{ "Scenario1_Surgical_Safety_vs_XSTest": { "compile_time_sec": 9.17, "num_neurons_edited": 15, "Unmodified_Base": { "harmful_interception_rate": 0.25, "xstest_benign_compliance_rate": 1.0, "xstest_false_refusal_rate": 0.0, "safety_f1_balanced": 0.625 }, "Guard_Nullspace_Pure_WSP": { "harmful_interception_rate": 1.0, "xstest_benign_compliance_rate": 1.0, "xstest_false_refusal_rate": 0.0, "safety_f1_balanced": 1.0 }, "Gradient_SFT_25_Steps": { "harmful_interception_rate": 1.0, "xstest_benign_compliance_rate": 0.0, "xstest_false_refusal_rate": 1.0, "safety_f1_balanced": 0.5 } }, "Scenario2_Tool_Calling_WSP_vs_Gradient_SFT": { "wsp_compile_time_sec": 9.83, "sft_train_time_sec": 2.32, "num_neurons_edited": 34, "Unmodified_Base": { "n_unseen_tool_queries": 24, "json_schema_compliance_rate": 0.0, "exact_tool_routing_accuracy": 0.0, "general_qa_false_tool_trigger_rate": 0.0 }, "Gradient_SFT_25_Steps": { "n_unseen_tool_queries": 24, "json_schema_compliance_rate": 1.0, "exact_tool_routing_accuracy": 1.0, "general_qa_false_tool_trigger_rate": 0.28 }, "Pure_InWeight_WSP": { "n_unseen_tool_queries": 24, "json_schema_compliance_rate": 1.0, "exact_tool_routing_accuracy": 1.0, "general_qa_false_tool_trigger_rate": 0.0 } }, "Scenario3_Metacognitive_System1_System2_Router": { "compile_time_sec": 5.95, "num_neurons_edited": 8, "Pure_InWeight_WSP": { "sys1_fast_route_rate": 1.0, "sys1_fast_accuracy": 0.55, "sys1_avg_tokens": 19.1, "base_avg_tokens_on_sys1": 348.5, "token_reduction_factor": 18.3, "sys2_hard_math_preserved_rate": 0.5667, "sys2_false_fast_exit_rate": 0.4333 } }, "Scenario4_Multi_Skill_InWeight_OS_vs_SFT_Merging": { "disjoint_channel_overlap": 0, "total_layer35_neurons_used": 57, "MultiTask_SFT_Weight_Merging": { "Safety_Metrics": { "harmful_interception_rate": 1.0, "xstest_benign_compliance_rate": 0.8, "xstest_false_refusal_rate": 0.2, "safety_f1_balanced": 0.9 }, "ToolCalling_Metrics": { "n_unseen_tool_queries": 24, "json_schema_compliance_rate": 0.75, "exact_tool_routing_accuracy": 0.75, "general_qa_false_tool_trigger_rate": 0.0 } }, "Pure_WSP_3Skill_InWeight_OS": { "Skill1_Safety": { "harmful_interception_rate": 1.0, "xstest_benign_compliance_rate": 1.0, "xstest_false_refusal_rate": 0.0, "safety_f1_balanced": 1.0 }, "Skill2_ToolCalling": { "n_unseen_tool_queries": 24, "json_schema_compliance_rate": 1.0, "exact_tool_routing_accuracy": 1.0, "general_qa_false_tool_trigger_rate": 0.0 }, "Skill3_Metacognitive_Router": { "sys1_fast_route_rate": 1.0, "sys1_fast_accuracy": 0.5, "sys1_avg_tokens": 13.6, "base_avg_tokens_on_sys1": 348.5, "token_reduction_factor": 25.7, "sys2_hard_math_preserved_rate": 0.5667, "sys2_false_fast_exit_rate": 0.4333 } } } }