{ "release_id": "MBDef-Gold-1.0.0", "export_created_at": "2026-09-08T12:09:05.811534+00:00", "export_sha256": "27ac4f2946deab4f3f8539b3a264b210f862b649cbd55353f6fe9f5bb29f9f46", "primary": { "paper_entries": 130, "nonempty_papers": 130, "records": 1003, "unique_terms_casefold": 840, "fields": { "definitions": 1192, "synonyms": 151, "description": 714, "related_terms": 1120, "subtypes": 304, "supertypes": 345, "examples": 387 }, "populated_records": { "definitions": 1003, "synonyms": 124, "description": 478, "related_terms": 652, "subtypes": 110, "supertypes": 334, "examples": 202 }, "citation_markers": 1098, "definition_multiplicity": { "1": 892, "2": 74, "3": 19, "4": 10, "5": 5, "6": 1, "9": 1, "15": 1 }, "splits": { "train": { "papers": 80, "nonempty_papers": 80, "records": 592, "definitions": 712 }, "dev": { "papers": 21, "nonempty_papers": 21, "records": 101, "definitions": 115 }, "original_test": { "papers": 14, "nonempty_papers": 14, "records": 183, "definitions": 205 }, "new_test": { "papers": 15, "nonempty_papers": 15, "records": 127, "definitions": 160 } } }, "non_relevant": { "paper_entries": 150, "nonempty_papers": 135, "records": 1325, "unique_terms_casefold": 1282, "fields": { "definitions": 1507, "synonyms": 236, "description": 890, "related_terms": 1416, "subtypes": 358, "supertypes": 506, "examples": 322 }, "populated_records": { "definitions": 1325, "synonyms": 205, "description": 642, "related_terms": 838, "subtypes": 134, "supertypes": 482, "examples": 160 }, "citation_markers": 1038, "definition_multiplicity": { "1": 1216, "2": 83, "3": 11, "4": 5, "5": 4, "6": 1, "7": 1, "8": 2, "9": 1, "14": 1 }, "splits": { "train": { "papers": 95, "nonempty_papers": 86, "records": 828, "definitions": 949 }, "dev": { "papers": 23, "nonempty_papers": 20, "records": 179, "definitions": 191 }, "original_test": { "papers": 15, "nonempty_papers": 13, "records": 168, "definitions": 201 }, "new_test": { "papers": 17, "nonempty_papers": 16, "records": 150, "definitions": 166 } } }, "v3": { "paper_entries": 150, "nonempty_papers": 150, "records": 2488, "unique_terms_casefold": 2258, "fields": { "definitions": 2865, "synonyms": 414, "description": 1718, "related_terms": 2697, "subtypes": 704, "supertypes": 906, "examples": 810 }, "populated_records": { "definitions": 2488, "synonyms": 355, "description": 1212, "related_terms": 1596, "subtypes": 259, "supertypes": 870, "examples": 403 }, "citation_markers": 2255, "definition_multiplicity": { "1": 2264, "2": 159, "3": 32, "4": 15, "5": 9, "6": 2, "7": 1, "8": 2, "9": 2, "14": 1, "15": 1 }, "splits": { "train": { "papers": 95, "nonempty_papers": 95, "records": 1510, "definitions": 1754 }, "dev": { "papers": 23, "nonempty_papers": 23, "records": 308, "definitions": 334 }, "original_test": { "papers": 15, "nonempty_papers": 15, "records": 369, "definitions": 425 }, "new_test": { "papers": 17, "nonempty_papers": 17, "records": 301, "definitions": 352 } } }, "split_origin_counts": [ { "split": "Train", "relevant": { "original": { "papers": 35, "records": 345 }, "added": { "papers": 45, "records": 247 } }, "non_relevant": { "original": { "papers": 44, "records": 540 }, "added": { "papers": 42, "records": 288 } } }, { "split": "Development", "relevant": { "original": { "papers": 12, "records": 65 }, "added": { "papers": 9, "records": 36 } }, "non_relevant": { "original": { "papers": 11, "records": 136 }, "added": { "papers": 9, "records": 43 } } }, { "split": "Test", "relevant": { "original": { "papers": 14, "records": 183 }, "added": { "papers": 15, "records": 127 } }, "non_relevant": { "original": { "papers": 13, "records": 168 }, "added": { "papers": 16, "records": 150 } } }, { "split": "Total", "relevant": { "original": { "papers": 61, "records": 593 }, "added": { "papers": 69, "records": 410 } }, "non_relevant": { "original": { "papers": 68, "records": 844 }, "added": { "papers": 67, "records": 481 } } } ], "packaging": { "relevant_empty_papers_removed": 20, "removed_relevant_paper_ids": [ "05bfced33d92944b7a0672490c371342d28ee076", "14bf8b0a9961f5c95b62861c9b7f3d5fcf778dcf", "1acbc58041a408e33ba33e2f0af5808f2bc56ff1", "2106.04554v2", "2106.16117v1", "264c3ad2d861782583e41130677fb6d7856f9dc3", "304b9778edf07175e6964dfa3f37cacec6006197", "383057f972b11b99cbc8c0d3e6c47170e9d95c1c", "4181f571f985a2e8ed2dcf716e265675218ad68e", "4d65bab6f9b1fd61885fe187e6014a89592df187", "56c569beddfd96bc0729bbb9d6f2629065b11419", "574071efbb372d219ad5adfd5c55e1ffbf8bf71d", "E105.D_2021EDR0003", "How_to_define_ecology_on_the_basis_of_its_current_understanding", "Rosen_gjcpi_2018_3", "c30d44f0b42f0ea441fd215b54c340d996f790e7", "d7701e78e0bfc92b03a89582e80cfb751ac03f26", "fa30ffaca501fbd391419a92b0cfb25881727700", "icomputing.0124", "s10816-016-9274-2" ], "retained_paper_objects_unchanged": true, "original_export_preserved": true, "non_relevant_export_unchanged": true }, "earlier_stages": { "defextra_scidef": { "paper_ids": 75, "records": 268, "unique_publications_documented": 73 }, "v2": { "paper_ids": 75, "records": 272, "unique_publications_documented": 73 } }, "fates": { "primary": 1003, "non_relevant": 1325, "definition_no": 158, "definition_unknown_relevance_no": 2 }, "approval_basis_all": { "annotation_policy": 2150, "curator": 338 }, "approval_basis_primary": { "curator": 334, "annotation_policy": 669 }, "non_relevant_supporting_fields_individually_reviewed": 0, "changed_primary_records": 174, "unchanged_primary_records": 829, "changed_record_keys": [ "016f7a076ac272db106fbcea056752c7307f676a:2", "0209e602acaeab882fee84e244caf574cf345ef9:4", "0209e602acaeab882fee84e244caf574cf345ef9:5", "0209e602acaeab882fee84e244caf574cf345ef9:19", "033b21cf1c6d3bdae587e673452b994443bf3546:0", "033b21cf1c6d3bdae587e673452b994443bf3546:2", "033b21cf1c6d3bdae587e673452b994443bf3546:5", "033b21cf1c6d3bdae587e673452b994443bf3546:12", "03c4bb2121b3dd2b5302d37c81e84092a501bc91:0", "044031c8bf57c9155572d26b0627af5ca80677f6:10", "044031c8bf57c9155572d26b0627af5ca80677f6:11", "04fce15680b781fd81dc2062b1583cc9ecd55bc0:10", "04fce15680b781fd81dc2062b1583cc9ecd55bc0:15", "04fce15680b781fd81dc2062b1583cc9ecd55bc0:18", "04fce15680b781fd81dc2062b1583cc9ecd55bc0:23", "04fce15680b781fd81dc2062b1583cc9ecd55bc0:24", "04fce15680b781fd81dc2062b1583cc9ecd55bc0:30", "04fce15680b781fd81dc2062b1583cc9ecd55bc0:31", "04fce15680b781fd81dc2062b1583cc9ecd55bc0:38", "04fce15680b781fd81dc2062b1583cc9ecd55bc0:39", "057bd5a3a6b652dfd1419128aae578478f5891b0:10", "057bd5a3a6b652dfd1419128aae578478f5891b0:11", "057bd5a3a6b652dfd1419128aae578478f5891b0:16", "057bd5a3a6b652dfd1419128aae578478f5891b0:17", "057bd5a3a6b652dfd1419128aae578478f5891b0:19", "057bd5a3a6b652dfd1419128aae578478f5891b0:20", "057bd5a3a6b652dfd1419128aae578478f5891b0:21", "057bd5a3a6b652dfd1419128aae578478f5891b0:22", "057bd5a3a6b652dfd1419128aae578478f5891b0:23", "057bd5a3a6b652dfd1419128aae578478f5891b0:25", "05b3fc81364c2ad10c3b58b3cefcf191f6feb120:15", "05b3fc81364c2ad10c3b58b3cefcf191f6feb120:19", "05b3fc81364c2ad10c3b58b3cefcf191f6feb120:31", "09c660d438e8b372f3e77504c069255b85c00256:10", "09c660d438e8b372f3e77504c069255b85c00256:23", "09c660d438e8b372f3e77504c069255b85c00256:25", "09c660d438e8b372f3e77504c069255b85c00256:28", "0d23df558a30492946059c017343a431dc3dc172:0", "0dcf170200969c29476284619dcc438070abe488:2", "0dcf170200969c29476284619dcc438070abe488:5", "0f7eda998bbce003745ff2fdbcaa1d9a8119368b:6", "118e1a32747f15bf92ddfd88abe5f00f893e4255:3", "1292dfb275a4d68cf877b3fdb37d142cae85b885:10", "1292dfb275a4d68cf877b3fdb37d142cae85b885:11", "167f1d5e64b874bea86acdef6d5476da904fec6a:1", "1ccc69b50a7495af1547833415f89536619c93e9:3", "1fc22db1adfbc21daef99f3199de1e5c8f05be09:4", "1fc22db1adfbc21daef99f3199de1e5c8f05be09:12", "2025.acl-long.1513:0", "2303.14725v2:3", "235c4f33d5bfc81bfa09a2458fcc0e42ef4454dc:1", "235c4f33d5bfc81bfa09a2458fcc0e42ef4454dc:4", "235c4f33d5bfc81bfa09a2458fcc0e42ef4454dc:6", "23eb7b57f821ec3b579605540b494d7c079a8467:2", "23eb7b57f821ec3b579605540b494d7c079a8467:5", "23eb7b57f821ec3b579605540b494d7c079a8467:9", "262153e94c3632ccf213dac45a93d8ff3cc3ff98:0", "262153e94c3632ccf213dac45a93d8ff3cc3ff98:4", "26af8e81a7ca5b137912acb81d8c19f38fce0200:0", "26af8e81a7ca5b137912acb81d8c19f38fce0200:3", "26af8e81a7ca5b137912acb81d8c19f38fce0200:4", "26af8e81a7ca5b137912acb81d8c19f38fce0200:5", "2d1201d181da2166ccbf1e922634b8b74a58f141:7", "2d1201d181da2166ccbf1e922634b8b74a58f141:15", "2d1201d181da2166ccbf1e922634b8b74a58f141:19", "32e71a5d430dafa32b3ac8df7d2b5554b55c3f29:5", "334b86c9a3c4bda5f1a127dfe72be72796f2364d:0", "3457607:0", "3457607:2", "3457607:7", "3457607:8", "3457607:24", "3457607:27", "3457607:34", "3457607:50", "34ec13e4a17aff92546ab99472e3ce95524d9add:4", "34ec13e4a17aff92546ab99472e3ce95524d9add:5", "34ec13e4a17aff92546ab99472e3ce95524d9add:6", "35266513e601aed2e2707e9263b2ccd466644b60:1", "35266513e601aed2e2707e9263b2ccd466644b60:2", "35266513e601aed2e2707e9263b2ccd466644b60:3", "35266513e601aed2e2707e9263b2ccd466644b60:6", "3584741:9", "3b50e1808471dd5a8d19a50ef227b03774b80cae:5", "3b50e1808471dd5a8d19a50ef227b03774b80cae:9", "3fbb00b939c3e84989ed922a6366608d1155aeb3:0", "3fbb00b939c3e84989ed922a6366608d1155aeb3:1", "44b1f4501cef2f9ec85d46e837da6737ebbb98c7:2", "44b1f4501cef2f9ec85d46e837da6737ebbb98c7:5", "44b1f4501cef2f9ec85d46e837da6737ebbb98c7:6", "44dc95dd0b145d265750d87a0cec5f136ec065b6:0", "44dc95dd0b145d265750d87a0cec5f136ec065b6:9", "44dc95dd0b145d265750d87a0cec5f136ec065b6:10", "4b33419863b96c270d5875af9bd5af3ce5dbb1e2:17", "5529d09545f03ad4fc611579cd8bae3d09aaa4b2:0", "591de36f141029eb8de754ff4f59a5c8be9f268d:17", "641b12df54a3d853bad273bf5fed2c0965936f83:2", "6924de9691e8f1bb5477da3907e2f5372ad0e565:26", "6924de9691e8f1bb5477da3907e2f5372ad0e565:32", "6ce27e8ceb8e7aa4e40d99312b6c98ac3f5260fb:5", "707ea8cab9147bf5c56762a97cbf425b1d6b1a94:1", "707ea8cab9147bf5c56762a97cbf425b1d6b1a94:2", "707ea8cab9147bf5c56762a97cbf425b1d6b1a94:4", "70c93e5e38a8176590f69c0491fd63ab2a9e67c4:0", "70c93e5e38a8176590f69c0491fd63ab2a9e67c4:1", "70c93e5e38a8176590f69c0491fd63ab2a9e67c4:4", "70c93e5e38a8176590f69c0491fd63ab2a9e67c4:6", "70c93e5e38a8176590f69c0491fd63ab2a9e67c4:9", "70c93e5e38a8176590f69c0491fd63ab2a9e67c4:23", "7a6823d16a1dc680c9bdfe03dc4caccbe2e944b6:0", "7a6823d16a1dc680c9bdfe03dc4caccbe2e944b6:2", "7a6823d16a1dc680c9bdfe03dc4caccbe2e944b6:5", "855a0e4669165e10caeaf7f1f3f58452610bd82a:0", "86abcc06c0270620b79bf68c1081926b56c10fa9:2", "8dd6a2c9c88c9b3465484228c93f4dcc11cfeab9:1", "8ff4cb3c4da8965b96c5d40f52298730ee097bae:0", "906e2f13fafbb3105cfc39444af00e004e86221a:4", "906e2f13fafbb3105cfc39444af00e004e86221a:17", "92427eb200269686224441fd9877de58a0a3c506:8", "92427eb200269686224441fd9877de58a0a3c506:10", "92427eb200269686224441fd9877de58a0a3c506:18", "92b4c8deecee703569b9e909dfb88aa70e691219:0", "92b4c8deecee703569b9e909dfb88aa70e691219:2", "92b4c8deecee703569b9e909dfb88aa70e691219:3", "92b4c8deecee703569b9e909dfb88aa70e691219:15", "A_survey_on_extremism_analysis_using_natural_langu:9", "A_survey_on_extremism_analysis_using_natural_langu:22", "A_survey_on_extremism_analysis_using_natural_langu:32", "a0f390307705585eae44a74d28eb6d3819979e6d:0", "a0f390307705585eae44a74d28eb6d3819979e6d:2", "a0f390307705585eae44a74d28eb6d3819979e6d:3", "a0f390307705585eae44a74d28eb6d3819979e6d:4", "a0f390307705585eae44a74d28eb6d3819979e6d:5", "a3ce69ebd2b1823b488c1d5b9d7f4b28de950a9d:5", "ac445a30aad717c7fba9a412ba8ca195a1d1603f:4", "ac445a30aad717c7fba9a412ba8ca195a1d1603f:7", "ac445a30aad717c7fba9a412ba8ca195a1d1603f:9", "cff9b9a8ec487511f4e5736aa9e4b9ab1e55969f:0", "d53723df40b36633ab301ff680df4687b6eb4c82:12", "d53723df40b36633ab301ff680df4687b6eb4c82:14", "d53723df40b36633ab301ff680df4687b6eb4c82:15", "d53723df40b36633ab301ff680df4687b6eb4c82:16", "d53723df40b36633ab301ff680df4687b6eb4c82:23", "d53723df40b36633ab301ff680df4687b6eb4c82:25", "d53723df40b36633ab301ff680df4687b6eb4c82:33", "d6baa6a163549cd7175f181483be827d43c83dbe:11", "doi:10.1145/3677092:1", "doi:10.1145/3677092:15", "doi_10.4108_eetsis.3894:3", "doi_10.48009_4_iis_2025_126:0", "dx.doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ipm.2021.102505:2", "eb29476dd81aefedf2896db42f039f003a0ec5bf:0", "hash_32ab4976acec6dfb:9", "hash_4105881299835d6b:0", "hash_4105881299835d6b:6", "hash_4105881299835d6b:14", "https://aclanthology.org/2024.lrec-main.952:0", "https://arxiv.org/abs/2312.16148:25", "https://arxiv.org/abs/2312.16148:27", "https://arxiv.org/abs/2312.16148:28", "https://arxiv.org/abs/2312.16148:29", "https://arxiv.org/abs/2312.16148:33", "https://arxiv.org/abs/2312.16148:36", "https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00799-018-0261-y:39", "https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00799-018-0261-y:40", "https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00799-018-0261-y:41", "https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00799-018-0261-y:44", "https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0957417423021437:26", "https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0957417423021437:30", "https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0957417423021437:31", "https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0957417423021437:41", "https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0957417423021437:42", "https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0957417423021437:61", "s10462-022-10338-7:11" ], "changed_fields": { "term": 3, "definitions": 52, "synonyms": 11, "description": 52, "related_terms": 19, "subtypes": 11, "supertypes": 16, "examples": 63 }, "exact_item_comparison": { "definitions": { "retained_v3_cohort": 1197, "final": 1192, "exact_unchanged": 1145, "before_only": 52, "after_only": 47 }, "synonyms": { "retained_v3_cohort": 157, "final": 151, "exact_unchanged": 146, "before_only": 11, "after_only": 5 }, "description": { "retained_v3_cohort": 731, "final": 714, "exact_unchanged": 684, "before_only": 47, "after_only": 30 }, "related_terms": { "retained_v3_cohort": 1125, "final": 1120, "exact_unchanged": 1109, "before_only": 16, "after_only": 11 }, "subtypes": { "retained_v3_cohort": 311, "final": 304, "exact_unchanged": 294, "before_only": 17, "after_only": 10 }, "supertypes": { "retained_v3_cohort": 349, "final": 345, "exact_unchanged": 337, "before_only": 12, "after_only": 8 }, "examples": { "retained_v3_cohort": 421, "final": 387, "exact_unchanged": 337, "before_only": 84, "after_only": 50 } }, "exact_cross_field_moves": [ { "source_key": "04fce15680b781fd81dc2062b1583cc9ecd55bc0:18", "from": "definitions", "to": "description", "item_sha256": "2f3c6715ece98e95d74b04e46c473a02b438e2c5539d4ed5ebf2861118ace50d" }, { "source_key": "04fce15680b781fd81dc2062b1583cc9ecd55bc0:18", "from": "definitions", "to": "description", "item_sha256": "ff581d369a38813e811da06aff72d3fd97ed18c9384a24560e4af5e5256bb2cc" }, { "source_key": "057bd5a3a6b652dfd1419128aae578478f5891b0:23", "from": "examples", "to": "description", "item_sha256": "6d38f78591eeaa2b3aa77db1acc376d466e210bd650a0a4d8d8d49db568d5090" }, { "source_key": "057bd5a3a6b652dfd1419128aae578478f5891b0:23", "from": "examples", "to": "description", "item_sha256": "8cd8fa42aa38bef782804b9902da16a7d1e6d55034010b86963e52bcf06c953b" }, { "source_key": "118e1a32747f15bf92ddfd88abe5f00f893e4255:3", "from": "supertypes", "to": "related_terms", "item_sha256": "eed9a2a8956c4d7aa91456dba508aecdb7ce6ca8d9cfd8f7509748a2c4ca87d9" }, { "source_key": "334b86c9a3c4bda5f1a127dfe72be72796f2364d:0", "from": "examples", "to": "subtypes", "item_sha256": "e29de04c52fec0df69d6a6815ae39b677ad79168613bfb0605485c54ff947e41" }, { "source_key": "334b86c9a3c4bda5f1a127dfe72be72796f2364d:0", "from": "examples", "to": "subtypes", "item_sha256": "fbdbfcf5f6d97591efafa398a55a33171a1fa651c24284adb1090bff7feb6c89" }, { "source_key": "3457607:24", "from": "description", "to": "definitions", "item_sha256": "e2e216419447dbb0a7f4f763ef9d1aadabc9e5d006aedeb340753b8687b4393f" }, { "source_key": "34ec13e4a17aff92546ab99472e3ce95524d9add:4", "from": "definitions", "to": "description", "item_sha256": "e60146539234d21d23a461787f2637d93457705eb7e62cf8393aa88db5f4f843" }, { "source_key": "5529d09545f03ad4fc611579cd8bae3d09aaa4b2:0", "from": "subtypes", "to": "examples", "item_sha256": "a6e73bb7604612db4911fe670a0e789ab990c03852ff7567eac86701ca3256ac" }, { "source_key": "5529d09545f03ad4fc611579cd8bae3d09aaa4b2:0", "from": "subtypes", "to": "examples", "item_sha256": "836e53fc06d93564434b4c1f68450fde4443430e251eea4e18100160da9a8526" }, { "source_key": "5529d09545f03ad4fc611579cd8bae3d09aaa4b2:0", "from": "subtypes", "to": "examples", "item_sha256": "407d1ac28baa1b65598d03f0572923dbab3d6124ff4925dd767ecbe7b618d129" }, { "source_key": "6924de9691e8f1bb5477da3907e2f5372ad0e565:26", "from": "examples", "to": "subtypes", "item_sha256": "b5797810c8a5e6f81028767a64b69ea88d0d4b7bb78a1446447338ebf10566a0" }, { "source_key": "707ea8cab9147bf5c56762a97cbf425b1d6b1a94:4", "from": "related_terms", "to": "subtypes", "item_sha256": "8f9ddbf5e5909711e7bdd9f5787d607cece23959142349ded7d8d1bfbb509a62" }, { "source_key": "92427eb200269686224441fd9877de58a0a3c506:18", "from": "subtypes", "to": "examples", "item_sha256": "a7bf47accb493480cdc7a8172dc7c26945e577da92b59417e89d48a1288b7506" }, { "source_key": "92427eb200269686224441fd9877de58a0a3c506:18", "from": "subtypes", "to": "examples", "item_sha256": "203e0e7aaa9b65102d821a9d1a1f6ad35a4fb6864b38b3941a7d41583c4b473c" }, { "source_key": "92427eb200269686224441fd9877de58a0a3c506:18", "from": "subtypes", "to": "examples", "item_sha256": "8826be895ee8f54187d8e79e90e85de6438a6d24ecb36fbd822bcf1770299b1b" }, { "source_key": "92427eb200269686224441fd9877de58a0a3c506:18", "from": "subtypes", "to": "examples", "item_sha256": "20678e593b22017ad22b2f999a0f436ca164afc0a30caf5e9e22c9b6886db192" }, { "source_key": "92427eb200269686224441fd9877de58a0a3c506:18", "from": "subtypes", "to": "examples", "item_sha256": "403d8b6f408d7ef95d43273ca59f351b024f4b39137c2ce6065aeab4d1f4102e" }, { "source_key": "92427eb200269686224441fd9877de58a0a3c506:18", "from": "subtypes", "to": "examples", "item_sha256": "c2a801144f34d999864a6991533d622508df817701818f00ae5aa6b86806bfc8" }, { "source_key": "A_survey_on_extremism_analysis_using_natural_langu:22", "from": "examples", "to": "subtypes", "item_sha256": "aa5ae67d562220c991ec11f3940a5c2665f5a7b6af3f60a686a6afce4e82e5bc" }, { "source_key": "a0f390307705585eae44a74d28eb6d3819979e6d:4", "from": "subtypes", "to": "related_terms", "item_sha256": "7b26d933074b5ec94bc93f3e70d923b5891999d3008d86c24d97194ef7be3523" }, { "source_key": "a0f390307705585eae44a74d28eb6d3819979e6d:4", "from": "subtypes", "to": "related_terms", "item_sha256": "752c9313a77a6ed83e4fec644044ce596039b24f06cd3d98d676e0f7229776e3" }, { "source_key": "d53723df40b36633ab301ff680df4687b6eb4c82:16", "from": "definitions", "to": "description", "item_sha256": "0eb809b0313ad04aee42f9a06ea51d17239773f0ed076bd83aff0a8c43f262e2" }, { "source_key": "d53723df40b36633ab301ff680df4687b6eb4c82:23", "from": "description", "to": "supertypes", "item_sha256": "3bc41c317f249ada3a270ffee27939fbd7f3997d50e4be84d5f302d9a0253090" }, { "source_key": "d53723df40b36633ab301ff680df4687b6eb4c82:23", "from": "examples", "to": "description", "item_sha256": "d8aad5bf4f81f57219b94356a3b004ec6d201f12d9f36e5fb14a6de8df328988" }, { "source_key": "hash_4105881299835d6b:0", "from": "definitions", "to": "description", "item_sha256": "3cb982805f1af87fc78db8243feb60e915979be9cee7d0241bceb69b7f8122dd" }, { "source_key": "https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00799-018-0261-y:39", "from": "definitions", "to": "description", "item_sha256": "35172d8f5a4d62425781e9beeef972dad57217ddf91491071ffcec2cc9b9c05a" }, { "source_key": "https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0957417423021437:30", "from": "subtypes", "to": "related_terms", "item_sha256": "a7a3a9d17ec3c0b4b8e1d818da2552a134028bb09d5a5d206bb5570709bc4376" }, { "source_key": "https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0957417423021437:30", "from": "subtypes", "to": "related_terms", "item_sha256": "c8631aca384f49582313613b936ae523714e64239933282cd5c521998a907166" }, { "source_key": "https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0957417423021437:30", "from": "subtypes", "to": "related_terms", "item_sha256": "b92359196e3d9ec0db936c00606b135bb1cc2bdf38e9ba1d657c0705d08059ba" } ], "same_paper_repeated_terms": [ { "paper_id": "d53723df40b36633ab301ff680df4687b6eb4c82", "term": "in-group bias", "records": 2 } ], "final_touch_outcomes": [ { "source_key": "3457607:0", "term": "Aggregation Bias", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "92b4c8deecee703569b9e909dfb88aa70e691219:0", "term": "deepfake", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "92b4c8deecee703569b9e909dfb88aa70e691219:3", "term": "enchantment deepfake", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "2d1201d181da2166ccbf1e922634b8b74a58f141:19", "term": "rhetorical contestation", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "6ce27e8ceb8e7aa4e40d99312b6c98ac3f5260fb:5", "term": "bias", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "235c4f33d5bfc81bfa09a2458fcc0e42ef4454dc:1", "term": "propaganda", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "2d1201d181da2166ccbf1e922634b8b74a58f141:7", "term": "framing contest", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "2d1201d181da2166ccbf1e922634b8b74a58f141:15", "term": "rhetoric", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "86abcc06c0270620b79bf68c1081926b56c10fa9:2", "term": "mainstream news sources", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "s10462-022-10338-7:11", "term": "discourse relations", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "d53723df40b36633ab301ff680df4687b6eb4c82:25", "term": "in-group bias", "outcome": "kept_existing" }, { "source_key": "a3ce69ebd2b1823b488c1d5b9d7f4b28de950a9d:5", "term": "implicit prejudice", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "04fce15680b781fd81dc2062b1583cc9ecd55bc0:23", "term": "stereotype threat", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "118e1a32747f15bf92ddfd88abe5f00f893e4255:3", "term": "individual level", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "0209e602acaeab882fee84e244caf574cf345ef9:5", "term": "fuzzy trace theory", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "0209e602acaeab882fee84e244caf574cf345ef9:19", "term": "ratio bias", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "04fce15680b781fd81dc2062b1583cc9ecd55bc0:30", "term": "internalized homophobia", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "04fce15680b781fd81dc2062b1583cc9ecd55bc0:31", "term": "residual internalized homophobia", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "26af8e81a7ca5b137912acb81d8c19f38fce0200:0", "term": "Undone science", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "26af8e81a7ca5b137912acb81d8c19f38fce0200:3", "term": "nonknowledge", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "26af8e81a7ca5b137912acb81d8c19f38fce0200:4", "term": "negative knowledge", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "26af8e81a7ca5b137912acb81d8c19f38fce0200:5", "term": "nescience", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "34ec13e4a17aff92546ab99472e3ce95524d9add:5", "term": "selective exposure", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "34ec13e4a17aff92546ab99472e3ce95524d9add:6", "term": "selective avoidance", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "44dc95dd0b145d265750d87a0cec5f136ec065b6:0", "term": "bad ideology", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "44dc95dd0b145d265750d87a0cec5f136ec065b6:9", "term": "fake news", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "70c93e5e38a8176590f69c0491fd63ab2a9e67c4:4", "term": "illusory correlation", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "70c93e5e38a8176590f69c0491fd63ab2a9e67c4:6", "term": "self-fulfilling prophecy", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "70c93e5e38a8176590f69c0491fd63ab2a9e67c4:9", "term": "belief persistence", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "05b3fc81364c2ad10c3b58b3cefcf191f6feb120:15", "term": "Framing", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "09c660d438e8b372f3e77504c069255b85c00256:28", "term": "time discounting", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "262153e94c3632ccf213dac45a93d8ff3cc3ff98:0", "term": "evaluation", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "262153e94c3632ccf213dac45a93d8ff3cc3ff98:4", "term": "register", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "3b50e1808471dd5a8d19a50ef227b03774b80cae:9", "term": "digital divide", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "A_survey_on_extremism_analysis_using_natural_langu:32", "term": "Terrorism", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "eb29476dd81aefedf2896db42f039f003a0ec5bf:0", "term": "hypothetical bias", "outcome": "all_applied" }, { "source_key": "A_survey_on_extremism_analysis_using_natural_langu:22", "term": "Polarization", "outcome": "kept_existing" } ], "annotation_archive": { "papers": 150, "records": 2488, "fragments": 321, "definitions": 2865, "raw_annotations": 920, "duplicate_annotations": 6, "third_records": 931, "notes": 309, "records_with_notes": 263, "records_with_field_conflicts": 177, "records_with_negative_fields": 240, "records_with_unmapped": 54, "records_with_field_issues": 475, "review_phases": { "confirm": 2011, "work": 477 }, "questions": { "definition_is_definition": { "complete_pairs": 2486, "missing_pairs": 2, "yes_yes": 2095, "no_no": 59, "disagree": 332, "agreement": 0.8664521319388576, "alpha_nominal": 0.1889665339820138, "final": { "Yes": 2332, "No": 154, "unresolved": 2 } }, "term_relevant": { "complete_pairs": 2488, "missing_pairs": 0, "yes_yes": 737, "no_no": 1050, "disagree": 701, "agreement": 0.7182475884244373, "alpha_nominal": 0.4275484535490198, "final": { "No": 1460, "Yes": 1028 } } }, "outcomes": { "Yes / No": 1325, "Yes / Yes": 1007, "No / No": 133, "No / Yes": 21, "unresolved / No": 2 }, "splits": { "dev": { "papers": 23, "records": 308, "both_yes": 101, "valid_definitions": 280, "disagreements": 102 }, "new_test": { "papers": 17, "records": 301, "both_yes": 127, "valid_definitions": 277, "disagreements": 105 }, "original_test": { "papers": 15, "records": 369, "both_yes": 184, "valid_definitions": 352, "disagreements": 110 }, "train": { "papers": 95, "records": 1510, "both_yes": 595, "valid_definitions": 1423, "disagreements": 614 } } }, "canonical_task_annotations_by_stage": { "weekly": 435, "third": 272, "rest": 207 }, "annotator_task_annotation_counts": { "1": { "weekly": 8 }, "2": { "weekly": 50, "rest": 104 }, "3": { "weekly": 42, "rest": 103 }, "4": { "weekly": 9 }, "5": { "weekly": 49 }, "6": { "weekly": 49 }, "7": { "weekly": 49 }, "8": { "weekly": 50 }, "9": { "weekly": 49 }, "10": { "weekly": 50 }, "11": { "third": 29 }, "12": { "weekly": 30 }, "13": { "third": 68 }, "14": { "third": 68 }, "15": { "third": 39 }, "16": { "third": 68 } }, "primary_original_supporting_fit_coverage": { "units": 2163, "zero_fit_answers": 37, "one_fit_answer": 165, "two_or_more_fit_answers": 1961 }, "missing_paper_metadata": { "title": 0, "authors": 0, "publication_year": 0, "doi": 3, "venue": 34 }, "pdf_identity": { "papers": 150, "available": 150, "same_input": 150 }, "integrity_checks": { "all_2488_decisions_reviewed": true, "all_final_touches_approved": true, "all_exported_fields_equal_saved_decisions": true, "all_paper_metadata_and_splits_preserved": true, "raw_originals_byte_identical": true, "no_duplicate_items_within_primary_fields": true }, "counting_notes": [ "Definition record = paper-specific concept; definition statement = one item in definitions; example = one item in examples.", "Earlier unique-publication counts follow the supplied IE wiki and data README; identical normalized titles alone are not treated as publication identity.", "Before-only and after-only items include text/citation edits and moves. They are not counts of semantic deletions and additions.", "Supporting fit coverage refers to original V3 items, not the resulting edited items; absent votes are not agreement.", "annotation_policy records preserve accepted human outcomes but do not imply individual curator checking of every supporting field." ] }