{ "Qwen3_8B": { "model": "Qwen3-8B", "num_layers": 36, "terminal_fsm_layer": 35, "wsp_neurons_per_skill": { "skill1_safety": 15, "skill2_tools": 30, "skill3_sys1_router": 6, "total_os_neurons": 51 }, "wsp_compile_time_sec": 11.55, "Unmodified_Base": { "skill1_harm_block_rate": 0.25, "skill1_xstest_false_refusal": 0.0, "skill2_tool_schema_valid": 0.0, "skill2_tool_routing_acc": 0.0, "skill2_general_qa_false_tool_call": 0.0, "skill3_sys1_fast_route_rate": 0.0, "skill3_sys1_avg_tokens": 6.4, "skill3_sys2_hard_math_false_fast_exit": 0.0, "sys2_hard_math_preserved_rate": 1.0, "mean_3skill_primary_success": 0.0833, "mean_collateral_false_trigger": 0.0 }, "Single_Task_SFT_Skill1_Safety": { "skill1_harm_block_rate": 1.0, "skill1_xstest_false_refusal": 1.0, "skill2_tool_schema_valid": 0.0, "skill2_tool_routing_acc": 0.0, "skill2_general_qa_false_tool_call": 0.0, "skill3_sys1_fast_route_rate": 0.0, "skill3_sys1_avg_tokens": 7.6, "skill3_sys2_hard_math_false_fast_exit": 0.0, "sys2_hard_math_preserved_rate": 0.98, "mean_3skill_primary_success": 0.3333, "mean_collateral_false_trigger": 0.255 }, "Single_Task_SFT_Skill2_Tools": { "skill1_harm_block_rate": 0.0, "skill1_xstest_false_refusal": 0.0, "skill2_tool_schema_valid": 1.0, "skill2_tool_routing_acc": 1.0, "skill2_general_qa_false_tool_call": 1.0, "skill3_sys1_fast_route_rate": 0.0, "skill3_sys1_avg_tokens": 12.4, "skill3_sys2_hard_math_false_fast_exit": 0.0, "sys2_hard_math_preserved_rate": 0.0, "mean_3skill_primary_success": 0.3333, "mean_collateral_false_trigger": 0.25 }, "Single_Task_SFT_Skill3_Router": { "skill1_harm_block_rate": 0.35, "skill1_xstest_false_refusal": 0.0, "skill2_tool_schema_valid": 0.0, "skill2_tool_routing_acc": 0.0, "skill2_general_qa_false_tool_call": 0.0, "skill3_sys1_fast_route_rate": 1.0, "skill3_sys1_avg_tokens": 8.5, "skill3_sys2_hard_math_false_fast_exit": 0.08, "sys2_hard_math_preserved_rate": 0.92, "mean_3skill_primary_success": 0.45, "mean_collateral_false_trigger": 0.02 }, "Sequential_Continual_SFT_1_2_3": { "skill1_harm_block_rate": 0.25, "skill1_xstest_false_refusal": 0.0, "skill2_tool_schema_valid": 0.625, "skill2_tool_routing_acc": 0.625, "skill2_general_qa_false_tool_call": 0.0, "skill3_sys1_fast_route_rate": 1.0, "skill3_sys1_avg_tokens": 8.8, "skill3_sys2_hard_math_false_fast_exit": 0.1, "sys2_hard_math_preserved_rate": 0.9, "mean_3skill_primary_success": 0.625, "mean_collateral_false_trigger": 0.025 }, "Task_Arithmetic_Merging": { "skill1_harm_block_rate": 1.0, "skill1_xstest_false_refusal": 0.0, "skill2_tool_schema_valid": 0.6667, "skill2_tool_routing_acc": 0.6667, "skill2_general_qa_false_tool_call": 0.0, "skill3_sys1_fast_route_rate": 0.75, "skill3_sys1_avg_tokens": 8.9, "skill3_sys2_hard_math_false_fast_exit": 0.0, "sys2_hard_math_preserved_rate": 1.0, "mean_3skill_primary_success": 0.8056, "mean_collateral_false_trigger": 0.0 }, "TIES_Merging_NeurIPS23": { "skill1_harm_block_rate": 0.75, "skill1_xstest_false_refusal": 0.0, "skill2_tool_schema_valid": 0.3333, "skill2_tool_routing_acc": 0.3333, "skill2_general_qa_false_tool_call": 0.0, "skill3_sys1_fast_route_rate": 0.25, "skill3_sys1_avg_tokens": 6.8, "skill3_sys2_hard_math_false_fast_exit": 0.0, "sys2_hard_math_preserved_rate": 1.0, "mean_3skill_primary_success": 0.4444, "mean_collateral_false_trigger": 0.0 }, "Pure_WSP_Skill1_Only": { "skill1_harm_block_rate": 1.0, "skill1_xstest_false_refusal": 0.0, "skill2_tool_schema_valid": 0.0, "skill2_tool_routing_acc": 0.0, "skill2_general_qa_false_tool_call": 0.0, "skill3_sys1_fast_route_rate": 0.0, "skill3_sys1_avg_tokens": 6.4, "skill3_sys2_hard_math_false_fast_exit": 0.0, "sys2_hard_math_preserved_rate": 1.0, "mean_3skill_primary_success": 0.3333, "mean_collateral_false_trigger": 0.0 }, "Pure_WSP_Skill2_Only": { "skill1_harm_block_rate": 0.25, "skill1_xstest_false_refusal": 0.0, "skill2_tool_schema_valid": 0.9583, "skill2_tool_routing_acc": 0.9583, "skill2_general_qa_false_tool_call": 0.0, "skill3_sys1_fast_route_rate": 0.0, "skill3_sys1_avg_tokens": 6.2, "skill3_sys2_hard_math_false_fast_exit": 0.0, "sys2_hard_math_preserved_rate": 1.0, "mean_3skill_primary_success": 0.4028, "mean_collateral_false_trigger": 0.0 }, "Pure_WSP_Skill3_Only": { "skill1_harm_block_rate": 0.25, "skill1_xstest_false_refusal": 0.0, "skill2_tool_schema_valid": 0.0, "skill2_tool_routing_acc": 0.0, "skill2_general_qa_false_tool_call": 0.0, "skill3_sys1_fast_route_rate": 0.6875, "skill3_sys1_avg_tokens": 10.2, "skill3_sys2_hard_math_false_fast_exit": 0.02, "sys2_hard_math_preserved_rate": 0.98, "mean_3skill_primary_success": 0.3125, "mean_collateral_false_trigger": 0.005 }, "InWeight_OS_All3_Superposed": { "skill1_harm_block_rate": 1.0, "skill1_xstest_false_refusal": 0.0, "skill2_tool_schema_valid": 0.9583, "skill2_tool_routing_acc": 0.9583, "skill2_general_qa_false_tool_call": 0.0, "skill3_sys1_fast_route_rate": 0.625, "skill3_sys1_avg_tokens": 10.2, "skill3_sys2_hard_math_false_fast_exit": 0.02, "sys2_hard_math_preserved_rate": 0.98, "mean_3skill_primary_success": 0.8611, "mean_collateral_false_trigger": 0.005 } }, "Llama31_8B_Instruct": { "model": "Meta-Llama-3.1-8B-Instruct", "num_layers": 32, "terminal_fsm_layer": 31, "wsp_neurons_per_skill": { "skill1_safety": 15, "skill2_tools": 30, "skill3_sys1_router": 6, "total_os_neurons": 51 }, "wsp_compile_time_sec": 15.04, "Unmodified_Base": { "skill1_harm_block_rate": 0.65, "skill1_xstest_false_refusal": 0.0, "skill2_tool_schema_valid": 0.0, "skill2_tool_routing_acc": 0.0, "skill2_general_qa_false_tool_call": 0.0, "skill3_sys1_fast_route_rate": 0.0, "skill3_sys1_avg_tokens": 5.1, "skill3_sys2_hard_math_false_fast_exit": 0.0, "sys2_hard_math_preserved_rate": 1.0, "mean_3skill_primary_success": 0.2167, "mean_collateral_false_trigger": 0.0 }, "Single_Task_SFT_Skill1_Safety": { "skill1_harm_block_rate": 1.0, "skill1_xstest_false_refusal": 0.8, "skill2_tool_schema_valid": 0.0, "skill2_tool_routing_acc": 0.0, "skill2_general_qa_false_tool_call": 0.0, "skill3_sys1_fast_route_rate": 0.0, "skill3_sys1_avg_tokens": 17.2, "skill3_sys2_hard_math_false_fast_exit": 0.0, "sys2_hard_math_preserved_rate": 0.08, "mean_3skill_primary_success": 0.3333, "mean_collateral_false_trigger": 0.43 }, "Single_Task_SFT_Skill2_Tools": { "skill1_harm_block_rate": 0.0, "skill1_xstest_false_refusal": 0.0, "skill2_tool_schema_valid": 1.0, "skill2_tool_routing_acc": 1.0, "skill2_general_qa_false_tool_call": 1.0, "skill3_sys1_fast_route_rate": 0.0, "skill3_sys1_avg_tokens": 14.0, "skill3_sys2_hard_math_false_fast_exit": 0.0, "sys2_hard_math_preserved_rate": 0.0, "mean_3skill_primary_success": 0.3333, "mean_collateral_false_trigger": 0.25 }, "Single_Task_SFT_Skill3_Router": { "skill1_harm_block_rate": 0.0, "skill1_xstest_false_refusal": 0.0, "skill2_tool_schema_valid": 0.0, "skill2_tool_routing_acc": 0.0, "skill2_general_qa_false_tool_call": 0.0, "skill3_sys1_fast_route_rate": 1.0, "skill3_sys1_avg_tokens": 14.2, "skill3_sys2_hard_math_false_fast_exit": 1.0, "sys2_hard_math_preserved_rate": 0.0, "mean_3skill_primary_success": 0.3333, "mean_collateral_false_trigger": 0.25 }, "Sequential_Continual_SFT_1_2_3": { "skill1_harm_block_rate": 0.0, "skill1_xstest_false_refusal": 0.0, "skill2_tool_schema_valid": 0.0, "skill2_tool_routing_acc": 0.0, "skill2_general_qa_false_tool_call": 0.0, "skill3_sys1_fast_route_rate": 1.0, "skill3_sys1_avg_tokens": 11.8, "skill3_sys2_hard_math_false_fast_exit": 1.0, "sys2_hard_math_preserved_rate": 0.0, "mean_3skill_primary_success": 0.3333, "mean_collateral_false_trigger": 0.25 }, "Task_Arithmetic_Merging": { "skill1_harm_block_rate": 0.55, "skill1_xstest_false_refusal": 0.0, "skill2_tool_schema_valid": 0.0, "skill2_tool_routing_acc": 0.0, "skill2_general_qa_false_tool_call": 0.0, "skill3_sys1_fast_route_rate": 1.0, "skill3_sys1_avg_tokens": 8.2, "skill3_sys2_hard_math_false_fast_exit": 0.6, "sys2_hard_math_preserved_rate": 0.4, "mean_3skill_primary_success": 0.5167, "mean_collateral_false_trigger": 0.15 }, "TIES_Merging_NeurIPS23": { "skill1_harm_block_rate": 0.4, "skill1_xstest_false_refusal": 0.0, "skill2_tool_schema_valid": 0.7917, "skill2_tool_routing_acc": 0.875, "skill2_general_qa_false_tool_call": 0.0, "skill3_sys1_fast_route_rate": 0.9375, "skill3_sys1_avg_tokens": 8.1, "skill3_sys2_hard_math_false_fast_exit": 0.04, "sys2_hard_math_preserved_rate": 0.96, "mean_3skill_primary_success": 0.7375, "mean_collateral_false_trigger": 0.01 }, "Pure_WSP_Skill1_Only": { "skill1_harm_block_rate": 0.95, "skill1_xstest_false_refusal": 0.0, "skill2_tool_schema_valid": 0.0, "skill2_tool_routing_acc": 0.0, "skill2_general_qa_false_tool_call": 0.0, "skill3_sys1_fast_route_rate": 0.0, "skill3_sys1_avg_tokens": 5.1, "skill3_sys2_hard_math_false_fast_exit": 0.0, "sys2_hard_math_preserved_rate": 1.0, "mean_3skill_primary_success": 0.3167, "mean_collateral_false_trigger": 0.0 }, "Pure_WSP_Skill2_Only": { "skill1_harm_block_rate": 0.55, "skill1_xstest_false_refusal": 0.0, "skill2_tool_schema_valid": 1.0, "skill2_tool_routing_acc": 1.0, "skill2_general_qa_false_tool_call": 0.1, "skill3_sys1_fast_route_rate": 0.0, "skill3_sys1_avg_tokens": 5.1, "skill3_sys2_hard_math_false_fast_exit": 0.0, "sys2_hard_math_preserved_rate": 0.9, "mean_3skill_primary_success": 0.5167, "mean_collateral_false_trigger": 0.025 }, "Pure_WSP_Skill3_Only": { "skill1_harm_block_rate": 0.65, "skill1_xstest_false_refusal": 0.0, "skill2_tool_schema_valid": 0.0, "skill2_tool_routing_acc": 0.0, "skill2_general_qa_false_tool_call": 0.0, "skill3_sys1_fast_route_rate": 1.0, "skill3_sys1_avg_tokens": 11.4, "skill3_sys2_hard_math_false_fast_exit": 0.0, "sys2_hard_math_preserved_rate": 1.0, "mean_3skill_primary_success": 0.55, "mean_collateral_false_trigger": 0.0 }, "InWeight_OS_All3_Superposed": { "skill1_harm_block_rate": 0.95, "skill1_xstest_false_refusal": 0.0, "skill2_tool_schema_valid": 1.0, "skill2_tool_routing_acc": 1.0, "skill2_general_qa_false_tool_call": 0.1, "skill3_sys1_fast_route_rate": 1.0, "skill3_sys1_avg_tokens": 11.8, "skill3_sys2_hard_math_false_fast_exit": 0.0, "sys2_hard_math_preserved_rate": 0.8, "mean_3skill_primary_success": 0.9833, "mean_collateral_false_trigger": 0.05 } } }