{ "rows": [ { "id": "n8_B1_50_single_d1_4", "n": 8, "budget": 0.02, "actual_kl": 0.019999966064147917, "actual_kl_kind": "certified_upper_bound", "kl_lower": 0.019999966064147917, "kl_upper": 0.019999966064147917, "kl_enclosure_width": 4.88980280386258e-35, "model_tv": 0.05801152137973986, "max_head_error": 0.23493951078551234, "family": "single", "spec": { "id": "single_d1_4", "family": "single", "shift": "1/4" }, "budget_matched": true, "cases": [ { "K": 2, "L": 0.06857508646135102, "U": 0.06857508646216331, "gap_lower": 0.01056356508161116, "width": 8.122980716525982e-13, "bellman_actions": 201, "fallback_states": 0 }, { "K": 3, "L": 0.06259081240023079, "U": 0.06259081240102617, "gap_lower": 0.004579291020490928, "width": 7.95383165798806e-13, "bellman_actions": 3195, "fallback_states": 0 }, { "K": 4, "L": 0.0593676374428469, "U": 0.059367637443296914, "gap_lower": 0.001356116063107038, "width": 4.5001355798192986e-13, "bellman_actions": 6189, "fallback_states": 0 } ] }, { "id": "n8_B1_20_single_d1_4", "n": 8, "budget": 0.05, "actual_kl": 0.049999932829739045, "actual_kl_kind": "certified_upper_bound", "kl_lower": 0.049999932829739045, "kl_upper": 0.049999932829739045, "kl_enclosure_width": 4.9904326967214e-35, "model_tv": 0.10407192441562074, "max_head_error": 0.24218356221272838, "family": "single", "spec": { "id": "single_d1_4", "family": "single", "shift": "1/4" }, "budget_matched": true, "cases": [ { "K": 2, "L": 0.12351995927019743, "U": 0.12351995927084798, "gap_lower": 0.01944803485457669, "width": 6.505432499528386e-13, "bellman_actions": 201, "fallback_states": 0 }, { "K": 3, "L": 0.1131691477039567, "U": 0.11316914770479526, "gap_lower": 0.009097223288335954, "width": 8.385584379884913e-13, "bellman_actions": 3195, "fallback_states": 0 }, { "K": 4, "L": 0.10733143138895684, "U": 0.10733143138973224, "gap_lower": 0.0032595069733361015, "width": 7.753971497869203e-13, "bellman_actions": 6189, "fallback_states": 0 } ] }, { "id": "n8_B1_10_single_d1_4", "n": 8, "budget": 0.1, "actual_kl": 0.09999987904350059, "actual_kl_kind": "certified_upper_bound", "kl_lower": 0.09999987904350059, "kl_upper": 0.09999987904350059, "kl_enclosure_width": 5.004663754794783e-35, "model_tv": 0.16218221300096047, "max_head_error": 0.2456009306529468, "family": "single", "spec": { "id": "single_d1_4", "family": "single", "shift": "1/4" }, "budget_matched": true, "cases": [ { "K": 2, "L": 0.19201755152607802, "U": 0.1920175515263913, "gap_lower": 0.02983533852511755, "width": 3.1326828354590396e-13, "bellman_actions": 201, "fallback_states": 0 }, { "K": 3, "L": 0.17691617291802686, "U": 0.17691617291856204, "gap_lower": 0.014733959917066386, "width": 5.351898511632803e-13, "bellman_actions": 3195, "fallback_states": 0 }, { "K": 4, "L": 0.16803950905887177, "U": 0.16803950906036316, "gap_lower": 0.005857296057911299, "width": 1.4913973971634927e-12, "bellman_actions": 6189, "fallback_states": 0 } ] }, { "id": "n12_B1_50_relaxed_d1_64", "n": 12, "budget": 0.02, "actual_kl": 0.019999973472031484, "actual_kl_kind": "certified_upper_bound", "kl_lower": 0.019999973472031484, "kl_upper": 0.019999973472031484, "kl_enclosure_width": 4.332004125421125e-35, "model_tv": 0.05322553409770929, "max_head_error": 0.2484656937390315, "family": "relaxed", "spec": { "id": "relaxed_d1_64", "family": "relaxed", "small_shift": "1/64", "top_shift": "1/4", "top_alternative_ratio": "1/2" }, "budget_matched": true, "cases": [ { "K": 2, "L": 0.06478036477346905, "U": 0.06478036477409801, "gap_lower": 0.011554830675759752, "width": 6.289753414178785e-13, "bellman_actions": 533, "fallback_states": 0 }, { "K": 3, "L": 0.05596104930828005, "U": 0.0559610493091502, "gap_lower": 0.0027355152105707596, "width": 8.701430363670517e-13, "bellman_actions": 19084, "fallback_states": 0 }, { "K": 4, "L": 0.05226141726143396, "U": 0.05226141726272498, "gap_lower": -0.0009641168362753311, "width": 1.2910161082484945e-12, "bellman_actions": 37635, "fallback_states": 0 } ] }, { "id": "n12_B1_20_relaxed_d1_64", "n": 12, "budget": 0.05, "actual_kl": 0.04999994966070365, "actual_kl_kind": "certified_upper_bound", "kl_lower": 0.04999994966070365, "kl_upper": 0.04999994966070365, "kl_enclosure_width": 4.342257746901678e-35, "model_tv": 0.09883983756348155, "max_head_error": 0.24918114126241575, "family": "relaxed", "spec": { "id": "relaxed_d1_64", "family": "relaxed", "small_shift": "1/64", "top_shift": "1/4", "top_alternative_ratio": "1/2" }, "budget_matched": true, "cases": [ { "K": 2, "L": 0.12048457682703884, "U": 0.12048457682771613, "gap_lower": 0.02164473926355729, "width": 6.772865820055084e-13, "bellman_actions": 533, "fallback_states": 0 }, { "K": 3, "L": 0.10444570931849739, "U": 0.10444570931933793, "gap_lower": 0.005605871755015845, "width": 8.405368745196611e-13, "bellman_actions": 19084, "fallback_states": 0 }, { "K": 4, "L": 0.09770444760852115, "U": 0.09770444760959128, "gap_lower": -0.0011353899549603973, "width": 1.0701286865834302e-12, "bellman_actions": 37635, "fallback_states": 0 } ] }, { "id": "n12_B1_10_relaxed_d1_64", "n": 12, "budget": 0.1, "actual_kl": 0.0999998931773226, "actual_kl_kind": "certified_upper_bound", "kl_lower": 0.0999998931773226, "kl_upper": 0.0999998931773226, "kl_enclosure_width": 4.5338628776702024e-35, "model_tv": 0.15800564990520213, "max_head_error": 0.2494950406472497, "family": "relaxed", "spec": { "id": "relaxed_d1_64", "family": "relaxed", "small_shift": "1/64", "top_shift": "1/4", "top_alternative_ratio": "1/2" }, "budget_matched": true, "cases": [ { "K": 2, "L": 0.1913868702868058, "U": 0.19138687028767726, "gap_lower": 0.033381220381603655, "width": 8.714720238143643e-13, "bellman_actions": 533, "fallback_states": 0 }, { "K": 3, "L": 0.1671049766273427, "U": 0.1671049766282662, "gap_lower": 0.009099326722140562, "width": 9.235130678596103e-13, "bellman_actions": 19084, "fallback_states": 0 }, { "K": 4, "L": 0.15686702539460384, "U": 0.15686702539587244, "gap_lower": -0.0011386245105982895, "width": 1.2685962679082162e-12, "bellman_actions": 37635, "fallback_states": 0 } ] }, { "id": "n16_B1_50_single_d1_8", "n": 16, "budget": 0.02, "actual_kl": 0.019999978463040427, "actual_kl_kind": "certified_upper_bound", "kl_lower": 0.019999978463040427, "kl_upper": 0.019999978463040427, "kl_enclosure_width": 5.083367056330365e-35, "model_tv": 0.0676811075010102, "max_head_error": 0.1235826612482162, "family": "single", "spec": { "id": "single_d1_8", "family": "single", "shift": "1/8" }, "budget_matched": true, "cases": [ { "K": 2, "L": 0.07539204180648085, "U": 0.07539204240849909, "gap_lower": 0.007710934305470646, "width": 6.020182424824654e-10, "bellman_actions": 1105, "fallback_states": 0 }, { "K": 3, "L": 0.07160591128013039, "U": 0.07160591128077225, "gap_lower": 0.003924803779120184, "width": 6.418603325441045e-13, "bellman_actions": 75701, "fallback_states": 0 }, { "K": 4, "L": 0.06921703004900337, "U": 0.06921703005006638, "gap_lower": 0.0015359225479931685, "width": 1.0630118599598226e-12, "bellman_actions": 150297, "fallback_states": 0 } ] }, { "id": "n16_B1_20_single_d1_8", "n": 16, "budget": 0.05, "actual_kl": 0.04999994115475418, "actual_kl_kind": "certified_upper_bound", "kl_lower": 0.04999994115475418, "kl_upper": 0.04999994115475418, "kl_enclosure_width": 5.156892136953227e-35, "model_tv": 0.11608876290525498, "max_head_error": 0.12428731698463166, "family": "single", "spec": { "id": "single_d1_8", "family": "single", "shift": "1/8" }, "budget_matched": true, "cases": [ { "K": 2, "L": 0.129168953700173, "U": 0.12916895370035283, "gap_lower": 0.013080190794918022, "width": 1.7984193475932695e-13, "bellman_actions": 1105, "fallback_states": 0 }, { "K": 3, "L": 0.12284333701245487, "U": 0.12284333701315132, "gap_lower": 0.0067545741071998846, "width": 6.964609881352321e-13, "bellman_actions": 75701, "fallback_states": 0 }, { "K": 4, "L": 0.11887869238580606, "U": 0.11887869238694705, "gap_lower": 0.0027899294805510786, "width": 1.1409952419592678e-12, "bellman_actions": 150297, "fallback_states": 0 } ] }, { "id": "n16_B1_10_single_d1_8", "n": 16, "budget": 0.1, "actual_kl": 0.09999988571616808, "actual_kl_kind": "certified_upper_bound", "kl_lower": 0.09999988571616808, "kl_upper": 0.09999988571616808, "kl_enclosure_width": 5.183377620459829e-35, "model_tv": 0.17408967062497657, "max_head_error": 0.12461830822073841, "family": "single", "spec": { "id": "single_d1_8", "family": "single", "shift": "1/8" }, "budget_matched": true, "cases": [ { "K": 2, "L": 0.19209433932883258, "U": 0.1920943393289305, "gap_lower": 0.018004668703856, "width": 9.791883603556012e-14, "bellman_actions": 1105, "fallback_states": 0 }, { "K": 3, "L": 0.18319063160197402, "U": 0.18319063160286622, "gap_lower": 0.009100960976997443, "width": 8.922103380708932e-13, "bellman_actions": 75701, "fallback_states": 0 }, { "K": 4, "L": 0.17812359402159927, "U": 0.17812359402230596, "gap_lower": 0.004033923396622698, "width": 7.066708911257519e-13, "bellman_actions": 150297, "fallback_states": 0 } ] } ], "candidates": [ { "id": "n8_B1_50_single_d1_16", "n": 8, "family": "single", "actual_kl": 0.0194308500539968, "gap": -0.00020617033169391397, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": false }, { "id": "n8_B1_50_single_d1_8", "n": 8, "family": "single", "actual_kl": 0.019999973771446196, "gap": 0.0008336203644687679, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n8_B1_50_single_d1_4", "n": 8, "family": "single", "actual_kl": 0.01999996606414797, "gap": 0.004579291021286486, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n8_B1_50_manuscript_two_level", "n": 8, "family": "manuscript", "actual_kl": 0.00831857821128072, "gap": 0.0024184840978487415, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": false }, { "id": "n8_B1_50_relaxed_d1_64", "n": 8, "family": "relaxed", "actual_kl": 0.019999974209116804, "gap": 0.004409735652359387, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n8_B1_50_relaxed_d1_32", "n": 8, "family": "relaxed", "actual_kl": 0.019999975130984837, "gap": 0.004220533749270748, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n8_B1_50_relaxed_d1_16", "n": 8, "family": "relaxed", "actual_kl": 0.019999974065901763, "gap": 0.003864006833910333, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n8_B1_50_relaxed_d1_8", "n": 8, "family": "relaxed", "actual_kl": 0.019999976298953337, "gap": 0.003540378440693659, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n8_B1_20_single_d1_16", "n": 8, "family": "single", "actual_kl": 0.0194308500539968, "gap": -0.00020617033169391397, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": false }, { "id": "n8_B1_20_single_d1_8", "n": 8, "family": "single", "actual_kl": 0.049999940941320264, "gap": 0.0017339978417713342, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n8_B1_20_single_d1_4", "n": 8, "family": "single", "actual_kl": 0.04999993282973913, "gap": 0.009097223289174505, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n8_B1_20_manuscript_two_level", "n": 8, "family": "manuscript", "actual_kl": 0.00831857821128072, "gap": 0.0024184840978487415, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": false }, { "id": "n8_B1_20_relaxed_d1_64", "n": 8, "family": "relaxed", "actual_kl": 0.04999993904209702, "gap": 0.008674456359374208, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n8_B1_20_relaxed_d1_32", "n": 8, "family": "relaxed", "actual_kl": 0.04999993999843981, "gap": 0.008240665196756411, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n8_B1_20_relaxed_d1_16", "n": 8, "family": "relaxed", "actual_kl": 0.04999994214801438, "gap": 0.00748051479122, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n8_B1_20_relaxed_d1_8", "n": 8, "family": "relaxed", "actual_kl": 0.049999934018145474, "gap": 0.00685016380685427, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n8_B1_10_single_d1_16", "n": 8, "family": "single", "actual_kl": 0.0194308500539968, "gap": -0.00020617033169391397, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": false }, { "id": "n8_B1_10_single_d1_8", "n": 8, "family": "single", "actual_kl": 0.07069520713316509, "gap": 0.0019085817049944442, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": false }, { "id": "n8_B1_10_single_d1_4", "n": 8, "family": "single", "actual_kl": 0.09999987904350069, "gap": 0.014733959917601597, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n8_B1_10_manuscript_two_level", "n": 8, "family": "manuscript", "actual_kl": 0.00831857821128072, "gap": 0.0024184840978487415, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": false }, { "id": "n8_B1_10_relaxed_d1_64", "n": 8, "family": "relaxed", "actual_kl": 0.07967918490626595, "gap": 0.012035234575114323, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": false }, { "id": "n8_B1_10_relaxed_d1_32", "n": 8, "family": "relaxed", "actual_kl": 0.08648084504224686, "gap": 0.01196944150651355, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": false }, { "id": "n8_B1_10_relaxed_d1_16", "n": 8, "family": "relaxed", "actual_kl": 0.09999988677173689, "gap": 0.01163948646369653, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n8_B1_10_relaxed_d1_8", "n": 8, "family": "relaxed", "actual_kl": 0.09999989516122347, "gap": 0.010456909189040131, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n12_B1_50_single_d1_16", "n": 12, "family": "single", "actual_kl": 0.019999978912029707, "gap": 0.0002770227726108243, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n12_B1_50_single_d1_8", "n": 12, "family": "single", "actual_kl": 0.019999974217970094, "gap": 0.002466185693778683, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n12_B1_50_single_d1_4", "n": 12, "family": "single", "actual_kl": 0.019999977394577206, "gap": 0.0016189557488572454, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n12_B1_50_manuscript_two_level", "n": 12, "family": "manuscript", "actual_kl": 0.01384669939600952, "gap": 0.0013750477842577047, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": false }, { "id": "n12_B1_50_relaxed_d1_64", "n": 12, "family": "relaxed", "actual_kl": 0.01999997347203151, "gap": 0.0027355152114408657, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n12_B1_20_single_d1_16", "n": 12, "family": "single", "actual_kl": 0.028850563104644563, "gap": 0.0003287230290106996, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": false }, { "id": "n12_B1_20_single_d1_8", "n": 12, "family": "single", "actual_kl": 0.04999994327284621, "gap": 0.004279762230950099, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n12_B1_20_single_d1_4", "n": 12, "family": "single", "actual_kl": 0.049999930034581655, "gap": 0.0035974289893762473, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n12_B1_20_manuscript_two_level", "n": 12, "family": "manuscript", "actual_kl": 0.01384669939600952, "gap": 0.0013750477842577047, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": false }, { "id": "n12_B1_20_relaxed_d1_64", "n": 12, "family": "relaxed", "actual_kl": 0.04999994966070373, "gap": 0.005605871755856154, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n12_B1_10_single_d1_16", "n": 12, "family": "single", "actual_kl": 0.028850563104644563, "gap": 0.0003287230290106996, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": false }, { "id": "n12_B1_10_single_d1_8", "n": 12, "family": "single", "actual_kl": 0.0999998846202203, "gap": 0.0054345017419989705, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n12_B1_10_single_d1_4", "n": 12, "family": "single", "actual_kl": 0.09999989027586556, "gap": 0.006074040666606023, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n12_B1_10_manuscript_two_level", "n": 12, "family": "manuscript", "actual_kl": 0.01384669939600952, "gap": 0.0013750477842577047, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": false }, { "id": "n12_B1_10_relaxed_d1_64", "n": 12, "family": "relaxed", "actual_kl": 0.09999989317732266, "gap": 0.00909932672306396, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n16_B1_50_single_d1_16", "n": 16, "family": "single", "actual_kl": 0.019999977919336925, "gap": 0.0007083556943741354, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n16_B1_50_single_d1_8", "n": 16, "family": "single", "actual_kl": 0.019999978463040392, "gap": 0.003924803779762162, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n16_B1_50_single_d1_4", "n": 16, "family": "single", "actual_kl": 0.01999997534793847, "gap": 0.0017067167844765016, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n16_B1_50_manuscript_two_level", "n": 16, "family": "manuscript", "actual_kl": 0.01939334151779694, "gap": 0.0018422975415477577, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": false }, { "id": "n16_B1_50_relaxed_d1_64", "n": 16, "family": "relaxed", "actual_kl": 0.019999967909938732, "gap": 0.0025080310246706136, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n16_B1_20_single_d1_16", "n": 16, "family": "single", "actual_kl": 0.038084739638459146, "gap": 0.0008937150499283841, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": false }, { "id": "n16_B1_20_single_d1_8", "n": 16, "family": "single", "actual_kl": 0.04999994115475413, "gap": 0.00675457410789633, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n16_B1_20_single_d1_4", "n": 16, "family": "single", "actual_kl": 0.04999993936496366, "gap": 0.003740777388260841, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n16_B1_20_manuscript_two_level", "n": 16, "family": "manuscript", "actual_kl": 0.01939334151779694, "gap": 0.0018422975415477577, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": false }, { "id": "n16_B1_20_relaxed_d1_64", "n": 16, "family": "relaxed", "actual_kl": 0.049999935009287, "gap": 0.0052291968602428684, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n16_B1_10_single_d1_16", "n": 16, "family": "single", "actual_kl": 0.038084739638459146, "gap": 0.0008937150499283841, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": false }, { "id": "n16_B1_10_single_d1_8", "n": 16, "family": "single", "actual_kl": 0.09999988571616793, "gap": 0.009100960977889483, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n16_B1_10_single_d1_4", "n": 16, "family": "single", "actual_kl": 0.09999989321873581, "gap": 0.006350806613587029, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true }, { "id": "n16_B1_10_manuscript_two_level", "n": 16, "family": "manuscript", "actual_kl": 0.01939334151779694, "gap": 0.0018422975415477577, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": false }, { "id": "n16_B1_10_relaxed_d1_64", "n": 16, "family": "relaxed", "actual_kl": 0.09999988247134689, "gap": 0.00857843795163446, "actual_kl_kind": "floating_point_estimate", "budget_matched": true } ], "all_constraints_certified": true, "certified_cases": 27, "max_optimality_interval_width": 6.020182424824654e-10, "screening_candidate_count": 54, "candidate_scope": "Floating-point screening; only selected witnesses independently certified; no outer-optimum claim", "scope": "Finite selected rational witnesses; independent integer/Fraction verification; not formal-kernel verification or an outer minimax optimum" }