5, 2022, it achieved fusion ignition for the first time. Major construction projects like
-the Electron-Ion Collider (EIC) and Long Baseline Neutrino Facility (LBNF) have hit critical milestones
-and announced significant international partnerships. On the planning and competition front, both the
-Department of Energy (DOE) and Department of State have engaged in global surveys of international
-RDI capabilities to help inform our future competitive landscape, and the DOE advisory committees are
-undertaking a broad-based prioritization effort to identify critical capabilities through the next
-decades. Significant progress has been made through community planning processes in all fields
-relevant to research and development infrastructure (RDI), supported by our federal advisory
-committees and the decadal planning processes undertaken by the National Academies of Sciences,
-Engineering, and Medicine (NASEM).
+3
-This report identifies four trends that can be found across federal research agencies. They are as
-follows:
+(A) 7mg
-• Aging and Inadequate Research Infrastructure
+(B) 0.7kg
-• Cascading Impacts from Substandard Facilities
+(C) 7kg
-1 America COMPETES Act of 2007. Public Law 10-69, Section 1007. https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/PLAW-
+(D) 70kg
-110publ69
+1. Qgained = Qlost
+2. Heat Gained by Aluminum = Heat Lost by the Steam (1. Cooling, 2. Condensing, 3. Water Cooling)
+3. mAlcAl(ΔT)Al = msteamcsteam(ΔT)steam + msteamLvaporization + mwatercwater(ΔT)water
+4. msteam = mwater (note csteam ≠ cwater)
+5. mAlcAl(ΔT)Al = msteam[csteam(ΔT)steam + Lvaporization + cwater(ΔT)water]
+6. msteam = mAlcAl(ΔT)Al /[csteam(ΔT)steam + Lvaporization + cwater(ΔT)water]
+7. msteam = [(0.5kg)(900J/kgC)(60C-20C)]/[2010J/kgC(140C-100C) +
-2 “National Strategic Overview for Research and Development Infrastructure” October 2021.
+2.2x106J/kg+ 4186J/kgC(100C-60C)]
-https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/NSTC-NSO-RDI-_REV_FINAL-10-2021.pdf
+8. msteam = 7.18x10-3kg ≈ 7mg
-– 4 –
+Aluminum:
+cAl = 900 J/kg*C
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
+Water:
+Lfusion = 33.5x104 J/kg
+Lvapor = 22.6x105 J/kg
+cice = 2090 J/kg ºC
+csteam = 2010 J/kg ºC
+cwater = 4186 J/kg ºC
-• Widening Gaps in Global Science and Technology (S&T) Outcomes
+A slug of copper (0.2kg) at 800C is immersed in 0.4kg of water at 80C.
+The final temp is 100C. Part of the water boiled off as steam.
+What was the mass of the water converted to steam?
-• Challenges in Recruiting and Retaining Top Scientific and Engineering Talent
+4
-To address these, the report identifies four areas that agencies can currently use within their existing
-budgets and legal authorities to help address these deficiencies:
+(A) 7mg
-• Strategic Planning
+(B) 8mg
-o Agencies should develop processes to communicate the need for RDI investments to
-budget planners, Congress, and other stakeholders, and include the potential impact if
-such investments in R&D infrastructure are not realized. Specific and measurable
-impacts to mission execution are more persuasive than general impacts that are
-difficult to attribute.
+(C) 9mg
-o The need for RDI investments should be documented with thorough assessments of
-facilities’ maintenance and modernization needs, including both costs and well-
-defined prioritizations developed by each agency, and these assessments should be
-updated regularly.
+(D) 10mg
-•
+1. Qgained = Qlost
+2. Heat lost by copper= Warms-up water + Converts some water to steam
+3.mCucCu(ΔT)Cu = mwatercwater(ΔT)water + msteamLvaporization
+4.msteam = [(mCucCu(ΔT)Cu) - (mwatercwater(ΔT)water)]/Lvaporization
+5.msteam = [(0.2kg)(387J/kgC)(800C-100C) - (0.4kg)(4186J/kgC)(100C-
-Identification of Gaps
+80C)]/(2.26x106J/kg)
-o Agencies should utilize decadal surveys, workshops, and other community planning
-efforts to identify and prioritize the long-term federal RDI needs of the U.S. research
-community, including elements that must be maintained to support U.S. researchers in
-academe, industry, and government.
+6.msteam = 9.16 x10-3 kg ≈ 9mg … which is 9mL of liquid water
-o Agencies should remain cognizant of the ways in which facility closures may result in
-U.S. dependence on international facilities and weigh the consequences if those
-capabilities are no longer possessed by the United States or its allies.
+Copper:
+cCu = 387 J/kg*C
-• Benchmarking International RDI and Identifying Collaborations
+Water:
+Lfusion = 33.5x104 J/kg
+Lvapor = 22.6x105 J/kg
+cice = 2090 J/kg ºC
+csteam = 2010 J/kg ºC
+cwater = 4186 J/kg ºC
-o Agencies should regularly assess the competitive position of U.S. capabilities in their
-respective mission areas through benchmarking activities, such as those conducted by
-DOE’s Office of Science (SC) federal advisory committees, the State Department’s
-survey of international facilities, and through the decadal survey process.
+It takes 10 minutes for your stove burner to bring 2 quarts of water
+(~1.9kg) to boiling (100C) from room temperature (20C).
+What is the minimum power output of your stove burner?
+(I.e. assume 100% efficiency of heat transfer)
-o To facilitate collaborations, agencies should pursue existing mechanisms (e.g., the
-Florence Agreement Program3 and S&T agreements) and identify new ways to facilitate
-both national and international cooperative activities, as well as reduce barriers for in-
-kind contributions, materials exchange, contract and intellectual property terms, and
-technologies importation.
+8
-• Sharing RDI Strategies
+(A) 1060 W (B) 600 W (C) 4186 W (D) 640,000 W
-o The NSTC Subcommittee on Research and Development Infrastructure will coordinate
-an interagency working group focused on ensuring the competitive position of U.S. RDI,
-with activities to include sharing information on long-term strategic planning efforts,
+1. Power = Energy/Time
+2. Energy = Heat = Q = mwatercwaterΔT = (1.9kg)(4186J/kgC)(100C-20C) = 636,272J
+3. Time = 10min=600s
+4. Power= (636,272J)/(600s) = 1060 J/s = 1060 W
-3 Statutory Import Programs,” (International Trade Administration, n.d.). www.trade.gov/statutory-import-
+Water:
+Lfusion = 33.5x104 J/kg
+Lvapor = 22.6x105 J/kg
+cice = 2090 J/kgC
+csteam = 2010 J/kgC
+cwater = 4186 J/kgC
+ρwater = 1000kg/m3
-programs
+You will NOT be asked about the material below on
+any homework or exam. Therefore you CAN IGNORE
+IT, if you like.
-– 5 –
+We had to trim the following from this year’s course content due to the pandemic.
+However, I think some of you may be curious.
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
+A washer is made of some metal with some thermal coefficient of linear
+expansion, α.
+If the washer is heated, what happens to R1 and R2?
-identifying gaps in capabilities, and facilitating opportunities for national and
-international collaborations in facilities.
+(A) R1 decreases, R2 increases
-Being a science superpower carries the burden of supporting and maintaining the advanced underlying
-infrastructure that supports the research and development enterprise. Congressional appropriations
-have not kept pace with maintenance needs across multiple administrations, resulting in multibillion
-dollar maintenance backlogs across multiple government agencies, forcing government managers into
-a position where they must choose between executing science missions or maintaining their facilities.
+(B) R1 increases, R2 increases
-These challenges come at a time when the People’s Republic of China (PRC) and other parts of the world
-are able to provide newer, state-of-the-art facilities offering improved access that attracts U.S. and
-other international researchers.4 Without action to remedy the situation, deferred maintenance will
-only increase in both cost and impact to the U.S. taxpayer and to many of the nation’s critical S&T
-programs.
+(C) R1 increases, R2 decreases
-Finally, to support the continued development of a robust federal RDI ecosystem, agencies should
-continue to support the opportunities mentioned in the 2021 National Strategic Overview:5
+(D) R1 decreases, R2 decreases
-• Maintaining Strong and Integrated RDI Planning and Coordination
+1. ΔL = αL0ΔT
+2. This means all linear dimensions increase.
+3. The radii are linear dimensions, so both will increase.
-• Ensuring RDIs Support a Flexible and Agile R&D Enterprise
+For instance, consider what would
+happen if our washer were made-
+up of separate square components.
+All sides would lengthen and “R1”
+and “R2” would both increase.
-• Advancing RDI Capabilities to Support the Convergence of Disciplines and Sectors
+Thermal Expansion of Solids: Volume expansion
-• Balancing RDI Openness with Security Needs
+• Sometimes we want to consider how the volume of an object changes
-4 “Can the U.S. Compete in Basic Energy Sciences? Critical Research Frontiers and Strategies” (A report by the
+when we heat it. This is the volume expansion
-BESAC Subcommittee on International Benchmarking, 2021), 3. https://science.osti.gov/-
-/media/bes/pdf/reports/2021/International_Benchmarking-Report.pdf
+• Volume expansion: ΔV = βV0ΔT
+• The fractional change in volume is: ΔV/V0 = βΔT
+• β is the coefficient of volume expansion (SI units: K-1)
-5 “National Strategic Overview for Research and Development Infrastructure” October 2021, vi.
+– For solids: β≈3α
+– For liquids: More complicated, so look-up in table
-https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/NSTC-NSO-RDI-_REV_FINAL-10-2021.pdf
+Most materials expand in volume when
+they heat-up. However, water doesn’t.
-– 6 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-Introduction
-
-“The race for technological dominance is
-inextricably intertwined with evolving
-geopolitics and is increasingly shaped by
-broader political, economic, and societal
-rivalries, particularly those associated with
-the PRC’s rise.
-
-The United States has a rich history of investing
-heavily in its S&T enterprise, its S&T workforce, as
-well as RDI, including laboratories, specialized
-facilities, and equipment. A focus on S&T expanded
-during the 1950s as the Cold War escalated. Under
-the GI Benefits Bill, thousands of returning veterans
-were trained as scientists and engineers to establish
-the nation’s leadership in S&T, and this growth
-continued as the generation of baby boomers, who
-grew up during the Sputnik era, pursued careers in
-S&T. During the 1950s and 1960s, the federal
-government greatly expanded research programs
-across multiple agencies to catalyze growth in
-research and development (R&D). Concurrently, the
-U.S. government invested millions of dollars in
-to
-building
-accommodate the nation’s growing R&D enterprise.
-These facilities, constructed at federal agencies and
-federally funded R&D centers (FFRDCs), included
-new laboratory buildings and specialized facilities
-and equipment, such as accelerators, ground- and
-space-based telescopes, reactors, and X-ray sources, to study fundamental and applied science. This
-investment helped build the nation’s research and development infrastructure (RDI), which is defined
-as the “facilities or systems used by scientific and technical communities to conduct R&D or foster
-innovation.”6
-
-Amassing the resources to sustain broad
-technology leadership, including the
-concentration of human talent,
-foundational knowledge, and supply
-chains, requires decades of long-term
-investment and visionary leadership. Those
-focusing their resources today are likely to
-be the technology leaders of 2040.”
+*Note the change in density is tiny, so we
+can usually get away with ignoring it,
+until the phase-transition to ice happens.
-“Global Trends 2040: A More Contested World,”
-National Intelligence Council, 2021, 56.
-http://www.dni.gov/files/ODNI/documents/assessm
-
-laboratories and other
-
-ents/GlobalTrends_2040.pdf
-
-facilities
-
-These substantial investments propelled the United States to global science leadership and led to
-technology breakthroughs that served as a foundation for the nation’s economic growth and national
-security. Even under the Congressionally-authorized levels in the CHIPS and Science Act of 2022,
-Federal RDI construction and maintenance has not seen the same level of prioritization as in prior
-decades. One result has been an aging of the infrastructure at federal research laboratories and
-facilities that is reducing scientific output and, in some cases, impacting the ability of departments and
-agencies to meet their mission needs.
-
-The existing federal scientific infrastructure served the nation well in the 20th century, enabling the
-United States to become a global leader in scientific discovery, talent development, and innovation.
-Having reached that pinnacle, however, many U.S. scientists and engineers are now faced with
-conducting 21st century R&D in many facilities designed in the 1950s that cannot support modern
-research and current laboratory practices in health and safety. Many do not have sufficient, clean,
-reliable, and secure electrical power necessary to support today’s instrumentation and high-
-performance computers. Some also lack modern information technology (IT) capabilities needed to
-
-6 “National Strategic Overview for Research and Development Infrastructure,” Subcommittee on Research and
-
-Development Infrastructure of the National Science and Technology Council, October 2021, iii.
-www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/NSTC-NSO-RDI-_REV_FINAL-10-2021.pdf
-
-– 7 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-protect against data loss and cyberattacks (assuming such networking capabilities are even present).
-Older HVAC systems are inefficient and costly to operate, and buildings were not designed to allow the
-strict environmental controls needed for today’s laboratory operations. In many cases, infrastructure
-has reached end-of-life for systems that manage water and sewage, steam and chilled water
-distribution, and electrical networks.
-
-Departments and agencies have reported that the average age of their facilities exceeds the 40- to 50-
-year design life of most facilities, with half rated to be in poor or critical condition. Because these
-facilities are operating well beyond their expected lifetimes, the risk of failures is high. The risk is further
-compounded by aging water, steam, gas, electrical, and other types of distribution systems that are
-often inefficient, difficult to repair, and do not meet modern safety codes. Failing infrastructure is
-causing interruptions in research activities lasting weeks or months and has resulted in significant
-setbacks due to lost work time, loss of samples, and damaged equipment, as well as increased costs to
-research programs. Another critical issue facing federal RDI is that facilities built in the mid-20th century
-generally cannot support the needs of modern research, which requires clean, reliable electrical power,
-strictly controlled environments, robust internet networks, and integrated cybersecurity infrastructure,
-among other requirements not found in older facilities. Further, investments in new scientific user
-facilities are needed to provide U.S. researchers with world-leading capabilities. Without RDI designed
-for advancing critical and emerging technologies, such as quantum information S&T, engineering
-materials, biotechnologies, sensors, and microelectronics, U.S. leadership in these areas will be
-seriously and adversely impacted.
-
-The challenges that the U.S. RDI enterprise is experiencing are not new and reflect decades of
-inadequate funding due to deprioritizing maintenance at existing facilities, development of new
-facilities, and decommissioning of outdated facilities. Further, these challenges are occurring
-simultaneously with intensified S&T competition with other nations. This is especially true of the PRC,
-which is vying to become the preferred partner on large RDI projects for other nations. For instance, the
-PRC has invested in new RDI outside of its borders, building supercomputers,7 earth observing satellite
-constellations,8 telescopes,9 and even biosafety labs10 in Africa and South America. In 2022, PRC
-President Xi Jinping committed to increase the number of international laboratories built in countries
-participating in the Belt and Road Initiative to 100 over five years.11 As the PRC develops such novel
-capabilities, the pressure for U.S. scientists to seek partnerships in order to utilize those capabilities in
-order to say at the top of their fields correspondingly increases.
-
-7 High speed computer donated to Tunisia's scientific research field. China Global Television Network, retrieved
-
-from YouTube, June 25, 2019. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VzLJ8qi_XGk
-
-8 Special Report: China’s Space Collaboration with Africa: Implications and Recommendations for the United
-
-States. U.S. Institute of Peace, September 2023. https://www.usip.org/sites/default/files/2023-09/sr-
-524_china-space-collaboration-africa-implications-recommendations-for-us.pdf
-
-9 South America is embracing Beijing’s science silk road. Nature, May 8, 2019.
-
-https://www.nature.com/immersive/d41586-019-01127-4/index.html
-
-10 Africa CDC and China CDC Commit to Deepen their Cooperation. Africa Centres for Disease Control and
-
-Prevention. https://africacdc.org/news-item/africa-cdc-and-china-cdc-commit-to-deepen-their-cooperation/
-
-11 China’s Belt and Road Initiative is boosting science — the West must engage, not withdraw. Nature, October
-
-24, 2023. https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-023-03299-6
-
-– 8 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-Some international facilities possess certain advantages due to their structuring as international
-organizations or state-supported commercial enterprises with stable, multiyear funding. Europe, in
-particular, has substantial experience leveraging investments from multiple countries through
-organizations like the European Organization for Nuclear Research (CERN), the European Southern
-Observatory, and the European Clinical Research Infrastructure Network. While many of these facilities,
-like CERN, provide open research platforms that mirror the U.S. model of facility access based on merit,
-other international facilities either require membership in an international treaty or fee-based access
-for outsiders. Others, like the European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasting (ECMWF) and
-COSMO-SkyMed satellite constellation charge for access to products and services. This has direct
-consequences for broad U.S. access to and utilization of significant RDI capabilities. The challenges
-associated with U.S. participation in such facilities (to include limitations due to the appropriations
-process and Anti-Deficiency Act) often means that the United States does not have a seat at the table
-when setting the rules for international RDI governance, providing an opening for competitors like the
-PRC and Russia to have greater say in the governance of platforms that may require the development
-of novel or dual-use technology.
-
-In addition to buildings and facilities, other capabilities factor into the way the United States conducts
-research. High-performance computers, combined with new modeling and data analysis techniques,
-such as artificial intelligence and machine learning, allow large sets of diverse data to be assimilated,
-analyzed, and modeled, accelerating the pace of discovery and development. For example,
-computational tools can be used in conjunction with multiple types of structural data combined with
-measured material properties to yield insight into the relationship of a material’s structure with its
-properties. Such an approach would expedite the discovery of new materials critical to emerging
-technologies, including electronics, quantum materials, and engineering materials. Similarly, data from
-infrastructure distributed across the nation, such as multiple types of air, water, and soil monitors and
-satellite data, could be rapidly analyzed and modeled to provide more complete and timely
-assessments of ecosystems.
-
-While the United States continues to lead the world in many fields of S&T at present, urgent efforts must
-be made to ensure that federal RDI is ready to serve the nation’s research community in the future.
-Numerous efforts to develop world-leading R&D capabilities have been deployed or are underway.
-These include the successful commissioning and deployment of JWST12 and major R&D facilities
-construction projects like the EIC13 and LBNF hitting critical milestones14 and announcing international
-partnerships. Designed to facilitate a shared national research infrastructure for responsible artificial
-intelligence (AI) discovery and innovation for the broad research and education community, the
-National AI Research Resource (NAIRR) launched its pilot on January 24, 2024, with 10 government
-
-12 “NASA’s Webb Telescope Is Now Fully Ready for Science.” (NASA. July 11, 2022).
-
-https://blogs.nasa.gov/webb/2022/07/11/nasas-webb-telescope-is-now-fully-ready-for-science/
-
-13 “Electron-Ion Collider Set to Begin Long-Lead Procurements.” (Brookhaven National Laboratory, April 2, 2024).
-
-https://www.bnl.gov/newsroom/news.php?a=121812
-
-14 “Excavation of colossal caverns for Fermilab’s DUNE experiment completed.” (Fermi National Accelerator
-
-Laboratory. February 9, 2024). https://news.fnal.gov/2024/02/excavation-of-colossal-caverns-for-fermilabs-
-dune-experiment-completed/
-
-– 9 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
+You fill-up your 12-gallon fuel tank in your sedan up to the brim and
+forget to put on your gas cap. Your friend makes the same mistake after
+filling-up the 18-gallon fuel tank in her truck to the brim.
+It gets really hot outside and the gasoline heats-up.
+Who loses the most gas?
-agency partners and 25 nongovernment partners.15 DOE/SC’s federal advisory committees have
-released international benchmarking studies comparing RDI capabilities of the United States with
-those in other parts of the world. The Department of State conducted a survey assessing planned RDI
-capabilities issued to all diplomatic and consular posts.
+5
-Major prioritization and assessment efforts, such as the 2023 Particle Physics Projects Prioritization
-Panel report16 have been released. Agencies continue to actively commission RDI prioritization
-exercises from their relevant federal advisory committees and through the decadal survey process,
-where agencies seek community input via NASEM. Within the context of the RDI subcommittee, the
-Interagency Working Group on Scientific Collections on November 29, 2023 released the “The Unique
-Role of Federal Scientific Collections,” assessing the varied ways that federal scientific collections have
-served the nation in diverse areas of American life.17 Historically, these activities have focused primarily
-on addressing the immediate scientific needs of the community; additional effort could be given to
-assessing and enhancing the competitive position of the United States.
+(A) You do
-To sustain world S&T leadership, the United States must continue to make strategic investments to
-maintain and renew federal facilities and supporting infrastructure, as well as phase out and
-decommission federal RDI that is no longer needed. These critical investments in new, modern facilities
-will underpin S&T innovation well into the future. These investments are also vital for training the next
-generation of U.S. scientists and engineers who will conduct research, develop new technical
-innovations, and manufacture new products. The challenge is to maintain a consistent and intentional
-revitalization of the U.S. RDI while balancing competing needs and ensuring well-coordinated
-prioritization decisions.
+(B) Your friend does
-Status and Outlook for U.S. Federal Research and Development Infrastructure
+(C) You both lose the same amount
-The Act requires that the National Science and Technology Council produce an annual report
-“identifying and prioritizing the deficiencies in research facilities and major instrumentation located at
-federal laboratories and national user facilities at academic institutions that are widely accessible for
-use by researchers in the United States.” This report answers that requirement.
-
-Four issues put the future success of the nation’s R&D enterprise at risk: Aging and Inadequate Research
-Infrastructure, Cascading Impacts from Substandard Facilities, Widening Gaps in Global S&T Outcomes,
-and Challenges in Recruiting and Retaining Top Scientific and Engineering Talent. Together, these
-issues present a serious threat to the country’s continued scientific innovation, output, and global
-leadership in S&T. Understanding the context and consequence of these issues can shape action plans
-for revitalizing the nation’s RDI.
-
-15 “Democratizing the future of AI R&D: NSF to launch National AI Research Resource pilot.” (National Science
-
-Foundation, January 24, 2024). https://new.nsf.gov/news/democratizing-future-ai-rd-nsf-launch-national-ai
-
-16 “Exploring Our Quantum Universe.” (Report of the 2023 Particle Physics Project Prioritization Panel,
-
-December, 2023). https://www.usparticlephysics.org/2023-p5-report/assets/pdf/P5Report2023_121023-
-DRAFT_single-pages.pdf
-
-17 “The Unique Role of Federal Scientific Collections: Infrastructure Generating Benefits, Serving Diverse Agency
-
-Missions” (A report of the Interagency Working Group on Scientific Collections).
-https://smithsonian.figshare.com/articles/book/The_Unique_Role_of_Federal_Scientific_Collections_Infrastr
-ucture_Generating_Benefits_Serving_Diverse_Agency_Missions/24559996/1
-
-– 10 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-Aging and Inadequate Research Infrastructure
-
-Outdated and deficient RDI across the federal government is threatening U.S. leadership in R&D and
-impeding technology breakthroughs.
-
-Aging infrastructure in many federal research laboratories and facilities is impacting the ability of
-federal agencies to meet their current missions. Many facilities are rated as being in very poor condition.
-
-• A 2023 survey of Department of Energy (DOE) facilities at its 17 national laboratories showed
-that the average age of these facilities was 46 years, close to the end of the planned 40- to 50-
-year design life. This study further stated that nearly 40 percent of DOE facilities have been rated
-as substandard or inadequate to serve DOE’s mission.18
-
-• A survey of research facilities at the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST)
-showed that 73 percent of facilities are 60 to 70 years old, and over 60 percent of the square
-footage is classified as in “poor to critical condition.”19
-
-• A 2019 report noted, “The buildings and facilities at the National Institutes of Health (NIH)
-Bethesda Campus are in need of significant improvement and upgrading to sustain their current
-mission and ongoing functionality. The 12 million facility square feet have an average Condition
-Index of 83.3, which is considered poor.”20
-
-•
-
-In an annual report to Congress in 2024, the Department of Defense’s (DoD) unfunded research,
-development, test, and evaluation (RDT&E) infrastructure requirements were shown to have
-grown significantly since annual reporting began in 2018, putting the military at risk of losing
-its technological superiority.21
-
-• A 2024 National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) report stated that 75 percent of
-its facilities are beyond their designed lifetime, and as of 2022, had an estimated deferred
-maintenance backlog of $3 billion.22
-
-• The United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) Agricultural Research Service (ARS) has
-approximately 3,000 facilities and structures in its inventory, with an average age of over 48
-years, and a $1.6 billion deferred maintenance backlog.
-
-Failures due to aging RDI can result in costly and significant interruptions in research activities lasting
-weeks or months. For example, failures over a nine-month period that led to inadequate back-up power
-and power conditioning at one NIST research facility cost an estimated $9 million and loss of 47,000
-
-18 Science Laboratories Infrastructure (SLI) Program. science.osti.gov/opm/Science-Laboratories-Infrastructure
-
-19 Technical Assessment of the Capital Facility Needs of the National Institute of Standards and Technology,
-
-National Academies Press eBooks, 2023, 31. https://doi.org/10.17226/26684
-
-20 Managing the NIH Bethesda Campus Capital Assets for Success in a Highly Competitive Global Biomedical
-
-Research Environment, National Academies Press eBooks, 2019. https://doi.org/10.17226/25483
-
-21 U.S. Department of Defense Fiscal Year 2025 Unfunded Requirements for Laboratory Military Construction
-Projects. February 2024. Office of the Under Secretary of Defense for Research and Engineering. Report to
-Congress on Section 2806 of the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2018 (Public Law 115-91).
-
-22 NASA’s FY 2024 Volume of Integrated Performance. www.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/fiscal-year-
-
-2024-volume-of-integrated-perfomance.pdf
-
-– 11 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-researcher hours.23 These failures can be compounded by the need to repair outdated equipment with
-scarce replacement parts as well as a lack of personnel familiar with older components and systems.
-These older systems also lack modern safety and security protection features that are standard in
-equipment purchased and installed today. For example, modern electrical switchgear often
-incorporates optical arc flash reduction systems, and today’s natural gas distribution systems have
-built-in safety features absent in older systems. Moreover, the configurations of old steam, chilled
-water, natural gas, compressed air, sewer, and other types of support systems make it difficult to
-maintain sections of pipe or valves without extended outages. Another looming issue is that older
-buildings do not meet today’s more stringent seismic standards, and the failure of susceptible buildings
-could indefinitely halt research activities. Finally, many of these older buildings are contaminated with
-materials that pose significant environmental and health concerns, including radioactive materials,
-beryllium, asbestos, and lead.
-
-Today’s research is vastly different than that conducted when these buildings were designed in the mid-
-20th century; thus, even well-maintained facilities do not meet the requirements of modern research.
-First, older buildings were designed with laboratories that accommodate a lead investigator and a few
-support staff, whereas today’s science is most often conducted by larger, collaborative teams of
-investigators who require flexible space that can be readily reconfigured to meet changing research
-directions. Second, research today is governed by robust environmental, health, and safety standards
-that were not in place when these buildings were designed. For example, 50 years ago, nearly all
-experiments were conducted at open laboratory benches, and laboratories included only a limited
-number of ventilation hoods. Today, research standards require hoods for nearly all chemistry,
-molecular biology, materials, and nanoscience experimental procedures. Also, updated fire codes
-restrict the types and quantities of chemicals and gases that can be stored and used in a single fire zone;
-older buildings were designed with a limited number of fire zones, and some have only one designated
-fire zone for an entire building encompassing thousands of square feet. Further, modern research has
-very different demands for utilities and other infrastructure that were not anticipated even a decade
-ago. For example, outdated and inefficient HVAC and electrical systems are incapable of controlling
-temperature and humidity within the exacting requirements of sensitive equipment, such as ultra-fast
-laser systems and microscopes used in materials science and biology studies. Often, this type of
-sensitive equipment also requires specialized environments with low vibration and electromagnetic
-interference.
-
-In addition to these concerns, the cost to maintain aging facilities, even without bringing them up to
-modern standards, continues to grow. For example, in annual DoD reports to Congress on RDT&E
-revitalization, these costs were estimated to be $4.7 billion in 2019, growing to $7.7 billion in 2024.24
-Similarly, a 2019 study commissioned by the NIH and led by NASEM reported that the backlog of
-
-23 Technical Assessment of the Capital Facility Needs of the National Institute of Standards and Technology,
-
-National Academies Press eBooks, 2023, 44. https://doi.org/10.17226/26684
-
-24 Report to Congress on Unfunded Requirements for Laboratory Military Construction Projects. February 2019.
-Office of the Under Secretary of Defense for Research and Engineering. Section 2806 of the National Defense
-Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2018 (Public Law 115-91)
-
-– 12 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-maintenance and repair for NIH’s Bethesda campus was $1.3 billion and growing rapidly.25 At the end
-of fiscal year (FY) 2023, the Bethesda backlog had grown to $3.4 billion and, taking into account all NIH
-sites in Maryland, Montana, and North Carolina, the backlog was reported to be $3.8 billion at the end
-of FY 2023. The NASEM study triggered Congressional interest, which resulted in increases in NIH’s
-Buildings and Facilities appropriation from $200 million in FY 2019 to $350 million in FY 2023. However,
-even at the higher investment amount, the backlog continues to increase.
-
-Construction and renovation of research infrastructure provides the opportunity to incorporate agile,
-efficient, and resilient designs that can adapt to new technologies, new operating standards, new work
-environments, and changing missions. Effective modernization and design will lead to savings in
-energy, cost, and space while improving laboratory functionality and capability (see sidebar “Modern
-Chemical and Materials Science Building”).
-
-A successful renovation of an older building is exemplified by Building 1 on the NIST campus in Boulder,
-CO, a structure that was dedicated by President Eisenhower in the 1950s. After renovation, a wing of
-this building became the new home to quantum information science and technology research,
-supporting experiments that demonstrated quantum entanglement of microresonators, an innovation
-recognized as the Physics World 2021 Breakthrough of the Year. This research could never have been
-accomplished in the original laboratory, which lacked necessary environmental controls for these
-sensitive experiments.26
-
-Some agencies have already taken steps and devised innovative solutions to address inadequate RDI.
-For example, DOE’s Office of Science (SC) instituted the Science Laboratories Infrastructure program,
-which invests over $300 million annually to transform and modernize foundational infrastructure at
-its national laboratories. To facilitate this strategic program, the DOE Laboratory Operations Board,27
-which includes federal and national laboratory representatives, assesses facilities and infrastructure
-across the DOE national laboratory complex. These enterprise-wide assessments result in a rigorous
-and consistent analysis of the condition, utilization, and functionality of the facilities and
-infrastructure that are most critical to accomplishing the mission. Building on these assessments, SC
-works with each of its laboratories to develop comprehensive campus strategies used to establish
-infrastructure priorities.
-
-25 National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. 2019. Managing the NIH Bethesda Campus Capital
-Assets for Success in a Highly Competitive Global Biomedical Research Environment. Washington, DC: The
-National Academies Press. https://doi.org/10.17226/25483
-
-26 Technical Assessment of the Capital Facility Needs of the National Institute of Standards and Technology,
-
-National Academies Press eBooks, 2023, 34, https://doi.org/10.17226/26684.
-
-27 Science Laboratories Infrastructure (SLI) Program. science.osti.gov/opm/Science-Laboratories-Infrastructure
-
-– 13 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-Modern Chemical and Materials Science Building
-
-Chemical and Materials Sciences Building constructed in 2011 at
-Oak Ridge National Laboratory. [Courtesy ORNL]
-
-With more than 300,000 square feet, Building 4500S at DOE’s Oak Ridge National Laboratory was
-built in the 1960s to house dozens of materials science and chemistry laboratories with associated
-offices. As was typical during this era, the labs in this facility were constructed with only one or two
-chemical hoods and a handful of electrical circuits. HVAC systems were designed to condition
-outside air and exhaust it through the chemical hoods, turning over the entire volume of air in the
-building at a rate of 30 times per hour; this made the building exceptionally expensive to operate.
-
-A new Chemical and Materials Sciences Building was constructed in 2011 and received Gold LEED
-certification by employing many energy saving innovations, such as reducing air flow in hoods not
-being actively used. To meet modern research requirements, these laboratories contain up to six
-hoods for use by teams of researchers and many electrical circuits and internet connections to
-accommodate modern laboratory equipment and computers. Compared to the single fire zone in
-the old building, the new building was designed with multiple fire zones and special storage rooms
-on each floor to facilitate high chemical loading and reduce fire hazards caused by storing chemicals
-in the laboratories.
-
-These features allowed lab space to be consolidated with a 30 percent savings in space compared
-to the old facility, while adding new functionalities, such as highly controlled environments required
-for laser spectroscopy and imaging. The labs were also designed to be readily reconfigurable to
-accommodate changing programs, with all benches equipped with wheels and special utility hook-
-ups enabling their easy removal. Importantly, the building was also designed with features that
-support collaborations across disciplines that are critical for today’s scientific enterprise. As a result,
-an influx of both student and staff researchers have joined the research programs of the
-organizations in this modern laboratory building.
-
-Similarly, the DoD has a variety of authorities to assist in the modernization and revitalization of its RDI.
-One of these, 10 U.S.C § 4123, also known as “FLEX-4,” authorizes laboratories to allocate between two
-percent and four percent of their total RDT&E funds toward workforce development, basic research,
-technology transition, and repair of laboratory infrastructure and equipment. DoD laboratories can use
-revitalization and recapitalization projects to adapt facilities and infrastructure to support new
-
-– 14 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-technology missions. Since the inception of the FLEX-4 Program in 2009, DoD laboratories have invested
-more than $4 billion across the four categories, funding improvements not possible otherwise.
-
-Since 2012, USDA ARS has reviewed its laboratory RDI and developed a long-term plan for future capital
-investments, as outlined in “Capital Investment Strategy” (CIS) reports. Since 2013, ARS has adopted
-the U.S. Corps of Engineers BUILDER assessment program28 to conduct assessments and assign a
-condition index to each facility assessed. This index takes into consideration facility age, capacity,
-safety and health issues, security, time since last repair/renovation, new capabilities needed, and
-current and future research priorities. Since 2015, ARS has received funding to modernize 30 projects of
-the 138 outlined in the most recent ARS CIS update.
-
-Many other agencies, such as the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) have developed plans for
-building renovations, but due to the lack of funds are unable to complete needed renovations at many
-of their laboratory sites.
-
-In summary, aging infrastructure can cause research setbacks due to lost work time, loss of samples,
-and damaged equipment, as well as increased costs to research programs. Further, outdated RDI
-impedes research that requires specialized infrastructure for sensitive experiments and equipment to
-advance tomorrow’s technologies. Some agencies have taken steps to address these issues by
-developing processes for prioritizing needs and by funding facility modernization and revitalization;
-however, more fully addressing these needs will require strategic planning across the federal R&D
-enterprise, as well as increased budgetary planning.
-
-Cascading Impacts from Substandard Facilities
-
-Aging and inadequate federal facilities can impact research efforts of government, universities, and
-industry.
-
-Federal laboratories are home to many types of RDI that provide unique capabilities needed to sustain
-the United States as a world leader in S&T. In addition to research facilities that support specific agency
-missions, federal agencies also host specialized facilities that serve the nation. These critically
-important facilities are not found in the private sector or academia due to their high construction and
-maintenance costs, as well as their support of highly specialized equipment. Such equipment includes
-the world’s largest vacuum chamber at NASA Glenn Research Center, radiation measurement and
-calibration laboratories at NIST, DOE’s suite of scientific user facilities, and the National Science
-Foundation’s (NSF) Antarctic research stations (see sidebar “Improving Antarctic Infrastructure”).
-
-Many of the nation’s unique federal research assets are operating well beyond their design lifetimes
-and RDI failures can have a serious impact on the nation’s research enterprise. For example, in the
-summer of 2022, the underground utility distribution system failed on the NIST campus in Gaithersburg,
-MD, along with HVAC systems, resulting in a shutdown that lasted 14 days and impacted nearly all 1,700
-campus laboratories. The effects of this shutdown lasted much longer, compromising NIST’s ability to
-provide measurement standards and support to multiple federal agencies, the private sector, and
-universities. In turn, the research conducted by these customers, who require standards for quantum
-
-28 BUILDER Sustainment Management System. https://www.erdc.usace.army.mil/Media/Fact-Sheets/Fact-
-
-Sheet-Article-View/Article/476728/builder-sustainment-management-system/
-
-– 15 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-science and technology, radiation physics, and other important traceable measurements, were
-significantly delayed.
-
-National laboratories have long documented the broader impact of facilities investments on local
-economies.29 While it is generally acknowledged that certain facilities have developed reputations as
-training grounds for scientists and engineers in specific fields, relatively less attention has been paid to
-the impact of facility degradation, incidents, and changes in facilities’ reputation on local universities,
-business, and other stakeholder communities. Given the importance of RDI to local economies, as well
-as their distribution around the country in diverse communities, greater attention to that relationship
-may be warranted.
-
-Impact of Investment on the U.S. National Collections
-
-Helianthus annuus [Courtesy NMNH]
-
-The United States National Herbarium is one of the world’s largest and most diverse botanical
-collections, accounting for more than 4 million specimens. The Smithsonian National Museum of
-Natural History’s (NMNH) multi-year, approximately 7-million-dollar effort to digitize the herbarium
-resulted in 3.8 million new specimen images, 2.8 million new label transcriptions, and over 80,000
-new taxonomic names added to the data catalog. This provides full access to the collection using
-digital technology and shared online platforms. Full digitization also improves management and
-enhances the long-term preservation of these fragile collections. Reliance on an industrial approach
-rather than specimen by specimen actions reduced the average cost per specimen of digitization
-from $3.32 and 555 seconds to $1.85 and 102 seconds. Deep learning tools have already been used
-to identify past specimen preservation methods that are hazardous prompting remediation efforts.
-The 500 percent increase in the past five years in web inquiries demonstrates that digital
-accessibility is serving research: in 2015, 14 million botanical records were queried via the online
-page. In 2020, during the COVID-19 pandemic, this number exploded to 70 million records queried.
-
-29 “Fermilab drives economic growth in Illinois and South Dakota.” (Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory,
-March 28, 2024). https://news.fnal.gov/2024/03/fermilab-drives-economic-growth-in-illinois-and-south-
-dakota/
-
-– 16 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-Improving Antarctic Infrastructure
-
-Amundsen-Scott South Pole Station at dawn. [Courtesy Raffaela Busse and
-the National Science Foundation. Reused under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0.]
-
-The National Science Foundation (NSF) oversees three facilities in Antarctica that support important
-and unique experiments sponsored by multiple U.S. agencies, ranging from astronomy to
-environmental studies. However, maintaining and operating infrastructure at these facilities present
-unique and costly challenges due to the harsh environment in Antarctica. For example, buildings are
-in danger of becoming buried in snow, resulting in structural damage, and even collapse.
-Environmental satellite grounds systems, which are crucial for weather forecasting, flight planning,
-aviation safety, station operations, and science support, are beyond their end-of-life timelines and
-in danger of failure. Even fuel transport to the South Pole Station has become more challenging due
-to aging and increasingly unreliable equipment for traverses that carry 100,000 gallons of fuel
-annually.
-
-A 2012 NSF report noted that “U.S. activities in Antarctica are very well managed but suffer from an
-aging infrastructure, lack of a capital budget, and the effects of operating in an extremely unforgiving
-environment. …when the…[NSF]…and its contractors must choose between repairing a roof or
-conducting science, science usually prevails. Only when the science is seriously disrupted because
-the roof begins to collapse will it be replaced; until then, it is likely only to be repaired. ...The status
-quo is simply not an option ...Failure to [recapitalize]... will simply increase logistics costs until they
-altogether squeeze out funding for science. A ten percent increase in the cost of logistics will
-consume 40 percent of the remaining science budget.”
-
-NSF established a recapitalization program of $60 million a year that comprises a portfolio of
-investments to mitigate aging infrastructure, assure safe working conditions, enhance operational
-efficiencies, and support continued U.S. science leadership on the continent.
-
-More and Better Science in Antarctica Through Increased Logistical Effectiveness: Report of the U.S. Antarctic Program
-Blue Ribbon Panel, 2012. www.nsf.gov/geo/opp/usap_special_review/usap_brp/rpt/antarctica_07232012.pdf
-
-– 17 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-Widening Gaps in Global S&T Outcomes
-
-Lagging U.S. RDI investment compared to other nations can erode U.S. leadership and influence in science
-and technology.
-
-Significant investments in specialized RDI catalyzed U.S. scientific innovations in the 20th century.
-These investments included large particle accelerators, wind tunnels, X-ray and neutron sources, and
-large outdoor test ranges, as well as state-of-the-art research laboratories. With these capabilities, the
-United States dominated for decades innovations that fueled the American economy, increased
-security, and improved quality of life—including advances in computers and personal electronics,
-breakthroughs in healthcare, and development of electric vehicles, among others. Today, however,
-increasing investments in RDI in other nations, if unanswered, may lead to loss of U.S. global leadership.
-
-An example of the threat to U.S. S&T leadership is clearly seen in the area of high-performance
-computing and computer science over the last decade. As shown in Figure 1, in 2015, the United States
-contributed the most supercomputers30 to the Top500 list globally, backed by strong support from the
-federal government for the development of leading high-performance computers. However, only seven
-years later, in 2022, the PRC surpassed the United States in number of supercomputers on the Top500
-list, due in part to the PRC’s increased investment in R&D. The impact of the PRC’s investment is readily
-apparent when comparing research output: the PRC is the top overall producer of S&E publications and
-international patents and has the greatest knowledge- and technology-intensive (KTI) manufacturing
-output.31 The United States remains the world leader in KTI services.
-
-Figure 1. Comparison of the 500 most powerful commercially-available supercomputers per country (from
-www.top500.org).
-
-30 Supercomputers are used to model and simulate complex, dynamic systems that would be too expensive,
-
-impractical or impossible to physically demonstrate. Supercomputers are changing the way scientists explore
-the evolution of our universe, biological systems, weather forecasting and even renewable energy. See more
-at https://www.energy.gov/supercomputing-and-exascale
-
-31 “Translation: U.S. and Global Science, Technology, and Innovation Capabilities.” The State of U.S. Science and
-Engineering 2024. Figures 21, 25. https://ncses.nsf.gov/pubs/nsb20243/translation-u-s-and-global-science-
-technology-and-innovation-capabilities
-
-– 18 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-Maintaining and improving U.S. computing infrastructure is critical for many applications. For example,
-accurate and timely climate and weather models are critical to missions that protect and support the
-U.S. economy and national security. However, evidence shows that the National Oceanic and
-Atmospheric Administration’s (NOAA’s) Global Forecast System lags behind the capabilities of systems
-developed by other countries, such as the ECMWF.32
-
-A 2021 NOAA Advisory Board report noted the lack of investment in computing power “indicates that
-not only are we underserving the American public, but also that the United States has the potential to
-provide more accurate and reliable weather information. The public benefits of NOAA regaining a
-leadership role would be increased forecast accuracy, longer lead times, and finer-scale detail for
-severe weather, flooding and hurricanes.”33 Further, many agencies including NOAA34 and DOE35 have
-highlighted the growing demand to provide expanded and updated computing infrastructure to
-complement experimental capabilities to facilitate efficient data sharing, integration, and analysis.
-
-In August 2023, the Defense Science Board reported in its briefing to the Office of Science and
-Technology Policy (OSTP) on Balancing Openness and Security, “China (the PRC) is outpacing the U.S.
-in global competition for key emerging technologies, leading in 37 out of 44 critical and emerging
-technologies (e.g., electric batteries, hypersonics, quantum computing, and others). Western
-democracies risk losing the global competition for research output and technological innovation.”36
-Leadership in this competition is enabled by state-of-the-art RDI, such as X-ray and neutron sources,
-nanoscience facilities, biotechnology centers, accelerators, and specialized testing facilities, among
-others (see sidebar “Broader Impacts of Accelerator Science and Technology”).
-
-Proactively planning and prioritizing federal infrastructure improvements and modernization can
-benefit from benchmarking with other countries. For example, the Basic Energy Science Advisory
-Committee, tasked by DOE/SC with benchmarking U.S. capabilities in basic research, concluded that
-“advanced research facilities in the United States funded by DOE’s Office of Basic Energy Sciences are
-world leading … largely because of long-range strategic planning, ongoing stewardship, and
-investments.”37 This type of planning can protect the nation’s research enterprise and have far-reaching
-effects. If DOE failed to develop and maintain capabilities at its five X-ray sources, the impact could
-affect the 10,000 users served annually, which include scientists from universities, government, and
-
-32 “A Report on Priorities for Weather Research” (NOAA Science Advisory Board, December 2021), 72.
-
-sab.noaa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/PWR-Report_Final_12-9-21.pdf .
-
-33 “A Report on Priorities for Weather Research” (NOAA Science Advisory Board, December 2021), 22.
-
-sab.noaa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/PWR-Report_Final_12-9-21.pdf
-
-34 “NOAA ‘Omics Strategy: Strategic Application of Transformational Tools” (NOAA, February 2020).
-
-sciencecouncil.noaa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/2020-Omics-Strategy.pdf
-
-35 “Basic Energy Sciences Network Requirements Review Final Report” (DOE/SC, November 2023).
-
-science.osti.gov/-/media/bes/pdf/reports/2023/ESnet-Report.pdf
-
-36 “Balancing Openness and Security Across the DoD Academic Research Enterprise” (Defense Science Board,
-
-July 2023), 11, apps.dtic.mil/sti/trecms/pdf/AD1212739.pdf
-
-37 “Can the U.S. Compete in Basic Energy Sciences? Critical Research Frontiers and Strategies” (A report by the
-
-BESAC Subcommittee on International Benchmarking, 2021), 3.
-science.osti.gov/-/media/bes/pdf/reports/2021/International_Benchmarking-Report.pdf
-
-– 19 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-industry. For example, the pharmaceutical industry is highly dependent on X-ray crystallography for the
-development of new drugs, and more than 30,000 samples are characterized annually on just a single
-beamline at the DOE Advanced Photon Source.
-
-Broader Impacts of Accelerator S&T
-
-Accelerators broadly impact science, industry, medicine, defense, and other sectors. Annually,
-particle accelerators are used to treat more than 5 million cancer patients; ion implantation is
-used to produce $300 billion worth of semiconductors; and e-beam irradiation is used to
-manufacture over $85 billion worth of consumer products, such as tires and insulation.
-
-Advances in accelerator technologies are also critical for maintaining the nation’s leadership in
-many high energy and nuclear physics experiments, as well as X-ray and neutron sources used
-broadly by the scientific community in studies on nanomaterials, vehicle batteries,
-pharmaceuticals, and more.
-
-For years, the United States has been a major supporter of accelerator technology advances, but
-its leadership position is being surpassed now by other nations. For example, growth in ultra-high
-intensity lasers, an accelerator-based technology, has been stagnant in the United States while
-development has increased significantly in Europe and Asia in the last several years.
-
-Maintaining leadership in this area requires investing in new accelerator infrastructure that can be
-used to develop new capabilities and applications. Investment is also needed in training and
-retaining experts who can create, operate, and further advance these technologies.
-
-“Ultra-High Intensity Lasers Facilities Across the Globe Over Time,” 2020. www.icuil.org/downloadss/laser-labs.html
-
-In some cases, optimizing RDI investments may include establishing international collaborations that
-benefit the U.S. S&T enterprise. For example, NSF partnered with S&T funding agencies from Europe,
-Japan, and Chile to build the Atacama Large Millimeter-Submillimeter Array (ALMA)—the most powerful
-telescope at these wavelengths in the world. Similarly, NASA partnered with the European and
-Canadian space agencies and 14 additional countries to build the JWST. Additionally, such
-collaborations offer untapped opportunities to enhance U.S. leadership.
-
-Proactive planning and prioritization of new and upgraded RDI is needed to ensure the nation’s global
-S&T leadership is not eclipsed. Strategies are needed to plan for and prioritize future RDI investments,
-including forming collaborations with domestic and international partners.
-
-Challenges in Recruiting and Retaining Top Scientific and Engineering Talent
-
-The declining state of infrastructure is affecting the United States’ ability to recruit and retain scientific
-talent.
-
-Departments, agencies, and federal advisory committees report that sub-optimal research
-infrastructure and project cancellations are factors that contribute to the loss of S&T talent in the
-federal workforce, impacting researchers at every stage of their careers.38 These conditions affect
-
-38 “Can the United States Maintain its Leadership in High Performance Computing? (A report by the ASCAC
-
-Subcommittee on International Benchmarking, 2021). 49. https://science.osti.gov/-
-/media/ascr/ascac/pdf/charges/2023/Report_20230627.pdf
-
-– 20 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-students and post-doctoral researchers when they cannot achieve an acceptable rate of productivity
-due to aging RDI, which limits their career opportunities. More established researchers are affected
-when their productivity and impact declines, preventing them from advancing their agency’s mission
-and reaching their career goals. Together, these factors can affect the morale of researchers and drive
-them away from the federal research arena.
-
-The research and often awe-inspiring technologies at the center of our federal laboratories have
-inspired generations to pursue technical careers and to push the boundaries of human knowledge,
-contributing to U.S. S&T leadership. For instance, NASA supports approximately 2,000 interns, annually,
-at all NASA facilities. DOE/SC hosts thousands of students, accounting for about one third of total
-unique users at scientific user facilities each year. In 2023, the Smithsonian Institution hosted 510
-interns and 355 fellows at its science units. Altogether, federal RDI facilities make up an important
-contribution to developing STEM talent around the country.
-
-Despite this, external assessments of some federal laboratories have identified major concerns in the
-workforce due to recruitment and retention problems which are straining existing staff to their limits.
-This can affect the nation’s ability to attract and retain a strong federal S&T workforce, which can in
-turn impact leadership and innovation in critical and emerging technologies, such as artificial
-intelligence, biotechnology, quantum information S&T, and microelectronics, particularly as other
-countries develop similar or more advanced capabilities. Breakthroughs in these areas are imperative
-for the development of new products and jobs that fuel the nation’s economy. Solving the RDI problem
-should help maintain the federal S&T workforce and R&D leadership to produce innovations critical to
-the nation’s economy, security, and well-being.
-
-One example of how aging infrastructure is impacting the ability to attract and retain researchers is
-NOAA’s Atlantic Oceanographic and Meteorological Laboratory (AOML). This laboratory, housed in a
-building that opened in 1973, is responsible for real-time hurricane-related measurements and
-associated activities that include hurricane science, model development, sustained observational
-platforms, and maintaining the global oceanographic climate data record. However, the 2019 AOML
-Laboratory Review Summary Report stated, “AOML’s physical infrastructure is no longer sufficient to
-support cutting-edge science and to attract a world-class scientific workforce.”39 (see Figure 2).
-
-39 “2019 AOML Laboratory Review Summary Report” (National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration,
-
-November 19, 2019), 17, www.aoml.noaa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/AOML-2019-Review-Summary-
-Report-FINAL-.pdf
-
-– 21 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-Figure 2. “When AOML started [in 1973], keypunch cards seemed cutting edge, and leisure suits seemed
-appropriate for the office.” [Courtesy NOAA]
-
-Foreign RDI investments are also prompting some U.S. researchers to leave the country to build state-
-of-the-art facilities and to find longer-term employment. For example, U.S. diplomats reported in 2018
-that numerous fusion energy researchers and technologists began traveling to the PRC following the
-shutdown of several U.S.-based magnetic confinement fusion facilities. U.S. scientists, technologies,
-and companies often engage with international facilities where the U.S. government is not present,
-such as the Extreme Light Infrastructure (ELI) in Czechia, Hungary, and Romania and the Square
-Kilometer Array (SKA) in South Africa to stay on the leading edge of their respective fields.
-
-The importance of planned investments in maintaining, upgrading, and building (where warranted)
-new RDI cannot be overstated, particularly given that many infrastructures may require decades of
-planning for successful execution. Such efforts require the development of specialized workforces
-around individual projects. Likewise, unexpected cancellations and inadequate communication with
-foreign partners can affect the reputation of the United States as a reliable partner, limiting the
-willingness of foreign experts to provide their unique expertise to major undertakings.40 Without
-significant efforts to address these issues, the nation risks losing the S&T workforce that is critical for
-maintaining its role as a global leader in S&T and innovation, which will have far-reaching impacts on
-the future economy and security of the United States.
-
-Opportunities
-
-Agencies must continue to revitalize RDI critical to the nation’s S&T enterprise, otherwise U.S. RDI will
-continue to deteriorate while costs for maintenance and replacement will continue to escalate.
-Although agencies need to plan and prioritize investments based on individual needs and budgets, the
-following four opportunities—Strategic Planning, Identification of Gaps, Benchmarking International
-RDI and Identifying Collaborations, and Sharing RDI Strategies—represent high-level steps required to
-ensure the nation’s RDI is prepared to meet future U.S. S&T needs.
-
-40 “The Path to Global Discovery: U.S. Leadership and Partnership in Particle Physics.” (A report of the High
-
-Energy Physics Advisory Panel. https://science.osti.gov/-
-/media/hep/hepap/pdf/202203/International_Benchmarking_HEPAP_2023112.pdf
-
-– 22 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-Strategic Planning
-
-Assessment and prioritization of investments are necessary to maintain and renew legacy facilities, as well
-as establish new infrastructure to realize future S&T advances.
-
-It is clear that the overall state of federal research facilities will continue to require substantial
-investments to meet future research needs. Federal agencies and departments must prioritize and
-develop short- and long-term strategies for addressing their RDI needs, including sufficient
-recapitalization, operations, and maintenance investments in facilities, and disposition of excess
-facilities, along with a strong workforce. As part of strategic planning for RDI, agencies should also
-develop and maintain standards for assessing total facility and infrastructure costs, including
-construction, annual operating costs, maintenance, and renovations, and regular recapitalization. For
-example, modernization efforts should address updated requirements for safety (e.g., changes in
-building codes), security, and specialized research. Where applicable, agencies should ensure a
-proactive lifecycle approach to real property management that aligns with the federal Real Property
-Reform Act of 2016, the associated Government Accountability Office framework. Agencies can also
-look to external resources, strategies, and best practices like the 2023 NASEM report titled “Strategies
-to Renew Federal Facilities.” The specific approaches employed may differ for the various agencies and
-their specific RDI requirements. For instance, planning for construction and lifecycle costs of a
-conventional laboratory building is quite different than the planning needed for a high-energy
-accelerator-based facility that serves thousands of users annually.
-
-• Agencies should develop processes to communicate the need for RDI investments to budget
-planners, Congress, and other stakeholders, and include the potential impact if such
-investments in R&D infrastructure are not realized. Specific and measurable impacts to mission
-execution are more persuasive than general impacts that are difficult to attribute.
-
-• The need for RDI investments should be documented with thorough assessments of facilities’
-maintenance and modernization needs, including both costs and well-defined prioritizations
-developed by each agency, and these assessments should be updated regularly.
-
-Identification of Gaps
-
-Agencies and departments should identify gaps in RDI needs and opportunities for collaborations with
-other federal, industrial, academic, and international partners.
-
-Effective planning for RDI first requires input from the federal and non-federal research community, as
-well as RDI managers, to help reveal or underscore serious gaps and to identify the potential impact of
-these gaps on the U.S. federal S&T enterprise and agency mission execution. This input can be gathered
-by various means, such as surveys, requests for information, workshops, and other avenues. For
-example, federal research agencies frequently convene researchers from the national and international
-communities to identify needs in research infrastructure, such as electron and X-ray sources,
-computers, distributed measurement networks, sequencing centers, and other key areas. This gap
-analysis could also be used to identify potential partnerships—with other agencies and departments,
-the private sector, universities, and international partners—that could provide opportunities for cost-
-sharing and result in more impactful RDI that serves a larger research community.
-
-• Agencies should utilize decadal surveys, workshops, and other community planning efforts to
-identify and prioritize the long-term federal RDI needs of the U.S. research community,
-
-– 23 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-including elements that must be maintained to support U.S. researchers in academe, industry,
-and government.
-
-• Agencies should remain cognizant of the ways in which facility closures may result in U.S.
-dependence on international facilities and weigh the consequences if those capabilities are no
-longer possessed by the United States or its allies.
-
-Benchmarking International RDI and Identifying Collaborations
-
-Regular benchmarking should be performed to assess the global position of U.S. RDI and to identify
-opportunities for international collaborations.
-
-Understanding the nation’s global standing in S&T is critical for prioritizing RDI investments and
-identifying areas for international collaboration. Benchmarking studies should include documented
-data on relevant topics, such as global development of large-scale and mid-scale research facilities,
-research outputs and impact, and workforce trends. These assessments would provide foundational
-data for the Quadrennial Science and Technology Review and National Science and Technology
-Strategy, as well as for other reports and activities related to global competitive assessments.
-
-These benchmarking studies will also identify opportunities to develop new collaborations and
-enhance existing partnerships as well as highlight strategic investments to restore and preserve U.S.
-leadership in critical areas while strengthening federal RDI and the scientific workforce. For
-international collaborations, processes must be established to reduce the administrative burdens often
-associated with developing cutting-edge scientific capabilities, including the importation of materials
-and technologies. Efforts should also be made to welcome the participation of international scientific
-experts in these benchmarking studies.
-
-• Agencies should regularly assess the competitive position of U.S. capabilities in their respective
-mission areas through benchmarking activities, such as those conducted by DOE’s SC federal
-advisory committees and the State Department’s survey of international facilities.
-
-• To facilitate collaborations, agencies should pursue existing mechanisms (e.g., the Florence
-Agreement Program and S&T agreements) and identify new ways to facilitate both national and
-international cooperative activities, as well as reduce barriers for in-kind contributions,
-materials exchange, contract and intellectual property terms, and technologies importation.
-
-Sharing RDI Strategies
-
-Establishing an interagency working group would support the modernization of RDI for the future.
-
-RDI planning would greatly benefit from having regular meetings where representatives from federal
-agencies discuss RDI strategic plans and needs at both the agency level and across the federal
-government. These discussions would catalyze collaborations and cost-sharing on upgrading or
-establishing new RDI. Although federal agencies and departments have unique business practices and
-operating principles, they share common issues facing RDI modernization. Therefore, establishing an
-interagency RDI working group could also be a platform for sharing best practices and ensuring access
-to state-of-the-art RDI across the federal government.
-
-• The NSTC’s Subcommittee on Research and Development Infrastructure should coordinate an
-interagency working group focused on ensuring the competitive position of U.S. RDI, with
-activities to include sharing information on long-term strategic planning efforts, identifying
-
-– 24 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-gaps in capabilities, and facilitating opportunities for national and international collaborations
-in facilities.
-
-Additionally, departments and agencies should continue to look to the policy opportunities identified
-in the National Strategic Overview on RDI, released in 2021:
-
-Maintaining Strong and Integrated RDI Planning and Coordination
-
-• Adopt a cohesive definition of RDI that encompasses experimental, observational, as well as
-
-knowledge- and cyber-infrastructure, in federal planning processes
-
-•
-
-Identify complementary RDI—and their capabilities—across the federal government and
-external R&D communities to inform agency priority-setting processes.
-
-• Plan for, invest in, and deploy the necessary knowledge infrastructure and research
-cyberinfrastructure to keep pace with the rate of growth of data acquisition in research, as well
-as published research data, to ensure the efficiency and trustworthiness of scientific pathways
-and pipelines.
-
-• Ensure consistent, sufficient, and timely RDI capabilities, strategically addressing episodic
-
-efforts that can undermine the ability to meet long-term needs
-
-• Regularly review and document RDI needs and develop planning processes that encompass
-
-repurposing, reusing, or decommissioning low-priority RDI.
-
-Ensuring RDIs Support a Flexible and Agile R&D Enterprise
-
-• Foster R&D community engagement to inform federal RDI planning and prioritization, for
-
-instance through assessments and cross-sector coordination.
-
-• Seek input from Federal Advisory Committee Act (FACA) and NSTC committees, as these
-committees are capable of providing valuable insight on future RDI needs and coordination
-possibilities.
-
-•
-
-Integrate agile design and decision processes in planning and maintaining RDIs so that
-capabilities keep pace with the growth in data and advancements in computing and analytics.
-
-• Support remote access to RDI capabilities, tools, and platforms, where appropriate.
-
-• Build strategic, long-term relationships with contractors and suppliers to enable agility in
-
-procurement, development, design, and portability of RDI systems.
-
-•
-
-•
-
-Incorporate lifecycle considerations, such as upfront costs of construction, operation, and
-maintenance, and anticipate future modernization needs for planned and existing RDIs.
-
-Incorporate lifecycle resourcing considerations to ensure RDIs sustain or enhance privacy and
-other legal protections.
-
-• Ensure large or complex RDI projects are managed by staff with appropriate design and project
-
-management experience to safeguard delivery on schedule and within budget.
-
-• Continue to create and promote STEM education programs that directly engage with and
-
-support the use of RDIs as education and training platforms.
-
-– 25 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-• Ensure processes that allow the nation’s R&D enterprise to thrive by fostering the participation
-
-of talent that reflects the diversity of America.
-
-Advancing RDI Capabilities to Support the Convergence of Disciplines and Sectors
-
-•
-
-Invest in RDIs that complement core disciplinary needs while identifying opportunities to
-enhance connections across disciplines and sectors.
-
-• Consider the potential use of RDIs beyond a single agency’s mission context in developing
-
-coordination efforts, especially for the Nation’s largest RDI investments.
-
-• Ensure RDIs foster convergence through partnerships and research information exchange.
-
-Balancing RDI Openness with Security Needs
-
-• Seek international collaborations for the development of RDIs as appropriate to foster
-
-international cooperation
-
-• Operate RDIs using research security frameworks that balance open science with appropriate
-
-levels of vigilance and that uphold U.S. principles of integrity
-
-• Ensure proper protections for RDIs that are vital to competitiveness, public health and safety
-resilience, and national security (e.g., intellectual property, certain classes of research data,
-implications from climate change)
-
-Conclusion
-
-Just like the investments in research facilities that were built during the Cold War, investments in
-modern federal RDI will support the development of new technologies and generate new jobs.
-Revitalizing federal RDI will also ensure the development of a workforce trained to discover, develop,
-manufacture, and use next-generation technologies.
-
-The nation can take immediate action to revitalize RDI and support a vibrant research enterprise for
-years to come. Federal departments and agencies should develop actionable strategic plans with
-priorities for RDI investments. These plans should be informed by input from the S&T community across
-government, university, and private-sector institutions, and from international benchmarking. This
-input can also identify opportunities to partner with both domestic and international institutions. An
-RDI working group can share approaches and identify where collaborations can be forged to provide
-enhanced capabilities to a broader research community. The time to act is now; prioritizing federal RDI
-will support generations of future researchers and allow the United States to maintain global leadership
-in science, technology, and innovation.
-
-– 26 –
+1. ΔV = βV0ΔT
+2. β*ΔT is the same for both of you.
+3. But, V0 is greater for the 18-gallon fuel-tank for the truck.
+4. So, ΔV will be larger for the truck and it will lose more fuel.
diff --git a/q0/random_k2/random_2.md b/q0/random_k2/random_2.md
index f1acb0854be2920866b2127b008e7c6e2f57b22b..35a7eb473c0028e63514bfe2ddbd9a16bdb5c94f 100644
--- a/q0/random_k2/random_2.md
+++ b/q0/random_k2/random_2.md
@@ -1,3733 +1,3030 @@
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT
+FOR RELEASE January 29, 2026
-Table of Contents
+Confidence in Trump
+Dips, and Fewer Now Say
+They Support His
+Policies and Plans
-Why must I report on information technology (IT) investments?
-What background information must I know?
-How do I ensure that IT investments are linked to and support agency strategic plans?
-What special terms should I know?
-How do I determine whether I must report?
+Rising share of Democrats want their party’s congressional
+leaders to stand up to Trump
-How do I submit Exhibit 53 and when is it due?
-If I submitted Exhibit 53 last year, how do I revise it this year?
-How is Exhibit 53 organized?
-How is Exhibit 53 coded?
-What are the steps to complete Exhibit 53?
-Agency IT Investment Portfolio
-Agency IT Security Portfolio
-Agency Cloud Computing Portfolio
-Agency IT Reductions and Reinvestments
+BY Hannah Hartig and Jocelyn Kiley
-1.
-2.
-3.
-4.
-5.
+FOR MEDIA OR OTHER INQUIRIES:
-53.1
-53.2
-53.3
-53.4
-53.5
-Ex53A
-Ex53B
-Ex53C
-Ex53D
+Jocelyn Kiley, Director of Political Research
+Steven Shepard, Associate Director of Political
+Research
+Nida Asheer, Senior Communications Manager
-300.1
-300.2
-300.3
-300.4
-300.5
-300.6
-Ex300A/B IT Capital Asset Overview and Justification, Performance Plan and Measurement Report
+202.419.4372
-What is the purpose of the section?
-Does Exhibit 300 apply to me?
-How will agencies manage capital assets?
-What other requirements does Exhibit 300 fulfill?
-What must I report on Exhibit 300A&B and when?
-How will OMB use Exhibit 300A&B?
+www.pewresearch.org
- Updates and consolidates special terms related to information technology (IT) and E-Government
+RECOMMENDED CITATION
-Summary of Changes
+Pew Research Center, January 2026, “Confidence in
+Trump dips, and fewer now say they support his
+policies and plans”
-(Section 4)
+1
-Significantly updates Exhibit 53 requirements:
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
- Requires agencies to submit a draft Fiscal Year (FY) 2014 Exhibit 53A by August 27, 2012 and the
+About Pew Research Center
-agency budget request Exhibit 53s on September 10, 2012
+Pew Research Center is a nonpartisan, nonadvocacy fact tank that informs the public about the
+issues, attitudes and trends shaping the world. It does not take policy positions. The Center
+conducts public opinion polling, demographic research, computational social science research and
+other data-driven research. It studies politics and policy; news habits and media; the internet and
+technology; religion; race and ethnicity; international affairs; social, demographic and economic
+trends; science; research methodology and data science; and immigration and migration. Pew
+Research Center is a subsidiary of The Pew Charitable Trusts, its primary funder.
- Adds two new 53 Exhibits: Cloud Computing and Reductions and Reinvestments per budget guidance
- Adds requirement for Functional/Business Sponsor identification for all investments
- Adds several fields to the Exhibit 53A for reporting government FTE, HSPD-12, and cloud
+© Pew Research Center 2026
-alternatives analysis
+www.pewresearch.org
- New FEA BRM 3.0 Service Mappings
+2
-Significantly updates Exhibit 300 requirements:
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
- Requires agencies to submit the FY 2014 Exhibit 300A/Bs between September 10-14, 2012.
+About this research
-Agencies may submit Exhibit 300Bs for any investment for which a 300A has been successfully
-submitted/updated
+This Pew Research Center report looks at how the U.S. public feels about Trump’s job
+performance, their expectations for his administration, and their views about whether
+congressional leaders should work with each other and the president.
- Adds a requirement to submit specific investment artifacts/documents
- Updates questions for areas of current policy emphasis
- Changes Summary of Funding to Life Cycle Costs
- Clarifies project and activity concepts and extends reporting time period
- Clarifies reporting of actuals for performance metrics
- Adds question on modular contracting
- Adds question on return on investment
+Why did we do this?
-Page 1 of 45
+Pew Research Center conducted this research to check in on how the public is feeling about the
+Trump administration. It is part of our regular work to understand how Americans feel about the
+policies, actions and events that occur during the presidency – as well as to understand how
+Americans feel about current events.
- (2012)
+Our research on presidents dates back to the 1980s, and has continued through the current Trump
+administration.
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT
+Learn more about Pew Research Center and our politics research.
-1. Why must I report on information technology (IT) investments?
+How did we do this?
-The required information allows the agency and the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) to review and
-evaluate each agency's IT spending and to compare IT spending across the Federal Government. Specifically,
-the information helps the agency and OMB to:
+We conducted a survey from January 20 through January 26, 2026 among 8,512 U.S. adults
+recruited through our American Trends panel.
- Provide a report on all IT investments for the agency, as required by the Clinger-Cohen Act of 1996;
+Here are the survey questions used for this report, the detailed responses and
+the survey methodology.
- Understand and compare the amount spent on the development of new capabilities (Development,
+www.pewresearch.org
-Modernization and Enhancement [DME], which may appropriately be treated as capitalized costs) and
-in support of operation and maintenance (O&M) for all agency IT investments;
+3
-
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Identify and report IT security costs for all IT investments and for agency and bureau IT security
-programs, as required by the Federal Information Security Management Act (FISMA); and
+Confidence in Trump dips, a
+they support his policies and plans
+Rising share of Democrats want their party
+to stand up to Trump
-
+nd fewer now say
-Identify and report on agency financial management systems.
+’s congressional leaders
-Agencies must provide required formation using the Exhibit 53 reporting format. This information should be
-consistent with information required in Section 51 of OMB Circular A-11. In addition, as an output of your
-agency's internal IT capital planning and investment control process, your budget justification for IT must
-provide results-oriented information in the context of the agency's missions and operations, as expressed
-through the agency’s enterprise architecture (EA). Your budget justification, including the status and plans
-for information systems, should be consistent with your agency's submissions for Exhibit 300 submissions
-(see guidance on Exhibit 300), regarding major IT investments.
+By Hannah Hartig and Jocelyn Kiley
-Investment costs must include all Federal budgetary resources (e.g., direct appropriation, working capital
-fund, revolving funds). Federal budgetary resources are defined in Section 20 of OMB Circular A-11. These
-investment costs and performance benefits must be formulated and reported order to support the Clinger-
-Cohen Act's requirement that the OMB Director shall submit to Congress a report on the net program
-performance benefits achieved as a result of major capital investments made by executive agencies in
-information systems and how the benefits relate to the accomplishment of the goals of the executive agencies.
+A year into his second administration,
+Americans’ views of President Donald Trump –
+already more negative than positive – have
+continued to slip.
-2. What background information must I know?
+Half of Americans say Trump’s actions
+have been worse than they expected
-The Federal Government must effectively manage its portfolio of capital assets to ensure scarce public
-resources are wisely invested. Capital programming integrates the planning, acquisition, and management of
-capital assets into the Budget decision-making process. It is intended to assist agencies in improving asset
-management and in complying with the results-oriented requirements of:
+% who ___ of the way Donald Trump is handling his job
+as president
- The Clinger-Cohen Act of 1996, which requires agencies to use a disciplined capital planning and
+▪ Trump’s approval rating stands at 37%,
-investment control (CPIC) process to acquire, use, maintain, and dispose of IT in alignment with the
-agency’s EA planning processes. OMB policy for the management of Federal information resources
-is detailed in Circular A-130, Management of Federal Information Resources.
+down from 40% in the fall.
- The Government Performance and Results Act (GPRA) of 1993, which establishes the foundation for
+Approve
-Budget decision making to achieve strategic goals in order to meet agency mission objectives.
-Instructions for preparing strategic plans, annual performance plans, and annual program performance
-reports are provided in Part 6 of OMB Circular A-11 (see Section 220).
+Disapprove
- The GPRA Modernization Act of 2010 (P.L. 111-352), which requires quarterly performance
+37
-assessments of Federal Government priorities and establishes agency Performance Improvement
-Officers and the Performance Improvement Council.
+61
-Page 2 of 45
+▪ By more than two-to-one, Americans say
+the administration’s actions have been
+worse than they expected (50%) rather than
+better (21%).
- (2012)
+▪ Only about a quarter of Americans today
+(27%) say they support all or most of
+Trump’s policies and plans, down from 35%
+when he returned to office last year. That
+change has come entirely among
+Republicans.
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT
+% who say the Trump administration’s actions since
+taking office last year have been ___ expected
- The Federal Managers Financial Integrity Act of 1982, Chief Financial Officers Act of 1990 (CFO
+Better than
-Act), and Federal Financial Management Improvement Act of 1996, which require accountability of
-financial and program managers for financial results of actions taken, control over the Federal
-Government's financial resources, and protection of Federal assets. OMB policies and standards for
-developing, operating, evaluating, and reporting on financial management systems are contained in
-Circular A–127, Financial Management Systems and OMB Circular A-11, Section 52.
+About as
- The Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995, which requires agencies to perform their information
+Worse than
-resources management activities in an efficient, effective, and economical manner.
+21
- The Federal Information Security Management Act of 2002, which requires agencies to integrate IT
-security into their capital planning and EA processes, conduct annual IT security reviews of all
-programs and systems, and report the results of those reviews to OMB.
+28
- The E-Government Act of 2002 (P.L. 107–347), which requires agencies to support government-wide
-E-Government (E-Gov) initiatives and to leverage cross-agency opportunities to further E-Gov. The
-Act also requires agencies to establish a process for determining which government information the
-agency intends to make available and accessible to the public on the Internet and by other means. In
-addition, the Act requires agencies to conduct and make publicly available privacy impact
-assessments (PIAs) for all new IT investments, administering information in an identifiable form
-collected from or about members of the public.
+50
- The National Technology Transfer and Advancement Act of 1995 (P.L. 104-113) and OMB Circular
-A-119, which state that voluntary consensus standards are the preferred type of standards for Federal
-Government use. When it would be inconsistent with law or otherwise impractical to use a voluntary
-consensus standard, agencies must submit a report to OMB through the National Institute of Standards
-and Technology (NIST) describing the reason(s) for the agency's use of government-unique standards
-in lieu of voluntary consensus standards.
+% who support ___ of Donald Trump’s policies and
+plans
- The Federal Records Act, which requires agencies to establish standards and procedures to ensure
-efficient and effective records management. The National Archives and Records Administration
-(NARA) issues policies and guidance for agencies to meet their records management goals and
-requirements. NARA also provides policies and guidance for planning and evaluating investments in
-electronic records management.
+All/Most
- The Privacy Act of 1974 (5 U.S.C. § 552a), which is an omnibus "code of fair information practices"
-that attempts to regulate the collection, maintenance, use, and dissemination of personal information
-by Federal executive branch agencies.
+Some
- NIST Special Publication 800-146 concepts and definitions regarding cloud computing.
+Few/None
- Recent OMB IT policies and guidance, including:
+27
-o 25 Point Implementation Plan to Reform Federal Information Technology Management
-o Federal Information Technology Shared Services Strategy
-o The Common Approach to Federal Enterprise Architecture
-o Digital Government Strategy: Building a 21st Century Platform to Better Serve the American
+20
-People
+52
-o OMB memo M-12-10 – Implementing PortfolioStat
-o The Federal Cloud Computing Strategy
+A new Pew Research Center survey of 8,512
+U.S. adults, conducted Jan. 20-26, also finds
+that – across six key qualities and abilities
+needed to serve as president – more Americans
+express little or no confidence in Trump than say they are extremely or very confident in him.
-Page 3 of 45
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
- (2012)
+Note: No answer responses are not shown.
+Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026.
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT
+Confidence is down on all six measures since last year, particularly among Republicans.
-o Security Authorization of Information Systems in Cloud Computing Environments
+Related: How Americans See Immigration Officers’ Behaviors and Civilian Actions
-(FedRAMP)
+www.pewresearch.org
-o OMB memo M-12-13 - Fiscal Year 2014 Budget Guidance
+4
- Executive Order 13514, Federal Leadership in Environmental, Energy, and Economic Performance
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
- Executive Order 13423, Strengthening Federal Environmental, Energy, and Transportation
+Trump’s qualities and abilities as president
-Management
+Today, 34% of Americans say
+they are extremely or very
+confident that Trump has the
+leadership skills needed to
+serve as president. A larger
+share (51%) are not too or not
+at all confident. Another 14%
+are somewhat confident.
- Federal Acquisition Regulation, including Subchapter B, Parts 5 through 12 and Part 23
+Similarly, about half say they
+are not too or not at all
+confident Trump has the
+mental fitness (52%) or
+physical fitness (50%) to do
+the job. Roughly three-in-ten
+express confidence on these
+measures.
- Federal Management Regulation, including Subchapters B and C
+Many Americans lack confidence in Trump on several
+measures, including his ethics in office
- Energy Independence and Security Act of 2007, including Sections 431 through 435 and 523 through
+% who say, thinking about the qualities needed to serve as president, they
+are ___ confident that Donald Trump …
-525
+No answer responses are not shown.
+Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026.
- Energy and Policy Act of 2005, including Sections 103, 104, 109, and 203
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-3. How do I ensure that IT investments align with and support the agency’s strategic plans?
+Even fewer say they are confident that Trump respects the country’s democratic values (25% are
+extremely or very confident) or that he picks good advisers (25%).
-Each IT investment must clearly demonstrate that the investment is needed to help meet the agency's strategic
-goals and mission. The agency must demonstrate how the investment supports a business line or enterprise
-service performance goal as documented in the agency’s EA and annual Enterprise Roadmap submission to
-OMB. Agency IT investment business cases (and other documents), the IT Capital Asset Summary (Exhibit
-300A), and Agency IT Investment Portfolio (Exhibit 53A) must demonstrate the agency’s management of IT
-investments and how governance processes are used to plan, select, develop, implement, and operate IT
-investments. Documents used to manage the planning, development, implementation, and operation of IT
-investments and documents that demonstrate the outcomes of agency, branch, and bureau governance
-decisions should be maintained and made readily available if requested by OMB.
+Americans express the least amount of confidence in Trump to act ethically in office. Just 21% are
+extremely or very confident he does this, while 60% express little or no confidence.
-The individual agency's Exhibit 53A and Exhibit 300A submissions are used to create an overall "Federal IT
-Investment Portfolio," which is published as part of the President's Budget. Agency and OMB portfolio
-reviews and Budget processes will ensure the selection of IT investments that support the agency’s strategic
-goals, as captured in the agency’s High Priority Performance Goals and Strategic Plan.
+www.pewresearch.org
-4. What special terms should I know?
+While overall confidence in
+Trump’s ethics in office was
+already relatively low last
+February (29%), it has
+declined 8 percentage points
+since. And nearly all of that
+drop has come among
+Republicans: At the
+beginning of Trump’s second
+term, a 55% majority of
+Republicans and Republican-
+leaning independents said
+they were confident that
+Trump acts ethically in office,
+but that share now stands at
+42%.
-Alternatives Analysis refers to an analysis of alternatives for addressing the performance objectives of an
-investment. The analysis is performed prior to the initial decision to implement a solution and updated
-periodically, as appropriate, to capture changes in the context for an investment decision. Alternatives
-analysis documentation must be submitted along with Exhibit 300 for all major IT investments. Alternatives
-Analysis should be performed for investments with projects in the planning or DME stages, whereas strictly
-operational investments should instead perform operational analyses until such time as a decision is made to
-re-evaluate the investment or to resume development, modernization or enhancement.
-
-Asset refers to anything that has value to an organization, including, but not limited to: a computing device,
-IT system, IT network, IT circuit, software (both an installed instance and a physical instance), virtual
-computing platform (common in cloud and virtualized computing), and related hardware (e.g., locks, cabinets,
-keyboards). Assets are the lowest level at which IT is planned, acquired, implemented, and operated.
-
-Benefit-Cost Analysis refers to the recommended technique to use in a formal economic analysis of
-government programs or projects. Guidance for Benefit-Cost Analysis is described in OMB Circular A-94.
-
-Page 4 of 45
-
- (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT
-
-Business Reference Model (BRM) refers to one of six reference models of the Federal Enterprise
-Architecture (FEA). It is a classification taxonomy used to describe mission sectors, business functions, and
-services that are performed within and between Federal agencies and with external partners. IT investments
-are mapped to the BRM to identify opportunities for collaboration, shared services, and solution reuse.
-Exhibit 53 allows for one primary service and up to four secondary service codes to be identified for each IT
-investment. BRM service codes can be found in the FEA Reference Model document library.
-Note: Updated definitions are scheduled for release in version 2 of the FEA.
-
-Capital Assets refer to land, structures, equipment, intellectual property (e.g., software), and IT (including the
-output of IT service contracts) that has been acquired by the Federal Government and have an estimated useful
-life of two years or more. See Appendix One of the Capital Programming Guide for a more complete
-definition of capital assets.
-
-Capital Investment (or Investment) refers to the planning, development, and acquisition of a capital asset and
-the management and operation of that asset through its usable life after the initial acquisition. IT capital
-investments may consist of one or more assets, which provide useful components in an operational
-(production) environment.
-
-Capital Planning and Investment Control (also called capital programming) refers to a decision-making
-process that ensures IT investments integrate strategic planning, budgeting, procurement, and management of
-IT in support of agency missions and business needs. The term was introduced in the Clinger-Cohen Act of
-1996 and generally is used in relation to IT management issues.
-
-Capital Programming refers to an integrated process within an agency that focuses on the planning,
-budgeting, procurement, and management of the agency’s portfolio of capital assets to achieve the agency’s
-strategic goals and objectives with the lowest overall cost and least risk.
-
-Cloud First Policy (IT Reform) refers to the Cloud First policy, launched in December 2010, which is
-intended to accelerate the pace at which the government realizes the value of cloud computing by requiring
-agencies to evaluate safe, secure cloud computing options before making any new investments. Per the
-Federal Cloud Computing Strategy, agencies should evaluate their technology sourcing plans to include
-consideration and application of cloud computing solutions as part of the budget process. Agencies should
-seek to optimize the use of cloud technologies in their IT portfolios to take full advantage of the benefits of
-cloud computing in order to maximize capacity utilization, improve IT flexibility and responsiveness, and
-minimize costs. When evaluating options for new IT deployments, OMB requires that agencies default to
-cloud-based solutions whenever a secure, reliable, cost-effective cloud option exists. Additionally, agencies
-shall continually evaluate cloud computing solutions across their IT portfolios, regardless of investment type
-or life cycle stage.
-
-Contributions (or expected contributions) refers to both monetary contributions and fees for services
-provided by partner agencies to managing partners or shared service providers of a multi-agency
-collaboration. Contributions should only apply to multi-agency collaborations.
-
-Cost refers to the expenditure of funds or use of property to acquire, produce, operate, or maintain an asset.
-Examples include, but are not limited to: sunk costs, operational costs, acquisition costs, and disposition costs
-(including variable costs such as labor hours).
-
-Cost Avoidance refers to from an action taken in the immediate time frame that will decrease costs in the
-future (as defined in OMB Circular A-131).
-
-Cost Saving refers to the reduction in actual expenditures to achieve a specific objective (as defined in OMB
-Circular A-131).
-
-Page 5 of 45
-
- (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT
-
-Data Center refers to a closet, room, floor, or building for the storage, management, and dissemination of data
-and information. Such a repository houses computer systems and associated components, such as databases,
-applications, and storage systems and data stores. A data center generally includes redundant or backup
-power supplies; redundant data communications connections; environmental controls (e.g., air conditioning,
-fire suppression); and special security devices housed in, leased (including by cloud providers), owned,
-collocated, or situated in stand-alone facilities. This definition excludes facilities exclusively devoted to
-communications and network equipment (e.g., telephone exchanges, telecommunications rooms). Neither
-square footage nor Uptime Institute tier classifications are required to define a facility as a data center. This
-definition of a data center applies to all agency IT assets, mission or otherwise. See March 2012 OMB Federal
-Data Center Consolidation Initiative Memorandum for more detail.
-
-Defense Acquisition Workforce Improvement Act (DAWIA) of 1990 (P.L. 101-510) refers to a congressional
-act that established for the Department of Defense an Acquisition Corps to professionalize the acquisition
-workforce in the Department of Defense through education, training, and work experience.
-
-Dependency refers to the identification of relationships between projects and operational assets within an
-investment as well as the identification of relationships between investments. Identification of dependencies
-is critical to the management of project, program, and portfolio risk.
-
-Development, Modernization and Enhancement refers to costs for projects and activities leading to new IT
-assets/systems and projects and activities that change or modify existing IT assets to: substantively improve
-capability or performance, implement legislative or regulatory requirements, or meet an agency leadership
-request. As part of DME, capital costs can include hardware, software development and acquisition costs,
-commercial off-the-shelf acquisition costs, government labor costs, and contracted labor costs for planning,
-development, acquisition, system integration, and direct project management and overhead support.
-
-Disposition Cost refers to the cost of retiring a capital asset once its useful life is completed or a replacement
-asset has superseded it; disposition costs may be included in operational activities near the end of the useful
-life of an asset.
-
-Earned Value Management (EVM) refers to a project management tool that effectively integrates the project
-scope of work with a schedule and cost elements for optimum project planning and control. The qualities and
-operating characteristics of earned value management systems (EVMS) are described in American National
-Standards Institute (ANSI)/Electronic Industries Alliance (EIA) Standard–748–1998, Earned Value
-Management Systems. Additional information on EVMS is available at www.acq.osd.mil/evm.
-
-Enterprise Architecture refers to the explicit description and documentation of the current and desired
-relationships among business and management processes and IT of an organization. It describes the “current
-architecture” and “target architecture”. An EA includes the rules and standards and systems life cycle
-information to optimize and maintain the environment which the agency wishes to create and maintain
-through its IT portfolio. An EA must provide a strategy that enables the agency to support its current state and
-provides a roadmap for transition to its target environment. An EA defines principles and goals and sets a
-direction on such issues as the promotion of interoperability, open systems, publics access, end-user
-satisfaction, and IT security. The agency must support an EA with a complete inventory of agency
-information resources including: personnel, equipment, systems, services, and funds devoted to information
-resources management and IT, at an appropriate level of detail.
-
-Enterprise Roadmap refers to an annual submission from each agency to OMB that describes the business
-and technology plan for the entire organization using EA methods. The Roadmap provides current views,
-future views, and transition plans at an appropriate level of detail for all IT investments, services, systems, and
-programs. The Enterprise Roadmap also contains an IT asset inventory using the FEA Reference Models and
-other attachments or appendices for CPIC, EA, shared service, and other planning products requested by
-OMB that provide additional information regarding Roadmap plans.
-
-Page 6 of 45
-
- (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT
-
-Evaluation (by Agency CIO) refers to the CIO’s best judgment of the current level of risk for the investment
-in terms of its ability to accomplish its goals. The evaluation should be informed by the following factors,
-including, but not limited to: risk management, requirements management, contractor oversight, historical
-performance, human capital and other factors that the CIO deems important to the forecasting future success.
-Each evaluation should include a narrative explanation when the rating has changed since the last evaluation.
-
-Federal Acquisition Certification for Program and Project Managers (FAC-P/PM) refers to a certification
-program that was established to clearly identify general training and experience requirements for program and
-project managers (PMs) in civilian agencies. The FAC-P/PM focuses on essential competencies needed for
-program managers and PMs. The certification program does not include functional or technical competencies,
-such as those for IT or agency-specific competencies. Defense agencies have a similar certification program
-under DAWIA. Agencies were required to be compliant with FAC-P/PM starting in FY 2008. Available
-levels are Entry/Apprentice, Mid/Journeyman, and Expert/Advanced for FAC-P/PM and 1, 2, and 3 for
-DAWIA. For more information about these programs, refer to the following links:
-http://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/omb/procurement/workforce/fed_acq_cert_042507.pdf
-http://whitehouse.gov/omb/procurement/acq_wk/fac_contracting_program.pdf
-
-Federal Enterprise Architecture refers to a business-based documentation and analysis framework for
-government-wide improvement. The FEA allows agencies to use standardized methods to describe the
-relationship between an agency’s strategic goals, business functions, and enabling technologies at various
-levels of scope and complexity. The FEA is comprised of documentation in six domain areas (strategic goals,
-business services, data and information, systems and applications, infrastructure, and security) that includes
-required and elective artifacts. There are six reference models to support the six domain areas that should
-facilitate standardized design; analysis; reporting; and the identification of duplicative investments, gaps, and
-opportunities for collaboration within and across Federal agencies. More information about the FEA is
-available in The Common Approach to Federal Enterprise Architecture (OMB, May 2, 2012) and at FEA
-Reference Model document library.
-
-Federal Enterprise Architecture Mapping Codes refers to a framework for describing important elements of
-the FEA in a common and consistent way. Through the use of this common framework and vocabulary, IT
-portfolios can be better managed and leveraged across the Federal Government. The first three-digit code
-indicates the primary service area served by this investment (the three-digit BRM service code). The second
-through fifth three-digit codes indicate the secondary services associated with this investment. Guidance on
-the codes for these mappings can be found at FEA Reference Model document library.
-
-Financial Management refers to activities that support the interrelationships and interdependencies among
-budget, cost and management functions, and information associated with business transactions.
-
-Financial Management Systems refers to systems necessary to support financial management, including
-automated and manual processes, procedures, controls, data, hardware, software, and support personnel
-dedicated to the operation and maintenance of system functions. The following are examples of financial
-management systems: core financial systems, procurement systems, loan systems, grants systems, payroll
-systems, budget formulation systems, billing systems, and travel systems. See OMB Circular A-127 for
-additional information and guidance at www.whitehouse.gov/omb/circulars_a127.
-
-Full Funding refers to a situation where appropriations are enacted sufficient in total to complete an asset or a
-useful segment of a capital asset before any obligations may be incurred. Incrementally funding the planning
-and acquisition of capital assets or (useful segments) without certainty if or when future funding will be
-available can result in poor planning, inadequate justification of assets acquisition, higher acquisition costs,
-project delays, cancellation of projects, the loss of sunk costs, and inadequate funding to maintain and operate
-the assets. Budget requests for full acquisition of capital assets must propose full funding (see Section 31.6 of
-OMB Circular A-11).
-
-Page 7 of 45
-
- (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT
-
-Funding refers to providing the budgetary resources to plan for, acquire, develop, sustain, or operate an asset.
-
-Funding Source refers to the direct appropriation or other budgetary resources an agency receives for an IT
-investment. When “original paying accounts” within agencies are transferring resources to a different agency
-account that ultimately supports the IT investment (for example, when bureau accounts are paying into a
-central CIO office account or a working capital fund), the funding source provided in Exhibit 53A should be
-the account that ultimately pays contracts and other costs for the investment directly (not the original
-account(s) for the funds).
-
-Note: For agencies on the IT Dashboard, funding sources are planned as the primary drivers in the algorithm
-to display “spending by bureau,” rather than using the bureau code associated with investments. It is critical
-that valid funding source codes be provided in agency submissions.
-
-Government Information refers to information created, collected, processed, disseminated, or disposed of by
-or for the Federal Government.
-
-Information Resource Management (IRM) Strategic Plan refers to a document that addresses all information
-resources management of an agency. Agencies must develop and maintain their IRM strategic plans as
-required by 44 U.S.C. 3506(b)(2) and OMB Circular A-130. IRM strategic plans should support the agency's
-strategic plan that is required in OMB Circular A-11; provide a description of how information resources
-management activities help accomplish the agency’s missions delivery area and program decisions; and
-ensure IRM decisions are integrated with management support areas, including organizational planning,
-budget, procurement, financial management, and human resources management.
-
-Information Security refers to all functions necessary to meet Federal information security policy
-requirements. It includes the development, implementation, and maintenance of security policies, procedures,
-and controls across the entire information life cycle. These functions should include implementation and
-activities associated with NIST 800-37, Security Awareness training (but not the technical infrastructure
-required for the delivery of training), FISMA compliance reporting, development of a security policy, and
-security audits and testing. It does not include the physical protection of facilities such as those described in
-Critical Infrastructure Protection (CIP).
-
-Information System refers to a discrete set of IT, data, and related resources, such as personnel, hardware,
-software, and associated IT services organized for the collection, processing, maintenance, use, sharing,
-dissemination, or disposition of information.
-
-Information Technology refers to any equipment or interconnected system or subsystem of equipment that is
-used in the automatic acquisition, storage, manipulation, management, movement, control, display, switching,
-interchange, transmission, or reception of data or information by an executive agency. IT is related to the
-terms capital asset, IT investment, program, project, sub-project, service, and system.
-
-Integrated Program Team (IPT) refers to a cross-functional or multidisciplinary group of individuals
-organized and collectively responsible for the specific purpose of delivering a project, product, or process to
-an external or internal customer. Each IPT should include experts in program and project management,
-resource management, procurement, systems engineering, system security, and other disciplines, as necessary,
-to plan and evaluate all aspects of the project. In order for OMB to approve the investment budget, an IPT
-must include at a minimum: a qualified, fully dedicated IT program manager; a contracting specialist, if
-applicable; an IT specialist; an IT security specialist; and a business process owner or subject matter expert
-(SME). Other members of the IPT might include enterprise architects; IT specialists with specific expertise in
-data, systems, or networks; capital planners; or performance specialists. Key members of the IPT should be
-co-located during the most critical junctures of the program, to the maximum extent possible. Agencies
-should establish IPT members’ individual performance goals to hold team members accountable for both
-
-Page 8 of 45
-
- (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT
-
-individual functional goals and the overall success of the program. The investment IPT should be defined in a
-program or an IPT charter.
-
-Interagency Acquisition refers to the use of the Federal Supply Schedules; a multi-agency contract (i.e., a task
-order or delivery order contract established by one agency for use by multiple government agencies to obtain
-supplies and services, consistent with the Economy Act, 31 U.S.C. 1535) or a government-wide acquisition
-contract (i.e., a task order or delivery order contract for IT established by one agency for government-wide
-use operated by an executive agent, as designated by OMB pursuant to Section 11302(3) of the Clinger-Cohen
-Act of 1996).
-
-IT Dashboard refers to a website (www.itdashboard.gov) that enables Federal agencies, industry, the general
-public, and other stakeholders to view details regarding the performance of Federal IT investments. The IT
-Dashboard is used by the Administration and Congress to inform budget and policy decisions.
-
-IT Investment refers to the expenditure of IT resources to address mission delivery and management support.
-An IT investment may include a project or projects for the development, modernization, enhancement, or
-maintenance of a single IT asset or group of IT assets with related functionality and the subsequent operation
-of those assets in a production environment. All IT investments should have a defined life cycle with start and
-end dates, with the end date representing the end of the currently estimated useful life of the investment,
-consistent with the investment’s most current alternatives analysis if applicable.
-
-IT Program Managers and IT Project Managers refers to the IPT members responsible for IT investments
-and lead the required IPT for the investment. In some cases, IT program managers and PMs can hold
-positions in other classification series; however they must still meet the requisite Federal certification and/or
-IT program management experience requirements. Further definitions are available in the Office of Personnel
-Management’s Job Family Standard for Administrative Work in the Information Technology Group (series
-2200 in the Federal Classification and Job Grading Systems).
-
-IT System refers to a discrete set of information resources organized for the collection, processing,
-maintenance, transmission, and dissemination of information, in accordance with defined procedures, whether
-automated or manual.
-
-Life Cycle Costs refers to all investment costs (including government FTEs) from the commencement of the
-investment through its estimated useful life (or the composite estimated useful life of the assets within the
-investment), independent of the funding source (e.g., revolving fund, appropriated fund, working capital fund,
-trust fund). For more information about life cycle costs, see the Capital Programming Guide of OMB Circular
-A-11 and OMB Circular A-131.
-
-Maintenance refers to the activity necessary to keep an asset functioning as designed during the O&M phase
-of an investment. Some maintenance activities should be managed as projects and reported in Section B of
-Exhibit 300B. Examples of maintenance projects may include, but are not limited to: operating system
-upgrades, technology refreshes, and security patch implementations. As defined in the Federal Accounting
-Standards Advisory Board Statement of Federal Financial Accounting Standards Number 10, “Maintenance
-excludes activities aimed at expanding the capacity of an asset or otherwise upgrading it to serve needs
-different from or significantly greater than those originally intended.” Maintenance costs refer to all costs
-(including all related personnel costs) needed to sustain an IT asset at the current capability and performance
-levels.
-
-Major IT Investment refers to an IT investment requiring special management attention because of its
-importance to the mission or function to the government; significant program or policy implications; high
-executive visibility; high development, operating, or maintenance costs; unusual funding mechanism; or
-definition as major by the agency’s capital planning and investment control process. OMB may work with the
-
-Page 9 of 45
-
- (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT
-
-agency to declare IT investments as major investments. Agencies should consult with assigned OMB analysts
-regarding which investments are considered “major.” Investments not considered “major” are “non-major.”
-
-Managing Partner refers to the lead agency that is responsible for coordinating the implementation of the E-
-Gov or Line of Business (LoB) initiative. The managing partner is also responsible for coordinating and
-submitting Exhibit 300 for the initiative; Exhibit 300 will be represented as part of the managing partner's
-budget portfolio. For additional information on managing partner reporting requirements for IT investments,
-refer to the OMB MAX portal.
-
-New IT Investment refers to an IT investment and its associated projects that is newly proposed by the agency
-and that has not been previously reported/funded by OMB.
-
-Non-Major IT Investment refers to any IT investment in the agency's IT Portfolio that does not meet the
-definition of “major IT investment.” All non-major investments must be reported in Exhibit 53.
-
-Ongoing IT Investment refers to an investment and its associated assets, including both maintenance projects
-and operational activities that have been through a complete Budget Cycle with OMB with respect to the
-President's Budget for the current year (CY)—in this case, for FY 2013.
-
-Operational Analysis refers to a method of examining the ongoing performance of an operating asset
-investment and measuring that performance against an established set of cost, schedule, and performance
-goals. An operational analysis is, by nature, less structured than performance reporting methods applied to
-developmental projects and should trigger considerations of how the investment's objectives could be better
-met, how costs could be reduced, and whether the organization should continue performing a particular
-function. Guidance for Operational Analysis is described in the Capital Programming Guide.
-
-Operations refer to the day-to-day management of an asset in the production environment and include, but are
-not limited to, activities that operate data centers, help desks, operational centers, telecommunication centers,
-and end-user support services. Operational activities are reported through Section C of Exhibit 300B.
-Operations costs include the expenses associated with an IT asset that is in the production environment; costs
-to sustain an IT asset at the current capability and performance levels, including Federal and contracted labor
-costs; and costs for the disposal of an asset.
-
-Operations and Maintenance (O&M) refers to the phase of the life cycle in which the asset is in operations
-and produces the same product or provides a repetitive service. Also commonly referred to as steady state.
-
-Partner Agency refers to the agency for an E-Gov or LoB initiative that is designated to provide resources
-(e.g., funding, full-time equivalents [FTEs], in-kind) for the management, development, deployment, or
-maintenance of a common solution. The partner agency is also responsible for including the appropriate line
-items in its Exhibit 53 and reflecting the amount of the contribution for each of the E-Gov or LoB initiatives
-to which the agency provides resources.
-
-Performance-based Acquisition Management refers to a documented, systematic process for program
-management, which includes the integration of program scope, schedule and cost objectives, the establishment
-of a baseline plan for accomplishment of program objectives, and the use of earned value techniques for
-performance measurement during execution of the program. This type of management includes prototypes
-and tests to select the most cost-effective alternative during the planning phase; the work during the
-acquisition phase; and any developmental, modification, or upgrade work done during the O&M phase. A
-performance-based acquisition (as defined in the Federal Acquisition Regulation 37.101) or
-contract/agreement with a defined quality assurance plan that includes performance standards/measures
-should be the basis for monitoring contractor or in-house performance of this phase.
-
-Page 10 of 45
-
- (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT
-
-Planning refers to preparing, developing, or acquiring the information used to design the asset; assess the
-benefits, risks, and risk-adjusted costs of alternative solutions; and establish realistic cost, schedule, and
-performance goals for the selected alternative, before either proceeding to full acquisition of the capital
-project or useful component or terminating the project. Planning must progress to the point where the agency
-is ready to commit to achieving specific goals for the completion of the acquisition before proceeding to the
-acquisition phase. Information gathering activities to support planning may include market research of
-available solutions, architectural drawings, geological studies, engineering and design studies, and prototypes.
-Planning may be general to the overall investment or may be specific to a useful component.
-
-PortfolioStat refers to a face-to-face, evidence-based review of an agency's IT portfolio. Reviews can be used
-to identify and address a broad range of issues, including management of commodity IT, duplication of
-investments, and alignment with the agency’s mission and strategy. More detail regarding the PortfolioStat
-process is described in OMB memo M-12-10 – Implementing PortfolioStat.
-
-Post-Implementation Review (PIR) refers to an evaluation of how successfully the investment or project
-objectives were met and how effective the project management practices were in keeping the investment or
-project on track. A PIR can be conducted after a project has been completed, or after an investment concludes
-the implementation phase. Additional details regarding the PIR process is described in the Capital
-Programming Guide.
-
-Privacy Impact Assessment is a process for examining the risks and ramifications of using IT to collect,
-maintain, and disseminate information from or about members of the public in an identifiable form. The
-process also is also used to identify and evaluate protections and alternative processes to mitigate the impact
-to privacy of collecting such information. Consistent with OMB guidance (M-03-22) regarding implementing
-the privacy provisions of the E-Government Act, agencies must conduct and make publicly available PIAs for
-all new or significantly altered IT investments that administer information in an identifiable form collected
-from or about members of the public.
-
-Project refers to a temporary endeavor undertaken to accomplish a unique product or service with a defined
-start and end point and specific objectives that, when attained, signify completion. Projects can be undertaken
-for the development, modernization, enhancement, disposal, or maintenance of an IT asset. Projects are
-composed of activities. When reporting projects in Exhibit 300A and 300B, to the maximum extent
-practicable, agencies should detail the characteristics of “increments” under modular contracting as described
-in the Clinger-Cohen Act of 1996 and the characteristics of “useful segments,” as described in OMB Circular
-A-130.
-
-Project Manager Level of Experience refers to the specific certification(s) or number of years of direct
-project management experience that the PM holds. Examples of PM certifications include FAC-P/PM,
-Project Management Institute/PMP, and other recognized certifications.
-
-Records refers to all books, papers, maps, photographs, machine-readable materials, or other documentary
-materials, regardless of physical form or characteristics, made or received by an agency of the United States
-Government under Federal law or in connection with the transaction of public business. Records may also
-include items that are preserved or appropriate for preservation by that agency or its legitimate successor as
-evidence of the organization, functions, policies, decisions, procedures, operations, or other activities of the
-Federal Government or because of the informational value of data in them. Library and museum material
-made or acquired and preserved solely for reference or exhibition purposes, extra copies of documents
-preserved only for convenience of reference, and stocks of publications and processed documents are may not
-be included as records.
-
-Risk Management refers to a systematic process of identifying, analyzing, and responding to risk. It includes
-maximizing the probability and consequences of positive events and minimizing the probability and
-consequences of adverse events to overall objectives.
-
-Page 11 of 45
-
- (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT
-
-Risk Management Plan refers to a documented and approved plan developed at the onset of the investment
-and maintained throughout that specifies the risk management process
-
-Shared Service Provider refers to the provider of a technical solution and/or service that supports the business
-of multiple agencies using a shared architecture.
-
-TechStat refers to a face-to-face, evidence-based review of an IT program with Bureau/Agency leadership and
-OMB as appropriate. TechStat sessions enable the Federal Government to turn around, halt, or terminate IT
-investments that do not produce dividends for the American people. More detail regarding the TechStat
-process is described in the TechStat Training Deck.
-
-Unique Investment Identifier (UII) refers to a persistent numeric code applied to an investment that allows
-the identification and tracking of an investment across multiple FYs of an agency’s investment portfolio. The
-UII is composed of a three-digit agency code concatenated with a nine-digit unique investment number
-generated by the agency. Some nine-digit numbers are reserved for OMB to assign and may not be assigned
-by agencies, as controlled by the restrictions described in the section on “Variable Information.”
-
-Additional budget terms and definitions are included in the Glossary in OMB Circular A-11, Appendix J,
-“Principles of Budgeting for Capital Asset Acquisitions.”
-
-5. How do I determine whether I must report?
-
-Agencies must submit an agency IT investment portfolio (Exhibit 53A, Exhibit 53C, Exhibit 53D, and
-Exhibits 300), if the government agency is subject to Executive Branch review (see OMB Circular A-11
-Section 25.1). All CFO Act agencies and any others directed to do so must submit an agency security
-portfolio (Exhibit 53B).
-
-The following agencies must also submit this information to the IT Dashboard:
-
-Department of Agriculture
-Department of Commerce
-Department of Defense
-Department of Education
-Department of Energy
-Department of Health and Human Services
-Department of Homeland Security
-Department of Housing and Urban Development
-Department of the Interior
-Department of Justice
-Department of Labor
-Department of State
-Department of Transportation
-Department of the Treasury
-
-Department of Veteran’s Affairs
-U.S. Agency for International Development
-U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
-Environmental Protection Agency
-General Services Administration
-National Aeronautics and Space Administration
-National Archives and Records Administration
-National Science Foundation
-Nuclear Regulatory Commission
-Office of Personnel Management
-Small Business Administration
-Smithsonian Institution
-Social Security Administration
-
-The agency’s IT capital planning office should coordinate and review all versions/revisions of the Exhibit 53
-prior to submission.
-
-Page 12 of 45
-
- (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
-
-53.1 How do I submit Exhibit 53 and when is it due?
-
-Agencies must submit a draft and updated versions of Exhibit 53s using the following schedule:
-
- Draft Exhibit 53A: August 27, 2012
- Agency Budget Request Exhibit 53A, B, C, and D: September 10, 2012
- President’s Budget Request Exhibit 53A, B, C, and D: Early January 2013 (tentative)
-
-Specifically, a draft version of Exhibit 53A shall be completed by the agency and submitted to OMB. This
-draft will allow the agency and OMB to agree on which major and non-major IT investments will be reported
-as part of the next President's Budget Request and to confirm the mapping of agency investments to agency
-architectures. The initial draft of Exhibit 53A must conform to a template described later in this section,
-which will be published on the OMB MAX portal. Specific steps for completing the submission will be
-available on the OMB MAX portal. The completion of the initial draft of Exhibit 53A should be coordinated
-by the agency’s IT capital planning lead. At a minimum, the draft Exhibit 53A should include the legacy UIIs
-and current UIIs, investment name, investment description, and the FEA BRM Primary services mappings.
+5
-All subsequent updates to the Exhibit 53s will be submitted to the IT Dashboard or otherwise as directed. The
-agency’s IT capital planning office should coordinate and review all versions of Exhibit 53 prior to
-submission.
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Additional updates to Exhibits 53A and 300A may be required after final budget decisions or if the agency
-requests supplemental funds that require changes to Exhibits 53A and 300A. Specific instructions and
-deadlines for submitting updates, corrections, and final submissions of these exhibits will be available on the
-OMB MAX portal.
+Republican confidence in Trump to respect country’s
+democratic values, act ethically in office declines
-53.2 If I submitted Exhibit 53 last year, how do I revise it this year?
+% who say, thinking about the qualities needed to serve as president, they are
+extremely/very confident that Donald Trump …
-If your agency submitted Exhibit 53 for the FY 2013 Budget, the revised FY 2014 Budget must be compliant
-with the specified format or it will be rejected. Agencies must note “changes in status” for each investment
-and provide descriptions for any changes in status.
+Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026.
-It is important that the agency updates its Exhibit 53 to reflect prior year (PY) for FY 2012, current year (CY)
-for FY 2013, and budget year (BY) for FY 2014. Exhibit 53A also requires MAX funding codes for all
-"Funding Sources" line items. Consistent with prior submissions, "Investment Descriptions" will be limited to
-255 characters.
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-53.3 How is Exhibit 53 organized?
+There’s a similar pattern
+across all six qualities we asked about.
-Exhibit 53 is composed of four parts:
+For example, 60% of Republicans said last February that they were extremely or very confident
+Trump respects the country’s democratic values – it’s 52% today. And while 66% of Republicans
+say he has the mental fitness to do the job, that’s down from three-quarters last year.
-1. Exhibit 53A, “Agency IT Investment Portfolio,” which includes IT investment budget and
+Democrats’ confidence in Trump on these measures remains very low.
-architecture information;
+For full trend on each of the qualities asked on the survey, refer to chart appendix.
-2. Exhibit 53B, “Agency IT Security Portfolio,” which includes a summary of agency and bureau IT
+www.pewresearch.org
-security information, including IT security costs; and
+6
-3. Exhibit 53C, “Agency Cloud Computing Portfolio,” which includes IT investment budget information
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-by cloud computing deployment model and service model.
+Support for Trump’s policies
-4. Exhibit 53D, “Agency IT Reductions and Reinvestments” (see OMB M-12-13)
+There has also been a significant decline over
+the last year in the share of adults who say they
+agree with Trump’s plans and policies.
-Agencies should compare all relevant portfolios to ensure consistency. For example, the sum of columns 41
-to 43 on Exhibit 53A should equal the sums of each table in Exhibit 53C.
+Republican support for Trump’s agenda
+has declined over the last year
-Page 13 of 45 Exhibit 53
+% who say they support all/most of Donald Trump’s
+plans and policies
- (2012)
+▪ Last year, 35% said they supported all or
+most of his plans, 17% supported some of
+them and 47% supported only a few or
+none.
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
+▪ Today, 27% say they support all or most,
-Agency IT Investment Portfolio (Exhibit 53A)
+20% support some and 52% support few or
+none.
-(a) Overview
+The decline in support has come
+exclusively among Republicans. Last
+year, 67% said they supported all or most
+of Trump’s plans and policies. Today, 56% do.
-Exhibit 53A is a report of all agency IT investments. Investment costs are to be provided in millions of
-dollars, and reporting three decimal places (precision to thousands of dollars) is recommended, although
-agencies may report up to six decimal places (whole dollars).
+Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026.
-Information reported in Exhibit 53A should be consistent with data reported in MAX schedule O, object
-classification (specifically, object classes 11.1 through 12.2, 23.1, 23.2, 25.2, 25.3, 25.7, 26.0, 31.0, and 41.0).
-All major and non-major IT investments must be reported in Exhibit 53A.
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Agencies must note all Federal budgetary resources (includes carryover and new budget authority) used to
-fund an IT investment, including discretionary or mandatory funding sources, user fees, or gifts. Funding
-should represent only Federal budgetary resources. Agencies should not include funding provided by non-
-Federal sources, such as in matching funds for grant programs provided by state or local governments.
+Very small shares of Democrats say they support his policies. Most (87%) support only a few or
+none.
-Funding levels in Exhibit 53A should represent:
+Related: Few Americans support Trump’s proposed takeover of Greenland.
- Estimated budgetary resources for BY (this may be different from the estimated obligations on the
+For full trend details, refer to the appendix.
-Exhibit 300 for some investments)
+www.pewresearch.org
- Estimated budgetary resources for CY (based on enactment where applicable) (this may be different
+7
-from the estimated obligations on the Exhibit 300 for some investments)
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
- Expended budgetary resources (actuals) for PY (or the best current estimate) (this cost should
+Republicans increasingly say GOP
+members of Congress aren’t obligated to
+support Trump if they disagree with him
-represent the actual costs reported to the Exhibit 300)
+% of Rep/Lean Rep who say Republicans in Congress …
-These levels should be consistent with program-level funding and branch, bureau, and agency summary
-funding tables. Funding from supplemental appropriations and the Recovery Act should also be included in a
-manner consistent with other budget submission displays of program data.
+Do Republicans in Congress have an
+obligation to support Trump?
-Exhibit 53A has six major parts:
+Today, 38% of Republicans and Republican-
+leaning independents say that congressional
+Republicans “have an obligation to support
+Trump’s policies and programs because he is a
+Republican president.” But a far larger share
+(61%) say GOP members of Congress do not
+have an obligation to support Trump if they
+disagree with him.
-Part 1.
-Part 2.
-Part 3.
-Part 4.
-Part 5.
-Part 6.
+The share saying Republicans in Congress do
+not have this obligation is up since last year,
+from 55%.
-IT Investments for Mission Delivery and Management Support
-IT Investments for Infrastructure, Office Automation, and Telecommunications
-IT Investments for EA, Capital Planning, and CIO Functions
-IT Investments for Grants Management Systems
-National Security Systems IT Investments
-Grants to State and Local IT Investments
+Note: No answer responses are not shown.
+Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026.
-All parts use the following common data elements:
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Agency Description of Change in Investment Status is used when an indicator has been chosen for “Change
-in Investment Status” in order to provide a description of the rationale for the change which may include
-impacted UPIs, specific references to legislative requirements, or governance board decisions and effective
-dates.
+www.pewresearch.org
-Agency Funding is the agency’s budgetary resources for a given investment.
+8
-Change in Investment Status is used when an investment has a change in status (e.g., downgraded to non-
-major investment, eliminated, retired, consolidated, split) for the current budget submission relative to the
-previous budget cycle. The change of status should be indicated with one of the following reasons:
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Page 14 of 45 Exhibit 53
+Other key findings from the survey
- (2012)
+Democrats increasingly say their congressional
+leaders should stand up to Trump on their issues
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
+% of Rep/Lean Rep who say
+Donald Trump should …
-1. Upgrade
-2. Downgrade
-3. Split
-4. Consolidation
-5. Reorganization
-6. Eliminated by funding
-7. Eliminated by split
-8. Eliminated by consolidation
-9. Eliminated by reorganization
-10. New
-11. No Change in Status
+% of Dem/Lean Dem who say
+Democratic congressional leaders
+should …
-Cloud Computing Alternatives Evaluation specifies whether, as of the date of the submission, a cloud
-alternative was evaluated for the investment or components/systems within the investment, per the Cloud First
-policy. All investments should answer this question regardless of the overall lifecycle stage of the investment,
-as operational investments may consider performing such an evaluation during or as a result of an operational
-analysis. The evaluation should indicate one of the following answers:
+▪ Democrats
-1. The agency evaluated a cloud alternative and chose a cloud alternative for some or all of the investment.
-2. The agency evaluated a cloud alternative but did not choose a cloud alternative for any of the investment.
-3. The agency did not evaluate a cloud alternative but plans to evaluate a cloud alternative by the end of the BY.
-4. The agency did not evaluate a cloud alternative and does not plan to evaluate a cloud alternative by the end of
+overwhelmingly say
+their congressional
+leadership should
+stand up to Trump.
+Today, 82% (up from 70%
+last year) want to see their
+leaders pushing back
+against Trump, even if that
+makes it harder to address
+problems. A smaller
+majority of Republicans
+(61%) say Trump should
+stand up to Democratic
+leaders. This is similar to
+their views a year ago.
-the BY.
+▪ Nearly half of
-Cloud Computing Spending refers to implementation and operational costs directly attributable to the cloud
-computing systems “within” the investment for the specified year.
+Note: No answer responses are not shown.
+Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026.
-Cross-Boundary Information Sharing is an activity that crosses a bureau or agency boundary, including
-information sharing with international, state, local, tribal, industry, or non-governmental organization partners.
-If the investment supports reusable, standardized information exchanges, agencies must indicate which of the
-following were used:
-
-1. NIEM
-2. UCORE
-3. XBRL
-4. Other
-5. None
-
-Current UII includes an agency code and a nine-digit unique identifier. Variable information formerly
-included in the UPI of previous years is not part of the UII primary key. Details are provided in Section 53.4.
-
-Development/Modernization/Enhancement Expenditures are the costs for projects leading to new IT assets
-and projects that change or modify existing IT assets to: improve capability or performance, implement
-legislative or regulatory requirements, or meet agency leadership requests. These expenditures correspond to
-capitalized costs, and expenses may include: hardware; software; Federal and contracted labor for system
-planning, development, acquisition, and integration; and direct overhead and project management. If non-
-repairable or non-working IT hardware or software is replaced to continue the operation of an asset, and as a
-result improves the capability or performance of an asset, the expense should be categorized as operations.
-
-FEA BRM Services include three-digit codes that indicate the service area served by the investment. The first
-three-digit code indicates the primary service area (the three-digit BRM service code) and the second through
-fifth three-digit codes indicate the secondary services associated with the investment. Guidance on providing
-appropriate FEA BRM Services mapping codes can be found at FEA Reference Model document library.
-
-Page 15 of 45 Exhibit 53
-
- (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
-
-Functional/Business Sponsor is the name of the agency official who is responsible for the program or
-function supported or implemented by the investment {44 U.S.C. 3501 (a) (4)}. The sponsor is responsible
-for expressing the value of, ensuring successful implementation of, and providing accurate and timely data for
-the IT investment to the agency CIO and OMB. The designated person may (or may not) be the same as the
-“Business Process owner/Subject Matter Expert” listed for a major investment on the Exhibit 300A under
-Integrated Program Team. Each major and non-major investment listed in Exhibit 53 must include the name
-of the functional/business sponsor as well as the individual’s title, phone number, and e-mail address.
-
-Funding Source means for each investment, the agency must identify the funding source and budgetary
-resources, including the MAX funding codes used for the investment. An agency should add as many funding
-source line items as are appropriate for the investment. To avoid double counting or under counting, the totals
-of the funding amounts for an investment must match the main investment line item, represented with the
-investment category of "00," "24," or “48.” See definition in section 4.
-
-Government FTE Number and Percentage means the number of government FTE included in the BY
-funding and the percentage of the total BY cost represented by the number of government FTE. This applies
-to all investments, both major and non-major. If an FTE’s costs are included in the investment costs for BY,
-the FTE or portion of the FTE should be reported, regardless of the FTE’s role in the investment (technical,
-managerial, functional, etc.).
-
-Homeland Security Priority Identifier means an IT investment supporting the homeland security mission
-areas of 1) Intelligence and warning, 2) Border and transportation security, 3) Defense against catastrophic
-threats, 4) Protection of critical infrastructure and key assets, 5) Emergency preparedness and response, 6)
-Other, 0) None. If the investment supports one or more of these mission areas, indicate which one(s) by
-listing the corresponding number(s) listed above.
-
-Homeland Security Presidential Directive-12 (HSPD-12) Costs refer to all costs to implement or provide
-logical access to the systems within the investment for the PY, per HSPD-12. HPSD-12 costs should be
-provided for all relevant investments, both major and non-major.
-
-Investment Description means a short public-facing description (limited to 255 characters) for each
-investment (major, migration, partner contribution, and non-major). This description should explain the
-purpose of the investment and what program(s) it supports, including the value to the public. The description
-should be understandable to someone who is not an expert of the agency. If the investment is part of a multi-
-agency initiative or another business case, the agency should describe where that business case is located in
-the appropriate agency Budget submission (e.g., managing partner UII). For example, if the investment
-represents your agency's participation in one of the Presidential initiatives, the description should state this
-information and refer to the UII of the managing partner's business case.
-
-Investment Title means a definitive title explaining the investment. For "funding source" information,
-provide the 10-digit OMB MAX account code (OMB Circular A-11, Section 79.2). To the extent that they are
-not part of the name used by the agency, other identifiers such as bureaus or other numeric codes should not
-be included as part of an Investment Title.
-
-Operations & Maintenance (Steady State) Costs describes the expenses associated with an IT asset that is in
-the O&M life cycle phase. Operations expenses include maintenance projects and operation costs needed to
-sustain the IT asset at the current capability and performance levels, including: Federal and contracted labor
-costs, corrective hardware and software maintenance, voice and data communications maintenance and
-service, replacement of broken or obsolete IT equipment, and overhead costs.
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Previous UII means the identifier depicting agency code and unique investment number used to report the
-investment in the previous BY Exhibit 53 submission to OMB. Indicating the UII used for a previous
+Americans (47%) now
+say Trump will be an
+unsuccessful president
+in the long term. This share is up 14 points since last year, with most of this change
+occurring among Democrats. A majority of Republicans continue to say Trump will be
+successful in the long run.
-Page 16 of 45 Exhibit 53
+▪ Trump’s approval among Republicans is now 73% – down slightly since
- (2012)
+September. Older Americans, White adults and those without a college degree continue to
+approve of his performance more than others. See detailed tables for additional demographic
+breaks.
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
+www.pewresearch.org
-submission allows cross-walk and historical analysis crossing FYs for tracking purposes. Previous UII is
-mandatory, with the exception of new investments. To indicate consolidations/splits/reorganizations, agencies
-can provide more than one entry and separate UIIs with commas.
-Supports Information Sharing, Access, and Safeguarding refers to an IT investment that supports the
-information sharing, access, and safeguarding mission areas of: 1) The national network of state and major
-urban area fusion centers; 2) Assured interoperability across Controlled Unclassified Information /Sensitive
-but Unclassified networks targeting Federal, state, local, and tribal law enforcement, public safety, homeland
-security, and intelligence personnel; 3) Assured interoperability across classified SECRET networks; 4)
-Nationwide suspicious activity reporting initiative; 5) Alerts, Warnings and Notifications; and 6) Case and
-event deconfliction; or 0) None. If the investment supports one or more of these mission areas, indicate which
-one(s) by listing the corresponding number(s) listed above.
+9
-(b) Part 1. IT Investments for Mission Delivery Areas and Management Support Areas1
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Report all IT investments directly supporting an agency-designated mission delivery area or management
-support area (“Mission delivery area” means programs or activities that execute the agency mission as
-outlined in the agency strategic plan. “Management support area” means activities such as human resource
-management, financial management, and command and control.). The investments support these mission
-deliveries should be consistent with your agency's strategic and annual performance plan. Include capital
-costs (planning, development, modernization, and enhancement) and O&M expenses for each IT investment.
+Appendix: Additional charts
-Agencies must include an area titled “Financial Management,” and it must be reported as the first area.
-Report all IT investments for major financial management systems in this area.
+Confidence in Trump on several key qualities and
+abilities needed to serve as president
-(c) Part 2. IT Investments for Infrastructure, IT Security, Office Automation, and Telecommunications
+% who say, thinking about the qualities needed to serve as president, they are
+extremely/very confident that Donald Trump …
-Report all IT investments supporting planning, development, modernization, enhancement, operation, and
-maintenance of common user systems such as IT infrastructure and IT security. Each agency may submit
-multiple Exhibits 300 encompassing office automation, infrastructure, security, and telecommunications for
-the agency. These investments may be defined at the bureau level and/or by functional components of the
-infrastructure. These IT infrastructure investments may support multiple mission areas and should include
-end-user services and support, mainframes and servers services and support, and telecommunications services
-and support. IT infrastructure includes direct costs—those that produce tangible IT products or services for
-business users—and indirect costs—those that do not lead to a tangible product or direct support of business
-users—such as IT program management costs and overhead expenses.
+Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026.
-Agencies are encouraged to report these investments as they are managed. If IT infrastructure is managed at
-both the agency and bureau levels, agencies should report both agency and bureau-level infrastructure
-investments.
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-(d) Part 3. IT Investments for EA, Capital Planning, and CIO Functions
+www.pewresearch.org
-Report all IT investments supporting the strategic management of IT operations (e.g., business process
-redesign efforts that are not part of an individual investment, EA development, capital planning and
-investment control processes, procurement management, IT policy development and implementation). IT
-investments in this part of Exhibit 53A should include costs for CIO functions.
+10
-(e) Part 4. IT Investments for Grants Management Systems
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-1 For the purpose of Exhibit 53, IT Investments for EA, Capital Planning, and CIO Functions remain in Part 3 and IT
-Investments for Grants Management Systems remain in Part 4.
+Will Trump be a successful president in the long term?
-Page 17 of 45 Exhibit 53
+% who say Donald Trump will be a(n) ___ president in the long run
- (2012)
+Note: No answer responses are not shown.
+Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026.
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Report all IT investments supporting information regarding the planning, development, modernization,
-enhancement, and operation of grants management systems.
+Have the Trump administration’s actions since taking
+office in 2025 been better or worse than expected?
-(f) Part 5. National Security Systems Investments
+% who say the Trump administration’s actions since taking office last year
+have been ___ expected
-Report all IT investments that represent planning, development, modernization, enhancement, and operation
-of national security systems. Only the Department of Defense should report investments in Part 5.
+Note: No answer responses are not shown.
+Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026.
-(g) Part 6. Grants to State and Local IT Investments
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Report amounts for grants to state and local agencies that fund the planning, development, modernization,
-enhancement, and operation of state and local IT systems. Agencies should only use Part 6 to report "Grants
-to State and Local” and not the systems that support these grant activities. Before using Part 6 for anything
-other than these types of investments, check with your agency’s OMB E-Gov analyst.
+www.pewresearch.org
-Agency Security Portfolio (Exhibit 53B)
+11
-The Agency Security Portfolio is to be completed at the agency level, not at the individual investment level.
-Exhibit 53B uses the following data elements (as they appear in Exhibit 53B). Note that eight data elements
-that were previously provided separately (see the BY2012 Exhibit 53B guidance) are to be reported in the
-aggregate of “Total IT Security Tools Costs.”
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
- Total IT Security Tools Costs (Anti-Virus)—a program that monitors desktops/laptops to identify all
+Public support for Trump’s policies and plans
-major types of viruses and prevent or contain virus incidents.
+% who say they support ___ of Donald Trump’s policies and plans
- Total IT Security Tools Costs (Anti-Malware)—a program that monitors a computer or network to
+Note: No answer responses are not shown.
+Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026.
-identify all major types of malware and prevent or contain malware incidents.
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
- Total IT Security Tools Costs (Data Leakage Protection Tools)—systems designed to detect and
-prevent the unauthorized use and transmission of confidential information including encryption for
-PII.
+www.pewresearch.org
- Total IT Security Tools Costs (E-mail Filtering Software)—software that organizes e-mail according
+12
-to defined criteria, most commonly used for detecting and eliminating spam and malware.
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
- Total Security Tools Costs (Intrusion Detection System [IDS])—software that looks for suspicious
+Trump’s approval rating in first year of
+his second term
-activity on networks and alerts administrators.
+% who approve of the way Donald Trump is handling
+his job as president
- Total IT Security Tools Costs (Intrusion Prevention System [IPS])—systems that can detect an
-intrusive activity on networks and attempt to stop the activity, ideally before it reaches its targets.
- Total IT Security Tools Costs (Security Information Management [SIM]/Security Information and
-Event Management [SIEM])—software/systems that collect security data (e.g., event logs) into a
-central repository for trend analysis.
+84
- Total IT Security Tools Costs (Web filtering software—also known as Content-Control software or
-Censorware)—software designed and optimized for controlling what content is permitted to a reader,
-especially when it is used to restrict material delivered over the web. Content-control software
-determines what content will be available.
+Rep/Lean Rep
-Page 18 of 45 Exhibit 53
+80
- (2012)
+75
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
+78
-Agency Cloud Computing Portfolio (Exhibit 53C)
+74
-The Agency Cloud Computing Portfolio is to be completed at the agency level, not at the individual
-investment level. Exhibit 53C is comprised of two tables to report the following data elements for each year
-(PY, CY, BY). Note that the sum of each year should match across the two tables and this sum should match
-the sum of columns 41 to 43 of Exhibit 53A. For definitions of terms used in Exhibit 53C, see NIST Special
-Publication 800-146. Only costs directly attributable to cloud computing implementations, operations or
-services should be reported, which may only be a portion of the total cost of contributing/associated
-investments.
+Total
-(a) Agency costs for cloud computing by deployment model, by year (PY, CY, BY)
+47
- Public Cloud portion of all agency cloud computing spending
- Private Cloud portion of all agency cloud computing spending
- Community Cloud portion of all agency cloud computing spending
- Hybrid Cloud portion of all agency cloud computing spending
+40
-(b) Agency costs for cloud computing by service model, by year (PY, CY, BY)
+41
- Software as a Service (SaaS) portion of all agency cloud computing spending
- Platform as a Service (PaaS) portion of all agency cloud computing spending
-
+38 40
-Infrastructure as a Service (IaaS) portion of all agency cloud computing spending
+Dem/Lean Dem
-53.4 How is Exhibit 53A coded?
+10
-Use the following UII 12-digit line number coding, and additional six 2-digit variable information fields, to
-categorize investments and line structure for your Exhibit 53A. Each investment identified in the agency's
-portfolio must have a unique UII.
+7
-Entry
+7
-Description
+6
-Unique Investment Identifier Primary Key
+6
-XXX-
-xxxxxxxxx
+73
-xxx-
-XXXXXXXXX
+37
-The first three digits represent your agency code (see Appendix C of OMB Circular A-11).
+5
-The last nine digits serve as your unique identifier. This identifier should be system
-generated and applied at the agency level. It will allow agencies up to one billion unique
-identifiers to associate with IT investments. Once used, the unique identifier must be
-retired. If an IT investment is retired, discontinued, or merged with another IT
-investment, the unique identifier persists with that IT investment.
+Feb '25
-Note: “99999XXXX” codes are reserved for approved multi-agency investments,
-including E-Gov and LoB initiatives
+Jan '26
-Page 19 of 45 Exhibit 53
+Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026.
- (2012)
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
+www.pewresearch.org
-Variable Information: The following attributes extracted from the FY 2012 Budget cycle and prior years’
-UPI should continue to be supplied.
+13
-XX-xx-
-xx-xx-
-xx-xx
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-xx-XX-
-xx-xx-
-xx-xx
+Acknowledgments
-xx-xx-
-XX-xx-
-xx -xx
+This report is a collaborative effort based on the input and analysis of the following individuals:
-xx-xx-
-xx-XX-
-xx-xx
+Research team
-xx-xx-
-xx-xx-
-XX-xx
+Communications and editorial
-00 = Code for all investments other than those coded “24” or “48”
+Jocelyn Kiley, Director, Political Research
+Steven Shepard, Associate Director, Political
+Research
+Hannah Hartig, Senior Researcher
+Baxter Oliphant, Senior Researcher
+Gabe Borelli, Research Associate
+Andrew Daniller, Research Associate
+Andy Cerda, Research Analyst
+Joseph Copeland, Research Analyst
+Shanay Gracia, Research Analyst
+Ted Van Green, Research Analyst
-24 = E-Gov initiatives or an individual agency's participation in one of the E-Gov initiatives
+Nida Asheer, Senior Communications
+Manager
+Maya Pottinger, Communications Associate
+David Kent, Senior Editorial Specialist
+Anna Jackson, Editorial Specialist
-48 = Any multi-agency collaboration or an individual agency’s participation in one of the multi-agency
-initiatives, excluding E-Gov initiatives
+Graphic design and web publishing
-The next two digits indicate your bureau code (see Appendix C of OMB Circular A-11). If this is
-a department level or an agency-wide activity, use 00 as your bureau code.
+Peter Bell, Associate Director, Design and
+Production
+Alissa Scheller, Senior Information Graphics
+Designer
+Reem Nadeem, Digital Producer
+Beshay Sakla, Associate Digital Producer
-These two digits indicate the six parts of Exhibit 53:
+Methodology
-01 = Part 1. IT Investments for Mission Delivery and Management Support Area
+Andrew Mercer, Senior Research
+Methodologist
+Dorene Asare-Marfo, Senior Panel Manager
+Dana Popky, Associate Panel Manager
+Arnold Lau, Research Methodologist
-02 = Part 2. IT Investments for Infrastructure, IT Security, Office Automation, and Telecommunications
+www.pewresearch.org
-03 = Part 3. IT Investments for EA, Capital Planning, and CIO Functions
+14
-04 = Part 4. IT Investments for Grants Management Systems
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-05 = Part 5. National Security Systems IT Investments (Department of Defense Only)
-06 = Part 6. Grants to State and Local IT Investments
+Methodology
-These two digits indicate the mission delivery and management support areas. Agencies should
-assign a unique code for each mission delivery and management support area reported.
+The American Trends Panel
-These two digits indicate your agency's type of investment. Select one of the following two digit
-codes according to the type of investment you are reporting:
+survey methodology
-01 = Major IT investments (see definition in Section 4)
+Overview
-02 = Non-major IT investments (see definition in Section 4)
+Data in this report comes from Wave 185 of the American Trends Panel (ATP), Pew Research
+Center’s nationally representative panel of randomly selected U.S. adults. The survey was
+conducted from Jan. 20 to Jan. 26, 2026. A total of 8,512 panelists responded out of 9,302 who
+were sampled, for a survey-level response rate of 92%.
-03 = IT migration investment portion of a larger asset and for which there is an existing business case for the
-overall asset. The description of the IT investment should indicate the UII of the major asset investment of
-the managing partner.
+The cumulative response rate accounting for all stages of nonresponse and attrition is 3%. The
+break-off rate among panelists who logged on to the survey and completed at least one item is 2%.
+The margin of sampling error for the full sample of 8,512 respondents is plus or minus 1.4
+percentage points.
-04 = Investments where the business case for the major IT investment is reported in another agency's Exhibit
-53. The description of the IT investment should indicate the UII of the major asset investment of the
-managing partner.
+The survey includes oversamples of non-Hispanic Asian adults and adults ages 18-to-29 in order
+to provide more precise estimates of the opinions and experiences of these smaller demographic
+subgroups. These oversampled groups are weighted back to reflect their correct proportions in the
+population.
-xx-xx-
-xx-xx-
-xx-XX
+SSRS conducted the survey for Pew Research Center via online (n=8,272) and live telephone
+(n=240) interviewing. Interviews were conducted in both English and Spanish.
-These two digits identify the nature of the “line item” in the Exhibit 53 structure. The digits
-represent the line number in both the XML format used for agencies on the IT Dashboard and the
-line number in an equivalent spreadsheet file (CSV or XLS file), for agencies not on the IT
-Dashboard:
+To learn more about the ATP, read “About the American Trends Panel.”
-00 = Total investment title line, structurally the first line for reporting this particular investment
+Panel recruitment
-04 = Funding source or appropriation
-[09 = Any subtotal – This value is only used only for agencies not on the IT Dashboard]
+Since 2018, the ATP has used address-based sampling (ABS) for recruitment. A study cover letter
+and a pre-incentive are mailed to a stratified, random sample of households selected from the U.S.
+Postal Service’s Computerized Delivery Sequence File. This Postal Service file has been estimated
+to cover 90% to 98% of the population.1 Within each sampled household, the adult with the next
+birthday is selected to participate. Other details of the ABS recruitment protocol have changed
+over time but are available upon request.2 Prior to 2018, the ATP was recruited using landline and
+cellphone random-digit-dial surveys administered in English and Spanish.
-Page 20 of 45 Exhibit 53
+1 AAPOR Task Force on Address-based Sampling. 2016. “AAPOR Report: Address-based Sampling.”
+2 Email pewsurveys@pewresearch.org.
- (2012)
+www.pewresearch.org
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
+15
-Use the following 10-digit number coding system to update or complete your OMB MAX account ID code
-information:
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Entry
+A national sample of U.S. adults has been recruited to the ATP approximately once per year since
+2014. In some years, the recruitment has included additional efforts (known as an “oversample”)
+to improve the accuracy of data for underrepresented groups. For example, Hispanic adults, Black
+adults and Asian adults were oversampled in 2019, 2022 and 2023, respectively.
-Description
+Sample design
-XXX-xx-xxxx-x
+The overall target population for this survey was noninstitutionalized persons ages 18 and older
+living in the United States. It featured a stratified random sample from among ATP members who
+previously completed Wave 183. Non-Hispanic Asian adults and adults ages 18 to 29 were selected
+with certainty. The remaining panelists were sampled at rates designed to ensure that the share of
+respondents in each stratum is proportional to its share of the U.S. adult population to the greatest
+extent possible. Respondent weights are adjusted to account for differential probabilities of
+selection as described in the Weighting section below.
-The first three digits are your agency code (see Appendix C of OMB Circular A-11).
+Questionnaire development and testing
-xxx-XX-xxxx-x
+The questionnaire was developed by Pew Research Center in consultation with SSRS. The web
+program used for online respondents was rigorously tested on both PC and mobile devices by the
+SSRS project team and Pew Research Center researchers. The SSRS project team also populated
+test data that was analyzed in SPSS to ensure the logic and randomizations were working as
+intended before launching the survey.
-The next two digits are your bureau code (see Appendix C of OMB Circular A-11).
+Incentives
-xxx-xx-XXXX-x
+All respondents were offered a post-paid incentive for their participation. Respondents could
+choose to receive the post-paid incentive in the form of a check or gift code to Amazon.com,
+Target.com or Walmart.com. Incentive amounts ranged from $5 to $20 depending on whether the
+respondent belongs to a part of the population that is harder or easier to reach. Differential
+incentive amounts were designed to increase panel survey participation among groups that
+traditionally have low survey response propensities.
-This is a four-digit account symbol for the appropriate MAX account (see Section 79.2 of
-OMB Circular A-11).
+Data collection protocol
-xxx-xx-xxxx-X
+The data collection field period for this survey was Jan. 20 to Jan. 26, 2026. Surveys were
+conducted via self-administered web survey or by live telephone interviewing.
-This is a single digit Transmittal Code (see Section 79.2 of OMB Circular A-11).
-For the purposes of Exhibit 53A only, funding sources should continue to utilize the “-9” transmittal code to
-flag funding from the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (ARRA).
+www.pewresearch.org
-Use the following set of 3-digit numbers to identify each investment’s primary service area and, if desired, up
-to four secondary service areas:
+16
-Entry
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Description
+For panelists who take surveys online:3 Postcard notifications were mailed to a subset on
+Jan. 20.4 Survey invitations were sent out in two separate launches: soft launch and full launch.
+Sixty panelists were included in the soft launch, which began with an initial invitation sent on Jan.
+20. All remaining English- and Spanish-speaking sampled online panelists were included in the
+full launch and were sent an invitation on Jan. 21.
-XXX (primary services)
+Invitation and reminder dates for web respondents,
+ATP Wave
-The first three digits identify the investment’s primary service area from the
-FEA BRM version 3.0.
+Soft launch
-XXX (secondary services)
+Jan. 20, 2026
-The second, third, fourth, and fifth set of three digits identify the investment’s
-secondary service area(s) from the FEA BRM version 3.0. Agencies should
-select from the following three-digit codes to map investments to primary and
-secondary service areas.
+Jan. 22, 2026
-53.5 What are the steps to complete Exhibit 53?
+Jan. 24, 2026
-Exhibit 53 is separated into four sub-exhibits. The following table provides step-by-step instructions to
-complete each part. See Section 4 and 53.3 for definitions.
+Full launch
-AGENCY IT INVESTMENT PORTFOLIO
+Jan. 21, 2026
-Entry
+Jan. 22, 2026
-Description
+Jan. 24, 2026
-Part 1. IT Investments for
-Mission Delivery Area
-and Management Support
-Area
+Initial invitation
-Report IT investments that directly support an agency-designated mission
-delivery and management support area as well as the mission delivery and
-management support area it supports. This information should map directly to
-your agency's strategic and annual performance plan. For IT investments that
-cover more than one agency, report in the mission area with oversight of the IT
-investment. Mission delivery and management support area 01 is reserved for IT
-investments for major financial management systems.
+First reminder
-Page 21 of 45 Exhibit 53
+Final reminder
- (2012)
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
+Panelists participating online were sent an email invitation and up to two email reminders if they
+did not respond to the survey. ATP panelists who consented to SMS messages were sent an SMS
+invitation with a link to the survey and up to two SMS reminders.
-IT investments for infrastructure, IT security, office automation, and
-telecommunications are reported in Part 2 of Exhibit 53A. Report all IT
-investments supporting common user systems, security, communications, and
-computing infrastructure. Each agency may have multiple Exhibit 300s
-encompassing office automation, infrastructure, IT security, and
-telecommunications for the agency. It is encouraged that these investments be
-reported at the point of management and thus may be defined at the bureau level
-and/or by functional components of the infrastructure. These may involve
-multiple mission areas and include end-user systems and support, mainframes
-and servers services and support, and telecommunications services and support.
-All IT investments capturing these shared services are to be included in Part 2.
+For panelists who take surveys over the phone with a live interviewer: Prenotification
+postcards were mailed on Jan. 16. Soft launch took place on Jan. 20 and involved dialing until a
+total of four interviews had been completed. All remaining English- and Spanish-speaking
+sampled phone panelists’ numbers were dialed throughout the remaining field period. Panelists
+who take surveys via phone can receive up to six calls from trained SSRS interviewers.
-List all EA, IT capital planning, and CIO function investments. For the
-President's Budget, EA, IT capital planning, and CIO function investments are
-not categorized as major investments and an Exhibit 300 is not required for them.
-Any capital planning and investment control process investments may be
-reported separately in this section. However, agencies should ensure that
-investments identified in variable information coding as belonging in Part 3 of
-Exhibit 53A have the correct primary FEA mapping in order to clearly
-distinguish the EA investments from other planning investments.
+Data quality checks
-Report IT investments that support grants management operations. See
-classification instructions in Section 53.3a under Grants Management.
+To ensure high-quality data, Center researchers performed data quality checks to identify any
+respondents showing patterns of satisficing. This includes checking for whether respondents left
+questions blank at very high rates or always selected the first or last answer presented. As a result
+of this checking, two ATP respondents were removed from the survey dataset prior to weighting
+and analysis.
-Part 2. IT Investments for
-Infrastructure, IT
-Security, Office
-Automation, and
-Telecommunications
+3 The ATP does not use routers or chains in any part of its online data collection protocol, nor are they used to direct respondents to additional
+surveys.
+4 Postcard notifications for web panelists are sent to 1) panelists who were recruited within the last two years and 2) panelists recruited prior
+to the last two years who opt to continue receiving postcard notifications.
-Part 3. IT Investments for
-EA, Capital Planning, and
-CIO Functions
+www.pewresearch.org
-Part 4. IT Investments for
-Grants Management
-Systems
+17
-Part 5. National Security
-Systems IT Investments
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Report IT investments related to national security systems (Department of
-Defense only).
+American Trends Panel weighting dimensions
-Part 6. Grants to State
-and Local IT Investments
+Variable
+Age (detailed)
+Age x Gender
+Education x Gender
+Education x Age
+Race/Ethnicity x Education
+Race/Ethnicity x Gender
+Race/Ethnicity x Age
+Born inside vs. outside the U.S. among
+Hispanics and Asian Americans
+Years lived in the U.S.
+Census region x Metropolitan status
-Report total amounts for IT investments for grants to state and local
-governments.
+Volunteerism
-Page 22 of 45 Exhibit 53
+Frequency of internet use
+Religious affiliation
+Party affiliation x Race/Ethnicity
+Party affiliation x Age
- (2012)
+Validated 2024 presidential election
+turnout and vote choice
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
+Benchmark source
-AGENCY IT INVESTMENT PORTFOLIO (COLUMNS)
+2023 American Community Survey
+(ACS)
-The following columns are required for the President's Budget Exhibit 53A, Agency IT Investment Portfolio:
+2023 CPS Volunteering & Civic Life
+Supplement
+2025 National Public Opinion
+Reference Survey (NPORS)
-Column 1: Previous UII (12 digits required for all legacy investments)
+Candidate vote share is based on
+official results from the Federal
+Election Commission. Turnout is
+based on estimates from the Election
+Lab at the University of Florida. The
+size of the voting-eligible population is
+based on the 2023 ACS.
-Column 2: Current UII (12-digit primary key for all investments)
+Note: Estimates from the ACS are based on noninstitutionalized adults. For weighting to the
+2024 presidential election results, panelists are considered validated voters if their self-
+report of having voted was confirmed after matching to a national voter registry.
-Column 3: Investment Category (2-digit code)
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Column 4: Bureau Code (2-digit code) (variable element)
+Weighting
-Column 5: Part of Exhibit 53 (2-digit code) (variable element)
+The ATP data is weighted in a
+process that accounts for
+multiple stages of sampling and
+nonresponse that occur at
+different points in the panel
+survey process. First, each
+panelist begins with a base
+weight that reflects their
+probability of recruitment into
+the panel. These weights are
+then calibrated to align with the
+population benchmarks in the
+accompanying table to correct
+for nonresponse to recruitment
+surveys and panel attrition. If
+only a subsample of panelists
+was invited to participate in the
+wave, this weight is adjusted to
+account for any differential
+probabilities of selection.
+Because respondents to this
+wave were sampled from
+among respondents to Wave
+183, the weights were also
+adjusted to account for
+nonresponse to Wave 183.
-Column 6: Mission Delivery and Management Support Area (2-digit code) (variable element)
+Among the panelists who completed the survey, this weight is then calibrated again to align with
+the population benchmarks identified in the accompanying table and trimmed at the 1st and 99th
+percentiles to reduce the loss in precision stemming from variance in the weights. Sampling errors
+and tests of statistical significance take into account the effect of weighting.
-Column 7: Type of Investment (2-digit code) (variable element)
+www.pewresearch.org
-Column 8: Line Item Descriptor (2-digit code) (variable element)
+18
-Column 9: Change in Investment Status Identifier (2-digit code)
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Column 10: Agency Description of Change in Investment Status (limited to 255 characters)
+The following table shows the unweighted sample sizes and the error attributable to sampling that
+would be expected at the 95% level of confidence for different groups in the survey.
-Column 11: Investment Title
+Sample sizes and margins of error, ATP Wave 185
-Column 12: Investment Description (limited to 255 characters)
+Group
+Total sample
-Column 13: FEA BRM Services – Primary service area (3-digit code)
+ Half form
-Column 14: FEA BRM Services – Secondary service area #1 (3-digit code)
+Rep/Lean Rep
-Column 15: FEA BRM Services – Secondary service area #2 (3-digit code)
+ Half form
-Column 16: FEA BRM Services – Secondary service area #3 (3-digit code)
+Dem/Lean Dem
-Column 17: FEA BRM Services – Secondary service area #4 (3-digit code)
+ Half form
-Column 18: Homeland Security Priority Identifier (select all that apply)
+Unweighted
+sample size
+8,512
-Column 19: HSPD-12 Cost (PY/2012) ($M)
+At least 4,250
-Column 20: Cross-Boundary Information Identifier (1-digit code)
+3,913
-Column 21: Supports Information Sharing, Access, and Safeguarding (select all that apply)
+At least 1,953
-Column 22: DME [Planning, Development/Capital Spending] (PY/2012) Agency Funding ($M)
+4,343
-Column 23: DME [Planning, Development/Capital Spending] (PY/2012) Contributions ($M)
+At least 2,164
-Column 24: DME [Planning, Development/Capital Spending] (CY/2013) Agency Funding ($M)
+Weighted %
-Column 25: DME [Planning, Development/Capital Spending] (CY/2013) Contributions ($M)
+46%
-Column 26: DME [Planning, Development/Capital Spending] (BY/2014) Agency Funding ($M)
+48%
-Column 27: DME [Planning, Development/Capital Spending] (BY/2014) Contributions ($M)
+Plus or minus …
+1.4 percentage points
-Column 28: O&M Spending [non-DME] (PY/2012) Agency Funding ($M)
+2.0 percentage points
-Column 29: O&M Spending [non-DME] (PY/2012) Contributions ($M)
+2.1 percentage points
-Column 30: O&M Spending [non-DME] (CY/2013) Agency Funding ($M)
+3.0 percentage points
-Column 31: O&M Spending [non-DME] (CY/2013) Contributions ($M)
+2.0 percentage points
-Column 32: O&M Spending [non-DME] (BY/2014) Agency Funding ($M)
+2.8 percentage points
-Column 33: O&M Spending [non-DME] (BY/2014) Contributions ($M)
+Note: This survey includes oversamples of non-Hispanic Asian adults and adults ages 18-to-29 respondents. Unweighted
+sample sizes do not account for the sample design or weighting and do not describe a group’s contribution to weighted
+estimates. See the Sample design and Weighting sections above for details.
-Column 34: Number of Government FTEs (BY/2014)
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Column 35: Percentage of Investment Cost for Government FTE (BY/2014)
+Sample sizes and sampling errors for other subgroups are available upon request. In addition to
+sampling error, one should bear in mind that question wording and practical difficulties in
+conducting surveys can introduce error or bias into the findings of opinion polls.
-Column 36: Functional/Business Sponsor Name
+www.pewresearch.org
-Column 37: Functional/Business Sponsor Title
+19
-Column 38: Functional/Business Sponsor Phone Number
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Column 39: Functional/Business Sponsor E-mail
+Dispositions and response rates
-Column 40: Cloud Computing Alternatives Evaluation
+Final dispositions, ATP Wave 185
-Column 41: Cloud Computing Spending (PY)
+Completed interview
-Column 42: Cloud Computing Spending (CY)
-Column 43: Cloud Computing Spending (BY)
+Logged in (web) / Contacted (CATI), but did not complete any items
-Page 23 of 45 Exhibit 53
+Started survey; broke off before completion
- (2012)
+Never logged on (web) / Never reached on phone (CATI)
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
+Survey completed after close of the field period
-AGENCY IT SECURITY PORTFOLIO (Exhibit 53B)
+Other non-interview
-Row
+Completed interview but was removed for data quality
-Description
+Total panelists sampled for the survey
-1 Agency code
+Completed interviews
-2 Number of government
-FTEs with information
-security responsibilities
+Partial interviews
-3 Average cost per
+Refusals
-government FTE with
-information security
-responsibilities
+Non-contact
-4 Number of contractor
-FTEs with information
-security responsibilities
+Other
-5
+Unknown household
-6
+Unknown other
-Average cost per
-contractor FTE for
-information security
-responsibilities
+Not eligible
-Total IT security tools
-cost
+Total
-List the three-digit agency identifier (see Appendix C of OMB Circular A-
-11).
+AAPOR RR1 = I / (I+P+R+NC+O+UH+UO)
-Report the number of government employees with information security
-responsibilities, including the fractional portion of those who devote a
-percentage of their time to these responsibilities. This number should
-include but should not be limited to: designated security officers, network
-security staff, system administrators, and system owners. The number
-should not include individuals responsible for physical security, such as
-guards. The number should be rounded to two decimal places.
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Using the salary information of the government employees counted in
-“Number of government FTEs with information security responsibilities,”
-calculate an average fully loaded cost per government FTE. The average
-cost should be represented in dollars and rounded to two decimal places.
+Cumulative response rate, ATP Wave 185
-Report the number of contractor staff with information security
-responsibilities, including the fractional portion of those who devote a
-percentage of their time to these responsibilities. The number should be
-rounded to two decimal places.
+Weighted response rate to recruitment surveys
-Using the billing rate of the contract staff counted in “Number of contractor
-FTEs with information security responsibilities,” calculate an average
-yearly cost per contractor FTE. The average cost should be represented in
-dollars and rounded to two decimal places.
+% of recruitment survey respondents who agreed to join the
+panel, among those invited
+% of those agreeing to join who were active panelists at start of
+Wave 185
-This is the sum of the following eight data elements, which were formerly
-provided separately in Exhibit 53B for the FY 2012 Budget cycle. Costs
-should be reported in thousands and reported to the dollar.
+Response rate to Wave 183 survey
-1. Anti-Virus Software Licensing Costs – The licensing costs incurred
+Response rate to Wave 185 survey
-or expected to be incurred for the respective BY. If an agency does not
-purchase anti-virus software separately from anti-malware software,
-enter all costs on the line for anti-malware and leave this line blank.
+Cumulative response rate
-2. Anti-Malware Software Licensing Costs – The licensing costs
-incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY.
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-3. Intrusion Detection Systems Licensing Costs – The licensing costs
+© Pew Research Center 2025
-incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY. If you have
-an IDS which is part of an IPS, include all costs in IPS and do not list
-here. Include the amount paid for the Managed Trusted Internet
-Protocol Service via the Networx contract as well as any other
-operational IDSs.
+www.pewresearch.org
-4. Intrusion Prevention Systems Licensing Costs – The licensing costs
+Total
-incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY.
-5. Web Filtering Software Licensing Costs – The licensing costs
+8,512
-incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY. Costs should
-be reported in thousands and reported to the dollar.
+145
-Page 24 of 45 Exhibit 53
+100
- (2012)
+541
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
+0
-6. E-mail Filtering Software – The licensing costs incurred or expected
-to be incurred for the respective BY. If an agency does not purchase e-
-mail filtering software separate from web filtering software, include all
-costs in web filtering software and do not list here.
+2
-7. SIM/SIEM Tools – Report the tool costs incurred or expected to be
+2
-incurred for the respective BY.
+9,302
-8. Data Leakage Protection Tools – Report the tool costs incurred or
+8,514
-expected to be incurred for the respective BY.
+0
-Report the costs incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY.
-Costs should be reported in thousands and reported to the dollar. Security
-authorization costs should only include contract costs.
+245
-Report the number of systems used to in cost calculations for “Costs for
-NIST 800-37 implementation.”
+541
-Report the costs incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY.
-Costs should be reported in thousands and reported to the dollar. Include all
-costs, including licensing of tools, services, and FTEs.
+4
-Report the costs incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY.
-Costs should be reported in thousands and reported to the dollar. Include all
-costs, including licensing of tools, services, and FTEs.
+0
-Report the costs incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY.
-Costs should be reported in thousands and reported to the dollar. Include
-the costs of annual security awareness training required by the FISMA Act.
+0
-Report the costs incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY.
-Costs should be reported in thousands and reported to the dollar. Do not
-include costs associated with annual awareness training.
+0
-Report the number of government employees with information security
-responsibilities, including the fractional portion of those who devote a
-percentage of their time to the responsibilities included in the costs reported
-in row 7 and rows 9 through 12. The associated government FTE costs
-(based on the average costs reported in row 3) will be subtracted from the
-total IT security cost to avoid any double-counting.
+9,302
-Report the number of contractor staff with information security
-responsibilities, including the fractional portion of those who devote a
-percentage of their time to the responsibilities included in the costs reported
-in row 7 and rows 9 through 12. The associated contractor FTE costs
-(based on the average costs reported in row 5) will be subtracted from the
-total IT security cost to avoid any double-counting.
+92%
-7 Costs for NIST 800-37
-implementation
+AAPOR code
-8 Number of systems
+1.1
-scheduled for activities
-represented in Row 7
+2.11
-9 Costs for annual FISMA
+2.12
-testing
+2.20
-10 Costs for network
-penetration testing
-activities
+2.27
-11 Security awareness
-training costs
+2.30
-12 Security training costs for
+2.90
-employees with
-significant security
-responsibilities
+I
-13 Number of government
+P
-FTEs included in costs for
-row 7 and rows 9 through
+R
+
+NC
+
+O
+
+UH
+
+UO
+
+NE
+
+Total
+
+12%
+
+74%
+
+40%
+
+92%
+
+92%
+
+3%
+
+20
+
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
+
+2026 PEW RESEARCH CENTER’S AMERICAN TRENDS PANEL
+WAVE 185 POLITICS JANUARY SURVEY
+FINAL TOPLINE
+January 20-26, 2026
+N=8,512
+
+Note: This survey was conducted primarily online, with some interviews conducted by live telephone. This
+topline shows the programming language for online administration. For details on how questions were slightly
+modified for phone administration, visit the questionnaire.
+
+American Trends Panel surveys conducted between October 2016 and June 2024 were conducted fully online
+(with tablets and data plans provided to adults without home internet). American Trends Panel surveys
+conducted prior to October 2016 were conducted primarily online, with some respondents completing by mail.
+For additional details, visit the Methodology.
+
+* ”No answer” includes web respondents who do not answer the question as well as telephone respondents
+who refuse to answer or who say that they don’t know how to answer. In cases where “not sure” was offered
+as an explicit option to web and telephone respondents, the “no answer” category includes only web skips and
+telephone refusals.
+
+ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,250]:
+SATIS All in all, are you satisfied or dissatisfied with the way things are going in this country today?
+
+Jan 20-26, 2026
+Oct 6-16, 2025
+Aug 4-10, 2025
+Apr 28-May 4, 2025
+Mar 10-16, 2025
+Jan 27-Feb 2, 2025
+Nov 12-17, 2024
+Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024
+Aug 5-11, 2024
+Jul 1-7, 2024
+May 13-19, 2024
+Jan 16-21, 2024
+Nov 27-Dec 3, 2023
+Jul 10-16, 2023
+Jun 5-11, 2023
+Mar 27-Apr 2, 2023
+Jan 18-24, 2023
+Nov 16-27, 2022
+Oct 10-16, 2022
+Aug 1-14, 2022
+Apr 25-May 1, 2022
+Jan 10-17, 2022
+Sep 20-26, 2021
+Sep 13-19, 2021
+Mar 1-7, 2021
+Nov 12-17, 2020
+Sep 30-Oct 5, 2020
+Jul 27-Aug 2, 2020
+
+Satisfied
+29
+27
+34
+32
+34
+38
+29
+23
+24
+18
+22
+21
+22
+22
+21
+19
+22
+24
+21
+18
+24
+21
+25
+26
+33
+22
+18
12
-14 Number of contractor
-
-FTEs included in costs for
-row 7 and rows 9 through
+Dissatisfied
+69
+72
+65
+67
+65
+61
+70
+76
+75
+82
+78
+78
+77
+77
+78
+80
+78
+75
+79
+81
+75
+78
+74
+74
+66
+77
+82
+87
+
+No answer*
+1
+1
+1
+1
+1
+1
+1
+*
+1
+*
+1
+1
+1
+1
+1
+1
+*
+1
+1
+1
+1
+1
+1
+*
+1
+1
+1
+1
+
+www.pewresearch.org
+
+21
+
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
+
+SATIS CONTINUED …
+
+Jun 16-22, 2020
+Apr 7-12, 2020
+Mar 19-24, 2020
+Oct 29-Nov 11, 2019
+Oct 1-13, 2019
+Jul 22-Aug 4, 2019
+Nov 27-Dec 10, 2018
+Jan 29-Feb 13, 2018
+Feb 28-Mar 12, 20175
+Sep 27-Oct 10, 2016
+Jun 7-Jul 5, 2016
+Sep 15-Oct 3, 2014
+
+Satisfied
12
+31
+33
+31
+28
+27
+34
+36
+32
+23
+19
+25
+
+Dissatisfied
+87
+68
+66
+69
+71
+72
+65
+63
+68
+75
+80
+75
+
+No answer*
+1
+1
+1
+1
+1
+1
+1
+1
+*
+2
+1
+*
+
+ASK FORM 2 ONLY [N=4,262]:
+YEARAHEAD
+
+Looking ahead, as far as you are concerned, do you think that 2026 will be …
+[ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-2/2-1]
+
+Better than 2025 Worse than 2025
+
+Jan 20-26, 2026
+Jan 27-Feb 2, 2025
+Jan 16-21, 2024
+Jan 18-24, 2023
+Jan 10-17, 2022
+Jan 8-12, 2021
+Jan 6-19, 2020
+
+50
+55
+55
+57
+61
+67
+55
+
+48
+45
+45
+43
+38
+32
+43
+
+No answer*
+1
+*
+1
+*
+1
+1
+2
+
+PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON:
+Looking ahead, as far as you are concerned, do you think that [coming year] will be better or worse
+than [prior year]?
+
+Jan 8-13, 2020
+Jan 9-14, 2019
+Jan 10-15, 2018
+Jan 4-9, 2017
+Jan 7-14, 2016
+Dec 3-7, 2014 (U)
+Jan 15-19, 2014
+Dec 5-9, 2012
+Jan 11-16, 2012
+Dec 1-5, 2010
+Jan 6-10, 2010
+Jan 7-11, 2009
+December, 2007
+December, 2006
+December, 1999
+December, 1998
+December, 1994
+Gallup: December, 1993
+
+Better
+55
+47
+61
+49
+56
+49
+56
+55
+57
+55
+67
+52
+50
+57
+66
+59
+59
+64
+
+Worse
+34
+43
+29
+42
+30
+42
+35
+36
+29
+31
+26
+37
+34
+28
+19
+25
+28
+20
+
+(VOL.)
+DK/Ref
+11
+10
+11
+9
+14
+9
+9
+9
+14
+14
+8
+11
+16
+15
+15
+16
+13
+16
+
+1
+
+The W24.5 Mode Study survey was administered by web and phone. Results reported here are from web mode only.
+
+www.pewresearch.org
+
+22
+
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
+
+PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON CONTINUED
+
+Gallup: December, 1992
+Gallup: December, 1991
+Gallup: December, 1990
+Gallup: December, 1986
+Gallup: December, 1985
+Gallup: December, 1984
+Gallup: December, 1982
+Gallup: December, 1981
+
+Better
+61
+61
+48
+53
+64
+61
+50
+41
+
+Worse
+11
+31
+42
+25
+20
+20
+32
+44
+
+(VOL.)
+DK/Ref
+28
+8
+10
+22
+17
+19
+18
+15
+
+ASK ALL:
+POL1DT
+ASK IF ANSWERED POL1DT (POL1DT=1,2) [N=8,378]:
+POL1DTSTR
+
+Do you approve or disapprove of the way Donald Trump is handling his job as president?
+
+Do you [IF POL1DT=1: approve; IF POL1DT=2: disapprove] of the way Donald Trump is
+handling his job as president…
+
+NET
+Approve
+
+Very
+strongly
+
+Not so
+strongly
+
+No
+answer*
+
+NET
+Disapprove
+
+Very
+strongly
+
+Not so
+strongly
+
+No
+answer*
+
+No
+answer*
+
+Trump Second Term
+Jan 20-26, 2026
+Sep 22-28, 2025
+Aug 4-10, 2025
+Jun 2-8, 2025
+Apr 7-13, 2025
+Jan 27-Feb 2, 2025
+
+Trump First Term
+Jan 8-12, 2021
+Jul 27-Aug 2, 2020
+Jun 16-22, 2020
+Apr 7-12, 2020
+Mar 19-24, 2020
+Jan 6-19, 2020
+Sep 3-15, 2019
+Jul 22-Aug 4, 2019
+Apr 29-May 13, 2019
+Feb 4-17, 2019
+Nov 7-13, 2018
+Sep 24-Oct 7, 2018
+Jul 30-Aug 12, 2018
+Jan 29-Feb 13, 2018
+Aug 8-21, 2017
+Apr 4-18, 2017
+Feb 28-Mar 12, 20176
+
+37
+40
+38
+41
+40
+47
+
+29
+38
+39
+44
+45
+40
+40
+40
+40
+38
+41
+38
+40
+38
+36
+39
+44
+
+27
+29
+27
+30
+31
+37
+
+21
+n/a
+29
+33
+34
+31
+31
+n/a
+29
+n/a
+n/a
+n/a
+31
+29
+26
+27
+30
+
+10
+10
+11
+11
+9
+9
+
+7
+n/a
+9
+10
+10
+9
+9
+n/a
+10
+n/a
+n/a
+n/a
+9
+9
+10
+12
+13
+
+*
+1
+*
+*
+*
+*
+
+*
+n/a
+1
+1
+1
+*
+*
+n/a
+*
+n/a
+n/a
+n/a
+*
+*
+*
+*
+*
+
+61
+58
+60
+58
+59
+51
+
+68
+59
+59
+53
+52
+58
+58
+59
+59
+61
+58
+61
+59
+60
+63
+61
+56
+
+49
+47
+47
+46
+48
+40
+
+56
+n/a
+48
+42
+40
+46
+46
+n/a
+48
+n/a
+n/a
+n/a
+48
+48
+49
+45
+43
-Note: Exhibit 53B should not include security costs typically embedded in IT investments, such as destruction
-of data (e.g., degaussing, shredding), physical or logical access control software, continuous monitoring
-software, tracking and reporting software, and annual disaster recovery and contingency plan tests.
-
-Page 25 of 45 Exhibit 53
-
- (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
-
-AGENCY CLOUD COMPUTING PORTFOLIO (Exhibit 53C)
-
-(a) Agency costs for cloud computing by deployment model, by year (Dollars in millions)
-
-PY
-
-CY
-
-BY
-
-Public Cloud
-
-Private Cloud
-
-Community Cloud
-
-Hybrid Cloud
-
-(b) Agency costs for cloud computing by service model, by year (Dollars in millions)
-
-PY
-
-CY
-
-BY
-
-SaaS
-
-PaaS
-
-IaaS
-
-Note: Exhibit 53C should describe agency funding for IT investments, not agency contributions. The sum of
-all cells in Table (a) should equal the sum of all cells in Table (b) and should equal the sum of columns 41 to
-43 in Exhibit 53A.
-
-Page 26 of 45 Exhibit 53
-
- (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
-
-AGENCY IT REDUCTIONS AND REINVESTMENTS (Exhibit 53D)
-
-When properly managed and applied, IT can create efficiencies, reduce costs, improve service delivery, and
-strengthen cybersecurity. But, too often spending on IT is still wasted on duplicative investments, missed
-opportunities to leverage economies of scale, rising operational costs that starve new development, and
-mismanaged projects that lead to cost overruns and schedule slippages.
-
-To address this issue, OMB Memorandum M-12-13 included guidance on IT reductions and reinvestments
-that agencies should reflect in their FY 2014 budget submission. In accordance with the memorandum, this
-section provides more specific guidance on how this information should be reflected in agency budgets,
-including additional detail on the nature of cuts and reinvestments and detailed reporting instructions.
-
-Agencies should propose reductions in IT that represent 10% of their overall spending, and propose a
-reinvestment of at least 5%, and up to 10%, of these savings, in priority IT investments for OMB
-consideration. To do this, agencies are required to report the specific investments in which they propose cuts
-and the specific investments in which they propose to reinvest funds.
-
-(a) What Agencies Will Provide
-
-As part of their FY 2014 budget submission, agencies are asked to complete the new Exhibit 53D (a
-downloadable template is available on OMB MAX; final submission will be made via OMB MAX). This
-new exhibit will allow agencies to show how they achieved the 10% reduction called for in the memorandum,
-and where they propose to reinvest some of these savings. The template, OMB MAX data collection exercise,
-and detailed technical instructions are available here.
-
-Please use the following guidelines when providing specific data on the proposed cuts and reinvestments from
-FY 2013 to FY 2014:
-
- Agencies should provide the following for each cut and reinvestment:
-o Specific IT investments and OMB accounts impacted,
-o Related category of the cut or reinvestment (provided in MAX exercise) and explanation,
-o Priority level and a description of the return on investment (reinvestments only);
-
-
-
-Information supplied in Exhibit 53D should be consistent with information supplied in Exhibits 53A,
-B and C, and Exhibits 300A and B;
-
- Agencies should include, in their FY 2014 budget submissions to OMB, a summary of all the
-information provided in Exhibit 53D, and the general approach the agency took to achieve its
-reductions and reinvestments; and
-
- Reductions and reinvestments apply Department-wide and should not solely target investments from
-
-agency-level IT or administrative accounts.
-
-(b) What Agencies Should Cut
-
-Regarding required reductions, OMB M-12-13 states “…include an explanation of how, at the investment and
-account level, you would achieve this reduction.”
-
-The 10% cuts should reduce agency spending in the following IT areas:
-
- Duplicative commodity IT investments or contracts (as emphasized in PortfolioStat and consistent
-
-with OMB Memoranda M-11-29 and M-12-10) include:
-
-IT infrastructure (e.g. data centers, networks, desktops, and/or mobile devices)
-
-o
-o Enterprise IT systems (e.g. email, help desk, collaboration, identify and access management,
-
-security and web infrastructure)
-
-o Business systems (e.g. HR, FM, and other administrative functions);
- Underperforming projects/investments of any type (as emphasized in TechStats); or
-
-Page 27 of 45 Exhibit 53
-
- (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
-
- Lower-value or lower-priority investments of any type.
-
-Exemptions from the 10% reduction target must be explicitly granted by OMB.
-
-(c) Where Agencies Should Reinvest
-
-Regarding reinvestments, OMB M-12-13, states “your budget submission may also propose where you would
-reinvest the savings from identified cuts in innovative IT solutions that would produce a favorable return on
-investment within 18 months or demonstrably improve citizen services or administrative efficiencies”
-
-Agencies should propose 10% cuts in IT and then propose a list of priority reinvestments to OMB up to the
-10%. If the Agency does not propose to reinvest at least 5% of these savings into IT, the agency is required to
-provide a justification explaining as to why it is unable to propose these reinvestments. Agencies should only
-propose reinvestments which demonstrate a favorable return on investment (quantitative or qualitative) to the
-agency within 18 months from the enactment of FY 2014 appropriations (excluding CRs).
-
-Proposed reinvestments should be in the following areas:
-
-Improvements to citizen services or administrative efficiencies;
-
-
- Adoption of shared services;
- Consolidation of commodity IT, including optimizing data centers;
-
-
-
-
-Improvements to the security posture of the agency’s IT and information assets;
-Improvements to the energy efficiency of IT facilities and equipment;
-Innovative investments consistent with policy initiatives such as cloud computing, modular
-development, reduction of improper payments, and digital government; or
-
- Data analytics or data management consistent with Administration priorities in Big Data.
-
-(d) How Much Agencies Should Cut Before Reinvesting
-
-Regarding the level of reductions, OMB M-12-13, states “…your 2014 budget submission should achieve an
-agency-wide 10% reduction in IT spending, compared to the average spending on IT from FY 2010 through
-2012”
-
-The table below shows the effects of the FY 2014 Budget policy for IT spending. Note that while the cut is
-calculated as 10% of the average total IT spend from FY 2010-2012, the FY (before proposed reinvestments)
-target is reached by applying the cut to the revised FY 2013 President's Budget level (as reported to the IT
-Dashboard by agencies in May 2012).
-
-FY 2013
-(President's
-Budget as
-of May
-2012)
-
-FY 2014
-10%
-Reduction
-(2010-
-2012)
-
-$2,611
-$2,396
-$32,669
-$552
-$2,016
-$7,102
-$5,629
-
-$252
-$259
-$3,509
-$61
-$205
-$662
-$587
-
-Average
- (2010-
-2012)
-$2,524
-$2,589
-$35,086
-$613
-$2,053
-$6,617
-$5,868
-
-FY 2014
-Target
-(before
-reinvestment)
-$2,359
-$2,137
-$29,161
-$491
-$1,811
-$6,440
-$5,042
-
-FY 2014
-Minimum
-(5%)
-reinvestment
-$126
-$129
-$1,754
-$31
-$103
-$331
-$293
-
-FY 2014
-Maximum
-(10%)
-reinvestment
-$252
-$259
-$3,509
-$61
-$205
-$662
-$587
-
-Agency
-USDA
-Commerce
-DOD
-ED
-Energy
-HHS
-DHS
-
-Page 28 of 45 Exhibit 53
-
- (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
-
-HUD
-Interior
-Justice
-Labor
-State
-USAID
-DOT
-Treasury
-VA
-USACE
-EPA
-GSA
-NASA
-NARA
-NSF
-NRC
-OPM
-SBA
-SI
-SSA
-
-$385
-$988
-$2,850
-$591
-$1,420
-$133
-$2,990
-$3,271
-$3,163
-$544
-$461
-$622
-$1,740
-$137
-$97
-$160
-$78
-$113
-$65
-$1,548
-$76,706
-
-$354
-$965
-$2,655
-$606
-$1,369
-$140
-$3,092
-$3,495
-$3,327
-$566
-$465
-$631
-$1,462
-$100
-$97
-$151
-$73
-$112
-$68
-$1,380
-$74,083
-
-$38
-$99
-$285
-$59
-$142
-$13
-$299
-$327
-$316
-$54
-$46
-$62
-$174
-$14
-$10
-$16
-$8
-$11
-$6
-$155
-$7,669
-
-$316
-$866
-$2,370
-$547
-$1,227
-$127
-$2,793
-$3,168
-$3,011
-$512
-$419
-$569
-$1,288
-$86
-$88
-$135
-$65
-$100
-$61
-$1,226
-$66,415
-
-$19
-$49
-$142
-$30
-$71
-$7
-$149
-$164
-$158
-$31
-$23
-$31
-$87
-$7
-$5
-$8
-$4
-$6
-$3
-$77
-$3,838
-
-$38
-$99
-$285
-$59
-$142
-$13
-$299
-$327
-$316
-$54
-$46
-$62
-$174
-$14
-$10
-$16
-$8
-$11
-$6
-$155
-$7,669
-
-Page 29 of 45 Exhibit 53
-
- (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT
-OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY CAPITAL ASSETS
-
-300.1 What is the purpose of this guidance?
-
-OMB provides specific policy, procedural, and analytic guidelines for planning, budgeting, acquisition, and
-management of major IT capital investments in addition to general guidance issued in OMB Circular A-11 and
-OMB Circular A-130.
-
-Exhibit 300 describes the justification, planning, and implementation of an individual capital asset included in the
-agency IT investment portfolio (as reported in Exhibit 53) and serves as a key artifact of the agency’s EA and IT
-CPIC processes. Exhibit 300 is comprised of two components—Exhibit 300A provides inherent investment
-information, including general information and planning for resources such as staffing and personnel. Exhibit
-300B provides more temporal information, such as projects and activities, risks, and operational performance of
-the investment.
-
-Together, Exhibits 53 and 300 provide the budgetary and management information necessary for sound planning,
-management, and governance of IT investments. These documents help agencies explicitly align IT investments
-with strategic and performance goals, and ultimately provide value to the public by making investment and
-management information more transparent. As architecture-driven IT investments are funded in the "Invest"
-phase, they move forward into the implementation phase where system development life cycle processes are
-followed and actual outputs, schedule, and operational performance expenditures are tracked versus planned
-numbers using performance-based management processes.
-
-300.2
-
- Does Exhibit 300 apply to my agency or IT investment?
-
-The policy and budget justification principles in Exhibit 300 apply to all agencies of the Executive Branch of the
-Federal Government that are subject to Executive Branch review (see Section 25 of OMB Circular A-11). In
-accordance with section 5, Exhibits 300A and B must be submitted for each major IT investment. Major IT
-investments must be reported on the agency’s Exhibit 53A, along with all non-major investments.
-
-300.3 How will agencies manage IT capital assets/investments?
-
-The Capital Programming Guide of OMB Circular A-11 provides guidance on the principles and techniques for
-effective capital programming. OMB Circular A-11, Appendix J explains the principles of financing capital asset
-acquisitions. Section 8b of OMB Circular A-130 establishes additional requirements for EAs, planning and
-control of information systems and IT investments, and performance management. Agencies must develop and
-implement a capital programming process to develop their capital asset portfolio and must:
-
- Evaluate and select capital assets that will support core mission functions performed by the Federal
-
-Government and which demonstrate projected returns on investment that are clearly equal to or better
-than alternative uses of available public resources. Specifically for IT, the investments should be
-informed by and should address performance gaps and goals identified in an agency’s strategic plan,
-annual performance plan, and EA;
-Initiate improvements to existing assets or acquisitions of new assets only when no alternative private
-sector or governmental source can more efficiently meet the need;
-Implement IT reforms from the 25 Point Implementation Plan to Reform Federal Information Technology
-Management, such as adhering to modular development principles and the requirement to establish an
-IPT prior to funding an IT investment;
-
-
-
-
-
- Simplify or otherwise redesign work processes to reduce costs, improve effectiveness, and maximize the
-
-use of commercial services and off-the-shelf technology;
-
- Assign a functional/business sponsor for each investment who is responsible for the program or
-function supported or implemented by the investment. The sponsor is responsible for expressing the
-
-Page 30 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS
-
-value of, ensuring successful implementation of, and providing accurate and timely data for the IT
-investment to the agency CIO and OMB. Each major and non-major investment listed in Exhibit 53 must
-include the name of the functional/business sponsor, title, phone number, and e-mail address;
-
- Reduce project risk by avoiding or isolating custom-designed components, using components that can be
-fully tested or prototyped prior to full implementation or production, and ensuring involvement and
-support of users in the design and testing of the asset;
-
- Structure major planning and acquisition into useful segments with a narrow scope and brief duration.
-These segments should make adequate use of competition and appropriately allocate risk between the
-Federal Government and contractor. The agency head must approve or define the cost, schedule, and
-performance goals for major acquisitions, and the agency's Chief Financial Officer must evaluate the
-proposed cost goals;
-
- Ensure a continuous linkage between Federal, agency, and bureau EAs, demonstrating such consistency
-
-
-
-through alignment with the agency’s Enterprise Roadmap and target architecture, compliance with agency
-business requirements and standards, as well as identification of milestones, as defined in the agency’s
-EA transition strategy;
-Institute performance measures and management processes to monitor and compare actual performance to
-planned results. Agencies must use a performance-based acquisition management system or EVMS,
-based on the ANSI/EIA Standard 748-B, to obtain timely information regarding the progress of capital
-investments, as defined in the Federal Acquisition Regulations (FAR). The system must also measure
-progress towards useful components in an independently verifiable basis in terms of cost, capability of the
-investment to meet specified requirements, timeliness, and quality;
-
- Per requirements of Federal Acquisition Streamlining Act of 1994 (FASA, Title V), agencies are expected
-to achieve, on average, 90 percent of the cost, schedule, and performance goals for major acquisitions.
-Through the TechStat process and as part of the Clinger-Cohen Act responsibly, Agency CIOs should
-review major acquisitions that have not achieved 90 percent of the goals to determine whether there is a
-continuing need and what corrective action, including termination, should be taken;
-
- Ensure that the planning and management of agency assets that are IT systems conform to the
-requirements of OMB Circular A-130, “Management of Federal Information Resources”;
-
- Ensure that agency assets that are financial management systems conform to the requirements of OMB
+12
+11
+13
+12
+10
+11
-Circular A-127;
+12
+n/a
+11
+11
+11
+11
+11
+n/a
+10
+n/a
+n/a
+n/a
+10
+12
+13
+15
+12
- Conduct post-implementation or post-occupancy reviews of capital programming and acquisition
+*
+*
+*
+*
+*
+*
+
+*
+n/a
+*
+*
+*
+1
+1
+n/a
+*
+n/a
+n/a
+n/a
+*
+*
+*
+*
+*
+
+2
+2
+2
+1
+1
+2
+
+3
+3
+2
+3
+2
+1
+1
+1
+1
+1
+1
+2
+2
+2
+1
+1
+1
+
+See past presidents’ approval trends: Joe Biden, Barack Obama, George W. Bush, Bill Clinton
-processes and projects to validate estimated costs and benefits and to document effective management
-practices (e.g., lessons learned) for broader use;
+6
- Establish oversight mechanisms that require periodic review of operational capital assets to determine
-how mission requirements might have changed and whether the asset continues to fulfill ongoing and
-anticipated mission requirements, deliver intended benefits to the agency and customers, and meet user
-requirements;
+The W24.5 Mode Study survey was administered by web and phone. Results reported here are from web mode only.
+
+www.pewresearch.org
+
+23
+
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
+
+ASK ALL:
+DTSUCCESS
+
+Jan 20-26,
+2026
+31
+47
+21
+1
+
+In the long run, do you think Donald Trump will be…
+[ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-2/2-1, HOLDING 3 LAST]
+
+A successful president
+An unsuccessful president
+Too early to tell
+No answer*
+
+Jan 27-Feb 2,
+2025
+35
+33
+31
+1
+
+Jan 6-19,
+2020
+34
+48
+18
+1
+
+TREND FOR COMPARISON:
+In the long run, do you think Joe Biden will be…
+
+A successful president
+An unsuccessful president
+Too early to tell
+No answer
+
+Jan 8-12,
+2021
+29
+26
+44
+1
+
+PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON
+In the long run, do you think Donald Trump will be a successful or unsuccessful president, or do you
+think it is too early to tell?
+
+Successful
+
+Unsuccessful
+
+Too early
+to tell
+
+(VOL.)
+DK/Ref
+
+Trump
+Jan 8-13, 2020
+Jan 9-14, 2019
+Jan 10-15, 2018
+Jan 4-9, 2017
+Obama
+Jan 7-14, 2016
+Jan 7-11, 2015
+Jan 15-19, 2014
+Jun 12-16, 2013
+Jan 9-13, 2013
+Jan 11-16, 2012
+Jan 5-9, 2011
+Jan 6-10, 2010
+Sep 30-Oct 4, 2009
+Jan 7-11, 2009
+Bush
+January, 2007
+January, 2006
+Early October, 2005
+January, 2005
+December, 2003
+Early October, 2002
+January, 2001
+Clinton
+January, 1999
+Early September, 1998
+February, 1995
+October, 1994
+May, 1994
+January, 1994
+October, 1993
+September, 1993
+August, 1993
+
+36
+29
+23
+21
+
+37
+32
+28
+34
+33
+27
+25
+24
+27
+30
+
+24
+27
+26
+36
+39
+40
+26
+
+44
+38
+18
+14
+21
+21
+18
+22
+13
+
+37
+47
+41
+20
+
+34
+38
+34
+31
+26
+32
+26
+21
+18
+4
+
+45
+37
+41
+27
+20
+15
+15
+
+24
+24
+34
+35
+26
+19
+25
+22
+25
+
+26
+23
+34
+58
+
+26
+29
+35
+33
+39
+39
+47
+52
+54
+65
+
+27
+32
+30
+35
+38
+44
+58
+
+29
+35
+43
+48
+52
+57
+56
+54
+60
+
+1
+1
+1
+1
+
+3
+2
+3
+2
+2
+2
+2
+3
+2
+1
+
+4
+4
+3
+2
+3
+1
+1
+
+3
+3
+5
+3
+1
+3
+1
+2
+2
- Provide Chief Information Officer (CIO) evaluations for all major investments on the IT Dashboard
+www.pewresearch.org
-which reflect the CIO’s best judgment of the current level of risk for the investment in terms of its ability
-to accomplish its goals. The evaluation should be informed by the following factors, including, but not
-limited to: risk management, requirements management, contractor oversight, historical performance,
-human capital and other factors that the CIO deems important to forecasting future success. Each
-evaluation should include a narrative explanation when the rating has changed since the last evaluation;
-and
+24
- Develop, maintain, and submit the following investment documents and artifacts for all major IT
-investments, as applicable. Provide updated versions (including date of last update) as significant
-changes are made or as available throughout the investment’s lifecycle:
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-o Risk management plan;
-o
-Investment charter, including IPT;
-o
-Investment-level alternative analysis and benefit-cost analysis;
-o Operational analyses (for operational or mixed life cycle systems);
-o Post implementation review results (investment level or project-specific); and,
-o Documentation of investment re-baseline management approval(s).
+ASK ALL:
+QUALPRES_TRMP
-Page 31 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012)
+Thinking about the qualities needed to serve as president, how confident are you that
+Donald Trump…7
+[ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-5/5-1]
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS
+Extremely
+confident
-300.4 What other requirements does Exhibit 300 fulfill?
+Very
+confident
-Exhibit 300A is designed to coordinate OMB’s collection of agency information for its reports to Congress, as
-required by the Federal Acquisition Streamlining Act of 1994 (FASA, Title V) and Clinger-Cohen Act of 1996.
-The business case (Exhibit 300A) for investment should demonstrate support for the mission statements, long-
-term goals and objectives, and annual performance plans developed pursuant to the GPRA-MA. Exhibit 300B
-establishes reporting requirements through the IT Dashboard to ensure the proper execution of those investments
-against the established performance plans.
+Somewhat
+confident
-300.5 What must I report on Exhibits 300A and B and when?
+Not too
+confident
-All information necessary to complete Exhibit 300A and Exhibit 300B should already exist as part of the agency's
-overall capital planning activities and within project- and program-specific documentation. The materials used to
-populate Exhibit 300A and Exhibit 300B should be readily available to OMB upon request.
+Not at all
+confident
-Agencies must submit Exhibit 300s using the following schedule:
+No
+answer*
- Agency Budget Request Exhibit 300A: September 10-14, 2012
- Agency Budget Request Exhibit 300B: September 14, 2012
- President’s Budget Request Exhibit 300A & B: February 2013 (tentative)
+MF
-o Submit initial documents/artifacts at this time
+Has the mental fitness
+needed to do the job
+ Jan 20-26, 2026
+ Jan 27-Feb 2, 20258
+ Apr 8-14, 2024
-Unless otherwise noted, IT exhibits and reporting must be submitted electronically to the IT Dashboard.
-Additional information regarding the submission process will be posted on the IT Dashboard, including business
-rules for the validation of data and a schema that describes how data should be transmitted. As always, pre-
-decisional and procurement sensitive information will not be displayed to the public.
+▪
-Projects within investments are encouraged to use modular development principles. All projects (regardless of
-whether they use modular development principles), must produce usable functionality at intervals of no more than
-six months.
+PHY ▪ Has the physical fitness
-Exhibit 300Bs shall establish cost, schedule and performance targets for CY 2013 and BY 2014. Regular updates
-for metrics and activities will be submitted to the IT Dashboard as soon as the data becomes available and at least
-once per each calendar month. How periodic performance metrics updates for ongoing operations will be, will
-vary according to the nature of the metric, as indicated in Table C1.
+needed to do the job
+ Jan 20-26, 2026
+ Jan 27-Feb 2, 20259
+ Apr 8-14, 2024
-If an agency requests supplemental funds or reallocates funding within its authority, which includes changes to
-the agency's portfolio and the performance targets, agencies should submit a new or revised version of Exhibit
-53A as part of their supplemental request.
+▪
+▪
+▪
-Multi-Agency Collaboration and Intra-agency Shared Services Investments (must submit both Exhibit 300A
-and Exhibit 300B)
+FIRM
-The managing partners (lead agency that provides services or coordination services to other agencies) will take
-the lead in completing and submitting the multi-agency collaboration investment Exhibits 300, managing it
-through the managing partner’s capital programming and budget process. The managing partners are also
-responsible for ensuring Exhibit 300 includes all necessary information from the partner agencies (customers who
-receive services from the managing partners) and have been approved by all necessary partner agencies through
-the appropriate governance process. The tracking of the multi-agency approvals, partner agency funding, and
-related capital assets (e.g., migration investments, Centers of Excellence, Shared Service Centers, supporting
-components) will be captured via an OMB MAX E-Gov Funding Tool. All initiative program managers or
-designated leads should have received details about this in an OMB e-mail distribution dated May 22, 2012.
+ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,250]
+Has the leadership skills
+needed to do the job
+Jan 20-26, 2026
+Jan 27-Feb 2, 2025
-Page 32 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012)
+RSP
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS
+Respects the country’s
+democratic values
+Jan 20-26, 2026
+Jan 27-Feb 2, 2025
+Apr 8-14, 2024
-For IT assets, partner agencies should report their participation in Exhibit 53 submissions. Partner agencies
-should reference the name and UII of the multi-agency Exhibit 300 in the “Investment Description” field of
-each Exhibit 53 line item related to the multi-agency Exhibit 300. Partner agencies should also ensure their
-activities and participation are included in the appropriate sections of the multi-agency Exhibit 300. The entire
-Summary of Funding Total for the investment, including funds provided by partner agencies, should be included
-in Exhibit 300.
+ ASK FORM 2 ONLY [N=4,262]
+ADV
-Investments that provide a service to other agencies but do not receive contributions from partner agencies
-should be reported as Multi-Agency Collaboration Investments.
+Picks good advisers
+ Jan 20-26, 2026
+ Jan 27-Feb 2, 202510
+ Apr 8-14, 2024
-Investments for multi-agency collaboration, shared services, and/or LoBs will be reflected in the managing
-partner's annual Enterprise Roadmap submission to OMB.
+▪
+▪
+▪
-Managing partners that provide multi-agency services should ensure that funding is prioritized to
-accommodate building and obtaining approval of a shared architecture. Approval should be obtained through
-a working governance model that includes partner agencies, customers, and OMB.
+ETHETH
-OMB may require additional information from partner agencies related to the multi-agency collaboration
-investment Exhibit 300. When necessary, OMB will work with the managing partners to coordinate data
-requests.
+Acts ethically in office
-Page 33 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012)
+Jan 20-26, 2026
+Jan 27-Feb 2, 2025
+Apr 8-14, 2024
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS
+17
+23
+20
-300.6 How will OMB use Exhibit 300?
+12
+17
+15
-Exhibit 300 is one component of your agency’s total budget justification (see Section 51.2 of OMB Circular A-
-11). OMB uses data reported in Exhibit 300 to make quantitative decisions about budgetary resources consistent
-with the Administration’s program priorities as well as qualitative assessments about whether the agency’s
-programming processes are consistent with OMB policies and guidance. OMB may request additional supporting
-information from agencies as necessary.
+19
+25
-Exhibit 300A: IT Capital Asset Overview and Justification
+13
+17
+17
-Section A: General Information
+11
+16
+11
-1. Investment Name:
-2. UII. Unique Investment Identifier (see Section 53.4) :
+9
+15
+11
-[Limit: 250 char]
-[Limit: 13 char]
+15
+17
+15
-Section B: Investment Detail
+15
+18
+18
-1. Briefly describe the investment’s purpose, goals, and current or anticipated benefits (quantitative and/or
-qualitative). Include the investment’s specific contribution to mission delivery or agency management
-support functions and identify key customers, stakeholders, and other beneficiaries.
-[Limit: 2500 char]
+15
+15
-2. Briefly describe how the investment contributes to the agency target EA and its role in the Enterprise
-Roadmap. Include a description of how the investment includes or will achieve programmatic or
-technical innovation.
-[Limit:2500 char]
+12
+14
+13
-3. Provide the investment’s currently projected return on investment (ROI) percentage, as documented in
+14
+15
+14
-the most recent alternatives analysis, and the date that it was established.
+12
+13
+12
-a. Current ROI:
-b. Date of Current ROI:
+16
+16
+17
-[percentage]
-[YYYY-MM-DD]
+22
+24
+26
-4. In the table below, indicate if the investment in whole or in part specifically addresses any of the
+14
+16
-following types of requirements:
+15
+16
+16
-Note: Where “Yes” is indicated, provide a brief description of the requirement and how the investment will meet
-the requirement. Include citations within descriptions, if available. Provide any URLs associated with each
-requirement. If citing the Agency Performance Plan, provide the applicable “PRM” code from Performance.gov.
-Description
-[Limit: 1000
-characters]
+18
+18
+22
-URL(s) / PRM code (s)
-[One or more]
+18
+17
+17
-Required
-by
-[Yes/No]
+14
+14
+15
-Legislative Mandate
-Outstanding Audit Finding or
-Material Weakness
-Published Agency Strategic
-Plan/Annual Performance Plan
-Presidential Direction (i.e.
-Presidential Directive, Presidential
-Memorandum, or Executive Order)
-Other Requirement
+19
+17
+17
-(URL required)
+14
+13
-(optional)
+15
+14
+12
-[URL of Agency Strategic Plan] (optional)
-[PRM code for Annual Performance Plan] (required)
+17
+14
+15
-(URL required)
+15
+14
+14
-(optional)
+37
+30
+32
-5. Provide a description of the investment’s progress and accomplishments in the PY, including the
+31
+24
+23
-investment’s overall performance against baseline goals, targets, significant milestones, or performance
-measures, and any corrective actions taken to address performance deficiencies.
-[Limit: 1000 char]
+36
+30
-Page 34 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012)
+43
+39
+41
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS
+40
+37
+37
-6. Describe the investment’s objectives for the CY, BY, and budget out years, if available, including
+45
+40
+45
-specific accomplishments to achieve, realize, or continue to achieve the benefits cited in question B.1.
-above.
-[Limit: 2500 char]
+*
+*
+*
-7. If this investment will result in the elimination or the reduction of another investment(s), please
+1
+1
+*
-complete the following:
+*
+*
-Investment UII (one or more)
+1
+*
+1
-8. Does the investment include the following?
-
-To be Status
-[to be eliminated/to be reduced]
+1
+1
+1
-A shared service (intra-or inter-agency—current and/or planned)
-A data center (current and/or planned)
-PIV-enabled systems (per HSPD-12) (all systems currently PIV-enabled)
-(see OMB memo M-11-11)
-Cloud computing (current and/or planned)
-APIs (application programming interfaces) consistent with the Digital Government
-Strategy
-
-Check all that Apply
-[Yes/No]
-[Yes/No]
-[Yes/No]
-
-[Yes/No]
-[Yes/No]
-
-9. Provide any URLs related to the investment and indicate how they are related. Identify each URL’s
-
-relationship to the investment (if applicable):
-
-Relationship to Investment
-(check all that apply)
-
-d
-e
-c
-u
-d
-o
-r
-p
-s
-t
-e
-s
-a
-t
-a
-d
-e
-l
-b
-i
-s
-s
-e
-c
-c
-a
-
-y
-l
-c
-i
-l
-b
-u
-p
-s
-e
-d
-i
-v
-o
-r
-P
+1
+*
+1
-.
-
-A
-
-t
-n
-e
-m
-t
-s
-e
-v
-n
-i
-
-s
-i
-h
-t
-y
-b
-
-e
-d
-i
-v
-o
-r
-p
-o
-t
+7
-I
-P
-A
-e
-l
-b
-i
-s
-s
-e
-c
-c
-a
-y
-l
-c
-i
-l
-b
-u
-p
-a
-
-s
-e
-d
-i
-v
-o
-r
-P
+8
+9
+10
-.
-
-B
-
-t
-n
-e
-m
-t
-s
-e
-v
-n
-i
-
-s
-i
-h
-t
-
-m
-o
-r
-f
-
-a
-t
-a
-d
-o
-t
-
-s
-s
-e
-c
-c
-a
-
-.
-t
-n
-e
-m
-t
-s
-e
-v
-n
-i
-
-s
-i
-h
-t
-
-t
-u
-o
-b
-a
-
-a
-i
-d
-e
-m
-
-l
-a
-i
-c
-o
-s
-o
-t
-
-s
-k
-n
-i
-L
-
-.
-
-C
-
-s
-i
-h
-t
-
-t
-u
-o
-b
-a
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-i
-
-l
-a
-r
-e
-n
-e
-g
-s
-e
-d
-i
-v
-o
-r
-P
+Prior to January 2026, question was worded: “Thinking about the qualities needed to effectively serve another term
+as president, how confident are you that Donald Trump…”
+Prior to January 2026, the word “mental” was not underlined.
+Prior to January 2026, the word “physical” was not underlined.
+Prior to January 2026, the word “advisers” was spelled “advisors.”
-.
-
-D
-
-t
-n
-e
-m
-t
-s
-e
-v
-n
-i
-
-s
-i
-h
-t
-
-y
-b
-d
-e
-v
-r
-e
-s
-m
-a
-r
-g
-o
-r
-p
-r
-o
-s
-s
-e
-c
-o
-r
-p
-s
-s
-e
-n
-i
-s
-u
-b
-
-f
-l
-e
-s
-t
-i
-
-t
-n
-e
-m
-t
-s
-e
-v
-n
-i
-
-e
-h
-t
-
-t
-o
-n
-t
-u
-b
-t
-n
-e
-m
-t
-s
-e
-v
-n
-i
-
-e
-h
-t
-
-t
-u
-o
-b
-a
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-i
-
-l
-a
-r
-e
-n
-e
-g
-s
-e
-d
-i
-v
-o
-r
-P
+www.pewresearch.org
-.
+25
-E
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-URL
-(as many as
-necessary)
+ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE
-http://...
+ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,250]:
+Thinking about important issues facing the country today…
-[X]
+TRUMPISSUE1 Overall, would you say you tend to agree with Donald Trump on…
-[X]
+[ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-4/4-1]
-[X]
+Jan 20-26,
+2026
+13
+27
+22
+37
+1
-[X]
+All or nearly all issues
+Many, but not all issues
+A few issues
+No or almost no issues
+No answer*
-[X]
+PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON:
-10. Provide the date of the investment or IPT charter establishing the required IPT.
+Jul 1-7,
+2024
+16
+25
+23
+35
+1
-[Date]
+Feb 4-15,
+2020
+19
+23
+23
+34
+1
-Page 35 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012)
+Apr 25-May 1
+2018
+19
+22
+24
+33
+2
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS
+Aug 15-21
+2017
+15
+18
+21
+45
+1
-11. Provide names and contact information for IPT members in the table below. If available, insert lines for
-other IPT members such as enterprise architects, capital planners, and performance specialists. The IT
-PM, business process owner/SME, and contracting specialist must be Federal Government employees.
-The business process owner or SME may or may not be the same person listed as the functional/business
-sponsor on the Exhibit 53-- the functional/business sponsor may be a higher-level agency official or
-executive.
+ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,250]:
+TRUMPISSUE2 Now thinking not about issues, but just about the way Donald Trump conducts himself as
-IPT Member Role
+president, would you say you...
+[ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-3/3-1]
-IT PM
+Jan 20-26,
+2026
+16
-Name (Required for
-all members listed)
-[Limit: 250 char]
+32
-Phone Number
-(Required for PM)
-[10 digits, 0-9 only]
+51
-Business Process Owner
-or SME
-Contracting Specialist
-IT Specialist
-IT Security Specialist
-(Optional: Insert other IPT
-members)
+1
-(optional)
+Like the way he conducts
+himself
+Have mixed feelings about the
+way he conducts himself
+Don’t like the way he conducts
+himself
+No answer*
-(optional)
-(optional)
-(optional)
-(optional)
+Jul 1-7,
+202411
+13
-Extension
+Feb 4-15,
+202012
+15
-[Optional: 6
-digits, 0-9 only ]
-(optional)
+32
-E-mail (Required
-for PM)
-[Limit: one e-
-mail only]
-(optional)
+54
-(optional)
-(optional)
-(optional)
-(optional)
+1
-(optional)
-(optional)
-(optional)
-(optional)
+30
-Page 36 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012)
+53
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS
+3
-Section C: Life Cycle Costs
+PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON:
-1. Provide the cost summary for the investment by completing the following tables. All costs are to be provided
-in millions of dollars, and reporting three decimal places (precision to thousands of dollars) is recommended,
-although agencies may report up to six decimal places (whole dollars). Federal personnel costs should be
-included only in the rows designated as “… Govt. FTEs” costs and should be excluded from the other cost
-breakouts. For multi-agency investments, this table should include all funding (both managing and partner
-agency contributions).
+Apr 25-May 1
+2018
-For PY (FY2012) and earlier, provide final obligations (actuals) as they become available. For CY (FY2013)
-and BY (FY2014) provide estimated obligations for each year. For BY+1 and beyond, please provide the
-estimated obligations through the end of the investments useful life (may be different from the estimated
-budget authority requests). The sum of amounts for all years should reflect the estimated lifecycle cost of the
-investment. As described above, the Exhibit 53 should represent the budgetary resources for CY and BY.
+Aug 15-21
+2017
-For lines in the table that ask for changes in your current submission compared to your most recent previous
-submission, use the President’s Budget as your previous submission. When making comparisons, ensure that
-you compare same-year-to-same-year (e.g., 2012 versus 2012).
+19
-Significant changes from the previous submission should be reflected in an updated investment-level
-Alternatives Analysis and is subject to OMB request, as discussed in Exhibit 300.3.
+26
-PY-1 &
-Prior
+54
-PY
-2012
+2
-CY
-2013
+16
-BY
-2014
+25
-BY+1
-2015
+58
-BY+2
-2016
+1
-BY+3
-2017
+ASK FORM 2 ONLY [N=4,262]:
+NEWPRES_SUPP
-BY+4 &
-Beyond
+How many of Donald Trump’s policies and plans would you say you support?
+[ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-5/5-1]
-Planning Costs:
+Jan 20-26,
+2026
+6
+22
+20
+26
+26
+1
+
+All of them
+Most of them
+Some of them
+Only a few of them
+None of them
+No answer*
+
+Jan 27-Feb 2,
+2025
+9
+25
+17
+23
+24
+1
+
+11
-DME (Excluding Planning)
-Costs:
-DME (Including Planning)
-Govt. FTEs:
-Sub-Total DME (Including
-Govt. FTE) :
-O&M Costs:
+12
-O&M Govt. FTEs:
+In July 2024, the question was worded “Now thinking NOT about issues, but about Donald Trump’s personal conduct, would
+you say you…”
+In February 2020, the question was worded “Now thinking NOT about issues, but just about the way Donald Trump
+conducts himself as president, would you say you…”
+
+www.pewresearch.org
+
+26
+
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
+
+ASK FORM 2 ONLY [N=4,262]:
+NEWPRES_ACTNS
+
+Would you say the Trump administration's actions since taking office last year have
+been... [ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-5/5-1]
+
+Jan 20-26,
+2026
+11
+10
+28
+15
+34
+1
+
+A lot better than you expected
+A little better than you expected
+About what you expected
+A little worse than you expected
+A lot worse than you expected
+No answer*
+
+Jun 2-8,
+202513
+11
+10
+31
+17
+32
+*
+
+Jan 27-Feb 2,
+2025
+17
+11
+36
+12
+24
+1
-Sub-Total O&M Costs
-(Including Govt. FTE):
-Total Cost (Including Govt.
-FTE):
+ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE
-Total Govt. FTE costs:
+[RANDOMIZE ORDER OF PRESWITHOP AND OPWITHPRES SUCH THAT FORM 1 (X_FORM=1) GETS
+PRESWITHOP FIRST AND OPWITHPRES SECOND WHILE FORM 2 (X_FORM=2) GETS OPWITHPRES
+FIRST AND PRESWITHOP SECOND]
-Number of FTE rep by
-costs:
+ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,250]:
+PRESWITHOP
-Total change from PY
-final President’s Budget ($)
-Total change from PY
-final President’s Budget (%)
-Note: Do not enter information for the dark gray cells (these will be calculated).
-
-2.a.
-
-In which year did or will this investment begin? (specify year – e.g., PY-1 = 2011)?
-
-2.b.
-
-In which year will this investment reach the end of its estimated useful life?
-(specify year – e.g., BY+5 = 2019)
-
-3. If the funding levels have changed from the FY 2012 President’s Budget request for PY
-
-[Limit: 500 char]
-
-or CY, briefly explain those changes:
-
-Page 37 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS
-
-Section D: Acquisition/Contract Strategy
-
-1. In the table below, provide all prime contracts (or task orders) for awarded or open solicitations for the
-investment (sub-award details are not required). Completed contracts and/or task orders should not be included in
-the table. Contracts in open solicitation should provide estimated data for all fields (for “Total Contract Value,”
-provide the estimated base contract costs and all anticipated option years). Data definitions can be found at
-www.usaspending.gov/learn#a2.
+This year, do you think Donald Trump should... [ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-2/2-1 IN
+SAME ORDER AS OPWITHPRES]
-For specifics, see notes 1 and 2 below the table.
+Jan 20-26,
+2026
+64
-Field
+33
-Data Description
+2
-Contract Status
-Contracting Agency ID
+Try as best he can to work with Democratic congressional leaders to accomplish things,
+even if it means disappointing people who voted for him
+Stand up to Democratic congressional leaders on issues that are important to people who
+voted for him, even if it means it’s harder to address critical problems facing the country
+No answer*
-Procurement Instrument
-Identifier (PIID)
+Jan 27-Feb 2,
+2025
+63
-Modular Approaches/
-Contracting
+35
-Indefinite Delivery
-Vehicle (IDV) Reference
-ID
-IDV Agency ID
+2
-Solicitation ID1
+TREND FOR COMPARISON
+This year, do you think Joe Biden should…
-EVM Required
-Ultimate Contract
-Value1
-Type of Contract/ Task
-Order (Pricing) 1
+Try as best he can to work with Republican
+congressional leaders to accomplish things, even if it
+means disappointing some people who voted for him
+Stand up to Republican congressional leaders on
+issues that are important to the people who voted
+for him, even if it means it’s harder to address
+critical problems facing the country
+No answer
-Is the contract a
-Performance-Based
-Service Acquisition
-(PBSA)?1
-Effective date1
+Jan 16-21
+2024
+74
-Actual or expected End
-Date of Contract/ Task
-Order1
-Extent Competed1
+Jan 18-24,
+2023
+73
-(1) Awarded, (2) Pre-award, but post-solicitation
-Provide the contracting agency’s ID. This is required only if the
-contracting agency is different than the agency submitting the
-Exhibit. Use the agency’s 4-digit code as used in FPDS.
-The unique identifier for each contract, agreement, or order. See
-www.usaspending.gov/learn#a2 for more information about
-PIIDs.
-Do acquisition planning, award, and management actions apply
-the principles and strategies described in “Contracting Guidance
-to Support Modular Development”? [Yes/No]
-Provide the IDV Reference ID. This is only required for IDVs.
-See www.usaspending.gov/learn#a2 for more information about
-IDV Reference IDs.
-Provide the IDV agency ID. This is a code for an agency, but it
-does not necessarily represent the agency that issued the contract.
-Instead, it serves as part of the unique identification for Federal
-Procurement Data System IDV records.
-Provide the identifier used to link transactions to solicitation
-information. See www.usaspending.gov/learn#a2 for more
-information.
-[Yes/No]
-Enter the total value of the contract, including base and all
-options. Complete using dollars to two decimal places.
-Provide information about the type of contract the investment is
-(e.g., fixed price, cost, cost plus, incentive, IDV, time and
-materials). See FAR Part 16 for more classifications.
-[Yes/No] Indicate whether the contract is a PBSA as defined by
-FAR Subpart 37.601. A PBSA describes the requirements in
-terms of results rather than the methods of performance of the
-work.
-Provide the actual or expected start date of the contract/task order
-that the parties have agreed on for the contract’s requirements.
-[YYYY-MM-DD]
-[YYYY-MM-DD]
+Jan 10-17,
+2022
+67
-Choose one of the following options: (A) Full and open
-competition, (B) Not available for competition, (C) Not
-competed, (D) Full and open competition after exclusion of
-sources, (E) Follow on to competed action, (F) Competed under
-simplified acquisition procedures, (G) Not competed under
-simplified acquisition procedures, (CDO) Competitive Delivery
-Order, (NDO) Non-competitive Delivery Order
+Jan 8-12,
+202114
+74
-Optional for
-Awarded
-Contracts
+24
-Contract/
-Task
-Order
+25
-Y
+29
-Y
+23
-Y
+2
-Y
+2
-Y
+4
-Y
+3
-Y
+13
+14
-Y
+Prior to January 2026, the question was worded “Would you say the Trump administration’s actions so far have been…”
+In January 2021, second response option was worded as “ … on issues that are important to his supporters …”.
-Y
+www.pewresearch.org
-Page 38 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012)
+27
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Contract Description
+ASK FORM 2 ONLY [N=4,262]:
+OPWITHPRES
-A brief description of the goods or services bought (for an award)
-or that are available (for an
-IDV).www.usaspending.gov/learn?tab=FAQ#2
+This year, do you think Democratic congressional leaders should... [ROTATE RESPONSE
+OPTIONS 1-2/2-1 IN SAME ORDER AS PRESWITHOP]
-Y
+Jan 20-26,
+2026
+49
-1Assuming the PIID or IDV PIID match with www.usaspending.gov, these data elements will be automatically populated for awarded IT acquisitions.
-2Assuming the PIID, IDV PIID, or solicitation number match with www.usaspending.gov or FedBizOpps (www.fbo.gov) this data will be automatically
-populated for awarded, pre-awarded, and post-solicitation IT acquisitions.
+49
-2. If earned value is not required or will not be a contract requirement
-for any of the contracts or task orders above, explain why:
+2
-[Limit: 2500 char]
+Try as best they can to work with Donald Trump to accomplish things, even if it
+means disappointing people who voted for them
+Stand up to Donald Trump on issues that are important to people who voted for
+them, even if it means it’s harder to address critical problems facing the country
+No answer*
-Page 39 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012)
+Jan 27-Feb 2,
+2025
+55
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS
+43
-Exhibit 300B: Performance Plan and Measurement Report
+2
-Exhibit 300B is used to provide OMB BY 2014 and current FY 2013 investment plans and performance data.
-Include in this exhibit, at a minimum, all projects, activities, and operations scheduled to commence or continue
-in the CY and/or BYs. Information in Exhibit 300B is to be updated as soon as new data becomes available, but
-at a minimum once per calendar month.
+TREND FOR COMPARISON
+This year, do you think Republican congressional leaders should…
-UNDERSTANDING EXHIBIT 300B
+Try as best they can to work with Joe Biden to
+accomplish things, even if it means disappointing
+some Republican voters
+Stand up to Joe Biden on issues that are important
+to Republican voters, even if it means it’s harder to
+address critical problems facing the country
+No answer
-In Exhibit 300B, investments are described as:
+Jan 16-21
+2024
+60
-
+Jan 18-24,
+2023
+63
-Investment
+Jan 10-17,
+2022
+61
-o Projects
+Jan 8-12,
+2021
+66
- Activities
+37
-o Operations
+35
-Report information about these areas in the following Exhibit 300B sections:
+37
-A.1: General Information. Enter basic information about the major investment.
-B.1: Projects. Identify all of the investment’s projects with activities occurring in the current FY.
-B.2: Activities. Outline the activities that are performed to achieve the outcome of each project.
-B.3: Project Risk. Identify significant risks to each project’s success.
-C.1: Operational Performance Information. Identify performance targets for evaluating operations.
-C.2: Operational Risk. Identify all significant risks to the investment achieving operational performance
+3
-targets.
+2
-SECTION A: GENERAL INFORMATION
+2
-1. Investment Name: Agency-provided name of investment, consistent with Exhibit 53.
-2. Investment UII: Agency-provided UII, consistent with Exhibit 53.
+31
-SECTION B: PROJECT PLAN AND EXECUTION DATA
+3
-In Tables B.1 and B.2., report, at a minimum, all projects with any activities that started in a previous FY (PY and
-earlier) and that have not been completed by the beginning of the CY. Also, report projects and activities that are
-scheduled to start in the CY and BY, including planning, DME, and maintenance projects. Include projects and
-activities commencing beyond the BY, as available. Include the following data in Table B.1:
+ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE
-1. Project ID: An agency-specified number that uniquely identifies the project within the investment.
-2. Project Name: Name used by the agency to refer specifically to the project.
-3. Objectives/Expected Outcomes: Description of the project’s functionality, capability, or goal.
-4. Project Start Date: Actual start date of in-progress projects or planned start of projects that have not yet
+ASK ALL:
+IMMIG_FAVOPP
-begun (may be before the current FY or activities listed in Table B.2).
+Thinking about immigration policy, do you favor or oppose each of the following?
+[RANDOMIZE ITEMS; ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-4/4-1 IN SAME ORDER
+AS VEN_MADREMV]
-5. Project Completion Date: Planned date of completion of in-progress projects or actual completion date
-of projects that have completed (may be after BY or of completion date of activities listed in activities
-Table B.2).
+Strongly
+favor
-6. Project Life cycle Cost: Enter the total cost of all activities related to the project as described in OMB
+Somewhat
+favor
-Circular A-131 (in $ millions).
+Somewhat
+oppose
-7. PM Name: Name of PM responsible for the success of the project.
-8. PM Level of Experience: The years of applicable experience or the status of certification for the PM.
+Strongly
+oppose
-Available selections include:
+No
+answer*
-1) FAC-P/PM(DAWIA-3) – Senior
-2) FAC-P/PM(DAWIA-2) – Mid-Level
-3) FAC-P/PM(DAWIA-1) – Entry Level
+SCMED
-Page 40 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012)
+FEE
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS
+ASY
-4) Other certification with 4 or more years of PM experience (within the last five years)
-5) Other certification with between 2 and 4 years of PM experience (within the last five years)
-6) Other certification with less than two years of PM experience (within the last five years)
-7) No certification, but with 4 or more years of PM experience (within the last five years)
-8) No certification, but with between 2 and 4 years of PM experience (within the last five years)
-9) No certification, but with less than two years of PM experience (within the last five years)
+MIL
-9. PM Phone: Phone number of the PM responsible for the success of the project.
-10. PM E-mail: E-mail address of the PM responsible for the success of the project.
+Requiring people who want to
+enter the U.S. to let
+immigration officers review
+their social media accounts
+ Jan 20-26, 2026
-Project
-ID
+Giving people priority in the
+immigration process if they pay
+a $1 million fee
+ Jan 20-26, 2026
-Project
-Name
+Suspending all asylum
+applications from people
+seeking to live in the U.S. to
+escape violence or danger
+ Jan 20-26, 2026
-Objectives/
-Expected
-Outcomes
+Maintaining a large military
+presence at the U.S. border
+with Mexico
+ Jan 20-26, 2026
-Project
-Start
-Date
+25
-Project
-Completion
-Date
+31
-Table B.1
-Project
-Life cycle
-Cost
+20
-PM
-Name
+23
-PM Level
-of
-Experience
+5
-PM
-Phone
+14
-PM
-Extension
+20
-[10 digit]
+60
-[Optional]
+11
-PM E-
-mail
-[Limit: one
-e-mail only]
+21
-In Table B.2, describe, at a minimum, all activities for projects in Table B.1 that started in a previous FY (PY and
-earlier) and that have not been completed by the beginning of the CY, as well as activities that are scheduled to
-start in the current FY and BY. In line with modular development principles, each project must produce usable
-functionality at intervals of no more than six months, as described in the 25 Point Implementation Plan to Reform
-Federal Information Technology Management. Include the following data in Table B.2:
+30
-1. Project ID: An agency-specified number that uniquely identifies the project within this investment.
-2. Activity Name: A short description consistent with the critical steps within the agency project management
+36
-methodology.
+31
-3. Activity Description: Describe what work is accomplished by the activity.
-4. Structure ID: Agency-specified identifier that indicates the work breakdown structure (WBS) the agency uses to
+31
-associate the activity with other activities or a project. Provide this in the format of “x.x.x.x.x” where the first string
-is the Project ID and each following string (separated by periods) matches the structure ID of a parent activity. See
-below for more guidance about parent and child activities expressed through this structure.
+21
-5. Key Deliverable/Usable Functionality: Indicate whether the completion of the activity provides a key deliverable
+16
-or usable functionality. This should only be provided for activities that do not have a child activity. Use this field to
-demonstrate the investment’s alignment with the modular development principles of the 25 Point Implementation
-Plan to Reform Federal Information Technology Management.
+2
-6. Start Date Planned: The planned start date for the activity. This is the baseline value.
-7. Start Date Projected: If the activity has not yet started, enter the current planned start date of the activity.
-8. Start Date Actual: When the activity starts, enter the actual start date here.
-9. Completion Date Planned: The planned completion date for the activity. This is the baseline value.
-10. Completion Date Projected: If the activity has not yet completed, enter the current planned completion date of the
+2
-activity.
+2
-11. Completion Date Actual: When the activity ends, enter the actual completion date here.
-12. Total Costs Planned: The planned total cost for the activity. This is the baseline value.
-13. Total Costs Projected: When the activity is not yet completed, enter the current planned total cost of the activity.
-14. Total Costs Actual: When the activity ends, enter the actual total costs for the activity here.
+1
-Note: For programs that are employing earned value management, agencies should reflect “budget at completion” in the
-“Total Costs Planned” field and “estimated at completion” in the “Total Costs Projected” field for projected costs.
+www.pewresearch.org
-A
+28
-B
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-C
+IMMIG_FAVOPP CONTINUED …
-D
+DTN
-E
+PAU75
-F
+Keeping large numbers of
+immigrants in detention centers
+while their cases are decided
+ Jan 20-26, 2026
-G
+Pausing visa applications from
+people in 75 countries seeking
+to legally immigrate to the U.S.
+ Jan 20-26, 2026
-Table B.2
-H
+Strongly
+favor
-Project
-ID
+Somewhat
+favor
-Activity
-Name
+Somewhat
+oppose
-Activity
-Description
+Strongly
+oppose
-Structure
-ID
+No
+answer*
-Key Deliverable/
-Usable Functionality
-[Key Deliverable,
-Usable Functionality,
-N/A]
+14
-Start Date
-Planned
+21
-Start Date
-Projected
+24
-Start Date
-Actual
+40
-I
-Completion
-Date
-Planned
+16
-J
-Completion
-Date
-Projected
+23
-K
+30
-L
+30
-M
+2
-N
+2
-Completion
-Date Actual
+ADDITONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE
-Total Costs
-Planned
+[RANDOMIZE ORDER OF IMMIGPPL_ACCEPT AND IMMIGAGNT_ACCEPT]
-Total Costs
-Projected
+ASK ALL:
+IMMIGPPL_ACCEPT
-Total Costs
-Actual
+Do you think each of the following is acceptable or unacceptable for people to
+do? [RANDOMIZE ITEMS; ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-4/4-1 IN
+SAME ORDER AS IMMIGAGNT_ACCEPT]
-Page 41 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012)
+Definitely
+acceptable
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS
+Probably
+acceptable
-Reporting Parent and Child Activities (WBS Structure)
+Probably
+unacceptable
-“Child” activities may be grouped into “Parent” activities to reflect the WBS used by the agency to manage the
-investment. If a WBS is not used by the agency, report the relationship between parent activities and child
-activities in “Structure ID” using this method.
+Definitely
+unacceptable
-When reporting an activity, enter the “Structure ID” as a period-delimited string consisting of the “Project ID”
-and each nested parent activity between the project level and the child activity. The “Structure ID” to enter will
-vary depending on the activity’s WBS level.
+No
+answer*
-Example: For child activity 3 which is part of parent activity 10, which in turn is part of parent activity 2, which in
-turn is part of Project A, enter: A.2.10.3
+VDEO
- Project A
+TRCK
-o Parent Activity 2
+REPT
- Parent Activity 10
+Record video of immigration
+officers while they make arrests
+ Jan 20-26, 2026
- Child Activity 3
+Share information about where
+immigration officers are arresting
+people
+ Jan 20-26, 2026
-There is no limit to the number of nested “child” and “parent” relationships allowed, and this depth may vary
-from activity to activity and from project to project.
+Report people who they think
+may be in the country illegally to
+immigration officers
+ Jan 20-26, 2026
-If any of a parent activity's child activities occurs in the current FY, then all child activities of the parent activity
-must be reported, regardless of their timing. This is to ensure that a complete view of the parent activity is
-available.
+48
-All activities with no child activities must have, at a minimum, Project ID, Activity Name, Activity Description, Structure ID,
-Start Date Planned, Start Date Projected, Completion Date Planned, Completion Date Projected, Total Costs Planned, and
-Total Costs Projected. Completed activities must also have Start Date Actual, Completion Date Actual, and Total Costs
-Actual.
+26
-Any parent activities with a child activity must be completely described by the aggregate attributes of its child
-activities. In the IT Dashboard, the cost and schedule information for parent activities will be based on the cost
-and schedule information of the lowest level of child activities reported. Agency-submitted cost and schedule
-information is not required for parent activities.
+13
-Project
-ID
+12
-A
-A
-A
-A
+35
-Activity Name
-Design
-Business Requirements
-Technical Requirements
-Architecture
+24
-Structure
-ID
+18
-Start Date
-Planned
+22
-Completion
-Date Planned
+22
-Planned Total
-Costs
+30
-…
+22
-A.2
-A.2.1
-A.2.2
-A.2.3
+25
-2/1/2012
-2/1/2012
-2/11/2012
-2/21/2012
+1
-2/29/2012
-2/10/2012
-2/20/2012
-2/29/2012
+1
-$2.5
-$1.0
-$1.0
-$0.5
+2
-Parent activities as highlighted are optional (Structure ID: A.2). Reported parent activities values will be ignored, as
-calculated values will be determined by aggregating the cost and schedule information reported in the child activities.
+www.pewresearch.org
-Page 42 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012)
+29
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Project Risk
+ASK ALL:
+IMMIGAGNT_ACCEPT
-Risk assessments should include risk information from all stakeholders and should be performed at the initial
-concept stage and then monitored and controlled throughout the life cycle of the investment. A copy of the
-investment Risk Management Plan must be uploaded to the IT Dashboard in conjunction with the Exhibit 300
-submission.
+Do you think each of the following is acceptable or unacceptable for federal
+immigration officers to do? [RANDOMIZE ITEMS; ROTATE RESPONSE
+OPTIONS 1-4/4-1 IN SAME ORDER AS IMMIGPPL_ACCEPT]
-In Table B.3, list all significant project-related risks submitted for the investment that are currently open and
-provide risk assessment information. It is not necessary to address all 19 OMB Risk Categories. Consider the
-combination of the risk probability and the risk impact when identifying significant risks. Include the following
-data in Table B.3:
+Definitely
+acceptable
-1. Project ID: An agency-specified number that uniquely identifies a project within the investment. For
+Probably
+acceptable
-each identified risk, list the associated Project ID.
+Probably
+unacceptable
-2. Risk Name: A short description that identifies a risk, the cause of the risk, and the effect that the risk
+Definitely
+unacceptable
-may have on the project.
+No
+answer*
-3. Risk Category: Select the relevant OMB risk category for each risk. Risk categories include: 1)
+MASK Wear face coverings that hide
+their identities while working
+ Jan 20-26, 2026
-Schedule, 2) Initial costs, 3) Life cycle costs, 4) Technical obsolescence, 5) Feasibility, 6) Reliability of
-systems, 7) Dependencies and interoperability between this investment and others, 8) Surety (asset
-protection) considerations, 9) Risk of creating a monopoly for future procurements, 10) Capability of
-agency to manage the investment, 11) Overall risk of investment failure, 12) Organizational and change
-management, 13) Business, 14) Data/info, 15) Technology, 16) Strategic, 17) Security, 18) Privacy, and
-19) Project resources.
+NGBH
-4. Risk Probability: The likelihood of a potential negative impact for the risk (Low, Medium, or High
+RLAN
-likelihood).
+Increase their presence in
+neighborhoods with many
+immigrants
+ Jan 20-26, 2026
-5. Risk Impact: The level of a potential negative impact for the risk (Low, Medium, or High impact).
-6. Mitigation Plan: A short description of the plan or steps to mitigate the identified risk.
+Use a person’s looks or the
+language they speak as a reason
+to check their immigration status
+ Jan 20-26, 2026
-Project ID
+CITZ
-Risk Name
-[Limit: 500
-char]
+Arrest U.S. citizens who help
+people avoid immigration officers
+ Jan 20-26, 2026
-Risk Category
-[19 risk
-categories]
+21
-Table B.3
-Risk Probability
+16
-Risk Impact
+15
-[Low, Medium, High]
+46
-[Low, Medium, High]
+18
-Mitigation Plan
-[char 500]
+26
-Page 43 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012)
+21
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS
+33
-SECTION C: OPERATIONAL DATA
+10
-Section C addresses operational activities that are not reported as a part of a project in Section B.
+18
-Operational Performance
-There are two essential types of operations metrics to be reported:
+20
-1. Results-Specific: Provide a minimum of two metrics that measure the effectiveness of the investment in
-delivering the desired service or support level. At least one metric should reflect customer results (e.g.
-service quality).
+23
-2. Activities or Technology-Specific: Provide a minimum of three metrics that measure the investment
-against its defined process standards or technical service level agreements (e.g. Reliability and
-Availability). At least one of these metrics must have a monthly reporting frequency
+21
-All data will be displayed to the public on the IT Dashboard. Ensure that all provided metrics information
-provided is publicly releasable.
+20
-Defining a new metric
+51
-When adding a new metric, such as for new investments or to provide new information about an existing
-investment, use the following table.
+34
-Metric ID
-[Limit:
-XXX char]
+1
-Metric
-Description
-[Limit: 500
-char]
+1
-Unit of
-Measure
-[Limit: 50
-char]
+1
-Table C.1A
+2
-FEA
-Performance
-Measurement
-Category
-Mapping
-[PRM
-Measurement
-Category]
+ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE
-2012
-Target
-[numeric]
+ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,250]:
+EXPAND_GRNLND_MOD
-2013
-Target
-[numeric]
+Donald Trump has mentioned an interest in the U.S. taking over Greenland.
+How likely do you think it is that Donald Trump will do this? [ROTATE
+RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-5/5-1 HOLDING 6 LAST]
-Measurement
-Condition
-[Over target/
-Under target]
+Jan 20-26,
+2026
+8
+12
+21
+22
+17
-Reporting
-Frequency
-[Monthly,
-Quarterly, Semi-
-Annual, Annual]
+Extremely likely
+Very likely
+Somewhat likely
+Not too likely
+Not at all likely
-Agency
-Strategic
-Goals/Agency
-Objective
-[New PRM Code]
+19
+1
-1. Metric ID: Unique ID provided by agency for the metric. When reporting actual results (see below), use
+Not sure
+No answer*
-this ID to reference the correct metric.
+Mar 24-30,
+202515
+7
+16
+28
+22
+13
-2. Metric Description: Description to help the user understand what is being measured. In this field,
+14
+*
-describe the units used, any calculation algorithm used, and the definition or limits of the population or
-“universe” measured.
+15
-3. Unit of Measure: Brief indication of what quantity is measured (e.g. number, percentage, dollar value)
+In the 2025 survey, question was worded “Donald Trump has mentioned an interest in the U.S. taking over Greenland. How
+likely do you think it is that Donald Trump will pursue this?”
-for each metric.
+www.pewresearch.org
-4. FEA Performance Measurement Category Mapping: Indicates the PRM measurement category as
+30
-described above.
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-5. 2012 Target: Metric target value from 2012
-6. 2013 Target: Metric target value for 2013
-7. Measurement Condition: Indicates whether a desired result would be “over the target” or “under the
-target.” For example, if the target is to reduce the error rate to 10%, then the desired result would be
-“under the target" so “under target” should be entered for measurement condition.
+ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,250]:
+EXPAND2_GRNLND
-8. Reporting Frequency: How often actual measurements will be reported (monthly, quarterly, semi-
+Do you favor or oppose the U.S. taking over Greenland, as Donald Trump has
+proposed? [ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-4/4-1 HOLDING 5 LAST]
-annually, or annually). Annual reporting frequencies are reserved for annual operating cost measures,
-performance measures associated with the agency’s annual performance plan, or other measures that can
-only be appropriated measured on an annual basis.
+Jan 20-26,
+2026
+10
+12
+13
+45
-9. Agency Strategic Goals/Agency Objective: For annual reporting frequency metrics, agencies will be
+Strongly favor
+Somewhat favor
+Somewhat oppose
+Strongly oppose
-required to provide the cross agency priority (CAP) goal; agency priority goal (APG); strategic goal (SG)
-or agency objective (OBJ) associated with the metric (using the new Performance Reference Model code
-use by Performance.gov).
+20
+1
-Page 44 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012)
+Not sure
+No answer*
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS
+Mar 24-30,
+2025
+8
+15
+12
+43
-Providing actual results:
+22
+1
-As actual results are measured at the appropriate frequency, report them using the following table. Also use this
-table when applicable to provide any historical actual results for a new metric (optional).
+ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE
-1. Metric ID: Unique ID provided by agency for the metric. Use this ID to reference the correct metric.
-2. Actual Result: Actual result measured.
-3. Date of Actual Result: End date of the most recent reporting period.
-4. Comment: A necessary provide a comment for each actual result reported, if necessary.
+ASK REPUBLICAN AND REPUBLICAN LEANERS (XPARTYSUMFINAL=1) [N=3,913]:
+Which comes closer to your view, even if neither is exactly right?
+REPWORKTRMP
+Republicans in Congress… [ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-2/2-1]
-When adding a new metric, include historical actual result information as available.
+Jan 20-26,
+2026
+38
-Metric ID
-[Limit: XXX char]
+61
-Table C.1B
+1
-Actual
-Result
-[numeric]
+Have an obligation to support Donald Trump’s policies and
+programs because he is a Republican president
+Do not have an obligation to support Donald Trump’s
+policies and programs if they disagree with him
+No answer*
-Date of Actual
-Result
-[date]
+Jan 27-Feb 2,
+2025
+44
-Comment
-[500 char]
-(optional)
+55
-Operational Risk
+1
-Risk assessments should include risk information from all stakeholders and should be performed at the initial
-concept stage and then monitored and controlled throughout the life cycle of the investment. A copy of the
-investment risk management plan must be uploaded to the IT Dashboard.
+ASK ALL:
+PARTY
+ASK IF INDEP/SOMETHING ELSE (PARTY=3,4 OR REFUSED):
+As of today do you lean more to…16
+PARTYLN
-In Table C.2, list all significant operational related risks submitted for the investment that are currently open and
-provide risk assessment information. It is not necessary to address all 19 OMB Risk Categories. Consider the
-combination of the risk probability and the risk impact when identifying significant risks. Include the following
-data in Table C.2:
+In politics today, do you consider yourself a…
-1. Risk Name: A short description that identifies the risk, the cause of the risk and the effect that the risk
+Republican
+28
-may have on the operational activity.
+Democrat Independent
-2. Risk Category: The relevant OMB Risk Category for each risk. Risk categories include:
+26
-1) Schedule, 2) Initial costs, 3) Life cycle costs, 4) Technical obsolescence, 5) Feasibility, 6) Reliability of systems,
-7) Dependencies and interoperability between this investment and others, 8) Surety (asset protection) considerations,
-9) Risk of creating a monopoly for future procurements, 10) Capability of agency to manage the investment, 11)
-Overall risk of investment failure, 12) Organizational and change management, 13) Business, 14) Data/info, 15)
-Technology, 16) Strategic, 17) Security, 18) Privacy, and 19) Project resources.
+29
-3. Risk Probability: The likelihood of a negative impact for the risk (Low, Medium, or High likelihood).
-4. Risk Impact: The level of a potential negative impact for the risk (Low, Medium, or High impact).
-5. Mitigation Plan: A short description of how to mitigate the risk.
+Something
+else
+15
-Risk Name
-[Limit: 500 char]
+No
+answer*
+2
-Risk Category
-[19 risk categories]
+Lean
+Rep
+18
-Table C.2
-Risk Probability
-[Low, Medium, High]
+Lean
+Dem
+21
-Risk Impact
-[Low, Medium, High]
+16
-Mitigation Plan
-[Limit: 500 char]
+PARTY and PARTYLN asked in a prior survey.
-Page 45 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012)
+www.pewresearch.org
diff --git a/q0/random_k4/question.json b/q0/random_k4/question.json
index b7c98542222d0a1508bb940f91c8e5938787c12e..fedeb6e3c785fe06d286de808a65b96119c714f0 100644
--- a/q0/random_k4/question.json
+++ b/q0/random_k4/question.json
@@ -17,10 +17,10 @@
],
"original_filenames": [
"PH_2016.06.08_Economy-Final.pdf",
- "web_24c4662e4f9e6338.pdf",
- "web_d455d7d1e8416aea.pdf",
- "web_b0b861dfece3f50d.pdf",
- "37a87e9ff89a0d96aebd89f4c09844ea1ab59f76.pdf"
+ "web_3cd8fd0905eadfd3.pdf",
+ "web_4af2298618127c8a.pdf",
+ "web_bfb031d3e591ca35.pdf",
+ "web_ff8dcb0ea2a037b7.pdf"
],
"modality": "markdown"
}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/q0/random_k4/random_1.md b/q0/random_k4/random_1.md
index 132a7a3a1eb856bf1ac3b2a8f7f839b34c78bc6d..0157c79493366431cd66d8105491fdfb94260f43 100644
--- a/q0/random_k4/random_1.md
+++ b/q0/random_k4/random_1.md
@@ -1,1593 +1,663 @@
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
+Thursday April 9
-About the National Science and Technology Council
+Topics for this Lecture:
+•Thermal Physics
-The National Science and Technology Council (NSTC) is the principal means by which the Executive
-Branch coordinates science and technology policy across the diverse entities that make up the federal
-research and development enterprise. A primary objective of the NSTC is to ensure science and
-technology (S&T) policy decisions and programs are consistent with the President’s stated goals. The
-NSTC prepares research and development strategies that are coordinated across federal agencies
-aimed at accomplishing multiple national goals. The work of the NSTC is organized under committees
-that oversee subcommittees and working groups focused on different aspects of science and
-technology. More information is available at www.whitehouse.gov/ostp/nstc.
+• Temperature & Heat
+• Temperature measurement
+• Thermal expansion
-About the Office of Science and Technology Policy
+•Thermal Physics
-The Office of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP) was established by the National Science and
-Technology Policy, Organization, and Priorities Act of 1976 to provide the President and others within
-the Executive Office of the President with advice on the scientific, engineering, and technological
-aspects of the economy, national security, homeland security, health, foreign relations, the
-environment, and the technological recovery and use of resources, among other topics. OSTP leads
-interagency S&T policy coordination efforts, assists the Office of Management and Budget with an
-annual review and analysis of federal research and development in budgets, and serves as a source of
-scientific and technological analysis and judgment for the President with respect to major policies,
-is available at
-plans, and programs of
-www.whitehouse.gov/ostp.
+• Phases & Latent Heat
+• Calorimetry
-federal government. More
+• TF = (9/5)(TC) + 32
+• “Temperature” is not “Heat”
+• Thermal linear expansion:
-information
+• ΔL = αL0ΔT [α] = K-1
-the
+• Heat energy flow:
+• Q=c*m*ΔT
+• Qlost = Qgained
-About the NSTC Subcommittee on Research and Development Infrastructure
+See the course webpage for slides,
+video links, and google docs Q&A links
+• Assignment 11 due Friday
+• Pre-class due 15min before class
+• Help Room: via Teams, 6-9pm
+Wed/Thurs, also via email on Wed/Thurs
+• SI: via Teams
+• Office Hours: via email
+(meisel@ohio.edu)
-The Subcommittee on Research and Development Infrastructure (RDI) coordinates federal investments
-in infrastructure supporting research and development (R&D) across the nation under the auspices of
-the NSTC’s Committee on Science and Technology Enterprise. This coordination ensures that U.S. R&D
-infrastructure and the scientific and engineering workforce it supports remain preeminent, relevant,
-and ready to address the nation’s economic and national security priorities.
+• Phase changes:
-About this Document
+Q=m*L
-Consistent with Section 1007 of the America Creating Opportunities to Meaningfully Promote
-Excellence in Technology, Education, and Science (COMPETES) Act, the National Science and
-Technology Council is required to “produce a report identifying and prioritizing the deficiencies in
-research facilities and major instrumentation located at federal laboratories and national user facilities
-at academic institutions that are widely accessible for use by researchers in the United States.” This
-document fulfills that requirement by providing an assessment of issues facing the United States’
-research and development infrastructure (RDI) and their impact on the nation’s status as a global leader
-in S&T. It aims be a tool for agencies to assess and address RDI concerns based on individual needs and
-resources. The assessment identifies four major issues affecting U.S. RDI: aging and inadequate
-research infrastructure; cascading impacts from substandard facilities; a widening gap in global S&T
-outcomes; and challenges in recruiting and retaining top talent. This assessment also offers four
-opportunities for agencies to meet future S&T needs: strategic planning, identifying gaps,
-benchmarking, and interagency collaboration).
+*If your circumstances
+hinder your completion of
+any of this class’s
+assignments, please let
+me know
+*These slides are
+recorded and posted in
+advance for your
+convenience.
+Administrative details
+may be out of date. Keep
+an eye on your email
+please.
-– i –
+Thermal Physics
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
+Why can we only see
+warm things in infrared
+and not cold objects?
-Copyright Information
+Why do bridges have
+these sorts of joints?
-This document is a work of the United States government and is in the public domain (see 17 U.S.C.
-§105). Subject to the stipulations below, it may be distributed and copied with acknowledgment to
-OSTP. Copyrights to graphics included in this document are reserved by the original copyright holders
-or their assignees and are used here under the government’s license and by permission. Requests to
-use any images must be made to the provider identified in the image credits or to OSTP if no provider
-is identified. Published in the United States of America, 2024.
+How much
+energy does it
+take to bring
+water to a boiling
+temperature?
-– ii –
+Temperature & Heat
+• Temperature:
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
+– A measure of the internal kinetic energy of atoms & molecules within an object.
+– This is a property of an object.
-NATIONAL SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY COUNCIL
+• Heat:
-Chair
+– A measure of the transfer of energy between two objects.
+– This is a property of an interaction, not of a single object.
+– Heat is the energy moving from a high temperature object to a low temperature object.
-Arati Prabhakar, Assistant to the President for
-Science and Technology; and Director, Office
-of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP)
+Temperature Scales
-Executive Director
+• A few common units are used for temperature:
-Kei Koizumi, Principal Deputy Director for
-Science, Society, and Policy, OSTP
+– Fahrenheit, Celsius, & Kelvin
+• Fahrenheit is related to Celsius by:
+ TFahrenheit = (9/5)TCelsius + 32
+ ΔTFahrenheit = (9/5)ΔTCelsius
+• Celsius is related to Kelvin by:
+ TKelvin = TCelsius + 273.15
-NSTC SUBCOMMITTEE ON RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT
-INFRASTRUCTURE
+20C is about
+room
+temperature.
-Co-Chairs
+Zero C is
+freezing,
+10C is cold,
+20C is nice,
+30C is hot.
-Executive Secretary
+• Zero Kelvin is “absolute zero” (lowest possible T)
+• Zero Celsius is the freezing point for water,
+which is 32 Fahrenheit and 273.15 Kelvin.
-Harriet Kung, Department of Energy
+• 100 Celsius is the boiling point for water,
-Mariam Elsayed, Department of Energy
+which is 212 Fahrenheit and 373.14 Kelvin.
-Linnea Avallone, National Science Foundation
+Thermal Expansion of Solids: Linear expansion
-Jagadeesh Pamulapati, Department of
+• Objects expand when their temperature increases.
+• The amount of expansion depends on the material
+properties and is known as
+the expansion coefficient: α
+• α depends on the particular material
+(and one the phase of matter). SI unit: K-1
+• α describes how much an object expands
+in a linear dimension for a given temperature
+increase
-Defense
+ ΔL = αL0ΔT
-Cole Donovan, Office of Science and
+• The fractional change in length is:
-Technology Policy
+ ΔL/L = αΔT
+ ΔT must be in Celsius or Kelvin
-Members
+• Typical α values are (at 20 degrees C):
-Aliya Iftikhar, Office of Science and
+–Aluminum, Copper, Silver: ~2x10-5 K-1
+–Concrete, Glass, Steel : ~1x10-5 K-1
+–Diamond: ~0.1x10-5 K-1
-Jason Boehm, National Institute for Standards
+This is why you need special
+joints for, e.g. bridges
-Technology Policy
+An 0.5m-long rod with a thermal expansion coefficient of α ~ 10-5 K-1 is heated
+from room temperature (~293K) to the boiling temperature for water (~373K).
+How much extra length does the rod have after heating?
-and Technology
+2
-Gordon Hengst, Department of Defense
+(A) 4x10-6 m
+(B) 4x10-4 m
+(C) 4x10-2 m
+(D) 4 m
-Gary Matlock, National Oceanic and
+1. ΔL = αL0ΔT
+2. ΔL = (10-5 K-1)(0.5m)(373K - 293K)
+3. ΔL = (10-5 K-1)(0.5m)(80K)
+4. ΔL = 0.0004m = 400μm This is ~4 human hair widths.
-Atmospheric Administration
+A bi-metallic strip is composed of one metal sandwiched together with
+another, so one metal is on top and another metal is on the bottom.
+If the metal on the top half has a smaller thermal expansion coefficient
+than the metal on the bottom half, which picture best represents what
+happens after the bi-metallic strip is heated?
-Terence Lynch, National Oceanic and
+3
-Atmospheric Administration
+(A) 1
+(B) 2
+(C) 3
-Bob McDonald, National Institutes of Health
+1. ΔL = αL0ΔT
+2. The top strip has a
+smaller α and so it
+will expand less than the
+bottom strip.
-Angela Hadley, Environmental Protection
+3. To achieve the extra
+length on the bottom,
+without lengthening the
+top-half by the same
+amount, the strip is
+forced to bend upwards.
-Agency
+Leonard G.
-Kartik Sheth, National Aeronautics and Space
+This is how some of the
+older spring-based
+thermostats work.
+Temperature changes cause
+the spring to bend,
+ultimately completing a
+circuit to turn on/off the
+heat/AC.
-Administration
+Heat
-Scott Miller, Smithsonian Institution
+ Sect 14.1
-Alexander Kurien, General Services
+• Heat is thermal energy that flows from a high-
-Administration
+temperature object to a low-temperature object.
-Paul Strang, Department of Homeland
+• Heat depends on parameters of a process.
-Security
+These are so-called “state variables”
+– Internal energy (U) of the objects,
-Joon Park, Department of Agriculture
+i.e. the kinetic energy of atoms/molecules inside
-Mike Villarreal, Department of Agriculture
+– Temperature (T) of the objects
-Geoff Plumlee, U.S. Geological Survey
+• Your body radiates heat to the surrounding
-Dan Hayba, U.S. Geological Survey
+environment as light.
+• We see that light in the
+infrared wavelengths.
-Esha Mathew, State Department
+Which of these processes will require the most thermal energy?
-– iii –
+6
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
+(A) Raising 1kg of water by 10K
-Acknowledgements
+(B) Raising 2kg of water by 10K
-OSTP and the NSTC thank the members of the Writing Team for their time, expertise, and significant
-contributions to the report: Michelle Buchanan, Shelby Walker, Skip Vaughn, Gordon Hengst, Mariam
-Elsayed, Aliya Iftikhar, and Cole Donovan. OSTP and the NSTC also thank the Oak Ridge National
-Laboratory science writing team—Betsy Sonewald, Holly Haun, Marissa Mills, and Jackie Kerr—for their
-efforts in shaping and finalizing the report, and the Institute for Defense Analysis, Science and
-Technology Policy Institute team—Walter Valdivia, Gifford Wong, Kush Patel, Skandan Ananthasekar,
-and Matthew Diasio—for their literature review and contributions.
+(C) Raising 2kg of water by 20K
-– 1 –
+(D) All the same
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
+1. More heat will be required to create a larger temperature change.
+2. The more material you have to heat-up, the more energy it will take.
-Table of Contents
+Heat: Heat-energy required to change an object’s temperature
-Executive Summary ........................................................................................................... 4
+• More heat is required to raise the temperature of a larger object.
+• More heat is required to induce a larger temperature change.
+• The exact amount of heat will depend on properties of the material.
-Introduction ...................................................................................................................... 7
+– These are described the the “specific heat capacity”, c
+– c is the amount of energy required to raise the temperature of a given
-Status and Outlook for U.S. Federal Research and Development Infrastructure ....................... 10
+mass of a particular material by a certain temperature change
-Aging and Inadequate Research Infrastructure .................................................................................... 11
+– The SI unit of c is: J/(kg*K)
+– Typical values of c are ~100J/(kg*K)
-Cascading Impacts from Substandard Facilities .................................................................................. 15
+Aluminum is 10X higher than this
+(which is atypically large for a solid).
+Meaning it is hard to heat-up.
+Though, liquid water is even higher.
-Widening Gaps in Global S&T Outcomes ............................................................................................... 18
+• In a formula:
-Challenges in Recruiting and Retaining Top Scientific and Engineering Talent .................................. 20
+ Q=c*m*ΔT
-Opportunities ................................................................................................................... 22
+• If the temperature of an object decreases,
+it will release heat into an environment
-Strategic Planning .................................................................................................................................. 23
+• This does not describe phase changes (e.g. liquid water to solid ice)
-Identification of Gaps ............................................................................................................................. 23
+You want to heat a 1kg block of aluminum and 0.5kg of water by 20K.
+Which of these processes will require the most thermal energy?
-Benchmarking International RDI and Identifying Collaborations ........................................................ 24
+7
-Sharing RDI Strategies ........................................................................................................................... 24
+(A) the aluminum block
-Maintaining Strong and Integrated RDI Planning and Coordination ................................................... 25
+(B) the water
-Ensuring RDIs Support a Flexible and Agile R&D Enterprise ................................................................. 25
+(C) both the same amount of heat
-Advancing RDI Capabilities to Support the Convergence of Disciplines and Sectors ......................... 26
+1. Q= mcΔT
+2. Qal= malcalΔT = (1kg)(900J/(kgK))(20K) = 18,000J
+3. Qwater= mwatercwaterΔT = (0.5kg)(4000J/(kgK))(20K) = 40,000J
+4. The water will require more heat.
-Balancing RDI Openness with Security Needs ...................................................................................... 26
+caluminum ≈ 900 J/(kg*K)
+cwater ≈ 4,000 J/(kg*K)
-Conclusion ....................................................................................................................... 26
+Calorimetry: Measuring heat-energy transfer via temperature changes
-– 1 –
+• Suppose I want to measure how much heat-energy a chemical reaction
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
+dumps into a fluid. How do I do it?
-Abbreviations and Acronyms
+• By measuring the temperature before and after the reaction, we get ΔT.
+• If we measure the mass of our fluid and know the specific heat,
-AI
+then the heat energy is given by Q= mcΔT
-Artificial Intelligence
+• The energy “lost” by the chemical reaction is gained by the surrounding
-ALMA
+environment:
-Atacama Large Millimeter-Submillimeter Array
+ Qlost = Qgained
-AOML
+• A key detail is that the stuff you care about (the system),
+e.g. the chemical reaction stuff + the water in this picture,
+must be thermally isolated from the surrounding environment
+(here by coffee cups)
-NOAA Atlantic Oceanographic and Meteorological Laboratory
+ Sect 14.2
-ARS
+Two liters of water at 353K is added to 1.5-liters of water at 293K.
+No energy is lost to the surroundings.
+What is the final equilibrium temperature of the water?
+Note, 1liter of water has a mass of 1kg.
-Agricultural Research Service
+8
-CERN
+(A) 293 K
-European Organization for Nuclear Research
+(B) 323K
-DoD
+(C) 327K
-DOE
+(D) 353 K
-Department of Defense
+1. Qlost = Qgained
+2. (mcΔT)2liters = (mcΔT)1.5liters
+3. (2kg)(353K - Tfinal) = (1.5kg)(Tfinal - 293K)
+4. 706kg*K - (2kg)Tfinal = (1.5kg)Tfinal - 439.5kg*K
+5. 1,145.5kg*K = (3.5kg)Tfinal
+6. Tfinal = (1,145.5kg*K)(3.5kg) ≈ 327K
-Department of Energy
+cwater ≈ 4,000 J/(kg*K)
-ECMWF European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasting
+You have two beakers of water, each with 1kg of water (c=4186J/(kgK)) at 293K.
+You drop one 353K block of 1kg of metal into each beaker, but one block is made
+of aluminum (c= 900J/(kgK)) and the other is made of copper (c= 386J/(kgK)).
+Once each beaker reaches thermal equilibrium with the block, which beaker of
+water has a higher temperature?
-EIC
+9
-EOP
+(A) beaker with aluminum
-EPA
+(B) beaker with copper
-Electron-Ion Collider
+(C) both reach same equilibrium temperature
-Executive Office of the President
+cwater ≈ 4,000 J/(kg*K)
-Environmental Protection Agency
+1. Aluminum has a larger specific heat capacity than copper.
+2. This means it takes more energy to change the temperature of aluminum.
+3. It also means that more energy is deposited by a change in temperature of the
-FAST
+aluminum block, relative to copper.
-Five-hundred-meter Aperture Spherical radio Telescope
+Math answer:
+1. Qlost = Qgained
+2. (mcΔT)block = (mcΔT)water
+3. mblockcblock(Tblock - Tfinal) = mwatercwater(Tfinal - Twater)
+4. mblockcblockTblock - mblockcblockTfinal = mwatercwaterTfinal - mwatercwaterTwater
+5. mblockcblockTblock - mwatercwaterTwater = (mwatercwater + mblockcblock)Tfinal
+6. Tfinal = (mblockcblockTblock - mwatercwaterTwater)/(mwatercwater + mblockcblock)
-FY
+Thermal Energy Storage
-fiscal year
+• Large objects can be used as energy reservoirs
-FFRDCs
+by storing energy as heat.
-federally funded R&D centers
+• Excess energy can be stored as heat to be
+released later, or to smooth-out the power
+distribution from a different energy source.
+• E.g. store extra solar energy from the day or
+wind energy from a windy day to use later
+during the night.
-NIST
+• The earth itself is a large hot object
-National Institutes of Standards and Technology
+(where the heat comes from radioactive decays
+inside the earth’s core).
+This heat forms the basis of geothermal energy.
-IT
+A 1kg block of aluminum (c=900J/(kgK)) has an initial temperature of 300K.
+The block is placed over an electric heater which provides 150W of power
+for 300 seconds.
+After this heating episode, what is the temperature of the aluminum block?
-information technology
+10
-JWST
+(A) 50K
-James Webb Space Telescope
+(B) 300K
-LBNF
+(C) 350K
-Long Baseline Neutrino Facility
+(D) 450K
-NAIRR National AI Research Resource
+1. Q = mcΔT
+2. ΔT = Q/mc
+3. Q = P*t = 150W*300s = 45,000J
+4. ΔT = (45,000J)/(1kg*900J/(kgK)) = 50K
+5. Tfinal = Tinitial + ΔT = 300K + 50K = 350K.
-NASA
+1W = 1J/s
-National Aeronautics and Space Administration
+Phases: Definitions
-NASEM National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine
+• Solid: Stays the same shape
+• Liquid: Takes the shape of the container*, but preserves volume
+• Gas: Fills the volume of the container
-NIH
+*To be clear,
+cats are not liquids
-National Institutes of Health
+Phase Changes
-NIST
+• Latent heat describes the amount of energy that needs to be absorbed to change phases
-National Institute for Standards and Technology
+or the amount of energy that is released upon a phase transition
+due to breaking/forming molecular bonds
-NMNH
+• Energy must be absorbed (“endothermic”) for solid->liquid or liquid->gas
+• Energy is released (“exothermic”) for gas->liquid or liquid->solid
+• Latent Heat of Fusion, LFusion: solid ↔ liquid
+• Latent heat of Vaporization, LVaporization: liquid ↔ gas
-Smithsonian National Museum of Natural History
+Latent Heat
-NOAA
+• Latent heat adds/removes heat during a phase transition:
+• Following the heat added to bring water from ice to water-vapor:
+𝑄𝑄 = 𝑚𝑚𝑚𝑚
+Water:
+Lfusion = 33.5x104 J/kg
+Lvapor = 22.6x105 J/kg
+cice = 2090 J/kg ºC
+csteam = 2010 J/kg ºC
+cwater = 4186 J/kg ºC
-National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration
+QA QB QC
-NSF
+QD
-National Science Foundation
+QE
-NSTC
+QA=mciceΔT
+QB=mLfusion
+QC=mcwaterΔT
+QD=mLvaporization
+QE=mcsteamΔT
-National Science and Technology Council
+How much energy is required to melt 0.5kg of ice?
-OSTP
+1
-Office of Science and Technology Policy
+(A) 1045 J
-PRC
+(B) 2090 J
-R&D
+(C) 2093 J
-RDI
+(D) 16.7x104 J
-People’s Republic of China
+1. This is a phase transition: use Q=mL
+Ice to liquid transition: Lfusion = 33.5x104 J/kg
+2.
+3. Q=(0.5kg)*(33.533.5x104 J/kg) = 16.7x104 J
-research and development
+Calorimetry
-research and development infrastructure
+• Qlost-from-hot-object = Qgained-by-cold-object
+• T is positive in this definition; i.e. subtract
+the higher temperature from the lower one
-RDT&E
+• The calorimeter is a classic tool to take
-research, development, test, and evaluation
+advantage of this
-SC
+• For the example on the right,
-DOE Office of Science
+mwatercwaterΔTwater + mcupccupTcup =
+mobjectcobjectTobject
-– 2 –
+Consider 1kg of material A (Blue) and material B (Green).
+Which requires the most energy to change from the liquid to the
+gas phase?
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
+2
-S&T
+(A) A (B) B (C) They require the same amount
-science and technology
+A longer horizontal stretch
+corresponds to more added heat
+to achieve a phase transition
-STEM
+C
-science, technology, engineering, and math
+º
-USDA
+p
+m
+e
+T
-U.S. Department of Agriculture
+B
-– 3 –
+A
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
+gas
-Executive Summary
+liquid
-President Biden is delivering an "Infrastructure Decade" that will unlock access to economic
-opportunity, create good paying jobs, boost domestic manufacturing, and grow America's economy
-from the middle out and bottom up. As the President has said, “To have the best economy in the
-world…you have to have the best infrastructure in the world.” That starts with investing in America and
-building on our leadership in American research and development (R&D).
+Solid
-The America Creating Opportunities to Meaningfully Promote Excellence in Technology, Education, and
-Science (COMPETES) Act of 2007 (“the Act”) requires that the National Science and Technology Council
-(NSTC) produce an annual report “identifying and prioritizing the deficiencies in research facilities and
-major instrumentation located at federal laboratories and national user facilities at academic
-institutions that are widely accessible for use by researchers in the United States.”1
+Heat
-This report focuses on the Act’s charge to address the growing deficiencies at federal and national
-laboratories. This report provides an overview of those deficiencies and (short of additional
-appropriations) makes suggestions about practices that could be more widely adopted throughout
-government agencies. The report builds on the 2021 National Strategic Overview for Research and
-Development Infrastructure,2 which provided a broad overview of the management and policy tools
-used in the development and management of federal research and development infrastructure (RDI).
+A 500g aluminum cylinder at T=20C is heated using steam at T=140C.
+What is the minimum mass of the steam required to raise the
+temperature of the aluminum cylinder by 40C?
-In spite of the challenges facing the federal RDI ecosystem, since the last report was written there have
-been several major developments in U.S. research and development infrastructure. For example, on
-December 25, 2021, the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) launched and has sent back unparalleled
-insight into exoplanets, the origins of our universe, and more. The National Ignition Facility announced
-that on December 5, 2022, it achieved fusion ignition for the first time. Major construction projects like
-the Electron-Ion Collider (EIC) and Long Baseline Neutrino Facility (LBNF) have hit critical milestones
-and announced significant international partnerships. On the planning and competition front, both the
-Department of Energy (DOE) and Department of State have engaged in global surveys of international
-RDI capabilities to help inform our future competitive landscape, and the DOE advisory committees are
-undertaking a broad-based prioritization effort to identify critical capabilities through the next
-decades. Significant progress has been made through community planning processes in all fields
-relevant to research and development infrastructure (RDI), supported by our federal advisory
-committees and the decadal planning processes undertaken by the National Academies of Sciences,
-Engineering, and Medicine (NASEM).
+3
-This report identifies four trends that can be found across federal research agencies. They are as
-follows:
+(A) 7mg
-• Aging and Inadequate Research Infrastructure
+(B) 0.7kg
-• Cascading Impacts from Substandard Facilities
+(C) 7kg
-1 America COMPETES Act of 2007. Public Law 10-69, Section 1007. https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/PLAW-
+(D) 70kg
-110publ69
+1. Qgained = Qlost
+2. Heat Gained by Aluminum = Heat Lost by the Steam (1. Cooling, 2. Condensing, 3. Water Cooling)
+3. mAlcAl(ΔT)Al = msteamcsteam(ΔT)steam + msteamLvaporization + mwatercwater(ΔT)water
+4. msteam = mwater (note csteam ≠ cwater)
+5. mAlcAl(ΔT)Al = msteam[csteam(ΔT)steam + Lvaporization + cwater(ΔT)water]
+6. msteam = mAlcAl(ΔT)Al /[csteam(ΔT)steam + Lvaporization + cwater(ΔT)water]
+7. msteam = [(0.5kg)(900J/kgC)(60C-20C)]/[2010J/kgC(140C-100C) +
-2 “National Strategic Overview for Research and Development Infrastructure” October 2021.
+2.2x106J/kg+ 4186J/kgC(100C-60C)]
-https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/NSTC-NSO-RDI-_REV_FINAL-10-2021.pdf
+8. msteam = 7.18x10-3kg ≈ 7mg
-– 4 –
+Aluminum:
+cAl = 900 J/kg*C
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
+Water:
+Lfusion = 33.5x104 J/kg
+Lvapor = 22.6x105 J/kg
+cice = 2090 J/kg ºC
+csteam = 2010 J/kg ºC
+cwater = 4186 J/kg ºC
-• Widening Gaps in Global Science and Technology (S&T) Outcomes
+A slug of copper (0.2kg) at 800C is immersed in 0.4kg of water at 80C.
+The final temp is 100C. Part of the water boiled off as steam.
+What was the mass of the water converted to steam?
-• Challenges in Recruiting and Retaining Top Scientific and Engineering Talent
+4
-To address these, the report identifies four areas that agencies can currently use within their existing
-budgets and legal authorities to help address these deficiencies:
+(A) 7mg
-• Strategic Planning
+(B) 8mg
-o Agencies should develop processes to communicate the need for RDI investments to
-budget planners, Congress, and other stakeholders, and include the potential impact if
-such investments in R&D infrastructure are not realized. Specific and measurable
-impacts to mission execution are more persuasive than general impacts that are
-difficult to attribute.
+(C) 9mg
-o The need for RDI investments should be documented with thorough assessments of
-facilities’ maintenance and modernization needs, including both costs and well-
-defined prioritizations developed by each agency, and these assessments should be
-updated regularly.
+(D) 10mg
-•
+1. Qgained = Qlost
+2. Heat lost by copper= Warms-up water + Converts some water to steam
+3.mCucCu(ΔT)Cu = mwatercwater(ΔT)water + msteamLvaporization
+4.msteam = [(mCucCu(ΔT)Cu) - (mwatercwater(ΔT)water)]/Lvaporization
+5.msteam = [(0.2kg)(387J/kgC)(800C-100C) - (0.4kg)(4186J/kgC)(100C-
-Identification of Gaps
+80C)]/(2.26x106J/kg)
-o Agencies should utilize decadal surveys, workshops, and other community planning
-efforts to identify and prioritize the long-term federal RDI needs of the U.S. research
-community, including elements that must be maintained to support U.S. researchers in
-academe, industry, and government.
+6.msteam = 9.16 x10-3 kg ≈ 9mg … which is 9mL of liquid water
-o Agencies should remain cognizant of the ways in which facility closures may result in
-U.S. dependence on international facilities and weigh the consequences if those
-capabilities are no longer possessed by the United States or its allies.
+Copper:
+cCu = 387 J/kg*C
-• Benchmarking International RDI and Identifying Collaborations
+Water:
+Lfusion = 33.5x104 J/kg
+Lvapor = 22.6x105 J/kg
+cice = 2090 J/kg ºC
+csteam = 2010 J/kg ºC
+cwater = 4186 J/kg ºC
-o Agencies should regularly assess the competitive position of U.S. capabilities in their
-respective mission areas through benchmarking activities, such as those conducted by
-DOE’s Office of Science (SC) federal advisory committees, the State Department’s
-survey of international facilities, and through the decadal survey process.
+It takes 10 minutes for your stove burner to bring 2 quarts of water
+(~1.9kg) to boiling (100C) from room temperature (20C).
+What is the minimum power output of your stove burner?
+(I.e. assume 100% efficiency of heat transfer)
-o To facilitate collaborations, agencies should pursue existing mechanisms (e.g., the
-Florence Agreement Program3 and S&T agreements) and identify new ways to facilitate
-both national and international cooperative activities, as well as reduce barriers for in-
-kind contributions, materials exchange, contract and intellectual property terms, and
-technologies importation.
+8
-• Sharing RDI Strategies
+(A) 1060 W (B) 600 W (C) 4186 W (D) 640,000 W
-o The NSTC Subcommittee on Research and Development Infrastructure will coordinate
-an interagency working group focused on ensuring the competitive position of U.S. RDI,
-with activities to include sharing information on long-term strategic planning efforts,
+1. Power = Energy/Time
+2. Energy = Heat = Q = mwatercwaterΔT = (1.9kg)(4186J/kgC)(100C-20C) = 636,272J
+3. Time = 10min=600s
+4. Power= (636,272J)/(600s) = 1060 J/s = 1060 W
-3 Statutory Import Programs,” (International Trade Administration, n.d.). www.trade.gov/statutory-import-
+Water:
+Lfusion = 33.5x104 J/kg
+Lvapor = 22.6x105 J/kg
+cice = 2090 J/kgC
+csteam = 2010 J/kgC
+cwater = 4186 J/kgC
+ρwater = 1000kg/m3
-programs
+You will NOT be asked about the material below on
+any homework or exam. Therefore you CAN IGNORE
+IT, if you like.
-– 5 –
+We had to trim the following from this year’s course content due to the pandemic.
+However, I think some of you may be curious.
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
+A washer is made of some metal with some thermal coefficient of linear
+expansion, α.
+If the washer is heated, what happens to R1 and R2?
-identifying gaps in capabilities, and facilitating opportunities for national and
-international collaborations in facilities.
+(A) R1 decreases, R2 increases
-Being a science superpower carries the burden of supporting and maintaining the advanced underlying
-infrastructure that supports the research and development enterprise. Congressional appropriations
-have not kept pace with maintenance needs across multiple administrations, resulting in multibillion
-dollar maintenance backlogs across multiple government agencies, forcing government managers into
-a position where they must choose between executing science missions or maintaining their facilities.
+(B) R1 increases, R2 increases
-These challenges come at a time when the People’s Republic of China (PRC) and other parts of the world
-are able to provide newer, state-of-the-art facilities offering improved access that attracts U.S. and
-other international researchers.4 Without action to remedy the situation, deferred maintenance will
-only increase in both cost and impact to the U.S. taxpayer and to many of the nation’s critical S&T
-programs.
+(C) R1 increases, R2 decreases
-Finally, to support the continued development of a robust federal RDI ecosystem, agencies should
-continue to support the opportunities mentioned in the 2021 National Strategic Overview:5
+(D) R1 decreases, R2 decreases
-• Maintaining Strong and Integrated RDI Planning and Coordination
+1. ΔL = αL0ΔT
+2. This means all linear dimensions increase.
+3. The radii are linear dimensions, so both will increase.
-• Ensuring RDIs Support a Flexible and Agile R&D Enterprise
+For instance, consider what would
+happen if our washer were made-
+up of separate square components.
+All sides would lengthen and “R1”
+and “R2” would both increase.
-• Advancing RDI Capabilities to Support the Convergence of Disciplines and Sectors
+Thermal Expansion of Solids: Volume expansion
-• Balancing RDI Openness with Security Needs
+• Sometimes we want to consider how the volume of an object changes
-4 “Can the U.S. Compete in Basic Energy Sciences? Critical Research Frontiers and Strategies” (A report by the
+when we heat it. This is the volume expansion
-BESAC Subcommittee on International Benchmarking, 2021), 3. https://science.osti.gov/-
-/media/bes/pdf/reports/2021/International_Benchmarking-Report.pdf
+• Volume expansion: ΔV = βV0ΔT
+• The fractional change in volume is: ΔV/V0 = βΔT
+• β is the coefficient of volume expansion (SI units: K-1)
-5 “National Strategic Overview for Research and Development Infrastructure” October 2021, vi.
+– For solids: β≈3α
+– For liquids: More complicated, so look-up in table
-https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/NSTC-NSO-RDI-_REV_FINAL-10-2021.pdf
+Most materials expand in volume when
+they heat-up. However, water doesn’t.
-– 6 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-Introduction
-
-“The race for technological dominance is
-inextricably intertwined with evolving
-geopolitics and is increasingly shaped by
-broader political, economic, and societal
-rivalries, particularly those associated with
-the PRC’s rise.
-
-The United States has a rich history of investing
-heavily in its S&T enterprise, its S&T workforce, as
-well as RDI, including laboratories, specialized
-facilities, and equipment. A focus on S&T expanded
-during the 1950s as the Cold War escalated. Under
-the GI Benefits Bill, thousands of returning veterans
-were trained as scientists and engineers to establish
-the nation’s leadership in S&T, and this growth
-continued as the generation of baby boomers, who
-grew up during the Sputnik era, pursued careers in
-S&T. During the 1950s and 1960s, the federal
-government greatly expanded research programs
-across multiple agencies to catalyze growth in
-research and development (R&D). Concurrently, the
-U.S. government invested millions of dollars in
-to
-building
-accommodate the nation’s growing R&D enterprise.
-These facilities, constructed at federal agencies and
-federally funded R&D centers (FFRDCs), included
-new laboratory buildings and specialized facilities
-and equipment, such as accelerators, ground- and
-space-based telescopes, reactors, and X-ray sources, to study fundamental and applied science. This
-investment helped build the nation’s research and development infrastructure (RDI), which is defined
-as the “facilities or systems used by scientific and technical communities to conduct R&D or foster
-innovation.”6
-
-Amassing the resources to sustain broad
-technology leadership, including the
-concentration of human talent,
-foundational knowledge, and supply
-chains, requires decades of long-term
-investment and visionary leadership. Those
-focusing their resources today are likely to
-be the technology leaders of 2040.”
+*Note the change in density is tiny, so we
+can usually get away with ignoring it,
+until the phase-transition to ice happens.
-“Global Trends 2040: A More Contested World,”
-National Intelligence Council, 2021, 56.
-http://www.dni.gov/files/ODNI/documents/assessm
-
-laboratories and other
-
-ents/GlobalTrends_2040.pdf
-
-facilities
-
-These substantial investments propelled the United States to global science leadership and led to
-technology breakthroughs that served as a foundation for the nation’s economic growth and national
-security. Even under the Congressionally-authorized levels in the CHIPS and Science Act of 2022,
-Federal RDI construction and maintenance has not seen the same level of prioritization as in prior
-decades. One result has been an aging of the infrastructure at federal research laboratories and
-facilities that is reducing scientific output and, in some cases, impacting the ability of departments and
-agencies to meet their mission needs.
-
-The existing federal scientific infrastructure served the nation well in the 20th century, enabling the
-United States to become a global leader in scientific discovery, talent development, and innovation.
-Having reached that pinnacle, however, many U.S. scientists and engineers are now faced with
-conducting 21st century R&D in many facilities designed in the 1950s that cannot support modern
-research and current laboratory practices in health and safety. Many do not have sufficient, clean,
-reliable, and secure electrical power necessary to support today’s instrumentation and high-
-performance computers. Some also lack modern information technology (IT) capabilities needed to
-
-6 “National Strategic Overview for Research and Development Infrastructure,” Subcommittee on Research and
-
-Development Infrastructure of the National Science and Technology Council, October 2021, iii.
-www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/NSTC-NSO-RDI-_REV_FINAL-10-2021.pdf
-
-– 7 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-protect against data loss and cyberattacks (assuming such networking capabilities are even present).
-Older HVAC systems are inefficient and costly to operate, and buildings were not designed to allow the
-strict environmental controls needed for today’s laboratory operations. In many cases, infrastructure
-has reached end-of-life for systems that manage water and sewage, steam and chilled water
-distribution, and electrical networks.
-
-Departments and agencies have reported that the average age of their facilities exceeds the 40- to 50-
-year design life of most facilities, with half rated to be in poor or critical condition. Because these
-facilities are operating well beyond their expected lifetimes, the risk of failures is high. The risk is further
-compounded by aging water, steam, gas, electrical, and other types of distribution systems that are
-often inefficient, difficult to repair, and do not meet modern safety codes. Failing infrastructure is
-causing interruptions in research activities lasting weeks or months and has resulted in significant
-setbacks due to lost work time, loss of samples, and damaged equipment, as well as increased costs to
-research programs. Another critical issue facing federal RDI is that facilities built in the mid-20th century
-generally cannot support the needs of modern research, which requires clean, reliable electrical power,
-strictly controlled environments, robust internet networks, and integrated cybersecurity infrastructure,
-among other requirements not found in older facilities. Further, investments in new scientific user
-facilities are needed to provide U.S. researchers with world-leading capabilities. Without RDI designed
-for advancing critical and emerging technologies, such as quantum information S&T, engineering
-materials, biotechnologies, sensors, and microelectronics, U.S. leadership in these areas will be
-seriously and adversely impacted.
-
-The challenges that the U.S. RDI enterprise is experiencing are not new and reflect decades of
-inadequate funding due to deprioritizing maintenance at existing facilities, development of new
-facilities, and decommissioning of outdated facilities. Further, these challenges are occurring
-simultaneously with intensified S&T competition with other nations. This is especially true of the PRC,
-which is vying to become the preferred partner on large RDI projects for other nations. For instance, the
-PRC has invested in new RDI outside of its borders, building supercomputers,7 earth observing satellite
-constellations,8 telescopes,9 and even biosafety labs10 in Africa and South America. In 2022, PRC
-President Xi Jinping committed to increase the number of international laboratories built in countries
-participating in the Belt and Road Initiative to 100 over five years.11 As the PRC develops such novel
-capabilities, the pressure for U.S. scientists to seek partnerships in order to utilize those capabilities in
-order to say at the top of their fields correspondingly increases.
-
-7 High speed computer donated to Tunisia's scientific research field. China Global Television Network, retrieved
-
-from YouTube, June 25, 2019. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VzLJ8qi_XGk
-
-8 Special Report: China’s Space Collaboration with Africa: Implications and Recommendations for the United
-
-States. U.S. Institute of Peace, September 2023. https://www.usip.org/sites/default/files/2023-09/sr-
-524_china-space-collaboration-africa-implications-recommendations-for-us.pdf
-
-9 South America is embracing Beijing’s science silk road. Nature, May 8, 2019.
-
-https://www.nature.com/immersive/d41586-019-01127-4/index.html
-
-10 Africa CDC and China CDC Commit to Deepen their Cooperation. Africa Centres for Disease Control and
-
-Prevention. https://africacdc.org/news-item/africa-cdc-and-china-cdc-commit-to-deepen-their-cooperation/
-
-11 China’s Belt and Road Initiative is boosting science — the West must engage, not withdraw. Nature, October
-
-24, 2023. https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-023-03299-6
-
-– 8 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-Some international facilities possess certain advantages due to their structuring as international
-organizations or state-supported commercial enterprises with stable, multiyear funding. Europe, in
-particular, has substantial experience leveraging investments from multiple countries through
-organizations like the European Organization for Nuclear Research (CERN), the European Southern
-Observatory, and the European Clinical Research Infrastructure Network. While many of these facilities,
-like CERN, provide open research platforms that mirror the U.S. model of facility access based on merit,
-other international facilities either require membership in an international treaty or fee-based access
-for outsiders. Others, like the European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasting (ECMWF) and
-COSMO-SkyMed satellite constellation charge for access to products and services. This has direct
-consequences for broad U.S. access to and utilization of significant RDI capabilities. The challenges
-associated with U.S. participation in such facilities (to include limitations due to the appropriations
-process and Anti-Deficiency Act) often means that the United States does not have a seat at the table
-when setting the rules for international RDI governance, providing an opening for competitors like the
-PRC and Russia to have greater say in the governance of platforms that may require the development
-of novel or dual-use technology.
-
-In addition to buildings and facilities, other capabilities factor into the way the United States conducts
-research. High-performance computers, combined with new modeling and data analysis techniques,
-such as artificial intelligence and machine learning, allow large sets of diverse data to be assimilated,
-analyzed, and modeled, accelerating the pace of discovery and development. For example,
-computational tools can be used in conjunction with multiple types of structural data combined with
-measured material properties to yield insight into the relationship of a material’s structure with its
-properties. Such an approach would expedite the discovery of new materials critical to emerging
-technologies, including electronics, quantum materials, and engineering materials. Similarly, data from
-infrastructure distributed across the nation, such as multiple types of air, water, and soil monitors and
-satellite data, could be rapidly analyzed and modeled to provide more complete and timely
-assessments of ecosystems.
-
-While the United States continues to lead the world in many fields of S&T at present, urgent efforts must
-be made to ensure that federal RDI is ready to serve the nation’s research community in the future.
-Numerous efforts to develop world-leading R&D capabilities have been deployed or are underway.
-These include the successful commissioning and deployment of JWST12 and major R&D facilities
-construction projects like the EIC13 and LBNF hitting critical milestones14 and announcing international
-partnerships. Designed to facilitate a shared national research infrastructure for responsible artificial
-intelligence (AI) discovery and innovation for the broad research and education community, the
-National AI Research Resource (NAIRR) launched its pilot on January 24, 2024, with 10 government
-
-12 “NASA’s Webb Telescope Is Now Fully Ready for Science.” (NASA. July 11, 2022).
-
-https://blogs.nasa.gov/webb/2022/07/11/nasas-webb-telescope-is-now-fully-ready-for-science/
-
-13 “Electron-Ion Collider Set to Begin Long-Lead Procurements.” (Brookhaven National Laboratory, April 2, 2024).
-
-https://www.bnl.gov/newsroom/news.php?a=121812
-
-14 “Excavation of colossal caverns for Fermilab’s DUNE experiment completed.” (Fermi National Accelerator
-
-Laboratory. February 9, 2024). https://news.fnal.gov/2024/02/excavation-of-colossal-caverns-for-fermilabs-
-dune-experiment-completed/
-
-– 9 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
+You fill-up your 12-gallon fuel tank in your sedan up to the brim and
+forget to put on your gas cap. Your friend makes the same mistake after
+filling-up the 18-gallon fuel tank in her truck to the brim.
+It gets really hot outside and the gasoline heats-up.
+Who loses the most gas?
-agency partners and 25 nongovernment partners.15 DOE/SC’s federal advisory committees have
-released international benchmarking studies comparing RDI capabilities of the United States with
-those in other parts of the world. The Department of State conducted a survey assessing planned RDI
-capabilities issued to all diplomatic and consular posts.
+5
-Major prioritization and assessment efforts, such as the 2023 Particle Physics Projects Prioritization
-Panel report16 have been released. Agencies continue to actively commission RDI prioritization
-exercises from their relevant federal advisory committees and through the decadal survey process,
-where agencies seek community input via NASEM. Within the context of the RDI subcommittee, the
-Interagency Working Group on Scientific Collections on November 29, 2023 released the “The Unique
-Role of Federal Scientific Collections,” assessing the varied ways that federal scientific collections have
-served the nation in diverse areas of American life.17 Historically, these activities have focused primarily
-on addressing the immediate scientific needs of the community; additional effort could be given to
-assessing and enhancing the competitive position of the United States.
+(A) You do
-To sustain world S&T leadership, the United States must continue to make strategic investments to
-maintain and renew federal facilities and supporting infrastructure, as well as phase out and
-decommission federal RDI that is no longer needed. These critical investments in new, modern facilities
-will underpin S&T innovation well into the future. These investments are also vital for training the next
-generation of U.S. scientists and engineers who will conduct research, develop new technical
-innovations, and manufacture new products. The challenge is to maintain a consistent and intentional
-revitalization of the U.S. RDI while balancing competing needs and ensuring well-coordinated
-prioritization decisions.
+(B) Your friend does
-Status and Outlook for U.S. Federal Research and Development Infrastructure
+(C) You both lose the same amount
-The Act requires that the National Science and Technology Council produce an annual report
-“identifying and prioritizing the deficiencies in research facilities and major instrumentation located at
-federal laboratories and national user facilities at academic institutions that are widely accessible for
-use by researchers in the United States.” This report answers that requirement.
-
-Four issues put the future success of the nation’s R&D enterprise at risk: Aging and Inadequate Research
-Infrastructure, Cascading Impacts from Substandard Facilities, Widening Gaps in Global S&T Outcomes,
-and Challenges in Recruiting and Retaining Top Scientific and Engineering Talent. Together, these
-issues present a serious threat to the country’s continued scientific innovation, output, and global
-leadership in S&T. Understanding the context and consequence of these issues can shape action plans
-for revitalizing the nation’s RDI.
-
-15 “Democratizing the future of AI R&D: NSF to launch National AI Research Resource pilot.” (National Science
-
-Foundation, January 24, 2024). https://new.nsf.gov/news/democratizing-future-ai-rd-nsf-launch-national-ai
-
-16 “Exploring Our Quantum Universe.” (Report of the 2023 Particle Physics Project Prioritization Panel,
-
-December, 2023). https://www.usparticlephysics.org/2023-p5-report/assets/pdf/P5Report2023_121023-
-DRAFT_single-pages.pdf
-
-17 “The Unique Role of Federal Scientific Collections: Infrastructure Generating Benefits, Serving Diverse Agency
-
-Missions” (A report of the Interagency Working Group on Scientific Collections).
-https://smithsonian.figshare.com/articles/book/The_Unique_Role_of_Federal_Scientific_Collections_Infrastr
-ucture_Generating_Benefits_Serving_Diverse_Agency_Missions/24559996/1
-
-– 10 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-Aging and Inadequate Research Infrastructure
-
-Outdated and deficient RDI across the federal government is threatening U.S. leadership in R&D and
-impeding technology breakthroughs.
-
-Aging infrastructure in many federal research laboratories and facilities is impacting the ability of
-federal agencies to meet their current missions. Many facilities are rated as being in very poor condition.
-
-• A 2023 survey of Department of Energy (DOE) facilities at its 17 national laboratories showed
-that the average age of these facilities was 46 years, close to the end of the planned 40- to 50-
-year design life. This study further stated that nearly 40 percent of DOE facilities have been rated
-as substandard or inadequate to serve DOE’s mission.18
-
-• A survey of research facilities at the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST)
-showed that 73 percent of facilities are 60 to 70 years old, and over 60 percent of the square
-footage is classified as in “poor to critical condition.”19
-
-• A 2019 report noted, “The buildings and facilities at the National Institutes of Health (NIH)
-Bethesda Campus are in need of significant improvement and upgrading to sustain their current
-mission and ongoing functionality. The 12 million facility square feet have an average Condition
-Index of 83.3, which is considered poor.”20
-
-•
-
-In an annual report to Congress in 2024, the Department of Defense’s (DoD) unfunded research,
-development, test, and evaluation (RDT&E) infrastructure requirements were shown to have
-grown significantly since annual reporting began in 2018, putting the military at risk of losing
-its technological superiority.21
-
-• A 2024 National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) report stated that 75 percent of
-its facilities are beyond their designed lifetime, and as of 2022, had an estimated deferred
-maintenance backlog of $3 billion.22
-
-• The United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) Agricultural Research Service (ARS) has
-approximately 3,000 facilities and structures in its inventory, with an average age of over 48
-years, and a $1.6 billion deferred maintenance backlog.
-
-Failures due to aging RDI can result in costly and significant interruptions in research activities lasting
-weeks or months. For example, failures over a nine-month period that led to inadequate back-up power
-and power conditioning at one NIST research facility cost an estimated $9 million and loss of 47,000
-
-18 Science Laboratories Infrastructure (SLI) Program. science.osti.gov/opm/Science-Laboratories-Infrastructure
-
-19 Technical Assessment of the Capital Facility Needs of the National Institute of Standards and Technology,
-
-National Academies Press eBooks, 2023, 31. https://doi.org/10.17226/26684
-
-20 Managing the NIH Bethesda Campus Capital Assets for Success in a Highly Competitive Global Biomedical
-
-Research Environment, National Academies Press eBooks, 2019. https://doi.org/10.17226/25483
-
-21 U.S. Department of Defense Fiscal Year 2025 Unfunded Requirements for Laboratory Military Construction
-Projects. February 2024. Office of the Under Secretary of Defense for Research and Engineering. Report to
-Congress on Section 2806 of the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2018 (Public Law 115-91).
-
-22 NASA’s FY 2024 Volume of Integrated Performance. www.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/fiscal-year-
-
-2024-volume-of-integrated-perfomance.pdf
-
-– 11 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-researcher hours.23 These failures can be compounded by the need to repair outdated equipment with
-scarce replacement parts as well as a lack of personnel familiar with older components and systems.
-These older systems also lack modern safety and security protection features that are standard in
-equipment purchased and installed today. For example, modern electrical switchgear often
-incorporates optical arc flash reduction systems, and today’s natural gas distribution systems have
-built-in safety features absent in older systems. Moreover, the configurations of old steam, chilled
-water, natural gas, compressed air, sewer, and other types of support systems make it difficult to
-maintain sections of pipe or valves without extended outages. Another looming issue is that older
-buildings do not meet today’s more stringent seismic standards, and the failure of susceptible buildings
-could indefinitely halt research activities. Finally, many of these older buildings are contaminated with
-materials that pose significant environmental and health concerns, including radioactive materials,
-beryllium, asbestos, and lead.
-
-Today’s research is vastly different than that conducted when these buildings were designed in the mid-
-20th century; thus, even well-maintained facilities do not meet the requirements of modern research.
-First, older buildings were designed with laboratories that accommodate a lead investigator and a few
-support staff, whereas today’s science is most often conducted by larger, collaborative teams of
-investigators who require flexible space that can be readily reconfigured to meet changing research
-directions. Second, research today is governed by robust environmental, health, and safety standards
-that were not in place when these buildings were designed. For example, 50 years ago, nearly all
-experiments were conducted at open laboratory benches, and laboratories included only a limited
-number of ventilation hoods. Today, research standards require hoods for nearly all chemistry,
-molecular biology, materials, and nanoscience experimental procedures. Also, updated fire codes
-restrict the types and quantities of chemicals and gases that can be stored and used in a single fire zone;
-older buildings were designed with a limited number of fire zones, and some have only one designated
-fire zone for an entire building encompassing thousands of square feet. Further, modern research has
-very different demands for utilities and other infrastructure that were not anticipated even a decade
-ago. For example, outdated and inefficient HVAC and electrical systems are incapable of controlling
-temperature and humidity within the exacting requirements of sensitive equipment, such as ultra-fast
-laser systems and microscopes used in materials science and biology studies. Often, this type of
-sensitive equipment also requires specialized environments with low vibration and electromagnetic
-interference.
-
-In addition to these concerns, the cost to maintain aging facilities, even without bringing them up to
-modern standards, continues to grow. For example, in annual DoD reports to Congress on RDT&E
-revitalization, these costs were estimated to be $4.7 billion in 2019, growing to $7.7 billion in 2024.24
-Similarly, a 2019 study commissioned by the NIH and led by NASEM reported that the backlog of
-
-23 Technical Assessment of the Capital Facility Needs of the National Institute of Standards and Technology,
-
-National Academies Press eBooks, 2023, 44. https://doi.org/10.17226/26684
-
-24 Report to Congress on Unfunded Requirements for Laboratory Military Construction Projects. February 2019.
-Office of the Under Secretary of Defense for Research and Engineering. Section 2806 of the National Defense
-Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2018 (Public Law 115-91)
-
-– 12 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-maintenance and repair for NIH’s Bethesda campus was $1.3 billion and growing rapidly.25 At the end
-of fiscal year (FY) 2023, the Bethesda backlog had grown to $3.4 billion and, taking into account all NIH
-sites in Maryland, Montana, and North Carolina, the backlog was reported to be $3.8 billion at the end
-of FY 2023. The NASEM study triggered Congressional interest, which resulted in increases in NIH’s
-Buildings and Facilities appropriation from $200 million in FY 2019 to $350 million in FY 2023. However,
-even at the higher investment amount, the backlog continues to increase.
-
-Construction and renovation of research infrastructure provides the opportunity to incorporate agile,
-efficient, and resilient designs that can adapt to new technologies, new operating standards, new work
-environments, and changing missions. Effective modernization and design will lead to savings in
-energy, cost, and space while improving laboratory functionality and capability (see sidebar “Modern
-Chemical and Materials Science Building”).
-
-A successful renovation of an older building is exemplified by Building 1 on the NIST campus in Boulder,
-CO, a structure that was dedicated by President Eisenhower in the 1950s. After renovation, a wing of
-this building became the new home to quantum information science and technology research,
-supporting experiments that demonstrated quantum entanglement of microresonators, an innovation
-recognized as the Physics World 2021 Breakthrough of the Year. This research could never have been
-accomplished in the original laboratory, which lacked necessary environmental controls for these
-sensitive experiments.26
-
-Some agencies have already taken steps and devised innovative solutions to address inadequate RDI.
-For example, DOE’s Office of Science (SC) instituted the Science Laboratories Infrastructure program,
-which invests over $300 million annually to transform and modernize foundational infrastructure at
-its national laboratories. To facilitate this strategic program, the DOE Laboratory Operations Board,27
-which includes federal and national laboratory representatives, assesses facilities and infrastructure
-across the DOE national laboratory complex. These enterprise-wide assessments result in a rigorous
-and consistent analysis of the condition, utilization, and functionality of the facilities and
-infrastructure that are most critical to accomplishing the mission. Building on these assessments, SC
-works with each of its laboratories to develop comprehensive campus strategies used to establish
-infrastructure priorities.
-
-25 National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. 2019. Managing the NIH Bethesda Campus Capital
-Assets for Success in a Highly Competitive Global Biomedical Research Environment. Washington, DC: The
-National Academies Press. https://doi.org/10.17226/25483
-
-26 Technical Assessment of the Capital Facility Needs of the National Institute of Standards and Technology,
-
-National Academies Press eBooks, 2023, 34, https://doi.org/10.17226/26684.
-
-27 Science Laboratories Infrastructure (SLI) Program. science.osti.gov/opm/Science-Laboratories-Infrastructure
-
-– 13 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-Modern Chemical and Materials Science Building
-
-Chemical and Materials Sciences Building constructed in 2011 at
-Oak Ridge National Laboratory. [Courtesy ORNL]
-
-With more than 300,000 square feet, Building 4500S at DOE’s Oak Ridge National Laboratory was
-built in the 1960s to house dozens of materials science and chemistry laboratories with associated
-offices. As was typical during this era, the labs in this facility were constructed with only one or two
-chemical hoods and a handful of electrical circuits. HVAC systems were designed to condition
-outside air and exhaust it through the chemical hoods, turning over the entire volume of air in the
-building at a rate of 30 times per hour; this made the building exceptionally expensive to operate.
-
-A new Chemical and Materials Sciences Building was constructed in 2011 and received Gold LEED
-certification by employing many energy saving innovations, such as reducing air flow in hoods not
-being actively used. To meet modern research requirements, these laboratories contain up to six
-hoods for use by teams of researchers and many electrical circuits and internet connections to
-accommodate modern laboratory equipment and computers. Compared to the single fire zone in
-the old building, the new building was designed with multiple fire zones and special storage rooms
-on each floor to facilitate high chemical loading and reduce fire hazards caused by storing chemicals
-in the laboratories.
-
-These features allowed lab space to be consolidated with a 30 percent savings in space compared
-to the old facility, while adding new functionalities, such as highly controlled environments required
-for laser spectroscopy and imaging. The labs were also designed to be readily reconfigurable to
-accommodate changing programs, with all benches equipped with wheels and special utility hook-
-ups enabling their easy removal. Importantly, the building was also designed with features that
-support collaborations across disciplines that are critical for today’s scientific enterprise. As a result,
-an influx of both student and staff researchers have joined the research programs of the
-organizations in this modern laboratory building.
-
-Similarly, the DoD has a variety of authorities to assist in the modernization and revitalization of its RDI.
-One of these, 10 U.S.C § 4123, also known as “FLEX-4,” authorizes laboratories to allocate between two
-percent and four percent of their total RDT&E funds toward workforce development, basic research,
-technology transition, and repair of laboratory infrastructure and equipment. DoD laboratories can use
-revitalization and recapitalization projects to adapt facilities and infrastructure to support new
-
-– 14 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-technology missions. Since the inception of the FLEX-4 Program in 2009, DoD laboratories have invested
-more than $4 billion across the four categories, funding improvements not possible otherwise.
-
-Since 2012, USDA ARS has reviewed its laboratory RDI and developed a long-term plan for future capital
-investments, as outlined in “Capital Investment Strategy” (CIS) reports. Since 2013, ARS has adopted
-the U.S. Corps of Engineers BUILDER assessment program28 to conduct assessments and assign a
-condition index to each facility assessed. This index takes into consideration facility age, capacity,
-safety and health issues, security, time since last repair/renovation, new capabilities needed, and
-current and future research priorities. Since 2015, ARS has received funding to modernize 30 projects of
-the 138 outlined in the most recent ARS CIS update.
-
-Many other agencies, such as the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) have developed plans for
-building renovations, but due to the lack of funds are unable to complete needed renovations at many
-of their laboratory sites.
-
-In summary, aging infrastructure can cause research setbacks due to lost work time, loss of samples,
-and damaged equipment, as well as increased costs to research programs. Further, outdated RDI
-impedes research that requires specialized infrastructure for sensitive experiments and equipment to
-advance tomorrow’s technologies. Some agencies have taken steps to address these issues by
-developing processes for prioritizing needs and by funding facility modernization and revitalization;
-however, more fully addressing these needs will require strategic planning across the federal R&D
-enterprise, as well as increased budgetary planning.
-
-Cascading Impacts from Substandard Facilities
-
-Aging and inadequate federal facilities can impact research efforts of government, universities, and
-industry.
-
-Federal laboratories are home to many types of RDI that provide unique capabilities needed to sustain
-the United States as a world leader in S&T. In addition to research facilities that support specific agency
-missions, federal agencies also host specialized facilities that serve the nation. These critically
-important facilities are not found in the private sector or academia due to their high construction and
-maintenance costs, as well as their support of highly specialized equipment. Such equipment includes
-the world’s largest vacuum chamber at NASA Glenn Research Center, radiation measurement and
-calibration laboratories at NIST, DOE’s suite of scientific user facilities, and the National Science
-Foundation’s (NSF) Antarctic research stations (see sidebar “Improving Antarctic Infrastructure”).
-
-Many of the nation’s unique federal research assets are operating well beyond their design lifetimes
-and RDI failures can have a serious impact on the nation’s research enterprise. For example, in the
-summer of 2022, the underground utility distribution system failed on the NIST campus in Gaithersburg,
-MD, along with HVAC systems, resulting in a shutdown that lasted 14 days and impacted nearly all 1,700
-campus laboratories. The effects of this shutdown lasted much longer, compromising NIST’s ability to
-provide measurement standards and support to multiple federal agencies, the private sector, and
-universities. In turn, the research conducted by these customers, who require standards for quantum
-
-28 BUILDER Sustainment Management System. https://www.erdc.usace.army.mil/Media/Fact-Sheets/Fact-
-
-Sheet-Article-View/Article/476728/builder-sustainment-management-system/
-
-– 15 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-science and technology, radiation physics, and other important traceable measurements, were
-significantly delayed.
-
-National laboratories have long documented the broader impact of facilities investments on local
-economies.29 While it is generally acknowledged that certain facilities have developed reputations as
-training grounds for scientists and engineers in specific fields, relatively less attention has been paid to
-the impact of facility degradation, incidents, and changes in facilities’ reputation on local universities,
-business, and other stakeholder communities. Given the importance of RDI to local economies, as well
-as their distribution around the country in diverse communities, greater attention to that relationship
-may be warranted.
-
-Impact of Investment on the U.S. National Collections
-
-Helianthus annuus [Courtesy NMNH]
-
-The United States National Herbarium is one of the world’s largest and most diverse botanical
-collections, accounting for more than 4 million specimens. The Smithsonian National Museum of
-Natural History’s (NMNH) multi-year, approximately 7-million-dollar effort to digitize the herbarium
-resulted in 3.8 million new specimen images, 2.8 million new label transcriptions, and over 80,000
-new taxonomic names added to the data catalog. This provides full access to the collection using
-digital technology and shared online platforms. Full digitization also improves management and
-enhances the long-term preservation of these fragile collections. Reliance on an industrial approach
-rather than specimen by specimen actions reduced the average cost per specimen of digitization
-from $3.32 and 555 seconds to $1.85 and 102 seconds. Deep learning tools have already been used
-to identify past specimen preservation methods that are hazardous prompting remediation efforts.
-The 500 percent increase in the past five years in web inquiries demonstrates that digital
-accessibility is serving research: in 2015, 14 million botanical records were queried via the online
-page. In 2020, during the COVID-19 pandemic, this number exploded to 70 million records queried.
-
-29 “Fermilab drives economic growth in Illinois and South Dakota.” (Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory,
-March 28, 2024). https://news.fnal.gov/2024/03/fermilab-drives-economic-growth-in-illinois-and-south-
-dakota/
-
-– 16 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-Improving Antarctic Infrastructure
-
-Amundsen-Scott South Pole Station at dawn. [Courtesy Raffaela Busse and
-the National Science Foundation. Reused under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0.]
-
-The National Science Foundation (NSF) oversees three facilities in Antarctica that support important
-and unique experiments sponsored by multiple U.S. agencies, ranging from astronomy to
-environmental studies. However, maintaining and operating infrastructure at these facilities present
-unique and costly challenges due to the harsh environment in Antarctica. For example, buildings are
-in danger of becoming buried in snow, resulting in structural damage, and even collapse.
-Environmental satellite grounds systems, which are crucial for weather forecasting, flight planning,
-aviation safety, station operations, and science support, are beyond their end-of-life timelines and
-in danger of failure. Even fuel transport to the South Pole Station has become more challenging due
-to aging and increasingly unreliable equipment for traverses that carry 100,000 gallons of fuel
-annually.
-
-A 2012 NSF report noted that “U.S. activities in Antarctica are very well managed but suffer from an
-aging infrastructure, lack of a capital budget, and the effects of operating in an extremely unforgiving
-environment. …when the…[NSF]…and its contractors must choose between repairing a roof or
-conducting science, science usually prevails. Only when the science is seriously disrupted because
-the roof begins to collapse will it be replaced; until then, it is likely only to be repaired. ...The status
-quo is simply not an option ...Failure to [recapitalize]... will simply increase logistics costs until they
-altogether squeeze out funding for science. A ten percent increase in the cost of logistics will
-consume 40 percent of the remaining science budget.”
-
-NSF established a recapitalization program of $60 million a year that comprises a portfolio of
-investments to mitigate aging infrastructure, assure safe working conditions, enhance operational
-efficiencies, and support continued U.S. science leadership on the continent.
-
-More and Better Science in Antarctica Through Increased Logistical Effectiveness: Report of the U.S. Antarctic Program
-Blue Ribbon Panel, 2012. www.nsf.gov/geo/opp/usap_special_review/usap_brp/rpt/antarctica_07232012.pdf
-
-– 17 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-Widening Gaps in Global S&T Outcomes
-
-Lagging U.S. RDI investment compared to other nations can erode U.S. leadership and influence in science
-and technology.
-
-Significant investments in specialized RDI catalyzed U.S. scientific innovations in the 20th century.
-These investments included large particle accelerators, wind tunnels, X-ray and neutron sources, and
-large outdoor test ranges, as well as state-of-the-art research laboratories. With these capabilities, the
-United States dominated for decades innovations that fueled the American economy, increased
-security, and improved quality of life—including advances in computers and personal electronics,
-breakthroughs in healthcare, and development of electric vehicles, among others. Today, however,
-increasing investments in RDI in other nations, if unanswered, may lead to loss of U.S. global leadership.
-
-An example of the threat to U.S. S&T leadership is clearly seen in the area of high-performance
-computing and computer science over the last decade. As shown in Figure 1, in 2015, the United States
-contributed the most supercomputers30 to the Top500 list globally, backed by strong support from the
-federal government for the development of leading high-performance computers. However, only seven
-years later, in 2022, the PRC surpassed the United States in number of supercomputers on the Top500
-list, due in part to the PRC’s increased investment in R&D. The impact of the PRC’s investment is readily
-apparent when comparing research output: the PRC is the top overall producer of S&E publications and
-international patents and has the greatest knowledge- and technology-intensive (KTI) manufacturing
-output.31 The United States remains the world leader in KTI services.
-
-Figure 1. Comparison of the 500 most powerful commercially-available supercomputers per country (from
-www.top500.org).
-
-30 Supercomputers are used to model and simulate complex, dynamic systems that would be too expensive,
-
-impractical or impossible to physically demonstrate. Supercomputers are changing the way scientists explore
-the evolution of our universe, biological systems, weather forecasting and even renewable energy. See more
-at https://www.energy.gov/supercomputing-and-exascale
-
-31 “Translation: U.S. and Global Science, Technology, and Innovation Capabilities.” The State of U.S. Science and
-Engineering 2024. Figures 21, 25. https://ncses.nsf.gov/pubs/nsb20243/translation-u-s-and-global-science-
-technology-and-innovation-capabilities
-
-– 18 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-Maintaining and improving U.S. computing infrastructure is critical for many applications. For example,
-accurate and timely climate and weather models are critical to missions that protect and support the
-U.S. economy and national security. However, evidence shows that the National Oceanic and
-Atmospheric Administration’s (NOAA’s) Global Forecast System lags behind the capabilities of systems
-developed by other countries, such as the ECMWF.32
-
-A 2021 NOAA Advisory Board report noted the lack of investment in computing power “indicates that
-not only are we underserving the American public, but also that the United States has the potential to
-provide more accurate and reliable weather information. The public benefits of NOAA regaining a
-leadership role would be increased forecast accuracy, longer lead times, and finer-scale detail for
-severe weather, flooding and hurricanes.”33 Further, many agencies including NOAA34 and DOE35 have
-highlighted the growing demand to provide expanded and updated computing infrastructure to
-complement experimental capabilities to facilitate efficient data sharing, integration, and analysis.
-
-In August 2023, the Defense Science Board reported in its briefing to the Office of Science and
-Technology Policy (OSTP) on Balancing Openness and Security, “China (the PRC) is outpacing the U.S.
-in global competition for key emerging technologies, leading in 37 out of 44 critical and emerging
-technologies (e.g., electric batteries, hypersonics, quantum computing, and others). Western
-democracies risk losing the global competition for research output and technological innovation.”36
-Leadership in this competition is enabled by state-of-the-art RDI, such as X-ray and neutron sources,
-nanoscience facilities, biotechnology centers, accelerators, and specialized testing facilities, among
-others (see sidebar “Broader Impacts of Accelerator Science and Technology”).
-
-Proactively planning and prioritizing federal infrastructure improvements and modernization can
-benefit from benchmarking with other countries. For example, the Basic Energy Science Advisory
-Committee, tasked by DOE/SC with benchmarking U.S. capabilities in basic research, concluded that
-“advanced research facilities in the United States funded by DOE’s Office of Basic Energy Sciences are
-world leading … largely because of long-range strategic planning, ongoing stewardship, and
-investments.”37 This type of planning can protect the nation’s research enterprise and have far-reaching
-effects. If DOE failed to develop and maintain capabilities at its five X-ray sources, the impact could
-affect the 10,000 users served annually, which include scientists from universities, government, and
-
-32 “A Report on Priorities for Weather Research” (NOAA Science Advisory Board, December 2021), 72.
-
-sab.noaa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/PWR-Report_Final_12-9-21.pdf .
-
-33 “A Report on Priorities for Weather Research” (NOAA Science Advisory Board, December 2021), 22.
-
-sab.noaa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/PWR-Report_Final_12-9-21.pdf
-
-34 “NOAA ‘Omics Strategy: Strategic Application of Transformational Tools” (NOAA, February 2020).
-
-sciencecouncil.noaa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/2020-Omics-Strategy.pdf
-
-35 “Basic Energy Sciences Network Requirements Review Final Report” (DOE/SC, November 2023).
-
-science.osti.gov/-/media/bes/pdf/reports/2023/ESnet-Report.pdf
-
-36 “Balancing Openness and Security Across the DoD Academic Research Enterprise” (Defense Science Board,
-
-July 2023), 11, apps.dtic.mil/sti/trecms/pdf/AD1212739.pdf
-
-37 “Can the U.S. Compete in Basic Energy Sciences? Critical Research Frontiers and Strategies” (A report by the
-
-BESAC Subcommittee on International Benchmarking, 2021), 3.
-science.osti.gov/-/media/bes/pdf/reports/2021/International_Benchmarking-Report.pdf
-
-– 19 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-industry. For example, the pharmaceutical industry is highly dependent on X-ray crystallography for the
-development of new drugs, and more than 30,000 samples are characterized annually on just a single
-beamline at the DOE Advanced Photon Source.
-
-Broader Impacts of Accelerator S&T
-
-Accelerators broadly impact science, industry, medicine, defense, and other sectors. Annually,
-particle accelerators are used to treat more than 5 million cancer patients; ion implantation is
-used to produce $300 billion worth of semiconductors; and e-beam irradiation is used to
-manufacture over $85 billion worth of consumer products, such as tires and insulation.
-
-Advances in accelerator technologies are also critical for maintaining the nation’s leadership in
-many high energy and nuclear physics experiments, as well as X-ray and neutron sources used
-broadly by the scientific community in studies on nanomaterials, vehicle batteries,
-pharmaceuticals, and more.
-
-For years, the United States has been a major supporter of accelerator technology advances, but
-its leadership position is being surpassed now by other nations. For example, growth in ultra-high
-intensity lasers, an accelerator-based technology, has been stagnant in the United States while
-development has increased significantly in Europe and Asia in the last several years.
-
-Maintaining leadership in this area requires investing in new accelerator infrastructure that can be
-used to develop new capabilities and applications. Investment is also needed in training and
-retaining experts who can create, operate, and further advance these technologies.
-
-“Ultra-High Intensity Lasers Facilities Across the Globe Over Time,” 2020. www.icuil.org/downloadss/laser-labs.html
-
-In some cases, optimizing RDI investments may include establishing international collaborations that
-benefit the U.S. S&T enterprise. For example, NSF partnered with S&T funding agencies from Europe,
-Japan, and Chile to build the Atacama Large Millimeter-Submillimeter Array (ALMA)—the most powerful
-telescope at these wavelengths in the world. Similarly, NASA partnered with the European and
-Canadian space agencies and 14 additional countries to build the JWST. Additionally, such
-collaborations offer untapped opportunities to enhance U.S. leadership.
-
-Proactive planning and prioritization of new and upgraded RDI is needed to ensure the nation’s global
-S&T leadership is not eclipsed. Strategies are needed to plan for and prioritize future RDI investments,
-including forming collaborations with domestic and international partners.
-
-Challenges in Recruiting and Retaining Top Scientific and Engineering Talent
-
-The declining state of infrastructure is affecting the United States’ ability to recruit and retain scientific
-talent.
-
-Departments, agencies, and federal advisory committees report that sub-optimal research
-infrastructure and project cancellations are factors that contribute to the loss of S&T talent in the
-federal workforce, impacting researchers at every stage of their careers.38 These conditions affect
-
-38 “Can the United States Maintain its Leadership in High Performance Computing? (A report by the ASCAC
-
-Subcommittee on International Benchmarking, 2021). 49. https://science.osti.gov/-
-/media/ascr/ascac/pdf/charges/2023/Report_20230627.pdf
-
-– 20 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-students and post-doctoral researchers when they cannot achieve an acceptable rate of productivity
-due to aging RDI, which limits their career opportunities. More established researchers are affected
-when their productivity and impact declines, preventing them from advancing their agency’s mission
-and reaching their career goals. Together, these factors can affect the morale of researchers and drive
-them away from the federal research arena.
-
-The research and often awe-inspiring technologies at the center of our federal laboratories have
-inspired generations to pursue technical careers and to push the boundaries of human knowledge,
-contributing to U.S. S&T leadership. For instance, NASA supports approximately 2,000 interns, annually,
-at all NASA facilities. DOE/SC hosts thousands of students, accounting for about one third of total
-unique users at scientific user facilities each year. In 2023, the Smithsonian Institution hosted 510
-interns and 355 fellows at its science units. Altogether, federal RDI facilities make up an important
-contribution to developing STEM talent around the country.
-
-Despite this, external assessments of some federal laboratories have identified major concerns in the
-workforce due to recruitment and retention problems which are straining existing staff to their limits.
-This can affect the nation’s ability to attract and retain a strong federal S&T workforce, which can in
-turn impact leadership and innovation in critical and emerging technologies, such as artificial
-intelligence, biotechnology, quantum information S&T, and microelectronics, particularly as other
-countries develop similar or more advanced capabilities. Breakthroughs in these areas are imperative
-for the development of new products and jobs that fuel the nation’s economy. Solving the RDI problem
-should help maintain the federal S&T workforce and R&D leadership to produce innovations critical to
-the nation’s economy, security, and well-being.
-
-One example of how aging infrastructure is impacting the ability to attract and retain researchers is
-NOAA’s Atlantic Oceanographic and Meteorological Laboratory (AOML). This laboratory, housed in a
-building that opened in 1973, is responsible for real-time hurricane-related measurements and
-associated activities that include hurricane science, model development, sustained observational
-platforms, and maintaining the global oceanographic climate data record. However, the 2019 AOML
-Laboratory Review Summary Report stated, “AOML’s physical infrastructure is no longer sufficient to
-support cutting-edge science and to attract a world-class scientific workforce.”39 (see Figure 2).
-
-39 “2019 AOML Laboratory Review Summary Report” (National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration,
-
-November 19, 2019), 17, www.aoml.noaa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/AOML-2019-Review-Summary-
-Report-FINAL-.pdf
-
-– 21 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-Figure 2. “When AOML started [in 1973], keypunch cards seemed cutting edge, and leisure suits seemed
-appropriate for the office.” [Courtesy NOAA]
-
-Foreign RDI investments are also prompting some U.S. researchers to leave the country to build state-
-of-the-art facilities and to find longer-term employment. For example, U.S. diplomats reported in 2018
-that numerous fusion energy researchers and technologists began traveling to the PRC following the
-shutdown of several U.S.-based magnetic confinement fusion facilities. U.S. scientists, technologies,
-and companies often engage with international facilities where the U.S. government is not present,
-such as the Extreme Light Infrastructure (ELI) in Czechia, Hungary, and Romania and the Square
-Kilometer Array (SKA) in South Africa to stay on the leading edge of their respective fields.
-
-The importance of planned investments in maintaining, upgrading, and building (where warranted)
-new RDI cannot be overstated, particularly given that many infrastructures may require decades of
-planning for successful execution. Such efforts require the development of specialized workforces
-around individual projects. Likewise, unexpected cancellations and inadequate communication with
-foreign partners can affect the reputation of the United States as a reliable partner, limiting the
-willingness of foreign experts to provide their unique expertise to major undertakings.40 Without
-significant efforts to address these issues, the nation risks losing the S&T workforce that is critical for
-maintaining its role as a global leader in S&T and innovation, which will have far-reaching impacts on
-the future economy and security of the United States.
-
-Opportunities
-
-Agencies must continue to revitalize RDI critical to the nation’s S&T enterprise, otherwise U.S. RDI will
-continue to deteriorate while costs for maintenance and replacement will continue to escalate.
-Although agencies need to plan and prioritize investments based on individual needs and budgets, the
-following four opportunities—Strategic Planning, Identification of Gaps, Benchmarking International
-RDI and Identifying Collaborations, and Sharing RDI Strategies—represent high-level steps required to
-ensure the nation’s RDI is prepared to meet future U.S. S&T needs.
-
-40 “The Path to Global Discovery: U.S. Leadership and Partnership in Particle Physics.” (A report of the High
-
-Energy Physics Advisory Panel. https://science.osti.gov/-
-/media/hep/hepap/pdf/202203/International_Benchmarking_HEPAP_2023112.pdf
-
-– 22 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-Strategic Planning
-
-Assessment and prioritization of investments are necessary to maintain and renew legacy facilities, as well
-as establish new infrastructure to realize future S&T advances.
-
-It is clear that the overall state of federal research facilities will continue to require substantial
-investments to meet future research needs. Federal agencies and departments must prioritize and
-develop short- and long-term strategies for addressing their RDI needs, including sufficient
-recapitalization, operations, and maintenance investments in facilities, and disposition of excess
-facilities, along with a strong workforce. As part of strategic planning for RDI, agencies should also
-develop and maintain standards for assessing total facility and infrastructure costs, including
-construction, annual operating costs, maintenance, and renovations, and regular recapitalization. For
-example, modernization efforts should address updated requirements for safety (e.g., changes in
-building codes), security, and specialized research. Where applicable, agencies should ensure a
-proactive lifecycle approach to real property management that aligns with the federal Real Property
-Reform Act of 2016, the associated Government Accountability Office framework. Agencies can also
-look to external resources, strategies, and best practices like the 2023 NASEM report titled “Strategies
-to Renew Federal Facilities.” The specific approaches employed may differ for the various agencies and
-their specific RDI requirements. For instance, planning for construction and lifecycle costs of a
-conventional laboratory building is quite different than the planning needed for a high-energy
-accelerator-based facility that serves thousands of users annually.
-
-• Agencies should develop processes to communicate the need for RDI investments to budget
-planners, Congress, and other stakeholders, and include the potential impact if such
-investments in R&D infrastructure are not realized. Specific and measurable impacts to mission
-execution are more persuasive than general impacts that are difficult to attribute.
-
-• The need for RDI investments should be documented with thorough assessments of facilities’
-maintenance and modernization needs, including both costs and well-defined prioritizations
-developed by each agency, and these assessments should be updated regularly.
-
-Identification of Gaps
-
-Agencies and departments should identify gaps in RDI needs and opportunities for collaborations with
-other federal, industrial, academic, and international partners.
-
-Effective planning for RDI first requires input from the federal and non-federal research community, as
-well as RDI managers, to help reveal or underscore serious gaps and to identify the potential impact of
-these gaps on the U.S. federal S&T enterprise and agency mission execution. This input can be gathered
-by various means, such as surveys, requests for information, workshops, and other avenues. For
-example, federal research agencies frequently convene researchers from the national and international
-communities to identify needs in research infrastructure, such as electron and X-ray sources,
-computers, distributed measurement networks, sequencing centers, and other key areas. This gap
-analysis could also be used to identify potential partnerships—with other agencies and departments,
-the private sector, universities, and international partners—that could provide opportunities for cost-
-sharing and result in more impactful RDI that serves a larger research community.
-
-• Agencies should utilize decadal surveys, workshops, and other community planning efforts to
-identify and prioritize the long-term federal RDI needs of the U.S. research community,
-
-– 23 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-including elements that must be maintained to support U.S. researchers in academe, industry,
-and government.
-
-• Agencies should remain cognizant of the ways in which facility closures may result in U.S.
-dependence on international facilities and weigh the consequences if those capabilities are no
-longer possessed by the United States or its allies.
-
-Benchmarking International RDI and Identifying Collaborations
-
-Regular benchmarking should be performed to assess the global position of U.S. RDI and to identify
-opportunities for international collaborations.
-
-Understanding the nation’s global standing in S&T is critical for prioritizing RDI investments and
-identifying areas for international collaboration. Benchmarking studies should include documented
-data on relevant topics, such as global development of large-scale and mid-scale research facilities,
-research outputs and impact, and workforce trends. These assessments would provide foundational
-data for the Quadrennial Science and Technology Review and National Science and Technology
-Strategy, as well as for other reports and activities related to global competitive assessments.
-
-These benchmarking studies will also identify opportunities to develop new collaborations and
-enhance existing partnerships as well as highlight strategic investments to restore and preserve U.S.
-leadership in critical areas while strengthening federal RDI and the scientific workforce. For
-international collaborations, processes must be established to reduce the administrative burdens often
-associated with developing cutting-edge scientific capabilities, including the importation of materials
-and technologies. Efforts should also be made to welcome the participation of international scientific
-experts in these benchmarking studies.
-
-• Agencies should regularly assess the competitive position of U.S. capabilities in their respective
-mission areas through benchmarking activities, such as those conducted by DOE’s SC federal
-advisory committees and the State Department’s survey of international facilities.
-
-• To facilitate collaborations, agencies should pursue existing mechanisms (e.g., the Florence
-Agreement Program and S&T agreements) and identify new ways to facilitate both national and
-international cooperative activities, as well as reduce barriers for in-kind contributions,
-materials exchange, contract and intellectual property terms, and technologies importation.
-
-Sharing RDI Strategies
-
-Establishing an interagency working group would support the modernization of RDI for the future.
-
-RDI planning would greatly benefit from having regular meetings where representatives from federal
-agencies discuss RDI strategic plans and needs at both the agency level and across the federal
-government. These discussions would catalyze collaborations and cost-sharing on upgrading or
-establishing new RDI. Although federal agencies and departments have unique business practices and
-operating principles, they share common issues facing RDI modernization. Therefore, establishing an
-interagency RDI working group could also be a platform for sharing best practices and ensuring access
-to state-of-the-art RDI across the federal government.
-
-• The NSTC’s Subcommittee on Research and Development Infrastructure should coordinate an
-interagency working group focused on ensuring the competitive position of U.S. RDI, with
-activities to include sharing information on long-term strategic planning efforts, identifying
-
-– 24 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-gaps in capabilities, and facilitating opportunities for national and international collaborations
-in facilities.
-
-Additionally, departments and agencies should continue to look to the policy opportunities identified
-in the National Strategic Overview on RDI, released in 2021:
-
-Maintaining Strong and Integrated RDI Planning and Coordination
-
-• Adopt a cohesive definition of RDI that encompasses experimental, observational, as well as
-
-knowledge- and cyber-infrastructure, in federal planning processes
-
-•
-
-Identify complementary RDI—and their capabilities—across the federal government and
-external R&D communities to inform agency priority-setting processes.
-
-• Plan for, invest in, and deploy the necessary knowledge infrastructure and research
-cyberinfrastructure to keep pace with the rate of growth of data acquisition in research, as well
-as published research data, to ensure the efficiency and trustworthiness of scientific pathways
-and pipelines.
-
-• Ensure consistent, sufficient, and timely RDI capabilities, strategically addressing episodic
-
-efforts that can undermine the ability to meet long-term needs
-
-• Regularly review and document RDI needs and develop planning processes that encompass
-
-repurposing, reusing, or decommissioning low-priority RDI.
-
-Ensuring RDIs Support a Flexible and Agile R&D Enterprise
-
-• Foster R&D community engagement to inform federal RDI planning and prioritization, for
-
-instance through assessments and cross-sector coordination.
-
-• Seek input from Federal Advisory Committee Act (FACA) and NSTC committees, as these
-committees are capable of providing valuable insight on future RDI needs and coordination
-possibilities.
-
-•
-
-Integrate agile design and decision processes in planning and maintaining RDIs so that
-capabilities keep pace with the growth in data and advancements in computing and analytics.
-
-• Support remote access to RDI capabilities, tools, and platforms, where appropriate.
-
-• Build strategic, long-term relationships with contractors and suppliers to enable agility in
-
-procurement, development, design, and portability of RDI systems.
-
-•
-
-•
-
-Incorporate lifecycle considerations, such as upfront costs of construction, operation, and
-maintenance, and anticipate future modernization needs for planned and existing RDIs.
-
-Incorporate lifecycle resourcing considerations to ensure RDIs sustain or enhance privacy and
-other legal protections.
-
-• Ensure large or complex RDI projects are managed by staff with appropriate design and project
-
-management experience to safeguard delivery on schedule and within budget.
-
-• Continue to create and promote STEM education programs that directly engage with and
-
-support the use of RDIs as education and training platforms.
-
-– 25 –
-
-U.S. FEDERAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
- A Foundation of the Nation’s Global Scientific Leadership and Future Economic and National Security
-
-• Ensure processes that allow the nation’s R&D enterprise to thrive by fostering the participation
-
-of talent that reflects the diversity of America.
-
-Advancing RDI Capabilities to Support the Convergence of Disciplines and Sectors
-
-•
-
-Invest in RDIs that complement core disciplinary needs while identifying opportunities to
-enhance connections across disciplines and sectors.
-
-• Consider the potential use of RDIs beyond a single agency’s mission context in developing
-
-coordination efforts, especially for the Nation’s largest RDI investments.
-
-• Ensure RDIs foster convergence through partnerships and research information exchange.
-
-Balancing RDI Openness with Security Needs
-
-• Seek international collaborations for the development of RDIs as appropriate to foster
-
-international cooperation
-
-• Operate RDIs using research security frameworks that balance open science with appropriate
-
-levels of vigilance and that uphold U.S. principles of integrity
-
-• Ensure proper protections for RDIs that are vital to competitiveness, public health and safety
-resilience, and national security (e.g., intellectual property, certain classes of research data,
-implications from climate change)
-
-Conclusion
-
-Just like the investments in research facilities that were built during the Cold War, investments in
-modern federal RDI will support the development of new technologies and generate new jobs.
-Revitalizing federal RDI will also ensure the development of a workforce trained to discover, develop,
-manufacture, and use next-generation technologies.
-
-The nation can take immediate action to revitalize RDI and support a vibrant research enterprise for
-years to come. Federal departments and agencies should develop actionable strategic plans with
-priorities for RDI investments. These plans should be informed by input from the S&T community across
-government, university, and private-sector institutions, and from international benchmarking. This
-input can also identify opportunities to partner with both domestic and international institutions. An
-RDI working group can share approaches and identify where collaborations can be forged to provide
-enhanced capabilities to a broader research community. The time to act is now; prioritizing federal RDI
-will support generations of future researchers and allow the United States to maintain global leadership
-in science, technology, and innovation.
-
-– 26 –
+1. ΔV = βV0ΔT
+2. β*ΔT is the same for both of you.
+3. But, V0 is greater for the 18-gallon fuel-tank for the truck.
+4. So, ΔV will be larger for the truck and it will lose more fuel.
diff --git a/q0/random_k4/random_2.md b/q0/random_k4/random_2.md
index f1acb0854be2920866b2127b008e7c6e2f57b22b..35a7eb473c0028e63514bfe2ddbd9a16bdb5c94f 100644
--- a/q0/random_k4/random_2.md
+++ b/q0/random_k4/random_2.md
@@ -1,3733 +1,3030 @@
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT
+FOR RELEASE January 29, 2026
-Table of Contents
+Confidence in Trump
+Dips, and Fewer Now Say
+They Support His
+Policies and Plans
-Why must I report on information technology (IT) investments?
-What background information must I know?
-How do I ensure that IT investments are linked to and support agency strategic plans?
-What special terms should I know?
-How do I determine whether I must report?
+Rising share of Democrats want their party’s congressional
+leaders to stand up to Trump
-How do I submit Exhibit 53 and when is it due?
-If I submitted Exhibit 53 last year, how do I revise it this year?
-How is Exhibit 53 organized?
-How is Exhibit 53 coded?
-What are the steps to complete Exhibit 53?
-Agency IT Investment Portfolio
-Agency IT Security Portfolio
-Agency Cloud Computing Portfolio
-Agency IT Reductions and Reinvestments
+BY Hannah Hartig and Jocelyn Kiley
-1.
-2.
-3.
-4.
-5.
+FOR MEDIA OR OTHER INQUIRIES:
-53.1
-53.2
-53.3
-53.4
-53.5
-Ex53A
-Ex53B
-Ex53C
-Ex53D
+Jocelyn Kiley, Director of Political Research
+Steven Shepard, Associate Director of Political
+Research
+Nida Asheer, Senior Communications Manager
-300.1
-300.2
-300.3
-300.4
-300.5
-300.6
-Ex300A/B IT Capital Asset Overview and Justification, Performance Plan and Measurement Report
+202.419.4372
-What is the purpose of the section?
-Does Exhibit 300 apply to me?
-How will agencies manage capital assets?
-What other requirements does Exhibit 300 fulfill?
-What must I report on Exhibit 300A&B and when?
-How will OMB use Exhibit 300A&B?
+www.pewresearch.org
- Updates and consolidates special terms related to information technology (IT) and E-Government
+RECOMMENDED CITATION
-Summary of Changes
+Pew Research Center, January 2026, “Confidence in
+Trump dips, and fewer now say they support his
+policies and plans”
-(Section 4)
+1
-Significantly updates Exhibit 53 requirements:
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
- Requires agencies to submit a draft Fiscal Year (FY) 2014 Exhibit 53A by August 27, 2012 and the
+About Pew Research Center
-agency budget request Exhibit 53s on September 10, 2012
+Pew Research Center is a nonpartisan, nonadvocacy fact tank that informs the public about the
+issues, attitudes and trends shaping the world. It does not take policy positions. The Center
+conducts public opinion polling, demographic research, computational social science research and
+other data-driven research. It studies politics and policy; news habits and media; the internet and
+technology; religion; race and ethnicity; international affairs; social, demographic and economic
+trends; science; research methodology and data science; and immigration and migration. Pew
+Research Center is a subsidiary of The Pew Charitable Trusts, its primary funder.
- Adds two new 53 Exhibits: Cloud Computing and Reductions and Reinvestments per budget guidance
- Adds requirement for Functional/Business Sponsor identification for all investments
- Adds several fields to the Exhibit 53A for reporting government FTE, HSPD-12, and cloud
+© Pew Research Center 2026
-alternatives analysis
+www.pewresearch.org
- New FEA BRM 3.0 Service Mappings
+2
-Significantly updates Exhibit 300 requirements:
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
- Requires agencies to submit the FY 2014 Exhibit 300A/Bs between September 10-14, 2012.
+About this research
-Agencies may submit Exhibit 300Bs for any investment for which a 300A has been successfully
-submitted/updated
+This Pew Research Center report looks at how the U.S. public feels about Trump’s job
+performance, their expectations for his administration, and their views about whether
+congressional leaders should work with each other and the president.
- Adds a requirement to submit specific investment artifacts/documents
- Updates questions for areas of current policy emphasis
- Changes Summary of Funding to Life Cycle Costs
- Clarifies project and activity concepts and extends reporting time period
- Clarifies reporting of actuals for performance metrics
- Adds question on modular contracting
- Adds question on return on investment
+Why did we do this?
-Page 1 of 45
+Pew Research Center conducted this research to check in on how the public is feeling about the
+Trump administration. It is part of our regular work to understand how Americans feel about the
+policies, actions and events that occur during the presidency – as well as to understand how
+Americans feel about current events.
- (2012)
+Our research on presidents dates back to the 1980s, and has continued through the current Trump
+administration.
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT
+Learn more about Pew Research Center and our politics research.
-1. Why must I report on information technology (IT) investments?
+How did we do this?
-The required information allows the agency and the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) to review and
-evaluate each agency's IT spending and to compare IT spending across the Federal Government. Specifically,
-the information helps the agency and OMB to:
+We conducted a survey from January 20 through January 26, 2026 among 8,512 U.S. adults
+recruited through our American Trends panel.
- Provide a report on all IT investments for the agency, as required by the Clinger-Cohen Act of 1996;
+Here are the survey questions used for this report, the detailed responses and
+the survey methodology.
- Understand and compare the amount spent on the development of new capabilities (Development,
+www.pewresearch.org
-Modernization and Enhancement [DME], which may appropriately be treated as capitalized costs) and
-in support of operation and maintenance (O&M) for all agency IT investments;
+3
-
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Identify and report IT security costs for all IT investments and for agency and bureau IT security
-programs, as required by the Federal Information Security Management Act (FISMA); and
+Confidence in Trump dips, a
+they support his policies and plans
+Rising share of Democrats want their party
+to stand up to Trump
-
+nd fewer now say
-Identify and report on agency financial management systems.
+’s congressional leaders
-Agencies must provide required formation using the Exhibit 53 reporting format. This information should be
-consistent with information required in Section 51 of OMB Circular A-11. In addition, as an output of your
-agency's internal IT capital planning and investment control process, your budget justification for IT must
-provide results-oriented information in the context of the agency's missions and operations, as expressed
-through the agency’s enterprise architecture (EA). Your budget justification, including the status and plans
-for information systems, should be consistent with your agency's submissions for Exhibit 300 submissions
-(see guidance on Exhibit 300), regarding major IT investments.
+By Hannah Hartig and Jocelyn Kiley
-Investment costs must include all Federal budgetary resources (e.g., direct appropriation, working capital
-fund, revolving funds). Federal budgetary resources are defined in Section 20 of OMB Circular A-11. These
-investment costs and performance benefits must be formulated and reported order to support the Clinger-
-Cohen Act's requirement that the OMB Director shall submit to Congress a report on the net program
-performance benefits achieved as a result of major capital investments made by executive agencies in
-information systems and how the benefits relate to the accomplishment of the goals of the executive agencies.
+A year into his second administration,
+Americans’ views of President Donald Trump –
+already more negative than positive – have
+continued to slip.
-2. What background information must I know?
+Half of Americans say Trump’s actions
+have been worse than they expected
-The Federal Government must effectively manage its portfolio of capital assets to ensure scarce public
-resources are wisely invested. Capital programming integrates the planning, acquisition, and management of
-capital assets into the Budget decision-making process. It is intended to assist agencies in improving asset
-management and in complying with the results-oriented requirements of:
+% who ___ of the way Donald Trump is handling his job
+as president
- The Clinger-Cohen Act of 1996, which requires agencies to use a disciplined capital planning and
+▪ Trump’s approval rating stands at 37%,
-investment control (CPIC) process to acquire, use, maintain, and dispose of IT in alignment with the
-agency’s EA planning processes. OMB policy for the management of Federal information resources
-is detailed in Circular A-130, Management of Federal Information Resources.
+down from 40% in the fall.
- The Government Performance and Results Act (GPRA) of 1993, which establishes the foundation for
+Approve
-Budget decision making to achieve strategic goals in order to meet agency mission objectives.
-Instructions for preparing strategic plans, annual performance plans, and annual program performance
-reports are provided in Part 6 of OMB Circular A-11 (see Section 220).
+Disapprove
- The GPRA Modernization Act of 2010 (P.L. 111-352), which requires quarterly performance
+37
-assessments of Federal Government priorities and establishes agency Performance Improvement
-Officers and the Performance Improvement Council.
+61
-Page 2 of 45
+▪ By more than two-to-one, Americans say
+the administration’s actions have been
+worse than they expected (50%) rather than
+better (21%).
- (2012)
+▪ Only about a quarter of Americans today
+(27%) say they support all or most of
+Trump’s policies and plans, down from 35%
+when he returned to office last year. That
+change has come entirely among
+Republicans.
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT
+% who say the Trump administration’s actions since
+taking office last year have been ___ expected
- The Federal Managers Financial Integrity Act of 1982, Chief Financial Officers Act of 1990 (CFO
+Better than
-Act), and Federal Financial Management Improvement Act of 1996, which require accountability of
-financial and program managers for financial results of actions taken, control over the Federal
-Government's financial resources, and protection of Federal assets. OMB policies and standards for
-developing, operating, evaluating, and reporting on financial management systems are contained in
-Circular A–127, Financial Management Systems and OMB Circular A-11, Section 52.
+About as
- The Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995, which requires agencies to perform their information
+Worse than
-resources management activities in an efficient, effective, and economical manner.
+21
- The Federal Information Security Management Act of 2002, which requires agencies to integrate IT
-security into their capital planning and EA processes, conduct annual IT security reviews of all
-programs and systems, and report the results of those reviews to OMB.
+28
- The E-Government Act of 2002 (P.L. 107–347), which requires agencies to support government-wide
-E-Government (E-Gov) initiatives and to leverage cross-agency opportunities to further E-Gov. The
-Act also requires agencies to establish a process for determining which government information the
-agency intends to make available and accessible to the public on the Internet and by other means. In
-addition, the Act requires agencies to conduct and make publicly available privacy impact
-assessments (PIAs) for all new IT investments, administering information in an identifiable form
-collected from or about members of the public.
+50
- The National Technology Transfer and Advancement Act of 1995 (P.L. 104-113) and OMB Circular
-A-119, which state that voluntary consensus standards are the preferred type of standards for Federal
-Government use. When it would be inconsistent with law or otherwise impractical to use a voluntary
-consensus standard, agencies must submit a report to OMB through the National Institute of Standards
-and Technology (NIST) describing the reason(s) for the agency's use of government-unique standards
-in lieu of voluntary consensus standards.
+% who support ___ of Donald Trump’s policies and
+plans
- The Federal Records Act, which requires agencies to establish standards and procedures to ensure
-efficient and effective records management. The National Archives and Records Administration
-(NARA) issues policies and guidance for agencies to meet their records management goals and
-requirements. NARA also provides policies and guidance for planning and evaluating investments in
-electronic records management.
+All/Most
- The Privacy Act of 1974 (5 U.S.C. § 552a), which is an omnibus "code of fair information practices"
-that attempts to regulate the collection, maintenance, use, and dissemination of personal information
-by Federal executive branch agencies.
+Some
- NIST Special Publication 800-146 concepts and definitions regarding cloud computing.
+Few/None
- Recent OMB IT policies and guidance, including:
+27
-o 25 Point Implementation Plan to Reform Federal Information Technology Management
-o Federal Information Technology Shared Services Strategy
-o The Common Approach to Federal Enterprise Architecture
-o Digital Government Strategy: Building a 21st Century Platform to Better Serve the American
+20
-People
+52
-o OMB memo M-12-10 – Implementing PortfolioStat
-o The Federal Cloud Computing Strategy
+A new Pew Research Center survey of 8,512
+U.S. adults, conducted Jan. 20-26, also finds
+that – across six key qualities and abilities
+needed to serve as president – more Americans
+express little or no confidence in Trump than say they are extremely or very confident in him.
-Page 3 of 45
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
- (2012)
+Note: No answer responses are not shown.
+Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026.
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT
+Confidence is down on all six measures since last year, particularly among Republicans.
-o Security Authorization of Information Systems in Cloud Computing Environments
+Related: How Americans See Immigration Officers’ Behaviors and Civilian Actions
-(FedRAMP)
+www.pewresearch.org
-o OMB memo M-12-13 - Fiscal Year 2014 Budget Guidance
+4
- Executive Order 13514, Federal Leadership in Environmental, Energy, and Economic Performance
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
- Executive Order 13423, Strengthening Federal Environmental, Energy, and Transportation
+Trump’s qualities and abilities as president
-Management
+Today, 34% of Americans say
+they are extremely or very
+confident that Trump has the
+leadership skills needed to
+serve as president. A larger
+share (51%) are not too or not
+at all confident. Another 14%
+are somewhat confident.
- Federal Acquisition Regulation, including Subchapter B, Parts 5 through 12 and Part 23
+Similarly, about half say they
+are not too or not at all
+confident Trump has the
+mental fitness (52%) or
+physical fitness (50%) to do
+the job. Roughly three-in-ten
+express confidence on these
+measures.
- Federal Management Regulation, including Subchapters B and C
+Many Americans lack confidence in Trump on several
+measures, including his ethics in office
- Energy Independence and Security Act of 2007, including Sections 431 through 435 and 523 through
+% who say, thinking about the qualities needed to serve as president, they
+are ___ confident that Donald Trump …
-525
+No answer responses are not shown.
+Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026.
- Energy and Policy Act of 2005, including Sections 103, 104, 109, and 203
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-3. How do I ensure that IT investments align with and support the agency’s strategic plans?
+Even fewer say they are confident that Trump respects the country’s democratic values (25% are
+extremely or very confident) or that he picks good advisers (25%).
-Each IT investment must clearly demonstrate that the investment is needed to help meet the agency's strategic
-goals and mission. The agency must demonstrate how the investment supports a business line or enterprise
-service performance goal as documented in the agency’s EA and annual Enterprise Roadmap submission to
-OMB. Agency IT investment business cases (and other documents), the IT Capital Asset Summary (Exhibit
-300A), and Agency IT Investment Portfolio (Exhibit 53A) must demonstrate the agency’s management of IT
-investments and how governance processes are used to plan, select, develop, implement, and operate IT
-investments. Documents used to manage the planning, development, implementation, and operation of IT
-investments and documents that demonstrate the outcomes of agency, branch, and bureau governance
-decisions should be maintained and made readily available if requested by OMB.
+Americans express the least amount of confidence in Trump to act ethically in office. Just 21% are
+extremely or very confident he does this, while 60% express little or no confidence.
-The individual agency's Exhibit 53A and Exhibit 300A submissions are used to create an overall "Federal IT
-Investment Portfolio," which is published as part of the President's Budget. Agency and OMB portfolio
-reviews and Budget processes will ensure the selection of IT investments that support the agency’s strategic
-goals, as captured in the agency’s High Priority Performance Goals and Strategic Plan.
+www.pewresearch.org
-4. What special terms should I know?
+While overall confidence in
+Trump’s ethics in office was
+already relatively low last
+February (29%), it has
+declined 8 percentage points
+since. And nearly all of that
+drop has come among
+Republicans: At the
+beginning of Trump’s second
+term, a 55% majority of
+Republicans and Republican-
+leaning independents said
+they were confident that
+Trump acts ethically in office,
+but that share now stands at
+42%.
-Alternatives Analysis refers to an analysis of alternatives for addressing the performance objectives of an
-investment. The analysis is performed prior to the initial decision to implement a solution and updated
-periodically, as appropriate, to capture changes in the context for an investment decision. Alternatives
-analysis documentation must be submitted along with Exhibit 300 for all major IT investments. Alternatives
-Analysis should be performed for investments with projects in the planning or DME stages, whereas strictly
-operational investments should instead perform operational analyses until such time as a decision is made to
-re-evaluate the investment or to resume development, modernization or enhancement.
-
-Asset refers to anything that has value to an organization, including, but not limited to: a computing device,
-IT system, IT network, IT circuit, software (both an installed instance and a physical instance), virtual
-computing platform (common in cloud and virtualized computing), and related hardware (e.g., locks, cabinets,
-keyboards). Assets are the lowest level at which IT is planned, acquired, implemented, and operated.
-
-Benefit-Cost Analysis refers to the recommended technique to use in a formal economic analysis of
-government programs or projects. Guidance for Benefit-Cost Analysis is described in OMB Circular A-94.
-
-Page 4 of 45
-
- (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT
-
-Business Reference Model (BRM) refers to one of six reference models of the Federal Enterprise
-Architecture (FEA). It is a classification taxonomy used to describe mission sectors, business functions, and
-services that are performed within and between Federal agencies and with external partners. IT investments
-are mapped to the BRM to identify opportunities for collaboration, shared services, and solution reuse.
-Exhibit 53 allows for one primary service and up to four secondary service codes to be identified for each IT
-investment. BRM service codes can be found in the FEA Reference Model document library.
-Note: Updated definitions are scheduled for release in version 2 of the FEA.
-
-Capital Assets refer to land, structures, equipment, intellectual property (e.g., software), and IT (including the
-output of IT service contracts) that has been acquired by the Federal Government and have an estimated useful
-life of two years or more. See Appendix One of the Capital Programming Guide for a more complete
-definition of capital assets.
-
-Capital Investment (or Investment) refers to the planning, development, and acquisition of a capital asset and
-the management and operation of that asset through its usable life after the initial acquisition. IT capital
-investments may consist of one or more assets, which provide useful components in an operational
-(production) environment.
-
-Capital Planning and Investment Control (also called capital programming) refers to a decision-making
-process that ensures IT investments integrate strategic planning, budgeting, procurement, and management of
-IT in support of agency missions and business needs. The term was introduced in the Clinger-Cohen Act of
-1996 and generally is used in relation to IT management issues.
-
-Capital Programming refers to an integrated process within an agency that focuses on the planning,
-budgeting, procurement, and management of the agency’s portfolio of capital assets to achieve the agency’s
-strategic goals and objectives with the lowest overall cost and least risk.
-
-Cloud First Policy (IT Reform) refers to the Cloud First policy, launched in December 2010, which is
-intended to accelerate the pace at which the government realizes the value of cloud computing by requiring
-agencies to evaluate safe, secure cloud computing options before making any new investments. Per the
-Federal Cloud Computing Strategy, agencies should evaluate their technology sourcing plans to include
-consideration and application of cloud computing solutions as part of the budget process. Agencies should
-seek to optimize the use of cloud technologies in their IT portfolios to take full advantage of the benefits of
-cloud computing in order to maximize capacity utilization, improve IT flexibility and responsiveness, and
-minimize costs. When evaluating options for new IT deployments, OMB requires that agencies default to
-cloud-based solutions whenever a secure, reliable, cost-effective cloud option exists. Additionally, agencies
-shall continually evaluate cloud computing solutions across their IT portfolios, regardless of investment type
-or life cycle stage.
-
-Contributions (or expected contributions) refers to both monetary contributions and fees for services
-provided by partner agencies to managing partners or shared service providers of a multi-agency
-collaboration. Contributions should only apply to multi-agency collaborations.
-
-Cost refers to the expenditure of funds or use of property to acquire, produce, operate, or maintain an asset.
-Examples include, but are not limited to: sunk costs, operational costs, acquisition costs, and disposition costs
-(including variable costs such as labor hours).
-
-Cost Avoidance refers to from an action taken in the immediate time frame that will decrease costs in the
-future (as defined in OMB Circular A-131).
-
-Cost Saving refers to the reduction in actual expenditures to achieve a specific objective (as defined in OMB
-Circular A-131).
-
-Page 5 of 45
-
- (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT
-
-Data Center refers to a closet, room, floor, or building for the storage, management, and dissemination of data
-and information. Such a repository houses computer systems and associated components, such as databases,
-applications, and storage systems and data stores. A data center generally includes redundant or backup
-power supplies; redundant data communications connections; environmental controls (e.g., air conditioning,
-fire suppression); and special security devices housed in, leased (including by cloud providers), owned,
-collocated, or situated in stand-alone facilities. This definition excludes facilities exclusively devoted to
-communications and network equipment (e.g., telephone exchanges, telecommunications rooms). Neither
-square footage nor Uptime Institute tier classifications are required to define a facility as a data center. This
-definition of a data center applies to all agency IT assets, mission or otherwise. See March 2012 OMB Federal
-Data Center Consolidation Initiative Memorandum for more detail.
-
-Defense Acquisition Workforce Improvement Act (DAWIA) of 1990 (P.L. 101-510) refers to a congressional
-act that established for the Department of Defense an Acquisition Corps to professionalize the acquisition
-workforce in the Department of Defense through education, training, and work experience.
-
-Dependency refers to the identification of relationships between projects and operational assets within an
-investment as well as the identification of relationships between investments. Identification of dependencies
-is critical to the management of project, program, and portfolio risk.
-
-Development, Modernization and Enhancement refers to costs for projects and activities leading to new IT
-assets/systems and projects and activities that change or modify existing IT assets to: substantively improve
-capability or performance, implement legislative or regulatory requirements, or meet an agency leadership
-request. As part of DME, capital costs can include hardware, software development and acquisition costs,
-commercial off-the-shelf acquisition costs, government labor costs, and contracted labor costs for planning,
-development, acquisition, system integration, and direct project management and overhead support.
-
-Disposition Cost refers to the cost of retiring a capital asset once its useful life is completed or a replacement
-asset has superseded it; disposition costs may be included in operational activities near the end of the useful
-life of an asset.
-
-Earned Value Management (EVM) refers to a project management tool that effectively integrates the project
-scope of work with a schedule and cost elements for optimum project planning and control. The qualities and
-operating characteristics of earned value management systems (EVMS) are described in American National
-Standards Institute (ANSI)/Electronic Industries Alliance (EIA) Standard–748–1998, Earned Value
-Management Systems. Additional information on EVMS is available at www.acq.osd.mil/evm.
-
-Enterprise Architecture refers to the explicit description and documentation of the current and desired
-relationships among business and management processes and IT of an organization. It describes the “current
-architecture” and “target architecture”. An EA includes the rules and standards and systems life cycle
-information to optimize and maintain the environment which the agency wishes to create and maintain
-through its IT portfolio. An EA must provide a strategy that enables the agency to support its current state and
-provides a roadmap for transition to its target environment. An EA defines principles and goals and sets a
-direction on such issues as the promotion of interoperability, open systems, publics access, end-user
-satisfaction, and IT security. The agency must support an EA with a complete inventory of agency
-information resources including: personnel, equipment, systems, services, and funds devoted to information
-resources management and IT, at an appropriate level of detail.
-
-Enterprise Roadmap refers to an annual submission from each agency to OMB that describes the business
-and technology plan for the entire organization using EA methods. The Roadmap provides current views,
-future views, and transition plans at an appropriate level of detail for all IT investments, services, systems, and
-programs. The Enterprise Roadmap also contains an IT asset inventory using the FEA Reference Models and
-other attachments or appendices for CPIC, EA, shared service, and other planning products requested by
-OMB that provide additional information regarding Roadmap plans.
-
-Page 6 of 45
-
- (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT
-
-Evaluation (by Agency CIO) refers to the CIO’s best judgment of the current level of risk for the investment
-in terms of its ability to accomplish its goals. The evaluation should be informed by the following factors,
-including, but not limited to: risk management, requirements management, contractor oversight, historical
-performance, human capital and other factors that the CIO deems important to the forecasting future success.
-Each evaluation should include a narrative explanation when the rating has changed since the last evaluation.
-
-Federal Acquisition Certification for Program and Project Managers (FAC-P/PM) refers to a certification
-program that was established to clearly identify general training and experience requirements for program and
-project managers (PMs) in civilian agencies. The FAC-P/PM focuses on essential competencies needed for
-program managers and PMs. The certification program does not include functional or technical competencies,
-such as those for IT or agency-specific competencies. Defense agencies have a similar certification program
-under DAWIA. Agencies were required to be compliant with FAC-P/PM starting in FY 2008. Available
-levels are Entry/Apprentice, Mid/Journeyman, and Expert/Advanced for FAC-P/PM and 1, 2, and 3 for
-DAWIA. For more information about these programs, refer to the following links:
-http://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/omb/procurement/workforce/fed_acq_cert_042507.pdf
-http://whitehouse.gov/omb/procurement/acq_wk/fac_contracting_program.pdf
-
-Federal Enterprise Architecture refers to a business-based documentation and analysis framework for
-government-wide improvement. The FEA allows agencies to use standardized methods to describe the
-relationship between an agency’s strategic goals, business functions, and enabling technologies at various
-levels of scope and complexity. The FEA is comprised of documentation in six domain areas (strategic goals,
-business services, data and information, systems and applications, infrastructure, and security) that includes
-required and elective artifacts. There are six reference models to support the six domain areas that should
-facilitate standardized design; analysis; reporting; and the identification of duplicative investments, gaps, and
-opportunities for collaboration within and across Federal agencies. More information about the FEA is
-available in The Common Approach to Federal Enterprise Architecture (OMB, May 2, 2012) and at FEA
-Reference Model document library.
-
-Federal Enterprise Architecture Mapping Codes refers to a framework for describing important elements of
-the FEA in a common and consistent way. Through the use of this common framework and vocabulary, IT
-portfolios can be better managed and leveraged across the Federal Government. The first three-digit code
-indicates the primary service area served by this investment (the three-digit BRM service code). The second
-through fifth three-digit codes indicate the secondary services associated with this investment. Guidance on
-the codes for these mappings can be found at FEA Reference Model document library.
-
-Financial Management refers to activities that support the interrelationships and interdependencies among
-budget, cost and management functions, and information associated with business transactions.
-
-Financial Management Systems refers to systems necessary to support financial management, including
-automated and manual processes, procedures, controls, data, hardware, software, and support personnel
-dedicated to the operation and maintenance of system functions. The following are examples of financial
-management systems: core financial systems, procurement systems, loan systems, grants systems, payroll
-systems, budget formulation systems, billing systems, and travel systems. See OMB Circular A-127 for
-additional information and guidance at www.whitehouse.gov/omb/circulars_a127.
-
-Full Funding refers to a situation where appropriations are enacted sufficient in total to complete an asset or a
-useful segment of a capital asset before any obligations may be incurred. Incrementally funding the planning
-and acquisition of capital assets or (useful segments) without certainty if or when future funding will be
-available can result in poor planning, inadequate justification of assets acquisition, higher acquisition costs,
-project delays, cancellation of projects, the loss of sunk costs, and inadequate funding to maintain and operate
-the assets. Budget requests for full acquisition of capital assets must propose full funding (see Section 31.6 of
-OMB Circular A-11).
-
-Page 7 of 45
-
- (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT
-
-Funding refers to providing the budgetary resources to plan for, acquire, develop, sustain, or operate an asset.
-
-Funding Source refers to the direct appropriation or other budgetary resources an agency receives for an IT
-investment. When “original paying accounts” within agencies are transferring resources to a different agency
-account that ultimately supports the IT investment (for example, when bureau accounts are paying into a
-central CIO office account or a working capital fund), the funding source provided in Exhibit 53A should be
-the account that ultimately pays contracts and other costs for the investment directly (not the original
-account(s) for the funds).
-
-Note: For agencies on the IT Dashboard, funding sources are planned as the primary drivers in the algorithm
-to display “spending by bureau,” rather than using the bureau code associated with investments. It is critical
-that valid funding source codes be provided in agency submissions.
-
-Government Information refers to information created, collected, processed, disseminated, or disposed of by
-or for the Federal Government.
-
-Information Resource Management (IRM) Strategic Plan refers to a document that addresses all information
-resources management of an agency. Agencies must develop and maintain their IRM strategic plans as
-required by 44 U.S.C. 3506(b)(2) and OMB Circular A-130. IRM strategic plans should support the agency's
-strategic plan that is required in OMB Circular A-11; provide a description of how information resources
-management activities help accomplish the agency’s missions delivery area and program decisions; and
-ensure IRM decisions are integrated with management support areas, including organizational planning,
-budget, procurement, financial management, and human resources management.
-
-Information Security refers to all functions necessary to meet Federal information security policy
-requirements. It includes the development, implementation, and maintenance of security policies, procedures,
-and controls across the entire information life cycle. These functions should include implementation and
-activities associated with NIST 800-37, Security Awareness training (but not the technical infrastructure
-required for the delivery of training), FISMA compliance reporting, development of a security policy, and
-security audits and testing. It does not include the physical protection of facilities such as those described in
-Critical Infrastructure Protection (CIP).
-
-Information System refers to a discrete set of IT, data, and related resources, such as personnel, hardware,
-software, and associated IT services organized for the collection, processing, maintenance, use, sharing,
-dissemination, or disposition of information.
-
-Information Technology refers to any equipment or interconnected system or subsystem of equipment that is
-used in the automatic acquisition, storage, manipulation, management, movement, control, display, switching,
-interchange, transmission, or reception of data or information by an executive agency. IT is related to the
-terms capital asset, IT investment, program, project, sub-project, service, and system.
-
-Integrated Program Team (IPT) refers to a cross-functional or multidisciplinary group of individuals
-organized and collectively responsible for the specific purpose of delivering a project, product, or process to
-an external or internal customer. Each IPT should include experts in program and project management,
-resource management, procurement, systems engineering, system security, and other disciplines, as necessary,
-to plan and evaluate all aspects of the project. In order for OMB to approve the investment budget, an IPT
-must include at a minimum: a qualified, fully dedicated IT program manager; a contracting specialist, if
-applicable; an IT specialist; an IT security specialist; and a business process owner or subject matter expert
-(SME). Other members of the IPT might include enterprise architects; IT specialists with specific expertise in
-data, systems, or networks; capital planners; or performance specialists. Key members of the IPT should be
-co-located during the most critical junctures of the program, to the maximum extent possible. Agencies
-should establish IPT members’ individual performance goals to hold team members accountable for both
-
-Page 8 of 45
-
- (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT
-
-individual functional goals and the overall success of the program. The investment IPT should be defined in a
-program or an IPT charter.
-
-Interagency Acquisition refers to the use of the Federal Supply Schedules; a multi-agency contract (i.e., a task
-order or delivery order contract established by one agency for use by multiple government agencies to obtain
-supplies and services, consistent with the Economy Act, 31 U.S.C. 1535) or a government-wide acquisition
-contract (i.e., a task order or delivery order contract for IT established by one agency for government-wide
-use operated by an executive agent, as designated by OMB pursuant to Section 11302(3) of the Clinger-Cohen
-Act of 1996).
-
-IT Dashboard refers to a website (www.itdashboard.gov) that enables Federal agencies, industry, the general
-public, and other stakeholders to view details regarding the performance of Federal IT investments. The IT
-Dashboard is used by the Administration and Congress to inform budget and policy decisions.
-
-IT Investment refers to the expenditure of IT resources to address mission delivery and management support.
-An IT investment may include a project or projects for the development, modernization, enhancement, or
-maintenance of a single IT asset or group of IT assets with related functionality and the subsequent operation
-of those assets in a production environment. All IT investments should have a defined life cycle with start and
-end dates, with the end date representing the end of the currently estimated useful life of the investment,
-consistent with the investment’s most current alternatives analysis if applicable.
-
-IT Program Managers and IT Project Managers refers to the IPT members responsible for IT investments
-and lead the required IPT for the investment. In some cases, IT program managers and PMs can hold
-positions in other classification series; however they must still meet the requisite Federal certification and/or
-IT program management experience requirements. Further definitions are available in the Office of Personnel
-Management’s Job Family Standard for Administrative Work in the Information Technology Group (series
-2200 in the Federal Classification and Job Grading Systems).
-
-IT System refers to a discrete set of information resources organized for the collection, processing,
-maintenance, transmission, and dissemination of information, in accordance with defined procedures, whether
-automated or manual.
-
-Life Cycle Costs refers to all investment costs (including government FTEs) from the commencement of the
-investment through its estimated useful life (or the composite estimated useful life of the assets within the
-investment), independent of the funding source (e.g., revolving fund, appropriated fund, working capital fund,
-trust fund). For more information about life cycle costs, see the Capital Programming Guide of OMB Circular
-A-11 and OMB Circular A-131.
-
-Maintenance refers to the activity necessary to keep an asset functioning as designed during the O&M phase
-of an investment. Some maintenance activities should be managed as projects and reported in Section B of
-Exhibit 300B. Examples of maintenance projects may include, but are not limited to: operating system
-upgrades, technology refreshes, and security patch implementations. As defined in the Federal Accounting
-Standards Advisory Board Statement of Federal Financial Accounting Standards Number 10, “Maintenance
-excludes activities aimed at expanding the capacity of an asset or otherwise upgrading it to serve needs
-different from or significantly greater than those originally intended.” Maintenance costs refer to all costs
-(including all related personnel costs) needed to sustain an IT asset at the current capability and performance
-levels.
-
-Major IT Investment refers to an IT investment requiring special management attention because of its
-importance to the mission or function to the government; significant program or policy implications; high
-executive visibility; high development, operating, or maintenance costs; unusual funding mechanism; or
-definition as major by the agency’s capital planning and investment control process. OMB may work with the
-
-Page 9 of 45
-
- (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT
-
-agency to declare IT investments as major investments. Agencies should consult with assigned OMB analysts
-regarding which investments are considered “major.” Investments not considered “major” are “non-major.”
-
-Managing Partner refers to the lead agency that is responsible for coordinating the implementation of the E-
-Gov or Line of Business (LoB) initiative. The managing partner is also responsible for coordinating and
-submitting Exhibit 300 for the initiative; Exhibit 300 will be represented as part of the managing partner's
-budget portfolio. For additional information on managing partner reporting requirements for IT investments,
-refer to the OMB MAX portal.
-
-New IT Investment refers to an IT investment and its associated projects that is newly proposed by the agency
-and that has not been previously reported/funded by OMB.
-
-Non-Major IT Investment refers to any IT investment in the agency's IT Portfolio that does not meet the
-definition of “major IT investment.” All non-major investments must be reported in Exhibit 53.
-
-Ongoing IT Investment refers to an investment and its associated assets, including both maintenance projects
-and operational activities that have been through a complete Budget Cycle with OMB with respect to the
-President's Budget for the current year (CY)—in this case, for FY 2013.
-
-Operational Analysis refers to a method of examining the ongoing performance of an operating asset
-investment and measuring that performance against an established set of cost, schedule, and performance
-goals. An operational analysis is, by nature, less structured than performance reporting methods applied to
-developmental projects and should trigger considerations of how the investment's objectives could be better
-met, how costs could be reduced, and whether the organization should continue performing a particular
-function. Guidance for Operational Analysis is described in the Capital Programming Guide.
-
-Operations refer to the day-to-day management of an asset in the production environment and include, but are
-not limited to, activities that operate data centers, help desks, operational centers, telecommunication centers,
-and end-user support services. Operational activities are reported through Section C of Exhibit 300B.
-Operations costs include the expenses associated with an IT asset that is in the production environment; costs
-to sustain an IT asset at the current capability and performance levels, including Federal and contracted labor
-costs; and costs for the disposal of an asset.
-
-Operations and Maintenance (O&M) refers to the phase of the life cycle in which the asset is in operations
-and produces the same product or provides a repetitive service. Also commonly referred to as steady state.
-
-Partner Agency refers to the agency for an E-Gov or LoB initiative that is designated to provide resources
-(e.g., funding, full-time equivalents [FTEs], in-kind) for the management, development, deployment, or
-maintenance of a common solution. The partner agency is also responsible for including the appropriate line
-items in its Exhibit 53 and reflecting the amount of the contribution for each of the E-Gov or LoB initiatives
-to which the agency provides resources.
-
-Performance-based Acquisition Management refers to a documented, systematic process for program
-management, which includes the integration of program scope, schedule and cost objectives, the establishment
-of a baseline plan for accomplishment of program objectives, and the use of earned value techniques for
-performance measurement during execution of the program. This type of management includes prototypes
-and tests to select the most cost-effective alternative during the planning phase; the work during the
-acquisition phase; and any developmental, modification, or upgrade work done during the O&M phase. A
-performance-based acquisition (as defined in the Federal Acquisition Regulation 37.101) or
-contract/agreement with a defined quality assurance plan that includes performance standards/measures
-should be the basis for monitoring contractor or in-house performance of this phase.
-
-Page 10 of 45
-
- (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT
-
-Planning refers to preparing, developing, or acquiring the information used to design the asset; assess the
-benefits, risks, and risk-adjusted costs of alternative solutions; and establish realistic cost, schedule, and
-performance goals for the selected alternative, before either proceeding to full acquisition of the capital
-project or useful component or terminating the project. Planning must progress to the point where the agency
-is ready to commit to achieving specific goals for the completion of the acquisition before proceeding to the
-acquisition phase. Information gathering activities to support planning may include market research of
-available solutions, architectural drawings, geological studies, engineering and design studies, and prototypes.
-Planning may be general to the overall investment or may be specific to a useful component.
-
-PortfolioStat refers to a face-to-face, evidence-based review of an agency's IT portfolio. Reviews can be used
-to identify and address a broad range of issues, including management of commodity IT, duplication of
-investments, and alignment with the agency’s mission and strategy. More detail regarding the PortfolioStat
-process is described in OMB memo M-12-10 – Implementing PortfolioStat.
-
-Post-Implementation Review (PIR) refers to an evaluation of how successfully the investment or project
-objectives were met and how effective the project management practices were in keeping the investment or
-project on track. A PIR can be conducted after a project has been completed, or after an investment concludes
-the implementation phase. Additional details regarding the PIR process is described in the Capital
-Programming Guide.
-
-Privacy Impact Assessment is a process for examining the risks and ramifications of using IT to collect,
-maintain, and disseminate information from or about members of the public in an identifiable form. The
-process also is also used to identify and evaluate protections and alternative processes to mitigate the impact
-to privacy of collecting such information. Consistent with OMB guidance (M-03-22) regarding implementing
-the privacy provisions of the E-Government Act, agencies must conduct and make publicly available PIAs for
-all new or significantly altered IT investments that administer information in an identifiable form collected
-from or about members of the public.
-
-Project refers to a temporary endeavor undertaken to accomplish a unique product or service with a defined
-start and end point and specific objectives that, when attained, signify completion. Projects can be undertaken
-for the development, modernization, enhancement, disposal, or maintenance of an IT asset. Projects are
-composed of activities. When reporting projects in Exhibit 300A and 300B, to the maximum extent
-practicable, agencies should detail the characteristics of “increments” under modular contracting as described
-in the Clinger-Cohen Act of 1996 and the characteristics of “useful segments,” as described in OMB Circular
-A-130.
-
-Project Manager Level of Experience refers to the specific certification(s) or number of years of direct
-project management experience that the PM holds. Examples of PM certifications include FAC-P/PM,
-Project Management Institute/PMP, and other recognized certifications.
-
-Records refers to all books, papers, maps, photographs, machine-readable materials, or other documentary
-materials, regardless of physical form or characteristics, made or received by an agency of the United States
-Government under Federal law or in connection with the transaction of public business. Records may also
-include items that are preserved or appropriate for preservation by that agency or its legitimate successor as
-evidence of the organization, functions, policies, decisions, procedures, operations, or other activities of the
-Federal Government or because of the informational value of data in them. Library and museum material
-made or acquired and preserved solely for reference or exhibition purposes, extra copies of documents
-preserved only for convenience of reference, and stocks of publications and processed documents are may not
-be included as records.
-
-Risk Management refers to a systematic process of identifying, analyzing, and responding to risk. It includes
-maximizing the probability and consequences of positive events and minimizing the probability and
-consequences of adverse events to overall objectives.
-
-Page 11 of 45
-
- (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBITS 53 AND 300 – INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND E-GOVERNMENT
-
-Risk Management Plan refers to a documented and approved plan developed at the onset of the investment
-and maintained throughout that specifies the risk management process
-
-Shared Service Provider refers to the provider of a technical solution and/or service that supports the business
-of multiple agencies using a shared architecture.
-
-TechStat refers to a face-to-face, evidence-based review of an IT program with Bureau/Agency leadership and
-OMB as appropriate. TechStat sessions enable the Federal Government to turn around, halt, or terminate IT
-investments that do not produce dividends for the American people. More detail regarding the TechStat
-process is described in the TechStat Training Deck.
-
-Unique Investment Identifier (UII) refers to a persistent numeric code applied to an investment that allows
-the identification and tracking of an investment across multiple FYs of an agency’s investment portfolio. The
-UII is composed of a three-digit agency code concatenated with a nine-digit unique investment number
-generated by the agency. Some nine-digit numbers are reserved for OMB to assign and may not be assigned
-by agencies, as controlled by the restrictions described in the section on “Variable Information.”
-
-Additional budget terms and definitions are included in the Glossary in OMB Circular A-11, Appendix J,
-“Principles of Budgeting for Capital Asset Acquisitions.”
-
-5. How do I determine whether I must report?
-
-Agencies must submit an agency IT investment portfolio (Exhibit 53A, Exhibit 53C, Exhibit 53D, and
-Exhibits 300), if the government agency is subject to Executive Branch review (see OMB Circular A-11
-Section 25.1). All CFO Act agencies and any others directed to do so must submit an agency security
-portfolio (Exhibit 53B).
-
-The following agencies must also submit this information to the IT Dashboard:
-
-Department of Agriculture
-Department of Commerce
-Department of Defense
-Department of Education
-Department of Energy
-Department of Health and Human Services
-Department of Homeland Security
-Department of Housing and Urban Development
-Department of the Interior
-Department of Justice
-Department of Labor
-Department of State
-Department of Transportation
-Department of the Treasury
-
-Department of Veteran’s Affairs
-U.S. Agency for International Development
-U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
-Environmental Protection Agency
-General Services Administration
-National Aeronautics and Space Administration
-National Archives and Records Administration
-National Science Foundation
-Nuclear Regulatory Commission
-Office of Personnel Management
-Small Business Administration
-Smithsonian Institution
-Social Security Administration
-
-The agency’s IT capital planning office should coordinate and review all versions/revisions of the Exhibit 53
-prior to submission.
-
-Page 12 of 45
-
- (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
-
-53.1 How do I submit Exhibit 53 and when is it due?
-
-Agencies must submit a draft and updated versions of Exhibit 53s using the following schedule:
-
- Draft Exhibit 53A: August 27, 2012
- Agency Budget Request Exhibit 53A, B, C, and D: September 10, 2012
- President’s Budget Request Exhibit 53A, B, C, and D: Early January 2013 (tentative)
-
-Specifically, a draft version of Exhibit 53A shall be completed by the agency and submitted to OMB. This
-draft will allow the agency and OMB to agree on which major and non-major IT investments will be reported
-as part of the next President's Budget Request and to confirm the mapping of agency investments to agency
-architectures. The initial draft of Exhibit 53A must conform to a template described later in this section,
-which will be published on the OMB MAX portal. Specific steps for completing the submission will be
-available on the OMB MAX portal. The completion of the initial draft of Exhibit 53A should be coordinated
-by the agency’s IT capital planning lead. At a minimum, the draft Exhibit 53A should include the legacy UIIs
-and current UIIs, investment name, investment description, and the FEA BRM Primary services mappings.
+5
-All subsequent updates to the Exhibit 53s will be submitted to the IT Dashboard or otherwise as directed. The
-agency’s IT capital planning office should coordinate and review all versions of Exhibit 53 prior to
-submission.
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Additional updates to Exhibits 53A and 300A may be required after final budget decisions or if the agency
-requests supplemental funds that require changes to Exhibits 53A and 300A. Specific instructions and
-deadlines for submitting updates, corrections, and final submissions of these exhibits will be available on the
-OMB MAX portal.
+Republican confidence in Trump to respect country’s
+democratic values, act ethically in office declines
-53.2 If I submitted Exhibit 53 last year, how do I revise it this year?
+% who say, thinking about the qualities needed to serve as president, they are
+extremely/very confident that Donald Trump …
-If your agency submitted Exhibit 53 for the FY 2013 Budget, the revised FY 2014 Budget must be compliant
-with the specified format or it will be rejected. Agencies must note “changes in status” for each investment
-and provide descriptions for any changes in status.
+Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026.
-It is important that the agency updates its Exhibit 53 to reflect prior year (PY) for FY 2012, current year (CY)
-for FY 2013, and budget year (BY) for FY 2014. Exhibit 53A also requires MAX funding codes for all
-"Funding Sources" line items. Consistent with prior submissions, "Investment Descriptions" will be limited to
-255 characters.
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-53.3 How is Exhibit 53 organized?
+There’s a similar pattern
+across all six qualities we asked about.
-Exhibit 53 is composed of four parts:
+For example, 60% of Republicans said last February that they were extremely or very confident
+Trump respects the country’s democratic values – it’s 52% today. And while 66% of Republicans
+say he has the mental fitness to do the job, that’s down from three-quarters last year.
-1. Exhibit 53A, “Agency IT Investment Portfolio,” which includes IT investment budget and
+Democrats’ confidence in Trump on these measures remains very low.
-architecture information;
+For full trend on each of the qualities asked on the survey, refer to chart appendix.
-2. Exhibit 53B, “Agency IT Security Portfolio,” which includes a summary of agency and bureau IT
+www.pewresearch.org
-security information, including IT security costs; and
+6
-3. Exhibit 53C, “Agency Cloud Computing Portfolio,” which includes IT investment budget information
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-by cloud computing deployment model and service model.
+Support for Trump’s policies
-4. Exhibit 53D, “Agency IT Reductions and Reinvestments” (see OMB M-12-13)
+There has also been a significant decline over
+the last year in the share of adults who say they
+agree with Trump’s plans and policies.
-Agencies should compare all relevant portfolios to ensure consistency. For example, the sum of columns 41
-to 43 on Exhibit 53A should equal the sums of each table in Exhibit 53C.
+Republican support for Trump’s agenda
+has declined over the last year
-Page 13 of 45 Exhibit 53
+% who say they support all/most of Donald Trump’s
+plans and policies
- (2012)
+▪ Last year, 35% said they supported all or
+most of his plans, 17% supported some of
+them and 47% supported only a few or
+none.
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
+▪ Today, 27% say they support all or most,
-Agency IT Investment Portfolio (Exhibit 53A)
+20% support some and 52% support few or
+none.
-(a) Overview
+The decline in support has come
+exclusively among Republicans. Last
+year, 67% said they supported all or most
+of Trump’s plans and policies. Today, 56% do.
-Exhibit 53A is a report of all agency IT investments. Investment costs are to be provided in millions of
-dollars, and reporting three decimal places (precision to thousands of dollars) is recommended, although
-agencies may report up to six decimal places (whole dollars).
+Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026.
-Information reported in Exhibit 53A should be consistent with data reported in MAX schedule O, object
-classification (specifically, object classes 11.1 through 12.2, 23.1, 23.2, 25.2, 25.3, 25.7, 26.0, 31.0, and 41.0).
-All major and non-major IT investments must be reported in Exhibit 53A.
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Agencies must note all Federal budgetary resources (includes carryover and new budget authority) used to
-fund an IT investment, including discretionary or mandatory funding sources, user fees, or gifts. Funding
-should represent only Federal budgetary resources. Agencies should not include funding provided by non-
-Federal sources, such as in matching funds for grant programs provided by state or local governments.
+Very small shares of Democrats say they support his policies. Most (87%) support only a few or
+none.
-Funding levels in Exhibit 53A should represent:
+Related: Few Americans support Trump’s proposed takeover of Greenland.
- Estimated budgetary resources for BY (this may be different from the estimated obligations on the
+For full trend details, refer to the appendix.
-Exhibit 300 for some investments)
+www.pewresearch.org
- Estimated budgetary resources for CY (based on enactment where applicable) (this may be different
+7
-from the estimated obligations on the Exhibit 300 for some investments)
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
- Expended budgetary resources (actuals) for PY (or the best current estimate) (this cost should
+Republicans increasingly say GOP
+members of Congress aren’t obligated to
+support Trump if they disagree with him
-represent the actual costs reported to the Exhibit 300)
+% of Rep/Lean Rep who say Republicans in Congress …
-These levels should be consistent with program-level funding and branch, bureau, and agency summary
-funding tables. Funding from supplemental appropriations and the Recovery Act should also be included in a
-manner consistent with other budget submission displays of program data.
+Do Republicans in Congress have an
+obligation to support Trump?
-Exhibit 53A has six major parts:
+Today, 38% of Republicans and Republican-
+leaning independents say that congressional
+Republicans “have an obligation to support
+Trump’s policies and programs because he is a
+Republican president.” But a far larger share
+(61%) say GOP members of Congress do not
+have an obligation to support Trump if they
+disagree with him.
-Part 1.
-Part 2.
-Part 3.
-Part 4.
-Part 5.
-Part 6.
+The share saying Republicans in Congress do
+not have this obligation is up since last year,
+from 55%.
-IT Investments for Mission Delivery and Management Support
-IT Investments for Infrastructure, Office Automation, and Telecommunications
-IT Investments for EA, Capital Planning, and CIO Functions
-IT Investments for Grants Management Systems
-National Security Systems IT Investments
-Grants to State and Local IT Investments
+Note: No answer responses are not shown.
+Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026.
-All parts use the following common data elements:
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Agency Description of Change in Investment Status is used when an indicator has been chosen for “Change
-in Investment Status” in order to provide a description of the rationale for the change which may include
-impacted UPIs, specific references to legislative requirements, or governance board decisions and effective
-dates.
+www.pewresearch.org
-Agency Funding is the agency’s budgetary resources for a given investment.
+8
-Change in Investment Status is used when an investment has a change in status (e.g., downgraded to non-
-major investment, eliminated, retired, consolidated, split) for the current budget submission relative to the
-previous budget cycle. The change of status should be indicated with one of the following reasons:
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Page 14 of 45 Exhibit 53
+Other key findings from the survey
- (2012)
+Democrats increasingly say their congressional
+leaders should stand up to Trump on their issues
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
+% of Rep/Lean Rep who say
+Donald Trump should …
-1. Upgrade
-2. Downgrade
-3. Split
-4. Consolidation
-5. Reorganization
-6. Eliminated by funding
-7. Eliminated by split
-8. Eliminated by consolidation
-9. Eliminated by reorganization
-10. New
-11. No Change in Status
+% of Dem/Lean Dem who say
+Democratic congressional leaders
+should …
-Cloud Computing Alternatives Evaluation specifies whether, as of the date of the submission, a cloud
-alternative was evaluated for the investment or components/systems within the investment, per the Cloud First
-policy. All investments should answer this question regardless of the overall lifecycle stage of the investment,
-as operational investments may consider performing such an evaluation during or as a result of an operational
-analysis. The evaluation should indicate one of the following answers:
+▪ Democrats
-1. The agency evaluated a cloud alternative and chose a cloud alternative for some or all of the investment.
-2. The agency evaluated a cloud alternative but did not choose a cloud alternative for any of the investment.
-3. The agency did not evaluate a cloud alternative but plans to evaluate a cloud alternative by the end of the BY.
-4. The agency did not evaluate a cloud alternative and does not plan to evaluate a cloud alternative by the end of
+overwhelmingly say
+their congressional
+leadership should
+stand up to Trump.
+Today, 82% (up from 70%
+last year) want to see their
+leaders pushing back
+against Trump, even if that
+makes it harder to address
+problems. A smaller
+majority of Republicans
+(61%) say Trump should
+stand up to Democratic
+leaders. This is similar to
+their views a year ago.
-the BY.
+▪ Nearly half of
-Cloud Computing Spending refers to implementation and operational costs directly attributable to the cloud
-computing systems “within” the investment for the specified year.
+Note: No answer responses are not shown.
+Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026.
-Cross-Boundary Information Sharing is an activity that crosses a bureau or agency boundary, including
-information sharing with international, state, local, tribal, industry, or non-governmental organization partners.
-If the investment supports reusable, standardized information exchanges, agencies must indicate which of the
-following were used:
-
-1. NIEM
-2. UCORE
-3. XBRL
-4. Other
-5. None
-
-Current UII includes an agency code and a nine-digit unique identifier. Variable information formerly
-included in the UPI of previous years is not part of the UII primary key. Details are provided in Section 53.4.
-
-Development/Modernization/Enhancement Expenditures are the costs for projects leading to new IT assets
-and projects that change or modify existing IT assets to: improve capability or performance, implement
-legislative or regulatory requirements, or meet agency leadership requests. These expenditures correspond to
-capitalized costs, and expenses may include: hardware; software; Federal and contracted labor for system
-planning, development, acquisition, and integration; and direct overhead and project management. If non-
-repairable or non-working IT hardware or software is replaced to continue the operation of an asset, and as a
-result improves the capability or performance of an asset, the expense should be categorized as operations.
-
-FEA BRM Services include three-digit codes that indicate the service area served by the investment. The first
-three-digit code indicates the primary service area (the three-digit BRM service code) and the second through
-fifth three-digit codes indicate the secondary services associated with the investment. Guidance on providing
-appropriate FEA BRM Services mapping codes can be found at FEA Reference Model document library.
-
-Page 15 of 45 Exhibit 53
-
- (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
-
-Functional/Business Sponsor is the name of the agency official who is responsible for the program or
-function supported or implemented by the investment {44 U.S.C. 3501 (a) (4)}. The sponsor is responsible
-for expressing the value of, ensuring successful implementation of, and providing accurate and timely data for
-the IT investment to the agency CIO and OMB. The designated person may (or may not) be the same as the
-“Business Process owner/Subject Matter Expert” listed for a major investment on the Exhibit 300A under
-Integrated Program Team. Each major and non-major investment listed in Exhibit 53 must include the name
-of the functional/business sponsor as well as the individual’s title, phone number, and e-mail address.
-
-Funding Source means for each investment, the agency must identify the funding source and budgetary
-resources, including the MAX funding codes used for the investment. An agency should add as many funding
-source line items as are appropriate for the investment. To avoid double counting or under counting, the totals
-of the funding amounts for an investment must match the main investment line item, represented with the
-investment category of "00," "24," or “48.” See definition in section 4.
-
-Government FTE Number and Percentage means the number of government FTE included in the BY
-funding and the percentage of the total BY cost represented by the number of government FTE. This applies
-to all investments, both major and non-major. If an FTE’s costs are included in the investment costs for BY,
-the FTE or portion of the FTE should be reported, regardless of the FTE’s role in the investment (technical,
-managerial, functional, etc.).
-
-Homeland Security Priority Identifier means an IT investment supporting the homeland security mission
-areas of 1) Intelligence and warning, 2) Border and transportation security, 3) Defense against catastrophic
-threats, 4) Protection of critical infrastructure and key assets, 5) Emergency preparedness and response, 6)
-Other, 0) None. If the investment supports one or more of these mission areas, indicate which one(s) by
-listing the corresponding number(s) listed above.
-
-Homeland Security Presidential Directive-12 (HSPD-12) Costs refer to all costs to implement or provide
-logical access to the systems within the investment for the PY, per HSPD-12. HPSD-12 costs should be
-provided for all relevant investments, both major and non-major.
-
-Investment Description means a short public-facing description (limited to 255 characters) for each
-investment (major, migration, partner contribution, and non-major). This description should explain the
-purpose of the investment and what program(s) it supports, including the value to the public. The description
-should be understandable to someone who is not an expert of the agency. If the investment is part of a multi-
-agency initiative or another business case, the agency should describe where that business case is located in
-the appropriate agency Budget submission (e.g., managing partner UII). For example, if the investment
-represents your agency's participation in one of the Presidential initiatives, the description should state this
-information and refer to the UII of the managing partner's business case.
-
-Investment Title means a definitive title explaining the investment. For "funding source" information,
-provide the 10-digit OMB MAX account code (OMB Circular A-11, Section 79.2). To the extent that they are
-not part of the name used by the agency, other identifiers such as bureaus or other numeric codes should not
-be included as part of an Investment Title.
-
-Operations & Maintenance (Steady State) Costs describes the expenses associated with an IT asset that is in
-the O&M life cycle phase. Operations expenses include maintenance projects and operation costs needed to
-sustain the IT asset at the current capability and performance levels, including: Federal and contracted labor
-costs, corrective hardware and software maintenance, voice and data communications maintenance and
-service, replacement of broken or obsolete IT equipment, and overhead costs.
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Previous UII means the identifier depicting agency code and unique investment number used to report the
-investment in the previous BY Exhibit 53 submission to OMB. Indicating the UII used for a previous
+Americans (47%) now
+say Trump will be an
+unsuccessful president
+in the long term. This share is up 14 points since last year, with most of this change
+occurring among Democrats. A majority of Republicans continue to say Trump will be
+successful in the long run.
-Page 16 of 45 Exhibit 53
+▪ Trump’s approval among Republicans is now 73% – down slightly since
- (2012)
+September. Older Americans, White adults and those without a college degree continue to
+approve of his performance more than others. See detailed tables for additional demographic
+breaks.
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
+www.pewresearch.org
-submission allows cross-walk and historical analysis crossing FYs for tracking purposes. Previous UII is
-mandatory, with the exception of new investments. To indicate consolidations/splits/reorganizations, agencies
-can provide more than one entry and separate UIIs with commas.
-Supports Information Sharing, Access, and Safeguarding refers to an IT investment that supports the
-information sharing, access, and safeguarding mission areas of: 1) The national network of state and major
-urban area fusion centers; 2) Assured interoperability across Controlled Unclassified Information /Sensitive
-but Unclassified networks targeting Federal, state, local, and tribal law enforcement, public safety, homeland
-security, and intelligence personnel; 3) Assured interoperability across classified SECRET networks; 4)
-Nationwide suspicious activity reporting initiative; 5) Alerts, Warnings and Notifications; and 6) Case and
-event deconfliction; or 0) None. If the investment supports one or more of these mission areas, indicate which
-one(s) by listing the corresponding number(s) listed above.
+9
-(b) Part 1. IT Investments for Mission Delivery Areas and Management Support Areas1
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Report all IT investments directly supporting an agency-designated mission delivery area or management
-support area (“Mission delivery area” means programs or activities that execute the agency mission as
-outlined in the agency strategic plan. “Management support area” means activities such as human resource
-management, financial management, and command and control.). The investments support these mission
-deliveries should be consistent with your agency's strategic and annual performance plan. Include capital
-costs (planning, development, modernization, and enhancement) and O&M expenses for each IT investment.
+Appendix: Additional charts
-Agencies must include an area titled “Financial Management,” and it must be reported as the first area.
-Report all IT investments for major financial management systems in this area.
+Confidence in Trump on several key qualities and
+abilities needed to serve as president
-(c) Part 2. IT Investments for Infrastructure, IT Security, Office Automation, and Telecommunications
+% who say, thinking about the qualities needed to serve as president, they are
+extremely/very confident that Donald Trump …
-Report all IT investments supporting planning, development, modernization, enhancement, operation, and
-maintenance of common user systems such as IT infrastructure and IT security. Each agency may submit
-multiple Exhibits 300 encompassing office automation, infrastructure, security, and telecommunications for
-the agency. These investments may be defined at the bureau level and/or by functional components of the
-infrastructure. These IT infrastructure investments may support multiple mission areas and should include
-end-user services and support, mainframes and servers services and support, and telecommunications services
-and support. IT infrastructure includes direct costs—those that produce tangible IT products or services for
-business users—and indirect costs—those that do not lead to a tangible product or direct support of business
-users—such as IT program management costs and overhead expenses.
+Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026.
-Agencies are encouraged to report these investments as they are managed. If IT infrastructure is managed at
-both the agency and bureau levels, agencies should report both agency and bureau-level infrastructure
-investments.
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-(d) Part 3. IT Investments for EA, Capital Planning, and CIO Functions
+www.pewresearch.org
-Report all IT investments supporting the strategic management of IT operations (e.g., business process
-redesign efforts that are not part of an individual investment, EA development, capital planning and
-investment control processes, procurement management, IT policy development and implementation). IT
-investments in this part of Exhibit 53A should include costs for CIO functions.
+10
-(e) Part 4. IT Investments for Grants Management Systems
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-1 For the purpose of Exhibit 53, IT Investments for EA, Capital Planning, and CIO Functions remain in Part 3 and IT
-Investments for Grants Management Systems remain in Part 4.
+Will Trump be a successful president in the long term?
-Page 17 of 45 Exhibit 53
+% who say Donald Trump will be a(n) ___ president in the long run
- (2012)
+Note: No answer responses are not shown.
+Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026.
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Report all IT investments supporting information regarding the planning, development, modernization,
-enhancement, and operation of grants management systems.
+Have the Trump administration’s actions since taking
+office in 2025 been better or worse than expected?
-(f) Part 5. National Security Systems Investments
+% who say the Trump administration’s actions since taking office last year
+have been ___ expected
-Report all IT investments that represent planning, development, modernization, enhancement, and operation
-of national security systems. Only the Department of Defense should report investments in Part 5.
+Note: No answer responses are not shown.
+Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026.
-(g) Part 6. Grants to State and Local IT Investments
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Report amounts for grants to state and local agencies that fund the planning, development, modernization,
-enhancement, and operation of state and local IT systems. Agencies should only use Part 6 to report "Grants
-to State and Local” and not the systems that support these grant activities. Before using Part 6 for anything
-other than these types of investments, check with your agency’s OMB E-Gov analyst.
+www.pewresearch.org
-Agency Security Portfolio (Exhibit 53B)
+11
-The Agency Security Portfolio is to be completed at the agency level, not at the individual investment level.
-Exhibit 53B uses the following data elements (as they appear in Exhibit 53B). Note that eight data elements
-that were previously provided separately (see the BY2012 Exhibit 53B guidance) are to be reported in the
-aggregate of “Total IT Security Tools Costs.”
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
- Total IT Security Tools Costs (Anti-Virus)—a program that monitors desktops/laptops to identify all
+Public support for Trump’s policies and plans
-major types of viruses and prevent or contain virus incidents.
+% who say they support ___ of Donald Trump’s policies and plans
- Total IT Security Tools Costs (Anti-Malware)—a program that monitors a computer or network to
+Note: No answer responses are not shown.
+Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026.
-identify all major types of malware and prevent or contain malware incidents.
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
- Total IT Security Tools Costs (Data Leakage Protection Tools)—systems designed to detect and
-prevent the unauthorized use and transmission of confidential information including encryption for
-PII.
+www.pewresearch.org
- Total IT Security Tools Costs (E-mail Filtering Software)—software that organizes e-mail according
+12
-to defined criteria, most commonly used for detecting and eliminating spam and malware.
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
- Total Security Tools Costs (Intrusion Detection System [IDS])—software that looks for suspicious
+Trump’s approval rating in first year of
+his second term
-activity on networks and alerts administrators.
+% who approve of the way Donald Trump is handling
+his job as president
- Total IT Security Tools Costs (Intrusion Prevention System [IPS])—systems that can detect an
-intrusive activity on networks and attempt to stop the activity, ideally before it reaches its targets.
- Total IT Security Tools Costs (Security Information Management [SIM]/Security Information and
-Event Management [SIEM])—software/systems that collect security data (e.g., event logs) into a
-central repository for trend analysis.
+84
- Total IT Security Tools Costs (Web filtering software—also known as Content-Control software or
-Censorware)—software designed and optimized for controlling what content is permitted to a reader,
-especially when it is used to restrict material delivered over the web. Content-control software
-determines what content will be available.
+Rep/Lean Rep
-Page 18 of 45 Exhibit 53
+80
- (2012)
+75
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
+78
-Agency Cloud Computing Portfolio (Exhibit 53C)
+74
-The Agency Cloud Computing Portfolio is to be completed at the agency level, not at the individual
-investment level. Exhibit 53C is comprised of two tables to report the following data elements for each year
-(PY, CY, BY). Note that the sum of each year should match across the two tables and this sum should match
-the sum of columns 41 to 43 of Exhibit 53A. For definitions of terms used in Exhibit 53C, see NIST Special
-Publication 800-146. Only costs directly attributable to cloud computing implementations, operations or
-services should be reported, which may only be a portion of the total cost of contributing/associated
-investments.
+Total
-(a) Agency costs for cloud computing by deployment model, by year (PY, CY, BY)
+47
- Public Cloud portion of all agency cloud computing spending
- Private Cloud portion of all agency cloud computing spending
- Community Cloud portion of all agency cloud computing spending
- Hybrid Cloud portion of all agency cloud computing spending
+40
-(b) Agency costs for cloud computing by service model, by year (PY, CY, BY)
+41
- Software as a Service (SaaS) portion of all agency cloud computing spending
- Platform as a Service (PaaS) portion of all agency cloud computing spending
-
+38 40
-Infrastructure as a Service (IaaS) portion of all agency cloud computing spending
+Dem/Lean Dem
-53.4 How is Exhibit 53A coded?
+10
-Use the following UII 12-digit line number coding, and additional six 2-digit variable information fields, to
-categorize investments and line structure for your Exhibit 53A. Each investment identified in the agency's
-portfolio must have a unique UII.
+7
-Entry
+7
-Description
+6
-Unique Investment Identifier Primary Key
+6
-XXX-
-xxxxxxxxx
+73
-xxx-
-XXXXXXXXX
+37
-The first three digits represent your agency code (see Appendix C of OMB Circular A-11).
+5
-The last nine digits serve as your unique identifier. This identifier should be system
-generated and applied at the agency level. It will allow agencies up to one billion unique
-identifiers to associate with IT investments. Once used, the unique identifier must be
-retired. If an IT investment is retired, discontinued, or merged with another IT
-investment, the unique identifier persists with that IT investment.
+Feb '25
-Note: “99999XXXX” codes are reserved for approved multi-agency investments,
-including E-Gov and LoB initiatives
+Jan '26
-Page 19 of 45 Exhibit 53
+Source: Survey of U.S. adults conducted Jan. 20-26, 2026.
- (2012)
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
+www.pewresearch.org
-Variable Information: The following attributes extracted from the FY 2012 Budget cycle and prior years’
-UPI should continue to be supplied.
+13
-XX-xx-
-xx-xx-
-xx-xx
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-xx-XX-
-xx-xx-
-xx-xx
+Acknowledgments
-xx-xx-
-XX-xx-
-xx -xx
+This report is a collaborative effort based on the input and analysis of the following individuals:
-xx-xx-
-xx-XX-
-xx-xx
+Research team
-xx-xx-
-xx-xx-
-XX-xx
+Communications and editorial
-00 = Code for all investments other than those coded “24” or “48”
+Jocelyn Kiley, Director, Political Research
+Steven Shepard, Associate Director, Political
+Research
+Hannah Hartig, Senior Researcher
+Baxter Oliphant, Senior Researcher
+Gabe Borelli, Research Associate
+Andrew Daniller, Research Associate
+Andy Cerda, Research Analyst
+Joseph Copeland, Research Analyst
+Shanay Gracia, Research Analyst
+Ted Van Green, Research Analyst
-24 = E-Gov initiatives or an individual agency's participation in one of the E-Gov initiatives
+Nida Asheer, Senior Communications
+Manager
+Maya Pottinger, Communications Associate
+David Kent, Senior Editorial Specialist
+Anna Jackson, Editorial Specialist
-48 = Any multi-agency collaboration or an individual agency’s participation in one of the multi-agency
-initiatives, excluding E-Gov initiatives
+Graphic design and web publishing
-The next two digits indicate your bureau code (see Appendix C of OMB Circular A-11). If this is
-a department level or an agency-wide activity, use 00 as your bureau code.
+Peter Bell, Associate Director, Design and
+Production
+Alissa Scheller, Senior Information Graphics
+Designer
+Reem Nadeem, Digital Producer
+Beshay Sakla, Associate Digital Producer
-These two digits indicate the six parts of Exhibit 53:
+Methodology
-01 = Part 1. IT Investments for Mission Delivery and Management Support Area
+Andrew Mercer, Senior Research
+Methodologist
+Dorene Asare-Marfo, Senior Panel Manager
+Dana Popky, Associate Panel Manager
+Arnold Lau, Research Methodologist
-02 = Part 2. IT Investments for Infrastructure, IT Security, Office Automation, and Telecommunications
+www.pewresearch.org
-03 = Part 3. IT Investments for EA, Capital Planning, and CIO Functions
+14
-04 = Part 4. IT Investments for Grants Management Systems
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-05 = Part 5. National Security Systems IT Investments (Department of Defense Only)
-06 = Part 6. Grants to State and Local IT Investments
+Methodology
-These two digits indicate the mission delivery and management support areas. Agencies should
-assign a unique code for each mission delivery and management support area reported.
+The American Trends Panel
-These two digits indicate your agency's type of investment. Select one of the following two digit
-codes according to the type of investment you are reporting:
+survey methodology
-01 = Major IT investments (see definition in Section 4)
+Overview
-02 = Non-major IT investments (see definition in Section 4)
+Data in this report comes from Wave 185 of the American Trends Panel (ATP), Pew Research
+Center’s nationally representative panel of randomly selected U.S. adults. The survey was
+conducted from Jan. 20 to Jan. 26, 2026. A total of 8,512 panelists responded out of 9,302 who
+were sampled, for a survey-level response rate of 92%.
-03 = IT migration investment portion of a larger asset and for which there is an existing business case for the
-overall asset. The description of the IT investment should indicate the UII of the major asset investment of
-the managing partner.
+The cumulative response rate accounting for all stages of nonresponse and attrition is 3%. The
+break-off rate among panelists who logged on to the survey and completed at least one item is 2%.
+The margin of sampling error for the full sample of 8,512 respondents is plus or minus 1.4
+percentage points.
-04 = Investments where the business case for the major IT investment is reported in another agency's Exhibit
-53. The description of the IT investment should indicate the UII of the major asset investment of the
-managing partner.
+The survey includes oversamples of non-Hispanic Asian adults and adults ages 18-to-29 in order
+to provide more precise estimates of the opinions and experiences of these smaller demographic
+subgroups. These oversampled groups are weighted back to reflect their correct proportions in the
+population.
-xx-xx-
-xx-xx-
-xx-XX
+SSRS conducted the survey for Pew Research Center via online (n=8,272) and live telephone
+(n=240) interviewing. Interviews were conducted in both English and Spanish.
-These two digits identify the nature of the “line item” in the Exhibit 53 structure. The digits
-represent the line number in both the XML format used for agencies on the IT Dashboard and the
-line number in an equivalent spreadsheet file (CSV or XLS file), for agencies not on the IT
-Dashboard:
+To learn more about the ATP, read “About the American Trends Panel.”
-00 = Total investment title line, structurally the first line for reporting this particular investment
+Panel recruitment
-04 = Funding source or appropriation
-[09 = Any subtotal – This value is only used only for agencies not on the IT Dashboard]
+Since 2018, the ATP has used address-based sampling (ABS) for recruitment. A study cover letter
+and a pre-incentive are mailed to a stratified, random sample of households selected from the U.S.
+Postal Service’s Computerized Delivery Sequence File. This Postal Service file has been estimated
+to cover 90% to 98% of the population.1 Within each sampled household, the adult with the next
+birthday is selected to participate. Other details of the ABS recruitment protocol have changed
+over time but are available upon request.2 Prior to 2018, the ATP was recruited using landline and
+cellphone random-digit-dial surveys administered in English and Spanish.
-Page 20 of 45 Exhibit 53
+1 AAPOR Task Force on Address-based Sampling. 2016. “AAPOR Report: Address-based Sampling.”
+2 Email pewsurveys@pewresearch.org.
- (2012)
+www.pewresearch.org
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
+15
-Use the following 10-digit number coding system to update or complete your OMB MAX account ID code
-information:
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Entry
+A national sample of U.S. adults has been recruited to the ATP approximately once per year since
+2014. In some years, the recruitment has included additional efforts (known as an “oversample”)
+to improve the accuracy of data for underrepresented groups. For example, Hispanic adults, Black
+adults and Asian adults were oversampled in 2019, 2022 and 2023, respectively.
-Description
+Sample design
-XXX-xx-xxxx-x
+The overall target population for this survey was noninstitutionalized persons ages 18 and older
+living in the United States. It featured a stratified random sample from among ATP members who
+previously completed Wave 183. Non-Hispanic Asian adults and adults ages 18 to 29 were selected
+with certainty. The remaining panelists were sampled at rates designed to ensure that the share of
+respondents in each stratum is proportional to its share of the U.S. adult population to the greatest
+extent possible. Respondent weights are adjusted to account for differential probabilities of
+selection as described in the Weighting section below.
-The first three digits are your agency code (see Appendix C of OMB Circular A-11).
+Questionnaire development and testing
-xxx-XX-xxxx-x
+The questionnaire was developed by Pew Research Center in consultation with SSRS. The web
+program used for online respondents was rigorously tested on both PC and mobile devices by the
+SSRS project team and Pew Research Center researchers. The SSRS project team also populated
+test data that was analyzed in SPSS to ensure the logic and randomizations were working as
+intended before launching the survey.
-The next two digits are your bureau code (see Appendix C of OMB Circular A-11).
+Incentives
-xxx-xx-XXXX-x
+All respondents were offered a post-paid incentive for their participation. Respondents could
+choose to receive the post-paid incentive in the form of a check or gift code to Amazon.com,
+Target.com or Walmart.com. Incentive amounts ranged from $5 to $20 depending on whether the
+respondent belongs to a part of the population that is harder or easier to reach. Differential
+incentive amounts were designed to increase panel survey participation among groups that
+traditionally have low survey response propensities.
-This is a four-digit account symbol for the appropriate MAX account (see Section 79.2 of
-OMB Circular A-11).
+Data collection protocol
-xxx-xx-xxxx-X
+The data collection field period for this survey was Jan. 20 to Jan. 26, 2026. Surveys were
+conducted via self-administered web survey or by live telephone interviewing.
-This is a single digit Transmittal Code (see Section 79.2 of OMB Circular A-11).
-For the purposes of Exhibit 53A only, funding sources should continue to utilize the “-9” transmittal code to
-flag funding from the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (ARRA).
+www.pewresearch.org
-Use the following set of 3-digit numbers to identify each investment’s primary service area and, if desired, up
-to four secondary service areas:
+16
-Entry
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Description
+For panelists who take surveys online:3 Postcard notifications were mailed to a subset on
+Jan. 20.4 Survey invitations were sent out in two separate launches: soft launch and full launch.
+Sixty panelists were included in the soft launch, which began with an initial invitation sent on Jan.
+20. All remaining English- and Spanish-speaking sampled online panelists were included in the
+full launch and were sent an invitation on Jan. 21.
-XXX (primary services)
+Invitation and reminder dates for web respondents,
+ATP Wave
-The first three digits identify the investment’s primary service area from the
-FEA BRM version 3.0.
+Soft launch
-XXX (secondary services)
+Jan. 20, 2026
-The second, third, fourth, and fifth set of three digits identify the investment’s
-secondary service area(s) from the FEA BRM version 3.0. Agencies should
-select from the following three-digit codes to map investments to primary and
-secondary service areas.
+Jan. 22, 2026
-53.5 What are the steps to complete Exhibit 53?
+Jan. 24, 2026
-Exhibit 53 is separated into four sub-exhibits. The following table provides step-by-step instructions to
-complete each part. See Section 4 and 53.3 for definitions.
+Full launch
-AGENCY IT INVESTMENT PORTFOLIO
+Jan. 21, 2026
-Entry
+Jan. 22, 2026
-Description
+Jan. 24, 2026
-Part 1. IT Investments for
-Mission Delivery Area
-and Management Support
-Area
+Initial invitation
-Report IT investments that directly support an agency-designated mission
-delivery and management support area as well as the mission delivery and
-management support area it supports. This information should map directly to
-your agency's strategic and annual performance plan. For IT investments that
-cover more than one agency, report in the mission area with oversight of the IT
-investment. Mission delivery and management support area 01 is reserved for IT
-investments for major financial management systems.
+First reminder
-Page 21 of 45 Exhibit 53
+Final reminder
- (2012)
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
+Panelists participating online were sent an email invitation and up to two email reminders if they
+did not respond to the survey. ATP panelists who consented to SMS messages were sent an SMS
+invitation with a link to the survey and up to two SMS reminders.
-IT investments for infrastructure, IT security, office automation, and
-telecommunications are reported in Part 2 of Exhibit 53A. Report all IT
-investments supporting common user systems, security, communications, and
-computing infrastructure. Each agency may have multiple Exhibit 300s
-encompassing office automation, infrastructure, IT security, and
-telecommunications for the agency. It is encouraged that these investments be
-reported at the point of management and thus may be defined at the bureau level
-and/or by functional components of the infrastructure. These may involve
-multiple mission areas and include end-user systems and support, mainframes
-and servers services and support, and telecommunications services and support.
-All IT investments capturing these shared services are to be included in Part 2.
+For panelists who take surveys over the phone with a live interviewer: Prenotification
+postcards were mailed on Jan. 16. Soft launch took place on Jan. 20 and involved dialing until a
+total of four interviews had been completed. All remaining English- and Spanish-speaking
+sampled phone panelists’ numbers were dialed throughout the remaining field period. Panelists
+who take surveys via phone can receive up to six calls from trained SSRS interviewers.
-List all EA, IT capital planning, and CIO function investments. For the
-President's Budget, EA, IT capital planning, and CIO function investments are
-not categorized as major investments and an Exhibit 300 is not required for them.
-Any capital planning and investment control process investments may be
-reported separately in this section. However, agencies should ensure that
-investments identified in variable information coding as belonging in Part 3 of
-Exhibit 53A have the correct primary FEA mapping in order to clearly
-distinguish the EA investments from other planning investments.
+Data quality checks
-Report IT investments that support grants management operations. See
-classification instructions in Section 53.3a under Grants Management.
+To ensure high-quality data, Center researchers performed data quality checks to identify any
+respondents showing patterns of satisficing. This includes checking for whether respondents left
+questions blank at very high rates or always selected the first or last answer presented. As a result
+of this checking, two ATP respondents were removed from the survey dataset prior to weighting
+and analysis.
-Part 2. IT Investments for
-Infrastructure, IT
-Security, Office
-Automation, and
-Telecommunications
+3 The ATP does not use routers or chains in any part of its online data collection protocol, nor are they used to direct respondents to additional
+surveys.
+4 Postcard notifications for web panelists are sent to 1) panelists who were recruited within the last two years and 2) panelists recruited prior
+to the last two years who opt to continue receiving postcard notifications.
-Part 3. IT Investments for
-EA, Capital Planning, and
-CIO Functions
+www.pewresearch.org
-Part 4. IT Investments for
-Grants Management
-Systems
+17
-Part 5. National Security
-Systems IT Investments
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Report IT investments related to national security systems (Department of
-Defense only).
+American Trends Panel weighting dimensions
-Part 6. Grants to State
-and Local IT Investments
+Variable
+Age (detailed)
+Age x Gender
+Education x Gender
+Education x Age
+Race/Ethnicity x Education
+Race/Ethnicity x Gender
+Race/Ethnicity x Age
+Born inside vs. outside the U.S. among
+Hispanics and Asian Americans
+Years lived in the U.S.
+Census region x Metropolitan status
-Report total amounts for IT investments for grants to state and local
-governments.
+Volunteerism
-Page 22 of 45 Exhibit 53
+Frequency of internet use
+Religious affiliation
+Party affiliation x Race/Ethnicity
+Party affiliation x Age
- (2012)
+Validated 2024 presidential election
+turnout and vote choice
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
+Benchmark source
-AGENCY IT INVESTMENT PORTFOLIO (COLUMNS)
+2023 American Community Survey
+(ACS)
-The following columns are required for the President's Budget Exhibit 53A, Agency IT Investment Portfolio:
+2023 CPS Volunteering & Civic Life
+Supplement
+2025 National Public Opinion
+Reference Survey (NPORS)
-Column 1: Previous UII (12 digits required for all legacy investments)
+Candidate vote share is based on
+official results from the Federal
+Election Commission. Turnout is
+based on estimates from the Election
+Lab at the University of Florida. The
+size of the voting-eligible population is
+based on the 2023 ACS.
-Column 2: Current UII (12-digit primary key for all investments)
+Note: Estimates from the ACS are based on noninstitutionalized adults. For weighting to the
+2024 presidential election results, panelists are considered validated voters if their self-
+report of having voted was confirmed after matching to a national voter registry.
-Column 3: Investment Category (2-digit code)
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Column 4: Bureau Code (2-digit code) (variable element)
+Weighting
-Column 5: Part of Exhibit 53 (2-digit code) (variable element)
+The ATP data is weighted in a
+process that accounts for
+multiple stages of sampling and
+nonresponse that occur at
+different points in the panel
+survey process. First, each
+panelist begins with a base
+weight that reflects their
+probability of recruitment into
+the panel. These weights are
+then calibrated to align with the
+population benchmarks in the
+accompanying table to correct
+for nonresponse to recruitment
+surveys and panel attrition. If
+only a subsample of panelists
+was invited to participate in the
+wave, this weight is adjusted to
+account for any differential
+probabilities of selection.
+Because respondents to this
+wave were sampled from
+among respondents to Wave
+183, the weights were also
+adjusted to account for
+nonresponse to Wave 183.
-Column 6: Mission Delivery and Management Support Area (2-digit code) (variable element)
+Among the panelists who completed the survey, this weight is then calibrated again to align with
+the population benchmarks identified in the accompanying table and trimmed at the 1st and 99th
+percentiles to reduce the loss in precision stemming from variance in the weights. Sampling errors
+and tests of statistical significance take into account the effect of weighting.
-Column 7: Type of Investment (2-digit code) (variable element)
+www.pewresearch.org
-Column 8: Line Item Descriptor (2-digit code) (variable element)
+18
-Column 9: Change in Investment Status Identifier (2-digit code)
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Column 10: Agency Description of Change in Investment Status (limited to 255 characters)
+The following table shows the unweighted sample sizes and the error attributable to sampling that
+would be expected at the 95% level of confidence for different groups in the survey.
-Column 11: Investment Title
+Sample sizes and margins of error, ATP Wave 185
-Column 12: Investment Description (limited to 255 characters)
+Group
+Total sample
-Column 13: FEA BRM Services – Primary service area (3-digit code)
+ Half form
-Column 14: FEA BRM Services – Secondary service area #1 (3-digit code)
+Rep/Lean Rep
-Column 15: FEA BRM Services – Secondary service area #2 (3-digit code)
+ Half form
-Column 16: FEA BRM Services – Secondary service area #3 (3-digit code)
+Dem/Lean Dem
-Column 17: FEA BRM Services – Secondary service area #4 (3-digit code)
+ Half form
-Column 18: Homeland Security Priority Identifier (select all that apply)
+Unweighted
+sample size
+8,512
-Column 19: HSPD-12 Cost (PY/2012) ($M)
+At least 4,250
-Column 20: Cross-Boundary Information Identifier (1-digit code)
+3,913
-Column 21: Supports Information Sharing, Access, and Safeguarding (select all that apply)
+At least 1,953
-Column 22: DME [Planning, Development/Capital Spending] (PY/2012) Agency Funding ($M)
+4,343
-Column 23: DME [Planning, Development/Capital Spending] (PY/2012) Contributions ($M)
+At least 2,164
-Column 24: DME [Planning, Development/Capital Spending] (CY/2013) Agency Funding ($M)
+Weighted %
-Column 25: DME [Planning, Development/Capital Spending] (CY/2013) Contributions ($M)
+46%
-Column 26: DME [Planning, Development/Capital Spending] (BY/2014) Agency Funding ($M)
+48%
-Column 27: DME [Planning, Development/Capital Spending] (BY/2014) Contributions ($M)
+Plus or minus …
+1.4 percentage points
-Column 28: O&M Spending [non-DME] (PY/2012) Agency Funding ($M)
+2.0 percentage points
-Column 29: O&M Spending [non-DME] (PY/2012) Contributions ($M)
+2.1 percentage points
-Column 30: O&M Spending [non-DME] (CY/2013) Agency Funding ($M)
+3.0 percentage points
-Column 31: O&M Spending [non-DME] (CY/2013) Contributions ($M)
+2.0 percentage points
-Column 32: O&M Spending [non-DME] (BY/2014) Agency Funding ($M)
+2.8 percentage points
-Column 33: O&M Spending [non-DME] (BY/2014) Contributions ($M)
+Note: This survey includes oversamples of non-Hispanic Asian adults and adults ages 18-to-29 respondents. Unweighted
+sample sizes do not account for the sample design or weighting and do not describe a group’s contribution to weighted
+estimates. See the Sample design and Weighting sections above for details.
-Column 34: Number of Government FTEs (BY/2014)
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Column 35: Percentage of Investment Cost for Government FTE (BY/2014)
+Sample sizes and sampling errors for other subgroups are available upon request. In addition to
+sampling error, one should bear in mind that question wording and practical difficulties in
+conducting surveys can introduce error or bias into the findings of opinion polls.
-Column 36: Functional/Business Sponsor Name
+www.pewresearch.org
-Column 37: Functional/Business Sponsor Title
+19
-Column 38: Functional/Business Sponsor Phone Number
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Column 39: Functional/Business Sponsor E-mail
+Dispositions and response rates
-Column 40: Cloud Computing Alternatives Evaluation
+Final dispositions, ATP Wave 185
-Column 41: Cloud Computing Spending (PY)
+Completed interview
-Column 42: Cloud Computing Spending (CY)
-Column 43: Cloud Computing Spending (BY)
+Logged in (web) / Contacted (CATI), but did not complete any items
-Page 23 of 45 Exhibit 53
+Started survey; broke off before completion
- (2012)
+Never logged on (web) / Never reached on phone (CATI)
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
+Survey completed after close of the field period
-AGENCY IT SECURITY PORTFOLIO (Exhibit 53B)
+Other non-interview
-Row
+Completed interview but was removed for data quality
-Description
+Total panelists sampled for the survey
-1 Agency code
+Completed interviews
-2 Number of government
-FTEs with information
-security responsibilities
+Partial interviews
-3 Average cost per
+Refusals
-government FTE with
-information security
-responsibilities
+Non-contact
-4 Number of contractor
-FTEs with information
-security responsibilities
+Other
-5
+Unknown household
-6
+Unknown other
-Average cost per
-contractor FTE for
-information security
-responsibilities
+Not eligible
-Total IT security tools
-cost
+Total
-List the three-digit agency identifier (see Appendix C of OMB Circular A-
-11).
+AAPOR RR1 = I / (I+P+R+NC+O+UH+UO)
-Report the number of government employees with information security
-responsibilities, including the fractional portion of those who devote a
-percentage of their time to these responsibilities. This number should
-include but should not be limited to: designated security officers, network
-security staff, system administrators, and system owners. The number
-should not include individuals responsible for physical security, such as
-guards. The number should be rounded to two decimal places.
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Using the salary information of the government employees counted in
-“Number of government FTEs with information security responsibilities,”
-calculate an average fully loaded cost per government FTE. The average
-cost should be represented in dollars and rounded to two decimal places.
+Cumulative response rate, ATP Wave 185
-Report the number of contractor staff with information security
-responsibilities, including the fractional portion of those who devote a
-percentage of their time to these responsibilities. The number should be
-rounded to two decimal places.
+Weighted response rate to recruitment surveys
-Using the billing rate of the contract staff counted in “Number of contractor
-FTEs with information security responsibilities,” calculate an average
-yearly cost per contractor FTE. The average cost should be represented in
-dollars and rounded to two decimal places.
+% of recruitment survey respondents who agreed to join the
+panel, among those invited
+% of those agreeing to join who were active panelists at start of
+Wave 185
-This is the sum of the following eight data elements, which were formerly
-provided separately in Exhibit 53B for the FY 2012 Budget cycle. Costs
-should be reported in thousands and reported to the dollar.
+Response rate to Wave 183 survey
-1. Anti-Virus Software Licensing Costs – The licensing costs incurred
+Response rate to Wave 185 survey
-or expected to be incurred for the respective BY. If an agency does not
-purchase anti-virus software separately from anti-malware software,
-enter all costs on the line for anti-malware and leave this line blank.
+Cumulative response rate
-2. Anti-Malware Software Licensing Costs – The licensing costs
-incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY.
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-3. Intrusion Detection Systems Licensing Costs – The licensing costs
+© Pew Research Center 2025
-incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY. If you have
-an IDS which is part of an IPS, include all costs in IPS and do not list
-here. Include the amount paid for the Managed Trusted Internet
-Protocol Service via the Networx contract as well as any other
-operational IDSs.
+www.pewresearch.org
-4. Intrusion Prevention Systems Licensing Costs – The licensing costs
+Total
-incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY.
-5. Web Filtering Software Licensing Costs – The licensing costs
+8,512
-incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY. Costs should
-be reported in thousands and reported to the dollar.
+145
-Page 24 of 45 Exhibit 53
+100
- (2012)
+541
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
+0
-6. E-mail Filtering Software – The licensing costs incurred or expected
-to be incurred for the respective BY. If an agency does not purchase e-
-mail filtering software separate from web filtering software, include all
-costs in web filtering software and do not list here.
+2
-7. SIM/SIEM Tools – Report the tool costs incurred or expected to be
+2
-incurred for the respective BY.
+9,302
-8. Data Leakage Protection Tools – Report the tool costs incurred or
+8,514
-expected to be incurred for the respective BY.
+0
-Report the costs incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY.
-Costs should be reported in thousands and reported to the dollar. Security
-authorization costs should only include contract costs.
+245
-Report the number of systems used to in cost calculations for “Costs for
-NIST 800-37 implementation.”
+541
-Report the costs incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY.
-Costs should be reported in thousands and reported to the dollar. Include all
-costs, including licensing of tools, services, and FTEs.
+4
-Report the costs incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY.
-Costs should be reported in thousands and reported to the dollar. Include all
-costs, including licensing of tools, services, and FTEs.
+0
-Report the costs incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY.
-Costs should be reported in thousands and reported to the dollar. Include
-the costs of annual security awareness training required by the FISMA Act.
+0
-Report the costs incurred or expected to be incurred for the respective BY.
-Costs should be reported in thousands and reported to the dollar. Do not
-include costs associated with annual awareness training.
+0
-Report the number of government employees with information security
-responsibilities, including the fractional portion of those who devote a
-percentage of their time to the responsibilities included in the costs reported
-in row 7 and rows 9 through 12. The associated government FTE costs
-(based on the average costs reported in row 3) will be subtracted from the
-total IT security cost to avoid any double-counting.
+9,302
-Report the number of contractor staff with information security
-responsibilities, including the fractional portion of those who devote a
-percentage of their time to the responsibilities included in the costs reported
-in row 7 and rows 9 through 12. The associated contractor FTE costs
-(based on the average costs reported in row 5) will be subtracted from the
-total IT security cost to avoid any double-counting.
+92%
-7 Costs for NIST 800-37
-implementation
+AAPOR code
-8 Number of systems
+1.1
-scheduled for activities
-represented in Row 7
+2.11
-9 Costs for annual FISMA
+2.12
-testing
+2.20
-10 Costs for network
-penetration testing
-activities
+2.27
-11 Security awareness
-training costs
+2.30
-12 Security training costs for
+2.90
-employees with
-significant security
-responsibilities
+I
-13 Number of government
+P
-FTEs included in costs for
-row 7 and rows 9 through
+R
+
+NC
+
+O
+
+UH
+
+UO
+
+NE
+
+Total
+
+12%
+
+74%
+
+40%
+
+92%
+
+92%
+
+3%
+
+20
+
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
+
+2026 PEW RESEARCH CENTER’S AMERICAN TRENDS PANEL
+WAVE 185 POLITICS JANUARY SURVEY
+FINAL TOPLINE
+January 20-26, 2026
+N=8,512
+
+Note: This survey was conducted primarily online, with some interviews conducted by live telephone. This
+topline shows the programming language for online administration. For details on how questions were slightly
+modified for phone administration, visit the questionnaire.
+
+American Trends Panel surveys conducted between October 2016 and June 2024 were conducted fully online
+(with tablets and data plans provided to adults without home internet). American Trends Panel surveys
+conducted prior to October 2016 were conducted primarily online, with some respondents completing by mail.
+For additional details, visit the Methodology.
+
+* ”No answer” includes web respondents who do not answer the question as well as telephone respondents
+who refuse to answer or who say that they don’t know how to answer. In cases where “not sure” was offered
+as an explicit option to web and telephone respondents, the “no answer” category includes only web skips and
+telephone refusals.
+
+ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,250]:
+SATIS All in all, are you satisfied or dissatisfied with the way things are going in this country today?
+
+Jan 20-26, 2026
+Oct 6-16, 2025
+Aug 4-10, 2025
+Apr 28-May 4, 2025
+Mar 10-16, 2025
+Jan 27-Feb 2, 2025
+Nov 12-17, 2024
+Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024
+Aug 5-11, 2024
+Jul 1-7, 2024
+May 13-19, 2024
+Jan 16-21, 2024
+Nov 27-Dec 3, 2023
+Jul 10-16, 2023
+Jun 5-11, 2023
+Mar 27-Apr 2, 2023
+Jan 18-24, 2023
+Nov 16-27, 2022
+Oct 10-16, 2022
+Aug 1-14, 2022
+Apr 25-May 1, 2022
+Jan 10-17, 2022
+Sep 20-26, 2021
+Sep 13-19, 2021
+Mar 1-7, 2021
+Nov 12-17, 2020
+Sep 30-Oct 5, 2020
+Jul 27-Aug 2, 2020
+
+Satisfied
+29
+27
+34
+32
+34
+38
+29
+23
+24
+18
+22
+21
+22
+22
+21
+19
+22
+24
+21
+18
+24
+21
+25
+26
+33
+22
+18
12
-14 Number of contractor
-
-FTEs included in costs for
-row 7 and rows 9 through
+Dissatisfied
+69
+72
+65
+67
+65
+61
+70
+76
+75
+82
+78
+78
+77
+77
+78
+80
+78
+75
+79
+81
+75
+78
+74
+74
+66
+77
+82
+87
+
+No answer*
+1
+1
+1
+1
+1
+1
+1
+*
+1
+*
+1
+1
+1
+1
+1
+1
+*
+1
+1
+1
+1
+1
+1
+*
+1
+1
+1
+1
+
+www.pewresearch.org
+
+21
+
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
+
+SATIS CONTINUED …
+
+Jun 16-22, 2020
+Apr 7-12, 2020
+Mar 19-24, 2020
+Oct 29-Nov 11, 2019
+Oct 1-13, 2019
+Jul 22-Aug 4, 2019
+Nov 27-Dec 10, 2018
+Jan 29-Feb 13, 2018
+Feb 28-Mar 12, 20175
+Sep 27-Oct 10, 2016
+Jun 7-Jul 5, 2016
+Sep 15-Oct 3, 2014
+
+Satisfied
12
+31
+33
+31
+28
+27
+34
+36
+32
+23
+19
+25
+
+Dissatisfied
+87
+68
+66
+69
+71
+72
+65
+63
+68
+75
+80
+75
+
+No answer*
+1
+1
+1
+1
+1
+1
+1
+1
+*
+2
+1
+*
+
+ASK FORM 2 ONLY [N=4,262]:
+YEARAHEAD
+
+Looking ahead, as far as you are concerned, do you think that 2026 will be …
+[ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-2/2-1]
+
+Better than 2025 Worse than 2025
+
+Jan 20-26, 2026
+Jan 27-Feb 2, 2025
+Jan 16-21, 2024
+Jan 18-24, 2023
+Jan 10-17, 2022
+Jan 8-12, 2021
+Jan 6-19, 2020
+
+50
+55
+55
+57
+61
+67
+55
+
+48
+45
+45
+43
+38
+32
+43
+
+No answer*
+1
+*
+1
+*
+1
+1
+2
+
+PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON:
+Looking ahead, as far as you are concerned, do you think that [coming year] will be better or worse
+than [prior year]?
+
+Jan 8-13, 2020
+Jan 9-14, 2019
+Jan 10-15, 2018
+Jan 4-9, 2017
+Jan 7-14, 2016
+Dec 3-7, 2014 (U)
+Jan 15-19, 2014
+Dec 5-9, 2012
+Jan 11-16, 2012
+Dec 1-5, 2010
+Jan 6-10, 2010
+Jan 7-11, 2009
+December, 2007
+December, 2006
+December, 1999
+December, 1998
+December, 1994
+Gallup: December, 1993
+
+Better
+55
+47
+61
+49
+56
+49
+56
+55
+57
+55
+67
+52
+50
+57
+66
+59
+59
+64
+
+Worse
+34
+43
+29
+42
+30
+42
+35
+36
+29
+31
+26
+37
+34
+28
+19
+25
+28
+20
+
+(VOL.)
+DK/Ref
+11
+10
+11
+9
+14
+9
+9
+9
+14
+14
+8
+11
+16
+15
+15
+16
+13
+16
+
+1
+
+The W24.5 Mode Study survey was administered by web and phone. Results reported here are from web mode only.
+
+www.pewresearch.org
+
+22
+
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
+
+PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON CONTINUED
+
+Gallup: December, 1992
+Gallup: December, 1991
+Gallup: December, 1990
+Gallup: December, 1986
+Gallup: December, 1985
+Gallup: December, 1984
+Gallup: December, 1982
+Gallup: December, 1981
+
+Better
+61
+61
+48
+53
+64
+61
+50
+41
+
+Worse
+11
+31
+42
+25
+20
+20
+32
+44
+
+(VOL.)
+DK/Ref
+28
+8
+10
+22
+17
+19
+18
+15
+
+ASK ALL:
+POL1DT
+ASK IF ANSWERED POL1DT (POL1DT=1,2) [N=8,378]:
+POL1DTSTR
+
+Do you approve or disapprove of the way Donald Trump is handling his job as president?
+
+Do you [IF POL1DT=1: approve; IF POL1DT=2: disapprove] of the way Donald Trump is
+handling his job as president…
+
+NET
+Approve
+
+Very
+strongly
+
+Not so
+strongly
+
+No
+answer*
+
+NET
+Disapprove
+
+Very
+strongly
+
+Not so
+strongly
+
+No
+answer*
+
+No
+answer*
+
+Trump Second Term
+Jan 20-26, 2026
+Sep 22-28, 2025
+Aug 4-10, 2025
+Jun 2-8, 2025
+Apr 7-13, 2025
+Jan 27-Feb 2, 2025
+
+Trump First Term
+Jan 8-12, 2021
+Jul 27-Aug 2, 2020
+Jun 16-22, 2020
+Apr 7-12, 2020
+Mar 19-24, 2020
+Jan 6-19, 2020
+Sep 3-15, 2019
+Jul 22-Aug 4, 2019
+Apr 29-May 13, 2019
+Feb 4-17, 2019
+Nov 7-13, 2018
+Sep 24-Oct 7, 2018
+Jul 30-Aug 12, 2018
+Jan 29-Feb 13, 2018
+Aug 8-21, 2017
+Apr 4-18, 2017
+Feb 28-Mar 12, 20176
+
+37
+40
+38
+41
+40
+47
+
+29
+38
+39
+44
+45
+40
+40
+40
+40
+38
+41
+38
+40
+38
+36
+39
+44
+
+27
+29
+27
+30
+31
+37
+
+21
+n/a
+29
+33
+34
+31
+31
+n/a
+29
+n/a
+n/a
+n/a
+31
+29
+26
+27
+30
+
+10
+10
+11
+11
+9
+9
+
+7
+n/a
+9
+10
+10
+9
+9
+n/a
+10
+n/a
+n/a
+n/a
+9
+9
+10
+12
+13
+
+*
+1
+*
+*
+*
+*
+
+*
+n/a
+1
+1
+1
+*
+*
+n/a
+*
+n/a
+n/a
+n/a
+*
+*
+*
+*
+*
+
+61
+58
+60
+58
+59
+51
+
+68
+59
+59
+53
+52
+58
+58
+59
+59
+61
+58
+61
+59
+60
+63
+61
+56
+
+49
+47
+47
+46
+48
+40
+
+56
+n/a
+48
+42
+40
+46
+46
+n/a
+48
+n/a
+n/a
+n/a
+48
+48
+49
+45
+43
-Note: Exhibit 53B should not include security costs typically embedded in IT investments, such as destruction
-of data (e.g., degaussing, shredding), physical or logical access control software, continuous monitoring
-software, tracking and reporting software, and annual disaster recovery and contingency plan tests.
-
-Page 25 of 45 Exhibit 53
-
- (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
-
-AGENCY CLOUD COMPUTING PORTFOLIO (Exhibit 53C)
-
-(a) Agency costs for cloud computing by deployment model, by year (Dollars in millions)
-
-PY
-
-CY
-
-BY
-
-Public Cloud
-
-Private Cloud
-
-Community Cloud
-
-Hybrid Cloud
-
-(b) Agency costs for cloud computing by service model, by year (Dollars in millions)
-
-PY
-
-CY
-
-BY
-
-SaaS
-
-PaaS
-
-IaaS
-
-Note: Exhibit 53C should describe agency funding for IT investments, not agency contributions. The sum of
-all cells in Table (a) should equal the sum of all cells in Table (b) and should equal the sum of columns 41 to
-43 in Exhibit 53A.
-
-Page 26 of 45 Exhibit 53
-
- (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
-
-AGENCY IT REDUCTIONS AND REINVESTMENTS (Exhibit 53D)
-
-When properly managed and applied, IT can create efficiencies, reduce costs, improve service delivery, and
-strengthen cybersecurity. But, too often spending on IT is still wasted on duplicative investments, missed
-opportunities to leverage economies of scale, rising operational costs that starve new development, and
-mismanaged projects that lead to cost overruns and schedule slippages.
-
-To address this issue, OMB Memorandum M-12-13 included guidance on IT reductions and reinvestments
-that agencies should reflect in their FY 2014 budget submission. In accordance with the memorandum, this
-section provides more specific guidance on how this information should be reflected in agency budgets,
-including additional detail on the nature of cuts and reinvestments and detailed reporting instructions.
-
-Agencies should propose reductions in IT that represent 10% of their overall spending, and propose a
-reinvestment of at least 5%, and up to 10%, of these savings, in priority IT investments for OMB
-consideration. To do this, agencies are required to report the specific investments in which they propose cuts
-and the specific investments in which they propose to reinvest funds.
-
-(a) What Agencies Will Provide
-
-As part of their FY 2014 budget submission, agencies are asked to complete the new Exhibit 53D (a
-downloadable template is available on OMB MAX; final submission will be made via OMB MAX). This
-new exhibit will allow agencies to show how they achieved the 10% reduction called for in the memorandum,
-and where they propose to reinvest some of these savings. The template, OMB MAX data collection exercise,
-and detailed technical instructions are available here.
-
-Please use the following guidelines when providing specific data on the proposed cuts and reinvestments from
-FY 2013 to FY 2014:
-
- Agencies should provide the following for each cut and reinvestment:
-o Specific IT investments and OMB accounts impacted,
-o Related category of the cut or reinvestment (provided in MAX exercise) and explanation,
-o Priority level and a description of the return on investment (reinvestments only);
-
-
-
-Information supplied in Exhibit 53D should be consistent with information supplied in Exhibits 53A,
-B and C, and Exhibits 300A and B;
-
- Agencies should include, in their FY 2014 budget submissions to OMB, a summary of all the
-information provided in Exhibit 53D, and the general approach the agency took to achieve its
-reductions and reinvestments; and
-
- Reductions and reinvestments apply Department-wide and should not solely target investments from
-
-agency-level IT or administrative accounts.
-
-(b) What Agencies Should Cut
-
-Regarding required reductions, OMB M-12-13 states “…include an explanation of how, at the investment and
-account level, you would achieve this reduction.”
-
-The 10% cuts should reduce agency spending in the following IT areas:
-
- Duplicative commodity IT investments or contracts (as emphasized in PortfolioStat and consistent
-
-with OMB Memoranda M-11-29 and M-12-10) include:
-
-IT infrastructure (e.g. data centers, networks, desktops, and/or mobile devices)
-
-o
-o Enterprise IT systems (e.g. email, help desk, collaboration, identify and access management,
-
-security and web infrastructure)
-
-o Business systems (e.g. HR, FM, and other administrative functions);
- Underperforming projects/investments of any type (as emphasized in TechStats); or
-
-Page 27 of 45 Exhibit 53
-
- (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
-
- Lower-value or lower-priority investments of any type.
-
-Exemptions from the 10% reduction target must be explicitly granted by OMB.
-
-(c) Where Agencies Should Reinvest
-
-Regarding reinvestments, OMB M-12-13, states “your budget submission may also propose where you would
-reinvest the savings from identified cuts in innovative IT solutions that would produce a favorable return on
-investment within 18 months or demonstrably improve citizen services or administrative efficiencies”
-
-Agencies should propose 10% cuts in IT and then propose a list of priority reinvestments to OMB up to the
-10%. If the Agency does not propose to reinvest at least 5% of these savings into IT, the agency is required to
-provide a justification explaining as to why it is unable to propose these reinvestments. Agencies should only
-propose reinvestments which demonstrate a favorable return on investment (quantitative or qualitative) to the
-agency within 18 months from the enactment of FY 2014 appropriations (excluding CRs).
-
-Proposed reinvestments should be in the following areas:
-
-Improvements to citizen services or administrative efficiencies;
-
-
- Adoption of shared services;
- Consolidation of commodity IT, including optimizing data centers;
-
-
-
-
-Improvements to the security posture of the agency’s IT and information assets;
-Improvements to the energy efficiency of IT facilities and equipment;
-Innovative investments consistent with policy initiatives such as cloud computing, modular
-development, reduction of improper payments, and digital government; or
-
- Data analytics or data management consistent with Administration priorities in Big Data.
-
-(d) How Much Agencies Should Cut Before Reinvesting
-
-Regarding the level of reductions, OMB M-12-13, states “…your 2014 budget submission should achieve an
-agency-wide 10% reduction in IT spending, compared to the average spending on IT from FY 2010 through
-2012”
-
-The table below shows the effects of the FY 2014 Budget policy for IT spending. Note that while the cut is
-calculated as 10% of the average total IT spend from FY 2010-2012, the FY (before proposed reinvestments)
-target is reached by applying the cut to the revised FY 2013 President's Budget level (as reported to the IT
-Dashboard by agencies in May 2012).
-
-FY 2013
-(President's
-Budget as
-of May
-2012)
-
-FY 2014
-10%
-Reduction
-(2010-
-2012)
-
-$2,611
-$2,396
-$32,669
-$552
-$2,016
-$7,102
-$5,629
-
-$252
-$259
-$3,509
-$61
-$205
-$662
-$587
-
-Average
- (2010-
-2012)
-$2,524
-$2,589
-$35,086
-$613
-$2,053
-$6,617
-$5,868
-
-FY 2014
-Target
-(before
-reinvestment)
-$2,359
-$2,137
-$29,161
-$491
-$1,811
-$6,440
-$5,042
-
-FY 2014
-Minimum
-(5%)
-reinvestment
-$126
-$129
-$1,754
-$31
-$103
-$331
-$293
-
-FY 2014
-Maximum
-(10%)
-reinvestment
-$252
-$259
-$3,509
-$61
-$205
-$662
-$587
-
-Agency
-USDA
-Commerce
-DOD
-ED
-Energy
-HHS
-DHS
-
-Page 28 of 45 Exhibit 53
-
- (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 53—INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PORTFOLIO
-
-HUD
-Interior
-Justice
-Labor
-State
-USAID
-DOT
-Treasury
-VA
-USACE
-EPA
-GSA
-NASA
-NARA
-NSF
-NRC
-OPM
-SBA
-SI
-SSA
-
-$385
-$988
-$2,850
-$591
-$1,420
-$133
-$2,990
-$3,271
-$3,163
-$544
-$461
-$622
-$1,740
-$137
-$97
-$160
-$78
-$113
-$65
-$1,548
-$76,706
-
-$354
-$965
-$2,655
-$606
-$1,369
-$140
-$3,092
-$3,495
-$3,327
-$566
-$465
-$631
-$1,462
-$100
-$97
-$151
-$73
-$112
-$68
-$1,380
-$74,083
-
-$38
-$99
-$285
-$59
-$142
-$13
-$299
-$327
-$316
-$54
-$46
-$62
-$174
-$14
-$10
-$16
-$8
-$11
-$6
-$155
-$7,669
-
-$316
-$866
-$2,370
-$547
-$1,227
-$127
-$2,793
-$3,168
-$3,011
-$512
-$419
-$569
-$1,288
-$86
-$88
-$135
-$65
-$100
-$61
-$1,226
-$66,415
-
-$19
-$49
-$142
-$30
-$71
-$7
-$149
-$164
-$158
-$31
-$23
-$31
-$87
-$7
-$5
-$8
-$4
-$6
-$3
-$77
-$3,838
-
-$38
-$99
-$285
-$59
-$142
-$13
-$299
-$327
-$316
-$54
-$46
-$62
-$174
-$14
-$10
-$16
-$8
-$11
-$6
-$155
-$7,669
-
-Page 29 of 45 Exhibit 53
-
- (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT
-OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY CAPITAL ASSETS
-
-300.1 What is the purpose of this guidance?
-
-OMB provides specific policy, procedural, and analytic guidelines for planning, budgeting, acquisition, and
-management of major IT capital investments in addition to general guidance issued in OMB Circular A-11 and
-OMB Circular A-130.
-
-Exhibit 300 describes the justification, planning, and implementation of an individual capital asset included in the
-agency IT investment portfolio (as reported in Exhibit 53) and serves as a key artifact of the agency’s EA and IT
-CPIC processes. Exhibit 300 is comprised of two components—Exhibit 300A provides inherent investment
-information, including general information and planning for resources such as staffing and personnel. Exhibit
-300B provides more temporal information, such as projects and activities, risks, and operational performance of
-the investment.
-
-Together, Exhibits 53 and 300 provide the budgetary and management information necessary for sound planning,
-management, and governance of IT investments. These documents help agencies explicitly align IT investments
-with strategic and performance goals, and ultimately provide value to the public by making investment and
-management information more transparent. As architecture-driven IT investments are funded in the "Invest"
-phase, they move forward into the implementation phase where system development life cycle processes are
-followed and actual outputs, schedule, and operational performance expenditures are tracked versus planned
-numbers using performance-based management processes.
-
-300.2
-
- Does Exhibit 300 apply to my agency or IT investment?
-
-The policy and budget justification principles in Exhibit 300 apply to all agencies of the Executive Branch of the
-Federal Government that are subject to Executive Branch review (see Section 25 of OMB Circular A-11). In
-accordance with section 5, Exhibits 300A and B must be submitted for each major IT investment. Major IT
-investments must be reported on the agency’s Exhibit 53A, along with all non-major investments.
-
-300.3 How will agencies manage IT capital assets/investments?
-
-The Capital Programming Guide of OMB Circular A-11 provides guidance on the principles and techniques for
-effective capital programming. OMB Circular A-11, Appendix J explains the principles of financing capital asset
-acquisitions. Section 8b of OMB Circular A-130 establishes additional requirements for EAs, planning and
-control of information systems and IT investments, and performance management. Agencies must develop and
-implement a capital programming process to develop their capital asset portfolio and must:
-
- Evaluate and select capital assets that will support core mission functions performed by the Federal
-
-Government and which demonstrate projected returns on investment that are clearly equal to or better
-than alternative uses of available public resources. Specifically for IT, the investments should be
-informed by and should address performance gaps and goals identified in an agency’s strategic plan,
-annual performance plan, and EA;
-Initiate improvements to existing assets or acquisitions of new assets only when no alternative private
-sector or governmental source can more efficiently meet the need;
-Implement IT reforms from the 25 Point Implementation Plan to Reform Federal Information Technology
-Management, such as adhering to modular development principles and the requirement to establish an
-IPT prior to funding an IT investment;
-
-
-
-
-
- Simplify or otherwise redesign work processes to reduce costs, improve effectiveness, and maximize the
-
-use of commercial services and off-the-shelf technology;
-
- Assign a functional/business sponsor for each investment who is responsible for the program or
-function supported or implemented by the investment. The sponsor is responsible for expressing the
-
-Page 30 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS
-
-value of, ensuring successful implementation of, and providing accurate and timely data for the IT
-investment to the agency CIO and OMB. Each major and non-major investment listed in Exhibit 53 must
-include the name of the functional/business sponsor, title, phone number, and e-mail address;
-
- Reduce project risk by avoiding or isolating custom-designed components, using components that can be
-fully tested or prototyped prior to full implementation or production, and ensuring involvement and
-support of users in the design and testing of the asset;
-
- Structure major planning and acquisition into useful segments with a narrow scope and brief duration.
-These segments should make adequate use of competition and appropriately allocate risk between the
-Federal Government and contractor. The agency head must approve or define the cost, schedule, and
-performance goals for major acquisitions, and the agency's Chief Financial Officer must evaluate the
-proposed cost goals;
-
- Ensure a continuous linkage between Federal, agency, and bureau EAs, demonstrating such consistency
-
-
-
-through alignment with the agency’s Enterprise Roadmap and target architecture, compliance with agency
-business requirements and standards, as well as identification of milestones, as defined in the agency’s
-EA transition strategy;
-Institute performance measures and management processes to monitor and compare actual performance to
-planned results. Agencies must use a performance-based acquisition management system or EVMS,
-based on the ANSI/EIA Standard 748-B, to obtain timely information regarding the progress of capital
-investments, as defined in the Federal Acquisition Regulations (FAR). The system must also measure
-progress towards useful components in an independently verifiable basis in terms of cost, capability of the
-investment to meet specified requirements, timeliness, and quality;
-
- Per requirements of Federal Acquisition Streamlining Act of 1994 (FASA, Title V), agencies are expected
-to achieve, on average, 90 percent of the cost, schedule, and performance goals for major acquisitions.
-Through the TechStat process and as part of the Clinger-Cohen Act responsibly, Agency CIOs should
-review major acquisitions that have not achieved 90 percent of the goals to determine whether there is a
-continuing need and what corrective action, including termination, should be taken;
-
- Ensure that the planning and management of agency assets that are IT systems conform to the
-requirements of OMB Circular A-130, “Management of Federal Information Resources”;
-
- Ensure that agency assets that are financial management systems conform to the requirements of OMB
+12
+11
+13
+12
+10
+11
-Circular A-127;
+12
+n/a
+11
+11
+11
+11
+11
+n/a
+10
+n/a
+n/a
+n/a
+10
+12
+13
+15
+12
- Conduct post-implementation or post-occupancy reviews of capital programming and acquisition
+*
+*
+*
+*
+*
+*
+
+*
+n/a
+*
+*
+*
+1
+1
+n/a
+*
+n/a
+n/a
+n/a
+*
+*
+*
+*
+*
+
+2
+2
+2
+1
+1
+2
+
+3
+3
+2
+3
+2
+1
+1
+1
+1
+1
+1
+2
+2
+2
+1
+1
+1
+
+See past presidents’ approval trends: Joe Biden, Barack Obama, George W. Bush, Bill Clinton
-processes and projects to validate estimated costs and benefits and to document effective management
-practices (e.g., lessons learned) for broader use;
+6
- Establish oversight mechanisms that require periodic review of operational capital assets to determine
-how mission requirements might have changed and whether the asset continues to fulfill ongoing and
-anticipated mission requirements, deliver intended benefits to the agency and customers, and meet user
-requirements;
+The W24.5 Mode Study survey was administered by web and phone. Results reported here are from web mode only.
+
+www.pewresearch.org
+
+23
+
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
+
+ASK ALL:
+DTSUCCESS
+
+Jan 20-26,
+2026
+31
+47
+21
+1
+
+In the long run, do you think Donald Trump will be…
+[ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-2/2-1, HOLDING 3 LAST]
+
+A successful president
+An unsuccessful president
+Too early to tell
+No answer*
+
+Jan 27-Feb 2,
+2025
+35
+33
+31
+1
+
+Jan 6-19,
+2020
+34
+48
+18
+1
+
+TREND FOR COMPARISON:
+In the long run, do you think Joe Biden will be…
+
+A successful president
+An unsuccessful president
+Too early to tell
+No answer
+
+Jan 8-12,
+2021
+29
+26
+44
+1
+
+PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON
+In the long run, do you think Donald Trump will be a successful or unsuccessful president, or do you
+think it is too early to tell?
+
+Successful
+
+Unsuccessful
+
+Too early
+to tell
+
+(VOL.)
+DK/Ref
+
+Trump
+Jan 8-13, 2020
+Jan 9-14, 2019
+Jan 10-15, 2018
+Jan 4-9, 2017
+Obama
+Jan 7-14, 2016
+Jan 7-11, 2015
+Jan 15-19, 2014
+Jun 12-16, 2013
+Jan 9-13, 2013
+Jan 11-16, 2012
+Jan 5-9, 2011
+Jan 6-10, 2010
+Sep 30-Oct 4, 2009
+Jan 7-11, 2009
+Bush
+January, 2007
+January, 2006
+Early October, 2005
+January, 2005
+December, 2003
+Early October, 2002
+January, 2001
+Clinton
+January, 1999
+Early September, 1998
+February, 1995
+October, 1994
+May, 1994
+January, 1994
+October, 1993
+September, 1993
+August, 1993
+
+36
+29
+23
+21
+
+37
+32
+28
+34
+33
+27
+25
+24
+27
+30
+
+24
+27
+26
+36
+39
+40
+26
+
+44
+38
+18
+14
+21
+21
+18
+22
+13
+
+37
+47
+41
+20
+
+34
+38
+34
+31
+26
+32
+26
+21
+18
+4
+
+45
+37
+41
+27
+20
+15
+15
+
+24
+24
+34
+35
+26
+19
+25
+22
+25
+
+26
+23
+34
+58
+
+26
+29
+35
+33
+39
+39
+47
+52
+54
+65
+
+27
+32
+30
+35
+38
+44
+58
+
+29
+35
+43
+48
+52
+57
+56
+54
+60
+
+1
+1
+1
+1
+
+3
+2
+3
+2
+2
+2
+2
+3
+2
+1
+
+4
+4
+3
+2
+3
+1
+1
+
+3
+3
+5
+3
+1
+3
+1
+2
+2
- Provide Chief Information Officer (CIO) evaluations for all major investments on the IT Dashboard
+www.pewresearch.org
-which reflect the CIO’s best judgment of the current level of risk for the investment in terms of its ability
-to accomplish its goals. The evaluation should be informed by the following factors, including, but not
-limited to: risk management, requirements management, contractor oversight, historical performance,
-human capital and other factors that the CIO deems important to forecasting future success. Each
-evaluation should include a narrative explanation when the rating has changed since the last evaluation;
-and
+24
- Develop, maintain, and submit the following investment documents and artifacts for all major IT
-investments, as applicable. Provide updated versions (including date of last update) as significant
-changes are made or as available throughout the investment’s lifecycle:
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-o Risk management plan;
-o
-Investment charter, including IPT;
-o
-Investment-level alternative analysis and benefit-cost analysis;
-o Operational analyses (for operational or mixed life cycle systems);
-o Post implementation review results (investment level or project-specific); and,
-o Documentation of investment re-baseline management approval(s).
+ASK ALL:
+QUALPRES_TRMP
-Page 31 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012)
+Thinking about the qualities needed to serve as president, how confident are you that
+Donald Trump…7
+[ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-5/5-1]
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS
+Extremely
+confident
-300.4 What other requirements does Exhibit 300 fulfill?
+Very
+confident
-Exhibit 300A is designed to coordinate OMB’s collection of agency information for its reports to Congress, as
-required by the Federal Acquisition Streamlining Act of 1994 (FASA, Title V) and Clinger-Cohen Act of 1996.
-The business case (Exhibit 300A) for investment should demonstrate support for the mission statements, long-
-term goals and objectives, and annual performance plans developed pursuant to the GPRA-MA. Exhibit 300B
-establishes reporting requirements through the IT Dashboard to ensure the proper execution of those investments
-against the established performance plans.
+Somewhat
+confident
-300.5 What must I report on Exhibits 300A and B and when?
+Not too
+confident
-All information necessary to complete Exhibit 300A and Exhibit 300B should already exist as part of the agency's
-overall capital planning activities and within project- and program-specific documentation. The materials used to
-populate Exhibit 300A and Exhibit 300B should be readily available to OMB upon request.
+Not at all
+confident
-Agencies must submit Exhibit 300s using the following schedule:
+No
+answer*
- Agency Budget Request Exhibit 300A: September 10-14, 2012
- Agency Budget Request Exhibit 300B: September 14, 2012
- President’s Budget Request Exhibit 300A & B: February 2013 (tentative)
+MF
-o Submit initial documents/artifacts at this time
+Has the mental fitness
+needed to do the job
+ Jan 20-26, 2026
+ Jan 27-Feb 2, 20258
+ Apr 8-14, 2024
-Unless otherwise noted, IT exhibits and reporting must be submitted electronically to the IT Dashboard.
-Additional information regarding the submission process will be posted on the IT Dashboard, including business
-rules for the validation of data and a schema that describes how data should be transmitted. As always, pre-
-decisional and procurement sensitive information will not be displayed to the public.
+▪
-Projects within investments are encouraged to use modular development principles. All projects (regardless of
-whether they use modular development principles), must produce usable functionality at intervals of no more than
-six months.
+PHY ▪ Has the physical fitness
-Exhibit 300Bs shall establish cost, schedule and performance targets for CY 2013 and BY 2014. Regular updates
-for metrics and activities will be submitted to the IT Dashboard as soon as the data becomes available and at least
-once per each calendar month. How periodic performance metrics updates for ongoing operations will be, will
-vary according to the nature of the metric, as indicated in Table C1.
+needed to do the job
+ Jan 20-26, 2026
+ Jan 27-Feb 2, 20259
+ Apr 8-14, 2024
-If an agency requests supplemental funds or reallocates funding within its authority, which includes changes to
-the agency's portfolio and the performance targets, agencies should submit a new or revised version of Exhibit
-53A as part of their supplemental request.
+▪
+▪
+▪
-Multi-Agency Collaboration and Intra-agency Shared Services Investments (must submit both Exhibit 300A
-and Exhibit 300B)
+FIRM
-The managing partners (lead agency that provides services or coordination services to other agencies) will take
-the lead in completing and submitting the multi-agency collaboration investment Exhibits 300, managing it
-through the managing partner’s capital programming and budget process. The managing partners are also
-responsible for ensuring Exhibit 300 includes all necessary information from the partner agencies (customers who
-receive services from the managing partners) and have been approved by all necessary partner agencies through
-the appropriate governance process. The tracking of the multi-agency approvals, partner agency funding, and
-related capital assets (e.g., migration investments, Centers of Excellence, Shared Service Centers, supporting
-components) will be captured via an OMB MAX E-Gov Funding Tool. All initiative program managers or
-designated leads should have received details about this in an OMB e-mail distribution dated May 22, 2012.
+ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,250]
+Has the leadership skills
+needed to do the job
+Jan 20-26, 2026
+Jan 27-Feb 2, 2025
-Page 32 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012)
+RSP
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS
+Respects the country’s
+democratic values
+Jan 20-26, 2026
+Jan 27-Feb 2, 2025
+Apr 8-14, 2024
-For IT assets, partner agencies should report their participation in Exhibit 53 submissions. Partner agencies
-should reference the name and UII of the multi-agency Exhibit 300 in the “Investment Description” field of
-each Exhibit 53 line item related to the multi-agency Exhibit 300. Partner agencies should also ensure their
-activities and participation are included in the appropriate sections of the multi-agency Exhibit 300. The entire
-Summary of Funding Total for the investment, including funds provided by partner agencies, should be included
-in Exhibit 300.
+ ASK FORM 2 ONLY [N=4,262]
+ADV
-Investments that provide a service to other agencies but do not receive contributions from partner agencies
-should be reported as Multi-Agency Collaboration Investments.
+Picks good advisers
+ Jan 20-26, 2026
+ Jan 27-Feb 2, 202510
+ Apr 8-14, 2024
-Investments for multi-agency collaboration, shared services, and/or LoBs will be reflected in the managing
-partner's annual Enterprise Roadmap submission to OMB.
+▪
+▪
+▪
-Managing partners that provide multi-agency services should ensure that funding is prioritized to
-accommodate building and obtaining approval of a shared architecture. Approval should be obtained through
-a working governance model that includes partner agencies, customers, and OMB.
+ETHETH
-OMB may require additional information from partner agencies related to the multi-agency collaboration
-investment Exhibit 300. When necessary, OMB will work with the managing partners to coordinate data
-requests.
+Acts ethically in office
-Page 33 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012)
+Jan 20-26, 2026
+Jan 27-Feb 2, 2025
+Apr 8-14, 2024
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS
+17
+23
+20
-300.6 How will OMB use Exhibit 300?
+12
+17
+15
-Exhibit 300 is one component of your agency’s total budget justification (see Section 51.2 of OMB Circular A-
-11). OMB uses data reported in Exhibit 300 to make quantitative decisions about budgetary resources consistent
-with the Administration’s program priorities as well as qualitative assessments about whether the agency’s
-programming processes are consistent with OMB policies and guidance. OMB may request additional supporting
-information from agencies as necessary.
+19
+25
-Exhibit 300A: IT Capital Asset Overview and Justification
+13
+17
+17
-Section A: General Information
+11
+16
+11
-1. Investment Name:
-2. UII. Unique Investment Identifier (see Section 53.4) :
+9
+15
+11
-[Limit: 250 char]
-[Limit: 13 char]
+15
+17
+15
-Section B: Investment Detail
+15
+18
+18
-1. Briefly describe the investment’s purpose, goals, and current or anticipated benefits (quantitative and/or
-qualitative). Include the investment’s specific contribution to mission delivery or agency management
-support functions and identify key customers, stakeholders, and other beneficiaries.
-[Limit: 2500 char]
+15
+15
-2. Briefly describe how the investment contributes to the agency target EA and its role in the Enterprise
-Roadmap. Include a description of how the investment includes or will achieve programmatic or
-technical innovation.
-[Limit:2500 char]
+12
+14
+13
-3. Provide the investment’s currently projected return on investment (ROI) percentage, as documented in
+14
+15
+14
-the most recent alternatives analysis, and the date that it was established.
+12
+13
+12
-a. Current ROI:
-b. Date of Current ROI:
+16
+16
+17
-[percentage]
-[YYYY-MM-DD]
+22
+24
+26
-4. In the table below, indicate if the investment in whole or in part specifically addresses any of the
+14
+16
-following types of requirements:
+15
+16
+16
-Note: Where “Yes” is indicated, provide a brief description of the requirement and how the investment will meet
-the requirement. Include citations within descriptions, if available. Provide any URLs associated with each
-requirement. If citing the Agency Performance Plan, provide the applicable “PRM” code from Performance.gov.
-Description
-[Limit: 1000
-characters]
+18
+18
+22
-URL(s) / PRM code (s)
-[One or more]
+18
+17
+17
-Required
-by
-[Yes/No]
+14
+14
+15
-Legislative Mandate
-Outstanding Audit Finding or
-Material Weakness
-Published Agency Strategic
-Plan/Annual Performance Plan
-Presidential Direction (i.e.
-Presidential Directive, Presidential
-Memorandum, or Executive Order)
-Other Requirement
+19
+17
+17
-(URL required)
+14
+13
-(optional)
+15
+14
+12
-[URL of Agency Strategic Plan] (optional)
-[PRM code for Annual Performance Plan] (required)
+17
+14
+15
-(URL required)
+15
+14
+14
-(optional)
+37
+30
+32
-5. Provide a description of the investment’s progress and accomplishments in the PY, including the
+31
+24
+23
-investment’s overall performance against baseline goals, targets, significant milestones, or performance
-measures, and any corrective actions taken to address performance deficiencies.
-[Limit: 1000 char]
+36
+30
-Page 34 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012)
+43
+39
+41
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS
+40
+37
+37
-6. Describe the investment’s objectives for the CY, BY, and budget out years, if available, including
+45
+40
+45
-specific accomplishments to achieve, realize, or continue to achieve the benefits cited in question B.1.
-above.
-[Limit: 2500 char]
+*
+*
+*
-7. If this investment will result in the elimination or the reduction of another investment(s), please
+1
+1
+*
-complete the following:
+*
+*
-Investment UII (one or more)
+1
+*
+1
-8. Does the investment include the following?
-
-To be Status
-[to be eliminated/to be reduced]
+1
+1
+1
-A shared service (intra-or inter-agency—current and/or planned)
-A data center (current and/or planned)
-PIV-enabled systems (per HSPD-12) (all systems currently PIV-enabled)
-(see OMB memo M-11-11)
-Cloud computing (current and/or planned)
-APIs (application programming interfaces) consistent with the Digital Government
-Strategy
-
-Check all that Apply
-[Yes/No]
-[Yes/No]
-[Yes/No]
-
-[Yes/No]
-[Yes/No]
-
-9. Provide any URLs related to the investment and indicate how they are related. Identify each URL’s
-
-relationship to the investment (if applicable):
-
-Relationship to Investment
-(check all that apply)
-
-d
-e
-c
-u
-d
-o
-r
-p
-s
-t
-e
-s
-a
-t
-a
-d
-e
-l
-b
-i
-s
-s
-e
-c
-c
-a
-
-y
-l
-c
-i
-l
-b
-u
-p
-s
-e
-d
-i
-v
-o
-r
-P
+1
+*
+1
-.
-
-A
-
-t
-n
-e
-m
-t
-s
-e
-v
-n
-i
-
-s
-i
-h
-t
-y
-b
-
-e
-d
-i
-v
-o
-r
-p
-o
-t
+7
-I
-P
-A
-e
-l
-b
-i
-s
-s
-e
-c
-c
-a
-y
-l
-c
-i
-l
-b
-u
-p
-a
-
-s
-e
-d
-i
-v
-o
-r
-P
+8
+9
+10
-.
-
-B
-
-t
-n
-e
-m
-t
-s
-e
-v
-n
-i
-
-s
-i
-h
-t
-
-m
-o
-r
-f
-
-a
-t
-a
-d
-o
-t
-
-s
-s
-e
-c
-c
-a
-
-.
-t
-n
-e
-m
-t
-s
-e
-v
-n
-i
-
-s
-i
-h
-t
-
-t
-u
-o
-b
-a
-
-a
-i
-d
-e
-m
-
-l
-a
-i
-c
-o
-s
-o
-t
-
-s
-k
-n
-i
-L
-
-.
-
-C
-
-s
-i
-h
-t
-
-t
-u
-o
-b
-a
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-i
-
-l
-a
-r
-e
-n
-e
-g
-s
-e
-d
-i
-v
-o
-r
-P
+Prior to January 2026, question was worded: “Thinking about the qualities needed to effectively serve another term
+as president, how confident are you that Donald Trump…”
+Prior to January 2026, the word “mental” was not underlined.
+Prior to January 2026, the word “physical” was not underlined.
+Prior to January 2026, the word “advisers” was spelled “advisors.”
-.
-
-D
-
-t
-n
-e
-m
-t
-s
-e
-v
-n
-i
-
-s
-i
-h
-t
-
-y
-b
-d
-e
-v
-r
-e
-s
-m
-a
-r
-g
-o
-r
-p
-r
-o
-s
-s
-e
-c
-o
-r
-p
-s
-s
-e
-n
-i
-s
-u
-b
-
-f
-l
-e
-s
-t
-i
-
-t
-n
-e
-m
-t
-s
-e
-v
-n
-i
-
-e
-h
-t
-
-t
-o
-n
-t
-u
-b
-t
-n
-e
-m
-t
-s
-e
-v
-n
-i
-
-e
-h
-t
-
-t
-u
-o
-b
-a
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-i
-
-l
-a
-r
-e
-n
-e
-g
-s
-e
-d
-i
-v
-o
-r
-P
+www.pewresearch.org
-.
+25
-E
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-URL
-(as many as
-necessary)
+ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE
-http://...
+ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,250]:
+Thinking about important issues facing the country today…
-[X]
+TRUMPISSUE1 Overall, would you say you tend to agree with Donald Trump on…
-[X]
+[ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-4/4-1]
-[X]
+Jan 20-26,
+2026
+13
+27
+22
+37
+1
-[X]
+All or nearly all issues
+Many, but not all issues
+A few issues
+No or almost no issues
+No answer*
-[X]
+PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON:
-10. Provide the date of the investment or IPT charter establishing the required IPT.
+Jul 1-7,
+2024
+16
+25
+23
+35
+1
-[Date]
+Feb 4-15,
+2020
+19
+23
+23
+34
+1
-Page 35 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012)
+Apr 25-May 1
+2018
+19
+22
+24
+33
+2
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS
+Aug 15-21
+2017
+15
+18
+21
+45
+1
-11. Provide names and contact information for IPT members in the table below. If available, insert lines for
-other IPT members such as enterprise architects, capital planners, and performance specialists. The IT
-PM, business process owner/SME, and contracting specialist must be Federal Government employees.
-The business process owner or SME may or may not be the same person listed as the functional/business
-sponsor on the Exhibit 53-- the functional/business sponsor may be a higher-level agency official or
-executive.
+ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,250]:
+TRUMPISSUE2 Now thinking not about issues, but just about the way Donald Trump conducts himself as
-IPT Member Role
+president, would you say you...
+[ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-3/3-1]
-IT PM
+Jan 20-26,
+2026
+16
-Name (Required for
-all members listed)
-[Limit: 250 char]
+32
-Phone Number
-(Required for PM)
-[10 digits, 0-9 only]
+51
-Business Process Owner
-or SME
-Contracting Specialist
-IT Specialist
-IT Security Specialist
-(Optional: Insert other IPT
-members)
+1
-(optional)
+Like the way he conducts
+himself
+Have mixed feelings about the
+way he conducts himself
+Don’t like the way he conducts
+himself
+No answer*
-(optional)
-(optional)
-(optional)
-(optional)
+Jul 1-7,
+202411
+13
-Extension
+Feb 4-15,
+202012
+15
-[Optional: 6
-digits, 0-9 only ]
-(optional)
+32
-E-mail (Required
-for PM)
-[Limit: one e-
-mail only]
-(optional)
+54
-(optional)
-(optional)
-(optional)
-(optional)
+1
-(optional)
-(optional)
-(optional)
-(optional)
+30
-Page 36 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012)
+53
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS
+3
-Section C: Life Cycle Costs
+PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON:
-1. Provide the cost summary for the investment by completing the following tables. All costs are to be provided
-in millions of dollars, and reporting three decimal places (precision to thousands of dollars) is recommended,
-although agencies may report up to six decimal places (whole dollars). Federal personnel costs should be
-included only in the rows designated as “… Govt. FTEs” costs and should be excluded from the other cost
-breakouts. For multi-agency investments, this table should include all funding (both managing and partner
-agency contributions).
+Apr 25-May 1
+2018
-For PY (FY2012) and earlier, provide final obligations (actuals) as they become available. For CY (FY2013)
-and BY (FY2014) provide estimated obligations for each year. For BY+1 and beyond, please provide the
-estimated obligations through the end of the investments useful life (may be different from the estimated
-budget authority requests). The sum of amounts for all years should reflect the estimated lifecycle cost of the
-investment. As described above, the Exhibit 53 should represent the budgetary resources for CY and BY.
+Aug 15-21
+2017
-For lines in the table that ask for changes in your current submission compared to your most recent previous
-submission, use the President’s Budget as your previous submission. When making comparisons, ensure that
-you compare same-year-to-same-year (e.g., 2012 versus 2012).
+19
-Significant changes from the previous submission should be reflected in an updated investment-level
-Alternatives Analysis and is subject to OMB request, as discussed in Exhibit 300.3.
+26
-PY-1 &
-Prior
+54
-PY
-2012
+2
-CY
-2013
+16
-BY
-2014
+25
-BY+1
-2015
+58
-BY+2
-2016
+1
-BY+3
-2017
+ASK FORM 2 ONLY [N=4,262]:
+NEWPRES_SUPP
-BY+4 &
-Beyond
+How many of Donald Trump’s policies and plans would you say you support?
+[ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-5/5-1]
-Planning Costs:
+Jan 20-26,
+2026
+6
+22
+20
+26
+26
+1
+
+All of them
+Most of them
+Some of them
+Only a few of them
+None of them
+No answer*
+
+Jan 27-Feb 2,
+2025
+9
+25
+17
+23
+24
+1
+
+11
-DME (Excluding Planning)
-Costs:
-DME (Including Planning)
-Govt. FTEs:
-Sub-Total DME (Including
-Govt. FTE) :
-O&M Costs:
+12
-O&M Govt. FTEs:
+In July 2024, the question was worded “Now thinking NOT about issues, but about Donald Trump’s personal conduct, would
+you say you…”
+In February 2020, the question was worded “Now thinking NOT about issues, but just about the way Donald Trump
+conducts himself as president, would you say you…”
+
+www.pewresearch.org
+
+26
+
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
+
+ASK FORM 2 ONLY [N=4,262]:
+NEWPRES_ACTNS
+
+Would you say the Trump administration's actions since taking office last year have
+been... [ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-5/5-1]
+
+Jan 20-26,
+2026
+11
+10
+28
+15
+34
+1
+
+A lot better than you expected
+A little better than you expected
+About what you expected
+A little worse than you expected
+A lot worse than you expected
+No answer*
+
+Jun 2-8,
+202513
+11
+10
+31
+17
+32
+*
+
+Jan 27-Feb 2,
+2025
+17
+11
+36
+12
+24
+1
-Sub-Total O&M Costs
-(Including Govt. FTE):
-Total Cost (Including Govt.
-FTE):
+ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE
-Total Govt. FTE costs:
+[RANDOMIZE ORDER OF PRESWITHOP AND OPWITHPRES SUCH THAT FORM 1 (X_FORM=1) GETS
+PRESWITHOP FIRST AND OPWITHPRES SECOND WHILE FORM 2 (X_FORM=2) GETS OPWITHPRES
+FIRST AND PRESWITHOP SECOND]
-Number of FTE rep by
-costs:
+ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,250]:
+PRESWITHOP
-Total change from PY
-final President’s Budget ($)
-Total change from PY
-final President’s Budget (%)
-Note: Do not enter information for the dark gray cells (these will be calculated).
-
-2.a.
-
-In which year did or will this investment begin? (specify year – e.g., PY-1 = 2011)?
-
-2.b.
-
-In which year will this investment reach the end of its estimated useful life?
-(specify year – e.g., BY+5 = 2019)
-
-3. If the funding levels have changed from the FY 2012 President’s Budget request for PY
-
-[Limit: 500 char]
-
-or CY, briefly explain those changes:
-
-Page 37 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012)
-
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS
-
-Section D: Acquisition/Contract Strategy
-
-1. In the table below, provide all prime contracts (or task orders) for awarded or open solicitations for the
-investment (sub-award details are not required). Completed contracts and/or task orders should not be included in
-the table. Contracts in open solicitation should provide estimated data for all fields (for “Total Contract Value,”
-provide the estimated base contract costs and all anticipated option years). Data definitions can be found at
-www.usaspending.gov/learn#a2.
+This year, do you think Donald Trump should... [ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-2/2-1 IN
+SAME ORDER AS OPWITHPRES]
-For specifics, see notes 1 and 2 below the table.
+Jan 20-26,
+2026
+64
-Field
+33
-Data Description
+2
-Contract Status
-Contracting Agency ID
+Try as best he can to work with Democratic congressional leaders to accomplish things,
+even if it means disappointing people who voted for him
+Stand up to Democratic congressional leaders on issues that are important to people who
+voted for him, even if it means it’s harder to address critical problems facing the country
+No answer*
-Procurement Instrument
-Identifier (PIID)
+Jan 27-Feb 2,
+2025
+63
-Modular Approaches/
-Contracting
+35
-Indefinite Delivery
-Vehicle (IDV) Reference
-ID
-IDV Agency ID
+2
-Solicitation ID1
+TREND FOR COMPARISON
+This year, do you think Joe Biden should…
-EVM Required
-Ultimate Contract
-Value1
-Type of Contract/ Task
-Order (Pricing) 1
+Try as best he can to work with Republican
+congressional leaders to accomplish things, even if it
+means disappointing some people who voted for him
+Stand up to Republican congressional leaders on
+issues that are important to the people who voted
+for him, even if it means it’s harder to address
+critical problems facing the country
+No answer
-Is the contract a
-Performance-Based
-Service Acquisition
-(PBSA)?1
-Effective date1
+Jan 16-21
+2024
+74
-Actual or expected End
-Date of Contract/ Task
-Order1
-Extent Competed1
+Jan 18-24,
+2023
+73
-(1) Awarded, (2) Pre-award, but post-solicitation
-Provide the contracting agency’s ID. This is required only if the
-contracting agency is different than the agency submitting the
-Exhibit. Use the agency’s 4-digit code as used in FPDS.
-The unique identifier for each contract, agreement, or order. See
-www.usaspending.gov/learn#a2 for more information about
-PIIDs.
-Do acquisition planning, award, and management actions apply
-the principles and strategies described in “Contracting Guidance
-to Support Modular Development”? [Yes/No]
-Provide the IDV Reference ID. This is only required for IDVs.
-See www.usaspending.gov/learn#a2 for more information about
-IDV Reference IDs.
-Provide the IDV agency ID. This is a code for an agency, but it
-does not necessarily represent the agency that issued the contract.
-Instead, it serves as part of the unique identification for Federal
-Procurement Data System IDV records.
-Provide the identifier used to link transactions to solicitation
-information. See www.usaspending.gov/learn#a2 for more
-information.
-[Yes/No]
-Enter the total value of the contract, including base and all
-options. Complete using dollars to two decimal places.
-Provide information about the type of contract the investment is
-(e.g., fixed price, cost, cost plus, incentive, IDV, time and
-materials). See FAR Part 16 for more classifications.
-[Yes/No] Indicate whether the contract is a PBSA as defined by
-FAR Subpart 37.601. A PBSA describes the requirements in
-terms of results rather than the methods of performance of the
-work.
-Provide the actual or expected start date of the contract/task order
-that the parties have agreed on for the contract’s requirements.
-[YYYY-MM-DD]
-[YYYY-MM-DD]
+Jan 10-17,
+2022
+67
-Choose one of the following options: (A) Full and open
-competition, (B) Not available for competition, (C) Not
-competed, (D) Full and open competition after exclusion of
-sources, (E) Follow on to competed action, (F) Competed under
-simplified acquisition procedures, (G) Not competed under
-simplified acquisition procedures, (CDO) Competitive Delivery
-Order, (NDO) Non-competitive Delivery Order
+Jan 8-12,
+202114
+74
-Optional for
-Awarded
-Contracts
+24
-Contract/
-Task
-Order
+25
-Y
+29
-Y
+23
-Y
+2
-Y
+2
-Y
+4
-Y
+3
-Y
+13
+14
-Y
+Prior to January 2026, the question was worded “Would you say the Trump administration’s actions so far have been…”
+In January 2021, second response option was worded as “ … on issues that are important to his supporters …”.
-Y
+www.pewresearch.org
-Page 38 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012)
+27
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Contract Description
+ASK FORM 2 ONLY [N=4,262]:
+OPWITHPRES
-A brief description of the goods or services bought (for an award)
-or that are available (for an
-IDV).www.usaspending.gov/learn?tab=FAQ#2
+This year, do you think Democratic congressional leaders should... [ROTATE RESPONSE
+OPTIONS 1-2/2-1 IN SAME ORDER AS PRESWITHOP]
-Y
+Jan 20-26,
+2026
+49
-1Assuming the PIID or IDV PIID match with www.usaspending.gov, these data elements will be automatically populated for awarded IT acquisitions.
-2Assuming the PIID, IDV PIID, or solicitation number match with www.usaspending.gov or FedBizOpps (www.fbo.gov) this data will be automatically
-populated for awarded, pre-awarded, and post-solicitation IT acquisitions.
+49
-2. If earned value is not required or will not be a contract requirement
-for any of the contracts or task orders above, explain why:
+2
-[Limit: 2500 char]
+Try as best they can to work with Donald Trump to accomplish things, even if it
+means disappointing people who voted for them
+Stand up to Donald Trump on issues that are important to people who voted for
+them, even if it means it’s harder to address critical problems facing the country
+No answer*
-Page 39 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012)
+Jan 27-Feb 2,
+2025
+55
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS
+43
-Exhibit 300B: Performance Plan and Measurement Report
+2
-Exhibit 300B is used to provide OMB BY 2014 and current FY 2013 investment plans and performance data.
-Include in this exhibit, at a minimum, all projects, activities, and operations scheduled to commence or continue
-in the CY and/or BYs. Information in Exhibit 300B is to be updated as soon as new data becomes available, but
-at a minimum once per calendar month.
+TREND FOR COMPARISON
+This year, do you think Republican congressional leaders should…
-UNDERSTANDING EXHIBIT 300B
+Try as best they can to work with Joe Biden to
+accomplish things, even if it means disappointing
+some Republican voters
+Stand up to Joe Biden on issues that are important
+to Republican voters, even if it means it’s harder to
+address critical problems facing the country
+No answer
-In Exhibit 300B, investments are described as:
+Jan 16-21
+2024
+60
-
+Jan 18-24,
+2023
+63
-Investment
+Jan 10-17,
+2022
+61
-o Projects
+Jan 8-12,
+2021
+66
- Activities
+37
-o Operations
+35
-Report information about these areas in the following Exhibit 300B sections:
+37
-A.1: General Information. Enter basic information about the major investment.
-B.1: Projects. Identify all of the investment’s projects with activities occurring in the current FY.
-B.2: Activities. Outline the activities that are performed to achieve the outcome of each project.
-B.3: Project Risk. Identify significant risks to each project’s success.
-C.1: Operational Performance Information. Identify performance targets for evaluating operations.
-C.2: Operational Risk. Identify all significant risks to the investment achieving operational performance
+3
-targets.
+2
-SECTION A: GENERAL INFORMATION
+2
-1. Investment Name: Agency-provided name of investment, consistent with Exhibit 53.
-2. Investment UII: Agency-provided UII, consistent with Exhibit 53.
+31
-SECTION B: PROJECT PLAN AND EXECUTION DATA
+3
-In Tables B.1 and B.2., report, at a minimum, all projects with any activities that started in a previous FY (PY and
-earlier) and that have not been completed by the beginning of the CY. Also, report projects and activities that are
-scheduled to start in the CY and BY, including planning, DME, and maintenance projects. Include projects and
-activities commencing beyond the BY, as available. Include the following data in Table B.1:
+ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE
-1. Project ID: An agency-specified number that uniquely identifies the project within the investment.
-2. Project Name: Name used by the agency to refer specifically to the project.
-3. Objectives/Expected Outcomes: Description of the project’s functionality, capability, or goal.
-4. Project Start Date: Actual start date of in-progress projects or planned start of projects that have not yet
+ASK ALL:
+IMMIG_FAVOPP
-begun (may be before the current FY or activities listed in Table B.2).
+Thinking about immigration policy, do you favor or oppose each of the following?
+[RANDOMIZE ITEMS; ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-4/4-1 IN SAME ORDER
+AS VEN_MADREMV]
-5. Project Completion Date: Planned date of completion of in-progress projects or actual completion date
-of projects that have completed (may be after BY or of completion date of activities listed in activities
-Table B.2).
+Strongly
+favor
-6. Project Life cycle Cost: Enter the total cost of all activities related to the project as described in OMB
+Somewhat
+favor
-Circular A-131 (in $ millions).
+Somewhat
+oppose
-7. PM Name: Name of PM responsible for the success of the project.
-8. PM Level of Experience: The years of applicable experience or the status of certification for the PM.
+Strongly
+oppose
-Available selections include:
+No
+answer*
-1) FAC-P/PM(DAWIA-3) – Senior
-2) FAC-P/PM(DAWIA-2) – Mid-Level
-3) FAC-P/PM(DAWIA-1) – Entry Level
+SCMED
-Page 40 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012)
+FEE
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS
+ASY
-4) Other certification with 4 or more years of PM experience (within the last five years)
-5) Other certification with between 2 and 4 years of PM experience (within the last five years)
-6) Other certification with less than two years of PM experience (within the last five years)
-7) No certification, but with 4 or more years of PM experience (within the last five years)
-8) No certification, but with between 2 and 4 years of PM experience (within the last five years)
-9) No certification, but with less than two years of PM experience (within the last five years)
+MIL
-9. PM Phone: Phone number of the PM responsible for the success of the project.
-10. PM E-mail: E-mail address of the PM responsible for the success of the project.
+Requiring people who want to
+enter the U.S. to let
+immigration officers review
+their social media accounts
+ Jan 20-26, 2026
-Project
-ID
+Giving people priority in the
+immigration process if they pay
+a $1 million fee
+ Jan 20-26, 2026
-Project
-Name
+Suspending all asylum
+applications from people
+seeking to live in the U.S. to
+escape violence or danger
+ Jan 20-26, 2026
-Objectives/
-Expected
-Outcomes
+Maintaining a large military
+presence at the U.S. border
+with Mexico
+ Jan 20-26, 2026
-Project
-Start
-Date
+25
-Project
-Completion
-Date
+31
-Table B.1
-Project
-Life cycle
-Cost
+20
-PM
-Name
+23
-PM Level
-of
-Experience
+5
-PM
-Phone
+14
-PM
-Extension
+20
-[10 digit]
+60
-[Optional]
+11
-PM E-
-mail
-[Limit: one
-e-mail only]
+21
-In Table B.2, describe, at a minimum, all activities for projects in Table B.1 that started in a previous FY (PY and
-earlier) and that have not been completed by the beginning of the CY, as well as activities that are scheduled to
-start in the current FY and BY. In line with modular development principles, each project must produce usable
-functionality at intervals of no more than six months, as described in the 25 Point Implementation Plan to Reform
-Federal Information Technology Management. Include the following data in Table B.2:
+30
-1. Project ID: An agency-specified number that uniquely identifies the project within this investment.
-2. Activity Name: A short description consistent with the critical steps within the agency project management
+36
-methodology.
+31
-3. Activity Description: Describe what work is accomplished by the activity.
-4. Structure ID: Agency-specified identifier that indicates the work breakdown structure (WBS) the agency uses to
+31
-associate the activity with other activities or a project. Provide this in the format of “x.x.x.x.x” where the first string
-is the Project ID and each following string (separated by periods) matches the structure ID of a parent activity. See
-below for more guidance about parent and child activities expressed through this structure.
+21
-5. Key Deliverable/Usable Functionality: Indicate whether the completion of the activity provides a key deliverable
+16
-or usable functionality. This should only be provided for activities that do not have a child activity. Use this field to
-demonstrate the investment’s alignment with the modular development principles of the 25 Point Implementation
-Plan to Reform Federal Information Technology Management.
+2
-6. Start Date Planned: The planned start date for the activity. This is the baseline value.
-7. Start Date Projected: If the activity has not yet started, enter the current planned start date of the activity.
-8. Start Date Actual: When the activity starts, enter the actual start date here.
-9. Completion Date Planned: The planned completion date for the activity. This is the baseline value.
-10. Completion Date Projected: If the activity has not yet completed, enter the current planned completion date of the
+2
-activity.
+2
-11. Completion Date Actual: When the activity ends, enter the actual completion date here.
-12. Total Costs Planned: The planned total cost for the activity. This is the baseline value.
-13. Total Costs Projected: When the activity is not yet completed, enter the current planned total cost of the activity.
-14. Total Costs Actual: When the activity ends, enter the actual total costs for the activity here.
+1
-Note: For programs that are employing earned value management, agencies should reflect “budget at completion” in the
-“Total Costs Planned” field and “estimated at completion” in the “Total Costs Projected” field for projected costs.
+www.pewresearch.org
-A
+28
-B
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-C
+IMMIG_FAVOPP CONTINUED …
-D
+DTN
-E
+PAU75
-F
+Keeping large numbers of
+immigrants in detention centers
+while their cases are decided
+ Jan 20-26, 2026
-G
+Pausing visa applications from
+people in 75 countries seeking
+to legally immigrate to the U.S.
+ Jan 20-26, 2026
-Table B.2
-H
+Strongly
+favor
-Project
-ID
+Somewhat
+favor
-Activity
-Name
+Somewhat
+oppose
-Activity
-Description
+Strongly
+oppose
-Structure
-ID
+No
+answer*
-Key Deliverable/
-Usable Functionality
-[Key Deliverable,
-Usable Functionality,
-N/A]
+14
-Start Date
-Planned
+21
-Start Date
-Projected
+24
-Start Date
-Actual
+40
-I
-Completion
-Date
-Planned
+16
-J
-Completion
-Date
-Projected
+23
-K
+30
-L
+30
-M
+2
-N
+2
-Completion
-Date Actual
+ADDITONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE
-Total Costs
-Planned
+[RANDOMIZE ORDER OF IMMIGPPL_ACCEPT AND IMMIGAGNT_ACCEPT]
-Total Costs
-Projected
+ASK ALL:
+IMMIGPPL_ACCEPT
-Total Costs
-Actual
+Do you think each of the following is acceptable or unacceptable for people to
+do? [RANDOMIZE ITEMS; ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-4/4-1 IN
+SAME ORDER AS IMMIGAGNT_ACCEPT]
-Page 41 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012)
+Definitely
+acceptable
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS
+Probably
+acceptable
-Reporting Parent and Child Activities (WBS Structure)
+Probably
+unacceptable
-“Child” activities may be grouped into “Parent” activities to reflect the WBS used by the agency to manage the
-investment. If a WBS is not used by the agency, report the relationship between parent activities and child
-activities in “Structure ID” using this method.
+Definitely
+unacceptable
-When reporting an activity, enter the “Structure ID” as a period-delimited string consisting of the “Project ID”
-and each nested parent activity between the project level and the child activity. The “Structure ID” to enter will
-vary depending on the activity’s WBS level.
+No
+answer*
-Example: For child activity 3 which is part of parent activity 10, which in turn is part of parent activity 2, which in
-turn is part of Project A, enter: A.2.10.3
+VDEO
- Project A
+TRCK
-o Parent Activity 2
+REPT
- Parent Activity 10
+Record video of immigration
+officers while they make arrests
+ Jan 20-26, 2026
- Child Activity 3
+Share information about where
+immigration officers are arresting
+people
+ Jan 20-26, 2026
-There is no limit to the number of nested “child” and “parent” relationships allowed, and this depth may vary
-from activity to activity and from project to project.
+Report people who they think
+may be in the country illegally to
+immigration officers
+ Jan 20-26, 2026
-If any of a parent activity's child activities occurs in the current FY, then all child activities of the parent activity
-must be reported, regardless of their timing. This is to ensure that a complete view of the parent activity is
-available.
+48
-All activities with no child activities must have, at a minimum, Project ID, Activity Name, Activity Description, Structure ID,
-Start Date Planned, Start Date Projected, Completion Date Planned, Completion Date Projected, Total Costs Planned, and
-Total Costs Projected. Completed activities must also have Start Date Actual, Completion Date Actual, and Total Costs
-Actual.
+26
-Any parent activities with a child activity must be completely described by the aggregate attributes of its child
-activities. In the IT Dashboard, the cost and schedule information for parent activities will be based on the cost
-and schedule information of the lowest level of child activities reported. Agency-submitted cost and schedule
-information is not required for parent activities.
+13
-Project
-ID
+12
-A
-A
-A
-A
+35
-Activity Name
-Design
-Business Requirements
-Technical Requirements
-Architecture
+24
-Structure
-ID
+18
-Start Date
-Planned
+22
-Completion
-Date Planned
+22
-Planned Total
-Costs
+30
-…
+22
-A.2
-A.2.1
-A.2.2
-A.2.3
+25
-2/1/2012
-2/1/2012
-2/11/2012
-2/21/2012
+1
-2/29/2012
-2/10/2012
-2/20/2012
-2/29/2012
+1
-$2.5
-$1.0
-$1.0
-$0.5
+2
-Parent activities as highlighted are optional (Structure ID: A.2). Reported parent activities values will be ignored, as
-calculated values will be determined by aggregating the cost and schedule information reported in the child activities.
+www.pewresearch.org
-Page 42 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012)
+29
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-Project Risk
+ASK ALL:
+IMMIGAGNT_ACCEPT
-Risk assessments should include risk information from all stakeholders and should be performed at the initial
-concept stage and then monitored and controlled throughout the life cycle of the investment. A copy of the
-investment Risk Management Plan must be uploaded to the IT Dashboard in conjunction with the Exhibit 300
-submission.
+Do you think each of the following is acceptable or unacceptable for federal
+immigration officers to do? [RANDOMIZE ITEMS; ROTATE RESPONSE
+OPTIONS 1-4/4-1 IN SAME ORDER AS IMMIGPPL_ACCEPT]
-In Table B.3, list all significant project-related risks submitted for the investment that are currently open and
-provide risk assessment information. It is not necessary to address all 19 OMB Risk Categories. Consider the
-combination of the risk probability and the risk impact when identifying significant risks. Include the following
-data in Table B.3:
+Definitely
+acceptable
-1. Project ID: An agency-specified number that uniquely identifies a project within the investment. For
+Probably
+acceptable
-each identified risk, list the associated Project ID.
+Probably
+unacceptable
-2. Risk Name: A short description that identifies a risk, the cause of the risk, and the effect that the risk
+Definitely
+unacceptable
-may have on the project.
+No
+answer*
-3. Risk Category: Select the relevant OMB risk category for each risk. Risk categories include: 1)
+MASK Wear face coverings that hide
+their identities while working
+ Jan 20-26, 2026
-Schedule, 2) Initial costs, 3) Life cycle costs, 4) Technical obsolescence, 5) Feasibility, 6) Reliability of
-systems, 7) Dependencies and interoperability between this investment and others, 8) Surety (asset
-protection) considerations, 9) Risk of creating a monopoly for future procurements, 10) Capability of
-agency to manage the investment, 11) Overall risk of investment failure, 12) Organizational and change
-management, 13) Business, 14) Data/info, 15) Technology, 16) Strategic, 17) Security, 18) Privacy, and
-19) Project resources.
+NGBH
-4. Risk Probability: The likelihood of a potential negative impact for the risk (Low, Medium, or High
+RLAN
-likelihood).
+Increase their presence in
+neighborhoods with many
+immigrants
+ Jan 20-26, 2026
-5. Risk Impact: The level of a potential negative impact for the risk (Low, Medium, or High impact).
-6. Mitigation Plan: A short description of the plan or steps to mitigate the identified risk.
+Use a person’s looks or the
+language they speak as a reason
+to check their immigration status
+ Jan 20-26, 2026
-Project ID
+CITZ
-Risk Name
-[Limit: 500
-char]
+Arrest U.S. citizens who help
+people avoid immigration officers
+ Jan 20-26, 2026
-Risk Category
-[19 risk
-categories]
+21
-Table B.3
-Risk Probability
+16
-Risk Impact
+15
-[Low, Medium, High]
+46
-[Low, Medium, High]
+18
-Mitigation Plan
-[char 500]
+26
-Page 43 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012)
+21
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS
+33
-SECTION C: OPERATIONAL DATA
+10
-Section C addresses operational activities that are not reported as a part of a project in Section B.
+18
-Operational Performance
-There are two essential types of operations metrics to be reported:
+20
-1. Results-Specific: Provide a minimum of two metrics that measure the effectiveness of the investment in
-delivering the desired service or support level. At least one metric should reflect customer results (e.g.
-service quality).
+23
-2. Activities or Technology-Specific: Provide a minimum of three metrics that measure the investment
-against its defined process standards or technical service level agreements (e.g. Reliability and
-Availability). At least one of these metrics must have a monthly reporting frequency
+21
-All data will be displayed to the public on the IT Dashboard. Ensure that all provided metrics information
-provided is publicly releasable.
+20
-Defining a new metric
+51
-When adding a new metric, such as for new investments or to provide new information about an existing
-investment, use the following table.
+34
-Metric ID
-[Limit:
-XXX char]
+1
-Metric
-Description
-[Limit: 500
-char]
+1
-Unit of
-Measure
-[Limit: 50
-char]
+1
-Table C.1A
+2
-FEA
-Performance
-Measurement
-Category
-Mapping
-[PRM
-Measurement
-Category]
+ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE
-2012
-Target
-[numeric]
+ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,250]:
+EXPAND_GRNLND_MOD
-2013
-Target
-[numeric]
+Donald Trump has mentioned an interest in the U.S. taking over Greenland.
+How likely do you think it is that Donald Trump will do this? [ROTATE
+RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-5/5-1 HOLDING 6 LAST]
-Measurement
-Condition
-[Over target/
-Under target]
+Jan 20-26,
+2026
+8
+12
+21
+22
+17
-Reporting
-Frequency
-[Monthly,
-Quarterly, Semi-
-Annual, Annual]
+Extremely likely
+Very likely
+Somewhat likely
+Not too likely
+Not at all likely
-Agency
-Strategic
-Goals/Agency
-Objective
-[New PRM Code]
+19
+1
-1. Metric ID: Unique ID provided by agency for the metric. When reporting actual results (see below), use
+Not sure
+No answer*
-this ID to reference the correct metric.
+Mar 24-30,
+202515
+7
+16
+28
+22
+13
-2. Metric Description: Description to help the user understand what is being measured. In this field,
+14
+*
-describe the units used, any calculation algorithm used, and the definition or limits of the population or
-“universe” measured.
+15
-3. Unit of Measure: Brief indication of what quantity is measured (e.g. number, percentage, dollar value)
+In the 2025 survey, question was worded “Donald Trump has mentioned an interest in the U.S. taking over Greenland. How
+likely do you think it is that Donald Trump will pursue this?”
-for each metric.
+www.pewresearch.org
-4. FEA Performance Measurement Category Mapping: Indicates the PRM measurement category as
+30
-described above.
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-5. 2012 Target: Metric target value from 2012
-6. 2013 Target: Metric target value for 2013
-7. Measurement Condition: Indicates whether a desired result would be “over the target” or “under the
-target.” For example, if the target is to reduce the error rate to 10%, then the desired result would be
-“under the target" so “under target” should be entered for measurement condition.
+ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,250]:
+EXPAND2_GRNLND
-8. Reporting Frequency: How often actual measurements will be reported (monthly, quarterly, semi-
+Do you favor or oppose the U.S. taking over Greenland, as Donald Trump has
+proposed? [ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-4/4-1 HOLDING 5 LAST]
-annually, or annually). Annual reporting frequencies are reserved for annual operating cost measures,
-performance measures associated with the agency’s annual performance plan, or other measures that can
-only be appropriated measured on an annual basis.
+Jan 20-26,
+2026
+10
+12
+13
+45
-9. Agency Strategic Goals/Agency Objective: For annual reporting frequency metrics, agencies will be
+Strongly favor
+Somewhat favor
+Somewhat oppose
+Strongly oppose
-required to provide the cross agency priority (CAP) goal; agency priority goal (APG); strategic goal (SG)
-or agency objective (OBJ) associated with the metric (using the new Performance Reference Model code
-use by Performance.gov).
+20
+1
-Page 44 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012)
+Not sure
+No answer*
-GUIDANCE ON EXHIBIT 300—PLANNING, BUDGETING, ACQUISITION, AND MANAGEMENT OF IT CAPITAL ASSETS
+Mar 24-30,
+2025
+8
+15
+12
+43
-Providing actual results:
+22
+1
-As actual results are measured at the appropriate frequency, report them using the following table. Also use this
-table when applicable to provide any historical actual results for a new metric (optional).
+ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE
-1. Metric ID: Unique ID provided by agency for the metric. Use this ID to reference the correct metric.
-2. Actual Result: Actual result measured.
-3. Date of Actual Result: End date of the most recent reporting period.
-4. Comment: A necessary provide a comment for each actual result reported, if necessary.
+ASK REPUBLICAN AND REPUBLICAN LEANERS (XPARTYSUMFINAL=1) [N=3,913]:
+Which comes closer to your view, even if neither is exactly right?
+REPWORKTRMP
+Republicans in Congress… [ROTATE RESPONSE OPTIONS 1-2/2-1]
-When adding a new metric, include historical actual result information as available.
+Jan 20-26,
+2026
+38
-Metric ID
-[Limit: XXX char]
+61
-Table C.1B
+1
-Actual
-Result
-[numeric]
+Have an obligation to support Donald Trump’s policies and
+programs because he is a Republican president
+Do not have an obligation to support Donald Trump’s
+policies and programs if they disagree with him
+No answer*
-Date of Actual
-Result
-[date]
+Jan 27-Feb 2,
+2025
+44
-Comment
-[500 char]
-(optional)
+55
-Operational Risk
+1
-Risk assessments should include risk information from all stakeholders and should be performed at the initial
-concept stage and then monitored and controlled throughout the life cycle of the investment. A copy of the
-investment risk management plan must be uploaded to the IT Dashboard.
+ASK ALL:
+PARTY
+ASK IF INDEP/SOMETHING ELSE (PARTY=3,4 OR REFUSED):
+As of today do you lean more to…16
+PARTYLN
-In Table C.2, list all significant operational related risks submitted for the investment that are currently open and
-provide risk assessment information. It is not necessary to address all 19 OMB Risk Categories. Consider the
-combination of the risk probability and the risk impact when identifying significant risks. Include the following
-data in Table C.2:
+In politics today, do you consider yourself a…
-1. Risk Name: A short description that identifies the risk, the cause of the risk and the effect that the risk
+Republican
+28
-may have on the operational activity.
+Democrat Independent
-2. Risk Category: The relevant OMB Risk Category for each risk. Risk categories include:
+26
-1) Schedule, 2) Initial costs, 3) Life cycle costs, 4) Technical obsolescence, 5) Feasibility, 6) Reliability of systems,
-7) Dependencies and interoperability between this investment and others, 8) Surety (asset protection) considerations,
-9) Risk of creating a monopoly for future procurements, 10) Capability of agency to manage the investment, 11)
-Overall risk of investment failure, 12) Organizational and change management, 13) Business, 14) Data/info, 15)
-Technology, 16) Strategic, 17) Security, 18) Privacy, and 19) Project resources.
+29
-3. Risk Probability: The likelihood of a negative impact for the risk (Low, Medium, or High likelihood).
-4. Risk Impact: The level of a potential negative impact for the risk (Low, Medium, or High impact).
-5. Mitigation Plan: A short description of how to mitigate the risk.
+Something
+else
+15
-Risk Name
-[Limit: 500 char]
+No
+answer*
+2
-Risk Category
-[19 risk categories]
+Lean
+Rep
+18
-Table C.2
-Risk Probability
-[Low, Medium, High]
+Lean
+Dem
+21
-Risk Impact
-[Low, Medium, High]
+16
-Mitigation Plan
-[Limit: 500 char]
+PARTY and PARTYLN asked in a prior survey.
-Page 45 of 45 Exhibit 300 (2012)
+www.pewresearch.org
diff --git a/q0/random_k4/random_3.md b/q0/random_k4/random_3.md
index 8f865df3772bc41afe1f8a2c8625c0b0956ae175..327782fda9cc6dd0e3c846808abb7a84285c7afc 100644
--- a/q0/random_k4/random_3.md
+++ b/q0/random_k4/random_3.md
@@ -1,2302 +1,1336 @@
-LINC: A Neurosymbolic Approach for Logical Reasoning by Combining
-| | | Language | | Models | with | First-Order | | Logic | Provers | | |
-| ---------------- | -------------------- | -------- | -------- | -------- | -------------------- | ----------------- | --- | ----- | ---------------- | --- | --- |
-| TheoX.Olausson*1 | | | | AlexGu*1 | BenjaminLipkin*2 | | | | CedegaoE.Zhang*2 | | |
-| | ArmandoSolar-Lezama1 | | | | JoshuaB.Tenenbaum1,2 | | | | RogerLevy2 | | |
-| | | | {theoxo, | gua, | lipkinb, | cedzhang}@mit.edu | | | | | |
-1MITCSAIL2MITBCS
-∗Equalcontribution.
-| | | Abstract | | | | 1 Introduction | | | | | |
-| ------- | ---------- | -------- | ----------- | --------- | --- | -------------- | -------- | --- | --- | -------------- | ------ |
-| | | | | | | Widespread | adoption | | of | large language | models |
-| Logical | reasoning, | i.e., | deductively | inferring | | | | | | | |
-the truth value of a conclusion from a set of (LLMs)suchasGPT-3(Brownetal.,2020),GPT-
-4202 beF 41 ]LC.sc[ 2v46151.0132:viXra
-| | | | | | | 4 (OpenAI, | 2023), | | and PaLM | (Chowdhery | et al., |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------ | --- | -------- | ---------- | ------- |
-premises,isanimportanttaskforartificialin-
-telligencewithwidepotentialimpactsonsci- 2022)haveledtoaseriesofremarkablesuccesses
-ence, mathematics, and society. While many in tasks ranging from text summarization to pro-
-prompting-basedstrategieshavebeenproposed gramsynthesis. Someofthesesuccesseshaveen-
-toenableLargeLanguageModels(LLMs)to
-couragedthehypothesisthatsuchmodelsareable
-| dosuchreasoningmoreeffectively, | | | | theystill | | | | | | | |
-| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-toflexiblyandsystematicallyreason(Huangand
-| appear | unsatisfactory, | | often failing | in subtle | | | | | | | |
-| ------ | --------------- | --- | ------------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-and unpredictable ways. In this work, we Chang, 2022), especially when using prompting
-strategiesthatexplicitlyencourageverbalizingin-
-| investigate | the | validity | of instead | reformulat- | | | | | | | |
-| ----------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-ingsuchtasksasmodularneurosymbolicpro- termediate reasoning steps before generating the
-LINC:
-gramming, which we call Logical In- final answer (Nye et al., 2021; Wei et al., 2022;
-ference via Neurosymbolic Computation. In Kojimaetal.,2022;Wangetal.,2023b). However,
-LINC,theLLMactsasasemanticparser,trans-
-thisreasoningabilityappearstobeunreliablefor
-latingpremisesandconclusionsfromnatural
-tasksthatrequirereasoningoutofdomain(Liang
-| language | to | expressions | in first-order | | logic. | | | | | | |
-| -------- | --- | ----------- | -------------- | --- | ------ | ------------- | ------- | --- | ------- | -------------------- | --- |
-| | | | | | | et al., 2022; | Saparov | | et al., | 2023), understanding | |
-Theseexpressionsarethenoffloadedtoanex-
-| | | | | | | negation | (Anil | et al., | 2022), | and following | long |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ----- | ------- | ------ | ------------- | ---- |
-ternaltheoremprover,whichsymbolicallyper-
-formsdeductiveinference. Leveragingthisap- reasoningchains(Dzirietal.,2023). Furthermore,
-proach, we observe significant performance whilethestandardapproachof“scalingup”seems
-gains on FOLIO and a balanced subset of toimproveperformanceacrosssomereasoningdo-
-ProofWriterforthreedifferentmodelsinnearly mains,otherdomains,e.g.,reasoninginvolvinguse
-| all experimental | | conditions | we | evaluate. | On | | | | | | |
-| ---------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --------- | -------- | ----------- | ---- | -------------------- | ------- |
-| | | | | | | of Modus | Tollens, | | show | no such improvements | |
-| ProofWriter, | | augmenting | the | comparatively | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | (McKenzie | et | al., 2022). | | These findings | suggest |
-smallopen-sourceStarCoder+(15.5Bparame-
-| | | | | | | that such | models | may | be | relying on approximate | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------ | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- |
-ters)withLINCevenoutperformsGPT-3.5and
-GPT-4withChain-of-Thought(CoT)prompt- heuristicsbasedonsurface-levelstatisticalpatterns
-ing by an absolute 38% and 10%, respec- in reasoning tasks, rather than consistent, gener-
-tively. When used with GPT-4, LINC scores alizablerepresentationsandstrategies(Srivastava
-CoT
-26% higher than on ProofWriter while etal.,2023;Creswelletal.,2023).
-performingcomparativelyonFOLIO.Further
-| | | | | | | At the | same | time, | the ability | to accurately | and |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ---- | ----- | ----------- | ------------- | --- |
-analysisrevealsthatalthoughbothmethodson
-soundlyperformlogicalreasoningisimportantfor
-averagesucceedroughlyequallyoftenonthis
-dataset,theyexhibitdistinctandcomplemen- AIandNLPduetoitsimpactondownstreamtasks.
-taryfailuremodes. Wethusprovidepromising For example: retrieval-augmented chatbots may
-evidenceforhowlogicalreasoningovernatural becomemoretruthfulifitcanbeverifiedthattheir
-languagecanbetackledthroughjointlylever-
-answerslogicallyfollowfromtheretrievedfacts;
-| agingLLMsalongsidesymbolicprovers. | | | | | All | | | | | | |
-| ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------ | --- | ------- | ---------- | --------- |
-| | | | | | | data-driven | models | | capable | of logical | reasoning |
-correspondingcodeispubliclyavailable.1
-| | | | | | | may speed | up | progress | across | mathematics | and |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------- | -------- | --------- | ----------- | ------- |
-| | | | | | | the sciences | through | | automated | theorem | proving |
-∗
-Authororderrandomized;allreservetherighttolist
-andknowledgediscovery;andAItutoringsystems
-theirnamefirst.
-https://github.com/benlipkin/linc which ensure internal logical consistency might
-1
+| | | | Fact | or Fiction: | Verifying | Scientific | | Claims | | | | |
+| --- | ------------------- | --- | ---- | ------------- | ----------- | ---------- | -------------------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+| | DavidWadden†∗ | | | ShanchuanLin† | | KyleLo‡ | | LucyLuWang‡ | | | | |
+| | MadeleinevanZuylen‡ | | | | ArmanCohan‡ | | HannanehHajishirzi†‡ | | | | | |
+† UniversityofWashington,Seattle,WA,USA
+‡
+AllenInstituteforArtificialIntelligence,Seattle,WA,USA
+{dwadden,linsh,hannaneh}@cs.washington.edu
+{kylel,lucyw,madeleinev,armanc}@allenai.org
+Abstract
+Claim
+We introduce scientific claim verification, a Cardiac injury is common in
+new task to select abstracts from the re- critical cases of COVID-19.
+searchliteraturecontainingevidencethatSUP-
+| PORTS | or REFUTES | | a given | scientific | claim, | | | | Fact-checker | | | |
+| ----- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- |
+Corpus
+| and to | identify | rationales | | justifying | each de- | | | | | | | |
+| ------- | -------- | ---------- | ----- | ------------ | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | -------- | --- |
+| | | | | | | | | | Decision: | | SUPPORTS | |
+| cision. | To study | this | task, | we construct | SCI- | | | | | | | |
+More severe COVID-19 infection
+| FACT, | a dataset | of | 1.4K expert-written | | scien- | | | | | | | |
+| ------------ | --------- | ------ | ------------------------ | --- | ------ | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | ----- |
+| | | | | | | | | is associated with higher | | | | mean |
+| tific claims | | paired | with evidence-containing | | | | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | | troponin | | (SMD 0.53, 95% CI 0.30 | | |
+abstracts annotated with labels and rationales. to 0.75, p < 0.001)
+| WedevelopbaselinemodelsforSCIFACT,and | | | | | | | | | | Rationale | | |
+| ------------------------------------- | --- | ---- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | --------------- | --- | ------ | --------- | ----------- | --- |
+| demonstrate | | that | simple domain | | adaptation | | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | Figure | 1: A scientific | | claim, | supported | by evidence | |
+techniquessubstantiallyimproveperformance
+compared to models trained on Wikipedia or identifiedbyoursystem. Tocorrectlyverifythisclaim,
+| | | | | | | the system | must | possess | background | | knowledge | that |
+| --------- | ------ | ------ | ------- | ----------- | --------- | ---------- | ------------ | ------- | ---------- | ------- | ---------- | ---- |
+| political | news. | We | show | that our | system is | | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | troponin | is a protein | found | in | cardiac | muscle and | that |
+| able to | verify | claims | related | to COVID-19 | by | | | | | | | |
+identifying evidence from the CORD-19 cor- elevated levels of troponin are a marker of cardiac
+| | | | | | | injury. | In addition, | it | must be | able to | reason about | di- |
+| ---- | --------------- | --- | -------- | ---- | ------- | ------- | ------------ | --- | ------- | ------- | ------------ | --- |
+| pus. | Our experiments | | indicate | that | SCIFACT | | | | | | | |
+will provide a challenging testbed for the de- rectionalrelationshipsbetweenscientificprocesses: re-
+| | | | | | | placing | higher | with | lower would | cause | the rationale | |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------ | ---- | ----------- | ----- | ------------- | --- |
+velopmentofnewsystemsdesignedtoretrieve
+| | | | | | | to REFUTE | theclaimratherthan | | | SUPPORT | it. | Finally, |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ------- | --- | -------- |
+andreasonovercorporacontainingspecialized
+domain knowledge. Data and code for this thesystemshouldinterpret p<0.001asanindication
+thatthereportedfindingisstatisticallysignificant.
+| new task | are | publicly | available | at | https:// | | | | | | | |
+| --------------------------- | --- | -------- | ------------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+| github.com/allenai/scifact. | | | | | A leader- | | | | | | | |
+| board | and | COVID-19 | fact-checking | | demo | | | | | | | |
+are available at https://scifact.apps. Fact-checking – a task in which the veracity
+allenai.org.
+| | | | | | | of an input | claim | is | verified | against | a corpus | of |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ----- | ------- | -------- | ------- | --------- | ----- |
+| | | | | | | documents | that | support | or | refute | the claim | – has |
+1 Introduction
+beenstudiedtocombattheproliferationofmisin-
+Due to rapid growth in the scientific literature, it formationinpoliticalnews, socialmedia, andon
+is difficult for researchers – and the general pub- the web (Thorne et al., 2018; Hanselowski et al.,
+2019). However,verifyingscientificclaimsposes
+licevenmoreso–tostayuptodateonthelatest
+findings. Thischallengeisespeciallyacuteduring new challenges to both dataset construction and
+publichealthcriseslikethecurrentCOVID-19pan- effectivemodeling. Whilepoliticalclaimsareread-
+ilyavailableonfact-checkingwebsitesandcanbe
+demic,duetotheextremelyfastrateatwhichnew
+findingsarereportedandtherisksassociatedwith verifiedbycrowdworkers,annotatorswithexten-
+makingdecisionsbasedonoutdatedorincomplete sive domain knowledge are required to generate
+andverifyscientificclaims.
+| information. | As | a result, | there | is a need | for auto- | | | | | | | |
+| ------------ | --- | --------- | ----- | --------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+matedtoolstoassistresearchersandthepublicin In addition, NLP systems for scientific claim
+evaluatingtheveracityofscientificclaims. verificationmustpossessadditionalcapabilitiesbe-
+| | | | | | | yond those | required | | to verify | factoid | claims. | For |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | -------- | --- | --------- | ------- | ------- | --- |
+∗WorkperformedduringinternshipwiththeAllenInsti-
+tuteforArtificialIntelligence. instance,toverifytheclaimshowninFigure1,a
+7534
+Proceedingsofthe2020ConferenceonEmpiricalMethodsinNaturalLanguageProcessing,pages7534–7550,
+November16–20,2020.(cid:13)c2020AssociationforComputationalLinguistics
-Input
-| Step 1: | | | | Premise: | All rectangles have four sides. | | | | | | | Output |
-| -------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ |
-| Semantic | | | | Premise: | All four-sided things are shapes. | | | | | | | |
-True
-| Parser | | | | Conclusion: | Are all rectangles shapes? | | | | | | | |
-| ------ | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | -------------------------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | Sample 1 | | | | Sample 1 | | |
- all x. (rectangle(x) -> foursides(x))
- all x. (foursides(x) -> isshape(x))
-| | all x. (rectangle(x) -> isshape(x)) | | | | | | | Step 2: | | True | | |
-| --- | -------------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | ---- | --- | --- |
-Step 3:
-Logic
-K-Maj
-| | | | | | | Sample 2 | | Theorem | | Sample 2 | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- |
- all x. (rectangle(x) -> foursides(x)) Voting
- all x. (foursides(x) -> isshape(x))) Prover Error
- all x. (rectangle(x) -> isshape(x))
-| | | | | | | Sample 3 | | | | Sample 3 | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- |
- all x. (rectangle(x) -> foursidedthings(x))
-| | all x. (foursidedthings(x) -> isshape(x)) | | | | | | | | | True | | |
-| --- | -------------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- |
- all x. (rectangle(x) -> isshape(x))
-| | | | | | | Sample N | | | | Sample N | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- |
- all x. (rectangle(x) -> foursides(x))
- all x. (foursidedthings(x) -> isshape(x)) Unknown
- all x. (rectangle(x) -> isshape(x))
-Figure 1: This figure showcases the essence of our approach. Starting from a problem in natural language, in
-Step1,theLLMsemanticparsersampleslogicformulasexpressingestimatesofthesemantics. Itispossiblethat
-someofthesemightcontainerrors,e.g.,thesecondexampleshowsasyntaxerrorinvolvinganextraparenthesis,
-whereasthefourthexamplehighlightsasemanticerrorcausedbymismatchedpredicates. InStep2,thesearethen
-eachoffloadedtoanautomatedtheoremprover,filteringoutsyntaxerrors,andproducinglabelsfortheremaining
-samples. InStep3,theremainingcandidateoutputsarepassedthroughamajority-votesievetoarriveatthebest
-estimateforasingleoutputlabel.
-make for better educational platforms, teaching thesolverastray,leadingtoanincorrectconclusion.
-studentstothinkmoreclearlyandrigorously. The Asitisnotclearwhetherthetaskofformalization
-questionofhowtoenablestate-of-the-artLLMsto ismoreorlessdifficultthanthatofend-to-endnat-
-becomemorereliablelogicalreasonersisthusone ural language reasoning, our core interest in this
-ofgreatimportance,withfar-reachingimplications. work is to compare and contrast our neurosym-
-bolicapproachtoexistingreasoningstrategieslike
-| In | this | work, | we analyze | LINC: | Logical | | | | | | | |
-| --- | ---- | ----- | ---------- | ----- | ------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | -------- |
-| | | | | | | | Chain-of-Thought. | | | Our contributions | | are thus |
-InferenceviaNeurosymbolicComputation(Fig.1).
-| LINC, | | | | | | | three-fold: | | | | | |
-| ----- | ------- | --------- | --- | ---------- | ------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| In | logical | reasoning | | is tackled | through | a | | | | | | |
-modular, two-step neurosymbolic process. First, • First,weproposeLINC,atwo-stageneurosym-
-thelanguagemodelconvertsthenaturallanguage bolic approach for logical reasoning tasks
-| premises | and | desired | conclusion | into | first-order | | (Sec.2). | | | | | |
-| ------------------------------------------- | ------ | --------------- | ---------- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | --------- | ------------ | ---------- | --------- | ------ | -------------- |
-| logic(FOL)expressions(Enderton,2001;Barker- | | | | | | | | | | LINC | | |
-| | | | | | | | • Second, | | we compare | | to | three baseline |
-| Plummer | et | al., 2011). | Second, | a symbolic | | FOL | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | LLM | strategies | | (Fig. 2), | across | three mod- |
-| theorem | prover | algorithmically | | determines | | the | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | els | (StarCoder+, | | GPT-3.5, | GPT-4) | and two |
-truthvalueoftheconclusiongiventheformalized
-| | | | | | | | datasets | | (FOLIO | and ProofWriter) | | (Sec. 4). |
-| --------- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ------ | ---------------- | --- | --------- |
-| premises. | Inpractice,wealsoincorporateathird | | | | | | | | | | | |
-WefindthatLINCsignificantlyimprovesper-
-| majority | voting | step, | which | is shown | to improve | | | | | | | |
-| -------- | ------ | ----- | ----- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-formanceovereverybaselineinallexperimen-
-LINCisanaturalextensionofrecent
-performance.
-talconditionsexceptforGPT-4onFOLIO.
-workaugmentinglanugagemodelswithsymbolic
-tools such as calculators or interpreters (Schick • Third,weprovideathorougherroranalysisof
-| | | | | | | | | LINC | Chain-of-Thought, | | | |
-| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ---- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --------- |
-| etal.,2023). | | | | | | | both | | and | | | identify- |
-LINChasakeyadvantage: ingthreehigh-levelfailuremodesofeach. We
-thelanguagemodel
-discoverthatthesefailuremodesaredistinct,
-itselfnolongerneedstoperformanydeductiverea-
-highlightingthepotentialforasynergyofthe
-| soning, | which | is offloaded | | to the theorem | prover. | | | | | | | |
-| ------- | ----- | ------------ | --- | -------------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-twomethods(Sec.5).
-| However, | therearealsocleardrawbacks: | | | | thefor- | | | | | | | |
-| -------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-malization from natural language to first-order Overall, we present strong evidence for the po-
-logic must perfectly capture all relevant informa- tentialoffutureneurosymboliclogicalreasoning
-tioncontainedinthepremises,andanylossofin- systemsbasedonintegratinglanguagemodelsand
-| formationintheformalizationproceduremaylead | | | | | | | theoremprovers. | | | | | |
-| ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+Claim1:Lopinavir/ritonavirhaveexhibitedfavorableclinicalresponseswhenusedasatreatmentforcoronavirus.
+Supports:...Interestingly,afterlopinavir/ritonavir(Kaletra,AbbVie)wasadministered,β-coronavirusviralloadssignificantly
+decreasedandnoorlittlecoronavirustiterswereobserved.
+Refutes:Thefocuseddrugrepurposingofknownapproveddrugs(suchaslopinavir/ritonavir)hasbeenreportedfailedfor
+curingSARS-CoV-2infectedpatients.Itisurgenttogeneratenewchemicalentitiesagainstthisvirus...
+Claim2:Thecoronaviruscannotthriveinwarmerclimates.
+Supports:...mostoutbreaksdisplayapatternofclusteringinrelativelycoolanddryareas...Thisisbecausetheenvironment
+canmediatehuman-to-humantransmissionofSARS-CoV-2,andunsuitableclimatescancausethevirustodestabilizequickly...
+Refutes: ...significantcasesinthecomingmonthsarelikelytooccurinmorehumid(warmer)climates,irrespectiveofthe
+climate-dependenceoftransmissionandthatsummertemperatureswillnotsubstrantiallylimitpandemicgrowth.
+Table1: EvidenceidentifiedbyoursystemassupportingandrefutingtwoclaimsconcerningCOVID-19.
+system must have the ability to access scientific CORD-19corpus(Wangetal.,2020). Expertanno-
+backgroundknowledge,reasonoverincreasesand tatorsjudgeretrievedevidencetobeplausiblefor
+23of36claims.1
+decreasesinquantitiesormeasurements,andmake Ourresultsandanalysesdemon-
+senseofspecializedstatisticallanguage. stratetheimportanceofthenewtaskanddatasetto
+In this paper, we introduce the task of scien- supportsignificantfutureresearchinthisdomain.
+tific claim verification to evaluate the veracity of Insummary,ourcontributionsinclude: (1)We
+scientific claims against a scientific corpus. Ta- introduceandformalizethescientificclaimverifi-
+ble 1 presents some examples. To facilitate re- cation task. (2) We develop a novel annotation
+search on this task, we construct SCIFACT, an protocol to generate and verify 1.4K naturally-
+expert-annotateddatasetof1,409scientificclaims occurringclaimsaboutscientificfindings. (3)We
+accompanied by abstracts that support or refute establish strong baselines on this task, and iden-
+eachclaim,andannotatedwithrationales(Leietal., tify substantial opportunities for improvement at
+2016)justifyingeachSUPPORTS/REFUTESdeci- allstagesofthemodelingpipeline. (4)Wedemon-
+sion. Tocreatethedataset,wedevelopanovelan- stratetheefficacyofoursysteminareal-worldcase
+notationprotocolinwhichannotatorsre-formulate studyverifyingclaimsaboutCOVID-19againstthe
+| naturallyoccurringclaimsinthescientificliterature | | | | | | researchliterature. | | | | |
+| ------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+–citationsentences–intoatomicscientificclaims.
+| | | | | | | 2 Backgroundandtaskdefinition | | | | |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+Usingcitationsentencesasasourceofclaimsboth
+speedstheclaimgenerationprocessandguarantees
+| | | | | | | As illustrated | in Figure | 1, | scientific claim | verifi- |
+| ------------------------ | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | -------------- | --------- | --- | ---------------- | ------- |
+| thatthetopicsdiscussedin | | | SCIFACTarerepresen- | | | | | | | |
+cationisthetaskofidentifyingevidencefromthe
+| tativeoftheresearchliterature. | | | Inaddition,citation | | | | | | | |
+| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --------- |
+| | | | | | | researchliteraturethat | | SUPPORTS | or | REFUTES a |
+linksindicatetheexactdocumentslikelytocontain
+| | | | | | | given scientific | claim. | Table | 1 shows | the results |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ------ | ----- | ------- | ----------- |
+evidencenecessarytoverifyagivenclaim.
+| | | | | | | of our system | applied | to | claims about | the novel |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ------- | --- | ------------ | --------- |
+WeestablishperformancebaselinesonSCIFACT
+| | | | | | | coronavirus | COVID-19. | | For each claim, | the sys- |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --------- | --- | --------------- | -------- |
+withanapproachsimilartoDeYoungetal.(2020a),
+temidentifiesrelevantscientificabstracts,andla-
+whichachievesstrongperformanceontheFEVER
+| | | | | | | bels the | relation of | each | abstract to the | claim as |
+| ------------------------------------------- | ------------- | ------ | ----- | --------- | --- | ------------------------ | ----------- | ---- | ------------------- | -------- |
+| claimverificationdataset(Thorneetal.,2018). | | | | | Our | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | eitherSUPPORTSorREFUTES. | | | Verifyingscientific | |
+| baseline | is a pipeline | system | which | retrieves | ab- | | | | | |
+claimsischallengingandrequiresdomain-specific
+| stracts | related | to an input | claim, uses | a | BERT- | | | | | |
+| ------- | ------- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+backgroundknowledge–forinstance,inorderto
+based(Devlinetal.,2019)sentenceselectortoiden-
+| | | | | | | identify | the evidence | supporting | Claim | 1 in Ta- |
+| -------------- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | ------------- | --- | -------- | ------------ | ---------- | ----- | -------- |
+| tify rationale | sentences, | | and labels | each abstract | | | | | | |
+ble1,thesystemmustdeterminethatareductionin
+| as SUPPORTS, | REFUTES,or | | NOINFO | withrespect | | | | | | |
+| ------------ | ---------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+coronavirusviralloadindicatesafavorableclinical
+| to the claim. | We | demonstrate | that | our baseline | | | | | | |
+| ------------- | --- | ----------- | ---- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+response,eventhoughthisfactisnevermentioned.
+canbenefitfromtrainingonclaimsfromdomains
+| | | | | | | ScientificclaimsIn | | SCIFACT,ascientificclaimis | | |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- |
+includingWikipediaarticlesandpolitics.
+We showcase the ability of our model to ver- anatomicverifiablestatementexpressingafinding
+| ify expert-written | | claims | concerning | the | novel | | | | | |
+| ------------------ | --- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+1Weemphasizethatourmodelisaresearchprototypeand
+coronavirusCOVID-19againstthenewly-released shouldnotbeusedtomakeanymedicaldecisionswhatsoever.
+7535
-| 2 LINC:LogicalInferencevia | | | | | | 3 Experiments | | | | | | |
-| -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-NeurosymbolicComputation
-Inthissection,wepresentourexperimentalsetup,
-themodelsweuse,andthethreebaselinestowhich
-| Ourneurosymbolicapproachtoend-to-endlogical | | | | | | wecompareLINC. | | | | | | |
-| ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| reasoningconsistsoftwostages. | | | | Inthefirststage, | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | Datasets: | | Ourexperimentsusetasksfromtwo | | | | |
-theLLMactsasasemanticparser,translatingNL
-| | | | | | | existing | datasets: | FOLIO | (Han | et | al., 2022) | and |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --------- | ----- | ---- | --- | ---------- | --- |
-statementsintoFOLexpressionsinoursupported
-ProofWriter(Tafjordetal.,2021),bothofwhich
-| logiclanguage. | Inthesecondstage,theseexpres- | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| -------------- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-havebeenshowntobechallengingforoff-the-shelf
-| sions are | parsed | from | the text | generated | by the | | | | | | | |
-| --------- | -------- | ------ | -------- | ------------ | ------ | --------------------------------------- | ------------------ | --- | ------------ | --- | --------- | --- |
-| | | | | | | LLMs(Hanetal.,2022;Creswelletal.,2023). | | | | | | FO- |
-| LLM and | then get | passed | to | an automated | theo- | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | LIO is | an expert-written, | | open-domain, | | logically | |
-remprover;weuseProver9,ahigh-performance
-complexanddiversedatasetfornaturallanguage
-| prover widely | used | in | the logic | community | (Mc- | | | | | | | |
-| ----------------- | ---- | --- | --------- | --------- | -------- | --------- | ------- | --------------- | ------ | -------- | --- | -------- |
-| | | | | | | reasoning | with | first-order | logic. | We | use | its val- |
-| Cune, 2005–2010). | | The | external | solver | then ex- | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | idation | set for | our evaluation. | | However, | | of the |
-ecutesasymbolicdeductionalgorithm,whichei-
-204samplesinthevalidationset,wediscoverthat
-| ther returns | a value | from | the | set {True, | False, | | | | | | | |
-| ------------ | ------- | ---- | --- | ---------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-22haveerrors(detailsinAppendixC),leavingus
-Uncertain}orraisesanexceptionduetoimproper
-| | | | | | | with182examplesforourevaluation. | | | | | ProofWriter, | |
-| ---------- | ------ | ------ | ----- | ----- | ---------- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- |
-| FOL syntax | (e.g., | if the | model | fails | to balance | | | | | | | |
-meanwhile,isasyntheticallygenerateddatasetfor
-paranthesesintheformulae).
-| | | | | | | logical | reasoning | over | natural | language. | | For our |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --------- | ---- | ------- | --------- | --- | ------- |
-Atitscore,thestrengthofthisapproachliesin evaluation,weusetheOWA(Open-WorldAssump-
-the reformulation of the problem space. End-to- tion)portionofProofWriter,sincethissettingbest
-endNL-basedreasoningallowsforoperationover
-| | | | | | | matches | that | of FOLIO. | Since | we | are running | a |
-| -------- | -------- | ---------- | ------ | --- | ---------- | ------- | ---- | --------- | ----- | --- | ----------- | --- |
-| a highly | flexible | expression | space, | but | leaves the | | | | | | | |
-largenumberofexperiments,werandomlyselect
-LLMwiththedifficulttaskofperformingexplicit 360 data points to evaluate on in order to reduce
-deductiveinferenceoverexpressionsinthisspace. costs. Wesampletheseinsuchawaythatthere-
-| Using LINC, | we | instead | trade | off the | flexible ex- | | | | | | | |
-| ----------- | --- | ------- | ----- | ------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-sultingdatasetisbalancedacrossboththenumber
-pressionspaceofNLforsyntacticallystrictlogic ofreasoningstepsintheshortestgroundtruthproof
-formulas, allowing us to leverage symbolic algo- (depth0-5;50sampleseach)andacrossthethree
-rithmswithprovableguaranteesthatthedeductive labels(True/False/Uncertain;120sampleseach;
-chainswillbecorrectwithrespecttothesemantics
-20eachperdepth).
-oftheintermediaterepresentation. Makingeffec- In-contextlearningexamples: Wehand-pick
-tiveuseofthisreformulationthusrequiresthelogic eight diverse samples from the FOLIO training
-expressionsgeneratedbytheLLMtobe1)syntac-
-| | | | | | | set to be | used | as few-shot | | in-context | examples. | |
-| -------------- | ---- | ---- | -------- | -------- | ------ | --------- | ---- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --------- | --- |
-| tically valid, | such | that | they are | accepted | by the | | | | | | | |
-BecauseProofWriterdoesnotcomewithground
-prover, and 2) semantically valid, such that their truthFOLstatements,weusetheseeightsamples
-| evaluationresultsinthecorrectconclusion. | | | | | Inour | | | | | | | |
-| ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -------- | ------------ | --- | -------- | --- | ------ | ----- |
-| | | | | | | for both | evaluations. | | Compared | to | FOLIO, | ques- |
-experiments,wemitigatetheserisksbyusingaK-
-tionsinProofWritergenerallyhavemorepremises
-waymajorityvotingprocedure,whichisdiscussed per question (in our validation sets: an average
-furtherinSec.3.
-| | | | | | | of 5.3 in | FOLIO | vs. | 18.8 in | ProofWriter). | | Thus, |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ----- | --- | ------- | ------------- | --- | ----- |
-The significance of this problem space refor- ourevaluationonFOLIOisanin-distributiontask,
-whereasProofWriterrequiresgeneralizingout-of-
-mulationcan—beyondthenumericalincreasesin
-performance observed across our experiments— distributiontoreasoningoverconsiderablylarger
-perhapsbestbeseenthroughanin-depthcompari- setsofpremisesthanaregivenintheprompt.
-sonofhowLINCandtraditionalend-to-endLLM
-| | | | | | | Majority | | voting: | K-way | majority | voting, | in |
-| ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --------------------- | ------- | ----- | ------------ | ------- | --- |
-| reasoningapproachessuchasChain-of-Thought | | | | | | whichK | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | samplesaretakeni.i.d. | | | fromthemodel | | |
-(CoT)fail. Toforeshadowourlatteranalysis,we and the mode is used as the final prediction, has
-CoT, LINC
-find that compared to has worse recall previouslybeenshowntoimprovetheperformance
-butbetterprecisiononTrue/Falsepredictions.
-| | | | | | We | ofprompting-basedstrategiesinlogicalreasoning | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-discussthisfurtherinSec.5andhighlightthatthis tasks (Wang et al., 2023b). We implement such
-suggeststhatLINC,aswellasneurosymboliccom- a strategy in our work, with reported accuracies
-putationmoregenerally,hasthepotentialtoreduce reflectingK=10-waymajorityvoting,unlessoth-
-LLMoverconfidenceandhallucination. erwise stated. In the case of ties between two la-
-
-All rectangles have four sides.
-All four-sided things are shapes.
-Are all rectangles shapes?
-* N ICL
-Examples
-⧺
-< A < E N / V S E A W V L E A U R L A : U T A E T T > r E u > e Naïve < N F N F N F A < E L O L O L O N / V : L : L : L S E A : : : W V L E A U R L A A a A a A a : U T l l l l r l A E l l l l e l T T > r E r x f x a x u > e . o . l . e c u l t ( r ( ( a r f r - r n e o e e s g c u c c i l t r t t d e a s a a e s n i n n d g d g g h l e l l t a e s e e h v ( ( ( s i e x x x n ) ) ) g s f s h o a - - - u a p > > > r r e e s f i i s ? o s s S i s u s s c d h r h h r e a s a a s p i p p a . e d e e t s e ( ( c . s x x h ( ) ) x ) ) p ) a ) d < S s a m A < E i i r u N / V n d e s S E A c e t W V L e s s E A U , h b R L A a a e : U T l a p A E l n e s T T > d s h r E r , a u > e a p e c l t e t l h s a e , n f n g o s l u a o e r l - s l T s r i h r u d a e e e v c ! d e t a t f n h o g i u l n r e C g s o s T < N F N F N F < E L O L O L O / V : L : L : L E A : : : V L A U L A A a A a A a U T l l l l r l A E l l l l e l T > E r x f x a x > e . o . l . c u l t ( r ( ( a r f r - r n e o e e s g c u c c i l t r t t d e a s a a e s n i n n d g d g g h l e l l t a e s e e h v ( ( ( s i e x x x n ) ) ) g s f s h o a - - - u a p > > > r r e e s f i i s ? o s s i s u s s d h r h h e a s a a s p i p p . e d e e s e ( ( L . s x x I ( ) ) N x ) ) C ) )
-⧺
-All dogs are mammals. ⧺ = string concatenation
-Harry is a dog.
-Is Harry a mammal?
-
-…
-Figure 2: This figure outlines the string concatenation workflow for each of our conditions. We start with the
-originalproblem,provideICLexamplesthroughanintermediatemarkuplanguage,andfinallyappendtheproblem
-toevaluate. Atthisstage,weallowthemodeltoautoregressivelysampleuntilproducingastoptoken.
-bels, we arbitrarily select the first of the two to IntheScratchpadbaseline(Nyeetal.,2021),the
-have been generated. We report the effect of K model is asked to first generate FOL expressions
-onperformanceacrossourconditionsandbriefly correspondingtothepremises,andthengenerate
-discusstrendsinAppendixH. thelabel. ThisbaselineisthusanablationofLINC,
-Models: We use three models pre-trained on
-whereweusetheLLMinsteadofProver9asthe
-bothnaturallanguageandcode: GPT-3.5(Ouyang logicsolver. Finally,intheCoTbaseline,weusethe
-et al., 2022), GPT-42 (OpenAI, 2023), and Star- standard technique of CoT prompting (Wei et al.,
-Coder+3 (Lietal.,2023)withadecodingtemper- 2022; Kojima et al., 2022; Wang et al., 2023b),
-ature of T = 0.8 for all experiments. We defer wherethemodelisaskedtogeneratestep-by-step
-model,hyperparameter,andhardwaredetailstoAp- naturallanguagereasoningtoarriveattheconclu-
-pendixB.WeoptforStarCoder+forthreereasons: sion. The prompts we use for all approaches can
-firstly,unliketheothermodelsweconsider,itisa befoundinAppendixD.
-free,open-accessmodel. Secondly,ithasadataset
-4 Results&Discussion
-search functionality4, with which we verify that
-FOLIOandProofWriterarenotinStarCoder+’s
-OurmainresultsareshowninFigure3. Eachbar
-trainingset,givingfurtherassuranceinthevalidity representseitherLINCoroneofthethreebaselines,
-ofourfindings. Thirdly,withits15.5Bparameters while each group of bars indicates the language
-itislikelyconsiderablysmallerthanGPT-3.5and modelused(in{StarCoder+,GPT-3.5,GPT-4}).
-GPT-45, allowing us to compare performance at WenotefirstthatintheFOLIOdomain(Figure
-differentmodelscales. 3a), StarCoder+—the smallest model we experi-
-Controlled baselines: We compare LINC to ment with—benefits the most from LINC, achiev-
-threebaselines,whichwecallNaïve,Scratchpad,
-ingameanaccuracythatis14.2pointshigherthan
-and Chain-of-Thought (CoT), as illustrated in the closest controlled baseline (56.0% vs. 41.8%
-Fig. 2. In the Naïve baseline, the model is given with CoT). We find that Scratchpad, where the
-the natural language premises and is asked to di- intermediate logical formulae are still generated
-rectlygeneratethelabel(True/False/Uncertain).
-but the call to the symbolic solver is ablated and
-replacedbythemodel’sownprediction,doesnot
-2Weusegpt-3.5-turbo-16k-0613andgpt-4-0613.
-appeartobenefitperformance;forStarCoder+,nei-
-3https://huggingface.co/bigcode/starcoderplus
-ther Scratchpad nor the Naïve baseline perform
-4See https://huggingface.co/spaces/bigcode/
-in-the-stack and https://huggingface.co/spaces/ betterthansimplydeterministicallypredictingthe
-bigcode/search. mostcommonlabel(“Uncertain”). ForGPT-3.5,
-5Although the exact size of these models has not been thetrendissimilar,althoughthegapbetweenLINC
-madepublic,theircommonpredecessorGPT-3wasknownto
-have175Bparameters;seeBrownetal.(2020). andtheclosestbaselineshrinks(62.6%vs. 54.9%
-
-| 100% | | | | | | 100% | | | |
-| ---- | ---------- | --- | ---------------- | ---------- | ----- | ---- | ---------- | ---------------- | ----------- |
-| | Naive | | Chain-of-Thought | | | | Naive | Chain-of-Thought | 96.4% 98.3% |
-| | Scratchpad | | LINC (ours) | | | | Scratchpad | LINC (ours) | |
-| 80% | | | | 75.3% | | 80% | | 82.5% | |
-| | | | | 69.8%68.7% | 72.5% | | | | 72.2% |
-62.6%
-| 60% | | 56.0% | 54.9% | | | 60% | | | 53.1% 55.8% |
-| --- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- |
-48.4%47.8%
-| | | 41.8% | | | | | | 43.6% | |
-| --- | ---------- | ----- | --------- | ----- | --- | --- | --------------- | --------------- | ----- |
-| | | | | | | | 37.8%38.1%38.6% | 36.4% | |
-| 40% | 34.6%32.4% | | | | | 40% | | 33.1% | |
-| 20% | | | | | | 20% | | | |
-| | StarCoder+ | | GPT-3.5 | GPT-4 | | | StarCoder+ | GPT-3.5 | GPT-4 |
-| | | | (a)FOLIO. | | | | | (b)ProofWriter. | |
-Figure3: ResultsofeachmodelontheFOLIOandProofWriterdatasets. Accuraciesareforbootstrapped10-way
-majorityvoteforallmodels. Errorbarsare±1bootstrappedstandarddeviation. Dotted,blacklineistheaccuracy
-obtainedbyalwaysguessingthemostcommonlabelinthedataset.
-averageaccuracies). ForGPT-4,thetrendreverses: tionofthenecessaryproofdepthinFigure4. We
-LINC underperforms CoT. However, we perform notefirstthatStarCoder+’sperformanceremains
-a McNemar’s test (McNemar, 1947) to get the p- flatandclosetochancewithallthreebaselinemeth-
-| | | | LINC | CoT | | | Meanwhile,withLINCtheperfor- | | |
-| ----- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- |
-| value | on | this GPT-4 | vs. | comparison, | | ods(Figure4a). | | | |
-and we find that the difference is not significant manceremainsfarabovechance,althoughitdrops
-(p = 0.58). Meanwhile,forourbalancedsubsetof somewhatasnecessaryproofdepthincreases;this
-ProofWriter,weseesignificantperformancegains performancedropsuggeststhatStarCoder+strug-
-across the board (Figure 3b); particularly so for glessomewhatwiththeNL-to-FOLtranslationtask
-GPT-3.5andGPT-4,whichachievemeanaccura- as the problem at hand gets larger. For GPT-3.5,
-ciesof96.4%and98.3%whenpairedwithLINC. allbaselinesperformabovechanceatproofdepth
-In light of the high accuracies obtained with 0 (i.e., where the conclusion can immediately be
-LINC on ProofWriter, we offer two plausible rea- reachedfromthepremises),butthenquicklydrop
-sons why LINC is particularly favorable on this backdown(Figure4b). WhileChain-of-Thought
-dataset. Firstly,ProofWriteris—unlikeFOLIO— prompting allows the model to complete some
-completelysyntheticallygenerated,withrelatively depth-1 tasks, even this strategy then performs
-shortsentences,perhapslendingitselfparticularly equivalentlytochance(within1standarddeviation)
-LINC,
-well to being formalized in FOL. However, it is for higher depths. When augmented with
-Scratchpad
-noteworthy that the mode does not however, GPT-3.5 is able to achieve near-perfect
-seemtoimproveperformanceovertheNaïvebase- performanceacrossallproofdepths,providingevi-
-line, indicating that even if the NL-to-FOL task denceforthescalabilityofthisapproachtolonger
-were particularly easy in this domain, this is not deductive chains. Finally, for GPT-4 we observe
-somethingthatthemodelisitselfcapableoflever- muchstrongerperformancefromthebaselines;in
-agingtoimproveitspredictions. Thesecondreason particular,CoTperformsabovechanceforallproof
-mightbethatthebaselinestrategiesstruggleinthis depths,andallbaselinesperformwellforshallow
-out-of-distributionsetting,inwhichthemodelmust proofs(Figure4c). However,evenwithGPT-4the
-generalizetoalargersetofpremises(withpoten- performance drops as the necessary proof depth
-tiallylongerdeductivechains)thanthosefoundin increaseswitheveryconfigurationexceptforLINC,
-theprompt. Thisdistributionshiftmakesitharder whichperformsnearoratceilingthroughthemax-
-imumproofdepthavailableinthedataset.
-forthemodeltoignoreirrelevantpremisesinthe
-| question | and | carry | out all deductive | chains | cor- | | | | |
-| -------- | --- | ----- | ----------------- | ------ | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-Meanwhile,withLINC,thesymbolicsolver
-| rectly. | | | | | | 5 ErrorAnalysis | | | |
-| -------- | ------- | ---------- | -------- | --- | -------- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- |
-| robustly | handles | irrelevant | premises | and | long de- | | | | |
-ductivechains,sincetheLLMonlyneedstotrans- HavingestablishedthatLINCcanimproveperfor-
-lateeachsentenceintoFOL. mance in many settings, we now move on to our
-Totestthislastexplanationfurther,weploteach finalresearchquestion: Howdothefailuremodes
-model’sperformanceacrossProofWriterasafunc- of LINCcomparetothoseofin-contextreasoning
-
-| 1.0 | | | | 1.0 | | | | | 1.0 | | | | |
-| -------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| 0.8 | | | | 0.8 | | | | | 0.8 | | | | |
-| ycaruccA | | | | ycaruccA | | | | | ycaruccA | | | | |
-| 0.6 | | | | 0.6 | | | | | 0.6 | | | | |
-| 0.4 | | | | 0.4 | | | | | 0.4 | | | | |
-| 0.2 | | | | 0.2 | | | | | 0.2 | | | | |
-Chance Scratchpad LINC (ours) Chance Scratchpad LINC (ours) Chance Scratchpad LINC (ours)
-Naive Chain-of-Thought Naive Chain-of-Thought Naive Chain-of-Thought
-| 0.0 | 0 1 | 2 3 4 | 5 | 0.0 | 0 1 | 2 3 | 4 | 5 | 0.0 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 5 |
-| --- | -------------- | ----------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --------- | ----------- | --- | --- |
-| | | Proof Depth | | | Proof Depth | | | | | | Proof Depth | | |
-| | (a)StarCoder+. | | | | (b)GPT-3.5. | | | | | (c)GPT-4. | | | |
-Figure4: AccuracypernecessaryproofdepthinProofWriter. Accuraciesreportedareforbootstrapped10-way
-majorityvote,andshadedareascover±1bootstrappedstandarddeviation. Black,dottedlinesreflecttheexpected
-successrateofguessingarandomlabel,whichis1/3inallsubsetsperourexperimentdesign.
-WefocusoncomparingGPT-4+CoTvs. onesymbolNaziGermanPolitician,causingthe
-methods?
-GPT-4+LINConFOLIO,sincetheiroverallperfor- informationthathewasindependentlyNazi,Ger-
-mance is very similar (75.3% vs. 72.5% average man, or a politician to be lost. As a result, LINC
-Uncertain
-accuracy). We leave an analysis of StarCoder+’s predicted instead of the ground truth
-| predictionsonFOLIOtoAppendixG. | | | | | | labelTrue. | | | | | | | |
-| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-5.1 QualitativeAnalysis Premise: Heinrich Scmidt was a Nazi German
-politician.
-Qualitatively,wefindthatLINCandCoThavecom-
-| | | | | | | FOL:NaziGermanPolitician | | | | (HeinrichSchmidt) | | | |
-| ------- | --------- | -------------- | --- | ------- | ------- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ------- | --- |
-| pletely | different | failure modes. | | We give | a high- | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | Conclusion(Prover9:Uncertain):Heinrich | | | | | | Schmidt | was |
-leveloverviewandabbreviatedexamplesofeach
-German.
-failuremodehere,leavingfulldetailedexamples
-| toAppendixE. | | | | | | FOL:German(HeinrichSchmidt) | | | | | | | |
-| ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-First,wedetailthefailuremodesforLINC:
-| | | | | | | L3: | FOL | contains | syntax | | errors. | Across | all |
-| --- | --- | ---------------- | -------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | -------- | ------ | --- | ------- | ------ | --- |
-| L1: | FOL | fails to capture | implicit | | informa- | | | | | | | | |
-tionnotmentionedinthepremises. Often,there generations, we find that the FOL expressions
-| | | | | | | sometimes | | contain | syntax | errors: | 38% | for | Star- |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ------- | ------ | ------- | --- | --- | ----- |
-isobviousinformationnotexplicitlylistedinthe
-CoderPlus,24%forGPT-3.5,and13%forGPT-4.
-premisesthatisnecessarytoexplicitlyencodein
-FOLinordertosuccessfullymakeadesireddeduc- The most common error is that the same symbol
-| | | | | | | is used | with | multiple | arities. | | As an | example, | if |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ---- | -------- | -------- | --- | ----- | -------- | --- |
-tion. Forexample,inthesnippetbelowonemust
-| | | | | | | Summer(July4)andLoves(Alex, | | | | | Summer)were | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- |
-encodeinFOLtheimplicitassumptionthatHarry
-Summer
-isaperson(Person(Harry)). both present in a FOL translation, would
-haveamultiplearityviolation.
-| P re m | ise 1 : W | h e n a person reads | a book, | that | person | | | | | | | | |
-| ------ | --------- | -------------------- | ------- | ---- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-Next,wedetailthreefailuremodesforCoT:
-| ga i ns | k n o w | l e dg e. | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| ------- | ------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-C1: CoTconcludessomethingdifferentthan
-| FOL:all | x. | all y. (Person(x) | | & Reads(x, | y) & | | | | | | | | |
-| ------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-Book(y) -> Gains(x, Knowledge)) it suggests. One common mistake we often see
-withtheCoTapproachisthatitgeneratesachainof
-| Premise2: | | Harry read the | book "Walden" | | by Henry | | | | | | | | |
-| --------- | --- | -------------- | ------------- | --- | -------- | --------- | --- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | --- | ---- | ------- |
-| Thoreau. | | | | | | reasoning | | indicating | uncertainty, | | but | then | asserts |
-FOL:Reads(Harry, Walden) thattheconclusionisfalse. Anexampleofthisis
-Conclusion (Prover9: Uncertain): Harry gains shownbelow,whereGPT-4suggeststhereis“no
-| knowledge. | | | | | | evidence” | | for the | conclusion | | but then | deduces | it |
-| ---------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- |
-| FOL:Gains(Harry, | | Knowledge) | | | | false. | | | | | | | |
-L2: FOLfailstocaptureinformationexplic-
-(GPT-4IncorrectCoT):Let’sthinkstepbystep.Wewant
-itlymentionedinthepremisesduetothechoice to evaluate if platypus are reptiles. We know from the
-premisesthatplatypusaremammalsandthattheyhaveno
-| ofrepresentation. | | Evenwheninformationisex- | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| ----------------- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --------- | ---- | ------- | ---- | ----- | -------- |
-| | | | | | | teeth. | The | fact that | some | mammals | have | teeth | does not |
-plicitlywritteninthepremises,thechoiceofhow
-contradictthefactthatplatypus,althoughmammals,donot
-theNLisrepresentedinFOLcanleadtolostinfor- haveteeth.Moreover,thestatementabouthumanshaving
-teethisunrelatedtotheclassificationofplatypus.There’s
-| mation. | Intheexamplebelow, | | thefactthatHein- | | | | | | | | | | |
-| ------- | ------------------ | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-noevidenceinthepremisesthatwouldsuggestplatypusare
-richwasaNaziGermanpoliticianiscapturedby
-reptiles.Therefore,thestatementisfalse.
-
-T
-ru
-e
-F a
-lse
-U
-n ce
-rta
-in
-E
-rro
-r
-Tr u
-e
-Fals
-e
-ert ai
-n
-Err
-or
-nc
-U
-Reference Label
-lebaL
-detciderP
-100 T
-ru
-39 4 1 0 e
-80
-F a
-0 31 0 0
-lse
-60 U
-n ce
-rta
-23 18 62 0 40 in
-E
-20 rro
-1 1 2 0 r
-0
-Tr u
-e
-Fals
-e
-ert ai
-n
-Err
-or
-nc
-U
-Reference Label
-(a)ConfusionmatrixforLINC.
-lebaL
-detciderP
-100
-50 1 7 0
-80
-3 38 9 0
-60
-10 15 49 0 40
-20
-0 0 0 0
+| about one | aspect | of a | scientific | entity | or | process, | | | | | | | |
+| --------- | ------ | ---- | ---------- | ------ | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+Corpus
+| | | | | | source.2 | | | N=601 | | | | | |
+| --------- | ----------- | --- | ---- | -------- | -------- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+| which can | be verified | | from | a single | | For | | | | | | | |
+Citing
+| instance,“TheR | | ofthenovelcoronavirusis2.5” | | | | | | | | | | | |
+| -------------- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
0
-(b)ConfusionmatrixforChain-of-Thought.
-C
-o
-rre
-ct
-In
-co rre
-ct
-ect ect
-orr orr C nc
-I
-LINC Outcome
-emoctuO
-ToC
-100 L IN 1.0
-C
-1
-80 108 29 0.8
-C o
-S T 0.22 1
-60 c ra
-tc 0.6
-h
-p
-a 40 d 0.21 0.54 1
-0.4
-24 21 N
-20 a iv
-e 0.14 0.52 0.56 1
-0.2
-0
-C T d e
-LI N C o c h p a N ai v at
-cr
-S
-(c) Comparing the consistency of LINC vs. (d)Similaritybetweenincorrectpredictionsofeachmethod,
-Chain-of-Thought. i.e.,(A wrong == B wrong) / (A wrong or B wrong).
-Figure5: AnalyzingandcomparingthemistakesmadebyGPT-4ontheFOLIOdataset.
-C2: CoTmakesincorrectlogicaldeductions. (GPT-4IncorrectCoT):Let’sthinkstepbystep.Wewant
-WhiletherearemanyinstanceswhereCoTmakes toevaluateifMikehasanF1visa.Fromthepremises,we
-know that Mike is an international student and needs to
-incorrectlogicaldeductions,onecommondeduc-
-applyforCPTifhewantstoworkintheUS.Wealsoknow
-tion mistake is the structure “if B is true and thataninternationalstudentintheUSwithanF1visaneeds
-A → B, then A is true”. In the example shown toapplyforCPTorOPTifthestudentwantstoworkinthe
-US.So,itisclearthatMikehasanF1visasincehefitsthe
-below,weseethisincorrectdeductionwhereAis
-criteria.Therefore,theconclusionistrue.
-“MikehasanF1visa”andBis“Mikeneedstoap-
-plyforCPTorOPTifhewantstoworkintheUS”. C3: CoTfailstofindcomplexpathsofreason-
-We note that making this type of logical mistake ing. We find that with all three models, CoT fails
-isoftencalledthefallacyoftheconverse,andthat whenthepathofreasoningnecessarytomakethe
-humansarenotimmunetoit,either. deduction is complex. Sometimes, CoT has diffi-
-cultygettingstarted,andothertimes,itgetsstuck
-Premise1: InternationalstudentsinUShaveeitheranF1
-inthemiddleofareasoningchain.
-visaoraJ1visa.
-Premise2:AninternationalstudentinUSwithanF1visa 5.2 QuantitativeAnalysis
-needstoapplyforCPTorOPTifthestudentwantstowork
-intheUS. 1. ComparedtoCoT,LINChasworserecallbut
-betterprecisiononTrue/Falsepredictions. To
-Premise3:Mikeisaninternationalstudent.
-seethis,weplottedtheconfusionmatricesinFig-
-Premise4:MikeneedstoapplyforCPTifhewantstowork
-ure 5b (CoT) and Figure 5a (LINC). Looking just
-intheUS.
-at the distributions of predicted labels of the two
-Conclusion(GroundTruth: Uncertain): MikehasanF1
-visa.
-methods,weseethatCoTpredicts32%True,27%
-
-| False, | and41%Uncertain, | | | whileLINCpredicts | | | | | | | | |
-| ------------------------------------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | vs. thenumberofinstanceswhereatleastoneof | | | | | |
-| 24%True,17%False,and57%Uncertain(with | | | | | | | themiswrong. | | | | | |
-2%ofpredictionsthrowinganerror). Notably,we Figure5dshowsthepairwisesimilaritybetween
-observethatLINCpredictsUncertainmuchmore
-| | | | | | | | our four | methods, | highlighting | | that | the similar- |
-| ---------- | --- | ---- | -------- | --------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | -------- | -------------- | --- | ---- | ------------- |
-| frequently | | than | CoT (57% | vs. 41%). | To | under- | | LINC’s | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | ity between | | mispredictions | | | and the other |
-stand why, note that the translation from natural methods’mispredictions(0.14,0.21,0.22)ismuch
-languagetoFOLisalossyprocess: recallthatin lower than the similarity between any pair of the
-L1andL2,wesawthattheinformationconveyed in-context reasoning methods (0.52, 0.54, 0.56).
-throughtheFOLissometimesasubsetoftheinfor-
-| | | | | | | | These results | suggest | | that for | GPT-4 | on FOLIO, |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ------- | --- | -------- | ----- | --------- |
-mationintheoriginalpremises. Removingpieces LINCistheonlymethodweevaluatewhichsignifi-
-ofcrucialinformationthatwereonthecriticalpath cantlyaltersthewaysinwhichthemodelfailsto
-todeducingTrue/Falsemaythenleaveanuncer-
-reason.
-| tainconclusion. | | | Atthesametime,whiletheFOL | | | | | | | | | |
-| ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| translationssometimesdonotretainalloftheinfor- | | | | | | | 6 RelatedWork | | | | | |
-mationintheNL,theyrarelycontainfalseinforma-
-tionthatwasnotprovidedintheoriginalpremises. Reasoning in LLMs: Our work contributes to
-| | | | | | | | the wider | literature | on | eliciting | natural | language |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | ------- | -------- |
-Therefore,LINC’sprecisionwhenpredictingTrue
-| | False | | | | | | reasoning | capabilities | | in models. | | Although we |
-| --- | ----- | ------- | ---------- | -------- | --- | ------- | --------- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------- |
-| or | | is very | high (93%) | compared | to | that of | | | | | | |
-CoT(81%),butthiscomesatthecostoflowerre- havefocusedhereoncomparinganeurosymbolic
-| | | | | | | | approach | to Scratchpad | | (Nye | et | al., 2021) and |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ---- | --- | -------------- |
-callonTrue/Falsepredictions(60%forLINCvs.
-| 75%forCoT). | | | | | | | Chain-of-Thought | | prompting | | (Wei | et al., 2022; |
-| ----------- | ---- | --- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | ---------------- | ------- | --------- | ---- | ------- | ------------- |
-| | LINC | | CoT | | | | Kojima | et al., | 2022; | Wang | et al., | 2023b), many |
-| | 2. | and | mispredict | on | different | ex- | | | | | | |
-amples. EarlierinSec. 5.1,wesawthatLINCand other similar or related techniques have been de-
-velopedinrecentyears;theseincludeleast-to-most
-CoTexhibitdifferentfailuremodes,whichsuggests
-prompting(Zhouetal.,2023),selection-inference
-| theyshouldfailondifferentexamples. | | | | | Indeed,we | | | | | | | |
-| ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-findthatthisisthecaseinourexperimentsonFO- (Creswelletal.,2023),backwardchaining(Tafjord
-etal.,2022;Kazemietal.,2023),andself-taught
-| LIO: | Figure | 5c | shows a | 2 × 2 confusion | | matrix | | | | | | |
-| ---- | ------ | --- | ------- | --------------- | --- | ------ | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- |
-| | | | | | | | reasoning(Zelikmanetal.,2022). | | | | | Someofthese |
-whichcompareswhetherornoteachmethod’spre-
-| | | | | | | | techniques | have | been | formalized | | under the lan- |
-| ------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------- | -------- | ------ | ---------- | ---- | ---- | ---------- | --- | -------------- |
-| diction | | was correct. | We | observe | that out | of the | | | | | | |
-24 + 29 + 21 = 74 samples where at least one guage model cascades framework (Dohan et al.,
-2022).
-methodmakesanincorrectprediction,only21are
-| | | | | | | | Semantic | parsing: | | The | notion | of a semantic |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------- |
-shared. Onacloserexaminationofthese21sam-
-ples,wefindthat16areambiguousorincorrectin parserrestsonalongtraditionofresearch(Kamath
-theirspecification(detailsinAppendixE.4),sothe andDas,2019)whoseaimistomapfragmentsof
-naturallanguageintouseful,symbolicmeaningrep-
-twomethodsonlyagreeon5well-formedsamples.
-ThissuggeststhatLINCandCoTarecomplementary resentations(ZelleandMooney,1996;Zettlemoyer
-methodswhichfailunderdistinctcircumstances. andCollins,2005;Berantetal.,2013;Liangetal.,
-| | | | | | | | 2013;Wongetal.,2023). | | | Unlikeearlierworksin | | |
-| --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --------- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- |
-| | 3. Mispredictions | | of | in-context | reasoning | | | | | | | |
-thistradition,weusealanguagemodeltogenerate
-| baselines | | are more | similar | to each | other | than | | | | | | |
-| --------- | --- | -------- | ------- | ------- | ----- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-theyarewithmispredictionsofLINC.Asanex- thesemanticparse,whichisamethodunderactive
-tensionofthepreviousanalysis,wenextinvestigate investigationinrecentyears(ShinandVanDurme,
-2022;Drozdovetal.,2022;Luetal.,2022;Wang
-thecorrelationbetweenthemispredictionsofeach
-| pair | of methods. | | To do so, | we define | a similarity | | etal.,2023a). | | | | | |
-| ---- | ----------- | --- | --------- | --------- | ------------ | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-score between two methods A and B as follows: Neurosymbolic approaches for reasoning:
-GivenadatasetD withN rowsandgroundtruth Methodswhichcombineneuralnetworkswithsym-
-| | | }N | }N | | | | bolictechniqueshaveseenbroaduptakeindomains | | | | | |
-| -------- | --- | ------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| labels{A | | i and{B | i | fromtwomethodsA | | | | | | | | |
-| | | i=1 | | i=1 | | | | | | | | |
-andB,wedefine adjacent to logical reasoning, such as generating
-| | | | (cid:80)N | | | | outputs | consistent | with | a pre-existing | | symbolic |
-| --- | --- | --- | --------- | ----- | ------ | --- | ------- | ---------- | ---- | -------------- | --- | -------- |
-| | | | | 1[A = | B ̸= R | ] | | | | | | |
-sim (A,B) ≜ i=1 i i i knowledge base (Marra et al., 2019; Manhaeve
-| | D | | (cid:80)N | | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | | 1[A | ̸= R | orB ̸= | R ] | | | | | | |
-i=1 i i i i et al., 2018; Zhang et al., 2023a) and performing
-Inwords,sim (A,B)measuresthenumberofin- algorithmicreasoningoversymbolicallygrounded
-D
-stanceswhereAandBarewronginidenticalways inputs (Ebrahimi et al., 2021; Ibarz et al., 2022;
-
-Velicˇkovic´ etal.,2022). Asforlogicalreasoning themodeldoesnotneedtolearnhoworwhereto
-withLLMsinparticular,therehavebeenafewdif- invokethetool: instead,thetoolispredefinedand
-ferentproposalsforwhenandhowtobestcombine is applied after the generation step finishes. For
-theLLMwithasymboliccomponent. Zhangetal. example,Gaoetal.(2023)andDrorietal.(2022)
-(2022)finetunealanguagemodeltosynthesizepo- solvemathematicalreasoningtasksbygenerating
-tential facts paired with likelihoods and then use PythonprogramsandusingthePythoninterpreter
-ahandwrittendifferentiablesymbolicreasonerin as the tool, Liu et al. (2023) approach physical
-ordertodeduceotherfacts. WeirandVanDurme reasoning tasks with a physical simulator as the
-(2022) relax thesolver byinstead training neural tool, and Wong et al. (2023) tackle cognitively-
-“entailment”modelstodecideifandhowagivenin- inspiredprobabilisticreasoningtaskswithChurch
-ferenceruleappliesateachstage. Concurrentlyto (aprobabilisticprogramminglanguage)asthetool.
-thiswork,Logic-LM(Panetal.,2023)andSATLM In the second class, the model must learn to in-
-(Yeetal.,2023)proposeneurosymbolicapproaches voke the tool by itself, meaning that the model
-whichhavemuchincommonwithLINC.However, mustgenerateexplicitAPIcallstothetoolwhich
-otherthanthemodelsanddatasetsconsidered,their are then executed when those calls are decoded
-contributions have a few key differences to ours. (Schick et al., 2023; Thoppilan et al., 2022; Yao
-First,weplaceparticularemphasisonestablishing etal.,2022;Chengetal.,2023). Ourworkbelongs
-anin-depthunderstandingoftherelativebenefits to the former class, with the task at hand being
-and drawbacks of a neurosymbolic approach to logicalreasoningandthetoolavailableforusebe-
-reasoningwhencomparedtotraditionalin-context ingaFOLsolver(Prover9). Wereferthereaderto
-reasoningstrategieslikeChain-of-Thought. Sec- Mialonetal.(2023)foramorethoroughsurveyof
-ond, Logic-LM employs a self-refinement strat- recentworkinthetool-usageliterature.
-egy, which has shown promise across code gen-
-7 Conclusion
-erationandNLPtasks(Zhangetal.,2023b;Chen
-etal.,2023a;Pengetal.,2023;Madaanetal.,2023;
-In this work, we present LINC: Logical Inference
-Olaussonetal.,2023)butwhichwedonotconsider
-viaNeurosymbolicComputation,aneurosymbolic
-here. Third,SATLMstudiesarithmeticreasoning
-approachforscalablelogicalreasoningwithlarge
-in addition to logical reasoning, showcasing the
-languagemodels. OurexperimentsshowthatLINC
-versatilityoftheneurosymbolicapproach. Fourth,
-leadstosignificantperformancegainsinnearlyev-
-andfinally,weuseanFOLrepresentationthatwe
-erysettingweconsider,andthatitsupportsgener-
-believeiseasierforhumanstoreadandmodelsto
-alizationtosettingswherethemodelhastoreason
-learn. We highly encourage interested readers to
-aboutamuchlargersetofpremisesthanitisshown
-studythesetwocontemporaryworksindetail.
-inthein-contextlearningexamples. Furthermore,
-Autoformalization: Theideaofautomatically carryingoutaquantitativeandqualitativeanalysis
-translating natural language into structured sym- of the mistakes made by LINC, we find evidence
-bolic representations that programs can reason thatitmaycomplementpurelyin-contextreasoning
-abouthasgainedpopularityinthedomainofformal strategiessuchasChain-of-Thoughtprompting,
-mathematics,leadingtoautoformalizationsystems sincetheydiffergreatlyinthetypesandfrequen-
-forseveraltheoremproversincludingMizar(Wang ciesofmistakesmade. Thisworkthussupportsthe
-etal.,2018,2020),Lean3(Azerbayevetal.,2023), efficacy of neurosymbolic approaches to natural
-andIsabelle(Wuetal.,2022). Outsideformalmath- languagereasoning,settingthestageforcontinued
-ematics,autoformalizationhasalsobeenappliedto advancesincombininglargelanguagemodelsand
-translatingnaturallanguageintosystemspecifica- symbolic reasoning engines; we discuss several
-tionlanguagessuchastemporallogic(Hahnetal., promisingfuturedirectionsinAppendixA.
-2022;Cosleretal.,2023;Chenetal.,2023b).
-8 Limitations
-Toolusage: Ourworkisheavilyinspiredbyre-
-cent work on tool usage. The central idea in this Narrowscopeoflogicalreasoningtaskconsid-
-lineofresearchistoaugmentlanguagemodelswith ered: Inthiswork,wefocusexclusivelyononeas-
-externaltoolssuchascalculators,codeinterpreters pectoflogicalreasoning: predictingthetruthvalue
-and information retrieval systems. We further di- of a conclusion given a set of natural language
-videtheseworksintotwoclasses. Inthefirstclass, premises. Here, we consider a setting where the
+| is valid, | but opinion-based | | | statements | like | “The | | | Seed | | | | |
+| --------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ---- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+governmentshouldrequirepeopletostandsixfeet
+N=140
+| apart to | stop coronavirus” | | | are not. | Compound | | | | | | | | |
+| -------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+claimslike“Aerosolizedcoronavirusdropletscan
+| travelatleast6feetandcanremainintheairfor3 | | | | | | | | | Co- | | | | |
+| ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+cited
+hours”shouldbesplitintotwoatomicclaims.
+Claim
+| Claims | in SCIFACT | | are | natural | – they | are de- | | N=4,259 | | | | | |
+| ------ | ---------- | --- | --- | ------- | ------ | ------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+rivedfromcitationsentences,orcitances(Nakov Cardiac injury is
+common in critical
+| et al., 2004), | that | occur | naturally | in | scientific | ar- | | | Dis- | | | | |
+| -------------- | ---- | ----- | --------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+cases of COVID-19.
+tractor
+| ticles. This | is | similar | to political | | fact-checking | | | | | | | | |
+| ------------ | --- | ------- | ------------ | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+datasetssuchasUKPSnopes(Hanselowskietal.,
+2019),whichusepoliticalfact-checkingwebsites
+| | | | | | | | Figure | 2: | Corpus construction. | | Citing | abstracts | are |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | -------------------- | --- | ------ | --------- | --- |
+as a source of natural claims. On the other hand, identified for each seed document. A claim is written
+basedonthesourcecitanceinthecitingabstract.
+| claimsinthepopular | | | FEVERdataset(Thorneetal., | | | | | | | | | | |
+| ------------------ | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+2018)aresynthetic,sincetheyarecreatedbyanno-
+| tators by | mutating | sentences | | from | the Wikipedia | | | | | | | | |
+| --------- | -------- | --------- | --- | ---- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+Abstractsthatsupportorrefuteeachclaimarean-
+articlesthatwillserveasevidence.
+| | | | | | | | notated | with | rationales. | We | describe | our | corpus |
+| ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | -------- | ------- | ----- | ------- | ---- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------ |
+| Supporting | and | refuting | | evidence | In most | fact- | | | | | | | |
+creationandannotationprocess.
+checkingwork,claimsareassignedaglobaltruth
+labelbasedontheentiretyoftheavailableevidence. 3.1 Datasourceandcorpusconstruction
+ForexampleinFEVER,theclaim“BarackObama
+| | | | | | | | Toconstruct | | SCIFACT,weuseS2ORC(Loetal., | | | | |
+| ---------- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- |
+| wasthe44th | PresidentoftheUnitedStates”canbe | | | | | | | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | 2020), | a | publicly-available | | corpus | of millions | of |
+verifiedusingWikipediaasanevidencesource.
+| | | | | | | | scientificarticles. | | Toensurethatdocumentsinour | | | | |
+| ----- | ------- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------ |
+| While | SCIFACT | claimsareindeedverifiableas- | | | | | | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | dataset | are | of high quality, | | we randomly | | sample |
+sertionsaboutscientificfindings,accuratelyassign-
+articlesfromamanuallycuratedcollectionofwell-
+ingaglobaltruthlabeltoascientificclaim(givena
+regardedjournalsspanningdomainsfrombasicsci-
+fixedscientificcorpus)requiresasystematicreview ence(e.g.,Cell,Nature)toclinicalmedicine(e.g.,
+| byateamofexperts. | | | Inthisworkwefocusonthe | | | | | | | | | | |
+| ----------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+JAMA,BMJ).Thefulllistofjournalsisincludedin
+| simplertaskofassigning | | | SUPPORTSor | | REFUTES | | | | | | | | |
+| ---------------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+| | | | | | | | AppendixC.1. | | Werestricttoarticleswithatleast | | | | |
+relationstoindividualclaim-abstractpairs. 10 citations. The resulting collection is referred
+Each SUPPORTS or REFUTESrelationbetween to as our seed set. We use the S2ORC citation
+claimandabstractmustbejustifiedbyatleastone
+| | | | | | | | graph | to | sample source | citances | from | citing | arti- |
+| ---------- | ----------- | --- | ---- | ------- | ---------- | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | ------------- | -------- | --------------- | ------ | ----- |
+| rationale. | A rationale | | is a | minimal | collection | of | | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | cleswhichcitetheseseedarticles. | | | | Ifacitancecites | | |
+sentenceswhich,takentogetheraspremisesinthe otherarticlesnotintheseedset,werefertothese
+contextoftheabstract,canreasonablybejudgedby
+| | | | | | | | asco-cited | | articlesandaddthemtothecorpus,as | | | | |
+| -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | -------------------------------- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- |
+| adomainexpertasimplyingtheclaim. | | | | | Rationales | | | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | depictedinFigure2. | | | Thecontentofthecitedab- | | | |
+facilitatethedevelopmentofinterpretablemodels stractsencompassesadiversearrayoftopicswithin
+whichnotonlyhavetheabilitytomakelabelpre- biomedicine,asshowninFigure3. Themajority
+dictions,butcanalsoidentifytheexactsentences
+| | | | | | | | of | citances | used for | SCIFACT | cite | only | the seed |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | -------- | ------- | ---- | ---- | -------- |
+thatarenecessaryfortheirdecisions.
+article(noco-citedarticles),aswefoundininitial
+annotationexperimentsthatthesecitancestended
+| 3 The | SCIFACT | dataset | | | | | | | | | | | |
+| ----- | ------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+toyieldspecific,easy-to-verifyclaims.
+| | | | | | | | To | expand | the corpus, | we | identify | five | papers |
+| ----------- | --- | ------- | -------- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | -------- | ---- | ------ |
+| The SCIFACT | | dataset | consists | of 1,409 | scientific | | | | | | | | |
+claims3 verifiedagainstacorpusof5,183abstracts. citedinthesamepaperaseachsourcecitancebut
+inadifferentparagraph,andaddthesetothecor-
+2Requiringannotatorstosearchmultiplesourcesincreases pusasdistractorabstracts. Theseabstractsoften
+cognitiveburdenanddecreasesannotationquality.
+3SCIFACTiscomparableinsizetorecentscientificdatasets has1,000 questions), and informationextraction(e.g. Sci-
+for tasks such as QA (e.g. PubMedQA (Jin et al., 2019) ERC(Luanetal.,2018)has500annotatedabstracts).
+7536
-premisesandconclusionareexpressedinrelatively dleproblemsrequiringhigher-orderlogics(Miller
-short statements, which makes the formalization andNadathur,1986;Higginbotham,1998). Also,
-tasktractable. Inparticular,ProofWriter’snatural in many settings it is desirable to work with non-
-language statements are synthetically generated, classicallogics(Priest,2008;Burgess,2009). Al-
-so they can be easily and accurately parsed into ternativetheoremproverswouldbeneededforsuch
-FOL. FOLIO reflects a more naturalistic dataset, problems. AmethodlikeLINCcanbenaturallyex-
-soweseeahigherfailurerateinLINC’ssemantic
-| | | | | | | tended | to those | settings, | but | exactly | how | well it |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | -------- | --------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- |
-parsingstep. However,theformalizationtaskbe- worksthererequiresfurtherinvestigations.
-comesmoredifficultifthepremisesareinlonger Computational costs: Implementing our ap-
-paragraphform,suchasinquestionansweringor proachwithbothGPTmodelsandtheStarCoder+
-contradictiondetectionfromcontextpassages. This modelrequiresnon-trivialresources. Theformer
-| is because | the same | piece | of | information | can be | | | | | | | |
-| ---------- | -------- | ----- | --- | ----------- | ------ | -------- | -------- | --- | ------ | ------------ | --- | ------- |
-| | | | | | | requires | reliance | on | costly | API requests | | and the |
-formalizedinavarietyofways,andthereisalot latterdedicatedGPUsforinference. Especiallyas
-ofinformationthatmustbepragmaticallyinferred weusemajorityvoting,manygenerationsmustbe
-toarriveattheproperconclusion. madeforeachquery,increasingthecomputational
-requirements.
-| Generalizability | | of | qualitative | evaluation: | | | | | | | | |
-| ---------------- | ------------ | ---- | ----------- | ----------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | LINC | | CoT | | | | | | | | |
-| While | we find that | | and | produce | com- | | | | | | | |
-plementarymistakesforournaturallanguagerea- 9 Acknowledgements
-soningtask,itisunclearifthisresultalsoholdstrue
-| | | | | | | T.X. Olausson | | is supported | | by the | Defense | Ad- |
-| ---------- | ---------- | ---- | --- | -------- | ---------- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------ | ------- | --- |
-| in similar | scenarios, | such | as | the ones | considered | | | | | | | |
-vancedResearchProjectsAgency(DARPA)under
-| inPAL(Gaoetal.,2023),Logic-LM,and | | | | | SATLM. | | | | | | | |
-| --------------------------------- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | --------------- | ------ | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | theASKEMprogram,awardHR00112220042. | | | | | | A. |
-| This is | due to the | difference | | in intermediate | lan- | | | | | | | |
-GuissupportedbytheNationalScienceFounda-
-| guageandoveralllogicalreasoningtask. | | | | | However, | | | | | | | |
-| ------------------------------------ | ---- | --- | -------- | --------- | -------- | ---------- | -------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | -------- | ----- |
-| | | | | | | tion (NSF) | Graduate | | Research | Fellowship | | under |
-| we hypothesize | that | it | will and | encourage | future | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | Grant No. | 2141064. | | B. Lipkin | | and C.E. | Zhang |
-investigationinthisdirection.
-| | | | | | | aresupportedbyMITPresidentialFellowships. | | | | | | A. |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-Moresophisticatedreasoningtechniques: Re- Solar-LezamaissupportedbytheNationalScience
-| cent work | has proposed | | more | sophisticated | tech- | | | | | | | |
-| --------- | ------------------------ | --- | ---- | ------------- | ---------- | -------------------- | ----- | --- | ----- | ------------------- | --- | ------- |
-| | | | | | | Foundation | (NSF) | and | Intel | Corporation | | through |
-| niques | beyond chain-of-thought, | | | such | as tree of | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | NSFGrantCCF:2217064. | | | | J.B.Tenenbaumissup- | | |
-thoughts (Yao et al., 2023), program of thoughts, portedbyAFOSRGrant#FA9550-22-1-0387and
-(Chenetal.,2022),orusingretrievalinchain-of-
-| | | | | | | the MIT-IBM | | Watson | AI | Lab. R.P. | Levy | is sup- |
-| ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ----------- | --- | ------ | --- | --------- | ---- | ------- |
-| thoughtprompting(Yasunagaetal.,2023). | | | | | These | | | | | | | |
-portedbyagrantfromtheSimonsFoundationto
-have potential to improve and eliminate some of theSimonsCenterfortheSocialBrainatMIT.
-thefailuremodesofthetraditionalCoTmethod.
-| | | | | | In | Wethankouranonymousreviewersfortheirin- | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-addition,ideassuchasself-repairmayalsoserve
-| | | | | | | sightfulfeedbackandrecommendations. | | | | | | Wethank |
-| --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- |
-| toimprovethesefailuremodes. | | | | Itremainsfuture | | | | | | | | |
-themembersoftheComputerAidedProgramming,
-work to do a more thorough investigation of the Computational Psycholinguistics, and Computa-
-| efficacy | of these | techniques, | | though there | is also | | | | | | | |
-| -------- | -------- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | ------- | ---------------- | --- | ------- | ------ | --- | ---------------- | --- |
-| | | | | | | tional Cognitive | | Science | groups | | for constructive | |
-preliminaryevidencethattheystilllackreasoning
-| | | | | | | commentaryatvariousstagesofthisproject. | | | | | | We |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-capabilities(Huangetal.,2023).
-thankYoonKimforhelpfulsuggestionsandcom-
-Scalability: It is unclear how well LINC will mentsonpiecesoftheinitialprojectproposal. In
-perform as the number of premises scales. First, addition,wethankZhaofengWuandSimengHan
-onemistakeinformalizationcanleadtoanincor- fordiscussionsregardingtheFOLIOdataset.
-rectdeduction,andmorepremisesleadtoahigher
-| probability | of errors. | | Second, | in the | deduction | | | | | | | |
-| ----------- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ------ | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-References
-| stage, while | many | fast | algorithms | (e.g., | forward- | | | | | | | |
-| ------------ | ---- | ---- | ---------- | ------ | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-andbackward-chaining)existforlogicaldeduction,
-| | | | | | | Cem Anil, | Yuhuai | Wu, | Anders | Andreassen, | | Aitor |
-| -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | ------ | ------ | ----------- | --------- | ----- |
-| thegeneralproblemisstillNP-hard. | | | | Therefore,the | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | Lewkowycz, | | Vedant | Misra, | Vinay | Ramasesh, | Am- |
-theoremprovermaytakealongtimeinpractice. broseSlone,GuyGur-Ari,EthanDyer,andBehnam
-| | | | | | | Neyshabur. | | 2022. | Exploring | length | generalization | |
-| ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ---------- | -------- | ------- | --------- | ----------- | -------------- | --------- |
-| Otherlogicsbeyondfirst-orderlogic: | | | | | Inthis | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | in large | language | models. | | In Advances | | in Neural |
-work, we exclusively focus on first-order logic. InformationProcessingSystems,volume35,pages
-| However, | FOL is | not | expressive | enough | to han- | | | | | | | |
-| -------- | ------ | --- | ---------- | ------ | ------- | ------------ | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | 38546–38556. | | (Citedonpg.1) | | | | |
+cationmodelperformspoorly,suggestingthatthe
+Humans
+| | Mice | | | | negationprocessdidnotintroducesevereartifacts. | | | | | | |
+| --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+Animals
+Female
+| | Male | | | | 3.3 Claimverification | | | | | | |
+| --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+Middle Aged
+Aged
+| | Adult | | | | AnnotationForeachclaim,alloftheclaim’scited | | | | | | |
+| --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+Cell Line
+Signal Transduction abstracts are annotated for evidence. Annotators
+RNA
+| | Receptors | | | | areshownasingleclaim-citedabstractpair,and | | | | | | |
+| --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+Gene Expression Regulation
+| | | | | | askedtolabelthepairas | | | SUPPORTS, | | REFUTES,or | |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ---------- | --- |
+Models
+Risk Factors
+| | | | | | NOINFO. | Althoughourtaskdefinitionallowsfora | | | | | |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+Cells
+Cell Differentiation
+| | Mutation | | | | singleclaimtobebothsupportedandrefuted(by | | | | | | |
+| --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+| | Microscopy | | | | differentabstracts)–anoccurrenceweobserveon | | | | | | |
+Infant
+| | | | | | real-world | COVID-19 | | claims | (§6.3) | – | this never |
+| --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------- | ---------- | -------- | --- | ------ | ------ | --- | ---------- |
+| | 0.0 | 0.2 | 0.4 0.6 | 0.8 1.0 | | | | | | | |
+Fraction of evidence abstracts
+| | | | | | occursinourdataset. | | | Eachclaimhasasinglelabel. | | | |
+| --------- | --------------- | --------- | ------- | ------- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | ----- |
+| | | | | | CountsforeachlabelareshowninTable2a. | | | | | | Over- |
+| Figure 3: | Most frequently | occurring | Medical | Subject | | | | | | | |
+all,theannotatorsfoundevidencein63%ofcited
+Headings(MeSH)terms(y-axis)amongcitedabstracts.
+MeSHisacontrolledvocabularyusedforindexingar- abstracts. Iftheannotatorassignsa SUPPORTS or
+ticles in PubMed. Topics range from clinical trial re- REFUTES label, they must also identify all ratio-
+ports(“Humans”,“RiskFactors”)tomolecularbiology nalesasdefinedin§2. Table2bprovidesstatistics
+(“CellLine”,“RNA”). onthenumberofsentencesperrationale,thenum-
+berofrationalesperclaim/abstractpair,andthe
+discusssimilartopicstotheevidencedocuments, number of evidence abstracts per claim. No ab-
+stracthasmorethan3rationalesforagivenclaim,
+| increasing | the difficulty | of abstract | retrieval | and | | | | | | | |
+| ---------- | -------------- | ----------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+andallrationalesconsistofatmostthreesentences.
+makingourmetricsmoreaccuratelyreflectthesys-
+| | | | | | RationalesinSCIFACTaremutuallyexclusive. | | | | | | 28 |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+tem’sperformanceonalargeresearchcorpus.
+rationalescontainnon-contiguoussentences.
+3.2 Claimwriting The verifiers included three NLP experts, five
+lifescienceundergraduates,andfivegraduatestu-
+AnnotationAnnotatorsareshownasourcecitance
+| | | | | | dents studying | | life sciences. | | Annotators | | verified |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | -------- |
+inthecontextofanarticle,andareaskedtowriteup
+| | | | | | claimsthattheydidnotwritethemselves. | | | | | | Annota- |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- |
+tothreeclaimsbasedonthecontentofthecitance;
+tionguidelinesareprovidedinAppendixD.
+| seeAppendixC.2foranexample. | | | Thisresultsin | | | | | | | | |
+| --------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------- | ------ | --- | ------------ | --- | ------- | --------- |
+| | | | | | SCIFACT | claims | | are verified | | against | abstracts |
+naturalclaimsbecausetheannotatordoesnotsee
+| | | | | | rather than | full | articles | since | (1) | abstracts | can be |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ---- | -------- | ----- | --- | --------- | ------ |
+thecitedarticle’sabstract–thecitedabstract–at
+annotatedmorescalably,(2)evidenceisfoundin
+| the time | of claim writing. | Annotators | are | asked | | | | | | | |
+| -------- | ----------------- | ---------- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+theabstractinmorethan60%ofcases,and(3)pre-
+toskipcitancesthatdonotmakestatementsabout
+viousattemptsatfull-documentannotationsuffered
+specificscientificfindings.
+fromlowannotatoragreement(§7).
+| The claim | writers included | | four experts | with | | | | | | | |
+| --------- | ---------------- | --- | ------------ | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+backgroundinscientificNLP,fifteenundergradu- QualityWeassign232claim-abstractpairsforin-
+| | | | | | dependent | re-annotation. | | The | label | agreement | is |
+| ------------- | ------------------ | --- | -------- | -------- | --------- | -------------- | --- | --- | ----- | --------- | --- |
+| ates studying | the life sciences, | | and four | graduate | | | | | | | |
+0.75Cohen’sκ,comparablewiththe0.68Fleiss’
+students(doctoralormedical)inthelifesciences.
+Detailedinformationontheannotatortrainingpro- κ reported in Thorne et al. (2018), and 0.70 Co-
+hen’sκreportedinHanselowskietal.(2019).
+| cess can | be found in Appendix | | C.3. The | claim- | | | | | | | To |
+| -------- | -------------------- | --- | -------- | ------ | ------- | --------- | ---------- | --- | --- | ----- | --------- |
+| | | | | | measure | rationale | agreement, | | we | treat | each sen- |
+writinginterfaceisshowninAppendixD.
+tenceaseitherclassifiedas“partofarationale”or
+| Claim negation | Unless | the authors | of the | source | | | | | | | |
+| -------------- | ------ | ----------- | ------ | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+“notpartofarationale”andcomputesentence-level
+| citance | were mistaken, | cited | articles should | pro- | | | | | | | |
+| --------------- | ------------------ | ----- | --------------- | -------- | ---------- | --------------------------- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- |
+| | | | | | agreement. | TheresultingCohen’sκis0.71. | | | | | |
+| vide supporting | evidence | for | the claims | made in | | | | | | | |
+| a citance. | To obtain examples | | where an | abstract | | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | 4 The | SCIFACT | | task | | | |
+REFUTESaclaim,anNLPexpertwrotenegations
+of existing claims, taking precautions not to bias TaskFormulationTheinputstoourtaskareasci-
+thenegationsbyusingobviouskeywordslike“not” entificclaimcandacorpusofabstractsA. Allab-
+(Schusteretal.,2019;Gururanganetal.,2018). In stractsa ∈ Aarelabeledasy(c,a) ∈ {SUPPORTS,
+§6.1, we demonstrate that a “claim-only” verifi- REFUTES, NOINFO } with respect to a claim c.
+7537
-Zhangir Azerbayev, Bartosz Piotrowski, Hailey language modeling with pathways. arXiv preprint
-Schoelkopf,EdwardWAyers,DragomirRadev,and arXiv:2204.02311. (Citedonpg.1)
-| Jeremy | Avigad. | 2023. | ProofNet: | Autoformalizing | | | | | | | |
-| ------ | ------- | ----- | --------- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-andformallyprovingundergraduate-levelmathemat-
-| | | | | | | | Matthias | Cosler, Christopher | | Hahn, | Daniel Men- |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------------- | --- | ----- | ----------- |
-ics. arXivpreprintarXiv:2302.12433. (Citedonpg. doza,FrederikSchmitt,andCarolineTrippel.2023.
-| 9) | | | | | | | nl2spec: | Interactivelytranslatingunstructurednatu- | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- |
-rallanguagetotemporallogicswithlargelanguage
-David Barker-Plummer, Jon Barwise, and John models. InComputerAidedVerification,pages383–
-| Etchemendy. | | 2011. Language, | | proof, | and logic, | 2 | | | | | |
-| ----------- | ------------------------------------ | --------------- | --- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- |
-| | | | | | | | 396,Cham.SpringerNatureSwitzerland. | | | | (Citedon |
-| edition. | CenterfortheStudyofLanguageandInfor- | | | | | | | | | | |
-pg.9)
-| mation. | (Citedonpg.2) | | | | | | | | | | |
-| ------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-AntoniaCreswell,MurrayShanahan,andIrinaHiggins.
-| Mohammad | Bavarian, | Heewoo | | Jun, Nikolas | Tezak, | | | | | | |
-| -------- | --------- | ------ | --- | ------------ | ------ | --- | ------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | 2023. Selection-inference:Exploitinglargelanguage | | | | |
-JohnSchulman,ChristineMcLeavey,JerryTworek,
-| | | | | | | | models | for interpretable | logical | reasoning. | In The |
-| -------- | ----- | ----- | --------- | -------- | --- | ---- | ------ | ----------------- | ------- | ---------- | ------ |
-| and Mark | Chen. | 2022. | Efficient | training | of | lan- | | | | | |
-EleventhInternationalConferenceonLearningRep-
-| guage | models | to fill in | the middle. | | arXiv preprint | | | | | | |
-| ----------------- | ------ | -------------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | resentations. | (Citedonpg.1,3,8) | | | |
-| arXiv:2207.14255. | | (Citedonpg.15) | | | | | | | | | |
-JonathanBerant,AndrewChou,RoyFrostig,andPercy David Dohan, Winnie Xu, Aitor Lewkowycz, Ja-
-Liang. 2013. Semantic parsing on Freebase from cob Austin, David Bieber, Raphael Gontijo Lopes,
-question-answerpairs. InProceedingsofthe2013 Yuhuai Wu, Henryk Michalewski, Rif A Saurous,
-Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Lan- JaschaSohl-Dickstein,etal.2022. Languagemodel
-| | | | | | | | cascades. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2207.10342. | | | (Cited |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | ------ |
-guageProcessing,pages1533–1544,Seattle,Wash-
-| ington,USA.AssociationforComputationalLinguis- | | | | | | | onpg.8) | | | | |
-| ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-tics. (Citedonpg.8)
-IddoDrori,SarahZhang,ReeceShuttleworth,Leonard
-Tom Brown, Benjamin Mann, Nick Ryder, Melanie Tang, Albert Lu, Elizabeth Ke, Kevin Liu, Linda
-Subbiah,JaredDKaplan,PrafullaDhariwal,Arvind
-| | | | | | | | Chen,SunnyTran,NewmanCheng,etal.2022. | | | | A |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-Neelakantan,PranavShyam,GirishSastry,Amanda
-neuralnetworksolves,explains,andgeneratesuni-
-Askell,etal.2020. Languagemodelsarefew-shot versitymathproblemsbyprogramsynthesisandfew-
-learners. InAdvancesinneuralinformationprocess- shotlearningathumanlevel. ProceedingsoftheNa-
-ingsystems,volume33,pages1877–1901. (Citedon tionalAcademyofSciences,119(32):e2123433119.
-pg.1,4)
-(Citedonpg.9)
-| JohnPBurgess.2009. | | Philosophicallogic. | | | Princeton | | | | | | |
-| ------------------ | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --------------- | --------- | -------- | ---- | -------- |
-| | | | | | | | Andrew Drozdov, | Nathanael | Schärli, | Ekin | Akyürek, |
-| UniversityPress. | | (Citedonpg.10) | | | | | | | | | |
-NathanScales,XinyingSong,XinyunChen,Olivier
-| | | | | | | | Bousquet, | and Denny | Zhou. | 2022. Compositional | |
-| ----- | ----- | -------- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | --------- | --------- | ----- | ------------------- | --- |
-| Wenhu | Chen, | Xueguang | Ma, | Xinyi | Wang, | and | | | | | |
-William W Cohen. 2022. Program of thoughts semanticparsingwithlargelanguagemodels. arXiv
-| | | | | | | | preprintarXiv:2209.15003. | | (Citedonpg.8) | | |
-| ---------- | ----------------------------------- | --------- | ------ | ----- | -------- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- |
-| prompting: | Disentanglingcomputationfromreason- | | | | | | | | | | |
-| ing for | numerical | reasoning | tasks. | arXiv | preprint | | | | | | |
-NouhaDziri,XimingLu,MelanieSclar,XiangLorraine
-| arXiv:2211.12588. | | (Citedonpg.10) | | | | | | | | | |
-| ----------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | -------------- | --- | ---------- | ----- |
-| | | | | | | | Li, LiweiJian, | BillYuchenLin, | | PeterWest, | Chan- |
-Xinyun Chen, Maxwell Lin, Nathanael Schärli, and dra Bhagavatula, Ronan Le Bras, Jena D Hwang,
-DennyZhou.2023a. Teachinglargelanguagemod- etal.2023. Faithandfate: Limitsoftransformerson
-elstoself-debug. arXivpreprintarXiv:2304.05128. compositionality. arXivpreprintarXiv:2305.18654.
-| (Citedonpg.9) | | | | | | | (Citedonpg.1) | | | | |
-| ------------- | ----- | ----- | ------- | ---- | ------ | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| Yongchao | Chen, | Rujul | Gandhi, | Yang | Zhang, | and | | | | | |
-MonirehEbrahimi,AaronEberhart,FedericoBianchi,
-| Chuchu | Fan. | 2023b. NL2TL: | | Transforming | | natu- | | | | | |
-| ------ | ---- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ----- | ---------------------- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | andPascalHitzler.2021. | | Towardsbridgingtheneuro- | | |
-rallanguagestotemporallogicsusinglargelanguage symbolic gap: Deep deductive reasoners. Applied
-| models. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2305.07766. | | | | (Citedon | | | | | | |
-| ------- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | Intelligence,51:6326–6348. | | | (Citedonpg.8) | |
-pg.9)
-| | | | | | | | HerbertBEnderton.2001. | | Amathematicalintroduction | | |
-| --------- | --------- | ------- | ----- | ----------- | ------------ | --- | ---------------------- | ----------------------- | ------------------------- | --- | --- |
-| Zhoujun | Cheng, | Tianbao | Xie, | Peng | Shi, Chengzu | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | tologic. | Elsevier. (Citedonpg.2) | | | |
-| Li, Rahul | Nadkarni, | | Yushi | Hu, Caiming | Xiong, | | | | | | |
-DragomirRadev,MariOstendorf,LukeZettlemoyer,
-| | | | | | | | Luyu Gao, | Aman Madaan, | Shuyan | Zhou, | Uri Alon, |
-| -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --------------- | ------------ | ------------------------- | ----- | --------- |
-| NoahA.Smith,andTaoYu.2023. | | | | Bindinglanguage | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | PengfeiLiu, | YimingYang, | JamieCallan, | | andGra- |
-| modelsinsymboliclanguages. | | | | InTheEleventhIn- | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | hamNeubig.2023. | | PAL:Program-aidedlanguage | | |
-ternationalConferenceonLearningRepresentations.
-| | | | | | | | models. | In International | Conference | | on Machine |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ---------------- | ---------- | --- | ---------- |
-(Citedonpg.9)
-| | | | | | | | Learning,pages10764–10799.PMLR. | | | | (Citedonpg. |
-| -------------------------------------------- | ------ | ------ | ------- | ---- | -------- | --- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- |
-| AakankshaChowdhery,SharanNarang,JacobDevlin, | | | | | | | 9,10) | | | | |
-| Maarten | Bosma, | Gaurav | Mishra, | Adam | Roberts, | | | | | | |
-Paul Barham, Hyung Won Chung, Charles Sutton, Herbert P Grice. 1975. Logic and conversation. In
-Sebastian Gehrmann, et al. 2022. Palm: Scaling Speechacts,pages41–58.Brill. (Citedonpg.15)
+Fold SUPPORTS NOINFO REFUTES All goldevidenceabstractforc,and(2)Thepredicted
+label is correct: y(c,a) = y(c,a). It is correctly
+Train 332 304 173 809 (cid:98)
+Dev 124 112 64 300 rationalized if,inaddition,thepredictedrationale
+Test 100 100 100 300
+sentencescontainagoldrationale,i.e.,thereexists
+All 556 516 337 1409 somegoldrationaleR
+i
+(c,a) ⊆ S(cid:98)(c,a).
+(a)DistributionofclaimlabelsinSCIFACT.
+LikeFEVER,whichlimitsthemaximumnumber
+ofpredictedrationalesentencestofive, SCIFACT
+0 1 2 3+
+limitstothreepredictedrationalesentences. Over-
+Citedabstractsperclaim - 1278 86 45
+all performance is measured by the micro-F1 of
+Evidenceabstractsperclaim 516 830 37 26
+theprecisionandrecalloverthecorrectly-labeled
+Rationalesperabstract - 552 290 153
+Sentencesperrationale - 1542 92 11 andcorrectly-rationalizedevidenceabstracts. We
+refertotheseevaluationsasAbstract and
+(b)Evidencecountsatvariouslevelsofgranularity.Forexam- Label-Only
+ple,Column2oftherow“Rationales/abstract”indicatesthat Abstract Label+Rationale ,respectively.
+290claim/abstractpairsaresupportedby2distinctrationales.
+Sentence-levelevaluationmeasuresperformance
+Table 2: Statistics on claim labels, and the number of inidentifyingindividualrationalesentences. Un-
+evidenceabstractsandrationalesperclaim. like the abstract-level metrics, this evaluation pe-
+nalizesthepredictionofextrarationalesentences.
+A predicted rationale sentence s(c,a) is cor-
+(cid:98)
+The abstracts that either SUPPORT or REFUTE c
+rectlyselected if(1)Itisamemberofsomegold
+arereferredtoasevidenceabstractsforc,denoted
+rationaleR (c,a),(2)allothersentencesfromthe
+i
+as E(c). Each evidence abstract a ∈ E(c) is an-
+same gold rationale R (c,a) are among the pre-
+i
+notated with rationales. A single rationale R i is dicted S(cid:98)(c,a), and (3) y
+(cid:98)
+(c,a) (cid:54)= NOINFO 4. It is
+acollectionofsentences{r (c,a),...,r (c,a)},
+1 m correctly labeled if, in addition, the abstract a is
+wheremisthenumberofsentencesinrationaleR .
+i correctlylabeled: y(c,a) = y(c,a).
+(cid:98)
+We denote the set of all rationales as R(c,a) =
+Overallperformanceismeasuredbythemicro-
+{R (c,a),...,R (c,a)}.
+1 n F1oftheprecisionandrecallofcorrectly-selected
+Given a claim c and a corpus A, the system andcorrectly-labeledrationalesentences,denoted
+mustpredictasetofevidenceabstractsE(cid:98)(c). For Sentence and Sentence .
+Selection-Only Selection+Label
+each abstract a ∈ E(cid:98)(c), it must predict a label Forsentence-levelevaluation,wedonotlimitthe
+y (cid:98) (c,a), and a collection of rationale sentences numberofpredictedrationalesentences,sincethe
+S(cid:98)(c,a) = {s (cid:98)1 (c,a),...,s (cid:98)(cid:96) (c,a)}. Note that al- evaluationpenalizesmodelsthatover-predict.
+thoughthegoldannotationsmaycontainmultiple
+separaterationales,tosimplifythepredictiontask 5 VERISCI: Baselinemodel
+weonlyrequirethemodeltopredictasinglecol-
+Wedevelopabaseline(referredtoasVERISCI)that
+lectionofrationalesentences;thesesentencesmay
+takes a claim c and corpus A as input, identifies
+encompassmultiplegoldrationales.
+evidenceabstractsE(cid:98)(c),andpredictsalabely
+(cid:98)
+(c,a)
+TaskEvaluationWeevaluatethetaskattwolevels
+andrationalesentencesS(cid:98)(c,a)foreacha ∈ E(cid:98)(c).
+of granularity. For abstract-level evaluation, we
+Followingthe“BERT-to-BERT”modelpresented
+assessthemodel’sabilitytoidentifytheabstracts
+inDeYoungetal.(2020a);Soleimanietal.(2019),
+thatsupportorrefutetheclaim. Forsentence-level
+VERISCIisapipelineofthreecomponents:
+evaluation, we evaluate the model’s performance
+1. ABSTRACTRETRIEVAL retrieves k abstracts
+atidentifyingthesentencessufficienttojustifythe
+withhighestTF-IDFsimilaritytotheclaim.
+abstract-levelpredictions. Weconductevaluations
+2. RATIONALESELECTION identifies rationale
+in both the “Open” FEVER-style (Thorne et al.,
+sentencesS(cid:98)(c,a)foreachabstract.
+2018) setting where the evidence abstracts must
+3. LABELPREDICTIONmakesthefinallabelpre-
+beretrieved,andthe“Oracleabstract” ERASER-
+dictiony(c,a).
+(cid:98)
+style (DeYoung et al., 2020a) setting where the
+Rationale selection Given a claim c and ab-
+goldevidenceabstractsE(c)areprovided. stract a, we train a model to predict z (cid:44)
+i
+Abstract-level evaluation is inspired by the
+4Condition(3)eliminatesrationalesentenceswhichwere
+FEVERscore. Givenaclaimc,apredictedevidence
+identifiedbytherationaleselector,butprovedinsufficientto
+abstracta ∈ E(cid:98)(c)iscorrectlylabeled if(1)aisa justifyafinalSUPPORTS/REFUTESdecision
+7538
-Christopher Hahn, Frederik Schmitt, Julia J Tillman, Percy Liang, Rishi Bommasani, Tony Lee, Dimitris
-NiklasMetzger,JulianSiber,andBerndFinkbeiner. Tsipras, Dilara Soylu, Michihiro Yasunaga, Yian
-2022. Formalspecificationsfromnaturallanguage. Zhang,DeepakNarayanan,YuhuaiWu,AnanyaKu-
-arXivpreprintarXiv:2206.01962. (Citedonpg.9) mar, et al. 2022. Holistic evaluation of language
-| | | | | | | models. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2211.09110. | | | (Citedon |
-| --------------------------------------------- | -------- | ----------- | ------- | -------- | --------- | ------------ | ------------------------------ | --------- | -------------- | -------- |
-| SimengHan,HaileySchoelkopf,YilunZhao,Zhenting | | | | | | pg.1) | | | | |
-| Qi, Martin | Riddell, | Luke | Benson, | Lucy | Sun, Eka- | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | Percy Liang, | Michael | I Jordan, | and Dan Klein. | 2013. |
-| terina Zubova, | | Yujie Qiao, | Matthew | Burtell, | et al. | | | | | |
-2022. Folio: Naturallanguagereasoningwithfirst- Learning dependency-based compositional seman-
-arXivpreprintarXiv:2209.00840. tics. Computational Linguistics, 39(2):389–446.
-| orderlogic. | | | | | (Cited | | | | | |
-| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-(Citedonpg.8)
-onpg.3)
-RuiboLiu,JasonWei,ShixiangShaneGu,Te-YenWu,
-| James Higginbotham. | | 1998. | On | higher-order | logic | | | | | |
-| ------------------- | --- | ----- | --- | ------------ | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-SoroushVosoughi,ClaireCui,DennyZhou,andAn-
-| andnaturallanguage. | | InProceedingsoftheBritish | | | | | | | | |
-| --------------------------- | --------- | ------------------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------------------------------- | ---------- | ---------- | ---------------- | ----------- |
-| | | | | | | drewM.Dai.2023. | | Mind’seye: | Groundedlanguage | |
-| Academy,volume95,pages1–27. | | | | (Citedonpg.10) | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | modelreasoningthroughsimulation. | | | InTheEleventh | |
-| | | | | | | International | Conference | on | Learning | Representa- |
-| Jie Huang | and Kevin | Chen-Chuan | | Chang. 2022. | To- | | | | | |
-tions. (Citedonpg.9)
-| wardsreasoninginlargelanguagemodels: | | | | | Asurvey. | | | | | |
-| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-arXivpreprintarXiv:2212.10403. (Citedonpg.1) XuantaoLu,JingpingLiu,ZhouhongGu,HanwenTong,
-| | | | | | | ChenhaoXie, | JunyangHuang, | | YanghuaXiao, | and |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | --- |
-Jie Huang, Xinyun Chen, Swaroop Mishra, Wenguang Wang. 2022. Parsing natural language
-Huaixiu Steven Zheng, Adams Wei Yu, Xiny- intopropositionalandfirst-orderlogicwithdualre-
-ingSong,andDennyZhou.2023. Largelanguage inforcement learning. In Proceedings of the 29th
-models cannot self-correct reasoning yet. arXiv InternationalConferenceonComputationalLinguis-
-| preprintarXiv:2310.01798. | | | (Citedonpg.10) | | | | | | | |
-| ------------------------- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | -------------------- | ------------------------------- | ------------- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | tics,pages5419–5431. | | (Citedonpg.8) | | |
-| | | | | | | AmanMadaan, | NiketTandon,PrakharGupta,Skyler | | | |
-BorjaIbarz,VitalyKurin,GeorgePapamakarios,Kyr-
-| | | | | | | Hallinan, | Luyu Gao, | Sarah | Wiegreffe, | Uri Alon, |
-| ---------------- | --- | ----- | -------- | ------ | -------- | --------- | --------- | ----- | ---------- | --------- |
-| iacos Nikiforou, | | Mehdi | Bennani, | Róbert | Csordás, | | | | | |
-AndrewJosephDudzik,MatkoBošnjak,AlexVitvit- Nouha Dziri, Shrimai Prabhumoye, Yiming Yang,
-skyi,YuliaRubanova,etal.2022. Ageneralistneural etal.2023. Self-refine:Iterativerefinementwithself-
-algorithmiclearner. InLearningonGraphsConfer- feedback. arXivpreprintarXiv:2303.17651. (Cited
-onpg.9)
-| ence,pages2–1.PMLR. | | | (Citedonpg.8) | | | | | | | |
-| ------------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-RobinManhaeve,SebastijanDumancic,AngelikaKim-
-| AishwaryaKamathandRajarshiDas.2019. | | | | | Asurvey | | | | | |
-| ----------------------------------- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | ------- | --------------------- | -------------------------------- | ------------------- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | mig, ThomasDemeester, | | andLucDeRaedt.2018. | | |
-| onsemanticparsing. | | InAutomatedKnowledgeBase | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | DeepProbLog: | Neuralprobabilisticlogicprogram- | | | |
-| Construction(AKBC). | | (Citedonpg.8) | | | | | | | | |
-ming. InAdvancesinneuralinformationprocessing
-| | | | | | | systems,volume31. | | (Citedonpg.8) | | |
-| -------------- | --- | ------- | ---- | -------------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- |
-| Mehran Kazemi, | | Najoung | Kim, | Deepti Bhatia, | Xin | | | | | |
-Xu,andDeepakRamachandran.2023. LAMBADA: Giuseppe Marra, Francesco Giannini, Michelangelo
-Backwardchainingforautomatedreasoninginnat-
-| | | | | | | Diligenti,andMarcoGori.2019. | | | Integratinglearn- | |
-| -------------- | ------------------ | -------------- | --- | ------------- | ------ | ----------------------------------- | ---------- | --- | ----------------- | ------- |
-| ural language. | | In Proceedings | | of the 61st | Annual | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | ingandreasoningwithdeeplogicmodels. | | | | InJoint |
-| Meeting | of the Association | | for | Computational | Lin- | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | European | Conference | on | Machine Learning | and |
-guistics(Volume1: LongPapers),pages6547–6568, KnowledgeDiscoveryinDatabases,pages517–532.
-Toronto,Canada.AssociationforComputationalLin- Springer. (Citedonpg.8)
-| guistics. | (Citedonpg.8) | | | | | | | | | |
-| --------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | ------ |
-| | | | | | | W. McCune. | 2005–2010. | | Prover9 and | mace4. |
-DenisKocetkov,RaymondLi,LoubnaBenAllal,JiaLi, |http://www.cs.unm.edu/ mccune/prover9/|. (Cited
-onpg.3)
-ChenghaoMou,CarlosMuñozFerrandis,YacineJer-
-nite,MargaretMitchell,SeanHughes,ThomasWolf,
-| | | | | | | Ian McKenzie, | Alexander | Lyzhov, | Alicia | Parrish, |
-| ---------- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --------- | ------- | ------ | -------- |
-| etal.2022. | TheStack:3TBofpermissivelylicensed | | | | | | | | | |
-AmeyaPrabhu,AaronMueller,NajoungKim,Sam
-| source code. | | arXiv | preprint | arXiv:2211.15533. | | | | | | |
-| -------------- | --- | ----- | -------- | ----------------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- |
-| (Citedonpg.15) | | | | | | Bowman,andEthanPerez.2022. | | | Theinversescaling | |
-prize. (Citedonpg.1)
-TakeshiKojima,ShixiangShaneGu,MachelReid,Yu- Quinn McNemar. 1947. Note on the sampling error
-| takaMatsuo,andYusukeIwasawa.2022. | | | | | Largelan- | | | | | |
-| --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-ofthedifferencebetweencorrelatedproportionsor
-| guagemodelsarezero-shotreasoners. | | | | InAdvances | | | | | | |
-| --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | ------ |
-| | | | | | | percentages. | Psychometrika,12(2):153–157. | | | (Cited |
-inneuralinformationprocessingsystems,volume35,
-onpg.5)
-| pages22199–22213. | | (Citedonpg.1,4,8) | | | | | | | | |
-| ----------------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-GrégoireMialon,RobertoDessì,MariaLomeli,Christo-
-Raymond Li, Loubna Ben Allal, Yangtian Zi, Niklas forosNalmpantis,RamPasunuru,RobertaRaileanu,
-Muennighoff,DenisKocetkov,ChenghaoMou,Marc Baptiste Rozière, Timo Schick, Jane Dwivedi-Yu,
-Marone,ChristopherAkiki,JiaLi,JennyChim,etal. AsliCelikyilmaz,etal.2023. Augmentedlanguage
-2023. Starcoder: maythesourcebewithyou! arXiv models: asurvey. arXivpreprintarXiv:2302.07842.
-| preprintarXiv:2305.06161. | | | (Citedonpg.4,15) | | | (Citedonpg.9) | | | | |
-| ------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+1[a isarationalesentence] for each sentence a RATIONAL-SELECT. LABEL-PRED.
+| i | | | | | | i | | | | | | |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+in a. For each sentence, we encode the concate- Trainingdata P R F1 ACC.
+| nated sequence | | w = | [a ,SEP,c] | | using | a BERT- | | | | | | |
+| ------------------- | ---------- | ----- | --------------------- | -------- | ------- | ------- | ------------- | --- | ---- | --------- | --- | ---- |
+| | | i | i | | | | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | FEVER | | 41.5 | 57.9 48.4 | | 67.6 |
+| style language | | model | and | predict | a score | z˜ = | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | i | UKPSnopes | | 42.5 | 62.3 50.5 | | 71.3 |
+| | | | | | | | SCIFACT | | 73.7 | 70.5 72.1 | | 75.7 |
+| σ[f(CLS(w | ))],whereσ | | isthesigmoidfunction, | | | | | | | | | |
+| | i | | | | | | FEVER+SCIFACT | | 72.4 | 67.2 69.7 | | 81.9 |
+| f isalinearlayerand | | | CLS(w | i )isthe | CLS | token | | | | | | |
+from the encoding of w . We train the model on Sentenceencoder P R F1 ACC.
+i
+pairs of claims and their cited abstracts and min- SCIBERT 74.5 74.3 74.4 69.2
+| | | | | | | | BioMedRoBERTa | | 75.3 | 69.9 72.5 | | 71.7 |
+| ------------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------- | --------- | ------------- | --- | ---- | --------- | --- | ---- |
+| imize cross-entropy | | | loss between | | z i and | z˜. i For | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | RoBERTa-base | | 76.1 | 66.1 70.8 | | 62.9 |
+eachclaim,weusecitedabstractslabeledNOINFO,
+| | | | | | | | RoBERTa-large | | 73.7 | 70.5 72.1 | | 75.7 |
+| ------- | ---------------- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------- | --------- | ------------- | --- | ---- | --------- | --- | ---- |
+| as well | as non-rationale | | sentences | | from | abstracts | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | Modelinputs | | P | R F1 | | ACC. |
+| labeled | SUPPORTS | and | REFUTES | | as negative | ex- | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | Claim-only | | - | - - | | 44.5 |
+amples. To make predictions, we select all sen- Abstract-only 60.1 60.9 60.5 53.3
+| tencesa | withz˜ | > tasrationalesentences,where | | | | | | | | | | |
+| ------- | ------ | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+| | i | i | | | | | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | Table3: Comparisonofdifferenttrainingdatasets, | | | | | en- |
+t ∈ [0,1]istunedonthedevset(AppendixA.1).
+| | | | | | | | coders, and | model | inputs for | RATIONALESELECTION | | |
+| ---------------- | -------- | --------- | ------ | ------------- | --- | ---------- | -------------------- | ----- | ---------- | ------------------ | ------ | ------- |
+| Label prediction | | Sentences | | identified | | by the ra- | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | and LABELPREDICTION, | | | evaluated | on the | SCIFACT |
+| tionale | selector | are | passed | to a separate | | BERT- | | | | | | |
+devset. Theclaim-onlymodelcannotselectrationales.
+| based model | to | make | the | final labeling | | decision. | | | | | | |
+| ----------- | ----- | ----- | -------- | -------------- | -------------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+| Given a | claim | c and | abstract | a, | we concatenate | | | | | | | |
+the claim and the predicted rationale sentences VERISCI, and (4) discuss some modeling chal-
+lengespresentedbythedataset.
+| u = [s | (c,a),...s | | (c,a),SEP,c]5, | | and | predict | | | | | | |
+| --------- | ------------- | ---------------- | -------------- | --- | ------ | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+| (cid:98)1 | | (cid:98)(cid:96) | | | | | | | | | | |
+| y˜(c,a) = | φ[f(CLS(u))], | | where | φ | is the | softmax | | | | | | |
+6.1 Pipelinecomponents
+| function,andf | | isalinearlayerwiththreeoutputs | | | | | | | | | | |
+| ------------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+representingthe{SUPPORTS, REFUTES, NOINFO We examine the effects of different training
+datasets,sentenceencoders,andmodelinputson
+| } labels. | We minimize | | the | cross-entropy | | loss be- | | | | | | |
+| --------- | ----------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+tweeny˜(c,a)andthetruelabely(c,a). the performance of the RATIONALESELECTION
+Wetrainthemodelonpairsofclaimsandtheir and LABELPREDICTION modules. The RATIO-
+citedabstractsusinggoldrationalesasinput. For NALESELECTIONmoduleisevaluatedonitsability
+toselectrationalesentencesgivengoldabstracts6.
+| cited abstracts | | labeled | NOINFO, | | we choose | the | | | | | | |
+| --------------- | --- | ------- | ------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+k sentences from the cited abstract with high- TheLABELPREDICTIONmoduleisevaluatedonits
+est TF-IDF similarity to the claim as input ra- 3-waylabelclassificationaccuracygivengoldratio-
+| | | | | | | | nalesfromcitedabstracts. | | | Citedabstractslabeled | | |
+| --------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------ | --- | --------- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- |
+| tionales. | For | prediction, | | we use | the | predicted | | | | | | |
+rationale sentences S(cid:98)(c,a) as input and predict NOINFOareincludedintheevaluation. Theseab-
+yˆ(c,a) = argmaxy˜(c,a). NOINFO is predicted stractshavenogoldrationalesentences;asin§5,
+weprovidethek
+forabstractswithnorationalesentences. mostsimilarsentencesfromthe
+abstractasinput(moredetailsinAppendixA).
+Weexperimentedwithalabelpredictionmodel
+whichencodesentireabstractsviatheLongformer
+| | | | | | | | Training Data | We | train | on (1) FEVER, | | (2) UKP |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ----- | ------------- | --- | ------- |
+(Beltagy et al., 2020), and makes predictions us- Snopes,(3)SCIFACT,and(4)FEVERpretraining
+ingthedocument-level CLS token. Performance followedby SCIFACTfine-tuning. RoBERTa-large
+wasnotcompetitivewithourpipelinesetup,likely
+(Liuetal.,2019)isusedasthesentenceencoder.
+| because | the label | predictor | | struggles | to | identify | | | | | | |
+| ------- | --------- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | -------- | ---------------- | --- | ------------ | ------- | --- | ------ |
+| | | | | | | | Sentence encoder | | We fine-tune | SCIBERT | | (Belt- |
+relevantinformationwhengivenfullabstracts.
+agyetal.,2019),BioMedRoBERTa(Gururangan
+etal.,2020),RoBERTa-base,andRoBERTa-large.
+6 Experiments
+SCIFACTisusedastrainingdata.
+Inourexperiments,we(1)analyzetheperformance
+| | | | | | | | Model Inputs | We | examine | the | performance | of |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------- | --- | ----------- | --- |
+ofeachindividualcomponentofVERISCI,(2)eval- “claim-only” and “abstract-only” models trained
+uatefulltaskperformanceinboththe“Oracleab-
+onSCIFACT,usingRoBERTa-largeasthesentence
+stract”and“Open”settings,(3)presentpromising
+encoder. Theclaim-onlymodelmakeslabelpredic-
+| results verifying | | claims | about | COVID-19 | | using | | | | | | |
+| ----------------- | --- | ------ | ----- | -------- | --- | ----- | ------------------ | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ------ |
+| | | | | | | | 6Our FEVER-trained | | RATIONALESELECTION | | | module |
+5WetruncatetherationaleinputifitexceedstheBERT achieves79.9sentence-levelF1ontheFEVERtestset,virtu-
+tokenlimit.cisnevertruncated. allyidenticalto79.6reportedinDeYoungetal.(2020a).
+7539
-DaleA.MillerandGopalanNadathur.1986. Someuses Abulhair Saparov, Richard Yuanzhe Pang, Vishakh
-ofhigher-orderlogicincomputationallinguistics. In Padmakumar,NitishJoshi,SeyedMehranKazemi,
-Proceedingsofthe24thAnnualMeetingonAssoci- Najoung Kim, and He He. 2023. Testing the
-ationforComputationalLinguistics,page247–256, general deductive reasoning capacity of large lan-
-NewYork,USA.AssociationforComputationalLin- guagemodelsusingoodexamples. arXivpreprint
-| guistics. | (Citedonpg.10) | | | | | | arXiv:2305.15269. | | (Citedonpg.1) | | | | |
-| --------- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-MaxwellNye,AndersJohanAndreassen,GuyGur-Ari, TimoSchick,JaneDwivedi-Yu,RobertoDessì,Roberta
-Henryk Michalewski, Jacob Austin, David Bieber, Raileanu,MariaLomeli,LukeZettlemoyer,Nicola
-| | | | | | | | Cancedda,andThomasScialom.2023. | | | | | Toolformer: | |
-| ----- | ------ | ----- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ------ | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- |
-| David | Dohan, | Aitor | Lewkowycz, | | Maarten | Bosma, | | | | | | | |
-Languagemodelscanteachthemselvestousetools.
-| DavidLuan,etal.2021. | | | Showyourwork: | | | Scratch- | | | | | | | |
-| -------------------- | ------------------------------ | --- | ------------- | --- | ---- | -------- | ------------------------------ | --- | ----- | ---- | --------------- | --- | --------- |
-| | | | | | | | arXivpreprintarXiv:2302.04761. | | | | (Citedonpg.2,9) | | |
-| pads | for intermediate | | computation | | with | language | | | | | | | |
-| models. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2112.00114. | | | | | (Citedon | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | Noam Shazeer. | | 2019. | Fast | transformer | | decoding: |
-pg.1,4,8)
-| | | | | | | | One write-head | | is all | you | need. | arXiv | preprint |
-| ------ | --------- | ------- | --- | ------- | ------------- | --------- | ----------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------ | ----- | -------- |
-| | | | | | | | arXiv:1911.02150. | | (Citedonpg.15) | | | | |
-| Theo X | Olausson, | Jeevana | | Priya | Inala, | Chenglong | | | | | | | |
-| Wang, | Jianfeng | Gao, | and | Armando | Solar-Lezama. | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | Richard Shin | and | Benjamin | Van | Durme. | 2022. | Few- |
-2023. Isself-repairasilverbulletforcodegenera-
-shotsemanticparsingwithlanguagemodelstrained
-| tion? | arXivpreprintarXiv:2306.09896. | | | | | (Citedon | | | | | | | |
-| ----- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | oncode. | InProceedingsofthe2022Conferenceof | | | | | |
-pg.9)
-theNorthAmericanChapteroftheAssociationfor
-| | | | | | | | ComputationalLinguistics: | | | HumanLanguageTech- | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- |
-OpenAI.2023. GPT-4technicalreport. (Citedonpg.1, nologies, pages 5417–5425, Seattle, United States.
-4,15)
-| | | | | | | | Association | for | Computational | | Linguistics. | | (Cited |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------ |
-onpg.8)
-LongOuyang,JeffreyWu,XuJiang,DiogoAlmeida,
-CarrollWainwright,PamelaMishkin,ChongZhang,
-| | | | | | | | Aarohi Srivastava, | | Abhinav | Rastogi, | | Abhishek | Rao, |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | -------- | ---- |
-SandhiniAgarwal,KatarinaSlama,AlexRay,etal. AbuAwalMdShoeb,AbubakarAbid,AdamFisch,
-2022. Training languagemodelsto followinstruc- AdamRBrown,AdamSantoro,AdityaGupta,Adrià
-tionswithhumanfeedback. InAdvancesinNeural Garriga-Alonso, et al. 2023. Beyond the imitation
-InformationProcessingSystems,volume35,pages
-| | | | | | | | game: | Quantifying | and | extrapolating | | the | capabili- |
-| ------------ | ---- | ---------------- | -------- | --- | ----- | --------- | --------------------- | ----------- | ------------- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --------- |
-| 27730–27744. | | (Citedonpg.4,15) | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | tiesoflanguagemodels. | | | TransactionsonMachine | | | |
-| | | | | | | | LearningResearch. | | (Citedonpg.1) | | | | |
-| Liangming | Pan, | Alon | Albalak, | | Xinyi | Wang, and | | | | | | | |
-William Yang Wang. 2023. Logic-lm: Empower- RobertStalnaker.2002. Commonground. Linguistics
-ing large language models with symbolic solvers andphilosophy,25(5/6):701–721. (Citedonpg.15)
-| for faithful | | logical | reasoning. | | arXiv | preprint | | | | | | | |
-| ------------ | --- | ------- | ---------- | --- | ----- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-OyvindTafjord,BhavanaDalvi,andPeterClark.2021.
-| arXiv:2305.12295. | | | (Citedonpg.9) | | | | | | | | | | |
-| ----------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | ---------- | ------------- | --- | ------- | ------- |
-| | | | | | | | ProofWriter: | | Generating | implications, | | proofs, | and |
-| | | | | | | | abductivestatementsovernaturallanguage. | | | | | | InFind- |
-GuilhermePenedo,QuentinMalartic,DanielHesslow,
-ingsoftheAssociationforComputationalLinguistics:
-| Ruxandra | Cojocaru, | | Alessandro | | Cappelli, | Hamza | | | | | | | |
-| -------- | --------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-Alobeidli, Baptiste Pannier, Ebtesam Almazrouei, ACL-IJCNLP2021,pages3621–3634,Online.Asso-
-| | | | | | | | ciationforComputationalLinguistics. | | | | | (Citedonpg. | |
-| --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- |
-| andJulienLaunay.2023. | | | | TheRefinedWebdataset | | | | | | | | | |
-3)
-| for Falcon | | LLM: | outperforming | | curated | corpora | | | | | | | |
-| ---------- | --------- | ---- | ------------- | ----- | ------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| with | web data, | and | web data | only. | arXiv | preprint | | | | | | | |
-OyvindTafjord,BhavanaDalviMishra,andPeterClark.
-| arXiv:2306.01116. | | | (Citedonpg.15) | | | | | | | | | | |
-| ----------------- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --------- | --------- | --- | --------------- | ---- | -------- |
-| | | | | | | | 2022. | Entailer: | Answering | | questions | with | faithful |
-| | | | | | | | andtruthfulchainsofreasoning. | | | | InProceedingsof | | |
-BaolinPeng,MichelGalley,PengchengHe,HaoCheng,
-the2022ConferenceonEmpiricalMethodsinNat-
-YujiaXie,YuHu,QiuyuanHuang,LarsLiden,Zhou
-uralLanguageProcessing,pages2078–2093,Abu
-| Yu,WeizhuChen,andJianfengGao.2023. | | | | | | Check | | | | | | | |
-| ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-Dhabi,UnitedArabEmirates.AssociationforCom-
-| yourfactsandtryagain: | | | Improvinglargelanguage | | | | | | | | | | |
-| --------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | putationalLinguistics. | | | (Citedonpg.8) | | | |
-modelswithexternalknowledgeandautomatedfeed-
-| back. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2302.12813. | | | | | (Citedon | | | | | | | |
-| ----- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-RomalThoppilan,DanielDeFreitas,JamieHall,Noam
-| pg.9) | | | | | | | Shazeer, | Apoorv | Kulshreshtha, | | Heng-Tze | | Cheng, |
-| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ----------- | ------------- | ------ | -------- | --- | ---------- |
-| | | | | | | | Alicia | Jin, Taylor | Bos, | Leslie | Baker, | Yu | Du, et al. |
-Gabriel Poesia, Alex Polozov, Vu Le, Ashish Tiwari, 2022. LaMDA:Languagemodelsfordialogapplica-
-GustavoSoares,ChristopherMeek,andSumitGul-
-| | | | | | | | tions. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2201.08239. | | | | | (Citedon |
-| ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- |
-| wani.2022. | | Synchromesh: | | Reliablecodegeneration | | | | | | | | | |
-pg.9)
-InInternational
-frompre-trainedlanguagemodels.
-ConferenceonLearningRepresentations. (Citedon Petar Velicˇkovic´, Adrià Puigdomènech Badia, David
-| pg.15) | | | | | | | Budden,RazvanPascanu,AndreaBanino,MishaDa- | | | | | | |
-| ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-shevskiy,RaiaHadsell,andCharlesBlundell.2022.
-GrahamPriest.2008. Anintroductiontonon-classical The clrs algorithmic reasoning benchmark. In In-
-logic: From if to is. Cambridge University Press. ternationalConferenceonMachineLearning,pages
-| (Citedonpg.10) | | | | | | | 22084–22102.PMLR. | | | (Citedonpg.9) | | | |
-| -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- |
+| | | | | Sentence-level | | | | | Abstract-level | | | |
+| --------- | ----- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --------------- | ---- | --- | ---------- | -------------- | --------------- | --- | --- |
+| | | Selection-Only | | | Selection+Label | | | Label-Only | | Label+Rationale | | |
+| Retrieval | Model | P | R | F1 | P | R F1 | | P R | F1 | P | R | F1 |
+Oraclerationale 1 100.0 80.5 89.2 89.6 72.2 79.9 90.1 77.5 83.3 90.1 77.5 83.3
+| | | | | 2.1 | | | 3.0 | | | 2.4 | | 2.4 |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+Oracle
+| | | | | 43.8 | | 37.2 | | | 66.3 | | | 51.8 |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | ---- |
+abstract Zero-shot 2 42.5 45.1 2.0 36.1 38.4 2.3 86.9 53.6 3.1 67.9 41.9 3.4
+VERISCI 3 76.1 63.8 69.4 66.5 55.7 60.6 87.3 65.3 74.7 84.9 63.5 72.7
+| | | | | 2.6 | | | 3.1 | | | 2.8 | | 2.9 |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+Oraclerationale 4 100.0 56.5 72.2 3.3 87.6 49.5 63.2 3.7 88.9 54.1 67.2 3.2 88.9 54.1 67.2 3.2
+Open Zero-shot 5 28.7 37.6 32.5 2.3 23.7 31.1 26.9 2.3 56.0 42.3 48.2 3.3 42.3 32.0 36.4 3.3
+VERISCI 6 45.0 47.3 46.1 3.0 38.6 40.5 39.5 3.0 47.5 47.3 47.4 3.1 46.6 46.4 46.5 3.1
+Table 4: Test set performance on SCIFACT, according to the metrics from §4. For the “Oracle abstract” rows,
+thesystemisprovidedwithgoldevidenceabstracts. “Oraclerationale”rowsindicatethatthegoldrationalesare
+providedasinput. “Zero-shot”indicateszero-shotperformanceofaverificationsystemtrainedonFEVER. Addi-
+tionally,standarddeviationsarereportedassubscriptsforallF1scores. SeeAppendixBforstandarddeviations
+onallreportedmetrics.
+tionsbasedontheclaimtextalone,withoutaccess inordertoidentifyrelevantevidence.
+| to evidence | abstracts. | The abstract-only | | model | | | | | | | | |
+| --------------------------------------------- | ---------- | ----------------- | --- | ----- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+| selectsrationalesentencesandmakeslabelpredic- | | | | | 6.2 | Fulltask | | | | | | |
+tionswithoutaccesstotheclaim.
+| | | | | | Experimental | | setup | Based | | on the | results | from |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | ----- | ----- | --- | ------ | ------- | ---- |
+ResultsTheresultsareshowninTable3. For LA- §6.1,weusetheRATIONALESELECTIONmodule
+| | | | | | trainedon | | SCIFACT | only,andthe | | LABELPREDIC- | | |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ------- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- |
+BELPREDICTION,thebestperformanceisachieved
+by training first on the large FEVER dataset and TIONmoduletrainedonFEVER+SCIFACTforour
+thenfine-tuningonthesmallerin-domainSCIFACT finalend-to-endsystem VERISCI. AlthoughSCIB-
+trainingset. TounderstandthebenefitsofFEVER ERTperformsslightlybetteronrationaleselection,
+pretraining,weexaminedtheclaim/evidencepairs usingRoBERTa-largeforbothRATIONALESELEC-
+wherethe FEVER+ SCIFACT-trainedmodelmade TION and LABELPREDICTION gavethebestfull-
+correctpredictionsbuttheSCIFACT-trainedmodel pipeline performance on the dev set, so we use
+| | | | | | RoBERTa-largeforbothcomponents. | | | | | | FortheAB- | |
+| -------- | ------------- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- |
+| did not. | In 36 / 44 of | these cases, | the | SCIFACT- | | | | | | | | |
+trainedmodelpredictsNOINFO. Thuspretraining STRACTRETRIEVALmodule,thebestdevsetfull-
+on FEVER appears to improve the model’s abil- pipeline performance was achieved by retrieving
+| | | | | | thetopk | | = 3documents. | | | | | |
+| ---------------- | ------- | ---------- | ------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+| ity to recognize | textual | entailment | relationships | | | | | | | | | |
+betweenevidenceandclaim–particularlyrelation-
+| | | | | | Model | comparisons | | We | report | performance | | of |
+| --------------- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | ---- | ----- | ----------- | --------- | --- | ------- | ----------- | ---------- | --- |
+| ships indicated | by non-domain-specific | | | cues | like | | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | three | model | variants. | | For the | “Oracle | rationale” | |
+“isassociatedwith”or“hasanimportantrolein”. setting,the RATIONALESELECTION moduleisre-
+For RATIONALESELECTION, training on SCI- placedbyanoraclewhichoutputsgoldrationales
+FACT alone produces the best results. We exam- forcorrectlyretrieveddocuments,andnorationales
+inedtherationalesthattheSCIFACT-trainedmodel forincorrectretrievals. The“Zero-shot”settingre-
+portsthezero-shotgeneralizationperformanceof
+| identified | but the FEVER- | trained | model | missed, | | | | | | | | |
+| ---------- | -------------- | ------- | ----- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+and found that they generally contain science- a model trained on FEVER (the results on UKP
+specific vocabulary. Thus, training on additional Snopeswereslightlyworse). VERISCIreportsthe
+performanceofourbestsystem.
+out-of-domaindataprovideslittlebenefit.
+RoBERTa-large exhibits the strongest perfor- Results The results are shown in Table 4. In the
+mance on label prediction, while SCIBERT has oracleabstractsetting,theabstract-levelF1scores
+areroughlycomparabletolabelclassificationaccu-
+| a slight | edge on rationale | selection. | The | “claim- | | | | | | | | |
+| -------- | ----------------- | ---------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+only”modelexhibitsverypoorperformance,which racies,andtheAbstract scoreinRow
+Label+Rationale
+providessomereassurancethattheclaimnegation 3impliesanend-to-endclassificationaccuracyof
+roughly70%,givengoldabstracts.
+proceduredescribedin§3.2doesnotintroduceob-
+viousstatisticalartifacts. Similarly,thepoorperfor- Access to in-domain data during training
+manceofthe“abstract-only”modelindicatesthat clearly improves performance. Despite the
+themodelneedsaccesstotheclaimbeingverified small size of SCIFACT, training on these data
+7540
-BailinWang,ZiWang,XuezhiWang,YuanCao,RifA MichihiroYasunaga,XinyunChen,YujiaLi,Panupong
-Saurous,andYoonKim.2023a. Grammarprompting Pasupat,JureLeskovec,PercyLiang,EdHChi,and
-fordomain-specificlanguagegenerationwithlarge DennyZhou.2023. Largelanguagemodelsasana-
-languagemodels. arXivpreprintarXiv:2305.19234. logicalreasoners. arXivpreprintarXiv:2310.01714.
-| (Citedonpg.8) | | | | | | | (Citedonpg.10) | | | | | |
-| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-QingxiangWang,ChadBrown,CezaryKaliszyk,and XiYe,QiaochuChen,IsilDillig,andGregDurrett.2023.
-JosefUrban.2020. Explorationofneuralmachine Satisfiability-aidedlanguagemodelsusingdeclara-
-translation in autoformalization of mathematics in tive prompting. arXiv preprint arXiv:2305.09656.
-| mizar. | In Proceedings | | of the | 9th ACM | SIGPLAN | | (Citedonpg.9) | | | | | |
-| ------ | -------------- | --- | ------ | ------- | ------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-InternationalConferenceonCertifiedProgramsand
-EricZelikman,YuhuaiWu,JesseMu,andNoahGood-
-| Proofs,pages85–98. | | | (Citedonpg.9) | | | | | | | | | |
-| ------------------ | ----- | ------ | ------------- | --- | ----- | ------ | ---------- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --------- | ---- |
-| | | | | | | | man. 2022. | STaR: Bootstrapping | | | reasoning | with |
-| | | | | | | | reasoning. | InAdvancesinNeuralInformationPro- | | | | |
-| Qingxiang | Wang, | Cezary | Kaliszyk, | and | Josef | Urban. | | | | | | |
-2018. First experiments with neural translation of cessing Systems, volume 35, pages 15476–15488.
-| informaltoformalmathematics. | | | | InIntelligentCom- | | | (Citedonpg.8) | | | | | |
-| ---------------------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| puterMathematics: | | 11thInternationalConference, | | | | | | | | | | |
-CICM2018,Hagenberg,Austria,August13-17,2018, John M Zelle and Raymond J Mooney. 1996. Learn-
-ingtoparsedatabasequeriesusinginductivelogic
-| Proceedings11,pages255–270.Springer. | | | | | (Citedon | | | | | | | |
-| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------ | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | programming. | InProceedingsoftheNationalCon- | | | | |
-pg.9)
-ferenceonArtificialIntelligence,pages1050–1055.
-| XuezhiWang,JasonWei,DaleSchuurmans,QuocVLe, | | | | | | | (Citedonpg.8) | | | | | |
-| ------------------------------------------- | ------------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| EdHChi, | SharanNarang, | | AakankshaChowdhery, | | | | | | | | | |
-andDennyZhou.2023b. Self-consistencyimproves LukeSZettlemoyerandMichaelCollins.2005. Learn-
-| | | | | | | | ing to | map sentences | to logical | form: | Structured | |
-| ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------- | ---------- | ----- | ---------- | --- |
-| chainofthoughtreasoninginlanguagemodels. | | | | | | In | | | | | | |
-classificationwithprobabilisticcategorialgrammars.
-TheEleventhInternationalConferenceonLearning
-| | | | | | | | In Proceedings | of the | Twenty-First | | Conference | on |
-| ---------------- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ------ | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- |
-| Representations. | | (Citedonpg.1,3,4,8,23) | | | | | | | | | | |
-UncertaintyinArtificialIntelligence,UAI’05,page
-JasonWei,XuezhiWang,DaleSchuurmans,Maarten 658–666, Arlington, Virginia, USA. AUAI Press.
-| Bosma,FeiXia,EdChi,QuocVLe,DennyZhou, | | | | | | | (Citedonpg.8) | | | | | |
-| ------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | -------- | ------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------- | ----------- | -------- | ------- | --------- | ----- |
-| etal.2022. | Chain-of-thoughtpromptingelicitsrea- | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | Hanlin Zhang, | Ziyang Li, | Jiani | Huang, | Mayur | Naik, |
-| soning | in large | language | models. | In | Advances | in | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | and Eric | Xing. 2022. | Improved | logical | reasoning | |
-NeuralInformationProcessingSystems,volume35,
-oflanguagemodelsviadifferentiablesymbolicpro-
-| pages24824–24837. | | | (Citedonpg.1,4,8) | | | | | | | | | |
-| ----------------- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ---- |
-| | | | | | | | gramming. | InFirstWorkshoponPre-training: | | | | Per- |
-spectives,Pitfalls,andPathsForwardatICML2022.
-| NathanielWeirandBenjaminVanDurme.2022. | | | | | | Dy- | | | | | | |
-| ---------------------------------------------- | --- | ------ | ------- | --- | ----- | -------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| namicgenerationofinterpretableinferencerulesin | | | | | | | (Citedonpg.9) | | | | | |
-| a neuro-symbolic | | expert | system. | | arXiv | preprint | | | | | | |
-HonghuaZhang,MeihuaDang,NanyunPeng,andGuy
-| arXiv:2209.07662. | | (Citedonpg.9) | | | | | | | | | | |
-| ----------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | -------------------------- | ------------------- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | VandenBroeck.2023a. | | Tractablecontrolforautore- | | | |
-| | | | | | | | gressivelanguagegeneration. | | | InInternationalCon- | | |
-LionelWong,GabrielGrand,AlexanderKLew,NoahD
-ferenceonMachineLearning,pages40932–40945.
-| Goodman, | Vikash | K | Mansinghka, | | Jacob Andreas, | | | | | | | |
-| ----------------------------------------- | ------- | --- | ----------- | --------------- | -------------- | ----- | ------------ | --------------------------------------- | ------- | ------ | --- | -------- |
-| | | | | | | | PMLR. | (Citedonpg.8) | | | | |
-| andJoshuaBTenenbaum.2023. | | | | Fromwordmod- | | | | | | | | |
-| els to world | models: | | Translating | from | natural | lan- | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | Kechi Zhang, | Zhuo Li, | Jia Li, | Ge Li, | and | Zhi Jin. |
-| guagetotheprobabilisticlanguageofthought. | | | | | | arXiv | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | 2023b. | Self-edit: Fault-awarecodeeditorforcode | | | | |
-| preprintarXiv:2306.12672. | | | | (Citedonpg.8,9) | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | generation. | InProceedingsofthe61stAnnualMeet- | | | | |
-ingoftheAssociationforComputationalLinguistics
-YuhuaiWu,AlbertQiaochuJiang,WendaLi,Markus
-| | | | | | | | (Volume1: | LongPapers),pages769–787,Toronto, | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-Rabe,CharlesStaats,MatejaJamnik,andChristian
-Canada.AssociationforComputationalLinguistics.
-| Szegedy. | 2022. | Autoformalization | | | with large | lan- | | | | | | |
-| ------------ | ----- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| guagemodels. | | InAdvancesinNeuralInformation | | | | | (Citedonpg.9) | | | | | |
-ProcessingSystems,volume35,pages32353–32368.
-| | | | | | | | Denny Zhou, | Nathanael | Schärli, | Le Hou, | Jason | Wei, |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --------- | -------- | ------- | ----- | ---- |
-(Citedonpg.9)
-| | | | | | | | Nathan | Scales, Xuezhi | Wang, | Dale | Schuurmans, | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | -------------- | ----- | ---- | ----------- | --- |
-ClaireCui,OlivierBousquet,QuocVLe,andEdH
-| Shunyu Yao, | Dian | Yu, | Jeffrey | Zhao, | Izhak | Shafran, | | | | | | |
-| ----------- | ------------ | --- | ------- | --------- | ---------- | -------- | -------------- | ------------- | --------- | ------- | ------- | ------ |
-| | | | | | | | Chi. 2023. | Least-to-most | prompting | | enables | com- |
-| Thomas | L Griffiths, | | Yuan | Cao, | and | Karthik | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | plex reasoning | in large | language | models. | | In The |
-| Narasimhan. | 2023. | | Tree of | thoughts: | Deliberate | | | | | | | |
-EleventhInternationalConferenceonLearningRep-
-| problemsolvingwithlargelanguagemodels. | | | | | | arXiv | | | | | | |
-| -------------------------------------- | ------- | ----- | ---- | -------------- | ------- | ----- | ------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | resentations. | (Citedonpg.8) | | | | |
-| preprintarXiv:2305.10601. | | | | (Citedonpg.10) | | | | | | | | |
-| Shunyu Yao, | Jeffrey | Zhao, | Dian | Yu, | Nan Du, | Izhak | | | | | | |
-Shafran,KarthikNarasimhan,andYuanCao.2022.
-React: Synergizingreasoningandactinginlanguage
-| models. | arXivpreprintarXiv:2210.03629. | | | | (Citedon | | | | | | | |
-| ------- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-pg.9)
+Reasoningtype Example
+Claim: Rapamycinslowsaginginfruitflies.
+Science Evidence: ...feedingrapamycintoadultDrosophilaproduceslifespanextension...
+background GoldVerdict: SUPPORTS
+Reasoning: Drosophilaisatypeoffruitfly.
+Claim: Inhibitingglucose-6-phospatedehydrogenaseimpairslipogenesis
+Evidence: ...suppressionof6PGDincreasedlipogenesis
+Directionality
+GoldVerdict: REFUTES
+Reasoning: Adecrease(notincrease)inlipogenesiswouldindicatelipogenesisimpairment.
+Claim: Bariatricsurgeryimprovesresolutionofdiabetes.
+Evidence: StrongassociationswerefoundbetweenbariatricsurgeryandtheresolutionofT2DM,
+Numerical
+withaHRof9.29(95%CI6.84-12.62)...
+reasoning
+GoldVerdict: SUPPORTS
+Reasoning: AHR(hazardratio)thatisgreaterthan1with95%confidenceindicatesimprovement.
+Claim: Majorvaultprotein(MVP)functionstodecreasetumoraggression.
+Evidence: KnockoutofMVPleadstomiR-193aaccumulation...inhibitingtumorprogression
+Causeand
+effect
+GoldVerdict: REFUTES
+Reasoning: Knockingout(removing)MVPinhibitstumorprogression→MVPincreasestumor
+aggression.
+Claim: Lowsaturatedfatdietshaveadverseeffectsonthedevelopmentofinfants
+Evidence: Neurologicaldevelopmentofchildrenintheinterventiongroupwasatleastasgoodas...
+Coreference thecontrolgroup
+GoldVerdict: REFUTES
+Reasoning: Theinterventiongroupinthisstudywasplacedonalowsaturatedfatdiet.
+Table 5: Reasoning types required to verify SCIFACT claims which are classified incorrectly by our modeling
+baseline. Wordscrucialforcorrectverificationarehighlighted.
+leads to relative improvements of 47% on sultsindicatethattheobserveddifferencesinmodel
+open Sentence , and 28% on open performancearestatisticallyrobustandcannotbe
+Selection+Label
+Abstract
+Label+Rationale
+overFEVERalone(Row6vs. attributedtorandomvariationinthedataset.
+Row5). Thethreepipelinecomponentsmakesimi-
+6.3 VerifyingclaimsaboutCOVID-19
+larcontributionstotheoverallmodelerror. Replac-
+ingRATIONALESELECTIONwithanoracleleads Weconductexploratoryexperimentsusingoursys-
+toaroughly20-pointriseinSentence Selection+Label tem to verify claims concerning COVID-19. We
+F1(Row6vs. Row4). ReplacingABSTRACTRE- taskedamedicalstudenttowrite36COVID-related
+TRIEVALwithanoracleaswellleadstoagainof claims. For each claim c, we used VERISCI to
+roughly20morepoints(Row4vs. Row1). predictevidenceabstractsE(cid:98)(c). Theannotatorex-
+Nearly all correctly-labeled abstracts are sup- amined each (c,E(cid:98)(c)) pair. A pair was labeled
+portedbyatleastonerationale. Thereisonlyatwo- plausibleifE(cid:98)(c)wasnonempty,andatleasthalfof
+point difference in F1 between Abstract
+Label-Only
+theevidenceabstractsinE(cid:98)(c)werejudgedtohave
+and Abstract in the oracle setting reasonablerationalesandlabels. For23/36claims,
+Label+Rationale
+(Row 3), and a one-point difference in the theresponseofVERISCIwasdeemedplausibleby
+open setting (Row 6). The differences between ourannotator,demonstratingthatVERISCIisable
+Sentence andSentence are to successfully retrieve and classify evidence in
+Selection-Only Selection+Label
+larger,causedbyexampleswherethemodelfinds manycases. TwoexamplesareshowninTable1.
+theevidencebutfailstopredictitsrelationshipto Inbothcases,oursystemidentifiesbothsupporting
+theclaim. Weexaminethesein§6.4. and refutingevidence.
+Weevaluatethestatisticalrobustnessofourre-
+6.4 Erroranalysis
+sultsbygenerating10,000bootstrap-resampledver-
+sions of the test set (Dror et al., 2018) and com- TobetterunderstandtheerrorsmadebyVERISCI,
+puting the standard deviation of all performance weconductamanualanalysisoftestsetpredictions
+metrics. Table4showsthestandarddeviationsin whereanevidenceabstractwascorrectlyretrieved,
+F1score. Uncertaintiesonallmetricsforboththe butwherethemodelfailedtoidentifyanyrelevant
+devandtestsetcanbefoundinAppendixB.There- rationalesorpredictedanincorrectlabel. Weiden-
+7541
-A FutureDirections
-dateforthepreviouslymentionedlargernumberof
-| | | | | | | | premises | involved | in | a typical | question). | | For the |
-| ------ | ----- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | -------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | ------- |
-| Of the | error | types | we catalog | in | our analysis | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | StarCoder+ | model, | we | allow | generation | up | until |
-LINC,
-| of | the key | opportunity | | for improvement | | is | | | | | | | |
-| --- | ------- | ----------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-the8192contextwindowlength,sincethismodel
-moreeleganthandlingofnaturalisticlanguageuse.
-| | | | | | | | is run locally. | | In either | case, | decoding | is | halted |
-| --------- | ------ | -------- | --- | -------- | ------ | ---- | --------------- | --- | --------- | ----- | -------- | --- | ------ |
-| While the | errors | observed | | with CoT | result | from | | | | | | | |
-earlywheneverthestoptokenispro-
-LINC,
-| faulty deductive | | inferences, | | in the | case of | | | | | | | | |
-| ---------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------ | ------- | --- | ------ | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | duced. | Alllocalexperimentswereexecutedona | | | | | |
-allerrorshavebeenlocalizedtothesemanticpars-
-clusterequippedwithNVIDIAA100GPUs.
-| ingprocedure. | | Thisprocessflowsprimarilyunim- | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| ------------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | GPT | Models: | We | use | the gpt-3.5-turbo-16k- | | |
-pededintheevaluationofthesyntheticProofWriter
-0613andgpt-4-0613checkpointsoftheGPT-3.5
-dataset,yetleavesroomforimprovementwiththe
-(Ouyangetal.,2022)andGPT-4(OpenAI,2023)
-| naturalistic | FOLIO. | | In follow-up | work, | we | hope | | | | | | | |
-| ------------ | ------ | --- | ------------ | ----- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-models,respectively,invokingbothmodelsviathe
-| to deeply | explore | naturalistic | | evaluation | settings, | | | | | | | | |
-| --------- | ------- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-OpenAIAPI.
-aswhendatagetthemostmessyisalsowhereim-
-| | | | | | | | StarCoder+: | | StarCoder+(15.5B)6 | | | isaversion | |
-| ------------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ----- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | ---------- | --- |
-| provementsbecomethe | | | mostvaluable. | | Here, | we | | | | | | | |
-ofStarCoderBase(Lietal.,2023)whichhasbeen
-| propose | three | strategies | for | further | improvement | | | | | | | | |
-| ------- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-finetunedon600Btokensfromacombinationof(1)
-onnaturalisticsettings.
-FalconRefinedWeb(Penedoetal.,2023)(filtered
-First,innaturalisticcommunication,“obvious”
-versionofCommonCrawl),(2)TheStackv1.2(Ko-
-informationisoftenleftoutofexplicitproductions,
-| | | | | | | | cetkov et | al., 2022), | | and (3) | a Wikipedia | | dataset. |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ------- | ----------- | --- | -------- |
-lefttobeinferredinthe“commonground”ofthe
-Itsbasemodel,StarCoderBase,isanopen-access
-communicativeact(Grice,1975;Stalnaker,2002).
-modelwithaGPT-2architectureusingmulti-query
-| Implicit | premise | rediscovery | | through | controlled | | | | | | | | |
-| -------- | ------- | ----------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-attention(Shazeer,2019)andfill-in-the-middleob-
-explorationonthelogicalneighborhoodoftheex-
-| | | | | | | | jective(Bavarianetal.,2022). | | | | StarCoderBasehas | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- |
-istingexplicitpremisespromisestobeapowerful
-| | | | | | | | a8192contextwindowandistrainedon1T | | | | | | code |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- |
-strategyforimprovingperformanceinunderspeci-
-tokensofpermissivelylicensedtextfromGitHub
-fiedsettings.
-across80programminglanguages(Lietal.,2023).
-| Second, | while | a | number | of samples | are | lost to | | | | | | | |
-| ------- | ----- | --- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ------- | ------ | ---------- | ------- | --- | ---------------- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | We use | StarCoder+ | instead | | of StarCoderBase | | be- |
-syntaxerrors,recentworkhasproposedrestricting
-| | | | | | | | cause it | is finetuned | | on natural | language, | | which |
-| ------------ | --- | ----- | ----- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ------------------------------------- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --------- | --- | ----- |
-| the sampling | | space | of an | LLM to | that which | is | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | shouldimprovetheperformanceonourtask. | | | | | | We |
-consistentwithtermexpansionsinacontext-free-
-runStarCoder+withbf16precisiontoreduceits
-| grammar(CFG)(Poesiaetal.,2022). | | | | | Doingsoin | | | | | | | | |
-| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-memoryfootprint.
-thissettingwouldeliminateallsyntaxerrors.
-Third, sometimes, the translation process to C FOLIODatasetPreprocessing
-FOLislossy,throwingawayvaluableinformation
-| | | | | | | | We use | the publicly | | available | FOLIO | dataset | on |
-| ------- | ------ | -------- | --------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------ | ------------ | --- | --------- | ----- | ------- | --- |
-| present | in the | original | sentence. | We | propose | im- | | | | | | | |
-https://github.com/Yale-LILY/FOLIO.
-| provingthefaithfulnessofFOLtranslationsbyask- | | | | | | | | | | | | | We |
-| --------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | -------------- | --- | ------- | ---- | ------------ | --- |
-| | | | | | | | choose | representative | | samples | from | the training | |
-ingtheLLMtotranslatetheFOLbacktonatural
-splitofthedatasettobeourfew-shotexamplesand
-| languageandcomparingwiththeoriginal. | | | | | Forward | | | | | | | | |
-| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-translationsthatrankhighlywhenback-translated use the validation split of the dataset in our eval-
-| | | | | | | | uation. | The testing | split | is | not publicly | available. | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ----------- | ----- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | --- |
-wouldbethosewhichhaveeffectivelycapturedthe
-Theoriginaldatasethas204validationexamples.
-intricaciesofaparticularsentence’ssemantics.
-However,wediscoveredthatthereareerrorsin22
-| Overall, | we | believe | that | shifting | to | evalua- | | | | | | | |
-| -------- | ---- | ------------ | ---- | --------- | ------------ | ------- | ------------- | --- | -------------------------- | --------- | --- | ------------- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | ofthesamples. | | Weremovethesesamplesforour | | | | |
-| tions on | more | naturalistic | | datasets, | and incorpo- | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | evaluation | and | use the | remaining | | 182 examples. | |
-ratingstrategiessuchasthosepresentedhere,will
-Theerrorsasfollows:
-helppavethepathforwardforneurosymbolicap-
-proachestoformalreasoning.
-• In4samples,oneormoreofthegroundtruth
-| | | | | | | | FOL | expressions | | have | unbalanced | parenthe- | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---- | ---------- | --------- | --- |
-B ModelDetailsandParameters
-ses(samples3,109,110,111).
-| We use | a decoding | | temperature | T | = 0.8 | for all | | | | | | | |
-| ------ | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-• In8samples,thelabelobtainedbyexecuting
-models. ForGPT-3.5andGPT-4,welimitthemax-
-| | | | | | | | the | ground-truth | | FOL | expressions | does | not |
-| ----------- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------- | ------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | ----------- | ---- | --- |
-| imum number | | of tokens | | to generate | to 1024 | for | | | | | | | |
-FOLIO and 4096 for ProofWriter (to accommo- 6https://huggingface.co/bigcode/starcoderplus
+tifyfivemodelingcapabilitiesrequiredtocorrect knowledgeintensivetaskswhichrequireanunder-
+thesemistakes(Table5providesexamples): standingoftherelationshipbetweenaninputquery
+andrelevantsupportingtext.
+| Science | background | | includes | | knowledge | of | | | | | | |
+| ------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+domain-specificlexicalrelationships. Automated evidence synthesis (Marshall and
+Directionalityrequiresunderstandingincreasesor Wallace, 2019; Beller et al., 2018; Tsafnat et al.,
+decreasesinscientificquantities. 2014;Marshalletal.,2017)seekstoautomatethe
+Numericalreasoninginvolvesinterpretingnumer- processofcreatingsystematicreviewsofthemed-
+icalorstatisticalfindings. icalliterature7 –forinstance,byextractingPICO
+Cause and effect requires reasoning about coun- snippets (Nye et al., 2018) and inferring the out-
+comesofclinicaltrials(Lehmanetal.,2019;DeY-
+terfactuals.
+Coreferenceinvolvesdrawingconclusionsusing oungetal.,2020b). Wehopethatsystemsforclaim
+contextstatedoutsideofarationalesentence. verificationwillserveascomponentsinfutureevi-
+dencesynthesisframeworks.
+7 Relatedwork
+8 Conclusionandfuturework
+| Fact checking | | and | rationalized | | NLP | models | | | | | | |
+| ------------- | ------- | -------- | ------------ | -------- | ---------- | ------- | ---------------------------------------- | ---- | ------- | --------------- | -------- | ----------- |
+| | | | | | | | Claim verification | | allows | us | to trace | the sources |
+| Fact-checking | | datasets | include | | PolitiFact | (Vla- | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | andmeasuretheveracityofscientificclaims. | | | | | These |
+| chos and | Riedel, | 2014), | | Emergent | (Ferreira | and | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | abilities | have | emerged | as particularly | | important |
+| Vlachos, | 2016), | LIAR | (Wang, | | 2017), | SemEval | | | | | | |
+2017Task8RumorEval(Derczynskietal.,2017), in the context of the current pandemic, and the
+| | | | | | | | broader | reproducibility | | crisis | in science. | In this |
+| ---------------------- | ------ | ------- | ------ | ----------- | ------ | ------ | -------- | --------------- | --- | -------- | ------------- | ------- |
+| Snopes | (Popat | et al., | 2017), | CLEF-2018 | | Check- | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | article, | we formalize | | the task | of scientific | claim |
+| That! (Barro´n-Ceden˜o | | | et | al., 2018), | Verify | (Baly | | | | | | |
+et al., 2018), Perspectrum (Chen et al., 2019), verification,andreleaseadataset(SCIFACT)and
+| | | | | | | | models | (VERISCI) | | to support | work | on this task. |
+| ----- | ------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------- | ------ | ------ | --------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ------------- |
+| FEVER | (Thorne | et | al., 2018), | | and UKP | Snopes | | | | | | |
+Ourresultsindicatethatitispossibletotrainmod-
+| (Hanselowski | | et al., | 2019). | Hanselowski | | et al. | | | | | | |
+| ------------------------------ | --- | ------- | ------ | ----------- | ----------- | ------ | ------- | ---------- | ------------- | --- | --- | ----------- |
+| | | | | | | | els for | scientific | fact-checking | | and | deploy them |
+| (2019)providesathoroughreview. | | | | | Toourknowl- | | | | | | | |
+edge, thereare noexistingdata setsfor scientific with reasonable efficacy on real-world claims re-
+latedtoCOVID-19.
+| claimverification. | | | Werefertoourtaskas“claim | | | | | | | | | |
+| ------------------ | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+Scientificclaimverificationpresentsanumber
+verification”ratherthan“fact-checking”toempha-
+sizethatourfocusistohelpresearchersmakesense ofpromisingavenuesforresearchonmodelscapa-
+bleofincorporatingbackgroundinformation,rea-
+ofscientificfindings,nottocounterdisinformation.
+| | | | | | | | soning | about | scientific | processes, | | and assessing |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ----- | ---------- | ---------- | --- | ------------- |
+Fact-checkingisoneofanumberoftaskswhere
+| | | | | | | | the strength | and | provenance | | of various | evidence |
+| ------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | ------- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | -------- |
+| a model | is required | | to justify | a | prediction | via ra- | | | | | | |
+tionalesfromthesourcedocument. TheERASER sources. Thislastchallengewillbeespeciallycru-
+cialforfutureworkthatseekstoverifyscientific
+| dataset | (DeYoung | | et al., | 2020a) | provides | a suite | | | | | | |
+| ------- | -------- | --- | ------- | ------ | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+claimsagainstsourcesotherthantheresearchlit-
+| of benchmark | | datasets | (including | | SCIFACT) | for | | | | | | |
+| ------------ | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+evaluatingrationalizedNLPmodels. erature–forinstance,socialmediaandthenews.
+| | | | | | | | We hope | that | the resources | | presented | in this pa- |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ---- | ------------- | --- | --------- | ----------- |
+RelatedscientificNLPtasksThecitationcontex-
+perencouragefutureresearchontheseimportant
+| tualization | task | (Cohan | et | al., 2015; | Jaidka | et al., | | | | | | |
+| ----------- | ---- | ------ | --- | ---------- | ------ | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+challenges,andhelpfacilitateprogresstowardthe
+2017)istoidentifyspansinaciteddocumentthat
+broadergoalofscientificdocumentunderstanding.
+arerelevanttoaparticularcitationinacitingdoc-
+ument. Unlike SCIFACT, these citations are not Acknowledgments
+| re-written | into | atomic | claims | | and are | therefore | | | | | | |
+| ---------------------- | ---- | ------ | ------------------------ | --- | ------- | --------- | ----------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ----------------- | -------- |
+| | | | | | | | This research | | was supported | | by the | ONR MURI |
+| moredifficulttoverify. | | | Expertannotatorsachieved | | | | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | N00014-18-1-2670, | | | ONR | N00014-18-1-2826, | |
+verylow(21.7%)inter-annotatoragreementonthe
+DARPAN66001-19-2-4031,NSF(IIS1616112),
+BioMedSummdataset(Cohenetal.,2014),which
+contains314citationsreferencing20papers. Allen Distinguished Investigator Award, and the
+| | | | | | | | Sloanfellowship. | | WethanktheSemanticScholar | | | |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- |
+Biomedicalquestionansweringdatasetsinclude
+teamatAI2,UW-NLP,andH2labatUWforhelp-
+BioASQ(Tsatsaronisetal.,2015)andPubMedQA
+(Jin et al., 2019), which contain 855 and 1,000 fulcommentsandfeedback.
+“yes/no”questionsrespectively(Guetal.,2020).
+7https://www.cochranelibrary.com/
+Claimverificationandquestionansweringareboth- about/about-cochrane-reviews
+7542
-main/data/v0.0/folio-train.jsonl.
-| match | the | provided | ground | | truth label. | We | | | | | | | We do |
-| ----- | --- | -------- | ------ | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- |
-double-checked this, first by executing the notoptimizeforthechoiceoffew-shotexamples,
-FOLexpressionsthroughProver9andsecond andthisistheonlysetofexamplesweevaluated
-bycheckingitmanually. (samples6,28,30, with, so it is likely that there exist better choices
-48,113,115,139,140). forfew-shotexamplesthatwouldleadtoimproved
-performanceacrosstheboard.
-• In10samples,thenumberofpremisesdoes
-not match the number of FOL expressions D.1 FOLIO,1-shot(baseline)
-| (samples | | 10, 11, | 12, 88, | 106, | 107, | 108, 174, | | | | | | | |
-| -------- | --- | ------- | ------- | ---- | ---- | --------- | --- | --------- | ---------------- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | The | following | is a first-order | | logic | (FOL) | |
-175,176).
-(cid:44)→ problem.
-| | | | | | | | The | problem | is to determine | | whether | the | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --------------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- |
-The sample numbers above refer to the (cid:44)→ conclusion follows from the premises.
-| | | | | | | | The | premises | are given | in the | form | of a set | of |
-| ---------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --------------------- | --------- | ---------------- | ---- | -------- | --- |
-| line index | in | the | validation | | file located | at | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | | (cid:44)→ first-order | | logic sentences. | | | |
-https://github.com/Yale-LILY/FOLIO/blob/
-| | | | | | | | The | conclusion | is given | in | the form | of a single | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | -------- | --- | -------- | ----------- | --- |
-main/data/v0.0/folio-validation.jsonl. (cid:44)→ first-order logic sentence.
-| | | | | | | | The | task is | to evaluate | the | conclusion | as | 'True', |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | ----------- | ----------- | ---------- | --------- | ------- |
-| | | | | | | | | (cid:44)→ 'False', | or | 'Uncertain' | | given the | |
-D FOLIOFew-ShotPrompts
-(cid:44)→ premises.
-| The methodologies | | | we investigate | | do | not re- | | | | | | | |
-| ----------------- | ---------- | ---------- | --------------- | --- | --------- | --------- | ---------- | ----------- | --------------- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- |
-| quire any | finetuning | on | domain-specific | | | data. In- | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | All | dispensable | things | are | environment-friendly. | | |
-| stead, we | use | in-context | learning | | (ICL) | with pre- | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | All | woodware | is dispensable. | | | | |
-| trained | models. | We | prompt | | the model | with | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | All | paper | is woodware. | | | | |
-a set of instructions and 1-8 ICL examples, No good things are bad.
-| | | | | | | | All | environment-friendly | | things | are | good. | |
-| ----------- | -------------------------------- | ----------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | ----------- | -------------------- | --------- | ------ | ----- | ------------ | --- |
-| which | adhere | to a | structured | | text format | de- | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | A worksheet | | is either | paper | or is | environment- | |
-| signed | to scaffold | generations | | | and ease | post- | | (cid:44)→ friendly. | | | | | |
-| processing. | Inparticular,webegineachICLexam- | | | | | | | | | | | | |
-
-| ple with | each | of the | NL premises | | wrapped | in an | | | | | | | |
-| -------- | ---- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ------- | ----- | ----------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | A worksheet | | is not dispensable. | | | | |
-...
-| HTML-style | | tag | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| ---------- | --- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| followed | by | the NL | conclusion | | wrapped | in | | | | | | | |
-Uncertain
-| .... | | | | | The | requi- | | | | | | | |
-| ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-
-siteevaluationstepsforeachevaluationparadigm
-
-arethenoutlinedinasubsequentsectionwrapped ...premises for sample here, one premise per
-| .... | | | | | Followingthein- | | | line | | | | | |
-| ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-(cid:44)→
-
-clusionofICLexamples,atestexampleisadded,
-
-withtheandsections.
-| | | | | | | | ...conclusion | | for sample | here | | | |
-| -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- |
-| Then,thetagisopened,andtheLM | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
-
-| is allowed | to | proceed | with | causal | generation | un- | | | | | | | |
-| ---------- | --- | ------- | ---- | ------ | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-
-| til the | | tag | is | generated. | Upon | gen- | | | | | | | |
-| ------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ---- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ---- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | | | Listing1: | | todo | | |
-
-| eration | of this | stop token, | | the | | block | | | | | | | |
-| ------- | ------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-issegmentedforpost-processingaccordingtothe
-D.2 FOLIO,1-shot(scratchpad)
-| | | | ({naïve, | | scratchpad, | | | | | | | | |
-| --------------------------------------- | --------- | --------- | ----------------- | -------- | ----------- | -------- | --- | -------------------- | ---------------- | ---------------- | -------- | --------- | --- |
-| method | being | evaluated | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| chain-of-thought, | | | neuro-symbolic}). | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | The | following | is a first-order | | logic | (FOL) | |
-| Forthefew-shotexamples,weusesamplesfrom | | | | | | | | (cid:44)→ problem. | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | The | problem | is to determine | | whether | the | |
-| the publicly | available | | FOLIO | training | | set. We | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | | (cid:44)→ conclusion | follows | | from the | premises. | |
-| | | | | | | | The | premises | are given | in the | form | of a set | of |
-| select a | set of | diverse | samples | that | are | balanced | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | | first-order | | logic sentences. | | | |
-(cid:44)→
-across labels. Since the FOLIO training set does The conclusion is given in the form of a single
-notcomewithFOLexpressionsfortheconclusions first-order logic sentence.
-(cid:44)→
-| | | | | | | | The | task is | to translate | each | of | the premises | |
-| -------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | ------- | ------------ | ---- | --- | ------------ | --- |
-| or chain | of thought | | prompts, | we | manually | add | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | | and | conclusions | into | FOL | expressions, | and |
-(cid:44)→
-bothforeachsample. Forthek-shotsetting(k<8), then to evaluate the conclusion as 'True
-(cid:44)→
-weusethefirstk samplesfromthefollowinglist ', 'False', or 'Uncertain' given the
-(cid:44)→
-premises.
-| of sample | indices: | 126, | 24, | 61, | 276, | 149, 262, | | (cid:44)→ | | | | | |
-| ---------------------------------------- | -------- | ------ | -------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | ---------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| 264, 684. | Here, | sample | i refers | | to the | ith line in | | | | | | | |
-| https://github.com/Yale-LILY/FOLIO/blob/ | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
+References Jay DeYoung, Eric Lehman, Ben Nye, Iain James
+Marshall, and Byron C. Wallace. 2020b. Evi-
+Ramy Baly, Mitra Mohtarami, James Glass, Llu´ıs
+dence inference 2.0: More data, better models. In
+Ma`rquez,AlessandroMoschitti,andPreslavNakov.
+BioNLP@ACL.
+2018. Integratingstancedetectionandfactchecking
+inaunifiedcorpus. InNAACL. RotemDror,GiliBaumer,SegevShlomov,andRoiRe-
+ichart.2018. Thehitchhiker’sguidetotestingstatis-
+Alberto Barro´n-Ceden˜o, Tamer Elsayed, Reem
+ticalsignificanceinnaturallanguageprocessing. In
+Suwaileh, Llu´ıs Ma`rquez i Villodre, Pepa ACL.
+Atanasova, Wajdi Zaghouani, Spas Kyuchukov,
+Giovanni Da San Martino, and Preslav Nakov. Bradley Efron and Robert Tibshirani. 1993. An intro-
+2018. Overviewoftheclef-2018checkthat! labon ductiontothebootstrap.
+automaticidentificationandverificationofpolitical
+claims.task2: Factuality. InCLEF. William Ferreira and Andreas Vlachos. 2016. Emer-
+gent: a novel data-set for stance classification. In
+Elaine Beller, Justin Clark, Guy Tsafnat, Clive Elliott NAACL.
+Adams, Heinz Diehl, Hans Lund, Mourad Ouzzani,
+Kristina Thayer, James Thomas, Tari Turner, J. S. Yu Gu, Robert Tinn, Hao Cheng, M. Lucas,
+Xia,KarenA.Robinson,andPaulPGlasziou.2018. Naoto Usuyama, Xiaodong Liu, Tristan Nau-
+Makingprogresswiththeautomationofsystematic mann, Jianfeng Gao, and Hoifung Poon. 2020.
+reviews: principles of the international collabora- Domain-specific language model pretraining for
+tionfortheautomationofsystematicreviews(icasr). biomedical natural language processing. ArXiv,
+SystematicReviews,7. abs/2007.15779.
+Suchin Gururangan, Ana Marasovic, Swabha
+IzBeltagy,KyleLo,andArmanCohan.2019. Scibert:
+Swayamdipta, Kyle Lo, Iz Beltagy, Doug Downey,
+A pretrained language model for scientific text. In
+and Noah A. Smith. 2020. Don’t stop pretraining:
+EMNLP.
+Adapt language models to domains and tasks. In
+Iz Beltagy, Matthew E. Peters, and Arman Cohan. ACL.
+2020. Longformer: Thelong-documenttransformer.
+Suchin Gururangan, Swabha Swayamdipta, Omer
+ArXiv,abs/2004.05150.
+Levy, Roy Schwartz, Samuel R. Bowman, and
+Taylor Berg-Kirkpatrick, David Burkett, and Dan Noah A. Smith. 2018. Annotation artifacts in nat-
+Klein. 2012. An empirical investigation of statisti- urallanguageinferencedata. InNAACL.
+calsignificanceinnlp. InEMNLP.
+AndreasHanselowski, ChristianStab, Claudia Schulz,
+Zile Li, and Iryna Gurevych. 2019. A richly anno-
+Sihao Chen, Daniel Khashabi, Wenpeng Yin, Chris
+tated corpus for different tasks in automated fact-
+Callison-Burch,andDanRoth.2019. Seeingthings
+checking. InCoNLL.
+fromadifferentangle: Discoveringdiverseperspec-
+tivesaboutclaims. InNAACL.
+Kokil Jaidka, Muthu Kumar Chandrasekaran, Devan-
+shuJain,andMin-YenKan.2017. Thecl-scisumm
+Arman Cohan, Luca Soldaini, and Nazli Goharian.
+shared task 2017: Results and key insights. In
+2015. Matching citation text and cited spans in
+BIRNDL@JCDL.
+biomedical literature: a search-oriented approach.
+InNAACL.
+QiaoJin,BhuwanDhingra,ZhengpingLiu,WilliamW.
+Cohen, and Xinghua Lu. 2019. Pubmedqa: A
+Kevin Bretonnel Cohen, Hoa Trang Dang, Anita
+dataset for biomedical research question answering.
+de Waard, Prabha Yadav, and Lucy Vanderwende.
+InEMNLP.
+2014. Tac 2014 biomedical summarization track.
+https://tac.nist.gov/2014/BiomedSumm/. Eric Lehman, Jay DeYoung, Regina Barzilay, and By-
+ron C. Wallace. 2019. Inferring which medical
+Leon Derczynski, Kalina Bontcheva, Maria Liakata,
+treatments work from reports of clinical trials. In
+RobProcter,GeraldineWongSakHoi,andArkaitz
+NAACL.
+Zubiaga.2017. SemEval-2017task8: RumourEval:
+Determining rumour veracity and support for ru- Tao Lei, Regina Barzilay, and Tommi S. Jaakkola.
+mours. InSemEval. 2016. Rationalizingneuralpredictions. InACL.
+Jacob Devlin, Ming-Wei Chang, Kenton Lee, and YinhanLiu,MyleOtt,NamanGoyal,JingfeiDu,Man-
+KristinaToutanova.2019. Bert:Pre-trainingofdeep dar Joshi, Danqi Chen, Omer Levy, Mike Lewis,
+bidirectional transformers for language understand- Luke Zettlemoyer, and Veselin Stoyanov. 2019.
+ing. InNAACL. Roberta: A robustly optimized bert pretraining ap-
+proach. ArXiv,abs/1907.11692.
+Jay DeYoung, Sarthak Jain, Nazneen Fatema Rajani,
+EricLehman, CaimingXiong, RichardSocher, and KyleLo,LucyLuWang,MarkNeumann,RodneyKin-
+Byron C. Wallace. 2020a. Eraser: A benchmark to ney,andDanielS.Weld.2020. S2ORC:TheSeman-
+evaluaterationalizednlpmodels. InACL. ticScholarOpenResearchCorpus. InACL.
+7543
-All dispensable things are environment-friendly.
-All woodware is dispensable. Let's think step by step. We want to evaluate if
-All paper is woodware. (cid:44)→ a worksheet is not dispensable. From
-No good things are bad. (cid:44)→ premise 6, we know that a worksheet is
-All environment-friendly things are good. (cid:44)→ either paper or is environment-friendly.
-A worksheet is either paper or is environment- (cid:44)→ If it is paper, then from premise 3, a
-(cid:44)→ friendly. (cid:44)→ worksheet is woodware, and from premise
- (cid:44)→ 2, a worksheet is dispensable. If it is
- (cid:44)→ environment-friendly, we know it is good
-A worksheet is not dispensable. (cid:44)→ from premise 5, but we know nothing about
- (cid:44)→ whether it is dispensable. Therefore, we
- (cid:44)→ don't know if a worksheet is dispensible
-TEXT: All dispensable things are environment- (cid:44)→ or not, so the statement is uncertain.
-(cid:44)→ friendly. ANSWER: Uncertain
-FOL: all x. (Dispensable(x) ->
-(cid:44)→ EnvironmentFriendly(x))
-TEXT: All woodware is dispensable.
-FOL: all x. (Woodware(x) -> Dispensable(x)) ...premises for sample here, one premise per
-TEXT: All paper is woodware. (cid:44)→ line
-FOL: all x. (Paper(x) -> Woodware(x))
-TEXT: No good things are bad.
-FOL: all x. (Good(x) -> -Bad(x)) ...conclusion for sample here
-TEXT: All environment-friendly things are good.
-FOL: all x. (EnvironmentFriendly(x) -> Good(x))
-TEXT: A worksheet is either paper or is
-(cid:44)→ environment-friendly.
-FOL: ((Paper(Worksheet) & -EnvironmentFriendly( D.4 FOLIO,1-shot(neurosymbolic)
-(cid:44)→ Worksheet)) | (-Paper(Worksheet) &
-(cid:44)→ EnvironmentFriendly(Worksheet))) The following is a first-order logic (FOL)
-TEXT: A worksheet is not dispensable. (cid:44)→ problem.
-FOL: -Dispensable(Worksheet) The problem is to determine whether the
-ANSWER: Uncertain (cid:44)→ conclusion follows from the premises.
- The premises are given in the form of a set of
-(cid:44)→ first-order logic sentences.
- The conclusion is given in the form of a single
-...premises for sample here, one premise per (cid:44)→ first-order logic sentence.
-(cid:44)→ line The task is to translate each of the premises
- (cid:44)→ and conclusions into FOL expressions, so
- (cid:44)→ that the expressions can be evaluated by
-...conclusion for sample here (cid:44)→ a theorem solver to determine whether the
- (cid:44)→ conclusion follows from the premises.
- Expressions should be adhere to the format of
-(cid:44)→ the Python NLTK package logic module.
-D.3 FOLIO,1-shot(chainofthought)
-
-The following is a first-order logic (FOL) All dispensable things are environment-friendly.
-(cid:44)→ problem. All woodware is dispensable.
-The problem is to determine whether the All paper is woodware.
-(cid:44)→ conclusion follows from the premises. No good things are bad.
-The premises are given in the form of a set of All environment-friendly things are good.
-(cid:44)→ first-order logic sentences. A worksheet is either paper or is environment-
-The conclusion is given in the form of a single (cid:44)→ friendly.
-(cid:44)→ first-order logic sentence.
-The task is to translate each of the premises
-(cid:44)→ and conclusions into FOL expressions, A worksheet is not dispensable.
-
-
- TEXT: All dispensable things are environment-
-All dispensable things are environment-friendly. (cid:44)→ friendly.
-All woodware is dispensable. FOL: all x. (Dispensable(x) ->
-All paper is woodware. (cid:44)→ EnvironmentFriendly(x))
-No good things are bad. TEXT: All woodware is dispensable.
-All environment-friendly things are good. FOL: all x. (Woodware(x) -> Dispensable(x))
-A worksheet is either paper or is environment- TEXT: All paper is woodware.
-(cid:44)→ friendly. FOL: all x. (Paper(x) -> Woodware(x))
- TEXT: No good things are bad.
- FOL: all x. (Good(x) -> -Bad(x))
-A worksheet is not dispensable. TEXT: All environment-friendly things are good.
- FOL: all x. (EnvironmentFriendly(x) -> Good(x))
+Yi Luan, Luheng He, Mari Ostendorf, and Hannaneh Andreas Vlachos and Sebastian Riedel. 2014. Fact
+Hajishirzi. 2018. Multi-task identification of enti- checking: Task definition and dataset construction.
+ties, relations, and coreference for scientific knowl- In ACL Workshop on Language Technologies and
+| edgegraphconstruction. | | | InEMNLP. | | | | ComputationalSocialScience. | | | | | |
+| ---------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+IainJamesMarshall,Joe¨lKuiper,EdwardBanner,and Lucy Lu Wang, Kyle Lo, Yoganand Chandrasekhar,
+RussellReas,JiangjiangYang,DarrinEide,Kathryn
+| ByronC.Wallace.2017. | | | Automatingbiomedicalev- | | | | | | | | | |
+| -------------------- | --- | -------------- | ----------------------- | ---- | --- | --- | ------------ | ------- | ----- | ------ | ------------- | ------- |
+| | | | | | | | Funk, Rodney | Kinney, | | Ziyang | Liu, William. | Mer- |
+| idencesynthesis: | | Robotreviewer. | | ACL. | | | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | rill, Paul | Mooney, | Dewey | A. | Murdick, | Devvret |
+Iain James Marshall and Byron C. Wallace. 2019. Rishi, Jerry Sheehan, Zhihong Shen, Brandon Stil-
+Toward systematic review automation: a practical son,AlexD.Wade,KuansanWang,ChristopherWil-
+| | | | | | | | helm, Boya | Xie, | Douglas | M. | Raymond, | Daniel S. |
+| -------- | ----- | ------- | -------- | --- | ----- | ----------- | ---------- | ---- | ------- | --- | -------- | --------- |
+| guide to | using | machine | learning | | tools | in research | | | | | | |
+Weld,OrenEtzioni,andSebastianKohlmeier.2020.
+| synthesis. | SystematicReviews,8. | | | | | | | | | | | |
+| ---------- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | -------- | ---- | -------- | -------- |
+| | | | | | | | Cord-19: | The | covid-19 | open | research | dataset. |
+ArXiv,abs/2004.10706.
+| Preslav I | Nakov, | Ariel | S Schwartz, | | and Marti | Hearst. | | | | | | |
+| --------- | ------ | ----- | ----------- | --- | --------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+2004. Citances: Citation sentences for semantic WilliamYangWang.2017. “liar,liarpantsonfire”: A
+| analysis | of bioscience | | text. | In SIGIR | workshop | on | | | | | | |
+| -------- | ------------- | --- | ----- | -------- | -------- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+| | | | | | | | newbenchmarkdatasetforfakenewsdetection. | | | | | In |
+SearchandDiscoveryinBioinformatics.
+ACL.
+Benjamin Nye, Junyi Jessy Li, Roma Patel, Yinfei Thomas Wolf, Lysandre Debut, Victor Sanh, Julien
+Yang, Iain James Marshall, Ani Nenkova, and By- Chaumond, ClementDelangue, AnthonyMoi, Pier-
+ronC.Wallace.2018. Acorpuswithmulti-levelan- ricCistac,TimRault,R’emiLouf,MorganFuntow-
+notationsofpatients,interventionsandoutcomesto icz, and Jamie Brew. 2019. Huggingface’s trans-
+| support | language | processing | | for medical | | literature. | | | | | | |
+| ------- | -------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | -------- | ---------------- | --- | ------- | -------- | -------- |
+| | | | | | | | formers: | State-of-the-art | | natural | language | process- |
+InACL.
+ing. ArXiv,abs/1910.03771.
+| Kashyap | Popat, | Subhabrata | | Mukherjee, | | Jannik | | | | | | |
+| ----------------------------- | ------------------------------------ | ---------- | ------- | ----------- | ---------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+| Stro¨tgen, | and | Gerhard | Weikum. | 2017. | | Where the | | | | | | |
+| truth lies: | Explaining | | the | credibility | of | emerging | | | | | | |
+| claimsonthewebandsocialmedia. | | | | | InWWW. | | | | | | | |
+| Tal Schuster, | Darsh | J. | Shah, | Yun | Jie Serene | Yeo, | | | | | | |
+| Daniel | Filizzola, | Enrico | Santus, | and | Regina | Barzi- | | | | | | |
+| lay.2019. | Towardsdebiasingfactverificationmod- | | | | | | | | | | | |
+els. InEMNLP.
+| Amir Soleimani, | | Christof | Monz, | and | Marcel | Worring. | | | | | | |
+| --------------- | ------------------------------------ | -------- | --------- | --- | --------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+| 2019. | Bert for | evidence | retrieval | | and claim | verifi- | | | | | | |
+| cation. | InEuropeanConferenceonInformationRe- | | | | | | | | | | | |
+trieval.
+| James Thorne, | | Andreas | | Vlachos, | | Christos | | | | | | |
+| ------------------- | -------------------------- | ----------- | ---------- | ------------ | -------------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+| Christodoulopoulos, | | | and | Arpit | Mittal. | 2018. | | | | | | |
+| Fever: | a large-scale | | dataset | for fact | extraction | and | | | | | | |
+| verification. | InNAACL. | | | | | | | | | | | |
+| Guy Tsafnat, | Paul | P Glasziou, | | Miew | Keen | Choong, | | | | | | |
+| Adam | G. Dunn, | Filippo | Galgani, | | and | Enrico W. | | | | | | |
+| Coiera. | 2014. | Systematic | | review | automation | tech- | | | | | | |
+| nologies. | SystematicReviews,3:74–74. | | | | | | | | | | | |
+| George Tsatsaronis, | | Georgios | | Balikas, | | Prodromos | | | | | | |
+| Malakasiotis, | | Ioannis | Partalas, | Matthias | | Zschunke, | | | | | | |
+| Michael | R. Alvers, | | Dirk | Weissenborn, | | Anastasia | | | | | | |
+| Krithara, | Sergios | Petridis, | Dimitris | | Polychronopou- | | | | | | | |
+| los, Yannis | Almirantis, | | John | Pavlopoulos, | | Nico- | | | | | | |
+| las Baskiotis, | | Patrick | Gallinari, | | Thierry | Artie`res, | | | | | | |
+| Axel-Cyrille | Ngonga | | Ngomo, | Norman | Heino, | E´ric | | | | | | |
+Gaussier,LilianaBarrio-Alvers,MichaelSchroeder,
+IonAndroutsopoulos,andGeorgiosPaliouras.2015.
+| An overview | | of the | bioasq | large-scale | | biomedical | | | | | | |
+| ----------- | --- | ------ | ------ | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+semanticindexingandquestionansweringcompeti-
+tion. InBMCBioinformatics.
+7544
-TEXT: A worksheet is either paper or is (Incorrect) Translation 2 (StarCoderPlus): ((
-(cid:44)→ environment-friendly. (cid:44)→ Rabbit(Animal) & -Squirrel(Animal)) | (-
-FOL: ((Paper(Worksheet) & -EnvironmentFriendly( (cid:44)→ Rabbit(Animal) & Squirrel(Animal)))
-(cid:44)→ Worksheet)) | (-Paper(Worksheet) & (Incorrect) Translation 3 (GPT-4): all x. ((
-(cid:44)→ EnvironmentFriendly(Worksheet))) (cid:44)→ Animal(x) & Rabbit(x)) | (Animal(x) &
-TEXT: A worksheet is not dispensable. (cid:44)→ Squirrel(x)))
-FOL: -Dispensable(Worksheet)
- Premise: a person either studys or teaches
-(Ground Truth) Translation: all x. (Study(x) |
- (cid:44)→ Teaches(x))
-...premises for sample here, one premise per (Incorrect) Translation 1 (StarCoderPlus):
-(cid:44)→ line (cid:44)→ Studys(Person) | Teaches(Person)
- (Incorrect) Translation 2 (StarCoderPlus): ((
- (cid:44)→ Study(Person) & -Teach(Person)) | (-Study
-...conclusion for sample here (cid:44)→ (Person) & Teach(Person)))
- (Correct) Translation 3 (GPT-4): all x. (Studies
- (cid:44)→ (x) | Teaches(x))
-Premise: A man is either kind or evil.
-E FOLIOErrorAnalysis (Ground Truth) Translation: all x. (Kind(x) & -
-(cid:44)→ Evil(x)) | (-Kind(x) & Evil(x))
-(Incorrect) Translation 1 (GPT-3.5): ((Man(x) & -
-E.1 Ambiguityof“Either”statements
-(cid:44)→ Kind(x)) | (-Man(x) & Evil(x)))
-Dependingonthecontext,thephrase“eitherxor (Incorrect) Translation 2 (StarCoderPlus): Kind(
-y”couldmeanx XOR y,x OR y,orbeambiguous. (cid:44)→ AMan) | Evil(AMan)
-(Incorrect) Translation 3 (StarCoderPlus): (Kind
-Throughoutourexperiments,wefoundthatmodels (cid:44)→ (x) | Evil(x))
-hadmanycreativelyincorrectwaysoftranslating
-Premise: Ben is either from The Simpsons or
-these statements. One reoccurring error was that
-(cid:44)→ funny.
-statementsthatclearlyintendedx XOR y(suchas,
-(Ground Truth) Translation: (Simpsons(Ben) & -
-“an animal is either a rabbit or a squirrel”) were (cid:44)→ Funny(Ben)) | (-Simpsons(Ben) & Funny(Ben
-translated into x OR y. We tried to account for (cid:44)→ ))
-(Correct) Translation 1 (StarCoderPlus): ((
-this into account by including multiple samples (cid:44)→ Simpsons(Ben) & -Funny(Ben)) | (-Simpsons
-with this construct in the few shot examples (see (cid:44)→ (Ben) & Funny(Ben)))
-(Incorrect) Translation 2 (GPT-3.5): (
-Sec. D.4). However, the models still handle this
-(cid:44)→ FromTheSimpsons(Ben) | Funny(Ben))
-constructinconsistentlyandincorrectly. (Incorrect) Translation 3 (GPT-4):
-Inaddition,wefindthatthroughouttheFOLIO (cid:44)→ FromTheSimpsons(Ben) | Funny(Ben)
-dataset,bymatchingthenaturallanguagepremises
-totheFOLpremises,wefindnoconsistentorpre- E.2 GPT-4LINCFailureModes
-dictable pattern as to how “either x or y” state-
-L1: FOL fails to capture implicit information
-ments are translated. For example, “an animal is
-notmentionedinthepremises. Threeexamples
-either a rabbi or a squirrel” is translated as all
-oferrorsfromtheFOLIOvalidationsetareshown
-x. Rabbit(x) | Squirrel(x),whilewebelieve
-below. ThefirsttwooccurringinbothGPT-3.5and
-thisinstanceshouldclearlybeXOR.Therefore,we
-GPT-4,andthelatteronlyoccursinGPT-3.5and
-believethatsomeofthesesamplesareinherently
-interestingly, is correct in GPT-4. In Example 1,
-ambiguousormalformed.
-tomakethecorrectconclusion,wemustencodein
-To highlight model behavior on these exam-
-FOLthatHarryisaperson(Person(Harry))and
-ples, four representative examples from the FO-
-that Walden is a book (Book("Walden")). Harry
-LIO validation set are shown below; examples
-being a person is implicit, but “Walden” being a
-have multiple translations because we used tem-
-bookisexplicitlymentionedinpremise4butfails
-peratureT = 0.8. Here,Correct/Incorrectindicate
-to be explicitly encoded by the model. In Exam-
-whether the translations match the ground truth
-ple 2, we must encode that KiKi is an animal to
-(which doesn’t necessarily match how we would
-make the correct deduction. One can argue that
-translateit).
-this example is ambiguous, but from the context,
-Premise: an animal is either a rabbit or a
-mostwouldmakethisinference. InExample3,we
-(cid:44)→ squirrel
-(Ground Truth) Translation: all x. (Rabbit(x) | needaclausethatsaysLGAandLGAarethesame
-(cid:44)→ Squirrel(x)) airport(SameAirport(LGA, LGA)).
-(Correct) Translation 1 (GPT-3.5): all x. (
-(cid:44)→ Animal(x) -> (Rabbit(x) | Squirrel(x))) Example 1 (GPT-4)
+| A | Modelimplementationdetails | | | | | | | A.3 Trainingthe | | LABELPREDICTION | | | |
+| --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- |
+module
+AllmodelsareimplementedusingtheHuggingface We adopt similar settings as we used for the RA-
+Transformerspackage(Wolfetal.,2019). TIONALESELECTION moduleandonlychangethe
+learningrateto1e-5forthetransformerbaseand
+| | | | | | | | | 1e-4forthelinearlayerformodelstrainedon | | | | | SCI- |
+| --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ---- |
+| A.1 | Parametersforthefinal | | | | VERISCIsystem | | | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | | FACT,FEVER,andUKPSnopes. | | | | Whentrainingon | |
+claim/citedabstractpairslabeledNOINFO,weuse
+| Forthe | ABSTRACTRETRIEVALmodule, | | | | | VERISCI | | | | | | | |
+| ------ | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+thek
+retrieves the top k = 3 documents ranked by TF- sentencesintheabstractwithgreatestsimi-
+| | | | | | | | | laritytotheclaimasrationales(§5). | | | | k issampled | |
+| --- | ---------- | --- | ----- | ------- | -------- | --- | --------- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- |
+| IDF | similarity | | using | unigram | + bigram | | features. | | | | | | |
+from{0,1}withuniformprobability.
+| Theseparametersaretunedonthe | | | | | SCIFACTdevel- | | | | | | | | |
+| ---------------------------- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------ | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+| opmentset. | | | | | | | | A.4 Additionaltrainingdetails | | | | | |
+| When | | making | predictions | | using | the | RATIO- | | | | | | |
+AllmodelsaretrainedusingasingleNvidiaP100
+NALESELECTIONmoduledescribedin§5,wefind GPUonGoogleColabortoaryProplatform.8
+For
+| that | the | usual decision | | rule | of predicting | | zˆ = 1 | | | | | | |
+| -------- | --- | ------------------------------- | ----- | ---- | ------------- | ------- | ------ | ---------------------------------------- | --- | ----- | ---------- | -------------- | --- |
+| | | | | | | | i | theRATIONALESELECTIONmodule,ittakesabout | | | | | |
+| when | z˜ | ≥ 0.5 | works | well | for models | trained | on | | | | | | |
+| | i | | | | | | | 150 minutes | to | train | on SCIFACT | for 20 epochs. | |
+| SCIFACT. | | However,formodelstrainedonFEVER | | | | | | | | | | | |
+120minutesonUKPSnopesfor5epochs,and700
+andUKPSnopes,weachievebetterperformance minuteson FEVER for3epochs. Forthe LABEL-
+| by | tuning | the classification | | | threshold | t, such | that | | | | | | |
+| --- | ------ | ------------------ | --- | ----- | ----------- | ------- | -------- | ---------- | ----------------------------- | --- | -------------- | ----------- | --- |
+| | | | | | | | | PREDICTION | module,ittakesabout130minutes | | | | |
+| zˆ | = 1 | when z˜ | ≥ | t, on | the SCIFACT | | dev set. | | | | | | |
+| i | | | i | | | | | to train | on SCIFACT | | for 20 epochs, | 160 minutes | |
+| The | best | threshold | was | t = | 0.025 | when | training | | | | | | |
+onUKPSnopesfor5epochs,and640minuteson
+| on | FEVER, | and | t = | 0.75 when | training | | on UKP | | | | | | |
+| --- | ------ | --- | --- | --------- | -------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+FEVERfor3epochs.
+Snopes.
+| | | | | | | | | A.5 Hyperparametersearch | | | | | |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+Thelearningrate,batchsize,andnumberofepochs
+| A.2 | Trainingthe | | RATIONALESELECTION | | | | | | | | | | |
+| --- | ----------- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- |
+| | | | | | | | | arethemostimportanthyperparameters. | | | | Weper- | |
+module
+formmanualtuningandselectthehyperparameters
+| | | | | | | | | that produce | the | highest | F1 on | the development | |
+| --- | ---------- | --- | ---- | ------- | -------- | ----- | ---- | --------------------------------------------- | --- | ------- | ----- | --------------- | --- |
+| We | experiment | | with | various | learning | rates | when | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | | set. Forthelearningrate,weexperimentwith1e-3, | | | | | |
+training SCIBERT,BioMedRoBERTa,RoBERTa-
+base,andRoBERTa-large. Belowwedescribethe 1e-4, 5e-5, 1e-5, and5e-6. Forbatchsize, weex-
+settingfortrainingRoBERTa-large. perimentwith64and256. Thenumberofepochs
+arecutoffafterthemodelconverges.
+| Formodelstrainedon | | | | SCIFACT,weuseanini- | | | | | | | | | |
+| ------------------ | -------- | ------ | ------- | ------------------- | --------------- | ----- | ------ | --------------------- | --------------- | --- | ------ | ---------------- | --- |
+| tial | learning | rate | of 1e-5 | on | the transformer | | base | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | | B Statisticalanalysis | | | | | |
+| and | 1e-3 | on the | linear | layer. | For | FEVER | + SCI- | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | | We assess | the uncertainty | | in the | results reported | |
+FACT,thelearningrateissetto1e-5fortheentire
+modelforpre-trainingon FEVER andfine-tuning inthemainresults(Table4)usingasimpleboot-
+on SCIFACT. Weuseabatchsizeof256through strapapproach(Droretal.,2018;Berg-Kirkpatrick
+| | | | | | | | | et al., 2012; | Efron | and | Tibshirani, | 1993). | Given |
+| -------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ------------- | ----- | --- | ----------- | ------ | ----- |
+| gradient | | accumulation | | and | apply cosine | | learning | | | | | | |
+ratedecayover20epochstofindthebestperform- our test set with n = 300 claims, we gener-
+test
+ingmodelonthedevset. ate n = 10,000 bootstrap-resampled test sets
+boot
+byresampling(uniformly,withreplacement)n
+| Formodelstrainedon | | | | FEVER,wesetthelearn- | | | | | | | | | test |
+| ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | ---- |
+| | | | | | | | | claimsfromthetestset. | | | Foreachresampledtestset, | | |
+ingrateto5e-6forthetransformerbaseand5e-5
+| | | | | | | | | wecomputethemetricsinTable4. | | | | Table6reports | |
+| --- | ---------- | ------ | --- | ---------- | ------- | --- | ------ | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- |
+| for | the linear | layer. | | For models | trained | | on UKP | | | | | | |
+themeanandstandarddeviationofthesemetrics,
+Snopes,wesetthelearningrate1e-5forthetrans-
+| | | | | | | | | computedoverthebootstrapsamples. | | | | Table7re- | |
+| ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --------- | --- |
+| formerbaseand1e-4forthelinearlayer. | | | | | | | Wefind | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | | portsdevsetmetrics. | | | Ourconclusionthattraining | | |
+thattheselearningrateshelpthemodelsconverge.
+onSCIFACTimprovesperformanceisrobusttothe
+| We | only | train the | model | for | 3 epochs | on | FEVER | | | | | | |
+| --- | ---- | --------- | ----- | --- | -------- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+uncertaintiespresentedinthesetables.
+| and | 5 epochs | on | UKP | Snopes | because | | they are | | | | | | |
+| ------------ | -------- | --- | ------- | ------ | --------- | --- | -------- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+| larger | datasets | | and the | models | converged | | within | | | | | | |
+| earlyepochs. | | | | | | | | 8https://colab.research.google.com/ | | | | | |
+7545
-| Premises: | | | | | | choice | of | representation. | | We | show | four | illus- |
-| --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | ---- | ---- | ------ |
-Books contain tons of knowledge. trative examples: the first two examples occur
-| When a person | reads | a book, | that | person | gains | | | | | | | | |
-| ------------- | ----- | ------- | ---- | ------ | ----- | ------- | ------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----- | -------- | --- |
-| | | | | | | in both | GPT-3.5 | | and GPT-4, | | while | the last | two |
-(cid:44)→ knowledge.
-If a person gains knowledge, they become smarter. examples only occur in GPT-3.5 and are correct
-| (cid:44)→ | | | | | | whenusingGPT-4. | | | Thefirstexampleisdescribed | | | | |
-| ---------- | -------- | -------- | --- | ----- | -------- | --------------- | ---- | ----- | -------------------------- | --- | ----- | ---- | ---- |
-| Harry read | the book | "Walden" | by | Henry | Thoreau. | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | in the | main | text. | In example | | 2, we | know | that |
-Conclusion (Ground Truth: True) Barutin Cove is a cove, but this lost information
-| Harry is | smarter than | before. | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| -------- | ------------ | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-isnotencodedintheFOL,sowecannotconclude
-| FOLs: | | | | | | Cove(BarutinCove), | | | although | | this is | crucial | in- |
-| --------------- | ------------- | ----------- | ---------- | ----------- | --------- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ----------- | ------- | --- |
-| all x. (Book(x) | -> | Contains(x, | | Knowledge)) | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | formationformakingthededuction. | | | | | InExample3, | | |
-| all x. all | y. (Person(x) | | & Reads(x, | y) | & Book(y) | | | | | | | | |
--> Gains(x, Knowledge)) wemustdeducethatTom’slicenseplateisalicense
-(cid:44)→
-all x. (Gains(x, Knowledge) -> Smarter(x)) plate(FromIstanbul(TomPlate)),whichisobvi-
-| Reads(Harry, | Walden) | | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| ------------ | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | --- | ------ | ------ | ----- |
-| | | | | | | ous | but is | not encoded | by | the | model. | In the | final |
-Conclusion (Prover9 Deduction: Uncertain) example,theideathatanobjecthasfoursidesisex-
-| Smarter(Harry) | | | | | | pressedbothasFourSided(x)andFourSides(x), | | | | | | | |
-| -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-sothemodelisunabletomakethecorrectdeduc-
-| Example 2 | (GPT-4) | | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| ------------ | ----------- | ---- | ---------- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| Premises: | | | | | | tion. | | | | | | | |
-| If an animal | barks, | then | Jane does | not | like it. | | | | | | | | |
-| All dogs | are animals | that | bark. | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | Example | 1 | (GPT-4) | | | | | |
-| If an animal | jumps, | then | Jane likes | it. | | | | | | | | | |
-Premises:
-| If an animal | has legs, | then | it | jumps. | | | | | | | | | |
-| --------------- | --------------- | ------ | --------- | ------ | --------- | ---------- | -------------------- | ---------- | ---------- | -------- | ----------- | -------- | --- |
-| | | | | | | Heinrich | Scmidt | was | a Nazi | German | politician. | | |
-| If an animal | is terricolous, | | then | it | has legs. | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | Heeinrich | | Scmidt was | also | a member | of | the | |
-| If KiKi neither | jumps | nor | has legs, | then | KiKi is | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | (cid:44)→ Prussian | State | Parliament | | and | the Nazi | |
-| | terricolous | or has | legs. | | | | | | | | | | |
-| (cid:44)→ | | | | | | | (cid:44)→ Reichstag. | | | | | | |
-| Conclusion | (Ground | Truth: | True) | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | Conclusion | | (Ground | Truth: | True): | | | |
-| KiKi neither | barks | nor is | a dog. | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | Heinrich | Schmidt | was | either | German | or | Russian. | |
-FOLs:
-FOLs:
-| all x. (Animal(x) | & | Barks(x) | -> | NotLike(Jane, | x) | | | | | | | | |
-| ----------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | GermanPolitician(HeinrichSchmidt) | | | | | & Nazi( | | |
-)
-| (cid:44)→ | | | | | | | (cid:44)→ HeinrichSchmidt) | | | | | | |
-| ----------------- | ------------ | -------- | ----------- | ---------- | --- | ---------------------------------------------- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| all x. (Dog(x) | -> Animal(x) | | & Barks(x)) | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | MemberPrussianStateParliament(HeinrichSchmidt) | | | | | | | & |
-| all x. (Animal(x) | & | Jumps(x) | -> | Like(Jane, | x)) | | | | | | | | |
-(cid:44)→ MemberNaziReichstag(HeinrichSchmidt)
-| all x. (Animal(x) | & | HasLegs(x) | | -> Jumps(x)) | | | | | | | | | |
-| ----------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- |
-| all x. (Animal(x) | & | Terricolous(x) | | -> | HasLegs(x) | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | Conclusion | | (Prover9 | Deduction: | | Uncertain): | | |
-)
-| (cid:44)→ | | | | | | German(HeinrichSchmidt) | | | | | Russian( | | | |
-| ------------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- |
-| (-Jumps(KiKi) | & -HasLegs(KiKi)) | | | -> (Terricolous( | | | | | | | | | |
-(cid:44)→ HeinrichSchmidt)
-| KiKi) | | HasLegs(KiKi)) | | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| ----- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-(cid:44)→
-| | | | | | | Example | 2 | (GPT-4) | | | | | |
-| ---------- | -------- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| Conclusion | (Prover9 | Deduction: | | Uncertain) | | | | | | | | | |
-Premises:
-| -Barks(KiKi) | & -Dog(KiKi) | | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| ------------ | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | -------------------- | -------- | ------------- | --- | --------- | ------- | --- |
-| | | | | | | Barutin | Cove | is named | after | the | Bulgarian | | |
-| | | | | | | | (cid:44)→ settlement | | of Barutin. | | | | |
-| Example 3 | (GPT-3.5): | | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | Barutin | Cove | is on | the southwest | | coast | of Snow | |
-Premises:
-(cid:44)→ Island.
-| Susan flies | to LGA | airport. | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| ------------- | ----------- | -------- | ------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------------- | -------- | ------- | ------- | --------- | ------- | --- |
-| | | | | | | The | South | Shetland | Islands | include | Snow | Island, | |
-| The departure | and arrival | | can not | be | the same | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | (cid:44)→ Greenwich | | Island, | and | Deception | Island. | |
-airport.
-| (cid:44)→ | | | | | | The | South | Shetland | Islands | are | considered | part | |
-| ------------ | -------- | -------- | ------ | --- | --- | ---------- | ------------ | ----------- | -------- | --------- | ---------- | ----- | ---- |
-| John flies | from LGA | airport. | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | (cid:44)→ of | Antarctica. | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | If A | is located | in | B and | B is | located | in C, | then |
-| Conclusion | (Ground | Truth: | False) | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | (cid:44)→ A | is located | in | C. | | | |
-| Susan flies | from LGA | airport. | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | Conclusion | | (Ground | Truth: | True) | | | |
-| FOLs: | | | | | | There | is at | least | one cove | in | Antarctica | named | |
-| Flies(Susan, | LGA) | | | | | | after | a place | in | Bulgaria. | | | |
-(cid:44)→
-| all x. all | y. (Departure(x) | | & Arrival(y) | | & - | | | | | | | | |
-| ------------------------ | ---------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| (cid:44)→ SameAirport(x, | | y)) | | | | FOLs: | | | | | | | |
-Flies(John, LGA) NamedAfter(BarutinCove, Barutin) & In(Barutin,
-Bulgaria)
-(cid:44)→
-Conclusion (Prover9 Deduction: Uncertain): On(BarutinCove, SnowIsland)
-| Flies(Susan, | LGA) | | | | | In(SnowIsland, | | SouthShetlandIslands) | | | | & In( | |
-| ------------ | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ---------------- | --------------------- | --- | --------------------- | --- | ----- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | GreenwichIsland, | | | SouthShetlandIslands) | | | & |
-(cid:44)→
-| | | | | | | | In(DeceptionIsland, | | | SouthShetlandIslands) | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- |
-(cid:44)→
-L2: FOL fails to capture information ex- In(SouthShetlandIslands, Antarctica)
-plicitly mentioned in the premises due to the all x. all y. all z. ((In(x, y) & In(y, z)) ->
+Sentence-level
+| | | | | Selection-Only | | | Selection+Label | |
+| --------- | --------------- | --- | ----- | -------------- | ---- | ---- | --------------- | ------- |
+| Retrieval | Model | Row | P | R | F1 | P | R | F1 |
+| | Oraclerationale | 1 | 100.0 | 80.5 | 89.2 | 89.6 | 72.2 | 79.9 |
+| | | | | 0.0 | 3.3 | 2.1 | 2.7 | 3.7 3.0 |
+Oracle
+| | Zero-shot | 2 | 42.6 | 45.2 | 43.8 | 36.2 | 38.4 | 37.2 |
+| -------- | --------------- | --- | ----- | ---- | ---- | ---- | ---- | ------- |
+| abstract | | | | 2.2 | 3.2 | 2.0 | 2.5 | 3.0 2.3 |
+| | VERISCI | 3 | 76.2 | 63.9 | 69.4 | 66.5 | 55.7 | 60.6 |
+| | | | | 2.9 | 3.6 | 2.6 | 3.4 | 3.7 3.1 |
+| | Oraclerationale | 4 | 100.0 | 56.6 | 72.2 | 87.6 | 49.5 | 63.2 |
+| | | | | 0.0 | 4.0 | 3.3 | 3.5 | 3.9 3.7 |
+| Open | Zero-shot | 5 | 28.7 | 37.6 | 32.5 | 23.8 | 31.1 | 26.9 |
+| | | | | 2.3 | 3.4 | 2.3 | 2.3 | 3.1 2.3 |
+| | VERISCI | 6 | 45.0 | 47.4 | 46.1 | 38.5 | 40.6 | 39.5 |
+| | | | | 3.0 | 3.8 | 3.0 | 3.0 | 3.6 3.0 |
+(a)Sentence-levelresults.
+Abstract-level
+| | | | | Label-Only | | | Label+Rationale | |
+| --------- | --------------- | --- | ---- | ---------- | ---- | ---- | --------------- | ------- |
+| Retrieval | Model | Row | P | R | F1 | P | R | F1 |
+| | | | 90.1 | 77.5 | 83.3 | 90.1 | 77.5 | 83.3 |
+| | Oraclerationale | 1 | | 2.2 | 2.8 | 2.4 | 2.2 | 2.8 2.4 |
+Oracle
+abstract Zero-shot 2 86.9 2.9 53.6 3.4 66.3 3.1 67.9 3.9 41.9 3.2 51.8 3.4
+| | VERISCI | 3 | 87.3 | 2.6 65.3 | 3.2 74.7 | 2.8 84.9 | 2.8 63.5 | 3.2 72.6 2.9 |
+| --- | --------------- | --- | ---- | -------- | -------- | -------- | -------- | ------------ |
+| | Oraclerationale | 4 | 88.9 | 2.7 54.1 | 3.5 67.2 | 3.2 88.9 | 2.7 54.1 | 3.5 67.2 3.2 |
+Open Zero-shot 5 56.0 3.9 42.3 3.4 48.2 3.3 42.3 4.0 32.0 3.2 36.4 3.3
+| | VERISCI | 6 | 47.5 | 3.3 47.3 | 3.5 47.4 | 3.1 46.6 | 3.3 46.4 | 3.5 46.4 3.1 |
+| --- | ------- | --- | ---- | -------- | -------- | -------- | -------- | ------------ |
+(b)Abstract-levelresults
+Table 6: Test set results as in Table 4, reporting mean and standard deviation over 10,000 bootstrap samples.
+Standarddeviationsarereportedassubscripts. SomemeansreportedhereareslightlydifferentfromTable4due
+tosamplingvariability.
+Sentence-level
+| | | | | Selection-Only | | | Selection+Label | |
+| --------- | --------------- | --- | ----- | -------------- | ---- | ---- | --------------- | ------- |
+| Retrieval | Model | Row | P | R | F1 | P | R | F1 |
+| | Oraclerationale | 1 | 100.0 | 81.9 | 90.0 | 91.4 | 74.9 | 82.3 |
+| | | | | 0.0 | 3.2 | 1.9 | 2.5 | 3.6 2.9 |
+Oracle
+| | Zero-shot | 2 | 40.7 | 48.1 | 44.0 | 36.1 | 42.6 | 39.0 |
+| -------- | --------------- | --- | ----- | ---- | ---- | ---- | ---- | ------- |
+| abstract | | | | 2.1 | 3.4 | 2.1 | 2.5 | 3.4 2.5 |
+| | VERISCI | 3 | 79.4 | 59.0 | 67.7 | 71.4 | 53.0 | 60.8 |
+| | | | | 2.7 | 3.6 | 2.8 | 3.5 | 3.6 3.3 |
+| | Oraclerationale | 4 | 100.0 | 58.4 | 73.7 | 90.2 | 52.7 | 66.4 |
+| | | | | 0.0 | 4.3 | 3.4 | 3.3 | 4.3 3.9 |
+| Open | Zero-shot | 5 | 28.6 | 38.5 | 32.8 | 24.8 | 33.4 | 28.4 |
+| | | | | 2.0 | 3.6 | 2.3 | 2.2 | 3.4 2.4 |
+| | VERISCI | 6 | 52.5 | 43.8 | 47.7 | 46.9 | 39.2 | 42.6 |
+| | | | | 3.5 | 3.7 | 3.2 | 3.7 | 3.6 3.2 |
+(a)Sentence-levelresults.
+Abstract-level
+| | | | | Label-Only | | | Label+Rationale | |
+| --------- | --------------- | --- | ---- | ---------- | -------- | -------- | --------------- | ------------ |
+| Retrieval | Model | Row | P | R | F1 | P | R | F1 |
+| | Oraclerationale | 1 | 91.4 | 2.2 76.1 | 3.0 83.0 | 2.5 91.4 | 2.2 76.1 | 3.0 83.0 2.5 |
+Oracle
+| | Zero-shot | 2 | 88.9 | 2.8 58.3 | 3.7 70.4 | 3.2 69.2 | 3.9 45.4 | 3.5 54.8 3.5 |
+| --- | --------- | --- | ---- | -------- | -------- | -------- | -------- | ------------ |
+abstract
+| | VERISCI | 3 | 91.0 | 2.3 67.4 | 3.3 77.4 | 2.7 85.2 | 2.9 63.2 | 3.5 72.5 3.1 |
+| ---- | --------------- | --- | ---- | -------- | -------- | -------- | -------- | ------------ |
+| | Oraclerationale | 4 | 91.0 | 2.6 53.1 | 3.8 67.0 | 3.4 91.0 | 2.6 53.1 | 3.8 67.0 3.4 |
+| Open | Zero-shot | 5 | 52.7 | 41.6 | 46.5 | 43.6 | 34.4 | 38.4 |
+| | | | | 3.7 | 3.7 | 3.4 | 3.7 | 3.5 3.3 |
+| | VERISCI | 6 | 55.4 | 47.5 | 51.0 | 52.6 | 45.1 | 48.5 |
+| | | | | 3.7 | 3.6 | 3.3 | 3.7 | 3.6 3.3 |
+(b)Abstract-levelresults
+Table7: DevsetresultsasinTable4,reportingmeanandstandarddeviationover10,000bootstrapsamples.
+7546
-| | (cid:44)→ In(x, | z)) | | | | | Premises: | | | | | | |
-| --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------- | ------- | ------- |
-| | | | | | | | There | are | four seasons | in | a year: | Spring, | Summer, |
-Conclusion (Prover9 Deduction: Uncertain) (cid:44)→ Fall, and Winter.
-exists x. (Cove(x) & In(x, Antarctica) & exists All students who want to have a long vacation
-(cid:44)→ y. (In(y, Bulgaria) & NamedAfter(x, y))) (cid:44)→ love summer the most.
-| Example | 3 | (GPT-3.5) | | | | | FOLs: | | | | | | |
-| --------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | ------ |
-| Premises: | | | | | | | all | x. (Year(x) | -> | (Spring(x) | | | Summer(x) | | Fall |
-All vehicle registration plates in Istanbul (cid:44)→ (x) | Winter(x)))
-(cid:44)→ begin with the number 34. all x. (Student(x) & WantsLongVacation(x) ->
-Plates that do not begin with the number 34 are Loves(x, Summer))
-(cid:44)→
-| | not | from | Istanbul. | | | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | ---- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-(cid:44)→
-| Joe's | vehicle | registration | | plate | is from | | Prover9 | Error: | | | | | |
-| ----- | --------- | ------------ | --- | ----- | ------- | --- | ------- | --------- | ------- | --- | ---- | ------------- | --- |
-| | Istanbul. | | | | | | The | following | symbols | are | used | with multiple | |
-(cid:44)→
-Tom's license plate begins with the number 35. arities: Summer/1, Summer/0.
-(cid:44)→
-| If a | license | plate | begins | with | the number | 35, | | | | | | | |
-| ---- | ------- | ------- | ------ | ----- | ---------- | ------ | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | then | it does | not | begin | with the | number | Example | 2 | | | | | |
-(cid:44)→
-| | 34. | | | | | | Premises: | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-(cid:44)→
-| | | | | | | | Badults | is | a British | Sitcom | series, | starring | |
-| ---------- | --- | ------- | ------ | ------- | --- | --- | ------- | ------- | --------- | -------- | ------- | -------- | --- |
-| Conclusion | | (Ground | Truth: | False): | | | | members | of | Pappy's. | | | |
-(cid:44)→
-Tom's license plate is from Istanbul. Badults piloted in July 2013 on BBC Three.
-| FOLs: | | | | | | | FOLs: | | | | | | |
-| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-all x. (VehicleRegistrationPlate(x) -> exists x. (Badults(x) & BritishSitcom(x) &
-| | BeginsWith(x, | | 34)) | | | | | StarringMembersOf(x, | | | Pappys)) | | |
-| --- | ------------- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- |
-| | (cid:44)→ | | | | | | | (cid:44)→ | | | | | |
-all x. (-BeginsWith(x, 34) -> -FromIstanbul(x)) Piloted(Badults, July2013, BBCThree)
-FromIstanbul(JoePlate)
-| BeginsWith(TomPlate, | | | 35) | | | | Prover9 | Error: | | | | | |
-| -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-all x. (LicensePlate(x) & BeginsWith(x, 35) -> - The following symbols are used with multiple
-| | BeginsWith(x, | | 34)) | | | | | arities: | | Badults/1, | Badults/0. | | |
-| ---------- | ------------- | -------- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----- | --------- | ----- | ---------- | ---------- | ------ | ----------- |
-| | (cid:44)→ | | | | | | | (cid:44)→ | | | | | |
-| Conclusion | | (Prover9 | Deduction: | | Uncertain): | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | While | rarer, | there | are | also | syntax | errors. For |
-FromIstanbul(TomPlate)
-illustration,twoexamplesfromGPT-4areshown
-| Example | 4 | (GPT-3.5) | | | | | below: | | | | | | |
-| ------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-Premises:
-| | | | | | | | Premise: | Ailton | Silva | foes | not | play for | a |
-| ---------- | ---------- | ----------- | ----------- | ------- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------ | ------------------- | ------- | -------------- | ------------- | --- |
-| All | squares | have | four sides. | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | | football | | club. | | | |
-| All | four-sided | things | are | shapes. | | | | (cid:44)→ | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | FOL: | -Exists | x. (FootballClub(x) | | | & PlaysFor( | |
-| | | | | | | | | AiltonSilva, | | x)) | | | |
-| Conclusion | | (Ground | Truth: | True): | | | | (cid:44)→ | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | Error: | Exists | should | not | be capitalized | | |
-| All | squares | are shapes. | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | Premise: | The | security | deposit | | can be either | |
-FOLs:
-| | | | | | | | | equal | to | one month's | rent | or more. | |
-| --- | ---------------- | --- | ---------------- | --------- | --- | --- | ---- | --------- | ------------ | ----------- | ---- | -------------- | --- |
-| all | x. (Square(x) | | -> FourSides(x)) | | | | | (cid:44)→ | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | FOL: | all x. | all y. | (Rent(x, | y) | -> (Deposit(x) | = |
-| all | x. (FourSided(x) | | -> | Shape(x)) | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | | y | | Deposit(x) | > | y)) | | |
-(cid:44)→
-| | | | | | | | Error: | > is | not allowed | | in Prover9's | FOL | |
-| ---------- | ------------------------ | -------- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --------- | ------- | ----- | ----------- | -------- | ------------ | ---------- | -------- |
-| Conclusion | | (Prover9 | Deduction: | | Uncertain) | | | | | | | | |
-| all | x. (Square(x) | | -> Shape(x)) | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | L4: | There | are | mistakes | | in the FOL | trans- |
-| | | | | | | | lation. | For | GPT-4, | there | are | very few | transla- |
-| L3: | FOLcontainssyntaxerrors. | | | | | Thisisone | | | | | | | |
-tionmistakes,butwestillfindacoupleinstances
-reasonthatweobservemajorityvotinghelpssig-
-whereGPT-3.5failstocapturethesemanticmean-
-nificantlyforneurosymbolicmethods,asmultiple
-| | | | | | | | ing | of the | NL examples | | properly. | Two | examples |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ----------- | --- | --------- | --- | -------- |
-generationsincreasethelikelihoodthatatoneleast
-areshownhere:
-| oneFOLrepresentationsuccessfullycompiles. | | | | | | As | | | | | | | |
-| ----------------------------------------- | --- | -------- | ----- | -------- | ------ | ----- | --------- | -------- | ----------------------- | ------- | ----- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | Premise: | Platypus | | have no | teeth | | |
-| stated | in | the main | text, | the most | common | error | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | Incorrect | | FOL: -NoTeeth(Platypus) | | | | |
-isthatthesamesymbolisusedwithmultipleari-
-ties. Twoexamplesofthisareshownbelow: inthe Premise: Imperium doesn't have a feud with a
-| | | | | | | | | professional | | wrestling | | stable | that |
-| ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------- | --- | ------ | ---- |
-| firstexample,theprimitiveSummerisbothusedas | | | | | | | | (cid:44)→ | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | | includes | | Ivy Nile. | | | |
-(cid:44)→
-a function representing that a year has a summer Incorrect FOL: -all x. (Includes(x, IvyNile) -> -
-| | | | | | | | | HasFeud(Imperium, | | | x)) | | |
-| --- | --------- | -------- | ----- | ------- | --------- | ---------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| (in | the first | premise) | and | as a | constant | represent- | | (cid:44)→ | | | | | |
-| ing | that a | student | loves | summer. | A similar | phe- | | | | | | | |
-nomenon occurs in the second example with the E.3 GPT-4CoTFailureModes
-symbolBadults.
-C1: CoTconcludessomethingdifferentthanit
-| Example | 1 | | | | | | suggests. | | We show | two | examples | of | this below |
-| ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | ------- | --- | -------- | --- | ---------- |
+| Journal | | | | | Count | | Source citance | | | | | |
+| ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+| BMJ | | | | | 60 | | | | | | | |
+"Future studies are also warranted to evaluate
+the potential association between WNT5A/PCP
+| Blood | | | | | | 8 | | | | | | |
+| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+signaling in adipose tissue and
+| CancerCell | | | | | | 8 | atherosclerotic CVD, given the major role that | | | | | |
+| ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+| Cell | | | | | 51 | | IL-6 signaling plays in this condition as | | | | | |
+revealed by large Mendelian randomization
+| CellMetabolism | | | | | 10 | | studies 44, 45 | | ." | | | |
+| -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+| CellStemCell | | | | | 41 | | | | | | | |
+Claim
+| Circulation | | | | | 12 | | | | | | | |
+| ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+IL-6 signaling plays a major role in
+| Immunity | | | | | 33 | | | | | | | |
+| -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease.
+| JAMA | | | | | 79 | | | | | | | |
+| ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+MolecularCell 27 Figure 4: A claim written based on a citance. Mate-
+MolecularSystemsBiology 5 rialunrelatedtothecitationisremoved. Theacronym
+“CVD”isexpandedto“cardiovasculardisease”.
+| Nature | | | | | 29 | | | | | | | |
+| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+| NatureCellBiology | | | | | 26 | | | | | | | |
+NatureCommunications 19 ten. Theseretrievalswouldbeincorrectlymarked
+| NatureGenetics | | | | | | 8 | | | | | | |
+| -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+wrongbyourevaluationmetrics.
+| NatureMedicine | | | | | 89 | | | | | | | |
+| -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+Distractorabstractsasdefinedin§3.1havetwo
+| NatureMethods | | | | | | 1 | | | | | | |
+| -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------- | --------- | ---------- | ------------- | ------------ |
+| | | | | | | | qualities | that | make them | a | good addition | to the |
+| NucleicAcidsResearch | | | | | 10 | | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | SCIFACT | corpus: | (1) | They | are cited | in the same |
+| PlosBiology | | | | | 36 | | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | articles | as our | evidence | abstracts, | | meaning that |
+| PlosMedicine | | | | | 38 | | | | | | | |
+theyoftendiscusssimilartopicsandincreasethe
+| Science | | | | | | 7 | difficulty | of | abstract retrieval | | methods | based on |
+| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------- | -------------------------- | --- | ---------- | --------- |
+| ScienceTranslationalMedicine | | | | | | 2 | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | lexicalsimilarity. | | (2)Theauthorsofourcitances | | | |
+| TheLancet | | | | | 22 | | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | were | aware of | the distractor | | abstracts, | and chose |
+| Other | | | | | 120 | | nottomentiontheminthecitancesusedtogenerate | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | claims. | Thismakesthemunlikelytobeasourceof | | | | |
+| Total | | | | | 741 | | | | | | | |
+falsenegativeretrievals.
+| Table8: | Numberofciteddocumentsbyjournal. | | | | | Some | | | | | | |
+| ------- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+| | | | | | | | C.2 | Annotationexamples | | | | |
+co-citedarticles(§3.1)comefromjournalsoutsideour
+curatedset;theseareindicatedby“Other”. Converting citances to claims Figure 4 shows
+| | | | | | | | an example | | of a citance | re-written | | as a claim. |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | ------------ | ----------- |
+| | | | | | | | The citance | | discusses | the | relationship | between |
+C Datasetcollectionandcorpusstatistics
+“atheroscleroticCVD”and“IL-6”,andcitestwopa-
+| C.1 Corpus | | | | | | | pers(44and45)asevidence. | | | | Toconverttoaclaim, | |
+| ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- |
+theacronym“CVD”isexpandedto“cardiovascu-
+| Source | journals | Table | 8 shows | | the number | of | | | | | | |
+| ------ | -------- | ----- | ------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+lardisease”,irrelevantinformationisremoved,and
+citedabstractsfromeachofourselectedjournals.
+theclaimiswrittenasanatomicfactualstatement.
+| The “Other” | category | | includes | “co-cited” | | (§3.1) | | | | | | |
+| ----------- | -------- | --------- | -------- | ---------- | --------- | ------ | ------------------ | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- |
+| abstracts | that | came from | journals | | not among | our | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | Multiplerationales | | | Figure5showsaclaimsup- | | |
+pre-definedset.
+| | | | | | | | ported | by two | rationales | from | the same | abstract. |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------ | ---------- | ---- | -------- | --------- |
+Thetextofeachrationaleonitsownissufficientto
+| Distractor | abstracts | | In §3.1, | we | mention | how | | | | | | |
+| ----------- | ---------- | ------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | ---- | --------------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+| we increase | the | size of | the corpus | | by adding | dis- | entailtheclaim. | | | | | |
+| tractor | abstracts. | The | reason | why | we do not | use | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | C.3 | Annotatorsandqualitycontrol | | | | |
+theentiretyofalargeresearchcorpuslikeS2ORC
+asourfact-checkingcorpusisthatdoingsowould Claimwriting Studentclaimwritersattendedan
+introducemanyfalsenegativeretrievals: abstracts in-person training session where they were intro-
+containingevidencerelevanttoagivenclaim,but ducedtothetaskandreceivedin-personfeedback
+notmentionedintheclaim’ssourcecitance. This fromthefourexperts. Followingtraining,student
+canoccureitherbecausethecitanceauthorssimply annotatorscontinuedwritingclaimsremotely. The
+were not aware of these abstracts, or because the expertannotatorsmonitoredclaimsforqualitydur-
+abstractswerepublishedafterthecitancewaswrit- ing the remote annotation process, and provided
+7547
-(bothofwhichLINCsolvescorrectly). (cid:44)→ needs to apply for CPT if he wants to
-(cid:44)→ work in the US. We also know that an
-Example 1 (cid:44)→ international student in the US with an
-Premises: (cid:44)→ F1 visa needs to apply for CPT or OPT if
-Plungers suck. (cid:44)→ the student wants to work in the US. So,
-Vacuums suck. (cid:44)→ it is clear that Mike has an F1 visa
-Vampires suck. (cid:44)→ since he fits the criteria. Therefore,
-Space is a vacuum. (cid:44)→ the conclusion is true.
-A duster is a household appliance that doesn't
-(cid:44)→ suck. Example 2
-Premises:
-Conclusion: If people perform in school talent shows often,
-Space is a vampire. (cid:44)→ then they attend and are very engaged
-(cid:44)→ with school events.
-(GPT-4 Incorrect CoT): Let's think step by step. People either perform in school talent shows
-(cid:44)→ We want to evaluate if Space is a (cid:44)→ often or are inactive and disinterested
-(cid:44)→ vampire. We know that Space is a vacuum (cid:44)→ members of their community.
-(cid:44)→ and that vacuums suck. However, while it' If people chaperone high school dances, then
-(cid:44)→ s true that vampires also suck, this (cid:44)→ they are not students who attend the
-(cid:44)→ doesn't mean that everything that sucks (cid:44)→ school.
-(cid:44)→ is a vampire. Therefore, there is no All people who are inactive and disinterested
-(cid:44)→ reason to believe that Space is a vampire (cid:44)→ members of their community chaperone high
-(cid:44)→ based on these premises, so the (cid:44)→ school dances.
-(cid:44)→ statement is false. All young children and teenagers who wish to
-ANSWER: False (cid:44)→ further their academic careers and
-(cid:44)→ educational opportunities are students
-Example 2 (cid:44)→ who attend the school.
-Premises: Bonnie either both attends and is very engaged
-Some mammals have teeth. (cid:44)→ with school events and is a student who
-Platypus have no teeth. (cid:44)→ attends the school, or she neither
-Platypus are mammals. (cid:44)→ attends and is very engaged with school
-Humans have teeth. (cid:44)→ events nor is a student who attends the
-(cid:44)→ school.
-Conclusion:
-Platypus are reptiles. Conclusion (Ground Truth: Uncertain):
-Bonnie performs in school talent shows often.
-(GPT-4 Incorrect CoT): Let's think step by step.
-(cid:44)→ We want to evaluate if platypus are (GPT-4 Incorrect CoT): Let's think step by step.
-(cid:44)→ reptiles. We know from the premises that (cid:44)→ We want to evaluate if Bonnie performs
-(cid:44)→ platypus are mammals and that they have (cid:44)→ in school talent shows often. Based on
-(cid:44)→ no teeth. The fact that some mammals have (cid:44)→ the last premise, if Bonnie is a student
-(cid:44)→ teeth does not contradict the fact that (cid:44)→ who attends the school and is very
-(cid:44)→ platypus, although mammals, do not have (cid:44)→ engaged with school events, this is only
-(cid:44)→ teeth. Moreover, the statement about (cid:44)→ possible if she performs in school talent
-(cid:44)→ humans having teeth is unrelated to the (cid:44)→ shows often, as per the first premise.
-(cid:44)→ classification of platypus. There's no (cid:44)→ If she doesn't attend and is not engaged
-(cid:44)→ evidence in the premises that would (cid:44)→ with school events, she is an inactive
-(cid:44)→ suggest platypus are reptiles. Therefore, (cid:44)→ and disinterested member of her community
-(cid:44)→ the statement is false. (cid:44)→ . But the fourth premise states that
-(cid:44)→ these individuals chaperone high school
-C2: CoTmakesincorrectlogicaldeductions. (cid:44)→ dances, meaning they cannot be students,
-(cid:44)→ which would contradict the last premise.
-Example 1 (cid:44)→ Therefore, Bonnie performs in school
-Premises: (cid:44)→ talent shows often, so the statement is
-International students in US have either an F1 (cid:44)→ true.
-(cid:44)→ visa or a J1 visa.
-An international student in US with an F1 visa
-(cid:44)→ needs to apply for CPT or OPT if the C3: CoTfailstofindcomplexpathsofreason-
-(cid:44)→ student wants to work in the US. ing. Wehighlighttwoexamplesbelow: inthefirst
-Mike is an international student.
-example, the ground truth is false. To make this
-Mike needs to apply for CPT if he wants to work
-(cid:44)→ in the US. deduction,onemustreasonthatifaGreyhoundis
-aBoeing707,thenitisaplane,whichmeansitis
-Conclusion (Ground Truth: Uncertain):
-empty, which means it cannot transport multiple
-Mike has an F1 visa.
-passengers,whichmeansitisnotanairline,which
-(GPT-4 Incorrect CoT): Let's think step by step.
-meanstherearenoGreyhoundplanes,whichisa
-(cid:44)→ We want to evaluate if Mike has an F1
-contradiction. LookingattheCoTgenerations,the
-(cid:44)→ visa. From the premises, we know that
-(cid:44)→ Mike is an international student and firstCoTattemptgivesupafterfailingtofindany
+https://scifact.s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.
+Claim
+Antibiotic induced alterations in the gut com/doc/evidence-annotation-instructions.
+microbiome reduce resistance against pdf.
+Clostridium difficile
+| | Decision: | | SUPPORTS | | |
+| --- | --------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- |
+Antibiotics can have significant and long-
+lasting effects on the gastrointestinal tract
+microbiota, reducing colonization resistance
+against pathogens including Clostridium
+difficile.
+Rationale 1
+Our results indicate that antibiotic-mediated
+alteration of the gut microbiome converts the
+global metabolic profile to one that favours
+C. difficile germination and growth.
+Rationale 2
+Figure5:Aclaimsupportedbytworationalesfromthe
+| same abstract. | The | text | of each | rationale | on its own |
+| -------------- | --- | ---- | ------- | --------- | ---------- |
+providessufficientevidencetoverifytheclaim.
+feedbackwhennecessary;low-qualityclaimswere
+| returnedtotheannotatorsforre-writing. | | | | | Asafinal |
+| ------------------------------------- | ---------- | --- | ------ | -------------- | -------- |
+| check, all | submitted | | claims | were proofread | (and |
+| edited if | necessary) | by | an | undergraduate | whose |
+claimsweredeemedespeciallyhigh-qualitybythe
+expertannotators.
+| Claim negations | | As | mentioned | in §3.2, | an ex- |
+| --------------- | --- | --- | --------- | -------- | ------ |
+pertannotatorwroteclaimnegationstointroduce
+| caseswhereanabstractREFUTESaclaim. | | | | | Thean- |
+| ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ |
+notatorskippedclaimsthatcouldonlybenegated
+| by adding | obvious | triggers | | like “not”. | The ma- |
+| --------- | ------- | --------- | -------- | ----------- | ----------- |
+| jority of | claim | negations | involved | a | reversal of |
+effectdirection;forinstance“Ahighmicroerythro-
+cytecountprotectsagainstsevereanemia”canbe
+negatedas“Ahighmicroerythrocytecountraises
+vulnerabilitytosevereanemia”.
+| Claimverification | | | Annotationswereperformed | | |
+| ----------------------------- | ------- | ------------- | ------------------------ | -------------- | ---------- |
+| remotelythroughawebinterface. | | | | Annotatorswere | |
+| required | to pass | a 10-question | | “quiz” | before an- |
+| notatingtheirownclaims. | | | Afterpassingthequiz, | | |
+subsequentsubmissionswerereviewedbyanNLP
+expertuntilthatexpertdeemedtheannotatorreli-
+able. Approvedannotatorswerethenassignedto
+| revieweachothers’submissions. | | | | Ingeneral,grad- | |
+| ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- |
+uatestudentswereassignedtoreviewannotations
+fromundergraduates.
+D Annotationinterfacesandguidelines
+Weshowascreenshotoftheclaimwritinginterface
+inFigure6,andtheclaimverificationinterfacein
+| Figure7. | Thecompleteannotationguideforclaim | | | | |
+| ------------ | ---------------------------------- | --------- | --- | ------------- | ---- |
+| verification | is | available | at | the following | URL: |
+7548
-linkbetweenGreyhoundandBoeing707. Thesec- No young person teaches.
-Jerry neither teaches nor is a manager.
-ondgenerationattemptstomakedeductionsfrom
-Rose is young or a student.
-thepremises. Inthiscase,noneofthe10CoTrea-
-soningchainsbeginwiththecorrectstepofstarting Conclusion (Ground Truth: True)
-Rose is a human or Jerry is a manager.
-fromthenegationoftheconclusionanddeducing
-itfalse. (GPT-4 Incorrect CoT, 1): Let's think step by
-Inthesecondexample, tomakethecorrectde- (cid:44)→ step. We want to evaluate if Rose is a
-(cid:44)→ human or Jerry is a manager. Let's first
-duction,weneedtostartfromthefactthatRoseis
-(cid:44)→ look at Rose. From premise 6, we know
-youngorastudent. IfRoseisyoung,thentheydo (cid:44)→ that Rose is either young or a student.
-not teach, which means they study, which means (cid:44)→ If Rose is a student, then from premise 1
-(cid:44)→ we know that Rose is a human. If Rose is
-theyareastudent,whichmeanstheyareahuman. (cid:44)→ young, we don't know from the premises
-IfRoseisastudent,thentheyarehumans. Neither (cid:44)→ whether she is a human. Therefore, it is
-oftheCoTgenerationisabletomakeprogresson (cid:44)→ uncertain whether Rose is a human. Now
-(cid:44)→ let's look at Jerry. From premise 5, we
-the deduction from the information that Rose is (cid:44)→ know that Jerry is not a manager.
-young. In addition, the first CoT generation also (cid:44)→ Therefore, Jerry is not a manager. So, it
-(cid:44)→ is uncertain whether Rose is a human,
-hasalogicalerroratthelaststep,whereitasserts
-(cid:44)→ but we know that Jerry is not a manager,
-that“AorFalse”isFalsewhenthetruthnessofA (cid:44)→ so the statement is false.
-isuncertain.
-(GPT-4 Incorrect CoT, 2): Let's think step by
-Example 1 (cid:44)→ step. We want to evaluate if Rose is a
-Premises: (cid:44)→ human or Jerry is a manager. First, we
-If something can transport multiple passengers, (cid:44)→ know that Jerry neither teaches nor is a
-(cid:44)→ then they are not empty. (cid:44)→ manager, which means Jerry is not a
-All airlines can transport multiple passengers. (cid:44)→ manager. Therefore, the only way for the
-All planes are empty. (cid:44)→ conclusion to be true is if Rose is a
-All Boeing 707s are planes. (cid:44)→ human. We know that Rose is either young
-If Greyhound is not an airline, then there are (cid:44)→ or a student. If she's a student, since
-(cid:44)→ no Greyhound planes. (cid:44)→ all students are humans, then she is a
-(cid:44)→ human. However, if Rose is young, we don'
-Conclusion (Ground Truth: False) (cid:44)→ t have enough information to determine
-A Greyhound is a Boeing 707. (cid:44)→ whether she's a human. Therefore, it's
-(cid:44)→ uncertain whether Rose is a human or
-(GPT-4 Incorrect CoT, 1): Let's think step by (cid:44)→ Jerry is a manager.
-(cid:44)→ step. We want to evaluate if a Greyhound
-(cid:44)→ is a Boeing 707. Looking at our premises,
-(cid:44)→ we have no direct or indirect E.4 SharedmistakesbetweenGPT-4CoTand
-(cid:44)→ information linking Greyhounds to Boeing LINC
-(cid:44)→ 707s. Given the information available, we
-(cid:44)→ cannot make any certain conclusion about AsshowninFig. 5c,thereare21commonerrors
-(cid:44)→ a Greyhound being a Boeing 707. betweenGPT-4CoTandGPT-4LINC.Afteranin-
-(cid:44)→ Therefore, it is uncertain whether a
-(cid:44)→ Greyhound is a Boeing 707. depthanalysisoftheexamples,weseethat16of
-theseariseduetoinherenterrorsinthedataset:
-(GPT-4 Incorrect CoT, 2): Let's think step by
-(cid:44)→ step. We want to evaluate if a Greyhound
-(cid:44)→ is a Boeing 707. The first three premises • 2ofthesesamplescontainthesentencefrag-
-(cid:44)→ don't provide any information about ment “Either Zaha Hadid’s design style or
-(cid:44)→ Greyhound or Boeing 707s. The fourth KellyWearstler’sdesignstyle.” asapremise.
-(cid:44)→ premise tells us that all Boeing 707s are
-(cid:44)→ planes but doesn't tell us anything This premise is likely intended to mean all
-(cid:44)→ about Greyhound. The fifth premise tells designstylesareoneofthesetwostyles,but
-(cid:44)→ us that if Greyhound is not an airline,
-this is hard for the model to grasp from just
-(cid:44)→ then there are no Greyhound planes, but
-(cid:44)→ this still doesn't imply that a Greyhound thefragment(sample41,42).
-(cid:44)→ is a Boeing 707. Therefore, we do not
-(cid:44)→ have enough information to conclude • 2ofthesesamplescontainthesentencefrag-
-(cid:44)→ whether a Greyhound is a Boeing 707 or
-ment“EitherfemaletennisplayersatRoland
-(cid:44)→ not. So, the statement is uncertain.
-Garros2022ormaletennisplayersatRoland
-Example 2
-Garros2022.” asapremise(sample43,45).
-Premises:
-All students are humans.
-• 2ofthesesampleshaveanambiguoususeof
-If someone studies, then they are a student.
-A person either studies or teaches. “either”: “BeniseitherfromTheSimpsonsor
+Figure 6: The claim-writing interface. The citation sentence is highlighted in blue on the top left. Additional
+context is provided on bottom left. The right side shows two claims that could be written based on this citation
+sentence.
+7549
-| | | | | | | F ProofwriterStarCoder+Errors | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-funny,”whichinthiscaseambiguouslymeans
-XOR.Webelievethissentenceisanunnatural
-Wealsoanalyzed,qualitatively,theerrorsthatStar-
-usageof“either”(sample142,143).
-| | | | | | | Coder+ | makes | on the | ProofWriter | | dataset. | Since |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ----- | ------ | ----------- | --- | -------- | ----- |
-premisesfromtheProofWriterdatasetarerelatively
-• In4samples,thereisanamethatisimplicitly
-| | | | | | | simpleanddirect,lossytranslationisrarer. | | | | | | Moster- |
-| ---------- | --- | ------- | --------- | ------- | ---- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- |
-| an animal, | but | this is | not clear | (sample | 126, | | | | | | | |
-rorsareduetosyntaxorimproperrepresentations.
-| 127, 128, | 199). | Also, | in samples | | 126-128, | | | | | | | |
-| --------- | ----- | ----- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-thereisastatement“IfRockisneitheraflynor Weshowfiverepresentativeerrorsbelow:
-a bird, then Rock neither flies nor breathes.” Premise: All quiet people are round.
-| | | | | | | StarCoder+ | FOL: | all x. | Quiet(x) | -> | Round(x) | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---- | ------ | -------- | --- | -------- | --- |
-thatshouldlikelysay“IfRockneitherfliesnor
-| | | | | | | Ground | Truth FOL: | all | x. (Quiet(x) | | -> Round(x)) | |
-| ---------- | ----- | -------- | -------- | ------------ | --- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------------ | --- |
-| is a bird, | ...”. | With the | original | formulation, | | | | | | | | |
-everythingcouldbeuncertainbecausenothing Premise: If someone is quiet and nice then they
-| | | | | | | (cid:44)→ | are cold. | | | | | |
-| -------- | ------ | ---- | --------- | ---- | -------- | ---------- | --------- | ------ | --------- | --- | -------- | --- |
-| is known | in the | case | that Rock | is a | fly (and | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | Starcoder+ | FOL: | all x. | (Quiet(x) | \& | Nice(x)) | -> |
-thisisareasonableinterpretation).
-(cid:44)→ Cold(x)
-| | | | | | | Ground | Truth FOL: | all | x. ((Quiet(x) | | \& Nice(x)) | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ----------- | --- |
-| | | | | | | (cid:44)→ | -> Cold(x)) | | | | | |
-• In5samples,theground-truthFOLrepresen-
-tationofthenaturallanguagepremiseisincor-
-| | | | | | | Premise: | If something | | is furry | then | it is | quiet. |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ---- | ----- | ------ |
-rect,causingthelabeltobeincorrect(samples Starcoder+ FOL: Furry(x) -> Quiet(x)
-| | | | | | | Ground | Truth FOL: | all | x. (Furry(x) | | -> Quiet(x)) | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------------ | --- |
-29,79,85,86,87).
-| | | | | | | Premise: | The cow | eats | the dog. | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------- | ---- | -------- | --- | --- | --- |
-• There is a sample where the conclusion is Starcoder+ FOL: Cow(Eats(Dog))
-likely mis-worded and should be “Barutin Ground Truth FOL: Eats(Cow, Dog)
-| Cove is | not located | in | Antarctica.” | | instead | | | | | | | |
-| ------- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------- | -------- | ------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | Premise: | The cow | is blue. | | | | |
-of“BarutinisnotlocatedinAntarctica.” This Starcoder+ FOL: Cow(x) \& Blue(x)
-| | | | | | | Ground | Truth FOL: | Blue(Cow) | | | | |
-| --------------------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | ------------ | ----- | --------------------------------- | ---------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| changesthegroundtruthlabel. | | | | (sample121). | | | | | | | | |
-| The remaining | | 5 samples | are | examples | where | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | G StarCoderPlusFOLIOErrorAnalysis | | | | | | |
-| bothmethodsfail. | | Inallcases,CoTfailstofindthe | | | | | | | | | | |
-correctreasoningchain,asthepremises/reasoning For StarCoder+, we see a slightly different trend.
-Meanwhile,LINC
-pathisconvolutedandcomplex. InFig. 6a, weseethesamepatternasforGPT-4,
-failsasfollows: withamajorityofuncertainpredictions. InFig. 6b,
-however,weseethatCoTforStarCoder+primarily
-• Insample104,LINCgeneratesseparatesym-
-| | | | | | | predictstrue. | Thisislikelybecausethemodelwas | | | | | |
-| -------- | ------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------------- | ------------------------------ | ---- | ---- | ---- | ----- | ------- |
-| bols for | NotLiveAtHome | | and | -LiveAtHome, | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | trained | on much | more | code | than | text, | and may |
-whicharesemanticallyequivalent. nothavepickedupsophisticatedtextualchain-of-
-| | | | | | | thought | reasoning | capabilities. | | In | Fig. | 6c, we |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | --------- | ------------- | --- | --- | ---- | ------ |
-Insample149,LINCgeneratesFOLsthatmiss
-| • | | | | | | | | | | | | CoT |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | -------- | -------------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | can see | that the | mispredictions | | between | | and |
-implicit information; i.e. that people with LINCdiffermuchmoreforStarCoder+thanGPT-
-namesRoseandJerryarehumans.
-| | | | | | | 4. Finally, | in | Fig. | 6d, we | see the | same | trends |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ---- | ----- | ------ | ---------------- | ---- | ------ |
-| | | | | | | as we saw | with | GPT-4 | but | more pronounced, | | as |
-• Insamples172and173,LINCdoesnotgener-
-thesimilaritybetweenmispredictionsinLINCand
-ateasinglevalidsetofFOLpremisesbecause
-| | | | | | | those in | the baseline | | methods | is even | lower | than |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------------ | --- | ------- | ------- | ----- | ---- |
-allgeneratedexpressionshaveamismatched
-theywereforGPT-4.
-arityissue.
-| | | | | | | H TheeffectofK-waymajorityvotingon | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-Insample193,LINCfailstoexpressthecon-
-| • | | | | | | LINCandCoT | | | | | | |
-| ------- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| clusion | correctly: | the | conclusion | is | “If Yuri | | | | | | | |
-is not an American basketball player, then In all our experiments, we use 10-way majority
-Yuri is a basketball player.”, but the FOLs voting, inspired by prior work which found that
-outputted are either -American(Yuri) Chain-of-Thoughtpromptingbenefitedtherefrom
-& -BasketballPlayer(Yuri) (Wang et al., 2023b). However, one might won-
-| | -American(Yuri) | | | | & | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------- | ------ | --------------- | --- | ----- | ---- | ---- |
-| or | | | | | | der how | robust | the performance | | gains | seen | with |
-BasketballPlayer(Yuri) LINCaretotheprecisevalueofK. Figure7thus
-
-| | T | | | | | 100 | | T | | | | | 100 |
-| --------------- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | ---- | --- |
-| | ru | | | | | | | ru | | | | | |
-| | e | | | | | | | | e | | | | |
-| | | 31 | 7 | 6 | 0 | | | | 61 | 38 | | 55 0 | |
-| | | | | | | 80 | | | | | | | 80 |
-| lebaL detciderP | F a | | | | | | lebaL detciderP | F a | | | | | |
-| | lse | | | | | | | lse | | | | | |
-| | | 1 | 16 | 0 | 0 | | | | 1 | 12 | | 7 0 | |
-| | U | | | | | 60 | | U | | | | | 60 |
-| | n | | | | | | | n | | | | | |
-| | ce | | | | | | | ce | | | | | |
-| | rta | | | | | | | rta | | | | | |
-| | in | | | | | | | in | | | | | |
-| | | 25 | 29 | 55 | 0 | 40 | | | 1 | 4 | | 3 0 | 40 |
-| | E | | | | | | | E | | | | | |
-| | rro | | | | | | | rro | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | 20 | | | | | | | 20 |
-| | r | 6 | 2 | 4 | 0 | | | | r 0 | 0 | | 0 0 | |
-| | | | | | | 0 | | | | | | | 0 |
-| | | e | e | n | or | | | | e | e | | n or | |
-| | | u | Fals | ai | | | | | u | Fals | ai | | |
-| | | Tr | | ert | Err | | | | Tr | | ert | Err | |
-| | | | | nc | | | | | | | nc | | |
-| | | | | U | | | | | | | U | | |
-| | | | Reference Label | | | | | | | Reference Label | | | |
-(a)ConfusionmatrixforLINC. (b)ConfusionmatrixforChain-of-Thought.
-| | | | | | | 100 | | L | | | | | 1.0 |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-IN
-| | C | | | | | | | C | | | | | |
-| ----------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | o rre | | | | | | | | 1 | | | | |
-| | ct | | | | | 80 | | | | | | | 0.8 |
-| | | 37 | | 39 | | | | | | | | | |
-| emoctuO ToC | | | | | | | | C o | | | | | |
-T
-| | | | | | | 60 | S c | | 0.11 | 1 | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | | ra | | | | | 0.6 |
-tc
-h
-| | In | | | | | | | p | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | co | | | | | 40 | | a d | | | | | |
-| | rre | | | | | | | | 0.1 | 0.62 | | 1 | |
-0.4
-ct
-| | | 65 | | 41 | | | | N | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | 20 | | a iv | | | | | |
-e
-| | | | | | | | | | 0.21 | 0.44 | 0.48 | 1 | 0.2 |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ---- | ---- | --- | --- |
-0
-| | | ect | | ect | | | | | C | T | | d e | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- |
-| | | | | | | | | | N | o | | a ai v | |
-| | | orr | | orr | | | | | LI | C | h p | N | |
-| | | C | | nc | | | | | | | c | | |
-| | | | | I | | | | | | | at | | |
-cr
-| | | | LINC Outcome | | | | | | | | S | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-(c) Comparing the consistency of LINC vs (d)Similaritybetweenincorrectpredictionsofeachmethod,
-Chain-of-Thought. i.e.,(A wrong == B wrong) / (A wrong or B wrong).
-Figure6: AnalyzingandcomparingthemistakesmadebyStarCoder+ontheFOLIOdataset.
-shows,foreachmodelequippedwitheitherLINC
-Chain-of-Thought,
-| or | | | | how the | accuracy | on FO- | | | | | | | |
-| --- | ------ | ---- | --- | --------------- | -------- | ------ | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --------------------------- | --- | ---------------------- | --- |
-| LIO | varies | with | K ∈ | {1,2,3,...,10}. | We | note | | 1.0 | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | | tes tset tuo-dleh no ycaruccA | | StarCoder+-Chain-of-Thought | | GPT-4-Chain-of-Thought | |
-that,generallyspeaking,LINCmakesgooduseof StarCoder+-LINC (ours) GPT-4-LINC (ours)
-| | | | | | | | | | | GPT-3.5-Chain-of-Thought | | Chance | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | ------ | --- |
-0.8
-increasedvaluesofK. Thisisespeciallytruefor GPT-3.5-LINC (ours)
-theweakermodels;thesearemorepronetogener-
-0.6
-atingsyntacticallyinvalidFOLexpressions,which
-| causethesolvertoreturnanError. | | | | | Takingthema- | | | | | | | | |
-| ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-0.4
-jorityvoteovermanysamplesthuslessenstherisk
-| ofpredictingError,whichisofcoursealwaysthe | | | | | | | | 0.2 | | | | | |
-| ------------------------------------------ | ------ | -------- | --- | ----------- | ------ | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| wrong | label. | Notably, | | our results | do not | indicate | | | | | | | |
-| | CoT | | | | | | | 0.0 | | | | | |
-that benefits from majority voting in this do- 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
-main. Futureworkisneededtoestablishhowthis K-way majority vote
-relatestothefindingsinthepreviouslymentioned Figure 7: Accuracy on FOLIO per value of K (Ap-
-| priorwork. | | | | | | | pendixH).Shadedareasare±1standarddeviationover | | | | | | |
-| ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ---- | --------------- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | 1000 | bootstrapped | | samples. | Note | that increasing | K |
-benefitsLINC(solidlines;shadingincolor)butnotCoT
-| | | | | | | | (dashedlines; | | shadingingray)inourexperimentson | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-thisdataset.
\ No newline at end of file
+Figure7: Theevidencecollectioninterface.
+7550
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/q0/random_k4/random_4.md b/q0/random_k4/random_4.md
index 4e5670a37f0474e9f9d39a1b53abe412288336c0..69d1305f3a9c9c9fb312a4e7dbd3718670cacdd2 100644
--- a/q0/random_k4/random_4.md
+++ b/q0/random_k4/random_4.md
@@ -1,1191 +1,2203 @@
-| | | | | Omanic: | | Towards | Step-wise | | | Evaluation | | of | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------- | --------- | ------- | --------- | ----- | -------- | ---------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | | Multi-hop | | Reasoning | | in | Large | Language | | | Models | | | |
-XiaojieGu1,SherryT.Tong1,AosongFeng2,SophiaSimengHan3,
-JinghuiLu4,YingjianChen1,YusukeIwasawa1,YutakaMatsuo1,ChanjunPark5,
-RexYing2,IreneLi1
-1TheUniversityofTokyo,2YaleUniversity,3StanfordUniversity,
-4XiaomiEV,5SoongsilUniversity
-| | | | Abstract | | | | | technique | | for eliciting | | intermediate | | logical | steps. |
-| ---------------------------------------- | ----------------- | --- | -------- | ----- | -------- | ------ | --- | --------- | ------- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | ---- | ------- | ------ |
-| | | | | | | | | Yet | growing | evidence | | reveals | that | LLMs | often |
-| 6202 raM 71 ]LC.sc[ 1v45661.3062:viXra | Reasoning-focused | | | large | language | models | | | | | | | | | |
-exhibitreasoningshortcuts(Shojaeeetal.,2025;
-| | (LLMs) | have | advanced | in | many | NLP tasks, | | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | ------ | ---------------- | -------- | ------- | ------------ | ---------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | ------ | -------- | --- | ---------- | ----- |
-| | | | | | | | | Hammoud | | et al., | 2025), | arriving | | at correct | final |
-| | yet | their evaluation | | remains | challenging: | | fi- | | | | | | | | |
-answersthroughheuristicpatternmatchingrather
-| | nal | answers | alone | do not | expose | the inter- | | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | ------- | ----- | ------ | ------ | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-thanrigorousdeduction,andthathighend-to-end
-| | mediate | reasoning | | steps, | making | it difficult | | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | ------- | --------- | --- | ------ | ------ | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-to determine whether a model truly reasons accuracycanmasksystematicfailuresininterme-
-| | | | | | | | | diate | steps | (Jacovi | et | al., 2024). | | This concern | is |
-| --- | --------- | --- | ----- | -------- | ------ | ----- | --- | ----- | ----- | ------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- |
-| | correctly | and | where | failures | occur, | while | ex- | | | | | | | | |
-isting multi-hop QA benchmarks lack step- especially acute in multi-hop reasoning, where
-levelannotationsfordiagnosingreasoningfail-
-| | | | | | | | | existing | | benchmarks | | such | as HotpotQA | | (Yang |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---- | ----------- | --- | ----- |
-ures. Toaddressthisgap,weproposeOmanic,
-| | | | | | | | | et al., | 2018) | and | MuSiQue | | (Trivedi | et al., | 2022), |
-| --- | -------------- | ---------- | --------- | ------------- | ----------- | ----------- | ---- | ---------- | ----- | --------- | ---------- | -------- | ---------- | ----------- | ------ |
-| | an open-domain | | multi-hop | | QA resource | | that | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | | despite | | advancing | | evidence | synthesis | | across |
-| | provides | decomposed | | sub-questions | | and | in- | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | | documents, | | lack | step-level | | structural | annotations | |
-| | termediate | | answers | as structural | | supervision | | | | | | | | | |
-for analyzing reasoning processes. It con- needed to diagnose where and why models fail
-| | | | | | | | | along | a | reasoning | chain. | | The absence | | of such |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --------- | ------ | --- | ----------- | --- | ------- |
-tains10,296machine-generatedtrainingexam-
-ples(OmanicSynth)and967expert-reviewed fine-grained ground truth creates a fundamental
-human-annotatedevaluationexamples(Oman- blind spot, making it difficult to distinguish
-| | icBench). | | Systematic | evaluations | | show | that | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --------- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | --- | ---- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-genuinecompositionalreasoningfromsuperficial
-| | state-of-the-art | | LLMs | achieve | only | 73.11% | | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | ---------------- | --- | ---- | ------- | ---- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-shortcutexploitation(Guetal.,2026).
-| | multiple-choice | | accuracy | | on OmanicBench, | | | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | ---------------------------- | --- | -------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ---- | ---- | --- | --------- | --- | ----- |
-| | | | | | | | | To | bridge | this | gap, | we | introduce | | Oman- |
-| | confirmingitshighdifficulty. | | | | Stepwiseanaly- | | | | | | | | | | |
-icBench(Open-domainMulti-hopquestionswith
-sisrevealsthatCoT’sperformancehingeson
-ANnotatedreasonIngChain),amulti-hopreason-
-factualcompleteness,withitsgainsdiminish-
-ing under knowledge gaps and errors ampli- ing benchmark centered on a human-annotated
-fying in later hops. Additionally, supervised evaluationsetwithstep-levelstructuralannotations,
-fine-tuning on OmanicSynth brings substan- enablingfine-grainedanalysisofmodelreasoning
-tialtransfergains(7.41averagepoints)across
-| | | | | | | | | behavior. | | OmanicBenchconsistsof967multi-hop | | | | | |
-| --- | ------------- | --- | --- | ---------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --------------------------------- | -------- | --------- | --- | --- | ------- |
-| | six reasoning | | and | math benchmarks, | | validat- | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | | questions, | | each | manually | annotated | | and | expert- |
-ingthedataset’squalityandfurthersupporting
-| | | | | | | | | reviewed | | (over | 300 | hours | of annotation | | effort), |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | ----- | --- | ----- | ------------- | --- | -------- |
-theeffectivenessofOmanicSynthassupervi-
-| | | | | | | | | providing | | high-quality | | ground | truth | for | analyz- |
-| --- | ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------ | ----- | --- | ------- |
-| | sionforreasoning-capabilitytransfer. | | | | | Were- | | | | | | | | | |
-lease the data at https://huggingface.co/ ingreasoningbehavior. Crucially,everyquestion
-datasets/li-lab/Omanic.1 isdecomposedintofourcross-domainsingle-hop
-sub-questionswithintermediateanswers,drawing
-| | 1 Introduction | | | | | | | onrichfactualknowledgeandconnectedthrough | | | | | | | |
-| --- | -------------- | --- | -------- | ------ | --- | ------ | --- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----- | --------- | --- | ------ |
-| | | | | | | | | mathematical | | reasoning. | | These | reasoning | | chains |
-| | As Large | | Language | Models | | (LLMs) | ma- | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | | areorganizedunderdistinctgraphtopologies. | | | | | | | Be- |
-ture(Google,2025;OpenAI,2025;Qwen,2026),
-| | | | | | | | | sides, | we | also | release | OmanicSynth, | | a | machine- |
-| --- | ------------ | --- | -------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ----- | ------ | --- | ---- | ------- | ------------ | --- | --- | -------- |
-| | the research | | frontier | has | progressively | | moved | | | | | | | | |
-generatedtrainingsetcontaining10,296instances
-| | beyond | single-task | proficiency | | toward | complex | | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | ------ | ----------- | ----------- | --- | ------ | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-forsupervisedtrainingandtransferexperiments.
-| | reasoning, | with | Chain-of-Thought | | | (CoT) | (Wei | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | ---------- | ---- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ----- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-Leveragingthestep-wiseannotationsinOmanic,
-| | et al., | 2022) | prompting | emerging | | as a | central | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | ------- | ----- | --------- | -------- | --- | ---- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-weconductasystematicanalysisofmulti-hoprea-
-1Codeathttps://github.com/XiaojieGu/Omanic soning behaviors in state-of-the-art LLMs. Our
+3
+2
+0
+2
+
+r
+a
+
+M
+7
+
+]
+L
+C
+.
+s
+c
+[
+
+4
+v
+1
+7
+1
+1
+1
+.
+3
+0
+2
+2
+:
+v
+i
+X
+r
+a
+
+Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023
+
+SELF-CONSISTENCY IMPROVES CHAIN OF THOUGHT
+REASONING IN LANGUAGE MODELS
+
+Jason Wei† Dale Schuurmans† Quoc Le† Ed H. Chi†
+
+Xuezhi Wang†‡
+Sharan Narang† Aakanksha Chowdhery† Denny Zhou†§
+†Google Research, Brain Team
+‡xuezhiw@google.com, §dennyzhou@google.com
+
+ABSTRACT
+
+Chain-of-thought prompting combined with pre-trained large language models has
+achieved encouraging results on complex reasoning tasks. In this paper, we propose
+a new decoding strategy, self-consistency, to replace the naive greedy decoding
+used in chain-of-thought prompting. It first samples a diverse set of reasoning paths
+instead of only taking the greedy one, and then selects the most consistent answer
+by marginalizing out the sampled reasoning paths. Self-consistency leverages the
+intuition that a complex reasoning problem typically admits multiple different ways
+of thinking leading to its unique correct answer. Our extensive empirical evaluation
+shows that self-consistency boosts the performance of chain-of-thought prompting
+with a striking margin on a range of popular arithmetic and commonsense reasoning
+benchmarks, including GSM8K (+17.9%), SVAMP (+11.0%), AQuA (+12.2%),
+StrategyQA (+6.4%) and ARC-challenge (+3.9%).
+
+1
+
+INTRODUCTION
+
+Although language models have demonstrated remarkable success across a range of NLP tasks, their
+ability to demonstrate reasoning is often seen as a limitation, which cannot be overcome solely by
+increasing model scale (Rae et al., 2021; BIG-bench collaboration, 2021, inter alia). In an effort
+to address this shortcoming, Wei et al. (2022) have proposed chain-of-thought prompting, where
+a language model is prompted to generate a series of short sentences that mimic the reasoning
+process a person might employ in solving a task. For example, given the question “If there are 3
+cars in the parking lot and 2 more cars arrive, how many cars are in the parking lot?”, instead
+of directly responding with “5”, a language model would be prompted to respond with the entire
+chain-of-thought: “There are 3 cars in the parking lot already. 2 more arrive. Now there are 3 +
+2 = 5 cars. The answer is 5.”. It has been observed that chain-of-thought prompting significantly
+improves model performance across a variety of multi-step reasoning tasks (Wei et al., 2022).
+
+In this paper, we introduce a novel decoding strategy called self-consistency to replace the greedy
+decoding strategy used in chain-of-thought prompting (Wei et al., 2022), that further improves
+language models’ reasoning performance by a significant margin. Self-consistency leverages the
+intuition that complex reasoning tasks typically admit multiple reasoning paths that reach a correct
+answer (Stanovich & West, 2000). The more that deliberate thinking and analysis is required for a
+problem (Evans, 2010), the greater the diversity of reasoning paths that can recover the answer.
+
+Figure 1 illustrates the self-consistency method with an example. We first prompt the language model
+with chain-of-thought prompting, then instead of greedily decoding the optimal reasoning path, we
+propose a “sample-and-marginalize” decoding procedure: we first sample from the language model’s
+decoder to generate a diverse set of reasoning paths; each reasoning path might lead to a different
+final answer, so we determine the optimal answer by marginalizing out the sampled reasoning paths
+to find the most consistent answer in the final answer set. Such an approach is analogous to the
+human experience that if multiple different ways of thinking lead to the same answer, one has greater
+confidence that the final answer is correct. Compared to other decoding methods, self-consistency
+avoids the repetitiveness and local-optimality that plague greedy decoding, while mitigating the
+stochasticity of a single sampled generation.
+
+1
+
+Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023
+
+Figure 1: The self-consistency method contains three steps: (1) prompt a language model using
+chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting; (2) replace the “greedy decode” in CoT prompting by sampling
+from the language model’s decoder to generate a diverse set of reasoning paths; and (3) marginalize
+out the reasoning paths and aggregate by choosing the most consistent answer in the final answer set.
+
+Self-consistency is far simpler than prior approaches that either train an additional verifier (Cobbe
+et al., 2021) or train a re-ranker given additional human annotations to improve generation quality
+(Thoppilan et al., 2022). Instead, self-consistency is entirely unsupervised, works off-the-shelf with
+pre-trained language models, requires no additional human annotation, and avoids any additional
+training, auxiliary models or fine-tuning. Self-consistency also differs from a typical ensemble
+approach where multiple models are trained and the outputs from each model are aggregated, it acts
+more like a “self-ensemble” that works on top of a single language model.
+
+We evaluate self-consistency on a wide range of arithmetic and commonsense reasoning tasks over
+four language models with varying scales: the public UL2-20B (Tay et al., 2022) and GPT-3-175B
+(Brown et al., 2020), and two densely-activated decoder-only language models: LaMDA-137B
+(Thoppilan et al., 2022) and PaLM-540B (Chowdhery et al., 2022). On all four language models,
+self-consistency improves over chain-of-thought prompting by a striking margin across all tasks. In
+particular, when used with PaLM-540B or GPT-3, self-consistency achieves new state-of-the-art levels
+of performance across arithmetic reasoning tasks, including GSM8K (Cobbe et al., 2021) (+17.9%
+absolute accuracy gains), SVAMP (Patel et al., 2021) (+11.0%), AQuA (Ling et al., 2017) (+12.2%),
+and across commonsense reasoning tasks such as StrategyQA (Geva et al., 2021) (+6.4%) and ARC-
+challenge (Clark et al., 2018) (+3.9%). In additional experiments, we show self-consistency can
+robustly boost performance on NLP tasks where adding a chain-of-thought might hurt performance
+compared to standard prompting (Ye & Durrett, 2022). We also show self-consistency significantly
+outperforms sample-and-rank, beam search, ensemble-based approaches, and is robust to sampling
+strategies and imperfect prompts.
+
+2 SELF-CONSISTENCY OVER DIVERSE REASONING PATHS
+
+A salient aspect of humanity is that people think differently. It is natural to suppose that in tasks
+requiring deliberate thinking, there are likely several ways to attack the problem. We propose that
+such a process can be simulated in language models via sampling from the language model’s decoder.
+For instance, as shown in Figure 1, a model can generate several plausible responses to a math
+question that all arrive at the same correct answer (Outputs 1 and 3). Since language models are not
+perfect reasoners, the model might also produce an incorrect reasoning path or make a mistake in
+one of the reasoning steps (e.g., in Output 2), but such solutions are less likely to arrive at the same
+answer. That is, we hypothesize that correct reasoning processes, even if they are diverse, tend to
+have greater agreement in their final answer than incorrect processes.
+
+We leverage this intuition by proposing the following self-consistency method. First, a language
+model is prompted with a set of manually written chain-of-thought exemplars (Wei et al., 2022). Next,
+
+2
+
+Language modelQ: If there are 3 cars in the parking lot and 2 more cars arrive, how many cars are in the parking lot?A: There are 3 cars in the parking lot already. 2 more arrive. Now there are 3 + 2 = 5 cars. The answer is 5.…Q: Janet’s ducks lay 16 eggs per day. She eats three for breakfast every morning and bakes muffins for her friends every day with four. She sells the remainder for $2 per egg. How much does she make every day?A:She has 16 - 3 - 4 = 9 eggs left. So she makes $2 * 9 = $18 per day. Sample a diverse set of reasoning pathsShe eats 3 for breakfast, so she has 16 - 3 = 13 left. Then she bakes muffins, so she has 13 - 4 = 9 eggs left. So she has 9 eggs * $2 = $18. This means she she sells the remainder for $2 * (16 - 4 - 3) = $26 per day. The answer is $18.The answer is $26.The answer is $18.The answer is $18.Marginalize out reasoning paths to aggregate final answersLanguage modelThis means she uses 3 + 4 = 7 eggs every day. She sells the remainder for $2 per egg, so in total she sells 7 * $2 = $14 per day. The answer is $14.The answer is $14.Greedy decodePublished as a conference paper at ICLR 2023
+
+GSM8K MultiArith
+
+AQuA
+
+SVAMP
+
+CSQA
+
+ARC-c
+
+Greedy decode
+
+56.5
+
+94.7
+
+35.8
+
+79.0
+
+79.0
+
+85.2
+
+Weighted avg (unnormalized)
+Weighted avg (normalized)
+
+56.3 ± 0.0
+22.1 ± 0.0
+
+90.5 ± 0.0
+59.7 ± 0.0
+
+35.8 ± 0.0 73.0 ± 0.0 74.8 ± 0.0 82.3 ± 0.0
+15.7 ± 0.0 40.5 ± 0.0 52.1 ± 0.0 51.7 ± 0.0
+
+Weighted sum (unnormalized)
+Weighted sum (normalized)
+
+59.9 ± 0.0
+74.1 ± 0.0
+
+92.2 ± 0.0
+99.3 ± 0.0
+
+38.2 ± 0.0 76.2 ± 0.0 76.2 ± 0.0 83.5 ± 0.0
+48.0 ± 0.0 86.8 ± 0.0 80.7 ± 0.0 88.7 ± 0.0
+
+Unweighted sum (majority vote) 74.4 ± 0.1
+
+99.3 ± 0.0
+
+48.3 ± 0.5 86.6 ± 0.1 80.7 ± 0.1 88.7 ± 0.1
+
+Table 1: Accuracy comparison of different answer aggregation strategies on PaLM-540B.
+
+we sample a set of candidate outputs from the language model’s decoder, generating a diverse set of
+candidate reasoning paths. Self-consistency is compatible with most existing sampling algorithms,
+including temperature sampling (Ackley et al., 1985; Ficler & Goldberg, 2017), top-k sampling (Fan
+et al., 2018; Holtzman et al., 2018; Radford et al., 2019), and nucleus sampling (Holtzman et al.,
+2020). Finally, we aggregate the answers by marginalizing out the sampled reasoning paths and
+choosing the answer that is the most consistent among the generated answers.
+In more detail, assume the generated answers ai are from a fixed answer set, ai ∈ A, where
+i = 1, . . . , m indexes the m candidate outputs sampled from the decoder. Given a prompt and a
+question, self-consistency introduces an additional latent variable ri, which is a sequence of tokens
+representing the reasoning path in the i-th output, then couples the generation of (ri, ai) where
+ri → ai, i.e., generating a reasoning path ri is optional and only used to reach the final answer ai. As
+an example, consider Output 3 from Figure 1: the first few sentences “She eats 3 for breakfast ... So
+she has 9 eggs * $2 = $18.” constitutes ri, while the answer 18 from the last sentence, “The answer
+is $18”, is parsed as ai.1 After sampling multiple (ri, ai) from the model’s decoder, self-consistency
+1(ai = a),
+applies a marginalization over ri by taking a majority vote over ai, i.e., arg maxa
+or as we defined as the most “consistent” answer among the final answer set.
+
+(cid:80)m
+
+i=1
+
+In Table 1, we show the test accuracy over a set of reasoning tasks by using different answer
+aggregation strategies. In addition to majority vote, one can also weight each (ri, ai) by P (ri, ai |
+prompt, question) when aggregating the answers. Note to compute P (ri, ai | prompt, question), we
+can either take the unnormalized probability of the model generating (ri, ai) given (prompt, question),
+or we can normalize the conditional probability by the output length (Brown et al., 2020), i.e.,
+
+P (ri, ai | prompt, question) = exp
+
+1
+K
+
+(cid:80)K
+
+k=1 log P (tk|prompt,question,t1,...,tk−1),
+
+(1)
+
+where log P (tk | prompt, question, t1, . . . , tk−1) is the log probability of generating the k-th token
+tk in (ri, ai) conditioned on the previous tokens, and K is the total number of tokens in (ri, ai).
+In Table 1, we show that taking the “unweighted sum”, i.e., taking a majority vote directly over ai
+yields a very similar accuracy as aggregating using the “normalized weighted sum”. We took a closer
+look at the model’s output probabilities and found this is because for each (ri, ai), the normalized
+conditional probabilities P (ri, ai | prompt, question) are quite close to each other, i.e., the language
+model regards those generations as “similarly likely”.2 Additionally, when aggregating the answers,
+the results in Table 1 show that the “normalized” weighted sum (i.e., Equation 1) yields a much
+higher accuracy compared to its unnormalized counterpart. For completeness, in Table 1 we also
+report the results by taking a “weighted average”, i.e., each a gets a score of its weighted sum divided
+by (cid:80)m
+i=1
+
+1(ai = a), which results in a much worse performance.
+
+Self-consistency explores an interesting space between open-ended text generation and optimal
+text generation with a fixed answer. Reasoning tasks typically have fixed answers, which is why
+researchers have generally considered greedy decoding approaches (Radford et al., 2019; Wei et al.,
+2022; Chowdhery et al., 2022). However, we have found that even when the desired answer is fixed,
+introducing diversity in the reasoning processes can be highly beneficial; therefore we leverage
+
+1The parser is task dependent. For arithmetic reasoning, we parse the first numerical part as the final answer
+after the model generates “The answer is ”. For commonsense reasoning, we parse the full string answer as the
+final answer after the model generates “The answer is ”. Most generated outputs have a consistent format of
+“{Reasoning paths}. The answer is X.” if we prompt the language model in this format.
+
+2This also means that the language model is not well calibrated and thus cannot distinguish well between
+correct solutions and wrong solutions, which also explains why additional re-rankers were trained to better judge
+the quality of the solutions in previous work (Cobbe et al., 2021; Thoppilan et al., 2022).
+
+3
+
+Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023
+
+sampling, as commonly used for open-ended text generation (Radford et al., 2019; Brown et al., 2020;
+Thoppilan et al., 2022), to achieve this goal. One should note that self-consistency can be applied
+only to problems where the final answer is from a fixed answer set, but in principle this approach can
+be extended to open-text generation problems if a good metric of consistency can be defined between
+multiple generations, e.g., whether two answers agree or contradict each other.
+
+3 EXPERIMENTS
+
+We conducted a series of experiments to compare the proposed self-consistency method with existing
+approaches on a range of reasoning benchmarks. We find that self-consistency robustly improves
+reasoning accuracy for every language model considered, spanning a wide range of model scales.
+
+3.1 EXPERIMENT SETUP
+
+Tasks and datasets. We evaluate self-consistency on the following reasoning benchmarks.3
+
+• Arithmetic reasoning. For these tasks, we used the Math Word Problem Repository (Koncel-
+Kedziorski et al., 2016), including AddSub (Hosseini et al., 2014), MultiArith (Roy & Roth,
+2015), and ASDiv (Miao et al., 2020). We also included AQUA-RAT (Ling et al., 2017), a
+recently published benchmark of grade-school-math problems (GSM8K; Cobbe et al., 2021),
+and a challenge dataset over math word problems (SVAMP; Patel et al., 2021).
+
+• Commonsense reasoning. For these tasks, we used CommonsenseQA (Talmor et al., 2019),
+StrategyQA (Geva et al., 2021), and the AI2 Reasoning Challenge (ARC) (Clark et al., 2018).
+• Symbolic Reasoning. We evaluate two symbolic reasoning tasks: last letter concatenation (e.g.,
+the input is “Elon Musk” and the output should be “nk”), and Coinflip (e.g., a coin is heads-up,
+after a few flips is the coin still heads-up?) from Wei et al. (2022).
+
+Language models and prompts. We evaluate self-consistency over four transformer-based lan-
+guage models with varying scales:
+
+• UL2 (Tay et al., 2022) is an encoder-decoder model trained on a mixture of denoisers with 20-
+billion parameters. UL2 is completely open-sourced4 and has similar or better performance than
+GPT-3 on zero-shot SuperGLUE, with only 20B parameters and thus is more compute-friendly;
+• GPT-3 (Brown et al., 2020) with 175-billion parameters. We use two public engines code-davinci-
+001 and code-davinci-002 from the Codex series (Chen et al., 2021) to aid reproducibility;5
+• LaMDA-137B (Thoppilan et al., 2022) is a dense left-to-right, decoder-only language model with
+137-billion parameters, pre-trained on a mixture of web documents, dialog data and Wikipedia;
+• PaLM-540B (Chowdhery et al., 2022) is a dense left-to-right, decoder-only language model with
+540-billion parameters, pre-trained on a high quality corpus of 780 billion tokens with filtered
+webpages, books, Wikipedia, news articles, source code, and social media conversations.
+We perform all experiments in the few-shot setting, without training or fine-tuning the language
+models. For a fair comparison we use the same prompts as in Wei et al. (2022): for all arithmetic
+reasoning tasks we use the same set of 8 manually written exemplars; for each commonsense
+reasoning task, 4-7 exemplars are randomly chosen from the training set with manually composed
+chain-of-thought prompts.6 Full details on the prompts used are given in Appendix A.3.
+
+Sampling scheme. To sample diverse reasoning paths, we followed similar settings to those
+suggested in Radford et al. (2019); Holtzman et al. (2020) for open-text generation. In particular, for
+UL2-20B and LaMDA-137B we applied temperature sampling with T = 0.5 and truncated at the
+top-k (k = 40) tokens with the highest probability, for PaLM-540B we applied T = 0.7, k = 40, and
+for GPT-3 we use T = 0.7 without top-k truncation. We provide an ablation study in Section 3.5 to
+show that self-consistency is generally robust to sampling strategies and parameters.
+
+3By default we use the test split for all datasets if the labels are available for evaluation. For CommonsenseQA
+we use the dev split; for StrategyQA we use the question-only set from BIG-bench collaboration (2021):
+https://github.com/google/BIG-bench/tree/main/bigbench/benchmark_tasks/strategyqa.
+
+4Model checkpoints at https://github.com/google-research/google-research/tree/master/ul2.
+5Public API available at https://openai.com/api/.
+6Self-consistency is robust to different sets of prompts and we provide a study in Appendix A.1.2.
+
+4
+
+Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023
+
+3.2 MAIN RESULTS
+
+We report the results of self-consistency averaged over 10 runs, where we sampled 40 outputs
+independently from the decoder in each run. The baseline we compare to is chain-of-thought
+prompting with greedy decoding (Wei et al., 2022), referred to as CoT-prompting, which has been
+previously used for decoding in large language models (Chowdhery et al., 2022).
+
+Arithmetic Reasoning The results are shown in Table 2.7 Self-consistency improves the arithmetic
+reasoning performance over all four language models significantly over chain-of-thought prompting.
+More surprisingly, the gains become more significant when the language model’s scale increases,
+e.g., we see +3%-6% absolute accuracy improvement over UL2-20B but +9%-23% for LaMDA-
+137B and GPT-3. For larger models that already achieve high accuracy on most tasks (e.g., GPT-3
+and PaLM-540B), self-consistency still contributes significant additional gains with +12%-18%
+absolute accuracy on tasks like AQuA and GSM8K, and +7%-11% on SVAMP and ASDiv. With
+self-consistency, we achieve new state-of-the-art results on almost all tasks: despite the fact that self-
+consistency is unsupervised and task-agnostic, these results compare favorably to existing approaches
+that require task-specific training, or fine-tuning with thousands of examples (e.g., on GSM8K).
+
+Method
+
+AddSub MultiArith ASDiv
+
+AQuA
+
+SVAMP
+
+GSM8K
+
+Previous SoTA 94.9a
+
+60.5a
+
+75.3b
+
+37.9c
+
+57.4d
+
+35e / 55g
+
+UL2-20B
+
+CoT-prompting
+Self-consistency 24.8 (+6.6)
+
+18.2
+
+10.7
+15.0 (+4.3)
+
+16.9
+21.5 (+4.6) 26.9 (+3.3)
+
+23.6
+
+12.6
+19.4 (+6.8)
+
+4.1
+7.3 (+3.2)
+
+LaMDA-137B
+
+PaLM-540B
+
+GPT-3
+Code-davinci-001
+
+CoT-prompting
+51.8
+Self-consistency 63.5 (+10.6) 75.7 (+23.9) 58.2 (+9.2) 26.8 (+9.1)
+
+49.0
+
+52.9
+
+17.7
+
+38.9
+53.3 (+14.4) 27.7 (+10.6)
+
+17.1
+
+CoT-prompting
+Self-consistency 93.7 (+1.8)
+
+91.9
+
+94.7
+99.3 (+4.6)
+
+74.0
+81.9 (+7.9) 48.3 (+12.5) 86.6 (+7.6)
+
+79.0
+
+35.8
+
+56.5
+74.4 (+17.9)
+
+CoT-prompting
+59.5
+Self-consistency 67.8 (+10.6) 82.7 (+23.2) 61.9 (+9.2) 25.6 (+6.7)
+
+52.7
+
+57.2
+
+18.9
+
+39.8
+54.5 (+14.7) 23.4 (+8.8)
+
+14.6
+
+GPT-3
+Code-davinci-002
+
+CoT-prompting
+Self-consistency 91.6 (+2.2)
+
+89.4
+
+96.2
+100.0 (+3.8) 87.8 (+7.6) 52.0 (+12.2) 86.8 (+11.0) 78.0 (+17.9)
+
+80.1
+
+75.8
+
+60.1
+
+39.8
+
+Table 2: Arithmetic reasoning accuracy by self-consistency compared to chain-of-thought prompting
+(Wei et al., 2022). The previous SoTA baselines are obtained from: a: Relevance and LCA operation
+classifier (Roy & Roth, 2015), b: Lan et al. (2021), c: Amini et al. (2019), d: Pi et al. (2022), e:
+GPT-3 175B finetuned with 7.5k examples (Cobbe et al., 2021), g: GPT-3 175B finetuned plus an
+additional 175B verifier (Cobbe et al., 2021). The best performance for each task is shown in bold.
+
+Method
+
+CSQA
+
+StrategyQA ARC-e
+
+ARC-c
+
+Letter (4) Coinflip (4)
+
+Previous SoTA 91.2a
+
+73.9b
+
+86.4c
+
+75.0c
+
+N/A
+
+N/A
+
+UL2-20B
+
+51.4
+CoT-prompting
+Self-consistency 55.7 (+4.3) 54.9 (+1.6)
+
+53.3
+
+61.6
+69.8 (+8.2) 49.5 (+6.8)
+
+42.9
+
+0.0
+0.0 (+0.0)
+
+50.4
+50.5 (+0.1)
+
+LaMDA-137B
+
+CoT-prompting
+57.9
+Self-consistency 63.1 (+5.2) 67.8 (+2.4)
+
+65.4
+
+75.3
+79.3 (+4.0) 59.8 (+4.7)
+
+55.1
+
+8.2
+8.2 (+0.0)
+
+72.4
+73.5 (+1.1)
+
+PaLM-540B
+
+79.0
+CoT-prompting
+Self-consistency 80.7 (+1.7) 81.6 (+6.3)
+
+75.3
+
+95.3
+96.4 (+1.1) 88.7 (+3.5)
+
+85.2
+
+65.8
+70.8 (+5.0) 91.2 (+3.0)
+
+88.2
+
+GPT-3
+Code-davinci-001
+
+CoT-prompting
+46.6
+Self-consistency 54.9 (+8.3) 61.7 (+5.0)
+
+56.7
+
+63.1
+72.1 (+9.0) 53.7 (+10.6) 10.0 (+2.2) 75.9 (+4.5)
+
+43.1
+
+71.4
+
+7.8
+
+GPT-3
+Code-davinci-002
+
+CoT-prompting
+79.0
+Self-consistency 81.5 (+2.5) 79.8 (+6.4)
+
+73.4
+
+94.0
+96.0 (+2.0) 87.5 (+3.9)
+
+83.6
+
+70.4
+73.4 (+3.0) 99.5 (+0.5)
+
+99.0
+
+Table 3: Commonsense and symbolic reasoning accuracy by self-consistency compared to chain-
+of-thought prompting (Wei et al., 2022). The previous SoTA baselines are obtained from: a:
+DeBERTaV3-large + KEAR (Xu et al., 2021b), b: Chowdhery et al. (2022), c: UnifiedQA-FT
+(Khashabi et al., 2020). The best performance for each task is shown in bold.
+
+7The standard deviation of self-consistency is ≤ 0.5 for all tasks and is thus omitted in the table. Please refer
+
+to Figure 2, Figure 7 and 8 for the standard deviations under varying numbers of sampled paths.
+
+5
+
+Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023
+
+Commonsense and Symbolic Reasoning Table 3 shows the results on commonsense and symbolic
+reasoning tasks. Similarly, self-consistency yields large gains across all four language models, and
+obtained SoTA results on 5 out of 6 tasks. For symbolic reasoning, we test the out-of-distribution
+(OOD) setting where the input prompt contains examples of 2-letters or 2-flips but we test examples
+of 4-letters and 4-flips (this setting is more challenging as PaLM-540B or GPT-3 can already achieve
+perfect in-distribution accuracy). In this challenging OOD setting, the gain of self-consistency is still
+quite significant compared to CoT-prompting with sufficient model sizes.
+
+To show the effect of the number of sampled reasoning paths, we plot the accuracy (mean and
+standard deviation over 10 runs) with respect to varying numbers of sampled paths (1, 5, 10, 20, 40)
+in Figure 2. The results show that sampling a higher number (e.g., 40) of reasoning paths leads to a
+consistently better performance, further emphasizing the importance of introducing diversity in the
+reasoning paths. In Table 4, we show self-consistency yields a richer set of reasoning paths compared
+to greedy decoding with a few example questions from two tasks.
+
+Figure 2: Self-consistency (blue) significantly improves accuracy over CoT-prompting with greedy
+decoding (orange) across arithmetic and commonsense reasoning tasks, over LaMDA-137B. Sampling
+a higher number of diverse reasoning paths consistently improves reasoning accuracy.
+
+GSM8K
+
+StrategyQA
+
+Question Henry made two stops during his 60-mile bike trip. He first stopped after 20
+miles. His second stop was 15 miles before the end of the trip. How many miles
+did he travel between his first and second stops?
+
+Yes or no: Is Albany, Georgia the most populous
+US Albany?
+
+Greedy
+Decode
+
+He traveled 60 miles in total. He stopped after 20 miles, so he traveled 60 - 20
+= 40 miles between the first and second stops. The answer is 40.
+
+Albany, Georgia is the most populous US Al-
+bany. Thus, the answer is yes.
+
+Sampled
+Path 1
+
+Sampled
+Path 2
+
+Henry travelled a total of 60 miles. His first stop was 20 miles in, and his
+second stop was 15 miles before the end. So between his first and second stops
+he travelled 60 - 20 -15 = 25 miles. The answer is 25.
+
+The most populous US Albany is Albany, New
+York. Thus, Albany, Georgia is not the most
+populous US Albany. So the answer is no.
+
+He made two stops during a 60-mile trip. The first was 20 miles into the trip.
+The second was 15 miles before the end of the trip. This means the second stop
+was 60 - 15 = 45 miles into the trip. Since he made the stops in order, the second
+stop must have been 45 - 20 = 25 miles after the first stop. The answer is 25.
+
+Albany, Georgia has a population of about
+88,000. Albany, New York has a population of
+about 95,000. Thus, Albany, Georgia is not the
+most populous US Albany. So the answer is no.
+
+Table 4: Examples where self-consistency helps repair the errors over greedy decode, on PaLM-540B.
+Two sampled reasoning paths that are consistent with the ground truth are shown.
+
+3.3 SELF-CONSISTENCY HELPS WHEN CHAIN-OF-THOUGHT HURTS PERFORMANCE
+
+Ye & Durrett (2022) show that sometimes chain-of-thought prompting could hurt performance
+compared to standard prompting in few-shot in-context learning. Here we perform a study using
+self-consistency to see if it can help fill in the gap, over a set of common NLP tasks, including (1)
+Closed-Book Question Answering: BoolQ (Clark et al., 2019), HotpotQA (Yang et al., 2018), and
+(2) Natural Language Inference: e-SNLI (Camburu et al., 2018), ANLI (Nie et al., 2020) and RTE
+(Dagan et al., 2005; Bar-Haim et al., 2006; Giampiccolo et al., 2007; Bentivogli et al., 2009).
+
+The results over PaLM-540B are shown in Table 5. For some tasks (e.g., ANLI-R1, e-SNLI, RTE),
+adding chain-of-thought does hurt performance compared to standard prompting (Brown et al., 2020),
+but self-consistency is able to robustly boost the performance and outperform standard prompting,
+making it a reliable way to add rationales in few-shot in-context learning for common NLP tasks.
+
+ANLI R1 / R2 / R3 e-SNLI RTE BoolQ HotpotQA (EM/F1)
+
+Standard-prompting (no-rationale)
+CoT-prompting (Wei et al., 2022)
+
+69.1 / 55.8 / 55.8
+68.8 / 58.9 / 60.6
+
+Self-consistency
+
+78.5 / 64.5 / 63.4
+
+85.8
+81.0
+
+88.4
+
+84.8
+79.1
+
+86.3
+
+71.3
+74.2
+
+78.4
+
+27.1 / 36.8
+28.9 / 39.8
+
+33.8 / 44.6
+
+Table 5: Compare Standard/CoT prompting with self-consistency on common NLP tasks.
+
+6
+
+0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths505560657075Accuracy (%)MultiArith0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths3336394245485154SVAMP0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths56586062Commonsense QA0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths505254565860ARC (Challenge)Greedy Decode (Single-path)Self Consistency (Multi-path)Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023
+
+3.4 COMPARE TO OTHER EXISTING APPROACHES
+
+We conduct a set of additional studies and show that self-consistency significantly outperforms
+existing methods including sample-and-rank, beam search, and ensemble-based approaches.
+
+Comparison to Sample-and-Rank One commonly used approach to improve generation quality is
+sample-and-rank, where multiple sequences are sampled from the decoder and then ranked according
+to each sequence’s log probability (Adiwardana et al., 2020). We compare self-consistency with
+sample-and-rank on GPT-3 code-davinci-001, by sampling the same number of sequences from the
+decoder as self-consistency and taking the final answer from the top-ranked sequence. The results are
+shown in Figure 3. While sample-and-rank does improve the accuracy with additionally sampled
+sequences and ranking, the gain is much smaller compared to self-consistency.
+
+Figure 3: Self-consistency significantly outperforms sample-and-rank with the same # of samples.
+
+Comparison to Beam Search In Table 6, we compare self-consistency with beam search decoding
+on the UL2-20B model. For a fair comparison we report the accuracy under the same number of
+beams and reasoning paths. On both tasks self-consistency outperforms beam search significantly.
+Note self-consistency can also adopt beam search to decode each reasoning path (results are shown
+as “Self-consistency using beam search”), but its performance is worse compared to self-consistency
+with sampling. The reason is that beam search yields a lower diversity in the outputs (Li & Jurafsky,
+2016), while in self-consistency the diversity of the reasoning paths is the key to a better performance.
+
+Beam size / Self-consistency paths
+
1
-| | | | | | | | edge graph | derived | | from Wikipedia. | | These | re- |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------- | --- | --------------- | --- | ----- | --- |
-trievedtripletsfunctionasthefoundationalbuild-
-ingblocksforour4-hopexpansion.
-| | | | | | | | Constrained | | Synthesis | | To construct | | 4-hop |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ----- |
-queries,wemergeoriginalMuSiQuecomponents
-| | | | | | | | with new | single-hop | | questions | synthesized | | from |
-| --------- | -------- | --- | ------ | ------------ | --------- | --- | --------------------------------------------- | ----------- | --- | ---------------------- | ----------- | ----------- | ---- |
-| | | | | | | | retrievedtriplets,utilizingClaude-Sonnet-4.5. | | | | | | This |
-| | | | | | | | process | is governed | | by domain | | constraints | and |
-| | | | | | | | reasoning-graphtopology. | | | Eachsynthesizedsingle- | | | |
-| Figure 1: | Overview | of | Omanic | construction | pipeline, | | | | | | | | |
-where rectangles denote entities and circles denote hopquestionisassignedtooneofeightpredefined
-single-hopquestions. domains(e.g.,HistoryandLiterature,ArtandAr-
-chitecture),andthesourceWikidatatripletiscon-
-| studyrevealstwokeyphenomena. | | | | | First,weiden- | | | | | | | | |
-| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-textuallyrefinedtoimprovefluencyandcoherence.
-| tify a knowledge | | floor | effect, | where | CoT | gains | | | | | | | |
-| ---------------- | --- | ----- | ------- | ----- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-Each4-hopinstanceisalsorequiredtocontainat
-diminishsharplyasrequiredatomicfactsbecome
-| | | | | | | | leastonemathematicallygroundedhop. | | | | | Numerical, | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- |
-missing,eventuallydisappearingbeyondacritical
-temporal,orcountableattributesarerewritteninto
-Second,weobserveerrorpropagation
-threshold.
-sub-questionsthatrequireexplicitquantitativerea-
-| alongreasoningchains: | | | laterhopsconsistentlyex- | | | | | | | | | | |
-| --------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-soning,suchascomparison,aggregation,counting,
-| hibit higher | error | rates, | indicating | | that reasoning | | | | | | | | |
-| ------------ | ----- | ------ | ---------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ---------- | ------------ | --- | --- | -------- | ------------ | --- |
-| | | | | | | | arithmetic | composition, | | or | temporal | calculation. | |
-errorsinherentlyamplifyduringsequentialmulti-
-Thismathematicalhopisembeddedintothechain
-| hop inference. | | Together, | | these findings | provide | | | | | | | | |
-| -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | ------- | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | ratherthanappendedindependently, | | | | | soitsinputs | |
-| new evidence | | that reasoning | | and knowledge | | re- | | | | | | | |
-dependonearlierhopsanditsoutputcansupport
-trievalconstituteseparablecapabilitiesofLLMs.
-| | | | | | | | later ones. | For | each | query, | we randomly | | choose |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ------ |
-Insummary,wemakethreemaincontributions.
-| | | | | | | | one of | three reasoning | | graph | topologies | | (Trivedi |
-| --------- | ------- | ------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --------------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | -------- |
-| First, we | propose | Omanic, | | the open-domain | | 4- | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | et al., 2022) | (Figure | | 6), which | determines | | both |
-hopQAbenchmarkwithstructuralannotationsfor
-| | | | | | | | question | synthesis | and | final | assembly. | For | exam- |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | --------- | --- | ----- | --------- | --- | ----- |
-step-levelreasoningdiagnosis,containing10,296
-ple,undertheBridgepattern(Table1),thesecond
-trainingand967expert-reviewedtestinginstances,
-| | | | | | | | hop depends | on | the first, | and | the | fourth | depends |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | ------ | ------- |
-wherestate-of-the-artLLMsonlyachieve73.11%
-onboththesecondandthird,preventingshortcut
-| accuracy. | Second,weevaluatevariousLLMsand | | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| --------- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | solutions | that bypass | | intermediate | | reasoning. | Fi- |
-fine-tuneopen-sourcemodelsonOmanicSynth,ob-
-nally,eachsingle-hopquestionispairedwiththree
-taining7.41averagepointsimprovementacrosssix
-distractors,andtheanswerandoptionsofthelast
-externalbenchmarks,showingstrongtransferabil-
-hopareusedasthegroundtruthandcandidateset
-| ityandhighdataquality. | | | Third,usingsingle-hop | | | | | | | | | | |
-| ---------------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-forthefull4-hopquery.
-decomposition,weempiricallyanalyzetheknowl-
-edge floor effect and error propagation in multi- Automated Filtering To maintain a great diffi-
-hopreasoning,revealingthatCoTbenefitsrelyon cultyceiling,wefilterthesynthesizeddatasetusing
-| factualcompletenessanderrorsamplifyalongthe | | | | | | | | | | models2. | | | |
-| ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | ----- | -------- | ----- |
-| | | | | | | | an ensemble | of | four | | Any | question | an- |
-| reasoningchain. | | | | | | | sweredcorrectlybytwoormoremodelsisdeemed | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | too simple | and | discarded. | | After | pruning, | 3,415 |
-2 OmanicConstructionPipeline
-| | | | | | | | instances | were | removed, | yielding | | a final | training |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---- | -------- | -------- | --- | ------- | -------- |
-Theoverviewofthedatasetconstructionpipeline setof10,296examples.
-isillustratedinFigure1.
-| | | | | | | | ExpertReview | | Toensurethehighqualityofthe | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-Triplets Retrieval To construct the Omanic OmanicBench,1,172candidateinstancesundergo
-rigoroushumanauditconductedby10trainedun-
-| dataset, | we | begin | with | the answers | | to the | | | | | | | |
-| -------- | --- | ----- | ---- | ----------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-original 2-hop questions in MuSiQue (Trivedi dergraduatesandpostgraduatesoverapproximately
-et al., 2022), which are themselves composed 300person-hoursviatheLabel Studioplatform3.
-of two single-hop questions. These answers For each instance, annotators first verify the fac-
-serveasanchorsubjectsforretrievingcorrespond-
-2IncludingLlama-3.1-8B-Instruct,Qwen3-8B,Mistral-7B-
-ing(subject,relation,object)tripletsfromWiki-
-Instruct-v0.3,andGemma-3-4b-it
-data5M (Wang et al., 2021), a large-scale knowl- 3https://labelstud.io/
-2
+AQuA
+
+MultiArith
+
+Beam search decoding (top beam)
+Self-consistency using beam search
+Self-consistency using sampling
+
+Beam search decoding (top beam)
+Self-consistency using beam search
+Self-consistency using sampling
+
+23.6
+23.6
+
+10.7
+10.7
+
+19.8 ± 0.3 21.2 ± 0.7 24.6 ± 0.4 24.2 ± 0.5
+19.7 ± 2.5 24.9 ± 2.6 25.3 ± 1.8 26.7 ± 1.0 26.9 ± 0.5
+
+12.0
+
+11.3
+
+11.0
+
+10.5
+
+11.8 ± 0.0 11.4 ± 0.1 12.3 ± 0.1 10.8 ± 0.1
+9.5 ± 1.2 11.3 ± 1.2 12.3 ± 0.8 13.7 ± 0.9 14.7 ± 0.3
+
+5
+
+19.3
+
+10
+
+16.1
+
+20
+
+15.0
+
+40
+
+10.2
+
+Table 6: Compare self-consistency with beam search decoding on the UL2-20B model.
+
+Comparison to Ensemble-based Approaches We further compare self-consistency to ensemble-
+based methods for few-shot learning. In particular, we consider ensembling by: (1) prompt order
+permutation: we randomly permute the exemplars in the prompt 40 times to mitigate model’s
+sensitivity to prompt order (Zhao et al., 2021; Lu et al., 2021); and (2) multiple sets of prompts
+(Gao et al., 2021): we manually write 3 different sets of prompts. We took majority vote of the
+answers from greedy decoding in both approaches as an ensemble. Table 7 shows that compared to
+self-consistency, existing ensemble-based approaches achieve a much smaller gain.8 In addition, note
+that self-consistency is different from a typical model-ensemble approach, where multiple models
+are trained and their outputs are aggregated. Self-consistency acts more like a “self-ensemble” on
+top of a single language model. We additionally show the results of ensembling multiple models in
+Appendix A.1.3 where the model-ensembles perform much worse compared to self-consistency.
+
+GSM8K MultiArith
+
+SVAMP
+
+ARC-e
+
+ARC-c
+
+CoT (Wei et al., 2022)
+Ensemble (3 sets of prompts)
+Ensemble (40 prompt permutations)
+Self-Consistency (40 sampled paths)
+
+17.1
+18.6 ± 0.5
+19.2 ± 0.1
+27.7 ± 0.2
+
+51.8
+57.1 ± 0.7
+60.9 ± 0.2
+75.7 ± 0.3
+
+38.9
+42.1 ± 0.6
+42.7 ± 0.1
+53.3 ± 0.2
+
+75.3
+76.6 ± 0.1
+76.9 ± 0.1
+79.3 ± 0.3
+
+55.1
+57.0 ± 0.2
+57.0 ± 0.1
+59.8 ± 0.2
+
+Table 7: Self-consistency outperforms prompt-order and multi-prompt ensembles on LaMDA-137B.
+
+8Self-consistency is compatible with both ensemble approaches and we show the results in Appendix A.1.4.
+
+7
+
+0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths12141618202224Accuracy (%)GSM8K0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths50556065707580Accuracy (%)MultiArith0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths303540455055Accuracy (%)ARC (Challenge)Self Consistency (Multi-path)Sample & Rank (Multi-path)Greedy Decode (Single-path)Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023
+
+3.5 ADDITIONAL STUDIES
+
+We conducted a number of additional experiments to analyze different aspects of the self-consistency
+method, including its robustness to sampling strategies and parameters, and how it works with
+imperfect prompts and non-natural-language reasoning paths.
+
+Self-Consistency is Robust to Sampling Strategies and Scaling We show self-consistency is
+robust to sampling strategies and parameters, by varying T in temperature sampling (Ackley et al.,
+1985; Ficler & Goldberg, 2017), k in top-k sampling (Fan et al., 2018; Holtzman et al., 2018; Radford
+et al., 2019), and p in nucleus sampling (Holtzman et al., 2020), over PaLM-540B in Figure 4 (left).
+Figure 4 (right) shows that self-consistency robustly improves performance across all scales for the
+LaMDA-137B model series. The gain is relatively lower for smaller models due to certain abilities
+(e.g., arithmetic) only emerge when the model reaches a sufficient scale (Brown et al., 2020).
+
+Figure 4: GSM8K accuracy. (Left) Self-consistency is robust to various sampling strategies and
+parameters. (Right) Self-consistency improves performance across language model scales.
+
+Self-Consistency Improves Robustness to Imperfect Prompts For few-shot learning with man-
+ually constructed prompts, human annotators sometimes make minor mistakes when creating the
+prompts. We further study if self-consistency can help improve a language model’s robustness to
+imperfect prompts.9 We show the results in Table 8: while imperfect prompts decrease accuracy with
+greedy decoding (17.1 → 14.9), self-consistency can fill in the gaps and robustly improve the results.
+
+Additionally, we found that the consistency (in terms of % of decodes agreeing with the final
+aggregated answer) is highly correlated with accuracy (Figure 5, over GSM8K). This suggests that
+one can use self-consistency to provide an uncertainty estimate of the model in its generated solutions.
+In other words, one can use low consistency as an indicator that the model has low confidence; i.e.,
+self-consistency confers some ability for the model to “know when it doesn’t know”.
+
+Prompt with correct chain-of-thought
+
+17.1
+
+LaMDA-137B
+
+Prompt with imperfect chain-of-thought 14.9
+23.4
+
++ Self-consistency (40 paths)
+
+Prompt with equations
+
++ Self-consistency (40 paths)
+
+PaLM-540B
+
+Zero-shot CoT (Kojima et al., 2022)
+
++ Self-consistency (40 paths)
+
+5.0
+6.5
+
+43.0
+69.2
+
+Table 8: Self-consistency works under imperfect prompts, equa-
+tion prompts and zero-shot chain-of-thought for GSM8K.
+
+Figure 5: The consistency is cor-
+related with model’s accuracy.
+
+Self-Consistency Works for Non-Natural-Language Reasoning Paths and Zero-shot CoT We
+also tested the generality of the self-consistency concept to alternative forms of intermediate reasoning
+like equations (e.g., from “There are 3 cars in the parking lot already. 2 more arrive. Now there
+are 3 + 2 = 5 cars.” to “3 + 2 = 5”). The results are shown in Table 8 (“Prompt with equations”):
+self-consistency still improves accuracy by generating intermediate equations; however, compared to
+generating natural language reasoning paths, the gain is smaller since the equations are much shorter
+and less opportunity remains for generating diversity in the decoding process. In addition, we tested
+self-consistency with zero-shot chain-of-thought (Kojima et al., 2022) and show that self-consistency
+works for zero-shot CoT as well and improves the results significantly (+26.2%) in Table 8.
+
+9We use the same prompts as before, but swap all the numbers in the reasoning paths with random numbers
+except the final answer, e.g., from “There are 3 cars in the parking lot already. 2 more arrive. Now there are 3 +
+2 = 5 cars.” to “There are 7 cars in the parking lot already. 6 more arrive. Now there are 7 + 6 = 5 cars.”.
+
+8
+
+0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths444852566064687276Accuracy (%)T=0.7, k=40T=0.5, k=40T=0.3, k=40T=0.7, k=20T=0.7, no top kp=0.95p=0.9Greedy Decode125102050100200Model size (#param in billions)510152025Accuracy (%)Self ConsistencyGreedy Decode020406080100Consistency (%)020406080100Accuracy (%)Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023
+
+4 RELATED WORK
+
+Reasoning in language models. Language models are known to struggle in Type 2 tasks, such as
+arithmetic, logical and commonsense reasoning (Evans, 2010). Previous work has primarily focused
+on specialized approaches for improving reasoning (Andor et al., 2019; Ran et al., 2019; Geva et al.,
+2020; Pi˛ekos et al., 2021). Compared to prior work, self-consistency is applicable to a wide range of
+reasoning tasks without any additional supervision or fine-tuning, while still substantially improving
+the performance of the chain-of-thought prompting approach proposed in Wei et al. (2022).
+Sampling and re-ranking in language models. Multiple decoding strategies for language models
+have been proposed in the literature, e.g., temperature sampling (Ackley et al., 1985; Ficler &
+Goldberg, 2017), top-k sampling (Fan et al., 2018; Holtzman et al., 2018; Radford et al., 2019),
+nucleus sampling (Holtzman et al., 2020), minimum Bayes risk decoding (Eikema & Aziz, 2020; Shi
+et al., 2022), and typical decoding (Meister et al., 2022). Other work has sought to explicitly promote
+diversity in the decoding process (Batra et al., 2012; Li et al., 2016; Vijayakumar et al., 2018).
+
+Re-ranking is another common approach to improve generation quality in language models (Adiwar-
+dana et al., 2020; Shen et al., 2021). Thoppilan et al. (2022) collect additional human annotations
+to train a re-ranker for response filtering. Cobbe et al. (2021) train a “verifier” to re-rank generated
+solutions, which substantially improves the solve rate on math tasks compared to just fine-tuning the
+language model. Elazar et al. (2021) improve the consistency of factual knowledge extraction by
+extending pre-training with an additional consistency loss. All these methods require either training
+an additional re-ranker or collecting additional human annotation, while self-consistency requires no
+additional training, fine-tuning, nor extra data collection.
+Extract reasoning paths. Some previous work has considered task-specific approaches for iden-
+tifying reasoning paths, such as constructing semantic graphs (Xu et al., 2021a), learning an RNN
+to retrieve reasoning paths over the Wikipedia graph (Asai et al., 2020), fine-tuning with human
+annotated reasoning paths on math problems (Cobbe et al., 2021), or training an extractor with
+heuristic-based pseudo reasoning paths (Chen et al., 2019). More recently, the importance of di-
+versity in the reasoning processes has been noticed, but only leveraged via task-specific training,
+either through an additional QA model over extracted reasoning paths (Chen et al., 2019), or by the
+introduction of latent variables in a commonsense knowledge graph (Yu et al., 2022). Compared to
+these approaches, self-consistency is far simpler and requires no additional training. The approach
+we propose simply couples the generation of reasoning paths and a final answer by sampling from
+the decoder, using aggregation to recover the most consistent answer without additional modules.
+Consistency in language models. Some prior work has shown that language models can suffer
+from inconsistency in conversation (Adiwardana et al., 2020), explanation generation (Camburu et al.,
+2020), and factual knowledge extraction (Elazar et al., 2021). Welleck et al. (2020) use “consistency”
+to refer to generating an infinite-length sequence in recurrent language models. Nye et al. (2021)
+improve the logical consistency of samples from a System 1 model by adding a System 2-inspired
+logical reasoning module. In this paper we focus on a slightly different notion of “consistency”, i.e.,
+utilizing answer consistency among diverse reasoning paths to improve accuracy.
+
+5 CONCLUSION AND DISCUSSION
+
+We introduced a simple yet effective method called self-consistency, and observed that it significantly
+improves accuracy in a range of arithmetic and commonsense reasoning tasks, across four large
+language models with varying scales. Beyond accuracy gains, self-consistency is also useful for
+collecting rationales when performing reasoning tasks with language models, and for providing
+uncertainty estimates and improved calibration of language model outputs.
+
+One limitation of self-consistency is that it incurs more computation cost. In practice people can try a
+small number of paths (e.g., 5 or 10) as a starting point to realize most of the gains while not incurring
+too much cost, as in most cases the performance saturates quickly (Figure 2). As part of future work,
+one could use self-consistency to generate better supervised data to fine-tune the model, such that the
+model can give more accurate predictions in a single inference run after fine-tuning. In addition, we
+observed that language models can sometimes generate incorrect or nonsensical reasoning paths (e.g.,
+the StrategyQA example in Table 4, the two population numbers are not exactly correct), and further
+work is needed to better ground models’ rationale generations.
+
+9
+
+Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023
+
+REPRODUCIBILITY STATEMENT
+
+In experiments, we included four different language models with varying scales. Two of them are pub-
+lic models: UL2 is a completely open-sourced model with model checkpoints available at https://
+github.com/google-research/google-research/tree/master/ul2; GPT-3 is
+also a public model with public API available at https://openai.com/api/. For GPT-3,
+we have included two public engines (“code-davinci-001” and “code-davinci-002”) to further aid
+reproducibility, as Codex is currently free so anyone can reproduce the results. In addition, as our
+results make use of LaMDA-137B and PaLM-540B that are not publicly available, we provide the
+exact input prompts for all tasks in Appendix A.3 (and note that we do not perform any finetuning
+and only apply prompting to off-the-shelf language models).
+
+ETHICS STATEMENT
+
+As we stated in the discussion, language models can sometimes generate nonsensical or non-factual
+reasoning paths, so one should use language models’ outputs with extra caution. We deal with
+reasoning tasks mostly and the generated rationales are only used for inspecting how a model reaches
+its answer. One could potentially use the generated rationales to further check why the model makes
+certain mistakes or whether the model contains any biases when performing a certain task. For
+language model in real-world use, further work is needed to better ground models’ predictions and
+improve model’s factuality and safety, to ensure the models do not cause harms to users.
+
+REFERENCES
+
+David H. Ackley, Geoffrey E. Hinton, and Terrence J. Sejnowski. A learning algorithm for boltzmann
+machines. Cognitive Science, 9(1):147–169, 1985. ISSN 0364-0213. URL https://www.
+sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0364021385800124.
+
+Daniel Adiwardana, Minh-Thang Luong, David R. So, Jamie Hall, Noah Fiedel, Romal Thoppilan,
+Zi Yang, Apoorv Kulshreshtha, Gaurav Nemade, Yifeng Lu, and Quoc V. Le. Towards a human-like
+open-domain chatbot, 2020.
+
+Aida Amini, Saadia Gabriel, Shanchuan Lin, Rik Koncel-Kedziorski, Yejin Choi, and Hannaneh
+Hajishirzi. MathQA: Towards interpretable math word problem solving with operation-based
+In Proceedings of the 2019 Conference of the North American Chapter of the
+formalisms.
+Association for Computational Linguistics: Human Language Technologies, Volume 1 (Long
+and Short Papers), pp. 2357–2367. Association for Computational Linguistics, June 2019. URL
+https://aclanthology.org/N19-1245.
+
+Daniel Andor, Luheng He, Kenton Lee, and Emily Pitler. Giving BERT a calculator: Finding
+operations and arguments with reading comprehension. In Proceedings of the 2019 Conference on
+Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing and the 9th International Joint Conference
+on Natural Language Processing (EMNLP-IJCNLP), 2019. URL https://aclanthology.
+org/D19-1609.
+
+Akari Asai, Kazuma Hashimoto, Hannaneh Hajishirzi, Richard Socher, and Caiming Xiong. Learn-
+ing to retrieve reasoning paths over wikipedia graph for question answering. In International
+Conference on Learning Representations, 2020. URL https://openreview.net/forum?
+id=SJgVHkrYDH.
+
+Roy Bar-Haim, Ido Dagan, Bill Dolan, Lisa Ferro, Danilo Giampiccolo, Bernardo Magnini, and
+Idan Szpektor. The second pascal recognising textual entailment challenge. In Proceedings of the
+second PASCAL challenges workshop on recognising textual entailment, 2006.
+
+Dhruv Batra, Payman Yadollahpour, Abner Guzman-Rivera, and Gregory Shakhnarovich. Diverse
+m-best solutions in markov random fields. In Proceedings of the 12th European Conference on
+Computer Vision - Volume Part V, ECCV’12, pp. 1–16, Berlin, Heidelberg, 2012. Springer-Verlag.
+ISBN 9783642337147. URL https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-33715-4_1.
+
+10
+
+Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023
+
+Luisa Bentivogli, Peter Clark, Ido Dagan, and Danilo Giampiccolo. The fifth pascal recognizing
+
+textual entailment challenge. In TAC, 2009.
+
+BIG-bench collaboration. Beyond the imitation game: Measuring and extrapolating the capabil-
+In preparation, 2021. URL https://github.com/google/
+
+ities of language models.
+BIG-bench/.
+
+Tom Brown, Benjamin Mann, Nick Ryder, Melanie Subbiah, Jared D Kaplan, Prafulla Dhariwal,
+Arvind Neelakantan, Pranav Shyam, Girish Sastry, Amanda Askell, Sandhini Agarwal, Ariel
+Herbert-Voss, Gretchen Krueger, Tom Henighan, Rewon Child, Aditya Ramesh, Daniel Ziegler,
+Jeffrey Wu, Clemens Winter, Chris Hesse, Mark Chen, Eric Sigler, Mateusz Litwin, Scott Gray,
+Benjamin Chess, Jack Clark, Christopher Berner, Sam McCandlish, Alec Radford, Ilya Sutskever,
+and Dario Amodei. Language models are few-shot learners. In Advances in Neural Information
+Processing Systems, 2020. URL https://proceedings.neurips.cc/paper/2020/
+file/1457c0d6bfcb4967418bfb8ac142f64a-Paper.pdf.
+
+language inference with natural
+
+Oana-Maria Camburu, Tim Rocktäschel, Thomas Lukasiewicz, and Phil Blunsom.
+
+snli: Natural
+gio, H. Wallach, H. Larochelle, K. Grauman, N. Cesa-Bianchi,
+(eds.), Advances
+Information Processing Systems 31,
+Curran Associates,
+8163-e-snli-natural-language-inference-with-natural-language-explanations.
+pdf.
+
+e-
+In S. Ben-
+and R. Garnett
+pp. 9539–9549.
+URL http://papers.nips.cc/paper/
+
+language explanations.
+
+in Neural
+Inc.,
+
+2018.
+
+Oana-Maria Camburu, Brendan Shillingford, Pasquale Minervini, Thomas Lukasiewicz, and Phil
+Blunsom. Make up your mind! adversarial generation of inconsistent natural language explanations.
+In Proceedings of the 58th Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics, pp.
+4157–4165, Online, July 2020. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/2020.
+acl-main.382. URL https://aclanthology.org/2020.acl-main.382.
+
+Jifan Chen, Shih-Ting Lin, and Greg Durrett. Multi-hop question answering via reasoning chains.
+
+CoRR, abs/1910.02610, 2019. URL http://arxiv.org/abs/1910.02610.
+
+Mark Chen, Jerry Tworek, Heewoo Jun, Qiming Yuan, Henrique Ponde de Oliveira Pinto, Jared
+Kaplan, Harri Edwards, Yuri Burda, Nicholas Joseph, Greg Brockman, et al. Evaluating large
+language models trained on code. arXiv preprint arXiv:2107.03374, 2021.
+
+Aakanksha Chowdhery, Sharan Narang, Jacob Devlin, Maarten Bosma, Gaurav Mishra, Adam
+Roberts, Paul Barham, Hyung Won Chung, Charles Sutton, Sebastian Gehrmann, Parker Schuh,
+Kensen Shi, Sasha Tsvyashchenko, Joshua Maynez, Abhishek Rao, Parker Barnes, Yi Tay, Noam
+Shazeer, Vinodkumar Prabhakaran, Emily Reif, Nan Du, Ben Hutchinson, Reiner Pope, James
+Bradbury, Jacob Austin, Michael Isard, Guy Gur-Ari, Pengcheng Yin, Toju Duke, Anselm Lev-
+skaya, Sanjay Ghemawat, Sunipa Dev, Henryk Michalewski, Xavier Garcia, Vedant Misra, Kevin
+Robinson, Liam Fedus, Denny Zhou, Daphne Ippolito, David Luan, Hyeontaek Lim, Barret Zoph,
+Alexander Spiridonov, Ryan Sepassi, David Dohan, Shivani Agrawal, Mark Omernick, Andrew M.
+Dai, Thanumalayan Sankaranarayana Pillai, Marie Pellat, Aitor Lewkowycz, Erica Moreira, Rewon
+Child, Oleksandr Polozov, Katherine Lee, Zongwei Zhou, Xuezhi Wang, Brennan Saeta, Mark
+Diaz, Orhan Firat, Michele Catasta, Jason Wei, Kathy Meier-Hellstern, Douglas Eck, Jeff Dean,
+Slav Petrov, and Noah Fiedel. Palm: Scaling language modeling with pathways, 2022. URL
+https://arxiv.org/abs/2204.02311.
-| ReasoningGraph | | Multi-hopQuestion | | | | | | Single-hopComposition | | | | |
-| -------------- | --- | ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | InthecountryofcitizenshipoftheauthorofCandida, | | | | | | 1. WhoistheauthorofCandida?BernardShaw | | | | |
-whichpoliticalpartywasfoundedthesamenumberof
-| | | | | | | | | 2. WhatisthecountryofcitizenshipofBernardShaw? | | | | |
-| --- | --- | -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | yearsbefore1968asthenumberofdistinct3-member | | | | | | Ireland | | | | |
-committeesthatcanbeformedfromagroupof7candi-
-| | | | | | | | | 3. Howmanydistinct3-membercommitteescanbeformed | | | | |
-| --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | dates?FineGael | | | | | | fromagroupof7candidates?35 | | | | |
-[A:FineGaelB:LabourPartyC:FiannaFáilD:Sinn 4. InIreland,whichpoliticalpartywasfounded35years
-Féin]
-before1968?FineGael
-Table1: Anexampleillustratingthemulti-hopreasoninggraphanditsstep-by-stepquestiondecomposition.
-| tual correctness | | of every | sub-question | | and | its an- | | | | | | |
-| ---------------- | ---------- | -------- | ------------ | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | -------- |
-| | | | | | | | | | | MCQ | ExactMatch | F1-Score |
-| swer by | consulting | the | Wikipedia | | articles | linked | | | | | | |
-ProprietaryLLMs
-totheunderlyingtriplets;forquestionsinvolving
-| | | | | | | | GPT-5.4 | | | 49.22 | 22.85 | 32.22 |
-| ------------ | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | ----- |
-| mathematical | reasoning, | | annotators | | are | addition- | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | GPT-5.4CoT | | | 70.84 | 27.09 | 43.58 |
-allyrequiredtoprovidedetailedstep-by-stepcom-
-| | | | | | | | Claude-Sonnet-4.6 | | | 55.43 | 20.73 | 37.15 |
-| ---------- | -------- | --------------- | --- | ------ | -------- | ------ | --------------------- | --- | --- | ----- | ------ | ------ |
-| putations. | They | then examine | | the | logical | coher- | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | Claude-Sonnet-4.6CoT | | | 73.11 | 14.81† | 32.27† |
-| ence of | the full | 4-hop reasoning | | chain, | checking | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | Gemini-3.1-flash-lite | | | 44.88 | 23.47 | 32.31 |
-whetheritconformstothedesignatedgraphtopol-
-| | | | | | | | Gemini-3.1-flash-liteCoT | | | 72.60 | 23.99 | 35.72 |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | ----- |
-ogy,andthenassignqualityscoresacrossmultiple
-| | | | | | | | Qwen3-Max | | | 49.02 | 17.79 | 26.31 |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | ----- |
-dimensions(factualaccuracy,distractorplausibil- Qwen3-MaxCoT 72.08 35.99 45.51
-| ity, fluency, | and | reasoning | integrity) | | following | a | | | | | | |
-| ------------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-Open-sourceLLMs
-standardizedrubric(detailedinAppendixA).They
-| | | | | | | | Qwen2.5-72B | | | 42.19 | 13.24 | 19.43 |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | ----- |
-alsoverifythecorrectnessoftherequirednumer-
-| | | | | | | | Qwen3-32B | | | 52.22 | 12.10 | 18.35 |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | ----- |
-icaloperationsinmathematicallygroundedhops,
-| | | | | | | | Qwen3-8B | | | 25.65 | 9.26 | 13.77 |
-| ----------------------------------------- | ----------------- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | ----- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | ----- |
-| ensuring | that intermediate | | calculations | | and | final | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | Qwen3-8BSFT | | | 53.62 | 10.97 | 16.60 |
-| derivedvaluesarearithmeticallyconsistent. | | | | | | Where | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | Qwen3-8BSFT+GRPO | | | 53.77 | 11.79 | 17.98 |
-deficienciesareidentified,annotatorsdirectlycor-
-| | | | | | | | LLaMA-3.3-70B | | | 40.04 | 11.77 | 20.47 |
-| --------- | ------------ | ------------- | --------- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | ----- |
-| rect the | instance | or supplement | | supporting | | refer- | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | LLaMA-3.3-70BSFT | | | 57.55 | 19.42 | 29.04 |
-| ences and | derivations. | | Instances | failing | | to meet | | | | | | |
-predefinedqualitythresholdswereexcluded,yield- Table 2: Performance comparison of proprietary and
-ingafinalsetof967high-qualityinstancesasthe open-sourceLLMsonOmanicBench. Subscriptsindi-
-evalset. AninstanceisshowninTable1. cate different prompting and training settings. Bold
-| | | | | | | | marks | the best | result | per metric. | †: discuss | in Ap- |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -------- | ------ | ----------- | ---------- | ------ |
-pendixB.2.
-3 ExperimentsandAnalysis
-3.1 ModelsandSetup tion setting, we report Exact Match (EM), which
-ToassessthequalityandutilityofOmanic,weeval- requiresstrictstringequivalencewiththegoldan-
-uate a diverse set of proprietary and open-source swer,andF1-Score,whichcapturespartialcredit
-atthetokenlevel(Rajpurkaretal.,2016).
-| LLMs under | multiple | | settings. | For | proprietary | | | | | | | |
-| ---------- | -------- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-models(e.g.,GPT-5(Singhetal.,2025)),weeval-
-| uate both | direct | answering | and | CoT | prompting. | | | | | | | |
-| --------- | ------ | --------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-Foropen-sourcemodels(e.g.,Qwen3-8B(Qwen,
-2025)),weadditionallyfine-tuneselectedmodels
-| on the | Omanic | training | set | via supervised | | fine- | | | | | | |
-| ------ | ------ | -------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-tuning(SFT)andGRPO-based(Shaoetal.,2024)
-| reinforcementlearning. | | | Toexaminewhethertrain- | | | | | | | | | |
-| ---------------------- | --- | --------- | ---------------------- | ---------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| ing on OmanicSynth | | transfers | | to broader | | reason- | | | | | | |
-ingcapabilities,wefurtherevaluatethefine-tuned
-modelsacrossmultiplereasoningbenchmarks(e.g.,
-| | | | | | | | Figure2: | Comparisonofaccuracyacrossbenchmarks | | | | |
-| ---- | ---------- | ------- | ------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------- | ------------------------------------ | ------- | --------- | ---------------- | ----- |
-| MATH | (Hendrycks | et al., | 2021)). | | For evaluation | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | between | the | vanilla | model and | its counterparts | fine- |
-onOmanicBench,wereportthreecomplementary
-tunedonOmanicSynth.
-| metricsacrosstwoevaluationparadigms. | | | | | | Forthe | | | | | | |
-| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-multiple-choicequestionsetting,weuseMultiple-
-| | | | | | | | 3.2 | MainResults | | | | |
-| ------ | ------------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------- | ------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| Choice | Question(MCQ) | | accuracy | | (Xinjie | et al., | | | | | | |
-2025), which measures selection accuracy over Table 2 presents the overall performance of all
-fourcandidateoptions. Fortheopen-endedgenera- evaluated models on OmanicBench. Proprietary
-3
+Christopher Clark, Kenton Lee, Ming-Wei Chang, Tom Kwiatkowski, Michael Collins, and Kristina
+Toutanova. Boolq: Exploring the surprising difficulty of natural yes/no questions. In NAACL,
+2019.
-LLMsconsistentlyoutperformopen-sourcecoun- To investigate this question, we group multi-hop
-terparts,andCoTpromptingyieldsnotablegains questionsbythenumberofconstituentsingle-hop
-across all proprietary models on MCQ. Among questionsansweredincorrectly,andthenmeasure
-proprietarymodels,Claude-Sonnet-4.6 achieves multi-hopaccuracywithineachgroup. Asshown
-CoT
-thehighestMCQaccuracy(73.11),whileQwen3- in Figure 3 (left), even in the zero-error group,
-Max leadsinopen-endedgeneration. Foropen- multi-hopaccuracyunderDirectpromptingreaches
-CoT
-sourcemodels,aftertrainingonOmanicSynth,we onlyabout60%,wellbelowceiling,indicatingthat
-observe substantial improvements across all fine- multi-hopreasoningandsingle-hopknowledgere-
-tuned models (e.g., Qwen3-8B MCQ: 25.65 → trievalarenotequivalent. Meanwhile,CoTgainde-
-53.77),confirmingthatOmanicBenchposesagen- creasesmonotonicallyasthenumberoferroneous
-uinechallengeforcurrentLLMswhileremaining single-hop steps increases, dropping to near zero
-amenable to targeted training. Notably, we also (−0.7) when three steps are incorrect, while the
-comparetheoutputlength,asshowninTable10, largest gain (+21.9) is observed in the zero-error
-theperformancegainsfromCoTforsomemodels group. These results quantify a clear knowledge
-comeatsubstantiallyhigherinferencecosts. While flooronOmanicBench: effectiveCoTrequiressuf-
-Qwen3-Max achievesthebestopen-endedper- ficientfactualgrounding,sharpeningcompositional
-CoT
-formance,itsoutputtokenlengthfarexceedsthat inferencebutnotsubstitutingformissingfacts.
-ofallothermodels. Incontrast,GPT-5.4 CoT iscon- RQ2: To what extent do errors amplify
-siderablymoreefficientinpractice. toward the end of a multi-hop reasoning
-Tofurtherassessthetransferabilityofskillsac- chain?(Pressetal.,2023)Toquantifythiseffect,
-quired from OmanicSynth, we evaluate the fine- wecomparetwoevaluationprotocols: independent
-tuned models on established reasoning (Yu et al., evaluation, where each step receives the gold an-
-2020;Liuetal.,2021;Wangetal.,2022;Saparov swertopriorsingle-hopquestions;andchainevalu-
-andHe,2023)andmathematics(Cobbeetal.,2021) ation,whereanswersfrompreviousstepspropagate
-benchmarks. AsshowninFigure2,fine-tunedmod- tosubsequentsteps. AsshowninFigure3(right),
-els consistently outperform their vanilla counter- evenunderindependentevaluation,Step4already
-parts,demonstratingthatOmanicSynthcomprises exhibitsasubstantiallyhighererrorratethanear-
-high-quality, non-trivial instances that cultivate liersteps,revealinganinherentdifficultygradient
-genuinecomplexlogicalreasoningandmathemat- inOmanicBenchbeyondpurepropagationeffects.
-ical reasoning capabilities rather than superficial Underchainevaluation,errorscompound: Step4
-pattern matching or factual knowledge retrieval reachesa33.0%errorrateunderDirectprompting,
-alone. Allimplementationdetailsareprovidedin 4.7 points higher than under independent evalua-
-theAppendixB.1. tion. While CoT reduces absolute error rates at
-every step, the amplification pattern remains in-
-3.3 KeyObservations
-tact,suggestingthatsequentialmulti-hopinference
-Beyondaggregateperformance,thestep-levelan- is intrinsically more fragile in later hops. Taken
-notations in OmanicBench allow us to quantita- together, these analyses show that OmanicBench
-tivelyexaminetworesearchquestionsaboutmulti- is not only a benchmark for end-to-end accuracy,
-hopreasoningbehavior. butalsoadiagnostictestbedforquantifyingwhere
-RQ1: TowhatextentdoesCoTrelyonasuffi- reasoning breaks down and how strongly errors
-cientknowledgefoundation?(Wangetal.,2023) compoundacrosshops.
-4 Conclusion
-WepresentOmanic,anopen-domainmulti-hopQA
-benchmarkintegratingmathematicalreasoningand
-factualinference,withdecomposedsingle-hopsub-
-questionsasreasoningannotations. Analysisshows
-thatCoTgainsdependonfactualcompletenessand
-Figure3: ResultsaveragedacrossLLMsunderDirect
-that errors propagate along the reasoning chain.
-andCoTprompting. Left: Multi-hopaccuracybynum-
-WereleaseOmanicasadiagnosticbenchmarkto
-berofsingle-hoperrors. Right: Step-wiseerrorrates
-facilitatefutureresearchonmulti-hopreasoning.
-underindependentandchainevaluation.
-4
+Peter Clark, Isaac Cowhey, Oren Etzioni, Tushar Khot, Ashish Sabharwal, Carissa Schoenick, and
+Oyvind Tafjord. Think you have solved question answering? try arc, the ai2 reasoning challenge.
+ArXiv, abs/1803.05457, 2018.
-Limitations
-| | | | | | | | Jian Liu, Leyang | Cui, Hanmeng | | Liu, | Dandan | Huang, |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ------------ | ------ | ----- | ------- | ------ |
-| | | | | | | | Yile Wang, | and Yue | Zhang. | 2021. | Logiqa: | a |
-Omanichasseverallimitationsthatsuggestdirec- challenge dataset for machine reading comprehen-
-| | | | | | | | sion with | logical reasoning. | | In Proceedings | | of the |
-| --------- | ------ | ----- | ------ | ------------- | --- | ------ | --------- | ------------------ | --- | -------------- | --- | ------ |
-| tions for | future | work. | First, | the benchmark | | is re- | | | | | | |
-strictedtoEnglishonly,limitingitsapplicabilityto Twenty-NinthInternationalConferenceonInterna-
-| | | | | | | | tional Joint | Conferences | on | Artificial | Intelligence, | |
-| -------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | ------------ | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ------------- | --- |
-| multilingualreasoningevaluation. | | | | Second,while | | | | | | | | |
-pages3622–3628.
-| 4-hop questions | | represent | a | meaningful | increase | | | | | | | |
-| --------------- | --- | --------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-incomplexityoverexisting2-hopbenchmarks,ex- https://openai.com/
-| | | | | | | | OpenAI. 2025. | Gpt5.1. | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-tendingtolongerreasoningchains(e.g.,6-hopor ja-JP/index/introducing-gpt-5/. Retrieved
-December12,2025.
-| 8-hop) would | | further | test the | limits | of composi- | | | | | | | |
-| ----------------- | --- | ------- | -------- | ------ | ----------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| tional reasoning. | | Third, | although | Omanic | | spans | | | | | | |
-OfirPress,MuruZhang,SewonMin,LudwigSchmidt,
-eightknowledgedomains,certainspecializeddo-
-| | | | | | | | NoahASmith,andMikeLewis.2023. | | | | Measuring | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- |
-mains(e.g.,legal,biomedical)remainunderrepre- andnarrowingthecompositionalitygapinlanguage
-| | | | | | | | models. | InFindingsoftheAssociationforComputa- | | | | |
-| ------- | ------- | ------------------------------ | ------------ | --- | ------- | --- | ------------------ | ------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| sented. | Fourth, | thedatasetscale(10,296training | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | tionalLinguistics: | EMNLP2023,pages5687–5711. | | | | |
-| and 967 | test | instances) | is moderate; | | scaling | up | | | | | | |
-throughbroaderknowledgegraphcoveragecould
-| | | | | | | | Qwen. 2025. | Qwen3 | technical | report. | | Preprint, |
-| ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | ----- | --------- | ------- | --- | --------- |
-| improvebothtrainingutilityandevaluationrobust- | | | | | | | arXiv:2505.09388. | | | | | |
-ness
-| | | | | | | | Qwen.2026. | Pushingqwen3-max-thinkingbeyondits | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ---------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-limits.
-References
-PranavRajpurkar,JianZhang,KonstantinLopyrev,and
-| Karl Cobbe, | Vineet | Kosaraju, | | Mohammad | Bavarian, | | | | | | | |
-| ----------- | ------ | --------- | --- | -------- | --------- | --- | ---------------- | ------ | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | PercyLiang.2016. | Squad: | | 100,000+questionsfor | | |
-MarkChen,HeewooJun,LukaszKaiser,Matthias machinecomprehensionoftext. InProc.EMNLP.
-| Plappert, | Jerry | Tworek, | Jacob | Hilton, | Reiichiro | | | | | | | |
-| --------- | ----- | ------- | ----- | ------- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-Nakano, Christopher Hesse, and John Schulman. AbulhairSaparovandHeHe.2023. Languagemodels
-| 2021. | Training | verifiers | to solve | math | word | prob- | | | | | | |
-| ----- | -------- | --------- | -------- | ---- | ---- | ----- | ------------------- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | aregreedyreasoners: | | Asystematicformalanalysis | | | |
-lems. arXivpreprintarXiv:2110.14168.
-| | | | | | | | ofchain-of-thought. | | InTheEleventhInternational | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- |
-ConferenceonLearningRepresentations.
-| Google.2025. | | Gemini-3-pro. | | https://docs.cloud. | | | | | | | | |
-| ------------ | --- | ------------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-google.com/vertex-ai/generative-ai/docs/
-| | | | | | | | Zhihong Shao, | Peiyi Wang, | | Qihao Zhu, | Runxin | Xu, |
-| -------------------- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | -------- | --- | ------------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | --- |
-| models/gemini/3-pro. | | | Retrieved | | December | 12, | | | | | | |
-JunxiaoSong,XiaoBi,HaoweiZhang,Mingchuan
-2025.
-| | | | | | | | Zhang, | YK Li, Yang | Wu, | and | 1 others. | 2024. |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --------- | ----- |
-| | | | | | | | Deepseekmath: | Pushingthelimitsofmathematical | | | | |
-KenGu,AdvaitBhat,MikeAMerrill,RobertWest,Xin
-| | | | | | | | reasoninginopenlanguagemodels. | | | | arXivpreprint | |
-| ------------------------------------ | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- |
-| Liu,DanielMcDuff,andTimAlthoff.2026. | | | | | | Synth- | | | | | | |
-| worlds: | Controlledparallelworldsfordisentangling | | | | | | arXiv:2402.03300. | | | | | |
-reasoningandknowledgeinlanguagemodels.
-| | | | | | | | Parshin Shojaee, | Iman | Mirzadeh, | Keivan | | Alizadeh, |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------- | ---- | --------- | ------ | --- | --------- |
-Hasan Abed Al Kader Hammoud, Hani Itani, and MaxwellHorton,SamyBengio,andMehrdadFara-
-| Bernard | Ghanem. | 2025. | Beyond | the | last | answer: | | | | | | |
-| ------- | ------- | ----- | ------ | --- | ---- | ------- | ------------ | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | jtabar.2025. | Theillusionofthinking:Understanding | | | | |
-Yourreasoningtraceuncoversmorethanyouthink. the strengths and limitations of reasoning models
-ArXivpreprintarXiv:2504.20708. viathelensofproblemcomplexity. arXivpreprint
-arXiv:2506.06941.
-DanHendrycks,CollinBurns,SauravKadavath,Akul
-Arora,StevenBasart,EricTang,DawnSong,andJa-
-AadityaSingh,AdamFry,AdamPerelman,AdamTart,
-| cobSteinhardt.2021. | | | Measuringmathematicalprob- | | | | | | | | | |
-| ------------------- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-AdiGanesh,AhmedEl-Kishky,AidanMcLaughlin,
-| lem solving | | with the | math dataset. | | arXiv preprint | | | | | | | |
-| ----------- | --- | -------- | ------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-AidenLow,AJOstrow,AkhilaAnanthram,and1oth-
-arXiv:2103.03874.
-| | | | | | | | ers.2025. | Openaigpt-5systemcard. | | | arXivpreprint | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- |
-arXiv:2601.03267.
-| Edward | J Hu, | Phillip | Wallis, | Zeyuan | Allen-Zhu, | | | | | | | |
-| ---------- | ----- | ---------- | ------- | ------ | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| YuanzhiLi, | | SheanWang, | LuWang, | | WeizhuChen, | | | | | | | |
-HarshTrivedi,NiranjanBalasubramanian,TusharKhot,
-| and 1 | others. | 2023. Lora: | Low-rank | | adaptation | of | | | | | | |
-| -------------------- | ------- | ----------- | ------------------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | ----- | -------- | --- | ------ |
-| | | | | | | | and Ashish | Sabharwal. | 2022. | Musique: | | Multi- |
-| largelanguagemodels. | | | InInternationalConference | | | | | | | | | |
-hopquestionsviasingle-hopquestioncomposition.
-onLearningRepresentations.
-TACL.
-AlonJacovi,YonatanBitton,BerndBohnet,Jonathan
-Herzig, Or Honovich, Michael Tseng, Michael Siyuan Wang, Zhongkun Liu, Wanjun Zhong, Ming
-Collins, Roee Aharoni, and Mor Geva. 2024. A Zhou,ZhongyuWei,ZhuminChen,andNanDuan.
-chain-of-thoughtisasstrongasitsweakestlink: A 2022. Fromlsat:Theprogressandchallengesofcom-
-benchmarkforverifiersofreasoningchains. InProc. plexreasoning. IEEE/ACMTransactionsonAudio,
-| ofACL. | | | | | | | Speech,andLanguageProcessing,30:2201–2216. | | | | | |
-| ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-5
+Karl Cobbe, Vineet Kosaraju, Mohammad Bavarian, Mark Chen, Heewoo Jun, Lukasz Kaiser,
+Matthias Plappert, Jerry Tworek, Jacob Hilton, Reiichiro Nakano, Christopher Hesse, and John
+Schulman. Training verifiers to solve math word problems, 2021.
-XiaozhiWang,TianyuGao,ZhaochengZhu,Zhengyan
-Zhang,ZhiyuanLiu,JuanziLi,andJianTang.2021.
-| Kepler: | Aunifiedmodelforknowledgeembedding | | | | |
-| --------------- | ---------------------------------- | -------- | --------------- | --- | -------- |
-| and pre-trained | | language | representation. | | Transac- |
-tionsofACL.
-XuezhiWang,JasonWei,DaleSchuurmans,QuocVLe,
-| EdHChi, | SharanNarang, | | AakankshaChowdhery, | | |
-| ---------------------------------------- | ------------- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- |
-| andDennyZhou.2023. | | | Self-consistencyimproves | | |
-| chainofthoughtreasoninginlanguagemodels. | | | | | In |
-TheEleventhInternationalConferenceonLearning
-Representations.
-JasonWei,XuezhiWang,DaleSchuurmans,Maarten
-Bosma,FeiXia,EdChi,QuocVLe,DennyZhou,
-| and1others.2022. | | Chain-of-thoughtpromptingelic- | | | |
-| ---------------- | --- | ------------------------------ | --- | ------- | -------- |
-| its reasoning | | in large language | | models. | Proc. of |
-NeurIPS.
-JianWu,LinyiYang,ZhenWang,ManabuOkumura,
-| andYueZhang.2025. | | Cofca: | Astep-wisecounter- | | |
-| ---------------------------------- | ----------- | ----------- | ---------------------- | -------------- | -------- |
-| factualmulti-hopqabenchmark. | | | | InProc.ofICLR. | |
-| Zhao Xinjie, | Fan | Gao, Xingyu | Song, | Yingjian | Chen, |
-| Rui Yang, | Yanran | Fu, Yuyang | Wang, | Yusuke | Iwa- |
-| sawa,YutakaMatsuo,andIreneLi.2025. | | | | | ReAgent: |
-| Reversible | multi-agent | | reasoning | for knowledge- | |
-| enhancedmulti-hopQA. | | | InProceedingsofthe2025 | | |
-| Conference | on | Empirical | Methods | in Natural | Lan- |
-guageProcessing,pages4067–4089,Suzhou,China.
-AssociationforComputationalLinguistics.
-ZhilinYang,PengQi,SaizhengZhang,YoshuaBengio,
-WilliamCohen,RuslanSalakhutdinov,andChristo-
-| pher D | Manning. | 2018. | Hotpotqa: | A dataset | for |
-| -------- | -------------------------------------- | ----- | --------- | --------- | --- |
-| diverse, | explainablemulti-hopquestionanswering. | | | | |
-InProc.ofEMNLP.
-WeihaoYu,ZihangJiang,YanfeiDong,andJiashiFeng.
-| 2020. | Reclor: | Areadingcomprehensiondatasetre- | | | |
-| ------------------------ | ------- | ------------------------------- | ---------------------- | --- | --- |
-| quiringlogicalreasoning. | | | InInternationalConfer- | | |
-enceonLearningRepresentations.
-AndrewZhu,AlyssaHwang,LiamDugan,andChris
-| Callison-Burch.2024. | | Fanoutqa: | Amulti-hop,multi- | | |
-| -------------------- | --- | --------- | ----------------- | --- | --- |
-documentquestionansweringbenchmarkforlarge
-| language | models. | In Proceedings | | of the | 62nd An- |
-| -------- | ------- | -------------- | --- | ------ | -------- |
-nualMeetingoftheAssociationforComputational
-| Linguistics(Volume2: | | ShortPapers),pages18–37. | | | |
-| -------------------- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- |
-6
+11
-A HumanAnnotationGuidance& – 2(Poor): Multiplecriticalfactsornumerical
-DatasetStatistics valuesareincorrect,significantlyimpacting
-the understanding of the problem. Evident
-Werecruit10undergraduateandgraduatestudents
-misuse of terminology or factual conflicts
-toconductthehumancorrectionandscoringpro-
-severelydamagestheprofessionalismofthe
-cess. To ensure ethical research practices, all an-
-content.
-notators are compensated at a rate exceeding the
-– 1(VeryPoor): Containsseverefactualerrors,
-local minimum wage. The entire project encom-
-falsestatements, orentirelyfabricated"hal-
-passesacumulativetotalof200person-hours. The
-lucinations." The question and answer fail
-detailedhumanannotationguidanceislistedinthe
-to correspond, or most content contradicts
-following:
-knownfacts.
-Forsingle-hopquestions:
-• Distractor Quality: This criterion evaluates
-• Factuality and Accuracy: This criterion as-
-whetherthethreeincorrectoptions(distractors)
-sesses the truthfulness and precision of the
-aresufficientlydeceptiveandbelongtoaplau-
-question-answer pair within real-world con-
-siblelogicalcategory. Annotatorsfollowfour
-texts, specific subject areas, or the provided
-steps:
-knowledge source. Annotators follow four
-1. Category Consistency Check. Verify that
-steps:
-all distractors belong to the same logical
-1. Core Element Extraction. Identify key en- category as the correct answer (e.g., if the
-tities (names, locations, events, dates) and answer is a location, distractors must also
-logicalrelationshipsinthequestion. belocations).
-2. Cross-Source Verification. Verify each en- 2. Domain Relevance Analysis. Assess
-tity’sattributesusingreliabledatabases,en- whether distractors share geographic, tem-
-cyclopedias,orauthoritativereferences. poral,orthematicproximitywiththecorrect
-3. Terminology and Value Audit. Check that answerwithinthesamedomain.
-specializedtermsarespelledcorrectlyand 3. TrapLogicIdentification. Examinewhether
-thatanynumericalcomputationsareerror- distractors exploit plausible intermediate-
-free. steperrorsorcommonover-simplifications
-4. FinalScoring. Assignascorebasedonthe (e.g.,arithmeticnear-missesortemporally
-number and severity of errors (critical vs. adjacententities).
-minor). 4. FinalScoring. Assignascore: ifdistractors
-arenearlyindistinguishablewithoutfullrea-
-– 5(Excellent): Allkeyterms,concepts,dates,
-soning,score5;iftheyspanunrelatedcate-
-and numerical values are entirely accurate.
-gories,score1–2.
-The content is supported by authoritative
-evidence, remains free of "hallucinations" – 5(HighlyDeceptive): Alldistractorsbelong
-or misleading information, and utilizes pre- tothesamedomain. Numericaloptionsrep-
-ciseterminologyconsistentwithfieldconven- resentlogical"traps"(e.g.,calculationnear-
-tions. misses), while semantic options consist of
-– 4(Good): Mostfactsareaccurate,withonly easily confused synonyms, similar institu-
-minor flaws in non-core details that do not tions, or entities derived from intermediate
-hinderoverallunderstanding. Terminologyis reasoningsteps.
-generally correct, though it may be slightly – 4(Effective): Distractorsarewithinareason-
-simplifiedwhileremainingacceptablewithin ablescope(e.g.,foraquestionaboutEurope,
-thedomain. alldistractorsareEuropean). Theformatis
-– 3 (Satisfactory): Core facts are fundamen- highly consistent with the answer, making
-tallycorrect,buterrorsexistthatcouldlead themimpossibletoexcludeviasimpleword-
-topartialmisunderstanding. Somekeyterms classorlogicalloopholes.
-maybepoorlytranslatedorexpressed,requir- – 3 (Moderate): Distractors share attributes
-ingthereadertoinferthetrueintentbasedon withtheanswer(e.g.,bothareyearsorloca-
-commonsense. tions),butoneortwooptionscanbequickly
-7
+Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023
-excludedusinggeneralknowledgeorobvious the core meaning is conveyed, it may omit
-| contextclues. | | | | | | | someimportantconstraintsorincludeirrele- | | | | |
-| ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-– 2 (Weak): Distractors belong to the same vantinformation;grammarerrorsarepresent
-broadcategorybutpossessobviousattribute butthemeaningremainsclear.
-differences(e.g.,askingforauniversityname – 2 (Poor): Lacks fluency with abrupt transi-
-whileprovidingacountrynameasadistrac- tionsandunclearlogicalconnections. Core
-tor)orinconsistentformatting. informationisincomplete,containingsignif-
-– 1(Non-existent): Distractorsarecompletely icant omissions or serious errors that affect
-irrelevant or cross-domain (e.g., a "year" theabilitytojudgethecorrectanswer.
-question with "apple" as an option). These – 1 (Very Poor): Language is extremely un-
-| are | illogical | "fillers" | | that can | be instantly | | | | | | |
-| ----------- | --------- | --------- | --- | -------- | ------------ | --- | ---------------------------- | ------------------ | --- | ---------- | ------ |
-| | | | | | | | natural | or unintelligible, | | containing | severe |
-| identified. | | | | | | | grammaticalandlogicalerrors. | | | Thecontent | |
-organizationischaoticandfailstoreflectthe
-| • Fluency | and | Completeness: | | | This criterion | | | | | | |
-| --------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-originalintentofthequestion.
-| evaluates | whether | | the language | | is natural, | the | | | | | |
-| --------- | ----------- | --- | ------------ | -------- | ----------- | ------- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| logic | is clear, | the | grammar | is | correct, | and all | For4-hopquestions: | | | | |
-| necessary | constraints | | for | a unique | answer | are | | | | | |
-provided. Annotatorsfollowfoursteps: • LogicalIntegrityandTechnicalFormatting:
-| | | | | | | | This criterion | evaluates | the | structural | rigor of |
-| ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | -------------- | --------- | --- | ---------- | -------- |
-| 1. NaturalnessFirst-Read. | | | | Readthequestion | | | | | | | |
-themulti-hopreasoningchainandthestandard-
-asanativespeaker,checkingforawkward
-izeduseofLaTeX,technicalterminology,and
-| phrasing, | | inverted | word | order, | or | logical | | | | | |
-| --------- | --- | -------- | ---- | ------ | --- | ------- | --------------- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | codeformatting. | Annotatorsfollowfoursteps: | | | |
-discontinuities—payingspecialattentionto
-subordinateclausesandpronounreferences 1. Logic Chain Decomposition. Break the
-| | | | | | | | multi-hop | question | into | an explicit | path |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | -------- | ---- | ----------- | ---- |
-inlongersentences.
-2. ConstraintCompletenessScan. Verifythat A → B → C → D andidentifyeachinter-
-| thequestionstemcontainseveryconstraint | | | | | | | mediatenode. | | | | |
-| -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | 2. Input–OutputMatching. | | | Verifythattheout- | |
-necessarytoderiveauniquecorrectanswer
-(e.g.,specificyears,inclusive/exclusivecon- putofeachprecedinghopiscorrectlyused
-| ditions). | | | | | | | as the | input condition | | for the subsequent | |
-| --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | ---------------------- | --------------- | --- | ------------------ | --- |
-| 3. GrammarandSpellingCheck. | | | | | Inspectpunc- | | hop. | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | 3. SymbolandCodeAudit. | | | CheckthatallLa- | |
-tuation,capitalizationofpropernouns,and
-| tenseconsistency. | | | | | | | TeX formulas, | mathematical | | notation, | cur- |
-| ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | ------------ | --- | --------- | ---- |
-4. Final Scoring. Assign a score: flawless rency symbols, and code blocks are cor-
-rectlyrenderedandunaltered.
-grammarwithaself-containedinformation
-loopscores5;translationartifactsormissing 4. Consistency Determination. Confirm that
-critical constraints lower the score accord- thelogicchainformsaclosedloopwithno
-| ingly. | | | | | | | breaksorcircularreasoning. | | | | |
-| ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-– 5(Excellent): Expressionisextremelynatu- – 5 (Excellent): The reasoning chain is per-
-ralandsmooth,fullyadheringtonativeusage fectlyairtightwithoutgapsorcircularity. All
-habits. Thestructureisrigorouswithappro- LaTeXsymbols,mathematicalformulas,and
-priatelogicalconnectivesandzerogrammati- currency signs ($) are technically flawless
-calerrors. Alloriginaldetailsandnecessary andcorrectlyrendered.
-constraintsarepreservedwithoutomission.
-| | | | | | | | – 4(Good): | Thelogicalchainiscompleteand | | | |
-| ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | --- | ------- | ---------- | ---------------------------- | ------- | -------- | ------- |
-| | | | | | | | sound, | though the | natural | language | transi- |
-| – 4 (Good): | | Expression | | is basically | | natural | | | | | |
-with only minor linguistic flaws. The main tions between hops may feel slightly rigid.
-meaning is preserved, though some non- Technical formatting is basically standard-
-critical descriptive details may be missing. izedwithonlynegligiblelayoutflaws.
-| Sentence | | structures | follow | standard | | norms | | | | | |
-| -------- | --- | ---------- | ------ | -------- | --- | ----- | ------------------ | ----------------------- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | – 3(Satisfactory): | Aminorlogicalflawexists | | | |
-withnegligibleerrors. (e.g.,ambiguouspronounreferencelike"the
-– 3(Satisfactory): Expressionisslightlyrigid artist"whenmultipleartistsarementioned),
-or exhibits a "translation-ese" tone. While requiringthereadertore-readtoclarifythe
-8
+Ido Dagan, Oren Glickman, and Bernardo Magnini. The pascal recognising textual entailment
-| steps. TerminologyorLaTeXsymbolsmay | | | | | conflictispresent. | | | |
-| ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- |
-showslightformattingdeviations.
-| | | | | | – 2(Poor): | Significantfactualflawsappearin | | |
-| ----------- | ------------- | --- | ------- | -------- | ---------- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- |
-| – 2 (Poor): | Relationships | | between | multiple | | | | |
-intermediatesteps(e.g.,asingle-hopanswer
-hopsareunclear,orcriticalpremisesarelost is"11years"butistreatedas"12years"dur-
-duetopoorphrasing,preventingasuccessful ingthemulti-hopcalculation),renderingthe
-logical"closed-loop."Formattingischaotic, finalresultunreliable.
-withLaTeXsymbolsorcodeblocksappear-
-| | | | | | – 1(VeryPoor): | Aseverefactualerrorexists | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | ------------------------- | --- | --- |
-inggarbled.
-inatleastoneintermediatestep,orthetime-
-– 1(VeryPoor): Thelogicalchainisentirely line is logically impossible (e.g., a divorce
-brokenorresultsinaparadox(e.g.,askingfor occurringbeforethemarriage).
-a"year"butrequiringa"monetaryamount"
-as the answer). Terminology is highly un- • AnswerObscurityandLeakagePrevention:
-professional,andformattinghascompletely This criterion evaluates whether the question
-| collapsed. | | | | | stem accidentally | reveals | the final answer | or |
-| ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | ------- | ---------------- | --- |
-ifthereasoningstepsprovideasufficientchal-
-| • ContextualFactConsistency: | | | | Thiscriterion | | | | |
-| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-lenge. Annotatorsfollowfoursteps:
-verifieswhetherallsingle-hopfactsremainfac-
-tuallyaccurateandconflict-freewhenamalga- 1. KeywordFiltering. Searchthequestionstem
-mated into a multi-hop narrative. Annotators for the final answer itself or any strongly
-characteristiccuesthatdirectlypointtoit.
-followfoursteps:
-| | | | | | 2. ShortcutTest. | Attempttoreachthecorrect | | |
-| --------- | ---- | ------------- | --- | ------------ | ---------------- | ------------------------ | --- | --- |
-| 1. Atomic | Fact | Backtracking. | | Compare each | | | | |
-answerwithoutcompletingtheintermediate
-backgroundclaiminthemulti-hopquestion
-hops—relyingonlyonthefinalsegmentof
-(e.g.,adate,atitle,anumericvalue)against
-thequestionorgeneralknowledge.
-theoriginalsingle-hopdata.
-| | | | | | 3. Distractor | Elimination | Check. Assess | |
-| ----------------- | -------- | -------- | ---------- | ---------------- | ------------- | ----------------- | ------------- | ---- |
-| 2. Spatiotemporal | | Conflict | Detection. | Verify | | | | |
-| | | | | | whether | the stem provides | enough | non- |
-| that the | combined | timeline | | is logically co- | | | | |
-logicalinformationtoruleoutallincorrect
-| herent | (e.g., | an appointment | | in 1877 re- | | | | |
-| ------ | ------ | -------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-optionswithoutgenuinereasoning.
-| quires | the predecessor’s | | tenure | to overlap | | | | |
-| ------ | ----------------- | --- | ------ | ---------- | ---------------- | ------------------------- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | 4. FinalScoring. | Ifeveryreasoningstepisin- | | |
-orprecedethatdate).
-dispensableforreachingtheanswer,score5;
-| 3. ModifierVerification. | | | Checkwhetherqual- | | | | | |
-| ------------------------ | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-ifthefinalsegmentalonemakestheanswer
-ifiersaddedduringcomposition(e.g.,“the
-obvious,lowerthescoreaccordingly.
-| large | art school”) | inadvertently | | alter the | | | | |
-| ---------------- | ------------ | ------------- | --- | --------- | --------------- | ---------- | ------------- | --- |
-| originalmeaning. | | | | | – 5(Excellent): | Noleakage. | Thesolvermust | |
-4. FinalScoring. Ifallintermediate-nodefacts completeeveryreasoningsteptofindthean-
-arecorrectandtransitionsarenatural,assign
-swer. Thefinalansweroritsdistinctcharac-
-thefullscore.
-teristicsdonotappear,directlyorindirectly,
-withinthequestionstem.
-| – 5(Excellent): | | Allintegratedfacts(dates,lo- | | | | | | |
-| --------------- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-cations,values)arelogicallyconsistentwith – 4 (Good): The reasoning chain is intact,
-thoughsomebackgrounddescriptionsmight
-oneanotherandthereal-worldbackground.
-The combined scenario is realistic (e.g., a allow a model to narrow down the answer
-museumestablishedin2000iscorrectlyde- rangeviaaprocessofeliminationratherthan
-purededuction.
-scribedasexistingin2005).
-– 4 (Good): Core facts are accurate, but mi- – 3(Satisfactory): Partialleakageoccurs. Cer-
-tainphrasingistoodirect(e.g.,mentioninga
-nordescriptivebiasesinnon-essentialdetails
-(e.g., secondary institutional titles or hon- highly unique year or rare proper noun), al-
-orifics)occurduringamalgamationwithout lowingexperiencedannotatorsormodelsto
-"guess"theanswerviashortcutsorcommon
-affectingthefinalanswer.
-sense.
-| – 3 (Satisfactory): | | Core | facts | remain funda- | | | | |
-| ------------------- | --- | ---- | ----- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-mentallycorrect,butthetimelineorlogical – 2 (Poor): The question contains obvious
-backgroundacrosshopsfeelsslightly"awk- hints that make the reasoning chain signif-
-ward" or strained, though no direct factual icantlyeasiertobypass.
-9
+challenge. In Machine Learning Challenges Workshop, pp. 177–190. Springer, 2005.
-| – 1 (Very | Poor): | Direct | leakage. | | The | final | textunreadable. | | | | | |
-| --------- | ------ | ------ | -------- | --- | --- | ----- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-answerappearswithinthemulti-hopdescrip-
-| | | | | | | | • Reasoning | Complexity | | and | Domain | Diver- |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ---------- | --- | --- | ------ | ------ |
-tion,orthequestionisphrasedinawaythat
-| | | | | | | | sity: This | criterion | | measures | the | degree of |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --------- | --- | -------- | --- | --------- |
-rendersthelogicalstepsmeaningless.
-cross-domaincomplexityandthedepthofthe
-• SemanticCompletenessandLinguisticFlu- logicaljumps. Annotatorsfollowfoursteps:
-ency: Thiscriterionevaluatestheretentionof
-| | | | | | | | 1. Domain | Counting. | | Identify | the | number of |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --------- | --- | -------- | --- | --------- |
-allnecessaryconstraintsandthenaturalnessof
-distinctknowledgedomainsspannedbythe
-| the linguistic | expression. | | | Annotators | follow | | | | | | | |
-| -------------- | ----------- | --- | --- | ---------- | ------ | --- | -------- | ------ | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | question | (e.g., | Literature, | | Geography, | Art |
-foursteps:
-History,Arithmetic).
-1. GrammarandRhetoricScan. Checklong, 2. HopCounting. Countthenumberofexplicit
-complex sentences for grammatical errors logicaltransitionsfromthestartingentityto
-| and ambiguous | | references | | (e.g., | multiple | | thefinalanswer. | | | | | |
-| ------------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------ | -------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-usesof“theartist”whenseveralartistsare 3. DepthandDependencyAnalysis. Determine
-mentioned).
-whethereachhoprequiresdomain-specific
-2. Constraint Condition Checklist. Confirm knowledgethatcannotbebypassedthrough
-| thatallcriticalconstraintsfromthesingle- | | | | | | | commonsensealone. | | | | | |
-| ---------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-hopquestions(e.g.,“since1855,”“priorto”) 4. LevelDetermination. Assignascorebased
-arefaithfullycarriedoverintothemulti-hop onthenumberofdomainscrossed(4+do-
-| question. | | | | | | | mains | = top | tier) | and the | number | of non- |
-| ------------------------- | ---- | --- | ------ | -------------- | ------ | --- | ---------------- | ----- | ----- | ------- | ------ | ---------- |
-| 3. LogicalConnectorCheck. | | | | Verifythatcon- | | | trivialhops. | | | | | |
-| nectors | such | as | “prior | to,” | “who,” | and | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | – 5 (Excellent): | | The | logical | chain | spans 4 or |
-“where”accuratelyreflecttheinter-hoprela-
-| | | | | | | | more | distinct | domains | (e.g., | Art | History → |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | -------- | ------- | ------ | --- | --------- |
-tionships.
-Geography→Law→FinancialArithmetic).
-| 4. Final | Scoring. | A | question | that | reads | flu- | | | | | | |
-| -------- | -------- | --- | -------- | ---- | ----- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-Eachstepisstrictlydependentontheprevi-
-entlyandpreservesallconstraintsscores5;
-ousoneandcannotbebypassedviacommon
-| noticeable | “translation-ese” | | | or | ambiguous | | | | | | | |
-| ---------- | ----------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-sense.
-referenceslowerthescoreto3orbelow.
-| | | | | | | | – 4(Good): | Thelogicspans3distinctdomains | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-– 5(Excellent): Allnecessaryconstraints(e.g., andinvolvesatleast4explicitlogicaljumps.
-| specific | year | ranges, | "inclusive," | | rounding | | – 3 (Satisfactory): | | | | | |
-| ------------------ | ---- | ------------- | ------------ | ------------ | -------- | --- | ------------------------ | ---- | --------- | ------------- | ----------------- | --------- |
-| | | | | | | | | | | The reasoning | | chain in- |
-| requirements) | | are perfectly | | preserved. | | The | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | volves | 3 or | more deep | logical | steps | within |
-| languageisnatural, | | | smooth, | andadheresto | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | atleast2distinctdomains. | | | | Iteffectivelydis- | |
-native-speakerhabitswithpreciselogicalcon-
-tinguishesmodelswithsingle-domainknowl-
-nectives.
-edge.
-| – 4(Good): | Constraintsarecomplete,butthe | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| ------------------------ | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | – 2(Poor): | Thechaininvolves2domainsbut | | | | |
-| phrasingisslightlywordy. | | | | Languageisflu- | | | | | | | | |
-only1–2simplelogicaljumps,oroneofthe
-ent,thoughthechoiceoflogicalconnectors
-domainsreliesoncommonknowledge.
-(e.g.,"priorto,""who")mayberepetitive.
-| | | | | | | | – 1 (Very | Poor): | "Pseudo-multi-hop." | | | The |
-| ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- | ------- | --- | --------- | ------ | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- |
-| – 3 (Satisfactory): | | | The | core | meaning | is | | | | | | |
-logicisextremelysimple,consistingmerely
-clear,butsomenon-essentialconstraintsare
-| | | | | | | | of the | additive | stacking | | of facts | within the |
-| ------- | ------ | ------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | ------ | -------- | -------- | --- | -------- | ---------- |
-| omitted | (e.g., | missing | a | rounding | instruc- | | | | | | | |
-samedomain.
-| tion). | The expression | | is | rigid | and exhibits | | | | | | | |
-| ------ | -------------- | --- | --- | ----- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-"translation-ese"oraformulaictone.
-| – 2 (Poor): | Critical | | constraints | | required | for | | | | | | |
-| ----------- | -------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-derivationaremissing,orredundantinforma-
-tionisaddedthatinterfereswithunderstand-
-ing. Logicalconnectorsareusedincorrectly.
-| – 1(VeryPoor): | | Keyconstraintsaremissing, | | | | | | | | | | |
-| -------------- | --- | ------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-makingitimpossibletodetermineaunique
-| answer. | Thelanguageisbrokenandthelog- | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| ------- | ----------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-icalrelationshipsareerroneous,makingthe
-10
+Bryan Eikema and Wilker Aziz. Is MAP decoding all you need? the inadequacy of the mode in neural
+machine translation. In Proceedings of the 28th International Conference on Computational Lin-
+guistics, pp. 4506–4520, Barcelona, Spain (Online), December 2020. International Committee on
+Computational Linguistics. URL https://aclanthology.org/2020.coling-main.
+398.
-Figure4: Annotationinterfaceforsingle-hopquestion.
-Single-hopSub-questions
-| | Factuality | Distractor | Fluency |
-| ---- | ---------- | ---------- | ------- |
-| Mean | 4.62 | 4.31 | 4.47 |
-| STD | 0.54 | 0.72 | 0.61 |
-4-hopQuestions
-| | Logic | Consistency | Obscurity |
-| ---- | ------- | ----------- | --------- |
-| Mean | 4.53 | 4.41 | 4.18 |
-| STD | 0.58 | 0.65 | 0.79 |
-| | Fluency | Complexity | |
-| Mean | 4.44 | 4.56 | |
-| STD | 0.62 | 0.53 | |
-Table3: Humanannotationscoresona1–5scaleover
-967testinstances.Eachcellreportsthemeanscorewith
-| thestandarddeviationinsubscript(mean | | std | ). |
-| ------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- |
-11
+Yanai Elazar, Nora Kassner, Shauli Ravfogel, Abhilasha Ravichander, Eduard Hovy, Hinrich
+Schütze, and Yoav Goldberg. Measuring and improving consistency in pretrained language
+models. Transactions of the Association for Computational Linguistics, 9:1012–1031, 2021. doi:
+10.1162/tacl_a_00410. URL https://aclanthology.org/2021.tacl-1.60.
+
+Jonathan St BT Evans. Intuition and reasoning: A dual-process perspective. Psychological Inquiry,
+
+21(4):313–326, 2010.
+
+Angela Fan, Mike Lewis, and Yann Dauphin. Hierarchical neural story generation. In Proceedings
+of the 56th Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics (Volume 1: Long
+Papers), pp. 889–898, Melbourne, Australia, July 2018. Association for Computational Linguistics.
+doi: 10.18653/v1/P18-1082. URL https://aclanthology.org/P18-1082.
+
+Jessica Ficler and Yoav Goldberg. Controlling linguistic style aspects in neural language generation. In
+Proceedings of the Workshop on Stylistic Variation, pp. 94–104, Copenhagen, Denmark, September
+2017. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/W17-4912. URL https:
+//aclanthology.org/W17-4912.
+
+Tianyu Gao, Adam Fisch, and Danqi Chen. Making pre-trained language models better few-shot
+learners. In Proceedings of the 59th Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguis-
+tics and the 11th International Joint Conference on Natural Language Processing (Volume 1: Long
+Papers), pp. 3816–3830, Online, August 2021. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi:
+10.18653/v1/2021.acl-long.295. URL https://aclanthology.org/2021.acl-long.
+295.
+
+Mor Geva, Ankit Gupta, and Jonathan Berant. Injecting numerical reasoning skills into language
+models. In Proceedings of the 58th Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguis-
+tics, 2020. doi: 10.18653/v1/2020.acl-main.89. URL https://aclanthology.org/2020.
+acl-main.89.
+
+Mor Geva, Daniel Khashabi, Elad Segal, Tushar Khot, Dan Roth, and Jonathan Berant. Did aristotle
+use a laptop? A question answering benchmark with implicit reasoning strategies. Transactions of
+the Association for Computational Linguistics, 2021. URL https://aclanthology.org/
+2021.tacl-1.21.
+
+Danilo Giampiccolo, Bernardo Magnini, Ido Dagan, and Bill Dolan. The third pascal recognizing
+textual entailment challenge. In Proceedings of the ACL-PASCAL workshop on textual entailment
+and paraphrasing, pp. 1–9. Association for Computational Linguistics, 2007.
+
+Ari Holtzman, Jan Buys, Maxwell Forbes, Antoine Bosselut, David Golub, and Yejin Choi. Learning
+In Proceedings of the 56th Annual Meeting of the
+to write with cooperative discriminators.
+Association for Computational Linguistics (Volume 1: Long Papers), pp. 1638–1649, Melbourne,
+Australia, July 2018. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/P18-1152.
+URL https://aclanthology.org/P18-1152.
+
+Ari Holtzman, Jan Buys, Li Du, Maxwell Forbes, and Yejin Choi. The curious case of neural text
+degeneration. In International Conference on Learning Representations, 2020. URL https:
+//openreview.net/forum?id=rygGQyrFvH.
+
+Mohammad Javad Hosseini, Hannaneh Hajishirzi, Oren Etzioni, and Nate Kushman. Learning to
+solve arithmetic word problems with verb categorization. In Proceedings of the 2014 Conference on
+Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing (EMNLP), 2014. doi: 10.3115/v1/D14-1058.
+URL https://aclanthology.org/D14-1058.
-Figure5: Annotationinterfacefor4-hopquestion.
12
-| ReasoningGraph | Multi-hopQuestion | Single-hopComposition | | | |
-| -------------- | -------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | Ifapoliticalregimebeganin1969andlasted | 1. WhoservedasEisenhower’svicepresident?Nixon | | | |
-foranumberofyearsequalto7timesthe 2. HowmanysuccessfulApollomoonlandingmissionsoccurred
-countofApollomoonlandingmissionsthatoc-
-whileNixonwaspresidentoftheU.S.?6
-curredduringthepresidencyofEisenhower’s 3. Ifapoliticalregimelastedfor6times7yearsstartingfrom1969,
-vicepresident,andiftheU.S.wasoneof2ma- whosefacewasmostcloselyassociatedwithLibya’sgovernment
-| | jorpowersthatrecognizedthisregime’sleader | duringthisperiod?Gaddafi | | | |
-| --- | ----------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | earlyon,whatwastheothermajorpower?So- | 4. IftheU.S.wasonemajorpowerthatrecognizedGaddafi’s | | | |
-vietUnion governmentatanearlydate,andtherewere2majorpowerstotal
-[A: United Kingdom B: France C: Soviet thatdidsoearlyon,whatwastheothermajorpowerbesidesthe
-| | UnionD:WestGermany] | U.S.?SovietUnion | | | |
-| --- | ------------------- | ---------------- | --- | --- | --- |
-GreatAmericanBallParkisthehomestadium 1. InwhichU.S.cityisGreatAmericanBallParklocated?Cincin-
-| | ofanMLBteamthathaswontheWorldSeries | nati | | | |
-| --- | ----------------------------------- | ---- | --- | --- | --- |
-multipletimes. Multiplytheirtotalchampi- 2. HowmanyWorldSerieschampionshipshavetheCincinnatiReds
-| | onshipcountbythenumberofplayersperma- | wonintotal?5 | | | |
-| --- | ------------------------------------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- |
-nentlybannedforfixingthe1919WorldSeries 3. EightChicagoWhiteSoxplayerswerepermanentlybannedfrom
-baseballfortheirroleinfixingthe1919WorldSeries(theBlack
-intheBlackSoxScandal.Thecarriernamed
-afterthepresidentwiththatordinalnumber SoxScandal).MultiplythisnumberbytheCincinnatiReds’total
-replacedwhichvesselatNavalStationYoko- WorldSerieschampionships(5).WhichU.S.Presidentheldthe
-| | suka,Japan,in2015?USSGeorgeWashing- | ordinalnumberequaltothisproduct?RonaldReagan | | | |
-| --- | ----------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | ton | 4. USSRonaldReaganreplacedwhichaircraftcarrierastheU.S. | | | |
-[A:USSNimitzB:USSCarlVinsonC:USS Navy’sforward-deployedvesselatNavalStationYokosuka,Japan,
-| | GeorgeWashingtonD:USSJohnC.Stennis] | in2015?USSGeorgeWashington | | | |
-| --- | ----------------------------------- | -------------------------- | --- | --- | --- |
-Table4: Examplemulti-hopreasoninggraphanditsstep-by-stepquestiondecomposition.
-Dataset OpenDomain #Hops Explicitstep-wisechain #Topologies Mathreasoning Expert-review
-| MuSiQue(Trivedietal.,2022) | Yes 2-4 | No | 3 | No | Yes |
-| -------------------------- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| FanOutQA(Zhuetal.,2024) | Yes 5-6 | Yes | 1 | No | Yes |
-| CofCA(Wuetal.,2025) | Yes 2-4 | No | 3 | No | No |
-| SynthWorlds(Guetal.,2026) | No 2-4 | No | 3 | No | No |
-| OmanicBench(ours) | Yes 4 | Yes | 3 | Yes | Yes |
-Table5: QualitativecomparisonbetweenOmanicBenchandrepresentativemulti-hoporreasoningbenchmarks. “#
-Hops”reportsthesupportedhoprange;forMuSiQueandCofCA,around80%ofthequestionsare2-hop. “Explicit
-step-wise chain” indicates whether a benchmark provides explicit step-level annotations, such as decomposed
-sub-questionsandintermediateanswers,fordiagnosingreasoningfailures. “#Topologies”countsthenumberof
-reasoningtopologiesdefinedforquestionsatthemaximumhoplevelofeachbenchmark.
+Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023
+
+Daniel Khashabi, Sewon Min, Tushar Khot, Ashish Sabharwal, Oyvind Tafjord, Peter Clark, and Han-
+naneh Hajishirzi. UNIFIEDQA: Crossing format boundaries with a single QA system. In Findings
+of the Association for Computational Linguistics: EMNLP 2020, pp. 1896–1907, Online, Novem-
+ber 2020. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/2020.findings-emnlp.171.
+URL https://aclanthology.org/2020.findings-emnlp.171.
+
+Takeshi Kojima, Shixiang Shane Gu, Machel Reid, Yutaka Matsuo, and Yusuke Iwasawa. Large
+language models are zero-shot reasoners. In Alice H. Oh, Alekh Agarwal, Danielle Belgrave,
+and Kyunghyun Cho (eds.), Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems, 2022. URL
+https://openreview.net/forum?id=e2TBb5y0yFf.
+
+Rik Koncel-Kedziorski, Subhro Roy, Aida Amini, Nate Kushman, and Hannaneh Hajishirzi. MAWPS:
+A math word problem repository. In Proceedings of the 2016 Conference of the North American
+Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics: Human Language Technologies, 2016.
+doi: 10.18653/v1/N16-1136. URL https://aclanthology.org/N16-1136.
+
+Yihuai Lan, Lei Wang, Qiyuan Zhang, Yunshi Lan, Bing Tian Dai, Yan Wang, Dongxiang Zhang,
+and Ee-Peng Lim. MWPToolkit: An open-source framework for deep learning-based math word
+problem solvers. arXiv preprint arXiv:2109.00799, 2021. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/
+2109.00799.
+
+Jiwei Li and Dan Jurafsky. Mutual information and diverse decoding improve neural machine
+
+translation, 2016. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/1601.00372.
+
+Jiwei Li, Will Monroe, and Dan Jurafsky. A simple, fast diverse decoding algorithm for neural
+generation. CoRR, abs/1611.08562, 2016. URL http://arxiv.org/abs/1611.08562.
+
+Wang Ling, Dani Yogatama, Chris Dyer, and Phil Blunsom. Program induction by rationale genera-
+tion: Learning to solve and explain algebraic word problems. In Proceedings of the 55th Annual
+Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics (Volume 1: Long Papers), 2017. doi:
+10.18653/v1/P17-1015. URL https://aclanthology.org/P17-1015.
+
+Yao Lu, Max Bartolo, Alastair Moore, Sebastian Riedel, and Pontus Stenetorp. Fantastically
+ordered prompts and where to find them: Overcoming few-shot prompt order sensitivity. ArXiv,
+abs/2104.08786, 2021.
+
+Clara Meister, Tiago Pimentel, Gian Wiher, and Ryan Cotterell. Typical decoding for natural language
+
+generation. arXiv preprint arXiv:2202.00666, 2022.
+
+Shen Yun Miao, Chao Chun Liang, and Keh Yih Su. A diverse corpus for evaluating and developing
+English math word problem solvers. In Proceedings of the 58th Annual Meeting of the Asso-
+ciation for Computational Linguistics, 2020. URL https://aclanthology.org/2020.
+acl-main.92.
+
+Yixin Nie, Adina Williams, Emily Dinan, Mohit Bansal, Jason Weston, and Douwe Kiela. Adver-
+sarial NLI: A new benchmark for natural language understanding. In Proceedings of the 58th
+Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics. Association for Computational
+Linguistics, 2020.
+
+Maxwell Nye, Michael Henry Tessler, Joshua B. Tenenbaum, and Brenden M. Lake. Improving
+coherence and consistency in neural sequence models with dual-system, neuro-symbolic reasoning.
+In A. Beygelzimer, Y. Dauphin, P. Liang, and J. Wortman Vaughan (eds.), Advances in Neural
+Information Processing Systems, 2021. URL https://openreview.net/forum?id=
+uyKk_avJ-p4.
+
+Arkil Patel, Satwik Bhattamishra, and Navin Goyal. Are NLP models really able to solve simple
+math word problems? In Proceedings of the 2021 Conference of the North American Chapter of
+the Association for Computational Linguistics: Human Language Technologies, pp. 2080–2094,
+Online, June 2021. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/2021.naacl-main.
+168. URL https://aclanthology.org/2021.naacl-main.168.
+
+Xinyu Pi, Qian Liu, Bei Chen, Morteza Ziyadi, Zeqi Lin, Yan Gao, Qiang Fu, Jian-Guang Lou, and
+
+Weizhu Chen. Reasoning like program executors, 2022.
+
13
-(a)Bridge (b)Chain (c)Converging
-Figure6: ThreereasoninggraphtopologiesusedinOmanicfororganizing4-hopquestions.
-Figure7: Domaindistributionofsingle-hopsub-questionsacrossOmanicSynth,OmanicBench,andtheoverall
-dataset.
-Figure8: ReasoninggraphtopologydistributionacrossOmanicSynth,OmanicBench,andtheoveralldataset.
+Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023
+
+Piotr Pi˛ekos, Mateusz Malinowski, and Henryk Michalewski. Measuring and improving BERT’s
+mathematical abilities by predicting the order of reasoning. In Proceedings of the 59th Annual Meet-
+ing of the Association for Computational Linguistics and the 11th International Joint Conference on
+Natural Language Processing (Volume 2: Short Papers), 2021. doi: 10.18653/v1/2021.acl-short.49.
+URL https://aclanthology.org/2021.acl-short.49.
+
+Alec Radford, Jeff Wu, Rewon Child, David Luan, Dario Amodei, and Ilya Sutskever. Language
+
+models are unsupervised multitask learners. 2019.
+
+Jack W Rae, Sebastian Borgeaud, Trevor Cai, Katie Millican, Jordan Hoffmann, Francis Song, John
+Aslanides, Sarah Henderson, Roman Ring, Susannah Young, et al. Scaling language models:
+Methods, analysis & insights from training gopher. arXiv preprint arXiv:2112.11446, 2021.
+
+Qiu Ran, Yankai Lin, Peng Li, Jie Zhou, and Zhiyuan Liu. NumNet: Machine reading comprehension
+with numerical reasoning. In Proceedings of the 2019 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural
+Language Processing and the 9th International Joint Conference on Natural Language Processing
+(EMNLP-IJCNLP), 2019. doi: 10.18653/v1/D19-1251. URL https://aclanthology.
+org/D19-1251.
+
+Subhro Roy and Dan Roth. Solving general arithmetic word problems. In Proceedings of the 2015
+Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing, 2015. doi: 10.18653/v1/
+D15-1202. URL https://aclanthology.org/D15-1202.
+
+Jianhao Shen, Yichun Yin, Lin Li, Lifeng Shang, Xin Jiang, Ming Zhang, and Qun Liu. Generate
+& rank: A multi-task framework for math word problems. In Findings of the Association for
+Computational Linguistics: EMNLP 2021, pp. 2269–2279, Punta Cana, Dominican Republic,
+November 2021. Association for Computational Linguistics. URL https://aclanthology.
+org/2021.findings-emnlp.195.
+
+Freda Shi, Daniel Fried, Marjan Ghazvininejad, Luke Zettlemoyer, and Sida I. Wang. Natural
+language to code translation with execution. In Proceedings of the 2022 Conference on Empirical
+Methods in Natural Language Processing, pp. 3533–3546, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates,
+December 2022. Association for Computational Linguistics. URL https://aclanthology.
+org/2022.emnlp-main.231.
+
+Keith E Stanovich and Richard F West.
+
+Individual differences in reasoning: Implications for
+the rationality debate? Behavioral and brain sciences, 23(5):645–665, 2000. URL https:
+//pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11301544/.
+
+Alon Talmor, Jonathan Herzig, Nicholas Lourie, and Jonathan Berant. CommonsenseQA: A question
+answering challenge targeting commonsense knowledge. In Proceedings of the 2019 Conference of
+the North American Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics: Human Language
+Technologies, Volume 1 (Long and Short Papers), 2019. URL https://aclanthology.
+org/N19-1421.
+
+Yi Tay, Mostafa Dehghani, Vinh Q. Tran, Xavier Garcia, Jason Wei, Xuezhi Wang, Hyung Won Chung,
+Dara Bahri, Tal Schuster, Steven Zheng, Denny Zhou, Neil Houlsby, and Donald Metzler. Unifying
+language learning paradigms, 2022. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2205.05131.
+
+Romal Thoppilan, Daniel De Freitas, Jamie Hall, Noam Shazeer, Apoorv Kulshreshtha, Heng-Tze
+Cheng, Alicia Jin, Taylor Bos, Leslie Baker, Yu Du, et al. Lamda: Language models for dialog
+applications. arXiv preprint arXiv:2201.08239, 2022. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/
+2201.08239.
+
+Ashwin Vijayakumar, Michael Cogswell, Ramprasaath Selvaraju, Qing Sun, Stefan Lee, David
+Crandall, and Dhruv Batra. Diverse beam search for improved description of complex scenes.
+Proceedings of the AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence, 32, Apr. 2018. URL https:
+//ojs.aaai.org/index.php/AAAI/article/view/12340.
+
+Jason Wei, Xuezhi Wang, Dale Schuurmans, Maarten Bosma, Brian Ichter, Fei Xia, Ed Chi, Quoc
+Le, and Denny Zhou. Chain of thought prompting elicits reasoning in large language models.
+Conference on Neural Information Processing Systems (NeurIPS), 2022. URL https://arxiv.
+org/pdf/2201.11903.
+
14
-B FullResults
-| | | | | | | | Parameter | | Value | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | Trainbatchsize | | 512 | |
-B.1 Implementationdetails
-| | | | | | | | Maxpromptlength | | 1024 | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ---- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | Maxresponselength | | 1024 | |
-Forsupervisedfine-tuning,weconstructamixed
-| | | | | | | | Actorlearningrate | | 1.0×10−5 | |
-| -------- | ------ | ----- | ---- | ------ | --------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | -------- | --- |
-| training | set in | which | half | of the | instances | are | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | PPOmini-batchsize | | 512 | |
-formattedasmulti-choicequestionexamplesand
-| | | | | | | | PPOmicro-batchsize/GPU | | 32 | |
-| --------- | --------- | ---------- | --------- | ------------- | ----- | ------- | ---------------------- | --- | ------- | --- |
-| the other | half are | formatted | | as open-ended | | gen- | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | PPOepochs | | 1 | |
-| eration | examples. | For | Qwen3-8B, | | we | adopt a | KLloss | | Enabled | |
-| two-stage | training | framework: | | we | first | perform | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | KLcoefficient | | 0.01 | |
-full-parameter SFT, and then conduct GRPO- Numberofrollouts 5
-based (Shao et al., 2024) reinforcement learning Totalepochs 3
-| starting | from the | fine-tuned | | model. | For LLaMA- | | | | | |
-| -------- | -------- | ---------- | --- | ------ | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-3.3-70B,weperformLoRA-based(Huetal.,2023) Table8: HyperparametersforQwen3-8BGRPOtrain-
-ing.
-| SFT on | the same | mixed | training | data. | All | exper- | | | | |
-| ------ | ------------- | ----- | -------- | ----- | ---- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| iments | are conducted | | on four | 96GB | H100 | NVL | | | | |
-GPUs, and the detailed training hyperparameters Parameter Value
-| arereportedinTables7,8,and9. | | | | Theevaluation | | | | | | |
-| ------------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | ------------- | --- | --- | -------------------- | -------- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | LoRArank | 8 | | |
-| templatesaresummarizedinTable6. | | | | | | | Cutofflength | 2048 | | |
-| | | | | | | | Per-devicebatchsize | 32 | | |
-| | | | | | | | Gradientaccumulation | 2 | | |
-| Setting | | | Template | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | Learningrate | 1.0×10−4 | | |
-| Directmulti-choicequestion | | | Selectthecorrectoption | | | | Epochs | 3.0 | | |
-| | | | fromfourcandidatesand | | | | Precision | BF16 | | |
-returnonlytheanswer
-letter(A/B/C/D).
-| | | | | | | | Table9: HyperparametersforLLaMA-3.3-70BLoRA | | | |
-| ---------------- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- |
-| Directopen-ended | | | Answerasconciselyas | | | | | | | |
-SFT.
-possibleandprovide
-onlythefinalanswer
-withoutexplanation.
-| | | | | | | | B.2 Discussion | | | |
-| ----------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------ | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --- |
-| CoTmulti-choicequestion | | | Thinkstepbystepand | | | | | | | |
-endtheresponsewith
-| | | | | | | | Asmarkedby† inTable2,Claude-Sonnet-4.6ex- | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- |
-“TheanswerisX”,where
-| | | | XisA,B,C,orD. | | | | hibitsauniquefailuremodeunderCoTprompting: | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- |
-CoTopen-ended Thinkstepbystepand itsMCQaccuracyimprovessubstantially,yetopen-
-writethefinalanswer
-| | | | | | | | ended performance | (EM/F1) | degrades. | Manual |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------------- | ------- | --------- | ------ |
-onaseparatelinein
-| | | | theformat“FINAL | | | | inspectionrevealsthatClaude’sCoTresponsesare | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- |
-ANSWER:”. substantially longer (avg. 1,812 tokens vs. GPT-
-5.4’s451tokens),withthefinalanswerfrequently
-| Table 6: | Evaluation | templates | | for direct | | and CoT | | | | |
-| -------- | ---------- | --------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-buriedinextendedproseratherthanpresentedinan
-prompting.
-| | | | | | | | extractableformat. | Thissuggeststhedegradation | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------ | -------------------------- | --- | --- |
-reflectsananswerextractionfailureratherthana
-reasoningregression,underscoringtheimportance
-| Parameter | | | Value | | | | ofevaluatingreasoningcapability(MCQ)andan- | | | |
-| --------- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- |
-swerarticulation(EM/F1)ascomplementary,not
-| Cutofflength | | | 2048 | | | | | | | |
-| ------------ | --- | --- | ---- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-interchangeable,axes.
-| Per-devicebatchsize | | | 32 | | | | | | | |
-| -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| Gradientaccumulation | | | 2 | | | | | | | |
-1.0×10−5
-Learningrate
-| Epochs | | | 3.0 | | | | | | | |
-| ----------- | ---------------------------------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| LRscheduler | | | Cosine | | | | | | | |
-| Warmupratio | | | 0.1 | | | | | | | |
-| Precision | | | BF16 | | | | | | | |
-| Table7: | HyperparametersforQwen3-8BFullSFT. | | | | | | | | | |
+Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023
+
+Sean Welleck, Ilia Kulikov, Jaedeok Kim, Richard Yuanzhe Pang, and Kyunghyun Cho. Consistency
+of a recurrent language model with respect to incomplete decoding. In Proceedings of the 2020
+Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing (EMNLP), pp. 5553–5568,
+Online, November 2020. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/2020.
+emnlp-main.448. URL https://aclanthology.org/2020.emnlp-main.448.
+
+Weiwen Xu, Yang Deng, Huihui Zhang, Deng Cai, and Wai Lam. Exploiting reasoning chains
+for multi-hop science question answering. In Findings of the Association for Computational
+Linguistics: EMNLP 2021, pp. 1143–1156, Punta Cana, Dominican Republic, November 2021a.
+Association for Computational Linguistics. URL https://aclanthology.org/2021.
+findings-emnlp.99.
+
+Yichong Xu, Chenguang Zhu, Shuohang Wang, Siqi Sun, Hao Cheng, Xiaodong Liu, Jianfeng
+Gao, Pengcheng He, Michael Zeng, and Xuedong Huang. Human parity on commonsenseqa:
+Augmenting self-attention with external attention, 2021b. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/
+2112.03254.
+
+Zhilin Yang, Peng Qi, Saizheng Zhang, Yoshua Bengio, William Cohen, Ruslan Salakhutdinov, and
+Christopher D. Manning. HotpotQA: A dataset for diverse, explainable multi-hop question answer-
+ing. In Proceedings of the 2018 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing,
+pp. 2369–2380, Brussels, Belgium, October-November 2018. Association for Computational Lin-
+guistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/D18-1259. URL https://aclanthology.org/D18-1259.
+
+Xi Ye and Greg Durrett. The unreliability of explanations in few-shot prompting for textual reasoning.
+In Alice H. Oh, Alekh Agarwal, Danielle Belgrave, and Kyunghyun Cho (eds.), Advances in
+Neural Information Processing Systems, 2022. URL https://openreview.net/forum?
+id=Bct2f8fRd8S.
+
+Wenhao Yu, Chenguang Zhu, Lianhui Qin, Zhihan Zhang, Tong Zhao, and Meng Jiang. Diversifying
+content generation for commonsense reasoning with mixture of knowledge graph experts. In
+Findings of Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics (ACL), 2022.
+
+Zihao Zhao, Eric Wallace, Shi Feng, Dan Klein, and Sameer Singh. Calibrate before use: Improving
+few-shot performance of language models. In Marina Meila and Tong Zhang (eds.), Proceed-
+ings of the 38th International Conference on Machine Learning, volume 139 of Proceedings of
+Machine Learning Research. PMLR, 2021. URL https://proceedings.mlr.press/
+v139/zhao21c.html.
+
15
-| | | | MCQ | ExactMatch F1-Score | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- |
-OpenAI
-| | | GPT-5.2 | 38.51 | 18.20 | 29.09 |
-| --- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ----- | ----- |
-| | | GPT-5.2CoT | 65.98 | 34.13 | 46.93 |
-| | | GPT-5.1 | 39.40 | 18.55 | 26.62 |
-| | | GPT-5.1CoT | 71.68 | 39.96 | 51.18 |
-Direct CoT
-| | | GPT-4o | 39.50 | 16.65 | 28.93 |
-| ----------------- | --------- | -------------------- | ----- | ----- | ----- |
-| OpenAI | | GPT-4oCoT | 66.91 | 37.85 | 47.04 |
-| GPT-5.4 | 13 451 | Anthropic | | | |
-| GPT-5.2 | 15 502 | Claude-Sonnet-4.5 | 51.24 | 24.56 | 34.04 |
-| | | Claude-Sonnet-4.5CoT | 75.88 | 44.40 | 54.89 |
-| GPT-5.1 | 12 1,126 | | | | |
-| | | Claude-Opus-4.5 | 61.97 | 10.17 | 16.00 |
-| GPT-4o | 16 1,314 | | | | |
-| | | Claude-Opus-4.5CoT | 76.68 | 44.50 | 55.44 |
-| Anthropic | | Claude-Opus-4.1 | 54.40 | 19.31 | 28.50 |
-| | | Claude-Opus-4.1CoT | 76.95 | 39.75 | 49.81 |
-| Claude-Sonnet-4.6 | 611 1,812 | | | | |
-| | | Claude-Sonnet-4 | 51.40 | 21.92 | 31.80 |
-| Claude-Sonnet-4.5 | 82 1,379 | | | | |
-| | | Claude-Sonnet-4CoT | 74.15 | 39.09 | 49.40 |
-| Claude-Opus-4.5 | 332 1,469 | Claude-Opus-4 | 52.02 | 22.45 | 32.16 |
-| | | Claude-Opus-4CoT | 73.10 | 40.44 | 50.18 |
-| Claude-Opus-4.1 | 196 1,221 | | | | |
-Google
-| Claude-Sonnet-4 | 76 1,316 | | | | |
-| ---------------------- | --------- | ------------------------- | ----- | ----- | ----- |
-| | | Gemini-3-Flash-Preview | 67.22 | 21.30 | 31.34 |
-| Claude-Opus-4 | 112 1,223 | | | | |
-| | | Gemini-3-Flash-PreviewCoT | 75.90 | 40.54 | 50.19 |
-| Google | | Gemini-2.5-Flash | 62.77 | 18.20 | 25.10 |
-| | | Gemini-2.5-FlashCoT | 54.60 | 27.71 | 36.55 |
-| Gemini-3.1-flash-Lite | 10 1,423 | | | | |
-| | | Gemini-2.5-Flash-Lite | 32.68 | 9.31 | 14.04 |
-| Gemini-3-Flash-Preview | 9 1,587 | | | | |
-| | | Gemini-2.5-Flash-LiteCoT | 32.26 | 22.54 | 29.24 |
-| Gemini-2.5-Flash | 8 3,837 | | | | |
-Gemini-2.5-Flash-Lite 8 6,453 Table11: ExpandedproprietaryLLMsresultsonOman-
-icBench.
-Meta
-| LLaMA-3.3-70B | 38 1,694 | | | | |
-| ------------- | -------- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- |
-| | | | MCQ | ExactMatch F1-Score | |
-| LLaMA-3-8B | 22 1,469 | | | | |
-Meta
-| LLaMA-3-70B | 11 735 | LLaMA-3.3-70B | 40.04 | 11.77 | 20.47 |
-| ----------- | ------ | ---------------- | ----- | ----- | ----- |
-| | | LLaMA-3.3-70BCoT | 59.57 | 31.33 | 39.43 |
-Alibaba
-| | | LLaMA-3-8B | 25.23 | 4.96 | 8.78 |
-| --------- | -------- | -------------- | ----- | ----- | ----- |
-| Qwen3-Max | 14 4,841 | LLaMA-3-8BCoT | 42.50 | 16.55 | 22.78 |
-| | | LLaMA-3-70B | 38.47 | 12.10 | 18.84 |
-| Qwen3-32B | 33 920 | | | | |
-| | | LLaMA-3-70BCoT | 57.39 | 29.09 | 37.49 |
-| Qwen3-8B | 24 357 | | | | |
-Alibaba
-| Qwen2.5-72B | 12 1,260 | Qwen3-32B | 52.22 | 12.10 | 18.35 |
-| ------------- | -------- | -------------- | ----- | ----- | ----- |
-| | | Qwen3-32BCoT | 54.86 | 30.37 | 38.98 |
-| Qwen2.5-7B | 15 1,313 | | | | |
-| | | Qwen3-8B | 25.65 | 9.26 | 13.77 |
-| DeepSeek | | Qwen3-8BCoT | 56.44 | 21.76 | 29.97 |
-| | | Qwen2.5-72B | 42.19 | 13.24 | 19.43 |
-| DeepSeek-V3.2 | 11 2,548 | | | | |
-| | | Qwen2.5-72BCoT | 60.81 | 32.06 | 41.31 |
-DeepSeek-R1-Distill-LLaMA-70B 111 652 Qwen2.5-7B 30.51 7.76 14.31
-| | | Qwen2.5-7BCoT | 46.85 | 19.44 | 25.60 |
-| ---------------------------- | ------ | ------------- | ----- | ----- | ----- |
-| DeepSeek-R1-Distill-Qwen-32B | 68 429 | | | | |
-DeepSeek
-| | | DeepSeek-V3.2 | 43.33 | 12.82 | 19.36 |
-| --- | --- | ------------- | ----- | ----- | ----- |
-Table10: AverageoutputlengthunderDirectandCoT
-| | | DeepSeek-V3.2CoT | 70.94 | 35.92 | 46.19 |
-| --- | --- | ---------------- | ----- | ----- | ----- |
-prompting.
-| | | DeepSeek-R1-Distill-LLaMA-70B | 75.92 | 1.72 | 13.71 |
-| --- | --- | -------------------------------- | ----------- | ------------ | ----- |
-| | | DeepSeek-R1-Distill-LLaMA-70BCoT | 72.67 | 41.27 | 51.08 |
-| | | DeepSeek-R1-Distill-Qwen-32B | 69.52 | 11.92 | 22.99 |
-| | | DeepSeek-R1-Distill-Qwen-32BCoT | 69.29 | 35.51 | 46.00 |
-| | | Table 12: Expanded | Open-source | LLMs results | on |
-OmanicBench.
+Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023
+
+A APPENDIX
+
+A.1 ADDITIONAL EXPERIMENT RESULTS
+
+A.1.1 ROBUSTNESS TO SAMPLING STRATEGIES AND PARAMETERS
+
+In Figure 6 we ablate the results with respect to different sampling strategies and parameters by
+varying T in temperature sampling and k in Top-k sampling, on LaMDA-137B. We show that
+self-consistency is robust to various sampling strategies and parameters.
+
+Figure 6: GSM8K accuracy over LaMDA-137B. Self-consistency works under various sampling
+strategies and sampling parameters.
+
+In Figure 7 and Figure 8, we show the results of self-consistency compared with greedy decoding a
+single path over LaMDA-137B and PaLM-540B, respectively. Self-consistency improves over greedy
+decode by a quite significant margin on both models, on top of high accuracy already achieved by
+scaling up model sizes.
+
+Figure 7: Self-consistency (blue) significantly improves accuracy across various arithmetic and
+commonsense reasoning tasks, over LaMDA-137B. Sampling a higher number of diverse reasoning
+paths consistently improves reasoning accuracy.
+
+We further show additional sampled reasoning paths from the LaMDA-137B model in Table 12, and
+sampled reasoning paths from the PaLM-540B model in Table 13. We see that the diversity in the
+additionally sampled reasoning paths indeed helps the model arrive at a more correct final answer
+after aggregation.
+
+A.1.2 ROBUSTNESS TO DIFFERENT SETS OF PROMPTS
+
+In Table 9, we further show that self-consistency is quite robust to different sets of input prompts.
+We manually wrote 3 different sets of chain-of-thought as prompts to the model. Across all sets of
+prompts, self-consistency yields consistent gains over the original CoT approach.
+
+A.1.3 COMPARED TO MODEL ENSEMBLES
+
+Additionally, we provide results of directly ensembling the outputs from multiple language models.
+The results are shown in Table 10, by greedily decoding sequences from 3 language models and
+
16
-B.3 FullresultsonKnowledgeFloorandthe
-ErrorPropagation
-For the step-wise error rates under chain evalua-
-tion,weexcludesingle-hopquestionsthatcanbe
-answeredwithoutrelyingonprecedingsteps,since
-theydonotreflectdependency-sensitiveerrorprop-
-agation. Forexample,undertheBridgetopology,
-thethirdhopisomittedbecauseitcanbeanswered
-independentlyofearlierhops.
-Figure11: Multi-hopaccuracybynumberofsingle-hop
-errorsforGPT-4o.
-Figure9: Multi-hopaccuracybynumberofsingle-hop
-errorsforGPT-5.2.
-Figure12: Multi-hopaccuracybynumberofsingle-hop
-errorsforGPT-5.4.
-Figure10: Multi-hopaccuracybynumberofsingle-hop
-errorsforGPT-5.1.
-Figure13: Multi-hopaccuracybynumberofsingle-hop
-errorsforClaude-Sonnet-4.5.
+481216202428323640#Sampled Reasoning Paths182022242628Accuracy (%)T=0.7, k=40T=0.5, k=40T=0.3, k=40T=0.5, k=20T=0.5, no top kGreedy Decode0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths505560657075Accuracy (%)MultiArith0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths4446485052545658ASDiv0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths3336394245485154SVAMP0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths1416182022242628GSM8KGreedy Decode (Single-path)Self Consistency (Multi-path)0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths56586062Accuracy (%)Commonsense QA0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths62636465666768Strategy QA0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths687072747678ARC (Easy)0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths505254565860ARC (Challenge)Greedy Decode (Single-path)Self Consistency (Multi-path)Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023
+
+Figure 8: Self-consistency (blue) significantly improves accuracy across various arithmetic and
+commonsense reasoning tasks, over PaLM-540B. Sampling a higher number of diverse reasoning
+paths consistently helps reasoning accuracy.
+
+Prompt set 1 (used in the main text)
+
+Prompt set 2
+
+Prompt set 3
+
+CoT (Wei et al., 2022)
+Self-consistency
+
+56.5
+74.4 (+17.9)
+
+54.6
+72.1 (+17.5)
+
+54.0
+70.4 (+16.4)
+
+Table 9: GSM8K accuracy over PaLM-540B. The results show robustness of self-consistency with
+respect to different prompts in the input.
+
+taking the majority vote (averaged over 10 runs). Note this is a typical ensemble approach (averaging
+over the predictions over multiple models) and it achieves a performance significantly worse than
+self-consistency (self-consistency over PaLM-540B gets an accuracy of 74.4%), as lower-capacity
+models drag down the performance of higher-capacity models. In addition, this approach is limited in
+two ways: 1) It requires multiple models for an ensemble which might not always be available, while
+self-consistency only requires one single model to “self-ensemble”; 2) If one of the models is much
+weaker, it can actually hurt the final performance.
+
+Method
+
+Single model
+
+PaLM-540B, greedy / self-consistency
+
+Ensemble of models
+
+LaMDA-137B + PaLM-540B
+PaLM-540B + GPT-3 (code-davinci-001, 175B)
+LaMDA-137B + GPT-3 (code-davinci-001, 175B)
+LaMDA-137B + PaLM-540B + GPT-3 (code-davinci-001, 175B)
+
+GSM8K accuracy
+
+56.5 / 74.4
+
+36.9 ± 0.5
+36.6 ± 0.4
+16.0 ± 0.8
+33.3 ± 0.7
+
+Table 10: Comparison of GSM8K accuracy over multiple-model ensembles.
+
+A.1.4 COMBINING SELF-CONSISTENCY WITH OTHER ENSEMBLING STRATEGIES
+
+Self-consistency is completely compatible with other ensemble strategies, although the gains achieved
+by self-consistency are significantly higher than other ensemble strategies (and can “override” the
+performance gains achieved by other ensemble strategies). We further performed experiments and
+include the results in Table 11 (for a fair comparison, we use 40 sets of prompts, or 40 prompt
+permutations to compare with self-consistency with 40 paths, all experiments are based on PaLM-
+540B).
+
17
-Figure14: Multi-hopaccuracybynumberofsingle-hop Figure17: Multi-hopaccuracybynumberofsingle-hop
-errorsforClaude-Opus-4.5. errorsforClaude-Opus-4.
-Figure15: Multi-hopaccuracybynumberofsingle-hop Figure18: Multi-hopaccuracybynumberofsingle-hop
-errorsforClaude-Opus-4.1. errorsforClaude-Sonnet-4.6.
-Figure16: Multi-hopaccuracybynumberofsingle-hop Figure19: Multi-hopaccuracybynumberofsingle-hop
-errorsforClaude-Sonnet-4. errorsforGemini-3-Flash-Preview.
+0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Chains8688909294Accuracy (%)AddSub0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Chains727476788082Accuracy (%)ASDiv0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Chains30333639424548Accuracy (%)AQuAGreedy Decode (Single-path)Self Consistency (Multi-path)0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Chains889092949698Accuracy (%)MultiArith0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Chains70.072.575.077.580.082.585.087.5Accuracy (%)SVAMP0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Chains505560657075Accuracy (%)GSM8KGreedy Decode (Single-path)Self Consistency (Multi-path)0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths7475767778798081Accuracy (%)Commonsense QA0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths7476788082Strategy QA0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths8890929496ARC (Easy)0510152025303540#Sampled Reasoning Paths788082848688ARC (Challenge)Greedy Decode (Single-path)Self Consistency (Multi-path)Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023
+
+GSM8K accuracy
+
+Different sets of prompts (x40)
+Prompt-permutation (x40)
+Self-consistency (x40)
+Self-consistency + different sets of prompts (x40)
+Self-consistency + prompt-permutation (x40)
+
+58.9
+59.6
+74.4
+75.4
+73.8
+
+Table 11: Combining self-consistency with other ensembling strategies.
+
+A.2 DETAILS ON RESOURCES AND INFERENCE
+
+For all four language models we perform prompting-based inference only. For UL2 we use TPU v3
+(2x2 configuration, 4 chips, 8 cores). For GPT-3 models the experiments are done though the public
+API.10 For LaMDA-137B we use TPU v3 (8x8 configuration, 64 chips, 128 cores). For PaLM-540B
+we use TPU v4 (4x4x12 configuration, 192 chips, 384 cores). Most inference jobs take 1 to 4 hours
+(over about 1,000 examples) for each task on UL2 and LaMDA-137B, and about 2 to 12 hours on
+PaLM-540B. Some tasks (e.g., commonsense reasoning) take longer but do not exceed 2 days for
+each task.
+
+For GPT-3 models, we use 128 max tokens for all methods, without frequency penalty or presence
+penalty. For all models, we take the generated outputs until the start of the next “Q:" to parse the final
+answers, consistent with our prompting format.
+
+Question
+
+Greedy Decode
+
+Sampled Path 1
+
+Sampled Path 2
+
+[MultiArith] Sam had 10 socks.
+If he threw away 3 old ones
+that didn’t fit and bought 36 new
+ones, how many socks would he
+have?
+
+Sam had 10 socks. He threw
+away 3 old ones that didn’t fit.
+He bought 36 new ones. That
+means he has 10 + 36 - 3 = 41
+socks. The answer is 41.
+
+[SVAMP] In a school there are
+697 girls and the rest are boys.
+If there are 228 more girls than
+boys. How many boys are there
+in that school?
+
+[AQuA] There are 10 oranges in
+a basket. Find the no. of ways in
+which 2 oranges are chosen from
+the basket? (a) 45 (b) 90 (c) 120
+(d) 150 (e) 180
+
+There are 697 girls and the rest
+are boys. That means there are
+697 + 228 = 925 girls. The
+rest are boys. So the number of
+boys is 925 - 697 = 228. The
+answer is 228.
+
+There are 10 oranges in a bas-
+ket.
+So there are 10 ways
+in which 2 oranges are chosen
+from the basket.
+
+[CommonsenseQA] The man
+laid on the soft moss and looked
+up at the trees, where was the
+man? (a) niagra falls (b) forest
+(c) waterfall (d) ground (e) tree
+
+The answer must be something
+that is soft and mossy. Of the
+above choices, only ground is
+soft and mossy. So the answer
+is (d).
+
+[ARC] Which of these will most
+likely harm a habitat? (a) plant-
+ing trees. (b) water pollution. (c)
+rainfall. (d) sunlight.
+
+Planting trees will not harm a
+habitat. So the answer is (a).
+
+[ARC-challenge] Which pro-
+cess in the carbon cycle takes the
+longest to complete? (a) emis-
+sion of waste. (b) respiration in
+animals.
+(c) photosynthesis in
+plants. (d) formation of fossil fu-
+els.
+
+The process of photosynthesis
+in plants takes the longest to
+complete. So the answer is (c).
+
+Sam had 10 socks. He
+threw away 3 old ones. So
+now he has 7 left. Then he
+bought 36 new ones. So
+now he has 7 + 36 = 43
+socks. The answer is 43.
+
+He had 10 socks. He threw away
+3 old ones that didn’t fit. He
+bought 36 new ones. So in total
+he has 10 - 3 + 36 = 43 socks. The
+answer is 43.
+
+The number of boys is the
+difference between 697
+and 228. This is 697 - 228
+= 469. The answer is 469.
+
+In the beginning there are 697
+girls and the rest are boys. So, the
+number of boys must be 697 - 228
+= 469 boys. The answer is 469.
+
+There are 10 oranges in a
+basket. We need to choose
+2 oranges from the basket.
+So the number of ways are
+10C2. So the answer is (a).
+
+The
+be
+answer must
+somewhere where moss
+is found. Of the above
+choices, only forests are
+known for having moss.
+So the answer is (b).
+
+The answer is (b), water
+pollution, because it will
+most likely harm the habi-
+tat. The other answers are
+not likely to harm the habi-
+tat.
+
+The formation of fossil fu-
+els takes the longest time
+to complete. So the an-
+swer is (d).
+
+There are 10 oranges in the bas-
+ket. If you choose 2 oranges, you
+have 10C2 = 45 ways of choosing
+2 oranges. So the answer is (a).
+
+The answer must be a place where
+the man is laying down and look-
+ing up at trees. Of the above
+is a place
+choices, only forest
+where people lay down and look
+at trees. So the answer is (b).
+
+The answer is (b), water pollution.
+Trees are good for a habitat, rain-
+fall is necessary for a habitat, and
+sunlight is necessary for a habitat.
+So the answer is (b).
+
+The process that takes the longest
+time to complete is the forma-
+tion of fossil fuels, which hap-
+pens over millions of years. So
+the answer is (d).
+
+Table 12: Additional examples where self-consistency helps repair the errors over greedy decode on
+LaMDA-137B. Two sampled reasoning paths that are consistent with the ground truth are shown.
+
+10https://beta.openai.com/docs/api-reference/making-requests
+
18
-Figure20: Multi-hopaccuracybynumberofsingle-hop Figure23: Multi-hopaccuracybynumberofsingle-hop
-errorsforGemini-2.5-Flash. errorsforQwen3-Max.
-Figure21: Multi-hopaccuracybynumberofsingle-hop Figure24: Step-wiseerrorratesunderindependentand
-errorsforGemini-2.5-Flash-Lite. chainevaluationforGPT-5.2.
-Figure22: Multi-hopaccuracybynumberofsingle-hop Figure25: Step-wiseerrorratesunderindependentand
-errorsforGemini-3.1-flash-lite. chainevaluationforGPT-5.1.
+Kyle bought a book that is sold
+for $19.50. With a 25% discount,
+the original price must be higher.
+If we call
+the original price x,
+then the discounted price is 0.75x.
+Since this is $19.50, we can write
+0.75x = 19.50. Solving this, we
+find that the original price is x =
+19.50 / 0.75 = $26. The answer is
+$26.
+
+The volume of the tank is 8 m *
+6 m * 2.5 m = 120 m3. One cu-
+bic meter contains 1000 litres, so
+the tank contains 120 m3 * 1000
+liters/m3 = 120,000 liters. So the
+answer is (d).
+
+Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023
+
+Question
+
+Greedy Decode
+
+Sampled Path 1
+
+Sampled Path 2
+
+[GSM8K] Kyle bought
+last
+year’s best-selling book for
+$19.50. This is with a 25% dis-
+count from the original price.
+What was the original price of
+the book?
+
+The book was sold for $19.50.
+This is 25% less than the origi-
+nal price. This means the original
+price was 100%. 25% of 100%
+is 25%.
+So the original price
+was 100% - 25% = 75%. The
+original price was 75% of $19.50.
+75% of $19.50 is 75% * $19.50 =
+$14.625. The answer is $14.625.
+
+The original price of the book
+is $19.50. Since it was dis-
+counted by 25%, the original
+price was 19.50 / 0.75 = 26.
+The answer is 26.
+
+The volume of the tank is 8 m *
+6 m * 2.5 m = 120 m3. So the
+capacity of the tank is 120 m3. So
+the answer is (c).
+
+The volume of the tank is 8m
+* 6m* 2.5m = 120m3. This is
+equal to 120000 litres. So the
+answer is (d)
+
+[AQuA] The capacity of a
+tank of dimensions (8 m x 6
+m x 2.5 m) is (a) 120 litres (b)
+1200 litres (c) 12000 litres (d)
+120000 litres (e) None of these
+
+no:
+[StrategyQA] Yes
+Can the Great Depression be
+treated with Prozac?
+
+or
+
+The Great Depression was an
+economic depression. Prozac is
+a drug used to treat depression.
+Thus, the Great Depression could
+be treated with Prozac. So the an-
+swer is yes.
+
+Prozac is an anti-depressant
+medication. The Great Depres-
+sion is not a disease. Thus,
+Prozac cannot treat the Great
+Depression. So the answer is
+no.
+
+The Great Depression is a time pe-
+riod. Prozac is used to treat de-
+pression (the mental illness). Thus,
+the Great Depression can not be
+treated with Prozac. So the answer
+is no.
+
+[ARC-easy] Which source of
+energy is nonrenewable? (a)
+coal.
+(c) water.
+(d) wood.
+
+(b) sunlight.
+
+Coal,
+sunlight, and water are
+all renewable sources of energy.
+Wood is a nonrenewable source of
+energy. So the answer is (d).
+
+Students
+[ARC-challenge]
+studied the revolution of Earth
+around the Sun. During which
+month will Florida have the
+most sunlight energy avail-
+able? (a) March. (b) June. (c)
+September. (d) December.
+
+The Earth is closest to the Sun
+in December, hence Florida will
+have the most sunlight energy
+available in December. So the an-
+swer is (d).
+
+A nonrenewable source of en-
+ergy is one in which the source
+is not replenished in a short
+amount of time. Thus, the only
+option that is nonrenewable is
+coal. So the answer is (a).
+
+Coal is a fossil fuel and is formed
+from dead organisms from the past.
+Coal cannot be produced in a short
+period of time, so it is considered
+a nonrenewable source of energy.
+So the answer is (a).
+
+Earth is closest to the Sun on
+June 21, the summer solstice.
+So the answer is (b).
+
+Florida is closer to the sun during
+June, so it will have the most sun-
+light energy during that month. So
+the answer is (b).
+
+Table 13: Additional examples where self-consistency helps repair the errors over greedy decode on
+PaLM-540B. Two sampled reasoning paths that are consistent with the ground truth are shown.
+
+A.3 FULL SETS OF PROMPTS
+
+We list the full details of the prompts used for two newly-introduced datasets, AQUA-RAT (Ling
+et al., 2017) and AI2 Reasoning Challenge (ARC) (Clark et al., 2018), where we manually composed
+the example chain-of-thought in this paper, in Table 14 and Table 15, respectively.
+
+Table 14: Few-shot exemplars for AQUA-RAT.
+Q: John found that the average of 15 numbers is 40. If 10 is added to each number then the mean of the
+numbers is? Answer Choices: (a) 50 (b) 45 (c) 65 (d) 78 (e) 64
+
+A: If 10 is added to each number, then the mean of the numbers also increases by 10. So the new mean
+would be 50. The answer is (a).
+
+Q: If a / b = 3/4 and 8a + 5b = 22,then find the value of a. Answer Choices: (a) 1/2 (b) 3/2 (c) 5/2 (d) 4/2 (e)
+7/2
+
+A: If a / b = 3/4, then b = 4a / 3. So 8a + 5(4a / 3) = 22. This simplifies to 8a + 20a / 3 = 22, which means
+44a / 3 = 22. So a is equal to 3/2. The answer is (b).
+
+Q: A person is traveling at 20 km/hr and reached his destiny in 2.5 hr then find the distance? Answer Choices:
+(a) 53 km (b) 55 km (c) 52 km (d) 60 km (e) 50 km
+
+A: The distance that the person traveled would have been 20 km/hr * 2.5 hrs = 50 km. The answer is (e).
+
+Q: How many keystrokes are needed to type the numbers from 1 to 500? Answer Choices: (a) 1156 (b) 1392
+(c) 1480 (d) 1562 (e) 1788
+
+A: There are 9 one-digit numbers from 1 to 9. There are 90 two-digit numbers from 10 to 99. There are 401
+three-digit numbers from 100 to 500. 9 + 90(2) + 401(3) = 1392. The answer is (b).
+
19
-Figure26: Step-wiseerrorratesunderindependentand Figure29: Step-wiseerrorratesunderindependentand
-chainevaluationforGPT-4o. chainevaluationforClaude-Opus-4.5.
-Figure27: Step-wiseerrorratesunderindependentand Figure30: Step-wiseerrorratesunderindependentand
-chainevaluationforGPT-5.4. chainevaluationforClaude-Opus-4.1.
-Figure28: Step-wiseerrorratesunderindependentand Figure31: Step-wiseerrorratesunderindependentand
-chainevaluationforClaude-Sonnet-4.5. chainevaluationforClaude-Sonnet-4.
+Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023
+
+Table 15: Few-shot exemplars for ARC easy/challenge.
+Q: George wants to warm his hands quickly by rubbing them. Which skin surface will produce the most
+heat? (a) dry palms. (b) wet palms. (c) palms covered with oil. (d) palms covered with lotion.
+
+A: Dry surfaces will more likely cause more friction via rubbing than other smoother surfaces, hence dry
+palms will produce the most heat. The answer is (a).
+
+Q: Which factor will most likely cause a person to develop a fever? (a) a leg muscle relaxing after exercise.
+(b) a bacterial population in the bloodstream. (c) several viral particles on the skin. (d) carbohydrates being
+digested in the stomach.
+
+A: Option (b), bacterial population is the most likely cause for a person developing fever. The answer is (b).
+
+Q: Which change in the state of water particles causes the particles to become arranged in a fixed position?
+(a) boiling. (b) melting. (c) freezing. (d) evaporating.
+
+A: When water is freezed, the particles are arranged in a fixed position; the particles are still moving for all
+other options. The answer is (c).
+
+Q: When a switch is used in an electrical circuit, the switch can (a) cause the charge to build. (b) increase
+and decrease the voltage. (c) cause the current to change direction. (d) stop and start the flow of current.
+
+A: The function of a switch is to start and stop the flow of a current. The answer is (d).
+
+Table 16: Few-shot exemplars for HotpotQA (closed-book setting).
+
+Q: Which magazine was started first Arthur’s Magazine or First for Women?
+
+A: Arthur’s Magazine started in 1844. First for Women started in 1989. So Arthur’s Magazine was started first.
+The answer is Arthur’s Magazine.
+
+Q: The Oberoi family is part of a hotel company that has a head office in what city?
+
+A: The Oberoi family is part of the hotel company called The Oberoi Group. The Oberoi Group has its head
+office in Delhi. The answer is Delhi.
+
+Q: What nationality was James Henry Miller’s wife?
+
+A: James Henry Miller’s wife is June Miller. June Miller is an American. The answer is American.
+
+Q: The Dutch-Belgian television series that "House of Anubis" was based on first aired in what year?
+
+A: "House of Anubis" is based on the Dutch–Belgian television series Het Huis Anubis. Het Huis Anubis is first
+aired in September 2006. The answer is 2006.
+
+As additional information, we also list the exact set of prompts used for all arithmetic reasoning tasks
+in Table 17, since there are multiple sets of prompts introduced in Wei et al. (2022). The prompts for
+CommonsenseQA and StrategyQA are the same as used in Wei et al. (2022).
+
+We provide the exact prompts used for common NLP tasks in the following tables as well, including
+NLI (Table 18, Table 19, Table 20) and Closed-Book Question-Answering tasks (Table 16, Table 21).
+
20
-Figure32: Step-wiseerrorratesunderindependentand Figure35: Step-wiseerrorratesunderindependentand
-chainevaluationforClaude-Opus-4. chainevaluationforGemini-2.5-Flash.
-Figure33: Step-wiseerrorratesunderindependentand Figure36: Step-wiseerrorratesunderindependentand
-chainevaluationforClaude-Sonnet-4.6. chainevaluationforGemini-2.5-Flash-Lite.
-Figure34: Step-wiseerrorratesunderindependentand Figure37: Step-wiseerrorratesunderindependentand
-chainevaluationforGemini-3-Flash-Preview. chainevaluationforGemini-3.1-flash-lite.
+Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023
+
+Table 17: Few-shot exemplars for all arithmetic reasoning tasks, from Wei et al. (2022).
+Q: There are 15 trees in the grove. Grove workers will plant trees in the grove today. After they are done,
+there will be 21 trees. How many trees did the grove workers plant today?
+
+A: We start with 15 trees. Later we have 21 trees. The difference must be the number of trees they planted.
+So, they must have planted 21 - 15 = 6 trees. The answer is 6.
+
+Q: If there are 3 cars in the parking lot and 2 more cars arrive, how many cars are in the parking lot?
+
+A: There are 3 cars in the parking lot already. 2 more arrive. Now there are 3 + 2 = 5 cars. The answer is 5.
+
+Q: Leah had 32 chocolates and her sister had 42. If they ate 35, how many pieces do they have left in total?
+
+A: Leah had 32 chocolates and Leah’s sister had 42. That means there were originally 32 + 42 = 74
+chocolates. 35 have been eaten. So in total they still have 74 - 35 = 39 chocolates. The answer is 39.
+
+Q: Jason had 20 lollipops. He gave Denny some lollipops. Now Jason has 12 lollipops. How many lollipops
+did Jason give to Denny?
+
+A: Jason had 20 lollipops. Since he only has 12 now, he must have given the rest to Denny. The number of
+lollipops he has given to Denny must have been 20 - 12 = 8 lollipops. The answer is 8.
+
+Q: Shawn has five toys. For Christmas, he got two toys each from his mom and dad. How many toys does
+he have now?
+
+A: He has 5 toys. He got 2 from mom, so after that he has 5 + 2 = 7 toys. Then he got 2 more from dad, so
+in total he has 7 + 2 = 9 toys. The answer is 9.
+
+Q: There were nine computers in the server room. Five more computers were installed each day, from
+monday to thursday. How many computers are now in the server room?
+
+A: There are 4 days from monday to thursday. 5 computers were added each day. That means in total 4 * 5 =
+20 computers were added. There were 9 computers in the beginning, so now there are 9 + 20 = 29 computers.
+The answer is 29.
+
+Q: Michael had 58 golf balls. On tuesday, he lost 23 golf balls. On wednesday, he lost 2 more. How many
+golf balls did he have at the end of wednesday?
+
+A: Michael initially had 58 balls. He lost 23 on Tuesday, so after that he has 58 - 23 = 35 balls. On
+Wednesday he lost 2 more so now he has 35 - 2 = 33 balls. The answer is 33.
+
+Q: Olivia has $23. She bought five bagels for $3 each. How much money does she have left?
+
+A: She bought 5 bagels for $3 each. This means she spent 5 * $3 = $15 on the bagels. She had $23 in
+beginning, so now she has $23 - $15 = $8. The answer is 8.
+
21
-Figure38: Step-wiseerrorratesunderindependentand
-chainevaluationforQwen3-Max.
-22
\ No newline at end of file
+Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023
+
+Table 18: Few-shot exemplars for ANLI.
+
+Premise:
+"Conceptually cream skimming has two basic dimensions - product and geography."
+Based on this premise, can we conclude the hypothesis "Product and geography are what make cream skimming
+work." is true?
+OPTIONS:
+- yes
+- no
+- it is not possible to tell
+
+A: Based on "cream skimming has two basic dimensions" we can’t infer that these two dimensions are what
+make cream skimming work. The answer is it is not possible to tell.
+
+Premise:
+"One of our member will carry out your instructions minutely."
+Based on this premise, can we conclude the hypothesis "A member of my team will execute your orders with
+immense precision." is true?
+OPTIONS:
+- yes
+- no
+- it is not possible to tell
+
+A: "one of" means the same as "a member of", "carry out" means the same as "execute", and "minutely" means
+the same as "immense precision". The answer is yes.
+
+Premise:
+"Fun for adults and children."
+Based on this premise, can we conclude the hypothesis "Fun for only children." is true?
+OPTIONS:
+- yes
+- no
+- it is not possible to tell
+
+A: "adults and children" contradicts "only children". The answer is no.
+
+Premise:
+"He turned and smiled at Vrenna."
+Based on this premise, can we conclude the hypothesis "He smiled at Vrenna who was walking slowly behind
+him with her mother." is true?
+OPTIONS:
+- yes
+- no
+- it is not possible to tell
+
+A: the premise does not say anything about "Vrenna was walking". The answer is it is not possible to tell.
+
+Premise:
+"well you see that on television also"
+Based on this premise, can we conclude the hypothesis "You can see that on television, as well." is true?
+OPTIONS:
+- yes
+- no
+- it is not possible to tell
+
+A: "also" and "as well" mean the same thing. The answer is yes.
+
+Premise:
+"Vrenna and I both fought him and he nearly took us."
+Based on this premise, can we conclude the hypothesis "Neither Vrenna nor myself have ever fought him." is
+true?
+OPTIONS:
+- yes
+- no
+- it is not possible to tell
+
+A: "Vrenna and I both" contradicts "neither Vrenna nor myself". The answer is no.
+
+22
+
+Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023
+
+Table 19: Few-shot exemplars for e-SNLI (the rationales are crowd-sourced annotations from the
+original dataset).
+
+Premise:
+"A person on a horse jumps over a broken down airplane."
+Based on this premise, can we conclude the hypothesis "A person is training his horse for a competition." is true?
+OPTIONS:
+- yes
+- no
+- it is not possible to tell
+A: The person is not necessarily training his horse. The answer is it is not possible to tell.
+
+Premise:
+"A person on a horse jumps over a broken down airplane."
+Based on this premise, can we conclude the hypothesis "A person is at a diner, ordering an omelette." is true?
+OPTIONS:
+- yes
+- no
+- it is not possible to tell
+A: One jumping horse cannot be in a diner ordering food. The answer is no.
+
+Premise:
+"A person on a horse jumps over a broken down airplane."
+Based on this premise, can we conclude the hypothesis "A person is outdoors, on a horse." is true?
+OPTIONS:
+- yes
+- no
+- it is not possible to tell
+A: A broken down airplane is outdoors. The answer is yes.
+
+Premise:
+"Children smiling and waving at camera."
+Based on this premise, can we conclude the hypothesis "They are smiling at their parents." is true?
+OPTIONS:
+- yes
+- no
+- it is not possible to tell
+A: Just because they are smiling and waving at a camera does not imply their parents or anyone is anyone behind
+it. The answer is it is not possible to tell.
+
+Premise:
+"Children smiling and waving at camera."
+Based on this premise, can we conclude the hypothesis "The kids are frowning." is true? OPTIONS:
+- yes
+- no
+- it is not possible to tell
+A: One cannot be smiling and frowning at the same time. The answer is no.
+
+Premise:
+"Children smiling and waving at camera."
+Based on this premise, can we conclude the hypothesis "There are children present." is true?
+OPTIONS:
+- yes
+- no
+- it is not possible to tell
+A:The children must be present to see them smiling and waving. The answer is yes.
+
+23
+
+Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023
+
+Table 20: Few-shot exemplars for RTE.
+
+Premise:
+"No Weapons of Mass Destruction Found in Iraq Yet."
+Based on this premise, can we conclude the hypothesis "Weapons of Mass Destruction Found in Iraq." is true?
+
+A: "No Weapons of Mass Destruction Found" contradicts "Weapons of Mass Destruction Found". The answer is
+no.
+
+Premise:
+"A place of sorrow, after Pope John Paul II died, became a place of celebration, as Roman Catholic faithful
+gathered in downtown Chicago to mark the installation of new Pope Benedict XVI."
+Based on this premise, can we conclude the hypothesis "Pope Benedict XVI is the new leader of the Roman
+Catholic Church." is true?’
+
+A: "installation of new Pope Benedict XVI." means "Pope Benedict XVI is the new leader". The answer is yes.
+
+Premise:
+"A man is due in court later charged with the murder 26 years ago of a teenager whose case was the first to
+be featured on BBC One’s Crimewatch. Colette Aram, 16, was walking to her boyfriend’s house in Keyworth,
+Nottinghamshire, on 30 October 1983 when she disappeared. Her body was later found in a field close to her
+home. Paul Stewart Hutchinson, 50, has been charged with murder and is due before Nottingham magistrates
+later."
+Based on this premise, can we conclude the hypothesis "Paul Stewart Hutchinson is accused of having stabbed a
+girl." is true?
+
+A: The premise does not say Paul Stewart Hutchinson "stabbed" this girl. The answer is no.
+
+Premise:
+"Herceptin was already approved to treat the sickest breast cancer patients, and the company said, Monday, it
+will discuss with federal regulators the possibility of prescribing the drug for more breast cancer patients."
+Based on this premise, can we conclude the hypothesis "Herceptin can be used to treat breast cancer." is true?
+
+A: "Herceptin was approved to treat breast cancer" implies that "Herceptin can be used to treat breast cancer".
+The answer is yes.
+
+Table 21: Few-shot exemplars for BoolQ (closed-book setting).
+
+Q: does system of a down have 2 singers?
+
+A: System of a Down currently consists of Serj Tankian, Daron Malakian, Shavo Odadjian and John Dolmayan.
+Serj and Daron do vocals, so the band does have two singers. The answer is yes.
+
+Q: do iran and afghanistan speak the same language?
+
+A: Iran and Afghanistan both speak the Indo-European language Persian. The answer is yes.
+
+Q: is a cello and a bass the same thing?
+
+A: The cello is played sitting down with the instrument between the knees, whereas the double bass is played
+standing or sitting on a stool. The answer is no.
+
+Q: can you use oyster card at epsom station?
+
+A: Epsom railway station serves the town of Epsom in Surrey and is not in the London Oyster card zone. The
+answer is no.
+
+24
+
diff --git a/q12/random_k2/question.json b/q12/random_k2/question.json
index 3f778059aa9be022e15d3d50fdbcdde4f37b0d57..b9e4df8d0f0b17f4ee46bc2963929cf97620473e 100644
--- a/q12/random_k2/question.json
+++ b/q12/random_k2/question.json
@@ -15,8 +15,8 @@
],
"original_filenames": [
"2401.18059v1.pdf",
- "web_c83d6885217d96f0.pdf",
- "web_ffc784688ff74004.pdf"
+ "web_f77c9a6a0c40e754.pdf",
+ "resize_r1_31.pdf"
],
"modality": "markdown"
}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/q12/random_k2/random_1.md b/q12/random_k2/random_1.md
index dd5d594edac856e6a90c63c0d5c3c52351225e37..e93939cddbb26da056c6d4cb5d86060af787292b 100644
--- a/q12/random_k2/random_1.md
+++ b/q12/random_k2/random_1.md
@@ -1,771 +1,979 @@
-1
-PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-2024 PEW RESEARCH CENTER’S AMERICAN TRENDS PANEL
-WAVE 159 POLITICS SURVEY NOVEMBER 2024
-FINAL TOPLINE
-NOVEMBER 12-17, 2024
-N=9,609
-Note: This survey was conducted primarily online, with some interviews conducted by live telephone. This
-topline shows the programming language for online administration. For details on how questions were slightly
-modified for phone administration, visit the questionnaire.
-American Trends Panel surveys conducted between October 2016 and June 2024 were conducted fully online
-(with tablets and data plans provided to adults without home internet). American Trends Panel surveys
-conducted prior to October 2016 were conducted primarily online, with some respondents completing by mail.
-For additional details, refer to the methodology.
-* “No answer” includes web respondents who do not answer the question as well as telephone respondents
-who refuse to answer or who say that they don’t know how to answer. In cases where “not sure” was offered
-as an explicit option to web and telephone respondents, the “no answer” category includes only web skips and
-telephone refusals.
-In addition to the parameters used in weighting each wave of the American Trends Panel, the results of this
-survey were weighted to the 2024 presidential popular vote and turnout among the voting-eligible population
-(as of Nov. 18, 2024). For additional information, refer to the methodology.
-ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS PREVIOUSLY RELEASED
-ASK ALL CITIZENS (XCITIZEN=1) [N=9,302]:
-VOTED Which of the following statements best describes you?
-Nov 29-
-Nov 12-17, Nov 16-27, Nov 12-17, Nov 7-16, Dec 12,
-2024 20221 2020 2018 2016
-I did not vote in the November
-22 2024 election 32 22 23 14
-13 I planned to vote but wasn’t able to 20 9 22 8
-I definitely voted in the November
-65 2024 election 47 67 55 77
-1 No answer* 1 2 1 1
-1 In 2022 and 2018, this question was asked about that November’s congressional election. In 2020 and 2016, this question
-was asked about that November’s presidential election.
-www.pewresearch.org
+INTRODUCING THE WINDOWS AZURE
+PLATFORM
+
+DAVID CHAPPELL
+
+OCTOBER 2010
+
+SPONSORED BY MICROSOFT CORPORATION
+
+CONTENTS
+
+An Overview of the Windows Azure Platform ....................................................................................... 3
+
+Windows Azure ........................................................................................................................................ 4
+
+SQL Azure ................................................................................................................................................. 6
+
+Windows Azure AppFabric....................................................................................................................... 8
+
+Windows Azure MarketPlace .................................................................................................................. 9
+
+A Closer Look at the Technologies ....................................................................................................... 10
+
+Windows Azure ...................................................................................................................................... 10
+
+Compute ............................................................................................................................................ 11
+
+Storage .............................................................................................................................................. 12
+
+Fabric Controller ................................................................................................................................ 14
+
+Content Delivery Network ................................................................................................................. 14
+
+Connect ............................................................................................................................................. 15
+
+SQL Azure ............................................................................................................................................... 15
+
+Database ........................................................................................................................................... 15
+
+Reporting ........................................................................................................................................... 17
+
+Data Sync .......................................................................................................................................... 17
+
+Windows Azure AppFabric..................................................................................................................... 19
+
+Service Bus ........................................................................................................................................ 19
+
+Access Control ................................................................................................................................... 21
+
+Caching .............................................................................................................................................. 23
+
+Windows Azure Marketplace ................................................................................................................ 24
+
+Looking Ahead .................................................................................................................................... 26
+
+Conclusions ......................................................................................................................................... 26
+
+About the Author ................................................................................................................................ 27
2
-PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-ASK IF VOTED (VOTED=3) [N=8,072]:
-VOTEGEN_POST In the 2024 presidential election, who did you vote for? [RANDOMIZE OPTIONS 1 AND 2
-FIRST FOLLOWED BY RANDOMIZED OPTIONS 3,4,5,6,7 WITH OPTION 8 AND 9 ALWAYS LAST]
-Nov 12-17,
-| 2024 | | | | | | | | | |
-| ----- | ----------------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| 49 | Donald Trump, the Republican | | | | | | | | |
-| 47 | Kamala Harris, the Democrat | | | | | | | | |
-| * | Robert F. Kennedy Jr., a third party candidate | | | | | | | | |
-| * | Chase Oliver, the Libertarian Party candidate | | | | | | | | |
-| * | Jill Stein, the Green Party candidate | | | | | | | | |
-| * | Cornel West, a third party candidate | | | | | | | | |
-| * | Claudia De la Cruz, the Socialism and Liberation Party candidate | | | | | | | | |
-| * | Another candidate | | | | | | | | |
-| 2 | I did not vote for a candidate for president | | | | | | | | |
-| * | No answer* | | | | | | | | |
-
-ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE
-
-ASK IF DID NOT VOTE (VOTED=1-2) [N=1,201]:
-| WISH_VOTED | Do you wish that you had voted in the election? | | | | | | | | |
-| ----------- | ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-
-| | | | | | | Nov 29- | | Nov 17- | |
-| ----------- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | -------- | --- |
-| Nov 12-17, | | Nov 12-17, | | Nov 7-16, | | Dec 12 | | Dec 15, | |
-| 2024 | | 2020 | | 2018 | | 2016 | | 2014 | |
-| 42 | Yes | | 45 | 61 | | 44 | | 55 | |
-| 57 | No | | 54 | 38 | | 55 | | 43 | |
-| 1 | No answer* | | 1 | | 1 | * | | 1 | |
-
-ASK IF CITIZEN AND DID NOT VOTE (X_CITIZEN=1 AND VOTED=1,2) [N=1,201]:
-NOVOTERSN2 There are lots of different reasons why many people don’t vote. For you personally,
-how much of a reason, if at all, is each of the following for why you did not vote?
-[RANDOMIZE]
-
-| | | | Major | | Minor | | Not a | | No |
-| ----- | ------------------------------------ | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | --- | -------- |
-| | | | reason | | reason | | reason | | answer* |
-| DIFF | I didn’t think my vote would make a | | | | | | | | |
-difference
-| | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | 35 | | | 26 | 39 | | 1 |
-| ----- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | Nov 7-16, 2018 | | 21 | | | 23 | 55 | | 1 |
-| | | | | | | | | | |
-| CARE | I didn’t care who won2 | | | | | | | | |
-| | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | 17 | | | 21 | 61 | | 1 |
-| | Nov 7-16, 2018 | | 12 | | | 23 | 64 | | 1 |
-| | | | | | | | | | |
-| ELGB | I’m not registered or not eligible to | | | | | | | | |
- vote
-| | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | 18 | | | 15 | 66 | | 1 |
-| ----- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | Nov 7-16, 2018 | | 19 | | | 10 | 70 | | 1 |
-| | | | | | | | | | |
-| INCV | It was too inconvenient for me to vote | | | | | | | | |
-| | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | 15 | | | 22 | 62 | | 1 |
-| | Nov 7-16, 2018 | | 20 | | | 21 | 59 | | 1 |
-| | | | | | | | | | |
-
-2 In 2018, the reason was worded “I didn’t care who won the congressional election in my area.”
-www.pewresearch.org
-3
-PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-| NOVOTERSN2 CONTINUED … | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| ----------------------- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | ------ | --- | ------- | -------- | --- |
-| | | | | Major | | | Minor | | Not a | No | |
-| | | | | reason | | reason | | | reason | answer* | |
-| LIKE | | I don’t like politics | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | 31 | | | 25 | | 43 | 1 | |
-| | | Nov 7-16, 2018 | | 26 | | | 23 | | 50 | 1 | |
-| | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| FRGT | | I forgot to vote | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | 8 | | 13 | | 79 | 1 | |
-| | | Nov 7-16, 2018 | | | 7 | | 15 | | 77 | 1 | |
-| | | | | | | | | | | | |
-
-ASK IF VOTED TRUMP (VOTEGEN_POST=1) [N=3,536]:
-DTFORAGNST_POST Would you say that your vote for Trump was more a vote…
-ASK IF VOTED HARRIS (VOTEGEN_POST=2) [N=4,185]:
-KHFORAGNST_POST Would you say that your vote for Harris was more a vote…
-
-BASED ON VOTERS [N=8,072]:
-
-| | | | | | | Based on registered voters | | | | | |
-| ------------- | ----------- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --------------------------- | ------ | --- | -------------- | --- | --- |
-| | Nov 12-17, | | | | | Sep 30-Oct 6, | | | Aug 26-Sep 2, | | |
-| | 2024 | | | | | | 20243 | | 2024 | | |
-| | 49 | | Trump | | | | 47 | | 49 | | |
-| | 40 | | For Trump | | | | 31 | | 33 | | |
-| | 9 | | Against Harris | | | | 15 | | 16 | | |
-| | * | | Refused | | | | * | | * | | |
-| 47 | | | Harris | | | | 48 | | 49 | | |
-| | 23 | | For Harris | | | | 23 | | 24 | | |
-| | 24 | | Against Trump | | | | 25 | | 25 | | |
-| | * | | Refused | | | | * | | * | | |
-| | 2 | | Vote for Kennedy Jr./Oliver/Stein/West/De | | | | - | | - | | |
-La Cruz/Another candidate
-| | 2 | | I did not vote for a candidate for president | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | * | | No answer* | | | | * | | * | | |
-
-| | | 2020 TREND FOR COMPARISON: | | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | Would you say that your vote for Trump was more a vote… | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | Would you say that your vote for Biden was more a vote… | | | | | | | | | |
-
-| | | | | | Based on voters | | | | Based on registered voters | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | ---------------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | --------------------------- | --- | ----------- |
-| | | | | | | Nov 12-17, | | Sep 30-Oct 5, | | | Jun 16-22, |
-| | | | | | | 2020 | | | 20204 | | 2020 |
-| | | | Trump | | | 47 | | | 42 | | 44 |
-| | | | For Trump | | | 36 | | | 30 | | 33 |
-| | | | Against Biden | | | 11 | | | 12 | | 10 |
-| | | | Biden | | | 51 | | | 52 | | 54 |
-| | | | For Biden | | | 24 | | | 19 | | 18 |
-| | | | Against Trump | | | 28 | | | 33 | | 36 |
-| | | | Vote for Jorgensen/Hawkins/Another | | | 1 | | | - | | - |
-candidate
-| | | | No answer | | | * | | | * | | - |
-| --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+AN OVERVIEW OF THE WINDOWS AZURE PLATFORM
+
+Using computers in the cloud can make lots of sense. Rather than buying and maintaining your own
+machines, why not exploit the acres of Internet-accessible servers on offer today? For some applications,
+both code and data might live in the cloud, where somebody else manages and maintains the systems
+they use. Alternatively, applications that run inside an organization—on-premises applications—might
+store data in the cloud or rely on other cloud infrastructure services. However it’s done, exploiting the
+cloud’s capabilities can improve our world.
+
+But whether an application runs in the cloud, uses services provided by the cloud, or both, some kind of
+application platform is required. Viewed broadly, an application platform can be thought of as anything
+that provides developer-accessible services for creating applications or storing data. In the on-premises
+Windows world, this includes technologies such as Windows Server and SQL Server. To let applications
+exploit the cloud, a cloud application platform must also exist.
+
+This is exactly what the Microsoft Windows Azure platform provides. It’s a group of cloud technologies,
+each providing a specific set of services to application developers. Figure 1 shows its components.
+
+Figure 1: The Windows Azure platform supports applications, data, and infrastructure in the cloud,
+together with a cloud marketplace.
+
+The Windows Azure platform today has four parts:
+
+ Windows Azure: A Windows environment for running applications and storing data on computers in
+
+Microsoft data centers.
+
+SQL Azure: Relational data services in the cloud based on SQL Server.
+
+ Windows Azure AppFabric: Cloud-based infrastructure services for applications running in the cloud
+
+or on premises.
3
-Trend for DTFORAGNST and KHFORAGNST asked prior to election combined those who said they were voting for the
-candidate or leaning toward the candidate. Postelection versions of these questions asked those who said they voted for
-Trump or Harris.
-4
-Trend for DTFORAGNST and JBFORAGNST asked prior to election combined those who said they were voting for the
-candidate or leaning toward the candidate. Postelection versions of these questions asked those who said they voted for
-Trump or Biden.
-www.pewresearch.org
+
+ Windows Azure Marketplace: An online service for purchasing cloud-based data and applications.
+
+All four of these components run in Microsoft data centers located around the world: two in North
+America, two in Europe, and two in Asia. Developers using the platform can control which data center
+runs their applications and stores their data, giving them the ability to place both closer to their users.
+
+Each part of the Windows Azure platform has its own role to play. This overview describes all four, first at
+a high level, then in a bit more detail. The goal is to provide a big-picture introduction to this cloud
+platform.
+
+WINDOWS AZURE
+
+At a high level, Windows Azure is simple to understand: It runs Windows applications and stores data in
+the cloud. Figure 2 shows its components.
+
+Figure 2: Windows Azure provides compute and storage services in the cloud.
+
+The five parts of Windows Azure today are the following:
+
+ Compute: The Windows Azure compute service runs applications on a Windows Server foundation.
+These applications can be created using the .NET Framework in languages such as C# and Visual Basic,
+or they can be built without .NET in C++, Java, and other languages. Developers can use Visual Studio
+or other development tools, and they’re free to use technologies such as ASP.NET, Windows
+Communication Foundation (WCF), and PHP.
+
+Storage: This service allows storing binary large objects (blobs), provides queues for communication
+between components of Windows Azure applications, and even offers a form of tables with a simple
+query language. (Windows Azure applications that need traditional relational storage can also use
4
-PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-ASK IF VOTED (VOTED=3) [N=8,072]:
-VOTEDECTIME As far as you can remember, when did you make up your mind about who you were going to
-vote for in the presidential election?
-BASED ON THOSE WHO SELECTED A CANDIDATE (VOTEGEN_POST=1-8) [N=7,977]
-Nov 29-
-Nov 12-17, Nov 12-17, Dec 12
-2024 2020 20165
-Last few days before Election
-4 Day 3 9
-The last week before Election
-3 Day 2 4
-7 In October 5 9
-6 In September 5 11
-81 Before September 84 67
-* No answer* * *
-PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON:
-When did you make up your mind definitely to vote for “Hillary Clinton;” “Donald Trump;” “Gary
-Johnson;” “Jill Stein,” “The candidate of your choice”?
-Nov 10-14 Nov 8-11 Nov Nov Nov Nov Nov
-2016 2012 2004 2000 1996 1992 1988
-On Election Day 4 4 4 5 6 9 6
-On Monday (day before the election) * 1 1 2 3 4 3
-Over the last weekend * 1 1 2 2 4 2
-In the last week 2 2 3 5 6 8 4
-In the last few weeks 5 -- -- -- -- -- --
-During or just after the Presidential debates 10 10 11 17 -- 12 --
-Before debates/after the Conventions 10 9 6 9 12 6 16
-Convention period (NET) 22 10 7 7 8 12 15
-During or after the Republican convention 13 9 1 4 -- -- --
-During or after the Democratic convention 9 1 6 3 -- -- --
-This year, before the conventions 22 16 23 21 13 18 19
-Before 2016 20 41 38 20 39 12 9
-Other -- 0 0 -- * 8 --
-Don’t remember 2 1 4 6 6 5 4
-Don’t know/Refused 1 4 2 3 2 1 2
-ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE
-5 In 2016, people who said “another candidate” were not asked this question; question read “As far as you can remember,
-when did you make up your mind definitely to vote for ‘Donald Trump;’ ‘Hillary Clinton;’ ‘Gary Johnson;’ ‘Jill Stein’?”
-www.pewresearch.org
+
+SQL Azure.) Both Windows Azure applications and on-premises applications can access the Windows
+Azure storage service, and both do it in the same way: using a RESTful approach.
+
+Fabric controller: As the figure suggests, Windows Azure runs on a large number of machines. The
+fabric controller’s job is to knit the machines in a single Windows Azure data center into a cohesive
+whole. The Windows Azure compute and storage services are then built on top of this pool of
+processing power.
+
+ Content delivery network (CDN): Caching frequently accessed data closer to its users speeds up
+access to that data. The Windows Azure CDN can do this for blobs, maintaining cached copies at sites
+around the world.
+
+ Connect: It’s often useful for organizations to interact with cloud applications as if they were inside
+the organization’s own firewall. Windows Azure Connect allows this, making it easier for, say, a
+Windows Azure application to access an on-premises database.
+
+Running applications and storing data in the cloud can have clear benefits. Rather than buying, installing,
+and operating its own systems, for example, an organization can rely on a cloud provider to do this for
+them. Also, customers pay just for the computing and storage they use, rather than maintaining a large
+set of servers only for peak loads. And applications written for Windows Azure can scale better, be more
+reliable, and require less administration than those written using the traditional Windows Server
+programming model.
+
+To create, configure, and monitor applications, Windows Azure customers can use a browser-accessible
+portal. A customer logs in with a Windows Live ID, then chooses whether to create a hosting account for
+running applications, a storage account for storing data, or both. Microsoft then charges each customer
+based on how much compute time, storage, and bandwidth that customer uses. How an application
+charges its own customers—if it charges them at all—is entirely up to the people who create that
+application.
+
+Windows Azure is a general platform that can be used in a broad set of scenarios. Here are a few
+examples:
+
+ An independent software vendor (ISV) creating a software-as-a-service (SaaS) version of an existing
+on-premises Windows application might choose to build it on Windows Azure. Because Windows
+Azure mostly provides a standard Windows environment, moving the application’s business logic to
+this cloud platform won’t typically pose many problems. And once again, building on an existing
+platform lets the ISV focus on business logic—the thing that makes them money—rather than
+spending time on infrastructure.
+
+ An enterprise creating an application for its customers or employees might choose to build it on
+Windows Azure. Because Windows Azure supports .NET, developers with the right skills aren’t
+difficult to find, nor are they prohibitively expensive. Running the application in Microsoft data
+centers frees the enterprise from the responsibility and expense of managing its own servers, turning
+capital expenses into operating expenses. And especially if the application has spikes in usage—
+maybe it’s an on-line flower store that must handle the Mother’s Day rush—letting Microsoft
+maintain the large server base required for this can make economic sense.
5
-PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-[RANDOMIZE ORDER OF VTADMIN_POST_COM AND VTADMIN_POST_US]
-
-ASK ALL:
-VTADMIN_POST_COM Do you think the elections this November in your community were run and
-administered…
-
-| Nov 12-17, | | | Nov 16-27, | | Nov 12-17, | | Nov 7-16, | | | |
-| ----------- | ---------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- |
-| 2024 | | | 2022 | | 2020 | | 2018 | | | |
-| 55 | Very well | | 42 | | 53 | | 49 | | | |
-| 35 | Somewhat well | | 42 | | 32 | | 38 | | | |
-| 7 | Not too well | | 9 | | 9 | | | 8 | | |
-| 2 | Not at all well | | 4 | | 6 | | | 4 | | |
-| 1 | No answer* | | 3 | | 1 | | | 1 | | |
-
-TREND FOR COMPARISON:
-Do you think the elections this November in your community will be run and administered…
-
-| | | | Sep 30-Oct 6, | | Oct 10-16, | | | Sep 30-Oct 5, | Sep 24-Oct 7, | |
-| --- | ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | -------------- | -------------- | ----- |
-| | | | 2024 | | | 2022 | | 2020 | | 2018 |
-| | Very well | | | 43 | | 40 | | 36 | | 41 |
-| | Somewhat well | | | 44 | | 45 | | 48 | | 46 |
-| | Not too well | | | 8 | | 10 | | 11 | | 9 |
-| | Not at all well | | | 4 | | 4 | | 4 | | 3 |
-| | No answer | | | 1 | | 1 | | * | | 1 |
-
-[RANDOMIZE ORDER OF VTADMIN_POST_COM AND VTADMIN_POST_US]
-
-ASK ALL:
-VTADMIN_POST_US Do you think the elections this November in the United States were run and
-administered…
-
-| Nov 12-17, | | Nov 16-27, | | Nov 12-17, | | | Nov 7-16, | | | |
-| ----------- | ---------------- | ----------- | ----- | ----------- | ----- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- |
-| 2024 | | | 2022 | | 2020 | | 2018 | | | |
-| 37 | Very well | | 25 | | 33 | | 21 | | | |
-| 47 | Somewhat well | | 46 | | 25 | | 53 | | | |
-| 11 | Not too well | | 18 | | 20 | | 18 | | | |
-| 4 | Not at all well | | 8 | | 22 | | 7 | | | |
-| 1 | No answer* | | 3 | | 1 | | 1 | | | |
-
-TREND FOR COMPARISON:
-Do you think the elections this November in the United States will be run and administered…
-
-| | | | Sep 30-Oct 6, | | Oct 10-16, | | | Sep 30-Oct 5, | Sep 24-Oct 7, | |
-| --- | ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | -------------- | -------------- | ----- |
-| | | | 2024 | | | 2022 | | 2020 | | 2018 |
-| | Very well | | | 20 | | 20 | | 12 | | 20 |
-| | Somewhat well | | | 50 | | 49 | | 46 | | 57 |
-| | Not too well | | | 21 | | 23 | | 30 | | 18 |
-| | Not at all well | | | 8 | | 7 | | 12 | | 4 |
-| | No answer | | | 1 | | 1 | | 1 | | 1 |
-
-| | | | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-www.pewresearch.org
+
+ A start-up creating a new Web site—the next Facebook, say—could build its application on Windows
+Azure. Because this platform supports both Web-facing services and background processes, the
+application can provide an
+interface as well as executing work for users
+asynchronously. Rather than spending time and money worrying about infrastructure, the start-up
+can instead focus solely on creating code that provides value to its customers and investors. The
+company can also start small, incurring low costs while its application has only a few users. If the
+application catches on and usage increases, Windows Azure can scale the application as needed.
+
+interactive user
+
+These three examples illustrate the kinds of things organizations might do with Windows Azure, but
+they’re not an exhaustive list. As interest in cloud computing continues to grow, expect to see a variety of
+applications created for this cloud platform.
+
+SQL AZURE
+
+Along with running applications, another attractive way to use the cloud is for storing data. SQL Azure
+addresses this area, offering cloud-based services for relational data. As Figure 3 shows, SQL Azure today
+includes three components.
+
+Figure 3: SQL Azure provides relational database services in the cloud.
+
+The components of SQL Azure today are the following:
+
+SQL Azure Database provides a cloud-based database management system (DBMS). This technology
+lets on-premises and cloud applications store relational data on Microsoft servers in Microsoft data
6
-PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-ASK IF VOTED (VOTED=3) [N=8,072]:
-VTEASY_POST Overall, was voting in the election this November for you personally... [ROTATE
-RESPONSES OPTIONS 1-4/4-1]
-
-| Nov 12-17, | | | | | Nov 12-17, | | | | | | |
-| ----------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| 2024 | | | | | | 2020 | | | | | |
-| | 79 | Very easy | | | | 77 | | | | | |
-| | 15 | Somewhat easy | | | | 17 | | | | | |
-| | 5 | Somewhat difficult | | | | 5 | | | | | |
-
-| | 2 | Very difficult | | | | 1 | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-
-| | * | No answer* | | | | * | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-
-TREND FOR COMPARISON:
-Overall, do you personally expect voting in the November elections to be...
-
-BASED ON REGISTERED VOTERS:
-
-| | | | | | | Sep 30- | Oct 10- | | Sep 30- | Jul 27- | Sep 24- |
-| --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | -------- | -------- | -------- |
-| | | | | | | Oct 6, | 16 | | Oct 5 | Aug 2 | Oct 7 |
-| | | | | | | 2024 | 2022 | | 2020 | 2020 | 2018 |
-| | | Very easy | | | | 43 | 45 | | 29 | 23 | 46 |
-| | | Somewhat easy | | | | 38 | 37 | | 36 | 28 | 39 |
-| | | Somewhat difficult | | | | 16 | 14 | | 29 | 38 | 13 |
-| | | Very difficult | | | | 4 | | 3 | 6 | 11 | 2 |
-| | | No answer | | | | * | | * | * | 1 | * |
-
-ASK ALL:
-SATCAND_POST Now that the campaign is over, how satisfied were you with the choice of presidential
-candidates? Would you say that you were…
-BASED ON VOTERS [N=8,072]:
-| Nov 12-17, | | | | | | Nov 12-17, | | | | | |
-| ----------- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| 2024 | | | | | | 2020 | | | | | |
-| | 32 | Very satisfied | | | | 30 | | | | | |
-| | 20 | Fairly satisfied | | | | 26 | | | | | |
-| | 22 | Not too satisfied | | | | 24 | | | | | |
-| | 25 | Not at all satisfied | | | | 19 | | | | | |
-| | * | No answer* | | | | * | | | | | |
-
- TREND FOR COMPARISON:
-What is your opinion of the presidential candidates for this year? Would you say that you are…
-
-BASED ON REGISTERED VOTERS:
-
-| | | | | | 2024 Election | | | | 2020 Election | | |
-| --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | -------------- | --------- | --- | --- | -------------- | ----------- | --- |
-| | | | | Aug 26- | | | | | Jul 27- | | |
-| | | | | Sep 2, | | Jul 1-7, | | | Aug 2, | Jun 16-22, | |
-| | | | | 2024 | | 2024 | | | 2020 | 2020 | |
-| | Very satisfied | | | | 15 | 11 | | | 15 | 16 | |
-| | Fairly satisfied | | | | 32 | 20 | | | 31 | 31 | |
-| | Not too satisfied | | | | 34 | 32 | | | 35 | 34 | |
-| | Not at all satisfied | | | | 17 | 37 | | | 19 | 19 | |
-| | No answer* | | | | 1 | | 1 | | 1 | 1 | |
-
-| | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-www.pewresearch.org
+
+centers. As with other cloud technologies, an organization pays only for what it uses, increasing and
+decreasing usage (and cost) as the organization’s needs change. Using a cloud database also allows
+converting what would be capital expenses, such as investments in disks and DBMS software, into
+operating expenses.
+
+SQL Azure Reporting is a version of SQL Server Reporting Services (SSRS) that runs in the cloud.
+Intended primarily for use with SQL Azure Database, it allows creating and publishing standard SSRS
+reports on cloud data.
+
+SQL Azure Data Sync allows synchronizing data between SQL Azure Database and on-premises SQL
+Server databases. It can also be used to synchronize data across different SQL Azure databases in
+different Microsoft data centers.
+
+SQL Azure is built on Microsoft SQL Server. As with SQL Server, developers can create indexes and views,
+use stored procedures, define triggers, and more. Applications can access SQL Azure data using Entity
+Framework, ADO.NET, and other Windows data access interfaces. In fact, applications that today access
+SQL Server locally will largely work unchanged with data in SQL Azure. Customers can also use on-
+premises software such as SQL Server Analysis Services to work with their cloud-based data.
+
+While applications can use SQL Azure much as they do a local DBMS, the management requirements are
+significantly reduced. Rather than worry about mechanics, such as monitoring disk usage and servicing log
+files, a SQL Azure customer can focus on their data; Microsoft handles the operational details. And as with
+other components of this cloud platform, customers use the common Windows Azure platform portal to
+access its services.
+
+Applications might use SQL Azure in a variety of ways. Here are some examples:
+
+ A Windows Azure application can store its data in SQL Azure. While Windows Azure provides its own
+storage, relational tables aren’t among the options it offers. Since many existing applications use
+relational storage and many developers know how to work with it, a significant number of Windows
+Azure applications rely on SQL Azure to work with data in this familiar way. For example, a SaaS
+application built on Windows Azure might create a separate SQL Azure database for each customer,
+providing an intrinsically multi-tenant design. And to improve performance, customers can specify
+that a particular Windows Azure application must run in the same data center in which SQL Azure
+Database stores that application’s information.
+
+ An application in a small business or a department of a larger organization might rely on SQL Azure.
+Rather than storing its data in a SQL Server or Access database running on a computer under
+somebody’s desk, the application can instead take advantage of the reliability and availability of cloud
+storage. It can also create reports on this data using either SQL Azure Reporting or SSRS on-premises.
+If the organization wishes to maintain an on-premises copy of the data as well, it can use SQL Azure
+Data Sync to synchronize the cloud and on-premises databases.
+
+Suppose a manufacturer wishes to make product information available both to its dealer network
+and directly to customers. Putting this data in SQL Azure would let it be accessed by applications
+running at the dealers and by a customer-facing Web application run by the manufacturer itself.
7
-PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-SATCAND_POST TREND FOR COMPARSION CONTINUED …
-PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON:
- Now that the campaign is over, how satisfied were you with the choice of presidential candidates?
+Whether it’s for supporting a Windows Azure application, making data more accessible, or other reasons,
+data services in the cloud can be attractive. The goal of SQL Azure is to provide these services in a familiar,
+usable way for cloud and on-premises applications.
+
+WINDOWS AZURE APPFABRIC
-BASED ON THOSE WHO VOTED:
+Running applications and storing data in the cloud are both important aspects of cloud computing.
+They’re far from the whole story, however. It’s also possible to provide cloud-based infrastructure
+services. Filling this gap is the goal of Windows Azure AppFabric.
-| | | | Nov 10-14, | | Nov 8-11, | | Nov Nov | | Nov Nov | Nov Nov |
-| --------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ----------- |
-| | | | 2016 | | 2012 | | 2008 2004 | | 2000 1996 | 1992 1988 |
-| Very satisfied | | | | 19 | 37 | | 39 | 33 | 24 18 | 24 26 |
-| Fairly satisfied | | | | 25 | 33 | | 28 | 33 | 44 33 | 37 36 |
-| Not very satisfied | | | | 26 | 16 | | 17 | 16 | 18 24 | 21 20 |
-| Not at all satisfied | | | | 29 | 12 | | 14 | 16 | 9 22 | 16 17 |
-| Don't | | | | 1 | 3 | | 2 | 2 | 5 3 | 2 1 |
-know/Refused
-(VOL.)
+The functions provided by AppFabric today address common challenges in building distributed
+applications. Figure 4 shows its components.
-[DISPLAY CMPGNTRAITPOST_PROUD, CMPGNTRAITPOST_NEG, CMPGNTRAITPOST_POLCY,
-CMPGNTRAITPOST_INT ON SAME PAGE; RANDOMIZE ORDER OF QUESTIONS; INCLUDE
-RANDOMIZATION IN DATA FILE. DO NOT RANDOMIZE RESPONSE OPTIONS WITHIN EACH
-QUESTION]
+Figure 4: Windows Azure AppFabric provides Windows Azure-based infrastructure services that can be
+used by both cloud and on-premises applications.
-ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,801]:
-CMPGNTRAITPOST_PROUD Would you say the 2024 presidential campaign was...
+As the figure suggests, all of the components of Windows Azure AppFabric are built on Windows Azure
+(although they don’t all provide services solely to Windows Azure applications). Those components are
+the following:
-BASED ON VOTERS [N=4,012]:
+Service Bus: Exposing an application’s services on the Internet is harder than it might seem. The goal
+of Service Bus is to make this simpler by letting an application expose endpoints in the cloud that can
+be accessed by other applications, whether on-premises or in the cloud. Each exposed endpoint is
+assigned a URI, which clients can use to locate and access the service. Service Bus also handles the
+challenges of dealing with network address translation and getting through firewalls without opening
+new ports for exposed applications.
-| | | | Made you feel proud | | | Did not make you feel | | | No | |
-| ---------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- |
-| | | | of the country | | | proud of the country | | | answer* | |
-| Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | | 29 | | | 70 | | 1 | |
+ Access Control: There are many ways for a user to get a digital identity today. The options include
+Active Directory, Windows Live ID, Google Accounts, Facebook, and more. If an application wants to
+let users log in with any of these, the application’s creator faces the daunting challenge of supporting
-| | | TREND FOR COMPARISON: | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | So far, would you say the 2024 presidential campaign… | | | | | | | | |
+8
-| | | BASED ON REGISTERED VOTERS: | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+this plethora of approaches. Access Control simplifies this by providing built-in support for all of them
+(and more). It also provides a single place for defining rules to control what each user is allowed to
+access.
-| | | | | | | Makes you feel proud | | Does not make you feel | | No |
-| --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | -------- |
-| | | | | | | of the country | | proud of the country | | answer* |
-| | | Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024 | | | | | 19 | | 79 | 2 |
-| | | Jul 1-7, 2024 | | | | | 12 | | 87 | 1 |
+ Caching: It’s common for applications to access the same data over and over. One way to speed up
+this kind of application is to cache frequently accessed information, reducing the number of times
+that application must query a database. The Caching service provides this—and the performance
+boost it brings—for Windows Azure applications.
-| | | | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-www.pewresearch.org
+Microsoft has announced plans to add more services under the Windows Azure AppFabric banner, so
+expect this list to grow in the not-too-distant future.
-8
-PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-
-ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,801]:
-CMPGNTRAITPOST_NEG Would you say the 2024 presidential campaign was...
-
-BASED ON VOTERS [N=4,012]:
-
-| | | | Too | | Not too | | No | | | | | |
-| ---------------- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | | negative | | negative | | answer* | | | | | |
-| Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | 74 | | 25 | | 1 | | | | | |
-
-| | | TREND FOR COMPARISON: | | | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | So far, would you say the 2024 presidential campaign… | | | | | | | | | | |
-
-| | | BASED ON REGISTERED VOTERS: | | | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | | Too | Not too | | No | |
-| | | | | | | | | negative | negative | | answer* | |
-| | | Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024 | | | | | | 71 | | 27 | | 2 |
-Jul 1-7, 2024
-| | | | | | | | | 68 | | 30 | | 2 |
-| --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | 2020 TREND FOR COMPARISON:6 | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | Nov 12-17, 2020 | | | | | | 76 | | 23 | | 1 |
-| | | July 27-Aug 2, 2020 | | | | | | 61 | | 37 | | 2 |
-
-ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,801]:
-CMPGNTRAITPOST_POLCY Would you say the 2024 presidential campaign was...
-
-BASED ON VOTERS [N=4,012]:
-
-| | | | Focused on important | | | Not focused on important | | | | No | | |
-| ---------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- |
-| | | | policy debates | | | | policy debates | | | answer* | | |
-| Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | | 35 | | | | 64 | | 1 | | |
-
-| | | TREND FOR COMPARISON: | | | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | So far, would you say the 2024 presidential campaign… | | | | | | | | | | |
-
-| | | BASED ON REGISTERED VOTERS: | | | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-
-| | | | | | | | | Focused on | | Not focused on | | |
-| --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | -------- |
-| | | | | | | | | important | | important | | No |
-| | | | | | | | | policy debates | | policy debates | | answer* |
-| | | Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024 | | | | | | 37 | | | 62 | 1 |
-| | | Jul 1-7, 2024 | | | | | | 23 | | | 76 | 1 |
-
-| | | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | 2020 TREND FOR COMPARISON:7 | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | Nov 12-17, 2020 | | | | | | 27 | | | 72 | 1 |
-| | | July 27-Aug 2, 2020 | | | | | | 25 | | | 73 | 2 |
-
-| | | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-
-6 Question asked about the 2020 presidential campaign.
-7 Question asked about the 2020 presidential campaign.
-www.pewresearch.org
+As with Windows Azure and SQL Azure, customers use a browser-accessible portal to sign up for
+AppFabric. Once this has been done, these services can be used in a variety of ways. Here are some of the
+possibilities:
+
+Suppose an enterprise wished to let software at its trading partners access one of its applications. It
+could expose this application’s functions through SOAP or RESTful services created using WCF, then
+register those service endpoints with Service Bus. Its trading partners could then use Service Bus to
+find these endpoints and access the services.
+
+Imagine that the creator of this same application needs to let trading partners log in with a variety of
+different identities. Rather than implementing support for these identities himself, he could use the
+Access Control service to hide this complexity.
+
+ A Windows Azure application created using ASP.NET might use the Session object to store per-client
+state. By changing only a configuration setting, the application can cause this data to be kept in the
+Caching service rather than, say, Windows Azure Storage tables. Doing this is likely to make the
+application faster and more scalable.
+
+Along with the cloud-based services of Windows Azure AppFabric, Microsoft also provides an analogous
+technology known as Windows Server AppFabric. As its name suggests, the services it provides run on
+Windows Server—they support on-premises applications—rather than in the cloud. The on-premises
+services aren’t exactly the same today as those in Windows Azure AppFabric (although Microsoft’s
+announced plan is make the two congruent). Don’t be confused; throughout this paper, the name
+“AppFabric” is used to refer to the cloud-based services. Also, don’t confuse Windows Azure AppFabric
+with the Windows Azure fabric controller. Even though both contain the term “fabric”, they’re wholly
+separate technologies addressing quite distinct problems.
+
+WINDOWS AZURE MARKETPLACE
+
+In the on-premises world, many applications are purchased rather than custom-built. Many organizations
+also rely on datasets from commercial providers. With the rise of the cloud, why not let customers find
+and buy cloud applications and cloud-accessible data? Making this possible is the goal of Windows Azure
+Marketplace. Figure 5 shows its two components.
9
-PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-
-ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,801]:
-CMPGNTRAITPOST_INT Would you say the 2024 presidential campaign was...
-
-BASED ON VOTERS [N=4,012]:
-
-| | | | | No | | | | | | |
-| ---------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | | Interesting | Dull answer* | | | | | | |
-| Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | 74 | 24 2 | | | | | | |
-
-| | | TREND FOR COMPARISON: | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | So far, would you say the 2024 presidential campaign… | | | | | | | | |
-
-| | | BASED ON REGISTERED VOTERS: | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | ----- | --- | -------- |
-| | | | | | | | | | | No |
-| | | | | | Interesting | | | Dull | | answer* |
-| | | Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024 | | | | 68 | | 30 | | 2 |
-| | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | 2020 TREND FOR COMPARISON8 | | | | | | | | |
-| | | Nov 12-17, 2020 | | | | 64 | | 34 | | 2 |
-| | | July 27-Aug 2, 2020 | | | | 39 | | 59 | | 2 |
-
-ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS PREVIOUSLY RELEASED
-
-ASK IF VOTED (VOTED=3) [N=8,072]:
-| VOTE_HOW_POST | | | How did you vote in the election? [RANDOMIZE] | | | | | | | |
-| -------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-ASK IF VOTED IN PERSON (VOTE_HOW_POST=1) [N=5,196]:
-| VOTEINPWHEN | | When did you vote? | | | | | | | | |
-| ------------ | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-
-| Nov 12-17, | | | | | | Nov 16-27, | | | Nov 12-17, | |
-| ----------- | ----- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | ----------- | --- |
-| | 2024 | | | | | | 2022 | | 2020 | |
-| | 65 | In person at a polling place | | | | | 65 | | 54 | |
-| | 34 | On Election Day | | | | | 44 | | | 27 |
-| | 32 | Before Election Day | | | | | 21 | | | 27 |
-| | * | Refused | | | | | * | | | * |
-| | 35 | By absentee or mail-in ballot | | | | | 35 | | 46 | |
-| | * | No answer* | | | | | * | | | * |
-
-TREND FOR COMPARISON:
-When did you vote in the elections this November?
-How did you vote in the November election?
-
-| | | | | | | Nov 7-16, | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-2018
-| | | On election day | | | | | 55 | | | |
-| --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | Before election day | | | | | 45 | | | |
-| | | Voted in person | | | | | 19 | | | |
-| | | Mailed in ballot | | | | | 25 | | | |
-| | | No answer | | | | | * | | | |
-| | | No answer | | | | | * | | | |
-| | | | | | | | | | | |
-
-| | | | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-
-8 Question asked about the 2020 presidential campaign.
-www.pewresearch.org
+
+Figure 5: Windows Azure Marketplace provides an online marketplace for cloud applications and data.
+
+The two parts of Windows Azure Marketplace are:
+
+ DataMarket (originally codenamed “Dallas”), providing a way for content providers to make datasets
+available. Customers can browse the offerings, then purchase whatever they find useful. Applications,
+both custom and off-the-shelf (such as Microsoft Excel), can then access this data through RESTful
+requests or the OData protocol.
+
+ AppMarket, providing a way for creators of cloud applications to expose those applications to
+
+potential customers. AppMarket will be available sometime after DataMarket.
+
+Using the cloud to find, evaluate, and purchase data and applications makes sense. The goal of Windows
+Azure Marketplace is to make these things easier to do.
+
+A CLOSER LOOK AT THE TECHNOLOGIES
+
+Having a broad understanding of the Windows Azure platform is an important first step. Making good
+decisions require a deeper understanding of these technologies, however. This section takes a slightly
+more in-depth look at each member of the family.
+
+WINDOWS AZURE
+
+Windows Azure provides what’s commonly called Platform as a Service (PaaS). Rather than offering a
+cloud replica of the on-premises world, it offers a higher level of service that’s meant to make life easier
+for both developers and administrators. What follows walks through the five components that
+collectively provide this service.
10
-PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-VOTE_HOW_POST/VOTEINPWHEN TREND FOR COMPARISON CONTINUED…
-
-PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON:
-Did you vote ON Election Day or BEFORE Election DAY?
-
-Did you vote in person or did you mail your ballot in?
-
-| | | | Nov 10-14 | Nov 6-9 | | Nov 8-11 | | Nov | | Nov | | Nov | Nov |
-| ------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | -------- | ----- | --------- | ----- | ----- | --- | ----- | --- | ----- | ----- |
-| | | | 2016 | | 2014 | | 2012 | 2008 | | 2006 | | 2004 | 2002 |
-| On Election Day | | | 59 | | 71 | | 63 | 66 | | 80 | | 80 | 85 |
-| Before Election Day | | | 41 | | 29 | | 37 | 34 | | 20 | | 20 | 15 |
-| Voted in person | | | 22 | | 12 | | 19 | 19 | | -- | | | |
-| Mailed in ballot | | | 18 | | 16 | | 17 | 14 | | -- | | | |
-| Other way/DK/Ref (VOL) | | | 1 | | 1 | | * | 1 | | -- | | | |
-| Don’t know/Refused (VOL) | | | 0 | | * | | 0 | * | | * | | * | * |
-| | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
-
-ASK IF VOTED BY ABSENTEE OR MAIL (VOTE_HOW_POST=2) [N=2,868]:
-VOTEMAIL How did you return your absentee or mail-in ballot? [RANDOMIZE]
-
-| Nov 12-17, | | | | | | | Nov 16-27, | | Nov 12-17, | | | | |
-| ----------- | ----- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | 2024 | | | | | | 2022 | | | 2020 | | | |
-| | 12 | In person to an election official or poll | | | | | | 12 | | 15 | | | |
-worker
-| | 38 | At a designated dropbox | | | | | | 36 | | 41 | | | |
-| --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | 50 | By mail | | | | | | 52 | | 44 | | | |
-| | * | No answer* | | | | | | * | | * | | | |
-
-ASK IF VOTED BY ABSENTEE OR MAIL (VOTE_HOW_POST=2) [N=2,868]:
-MAILWHEN When did you mail or return your absentee or mail-in ballot?
-
-| | Nov 12-17, | | | | | | Nov 12-17, | | | | | | |
-| --- | ----------- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | 2024 | | | | | | 2020 | | | | | | |
-| | 33 | In the week leading up to Election Day | | | | | | 23 | | | | | |
-| | 67 | Before that | | | | | | 76 | | | | | |
-| | * | No answer* | | | | | | * | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
-
-ASK IF VOTED IN PERSON (VOTE_HOW_POST=1) [N=5,196]:
-WAITVOTE When you went to vote, approximately how long did you have to wait in line to
-vote?
-| | | | | | | | | | | | Nov 17- | | |
-| ------------ | ----- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | ----- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- |
-| Nov 12-17, | | | | | Nov 12-17, | | | Nov 7-16, | | | Dec 15, | | |
-| | 2024 | | | | | 2020 | | 2018 | | | 2014 | | |
-| | 42 | Did not wait at all9 | | | | 35 | | 47 | | | | 53 | |
-| | 30 | Less than 10 minutes | | | | 27 | | 33 | | | | 30 | |
-| | 17 | 10 to 30 minutes | | | | 20 | | 14 | | | | 13 | |
-| | 7 | 31 minutes to 1 hour | | | | 11 | | | 5 | | | 3 | |
-| | 4 | More than 1 hour | | | | 6 | | | 1 | | | * | |
-| | * | No answer* | | | | * | | | * | | | * | |
-
-| | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-
-9 In surveys prior to November 2024, the response was worded “Not at all”.
-www.pewresearch.org
+
+Compute
+
+An application built on the Windows Azure compute service is structured as one or more roles. When it
+executes, the application typically runs two or more instances of each role, with each instance running as
+its own virtual machine (VM). Figure 6 shows how this looks.
+
+Figure 6: A running Windows Azure application consists of any combination of Web role instances,
+Worker role instances, and VM role instances.
+
+A Windows Azure application today can be created using three kinds of roles:
+
+ Web roles, intended primarily for running Web-based applications. Each Web role instance has
+Internet Information Services (IIS) 7 pre-configured to run inside it, so creating applications using
+ASP.NET, WCF, or other Web technologies is straightforward. It’s also possible to create applications
+using PHP, Java, and other non-Microsoft technologies.
+
+ Worker roles, designed to run a variety of code. A Worker role might run a simulation, for example,
+or video processing or nearly anything else. It’s common for an application to interact with users
+through a Web role, then hand tasks off to a Worker role for processing.
+
+ VM roles, which can run a user-provided Windows Server 2008 R2 image. A VM role can be the right
+
+choice for moving some on-premises Windows Server applications to Windows Azure.
+
+When a developer gives Windows Azure an application to run, she submits configuration information
+along with it. Among other things, this information tells the platform how many instances of each role to
+run. The Windows Azure fabric controller then creates a VM for each instance, running the code for the
11
-PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-
-ASK IF VOTED BY MAIL OR ABSENTEE (VOTE_HOW_POST=2) [N=2,868]:
-MAILFIRST Is this the first time you have ever voted by mail or absentee ballot?
-
-| Nov 12-17, | | | Nov 12-17, | | |
-| ----------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- |
-| 2024 | | | 2020 | | |
-Yes, this is the first time I have ever voted by
-| 12 | | | 39 | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-mail or absentee ballot
-| 88 | No, I have voted by mail or absentee ballot before | | 61 | | |
-| --- | --------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| * | No answer* | | * | | |
-
-ASK IF VOTED IN PERSON BEFORE ELECTION DAY (VOTEINPWHEN=1) [N=2,671]:
-| EARLYFIRST | Is this the first time you have ever voted early? | | | | |
-| ----------- | -------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-
-Nov 12-17,
-| 2024 | | | | | |
-| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-29 Yes, this is the first time I have ever voted early
-71 No, I have voted early before
-* No answer*
-
-ASK IF VOTED IN PERSON ON ELECTION DAY (VOTEINPWHEN=2) [N=2,513]:
-ELECDFIRST Is this the first time you have ever voted in person on Election Day?
-
-Nov 12-17,
-2024
-Yes, this is the first time I have ever voted in person on Election Day
-7
-93 No, I have voted in person on Election Day before
-* No answer*
-
-ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS PREVIOUSLY RELEASED
-
-ASK IF VOTED (VOTED=3) [N=8,072]:
-VTCOUNT_OWN How confident are you that your vote was accurately counted?
-
-| Nov 12-17, | | | Nov 16-27, | Nov 12-17, | |
-| ----------- | ------------------- | --- | ----------- | ----------- | --- |
-| 2024 | | | 2022 | 2020 | |
-| 59 | Very confident | | 57 | 59 | |
-| 33 | Somewhat confident | | 31 | 26 | |
-| 5 | Not too confident | | 8 | 9 | |
-Not at all confident
-| 2 | | | 3 | 6 | |
-| --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| * | No answer* | | * | * | |
-
-| | PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON: | | | | |
-| --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-
-| | | Nov 10-14 Nov 6-9 Nov 8-11 Nov 4-7 | | Nov Nov | Nov |
-| --- | -------------------------- | ----------------------------------- | ----------- | ----------- | ----- |
-| | | 2016 2014 | 2012 2010 | 2008 2006 | 2004 |
-| | Very confident | 71 68 | 68 64 | 73 70 | 68 |
-| | Somewhat confident | 19 21 | 22 26 | 22 23 | 24 |
-| | Not too confident | 4 5 | 5 4 | 3 3 | 4 |
-| | Not at all confident | 5 4 | 3 3 | 2 2 | 3 |
-| | Don’t know/Refused (VOL.) | 1 1 | 1 3 | * 2 | 1 |
-| | | | | | |
-www.pewresearch.org
+
+appropriate role in each VM. And as Figure 6 indicates, requests from the outside world are load balanced
+across all instances of a role.
+
+This has an important implication: To be scalable, Windows Azure role instances shouldn’t maintain their
+state themselves between requests. Because the load balancer doesn’t allow creating an affinity with a
+particular role instance—there’s no support for sticky sessions—there’s no way to guarantee that multiple
+requests from the same user will be sent to the same instance. Instead, any client-specific state should be
+written to Windows Azure storage, stored in SQL Azure Database, or maintained externally in some other
+way.
+
+For role instances, Windows Azure lets developers choose from several VM sizes, each with a specific
+number of processor cores and memory. Since each instance can be assigned one or more cores,
+applications have predictable performance. And to increase the load an application can handle, its owner
+or the application itself can request an increase in the number of running instances for one or more roles.
+The Windows Azure fabric controller will then spin up new VMs for these instances and start them
+running. It’s also possible to explicitly decrease the number of instances for a role, letting an application
+grow and shrink as needed to handle changing loads.
+
+For developers, building a Windows Azure application looks much like building a traditional Windows
+application. Microsoft provides Visual Studio project templates, for instance, to help developers create
+Windows Azure applications. Also, the Windows Azure software development kit includes a version of the
+Windows Azure environment that runs on the developer’s machine. Known as the Windows Azure
+development fabric, it implements a local replica of the Windows Azure compute and storage services. A
+developer can create and debug his application using this local simulacrum, then deploy it to Windows
+Azure in the cloud when it’s ready. Windows Azure also provides other services for developers, such as
+information about a running application’s CPU consumption, incoming and outgoing bandwidth, and
+storage usage.
+
+Storage
+
+Applications work with data in many different ways. Sometimes, all that’s required are simple blobs, while
+other situations call for a more structured way to store information. And in some cases, all that’s really
+needed is a way to exchange data between different parts of an application. Windows Azure storage
+addresses all three of these requirements, as Figure 7 shows.
12
-PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-[RANDOMIZE ORDER OF VTCOUNT_POST_INP AND VTCOUNT_POST_ABS]
-
-ASK ALL:
-VTCOUNT_POST_INP How confident are you that votes cast in person at polling places across the United
-States were counted as voters intended in the elections this November?
-
-| Nov 12-17, | | Nov 16-27, | | Nov 12-17, | | |
-| ----------- | --------------------- | ----------- | ----- | ----------- | ----- | --- |
-| 2024 | | | 2022 | | 2020 | |
-| 38 | Very confident | | 37 | | 42 | |
-| 47 | Somewhat confident | | 43 | | 35 | |
-| 11 | Not too confident | | 13 | | 13 | |
-| 4 | Not at all confident | | 6 | | 8 | |
-| 1 | No answer* | | 1 | | 1 | |
-
-TREND FOR COMPARISON:
-How confident are you that votes cast in person at polling places across the United States will
-be counted as voters intend in the elections this November?
-
-| | | | Sep 30- | | | Sep 30- |
-| --- | --------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ----------- | -------- |
-| | | | Oct 6, | | Oct 10-16, | Oct 5, |
-| | | | 2024 | | 2022 | 2020 |
-| | Very confident | | 36 | | 34 | 42 |
-| | Somewhat confident | | 46 | | 45 | 44 |
-| | Not too confident | | 13 | | 15 | 10 |
-| | Not at all confident | | | 5 | 5 | 4 |
-| | No answer* | | | 1 | 1 | 1 |
-
-[RANDOMIZE ORDER OF VTCOUNT_POST_INP AND VTCOUNT_POST_ABS]
-
-ASK ALL:
-VTCOUNT_POST_ABS How confident are you that votes cast by absentee or mail in ballot across the United
-States were counted as voters intended in the elections this November?
-
-| Nov 12-17, | | Nov 16-27, | | Nov 12-17, | | |
-| ----------- | --------------------- | ----------- | ----- | ----------- | ----- | --- |
-| 2024 | | | 2022 | | 2020 | |
-| 24 | Very confident | | 25 | | 30 | |
-| 46 | Somewhat confident | | 37 | | 27 | |
-| 21 | Not too confident | | 23 | | 19 | |
-| 7 | Not at all confident | | 13 | | 23 | |
-| 1 | No answer* | | 1 | | 1 | |
-
-TREND FOR COMPARISON:
-How confident are you that votes cast by absentee or mail-in ballot across the United States
-will be counted as voters intend in the elections this November?
-
-| | | | Sep 30- | | | Sep 30- |
-| --- | --------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ----------- | -------- |
-| | | | Oct 6, | | Oct 10-16, | Oct 5, |
-| | | | 2024 | | 2022 | 2020 |
-| | Very confident | | 22 | | 21 | 17 |
-| | Somewhat confident | | 38 | | 38 | 38 |
-| | Not too confident | | 27 | | 24 | 28 |
-| | Not at all confident | | 12 | | 16 | 16 |
-| | No answer* | | | 1 | 1 | 1 |
-
-www.pewresearch.org
+
+Figure 7: Windows Azure provides blobs, tables, and queues, all accessed in a RESTful style via HTTP,
+HTTPS, or OData.
+
+The simplest way to store data in Windows Azure storage is to use blobs. As Figure 7 suggests, there’s a
+simple hierarchy: A storage account can have one or more containers, each of which holds one or more
+blobs. Blobs can be big—as large as a terabyte each—and to make transferring large blobs more efficient,
+they can potentially be subdivided into blocks. If a failure occurs, retransmission can resume with the
+most recent block rather than sending the entire blob again. Blobs can also have associated metadata,
+such as information about where a JPEG photograph was taken or who the composer is for an MP3 file.
+
+Another way to use blobs is through Windows Azure drives, which can be mounted by a role instance. The
+underlying storage for a drive is a blob, and so once a drive is mounted, the instance can read and write
+file system data that gets stored persistently in a blob.
+
+Blobs are just right for some kinds of data, but they’re too unstructured for many situations. To allow
+applications to work with data in a more fine-grained way, Windows Azure storage provides tables. Don’t
+be misled by the name: These aren’t relational tables. In fact, even though they’re called “tables”, the
+data they contain is actually stored in a set of entities with properties. A table has no defined schema;
+instead, properties can have various types, such as int, string, Bool, or DateTime. And rather than using
+SQL, an application can access a table’s data using the simple query language defined by OData. A single
+table can be quite large, with billions of entities holding terabytes of data, and Windows Azure storage
+can partition it across many servers if necessary to improve performance.
+
+Blobs and tables are both focused on storing data. The third option in Windows Azure storage, queues,
+has a somewhat different purpose. A primary use of queues is to let Web role instances communicate
+with Worker role instances. For example, a user might submit a request to perform some compute-
13
-PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-ASK ALL:
-ELECT_CONFNOVPOS How confident, if at all, are you that... [RANDOMIZE ITEMS]
-
-| | | | | | | Very | Somewhat | | Not too | | Not at all | No |
-| ------ | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | -------- |
-| | | | | | confident | | confident | | confident | | confident | answer* |
-| PRVFR | | People who were not legally | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | qualified to vote are prevented | | | | | | | | | | |
-from casting a ballot
-| | | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | | 27 | | 38 | 26 | | 8 | 1 |
-| ------- | -------------------------------- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | TREND FOR COMPARISON10: | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024 | | | | 29 | | 30 | 24 | | 17 | 1 |
-| | | Sep 30-Oct 5, 2020 | | | | 23 | | 36 | 28 | | 11 | 1 |
-| | | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| PRVSUP | | People who were legally | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | qualified and want to vote are | | | | | | | | | | |
-able to cast a ballot
-| | | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | | 45 | | 42 | 9 | | 3 | 1 |
-| --- | -------------------------------- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | TREND FOR COMPARISON11: | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024 | | | | 44 | | 43 | 10 | | 3 | 1 |
-| | | Sep 30-Oct 5, 2020 | | | | 36 | | 45 | 14 | | 4 | 1 |
-| | | | | | | | | | | | | |
-
-ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS PREVIOUSLY RELEASED
-
-ASK ALL:
-| PARTY | | In politics today, do you consider yourself a… | | | | | | | | | | |
-| ---------------- | --- | ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-ASK IF INDEP/SOMETHING ELSE (PARTY=3, 4 OR REFUSED):
-| PARTYLN | | As of today do you lean more to…12 | | | | | | | | | | |
-| -------------- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- |
-| | | | | | | Something | | No | | Lean | Lean | |
- Republican Democrat Independent else answer* Rep Dem
-| | | 28 | 27 | 30 | | 14 | | 1 | | 20 | | 20 |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-
-10 In October 2024 and October 2020, the item was worded “People who are not legally qualified to vote are prevented from
-casting a ballot.”
-11
-In October 2024 and October 2020, the item was worded “People who are legally qualified and want to vote are able to cast
-a ballot.”
-12 PARTY and PARTYLN asked in a prior survey.
-www.pewresearch.org
\ No newline at end of file
+
+intensive task via a Web page implemented by a Windows Azure Web role. The Web role instance that
+receives this request can write a message into a queue describing the work to be done. A Worker role
+instance that’s waiting on this queue can then read the message and carry out the task it specifies. Any
+results can be returned via another queue or handled in some other way.
+
+Regardless of how it’s stored—in blobs, tables, or queues—all data held in Windows Azure storage is
+replicated three times. This replication allows fault tolerance, since losing a copy isn’t fatal. The system
+guarantees consistency, however, so an application that reads data it has just written will get what it
+expects.
+
+Windows Azure storage can be accessed either by a Windows Azure application or by an application
+running somewhere else. In both cases, all three Windows Azure storage styles use the conventions of
+REST (and the OData protocol for tables) to identify and expose data. Everything is named using URIs and
+accessed with standard HTTP operations, so clients can be created using .NET, Java, or other familiar
+technologies.
+
+The Windows Azure platform charges independently for compute and storage resources. This means that
+an on-premises application can use just Windows Azure storage, accessing its data in the RESTful way just
+described. For example, a Windows Server application running in an enterprise data center might choose
+to store backups in Windows storage blobs.
+
+Fabric Controller
+
+Even though a Windows Azure application runs in VMs, a developer doesn’t explicitly create and manage
+those VMs. Instead, as described earlier, she just tells the platform how many instances the application
+needs, and Windows Azure silently creates the necessary VMs and runs her application. This magic is
+performed by the fabric controller, a fundamental aspect of Windows Azure.
+
+Along with creating VMs and starting the applications that run in them, the fabric controller also monitors
+all running instances. A role instance might fail for many reasons; maybe the code threw an exception or
+the VM crashed or the physical server it’s running on went down. Whatever the reason, the fabric
+controller will start a new instance to maintain the total number of instances required for this application.
+
+The fabric controller also handles housekeeping tasks like patching the operating system and other
+system software, which minimizes the need for administrators. These are all examples of why Windows
+Azure is viewed as PaaS: It provides a platform that lets customers run applications without worrying
+about administering the environment they run in.
+
+Content Delivery Network
+
+One common use of blobs is to store information that will be accessed from many different places. Think
+of an application that serves up videos, for example, to Flash, Silverlight, or HTML 5 clients around the
+world. To improve performance in situations like this, Windows Azure provides a content delivery
+network. The CDN stores copies of a blob at sites closer to the clients that use it. This speeds up delivery
+of frequently accessed content, improving performance for users of this information.
+
+14
+
+Connect
+
+Windows Azure applications can interact with the outside world via HTTP, HTTPS, or TCP. But suppose
+you’d like to connect a role in an application to a machine outside the cloud at the IP level. For example,
+suppose an organization decides to move an existing ASP.NET application to Windows Azure, but wishes
+to keep the application’s data in an on-premises SQL Server database. Windows Azure Connect allows
+this.
+
+Using this option requires running Windows Azure Connect software on the on-premises machine that
+contains SQL Server, and it also requires some straightforward configuration. (This configuration can be
+done by the developer—there’s no need to get a network administrator involved.) Once this is done, all of
+the instances in the Web role can behave as if they’re on the same IP network as the SQL Server machine.
+In fact, they can use the same SQL Server connection string as when the application was running on
+premises—there’s no difference.
+
+Note that this isn’t a full-fledged virtual private network (VPN). While Microsoft has announced plans to
+let customers connect to Windows Azure via a VPN, this isn’t currently supported. It is possible to use
+Windows Azure Connect to domain-join a Windows Azure application to an on-premises Active Directory,
+however. Doing this allows single sign-on by on-premises users to the cloud application, and it also lets
+the application use existing Active Directory accounts and groups for access control.
+
+The goal of application platforms, whether on-premises or in the cloud, is to support applications and
+data. Windows Azure provides a home for both of these things. Going forward, expect to see a substantial
+share of what would have been on-premises Windows applications instead running on this new cloud
+platform.
+
+SQL AZURE
+
+A DBMS in the cloud is attractive for many reasons. Letting a specialized service provider ensure reliability
+and perform essential management functions can make sense, especially for organizations that find these
+things hard to do on their own. Data in the cloud can also be accessed by applications running anywhere,
+even on mobile devices. And given the economies of scale that a service provider enjoys, using a cloud
+database may well be cheaper than doing it yourself.
+
+SQL Azure provides these things, together with cloud-based reporting and data synchronization services.
+And while all of them are important, the place to start is with the foundation: SQL Azure Database.
+
+Database
+
+SQL Azure Database is simple to understand. As seen by an application, it provides the core database
+functions of SQL Server as a cloud service. Figure 8 shows the basics of this technology.
+
+15
+
+Figure 8: Applications access data in SQL Azure Database through Microsoft’s TDS protocol or via OData.
+
+An application using SQL Azure Database might run on Windows Azure, in an enterprise’s data center, on
+a mobile device, or somewhere else. Wherever it runs, the application typically accesses data via a
+protocol called Tabular Data Stream (TDS). This is the same protocol used to access a local SQL Server
+database, and so a SQL Azure Database application can use any existing SQL Server client. This includes
+Entity Framework, ADO.NET, ODBC, PHP and others. And because SQL Azure Database looks like an
+ordinary SQL Server system, standard tools can also be used, including SQL Server Management Studio,
+SQL Server Integration Services, and BCP for bulk data copy. Also, as Figure 8 shows, applications can
+optionally access SQL Azure Database using OData.
+
+Each SQL Azure account can have one or more logical servers. (Note that these provide a way to organize
+the data and billing for an account—they aren’t actual instances of SQL Server.) Each server can then have
+multiple databases, each of which can be up to 50 gigabytes in size. A user is free to use multiple
+databases if required, spreading data across them for better performance or for other reasons. It’s also
+possible to store a snapshot of one SQL Azure database into another, providing a simple backup
+mechanism.
+
+For the most part, an application using SQL Azure Database sees a familiar SQL Server environment. A few
+things are omitted in the technology’s current release, however, such as the SQL Common Language
+Runtime (CLR) and support for full-text search. (Microsoft says that both will be available in a future
+version.) Also, because administration is handled by Microsoft, the service doesn’t expose physical
+administrative functions. A customer can’t shut down the system, for example, or interact directly with
+the hardware it runs on. And as you’d expect in a shared environment, a query can run for only a limited
+time—no single request can take up more than a pre-defined amount of resources.
+
+16
+
+Yet while the environment looks quite standard, the service an application gets is more robust than what
+a single instance of SQL Server provides. As in Windows Azure storage, all data stored in SQL Azure
+Database is replicated three times for high availability. Also like Windows Azure storage, the service
+provides strong consistency: When a write returns, the data has been made persistent. The goal is to
+provide reliable data storage even in the face of system and network failures.
+
+Whether an application needs multiple databases or just one, SQL Azure Database can help developers
+address a range of scenarios. Whatever problem is being solved, the technology’s fundamental goal
+remains the same: to provide a familiar, reliable, and low-cost cloud database for many kinds of
+applications.
+
+Reporting
+
+Storing data in SQL Azure Database can be useful. But as soon as that data exists, there’s likely to be a
+demand for reports based on that data. Meeting this demand is the purpose of SQL Azure Reporting.
+Based on SQL Server Reporting Services (SSRS), this technology provides a cloud-based way to create
+reports.
+
+Given that SQL Azure Database looks like SQL Server to an application, it’s always possible to use SSRS on-
+premises with the data it contains. So why bother to provide a cloud reporting service as well? SQL Azure
+Reporting today targets two main scenarios:
+
+ Reports created using SQL Azure Reporting can be published to a SQL Azure Reporting portal, letting
+
+users access it there, or made accessible directly via a URL.
+
+ An ISV can embed reports published to the SQL Azure Reporting portal in any application, including
+Windows Azure applications. This lets users access those reports without leaving the application. To
+do this, the ISV can use the standard ReportViewer controls in Visual Studio—it’s no different from
+embedding on-premises reports into applications.
+
+SQL Azure Reporting is designed to work with data stored in SQL Azure Database. Reports used with SQL
+Azure Reporting are created on-premises, however, with Business Intelligence Developer Studio, the
+Visual Studio-hosted tool that’s also used to create SSRS reports. In fact, SQL Azure Reporting relies on the
+same reporting format, expressed in the Report Definition Language (RDL), used with SSRS.
+
+Like other aspects of SQL Azure, SQL Azure Reporting doesn’t provide all of the functions offered by SSRS
+on premises. There’s currently no support for scheduling and subscriptions, for example, that let a report
+be run and delivered at regular intervals. Still, cloud-based reporting services can be useful, and they’re an
+important part of the SQL Azure technology family.
+
+Data Sync
+
+Storing data in SQL Azure Database can make it accessible to any application with an Internet connection.
+Still, there are often situations where it makes sense to maintain a copy of this cloud-based data in some
+other place. Suppose an organization needs to have an on-premises copy of the same information, for
+example, for performance reasons or to ensure access if the network fails. For scenarios like this, the
+ability to synchronize data in SQL Azure Database with other data stores is useful.
+
+17
+
+It’s always possible to write synchronization code yourself using the Microsoft Sync Framework. To make
+this easier, Microsoft provides SQL Azure Data Sync. Rather than requiring its user to write code, this
+technology is entirely configuration-driven (although unsurprisingly, it’s built on the Microsoft Sync
+Framework). As Figure 9 shows, SQL Azure Data Sync supports two options today.
+
+Figure 9: SQL Azure Data Sync can synchronize data between SQL Azure databases or between a SQL
+Azure database and on-premises SQL Server databases.
+
+The two synchronization options are the following:
+
+Synchronizing data between a SQL Azure database and an on-premises SQL Server database. Having
+an on-premises copy of cloud data might make sense for a variety of reasons. Maybe an organization
+wants to make sure that this data is always available, for instance, even in the event of network
+failures, or perhaps regulations require that a copy of the data always be available within a country’s
+borders. And even though SQL Azure’s built-in data replication guards against hardware failures, the
+data’s owner might choose to maintain an on-premises backup copy in case of administrative errors,
+such as incorrect table deletions.
+
+Synchronizing data between SQL Azure databases in different Microsoft data centers. For example,
+suppose an ISV or a global enterprise creates an application that’s used by people around the world.
+To provide good performance for all of them, its creator might choose to run this application in three
+different Windows Azure data centers: one each in North America, Europe, and Asia. If the
+application stores data in SQL Azure Database, it might rely on SQL Azure Data Sync to keep
+information synchronized across these three data centers.
+
+SQL Azure Data Sync uses a hub-and-spoke model. All changes are copied first to the SQL Azure database
+hub, then out to the spokes (referred to as members). The members might be other SQL Azure databases
+
+18
+
+or on-premises SQL Server databases. In both cases, the technology provides synchronization of an entire
+database or just specific tables, with changes made to any copy propagated to all of the others. And while
+it’s possible to initiate synchronization manually, SQL Azure Data Sync also includes a scheduling service.
+This lets users schedule, say, hourly synchronization between a pair of databases. However it’s used, the
+purpose is the same: providing a straightforward way to synchronize data between a SQL Azure database
+in a Microsoft data center and one or more databases located somewhere else.
+
+ WINDOWS AZURE APPFABRIC
+
+Applications exist because their business logic has value. Yet applications rely on infrastructure to provide
+a foundation for that logic. A good application platform provides this infrastructure; application
+developers shouldn’t need to write it themselves.
+
+Windows Azure AppFabric provides infrastructure for applications. The people who create applications
+can benefit from different kinds of infrastructure, and so AppFabric contains various parts. This section
+takes a closer look at Service Bus, Access Control, and Caching, the three components of Windows Azure
+AppFabric today.
+
+Service Bus
+
+Suppose you have an application running inside your organization that exposes a Web service built with
+Windows Communication Foundation (WCF). Suppose further that you’d like to connect this service
+through the Internet to software running outside your organization. This client software might be running
+on a cloud platform, such as Windows Azure, or inside another organization.
+
+At first glance, this can seem like a simple problem. Since your application provides its functionality
+through Web services (either RESTful or SOAP-based), you can just make those Web services visible to the
+outside world. When you actually try to do this, though, some problems appear.
+
+First, how can clients in other organizations find endpoints they can connect to for your service? It would
+be nice to have some kind of registry where others could locate your application. And once they’ve found
+it, how can requests from software in other organizations get through to your service? Network address
+translation (NAT) is very common, so an application frequently doesn’t have a fixed IP address to expose
+externally. And even if NAT isn’t being used, how can requests get through your firewall? It’s possible to
+open firewall ports to allow access to your application, but network administrators frown on this.
+
+Service Bus addresses these challenges. Figure 10 shows how.
+
+19
+
+Figure 10: A WCF service can register endpoints with Service Bus, then have clients discover and use
+those endpoints to access the service.
+
+To begin, your WCF service registers one or more endpoints with Service Bus (step 1). For each registered
+endpoint, Service Bus exposes its own corresponding endpoint (step 2). Service Bus assigns your
+organization a URI root, below which you’re free to create any naming hierarchy you like. This allows your
+endpoints to be assigned specific, discoverable URIs.
+
+When a client running in the cloud or on-premises at some other organization wishes to access your
+service, it contacts the Service Bus registry (step 3) to find the endpoint, providing the endpoint’s URI. This
+request uses the Atom Publishing Protocol, and it returns an AtomPub service document with references
+to the endpoints Service Bus exposes on behalf of your application. Once it has these, the client can
+invoke operations on the services exposed through these endpoints (step 4). For each request Service Bus
+receives, it invokes the corresponding operation in the endpoint exposed by your WCF service (step 5).
+(Although it’s not shown in the figure, Service Bus establishes a direct connection between an application
+and its client whenever possible, making their communication more efficient.)
+
+There’s an obvious question here: How exactly does step 5 work? How does the request from Service Bus
+back to your service deal with the challenges of NAT and firewalls? The answer is that in step 1, your
+service opened a TCP connection with Service Bus for this exposed endpoint. Service Bus holds this
+connection open, which solves two problems. First, NAT is no longer an issue, since traffic on the open
+connection with Service Bus will always be routed to your application. Second, because the connection
+was initiated from inside the firewall, there’s no problem passing information back to the application via
+this connection—the firewall won’t block this traffic.
+
+20
+
+Along with making communication easier, Service Bus can also improve security. Because clients now see
+only an IP address provided by Service Bus, there’s no need to expose any IP addresses from within your
+organization. This effectively makes your application anonymous, since the outside world can’t see it.
+Service Bus acts as an external DMZ, providing a layer of indirection to deter attackers.
+
+While an application that exposes its services via Service Bus is typically implemented using WCF, clients
+can be built with WCF or other technologies, such as Java. However they’re created, these clients can
+make requests via TCP, HTTP, or HTTPS. Applications are also free to use their own security mechanisms,
+such as encryption, to shield their communication from attackers.
+
+Service Bus provides a few more useful features, including these:
+
+Support for message buffers, which act like simple queues. Rather than require a client to make
+direct calls to a service, the client can place a message of up to 256 kilobytes into a message buffer.
+The message is persisted to disk—it’s durable—and the service can then read this message at some
+later time. And as usual in the Windows Azure platform, the persisted messages are replicated to
+guard against failures.
+
+ The ability for multiple WCF services to listen on the same URI. Service Bus will then randomly spread
+client requests across all of the listening services. The goal is to provide both load balancing and fault
+tolerance for the WCF services.
+
+Exposing applications to the outside world isn’t as simple as it might seem. The intent of Service Bus is to
+make implementing these interactions as straightforward as possible.
+
+Access Control
+
+Working with identity is a fundamental part of most distributed applications. The modern approach to
+this, called claims-based identity, lets a user send a token full of claims that contain identity information.
+One claim might contain the user’s name, for example, while another contains her age or a group she
+belongs to. An application can use the claims in a token to decide what the user is allowed to do or in
+other ways.
+
+In a claims-based world, tokens are issued by identity providers (IdPs). Some IdPs, such as Active Directory
+Federation Services (AD FS) 2.0, exist inside organizations. Others, such as Windows Live ID and Google
+Accounts, are accessible to anyone via the Internet. Each application can decide which IdPs it trusts and
+thus which tokens it’s willing to accept. For example, an application running inside your company might
+only accept tokens issued by your own AD FS server, while an application running on the Internet might
+accept tokens issued by, say, Google and Facebook.
+
+Yet different IdPs use different token formats, and they represent claims in different ways. An application
+that directly accepts identities from Google, Facebook, and Yahoo, for instance, would need to handle
+these differences itself. But why do this? Why not instead create an intermediary that can generate a
+single token format with a common representation of claims? Doing this would make life simpler for the
+people who create applications, since they now need to handle only one kind of token.
+
+The Access Control service does exactly this, providing an intermediary in the cloud for working with
+claims-based identity. Figure 11 shows how it works.
+
+21
+
+Figure 11: The Access Control service makes it easier for applications to accept identity information
+issued by different identity providers.
+
+As the figure shows, an application that relies on Access Control can run either on-premises or in the
+cloud. In either case, the process begins when a user attempts to access this application via a browser
+(step 1). The application then redirects the browser to an IdP whose token this application will accept. The
+user authenticates herself with this IdP, such as by entering a username and password, and the IdP
+returns a token containing claims about her (step 2).
+
+Next, the user’s browser sends the IdP token to Access Control (step 3). Access Control validates the
+token, making sure that it really was issued by this IdP, then creates a new token according to whatever
+rules have been defined for this application (step 4). Access Control contains a rules engine, allowing each
+application’s administrator to define how tokens from various IdPs should be transformed into an Access
+Control token. For example, if different IdPs use different formats for representing usernames, Access
+Control rules can transform all of these into a common username string. Access Control then sends this
+new token back to the browser (step 5), which submits it to the application (step 6). Once it has the
+Access Control token, the application verifies that it really was issued by Access Control, then uses the
+claims it contains (step 7).
+
+While this process might seem a little complicated, it actually makes life significantly simpler for the
+creator of the application. Rather than handle diverse tokens containing various claims, the application
+can accept identities issued by multiple identity providers while still receiving only a single token with
+familiar claims. And rather than require each application to be configured to trust various IdPs, these trust
+relationships are instead maintained by Access Control—an application need only trust it.
+
+22
+
+As Figure 11 shows, Access Control has built-in support for several identity providers, including AD FS 2.0,
+Windows Live ID, Google, Yahoo, and Facebook. It can also work with any IdP that supports OpenID.
+Browsers and other clients can request Access Control tokens using either OAuth 2 or WS-Trust, and these
+tokens can have various formats, including SAML 1.1, SAML 2.0, and Simple Web Token (SWT). And to
+create applications that accept Access Control tokens, Windows developers can use Windows Identity
+Foundation (WIF). (It’s worth pointing out, however, that nothing about Access Control is tied to
+Windows—it could just as well be used by a Linux application that accepted only Google and Facebook
+identities.)
+
+Working with identity is important in nearly every distributed application. The goal of Access Control is to
+make it easier for developers to create secure applications that accept identities from diverse providers.
+By putting this service in the cloud, Microsoft has made it available to any application running on any
+platform.
+
+Caching
+
+For many applications, one of the most effective ways to improve performance is by caching frequently
+accessed data. Since applications tend to use the same information over and over, making this
+information more readily accessible can make the application faster. Doing this is the purpose of Windows
+Azure AppFabric Caching. Figure 12 illustrates the idea.
+
+Figure 12: Windows Azure AppFabric Caching speeds up access to frequently accessed data for
+Windows Azure applications.
+
+23
+
+The Caching service provides a distributed cache for Windows Azure applications, along with a library to
+access this cache. As Figure 12 suggests, the service includes a local cache that can keep a copy of recently
+accessed data items in each of an application’s role instances. If a data item the application needs isn’t
+found in the local cache, the cache library automatically contacts the shared cache provided by the
+Caching service. As the figure shows, this cache is spread across a number of Windows Azure instances,
+each holding different cached data. This diversity isn’t visible to applications using the cache, however. An
+application just requests a data item, then lets the cache find it (if it’s in the cache) and return it from
+whatever instance contains it.
+
+Recently accessed data isn’t automatically cached, however. Instead, the application explicitly inserts data
+items in the cache, such as by using the Caching API. It’s also possible to configure an ASP.NET application
+running on Windows Azure to store Session object data in the Caching service, speeding it up without
+changing any of its code.
+
+Windows Server AppFabric, the on-premises analog to Windows Azure AppFabric, also provides a Caching
+service. In fact, the two are very similar. The biggest different is that unlike its on-premises counterpart,
+Windows Azure AppFabric Caching is a service—there’s no need to configure servers and administer the
+cache. Instead, all of this is handled automatically by the service itself. And the cloud Caching service is
+multi-tenant, so each application using it gets its own instance. Because the application must authenticate
+itself to this instance, data held in the Caching service isn’t accessible to other applications.
+
+Caching can make applications faster and more scalable with little effort from developers, and so using it
+makes sense. By providing caching as a service, Windows Azure AppFabric Caching makes this easier to
+do.
+
+WINDOWS AZURE MARKETPLACE
+
+Cloud platforms are useful, but they’re just a means to an end. The real goal is offering applications and
+data that provide value for people. Since the Windows Azure platform provides a foundation for both,
+why shouldn’t it also include a way for people to find the applications and data that they need?
+
+The Windows Azure Marketplace is designed to address this need. Its two components, AppMarket and
+DataMarket, let users find, try, and purchase applications and data, respectively. While both are
+important, DataMarket will appear first, and so what follows focuses on this aspect of the Marketplace.
+
+Buying applications is common today—nearly every organization does it. Buying data is less common, but
+it’s no less important. Many firms sell many different kinds of data, including demographic information,
+financial information, legal information, and much more. Yet using purchased data typically requires
+figuring out whether the data you need exists, finding a firm that offers it, then determining whether their
+data meets your needs.
+
+All of this is more difficult than it needs to be. Why not create one place where customers can find all
+kinds of data from all kinds of content providers? Why not let them examine the data to make sure it
+meets their needs, then purchase what they need right then and there? The DataMarket component of
+Windows Azure Marketplace was created to do these things. Figure 13 shows its main components.
+
+24
+
+Figure 13: Built on Windows Azure, the DataMarket allows access to content partner datasets stored in
+Windows Azure, SQL Azure, or externally.
+
+As the figure suggests, both people and applications can access information through DataMarket. Using a
+Windows Azure-based application called the Service Explorer, a user can see what datasets are available,
+then purchase what she needs. Once this is done, applications can access that data using RESTful or OData
+requests. The datasets made available by DataMarket can be stored on the Windows Azure platform itself
+using Windows Azure Storage or SQL Azure Database. They can also be stored externally, such as in a data
+center owned by the content provider. There’s no requirement to put everything in the cloud.
+
+For customers, DataMarket provides a single place to find, buy, and access a variety of commercial
+datasets. For content providers—the owners of those data sets—DataMarket offers a chance to expose
+their offerings to more customers through Microsoft’s cloud platform. While content providers set prices
+for their data, DataMarket provides a billing service that frees them from dealing directly with customers.
+Microsoft will also vet the quality of the content providers, limiting DataMarket initially to just the top five
+providers in a particular industry.
+
+Applications are free to use purchased data in any way that the content provider’s license allows. Users of
+Microsoft Excel 2010, for example, can access DataMarket’s information directly using an Excel add-in or
+use the PowerPivot for Excel support for OData to access information from DataMarket for data analysis.
+It’s also possible to combine data purchased from DataMarket with your own data, such as for reports
+created using SQL Server Reporting Services.
+
+25
+
+Getting business value from information technology requires the right applications, but it also requires
+the right data. By making it easier to discover, evaluate, and buy commercially available datasets,
+DataMarket intends to make it simpler for organizations to find and use the information they need.
+
+LOOKING AHEAD
+
+Microsoft has announced a number of updates that it plans to add to the Windows Azure platform in the
+near future. They include the following:
+
+ The Windows Azure Platform Appliance: Microsoft has announced plans to offer a Windows Azure
+Platform Appliance, allowing hosters and enterprises to run Windows Azure in their own data
+centers. Because Windows Azure requires a specific hardware configuration—it’s not just software—
+this appliance will include servers, networking, and storage, all running Windows Azure. And while it
+will initially be targeted only at large organizations, Microsoft’s goal is eventually to make the
+Windows Azure Platform Appliance useful for smaller organizations as well.
+
+ CDN dynamic content caching: Today, the Windows Azure CDN works only with blob data. This
+forthcoming functionality will let the CDN also cache content created dynamically by a Windows
+Azure application.
+
+ VM role snapshotting: In its first release, the Windows Azure VM role doesn’t save any changes made
+to the OS volume while it’s running. Snapshotting will change this, providing a way to periodically
+save the state of this volume to persistent storage.
+
+ Better Java support: While Windows Azure can run Java applications today, Microsoft plans to make
+this better. The coming improvements include better Java performance, stronger support for Eclipse-
+based tools, and a more complete set of Java libraries for Windows Azure.
+
+Support for composite applications: To make it easier to build Windows Azure applications by
+combining existing components and services, Windows Azure AppFabric will add a composition
+model. Accompanied by runtime services and a Visual Studio-based designer, this model will let
+developers work with the various parts of an application as a single logical entity throughout its
+lifecycle.
+
+ All of these changes target the same goal: making the Windows Azure platform useful in a broader range
+of scenarios.
+
+CONCLUSIONS
+
+The truth is evident: Cloud computing is here. For developers, taking advantage of the cloud means using
+cloud platforms. With the Windows Azure platform, Microsoft presents a range of options addressing a
+variety of needs:
+
+ Windows Azure provides a computing and storage environment in the cloud.
+
+SQL Azure provides a relational DBMS in the cloud, together with reporting and data synchronization.
+
+26
+
+ Windows Azure AppFabric offers cloud-based infrastructure supporting both cloud and on-premises
+
+applications.
+
+ Windows Azure Marketplace is an online store for finding and purchasing datasets from content
+
+providers, together with a forthcoming store for cloud applications.
+
+These approaches address a variety of requirements, and not every developer will use all of them. Yet
+whether you work for an ISV, a systems integrator, or an enterprise, some cloud platform services are
+likely to be useful for applications your organization creates. A new world is unfolding; prepare to be part
+of it.
+
+ABOUT THE AUTHOR
+
+David Chappell is Principal of Chappell & Associates (www.davidchappell.com) in San Francisco, California.
+Through his speaking, writing, and consulting, he helps people around the world understand, use, and
+make better decisions about new technologies.
+
+27
+
diff --git a/q12/random_k2/random_2.md b/q12/random_k2/random_2.md
index 568511cdd3e8b935079ff674d5949ce1b387f331..41b128d8d6a3808185f462ec8b46e331c45f6af0 100644
--- a/q12/random_k2/random_2.md
+++ b/q12/random_k2/random_2.md
@@ -1,5479 +1,448 @@
-Owner’s Manual
+Amazfit GTR User Manual
+
+Content
+
+Operating Instructions and Functions Navigation ............................................................................. 2
+Basic Operations ....................................................................................................................... 2
+Functions Navigation ................................................................................................................ 2
+Watch Wearing and Charging ............................................................................................................ 4
+Use of Functions ............................................................................................................................... 5
+Device Pairing and Unpairing ................................................................................................... 5
+Control Shortcut Menu .............................................................................................................. 7
+Flashlight ........................................................................................................................... 7
+Brightness adjustment ....................................................................................................... 8
+DND mode ........................................................................................................................ 8
+Battery saver mode ............................................................................................................ 9
+Lock screen ..................................................................................................................... 10
+Replace the Watch Face .......................................................................................................... 11
+Status ....................................................................................................................................... 11
+Heart Rate ............................................................................................................................... 12
+Workout ................................................................................................................................... 13
+Workout Record ...................................................................................................................... 14
+Weather ................................................................................................................................... 15
+Music....................................................................................................................................... 16
+Notifications ............................................................................................................................ 17
+Alarm ...................................................................................................................................... 18
+Event Reminder....................................................................................................................... 20
+Timer ....................................................................................................................................... 22
+Count Down ............................................................................................................................ 23
+Find Device ............................................................................................................................. 24
+Compass/Air Pressure/Altitude ............................................................................................... 25
+Settings .................................................................................................................................... 27
+Workout Function ........................................................................................................................... 29
+Workout Positioning................................................................................................................ 30
+During Workouts ..................................................................................................................... 31
+Swimming ............................................................................................................................... 32
+Workout Reminder .................................................................................................................. 33
+Workout Pause and End .......................................................................................................... 33
+Workout Settings ..................................................................................................................... 34
+
+Operating Instructions and Functions Navigation
+
+Amazfit GTR features one AMOLED touch screen and two physical buttons.
+
+Basic Operations
+
+Slide left and right or up and down: You can switch between different function pages.
+Tap and exit: You can tap to enter a specific function page and also operate the tap tips on that page.
+You can slide right to quickly return to the upper-level menu after tapping to enter a certain function
+page.
+Button on the upper right:
+① Short press to light up the screen.
+② Short press the watch face page to close the screen.
+③ Short press other pages to quickly return to the watch face.
+④ Long press for 10s to shut down.
+Button on the bottom right:
+① Short press to light up the screen.
+② Short press the watch face page to quickly enter the workout list. (This function can be
+customized and used to short press to quickly start other functions)
+You can long press either of the two buttons above to exit the battery saver mode, suspend the
+workout, and close the alarm alert.
+
+Functions Navigation
+
+Pull the watch face down: You can then enter the shortcut control menu, which allows you to quickly
+open the flashlight, set brightness, control the DND mode, enter the battery saver mode, and lock
+the screen.
+
+Slide the watch face left and right: You can then quickly enter Status, Heart rate,
+
+Slide the watch face up: You can then enter the function list.
+
+Watch Wearing and Charging
+
+Daily wearing: During daily use, it is recommended to wear the watch with a moderate tightness at
+a distance two fingers far from your wrist to ensure that the optical heart rate monitor works properly.
+Wearing during workouts: During workouts, it is recommended to wear the watch comfortably and
+ensure a tight fit without slipping. Being too tight or too loose may cause the inaccuracy of detected
+workout data, so avoid doing this.
+Charging
+
+
+The watch charger's USB port needs to be plugged into the USB-supported device, such as
+socket, PC, power bank.
+
+ When placing the watch into the power socket, it's required to keep the watch in a proper
+direction and position. Be sure that the metal contacts on the back of the watch are closely
+connected to the charging base.
+The screen will display the charging reminder when the watch is placed properly.
+
+
+
+Use of Functions
+
+Download the Amazfit App via the mobile phone before using Amazfit GTR. You cannot use the
+entire watch functions nor save and upload watch data to your personal cloud account until the
+watch is paired by using the Amazfit App.
+
+Device Pairing and Unpairing
+
+Download the Amazfit App from Google Play Store or App Store and register an account or log in.
+
+Open the Amazfit App and choose "Profile – My devices – Watch – Amazfit GTR" to search the
+device nearby.
+Please tap the check-mark when it shows a pairing request on the watch.
+
+If a device can be paired by scanning a QR code, with the Amazfit App on, you can directly pair the
+device by scanning the QR code on your watch.
+After paired, the watch usually needs to be upgraded. Wait for upgrading with patience. With the
+mobile network and Bluetooth on, you also need to keep the watch close to the mobile phone, so as
+to ensure a successful upgrade.
+
+After the watch is paired and upgraded, its functions are available. Meanwhile, the Amazfit App
+allows for the watch function-specific operations and settings.
+To unpair the watch, open the Amazfit App, tap "Profile – My devices – Amazfit GTR" and then
+swipe up and tap the "Unpair" button.
-Models
-14, 16, 17, 18
+Control Shortcut Menu
-Refrigerators
+Pulling down on the watch face page can quickly open the control shortcut menu page.
-TOP-MOUNT NO-FROST
+Flashlight
+Tapping the flashlight icon can open the flashlight function. The white background on the watch
+screen helps light up a small area at night. You can close the enabled flashlight function by sliding
-Part No. 162D6736P004 Pub. No.39-6424-1 9-99 JR
+right or pressing the button on the upper right.
-Congratulations!
+Brightness adjustment
+Tapping on the brightness adjustment button can go to the brightness adjustment settings.
+Auto brightness: The watch will automatically adjust the screen brightness upon ambient light.
+Manual brightness: You can tailor the screen brightness as you wish.
-Welcome to our family. We’re proud of our
-quality products and we are committed to
-providing dependable service. You’ll see it in
-this easy-to-use Owner’s Manual and you’ll
-hear it in the friendly voices of our customer
-service department.
+DND mode
+Enable DND: With the DND mode enabled, the watch will not vibrate when receiving any message
+pushed by the mobile phone.
+Time DND: You can tailor the time period during which the DND mode changes from automatically
+enabled to disabled.
-Best of all, you’ll experience these values
-each time you use your refrigerator. That’s
-important, because your new refrigerator will
-be part of your family for many years. And we
-hope you will be part of ours for a long time
-to come.
+Smart DND: After you fall asleep with the watch, the watch will automatically enable the DND
+mode.
+Disable DND: The DND mode is disabled, so the watch will vibrate when receiving notifications.
-We appreciate your purchase, and hope you
-will continue to rely on us whenever you
-need quality appliances for your home.
+Battery saver mode
+The battery saver mode can minimize the power consumption of the watch and improve its
+endurance. With the battery saver mode on, the watch can only record steps and sleep time, with
+other functions disabled.
-Important!
+To exit the battery saver mode, long press any button on the watch.
-Fill out and return the Consumer Product
-Registration Card that is packed with this
-product. If you cannot find it, please send
-in the duplicate card printed in the back of
-this manual.
+Lock screen
+With the lock screen function on, you can unlock the watch to enter the watch face page only by
+using the watch button. This can prevent any error caused by mistouch. To close the lock screen
+function, tap the lock screen button again to close this function.
-Write the model and serial
-numbers here.
+Replace the Watch Face
-#
+To replace the watch face on the watch: Long press the watch face page for 2s, or go to "Settings –
+Watch face settings", slide left and right to scan the watch face, and tap one to complete replacement.
+To replace the watch face on the App: Tap "Profile – Amazfit GTR – Watch face settings" to
+download more watch faces on the Watch Face Store.
-#
+Status
-You can find them on a label on the
-upper left side of the fresh food
-compartment.
+Sliding left on the watch face page can enable you to enter the status page which displays the current
+steps and goal completed. Tapping the status entry can enable you to enter the details page which
-Staple sales slip or cancelled
-check here.
+shows you the steps, distance, calories and idle data.
-Proof of the original purchase date
-is needed to obtain service under
-the warranty.
+You can also enter the details page by sliding up on the watch face page and choosing "Status".
-2
+Heart Rate
-AService Partnership.
+Sliding left on the watch face can enable you to enter the heart rate page, and then the watch
+automatically starts to measure the heart rate. During measurement, it is required to properly wear
+the watch and keep the back of the watch fairly close to your skin until the watch can measure a
+stable heart rate.
+To enable the all-day measure function, open the Amazfit App, go to "Profile – Amazfit GTR –
+Heart rate detection", and choose to enable automatic heart rate detection.
-We stand behind our products with
-unmatched quality service. However, did
-you know that most questions result from
-simple problems that you can easily
-fix yourself in just a few minutes? This
-Owner’s Manual can tell you how.
+Notes: With the all-day measure function on, the watch will measure the heart rate at regular time.
+Sliding right on the watch face can make the last heart rate value visible. You can enter the all-day
+heart rate details page by tapping it.
-Read this Manual
-Inside you will find many
-helpful hints on how to use and
-maintain your refrigerator
-properly. Just a little preventive
-care on your part can save you a
-great deal of time and money
-over the life of your refrigerator.
+Workout
-Review the Section on
-Troubleshooting Tips
+Amazfit GTR supports twelve workout types: Outdoor running, Walking, Outdoor cycling,
+Treadmill, Indoor cycling, Pool swim, Open water swim, Elliptical trainer, Climb, Trail run, Skiing,
+and Exercise. See the "Workout" section for more details about the functions of different workout
+types.
-You’ll find many answers to
-common problems here.
-If you review our chart of
-Troubleshooting Tips first,
-you may not need to call for
-service at all.
+Workout Record
-If You Need Service
+The workout data on the watch will be stored in workout records, which are shown from the latest
+to the earliest. Tapping a specific workout record will make the workout details visible. The visible
+details vary in workout type.
-If you do need service, you can
-relax knowing help is only a
-phone call away. A list of toll-free
-customer service numbers is
-included in the back section.
-Or you can always call the
-GE Answer Center® at
-800.626.2000, 24 hours a day,
-7 days a week.
+The workout record not uploaded to the App will be marked with a little red dot before it. Open the
+App to synchronize data timely to avoid the loss of workout records.
-Safety Information
-Safety Precautions . . . . . . . . . .4
-Proper Disposal . . . . . . . . . . . . .5
-How to Connect Electricity . . . .6
-Use of Adapter Plugs . . . . . .6, 7
-Use of Extension Cords . . . . . .7
+To delete a workout record on the watch, tap to enter the workout record details page, slide up to
+the bottom of the page, and then tap the delete button.
-Operating Instructions
+Weather
-Temperature Control Dial . . . . .8
-Shelves . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .9, 10
-Storage Drawers . . . . . . . .11, 12
-Automatic Icemaker . . . . . . . .13
-Care and Cleaning . . . . . .14–16
+Tapping the weather function can give you access to the current weather conditions and the weather
+forecast. If weather data are invisible, you should open the App and connect the device to update
+the data.
-Installation Instructions
+Music
-Preparing to
-Install the Refrigerator . . .17, 18
-Water Line Installation . . .19–23
-Reversing the
-Door Swing . . . . . . . . . . . .24–29
+With the Bluetooth, the watch can suspend or play the music on the mobile music player, switch
+between songs, and adjust the volume.
+ Open the mobile music player first, and then enable the music function on the watch.
+
+
-Troubleshooting Tips
+If you are using an iOS device, you need to pair and connect the watch with the Amazfit App.
+If you are using an Android device, you need to connect the watch with the Amazfit App and
+also enable the notification reading permission on the App.
-Normal Operating Sounds . . .30
-Before You
-Call For Service . . . . . . . . .31–33
+Notes: The compatibility of the Android mobile phone system and the openness of different music
+players may to a certain extent affect the music control function of the watch.
-Customer Service
-Product Registration . . . . . . . .37
-Warranty . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .39
-Service Telephone
-Numbers . . . . . . . . . .Back Cover
+Notifications
-3
+Enable notifications
+During use, you need to enable the corresponding "App alerts" on the App, and keep the watch and
+the mobile phone connected. You can also enable the incoming SMS and incoming call alerts as you
+wish.
+
+
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
+If you are using an iOS device, you need to pair and connect the watch with the Amazfit App.
+If you are using an Android device, you need to keep the App running in the background or
+include the App into the self-starting whitelist, so as to ensure the mobile phone can send the
+alert to the watch.
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
+View notifications
+1.
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
+In the case of an incoming notification, the watch will automatically light up the screen and
+display the content.
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
+2. You can view the unread notification in the notification list and tap any notification to enter the
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
+notification details page.
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
+Delete notifications
+
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
+The read notification on the watch or the mobile phone will be automatically deleted from the
+notification list on the watch.
+To manually delete the notification on the watch, slide left on the notification to be deleted and
+tap the delete button.
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
+
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
+Alarm
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
+Amazfit GTR supports creating and managing the alarm on the watch. You can also create a watch
+alarm on the Amazfit App.
+Tapping the create button on the watch alarm function page can enable you to set the alarm time and
-4
+cycle. After saved, the alarm can be opened and closed in the alarm list.
+To create an alarm via the Amazfit App, go to "Profile – Amazfit GTR – Watch alarm" and add an
+alarm upon the tips on the page.
-IMPORTANT SAFETY INFORMATION.
-READ ALL INSTRUCTIONS BEFORE USING.
-WARNING!
+Alarm alert
+In the case of a watch alarm alert, you can choose to close it or remind you later.
-Use this appliance only for its intended purpose as
-described in this Owner’s Manual.
+To close the alarm, long press any button for 2s within the duration of the alarm alert.
-SAFETY PRECAUTIONS
-When using electrical appliances, basic safety precautions
-should be followed, including the following:
+To make a delayed alert, you can, within the duration of the alarm alert, tap the "Z" button at the
+bottom. Then, the alarm will remind you 10min later.
-n Keep fingers out of the
-“pinch point” areas;
-clearances between the
-doors and between the doors
-and cabinet are necessarily
-small. Be careful closing
-doors when children are in
-the area.
+Event Reminder
-n Unplug the refrigerator
+You need to create and manage the event reminder via the Amazfit App. The watch will display
+your to-do list and vibrate to remind you in the set time.
+Open the Amazfit App, go to "Profile – Amazfit GTR – Event reminder", and create the event
+reminder upon the tips on the page.
+An alert will pop up on the watch when the time set for the event arrives. Tap the "×" button at the
+bottom to close the alert.
-before cleaning and making
-repairs.
+The watch supports modifying and deleting the event reminder.
+To modify the event reminder, tap the right arrow on the event reminder list page to modify the
+event reminder date and time.
-NOTE: We strongly recommend
-that any servicing be performed
-by a qualified individual.
+To delete the event reminder, slide right on the event to be deleted and tap the trash icon to delete it.
-n Turning the control to the
+Timer
-OFF position does not remove
-power to the light circuit.
-n Do not refreeze frozen foods
+The timer on the watch supports one hundredth of a second. To enable the timer, pull up the app list
+on the watch face and choose the timer app.
+
+ During timing, you can also count the number of times by tapping the button on the bottom
-which have thawed
-completely.
+Tapping the start button can activate the timer to time it right away.
-n This refrigerator must be
-properly installed and
-located in accordance with
-the Installation Instructions
-before it is used.
+left on the watch screen (up to 99 times of such operation),
+and suspend the current timer by tapping the button on the bottom right on the watch screen.
-n Do not allow children to
+
+ When the timer pauses, you can reset it by tapping the button on the bottom left on the watch
+screen, and resume timing by tapping the button on the bottom right on the watch screen.
-climb, stand or hang on the
-shelves in the refrigerator.
-They could damage the
-refrigerator and seriously
-injure themselves.
-n Do not touch the cold
-surfaces in the freezer
-compartment, particularly
-when hands are damp or wet.
-Skin may stick to these
-extremely cold surfaces.
-n Do not store or use gasoline
-or other flammable vapors
-and liquids in the vicinity of
-this or any other appliance.
+Count Down
-n In refrigerators with
+To enable the count down, pull up the app list on the watch face and choose the count down app.
+By default, the watch supports the shortcut count down of 1min, 3min, 5min, 10min, 15min, 20min,
+30min, and 60min. You can enable the count down function right away by tapping it.
+A custom count down function is available, which ranges from 1min to 23h and 59min.
-automatic icemakers, avoid
-contact with the moving parts
-of the ejector mechanism, or
-with the heating element that
-releases the cubes. Do not
-place fingers or hands on the
-automatic icemaking
-mechanism while the
-refrigerator is plugged in.
+You can suspend, resume or stop the count down function anytime when it operates. When time's
+up, the watch will vibrate to remind you. You can close the count down function by tapping the "×"
+button at the bottom.
-DANGER! RISK OF CHILD
+Find Device
-ENTRAPMENT
-PROPER DISPOSAL OF THE REFRIGERATOR
+Amazfit GTR supports finding the device via the Bluetooth. To enable this function, slide up the
+app list on the watch face page and tap the find device function.
+
-Child entrapment and suffocation are not problems of
-the past. Junked or abandoned refrigerators are still
-dangerous…even if they will sit for “just a few days.”
-If you are getting rid of your old refrigerator, please
-follow the instructions below to help prevent accidents.
+To activate the find device function, you need to keep the Amazfit App running and ensure the
+watch is connected to the mobile phone. Otherwise the function is not available.
-Before You Throw Away Your Old Refrigerator
-or Freezer:
+ On the find page, the watch will automatically find the device. If no device is found after 60s,
-n Take off the doors.
-n Leave the shelves in place so that children may not
+a failure prompt will display and then you can try again.
-easily climb inside.
+ When found, the mobile phone will beep. You can close the ring on the mobile phone by
+tapping the tip button on the watch. Meanwhile, the mobile phone will produce a message on
+the notification bar. Tapping the message can draw back the Amazfit App and close the ring on
+the mobile phone.
-CFC Disposal
+Notes: If you wish to use the find device function anytime, you can include the Amazfit App into
+the built-in self-starting whitelist and keep it running in the background. In addition, the watch is
+required to be connected to the mobile phone, otherwise it is unable to find the mobile phone.
-Your old refrigerator has a cooling system that used
-CFCs (chlorofluorocarbons). CFCs are believed to harm
-stratospheric ozone.
+Compass/Air Pressure/Altitude
-If you are throwing away your old refrigerator, make
-sure the CFC refrigerant is removed for proper disposal
-by a qualified servicer. If you intentionally release this
-CFC refrigerant you can be subject to fines and
-imprisonment under provisions of the Federal Clean
-Air Act.
+Amazfit GTR supports the compass function. When the compass page opens, the watch
+automatically detects the current orientation and degree. If needed, you can wear the watch and
+calibrate the compass by filling out that circle with figure 8 movements in the air, until the watch
+vibrates. Then the compass function can be reused.
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
+Sliding up on the compass page can enable you to enter the atmospheric pressure page. The
+barometer on the watch displays the current air pressure in real time.
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
+Sliding up on the air pressure page can enable you to enter the altitude page. The altitude requires
+double calibration of watch barometer and GPS. If you want more accurate altitude data, try to get
+the satellite positioning in an open area as soon as possible.
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
+Settings
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
+The watch settings page includes some watch settings and built-in control functions.
+Watch face settings: You can quickly switch between watch faces.
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
+Screen-on duration: You can control the screen-on duration of the watch for 8s (by default) to 15s
+(max).
-5
+Quick start: You can short press the button on the bottom right to quickly start one watch function
+(by default, workout list).
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
+System: It supports viewing the firmware version and regulatory information, and controlling the
+actions of closing and rebooting the watch and performing the factory reset.
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
+Workout Function
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
+Amazfit GTR supports twelve workout types: Outdoor running, Walking, Outdoor cycling,
+Treadmill, Indoor cycling, Pool swim, Open water swim, Elliptical trainer, Climb, Trail run, Skiing,
+and Exercise. And the workout types like Outdoor running, Walking, Outdoor cycling, Open water
+swim, Climb, Trail run, and Skiing support recording GPS-enabled workout tracks.
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
+There are two approaches to enabling the workout function on the watch:
+
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
+If the workout list is set for quick start, then you can quickly enter the workout list by short
+pressing the button on the bottom right on the watch face page. By default, the last workout
+type displays.
+Sliding up on the watch face page and choosing "Workout" can enable you to enter the workout
+list page and choose the workout you want to start.
-6
+
-IMPORTANT SAFETY INFORMATION.
-READ ALL INSTRUCTIONS BEFORE USING.
-WARNING!
+Workout Positioning
-HOW TO CONNECT ELECTRICITY
-Do not, under any circumstances, cut or remove the third
-(ground) prong from the power cord. For personal safety,
-this appliance must be properly grounded.
+If you choose to start Outdoor running, you'd better go to the open area before workouts, which is
+conducive to rapid GPS positioning.
-The power cord of this appliance is equipped with a 3-prong
-(grounding) plug which mates with a standard 3-prong
-(grounding) wall outlet to minimize the possibility of electric
-shock hazard from this appliance.
+If it takes a long time to process positioning, it may be because the buildings nearby block satellite
+signals, or because the watch is disconnected to the App for a long time, causing the AGPS to be
+not upgraded. You can open the Amazfit App, connect it to the watch, and try again after the AGPS
+is updated.
+It is recommended to ensure GPS positioning is processed successfully before the outdoor workout.
+If you start the workout during positioning, the workout track cannot be recorded and the recorded
+workout data will not be accurate.
+After GPS positioning is processed successfully, the "GO" icon will be lit up and you can tap it to
+start the workout.
-Have the wall outlet and circuit checked by a qualified electrician
-to make sure the outlet is properly grounded.
+During Workouts
-Where a standard 2-prong wall outlet is encountered, it is your
-personal responsibility and obligation to have it replaced with a
-properly grounded 3-prong wall outlet.
+During workouts, the watch will display the current workout data in real time, such as time, distance,
+pace/speed, and heart rate. After the watch screen goes off, the screen can be lit up again by lifting
+the wrist or touching the screen.
+Sliding right during workouts can enable you to view the time, date, and watch power.
-The refrigerator should always be plugged into its own individual
-electrical outlet which has a voltage rating that matches the rating
-plate.
+Swimming
-This provides the best performance and also prevents overloading
-house wiring circuits which could cause a fire hazard from
-overheated wires.
+With the swimming workout enabled, the watch will automatically lock the screen to avoid water
+drops interfering with the screen display during the workout. To unlock the screen, you can short
+press any button on the watch, and the screen will be locked again after the watch screen goes off.
-Never unplug your refrigerator by pulling on the power cord.
-Always grip plug firmly and pull straight out from the outlet.
+Workout Reminder
-Repair or replace immediately all power cords that have become
-frayed or otherwise damaged. Do not use a cord that shows cracks or
-abrasion damage along its length or at either end.
+The workout reminder on the watch varies in workout type. For the workout types Running, Cycling,
+and Walking, the alert will be vibrated once per kilometer by default. You can also set the alerts for
+other workout types before workouts. See the "Workout Settings" section for more details.
-When moving the refrigerator away from the wall, be careful not to
-roll over or damage the power cord.
+Workout Pause and End
-USE OF ADAPTER PLUGS
-Because of potential safety hazards under certain
-conditions, we strongly recommend against the use of an
-adapter plug.
+With the auto pause function on, the watch will automatically pause when the workout end is
+detected. When the workout resumes, the watch will automatically end the pause status and resume
+recording the workout performance.
-However, if you must use an adapter, where local codes permit, a
-temporary connection may be made to a properly grounded 2-prong
-wall outlet by use of a UL-listed adapter available at most local
-hardware stores.
+Tapping any button during a workout can suspend the workout.
-The larger slot in the adapter must be aligned with the larger slot in
-the wall outlet to provide proper polarity in the connection of the
-power cord.
+Tapping the right button can cancel the pause and resume the workout.
+Tapping the left button can end the current workout and save the workout performance.
-When disconnecting the power cord from the adapter, always hold
-the adapter in place with one hand while pulling the power cord
-plug with the other hand. If this is not done, the adapter ground
-terminal is very likely to break with repeated use.
+Workout Settings
-If the adapter ground terminal breaks, DO NOT USEthe refrigerator
-until a proper ground has been established.
+Before workouts, you can set some relevant functions.
+The workout goal supports three types: mileage, duration, and calories. When the set goal is
+achieved, the watch will vibrate to remind you.
-Attaching the adapter ground terminal to a wall outlet cover screw does not
-ground the appliance unless the cover screw is metal, and not insulated, and the
-wall outlet is grounded through the house wiring. You should have the circuit
-checked by a qualified electrician to make sure the outlet is properly grounded.
+The workout reminder supports five types: distance, pace, safe heart rate, heart rate zone, and pace
+With a reminder set, the watch will vibrate to remind you as long as the set value is reached during
+workouts.
-USE OF EXTENSION CORDS
-Because of potential safety hazards under certain
-conditions, we strongly recommend against the use of an
-extension cord.
+With the auto pause on, the watch will automatically detect the workout status. When the workout
+is stopped, the watch will automatically suspend the current exercise. And the watch will re-record
+the data when the workout is resumed.
+The real-time diagram supports demonstrating the real-time heart rate and pace. With the real-time
+diagram on, a curve is drawn for the fluctuations of the heart rate or pace during workouts.
-However, if you must use an extension cord, it is absolutely
-necessary that it be a UL-listed, 3-wire grounding type appliance
-extension cord having a grounding type plug and outlet and that
-the electrical rating of the cord be 15 amperes (minimum) and
-120 volts.
-
-REMEMBER…
-Your continued health and safety are important to us.
-
-Please read and follow this Safety Information carefully.
-
-We want you to remain a happy and healthy part of our
-family.
-SAVE THESE INSTRUCTIONS
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-7
-
-About the temperature control dial.
-
-Turning the dial to OFFstops cooling in both compartments—
-fresh food and freezer.
-
-9
-
-OFF
-
-7
-
-5
-
-3
-
-1
-
-Control Settings
-Temperature Control Dial
-
-The temperature control dial has nine settings plus OFF.
-1 is the warmest. 9 is the coldest. At first, set the dial at 5.
-
-After using the refrigerator, adjust the dial if necessary.
-
-Insert a coin into the slot in the middle of the dial and you can turn
-the dial to the setting that’s best suited to your needs.
-
-Allow 24 hours for the refrigerator to get cold.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-8
-
-About the fresh food compartment shelves.
-
-Shelf supports at various levels allow you to custom-space your shelves.
-Not all features are on all models.
-
-2 Lift up and out
-
-1 Tilt up
-
-Half-Width Shelves
-
-One end of the shelf rests on a molded side-wall
-support; a bracket on the other end hooks into a track
-on the rear cabinet wall.
-
-To remove,lift the shelf up at front, then off the support
-and out of the track.
-
-To replace,select desired shelf height. With shelf front
-raised slightly, hook the bracket’s top lug into the track,
-then lower the shelf onto the support.
-
-NOTE: The shelf to the right of the track is designed to
-hook into the right-hand slot; the shelf to the left is
-designed to hook into the left-hand slot.
-
-Full-Width Shelves
-
-Some models have a steel wire sliding shelf, a stationary
-tempered glass shelf or two steel wire stationary shelves.
-These shelves can be moved to another place in the
-fresh food compartment.
-
-The full-width sliding shelf has stop-locks. When placed
-correctly on the shelf supports, the shelf will stop before
-coming completely out of the refrigerator and will not
-tilt when you place food on it or remove food from it.
-
-To remove the full-width shelves,lift the rear of the shelf
-and pull forward.
-
-To remove a full-width shelf when the fresh food
-compartment door cannot be opened fully,lift the rear of
-the shelf, pull forward and down, tilt the shelf and take it
-out.
-
-9
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-About the freezer compartment shelves.
-
-Some models have an ice-tray shelf and some have a full-width step shelf.
-
-Plug Supports
-
-Ice-Tray Shelf
-
-To remove the ice-tray shelf:Lift the left side of the shelf
-off its supports, then pull the shelf to the left to free it of
-the plug supports. Pull the shelf to the right to free the
-pins from the holes in the cabinet wall.
-
-(cid:49)
-
-(cid:50)
-
-Step Shelf
-
-To remove the step shelf:
-
-1
-2
-
-3
-
-Lift left side of shelf slightly.
-
-Move shelf to the left to free its right ends from holes
-in the cabinet wall.
-
-Lower right side of shelf, move shelf to the right and
-take it out.
-
-To replace the step shelf:
-
-1
-
-2
-
-With shelf tilted as shown, fit left ends of shelf into
-holes in cabinet wall.
-
-Lift left side of shelf slightly, swing shelf up, fit right
-ends of shelf into holes in cabinet wall, and lower
-shelf into place.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-10
-
-About the storage drawers.
-
-Not all features are on all models.
-
-Fruit and Vegetable Drawers
-
-Excess water that may accumulate in the bottom of the
-drawers should be emptied and the drawers wiped dry.
-
-Utility Drawer
-
-The utility drawer can be moved to the most useful
-location for your family’s needs.
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-11
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-12
-
-About storage drawer and cover removal.
-
-Not all features are on all models.
-
-Drawer and Cover Removal
-
-Drawers will stop before coming all the way out of the refrigerator to
-help prevent contents from spilling onto the floor. These drawers
-can be removed easily by grasping the sides and lifting up slightly
-while pulling drawers past the stoplocation.
-
-Full-Width Drawer with Plastic Cover
-
-To remove the cover, lift it off its supports, pull it
-forward, tilt it and take it out.
-
-Twin Drawer With Glass Cover
-
-To remove:
-
-1
-2
-
-Remove the drawers.
-
-Reach in, push the front of glass cover up and, at the
-same time, pull it forward as far as it will come.
-
-Tilt it and take it out. Avoid cleaning the cold glass cover
-with hot water because the extreme temperature
-difference may cause it to break.
-
-3
-
-Remove the drawer frame. (Always remove the glass
-cover before you take out the drawer frame.)
-
-Lift the frame off the supports at each side and back,
-pull it forward, tilt it and take it out.
-
-To replace:
-
-Lower the frame until it rests on the supports at each
-side and back.
-
-Replace the glass cover, pushing its rear edge firmly
-into the rear frame channel and gently lowering the
-front into place.
-
-Replace the drawers.
-
-1
-
-2
-
-3
-
-About the automatic icemaker.
-
-A newly-installed refrigerator may take 8 to 12 hours to begin making ice.
-
-Icemaker
-
-Feeler arm
-in the STOP
-(up) position
-
-Ice Storage Bin
-
-Automatic Icemaker (on some models)
-
-The icemaker will produce eight cubes per cycle—
-approximately 100 cubes in a 24-hour period,
-depending on freezer compartment temperature, room
-temperature, number of door openings and other use
-conditions.
-
-If the refrigerator is operated before the water
-connection is made to the icemaker, keep the feeler arm
-in the STOP (up) position.
-
-Feeler arm in the
-ON (down) position
-
-When the refrigerator has been connected to the water
-supply, move the feeler arm to the ON (down) position.
-
-The icemaker will fill with water when it cools to
-freezing. A newly-installed refrigerator may take 8 to 12
-hours to begin making ice cubes.
-
-Throw away the first few batches of ice to allow the water
-line to clear.
-
-Be sure nothing interferes with the swing of the feeler
-arm.
-
-It is normal for several cubes to be joined together.
-
-If ice is not used frequently, old ice cubes will become
-cloudy and taste stale.
-
-Icemaker Accessory Kit
-
-If your refrigerator did not come already equipped with an
-automatic icemaker, an icemaker accessory kit is available at extra
-cost. Check the back of the refrigerator for the specific icemaker kit
-needed for your model.
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-13
-
-Care and cleaning of the refrigerator.
-
-Cleaning the Outside
-
-The door handles and trim (on some models). Clean with a cloth
-dampened with soapy water. Dry with a soft cloth.
-
-Keep the outside clean.Wipe with a clean cloth lightly dampened
-with kitchen appliance wax or mild liquid dish detergent. Dry and
-polish with a clean, soft cloth.
-
-Do not wipe the refrigerator with a soiled dish cloth or wet towel. These may
-leave a residue that can erode the paint. Do not use scouring pads, powdered
-cleaners, bleach or cleaners containing bleach because these products can
-scratch and weaken the paint finish.
-
-Cleaning the Inside
-
-To help prevent odors, leave an open box of baking soda in the fresh
-food and freezer compartments.
-
-Unplug the refrigerator before cleaning. If this is not practical, wring
-excess moisture out of sponge or cloth when cleaning around
-switches, lights or controls.
-
-Use warm water and baking soda solution—about a tablespoon
-(15 ml) of baking soda to a quart (1 L) of water. This both cleans
-and neutralizes odors. Rinse and wipe dry.
-
-Use an appliance wax polish on the inside surface between the
-doors.
-
-After cleaning the door gaskets, apply a thin layer of petroleum jelly
-to the door gaskets at the hinge side. This helps keep the gaskets
-from sticking and bending out of shape.
-
-Avoid cleaning cold glass shelves (on some models) with hot water because the
-extreme temperature difference may cause them to break. Handle glass shelves
-carefully. Bumping tempered glass can cause it to shatter.
-
-Do not wash any plastic refrigerator parts in the dishwasher.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-14
-
-Under the Refrigerator
-
-For most efficient operation, keep the area under the
-refrigerator clean. Turn the temperature control dial to
-OFF. Sweep away or vacuum up dust.
-
-Clean the condenser coils at least
-once a year.
-
-For best results, use a brush specially designed for this
-purpose. It is available at most appliance parts stores.
-
-Behind the Refrigerator
-
-Be careful when moving the refrigerator away from the wall. All
-types of floor coverings can be damaged, particularly cushioned
-coverings and those with embossed surfaces.
-
-Turn the leveling legs at each front corner of the refrigerator
-counterclockwise until the rollers support the refrigerator. Pull
-the refrigerator straight out and return it to position by pushing it
-straight in. Moving the refrigerator in a side direction may result in
-damage to the floor covering or refrigerator.
-
-When pushing the refrigerator back, make sure you don’t roll over the power
-cord or icemaker supply line (on some models).
-
-After rolling the refrigerator back into place, turn the legs clockwise
-until the legs again bear the weight of the refrigerator.
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-15
-
-Care and cleaning of the refrigerator.
-
-Light Bulb Replacement
-
-To replace a burned out bulb, unplug the refrigerator from its
-electrical outlet, unscrew the bulb when cool and replace it with an
-appliance bulb of the same or lower wattage.
-
-Turning the control to the OFFposition does not remove power to the light circuit.
-
-Preparing for Vacation
-
-For long vacations or absences, remove food and unplug the
-refrigerator. Turn the temperature control dial to the OFF position,
-and clean the interior with a baking soda solution of one tablespoon
-(15 ml) of baking soda to one quart (1 L) of water. Leave the
-doors open.
-
-Move the icemaker feeler arm to STOP (up) position and shut
-off the water supply to the refrigerator.
-
-If the temperature can drop below freezing, have a qualified
-servicer drain the water supply system (on some models) to prevent
-serious property damage due to flooding.
-
-Preparing to Move
-
-Secure all loose items such as grille, shelves and drawers by taping
-them securely in place to prevent damage.
-
-Be sure the refrigerator stays in an upright position during moving.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-16
-
-Preparing to install the refrigerator.
-
-Read these instructions completely and carefully.
-
-Water Supply to the Icemaker (on some models)
-
-If the refrigerator has an icemaker, or if you plan to add an
-icemaker later, it will have to be connected to a cold water line.
-
-A water supply kit (containing copper tubing, shutoff valve, fittings
-and instructions) is available at extra cost from your dealer or from
-Parts and Accessories, 800-626-2002.
-
-Refrigerator Location
-
-Do not install the refrigerator where the temperature will go below
-60°F. (16°C.) because it will not run often enough to maintain
-proper temperatures.
-
-Install it on a floor strong enough to support it fully loaded.
-
-Clearances
-
-Allow the following clearances for ease of installation, proper air
-circulation and plumbing and electrical connections:
-3/4† (19 mm)
-1† (25 mm)
-1† (25 mm)
-
-Sides
-
-Back
-
-Top
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-17
-
-Preparing to install the refrigerator.
-
-Read these instructions completely and carefully.
-
-Rollers and Leveling Legs
-
-Leveling legsnear each front corner of the refrigerator are adjustable. They
-firmly position the refrigerator and prevent it from moving when the doors are
-opened. Leveling legs should be set so the front of the refrigerator is raised just
-enough that the doors close easily when opened about halfway.
-
-Turn the leveling legs clockwise to raisethe refrigerator, counterclockwise to
-lower it.
-
-Rollersnext to the leveling legs allow you to move the refrigerator away from the
-wall for cleaning.
-
-Turn the legs counterclockwise until the weight of the refrigerator is transferred
-from them to the rollers. After rolling the refrigerator back into place, turn the
-legs clockwise until the legs again bear the weight of the refrigerator.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-18
-
-Installing the water line.
-
-Read these instructions completely and carefully.
-
-Before You Begin
-This water line installation is not warranted by the
-refrigerator or icemaker manufacturer. Follow these
-instructions carefully to minimize the risk of expensive
-water damage.
-
-Water hammer (water banging in the pipes) in house
-plumbing can cause damage to refrigerator parts and lead
-to water leakage or flooding. Call a qualified plumber to
-correct water hammer before installing the water supply
-line to the refrigerator.
-
-To prevent burns and product damage, do not hook up the
-water line to the hot water line.
-
-If you use your refrigerator before connecting the water
-line, make sure the icemaker feeler arm is kept in the STOP
-(up) position.
-
-Do not install the icemaker tubing in areas where
-temperatures fall below freezing.
-
-When using any electrical device (such as a power drill)
-during installation, be sure the device is insulated or wired
-in a manner to prevent the hazard of electric shock.
-
-All installations must be in accordance with local plumbing
-code requirements.
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-19
-
-Installing the water line.
-
-Read these instructions completely and carefully.
-
-What You Will Need
-To determine how much copper tubing you need:
-
-Measure the distance from the water valve on the back of the
-refrigerator to the water supply pipe. Then add 8 feet (244 cm).
-Be sure there is sufficient extra tubing [about 8 feet (244 cm)
-coiled into 3 turns of about 10 inches (25 cm) diameter] to allow
-the refrigerator to move out from the wall after installation.
-n A water supply kit(containing copper tubing, shutoff valve and
-fittings listed below) is available at extra cost from your dealer
-or from Parts and Accessories, 800-626-2002.
-
-n Cold water supply.The water pressure must be between
-
-20 and 120 p.s.i.
-
-n Power drill.
-
-n Copper tubing,1/4† outer diameter to connect the refrigerator to
-the water supply. Be sure both ends of the tubing are cut square.
-
-Do not use plastic tubing or plastic fittings because the water supply line is
-under pressure at all times. Certain types of plastic tubing may become brittle
-with age and crack, resulting in water leakage.
-
-n Two 1/4† outer diameter compression nuts and 2 ferrules (sleeves)—
-
-to connect the copper tubing to the shutoff valve and the
-refrigerator water valve.
-
-n If your existing water line has a flared fitting at the end, you will
-
-need an adapter(available at plumbing supply stores) to connect
-the water line to the refrigerator ORyou can cut off the flared
-fitting with a tube cutter and then use a compression fitting.
-n Shutoff valve to connect to the cold water line. The shutoff valve
-should have a water inlet with a minimum inside diameter of
-5/32† at the point of connection to the COLD WATER LINE.Saddle-
-type shutoff valves are included in many water supply kits. Before
-purchasing, make sure a saddle-type valve complies with your
-local plumbing codes.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-20
-
-Shut Off the Main Water Supply
-
-Turn on the nearest faucet long enough to clear the line of water.
-
-Install the Shutoff Valve
-1
-2
-
-Install the shutoff valve on the nearest frequently used drinking water line.
-
-Choose a location for the valve that is easily accessible. It is best to connect
-into the side of a vertical water pipe. When it is necessary to connect into a
-horizontal water pipe, make the connection to the top or side, rather than at
-the bottom, to avoid drawing off any sediment from the water pipe.
-Drill a 1/4† hole in the water pipe, using a sharp bit. Remove any burrs
-resulting from drilling the hole in the pipe.
-
-3
-
-4
-5
-
-Fasten the shutoff valve to the cold water pipe with the pipe clamp.
-
-Tighten the clamp screws until the sealing washer begins to swell.
-
-Do not overtighten or you may crush the copper tubing.
-
-Pipe Clamp
-
-Washer
-
-Inlet End
-
-Saddle-Type Shutoff Valve
-
-Vertical Cold Water Pipe
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-21
-
-Installing the water line.
-
-Read these instructions completely and carefully.
-
-Route the Copper Tubing and Connect It to the Shutoff Valve
-
-Route the copper tubing between the cold water line and the refrigerator.
-
-Route the tubing through a hole drilled in the wall or floor (behind the
-refrigerator or adjacent base cabinet) as close to the wall as possible.
-
-Be sure there is sufficient extra tubing [about 8 feet (244 cm) coiled into 3 turns of about
-10† (25 cm) diameter] to allow the refrigerator to move out from the wall after installation.
-
-Place the compression nut and ferrule (sleeve) onto the end of the tubing and
-connect it to the shutoff valve.
-
-Make sure the tubing is fully inserted into the valve. Tighten the compression nut
-securely.
-
-Saddle-Type Shutoff Valve
-
-Compression Nut
-
-Packing
-Nut
-
-Outlet Valve
-
-Ferrule (sleeve)
-
-Turn On the Water and Flush Out the Tubing
-1
-
-Turn the main water supply on and flush out the tubing until the water
-is clear.
-
-2
-
-Shut the water off at the water valve after about one quart (1 L) of water has
-been flushed through the tubing.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-22
-
-Connect the Tubing to the Refrigerator
-
-Before making the connection to the refrigerator, be sure the
-refrigerator power cord is not plugged into the wall outlet.
-
-We recommend installing a water filter if your water supply has sand or particles
-that could clog the screen of the refrigerator’s water valve. Install it in the water
-line near the refrigerator.
-
-1
-2
-
-3
-
-4
-
-Remove the plastic flexible cap from the water valve.
-
-Place the compression nut and ferrule (sleeve) onto the end of the tubing as
-shown.
-
-Insert the end of the copper tubing into the water valve connection as far as
-possible. While holding the tubing, tighten the fitting.
-
-Fasten the copper tubing into the clamp provided to hold it in a vertical
-position. You may need to pry open the clamp.
-
-1/4† Copper Tubing
-
-Tubing Clamp
-
-Ferrule (sleeve)
-
-1/4† Compression Nut
-
-Refrigerator Connection
-
-Turn the Water On at the Shutoff Valve
-
-Tighten any connections that leak.
-
-Plug In the Refrigerator
-
-Arrange the coil of copper tubing so that it does not vibrate against the back of
-the refrigerator or against the wall.
-
-Push the refrigerator back to the wall.
-
-Start the Icemaker
-
-Set the icemaker feeler arm to the ON (down) position. The icemaker will
-not begin to operate until it reaches its operating temperature of 15°F. (-9°C.)
-or below. It will then begin operation automatically if the icemaker feeler arm
-is in the ON(down) position.
-
-NOTE: The icemaker may double-cycle when it first starts, causing some water spillage from
-the icemaker into the ice bucket. This is normal and should not happen again.
-
-23
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-Reversing the door swing.
-
-Read these instructions completely and carefully.
-
-Important Notes
-When reversing the door swing :
-
-n Read the instructions all the way through before starting.
-n Handle parts carefully to avoid scratching paint.
-n Set screws down by their related parts to avoid using them in the
-
-wrong places.
-
-n Provide a non-scratching work surface for the doors.
-IMPORTANT: Once you begin, do not move the cabinet until
-door-swing reversal is completed.
-
-These instructions are for changing the hinges from the
-right side to the left side—if you ever want to change the
-hinges back to the right side, follow these same instructions
-and reverse all references to left and right.
-
-Tools Required
-n 5/16† hex-head socket screwdriver
-n Masking tape
-n T20 or T25 Torxdriver, whichever your model requires
-n Putty knife or thin-blade screwdriver
-n 5/16† open-end wrench
-n Phillips screwdriver
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-24
-
-Removing the doors.
-
-Unplug the refrigerator from its electrical outlet.
-
-Before Removing the Doors
-1
-2
-CAUTION: Do not let either door drop to the floor. To do so could
-damage the door stop.
-
-Empty all door shelves, including the dairy compartment.
-
-Remove the Freezer Door
-1
-2
-
-Tape the door shut with masking tape.
-With a 5/16† hex-head socket screwdriver, remove the screws that hold the
-top hinge to the cabinet.
-
-3
-
-4
-
-5
-6
-
-Lift the hinge (and the shim glued to it) straight up to free the hinge pin
-from the socket in the top of the door and set it aside, along with its screws.
-
-Remove the tape, tilt the door away from the cabinet and carefully lift the
-door to free its bottom socket from the hinge pin on the center hinge
-bracket.
-
-Set the door on a non-scratching surface with the outside up.
-
-Using a Torxdriver, transfer the 2 screws from the opposite side of the
-cabinet to the screw holes vacated by the top hinge removal.
-
-Top Hinge
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-25
-
-Removing the doors/Reversing the hardware.
-
-Read these instructions completely and carefully.
-
-Remove the Fresh Food Door
-1
-2
-
-Tape the door shut with masking tape.
-Using a 5/16† hex-head socket screwdriver and a 5/16† open-end wrench,
-remove the two screws holding the center hinge (and the shim glued to it) to
-the cabinet. Lift the center hinge to free its pin from the socket in the top of
-the door, and set hinge and screws aside.
-
-3
-
-4
-5
-
-6
-
-Remove the tape and tilt the door away from the cabinet. Lift the door from
-the pin in the bottom hinge bracket. (If the plastic washer sticks to the door
-bottom, put it back on the hinge.)
-
-Set the door outside-up on a non-scratching surface.
-
-Using a Torxdriver, transfer the two screws from the opposite side of the
-cabinet to the screw holes vacated by the center hinge removal.
-
-Take one of the screws removed in step 2 and start it in the outermost screw
-hole on the opposite side. Do not drive it all the way down—leave enough
-space under the screw head for thickness of shim and bracket.
-
-Center Hinge Bracket
-
-Hinge Pin
-
-Plastic Washer
-
-Transfer Bottom Hinge to the Left
-1
-
-Remove the base grille (if your refrigerator has one) by pulling it straight
-out.
-
-2
-
-Using a Torxdriver, move the bottom hinge bracket (and the shim glued to
-it) and plastic washer from the right side to the left side.
-
-Plastic Washer
-
-Hinge Bracket
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-26
-
-Reversing the door handles.
-
-Transfer Top Hinge to the Left
-
-Interchange hinge (and the shim glued to it) and screws at top right with screws
-at top left of cabinet.
-
-Do not tighten screws on hinge side at this time.
-
-Some hinges have four holes. Which holes you use for installing the hinge
-depends on which side you install the hinge.
-
-Installing the hinge on the left.
-
-Installing the hinge on the right.
-
-Transfer Fresh Food Door Handle
-
-Top View
-
-Bottom View
-
-1
-
-2
-
-3
-4
-
-Remove the bottom cap by
-pushing it toward the bottom of
-the door and remove the screw
-underneath.
-
-Remove the two screws holding
-the handle to the top of the door.
-
-Remove the handle.
-
-Remove the screws from the right
-edge of the door top and insert
-them into the handle screw holes
-on the opposite side.
-
-5
-
-6
-
-With tape-tipped putty knife or
-thin-blade screwdriver, pry out the
-plug button from the hinge hole
-on the left side of the door and
-insert it into the hole on the
-opposite side that was vacated by
-removal of the top hinge.
-
-Pull the plug button from the
-front of the door and transfer it to
-the opposite side.
-
-Plug Button
-
-Screws for
-Handle Holes
-
-Plug Button
-
-To reattach the handle on the
-opposite side.
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-27
-
-Rehanging the doors.
-
-Read these instructions completely and carefully.
-
-Transfer Door Stop
-1
-
-Move the metal door stop from
-the right end to the left end. Use a
-Torxdriver.
-
-Door Stop
-
-2
-
-Move any screws from the left end
-to the right end.
-
-Right Side
-
-Left Side
-
-Reinstalling the Fresh Food Door Handle
-1
-
-Attach the handle to the right side of the door with screws at the top and
-under the handle plug.
-
-Reinstall the handle plug.
-
-2
-Transfer Freezer Door Handle
-1
-
-Remove the screw holding the handle to the top of the door and the two
-screws holding the handle to the bottom of the door.
-
-2
-3
-
-4
-
-5
-6
-
-Remove the handle.
-
-Remove the screw from the right top edge of the door and insert it into the
-handle screw hole on the left side.
-
-Pull the plug button from the left top edge of the door and transfer it to the
-opposite side.
-
-Transfer the door stop as shown above.
-
-Attach the handle to the right edge of the door with screws at top and
-bottom, using bottom holes vacated by removal of the door stop screws.
-
-Left Side
-
-Right Side
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-28
-
-Rehang the Fresh Food Door
-1
-
-Lower the bottom socket of the fresh food door onto the pin on the bottom
-hinge.
-
-Be sure the washer is in place on the pin.
-
-2
-
-3
-
-Insert the pin on the center hinge into the socket in the top of the door.
-NOTE:The center hinge must be turned over as shown when mounted on the
-left side.
-
-Tilt the door toward the cabinet. As the door is brought into position, slide
-the hinge under the head of the screw which earlier had been partly driven
-into the outermost hole. Insert the remaining screw, then tighten both
-screws securely.
-
-Hinge Pin
-
-Plastic
-Washer
-
-Hinge Pin
-
-Plastic Washer
-
-Rehang the Freezer Door
-1
-
-Be sure the washer is in place on the pin.
-
-Lower the bottom socket of the freezer door onto the center hinge pin.
-
-2
-
-3
-
-Tilt the door toward the cabinet, lifting the top hinge so the pin fits into the
-socket on the top of the door.
-
-Make sure the door is straight and the gap between the doors is even
-across the front. Tighten the top hinge screws. Do not overtighten these
-screws—tighten them until they are just snug, then turn them another one-
-half turn.
-
-Center Hinge Pin
-
-Plastic Washer
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-29
-
-Normal operating sounds.
-
-Depending on the placement of the refrigerator in your kitchen,
-you may want to place a piece of rubber backed carpet under
-the refrigerator to reduce noise.
-
-The fan circulating air inside the freezer which
-keeps the temperatures even.
-
-Boiling water or a gurgling noise. The flow of
-refrigerant through the freezer cooling coils.
-
-Sizzling, hissing or popping sound. Water
-dropping on the defrost heater during the
-defrost cycle.
-
-Cracking or popping sound. Cooling coils
-expanding and contracting during the
-defrosting cycle.
-
-Water dripping as it melts from the evaporator
-and flows to the drain pan during the defrost
-cycle.
-
-Icemaker (on some models)
-
-The icemaker water valve will buzz when the
-icemaker fills with water. If the feeler arm is in
-the ON(down) position it will buzz even if it has
-not yet been hooked up to water. Keeping the
-feeler arm in the ON(down) position before it is
-hooked up to water can damage the icemaker.
-To prevent this, raise the feeler arm to the STOP
-(up) position. This will stop the buzzing.
-
-The sound of cubes dropping into the bin and
-water running in pipes as icemaker refills.
-
-These sounds are normal
-and are due mostly to highly
-efficient operation.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-30
-
-Before you call for service…
-
-Troubleshooting Tips
-Save time and money! Review the charts on the following pages first and
-you may not need to call for service.
-
-Problem
-
-Possible Causes
-
-What To Do
-
-Refrigerator does not
-operate
-
-Refrigerator in
-defrost cycle.
-
-Temperature control
-dial in OFFposition.
-
-Refrigerator is
-unplugged.
-
-The fuse is blown/
-circuit breaker is
-tripped.
-
-Normal when
-refrigerator is first
-plugged in.
-
-Often occurs when large
-amounts of food are
-placed in refrigerator.
-
-Door left open.
-
-• Wait about 30 minutes for
-
-defrost cycle to end.
-
-• Move the temperature
-
-control dial to a
-temperature setting.
-
-• Push the plug completely
-
-into the outlet.
-
-• Replace fuse or reset the
-
-breaker.
-
-• Wait 24 hours for the
-
-refrigerator to completely
-cool down.
-
-• This is normal.
-
-• Check to see if package is
-
-holding door open.
-
-Hot weather or frequent
-door openings.
-
-• This is normal.
-
-Temperature control dial
-set at the coldest setting.
-
-• See About the temperature
-
-control dial.
-
-Grille and condenser
-need cleaning.
-
-Front roller screws or
-front leveling legs need
-adjusting.
-
-• See Care and cleaning.
-
-• See Rollers and leveling legs.
-
-Motor operates for long
-periods or cycles on and
-off frequently. (Modern
-refrigerators with more
-storage space and a larger
-freezer require more
-operating time. They start
-and stop often to maintain
-even temperatures.)
-
-Vibration or rattling
-(slight vibration is normal)
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-31
-
-Before you call for service…
-
-Troubleshooting Tips
-
-Problem
-
-Possible Causes
-
-What To Do
-
-Fresh food or freezer
-compartment too warm
-
-Temperature control
-dial not set cold enough.
-
-• See About the temperature
-
-control dial.
-
-Warm weather or
-frequent door openings.
-
-Door left open.
-
-Package blocking air
-duct in freezer
-compartment.
-
-Door left open.
-
-Too frequent or too
-long door openings.
-
-• Set the temperature
-control dial one step
-colder. See About the
-temperature control dial.
-
-• Check to see if package is
-
-holding door open.
-
-• Check to see if package is
-
-blocking air duct in freezer
-compartment.
-
-• Check to see if package is
-
-holding door open.
-
-Icemaker feeler arm in
-STOP (up) position.
-
-• Move the feeler arm to the
-
-ON (down) position.
-
-Water supply turned
-off or not connected.
-
-Freezer compartment
-too warm.
-
-Water shutoff valve
-connecting refrigerator
-to water line may be
-clogged.
-
-• See Installing thewater line.
-
-• Wait 24 hours for the
-
-refrigerator to completely
-cool down.
-
-• Call a plumber to clear
-
-the valve.
-
-Frost or ice crystals on
-frozen food (frost within
-package is normal)
-
-Automatic icemaker
-does not work
-(on some models)
-
-Cubes too small
-
-Slow ice cube freezing
-
-Door left open.
-
-• Check to see if package is
-
-holding door open.
-
-Temperature control
-dial not set cold enough.
-
-• See About the temperature
-
-control dial.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-32
-
-Problem
-
-Ice cubes have
-odor/taste
-
-Possible Causes
-
-What To Do
-
-Ice storage bin needs
-cleaning.
-
-• Empty and wash bin.
-Discard old cubes.
-
-Food transmitting odor/
-taste to ice cubes.
-
-Interior of refrigerator
-needs cleaning.
-
-• Wrap foods well.
-
-• See Care andcleaning.
-
-Moisture forms on
-cabinet surface
-between the doors
-
-Moisture collects inside
-(in humid weather, air
-carries moisture into
-refrigerator when doors
-are opened)
-
-Refrigerator has odor
-
-Not unusual during
-periods of high
-humidity.
-
-Too frequent or too
-long door openings.
-
-Foods transmitting
-odor to refrigerator.
-
-• Wipe surface dry and
-
-reset temperature control
-dial one setting colder.
-
-• Foods with strong odors
-
-should be tightly wrapped.
-• Keep an open box of baking
-soda in the refrigerator;
-replace every three months.
-
-Interior needs cleaning.
-
-• See Care and cleaning.
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-33
-
-Notes
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-34
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-35
-
-Notes
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-36
-
-GE Service Protection Plus™
-
-GE, a name recognized worldwide for quality and dependability,
-offers you Service Protection Plus™—comprehensive protection on
-all your appliances—No Matter What Brand!
-
-Benefits Include:
-• Backed by GE
-• All brands covered
-• Unlimited service calls
-• All parts and labor costs included
-• No out-of-pocket expenses
-• No hidden deductibles
-• One 800 number to call
-
-We’ll Cover Any Appliance.
-Anywhere. Anytime.*
-
-You will be completely satisfied with our service protection or you may request your
-money back on the remaining value of your contract. No questions asked. It’s that simple.
-
-Protect your refrigerator, dishwasher, washer and dryer, range, TV, VCR and much
-more—any brand! Plus there’s no extra charge for emergency service and low monthly
-financing is available. Even icemaker coverage and food spoilage protection is offered.
-You can rest easy, knowing that all your valuable household products are protected
-against expensive repairs.
-
-Place your confidence in GE and call us in the U.S. toll-free at 800-626-2224
-for more information.
-
-*All brands covered, up to 20 years old, in the continental U.S.
-
-"
-
-Cut here
-
-Please place in envelope and mail to:
-
-General Electric Company
-Warranty Registration Department
-P.O. Box 34070
-Louisville, KY 40232-4070
-
-37
-
-Consumer Product Ownership Registration
-Dear Customer:
-Thank you for purchasing our product and thank you for placing your confidence in us.
-We are proud to have you as a customer!
-
-Follow these three steps to protect your new appliance investment:
-
-1
-
-Complete and mail
-your Consumer
-Product Ownership
-Registration today.
-Have the peace of
-mind of knowing
-we can contact you
-in the unlikely event of a safety
-modification.
-
-2
-
-After mailing
-the registration
-below, store this
-document in a safe
-place. It contains
-information you
-will need should
-
-you require service. Our
-service number is 800 GE
-CARES (800-432-2737).
-
-3
-
-Read your
-Owner’s Manual
-carefully.
-It will help you
-operate your
-new appliance
-properly.
-
-If you have questions, or need
-more information, call the GE
-Answer Center® 800.626.2000.
-
-Model Number
-
-Serial Number
-
-Important: If you did not get a registration card with your product,
-
-detach and return the form below to ensure that your
-product is registered.
-
-"
-Consumer Product Ownership Registration
-
-Cut here
-
-Important
-Mail
-Today!
-
-First
-Name
-
-Street
-Address
-
-Apt. #
-
-City
-
-Model Number
-
-Serial Number
-
-Mr. (cid:108) Ms. (cid:108) Mrs. (cid:108) Miss (cid:108)
-
-Last
-Name
-
-E-mail Address
-
-State
-
-Zip
-Code
-
-Date Placed In Use
-
-Month
-
-Day
-
-Year
-
-Phone
-Number
-
-Occasionally, we may allow selected companies to send you information.
-(cid:108) Check here if you do not want this information.
-
-GE Appliances
-General Electric Company
-Louisville, Kentucky 40225
-www.ge.com/appliances
-
-38
-
-Refrigerator Warranty (For customers in the United States)
-
-All warranty service provided by our Factory Service Centers,
-or an authorized Customer Care®technician. For service,
-call 800-GE-CARES.
-
-For The Period Of: We Will Replace, At No Charge To You:
-
-One Year
-From the date of the
-original purchase
-
-Five Years
-From the date of the
-original purchase
-
-Any partof the refrigerator which fails due to a defect
-in materials or workmanship. During this full one-year
-warranty, we will also provide, free of charge, all labor
-and in-home service to replace the defective part.
-
-Any part of the sealed refrigerating system
-(the compressor, condenser, evaporator and all
-connecting tubing) which fails due to a defect in
-materials or workmanship. During this additional
-four-year warranty, we will also provide, free of charge,
-all labor and in-home service to replace the
-defective part.
-
-What Is Not Covered:
-
-n Service trips to your home to teach you
-
-how to use the product.
-
-n Improper installation.
-
-n Failure of the product if it is
-
-abused, misused, or used for other
-than the intended purpose or used
-commercially.
-
-n Loss of food due to spoilage.
-
-n Replacement of house fuses or
-resetting of circuit breakers.
-
-n Damage to the product caused by
-
-accident, fire, floods or acts of God.
-
-n Incidental or consequential damage to
-personal property caused by possible
-defects with this appliance.
-
-This warranty is extended to the original purchaser and any succeeding owner for products purchased
-for home use within the USA. In Alaska, the warranty excludes the cost of shipping or service calls to
-your home.
-
-Some states do not allow the exclusion or limitation of incidental or consequential damages. This
-warranty gives you specific legal rights, and you may also have other rights which vary from state to
-state. To know what your legal rights are, consult your local or state consumer affairs office or your
-state’s Attorney General.
-
-Warrantor: General Electric Company. Louisville, KY 40225
-
-39
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-Service Telephone Numbers.
-
-GE Answer Center® 800.626.2000
-
-The GE Answer Center® is open 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
-
-In-Home Repair Service800-GE-CARES (800-432-2737)
-
-Expert GE repair service is only a phone call away.
-
-Special Needs Service800.626.2000
-TDD 800-TDD-GEAC (800-833-4322)
-
-GE offers, free of charge, a brochure to assist in planning a barrier-
-free kitchen for persons with limited mobility.
-
-Service Contracts800-626-2224
-
-Purchase a GE service contract while your warranty is still in effect
-and you’ll receive a substantial discount. GE Consumer Service will
-still be there after your warranty expires.
-
-Parts and Accessories800-626-2002
-
-Individuals qualified to service their own appliances can have parts
-or accessories sent directly to their homes (VISA, MasterCard and
-Discover cards are accepted).
-Instructions contained in this manual cover procedures to be performed
-by any user. Other servicing generally should be referred to qualified
-service personnel. Caution must be exercised, since improper servicing
-may cause unsafe operation.
-
-Service Satisfaction
-
-If you are not satisfied with the service you receive from GE, follow
-these steps. First, contact the people who serviced your appliance.
-Next, if you are still not pleased, write all the details—including your
-phone number—to: Manager, Consumer Relations, GE Appliances,
-Appliance Park, Louisville, KY 40225.
-
-40
-
-Printed in Louisville, KY
+Notes: Some workout types don't support the above four settings. The settings might slightly vary
+in workout type.
diff --git a/q12/random_k4/question.json b/q12/random_k4/question.json
index a61a792157cc749b88fbeb1fb32c0f42982f60e5..d68acaf914974cb3393889592b16db50ce41f1b7 100644
--- a/q12/random_k4/question.json
+++ b/q12/random_k4/question.json
@@ -17,10 +17,10 @@
],
"original_filenames": [
"2401.18059v1.pdf",
- "web_c83d6885217d96f0.pdf",
- "web_ffc784688ff74004.pdf",
- "web_a84abfae977a788a.pdf",
- "675e3aeb6d0fc8bd13ab143192bd5d7a21a66de2.pdf"
+ "web_f77c9a6a0c40e754.pdf",
+ "resize_r1_31.pdf",
+ "web_a290dd87b6ce3b94.pdf",
+ "resize_fb_1.pdf"
],
"modality": "markdown"
}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/q12/random_k4/random_1.md b/q12/random_k4/random_1.md
index dd5d594edac856e6a90c63c0d5c3c52351225e37..e93939cddbb26da056c6d4cb5d86060af787292b 100644
--- a/q12/random_k4/random_1.md
+++ b/q12/random_k4/random_1.md
@@ -1,771 +1,979 @@
-1
-PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-2024 PEW RESEARCH CENTER’S AMERICAN TRENDS PANEL
-WAVE 159 POLITICS SURVEY NOVEMBER 2024
-FINAL TOPLINE
-NOVEMBER 12-17, 2024
-N=9,609
-Note: This survey was conducted primarily online, with some interviews conducted by live telephone. This
-topline shows the programming language for online administration. For details on how questions were slightly
-modified for phone administration, visit the questionnaire.
-American Trends Panel surveys conducted between October 2016 and June 2024 were conducted fully online
-(with tablets and data plans provided to adults without home internet). American Trends Panel surveys
-conducted prior to October 2016 were conducted primarily online, with some respondents completing by mail.
-For additional details, refer to the methodology.
-* “No answer” includes web respondents who do not answer the question as well as telephone respondents
-who refuse to answer or who say that they don’t know how to answer. In cases where “not sure” was offered
-as an explicit option to web and telephone respondents, the “no answer” category includes only web skips and
-telephone refusals.
-In addition to the parameters used in weighting each wave of the American Trends Panel, the results of this
-survey were weighted to the 2024 presidential popular vote and turnout among the voting-eligible population
-(as of Nov. 18, 2024). For additional information, refer to the methodology.
-ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS PREVIOUSLY RELEASED
-ASK ALL CITIZENS (XCITIZEN=1) [N=9,302]:
-VOTED Which of the following statements best describes you?
-Nov 29-
-Nov 12-17, Nov 16-27, Nov 12-17, Nov 7-16, Dec 12,
-2024 20221 2020 2018 2016
-I did not vote in the November
-22 2024 election 32 22 23 14
-13 I planned to vote but wasn’t able to 20 9 22 8
-I definitely voted in the November
-65 2024 election 47 67 55 77
-1 No answer* 1 2 1 1
-1 In 2022 and 2018, this question was asked about that November’s congressional election. In 2020 and 2016, this question
-was asked about that November’s presidential election.
-www.pewresearch.org
+INTRODUCING THE WINDOWS AZURE
+PLATFORM
+
+DAVID CHAPPELL
+
+OCTOBER 2010
+
+SPONSORED BY MICROSOFT CORPORATION
+
+CONTENTS
+
+An Overview of the Windows Azure Platform ....................................................................................... 3
+
+Windows Azure ........................................................................................................................................ 4
+
+SQL Azure ................................................................................................................................................. 6
+
+Windows Azure AppFabric....................................................................................................................... 8
+
+Windows Azure MarketPlace .................................................................................................................. 9
+
+A Closer Look at the Technologies ....................................................................................................... 10
+
+Windows Azure ...................................................................................................................................... 10
+
+Compute ............................................................................................................................................ 11
+
+Storage .............................................................................................................................................. 12
+
+Fabric Controller ................................................................................................................................ 14
+
+Content Delivery Network ................................................................................................................. 14
+
+Connect ............................................................................................................................................. 15
+
+SQL Azure ............................................................................................................................................... 15
+
+Database ........................................................................................................................................... 15
+
+Reporting ........................................................................................................................................... 17
+
+Data Sync .......................................................................................................................................... 17
+
+Windows Azure AppFabric..................................................................................................................... 19
+
+Service Bus ........................................................................................................................................ 19
+
+Access Control ................................................................................................................................... 21
+
+Caching .............................................................................................................................................. 23
+
+Windows Azure Marketplace ................................................................................................................ 24
+
+Looking Ahead .................................................................................................................................... 26
+
+Conclusions ......................................................................................................................................... 26
+
+About the Author ................................................................................................................................ 27
2
-PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-ASK IF VOTED (VOTED=3) [N=8,072]:
-VOTEGEN_POST In the 2024 presidential election, who did you vote for? [RANDOMIZE OPTIONS 1 AND 2
-FIRST FOLLOWED BY RANDOMIZED OPTIONS 3,4,5,6,7 WITH OPTION 8 AND 9 ALWAYS LAST]
-Nov 12-17,
-| 2024 | | | | | | | | | |
-| ----- | ----------------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| 49 | Donald Trump, the Republican | | | | | | | | |
-| 47 | Kamala Harris, the Democrat | | | | | | | | |
-| * | Robert F. Kennedy Jr., a third party candidate | | | | | | | | |
-| * | Chase Oliver, the Libertarian Party candidate | | | | | | | | |
-| * | Jill Stein, the Green Party candidate | | | | | | | | |
-| * | Cornel West, a third party candidate | | | | | | | | |
-| * | Claudia De la Cruz, the Socialism and Liberation Party candidate | | | | | | | | |
-| * | Another candidate | | | | | | | | |
-| 2 | I did not vote for a candidate for president | | | | | | | | |
-| * | No answer* | | | | | | | | |
-
-ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE
-
-ASK IF DID NOT VOTE (VOTED=1-2) [N=1,201]:
-| WISH_VOTED | Do you wish that you had voted in the election? | | | | | | | | |
-| ----------- | ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-
-| | | | | | | Nov 29- | | Nov 17- | |
-| ----------- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- | -------- | --- |
-| Nov 12-17, | | Nov 12-17, | | Nov 7-16, | | Dec 12 | | Dec 15, | |
-| 2024 | | 2020 | | 2018 | | 2016 | | 2014 | |
-| 42 | Yes | | 45 | 61 | | 44 | | 55 | |
-| 57 | No | | 54 | 38 | | 55 | | 43 | |
-| 1 | No answer* | | 1 | | 1 | * | | 1 | |
-
-ASK IF CITIZEN AND DID NOT VOTE (X_CITIZEN=1 AND VOTED=1,2) [N=1,201]:
-NOVOTERSN2 There are lots of different reasons why many people don’t vote. For you personally,
-how much of a reason, if at all, is each of the following for why you did not vote?
-[RANDOMIZE]
-
-| | | | Major | | Minor | | Not a | | No |
-| ----- | ------------------------------------ | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | --- | -------- |
-| | | | reason | | reason | | reason | | answer* |
-| DIFF | I didn’t think my vote would make a | | | | | | | | |
-difference
-| | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | 35 | | | 26 | 39 | | 1 |
-| ----- | -------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | Nov 7-16, 2018 | | 21 | | | 23 | 55 | | 1 |
-| | | | | | | | | | |
-| CARE | I didn’t care who won2 | | | | | | | | |
-| | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | 17 | | | 21 | 61 | | 1 |
-| | Nov 7-16, 2018 | | 12 | | | 23 | 64 | | 1 |
-| | | | | | | | | | |
-| ELGB | I’m not registered or not eligible to | | | | | | | | |
- vote
-| | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | 18 | | | 15 | 66 | | 1 |
-| ----- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | Nov 7-16, 2018 | | 19 | | | 10 | 70 | | 1 |
-| | | | | | | | | | |
-| INCV | It was too inconvenient for me to vote | | | | | | | | |
-| | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | 15 | | | 22 | 62 | | 1 |
-| | Nov 7-16, 2018 | | 20 | | | 21 | 59 | | 1 |
-| | | | | | | | | | |
-
-2 In 2018, the reason was worded “I didn’t care who won the congressional election in my area.”
-www.pewresearch.org
-3
-PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-| NOVOTERSN2 CONTINUED … | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| ----------------------- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ------- | ------ | --- | ------- | -------- | --- |
-| | | | | Major | | | Minor | | Not a | No | |
-| | | | | reason | | reason | | | reason | answer* | |
-| LIKE | | I don’t like politics | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | 31 | | | 25 | | 43 | 1 | |
-| | | Nov 7-16, 2018 | | 26 | | | 23 | | 50 | 1 | |
-| | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| FRGT | | I forgot to vote | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | 8 | | 13 | | 79 | 1 | |
-| | | Nov 7-16, 2018 | | | 7 | | 15 | | 77 | 1 | |
-| | | | | | | | | | | | |
-
-ASK IF VOTED TRUMP (VOTEGEN_POST=1) [N=3,536]:
-DTFORAGNST_POST Would you say that your vote for Trump was more a vote…
-ASK IF VOTED HARRIS (VOTEGEN_POST=2) [N=4,185]:
-KHFORAGNST_POST Would you say that your vote for Harris was more a vote…
-
-BASED ON VOTERS [N=8,072]:
-
-| | | | | | | Based on registered voters | | | | | |
-| ------------- | ----------- | --- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --------------------------- | ------ | --- | -------------- | --- | --- |
-| | Nov 12-17, | | | | | Sep 30-Oct 6, | | | Aug 26-Sep 2, | | |
-| | 2024 | | | | | | 20243 | | 2024 | | |
-| | 49 | | Trump | | | | 47 | | 49 | | |
-| | 40 | | For Trump | | | | 31 | | 33 | | |
-| | 9 | | Against Harris | | | | 15 | | 16 | | |
-| | * | | Refused | | | | * | | * | | |
-| 47 | | | Harris | | | | 48 | | 49 | | |
-| | 23 | | For Harris | | | | 23 | | 24 | | |
-| | 24 | | Against Trump | | | | 25 | | 25 | | |
-| | * | | Refused | | | | * | | * | | |
-| | 2 | | Vote for Kennedy Jr./Oliver/Stein/West/De | | | | - | | - | | |
-La Cruz/Another candidate
-| | 2 | | I did not vote for a candidate for president | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | * | | No answer* | | | | * | | * | | |
-
-| | | 2020 TREND FOR COMPARISON: | | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | Would you say that your vote for Trump was more a vote… | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | Would you say that your vote for Biden was more a vote… | | | | | | | | | |
-
-| | | | | | Based on voters | | | | Based on registered voters | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | ---------------- | ----------- | --- | -------------- | --------------------------- | --- | ----------- |
-| | | | | | | Nov 12-17, | | Sep 30-Oct 5, | | | Jun 16-22, |
-| | | | | | | 2020 | | | 20204 | | 2020 |
-| | | | Trump | | | 47 | | | 42 | | 44 |
-| | | | For Trump | | | 36 | | | 30 | | 33 |
-| | | | Against Biden | | | 11 | | | 12 | | 10 |
-| | | | Biden | | | 51 | | | 52 | | 54 |
-| | | | For Biden | | | 24 | | | 19 | | 18 |
-| | | | Against Trump | | | 28 | | | 33 | | 36 |
-| | | | Vote for Jorgensen/Hawkins/Another | | | 1 | | | - | | - |
-candidate
-| | | | No answer | | | * | | | * | | - |
-| --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+AN OVERVIEW OF THE WINDOWS AZURE PLATFORM
+
+Using computers in the cloud can make lots of sense. Rather than buying and maintaining your own
+machines, why not exploit the acres of Internet-accessible servers on offer today? For some applications,
+both code and data might live in the cloud, where somebody else manages and maintains the systems
+they use. Alternatively, applications that run inside an organization—on-premises applications—might
+store data in the cloud or rely on other cloud infrastructure services. However it’s done, exploiting the
+cloud’s capabilities can improve our world.
+
+But whether an application runs in the cloud, uses services provided by the cloud, or both, some kind of
+application platform is required. Viewed broadly, an application platform can be thought of as anything
+that provides developer-accessible services for creating applications or storing data. In the on-premises
+Windows world, this includes technologies such as Windows Server and SQL Server. To let applications
+exploit the cloud, a cloud application platform must also exist.
+
+This is exactly what the Microsoft Windows Azure platform provides. It’s a group of cloud technologies,
+each providing a specific set of services to application developers. Figure 1 shows its components.
+
+Figure 1: The Windows Azure platform supports applications, data, and infrastructure in the cloud,
+together with a cloud marketplace.
+
+The Windows Azure platform today has four parts:
+
+ Windows Azure: A Windows environment for running applications and storing data on computers in
+
+Microsoft data centers.
+
+SQL Azure: Relational data services in the cloud based on SQL Server.
+
+ Windows Azure AppFabric: Cloud-based infrastructure services for applications running in the cloud
+
+or on premises.
3
-Trend for DTFORAGNST and KHFORAGNST asked prior to election combined those who said they were voting for the
-candidate or leaning toward the candidate. Postelection versions of these questions asked those who said they voted for
-Trump or Harris.
-4
-Trend for DTFORAGNST and JBFORAGNST asked prior to election combined those who said they were voting for the
-candidate or leaning toward the candidate. Postelection versions of these questions asked those who said they voted for
-Trump or Biden.
-www.pewresearch.org
+
+ Windows Azure Marketplace: An online service for purchasing cloud-based data and applications.
+
+All four of these components run in Microsoft data centers located around the world: two in North
+America, two in Europe, and two in Asia. Developers using the platform can control which data center
+runs their applications and stores their data, giving them the ability to place both closer to their users.
+
+Each part of the Windows Azure platform has its own role to play. This overview describes all four, first at
+a high level, then in a bit more detail. The goal is to provide a big-picture introduction to this cloud
+platform.
+
+WINDOWS AZURE
+
+At a high level, Windows Azure is simple to understand: It runs Windows applications and stores data in
+the cloud. Figure 2 shows its components.
+
+Figure 2: Windows Azure provides compute and storage services in the cloud.
+
+The five parts of Windows Azure today are the following:
+
+ Compute: The Windows Azure compute service runs applications on a Windows Server foundation.
+These applications can be created using the .NET Framework in languages such as C# and Visual Basic,
+or they can be built without .NET in C++, Java, and other languages. Developers can use Visual Studio
+or other development tools, and they’re free to use technologies such as ASP.NET, Windows
+Communication Foundation (WCF), and PHP.
+
+Storage: This service allows storing binary large objects (blobs), provides queues for communication
+between components of Windows Azure applications, and even offers a form of tables with a simple
+query language. (Windows Azure applications that need traditional relational storage can also use
4
-PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-ASK IF VOTED (VOTED=3) [N=8,072]:
-VOTEDECTIME As far as you can remember, when did you make up your mind about who you were going to
-vote for in the presidential election?
-BASED ON THOSE WHO SELECTED A CANDIDATE (VOTEGEN_POST=1-8) [N=7,977]
-Nov 29-
-Nov 12-17, Nov 12-17, Dec 12
-2024 2020 20165
-Last few days before Election
-4 Day 3 9
-The last week before Election
-3 Day 2 4
-7 In October 5 9
-6 In September 5 11
-81 Before September 84 67
-* No answer* * *
-PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON:
-When did you make up your mind definitely to vote for “Hillary Clinton;” “Donald Trump;” “Gary
-Johnson;” “Jill Stein,” “The candidate of your choice”?
-Nov 10-14 Nov 8-11 Nov Nov Nov Nov Nov
-2016 2012 2004 2000 1996 1992 1988
-On Election Day 4 4 4 5 6 9 6
-On Monday (day before the election) * 1 1 2 3 4 3
-Over the last weekend * 1 1 2 2 4 2
-In the last week 2 2 3 5 6 8 4
-In the last few weeks 5 -- -- -- -- -- --
-During or just after the Presidential debates 10 10 11 17 -- 12 --
-Before debates/after the Conventions 10 9 6 9 12 6 16
-Convention period (NET) 22 10 7 7 8 12 15
-During or after the Republican convention 13 9 1 4 -- -- --
-During or after the Democratic convention 9 1 6 3 -- -- --
-This year, before the conventions 22 16 23 21 13 18 19
-Before 2016 20 41 38 20 39 12 9
-Other -- 0 0 -- * 8 --
-Don’t remember 2 1 4 6 6 5 4
-Don’t know/Refused 1 4 2 3 2 1 2
-ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS HELD FOR FUTURE RELEASE
-5 In 2016, people who said “another candidate” were not asked this question; question read “As far as you can remember,
-when did you make up your mind definitely to vote for ‘Donald Trump;’ ‘Hillary Clinton;’ ‘Gary Johnson;’ ‘Jill Stein’?”
-www.pewresearch.org
+
+SQL Azure.) Both Windows Azure applications and on-premises applications can access the Windows
+Azure storage service, and both do it in the same way: using a RESTful approach.
+
+Fabric controller: As the figure suggests, Windows Azure runs on a large number of machines. The
+fabric controller’s job is to knit the machines in a single Windows Azure data center into a cohesive
+whole. The Windows Azure compute and storage services are then built on top of this pool of
+processing power.
+
+ Content delivery network (CDN): Caching frequently accessed data closer to its users speeds up
+access to that data. The Windows Azure CDN can do this for blobs, maintaining cached copies at sites
+around the world.
+
+ Connect: It’s often useful for organizations to interact with cloud applications as if they were inside
+the organization’s own firewall. Windows Azure Connect allows this, making it easier for, say, a
+Windows Azure application to access an on-premises database.
+
+Running applications and storing data in the cloud can have clear benefits. Rather than buying, installing,
+and operating its own systems, for example, an organization can rely on a cloud provider to do this for
+them. Also, customers pay just for the computing and storage they use, rather than maintaining a large
+set of servers only for peak loads. And applications written for Windows Azure can scale better, be more
+reliable, and require less administration than those written using the traditional Windows Server
+programming model.
+
+To create, configure, and monitor applications, Windows Azure customers can use a browser-accessible
+portal. A customer logs in with a Windows Live ID, then chooses whether to create a hosting account for
+running applications, a storage account for storing data, or both. Microsoft then charges each customer
+based on how much compute time, storage, and bandwidth that customer uses. How an application
+charges its own customers—if it charges them at all—is entirely up to the people who create that
+application.
+
+Windows Azure is a general platform that can be used in a broad set of scenarios. Here are a few
+examples:
+
+ An independent software vendor (ISV) creating a software-as-a-service (SaaS) version of an existing
+on-premises Windows application might choose to build it on Windows Azure. Because Windows
+Azure mostly provides a standard Windows environment, moving the application’s business logic to
+this cloud platform won’t typically pose many problems. And once again, building on an existing
+platform lets the ISV focus on business logic—the thing that makes them money—rather than
+spending time on infrastructure.
+
+ An enterprise creating an application for its customers or employees might choose to build it on
+Windows Azure. Because Windows Azure supports .NET, developers with the right skills aren’t
+difficult to find, nor are they prohibitively expensive. Running the application in Microsoft data
+centers frees the enterprise from the responsibility and expense of managing its own servers, turning
+capital expenses into operating expenses. And especially if the application has spikes in usage—
+maybe it’s an on-line flower store that must handle the Mother’s Day rush—letting Microsoft
+maintain the large server base required for this can make economic sense.
5
-PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-[RANDOMIZE ORDER OF VTADMIN_POST_COM AND VTADMIN_POST_US]
-
-ASK ALL:
-VTADMIN_POST_COM Do you think the elections this November in your community were run and
-administered…
-
-| Nov 12-17, | | | Nov 16-27, | | Nov 12-17, | | Nov 7-16, | | | |
-| ----------- | ---------------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- |
-| 2024 | | | 2022 | | 2020 | | 2018 | | | |
-| 55 | Very well | | 42 | | 53 | | 49 | | | |
-| 35 | Somewhat well | | 42 | | 32 | | 38 | | | |
-| 7 | Not too well | | 9 | | 9 | | | 8 | | |
-| 2 | Not at all well | | 4 | | 6 | | | 4 | | |
-| 1 | No answer* | | 3 | | 1 | | | 1 | | |
-
-TREND FOR COMPARISON:
-Do you think the elections this November in your community will be run and administered…
-
-| | | | Sep 30-Oct 6, | | Oct 10-16, | | | Sep 30-Oct 5, | Sep 24-Oct 7, | |
-| --- | ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | -------------- | -------------- | ----- |
-| | | | 2024 | | | 2022 | | 2020 | | 2018 |
-| | Very well | | | 43 | | 40 | | 36 | | 41 |
-| | Somewhat well | | | 44 | | 45 | | 48 | | 46 |
-| | Not too well | | | 8 | | 10 | | 11 | | 9 |
-| | Not at all well | | | 4 | | 4 | | 4 | | 3 |
-| | No answer | | | 1 | | 1 | | * | | 1 |
-
-[RANDOMIZE ORDER OF VTADMIN_POST_COM AND VTADMIN_POST_US]
-
-ASK ALL:
-VTADMIN_POST_US Do you think the elections this November in the United States were run and
-administered…
-
-| Nov 12-17, | | Nov 16-27, | | Nov 12-17, | | | Nov 7-16, | | | |
-| ----------- | ---------------- | ----------- | ----- | ----------- | ----- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- |
-| 2024 | | | 2022 | | 2020 | | 2018 | | | |
-| 37 | Very well | | 25 | | 33 | | 21 | | | |
-| 47 | Somewhat well | | 46 | | 25 | | 53 | | | |
-| 11 | Not too well | | 18 | | 20 | | 18 | | | |
-| 4 | Not at all well | | 8 | | 22 | | 7 | | | |
-| 1 | No answer* | | 3 | | 1 | | 1 | | | |
-
-TREND FOR COMPARISON:
-Do you think the elections this November in the United States will be run and administered…
-
-| | | | Sep 30-Oct 6, | | Oct 10-16, | | | Sep 30-Oct 5, | Sep 24-Oct 7, | |
-| --- | ---------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | -------------- | -------------- | ----- |
-| | | | 2024 | | | 2022 | | 2020 | | 2018 |
-| | Very well | | | 20 | | 20 | | 12 | | 20 |
-| | Somewhat well | | | 50 | | 49 | | 46 | | 57 |
-| | Not too well | | | 21 | | 23 | | 30 | | 18 |
-| | Not at all well | | | 8 | | 7 | | 12 | | 4 |
-| | No answer | | | 1 | | 1 | | 1 | | 1 |
-
-| | | | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-www.pewresearch.org
+
+ A start-up creating a new Web site—the next Facebook, say—could build its application on Windows
+Azure. Because this platform supports both Web-facing services and background processes, the
+application can provide an
+interface as well as executing work for users
+asynchronously. Rather than spending time and money worrying about infrastructure, the start-up
+can instead focus solely on creating code that provides value to its customers and investors. The
+company can also start small, incurring low costs while its application has only a few users. If the
+application catches on and usage increases, Windows Azure can scale the application as needed.
+
+interactive user
+
+These three examples illustrate the kinds of things organizations might do with Windows Azure, but
+they’re not an exhaustive list. As interest in cloud computing continues to grow, expect to see a variety of
+applications created for this cloud platform.
+
+SQL AZURE
+
+Along with running applications, another attractive way to use the cloud is for storing data. SQL Azure
+addresses this area, offering cloud-based services for relational data. As Figure 3 shows, SQL Azure today
+includes three components.
+
+Figure 3: SQL Azure provides relational database services in the cloud.
+
+The components of SQL Azure today are the following:
+
+SQL Azure Database provides a cloud-based database management system (DBMS). This technology
+lets on-premises and cloud applications store relational data on Microsoft servers in Microsoft data
6
-PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-ASK IF VOTED (VOTED=3) [N=8,072]:
-VTEASY_POST Overall, was voting in the election this November for you personally... [ROTATE
-RESPONSES OPTIONS 1-4/4-1]
-
-| Nov 12-17, | | | | | Nov 12-17, | | | | | | |
-| ----------- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| 2024 | | | | | | 2020 | | | | | |
-| | 79 | Very easy | | | | 77 | | | | | |
-| | 15 | Somewhat easy | | | | 17 | | | | | |
-| | 5 | Somewhat difficult | | | | 5 | | | | | |
-
-| | 2 | Very difficult | | | | 1 | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-
-| | * | No answer* | | | | * | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-
-TREND FOR COMPARISON:
-Overall, do you personally expect voting in the November elections to be...
-
-BASED ON REGISTERED VOTERS:
-
-| | | | | | | Sep 30- | Oct 10- | | Sep 30- | Jul 27- | Sep 24- |
-| --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ------- | --- | -------- | -------- | -------- |
-| | | | | | | Oct 6, | 16 | | Oct 5 | Aug 2 | Oct 7 |
-| | | | | | | 2024 | 2022 | | 2020 | 2020 | 2018 |
-| | | Very easy | | | | 43 | 45 | | 29 | 23 | 46 |
-| | | Somewhat easy | | | | 38 | 37 | | 36 | 28 | 39 |
-| | | Somewhat difficult | | | | 16 | 14 | | 29 | 38 | 13 |
-| | | Very difficult | | | | 4 | | 3 | 6 | 11 | 2 |
-| | | No answer | | | | * | | * | * | 1 | * |
-
-ASK ALL:
-SATCAND_POST Now that the campaign is over, how satisfied were you with the choice of presidential
-candidates? Would you say that you were…
-BASED ON VOTERS [N=8,072]:
-| Nov 12-17, | | | | | | Nov 12-17, | | | | | |
-| ----------- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| 2024 | | | | | | 2020 | | | | | |
-| | 32 | Very satisfied | | | | 30 | | | | | |
-| | 20 | Fairly satisfied | | | | 26 | | | | | |
-| | 22 | Not too satisfied | | | | 24 | | | | | |
-| | 25 | Not at all satisfied | | | | 19 | | | | | |
-| | * | No answer* | | | | * | | | | | |
-
- TREND FOR COMPARISON:
-What is your opinion of the presidential candidates for this year? Would you say that you are…
-
-BASED ON REGISTERED VOTERS:
-
-| | | | | | 2024 Election | | | | 2020 Election | | |
-| --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | -------------- | --------- | --- | --- | -------------- | ----------- | --- |
-| | | | | Aug 26- | | | | | Jul 27- | | |
-| | | | | Sep 2, | | Jul 1-7, | | | Aug 2, | Jun 16-22, | |
-| | | | | 2024 | | 2024 | | | 2020 | 2020 | |
-| | Very satisfied | | | | 15 | 11 | | | 15 | 16 | |
-| | Fairly satisfied | | | | 32 | 20 | | | 31 | 31 | |
-| | Not too satisfied | | | | 34 | 32 | | | 35 | 34 | |
-| | Not at all satisfied | | | | 17 | 37 | | | 19 | 19 | |
-| | No answer* | | | | 1 | | 1 | | 1 | 1 | |
-
-| | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-www.pewresearch.org
+
+centers. As with other cloud technologies, an organization pays only for what it uses, increasing and
+decreasing usage (and cost) as the organization’s needs change. Using a cloud database also allows
+converting what would be capital expenses, such as investments in disks and DBMS software, into
+operating expenses.
+
+SQL Azure Reporting is a version of SQL Server Reporting Services (SSRS) that runs in the cloud.
+Intended primarily for use with SQL Azure Database, it allows creating and publishing standard SSRS
+reports on cloud data.
+
+SQL Azure Data Sync allows synchronizing data between SQL Azure Database and on-premises SQL
+Server databases. It can also be used to synchronize data across different SQL Azure databases in
+different Microsoft data centers.
+
+SQL Azure is built on Microsoft SQL Server. As with SQL Server, developers can create indexes and views,
+use stored procedures, define triggers, and more. Applications can access SQL Azure data using Entity
+Framework, ADO.NET, and other Windows data access interfaces. In fact, applications that today access
+SQL Server locally will largely work unchanged with data in SQL Azure. Customers can also use on-
+premises software such as SQL Server Analysis Services to work with their cloud-based data.
+
+While applications can use SQL Azure much as they do a local DBMS, the management requirements are
+significantly reduced. Rather than worry about mechanics, such as monitoring disk usage and servicing log
+files, a SQL Azure customer can focus on their data; Microsoft handles the operational details. And as with
+other components of this cloud platform, customers use the common Windows Azure platform portal to
+access its services.
+
+Applications might use SQL Azure in a variety of ways. Here are some examples:
+
+ A Windows Azure application can store its data in SQL Azure. While Windows Azure provides its own
+storage, relational tables aren’t among the options it offers. Since many existing applications use
+relational storage and many developers know how to work with it, a significant number of Windows
+Azure applications rely on SQL Azure to work with data in this familiar way. For example, a SaaS
+application built on Windows Azure might create a separate SQL Azure database for each customer,
+providing an intrinsically multi-tenant design. And to improve performance, customers can specify
+that a particular Windows Azure application must run in the same data center in which SQL Azure
+Database stores that application’s information.
+
+ An application in a small business or a department of a larger organization might rely on SQL Azure.
+Rather than storing its data in a SQL Server or Access database running on a computer under
+somebody’s desk, the application can instead take advantage of the reliability and availability of cloud
+storage. It can also create reports on this data using either SQL Azure Reporting or SSRS on-premises.
+If the organization wishes to maintain an on-premises copy of the data as well, it can use SQL Azure
+Data Sync to synchronize the cloud and on-premises databases.
+
+Suppose a manufacturer wishes to make product information available both to its dealer network
+and directly to customers. Putting this data in SQL Azure would let it be accessed by applications
+running at the dealers and by a customer-facing Web application run by the manufacturer itself.
7
-PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-SATCAND_POST TREND FOR COMPARSION CONTINUED …
-PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON:
- Now that the campaign is over, how satisfied were you with the choice of presidential candidates?
+Whether it’s for supporting a Windows Azure application, making data more accessible, or other reasons,
+data services in the cloud can be attractive. The goal of SQL Azure is to provide these services in a familiar,
+usable way for cloud and on-premises applications.
+
+WINDOWS AZURE APPFABRIC
-BASED ON THOSE WHO VOTED:
+Running applications and storing data in the cloud are both important aspects of cloud computing.
+They’re far from the whole story, however. It’s also possible to provide cloud-based infrastructure
+services. Filling this gap is the goal of Windows Azure AppFabric.
-| | | | Nov 10-14, | | Nov 8-11, | | Nov Nov | | Nov Nov | Nov Nov |
-| --------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ----------- |
-| | | | 2016 | | 2012 | | 2008 2004 | | 2000 1996 | 1992 1988 |
-| Very satisfied | | | | 19 | 37 | | 39 | 33 | 24 18 | 24 26 |
-| Fairly satisfied | | | | 25 | 33 | | 28 | 33 | 44 33 | 37 36 |
-| Not very satisfied | | | | 26 | 16 | | 17 | 16 | 18 24 | 21 20 |
-| Not at all satisfied | | | | 29 | 12 | | 14 | 16 | 9 22 | 16 17 |
-| Don't | | | | 1 | 3 | | 2 | 2 | 5 3 | 2 1 |
-know/Refused
-(VOL.)
+The functions provided by AppFabric today address common challenges in building distributed
+applications. Figure 4 shows its components.
-[DISPLAY CMPGNTRAITPOST_PROUD, CMPGNTRAITPOST_NEG, CMPGNTRAITPOST_POLCY,
-CMPGNTRAITPOST_INT ON SAME PAGE; RANDOMIZE ORDER OF QUESTIONS; INCLUDE
-RANDOMIZATION IN DATA FILE. DO NOT RANDOMIZE RESPONSE OPTIONS WITHIN EACH
-QUESTION]
+Figure 4: Windows Azure AppFabric provides Windows Azure-based infrastructure services that can be
+used by both cloud and on-premises applications.
-ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,801]:
-CMPGNTRAITPOST_PROUD Would you say the 2024 presidential campaign was...
+As the figure suggests, all of the components of Windows Azure AppFabric are built on Windows Azure
+(although they don’t all provide services solely to Windows Azure applications). Those components are
+the following:
-BASED ON VOTERS [N=4,012]:
+Service Bus: Exposing an application’s services on the Internet is harder than it might seem. The goal
+of Service Bus is to make this simpler by letting an application expose endpoints in the cloud that can
+be accessed by other applications, whether on-premises or in the cloud. Each exposed endpoint is
+assigned a URI, which clients can use to locate and access the service. Service Bus also handles the
+challenges of dealing with network address translation and getting through firewalls without opening
+new ports for exposed applications.
-| | | | Made you feel proud | | | Did not make you feel | | | No | |
-| ---------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- |
-| | | | of the country | | | proud of the country | | | answer* | |
-| Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | | 29 | | | 70 | | 1 | |
+ Access Control: There are many ways for a user to get a digital identity today. The options include
+Active Directory, Windows Live ID, Google Accounts, Facebook, and more. If an application wants to
+let users log in with any of these, the application’s creator faces the daunting challenge of supporting
-| | | TREND FOR COMPARISON: | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | So far, would you say the 2024 presidential campaign… | | | | | | | | |
+8
-| | | BASED ON REGISTERED VOTERS: | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+this plethora of approaches. Access Control simplifies this by providing built-in support for all of them
+(and more). It also provides a single place for defining rules to control what each user is allowed to
+access.
-| | | | | | | Makes you feel proud | | Does not make you feel | | No |
-| --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | ----------------------- | --- | -------- |
-| | | | | | | of the country | | proud of the country | | answer* |
-| | | Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024 | | | | | 19 | | 79 | 2 |
-| | | Jul 1-7, 2024 | | | | | 12 | | 87 | 1 |
+ Caching: It’s common for applications to access the same data over and over. One way to speed up
+this kind of application is to cache frequently accessed information, reducing the number of times
+that application must query a database. The Caching service provides this—and the performance
+boost it brings—for Windows Azure applications.
-| | | | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-www.pewresearch.org
+Microsoft has announced plans to add more services under the Windows Azure AppFabric banner, so
+expect this list to grow in the not-too-distant future.
-8
-PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-
-ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,801]:
-CMPGNTRAITPOST_NEG Would you say the 2024 presidential campaign was...
-
-BASED ON VOTERS [N=4,012]:
-
-| | | | Too | | Not too | | No | | | | | |
-| ---------------- | --- | --- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | | negative | | negative | | answer* | | | | | |
-| Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | 74 | | 25 | | 1 | | | | | |
-
-| | | TREND FOR COMPARISON: | | | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | So far, would you say the 2024 presidential campaign… | | | | | | | | | | |
-
-| | | BASED ON REGISTERED VOTERS: | | | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | -------- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | | Too | Not too | | No | |
-| | | | | | | | | negative | negative | | answer* | |
-| | | Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024 | | | | | | 71 | | 27 | | 2 |
-Jul 1-7, 2024
-| | | | | | | | | 68 | | 30 | | 2 |
-| --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | 2020 TREND FOR COMPARISON:6 | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | Nov 12-17, 2020 | | | | | | 76 | | 23 | | 1 |
-| | | July 27-Aug 2, 2020 | | | | | | 61 | | 37 | | 2 |
-
-ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,801]:
-CMPGNTRAITPOST_POLCY Would you say the 2024 presidential campaign was...
-
-BASED ON VOTERS [N=4,012]:
-
-| | | | Focused on important | | | Not focused on important | | | | No | | |
-| ---------------- | --- | --- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ------------------------- | --------------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- |
-| | | | policy debates | | | | policy debates | | | answer* | | |
-| Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | | 35 | | | | 64 | | 1 | | |
-
-| | | TREND FOR COMPARISON: | | | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | So far, would you say the 2024 presidential campaign… | | | | | | | | | | |
-
-| | | BASED ON REGISTERED VOTERS: | | | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-
-| | | | | | | | | Focused on | | Not focused on | | |
-| --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------------- | --- | --------------- | --- | -------- |
-| | | | | | | | | important | | important | | No |
-| | | | | | | | | policy debates | | policy debates | | answer* |
-| | | Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024 | | | | | | 37 | | | 62 | 1 |
-| | | Jul 1-7, 2024 | | | | | | 23 | | | 76 | 1 |
-
-| | | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | 2020 TREND FOR COMPARISON:7 | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | Nov 12-17, 2020 | | | | | | 27 | | | 72 | 1 |
-| | | July 27-Aug 2, 2020 | | | | | | 25 | | | 73 | 2 |
-
-| | | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-
-6 Question asked about the 2020 presidential campaign.
-7 Question asked about the 2020 presidential campaign.
-www.pewresearch.org
+As with Windows Azure and SQL Azure, customers use a browser-accessible portal to sign up for
+AppFabric. Once this has been done, these services can be used in a variety of ways. Here are some of the
+possibilities:
+
+Suppose an enterprise wished to let software at its trading partners access one of its applications. It
+could expose this application’s functions through SOAP or RESTful services created using WCF, then
+register those service endpoints with Service Bus. Its trading partners could then use Service Bus to
+find these endpoints and access the services.
+
+Imagine that the creator of this same application needs to let trading partners log in with a variety of
+different identities. Rather than implementing support for these identities himself, he could use the
+Access Control service to hide this complexity.
+
+ A Windows Azure application created using ASP.NET might use the Session object to store per-client
+state. By changing only a configuration setting, the application can cause this data to be kept in the
+Caching service rather than, say, Windows Azure Storage tables. Doing this is likely to make the
+application faster and more scalable.
+
+Along with the cloud-based services of Windows Azure AppFabric, Microsoft also provides an analogous
+technology known as Windows Server AppFabric. As its name suggests, the services it provides run on
+Windows Server—they support on-premises applications—rather than in the cloud. The on-premises
+services aren’t exactly the same today as those in Windows Azure AppFabric (although Microsoft’s
+announced plan is make the two congruent). Don’t be confused; throughout this paper, the name
+“AppFabric” is used to refer to the cloud-based services. Also, don’t confuse Windows Azure AppFabric
+with the Windows Azure fabric controller. Even though both contain the term “fabric”, they’re wholly
+separate technologies addressing quite distinct problems.
+
+WINDOWS AZURE MARKETPLACE
+
+In the on-premises world, many applications are purchased rather than custom-built. Many organizations
+also rely on datasets from commercial providers. With the rise of the cloud, why not let customers find
+and buy cloud applications and cloud-accessible data? Making this possible is the goal of Windows Azure
+Marketplace. Figure 5 shows its two components.
9
-PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-
-ASK FORM 1 ONLY [N=4,801]:
-CMPGNTRAITPOST_INT Would you say the 2024 presidential campaign was...
-
-BASED ON VOTERS [N=4,012]:
-
-| | | | | No | | | | | | |
-| ---------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | -------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | | Interesting | Dull answer* | | | | | | |
-| Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | 74 | 24 2 | | | | | | |
-
-| | | TREND FOR COMPARISON: | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | ------------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | So far, would you say the 2024 presidential campaign… | | | | | | | | |
-
-| | | BASED ON REGISTERED VOTERS: | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | ----- | --- | -------- |
-| | | | | | | | | | | No |
-| | | | | | Interesting | | | Dull | | answer* |
-| | | Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024 | | | | 68 | | 30 | | 2 |
-| | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | 2020 TREND FOR COMPARISON8 | | | | | | | | |
-| | | Nov 12-17, 2020 | | | | 64 | | 34 | | 2 |
-| | | July 27-Aug 2, 2020 | | | | 39 | | 59 | | 2 |
-
-ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS PREVIOUSLY RELEASED
-
-ASK IF VOTED (VOTED=3) [N=8,072]:
-| VOTE_HOW_POST | | | How did you vote in the election? [RANDOMIZE] | | | | | | | |
-| -------------- | --- | --- | ---------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-ASK IF VOTED IN PERSON (VOTE_HOW_POST=1) [N=5,196]:
-| VOTEINPWHEN | | When did you vote? | | | | | | | | |
-| ------------ | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-
-| Nov 12-17, | | | | | | Nov 16-27, | | | Nov 12-17, | |
-| ----------- | ----- | ------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | ----------- | --- |
-| | 2024 | | | | | | 2022 | | 2020 | |
-| | 65 | In person at a polling place | | | | | 65 | | 54 | |
-| | 34 | On Election Day | | | | | 44 | | | 27 |
-| | 32 | Before Election Day | | | | | 21 | | | 27 |
-| | * | Refused | | | | | * | | | * |
-| | 35 | By absentee or mail-in ballot | | | | | 35 | | 46 | |
-| | * | No answer* | | | | | * | | | * |
-
-TREND FOR COMPARISON:
-When did you vote in the elections this November?
-How did you vote in the November election?
-
-| | | | | | | Nov 7-16, | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-2018
-| | | On election day | | | | | 55 | | | |
-| --- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | Before election day | | | | | 45 | | | |
-| | | Voted in person | | | | | 19 | | | |
-| | | Mailed in ballot | | | | | 25 | | | |
-| | | No answer | | | | | * | | | |
-| | | No answer | | | | | * | | | |
-| | | | | | | | | | | |
-
-| | | | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-
-8 Question asked about the 2020 presidential campaign.
-www.pewresearch.org
+
+Figure 5: Windows Azure Marketplace provides an online marketplace for cloud applications and data.
+
+The two parts of Windows Azure Marketplace are:
+
+ DataMarket (originally codenamed “Dallas”), providing a way for content providers to make datasets
+available. Customers can browse the offerings, then purchase whatever they find useful. Applications,
+both custom and off-the-shelf (such as Microsoft Excel), can then access this data through RESTful
+requests or the OData protocol.
+
+ AppMarket, providing a way for creators of cloud applications to expose those applications to
+
+potential customers. AppMarket will be available sometime after DataMarket.
+
+Using the cloud to find, evaluate, and purchase data and applications makes sense. The goal of Windows
+Azure Marketplace is to make these things easier to do.
+
+A CLOSER LOOK AT THE TECHNOLOGIES
+
+Having a broad understanding of the Windows Azure platform is an important first step. Making good
+decisions require a deeper understanding of these technologies, however. This section takes a slightly
+more in-depth look at each member of the family.
+
+WINDOWS AZURE
+
+Windows Azure provides what’s commonly called Platform as a Service (PaaS). Rather than offering a
+cloud replica of the on-premises world, it offers a higher level of service that’s meant to make life easier
+for both developers and administrators. What follows walks through the five components that
+collectively provide this service.
10
-PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-VOTE_HOW_POST/VOTEINPWHEN TREND FOR COMPARISON CONTINUED…
-
-PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON:
-Did you vote ON Election Day or BEFORE Election DAY?
-
-Did you vote in person or did you mail your ballot in?
-
-| | | | Nov 10-14 | Nov 6-9 | | Nov 8-11 | | Nov | | Nov | | Nov | Nov |
-| ------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | -------- | ----- | --------- | ----- | ----- | --- | ----- | --- | ----- | ----- |
-| | | | 2016 | | 2014 | | 2012 | 2008 | | 2006 | | 2004 | 2002 |
-| On Election Day | | | 59 | | 71 | | 63 | 66 | | 80 | | 80 | 85 |
-| Before Election Day | | | 41 | | 29 | | 37 | 34 | | 20 | | 20 | 15 |
-| Voted in person | | | 22 | | 12 | | 19 | 19 | | -- | | | |
-| Mailed in ballot | | | 18 | | 16 | | 17 | 14 | | -- | | | |
-| Other way/DK/Ref (VOL) | | | 1 | | 1 | | * | 1 | | -- | | | |
-| Don’t know/Refused (VOL) | | | 0 | | * | | 0 | * | | * | | * | * |
-| | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
-
-ASK IF VOTED BY ABSENTEE OR MAIL (VOTE_HOW_POST=2) [N=2,868]:
-VOTEMAIL How did you return your absentee or mail-in ballot? [RANDOMIZE]
-
-| Nov 12-17, | | | | | | | Nov 16-27, | | Nov 12-17, | | | | |
-| ----------- | ----- | ------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | ----------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | 2024 | | | | | | 2022 | | | 2020 | | | |
-| | 12 | In person to an election official or poll | | | | | | 12 | | 15 | | | |
-worker
-| | 38 | At a designated dropbox | | | | | | 36 | | 41 | | | |
-| --- | --- | ------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | 50 | By mail | | | | | | 52 | | 44 | | | |
-| | * | No answer* | | | | | | * | | * | | | |
-
-ASK IF VOTED BY ABSENTEE OR MAIL (VOTE_HOW_POST=2) [N=2,868]:
-MAILWHEN When did you mail or return your absentee or mail-in ballot?
-
-| | Nov 12-17, | | | | | | Nov 12-17, | | | | | | |
-| --- | ----------- | --------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | 2024 | | | | | | 2020 | | | | | | |
-| | 33 | In the week leading up to Election Day | | | | | | 23 | | | | | |
-| | 67 | Before that | | | | | | 76 | | | | | |
-| | * | No answer* | | | | | | * | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
-
-ASK IF VOTED IN PERSON (VOTE_HOW_POST=1) [N=5,196]:
-WAITVOTE When you went to vote, approximately how long did you have to wait in line to
-vote?
-| | | | | | | | | | | | Nov 17- | | |
-| ------------ | ----- | --------------------- | --- | --- | ------------ | ----- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | -------- | --- | --- |
-| Nov 12-17, | | | | | Nov 12-17, | | | Nov 7-16, | | | Dec 15, | | |
-| | 2024 | | | | | 2020 | | 2018 | | | 2014 | | |
-| | 42 | Did not wait at all9 | | | | 35 | | 47 | | | | 53 | |
-| | 30 | Less than 10 minutes | | | | 27 | | 33 | | | | 30 | |
-| | 17 | 10 to 30 minutes | | | | 20 | | 14 | | | | 13 | |
-| | 7 | 31 minutes to 1 hour | | | | 11 | | | 5 | | | 3 | |
-| | 4 | More than 1 hour | | | | 6 | | | 1 | | | * | |
-| | * | No answer* | | | | * | | | * | | | * | |
-
-| | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-
-9 In surveys prior to November 2024, the response was worded “Not at all”.
-www.pewresearch.org
+
+Compute
+
+An application built on the Windows Azure compute service is structured as one or more roles. When it
+executes, the application typically runs two or more instances of each role, with each instance running as
+its own virtual machine (VM). Figure 6 shows how this looks.
+
+Figure 6: A running Windows Azure application consists of any combination of Web role instances,
+Worker role instances, and VM role instances.
+
+A Windows Azure application today can be created using three kinds of roles:
+
+ Web roles, intended primarily for running Web-based applications. Each Web role instance has
+Internet Information Services (IIS) 7 pre-configured to run inside it, so creating applications using
+ASP.NET, WCF, or other Web technologies is straightforward. It’s also possible to create applications
+using PHP, Java, and other non-Microsoft technologies.
+
+ Worker roles, designed to run a variety of code. A Worker role might run a simulation, for example,
+or video processing or nearly anything else. It’s common for an application to interact with users
+through a Web role, then hand tasks off to a Worker role for processing.
+
+ VM roles, which can run a user-provided Windows Server 2008 R2 image. A VM role can be the right
+
+choice for moving some on-premises Windows Server applications to Windows Azure.
+
+When a developer gives Windows Azure an application to run, she submits configuration information
+along with it. Among other things, this information tells the platform how many instances of each role to
+run. The Windows Azure fabric controller then creates a VM for each instance, running the code for the
11
-PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-
-ASK IF VOTED BY MAIL OR ABSENTEE (VOTE_HOW_POST=2) [N=2,868]:
-MAILFIRST Is this the first time you have ever voted by mail or absentee ballot?
-
-| Nov 12-17, | | | Nov 12-17, | | |
-| ----------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --- |
-| 2024 | | | 2020 | | |
-Yes, this is the first time I have ever voted by
-| 12 | | | 39 | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-mail or absentee ballot
-| 88 | No, I have voted by mail or absentee ballot before | | 61 | | |
-| --- | --------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| * | No answer* | | * | | |
-
-ASK IF VOTED IN PERSON BEFORE ELECTION DAY (VOTEINPWHEN=1) [N=2,671]:
-| EARLYFIRST | Is this the first time you have ever voted early? | | | | |
-| ----------- | -------------------------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-
-Nov 12-17,
-| 2024 | | | | | |
-| ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-29 Yes, this is the first time I have ever voted early
-71 No, I have voted early before
-* No answer*
-
-ASK IF VOTED IN PERSON ON ELECTION DAY (VOTEINPWHEN=2) [N=2,513]:
-ELECDFIRST Is this the first time you have ever voted in person on Election Day?
-
-Nov 12-17,
-2024
-Yes, this is the first time I have ever voted in person on Election Day
-7
-93 No, I have voted in person on Election Day before
-* No answer*
-
-ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS PREVIOUSLY RELEASED
-
-ASK IF VOTED (VOTED=3) [N=8,072]:
-VTCOUNT_OWN How confident are you that your vote was accurately counted?
-
-| Nov 12-17, | | | Nov 16-27, | Nov 12-17, | |
-| ----------- | ------------------- | --- | ----------- | ----------- | --- |
-| 2024 | | | 2022 | 2020 | |
-| 59 | Very confident | | 57 | 59 | |
-| 33 | Somewhat confident | | 31 | 26 | |
-| 5 | Not too confident | | 8 | 9 | |
-Not at all confident
-| 2 | | | 3 | 6 | |
-| --- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| * | No answer* | | * | * | |
-
-| | PHONE TREND FOR COMPARISON: | | | | |
-| --- | ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-
-| | | Nov 10-14 Nov 6-9 Nov 8-11 Nov 4-7 | | Nov Nov | Nov |
-| --- | -------------------------- | ----------------------------------- | ----------- | ----------- | ----- |
-| | | 2016 2014 | 2012 2010 | 2008 2006 | 2004 |
-| | Very confident | 71 68 | 68 64 | 73 70 | 68 |
-| | Somewhat confident | 19 21 | 22 26 | 22 23 | 24 |
-| | Not too confident | 4 5 | 5 4 | 3 3 | 4 |
-| | Not at all confident | 5 4 | 3 3 | 2 2 | 3 |
-| | Don’t know/Refused (VOL.) | 1 1 | 1 3 | * 2 | 1 |
-| | | | | | |
-www.pewresearch.org
+
+appropriate role in each VM. And as Figure 6 indicates, requests from the outside world are load balanced
+across all instances of a role.
+
+This has an important implication: To be scalable, Windows Azure role instances shouldn’t maintain their
+state themselves between requests. Because the load balancer doesn’t allow creating an affinity with a
+particular role instance—there’s no support for sticky sessions—there’s no way to guarantee that multiple
+requests from the same user will be sent to the same instance. Instead, any client-specific state should be
+written to Windows Azure storage, stored in SQL Azure Database, or maintained externally in some other
+way.
+
+For role instances, Windows Azure lets developers choose from several VM sizes, each with a specific
+number of processor cores and memory. Since each instance can be assigned one or more cores,
+applications have predictable performance. And to increase the load an application can handle, its owner
+or the application itself can request an increase in the number of running instances for one or more roles.
+The Windows Azure fabric controller will then spin up new VMs for these instances and start them
+running. It’s also possible to explicitly decrease the number of instances for a role, letting an application
+grow and shrink as needed to handle changing loads.
+
+For developers, building a Windows Azure application looks much like building a traditional Windows
+application. Microsoft provides Visual Studio project templates, for instance, to help developers create
+Windows Azure applications. Also, the Windows Azure software development kit includes a version of the
+Windows Azure environment that runs on the developer’s machine. Known as the Windows Azure
+development fabric, it implements a local replica of the Windows Azure compute and storage services. A
+developer can create and debug his application using this local simulacrum, then deploy it to Windows
+Azure in the cloud when it’s ready. Windows Azure also provides other services for developers, such as
+information about a running application’s CPU consumption, incoming and outgoing bandwidth, and
+storage usage.
+
+Storage
+
+Applications work with data in many different ways. Sometimes, all that’s required are simple blobs, while
+other situations call for a more structured way to store information. And in some cases, all that’s really
+needed is a way to exchange data between different parts of an application. Windows Azure storage
+addresses all three of these requirements, as Figure 7 shows.
12
-PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-[RANDOMIZE ORDER OF VTCOUNT_POST_INP AND VTCOUNT_POST_ABS]
-
-ASK ALL:
-VTCOUNT_POST_INP How confident are you that votes cast in person at polling places across the United
-States were counted as voters intended in the elections this November?
-
-| Nov 12-17, | | Nov 16-27, | | Nov 12-17, | | |
-| ----------- | --------------------- | ----------- | ----- | ----------- | ----- | --- |
-| 2024 | | | 2022 | | 2020 | |
-| 38 | Very confident | | 37 | | 42 | |
-| 47 | Somewhat confident | | 43 | | 35 | |
-| 11 | Not too confident | | 13 | | 13 | |
-| 4 | Not at all confident | | 6 | | 8 | |
-| 1 | No answer* | | 1 | | 1 | |
-
-TREND FOR COMPARISON:
-How confident are you that votes cast in person at polling places across the United States will
-be counted as voters intend in the elections this November?
-
-| | | | Sep 30- | | | Sep 30- |
-| --- | --------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ----------- | -------- |
-| | | | Oct 6, | | Oct 10-16, | Oct 5, |
-| | | | 2024 | | 2022 | 2020 |
-| | Very confident | | 36 | | 34 | 42 |
-| | Somewhat confident | | 46 | | 45 | 44 |
-| | Not too confident | | 13 | | 15 | 10 |
-| | Not at all confident | | | 5 | 5 | 4 |
-| | No answer* | | | 1 | 1 | 1 |
-
-[RANDOMIZE ORDER OF VTCOUNT_POST_INP AND VTCOUNT_POST_ABS]
-
-ASK ALL:
-VTCOUNT_POST_ABS How confident are you that votes cast by absentee or mail in ballot across the United
-States were counted as voters intended in the elections this November?
-
-| Nov 12-17, | | Nov 16-27, | | Nov 12-17, | | |
-| ----------- | --------------------- | ----------- | ----- | ----------- | ----- | --- |
-| 2024 | | | 2022 | | 2020 | |
-| 24 | Very confident | | 25 | | 30 | |
-| 46 | Somewhat confident | | 37 | | 27 | |
-| 21 | Not too confident | | 23 | | 19 | |
-| 7 | Not at all confident | | 13 | | 23 | |
-| 1 | No answer* | | 1 | | 1 | |
-
-TREND FOR COMPARISON:
-How confident are you that votes cast by absentee or mail-in ballot across the United States
-will be counted as voters intend in the elections this November?
-
-| | | | Sep 30- | | | Sep 30- |
-| --- | --------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | ----------- | -------- |
-| | | | Oct 6, | | Oct 10-16, | Oct 5, |
-| | | | 2024 | | 2022 | 2020 |
-| | Very confident | | 22 | | 21 | 17 |
-| | Somewhat confident | | 38 | | 38 | 38 |
-| | Not too confident | | 27 | | 24 | 28 |
-| | Not at all confident | | 12 | | 16 | 16 |
-| | No answer* | | | 1 | 1 | 1 |
-
-www.pewresearch.org
+
+Figure 7: Windows Azure provides blobs, tables, and queues, all accessed in a RESTful style via HTTP,
+HTTPS, or OData.
+
+The simplest way to store data in Windows Azure storage is to use blobs. As Figure 7 suggests, there’s a
+simple hierarchy: A storage account can have one or more containers, each of which holds one or more
+blobs. Blobs can be big—as large as a terabyte each—and to make transferring large blobs more efficient,
+they can potentially be subdivided into blocks. If a failure occurs, retransmission can resume with the
+most recent block rather than sending the entire blob again. Blobs can also have associated metadata,
+such as information about where a JPEG photograph was taken or who the composer is for an MP3 file.
+
+Another way to use blobs is through Windows Azure drives, which can be mounted by a role instance. The
+underlying storage for a drive is a blob, and so once a drive is mounted, the instance can read and write
+file system data that gets stored persistently in a blob.
+
+Blobs are just right for some kinds of data, but they’re too unstructured for many situations. To allow
+applications to work with data in a more fine-grained way, Windows Azure storage provides tables. Don’t
+be misled by the name: These aren’t relational tables. In fact, even though they’re called “tables”, the
+data they contain is actually stored in a set of entities with properties. A table has no defined schema;
+instead, properties can have various types, such as int, string, Bool, or DateTime. And rather than using
+SQL, an application can access a table’s data using the simple query language defined by OData. A single
+table can be quite large, with billions of entities holding terabytes of data, and Windows Azure storage
+can partition it across many servers if necessary to improve performance.
+
+Blobs and tables are both focused on storing data. The third option in Windows Azure storage, queues,
+has a somewhat different purpose. A primary use of queues is to let Web role instances communicate
+with Worker role instances. For example, a user might submit a request to perform some compute-
13
-PEW RESEARCH CENTER
-ASK ALL:
-ELECT_CONFNOVPOS How confident, if at all, are you that... [RANDOMIZE ITEMS]
-
-| | | | | | | Very | Somewhat | | Not too | | Not at all | No |
-| ------ | --- | -------------------------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----- | ---------- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------- | -------- |
-| | | | | | confident | | confident | | confident | | confident | answer* |
-| PRVFR | | People who were not legally | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | qualified to vote are prevented | | | | | | | | | | |
-from casting a ballot
-| | | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | | 27 | | 38 | 26 | | 8 | 1 |
-| ------- | -------------------------------- | ------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | TREND FOR COMPARISON10: | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024 | | | | 29 | | 30 | 24 | | 17 | 1 |
-| | | Sep 30-Oct 5, 2020 | | | | 23 | | 36 | 28 | | 11 | 1 |
-| | | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| PRVSUP | | People who were legally | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | qualified and want to vote are | | | | | | | | | | |
-able to cast a ballot
-| | | Nov 12-17, 2024 | | | | 45 | | 42 | 9 | | 3 | 1 |
-| --- | -------------------------------- | ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | TREND FOR COMPARISON11: | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | Sep 30-Oct 6, 2024 | | | | 44 | | 43 | 10 | | 3 | 1 |
-| | | Sep 30-Oct 5, 2020 | | | | 36 | | 45 | 14 | | 4 | 1 |
-| | | | | | | | | | | | | |
-
-ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS PREVIOUSLY RELEASED
-
-ASK ALL:
-| PARTY | | In politics today, do you consider yourself a… | | | | | | | | | | |
-| ---------------- | --- | ------------------------------------------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-ASK IF INDEP/SOMETHING ELSE (PARTY=3, 4 OR REFUSED):
-| PARTYLN | | As of today do you lean more to…12 | | | | | | | | | | |
-| -------------- | --- | ----------------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ----- | --- |
-| | | | | | | Something | | No | | Lean | Lean | |
- Republican Democrat Independent else answer* Rep Dem
-| | | 28 | 27 | 30 | | 14 | | 1 | | 20 | | 20 |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-
-10 In October 2024 and October 2020, the item was worded “People who are not legally qualified to vote are prevented from
-casting a ballot.”
-11
-In October 2024 and October 2020, the item was worded “People who are legally qualified and want to vote are able to cast
-a ballot.”
-12 PARTY and PARTYLN asked in a prior survey.
-www.pewresearch.org
\ No newline at end of file
+
+intensive task via a Web page implemented by a Windows Azure Web role. The Web role instance that
+receives this request can write a message into a queue describing the work to be done. A Worker role
+instance that’s waiting on this queue can then read the message and carry out the task it specifies. Any
+results can be returned via another queue or handled in some other way.
+
+Regardless of how it’s stored—in blobs, tables, or queues—all data held in Windows Azure storage is
+replicated three times. This replication allows fault tolerance, since losing a copy isn’t fatal. The system
+guarantees consistency, however, so an application that reads data it has just written will get what it
+expects.
+
+Windows Azure storage can be accessed either by a Windows Azure application or by an application
+running somewhere else. In both cases, all three Windows Azure storage styles use the conventions of
+REST (and the OData protocol for tables) to identify and expose data. Everything is named using URIs and
+accessed with standard HTTP operations, so clients can be created using .NET, Java, or other familiar
+technologies.
+
+The Windows Azure platform charges independently for compute and storage resources. This means that
+an on-premises application can use just Windows Azure storage, accessing its data in the RESTful way just
+described. For example, a Windows Server application running in an enterprise data center might choose
+to store backups in Windows storage blobs.
+
+Fabric Controller
+
+Even though a Windows Azure application runs in VMs, a developer doesn’t explicitly create and manage
+those VMs. Instead, as described earlier, she just tells the platform how many instances the application
+needs, and Windows Azure silently creates the necessary VMs and runs her application. This magic is
+performed by the fabric controller, a fundamental aspect of Windows Azure.
+
+Along with creating VMs and starting the applications that run in them, the fabric controller also monitors
+all running instances. A role instance might fail for many reasons; maybe the code threw an exception or
+the VM crashed or the physical server it’s running on went down. Whatever the reason, the fabric
+controller will start a new instance to maintain the total number of instances required for this application.
+
+The fabric controller also handles housekeeping tasks like patching the operating system and other
+system software, which minimizes the need for administrators. These are all examples of why Windows
+Azure is viewed as PaaS: It provides a platform that lets customers run applications without worrying
+about administering the environment they run in.
+
+Content Delivery Network
+
+One common use of blobs is to store information that will be accessed from many different places. Think
+of an application that serves up videos, for example, to Flash, Silverlight, or HTML 5 clients around the
+world. To improve performance in situations like this, Windows Azure provides a content delivery
+network. The CDN stores copies of a blob at sites closer to the clients that use it. This speeds up delivery
+of frequently accessed content, improving performance for users of this information.
+
+14
+
+Connect
+
+Windows Azure applications can interact with the outside world via HTTP, HTTPS, or TCP. But suppose
+you’d like to connect a role in an application to a machine outside the cloud at the IP level. For example,
+suppose an organization decides to move an existing ASP.NET application to Windows Azure, but wishes
+to keep the application’s data in an on-premises SQL Server database. Windows Azure Connect allows
+this.
+
+Using this option requires running Windows Azure Connect software on the on-premises machine that
+contains SQL Server, and it also requires some straightforward configuration. (This configuration can be
+done by the developer—there’s no need to get a network administrator involved.) Once this is done, all of
+the instances in the Web role can behave as if they’re on the same IP network as the SQL Server machine.
+In fact, they can use the same SQL Server connection string as when the application was running on
+premises—there’s no difference.
+
+Note that this isn’t a full-fledged virtual private network (VPN). While Microsoft has announced plans to
+let customers connect to Windows Azure via a VPN, this isn’t currently supported. It is possible to use
+Windows Azure Connect to domain-join a Windows Azure application to an on-premises Active Directory,
+however. Doing this allows single sign-on by on-premises users to the cloud application, and it also lets
+the application use existing Active Directory accounts and groups for access control.
+
+The goal of application platforms, whether on-premises or in the cloud, is to support applications and
+data. Windows Azure provides a home for both of these things. Going forward, expect to see a substantial
+share of what would have been on-premises Windows applications instead running on this new cloud
+platform.
+
+SQL AZURE
+
+A DBMS in the cloud is attractive for many reasons. Letting a specialized service provider ensure reliability
+and perform essential management functions can make sense, especially for organizations that find these
+things hard to do on their own. Data in the cloud can also be accessed by applications running anywhere,
+even on mobile devices. And given the economies of scale that a service provider enjoys, using a cloud
+database may well be cheaper than doing it yourself.
+
+SQL Azure provides these things, together with cloud-based reporting and data synchronization services.
+And while all of them are important, the place to start is with the foundation: SQL Azure Database.
+
+Database
+
+SQL Azure Database is simple to understand. As seen by an application, it provides the core database
+functions of SQL Server as a cloud service. Figure 8 shows the basics of this technology.
+
+15
+
+Figure 8: Applications access data in SQL Azure Database through Microsoft’s TDS protocol or via OData.
+
+An application using SQL Azure Database might run on Windows Azure, in an enterprise’s data center, on
+a mobile device, or somewhere else. Wherever it runs, the application typically accesses data via a
+protocol called Tabular Data Stream (TDS). This is the same protocol used to access a local SQL Server
+database, and so a SQL Azure Database application can use any existing SQL Server client. This includes
+Entity Framework, ADO.NET, ODBC, PHP and others. And because SQL Azure Database looks like an
+ordinary SQL Server system, standard tools can also be used, including SQL Server Management Studio,
+SQL Server Integration Services, and BCP for bulk data copy. Also, as Figure 8 shows, applications can
+optionally access SQL Azure Database using OData.
+
+Each SQL Azure account can have one or more logical servers. (Note that these provide a way to organize
+the data and billing for an account—they aren’t actual instances of SQL Server.) Each server can then have
+multiple databases, each of which can be up to 50 gigabytes in size. A user is free to use multiple
+databases if required, spreading data across them for better performance or for other reasons. It’s also
+possible to store a snapshot of one SQL Azure database into another, providing a simple backup
+mechanism.
+
+For the most part, an application using SQL Azure Database sees a familiar SQL Server environment. A few
+things are omitted in the technology’s current release, however, such as the SQL Common Language
+Runtime (CLR) and support for full-text search. (Microsoft says that both will be available in a future
+version.) Also, because administration is handled by Microsoft, the service doesn’t expose physical
+administrative functions. A customer can’t shut down the system, for example, or interact directly with
+the hardware it runs on. And as you’d expect in a shared environment, a query can run for only a limited
+time—no single request can take up more than a pre-defined amount of resources.
+
+16
+
+Yet while the environment looks quite standard, the service an application gets is more robust than what
+a single instance of SQL Server provides. As in Windows Azure storage, all data stored in SQL Azure
+Database is replicated three times for high availability. Also like Windows Azure storage, the service
+provides strong consistency: When a write returns, the data has been made persistent. The goal is to
+provide reliable data storage even in the face of system and network failures.
+
+Whether an application needs multiple databases or just one, SQL Azure Database can help developers
+address a range of scenarios. Whatever problem is being solved, the technology’s fundamental goal
+remains the same: to provide a familiar, reliable, and low-cost cloud database for many kinds of
+applications.
+
+Reporting
+
+Storing data in SQL Azure Database can be useful. But as soon as that data exists, there’s likely to be a
+demand for reports based on that data. Meeting this demand is the purpose of SQL Azure Reporting.
+Based on SQL Server Reporting Services (SSRS), this technology provides a cloud-based way to create
+reports.
+
+Given that SQL Azure Database looks like SQL Server to an application, it’s always possible to use SSRS on-
+premises with the data it contains. So why bother to provide a cloud reporting service as well? SQL Azure
+Reporting today targets two main scenarios:
+
+ Reports created using SQL Azure Reporting can be published to a SQL Azure Reporting portal, letting
+
+users access it there, or made accessible directly via a URL.
+
+ An ISV can embed reports published to the SQL Azure Reporting portal in any application, including
+Windows Azure applications. This lets users access those reports without leaving the application. To
+do this, the ISV can use the standard ReportViewer controls in Visual Studio—it’s no different from
+embedding on-premises reports into applications.
+
+SQL Azure Reporting is designed to work with data stored in SQL Azure Database. Reports used with SQL
+Azure Reporting are created on-premises, however, with Business Intelligence Developer Studio, the
+Visual Studio-hosted tool that’s also used to create SSRS reports. In fact, SQL Azure Reporting relies on the
+same reporting format, expressed in the Report Definition Language (RDL), used with SSRS.
+
+Like other aspects of SQL Azure, SQL Azure Reporting doesn’t provide all of the functions offered by SSRS
+on premises. There’s currently no support for scheduling and subscriptions, for example, that let a report
+be run and delivered at regular intervals. Still, cloud-based reporting services can be useful, and they’re an
+important part of the SQL Azure technology family.
+
+Data Sync
+
+Storing data in SQL Azure Database can make it accessible to any application with an Internet connection.
+Still, there are often situations where it makes sense to maintain a copy of this cloud-based data in some
+other place. Suppose an organization needs to have an on-premises copy of the same information, for
+example, for performance reasons or to ensure access if the network fails. For scenarios like this, the
+ability to synchronize data in SQL Azure Database with other data stores is useful.
+
+17
+
+It’s always possible to write synchronization code yourself using the Microsoft Sync Framework. To make
+this easier, Microsoft provides SQL Azure Data Sync. Rather than requiring its user to write code, this
+technology is entirely configuration-driven (although unsurprisingly, it’s built on the Microsoft Sync
+Framework). As Figure 9 shows, SQL Azure Data Sync supports two options today.
+
+Figure 9: SQL Azure Data Sync can synchronize data between SQL Azure databases or between a SQL
+Azure database and on-premises SQL Server databases.
+
+The two synchronization options are the following:
+
+Synchronizing data between a SQL Azure database and an on-premises SQL Server database. Having
+an on-premises copy of cloud data might make sense for a variety of reasons. Maybe an organization
+wants to make sure that this data is always available, for instance, even in the event of network
+failures, or perhaps regulations require that a copy of the data always be available within a country’s
+borders. And even though SQL Azure’s built-in data replication guards against hardware failures, the
+data’s owner might choose to maintain an on-premises backup copy in case of administrative errors,
+such as incorrect table deletions.
+
+Synchronizing data between SQL Azure databases in different Microsoft data centers. For example,
+suppose an ISV or a global enterprise creates an application that’s used by people around the world.
+To provide good performance for all of them, its creator might choose to run this application in three
+different Windows Azure data centers: one each in North America, Europe, and Asia. If the
+application stores data in SQL Azure Database, it might rely on SQL Azure Data Sync to keep
+information synchronized across these three data centers.
+
+SQL Azure Data Sync uses a hub-and-spoke model. All changes are copied first to the SQL Azure database
+hub, then out to the spokes (referred to as members). The members might be other SQL Azure databases
+
+18
+
+or on-premises SQL Server databases. In both cases, the technology provides synchronization of an entire
+database or just specific tables, with changes made to any copy propagated to all of the others. And while
+it’s possible to initiate synchronization manually, SQL Azure Data Sync also includes a scheduling service.
+This lets users schedule, say, hourly synchronization between a pair of databases. However it’s used, the
+purpose is the same: providing a straightforward way to synchronize data between a SQL Azure database
+in a Microsoft data center and one or more databases located somewhere else.
+
+ WINDOWS AZURE APPFABRIC
+
+Applications exist because their business logic has value. Yet applications rely on infrastructure to provide
+a foundation for that logic. A good application platform provides this infrastructure; application
+developers shouldn’t need to write it themselves.
+
+Windows Azure AppFabric provides infrastructure for applications. The people who create applications
+can benefit from different kinds of infrastructure, and so AppFabric contains various parts. This section
+takes a closer look at Service Bus, Access Control, and Caching, the three components of Windows Azure
+AppFabric today.
+
+Service Bus
+
+Suppose you have an application running inside your organization that exposes a Web service built with
+Windows Communication Foundation (WCF). Suppose further that you’d like to connect this service
+through the Internet to software running outside your organization. This client software might be running
+on a cloud platform, such as Windows Azure, or inside another organization.
+
+At first glance, this can seem like a simple problem. Since your application provides its functionality
+through Web services (either RESTful or SOAP-based), you can just make those Web services visible to the
+outside world. When you actually try to do this, though, some problems appear.
+
+First, how can clients in other organizations find endpoints they can connect to for your service? It would
+be nice to have some kind of registry where others could locate your application. And once they’ve found
+it, how can requests from software in other organizations get through to your service? Network address
+translation (NAT) is very common, so an application frequently doesn’t have a fixed IP address to expose
+externally. And even if NAT isn’t being used, how can requests get through your firewall? It’s possible to
+open firewall ports to allow access to your application, but network administrators frown on this.
+
+Service Bus addresses these challenges. Figure 10 shows how.
+
+19
+
+Figure 10: A WCF service can register endpoints with Service Bus, then have clients discover and use
+those endpoints to access the service.
+
+To begin, your WCF service registers one or more endpoints with Service Bus (step 1). For each registered
+endpoint, Service Bus exposes its own corresponding endpoint (step 2). Service Bus assigns your
+organization a URI root, below which you’re free to create any naming hierarchy you like. This allows your
+endpoints to be assigned specific, discoverable URIs.
+
+When a client running in the cloud or on-premises at some other organization wishes to access your
+service, it contacts the Service Bus registry (step 3) to find the endpoint, providing the endpoint’s URI. This
+request uses the Atom Publishing Protocol, and it returns an AtomPub service document with references
+to the endpoints Service Bus exposes on behalf of your application. Once it has these, the client can
+invoke operations on the services exposed through these endpoints (step 4). For each request Service Bus
+receives, it invokes the corresponding operation in the endpoint exposed by your WCF service (step 5).
+(Although it’s not shown in the figure, Service Bus establishes a direct connection between an application
+and its client whenever possible, making their communication more efficient.)
+
+There’s an obvious question here: How exactly does step 5 work? How does the request from Service Bus
+back to your service deal with the challenges of NAT and firewalls? The answer is that in step 1, your
+service opened a TCP connection with Service Bus for this exposed endpoint. Service Bus holds this
+connection open, which solves two problems. First, NAT is no longer an issue, since traffic on the open
+connection with Service Bus will always be routed to your application. Second, because the connection
+was initiated from inside the firewall, there’s no problem passing information back to the application via
+this connection—the firewall won’t block this traffic.
+
+20
+
+Along with making communication easier, Service Bus can also improve security. Because clients now see
+only an IP address provided by Service Bus, there’s no need to expose any IP addresses from within your
+organization. This effectively makes your application anonymous, since the outside world can’t see it.
+Service Bus acts as an external DMZ, providing a layer of indirection to deter attackers.
+
+While an application that exposes its services via Service Bus is typically implemented using WCF, clients
+can be built with WCF or other technologies, such as Java. However they’re created, these clients can
+make requests via TCP, HTTP, or HTTPS. Applications are also free to use their own security mechanisms,
+such as encryption, to shield their communication from attackers.
+
+Service Bus provides a few more useful features, including these:
+
+Support for message buffers, which act like simple queues. Rather than require a client to make
+direct calls to a service, the client can place a message of up to 256 kilobytes into a message buffer.
+The message is persisted to disk—it’s durable—and the service can then read this message at some
+later time. And as usual in the Windows Azure platform, the persisted messages are replicated to
+guard against failures.
+
+ The ability for multiple WCF services to listen on the same URI. Service Bus will then randomly spread
+client requests across all of the listening services. The goal is to provide both load balancing and fault
+tolerance for the WCF services.
+
+Exposing applications to the outside world isn’t as simple as it might seem. The intent of Service Bus is to
+make implementing these interactions as straightforward as possible.
+
+Access Control
+
+Working with identity is a fundamental part of most distributed applications. The modern approach to
+this, called claims-based identity, lets a user send a token full of claims that contain identity information.
+One claim might contain the user’s name, for example, while another contains her age or a group she
+belongs to. An application can use the claims in a token to decide what the user is allowed to do or in
+other ways.
+
+In a claims-based world, tokens are issued by identity providers (IdPs). Some IdPs, such as Active Directory
+Federation Services (AD FS) 2.0, exist inside organizations. Others, such as Windows Live ID and Google
+Accounts, are accessible to anyone via the Internet. Each application can decide which IdPs it trusts and
+thus which tokens it’s willing to accept. For example, an application running inside your company might
+only accept tokens issued by your own AD FS server, while an application running on the Internet might
+accept tokens issued by, say, Google and Facebook.
+
+Yet different IdPs use different token formats, and they represent claims in different ways. An application
+that directly accepts identities from Google, Facebook, and Yahoo, for instance, would need to handle
+these differences itself. But why do this? Why not instead create an intermediary that can generate a
+single token format with a common representation of claims? Doing this would make life simpler for the
+people who create applications, since they now need to handle only one kind of token.
+
+The Access Control service does exactly this, providing an intermediary in the cloud for working with
+claims-based identity. Figure 11 shows how it works.
+
+21
+
+Figure 11: The Access Control service makes it easier for applications to accept identity information
+issued by different identity providers.
+
+As the figure shows, an application that relies on Access Control can run either on-premises or in the
+cloud. In either case, the process begins when a user attempts to access this application via a browser
+(step 1). The application then redirects the browser to an IdP whose token this application will accept. The
+user authenticates herself with this IdP, such as by entering a username and password, and the IdP
+returns a token containing claims about her (step 2).
+
+Next, the user’s browser sends the IdP token to Access Control (step 3). Access Control validates the
+token, making sure that it really was issued by this IdP, then creates a new token according to whatever
+rules have been defined for this application (step 4). Access Control contains a rules engine, allowing each
+application’s administrator to define how tokens from various IdPs should be transformed into an Access
+Control token. For example, if different IdPs use different formats for representing usernames, Access
+Control rules can transform all of these into a common username string. Access Control then sends this
+new token back to the browser (step 5), which submits it to the application (step 6). Once it has the
+Access Control token, the application verifies that it really was issued by Access Control, then uses the
+claims it contains (step 7).
+
+While this process might seem a little complicated, it actually makes life significantly simpler for the
+creator of the application. Rather than handle diverse tokens containing various claims, the application
+can accept identities issued by multiple identity providers while still receiving only a single token with
+familiar claims. And rather than require each application to be configured to trust various IdPs, these trust
+relationships are instead maintained by Access Control—an application need only trust it.
+
+22
+
+As Figure 11 shows, Access Control has built-in support for several identity providers, including AD FS 2.0,
+Windows Live ID, Google, Yahoo, and Facebook. It can also work with any IdP that supports OpenID.
+Browsers and other clients can request Access Control tokens using either OAuth 2 or WS-Trust, and these
+tokens can have various formats, including SAML 1.1, SAML 2.0, and Simple Web Token (SWT). And to
+create applications that accept Access Control tokens, Windows developers can use Windows Identity
+Foundation (WIF). (It’s worth pointing out, however, that nothing about Access Control is tied to
+Windows—it could just as well be used by a Linux application that accepted only Google and Facebook
+identities.)
+
+Working with identity is important in nearly every distributed application. The goal of Access Control is to
+make it easier for developers to create secure applications that accept identities from diverse providers.
+By putting this service in the cloud, Microsoft has made it available to any application running on any
+platform.
+
+Caching
+
+For many applications, one of the most effective ways to improve performance is by caching frequently
+accessed data. Since applications tend to use the same information over and over, making this
+information more readily accessible can make the application faster. Doing this is the purpose of Windows
+Azure AppFabric Caching. Figure 12 illustrates the idea.
+
+Figure 12: Windows Azure AppFabric Caching speeds up access to frequently accessed data for
+Windows Azure applications.
+
+23
+
+The Caching service provides a distributed cache for Windows Azure applications, along with a library to
+access this cache. As Figure 12 suggests, the service includes a local cache that can keep a copy of recently
+accessed data items in each of an application’s role instances. If a data item the application needs isn’t
+found in the local cache, the cache library automatically contacts the shared cache provided by the
+Caching service. As the figure shows, this cache is spread across a number of Windows Azure instances,
+each holding different cached data. This diversity isn’t visible to applications using the cache, however. An
+application just requests a data item, then lets the cache find it (if it’s in the cache) and return it from
+whatever instance contains it.
+
+Recently accessed data isn’t automatically cached, however. Instead, the application explicitly inserts data
+items in the cache, such as by using the Caching API. It’s also possible to configure an ASP.NET application
+running on Windows Azure to store Session object data in the Caching service, speeding it up without
+changing any of its code.
+
+Windows Server AppFabric, the on-premises analog to Windows Azure AppFabric, also provides a Caching
+service. In fact, the two are very similar. The biggest different is that unlike its on-premises counterpart,
+Windows Azure AppFabric Caching is a service—there’s no need to configure servers and administer the
+cache. Instead, all of this is handled automatically by the service itself. And the cloud Caching service is
+multi-tenant, so each application using it gets its own instance. Because the application must authenticate
+itself to this instance, data held in the Caching service isn’t accessible to other applications.
+
+Caching can make applications faster and more scalable with little effort from developers, and so using it
+makes sense. By providing caching as a service, Windows Azure AppFabric Caching makes this easier to
+do.
+
+WINDOWS AZURE MARKETPLACE
+
+Cloud platforms are useful, but they’re just a means to an end. The real goal is offering applications and
+data that provide value for people. Since the Windows Azure platform provides a foundation for both,
+why shouldn’t it also include a way for people to find the applications and data that they need?
+
+The Windows Azure Marketplace is designed to address this need. Its two components, AppMarket and
+DataMarket, let users find, try, and purchase applications and data, respectively. While both are
+important, DataMarket will appear first, and so what follows focuses on this aspect of the Marketplace.
+
+Buying applications is common today—nearly every organization does it. Buying data is less common, but
+it’s no less important. Many firms sell many different kinds of data, including demographic information,
+financial information, legal information, and much more. Yet using purchased data typically requires
+figuring out whether the data you need exists, finding a firm that offers it, then determining whether their
+data meets your needs.
+
+All of this is more difficult than it needs to be. Why not create one place where customers can find all
+kinds of data from all kinds of content providers? Why not let them examine the data to make sure it
+meets their needs, then purchase what they need right then and there? The DataMarket component of
+Windows Azure Marketplace was created to do these things. Figure 13 shows its main components.
+
+24
+
+Figure 13: Built on Windows Azure, the DataMarket allows access to content partner datasets stored in
+Windows Azure, SQL Azure, or externally.
+
+As the figure suggests, both people and applications can access information through DataMarket. Using a
+Windows Azure-based application called the Service Explorer, a user can see what datasets are available,
+then purchase what she needs. Once this is done, applications can access that data using RESTful or OData
+requests. The datasets made available by DataMarket can be stored on the Windows Azure platform itself
+using Windows Azure Storage or SQL Azure Database. They can also be stored externally, such as in a data
+center owned by the content provider. There’s no requirement to put everything in the cloud.
+
+For customers, DataMarket provides a single place to find, buy, and access a variety of commercial
+datasets. For content providers—the owners of those data sets—DataMarket offers a chance to expose
+their offerings to more customers through Microsoft’s cloud platform. While content providers set prices
+for their data, DataMarket provides a billing service that frees them from dealing directly with customers.
+Microsoft will also vet the quality of the content providers, limiting DataMarket initially to just the top five
+providers in a particular industry.
+
+Applications are free to use purchased data in any way that the content provider’s license allows. Users of
+Microsoft Excel 2010, for example, can access DataMarket’s information directly using an Excel add-in or
+use the PowerPivot for Excel support for OData to access information from DataMarket for data analysis.
+It’s also possible to combine data purchased from DataMarket with your own data, such as for reports
+created using SQL Server Reporting Services.
+
+25
+
+Getting business value from information technology requires the right applications, but it also requires
+the right data. By making it easier to discover, evaluate, and buy commercially available datasets,
+DataMarket intends to make it simpler for organizations to find and use the information they need.
+
+LOOKING AHEAD
+
+Microsoft has announced a number of updates that it plans to add to the Windows Azure platform in the
+near future. They include the following:
+
+ The Windows Azure Platform Appliance: Microsoft has announced plans to offer a Windows Azure
+Platform Appliance, allowing hosters and enterprises to run Windows Azure in their own data
+centers. Because Windows Azure requires a specific hardware configuration—it’s not just software—
+this appliance will include servers, networking, and storage, all running Windows Azure. And while it
+will initially be targeted only at large organizations, Microsoft’s goal is eventually to make the
+Windows Azure Platform Appliance useful for smaller organizations as well.
+
+ CDN dynamic content caching: Today, the Windows Azure CDN works only with blob data. This
+forthcoming functionality will let the CDN also cache content created dynamically by a Windows
+Azure application.
+
+ VM role snapshotting: In its first release, the Windows Azure VM role doesn’t save any changes made
+to the OS volume while it’s running. Snapshotting will change this, providing a way to periodically
+save the state of this volume to persistent storage.
+
+ Better Java support: While Windows Azure can run Java applications today, Microsoft plans to make
+this better. The coming improvements include better Java performance, stronger support for Eclipse-
+based tools, and a more complete set of Java libraries for Windows Azure.
+
+Support for composite applications: To make it easier to build Windows Azure applications by
+combining existing components and services, Windows Azure AppFabric will add a composition
+model. Accompanied by runtime services and a Visual Studio-based designer, this model will let
+developers work with the various parts of an application as a single logical entity throughout its
+lifecycle.
+
+ All of these changes target the same goal: making the Windows Azure platform useful in a broader range
+of scenarios.
+
+CONCLUSIONS
+
+The truth is evident: Cloud computing is here. For developers, taking advantage of the cloud means using
+cloud platforms. With the Windows Azure platform, Microsoft presents a range of options addressing a
+variety of needs:
+
+ Windows Azure provides a computing and storage environment in the cloud.
+
+SQL Azure provides a relational DBMS in the cloud, together with reporting and data synchronization.
+
+26
+
+ Windows Azure AppFabric offers cloud-based infrastructure supporting both cloud and on-premises
+
+applications.
+
+ Windows Azure Marketplace is an online store for finding and purchasing datasets from content
+
+providers, together with a forthcoming store for cloud applications.
+
+These approaches address a variety of requirements, and not every developer will use all of them. Yet
+whether you work for an ISV, a systems integrator, or an enterprise, some cloud platform services are
+likely to be useful for applications your organization creates. A new world is unfolding; prepare to be part
+of it.
+
+ABOUT THE AUTHOR
+
+David Chappell is Principal of Chappell & Associates (www.davidchappell.com) in San Francisco, California.
+Through his speaking, writing, and consulting, he helps people around the world understand, use, and
+make better decisions about new technologies.
+
+27
+
diff --git a/q12/random_k4/random_2.md b/q12/random_k4/random_2.md
index 568511cdd3e8b935079ff674d5949ce1b387f331..41b128d8d6a3808185f462ec8b46e331c45f6af0 100644
--- a/q12/random_k4/random_2.md
+++ b/q12/random_k4/random_2.md
@@ -1,5479 +1,448 @@
-Owner’s Manual
+Amazfit GTR User Manual
+
+Content
+
+Operating Instructions and Functions Navigation ............................................................................. 2
+Basic Operations ....................................................................................................................... 2
+Functions Navigation ................................................................................................................ 2
+Watch Wearing and Charging ............................................................................................................ 4
+Use of Functions ............................................................................................................................... 5
+Device Pairing and Unpairing ................................................................................................... 5
+Control Shortcut Menu .............................................................................................................. 7
+Flashlight ........................................................................................................................... 7
+Brightness adjustment ....................................................................................................... 8
+DND mode ........................................................................................................................ 8
+Battery saver mode ............................................................................................................ 9
+Lock screen ..................................................................................................................... 10
+Replace the Watch Face .......................................................................................................... 11
+Status ....................................................................................................................................... 11
+Heart Rate ............................................................................................................................... 12
+Workout ................................................................................................................................... 13
+Workout Record ...................................................................................................................... 14
+Weather ................................................................................................................................... 15
+Music....................................................................................................................................... 16
+Notifications ............................................................................................................................ 17
+Alarm ...................................................................................................................................... 18
+Event Reminder....................................................................................................................... 20
+Timer ....................................................................................................................................... 22
+Count Down ............................................................................................................................ 23
+Find Device ............................................................................................................................. 24
+Compass/Air Pressure/Altitude ............................................................................................... 25
+Settings .................................................................................................................................... 27
+Workout Function ........................................................................................................................... 29
+Workout Positioning................................................................................................................ 30
+During Workouts ..................................................................................................................... 31
+Swimming ............................................................................................................................... 32
+Workout Reminder .................................................................................................................. 33
+Workout Pause and End .......................................................................................................... 33
+Workout Settings ..................................................................................................................... 34
+
+Operating Instructions and Functions Navigation
+
+Amazfit GTR features one AMOLED touch screen and two physical buttons.
+
+Basic Operations
+
+Slide left and right or up and down: You can switch between different function pages.
+Tap and exit: You can tap to enter a specific function page and also operate the tap tips on that page.
+You can slide right to quickly return to the upper-level menu after tapping to enter a certain function
+page.
+Button on the upper right:
+① Short press to light up the screen.
+② Short press the watch face page to close the screen.
+③ Short press other pages to quickly return to the watch face.
+④ Long press for 10s to shut down.
+Button on the bottom right:
+① Short press to light up the screen.
+② Short press the watch face page to quickly enter the workout list. (This function can be
+customized and used to short press to quickly start other functions)
+You can long press either of the two buttons above to exit the battery saver mode, suspend the
+workout, and close the alarm alert.
+
+Functions Navigation
+
+Pull the watch face down: You can then enter the shortcut control menu, which allows you to quickly
+open the flashlight, set brightness, control the DND mode, enter the battery saver mode, and lock
+the screen.
+
+Slide the watch face left and right: You can then quickly enter Status, Heart rate,
+
+Slide the watch face up: You can then enter the function list.
+
+Watch Wearing and Charging
+
+Daily wearing: During daily use, it is recommended to wear the watch with a moderate tightness at
+a distance two fingers far from your wrist to ensure that the optical heart rate monitor works properly.
+Wearing during workouts: During workouts, it is recommended to wear the watch comfortably and
+ensure a tight fit without slipping. Being too tight or too loose may cause the inaccuracy of detected
+workout data, so avoid doing this.
+Charging
+
+
+The watch charger's USB port needs to be plugged into the USB-supported device, such as
+socket, PC, power bank.
+
+ When placing the watch into the power socket, it's required to keep the watch in a proper
+direction and position. Be sure that the metal contacts on the back of the watch are closely
+connected to the charging base.
+The screen will display the charging reminder when the watch is placed properly.
+
+
+
+Use of Functions
+
+Download the Amazfit App via the mobile phone before using Amazfit GTR. You cannot use the
+entire watch functions nor save and upload watch data to your personal cloud account until the
+watch is paired by using the Amazfit App.
+
+Device Pairing and Unpairing
+
+Download the Amazfit App from Google Play Store or App Store and register an account or log in.
+
+Open the Amazfit App and choose "Profile – My devices – Watch – Amazfit GTR" to search the
+device nearby.
+Please tap the check-mark when it shows a pairing request on the watch.
+
+If a device can be paired by scanning a QR code, with the Amazfit App on, you can directly pair the
+device by scanning the QR code on your watch.
+After paired, the watch usually needs to be upgraded. Wait for upgrading with patience. With the
+mobile network and Bluetooth on, you also need to keep the watch close to the mobile phone, so as
+to ensure a successful upgrade.
+
+After the watch is paired and upgraded, its functions are available. Meanwhile, the Amazfit App
+allows for the watch function-specific operations and settings.
+To unpair the watch, open the Amazfit App, tap "Profile – My devices – Amazfit GTR" and then
+swipe up and tap the "Unpair" button.
-Models
-14, 16, 17, 18
+Control Shortcut Menu
-Refrigerators
+Pulling down on the watch face page can quickly open the control shortcut menu page.
-TOP-MOUNT NO-FROST
+Flashlight
+Tapping the flashlight icon can open the flashlight function. The white background on the watch
+screen helps light up a small area at night. You can close the enabled flashlight function by sliding
-Part No. 162D6736P004 Pub. No.39-6424-1 9-99 JR
+right or pressing the button on the upper right.
-Congratulations!
+Brightness adjustment
+Tapping on the brightness adjustment button can go to the brightness adjustment settings.
+Auto brightness: The watch will automatically adjust the screen brightness upon ambient light.
+Manual brightness: You can tailor the screen brightness as you wish.
-Welcome to our family. We’re proud of our
-quality products and we are committed to
-providing dependable service. You’ll see it in
-this easy-to-use Owner’s Manual and you’ll
-hear it in the friendly voices of our customer
-service department.
+DND mode
+Enable DND: With the DND mode enabled, the watch will not vibrate when receiving any message
+pushed by the mobile phone.
+Time DND: You can tailor the time period during which the DND mode changes from automatically
+enabled to disabled.
-Best of all, you’ll experience these values
-each time you use your refrigerator. That’s
-important, because your new refrigerator will
-be part of your family for many years. And we
-hope you will be part of ours for a long time
-to come.
+Smart DND: After you fall asleep with the watch, the watch will automatically enable the DND
+mode.
+Disable DND: The DND mode is disabled, so the watch will vibrate when receiving notifications.
-We appreciate your purchase, and hope you
-will continue to rely on us whenever you
-need quality appliances for your home.
+Battery saver mode
+The battery saver mode can minimize the power consumption of the watch and improve its
+endurance. With the battery saver mode on, the watch can only record steps and sleep time, with
+other functions disabled.
-Important!
+To exit the battery saver mode, long press any button on the watch.
-Fill out and return the Consumer Product
-Registration Card that is packed with this
-product. If you cannot find it, please send
-in the duplicate card printed in the back of
-this manual.
+Lock screen
+With the lock screen function on, you can unlock the watch to enter the watch face page only by
+using the watch button. This can prevent any error caused by mistouch. To close the lock screen
+function, tap the lock screen button again to close this function.
-Write the model and serial
-numbers here.
+Replace the Watch Face
-#
+To replace the watch face on the watch: Long press the watch face page for 2s, or go to "Settings –
+Watch face settings", slide left and right to scan the watch face, and tap one to complete replacement.
+To replace the watch face on the App: Tap "Profile – Amazfit GTR – Watch face settings" to
+download more watch faces on the Watch Face Store.
-#
+Status
-You can find them on a label on the
-upper left side of the fresh food
-compartment.
+Sliding left on the watch face page can enable you to enter the status page which displays the current
+steps and goal completed. Tapping the status entry can enable you to enter the details page which
-Staple sales slip or cancelled
-check here.
+shows you the steps, distance, calories and idle data.
-Proof of the original purchase date
-is needed to obtain service under
-the warranty.
+You can also enter the details page by sliding up on the watch face page and choosing "Status".
-2
+Heart Rate
-AService Partnership.
+Sliding left on the watch face can enable you to enter the heart rate page, and then the watch
+automatically starts to measure the heart rate. During measurement, it is required to properly wear
+the watch and keep the back of the watch fairly close to your skin until the watch can measure a
+stable heart rate.
+To enable the all-day measure function, open the Amazfit App, go to "Profile – Amazfit GTR –
+Heart rate detection", and choose to enable automatic heart rate detection.
-We stand behind our products with
-unmatched quality service. However, did
-you know that most questions result from
-simple problems that you can easily
-fix yourself in just a few minutes? This
-Owner’s Manual can tell you how.
+Notes: With the all-day measure function on, the watch will measure the heart rate at regular time.
+Sliding right on the watch face can make the last heart rate value visible. You can enter the all-day
+heart rate details page by tapping it.
-Read this Manual
-Inside you will find many
-helpful hints on how to use and
-maintain your refrigerator
-properly. Just a little preventive
-care on your part can save you a
-great deal of time and money
-over the life of your refrigerator.
+Workout
-Review the Section on
-Troubleshooting Tips
+Amazfit GTR supports twelve workout types: Outdoor running, Walking, Outdoor cycling,
+Treadmill, Indoor cycling, Pool swim, Open water swim, Elliptical trainer, Climb, Trail run, Skiing,
+and Exercise. See the "Workout" section for more details about the functions of different workout
+types.
-You’ll find many answers to
-common problems here.
-If you review our chart of
-Troubleshooting Tips first,
-you may not need to call for
-service at all.
+Workout Record
-If You Need Service
+The workout data on the watch will be stored in workout records, which are shown from the latest
+to the earliest. Tapping a specific workout record will make the workout details visible. The visible
+details vary in workout type.
-If you do need service, you can
-relax knowing help is only a
-phone call away. A list of toll-free
-customer service numbers is
-included in the back section.
-Or you can always call the
-GE Answer Center® at
-800.626.2000, 24 hours a day,
-7 days a week.
+The workout record not uploaded to the App will be marked with a little red dot before it. Open the
+App to synchronize data timely to avoid the loss of workout records.
-Safety Information
-Safety Precautions . . . . . . . . . .4
-Proper Disposal . . . . . . . . . . . . .5
-How to Connect Electricity . . . .6
-Use of Adapter Plugs . . . . . .6, 7
-Use of Extension Cords . . . . . .7
+To delete a workout record on the watch, tap to enter the workout record details page, slide up to
+the bottom of the page, and then tap the delete button.
-Operating Instructions
+Weather
-Temperature Control Dial . . . . .8
-Shelves . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .9, 10
-Storage Drawers . . . . . . . .11, 12
-Automatic Icemaker . . . . . . . .13
-Care and Cleaning . . . . . .14–16
+Tapping the weather function can give you access to the current weather conditions and the weather
+forecast. If weather data are invisible, you should open the App and connect the device to update
+the data.
-Installation Instructions
+Music
-Preparing to
-Install the Refrigerator . . .17, 18
-Water Line Installation . . .19–23
-Reversing the
-Door Swing . . . . . . . . . . . .24–29
+With the Bluetooth, the watch can suspend or play the music on the mobile music player, switch
+between songs, and adjust the volume.
+ Open the mobile music player first, and then enable the music function on the watch.
+
+
-Troubleshooting Tips
+If you are using an iOS device, you need to pair and connect the watch with the Amazfit App.
+If you are using an Android device, you need to connect the watch with the Amazfit App and
+also enable the notification reading permission on the App.
-Normal Operating Sounds . . .30
-Before You
-Call For Service . . . . . . . . .31–33
+Notes: The compatibility of the Android mobile phone system and the openness of different music
+players may to a certain extent affect the music control function of the watch.
-Customer Service
-Product Registration . . . . . . . .37
-Warranty . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .39
-Service Telephone
-Numbers . . . . . . . . . .Back Cover
+Notifications
-3
+Enable notifications
+During use, you need to enable the corresponding "App alerts" on the App, and keep the watch and
+the mobile phone connected. You can also enable the incoming SMS and incoming call alerts as you
+wish.
+
+
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
+If you are using an iOS device, you need to pair and connect the watch with the Amazfit App.
+If you are using an Android device, you need to keep the App running in the background or
+include the App into the self-starting whitelist, so as to ensure the mobile phone can send the
+alert to the watch.
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
+View notifications
+1.
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
+In the case of an incoming notification, the watch will automatically light up the screen and
+display the content.
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
+2. You can view the unread notification in the notification list and tap any notification to enter the
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
+notification details page.
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
+Delete notifications
+
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
+The read notification on the watch or the mobile phone will be automatically deleted from the
+notification list on the watch.
+To manually delete the notification on the watch, slide left on the notification to be deleted and
+tap the delete button.
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
+
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
+Alarm
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
+Amazfit GTR supports creating and managing the alarm on the watch. You can also create a watch
+alarm on the Amazfit App.
+Tapping the create button on the watch alarm function page can enable you to set the alarm time and
-4
+cycle. After saved, the alarm can be opened and closed in the alarm list.
+To create an alarm via the Amazfit App, go to "Profile – Amazfit GTR – Watch alarm" and add an
+alarm upon the tips on the page.
-IMPORTANT SAFETY INFORMATION.
-READ ALL INSTRUCTIONS BEFORE USING.
-WARNING!
+Alarm alert
+In the case of a watch alarm alert, you can choose to close it or remind you later.
-Use this appliance only for its intended purpose as
-described in this Owner’s Manual.
+To close the alarm, long press any button for 2s within the duration of the alarm alert.
-SAFETY PRECAUTIONS
-When using electrical appliances, basic safety precautions
-should be followed, including the following:
+To make a delayed alert, you can, within the duration of the alarm alert, tap the "Z" button at the
+bottom. Then, the alarm will remind you 10min later.
-n Keep fingers out of the
-“pinch point” areas;
-clearances between the
-doors and between the doors
-and cabinet are necessarily
-small. Be careful closing
-doors when children are in
-the area.
+Event Reminder
-n Unplug the refrigerator
+You need to create and manage the event reminder via the Amazfit App. The watch will display
+your to-do list and vibrate to remind you in the set time.
+Open the Amazfit App, go to "Profile – Amazfit GTR – Event reminder", and create the event
+reminder upon the tips on the page.
+An alert will pop up on the watch when the time set for the event arrives. Tap the "×" button at the
+bottom to close the alert.
-before cleaning and making
-repairs.
+The watch supports modifying and deleting the event reminder.
+To modify the event reminder, tap the right arrow on the event reminder list page to modify the
+event reminder date and time.
-NOTE: We strongly recommend
-that any servicing be performed
-by a qualified individual.
+To delete the event reminder, slide right on the event to be deleted and tap the trash icon to delete it.
-n Turning the control to the
+Timer
-OFF position does not remove
-power to the light circuit.
-n Do not refreeze frozen foods
+The timer on the watch supports one hundredth of a second. To enable the timer, pull up the app list
+on the watch face and choose the timer app.
+
+ During timing, you can also count the number of times by tapping the button on the bottom
-which have thawed
-completely.
+Tapping the start button can activate the timer to time it right away.
-n This refrigerator must be
-properly installed and
-located in accordance with
-the Installation Instructions
-before it is used.
+left on the watch screen (up to 99 times of such operation),
+and suspend the current timer by tapping the button on the bottom right on the watch screen.
-n Do not allow children to
+
+ When the timer pauses, you can reset it by tapping the button on the bottom left on the watch
+screen, and resume timing by tapping the button on the bottom right on the watch screen.
-climb, stand or hang on the
-shelves in the refrigerator.
-They could damage the
-refrigerator and seriously
-injure themselves.
-n Do not touch the cold
-surfaces in the freezer
-compartment, particularly
-when hands are damp or wet.
-Skin may stick to these
-extremely cold surfaces.
-n Do not store or use gasoline
-or other flammable vapors
-and liquids in the vicinity of
-this or any other appliance.
+Count Down
-n In refrigerators with
+To enable the count down, pull up the app list on the watch face and choose the count down app.
+By default, the watch supports the shortcut count down of 1min, 3min, 5min, 10min, 15min, 20min,
+30min, and 60min. You can enable the count down function right away by tapping it.
+A custom count down function is available, which ranges from 1min to 23h and 59min.
-automatic icemakers, avoid
-contact with the moving parts
-of the ejector mechanism, or
-with the heating element that
-releases the cubes. Do not
-place fingers or hands on the
-automatic icemaking
-mechanism while the
-refrigerator is plugged in.
+You can suspend, resume or stop the count down function anytime when it operates. When time's
+up, the watch will vibrate to remind you. You can close the count down function by tapping the "×"
+button at the bottom.
-DANGER! RISK OF CHILD
+Find Device
-ENTRAPMENT
-PROPER DISPOSAL OF THE REFRIGERATOR
+Amazfit GTR supports finding the device via the Bluetooth. To enable this function, slide up the
+app list on the watch face page and tap the find device function.
+
-Child entrapment and suffocation are not problems of
-the past. Junked or abandoned refrigerators are still
-dangerous…even if they will sit for “just a few days.”
-If you are getting rid of your old refrigerator, please
-follow the instructions below to help prevent accidents.
+To activate the find device function, you need to keep the Amazfit App running and ensure the
+watch is connected to the mobile phone. Otherwise the function is not available.
-Before You Throw Away Your Old Refrigerator
-or Freezer:
+ On the find page, the watch will automatically find the device. If no device is found after 60s,
-n Take off the doors.
-n Leave the shelves in place so that children may not
+a failure prompt will display and then you can try again.
-easily climb inside.
+ When found, the mobile phone will beep. You can close the ring on the mobile phone by
+tapping the tip button on the watch. Meanwhile, the mobile phone will produce a message on
+the notification bar. Tapping the message can draw back the Amazfit App and close the ring on
+the mobile phone.
-CFC Disposal
+Notes: If you wish to use the find device function anytime, you can include the Amazfit App into
+the built-in self-starting whitelist and keep it running in the background. In addition, the watch is
+required to be connected to the mobile phone, otherwise it is unable to find the mobile phone.
-Your old refrigerator has a cooling system that used
-CFCs (chlorofluorocarbons). CFCs are believed to harm
-stratospheric ozone.
+Compass/Air Pressure/Altitude
-If you are throwing away your old refrigerator, make
-sure the CFC refrigerant is removed for proper disposal
-by a qualified servicer. If you intentionally release this
-CFC refrigerant you can be subject to fines and
-imprisonment under provisions of the Federal Clean
-Air Act.
+Amazfit GTR supports the compass function. When the compass page opens, the watch
+automatically detects the current orientation and degree. If needed, you can wear the watch and
+calibrate the compass by filling out that circle with figure 8 movements in the air, until the watch
+vibrates. Then the compass function can be reused.
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
+Sliding up on the compass page can enable you to enter the atmospheric pressure page. The
+barometer on the watch displays the current air pressure in real time.
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
+Sliding up on the air pressure page can enable you to enter the altitude page. The altitude requires
+double calibration of watch barometer and GPS. If you want more accurate altitude data, try to get
+the satellite positioning in an open area as soon as possible.
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
+Settings
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
+The watch settings page includes some watch settings and built-in control functions.
+Watch face settings: You can quickly switch between watch faces.
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
+Screen-on duration: You can control the screen-on duration of the watch for 8s (by default) to 15s
+(max).
-5
+Quick start: You can short press the button on the bottom right to quickly start one watch function
+(by default, workout list).
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
+System: It supports viewing the firmware version and regulatory information, and controlling the
+actions of closing and rebooting the watch and performing the factory reset.
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
+Workout Function
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
+Amazfit GTR supports twelve workout types: Outdoor running, Walking, Outdoor cycling,
+Treadmill, Indoor cycling, Pool swim, Open water swim, Elliptical trainer, Climb, Trail run, Skiing,
+and Exercise. And the workout types like Outdoor running, Walking, Outdoor cycling, Open water
+swim, Climb, Trail run, and Skiing support recording GPS-enabled workout tracks.
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
+There are two approaches to enabling the workout function on the watch:
+
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
+If the workout list is set for quick start, then you can quickly enter the workout list by short
+pressing the button on the bottom right on the watch face page. By default, the last workout
+type displays.
+Sliding up on the watch face page and choosing "Workout" can enable you to enter the workout
+list page and choose the workout you want to start.
-6
+
-IMPORTANT SAFETY INFORMATION.
-READ ALL INSTRUCTIONS BEFORE USING.
-WARNING!
+Workout Positioning
-HOW TO CONNECT ELECTRICITY
-Do not, under any circumstances, cut or remove the third
-(ground) prong from the power cord. For personal safety,
-this appliance must be properly grounded.
+If you choose to start Outdoor running, you'd better go to the open area before workouts, which is
+conducive to rapid GPS positioning.
-The power cord of this appliance is equipped with a 3-prong
-(grounding) plug which mates with a standard 3-prong
-(grounding) wall outlet to minimize the possibility of electric
-shock hazard from this appliance.
+If it takes a long time to process positioning, it may be because the buildings nearby block satellite
+signals, or because the watch is disconnected to the App for a long time, causing the AGPS to be
+not upgraded. You can open the Amazfit App, connect it to the watch, and try again after the AGPS
+is updated.
+It is recommended to ensure GPS positioning is processed successfully before the outdoor workout.
+If you start the workout during positioning, the workout track cannot be recorded and the recorded
+workout data will not be accurate.
+After GPS positioning is processed successfully, the "GO" icon will be lit up and you can tap it to
+start the workout.
-Have the wall outlet and circuit checked by a qualified electrician
-to make sure the outlet is properly grounded.
+During Workouts
-Where a standard 2-prong wall outlet is encountered, it is your
-personal responsibility and obligation to have it replaced with a
-properly grounded 3-prong wall outlet.
+During workouts, the watch will display the current workout data in real time, such as time, distance,
+pace/speed, and heart rate. After the watch screen goes off, the screen can be lit up again by lifting
+the wrist or touching the screen.
+Sliding right during workouts can enable you to view the time, date, and watch power.
-The refrigerator should always be plugged into its own individual
-electrical outlet which has a voltage rating that matches the rating
-plate.
+Swimming
-This provides the best performance and also prevents overloading
-house wiring circuits which could cause a fire hazard from
-overheated wires.
+With the swimming workout enabled, the watch will automatically lock the screen to avoid water
+drops interfering with the screen display during the workout. To unlock the screen, you can short
+press any button on the watch, and the screen will be locked again after the watch screen goes off.
-Never unplug your refrigerator by pulling on the power cord.
-Always grip plug firmly and pull straight out from the outlet.
+Workout Reminder
-Repair or replace immediately all power cords that have become
-frayed or otherwise damaged. Do not use a cord that shows cracks or
-abrasion damage along its length or at either end.
+The workout reminder on the watch varies in workout type. For the workout types Running, Cycling,
+and Walking, the alert will be vibrated once per kilometer by default. You can also set the alerts for
+other workout types before workouts. See the "Workout Settings" section for more details.
-When moving the refrigerator away from the wall, be careful not to
-roll over or damage the power cord.
+Workout Pause and End
-USE OF ADAPTER PLUGS
-Because of potential safety hazards under certain
-conditions, we strongly recommend against the use of an
-adapter plug.
+With the auto pause function on, the watch will automatically pause when the workout end is
+detected. When the workout resumes, the watch will automatically end the pause status and resume
+recording the workout performance.
-However, if you must use an adapter, where local codes permit, a
-temporary connection may be made to a properly grounded 2-prong
-wall outlet by use of a UL-listed adapter available at most local
-hardware stores.
+Tapping any button during a workout can suspend the workout.
-The larger slot in the adapter must be aligned with the larger slot in
-the wall outlet to provide proper polarity in the connection of the
-power cord.
+Tapping the right button can cancel the pause and resume the workout.
+Tapping the left button can end the current workout and save the workout performance.
-When disconnecting the power cord from the adapter, always hold
-the adapter in place with one hand while pulling the power cord
-plug with the other hand. If this is not done, the adapter ground
-terminal is very likely to break with repeated use.
+Workout Settings
-If the adapter ground terminal breaks, DO NOT USEthe refrigerator
-until a proper ground has been established.
+Before workouts, you can set some relevant functions.
+The workout goal supports three types: mileage, duration, and calories. When the set goal is
+achieved, the watch will vibrate to remind you.
-Attaching the adapter ground terminal to a wall outlet cover screw does not
-ground the appliance unless the cover screw is metal, and not insulated, and the
-wall outlet is grounded through the house wiring. You should have the circuit
-checked by a qualified electrician to make sure the outlet is properly grounded.
+The workout reminder supports five types: distance, pace, safe heart rate, heart rate zone, and pace
+With a reminder set, the watch will vibrate to remind you as long as the set value is reached during
+workouts.
-USE OF EXTENSION CORDS
-Because of potential safety hazards under certain
-conditions, we strongly recommend against the use of an
-extension cord.
+With the auto pause on, the watch will automatically detect the workout status. When the workout
+is stopped, the watch will automatically suspend the current exercise. And the watch will re-record
+the data when the workout is resumed.
+The real-time diagram supports demonstrating the real-time heart rate and pace. With the real-time
+diagram on, a curve is drawn for the fluctuations of the heart rate or pace during workouts.
-However, if you must use an extension cord, it is absolutely
-necessary that it be a UL-listed, 3-wire grounding type appliance
-extension cord having a grounding type plug and outlet and that
-the electrical rating of the cord be 15 amperes (minimum) and
-120 volts.
-
-REMEMBER…
-Your continued health and safety are important to us.
-
-Please read and follow this Safety Information carefully.
-
-We want you to remain a happy and healthy part of our
-family.
-SAVE THESE INSTRUCTIONS
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-7
-
-About the temperature control dial.
-
-Turning the dial to OFFstops cooling in both compartments—
-fresh food and freezer.
-
-9
-
-OFF
-
-7
-
-5
-
-3
-
-1
-
-Control Settings
-Temperature Control Dial
-
-The temperature control dial has nine settings plus OFF.
-1 is the warmest. 9 is the coldest. At first, set the dial at 5.
-
-After using the refrigerator, adjust the dial if necessary.
-
-Insert a coin into the slot in the middle of the dial and you can turn
-the dial to the setting that’s best suited to your needs.
-
-Allow 24 hours for the refrigerator to get cold.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-8
-
-About the fresh food compartment shelves.
-
-Shelf supports at various levels allow you to custom-space your shelves.
-Not all features are on all models.
-
-2 Lift up and out
-
-1 Tilt up
-
-Half-Width Shelves
-
-One end of the shelf rests on a molded side-wall
-support; a bracket on the other end hooks into a track
-on the rear cabinet wall.
-
-To remove,lift the shelf up at front, then off the support
-and out of the track.
-
-To replace,select desired shelf height. With shelf front
-raised slightly, hook the bracket’s top lug into the track,
-then lower the shelf onto the support.
-
-NOTE: The shelf to the right of the track is designed to
-hook into the right-hand slot; the shelf to the left is
-designed to hook into the left-hand slot.
-
-Full-Width Shelves
-
-Some models have a steel wire sliding shelf, a stationary
-tempered glass shelf or two steel wire stationary shelves.
-These shelves can be moved to another place in the
-fresh food compartment.
-
-The full-width sliding shelf has stop-locks. When placed
-correctly on the shelf supports, the shelf will stop before
-coming completely out of the refrigerator and will not
-tilt when you place food on it or remove food from it.
-
-To remove the full-width shelves,lift the rear of the shelf
-and pull forward.
-
-To remove a full-width shelf when the fresh food
-compartment door cannot be opened fully,lift the rear of
-the shelf, pull forward and down, tilt the shelf and take it
-out.
-
-9
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-About the freezer compartment shelves.
-
-Some models have an ice-tray shelf and some have a full-width step shelf.
-
-Plug Supports
-
-Ice-Tray Shelf
-
-To remove the ice-tray shelf:Lift the left side of the shelf
-off its supports, then pull the shelf to the left to free it of
-the plug supports. Pull the shelf to the right to free the
-pins from the holes in the cabinet wall.
-
-(cid:49)
-
-(cid:50)
-
-Step Shelf
-
-To remove the step shelf:
-
-1
-2
-
-3
-
-Lift left side of shelf slightly.
-
-Move shelf to the left to free its right ends from holes
-in the cabinet wall.
-
-Lower right side of shelf, move shelf to the right and
-take it out.
-
-To replace the step shelf:
-
-1
-
-2
-
-With shelf tilted as shown, fit left ends of shelf into
-holes in cabinet wall.
-
-Lift left side of shelf slightly, swing shelf up, fit right
-ends of shelf into holes in cabinet wall, and lower
-shelf into place.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-10
-
-About the storage drawers.
-
-Not all features are on all models.
-
-Fruit and Vegetable Drawers
-
-Excess water that may accumulate in the bottom of the
-drawers should be emptied and the drawers wiped dry.
-
-Utility Drawer
-
-The utility drawer can be moved to the most useful
-location for your family’s needs.
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-11
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-12
-
-About storage drawer and cover removal.
-
-Not all features are on all models.
-
-Drawer and Cover Removal
-
-Drawers will stop before coming all the way out of the refrigerator to
-help prevent contents from spilling onto the floor. These drawers
-can be removed easily by grasping the sides and lifting up slightly
-while pulling drawers past the stoplocation.
-
-Full-Width Drawer with Plastic Cover
-
-To remove the cover, lift it off its supports, pull it
-forward, tilt it and take it out.
-
-Twin Drawer With Glass Cover
-
-To remove:
-
-1
-2
-
-Remove the drawers.
-
-Reach in, push the front of glass cover up and, at the
-same time, pull it forward as far as it will come.
-
-Tilt it and take it out. Avoid cleaning the cold glass cover
-with hot water because the extreme temperature
-difference may cause it to break.
-
-3
-
-Remove the drawer frame. (Always remove the glass
-cover before you take out the drawer frame.)
-
-Lift the frame off the supports at each side and back,
-pull it forward, tilt it and take it out.
-
-To replace:
-
-Lower the frame until it rests on the supports at each
-side and back.
-
-Replace the glass cover, pushing its rear edge firmly
-into the rear frame channel and gently lowering the
-front into place.
-
-Replace the drawers.
-
-1
-
-2
-
-3
-
-About the automatic icemaker.
-
-A newly-installed refrigerator may take 8 to 12 hours to begin making ice.
-
-Icemaker
-
-Feeler arm
-in the STOP
-(up) position
-
-Ice Storage Bin
-
-Automatic Icemaker (on some models)
-
-The icemaker will produce eight cubes per cycle—
-approximately 100 cubes in a 24-hour period,
-depending on freezer compartment temperature, room
-temperature, number of door openings and other use
-conditions.
-
-If the refrigerator is operated before the water
-connection is made to the icemaker, keep the feeler arm
-in the STOP (up) position.
-
-Feeler arm in the
-ON (down) position
-
-When the refrigerator has been connected to the water
-supply, move the feeler arm to the ON (down) position.
-
-The icemaker will fill with water when it cools to
-freezing. A newly-installed refrigerator may take 8 to 12
-hours to begin making ice cubes.
-
-Throw away the first few batches of ice to allow the water
-line to clear.
-
-Be sure nothing interferes with the swing of the feeler
-arm.
-
-It is normal for several cubes to be joined together.
-
-If ice is not used frequently, old ice cubes will become
-cloudy and taste stale.
-
-Icemaker Accessory Kit
-
-If your refrigerator did not come already equipped with an
-automatic icemaker, an icemaker accessory kit is available at extra
-cost. Check the back of the refrigerator for the specific icemaker kit
-needed for your model.
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-13
-
-Care and cleaning of the refrigerator.
-
-Cleaning the Outside
-
-The door handles and trim (on some models). Clean with a cloth
-dampened with soapy water. Dry with a soft cloth.
-
-Keep the outside clean.Wipe with a clean cloth lightly dampened
-with kitchen appliance wax or mild liquid dish detergent. Dry and
-polish with a clean, soft cloth.
-
-Do not wipe the refrigerator with a soiled dish cloth or wet towel. These may
-leave a residue that can erode the paint. Do not use scouring pads, powdered
-cleaners, bleach or cleaners containing bleach because these products can
-scratch and weaken the paint finish.
-
-Cleaning the Inside
-
-To help prevent odors, leave an open box of baking soda in the fresh
-food and freezer compartments.
-
-Unplug the refrigerator before cleaning. If this is not practical, wring
-excess moisture out of sponge or cloth when cleaning around
-switches, lights or controls.
-
-Use warm water and baking soda solution—about a tablespoon
-(15 ml) of baking soda to a quart (1 L) of water. This both cleans
-and neutralizes odors. Rinse and wipe dry.
-
-Use an appliance wax polish on the inside surface between the
-doors.
-
-After cleaning the door gaskets, apply a thin layer of petroleum jelly
-to the door gaskets at the hinge side. This helps keep the gaskets
-from sticking and bending out of shape.
-
-Avoid cleaning cold glass shelves (on some models) with hot water because the
-extreme temperature difference may cause them to break. Handle glass shelves
-carefully. Bumping tempered glass can cause it to shatter.
-
-Do not wash any plastic refrigerator parts in the dishwasher.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-14
-
-Under the Refrigerator
-
-For most efficient operation, keep the area under the
-refrigerator clean. Turn the temperature control dial to
-OFF. Sweep away or vacuum up dust.
-
-Clean the condenser coils at least
-once a year.
-
-For best results, use a brush specially designed for this
-purpose. It is available at most appliance parts stores.
-
-Behind the Refrigerator
-
-Be careful when moving the refrigerator away from the wall. All
-types of floor coverings can be damaged, particularly cushioned
-coverings and those with embossed surfaces.
-
-Turn the leveling legs at each front corner of the refrigerator
-counterclockwise until the rollers support the refrigerator. Pull
-the refrigerator straight out and return it to position by pushing it
-straight in. Moving the refrigerator in a side direction may result in
-damage to the floor covering or refrigerator.
-
-When pushing the refrigerator back, make sure you don’t roll over the power
-cord or icemaker supply line (on some models).
-
-After rolling the refrigerator back into place, turn the legs clockwise
-until the legs again bear the weight of the refrigerator.
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-15
-
-Care and cleaning of the refrigerator.
-
-Light Bulb Replacement
-
-To replace a burned out bulb, unplug the refrigerator from its
-electrical outlet, unscrew the bulb when cool and replace it with an
-appliance bulb of the same or lower wattage.
-
-Turning the control to the OFFposition does not remove power to the light circuit.
-
-Preparing for Vacation
-
-For long vacations or absences, remove food and unplug the
-refrigerator. Turn the temperature control dial to the OFF position,
-and clean the interior with a baking soda solution of one tablespoon
-(15 ml) of baking soda to one quart (1 L) of water. Leave the
-doors open.
-
-Move the icemaker feeler arm to STOP (up) position and shut
-off the water supply to the refrigerator.
-
-If the temperature can drop below freezing, have a qualified
-servicer drain the water supply system (on some models) to prevent
-serious property damage due to flooding.
-
-Preparing to Move
-
-Secure all loose items such as grille, shelves and drawers by taping
-them securely in place to prevent damage.
-
-Be sure the refrigerator stays in an upright position during moving.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-16
-
-Preparing to install the refrigerator.
-
-Read these instructions completely and carefully.
-
-Water Supply to the Icemaker (on some models)
-
-If the refrigerator has an icemaker, or if you plan to add an
-icemaker later, it will have to be connected to a cold water line.
-
-A water supply kit (containing copper tubing, shutoff valve, fittings
-and instructions) is available at extra cost from your dealer or from
-Parts and Accessories, 800-626-2002.
-
-Refrigerator Location
-
-Do not install the refrigerator where the temperature will go below
-60°F. (16°C.) because it will not run often enough to maintain
-proper temperatures.
-
-Install it on a floor strong enough to support it fully loaded.
-
-Clearances
-
-Allow the following clearances for ease of installation, proper air
-circulation and plumbing and electrical connections:
-3/4† (19 mm)
-1† (25 mm)
-1† (25 mm)
-
-Sides
-
-Back
-
-Top
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-17
-
-Preparing to install the refrigerator.
-
-Read these instructions completely and carefully.
-
-Rollers and Leveling Legs
-
-Leveling legsnear each front corner of the refrigerator are adjustable. They
-firmly position the refrigerator and prevent it from moving when the doors are
-opened. Leveling legs should be set so the front of the refrigerator is raised just
-enough that the doors close easily when opened about halfway.
-
-Turn the leveling legs clockwise to raisethe refrigerator, counterclockwise to
-lower it.
-
-Rollersnext to the leveling legs allow you to move the refrigerator away from the
-wall for cleaning.
-
-Turn the legs counterclockwise until the weight of the refrigerator is transferred
-from them to the rollers. After rolling the refrigerator back into place, turn the
-legs clockwise until the legs again bear the weight of the refrigerator.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-18
-
-Installing the water line.
-
-Read these instructions completely and carefully.
-
-Before You Begin
-This water line installation is not warranted by the
-refrigerator or icemaker manufacturer. Follow these
-instructions carefully to minimize the risk of expensive
-water damage.
-
-Water hammer (water banging in the pipes) in house
-plumbing can cause damage to refrigerator parts and lead
-to water leakage or flooding. Call a qualified plumber to
-correct water hammer before installing the water supply
-line to the refrigerator.
-
-To prevent burns and product damage, do not hook up the
-water line to the hot water line.
-
-If you use your refrigerator before connecting the water
-line, make sure the icemaker feeler arm is kept in the STOP
-(up) position.
-
-Do not install the icemaker tubing in areas where
-temperatures fall below freezing.
-
-When using any electrical device (such as a power drill)
-during installation, be sure the device is insulated or wired
-in a manner to prevent the hazard of electric shock.
-
-All installations must be in accordance with local plumbing
-code requirements.
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-19
-
-Installing the water line.
-
-Read these instructions completely and carefully.
-
-What You Will Need
-To determine how much copper tubing you need:
-
-Measure the distance from the water valve on the back of the
-refrigerator to the water supply pipe. Then add 8 feet (244 cm).
-Be sure there is sufficient extra tubing [about 8 feet (244 cm)
-coiled into 3 turns of about 10 inches (25 cm) diameter] to allow
-the refrigerator to move out from the wall after installation.
-n A water supply kit(containing copper tubing, shutoff valve and
-fittings listed below) is available at extra cost from your dealer
-or from Parts and Accessories, 800-626-2002.
-
-n Cold water supply.The water pressure must be between
-
-20 and 120 p.s.i.
-
-n Power drill.
-
-n Copper tubing,1/4† outer diameter to connect the refrigerator to
-the water supply. Be sure both ends of the tubing are cut square.
-
-Do not use plastic tubing or plastic fittings because the water supply line is
-under pressure at all times. Certain types of plastic tubing may become brittle
-with age and crack, resulting in water leakage.
-
-n Two 1/4† outer diameter compression nuts and 2 ferrules (sleeves)—
-
-to connect the copper tubing to the shutoff valve and the
-refrigerator water valve.
-
-n If your existing water line has a flared fitting at the end, you will
-
-need an adapter(available at plumbing supply stores) to connect
-the water line to the refrigerator ORyou can cut off the flared
-fitting with a tube cutter and then use a compression fitting.
-n Shutoff valve to connect to the cold water line. The shutoff valve
-should have a water inlet with a minimum inside diameter of
-5/32† at the point of connection to the COLD WATER LINE.Saddle-
-type shutoff valves are included in many water supply kits. Before
-purchasing, make sure a saddle-type valve complies with your
-local plumbing codes.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-20
-
-Shut Off the Main Water Supply
-
-Turn on the nearest faucet long enough to clear the line of water.
-
-Install the Shutoff Valve
-1
-2
-
-Install the shutoff valve on the nearest frequently used drinking water line.
-
-Choose a location for the valve that is easily accessible. It is best to connect
-into the side of a vertical water pipe. When it is necessary to connect into a
-horizontal water pipe, make the connection to the top or side, rather than at
-the bottom, to avoid drawing off any sediment from the water pipe.
-Drill a 1/4† hole in the water pipe, using a sharp bit. Remove any burrs
-resulting from drilling the hole in the pipe.
-
-3
-
-4
-5
-
-Fasten the shutoff valve to the cold water pipe with the pipe clamp.
-
-Tighten the clamp screws until the sealing washer begins to swell.
-
-Do not overtighten or you may crush the copper tubing.
-
-Pipe Clamp
-
-Washer
-
-Inlet End
-
-Saddle-Type Shutoff Valve
-
-Vertical Cold Water Pipe
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-21
-
-Installing the water line.
-
-Read these instructions completely and carefully.
-
-Route the Copper Tubing and Connect It to the Shutoff Valve
-
-Route the copper tubing between the cold water line and the refrigerator.
-
-Route the tubing through a hole drilled in the wall or floor (behind the
-refrigerator or adjacent base cabinet) as close to the wall as possible.
-
-Be sure there is sufficient extra tubing [about 8 feet (244 cm) coiled into 3 turns of about
-10† (25 cm) diameter] to allow the refrigerator to move out from the wall after installation.
-
-Place the compression nut and ferrule (sleeve) onto the end of the tubing and
-connect it to the shutoff valve.
-
-Make sure the tubing is fully inserted into the valve. Tighten the compression nut
-securely.
-
-Saddle-Type Shutoff Valve
-
-Compression Nut
-
-Packing
-Nut
-
-Outlet Valve
-
-Ferrule (sleeve)
-
-Turn On the Water and Flush Out the Tubing
-1
-
-Turn the main water supply on and flush out the tubing until the water
-is clear.
-
-2
-
-Shut the water off at the water valve after about one quart (1 L) of water has
-been flushed through the tubing.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-22
-
-Connect the Tubing to the Refrigerator
-
-Before making the connection to the refrigerator, be sure the
-refrigerator power cord is not plugged into the wall outlet.
-
-We recommend installing a water filter if your water supply has sand or particles
-that could clog the screen of the refrigerator’s water valve. Install it in the water
-line near the refrigerator.
-
-1
-2
-
-3
-
-4
-
-Remove the plastic flexible cap from the water valve.
-
-Place the compression nut and ferrule (sleeve) onto the end of the tubing as
-shown.
-
-Insert the end of the copper tubing into the water valve connection as far as
-possible. While holding the tubing, tighten the fitting.
-
-Fasten the copper tubing into the clamp provided to hold it in a vertical
-position. You may need to pry open the clamp.
-
-1/4† Copper Tubing
-
-Tubing Clamp
-
-Ferrule (sleeve)
-
-1/4† Compression Nut
-
-Refrigerator Connection
-
-Turn the Water On at the Shutoff Valve
-
-Tighten any connections that leak.
-
-Plug In the Refrigerator
-
-Arrange the coil of copper tubing so that it does not vibrate against the back of
-the refrigerator or against the wall.
-
-Push the refrigerator back to the wall.
-
-Start the Icemaker
-
-Set the icemaker feeler arm to the ON (down) position. The icemaker will
-not begin to operate until it reaches its operating temperature of 15°F. (-9°C.)
-or below. It will then begin operation automatically if the icemaker feeler arm
-is in the ON(down) position.
-
-NOTE: The icemaker may double-cycle when it first starts, causing some water spillage from
-the icemaker into the ice bucket. This is normal and should not happen again.
-
-23
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-Reversing the door swing.
-
-Read these instructions completely and carefully.
-
-Important Notes
-When reversing the door swing :
-
-n Read the instructions all the way through before starting.
-n Handle parts carefully to avoid scratching paint.
-n Set screws down by their related parts to avoid using them in the
-
-wrong places.
-
-n Provide a non-scratching work surface for the doors.
-IMPORTANT: Once you begin, do not move the cabinet until
-door-swing reversal is completed.
-
-These instructions are for changing the hinges from the
-right side to the left side—if you ever want to change the
-hinges back to the right side, follow these same instructions
-and reverse all references to left and right.
-
-Tools Required
-n 5/16† hex-head socket screwdriver
-n Masking tape
-n T20 or T25 Torxdriver, whichever your model requires
-n Putty knife or thin-blade screwdriver
-n 5/16† open-end wrench
-n Phillips screwdriver
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-24
-
-Removing the doors.
-
-Unplug the refrigerator from its electrical outlet.
-
-Before Removing the Doors
-1
-2
-CAUTION: Do not let either door drop to the floor. To do so could
-damage the door stop.
-
-Empty all door shelves, including the dairy compartment.
-
-Remove the Freezer Door
-1
-2
-
-Tape the door shut with masking tape.
-With a 5/16† hex-head socket screwdriver, remove the screws that hold the
-top hinge to the cabinet.
-
-3
-
-4
-
-5
-6
-
-Lift the hinge (and the shim glued to it) straight up to free the hinge pin
-from the socket in the top of the door and set it aside, along with its screws.
-
-Remove the tape, tilt the door away from the cabinet and carefully lift the
-door to free its bottom socket from the hinge pin on the center hinge
-bracket.
-
-Set the door on a non-scratching surface with the outside up.
-
-Using a Torxdriver, transfer the 2 screws from the opposite side of the
-cabinet to the screw holes vacated by the top hinge removal.
-
-Top Hinge
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-25
-
-Removing the doors/Reversing the hardware.
-
-Read these instructions completely and carefully.
-
-Remove the Fresh Food Door
-1
-2
-
-Tape the door shut with masking tape.
-Using a 5/16† hex-head socket screwdriver and a 5/16† open-end wrench,
-remove the two screws holding the center hinge (and the shim glued to it) to
-the cabinet. Lift the center hinge to free its pin from the socket in the top of
-the door, and set hinge and screws aside.
-
-3
-
-4
-5
-
-6
-
-Remove the tape and tilt the door away from the cabinet. Lift the door from
-the pin in the bottom hinge bracket. (If the plastic washer sticks to the door
-bottom, put it back on the hinge.)
-
-Set the door outside-up on a non-scratching surface.
-
-Using a Torxdriver, transfer the two screws from the opposite side of the
-cabinet to the screw holes vacated by the center hinge removal.
-
-Take one of the screws removed in step 2 and start it in the outermost screw
-hole on the opposite side. Do not drive it all the way down—leave enough
-space under the screw head for thickness of shim and bracket.
-
-Center Hinge Bracket
-
-Hinge Pin
-
-Plastic Washer
-
-Transfer Bottom Hinge to the Left
-1
-
-Remove the base grille (if your refrigerator has one) by pulling it straight
-out.
-
-2
-
-Using a Torxdriver, move the bottom hinge bracket (and the shim glued to
-it) and plastic washer from the right side to the left side.
-
-Plastic Washer
-
-Hinge Bracket
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-26
-
-Reversing the door handles.
-
-Transfer Top Hinge to the Left
-
-Interchange hinge (and the shim glued to it) and screws at top right with screws
-at top left of cabinet.
-
-Do not tighten screws on hinge side at this time.
-
-Some hinges have four holes. Which holes you use for installing the hinge
-depends on which side you install the hinge.
-
-Installing the hinge on the left.
-
-Installing the hinge on the right.
-
-Transfer Fresh Food Door Handle
-
-Top View
-
-Bottom View
-
-1
-
-2
-
-3
-4
-
-Remove the bottom cap by
-pushing it toward the bottom of
-the door and remove the screw
-underneath.
-
-Remove the two screws holding
-the handle to the top of the door.
-
-Remove the handle.
-
-Remove the screws from the right
-edge of the door top and insert
-them into the handle screw holes
-on the opposite side.
-
-5
-
-6
-
-With tape-tipped putty knife or
-thin-blade screwdriver, pry out the
-plug button from the hinge hole
-on the left side of the door and
-insert it into the hole on the
-opposite side that was vacated by
-removal of the top hinge.
-
-Pull the plug button from the
-front of the door and transfer it to
-the opposite side.
-
-Plug Button
-
-Screws for
-Handle Holes
-
-Plug Button
-
-To reattach the handle on the
-opposite side.
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-27
-
-Rehanging the doors.
-
-Read these instructions completely and carefully.
-
-Transfer Door Stop
-1
-
-Move the metal door stop from
-the right end to the left end. Use a
-Torxdriver.
-
-Door Stop
-
-2
-
-Move any screws from the left end
-to the right end.
-
-Right Side
-
-Left Side
-
-Reinstalling the Fresh Food Door Handle
-1
-
-Attach the handle to the right side of the door with screws at the top and
-under the handle plug.
-
-Reinstall the handle plug.
-
-2
-Transfer Freezer Door Handle
-1
-
-Remove the screw holding the handle to the top of the door and the two
-screws holding the handle to the bottom of the door.
-
-2
-3
-
-4
-
-5
-6
-
-Remove the handle.
-
-Remove the screw from the right top edge of the door and insert it into the
-handle screw hole on the left side.
-
-Pull the plug button from the left top edge of the door and transfer it to the
-opposite side.
-
-Transfer the door stop as shown above.
-
-Attach the handle to the right edge of the door with screws at top and
-bottom, using bottom holes vacated by removal of the door stop screws.
-
-Left Side
-
-Right Side
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-28
-
-Rehang the Fresh Food Door
-1
-
-Lower the bottom socket of the fresh food door onto the pin on the bottom
-hinge.
-
-Be sure the washer is in place on the pin.
-
-2
-
-3
-
-Insert the pin on the center hinge into the socket in the top of the door.
-NOTE:The center hinge must be turned over as shown when mounted on the
-left side.
-
-Tilt the door toward the cabinet. As the door is brought into position, slide
-the hinge under the head of the screw which earlier had been partly driven
-into the outermost hole. Insert the remaining screw, then tighten both
-screws securely.
-
-Hinge Pin
-
-Plastic
-Washer
-
-Hinge Pin
-
-Plastic Washer
-
-Rehang the Freezer Door
-1
-
-Be sure the washer is in place on the pin.
-
-Lower the bottom socket of the freezer door onto the center hinge pin.
-
-2
-
-3
-
-Tilt the door toward the cabinet, lifting the top hinge so the pin fits into the
-socket on the top of the door.
-
-Make sure the door is straight and the gap between the doors is even
-across the front. Tighten the top hinge screws. Do not overtighten these
-screws—tighten them until they are just snug, then turn them another one-
-half turn.
-
-Center Hinge Pin
-
-Plastic Washer
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-29
-
-Normal operating sounds.
-
-Depending on the placement of the refrigerator in your kitchen,
-you may want to place a piece of rubber backed carpet under
-the refrigerator to reduce noise.
-
-The fan circulating air inside the freezer which
-keeps the temperatures even.
-
-Boiling water or a gurgling noise. The flow of
-refrigerant through the freezer cooling coils.
-
-Sizzling, hissing or popping sound. Water
-dropping on the defrost heater during the
-defrost cycle.
-
-Cracking or popping sound. Cooling coils
-expanding and contracting during the
-defrosting cycle.
-
-Water dripping as it melts from the evaporator
-and flows to the drain pan during the defrost
-cycle.
-
-Icemaker (on some models)
-
-The icemaker water valve will buzz when the
-icemaker fills with water. If the feeler arm is in
-the ON(down) position it will buzz even if it has
-not yet been hooked up to water. Keeping the
-feeler arm in the ON(down) position before it is
-hooked up to water can damage the icemaker.
-To prevent this, raise the feeler arm to the STOP
-(up) position. This will stop the buzzing.
-
-The sound of cubes dropping into the bin and
-water running in pipes as icemaker refills.
-
-These sounds are normal
-and are due mostly to highly
-efficient operation.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-30
-
-Before you call for service…
-
-Troubleshooting Tips
-Save time and money! Review the charts on the following pages first and
-you may not need to call for service.
-
-Problem
-
-Possible Causes
-
-What To Do
-
-Refrigerator does not
-operate
-
-Refrigerator in
-defrost cycle.
-
-Temperature control
-dial in OFFposition.
-
-Refrigerator is
-unplugged.
-
-The fuse is blown/
-circuit breaker is
-tripped.
-
-Normal when
-refrigerator is first
-plugged in.
-
-Often occurs when large
-amounts of food are
-placed in refrigerator.
-
-Door left open.
-
-• Wait about 30 minutes for
-
-defrost cycle to end.
-
-• Move the temperature
-
-control dial to a
-temperature setting.
-
-• Push the plug completely
-
-into the outlet.
-
-• Replace fuse or reset the
-
-breaker.
-
-• Wait 24 hours for the
-
-refrigerator to completely
-cool down.
-
-• This is normal.
-
-• Check to see if package is
-
-holding door open.
-
-Hot weather or frequent
-door openings.
-
-• This is normal.
-
-Temperature control dial
-set at the coldest setting.
-
-• See About the temperature
-
-control dial.
-
-Grille and condenser
-need cleaning.
-
-Front roller screws or
-front leveling legs need
-adjusting.
-
-• See Care and cleaning.
-
-• See Rollers and leveling legs.
-
-Motor operates for long
-periods or cycles on and
-off frequently. (Modern
-refrigerators with more
-storage space and a larger
-freezer require more
-operating time. They start
-and stop often to maintain
-even temperatures.)
-
-Vibration or rattling
-(slight vibration is normal)
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-31
-
-Before you call for service…
-
-Troubleshooting Tips
-
-Problem
-
-Possible Causes
-
-What To Do
-
-Fresh food or freezer
-compartment too warm
-
-Temperature control
-dial not set cold enough.
-
-• See About the temperature
-
-control dial.
-
-Warm weather or
-frequent door openings.
-
-Door left open.
-
-Package blocking air
-duct in freezer
-compartment.
-
-Door left open.
-
-Too frequent or too
-long door openings.
-
-• Set the temperature
-control dial one step
-colder. See About the
-temperature control dial.
-
-• Check to see if package is
-
-holding door open.
-
-• Check to see if package is
-
-blocking air duct in freezer
-compartment.
-
-• Check to see if package is
-
-holding door open.
-
-Icemaker feeler arm in
-STOP (up) position.
-
-• Move the feeler arm to the
-
-ON (down) position.
-
-Water supply turned
-off or not connected.
-
-Freezer compartment
-too warm.
-
-Water shutoff valve
-connecting refrigerator
-to water line may be
-clogged.
-
-• See Installing thewater line.
-
-• Wait 24 hours for the
-
-refrigerator to completely
-cool down.
-
-• Call a plumber to clear
-
-the valve.
-
-Frost or ice crystals on
-frozen food (frost within
-package is normal)
-
-Automatic icemaker
-does not work
-(on some models)
-
-Cubes too small
-
-Slow ice cube freezing
-
-Door left open.
-
-• Check to see if package is
-
-holding door open.
-
-Temperature control
-dial not set cold enough.
-
-• See About the temperature
-
-control dial.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-32
-
-Problem
-
-Ice cubes have
-odor/taste
-
-Possible Causes
-
-What To Do
-
-Ice storage bin needs
-cleaning.
-
-• Empty and wash bin.
-Discard old cubes.
-
-Food transmitting odor/
-taste to ice cubes.
-
-Interior of refrigerator
-needs cleaning.
-
-• Wrap foods well.
-
-• See Care andcleaning.
-
-Moisture forms on
-cabinet surface
-between the doors
-
-Moisture collects inside
-(in humid weather, air
-carries moisture into
-refrigerator when doors
-are opened)
-
-Refrigerator has odor
-
-Not unusual during
-periods of high
-humidity.
-
-Too frequent or too
-long door openings.
-
-Foods transmitting
-odor to refrigerator.
-
-• Wipe surface dry and
-
-reset temperature control
-dial one setting colder.
-
-• Foods with strong odors
-
-should be tightly wrapped.
-• Keep an open box of baking
-soda in the refrigerator;
-replace every three months.
-
-Interior needs cleaning.
-
-• See Care and cleaning.
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-33
-
-Notes
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-34
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-35
-
-Notes
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-36
-
-GE Service Protection Plus™
-
-GE, a name recognized worldwide for quality and dependability,
-offers you Service Protection Plus™—comprehensive protection on
-all your appliances—No Matter What Brand!
-
-Benefits Include:
-• Backed by GE
-• All brands covered
-• Unlimited service calls
-• All parts and labor costs included
-• No out-of-pocket expenses
-• No hidden deductibles
-• One 800 number to call
-
-We’ll Cover Any Appliance.
-Anywhere. Anytime.*
-
-You will be completely satisfied with our service protection or you may request your
-money back on the remaining value of your contract. No questions asked. It’s that simple.
-
-Protect your refrigerator, dishwasher, washer and dryer, range, TV, VCR and much
-more—any brand! Plus there’s no extra charge for emergency service and low monthly
-financing is available. Even icemaker coverage and food spoilage protection is offered.
-You can rest easy, knowing that all your valuable household products are protected
-against expensive repairs.
-
-Place your confidence in GE and call us in the U.S. toll-free at 800-626-2224
-for more information.
-
-*All brands covered, up to 20 years old, in the continental U.S.
-
-"
-
-Cut here
-
-Please place in envelope and mail to:
-
-General Electric Company
-Warranty Registration Department
-P.O. Box 34070
-Louisville, KY 40232-4070
-
-37
-
-Consumer Product Ownership Registration
-Dear Customer:
-Thank you for purchasing our product and thank you for placing your confidence in us.
-We are proud to have you as a customer!
-
-Follow these three steps to protect your new appliance investment:
-
-1
-
-Complete and mail
-your Consumer
-Product Ownership
-Registration today.
-Have the peace of
-mind of knowing
-we can contact you
-in the unlikely event of a safety
-modification.
-
-2
-
-After mailing
-the registration
-below, store this
-document in a safe
-place. It contains
-information you
-will need should
-
-you require service. Our
-service number is 800 GE
-CARES (800-432-2737).
-
-3
-
-Read your
-Owner’s Manual
-carefully.
-It will help you
-operate your
-new appliance
-properly.
-
-If you have questions, or need
-more information, call the GE
-Answer Center® 800.626.2000.
-
-Model Number
-
-Serial Number
-
-Important: If you did not get a registration card with your product,
-
-detach and return the form below to ensure that your
-product is registered.
-
-"
-Consumer Product Ownership Registration
-
-Cut here
-
-Important
-Mail
-Today!
-
-First
-Name
-
-Street
-Address
-
-Apt. #
-
-City
-
-Model Number
-
-Serial Number
-
-Mr. (cid:108) Ms. (cid:108) Mrs. (cid:108) Miss (cid:108)
-
-Last
-Name
-
-E-mail Address
-
-State
-
-Zip
-Code
-
-Date Placed In Use
-
-Month
-
-Day
-
-Year
-
-Phone
-Number
-
-Occasionally, we may allow selected companies to send you information.
-(cid:108) Check here if you do not want this information.
-
-GE Appliances
-General Electric Company
-Louisville, Kentucky 40225
-www.ge.com/appliances
-
-38
-
-Refrigerator Warranty (For customers in the United States)
-
-All warranty service provided by our Factory Service Centers,
-or an authorized Customer Care®technician. For service,
-call 800-GE-CARES.
-
-For The Period Of: We Will Replace, At No Charge To You:
-
-One Year
-From the date of the
-original purchase
-
-Five Years
-From the date of the
-original purchase
-
-Any partof the refrigerator which fails due to a defect
-in materials or workmanship. During this full one-year
-warranty, we will also provide, free of charge, all labor
-and in-home service to replace the defective part.
-
-Any part of the sealed refrigerating system
-(the compressor, condenser, evaporator and all
-connecting tubing) which fails due to a defect in
-materials or workmanship. During this additional
-four-year warranty, we will also provide, free of charge,
-all labor and in-home service to replace the
-defective part.
-
-What Is Not Covered:
-
-n Service trips to your home to teach you
-
-how to use the product.
-
-n Improper installation.
-
-n Failure of the product if it is
-
-abused, misused, or used for other
-than the intended purpose or used
-commercially.
-
-n Loss of food due to spoilage.
-
-n Replacement of house fuses or
-resetting of circuit breakers.
-
-n Damage to the product caused by
-
-accident, fire, floods or acts of God.
-
-n Incidental or consequential damage to
-personal property caused by possible
-defects with this appliance.
-
-This warranty is extended to the original purchaser and any succeeding owner for products purchased
-for home use within the USA. In Alaska, the warranty excludes the cost of shipping or service calls to
-your home.
-
-Some states do not allow the exclusion or limitation of incidental or consequential damages. This
-warranty gives you specific legal rights, and you may also have other rights which vary from state to
-state. To know what your legal rights are, consult your local or state consumer affairs office or your
-state’s Attorney General.
-
-Warrantor: General Electric Company. Louisville, KY 40225
-
-39
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-Service Telephone Numbers.
-
-GE Answer Center® 800.626.2000
-
-The GE Answer Center® is open 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
-
-In-Home Repair Service800-GE-CARES (800-432-2737)
-
-Expert GE repair service is only a phone call away.
-
-Special Needs Service800.626.2000
-TDD 800-TDD-GEAC (800-833-4322)
-
-GE offers, free of charge, a brochure to assist in planning a barrier-
-free kitchen for persons with limited mobility.
-
-Service Contracts800-626-2224
-
-Purchase a GE service contract while your warranty is still in effect
-and you’ll receive a substantial discount. GE Consumer Service will
-still be there after your warranty expires.
-
-Parts and Accessories800-626-2002
-
-Individuals qualified to service their own appliances can have parts
-or accessories sent directly to their homes (VISA, MasterCard and
-Discover cards are accepted).
-Instructions contained in this manual cover procedures to be performed
-by any user. Other servicing generally should be referred to qualified
-service personnel. Caution must be exercised, since improper servicing
-may cause unsafe operation.
-
-Service Satisfaction
-
-If you are not satisfied with the service you receive from GE, follow
-these steps. First, contact the people who serviced your appliance.
-Next, if you are still not pleased, write all the details—including your
-phone number—to: Manager, Consumer Relations, GE Appliances,
-Appliance Park, Louisville, KY 40225.
-
-40
-
-Printed in Louisville, KY
+Notes: Some workout types don't support the above four settings. The settings might slightly vary
+in workout type.
diff --git a/q12/random_k4/random_3.md b/q12/random_k4/random_3.md
index c8ab7ba6e2f09f6f6ed15e4f7482f41d41ee6cf8..a4b2b07cac278442884a849032b2d8b161f383fe 100644
--- a/q12/random_k4/random_3.md
+++ b/q12/random_k4/random_3.md
@@ -1,1717 +1,2777 @@
-Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 1 of 29
-
-UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
-FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
-
-Civil No.
-
-Action for Declaratory and Injunctive
-Relief to Remedy Violations of the
-Oregon and California Railroad and Coos
-Bay Wagon Road Grant Lands Act of
-1937, 43 U.S.C. §1181a; Federal Land
-Policy and Management Act, 43 U.S.C.A.
-§1701 Savings Provision; and
-Administrative Procedure Act, 5
-U.S.C.§§701-706
-
-AMERICAN FOREST RESOURCE
-COUNCIL, 5100 SW Macadam Ave., Ste.
-350, Portland, OR 97239; CARPENTERS
-INDUSTRIAL COUNCIL,12788 SE Stark
-Street, Portland, OR 97233; DOUGLAS
-TIMBER OPERATORS, INC., 3000
-Stewart Parkway, Suite 208, Roseburg, OR
-97470; C & D LUMBER CO., 1182 Pruner
-Road, Riddle, OR 97469; FRERES
-LUMBER CO. INC., P.O. Box 276, Lyons,
-OR 97358; SENECA SAWMILL
-COMPANY including its affiliate SENECA
-JONES TIMBER COMPANY, 90201
-Highway 99N, Eugene, OR 97401;
-STARFIRE LUMBER CO., INC., P.O. Box
-547, Cottage Grove, OR 97424; SWANSON
-GROUP MFG. LLC, 2695 Glendale Valley
-Road, Glendale, OR 97442,
-
-v.
-
-Plaintiffs,
-
-NEIL KORNZE, Director, Bureau of Land
-Management, 1849 C Street NW, Washington,
-D.C. 20240 and S. M. R. JEWELL, Secretary
-of Interior, 1849 C Street NW, Washington,
-D.C. 20240,
-
-___________________________________
-
-Defendants
+Digital Landscape
-)
-)
-)
-)
-)
-)
-)
-)
-)
-)
-)
-)
-)
-)
-)
-)
-)
-)
-)
-)
-)
-)
-)
-)
-)
-)
-)
-)
-)
-)
-)
-
-COMPLAINT
-
-For their complaint herein, plaintiffs allege as follows:
-
-INTRODUCTION
-
-1.
-
-This is an action against the Hon. Neil Kornze, Director of the Bureau of Land
-
-Management (BLM), and the Hon. S. M. R. Jewell, Secretary of Interior, for declaratory and
-
-injunctive relief to remedy violations of the Oregon and California Railroad and Coos Bay Wagon
-
-Road Grant Lands Act of 1937 (O&C Act), 43 U.S.C. §1181a, the Federal Land Policy and
-
-Page 1 - Complaint
-
-Mark C. Rutzick, Inc.
-12402 Myra Virginia Ct
-Oak Hill, Virginia 20171
- Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com
-
-Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 2 of 29
-
-Management Act (FLPMA), 43 U.S.C.A. §1701 Savings Provision, and the Administrative
-
-Procedure Act (APA), 5 U.S.C.§§701-706, relating to the decision by defendant Kornze (through
-
-Deputy BLM Director Steven A. Ellis) on August 5, 2016 approving the Southwest Oregon Resource
-
-Management Plan and the Northwestern and Coastal Oregon Resource Management Plan (2016
-
-RMPs) to direct the management of six BLM districts in Western Oregon.
-
-JURISDICTION AND VENUE
-
-2.
-
-This Court has jurisdiction over this action pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1331 (federal
-
-question), § 2201 (declaratory relief) and § 2202 (injunctive relief). Plaintiffs have challenged final
-
-agency action as defined by the APA, 5 U.S.C. §704. Venue in this district is proper under 28
-
-U.S.C. § 1391(e) because defendant Kornze and the Secretary of the Interior were personally
-
-involved in the issues raised in this case, the challenged decision was approved in this district, a
-
-substantial part of the events or omissions giving rise to the claims occurred in this district, and the
-
-defendants reside in this district. This action is timely under 28 U.S.C. § 2401(a)(1) because the
-
-2016 RMPs were approved on August 5, 2016.
-
-PARTIES
-
-3.
-
-Plaintiff American Forest Resource Council (AFRC), a nonprofit corporation organized
-
-under the laws of the state of Oregon, is a forest products trade association located in Portland,
-
-Oregon which represents approximately 60 wood products manufacturing companies and landowners
-
-throughout the states of Washington, Oregon, California and elsewhere in the western United States.
-
-Among AFRC’s members are plaintiffs C & D Lumber Co., Freres Lumber Co. Inc, Seneca Sawmill
-
-Company, Starfire Lumber Co., Inc., and Swanson Group Mfg. LLC, as well as companies such as
-
-Hampton Industries, with operations in Washington and Oregon; Interfor Pacific, Inc., with
-
-operations in Oregon, Washington and elsewhere; Rosboro, LLC, based in Oregon; Roseburg Forest
-
-Products, with operations in Oregon and California, and South Coast Lumber, Co, in Brookings, OR,
-
-Page 2 - Complaint
-
-Mark C. Rutzick, Inc.
-12402 Myra Virginia Ct
-Oak Hill, Virginia 20171
- Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com
-
-Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 3 of 29
-
-all of which have recently purchased BLM timber sales and seek to purchase more such sales. Many
-
-of AFRC’s members could not continue to operate at their current levels of production, and would
-
-suffer financial harm, without a reliable and adequate supply of timber sold by the BLM. One of
-
-AFRC’s primary purposes is to represent the interests of its members on matters relating to federal
-
-timber supply.
-
-4.
-
-AFRC and its predecessors have served as the representative for the wood products
-
-industry on major regional federal land management decisions since 1986. AFRC collects
-
-information about the environmental, economic and social impacts of these major federal land
-
-management decisions, and disseminates this information to its members and participants, to public
-
-officials and to thousands of members of the public who are directly affected by these decisions.
-
-5.
-
-AFRC also represents the interests of its members who own private forest land, including
-
-many who own private forest land intermingled with, adjoining or adjacent to O&C forests. The
-
-ability of these companies to manage their own lands has been and will be directly and adversely
-
-affected by the BLM’s management of the O&C lands. The risk of fire, disease or insect infestation
-
-starting on O&C land and spreading to nearby private land has been greatly increased by the 2016
-
-RMPs because those decisions hinder or proscribe land management activities, including
-
-implementation of hazardous fuel reduction projects, on 74 percent of the O&C lands. These
-
-restrictions present a substantial threat to AFRC members’ lands in the vicinity of these O&C
-
-forests, which the decisions challenged in this case substantially increased, and may also limit AFRC
-
-members’ access to their lands through these O&C forests.
-
-6.
-
-Plaintiff Carpenters Industrial Council (CIC) is a labor organization that represents
-
-thousands of forest products workers in Oregon, Washington, northern California and nationwide.
-
-The CIC was chartered July 1, 2006, by the United Brotherhood of Carpenters and Joiners of
-
-America, which is headquartered in Washington, D.C. The CIC was formed after the merger of four
-
-Page 3 - Complaint
-
-Mark C. Rutzick, Inc.
-12402 Myra Virginia Ct
-Oak Hill, Virginia 20171
- Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com
-
-Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 4 of 29
-
-Regional Industrial Councils – the Carpenters East Coast Industrial Council, the Midwestern Council
-
-of Industrial Workers, the Southern Council of Industrial Workers, and the Western Council of
-
-Industrial Workers. Many CIC members live in remote communities that are heavily dependent on
-
-BLM timber. Several thousand of these workers have experienced, or continue to be threatened
-
-with, permanent job loss caused by timber supply reductions resulting from the land management
-
-plans adopted for the BLM’s western Oregon districts since 1995, including the 2016 RMPs. There
-
-are few, if any, prospects for CIC members to replace their jobs at a comparable wage in their home
-
-towns.
-
-7.
-
-Plaintiff Douglas Timber Operators, Inc. (DTO), a nonprofit corporation organized under
-
-the laws of the State of Oregon, is a forest products trade association located in Roseburg, Oregon
-
-which represents approximately 145 timber and logging companies and other businesses operating
-
-in Douglas, Coos and Lane Counties and elsewhere in Oregon. DTO's membership includes
-
-businesses in every segment of the forest products industry, from logging companies and small
-
-independent sawmills to large integrated manufacturers. DTO's members include such companies
-
-as C & D Lumber Co.; Herbert Lumber Co., based in Riddle, Oregon; Starfire Lumber Co. and
-
-Douglas County Forest Products, based in Winchester, Oregon. DTO’s members purchase many of
-
-the timber sales that are offered by the BLM’s western Oregon districts. These companies have
-
-historically depended in large measure on timber sold by the BLM for their timber supply. One of
-
-DTO’s primary purposes is to represent the interests of its members on matters relating to federal
-
-timber supply.
-
-8.
-
- Plaintiff C & D Lumber Co. (C & D) is a family-owned manufacturer of lumber and
-
-wood products located in Riddle, Oregon, where it has operated for more than 60 years. C & D is
-
-a member of AFRC and DTO. C & D operates a cutting mill that can process logs as small as six
-
-inches in diameter but operates most efficiently with larger, high quality Douglas-fir, incense cedar
-
-Page 4 - Complaint
-
-Mark C. Rutzick, Inc.
-12402 Myra Virginia Ct
-Oak Hill, Virginia 20171
- Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com
-
-Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 5 of 29
-
-and Port Orford cedar logs over sixteen inches in diameter. C&D employs about 110 workers at its
-
-mill and associated facilities, and produces about 40 million board feet of lumber annually. C & D
-
-has no trouble selling all of the forest products it produces. C & D purchases and has historically
-
-depended heavily on timber sold from the O&C lands in the BLM’s Medford and Roseburg Districts
-
-and from the Umpqua and Willamette National Forests and on timber supplied by other private and
-
-state timberland owners for the raw materials needed to operate its processing facility. C & D is
-
-certified as a small business by the Small Business Administration (SBA).
-
-9.
-
- Riddle is a small town in Douglas County, in rural southwestern Oregon, with a
-
-population of about 1,000. C & D was founded in Douglas County, and has operated there for
-
-more than 60 years. When it is in full operation C & D can process up to 55 million board feet of
-
-timber per year, but is currently unable to process that volume of wood due to lack of log supply.
-
-C & D recently made a significant mill modernization update, and with adequate timber supply it
-
-expects to continue indefinitely to provide wood products to its customers for use in building
-
-construction throughout the United States. Without an adequate supply of timber, C & D faces
-
-the prospect of being forced to shut down, lay off all its employees and close its doors forever.
-
-10. Silver Butte Timber Company, a sister company of C & D with common ownership,
-
-owns 45,000 acres of forest land in Douglas, Coos, Jackson and Josephine Counties, Oregon. The
-
-Silver Butte lands can supply C & D with only about 15-25 percent of its required raw material
-
-supply. Approximately 80 -90 percent of Silver Butte's holdings are adjacent on at least two, and
-
-in some cases four, sides to BLM O&C Act timber lands, including O&C land that has been
-
-designated as no-management reserves in the 2016 RMPs. The management practices on the
-
-adjoining BLM lands directly and substantially influence the health and safety of Silver Butte's
-
-timberland assets, and substantially threaten C&D’s timber supply.
-
-11. The failure of the BLM to offer the level of sustained-yield timber sales required by
-
-Page 5 - Complaint
-
-Mark C. Rutzick, Inc.
-12402 Myra Virginia Ct
-Oak Hill, Virginia 20171
- Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com
-
-Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 6 of 29
-
-the O&C Act directly and substantially harms and threatens to harm C & D. The absence of these
-
-sustained-yield timber sales denies C & D the opportunity to bid on a supply of timber that it would
-
-like to purchase at competitive auction in the upcoming months and years to meet the increasing
-
-demand for home construction materials in the United States. In addition, an increase in BLM
-
-timber sales would mean more effective and proactive management of BLM forestlands, reducing
-
-the risk of fire, disease or insect infestation starting on BLM land and spreading to Silver Butte's
-
-land. There is a substantial probability that Silver Butte’s lands will be directly and substantially
-
-harmed by the failure to offer the timber sales mandated by the O&C Act. The risk of fire, disease
-
-or insect infestation starting on BLM land and spreading to adjoining C & D land has increased
-
-due to past BLM land mismanagement, will substantially increase further under the 2016 RMPs, and
-
-is substantial at the present time.
-
-12. Plaintiff Freres Lumber Co. Inc. (Freres) is a family-owned small business that was
-
-founded in 1922. Freres operates mills that manufacture softwood veneer, lumber and plywood. The
-
-company is headquartered in Lyons, Oregon, 20 miles east of Salem, Oregon. Freres is a member
-
-of AFRC. Freres purchases federal timber from the BLM’s Salem District and the Mt. Hood,
-
-Willamette, and Siuslaw National Forests. Freres is the largest contract holder of BLM timber in
-
-the state of Oregon. The decision in the 2016 RMPs to reduce BLM timber sales far below the
-
-legally required level will severely hinder Freres’ ability to maintain its current level of operations.
-
-13. Freres currently employs about 480 people, but at its peak capacity, it can employ as
-
-many as 499 workers. In the decade 1980-89, Freres processed approximately 50 million board feet
-
-of timber per year. Since the 1980’s the company has invested heavily in new technology that has
-
-increased its capability to process timber. In the past decade alone Freres has invested over $65
-
-million in new equipment and technology for its plants in order to modernize the mill and increase
-
-its capacity. Over the past decade Freres has processed on average (with considerable variation)
+February 2020
-Page 6 - Complaint
+This artwork was created using Nielsen data.
+Copyright © 2019 The Nielsen Company (US), LLC. Confidential and proprietary. Do not distribute.
-Mark C. Rutzick, Inc.
-12402 Myra Virginia Ct
-Oak Hill, Virginia 20171
- Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com
+Snapshot
-Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 7 of 29
+This artwork was created using Nielsen data.
+Copyright © 2019 The Nielsen Company (US), LLC. Confidential and proprietary. Do not distribute.
-about 78 million board feet of timber per year, and it is currently capable of processing 100 million
+Landscape Overview
-board feet of timber per year if adequate timber supply were available. In 2011-13 Freres averaged
+Metric
-86 million board feet of timber processed in its mill and sold as finished wood products. Freres
+Device
-would increase its production to its 100 million board foot capacity, and hire additional employees
+Jan-2020
-to perform the work, if additional timber were available. Freres is a modern, efficient processor of
+Feb-2020
-timber, and with adequate timber supply it expects to continue indefinitely to provide wood products
+Unique Audience (000)
-to its customers for use in building construction throughout the United States. Freres has no
+Digital (C/M)
-difficulty selling all of the forests products it manufactures.
+Active Reach (%)
-14. In the decade 1980-89, almost 100 percent of Freres’ timber supply came from federal
+Time Spent per Person
+(hh:mm:ss)
-forests and State of Oregon lands. About 75 percent of its timber supply (37.5 million board feet)
+Desktop
-was provided by the Forest Service, 15 percent (7.5 million board feet) by the BLM and 10 percent
+Smartphone
-(5 million board feet) from Oregon state lands. Its current capacity is double the 1980’s level, but
+Tablet
-since the 1980’s the Forest Service and BLM timber sale programs have diminished to a small
+Digital (C/M)
-fraction of 1980s levels. In the 1980’s western Oregon national forests sold over three billion board
+Desktop
-feet of timber per year, and the BLM sold over one billion board feet of timber per year. Today the
+Smartphone
-Forest Service allowable sale level in western Oregon has been reduced to only about 350 million
+Tablet
-board feet of timber per year, and the 2016 RMPs set the BLM annual allowable sale level at only
+Digital (C/M)
-17 percent of the legally required volume. The drop in Forest Service timber has been greatest, as
+Desktop
-Freres now obtains just 14 percent of its timber supply (12 million board feet) from the Forest
+Smartphone
-Service. Freres’ BLM percentage of timber has dropped to 12 percent (10 million board feet), and
+Tablet
-timber from Oregon state lands slightly increased to 12 percent (10 million board feet). Its sister
+21,152
-company Freres Timber owns 14,500 acres of timberland and another related entity, Freres
+18,505
-Partnership LLC, owns 2,400 acres, but under the sustained-yield management that these companies
+16,383
-practice, their lands (referred to jointly as Freres Lands) can supply only about 13 percent of Freres’
+7,441
-Page 7 - Complaint
+100%
-Mark C. Rutzick, Inc.
-12402 Myra Virginia Ct
-Oak Hill, Virginia 20171
- Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com
+87%
-Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 8 of 29
+77%
-annual timber requirement, and Freres is not able to increase the annual supply of timber from the
+35%
-Freres Lands without destroying their long-term productivity.
+108:47:50
-15. In addition to BLM timber sales, Freres acquires timber for its mills from the Mt. Hood,
+21:57:14
-Siuslaw and Willamette National Forests, Oregon state forests and private timberland owners. None
+89:56:34
-of these sources has any prospect of supplying a steady and reliable increase in timber production
+58:05:33
-that would allow Freres to expand its business. The National Forests operate under the Northwest
+21,310
-Forest Plan adopted in 1994, which is not scheduled to be revised in western Oregon for at least five
+18,656
-more years. Each national Forest has an annual allowable sale quantity of timber that it is not
+16570
-permitted to exceed. The Forest Service rarely if ever achieves its allowable sale quantity, and there
+7,449
-is no plausible likelihood the Forest Service will voluntarily or involuntarily increase timber sales
+100%
-from the Mt. Hood, Siuslaw or Willamette National Forests in the next five years or longer. Oregon
+88%
-state forests also operate under a maximum permitted annual sale volume, and the State of Oregon
+78%
-has no plans to increase the permitted annual sale volume on its state forests in the foreseeable
+35%
-future. Oregon has offered sell one of its premier timber-producing state forests due to the low sale
+90:49:40
-volume it has achieved in recent years.
+20:17:06
-16. Freres currently purchases about half its timber supply on the open market from other
+72:18:43
-private companies, but for several reasons these sales do not have the same value to Freres as BLM
+48:48:53
-sustained-yield sales. First, these sales are solely at the discretion of the seller, and Freres has no
+Source: Nielsen Digital Panel, Jan 2020, Feb 2020, Total Platform, Desktop, Smartphone, Tablet, P2+, Unique Audience (000), Active Reach (Calculated from UA), Time Spent per Person
+(hh:mm:ss).
+3
-contractual right to any steady supply of timber from any private company. Any company could stop
+.
+.
-selling timber, or stop selling timber to Freres, at any time without notice. For these reasons, Freres
-
-does not rely on private timber purchases as a basis for expanding its production. In contrast, a BLM
-
-timber sale contract generally allows three years for completion of the sale, so Freres can plan its
-
-operations with the certainty that the BLM logs will be available at the time of its choosing during
-
-the sale period. In addition, the BLM has a legal obligation to sell its declared and determined
-
-Page 8 - Complaint
-
-Mark C. Rutzick, Inc.
-12402 Myra Virginia Ct
-Oak Hill, Virginia 20171
- Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com
-
-Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 9 of 29
-
-allowable sale quantity each year, so Freres should be able to rely on a steady supply of BLM
-
-sustained-yield sales every year at the full productive capacity of the O&C lands. While sales are
-
-all competitively bid, and Freres has no guarantee of being able to purchase any particular sale, there
-
-is a substantial probability that Freres would purchase additional BLM timber sales if they are
-
-offered. Freres is certified as a small business under SBA rules, and a certain percentage of BLM
-
-timber sales are set aside for bidding solely by certified small businesses like Freres, increasing its
-
-chances of successfully bidding on those sales. Freres has been injured by BLM’s failure to offer the
-
-full legally-required level of sustained-yield sales. BLM’s certain failure under the 2016 RMPs to
-
-offer the full required level of sustained-yield sales each year (calculated with no reserves) creates
-
-a substantial probability of imminent future injury to Freres through loss of the opportunity to bid
-
-on additional timber sales and to process 14 million board feet of timber into additional forest
-
-products to be sold this year and next year and the year after that, indefinitely. The non-sustained-
-
-yield thinning sales offered by the BLM are not sufficiently reliable to serve as the basis for business
-
-expansion because there is no way to predict from year to year how many non-sustained-yield sales
-
-will be offered.
-
-17. The BLM’s continued failure to offer sustained-yield timber sales based on permanent
-
-forest production of all the suitable O&C timberlands in the BLM Salem district, and other districts,
-
-has also injured and imminently threatens to continue to injure Freres by making log prices higher
-
-than they otherwise would be (reducing the company’s profit margin and total profit). If the BLM
-
-Salem district, and other BLM districts in Oregon, increased their annual timber sale volume to the
-
-level required by the O&C Act, it is very likely that log prices in western Oregon would decline
-
-across the board, which would add to Freres’ profit margin and total profit. There is a substantial
-
-probability that BLM’s on-going violations of the O&C Act will cause Freres to suffer imminent
-
-future financial loss from having to pay above-market prices for the logs its purchases, which
-
-Page 9 - Complaint
-
-Mark C. Rutzick, Inc.
-12402 Myra Virginia Ct
-Oak Hill, Virginia 20171
- Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com
-
-Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 10 of 29
-
-reduces the profit margin and profitability of the wood products it sells.
-
-18. The quality of wood on BLM timber sales is very high, which increases the profitability
-
-of the forest products produced from those sales. In addition, the BLM is required to offer its full
-
-allowable sale quantity of sustained-yield sales every year regardless of log prices, and federal timber
-
-may not lawfully be exported, eliminating purchases by China as a market factor, which tempers
-
-bidding prices for BLM sales.
-
-19. The Freres Lands share 36 miles of boundary with O&C lands subject to the 2016 RMPs,
-
-including many miles of O&C land that has been designated as no-management reserves in the 2016
-
-RMPs, and the Freres Lands are directly, immediately and substantially threatened with fire starting
-
-on poorly managed BLM lands and spreading uncontrollably onto the Freres Lands.
-
-20. Plaintiff Seneca Sawmill Company (Seneca) was founded by Aaron U. Jones in Eugene,
-
-Oregon in 1953 and continues to be owned by members of the Aaron U. Jones family. Seneca is a
-
-leading innovator in lumber manufacturing, and Seneca holds over 25 U.S. and Canadian patents in
-
-various sawmill technologies. Seneca manufactures 550 million board feet of studs and dimension
-
-lumber products annually from its manufacturing facilities in Eugene and Noti, Oregon, and sells
-
-everything it can produce. Seneca's affiliate Seneca Jones Timber Company (Seneca Jones) owns
-
-approximately 167,000 acres of forestland in Lane, Douglas, Curry, Jackson, Linn, Benton, Coos and
-
-Josephine Counties, Oregon. Seneca Jones manages its timberlands on a long-term sustained-yield
-
-basis. Operating on a sustained yield basis, Seneca Jones timberlands can only supply about 28%
-
-of Seneca Sawmill’s required timber needs. Seneca Sawmill currently employs about 420 workers,
-
-and is an SBA-qualified small business. Seneca relies heavily on timber supplied by the Coos Bay,
-
-Eugene, Roseburg and Salem districts of the BLM and by nearby national forests, which
-
-complements the timber available annually from Seneca Jones. There is no prospect that the USFS
-
-can increase its timber sale volume, so BLM is the only seller capable of increasing its annual timber
-
-Page 10 - Complaint
-
-Mark C. Rutzick, Inc.
-12402 Myra Virginia Ct
-Oak Hill, Virginia 20171
- Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com
-
-Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 11 of 29
-
-sale level. Seneca is a member of AFRC.
-
-21. Seneca Sawmill cannot maintain its current production level without a steady or
-
-increasing supply of federal timber. Seneca Sawmill does not currently operate at capacity, and an
-
-additional timber supply will be needed to produce at capacity. The continuing lack of adequate
-
-timber sales under the 2016 RMPs will also increase the cost of logs, causing financial harm to
-
-Seneca Sawmill. BLM sustained-yield sales are the only reliable source of additional timber that
-
-would allow increased production. Neither the Forest Service, Oregon state lands, Seneca Jones,
-
-other private landowners nor BLM non-sustained-yield thinning sales can be relied on to supply
-
-more timber than their current sale level. Seneca’s inability to operate at full capacity has reduced
-
-and will continue to reduce the company’s profitability. Seneca has been injured by the denial of
-
-the opportunity to bid on the full supply of BLM sustained-yield sales that are legally required to be
-
-offered each year, and faces the imminent threat of such future harm.
-
-22. The Seneca Jones timberlands include forestland that is both adjacent to, and, many
-
-times, intermingled with BLM land. Seneca Jones timberlands share a common boundary with O&C
-
-timberlands over a linear distance of 689 miles, including many linear miles of O&C land that has
-
-been designated as no-management reserves in the 2016 RMPs.
-
-23. Although the O&C Act requires BLM to manage all of its O&C timberlands for
-
-permanent forest production, for the past 20 years BLM has failed to do so over a majority of the
-
-O&C land it manages. The 2016 RMPs further reduce the area of O&C land that BLM is permitted
-
-to manage for sustained-yield timber production to 20 percent of its forested land base, down from
-
-27 percent under the 1995 RMPs, with 74 percent allocated to unlawful reserves where permanent
-
-forest production has been prohibited, and six percent to sparsely forested areas with no significant
-
-potential for timber production. The “Harvest Land Base” where sustained-yield timber production
-
-is permitted contains just 18 percent of the 72 billion board feet of standing timber on the O&C
-
-Page 11 - Complaint
-
-Mark C. Rutzick, Inc.
-12402 Myra Virginia Ct
-Oak Hill, Virginia 20171
- Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com
-
-Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 12 of 29
-
-lands. Proposed Resource Management Plan/Final EIS (2016) (FEIS) at 335. The past unlawful
-
-management of the O&C lands has already resulted in neglect and mismanagement of adjoining
-
-O&C lands, creating hundreds of thousands of acres of forests with high fuel loads that increase the
-
-risk, spread and intensity of wildfire, and threaten Seneca Jones= forestland. Conditions will only
-
-get worse under the 2016 RMPs. Continued neglect and mismanagement of BLM lands is a direct,
-
-immediate and substantial threat to Seneca Sawmill=s business and Seneca Jones= forest land. Seneca
-
-Jones relies on access to its own land through rights-of-way across BLM land. Loss of a BLM right-
-
-of-way road will cost Seneca Jones significant economic loss by preventing, or at least increasing
-
-the expense of, removal of Seneca Jones’ timber from its own land, thereby reducing the profitability
-
-of any subsequent use of the timber and causing financial harm to Seneca Jones.
-
-24. The risk of fire, disease or insect infestation starting on BLM lands and spreading to
-
-adjoining private land has increased substantially over the past 20 years, is substantial and will
-
-continue to increase as long as BLM fails to manage all of the O&C timberlands for permanent forest
-
-production under the O&C Act. For Seneca Jones, this concern is not imaginary. In 2009, the
-
-Williams Creek Fire in Douglas County burned approximately 490 acres of Seneca Jones property
-
-in late July and early August. The fire started on Forest Service land over two miles from Seneca
-
-Jones property in an area where no active management had occurred for over 15 years, and there
-
-were no maintained roads suitable for mechanized access – the same management regime that is
-
-commanded by the 2016 RMPs for 74 percent of the O&C timberlands.
-
-25. For the Williams Creek fire, lack of access to the burning area by mechanized transport
-
-created difficulty in firefighting efforts from the beginning of the fire throughout the life of the
-
-incident. Over the 16-day incident, access by ground personnel was a severely limiting factor in
-
-providing opportunity for control of the fire. Without access for facilitation of effective retreat for
-
-ground forces, safety concerns dictated an indirect attack method that utilized natural landscape
-
-Page 12 - Complaint
-
-Mark C. Rutzick, Inc.
-12402 Myra Virginia Ct
-Oak Hill, Virginia 20171
- Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com
-
-Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 13 of 29
-
-features for controlling the perimeter location. Therefore, the Forest Service had to conduct a
-
-backburning of Seneca property on or near a ridgeline in three separate locations, with a total burned
-
-area of approximately 490 acres. Backburning of Seneca property should not have been necessary
-
-because there is an intervening ridge of Forest Service land between the area where the fire started
-
-and Seneca’s property, which could have been used as the site for the backburn had proper access
-
-been available. Unfortunately, the fire crews could not gain access to this ridge due to the Forest
-
-Service=s failure to properly manage its land. The fire crews could gain easy access to Seneca Jones
-
-land, so they had no choice but to use Seneca’s land for the backburn.
-
-26. Seneca Jones’ losses included Douglas-fir plantations ranging in age from four to 29
-
-years, and many acres were 28 years old with a net value of $3,000 per acre. Seneca has
-
-reestablished these plantations with an initial average cost of $600 per acre, and will incur further
-
-costs associated with fertilization and precommercial thinning. Had the Forest Service been actively
-
-managing the area adjacent to Seneca property, they would have been able to control the fire prior
-
-to its entering Seneca=s land. The management regime adopted in the 2016 RMPs will result in
-
-comparable management constraints on the O&C land adjoining Seneca Jones’ property.
-
-27. Plaintiff Starfire Lumber Co., Inc. (Starfire) is a family-owned small business that
-
-manufactures high grade Douglas-fir lumber, including beams, stringers, timbers, clears and other
-
-specialty cuttings, at its mill in Cottage Grove, Oregon. Starfire is a member of AFRC and DTO.
-
-Starfire owns virtually no commercial forestland so timber from federal land has been and remains
-
-a vital source of its log supply. Starfire obtains its logs from O&C lands including the Salem,
-
-Eugene, and Roseburg BLM Districts as well as the Mt. Hood, Willamette, Siuslaw and Umpqua
-
-National Forests. The BLM forests formerly provided a steady supply of high quality large logs
-
-suitable for Starfire’s operations, but BLM timber sales containing high quality logs have sharply
-
-declined even though the O&C lands contain a huge inventory of large high quality trees.
-
-Page 13 - Complaint
-
-Mark C. Rutzick, Inc.
-12402 Myra Virginia Ct
-Oak Hill, Virginia 20171
- Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com
-
-Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 14 of 29
-
-28. Starfire currently has 75 employees, and processes approximately 2.5 million board
-
-feet of timber per month, equal to 30 million board feet per year. It currently operates one shift at
-
-the mill, but with additional reliable timber supply it would expand its operations by adding a second
-
-shift and hiring new employees to work that shift, which would make the company more efficient
-
-and more profitable. However at the present time Starfire does not have any additional reliable
-
-source of timber supply that would permit it to add a second shift. Starfire is certified as an SBA
-
-small business, and can sell all the forest products it produces without difficulty.
-
-29. In the 1980’s and early 1990’s, when federal timber supply was more plentiful,
-
-Starfire operated three shifts, employing 120 workers and consuming about 4.5 million board feet
-
-per month, equal to 54 million board feet per year. At that time approximately 70-90 percent of its
-
-timber supply came from federal forestlands within its sourcing radius (the geographic distance at
-
-which Starfire can afford to ship logs to the mill). Of that portion of its timber supply, approximately
-
-15 percent came from the BLM and approximately 85 percent from USFS. However since the
-
-Northwest Forest Plan was adopted in 1994 reducing federal timber sales by more than 80 percent,
-
-the availability of BLM and Forest Service timber has dropped sharply. Today only approximately
-
-1 percent of Starfire’s log supply comes from BLM. About 1.5 percent comes from the Forest
-
-Service, and the rest of its log supply comes from private timberland owners. Starfire has no long
-
-term contracts with any supplier. The company purchases logs one month at a time at a negotiated
-
-price based on current log market prices.
+e
+e
+t
+t
+u
+u
+b
+b
+i
+i
+r
+r
+t
+t
+s
+s
+i
+i
+d
+d
+t
+t
+o
+o
+n
+n
+o
+o
+D
+D
+
+.
+.
+y
+y
+r
+r
+a
+a
+t
+t
+e
+e
+i
+i
+r
+r
+p
+p
+o
+o
+r
+r
+p
+p
+d
+d
+n
+n
+a
+a
+
+l
+l
+
+a
+a
+i
+i
+t
+t
+n
+n
+e
+e
+d
+d
+fi
+fi
+n
+n
+o
+o
+C
+C
+
+.
+.
+
+C
+C
+L
+L
+L
+L
+
+,
+,
+)
+)
+S
+S
+U
+U
+
+(
+(
+
+y
+y
+n
+n
+a
+a
+p
+p
+m
+m
+o
+o
+C
+C
+n
+n
+e
+e
+s
+s
+l
+l
+e
+e
+N
+N
+e
+e
+h
+h
+T
+T
+9
+9
+1
+1
+0
+0
+2
+2
+©
+©
+
+i
+i
+
+t
+t
+h
+h
+g
+g
+i
+i
+r
+r
+y
+y
+p
+p
+o
+o
+C
+C
+
+Trend - Time Spent by Device - DCR
+
+.
+.
+
+e
+e
+t
+t
+u
+u
+b
+b
+i
+i
+r
+r
+t
+t
+s
+s
+i
+i
+d
+d
+t
+t
+o
+o
+n
+n
+o
+o
+D
+D
+
+.
+.
+y
+y
+r
+r
+a
+a
+t
+t
+e
+e
+i
+i
+r
+r
+p
+p
+o
+o
+r
+r
+p
+p
+d
+d
+n
+n
+a
+a
+
+l
+l
+
+a
+a
+i
+i
+t
+t
+n
+n
+e
+e
+d
+d
+fi
+fi
+n
+n
+o
+o
+C
+C
+
+.
+.
+
+C
+C
+L
+L
+L
+L
+
+,
+,
+)
+)
+S
+S
+U
+U
+
+(
+(
+
+y
+y
+n
+n
+a
+a
+p
+p
+m
+m
+o
+o
+C
+C
+n
+n
+e
+e
+s
+s
+l
+l
+e
+e
+N
+N
+e
+e
+h
+h
+T
+T
+9
+9
+1
+1
+0
+0
+2
+2
+©
+©
-30. Starfire processes large-diameter logs that commonly comprise only a small
+i
+i
-proportion of the typical BLM timber sale today. Starfire regularly purchases BLM logs from other
+t
+t
+h
+h
+g
+g
+i
+i
+r
+r
+y
+y
+p
+p
+o
+o
+C
+C
-companies that purchase a BLM timber sale, operate the sale and then sell Starfire the large-diameter
+Source: Nielsen Digital Content Ratings, Monthly Total, Jan 2019 - Feb 2020, Desktop, Smartphone, Tablet, P 2+, % of Total Time Spent, Text
-logs from the sale, which normally are too big to be processed in most small-dimension sawmills.
+4
-In particular, BLM sustained-yield sales are most likely to contain large-diameter logs suitable for
+Age Breakdowns Overview
-Page 14 - Complaint
+This artwork was created using Nielsen data.
+Copyright © 2019 The Nielsen Company (US), LLC. Confidential and proprietary. Do not distribute.
-Mark C. Rutzick, Inc.
-12402 Myra Virginia Ct
-Oak Hill, Virginia 20171
- Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com
+Digital Audience Reach and Time by Demo Overview
-Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 15 of 29
+Data Type
-Starfire while the non-sustained-yield thinning sales have few if any large-diameter logs suitable for
+Device
-Starfire. All of the BLM logs Starfire currently owns came from other purchasers of BLM timber
+Unique
+Audience
-sales, although on occasion Starfire will bid on and buy a BLM timber sale. All of the O&C Lands
+Total Platform
-are within its sourcing radius. Starfire has been injured, and faces imminent threat of future injury,
+Desktop
-by the failure of the 2016 RMPs to permit BLM to offer the full legally-required level of sustained-
+Smartphone
-yield sales from the O&C lands.
+Tablet
-31. There is no prospect the Forest Service will increase its annual harvest level in the
+Profile %
-near future, and there is no prospect that any private timberland owner will enter into a long-term
+Total Platform
-supply contract with Starfire, or will increase the monthly volume of timber Starfire purchases at the
+Desktop
-present time. The only plausible source of increased timber supply in its area is the BLM. Starfire
+Smartphone
-purchases BLM logs originating on the Salem, Eugene, and Roseburg BLM Districts. If these
+Tablet
-districts offered a higher volume of sustained-yield timber sales, it is very likely that the additional
+P 18+
-sustained-yield sales would contain additional large-diameter logs, and that Starfire would be able
+18,300
-to purchase additional logs from such sales. In addition, if more BLM sustained-yield sales were
+15,646
-offered on these districts, Starfire, as an SBA-certified small business, would likely be able to
+16,570
-purchase a sale at competitive auction, which would be a source of profit for the company even if
+7,449
-it sells the small-diameter logs to other enterprises.
+100%
-32. Plaintiff Swanson Group Mfg. LLC (Swanson) is a family-owned enterprise that operates
+100%
-forest product manufacturing facilities in Glendale, Roseburg and Springfield, Oregon and employs
+100%
-over 700 workers at its sawmills and related operations. Swanson is one of the largest purchasers
+100%
-of timber sales offered by the BLM in Oregon. At the current time Swanson’s manufacturing
+P 18-24
-facilities process 200-300 million board feet of timber in a year (the variation is due to differing log
+P 25-34
-scaling measures), producing wood products sold to customers throughout the United States.
+P 35-44
-Swanson has no trouble selling all the wood products it currently produces. Swanson has the capacity
+P 45-54
-Page 15 - Complaint
+P 55-64
-Mark C. Rutzick, Inc.
-12402 Myra Virginia Ct
-Oak Hill, Virginia 20171
- Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com
+2,353
-Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 16 of 29
+1,931
-to process an additional 58 million board feet of timber in a year by running additional shifts at its
+2,313
-mills. If Swanson could produce more wood products the company would easily be able to sell those
+304
-products into the open market and increase its profitability. Swanson is a member of the AFRC and
+13%
-DTO.
+12%
-33. Swanson owns virtually no private timber land. For its supply of raw materials to operate
+14%
-its business, Swanson relies on BLM timber provided by the Medford, Roseburg, Coos Bay, Eugene
+4%
-and Salem districts, on USFS timber from the Rogue-Siskiyou, Umpqua, Willamette and Siuslaw
+3,813
-National Forests, on timber supplied by the State of Oregon and on timber supplied by private
+3,392
-timberland owners. Swanson is currently unable to purchase additional timber for processing beyond
+3,813
-the volume it now processes.
+1,360
-34. The Forest Service is not capable of selling more timber than it currently does. Each
+21%
-national forest has an allowable annual sale quantity of timber set in its land and resource
+22%
-management plan, and it cannot exceed that volume of timber in a year. The Forest Service cannot
+23%
-reach its allowable sale quantity on any of its national forests in Oregon due to a combination of
+18%
-budget constraints, personnel limitations, Endangered Species Act consultations, restrictions in the
+3,332
-Northwest Forest Plan (which governs all the national forests in western Oregon) and citizen appeals
+2,998
-and litigation of planned timber sales. There is no reasonable possibility the Forest Service can
+3,320
-increase its annual timber sales beyond the level it currently sells.
+1,499
-35. The State of Oregon only owns a small amount of commercial forest lands, and offers a very
+18%
-small annual sale program each year. The Oregon state sale trend is down due to new management
+19%
-constraints and litigation, and Oregon is trying to sell some of its state-owned timberlands to private
+20%
-interests. There is no plausible chance Oregon state lands will increase their annual timber sales
+20%
-beyond the current level.
+3,115
-Page 16 - Complaint
+2,700
-Mark C. Rutzick, Inc.
-12402 Myra Virginia Ct
-Oak Hill, Virginia 20171
- Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com
+2,904
-Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 17 of 29
+1,599
-36. Swanson currently purchases over 130 million board feet per year of private timber.
+17%
-Swanson is one of the largest purchasers of private timber in the state of Oregon. Virtually all of the
+17%
-companies it buys timber from manage their lands on a long-term sustained-yield basis, which means
+18%
-these companies do not have the capacity to increase their annual sales above current levels. These
+21%
-timber sellers are free to sell timber to whomever they choose, including foreign buyers such as
+2,716
-China, or not to sell timber in times of unfavorable market conditions. Most of Swanson’s private
+2,344
-timber purchases are on the “spot” market, based on currently available logs. Swanson cannot rely
+2,463
-on unpredictable future private timber sale levels to expand its operations.
+1,399
-37. The BLM’s western Oregon O&C districts are the only timber sellers that have the capacity
+15%
-to increase timber sales that Swanson might be able to purchase at competitive auction. Those
+15%
-districts can sell more timber if ordered to do so because that is what has happened in the Medford
+15%
-and Roseburg Districts when the court in Swanson Group v. Salazar, No. 10-1843 (D.D.C.) ordered
+19%
-the BLM in 2013 to sell or offer for sale the allowable sale quantity (ASQ) declared in its resource
+P 65+
-management plans (RMPs) for the Medford and Roseburg districts. In response to the court’s order,
+2,972
-the BLM significantly increased its timber sale program for Fiscal Years 2014 and 2015 in the
+2,281
-Medford and Roseburg districts. Swanson purchased the Rockstar Salvage sale in FY 2014 on the
+1,757
-Medford district, containing over 12 million board feet of timber, for $1,180,205.40 (more than
+1,288
-$220,000 over the appraised price) and will be injured if it is denied the opportunity to bid on and
+16%
-attempt to purchase additional sales in future auctions.
+15%
-38. Not all BLM timber sales are equally reliable as the basis for adding shifts and employees.
+11%
-The O&C Act requires the BLM to sell or offer for sale the allowable sale quantity (ASQ) declared
+17%
-in each of its O&C districts’ resource management plans. These sales, known as ASQ sales, must
+Time Spent per
+Person (Text)
-come from areas of O&C land designated for sustained-yield timber production, must be sold or
+Total Platform
-offered every year, and are therefore reliable as a basis for adding a shift and new employees. The
+105:15:33
-Page 17 - Complaint
+82:51:47
-Mark C. Rutzick, Inc.
-12402 Myra Virginia Ct
-Oak Hill, Virginia 20171
- Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com
+104:05:13
-Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 18 of 29
+131:29:27
-BLM also offers “non-ASQ” sales involving commercial thinning of reserved areas where no
+121:53:22
-sustained-yield timber production is permitted, but these sales are not reliable as a basis for adding
+103:45:04
-a shift and new employees because there is no statutory requirement for BLM to offer the same
+79:01:37
-amount, or any amount, of these sales each year.
+Desktop
-39. Swanson’s inability to secure additional long-term timber supplies necessary to add shifts
+23:39:39
-to its mills is occurring at the present time and currently deprives Swanson of the additional profits
+22:28:55
-that would be generated by adding an additional shift and processing more timber. For the same
+19:08:11
-reason the reduction in BLM timber sales from the Medford and Roseburg districts under the 2016
+26:13:02
-RMPs also creates a substantial probability of imminent future injury to Swanson.
+27:00:23
-40. Neil Kornze, Director of the BLM, is the official in charge of the BLM and made the decision
+22:41:43
-challenged in this case. S. M. R. Jewell, the Secretary of the Interior, is the official charged with
+25:03:33
-administering the O&C Act, through the BLM. Since 1993 several of Secretary Jewell’s
+Smartphone
-precedessors, including Bruce Babbitt and Ken Salazar, were personally involved in various
+72:18:43
-decisions concerning the BLM western Oregon O&C lands that are the subject of this case.
+59:11:44
-A. The O&C Act.
+68:14:18
-BACKGROUND ALLEGATIONS
+78:06:30
-41. In 1866 and 1870 Congress passed legislation that led to grants of large amounts of
+83:00:33
-federally-owned land in western Oregon to the Oregon and California Railroad Company in
+72:09:21
-exchange for construction of a north-south rail line from the Columbia River to California. The
+70:01:28
-grant was conditioned on requirements that the land be resold by the railroad to "actual settlers" in
+Tablet
-parcels not to exceed 160 acres and for no more than $2.50 per acre. Once acquired by the railroad,
+48:48:53
-these lands became subject to county property taxes and were an important source of tax revenues
+80:59:43
-for the counties in which the lands are located (the "O&C Counties"). The railroad completed
+64:04:38
-construction of the rail line and initially complied with the terms of the grant, but eventually ceased
+35:49:12
-Page 18 - Complaint
+50:59:20
-Mark C. Rutzick, Inc.
-12402 Myra Virginia Ct
-Oak Hill, Virginia 20171
- Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com
+41:43:09
-Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 19 of 29
+44:10:57
-reselling lands to actual settlers. Controversy followed, during which the railroad stopped paying
+Source: Nielsen Digital Panel, Feb 2020, Total Platform, Desktop, Tablet, Smartphone, P18+, P18-24, P25-34, P35-44, P45-54, P55-64, P65+, Unique Audience, Profile
+(Calculated from UA), Time Spent per Person (text).
-property taxes to the O&C Counties on the grant lands. Following a lengthy court battle, Congress
+6
-passed the Chamberlain-Ferris Revestment Act in 1916, revesting the grant lands ("O&C lands") to
+.
+.
-federal ownership, but requiring the government to pay the railroad company the amount it would
+e
+e
+t
+t
+u
+u
+b
+b
+i
+i
+r
+r
+t
+t
+s
+s
+i
+i
+d
+d
+t
+t
+o
+o
+n
+n
+o
+o
+D
+D
+
+.
+.
+y
+y
+r
+r
+a
+a
+t
+t
+e
+e
+i
+i
+r
+r
+p
+p
+o
+o
+r
+r
+p
+p
+d
+d
+n
+n
+a
+a
+
+l
+l
+
+a
+a
+i
+i
+t
+t
+n
+n
+e
+e
+d
+d
+fi
+fi
+n
+n
+o
+o
+C
+C
+
+.
+.
+
+C
+C
+L
+L
+L
+L
+
+,
+,
+)
+)
+S
+S
+U
+U
+
+(
+(
+
+y
+y
+n
+n
+a
+a
+p
+p
+m
+m
+o
+o
+C
+C
+n
+n
+e
+e
+s
+s
+l
+l
+e
+e
+N
+N
+e
+e
+h
+h
+T
+T
+9
+9
+1
+1
+0
+0
+2
+2
+©
+©
+
+i
+i
+
+t
+t
+h
+h
+g
+g
+i
+i
+r
+r
+y
+y
+p
+p
+o
+o
+C
+C
+
+Digital Audience Reach and Time Demo Overview
+
+Unique Audience
+
+Time Spent per Person
+
+.
+.
+
+e
+e
+t
+t
+u
+u
+b
+b
+i
+i
+r
+r
+t
+t
+s
+s
+i
+i
+d
+d
+t
+t
+o
+o
+n
+n
+o
+o
+D
+D
+
+.
+.
+y
+y
+r
+r
+a
+a
+t
+t
+e
+e
+i
+i
+r
+r
+p
+p
+o
+o
+r
+r
+p
+p
+d
+d
+n
+n
+a
+a
+
+l
+l
+
+a
+a
+i
+i
+t
+t
+n
+n
+e
+e
+d
+d
+fi
+fi
+n
+n
+o
+o
+C
+C
+
+.
+.
+
+C
+C
+L
+L
+L
+L
+
+,
+,
+)
+)
+S
+S
+U
+U
+
+(
+(
+
+y
+y
+n
+n
+a
+a
+p
+p
+m
+m
+o
+o
+C
+C
+n
+n
+e
+e
+s
+s
+l
+l
+e
+e
+N
+N
+e
+e
+h
+h
+T
+T
+9
+9
+1
+1
+0
+0
+2
+2
+©
+©
+
+i
+i
+
+t
+t
+h
+h
+g
+g
+i
+i
+r
+r
+y
+y
+p
+p
+o
+o
+C
+C
+
+Source: Nielsen Digital Panel, Feb 2020, Total Platform, Desktop, Tablet, Smartphone, P0-17, P18-24, P25-34, P35-44, P45-54, P55-64, P65+, Unique Audience, Universe
+Reach %, Time Spent per Person (text).
+
+* Persons 0-17 does not include mobile data.
+
+7
+
+Surfing Reports
+
+This artwork was created using Nielsen data.
+Copyright © 2019 The Nielsen Company (US), LLC. Confidential and proprietary. Do not distribute.
+
+People 2+ Surfing Online
+
+.
+.
+
+e
+e
+t
+t
+u
+u
+b
+b
+i
+i
+r
+r
+t
+t
+s
+s
+i
+i
+d
+d
+t
+t
+o
+o
+n
+n
+o
+o
+D
+D
+
+.
+.
+y
+y
+r
+r
+a
+a
+t
+t
+e
+e
+i
+i
+r
+r
+p
+p
+o
+o
+r
+r
+p
+p
+d
+d
+n
+n
+a
+a
+
+l
+l
+
+a
+a
+i
+i
+t
+t
+n
+n
+e
+e
+d
+d
+fi
+fi
+n
+n
+o
+o
+C
+C
+
+.
+.
+
+C
+C
+L
+L
+L
+L
+
+,
+,
+)
+)
+S
+S
+U
+U
+
+(
+(
+
+y
+y
+n
+n
+a
+a
+p
+p
+m
+m
+o
+o
+C
+C
+n
+n
+e
+e
+s
+s
+l
+l
+e
+e
+N
+N
+e
+e
+h
+h
+T
+T
+9
+9
+1
+1
+0
+0
+2
+2
+©
+©
-have received had it sold the lands as the grant legislation originally required. A smaller amount of
+i
+i
-land associated with the Coos Bay Wagon Road was also reconveyed to the United States in 1919
+t
+t
+h
+h
+g
+g
+i
+i
+r
+r
+y
+y
+p
+p
+o
+o
+C
+C
-in a similar manner, and is also included herein in the reference to "O&C lands."
+Source: Nielsen Digital Panel, Monthly Total, Text, Feb 2019 - Feb 2020, Digital (C/M), People 2+ Market Line
-42. The 1916 Chamberlain-Ferris Act required that the O&C lands be classified as
+9
-timberlands, agriculture lands or power-site lands, that the timber on these lands be sold as rapidly
+Surfing Report
-as reasonably possible, and that the cutover lands classified as timber or agricultural lands be
+People 2+
-returned to private ownership and county tax rolls by selling them for $2.50 per acre. An amount
+People 18+
-was appropriated from the Treasury to pay counties the back taxes owed by the railroad at the time
+Name
-of revestment in 1916, and to pay the railroad what it would have earned from selling the lands as
+UA
-was originally required. Future sums from expected land and timber sales were earmarked for
+Avg Time Spent Total Time Spent
-sharing with the O&C Counties to offset the loss of property taxes after 1916 until the lands were
+Name
-finally once again all in private ownership. Those payments to counties, however, would be delayed
+UA
-until the federal government had first recovered from land and timber sales all amounts appropriated
+Avg Time Spent Total Time Spent
-in 1916 in connection with the terms of the Revestment Act. For the next 10 years the land and
+Google
-timber sales were insufficient to repay the amount appropriated in 1916, and the O&C Counties
+Facebook
-therefore received nothing from 1916 until 1926. In order to relieve the financial plight of the
+YouTube
-counties, Congress passed additional legislation in 1926 that appropriated monies to pay the
+19,848,439
-equivalent of county taxes on the O&C lands still in federal ownership from 1916 through 1926.
+17,837,239
-The policy of selling timber and then selling the cutover lands continued.
+17,068,585
-Page 19 - Complaint
+13:40:46
-Mark C. Rutzick, Inc.
-12402 Myra Virginia Ct
-Oak Hill, Virginia 20171
- Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com
+16,291,203,606
-Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 20 of 29
+Google
-43. The 1926 law did not take into account that most of the remaining lands were unsuitable
+18:39:42
-for agriculture, and did not consider the adverse impact that liquidating the timber with no provision
+19,972,379,884
-for reforestation would have on local timber-dependent communities. Controversy regarding the
+YouTube
-lands continued. In 1937 Congress enacted the O&C Act, abandoning the cut-and-dispose
+23:05:53
-philosophy of the 1916 and 1926 laws and replacing it with a new policy calling for permanent
+23,655,150,362
-timber production from the O&C lands based on the scientific forestry principle of “sustained yield”
+Facebook
-to produce a permanent timber supply and to provide revenues to the O&C Counties that had been
+17,943,703
-promised but not delivered by prior legislation. Determination of a sustained yield timber harvest
+16,204,525
-level for a forested area requires two facts: the volume of standing timber and the “rotation period”
+17,278,479
-(the time for a tree to grow from a seedling to optimum harvest size). The volume of standing timber
+15:04:14
-is divided by the years in the rotation period to calculate the allowable annual sustained yield timber
+16,225,558,846
-harvest, which can then continue in perpetuity. At the time of enactment of the O&C Act, Congress’
+23:52:30
-best available estimate of the standing timber on the O&C lands was approximately 50 billion board
+23,213,035,282
-feet. To set an interim timber sale level pending completion of more accurate volume and rotation
+19:15:20
-determinations, Congress used an approximate 100 year rotation period, and thus established 500
+19,962,616,731
-million board feet per year as the minimum required sale level until the larger sustained yield amount
+MSN/Outlook/Bing/Skype
-could be accurately determined (i.e., annually harvesting 500 million board feet of timber for 100
+13,681,073
-years would remove 50 billion board feet of timber, while regeneration and regrowth of new trees
+4:55:39
-would produce 50 billion board feet of new timber in 100 years, leaving at least as much timber
+4,044,846,450
-standing at the end of the 100 years as at the beginning). To implement the new policy the O&C Act
+MSN/Outlook/Bing/Skype
-provided:
+12,995,336
-[O & C lands] classified as timberlands . . . shall be managed . . . for
-permanent forest production, and the timber thereon shall be sold, cut, and
-removed in conformity with the principal [sic] of sustained yield for the
-purpose of providing a permanent source of timber supply, protecting
-watersheds, regulating stream flow, and contributing to the economic stability
-of local communities and industries, and providing recreational facilities.
+Apple
-Page 20 - Complaint
+Instagram
-Mark C. Rutzick, Inc.
-12402 Myra Virginia Ct
-Oak Hill, Virginia 20171
- Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com
+eBay
-Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 21 of 29
+PayPal
-The annual productive capacity for such lands shall be determined and
-declared . . . Provided, that timber from said lands in an amount not less than
-one-half billion feet board measure, or not less than the annual sustained yield
-capacity when the same has been determined and declared, shall be sold
-annually, or so much thereof as can be sold at reasonable prices on a normal
-market.
+Microsoft
-43 U.S.C. §1181a. Thus, the O&C Act imposes four mandatory duties on the BLM:
+12,866,475
-1. All of the O & C lands classified as timberlands “shall be managed . . .
+12,684,785
-for permanent forest production.”
+12,605,107
-2. The timber on those lands “shall be sold, cut, and removed in conformity
+12,094,593
-with the princip[le] of sustained yield ....”
+11,551,875
-3. “The annual productive capacity for such lands shall be determined and
+ABC Online Network
-declared.”
+11,333,137
-4. Timber from the O&C timberlands “in an amount not less than one-half
-billion feet board measure, or not less than the annual sustained yield
-capacity when the same has been determined and declared, shall be sold
-annually, or so much thereof as can be sold at reasonable prices on a
-normal market.”
+Woolworths
-44. Following passage of the O&C Act, the Interior Department immediately began to
+Wikipedia
-determine the inventory of standing timber and the proper classification of O&C lands as
+LinkedIn
-timberlands. By 1942 the Department determined that 2,446,000 acres of O&C lands were properly
+realestate.com.au
-classified as timberlands (referred to as “O&C timberlands”). U.S. Department of Interior General
+news.com.au
-Land Office, Forever Timber: Perpetual Sustained Yield Forestry on the Revested Oregon and
+10,376,298
-California Railroad Grant Lands and the Reconveyed Coos Bay Wagon Road Grant Lands in
+10,187,717
-Western Oregon (1945) at 17. The Department also immediately began marketing timber from the
+9,762,158
-O&C lands, selling 593 million board feet of timber sales from the O&C lands in fiscal year 1940.
+9,634,420
-W. Horning, The O&C Lands and their Management, an Important Advance in Forest Conservation
+9,348,648
-(U.S. Department of Interior General Land Office) (December 1940) at 7.
+1:59:17
-45. The O&C Act authorizes the Secretary to subdivide the revested lands “into
+1,534,854,537
-sustained-yield forest units, the boundary lines of which shall be so established that a forest unit will
+Apple
-Page 21 - Complaint
+3:37:53
-Mark C. Rutzick, Inc.
-12402 Myra Virginia Ct
-Oak Hill, Virginia 20171
- Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com
+2,764,000,687
-Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 22 of 29
+Instagram
-provide, insofar as practicable, a permanent source of raw materials for the support of dependent
+1:29:37
-communities and local industries of the region ....” 43 U.S.C. §1181a. Under this authority the BLM
+1,129,694,442
-has subdivided the O&C lands into five “districts” based in the western Oregon cities of Coos Bay,
+eBay
-Eugene, Medford, Roseburg and Salem, and a subdivision of a sixth district (the Lakeview district)
+0:09:31
-based in Klamath Falls.
+1:07:37
-46. After the BLM determined the annual productive capacity of the six units, the agency
+1:18:02
-steadily increased the allowable sale quantities until starting in 1959 the BLM began selling an
+0:19:47
-average of more than 1.1 billion board feet (bbf) of timber from the O&C lands every year for the
+0:14:00
-next 32 years, with the peak sale level of 1.662 bbf occurring in 1960. See FEIS 602; Final
+1:15:48
-Environmental Impact Statement for the Revision of the Resource Management Plans of the Western
+0:46:34
-Oregon Bureau of Land Management (October 2008) at 3-239-40. This level of annual timber sales
+0:36:05
-proved to be sustainable in perpetuity: the standing timber on the O&C lands in 1990 was greater
+115,109,629
-than in 1960. FEIS 333.
+PayPal
-47. To provide a reliable stream of income to the O&C Counties, the O&C Act mandated that
+781,266,772
-50 percent of the gross revenues from timber sales on the O & C lands be paid to the counties, 43
+Microsoft
-U.S.C. §1181f (a), and that an additional 25 percent of the gross revenues from timber sales on the
+884,466,592
-O & C lands also be paid to the counties under certain conditions. 43 U.S.C. §1181f (b). The
+ABC Online Network
-remaining 25 percent of gross revenues would go to the government to cover the administrative cost
+205,325,529
-of running the sale program.
+Woolworths
-48. The BLM currently manages approximately 2,151,200 acres of O&C lands. FEIS 118.
+142,669,437
-In 2008 the Director of the BLM recognized that “[b]ased on the O&C Act, management of timber
+Wikipedia
-is the dominant use of the O&C lands in western Oregon” and affirmed that “[t]he O&C Act requires
+740,053,674
-O&C lands classified as timberlands to be managed for permanent forest production following the
+LinkedIn
-principles of sustained yield, which include determining and declaring the annual productive capacity
+448,667,709
-Page 22 - Complaint
+realestate.com.au
-Mark C. Rutzick, Inc.
-12402 Myra Virginia Ct
-Oak Hill, Virginia 20171
- Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com
+337,483,439
-Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 23 of 29
+news.com.au
-of such lands with the timber from those lands (not less than the annual sustained yield capacity)
+12,763,377
-being sold annually.” In 2016 Defendant Kornze again confirmed that “The O&C Act established
+12,579,558
-sustained-yield timber production as the primary or dominant use of O&C lands in western Oregon.”
+12,221,372
- Director’s Protest Resolution Report (August 5, 2016) 188.
+11,957,707
-B.
+11,265,747
-Resource Management Plan Development and Revision under FLPMA.
+10,981,388
-49. FLPMA, adopted in 1976, requires the BLM to “develop, maintain, and, when
+10,298,974
-appropriate, revise land use plans which provide by tracts or areas for the use of the public lands.”
+9,957,687
-43 U.S.C. §1712(a). FLPMA also requires the BLM to provide the public adequate notice and
+9,737,846
-opportunity to comment upon and participate in the formulation of plans and programs relating to
+9,463,425
-the management of the public lands. 43 U.S.C. §1712(f). FLPMA’s procedural measures apply to
+9,174,848
-the O&C lands, but in the event FLPMA conflicts with the substantive measures of the O&C Act
+5:10:42
-“insofar as they relate to the management of timber resources,” the O&C Act prevails. 43 U.S.C.A.
+2:00:13
-§ 1701 Savings Provision Note (West 2010).
+3:39:33
-C.
+1:31:56
-BLM Management of O& C lands since 1994.
+0:09:35
-50. In 1994 the Secretaries of Interior and Agriculture adopted a land management plan
+1:08:45
-known as the Northwest Forest Plan (NWFP) for the administration of the O&C lands as well as all
+1:19:29
-or parts of 19 national forests in Washington, Oregon and California that lie within the range of the
+0:19:53
-northern spotted owl, a bird that was listed throughout its range as a threatened species under the
+0:14:15
-Endangered Species Act in 1990. 55 Fed. Reg. 26114 (June 26, 1990).
+1:15:58
-51. The BLM adopted RMPs in 1995 to implement the NWFP. The 1995 RMPs reduced
+0:46:50
-the annual sustained yield timber level on the O&C lands to 211 mmbf, an 82% reduction from the
+0:36:24
-previous allowable level. FEIS 341. The annual harvest level was later further reduced to 203
+4,037,669,825
-million board feet, id, but in 2016 BLM recalculated that ASQ and raised it to 277 million board feet
+1,534,537,028
-based on new data and analysis. Id. The 1995 plans permitted sustained yield timber management
+2,761,947,509
-Page 23 - Complaint
+1,123,728,567
-Mark C. Rutzick, Inc.
-12402 Myra Virginia Ct
-Oak Hill, Virginia 20171
- Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com
+114,630,946
-Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 24 of 29
+774,538,814
-on only 27 percent of the O&C timberlands. As a result of these decisions, the revenues from O&C
+872,997,444
-timber sales dropped sharply, severely reducing payments to the 18 O&C Counties in western
+204,886,013
-Oregon. To replace the lost revenues to the O&C counties, starting in the mid-1990's the federal
+141,942,109
-government appropriated and paid several billion dollars of direct federal payments to the counties,
+739,859,176
-with the funding levels steadily dropping as time passed, and ending in 2016. As a result of the
+443,213,459
-absence of O&C timber revenues and the diminishing federal grant program, exacerbated in recent
+333,989,057
-years by poor economic conditions, rural western Oregon counties have faced, and continue to face,
+Source: Digital Content Ratings, Monthly Total, Text, Feb 2020, People 2+, People 13+, Unique Audience, Avg TIme Spent, Total Time Spent.
+*YouTube reporting is sourced from DCR Monthly Total Video
-a grave financial crisis, with counties publically discussing bankruptcy filings and wholesale layoffs
+10
-of law enforcement personnel.
+.
+.
-52. Plaintiffs AFRC, CIC, C & D, Swanson and other citizens filed a legal challenge in this
+e
+e
+t
+t
+u
+u
+b
+b
+i
+i
+r
+r
+t
+t
+s
+s
+i
+i
+d
+d
+t
+t
+o
+o
+n
+n
+o
+o
+D
+D
+
+.
+.
+y
+y
+r
+r
+a
+a
+t
+t
+e
+e
+i
+i
+r
+r
+p
+p
+o
+o
+r
+r
+p
+p
+d
+d
+n
+n
+a
+a
+
+l
+l
+
+a
+a
+i
+i
+t
+t
+n
+n
+e
+e
+d
+d
+fi
+fi
+n
+n
+o
+o
+C
+C
+
+.
+.
+
+C
+C
+L
+L
+L
+L
+
+,
+,
+)
+)
+S
+S
+U
+U
+
+(
+(
+
+y
+y
+n
+n
+a
+a
+p
+p
+m
+m
+o
+o
+C
+C
+n
+n
+e
+e
+s
+s
+l
+l
+e
+e
+N
+N
+e
+e
+h
+h
+T
+T
+9
+9
+1
+1
+0
+0
+2
+2
+©
+©
+
+i
+i
+
+t
+t
+h
+h
+g
+g
+i
+i
+r
+r
+y
+y
+p
+p
+o
+o
+C
+C
+
+Streaming Video
+
+This artwork was created using Nielsen data.
+Copyright © 2019 The Nielsen Company (US), LLC. Confidential and proprietary. Do not distribute.
+
+Streaming Video - Audience, Reach and Time Spent
+
+Demo
+
+Total 18+
+Total 18 - 24
+Total 25 - 34
+Total 35 - 44
+Total 45 - 54
+Total 55 - 64
+Total 65+
+Total Female 18+
+Female 18 - 24
+Female 25 - 34
+Female 35 - 44
+Female 45 - 54
+Female 55 - 64
+Female 65+
+Total Male 18+
+Male 18 - 24
+Male 25 - 34
+Male 35 - 44
+Male 45 - 54
+Male 55 - 64
+Male 65+
+
+Unique Audience
+16,888,355
+
+Population Reach (%)
+86%
+
+Average Time Spent
+37:42:52
+
+2,224,910
+3,636,729
+3,163,950
+2,933,646
+2,574,718
+2,417,820
+8,663,869
+1,099,710
+1,829,763
+1,598,064
+1,560,162
+1,359,606
+1,216,564
+8,287,904
+1,125,200
+1,806,966
+1,565,886
+1,373,484
+1,215,112
+1,201,256
+
+94.5%
+96.7%
+95.6%
+90.7%
+88.3%
+61.0%
+87.1%
+95.6%
+96.8%
+96.2%
+94.5%
+91.1%
+57.8%
+86.4%
+93.5%
+96.6%
+94.9%
+86.7%
+85.4%
+64.7%
+
+70:58:47
+43:08:00
+37:51:40
+33:36:20
+20:05:40
+16:42:54
+32:57:32
+57:17:19
+38:46:58
+32:35:06
+32:47:02
+19:27:09
+18:00:58
+40:59:43
+84:21:38
+47:32:19
+43:14:45
+34:32:20
+20:48:47
+15:23:50
+
+Source: Nielsen Digital Content Ratings, Video, Feb 2020, People 18+, Panel + Census
+
+12
+
+.
+.
+
+e
+e
+t
+t
+u
+u
+b
+b
+i
+i
+r
+r
+t
+t
+s
+s
+i
+i
+d
+d
+t
+t
+o
+o
+n
+n
+o
+o
+D
+D
+
+.
+.
+y
+y
+r
+r
+a
+a
+t
+t
+e
+e
+i
+i
+r
+r
+p
+p
+o
+o
+r
+r
+p
+p
+d
+d
+n
+n
+a
+a
+
+l
+l
+
+a
+a
+i
+i
+t
+t
+n
+n
+e
+e
+d
+d
+fi
+fi
+n
+n
+o
+o
+C
+C
+
+.
+.
+
+C
+C
+L
+L
+L
+L
+
+,
+,
+)
+)
+S
+S
+U
+U
+
+(
+(
+
+y
+y
+n
+n
+a
+a
+p
+p
+m
+m
+o
+o
+C
+C
+n
+n
+e
+e
+s
+s
+l
+l
+e
+e
+N
+N
+e
+e
+h
+h
+T
+T
+9
+9
+1
+1
+0
+0
+2
+2
+©
+©
+
+i
+i
+
+t
+t
+h
+h
+g
+g
+i
+i
+r
+r
+y
+y
+p
+p
+o
+o
+C
+C
+
+Streaming Video - Audience, Reach and Time Spent
+
+Unique Audience
+
+Population Reach%
+
+Average Time Spent
+
+.
+.
+
+e
+e
+t
+t
+u
+u
+b
+b
+i
+i
+r
+r
+t
+t
+s
+s
+i
+i
+d
+d
+t
+t
+o
+o
+n
+n
+o
+o
+D
+D
+
+.
+.
+y
+y
+r
+r
+a
+a
+t
+t
+e
+e
+i
+i
+r
+r
+p
+p
+o
+o
+r
+r
+p
+p
+d
+d
+n
+n
+a
+a
+
+l
+l
+
+a
+a
+i
+i
+t
+t
+n
+n
+e
+e
+d
+d
+fi
+fi
+n
+n
+o
+o
+C
+C
+
+.
+.
+
+C
+C
+L
+L
+L
+L
+
+,
+,
+)
+)
+S
+S
+U
+U
+
+(
+(
+
+y
+y
+n
+n
+a
+a
+p
+p
+m
+m
+o
+o
+C
+C
+n
+n
+e
+e
+s
+s
+l
+l
+e
+e
+N
+N
+e
+e
+h
+h
+T
+T
+9
+9
+1
+1
+0
+0
+2
+2
+©
+©
-Court against the Secretary of Interior’s adoption of the 1994 NWFP in American Forest Resource
+i
+i
-Council et al. v. Dombeck, No. C94-1031 (D.D.C.). On October 17, 2003 the parties in that case
+t
+t
+h
+h
+g
+g
+i
+i
+r
+r
+y
+y
+p
+p
+o
+o
+C
+C
-(then captioned AFRC v. Caswell) entered into a Settlement Agreement to resolve the case, which
+Source: Nielsen Digital Content Ratings, Video, Feb 2020, People 18+, Panel + Census
-included an agreement for the BLM to “revise its resource management plans for its Coos Bay,
+13
-Eugene, Lakeview, Medford, Roseburg and Salem Districts by December 31, 2008.” Settlement
+Streaming Video Report - Total - Computer
-Agreement, paragraph 3.5.
+Name
-53. In 2005 the BLM began the plan revision process required by the 2003 Settlement
+Market Total
-Agreement, which BLM called the Western Oregon Plan Revision (WOPR). Each of the six WOPR
+Facebook
-plans was prepared and adopted in accordance with the BLM’s FLPMA land use planning
+YouTube
-regulations. The BLM undertook extensive public involvement during the plan revision process,
+news.com.au*
-beginning in August 2005 and extending through December 2008.
+Netflix
-54. On December 30, 2008 the Secretary of Interior approved the WOPR RODs for the six
+ABC Online Network
-BLM districts consistent with the schedule in the Settlement Agreement in AFRC v. Caswell. See
+Pinterest
-74 Fed. Reg. 829 (January 8, 2009). The six WOPR RODs went into effect immediately. Id. The
+Yahoo!
-Page 24 - Complaint
+9Now*
-Mark C. Rutzick, Inc.
-12402 Myra Virginia Ct
-Oak Hill, Virginia 20171
- Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com
+smh.com.au
-Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 25 of 29
+Daily Mail Australia*
-six WOPR RODs collectively directed the BLM to offer 502 million board feet of timber per year.
+Reddit
-55. On July 16, 2009, the Department of Interior’s Acting Assistant Secretary of Interior for
+nine.com.au*
-Land and Minerals Management purported to withdraw the WOPR RODs through a two-page
+Instagram
-internal memorandum to the Acting Director of the BLM. The decision included direction for the
+SBS (Special Broadcasting Service)*
-BLM to return to management of the O&C lands under its 1995 RMPs, id., and the BLM did so.
+UA
-56. Plaintiffs DTO, CIC, Seneca Jones and Swanson Group filed a lawsuit in this court
+Pop Base
-challenging the withdrawal of the WOPR RODs. On March 31, 2011 the court found that the
+Reach %
-withdrawal was procedurally unlawful under FLPMA, and vacated and remanded the unlawful
+10,010,479
-withdrawal decision, which had the effect of reinstating the WOPR. Douglas Timber Operators v.
+6,300,756
-Salazar, 774 F.Supp.2d 245, 261-62 (D.D.C. 2011).
+6,283,189
-57. Environmental groups then filed an action in Oregon challenging the BLM's failure to
+1,740,628
-engage in consultation on the WOPR RODs under the ESA, 16 U.S.C. §1536(a)-(b), with the U.S.
+1,602,615
-Fish and Wildlife Service and the Commerce Department’s NOAA Fisheries. Pacific Rivers Council
+975,781
-v. Shepard, Civ. No. 11-442-HU (D. Or. filed April 8, 2011). The Oregon district court entered an
+952,349
-order on May 16,2012 vacating the WOPR RODs and reinstating the 1995 RMPs.
+888,471
-58. On March 12, 2012 the Interior Department announced that BLM would commence a
+812,255
-new process for revising the 1995 RMPs. That process culminated in the decision by defendant
+766,276
-Kornze on August 5, 2016 adopting the 2016 RMPs for the six BLM districts in Western Oregon.
+719,233
-59. The BLM has determined that at the present time the annual productive capacity of the
+710,274
-O&C timberlands, based on the entire land base of O&C timberlands, is approximately 1.2 billion
+699,436
-board feet of timber per year. FEIS 340, 1853. The current standing volume of timber on the O&C
+629,777
-timberlands is 72-73.3 billion board feet. FEIS 334, 335 (two differing estimates).
+623,930
-60. The 2016 RMPs together designate 957,872 acres (38 percent of the total area) of O&C
+19,774,230
-timberlands as late-successional reserves where the sale, cutting and removal of timber in conformity
+19,774,230
-Page 25 - Complaint
+19,774,230
-Mark C. Rutzick, Inc.
-12402 Myra Virginia Ct
-Oak Hill, Virginia 20171
- Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com
+19,774,230
-Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 26 of 29
+19,774,230
-with the principles of sustained yield timber management is prohibited. The 2016 RMPs designate
+19,774,230
-another 520,092 acres (21 percent of the total area) as “Riparian Reserves” where the sale, cutting
+19,774,230
-and removal of timber in conformity with the principles of sustained yield timber management is
+19,774,230
-prohibited. Finally, the 2016 RMPs designate another 362,894 acres (15 percent of the total area)
+19,774,230
-as “Other Reserves,” including Special Recreation Management Areas, where the sale, cutting and
+19,774,230
-removal of timber in conformity with the principles of sustained yield timber management is
+19,774,230
-prohibited. The 2016 RMPs designate only 498,597 acres (20 percent of the lands suitable for timber
+19,774,230
-production) as the “Harvest Land Base” available for sustained-yield timber management, and even
+19,774,230
-that small area is subject to harvest constraints inconsistent with sustained-yield management under
+19,774,230
-the O&C Act. The level of permitted annual sustained-yield timber harvest dropped from 277
+19,774,230
-million board feet under the Northwest Forest Plan (as recalculated by BLM in 2016) to 205 million
+50.6
-board feet, a 26 percent reduction. FEIS 341. In southwestern Oregon, the reductions are even
+31.9
-greater on a percentage basis: the Coos Bay ASQ falls from 46 million board feet to 12 million board
+31.8
-feet, a 74 percent drop; the Medford ASQ declines from 73 million board feet to 37 million board
+8.8
-feet, a 49 percent drop; and the Roseburg ASQ goes down from 55 million board feet to 32 million
+8.1
-board feet, a 42 percent drop.
+4.9
-61. The legal violations described below are causing current and threatened injury to
+4.8
-plaintiffs, who have no remedy at law for these injuries.
+4.5
-CLAIM FOR RELIEF
+4.1
-(Violation of O&C Act, 43 U.S.C. §1181a; arbitrary and capricious agency action under 5
-U.S.C. §706(2); approval of 2016 RMPs that fail to require management of O&C
-timberlands for permanent sustained yield timber production, fail to sell timber from O&C
-timberlands in conformity with the principle of sustained yield, unlawfully determine and
-declare the annual productive capacity of O&C timberlands, and fail to require annual
-offering of timber sales equal to the annual productive capacity of O&C timberlands)
+3.9
-62. Plaintiffs repeat and reallege the allegations in paragraphs 1-61 as if fully set forth
+3.6
-herein.
+3.6
-Page 26 - Complaint
+3.5
-Mark C. Rutzick, Inc.
-12402 Myra Virginia Ct
-Oak Hill, Virginia 20171
- Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com
+3.2
-Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 27 of 29
+3.2
-63. The 2016 RMPs violate the O&C Act, 43 U.S.C. § 1181a. The RMPs do not allow the
+Source: Nielsen Digital Content Ratings, Monthly Total, Video, 0 secs Qualifier, February 2020, People 18+, Computer, Unique Audience, Population Base, Reach %
+*Brands marked with an asterisk represent metrics from tagged methodology.
-timber on 74 percent of the O&C timberlands to be sold, cut, and removed in conformity with the
+14
-principle of sustained yield by assigning those lands to land use allocations that do not permit
+.
+.
-sustained yield timber production, and place unlawful constraints on management of the 20 percent
+e
+e
+t
+t
+u
+u
+b
+b
+i
+i
+r
+r
+t
+t
+s
+s
+i
+i
+d
+d
+t
+t
+o
+o
+n
+n
+o
+o
+D
+D
+
+.
+.
+y
+y
+r
+r
+a
+a
+t
+t
+e
+e
+i
+i
+r
+r
+p
+p
+o
+o
+r
+r
+p
+p
+d
+d
+n
+n
+a
+a
+
+l
+l
+
+a
+a
+i
+i
+t
+t
+n
+n
+e
+e
+d
+d
+fi
+fi
+n
+n
+o
+o
+C
+C
+
+.
+.
+
+C
+C
+L
+L
+L
+L
+
+,
+,
+)
+)
+S
+S
+U
+U
+
+(
+(
+
+y
+y
+n
+n
+a
+a
+p
+p
+m
+m
+o
+o
+C
+C
+n
+n
+e
+e
+s
+s
+l
+l
+e
+e
+N
+N
+e
+e
+h
+h
+T
+T
+9
+9
+1
+1
+0
+0
+2
+2
+©
+©
-of O&C timberlands in the “Harvest Land Base” that prevent full sustained yield timber production
+i
+i
-of those lands. Although the actual productive capacity of the O&C timberlands is approximately
+t
+t
+h
+h
+g
+g
+i
+i
+r
+r
+y
+y
+p
+p
+o
+o
+C
+C
-1.2 billion board feet per year, the 2016 RMPs set the annual sustained yield harvest level at 205
+Streaming Video Report - Tagged - 2 secs
-million board feet, just 17 percent of the required total. The BLM is not selling, and has no intention
+Name
-of selling, the actual annual productive capacity of the O&C timberlands of approximately 1.2 billion
+SWM 7
-board feet.
+news.com.au
-64. The non-discretionary duties imposed on the BLM by the O&C Act to manage all O&C
+nine.com.au
-timberlands for sustained yield timber production are the exclusive criteria for management of the
+9Now
-O&C timberlands. The O&C Act does not identify wildlife conservation or the protection of
+Daily Mail Australia
-threatened or endangered species as a factor for management of the O&C timberlands. When
+Network 10
-adopting a resource management plan for the O&C lands as required by FLPMA, the O&C Act
+Whimn
-prohibits the BLM from considering any factors outside the O&C Act. The BLM does not have
+taste.com.au
-authority under the O&C Act to manage any of the O&C timberlands for wildlife conservation or
+SBS (Special Broadcasting Service)
-protection of endangered or threatened species in a manner that does not constitute sustained yield
+perthnow
-timber production required by the O&C Act. Nonetheless, the 2016 RMPs unlawfully assert that
+The Daily Telegraph
-“[t]he purpose of the action includes contributing to the conservation and recovery of threatened and
+couriermail.com.au
-endangered species within the planning area, including the northern spotted owl, marbled murrelet,
+AdelaideNow
-and threatened and endangered anadromous fish” and that this purpose “necessarily includes
+Herald Sun
-maintaining a network of large blocks of forest to be managed for late-successional forests and
+THE AUSTRALIAN
-maintaining older and more structurally-complex multi-layered conifer forests.” FEIS 7. Defendant
+UA
-Page 27 - Complaint
+Pop Base
-Mark C. Rutzick, Inc.
-12402 Myra Virginia Ct
-Oak Hill, Virginia 20171
- Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com
+Reach %
-Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 28 of 29
+3,491,937
-Kornze expressly asserted on August 5, 2016 that “[t]he BLM must comply with the O&C Act as
+2,689,535
-well as other environmental statutes, including ... the ESA.”
+1,936,015
-65. The BLM’s approval of the 2016 RMPs that fail to require management of O&C
+1,904,222
-timberlands for sustained yield timber production, fail to sell timber from O&C timberlands in
+1,431,763
-conformity with the principle of sustained yield, fail to determine and declare the annual productive
+1,238,902
-capacity of O&C timberlands, and fail to require annual offering of timber sales equal to the annual
+587,609
-productive capacity of O&C timberlands in accordance with the O&C Act is arbitrary and capricious,
+431,831
-an abuse of discretion, not in accordance with law, without observance of procedure required by law,
+404,486
-in excess of statutory authority and short of statutory right under 5 U.S.C. § 706(2).
+387,648
-PRAYER FOR RELIEF
+303,779
-WHEREFORE, plaintiffs pray for judgment as follows:
+275,778
-1.
+165,451
-A declaration that defendant Kornze’s decision to approve the 2016 RMPs that fail to
+161,710
-require management of O&C timberlands for permanent sustained yield timber production, fail to
+115,625
-sell timber from O&C timberlands in conformity with the principle of sustained yield, fail to
+19,774,230
-determine and declare the annual productive capacity of the O&C timberlands, and fail to require
+19,774,230
-annual offering of timber sales equal to the annual productive capacity of O&C timberlands in
+19,774,230
-accordance with the O&C Act violates the O&C Act, 43 U.S.C. § 1181a, and that these violations
+19,774,230
-are arbitrary and capricious, an abuse of discretion, not in accordance with law, without observance
+19,774,230
-of procedure required by law, in excess of statutory authority and short of statutory right under 5
+19,774,230
-U.S.C. § 706(2).
+19,774,230
-2.
+19,774,230
-A declaration that the non-discretionary duties imposed on the BLM by the O&C Act are
+19,774,230
-the exclusive criteria for management of the O&C timberlands, that when the BLM adopts a resource
+19,774,230
-management plan for the O&C lands as required by FLPMA, the O&C Act prohibits the BLM from
+19,774,230
-considering any factors outside the O&C Act, and that the BLM does not have authority under the
+19,774,230
-Page 28 - Complaint
+19,774,230
-Mark C. Rutzick, Inc.
-12402 Myra Virginia Ct
-Oak Hill, Virginia 20171
- Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com
+19,774,230
-Case 1:16-cv-01599-RJL Document 1 Filed 08/05/16 Page 29 of 29
+19,774,230
-O&C Act to manage any of the O&C timberlands for wildlife conservation or protection of
+18
-endangered or threatened species in a manner that does not constitute sustained-yield timber
+14
-production required by the O&C Act.
+10
-3.
+10
-4.
+7
-An order vacating and remanding the 2016 RMPs to the Secretary of Interior.
+6
-An injunction requiring the BLM to offer at least 500 million board feet of timber sales
+3
-from O&C timberlands annually at reasonable prices on a normal market until the BLM adopts new
+2
-RMPs that comply with the O&C Act.
+2
-5.
+2
-An order awarding plaintiff AFRC its attorneys fees under the Equal Access to Justice
+2
-Act, 28 U.S.C. §2412.
+1
-6.
+1
-Granting plaintiffs such further relief as may be just, proper and equitable.
+1
-Dated this 5th day of August, 2016.
+1
-By: /s/
+Source: Nielsen Digital Content Ratings, Monthly Tagged, Video, 2 secs Qualifier ,Ad Supported (Video), February 2020, People 18+, Digital (C/M), Unique Audience, Population
+Base, Reach %
-Mark C. Rutzick, D.C. Bar No. 979547
-markrutzick@rutzick.com
-Mark C. Rutzick, Inc.
-12402 Myra Virginia Ct., Oak Hill, VA 20171
-Telephone/Facsimile: (703) 870-7347
-Attorney for Plaintiffs
+15
-Page 29 - Complaint
+.
+.
-Mark C. Rutzick, Inc.
-12402 Myra Virginia Ct
-Oak Hill, Virginia 20171
- Phone/Fax: 703-870-7347 ! E-mail: markrutzick@rutzick.com
+e
+e
+t
+t
+u
+u
+b
+b
+i
+i
+r
+r
+t
+t
+s
+s
+i
+i
+d
+d
+t
+t
+o
+o
+n
+n
+o
+o
+D
+D
+
+.
+.
+y
+y
+r
+r
+a
+a
+t
+t
+e
+e
+i
+i
+r
+r
+p
+p
+o
+o
+r
+r
+p
+p
+d
+d
+n
+n
+a
+a
+
+l
+l
+
+a
+a
+i
+i
+t
+t
+n
+n
+e
+e
+d
+d
+fi
+fi
+n
+n
+o
+o
+C
+C
+
+.
+.
+
+C
+C
+L
+L
+L
+L
+
+,
+,
+)
+)
+S
+S
+U
+U
+
+(
+(
+
+y
+y
+n
+n
+a
+a
+p
+p
+m
+m
+o
+o
+C
+C
+n
+n
+e
+e
+s
+s
+l
+l
+e
+e
+N
+N
+e
+e
+h
+h
+T
+T
+9
+9
+1
+1
+0
+0
+2
+2
+©
+©
+
+i
+i
+
+t
+t
+h
+h
+g
+g
+i
+i
+r
+r
+y
+y
+p
+p
+o
+o
+C
+C
diff --git a/q12/random_k4/random_4.md b/q12/random_k4/random_4.md
index 4f893ddec7d5896260cf6c80e16cbb4898829c99..93421da53624a4659d5f91ceaa6a712c34229053 100644
--- a/q12/random_k4/random_4.md
+++ b/q12/random_k4/random_4.md
@@ -1,422 +1,2535 @@
-# **Robust Reasoning Benchmark**
+BY08 Capital Asset Plan and Business Case Summary
+Exhibit 300
-# **Pavel Golikov[1,2] , Evgenii Opryshko[1,2] , Gennady Pekhimenko[1,2] , Mark C. Jeffrey[1]**
+PART I: SUMMARY INFORMATION AND JUSTIFICATION
-1University of Toronto, 2Vector Institute
+In Part I, complete Sections A. B, C, and D for all capital assets (IT and non-IT). Complete Sections E and
+F for IT capital assets.
-## **Abstract**
+Section A: Overview (All Capital Assets)
-While Large Language Models (LLMs) achieve high performance on standard mathematical benchmarks, their underlying reasoning processes remain highly overfit to standard textual formatting. We propose a perturbation pipeline consisting of 14 techniques to evaluate robustness of LLM reasoning. We apply this pipeline to AIME 2024 dataset and evalute 8 state-of-the-art models on the resulting benchmark. While frontier models exhibit resilience, open-weights reasoning models suffer catastrophic collapses (up to 55% average accuracy drops across perturbations and up to 100% on some), exposing structural fragility. To further disentangle mechanical parsing failures from downstream reasoning failures, we strictly isolate the models’ working memory capacity by forcing models to solve multiple unperturbed mathematical problems sequentially within a single context window. Our results indicate that open weight models ranging from 7B to 120B parameters and Claude Opus 4.6 exhibit accuracy decay on subsequent problems. This degradation demonstrates that intermediate reasoning steps permanently pollute standard dense attention mechanisms. We argue that to achieve reliable reasoning, future reasoning architectures must integrate explicit contextual resets within a model’s own Chain-of-Thought, leading to fundamental open questions regarding the optimal granularity of atomic reasoning tasks.
+The following series of questions are to be completed for all investments to help OMB to identify which
+agency and bureau is responsible for managing each capital asset, which OMB MAX budget account funds
+the project, the kind of the project, who to contact with questions about the information provided in the
+exhibit 300, and whether or not it is an IT or a non-IT capital asset.
-## **1 Introduction**
+(1) Date of Submission:
+(2) Agency:
+(3) Bureau:
+(4) Name of this Capital Asset:
-Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable success on mathematical reasoning benchmarks, with state-of-the-art models approaching saturation on datasets like AIME, GSM8K, and MATH [6, 13, 25]. These results have fueled the perception that LLMs possess robust algorithmic reasoning capabilities—the ability to decompose complex problems into logical intermediate steps. However, a growing body of literature [26, 18, 29] suggests that this performance may be brittle, relying instead on probabilistic pattern matching and surface-level correlations.
+09/11/2006
+422
-To distinguish between robust reasoning and fragile memorization, recent research has turned to adversarial evaluation. Existing approaches generally fall into two categories: changing numeric values to test arithmetic generalization [35, 53, 42] or increasing environmental complexity by adding irrelevant context or harder logic [39, 19, 2]. While valuable, these methods often introduce confounding variables. When a model fails after numerical perturbation, it is unclear whether the failure lies in the reasoning logic or the arithmetic calculation. Similarly, when a model fails on a more complex problem, it is difficult to distinguish between a lack of robustness and a hard limit on the model’s inherent capacity. Furthermore, some benchmarks rely on LLMs to generate the perturbations, introducing non-deterministic noise and potential validity errors into the evaluation pipeline.
+00
-In this paper, we first propose an evaluation framework based on 14 deterministic structural perturbations: the Robust Reasoning Benchmark (RRB). Unlike prior work, we do not alter the mathematical values, the logic, or the final answer. Instead, we apply reversible algorithmic transformations, such as syntactic string reversals, visual 2D grid encodings (e.g., Rail Fence, Snake), and semantic
+Financial Accounting System (FAS)
-Preprint.
+(250 Character Max)
+(5) Unique ID (Unique Project
+Identifier ) :
+Format xxx-xx-xx-xx-xx-xxxx-xx
+(For IT investments only, see section 53. For all other, use agency ID system.)
-**==> picture [393 x 109] intentionally omitted <==**
+422-00-01-01-01-0001-00
-**----- Start of picture text -----**
-100
User Prompt Example 90 -0.4% -1.2%
Solve these completely unrelated math problems. For 80 -13.8% -6.7% -7.1%
eachProblemproblem1: Findput theyournumberfinal ofanswerwayswithinto place\boxed{}.a ... 70 -7.1%
-10.6%
Problem 2: Let ABC be a triangle inscribed ... 60
Problem 3: Let p be the least prime number for... 50 1 4 1 4 1 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 1 2 3 1 2 3 4 5 1 -7.1%2 3
The last problem (3) is the target problem. The
prior problems (1 and 2) are distractor problems.
Gemini 3.1 Pro gpt-5.4 Claude Opus 4.6Qwen3-30B-A3BNemotron-32BNemotron-7BGPT-OSS-120BDSR1-Llama-70B
Accuracy on Last Problem (%)
**----- End of picture text -----**
+(6) What kind of investment
+Will in be this FY2008?
+(7) What was the first budget
+year this investment was
+submitted to OMB?
+Operations and Maintenance
-Figure 1: **The Intra-Query Attention Dilution.** _Left:_ The sequential cognitive overload setup, where models are prompted to solve multiple independent AIME 2024 problems within a single prompt. _Right:_ Mathematical accuracy strictly on the _final_ problem of the sequence. While frontier APIs like Gemini 3.1 Pro and GPT-5.4 exhibit strong resilience, Claude Opus 4.6 and all tested open-weights models suffer a degradation in reasoning accuracy. This reasoning degradation seems to be scale-invariant across open weight models ranging from 7B to 120B parameters. This suggests that prior reasoning steps permanently degrade subsequent reasoning ability, highlighting a fundamental architectural need for explicit working memory isolation inside of model’s own chain-of-thought.
+FY2001 or earlier
-wrappers. We provide the descriptions of the transformation in context to isolate the ability to perform the reverse transformation from the ability to recognize the transformation in the first place. Our transformations are cognitively trivial for humans to decode but structurally hostile to LLM tokenization and attention mechanisms.
+(8) Provide a brief summary and justification for this investment, including a brief description of how this
+closes a gap in part or in whole an identified agency performance gap: (2500 Char Max)
-To further disentangle parsing failures from reasoning failures, we additionally task models with solving several mathematical problems within a single query. By measuring the accuracy only on the last problem, we identify **Intra-Query Attention Dilution** . As visualized in Figure 1, the accuracy on the last problem degrades as the context window is polluted by the model’s own prior reasoning steps. This effect persists across open-weights models from 7B to 120B parameters.
+The Financial Accounting System (FAS) is the main tool NSF staff utilizes to monitor, control, and execute the
+management and financial accountability of approximately 20,000 active awards with 2000+ external
+grantees. The FAS is an on-line real time system is the primary vehicle for managing all funding allocated to the
+NSF. A central transaction management procedure called the "post-routine" represents the core of the system,
+handling the full spectrum of financial transaction processing, accounts maintenance, transaction history, and
+rules processing. This procedure processes any financial request, whether generated from within the Financial
+System itself or by an external system. The FAS is extensively integrated with all of NSF's core business
+systems including the e-Jacket, Proposal and Reviewer System, the Awards System, Guest Travel System, and
+the FastLane System in support of Grants management. NSF's accounting and financial systems staff
+created a data warehousing environment with the ability to produce our financial statements including the
+Closing Package statements, generate automated closing entries and in produce the SGL Tie points reports. In
+FY06, NSF implemented a near real-time interface between FAS and FedTraveler that
-Long-context attention drift is a recognized challenge in information retrieval [37] and recent systemprompt leaks [46], A.5 from proprietary agentic frameworks suggest the industry is attempting to mitigate this through the use of explicit contextual resets. In this work, we demonstrate that such pollution exists even within the span of a single query. We argue that this represents a fundamental architectural limitation of the standard dense attention mechanism, which lacks the inherent capacity for working memory isolation. To achieve reliable algorithmic reasoning, we argue that future architectures must integrate explicit contextual resets within the model’s own Chain-of-Thought or use alternative mechanisms to achieve the same effect, such as using sub-agents [44, 55]. This introduces an open research question regarding the optimal _granularity of reasoning_ , which we further discuss in A.4.
+NSF FAS 1-3-07
-In summary, our contributions are:
+1 of 18
-- A taxonomy and implementation pipeline of 14 deterministic textual transforms that perturb structure without altering meaning or difficulty, allowing to evaluate robustness of LLMs to textual perturbations.
+FY08 Exhibit 300
-- A benchmark, based on AIME 2024 dataset, with 14 textual perturbations that can be used to evaluate robustness of LLM reasoning.
+includes evaluation of funds availability and funds obligation. NSF expects the same type of data exchanges with
+other externally provided cross-services. The e-Learning and e-Procurement /FAS interfaces are
+scheduled to be implemented in FY 2007. The FAS will remain in a steady-state phase in the FY05-FY10
+timeframe. NSF will be approaching its future financial system requirements as an integral part of its grant
+process. NSF will conduct an integrated review of the GMLOB/FMLOB solution in 2007. If that solution is
+determined to not be feasible, NSF will analyze the FMLOB Shared Service Provider (SSP) options in 2008. If
+necessary, NSF will conduct a Business Case Feasibility Study for the FMLOB solution in 2009. This plan allows
+the NSF to take advantage of the results/findings of the GMLOB process in becoming a SSP to more fully
+define our financial requirements. NSF anticipates that if a conversion is necessary it will substantially impact
+NSF Grantees and will begin in 2010. The current FAS will remain in steady-state maintenance until the
+conversion is complete. Any decisions NSF makes regarding the future financial system modernization will
+support the President's Management Agenda.
-- A comprehensive evaluation and analysis of LLM reasoning robustness on benchmark generated from AIME 2024 datset across 5 open-source models and 3 closed-source flagship models (GPT-5.4, Gemini-3.1 Pro, Claude 4.6 Opus).
+(9) Did the Agency's Executive/Investment Committee approve this request?
-## **2 Background and Related Work**
+a. If "yes," what was the date of this approval?
-## **2.1 Reasoning Large Language Models**
+(10) Did the Project Manager review this Exhibit?
-There are several benchmarks introduced to evaluate the performance of LLMs on mathematical reasoning tasks, such as GSM8K, MATH, AIME 2024 [6, 13, 25]. Techniques like Chain-of-Thought
+11) Contact Information of Project Manager?
-2
+N a me :
+Phone Number:
+E-Mail:
-(CoT) and Tree-of-Thought (ToT) [49, 54] have been the primary drivers of this success. However, static benchmark accuracy can mask the fragility of the underlying thinking process.
+Carolyn Miller
-While Large Language Models (LLMs) excel at pattern matching, distinguishing this from genuine reasoning remains a challenge. Following the classical definition by Newell & Simon [28], reasoning involves the manipulation of symbols to bridge premises and conclusions. In cognitive science, this aligns with algorithmic thinking - a slow, deliberate, and multi-step process - as opposed to the rapid, intuitive processing often associated with neural inference [20].
+703-292-4272
-A critical attribute of robust reasoning is invariance to surface-level perturbations. If a model truly understands the concepts and how to manipulate them (like words, sentences, symbols, and math operations), it should be resistant to both surface-level perturbations and deeper logical distractions.
+cmiller@nsf.gov
-## **2.2 Prior Works**
+yes
-**Surface-level and Informational Perturbations.** A prominent line of prior work evaluates robustness by introducing irrelevant information or lexical shifts to test whether a model is reasoning or merely pattern matching. GSM-Symbolic [27], PROBLEMATHIC [2], and others [39, 18, 19] demonstrate the fragility of LLM math reasoning by injecting irrelevant numeric variables or token biases. Beyond irrelevant information, RUPBench [48], ROMMATH [56], and meaning-preserving rephrasing studies [22, 12, 43, 21, 15, 57, 1] systematically quantify how homophones, sentence rephrasings, and visual attacks degrade accuracy. Unlike these methods, which can introduce semantic ambiguity or rely on LLM-generation, our perturbations are strictly deterministic and textualy based. By explicitly providing the decoding rule, we isolate pure structural fragility without altering the semantic or logical constraints of the problem.
+.
-**Dataset Contamination, Memorization, and Numerical Variations.** Another approach alters values and variables to prove the model is not simply reciting training data. Works like [35, 29, 23, 42, 52] dynamically alter numeric values or utilize abstract syntax trees to minimally edit problems, while [41, 51] convert static problems into code functions to enable autmatic generation or measuring memorization limits. Embers of Autoregression [26] demonstrates that performance is heavily driven by text probability. While changing numbers effectively tests memorization, it modifies the mathematical constraints themselves. Our approach preserves the exact pristine mathematical state. Furthermore, unlike Embers, which solely tests text decoding, we force the model to sequentially decode **and** reason, evaluating how decoding structural noise impacts downstream logic.
+08/30/2006
-**Perturbations within Chain-of-Thought Trajectories.** Recent work explores robustness by perturbing the intermediate steps of a model’s reasoning trajectory. Von Recum et al. [47] and Fragile Thoughts [5] inject errors or interventions directly into the CoT to highlight that internal reasoning processes remain susceptible to derailment. Rather than perturbing the active reasoning steps, our work pollutes the initial problem presentation.
+yes
-**Formal, Symbolic, and Difficulty-Based Evaluations.** Several works modify existing benchmarks to evolve their inherent difficulty. Frameworks like Algebraic Circuit Complexity [17], ASyMOB [38], and others [40, 24, 16, 14] design controlled environments, perform confusing parameter substitutions, or rewrite questions into more mathematically complex versions. These benchmarks intentionally increase the mathematical or algorithmic complexity of the task. In contrast, our textual transformations maintain a constant level of difficulty. Moreover, our method is entirely domain-agnostic and can be applied at scale to any existing LaTeX-formatted math dataset without requiring complex problem rewrites.
+(12) Has the agency developed and/or promoted cost effective, energy-efficient and environmentally
+sustainable techniques or practices for this project.
-3
+no
-**==> picture [350 x 356] intentionally omitted <==**
+(a) Will this investment include electronic assets (including computers)?
-**----- Start of picture text -----**
-Semantic and Lexical Substitutions Visual Encoding
Original Problem
Rail Fence Cipher
Let $p$ be the least prime number for L...$...b...h...e... ...m...u...r...r
which there exists a positive integer $n$ .e. .p. .e.t.e.l.a.t.p.i.e.n.m.e. .o.
such that ... ..t...$... ... ...s...r... ...b...f..
Not Not
Let $p$ be the not not least not not prime Rectangle Perimeter
not not number for which there exists a Let $p$ be the least prime number for
... ....................................
....................................w
$...................................h
Opposites
Forbid $p$ be the most antiprime ...
defyn{let "most" mean "least", let "For Snake Horizontal
bid" mean "Let"}. → Let $p$ be the least prime number
...is indivisible by $pˆ{2}$. ← vitisop a stsixe ereht hcihw rof
Wrappers Snake Vertical
Let $3(p)$ be the least prime 2(number) Le t m b h i e p o n t s $ i
fordefyn{letwhich "3(p)"there existsmean "p",a ......let "7(p)" etbthsapurn er w hc er xi a si i eg $n uc ta nˆ $1s
mean "p"}. $eei r e s t e e $ h h { + d
...divisible by $7(p)ˆ{9(2)}$. $p lme f o t h t s i v r t 4 } i
Syntactic Distortions
Contextual Overload
Sentence Reversal
Line-Level
A> LetLet $ABCD$$p$ be bethea leasttetr ...... Findthat the$nˆ{4}+1$least positiveis divisibleintegerby $pˆ{2}$.$m$ such
ositive integer $n$ ... Let $p$ be the least prime number ...
Word Reversal
Word-level
$pˆ{2}$. by divisible is $mˆ{4}+1$ that
Let Let $p$ $ABCD$ be be the a least such $m$ integer positive least the Find
tetrahedron prime such number that ...
Symbol Reversal
Symbol-level teL $p$ eb eht tsael emirp rebmun rof
LLeett $$pA$B CbDe$ tbhee al etaest hcihw ereht stsixe a evitisop regetni $n$
tr aphreidmreo nn usmubcehr tfhoart ...
**----- End of picture text -----**
+yes
+(b) Is this investment for new construction or major retrofit of a Federal building or
+facility? (answer applicable to non-IT assets only)
+[1] If "yes," is an ESPC or UESC being used to help fund this investment?
+[2] If "yes," will this investment meet sustainable design principles?
+[3] If "yes," is it designed to be 30% more energy efficient than relevant code?
-Figure 2: Examples of the 13 structural transformations applied to a sample mathematical query. Target problems and lengthier text mappings have been truncated (...) for brevity.
+(13) Does this investment support one of the PMA initiatives? yes
-## **3 Adversarial Transformations and Context Pollution**
+If "yes," select all that apply:
+President's Management Agenda (PMA) Initiatives
+E x p a n d e d E - G o v e r n m e n t
-To evaluate the robustness of mathematical reasoning, we design 14 input perturbations, grouped into four broad categories. These transformations are strictly textual and deterministic; they are cognitively trivial for a human with pen, paper, and access to the decoding rules. Examples in Figure 2.
+Budget Performance Integration
-## **3.1 Semantic and Lexical Substitutions**
+a. Briefly describe how this asset directly supports the identified initiative(s)?
-This category challenges the model’s ability to maintain logical coherence when linguistic structures are obscured by aliasing or redundant operators. **Not Not:** We insert double negations (“not not”) prior to numerical values and adjectives. Because the double negation is logically equivalent to the original term, a robust reasoner should parse and discard these terms without altering its mathematical logic. **Opposites:** Semantic terms within the query are remapped to antonyms (e.g., “short” means “long”, “stop” means “goes”). **Wrappers:** Terms are encapsulated within arbitrary syntactic wrappers (e.g., replacing “morning” with “3(morning)”). All wrappers are strictly identity functions. For both **Opposites** and **Wrappers** , the specific localized substitutions are explicitly defined inside a of the user query. Solving these problems requires precise, localized key-value substitution.
+NSF's Enterprise Information System, the FAS and the Report web reporting system provide
+financial, budgetary, awards and performance information (including PART) that is accessible in
-4
+NSF FAS 1-3-07
-## **3.2 Contextual Overload and Saturation**
+2 of 18
-**Interleaved Contexts:** The text of two distinct math problems (Problem A and Problem B) is interwoven into a single prompt. The model is explicitly instructed to only solve Problem A. We evaluate three granularities of interleaving. **Line-level:** The statements are split into line segments of at most 60 symbols. Each segment is placed on a separate line, prefixed by a tag (e.g., `` ), and segments for two problems are strictly alternated. **Word-level:** The words of Problem A and Problem B are strictly alternated one by one. **Symbol-level:** The individual characters/symbols of the two problems are alternatingly interwoven. If one problem statement is shorter than the other, the remaining gaps are padded by repeating the shorter problem from its beginning.
+FY08 Exhibit 300
-**Context Saturation.** Distinct from algorithmic interleaving, context saturation investigates the impact of domain-specific noise on long-horizon reasoning. We prepend the question with synthetic mathematical questions paired with Chain-of-Thought reasoning trajectories generated by an open source model before asking the target non-transformed question.
+multiple formats at every workstation on a 24/7, real-time basis. Managers use this information to
+make decisions regarding NSF budget priorities and business processes. NSF's Statement of Net
+Cost uses the FAS to report the full cost of each strategic goal - Ideas, Tools, People and
+Stewardship.
-## **3.3 Syntactic Distortions**
+(14) Does this investment support a program assessed using OMB's
+Program Assessment Rating Tool (PART)?
+(a) If "yes," does this investment address a
+weakness found during a PART review?
+(b) If "yes," what is the name of the PARTed
+program ?
+(c) If "yes," what rating did the PART receive?
-Transformations in this category belong to “split-modify-join” paradigm. In these permutations, the text is partitioned based on a specific delimiter (e.g., spaces or periods), and either the order of the resulting tokens is reversed, or the sequence of symbols within each token is reversed. While this can be extended to arbitrary delimiters or multi-stage combinations, we focus on three foundational variants. **Sentence Reversal:** The order of sentences (defined as sequences of symbols separated by periods) in the user query has been reversed. **Word Reversal:** The order of words (words are defined as sequences of symbols separated by spaces) in user query has been reversed. **Symbol Reversal:** Every word (words defined as in Word Reversal above) in user query has its symbols in reverse order.
+no
-## **3.4 Visual and Spatial Encoding**
+(15) Is this investment for information technology? (see section 53 for definition)) yes
-This category tests the model’s character-level attention by mapping the 1D problem string onto a 2D visual grid. All transformed inputs in this category are bounded by `GRID START` and `GRID END` markers. We evaluate four distinct spatial transformations. **Rail Fence Cipher:** The symbols of the encoded string are placed in a zigzag pattern across multiple rails (rows), and empty spatial gaps are filled with dots ( `.` ) [50]. **Rectangle Perimeter:** User query is mapped onto the perimeter of a rectangle. The message is written as a single continuous string following the edges of the shape in a clockwise manner, beginning at the top-left. **Snake Vertical:** User query is written into a grid using a vertical ‘snake’ (zigzag) pattern. Starting from the top-left, the text is written down the first column, then up the second column, then down the third, etc... **Snake Horizontal:** The user query is written into a grid using a horizontal ‘snake’ (boustrophedon) pattern.
+If the answer to Question 15 was "Yes," complete questions 16-23 below. If
+the answer is "No," do not answer questions 16-23.
-## **4 Methodology and Results**
+Level 1
-## **4.1 Methodology**
+ (1) Project manager has been validated as qualified for this
+investment
-**Dataset Preprocessing and Sanitization** To ensure our evaluation strictly measures mathematical reasoning and avoid introducing low-level parsing or tokenizer artifacts, we apply a preprocessing pipeline to AIME 2024 [25]. String reversals can create executable escape sequences. For instance, if a variable is enclosed in escaped parentheses, e.g., `\(b\)` , character reversal yields `\)\b(\` . During string rendering, `\b` may be interpreted as a backspace, thereby silently deleting the preceding character. To eliminate information loss, we apply three preprocessing steps to all problem statements prior to transformation. For completeness, we apply these steps to the baseline as well. **LaTeX Comment Removal:** We strip all inline LaTeX comments. **Newline Flattening:** We replace all newline characters with a semicolon followed by a space ( `;` ). This preserves the logical segmentation of the text while preventing spatial layout anomalies that can confuse the model’s spatial attention during transformation reversal. **Escape Sequence Neutralization:** We systematically insert a space between backslashes and specific characters ( `n, t, b, r, a, f` ) to neutralize the accidental formation of control characters during string reversal. These sanitization steps are semantically invariant; they do not meaningfully alter the mathematical problem and are trivial for a human reader to parse and ignore.
+no
-5
+No
-**Transformation Design Principles** To ensure rigor, fairness, and consistency, every adversarial transformation adheres to four guidelines:
+(16) What is the level of the IT Project (per CIO
+Council PM Guidance)?
+(17) What project management qualifications does
+the Project Manager have? (per CIO Council PM
-- **Information-Theoretic Invariance:** The transformation cannot add extraneous mathematical constraints, remove necessary premises, or introduce lexical ambiguities that would change the difficulty of the problem.
+(18) Is this investment identified as "high risk" on
+the Q4 - FY 2006 agency high risk report
+(per OMB's 'high risk" memo)?
-- **Algorithmic Reversibility:** The transformation must be deterministic and programmatically invertible. We verify this by using Python reversal scripts for each transformation rule, confirming that original problem statement can be reconstructed without heuristics.
+(19) Is this a financial management system?
+(a) If "yes," does this investment address a FFMIA
+compliance area?
-- **Cognitive Tractability:** The transform must be simple enough that a human, equipped only with pen and paper, can decode the text and subsequently solve the mathematical problem without any degradation compared to their baseline accuracy.
+[1] If "yes," which compliance area:
+[2] If "no," what does it address?
-- **Explicit Decoding Protocol:** The exact transformation rule is provided in plain English to the model in user query. The model is explicitly instructed to execute a two-stage trajectory: first, programmatically decode the input to reconstruct the problem statement; second, execute mathematical reasoning to solve it.
+(b) If "yes," please identify the system name(s) and
+system acronym(s) as reported in the most recent
+financial systems inventory update required by
+Circular A-11 section 52:
-- **Grid Padding and Alignment:** For all visual and spatial encodings, we ensure that character spacing is strictly preserved by substituting blank spaces with explicit dots ( `.` ) or padding the grid dimensions perfectly. This ensures that when the LLM’s tokenizer parses the grid, the geometric alignment (e.g., columns in the vertical snake, or edges in the rectangle) remains structurally intact.
+(20) What is the percentage breakout for the total FY2008 funding request for the following?
+(This should total 100%)
-All models are supplied with standard chain-of-thought system prompt: "You are a helpful math assistant. Please reason step by step, and put your final answer within `\\boxed{}` ." To disentangle perturbation decoding from reasoning failures, we perform sequential cognitive overload experiment, where we ask the model to solve a set of problems within a single query and record the accuracy only on the last problem. For sequential cognitive overload, we additionally prompt the model in user query with "Solve these completely unrelated math problems. For each problem put your final answer within `\\boxed{}` ".
+Hardware %:
+0
-**Context Saturation Protocol** For our contextual overload experiments, we construct input contexts by simulating multi-turn mathematical problem-solving sessions. To ensure the distractors are domainrelevant, we use synthetically generated math questions paired with chain-of-thought solutions generated by the `tiiuae/Falcon-H1R-7B` [45]. Prior to injection, we sanitize these distractor trajectories by stripping their internal `` tokens. This domain-specific noise occupies 75% of each target model’s maximum context window (e.g., up to 750K tokens for three frontier models). For closed-source APIs, we leverage provider-native context caching mechanisms to execute these high-volume evaluations [4, 8, 34]. This domain specific noise is generated once and reused across all models.
+Software %:
+0
-**Evaluation Metrics** We evaluate the robustness of each model using two primary metrics. **ProblemSolving Accuracy:** The percentage of final mathematical answers evaluated as strictly correct (extracted via the `\boxed{}` format using `math_verify` [9] package). When evaluating the baseline, we report max token cutoffs as failures, except for sequential cognitive overload where we count max token cutoffs as successes since it can be argued that the model is still reasoning about the last problem when it hits the max token limit. For sequential cognitive overload, we search through all `\boxed{}` blocks and count the sample as correct if any of them match the ground truth of the target problem, in case the model outputs answers out of order. **Reasoning Efficiency:** The token consumption required by the model to reach a final solution, serving as a proxy for the computational friction introduced by the adversarial transformations. Discussion of Reasoning Efficiency is deferred to the Appendix A.3.
+Services %:
+100
-**Models and Experimental Scope** Our evaluation encompasses a suite of eight state-of-the-art models, comprising five open-source weights and three proprietary APIs. The open-source models: `Qwen/Qwen3-30B-A3B-Thinking-2507` [36], `nvidia/OpenReasoning-Nemotron-7B` [31], `nvidia/OpenReasoning-Nemotron-32B` [30], `DeepSeek-R1-Distill-70B` [7] (DSR1-Llama70B), and `openai/gpt-oss-120b` [32]. The closed-source models are Gemini 3.1 Pro [11], GPT5.4 [33], and Claude 4.6 Opus [3]. All experiments are conducted on AIME 2024 dataset [25]. We sample 8 zero-shot trajectories per problem for the proprietary models, and 16 zero-shot trajectories for open-source models. The only exception is context saturation, where we sample 8 zero-shot trajectories per problem for all problems. GPT-5.4 was used with _high_ reasoning effort setting
+Other %:
-6
+0
-throughout. For experiments with perturbations, temperature for all models was set to 0.7, _top_ p_ to 1.0, and _max_ tokens_ to 32000. For sequential cognitive overload, temperature was set to 0.6, _top_ p_ to 0.95, and _max_ tokens_ as follows: Qwen3-30B-A3B: 81920, Nemotron-7B: 65536, Nemotron32B: 65536, DSR1-Llama-70B: 65536, gpt-oss-120b: 128000. When evaluating sequential cognitive overload on proprietary models, due to high computational cost, we sampled only the baseline and 4 sequential problems.
+Total %
+100
-## **4.2 Results and Discussion**
+(21) If this project produces information dissemination products for the public, are these products
+published to the Internet in conformance with OMB Memorandum 05-04 and included in your
+agency inventory, schedules and priorities?
+n/a
-We evaluate mathematical reasoning robustness across a total of 15 transformations. Our results expose fragility in modern mathematical reasoning models, particularly within open-weights.
+NSF FAS 1-3-07
-**==> picture [390 x 466] intentionally omitted <==**
+3 of 18
-**----- Start of picture text -----**
-Gemini 3.1 Pro GPT-5.4
100 99 98 96 97 97 96 95 [98] [98] 95 97 99 100 96 95 92 96 95 91 96 95 94 95 87 [94]
80 62 62 65 80 70 [77] 72
60 60
40 40
20 20
0 0
Claude Opus 4.6 GPT-OSS-120B
100 99 97 92 97 98 90 99 96 100
80 80 78 69 69 70 78 74
63
60 51 60 53 50
39 40
40 32 32 40
26
20 3 2 8 3 20 1 0 11
0 0
Qwen3-30B-A3B Nemotron-32B
100 89 100
80 82 78 68 77 74 [80] 80 81 77 77 70 77 78 [82]
60 60 53
48
40 25 35 40 29
20 16 20 16 14
0 0 4 1 0 0 6 0
0 0
Nemotron-7B DSR1-Llama-70B
100 100
80 77 78 80
67 66
60 59 43 60 57 53 44 54 48
40 33 40
22
20 5 0 8 13 0 0 0 0 0 20 14 0 0 5 0 0 0 1
0 0
BaselineNot-NotOppositesWrappersInterleave-LInterleave-WInterleave-SSentence-RevContextWord-RevSplit-RevRail FenceRectangleSnake-VSnake-H BaselineNot-NotOppositesWrappersInterleave-LInterleave-WInterleave-SSentence-RevContextWord-RevSplit-RevRail FenceRectangleSnake-VSnake-H
BaselineNot-NotOppositesWrappersInterleave-LInterleave-WInterleave-SSentence-RevContextWord-RevSplit-RevRail FenceRectangleSnake-VSnake-H BaselineNot-NotOppositesWrappersInterleave-LInterleave-WInterleave-SSentence-RevContextWord-RevSplit-RevRail FenceRectangleSnake-VSnake-H
BaselineNot-NotOppositesWrappersInterleave-LInterleave-WInterleave-SSentence-RevContextWord-RevSplit-RevRail FenceRectangleSnake-VSnake-H BaselineNot-NotOppositesWrappersInterleave-LInterleave-WInterleave-SSentence-RevContextWord-RevSplit-RevRail FenceRectangleSnake-VSnake-H
BaselineNot-NotOppositesWrappersInterleave-LInterleave-WInterleave-SSentence-RevContextWord-RevSplit-RevRail FenceRectangleSnake-VSnake-H BaselineNot-NotOppositesWrappersInterleave-LInterleave-WInterleave-SSentence-RevContextWord-RevSplit-RevRail FenceRectangleSnake-VSnake-H
Accuracy (%) Accuracy (%)
Accuracy (%) Accuracy (%)
Accuracy (%) Accuracy (%)
Accuracy (%) Accuracy (%)
**----- End of picture text -----**
+FY08 Exhibit 300
+(22) Contact information of individual responsible for privacy related questions:
-Figure 3: Full bars represent Achieved Accuracy on the AIME 2024 benchmark modified with our perturbations. Semi-transparent segments indicate model refusals or failed answers.
+Name:
+Phone
+Number:
+Title:
+E-Mail:
-7
+Leslie A. Jensen
-**==> picture [390 x 175] intentionally omitted <==**
+703-292-8060
-**----- Start of picture text -----**
-Gemini 3.1 Pro GPT-5.4 Claude Opus 4.6 GPT-OSS-120B
Syntactic80 Syntactic80 Syntactic80 Syntactic80
60 60 60 60
40 40 40 40
20 20 20 20
Semantic Semantic Semantic Semantic
Contextual Contextual Contextual Contextual
Visual Visual Visual Visual
Qwen3-30B-A3B Nemotron-32B Nemotron-7B DSR1-Llama-70B
Syntactic80 Syntactic80 Syntactic80 Syntactic80
60 60 60 60
40 40 40 40
20 20 20 20
Semantic Semantic Semantic Semantic
Contextual Contextual Contextual Contextual
Visual Visual Visual Visual
**----- End of picture text -----**
+NSF FOIA/Privacy Act Officer
+Ijensen@nsf.gov
-Figure 4: Vulnerability Profiling: Average accuracy on transformations from each of the 4 categories by model.
+(23) Are the records produced by this investment appropriately scheduled with the National
+Archives and Records Administration's approval? no
-## **4.2.1 Robustness Against Perturbations: Frontier vs. Open-Weights Models.**
+Section B: Summary of Funding (All Capital Assets)
+(1) Provide the total estimated life-cycle cost for this investment by completing the following table.
+All amounts represent budget authority in millions, and are rounded to three decimal places.
+Federal personnel costs should be included only in the row designated "Government FTE Cost,"
+and should be excluded from the amounts shown for "Planning," "Full Acquisition," and
+"Operation/Maintenance." The total estimated annual cost of the investment is the sum of costs for
+"Planning," "Full Acquisition," and "Operation/Maintenance." For Federal buildings and facilities,
+life-cycle costs should include long term energy, environmental, decommissioning, and/or
+restoration costs. The costs associated with the entire life-cycle of the investment should be
+included in this report.
-Our macro-level evaluation reveals a stark divergence in architectural resilience towards textual perturbations, visualized in the Average Accuracy Drop (Figure 5) and Achieved Accuracy (Figure 3). State-of-the-art proprietary models exhibit remarkable robustness to structural noise; GPT-5.4 and Gemini 3.1 Pro suffer average performance degradations of only 7% and 10%, respectively. In contrast, the open-weights ecosystem experiences substantial reasoning degradation. Despite demonstrating strong baseline accuracy on the AIME 2024 dataset, models such as Nemotron-7B and Qwen3-30B-A3B-Thinking-2507 suffer average accuracy drops of 55% and 47%, respectively.
+Table 1: SUMMARY OF SPENDING FOR PROJECT PHASES (REPORTED IN MILLIONS)
+All amounts represent Budget Authority (Estimates for BY+1 and beyond are for planning purposes only and do not
+represent budget decisions)
-This “robustness gap” indicates that while current open-weights architectures and RL paradigms can memorize and execute standard mathematical heuristics, their reasoning pathways are overfit to standard textual formatting and sequential presentation. By disaggregating performance into transformation categories (Figure 4), we can pinpoint the exact mechanical failures of these models. Semantic substitutions are handled relatively well across the board. However, open-weights models universally degrade on **Syntactic Distortions** and **Visual Encodings** . Transformations that break words down into isolated characters, such as _Interleave (Symbol)_ and _Rail Fence Cipher_ , strongly affect Byte-Pair Encoding (BPE) boundaries. Consequently, models like Qwen3 and DSR1 drop to 0% accuracy on these tasks. This shows that their general reasoning is bottlenecked by subword semantic priors; they cannot map isolated character tokens back into a coherent internal causal graph. Our 2D spatial mappings show the inherent autoregressive bias of standard Transformers. When presented with the _Snake (Horizontal)_ task, Gemini 3.1 Pro scores 98%, and Qwen3 scores 16%. However, when the exact same text is mapped vertically ( _Snake (Vertical)_ ), Gemini drops to 65%, and Qwen3 drops to near 1%. This suggests that even when explicitly prompted to perform simple spatial grid algorithmic tasks, LLMs are fundamentally constrained by their left-to-right, 1D pre-training biases.
+PY-1
+Spending
+Prior to 2006
-**The Alignment Issues** While closed-source models generally excel, Claude Opus 4-6 presents a striking anomaly, suffering a 41.7% average accuracy drop. A review of the data reveals that this drop is not due to reasoning failure, but rather a disproportionate rate of model refusals (indicated by the semi-transparent upper segments of the bar charts in Figure 3). Claude categorically refuses to process the vast majority of the prompts involving symbol manipulation. We hypothesize that this is an artifact of its safety filters, which aggressively flag abstract symbol manipulation as prompt injection or jailbreak attempts. This highlights an unintended consequence of current alignment strategies that penalize abstract, character-level reasoning by misclassifying textually complex inputs as adversarial attacks.
+BY +1 BY+2 2010
+2009
-8
+2011
-**==> picture [175 x 103] intentionally omitted <==**
+Total
-**----- Start of picture text -----**
-60 55
50 45 47
40 40 42
32
30
20
10 7 10
0GPT-5.4Gemini 3.1 ProGPT-OSS-120BNemotron-32BClaude Opus 4.6DSR1-Llama-70BQwen3-30B-A3BNemotron-7B
Avg Accuracy Drop (%)
**----- End of picture text -----**
+BY+4
+2012 and
+beyond
+Planning
-Figure 5: Average Accuracy Drop across all models and transformations.
+Acquisition
+Subtotal
+Planning &
+Acquisition
+Operations
-**==> picture [199 x 111] intentionally omitted <==**
+$0.000
-**----- Start of picture text -----**
-100
-0.4%
90 -1.2%
80 -13.8% -6.7% -7.1%
70 -7.1%
-10.6%
60
-7.1%
50 1 4 1 4 1 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 1 2 3 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3
Gemini 3.1 Pro gpt-5.4 Claude Opus 4.6Qwen3-30B-A3BNemotron-32BNemotron-7BGPT-OSS-120BDSR1-Llama-70B
Accuracy on Last Problem (%)
**----- End of picture text -----**
+$0.000
+$0.000
+$0.000
-Figure 6: Mathematical accuracy on last problem in sequential overload. Number of problems asked is shown as a sequence on the x-axis. Total accuracy drop from baseline is shown in red.
+$0.000
+$0.000
-## **4.2.2 Intra-Query Context Management**
+$0.000
-It is well-established in the literature that long-horizon, multi-turn agentic workflows suffer from attention drift, necessitating explicit state management to maintain coherence. However, our findings suggest that this phenomenon is not restricted to macro-level agentic interactions; it is a fundamental architectural bottleneck that degrades reasoning _within a single query_ . Complex mathematical problems, much like real-world tasks, require multi-step, sequential reasoning. As models become more capable, they are used for ever more complex multi-step tasks. Figure 6 illustrates that the cognitive load of prior reasoning steps negatively affects the model’s reasoning ability. All evaluated open-weights models ranging from 7B parameters to 120B parameters experience this degradation in performance. This suggests that single-turn attention dilution is a fundamental limitation of the standard dense attention mechanism, which forces subsequent reasoning steps to unconditionally attend to prior ones.
+$0.000
+$0.000
-Recent community leaks [46] and artifacts observed during the development of this project (Appendix A.5) reveal that proprietary agent frameworks, such as Google’s AntiGravity [10], utilize explicit scaffolding like the `` . This strongly suggests the industry is aware of long context attention drift and likely attempts to mitigate it by enforcing context management for long-horizon, multi-turn tasks. Building on our empirical evidence of intra-query attention dilution, we argue that these same principles must be applied at the micro-level. To achieve reliable algorithmic reasoning, future architectures require mechanisms for _micro-context isolation_ - allowing the model to explicitly summarize state and flush the noisy “scratchpad” of previous intermediate steps, effectively resetting its attention focus within a single Chain-of-Thought. This raises fundamental open research questions about optimal granularity of reasoning tasks, which we discuss in Appendix A.4.
+$0.000
-## **5 Conclusion**
+$0.000
+$0.000
-In this work we demonstrate that current LLMs suffer from mathematical reasoning fragility, revealing that their reasoning prowess is often overfit to standard textual presentation rather than abstract logical manipulation. By decoupling deterministic mechanical deciphering from downstream mathematical reasoning, we identify intra-query attention dilution. We empirically show that this reasoning degradation is present in open weight models from 7B to 120B parameters, demonstrating that intermediate reasoning steps pollute the context window. Our findings, corroborated by artifacts leaked from proprietary agentic frameworks, suggest that standard dense attention mechanisms are inherently insufficient for robust algorithmic reasoning because they fail to isolate working memory between sequential reasoning steps _inside a single forward pass_ . In this work we argue that achieving reliable multi-step deduction requires the integration of native contextual resets and task-boundary compartmentalization to flush intermediate states and preserve logical coherence.
+$7.570
-9
+$1.500
-## **Acknowledgments**
+$1.500
-We gratefully acknowledge Vector Institute and Compute Canada Alliance for providing the computational resources required for this study on their Killarney cluster.
+$1.120
-## **References**
+TOTAL
-- [1] Khashayar Alavi, Zhastay Yeltay, Lucie Flek, and Akbar Karimi. More agents helps but adversarial robustness gap persists, 2025. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2511.07112` .
+$7.570
-- [2] Ujjwala Anantheswaran, Himanshu Gupta, Kevin Scaria, Shreyas Verma, Chitta Baral, and Swaroop Mishra. Cutting through the noise: Boosting llm performance on math word problems, 2025. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15444` .
+$1.500
-- [3] Anthropic. The claude 4.6 model family. Technical report, Anthropic, 2026. URL `https: //www.anthropic.com/news/claude-opus-4-6` .
+$1.500
-- [4] Google Gemini API. Prompt caching, 2026. URL `https://ai.google.dev/gemini-api/ docs/caching` .
+$1.120
-- [5] Ashwath Vaithinathan Aravindan and Mayank Kejriwal. Fragile thoughts: How large language models handle chain-of-thought perturbations, 2026. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2603. 03332` .
+Government FTE Costs
+should not be included
+th
-- [6] Karl Cobbe, Vineet Kosaraju, Mohammad Bavarian, Mark Chen, Heewoo Jun, Lukasz Kaiser, Matthias Plappert, Jerry Tworek, Jacob Hilton, Reiichiro Nakano, Christopher Hesse, and John Schulman. Training verifiers to solve math word problems, 2021. URL `https://arxiv.org/ abs/2110.14168` .
+i
-- [7] DeepSeek-AI. Deepseek-r1-distill-llama-70b, January 2025. URL `https://huggingface. co/deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-R1-Distill-Llama-70B` .
+t
-- [8] Claude API Docs. Prompt caching, 2026. URL `https://platform.claude.com/docs/en/ build-with-claude/prompt-caching` .
+provided
+above.
-- [9] Hugging Face. Math verify, 2026. URL `https://pypi.org/project/math-verify/` .
+$0.360
-- [10] Google. Google antigravity, 2026. URL `https://antigravity.google/` .
+$0.360
-- [11] Google DeepMind. Gemini 3.1: Advancing the state of the art in multimodal reasoning. Technical report, Google, 2026. URL `https://blog.google/innovation-and-ai/ models-and-research/gemini-models/gemini-3-1-pro/` .
+$0.360
-- [12] Yuren Hao, Xiang Wan, and ChengXiang Zhai. An investigation of robustness of llms in mathematical reasoning: Benchmarking with mathematically-equivalent transformation of advanced mathematical problems, 2025. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2508.08833` .
+$1.800
-- [13] Dan Hendrycks, Collin Burns, Saurav Kadavath, Akul Arora, Steven Basart, Eric Tang, Dawn Song, and Jacob Steinhardt. Measuring mathematical problem solving with the math dataset. In _Proceedings of the Neural Information Processing Systems Track on Datasets and Benchmarks_ , 2021. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2103.03874` .
+Government
+FTE Costs
+Number of
+FTE
+represented
+by cost
+Note: For the cross-agency investments, this table should include all funding (both managing partner
+and partner agencies). Government FTE Costs should not be included as part of the TOTAL
+represented.
-- [14] Pengfei Hong, Navonil Majumder, Deepanway Ghosal, Somak Aditya, Rada Mihalcea, and Soujanya Poria. Evaluating LLMs’ mathematical and coding competency through ontologyguided interventions. In _Findings of the Association for Computational Linguistics: ACL 2025_ , pages 22811–22849, Vienna, Austria, jul 2025. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/2025.findings-acl.1172. URL `https://aclanthology.org/2025. findings-acl.1172` .
+NSF FAS 1-3-07
-- [15] Yutao Hou, Zeguan Xiao, Fei Yu, Yihan Jiang, Xuetao Wei, Hailiang Huang, Yun Chen, and Guanhua Chen. Automatic robustness stress testing of llms as mathematical problem solvers, 2025. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2506.05038` .
+4 of 18
-10
+FY08 Exhibit 300
-- [16] Kaixuan Huang, Jiacheng Guo, Zihao Li, Xiang Ji, Jiawei Ge, Wenzhe Li, Yingqing Guo, Tianle Cai, Hui Yuan, Runzhe Wang, Yue Wu, Ming Yin, Shange Tang, Yangsibo Huang, Chi Jin, Xinyun Chen, Chiyuan Zhang, and Mengdi Wang. Math-perturb: Benchmarking llms’ math reasoning abilities against hard perturbations. In _Forty-second International Conference on Machine Learning (ICML)_ , 2025. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2502.06453` .
+(2) Will this project require the agency to hire additional FTE's? no
-- [17] Takuya Ito, Murray Campbell, Lior Horesh, Tim Klinger, and Parikshit Ram. Quantifying artificial intelligence through algorithmic generalization. In _Nature Machine Intelligence_ , 2025. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2411.05943` .
+(a) If "yes," How many and in what year?
-- [18] Bowen Jiang, Yangxinyu Xie, Zhuoqun Hao, Xiaomeng Wang, Tanwi Mallick, Weijie J. Su, Camillo Jose Taylor, and Dan Roth. A peek into token bias: Large language models are not yet genuine reasoners. In _Proceedings of the 2024 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing (EMNLP)_ , pages 4722–4756, Miami, Florida, USA, nov 2024. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/2024.emnlp-main.272. URL `https://aclanthology.org/2024.emnlp-main.272` .
+(3) If the summary of spending has changed from the FY2007 President's budget request, briefly
+explain those changes.
-- [19] Ming Jiang, Tingting Huang, Biao Guo, Yao Lu, and Feng Zhang. Enhancing robustness in large language models: Prompting for mitigating the impact of irrelevant information, 2025. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2408.10615` .
+Section C: Acquisition/Contract Strategy (All Capital Assets)
-- [20] Daniel Kahneman. _Thinking, fast and slow_ . Farrar, Straus and Giroux, New York, 2011. ISBN 9780374275631 0374275637. URL `https://mlsu.ac.in/econtents/2950_Daniel% 20Kahneman%20-%20Thinking,%20Fast%20and%20Slow%20(2013).pdf` .
+(1) Complete the table for all contracts and/or task orders in place or planned for this investment:
-- [21] Aabid Karim, Abdul Karim, Bhoomika Lohana, Matt Keon, Jaswinder Singh, and Abdul Sattar. Lost in cultural translation: Do llms struggle with math across cultural contexts?, 2025. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2503.18018` .
+Contract or Task Order Number: BZ-11/0533982 Type of Contract/TO Used: Cost Plus Fixed Fee
+Has the Contract Being Awarded: yes
+Contract Actual/Planned Award Date:
+05/01/2005
+Contract/TO Start Date:
+05/01/2005
+Contract/TO End Date:
+04/30/2007
+Contract/TO Total Value ($M): $32.200 Inter Agency Acquisition: no
+Performance Based Contract: yes
+Competitively Awarded Contract: yes
+Alternative Financing: NA EVM Required: yes
+Security Privacy Clause: yes
-- [22] Neeraja Kirtane, Yuvraj Khanna, and Peter Relan. Mathrobust-lv: Evaluation of large language models’ robustness to linguistic variations in mathematical reasoning, 2025. URL `https: //arxiv.org/abs/2510.06430` .
+Contracting Officer (CO) Contact Information:
-- [23] Qintong Li, Leyang Cui, Xueliang Zhao, Lingpeng Kong, and Wei Bi. GSM-plus: A comprehensive benchmark for evaluating the robustness of LLMs as mathematical problem solvers. In _Proceedings of the 62nd Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics (Volume 1: Long Papers)_ , pages 2961–2984, Bangkok, Thailand, aug 2024. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/2024.acl-long.163. URL `https://aclanthology.org/2024.acl-long.163` .
+CO Name: Patricia S. Williams
+CO Contact Information (Phone/Email): (703) 292-8240 pswillia@nsf.gov
+CO Certification Level (Level 1, 2, 3, N/A): 3
+If N/A has the agency determined the CO assigned has the competencies and skills necessary to
+support this acquisition? (Y/N)
-- [24] Xinyuan Li, Murong Xu, Wenbiao Tao, Hanlun Zhu, Yike Zhao, Jipeng Zhang, and Yunshi Lan. Ride: Difficulty evolving perturbation with item response theory for mathematical reasoning, 2026. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2511.04120` .
+(2) If earned value is not required or will not be a contract requirement for any of the contracts or
-- [25] Mathematical Association of America. Aime 2024 dataset, 2024. URL `https:// huggingface.co/datasets/HuggingFaceH4/aime_2024` .
+task orders above, explain why:
-- [26] R. Thomas McCoy, Shunyu Yao, Dan Friedman, Matthew Hardy, and Thomas L. Griffiths. Embers of autoregression: Understanding large language models through the problem they are trained to solve. In _Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS)_ , 2023. doi: 10. 1073/pnas.2322420121. URL `https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2322420121` .
+The contract has a requirement to utilize earned value management (EVM) for tasks/projects designated as
+new development or "Development/Modernization/Enhancements (DME)." FAS is in Steady State and its
+maintenance activities are exempt from EVM at this time per OMB Guidance.
-- [27] Iman Mirzadeh, Keivan Alizadeh, Hooman Shahrokhi, Oncel Tuzel, Samy Bengio, and Mehrdad Farajtabar. Gsm-symbolic: Understanding the limitations of mathematical reasoning in large language models. In _The Thirteenth International Conference on Learning Representations (ICLR)_ , 2025. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2410.05229` .
+(3) Do the contracts ensure Section 508 compliance? yes
+Section 508 Compliance Explanation:
+The system was reviewed and modified, as needed, in 2001 for Section 508 compliance. The FAS consists of an
+end-user GUI and back-end software programs. Only the end-user GUI is used by users; therefore only changes
+to it would affect Section 508 compliance. While the majority of maintenance changes are to the back-end
+software, when the GUI is affected, NSF staff review each maintenance change for Section 508 compliance
+before the change is implemented.
-- [28] Allen Newell and Herbert A. Simon. Computer science as empirical inquiry: symbols and search. _Commun. ACM_ , 19(3), March 1976. ISSN 0001-0782. doi: 10.1145/360018.360022. URL `https://doi.org/10.1145/360018.360022` .
+NSF FAS 1-3-07
-- [29] Marianna Nezhurina, Lucia Cipolina-Kun, Mehdi Cherti, and Jenia Jitsev. Alice in wonderland: Simple tasks showing complete reasoning breakdown in state-of-the-art large language models, 2025. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02061` .
+5 of 18
-11
+FY08 Exhibit 300
-- [30] NVIDIA. Openreasoning-nemotron-32b, 2025. URL `https://huggingface.co/nvidia/ OpenReasoning-Nemotron-32B` .
+(4) Is there an acquisition plan which has been approved in accordance with agency requirements?
-- [31] NVIDIA. Openreasoning-nemotron-7b, 2025. URL `https://huggingface.co/nvidia/ OpenReasoning-Nemotron-7B` .
+yes
-- [32] OpenAI. gpt-oss-120b, 2025. URL `https://huggingface.co/openai/gpt-oss-120b` .
+(a) If "yes", what is the date?
+12/01/2001
+(b) If "no," will an acquisition plan be developed?
-- [33] OpenAI. Gpt-5.4 technical report. Technical report, OpenAI, 2026. URL `https://openai. com/index/introducing-gpt-5-4/` .
+[1] If "no," briefly explain why:
-- [34] OpenAI. Prompt caching, 2026. URL `https://openai.com/index/ api-prompt-caching/` .
+Section D: Performance Information (All Capital Assets)
-- [35] Kun Qian, Shunji Wan, Claudia Tang, Youzhi Wang, Xuanming Zhang, Maximillian Chen, and Zhou Yu. VarBench: Robust language model benchmarking through dynamic variable perturbation. In _Findings of the Association for Computational Linguistics: EMNLP 2024_ , pages 16131–16161, Miami, Florida, USA, nov 2024. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/2024.findings-emnlp.946. URL `https://aclanthology.org/2024. findings-emnlp.946` .
+In order to successfully address this area of the exhibit 300, performance goals must be provided for the
+agency and be linked to the annual performance plan. The investment must discuss the agency's mission and
+strategic goals, and performance measures must be provided. These goals need to map to the gap in the
+agency's strategic goals and objectives this investment is designed to fill. They are the internal and external
+performance benefits this investment is expected to deliver to the agency (e.g., improve efficiency by 60
+percent, increase citizen participation by 300 percent a year to achieve an overall citizen participation rate of
+75 percent by FY 2xxx, etc.). The goals must be clearly measurable investment outcomes, and if applicable,
+investment outputs. They do not include the completion date of the module, milestones, or investment, or
+general goals, such as, significant, better, improved that do not have a quantitative or qualitative measure.
-- [36] Qwen Team. Qwen3: The next generation of qwen large language models, 2026. URL `https://huggingface.co/Qwen/Qwen3-30B-A3B-Thinking-2507` .
+Agencies must use Table 1 below for reporting performance goals and measures for all non-IT investments
+and for existing IT investments that were initiated prior to FY 2005. The table can be extended to include
+measures for years beyond FY 2006.
-- [37] Nikolaus Salvatore, Hao Wang, and Qiong Zhang. Lost in the middle: An emergent property from information retrieval demands in llms, 2025. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2510. 10276` .
+Table 1
-- [38] Michael Shalyt, Rotem Elimelech, and Ido Kaminer. Asymob: Algebraic symbolic mathematical operations benchmark, 2025. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2505.23851` .
+Fiscal Year
-- [39] Freda Shi, Xinyun Chen, Kanishka Misra, Nathan Scales, David Dohan, Ed H. Chi, Nathanael Schärli, and Denny Zhou. Large language models can be easily distracted by irrelevant context. In _Proceedings of the 40th International Conference on Machine Learning (ICML)_ , pages 31210–31227, 2023. URL `https://proceedings.mlr.press/v202/shi23a.html` .
+Strategic
-- [40] Parshin Shojaee, Iman Mirzadeh, Keivan Alizadeh, Maxwell Horton, Samy Bengio, and Mehrdad Farajtabar. The illusion of thinking: Understanding the strengths and limitations of reasoning models via the lens of problem complexity, 2025. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/ 2506.06941` .
+Goal(s)
+Supported
-- [41] Saurabh Srivastava, Annarose M B, Anto P V, Shashank Menon, Ajay Sukumar, Adwaith Samod T, Alan Philipose, Stevin Prince, and Sooraj Thomas. Functional benchmarks for robust evaluation of reasoning performance, and the reasoning gap, 2024. URL `https://arxiv. org/abs/2402.19450` .
+2003
-- [42] Zhishen Sun, Guang Dai, Ivor Tsang, and Haishan Ye. Numerical sensitivity and robustness: Exploring the flaws of mathematical reasoning in large language models, 2025. URL `https: //arxiv.org/abs/2511.08022` .
+2003
-- [43] Zhishen Sun, Guang Dai, and Haishan Ye. Mscr: Exploring the vulnerability of llms’ mathematical reasoning abilities using multi-source candidate replacement, 2025. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2511.08055` .
+2003
-- [44] Kimi Team, Tongtong Bai, Yifan Bai, Yiping Bao, S. H. Cai, Yuan Cao, Y. Charles, H. S. Che, Cheng Chen, Guanduo Chen, Huarong Chen, Jia Chen, Jiahao Chen, Jianlong Chen, Jun Chen, Kefan Chen, Liang Chen, Ruijue Chen, Xinhao Chen, Yanru Chen, Yanxu Chen, Yicun Chen, Yimin Chen, Yingjiang Chen, Yuankun Chen, Yujie Chen, Yutian Chen, Zhirong Chen, Ziwei Chen, Dazhi Cheng, Minghan Chu, Jialei Cui, Jiaqi Deng, Muxi Diao, Hao Ding, Mengfan Dong, Mengnan Dong, Yuxin Dong, Yuhao Dong, Angang Du, Chenzhuang Du, Dikang Du, Lingxiao Du, Yulun Du, Yu Fan, Shengjun Fang, Qiulin Feng, Yichen Feng, Garimugai Fu, Kelin Fu, Hongcheng Gao, Tong Gao, Yuyao Ge, Shangyi Geng, Chengyang Gong, Xiaochen Gong, Zhuoma Gongque, Qizheng Gu, Xinran Gu, Yicheng Gu, Longyu Guan, Yuanying Guo,
+2003
-12
+2004
-Xiaoru Hao, Weiran He, Wenyang He, Yunjia He, Chao Hong, Hao Hu, Jiaxi Hu, Yangyang Hu, Zhenxing Hu, Ke Huang, Ruiyuan Huang, Weixiao Huang, Zhiqi Huang, Tao Jiang, Zhejun Jiang, Xinyi Jin, Yu Jing, Guokun Lai, Aidi Li, C. Li, Cheng Li, Fang Li, Guanghe Li, Guanyu Li, Haitao Li, Haoyang Li, Jia Li, Jingwei Li, Junxiong Li, Lincan Li, Mo Li, Weihong Li, Wentao Li, Xinhang Li, Xinhao Li, Yang Li, Yanhao Li, Yiwei Li, Yuxiao Li, Zhaowei Li, Zheming Li, Weilong Liao, Jiawei Lin, Xiaohan Lin, Zhishan Lin, Zichao Lin, Cheng Liu, Chenyu Liu, Hongzhang Liu, Liang Liu, Shaowei Liu, Shudong Liu, Shuran Liu, Tianwei Liu, Tianyu Liu, Weizhou Liu, Xiangyan Liu, Yangyang Liu, Yanming Liu, Yibo Liu, Yuanxin Liu, Yue Liu, Zhengying Liu, Zhongnuo Liu, Enzhe Lu, Haoyu Lu, Zhiyuan Lu, Junyu Luo, Tongxu Luo, Yashuo Luo, Long Ma, Yingwei Ma, Shaoguang Mao, Yuan Mei, Xin Men, Fanqing Meng, Zhiyong Meng, Yibo Miao, Minqing Ni, Kun Ouyang, Siyuan Pan, Bo Pang, Yuchao Qian, Ruoyu Qin, Zeyu Qin, Jiezhong Qiu, Bowen Qu, Zeyu Shang, Youbo Shao, Tianxiao Shen, Zhennan Shen, Juanfeng Shi, Lidong Shi, Shengyuan Shi, Feifan Song, Pengwei Song, Tianhui Song, Xiaoxi Song, Hongjin Su, Jianlin Su, Zhaochen Su, Lin Sui, Jinsong Sun, Junyao Sun, Tongyu Sun, Flood Sung, Yunpeng Tai, Chuning Tang, Heyi Tang, Xiaojuan Tang, Zhengyang Tang, Jiawen Tao, Shiyuan Teng, Chaoran Tian, Pengfei Tian, Ao Wang, Bowen Wang, Chensi Wang, Chuang Wang, Congcong Wang, Dingkun Wang, Dinglu Wang, Dongliang Wang, Feng Wang, Hailong Wang, Haiming Wang, Hengzhi Wang, Huaqing Wang, Hui Wang, Jiahao Wang, Jinhong Wang, Jiuzheng Wang, Kaixin Wang, Linian Wang, Qibin Wang, Shengjie Wang, Shuyi Wang, Si Wang, Wei Wang, Xiaochen Wang, Xinyuan Wang, Yao Wang, Yejie Wang, Yipu Wang, Yiqin Wang, Yucheng Wang, Yuzhi Wang, Zhaoji Wang, Zhaowei Wang, Zhengtao Wang, Zhexu Wang, Zihan Wang, Zizhe Wang, Chu Wei, Ming Wei, Chuan Wen, Zichen Wen, Chengjie Wu, Haoning Wu, Junyan Wu, Rucong Wu, Wenhao Wu, Yuefeng Wu, Yuhao Wu, Yuxin Wu, Zijian Wu, Chenjun Xiao, Jin Xie, Xiaotong Xie, Yuchong Xie, Yifei Xin, Bowei Xing, Boyu Xu, Jianfan Xu, Jing Xu, Jinjing Xu, L. H. Xu, Lin Xu, Suting Xu, Weixin Xu, Xinbo Xu, Xinran Xu, Yangchuan Xu, Yichang Xu, Yuemeng Xu, Zelai Xu, Ziyao Xu, Junjie Yan, Yuzi Yan, Guangyao Yang, Hao Yang, Junwei Yang, Kai Yang, Ningyuan Yang, Ruihan Yang, Xiaofei Yang, Xinlong Yang, Ying Yang, Yi Yang, Yi Yang, Zhen Yang, Zhilin Yang, Zonghan Yang, Haotian Yao, Dan Ye, Wenjie Ye, Zhuorui Ye, Bohong Yin, Chengzhen Yu, Longhui Yu, Tao Yu, Tianxiang Yu, Enming Yuan, Mengjie Yuan, Xiaokun Yuan, Yang Yue, Weihao Zeng, Dunyuan Zha, Haobing Zhan, Dehao Zhang, Hao Zhang, Jin Zhang, Puqi Zhang, Qiao Zhang, Rui Zhang, Xiaobin Zhang, Y. Zhang, Yadong Zhang, Yangkun Zhang, Yichi Zhang, Yizhi Zhang, Yongting Zhang, Yu Zhang, Yushun Zhang, Yutao Zhang, Yutong Zhang, Zheng Zhang, Chenguang Zhao, Feifan Zhao, Jinxiang Zhao, Shuai Zhao, Xiangyu Zhao, Yikai Zhao, Zijia Zhao, Huabin Zheng, Ruihan Zheng, Shaojie Zheng, Tengyang Zheng, Junfeng Zhong, Longguang Zhong, Weiming Zhong, M. Zhou, Runjie Zhou, Xinyu Zhou, Zaida Zhou, Jinguo Zhu, Liya Zhu, Xinhao Zhu, Yuxuan Zhu, Zhen Zhu, Jingze Zhuang, Weiyu Zhuang, Ying Zou, and Xinxing Zu. Kimi k2.5: Visual agentic intelligence, 2026. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2602.02276` .
+2004
-- [45] Technology Innovation Institute. Falcon-h1r: Pushing the reasoning frontiers with a hybrid model for efficient test-time scaling, January 2026. URL `https://huggingface.co/ tiiuae/Falcon-H1R-7B` .
+2004
-- [46] Reddit User. Leaked: I caught google antigravity’s hidden inner prompt, 2026. URL `https://www.reddit.com/r/google_antigravity/comments/1rl1vjx/leaked_i_ caught_google_antigravitys_hidden_inner/` .
+2004
-- [47] Alexander von Recum, Leander Girrbach, and Zeynep Akata. Are reasoning llms robust to interventions on their chain-of-thought? In _The Fourteenth International Conference on Learning Representations (ICLR)_ , 2026. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2602.07470` .
+Financial
+Management
+Financial
+Management
-- [48] Yuqing Wang and Yun Zhao. Rupbench: Benchmarking reasoning under perturbations for robustness evaluation in large language models, 2024. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2406. 11020` .
+Financial
+Management
-- [49] Jason Wei, Xuezhi Wang, Dale Schuurmans, Maarten Bosma, Brian Ichter, Fei Xia, Ed H. Chi, Quoc V. Le, and Denny Zhou. Chain-of-thought prompting elicits reasoning in large language models. In _Proceedings of the 36th International Conference on Neural Information Processing Systems_ , NIPS ’22, Red Hook, NY, USA, 2022. Curran Associates Inc. ISBN 9781713871088.
+Financial
+Management
-13
+Financial
+Management
-- [50] Wikipedia. Rail fence cipher, 2026. URL `https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rail_fence_ cipher` .
+Financial
+Management
-- [51] Chulin Xie, Yangsibo Huang, Chiyuan Zhang, Da Yu, Xinyun Chen, Bill Yuchen Lin, Bo Li, Badih Ghazi, and Ravi Kumar. On memorization of large language models in logical reasoning. In _Proceedings of the 14th International Joint Conference on Natural Language Processing and the 4th Conference of the Asia-Pacific Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics_ , pages 2742–2785. Association for Computational Linguistics, 2025. URL `https: //aclanthology.org/2025.ijcnlp-long.148/` .
+Financial
+Management
-- [52] Roy Xie, Chengxuan Huang, Junlin Wang, and Bhuwan Dhingra. Adversarial math word problem generation. pages 5075–5093, Miami, Florida, USA, 2024. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/2024.findings-emnlp.292. URL `https://aclanthology.org/ 2024.findings-emnlp.292` .
+Financial
+Management
-- [53] Yuli Yang, Hiroaki Yamada, and Takenobu Tokunaga. Evaluating robustness of LLMs to numerical variations in mathematical reasoning. In _The Sixth Workshop on Insights from Negative Results in NLP_ , pages 171–180, Albuquerque, New Mexico, May 2025. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/2025.insights-1.16. URL `https://aclanthology.org/2025.insights-1.16/` .
+Performance Measure
-- [54] Shunyu Yao, Dian Yu, Jeffrey Zhao, Izhak Shafran, Thomas L. Griffiths, Yuan Cao, and Karthik Narasimhan. Tree of thoughts: Deliberate problem solving with large language models. In _Proceedings of the Neural Information Processing Systems_ , volume 36, 2023. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10601` .
+Actual/
-- [55] Alex L. Zhang, Tim Kraska, and Omar Khattab. Recursive language models, 2026. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2512.24601` .
+Migrate from current payroll system to
+Government wide Payroll provider
-- [56] Yilun Zhao, Guo Gan, Chengye Wang, Chen Zhao, and Arman Cohan. Are multimodal LLMs robust against adversarial perturbations? RoMMath: A systematic evaluation on multimodal math reasoning. In Luis Chiruzzo, Alan Ritter, and Lu Wang, editors, _Proceedings of the 2025 Conference of the Nations of the Americas Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics: Human Language Technologies (Volume 1: Long Papers)_ , Albuquerque, New Mexico, April 2025. Association for Computational Linguistics. doi: 10.18653/v1/2025. naacl-long.582. URL `https://aclanthology.org/2025.naacl-long.582/` .
+Meet Accelerated Financial Management
+Reporting Requirements (45 days after
+fiscal year-end)
+Meet Quarterly reporting requirement
-- [57] Kaijie Zhu, Jindong Wang, Qinlin Zhao, Ruochen Xu, and Xing Xie. Dynamic evaluation of large language models by meta probing agents. In _Forty-first International Conference on Machine Learning (ICML)_ , 2024. URL `https://arxiv.org/abs/2402.14865` .
+Unqualified Audit Opinion for Financial
+Statements
-## **A Appendix**
+Implement Government wide ePayroll
+service provider
-## **A.1 A - Methodology Details**
+Baseline (from
+previous year)
-When the model is given a transformed user query, it is given instructions on what transformation was applied to the original user query. Below are the transformations descriptions that are supplied to the model in plain English.
+Legacy System-IPAY
-1. Word Reversal: The order of words (words are defined as sequences of symbols separated by spaces) in the user query has been reversed.
+Met Current Financial
+Management Reporting
+Requirements
+Met Current Financial
+Management Reporting
+Requirements
+Unqualified Audit
+Opinion
-2. Sentence Reversal: The order of sentences in the user query has been reversed. Sentences are defined as sequences of symbols separated by periods.
+Legacy System-IPAY
-3. Interleaved Context Word: User query will consist of two problems - A and B, whose statements are interleaved word by word. First word belongs to problem A, second word belongs to problem B, third word belongs to problem A, and so on. You need to solve only problem A. Words are defined as sequences of symbols separated by spaces. If one problem statement is shorter than the other, the empty spaces resulting from the shorter problem statement will be filled with the shorter problem statement repeated from the beginning.
+Planned
+Performance
+Metric (Target)
-14
+Select ePayroll provider in
+FY03
+Submit NSF Performance
+and Accountability Report
+to OMB on November 17
+Submit Quarterly financial
+statements to OMB within
+45 days of end of quarter
-4. Interleaved Context Line: User query will consist of two problems - A and B, whose statements are split into line segments at most 60 symbols long. Each segment is followed by a space and a problem tag (e.g. problem A or B). The segments are interleaved. You need to solve only problem A. If one problem statement is shorter than the other, the empty lines resulting from the shorter problem statement will be filled with the shorter problem statement repeated from the beginning.
+Unqualified Audit Opinion
+for FY 2003 Financial
+Statements
+Successful transition to
+Government wide ePayroll
+service provide and
+retirement of IPAY system
-5. Word Split Swap: Every word (words are defined as sequences of symbols separated by spaces) in user query is split into 2 parts down the middle. If the word has odd number of symbols, the first part has one symbol less than the second part. After splitting, the 2 parts are swapped.
+Meet Accelerated Financial Management
+Reporting Requirements 45 days after fiscal
+year end
+Unqualified Audit Opinion for Financial
+Statements
-6. Split Reversal: Every word (words are defined as sequences of symbols separated by spaces) in user query has its symbols in reverse order.
+Met Current Financial
+Management Reporting
+Requirements
+Unqualified Audit
+Opinion
-7. Opposites: There will be terms remapped in the user query. The remappings are defined inside ’defyn’ block in the middle of user query.
+Submit NSF Performance
+and Accountability Report
+by November 15
+Unqualified Audit Opinion
+for FY 2004 Financial
+Statements
-8. Wrappers: There will be terms remapped in the user query. The remappings are defined inside ’defyn’ block in the middle of user query.
+Produce Quarterly Financial Statements
+within 21 days of end of quarter
-9. Rail Fence: The user query is encoded using the Rail Fence Cipher. The input is provided as a visual grid where the symbols (including spaces) of the encoded message string (message string does NOT contain any newline characters) are placed in a zigzag pattern across multiple rails (rows), and empty spaces are filled with dots (.). To decode, read the characters in zigzag order: Down-and-Right diagonally until you hit bottom rail, then Up-and-Right diagonally until you hit top rail, then Down-and-Right again etc... Rows are given on separate lines and all have equal lengths.
+Produced Quarterly
+Financial Statements
+within 21 days of end of
+quarter
-10. Rectangle Perimeter: "The user query is mapped onto the perimeter of a rectangle. The message is written as a single continuous string following the edges of the shape in a clockwise manner, beginning at the top-left. The TRANSFORMED INPUT is provided as a visual text block representing this rectangle with GRID START and GRID END markers. The center of the shape is filled with dots.
+Produce Quarterly
+Financial Statements
+within 21 days of end of
+quarter
-11. Snake Vertical: The user query is written into a grid using a vertical ’snake’ (zigzag) pattern. Starting from the top-left, the text is written down the first column, then up the second column, then down the third, and so on. The TRANSFORMED INPUT is provided as a visual grid with GRID START and GRID END markers.
+Performance Metric
+Results (Actual)
-12. Snake Horizontal: The user query is written into a grid using a horizontal ’snake’ (zigzag) pattern. Starting from the top-left, the text is written across the first row, then left across the second row, then right across the third, and so on. The TRANSFORMED INPUT is provided as a visual grid with GRID START and GRID END markers.
+ePayroll Service Provider
+selected in January 2003
+November 15th date was
+achieved one year ahead of
+OMB requirements
+NSF's Quarterly reports
+were consistently one of the
+first submitted to OMB
+NSF received an Unqualified
+Audit Opinion for FY 2003
+on 11/05/04
+New ePayroll service
+provider began processing
+NSF's payroll in May 2004.
+Because NSF's payroll
+system ran for part of the
+calendar year, NSF cannot
+retire its IPAY system until
+all reconciliation for the
+calendar year is done and W-
+2s are generated
+PAR Report submitted on
+11/15/2004
-**Disclosure:** This research utilized the AntiGravity agent framework to programmatically develop the evaluation codebase, and assist in experimental data analysis. The observational artifacts presented in Appendix A.5 were captured during the development of this codebase.
+NSF received an Unqualified
+Audit Opinion for FY 2004
+on 11/04/2005
+Quarterly reports produced
+within 21 days beginning
+March 2004
-## **A.2 Prompts**
+NSF FAS 1-3-07
-Baseline system prompt: ‘You are a helpful math assistant. Please reason step by step, and put your final answer within `\\boxed{}` .’
+6 of 18
-Solution Protocol Prompt that is inserted before the query.
+FY08 Exhibit 300
-## YOUR PROTOCOL:
+Fiscal Year
-1. Read the "TRANSFORMATION RULE" provided by the user and reverse the transformation on the "TRANSFORMED INPUT" to obtain the original problem statement.
+Strategic
+Goal(s)
+Supported
-2. Once you have the original problem statement, proceed to solve the math problem.
+Performance Measure
-3. Put your final answer within `\\boxed{}` .
+Actual/
+Baseline (from
+previous year)
-## **A.3 Cognitive Thrashing**
+2004
-Figure 7 shows the average output token length for each transformation. The number in the center of each bar is the accuracy of the model on that transformation. Analysis of the figure reveals a
+2005
-15
+Financial
+Management
-**==> picture [390 x 466] intentionally omitted <==**
+Automate closing package financial
+statements
-**----- Start of picture text -----**
-Gemini 3.1 Pro GPT-5.4
1250 1 1 1
1000 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 800
750 600 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
0
500 400
250 200
0 0
Claude Opus 4.6 GPT-OSS-120B
12501000 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 100008000 9 7 8 7 10 8
750 1 1 6000 5 5 4 5 5 5 4 5 6
500 0 0 0 4000
250 0 2000
0
0 0
Qwen3-30B-A3B Nemotron-32B
1500010000 16 15 10 12 11 13 14 8 11 10 13 15 15 13 16 3000020000 18 19 17 19 17 24 29 16 17 18 21 20 28 22 27
5000 10000
0 0
Nemotron-7B DSR1-Llama-70B
2500020000 19 20 17 22 23 25 28 19 18 20 22 25 27 24 27 100008000 9 10 7 7 7 8 9 6 10 7 10 10
6000 6
15000 5
10000 4000
5000 2000 1
0 0
BaselineNot-NotOppositesWrappersInterleave-LInterleave-WInterleave-SSentence-RevContextWord-RevSplit-RevRail FenceRectangleSnake-VSnake-H BaselineNot-NotOppositesWrappersInterleave-LInterleave-WInterleave-SSentence-RevContextWord-RevSplit-RevRail FenceRectangleSnake-VSnake-H
BaselineNot-NotOppositesWrappersInterleave-LInterleave-WInterleave-SSentence-RevContextWord-RevSplit-RevRail FenceRectangleSnake-VSnake-H BaselineNot-NotOppositesWrappersInterleave-LInterleave-WInterleave-SSentence-RevContextWord-RevSplit-RevRail FenceRectangleSnake-VSnake-H
BaselineNot-NotOppositesWrappersInterleave-LInterleave-WInterleave-SSentence-RevContextWord-RevSplit-RevRail FenceRectangleSnake-VSnake-H BaselineNot-NotOppositesWrappersInterleave-LInterleave-WInterleave-SSentence-RevContextWord-RevSplit-RevRail FenceRectangleSnake-VSnake-H
BaselineNot-NotOppositesWrappersInterleave-LInterleave-WInterleave-SSentence-RevContextWord-RevSplit-RevRail FenceRectangleSnake-VSnake-H BaselineNot-NotOppositesWrappersInterleave-LInterleave-WInterleave-SSentence-RevContextWord-RevSplit-RevRail FenceRectangleSnake-VSnake-H
Length (tokens) Length (tokens)
Length (tokens) Length (tokens)
Length (tokens) Length (tokens)
Length (tokens) Length (tokens)
**----- End of picture text -----**
+Met new Closing
+package requirements
+Financial
+Management
-Figure 7: Reasoning Efficiency: Average output token length by task. On top of each bar is output prompt length in thousands of tokens. Values in the middle of each bar are the accuracy of the model on that transformation.
+Unqualified Audit Opinion for Financial
+Statements
-pathological failure mode unique to modern open-source “Thinking” models (e.g., Qwen3, Nemotron). Rather than failing cleanly when presented with unrecognizable structural logic, these models enter massive, unproductive loops. For example, when attempting the _Rectangle Perimeter_ task, Nemotron7B outputs an average of 27K tokens, only to achieve 0% accuracy. Similarly, Qwen generates 13K tokens on the _Snake (Vertical)_ task with 1% accuracy. This indicates that the stopping criteria and logical progression heuristics are highly brittle. When structural noise breaks the expected syntactic progression of a math problem, the model’s internal confidence mechanisms fail, resulting in hallucination loops rather than structured problem-solving.
+Unqualified Audit
+Opinion
-16
+2005
-## **A.4 Open Questions: The Granularity of Atomic Reasoning**
+FFMIA Compliance
-If the mitigation of intra-query attention dilution requires explicitly breaking complex reasoning into isolated sub-tasks with contextual resets, it immediately raises a fundational open question for future research: _What is the optimal granularity of a sub-task?_
+Receive Assertion of FFMIA Compliance -
+Implement FAS Requirements necessary to
+maintain compliance
-Currently, task decomposition in LLMs is treated as an arbitrary, heuristic-driven prompting technique. However, our findings suggest that there exists a theoretical "atomic unit" of reasoning - the maximum amount of computation a model can perform in a single context state before structural noise irreversibly degrades its algorithmic logic.
+Financial
+Management
-This introduces a critical trade-off. If a task is not decomposed enough, the model falls victim to the attention dilution and cognitive thrashing demonstrated in our benchmark. Conversely, if a task is decomposed too finely, the system will incur massive computational overhead from constantly explicitly summarizing state, calling boundary tools, and flushing context, which may disrupt the continuous latent representations necessary for deep reasoning.
+Produce Quarterly Financial Statements
+within 21 days of end of quarter
-Furthermore, it remains unknown how this atomic reasoning capacity scales. It is entirely possible that the _optimal chunk size_ of a sub-task scales conditionally with parameter count or network depth. We argue that formally quantifying the maximum safe "cognitive load" of a single transformer forward-pass—and designing architectures that can dynamically determine their own optimal sub-task boundaries—represents an important frontier for the next generation of reasoning models.
+Financial
+Management
-## **A.5 Agent Leaks**
+Unqualified Audit Opinion for Financial
+Statements
-The following Antigravity leaks were observed during work on this project.
+Unqualified Audit
+Opinion
-17
+Financial
+Management
-**==> picture [378 x 503] intentionally omitted <==**
+Produce Quarterly and year end Financial
+statement
-Figure 8: Agent Context Leaks (1/3): Example of the `task_boundary` mechanism observed in Antigravity.
+2006
-18
+FFMIA Compliance
-**==> picture [378 x 503] intentionally omitted <==**
+Receive Assertion of FFMIA Compliance -
+Implement FAS Requirements necessary to
+maintain compliance
-Figure 9: Agent Context Leaks (2/3): Observed internal reasoning steps. Images are displayed at full width for maximum readability of the internal thought traces.
+Financial
+Management
-19
+Unqualified Audit Opinion for Financial
+Statements
-**==> picture [378 x 503] intentionally omitted <==**
+Unqualified Audit
+Opinion
-Figure 10: Agent Context Leaks (3/3): Note "Wait, the system message explicitly said You have called 5 tools in a row without calling a task_boundary tool."
+2005
-20
+2006
+
+20116
+
+2007
+
+2007
+
+Financial
+Management
+
+Produce Quarterly and year end Financial
+statement
+
+2007
+
+FFMIA Compliance
+
+Receive Assertion of FFMIA Compliance -
+Implement FAS Requirements necessary to
+maintain compliance
+
+2007
+
+2007
+
+2008
+
+2008
+
+2008
+
+2008
+
+2008
+
+Financial
+Management
+
+Federal Cash Transactions Report
+Monitoring
+
+Financial
+Management
+
+Grant Closeout - Review the Award
+Closeout Report on a quarterly basis
+
+Financial
+Management
+
+Federal Cash Transactions Report
+Monitoring
+
+Financial
+Management
+
+Grant Closeout - Review the Award
+Closeout Report on a quarterly basis
+
+Financial
+Management
+
+Unqualified Audit Opinion for Financial
+Statements
+
+Financial
+Management
+
+Produce Quarterly and year end Financial
+statement
+
+FFMIA Compliance
+
+Receive Assertion of FFMIA Compliance -
+Implement FAS Requirements necessary to
+maintain compliance
+
+Planned
+Performance
+Metric (Target)
+Automate closing package
+financial statements
+
+Performance Metric
+Results (Actual)
+
+Closing package statement
+became automated in June
+2004 NSF produces its
+automated financial
+statements and closing
+package statements
+simultaneously
+
+Unqualified Audit Opinion
+for FY 2005 Financial
+Statements
+Maintain Assertion of
+FFMIA Compliance
+through FAS compliance
+with requirements
+
+FFMIA compliance asserted
+on 11/08/2005
+
+Produce Quarterly
+Financial Statements
+within 21 days of end of
+quarter
+
+NSF submitted timely and
+accurate quarterly statements
+within 21 days of the end of
+quarter
+
+Unqualified Audit Opinion
+for FY 2006 Financial
+Statements
+Quarterly reports
+produced
+within 21 days and year
+
+ithi 45 d
+
+Maintain Assertion of
+FFMIA Compliance
+through FAS compliance
+with requirements
+
+Unqualified Audit Opinion
+for FY 2007 Financial
+Statements
+Quarterly reports
+produced
+within 21 days and year
+Maintain Assertion of
+FFMIA Compliance
+through FAS compliance
+with requirements
+
+ithi 45 d
+
+Resolve 100% of
+excessive cash on hand
+findings
+
+Close 100% of awards
+within two full reporting
+quarters after the
+expiration date
+
+Resolve 100% of
+excessive cash on hand
+findings
+
+Close 100% of awards
+within two full reporting
+quarters after the
+expiration date
+
+Unqualified Audit Opinion
+for FY 2008 Financial
+Statements
+Quarterly reports
+produced
+within 21 days and year
+
+ithi 45 d
+
+Maintain Assertion of
+FFMIA Compliance
+through FAS compliance
+with requirements
+
+Received Assertion of
+FFMIA Compliance -
+Implemented required
+changes to SGL and
+transactions
+
+Produced Quarterly
+Financial Statements
+within 21 days of end
+of
+
+Produced Quarterly and
+year-end Financial
+Statements by deadlines
+
+Received Assertion of
+FFMIA Compliance -
+Implemented required
+changes to SGL and
+transactions
+
+Produce Quarterly and
+year-end Financial
+Statements by deadlines
+
+Received Assertion of
+FFMIA Compliance -
+Implemented required
+changes to SGL and
+transactions
+
+Reviewed 100% of
+Federal Cash
+Transactions Reports
+with positive cash on
+hand
+
+Closed 100% of awards
+within two full
+reporting
+quarters after the
+expiration date
+Reviewed 100% of
+Federal Cash
+Transactions Reports
+with positive cash on
+hand
+
+Closed 100% of awards
+within two full
+reporting
+quarters after the
+expiration date
+Unqualified Audit
+Opinion
+
+Produced Quarterly and
+year-end Financial
+Statements by deadlines
+
+Received Assertion of
+FFMIA Compliance -
+Implemented required
+changes to SGL and
+transactions
+
+NSF FAS 1-3-07
+
+7 of 18
+
+FY08 Exhibit 300
+
+ Fiscal Year
+
+Strategic
+Goal(s)
+Supported
+
+Performance Measure
+
+Actual/
+Baseline (from
+previous year)
+
+Planned
+Performance
+Metric (Target)
+
+Performance Metric
+Results (Actual)
+
+2009
+
+2009
+
+2009
+
+2009
+
+2009
+
+2010
+
+2011
+
+2010
+
+2010
+
+2010
+
+2011-
+
+2011
+
+2011
+
+2011
+
+2011
+
+All new IT investments initiated for FY 2005 and beyond must use Table 2 and are required to use the
+Federal Enterprise Architecture (FEA) Performance Reference Model (PRM). Please use Table 2 and the
+PRM to identify the performance information pertaining to this major IT investment. Map all Measurement
+Indicators to the corresponding "Measurement Area" and "Measurement Grouping" identified in the PRM.
+There should be at least one Measurement Indicator for at least four different Measurement Areas (for each
+fiscal year). The PRM is available at www.egov.gov.
+
+NSF FAS 1-3-07
+
+8 of 18
+
+FY08 Exhibit 300
+
+Table 2
+Fiscal
+Year
+
+Measurement Area IT
+
+Measurement Grouping IT
+
+Measurement
+I di
+
+t
+
+Baseline Planned
+
+Actual Results
+
+Improvement to
+the Baseline
+
+Section E: Security and Privacy (IT Capital Assets Only)
+
+In order to successfully address this area of the business case, each question below must be answered at the
+system/application level, not at a program or agency level. Systems supporting this investment on the planning and
+operational systems security tables should match the systems on the privacy table below. Systems on the Operational
+Security Table must be included on your agency FISMA system inventory and should be easily referenced in the
+inventory (i.e., should use the same name or identifier).
+
+All systems supporting and/or part of this investment should be included in the tables below, inclusive of both agency
+owned systems and contractor systems. For IT investments under development, security and privacy planning must
+proceed in parallel with the development of the system/s to ensure IT security and privacy requirements and costs are
+identified and incorporated into the overall lifecycle of the system/s.
+
+Please respond to the questions below and verify the system owner took the following actions:
+
+(1) Have the IT security costs for the system(s) been identified and integrated into the overall costs of the
+
+investment: yes
+
+(a) If "yes," provide the "Percentage IT Security" for the budget year: 14
+
+(2) Is identifying and assessing security and privacy risks a part of the overall risk management effort for
+each system supporting or part of this investment. yes
+
+(3) Systems in Planning - Security:
+
+Name Of System
+
+Agency Or Contractor Operated
+
+System?
+
+Planned Operational Date
+
+Planned or Actual
+C&A Completion Date
+
+(4) Operational Systems - Security:
+
+Name Of System
+
+Agency Or Contractor
+Operated system
+
+NIST FIPS
+199
+
+Risk Impact
+Level (High,
+Moderate,
+Low)
+
+Has the
+C&A been
+completed
+using
+NIST 800-
+37?
+
+Date C&A
+Complete
+
+What standards we
+used for the
+Security Controls
+tests?
+
+Date Completed
+
+Security
+Control Testing
+
+Date
+Contingency
+Plan Tested
+
+FAS
+
+Contractor and
+Government
+
+High
+
+yes
+
+04/05/06
+
+FIPS 200 / NIST
+800-53
+
+01/18/06
+
+02/15/06
+
+(5) Have any weaknesses, not yet remediated, related to any of the systems part of or supporting this
+investment been identified by the agency or IG? no
+
+(a) If "yes," have those weaknesses been incorporated into the agency's plan of action and milestone
+
+process?
+
+(6) Indicate whether an increase in IT security funding is requested to remediate IT security
+weaknesses? no
+
+NSF FAS 1-3-07
+
+9 of 18
+
+FY08 Exhibit 300
+
+(a) If "yes," specify the amount, a general description of the weakness, and how the funding request
+will remediate the weakness.
+
+(7) How are contractor security procedures monitored, verified, and validated by the agency for
+
+the contractor systems above?
+
+NSF uses a range of methods to review the security of operations through contract requirements, project
+management oversight and review, certification and accreditation processes, IG independent reviews,
+proactive testing of controls through penetration testing and vulnerability scans to ensure services are
+adequately secure and meet the requirements of FISMA, OMB policy, NIST guidelines and NSF policy. The
+system is operated on-site by a team of contractors and NSF personnel with system administrators tightly
+controlling access to the systems. Only administrators with current need have access to the system,
+and strict code migration, quality control, and configuration management procedures prevent deployment of
+hostile or vulnerable software on the systems. Contractors are trained in the same security measures as
+NSF employees. All NSF employees and contract staff are required to complete an on-line security training
+class each year, including the rules of behavior. Background checks are done routinely as a part of the
+NSF contracting process, and IT security requirements are stated in the contracts statement of work.
+Contractor security procedures are monitored, verified, and validated by the agency in the same way as for
+government employees. Once on board, contractors are allowed access to the NSF systems based on their
+specific job requirements. Audit logs are also implemented to monitor operating system changes - these
+audit logs are reviewed by the system administrators. Additionally, roles and responsibilities are separated
+to the extent possible to allow for checks and balances in system management and multiple levels of
+oversight.
+
+(8) Planning and Operational Systems - Privacy:
+
+(a) Name Of System
+
+(b) Is this a
+new system?
+
+(c) Is there a PIA that
+covers this system? •
+
+(d) Is the PIA available to the public?
+
+F A S
+
+no
+
+1. Y e s .
+
+2 . No, because a PIA is not yet
+
+required to be completed at this time.
+
+(e) Is a
+System
+Records
+Notice
+(SORN)
+required for
+this system?
+
+no
+
+(I) Was a new or amended SORN
+published in FY06?
+
+5. No, because the system is
+
+not a Privacy Act system of
+
+records.
+
+(c) Is there a Privacy Impact Assessment (PIA) that covers this system?
+
+1. Yes.
+2. No.
+3. No, because the system does not contain, process, or transmit personal identifying information.
+4. No, because even though it has personal identifying information, the system contains information solely about
+
+federal employees and agency contractors.
+
+(d) Is the PIA available to the public?
+
+1. Yes.
+2. No, because a PIA is not yet required to be completed at this time.
+3. No, because the PIA has not been prepared.
+
+(f) Was a new or amended SORN published in FY2006?
+
+NSF FAS 1-3-07
+
+10 of 18
+
+FY08 Exhibit 300
+
+1. Yes, because this is a newly established Privacy Act system of records.
+2. Yes, because the existing Privacy Act system of records was substantially revised in FY 06.
+3. No, because the existing Privacy Act system of records was not substantially revised in FY 06.
+4. No; the system is operational, but the SORN has not yet been published.
+5. No, because the system is not a Privacy Act system of records.
+
+Section F: Enterprise Architecture (EA) (IT Capital Assets Only)
+
+In order to successfully address this area of the business case and capital asset plan you must ensure
+the investment is included in the agency's EA and Capital Planning and Investment Control (CPIC)
+process, and is mapped to and supports the FEA. You must also ensure the business case demonstrates
+the relationship between the investment and the business, performance, data, services, application, and
+technology layers of the agency's EA.
+
+(1) Is this investment included in your agency's target enterprise architecture? yes (a)
+
+If "no," please explain why?
+
+(2) Is this investment included in the agency's EA Transition Strategy? yes
+
+a. If "yes," provide the
+investment name as identified
+in the Transition Strategy
+provided in the agency's most
+recent annual EA
+Assessment.
+b. If "no," please explain
+why?
+
+The Financial Accounting System (FAS) is included as part of the Next
+Generation Grants Management workstream in the EA Transition Strategy
+submitted to OMB on February 28, 2006.
+
+(3) Identify the service components funded by this major IT investment (e.g., knowledge
+management, content management, customer relationship management, etc.). Provide this
+information in the format of the following table. For detailed guidance regarding components,
+please refer to http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/egov/.
+
+Agency
+Component
+Name
+
+Agency
+Comonent
+p
+
+Description
+
+Advice of BEP Maintenance of
+
+FEASRM
+Service Type
+
+FEA SRM
+Component
+(a)
+
+Billing and
+
+FEA Service Component Reused (b)
+
+Reused Service
+Component Name
+
+Reused Service Component
+UPI
+
+Internal External
+Reuse (c)
+
+Funding
+Percentage
+(d)
+
+No Reuse
+
+10
+
+Charge Card
+Module
+
+FASTRAN
+
+AP Log
+
+Funding
+Allocations
+Charge Card
+Bill Processing
+
+Transaction
+Processing
+Module
+
+Accounts
+Payable/Prompt
+Pay and Invoice
+tracking
+
+Management
+
+Credit /
+Charge
+
+Management
+
+Financials
+
+Management
+
+Expense
+Management
+
+Financial
+
+Management
+
+Payment /
+Settlement
+
+No Reuse
+
+No Reuse
+
+No Reuse
+
+3
+
+10
+
+7
+
+NSF FAS 1-3-07
+
+11 of 18
+
+FY08 Exhibit 300
+
+Agency
+Componen
+Name
+
+FASTRAN
+
+FAS Core
+
+Agency
+Component
+Description
+
+FEASRM
+Service Type
+
+FEA SRM
+Component
+(a)
+
+FEA Service Component Reused (b)
+
+Reused Service
+Component Name
+
+Reused Service Component
+UPI
+
+Internal External
+Reuse(c)
+
+Funding
+Percentage
+(d)
+
+Transaction
+Processing
+Module
+
+Financial
+Management
+
+Debt
+Collection
+
+Core
+Functionally of
+Accounting
+System
+
+Internal
+Controls
+
+Financial
+
+Management
+
+No Reuse
+
+10
+
+No Reuse
+
+60
+
+a. Use existing SRM Components or identify as "NEW". A "NEW" component is one not already
+identified as a service component in the FEA SRM.
+
+b. A reused component is one being funded by another investment, but being used by this
+investment. Rather than answer yes or no, identify the reused service component funded by the other
+investment and identify the other investment using the Unique Project Identifier (UPI) code from the
+OMB Ex 300 or Ex 53 submission.
+
+c. 'Internal' reuse is within an agency. For example, one agency within a department is reusing a
+service component provided by another agency within the same department. 'External' reuse is one
+agency within a department reusing a service component provided by another agency in another
+department. A good example of this is an E-Gov initiatiye service being reused by multiple
+organizations across the federal government.
+
+d. Please provide the percentage of the BY requested funding amount used for each service
+component listed in the table. If external, provide the funding level transferred to another agency to
+pay for the service.
+
+4. To demonstrate how this major IT investment aligns with the FEA Technical Reference Model
+(TRM), please list the Service Areas, Categories, Standards, and Service Specifications supporting
+this IT investment.
+
+FEA SRM Component (a) FEA TRM Service Area
+Billing and Accounting
+
+Service Access and
+
+FEA TRM Service Category
+Access Channels
+
+FEA TRM Service Standard
+Other Electronic Channels
+
+FEAService Specification (b)
+
+Billing and Accounting
+
+Delivery
+
+Delivery Channels
+
+Intranet
+
+Billing and Accounting
+
+Billing and Accounting
+
+Service Access and
+
+Delivery
+
+Service Access and
+Delivery
+
+Service Access and
+Delivery
+
+Service Requirements
+
+Legislative / Compliance
+
+Service Transport
+
+Service Transport
+
+Billing and Accounting.
+
+Service Platform and
+
+Support Platforms
+
+Platform Dependent
+
+Windows XP
+
+Billing and Accounting
+
+Billing and Accounting
+
+Billing and Accounting
+
+Infrastructure
+
+Service Platform and
+
+Infrastructure
+
+Service Platform and
+
+Infrastructure
+
+Service Platform and
+
+Infrastructure
+
+Delivery Servers
+
+Application Servers
+
+Windows NT
+
+Database / Storage
+
+Database
+
+Sybase 12,x
+
+Hardware / Infrastructure
+
+Servers / Computers
+
+Windows NT
+
+NSF FAS 1-3-07
+
+12 of 18
+
+FY08 Exhibit 300
+
+Billing and Accounting
+
+Billing and Accounting
+
+Billing and Accounting
+Billing and Accounting
+
+Component Framework Presentation / Interface
+
+Static Display
+
+Component Framework Data Management
+
+Database Connectivity.
+
+Sybase 12.x
+
+Component Framework Data Management
+
+Service Interface and
+
+Integration
+
+Integration
+
+Reporting and Analysis
+Enterprise Application
+
+Integration
+
+Billing and Accounting
+
+Service Interface and
+
+lnteroperability
+
+Data Transformation
+
+Integration
+
+Billing and Accounting
+
+Service Interface and
+
+Interface
+
+Service Description
+
+API
+
+Credit / Charge
+
+Service Access and
+
+Access Channels
+
+Other Electronic Channels
+
+Integration
+
+Interface
+
+Delivery
+
+Credit / Charge
+
+Service Access and
+
+Delivery Channels
+
+Intranet
+
+Delivery
+
+Credit / Charge
+
+Service Access and
+
+Service Requirements
+
+Legislative / Compliance
+
+Credit / Charge
+
+Service Access and
+
+Service Transport
+
+Service Transport
+
+Delivery
+
+Credit / Charge
+
+Credit / Charge
+
+Credit / Charge
+
+Credit / Charge
+
+Delivery.
+
+Service Platform and
+
+Infrastructure
+
+Service Platform and
+
+Infrastructure
+
+Service Platform and
+
+Infrastructure
+
+Service Platform and
+
+Infrastructure
+
+Support Platforms
+
+Platform Dependent
+
+Windows XP
+
+Delivery Servers
+
+Application Servers
+
+Windows NT
+
+Database / Storage
+
+Database:
+
+Sybase 12,x
+
+Hardware / Infrastructure Servers / Computers
+
+Windows NT
+
+Credit / Charge
+
+Component Framework
+
+Presentation / Interface
+
+Static Display
+
+Credit / Charge
+
+Component Framework Data Management
+
+Database Connectivity
+
+Sybase 12.x
+
+Credit / Charge
+
+Component Framework Data Management
+
+Credit / Charge
+
+Service Interface and
+
+Integration;
+
+Reporting and Analysis
+
+.
+
+Enterprise Application
+Integration
+
+Credit / Charge
+
+Credit / Charge
+
+Integration
+
+Service Interface and
+
+Integration
+
+Service Interface and
+Integration
+
+lnteroperability
+
+Data Transformation
+
+Interface
+
+Service Description /
+
+API
+
+Interface
+
+Expense Management
+
+Service Access and
+
+Access Channels
+
+Other Electronic Channels
+
+Delivery
+
+Expense Management
+
+Service Access and
+
+Delivery Channels
+
+Intranet
+
+Delivery
+
+Expense Management
+
+Service Access and
+
+Service Requirements
+
+Legislative / Compliance
+
+Expense Management
+
+Service Access and
+
+Service Transport
+
+Service Transport
+
+Delivery
+
+Delivery
+
+Expense Management
+
+Service Platform and
+
+Support Platforms
+
+Platform Dependent
+
+Windows XP
+
+Infrastructure
+
+Expense Management
+
+Service Platform and
+
+Delivery Servers
+
+Application Servers
+
+Windows NT
+
+Expense Management
+
+Service Platform and
+
+Database / Storage
+
+Database,
+
+Sybase 12,x
+
+Infrastructure
+
+Infrastructure
+
+NSF FAS 1-3-07
+
+13 of 18
+
+FY08 Exhibit 300
+
+Expense Management
+
+Service Platform and
+
+Hardware / Infrastructure
+
+Servers / Computers,
+
+Windows NT
+
+Infrastructure
+
+Expense Management
+
+Component Framework
+
+Presentation / Interface
+
+Static Display
+
+Expense Management
+
+Component Framework Data Management
+
+Database Connectivity
+
+Sybase 12.x
+
+Expense Management
+Expense Management
+
+Component Framework Data Management
+
+Reporting and Analysis
+
+Service Interface and
+
+Integration
+
+Integration
+
+Enterprise Application
+
+Integration
+
+Expense Management.
+
+Service Interface and
+
+lnteroperability
+
+Data Transformation
+
+Integration:
+
+Expense Management
+
+Service Interface and
+
+Interface
+
+Service Description /
+
+API
+
+Payment / Settlement
+
+Service Access and
+
+Access Channels
+
+Other Electronic Channels
+
+Integration
+
+Interface
+
+Delivery
+
+Payment / Settlement
+
+Service Access and
+
+Delivery Channels
+
+Intranet
+
+Delivery
+
+Payment / Settlement
+
+Service Access and
+
+Service Requirements
+
+Legislative / Compliance
+
+Payment / Settlement
+
+Payment / Settlement
+
+Payment / Settlement
+
+Delivery
+
+Service Access and
+Delivery
+
+Service Platform and
+
+Infrastructure
+
+Service Platform and
+
+Infrastructure
+
+Service Transport
+
+Service Transport
+
+Support Platforms
+
+Platform Dependent
+
+Windows XP
+
+Delivery Servers
+
+Application Servers
+
+Windows NT
+
+Payment / Settlement
+
+Service Platform and
+
+Database / Storage
+
+Database
+
+Sybase 12,x
+
+Infrastructure
+
+Payment / Settlement
+
+Service Platform and
+
+Hardware / Infrastructure
+
+Servers / Computers
+
+Windows NT
+
+Payment / Settlement
+
+Infrastructure
+Component Framework Presentation / Interface
+
+Static Display
+
+Payment / Settlement
+
+Component Framework Data Management
+
+Database Connectivity
+
+Sybase 12.x
+
+Payment / Settlement
+
+Component Framework: Data Management
+
+Reporting and Analysis,
+
+Payment / Settlement
+
+Service Interface and
+
+Integration
+
+Integration
+
+Payment / Settlement
+
+Service Interface and
+
+Interoperability
+
+Payment / Settlement
+
+Debt Collection
+
+Integration
+
+Service Interface and
+Integration
+
+Interface
+
+Enterprise Application
+
+Integration
+„..,,
+Data Transformation
+
+Service Description /
+
+Interface'
+
+Service Access and
+
+ Delivery
+
+Access Channels
+
+Other Electronic Channels
+
+Debt Collection
+
+Service Access and
+
+Delivery Channels
+
+Intranet
+
+Debt Collection
+
+Debt Collection
+
+Debt Collection
+
+Debt Collection
+
+Delivery
+
+Service Access and
+
+Delivery
+
+Service Access and
+
+ Delivery
+
+Service Platform and,
+
+Infrastructure
+
+Service Platform and
+
+Infrastructure
+
+Service Requirements
+
+Legislative / Compliance
+
+Service Transport
+
+Service Transport
+
+Support Platforms
+
+Platform Dependent
+
+Windows XP
+
+Delivery Servers
+
+!Application Servers
+
+Windows NT
+
+NSF FAS 1-3-07
+
+14 of 18
+
+FY08 Exhibit 300
+
+Debt Collection
+
+Debt Collection
+
+Service Platform and
+
+Infrastructure
+
+Service Platform and
+
+Infrastructure
+
+Database / Storage
+
+Database
+
+Sybase 12,x
+
+Hardware / Infrastructure
+
+Servers / Computers
+
+Windows NT
+
+Debt Collection
+
+Component Framework
+
+Presentation / Interface
+
+Static Display
+
+Debt Collection
+
+Component Framework Data Management
+
+Database Connectivity
+
+Sybase 12.x.
+
+Debt Collection
+Debt Collection
+
+Debt Collection
+
+Debt Collection
+
+Internal Controls
+
+Internal Controls
+
+Internal Controls
+
+Internal Controls
+
+Internal Controls
+
+Internal Controls
+
+Internal Controls
+
+Internal Controls
+
+Component Framework Data Management
+
+Reporting and Analysis
+
+Service Interface and
+Integration
+
+Service Interface and
+Integration
+
+Service Interface and
+Integration
+
+Service Access and
+Delivery
+
+Service Access and
+
+Delivery
+
+Service Access and
+
+Delivery
+
+Service Access and
+Delivery
+
+Service Platform and
+
+Infrastructure
+
+Service Platform and
+
+Infrastructure
+
+Service Platform and
+
+Infrastructure
+
+Service Platform and
+
+Infrastructure
+
+Integration
+
+Enterprise Application:
+
+Integration
+
+Interoperability
+
+Data Transformation
+
+Interface
+
+Service Description /
+
+Interface
+
+API
+
+Access Channels
+
+:Other Electronic Channels.
+
+Delivery Channels
+
+Intranet
+
+Service Requirements
+
+Legislative / Compliance
+
+Service Transport
+
+Service Transport
+
+Support Platforms
+
+Platform Dependent
+
+Windows XP
+
+Delivery Servers
+
+Application Servers
+
+Windows NT
+
+Database / Storage
+
+Database
+
+Sybase 12,x
+
+Hardware / Infrastructure
+
+Servers / Computers
+
+Windows NT
+
+Internal Controls
+
+Component Framework Presentation / Interface
+
+Internal Controls
+
+Component Framework Data Management
+
+Static Display
+Database Connectivity
+
+Sybase 12.x
+
+Internal Controls
+Internal Controls
+
+Internal Controls
+
+Component Framework Data Management
+
+Reporting and Analysis,
+
+Service Interface and
+Integration
+
+Service Interface and
+Integration
+
+Integration
+
+Enterprise Application
+
+Integration
+
+Interoperability.
+
+Data Transformation
+
+Internal Controls:
+
+Service Interface and!
+
+Interface
+
+Service Description /
+
+API
+
+Integration
+
+Interface
+
+a. Service Components identified in the previous question should be entered in this column. Please
+enter multiple rows for FEA SRM Components supported by multiple TRM Service Specifications.
+
+b. In the Service Specification field, Agencies should provide information on the specified technical
+standard or vendor product mapped to the FEA TRM Service Standard, including model or version
+numbers, as appropriate.
+
+5. Will the application leverage existing components and/or applications across the Government
+(i.e., FirstGov, Pay.Gov, etc)? no
+
+NSF FAS 1-3-07
+
+15 of 18
+
+FY08 Exhibit 300
+
+a. If "yes," please describe.
+
+6. Does this investment provide the public with access to a government automated information
+system? no
+
+(a) If "yes," does customer access require specific software (e.g., a
+specific web browser version)?
+[1] If "yes," provide the specific product name(s) and version number(s) of the required software and
+the date when the public will be able to access this investment by any software (i.e. to ensure
+equitable and timely access of government information and services).
+
+NSF FAS 1-3-07
+
+16 of 18
+
+FY08 Exhibit 300
+
+PART III: For "Operation and Maintenance" Investments ONLY (Steady State)
+
+Part III should be completed only for investments which will be in "Operation and Maintenance"
+(Steady State) in response to Question 6 in Part I, Section A above.
+
+Section A: Risk Management (All Capital Assets)
+
+You should have performed a risk assessment during the early planning and initial concept phase of
+this investment's life-cycle, developed a risk-adjusted life-cycle cost estimate and a plan to
+eliminate, mitigate or manage risk, and be actively managing risk throughout the investment's life-
+cycle.
+
+Answer the following questions to describe how you are managing investment risks.
+
+1. Does the investment have a Risk Management Plan? yes
+
+a. If "yes," what is the date of the plan?
+
+06/01/2005
+
+b. Has the Risk Management Plan been significantly changed since last year's submission to
+
+OMB? no
+
+c. If "yes," describe any significant changes:
+
+2. If there currently is no plan, will a plan be developed?
+
+a. If "yes," what is the planned completion date?
+b. If "no," what is the strategy for managing the risks?
+
+Section B: Cost and Schedule Performance (All Capital Assets)
+
+Answer the following questions about how you are currently managing this investment.
+
+1. Was an operational analysis conducted? yes
+
+a. If "yes," provide the date the analysis was completed.
+
+06/01/2005
+
+b. If "yes," what were the results? (Max 2500 Characters)
+
+The results of the OA recommend that the FAS continue to be used as the NSF's financial accounting
+
+system for the next several years. The NSF is in the process of conducting a pilot project as a Grants
+
+Management Line of Business provider. We plan to take advantage of the results/findings of the GMLOB
+
+process in becoming an SSP to more fully define our financial requirements. This will allow the NSF to take
+
+an integrated approach to both GMLOB & FMLOB in regards to the future of FAS and NSF's
+
+financial system.
+
+NSF FAS 1-3-07
+
+17 of 18
+
+FY08 Exhibit 300
+
+c. If "no," please explain why it was not conducted and if there are any plans to conduct an
+
+operational analysis in the future? (Max 2500 Characters)
+
+2. Complete the following table to compare actual cost performance against the planned cost
+performance baseline. Milestones reported may include specific individual scheduled preventative
+and predictable corrective maintenance activities, or may be the total of planned annual operation
+and maintenance efforts). Indicate if the information provided includes government and contractor
+costs:
+
+a. What costs are included in the reported Cost/Schedule Performance information (Government
+Only/Contractor Only/Both)? Contractor Only
+
+Description of Milestone (Max 50
+Characters)
+
+Planned
+
+Completion Date
+
+Total Cost
+($M)
+
+Actual
+Completion Date Total Costs
+
+($M)
+
+$1.800
+
+$1.500
+
+09/30/2001
+
+09/30/2002
+
+$1.800
+
+$1.500
+
+09/30/2001
+
+09/30/2002
+
+09/30/2003
+
+$1.670
+
+09/30/2003
+
+$1.670
+
+09/30/2004
+
+09/30/2005
+
+09/30/200
+
+09/30/2007
+
+$1.300
+
+$1.300
+
+$1.500
+
+$1.500.
+
+09/30/2004
+
+09/30/2005
+
+09/30/2006
+
+$1.300:
+
+$1.300
+
+$1.500
+
+$0.000
+
+Baseline
+Schedule
+Variance
+(#Days)
+
+Baseline
+Cost
+Variance
+($M)
+
+$0.000
+
+$0.000
+
+$0.000
+
+$0.000
+
+$0.000
+
+$0.000
+
+$0.000
+
+FY01 Steady State Operations
+
+FY02 Steady State Operations
+
+FY03 Steady State Operations
+
+FY04 Steady State Operations
+
+FY05 Steady State Operations
+
+FY06 Steady State Operations
+
+FY07 Steady State Operations
+
+Total Planned Costs:
+
+Total Actual Costs: $9.070
+
+NSF FAS 1-3-07
+
+18 of 18
+
+FY08 Exhibit 300
diff --git a/q15/random_k2/question.json b/q15/random_k2/question.json
index 9eb0d24f1915f708e5916a78f9fd1f32e456a74c..c308919e32a1b0e0411e0cfb981f026a068dc7a6 100644
--- a/q15/random_k2/question.json
+++ b/q15/random_k2/question.json
@@ -15,8 +15,8 @@
],
"original_filenames": [
"2312.10997v5.pdf",
- "web_ffc784688ff74004.pdf",
- "web_c40e5cade76fba39.pdf"
+ "web_0592b193cfe894c0.pdf",
+ "resize_r2_25.pdf"
],
"modality": "markdown"
}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/q15/random_k2/random_1.md b/q15/random_k2/random_1.md
index 568511cdd3e8b935079ff674d5949ce1b387f331..d3a8827a2c9c1661d68231635f74293c020f1a02 100644
--- a/q15/random_k2/random_1.md
+++ b/q15/random_k2/random_1.md
@@ -1,5479 +1,1353 @@
-Owner’s Manual
+CHAPTER 42
-Models
-14, 16, 17, 18
-
-Refrigerators
+FORMWORK
-TOP-MOUNT NO-FROST
+42 FORMWORK
-Part No. 162D6736P004 Pub. No.39-6424-1 9-99 JR
+Definitions
-Congratulations!
-
-Welcome to our family. We’re proud of our
-quality products and we are committed to
-providing dependable service. You’ll see it in
-this easy-to-use Owner’s Manual and you’ll
-hear it in the friendly voices of our customer
-service department.
-
-Best of all, you’ll experience these values
-each time you use your refrigerator. That’s
-important, because your new refrigerator will
-be part of your family for many years. And we
-hope you will be part of ours for a long time
-to come.
+The following definitions are used in the forming
+industry. Some terms may be used by other trades
+as well, but their meanings may be different from
+these depending upon the application.
-We appreciate your purchase, and hope you
-will continue to rely on us whenever you
-need quality appliances for your home.
+Falsework, in relation to a form or structure, means
+the structural supports and bracing used to support
+all or part of the form or structure until the concrete
+is poured and is strong enough to support loads.
-Important!
-
-Fill out and return the Consumer Product
-Registration Card that is packed with this
-product. If you cannot find it, please send
-in the duplicate card printed in the back of
-this manual.
+Flying formwork is a designed floor formwork
+system that can be hoisted between levels as a unit.
-Write the model and serial
-numbers here.
-
-#
-
-#
-
-You can find them on a label on the
-upper left side of the fresh food
-compartment.
-
-Staple sales slip or cancelled
-check here.
-
-Proof of the original purchase date
-is needed to obtain service under
-the warranty.
-
-2
-
-AService Partnership.
-
-We stand behind our products with
-unmatched quality service. However, did
-you know that most questions result from
-simple problems that you can easily
-fix yourself in just a few minutes? This
-Owner’s Manual can tell you how.
-
-Read this Manual
-Inside you will find many
-helpful hints on how to use and
-maintain your refrigerator
-properly. Just a little preventive
-care on your part can save you a
-great deal of time and money
-over the life of your refrigerator.
-
-Review the Section on
-Troubleshooting Tips
-
-You’ll find many answers to
-common problems here.
-If you review our chart of
-Troubleshooting Tips first,
-you may not need to call for
-service at all.
-
-If You Need Service
-
-If you do need service, you can
-relax knowing help is only a
-phone call away. A list of toll-free
-customer service numbers is
-included in the back section.
-Or you can always call the
-GE Answer Center® at
-800.626.2000, 24 hours a day,
-7 days a week.
-
-Safety Information
-Safety Precautions . . . . . . . . . .4
-Proper Disposal . . . . . . . . . . . . .5
-How to Connect Electricity . . . .6
-Use of Adapter Plugs . . . . . .6, 7
-Use of Extension Cords . . . . . .7
-
-Operating Instructions
-
-Temperature Control Dial . . . . .8
-Shelves . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .9, 10
-Storage Drawers . . . . . . . .11, 12
-Automatic Icemaker . . . . . . . .13
-Care and Cleaning . . . . . .14–16
-
-Installation Instructions
-
-Preparing to
-Install the Refrigerator . . .17, 18
-Water Line Installation . . .19–23
-Reversing the
-Door Swing . . . . . . . . . . . .24–29
-
-Troubleshooting Tips
-
-Normal Operating Sounds . . .30
-Before You
-Call For Service . . . . . . . . .31–33
-
-Customer Service
-Product Registration . . . . . . . .37
-Warranty . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .39
-Service Telephone
-Numbers . . . . . . . . . .Back Cover
-
-3
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-4
-
-IMPORTANT SAFETY INFORMATION.
-READ ALL INSTRUCTIONS BEFORE USING.
-WARNING!
-
-Use this appliance only for its intended purpose as
-described in this Owner’s Manual.
-
-SAFETY PRECAUTIONS
-When using electrical appliances, basic safety precautions
-should be followed, including the following:
-
-n Keep fingers out of the
-“pinch point” areas;
-clearances between the
-doors and between the doors
-and cabinet are necessarily
-small. Be careful closing
-doors when children are in
-the area.
-
-n Unplug the refrigerator
-
-before cleaning and making
-repairs.
-
-NOTE: We strongly recommend
-that any servicing be performed
-by a qualified individual.
-
-n Turning the control to the
-
-OFF position does not remove
-power to the light circuit.
-n Do not refreeze frozen foods
-
-which have thawed
-completely.
-
-n This refrigerator must be
-properly installed and
-located in accordance with
-the Installation Instructions
-before it is used.
-
-n Do not allow children to
-
-climb, stand or hang on the
-shelves in the refrigerator.
-They could damage the
-refrigerator and seriously
-injure themselves.
-n Do not touch the cold
-surfaces in the freezer
-compartment, particularly
-when hands are damp or wet.
-Skin may stick to these
-extremely cold surfaces.
-n Do not store or use gasoline
-or other flammable vapors
-and liquids in the vicinity of
-this or any other appliance.
-
-n In refrigerators with
-
-automatic icemakers, avoid
-contact with the moving parts
-of the ejector mechanism, or
-with the heating element that
-releases the cubes. Do not
-place fingers or hands on the
-automatic icemaking
-mechanism while the
-refrigerator is plugged in.
-
-DANGER! RISK OF CHILD
-
-ENTRAPMENT
-PROPER DISPOSAL OF THE REFRIGERATOR
-
-Child entrapment and suffocation are not problems of
-the past. Junked or abandoned refrigerators are still
-dangerous…even if they will sit for “just a few days.”
-If you are getting rid of your old refrigerator, please
-follow the instructions below to help prevent accidents.
-
-Before You Throw Away Your Old Refrigerator
-or Freezer:
-
-n Take off the doors.
-n Leave the shelves in place so that children may not
-
-easily climb inside.
-
-CFC Disposal
-
-Your old refrigerator has a cooling system that used
-CFCs (chlorofluorocarbons). CFCs are believed to harm
-stratospheric ozone.
-
-If you are throwing away your old refrigerator, make
-sure the CFC refrigerant is removed for proper disposal
-by a qualified servicer. If you intentionally release this
-CFC refrigerant you can be subject to fines and
-imprisonment under provisions of the Federal Clean
-Air Act.
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-5
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-6
-
-IMPORTANT SAFETY INFORMATION.
-READ ALL INSTRUCTIONS BEFORE USING.
-WARNING!
-
-HOW TO CONNECT ELECTRICITY
-Do not, under any circumstances, cut or remove the third
-(ground) prong from the power cord. For personal safety,
-this appliance must be properly grounded.
-
-The power cord of this appliance is equipped with a 3-prong
-(grounding) plug which mates with a standard 3-prong
-(grounding) wall outlet to minimize the possibility of electric
-shock hazard from this appliance.
-
-Have the wall outlet and circuit checked by a qualified electrician
-to make sure the outlet is properly grounded.
-
-Where a standard 2-prong wall outlet is encountered, it is your
-personal responsibility and obligation to have it replaced with a
-properly grounded 3-prong wall outlet.
-
-The refrigerator should always be plugged into its own individual
-electrical outlet which has a voltage rating that matches the rating
-plate.
-
-This provides the best performance and also prevents overloading
-house wiring circuits which could cause a fire hazard from
-overheated wires.
-
-Never unplug your refrigerator by pulling on the power cord.
-Always grip plug firmly and pull straight out from the outlet.
-
-Repair or replace immediately all power cords that have become
-frayed or otherwise damaged. Do not use a cord that shows cracks or
-abrasion damage along its length or at either end.
-
-When moving the refrigerator away from the wall, be careful not to
-roll over or damage the power cord.
-
-USE OF ADAPTER PLUGS
-Because of potential safety hazards under certain
-conditions, we strongly recommend against the use of an
-adapter plug.
-
-However, if you must use an adapter, where local codes permit, a
-temporary connection may be made to a properly grounded 2-prong
-wall outlet by use of a UL-listed adapter available at most local
-hardware stores.
-
-The larger slot in the adapter must be aligned with the larger slot in
-the wall outlet to provide proper polarity in the connection of the
-power cord.
-
-When disconnecting the power cord from the adapter, always hold
-the adapter in place with one hand while pulling the power cord
-plug with the other hand. If this is not done, the adapter ground
-terminal is very likely to break with repeated use.
-
-If the adapter ground terminal breaks, DO NOT USEthe refrigerator
-until a proper ground has been established.
-
-Attaching the adapter ground terminal to a wall outlet cover screw does not
-ground the appliance unless the cover screw is metal, and not insulated, and the
-wall outlet is grounded through the house wiring. You should have the circuit
-checked by a qualified electrician to make sure the outlet is properly grounded.
-
-USE OF EXTENSION CORDS
-Because of potential safety hazards under certain
-conditions, we strongly recommend against the use of an
-extension cord.
-
-However, if you must use an extension cord, it is absolutely
-necessary that it be a UL-listed, 3-wire grounding type appliance
-extension cord having a grounding type plug and outlet and that
-the electrical rating of the cord be 15 amperes (minimum) and
-120 volts.
-
-REMEMBER…
-Your continued health and safety are important to us.
-
-Please read and follow this Safety Information carefully.
-
-We want you to remain a happy and healthy part of our
-family.
-SAVE THESE INSTRUCTIONS
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-7
-
-About the temperature control dial.
-
-Turning the dial to OFFstops cooling in both compartments—
-fresh food and freezer.
-
-9
-
-OFF
-
-7
-
-5
-
-3
-
-1
-
-Control Settings
-Temperature Control Dial
-
-The temperature control dial has nine settings plus OFF.
-1 is the warmest. 9 is the coldest. At first, set the dial at 5.
-
-After using the refrigerator, adjust the dial if necessary.
-
-Insert a coin into the slot in the middle of the dial and you can turn
-the dial to the setting that’s best suited to your needs.
-
-Allow 24 hours for the refrigerator to get cold.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-8
-
-About the fresh food compartment shelves.
-
-Shelf supports at various levels allow you to custom-space your shelves.
-Not all features are on all models.
-
-2 Lift up and out
-
-1 Tilt up
-
-Half-Width Shelves
-
-One end of the shelf rests on a molded side-wall
-support; a bracket on the other end hooks into a track
-on the rear cabinet wall.
-
-To remove,lift the shelf up at front, then off the support
-and out of the track.
-
-To replace,select desired shelf height. With shelf front
-raised slightly, hook the bracket’s top lug into the track,
-then lower the shelf onto the support.
-
-NOTE: The shelf to the right of the track is designed to
-hook into the right-hand slot; the shelf to the left is
-designed to hook into the left-hand slot.
-
-Full-Width Shelves
-
-Some models have a steel wire sliding shelf, a stationary
-tempered glass shelf or two steel wire stationary shelves.
-These shelves can be moved to another place in the
-fresh food compartment.
-
-The full-width sliding shelf has stop-locks. When placed
-correctly on the shelf supports, the shelf will stop before
-coming completely out of the refrigerator and will not
-tilt when you place food on it or remove food from it.
-
-To remove the full-width shelves,lift the rear of the shelf
-and pull forward.
-
-To remove a full-width shelf when the fresh food
-compartment door cannot be opened fully,lift the rear of
-the shelf, pull forward and down, tilt the shelf and take it
-out.
-
-9
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-About the freezer compartment shelves.
-
-Some models have an ice-tray shelf and some have a full-width step shelf.
-
-Plug Supports
-
-Ice-Tray Shelf
-
-To remove the ice-tray shelf:Lift the left side of the shelf
-off its supports, then pull the shelf to the left to free it of
-the plug supports. Pull the shelf to the right to free the
-pins from the holes in the cabinet wall.
-
-(cid:49)
-
-(cid:50)
-
-Step Shelf
-
-To remove the step shelf:
-
-1
-2
-
-3
-
-Lift left side of shelf slightly.
-
-Move shelf to the left to free its right ends from holes
-in the cabinet wall.
-
-Lower right side of shelf, move shelf to the right and
-take it out.
-
-To replace the step shelf:
-
-1
-
-2
-
-With shelf tilted as shown, fit left ends of shelf into
-holes in cabinet wall.
-
-Lift left side of shelf slightly, swing shelf up, fit right
-ends of shelf into holes in cabinet wall, and lower
-shelf into place.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-10
-
-About the storage drawers.
-
-Not all features are on all models.
-
-Fruit and Vegetable Drawers
-
-Excess water that may accumulate in the bottom of the
-drawers should be emptied and the drawers wiped dry.
-
-Utility Drawer
-
-The utility drawer can be moved to the most useful
-location for your family’s needs.
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-11
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-12
-
-About storage drawer and cover removal.
-
-Not all features are on all models.
-
-Drawer and Cover Removal
-
-Drawers will stop before coming all the way out of the refrigerator to
-help prevent contents from spilling onto the floor. These drawers
-can be removed easily by grasping the sides and lifting up slightly
-while pulling drawers past the stoplocation.
-
-Full-Width Drawer with Plastic Cover
-
-To remove the cover, lift it off its supports, pull it
-forward, tilt it and take it out.
-
-Twin Drawer With Glass Cover
-
-To remove:
-
-1
-2
-
-Remove the drawers.
-
-Reach in, push the front of glass cover up and, at the
-same time, pull it forward as far as it will come.
-
-Tilt it and take it out. Avoid cleaning the cold glass cover
-with hot water because the extreme temperature
-difference may cause it to break.
-
-3
-
-Remove the drawer frame. (Always remove the glass
-cover before you take out the drawer frame.)
-
-Lift the frame off the supports at each side and back,
-pull it forward, tilt it and take it out.
-
-To replace:
-
-Lower the frame until it rests on the supports at each
-side and back.
-
-Replace the glass cover, pushing its rear edge firmly
-into the rear frame channel and gently lowering the
-front into place.
-
-Replace the drawers.
-
-1
-
-2
-
-3
-
-About the automatic icemaker.
-
-A newly-installed refrigerator may take 8 to 12 hours to begin making ice.
-
-Icemaker
-
-Feeler arm
-in the STOP
-(up) position
-
-Ice Storage Bin
-
-Automatic Icemaker (on some models)
-
-The icemaker will produce eight cubes per cycle—
-approximately 100 cubes in a 24-hour period,
-depending on freezer compartment temperature, room
-temperature, number of door openings and other use
-conditions.
-
-If the refrigerator is operated before the water
-connection is made to the icemaker, keep the feeler arm
-in the STOP (up) position.
-
-Feeler arm in the
-ON (down) position
-
-When the refrigerator has been connected to the water
-supply, move the feeler arm to the ON (down) position.
-
-The icemaker will fill with water when it cools to
-freezing. A newly-installed refrigerator may take 8 to 12
-hours to begin making ice cubes.
-
-Throw away the first few batches of ice to allow the water
-line to clear.
-
-Be sure nothing interferes with the swing of the feeler
-arm.
-
-It is normal for several cubes to be joined together.
-
-If ice is not used frequently, old ice cubes will become
-cloudy and taste stale.
-
-Icemaker Accessory Kit
-
-If your refrigerator did not come already equipped with an
-automatic icemaker, an icemaker accessory kit is available at extra
-cost. Check the back of the refrigerator for the specific icemaker kit
-needed for your model.
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-13
-
-Care and cleaning of the refrigerator.
-
-Cleaning the Outside
-
-The door handles and trim (on some models). Clean with a cloth
-dampened with soapy water. Dry with a soft cloth.
-
-Keep the outside clean.Wipe with a clean cloth lightly dampened
-with kitchen appliance wax or mild liquid dish detergent. Dry and
-polish with a clean, soft cloth.
-
-Do not wipe the refrigerator with a soiled dish cloth or wet towel. These may
-leave a residue that can erode the paint. Do not use scouring pads, powdered
-cleaners, bleach or cleaners containing bleach because these products can
-scratch and weaken the paint finish.
-
-Cleaning the Inside
-
-To help prevent odors, leave an open box of baking soda in the fresh
-food and freezer compartments.
-
-Unplug the refrigerator before cleaning. If this is not practical, wring
-excess moisture out of sponge or cloth when cleaning around
-switches, lights or controls.
-
-Use warm water and baking soda solution—about a tablespoon
-(15 ml) of baking soda to a quart (1 L) of water. This both cleans
-and neutralizes odors. Rinse and wipe dry.
-
-Use an appliance wax polish on the inside surface between the
-doors.
-
-After cleaning the door gaskets, apply a thin layer of petroleum jelly
-to the door gaskets at the hinge side. This helps keep the gaskets
-from sticking and bending out of shape.
-
-Avoid cleaning cold glass shelves (on some models) with hot water because the
-extreme temperature difference may cause them to break. Handle glass shelves
-carefully. Bumping tempered glass can cause it to shatter.
-
-Do not wash any plastic refrigerator parts in the dishwasher.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-14
-
-Under the Refrigerator
-
-For most efficient operation, keep the area under the
-refrigerator clean. Turn the temperature control dial to
-OFF. Sweep away or vacuum up dust.
-
-Clean the condenser coils at least
-once a year.
-
-For best results, use a brush specially designed for this
-purpose. It is available at most appliance parts stores.
-
-Behind the Refrigerator
-
-Be careful when moving the refrigerator away from the wall. All
-types of floor coverings can be damaged, particularly cushioned
-coverings and those with embossed surfaces.
-
-Turn the leveling legs at each front corner of the refrigerator
-counterclockwise until the rollers support the refrigerator. Pull
-the refrigerator straight out and return it to position by pushing it
-straight in. Moving the refrigerator in a side direction may result in
-damage to the floor covering or refrigerator.
-
-When pushing the refrigerator back, make sure you don’t roll over the power
-cord or icemaker supply line (on some models).
-
-After rolling the refrigerator back into place, turn the legs clockwise
-until the legs again bear the weight of the refrigerator.
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-15
-
-Care and cleaning of the refrigerator.
-
-Light Bulb Replacement
-
-To replace a burned out bulb, unplug the refrigerator from its
-electrical outlet, unscrew the bulb when cool and replace it with an
-appliance bulb of the same or lower wattage.
-
-Turning the control to the OFFposition does not remove power to the light circuit.
-
-Preparing for Vacation
-
-For long vacations or absences, remove food and unplug the
-refrigerator. Turn the temperature control dial to the OFF position,
-and clean the interior with a baking soda solution of one tablespoon
-(15 ml) of baking soda to one quart (1 L) of water. Leave the
-doors open.
-
-Move the icemaker feeler arm to STOP (up) position and shut
-off the water supply to the refrigerator.
-
-If the temperature can drop below freezing, have a qualified
-servicer drain the water supply system (on some models) to prevent
-serious property damage due to flooding.
-
-Preparing to Move
-
-Secure all loose items such as grille, shelves and drawers by taping
-them securely in place to prevent damage.
-
-Be sure the refrigerator stays in an upright position during moving.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-16
-
-Preparing to install the refrigerator.
-
-Read these instructions completely and carefully.
-
-Water Supply to the Icemaker (on some models)
-
-If the refrigerator has an icemaker, or if you plan to add an
-icemaker later, it will have to be connected to a cold water line.
-
-A water supply kit (containing copper tubing, shutoff valve, fittings
-and instructions) is available at extra cost from your dealer or from
-Parts and Accessories, 800-626-2002.
-
-Refrigerator Location
-
-Do not install the refrigerator where the temperature will go below
-60°F. (16°C.) because it will not run often enough to maintain
-proper temperatures.
-
-Install it on a floor strong enough to support it fully loaded.
-
-Clearances
-
-Allow the following clearances for ease of installation, proper air
-circulation and plumbing and electrical connections:
-3/4† (19 mm)
-1† (25 mm)
-1† (25 mm)
-
-Sides
-
-Back
-
-Top
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-17
-
-Preparing to install the refrigerator.
-
-Read these instructions completely and carefully.
-
-Rollers and Leveling Legs
-
-Leveling legsnear each front corner of the refrigerator are adjustable. They
-firmly position the refrigerator and prevent it from moving when the doors are
-opened. Leveling legs should be set so the front of the refrigerator is raised just
-enough that the doors close easily when opened about halfway.
-
-Turn the leveling legs clockwise to raisethe refrigerator, counterclockwise to
-lower it.
-
-Rollersnext to the leveling legs allow you to move the refrigerator away from the
-wall for cleaning.
-
-Turn the legs counterclockwise until the weight of the refrigerator is transferred
-from them to the rollers. After rolling the refrigerator back into place, turn the
-legs clockwise until the legs again bear the weight of the refrigerator.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-18
-
-Installing the water line.
-
-Read these instructions completely and carefully.
-
-Before You Begin
-This water line installation is not warranted by the
-refrigerator or icemaker manufacturer. Follow these
-instructions carefully to minimize the risk of expensive
-water damage.
-
-Water hammer (water banging in the pipes) in house
-plumbing can cause damage to refrigerator parts and lead
-to water leakage or flooding. Call a qualified plumber to
-correct water hammer before installing the water supply
-line to the refrigerator.
-
-To prevent burns and product damage, do not hook up the
-water line to the hot water line.
-
-If you use your refrigerator before connecting the water
-line, make sure the icemaker feeler arm is kept in the STOP
-(up) position.
-
-Do not install the icemaker tubing in areas where
-temperatures fall below freezing.
-
-When using any electrical device (such as a power drill)
-during installation, be sure the device is insulated or wired
-in a manner to prevent the hazard of electric shock.
-
-All installations must be in accordance with local plumbing
-code requirements.
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-19
-
-Installing the water line.
-
-Read these instructions completely and carefully.
-
-What You Will Need
-To determine how much copper tubing you need:
-
-Measure the distance from the water valve on the back of the
-refrigerator to the water supply pipe. Then add 8 feet (244 cm).
-Be sure there is sufficient extra tubing [about 8 feet (244 cm)
-coiled into 3 turns of about 10 inches (25 cm) diameter] to allow
-the refrigerator to move out from the wall after installation.
-n A water supply kit(containing copper tubing, shutoff valve and
-fittings listed below) is available at extra cost from your dealer
-or from Parts and Accessories, 800-626-2002.
-
-n Cold water supply.The water pressure must be between
-
-20 and 120 p.s.i.
-
-n Power drill.
-
-n Copper tubing,1/4† outer diameter to connect the refrigerator to
-the water supply. Be sure both ends of the tubing are cut square.
-
-Do not use plastic tubing or plastic fittings because the water supply line is
-under pressure at all times. Certain types of plastic tubing may become brittle
-with age and crack, resulting in water leakage.
-
-n Two 1/4† outer diameter compression nuts and 2 ferrules (sleeves)—
-
-to connect the copper tubing to the shutoff valve and the
-refrigerator water valve.
-
-n If your existing water line has a flared fitting at the end, you will
-
-need an adapter(available at plumbing supply stores) to connect
-the water line to the refrigerator ORyou can cut off the flared
-fitting with a tube cutter and then use a compression fitting.
-n Shutoff valve to connect to the cold water line. The shutoff valve
-should have a water inlet with a minimum inside diameter of
-5/32† at the point of connection to the COLD WATER LINE.Saddle-
-type shutoff valves are included in many water supply kits. Before
-purchasing, make sure a saddle-type valve complies with your
-local plumbing codes.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-20
-
-Shut Off the Main Water Supply
-
-Turn on the nearest faucet long enough to clear the line of water.
-
-Install the Shutoff Valve
-1
-2
-
-Install the shutoff valve on the nearest frequently used drinking water line.
-
-Choose a location for the valve that is easily accessible. It is best to connect
-into the side of a vertical water pipe. When it is necessary to connect into a
-horizontal water pipe, make the connection to the top or side, rather than at
-the bottom, to avoid drawing off any sediment from the water pipe.
-Drill a 1/4† hole in the water pipe, using a sharp bit. Remove any burrs
-resulting from drilling the hole in the pipe.
-
-3
-
-4
-5
-
-Fasten the shutoff valve to the cold water pipe with the pipe clamp.
-
-Tighten the clamp screws until the sealing washer begins to swell.
-
-Do not overtighten or you may crush the copper tubing.
-
-Pipe Clamp
-
-Washer
-
-Inlet End
-
-Saddle-Type Shutoff Valve
-
-Vertical Cold Water Pipe
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-21
-
-Installing the water line.
-
-Read these instructions completely and carefully.
-
-Route the Copper Tubing and Connect It to the Shutoff Valve
-
-Route the copper tubing between the cold water line and the refrigerator.
-
-Route the tubing through a hole drilled in the wall or floor (behind the
-refrigerator or adjacent base cabinet) as close to the wall as possible.
-
-Be sure there is sufficient extra tubing [about 8 feet (244 cm) coiled into 3 turns of about
-10† (25 cm) diameter] to allow the refrigerator to move out from the wall after installation.
-
-Place the compression nut and ferrule (sleeve) onto the end of the tubing and
-connect it to the shutoff valve.
-
-Make sure the tubing is fully inserted into the valve. Tighten the compression nut
-securely.
-
-Saddle-Type Shutoff Valve
-
-Compression Nut
-
-Packing
-Nut
-
-Outlet Valve
-
-Ferrule (sleeve)
-
-Turn On the Water and Flush Out the Tubing
-1
-
-Turn the main water supply on and flush out the tubing until the water
-is clear.
-
-2
-
-Shut the water off at the water valve after about one quart (1 L) of water has
-been flushed through the tubing.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-22
-
-Connect the Tubing to the Refrigerator
-
-Before making the connection to the refrigerator, be sure the
-refrigerator power cord is not plugged into the wall outlet.
-
-We recommend installing a water filter if your water supply has sand or particles
-that could clog the screen of the refrigerator’s water valve. Install it in the water
-line near the refrigerator.
-
-1
-2
-
-3
-
-4
-
-Remove the plastic flexible cap from the water valve.
-
-Place the compression nut and ferrule (sleeve) onto the end of the tubing as
-shown.
-
-Insert the end of the copper tubing into the water valve connection as far as
-possible. While holding the tubing, tighten the fitting.
-
-Fasten the copper tubing into the clamp provided to hold it in a vertical
-position. You may need to pry open the clamp.
-
-1/4† Copper Tubing
-
-Tubing Clamp
-
-Ferrule (sleeve)
-
-1/4† Compression Nut
-
-Refrigerator Connection
-
-Turn the Water On at the Shutoff Valve
-
-Tighten any connections that leak.
-
-Plug In the Refrigerator
-
-Arrange the coil of copper tubing so that it does not vibrate against the back of
-the refrigerator or against the wall.
-
-Push the refrigerator back to the wall.
-
-Start the Icemaker
-
-Set the icemaker feeler arm to the ON (down) position. The icemaker will
-not begin to operate until it reaches its operating temperature of 15°F. (-9°C.)
-or below. It will then begin operation automatically if the icemaker feeler arm
-is in the ON(down) position.
-
-NOTE: The icemaker may double-cycle when it first starts, causing some water spillage from
-the icemaker into the ice bucket. This is normal and should not happen again.
-
-23
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-Reversing the door swing.
-
-Read these instructions completely and carefully.
-
-Important Notes
-When reversing the door swing :
-
-n Read the instructions all the way through before starting.
-n Handle parts carefully to avoid scratching paint.
-n Set screws down by their related parts to avoid using them in the
-
-wrong places.
-
-n Provide a non-scratching work surface for the doors.
-IMPORTANT: Once you begin, do not move the cabinet until
-door-swing reversal is completed.
-
-These instructions are for changing the hinges from the
-right side to the left side—if you ever want to change the
-hinges back to the right side, follow these same instructions
-and reverse all references to left and right.
-
-Tools Required
-n 5/16† hex-head socket screwdriver
-n Masking tape
-n T20 or T25 Torxdriver, whichever your model requires
-n Putty knife or thin-blade screwdriver
-n 5/16† open-end wrench
-n Phillips screwdriver
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-24
-
-Removing the doors.
-
-Unplug the refrigerator from its electrical outlet.
-
-Before Removing the Doors
-1
-2
-CAUTION: Do not let either door drop to the floor. To do so could
-damage the door stop.
-
-Empty all door shelves, including the dairy compartment.
-
-Remove the Freezer Door
-1
-2
-
-Tape the door shut with masking tape.
-With a 5/16† hex-head socket screwdriver, remove the screws that hold the
-top hinge to the cabinet.
-
-3
-
-4
-
-5
-6
-
-Lift the hinge (and the shim glued to it) straight up to free the hinge pin
-from the socket in the top of the door and set it aside, along with its screws.
-
-Remove the tape, tilt the door away from the cabinet and carefully lift the
-door to free its bottom socket from the hinge pin on the center hinge
-bracket.
-
-Set the door on a non-scratching surface with the outside up.
-
-Using a Torxdriver, transfer the 2 screws from the opposite side of the
-cabinet to the screw holes vacated by the top hinge removal.
-
-Top Hinge
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-25
-
-Removing the doors/Reversing the hardware.
-
-Read these instructions completely and carefully.
-
-Remove the Fresh Food Door
-1
-2
-
-Tape the door shut with masking tape.
-Using a 5/16† hex-head socket screwdriver and a 5/16† open-end wrench,
-remove the two screws holding the center hinge (and the shim glued to it) to
-the cabinet. Lift the center hinge to free its pin from the socket in the top of
-the door, and set hinge and screws aside.
-
-3
-
-4
-5
-
-6
-
-Remove the tape and tilt the door away from the cabinet. Lift the door from
-the pin in the bottom hinge bracket. (If the plastic washer sticks to the door
-bottom, put it back on the hinge.)
-
-Set the door outside-up on a non-scratching surface.
-
-Using a Torxdriver, transfer the two screws from the opposite side of the
-cabinet to the screw holes vacated by the center hinge removal.
-
-Take one of the screws removed in step 2 and start it in the outermost screw
-hole on the opposite side. Do not drive it all the way down—leave enough
-space under the screw head for thickness of shim and bracket.
-
-Center Hinge Bracket
-
-Hinge Pin
-
-Plastic Washer
-
-Transfer Bottom Hinge to the Left
-1
-
-Remove the base grille (if your refrigerator has one) by pulling it straight
-out.
-
-2
-
-Using a Torxdriver, move the bottom hinge bracket (and the shim glued to
-it) and plastic washer from the right side to the left side.
-
-Plastic Washer
-
-Hinge Bracket
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-26
-
-Reversing the door handles.
-
-Transfer Top Hinge to the Left
-
-Interchange hinge (and the shim glued to it) and screws at top right with screws
-at top left of cabinet.
-
-Do not tighten screws on hinge side at this time.
-
-Some hinges have four holes. Which holes you use for installing the hinge
-depends on which side you install the hinge.
-
-Installing the hinge on the left.
-
-Installing the hinge on the right.
-
-Transfer Fresh Food Door Handle
-
-Top View
-
-Bottom View
-
-1
-
-2
-
-3
-4
-
-Remove the bottom cap by
-pushing it toward the bottom of
-the door and remove the screw
+Forms are the moulds into which concrete or
+another material is poured.
+
+Formwork is a system of forms connected
+together.
+
+Gangforms are large panels designed to be hoisted
+as a unit, and to be erected, stripped, and re-used.
+
+Knock-down forms are traditional formwork
+supported by falsework and shoring, assembled
+from bulk materials, used once, and then
+dismantled.
+
+Panels are sections of form intended to be
+connected together.
+
+Sheathing is the material directly supported by
+wales, and against which concrete is to be placed.
+
+Specialty formwork is designed specifically for a
+particular structure or placing technique.
+
+Struts are vertical members of shoring that directly
+resist pressure from wales.
+
+Wales are horizontal members of shoring that are
+placed against sheathing to directly resist pressure
+from the sheathing.
+
+Introduction
+
+In most cases, the formwork required for concrete
+construction is built by carpenters. Shoring and
+bracing support the forms that contain the wet
+concrete. Formwork must also support the temporary
+weight of material such as bundles of reinforcing
+steel and live loads of workers and equipment.
+
+There are three stages in formwork operations:
+
+1. Assembly and erection
+
+2. Concrete placement
+
+3. Stripping and dismantling.
+
+To be done safely, each of these jobs requires
+planning, knowledge, and skill from both
+supervisors and workers. Design and planning
+are a supervisory function that may also legally
+require a professional engineer’s involvement.
+Small construction and renovation jobs, however,
+sometimes call for typical design work (e.g.,
+specific heights and sizes from the manufacturer),
+which can be done on site by workers.
+
+Where design drawings are provided, it is
+important to construct the formwork as designed.
+Any confusion regarding the design should be
+approved by the designer.
+
+If site conditions require changes or the design
+does not seem to suit the situation, changes
+and approval should also be obtained from the
+designer. Formwork failures frequently involve
+deviations from the original design that were done
+without consulting the designer. They may also
+involve human error. For these reasons, formwork
+and shoring must always be inspected before
+concrete is placed.
+
+All large formwork installations in Ontario must be
+designed by a professional engineer. But there are
+always smaller jobs of moderate height or depth—
+basements, footings, stairs—that may include
+formwork with typical design arrangements from
+a form tie manufacturer, which is installed and
+constructed on the site.
+
+Every carpenter should therefore know the type
+of formwork needed and how to build, install, and
+dismantle it safely.
+
+Formwork must always be constructed according
+to good, safe, and sound carpentry practice. It must
+have the following:
+
+• Adequate braces and supports
+
+• Reliable bearing surfaces, especially where wood
+
+structures are involved
+
+• Adequate ties, bolts, or bracing to prevent
+
+movement or bulging.
+
+Because wood is relatively soft, it will crush under
+heavy loads such as concrete when the bearing
+surface of joists on stringers, or studs on wales, is
+not adequate.
+
+Crushing can be avoided by increasing the bearing
+area between members, using spreader washers
+(Figure 42-1), or increasing the number of joists
+or studs.
+
+Figure 42-1: Spreader Washer on
+Wooden Wale System
+
+Tools and Techniques
+
+42-1
+
+FORMWORK
+
+Hazards
+
+The following are the main hazard areas in
+formwork operations.
+
+• Falls – They are the major hazard because they are
+potentially fatal. Cramped work areas, inadequate
+access, failure to install guardrails, failure to use fall
+arrest systems, tools or material left underfoot, and
+surfaces slippery from form oil can all lead to falls.
+Ladders are also frequently involved in falls. All
+workers in Ontario who may be exposed to a fall
+hazard and who may use a fall protection system
+must have working at heights training that has been
+approved by the Chief Prevention Officer. (See
+Chapter 18: Guardrails and Chapter 19: Personal
+Fall Protection)
+
+• Dust and concrete – Blowing dust and flying
+
+concrete particles during the chipping or cleaning
+of formwork can injure unprotected eyes.
+
+• Access equipment – Access equipment such as
+ladders and scaffolds is involved not only in falls
+but in slips, trips, and other accidents. Hazards
+include ladders not tied off, workers carrying
+materials while climbing, ladders obstructed at
+top or bottom, scaffolds not completely decked
+in, and scaffolds erected or dismantled without
+fall protection.
+
+• Lighting – Inadequate lighting can create or
+
+aggravate hazards when workers install or strip
+forms in dark areas or place concrete at night.
+
+• Materials handling – The activity most frequently
+
+Injuries
+
+connected with injury. Improper or excessive
+materials handling can result in sprains, strains,
+and overexertion in shoulders, arms, and back, as
+well as bruises, abrasions, and crushed fingers.
+
+• Struck against – Common because formwork
+
+operations are constantly changing and involve
+the movement of heavy, awkward, and pointed
+components. Wales, beams, panels, snap-ties,
+nails, bolts, and rebar can cause punctures, cuts,
+contusions, and abrasions.
+
+• Struck by – Another common cause of injury.
+Rebar, formwork panels, concrete buckets,
+and other material hoisted overhead can strike
+workers. Struck-by injuries can also be caused by
+hammers, pry bars, stakes, wedges, and material
+such as joists and panels during stripping.
+
+• Electrical contact – Power tools, extension cords,
+and temporary supply and wiring systems, used
+under less-than-ideal conditions – mud, ground
+water, wet excavations, fresh concrete – can lead
+to ground faults, shortcircuits, and shock hazards.
+Ground fault circuit interrupters are legally
+required for portable tools used outdoors or in
+wet locations.
+
+• Collapses – Even with advanced methods of
+
+design and installation, there is always the risk
+that formwork, slabforms, wall forms, and other
+large components can come loose, slip out of
+place, or fall over, striking or crushing workers
underneath.
-Remove the two screws holding
-the handle to the top of the door.
-
-Remove the handle.
-
-Remove the screws from the right
-edge of the door top and insert
-them into the handle screw holes
-on the opposite side.
-
-5
-
-6
-
-With tape-tipped putty knife or
-thin-blade screwdriver, pry out the
-plug button from the hinge hole
-on the left side of the door and
-insert it into the hole on the
-opposite side that was vacated by
-removal of the top hinge.
-
-Pull the plug button from the
-front of the door and transfer it to
-the opposite side.
-
-Plug Button
-
-Screws for
-Handle Holes
-
-Plug Button
-
-To reattach the handle on the
-opposite side.
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-27
-
-Rehanging the doors.
-
-Read these instructions completely and carefully.
-
-Transfer Door Stop
-1
-
-Move the metal door stop from
-the right end to the left end. Use a
-Torxdriver.
-
-Door Stop
-
-2
-
-Move any screws from the left end
-to the right end.
-
-Right Side
-
-Left Side
-
-Reinstalling the Fresh Food Door Handle
-1
-
-Attach the handle to the right side of the door with screws at the top and
-under the handle plug.
-
-Reinstall the handle plug.
-
-2
-Transfer Freezer Door Handle
-1
-
-Remove the screw holding the handle to the top of the door and the two
-screws holding the handle to the bottom of the door.
-
-2
-3
-
-4
-
-5
-6
-
-Remove the handle.
-
-Remove the screw from the right top edge of the door and insert it into the
-handle screw hole on the left side.
-
-Pull the plug button from the left top edge of the door and transfer it to the
-opposite side.
-
-Transfer the door stop as shown above.
-
-Attach the handle to the right edge of the door with screws at top and
-bottom, using bottom holes vacated by removal of the door stop screws.
-
-Left Side
-
-Right Side
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-28
-
-Rehang the Fresh Food Door
-1
-
-Lower the bottom socket of the fresh food door onto the pin on the bottom
-hinge.
-
-Be sure the washer is in place on the pin.
-
-2
-
-3
-
-Insert the pin on the center hinge into the socket in the top of the door.
-NOTE:The center hinge must be turned over as shown when mounted on the
-left side.
-
-Tilt the door toward the cabinet. As the door is brought into position, slide
-the hinge under the head of the screw which earlier had been partly driven
-into the outermost hole. Insert the remaining screw, then tighten both
-screws securely.
-
-Hinge Pin
-
-Plastic
-Washer
-
-Hinge Pin
-
-Plastic Washer
-
-Rehang the Freezer Door
-1
-
-Be sure the washer is in place on the pin.
-
-Lower the bottom socket of the freezer door onto the center hinge pin.
-
-2
-
-3
-
-Tilt the door toward the cabinet, lifting the top hinge so the pin fits into the
-socket on the top of the door.
-
-Make sure the door is straight and the gap between the doors is even
-across the front. Tighten the top hinge screws. Do not overtighten these
-screws—tighten them until they are just snug, then turn them another one-
-half turn.
-
-Center Hinge Pin
-
-Plastic Washer
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-29
-
-Normal operating sounds.
-
-Depending on the placement of the refrigerator in your kitchen,
-you may want to place a piece of rubber backed carpet under
-the refrigerator to reduce noise.
-
-The fan circulating air inside the freezer which
-keeps the temperatures even.
-
-Boiling water or a gurgling noise. The flow of
-refrigerant through the freezer cooling coils.
-
-Sizzling, hissing or popping sound. Water
-dropping on the defrost heater during the
-defrost cycle.
-
-Cracking or popping sound. Cooling coils
-expanding and contracting during the
-defrosting cycle.
-
-Water dripping as it melts from the evaporator
-and flows to the drain pan during the defrost
-cycle.
-
-Icemaker (on some models)
-
-The icemaker water valve will buzz when the
-icemaker fills with water. If the feeler arm is in
-the ON(down) position it will buzz even if it has
-not yet been hooked up to water. Keeping the
-feeler arm in the ON(down) position before it is
-hooked up to water can damage the icemaker.
-To prevent this, raise the feeler arm to the STOP
-(up) position. This will stop the buzzing.
-
-The sound of cubes dropping into the bin and
-water running in pipes as icemaker refills.
-
-These sounds are normal
-and are due mostly to highly
-efficient operation.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-30
-
-Before you call for service…
-
-Troubleshooting Tips
-Save time and money! Review the charts on the following pages first and
-you may not need to call for service.
-
-Problem
-
-Possible Causes
-
-What To Do
-
-Refrigerator does not
-operate
-
-Refrigerator in
-defrost cycle.
-
-Temperature control
-dial in OFFposition.
-
-Refrigerator is
-unplugged.
-
-The fuse is blown/
-circuit breaker is
-tripped.
-
-Normal when
-refrigerator is first
-plugged in.
-
-Often occurs when large
-amounts of food are
-placed in refrigerator.
-
-Door left open.
-
-• Wait about 30 minutes for
-
-defrost cycle to end.
-
-• Move the temperature
-
-control dial to a
-temperature setting.
-
-• Push the plug completely
-
-into the outlet.
-
-• Replace fuse or reset the
-
-breaker.
-
-• Wait 24 hours for the
-
-refrigerator to completely
-cool down.
-
-• This is normal.
-
-• Check to see if package is
-
-holding door open.
-
-Hot weather or frequent
-door openings.
-
-• This is normal.
-
-Temperature control dial
-set at the coldest setting.
-
-• See About the temperature
-
-control dial.
-
-Grille and condenser
-need cleaning.
-
-Front roller screws or
-front leveling legs need
-adjusting.
-
-• See Care and cleaning.
-
-• See Rollers and leveling legs.
-
-Motor operates for long
-periods or cycles on and
-off frequently. (Modern
-refrigerators with more
-storage space and a larger
-freezer require more
-operating time. They start
-and stop often to maintain
-even temperatures.)
-
-Vibration or rattling
-(slight vibration is normal)
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-31
-
-Before you call for service…
-
-Troubleshooting Tips
-
-Problem
-
-Possible Causes
-
-What To Do
-
-Fresh food or freezer
-compartment too warm
-
-Temperature control
-dial not set cold enough.
-
-• See About the temperature
-
-control dial.
-
-Warm weather or
-frequent door openings.
-
-Door left open.
-
-Package blocking air
-duct in freezer
-compartment.
-
-Door left open.
-
-Too frequent or too
-long door openings.
-
-• Set the temperature
-control dial one step
-colder. See About the
-temperature control dial.
-
-• Check to see if package is
-
-holding door open.
-
-• Check to see if package is
-
-blocking air duct in freezer
-compartment.
-
-• Check to see if package is
-
-holding door open.
-
-Icemaker feeler arm in
-STOP (up) position.
-
-• Move the feeler arm to the
-
-ON (down) position.
-
-Water supply turned
-off or not connected.
-
-Freezer compartment
-too warm.
-
-Water shutoff valve
-connecting refrigerator
-to water line may be
-clogged.
-
-• See Installing thewater line.
-
-• Wait 24 hours for the
-
-refrigerator to completely
-cool down.
-
-• Call a plumber to clear
-
-the valve.
-
-Frost or ice crystals on
-frozen food (frost within
-package is normal)
-
-Automatic icemaker
-does not work
-(on some models)
-
-Cubes too small
-
-Slow ice cube freezing
-
-Door left open.
-
-• Check to see if package is
-
-holding door open.
-
-Temperature control
-dial not set cold enough.
-
-• See About the temperature
-
-control dial.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-32
-
-Problem
-
-Ice cubes have
-odor/taste
-
-Possible Causes
-
-What To Do
-
-Ice storage bin needs
-cleaning.
-
-• Empty and wash bin.
-Discard old cubes.
-
-Food transmitting odor/
-taste to ice cubes.
-
-Interior of refrigerator
-needs cleaning.
-
-• Wrap foods well.
-
-• See Care andcleaning.
-
-Moisture forms on
-cabinet surface
-between the doors
-
-Moisture collects inside
-(in humid weather, air
-carries moisture into
-refrigerator when doors
-are opened)
-
-Refrigerator has odor
-
-Not unusual during
-periods of high
-humidity.
-
-Too frequent or too
-long door openings.
-
-Foods transmitting
-odor to refrigerator.
-
-• Wipe surface dry and
-
-reset temperature control
-dial one setting colder.
-
-• Foods with strong odors
-
-should be tightly wrapped.
-• Keep an open box of baking
-soda in the refrigerator;
-replace every three months.
-
-Interior needs cleaning.
-
-• See Care and cleaning.
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-33
-
-Notes
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-34
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-35
-
-Notes
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-36
-
-GE Service Protection Plus™
-
-GE, a name recognized worldwide for quality and dependability,
-offers you Service Protection Plus™—comprehensive protection on
-all your appliances—No Matter What Brand!
-
-Benefits Include:
-• Backed by GE
-• All brands covered
-• Unlimited service calls
-• All parts and labor costs included
-• No out-of-pocket expenses
-• No hidden deductibles
-• One 800 number to call
-
-We’ll Cover Any Appliance.
-Anywhere. Anytime.*
-
-You will be completely satisfied with our service protection or you may request your
-money back on the remaining value of your contract. No questions asked. It’s that simple.
-
-Protect your refrigerator, dishwasher, washer and dryer, range, TV, VCR and much
-more—any brand! Plus there’s no extra charge for emergency service and low monthly
-financing is available. Even icemaker coverage and food spoilage protection is offered.
-You can rest easy, knowing that all your valuable household products are protected
-against expensive repairs.
-
-Place your confidence in GE and call us in the U.S. toll-free at 800-626-2224
-for more information.
-
-*All brands covered, up to 20 years old, in the continental U.S.
-
-"
-
-Cut here
-
-Please place in envelope and mail to:
-
-General Electric Company
-Warranty Registration Department
-P.O. Box 34070
-Louisville, KY 40232-4070
-
-37
-
-Consumer Product Ownership Registration
-Dear Customer:
-Thank you for purchasing our product and thank you for placing your confidence in us.
-We are proud to have you as a customer!
+• Health hazards – The spraying of form oils and
+
+curing compounds can irritate the lungs. Contact
+with these chemicals can irritate the skin, leading
+to redness, inflammation, or dermatitis. The
+same conditions can result from the abrasive/
+corrosive effect of skin contact with concrete or
+cement, especially when inadvertently left inside
+boots all day.
+
+• Environmental conditions – Ice, snow, and rain
+create slippery conditions. Wind can be a major
+hazard. Handling sheets of plywood becomes
+more difficult, panels may require more bracing,
+and hoisting gets harder, especially with large
+panels or tables.
+
+Formwork hazards can lead to the injuries
+described below. Follow the safety tips to prevent
+such injuries.
+
+• Eye injuries – These are quite common in
+
+formwork operations. Most result from particles
+of wood or concrete that fall or are blown into
+the eye during chipping and cleaning. The injuries
+may not be severe but most can be prevented
+by wearing eye protection. It is strongly
+recommended that everyone on site wear eye
+protection at all times.
+
+• Cuts, scrapes, punctures – The manhandling
+
+necessary to install and strip formwork can lead
+to cut hands, arms, and legs, as well as pinched
+or crushed fingers. Gloves help to prevent
+injuries from rough or sharp edges on formwork
+components. But workers must also have the
+knowledge, skill, and physical ability necessary
+for safe materials handling. That means knowing
+your limitations and asking for help when needed.
+Formwork involves protruding objects such as
+nails, snap ties, conduit, and bolts that can give
+you cuts and punctures. Where possible, these
+objects should not be left sticking out or should
+be covered over.
+
+• Back injuries – These injuries are frequently
+
+related to materials handling. The most important
+preventive measure is back care. Exercise
+programs, warm-ups before work, and knowing
+your limitations can help to prevent sprains and
+strains. Wherever necessary, get help or use
+dollies, carts, or other mechanical devices.
+
+• Ankle sprains and fractures – Working in
+close quarters, stepping over debris and
+material, climbing into excavations, turning with
+awkward loads, jumping down from scaffolds
+or benches—these can lead to ankle and other
+foot or leg injuries. Prevention starts with proper
+housekeeping and materials handling.
+
+• Bruises and contusions – Handling formwork
+
+under rushed, cramped, or slippery conditions or
+beyond a person's physical limitations can lead to
+bruises. Bruises and contusions also result from
+contact with protruding formwork components.
+
+42-2
+
+Construction Health and Safety ManualFORMWORK
+
+More serious are contusions from falling formwork
+materials. Formwork must be braced to ensure
+stability, especially under windy conditions. Try
+to avoid areas where work such as hoisting or
+stripping is being done overhead.
+
+• Fall injuries – All of the injuries above, and many
+others, can result from falls. Most falls are caused
+by missing or inadequate guardrails, failure to use
+fall-arrest equipment, failure to completely plank
+scaffolds and other work platforms, and standing
+or climbing on surfaces not meant to be used as
+such – the tops of wall forms or 2 x 4 wales, for
+example. Installing and stripping formwork often
+requires the use of a fall-arrest system.
+
+• Falls also result from holes left unguarded or
+
+uncovered in formwork. These should be covered
+up or fitted with guardrails as quickly as possible.
+Where this cannot be done, the area should
+be roped off and posted with warning signs to
+prevent unauthorized entry.
+
+Planning
+
+Planning is the first and most important step in
+reducing hazards and preventing injuries.
+
+Because formwork operations must often be
+carried out in congested areas where other trades
+are also working, planning is essential in making the
+most of the time and space available to improve
+safety and efficiency.
+
+Planning is a must for fall protection, work
+platforms, material staging areas, housekeeping,
+and material handling and movement.
+
+Planning should take place at every level from
+manager to supervisor to worker. Planning labour,
+materials, equipment, and work schedules to
+meet design requirements is the responsibility of
+management and supervision. But supervisors and
+workers should come together to plan the details
+of their assigned tasks based on the most effective
+work methods and safety measures.
+
+For example, the normal weight of liquid concrete
+is 150 lb per cubic foot (2,403 kg per cubic metre).
+So a form designed to withstand 600 lb per square
+feet (2929 kg per square metre) of pressure will be
+able to support liquid concrete up to a height of 4
+feet (1.2 metres).
+
+600 lb/ft2 ÷ 150 lb/ft3 = 4 ft
+
+2929 kg/m2 ÷ 2403 kg/m3 = 1.2 m
+
+Other factors determine how long concrete
+will remain liquid, such as temperature, slump,
+vibration, and admixtures. For example, concrete
+will set much more quickly in hot summer weather
+than in cold winter weather. As a result, the same
+form filled at the same pour rate may be subjected
+to greater pressure in winter than in summer.
+
+Concrete pumping may cause additional pressure,
+as well as vibration, on forms and must be
+considered at the design stage. The action of the
+pump sends surges of pressure through the piping
+system which are often transmitted directly to
+the forms, especially for narrow walls or columns.
+Vibration may move the forms or loosen bracing,
+ties, or spreaders.
+
+Pressure acts perpendicular to formwork surfaces
+(Figure 42-2). This causes an outward thrust for
+typical wall or column forms. However, it can also
+cause uplift for battered or sloping forms. These
+require hold-down anchors or tie-down braces. The
+anchors will prevent the forms from lifting up or
+floating on the concrete.
+
+Expansion Anchors Holding
+Down Battered Form
+
+Design
+
+Safety and economy are the main factors in design.
+Both have to be considered because adjustments in
+one affect the other.
+
+For example, reducing the support structure for
+wall forms in expectation of reduced pouring rates
+should not be considered if the rate of pour is not
+going to be controlled on the job.
+
+Fresh concrete exerts a pressure on formwork
+similar to liquids. Concrete starts to set when
+poured. So if the pour rate is slow, the maximum
+formwork design pressure can be reduced, since
+concrete at the bottom will be set before concrete
+at the top is poured. Similarly, if the forms are
+filled to the top immediately, they must be able to
+withstand the pressure of the full liquid head.
+
+Figure 42-2: Pressure of Concrete on
+Vertical (left) and Battered Formwork
+
+Consider using bracing systems and spreaders for
+wall forms. Concrete filling the bottom of the form
+may cause forces at the top to push the two sides
+together unless they are properly braced and/
+or separated with spreaders. Formwork has to be
+designed to resist such forces. During pouring,
+ensure that spreaders are not removed until concrete
+has reached at least two-thirds of the form height.
+
+Where box forms are used—for instance, on one-
+piece covers for open-cut tunnels—you must use
+bracing against the side thrusts caused by the
+uneven pouring rates of the walls. Resisting these
+forces requires that the system be tied together
+and securely braced (Figure 42-3).
+
+Tools and Techniques
+
+42-3
+
+FORMWORK
+
+Figure 42-3: Open-Cut Tunnel Formwork with
+Bracing and Spreaders on Each Side
+
+Formwork should be designed and constructed
+with stripping and removing as well as pouring in
+mind. On wooden forms, crush plates or filler strips
+should be used at corners such as slab-and-column
+or slab-and-wall intersections (Figure 42-4). The
+plates or strips are easily removed with a wrecking
+bar and, once removed, make the stripping of
+adjacent panels much easier.
+
+Crush Plates
+
+Figure 42-5: Formwork Panel
+
+A formwork panel or wall form to be lifted as a
+single unit must be designed to withstand the
+loads and forces exerted by hoisting (Figure
+42-6). In most cases, this means designing a more
+substantial structure. Fastening components may
+also need more attention at the design stage. For
+example, simple nailing may not be enough to hold
+plywood sheets.
+
+Figure 42-4: Crush Plates
+
+The strips should be big enough to leave space at
+the edges of the panels to accommodate wrecking
+bars.
+
+When formwork has to be manhandled during
+assembly or dismantling, the design should ensure
+that the components are manageable. Formwork
+panels are not only heavy but awkward (Figure
+42-5). Realistic design demands consideration of
+the size as well as the weight of panels.
+
+Figure 42-6: Formwork Lifted as Single Unit
+
+Special attention must also be applied to the design,
+construction, and use of pick points for hoisting. The
+strongbacks and wales must be securely attached
+to the formwork. The pick points must be located
+so that the panel hangs properly during installation,
+concrete placement, and removal.
+
+42-4
+
+Construction Health and Safety ManualFORMWORK
+
+Types of Formwork
+
+Below Grade
+
+The first concern with formwork below grade is
+the stability of the excavation walls. Walls must be
+either shored or sloped according to soil type as
+defined by section 226 of the Construction Projects
+regulation (O.Reg. 213/91). Figure 42-7 shows
+typical slopes.
+
+Good Soil
+
+Fairly
+Good Soil
+
+Max 1.2m
+
+(4 ft.)
+
+Type 1 & 2 Soil
+
+Type 3 Soil
+
+Poor Soil
+
+Type 4 Soil
+
+Figure 42-7: Excavation Slopes for Soil Types
+
+In most cases the shoring must be designed by an
+engineer. Engineers may also specify slopes for
+excavations. In both instances the design drawings
+must be kept on the project.
+
+Excavations should be kept essentially dry. Water
+should be pumped out. Mud should be cleared off
+and replaced by compacted granular material in
+work areas and on surfaces where concrete will be
+placed. Mud presents slipping hazards and can lead
+to inferior construction if not removed or replaced.
+
+Since mud has to be removed before concrete
+is placed, it might as well be removed before
+formwork is constructed, thereby reducing slipping
+hazards at both stages.
+
+Water and mud also contribute to electrical
+hazards. Grounding and insulation must be
+effective and intact. Ground fault circuit
+interrupters (GFCIs) are required by law on all
+portable tools used outdoors or in wet locations.
+
+Formwork for footings and grade walls frequently
+begins before excavation in the area is complete.
+Trucks and excavating equipment put workers on
+foot at the risk of being struck down or run over.
+
+Wherever possible, formwork operations should
+be roped off from other work such as excavation
+or pile-driving (Figure 42-8). Separate access
+ramps for vehicles and workers are strongly
+recommended. Stairs are an even better alternative
+for personnel on foot.
+
+Figure 42-8: Formwork Roped-Off
+from Other Operations
+
+Mud sills must be used to support any shoring or
+bracing that rests on soil in the excavation (Figure
+42-9). The sill must bear on the soil throughout its
+length. Sills should not be used to bridge holes or
+irregular surfaces. To ensure uniform bearing, soil
+should be levelled before sills are set in position.
+
+Figure 42-9: Mud Sills Under Shoring Frames
+
+The soil must have the capacity to bear whatever
+loads are applied (Table 42-1). This information
+may or may not be on the design drawings.
+
+Table 42-1: In Situ Bearing
+Pressure for Dry Soil Conditions
+(Conservative Estimates)
+
+ Silt and clay
+ Sands
+ Gravelly sands
+ Gravel
+
+1,200 lb/ft2 (5,859 kg/m2)
+4,000 lb/ft2 (19,530 kg/m2)
+6,000 lb/ft2 (29,295 kg/m2)
+8,000 lb/ft2 (39,059 kg/m2)
+
+Tools and Techniques
+
+42-5
+
+FORMWORK
+
+Soil that supports bracing or shoring should
+be compacted and qualify as good soil at least
+(cohesive, hard, with no water). Professional advice
+from a geotechnical engineer may be required
+for heavy structures such as elevated equipment
+supports shored at or below grade.
+
+Formwork in these situations is frequently built in
+place. Planning is required to store material and
+equipment out of the way, dispose of scrap and
+debris, and ensure safe, efficient access (Figure
+42-10). Because conditions are often cramped and
+scrap accumulates quickly, it is important to clean
+up as work proceeds.
+
+Starting the Form
+
+Setting up the first form is always hard, heavy,
+manual work. It requires enough workers to do
+the job without overexertion or injury. Whenever
+possible, use mechanical assistance such as a boom,
+truck, or crane for this operation. It will reduce the
+risk of injury to workers and increase productivity.
+
+Temporary bracing (Figure 42-12) is needed from the
+start and at every step to prevent wind loads from
+toppling the forms—historically the cause of many
+serious injuries. A wind speed as low as 30 km/h can
+create a dangerous wind load on formwork.
+
+Figure 42-10: Well-Planned Storage,
+Access, and Setup
+
+Wall Forms
+
+Wall forms built in place are hazardous to
+construct. Hazards include
+
+• Dowels sticking up from concrete slabs or
+
+footings
+
+• Unstable work surfaces and access created by
+
+poor planning
+
+• Manual handling of heavy material such as
+
+plywood sheets, panels, wales, and buckets of
+snap-ties, wedges, and plates
+
+• Slippery surfaces at and below grade
+
+• Inadequate design
+
+• Improper construction.
+
+The best protection against dowels is a wood
+cover built of lumber at least 1 1/2 inches thick and
+wired in place or protective caps placed over the
+exposed ends of rebar (Figure 42-11).
+
+Figure 42-12: Temporary Bracing at
+Start of Form Construction
+
+Access to wall forms is not always given enough
+thought. Forms more than 2 metres high will
+require access platforms for workers involved in
+concrete placing. The platforms can also be used
+to complete the upper portion of the formwork.
+
+An alternative is a frame scaffold, which can also
+be used to install reinforcing steel (Figure 42-13).
+
+Figure 42-11: Protective Covers
+Over Dowels and Rebar
+
+42-6
+
+Figure 42-13: Scaffolding for Access
+
+Construction Health and Safety ManualFall arrest systems or scaffolds with guardrails
+must be used where workers may fall more than
+3 m (10 ft), or onto hazards such as projecting
+dowels (Figure 42-14). In some circumstances, you
+must use fall protection when the height is 2.4 m
+(8 ft) or more. (See chapters on Guardrails and
+Personal Fall Protection.)
+
+FORMWORK
+
+Figure 42-15: Formwork Properly Tied and Braced
+
+Recommended design pressures for various pour
+rates and environmental conditions are set out
+in CAN/CSA S269.1-16: Falsework and Formwork.
+The standard defines a number of other design
+considerations and should be consulted by field staff.
+
+Slab Forms or Falsework Built in Place
+
+With slab forms built in place the major hazard is
+falls. Injuries are also connected with the manual
+handling of heavy materials and components.
+
+Forms built in place usually have to be taken
+down in place after the concrete has hardened
+sufficiently. This should be considered at the
+construction stage. Stability may also be a
+consideration where the structure is high, carries
+heavy loads, and is placed on grade as in bridge
+and overpass construction.
+
+Fall protection is difficult to provide for workers
+building slab forms in place. That’s why planning is
+essential in the design and erection procedure.
+
+Workers should wear a safety harness with the
+lanyard tied off to the structure of the formwork
+(Figure 42-16). This means tying off to the support
+structure where shoring frame structures are being
+constructed, tying off to a lifeline when placing
+plywood panels at a leading edge, constructing
+a guardrail at the edge of the formwork, or tying
+off to the support structure when connecting it
+together with tube and clamp. Don’t wait for the
+structure to be completed before tying-off.
+
+Figure 42-14: Workers Wear Fall Arrest While
+Attaching Wales to Threaded Rods
+
+Materials should be distributed along the work
+location to minimize further handling. But traffic
+and work areas must be kept clear for the safe
+movement and installation of material.
+
+Form Construction
+
+Wall forms must be constructed as designed.
+The design must indicate clearly what is required.
+Some wall forms are designed for specific concrete
+placement rates expressed in metres of height per
+hour (m/hr). A wall form in which concrete is
+placed to a height of one metre in one hour would
+have a placement rate of 1 m/hr. Slower pouring
+rates result in lower formwork pressure because
+the bottom concrete has started to set.
+
+Note: Using a concrete vibrator will increase the
+liquid (hydraulic) pressure on the form in the
+immediate area of the vibration. Over-vibrating the
+concrete while increasing the pour rate can cause
+the formwork to fail.
+
+Ensure that ties and braces are installed where
+indicated on design drawings. Ties should be
+snugged up. Braces should be securely fastened to
+forms and wedged or fastened to a support that
+will not settle or deform under load (Figure 42-15).
+
+Formwork platforms must be:
+
+• Capable of bearing at least 50 lb/ft2
+
+• Adequately supported
+
+• Equipped with guardrails
+
+• Secured at the level or levels where work such as
+
+pouring and stripping will be done.
+
+Figure 42-16: Workers Tie Off to
+Shoring Frames While Placing Stringers
+
+Tools and Techniques
+
+42-7
+
+FORMWORK
+
+Make sure you have fall protection at all stages of
+formwork construction. Wherever possible, cranes or
+other equipment should be used to move material,
+thereby reducing the amount of manual carrying,
+lifting, and handling.
+
+Shoring towers require special consideration.
+
+• Towers must remain stable during construction
+and dismantling. Guys or other bracing and
+supports may be necessary to maintain stability
+(Figure 42-17).
+
+• If towers are to be tied together and braced
+horizontally, this should be done as work
+progresses (Figure 42-18).
+
+• Shoring towers and shores should be installed so
+
+they are plumb to within 1/8 inch in 3 feet.
+
+• Shoring towers should be snugged up under the
+
+stringers with adjustable base plates and U-heads
+(Figure 42-19).
+
+• If frames do not ride tightly on top of one
+
+another after tightening, one or more are out of
+square and should be replaced (Figure 42-20).
+
+• With single-post shores, provide adequate lateral
+bracing (Figure 42-21). Stairwells and balconies
+are places where horizontal bracing for single-
+post shoring systems may be required.
+
+Figure 42-19: Typical Shoring Tower with
+Stringers, Adjustable Base Plates, and U-Heads
+
+Replace this frame.
+
+Figure 42-17: High Towers with Guys for Support
+
+Figure 42-20: Frame Bent Out of Shape
+
+Figure 42-18: Towers Tied
+Together and Braced Horizontally
+
+Figure 42-21: Single-Post
+Shores with Lateral Bracing
+
+42-8
+
+Construction Health and Safety ManualFORMWORK
+
+Using forms designed for typical floors in non-
+typical situations has resulted in serious accidents.
+Before using any flying form under non-typical
+conditions, consult the designer or manufacturer.
+Wall forms should not be extended in height or
+width, for instance, or slab panels cantilevered
+without the review and approval of a professional
+engineer. Such situations usually occur with
+penthouses or mechanical rooms where wall and
+ceiling heights are greater than for typical floors.
+
+Other hazards with flying forms include the
+following.
+
+• Stability during initial fabrication
+
+• Fill-in work between slab panels
+
+• Wind and fall hazards during flying operations
+
+• Stripping, flying, and re-setting.
+
+Although a flying form is designed to be stable
+when complete, it may not be stable during
+fabrication or erection. Temporary bracing or
+temporary support by a crane may be necessary
+to ensure stability during certain phases of the
+operation (Figure 42-24).
+
+Figure 42-22: Two Rows of Shoring Frames with
+Row of Shoring Posts in Centre
+
+Frequently, supports for built-in-place forms are
+deliberately left out to allow other work to be
+done. One example might be a row of single-post
+shores left out until work below is complete. Or,
+an area might be supported temporarily during
+construction by a few single-post shores that will
+be replaced later by a shoring tower.
+
+In these and other instances of incomplete
+formwork, heavy temporary loads such as bundles
+of rebar or stacks of plywood should not be placed
+on the structure. Even on completed formwork,
+make sure that landed material will not overload
+the structure.
+
+Before placing concrete, the formwork must be
+inspected and approved by a professional engineer
+or their designate. Keep a copy of this inspection
+and approval on the site in case an inspector asks
+to see it.
+
+Flying Forms
+
+Flying forms must always be designed by a
+professional engineer and constructed, hoisted,
+moved, and set strictly according to the
+instructions of the designer or manufacturer.
+
+Figure 42-24: Temporary Support of Shoring
+System for Flying Wall Form
+
+One example is setting up trusses for a flying slab
+formwork table. The trusses must be held upright
+to be connected or disconnected. If not adequately
+supported, they can fall over on workers.
+
+Trusses and wall panels have also been blown over
+by wind during fabrication and dismantling. Set-
+up procedures should indicate the maximum wind
+speed where the flying form operation can be done
+safely. This wind speed should be determined by the
+professional engineer who designed the system.
+
+Work with flying forms requires adequate space
+for stacking materials and components. Working in
+cramped quarters is not only difficult but hazardous.
+
+Figure 42-23: Flying Forms
+
+Tools and Techniques
+
+42-9
+
+FORMWORK
+
+Fall Protection
+
+A fall arrest system should be used by any worker
+who is at risk of falling when:
+
+• Installing a panel
+
+• Pushing a panel out toward the slab edge
+
+• Pulling a panel in from the slab edge (Figure
+
+42-24)
+
+• Helping other workers attach rigging hardware
+
+such as slings
+
+• Getting on and off
+
+• Bolting and unbolting wall forms for exterior walls
+
+and elevator shafts (Figure 42-25)
+
+• Stepping onto a panel to attach slings to pick
+
+points
+
+Figure 42-24: Fall Protection Required when
+Receiving a Flying Form
+
+Figure 42-25: Attaching Chain Sling to Wall Form
+
+Each worker’s fall-arrest system must be attached
+to an individual anchor independent of the flying
+form. Contractors can provide for anchorage by
+casting rebar anchors in columns or other areas to
+be covered over or filled in later (Figure 42-26).
+This type of anchorage must be approved by a
+professional engineer.
+
+Figure 42-26: Rebar Anchor Cast in Concrete
+
+Safety Below Flying Forms
+
+The previous section covered the safety of workers
+flying the forms. But precautions must also be
+taken to protect workers below the hoisting
+operation and the public at large, since forms are
+often swung out over sidewalks and streets. The
+Construction Projects regulation (213/91, s. 103(2))
+prohibits hoisting a load over the head of a person
+who is not receiving the load or sinking a shaft.
+
+The most efficient protection for workers is to
+fence or rope off the area below the flying form to
+prevent anyone from entering the area. Pedestrian
+traffic on sidewalks, as well as vehicle traffic if
+necessary, should be detoured around the area
+while hoisting is under way.
+
+Communication
+
+Flying forms are heavy, large, and awkward to
+move. Hoisting and moving them safely requires
+clear reliable communication. While hand signals
+are often necessary and are still used, direct
+radio or cell phone communication between the
+signaller and the crane operator is more accurate
+and effective. Relying on hand signals alone is not
+recommended.
+
+Stripping
+
+Formwork stripping is probably the most
+hazardous operation in concrete construction.
+Hazards include the following.
+
+• Falling material
+
+• Waste material and equipment underfoot
+
+• Manual handling of heavy or awkward forms,
+
+panels, and other components
+
+• Prying forms loose from concrete presents risk of
+
+overexertion, lost balance, and slips and falls.
+
+42-10
+
+Construction Health and Safety ManualHazards can be reduced by
+
+• Planning and providing for stripping when
+
+designing and constructing formwork
+
+• Stripping as soon as it is permitted by the
+
+engineer
+
+• Supplying facilities and equipment for removing
+
+materials as they are stripped
+
+• Providing proper tools and adequate access for
+
+the stripping crew
+
+• Training personnel properly for this and other
+
+aspects of formwork.
+
+Forms can be designed with crush plates or filler
+strips to facilitate removal at difficult intersections
+of columns, beams, and wall forms. Later, formwork
+oils should be used liberally to make stripping
+easier.
+
+Wherever possible, waste materials, plywood, and
+debris should be removed from the area as work
+proceeds. This will reduce the need to walk over or
+work around things left on floor or ground.
+
+Providing carts or cradles can help the crew
+remove material and reduce the need for lifting
+and carrying. Material on a cart can be rolled away.
+Material in cradles can be hoisted off by a crane.
+
+Climbing partially stripped formwork is not
+only hazardous but unnecessary. Safe access
+such as rolling scaffolds or powered elevating
+work platforms should be provided for stripping
+formwork at elevated locations.
+
+Poor lighting may be a hazard in formwork
+stripping in the early morning or late in the day
+during certain times of the year. Mobile light
+stands are probably the best solution, since pigtail
+stringers can easily be knocked down and damaged
+during stripping.
+
+Wherever possible, stripping crews should be
+small. This is especially important with knock-down
+systems. In small crews, the supervisor and each
+worker can more easily keep track of what the
+others are doing. Workers are not as likely to create
+hazards for each other. Crews of two or three are
+recommended for knock-down systems. If more
+workers are required, they can still be divided into
+small crews working in separate areas.
+
+Other trades and operations should not be allowed
+in areas where stripping is under way. Given the
+many hazards involved, the area should be fenced
+or roped off and warning signs posted.
+
+Knock-Down Slab Systems
+
+Stripping these forms is physically difficult
+because much of the work is overhead. The
+usual arrangement involves shoring frames or a
+combination of shoring frames and jacks.
+
+Wherever possible, the work should proceed
+progressively from one side. That means taking out
+one row of formwork supported by a row of stringers
+on shoring frames.
+
+FORMWORK
+
+The first step is to back off the adjustable base plates
+and U-heads in one area, which will in turn lower the
+stringers, joists, and plywood (Figure 42-27).
+
+Figure 42-27: Lowering Base Plates
+and U-Heads to Release Slab Form
+
+In practice, however, the plywood will stick to
+the underside of the concrete, especially around
+beams, column caps, and similar points. Wherever
+possible, stuck sheets should be loosened and
+removed before the shoring structure is dismantled.
+
+Stripping should proceed in reverse order to
+erection. Plywood should be removed first,
+followed by joists and stringers. The last items to
+be removed are the shoring frames.
+
+When scaffold or shoring frames are used as a
+work platform, it should be completely decked
+in with planks (Figure 42-28). Otherwise planks
+can shift and slide as workers pry or pull at stuck
+pieces of formwork, lose their balance, and fall. This
+has been a frequent cause of injuries. Temporary
+guardrails may be required near the edge of the
+structure or workers will need to use fall protection
+during this operation.
+
+Figure 42-28: Shoring Frame
+Fully Planked for Access
+
+Tools and Techniques
+
+42-11
+
+FORMWORK
+
+The area where stripping starts should be planned
+to allow access for taking away material as the
+form is dismantled.
+
+Columns
+
+Check the following:
+
+Sound training, effective supervision, well-
+designed safe access facilities, and immediate and
+continuous cleanup can help reduce hazards in
+stripping knock-down slab forms.
+
+Built-in-Place Wall Forms
+
+These forms are frequently of only moderate height.
+Taller types usually make use of large panels erected
+and removed by crane rather than hand. Built-
+in-place wall forms are usually a stud-and-wale
+system using some type of formwork ties.
+
+Where workers cannot reach the top of the wall,
+scaffolding should be provided for removing wales
+on the upper level. Safe access is essential for the
+dismantling and manhandling of wales that are
+frequently long, heavy, and waterlogged.
+
+Material should then be removed immediately to a
+staging area.
+
+Inspection
+
+Before concrete placing begins, formwork must be
+inspected and signed off by a professional engineer
+or a competent person designated by the engineer
+to ensure that it has been constructed to provide
+for worker safety and to meet job specifications.
+
+A report must be completed by the person doing
+the inspection stating whether the formwork has
+been constructed according to the design. Any
+discrepancies must be approved by the design
+engineer before concrete placing proceeds.
+
+It is in everyone’s best interest to ensure that the
+formwork has been inspected by a competent
+person for workmanship, stability, and adherence
+to design drawings and specifications. Inspection
+should begin when the forms are being constructed
+and continue until concrete placing is complete.
+
+Checking line and grade is best carried out while the
+formwork is being constructed. Shoring structures
+should be within the alignment limits specified on
+the design drawings. Line and grade should also
+be checked during the pour to determine whether
+formwork is shifting or deflecting.
+
+Dimensions of special features like beams, column
+capitals, and inserts are best checked at the time of
+construction. If inspection is delayed until formwork
+is completed, some details may be covered up or
+become more difficult to check.
+
+• The proper size and type of materials are used
+
+• Column ties or column clamps are spaced
+
+according to design drawings
+
+• The spacing of ties or clamps is based on a
+
+sound assessment of concrete pressure (generally
+columns are designed for a full liquid head of
+150 lb per cubic foot (2,403 kg per cubic metre)
+times height)
+
+• Columns are adequately braced where they are
+
+not tied in to a slab-form structure.
+
+NOTE: For more information on column formwork
+pressures, refer to CAN/CSA S269.1-16: Falsework
+and Formwork or the American Concrete Institute
+(ACI) standard Formwork for Concrete (SP-4).
+
+Wall Forms
+
+Check the following:
+
+• Materials and any manufactured components are as
+specified in design drawings (size and spacing of
+studs, wales, and ties are crucial to safety)
+
+• Ties are snugged up before concrete is placed
+
+• Wedges in wedged systems are tight
+
+• Nuts in threaded systems are tight
+
+• Bracing conforms to design drawings
+
+• Free-standing formwork is braced to ensure stability
+
+and resistance to loads during concrete placing
+
+• Specified pour rates are not exceeded (wall
+
+forms are often designed for specific pour rates;
+exceeding these rates can cause failure or collapse).
+
+Slab Forms
+
+From a safety perspective, this is the most critical
+type of formwork. The collapse of slab forms has
+caused many injuries and deaths, whether from
+flawed design (e.g., not considering the effect
+of wind loading on the design), unauthorized
+modifications in the field, or the failure to
+inspect, which would have located and corrected
+deficiencies.
+
+Competent inspection demands knowledge,
+experience, and the ability to
+
+1) Distinguish between similar but different
+
+materials and shoring equipment
+
+2) Read and interpret design drawings
+
+3)
+
+Identify and clear up with the designer any
+apparent or real discrepancies in components
+such as shoring frames.
-Follow these three steps to protect your new appliance investment:
+42-12
-1
+Construction Health and Safety ManualFORMWORK
-Complete and mail
-your Consumer
-Product Ownership
-Registration today.
-Have the peace of
-mind of knowing
-we can contact you
-in the unlikely event of a safety
-modification.
+Check the following:
-2
+Watch for the following warning signs:
-After mailing
-the registration
-below, store this
-document in a safe
-place. It contains
-information you
-will need should
+• Grade beams or mud sills supporting shoring are
-you require service. Our
-service number is 800 GE
-CARES (800-432-2737).
+• Lateral displacement or movement of single-post
-3
+properly sized and located.
-Read your
-Owner’s Manual
-carefully.
-It will help you
-operate your
-new appliance
-properly.
+shoring for slab forms
-If you have questions, or need
-more information, call the GE
-Answer Center® 800.626.2000.
+• Hazardous soil conditions such as excessive
+moisture, freezing, and uncompacted soil
+conditions are reported and discussed with the
+professional engineer.
-Model Number
+• Shoring frames and jacks are located and aligned
-Serial Number
+within tolerances specified on the drawings.
-Important: If you did not get a registration card with your product,
+• Shoring frames and jacks are out of plumb no
-detach and return the form below to ensure that your
-product is registered.
+more than 1/8 inch every 3 feet.
-"
-Consumer Product Ownership Registration
+• Adjustable base plates for shoring frames and
-Cut here
+jacks are snugged up.
-Important
-Mail
-Today!
+• U-heads are wedged in place.
-First
-Name
+• Stringers are the specified size and number, with
-Street
-Address
+supports properly spaced.
-Apt. #
+• Aluminum stringers have no bent flanges or other
-City
+damage.
-Model Number
+• Movement or deflection of lateral bracing for
-Serial Number
+single-post shores
-Mr. (cid:108) Ms. (cid:108) Mrs. (cid:108) Miss (cid:108)
+• Movement of stringers on U-heads
-Last
-Name
+• Crushing of wooden stringers on U-heads
-E-mail Address
+(Figure 42-29)
-State
+• Gaps or shoring that is not snugged up under
-Zip
-Code
+stringers
-Date Placed In Use
+• Deflection of stringers between supports
-Month
+(Figure 42-30)
-Day
+• Deflection of wales or strongbacks on wall forms
-Year
+• Wall forms that are bulging or cracking
-Phone
-Number
+• Crushing of wales or strongbacks at washers
-Occasionally, we may allow selected companies to send you information.
-(cid:108) Check here if you do not want this information.
+for ties
-GE Appliances
-General Electric Company
-Louisville, Kentucky 40225
-www.ge.com/appliances
+• Movement of wall forms
-38
+• Joists are the specified size and properly spaced.
-Refrigerator Warranty (For customers in the United States)
+• Uplifting of battered forms
-All warranty service provided by our Factory Service Centers,
-or an authorized Customer Care®technician. For service,
-call 800-GE-CARES.
+• Support structures and shoring for beam bottoms
+and column capitals are constructed according to
+design.
-For The Period Of: We Will Replace, At No Charge To You:
+• Lateral bracing is provided where required (for
+instance, on freestanding formwork for bridges
+and overpasses).
-One Year
-From the date of the
-original purchase
+• The bearing surface for lateral bracing is
+adequate—that is, stable footings or well-
+compacted soil.
-Five Years
-From the date of the
-original purchase
+• Temporary loads such as rebar are not
-Any partof the refrigerator which fails due to a defect
-in materials or workmanship. During this full one-year
-warranty, we will also provide, free of charge, all labor
-and in-home service to replace the defective part.
+overloading the system.
-Any part of the sealed refrigerating system
-(the compressor, condenser, evaporator and all
-connecting tubing) which fails due to a defect in
-materials or workmanship. During this additional
-four-year warranty, we will also provide, free of charge,
-all labor and in-home service to replace the
-defective part.
+Concrete Placing
-What Is Not Covered:
+Forms should continue being observed during
+concrete placing. Any signs of movement, crushing,
+cracking, or deflection are cause for alarm. Placing
+concrete should be suspended until the situation is
+corrected.
-n Service trips to your home to teach you
+• Pour rates that exceed design specifications.
-how to use the product.
+Figure 42-29: Crushing of Stringer Over U-Head
-n Improper installation.
+Figure 42-30: Deflection
+of Stringers Between Supports
-n Failure of the product if it is
+Tools and Techniques
-abused, misused, or used for other
-than the intended purpose or used
-commercially.
-
-n Loss of food due to spoilage.
-
-n Replacement of house fuses or
-resetting of circuit breakers.
-
-n Damage to the product caused by
-
-accident, fire, floods or acts of God.
-
-n Incidental or consequential damage to
-personal property caused by possible
-defects with this appliance.
-
-This warranty is extended to the original purchaser and any succeeding owner for products purchased
-for home use within the USA. In Alaska, the warranty excludes the cost of shipping or service calls to
-your home.
-
-Some states do not allow the exclusion or limitation of incidental or consequential damages. This
-warranty gives you specific legal rights, and you may also have other rights which vary from state to
-state. To know what your legal rights are, consult your local or state consumer affairs office or your
-state’s Attorney General.
-
-Warrantor: General Electric Company. Louisville, KY 40225
-
-39
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-Service Telephone Numbers.
-
-GE Answer Center® 800.626.2000
-
-The GE Answer Center® is open 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
-
-In-Home Repair Service800-GE-CARES (800-432-2737)
-
-Expert GE repair service is only a phone call away.
-
-Special Needs Service800.626.2000
-TDD 800-TDD-GEAC (800-833-4322)
-
-GE offers, free of charge, a brochure to assist in planning a barrier-
-free kitchen for persons with limited mobility.
-
-Service Contracts800-626-2224
-
-Purchase a GE service contract while your warranty is still in effect
-and you’ll receive a substantial discount. GE Consumer Service will
-still be there after your warranty expires.
-
-Parts and Accessories800-626-2002
-
-Individuals qualified to service their own appliances can have parts
-or accessories sent directly to their homes (VISA, MasterCard and
-Discover cards are accepted).
-Instructions contained in this manual cover procedures to be performed
-by any user. Other servicing generally should be referred to qualified
-service personnel. Caution must be exercised, since improper servicing
-may cause unsafe operation.
-
-Service Satisfaction
-
-If you are not satisfied with the service you receive from GE, follow
-these steps. First, contact the people who serviced your appliance.
-Next, if you are still not pleased, write all the details—including your
-phone number—to: Manager, Consumer Relations, GE Appliances,
-Appliance Park, Louisville, KY 40225.
-
-40
-
-Printed in Louisville, KY
+42-13
diff --git a/q15/random_k2/random_2.md b/q15/random_k2/random_2.md
index 3f8f519b055815348eb52fd213fd7d32396a7bde..a7cbcf7d4134f4c225b224673f418e279c4db69c 100644
--- a/q15/random_k2/random_2.md
+++ b/q15/random_k2/random_2.md
@@ -1,3490 +1,1314 @@
-Fully Automatic Coffee Machine
-OPERATION MANUAL
-
-Instructions of coffee machine parts
-
+B160V
+
+User Guide
+
+Contents
+Safety information . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2
+Getting to know your phone . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
+Setting up your phone . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7
+Contacts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11
+Messages . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12
+Email . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13
+Chrome browser . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14
+Bluetooth . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15
+Wi-Fi . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16
+Camera . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17
+Photos . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18
+Calendar . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19
+Calculator . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20
+Calculator . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20
+Clock . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21
+Google Maps . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22
+Google Play Store . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23
+Settings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24
+Troubleshooting . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 38
+Regulatory Information . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42
1
-2
-
-3
-
-4
-
-5
-
-9
+Safety information
-6
+Please carefully read the items bellow:
+Use Safely
+Do not use the phone in situations where it might cause danger.
+Transportation Safety
+Please observe all transportation laws and regulations.
+Please drive with both hands on the wheel.
-7
+DO NOT TEXT AND DRIVE
-9
+Hospitals
+Please follow limitations.
+Please turn off your mobile phone when near medical instruments.
+Airports
+Remember to follow all airport and flight safety regulations.
+Please do not use your phone during flight.
-10
+2
-11
+Toxic Chemicals
+Do not use your mobile phone around fuels or chemicals.
-12
+Hazard
+Do not use in hazardous areas where explosions may occur.
-13
+Accessories and Batteries
+Use only Blu authorized batteries and accessories.
-8
+Backup
+Remember to keep a written record of all important information.
-1
+Water
+Your phone is not waterproof. Keep it away from water and liquids.
-2
+SOS Emergency Calls
+Make sure your mobile phone is switched on and in a service area. In
+home screen, tap the phone key and dial 911 and send.
3
-4
-
-5
-
-6
-
-7
+Getting to know your phone
-Bean container
+Receiver
-Water tank
+Headset port
+Status bar
-Coffee grounds container
+Front camera
-Pre - ground coffee chute
+Rear cameras
-Grinding wheel
+Volume keys
-Coffee spout
+Power key
-Handle
+Flash
-8
+Back
+Home
-9
+Recent Apps
-10
+USB port
-11
+4
-12
+Power
+key
-13
+• Press to turn the screen on or off.
+• Press and hold to turn the phone on.
+• Press along with the Volume up key to turn the phone off.
+• Press along with the Volume down key to take a
-Waste water container
+screenshot.
-Milk pipe
+Volume
+keys
-Milk frother
+Adjust the volume for ringtones, media, notifications, and
+system sounds.
-Hot water spout
+Home
-Milk and foam spout
+The home button pauses any current action and returns to
+the home screen.
-Power cord
+Recent
+Apps
-Coffee machine operation interface instructions
+Open a list of recently opened applications that allows you
+to switch conveniently between them. This option can also
+close any open applications by swiping to the side.
-5
+Back
-1
+Return to the previous screen; Closes the keyboard, any
+open program, or any menu option.
-2
+USB port
-3
+Charge the device and transfers data such as documents,
+music, and video between your device and a PC.
-4
+Headset
+port
-6
+Connect earphones to this port for hands-free capabilities.
+You may also to listen to music or FM radio.
-7
+Status
+bar
-8
+Provide phone and service status information on the right
+side and notification alerts on the left.
-9
+Front
+Camera
-10
+A high-resolution front camera to take pictures and video.
+This option is ideal for self-portraits.
-1
+Rear
+Cameras
-2
+Flash
-3
+A high-resolution rear camera to take pictures and video.
-4
+Provide light for pictures in low-light conditions. It also
+may be used as a flashlight.
5
-Espresso icon
-
-Long coffee icon
-
-Hot water icon
-
-Power switch
-
-Display
-
6
-7
-
-8
-
-9
-
-Cappuccino icon
-
-Coffee Latte icon
-
-Hot milk/foam icon
-
-Cleaning button
-
-10
-
-Rotary button
-
-Safety Instructions
-
-Please see specification label on the bottom of the coffee machine or
-technical date indicated in the instruction manual(P20).
-
-IMPORTANT SAFEGUARDS
-
-When using electrical appliances, basic safety precautions should always be followed,
-including the following:
-1. Read all Instructions.
-2. Do not touch hot surfaces. Use handles or knobs.
-3. To protect against fire, electric shock and injury to persons do not immerse cord,
-plugs, or (state specific part or parts in question) in water or other liquid.
-4. Unplug from outlet when not in use and before cleaning. Allow to cool before
-putting on or taking off parts, and before cleaning the appliance.
-5.Avoid contacting moving parts.
-6. Do not operate any appliance with a damaged cord or plug or if the appliance
-malfunctions, or has been damaged in any manner. Return the appliance to the near
-est authorized service facility for examination, repair or adjustment.
-7. The use of accessory attachments not recommended by the appliance manufac
-turer may result in fire, electric shock or injury to persons.
-8. Do not use outdoors .
-9. Do not let the cord hang over edge of table or counter, or touch hot surfaces.
-10. Do not place on or near a hot gas or electric burner, or in a heated oven.
-11. Always plug cord into the wall outlet first,then turn controls to
-turn any control to”off“,
-12. Do not use appliance for other than intended use.
-13. Check bean hopper for presence of foreign objects before using the brewer .
-14. Unplug power cord from outlet before cleaning brewer exterior. Allow to cool
-before disassembling and cleaning the coffee machine.
-15. When dispensing drinks high temperature liquid will flow from coffee spout and hot
-water spout. Do not touch hot liquids to avoid scalding
-16. When using cappuccino, coffee latte, hot milk/foam, please confirm that the milk
-pipe has been connected from the milk frother to milk before making cappuccino,
-coffee latte, and hot milk/cream. Otherwise, high temperature steam may cause
-personal injury.
-17. Never connect to voltage different than the electric specification of the machine;
-Brewer damage will occur.
-18. Only potable water at room temperature should be used in the water tank.
-Never put warm water, hot water, milk or other liquid into the tank.
-
-then remove plug from wall outlet.
-
-To disconnect,
-
-"on".
-
-01
-
-Safety Instructions
-
-19. Never carry or move the coffee machine while power is on.
-20. The machine will release heat and some steam. Therefore, when placing the
-machine on a workbench, at least 3cm must be left between its surfaces, sides and
-rear; at least15cm must be left above its top.
-As for dimension of the machine, please look up the Technical Data in the User
-Manual(Page 20).
-21. Never use harsh or abrasive cleaner to wipe the machine, it may cause
-corrosion of the coffee machine, and result in a risk of electric shock.
-22. Never use hard edged tool or rough rag to clean the stain on the machine, it will
-damage the surfaces.
-23. Never fill specially treated coffee beans (e.g. cocoa, sugar coated) into the
-beancontainer, it will cause the coffee machine damage .
-24. Only roasted coffee bean are approved to place into the bean container. Rice,
-soybean, chocolate bean, nut, sugar, spice etc are prohibited. Otherwise it would
-cause the coffee machine to be damaged.
-25. Never wash the bean container or pre-ground coffee chute with water, it will
-damage the machine.
-26. Never use the coffee machine in the environment temperature below 0 °C.
-Water inside the machine will freeze and cause the coffee machine damaged.
-27. Never expose the machine in rainy, snowy, frosty environment. It would cause
-the coffee machine to be damaged.
-28. Save these Instructions.
-
-POWER CORD EXTENSION USE
-
-Please don’t use power cord extensions.
-
-02
-
--
-
--
-
-Proper operation
-
-the
-
-sure
-
-taste,
-
-make
-
-that the
-
-guarantee
-
-To
-coffee
-into the water tank is at room temperature.
-used
-can
-The coffee
-We
-intended
-it
-use
-of
-read
-this manual, so that you can understand operation of the coffee machine
-sufficiently.
-
-preparing
-not be responsible
-contents
-
-machine
-other
-use.
-
-be
-use.
-carefully
-
-any
-for
-improper
-
-hot
-for the
-
-temperature
-
-for
-will
-
-coffee
-
-Please
-
-only
-
-and
-
-the
-
-the
-
-all
-
-of
-
-of
-
-water
-
-poured
-
-water.
-Do
-consequences
-
-not
-
-Please keep this manual in an appropriate place to
-Safety Tips
-
-be accessed
-
-at any time.
-
-if
-
-is
-
-(if
-
-or
-
-the
-
-the
-
-the
-
-the
-
-smell
-
-power
-
-power
-
-coffee
-
-coffee
-
-unplug
-
-burning
-
-operate
-
-machine
-
-machine
-
-appliance
-
-or
-an authorized
-
-any
-contact
+Setting up your phone
-machine
-and
+Charge the battery
+1. Connect one end of the data cable to the USB port located on the
-the
-of
-immediately
+Install a Nano SIM/microSD card
-a breakdown
-cord
-power
+bottom of your phone.
-encountering
-the
+Note: Please contact your cellular phone service provider directly to
+obtain your SIM card if your card is not preinstalled.
+1. Insert the included SIM tray pin into
-cord of the
-service center.
+the tray slot and remove the SIM tray.
+2. Place the Nano SIM card and microSD
-Please notice the following tips to avoid personal injury from electric shock.
-cord
+microSD
-Do
-not
-damaged.
-When
-smoke),
-service center.
-If
-authorized
-Place the coffee machine and the power cord far away from heat sources.
-Please don't contact the power cord with sharp tools.Do
-coffee
-it
-operate
-mentioned in this manual, to avoid personal injury.
-Place the coffee machine out of the reach of children.
-periods,
-is
-When the
-cord and put it away, so that not to trip up people or damage to the power
-cord.
-Please
-be damaged.
+Nano SIM
-not
-way that is not
+card (not included) with metal
+contacts facing down into the tray.
+3. Gently slide the SIM tray back into
-authorization
+SIM tray
-contact an
+Pin
-damaged,
+the slot.
-otherwise,
+Warning: Please keep the SIM card out of the reach of children.
+The SIM card and its contact are easily damaged due to scratching or
+bending. Please use caution when carrying, installing, or taking out the
+SIM card.
-unoriginal
+2. Connect the other end to the power adapter.
+3. Connect the power adapter to an electrical outlet to fully charge your
-machine
+phone.
-machine
+Power On and Off
+Long press the Power key to switch on the phone.
+To turn off the phone, press the Power key and the
+Volume up key at the same time, and tap Power Off on
+the screen that displayed.
-without
-
-unused
-
-Coffee
-
-unplug
-
-please
-
-power
-
-cause
-
-repair
-
-parts,
-
-the machine to
-
-don't
-
-may
-
-long
-
-the
-
-any
-
-use
-
-the
-
-for
-
-or
-
-in
-
-is
-
-it
-
-03
-
-Instructions for use
-
-Reading this manual will help you familiarize yourself with the coffee
-machine, and enable you to use
-“Instruction
-coffee
-“Failures handling" will provide information when encountering problems.
-
-the
-use
- machine step-by-step, for first-time use.
-
-it properly.
-introduces
-
-operation
-
-first-time
-
-process
-
-for
-
-of
-
-"
-
-the
-
-Coffee machine model
-
-This
+Power
+key
-Manual
+7
-is
+8
-only
+Phone
+Make a call
-applicable
+1. To make a call, tap Phone
+2. Tap Dialer
-to the
+ from the Home screen.
-1601pro series coffee machine.
+ to access the keypad, or select one of the following:
-Symbol description
+• Choose frequently called or favorite contacts in Favorites.
-Non-compliance
-and threat to life.
+• Choose recently called numbers and contacts in Recents.
-with
+• Choose a saved contact in Contacts.
-proper
+3. Tap
+4. During a call, you can tap
-operation,
+ to make a call.
-may
+up.
-cause
+ at the bottom of the screen to hang
-electric
+Enable Wi-Fi call
-shock,
+You can make a voice call with Wi-Fi Calling.
+1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Settings
+2. Tap Network & internet > Wi-Fi Calling. Slide the switch to the
-Non-compliance
-damage, or personal injury.
+.
-with
+On
+ position to enable it. You must have an active Wi-Fi
+connection and have Wi-Fi calling service activated before it can be
+used.
-proper
+Call history
-operation
+Every telephone number called and received will be saved in the history.
+1. From the Home screen, tap Phone
+2. Tap Recents on the bottom bar to display the call history.
+You can tap a contact in the call history to display more options.
-may
+.
-cause
+Call settings
-Coffee
+1. From the Home screen, tap Phone
+2. Tap Options > Settings to configure your phone settings.
-machine
+.
-Non-compliance
+9
-with
+10
-proper
+Contacts
-operation,
+Add a contact
-may
+1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Contacts
-cause
+.
+2. Tap
+3. Use the keyboard to enter contact information, such as picture,
-scalding
+ to add a contact.
-or
+name, telephone number, group, address, email, etc.
-burn
+4. When you are finished, tap Save.
-injury.This symbol, if prompted, please carefully read it.
+Edit a contact
-This symbol, if prompted, represents recyclable.
+To edit a contact, tap the contact from the Contacts screen to view its
+details, and tap
-01
+.
-03
+Messages
-03
-03
+Send a text or multimedia message
+1. From the Home screen, tap Messaging
+2. Tap Start chat to create a new text or multimedia message, or start
-03
+.
-05
+a new group chat.
-05
+3. Enter the recipient(s) name from your Contacts list or phone number
-05
+in the To field.
-05
+ to send the text message.
-05
+4. Type your message and tap
+5. Or tap
-06
+ to the left side of the text box to add location, contacts,
-06
+or files. Tap
+recordings. When done, tap
-07
-07
-08
- 09
+ to attach photos or videos. Tap
-Catalogue
+ to send sound
+ to send the multimedia message.
-Safety Instructions
+Message settings
+From Message screen, tap
+ on the top right corner of the Messages
+screen and tap Messages Settings to adjust your messages settings.
-Proper operation
+11
-Instructions for use
+12
-Coffee machine model
-Symbol description
+Email
-Instructions for first time use
+Email setup (Gmail, Yahoo!, etc.)
-Power connection
+From the Home screen, tap Gmail
+your account.
-Fill water tank
+, and follow the steps to set up
-Fill beans
+Create and send an email message
+1. Tap Compose from the Inbox screen to compose a new message.
+2. Enter the recipient(s) email address in the To field. To add a carbon copy
-Grinding wheel
+or blind carbon copy, tap
-Power on
+.
-Power off
+3. Enter the subject and content of your message. To add attachments, tap
-Making beverages
+ and select Attach file.
-Preparing coffee by touch icon
+4. Tap
-Adjusting coffee parameters during a brew cycle.
+ to send.
-Preparing coffee with pre-ground coffee
+Email settings
+From Email screen, tap Menu
+settings.
-Program setting
+ > Settings to configure your Email
-Beverage
+Chrome browser
+From the Home screen, tap Chrome
+for information, and bookmark your favorite web pages for convenient
+access.
-setting
+ to browse the Internet, search
-Setting beverage parameters and range
+Browsing web pages
+From the Chrome browser screen, tap the address field and enter a web
+address or a keyword to browse for web pages.
-Temperature setting
+Adding a bookmark
+Open the web page you want to bookmark and tap Menu >
-Eco-settings
+.
-Automatic power-down
+Opening a bookmark
+From the Chrome browser screen, tap Menu > Bookmarks, select
+the bookmark of the website you want to view.
-Factory Reset
+Browser settings
+From the Chrome browser screen, tap Menu > Settings to customize
+the browser.
-Information Statics
+13
-Language
+14
-Exit
+Bluetooth
-Cleaning and maintenance
+Wi-Fi
-Cleaning the coffee machine before operation
+Bluetooth is a short-range wireless communications technology that
+devices can use to exchange information and connect to different types
+of devices which include headsets and other devices.
-Cleaning brewing unit
+Enable Bluetooth
-Rinsing milk unit
+1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Settings
+2. Tap Connected devices > Connection preferences >
-Descaling the coffee machine
+.
-Cleaning coffee
+Bluetooth.
-grounds
+3. Slide the Bluetooth switch to the On
-container and drip tray
+ position.
-Cleaning water tank
+Pair Bluetooth devices
-Cleaning bean hopper
+1. From the Connected devices screen, tap Pair new device.
+2. Tap a device under Available devices and follow the on-screen
-Disassembling and cleaning the milk frother
+instructions to pair with the device.
-Installing milk pipe
+3. When the device is connected to your phone, You can then use the
+headset or car kit to listen to music or make and receive phone calls.
-Cleaning milk pipe
+To use your phone’s Wi-Fi, you need access to a wireless access point or
+hotspot.
+1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Settings
+2. Tap Network & internet > Internet > Wi-Fi.
+3. Slide the Wi-Fi switch to the On
+4. Tap a Wi-Fi network to connect, enter the password (if applicable),
-Cleaning coffee machine
+ position to enable Wi-Fi.
-Failures handling
+.
-Display information
+and then tap CONNECT .
-Transport and recycle
+5. Your phone will be connected to the Wi-Fi network. You will see
-Technical data
+in the status bar.
-04
+You can drag down the status bar twice to access Quick Settings panel
+to enable or disable Bluetooth and Wi-Fi quickly and easily.
-9
-10
+15
-10
+16
-10
+Camera
-11
+Photos
-11
+Take a photo
+1. From the Home screen, tap Camera
+2. Tap Photo to switch to Photo mode.
+3. Aim the camera at your subject and tap
-11
+ to take the photo.
-11
+.
-11
+Record a video
+1. From the Camera screen, tap Video to switch to Video mode.
+2. Tap
+3. Tap
-11
+ to start recording a video.
+ again to stop recording and save your video.
-12
-12
+Camera settings
+From the Camera screen, tap Settings
-12
+ to adjust camera settings.
-13
+You can view photos and watch videos that you’ve taken, downloaded,
+or copied onto your storage card or phone memory.
-14
+Edit photos
+1. From the Home screen, tap Photos
+2. Tap the picture you want to edit.
+3. Tap
+save.
-16
+.
-17
+ to access the Edit screen. When finished, tap Save copy to
-17
+Share pictures and videos
+1. Select the photos or videos you want to share.
+2. Tap
-17
+, select a sharing method, and follow the on-screen prompts
-17
+to send the photos or videos.
17
18
-18
-
-19
-
-20
-
-20
-
-Instructions for first-time use
-
-This chapter will help you understand the basic operations and settings for your
-first time use
-
-Power connection
-
-●
-
-●
-
-●
-
-●
-
-coffee
-
-machine
-
-Place the coffee machine on a stable workbench that is not
-close to water.
-Keep
-the
-heat sources.
-Be sure to use the power supply that is in accordance with
-specification label.
-Put
-at
-power
-tripping over the cord.
+Calendar
-avoid people
+Calculator
+Calculator
-temperature
+Use the Calendar to create and manage events, meetings, and
+appointments.
-suitable
+Add an event
-place
+1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Calendar
-away
-
-cord
-
-from
-
-high
-
-the
-
-far
-
-to
-
-a
-
-Fill water tank
-
-●
-
-●
-
-●
-
-temperature
+.
+2. Tap Add
+3. Enter event details, and then tap Save.
-milk).
+ to add an event.
-room
+Calendar settings
-water,
+1. From the Calendar screen, tap Menu
+2. Tap an option to adjust Calendar settings.
-at
-tank,
+ > Settings.
-water
-water
+Your phone’s convenient built-in calculator lets you perform basic
+Your phone’s convenient built-in calculator lets you perform basic
+mathematical equations.
+mathematical equations.
+1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Calculator
+1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Calculator
-fill
-will
-taste
+.
.
-never
-It
-the
-at 25℃
-
-potable
-in the
-water,hot
-In
-
-to ensure
-order
-water
-to
-use
-a
-create
-
-Only
-poured
-warm
-machine.
-recommended
-water
-will
-taste.
-To
-change the water in the tank every day.
-The
-in
-height of the MAX mark.
-
-the water
-
-a healthy
+2. Enter the first number, tap a mathematical function key, and then
+2. Enter the first number, tap a mathematical function key, and then
-amount
+enter the second number.
+enter the second number.
-ensure
+3. Tap
+3. Tap
-water
+ to view the result, tap
+ to view the result, tap
-good
+ to clear the results.
+ to clear the results.
-tasty
+View calculator history
+View calculator history
-tank
+From the Calculator screen, tap Menu > History, or drag down on
+From the Calculator screen, tap Menu > History, or drag down on
+the history bar
+the history bar
+To clear the calculator history, tap Menu > Clear. To return to the
+To clear the calculator history, tap Menu > Clear. To return to the
+.
+calculator, drag the history bar
+.
+calculator, drag the history bar
-and
+ back up or tap the Back button
+ back up or tap the Back button
-not
+ to view the calculator history.
+ to view the calculator history.
-the
+19
-of
+20
-to be
+Clock
-is
-other
+Google Maps
-allowed
-liquid
+The Clock app allows you to set alarms, view different world times, use
+a stopwatch, set a timer, manage your bedtime, and use your phone as
+a desk clock.
-any
-coffee
-damage the
-it
-is
-coffee,
-temperature
+Use the Google Maps app to determine your location, get directions,
+browse local businesses and attractions, rate and review places, and
+more.
-of
-Low
+Set the date and time manually
-(e.g.
+1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Clock
+2. Tap Menu > Settings > Change date & time > Set time
+automatically > Off, and set the date and time manually.
-coffee drink,
+.
-please
+Create a new alarm
-cannot
+1. From the Clock screen, tap Alarm
+2. Set the time for the alarm and tap OK.
-exceed
+ >
-the
+.
-Fill beans
+Search for destinations
+1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Maps
+2. Tap Search here.
+3. Enter an address, city, facility name, etc., and then choose a search
-05
+.
-●
+result. You will see your location on the map.
-●
+Find a route to your destination
+Tap Go
+, enter your desired start location and destination, and tap a
+method of transportation (car, public transit, or on foot) for the detailed
+directions to your destination.
-●
+21
-●
+22
-●
+Google Play Store
-put
+Access Google Play
-Never
-treated (e.g. sugar, cocoa) into the bean hopper.
+1. From the Home screen, tap Play Store
+2. Enter your existing GoogleTM Account login or create one by following
-coffee
+.
-beans
+the steps on the screen.
-been
+Navigate Google Play
-have
+1. Tap Search for apps & games on the top of the screen to search
-that
+for a specific game or app.
-specially
+2. To install an app, tap the app and follow the prompts to complete
+the process. After installation, you will see a notification in the
+Notifications panel. You can open the app from the notification panel
+or Apps list.
-into
-soybeans,
+Settings
-be
+From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Settings
+to access your phone’s Settings menu.
-put
+Network & Internet
-can
-rice,
+From the Settings screen, tap Network & internet.
+• Internet: Enable or disable Wi-Fi, add Wi-Fi network, view saved
-beans
-like
+networks, and monitor data usage.
-roasted
-put
+• Wi-Fi Calling: Enable or disable Wi-Fi Calling, adjust Wi-Fi Calling settings.
+• Mobile network: Enable or disable mobile data, adjust data roaming
+settings, view mobile data usage, set data limit and warning mode, etc.
-coffee
-other items
+• Airplane mode: Enable or disable Airplane mode.
+• Mobile plan: View your mobile plan.
+• Others: Adjust settings on Hotspot & tethering, Data saver, VPN,
-Only
-never
-nuts,sugar, and spices into the hopper.
-objects
-Never
-damage the grinder.
-bean hopper
-The
-beans
-of
+Private DNS, etc.
-cover acts
-maximized.
+23
-as a
-Please
+24
- coffee
+Connected devices
+From the Settings screen, tap Connected devices > Connection
+preferences.
+• USB: Connect your phone with a computer using a USB cable to
+transfer data, share network connectivity, or charge your phone.
+• Bluetooth: Pair Bluetooth devices to launch wirelessly hear calls,
-hard
+connect speakers, transfer data, and more.
-into
+• Cast: Scan for nearby devices to connect to and set them up.
+• Printing: Connect your device to a printer on the same Wi-Fi
-put
+network.
-the
+• Chromebook: Link your phone to a chromebook.
+• Nearby Share: Allow the rapid short-range exchange of images,
-seal.
-do
+videos, text, contact info, directions, YouTube videos, and other data
+via Bluetooth and Wi-Fi.
-beanhopper,
+• Android Auto: Control your phone’s maps, media and messaging
-otherwise
+functions, with the Google Assistant while you drive.
-it will
+Apps
-It
-not
+View current running applications, manage permissions, and more.
+From the Settings screen, tap Apps.
+• Recently opened apps: Tap an app to view detailed information.
+• Default apps: Set the default app for the browser, phone, messages,
-keeps
+etc. You can also set default apps for opening links.
-the aroma
+• Screen time: You can tap
-lose
+on the right side of most apps to set
-the cover.
+daily timers. When the app timer ends, the app is paused for the rest
+of the day.
-the
+• Unused apps: View apps that you have not used for a long time. You
-bean hopper,
+can un-install them to free up some space.
-chocolate
+• App battery usage: Set battery usage for apps.
+• Special app access: View app access for special functions, such as
-beans,
+battery optimization, display over other apps, unrestricted data, usage
+access, etc.
-Don't pour liquid in the bean container.
+25
-Grinding wheel
+26
-●
+Notifications
-●
+Battery
-●
+From the Settings screen, tap Notifications.
+• App notifications: Control notifications from individual apps.
+• Notification history: View your recent and snoozed notifications.
+• Conversations: View priority and modified conversations.
+• Bubbles: Enable message conversations display as bubbles, floating
-●
+on top of other apps.
-●
+• Device & app notification: Control which apps and devices can
-●
+read notifications.
-●
+• Notifications on lock screen: Select how you want notifications to
-adjust
+be displayed on the lock screen.
-Please
-according to the coffee bean type.
+• Do Not Disturb: Enable or disable Do Not Disturb. Set Do Not
-fineness
+Disturb behavior, exceptions, schedule, etc.
-coffee
+• Others: You can adjust other notifications settings, like wireless
-the
+emergency alerts, hide silent notifications in status bar, etc.
-of
+Monitor your phone’s battery usage.
+From the Settings screen, tap Battery.
+• Battery Usage: View the battery percentage that each apps used
-bean
+from last full charge.
-grind choice
+• Battery Saver: Enable or disable Battery Saver, set a schedule for
+turning on the Battery Saver, turn the Battery Saver off when your
+phone charges above 90%.
-adjust
+• Battery percentage: Show battery percentage in the Status bar.
-Please
-or the grinder may be damaged.
+Storage
-grinding
+Manage internal storage on your phone and provides menu choices for
+an optional SD card.
+From the Settings screen, tap Storage.
+• Device storage: From Storage screen, tap THIS DEVICE > This
-wheel
+device. Tap a category to view the storage amount used by each app.
-the
+27
-when
+28
-the
+• SD card: From Storage screen, tap THIS DEVICE > SD CARD to
-grinder
+Display
-is
+view files stored on your SD card. Tap on the top right corner of the
+screen to rename, eject or format the SD card.
-running,
+• Storage manager: Storage manager removes backed up photos and
-it
+videos from your device.
-is
+Sound & vibration
+From the Settings screen, tap Sound & vibration.
+• Media/Call/Ring/Notification/Alarm volume: Drag the slides to
-are
+adjust the media, call, ring & notification, and alarm volumes.
-are
+• Do Not Disturb: Manage Do Not Disturb settings.
+• Phone ringtone: Select a ringtone for incoming phone calls.
+• Media: Enable Media to hide player when the media session has ended.
+• Others: You can adjust other sound and vibration settings, like
-your
+vibration & haptics, default notification and alarm sounds, enable
+tones or vibration on other scenarios, etc.
-your
+From the Settings screen, tap Display.
+• Brightness level: Drag the slide to adjust the screen brightness
-color,
+level.
-beans
+• Adaptive brightness: Enable adaptive brightness to automatically
-beans
+adjust the screen brightness basing on the lighting conditions.
-light in
+• Lock screen: Set what to show on lock screen.
+• Screen timeout: Your screen will automatically go to sleep after the
-coffee
+set amount of time.
-coffee
+• Dark theme: Turn on dark theme.
+• Display size and text: Adjust font size and display size.
+• Night Light: Set a Night Light schedule and intensity.
+• Others: You can adjust other display settings, like enable auto-rotate
+screen and life to wake features, adjust display color and screen saver,
+etc.
-recommended to
+29
-dark in
+30
-If
-set to the coarse grind.
-If
-to set to the fine grind.
-While
-very
-coarse grind.
-Adjust grind choice as needed, increase or decrease grind
-level.
+Accessibility
-making
-slowly , please change the grind choice to a more
+Security & privacy
-recommended
+Manage accessibility-related apps to make the device easier to use for
+those with certain physical disabilities.
+From the Settings screen, tap Accessibility.
+• Real-Time text call: Manage RTT call options.
+• Display: Adjust the font size and display size, enable or disable dark
-brew dispense
+theme, enable screen magnification, etc.
-coffee drinks,
+• Interaction controls: Enable or disable useful interaction functions,
-coffee
+such as timing control, system controls, etc.
-color,
+• Captions: Enable or disable captions. You can also set caption display
-the
+language, text size, and caption style.
-is
+• Audio: Pair your hearing aids, enable mono audio, or adjust the audio
-it
+balance from the speaker.
-if
+• Accessibility shortcuts: Mange the settings on accessibility button.
+• Text-to-speech output: Set the text-to-speech engine, language,
-adjustment
+speech rate, etc.
-The
-making two or more cups of coffee.
+From the Settings screen, tap Security & privacy.
+• App security: Check your device and prevent/warn you of potential
-grinding
+harm.
-wheel
+• Device lock: Set your screen lock method, pattern, PIN, password, etc.
+• Account security: Add a Google Account to secure your device.
+• Device finders: Enable Find My Device to locate your device
-of
+remotely, keeping your data safe in the event that your phone is lost.
+• System & updates: Check for new software updates for your device.
+• Privacy: Manage a batch of privacy settings.
+• Face unlock: Unlock your phone by looking at it.
+• More security & privacy: Adjust more security and privacy settings.
-will
+Unlock your device automatically in certain conditions.
-be
+31
-effective
+32
-only
+Location
-after
+From the Settings screen, tap Location.
+• Recent access: View a list of apps that have recently requested your
-Finest
+location.
-Fine
+• App location permissions: View which apps have permission to
-Medium
+access location services.
-Coarse
+• Location services: Manage settings on other location services, such
-Coarsest
+as emergency location service, Google location accuracy, etc.
-Power on
+Safety & emergency
-First-time use
+Fulfill your medical and emergency information, view emergency alerts,
+and manage settings on emergency SOS and location service.
+From the Settings screen, tap Safety & emergency.
+• Emergency information: Add medical information and emergency
+contacts to help first responders in an emergency. Anyone can read
+this information from your lock screen and dial your emergency
+contacts without unlocking your phone..
-●
+• Emergency SOS: If you have turned the Emergency SOS function
+on, when you have an emergency and need emergency services,
+press the Power/Lock key 5 or more times quickly.
-As
-be
+• Emergency Location Service: If you have turned Emergency
+Location Services (ELS) on, when you call or text an emergency
+number, your device will use ELS to automatically send your location
+to emergency responders.
-the
-a
+• Earthquake alerts: Get an alert with the initial estimated magnitude
-machine
+and distance from your location.
-has
+• Wireless emergency alerts: Turn wireless emergency alerts on
-been
+or off. You can also view emergency alert history and manage alert
+preferences.
-tested
+Passwords & accounts
-at the
+Set up and manage all of your accounts, including your Google Account
+and other social networking accounts, through the Accounts settings
+menu. From the Settings screen, tap Passwords & accounts.
-factory,
+33
-there
+34
-may
+• Passwords: See, change, or remove passwords you saved in your
-little
+• Reduce interruptions: Enable or disable the notifications of apps
-coffee
+Google Account.
-left in the machine
+and Do Not Disturb mode.
-.
+• Autofill service: Autofill your information when needed from your
-●
+Google Account.
-●
+• Add account: Set up your account.
+• Automatically sync app data: Activate automatic data syncing.
-●
+Digital Wellbeing & parental controls
-coffee
+Statistics screen usage time, app timers, bedtime schedules, manage
+notifications, etc.
+From the Settings screen, tap Digital Wellbeing & parental controls.
+• Your Digital Wellbeing tools: Use app timers and other tools to
-The
-first-time
-best working condition, and this process cannot be skipped
+keep track of screen time and unplug more easily.
-cleaning upon
-achieve
+• Ways to disconnect: View your screen time and set timers for your
+apps, set a bedtime schedule to disconnect from your phone and
+avoid interruptions while you sleep, pause distracting apps when you
+need time to focus.
-and
-machine
+• Show icon in the app list: Enable icons in the app list.
+• Parental controls: Add content restrictions and set other limits to
-machine
-this
+help your child balance their screen time.
-will
-helps
+Google
-start
-the
+Configure your device’s Google settings. Available options depend on
+your Google Account. From the Settings screen, tap Google.
-self-testing
+System
-coffee
+Manage detailed settings for your phone, including language and input
+settings, battery and storage, date and time, etc.
+From the Settings screen, tap System.
+• Languages: Set the language for the phone’s menus and keyboards,
+set the language for each app, set units and number preferences, etc.
-use,
+• Keyboard: Select and configure keyboard settings
-the
+35
-When powering on the coffee machine, it will automatically
+36
-complete heating and cleaning for one time, every
+• Gestures: Enable useful gestures, such as Quickly open camera,
+Navigation mode, Power & hold power menu and Prevent ringing.
+• Date & time: Enable or disable network-provided time, automatic
-time and the process cannot be stopped. The coffee machine
+time zone, 24-hour format, etc.
-can only be used after the above cycle process is finished.
+• Backup: Back up your phone’s data and settings to Google servers
-During the cleaning process, some hot water may flow out of
+before resetting your phone to the original factory settings.
-the coffee spout into the drip tray. Please avoid contacting
+• System update: Check for new software updates for your device.
+• Multiple users: Share this device with other people by creating
-the hot water.
+additional users.
-Please ensure the power is connected before pressing
-the
+• Reset options: View different reset options and reset your device.
-power button.
+About phone
-Power off
+Access important phone information, search for and apply updates, and
+view legal and safety information.
+From the Settings screen, tap About phone.
-●
+Troubleshooting
-●
+Below is a list of common problems that may occur when using your
+mobile phone. Try these easy troubleshooting steps to resolve any type
+of issues you may encounter.
+The phone does not power on
+• Press and hold the power key until the startup sequence appears on
-●
+the display.
-When powering off the coffee machine , it will automatically
-complete the cleaning process for one time, every time,and the
-process cannot be stopped. This operation is to clean up
-the coffee pipelines and remove the coffee grounds.
+• Check the battery level and ensure there is sufficient charge.
+The phone does not respond after several minutes
+• Remove and insert the battery – If the phone has an internal battery,
-During the cleaning process, some hot water will flow out of
-the coffee spout into the drip tray. Avoid touching hot
-water, so as not to be burned.
-Only after using milk/foam/cappuccino/latte, the Rinse
-Milk Unit function will be operated when the power is turned off.
+please press and hold the power button.
-When you press the power button, the machine will be
-powered off after auto cleaning
+The phone powers off by itself
+• Check if the screen lock of the phone is enabled.
+• Check if the phone needs to be charged.
-When
+37
-you
+38
-press
+The battery will not charge
+• Check if the battery is already fully charged.
+• Make sure that the battery is inserted correctly.
+• Ensure that the battery being used is a BLU approved battery.
+• Double check if the charger connector is properly connected to the
-the power
+phone.
-button,
+Note: Connect charger only after the battery has been inserted.
-the
+The phone displays a SIM Error
+• Make sure the SIM is properly inserted and in its intended slot.
+• Make sure that the SIM card is not damaged or scratched.
+The PIN code was entered incorrectly three times
+• The SIM card will lock, and you will need to enter the PUK code (PIN
+Unlock Code). Please contact your local service provider to obtain the
+PUK.
-machine
+The standby time is too short
+• Please keep in mind that standby time relates directly to phone usage
-will
+I cannot make calls
+• Make sure that the number you dialed is correct and the dial key has
-be
+(Internet, Text, Voice Calls, Maps, etc.).
-powered
+been pressed.
-off after auto
+• Batteries typically have to be replaced after a year of use.
+The phone cannot connect to the network (Voice or Data)
+• Verify if you have active service with your service provider.
+• Contact your local network service provider and verify if you are within
-cleaning.
+its network coverage area.
-READY
+• Use the full national area code when dialing out of your area or when
-06
+abroad, use country-specific international access codes.
-Making beverages
+I cannot receive calls
+• Make sure that your phone is connected to a network.
-T, his chapter instructs you on how to make various kinds
-of coffee, hot water,hot milk and milk foam by this coffee
-machine.Please read the following instructions carefully to help
-you make high-quality beverages
+39
-temperature
-The
-avoid being scalded.
+40
-of
+The caller ID does not display on incoming calls
+• Contact your local network service provider and verify you have the
+caller ID feature enabled on your account or verify if the caller may
+have blocked his number from appearing.
-the
+The caller cannot leave a voicemail message
+• Contact your local network service provider and verify if the voicemail
-hot
+service is active on your account or check if the network is busy.
-water
+The phone does not connect to the internet
+• Ensure with your service provider that your account has the
-is
+appropriate internet/data plan enabled.
-high,
+• Ensure internet APN settings are configured (Carrier dependent).
+Text Messages cannot be Sent / Received
+• Ensure text messaging is enabled with your service provider.
+• Ensure APN settings are configured (Carrier dependent).
-please
+Regulatory Information
-do
+FCC regulations
-not
+This mobile phone complies with part 15 of the FCC Rules. Operation is
+subject to the following two conditions: (1) This device may not cause
+harmful interference, and (2) this device must accept any interference
+received, including interference that may cause undesired operation.
+This mobile phone has been tested and found to comply with the limits
+for a Class B digital device, pursuant to Part 15 of the FCC Rules. These
+limits are designed to provide reasonable protection against harmful
+interference in a residential installation.
+This equipment generates, uses and can radiate radio frequency energy
+and, if not installed and used in accordance with the instructions, may
+cause harmful interference to radio communications.
+
+41
+
+42
+
+However, there is no guarantee that interference will not occur in a
+particular installation If this equipment does cause harmful interference
+to radio or television reception, which can be determined by turning
+the equipment off and on, the user is encouraged to try to correct the
+interference by one or more of the following measures:
+• Reorient or relocate the receiving antenna.
+• Increase the separation between the equipment and receiver.
+• Connect the equipment into an outlet on a circuit different from that
+
+to which the receiver is connected.
+
+• Consult the dealer or an experienced radio/TV technician for help.
+Changes or modifications not expressly approved by the party
+responsible for compliance could void the user’s authority to operate the
+equipment.
+The antenna(s) used for this transmitter must not be co-located or
+operating in conjunction with any other antenna or transmitter.
+
+RF Exposure Information (SAR)
+
+This mobile phone meets the government’s requirements for exposure to
+radio waves.
+This phone is designed and manufactured not to exceed the emission
+limits for exposure to radio frequency (RF) energy set by the Federal
+Communications Commission of the U.S. Government.
+The exposure standard for wireless mobile phones employs a unit of
+measurement known as the Specific Absorption Rate, or SAR. The SAR
+limit set by the FCC is 1.6 W/kg. *Tests for SAR are conducted using
+standard operating positions accepted by the FCC with the phone
+transmitting at its highest certified power level in all tested frequency
+bands.
+Although the SAR is determined at the highest certified power level,
+the actual SAR level of the phone while operating can be well below
+the maximum value. This is because the phone is designed to operate
+at multiple power levels so as to use only the poser required to reach
+the network. In general, the closer you are to a wireless base station
+antenna, the lower the power output.
+
+43
+
+44
+
+The highest SAR value for the model phone as reported to the FCC when
+tested for use at the ear is 1.29 W/kg and when worn on the body, as
+described in this user guide, is 0.89 W/kg (Body-worn measurements
+differ among phone models, depending upon available accessories and
+FCC requirements.).
+While there may be differences between the SAR levels of various
+phones and at various positions, they all meet the government
+requirement.
+The FCC has granted an Equipment Authorization for this model phone
+with all reported SAR levels evaluated as in compliance with the FCC RF
+exposure guidelines. SAR information on this model phone is on file with
+the FCC and can be found under the Display Grant section of www.fcc.
+gov/oet/ea/fccid after searching on FCC ID: YHLBLUB160V.
+For body worn operation, this phone has been tested and meets the FCC
+RF exposure guidelines for use with an accessory that contains no metal
+and the positions the handset with a minimum of 1.5 cm from the body.
+
+Use of other accessories may not ensure compliance with FCC RF
+exposure guidelines. If you do not use a body-worn accessory and are
+not holding the phone at the ear, position the handset a minimum of 1.5
+cm from your body when the phone is switched on.
+
+Safety precautions for power supply unit
+
+Use the correct external power source
+A product should be operated only from the type of power source
+indicated on the electrical ratings label. If you are not sure of the type
+of power source required, consult your authorized service provider or
+local power company. For a product that operates from battery power or
+other sources, refer to the operating instructions that are included with
+the product.
+This product should be operated only with the following designated
+power supply unit(s).
+Travel charger: Input: 100-240V, 50/60Hz, 0.35A. Output: 5V, 2000mA.
+
+45
+
+46
+
+Handle battery packs carefully
+This product contains a Lithium-ion battery. There is a risk of fire and
+burns if the battery pack is handled improperly. Do not attempt to open
+or service the battery pack. Do not disassemble, crush, puncture, short
+circuit the external contacts or circuits, dispose of in fire or water, or
+expose a battery pack to temperatures higher than 140°F (60°C). The
+operating temperature for the phone is 14°F (-10°C) to 113°F (45°C).
+Warning: Battery is non-removable. Do not attempt to remove
+the battery for danger of explosion.
+To reduce risk of fire or burns, do not disassemble, crush, puncture,
+short circuit the external contacts, expose to temperature above 113°F
+(45°C), or dispose of in fire or water. Do not attempt to replace the
+non-removable battery. The phone and battery as a unibody device
+must be disposed of in accordance with locally applicable environmental
+regulations or guides supplied with your product.
+
+47
+
+Take extra precautions
+• Do not disassemble or open crush, bend or deform, puncture or
+
+shred.
+
+• Do not modify or remanufacture, attempt to insert foreign objects into
+the battery, immerse or expose to water or other liquids, expose to
+fire, explosion, or other hazards.
+
+• Only use the battery with a charging system that has been qualified
+
+with the system per CTIA Certification Requirement for Battery System
+Compliance to IEEE1725. Use of an unqualified battery or charger may
+present a risk of fire, explosion, leakage, or other hazards.
+
+• Replace the battery only with another battery that has been qualified
+
+with the system per this standard, IEEE-Std-1725. Use of an
+unqualified battery may present a risk of fire, explosion, leakage or
+other hazards. Only authorized service providers shall replace battery.
+(If the battery is non-user replaceable).
+
+• Promptly dispose of used batteries in accordance with local
+
+regulations.
+
+• Improper battery use may result in a fire, explosion, or other hazards.
+48
+
+• Do not replace an embedded battery pack. Improper replacement may
+present a risk of fire, explosion, leakage or other hazards. Contact the
+manufacturer for replacement instructions.
+
+• The phone identifies the battery by the Battery ID Pin.
+• If the battery leaks:
+
+• Do not allow the leaking fluid to come in contact with skin or
+
+clothing. If already in contact, flush the affected area immediately
+with clean water and seek medical advice.
+
+• Do not allow the leaking fluid to come in contact with eyes.
+If already in contact, DO NOT rub; rinse with clean water
+immediately and seek medical advice.
+
+• Take extra precautions to keep a leaking battery away from fire as
+
+there is a danger of ignition or explosion.
+
+Hearing Aid Compatibility (HAC)
+
+This device is hearing aid-compatible as determined by ANSI C63.19-
+2019 and waiver DA-23-914. The lowest conversational gain is 10.32
+dB with a hearing-aid, and 13.93 dB without hearing-aid, using telecoil
+coupling capability and Bluetooth connectivity.
+The 2019 ANSI C63.19 standard does not use this rating system nor
+do any test standards exist for any wireless technologies that transmit
+above 6 GHz. Instead, this standard uses the conversational gains for
+the device’s hearing aid compatible capabilities.
+This device has been tested and certified for use with hearing aids for
+some of the wireless technologies that it uses. However, there may be
+some newer wireless technologies used in this phone that have not been
+tested yet for use with hearing aids. It is important to try the different
+features of this phone thoroughly and in different locations, using your
+hearing aid or cochlear implant, to determine if you hear any interfering
+noise. Consult your service provider or the manufacturer of this phone
+for information on hearing aid compatibility. If you have questions about
+return or exchange policies, consult your service provider or retailer.
-touch
+49
-it
+50
-to
+We consent to the following conditions of the waiver:
+• Pass Conversational Gain, Receive Distortion and Noise and Receive
-Before making
-display.
-on
+Acoustic Frequency Response testing using one narrowband and one
+wideband codec, limited to one bit rate.
-the
+• Pass Conversational Gain at both 2N and 8N on all available
-all
+narrowband and wideband codecs and air interface combinations.
+Please see the HAC Volume Control test report for further details and
+supporting data.
-kinds
+The information provided in this user manual is subject to change without notice
+and BLU Products reserves the right to modify the manual at any given time. BLU
+Products has made every effort to ensure that this user manual is accurate and
+disclaims responsibility and liability for any inaccuracies or omissions. BLU Products
+makes no commitment to keep current the user manuals, however, does reserve
+the right to make improvements to the user manual at any given time without
+notice.
-of
+Google, Google Play, Google Maps, YouTube, Gmail and other marks are
+trademarks of Google LLC.
-coffee,
-
-please
-
-ensure
-
-“READY”
-
-is
-
-indicated
-
-●
-●
-
-●
-
-●
-
-●
-
-●
-
-used.
-
-ensure
-
-at
-it
-of
-
-recommended
-
-water
-better,
-quality
-
-normal
-is
-coffee,
-
-potable
-tastes
-the
-
-can
-temperature
-use
-to
-change
-
-The coffee beans should be stored in a dry place and avoid sunlight.
-Only
-make the
-coffee
-To
-tank every day.
-Please
-taste.
-Please
-of
-height of the cup in order to avoid coffee splashing.
-Adjustable height of coffee spout: 80-140mm.
-
-around25℃.
-in the
-
-be
-water
-the
-
-making the
-
-according
-
-please
-
-before
-
-coffee
-
-coffee
-
-coffee
-
-height
-
-better
-
-adjust
-
-water
-
-water
-
-warm
-
-spout
-
-cup
-
-the
-
-the
-
-the
-
-the
-
-for
-
-To
-
-to
-
-Preparing coffee by touch icon
-
-You can make 4 kinds of coffee using the touch icons, when
-shows
-“READY”
-
-the screen
-
-Take espresso for example to explain how to make coffee by touch icons.
-
-07
-
-The volume of espresso is suggested between 30 to 50ml.
-Because of the small volume of espresso, please warm the coffee cup before
-making coffee.
-
-Touch the espresso icon for espresso
-function.
-
-ESPRESSO
-
-STRONG
-
-VOLUME
-
-50ML
-
-ENJOY !
-
-The grinder will begin to grind . At this time
-you can adjust the amount of coffee beans
-by rotating the rotary button.
-Default amount of coffee beans for
-espresso:
-
-During making coffee, you can adjust the
-volume of coffee by rotating the rotary
-button.
-Default volume of espresso: 50ML
-
-When the screen shows as the left picture, it
-means the espresso is ready, please enjoy
-it.
-
-READY
-
-ESPRESSO
-
-Single time setting of coffee parameters
-
-Adjusting coffee parameters during a brew cycle.
-
-Making beverages
-
-●
-●
-●
-●
-●
-●
-●
-●
-
-Set the amount of coffee beans during the grinding process.
-Set the volume of coffee when making coffee
-Set the dispense time of milk
-foam to control the
-to
-Set the dispense time of milk
-Set the temperature of hot water before making hot water
-Set the hot water volume when making hot water
-Set the dispense time of hot milk
-Set the dispense time of hot foam when making hot foam
-
-the volume
-
-control the
-
-volume
-
-volume
-
-control
-
-to
-
-making
-when
-when making latte
-
-cappuccino
-
-when making hot milk
-
-Detail instructions
-You can set the strength of coffee before making the beverage and the
-volume of the beverage
-saved.
-
-during the brew cycle. The settings will
-
-not be
-
-STRONG
-
-VOLUME
-
-40ML
-
-FOAM TIME
-
-20S
-
-MILK TIME
-
-15S
-
-NORMAL
-
-VOLUME
-
-60ML
-
-When
-rotate
-
-grinding
-rotary
-the
-
-the
-button
-
-coffee
-to
-
-beans,
-the
-
-you
-amount
-
-can
-of
-
-adjust
-
-coffee
-
-beans,
-
-to
-
-the left
-
-is
-
-mild
-
-,
-
-and
-
-to
-
-the right
-
-is strong . The
-
-default
-
-amount
-
-is normal
-
-When
-can
-For
-2
-clicks
-
-making long
-
-coffee
-
-volume
-
-coffee,
-by using the
-
-be adjusted
-example,
-
-the current
-
-rotary
-is
-to reduce
-95ml,
-increase to 105ml.
-
-volume
-to
-
-button.
-100ml,
-2
-and
-
-clicks
-
-to the
-
-to the
-
-right
-
-left
-to
-
-cappuccino,
-making
-the
-
-making
-latte,the foam
-
-When
-coffee
-adjusted by rotating
-the milk foam outflows.
-current time is 20s,2 clicks
-reduce
-increase to 21S.
-
-For
-
-to
-
-milk
-time
-
-foam
-be
-
-or
-
-can
-rotary
-button
-example,the
-to
-to the
-
-left
-
-19S,and 2 clicks to the right to
-
-while
-
-08
-
-making
-
-time
-button.
-
-When
-dispensing
-the rotary
-milk dispensing
-left to reduce to
-to increase to 16S.
-
-hot
-can
-
-milk
-be
-
-coffee
-
-or
-adjusted
-
-For
-time
-14S,
-
-example,
-is
-and
-
-15S,
-2
-
-2
-clicks
-
-latte,
-
-milk
-rotating
-current
-to the
-
-by
-the
-clicks
-
-to the
-
-right
-
-hot
-
-making
-
-Before
-adjusted
-be
-the left
-low,
-is
-temperature is normal.
-
-water,
-rotating
-right is
-
-by
-to the
-
-temperature
-rotary
-
-the
-the
-high. The
-
-default
-
-button.
-
-can
-To
-
-dispensing
-
-be
-
- can
-button.
-is
-and
-
-For
-100ML,
-2
-
-hot
-
-adjusted
-
-water,
-by
-example,
-clicks
-2
-to
-clicks
-
-the
-hot
-rotating
-the
-to the
-
-water
-the
-current
-reduce
-left
- the right to increase
-
-to
-
-When
-volume
-rotary
-volume
-to
-95ML,
-to 105ML.
-
-Making beverages
-
-Preparing coffee with pre-ground coffee
-
-can
-
-You
-Pre-ground coffee.
-
-choose
-
-this
-
-function
-
-if
-
-you
-
-want
-
-to
-
-make
-
-coffee
-
-with
-
-●Do not use instant coffee powder
-pre-ground
-damage the machine.
-
-or cocoa powder in the
-coffee chute. powder container.Otherwise it will
-
-●
-Do not put pre-ground coffee powder into the coffee
-bean hopper,otherwise, it will damage the machine.
-
-●
-
-●
-
-●
-
-Please use proper Pre-ground coffee for espresso.
-
-Only 7-14g of pre-ground coffee can be added.
-Machine will be
-
-damaged.
-
-The process of using pre-ground coffee to make coffee
-only skips the process of grinding coffee beans, other
-operations are the same as making espresso, long coffee,
-cappuccino, and coffee latte. This chapter illustrates with
-espresso.
-
-Press and hold the rotary button to
-enter into
-programming when the
-coffee machine is
-“READY”.
-
-READY
-
-09
-
-GROUND COFFEE
-
-Display shows “GROUND COFFEE ” page
-after entered into programming. Press
-the rotary button to make coffee.
-
-Open pre-ground coffee chute cover and
-fill .close the cover. Touch the
-
-icon
-beverage
-Press the rotary button to
-
-need
-
-you
-
-to
-
-make
-cancel.
-
-coffee.
-
-FILL GROUND COFFEE
-
-SELECT COFFEE
-ROTARY TO CANCEL
-
-Program setting
-
-●
-
-This chapter will give instructions on program settings.
-
-●
-
-Ensure the coffee machine shows “READY”, press and hold the
-
-rotary button , then you can enter into the menu
-
-Beverage setting
-
-will
-
-instruct
-
-chapter
-
-This
-settings
-temperature
-hot milk, dispense time of
-
-you
-parameters include
-hot
-
-of
-
-how
-to
-coffee
-
-set
-strength,
-
-beverages parameters.
-coffee,
-
-volume
-
-of
-
-The
-
-water,volume of hot water,dispense time of making
-
-making hot foam
-
-parameters
-
-accomplished
-
-by the
-
-beverage
-
-setting
-
-will
-
-be
-
-the
-
-The
-default
-
- values for each beverage.
-
-1. Espresso setting
-2. Long coffee setting
-3. Hot water setting
-4. Cappuccino setting
-5. Coffee latte setting
-6. Hot milk setting
-7. Hot foam setting
-
-Setting beverage parameters and range
-
-The parameters such as strength, volume, temperature and
-forthe beverages below.
-
-time can be set
-
-can be set
-
-can be set
-
-The strength and volume of espresso
-The strength and volume of long coffee
-The strength and volume of coffee part of cappuccino
-set
-The foam dispensing time in cappuccino
-eht dna trap eeffoc fo emulov dna htgnerts ehT
-can be set
-The temperature and the volume of hot water can be set
-Hot milk making time can be set
-Hot foam making time can be set
-
-can be set
-
-can be
-
- ettal ni emit gnitiaw
-
-Please read the following table for the detail setting parameters and
-adjustment range
-
-10
-
-Drinks
-
-espresso
-
-long coffee
-
-cappuccino
-
-coffee Latte
-
-hot water
-
-hot milk
-
-hot foam
-
-Strength
-
-Volume range
-
-Default
-
-Mild:
-Normal:
-Strong:
-
-Mild:
-Normal:
-Strong:
-
-Volume: 15 -120ML
-
-Volume: 15 - 240ML
-
-Volume: 15 - 240ML
-Milk time: 0 - 120SEC
-Foam time: 3 - 120SEC
-Wait time: 0 - 30SEC
-
-Volume: 25 -450ML
-
-Milk time: 3 -120SEC
-
-Foam time: 3 -120SEC
-
-50ML
-
-100ML
-
-60ML
-
-Foam time: 20SEC
-
-60ML
-
-Milk time: 15SEC
-Foam time: 20SEC
-Wait : 20SEC
-
-100ML
-
-15 SEC
-
-15 SEC
-
-Temperature Setting
-
-The coffee temperature can be adjusted to your liking with the “ Temperature setting”
-function and you can choose:
-
-1 .Low
-
-2 .Normal
-
-3 .High
-
-The default temperature is Normal, and it’s only adjustable for coffee not milk.
-
-Program setting
-
-Eco settings
-
-●
-
-●
-
-If the machine is set to Eco-setting, the machine needs 30
-seconds to warm up to make Cappuccino, Coffee Latte,
-milk and foam. . The normal setting has more energy
-consumption than the Eco-saving mode.
-
-Hot
-
-The factory default setting of the machine is normal mode.
-entering the program setting, please turn the rotary
-“ECO SETTING” option, then press the rotary button,
-finished.
-
-button to
-setting is
-
-After
-
-Automatic power-down
-
-switch
-
-off
-
-time
-
-automatically
-
-is 4 hours,
-switch
-
-which
-off 4 hours
-
-automatic
-
-switch-off
-
-is
-
-from
-
-15
-
-minutes
-
-to
-
-program
-
-setting,
-Then
-
-please
-press
-
-the
-
-turn
-
-the
-rotary
-
-rotary
-button,
-
-option.
-
-will
-
-default
-
-machine
-
-machine’s
-
-the
-setting
-
-last use .
-range
-
-The
-means the
-after
-The
-24 hours.
-entering
-After
-button
-“Auto-off”
-the
-the setting is completed.
-
-the
-
-to
-
-of
-
-Factory Reset
-
-●
-
-●
-
-●
-
-●
-
-●
-
-will
-
-the
-
-the
-
-all
-to
-
-function
-
-reset
-parameters
-options). However
-
-This
-beverage
-language
-not be reset.
-After
-the
-confirm, the setting is completed.
-
-program
-option
-
-“FACTORY RESET”
-
-entering
-
-the
-
-the
-
-menu
-factory
-
-setting
-settings
-
-and
-(except
-
-default
-the
-
-information
-
-options
-
-will
-
-setting,
-then
-
-please
-
-press
-
-the
-
-turn
-
-the
-rotary
-
-rotarybutton
-button
-
-to
-
-to
-
-Information Statics
-
-11
-
-●
-
-In this program you can view the statistical information on
-the number of drinks, total drinks numbers, etc.
-
-1. Number of rinses
-2. Number of total cycles
-3. Number of espresso
-4. Number of long coffee
-5. Number of hot water
-6. Number of cappuccino
-7. Number of coffee latte
-8. Number of hot milk
-9. Number of hot foam
-10. Number of descales
-11. Number of ground coffee
-12. Number of brew unit cleans
-13. Number of milk unit rinses
-
-●
-
-When first viewed there will
-produced
-been
-
-because
-before leaving the factory.
-
-already be
-each
-
-beverages
-
-tested
-
-a
-coffee
-
-number
-
-of
-machine
-
-has
-
-Language
-
-●
-
-You can set your preferred language on the coffee machine.
-
-●
-
-After entering the program setting, turn the rotary button to the "CHOOSE
-LANGUAGE" option, then press the rotary button, rotate the rotary to
-choose the language, and press the rotary button, the language setting
-is completed.
-EXIT
-
-●
-
-After entering the program setting, please turn the rotary button to the
-“EXIT” option. Then press the rotary button. The
-machine will return to
-“READY” .
-
-Cleaning and maintenance
-
-chapter
-
-This
-the coffee machine.
-
-will
-
-instruct
-
-you on
-
-how
-
-to
-
-clean
-
-and
-
-maintain
-
-Paying
-machine,will
-coffee,
-
-attention
-not
-also
-
-but
-
-daily
-
-maintenance
-to
-only
-of
-taste
-the
-extend the life of the coffee machine.
-
-coffee
-cup
-
-of the
-of
-
-ensure
-
-each
-
-Cleaning the coffee machine before operation
-
-chapter
-This
-coffee machine.
-
-will
-
-instruct
-
-you
-
-on how
-
-to
-
-clean
-
-and
-
-maintain
-
-the
-
-Cleaning function must be processed in “READY” status.
-
-When the coffee machine is in “READY”
-status and the cleaning indicator light is not
-on, press the cleaning button to start
-cleaning the brewing unit and coffee
-spout.
-
-The process of cleaning coffee machine
-cannot be interrupted, and it will
-automatically return to “READY” status after
-cleaning.
-
-READY
-
-CLEANING
-
-Cleaning brewing unit
-
-READY
-
-12
-
-After a long-term use, there will be some coffee ground
-brewing unit. Remove the grounds by deeply cleaning the
-brewing
-The process of cleaning the brewing unit takes about
-
- unit.
-
-20minutes.
-
-left in the
-
-After entering the program settings, turn the
-rotary button to the "MAINTENANCE" option,
-and press the rotary button.
-
-When the screen shows the picture on the
-indicates cleaning the brewing unit
-left, it
- has been selected. Press the
-program
-cleaning
-button to start cleaning the
-brewing unit.
-
-The brew unit is cleaning.
-
-MAINTENANCE
-
-CLEAN BREW UNIT
-
-CLEANING
-
-Cleaning and maintenance
-
-OPEN COVER ADD
-CLEANING TABLET
-
-CLOSE COVER
-PRESS RINSE
-
-CLEAN
-
-CLEANING
-
-READY
-
-Open the pre-ground coffee chute cover,
-add
-
-the cleaning tablet.
-
-Close the pre-ground coffee chute
-cover,
-press the cleaning button to
-start the cleaning process.
-
-The screen will display as the left picture,
-
-Brew unit is now cleaning.
-
-After cleaning has finished, the machine
-re-enters
-
-into “READY” status.
-
-13
-
-Please empty the drip tray after the cleaning program is completed.
-
-First 5 cups must be discarded after cleaning.
-
-RINSE MILK UNIT
-
-●
-
-After long-term use, some milk waste would be left in the Milk
-needs to
-
-be cleaned.
-
-unit and
-
-Enter the program setting, Turn the
-rotary
-page and
-
-button to the“MAINTENANCE”
-pressed the rotary button.
-
-When showing left picture in the display, it is
-now in milk unit cleaning mode, press the
-cleaning button to start.
-
-Remove the milk pipe from the milk
-container and insert it into the hole in the
-drip tray grid according to the display.
-Press the rinse button to rinse milk unit.
-
-MAINTENANCE
-
-RINSE MILK UNIT
-
-REMOVE MILK PIPE
-
-PRESS RINSE
-
-Milk unit is cleaning.
-After cleaning is finished, the machine
-enters
-
- into “READY” status.
-
-Cleaning and maintenance
-
-RINSE MILK UNIT
-
-Please empty the drip tray after the cleaning process
-
-is
-
-completed.
-
-First 5 cups must be discarded after cleaning.
-
-Descaling the coffee machine
-
-The daily usage will cause calcium deposits in the coffee
-machine. The depositing rate varies with the local water
-hardness.
-
-Decalcifier contains acidic substances that
-could hurt
-comply with the security warnings noted by the
-manufacturer on the packaging.
-
-your eyes and skin, so you must strictly
-
-Dissolve the decalcifier in clean water, and then put the
-mixed liquid into the water tank. Fully dissolved the
-Decalcifier can descale the coffee machine more
-thoroughly.
-The whole descaling process takes about 30 minutes.
-Do not cancel the descaling process or you will damage
-the coffee machine.
-once
-process,please do not terminate it midway or turn off
-power to themachine.
-
-descaling
-
-start
-
-you
-
-the
-
-So
-
-NEED DESCALE
-
-PRESS RINSE
-
-MAINTENANCE
-
-DESCALE
-
-30 MINS
-
-PRESS RINSE
-
-14
-
-After a certain time of use, if it reaches a
-high
-degree of scaling, “NEEDS DESCALE"
-and"PRESS RINSE " will automatically
-display on
-the screen alternately. Now, press the
-cleaning button to enter the descaling
-program.
-
-Turn the rotary button to the maintenance
-setting option, press the rotary button to
-enter.
-
-Turn the rotary button to descaling option,
-press rotary button to enter
-
-After entering the descaling program, press
-the cleaning button to start the descaling
-program; it will take about
-
-minutes.
-
-30
-
-Cleaning and maintenance
-
-SOLVENT IN TANK
-
-PRESS RINSE
-
-DECALCIFYING
-
-EMPTY TRAY
-
-Take a bag of decalcifier and sufficiently
-dissolve it in clean water, then put this
-mixed liquid to the water tank, and reinstall
-the water tank to the coffee machine.
-
-After adding decalcifier, press the
-cleaning
-cleaning.
-
-button to start descaling and
-
-To start descaling and cleaning for the first
-time, put a container, of which the
-capacity is more than 1L, under the coffee
-spout.
-
-Empty tray.
-
-Install tray.
-
-INSTALL TRAY
-
-15
-
-FILL WATER TANK
-
-After descaling and cleaning for the first
-time, take the water tank out, empty the
-rest of the water and clean it. Add
-potable water again, and reinstall it to the
-coffee machine
-
- and cleaning for the second
-
-Press the cleaning button to enter
-descaling
-time. This is to clean
-decalcifying water in pipes at
-a container, of which the
-than 1L, under the coffee
-
-the residual
-
-capacity is more
-spout.
-
-this time . Put
-
-Decalcifying.
-
-the
-
-screen
-
-When
-shows
-the descaling is completed; Now, you can
-continue to brew beverages.
-
-“READY”,
-
-indicates
-
-it
-
-PRESS RINSE
-
-DECALCIFYING
-
-READY
-
-Please empty the drip tray after the cleaning program is completed.
-
-First 5 cups must be discarded after cleaning.
-
-Cleaning coffee grounds container and drip tray
-
-●
-
-●
-
-●
-
-not
-
-use
-
-and
-
-corrosive
-
-chemical
-
-Do
-cleaner
-solvents
-to clean the coffee grounds container and drip tray.
-The drip tray and coffee grounds container cannot be cleaned
-in dishwasher.
-not
-Do
-avoid
-
-residue
-container.
-
-use
-scraping
-
-coffee
-grounds
-
-objects
-drip
-
-or
-dirt
-coffee
-
-clean
-and
-
-to
-tray
-
-metal
-
-the
-
-to
-
-or
-
-alcohol
-
-Cleaning and maintenance
-
-1
-
-●
-When prompted to empty the coffee grounds, coffee grounds
-must be cleaned up, or it will cause the machine to be
-damaged.
-
-.
-
-When it accumulates to 35 cups, it will
-automatically indicate “EMPTY GROUNDS”.
-
-2
-
-EMPTY GROUNDS
-
-INSTALL TRAY
-
-READY
-
-EMPTY TRAY
-
-INSTALL TRAY
-
-READY
-
-When it shows “INSTALL TRAY “, please
-remove coffee grounds from the drip tray
-and
-more than 3 seconds.
-
- coffee grounds container. This will take
-
-Reinstall the water drip tray in the machine,
-it should returns to “READY” status. You can
-continue using the machine.
-
-If the drip tray is full, the machine will
-automatically indicate"EMPTY TRAY". Take
-out the water drip tray and dispose of
-waste
-
- water.
-
-After clearing the waste water, reinstall the
-drip tray to the coffee machine, it should
-returns to“READY” status. You can continue
-using the machine.
-
-3
-
-4
-
-16
-
- ●
-
-Each time you are cleaning coffee grounds and waste water
-from the drip tray, please empty the drip tray and coffee
-grounds
-
-container.
-
-●
-
-Each time after cleaning coffee grounds and waste water from the drip
-tray,
-at the end of drip tray, then reinstall the drip tray to the coffee machine.
-
-please rinse the tray with clean water, and wipe dry the 2 steel plates
-
-Cleaning and maintenance
-
-Cleaning water tank
-
-●
-
-●
-
-●
-
-It is suggested that, each time adding water, clean the tank
-thoroughly with running water first.
-Cleaning the water tank regularly
-
-to
-
-be
-
-use
-
-rag
-
-a wet
-
-better
-
-would
-
-and some mild
-
-it
-cleaning fluid.
-Because the water tank is made from food-grade materials and
-environmental materials, it might crack if handled
-aggressively. Please gently pick it up
-and put it down, and
-never let it fall down. if the water tank is damaged, please
-contact the customer service center.
-
-Cleaning bean container
-
-●
-
-●
-
-●
-
-to
-
-do
-
-not
-
-use
-
-wash
-
-water
-
-,
-would
-it
-
-beans hopper
-
-in the bean hopper
-
-the
-Please
-cause the grinder to be damaged.
-Please use a dry rag or a paper towel to clean the
-residue
-food-grade
-Because
-crack if handle aggre.
- and
-Please gently pick it up and put it down, and never let it fall
-down. If the bean container lid is damaged , please contact
-the customer service center.
-
-.
-cover
-it
-
-environmental
-
-is
-might
-
-container
-
-materials,
-
-grease
-
-made
-
-bean
-
-from
-
-the
-
-ssively.
-
-Disassembling and cleaning the milk frother
-
-In order to guarantee the fine and smooth milk foam, please
-clean the milk frother every day.
-
-1. Carefully take off the milk frother.
-2. Disassemble each part of the milk frother thoroughly.
-3. Wash the parts with running water.
-4. Reassemble the milk frother, and install it to the coffee
-machine.
-
-17
-
-1
-
-2
-
-3
-
-4
-
-Installing milk pipe
-
-●
-
-Install the milk pipe to the milk frother inlet.
-
-Cleaning milk pipe
-
-In order to keep milk pipe clean, please clean it every day.
-
-1. Take off milk pipe carefully.
-2. Clean milk pipe in running water.
-
-Cleaning coffee machine
-
-●
-
-●
-
-●
-
-●
-
-the
-
-check
-
-coffee
-
-grounds residue
-
-Before cleaning the interior of the coffee machine, power it
-off, the disconnect power cord from the outlet ,Never
-immerse the coffee machine inwater. There will be a risk of
-electric shock.
-Regularly
-coffee
-brush to remove the coffee
-
-machine
-the
-ground.
-Use a dry and soft
-machine.
-the
-As the touch panel is made of glass, please do not hit it to
-avoid the risk of electric shock once the glass broken.
-Use a dry and soft rag to wipe the surface of the machine,
-and never use hard objects to clean coffee residue on the
-surface, otherwise it would cause the surface to be
-damaged.
-
-is
-can use a
-
-whether
-machine.
-
-there
-You
-
-excessive
-
-touch
-
-panel
-
-inside
-
-wipe
-
-rag
-
-the
-
-to
-
-of
-
-Problem Causes and Solutions
-
-●
-
-●
-
-This chapter will instruct you on some errors that you may
-encounter
-
-and the solutions.
-
-If there are some failures cannot be resolved by the following
-methods, please contact with the authorized service center.
-
-melborP
-
-Cause
-
-snoituloS
-
-The coffee temperature is too low.
-
-The coffee cup was not pre-heated.
-
-Wash the coffee cup with hot water
-before making coffee.
-
-Several minutes have passed since the
-last time of coffee making , so the
-brewing unit and the internal pipes are
-already cold.
-
-Make some more cups of coffee.
-
-18
-
-Coffee only comes out from the
-coffee spout drop by drop.
-
-Overly fine pre -ground coffee or coffee
-bean has been ground too fine.
-
-Adjust the grinding level to coarse
-or use the suitable pre-ground coffee .
-
-Brewing unit filter was blocked.
-
-Run the brewing unit rinse programme
-
-Insufficient coffee oil.
-
-Chose the wrong coffee bean type.
-
-The grinder is making unusual noises.
-
-There are foreign objects in the grinder.
-
-Use suitable coffee beans.
-
-Make coffee again, if it still fails, please
-contact the authorized service center
-
-The milk frother cannot make any milk
-foam.
-
-The milk frother is blocked.
-
-Cleaning the milk frother ( refer to P17).
-
-Milk sprays from the milk frother.
-
-The milk frother was not assembled
-correctly.
-
-Reassemble the milk frother.
-
-Screen always indicates "EMPTY TRAY".
-
-Screen always indicates "INSTALL TRAY".
-
-Screen always indicates “FILL WATER
-TANK”, but the water tank is full.
-
-The sheet metal at the end of the drip
-tray is dirty or wet.
-
-Coffee grounds in the bottom of the
-machine are not cleaned.
-
-Wipe the sheet metal to dry ( refer to P16).
-
-Clean the coffee grounds in the bottom.
-
-The water tank inductor is trapped.
-
-Clean the water tank ( refer to P17).
-
-Screen always indicates “FILL BEANS”,
-but the bean container is full.
-
-The bean container is too oily and
-sticky for coffee beans.
-
-“Errors 1 to 7”is displayed.
-
-If the coffee machine fails, it cannot
-continue to be used
-
-1. Stir coffee beans in bean container.
-2. Observe if the coffee beans are over
-roasted or charcoal roasted.
-3. Clean the beans container ( refer to
-P17).
-
-1. Restart coffee machine.
-2. If “errors” still exist, switch off the main
-power, and contact the authorized
-service center
-
-Display information
-
-●
-
-This chapter will instruct you on the error information
-that is
-
-screen and the solutions.
-
- displayed on the
-
-Causes
-
-Solutions
-
-If the water drip tray is full,
-making beverage will
-service.
-
- be out of
-
-Take the drip tray out, empty the
-waste water in the drip tray and
-reinstall it to the machine.
-
-If the coffee grounds container is
-full, making
- beverage will be out
-of service.
-
-Take the coffee grounds container
-out, empty the coffee grounds
-container and reinstall it.
-
-If water in the water tank is
-empty, making
-be out of service.
-
- beverage will
-
-Fill the water tank with water.
-
-If coffee beans in the bean
-hopper are used up, making
-coffee will be out of
-
-service.
-
-Add beans into bean container,
-and press the rotary button to
-release.
-
-There is not enough pre -
-ground
-pre-ground coffee
-
-coffee
-
-in the
-
- chute.
-
-Next time when making coffee
-with pre-ground coffee , please
-use proper amount.
-
-The drip tray is not installed
-correctly; any function is out of
-service.
-
-Install the drip tray correctly.
-
-The water in the pipe inside the
-machine is not enough; any
-function is out of service.
-
-Press the rotary button to release,
-to run the water replenishing system.
-
-Temperature of the machine is too
-high, the machine cannot be used.
-
-Power off the main power, and
-wait 1 hour later.
-
-Temperature of the machine is too
-low, the machine cannot be used.
-
-Increase environmental temperature
-to above 10℃.
-
-EMPTY TRAY
-
-EMPTY GROUNDS
-
-FILL WATER TANK
-
-FILL BEANS
-
-FILL POWDER
-
-19
-
-INSTALL TRAY
-
-UNIT EMPTY
-
-TEMPERATURE HIGH
-
-TEMPERATURE LOW
-
-ERROR 1
-
-The coffee machine fails
-error1.may
-used.
-
-not be able to be
-
-1. Power off, then power back
-;2. If still unresolved, please
-on
-unplug from outlet.Contact with
-authorized service center.
-the
-
-1. Using dark roasted coffee beans
-or over fine pre-ground coffee
-filter of the brewer is
-2. The
-clogged.
-
-1.Adjust grinder wheel to a coarse
-setting2. Start brewer cleaning
-procedure(refer to P12).
-
-Dispenser valve is blocked.
-
-Restart coffee machine.
-
-PRESSURE HIGH
-
-VALVE RESET
-RESTART MACHINE
-
-Transport and recycle
-
-Transport
-
-Please save the packaging of the coffee machine for future
-transportation.
-Make sure to empty water inside the machine before transportation,
-otherwise, it will damage the machine.
-After emptying the waterway, please wipe the machine both
-inside and outside to dry.
-Once the empty waterway program was executed, the system
-will rerun to the program of “first-time use”, when the coffee
-machine is used again.( refer to P6, First-time use)
-While emptying the waterway, there will be high-temperature
-steam sprays from coffee spout. Please pay special attention to
-avoid being scalded.
-
-READY
-
-FILL WATER TANK
-
-EMPTY UNIT
-
-The machine is on the status of “READY”.
-
-Take out the water tank, and the machine
-indicates “FILL WATER TANK”.
-
-Press and hold the cleaning button until
-the screen shows "EMPTY UNIT", themachine
-begins to clean up the waterway
-automatically, and steam will spray from
-coffee spout, please keep your distance to
-avoid scalding.
-
-the
-
-After emptying the waterway, the machine
-will automatically power off. Take the drip
-tray out after the power is switched off, and
-clear the water in the drip tray.
-
-Recycle
-
-When recycling the machine, some inner parts can be
-recycled to use again. Please pay attention to recycle them
-for environmental protection.
-
-Technical Data
-
-Voltage/Frequency
-
-120V~ 50/60 Hz
-
-Power
-
-Pump pressure
-
-1450 W
-
-19 bar
-
-Capacity of water tank
-
-2 L or connect to water barrel
-
-Capacity of bean hopper
-
-Capacity of coffee ground waste bin
-
-Capacity of the brewing unit
-
-750 g
-
-35 cakes
-
-7 - 14 g
-
-Adjusting the height of coffee spout
-
-80 - 140 mm
-
-Length of power cord
-
-Net weight
-
-1.5 m
-
-16 kg
-
-Dimensions (Length×Width×Height)
-
-533mm×383mm×662mm
-
-20
+51
diff --git a/q15/random_k4/question.json b/q15/random_k4/question.json
index 4f851e40715cac938495549d782e4af34c348f93..cae82c8bbfd0130cc7e7558454d010d736ac2748 100644
--- a/q15/random_k4/question.json
+++ b/q15/random_k4/question.json
@@ -17,10 +17,10 @@
],
"original_filenames": [
"2312.10997v5.pdf",
- "web_ffc784688ff74004.pdf",
- "web_c40e5cade76fba39.pdf",
- "web_eb48e5fd4ea89aaf.pdf",
- "web_2ccba6013fe960b7.pdf"
+ "web_0592b193cfe894c0.pdf",
+ "resize_r2_25.pdf",
+ "web_fe44495665edf65a.pdf",
+ "web_5b8076d084922575.pdf"
],
"modality": "markdown"
}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/q15/random_k4/random_1.md b/q15/random_k4/random_1.md
index 568511cdd3e8b935079ff674d5949ce1b387f331..d3a8827a2c9c1661d68231635f74293c020f1a02 100644
--- a/q15/random_k4/random_1.md
+++ b/q15/random_k4/random_1.md
@@ -1,5479 +1,1353 @@
-Owner’s Manual
+CHAPTER 42
-Models
-14, 16, 17, 18
-
-Refrigerators
+FORMWORK
-TOP-MOUNT NO-FROST
+42 FORMWORK
-Part No. 162D6736P004 Pub. No.39-6424-1 9-99 JR
+Definitions
-Congratulations!
-
-Welcome to our family. We’re proud of our
-quality products and we are committed to
-providing dependable service. You’ll see it in
-this easy-to-use Owner’s Manual and you’ll
-hear it in the friendly voices of our customer
-service department.
-
-Best of all, you’ll experience these values
-each time you use your refrigerator. That’s
-important, because your new refrigerator will
-be part of your family for many years. And we
-hope you will be part of ours for a long time
-to come.
+The following definitions are used in the forming
+industry. Some terms may be used by other trades
+as well, but their meanings may be different from
+these depending upon the application.
-We appreciate your purchase, and hope you
-will continue to rely on us whenever you
-need quality appliances for your home.
+Falsework, in relation to a form or structure, means
+the structural supports and bracing used to support
+all or part of the form or structure until the concrete
+is poured and is strong enough to support loads.
-Important!
-
-Fill out and return the Consumer Product
-Registration Card that is packed with this
-product. If you cannot find it, please send
-in the duplicate card printed in the back of
-this manual.
+Flying formwork is a designed floor formwork
+system that can be hoisted between levels as a unit.
-Write the model and serial
-numbers here.
-
-#
-
-#
-
-You can find them on a label on the
-upper left side of the fresh food
-compartment.
-
-Staple sales slip or cancelled
-check here.
-
-Proof of the original purchase date
-is needed to obtain service under
-the warranty.
-
-2
-
-AService Partnership.
-
-We stand behind our products with
-unmatched quality service. However, did
-you know that most questions result from
-simple problems that you can easily
-fix yourself in just a few minutes? This
-Owner’s Manual can tell you how.
-
-Read this Manual
-Inside you will find many
-helpful hints on how to use and
-maintain your refrigerator
-properly. Just a little preventive
-care on your part can save you a
-great deal of time and money
-over the life of your refrigerator.
-
-Review the Section on
-Troubleshooting Tips
-
-You’ll find many answers to
-common problems here.
-If you review our chart of
-Troubleshooting Tips first,
-you may not need to call for
-service at all.
-
-If You Need Service
-
-If you do need service, you can
-relax knowing help is only a
-phone call away. A list of toll-free
-customer service numbers is
-included in the back section.
-Or you can always call the
-GE Answer Center® at
-800.626.2000, 24 hours a day,
-7 days a week.
-
-Safety Information
-Safety Precautions . . . . . . . . . .4
-Proper Disposal . . . . . . . . . . . . .5
-How to Connect Electricity . . . .6
-Use of Adapter Plugs . . . . . .6, 7
-Use of Extension Cords . . . . . .7
-
-Operating Instructions
-
-Temperature Control Dial . . . . .8
-Shelves . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .9, 10
-Storage Drawers . . . . . . . .11, 12
-Automatic Icemaker . . . . . . . .13
-Care and Cleaning . . . . . .14–16
-
-Installation Instructions
-
-Preparing to
-Install the Refrigerator . . .17, 18
-Water Line Installation . . .19–23
-Reversing the
-Door Swing . . . . . . . . . . . .24–29
-
-Troubleshooting Tips
-
-Normal Operating Sounds . . .30
-Before You
-Call For Service . . . . . . . . .31–33
-
-Customer Service
-Product Registration . . . . . . . .37
-Warranty . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .39
-Service Telephone
-Numbers . . . . . . . . . .Back Cover
-
-3
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-4
-
-IMPORTANT SAFETY INFORMATION.
-READ ALL INSTRUCTIONS BEFORE USING.
-WARNING!
-
-Use this appliance only for its intended purpose as
-described in this Owner’s Manual.
-
-SAFETY PRECAUTIONS
-When using electrical appliances, basic safety precautions
-should be followed, including the following:
-
-n Keep fingers out of the
-“pinch point” areas;
-clearances between the
-doors and between the doors
-and cabinet are necessarily
-small. Be careful closing
-doors when children are in
-the area.
-
-n Unplug the refrigerator
-
-before cleaning and making
-repairs.
-
-NOTE: We strongly recommend
-that any servicing be performed
-by a qualified individual.
-
-n Turning the control to the
-
-OFF position does not remove
-power to the light circuit.
-n Do not refreeze frozen foods
-
-which have thawed
-completely.
-
-n This refrigerator must be
-properly installed and
-located in accordance with
-the Installation Instructions
-before it is used.
-
-n Do not allow children to
-
-climb, stand or hang on the
-shelves in the refrigerator.
-They could damage the
-refrigerator and seriously
-injure themselves.
-n Do not touch the cold
-surfaces in the freezer
-compartment, particularly
-when hands are damp or wet.
-Skin may stick to these
-extremely cold surfaces.
-n Do not store or use gasoline
-or other flammable vapors
-and liquids in the vicinity of
-this or any other appliance.
-
-n In refrigerators with
-
-automatic icemakers, avoid
-contact with the moving parts
-of the ejector mechanism, or
-with the heating element that
-releases the cubes. Do not
-place fingers or hands on the
-automatic icemaking
-mechanism while the
-refrigerator is plugged in.
-
-DANGER! RISK OF CHILD
-
-ENTRAPMENT
-PROPER DISPOSAL OF THE REFRIGERATOR
-
-Child entrapment and suffocation are not problems of
-the past. Junked or abandoned refrigerators are still
-dangerous…even if they will sit for “just a few days.”
-If you are getting rid of your old refrigerator, please
-follow the instructions below to help prevent accidents.
-
-Before You Throw Away Your Old Refrigerator
-or Freezer:
-
-n Take off the doors.
-n Leave the shelves in place so that children may not
-
-easily climb inside.
-
-CFC Disposal
-
-Your old refrigerator has a cooling system that used
-CFCs (chlorofluorocarbons). CFCs are believed to harm
-stratospheric ozone.
-
-If you are throwing away your old refrigerator, make
-sure the CFC refrigerant is removed for proper disposal
-by a qualified servicer. If you intentionally release this
-CFC refrigerant you can be subject to fines and
-imprisonment under provisions of the Federal Clean
-Air Act.
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-5
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-6
-
-IMPORTANT SAFETY INFORMATION.
-READ ALL INSTRUCTIONS BEFORE USING.
-WARNING!
-
-HOW TO CONNECT ELECTRICITY
-Do not, under any circumstances, cut or remove the third
-(ground) prong from the power cord. For personal safety,
-this appliance must be properly grounded.
-
-The power cord of this appliance is equipped with a 3-prong
-(grounding) plug which mates with a standard 3-prong
-(grounding) wall outlet to minimize the possibility of electric
-shock hazard from this appliance.
-
-Have the wall outlet and circuit checked by a qualified electrician
-to make sure the outlet is properly grounded.
-
-Where a standard 2-prong wall outlet is encountered, it is your
-personal responsibility and obligation to have it replaced with a
-properly grounded 3-prong wall outlet.
-
-The refrigerator should always be plugged into its own individual
-electrical outlet which has a voltage rating that matches the rating
-plate.
-
-This provides the best performance and also prevents overloading
-house wiring circuits which could cause a fire hazard from
-overheated wires.
-
-Never unplug your refrigerator by pulling on the power cord.
-Always grip plug firmly and pull straight out from the outlet.
-
-Repair or replace immediately all power cords that have become
-frayed or otherwise damaged. Do not use a cord that shows cracks or
-abrasion damage along its length or at either end.
-
-When moving the refrigerator away from the wall, be careful not to
-roll over or damage the power cord.
-
-USE OF ADAPTER PLUGS
-Because of potential safety hazards under certain
-conditions, we strongly recommend against the use of an
-adapter plug.
-
-However, if you must use an adapter, where local codes permit, a
-temporary connection may be made to a properly grounded 2-prong
-wall outlet by use of a UL-listed adapter available at most local
-hardware stores.
-
-The larger slot in the adapter must be aligned with the larger slot in
-the wall outlet to provide proper polarity in the connection of the
-power cord.
-
-When disconnecting the power cord from the adapter, always hold
-the adapter in place with one hand while pulling the power cord
-plug with the other hand. If this is not done, the adapter ground
-terminal is very likely to break with repeated use.
-
-If the adapter ground terminal breaks, DO NOT USEthe refrigerator
-until a proper ground has been established.
-
-Attaching the adapter ground terminal to a wall outlet cover screw does not
-ground the appliance unless the cover screw is metal, and not insulated, and the
-wall outlet is grounded through the house wiring. You should have the circuit
-checked by a qualified electrician to make sure the outlet is properly grounded.
-
-USE OF EXTENSION CORDS
-Because of potential safety hazards under certain
-conditions, we strongly recommend against the use of an
-extension cord.
-
-However, if you must use an extension cord, it is absolutely
-necessary that it be a UL-listed, 3-wire grounding type appliance
-extension cord having a grounding type plug and outlet and that
-the electrical rating of the cord be 15 amperes (minimum) and
-120 volts.
-
-REMEMBER…
-Your continued health and safety are important to us.
-
-Please read and follow this Safety Information carefully.
-
-We want you to remain a happy and healthy part of our
-family.
-SAVE THESE INSTRUCTIONS
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-7
-
-About the temperature control dial.
-
-Turning the dial to OFFstops cooling in both compartments—
-fresh food and freezer.
-
-9
-
-OFF
-
-7
-
-5
-
-3
-
-1
-
-Control Settings
-Temperature Control Dial
-
-The temperature control dial has nine settings plus OFF.
-1 is the warmest. 9 is the coldest. At first, set the dial at 5.
-
-After using the refrigerator, adjust the dial if necessary.
-
-Insert a coin into the slot in the middle of the dial and you can turn
-the dial to the setting that’s best suited to your needs.
-
-Allow 24 hours for the refrigerator to get cold.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-8
-
-About the fresh food compartment shelves.
-
-Shelf supports at various levels allow you to custom-space your shelves.
-Not all features are on all models.
-
-2 Lift up and out
-
-1 Tilt up
-
-Half-Width Shelves
-
-One end of the shelf rests on a molded side-wall
-support; a bracket on the other end hooks into a track
-on the rear cabinet wall.
-
-To remove,lift the shelf up at front, then off the support
-and out of the track.
-
-To replace,select desired shelf height. With shelf front
-raised slightly, hook the bracket’s top lug into the track,
-then lower the shelf onto the support.
-
-NOTE: The shelf to the right of the track is designed to
-hook into the right-hand slot; the shelf to the left is
-designed to hook into the left-hand slot.
-
-Full-Width Shelves
-
-Some models have a steel wire sliding shelf, a stationary
-tempered glass shelf or two steel wire stationary shelves.
-These shelves can be moved to another place in the
-fresh food compartment.
-
-The full-width sliding shelf has stop-locks. When placed
-correctly on the shelf supports, the shelf will stop before
-coming completely out of the refrigerator and will not
-tilt when you place food on it or remove food from it.
-
-To remove the full-width shelves,lift the rear of the shelf
-and pull forward.
-
-To remove a full-width shelf when the fresh food
-compartment door cannot be opened fully,lift the rear of
-the shelf, pull forward and down, tilt the shelf and take it
-out.
-
-9
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-About the freezer compartment shelves.
-
-Some models have an ice-tray shelf and some have a full-width step shelf.
-
-Plug Supports
-
-Ice-Tray Shelf
-
-To remove the ice-tray shelf:Lift the left side of the shelf
-off its supports, then pull the shelf to the left to free it of
-the plug supports. Pull the shelf to the right to free the
-pins from the holes in the cabinet wall.
-
-(cid:49)
-
-(cid:50)
-
-Step Shelf
-
-To remove the step shelf:
-
-1
-2
-
-3
-
-Lift left side of shelf slightly.
-
-Move shelf to the left to free its right ends from holes
-in the cabinet wall.
-
-Lower right side of shelf, move shelf to the right and
-take it out.
-
-To replace the step shelf:
-
-1
-
-2
-
-With shelf tilted as shown, fit left ends of shelf into
-holes in cabinet wall.
-
-Lift left side of shelf slightly, swing shelf up, fit right
-ends of shelf into holes in cabinet wall, and lower
-shelf into place.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-10
-
-About the storage drawers.
-
-Not all features are on all models.
-
-Fruit and Vegetable Drawers
-
-Excess water that may accumulate in the bottom of the
-drawers should be emptied and the drawers wiped dry.
-
-Utility Drawer
-
-The utility drawer can be moved to the most useful
-location for your family’s needs.
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-11
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-12
-
-About storage drawer and cover removal.
-
-Not all features are on all models.
-
-Drawer and Cover Removal
-
-Drawers will stop before coming all the way out of the refrigerator to
-help prevent contents from spilling onto the floor. These drawers
-can be removed easily by grasping the sides and lifting up slightly
-while pulling drawers past the stoplocation.
-
-Full-Width Drawer with Plastic Cover
-
-To remove the cover, lift it off its supports, pull it
-forward, tilt it and take it out.
-
-Twin Drawer With Glass Cover
-
-To remove:
-
-1
-2
-
-Remove the drawers.
-
-Reach in, push the front of glass cover up and, at the
-same time, pull it forward as far as it will come.
-
-Tilt it and take it out. Avoid cleaning the cold glass cover
-with hot water because the extreme temperature
-difference may cause it to break.
-
-3
-
-Remove the drawer frame. (Always remove the glass
-cover before you take out the drawer frame.)
-
-Lift the frame off the supports at each side and back,
-pull it forward, tilt it and take it out.
-
-To replace:
-
-Lower the frame until it rests on the supports at each
-side and back.
-
-Replace the glass cover, pushing its rear edge firmly
-into the rear frame channel and gently lowering the
-front into place.
-
-Replace the drawers.
-
-1
-
-2
-
-3
-
-About the automatic icemaker.
-
-A newly-installed refrigerator may take 8 to 12 hours to begin making ice.
-
-Icemaker
-
-Feeler arm
-in the STOP
-(up) position
-
-Ice Storage Bin
-
-Automatic Icemaker (on some models)
-
-The icemaker will produce eight cubes per cycle—
-approximately 100 cubes in a 24-hour period,
-depending on freezer compartment temperature, room
-temperature, number of door openings and other use
-conditions.
-
-If the refrigerator is operated before the water
-connection is made to the icemaker, keep the feeler arm
-in the STOP (up) position.
-
-Feeler arm in the
-ON (down) position
-
-When the refrigerator has been connected to the water
-supply, move the feeler arm to the ON (down) position.
-
-The icemaker will fill with water when it cools to
-freezing. A newly-installed refrigerator may take 8 to 12
-hours to begin making ice cubes.
-
-Throw away the first few batches of ice to allow the water
-line to clear.
-
-Be sure nothing interferes with the swing of the feeler
-arm.
-
-It is normal for several cubes to be joined together.
-
-If ice is not used frequently, old ice cubes will become
-cloudy and taste stale.
-
-Icemaker Accessory Kit
-
-If your refrigerator did not come already equipped with an
-automatic icemaker, an icemaker accessory kit is available at extra
-cost. Check the back of the refrigerator for the specific icemaker kit
-needed for your model.
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-13
-
-Care and cleaning of the refrigerator.
-
-Cleaning the Outside
-
-The door handles and trim (on some models). Clean with a cloth
-dampened with soapy water. Dry with a soft cloth.
-
-Keep the outside clean.Wipe with a clean cloth lightly dampened
-with kitchen appliance wax or mild liquid dish detergent. Dry and
-polish with a clean, soft cloth.
-
-Do not wipe the refrigerator with a soiled dish cloth or wet towel. These may
-leave a residue that can erode the paint. Do not use scouring pads, powdered
-cleaners, bleach or cleaners containing bleach because these products can
-scratch and weaken the paint finish.
-
-Cleaning the Inside
-
-To help prevent odors, leave an open box of baking soda in the fresh
-food and freezer compartments.
-
-Unplug the refrigerator before cleaning. If this is not practical, wring
-excess moisture out of sponge or cloth when cleaning around
-switches, lights or controls.
-
-Use warm water and baking soda solution—about a tablespoon
-(15 ml) of baking soda to a quart (1 L) of water. This both cleans
-and neutralizes odors. Rinse and wipe dry.
-
-Use an appliance wax polish on the inside surface between the
-doors.
-
-After cleaning the door gaskets, apply a thin layer of petroleum jelly
-to the door gaskets at the hinge side. This helps keep the gaskets
-from sticking and bending out of shape.
-
-Avoid cleaning cold glass shelves (on some models) with hot water because the
-extreme temperature difference may cause them to break. Handle glass shelves
-carefully. Bumping tempered glass can cause it to shatter.
-
-Do not wash any plastic refrigerator parts in the dishwasher.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-14
-
-Under the Refrigerator
-
-For most efficient operation, keep the area under the
-refrigerator clean. Turn the temperature control dial to
-OFF. Sweep away or vacuum up dust.
-
-Clean the condenser coils at least
-once a year.
-
-For best results, use a brush specially designed for this
-purpose. It is available at most appliance parts stores.
-
-Behind the Refrigerator
-
-Be careful when moving the refrigerator away from the wall. All
-types of floor coverings can be damaged, particularly cushioned
-coverings and those with embossed surfaces.
-
-Turn the leveling legs at each front corner of the refrigerator
-counterclockwise until the rollers support the refrigerator. Pull
-the refrigerator straight out and return it to position by pushing it
-straight in. Moving the refrigerator in a side direction may result in
-damage to the floor covering or refrigerator.
-
-When pushing the refrigerator back, make sure you don’t roll over the power
-cord or icemaker supply line (on some models).
-
-After rolling the refrigerator back into place, turn the legs clockwise
-until the legs again bear the weight of the refrigerator.
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-15
-
-Care and cleaning of the refrigerator.
-
-Light Bulb Replacement
-
-To replace a burned out bulb, unplug the refrigerator from its
-electrical outlet, unscrew the bulb when cool and replace it with an
-appliance bulb of the same or lower wattage.
-
-Turning the control to the OFFposition does not remove power to the light circuit.
-
-Preparing for Vacation
-
-For long vacations or absences, remove food and unplug the
-refrigerator. Turn the temperature control dial to the OFF position,
-and clean the interior with a baking soda solution of one tablespoon
-(15 ml) of baking soda to one quart (1 L) of water. Leave the
-doors open.
-
-Move the icemaker feeler arm to STOP (up) position and shut
-off the water supply to the refrigerator.
-
-If the temperature can drop below freezing, have a qualified
-servicer drain the water supply system (on some models) to prevent
-serious property damage due to flooding.
-
-Preparing to Move
-
-Secure all loose items such as grille, shelves and drawers by taping
-them securely in place to prevent damage.
-
-Be sure the refrigerator stays in an upright position during moving.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-16
-
-Preparing to install the refrigerator.
-
-Read these instructions completely and carefully.
-
-Water Supply to the Icemaker (on some models)
-
-If the refrigerator has an icemaker, or if you plan to add an
-icemaker later, it will have to be connected to a cold water line.
-
-A water supply kit (containing copper tubing, shutoff valve, fittings
-and instructions) is available at extra cost from your dealer or from
-Parts and Accessories, 800-626-2002.
-
-Refrigerator Location
-
-Do not install the refrigerator where the temperature will go below
-60°F. (16°C.) because it will not run often enough to maintain
-proper temperatures.
-
-Install it on a floor strong enough to support it fully loaded.
-
-Clearances
-
-Allow the following clearances for ease of installation, proper air
-circulation and plumbing and electrical connections:
-3/4† (19 mm)
-1† (25 mm)
-1† (25 mm)
-
-Sides
-
-Back
-
-Top
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-17
-
-Preparing to install the refrigerator.
-
-Read these instructions completely and carefully.
-
-Rollers and Leveling Legs
-
-Leveling legsnear each front corner of the refrigerator are adjustable. They
-firmly position the refrigerator and prevent it from moving when the doors are
-opened. Leveling legs should be set so the front of the refrigerator is raised just
-enough that the doors close easily when opened about halfway.
-
-Turn the leveling legs clockwise to raisethe refrigerator, counterclockwise to
-lower it.
-
-Rollersnext to the leveling legs allow you to move the refrigerator away from the
-wall for cleaning.
-
-Turn the legs counterclockwise until the weight of the refrigerator is transferred
-from them to the rollers. After rolling the refrigerator back into place, turn the
-legs clockwise until the legs again bear the weight of the refrigerator.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-18
-
-Installing the water line.
-
-Read these instructions completely and carefully.
-
-Before You Begin
-This water line installation is not warranted by the
-refrigerator or icemaker manufacturer. Follow these
-instructions carefully to minimize the risk of expensive
-water damage.
-
-Water hammer (water banging in the pipes) in house
-plumbing can cause damage to refrigerator parts and lead
-to water leakage or flooding. Call a qualified plumber to
-correct water hammer before installing the water supply
-line to the refrigerator.
-
-To prevent burns and product damage, do not hook up the
-water line to the hot water line.
-
-If you use your refrigerator before connecting the water
-line, make sure the icemaker feeler arm is kept in the STOP
-(up) position.
-
-Do not install the icemaker tubing in areas where
-temperatures fall below freezing.
-
-When using any electrical device (such as a power drill)
-during installation, be sure the device is insulated or wired
-in a manner to prevent the hazard of electric shock.
-
-All installations must be in accordance with local plumbing
-code requirements.
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-19
-
-Installing the water line.
-
-Read these instructions completely and carefully.
-
-What You Will Need
-To determine how much copper tubing you need:
-
-Measure the distance from the water valve on the back of the
-refrigerator to the water supply pipe. Then add 8 feet (244 cm).
-Be sure there is sufficient extra tubing [about 8 feet (244 cm)
-coiled into 3 turns of about 10 inches (25 cm) diameter] to allow
-the refrigerator to move out from the wall after installation.
-n A water supply kit(containing copper tubing, shutoff valve and
-fittings listed below) is available at extra cost from your dealer
-or from Parts and Accessories, 800-626-2002.
-
-n Cold water supply.The water pressure must be between
-
-20 and 120 p.s.i.
-
-n Power drill.
-
-n Copper tubing,1/4† outer diameter to connect the refrigerator to
-the water supply. Be sure both ends of the tubing are cut square.
-
-Do not use plastic tubing or plastic fittings because the water supply line is
-under pressure at all times. Certain types of plastic tubing may become brittle
-with age and crack, resulting in water leakage.
-
-n Two 1/4† outer diameter compression nuts and 2 ferrules (sleeves)—
-
-to connect the copper tubing to the shutoff valve and the
-refrigerator water valve.
-
-n If your existing water line has a flared fitting at the end, you will
-
-need an adapter(available at plumbing supply stores) to connect
-the water line to the refrigerator ORyou can cut off the flared
-fitting with a tube cutter and then use a compression fitting.
-n Shutoff valve to connect to the cold water line. The shutoff valve
-should have a water inlet with a minimum inside diameter of
-5/32† at the point of connection to the COLD WATER LINE.Saddle-
-type shutoff valves are included in many water supply kits. Before
-purchasing, make sure a saddle-type valve complies with your
-local plumbing codes.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-20
-
-Shut Off the Main Water Supply
-
-Turn on the nearest faucet long enough to clear the line of water.
-
-Install the Shutoff Valve
-1
-2
-
-Install the shutoff valve on the nearest frequently used drinking water line.
-
-Choose a location for the valve that is easily accessible. It is best to connect
-into the side of a vertical water pipe. When it is necessary to connect into a
-horizontal water pipe, make the connection to the top or side, rather than at
-the bottom, to avoid drawing off any sediment from the water pipe.
-Drill a 1/4† hole in the water pipe, using a sharp bit. Remove any burrs
-resulting from drilling the hole in the pipe.
-
-3
-
-4
-5
-
-Fasten the shutoff valve to the cold water pipe with the pipe clamp.
-
-Tighten the clamp screws until the sealing washer begins to swell.
-
-Do not overtighten or you may crush the copper tubing.
-
-Pipe Clamp
-
-Washer
-
-Inlet End
-
-Saddle-Type Shutoff Valve
-
-Vertical Cold Water Pipe
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-21
-
-Installing the water line.
-
-Read these instructions completely and carefully.
-
-Route the Copper Tubing and Connect It to the Shutoff Valve
-
-Route the copper tubing between the cold water line and the refrigerator.
-
-Route the tubing through a hole drilled in the wall or floor (behind the
-refrigerator or adjacent base cabinet) as close to the wall as possible.
-
-Be sure there is sufficient extra tubing [about 8 feet (244 cm) coiled into 3 turns of about
-10† (25 cm) diameter] to allow the refrigerator to move out from the wall after installation.
-
-Place the compression nut and ferrule (sleeve) onto the end of the tubing and
-connect it to the shutoff valve.
-
-Make sure the tubing is fully inserted into the valve. Tighten the compression nut
-securely.
-
-Saddle-Type Shutoff Valve
-
-Compression Nut
-
-Packing
-Nut
-
-Outlet Valve
-
-Ferrule (sleeve)
-
-Turn On the Water and Flush Out the Tubing
-1
-
-Turn the main water supply on and flush out the tubing until the water
-is clear.
-
-2
-
-Shut the water off at the water valve after about one quart (1 L) of water has
-been flushed through the tubing.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-22
-
-Connect the Tubing to the Refrigerator
-
-Before making the connection to the refrigerator, be sure the
-refrigerator power cord is not plugged into the wall outlet.
-
-We recommend installing a water filter if your water supply has sand or particles
-that could clog the screen of the refrigerator’s water valve. Install it in the water
-line near the refrigerator.
-
-1
-2
-
-3
-
-4
-
-Remove the plastic flexible cap from the water valve.
-
-Place the compression nut and ferrule (sleeve) onto the end of the tubing as
-shown.
-
-Insert the end of the copper tubing into the water valve connection as far as
-possible. While holding the tubing, tighten the fitting.
-
-Fasten the copper tubing into the clamp provided to hold it in a vertical
-position. You may need to pry open the clamp.
-
-1/4† Copper Tubing
-
-Tubing Clamp
-
-Ferrule (sleeve)
-
-1/4† Compression Nut
-
-Refrigerator Connection
-
-Turn the Water On at the Shutoff Valve
-
-Tighten any connections that leak.
-
-Plug In the Refrigerator
-
-Arrange the coil of copper tubing so that it does not vibrate against the back of
-the refrigerator or against the wall.
-
-Push the refrigerator back to the wall.
-
-Start the Icemaker
-
-Set the icemaker feeler arm to the ON (down) position. The icemaker will
-not begin to operate until it reaches its operating temperature of 15°F. (-9°C.)
-or below. It will then begin operation automatically if the icemaker feeler arm
-is in the ON(down) position.
-
-NOTE: The icemaker may double-cycle when it first starts, causing some water spillage from
-the icemaker into the ice bucket. This is normal and should not happen again.
-
-23
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-Reversing the door swing.
-
-Read these instructions completely and carefully.
-
-Important Notes
-When reversing the door swing :
-
-n Read the instructions all the way through before starting.
-n Handle parts carefully to avoid scratching paint.
-n Set screws down by their related parts to avoid using them in the
-
-wrong places.
-
-n Provide a non-scratching work surface for the doors.
-IMPORTANT: Once you begin, do not move the cabinet until
-door-swing reversal is completed.
-
-These instructions are for changing the hinges from the
-right side to the left side—if you ever want to change the
-hinges back to the right side, follow these same instructions
-and reverse all references to left and right.
-
-Tools Required
-n 5/16† hex-head socket screwdriver
-n Masking tape
-n T20 or T25 Torxdriver, whichever your model requires
-n Putty knife or thin-blade screwdriver
-n 5/16† open-end wrench
-n Phillips screwdriver
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-24
-
-Removing the doors.
-
-Unplug the refrigerator from its electrical outlet.
-
-Before Removing the Doors
-1
-2
-CAUTION: Do not let either door drop to the floor. To do so could
-damage the door stop.
-
-Empty all door shelves, including the dairy compartment.
-
-Remove the Freezer Door
-1
-2
-
-Tape the door shut with masking tape.
-With a 5/16† hex-head socket screwdriver, remove the screws that hold the
-top hinge to the cabinet.
-
-3
-
-4
-
-5
-6
-
-Lift the hinge (and the shim glued to it) straight up to free the hinge pin
-from the socket in the top of the door and set it aside, along with its screws.
-
-Remove the tape, tilt the door away from the cabinet and carefully lift the
-door to free its bottom socket from the hinge pin on the center hinge
-bracket.
-
-Set the door on a non-scratching surface with the outside up.
-
-Using a Torxdriver, transfer the 2 screws from the opposite side of the
-cabinet to the screw holes vacated by the top hinge removal.
-
-Top Hinge
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-25
-
-Removing the doors/Reversing the hardware.
-
-Read these instructions completely and carefully.
-
-Remove the Fresh Food Door
-1
-2
-
-Tape the door shut with masking tape.
-Using a 5/16† hex-head socket screwdriver and a 5/16† open-end wrench,
-remove the two screws holding the center hinge (and the shim glued to it) to
-the cabinet. Lift the center hinge to free its pin from the socket in the top of
-the door, and set hinge and screws aside.
-
-3
-
-4
-5
-
-6
-
-Remove the tape and tilt the door away from the cabinet. Lift the door from
-the pin in the bottom hinge bracket. (If the plastic washer sticks to the door
-bottom, put it back on the hinge.)
-
-Set the door outside-up on a non-scratching surface.
-
-Using a Torxdriver, transfer the two screws from the opposite side of the
-cabinet to the screw holes vacated by the center hinge removal.
-
-Take one of the screws removed in step 2 and start it in the outermost screw
-hole on the opposite side. Do not drive it all the way down—leave enough
-space under the screw head for thickness of shim and bracket.
-
-Center Hinge Bracket
-
-Hinge Pin
-
-Plastic Washer
-
-Transfer Bottom Hinge to the Left
-1
-
-Remove the base grille (if your refrigerator has one) by pulling it straight
-out.
-
-2
-
-Using a Torxdriver, move the bottom hinge bracket (and the shim glued to
-it) and plastic washer from the right side to the left side.
-
-Plastic Washer
-
-Hinge Bracket
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-26
-
-Reversing the door handles.
-
-Transfer Top Hinge to the Left
-
-Interchange hinge (and the shim glued to it) and screws at top right with screws
-at top left of cabinet.
-
-Do not tighten screws on hinge side at this time.
-
-Some hinges have four holes. Which holes you use for installing the hinge
-depends on which side you install the hinge.
-
-Installing the hinge on the left.
-
-Installing the hinge on the right.
-
-Transfer Fresh Food Door Handle
-
-Top View
-
-Bottom View
-
-1
-
-2
-
-3
-4
-
-Remove the bottom cap by
-pushing it toward the bottom of
-the door and remove the screw
+Forms are the moulds into which concrete or
+another material is poured.
+
+Formwork is a system of forms connected
+together.
+
+Gangforms are large panels designed to be hoisted
+as a unit, and to be erected, stripped, and re-used.
+
+Knock-down forms are traditional formwork
+supported by falsework and shoring, assembled
+from bulk materials, used once, and then
+dismantled.
+
+Panels are sections of form intended to be
+connected together.
+
+Sheathing is the material directly supported by
+wales, and against which concrete is to be placed.
+
+Specialty formwork is designed specifically for a
+particular structure or placing technique.
+
+Struts are vertical members of shoring that directly
+resist pressure from wales.
+
+Wales are horizontal members of shoring that are
+placed against sheathing to directly resist pressure
+from the sheathing.
+
+Introduction
+
+In most cases, the formwork required for concrete
+construction is built by carpenters. Shoring and
+bracing support the forms that contain the wet
+concrete. Formwork must also support the temporary
+weight of material such as bundles of reinforcing
+steel and live loads of workers and equipment.
+
+There are three stages in formwork operations:
+
+1. Assembly and erection
+
+2. Concrete placement
+
+3. Stripping and dismantling.
+
+To be done safely, each of these jobs requires
+planning, knowledge, and skill from both
+supervisors and workers. Design and planning
+are a supervisory function that may also legally
+require a professional engineer’s involvement.
+Small construction and renovation jobs, however,
+sometimes call for typical design work (e.g.,
+specific heights and sizes from the manufacturer),
+which can be done on site by workers.
+
+Where design drawings are provided, it is
+important to construct the formwork as designed.
+Any confusion regarding the design should be
+approved by the designer.
+
+If site conditions require changes or the design
+does not seem to suit the situation, changes
+and approval should also be obtained from the
+designer. Formwork failures frequently involve
+deviations from the original design that were done
+without consulting the designer. They may also
+involve human error. For these reasons, formwork
+and shoring must always be inspected before
+concrete is placed.
+
+All large formwork installations in Ontario must be
+designed by a professional engineer. But there are
+always smaller jobs of moderate height or depth—
+basements, footings, stairs—that may include
+formwork with typical design arrangements from
+a form tie manufacturer, which is installed and
+constructed on the site.
+
+Every carpenter should therefore know the type
+of formwork needed and how to build, install, and
+dismantle it safely.
+
+Formwork must always be constructed according
+to good, safe, and sound carpentry practice. It must
+have the following:
+
+• Adequate braces and supports
+
+• Reliable bearing surfaces, especially where wood
+
+structures are involved
+
+• Adequate ties, bolts, or bracing to prevent
+
+movement or bulging.
+
+Because wood is relatively soft, it will crush under
+heavy loads such as concrete when the bearing
+surface of joists on stringers, or studs on wales, is
+not adequate.
+
+Crushing can be avoided by increasing the bearing
+area between members, using spreader washers
+(Figure 42-1), or increasing the number of joists
+or studs.
+
+Figure 42-1: Spreader Washer on
+Wooden Wale System
+
+Tools and Techniques
+
+42-1
+
+FORMWORK
+
+Hazards
+
+The following are the main hazard areas in
+formwork operations.
+
+• Falls – They are the major hazard because they are
+potentially fatal. Cramped work areas, inadequate
+access, failure to install guardrails, failure to use fall
+arrest systems, tools or material left underfoot, and
+surfaces slippery from form oil can all lead to falls.
+Ladders are also frequently involved in falls. All
+workers in Ontario who may be exposed to a fall
+hazard and who may use a fall protection system
+must have working at heights training that has been
+approved by the Chief Prevention Officer. (See
+Chapter 18: Guardrails and Chapter 19: Personal
+Fall Protection)
+
+• Dust and concrete – Blowing dust and flying
+
+concrete particles during the chipping or cleaning
+of formwork can injure unprotected eyes.
+
+• Access equipment – Access equipment such as
+ladders and scaffolds is involved not only in falls
+but in slips, trips, and other accidents. Hazards
+include ladders not tied off, workers carrying
+materials while climbing, ladders obstructed at
+top or bottom, scaffolds not completely decked
+in, and scaffolds erected or dismantled without
+fall protection.
+
+• Lighting – Inadequate lighting can create or
+
+aggravate hazards when workers install or strip
+forms in dark areas or place concrete at night.
+
+• Materials handling – The activity most frequently
+
+Injuries
+
+connected with injury. Improper or excessive
+materials handling can result in sprains, strains,
+and overexertion in shoulders, arms, and back, as
+well as bruises, abrasions, and crushed fingers.
+
+• Struck against – Common because formwork
+
+operations are constantly changing and involve
+the movement of heavy, awkward, and pointed
+components. Wales, beams, panels, snap-ties,
+nails, bolts, and rebar can cause punctures, cuts,
+contusions, and abrasions.
+
+• Struck by – Another common cause of injury.
+Rebar, formwork panels, concrete buckets,
+and other material hoisted overhead can strike
+workers. Struck-by injuries can also be caused by
+hammers, pry bars, stakes, wedges, and material
+such as joists and panels during stripping.
+
+• Electrical contact – Power tools, extension cords,
+and temporary supply and wiring systems, used
+under less-than-ideal conditions – mud, ground
+water, wet excavations, fresh concrete – can lead
+to ground faults, shortcircuits, and shock hazards.
+Ground fault circuit interrupters are legally
+required for portable tools used outdoors or in
+wet locations.
+
+• Collapses – Even with advanced methods of
+
+design and installation, there is always the risk
+that formwork, slabforms, wall forms, and other
+large components can come loose, slip out of
+place, or fall over, striking or crushing workers
underneath.
-Remove the two screws holding
-the handle to the top of the door.
-
-Remove the handle.
-
-Remove the screws from the right
-edge of the door top and insert
-them into the handle screw holes
-on the opposite side.
-
-5
-
-6
-
-With tape-tipped putty knife or
-thin-blade screwdriver, pry out the
-plug button from the hinge hole
-on the left side of the door and
-insert it into the hole on the
-opposite side that was vacated by
-removal of the top hinge.
-
-Pull the plug button from the
-front of the door and transfer it to
-the opposite side.
-
-Plug Button
-
-Screws for
-Handle Holes
-
-Plug Button
-
-To reattach the handle on the
-opposite side.
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-27
-
-Rehanging the doors.
-
-Read these instructions completely and carefully.
-
-Transfer Door Stop
-1
-
-Move the metal door stop from
-the right end to the left end. Use a
-Torxdriver.
-
-Door Stop
-
-2
-
-Move any screws from the left end
-to the right end.
-
-Right Side
-
-Left Side
-
-Reinstalling the Fresh Food Door Handle
-1
-
-Attach the handle to the right side of the door with screws at the top and
-under the handle plug.
-
-Reinstall the handle plug.
-
-2
-Transfer Freezer Door Handle
-1
-
-Remove the screw holding the handle to the top of the door and the two
-screws holding the handle to the bottom of the door.
-
-2
-3
-
-4
-
-5
-6
-
-Remove the handle.
-
-Remove the screw from the right top edge of the door and insert it into the
-handle screw hole on the left side.
-
-Pull the plug button from the left top edge of the door and transfer it to the
-opposite side.
-
-Transfer the door stop as shown above.
-
-Attach the handle to the right edge of the door with screws at top and
-bottom, using bottom holes vacated by removal of the door stop screws.
-
-Left Side
-
-Right Side
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-28
-
-Rehang the Fresh Food Door
-1
-
-Lower the bottom socket of the fresh food door onto the pin on the bottom
-hinge.
-
-Be sure the washer is in place on the pin.
-
-2
-
-3
-
-Insert the pin on the center hinge into the socket in the top of the door.
-NOTE:The center hinge must be turned over as shown when mounted on the
-left side.
-
-Tilt the door toward the cabinet. As the door is brought into position, slide
-the hinge under the head of the screw which earlier had been partly driven
-into the outermost hole. Insert the remaining screw, then tighten both
-screws securely.
-
-Hinge Pin
-
-Plastic
-Washer
-
-Hinge Pin
-
-Plastic Washer
-
-Rehang the Freezer Door
-1
-
-Be sure the washer is in place on the pin.
-
-Lower the bottom socket of the freezer door onto the center hinge pin.
-
-2
-
-3
-
-Tilt the door toward the cabinet, lifting the top hinge so the pin fits into the
-socket on the top of the door.
-
-Make sure the door is straight and the gap between the doors is even
-across the front. Tighten the top hinge screws. Do not overtighten these
-screws—tighten them until they are just snug, then turn them another one-
-half turn.
-
-Center Hinge Pin
-
-Plastic Washer
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-29
-
-Normal operating sounds.
-
-Depending on the placement of the refrigerator in your kitchen,
-you may want to place a piece of rubber backed carpet under
-the refrigerator to reduce noise.
-
-The fan circulating air inside the freezer which
-keeps the temperatures even.
-
-Boiling water or a gurgling noise. The flow of
-refrigerant through the freezer cooling coils.
-
-Sizzling, hissing or popping sound. Water
-dropping on the defrost heater during the
-defrost cycle.
-
-Cracking or popping sound. Cooling coils
-expanding and contracting during the
-defrosting cycle.
-
-Water dripping as it melts from the evaporator
-and flows to the drain pan during the defrost
-cycle.
-
-Icemaker (on some models)
-
-The icemaker water valve will buzz when the
-icemaker fills with water. If the feeler arm is in
-the ON(down) position it will buzz even if it has
-not yet been hooked up to water. Keeping the
-feeler arm in the ON(down) position before it is
-hooked up to water can damage the icemaker.
-To prevent this, raise the feeler arm to the STOP
-(up) position. This will stop the buzzing.
-
-The sound of cubes dropping into the bin and
-water running in pipes as icemaker refills.
-
-These sounds are normal
-and are due mostly to highly
-efficient operation.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-30
-
-Before you call for service…
-
-Troubleshooting Tips
-Save time and money! Review the charts on the following pages first and
-you may not need to call for service.
-
-Problem
-
-Possible Causes
-
-What To Do
-
-Refrigerator does not
-operate
-
-Refrigerator in
-defrost cycle.
-
-Temperature control
-dial in OFFposition.
-
-Refrigerator is
-unplugged.
-
-The fuse is blown/
-circuit breaker is
-tripped.
-
-Normal when
-refrigerator is first
-plugged in.
-
-Often occurs when large
-amounts of food are
-placed in refrigerator.
-
-Door left open.
-
-• Wait about 30 minutes for
-
-defrost cycle to end.
-
-• Move the temperature
-
-control dial to a
-temperature setting.
-
-• Push the plug completely
-
-into the outlet.
-
-• Replace fuse or reset the
-
-breaker.
-
-• Wait 24 hours for the
-
-refrigerator to completely
-cool down.
-
-• This is normal.
-
-• Check to see if package is
-
-holding door open.
-
-Hot weather or frequent
-door openings.
-
-• This is normal.
-
-Temperature control dial
-set at the coldest setting.
-
-• See About the temperature
-
-control dial.
-
-Grille and condenser
-need cleaning.
-
-Front roller screws or
-front leveling legs need
-adjusting.
-
-• See Care and cleaning.
-
-• See Rollers and leveling legs.
-
-Motor operates for long
-periods or cycles on and
-off frequently. (Modern
-refrigerators with more
-storage space and a larger
-freezer require more
-operating time. They start
-and stop often to maintain
-even temperatures.)
-
-Vibration or rattling
-(slight vibration is normal)
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-31
-
-Before you call for service…
-
-Troubleshooting Tips
-
-Problem
-
-Possible Causes
-
-What To Do
-
-Fresh food or freezer
-compartment too warm
-
-Temperature control
-dial not set cold enough.
-
-• See About the temperature
-
-control dial.
-
-Warm weather or
-frequent door openings.
-
-Door left open.
-
-Package blocking air
-duct in freezer
-compartment.
-
-Door left open.
-
-Too frequent or too
-long door openings.
-
-• Set the temperature
-control dial one step
-colder. See About the
-temperature control dial.
-
-• Check to see if package is
-
-holding door open.
-
-• Check to see if package is
-
-blocking air duct in freezer
-compartment.
-
-• Check to see if package is
-
-holding door open.
-
-Icemaker feeler arm in
-STOP (up) position.
-
-• Move the feeler arm to the
-
-ON (down) position.
-
-Water supply turned
-off or not connected.
-
-Freezer compartment
-too warm.
-
-Water shutoff valve
-connecting refrigerator
-to water line may be
-clogged.
-
-• See Installing thewater line.
-
-• Wait 24 hours for the
-
-refrigerator to completely
-cool down.
-
-• Call a plumber to clear
-
-the valve.
-
-Frost or ice crystals on
-frozen food (frost within
-package is normal)
-
-Automatic icemaker
-does not work
-(on some models)
-
-Cubes too small
-
-Slow ice cube freezing
-
-Door left open.
-
-• Check to see if package is
-
-holding door open.
-
-Temperature control
-dial not set cold enough.
-
-• See About the temperature
-
-control dial.
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-32
-
-Problem
-
-Ice cubes have
-odor/taste
-
-Possible Causes
-
-What To Do
-
-Ice storage bin needs
-cleaning.
-
-• Empty and wash bin.
-Discard old cubes.
-
-Food transmitting odor/
-taste to ice cubes.
-
-Interior of refrigerator
-needs cleaning.
-
-• Wrap foods well.
-
-• See Care andcleaning.
-
-Moisture forms on
-cabinet surface
-between the doors
-
-Moisture collects inside
-(in humid weather, air
-carries moisture into
-refrigerator when doors
-are opened)
-
-Refrigerator has odor
-
-Not unusual during
-periods of high
-humidity.
-
-Too frequent or too
-long door openings.
-
-Foods transmitting
-odor to refrigerator.
-
-• Wipe surface dry and
-
-reset temperature control
-dial one setting colder.
-
-• Foods with strong odors
-
-should be tightly wrapped.
-• Keep an open box of baking
-soda in the refrigerator;
-replace every three months.
-
-Interior needs cleaning.
-
-• See Care and cleaning.
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-33
-
-Notes
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-34
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-35
-
-Notes
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-36
-
-GE Service Protection Plus™
-
-GE, a name recognized worldwide for quality and dependability,
-offers you Service Protection Plus™—comprehensive protection on
-all your appliances—No Matter What Brand!
-
-Benefits Include:
-• Backed by GE
-• All brands covered
-• Unlimited service calls
-• All parts and labor costs included
-• No out-of-pocket expenses
-• No hidden deductibles
-• One 800 number to call
-
-We’ll Cover Any Appliance.
-Anywhere. Anytime.*
-
-You will be completely satisfied with our service protection or you may request your
-money back on the remaining value of your contract. No questions asked. It’s that simple.
-
-Protect your refrigerator, dishwasher, washer and dryer, range, TV, VCR and much
-more—any brand! Plus there’s no extra charge for emergency service and low monthly
-financing is available. Even icemaker coverage and food spoilage protection is offered.
-You can rest easy, knowing that all your valuable household products are protected
-against expensive repairs.
-
-Place your confidence in GE and call us in the U.S. toll-free at 800-626-2224
-for more information.
-
-*All brands covered, up to 20 years old, in the continental U.S.
-
-"
-
-Cut here
-
-Please place in envelope and mail to:
-
-General Electric Company
-Warranty Registration Department
-P.O. Box 34070
-Louisville, KY 40232-4070
-
-37
-
-Consumer Product Ownership Registration
-Dear Customer:
-Thank you for purchasing our product and thank you for placing your confidence in us.
-We are proud to have you as a customer!
+• Health hazards – The spraying of form oils and
+
+curing compounds can irritate the lungs. Contact
+with these chemicals can irritate the skin, leading
+to redness, inflammation, or dermatitis. The
+same conditions can result from the abrasive/
+corrosive effect of skin contact with concrete or
+cement, especially when inadvertently left inside
+boots all day.
+
+• Environmental conditions – Ice, snow, and rain
+create slippery conditions. Wind can be a major
+hazard. Handling sheets of plywood becomes
+more difficult, panels may require more bracing,
+and hoisting gets harder, especially with large
+panels or tables.
+
+Formwork hazards can lead to the injuries
+described below. Follow the safety tips to prevent
+such injuries.
+
+• Eye injuries – These are quite common in
+
+formwork operations. Most result from particles
+of wood or concrete that fall or are blown into
+the eye during chipping and cleaning. The injuries
+may not be severe but most can be prevented
+by wearing eye protection. It is strongly
+recommended that everyone on site wear eye
+protection at all times.
+
+• Cuts, scrapes, punctures – The manhandling
+
+necessary to install and strip formwork can lead
+to cut hands, arms, and legs, as well as pinched
+or crushed fingers. Gloves help to prevent
+injuries from rough or sharp edges on formwork
+components. But workers must also have the
+knowledge, skill, and physical ability necessary
+for safe materials handling. That means knowing
+your limitations and asking for help when needed.
+Formwork involves protruding objects such as
+nails, snap ties, conduit, and bolts that can give
+you cuts and punctures. Where possible, these
+objects should not be left sticking out or should
+be covered over.
+
+• Back injuries – These injuries are frequently
+
+related to materials handling. The most important
+preventive measure is back care. Exercise
+programs, warm-ups before work, and knowing
+your limitations can help to prevent sprains and
+strains. Wherever necessary, get help or use
+dollies, carts, or other mechanical devices.
+
+• Ankle sprains and fractures – Working in
+close quarters, stepping over debris and
+material, climbing into excavations, turning with
+awkward loads, jumping down from scaffolds
+or benches—these can lead to ankle and other
+foot or leg injuries. Prevention starts with proper
+housekeeping and materials handling.
+
+• Bruises and contusions – Handling formwork
+
+under rushed, cramped, or slippery conditions or
+beyond a person's physical limitations can lead to
+bruises. Bruises and contusions also result from
+contact with protruding formwork components.
+
+42-2
+
+Construction Health and Safety ManualFORMWORK
+
+More serious are contusions from falling formwork
+materials. Formwork must be braced to ensure
+stability, especially under windy conditions. Try
+to avoid areas where work such as hoisting or
+stripping is being done overhead.
+
+• Fall injuries – All of the injuries above, and many
+others, can result from falls. Most falls are caused
+by missing or inadequate guardrails, failure to use
+fall-arrest equipment, failure to completely plank
+scaffolds and other work platforms, and standing
+or climbing on surfaces not meant to be used as
+such – the tops of wall forms or 2 x 4 wales, for
+example. Installing and stripping formwork often
+requires the use of a fall-arrest system.
+
+• Falls also result from holes left unguarded or
+
+uncovered in formwork. These should be covered
+up or fitted with guardrails as quickly as possible.
+Where this cannot be done, the area should
+be roped off and posted with warning signs to
+prevent unauthorized entry.
+
+Planning
+
+Planning is the first and most important step in
+reducing hazards and preventing injuries.
+
+Because formwork operations must often be
+carried out in congested areas where other trades
+are also working, planning is essential in making the
+most of the time and space available to improve
+safety and efficiency.
+
+Planning is a must for fall protection, work
+platforms, material staging areas, housekeeping,
+and material handling and movement.
+
+Planning should take place at every level from
+manager to supervisor to worker. Planning labour,
+materials, equipment, and work schedules to
+meet design requirements is the responsibility of
+management and supervision. But supervisors and
+workers should come together to plan the details
+of their assigned tasks based on the most effective
+work methods and safety measures.
+
+For example, the normal weight of liquid concrete
+is 150 lb per cubic foot (2,403 kg per cubic metre).
+So a form designed to withstand 600 lb per square
+feet (2929 kg per square metre) of pressure will be
+able to support liquid concrete up to a height of 4
+feet (1.2 metres).
+
+600 lb/ft2 ÷ 150 lb/ft3 = 4 ft
+
+2929 kg/m2 ÷ 2403 kg/m3 = 1.2 m
+
+Other factors determine how long concrete
+will remain liquid, such as temperature, slump,
+vibration, and admixtures. For example, concrete
+will set much more quickly in hot summer weather
+than in cold winter weather. As a result, the same
+form filled at the same pour rate may be subjected
+to greater pressure in winter than in summer.
+
+Concrete pumping may cause additional pressure,
+as well as vibration, on forms and must be
+considered at the design stage. The action of the
+pump sends surges of pressure through the piping
+system which are often transmitted directly to
+the forms, especially for narrow walls or columns.
+Vibration may move the forms or loosen bracing,
+ties, or spreaders.
+
+Pressure acts perpendicular to formwork surfaces
+(Figure 42-2). This causes an outward thrust for
+typical wall or column forms. However, it can also
+cause uplift for battered or sloping forms. These
+require hold-down anchors or tie-down braces. The
+anchors will prevent the forms from lifting up or
+floating on the concrete.
+
+Expansion Anchors Holding
+Down Battered Form
+
+Design
+
+Safety and economy are the main factors in design.
+Both have to be considered because adjustments in
+one affect the other.
+
+For example, reducing the support structure for
+wall forms in expectation of reduced pouring rates
+should not be considered if the rate of pour is not
+going to be controlled on the job.
+
+Fresh concrete exerts a pressure on formwork
+similar to liquids. Concrete starts to set when
+poured. So if the pour rate is slow, the maximum
+formwork design pressure can be reduced, since
+concrete at the bottom will be set before concrete
+at the top is poured. Similarly, if the forms are
+filled to the top immediately, they must be able to
+withstand the pressure of the full liquid head.
+
+Figure 42-2: Pressure of Concrete on
+Vertical (left) and Battered Formwork
+
+Consider using bracing systems and spreaders for
+wall forms. Concrete filling the bottom of the form
+may cause forces at the top to push the two sides
+together unless they are properly braced and/
+or separated with spreaders. Formwork has to be
+designed to resist such forces. During pouring,
+ensure that spreaders are not removed until concrete
+has reached at least two-thirds of the form height.
+
+Where box forms are used—for instance, on one-
+piece covers for open-cut tunnels—you must use
+bracing against the side thrusts caused by the
+uneven pouring rates of the walls. Resisting these
+forces requires that the system be tied together
+and securely braced (Figure 42-3).
+
+Tools and Techniques
+
+42-3
+
+FORMWORK
+
+Figure 42-3: Open-Cut Tunnel Formwork with
+Bracing and Spreaders on Each Side
+
+Formwork should be designed and constructed
+with stripping and removing as well as pouring in
+mind. On wooden forms, crush plates or filler strips
+should be used at corners such as slab-and-column
+or slab-and-wall intersections (Figure 42-4). The
+plates or strips are easily removed with a wrecking
+bar and, once removed, make the stripping of
+adjacent panels much easier.
+
+Crush Plates
+
+Figure 42-5: Formwork Panel
+
+A formwork panel or wall form to be lifted as a
+single unit must be designed to withstand the
+loads and forces exerted by hoisting (Figure
+42-6). In most cases, this means designing a more
+substantial structure. Fastening components may
+also need more attention at the design stage. For
+example, simple nailing may not be enough to hold
+plywood sheets.
+
+Figure 42-4: Crush Plates
+
+The strips should be big enough to leave space at
+the edges of the panels to accommodate wrecking
+bars.
+
+When formwork has to be manhandled during
+assembly or dismantling, the design should ensure
+that the components are manageable. Formwork
+panels are not only heavy but awkward (Figure
+42-5). Realistic design demands consideration of
+the size as well as the weight of panels.
+
+Figure 42-6: Formwork Lifted as Single Unit
+
+Special attention must also be applied to the design,
+construction, and use of pick points for hoisting. The
+strongbacks and wales must be securely attached
+to the formwork. The pick points must be located
+so that the panel hangs properly during installation,
+concrete placement, and removal.
+
+42-4
+
+Construction Health and Safety ManualFORMWORK
+
+Types of Formwork
+
+Below Grade
+
+The first concern with formwork below grade is
+the stability of the excavation walls. Walls must be
+either shored or sloped according to soil type as
+defined by section 226 of the Construction Projects
+regulation (O.Reg. 213/91). Figure 42-7 shows
+typical slopes.
+
+Good Soil
+
+Fairly
+Good Soil
+
+Max 1.2m
+
+(4 ft.)
+
+Type 1 & 2 Soil
+
+Type 3 Soil
+
+Poor Soil
+
+Type 4 Soil
+
+Figure 42-7: Excavation Slopes for Soil Types
+
+In most cases the shoring must be designed by an
+engineer. Engineers may also specify slopes for
+excavations. In both instances the design drawings
+must be kept on the project.
+
+Excavations should be kept essentially dry. Water
+should be pumped out. Mud should be cleared off
+and replaced by compacted granular material in
+work areas and on surfaces where concrete will be
+placed. Mud presents slipping hazards and can lead
+to inferior construction if not removed or replaced.
+
+Since mud has to be removed before concrete
+is placed, it might as well be removed before
+formwork is constructed, thereby reducing slipping
+hazards at both stages.
+
+Water and mud also contribute to electrical
+hazards. Grounding and insulation must be
+effective and intact. Ground fault circuit
+interrupters (GFCIs) are required by law on all
+portable tools used outdoors or in wet locations.
+
+Formwork for footings and grade walls frequently
+begins before excavation in the area is complete.
+Trucks and excavating equipment put workers on
+foot at the risk of being struck down or run over.
+
+Wherever possible, formwork operations should
+be roped off from other work such as excavation
+or pile-driving (Figure 42-8). Separate access
+ramps for vehicles and workers are strongly
+recommended. Stairs are an even better alternative
+for personnel on foot.
+
+Figure 42-8: Formwork Roped-Off
+from Other Operations
+
+Mud sills must be used to support any shoring or
+bracing that rests on soil in the excavation (Figure
+42-9). The sill must bear on the soil throughout its
+length. Sills should not be used to bridge holes or
+irregular surfaces. To ensure uniform bearing, soil
+should be levelled before sills are set in position.
+
+Figure 42-9: Mud Sills Under Shoring Frames
+
+The soil must have the capacity to bear whatever
+loads are applied (Table 42-1). This information
+may or may not be on the design drawings.
+
+Table 42-1: In Situ Bearing
+Pressure for Dry Soil Conditions
+(Conservative Estimates)
+
+ Silt and clay
+ Sands
+ Gravelly sands
+ Gravel
+
+1,200 lb/ft2 (5,859 kg/m2)
+4,000 lb/ft2 (19,530 kg/m2)
+6,000 lb/ft2 (29,295 kg/m2)
+8,000 lb/ft2 (39,059 kg/m2)
+
+Tools and Techniques
+
+42-5
+
+FORMWORK
+
+Soil that supports bracing or shoring should
+be compacted and qualify as good soil at least
+(cohesive, hard, with no water). Professional advice
+from a geotechnical engineer may be required
+for heavy structures such as elevated equipment
+supports shored at or below grade.
+
+Formwork in these situations is frequently built in
+place. Planning is required to store material and
+equipment out of the way, dispose of scrap and
+debris, and ensure safe, efficient access (Figure
+42-10). Because conditions are often cramped and
+scrap accumulates quickly, it is important to clean
+up as work proceeds.
+
+Starting the Form
+
+Setting up the first form is always hard, heavy,
+manual work. It requires enough workers to do
+the job without overexertion or injury. Whenever
+possible, use mechanical assistance such as a boom,
+truck, or crane for this operation. It will reduce the
+risk of injury to workers and increase productivity.
+
+Temporary bracing (Figure 42-12) is needed from the
+start and at every step to prevent wind loads from
+toppling the forms—historically the cause of many
+serious injuries. A wind speed as low as 30 km/h can
+create a dangerous wind load on formwork.
+
+Figure 42-10: Well-Planned Storage,
+Access, and Setup
+
+Wall Forms
+
+Wall forms built in place are hazardous to
+construct. Hazards include
+
+• Dowels sticking up from concrete slabs or
+
+footings
+
+• Unstable work surfaces and access created by
+
+poor planning
+
+• Manual handling of heavy material such as
+
+plywood sheets, panels, wales, and buckets of
+snap-ties, wedges, and plates
+
+• Slippery surfaces at and below grade
+
+• Inadequate design
+
+• Improper construction.
+
+The best protection against dowels is a wood
+cover built of lumber at least 1 1/2 inches thick and
+wired in place or protective caps placed over the
+exposed ends of rebar (Figure 42-11).
+
+Figure 42-12: Temporary Bracing at
+Start of Form Construction
+
+Access to wall forms is not always given enough
+thought. Forms more than 2 metres high will
+require access platforms for workers involved in
+concrete placing. The platforms can also be used
+to complete the upper portion of the formwork.
+
+An alternative is a frame scaffold, which can also
+be used to install reinforcing steel (Figure 42-13).
+
+Figure 42-11: Protective Covers
+Over Dowels and Rebar
+
+42-6
+
+Figure 42-13: Scaffolding for Access
+
+Construction Health and Safety ManualFall arrest systems or scaffolds with guardrails
+must be used where workers may fall more than
+3 m (10 ft), or onto hazards such as projecting
+dowels (Figure 42-14). In some circumstances, you
+must use fall protection when the height is 2.4 m
+(8 ft) or more. (See chapters on Guardrails and
+Personal Fall Protection.)
+
+FORMWORK
+
+Figure 42-15: Formwork Properly Tied and Braced
+
+Recommended design pressures for various pour
+rates and environmental conditions are set out
+in CAN/CSA S269.1-16: Falsework and Formwork.
+The standard defines a number of other design
+considerations and should be consulted by field staff.
+
+Slab Forms or Falsework Built in Place
+
+With slab forms built in place the major hazard is
+falls. Injuries are also connected with the manual
+handling of heavy materials and components.
+
+Forms built in place usually have to be taken
+down in place after the concrete has hardened
+sufficiently. This should be considered at the
+construction stage. Stability may also be a
+consideration where the structure is high, carries
+heavy loads, and is placed on grade as in bridge
+and overpass construction.
+
+Fall protection is difficult to provide for workers
+building slab forms in place. That’s why planning is
+essential in the design and erection procedure.
+
+Workers should wear a safety harness with the
+lanyard tied off to the structure of the formwork
+(Figure 42-16). This means tying off to the support
+structure where shoring frame structures are being
+constructed, tying off to a lifeline when placing
+plywood panels at a leading edge, constructing
+a guardrail at the edge of the formwork, or tying
+off to the support structure when connecting it
+together with tube and clamp. Don’t wait for the
+structure to be completed before tying-off.
+
+Figure 42-14: Workers Wear Fall Arrest While
+Attaching Wales to Threaded Rods
+
+Materials should be distributed along the work
+location to minimize further handling. But traffic
+and work areas must be kept clear for the safe
+movement and installation of material.
+
+Form Construction
+
+Wall forms must be constructed as designed.
+The design must indicate clearly what is required.
+Some wall forms are designed for specific concrete
+placement rates expressed in metres of height per
+hour (m/hr). A wall form in which concrete is
+placed to a height of one metre in one hour would
+have a placement rate of 1 m/hr. Slower pouring
+rates result in lower formwork pressure because
+the bottom concrete has started to set.
+
+Note: Using a concrete vibrator will increase the
+liquid (hydraulic) pressure on the form in the
+immediate area of the vibration. Over-vibrating the
+concrete while increasing the pour rate can cause
+the formwork to fail.
+
+Ensure that ties and braces are installed where
+indicated on design drawings. Ties should be
+snugged up. Braces should be securely fastened to
+forms and wedged or fastened to a support that
+will not settle or deform under load (Figure 42-15).
+
+Formwork platforms must be:
+
+• Capable of bearing at least 50 lb/ft2
+
+• Adequately supported
+
+• Equipped with guardrails
+
+• Secured at the level or levels where work such as
+
+pouring and stripping will be done.
+
+Figure 42-16: Workers Tie Off to
+Shoring Frames While Placing Stringers
+
+Tools and Techniques
+
+42-7
+
+FORMWORK
+
+Make sure you have fall protection at all stages of
+formwork construction. Wherever possible, cranes or
+other equipment should be used to move material,
+thereby reducing the amount of manual carrying,
+lifting, and handling.
+
+Shoring towers require special consideration.
+
+• Towers must remain stable during construction
+and dismantling. Guys or other bracing and
+supports may be necessary to maintain stability
+(Figure 42-17).
+
+• If towers are to be tied together and braced
+horizontally, this should be done as work
+progresses (Figure 42-18).
+
+• Shoring towers and shores should be installed so
+
+they are plumb to within 1/8 inch in 3 feet.
+
+• Shoring towers should be snugged up under the
+
+stringers with adjustable base plates and U-heads
+(Figure 42-19).
+
+• If frames do not ride tightly on top of one
+
+another after tightening, one or more are out of
+square and should be replaced (Figure 42-20).
+
+• With single-post shores, provide adequate lateral
+bracing (Figure 42-21). Stairwells and balconies
+are places where horizontal bracing for single-
+post shoring systems may be required.
+
+Figure 42-19: Typical Shoring Tower with
+Stringers, Adjustable Base Plates, and U-Heads
+
+Replace this frame.
+
+Figure 42-17: High Towers with Guys for Support
+
+Figure 42-20: Frame Bent Out of Shape
+
+Figure 42-18: Towers Tied
+Together and Braced Horizontally
+
+Figure 42-21: Single-Post
+Shores with Lateral Bracing
+
+42-8
+
+Construction Health and Safety ManualFORMWORK
+
+Using forms designed for typical floors in non-
+typical situations has resulted in serious accidents.
+Before using any flying form under non-typical
+conditions, consult the designer or manufacturer.
+Wall forms should not be extended in height or
+width, for instance, or slab panels cantilevered
+without the review and approval of a professional
+engineer. Such situations usually occur with
+penthouses or mechanical rooms where wall and
+ceiling heights are greater than for typical floors.
+
+Other hazards with flying forms include the
+following.
+
+• Stability during initial fabrication
+
+• Fill-in work between slab panels
+
+• Wind and fall hazards during flying operations
+
+• Stripping, flying, and re-setting.
+
+Although a flying form is designed to be stable
+when complete, it may not be stable during
+fabrication or erection. Temporary bracing or
+temporary support by a crane may be necessary
+to ensure stability during certain phases of the
+operation (Figure 42-24).
+
+Figure 42-22: Two Rows of Shoring Frames with
+Row of Shoring Posts in Centre
+
+Frequently, supports for built-in-place forms are
+deliberately left out to allow other work to be
+done. One example might be a row of single-post
+shores left out until work below is complete. Or,
+an area might be supported temporarily during
+construction by a few single-post shores that will
+be replaced later by a shoring tower.
+
+In these and other instances of incomplete
+formwork, heavy temporary loads such as bundles
+of rebar or stacks of plywood should not be placed
+on the structure. Even on completed formwork,
+make sure that landed material will not overload
+the structure.
+
+Before placing concrete, the formwork must be
+inspected and approved by a professional engineer
+or their designate. Keep a copy of this inspection
+and approval on the site in case an inspector asks
+to see it.
+
+Flying Forms
+
+Flying forms must always be designed by a
+professional engineer and constructed, hoisted,
+moved, and set strictly according to the
+instructions of the designer or manufacturer.
+
+Figure 42-24: Temporary Support of Shoring
+System for Flying Wall Form
+
+One example is setting up trusses for a flying slab
+formwork table. The trusses must be held upright
+to be connected or disconnected. If not adequately
+supported, they can fall over on workers.
+
+Trusses and wall panels have also been blown over
+by wind during fabrication and dismantling. Set-
+up procedures should indicate the maximum wind
+speed where the flying form operation can be done
+safely. This wind speed should be determined by the
+professional engineer who designed the system.
+
+Work with flying forms requires adequate space
+for stacking materials and components. Working in
+cramped quarters is not only difficult but hazardous.
+
+Figure 42-23: Flying Forms
+
+Tools and Techniques
+
+42-9
+
+FORMWORK
+
+Fall Protection
+
+A fall arrest system should be used by any worker
+who is at risk of falling when:
+
+• Installing a panel
+
+• Pushing a panel out toward the slab edge
+
+• Pulling a panel in from the slab edge (Figure
+
+42-24)
+
+• Helping other workers attach rigging hardware
+
+such as slings
+
+• Getting on and off
+
+• Bolting and unbolting wall forms for exterior walls
+
+and elevator shafts (Figure 42-25)
+
+• Stepping onto a panel to attach slings to pick
+
+points
+
+Figure 42-24: Fall Protection Required when
+Receiving a Flying Form
+
+Figure 42-25: Attaching Chain Sling to Wall Form
+
+Each worker’s fall-arrest system must be attached
+to an individual anchor independent of the flying
+form. Contractors can provide for anchorage by
+casting rebar anchors in columns or other areas to
+be covered over or filled in later (Figure 42-26).
+This type of anchorage must be approved by a
+professional engineer.
+
+Figure 42-26: Rebar Anchor Cast in Concrete
+
+Safety Below Flying Forms
+
+The previous section covered the safety of workers
+flying the forms. But precautions must also be
+taken to protect workers below the hoisting
+operation and the public at large, since forms are
+often swung out over sidewalks and streets. The
+Construction Projects regulation (213/91, s. 103(2))
+prohibits hoisting a load over the head of a person
+who is not receiving the load or sinking a shaft.
+
+The most efficient protection for workers is to
+fence or rope off the area below the flying form to
+prevent anyone from entering the area. Pedestrian
+traffic on sidewalks, as well as vehicle traffic if
+necessary, should be detoured around the area
+while hoisting is under way.
+
+Communication
+
+Flying forms are heavy, large, and awkward to
+move. Hoisting and moving them safely requires
+clear reliable communication. While hand signals
+are often necessary and are still used, direct
+radio or cell phone communication between the
+signaller and the crane operator is more accurate
+and effective. Relying on hand signals alone is not
+recommended.
+
+Stripping
+
+Formwork stripping is probably the most
+hazardous operation in concrete construction.
+Hazards include the following.
+
+• Falling material
+
+• Waste material and equipment underfoot
+
+• Manual handling of heavy or awkward forms,
+
+panels, and other components
+
+• Prying forms loose from concrete presents risk of
+
+overexertion, lost balance, and slips and falls.
+
+42-10
+
+Construction Health and Safety ManualHazards can be reduced by
+
+• Planning and providing for stripping when
+
+designing and constructing formwork
+
+• Stripping as soon as it is permitted by the
+
+engineer
+
+• Supplying facilities and equipment for removing
+
+materials as they are stripped
+
+• Providing proper tools and adequate access for
+
+the stripping crew
+
+• Training personnel properly for this and other
+
+aspects of formwork.
+
+Forms can be designed with crush plates or filler
+strips to facilitate removal at difficult intersections
+of columns, beams, and wall forms. Later, formwork
+oils should be used liberally to make stripping
+easier.
+
+Wherever possible, waste materials, plywood, and
+debris should be removed from the area as work
+proceeds. This will reduce the need to walk over or
+work around things left on floor or ground.
+
+Providing carts or cradles can help the crew
+remove material and reduce the need for lifting
+and carrying. Material on a cart can be rolled away.
+Material in cradles can be hoisted off by a crane.
+
+Climbing partially stripped formwork is not
+only hazardous but unnecessary. Safe access
+such as rolling scaffolds or powered elevating
+work platforms should be provided for stripping
+formwork at elevated locations.
+
+Poor lighting may be a hazard in formwork
+stripping in the early morning or late in the day
+during certain times of the year. Mobile light
+stands are probably the best solution, since pigtail
+stringers can easily be knocked down and damaged
+during stripping.
+
+Wherever possible, stripping crews should be
+small. This is especially important with knock-down
+systems. In small crews, the supervisor and each
+worker can more easily keep track of what the
+others are doing. Workers are not as likely to create
+hazards for each other. Crews of two or three are
+recommended for knock-down systems. If more
+workers are required, they can still be divided into
+small crews working in separate areas.
+
+Other trades and operations should not be allowed
+in areas where stripping is under way. Given the
+many hazards involved, the area should be fenced
+or roped off and warning signs posted.
+
+Knock-Down Slab Systems
+
+Stripping these forms is physically difficult
+because much of the work is overhead. The
+usual arrangement involves shoring frames or a
+combination of shoring frames and jacks.
+
+Wherever possible, the work should proceed
+progressively from one side. That means taking out
+one row of formwork supported by a row of stringers
+on shoring frames.
+
+FORMWORK
+
+The first step is to back off the adjustable base plates
+and U-heads in one area, which will in turn lower the
+stringers, joists, and plywood (Figure 42-27).
+
+Figure 42-27: Lowering Base Plates
+and U-Heads to Release Slab Form
+
+In practice, however, the plywood will stick to
+the underside of the concrete, especially around
+beams, column caps, and similar points. Wherever
+possible, stuck sheets should be loosened and
+removed before the shoring structure is dismantled.
+
+Stripping should proceed in reverse order to
+erection. Plywood should be removed first,
+followed by joists and stringers. The last items to
+be removed are the shoring frames.
+
+When scaffold or shoring frames are used as a
+work platform, it should be completely decked
+in with planks (Figure 42-28). Otherwise planks
+can shift and slide as workers pry or pull at stuck
+pieces of formwork, lose their balance, and fall. This
+has been a frequent cause of injuries. Temporary
+guardrails may be required near the edge of the
+structure or workers will need to use fall protection
+during this operation.
+
+Figure 42-28: Shoring Frame
+Fully Planked for Access
+
+Tools and Techniques
+
+42-11
+
+FORMWORK
+
+The area where stripping starts should be planned
+to allow access for taking away material as the
+form is dismantled.
+
+Columns
+
+Check the following:
+
+Sound training, effective supervision, well-
+designed safe access facilities, and immediate and
+continuous cleanup can help reduce hazards in
+stripping knock-down slab forms.
+
+Built-in-Place Wall Forms
+
+These forms are frequently of only moderate height.
+Taller types usually make use of large panels erected
+and removed by crane rather than hand. Built-
+in-place wall forms are usually a stud-and-wale
+system using some type of formwork ties.
+
+Where workers cannot reach the top of the wall,
+scaffolding should be provided for removing wales
+on the upper level. Safe access is essential for the
+dismantling and manhandling of wales that are
+frequently long, heavy, and waterlogged.
+
+Material should then be removed immediately to a
+staging area.
+
+Inspection
+
+Before concrete placing begins, formwork must be
+inspected and signed off by a professional engineer
+or a competent person designated by the engineer
+to ensure that it has been constructed to provide
+for worker safety and to meet job specifications.
+
+A report must be completed by the person doing
+the inspection stating whether the formwork has
+been constructed according to the design. Any
+discrepancies must be approved by the design
+engineer before concrete placing proceeds.
+
+It is in everyone’s best interest to ensure that the
+formwork has been inspected by a competent
+person for workmanship, stability, and adherence
+to design drawings and specifications. Inspection
+should begin when the forms are being constructed
+and continue until concrete placing is complete.
+
+Checking line and grade is best carried out while the
+formwork is being constructed. Shoring structures
+should be within the alignment limits specified on
+the design drawings. Line and grade should also
+be checked during the pour to determine whether
+formwork is shifting or deflecting.
+
+Dimensions of special features like beams, column
+capitals, and inserts are best checked at the time of
+construction. If inspection is delayed until formwork
+is completed, some details may be covered up or
+become more difficult to check.
+
+• The proper size and type of materials are used
+
+• Column ties or column clamps are spaced
+
+according to design drawings
+
+• The spacing of ties or clamps is based on a
+
+sound assessment of concrete pressure (generally
+columns are designed for a full liquid head of
+150 lb per cubic foot (2,403 kg per cubic metre)
+times height)
+
+• Columns are adequately braced where they are
+
+not tied in to a slab-form structure.
+
+NOTE: For more information on column formwork
+pressures, refer to CAN/CSA S269.1-16: Falsework
+and Formwork or the American Concrete Institute
+(ACI) standard Formwork for Concrete (SP-4).
+
+Wall Forms
+
+Check the following:
+
+• Materials and any manufactured components are as
+specified in design drawings (size and spacing of
+studs, wales, and ties are crucial to safety)
+
+• Ties are snugged up before concrete is placed
+
+• Wedges in wedged systems are tight
+
+• Nuts in threaded systems are tight
+
+• Bracing conforms to design drawings
+
+• Free-standing formwork is braced to ensure stability
+
+and resistance to loads during concrete placing
+
+• Specified pour rates are not exceeded (wall
+
+forms are often designed for specific pour rates;
+exceeding these rates can cause failure or collapse).
+
+Slab Forms
+
+From a safety perspective, this is the most critical
+type of formwork. The collapse of slab forms has
+caused many injuries and deaths, whether from
+flawed design (e.g., not considering the effect
+of wind loading on the design), unauthorized
+modifications in the field, or the failure to
+inspect, which would have located and corrected
+deficiencies.
+
+Competent inspection demands knowledge,
+experience, and the ability to
+
+1) Distinguish between similar but different
+
+materials and shoring equipment
+
+2) Read and interpret design drawings
+
+3)
+
+Identify and clear up with the designer any
+apparent or real discrepancies in components
+such as shoring frames.
-Follow these three steps to protect your new appliance investment:
+42-12
-1
+Construction Health and Safety ManualFORMWORK
-Complete and mail
-your Consumer
-Product Ownership
-Registration today.
-Have the peace of
-mind of knowing
-we can contact you
-in the unlikely event of a safety
-modification.
+Check the following:
-2
+Watch for the following warning signs:
-After mailing
-the registration
-below, store this
-document in a safe
-place. It contains
-information you
-will need should
+• Grade beams or mud sills supporting shoring are
-you require service. Our
-service number is 800 GE
-CARES (800-432-2737).
+• Lateral displacement or movement of single-post
-3
+properly sized and located.
-Read your
-Owner’s Manual
-carefully.
-It will help you
-operate your
-new appliance
-properly.
+shoring for slab forms
-If you have questions, or need
-more information, call the GE
-Answer Center® 800.626.2000.
+• Hazardous soil conditions such as excessive
+moisture, freezing, and uncompacted soil
+conditions are reported and discussed with the
+professional engineer.
-Model Number
+• Shoring frames and jacks are located and aligned
-Serial Number
+within tolerances specified on the drawings.
-Important: If you did not get a registration card with your product,
+• Shoring frames and jacks are out of plumb no
-detach and return the form below to ensure that your
-product is registered.
+more than 1/8 inch every 3 feet.
-"
-Consumer Product Ownership Registration
+• Adjustable base plates for shoring frames and
-Cut here
+jacks are snugged up.
-Important
-Mail
-Today!
+• U-heads are wedged in place.
-First
-Name
+• Stringers are the specified size and number, with
-Street
-Address
+supports properly spaced.
-Apt. #
+• Aluminum stringers have no bent flanges or other
-City
+damage.
-Model Number
+• Movement or deflection of lateral bracing for
-Serial Number
+single-post shores
-Mr. (cid:108) Ms. (cid:108) Mrs. (cid:108) Miss (cid:108)
+• Movement of stringers on U-heads
-Last
-Name
+• Crushing of wooden stringers on U-heads
-E-mail Address
+(Figure 42-29)
-State
+• Gaps or shoring that is not snugged up under
-Zip
-Code
+stringers
-Date Placed In Use
+• Deflection of stringers between supports
-Month
+(Figure 42-30)
-Day
+• Deflection of wales or strongbacks on wall forms
-Year
+• Wall forms that are bulging or cracking
-Phone
-Number
+• Crushing of wales or strongbacks at washers
-Occasionally, we may allow selected companies to send you information.
-(cid:108) Check here if you do not want this information.
+for ties
-GE Appliances
-General Electric Company
-Louisville, Kentucky 40225
-www.ge.com/appliances
+• Movement of wall forms
-38
+• Joists are the specified size and properly spaced.
-Refrigerator Warranty (For customers in the United States)
+• Uplifting of battered forms
-All warranty service provided by our Factory Service Centers,
-or an authorized Customer Care®technician. For service,
-call 800-GE-CARES.
+• Support structures and shoring for beam bottoms
+and column capitals are constructed according to
+design.
-For The Period Of: We Will Replace, At No Charge To You:
+• Lateral bracing is provided where required (for
+instance, on freestanding formwork for bridges
+and overpasses).
-One Year
-From the date of the
-original purchase
+• The bearing surface for lateral bracing is
+adequate—that is, stable footings or well-
+compacted soil.
-Five Years
-From the date of the
-original purchase
+• Temporary loads such as rebar are not
-Any partof the refrigerator which fails due to a defect
-in materials or workmanship. During this full one-year
-warranty, we will also provide, free of charge, all labor
-and in-home service to replace the defective part.
+overloading the system.
-Any part of the sealed refrigerating system
-(the compressor, condenser, evaporator and all
-connecting tubing) which fails due to a defect in
-materials or workmanship. During this additional
-four-year warranty, we will also provide, free of charge,
-all labor and in-home service to replace the
-defective part.
+Concrete Placing
-What Is Not Covered:
+Forms should continue being observed during
+concrete placing. Any signs of movement, crushing,
+cracking, or deflection are cause for alarm. Placing
+concrete should be suspended until the situation is
+corrected.
-n Service trips to your home to teach you
+• Pour rates that exceed design specifications.
-how to use the product.
+Figure 42-29: Crushing of Stringer Over U-Head
-n Improper installation.
+Figure 42-30: Deflection
+of Stringers Between Supports
-n Failure of the product if it is
+Tools and Techniques
-abused, misused, or used for other
-than the intended purpose or used
-commercially.
-
-n Loss of food due to spoilage.
-
-n Replacement of house fuses or
-resetting of circuit breakers.
-
-n Damage to the product caused by
-
-accident, fire, floods or acts of God.
-
-n Incidental or consequential damage to
-personal property caused by possible
-defects with this appliance.
-
-This warranty is extended to the original purchaser and any succeeding owner for products purchased
-for home use within the USA. In Alaska, the warranty excludes the cost of shipping or service calls to
-your home.
-
-Some states do not allow the exclusion or limitation of incidental or consequential damages. This
-warranty gives you specific legal rights, and you may also have other rights which vary from state to
-state. To know what your legal rights are, consult your local or state consumer affairs office or your
-state’s Attorney General.
-
-Warrantor: General Electric Company. Louisville, KY 40225
-
-39
-
-S
-a
-f
-e
-t
-y
-I
-n
-f
-o
-r
-m
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-
-O
-p
-e
-r
-a
-t
-i
-n
-g
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-I
-n
-s
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-i
-o
-n
-I
-n
-s
-t
-r
-u
-c
-t
-i
-o
-n
-s
-
-Tr
-o
-u
-b
-l
-e
-s
-h
-o
-o
-t
-i
-n
-g
-Ti
-p
-s
-
-C
-u
-s
-t
-o
-m
-e
-r
-S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-m
-r
-o
-f
-n
-I
-y
-t
-e
-f
-a
-S
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-g
-n
-i
-t
-a
-r
-e
-p
-O
-
-s
-n
-o
-i
-t
-c
-u
-r
-t
-s
-n
-I
-n
-o
-i
-t
-a
-l
-l
-a
-t
-s
-n
-I
-
-s
-p
-Ti
-g
-n
-i
-t
-o
-o
-h
-s
-e
-l
-b
-u
-o
-Tr
-
-e
-c
-i
-v
-r
-e
-S
-r
-e
-m
-o
-t
-s
-u
-C
-
-Service Telephone Numbers.
-
-GE Answer Center® 800.626.2000
-
-The GE Answer Center® is open 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
-
-In-Home Repair Service800-GE-CARES (800-432-2737)
-
-Expert GE repair service is only a phone call away.
-
-Special Needs Service800.626.2000
-TDD 800-TDD-GEAC (800-833-4322)
-
-GE offers, free of charge, a brochure to assist in planning a barrier-
-free kitchen for persons with limited mobility.
-
-Service Contracts800-626-2224
-
-Purchase a GE service contract while your warranty is still in effect
-and you’ll receive a substantial discount. GE Consumer Service will
-still be there after your warranty expires.
-
-Parts and Accessories800-626-2002
-
-Individuals qualified to service their own appliances can have parts
-or accessories sent directly to their homes (VISA, MasterCard and
-Discover cards are accepted).
-Instructions contained in this manual cover procedures to be performed
-by any user. Other servicing generally should be referred to qualified
-service personnel. Caution must be exercised, since improper servicing
-may cause unsafe operation.
-
-Service Satisfaction
-
-If you are not satisfied with the service you receive from GE, follow
-these steps. First, contact the people who serviced your appliance.
-Next, if you are still not pleased, write all the details—including your
-phone number—to: Manager, Consumer Relations, GE Appliances,
-Appliance Park, Louisville, KY 40225.
-
-40
-
-Printed in Louisville, KY
+42-13
diff --git a/q15/random_k4/random_2.md b/q15/random_k4/random_2.md
index 3f8f519b055815348eb52fd213fd7d32396a7bde..a7cbcf7d4134f4c225b224673f418e279c4db69c 100644
--- a/q15/random_k4/random_2.md
+++ b/q15/random_k4/random_2.md
@@ -1,3490 +1,1314 @@
-Fully Automatic Coffee Machine
-OPERATION MANUAL
-
-Instructions of coffee machine parts
-
+B160V
+
+User Guide
+
+Contents
+Safety information . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2
+Getting to know your phone . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
+Setting up your phone . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7
+Contacts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11
+Messages . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12
+Email . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13
+Chrome browser . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14
+Bluetooth . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15
+Wi-Fi . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16
+Camera . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17
+Photos . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18
+Calendar . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19
+Calculator . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20
+Calculator . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20
+Clock . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21
+Google Maps . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22
+Google Play Store . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23
+Settings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24
+Troubleshooting . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 38
+Regulatory Information . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42
1
-2
-
-3
-
-4
-
-5
-
-9
+Safety information
-6
+Please carefully read the items bellow:
+Use Safely
+Do not use the phone in situations where it might cause danger.
+Transportation Safety
+Please observe all transportation laws and regulations.
+Please drive with both hands on the wheel.
-7
+DO NOT TEXT AND DRIVE
-9
+Hospitals
+Please follow limitations.
+Please turn off your mobile phone when near medical instruments.
+Airports
+Remember to follow all airport and flight safety regulations.
+Please do not use your phone during flight.
-10
+2
-11
+Toxic Chemicals
+Do not use your mobile phone around fuels or chemicals.
-12
+Hazard
+Do not use in hazardous areas where explosions may occur.
-13
+Accessories and Batteries
+Use only Blu authorized batteries and accessories.
-8
+Backup
+Remember to keep a written record of all important information.
-1
+Water
+Your phone is not waterproof. Keep it away from water and liquids.
-2
+SOS Emergency Calls
+Make sure your mobile phone is switched on and in a service area. In
+home screen, tap the phone key and dial 911 and send.
3
-4
-
-5
-
-6
-
-7
+Getting to know your phone
-Bean container
+Receiver
-Water tank
+Headset port
+Status bar
-Coffee grounds container
+Front camera
-Pre - ground coffee chute
+Rear cameras
-Grinding wheel
+Volume keys
-Coffee spout
+Power key
-Handle
+Flash
-8
+Back
+Home
-9
+Recent Apps
-10
+USB port
-11
+4
-12
+Power
+key
-13
+• Press to turn the screen on or off.
+• Press and hold to turn the phone on.
+• Press along with the Volume up key to turn the phone off.
+• Press along with the Volume down key to take a
-Waste water container
+screenshot.
-Milk pipe
+Volume
+keys
-Milk frother
+Adjust the volume for ringtones, media, notifications, and
+system sounds.
-Hot water spout
+Home
-Milk and foam spout
+The home button pauses any current action and returns to
+the home screen.
-Power cord
+Recent
+Apps
-Coffee machine operation interface instructions
+Open a list of recently opened applications that allows you
+to switch conveniently between them. This option can also
+close any open applications by swiping to the side.
-5
+Back
-1
+Return to the previous screen; Closes the keyboard, any
+open program, or any menu option.
-2
+USB port
-3
+Charge the device and transfers data such as documents,
+music, and video between your device and a PC.
-4
+Headset
+port
-6
+Connect earphones to this port for hands-free capabilities.
+You may also to listen to music or FM radio.
-7
+Status
+bar
-8
+Provide phone and service status information on the right
+side and notification alerts on the left.
-9
+Front
+Camera
-10
+A high-resolution front camera to take pictures and video.
+This option is ideal for self-portraits.
-1
+Rear
+Cameras
-2
+Flash
-3
+A high-resolution rear camera to take pictures and video.
-4
+Provide light for pictures in low-light conditions. It also
+may be used as a flashlight.
5
-Espresso icon
-
-Long coffee icon
-
-Hot water icon
-
-Power switch
-
-Display
-
6
-7
-
-8
-
-9
-
-Cappuccino icon
-
-Coffee Latte icon
-
-Hot milk/foam icon
-
-Cleaning button
-
-10
-
-Rotary button
-
-Safety Instructions
-
-Please see specification label on the bottom of the coffee machine or
-technical date indicated in the instruction manual(P20).
-
-IMPORTANT SAFEGUARDS
-
-When using electrical appliances, basic safety precautions should always be followed,
-including the following:
-1. Read all Instructions.
-2. Do not touch hot surfaces. Use handles or knobs.
-3. To protect against fire, electric shock and injury to persons do not immerse cord,
-plugs, or (state specific part or parts in question) in water or other liquid.
-4. Unplug from outlet when not in use and before cleaning. Allow to cool before
-putting on or taking off parts, and before cleaning the appliance.
-5.Avoid contacting moving parts.
-6. Do not operate any appliance with a damaged cord or plug or if the appliance
-malfunctions, or has been damaged in any manner. Return the appliance to the near
-est authorized service facility for examination, repair or adjustment.
-7. The use of accessory attachments not recommended by the appliance manufac
-turer may result in fire, electric shock or injury to persons.
-8. Do not use outdoors .
-9. Do not let the cord hang over edge of table or counter, or touch hot surfaces.
-10. Do not place on or near a hot gas or electric burner, or in a heated oven.
-11. Always plug cord into the wall outlet first,then turn controls to
-turn any control to”off“,
-12. Do not use appliance for other than intended use.
-13. Check bean hopper for presence of foreign objects before using the brewer .
-14. Unplug power cord from outlet before cleaning brewer exterior. Allow to cool
-before disassembling and cleaning the coffee machine.
-15. When dispensing drinks high temperature liquid will flow from coffee spout and hot
-water spout. Do not touch hot liquids to avoid scalding
-16. When using cappuccino, coffee latte, hot milk/foam, please confirm that the milk
-pipe has been connected from the milk frother to milk before making cappuccino,
-coffee latte, and hot milk/cream. Otherwise, high temperature steam may cause
-personal injury.
-17. Never connect to voltage different than the electric specification of the machine;
-Brewer damage will occur.
-18. Only potable water at room temperature should be used in the water tank.
-Never put warm water, hot water, milk or other liquid into the tank.
-
-then remove plug from wall outlet.
-
-To disconnect,
-
-"on".
-
-01
-
-Safety Instructions
-
-19. Never carry or move the coffee machine while power is on.
-20. The machine will release heat and some steam. Therefore, when placing the
-machine on a workbench, at least 3cm must be left between its surfaces, sides and
-rear; at least15cm must be left above its top.
-As for dimension of the machine, please look up the Technical Data in the User
-Manual(Page 20).
-21. Never use harsh or abrasive cleaner to wipe the machine, it may cause
-corrosion of the coffee machine, and result in a risk of electric shock.
-22. Never use hard edged tool or rough rag to clean the stain on the machine, it will
-damage the surfaces.
-23. Never fill specially treated coffee beans (e.g. cocoa, sugar coated) into the
-beancontainer, it will cause the coffee machine damage .
-24. Only roasted coffee bean are approved to place into the bean container. Rice,
-soybean, chocolate bean, nut, sugar, spice etc are prohibited. Otherwise it would
-cause the coffee machine to be damaged.
-25. Never wash the bean container or pre-ground coffee chute with water, it will
-damage the machine.
-26. Never use the coffee machine in the environment temperature below 0 °C.
-Water inside the machine will freeze and cause the coffee machine damaged.
-27. Never expose the machine in rainy, snowy, frosty environment. It would cause
-the coffee machine to be damaged.
-28. Save these Instructions.
-
-POWER CORD EXTENSION USE
-
-Please don’t use power cord extensions.
-
-02
-
--
-
--
-
-Proper operation
-
-the
-
-sure
-
-taste,
-
-make
-
-that the
-
-guarantee
-
-To
-coffee
-into the water tank is at room temperature.
-used
-can
-The coffee
-We
-intended
-it
-use
-of
-read
-this manual, so that you can understand operation of the coffee machine
-sufficiently.
-
-preparing
-not be responsible
-contents
-
-machine
-other
-use.
-
-be
-use.
-carefully
-
-any
-for
-improper
-
-hot
-for the
-
-temperature
-
-for
-will
-
-coffee
-
-Please
-
-only
-
-and
-
-the
-
-the
-
-all
-
-of
-
-of
-
-water
-
-poured
-
-water.
-Do
-consequences
-
-not
-
-Please keep this manual in an appropriate place to
-Safety Tips
-
-be accessed
-
-at any time.
-
-if
-
-is
-
-(if
-
-or
-
-the
-
-the
-
-the
-
-the
-
-smell
-
-power
-
-power
-
-coffee
-
-coffee
-
-unplug
-
-burning
-
-operate
-
-machine
-
-machine
-
-appliance
-
-or
-an authorized
-
-any
-contact
+Setting up your phone
-machine
-and
+Charge the battery
+1. Connect one end of the data cable to the USB port located on the
-the
-of
-immediately
+Install a Nano SIM/microSD card
-a breakdown
-cord
-power
+bottom of your phone.
-encountering
-the
+Note: Please contact your cellular phone service provider directly to
+obtain your SIM card if your card is not preinstalled.
+1. Insert the included SIM tray pin into
-cord of the
-service center.
+the tray slot and remove the SIM tray.
+2. Place the Nano SIM card and microSD
-Please notice the following tips to avoid personal injury from electric shock.
-cord
+microSD
-Do
-not
-damaged.
-When
-smoke),
-service center.
-If
-authorized
-Place the coffee machine and the power cord far away from heat sources.
-Please don't contact the power cord with sharp tools.Do
-coffee
-it
-operate
-mentioned in this manual, to avoid personal injury.
-Place the coffee machine out of the reach of children.
-periods,
-is
-When the
-cord and put it away, so that not to trip up people or damage to the power
-cord.
-Please
-be damaged.
+Nano SIM
-not
-way that is not
+card (not included) with metal
+contacts facing down into the tray.
+3. Gently slide the SIM tray back into
-authorization
+SIM tray
-contact an
+Pin
-damaged,
+the slot.
-otherwise,
+Warning: Please keep the SIM card out of the reach of children.
+The SIM card and its contact are easily damaged due to scratching or
+bending. Please use caution when carrying, installing, or taking out the
+SIM card.
-unoriginal
+2. Connect the other end to the power adapter.
+3. Connect the power adapter to an electrical outlet to fully charge your
-machine
+phone.
-machine
+Power On and Off
+Long press the Power key to switch on the phone.
+To turn off the phone, press the Power key and the
+Volume up key at the same time, and tap Power Off on
+the screen that displayed.
-without
-
-unused
-
-Coffee
-
-unplug
-
-please
-
-power
-
-cause
-
-repair
-
-parts,
-
-the machine to
-
-don't
-
-may
-
-long
-
-the
-
-any
-
-use
-
-the
-
-for
-
-or
-
-in
-
-is
-
-it
-
-03
-
-Instructions for use
-
-Reading this manual will help you familiarize yourself with the coffee
-machine, and enable you to use
-“Instruction
-coffee
-“Failures handling" will provide information when encountering problems.
-
-the
-use
- machine step-by-step, for first-time use.
-
-it properly.
-introduces
-
-operation
-
-first-time
-
-process
-
-for
-
-of
-
-"
-
-the
-
-Coffee machine model
-
-This
+Power
+key
-Manual
+7
-is
+8
-only
+Phone
+Make a call
-applicable
+1. To make a call, tap Phone
+2. Tap Dialer
-to the
+ from the Home screen.
-1601pro series coffee machine.
+ to access the keypad, or select one of the following:
-Symbol description
+• Choose frequently called or favorite contacts in Favorites.
-Non-compliance
-and threat to life.
+• Choose recently called numbers and contacts in Recents.
-with
+• Choose a saved contact in Contacts.
-proper
+3. Tap
+4. During a call, you can tap
-operation,
+ to make a call.
-may
+up.
-cause
+ at the bottom of the screen to hang
-electric
+Enable Wi-Fi call
-shock,
+You can make a voice call with Wi-Fi Calling.
+1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Settings
+2. Tap Network & internet > Wi-Fi Calling. Slide the switch to the
-Non-compliance
-damage, or personal injury.
+.
-with
+On
+ position to enable it. You must have an active Wi-Fi
+connection and have Wi-Fi calling service activated before it can be
+used.
-proper
+Call history
-operation
+Every telephone number called and received will be saved in the history.
+1. From the Home screen, tap Phone
+2. Tap Recents on the bottom bar to display the call history.
+You can tap a contact in the call history to display more options.
-may
+.
-cause
+Call settings
-Coffee
+1. From the Home screen, tap Phone
+2. Tap Options > Settings to configure your phone settings.
-machine
+.
-Non-compliance
+9
-with
+10
-proper
+Contacts
-operation,
+Add a contact
-may
+1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Contacts
-cause
+.
+2. Tap
+3. Use the keyboard to enter contact information, such as picture,
-scalding
+ to add a contact.
-or
+name, telephone number, group, address, email, etc.
-burn
+4. When you are finished, tap Save.
-injury.This symbol, if prompted, please carefully read it.
+Edit a contact
-This symbol, if prompted, represents recyclable.
+To edit a contact, tap the contact from the Contacts screen to view its
+details, and tap
-01
+.
-03
+Messages
-03
-03
+Send a text or multimedia message
+1. From the Home screen, tap Messaging
+2. Tap Start chat to create a new text or multimedia message, or start
-03
+.
-05
+a new group chat.
-05
+3. Enter the recipient(s) name from your Contacts list or phone number
-05
+in the To field.
-05
+ to send the text message.
-05
+4. Type your message and tap
+5. Or tap
-06
+ to the left side of the text box to add location, contacts,
-06
+or files. Tap
+recordings. When done, tap
-07
-07
-08
- 09
+ to attach photos or videos. Tap
-Catalogue
+ to send sound
+ to send the multimedia message.
-Safety Instructions
+Message settings
+From Message screen, tap
+ on the top right corner of the Messages
+screen and tap Messages Settings to adjust your messages settings.
-Proper operation
+11
-Instructions for use
+12
-Coffee machine model
-Symbol description
+Email
-Instructions for first time use
+Email setup (Gmail, Yahoo!, etc.)
-Power connection
+From the Home screen, tap Gmail
+your account.
-Fill water tank
+, and follow the steps to set up
-Fill beans
+Create and send an email message
+1. Tap Compose from the Inbox screen to compose a new message.
+2. Enter the recipient(s) email address in the To field. To add a carbon copy
-Grinding wheel
+or blind carbon copy, tap
-Power on
+.
-Power off
+3. Enter the subject and content of your message. To add attachments, tap
-Making beverages
+ and select Attach file.
-Preparing coffee by touch icon
+4. Tap
-Adjusting coffee parameters during a brew cycle.
+ to send.
-Preparing coffee with pre-ground coffee
+Email settings
+From Email screen, tap Menu
+settings.
-Program setting
+ > Settings to configure your Email
-Beverage
+Chrome browser
+From the Home screen, tap Chrome
+for information, and bookmark your favorite web pages for convenient
+access.
-setting
+ to browse the Internet, search
-Setting beverage parameters and range
+Browsing web pages
+From the Chrome browser screen, tap the address field and enter a web
+address or a keyword to browse for web pages.
-Temperature setting
+Adding a bookmark
+Open the web page you want to bookmark and tap Menu >
-Eco-settings
+.
-Automatic power-down
+Opening a bookmark
+From the Chrome browser screen, tap Menu > Bookmarks, select
+the bookmark of the website you want to view.
-Factory Reset
+Browser settings
+From the Chrome browser screen, tap Menu > Settings to customize
+the browser.
-Information Statics
+13
-Language
+14
-Exit
+Bluetooth
-Cleaning and maintenance
+Wi-Fi
-Cleaning the coffee machine before operation
+Bluetooth is a short-range wireless communications technology that
+devices can use to exchange information and connect to different types
+of devices which include headsets and other devices.
-Cleaning brewing unit
+Enable Bluetooth
-Rinsing milk unit
+1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Settings
+2. Tap Connected devices > Connection preferences >
-Descaling the coffee machine
+.
-Cleaning coffee
+Bluetooth.
-grounds
+3. Slide the Bluetooth switch to the On
-container and drip tray
+ position.
-Cleaning water tank
+Pair Bluetooth devices
-Cleaning bean hopper
+1. From the Connected devices screen, tap Pair new device.
+2. Tap a device under Available devices and follow the on-screen
-Disassembling and cleaning the milk frother
+instructions to pair with the device.
-Installing milk pipe
+3. When the device is connected to your phone, You can then use the
+headset or car kit to listen to music or make and receive phone calls.
-Cleaning milk pipe
+To use your phone’s Wi-Fi, you need access to a wireless access point or
+hotspot.
+1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Settings
+2. Tap Network & internet > Internet > Wi-Fi.
+3. Slide the Wi-Fi switch to the On
+4. Tap a Wi-Fi network to connect, enter the password (if applicable),
-Cleaning coffee machine
+ position to enable Wi-Fi.
-Failures handling
+.
-Display information
+and then tap CONNECT .
-Transport and recycle
+5. Your phone will be connected to the Wi-Fi network. You will see
-Technical data
+in the status bar.
-04
+You can drag down the status bar twice to access Quick Settings panel
+to enable or disable Bluetooth and Wi-Fi quickly and easily.
-9
-10
+15
-10
+16
-10
+Camera
-11
+Photos
-11
+Take a photo
+1. From the Home screen, tap Camera
+2. Tap Photo to switch to Photo mode.
+3. Aim the camera at your subject and tap
-11
+ to take the photo.
-11
+.
-11
+Record a video
+1. From the Camera screen, tap Video to switch to Video mode.
+2. Tap
+3. Tap
-11
+ to start recording a video.
+ again to stop recording and save your video.
-12
-12
+Camera settings
+From the Camera screen, tap Settings
-12
+ to adjust camera settings.
-13
+You can view photos and watch videos that you’ve taken, downloaded,
+or copied onto your storage card or phone memory.
-14
+Edit photos
+1. From the Home screen, tap Photos
+2. Tap the picture you want to edit.
+3. Tap
+save.
-16
+.
-17
+ to access the Edit screen. When finished, tap Save copy to
-17
+Share pictures and videos
+1. Select the photos or videos you want to share.
+2. Tap
-17
+, select a sharing method, and follow the on-screen prompts
-17
+to send the photos or videos.
17
18
-18
-
-19
-
-20
-
-20
-
-Instructions for first-time use
-
-This chapter will help you understand the basic operations and settings for your
-first time use
-
-Power connection
-
-●
-
-●
-
-●
-
-●
-
-coffee
-
-machine
-
-Place the coffee machine on a stable workbench that is not
-close to water.
-Keep
-the
-heat sources.
-Be sure to use the power supply that is in accordance with
-specification label.
-Put
-at
-power
-tripping over the cord.
+Calendar
-avoid people
+Calculator
+Calculator
-temperature
+Use the Calendar to create and manage events, meetings, and
+appointments.
-suitable
+Add an event
-place
+1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Calendar
-away
-
-cord
-
-from
-
-high
-
-the
-
-far
-
-to
-
-a
-
-Fill water tank
-
-●
-
-●
-
-●
-
-temperature
+.
+2. Tap Add
+3. Enter event details, and then tap Save.
-milk).
+ to add an event.
-room
+Calendar settings
-water,
+1. From the Calendar screen, tap Menu
+2. Tap an option to adjust Calendar settings.
-at
-tank,
+ > Settings.
-water
-water
+Your phone’s convenient built-in calculator lets you perform basic
+Your phone’s convenient built-in calculator lets you perform basic
+mathematical equations.
+mathematical equations.
+1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Calculator
+1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Calculator
-fill
-will
-taste
+.
.
-never
-It
-the
-at 25℃
-
-potable
-in the
-water,hot
-In
-
-to ensure
-order
-water
-to
-use
-a
-create
-
-Only
-poured
-warm
-machine.
-recommended
-water
-will
-taste.
-To
-change the water in the tank every day.
-The
-in
-height of the MAX mark.
-
-the water
-
-a healthy
+2. Enter the first number, tap a mathematical function key, and then
+2. Enter the first number, tap a mathematical function key, and then
-amount
+enter the second number.
+enter the second number.
-ensure
+3. Tap
+3. Tap
-water
+ to view the result, tap
+ to view the result, tap
-good
+ to clear the results.
+ to clear the results.
-tasty
+View calculator history
+View calculator history
-tank
+From the Calculator screen, tap Menu > History, or drag down on
+From the Calculator screen, tap Menu > History, or drag down on
+the history bar
+the history bar
+To clear the calculator history, tap Menu > Clear. To return to the
+To clear the calculator history, tap Menu > Clear. To return to the
+.
+calculator, drag the history bar
+.
+calculator, drag the history bar
-and
+ back up or tap the Back button
+ back up or tap the Back button
-not
+ to view the calculator history.
+ to view the calculator history.
-the
+19
-of
+20
-to be
+Clock
-is
-other
+Google Maps
-allowed
-liquid
+The Clock app allows you to set alarms, view different world times, use
+a stopwatch, set a timer, manage your bedtime, and use your phone as
+a desk clock.
-any
-coffee
-damage the
-it
-is
-coffee,
-temperature
+Use the Google Maps app to determine your location, get directions,
+browse local businesses and attractions, rate and review places, and
+more.
-of
-Low
+Set the date and time manually
-(e.g.
+1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Clock
+2. Tap Menu > Settings > Change date & time > Set time
+automatically > Off, and set the date and time manually.
-coffee drink,
+.
-please
+Create a new alarm
-cannot
+1. From the Clock screen, tap Alarm
+2. Set the time for the alarm and tap OK.
-exceed
+ >
-the
+.
-Fill beans
+Search for destinations
+1. From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Maps
+2. Tap Search here.
+3. Enter an address, city, facility name, etc., and then choose a search
-05
+.
-●
+result. You will see your location on the map.
-●
+Find a route to your destination
+Tap Go
+, enter your desired start location and destination, and tap a
+method of transportation (car, public transit, or on foot) for the detailed
+directions to your destination.
-●
+21
-●
+22
-●
+Google Play Store
-put
+Access Google Play
-Never
-treated (e.g. sugar, cocoa) into the bean hopper.
+1. From the Home screen, tap Play Store
+2. Enter your existing GoogleTM Account login or create one by following
-coffee
+.
-beans
+the steps on the screen.
-been
+Navigate Google Play
-have
+1. Tap Search for apps & games on the top of the screen to search
-that
+for a specific game or app.
-specially
+2. To install an app, tap the app and follow the prompts to complete
+the process. After installation, you will see a notification in the
+Notifications panel. You can open the app from the notification panel
+or Apps list.
-into
-soybeans,
+Settings
-be
+From the Home screen, swipe up to access Apps and tap Settings
+to access your phone’s Settings menu.
-put
+Network & Internet
-can
-rice,
+From the Settings screen, tap Network & internet.
+• Internet: Enable or disable Wi-Fi, add Wi-Fi network, view saved
-beans
-like
+networks, and monitor data usage.
-roasted
-put
+• Wi-Fi Calling: Enable or disable Wi-Fi Calling, adjust Wi-Fi Calling settings.
+• Mobile network: Enable or disable mobile data, adjust data roaming
+settings, view mobile data usage, set data limit and warning mode, etc.
-coffee
-other items
+• Airplane mode: Enable or disable Airplane mode.
+• Mobile plan: View your mobile plan.
+• Others: Adjust settings on Hotspot & tethering, Data saver, VPN,
-Only
-never
-nuts,sugar, and spices into the hopper.
-objects
-Never
-damage the grinder.
-bean hopper
-The
-beans
-of
+Private DNS, etc.
-cover acts
-maximized.
+23
-as a
-Please
+24
- coffee
+Connected devices
+From the Settings screen, tap Connected devices > Connection
+preferences.
+• USB: Connect your phone with a computer using a USB cable to
+transfer data, share network connectivity, or charge your phone.
+• Bluetooth: Pair Bluetooth devices to launch wirelessly hear calls,
-hard
+connect speakers, transfer data, and more.
-into
+• Cast: Scan for nearby devices to connect to and set them up.
+• Printing: Connect your device to a printer on the same Wi-Fi
-put
+network.
-the
+• Chromebook: Link your phone to a chromebook.
+• Nearby Share: Allow the rapid short-range exchange of images,
-seal.
-do
+videos, text, contact info, directions, YouTube videos, and other data
+via Bluetooth and Wi-Fi.
-beanhopper,
+• Android Auto: Control your phone’s maps, media and messaging
-otherwise
+functions, with the Google Assistant while you drive.
-it will
+Apps
-It
-not
+View current running applications, manage permissions, and more.
+From the Settings screen, tap Apps.
+• Recently opened apps: Tap an app to view detailed information.
+• Default apps: Set the default app for the browser, phone, messages,
-keeps
+etc. You can also set default apps for opening links.
-the aroma
+• Screen time: You can tap
-lose
+on the right side of most apps to set
-the cover.
+daily timers. When the app timer ends, the app is paused for the rest
+of the day.
-the
+• Unused apps: View apps that you have not used for a long time. You
-bean hopper,
+can un-install them to free up some space.
-chocolate
+• App battery usage: Set battery usage for apps.
+• Special app access: View app access for special functions, such as
-beans,
+battery optimization, display over other apps, unrestricted data, usage
+access, etc.
-Don't pour liquid in the bean container.
+25
-Grinding wheel
+26
-●
+Notifications
-●
+Battery
-●
+From the Settings screen, tap Notifications.
+• App notifications: Control notifications from individual apps.
+• Notification history: View your recent and snoozed notifications.
+• Conversations: View priority and modified conversations.
+• Bubbles: Enable message conversations display as bubbles, floating
-●
+on top of other apps.
-●
+• Device & app notification: Control which apps and devices can
-●
+read notifications.
-●
+• Notifications on lock screen: Select how you want notifications to
-adjust
+be displayed on the lock screen.
-Please
-according to the coffee bean type.
+• Do Not Disturb: Enable or disable Do Not Disturb. Set Do Not
-fineness
+Disturb behavior, exceptions, schedule, etc.
-coffee
+• Others: You can adjust other notifications settings, like wireless
-the
+emergency alerts, hide silent notifications in status bar, etc.
-of
+Monitor your phone’s battery usage.
+From the Settings screen, tap Battery.
+• Battery Usage: View the battery percentage that each apps used
-bean
+from last full charge.
-grind choice
+• Battery Saver: Enable or disable Battery Saver, set a schedule for
+turning on the Battery Saver, turn the Battery Saver off when your
+phone charges above 90%.
-adjust
+• Battery percentage: Show battery percentage in the Status bar.
-Please
-or the grinder may be damaged.
+Storage
-grinding
+Manage internal storage on your phone and provides menu choices for
+an optional SD card.
+From the Settings screen, tap Storage.
+• Device storage: From Storage screen, tap THIS DEVICE > This
-wheel
+device. Tap a category to view the storage amount used by each app.
-the
+27
-when
+28
-the
+• SD card: From Storage screen, tap THIS DEVICE > SD CARD to
-grinder
+Display
-is
+view files stored on your SD card. Tap on the top right corner of the
+screen to rename, eject or format the SD card.
-running,
+• Storage manager: Storage manager removes backed up photos and
-it
+videos from your device.
-is
+Sound & vibration
+From the Settings screen, tap Sound & vibration.
+• Media/Call/Ring/Notification/Alarm volume: Drag the slides to
-are
+adjust the media, call, ring & notification, and alarm volumes.
-are
+• Do Not Disturb: Manage Do Not Disturb settings.
+• Phone ringtone: Select a ringtone for incoming phone calls.
+• Media: Enable Media to hide player when the media session has ended.
+• Others: You can adjust other sound and vibration settings, like
-your
+vibration & haptics, default notification and alarm sounds, enable
+tones or vibration on other scenarios, etc.
-your
+From the Settings screen, tap Display.
+• Brightness level: Drag the slide to adjust the screen brightness
-color,
+level.
-beans
+• Adaptive brightness: Enable adaptive brightness to automatically
-beans
+adjust the screen brightness basing on the lighting conditions.
-light in
+• Lock screen: Set what to show on lock screen.
+• Screen timeout: Your screen will automatically go to sleep after the
-coffee
+set amount of time.
-coffee
+• Dark theme: Turn on dark theme.
+• Display size and text: Adjust font size and display size.
+• Night Light: Set a Night Light schedule and intensity.
+• Others: You can adjust other display settings, like enable auto-rotate
+screen and life to wake features, adjust display color and screen saver,
+etc.
-recommended to
+29
-dark in
+30
-If
-set to the coarse grind.
-If
-to set to the fine grind.
-While
-very
-coarse grind.
-Adjust grind choice as needed, increase or decrease grind
-level.
+Accessibility
-making
-slowly , please change the grind choice to a more
+Security & privacy
-recommended
+Manage accessibility-related apps to make the device easier to use for
+those with certain physical disabilities.
+From the Settings screen, tap Accessibility.
+• Real-Time text call: Manage RTT call options.
+• Display: Adjust the font size and display size, enable or disable dark
-brew dispense
+theme, enable screen magnification, etc.
-coffee drinks,
+• Interaction controls: Enable or disable useful interaction functions,
-coffee
+such as timing control, system controls, etc.
-color,
+• Captions: Enable or disable captions. You can also set caption display
-the
+language, text size, and caption style.
-is
+• Audio: Pair your hearing aids, enable mono audio, or adjust the audio
-it
+balance from the speaker.
-if
+• Accessibility shortcuts: Mange the settings on accessibility button.
+• Text-to-speech output: Set the text-to-speech engine, language,
-adjustment
+speech rate, etc.
-The
-making two or more cups of coffee.
+From the Settings screen, tap Security & privacy.
+• App security: Check your device and prevent/warn you of potential
-grinding
+harm.
-wheel
+• Device lock: Set your screen lock method, pattern, PIN, password, etc.
+• Account security: Add a Google Account to secure your device.
+• Device finders: Enable Find My Device to locate your device
-of
+remotely, keeping your data safe in the event that your phone is lost.
+• System & updates: Check for new software updates for your device.
+• Privacy: Manage a batch of privacy settings.
+• Face unlock: Unlock your phone by looking at it.
+• More security & privacy: Adjust more security and privacy settings.
-will
+Unlock your device automatically in certain conditions.
-be
+31
-effective
+32
-only
+Location
-after
+From the Settings screen, tap Location.
+• Recent access: View a list of apps that have recently requested your
-Finest
+location.
-Fine
+• App location permissions: View which apps have permission to
-Medium
+access location services.
-Coarse
+• Location services: Manage settings on other location services, such
-Coarsest
+as emergency location service, Google location accuracy, etc.
-Power on
+Safety & emergency
-First-time use
+Fulfill your medical and emergency information, view emergency alerts,
+and manage settings on emergency SOS and location service.
+From the Settings screen, tap Safety & emergency.
+• Emergency information: Add medical information and emergency
+contacts to help first responders in an emergency. Anyone can read
+this information from your lock screen and dial your emergency
+contacts without unlocking your phone..
-●
+• Emergency SOS: If you have turned the Emergency SOS function
+on, when you have an emergency and need emergency services,
+press the Power/Lock key 5 or more times quickly.
-As
-be
+• Emergency Location Service: If you have turned Emergency
+Location Services (ELS) on, when you call or text an emergency
+number, your device will use ELS to automatically send your location
+to emergency responders.
-the
-a
+• Earthquake alerts: Get an alert with the initial estimated magnitude
-machine
+and distance from your location.
-has
+• Wireless emergency alerts: Turn wireless emergency alerts on
-been
+or off. You can also view emergency alert history and manage alert
+preferences.
-tested
+Passwords & accounts
-at the
+Set up and manage all of your accounts, including your Google Account
+and other social networking accounts, through the Accounts settings
+menu. From the Settings screen, tap Passwords & accounts.
-factory,
+33
-there
+34
-may
+• Passwords: See, change, or remove passwords you saved in your
-little
+• Reduce interruptions: Enable or disable the notifications of apps
-coffee
+Google Account.
-left in the machine
+and Do Not Disturb mode.
-.
+• Autofill service: Autofill your information when needed from your
-●
+Google Account.
-●
+• Add account: Set up your account.
+• Automatically sync app data: Activate automatic data syncing.
-●
+Digital Wellbeing & parental controls
-coffee
+Statistics screen usage time, app timers, bedtime schedules, manage
+notifications, etc.
+From the Settings screen, tap Digital Wellbeing & parental controls.
+• Your Digital Wellbeing tools: Use app timers and other tools to
-The
-first-time
-best working condition, and this process cannot be skipped
+keep track of screen time and unplug more easily.
-cleaning upon
-achieve
+• Ways to disconnect: View your screen time and set timers for your
+apps, set a bedtime schedule to disconnect from your phone and
+avoid interruptions while you sleep, pause distracting apps when you
+need time to focus.
-and
-machine
+• Show icon in the app list: Enable icons in the app list.
+• Parental controls: Add content restrictions and set other limits to
-machine
-this
+help your child balance their screen time.
-will
-helps
+Google
-start
-the
+Configure your device’s Google settings. Available options depend on
+your Google Account. From the Settings screen, tap Google.
-self-testing
+System
-coffee
+Manage detailed settings for your phone, including language and input
+settings, battery and storage, date and time, etc.
+From the Settings screen, tap System.
+• Languages: Set the language for the phone’s menus and keyboards,
+set the language for each app, set units and number preferences, etc.
-use,
+• Keyboard: Select and configure keyboard settings
-the
+35
-When powering on the coffee machine, it will automatically
+36
-complete heating and cleaning for one time, every
+• Gestures: Enable useful gestures, such as Quickly open camera,
+Navigation mode, Power & hold power menu and Prevent ringing.
+• Date & time: Enable or disable network-provided time, automatic
-time and the process cannot be stopped. The coffee machine
+time zone, 24-hour format, etc.
-can only be used after the above cycle process is finished.
+• Backup: Back up your phone’s data and settings to Google servers
-During the cleaning process, some hot water may flow out of
+before resetting your phone to the original factory settings.
-the coffee spout into the drip tray. Please avoid contacting
+• System update: Check for new software updates for your device.
+• Multiple users: Share this device with other people by creating
-the hot water.
+additional users.
-Please ensure the power is connected before pressing
-the
+• Reset options: View different reset options and reset your device.
-power button.
+About phone
-Power off
+Access important phone information, search for and apply updates, and
+view legal and safety information.
+From the Settings screen, tap About phone.
-●
+Troubleshooting
-●
+Below is a list of common problems that may occur when using your
+mobile phone. Try these easy troubleshooting steps to resolve any type
+of issues you may encounter.
+The phone does not power on
+• Press and hold the power key until the startup sequence appears on
-●
+the display.
-When powering off the coffee machine , it will automatically
-complete the cleaning process for one time, every time,and the
-process cannot be stopped. This operation is to clean up
-the coffee pipelines and remove the coffee grounds.
+• Check the battery level and ensure there is sufficient charge.
+The phone does not respond after several minutes
+• Remove and insert the battery – If the phone has an internal battery,
-During the cleaning process, some hot water will flow out of
-the coffee spout into the drip tray. Avoid touching hot
-water, so as not to be burned.
-Only after using milk/foam/cappuccino/latte, the Rinse
-Milk Unit function will be operated when the power is turned off.
+please press and hold the power button.
-When you press the power button, the machine will be
-powered off after auto cleaning
+The phone powers off by itself
+• Check if the screen lock of the phone is enabled.
+• Check if the phone needs to be charged.
-When
+37
-you
+38
-press
+The battery will not charge
+• Check if the battery is already fully charged.
+• Make sure that the battery is inserted correctly.
+• Ensure that the battery being used is a BLU approved battery.
+• Double check if the charger connector is properly connected to the
-the power
+phone.
-button,
+Note: Connect charger only after the battery has been inserted.
-the
+The phone displays a SIM Error
+• Make sure the SIM is properly inserted and in its intended slot.
+• Make sure that the SIM card is not damaged or scratched.
+The PIN code was entered incorrectly three times
+• The SIM card will lock, and you will need to enter the PUK code (PIN
+Unlock Code). Please contact your local service provider to obtain the
+PUK.
-machine
+The standby time is too short
+• Please keep in mind that standby time relates directly to phone usage
-will
+I cannot make calls
+• Make sure that the number you dialed is correct and the dial key has
-be
+(Internet, Text, Voice Calls, Maps, etc.).
-powered
+been pressed.
-off after auto
+• Batteries typically have to be replaced after a year of use.
+The phone cannot connect to the network (Voice or Data)
+• Verify if you have active service with your service provider.
+• Contact your local network service provider and verify if you are within
-cleaning.
+its network coverage area.
-READY
+• Use the full national area code when dialing out of your area or when
-06
+abroad, use country-specific international access codes.
-Making beverages
+I cannot receive calls
+• Make sure that your phone is connected to a network.
-T, his chapter instructs you on how to make various kinds
-of coffee, hot water,hot milk and milk foam by this coffee
-machine.Please read the following instructions carefully to help
-you make high-quality beverages
+39
-temperature
-The
-avoid being scalded.
+40
-of
+The caller ID does not display on incoming calls
+• Contact your local network service provider and verify you have the
+caller ID feature enabled on your account or verify if the caller may
+have blocked his number from appearing.
-the
+The caller cannot leave a voicemail message
+• Contact your local network service provider and verify if the voicemail
-hot
+service is active on your account or check if the network is busy.
-water
+The phone does not connect to the internet
+• Ensure with your service provider that your account has the
-is
+appropriate internet/data plan enabled.
-high,
+• Ensure internet APN settings are configured (Carrier dependent).
+Text Messages cannot be Sent / Received
+• Ensure text messaging is enabled with your service provider.
+• Ensure APN settings are configured (Carrier dependent).
-please
+Regulatory Information
-do
+FCC regulations
-not
+This mobile phone complies with part 15 of the FCC Rules. Operation is
+subject to the following two conditions: (1) This device may not cause
+harmful interference, and (2) this device must accept any interference
+received, including interference that may cause undesired operation.
+This mobile phone has been tested and found to comply with the limits
+for a Class B digital device, pursuant to Part 15 of the FCC Rules. These
+limits are designed to provide reasonable protection against harmful
+interference in a residential installation.
+This equipment generates, uses and can radiate radio frequency energy
+and, if not installed and used in accordance with the instructions, may
+cause harmful interference to radio communications.
+
+41
+
+42
+
+However, there is no guarantee that interference will not occur in a
+particular installation If this equipment does cause harmful interference
+to radio or television reception, which can be determined by turning
+the equipment off and on, the user is encouraged to try to correct the
+interference by one or more of the following measures:
+• Reorient or relocate the receiving antenna.
+• Increase the separation between the equipment and receiver.
+• Connect the equipment into an outlet on a circuit different from that
+
+to which the receiver is connected.
+
+• Consult the dealer or an experienced radio/TV technician for help.
+Changes or modifications not expressly approved by the party
+responsible for compliance could void the user’s authority to operate the
+equipment.
+The antenna(s) used for this transmitter must not be co-located or
+operating in conjunction with any other antenna or transmitter.
+
+RF Exposure Information (SAR)
+
+This mobile phone meets the government’s requirements for exposure to
+radio waves.
+This phone is designed and manufactured not to exceed the emission
+limits for exposure to radio frequency (RF) energy set by the Federal
+Communications Commission of the U.S. Government.
+The exposure standard for wireless mobile phones employs a unit of
+measurement known as the Specific Absorption Rate, or SAR. The SAR
+limit set by the FCC is 1.6 W/kg. *Tests for SAR are conducted using
+standard operating positions accepted by the FCC with the phone
+transmitting at its highest certified power level in all tested frequency
+bands.
+Although the SAR is determined at the highest certified power level,
+the actual SAR level of the phone while operating can be well below
+the maximum value. This is because the phone is designed to operate
+at multiple power levels so as to use only the poser required to reach
+the network. In general, the closer you are to a wireless base station
+antenna, the lower the power output.
+
+43
+
+44
+
+The highest SAR value for the model phone as reported to the FCC when
+tested for use at the ear is 1.29 W/kg and when worn on the body, as
+described in this user guide, is 0.89 W/kg (Body-worn measurements
+differ among phone models, depending upon available accessories and
+FCC requirements.).
+While there may be differences between the SAR levels of various
+phones and at various positions, they all meet the government
+requirement.
+The FCC has granted an Equipment Authorization for this model phone
+with all reported SAR levels evaluated as in compliance with the FCC RF
+exposure guidelines. SAR information on this model phone is on file with
+the FCC and can be found under the Display Grant section of www.fcc.
+gov/oet/ea/fccid after searching on FCC ID: YHLBLUB160V.
+For body worn operation, this phone has been tested and meets the FCC
+RF exposure guidelines for use with an accessory that contains no metal
+and the positions the handset with a minimum of 1.5 cm from the body.
+
+Use of other accessories may not ensure compliance with FCC RF
+exposure guidelines. If you do not use a body-worn accessory and are
+not holding the phone at the ear, position the handset a minimum of 1.5
+cm from your body when the phone is switched on.
+
+Safety precautions for power supply unit
+
+Use the correct external power source
+A product should be operated only from the type of power source
+indicated on the electrical ratings label. If you are not sure of the type
+of power source required, consult your authorized service provider or
+local power company. For a product that operates from battery power or
+other sources, refer to the operating instructions that are included with
+the product.
+This product should be operated only with the following designated
+power supply unit(s).
+Travel charger: Input: 100-240V, 50/60Hz, 0.35A. Output: 5V, 2000mA.
+
+45
+
+46
+
+Handle battery packs carefully
+This product contains a Lithium-ion battery. There is a risk of fire and
+burns if the battery pack is handled improperly. Do not attempt to open
+or service the battery pack. Do not disassemble, crush, puncture, short
+circuit the external contacts or circuits, dispose of in fire or water, or
+expose a battery pack to temperatures higher than 140°F (60°C). The
+operating temperature for the phone is 14°F (-10°C) to 113°F (45°C).
+Warning: Battery is non-removable. Do not attempt to remove
+the battery for danger of explosion.
+To reduce risk of fire or burns, do not disassemble, crush, puncture,
+short circuit the external contacts, expose to temperature above 113°F
+(45°C), or dispose of in fire or water. Do not attempt to replace the
+non-removable battery. The phone and battery as a unibody device
+must be disposed of in accordance with locally applicable environmental
+regulations or guides supplied with your product.
+
+47
+
+Take extra precautions
+• Do not disassemble or open crush, bend or deform, puncture or
+
+shred.
+
+• Do not modify or remanufacture, attempt to insert foreign objects into
+the battery, immerse or expose to water or other liquids, expose to
+fire, explosion, or other hazards.
+
+• Only use the battery with a charging system that has been qualified
+
+with the system per CTIA Certification Requirement for Battery System
+Compliance to IEEE1725. Use of an unqualified battery or charger may
+present a risk of fire, explosion, leakage, or other hazards.
+
+• Replace the battery only with another battery that has been qualified
+
+with the system per this standard, IEEE-Std-1725. Use of an
+unqualified battery may present a risk of fire, explosion, leakage or
+other hazards. Only authorized service providers shall replace battery.
+(If the battery is non-user replaceable).
+
+• Promptly dispose of used batteries in accordance with local
+
+regulations.
+
+• Improper battery use may result in a fire, explosion, or other hazards.
+48
+
+• Do not replace an embedded battery pack. Improper replacement may
+present a risk of fire, explosion, leakage or other hazards. Contact the
+manufacturer for replacement instructions.
+
+• The phone identifies the battery by the Battery ID Pin.
+• If the battery leaks:
+
+• Do not allow the leaking fluid to come in contact with skin or
+
+clothing. If already in contact, flush the affected area immediately
+with clean water and seek medical advice.
+
+• Do not allow the leaking fluid to come in contact with eyes.
+If already in contact, DO NOT rub; rinse with clean water
+immediately and seek medical advice.
+
+• Take extra precautions to keep a leaking battery away from fire as
+
+there is a danger of ignition or explosion.
+
+Hearing Aid Compatibility (HAC)
+
+This device is hearing aid-compatible as determined by ANSI C63.19-
+2019 and waiver DA-23-914. The lowest conversational gain is 10.32
+dB with a hearing-aid, and 13.93 dB without hearing-aid, using telecoil
+coupling capability and Bluetooth connectivity.
+The 2019 ANSI C63.19 standard does not use this rating system nor
+do any test standards exist for any wireless technologies that transmit
+above 6 GHz. Instead, this standard uses the conversational gains for
+the device’s hearing aid compatible capabilities.
+This device has been tested and certified for use with hearing aids for
+some of the wireless technologies that it uses. However, there may be
+some newer wireless technologies used in this phone that have not been
+tested yet for use with hearing aids. It is important to try the different
+features of this phone thoroughly and in different locations, using your
+hearing aid or cochlear implant, to determine if you hear any interfering
+noise. Consult your service provider or the manufacturer of this phone
+for information on hearing aid compatibility. If you have questions about
+return or exchange policies, consult your service provider or retailer.
-touch
+49
-it
+50
-to
+We consent to the following conditions of the waiver:
+• Pass Conversational Gain, Receive Distortion and Noise and Receive
-Before making
-display.
-on
+Acoustic Frequency Response testing using one narrowband and one
+wideband codec, limited to one bit rate.
-the
+• Pass Conversational Gain at both 2N and 8N on all available
-all
+narrowband and wideband codecs and air interface combinations.
+Please see the HAC Volume Control test report for further details and
+supporting data.
-kinds
+The information provided in this user manual is subject to change without notice
+and BLU Products reserves the right to modify the manual at any given time. BLU
+Products has made every effort to ensure that this user manual is accurate and
+disclaims responsibility and liability for any inaccuracies or omissions. BLU Products
+makes no commitment to keep current the user manuals, however, does reserve
+the right to make improvements to the user manual at any given time without
+notice.
-of
+Google, Google Play, Google Maps, YouTube, Gmail and other marks are
+trademarks of Google LLC.
-coffee,
-
-please
-
-ensure
-
-“READY”
-
-is
-
-indicated
-
-●
-●
-
-●
-
-●
-
-●
-
-●
-
-used.
-
-ensure
-
-at
-it
-of
-
-recommended
-
-water
-better,
-quality
-
-normal
-is
-coffee,
-
-potable
-tastes
-the
-
-can
-temperature
-use
-to
-change
-
-The coffee beans should be stored in a dry place and avoid sunlight.
-Only
-make the
-coffee
-To
-tank every day.
-Please
-taste.
-Please
-of
-height of the cup in order to avoid coffee splashing.
-Adjustable height of coffee spout: 80-140mm.
-
-around25℃.
-in the
-
-be
-water
-the
-
-making the
-
-according
-
-please
-
-before
-
-coffee
-
-coffee
-
-coffee
-
-height
-
-better
-
-adjust
-
-water
-
-water
-
-warm
-
-spout
-
-cup
-
-the
-
-the
-
-the
-
-the
-
-for
-
-To
-
-to
-
-Preparing coffee by touch icon
-
-You can make 4 kinds of coffee using the touch icons, when
-shows
-“READY”
-
-the screen
-
-Take espresso for example to explain how to make coffee by touch icons.
-
-07
-
-The volume of espresso is suggested between 30 to 50ml.
-Because of the small volume of espresso, please warm the coffee cup before
-making coffee.
-
-Touch the espresso icon for espresso
-function.
-
-ESPRESSO
-
-STRONG
-
-VOLUME
-
-50ML
-
-ENJOY !
-
-The grinder will begin to grind . At this time
-you can adjust the amount of coffee beans
-by rotating the rotary button.
-Default amount of coffee beans for
-espresso:
-
-During making coffee, you can adjust the
-volume of coffee by rotating the rotary
-button.
-Default volume of espresso: 50ML
-
-When the screen shows as the left picture, it
-means the espresso is ready, please enjoy
-it.
-
-READY
-
-ESPRESSO
-
-Single time setting of coffee parameters
-
-Adjusting coffee parameters during a brew cycle.
-
-Making beverages
-
-●
-●
-●
-●
-●
-●
-●
-●
-
-Set the amount of coffee beans during the grinding process.
-Set the volume of coffee when making coffee
-Set the dispense time of milk
-foam to control the
-to
-Set the dispense time of milk
-Set the temperature of hot water before making hot water
-Set the hot water volume when making hot water
-Set the dispense time of hot milk
-Set the dispense time of hot foam when making hot foam
-
-the volume
-
-control the
-
-volume
-
-volume
-
-control
-
-to
-
-making
-when
-when making latte
-
-cappuccino
-
-when making hot milk
-
-Detail instructions
-You can set the strength of coffee before making the beverage and the
-volume of the beverage
-saved.
-
-during the brew cycle. The settings will
-
-not be
-
-STRONG
-
-VOLUME
-
-40ML
-
-FOAM TIME
-
-20S
-
-MILK TIME
-
-15S
-
-NORMAL
-
-VOLUME
-
-60ML
-
-When
-rotate
-
-grinding
-rotary
-the
-
-the
-button
-
-coffee
-to
-
-beans,
-the
-
-you
-amount
-
-can
-of
-
-adjust
-
-coffee
-
-beans,
-
-to
-
-the left
-
-is
-
-mild
-
-,
-
-and
-
-to
-
-the right
-
-is strong . The
-
-default
-
-amount
-
-is normal
-
-When
-can
-For
-2
-clicks
-
-making long
-
-coffee
-
-volume
-
-coffee,
-by using the
-
-be adjusted
-example,
-
-the current
-
-rotary
-is
-to reduce
-95ml,
-increase to 105ml.
-
-volume
-to
-
-button.
-100ml,
-2
-and
-
-clicks
-
-to the
-
-to the
-
-right
-
-left
-to
-
-cappuccino,
-making
-the
-
-making
-latte,the foam
-
-When
-coffee
-adjusted by rotating
-the milk foam outflows.
-current time is 20s,2 clicks
-reduce
-increase to 21S.
-
-For
-
-to
-
-milk
-time
-
-foam
-be
-
-or
-
-can
-rotary
-button
-example,the
-to
-to the
-
-left
-
-19S,and 2 clicks to the right to
-
-while
-
-08
-
-making
-
-time
-button.
-
-When
-dispensing
-the rotary
-milk dispensing
-left to reduce to
-to increase to 16S.
-
-hot
-can
-
-milk
-be
-
-coffee
-
-or
-adjusted
-
-For
-time
-14S,
-
-example,
-is
-and
-
-15S,
-2
-
-2
-clicks
-
-latte,
-
-milk
-rotating
-current
-to the
-
-by
-the
-clicks
-
-to the
-
-right
-
-hot
-
-making
-
-Before
-adjusted
-be
-the left
-low,
-is
-temperature is normal.
-
-water,
-rotating
-right is
-
-by
-to the
-
-temperature
-rotary
-
-the
-the
-high. The
-
-default
-
-button.
-
-can
-To
-
-dispensing
-
-be
-
- can
-button.
-is
-and
-
-For
-100ML,
-2
-
-hot
-
-adjusted
-
-water,
-by
-example,
-clicks
-2
-to
-clicks
-
-the
-hot
-rotating
-the
-to the
-
-water
-the
-current
-reduce
-left
- the right to increase
-
-to
-
-When
-volume
-rotary
-volume
-to
-95ML,
-to 105ML.
-
-Making beverages
-
-Preparing coffee with pre-ground coffee
-
-can
-
-You
-Pre-ground coffee.
-
-choose
-
-this
-
-function
-
-if
-
-you
-
-want
-
-to
-
-make
-
-coffee
-
-with
-
-●Do not use instant coffee powder
-pre-ground
-damage the machine.
-
-or cocoa powder in the
-coffee chute. powder container.Otherwise it will
-
-●
-Do not put pre-ground coffee powder into the coffee
-bean hopper,otherwise, it will damage the machine.
-
-●
-
-●
-
-●
-
-Please use proper Pre-ground coffee for espresso.
-
-Only 7-14g of pre-ground coffee can be added.
-Machine will be
-
-damaged.
-
-The process of using pre-ground coffee to make coffee
-only skips the process of grinding coffee beans, other
-operations are the same as making espresso, long coffee,
-cappuccino, and coffee latte. This chapter illustrates with
-espresso.
-
-Press and hold the rotary button to
-enter into
-programming when the
-coffee machine is
-“READY”.
-
-READY
-
-09
-
-GROUND COFFEE
-
-Display shows “GROUND COFFEE ” page
-after entered into programming. Press
-the rotary button to make coffee.
-
-Open pre-ground coffee chute cover and
-fill .close the cover. Touch the
-
-icon
-beverage
-Press the rotary button to
-
-need
-
-you
-
-to
-
-make
-cancel.
-
-coffee.
-
-FILL GROUND COFFEE
-
-SELECT COFFEE
-ROTARY TO CANCEL
-
-Program setting
-
-●
-
-This chapter will give instructions on program settings.
-
-●
-
-Ensure the coffee machine shows “READY”, press and hold the
-
-rotary button , then you can enter into the menu
-
-Beverage setting
-
-will
-
-instruct
-
-chapter
-
-This
-settings
-temperature
-hot milk, dispense time of
-
-you
-parameters include
-hot
-
-of
-
-how
-to
-coffee
-
-set
-strength,
-
-beverages parameters.
-coffee,
-
-volume
-
-of
-
-The
-
-water,volume of hot water,dispense time of making
-
-making hot foam
-
-parameters
-
-accomplished
-
-by the
-
-beverage
-
-setting
-
-will
-
-be
-
-the
-
-The
-default
-
- values for each beverage.
-
-1. Espresso setting
-2. Long coffee setting
-3. Hot water setting
-4. Cappuccino setting
-5. Coffee latte setting
-6. Hot milk setting
-7. Hot foam setting
-
-Setting beverage parameters and range
-
-The parameters such as strength, volume, temperature and
-forthe beverages below.
-
-time can be set
-
-can be set
-
-can be set
-
-The strength and volume of espresso
-The strength and volume of long coffee
-The strength and volume of coffee part of cappuccino
-set
-The foam dispensing time in cappuccino
-eht dna trap eeffoc fo emulov dna htgnerts ehT
-can be set
-The temperature and the volume of hot water can be set
-Hot milk making time can be set
-Hot foam making time can be set
-
-can be set
-
-can be
-
- ettal ni emit gnitiaw
-
-Please read the following table for the detail setting parameters and
-adjustment range
-
-10
-
-Drinks
-
-espresso
-
-long coffee
-
-cappuccino
-
-coffee Latte
-
-hot water
-
-hot milk
-
-hot foam
-
-Strength
-
-Volume range
-
-Default
-
-Mild:
-Normal:
-Strong:
-
-Mild:
-Normal:
-Strong:
-
-Volume: 15 -120ML
-
-Volume: 15 - 240ML
-
-Volume: 15 - 240ML
-Milk time: 0 - 120SEC
-Foam time: 3 - 120SEC
-Wait time: 0 - 30SEC
-
-Volume: 25 -450ML
-
-Milk time: 3 -120SEC
-
-Foam time: 3 -120SEC
-
-50ML
-
-100ML
-
-60ML
-
-Foam time: 20SEC
-
-60ML
-
-Milk time: 15SEC
-Foam time: 20SEC
-Wait : 20SEC
-
-100ML
-
-15 SEC
-
-15 SEC
-
-Temperature Setting
-
-The coffee temperature can be adjusted to your liking with the “ Temperature setting”
-function and you can choose:
-
-1 .Low
-
-2 .Normal
-
-3 .High
-
-The default temperature is Normal, and it’s only adjustable for coffee not milk.
-
-Program setting
-
-Eco settings
-
-●
-
-●
-
-If the machine is set to Eco-setting, the machine needs 30
-seconds to warm up to make Cappuccino, Coffee Latte,
-milk and foam. . The normal setting has more energy
-consumption than the Eco-saving mode.
-
-Hot
-
-The factory default setting of the machine is normal mode.
-entering the program setting, please turn the rotary
-“ECO SETTING” option, then press the rotary button,
-finished.
-
-button to
-setting is
-
-After
-
-Automatic power-down
-
-switch
-
-off
-
-time
-
-automatically
-
-is 4 hours,
-switch
-
-which
-off 4 hours
-
-automatic
-
-switch-off
-
-is
-
-from
-
-15
-
-minutes
-
-to
-
-program
-
-setting,
-Then
-
-please
-press
-
-the
-
-turn
-
-the
-rotary
-
-rotary
-button,
-
-option.
-
-will
-
-default
-
-machine
-
-machine’s
-
-the
-setting
-
-last use .
-range
-
-The
-means the
-after
-The
-24 hours.
-entering
-After
-button
-“Auto-off”
-the
-the setting is completed.
-
-the
-
-to
-
-of
-
-Factory Reset
-
-●
-
-●
-
-●
-
-●
-
-●
-
-will
-
-the
-
-the
-
-all
-to
-
-function
-
-reset
-parameters
-options). However
-
-This
-beverage
-language
-not be reset.
-After
-the
-confirm, the setting is completed.
-
-program
-option
-
-“FACTORY RESET”
-
-entering
-
-the
-
-the
-
-menu
-factory
-
-setting
-settings
-
-and
-(except
-
-default
-the
-
-information
-
-options
-
-will
-
-setting,
-then
-
-please
-
-press
-
-the
-
-turn
-
-the
-rotary
-
-rotarybutton
-button
-
-to
-
-to
-
-Information Statics
-
-11
-
-●
-
-In this program you can view the statistical information on
-the number of drinks, total drinks numbers, etc.
-
-1. Number of rinses
-2. Number of total cycles
-3. Number of espresso
-4. Number of long coffee
-5. Number of hot water
-6. Number of cappuccino
-7. Number of coffee latte
-8. Number of hot milk
-9. Number of hot foam
-10. Number of descales
-11. Number of ground coffee
-12. Number of brew unit cleans
-13. Number of milk unit rinses
-
-●
-
-When first viewed there will
-produced
-been
-
-because
-before leaving the factory.
-
-already be
-each
-
-beverages
-
-tested
-
-a
-coffee
-
-number
-
-of
-machine
-
-has
-
-Language
-
-●
-
-You can set your preferred language on the coffee machine.
-
-●
-
-After entering the program setting, turn the rotary button to the "CHOOSE
-LANGUAGE" option, then press the rotary button, rotate the rotary to
-choose the language, and press the rotary button, the language setting
-is completed.
-EXIT
-
-●
-
-After entering the program setting, please turn the rotary button to the
-“EXIT” option. Then press the rotary button. The
-machine will return to
-“READY” .
-
-Cleaning and maintenance
-
-chapter
-
-This
-the coffee machine.
-
-will
-
-instruct
-
-you on
-
-how
-
-to
-
-clean
-
-and
-
-maintain
-
-Paying
-machine,will
-coffee,
-
-attention
-not
-also
-
-but
-
-daily
-
-maintenance
-to
-only
-of
-taste
-the
-extend the life of the coffee machine.
-
-coffee
-cup
-
-of the
-of
-
-ensure
-
-each
-
-Cleaning the coffee machine before operation
-
-chapter
-This
-coffee machine.
-
-will
-
-instruct
-
-you
-
-on how
-
-to
-
-clean
-
-and
-
-maintain
-
-the
-
-Cleaning function must be processed in “READY” status.
-
-When the coffee machine is in “READY”
-status and the cleaning indicator light is not
-on, press the cleaning button to start
-cleaning the brewing unit and coffee
-spout.
-
-The process of cleaning coffee machine
-cannot be interrupted, and it will
-automatically return to “READY” status after
-cleaning.
-
-READY
-
-CLEANING
-
-Cleaning brewing unit
-
-READY
-
-12
-
-After a long-term use, there will be some coffee ground
-brewing unit. Remove the grounds by deeply cleaning the
-brewing
-The process of cleaning the brewing unit takes about
-
- unit.
-
-20minutes.
-
-left in the
-
-After entering the program settings, turn the
-rotary button to the "MAINTENANCE" option,
-and press the rotary button.
-
-When the screen shows the picture on the
-indicates cleaning the brewing unit
-left, it
- has been selected. Press the
-program
-cleaning
-button to start cleaning the
-brewing unit.
-
-The brew unit is cleaning.
-
-MAINTENANCE
-
-CLEAN BREW UNIT
-
-CLEANING
-
-Cleaning and maintenance
-
-OPEN COVER ADD
-CLEANING TABLET
-
-CLOSE COVER
-PRESS RINSE
-
-CLEAN
-
-CLEANING
-
-READY
-
-Open the pre-ground coffee chute cover,
-add
-
-the cleaning tablet.
-
-Close the pre-ground coffee chute
-cover,
-press the cleaning button to
-start the cleaning process.
-
-The screen will display as the left picture,
-
-Brew unit is now cleaning.
-
-After cleaning has finished, the machine
-re-enters
-
-into “READY” status.
-
-13
-
-Please empty the drip tray after the cleaning program is completed.
-
-First 5 cups must be discarded after cleaning.
-
-RINSE MILK UNIT
-
-●
-
-After long-term use, some milk waste would be left in the Milk
-needs to
-
-be cleaned.
-
-unit and
-
-Enter the program setting, Turn the
-rotary
-page and
-
-button to the“MAINTENANCE”
-pressed the rotary button.
-
-When showing left picture in the display, it is
-now in milk unit cleaning mode, press the
-cleaning button to start.
-
-Remove the milk pipe from the milk
-container and insert it into the hole in the
-drip tray grid according to the display.
-Press the rinse button to rinse milk unit.
-
-MAINTENANCE
-
-RINSE MILK UNIT
-
-REMOVE MILK PIPE
-
-PRESS RINSE
-
-Milk unit is cleaning.
-After cleaning is finished, the machine
-enters
-
- into “READY” status.
-
-Cleaning and maintenance
-
-RINSE MILK UNIT
-
-Please empty the drip tray after the cleaning process
-
-is
-
-completed.
-
-First 5 cups must be discarded after cleaning.
-
-Descaling the coffee machine
-
-The daily usage will cause calcium deposits in the coffee
-machine. The depositing rate varies with the local water
-hardness.
-
-Decalcifier contains acidic substances that
-could hurt
-comply with the security warnings noted by the
-manufacturer on the packaging.
-
-your eyes and skin, so you must strictly
-
-Dissolve the decalcifier in clean water, and then put the
-mixed liquid into the water tank. Fully dissolved the
-Decalcifier can descale the coffee machine more
-thoroughly.
-The whole descaling process takes about 30 minutes.
-Do not cancel the descaling process or you will damage
-the coffee machine.
-once
-process,please do not terminate it midway or turn off
-power to themachine.
-
-descaling
-
-start
-
-you
-
-the
-
-So
-
-NEED DESCALE
-
-PRESS RINSE
-
-MAINTENANCE
-
-DESCALE
-
-30 MINS
-
-PRESS RINSE
-
-14
-
-After a certain time of use, if it reaches a
-high
-degree of scaling, “NEEDS DESCALE"
-and"PRESS RINSE " will automatically
-display on
-the screen alternately. Now, press the
-cleaning button to enter the descaling
-program.
-
-Turn the rotary button to the maintenance
-setting option, press the rotary button to
-enter.
-
-Turn the rotary button to descaling option,
-press rotary button to enter
-
-After entering the descaling program, press
-the cleaning button to start the descaling
-program; it will take about
-
-minutes.
-
-30
-
-Cleaning and maintenance
-
-SOLVENT IN TANK
-
-PRESS RINSE
-
-DECALCIFYING
-
-EMPTY TRAY
-
-Take a bag of decalcifier and sufficiently
-dissolve it in clean water, then put this
-mixed liquid to the water tank, and reinstall
-the water tank to the coffee machine.
-
-After adding decalcifier, press the
-cleaning
-cleaning.
-
-button to start descaling and
-
-To start descaling and cleaning for the first
-time, put a container, of which the
-capacity is more than 1L, under the coffee
-spout.
-
-Empty tray.
-
-Install tray.
-
-INSTALL TRAY
-
-15
-
-FILL WATER TANK
-
-After descaling and cleaning for the first
-time, take the water tank out, empty the
-rest of the water and clean it. Add
-potable water again, and reinstall it to the
-coffee machine
-
- and cleaning for the second
-
-Press the cleaning button to enter
-descaling
-time. This is to clean
-decalcifying water in pipes at
-a container, of which the
-than 1L, under the coffee
-
-the residual
-
-capacity is more
-spout.
-
-this time . Put
-
-Decalcifying.
-
-the
-
-screen
-
-When
-shows
-the descaling is completed; Now, you can
-continue to brew beverages.
-
-“READY”,
-
-indicates
-
-it
-
-PRESS RINSE
-
-DECALCIFYING
-
-READY
-
-Please empty the drip tray after the cleaning program is completed.
-
-First 5 cups must be discarded after cleaning.
-
-Cleaning coffee grounds container and drip tray
-
-●
-
-●
-
-●
-
-not
-
-use
-
-and
-
-corrosive
-
-chemical
-
-Do
-cleaner
-solvents
-to clean the coffee grounds container and drip tray.
-The drip tray and coffee grounds container cannot be cleaned
-in dishwasher.
-not
-Do
-avoid
-
-residue
-container.
-
-use
-scraping
-
-coffee
-grounds
-
-objects
-drip
-
-or
-dirt
-coffee
-
-clean
-and
-
-to
-tray
-
-metal
-
-the
-
-to
-
-or
-
-alcohol
-
-Cleaning and maintenance
-
-1
-
-●
-When prompted to empty the coffee grounds, coffee grounds
-must be cleaned up, or it will cause the machine to be
-damaged.
-
-.
-
-When it accumulates to 35 cups, it will
-automatically indicate “EMPTY GROUNDS”.
-
-2
-
-EMPTY GROUNDS
-
-INSTALL TRAY
-
-READY
-
-EMPTY TRAY
-
-INSTALL TRAY
-
-READY
-
-When it shows “INSTALL TRAY “, please
-remove coffee grounds from the drip tray
-and
-more than 3 seconds.
-
- coffee grounds container. This will take
-
-Reinstall the water drip tray in the machine,
-it should returns to “READY” status. You can
-continue using the machine.
-
-If the drip tray is full, the machine will
-automatically indicate"EMPTY TRAY". Take
-out the water drip tray and dispose of
-waste
-
- water.
-
-After clearing the waste water, reinstall the
-drip tray to the coffee machine, it should
-returns to“READY” status. You can continue
-using the machine.
-
-3
-
-4
-
-16
-
- ●
-
-Each time you are cleaning coffee grounds and waste water
-from the drip tray, please empty the drip tray and coffee
-grounds
-
-container.
-
-●
-
-Each time after cleaning coffee grounds and waste water from the drip
-tray,
-at the end of drip tray, then reinstall the drip tray to the coffee machine.
-
-please rinse the tray with clean water, and wipe dry the 2 steel plates
-
-Cleaning and maintenance
-
-Cleaning water tank
-
-●
-
-●
-
-●
-
-It is suggested that, each time adding water, clean the tank
-thoroughly with running water first.
-Cleaning the water tank regularly
-
-to
-
-be
-
-use
-
-rag
-
-a wet
-
-better
-
-would
-
-and some mild
-
-it
-cleaning fluid.
-Because the water tank is made from food-grade materials and
-environmental materials, it might crack if handled
-aggressively. Please gently pick it up
-and put it down, and
-never let it fall down. if the water tank is damaged, please
-contact the customer service center.
-
-Cleaning bean container
-
-●
-
-●
-
-●
-
-to
-
-do
-
-not
-
-use
-
-wash
-
-water
-
-,
-would
-it
-
-beans hopper
-
-in the bean hopper
-
-the
-Please
-cause the grinder to be damaged.
-Please use a dry rag or a paper towel to clean the
-residue
-food-grade
-Because
-crack if handle aggre.
- and
-Please gently pick it up and put it down, and never let it fall
-down. If the bean container lid is damaged , please contact
-the customer service center.
-
-.
-cover
-it
-
-environmental
-
-is
-might
-
-container
-
-materials,
-
-grease
-
-made
-
-bean
-
-from
-
-the
-
-ssively.
-
-Disassembling and cleaning the milk frother
-
-In order to guarantee the fine and smooth milk foam, please
-clean the milk frother every day.
-
-1. Carefully take off the milk frother.
-2. Disassemble each part of the milk frother thoroughly.
-3. Wash the parts with running water.
-4. Reassemble the milk frother, and install it to the coffee
-machine.
-
-17
-
-1
-
-2
-
-3
-
-4
-
-Installing milk pipe
-
-●
-
-Install the milk pipe to the milk frother inlet.
-
-Cleaning milk pipe
-
-In order to keep milk pipe clean, please clean it every day.
-
-1. Take off milk pipe carefully.
-2. Clean milk pipe in running water.
-
-Cleaning coffee machine
-
-●
-
-●
-
-●
-
-●
-
-the
-
-check
-
-coffee
-
-grounds residue
-
-Before cleaning the interior of the coffee machine, power it
-off, the disconnect power cord from the outlet ,Never
-immerse the coffee machine inwater. There will be a risk of
-electric shock.
-Regularly
-coffee
-brush to remove the coffee
-
-machine
-the
-ground.
-Use a dry and soft
-machine.
-the
-As the touch panel is made of glass, please do not hit it to
-avoid the risk of electric shock once the glass broken.
-Use a dry and soft rag to wipe the surface of the machine,
-and never use hard objects to clean coffee residue on the
-surface, otherwise it would cause the surface to be
-damaged.
-
-is
-can use a
-
-whether
-machine.
-
-there
-You
-
-excessive
-
-touch
-
-panel
-
-inside
-
-wipe
-
-rag
-
-the
-
-to
-
-of
-
-Problem Causes and Solutions
-
-●
-
-●
-
-This chapter will instruct you on some errors that you may
-encounter
-
-and the solutions.
-
-If there are some failures cannot be resolved by the following
-methods, please contact with the authorized service center.
-
-melborP
-
-Cause
-
-snoituloS
-
-The coffee temperature is too low.
-
-The coffee cup was not pre-heated.
-
-Wash the coffee cup with hot water
-before making coffee.
-
-Several minutes have passed since the
-last time of coffee making , so the
-brewing unit and the internal pipes are
-already cold.
-
-Make some more cups of coffee.
-
-18
-
-Coffee only comes out from the
-coffee spout drop by drop.
-
-Overly fine pre -ground coffee or coffee
-bean has been ground too fine.
-
-Adjust the grinding level to coarse
-or use the suitable pre-ground coffee .
-
-Brewing unit filter was blocked.
-
-Run the brewing unit rinse programme
-
-Insufficient coffee oil.
-
-Chose the wrong coffee bean type.
-
-The grinder is making unusual noises.
-
-There are foreign objects in the grinder.
-
-Use suitable coffee beans.
-
-Make coffee again, if it still fails, please
-contact the authorized service center
-
-The milk frother cannot make any milk
-foam.
-
-The milk frother is blocked.
-
-Cleaning the milk frother ( refer to P17).
-
-Milk sprays from the milk frother.
-
-The milk frother was not assembled
-correctly.
-
-Reassemble the milk frother.
-
-Screen always indicates "EMPTY TRAY".
-
-Screen always indicates "INSTALL TRAY".
-
-Screen always indicates “FILL WATER
-TANK”, but the water tank is full.
-
-The sheet metal at the end of the drip
-tray is dirty or wet.
-
-Coffee grounds in the bottom of the
-machine are not cleaned.
-
-Wipe the sheet metal to dry ( refer to P16).
-
-Clean the coffee grounds in the bottom.
-
-The water tank inductor is trapped.
-
-Clean the water tank ( refer to P17).
-
-Screen always indicates “FILL BEANS”,
-but the bean container is full.
-
-The bean container is too oily and
-sticky for coffee beans.
-
-“Errors 1 to 7”is displayed.
-
-If the coffee machine fails, it cannot
-continue to be used
-
-1. Stir coffee beans in bean container.
-2. Observe if the coffee beans are over
-roasted or charcoal roasted.
-3. Clean the beans container ( refer to
-P17).
-
-1. Restart coffee machine.
-2. If “errors” still exist, switch off the main
-power, and contact the authorized
-service center
-
-Display information
-
-●
-
-This chapter will instruct you on the error information
-that is
-
-screen and the solutions.
-
- displayed on the
-
-Causes
-
-Solutions
-
-If the water drip tray is full,
-making beverage will
-service.
-
- be out of
-
-Take the drip tray out, empty the
-waste water in the drip tray and
-reinstall it to the machine.
-
-If the coffee grounds container is
-full, making
- beverage will be out
-of service.
-
-Take the coffee grounds container
-out, empty the coffee grounds
-container and reinstall it.
-
-If water in the water tank is
-empty, making
-be out of service.
-
- beverage will
-
-Fill the water tank with water.
-
-If coffee beans in the bean
-hopper are used up, making
-coffee will be out of
-
-service.
-
-Add beans into bean container,
-and press the rotary button to
-release.
-
-There is not enough pre -
-ground
-pre-ground coffee
-
-coffee
-
-in the
-
- chute.
-
-Next time when making coffee
-with pre-ground coffee , please
-use proper amount.
-
-The drip tray is not installed
-correctly; any function is out of
-service.
-
-Install the drip tray correctly.
-
-The water in the pipe inside the
-machine is not enough; any
-function is out of service.
-
-Press the rotary button to release,
-to run the water replenishing system.
-
-Temperature of the machine is too
-high, the machine cannot be used.
-
-Power off the main power, and
-wait 1 hour later.
-
-Temperature of the machine is too
-low, the machine cannot be used.
-
-Increase environmental temperature
-to above 10℃.
-
-EMPTY TRAY
-
-EMPTY GROUNDS
-
-FILL WATER TANK
-
-FILL BEANS
-
-FILL POWDER
-
-19
-
-INSTALL TRAY
-
-UNIT EMPTY
-
-TEMPERATURE HIGH
-
-TEMPERATURE LOW
-
-ERROR 1
-
-The coffee machine fails
-error1.may
-used.
-
-not be able to be
-
-1. Power off, then power back
-;2. If still unresolved, please
-on
-unplug from outlet.Contact with
-authorized service center.
-the
-
-1. Using dark roasted coffee beans
-or over fine pre-ground coffee
-filter of the brewer is
-2. The
-clogged.
-
-1.Adjust grinder wheel to a coarse
-setting2. Start brewer cleaning
-procedure(refer to P12).
-
-Dispenser valve is blocked.
-
-Restart coffee machine.
-
-PRESSURE HIGH
-
-VALVE RESET
-RESTART MACHINE
-
-Transport and recycle
-
-Transport
-
-Please save the packaging of the coffee machine for future
-transportation.
-Make sure to empty water inside the machine before transportation,
-otherwise, it will damage the machine.
-After emptying the waterway, please wipe the machine both
-inside and outside to dry.
-Once the empty waterway program was executed, the system
-will rerun to the program of “first-time use”, when the coffee
-machine is used again.( refer to P6, First-time use)
-While emptying the waterway, there will be high-temperature
-steam sprays from coffee spout. Please pay special attention to
-avoid being scalded.
-
-READY
-
-FILL WATER TANK
-
-EMPTY UNIT
-
-The machine is on the status of “READY”.
-
-Take out the water tank, and the machine
-indicates “FILL WATER TANK”.
-
-Press and hold the cleaning button until
-the screen shows "EMPTY UNIT", themachine
-begins to clean up the waterway
-automatically, and steam will spray from
-coffee spout, please keep your distance to
-avoid scalding.
-
-the
-
-After emptying the waterway, the machine
-will automatically power off. Take the drip
-tray out after the power is switched off, and
-clear the water in the drip tray.
-
-Recycle
-
-When recycling the machine, some inner parts can be
-recycled to use again. Please pay attention to recycle them
-for environmental protection.
-
-Technical Data
-
-Voltage/Frequency
-
-120V~ 50/60 Hz
-
-Power
-
-Pump pressure
-
-1450 W
-
-19 bar
-
-Capacity of water tank
-
-2 L or connect to water barrel
-
-Capacity of bean hopper
-
-Capacity of coffee ground waste bin
-
-Capacity of the brewing unit
-
-750 g
-
-35 cakes
-
-7 - 14 g
-
-Adjusting the height of coffee spout
-
-80 - 140 mm
-
-Length of power cord
-
-Net weight
-
-1.5 m
-
-16 kg
-
-Dimensions (Length×Width×Height)
-
-533mm×383mm×662mm
-
-20
+51
diff --git a/q15/random_k4/random_3.md b/q15/random_k4/random_3.md
index 0572cd5a0b3a091ffd9cca8b1a4cbd9e0b32bc77..7f06b970eb191d018409053c543e59811fc6cbd9 100644
--- a/q15/random_k4/random_3.md
+++ b/q15/random_k4/random_3.md
@@ -1,217 +1,1186 @@
-Active Noise Cancelling
-Wireless Headphones
-INSTRUCTION MANUAL
+TABLE OF
+CONTENTS
-QDPRANCBK
+Is Graduate School Right for You?.............................
-The Bluetooth® word mark and logos are registered
-trademarks owned by Bluetooth SIG,Inc. and any
-use of such marks by Officeworks Ltd. is under license.
+4
-1/8
+What to Expect from Graduate School ....................
- Functions
+5
-ANC switch
+Why UTRGV?................................................................
-ANC switch indicator
+6
-USB charging port
+Institutional Accreditations ......................................
-Charging light
+Graduate Programs .....................................................
-Line in audio cable
-Microphone
+Graduate Admissions ................................................
-LED status
-indicator
+Research Centers & Key Research Areas .................
-VOL+ (Short Press)
-NEXT (Long Press)
+Costs & Financing .......................................................
-Power button
-VOL- (Short Press)
-PREV (Long Press)
+Important Contact Information ...............................
-Pack Contents
-1. Headphones 2. Instruction manual 3. USB charging cable
-4. Audio cable 5. Airline adaptor 6. Headphone case
-Note: When an audio cable is plugged in, the Bluetooth wireless function will disconnect.
+8
-2/8
+10
-Power On
+12
-Power Off
+14
-Press and hold
-3 sec
+16
-Press and hold
-3 sec
+18
-3/8
+2
-Bluetooth Pairing
+3
-Press and hold
-3 sec
+IS GRADUATE
+SCHOOL
+Right for You?
+Right for You?
-LED will flash red
-and blue when ready
-to connect
+Your undergraduate education gave you a strong foundation of knowledge and skills to start
+your career. These days, however, to become an expert in your field, a graduate education is
+often required.
-Bluetooth
+Specialized skills that you’ll learn and practice in graduate school are the key to career growth,
+a better income, and unlocking your full potential. More and more, employers look for hiring
+candidates to hold a graduate degree that demonstrates their expertise.
-Bluetooth
+Even if you’re currently satisfied with your career, you might have a passion for lifelong
+learning or want to take a deeper dive into a particular subject. Investing in self-development is
+never a bad decision, and a graduate degree can create surprising benefits for you in the future.
-Devices
+As a graduate student, you’ll connect with supportive faculty who are leaders in their fields,
+as well as other motivated graduate students who share similar goals and interests. You have
+the flexibility to choose the pathway that’s right for you, including research, accelerated online
+master’s programs, on-campus master’s or doctoral programs, and certificates.
- 16BN01
+WHAT TO
+EXPECT FROM
+Graduate School?
+Graduate School?
-ON
+• You can expect to be more responsible for your success than you were as a an
-Paired
+• You’ll need to plan ahead to ensure you don’t miss out on required classes.
-Now discoverable
+undergraduate. You may even help with research or teaching.
-In your device‘s Bluetooth
-settings activate bluetooth and
-select ” 16BN01” enter
-the PIN ‘0000’ if needed
+Since some classes are only offered, for example, in the spring, you will prepare
+a graduation plan to guide you towards on-time completion of your program.
-The blue LED light will be on
-and flash to indicate the
-headphone is connected
+• You’ll take rigorous classes alongside driven classmates like yourself. Being in
-4/8
+graduate school raises the bar for expectations. You’ll need to maintain at least
+a 3.0 GPA.
-Play
+• Unlike large undergraduate classes with hundreds of students, graduate
-10m
+classes are smaller. You will be on a first-name basis with your professors, who
+will be both instructors and valuable mentors.
-1 × Press
+• As an undergraduate, you may have assisted graduate students or faculty with
+their research. As a graduate student, depending on your program, you’ll be
+expected to carry out your own research, present it, and publish it.
-Press and hold
+• If you’re taking classes on campus, you can expect most of them to be in the
+evening. Many graduate students have jobs and families, so most on-campus
+graduate classes are offered after 5 pm, twice a week. Online students need to
+prioritize and allocate time for classwork in their schedules.
-1 × Press
+• You can expect to be proud of your hard work and for pursuing your passion.
-1 × Press
+Get ready to positively transform your community and the world.
-Press and hold
+4
-Calling Mode
+5
-10m
+UTRGV?
-Answer
+WhyWhy
-1 × Press
+A high-quality education at an affordable price
-Hung up
+Graduate school at UTRGV is the perfect fit for
-1 × Press
+ambitious leaders, dreamers, researchers, educators,
-Decline
+and creators.
-Press and hold
-for 2 sec
+We welcome you to join our vibrant community,
+whether on campus or online. This is your opportunity
+to leap forward in your career with an excellent
+graduate education that’s both rigorous and affordable.
-5/8
+Pursuing a graduate degree is a commitment to your
+future, and we understand that our students have
+different learning styles and real-world responsibilities.
+We have options to suit your lifestyle and give you the
+flexibility to choose between 100% online or on-campus
+programs. All students receive the same high level of
+training and support from faculty and staff.
-Active Noise Cancelling (ANC) Function
+UTRGV offers unique research and resources through
+the STARGATE partnership with SpaceX, the Coastal
+Studies Laboratory on South Padre Island, and UT
+Health RGV clinics from our School of Medicine.
-ON
+The Valley itself has a low cost of living that’s 10.2%
+below the national average, with easy access to the
+beautiful Gulf Coast.
-OFF
+Demand for trained professionals in the Rio Grande
+Valley, the United States, and around the world
+continues to grow, and UTRGV equips graduate students
+with the necessary competitive edge.
-Turning ON: Slide the ANC switch on the right headphone to ON, the indicator light
-on the switch will turn red.
+Established in
-The ANC function uses more power when turned on and will reduce the time between
-charge of the headphones.
+2015
-ANC reduced 15db±3db noise.
+4th Largest
-Product Specifications
+institution in
+the UT System
-1. Charging voltage:
-2. Bluetooth working range:
-3. Working time:
-4. Standby time:
+Enrollment Numbers 2020:
+Graduate
-Micro USB 5V
-10 metres
-ANC off: 7-8 hours, ANC on: 3-3.5 hours
-Up to 70 hours
+Overall
-6/8
+32,618
-Charging
+5,122
-Plug micro-USB cable
-into computer’s USB port
+UTRGV RANKINGS
+UTRGV
+RANKINGS
+19th
+6th
-Plug micro-USB cable
-into USB wall charger
+1st
-Charging
+In net price among
+national universities by
+Washington Monthly (2018)
-Before using the headphone for the first time, charge it for at least
-two hours
+In the nation for top master’s
+universities by Washington
+Monthly (2019)
-Low battery alert
-When battery voltage less than 3.3V, the Headphone will be
-warning and have tone speak out from speaker.
+Best online college in Texas by
+OnlineColleges.com (2019)
-Charging
-red light on
+3rd
-Full charge
-light off
+Most affordable university in
+America by BestValueSchools.com
+(2018)
-Airline Adaptor
+1st
-The airline adaptor can only be used on the aircraft.
+4th
-Plug the airline adaptor into the connector of the video player on the plane, then connect the
-headphone with the Adaptor by audio cable.
+19th
-7/8
+79th
+6th
-Trouble Shooting
+Best college in Texas by
+BestColleges.com (2018)
-Do not expose the device to water or attempt to disassemble the device
-Headphones will not turn on
-Ensure headphones are fully charged before turning it on.
+In net price among
+national universities by
+Washington Monthly
+(2018)
-My mobile device is unable to find the Bluetooth headphones
-Check that the headphones is in pairing mode (blue/red indicator lights flashing).
-Remove“ 16BN01” from Bluetooth settings list and setup again.
-If still no search result, please restart the headset and phone, and try again.
+In the nation for top
+master’s universities by
+Washington Monthly
+(2019)
-After successfully pairing, headphones disconnect
-Check the battery level and recharge if low.
-Ensure headphones are within 10m of mobile device and free of destructions.
-The connection may be affected by obstructions such as walls or other electronic devices. Try moving
-closer to the device you are connected to.
+Best online college
+Among 300+ national universities
+in Texas by
+by Washington Monthly (2018)
+OnlineColleges.com
+(2019)
-When answering a call, I cannot hear anything
-Ensure the mobile device is connected to headphones and not on speakerphone mode.
-Increase the volume on your mobile device.
+3rd
-There is no sound when listening to music
-Increase the volume on your mobile device.
-Reconnect the headphones to your mobile device.
-Check if the app has paused or stopped playback.
+in the nation among public
+institutions for least student
+Most affordable
+debt according to U.S. News
+university in America
+& World Report (2020)
+by BestValueSchools.com
+(2018)
-Headphones will not charge
-Check whether the charging cable is functional.
-Ensure the micro-USB charging cable is fully seated in the headphones and wall charger ports.
-Ensure the charging cable and wall charger are functional.
+1st
-Officework address: Officeworks Ltd. 1 South Drive, 236-262 East Boundary Road,
- East Bentleigh, VIC 3165
+4th
-8/8
+3rd
+79th
+
+Best college in Texas
+by BestColleges.com
+(2018)
+
+America’s Best Bank for the
+Buck Colleges: South by
+Washington Monthly (2020)
+
+Among 300+ national
+universities by
+Washington Monthly
+(2018)
+
+QUALITY . FLEXIBILITY . AFFORDABILITY
+
+• According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 101 occupations require a graduate degree for entry.
+
+• The number of jobs requiring a master’s degree is projected to increase by 17% between 2016 and 2026.
+
+• Students who obtain master’s degrees earn, on average, $12,000 more in entry-level positions.
+
+• UTRGV offers graduate programs that align with the fastest growing careers.
+
+% change
+2018-2028
+
+Medium annual wage (2018)
+
+2018 Fastest Growing Occupations
+
+Occupational therapy assistants
+
+Information security analysts
+
+Physician assistants
+
+Statisticians
+
+Nurse practitioners
+
+Speech-language pathologists
+
+Physical therapist assistants
+
+Genetic counselors
+
+Mathematicians
+
+Operations research analysts
+
+Software developers, applications
+
+Health specialties teachers, postsecondary
+
+ 33.1
+
+ 31.6
+
+ 31.1
+
+ 30.7
+
+ 28.2
+
+ 27.3
+
+ 27.1
+
+ 27.0
+
+ 26.0
+
+ 25.6
+
+ 25.6
+
+ 23.2
+
+ $60,220
+
+ $98,350
+
+ $108,610
+
+ $87,780
+
+ $107,030
+
+ $77,510
+
+ $58,040
+
+ $80,370
+
+ $101,900
+
+ $83,390
+
+ $103,620
+
+ $97,370
+
+ $44,630
+
+ $50,090
+
+ $87,930
+
+ $60,280
+
+ $63,120
+
+ $73,490
+
+Substance abuse, behavioral disorder, and mental health counselors
+
+ 22.5
+
+Marriage and family therapists
+
+Physical therapists
+
+Respiratory therapists
+
+Market research analysts and marketing specialists
+
+Nursing instructors and teachers, postsecondary
+
+ 22.3
+
+ 21.9
+
+ 20.8
+
+ 20.4
+
+ 20.0
+
+Bureau of Labor Statistics, U.S. Department of Labor, Occupational Outlook Handbook, [Fastest Growing Occupations], on the Internet
+at [https://www.bls.gov/ooh/fastest-growing.htm] (visited [October 2019]).”” * U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics
+
+55+
+
+ON-CAMPUS AND ONLINE
+MASTER’S PROGRAMS
+16-week-long semesters
+
+Full-time students (9 hours/semester)
+can finish in as little as 2 years
+
+25
+
+ACCELERATED ONLINE
+
+PROGRAMS
+7-week-long modules
+
+Full-time students (6 hours/module)
+can finish in as little as 1 year
+
+6DOCTORAL PROGRAMS
+
+40CERTIFICATE PROGRAMS
+
+SCHOLARSHIPS & ASSISTANTSHIPS
+AVAILABLE
+
+$0
+
+APPLICATION FEE
+
+Except: Occupational Therapy, Physician Assistant
+Studies, Communication Sciences and Disorders,
+Psychiatric Mental Health Nurse Practitioner, and
+Physician Assistant Studies - Bridge.
+
+6
+
+7
+
+INSTITUTIONAL
+Accreditations
+Accreditations
+
+The University of Texas Rio Grande Valley (UTRGV) is accredited by the Southern Association of Colleges and
+
+Schools Commission on Colleges to award bachelor’s, master’s, and doctoral degrees.
+
+Individual Program Accreditations and Recognitions
+
+• Robert C. Vackar College of Business & Entrepreneurship
+ AACSB International, The Association to Advance
+
+• Department of Physician Assistant Studies
+ Accreditation Review Commission on Education for the
+
+Collegiate Schools of Business
+
+Physician Assistant (ARC-PA)
+
+• Educational Leadership (EdD) and Curriculum and
+
+Instruction (EdD)
+
+• School of Rehabilitation Services & Counseling
+ Council for Accreditation of Counseling and Related
+
+ Admitted to the Carnegie Project on the Education
+
+Educational Programs
+
+Doctorate (CPED)
+
+• Social Work (MSSW)
+ Council on Social Work Education (CSWE)
+
+• Music (MM)
+ National Association of School of Music (NASM)
+
+• Department of Occupational Therapy
+ Accreditation Council for Occupational Therapy
+
+Education (ACOTE)
+
+• Department of Communication Sciences & Disorders
+ Council on Academic Accreditation in Audiology and
+Speech-Language Pathology of the American Speech-
+Language-Hearing Association
+
+• Master’s Degree in Nursing and Post-Graduate
+
+Psychiatric Mental Health Nurse Practitioner Certificate
+
+ Commision on Collegiate Nursing Education
+
+• Counseling (MEd)
+ Council for Accreditation of Counseling and Related
+
+Educational Programs
+
+8
+
+9
+
+GRADUATE PROGRAMS
+
+COLLEGE OF EDUCATION
+AND P-16 INTEGRATION
+utrgv.edu/cep
+Bilingual Education (MEd)2
+Board Certified Behavior Analyst
+
+(Certificate)
+
+Certificado Avanzado en Educación
+ Bilingüe 2
+Counseling (MEd)
+Curriculum & Instruction (MEd)
+ Content Specialization in English (MEd)3
+ Content Specialization in Mathematics (MEd)3
+ Content Specialization in Elementary Math and
+
+Science Education (MEd)3
+
+ Content Specialization in Mathematics
+
+Education (MEd)3
+
+Curriculum and Instruction (EdD)
+Digital Literacy Leader (Certificate)2
+Early Childhood Education (MEd)
+Educational Leadership (EdD)
+Educational Leadership (MEd)4
+Educational Technology (MEd)3
+E-Learning (Certificate)3
+Higher Education Teaching (Certificate)3
+Online Instructional Designer (Certificate)3
+Principal Credential Certification (6 Credit Hours)
+
+(Certificate) 4
+
+Principal Credential Certification (21 Credit Hours)
+Reading and Literacy (MEd) 2
+Reading Specialist Certification (Certificate) 2
+School Psychology (MA)
+Secondary Bilingual Education (Certificate) 2
+Special Education (MEd)3
+Superintendent Certification (Certificate)
+Teacher Leadership (MEd)4
+Technology Leadership in Education
+
+(Certificate)3
+
+TxVSN Digital Literacies (Certificate)2
+
+COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING
+AND COMPUTER SCIENCE
+utrgv.edu/coec
+Civil Engineering (MS)
+Computer Science (MS)
+Electrical Engineering (MSE)
+Engineering Management (MS) 4
+Information Technology (MS)
+Manufacturing Engineering (MSE)
+Materials (Certificate)
+Mechanical Engineering (MSE)
+Mechanics and Design (Certificate)
+Thermal Fluid Science (Certificate)
+
+COLLEGE OF FINE ARTS
+utrgv.edu/cofa
+Art (MFA)
+Interdisciplinary Studies (MA)
+ Concentration in Art History
+Creative Writing (MFA)
+Design (Certificate)
+Latin American Art History (Certificate)
+Music (MM)
+
+COLLEGE OF HEALTH PROFESSIONS
+utrgv.edu/coha
+Bilingual Counseling (Certificate)2
+Bioethics (MS)2
+Clinical Rehabilitation Counseling (MS)
+Clinical Laboratory Sciences (Certificate)3
+Communication Sciences and Disorders (MS)
+Cooperative Pharmacy Program (with UT Austin)
+Exercise Science (MS)
+Health Sciences (MS)3
+ Concentration in Clinical Laboratory Sciences3
+ Concentration in Healthcare Administration3
+ Concentration in Health Professions Education
+
+and Technology3
+
+ Concentration in Healthcare Informatics3
+ Concentration in Nutrition3
+Health Science Nutrition (Certificate)3
+Healthcare Informatics (Certificate)3
+Kinesiology (MS)3
+Occupational Therapy (MS)
+Physician Assistant Studies (MPAS)
+Physician Assistant Studies - Bridge
+ Program (MPAS)2
+Rehabilitation Counseling (PhD)
+
+ROBERT C. VACKAR COLLEGE OF
+BUSINESS & ENTREPRENEURSHIP
+utrgv.edu/cobe
+Accountancy (MAcc)4
+Advanced Business Administration
+
+(Certificate)4
+
+Business Administration (MBA)
+ General4
+ Specialization in Accounting (MBA)4
+ Specialization in Business Analytics (MBA)4
+ Specialization in Entrepreneurship (MBA)4
+ Specialization in Financial Planning (MBA)4
+
+ Specialization in Health Care Administration
+
+(MBA)4
+
+ Specialization in International Trade (MBA)4
+ Specialization in Marketing (MBA)4
+Business Administration (PhD)
+Business Administration in Spanish (MBA)3
+Business Analytics (Certificate)
+Business Analytics (MS)3
+Entrepreneurship (Certificate)
+Healthcare Administration Leadership
+
+(Certificate)
+
+International Sustainability Management
+
+(Internal Certificate)5
+
+User Experience and User Interface Design (UX/UI)
+
+(Certificate)3
+
+SCHOOL OF NURSING
+utrgv.edu/nursing
+Family Nurse Practitioner (MSN)
+Nursing Administration (MSN)3
+Nursing Education (MSN)3
+Psychiatric Mental Health Nurse
+ Practitioner (Certificate)2
+
+SCHOOL OF SOCIAL WORK
+utrgv.edu/social work
+Social Work (63-Hour) (MSSW)
+Social Work (MSSW)4
+ Concentration in Administration and
+
+Community Practice (Advanced Standing)
+(MSSW)4
+
+ Concentration in Direct Practice with Latino
+Individuals, Families, and Groups (Advanced
+Standing) (MSSW)4
+
+COLLEGE OF LIBERAL ARTS
+utrgv.edu/cla
+Advanced Placement Spanish Literature
+
+(Certificate)2
+
+Board Certified Behavior Analyst
+
+(Certificate)
+
+Clinical Psychology (MA, PhD)
+Communication (MA)
+Communication Training and Consulting
+
+(Certificate)
+
+Court Interpreting (Certificate)2
+Criminal Justice (MS)4
+Disaster Studies (MA)
+English (MA)
+English as a Second Language (MA)
+
+COLLEGE OF LIBERAL ARTS cont.
+Experimental Psychology (MA)
+Gender and Women’s Studies (Certificate)
+Healthcare Interpreting (Certificate)2
+History (MA)
+Interdisciplinary Studies (MA)
+ Concentration in Anthropology
+ Concentration in English
+ Concentration in History
+ Concentration in Mexican American Studies
+Literary Translation (Certificate)2
+Localization and Audiovisual Translation
+
+(Certificate)2
+
+Media Relations and Strategic
+ Communication (Certificate)
+Mexican American Studies (Certificate)
+Political Science (MA)
+Public Affairs (MPA)4
+Secondary English Language Arts (Certificate)
+Sociology (MS)
+Spanish (MA)
+Spanish Translation and Interpreting
+
+(MA, Certificate) 2
+
+COLLEGE OF SCIENCES
+utrgv.edu/cos
+Agricultural, Environmental and Sustainability
+
+Sciences (MS)
+
+Applied Statistics and Data Science (MS)
+
+Biochemistry and Molecular Biology (MS)
+
+Biology (MS)
+
+Chemistry (MS)
+
+Cooperative PhD in Physics (with UT Arlington)
+
+Mathematics (Accelerated BS/MS
+
+ 5-Year Program, MS)
+
+Ocean, Coastal, and Earth Sciences (MS)
+
+Physics (MS, PhD)
+Interdisciplinary Studies (MS)
+
+ Concentration in Science and Technology
+
+Instructional method is traditional
+(face-to-face) unless otherwise noted.
+2 Online (16-week Semesters)
+3 Accelerated Online (7-Week Courses)
+4 On-Campus & Accelerated Online Options
+5 Online (16-week semester) and Accelerated
+ Online Options
+
+Graduate
+Graduate
+ADMISSIONS
+
+While most of our graduate programs have rolling admissions, ideally, you should begin the application
+process several months in advance to ensure that you submit all documents on time and to have the best
+chance for scholarships and assistantships.
+Admissions Checklist:
+
+Apply online: utrgv.edu/gradapply
+Get a certified English translation of your educational records
+
+Send your official college or university transcripts
+
+Submit official English Proficiency exam scores. (TOEFL, IELTS or Duolingo English Test)
+Send your official GRE or GMAT scores (if applicable)*Note: Due to the impacts of the coronavirus pandemic on
+testing centers across the world, we are temporarily suspending the GRE and GMAT test score requirements for
+
+most graduate programs until Fall 2021.
+Other documents requested by the program (varies by program). Review requirements at utrgv.edu/grad
+The application fee is waived for all graduate programs, except for Physician Assistant Studies,
+
+Occupational Therapy, Communication Sciences & Disorders, Physician Assistant Studies Bridge Program,
+
+and Psychiatric Mental Health Nurse Practitioner
+
+*If you will be pursuing your degree as an *International Student, please complete the following steps with International
+Admissions & Student Services to finalize your admissions process.*International Student is defined as someone
+who is not a U.S. citizen or U.S. resident and has a visa status or will require one to pursue their studies in a U.S. higher
+education institution.
+
+Submit financial documentation
+
+Submit immigration documents
+
+To check the status of your application and review the final decision, visit the self-service center at utrgv.edu/selfservice.
+
+FAQ FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
+
+Does my program require the GRE or GMAT?
+Not all graduate programs require an entrance exam.
+Visit utrgv.edu/graduate to find out
+if your program requires one.
+
+*Note: Due to the impacts of the coronavirus pandemic
+
+on testing centers across the world, we are temporarily
+
+suspending the GRE and GMAT test score requirements for
+
+most graduate programs until Fall 2021.
+
+Where can I register for the GRE? What is UTRGV’s GRE
+code?
+You can register to take the GRE at ets.org/gre and send us
+your scores using the GRE Code 6570.
+
+Where can I register for the GMAT? What is UTRGV’s
+GMAT code?
+You can register to take the GMAT at mba.com and send us
+your scores using the GMAT Code 9P3.
+
+I attended a legacy institution (UT Pan American, UT
+Brownsville, or Texas Southmost College).
+Do I need to request those transcripts to be sent to
+UTRGV?
+No, we have access to all transcripts from our legacy
+institutions and can upload them to your application.
+
+I started a graduate application. How do I log back
+into my application?
+Visit utrgv.edu/selfservice to log in with your username and
+password that you previously
+created. Do not create another application.
+
+Where do I send my official transcripts?
+You can get them sent electronically to gradapps@utrgv.edu
+or mail them to: The University of Texas Rio Grande Valley
+The Graduate College
+Marialice Shary Shivers Bldg. 1.158
+1201 W. Univesity Dr., Edinburg, TX 78539-2999
+
+What are the minimum English Proficiency Exam
+scores?
+TOEFL minimum: 550 paper based, 79 internet based
+IELTS minimum: 6.5
+Duolingo English Test score minimum of 105
+(Applicants with a score of 105 or above may also be
+required to participate in a Zoom or Skype interview before
+receiving a final decision.)
+
+How long is a TOEFL or IELTS score valid?
+The TOEFL and the IELTS exam scores have a two year
+validity period.
+
+Do you have exemptions for the English Proficiency
+Exam (TOELF or IELTS)?
+To view a list of exempt countries visit UTRGV.edu/grad
+
+Do I need to get my transcripts evaluated by an
+evaluation agency?
+We accept evaluations from the Foreign Credentials Services
+of America (FCSA) or the World Education Services (WES).
+However, if you have not had your transcript evaluated
+by FCSA or WES, you can send us your transcripts to be
+evaluated by UTRGV.
+
+How many credit hours do I need to be enrolled if I
+have a F1 visa?
+Nine credit hours per semester is the minimum; please
+contact the International Admissions and Student Services
+Office at international@utrgv.edu for
+more details.
+
+Is proof of health insurance required for
+international students?
+Medical insurance is mandatory for any enrolled
+international students on non-immigrant visa J-1, J-2, F-1,
+F-2. An insurance waiver is available for students with
+medical coverage. Although, medical insurance is strongly
+recommended, F-1/F-2 Mexican students are exempt from
+this health insurance requirement. For information on
+waivers, contact the International Admissions and Student
+Services office at international@utrgv.edu
+
+Who should I contact to assist me with inquires on
+the student visa process?
+International Admissions and Student Services
+1-(956) 882-7092 | 1- (956) 665-2922
+utrgv.edu/iass | international@utrgv.edu
+
+12
+
+13
+
+Research
+CENTERS
+
+At UTRGV, we have 15 research centers and
+institutes
+
+• Center for Advanced Radio Astronomy (CARA)
+• Center for Excellence in STEM Education
+• University Transportation Center for Railway Safety (UTCRS)
+• Texas Manufacturing Assistance Center (TMAC)
+• South Texas Industrial Assessment Center
+• Spacecraft Tracking and Astronomical Research into Gigahertz
+ Astrophysical Transient Emission (STARGATE)
+• Nanotechnology Center of Excellence
+• The Institute for Neuroscience
+• Center for Vector-Borne Disease (CVBD)
+• Coastal Studies Laboratory
+• Center for Sustainable Agriculture & Rural Advancement (SARA)
+• Center for Gravitational Wave Astronomy (CGWA)
+• The South Texas Diabetes and Obesity Institute (STDOI)
+• Dr. Cristina V. Torres Memorial Astronomical Observatory
+• Center for Innovation and Commercialization
+
+KEY RESEARCH
+Areas
+
+• Sustainable Agriculture
+
+ and Food Systems
+
+• Diabetes, Obesity, and Human
+
+ Genetics
+
+• Gravitational Wave and
+
+• Advanced Renewable
+
+ Advanced Radio Astronomy
+
+ Energy
+
+• Space Science Technology
+
+• Cell and Molecular
+
+ (STARGATE)
+
+• Material Science and
+
+ Engineering
+
+• Nanoscience and
+
+ Nanotechnology
+
+• Optics
+
+• Coastal Resilience
+
+ and Disaster Studies
+
+• Ocean Intelligence
+
+ Biology
+
+• Biophysics
+
+• Computational Biology
+
+• Applied Statistics and
+
+ Data Science
+
+• Mathematics (nonlinear
+
+ waves, fluid dynamics,
+
+ solitons, integrable
+
+ systems)
+
+14
+
+15
+
+Costs &
+FINANCING
+
+Scholarships*
+UTRGV has several scholarship opportunities that use the same scholarship application. Scholarships are highly
+competitive, so be sure to apply early. Visit utrgv.edu/applyscholarships for more information and to start your
+application.
+
+Graduate College Scholarships
+
+Each semester the Graduate College may offer a variety of scholarships, dependent upon funding. To view
+
+what scholarships are currently being offered visit utrgv.edu/gradscholarships.
+
+Assistantships
+
+Assistantships give students the opportunity to work on campus (up to 20-hour work weeks) and are
+
+based on college/institutional demands and funds. Three types of assistantships are offered:
+
+• Teaching
+
+• Research
+
+• Graduate
+
+Please see your program director about the different assistantships available in your
+
+field of study. Visit careers.utrgv.edu for additional graduate assistantship opportunities.
+
+Texas Resident Tuition Rate
+The Texas resident tuition rate may be granted to students who receive a teaching or
+research assistantship in their discipline or who are awarded a competitive scholarship
+of over $1,000.
+
+Payment Options
+UTRGV provides payment plans to assist with the cost of tuition and fees. Eligible students may elect one of two payment
+assistance options during the term of registration:
+
+• Installment Plan: This plan is available to any student unable to pay the full amount or partial amount due by the
+ university due dates. Installment plans consist of 4 payments.
+ Note: This is not available for summer sessions and accelerated online students.
+
+• Emergency Tuition and Fee Loan: This plan defers the payment of qualified tuition and fee charges to a future date.
+
+You can set up payment plans online through your my.utrgv.edu account within the ASSIST application. For additional
+information, contact student_billing@utrgv.edu or call 956-665-7824 or 956-665-2191.
+
+Estimated Cost of Attendance: Fall 2020 - Summer 2021
+
+Online and On-Campus (16-Week Semester) Programs
+
+Residency
+
+Texas Resident
+
+Non-Resident/International
+
+Per 3-Credit-Hour Course
+
+Per 9-Credit-Hour Semester
+
+$1,481.39
+
+$2,708.39
+
+$3,894.17
+
+$7,575.17
+
+Accelerated Online (7-Week Module) Programs
+
+Program
+
+Per 3-Credit-Hour Course
+
+Total Cost
+
+Technology Leadership in Education (Certificate)
+
+$1,374.99
+
+E-Learning (Certificate)
+
+$1,374.99
+
+Online Instructional Designer (Certificate)
+
+$1,374.99
+
+Principal Certification (Certificate)
+
+$1,374.99
+
+$4,125
+
+$5,500
+
+$5,500
+
+$9,625
+
+Curriculum & Instruction (MEd)
+Educational Leadership (MEd)
+Educational Technology (MEd)
+Special Education (MEd)
+
+Social Work 33-Hour (MSSW)
+
+Social Work (MSSW) (63 Hr)
+
+Accountancy (MACC)
+
+Business Analytics (MS)
+
+Health Sciences (MS)
+
+$1,374.99
+
+$13,750
+
+$1,333.32
+
+$1,333.32
+
+$1,416.66
+
+$1,416.66
+
+$1,333.32
+
+$14,667
+
+$27,999
+
+$14,170
+
+$15,584
+
+$16,000
+
+12
+
+16
+
+13
+17
+
+Accelerated Online (7-Week Module) Programs
+
+Program
+
+Per 3-Credit-Hour Course
+
+Total Cost
+
+Health Sciences (Certificate)
+
+Kinesiology (MS)
+
+Nursing (MSN)
+
+Public Affairs (MPA)
+
+Criminal Justice (MS)
+
+Business Administration (MBA)
+
+Business Analytics (MS)
+
+ International Sustainability Management
+(Certificate)
+
+Entrepreneurship (Certificate
+
+$1,333.32
+
+$1,333.32
+
+$1,333.32
+
+$1,333.32
+
+$1,333.32
+
+$1,416.66
+
+$1,416.66
+
+$1,416.66
+
+$1,416.66
+
+User Experience and User Interface Design
+ (UX/UI) (Certificate)
+
+$1,416.66
+
+$8,000
+
+$16,000
+
+$16,000
+
+$17,000
+
+$16,000
+
+$9,625
+
+$15,583
+
+$5,666
+
+$5,666
+
+$5,666
+
+IMPORTANT CONTACT
+Information
+Information
+
+GRADUATE SCHOLARSHIPS
+gradscholarships@utrgv.edu
+
+CONTINUING EDUCATION
+continuinged@utrgv.edu
+
+RESIDENCE LIFE
+home@utrgv.edu
+
+INTERNATIONAL ADMISSIONS
+international@utrgv.edu
+
+LANGUAGE INSTITUTE
+international@utrgv.edu
+
+18
+
+19
diff --git a/q15/random_k4/random_4.md b/q15/random_k4/random_4.md
index d1771f94490a748cfd31a8d039434182828c4f11..89df54c010831780605bc9c91d547406d9ddb498 100644
--- a/q15/random_k4/random_4.md
+++ b/q15/random_k4/random_4.md
@@ -1,2639 +1,2646 @@
-For Immediate Release
+Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 1 of 21
-Contact:
+Tina Wolfson (SBN 174806)
+twolfson@ahdootwolfson.com
+Robert Ahdoot (SBN 172098)
+rahdoot@ahdootwolfson.com
+Theodore W. Maya (SBN 223242)
+tmaya@ahdootwolfson.com
+Alyssa D. Brown (SBN 301313)
+abrown@ahdootwolfson.com
+AHDOOT & WOLFSON, PC
+2600 W. Olive Avenue, Suite 500
+Burbank, CA 91505-4521
+Telephone: 310-474-9111
+Facsimile: 310-474-8585
-Ken Bond
-Oracle Investor Relations
-1.650.607.0349
-ken.bond@oracle.com
+Counsel for Plaintiff and the Proposed Class
-Deborah Hellinger
-Oracle Corporate Communications
-1.212.508.7935
-deborah.hellinger@oracle.com
+UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
-SAAS AND PAAS CLOUD REVENUE UP 32%, SOFTWARE AND CLOUD REVENUE UP 6% TO $6.6 BILLION
+NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
-Record Quarterly Operating Cash Flow Up 7% to $6.7 Billion
+THOMAS THELE, individually and on
+behalf of all others similarly situated,
-REDWOOD SHORES, Calif., September 18, 2014 -- Oracle Corporation (NYSE: ORCL)
+Case No. 5:25-cv-09704
-today announced that fiscal 2015 Q1 total revenues were up 3% to $8.6 billion. Total Software plus
+Plaintiff,
-Cloud revenue was up 6% to $6.6 billion. Software-as-a-service (SaaS) and Platform-as-a-service
+CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
-(PaaS) cloud revenue was up 32% to $337 million. Infrastructure-as-a-service (IaaS) cloud revenue
+DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL
-was up 26% to $138 million. Hardware systems revenue was down 8% to $1.2 billion. GAAP
+v.
-operating income was up 3% to $3.0 billion, and the GAAP operating margin was 34%. Non-GAAP
+GOOGLE LLC,
-operating income was up 2% to $3.8 billion, and the non-GAAP operating margin was 44%. GAAP
+Defendant.
-net income was unchanged at $2.2 billion while non-GAAP net income was up 2% at $2.8 billion.
+1
+
+2
+
+3
+
+4
+
+5
+
+6
+
+7
+
+8
+
+9
+
+10
+
+11
+
+12
+
+13
+
+14
+
+15
+
+16
+
+17
+
+18
+
+19
+
+20
+
+21
+
+22
+
+23
+
+24
+
+25
+
+26
+
+27
+
+28
+
+- i -
+
+CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704
+CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
+
+Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 2 of 21
+
+Plaintiff Thomas Thele (“Plaintiff”), individually and on behalf of all others similarly
+
+situated (the “Class” or “Class Members”), by and through his undersigned counsel, brings this
+
+class action complaint against Defendant Google LLC (“Google” or “Defendant”).
+
+I.
+
+INTRODUCTION
+
+1.
+
+Much like its competitors, Google has developed and deployed an artificial
+
+intelligence program named Gemini throughout its portfolio of services. Some of Google’s most
+
+popular services include Gmail, Chat, and Meet, which millions of Americans use every day to
+
+email, instant message, and videoconference, respectively. Until recently, Google users could “opt
+
+in” and turn on Gemini as a “Smart” feature for these services, purportedly to “personalize [their]
+
+experience”:
+
+1
+
+2
+
+3
+
+4
+
+5
+
+6
+
+7
+
+8
+
+9
+
+10
+
+11
+
+12
+
+13
+
+14
+
+15
+
+16
+
+17
+
+18
+
+19
+
+20
+
+21
+
+22
+
+23
+
+24
+
+25
+
+26
+
+27
+
+28
+
+- 1 -
+
+CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704
+CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
+
+Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 3 of 21
+
+1
+
+2
+
+3
+
+4
+
+5
+
+6
+
+7
+
+8
+
+9
+
+10
+
+11
+
+12
+
+13
+
+14
+
+15
+
+16
+
+17
+
+18
+
+19
+
+20
+
+21
+
+22
+
+23
+
+24
+
+25
+
+26
+
+27
+
+28
+
+2.
+
+However, on or about October 10, 2025, Google secretly turned on Gemini for all
+
+its users’ Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts, enabling AI to track its users’ private communications
+
+contained in those platforms without the users’ knowledge or consent. As of the date of this filing,
+
+Google continues to track these private communications with Gemini by default, requiring users to
+
+affirmatively find this data privacy setting and shut it off, despite never “agreeing” to such AI
+
+tracking in the first place (“When you turn this setting on, you agree . . . .”).
+
+3.
+
+Despite users never giving Google informed consent to track and store their private
+
+communications, Google does just that, using Gemini AI to access and exploit the entire recorded
+
+history of its users’ private communications, including literally every email and attachment sent
+
+and received in their Gmail accounts.
+
+4.
+
+Google’s deceptive and outrageous conduct violates its users’ reasonable
+
+expectations of privacy. The intent and efforts of individuals to safeguard their private information
+
+and communications must be respected. The ramifications of unauthorized access to voluminous
+
+private communications can be severe, and individuals accordingly go to great lengths to safeguard
+
+not only their own email and messaging accounts, but, in the case of parents and guardians, also
+
+that of their minor children.
+
+5.
+
+While falsely characterizing its illusory privacy controls, Google deceptively and
+
+unconscionably deprived and continues to deprive Plaintiff and Class Members of their privacy
+
+right to send and receive private communications via email, chat, and video. This is true not only
+
+for Plaintiff and Class Members, but also for their children, whose private communications they
+
+also sought to protect.
+
+6.
+
+Google’s conduct violates the California Invasion of Privacy Act (Cal. Pen. Code
+
+§§ 630, et seq. (“CIPA”)), the California Computer Data Access and Fraud Act (Cal. Pen. Code §
+
+502 (“CDAFA”)), the Stored Communications Act (18 U.S.C. § 2701, et seq. (“SCA”)), and
+
+California’s Constitutional Right to Privacy, and it constitutes an unlawful intrusion upon
+
+seclusion.
+
+II.
+
+THE PARTIES
+
+7.
+
+Plaintiff Thomas Thele resides in Cook County, Illinois. From at least October 10,
+
+- 2 -
+
+CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704
+CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
+
+Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 4 of 21
+
+1
+
+2
+
+3
+
+4
+
+5
+
+6
+
+7
+
+8
+
+9
+
+10
+
+11
+
+12
+
+13
+
+14
+
+15
+
+16
+
+17
+
+18
+
+19
+
+20
+
+21
+
+22
+
+23
+
+24
+
+25
+
+26
+
+27
+
+28
+
+2025 until the present, Plaintiff has maintained and used, and continues to maintain and use, his
+
+Google account, including the Gmail, Chat, and/or Meet services. Plaintiff values his privacy—and
+
+the privacy of his family and friends—in the use of these password-protected services and
+
+reasonably expected the messages and conversations therein to remain private. Despite this
+
+reasonable expectation, Google surreptitiously turned on the “Smart features” setting in Plaintiff’s
+
+Data privacy settings without Plaintiff’s knowledge or consent and began tracking Plaintiff’s
+
+private communications with Gemini AI. Throughout the relevant time period, Plaintiff regularly
+
+used his Gmail, Chat, and/or Meet accounts throughout the day, unaware that Google’s Gemini AI
+
+was monitoring and tracking those private messages and conversations. In the interest of protecting
+
+his privacy and security, Plaintiff does not recite here the precise Gmail, Chat, and/or Meet
+
+communications that he sent or received with the “Smart features” setting surreptitiously turned on
+
+during the relevant time, but he does allege that the following could be determined from those
+
+communications: financial information and records, employment information and records, religious
+
+affiliations and activities, political affiliations and activities, medical care and records, the identities
+
+of his family, friends, and other contacts, social habits and activities, eating habits, shopping habits,
+
+exercise habits, the extent to which he is involved in the activities of his children (if any), and what
+
+those activities are.
+
+8.
+
+Defendant Google LLC is a limited liability company headquartered in Mountain
+
+View, California, and formed under the laws of Delaware. Google is a sophisticated mobile
+
+operating system, email, and applications developer in the business of commercializing personal
+
+data extracted from the use of tools and services connected to the internet. As such, Google is aware
+
+of and benefits from the conduct described herein. Indeed, this forms a core component, among
+
+others, of Google’s business model.
+
+III.
+
+JURISDICTION AND VENUE
+
+9.
+
+This Court has subject matter jurisdiction over this action pursuant to 28 U.S.C.
+
+§§ 1332 and 1367 because this is a class action in which the matter or controversy exceeds the sum
+
+of $5,000,000, exclusive of interest and costs, and in which some Members of the proposed Class
+
+are citizens of a state different from Defendant.
+
+- 3 -
+
+CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704
+CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
+
+Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 5 of 21
+
+1
+
+2
+
+3
+
+4
+
+5
+
+6
+
+7
+
+8
+
+9
+
+10
+
+11
+
+12
+
+13
+
+14
+
+15
+
+16
+
+17
+
+18
+
+19
+
+20
+
+21
+
+22
+
+23
+
+24
+
+25
+
+26
+
+27
+
+28
+
+10.
+
+This Court has personal jurisdiction over Defendant because Defendant owns and
+
+operates a business that is headquartered in this District and conducts substantial business
+
+throughout California. Defendant expressly consents to the jurisdiction of the federal or state courts
+
+of Santa Clara County, California through its terms of service.1
+
+11.
+
+Venue properly lies in this District pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1391(b)(1), as Defendant
+
+is headquartered in this District.
+
+IV. CHOICE OF LAW
+
+12.
+
+California law governs the substantive legal issues in this case. Google’s Terms of
+
+Service provide in pertinent part that California law will apply to any disputes arising out of or
+
+relating to Google’s terms of service.2
+
+V.
+
+STATEMENT OF FACTS
+
+13.
+
+According to recent reporting, an estimated 1.8 billion people globally in 2025 have
+
+active Gmail accounts.3 It is estimated that 41.9% of United States citizens use Gmail, which
+
+amounts to over 130 million American users.4
+
+14.
+
+In Google’s Gmail, Chat, and Meet services, users reasonably expect to customize
+
+their use of these services to their preferences by managing various functionalities and settings.
+
+They can, for example, change their preferred language, time zone, or storage settings. Included
+
+among these functionalities, within “Data privacy,” is the option to turn on or off Google’s use of
+
+“Smart features”—that is, Google’s ability to track the user’s “email, chat, and video content” with
+
+its Gemini AI technology. In its terms of service, Google’s only reference to AI is in the context of
+
+“develop[ing], improv[ing], and updat[ing]” its services:
+
+We’re constantly developing new technologies and features to improve
+our services. For example, we use artificial intelligence and machine
+learning to provide you with simultaneous translations, and to better
+detect and block spam and malware. As part of this continual
+
+1 Google Terms of Service (last modified May 22, 2024), available at
+https://policies.google.com/terms?hl=en.
+2 Id.
+3 Robert A. Lee, Gmail Statistics 2025: User Growth, Market Share & Emerging Trends, SQ
+MAGAZINE, Aug. 6, 2025, available at https://sqmagazine.co.uk/gmail-statistics/.
+4 Id.; see also Dominic Reigns, 35+ Gmail Statistics And User Trends [2025 Updated], ABOUT
+CHROMEBOOKS, Aug. 7, 2025, available at https://www.aboutchromebooks.com/gmail-statistics/.
+CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704
+CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
+
+- 4 -
+
+Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 6 of 21
+
+improvement, we sometimes add or remove features and functionalities,
+increase or decrease limits to our services, and start offering new
+services or stop offering old ones.5
+
+In its privacy policy, Google states that “across our services, you can adjust your privacy settings
+
+to control whether we collect some types of data and how we use it.”6
+
+15.
+
+On information and belief, Google turned on this “Smart features” option—without
+
+any notice to users—for all Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts on or about October 10, 2025, which
+
+enabled Gemini AI to scan, read, and analyze every email (and email attachment), message, and
+
+conversation on those services. Google users now must proactively go into their account settings
+
+and locate and turn off this feature to prevent Gemini AI from tracking their Gmail, Chat, or Meet
+
+communications. Despite this setting being in default, “opt out” status since at least October 10,
+
+the setting is still worded as an “opt in” feature: “When you turn this setting on, you agree . . .”
+
+(emphasis added). Google’s secretive Gmail, Chat, and Meet tracking practices are not only
+
+deceptive and unethical, they are directly contrary to users’ reasonable expectations of privacy.
+
+16.
+
+It appears that even tech journalists monitoring Google’s use of Gemini AI in Gmail
+
+are not fully aware of this change. Recent articles about using Gemini in Google services like Gmail
+
+still characterize the feature as something that must be agreed to and affirmatively turned on.7
+
+Nonetheless, this reporting confirms that, when active, Gemini is “downright creepy” in its ability
+
+to track, analyze, and immediately know private information:
+
+In testing [Gemini in Gmail], it was able to tell me useful information,
+such as when my next Trade coffee delivery would arrive and if I had
+any pressing emails that required responses. But it goes far beyond that.
+
+When I asked it about my first crush, Gemini was able to determine that
+it occurred in elementary school, as well as tell me the name of my first
+love, how we met, and when. Upon request, Gemini also told me who
+my top Facebook friends were in 2009 and who my best friend was in
+2010. Gemini even explained that one of my character flaws is that I get
+“too laser-focused on what [I] want, which extracts a toll on [my]
+relationships, much like Drake from the Uncharted game.” And, yes,
+
+5 Supra n.1.
+6 Google Privacy Policy (last modified July 1, 2025), available at
+https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=en-US.
+7 Ruben Circelli, I Let Gemini Access My Gmail, and It’s Downright Creepy, PC MAG, Nov. 5,
+2025, available at https://www.pcmag.com/opinions/i-let-gemini-access-my-gmail-and-its-
+downright-creepy.
+
+- 5 -
+
+CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704
+CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
+
+1
+
+2
+
+3
+
+4
+
+5
+
+6
+
+7
+
+8
+
+9
+
+10
+
+11
+
+12
+
+13
+
+14
+
+15
+
+16
+
+17
+
+18
+
+19
+
+20
+
+21
+
+22
+
+23
+
+24
+
+25
+
+26
+
+27
+
+28
+
+Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 7 of 21
+
+that’s one of my favorite game franchises, which apparently Gemini
+knows, too.
+
+How does Gemini know that? The simple answer is that the information
+is somewhere within the 16 years’ worth of my email history that it can
+access.
+
+. . . .
+
+I don’t plan on letting Gemini access my personal email anymore.8
+
+17.
+
+Google is now able to collect and utilize users’ private communications through AI
+
+“Smart features” and combine it with existing data profiles it has for its users. Back in 2012, Google
+
+announced that it would eliminate distinctions between data collected from different Google
+
+products and services for purposes of its advertising, data analysis, and other activities, saying
+
+specifically that Google “may combine information you’ve provided from one service with
+
+information from other services,” and “[w]e’ll treat you as a single user across all our products.”9
+
+18.
+
+Through the use of its Gemini AI technology, Google has created the means to
+
+illicitly compile all of its users’ private communications on its platforms without those users’
+
+express knowledge and consent. The data from these communications enables Google to cross-
+
+reference and conduct unlimited analysis toward unmerited, improper, and monetizable insights
+
+into users’ private lives, including their social, professional, and other relationships.
+
+19.
+
+The collection and use of users’ private communications violates users’ reasonable
+
+expectations of privacy, and also puts them at increased risk for further privacy violations. Data
+
+breaches and other security vulnerabilities are increasingly common among companies that store
+
+user data. As a major aggregator of valuable personally identifying and other information, Google
+
+is an obvious target for hackers. Any information that Google stores through its Gemini AI platform
+
+may eventually be stolen, if it has not already been. In 2018, for example, Google announced that
+
+it had discovered a vulnerability in its Google+ program that exposed personal account information
+
+to third-parties, contrary to its user agreements and representations. Reportedly, in order to protect
+
+8 Id.
+9 Alma Whitten, Updating our privacy policies and terms of service, GOOGLE OFFICIAL BLOG
+(Jan. 24, 2012), available at https://googleblog.blogspot.com/2012/01/updating-our-privacy-
+policies-and-terms.html.
+
+- 6 -
+
+CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704
+CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
+
+1
+
+2
+
+3
+
+4
+
+5
+
+6
+
+7
+
+8
+
+9
+
+10
+
+11
+
+12
+
+13
+
+14
+
+15
+
+16
+
+17
+
+18
+
+19
+
+20
+
+21
+
+22
+
+23
+
+24
+
+25
+
+26
+
+27
+
+28
+
+Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 8 of 21
+
+its public image, Google failed to disclose that information to the public for months, and came clean
+
+only after the security risk was discovered by the media.10
+
+20.
+
+Each of the following acts defy social norms and invade reasonable privacy
+
+expectations: tracking private communications contrary to users’ consent, misleading users
+
+regarding whether the AI tracking required the users to opt out, and failing to disclose how AI was
+
+monitoring, tracking, and utilizing these private communications. Normally, mobile device and
+
+Internet users such as Plaintiff are able to affirmatively control the flow of sensitive information
+
+about themselves through “settings” and “permissions” that they grant, or withhold, from third
+
+parties, particularly private parties such as Google. Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ expectations
+
+that those settings and permissions would be heeded and effective, and that they could send and
+
+receive communications privately without being tracked by Google, are eminently reasonable.
+
+21.
+
+Plaintiff and Class Members took specific steps to protect their private
+
+communications (as well as the private communications of their minor children) and had a
+
+reasonable expectation that Google would not use AI to monitor and track their private
+
+communications without their informed consent. Based on Google’s representations and omissions,
+
+context, and industry norms, they expected Google to heed and follow their instructions and, as a
+
+result, expected that their private communications would be private, not tracked and utilized by
+
+Google’s AI tool for Google’s own benefit and to the detriment of their personal privacy. Those
+
+reasonable expectations were consistent with sentiments that are widely shared in American society
+
+and elsewhere, and grounded in long-standing social norms and jurisprudence protecting privacy.
+
+22.
+
+Invasion of privacy has been recognized as a common law tort for more than a
+
+century. In Griswold v. Connecticut, 381 U.S. 479 (1965), the Supreme Court confirmed the
+
+primacy of privacy rights, explaining that the Constitution operates in the shadow of a “right of
+
+10 Douglas MacMillan and Robert McMillan, Google Exposed User Data, Feared Repercussions
+of Disclosing to Public, THE WALL STREET JOURNAL (Oct. 8, 2018), available at
+https://www.wsj.com/articles/google-exposed-user-data-feared-repercussions-of-disclosing-to-
+public-1539017194. Shortly thereafter, Google shut down the Google+ product entirely. Bill
+Chappell, Google Accelerates Google+ Shutdown After 52.5 Million Users’ Data Exposed, NPR
+(Dec. 11, 2018), available at https://www.npr.org/2018/12/11/675529798/with-52-5-million-
+users-data-exposed-on-google-google-quickens-shutdown.
+
+- 7 -
+
+CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704
+CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
+
+1
-GAAP earnings per share were $0.48, up 2% compared to last year while non-GAAP earnings per
+2
+
+3
+
+4
-share were $0.62, up 4%. GAAP operating cash flow on a trailing twelve-month basis was $15.4
+5
-billion.
+6
-“We are increasing our cloud services growth rate while simultaneously delivering record
+7
-levels of cash flow,” said Oracle CEO, Safra Catz. “In Q1, our overall cloud services business grew
+8
-more than 30% to $475 million in revenue. At the same time, we delivered an all-time record
+9
-operating cash flow up 7% to $6.7 billion. We are laser focused on two goals: growing our cloud
+10
-business and growing our cash flow. We’re off to a good start in FY15.”
+11
-“Our internally developed Fusion cloud applications business grew at a rate of nearly 200%
+12
-in the quarter,” said Oracle CEO, Mark Hurd. “As our hyper-growth Fusion applications become a
+13
-larger and larger portion of our total SaaS sales, that will drive up our overall cloud services growth
+14
-rate. Our cloud business is already three times the size of Workday, but we won’t be satisfied until
+15
-we’re number one in the cloud.”
+16
-“Next week at Oracle Open World, we will be rolling out our database cloud service,” said
+17
-Oracle Executive Chairman and Chief Technology Officer, Larry Ellison. “Database is our largest
+18
-software business, and database will be our largest cloud service. With our new multitenant Database
+19
-as a Service offering, our customers and ISV’s can move any of their existing Oracle databases and
+20
-applications to the Oracle Cloud with the push of a button.”
+21
-The Board of Directors also declared a quarterly cash dividend of $0.12 per share of
+22
-outstanding common stock. This dividend will be paid to stockholders of record as of the close of
+23
-business on October 8, 2014, with a payment date of October 29, 2014.
+24
-Oracle also announced that its Board of Directors authorized the repurchase of up to an
+25
-additional $13.0 billion of common stock under its existing share repurchase program in future
+26
-quarters.
+27
-Q1 Fiscal 2015 Earnings Conference Call and Webcast
+28
-Oracle will hold a conference call and webcast today to discuss these results at 2:00 p.m.
+Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 9 of 21
-Pacific. You may listen to the call by dialing (816) 287-5563, Passcode: 425392. To access the live
+1
-webcast of this event, please visit the Oracle Investor Relations website at
+2
-http://www.oracle.com/investor. In addition, Oracle’s Q1 results and Fiscal 2015 financial tables are
+3
-available on the Oracle Investor Relations website.
+4
-A replay of the conference call will also be available by dialing (855) 859-2056 or (404) 537-
+5
-3406, Passcode: 99926438.
+6
-About Oracle
+7
-Oracle engineers hardware and software to work together in the cloud and in your data center. For more
+8
-information about Oracle (NYSE: ORCL), visit www.oracle.com or contact Investor Relations at
+9
-investor_us@oracle.com or (650) 506-4073.
+10
-# # #
+11
-Trademarks
+12
-Oracle and Java are registered trademarks of Oracle and/or its affiliates. Other names may be trademarks
+13
-of their respective owners.
+14
- "Safe Harbor" Statement: Statements in this press release relating to Oracle's future plans,
-expectations, beliefs, intentions and prospects, including statements regarding our cloud services
-growth rate, growing our cash flow, our plans to be number one in the cloud, our Database as a
-Service offering and that database will be our largest cloud service, are "forward-looking statements"
+15
-and are subject to material risks and uncertainties. Many factors could affect our current expectations
-and our actual results, and could cause actual results to differ materially. We presently consider the
-following to be among the important factors that could cause actual results to differ materially from
-expectations: (1) Economic, geopolitical and market conditions, including the continued slow
-economic recovery in the U.S. and other parts of the world, can adversely affect our business, results
-of operations and financial condition, including our revenue growth and profitability, which in turn
-could adversely affect our stock price. (2) We may fail to achieve our financial forecasts due to such
-factors as delays or size reductions in transactions, fewer large transactions in a particular quarter,
-unanticipated fluctuations in currency exchange rates, delays in delivery of new products or releases
-or a decline in our renewal rates for support contracts. (3) Our cloud computing strategy, including
-our Oracle Cloud Software-as-a-Service, Platform-as-a-Service, Infrastructure-as-a-Service and our
-new Database as a Service offerings, may not be successful. (4) If we are unable to develop new or
-sufficiently differentiated products and services, or to enhance and improve our products and support
-services in a timely manner or to position and/or price our products and services to meet market
-demand, customers may not buy new software licenses, cloud software subscriptions or hardware
-systems products or purchase or renew support contracts. (5) Our international sales and operations
-subject us to additional risks that can adversely affect our operating results, including risks relating
-to foreign currency gains and losses. (6) If the security measures for our software, hardware, services
-or Oracle Cloud offerings are compromised or if such offerings contain significant coding,
-manufacturing or configuration errors, we may experience reputational harm, legal claims and
-financial exposure. (7) We have an active acquisition program and our acquisitions may not be
-successful, may involve unanticipated costs or other integration issues or may disrupt our existing
-operations. A detailed discussion of these factors and other risks that affect our business is contained
-in our SEC filings, including our most recent reports on Form 10-K and Form 10-Q, particularly
-under the heading "Risk Factors." Copies of these filings are available online from the SEC or by
-contacting Oracle Corporation's Investor Relations Department at (650) 506-4073 or by clicking on
-SEC Filings on Oracle’s Investor Relations website at http://www.oracle.com/investor. All
-information set forth in this press release is current as of September 18, 2014. Oracle undertakes no
-duty to update any statement in light of new information or future events.
+16
-ORACLE CORPORATION
- Q1 FISCAL 2015 FINANCIAL RESULTS
-CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF OPERATIONS
-($ in millions, except per share data)
+17
-Three Months Ended August 31,
+18
-2014
+19
-% of
-Revenues
+20
-2013
+21
-% of
-Revenues
+22
-% Increase
-(Decrease)
-in US $
+23
-% Increase
-(Decrease)
-in Constant
-Currency (1)
+24
-REVENUES
+25
-New software licenses
-Cloud software-as-a-service and platform-as-a-service
-Cloud infrastructure-as-a-service
-Software license updates and product support
+26
-$
+27
-1,370
-337
-138
-4,731
+28
-Software and Cloud Revenues
+privacy older than the Bill of Rights.” For its part, California amended its constitution in 1972 to
-Hardware systems products
-Hardware systems support
+specifically enumerate a right to privacy in its very first section. See Cal. Const. Art. I, § 1.
-Hardware Systems Revenues
+23.
-Services Revenues
+Google itself has long acknowledged the importance of user control over privacy
- Total Revenues
+settings. In 2018, Google’s Chief Privacy Officer testified to United States Senate Committee on
-OPERATING EXPENSES
-Sales and marketing
-Cloud software-as-a-service and platform-as-a-service
-Cloud infrastructure-as-a-service
-Software license updates and product support
-Hardware systems products
-Hardware systems support
-Services
-Research and development
-General and administrative
-Amortization of intangible assets
-Acquisition related and other
-Restructuring
-
- Total Operating Expenses
-
-OPERATING INCOME
-OPERATING INCOME
-Interest expense
-Non-operating income, net
-
-INCOME BEFORE PROVISION FOR INCOME TAXES
-
-Provision for income taxes
-
-8,596
+Commerce, Science, and Transportation that “users trust [Google] to keep their personal
-100%
+information confidential and under their control.”11
-8,372
+24.
-100%
+According to a poll by the Pew Research Center, 93% of adults believe that being
-16%
-4%
-1%
-55%
+in control of who can get information about them is important, and 90% believe that controlling
-76%
-7%
-7%
+what information is collected about them is important.12 Additionally, Americans say they do not
-14%
+approve of observation without consent: 88% say it is important that they not have someone watch
-10%
+or listen to them without their permission.13
-$
+25.
-1,399
-254
-109
-4,431
+According to a 2013 Pew Research study, “86% of Internet users have tried to be
-6,193
-669
-592
+anonymous online and taken at least one step to try to mask their behavior or avoid being tracked.”14
-1,261
+For example, 64% percent of adults claim to clear their cookies and browser histories in an attempt
-918
+to be less visible online. 15 Such behaviors exemplify people’s expectation that their personal
-17%
-3%
-1%
-53%
+information will not be tracked by others without their consent or permission, and that settings
-74%
-8%
-7%
+claiming to allow them to protect such information will be effective.
-15%
+26.
-11%
+A 2010 study comparing the opinions of young adults between the ages of 18 to 24
-20%
-2%
-1%
-3%
-4%
-2%
-8%
-16%
-3%
-6%
-0%
-1%
+with other age categories (25-34, 35-44, 45-54, 55-64, and 65+) found that a large percentage of
-66%
+young adults were in harmony with older Americans regarding concerns about online privacy,
-34%
-34%
-(3%)
-0%
+11 Written Testimony of Keith Enright Chief Privacy Officer, United States Senate Committee on
+Commerce, Science, and Transportation, Examining Safeguards for Consumer Data Privacy,
+(Sept. 26, 2018), available at https://nsarchive.gwu.edu/document/17926-keith-enright-chief-
+privacy-officer-google (emphasis added).
+12 Mary Madden and Lee Rainie, Americans’ Attitudes About Privacy, Security and Surveillance,
+PEW RESEARCH CENTER (May 20, 2015), available at
+https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2015/05/20/americans-attitudes-about-privacy-security-
+and-surveillance/.
+13 Id.
+14 Lee Rainie, et al., Anonymity, Privacy, and Security Online, PEW RESEARCH CENTER (Sept. 5,
+2013) available at https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2013/09/05/anonymity-privacy-and-
+security-online/.
+15 Id.
-31%
-6%
+- 8 -
-25%
+CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704
+CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
-1,620
-102
-72
-288
-330
-209
-720
-1,237
-260
-595
-10
-56
+Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 10 of 21
-5,499
+1
-2,873
-2,873
-(217)
-7
+2
-2,663
-472
+3
-$
+4
-2,191
+5
-19%
-1%
-1%
-3%
-4%
-3%
-9%
-15%
-3%
-7%
-0%
-1%
+6
-66%
+7
-34%
-34%
-(2%)
-0%
+8
-32%
-6%
+9
-26%
+10
-6,576
-578
-587
+11
-1,165
+12
-855
+13
-1,706
-149
-79
-272
-298
-192
-691
-1,329
-276
-547
-25
-69
+14
-5,633
+15
-2,963
-2,963
-(261)
16
-2,718
-534
+17
-(2%)
-32%
-26%
-7%
+18
-6%
-(14%)
-(1%)
+19
-(8%)
+20
-(7%)
+21
-3%
+22
-5%
-47%
-10%
-(5%)
-(10%)
-(8%)
-(4%)
-7%
-6%
-(8%)
-138%
-23%
+23
-2%
+24
-3%
-3%
-21%
-144%
+25
-2%
-13%
+26
-0%
+27
-(2%)
-32%
-25%
-6%
+28
-6%
-(14%)
-(2%)
+norms, and policy suggestions.16 For example, 88% of young adults surveyed responded that “there
-(8%)
+should be a law that requires websites and advertising companies to delete all stored information
-(8%)
+about an individual”; for individuals in the 45-54 age range, 94% approved of such a law.17
-2%
+27.
-5%
-45%
-9%
-(6%)
-(10%)
-(9%)
-(5%)
-7%
-5%
-(8%)
-134%
-21%
+The same study noted that “[o]ne way to judge a person’s concern about privacy
-2%
+laws is to ask about the penalties that companies or individuals should pay for breaching them.” A
-2%
-2%
-21%
-80%
+majority of the 18- to 24-year-olds polled selected the highest dollar amount of punishment (“more
-1%
-12%
+than $2,500”) in response to how a company should be fined if it purchases or uses someone’s
-(1%)
+personal information illegally; across all age groups, 69% of individuals opted for the highest fine.
-NET INCOME
+Beyond a fine, approximately half of the sample (across all age groups) chose the harshest penalties
-$
+for companies using a person’s information illegally: putting them out of business and imposing
-2,184
+jail time.18
-EARNINGS PER SHARE:
+28.
-Basic
-Diluted
+Google claimed to offer people a choice when it came to data privacy. In purporting
-WEIGHTED AVERAGE COMMON SHARES OUTSTANDING:
+to offer users the ability to adjust data privacy settings to control whether Google’s AI technology
-Basic
-Diluted
+accesses their Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts, Google warranted that it would respect those users’
-$
-$
+privacy choices. In reality, Google rendered users’ choices meaningless when it surreptitiously
-0.49
-0.48
+turned on the “Smart features” setting for all Gmail, Chat, and Meet users without their knowledge
-$
-$
+or consent. Google’s AI tracking of users’ private communications was surreptitious and purposely
-0.48
-0.47
+deceptive, as they did not provide notification of this change, thus requiring users to discover this
-4,451
-4,548
+change on their own and manually turn off the “Smart features” setting.
-4,608
-4,674
+29.
-(1)
+Not only were Google’s representations about privacy likely to deceive people,
-We compare the percent change in the results from one period to another period using constant currency disclosure. We present constant currency information to
-provide a framework for assessing how our underlying businesses performed excluding the effect of foreign currency rate fluctuations. To present this information,
-current and comparative prior period results for entities reporting in currencies other than United States dollars are converted into United States dollars at the exchange
-rates in effect on May 31, 2014, which was the last day of our prior fiscal year, rather than the actual exchange rates in effect during the respective periods. Movements
-in international currencies relative to the United States dollar during the three months ended August 31, 2014 compared with the corresponding prior year period
-increased our revenues by 1 percentage point and operating income by 1 percentage point.
+Google did in fact deceive the millions of people who use Gmail, Chat, and Meet. Ordinary users,
- 1
+including Plaintiff, reasonably expected that their Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts would not be
-ORACLE CORPORATION
- Q1 FISCAL 2015 FINANCIAL RESULTS
-RECONCILIATION OF SELECTED GAAP MEASURES TO NON-GAAP MEASURES (1)
-($ in millions, except per share data)
+tracked and stored by AI unless they affirmatively turned on that feature in their Google accounts.
-Three Months Ended August 31,
+16 Chris Hoofnagle, et al., How Different Are Young Adults from Older Adults When It Comes to
+Information Privacy Attitudes & Policies, University of Pennsylvania Scholarly Commons (April
+14, 2010), available at
+https://www.ftc.gov/sites/default/files/documents/public_comments/privacy-roundtables-
+comment-project-no.p095416-544506-00125/544506-00125.pdf.
+17 Id.
+18 Id.
-% Increase (Decrease)
-in US $
+- 9 -
-% Increase (Decrease) in
-Constant Currency (2)
+CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704
+CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
-2014
-GAAP
+Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 11 of 21
-Adj.
+30.
-2014
-Non-GAAP
+Google’s misrepresentations continue, despite public reporting. Users are still being
-2013
-GAAP
+deceived and tracked without consent unless they are made aware of the change to their data privacy
-Adj.
+settings and affirmatively turn off the “Smart features” setting, which is still worded in terms that
-2013
-Non-GAAP
+deceptively suggest it is something that must be agreed to and turned on by the user, not Google.
-GAAP
+VI. CLASS ALLEGATIONS
-Non-GAAP
+31.
-GAAP
+Plaintiff brings this class action, pursuant to Rule 23 of the Federal Rules of Civil
-Non-GAAP
+Procedure, individually and on behalf of all members of the following class, which is referred to
-TOTAL REVENUES (3) (4)
+throughout this Complaint as the “Class”:
-$
+All natural persons residing in the United States with Google
+accounts whose private communications in Gmail, Chat, and/or
+Meet were tracked by Google’s Gemini AI after Google turned on
+“Smart features” in those persons’ data privacy account settings.
-8,596
+32.
-$
-3
+Excluded from each Class are the following individuals: officers and directors of
-$
+Google and its parents, subsidiaries, affiliates, any entity in which Google has a controlling interest,
-8,599
+and all judges assigned to hear any aspect of this litigation, as well as their immediate family
-$
+members.
-8,372
+33.
-$
-9
+Plaintiff reserves the right to modify or amend the Class definition before the Court
-$
+determines whether certification is appropriate.
-8,381
+34.
-TOTAL SOFTWARE AND CLOUD REVENUES (3)
+This action readily satisfies the requirements set forth under Federal Rule of Civil
-$
+Procedure 23:
-6,576
+a.
-$
-2
+Each Class is so numerous that joinder of all Members is impracticable.
-$
+Upon information and belief, Class Members number in the millions.
-6,578
+b.
-$
+There are questions of law or fact common to the Class. These questions
-6,193
+include, but are not limited to, the following:
-$
-4
+i.
-$
+Whether Google’s acts and practices complained of herein amount
-6,197
+to the use of “an electronic amplifying or recording device to eavesdrop upon or record”
-New software licenses
-Cloud software-as-a-service and platform-as-a-service (3)
-Cloud infrastructure-as-a-service
-Software license updates and product support
+confidential communications in violation of CIPA;
-1,370
-337
-138
-4,731
+- 10 -
--
-2
--
--
+CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704
+CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
-1,370
-339
-138
-4,731
+1
-1,399
-254
-109
-4,431
+2
--
3
--
-1
-1,399
-257
-109
-4,432
+4
+
+5
-TOTAL HARDWARE SYSTEMS REVENUES (4)
+6
-Hardware systems products
-Hardware systems support (4)
+7
-TOTAL OPERATING EXPENSES
-Stock-based compensation (5)
-Amortization of intangible assets (6)
-Acquisition related and other
-Restructuring
+8
-OPERATING INCOME
+9
-OPERATING MARGIN %
+10
-INCOME TAX EFFECTS (7)
+11
-NET INCOME
+12
-$
+13
-1,165
-578
-587
+14
-1
-$
--
-1
+15
-$
+16
+
+17
+
+18
-1,166
-578
-588
+19
-$
+20
-1,261
-669
-592
+21
-$
+22
+
+23
+
+24
-5,633
-212
-547
25
-69
-$
+26
-(853)
-(212)
-(547)
-(25)
-(69)
+27
-$
+28
-4,780
--
--
--
--
+Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 12 of 21
-$
+1
-5,499
-198
-595
-10
-56
+2
+
+3
+
+4
5
-$
--
-5
-$
+6
+
+7
+
+8
-(859)
-(198)
-(595)
-(10)
-(56)
+9
-$
+10
-1,266
-669
-597
+11
-$
+12
-4,640
--
--
--
--
+13
-$
+14
-2,963
+15
-$
+16
-856
+17
-$
+18
-3,819
+19
-$
+20
-2,873
+21
-$
+22
-868
+23
-$
+24
-3,741
+25
-3%
+26
-34%
+27
-44%
+28
-34%
+ii.
-45%
+Whether Google’s acts and practices complained of herein amount
-15 bp.
+to “tampering, interference, damage, and unauthorized access to lawfully created computer data
-(22) bp.
+and computer systems” in violation of CDAFA;
-$
+iii. Whether Google’s acts and practices complained of herein amount
-534
+to “intentionally accesses without authorization a facility through which an electronic
-$
+communication service is provided” in violation of the SCA;
-234
+iv. Whether Google’s acts and practices complained of herein amount
-$
+to egregious breaches of social norms;
-768
+v.
-$
+Whether Google acted intentionally in violating Plaintiff’s and Class
-472
+Members’ privacy rights;
-$
+vi. Whether an injunction should issue; and
-298
+vii. Whether declaratory relief should be granted.
-$
+c.
-770
+Plaintiff’s claims are typical of the claims of the Class. Plaintiff and Class
-13%
+Members maintained private, password-protected Gmail, Chat, and/or Meet accounts that they
-$
+thought were secure and not being tracked by Google. Despite these efforts and contrary to
-2,184
+Google’s representations, Plaintiff and Class Members nonetheless had their Gmail, Chat, and/or
-$
+Meet accounts tracked by Google’s AI technology. Plaintiff and Class Members did not consent to
-622
+Google’s tracking of their private communications, which forms the basis for this suit.
-$
+d.
-2,806
+Moreover, like all Class Members, Plaintiff suffered a substantial risk of
-$
+repeated injury in the future. Plaintiff continues to use the Gmail, Chat, and/or Meet services that
-2,191
+are capable of being tracked by Google’s Gemini AI, and Google may unilaterally change his
-$
+privacy settings again in the future. Google has shown deliberate indifference to Plaintiff’s and
-570
+Class Members’ desire to keep their communications private, and has indeed taken pains to deceive
-$
+and mislead Plaintiff (and all Class Members) and to conduct its business contrary to their privacy
-2,761
+rights, and contrary to the plain meaning of its own terms of service in favor of surreptitiously and
-3%
+deceitfully monitoring their private communications. Google’s deceptive and deliberate actions
-6%
+have thwarted and continue to threaten Plaintiff’s (and Class Members’) ability to exercise control
-(2%)
-32%
-26%
-7%
+over their own privacy while using their Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts. Because the conduct
-(8%)
-(14%)
-(1%)
+- 11 -
-2%
-7%
-(8%)
-138%
-23%
+CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704
+CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
-0%
+Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 13 of 21
-2%
+1
-3%
+2
-6%
+3
-(2%)
-32%
-26%
-7%
+4
-(8%)
-(14%)
-(2%)
+5
-3%
-*
-*
-*
-*
+6
-2%
+7
-0%
+8
-2%
+9
-4%
+10
-2%
+11
-6%
+12
-(2%)
-32%
-25%
-6%
+13
-(8%)
-(14%)
-(2%)
+14
-2%
-7%
-(8%)
-134%
-21%
+15
-2%
+16
-8 bp.
+17
-12%
+18
-(1%)
+19
-1%
+20
-(3%)
+21
-2%
+22
-6%
+23
-(2%)
-31%
-25%
-6%
+24
-(8%)
-(14%)
-(2%)
+25
-2%
-*
-*
-*
-*
+26
-1%
+27
-(25) bp.
+28
-(1%)
+complained of herein is systemic, Plaintiff and Class Members face substantial risk of the same
-1%
+injury in the future. Google’s conduct is common to all Class Members and represents a common
-4%
+pattern of conduct resulting in injury to all Class Members. Plaintiff has suffered the harm alleged
-(3%)
+and has no interests antagonistic to any other Class member.
-DILUTED EARNINGS PER SHARE
+e.
-$
+Plaintiff will fairly and adequately protect the interests of the Class.
-0.48
+Plaintiff’s interests do not conflict with the interests of the Class Members. Furthermore, Plaintiff
-$
+has retained competent counsel experienced in class action litigation, consumer protection
-0.62
+litigation, and electronic privacy litigation. Plaintiff’s counsel will fairly and adequately protect and
-$
+represent the interests of the Class. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(a)(4) and 23(g) are satisfied.
-0.47
+f.
-$
+In acting as alleged above, and in failing and refusing to cease and desist
-0.59
+despite being exposed, Google has acted on grounds generally applicable to the entire Class,
-DILUTED WEIGHTED AVERAGE COMMON SHARES OUTSTANDING
+thereby making final injunctive relief and corresponding declaratory relief each appropriate with
-4,548
+respect to the Class as a whole. The prosecution of separate actions by individual Class Members
--
+would create the risk of inconsistent or varying adjudications with respect to individual Class
-4,548
+Members that would establish incompatible standards of conduct for Google.
-4,674
+g.
--
+Injunctive relief is necessary to prevent further unlawful and unfair conduct
-4,674
+by Google. Money damages, alone, could not afford adequate and complete relief, and injunctive
-(3%)
+relief is necessary to restrain Google from continuing to commit its illegal and unfair violations of
-(3%)
+privacy.
-(1)
+VII. CAUSES OF ACTION
-(2)
+ Count One
+(Violations of CIPA, Cal. Pen. Code §§ 630, et seq.)
-This presentation includes non-GAAP measures. Our non-GAAP measures are not meant to be considered in isolation or as a substitute for comparable GAAP measures, and should be read only in conjunction with our consolidatedfinancial statements prepared in
-accordance with GAAP. For a detailed explanation of the adjustments made to comparable GAAP measures, the reasons why management uses these measures, the usefulness of these measures and the material limitations on the usefulness of these measures,
-please see Appendix A.
+35.
-We compare the percent change in the results from one period to another period using constant currency disclosure. We present constant currency information to provide a framework for assessing how our underlying businesses performed excluding the effect of
-foreign currency rate fluctuations. To present this information, current and comparative prior period results for entities reporting in currencies other than United States dollars are converted into United States dollars at the exchange rates in effect on May 31, 2014,
-which was the last day of our prior fiscal year, rather than the actual exchange rates in effect during the respective periods.
+36.
-(3)
+Plaintiff repeats and realleges all preceding paragraphs contained herein.
-As of August 31, 2014, approximately $1 million in estimated revenues related to assumed cloud software-as-a-service and platform-as-a-service contracts will not be recognized for the remainder of fiscal 2015 due to business combination accounting rules.
+Cal. Pen. Code § 630 provides that “[t]he Legislature hereby declares that advances
-(4)
+in science and technology have led to the development of new devices and techniques for the
-As of August 31, 2014, approximately $1 million in estimated revenues related to hardware systems support contracts will not be recognized for the remainder of fiscal 2015 due to business combination accounting rules.
+purpose of eavesdropping upon private communication and that the invasion of privacy resulting
-(43)
-(2)
-(1)
-( )
-(5)
-(1)
-(1)
-(6)
-(108)
-(45)
-(212)
-(3)
-(215)
+from the continual and increasing use of such devices and techniques has created a serious threat
-Non-GAAP
--
-$
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
-$
--
+to the free exercise of personal liberties and cannot be tolerated in a free and civilized society.”
-Three Months Ended
-August 31, 2013
-Adj.
-$
+- 12 -
-GAAP
+CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704
+CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
-$
+Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 14 of 21
-39
-2
1
-6
+
2
+
3
-6
-97
-42
-198
-2
-200
-
-(39)
-(2)
-(1)
-( )
-(6)
-(2)
-(3)
-(6)
-(97)
-(42)
-(198)
-(2)
-(200)
-
-Non-GAAP
--
-$
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
-$
--
-
-$
-
-$
-
-$
-
-$
-
-(5)
-
-Stock-based compensation was included in the following GAAP operating expense categories:
-
-Three Months Ended
-August 31, 2014
-
-GAAP
-
-$
-
-Adj.
-$
-
- Sales and marketing
- Cloud software-as-a-service and platform-as-a-service
- Cloud infrastructure-as-a-service
- Software license updates and product support
- Hardware systems products
- Hardware systems support
- Services
- Research and development
- General and administrative
- Subtotal
- Acquisition related and other
- Total stock-based compensation
-
-Remainder of Fiscal 2015
-Fiscal 2016
-Fiscal 2017
-Fiscal 2018
-Fiscal 2019
-Fiscal 2020
-Thereafter
-
-Total intangible assets subject to amortization
-
-In-process research and development
-
-Total intangible assets, net
-
-43
-2
-1
+
+4
+
5
-1
-1
+
6
-108
-45
-212
-3
-215
-
-1,395
-1,345
-749
-611
-511
-387
-592
-5,590
+
+7
+
+8
+
+9
+
+10
+
+11
+
+12
+
+13
+
+14
+
15
-5,605
-$
+16
-$
+17
-(6)
+18
-Estimated future annual amortization expense related to intangible assets as of August 31, 2014 was as follows:
+19
-(7)
+20
-Income tax effects were calculated reflecting an effective GAAP tax rate of 19.7% and 17.7% in the first quarter of fiscal 2015 and 2014, respectively, and an effective non-GAAP tax rate of 21.5% and 21.8% in the first quarter of fiscal 2015 and 2014, respectively.
-The differences between our GAAP and non-GAAP tax rates in the first quarter of fiscal 2015 and 2014 were primarily due to the net tax effects of acquisition related items, including the tax effects of amortization of intangible assets.
+21
-* Not meaningful
+22
- 2
- 2
+23
-ORACLE CORPORATION
+24
-Q1 FISCAL 2015 FINANCIAL RESULTS
-CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEETS
-($ in millions)
+25
-ASSETS
+26
-Current Assets:
+27
-Cash and cash equivalents
-Marketable securities
-Trade receivables, net
-Inventories
-Deferred tax assets
-Prepaid expenses and other current assets
+28
-Total Current Assets
+37.
-Non-Current Assets:
+Google’s acts and practices complained of herein, engaged in for purposes of
- Property, plant and equipment, net
- Intangible assets, net
- Goodwill
- Deferred tax assets
- Other assets
+tracking and storing indefinitely the private communications of its users without their consent—
-Total Non-Current Assets
+and indeed in direct contravention of Google’s own wording of the “Smart features” setting that
-TOTAL ASSETS
+suggests it must be turned on to “opt in,” when, in reality, Google has already secretly turned it on
-LIABILITIES AND EQUITY
+and requires users to find the setting and turn it off to “opt out”—violated and continues to violate
-Current Liabilities:
+Cal. Pen. Code § 632.
-August 31,
-2014
+38.
-May 31,
-2014
+Cal. Pen. Code § 632 prohibits the use of “an electronic amplifying or recording
-$
+device to eavesdrop upon or record [a] confidential communication, whether the communication is
-24,179
-27,437
-3,551
-179
-833
-2,015
+carried on among the parties in the presence of one another or by means of a telegraph, telephone,
-$
+or other device . . . .”
-17,769
-21,050
-6,087
-189
-914
-2,129
+39.
-58,194
+In direct violation of this prohibition and without the consent of Plaintiff or Class
-3,086
-5,605
-29,707
-916
-2,218
+Members, Google has been using its Gemini AI technology to eavesdrop and record the confidential
-41,532
+communications of Plaintiff and Class Members on their Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts.
-48,138
+40.
-3,061
-6,137
-29,652
-837
-2,519
+Google accessed or caused to be accessed Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ private
-42,206
+communications from California. On information and belief, Google uses servers located in
-$
+California that allow Google to access private communications of Plaintiff and Class Members.
-99,726
+Google’s terms of service indicate that California law controls the use of its services.
-$
+41.
-90,344
+As a result of Google’s violations of Cal. Pen. Code § 632, Plaintiff and Class
-Notes payable, current and other current borrowings
-Notes payable, current and other current borrowings
-Accounts payable
-Accrued compensation and related benefits
-Income taxes payable
-Deferred revenues
-Other current liabilities
+Members are entitled to the following relief:
--
-$
-$
-423
-1,491
-425
-8,939
-2,099
+a.
-$
-$
+b.
-1,508
-1,508
-471
-1,940
-416
-7,269
-2,785
+c.
-Total Current Liabilities
+A declaration that Google’s conduct violates CIPA;
-Non-Current Liabilities:
+Statutory damages and/or trebled actual damages;
-Notes payable and other non-current borrowings
-Income taxes payable
-Other non-current liabilities
+Injunctive relief in the form of, inter alia, an order enjoining Google from
-Total Non-Current Liabilities
+continuing to access Class Members’ private communications in violation of CIPA;
-Equity
+d.
-13,377
+Injunctive relief in the form of, inter alia, an order requiring Google to
-32,567
-4,148
-1,703
+destroy all data created or otherwise obtained from its illegal tracking of Class Members’ private
-38,418
+communications; and
-47,931
+e.
-14,389
+An award of attorney’s fees and costs of litigation as provided by CIPA, the
-22,667
-4,184
-1,657
+private attorney general doctrine existing at common law and also codified at California Civil Code
-28,508
+- 13 -
-47,447
+CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704
+CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
-TOTAL LIABILITIES AND EQUITY
+Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 15 of 21
-$
+1
-99,726
+2
-$
+3
-90,344
+4
- 3
- 3
+5
- ORACLE CORPORATION
+6
-Q1 FISCAL 2015 FINANCIAL RESULTS
+7
-CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF CASH FLOWS
-($ in millions)
+8
-Cash Flows From Operating Activities:
+9
-Net income
-Adjustments to reconcile net income to net cash provided by operating activities:
+10
-Depreciation
-Amortization of intangible assets
-Deferred income taxes
-Stock-based compensation
-Tax benefits on the exercise of stock options and vesting of restricted stock-based awards
-Excess tax benefits on the exercise of stock options and vesting of restricted stock-based awards
-Other, net
-Changes in operating assets and liabilities, net of effects from acquisitions:
+11
-Decrease in trade receivables, net
-Decrease in inventories
-Decrease in prepaid expenses and other assets
-Decrease in accounts payable and other liabilities
-Increase (decrease) in income taxes payable
-Increase in deferred revenues
+12
-Net cash provided by operating activities
+13
-Cash Flows From Investing Activities:
+14
-Purchases of marketable securities and other investments
-Proceeds from maturities and sales of marketable securities and other investments
-Acquisitions, net of cash acquired
-Capital expenditures
+15
-Net cash used for investing activities
+16
-Cash Flows From Financing Activities:
+17
-Payments for repurchases of common stock
-Proceeds from issuances of common stock
-Payments of dividends to stockholders
-Proceeds from borrowings, net of issuance costs
-Repayments of borrowings
-Excess tax benefits on the exercise of stock options and vesting of restricted stock-based awards
-Distributions to noncontrolling interests
+18
-Net cash provided by financing activities
+19
-Effect of exchange rate changes on cash and cash equivalents
+20
-Net increase in cash and cash equivalents
+21
-Cash and cash equivalents at beginning of period
+22
-Cash and cash equivalents at end of period
+23
-Three Months Ended August 31,
+24
-2014
+25
-2013
+26
-$
+27
-2,184
+28
-$
+Section 1021.5, and all other applicable laws.
-2,191
+Count Two
+(Intrusion Upon Seclusion)
-160
-547
-(68)
-215
-96
-(51)
-46
+42.
-2,506
-10
-275
-(1,088)
-80
-1,816
+43.
-6,728
+Plaintiff repeats and realleges all preceding paragraphs contained herein.
-(10,340)
-3,878
-(37)
-(201)
+Plaintiff and Class Members have reasonable expectations of privacy in their Gmail,
-(6,700)
+Chat, and Meet accounts. Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ private affairs include communications
-(2,000)
-588
-(537)
-9,945
-(1,500)
-51
-(27)
+contained in these accounts.
-6,520
+44.
-(138)
+The reasonableness of such expectations of privacy is supported by Google’s unique
-6,410
+position to monitor Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ private communications through its access to
-17,769
+Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts. It is further supported by the
-150
-595
-(101)
-200
-67
-(40)
-17
+surreptitious nature of Google’s tracking.
-2,707
-5
-366
-(994)
-(313)
-1,442
+45.
-6,292
+Defendant intentionally intruded on and into Plaintiff’s and Class Members’
-(8,549)
-6,515
-(1,314)
-(153)
+solitude, seclusion, or private affairs by intentionally using AI to track their private
-(3,501)
+communications.
-(2,968)
-285
-(554)
-5,566
--
+46.
-40
-(28)
+These intrusions are highly offensive to a reasonable person. The communications
-2,341
+sent and received through Gmail, Chat, and Meet are reasonably considered private information
-(81)
+and are thus password protected, encrypted, and/or protected via two-factor authorization.
-5,051
+Moreover, Google engaged in AI tracking deceptively and without the informed consent of Plaintiff
-14,613
+and Class Members. Also supporting the highly offensive nature of Google’s conduct is the fact
-$
+that Google surreptitiously turned on this AI tracking “feature” without informing or obtaining the
-24,179
+consent of Plaintiff and Class Members.
-$
+47.
-19,664
+Plaintiff and Class Members were harmed by the intrusion into their private affairs
- 4
- 4
+as detailed throughout this Complaint.
-ORACLE CORPORATION
-Q1 FISCAL 2015 FINANCIAL RESULTS
-FREE CASH FLOW - TRAILING 4-QUARTERS (1)
-($ in millions)
+48.
-Q1
+Google’s actions and conduct complained of herein were a substantial factor in
-Fiscal 2014
+causing the harm suffered by Plaintiff and Class Members.
-Q2
+49.
-Q3
+As a result of Google’s actions, Plaintiff and Class Members seek damages and
-Q4
+punitive damages in an amount to be determined at trial. Plaintiff and Class Members seek punitive
-Q1
+damages because Google’s actions—which were malicious, oppressive, and willful—were
-Q2
+- 14 -
-Q3
+CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704
+CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
-Q4
+Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 16 of 21
-Fiscal 2015
+1
-GAAP Operating Cash Flow
+2
-$
+3
-14,845
+4
-$
+5
-15,196
+6
-$
+7
-15,029
+8
-$
+9
-14,921
+10
-$
+11
-15,357
+12
-Capital Expenditures (2)
+13
-(664)
+14
-(578)
+15
-(609)
+16
-(580)
+17
-(628)
+18
-Free Cash Flow
+19
-$
+20
-14,181
+21
-$
+22
-14,618
+23
-$
+24
-14,420
+25
-$
+26
-14,341
+27
-$
+28
-14,729
+calculated to injure Plaintiff and Class Members and made in conscious disregard of Plaintiff’s and
-% Growth over prior year
+Class Members’ privacy rights. Punitive damages are warranted to deter Google from engaging in
-6%
+future misconduct.
-14%
+Count Three
+(California Constitutional Right to Privacy, Cal. Const. Art. I, § 1)
-11%
+50.
-6%
+51.
-4%
+Plaintiff repeats and realleges all preceding paragraphs contained herein.
-GAAP Net Income
+Plaintiff and Class Members have reasonable expectations of privacy in their Gmail,
-$
+Chat, and Meet accounts. Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ private affairs include communications
-11,082
+contained in these accounts.
-$
+52.
-11,054
+Google intentionally intruded on and into Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ solitude,
-$
+seclusion, right of privacy, or private affairs by intentionally tracking the private communications.
-11,115
+53.
-$
+These intrusions are highly offensive to a reasonable person. The communications
-10,955
+sent and received through Gmail, Chat, and Meet are reasonably considered private information
-$
+and are thus password protected, encrypted, and/or protected via two-factor authorization.
-10,948
+Moreover, Google engaged in AI tracking deceptively and without the informed consent of Plaintiff
-Free Cash Flow as a % of Net Income
+and Class Members. Also supporting the highly offensive nature of Google’s conduct is the fact
-128%
+that Google surreptitiously turned on this AI tracking “feature” without informing or obtaining the
-132%
+consent of Plaintiff and Class Members.
-130%
+54.
-131%
+Plaintiff and Class Members were harmed by the intrusion into their private affairs
-135%
+as detailed throughout this Complaint.
-(1)
+55.
-To supplement our statements of cash flows presented on a GAAP basis, we use non-GAAP measures of cash flows on a trailing 4-quarter basis to analyze cash flow generated
-from operations. We believe free cash flow is also useful as one of the bases for comparing our performance with our competitors. The presentation of non-GAAP free cash flow is
-not meant to be considered in isolation or as an alternative to net income as an indicator of our performance, or as an alternative to cash flows from operating activities as a
-measure of liquidity.
+Google’s actions and conduct complained of herein were a substantial factor in
-(2)
+causing the harm suffered by Plaintiff and Class Members.
-Derived from capital expenditures as reported in cash flows from investing activities as per our consolidated statements of cash flows presented in accordance with GAAP.
+56.
- 5 5
+As a result of Google’s actions, Plaintiff and Class Members seek damages and
-ORACLE CORPORATION
-Q1 FISCAL 2015 FINANCIAL RESULTS
-SUPPLEMENTAL ANALYSIS OF GAAP REVENUES AND HEADCOUNT (1)
-($ in millions)
+punitive damages in an amount to be determined at trial. Plaintiff and Class Members seek punitive
-Q1
+damages because Google’s actions—which were malicious, oppressive, and willful—were
-Q2
+calculated to injure Plaintiff and Class Members and made in conscious disregard of Plaintiff’s and
-Fiscal 2014
-Q3
+Class Members’ privacy rights. Punitive damages are warranted to deter Google from engaging in
-Q4
+future misconduct.
-TOTAL
+- 15 -
-Q1
+CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704
+CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
-Q2
+Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 17 of 21
-Fiscal 2015
-Q3
+1
-Q4
+2
-TOTAL
+3
-REVENUES
-New software licenses
-Cloud software-as-a-service and platform-as-a-service
-Cloud infrastructure-as-a-service
-Software license updates and product support
+4
-Software and Cloud Revenues
+5
-Hardware systems products
-Hardware systems support
+6
-Hardware Systems Revenues
+7
-Services Revenues
+8
-Total Revenues
+9
-AS REPORTED REVENUE GROWTH RATES
-New software licenses
-Cloud software-as-a-service and platform-as-a-service
-Cloud infrastructure-as-a-service
-Software license updates and product support
+10
-Software and Cloud Revenues
+11
-Hardware systems products
-Hardware systems support
+12
-Hardware Systems Revenues
+13
-Services Revenues
+14
-Total Revenues
+15
-CONSTANT CURRENCY GROWTH RATES (2)
-New software licenses
-Cloud software-as-a-service and platform-as-a-service
-Cloud infrastructure-as-a-service
-Software license updates and product support
-d R
+16
-Software and Cloud Revenues
-S ft
+17
-d Cl
+18
-Hardware systems products
-Hardware systems support
+19
-Hardware Systems Revenues
+20
-Services Revenues
+21
-Total Revenues
+22
-GEOGRAPHIC REVENUES
+23
-REVENUES
-Americas
-Europe, Middle East & Africa
-Asia Pacific
+24
-Total Revenues
+25
-HEADCOUNT
+26
-GEOGRAPHIC AREA
+27
-Americas
-Europe, Middle East & Africa
-Asia Pacific
+28
-Total Company
+Count Four
+(Violations of CDAFA, Cal. Pen. Code § 502)
-$
+57.
-1,399
-254
-109
-4,431
-6,193
+58.
-$
+Plaintiff repeats and realleges all preceding paragraphs contained herein.
-2,121
-259
-97
-4,516
-6,993
+The California legislature enacted CDAFA with the intent of “expand[ing] the
-$
+degree of protection afforded to individuals . . . from tampering, interference, damage, and
-2,128
-287
-121
-4,564
-7,100
+unauthorized access to lawfully created computer data and computer systems.” Cal. Penal Code
-$
+§502(a). The enactment of CDAFA was motivated by the finding that “the proliferation of
-3,769
-322
-128
-4,695
-8,914
+computer technology has resulted in a concomitant proliferation of . . . unauthorized access to
-$
+computers, computer systems, and computer data.” Id.
-9,416
-1,121
-456
-18,206
-29,199
+59.
-$
+Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ computing devices used to access their Gmail, Chat,
-1,370
-337
-138
-4,731
-6,576
+and Meet accounts constitute “computers” within the scope of CDAFA.
-669
-592
-1,261
+60.
-714
-609
-1,323
+Google violated the following sections of CDAFA:
-725
-598
-1,323
+a.
-870
-596
-1,466
+Section 502(c)(1), which makes it unlawful to “knowingly access[] and
-2,976
-2,396
-5,372
+without permission . . . use[] any data, computer, computer system, or computer network in order
-578
-587
-1,165
+to either (A) devise or execute any scheme or artifice to defraud, deceive, or extort, or (B)
-918
+wrongfully control or obtain money, property, or data;”
-959
+b.
-884
+Section 502(c)(2), which makes it unlawful to “knowingly accesses and
-940
+without permission takes, copies, or makes use of any data from a computer, computer system, or
-3,704
+computer network, or takes or copies any supporting documentation, whether existing or residing
-855
+internal or external to a computer, computer system, or computer network;” and
-$
+c.
-1,370
-337
-138
-4,731
-6,576
+Section 502(c)(7), which makes it unlawful to “knowingly and without
-578
-587
-1,165
+permission accesses or causes to be accessed any computer, computer system, or computer
-855
+network.”
-$
+61.
-8,372
+Google knowingly accessed Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Gmail, Chat, and Meet
-$
+accounts without their permission by surreptitiously activating Gemini AI access that intercepts
-9,275
+and transmits data, communications, and personal information concerning Plaintiff and Class
-$
+Members.
-9,307
+62.
-$
+Google used data, communications, and personal information that it intercepted and
-11,320
+- 16 -
-$
+CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704
+CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
-38,275
+Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 18 of 21
-$
+1
-8,596
+2
-$
+3
-8,596
+4
-2%
-25%
-(9%)
-7%
-6%
+5
-(14%)
-3%
-(7%)
+6
-(2%)
-19%
-(15%)
-6%
-3%
+7
-(3%)
-4%
-0%
+8
-1%
-24%
-10%
-5%
-5%
+9
-8%
-5%
-7%
+10
-0%
-25%
-13%
-7%
-4%
+11
-2%
-2%
-2%
+12
-0%
-23%
-0%
-6%
-5%
+13
-(2%)
-4%
-0%
+14
-(2%)
-32%
-26%
-7%
-6%
+15
-(14%)
-(1%)
-(8%)
+16
-(8%)
+17
-(5%)
+18
-(5%)
+19
-(4%)
+20
-(5%)
+21
-(7%)
+22
-2%
+23
-2%
+24
-4%
+25
-3%
+26
-3%
+27
-3%
+28
-5%
-26%
-(7%)
-8%
-8%
-8%
+took from Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts to wrongfully and
-(13%)
-5%
-(6%)
+unjustly enrich itself at the expense of Plaintiff and Class Members.
-0%
-20%
-(14%)
-7%
-5%
-5%
+63.
-(2%)
-5%
-1%
+Defendant took, copied, intercepted, and made use of data, communications, and
-3%
-25%
-11%
-7%
-6%
-6%
+personal information from Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts.
-10%
-7%
-9%
+64.
-(1%)
-25%
-13%
-6%
-4%
-4%
+Defendant knowingly and without Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ permission
-3%
-2%
-3%
+accessed or caused to be accessed their Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts by installing—without
-1%
-24%
-1%
-7%
-5%
-5%
+Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ informed consent—AI software that intercepts and/or takes data,
-(1%)
-5%
-2%
+communications, and personal information concerning Plaintiffs and Class Members.
-(2%)
-32%
-25%
-6%
-6%
-6%
+65.
-(14%)
-(2%)
-(8%)
+Google accessed or caused to be accessed Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ data,
-(6%)
+communications, and personal information from California. On information and belief, Google
-(3%)
+uses servers located in California that allow Google to access and process the data, communications
-(3%)
+and personal information concerning Plaintiff and Class Members. Google’s terms of service
-(3%)
+indicate that California law controls the use of its services.
-(4%)
+66.
-(8%)
+Google was unjustly enriched by intercepting, acquiring, taking, or using Plaintiff’s
-4%
+and Class Members’ data, communications, and personal information without their permission, and
-3%
+using it for Google’s own financial benefit. Google has been unjustly enriched in an amount to be
-6%
+determined at trial.
-3%
+67.
-4%
+As a direct and proximate result of Google’s violations of CDAFA, Plaintiff and
-2%
+Class Members suffered damages.
-(2%)
-32%
-26%
-7%
-6%
+68.
-(14%)
-(1%)
-(8%)
+Pursuant to CDAFA Section 502(e)(1), Plaintiff and Class Members seek
-(7%)
+compensatory, injunctive, and equitable relief in an amount to be determined at trial.
-3%
+69.
-(2%)
-32%
-25%
-6%
-6%
-6%
+Pursuant to CDAFA Section 502(e)(2), Plaintiff and Class Members seek an award
-(14%)
-(2%)
-(8%)
+of reasonable attorney’s fees and costs.
-(8%)
+70.
-2%
+Pursuant to CDAFA Section 502(e)(4), Plaintiff and Class Members seek punitive
-$
+or exemplary damages for Google’s willful violations of CDAFA.
-$
+Count Five
+(Violations of the SCA, 18 U.S.C. § 2701, et seq.)
-$
+71.
-4,517
-2,439
-1,416
-8,372
+Plaintiff repeats and realleges all preceding paragraphs contained herein.
-4,995
-2,817
-1,463
-9,275
+- 17 -
-$
+CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704
+CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
-$
+Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 19 of 21
-$
+1
-4,953
-2,923
-1,431
-9,307
+2
-$
+3
-5,857
-3,768
-1,695
-11,320
+4
-$
+5
-$
+6
-20,323
-11,946
-6,006
-38,275
+7
-$
+8
-$
+9
-$
+10
-4,620
-2,589
-1,387
-8,596
+11
-$
+12
-$
+13
-4,620
-2,589
-1,387
-8,596
+14
-53,465
-23,349
-45,513
-122,327
+15
-53,073
-23,178
-45,617
-121,868
+16
-53,799
-23,350
-45,561
-122,710
+17
-53,827
-23,339
-45,108
-122,274
+18
-54,073
-23,349
-45,496
-122,918
+19
-(1) The sum of the quarterly financial information may vary from year-to-date financial information due to rounding.
+20
-(2)
+21
-We compare the percent change in the results from one period to another period using constant currency disclosure. We present constant currency information to provide a framework for
-assessing how our underlying businesses performed excluding the effect of foreign currency rate fluctuations. To present this information, current and comparative prior period results for
-entities reporting in currencies other than United States dollars are converted into United States dollars at the exchange rates in effect on May 31, 2014 and 2013 for the fiscal 2015 and fiscal
-2014 constant currency growth rate calculations presented, respectively, rather than the actual exchange rates in effect during the respective periods.
+22
- 6
- 6
+23
-ORACLE CORPORATION
-Q1 FISCAL 2015 FINANCIAL RESULTS
-SUPPLEMENTAL GEOGRAPHIC REVENUES ANALYSIS (1)
-($ in millions)
+24
-Q1
+25
-Q2
+26
-Fiscal 2014
-Q3
+27
-Q4
+28
-TOTAL
+72.
-Q1
+The SCA provides a cause of action against any person who “intentionally accesses
-Q2
+without authorization a facility through which an electronic communication service is provided,”
-Fiscal 2015
-Q3
+or any person “who intentionally exceeds an authorization to access that facility; and thereby
-Q4
+obtains, alters or prevents authorized access to a wire or electronic communication while it is in
-TOTAL
+electronic storage in such a system.” 18 U.S.C. § 2701(a).
-AMERICAS
- Software and cloud revenues
- Hardware systems revenues
+73.
-AS REPORTED GROWTH RATES
- Software and cloud revenues
- Hardware systems revenues
+The SCA defines “electronic storage” as “any temporary, intermediate storage of a
-CONSTANT CURRENCY GROWTH RATES (2)
- Software and cloud revenues
- Hardware systems revenues
+wire or electronic communication incidental to the electronic transmission thereof;” and “any
-EUROPE / MIDDLE EAST / AFRICA
- Software and cloud revenues
- Hardware systems revenues
+storage of such communication by an electronic communication service for purposes of backup
-AS REPORTED GROWTH RATES
- Software and cloud revenues
- Hardware systems revenues
+protection of such communication.” 18 U.S.C. § 2510(17).
-CONSTANT CURRENCY GROWTH RATES (2)
- Software and cloud revenues
- Hardware systems revenues
+74.
-ASIA PACIFIC
- Software and cloud revenues
- Hardware systems revenues
+The SCA defines an “electronic communications service” as “any service which
-AS REPORTED GROWTH RATES
- Software and cloud revenues
- Hardware systems revenues
+provides to users thereof the ability to send or receive wire or electronic communications.” 18
-CONSTANT CURRENCY GROWTH RATES (2)
- Software and cloud revenues
- Hardware systems revenues
+U.S.C. § 2510(15).
-TOTAL COMPANY
- Software and cloud revenues
- Hardware systems revenues
+75.
-AS REPORTED GROWTH RATES
-Software and cloud revenues
- Software and cloud revenues
- Hardware systems revenues
+Google intentionally accessed without authorization or intentionally exceeded
-CONSTANT CURRENCY GROWTH RATES (2)
- Software and cloud revenues
- Hardware systems revenues
+authorization to access facilities through which an electronic communications services was
-$
-$
+provided when it used its Gemini AI technology to access the Plaintiff’s and Class Members’
-3,434
-640
+Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts for purposes of tracking their private communications.
-$
-$
+76.
-3,808
-694
+The Gmail, Chat, and Meet services utilized by Plaintiff and Class Members on their
-$
-$
+computing devices provide electronic communications services to Plaintiff and Class Members
-3,847
-655
+because they “provide to users thereof the ability to send or receive wire or electronic
-$
-$
+communications.” 18 U.S.C. § 2510(15).
-4,649
-747
+77.
-$
-$
+The Gmail, Chat, and Meet services to which the Plaintiff and Class Members use
-15,737
-2,736
+or subscribe to provide electronic communication services to Plaintiff and Class Members because
-$
-$
+they “provide to users thereof the ability to send or receive wire or electronic communications.” 18
-3,614
-583
+U.S.C. § 2510(15).
-9%
-(2%)
+78.
-9%
-(1%)
+Neither the Plaintiff and Class Members nor the third parties with whom they
-5%
-7%
+communicated with on Gmail, Chat, and Meet authorized the extent of Google’s access to
-6%
-8%
+Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ computing devices and Google’s services therein.
-5%
-14%
+79.
-7%
-16%
+Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Gmail, Chat, and Meet accounts—and the
-(1%)
-3%
+- 18 -
-1%
-5%
+CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704
+CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
-4%
-5%
+Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 20 of 21
-5%
-6%
+1
-5%
-(9%)
+2
-6%
-(8%)
+3
-$
-$
+4
-1,816
-358
+5
-$
-$
+6
-2,155
-372
+7
-$
-$
+8
-2,245
-403
+9
-$
-$
+10
-3,032
-440
+11
-$
-$
+12
-9,249
-1,572
+13
-$
-$
+14
-1,992
-338
+15
-7%
-(11%)
+16
-4%
-(13%)
+17
-8%
-(5%)
+18
-6%
-(6%)
+19
-8%
-3%
+20
-6%
-2%
+21
-15%
-7%
+22
-10%
-3%
+23
-10%
-(1%)
+24
-7%
-(3%)
+25
-10%
-(6%)
+26
-7%
-(7%)
+27
-$
-$
+28
-943
-263
+computing devices, applications, and/or web browsers through which they accessed those
-$
-$
+services—also are facilities under the SCA because they comprise the software necessary for and
-1,030
-257
+“through which (the) electronic communications service is provided.”
-$
-$
+80.
-1,008
-265
+Google intentionally accessed Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ Gmail, Chat, and
-$
-$
+Meet accounts without authorization when Google turned on the Gemini AI access to those services
-1,233
-279
+without obtaining the consent of the Plaintiff and Class Members.
-$
-$
+81.
-4,213
-1,064
+Upon information and belief, Google’s acquisition of electronic communications
-$
-$
+from Plaintiff and Class Members included private communications Plaintiff and Class Members
-970
-244
+had with third parties that are not affiliated with Google.
-(3%)
-(12%)
+82.
-8%
-(5%)
+Plaintiff and Class Members were harmed by Google’s violations and, pursuant to
-(9%)
-(9%)
+18 U.S.C. § 2707(c), are entitled to statutory damages or actual damages, including profits earned
-0%
-(3%)
+by Google attributable to the violations, punitive damages, costs, and reasonable attorney’s fees.
-(5%)
-(3%)
+VIII. PRAYER FOR RELIEF
-3%
-3%
+WHEREFORE, Plaintiff requests that judgment be entered against Google and that the
-0%
-(4%)
+Court grant the following:
-3%
-(3%)
+A.
-(4%)
-(7%)
+An order determining that this action may be maintained as a class action under Rule
-3%
-(2%)
+23 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, that Plaintiff is a proper class representative, that
-3%
-(8%)
+Plaintiff’s attorneys shall be appointed as Class counsel pursuant to Rule 23(g) of the Federal Rules
-2%
-(8%)
+of Civil Procedure, and that Class notice be promptly issued;
-$
-$
+B.
-6,193
-1,261
+Judgment against Google for Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ asserted causes of
-$
-$
+action;
-6,993
-1,323
+C.
-$
-$
+D.
-7,100
-1,323
+Appropriate declaratory relief against Google;
-$
-$
+Injunctive relief in the form of, inter alia, an order enjoining Google from
-8,914
-1,466
+continuing its practice of accessing, using, and/or storing Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ private
-$
-$
+communications without their knowledge or consent in violation of CIPA, CDAFA, and/or SCA;
-29,199
-5,372
+E.
-$
-$
+Injunctive relief in the form of, inter alia, an order enjoining Google from
-6,576
-1,165
+continuing its practice of tracking, recording, and using Plaintiff’s and Class Members’ private
-6%
-6%
-(7%)
+communications;
-8%
-(6%)
+- 19 -
-3%
-3%
-0%
+CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704
+CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
-5%
-1%
+Case 5:25-cv-09704 Document 1 Filed 11/11/25 Page 21 of 21
-5%
-5%
-7%
+F.
-6%
-9%
+An order awarding Plaintiff and the Class Members damages, special damages,
-4%
-4%
-2%
+general damages, and restitution;
-4%
-3%
+G.
-5%
-5%
-0%
+H.
-5%
-2%
+I.
-6%
-6%
-(8%)
+J.
-6%
-(8%)
+An order requiring Google to pay punitive damages and exemplary damages;
-$
-$
+An order requiring Google to pay pre-judgment and post-judgment interest;
-3,614
-583
+Reasonable attorney’s fees and costs reasonably incurred; and
-5%
-(9%)
+Any and all other and further relief to which Plaintiff and the Class may be entitled.
-6%
-(8%)
+IX. DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL
-$
-$
+Plaintiff hereby demands a trial by jury of all issues so triable.
-1,992
-338
+Dated: November 11, 2025
-10%
-(6%)
+Respectfully Submitted,
-7%
-(7%)
+/s/ Tina Wolfson
+Tina Wolfson (SBN 174806)
+twolfson@ahdootwolfson.com
+Robert Ahdoot (SBN 172098)
+rahdoot@ahdootwolfson.com
+Theodore W. Maya (SBN 223242)
+tmaya@ahdootwolfson.com
+Alyssa D. Brown (SBN 301313)
+abrown@ahdootwolfson.com
+AHDOOT & WOLFSON, PC
+2600 W. Olive Avenue, Suite 500
+Burbank, CA 91505-4521
+Telephone: 310.474.9111
+Facsimile: 310.474.8585
-$
-$
+Bradley K. King (SBN 274399)
+bking@ahdootwolfson.com
+AHDOOT & WOLFSON, PC
+521 Fifth Avenue, 17th Floor
+New York, NY 10175
+Telephone: 917.336.0171
+Facsimile: 917.336.0177
-970
-244
+Counsel for Plaintiff and the Proposed Class
-3%
-(8%)
+- 20 -
-2%
-(8%)
+CASE NO. 5:25-cv-09704
+CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT
-$
-$
+1
-6,576
-1,165
+2
-6%
-6%
-(8%)
+3
-6%
-(8%)
+4
-(1) The sum of the quarterly financial information may vary from year-to-date financial information due to rounding.
+5
-(2) We compare the percent change in the results from one period to another period using constant currency disclosure. We present constant currency information to provide a framework for
-assessing how our underlying businesses performed excluding the effect of foreign currency rate fluctuations. To present this information, current and comparative prior period results for entities
-reporting in currencies other than United States dollars are converted into United States dollars at the exchange rates in effect on May 31, 2014 and 2013 for the fiscal 2015 and fiscal 2014 constant
-currency growth rate calculations presented, respectively, rather than the actual exchange rates in effect during the respective periods.
-
- 7
- 7
-
-ORACLE CORPORATION
-Q1 FISCAL 2015 FINANCIAL RESULTS
-EXPLANATION OF NON-GAAP MEASURES
-
-APPENDIX A
+6
-To supplement our financial results presented on a GAAP basis, we use the non-GAAP measures indicated in the tables, which exclude
-certain business combination accounting entries and expenses related to acquisitions, as well as other significant expenses including
-stock-based compensation, that we believe are helpful in understanding our past financial performance and our future results. Our non-
-GAAP financial measures are not meant to be considered in isolation or as a substitute for comparable GAAP measures and should be
-read only in conjunction with our consolidated financial statements prepared in accordance with GAAP. Our management regularly uses
-our supplemental non-GAAP financial measures internally to understand, manage and evaluate our business and make operating
-decisions. These non-GAAP measures are among the primary factors management uses in planning for and forecasting future periods.
-Compensation of our executives is based in part on the performance of our business based on these non-GAAP measures. Our non-
-GAAP financial measures reflect adjustments based on the following items, as well as the related income tax effects:
-
-• Cloud software-as-a-service and platform-as-a-service, software license updates and product support and hardware systems support
-deferred revenues: Business combination accounting rules require us to account for the fair values of cloud software-as-a-service and
-platform-as-a-service contracts, software license updates and product support contracts and hardware systems support contracts assumed
-in connection with our acquisitions. Because these contracts are generally one year in duration, our GAAP revenues generally for the one
-year period subsequent to our acquisition of a business do not reflect the full amount of revenues on these assumed cloud and support
-contracts that would have otherwise been recorded by the acquired entity. The non-GAAP adjustment to our cloud software-as-a-service
-and platform-as-a-service revenues, software license updates and product support revenues and hardware systems support revenues is
-intended to include, and thus reflect, the full amount of such revenues. We believe the adjustment to these revenues is useful to investors
-as a measure of the ongoing performance of our business. We have historically experienced high renewal rates on our software license
-updates and product support contracts and our objective is to increase the renewal rates on acquired and new cloud software-as-a-service
-and platform-as-a-service and hardware systems support contracts; however, we cannot be certain that our customers will renew our
-cloud software-as-a-service and platform-as-a-service contracts, software license updates and product support contracts or our hardware
-systems support contracts.
-
-• Stock-based compensation expenses: We have excluded the effect of stock-based compensation expenses from our non-GAAP
-operating expenses and net income measures. Although stock-based compensation is a key incentive offered to our employees, and we
-believe such compensation contributed to the revenues earned during the periods presented and also believe it will contribute to the
-generation of future period revenues, we continue to evaluate our business performance excluding stock-based compensation expenses.
-Stock-based compensation expenses will recur in future periods.
-
-• Amortization of intangible assets: We have excluded the effect of amortization of intangible assets from our non-GAAP operating
-expenses and net income measures. Amortization of intangible assets is inconsistent in amount and frequency and is significantly
-affected by the timing and size of our acquisitions. Investors should note that the use of intangible assets contributed to our revenues
-earned during the periods presented and will contribute to our future period revenues as well. Amortization of intangible assets will recur
-in future periods.
-
-• Acquisition related and other expenses; and restructuring expenses: We have excluded the effect of acquisition related and other
-expenses and the effect of restructuring expenses from our non-GAAP operating expenses and net income measures. We incurred
-significant expenses in connection with our acquisitions and also incurred certain other operating expenses or income, which we
-generally would not have otherwise incurred in the periods presented as a part of our continuing operations. Acquisition related and other
-expenses consist of personnel related costs for transitional employees, other acquired employee related costs, stock-based compensation
-expenses (in addition to the stock-based compensation expenses described above), integration related professional services, certain
-business combination adjustments including adjustments after the measurement period has ended and certain other operating items, net.
-Substantially all of the stock-based compensation expenses included in acquisition related and other expenses resulted from unvested
-options assumed in acquisitions whose vesting was fully accelerated upon termination of the employees pursuant to the original terms of
-those options. Restructuring expenses consist of employee severance and other exit costs. We believe it is useful for investors to
-understand the effects of these items on our total operating expenses. Although acquisition related expenses and restructuring expenses
-generally diminish over time with respect to past acquisitions, we generally will incur these expenses in connection with any future
-acquisitions.
+7
8
+9
+
+10
+
+11
+
+12
+
+13
+
+14
+
+15
+
+16
+
+17
+
+18
+
+19
+
+20
+
+21
+
+22
+
+23
+
+24
+
+25
+
+26
+
+27
+
+28
+
+ClassAction.org
+
+This complaint is part of ClassAction.org's searchable class action lawsuit
+database and can be found in this post: Google Hit with Data Privacy Lawsuit
+After ‘Secretly’ Turning On Gemini AI for All Users
+
diff --git a/q158/random_k2/question.json b/q158/random_k2/question.json
index 9e7999d866671790e0de63806c0fe2c65032f36f..58949097360e7c30ef2cde0d0d84fa2377de5135 100644
--- a/q158/random_k2/question.json
+++ b/q158/random_k2/question.json
@@ -15,8 +15,8 @@
],
"original_filenames": [
"f8d3a162ab9507e021d83dd109118b60.pdf",
- "web_ed8636d8f0faddf2.pdf",
- "web_289916b20eaef9df.pdf"
+ "web_ae1b8a373064ff5e.pdf",
+ "web_19b03cfaf44f6244.pdf"
],
"modality": "markdown"
}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/q158/random_k2/random_1.md b/q158/random_k2/random_1.md
index 4df5215b83d8f847c48c411dacd211a9574481da..d1447fd886d0d69697641e94fcf1890d83769afd 100644
--- a/q158/random_k2/random_1.md
+++ b/q158/random_k2/random_1.md
@@ -1,752 +1,1679 @@
-C H A P T E R 1
+Hobart and William SmitH CollegeS
-Get started with
-Web GIS
+Handbook for
+International Students
-T his chapter introduces the basic concepts and workflows of Web GIS and the Esri® geo-
+intercultural affairs Center
+288 Pulteney Street
+geneva, nY 14456
+(315) 781-3319 – Phone
+(315) 781-3888 – Fax
-spatial cloud. The chapter begins with an overview of Web GIS and its advantages; intro-
-duces Esri’s geospatial cloud including ArcGIS® Online and ArcGIS Enterprise; illustrates online,
-on-premises, and hybrid deployment patterns; lists the technical evolutions in Web GIS; explains
-the content types, hosted feature layers, app types, and user types in Web GIS; and demonstrates
-the workflow to build Web GIS apps using the Attachment Viewer instant app template. This
-chapter familiarizes you with ArcGIS Online and ArcGIS Enterprise basic operations and work-
-flows and introduces flexible ways to build Web GIS apps that you will explore in other chapters.
+TABLE OF CONTENTS
-Objectives
+SECTION I: General Information
+ Welcome
-• Grasp the concept and advantages of Web GIS.
-• Understand the deployment patterns of Web GIS.
-• Learn the components of the new-generation Web GIS.
-• Understand the technical evolutions and trends in Web GIS.
-• Understand the concepts of web services and hosted feature layers.
-• Publish hosted feature layers from CSV files.
-• Learn the workflow for creating web maps and web apps.
+important Campus Phone numbers
-Copyright © 2022 Esri. All rights reserved.2
+ office locations
-Chapter 1: Get started with Web GIS
+banks and theaters
+Places to Stay
+Frequently asked Questions
-Web GIS and the geospatial cloud
+SECTION II: Immigration Procedures
+ How to get assistance with immigration matters
+immigration basics and definition of terms
-Web GIS is the combination of the web and geographic information systems (GIS). The web
-removed the constraint of distance and thus allows people the freedom to interact with GIS apps
-globally and access information almost instantly. Web GIS uses web technologies, including but
-not limited to Hypertext Transfer Protocol (HTTP), Hypertext Markup Language (HTML),
-Uniform Resource Locator (URL), JavaScript, Web Graphics Library (WebGL), and WebSocket.
-The first operational GIS was developed in the 1960s by Roger Tomlinson (who developed
-the Canada Geographic Information System). Since then, GIS has evolved from a local file-based,
-single-computer system to a central database client/server system, often with multiple servers
-and many more client computers. The invention of the internet in the 1980s and the growth
-of the World Wide Web in the early 1990s laid the foundation for an evolutionary leap toward
-Web GIS. In 1993, the Palo Alto Research Center (PARC), a Xerox company, developed a map-
-ping web page, which marked the origin of Web GIS. In the 2000s, Web GIS evolved into a new
-generation — a system of distributed web services in the cloud you can access anywhere, repre-
-sented by ArcGIS.
+ obtaining a Visa and Form i-20
-Inheriting the power of the web and the cloud, Web GIS offers many advantages:
+differences between F-1 and J-1 Status
-• Global reach: You can share your geographic information easily, within your organization
+ arriving at a U.S. port of entry… What a student can expect
-and with people all over the world.
+dealing with the department of Homeland Security (dHS)
+exceptions to a Full Course of Study
+duration of Status for F-1 Students
+temporary departure from the US
-• Large number of users: You can share your app with dozens, or even millions, of users sup-
+ accepting U.S. government Public assistance or Public benefits
+ Work opportunities for students with F-1 Status
+ Work opportunities for students in J-1 Status
-ported by scalable cloud technology.
+Practical training
+ optional Practical training (oPt)
+ Curricular Practical training (CPt)
+departure Checklist
-• Low cost per user: The cost of building one Web GIS app is often lower than building a
-
-stand-alone desktop solution and installing it for every user.
-
-• Better cross-platform capabilities: Web apps, especially those built with JavaScript, can
-
-run on desktop and mobile browsers running a wide range of operating systems, including
-Windows, Mac OS, and Linux, along with iOS, Android, and Windows Phone.
-
-• Easy to use: Web GIS apps typically incorporate simplicity, intuition, and convenience in
-their design. Public users can use these apps without a technical background (see figure).
-• Easy to maintain: Web clients can benefit from the latest program and data updates each
-time they access a web app. The web administrator does not have to update all the clients
-separately.
+page 1
+9
+10
+10
+10
+12
-Copyright © 2022 Esri. All rights reserved.Web GIS and the geospatial cloud
+15
+16
+17
+19
+21
+22
+24
+24
+24
+25
+26
+26
+27
+27
+28
+29
+
+SECTION III:
+
+Sample Fall orientation Schedule for international Students
+
+30
+
+2
+
+SECTION I:
+GENERAL INFORMATION
+
+Welcome!
+
+Welcome to Hobart and William Smith Colleges (the Colleges or HWS). to you, the
+decision to study abroad might have been a small one – or, indeed, a rather big step.
+either way you won’t know what your experience will be like until you are here. this
+handbook is designed to help you prepare for the adventure of studying in the United
+States. in our experience the better prepared you are the more you will benefit from
+your time at the Colleges.
+ While we are trying to answer many of your questions prior to your arrival in the
+United States, some of your questions will only arise once you are here. the inter-
+national Student adviser will serve as a resource to you and your parents or guardians
+throughout the application process and during your stay at Hobart and William Smith
+Colleges. The adviser will be your primary contact for any questions or concerns
+regarding visas and immigration issues, employment, travel and a host of other
+ matters that may arise.
+
+the International Student Office (iSo) is located on the second floor of the
+
+intercultural affairs Center at 288 Pulteney Street. this office advocates for and ad-
+dresses the needs of international students as well as provides programs and services
+related to immigration matters. during the academic school year the iSo sponsors
+and co-sponsors events designed to promote cross-cultural sharing between the many
+groups at the Colleges and
+geneva communities.
+Currently, international
+students come to us from 22
+nations: austria, bulgaria,
+Canada, China, Colombia,
+Czech republic, germany,
+india, iran, nepal, Pakistan,
+Portugal, Scotland, South
+africa, South Korea, Swe-
+den, Switzerland, thailand,
+the netherlands, turkey,
+Ukraine and Vietnam.
+
+Intercultural Affairs Center – Home to the International Student Office.
+
+in the fall international students attend a special two-day orientation before
+the regular first year orientation begins. at Hobart and William Smith, we ask that
+incoming international students join us ahead of time as it is a wonderful opportunity
+to get acquainted with the new culture, get assimilated with the campus, and provide
+a forum to answer your questions before the rush of orientation activities begins. at
+the iSo, we will check to make sure that all your immigration paperwork is in order as
+well as help you gain a better understanding of what your F-1 or J-1 status means and
+how to maintain it; help to answer any questions that you might have about adjusting
+to life as a student in the United States, specifically life at HWS; and meet students,
+staff and faculty members.
3
-GIS professional
-using Web GIS
-
-Casual users
-
-Developers
-
-Open data
-community
-
-Web GIS offers a collaborative environment and a pattern for delivering GIS capabilities. GIS
-professionals share information to Web GIS and extend geospatial intelligence to users across
-organizations and throughout communities.
-
-GIS is the science of locations — The Science of Where®. The term has two meanings. One mean-
-ing is that GIS is itself a science, as the scientific basis for GIS technology. The other meaning
-is that GIS has been used for science as an effective tool for making scientific discoveries. The
-Science of Where is now recognized as a force for solving problems and understanding our
-world. Web GIS takes the science to a whole new scale, transforming how we share and col-
-laborate and revealing deeper insight into data. The common patterns of Web GIS applications
-include mapping and visualization, data management, field mobility, monitoring, analytics,
-design and planning, decision support, constituent engagement, sharing, and collaboration.
-Web GIS unlocks and delivers this science to offices and homes and puts GIS technology in the
-hands of billions of people. Web GIS provides immense value to government, business, science,
-and daily life. In recent years, the concept and importance of spatial location have become more
-mainstream, and Web GIS awareness is growing more prominent in many organizations:
-
-• Government: Web GIS offers an ideal channel for sharing public information services and
-delivering open data, an engaging medium for encouraging public participation, and a pow-
-erful framework for supporting decision-making.
-
-• Business: Web GIS helps create novel business models and reshapes existing ones. It
-
-enhances the power of location-based advertising, business analysis, and volunteered geo-
-graphic information, generating tremendous revenue directly and indirectly.
-• Science: Web GIS creates research areas and renews existing avenues of research.
-• Daily life: Web GIS helps people decide where to eat, stay, shop, and learn how to get from
-
-place to place.
-
-Table 1.1 describes patterns of Web GIS applications, including mapping and visualization, data
-management, and analytics.
-
-Copyright © 2022 Esri. All rights reserved.4
-
-Chapter 1: Get started with Web GIS
-
-Table 1 .1 . Common patterns of Web GIS applications
-
-Pattern name
-
-Description
-
-Mapping and visualization Understand locations and relationships with maps and visual representations.
-
-Data management
-
-Collect, organize, and maintain accurate locations and details about assets
-and resources.
-
-Field mobility
-
-Monitoring
-
-Analytics
-
-Manage and enable a mobile workforce to collect and access information in
-the field.
-
-Track, manage, and monitor assets and resources in real time.
-
-Discover, quantify, and predict trends and patterns to improve outcomes.
-
-Design and planning
-
-Evaluate alternative solutions and create optimal designs.
-
-Decision support
-
-Gain situational awareness and enable information-driven decision-making.
-
-Constituent engagement
-
-Communicate and collaborate with citizens and external communities
-of interest.
-
-Sharing and collaboration
-
-Empower everyone to discover, use, make, and share geographic information.
-
-The geospatial cloud powers Web GIS
-Esri’s Web GIS capabilities are provided by ArcGIS Online and ArcGIS Enterprise, which are at
-the core of the geospatial cloud.
-
-• ArcGIS Online is a software-as-a-service (SaaS) offering of Web GIS. ArcGIS Online is
-
-hosted on the Amazon Web Services (AWS) cloud and Microsoft Azure cloud platforms and
-is managed by Esri. There is no hardware infrastructure for an organization to maintain.
-ArcGIS Online hosts hundreds of millions of content items and registered users. It serves bil-
-lions of maps per day with high performance, scalability, and availability. With the benefits
-of cloud computing, ArcGIS Online has been quickly adopted by government and commer-
-cial organizations around the world.
-
-• ArcGIS Enterprise is a Web GIS software product that organizations can acquire and deploy.
-
-ArcGIS Enterprise includes four basic software components: Portal for ArcGIS, ArcGIS
-Server, ArcGIS Data Store, and ArcGIS Web Adaptor. These components support flexible
-ways for deployment, from a single-machine deployment to multiple-machine deployments,
-highly available (HA) deployment, on Windows, Linux, and the Kubernetes platform, in
-on-premises data centers or in AWS, Microsoft Azure, Google Cloud, and many other cloud
-platforms.
-
-Table 1.2 lists these deployment patterns.
-
-Copyright © 2022 Esri. All rights reserved.Web GIS and the geospatial cloud
+Questions? Please
+contact the International
+Student Adviser by phone
+ at (315) 781-3319. The
+ International Student
+ Office is located on the
+ 2nd floor of the
+Intercultural Affairs Cent-
+ter, 288 Pulteney Street,
+Geneva, NY 14456. (315)
+781-3319 – Phone (315)
+781-3888-Fax. Office
+hours are 8:30 am to
+5:00 pm weekdays during
+the academic year.
+
+THINGS TO DO BEFORE GOING ABROAD
+before you can board a plane and start your study
+abroad adventure, there are some formalities you will
+need to take care of. the earlier you start thinking
+about the things you need, the smoother your prepara-
+tions will go. this list will help you consider some of
+the things you will have to do.
+
+Obtaining a Visa
+Upon receipt of the form i-20 (for F-1 students) or dS-
+2019 (for J-1 exchange students) you can apply for your
+student visa. it is wise to schedule an appointment with
+the U.S. embassy or consulate in your country as soon
+as possible as sometimes there are no appointments
+available for weeks. You should also give yourself some
+time to prepare for your visit to the U.S. embassy or
+consulate. Visa procedures vary from country to country.
+make sure to check the website of the embassy or
+
+consulate in your country to find out what documents you need to bring. document
+you certainly need include: (1) a current, valid passport; (2) your i-20 or dS-2019
+form; (3) evidence of financial support for the duration of time you will spend in the
+US; (4) proof that you have a permanent residence outside the US; (5) one or more
+passport pictures meeting U.S. requirements; (6) a nonimmigrant visa application.
+
+Medical Insurance
+HWS Colleges require that all students buy the medical insurance provided by
+the colleges. all J-1 student-visa holders (that is, all exchange students) are also
+required by U.S. law to have their own medical insurance. While F-2 students are
+covered by the Colleges medical insurance you might nevertheless consider buying
+additional medical coverage.
+
+Important Documents
+You need to bring all important documents relating to your legal, medical, and aca-
+demic history with you. Such documents might include medical and dental records,
+certificates of immunizations, information about medical conditions and treatments,
+prescriptions for medication and eyeglasses or contact lenses, and official transcripts
+from secondary school and college. make sure you photocopy all documents and
+leave some copies with a person you trust in your home country. it is also helpful to
+translate these documents into english before you leave your home country.
+
+Packing
+Pack as light as possible. remember that you might have to carry all your things at
+different times during the journey. if you are studying abroad for only a semester you
+might not need to bring your entire wardrobe. You might also want to leave room
+in your suitcase for souvenirs you will buy while in the US. at the same time there
+might be things you want to bring because they will make you more comfortable
+
+4
+
+and will make your transition to a new environment easier. Some exchange students
+and international students also like to bring small gifts from their home country to
+share with new friends abroad. this might be a means for you to share and explain
+your culture to your new acquaintances. if you have traditional, national cloth-
+ing consider bringing it to wear at events sponsored by the international Students
+association or other cultural events. if you arrive during spring semester (January),
+to bring a warm jacket and boots, a scarf, gloves and hat. We encourage you to take
+advantage of the option to ship your packages ahead of time using the box number
+that will be provided to you from the Colleges orientation office. You may also
+consider purchasing larger items upon your arrival at our local shopping centers.
+
+Traveling Tips
+You can book your flight as soon as you find the Colleges start date for international
+Student orientation. at this time, you might have already received the schedule of
+international student orientation. the Colleges provide a complimentary pick-up
+from rochester and Syracuse airport for those international students coming to the
+Colleges for the first time if you arrive during the assigned times. long-distance
+traveling can be really exhausting, so try to get a good-night’s sleep before the trip,
+eat lightly and drink plenty of water. it is also a good idea to wear several layers of
+clothes so you can accommodate to changes in temperature. label your luggage with
+both your home address and the address in the United States (if you don’t have an
+address yet, use that of the international student office). Keep you passport, impor-
+tant documents, flight tickets, and money or traveler’s checks with you at all times.
+You might also want to pack everything you need for a one-night emergency stay
+into your hand luggage in case you get stuck at the airport or your luggage gets lost.
+
+Money
+You should carry a small amount of U.S. dollars with you while traveling so that you
+can buy some food or other small things you might need. However, it is not a good
+idea to carry large sums of money. We recommend that you buy traveler’s checks or
+get a credit card that allows you to withdraw money from a cash machine when you
+need to. Upon arrival on campus, the international student adviser can help you to
+set up an account with a local bank. it is highly recommended to have an U.S. bank
+account because it will make payments so much easier. Students can create bank
+accounts free of charge.
+
+GETTING TO KNOW HOBART AND WILLIAM SMITH COLLEGES
+College is an exciting time for everyone and it is a transition for all students. if you
+are an exchange student, you already went through the transition process once.
+nevertheless, studying abroad brings with it a range of new experiences. every col-
+lege is a little different and if you have never studied in the United States before,
+many things might be very confusing.
+
+Hobart and William Smith Colleges
+Hobart and William Smith is a small, private liberal arts institution. You can expect
+to study in relatively small classes and build close relationships with your classmates
5
-Table 1 .2 . Esri Web GIS deployment patterns
-
-Online
-
-Hybrid
-
-On-premises or in cloud
-
-Esri managed
-
-ArcGIS Online
+and professors. Virtually all students are being housed on campus. living so close
+to each other has many advantages: it is relatively easy to get to know new people,
+get involved in clubs and activities, and make an impact on the community. at the
+same time it can be hard to find personal time and separate school from other activi-
+ties when the two are not physically separated.
+
+Classes
+at HWS, a normal course load is four classes per semester. this means that you
+will be in class for between 12 and 15 hours every week, or more if you take courses
+requiring labs or studio work. there are different types of classes. 100- and 200-level
+classes are usually introductory classes and have a wider focus. 300- and 400-level
+classes have a narrower, more specific focus. Some professors prefer to lecture, but
+you also encounter class-discussions. Higher level classes tend to be taught in a semi-
+nar style, in which a lot of the class’ content relies on student presentations. there
+are also independent study classes in which you research a topic under a professor’s
+guidance but without the classroom structure. as an upper-class student you might
+choose to work on an honors project. this is an independent research project that
+will culminate in a 80- to 100-page paper. You can take classes from all departments
+but at the end of your Sophomore (2nd) year, you will need to declare a major and a
+minor subject (or one major, two minors; or two majors, one minor; or two majors,
+two minors). as part of your liberal arts education, you will also have to fulfill cer-
+tain academic goals. Your academic adviser will help you with that.
+
+Grading and Grades
+Foreign students often find that americans are very competitive. this also reflects
+on the system of grading. You will find that you will have many opportunities to
+prove your knowledge of a subject in class. many professors will give short, unan-
+nounced quizzes that test your knowledge of the course material assigned for that
+day. exams are bigger, announced tests that cover the course material of a longer pe-
+riod of time. they can be compromised of true or false questions, sentence comple-
+tion (“fill in the blank”), multiple choice, matching, essay questions, or a combina-
+tion of these. Professors will also assign essays and papers you have to write on your
+own time. Your class participation might also count toward your final grade. the
+Colleges use the grading system based on a four-point scale: a= 4.0, b= 3.0, C= 2.0,
+d= 1.0. You need at least a C average in your classes to remain a full-time student.
+
+Homework
+Some foreign students are overwhelmed by the quantity of homework assigned by
+american colleges. especially in the beginning when you still have problems with
+the english language, keeping up with homework can be really hard. if you find
+yourself struggling to keep up with work, ask for help. Find the Center for teaching
+and learning on campus and schedule an appointment! Ctl is open to all students
+and its services are already covered by your tuition. they can help you with your
+writing assignments, help with time management, or assign you a tutor to help you
+with the content of a class. it is also important to realize that most american stu-
+dents prioritize their work: decide what readings are important to do and read them
+thoroughly; skim the others.
+6
+
+Professors and Advisers
+every student at HWS is assigned an academic adviser. He or she will help you
+with any questions you have related to your academic life. Feel free to consult them
+before choosing classes, if you are struggling with certain classes or professors, if you
+want to know how and when to declare majors and minors, and any other questions
+you might have. most professors are also interested in helping you as much as pos-
+sible and want to get to know you outside of class. don’t feel embarrassed to ask a
+professor a question after class. You should also take advantage of their office hours.
+interaction between professors and students in america is a lot tighter than in many
+other countries. Students sometimes stop by their professor’s office simply to talk
+about something that they are interested in.
+
+Important information on financial aid
+Hobart and William Smith Colleges offer merit scholarships as well as need-based
+grants to international students. the average package typically equals more than
+half the annual cost of tuition, room and board. Highly competitive applicants will
+be considered for a full tuition scholarships.
+
+Financial aid is available for a maximum of four years for those who enroll as
+
+first-year students. For those entering with advanced standing (transfers), aid is
+available for the time allotted to complete a degree. awards based on demonstrated
+financial need, if it becomes apparent that such need no longer exists, may be re-
+duced. Students must resubmit a financial aid application each year.
+
+ADJUSTING TO A NEW ENVIRONMENT
+going abroad for a semester or the duration of one’s studies is exciting. at times,
+however, the confrontation with a foreign culture can be challenging. Studying
+abroad is a learning experience in every sense of the word. besides your scholastic
+learning in college courses, you will get to know the american culture and how
+people around you view their world and their lives. by experiencing and understand-
+ing a different way of life, you will also learn about things in your own culture you
+have never thought of before. this is your chance to broaden your view and reflect
+on and mature your own values. the process of learning about a new culture and
+finding your own place in the new environment can be confusing and tiring. the
+best way to deal with a new situation and find out about something you don’t under-
+stand is to ask questions.
+
+Culture Shock and Adjustment
+Culture shock is a normal phenomenon on your way to adjusting to a new environ-
+ment. For some people, the encounter with a new culture can be shocking, indeed,
+but for most people culture shock is not as sudden and dramatic as you might expect.
+When the excitement about being in a foreign country wears off, cultural differences
+can become overwhelming. You might think your language skills are inadequate; you
+might be struggling with course work; you might be troubled by unfamiliar food; you
+might have difficulties interpreting other people’s behavior; you might be offended
+by the way people act or dress or by their body language. there are a variety of
+symptoms of culture shock. Some people feel tired and nervous; some are frustrated
-ArcGIS Online
-
-Customer managed
+7
-ArcGIS Enterprise
+with or even hostile toward the american culture; some get angry and irritated very
+easily; some isolate themselves or socialize only with other international students and
+people who speak their language. You might also feel very homesick and question
+why you decided to go abroad in the first place. a way to prepare yourself to deal with
+culture shock is to clarify for yourself why you want to study abroad. Knowing your
+personal expectations and goals will help you overcome periods of doubt.
-ArcGIS Enterprise
+THINGS TO DO
+• Chose a non-credit or half-credit class like tennis, scuba diving, or basic sailing.
+• Join some of the many student clubs on campus (http://www.hws.edu/studentlife/
-Although on-premises data center technology is not necessarily on the verge of extinction, cloud
-computing is an option with many benefits, including scalability, agility, and cost efficiency.
-During the COVID-19 pandemic, cloud usage increased rapidly because people use the cloud
-platforms to work and shop from home. Today, more organizations are adopting ArcGIS Online
-or deploying their ArcGIS Enterprise to the cloud, such as AWS, Microsoft Azure, Google
-Cloud, and others (see figure). Many organizations adopt a hybrid model by integrating ArcGIS
-Online and ArcGIS Enterprise.
+campuslife/sll/clubs).
-ArcGIS Online and ArcGIS Enterprise benefit from an effective framework to enforce security
-and protect user privacy. They are certified as compliant with many federal and international
-security and privacy standards. For more information, see the ArcGIS Trust Center page at
-doc .arcgis .com/en/trust/compliance/compliance-tab-intro .htm.
+• You like to be active? Visit the sport and recreation facilities and take a yoga class,
+borrow a racquet and play tennis or racquetball. You can also try out for intramu-
+ral sports.
-Built on ArcGIS Online, the Johns Hopkins COVID-19 Dashboard, a real-time pandemic tracker, has become
-a global reference for the pandemic and one of the most cited resources to track the spread of coronavirus
-around the world. It has received billions of views and remained highly efficient under a massive amount of
-web traffic.
+• get involved in the religious life on campus! there are services and meditation as
+well as bible study sessions, ecumenical candlelight prayers, Sabbath dinners and
+a lot more.
-Copyright © 2022 Esri. All rights reserved.
+• Participate in ongoing events – take in a movie on Fridays at Friday Flix, visit the
+Cellar Pub in the basement of Coxe Hall and see what is happening (comedians,
+bands, etc.), show school spirit by supporting one of many sporting events hap-
+pening on campus.
-6
+• are you interested in current events? Political and social developments? the
+Fisher Center lecture Series, the President’s Forum and the President’s radio
+Show are a few venues through which you can satisfy this interest.
-Chapter 1: Get started with Web GIS
+• travel the area! intercultural affairs (iC) and the Center for global education
-New-generation Web GIS architecture and trends
+(Cge) will occasionally offer trips to see the area, oraP (outdoor recreational
+activities Program) organizes hiking, rock climbing and rafting trips (among
+others), and you can always get a group of friends together and go somewhere on
+your own.
-ArcGIS Online and ArcGIS Enterprise represent the new generation of Web GIS. Although the
-two have some differences (see chapter 5), they generally share similar architecture, similar capa-
-bilities, and similar workflows for creating content, as shown in this figure.
+• offer your help in the language departments. maybe someone needs a Spanish
-Desktop
+tutor or a teaching assistant for mandarin?
-Web
+• discover geneva. Volunteer. to find out how visit the Public Service office in
-Device
+trinity (2nd floor) (or call x3825).
-ArcGIS Online
+• do you like to dance? or watch others dance? the dance department is big on
+campus and the students as well as the faculty put on dance shows! ask about
+Koshare or join one of the dance teams.
-Portal for
-ArcGIS
+• Check the daily Update! there is always something going on – just show up and
-Server
+try it out!
-Web services
+8
+P
+H
+O
+N
+E
+N
+U
+M
+B
+E
+R
+S
+&
+O
+F
+F
+I
C
-
-l
-i
-
-e
-n
-t
-
-a
-p
-p
-s
-
-A
-c
-c
-e
-s
-s
-
+E
S
-e
-r
-v
-i
-c
-e
-s
-
-ArcGIS is a new-generation Web GIS that provides mapping, analysis, data management, and collaboration.
-
-This new-generation Web GIS architecture is described as follows:
-
-• At the center of the new Web GIS architecture is a portal—ArcGIS Online or Portal for
-
-ArcGIS—which represents a gateway for accessing all spatial products in an organization.
-The portal helps organize, secure, and facilitate access to geographic information products.
-• On the back end, the portal is powered by two components: GIS servers that allow you to
-create content and ready-to-use content such as ArcGIS Living Atlas of the World, which
-provides tens of thousands of data layers and maps.
-
-• On the client side, users can search, discover, and use the layers, maps, and apps on desktops,
-
-in web browsers, and on mobile devices anywhere, anytime.
-Technology evolution and trends in Web GIS
-Since its inception, Web GIS has coevolved with geographic science and information technology
-(see figure). This evolution and these trends are discussed in greater detail in later chapters.
-
-Copyright © 2022 Esri. All rights reserved.
-New-generation Web GIS architecture and trends
-
-7
-
-Web GIS has coevolved with geographic information science and information technology.
-
-Web GIS has exemplified the following evolution of stages and trends in technologies:
-
-• From closed websites to open geospatial web services. Early Web GIS apps were developed
-as independent websites. These websites were isolated from one another. It was difficult to
-share information and functions between them and difficult to remix the content to create
-apps. In the later 1990s, web services technology was conceived. Web services can be thought
-of as building blocks that can be shared and remixed in versatile ways for building web apps.
-The GIS industry adopted the concept of web services in manufacturing Web GIS products.
-For example, ArcGIS Web GIS products fully support the web services architecture. The
-server side provides ready-to-use services and allows users to create their own services,
-whereas the client side can consume and combine these services to create apps.
-
-• From one-way to two-way information flow. Early Web GIS products and applications
-
-mainly supported one-way information flow, which was from server side to client side. Users
-were merely the receivers of information. As we entered the 21st century, user-generated
-content (UGC) became a significant phenomenon and created a reversed information flow,
-from client side to server side. Volunteered geographic information (VGI) is the UGC of a
-geospatial nature. For example, ArcGIS facilitates VGI through editable layers, Mobile GIS
-apps, and browser-based apps. Users can view maps and perform queries, as well as conduct
-field surveys, collect data, and report events they see.
-
-Copyright © 2022 Esri. All rights reserved.8
-
-Chapter 1: Get started with Web GIS
-
-• Portal technology is becoming essential. The word portal means gate or entrance. It was
-adopted in the mid-1990s to form new terms such as web portal, referring to a website
-that serves as the gateway to other websites or web resources. Geoportals are gateways to
-geospatial information. Portals have become a core component of Web GIS technology. For
-example, ArcGIS Online and Portal for ArcGIS have geoportal capabilities. They facilitate
-the management, search, discovery, configuration, security, and remix of GIS data layers and
-services. Today, portal collaboration allows different organizations to replicate selected con-
-tent as hosts and guests, creating a portal of portals — a distributed Web GIS pattern. ArcGIS
-Hub℠ and ArcGIS Enterprise Sites are examples of subject- or initiative-based portals. They
-provide an easy-to-configure community engagement platform that organizes people, data,
-and tools through information-driven initiatives. Organizations can create websites to share
-data, documents, videos, and web maps on a certain subject or for a certain initiative. For
-instance, the COVID-19 GIS Hub (coronavirus-resources .esri .com) provides GIS resources,
-solutions, and a collaboration platform for the world to combat the coronavirus pandemic.
-• Cloud GIS delivers GIS functionality and ready-to-use contents. Cloud GIS, which uses
-public and private cloud computing to provide GIS software and contents, has become the
-primary way to deliver GIS — not just functionality but also content. Cloud GIS advantages
-include vast content and functionality, the flexibility of pay-as-you-go or subscription pric-
-ing, reduced complexity, and increased availability of services. Because of these advantages,
-cloud GIS, such as ArcGIS Online, has penetrated organizations that have not used GIS
-before or been able to afford GIS on their own.
-
-• Mobile is becoming the pervasive Web GIS client platform. In the post-PC era, mobile
-
-devices have surpassed desktops and notebooks as the primary platform for accessing online
-information. Mobile devices are a part of everyone’s life and work. “Mobile first” is a strategy
-of many industries, including the Web GIS industry. Vendors have given extra attention to
-Mobile GIS. For example, Esri provides numerous mobile-native apps and mobile-friendly
-browser apps to support the needs of users and organizations for Mobile GIS. Mobile GIS
-is also associated with many frontiers in Web GIS, such as augmented reality (AR). AR can
-superimpose GIS data on top of a user’s camera views and thus augment a user’s sense of
-reality. With the rapid advances in Mobile GIS, the vision of using GIS for anything, any-
-time, anywhere, and by anyone is being realized faster than we can imagine.
-
-• Map visualization goes from 2D to 3D and virtual reality. With the increased client-side
-graphics processing power and the broader support of WebGL (a JavaScript application pro-
-gramming interface [API] that renders interactive 2D and 3D graphics in a browser), Web
-GIS products such as ArcGIS Online and ArcGIS Enterprise can smoothly create and display
-
-Copyright © 2022 Esri. All rights reserved.New-generation Web GIS architecture and trends
+ Extension
+
+IMPORTANT PHONE NUMBERS
+Office
+business office
+Center for global education
+Center for teaching and learning
+Counseling Center
+deans: Hobart
+deans: William Smith
+Financial aid
+Hubbs Health Center
+information technology
+intercultural affairs
+registrar
+residential education
+Security
+emergency
+Student accounts
+
+3655
+3307
+3351
+3388
+3300
+3467
+3315
+3600
+4357 (HelP)
+3319
+3651
+3900
+3656
+3333
+3386
+
+OFFICE LOCATIONS
+admissions
+alcohol and other drug Programs
+alumni House
+athletics (WS)
+buildings and grounds
+business office
+Career Services
+Center for global education
+Ctl
+Chapel
+College Store
+Communications office
+deans: Hobart
+deans: William Smith
+dining Services
+
+Financial aid
+Hubbs Health/Counseling Center
+information technology
+intercultural affairs
+President
+Provost’s office
+Public Service office
+registrar
+residential education
+Security
+Student accounts
+Student life and leadership
+WeoS radio Station
+
+bradford House
+Smith Hall
+615 South main
+Winn-Seeley
+medbery Parking lot
+demarest (basement)
+trinity (1st Floor)
+trinity (3rd Floor)
+Harris House (678 S. main St.)
+St. John’s Chapel (near 630 S. main St.)
+51 Saint Clair Street, Sherrill Hall
+durfee House (639 S. main St.)
+Smith Hall (1st Floor)
+Smith Hall (1st Floor)
+Scandling Center Café, Saga,
+Cellar Pub, de Cordova Café
+demarest (basement)
+119 St. Clair St.
+Williams Hall
+288 Pulteney St.
+Coxe Hall (2nd Floor)
+Coxe Hall (2nd Floor)
+trinity (3rd Floor)
+gulick (1st Floor)
+101 St. Clair St.
+medbery Parking lot
+demarest (basement)
+Scandling Center (2nd Floor)
+113 Hamilton St.
9
-thematic and photo-realistic 3D web scenes. Representing a big step from 2D online maps,
-3D web scenes provide users a more intuitive means to understand their data. Web scenes
-are also important for indoor mapping, an ongoing trend in GIS. Even more intuitive than
-3D, virtual reality (VR) allows users with certain visual wearables to immerse themselves in
-3D city models by transporting themselves into static viewpoints and comparing different
-urban design scenarios. This immersive experience brings GIS data and geospatial under-
-standing even closer to users. The GIS community can play an important role in building the
-metaverse and can assist with getting real work done in the virtual world environment. The
-term metaverse refers to the fully immersive 3D expansion of existing internet technologies
-to include AR and VR.
-
-• Data source goes from static to real time and spatiotemporal big data. Many elements in
-
-Web GIS are of a real-time nature, such as the incidents immediately reported by field crews,
-citizens using mobile devices, concurrent measurements from sensor networks, and smart
-cities. This massive amount of data presents challenges in real-time intake, processing, analy-
-sis, visualization, and storage. ArcGIS GeoEvent™ Server and ArcGIS Velocity use cluster
-computing and can ingest millions of sensor readings per second, process them, and store
-them in real time. Such products and research allow Web GIS to meet the requirements of
-the sensor web and the Internet of Things (IoT).
-
-• Web GIS is becoming more intelligent. Map visualization is the first step toward data
-analysis. ArcGIS smart mapping can analyze the data automatically and suggest the best
-mapping style and best defaults. This can help both expert and novice users quickly create
-aesthetic and informative maps. Web GIS goes far beyond mapping. Web GIS can perform
-big data analysis using distributed computing, aggregate data in the context of both space
-and time, extrapolate new ideas from raw data, and bring superior intelligence to business
-decisions. More recently, Web GIS has started to use artificial intelligence (AI), especially
-machine learning and deep learning. For example, AI significantly improves the accuracy of
-online imagery classification. AI can quickly identify the damaged locations from millions of
-facilities’ photos and ensure that the damaged facilities are repaired early.
-
-Copyright © 2022 Esri. All rights reserved.10
-
-Chapter 1: Get started with Web GIS
-
-Web GIS information model: Users, web layers, maps, and
-
-apps
-
-Web GIS elements include users, groups, content items, and metadata (see figure).
-
-• Users with necessary privileges can create and join groups.
-• Users sign in to create and share content items (with certain privileges), which include a
-
-large variety of data, web layers, tools, web maps, web scenes, and web apps.
-
-• Content items have metadata, including title, summary, description, categories, and tags, and
-additional standards-based metadata. Metadata is indexed so users can search and discover
-items more efficiently.
-
-• Users can keep information to themselves, share with certain groups (rather than individual
-users), share with their organizations, or share with everyone — even the public if the organi-
-zation allows anonymous access. This allows other users to see and access the items.
-
-own or join
-
-Users
-
-o
-w
-n
-
-organize and secure
-
-Groups
-
-x
-e
-d
-n
-
-i
-
-index
-
-Items
-
-Metadata
-
-The ArcGIS Online and Portal for ArcGIS high-level information model.
-
-Main types of content items
-Web GIS has five main types of content: data, layers, tools, web maps and scenes, and apps. Data
-can be used to publish web layers; web layers can be used to create web maps and web scenes;
-web maps and scenes and web tools can be used in apps or to create apps, as shown in the figure.
+BANKS AND MOVIE THEATERS IN GENEVA
+
+Community Bank
+5 Seneca St.
+geneva, nY 14456
+Phone: (315) 789-7700
+Website: www.communitybankna.com
+
+First Niagara Bank
+811 Canandaigua road
+geneva, nY 14456
+Phone: (315) 789-1049
+Fax: (315) 789-6009
+Website: www.firstniagarabank.com
+
+BANKS
+Five-Star Bank
+P.o. box 193
+geneva, nY 14456
+Phone: (315) 789-2300
+Fax: (315) 787-3263
+Website: www.five-starbank.com
+
+Seneca Falls Savings Bank
+342 Hamilton St.
+geneva, nY 14456
+Phone: 315-789-8100
+Website: www.seneca24.net/
+
+MOVIE THEATERS
+Geneva Movieplex 8
+t & C Plaza, Hamilton St.
+geneva, nY, 14456
+Phone: (315) 789-4524
+Web: www.cinemanorth.com
+
+PLACES TO STAY
+Note: the Colleges provide this list as a service to all who might visit our area, but
+do not endorse any local hotel, motel, inn or bed and breakfast.
+
+the following are a handful of accommodations that are available in and around
+geneva, no more than 30 minutes from campus. lodging is also available in ithaca,
+rochester and Syracuse, which are each approximately one hour from Hobart and
+William Smith. You can find out more about accommodations outside the greater
+geneva area by visiting the geneva Chamber of Commerce or ontario County
+tourism bureau websites.
+
+Holiday inn, Waterloo
+(315) 539-5011 or (800) HolidaY
+
+Hampton inn
+(315) 781-2037
+
+ramada inn, geneva, lakefront
+(315) 789-0400
+
+belhurst Castle/White Spring manor,
+geneva
+(315) 781-0201
+
+microtel inn & Suites, Seneca Falls
+(315) 539-8438
+
+geneva-on-the-lake, geneva
+(315) 789-7190 or (800) 3-geneVa
+
+motel 6, Hamilton Street, geneva
+(315) 789-4050 or (800) 466-8356
+
+10
+
+G
+E
+N
+E
+V
+A
-Copyright © 2022 Esri. All rights reserved.Web GIS information model: Users, web layers, maps, and apps
+,
+
+N
+E
+W
+Y
+O
+R
+K
+
+PLACES TO EAT
+*Please note that some restaurants are closed on Mondays or Tuesdays,
+so call ahead.
+
+The area code for all numbers listed below is (315).
+
+American/Continental
+abigail’s restaurant, routes 5 & 20, Seneca Falls, 539-9300
+belhurst Castle, lochland road, route 14, 781-0201
+the Crow’s nest, 415 boody’s Hill road, 781-0600
+emile’s restaurant, east north Street and routes 5 & 20, 789-2775
+geneva-on-the-lake, 1001 lochland road, 789-7190
+madderlake Café, West lake road, 781-2424
+the red brick inn, 291 main St., 789-3247
+
+Diners/Grilles
+Flour Petal Café, 34 linden St., 781-2233
+Parkers’ grille & tap House, 100 Seneca St., 789-4656
+Ports Cone & grill, 4432 W. lake road, 789-2020
+Water Street Café, 467 exchange St., 789-2560
+the Captain’s room, 372 exchange St., 781-0122
+dana’s time out, 258 Hamilton St., 781-2107
+
+Italian-American and Pizza
+nonna Cosentino’s trattoria, 1 railroad Place, 789-1638
+Uncle Joe’s Pizzeria, 99 n. genesee Street, 781-1199
+
+International
+ling ling, 481 Hamilton Street, 781-0668
+main moon, 480 exchange Street, 781-5106
+Wing tai oriental restaurant, 164 Castle Street, 789-8892
+garcia’s mexican restaurant, 313 Hamilton Street, 789-5760
+
+Fast Food/Family Chains
+routes 5 & 20 west of downtown geneva (Hamilton Street) offers an array of popu-
+lar fast food and family chains, including Quiznos, tim Horton’s, Club 86 bagels
+and Cakes, Friendly’s, KFC-taco bell, mcdonald’s, long John Silver’s, Pizza Hut,
+Subway, Waffle Works and Wendy’s.
11
-Tools
-
-configured
-and used in
-
-published to
-
-added to
-
-Web, mobile,
-and desktop apps
-
-Data
-
-Web layers
+FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS (FAQs)
+
+Do you require the TOEFL for international students?
+Yes, we do require the toeFl (test of english as a Foreign language). We offer limited
+english language support on campus, and require that students have a solid foundation
+in english prior to admission. the minimum required computer based toeFl score is
+220. the Colleges also will accept the aPiel examination in lieu of the toeFl.
+
+Do you offer financial assistance for international students?
+need-based scholarships are available to international students. the cost of attend-
+ing college here for the 2007-2008 academic year is U.S. $45,968. the average aid
+package typically equals more than half the annual cost of tuition, room and board.
+Highly competitive applicants will be considered for a full-tuition scholarship. the
+financial aid application forms are included in the application for admissions.
+
+How many international students do you currently have on campus?
+We have 32 full-time matriculated students in a degree program Fall 2006
+Semester. the following countries are represented: austria, bulgaria, Canada,
+China, Colombia, Czech republic, germany, india, nepal, Pakistan, South Korea,
+Sweden, turkey, Ukraine, United Kingdom and Vietnam.
+
+Do you have an international student adviser?
+Yes, the student adviser is responsible for working with our international students
+on campus to help them make the transition from home to the Colleges. We offer an
+international student orientation prior to the first-year and transfer student orienta-
+tion at the beginning of the academic year, and the beginning of the spring semester
+for new arrivals. a variety of activities and programs are available throughout the
+year. Student advising and counseling is available in a variety of other areas on cam-
+pus, including faculty advisers, Hubbs Health Center, and the Center for teaching
+and learning. We make every effort to work individually with each student to help
+them reach their potential and make the most of the opportunities available here.
+
+Do you have an international student organization?
+Yes. the international Student association (iSa) is a student organization that cel-
+ebrates the diverse cultures found around the globe. other cultural clubs with interna-
+tional perspectives represented on campus include asian Student association (aSU),
+latin american organization (lao), Caribbean Student association (CSa), and
+dia al-din: muslim Student association.
+
+Do you have E.S.L. services?
+Yes, an entry level course is offered, as are workshops and one-to-one tutoring. How-
+ever, the Colleges do not offer a full e.S.l. curriculum.
+
+What kinds of housing are available?
+Within the Hobart and William Smith community are dozens of smaller communi-
+ties--those of the individual residences. the range of housing options is extensive,
+
+12
+
+with coed or single-sex college residences, cooperative houses, theme houses, and
+town houses among the choices you’ll find over your four years here. residence
+halls offer a variety of configurations, with traditional singles and doubles as well as
+suites. Some recent theme houses have included Jewish Culture House, multicul-
+tural Sisterhood House, Writers House, and international awareness House. the
+ten cooperative houses provide an alternative to standard residence-hall living, with
+residents sharing responsibility for food and housecleaning arrangements.
+
+Is it possible to work on campus?
+You are eligible to work up to 20 hours a week on campus, if your visa status permits
+it. However, the demand for such employment exceeds the number of jobs available.
+therefore, you cannot use on-campus employment as a resource for the issuance of
+the i-20 form.
+
+STORAGE AND TRANSPORTATION OF SCHOOL YEAR ITEMS
+Special consideration will be given to those international students who need storage
+on campus during the school breaks. international students must attend a manda-
+tory meeting in September regarding storage and transportation of school year items.
+attendance will be taken at this meeting. Students unable to attend this meeting
+must take the initiative to set up a meeting with the international Student adviser
+before oct. 1.
+
+the storage and transportation meeting in September will encompass the following
+information:
+a. date and time of transportation to and from storage areas
+
+- Winter break (december)
+- Summer break (may)
+b. location of storage areas
+c. How to pack and maximum number of storage items allowed
+each student will be allowed no more than 8 items. items must be labeled with
+students name, return date and number of items. boxes must be secured properly
+and must be easily manageable. large items such as refrigerators, sofas, etc. will not
+be accommodated due to limited space.
+d. transportation requirements: items are to be placed at curbside 15 minutes
+before van arrives for pick up.
+e. Cost of transportation = $20 per student (gas and labor cost)
+f. information on surcharges: the student’s account will be charged a surcharge for
+each infraction:
+
+- No shows = $50
+- Fail to have items at curbside = $20
+- Not packed = $20
+- Change of time and/or date without 24 hour notice to Intercultural Affairs
+ Office = $40
+
+Please Note: Storage space is limited, therefore there is no guarantee that you
+will get storage or transportation support.
-Web maps
-and scenes
-
-The main types of content in Web GIS and their relationships.
-
-These five main content types are described as follows:
-
-• Data: ArcGIS Online supports data in a variety of formats, including CSV, shapefiles, GPS
-
-Exchange Format (GPX), JavaScript Object Notation (GeoJSON), photos, imagery, geodata-
-bases, and so on.
-
-• Layers: The Esri geospatial cloud can host layers, including feature layers, tiled layers, vector
-tiles, map image layers, image layers, scene layers, CSV layers, tables, and Open Geospatial
-Consortium (OGC) standard layers such as Keyhole Markup Language (KML), Web Map
-Service (WMS), Web Map Tile Service (WMTS), and Web Feature Service (WFS).
-
-• Web maps and scenes: A web map, which is 2D, or a scene, which is 3D, comprises one or
-
-multiple layers and allows sophisticated layer configuration, including styles, pop-ups, labels,
-and access permission.
-
-• Tools: Tools perform analytical functions, such as geocoding, routing, generating PDF files,
-
-summarizing data, finding hot spots, and analyzing proximity.
-
-• Apps: GIS apps are lightweight mapcentric programs that can be used on mobile devices,
-in web browsers, or on desktops. Developers can program with ArcGIS web APIs to build
-web apps. However, you do not have to be a developer to create a web app. ArcGIS provides
-many ready-to-use web apps and mobile apps that can be used without programming.
+13
-Apps: The face of Web GIS
-Apps bring Web GIS to life. Web GIS end users directly interact with apps. The back-end data,
-web layers, and server computation power of Web GIS become live and useful through apps.
-ArcGIS provides ready-to-use apps out of the box and provides APIs and software development
-kits (SDKs) for developers to create custom apps.
+IN CASE OF AN EMERGENCY
+if you should have a need to contact the international Student adviser while travel-
+ing outside of the United States please call (315) 781-3656 and ask for extension
+3319. You can also contact the office directly by calling (315) 781-3319.
+
+In an emergency, they can be reached at (315) 781-3333.
+
+remember that the international Student adviser, while a resource to you, is not
+your only resource during your time at the Colleges. While on campus, your respec-
+tive deans will be available to assist you with a variety of issues, and should always
+be kept aware of important matters.
+
+WHAT TO EXPECT DURING SCHOOL BREAKS
+Since not everyone is able to return home during school breaks, international
+students are allowed to remain on campus during those times. at specific times
+during the fall and spring, you will receive e-mails from the residential education
+office asking about their plans during the upcoming break. Your immediate response
+is necessary as it is the only way to ensure that you will get permission to remain in
+your room or elsewhere on the campus during school breaks.
+
+Students are not allowed to remain in their rooms during fall, winter and spring
+
+breaks. during summer vacation, students who remain on campus must move into
+temporary housing. once again, an e-mail from the residential education office
+is the first step in determining where students will be staying during the summer.
+Currently, international students are allowed to stay on campus during the summer
+holiday free of charge (subject to change).
+
+the dining hall is not open to students during the summer months so students
+will need to provide their own meals. most summer housing will feature a kitchen,
+but in the event that one doesn’t, appropriate accommodations will be made for
+those students who wish to prepare their own meals.
+
+the international student adviser must also know your plans and should also be
+
+notified if you will or will not be staying on campus.
+
+US Holidays/Observances
+January 1
+January 15
+3rd monday in February
+2nd Sunday in may
+4th monday in may
+3rd Sunday in June
+July 4th
+1st monday in September
+october 31
+november 11
+4th thursday in november
+december 4
+december 25
+december 26
+
+14
+
+new Year’s day
+martin luther King Jr. day
+Presidents day
+mother’s day
+memorial day
+Father’s day
+independence day
+labor day
+Halloween
+Veterans day
+thanksgiving
+Hanukkah begins
+Christmas day
+Kwanzaa
+
+SECTION II:
+IMMIGRATION PROCEDURES
+
+HOW TO GET ASSISTANCE WITH IMMIGRATION MATTERS
+
+the international Student adviser is available to help you process your immigration
+forms and documents. Working with the department of Homeland Security can be
+very complicated, detailed, and time-consuming. it is important that you do not rely
+on information obtained from friends and other students because circumstances may
+vary from one student to another and the regulations can and do change.
+ the international Student adviser must work within the federal immigration
+laws. When making a request, please make sure that you allow plenty of time for
+your request to be processed and plan to be patient. Have your documents, such as
+your passport, i-94 card, i-20 or dS-2019 with you when you go to the international
+student office for immigration assistance.
+
+Important: You should allow at least one week for processing signatures, letters
+and/or other types of paperwork. Special consideration will be given for emergency
+situations.
+
+Reminder: the international Student adviser cannot remember when each
+student’s documents expire. it is YOUR responsibility to keep track of all immigra-
+tion documents and keep them current.
+
+Hristo Dimitrov ’09 (Bulguria), and Ayokunle Abogan ’06 (Nigeria)
-Copyright © 2022 Esri. All rights reserved.12
+15
-Chapter 1: Get started with Web GIS
+IMMIGRATION BASICS AND DEFINITION OF TERMS
+
+as with all countries, the United States has laws and regulations governing foreign-
+ers who are temporarily within its borders. the immigration regulations are adminis-
+tered by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS).
+
+immigration regulations can change frequently and are difficult to interpret. it
+is important for international students to understand the rules as they apply to stu-
+dent status. The DHS does not consider ignorance of the law a legitimate reason
+for failing to obey it.
+ Questions should be directed to the international Student adviser, who will be
+able to assist with legal regulations and can sign your immigration documents.
+
+dHS requires that a copy of your passport, i-94 and other immigration docu-
+ments be kept on file by the international Student adviser, as well as your local
+address and telephone number.
+
+Passport
+be sure to keep your passport in a safe place. it is your most important document.
+most passports are good for a limited period of time. Your passport must be valid at
+all times while you are in the United States.
+
+the expiration date of your passport should be six months beyond the date you
+
+enter the U.S. if your passport expiration date is close to the date you will begin
+classes, obtain a new passport before leaving home.
+
+it is your responsibility to remember when your passport will expire and to con-
+tact the nearest consulate or embassy for your country. to find the nearest consulate
+or U.S. embassy check http://usembassy.state.gov.
+
+Your passport can only be extended by your government and it usually takes
+several weeks for a passport to be renewed, so be sure to allow enough time. You may
+extend your passport in the U.S. at your home country’s embassy or consulate. You
+are in this country illegally if your passport expires and are subject to deportation.
+
+Visas
+the visa stamped in your passport at the U.S. embassy or Consulate is for permis-
+sion to enter the United States for a specific purpose and period of time. Students
+are usually given an F-1 visa. J-1 visas are given to researchers, scholars and students
+who are sponsored by agencies or universities.
+
+Since the visa stamp is only important for entry and re-entry to the United
+States, there is no need to worry if it expires while you are here if you are maintain-
+ing your student status. because a visa is only a permit to apply for entry into a coun-
+try, it is not possible to obtain a U.S. visa while you are in the U.S. to apply for a
+visa, you must go to a U.S. consulate or embassy in a country other than the United
+States, usually your home country.
+
+I-94 (Arrival/Departure Record)
+Form i-94, also called the arrival/departure record of Stay Permit, is the small white
+card given to you at the port of entry to the U.S. this form is very important since it
+officially determines how long an international student can remain in the U.S.
+
+16
+
+Students on the F-1 and J-1 visas usually have their i-94 stamped “d/S” (dura-
+
+tion of Status), which means that the student can remain in this country for the
+length of time required to complete his/her studies as long as the student follows all
+of the regulations of the student visa. the eleven-digit number written on your i-94
+is your dHS admission number, which is used by the dHS to monitor entry into and
+departure from the U.S. The I-94 cards are turned in when leaving the U.S. and a
+new I-94 is completed with each subsequent entry.
+
+if you are on a visa other than a F or J, or if you have a specific date stamped on
+
+your i-94 card instead of the “d/S” designation, you must apply for an extension, a
+Change of Status, or exit the U.S before the expiration date or you will be consid-
+ered out of status and a visa overstay, which can have serious dHS consequences.
+
+SEVIS
+an acronym for Student and exchange Visitor information System (SeViS). it is a
+data collection and monitoring system that creates an interface between institutions
+of higher education, the department of Homeland Security (dHS), consulates and
+embassies abroad, and ports of entry. Schools are required to make regular electronic
+updates in SeViS throughout each semester on the records of their enrolled students
+in F-1 and J-1 status and their dependents and their researchers and faculty on J-1
+status. this includes, but is not limited to enrollment status, changes in address,
+changes in level of study, employment recommendations and school transfers.
+
+Form I-20
+When Hobart and William Smith Colleges accepts an international student for
+full-time study, the student is sent a Form i-20 a-b as proof of acceptance and to
+use when applying for an F-1 Student Visa at a U.S. Consulate abroad. the student
+presents the i-20 with their passport and visa at the Port of entry and the i-20 is
+stamped and given back to the student. this is your Certificate of eligibility, and
+it must be signed by a dSo/ international Student adviser before you leave the
+United States. Students should keep copies of all i-20 issued to them.
+
+Immigration Status
+this is often confused with “visa” but your immigration status, e.g., F-1, J-1, etc. is
+determined at the time of your entry into the U.S. by an immigration official and is
+noted on the Form i-94. You may have many visa stamps in your passport but, upon
+entry into the U.S., an immigration inspector will admit you in only one immigra-
+tion status which is noted on the i-94 card.
+
+OBTAINING A VISA AND FORM I-20
+Your passport should be valid at least six months beyond the date of entering the U.S.
+as a student. be sure to check your passport expiration date. if it will expire close to
+when you will begin classes, obtain a new passport before applying for your visa.
+
+How to Obtain a Visa
+although U.S. embassies will not issue a student visa prior to 120 days before the
+start date on the i-20 (or dS-2019 for J’s), you can schedule an appointment prior
+
+17
+
+to the 120-day period. Since processing times have become longer due to increased
+security clearances, students should check with their local U.S. embassy or consulate
+to learn the estimated waiting time and allow plenty of time to obtain the visa. a
+list of consulates and embassies can be found at http://usembassy.state.gov/.
+
+You will need to pay a $100 SeViS fee at least 3 business days before your visa
+interview. the fee can be paid online or by mail. For complete directions, see http://
+www.fmJfee.com.
+ Unless you are a sponsored J-1 student or already in another visa category, the
+Colleges’ office of admissions will send you a Form i-20 when you are admitted and
+have submitted proof of your ability to finance your education. take the i-20 form,
+your acceptance letter, passport, copies of sponsorship letters and bank statements
+to prove financial support, and a receipt for your SeViS fee payment to the United
+States embassy or consulate nearest your home. once you have acquired the visa
+stamp in your passport, you are ready to enter the U.S.
+
+Note: Students may not enter the U.S. more than 30 days prior to the start date
+on their I-20.
+
+Canadian and some British Commonwealth citizens do not need visas to enter
+the U.S., but they must request F-1 status and present their i-20 forms for process-
+ing at the point of entry even if the official does not ask for it. they should also be
+prepared to show evidence of financial support and proof of citizenship. Without a
+stamped i-20 and an i-94 card with the F-1 or J-1 designation on it, you are con-
+sidered a tourist in the United States and will not be legally able to study and take
+advantage of the special privileges allowed those in Student Status until he or she
+has been in an immigration status appropriate for studying for at least nine consecu-
+tive months.
+
+Note: If you will not be entering the U.S. on an F-1 visa, do not use an I-20 form
+to obtain a visa. If you received an I-20, please return it to the Office of Admis-
+sions with an explanation of the type of visa you hold.
+
+if your visa document (i-20 or dS-2019) does not arrive in time for you to secure
+the proper visa, do not enter the United States on a B1/B2 Visitor Visa. obtain a
+b-2 “prospective student” or “prospective exchange visitor” visa from a U.S. embassy
+or consulate post in your country. be certain the consul writes “Prospective Student”
+or “Prospective exchange Visitor” (for J-1) in your passport on the visa page. You
+will need to present your letter of acceptance and evidence of financial support to
+request this visa.
+
+in general, it is best to avoid using the b-2 visa since you will have to pay a fee
+and do a time-consuming change of status through dHS (department of Homeland
+Security) after you arrive. You may not begin your studies until the change is com-
+pleted, so this could also delay the start of your studies until a subsequent term.
+
+Note: Students must attend the school named on the I-20 or DS-2019 presented at
+the port of entry in order to be in status. Also, do not enter the U.S. on a “W-T”
+
+18
+
+(waiver) as this classification cannot be extended or changed and you will lose your
+legal immigration status as a student.
+
+Students Transferring From another Colleges in the United States
+if you are an F-1 student transferring from a U.S. institution and will not be leav-
+ing the country prior to enrollment at Hobart and William Smith Colleges, follow
+the procedures required by dHS. bring your completed i-20 to the international
+Student adviser’s office as soon as possible after your arrival on campus. Sign the
+document and leave it to be processed by a dSo/ international Student adviser
+who will notify you when you may pick it up.
+
+if you leave the U.S. before beginning your studies at Hobart and William
+Smith Colleges, use the new i-20 issued by the Colleges when you arrive at the port
+of entry. Keep the i-20 from your old school with your immigration records, but do
+not use it to enter the U.S. it is not necessary for transfer students with an unex-
+pired student visa and who have maintained their status to obtain a new visa, even
+though the former school’s name is listed.
+
+Transfer to another School
+to be eligible to transfer schools, you must be pursuing a full-course of study at your
+current school. otherwise you are “out of status” and must apply to dHS for rein-
+statement to student status, which, if granted, will allow you to transfer.
+
+Students transferring to another school must notify the dSo/international
+Student adviser of their intent to transfer. Hobart and William Smith Colleges
+must release your SeViS record to the new school before a new i-20 can be issued
+for the transfer. Upon arrival at the new school, the student should take the new
+i-20 to the international Student adviser at the new school. J-1 students wishing to
+transfer should consult with their sponsor.
+
+Changing Your Academic Level
+if you are currently a student at Hobart and William Smith Colleges, and will be
+continuing your studies in an additional program of study (such as a mat Program),
+you should follow the transfer procedure. a new i-20 will be issued for the new pro-
+gram, and you will use the new i-20 to enter the country. if you do not leave, bring
+it to the international Student adviser as described in the transfer process in the
+preceding paragraph. Failure to complete this “internal transfer” will cause you to
+be out of status with dHS, which can adversely affect work authorizations or other
+student privileges.
+
+DIFFERENCES BETWEEN F-1 AND J-1 STATUS
+there are two types of entry visa issued to nonimmigrant students who intend to
+study full-time at Hobart and William Smith Colleges—the F-1 student visa and the
+J-1 exchange visitor visa.
+
+• Source of Funding: J-1 exchange visitor visa status is available to those students
+who are supported substantially by funding other than personal or family funds.
+Such funding may include that which comes from the U.S. government or the
+
+19
+
+student’s home government, or an international organization, or the Colleges. Stu-
+dents who are supported by personal or family funds are ineligible for J-1 immigra-
+tion status and must come to the U.S. to study in F-1 immigration status.
+
+• Foreign Residence Requirement: Students in J-1 immigration status and the J-2
+dependents may be subject to a “foreign residence requirement.” J-1 students who
+receive direct or indirect U.S. or home government funding, or who are studying
+in fields for which personnel are considered in short supply in their home coun-
+tries (most developing nations have “Country Skills” lists of varying lengths), are
+ineligible to apply for a change to another non-immigrant status (except a or g)
+or permanent residency in the U.S. until they have satisfied the “two year home
+country physical presence requirement. only those in J-1 status with government
+funding or whose skills are on Country Skills list are subject to the foreign resi-
+dence requirement, which mean upon completion of the program of study they must
+reside in their country of last legal permanent residence for two years before they are
+eligible to apply for entry into the U.S. on an immigrant visa or on specialized work
+visa (H or l). there is no foreign residence requirement for students on F-1 student
+status. refer to the department of State’s website for additional information on the
+exchange Visitor Program.
+
+• Medical Insurance: Students in J-1 status and their J-2 dependents are required to
+have comprehensive medical coverage in order to fulfill U.S. government regula-
+tions governing the J exchange Visitor status. Currently the medical insurance
+offered by Hobart and William Smith Colleges does not cover all requirements for
+those in J immigration status. the U.S. department of State specifies that program
+participants and their dependents have medical coverage with the following mini-
+mum requirements (22 CFr 62:14): medical benefits of at least $50,000 per accident
+or illness; repatriation of remains in the amount of $7, 500, medical evacuation of
+the exchange visitor to his or her home country in the amount of $10, 000, and a
+deductible not to exceed $500 per accident or illness. For more information please
+contact the international Student adviser.
+
+• Work Permission: Students in either F-1 or J-1 immigration status may work part
+time (up to 20 hours per week) on campus with permission from the international
+Student adviser. For both statuses, permission to work off campus based on eco-
+nomic need may be requested only after the first full academic year of student status,
+and only under extraordinary circumstances of unforeseen need. the United States
+Citizenship and immigration Services (USCiS) authorizes F-1 students to work off
+campus, whereas J-1 students submit an application for work permission to their visa
+sponsor, i.e. the agency or school that issued the dS-2019 form.
+
+• Practical or Academic Training: Students in F-1 and J-1 immigration status are
+eligible to engage in differing lengths of practical or academic training during their
+studies and at the completion of their academic programs. Practical training, a
+privilege of F-1 immigration status if you are eligible, is employment in one’s field of
+study. those in F-1 immigration classification may be eligible for “curricular” practi-
+
+20
+
+cal training (which is authorized by the international Student adviser) during their
+programs, in addition to one year of “optional” practical training that may take place
+during or after one’s program of study. Permission to engage in practical training may
+be granted only after you have been in valid student status for one academic year,
+except in a graduate program that requires it from the first term. the international
+Student adviser recommends optional practical training and the USCiS authorizes
+it. refer to the Practical training overview for complete information on both cur-
+ricular and optional practical training. academic training, a privilege of J-1 immi-
+gration status if you are eligible, is employment which is integral, not just related,
+to one’s field of study. one is eligible to apply for permission to engage in academic
+training after one academic term in valid student status. a total of 18 months of
+academic training is possible during or following completion of a program of study,
+with the exception of some postdoctoral research positions that may qualify for up
+to 36 months. an application for academic training is made to the J-1 student’s
+exchange Visitor program sponsor. refer to academic training authorization for
+those in J-1 exchange Visitor immigration Status for complete information.
+
+ARRIVING AT A U.S. PORT OF ENTRY …
+WHAT A STUDENT CAN EXPECT
+Plan your arrival: You may be refused entry into the United States if you attempt to
+arrive more than 30 days before the start date listed on your SeViS i-20 form.
+
+Always carry your passport and I-20 on hand: do not check the following docu-
+ments in your baggage. if your baggage is lost or delayed, you will be unable to pres-
+ent the documents at your port of entry. as a result, you may not be able to enter
+the United States.
+
+In addition, it is strongly recommended that you carry on hand the following
+
+documentation:
+
+1. evidence of financial resources
+2. evidence of student status, such as tuition receipts
+3. name and contact information for your international Student adviser,
+
+including a 24-hour emergency contact number at the school
+
+Complete your entry paperwork:
+Arriving by Air: Flight attendants will distribute Customs declaration Forms and
+arrival departure Forms (i-94). these must be completed prior to landing.
+
+Arriving by Land or Sea: the CbP officer at the port of entry will provide the
+necessary Customs declaration Form and the arrival-departure Form (i-94) to be
+filled out upon arrival.
+ as you arrive at the port of entry proceed to the terminal area for arriving
+passengers. Have the following documents available for presentation: you passport,
+i-20, arrival-departure Form (i-94), and the Customs declaration Form. Your docu-
+ments will be examined and processed by the department of Homeland Security
+(dHS) at the port of entry. Your passport will be returned to you along with an i-94
+card (arrival/departure record) designated “d/S” which means “duration of status”
+
+21
+
+and refers to the time you are engaged in a full-time course of study as indicated on
+your visa document. the dHS official will stamp and return your i-20 to you.
+
+Note: Your documents are extremely important. They legitimize your presence in
+the United States. Keep them in a safe and secure place.
+
+For Further Information:
+Preparing to Study in the U.S. http://educationusa.state.gov/
+applying for a Visa to Study in the U.S. http://travel.state.gov/visa/temp/types/
+types_1268.html
+
+MAINTAINING & BEING IN STATUS WITH DHS
+an F-1 student is considered in-status for the entire length of time during which
+he/she is enrolled as a full-time student in an educational program if adhering to
+the conditions of the visa designated on the i-94 card, plus any authorized period of
+practical training and an additional sixty (60) days to prepare for departure. be sure
+to pay close attention to the conditions described below:
+
+• report to the international Student adviser for SeViS registration upon arrival
+at Hobart and William Smith Colleges.
+
+• attend only the school authorized. this means that you must only attend the
+school whose i-20 you last used to enter the U.S. or the school whose i-20 you used
+to transfer schools. if you decide to withdraw from the Colleges before completing
+your program, you are not allowed to remain in the U.S. with in-student status un-
+less you transfer to another institution.
+
+• Complete a full course of study for each academic term and make normal academ-
+ic progress towards completion of program. attendance and/or full-time enrollment
+is not required during the summer. at Hobart and William Smith Colleges 4 credit
+hours per semester is required and exceptions can be made on the recommenda-
+tion of the international Student adviser for valid medical or academic reasons as
+defined by the dHS. be sure to speak with the international Student adviser about
+any exceptions beFore dropping below full-time status in order to avoid the seri-
+ous consequences that may result from being out of status.
+
+• transfer or extend program in a timely manner. duration of Status expires if a
+student takes longer than expected to complete a given academic level (e.g. bachelor’s,
+master’s, and doctorate). the amount of time permitted for completing studies at a
+given level is determined by the date on the initial i-20 issued at the beginning of each
+academic level. Students must pay close attention to the expected completion date
+noted in item 5 on the form i-20 for each level. if more time is needed, an applica-
+tion for extension of stay must be filed with the dHS. there are certain requirements
+to meet in order to be eligible for an extension, so you will need to consult with the
+international Student adviser at least 45 days before the completion date.
+
+22
+
+• Keep continuity in the program of study (in general an absence from the U.S. of
+more than 5 months terminates status. However, an authorized study abroad pro-
+gram does not break continuity).
+
+• refrain from unauthorized work. When you apply for an F-1 visa, you must prove
+that you have full financial support. the law assumes that you will not be employed
+in the U.S. and therefore will not accept employment that could be filled by a U.S.
+worker or student. there are some exceptions to this policy provided that full-time
+enrollment during the year is maintained and the appropriate permission is ob-
+tained, but you should always check with the international Student adviser before
+accepting employment, especially if it is off campus.
+
+• When traveling abroad, always return in proper F-1 status.
+
+• maintain a valid passport for 6 months into the future (Some countries have
+agreements with the U.S. that recognize the passport as valid for 6 months after the
+expiration date).
+
+• report any address changes to the international Student adviser within 10 days
+of the change. dHS regulations require that the international Student adviser
+maintain a record of the current address where you are living. therefore, you must
+always notify the international Student adviser immediately of any change of ad-
+dress. addresses with a post office box number or addresses of your academic depart-
+ment are not acceptable to the dHS.
+
+• Comply with Special registration requirements if applicable (nSeerS).
+
+• File timely requests of change of status, practical training and other benefits.
+
+• obey all State and Federal laws.
+
+• depart form the U.S. in a timely manner.
+
+• do not enter on a tourist visa (b-1 or b-2).
+
+Note: Students who fail to maintain full-time enrollment are not eligible for any
+of the benefits of the student visa, such as on-campus and off-campus employ-
+ment, practical training, remaining in the U.S. during summer vacation, transfer
+to another school or change of level, or registration for further courses. they are
+considered to be “out of status” and must apply to dHS for reinstatement to valid
+student status. eligibility for benefits will be regained only if and when the dHS
+approves the reinstatement. if you have any questions regarding reinstatement, see
+the international Student adviser immediately.
+
+23
+
+EXCEPTIONS TO A FULL COURSE OF STUDY
+
+• the normal vacation period;
+
+• medical problems documented by a licensed medical doctor, osteopath or clinical
+psychologist. approval for reduced or no course load for a medical condition is limited
+to 12 months total for the program of study;
+
+• teaching or research assistantship;
+
+• Valid academic reasons, such as first semester language difficulties and/or adjustment
+problems, improper course placement, unfamiliarity with american teaching methods;
+
+• the final term when the student needs less than a fulltime course load to complete
+program of study. Student must be enrolled in at least one credit;
+
+• during a period of full-time optional or Curricular Practical training.
+
+DURATION OF STATUS FOR F-1 STUDENTS
+an F-1 student is admitted to the U.S. for a period known as “duration of Status”
+which is recorded upon entry documents i-94 and i-20 with the notation “d/S”. du-
+ration of Status refers to the period a student is pursuing a full course of study, plus
+any authorized practical training following completion. The dates on the I-20 de-
+termine the initial parameters of the duration of status. A student can be admit-
+ted to the U.S. up to 30 days prior to the report date on the I-20 and may remain
+60 days after completion of program or practical training. Certain factors may
+reduce grace period to 15 days or to 0 days. an international Student adviser au-
+thorized withdrawal from classes is allowed a 15-day period for departure. a student
+who fails to maintain status is not eligible for an additional period for departure.
+
+TEMPORARY DEPARTURE FROM THE U.S.
+If you plan on leaving the U.S. temporarily to visit your homeland or some other
+country, an International Student Adviser must validate your I-20 for re-entry into
+the U.S. You may not be allowed back into the U.S. without the validated immigra-
+tion documents, a current visa, and a passport which is valid for at least six months
+after you re-enter the country.
+ most students with valid status may travel to Canada, mexico and many of the
+adjacent islands if they have a valid passport, a valid i-94 and a valid i-20 or dS-2019.
+if you re-enter the U.S. in fewer than 30 days, an unexpired U.S. visa is not required.
+However, Canada, mexico and the island nations do require entry visas for citizens of
+certain countries.
+
+it is always best to check with the embassy or consulate of any country you wish
+
+to visit. Since certain countries are ineligible for this benefit and travel regulations are
+subject to change, you should check with the international Student adviser if you
+intend to travel with an expired visa.
+
+Students who apply for a new visa in contiguous territory forfeit the right to re-
+
+24
+
+enter with an expired visa. if the new visa is denied, the student would not be able to
+re-enter the United States to study until a valid visa is obtained in their home country.
+
+ACCEPTING U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLIC ASSISTANCE OR PUBLIC
+BENEFITS
+international students and scholars should not, under any circumstance, accept public
+benefits from the federal, state, county or any other local government agencies in the
+United States. this includes, but is not limited to, participation in programs such
+as medicare/medicaid, Supplemental Social Security income, aid to Families with
+dependent Children, food stamps, and subsidized housing. accepting such benefits
+can cause you to lose your legal status in the United States and create a bar to your
+re-entry to this country.
+
+Cooperation between state social service agencies and the inS and department
+
+of State make it possible for an inS inspector or U.S. Consular officer to become
+aware of an individual who has accepted public benefits. the acceptance of public
+benefits is interpreted as a declaration that the individual is unable to meet his or her
+financial obligations (a requirement of obtaining and maintaining status) and thereby
+rendering him or herself ineligible for F-1 or J-1 status.
+ occasionally a well-meaning social service agency, hospital or public housing admin-
+istrator may offer such assistance not realizing that non-immigrants are ineligible for such
+benefits. additionally, even though U.S. citizen children of non-immigrant parents may be
+eligible for pre and post-natal public benefits, the non-immigrant parent may be denied a
+visa or re-entry based on the child’s receiving the benefits. again this is interpreted as the
+non-immigrant individual not being able to meet his or her financial obligations.
+
+Information on U.S. Social Security Numbers (SSN)
+if you will be employed in the United States, including at Hobart and William Smith
+Colleges, you must obtain a U.S. Social Security number, which is used by the U.S.
+government to identify wage earners for tax purposes. the number assigned to interna-
+tional students is not a valid U.S. Social Security number.
+
+to apply for a Social Security number (SSn) you must obtain a “proof of work”
+
+form from the international Student adviser confirming your student or exchange
+visitor status, that you are authorized to engage in on-campus employment, the nature
+of the employment to be engaged in, and identify the department/office for whom you
+will be working before being able to apply to the Social Security administration for
+a SSn. You must also present your passport, your i-20 or dS-2019 form and your i-94
+form. the Social Security administration office is open monday-Friday from 9:00 a.m.
+to 4:00 p.m. (closed on federal holidays).
+
+Social Ssecurity numbers will not be issued to foreign nationals who are not
+authorized to work. a Social Security number is not required for opening a bank
+account, registering for school, filing a U.S. tax form or applying for a driver’s license.
+if you are required to file a tax return and are not eligible for a U.S. Social Security
+number, you will have to apply to the internal revenue Service (irS) for a tax iden-
+tification number (tin) on form W-7. this form may be obtained from the Colleges
+payroll department.
+
+For more information about U.S. Social Security Numbers visit the website or
+
+call their toll-free number at 1-800-772-1213.
+
+25
+
+WORK OPPORTUNITIES FOR STUDENTS IN F-1 STATUS
+The following is a list of all opportunities to obtain authorization to work in the
+United States if you are in F-1 immigration status. Each category may allow for
+authorization under different circumstances and at different times during your
+stay in the U.S. This is summary of work benefits but does not include all regu-
+lations governing employment.
+
+On-campus Work: Full-time students are allowed to work up to twenty hours per
+week during the academic year. on campus employment means that you are paid by
+Hobart and William Smith Colleges or working at a Colleges location with an em-
+ployer that is providing services to students, such as Sodexho’s Saga dining hall or
+the Café. on-campus employment requires an i-9 employment verification autho-
+rization form to be completed by you at the Colleges business office.
+
+Off-campus Work Based on Financial Need: Students who have been in F-1 status
+for one academic year and who are experiencing extreme financial difficulties due to
+unforeseen changes that severely affect their financial resources may apply for work
+permission. authorization is given by the dHS with the recommendation of the
+international Student advisers/ dSo.
+
+Internship with an International Organization: Students in F-1 status are eligible
+to apply for permission to work for international organizations such as the World
+bank, the international monetary Fund, etc. authorization is granted by the dHS
+with the recommendation of the international Student adviser/dSo.
+
+WORK OPPORTUNITIES FOR STUDENTS IN J-1 STATUS
+J-1 On-Campus Employment
+enrolled J-1 students may work on campus up to 20 hours per week during the
+semester and full time during the break with the permission of their sponsor. if the
+Colleges are your sponsor please see the international Student adviser.
+
+J-1 Off-Campus Employment
+if a J-1 student needs employment during the academic year due to financial hard-
+ship arising form unforeseen circumstances, the program sponsor may authorize it.
+Such employment cannot interfere with full-time pursuit of the exchange visitor’s
+program objective and is limited to 20 hours per week during the academic year and
+full-time during break.
+
+PRACTICAL TRAINING:
+this is defined as employment related to your field of study and is available dur-
+ing and after completion of your studies. the following is a list of the categories of
+practical training:
+
+Curricular practical training (before completion of your studies) is defined as
+
+employment pursuant to a required or optional internship which is an integral part
+of the established curriculum of your school.
+
+26
+
+optional practical training is defined as employment related to your field of study.
+it is authorized in variable increments, deducted form the maximum of one year of
+optional practical training per educational level, and is available in the following
+variations:
+
+1. optional practical training after completion of your studies
+2. optional practical training before completion of your studies with three pos-
+
+sible variations:
+
+a. practical training during the annual vacation. the annual vacation must
+
+follow at least two consecutive terms of fulltime enrollment and is usually taken in
+the summer
+
+b. practical training when school is in session, provided that employment
+
+does not exceed 20 hours a week
+
+c. practical training following the completion of all the course requirements
+
+for the degree except the thesis or equivalent
+
+Optional Practical Training (OPT) Before Completion of Degree Requirements
+definition: employment related to your field of study before completion of all degree
+requirements. it is authorized in variable increments and is deducted from the
+maximum of one year (12 months) of optional practical training per educational
+level. there are three circumstances under which this type of practical training can
+be authorized:
-The ready-to-use apps include configurable apps (also referred to as ArcGIS Online and Portal
-for ArcGIS web app templates), ArcGIS StoryMaps℠ stories, mobile apps, app builders, and
-more. ArcGIS organizes these apps into bundles:
+1. Following completion of all degree requirements except the thesis or equivalent
+2. during the annual vacation
+3. Part-time (up to 20 hours per week) during the academic year
-• Essential apps bundle: ArcGIS StoryMaps, ArcGIS Experience Builder, ArcGIS Web
-AppBuilder, ArcGIS Dashboards, instant apps, ArcGIS Hub Basic, Map Viewer, Scene
-Viewer, and so on
+Eligibility to Engage In OPT: You must:
+• be a registered student in F-1 status physically in the United States at the time of
+application
+• have been enrolled in lawful student status on a full-time basis for at least one full
+academic year
+• not have used twelve months or more of full-time curricular practical training
+oPt is permitted for a period of up to a maximum of twelve months per educational
+level (bachelors, masters, etc.).
-• Field apps bundle: ArcGIS Field Maps, ArcGIS Survey123, ArcGIS QuickCapture, and so on
-• Office apps bundle: ArcGIS for Office, ArcGIS for SharePoint, and so on
-• ArcGIS Pro
-• ArcGIS Insights℠
-• Add-on apps: ArcGIS Drone2Map®, ArcGIS Navigator, ArcGIS Business Analyst™, and so on
+Procedure: obtaining authorization for oPt is a two-step process. Your first step in
+obtaining an employment authorization document (ead) is to qualify for a certifica-
+tion from the international Student adviser/dSo recommending you for oPt. the
+international Student adviser/dSo cannot authorize oPt - only the United States
+Citizenship and immigration Services (USCiS) can do so by issuing you an ead.
-ArcGIS user types consist of Viewer, Storyteller, Editor, Field Worker, Creator, GIS
-Professional, and Insights Analyst (see table 1.3). Different user types have included access to
-different app bundles and apps. Apps that are not included with a user type can be acquired and
-assigned as add-on licenses. To finish most of the tutorials in this book, a Creator user type with
-a Publisher role is required.
+You may not begin employment until you have been issued an ead by the US-
-Table 1 .3 . Main ArcGIS user types, privileges, and included apps
+CiS and can work only within the time period indicated on the card. requests for
+employment authorization must be mailed to the USCiS regional Service Center
+having jurisdiction over your place of residence and may require 6 to 12 weeks for
+adjudication.
-Type
+27
-Viewer
+When to Apply:
+• not more than 90 days prior to being enrolled for one full academic year·
+• not more than 120 days prior to the employment start date that you select
+Please note: the employment start date cannot be earlier than the date on which
+you will have completed one full academic year.
-Storyteller
+How to Apply:
+Obtaining the International Student Adviser recommendation
+Since you must first obtain a new SeViS i-20 with the international Student ad-
+viser/dSo’s oPt endorsement, which may require 5 working days, you should make
+every effort to apply as early as possible within the 90 or 120 day window. You might
+need to come twice to the international Student adviser/dSo—once to submit the
+application and another to pick up the approved recommendation on a SeViS i-20.
-Editor
+Curricular Practical Training in F-1 Status
+Definition: Curricular practical training (CPt) is employment pursuant to an intern-
+ship requirement or internship elective which is an integral part of the established
+curriculum of your school, which will be counted towards completion of your degree.
-Privileges
+Eligibility to engage in CPT: You must be a degree candidate who has been in
+lawful status for at least one academic year. You must have been offered a specific
+training opportunity that must fall into one of the following categories:
+• to satisfy an internship requirement expected of all students in your program
+and necessary for completion of your degree;
+• to satisfy an internship elective which counts towards completion of your degree.
+the internship elective must be listed in your school’s bulletin and must state in the
+official course description that it is specifically designed to allow students enrolled in
+the course to engage in off-campus internships;
+• the internship may be done to engage in research necessary and integral to the
+completion of the doctoral dissertation.
-Can view items
-Can’t create, edit, share, or analyze items
+Restrictions: U.S. Citizenship and immigration Services (USCiS) regulations do
+not place an absolute limit on the amount of CPt you may utilize. However, if you
+engage in one year or more of full-time CPt, you will lose your eligibility to engage
+in optional Practical training. CPt is always part-time during the academic year
+unless the student is engaged in doctoral dissertation research. CPt may be full time
+during the annual vacation. You may engage in curricular practical training only
+after your SeViS record has been updated by the international Student adviser and
+the i-20 has been printed, indicating the approved employment. the endorsement
+will indicate the precise details of the authorized training, including the name and
+location of the employer, the specific dates of the training period, and whether it
+is full-time or part-time. We encourage you to contact the international Student
+adviser/dSo if you have questions.
-Can create stories and express maps
-Can’t create other types of content
+28
-Can view and edit data
-Can’t analyze, create, or share items
+Departure Checklist
-Included apps
+q admissions letter from HWS
-Essential apps bundle
+q evidence of Financial resources
-Essential apps bundle
+q Passport with Student Visa
-Essential apps bundle
+q Form 1-20 or dS-2019
-Field Worker
+q Copies of medical records and other important documents translated into english
-Same as Editor
+q if J-1 visa holder – additional health insurance requirements. this must also be
-+ Field apps bundles
+translated into english, if needed.
-Creator
+q emergency outfit packed in carry-on luggage
-Can edit, create, share content, and do analysis
+q Calling card to use during travel
-+ Office apps bundles
+q emergency phone numbers (HWS: 1-315-781-3333)
-GIS Professional
+q minimum of 100 U.S. dollars for use in an emergency
-Same as Creator
+q Sweater or jacket in event of bad weather
-Insights Analyst
+q if taking prescription medicine bring prescription for future refills (translated into
-Same as GIS Professional
+english)
-+ ArcGIS Pro
+q Photocopy of your passport, visa, etc. do not carry in the same place as your
-Insights
+original documents.
-“+” means including the apps from the user type listed earlier in the table .
+29
-Copyright © 2022 Esri. All rights reserved.Web GIS information model: Users, web layers, maps, and apps
+SECTION III:
+*SAMPLE* ORIENTATION SCHEDULE *SAMPLE*
-13
+Hobart and William Smith Colleges
+international Students orientation
+“let Your adventure begin!”
+august 22 -25, 2006
-Basic components of a Web GIS app
-Today’s best practices recommend that a GIS app have basemaps, operational layers, and tools
-(see figure). ArcGIS supports this practice and allows you to create Web GIS apps.
+Tuesday, August 22
+8:30 a.m. –7:00 p.m.
-+
+Wednesday, August 23
+8:30 a.m. –12:00 p.m.
-+
+arrival/Check-in
+location: office of intercultural affairs
+288 Pulteney Street
+**bring all immigration paperwork
-=
+arrival/Check-in
+location: office of intercultural affairs,
+288 Pulteney Street
+**bring all immigration paperwork
-Basemaps
+HWS Student id Cards
+location: registrar’s office
-Operational
-layers
+Campus tour
-Tools
+Shopping @ Wal-mart & Wegmans Supermarket,
+Van leaves from intercultural affairs parking lot
-Web GIS app
+12:30 p.m. - 1:30 p.m.
-The basic components of a Web GIS app.
+lunch with deans of the Colleges
+location: blue room in Scandling Center
-The components of a Web GIS app are described as follows:
+1:45 p.m. – 2:45 p.m.
-• Basemap layers: Basemaps provide a reference or context for your app. ArcGIS provides a
-collection of fast-responding 2D and 3D basemaps (see figure). In addition, you can create
-and use your own basemaps.
+overview of library Services
+location: Warren Hunting Smith library
-ArcGIS provides a gallery of basemaps and an elevation service to support 2D and 3D web maps and apps.
+6:00 p.m. – 7:30 p.m.
-• Operational layers: Operational layers are theme layers that you and other users can use and
-interact with. You can use existing layers from ArcGIS Online and ArcGIS Living Atlas of
-the World as your operational layers. These layers span a range of subjects and can support
+dinner
+location: intercultural affairs Center
-Copyright © 2022 Esri. All rights reserved.14
+Thursday, August 24
+7:30 a.m. – 8:00 a.m.
-Chapter 1: Get started with Web GIS
+8:15 a.m. 9:45 a.m.
-maps and apps of almost every subject. You can search these collections and discover layers
-that fit your needs. You can also create and use your own operational layers.
+30
-• Tools: Tools perform tasks beyond mapping, including common tasks such as query, geocod-
-ing, routing, and more specialized tasks. ArcGIS Online provides extensive spatial analysis
-tools for you to ask questions and solve spatial problems. ArcGIS Enterprise provides tools
-for standard analysis, big data analysis, and raster analysis, and allows you to publish custom
-web tools — in other words, geoprocessing services.
+breakfast
+location: Saga dining Hall in the blue room
-Web layers or services: The building blocks of Web GIS
-Web services technology is at the foundation of today’s Web GIS. The previously mentioned
-three types of components of Web GIS apps are typically all based on web services. To make it
-easier to understand, web services in ArcGIS are also called web layers or web tools. For exam-
-ple, basemaps are often tile services or tile layers, operational layers are often feature services or
-feature layers, and many tools are based on geoprocessing services or web tools.
+immigration regulations overview
+location: Conference room, 2nd Floor,
+intercultural affairs
-Early Web GIS was not based on web services; instead, it consisted mostly of stand-alone
-websites in which GIS data and functions were available only to their own clients and couldn’t
-be reused in other systems. This situation greatly limited the reusability of Web GIS resources.
-In the late 1990s, web services technology was conceived. A web service is a program that runs
-on a web server and provides programming interfaces for clients to consume over the web. Web
-services have many advantages, such as flexibility in being reused and remixed in many web apps.
-The GIS industry quickly adopted web services technology and reformed Web GIS products
-based on web services architecture in the early 2000s. Today’s Web GIS products are designed to
-support the publication, discovery, and use of GIS web services. A GIS service represents a GIS
-resource — such as a layer, map, locator, or toolbox — that is located on the server and made avail-
-able to web clients. For example, ArcGIS Living Atlas provides collections of ready-to-use GIS
-services. The Esri geospatial cloud allows publishers to publish many types of GIS services and
-allows users to discover and use GIS services in web maps, web apps, and mobile apps.
+10:00 a.m. – 11:00 a.m.
-This chapter introduces feature layers and services. Other chapters introduce raster tile ser-
-vices, vector tile services, 3D scene services, map services, image services, stream services, geo-
-processing services, geocoding services, and more. To support interoperability, ArcGIS supports
-OGC standards such as WMS, WMTS, WFS, and KML.
+11:05 a.m. – 11:35 a.m.
-Copyright © 2022 Esri. All rights reserved.Web GIS information model: Users, web layers, maps, and apps
+on Campus employment/Social Security
+elaine Ferrara, business office
+location: tba
-15
+benefits of the HWS Health insurance
+ann brink, bursars office
+location: tba
-Hosted and nonhosted feature layers
-Feature layers are the most used layer type for operational layers. Feature refers to vector data:
-points, lines, and polygons. Feature layers can be hosted or nonhosted, depending on where the
-underlying data is stored.
+12:00 p.m. – 1:30 p.m.
-• Hosted refers to a situation in which a web service is based on ArcGIS-managed data: for
-instance, the data is stored in the ArcGIS Online cloud database (which is managed auto-
-matically by Esri) or in ArcGIS Data Store (which is managed automatically by ArcGIS
-Enterprise).
+lunch with Chaplain lesley adams
+location: Chaplain’s residence, 630 S. main St.
-• Nonhosted refers to a situation in which a web service connects directly to user-managed
+1:45 p.m. – 2:15 p.m.
-data: for instance, the data is stored in your organization’s own database, and the database is
-managed by your own organization.
+money matters
+beth turner, director of Financial aid
+location: tba
-Feature layers published to ArcGIS Online are always hosted feature layers. Feature layers pub-
-lished in ArcGIS Enterprise can be hosted if the data is stored in ArcGIS Data Store or nonhosted
-if your feature layers reference your organization’s own geodatabase — for example, SQL Server,
-Oracle, or PostgreSQL.
+2:30 p.m. – 3:00 p.m.
-Hosted feature layers are often easier to publish because you don’t have to worry about the
-underlying database. You don’t have to (and you won’t be able to) directly connect to the database
-and manipulate it. To change the database schema and edit the data, you must go through the
-hosted feature layer web interface. Nonhosted feature layers require that you have and manage
-your own database. You can directly connect to the database and perform various operations
-on it.
+a Healthy You
+location: Hubbs Health Center
-This book teaches many ways to publish hosted feature layers—from CSV files, zipped file
-geodatabases, ArcGIS Pro, and so on. You can also create empty feature layers and add fields in
-ArcGIS Online (see chapter 4).
+3:15 p.m. – 3:45 p.m.
-Web maps and web scenes: The bridge between layers and apps
-Web GIS provides Map Viewer and Scene Viewer for creators to integrate multiple layers, style
-these layers, configure layer pop-ups, and make many other configurations. After a web map or
-web scene is created, it can be used in one app or reused in many apps. This makes it easier for
-creators to create apps. Without web maps and scenes, creators would often have to integrate the
-layers directly and configure them in the apps, which can be cumbersome.
+5:30 p.m. – 7:30 p.m.
-Copyright © 2022 Esri. All rights reserved.16
+Friday , August 25
+10:00 a.m. – 11:00 a.m.
-Chapter 1: Get started with Web GIS
+Study basics
+Center for teaching & learning
+location: Center for teaching & learning
+(Ctl)
-Paths to building Web GIS applications
-The tutorials in this book teach readers how to build Web GIS apps. ArcGIS offers many paths to
-this goal, as shown in this figure, which will be used throughout the book.
+Welcome dinner
+President and mrs. mark gearan & Family
+location: President’s House – 690 South main St.
-ArcGIS offers many ways to build web apps. The green arrows in the figure highlight the workflows and
-technology presented in this chapter.
+guide to U.S. education & Culture
+amy teel and doug reilly, Center for
+global education
+location: delancey House
-The figure presents the generic workflow to build Web GIS apps:
+12:00 p.m. – 1:00 p.m.
-• The data tier contains formats that range from simple CSV files managed with Microsoft
+lunch
+location: delancey House
-Excel to sophisticated geodatabases managed with enterprise databases.
+1:30 p.m.
-• You can publish desktop resources to ArcGIS Online or ArcGIS Enterprise as web layers,
+Join regular campus wide orientation schedule
-tools, or other services. You can also use layers provided by ArcGIS Living Atlas. You can add
-layers to web maps and web scenes and configure the styles and pop-ups in these layers.
+Welcome to Hobart and William Smith Colleges
-• On the client side, you can use various ready-to-use apps or custom apps. The former can be
-configured without programming. The latter can be developed using various web APIs or
-SDKs.
+31
-Copyright © 2022 Esri. All rights reserved.
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/q158/random_k2/random_2.md b/q158/random_k2/random_2.md
index 482f9de9b0ff67f242f61e09321d1c78cb243915..7c9bfe03e0f0526a505a4d46c111520dc2f0531c 100644
--- a/q158/random_k2/random_2.md
+++ b/q158/random_k2/random_2.md
@@ -1,410 +1,1126 @@
-IEEEInternationalConferenceonDataMining(ICDM),WorkshoponUserModelingandRecommendation(UMRec),Washington,DC,USA,2025
-| Effectiveness | | | | | of LLMs | | in | Temporal | | | User | | Profiling | | |
-| ------------- | --- | --- | ------ | -------------------- | ------- | -------------- | --------------------- | ----------- | ----------- | ---------------------- | --------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | for | Recommendation | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | Milad | Sabouri∗, | | Masoud | Mansoury†, | Kun | Lin∗, | Bamshad | Mobasher∗ | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | ∗DePaul University, | | USA | | | | | | |
-| | | | Email: | msabouri@depaul.edu, | | | klin13@depaul.edu, | | | mobasher@cs.depaul.edu | | | | | |
-| | | | | | †Delft | University | of | Technology, | Netherlands | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | Email: | m.mansoury@tudelft.nl | | | | | | | | |
-Abstract—Effectively modeling the dynamic nature of user 17% in Recall@10 and 14% in NDCG@10, benefits are
-| preferences | is crucial | | for enhancing | | recommendation | | accuracy | | | | | | | | |
-| ----------- | ---------- | --- | ------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------- | ---- | ---------- | --- | ------- | ------------ | --- | ---------- | ------ |
-| | | | | | | | | less | pronounced | in | sparser | environments | | like Video | Games. |
-5202 tcO 13 ]RI.sc[ 1v67100.1152:viXra andfosteringtransparencyinrecommendersystems.Traditional
-| | | | | | | | | Our | analysis | of these | results | leads | us | to hypothesize | that |
-| -------------- | ----- | --------- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------- | ---------- | ---- | -------- | ---------- | ------- | ------------ | ------- | -------------- | ------ |
-| user profiling | often | overlooks | | the distinction | | between | transitory | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | | this | nuanced | capability | is | particularly | evident | where | short- |
-short-terminterestsandstablelong-termpreferences.Thispaper
-examines the capability of leveraging Large Language Models term and long-term preferences are more clearly separable
-(LLMs) to capture these temporal dynamics, generating richer (e.g., Movies&TV), versus domains with more stable user
-| user representations | | through | | distinct | short-term | and | long-term | | | | | | | | |
-| -------------------- | --- | ------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-profiles(e.g.,VideoGames).Thishighlightsacriticaltrade-off
-textualsummariesofinteractionhistories.Ourobservationssug-
-betweenLLM-enhancedpredictivepowerandassociatedcom-
-gestthatwhileLLMstendtoimproverecommendationqualityin
-| | | | | | | | | putational | | costs, suggesting | | context-dependent | | application. | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ----------------- | --- | ------------ | --- |
-domainswithmoreactiveuserengagement,theirbenefitsappear
-less pronounced in sparser environments. This disparity likely Also,beyondpredictiveaccuracy,thisLLM-drivenapproach
-stemsfromthevaryingdistinguishabilityofshort-termandlong- inherently offers an intrinsic potential for transparency. The
-| term preferences | | across | domains; | the | approach | shows | greater | | | | | | | | |
-| ---------------- | --- | ------ | -------- | --- | -------- | ----- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-naturallanguageprofilesandlearnedattentionweightsprovide
-utilitywherethesetemporalinterestsaremoreclearlyseparable
-| | | | | | | | | a pathway | | toward interpretability, | | | conveying | whether | recom- |
-| ----------------- | ------------ | -------- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | ---------- | ----------- | ---------- | --- | ------------------------ | ------ | --- | --------- | ---------- | ------ |
-| (e.g., Movies&TV) | | compared | | to domains | with | more | stable user | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | | mendations | | stem from | recent | or | enduring | interests. | While |
-| profiles | (e.g., Video | Games). | | This | highlights | a critical | trade- | | | | | | | | |
-off between enhanced performance and computational costs, fully realizing user-facing explanations is a future direction,
-suggesting context-dependent LLM application. Beyond predic- this work contributes insights into the practical capability
-| tive capability, | this | LLM-driven | | approach | inherently | | provides | | | | | | | | |
-| ---------------- | --------- | ---------- | -------------------- | -------- | ---------- | ---- | ----------- | ----------- | --------- | ---------------- | -------- | ------------- | ---------- | ------------ | ---- |
-| | | | | | | | | and | inherent | interpretability | | of LLM-driven | | temporal | user |
-| an intrinsic | potential | | for interpretability | | through | | its natural | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | | profiling, | outlining | new | research | | directions | for adaptive | and |
-| language | profiles | and | attention | weights. | This | work | contributes | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | | transparent | | recommender | systems. | | | | |
-insightsintothepracticalcapabilityandinherentinterpretability
-| of LLM-driven | | temporal | user | profiling, | outlining | new | research | | | | | | | | |
-| ------------- | --- | -------- | ---- | ---------- | --------- | --- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-II. RELATEDWORK
-directionsfordevelopingadaptiveandtransparentrecommender
-systems. Modeling the dynamic nature of user preferences is a
-IndexTerms—TemporalUserProfiling,LargeLanguageMod-
-| | | | | | | | | long-standing | | challenge | in | recommender | | systems. | Traditional |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------- | --- | --------- | --- | ----------- | --- | -------- | ----------- |
-els, User Modeling
-| | | | | | | | | methods, | such | as averaging | | item embeddings | | [3], | often fail to |
-| --- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------- | ---------- | ------------ | ----------- | --------------- | --- | ------------ | ------------- |
-| | | | | | | | | capture | the | evolving | distinction | between | | short-term | and long- |
-| | | I. | INTRODUCTION | | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | | term | interests. | More | advanced | approaches | | for temporal | and |
-Effective recommender systems demand both accurate and sequential recommendation include time-aware matrix factor-
-transparent suggestions, a challenge exacerbated by the dy- ization (e.g., TimeSVD++ [4]), and sequential deep learning
-namic nature of user preferences. Traditional user profiling, models like GRU4Rec [5] and SASRec [6], which learn user
-such as averaging item embeddings, often oversimplifies user dynamics from interaction sequences. Recent work has also
-interests by conflating fleeting short-term desires with sta- explored long short-term preference modeling for continuous-
-ble long-term tastes, hindering both recommendation quality time sequential recommendation [7].
-and interpretability. This paper examines the capability of Research in recommender systems increasingly emphasizes
-leveraging Large Language Models (LLMs) to capture these balancing predictive accuracy with interpretability. Early ef-
-temporaldynamics.Ourapproachgeneratesdistinctshort-term forts integrated explanations through content summarization
-and long-term textual summaries of user interaction histories, or leveraged user-generated reviews [8]. More recently, Large
-which are then encoded via BERT [1] and adaptively fused LanguageModels(LLMs)[9],[10]haveemergedaspowerful
-using an attention mechanism [2] to form a unified user tools for generating richer explanations, demonstrating their
-representation. capacity to enhance interpretability through personalized nar-
-Our observations reveal a nuanced capability of this LLM- rativesandcollaborativeadaptors[11]–[14].Knowledgegraph
-driven approach across varying user engagement patterns. (KG)-based approaches [15] have also integrated structured
-While it tends to improve recommendation quality in ac- side information for explanations, sometimes combined with
-tive domains like Movies&TV, with improvements such as LLM outputs [15]–[18].
+IEEETRANSACTIONSONMULTIMEDIA 1
+RA-BLIP: Multimodal Adaptive
+Retrieval-Augmented Bootstrapping
+Language-Image Pre-training
+Muhe Ding, Yang Ma, Pengda Qin, Jianlong Wu, Member, IEEE, Yuhong Li, Liqiang Nie, Senior Member, IEEE
+rec A en bs tl t y ra r c e t c — ei M ve u d lt s i u m b o s d ta a n l t L ia a l r i g n e te L r a e n st g , u w a h g i e ch M s o h d o e w ls s ( t M he L ir L e M m s e ) r h g a in v g e (a) × × In
+S
+n
+i
+e
+m
+r
+i
+P
+la
+ro
+ri
+d
+ty
+uct (b) 𝐻 …["#$] … 𝐼) T
+S
+o
+i
+k
+m
+en
+il
+-
+a
+W
+rit
+i
+y
+se
+potential as general-purpose models for various vision-language
+𝐻,-./012 𝐼&
+tasks.MLLMsinvolvesignificantexternalknowledgewithintheir ContrastiveLearning 𝐻["#$] 𝐻& 𝐻'()* …𝐻!"#$%&' 𝐼) 𝐼* 𝐼+ …𝐼&
+parameters; however, it is challenging to continually update
+these models with the latest knowledge, which involves huge Text Image Text Image
+Encoder Encoder Encoder Encoder
+computationalcostsandpoorinterpretability.Retrievalaugmen-
+tation techniques have proven to be effective plugins for both
+LLMsandMLLMs.Inthisstudy,weproposemultimodaladap- Arockband Arockband
+isplaying isplaying
+tive Retrieval-Augmented Bootstrapping Language-Image Pre-
+training (RA-BLIP), a novel retrieval-augmented framework for (c) Multimodal Knowledge Semantic Space
+various MLLMs. Considering the redundant information within
+vision modality, we first leverage the question to instruct the
+extractionofvisualinformationthroughinteractionswithoneset
+of learnable queries, minimizing irrelevant interference during
+retrieval and generation. Besides, we introduce a pre-trained
+multimodal adaptive fusion module to achieve question text-to- MultimodalAdaptiveRA-BLIP
+multimodalretrievalandintegrationofmultimodalknowledgeby
+projectingvisualandlanguagemodalitiesintoaunifiedsemantic … … … …
+space.Furthermore,wepresentanAdaptiveSelectionKnowledge
+Generation (ASKG) strategy to train the generator to au-
+tonomously discern the relevance of retrieved knowledge, which
+Which streetwas paved with
+realizes excellent denoising performance. Extensive experiments boards; Little Champlain
+Street, Quebec City, 1916 or
+o th n at op R e A n -B m L u I l P tim a o ch d i a e l ve q s ue si s g ti n o i n fi - c a a n n s t w p er e i r n fo g rm da a t n a c s e ets an d d em su o r n p s a tr s a se te s Quebec C w i i t n y t e R r u 2 e 0 S 1 a 0 int-Louis N Q aN w t u i Q ao i N e w t nu n b i Q a t o i e a e e wn tn b lu c i rt oai ee eH 2 n C ln cbr 0 ti Ha i e es2 C1 t l ctr y 0 i 0 o i Hs 21 tC. r R t y i00 oi Lic s u 1. r tR t oy i e S0 o L c uu . r iR S o e i tSi L s e a u c u i S i iot Seo S n s e a u t f t i iSrS i - ot ne Cs e L at f t er i - aS o o en C tL n - u t f eta ra o a- i te C L n s -d u ea aa a io t s dn - u aaa i s d a
+Question Image Image-Text Document
+the state-of-the-art retrieval-augmented models.
+QuestionPrompt Inter-Modal Intra-Modal Relevant
+Index Terms—Retrieval-augmented model, vision-language Instruction Interaction Interaction Irrelevant
+pre-training, multimodal retrieval, open question answering. Question Image Image-Text Text
+Embeddings Embeddings Embeddings Embeddings
+I. INTRODUCTION
+Fig. 1. Illustration of different multimodal retrieval approaches. (a) Cross-
+THE birth of the Internet has triggered an unprecedented modality retrieval. (b) Late-interaction retrieval. (c) RA-BLIP multimodal
+information revolution, catapulting humanity into the era adaptive retrieval. For RA-BLIP, questions, documents, images, and image-
+textpairsareprojectedintoaunifiedmultimodalspace.
+of information explosion. It is a great challenge to efficiently
+find answers from a vast amount of information based on
+our questions. Open Multimodal Multihop Question Answer-
+BLIP-2 [10], GPT-4 [11], etc., have been notably explored to
+ing (MMQA) [1]–[7] can help alleviate this problem of in-
+enhancetheirperformancebyimplicitlyencodingasubstantial
+formationoverloadbyretrievingexternalknowledgebasedon
+amount of external knowledge within their parameters, which
+questionsandgeneratingcorrectanswers.Inrecentyears,sev-
+now scale into the hundreds of billions [12]. While these
+eraladvancedLLMsandMLLMslikeFlanT5[8],LLaMA[9],
+models have yielded exciting results on various multimodal
+ThisworkwassupportedinpartbytheNationalNaturalScienceFoundation tasks, they have also encountered high computational costs
+ofChinaunderGrant62376069,inpartbyYoungEliteScientistsSponsorship and significant challenges in terms of interpretability.
+ProgrambyCASTunderGrant2023QNRC001,andinpartbyGuangdongBa-
+To alleviate the challenge, many researchers proposed re-
+sicandAppliedBasicResearchFoundationunderGrant2024A1515012027.
+Muhe Ding, Jianlong Wu and Liqiang Nie are with the School trievalaugmentationtechniquesthatdividethemodelintotwo
+of Computer Science and Technology, Harbin Institute of Technology keycomponents:theretrieverandthegenerator[13]–[16].The
+(Shenzhen),Shenzhen518055,China(e-mail:dmh1216380870@gmail.com,
+retriever accesses relevant knowledge from a knowledge base
+jlwu1992@pku.edu.cn,nieliqiang@gmail.com).
+Yang Ma is with the School of Computer Science, University of Sydney, based on the posed question, while the generator leverages
+Sydney,NSW2006,Australia(e-mail:yama5878@uni.sydney.edu.au). this information to create textual output in response. In ear-
+Pengda Qin and Yuhong Li are with the Security Department, Al-
+lier stages, text-modality retrieval-augmented models, such as
+ibaba Group, Hangzhou 311121, China (e-mail: qinpengda0406@163.com,
+daniel.yuhong@gmail.com). REALM [13], RAG [17], and so on [18], [19], have been
+4202
+tcO
+81
+]MM.sc[
+1v45141.0142:viXra
-| | | Fig.1. | Pipeline | for | LLM-Driven | Temporal | | User Profile | Generation | and | Recommendation. | | | | |
-| --- | --- | ------ | -------- | --- | ---------- | -------- | --- | ------------ | ---------- | --- | --------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-Ourworkintersectsthesetwocriticalareasbyinvestigating (i) LLM-based Temporal Profile Generation: To capture
-the utility of leveraging LLMs to explicitly model temporal temporal aspects of user preferences, our approach prompts
-user dynamics for enhanced content-based recommendations the LLM twice over each user’s interaction history H , using
-u
-and inherent transparency. Unlike existing methods that pri- distinct instructions to generate two textual summaries. The
-marily use static profiles or sequential models without natural first focuses on recent interactions, producing the short-term
-| language | grounding | [6], | [19], | [20], this | study | explores | an | profile: | | | | | | | |
-| -------------- | -------------- | --------- | -------- | ---------- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ---------- | ---------- | ------- | ---------- | -------------- | --- | ------ | -------- |
-| approach | that generates | | distinct | natural | language | summaries | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | | | | NLshort | =LLM(H | ,Promptshort). | | | (2) |
-| | | | | | | | | | | u | | u | | | |
-| for short-term | and | long-term | user | behaviors. | By | encoding | and | | | | | | | | |
-| adaptively | fusing | these | semantic | summaries, | | this approach | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | | The second | summarizes | | persistent | behaviors | | across | the full |
-aims to create intrinsically interpretable user profiles. This history, forming the long-term profile:
-| unique combination | | transparently | | highlights | the | temporal | ra- | | | | | | | | |
-| -------------------- | --------- | ---------------- | ------------ | ----------- | -------- | -------- | -------- | --------------- | ------- | ----------- | ---------------- | ------------- | ------------ | ------------- | ------ |
-| tionale behind | | recommendations, | | bridging | advanced | | LLM- | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | | | | NLlong | =LLM(H | ,Promptlong). | | | (3) |
-| | | | | | | | | | | u | | u | | | |
-| based explainability | | with | nuanced | temporal | dynamics | | of user | | | | | | | | |
-| interests. | This work | provides | | preliminary | insights | | into the | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | | These summaries | | enhance | interpretability | | by | separating | tran- |
-| practical | utility | of this novel | integration. | | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | | sient and | stable | user | interests. | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | | To provide | | a concrete | understanding | | of | our LLM-based | |
-| | | III. | METHODOLOGY | | | | | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | | temporal | profile | generation, | | we include | a conceptual | | illus- |
-Let U = u ,u ,...,u be users, and I = i ,i ,...,i tration of the prompts and their corresponding output in
-| | 1 | 2 | |U| | | | 1 2 | |I| | | | | | | | | |
-| --------- | ---- | -------- | ----------- | ---- | -------- | --- | -------- | --------- | --- | ------- | ------------- | -------- | --- | --------- | -------- |
-| be items. | Each | user u ∈ | U interacts | with | a subset | | of items | | | | | | | | |
-| | | | | | | | | Figure 3. | The | prompts | are carefully | designed | | to elicit | distinct |
-I u ⊆ I, with interactions associated to timestamps. We temporal summaries. As shown, the ”Long-term Preference
-| define the | interaction | history | as | Hu=(i,t | ):i∈I | | sorted | | | | | | | | |
-| ---------- | ----------- | ------- | --- | ------- | ----- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-u,i u Prompt” emphasizes identifying enduring interests and con-
-chronologically.
-| | | | | | | | | sistent themes | | across | the user’s | entire | history. | In | contrast, |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------ | ---------- | ------ | -------- | --- | --------- |
-∈Rd)
-We aim to learn embeddings for users (e u and items the ”Short-term Preference Prompt” is engineered to focus
-| (e ∈Rd) | to predict | user-item | | interaction | likelihood: | | | | | | | | | | |
-| ------- | ---------- | --------- | --- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-i specifically on recent behaviors and fleeting interests. While
-thefull,detailedpromptsandtheirconfigurationsareavailable
-| | | yˆ | =f(e | ,e ), | | | (1) | | | | | | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | ---- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| | | u,i | | u i | | | | | | | | | | | |
-inourpublicrepository(seesectionIV)toensurereproducibil-
-wheref isamulti-layerperceptron(MLP).Thepipeline(Fig- ity, these examples demonstrate the core strategy of using
-ure 1) comprises three steps: (i) profile generation via LLMs, natural language instructions to temporally disentangle user
-| (ii) semantic | embedding, | | and (iii) | interaction | prediction. | | | preferences. | | | | | | | |
-| ------------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | ----------- | ----------- | --- | --- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+| IEEETRANSACTIONSONMULTIMEDIA | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | 2 |
+| ---------------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+proposed to solve text-only question answering. They build an adaptive selection knowledge generation strategy, which
+the dense index as a non-parametric document memory from gives the generator the capability of selecting knowledge by
+extensive textual sources like Wikipedia for effective knowl- data enhancement to make the model automatically judge the
+edge retrieval, and the generator produces answers based on relevance of knowledge. ASKG strategy allows the generator
+the retrieved knowledge. More recently, multimodal retrieval- tonotsimplyrelyonthewordsimilaritybetweenthequestion
+augmented models, such as MuRAG [14], SKURG [20], and and knowledge, but to understand the semantic information
+soon[16],[21],haveemergedoneafteranother.Thesemodels of question and know which knowledge contains the answer.
+extend the knowledge memory across various modalities, em- Furthermore, the parameters of the image encoder and LLM
+ployingpre-trainedvisuallanguagemodelstoretrieverelevant of our framework are frozen, significantly reducing computa-
+evidence and support reasoning for answers. tionalcosts.ExtensiveexperimentsonthreerepresentativeQA
+However, existing methods exhibit certain limitations. The datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of our methods.
+first limitation is the insufficient integration and interaction Overall, our key contributions are as follows:
+| between | vision | and | language. | On | the one | hand, | existing | | | | | | | | |
+| ------- | ------ | -------- | ----------- | --- | ---------- | ------------ | -------- | --------- | ------- | ---------- | ---------- | -------- | -------- | -------- | ---------- |
+| | | | | | | | | • We | propose | a novel | multimodal | | adaptive | | retrieval- |
+| methods | lack | explicit | integration | of | multimodal | information, | | | | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | | augmented | | framework, | which | achieves | | question | text-to- |
+hindering the alignment of questions and multimodal knowl- multimodalretrievalandknowledge-intensivemultimodal
+| edge in | the semantic | | space. | As shown | in | Fig. | 1(a), some | | | | | | | | |
+| ------- | ------------ | --- | ------ | -------- | --- | ---- | ---------- | --- | -------------- | --- | ------ | ------------ | --- | ---------- | --- |
+| | | | | | | | | QA | by integrating | | visual | and language | | modalities | and |
+methods [14], [22], [23] have employed separate visual en- projecting them into a unified semantic space.
+| coder and | text | encoder | for individual | | modality | encoding | and | | | | | | | | |
+| --------- | ---- | ------- | -------------- | --- | -------- | -------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+• Weintroduceanadaptiveselectionknowledgegeneration
+| adopted | contrastive | learning | | [24] for | multimodal | | alignment | | | | | | | | |
+| ------- | ----------- | -------- | --- | -------- | ---------- | --- | --------- | -------- | ---- | --------- | --- | -------- | ------------ | --- | ------- |
+| | | | | | | | | strategy | that | leverages | the | powerful | capabilities | | of LLMs |
+to retrieve. This may lead to an unbalanced and biased to select the relevant retrieved knowledge for answer
+| multimodal | retrieval | | and reasoning | | process | towards | specific | | | | | | | | |
+| ---------- | --------- | --- | ------------- | --- | ------- | ------- | -------- | --------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+| | | | | | | | | reasoning | | autonomously. | | | | | |
+modalities.Besides,late-interactionretrievalapproaches[25]– We conduct extensive experiments on various multi-
+•
+[27] in Fig. 1(b), retain dual-encoder independent encoding modal and multihop datasets (i.e., WebQA [4], Multi-
+| architecture | and | perform | token-wise | | interactions | only | in the | | | | | | | | |
+| ------------ | --- | ------- | ---------- | --- | ------------ | ---- | ------ | ------- | --- | -------- | ------ | ----- | ------- | --- | ------ |
+| | | | | | | | | modalQA | | [5], and | MMCoQA | [6]). | RA-BLIP | | demon- |
+late scoring stage, which sacrifices the retrieval efficiency for strates superiority over the existing state-of-the-art
+thebenefitsoffine-grainedfeaturelearning.Ontheotherhand,
+| | | | | | | | | retrieval-augmented | | | models. | | | | |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ------- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+existingmethods[14],[20],[28],[29]donotutilizequestions
+| to instruct | the | image | encoder | in selectively | | extracting | visual | | | | | | | | |
+| ------------- | ----------- | -------------- | ------- | -------------- | ------------- | ---------- | ---------- | ------------------ | --- | ------------ | ----------- | ----- | ------- | ---------------- | ------ |
+| | | | | | | | | | | II. | RELATEDWORK | | | | |
+| features, | and | thus suffer | from | interference | | and noise | caused | | | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | | A. Vision-Language | | Pretraining | | | | | |
+| by redundant | information | | in | images. | Moreover, | such | methods | | | | | | | | |
+| lack mutual | instruction | | when | encoding | different | | modal fea- | | | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | | Vision-language | | pre-training | | (VLP) | aims | to train | models |
+| tures, making | | it challenging | | to model | relationships | | between | | | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | | on large-scale | | image-text | datasets | to | capture | the relationship | |
+multiple sources. The second limitation is that existing ap- between these two modalities. Broadly, VLP methodologies
+proachesdonotinspectthecorrectnessoftheretrievedrelevant
+| | | | | | | | | fall into | two categories | | based | on their | training | approach: | 1) |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | -------------- | --- | ----- | -------- | -------- | --------- | --- |
+knowledge at the generation stage. However, the retrieved End-to-end Methods: This category includes methods [35]–
+| knowledge | contains | significant | | noise, | resulting | in poor | model | | | | | | | | |
+| --------- | -------- | ----------- | --- | ------ | --------- | ------- | ----- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+[38]thattrainmodelsend-to-end,backpropagatinglearnedsig-
+| anti-interference | | and | robustness. | The | generator | assumes | all | | | | | | | | |
+| ----------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --- | --------- | ------- | --- | --------------- | --- | ------ | -------- | ------- | --------- | --- | ----------- |
+| | | | | | | | | nals to achieve | | mutual | learning | between | different | | modalities. |
+retrieved relevant knowledge is correct, potentially leading to 2)ModularMethods:Incontrast,modularmethods,asseenin
+| the utilization | | of irrelevant | or | confusing | information. | | | | | | | | | | |
+| --------------- | --- | ------------- | --- | --------- | ------------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+worksby[39]–[43],involvekeepingtheparametersofspecific
+To address the above issues, we propose multimodal adap- pre-trainedcomponents(likeimageencodersorlargelanguage
+tiveRetrieval-AugmentedBootstrappingLanguage-ImagePre- models) fixed while focusing on refining other aspects of the
+| training | (RA-BLIP). | | RA-BLIP | consists | of | two key | compo- | | | | | | | | |
+| -------- | ---------- | --- | ------- | -------- | --- | ------- | ------ | ------ | ------------- | --- | ---- | -------- | ------------- | --- | ------ |
+| | | | | | | | | model. | For instance, | LiT | [44] | utilizes | a pre-trained | | frozen |
+nents: a multimodal adaptive retrieval-augmented framework image encoder from CLIP, while Flamingo [45] and BLIP-2
+| and an | adaptive | selection | | knowledge | generation | | (ASKG) | | | | | | | | |
+| ------ | -------- | --------- | --- | --------- | ---------- | --- | ------ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+[10]freezethelanguagemodeltointegrateLLMsintovision-
+strategy. To tackle the first limitation, RA-BLIP is based on language tasks better. Besides, instruction tuning is also an
+the InstructBLIP architecture [30] and adopts Q-Former to effective approach during VLP. InstructBLIP [30] represents
+implementinstruction-awarevisualfeatureextractionthatuses
+arecentadvancementinthisarea,achievinginstruction-aware
+questions as instructions. The question instruction interacts visual feature extraction and instruction-guided LLM genera-
+withthequeryembeddingsthroughsharedself-attentionlayers
+| | | | | | | | | tion. The | unique | capability | of | InstructBLIP | to | extract | features |
+| -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | -------------------- | --- | --- | ----------- | --------- | ------ | ------------- | --- | ------------ | ---- | ------- | ----------- |
+| and encourages | | the extraction | | of question-relevant | | | visual fea- | | | | | | | | |
+| | | | | | | | | based on | prompt | instructions, | | combined | with | its | utilization |
+tures. Additionally, we incorporate a pre-trained multimodal of frozen LLMs and image encoders, positions it as an ideal
+| adaptive | fusion | module | to fuse | vision | and | text information, | | | | | | | | | |
+| ------------- | ---------- | -------- | ------------------ | ---------- | --- | ----------------- | --------- | -------- | ------- | -------- | ------------------- | --- | --- | ---------- | --- |
+| | | | | | | | | backbone | for our | proposed | retrieval-augmented | | | framework. | |
+| obtaining | multimodal | | features | [31]–[33]. | | As a result, | RA- | | | | | | | | |
+| BLIP achieves | | question | text-to-multimodal | | | retrieval | by align- | | | | | | | | |
+ing the questions and multimodal knowledge bases in the B. Text-modality Retrieval-Augmented Models
+semantic space of three modalities: text, image, and image- Retrieval-augmented techniques have proven to be ef-
+text [34], as shown in Fig. 1(c). For the second limitation, fective plugins for both LLMs and MLLMs in academia.
+we leverage the implicit capabilities of LLMs and introduce These techniques extract pertinent world knowledge from
-Fig. 2. A conceptual illustration of the framework’s potential for enhancing transparency. (A) and (B) show the short-term and long-term
-textual profiles generated and encoded by our current approach. (C) shows a hypothetical extension wherein the final recommendation is
-explicitly justified by both sets of preferences, further strengthening user-facing transparency—an aspect we plan to explore in future work.
-TABLEI
-DATASETSSTATISTICS
-| | | | | | | | | Dataset | Users | Items | | Interactions | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --------- | ------ | ------ | ----- | ------------ | --- | --- |
-| | | | | | | | | Movies&TV | 10,000 | 14,420 | | 202,583 | | |
-| | | | | | | | | Games | 10,371 | | 3,790 | 83,842 | | |
-TABLEII
-USERPROFILESSTATISTICS
-| | | | | | | | Dataset | | Mean | Median | Mode | | StdDev | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---------- | ----------- | ----------- | -------- | --------- | --------- | ------ | ---------- | ------ |
-| | | | | | | | Movies&TV | | 11.79 | 9.00 | | 6 | 9.80 | |
-| | | | | | | | Games | | 4.55 | 3.00 | | 3 | 3.97 | |
-| | | | | | | Crucially, | | the learned | weights | | (αshort, | αlong) | explicitly | con- |
-| | | | | | | | | | | | u | u | | |
-| | | | | | | vey | the model’s | | decision | rationale | regarding | | recent | versus |
-| | | | | | | historical | user | interests. | | | | | | |
-(iii)InteractionPrediction:Topredictinteractionprobabili-
-| | | | | | | ties, | we concatenate | | user embedding | | e | with item | embedding | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | -------------- | --- | -------------- | --- | --- | --------- | --------- | --- |
-u
-| | | | | | | e and | process | through | an | MLP | [21]: | | | |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | ------- | ------- | --- | --- | ----- | --- | --- | --- |
+IEEETRANSACTIONSONMULTIMEDIA 3
+extensive databases, subsequently integrating this information A. Problem Formulation
+to formulate answers. Pioneering methods like ORQA [3]
+This paper presents a multimodal adaptive retrieval-
+have employed inverse cloze tasks for retriever pre-training,
+augmentedframeworkcalledRA-BLIPforopenmultihopand
+showcasing their efficacy on open-ended question answering
+multimodalQA,integratingretrievalandgenerationfunctions.
+datasets. Following suit, REALM [13] extends this by retriev-
+For knowledge-intensive QA, we deconstruct the task into
+ing and processing documents from comprehensive sources
+two stages: retrieval and generation, which are implemented
+like Wikipedia for logical reasoning, which is pre-trained to
+by the retriever and generator respectively. The goal of our
+reason over a large corpus of knowledge on the fly during model training is to learn the distribution P(y|x ) to generate
+q
+inference. Furthermore, RAG [17] adopts a pre-trained model a textual output y conditioned on input question x and
+q
+andnon-parametricmemoryforlanguagegeneration.FiD[18] multimodal knowledge base KB (KB = k ,...,k ). Firstly,
+1 n
+leveragesencoder-decodertransformermodelsforknowledge-
+the retriever encodes questions, images, and texts from the
+intensivetasks,settingnewbenchmarksinQA.Morerecently, knowledge base KB. It identifies the most relevant retrieved
+RETRO [19] has advanced these methods by handling longer knowledge, K ⊂KB (K is the retrieved knowledge) for
+ret ret
+sequences and accessing diverse documents for segmented each question x , which is modeled as p(K |x ). Secondly,
+q ret q
+sequences from expansive retrieval datasets. Text-modality the generator utilizes an LLM to generate answers y, condi-
+retrieval-augmented models construct dense indices as non-
+tionedonboththequestionandtheretrievedknowledge,which
+parametricdocumentmemories,usingextensivetextualknowl- is modeled as p(y|x ,K ). We treat multimodal knowledge
+q ret
+edge bases to align the retrieval process with specific queries. K asalatentvariablefromtheexternalknowledgebaseand
+ret
+Despite these advancements, a notable limitation remains the
+marginalize it to increase the overall likelihood of the answer
+needforthesemethodstoeffectivelyleveragevastmultimodal y. The overall process is encapsulated in the equation:
+knowledge, thereby constraining their applicability in the
+(cid:88)
+domain of open multimodal question answering. p(y |x q )= p(K ret |x q )·p(y |x q ,K ret ). (1)
+(cid:124) (cid:123)(cid:122) (cid:125) (cid:124) (cid:123)(cid:122) (cid:125)
+Kret⊂KB
+Retrieval Generation
+C. Multimodal Retrieval-Augmented Models This dual-stage framework effectively addresses the complex-
+To overcome the limitations of text-modality retrieval- ities of open multimodal QA by balancing the retrieval of
+augmented models, recent research [10], [15], [30], [46], [47] multimodal data and knowledge-based generation, and has
+has made strides in integrating multimodal knowledge. No- been validated by extensive experiments and ablation studies.
+tableefforts,includingAutoRouting[5]andMAE[6],involve
+trainingdistinctmodelsforeachmodalityandusingclassifiers B. Model Architecture
+for task-specific routing, though this approach often hampers
+RA-BLIP is built on a simple backbone model that is pre-
+cross-modal reasoning. MuRAG [14] seeks to overcome this
+trained to encode image-text pairs so that they are suitable
+limitation by employing separate encoders for visual and
+for both knowledge base retrieval and answer generation.
+textualmodalities,followedbyajointencoderformultimodal
+The overall framework of RA-BLIP is shown in Fig. 2. The
+fusion. However, this approach lacks integrated guidance for
+backbone model consists of a multimodal encoder f (·) and
+θ
+different modalities and cannot model the relations between
+decoderg (·),whichareusedascomponentsoftheRA-BLIP
+θ
+knowledge sources during retrieval. SKURG [20] attempts to
+model to implement retrieval and generation. The multimodal
+bridge this gap by using an entity-centered fusion encoder
+encoder f (·) contains a frozen image encoder ViT [48],
+θ
+to align modalities, yet faces challenges in computational
+Q-Former architecture [30], and the pre-trained multimodal
+efficiency and limited interpretability. Besides, Solar [21]
+adaptive fusion module. The decoder g (·) is composed of
+θ
+transforms multimodal inputs into a unified language format
+a LLM FlanT5 [8]. Querying Transformer (Q-Former) [10]
+but falls short in handling complex tasks and generalizing
+is a lightweight Transformer consisting of two modules that
+visual information. REVAL [16] leverages large-scale knowl-
+sharethesameself-attentionlayer:oneisanimagetransformer
+edgegraphstoassistvisuallanguagepre-training,butitbrings
+that interacts with the frozen image encoder ViT for visual
+a lot of calculations. In contrast, RA-BLIP distinguishes itself
+featureextraction,andtheotherisatexttransformercanactas
+by seamlessly integrating visual and language modalities into
+both text encoder and text decoder for text feature. The visual
+a cohesive semantic space, enabling the autonomous selection
+encoder, composed of ViT and Q-Former image transformer,
+of relevant knowledge for reasoning, thus addressing these
+hasinstruction-awarevisualfeatureextractioncapabilitiesand
+limitations more effectively.
+can extract visual information based on question instructions.
+We input N learnable query embeddings into the Q-Former
+III. METHODOLOGY
+imagetransformer,whichinteracts withfrozenimagefeatures
+In this section, we first formulate the research problem through cross-attention layers to obtain visual representation
+and subsequently elaborate on the model architecture of our f (I) ∈ RN×D, where D is the hidden dimension of the Q-
+θ
+retrieval-augmented framework. Then, we describe the learn- Former.Additionally,weusetheQ-Formertexttransformerto
+ablequeryinteractionapproach,followedbymultimodaladap- encode text, taking the [CLS] token as the text representation
+tive fusion module. Subsequently, we show how to train the f (T)∈R1×D.Toobtainmultimodalfeaturescombiningboth
+θ
+retrieverandranktherelevantknowledge.Lastly,weintroduce imageandtext,weintroduceapre-trainedmultimodaladaptive
+the adaptive selection knowledge generation strategy. fusion module M (·) to obtain the multimodal representation
+θ
+
+IEEETRANSACTIONSONMULTIMEDIA 4
+Q:The Marina Bay Sands
+in Singapore is made of
+what building material?
+Retrieval Knowledge
+Template: {Q}. Which item is related to this question? Positive & Negative Knowledge Pair
+Answer
+Generation Stage:
+Q-Former
+Q-Former
+Q-Former
+Fusion
+Multimodal
+LLM
+Retrieval Stage: Learnable queries
+🔥 🔥
+Image 𝑓!(𝑘"#)
+… Encoder 𝑓!(𝑘")
+Marina Bay Q K1 🔥Q-Former
+Sands Singapore 🔥
+Q:The Marina Bay Sands 𝑓!(𝑘#)
+in Singapore is made of
+what building material?
+It is close to some of Singapore's famous In Asia, the Marina 🔥 S l u a n n t d e m c a C r i k t s y , s u M c a h r i a n s a S B i a n y g a S p a o n r d e s w lo a c s a a te d d d e in d 𝑓!(𝑘#) Bay Sands, Esplanade,
+to the company's portfolio in 2010…
+…
+ModalityRepresentation
+…
+Text Question
+QA Data Format
+Image Relevant Knowledge Input
+Learnable queries
+Image-Text
+concat
+Q K2 Image Encoder
+Instruction Top-K Q K3 Q K4 Question& Caption
+Marina Bay ASKG Data Format Sands Singapore
+FeatureEncoder
+In 2010, when it opened, at total cosTt he Downtown MRInT Asia, the Marina 🔥 Classifier inc o lu f d S in $ g 8 l b a i n ll d io c n o stm, st e a t t e io rs n t i o s t b h u e i l W t a e s fe St B w oi a nf y g a S p a o n r d e s w lo a c s a a te d d d e in d Marina Bay Sands… the building. to the company's portfolio in 2010…
+Maximum Inner Product Search Ranking
+Fig. 2. The overall workflow of RA-BLIP consists of a retrieval stage and a generation stage. We utilize multimodal encoder f θ (·) to project questions
+and multimodal knowledge into a unified semantic space to achieve question text-to-multimodal retrieval, and exclude confusing knowledge by ranking.
+Additionally, we employ ASKG strategy to filter out invalid knowledge, enabling precise reasoning. The parameters of LLM and image encoder are fixed,
+onlytheQ-Formerandclassifieraretrainable.
+f (IT) ∈ R(N+1)×D. Consequently, the multimodal encoder Q-Former has aligned visual and text feature representation,
+θ
+can simultaneously encode image, text, and image-text fea- we use Image-Text Matching loss and Image-grounded Text
+tures. Questions and knowledge are encoded into multimodal Generation loss for pre-training. As shown in Fig. 3, our
+information through the multimodal encoder and then input approach is to fix the parameters of the image encoder and
+into the decoder for answer generation. In the generation Q-Former, and solely fine-tune the parameters of the multi-
+stage, compared with the retriever, the multimodal encoder modal adaptive fusion module. The module concatenates the
+discards the multimodal adaptive fusion module to reduce the visual embedding and text embedding with a dimension of
+computational cost. R(N+L)×D, where N is the learnable query embeddings and
+L is the length of text tokens. Image-text matching loss is
+used to fuse image and text representations, and the results
+C. Learnable Query Interaction for Multi-images
+of the fusion module are fed into a binary linear classifier
+Questions and image captions are used as instructions to
+foreachoutputquerytoobtainthelogitsandtaketheaverage
+extract visual features to get learnable query embeddings
+logitsofallqueriesasthematchingscore.Givenapre-training
+and input them together with text knowledge to LLMs for dataset X = {I ,T }n , we randomly sample negative texts
+i i i=1
+generation. We employ a novel approach for extracting visual
+foreachimageandrandomlysamplenegativeimagesforeach
+information to alleviate the burden of LLMs in distinguishing
+text, to generate negative training data. Therefore, we denote
+knowledge. In the original Q-Former in [30], multiple images
+the ground truth label as y ∈ {1,0} for each image-text pair
+are processed by employing multiple separate sets of queries
+(I ,T ), indicating if the input image-text pair is relevant or
+i i
+for each, with each set of queries independently extracting
+not.Weusethemultimodalencoderf (·)toencodeimage-text
+θ
+visualfeatures.Thisresultsinusingmultiplequeryfeaturesfor
+pairs and input it into the multimodal adaptive fusion module
+generation, which can be computationally intensive and less
+M (·). The objective function is defined as follows:
+θ
+efficientincapturingtheinterrelationsamongdifferentimages.
+1 (cid:88)
+In contrast, our method innovates by succinctly utilizing one L =− ylog(ρ(M (f (I );f (T )))), (2)
+itm n θ θ i θ i
+set of learnable queries to directly interact with and extract Ii,Ti∈X
+features from multiple images in a unified manner. This pro- whereρ(·)isthesoftmaxfunction.Image-groundedTextGen-
+cessoccursduringtheQ-Formerstage,enablingmoreefficient
+eration loss trains the fusion module to generate texts, given
+and integrated interaction among multiple visual references.
+input images as the condition [10], [30]. For the image-text
+By employing one set of query interaction approach, RA- pairs in the pre-training dataset, each image I corresponds to
+BLIP not only simplifies the feature extraction process but a text sentence y ={y ,...,y } of length T. We employ a
+1:T 1 T
+also enhances the efficiency of information extraction. This
+multimodalcausalself-attentionmaskformultimodalencoder
+unified interaction allows the model to understand better and f (·)andmultimodaladaptivefusionmoduleM (·)tocontrol
+θ θ
+represent the collective information presented in multiple im-
+the interaction between queries and text. The visual query
+ages, enabling more effective and cohesive feature utilization,
+functions as a prefix causal, ensuring that queries can attend
+especially when dealing with complex scenes or subjects
+to each other while excluding text tokens. Similarly, each text
+across multiple images. token y can attend to all visual queries and preceding text
+tokens. The loss function is defined as:
+D. Multimodal Adaptive Fusion Module T
+(cid:88)
+L =− logM (f ((y |y ,I)). (3)
+The pre-trained multimodal adaptive fusion module M (·) itg θ θ t