instruction stringlengths 35 27.7k |
|---|
To get the ball rolling... I will answer this question this evening
For people aware & unaware I think it would be a great way to introduce the group, resources for fundamental knowledge & concepts.
|
I want to start learning quantitative finance, what articles or blogs should I look at to start?
Also see the Related Question on Quantitative Finance Books
|
How do you model concentration risk of credit portfolio in IRB/Basel II framework?
|
It seems that VIX futures could be a great hedge for a long-only stock portfolio since they rise when stocks fall. But how many VIX futures should I buy to hedge my portfolio, and which futures expiration should I use?
|
At my work I often see option prices or vols quoted against deltas rather than against strikes. For example for March 2013 Zinc options I might see 5 quotes available for deltas as follows:
ZINC MARCH 2013 OPTION DELTA -10 POINTS
ZINC MARCH 2013 OPTION DELTA -25 POINTS
ZINC MARCH 2013 OPTION DELTA +10 POINTS
ZINC MARC... |
There are three different commonly used Value at Risk (VaR) methods:
Historical method
Variance-Covariance Method
Monte Carlo
What is the difference between these approaches, and under what circumstances should each be used?
|
When using time-series analysis to forecast some type of value, what types of error analysis are worth considering when trying to determine which models are appropriate.
One of the big issues that may arise is that successive residuals between the 'forecast' and the 'realized' value of the variable may not be properly ... |
According to the Wikipedia article,
Contracts similar to options are believed to have been used since ancient times.
In London, puts and "refusals" (calls) first became well-known trading instruments in the 1690s during the reign of William and Mary.
Privileges were options sold over the counter in nineteenth century ... |
Are there any empirical observations or practices when to prefer Local Volatility Model for pricing over Stochastic Model or vice versa?
|
When looking at option chains, I often notice that the (broker calculated) implied volatility has an inverse relation to the strike price. This seems true both for calls and puts.
As a current example, I could point at the SPY calls for MAR31'11 : the 117 strike has 19.62% implied volatility, which decreaseses quite s... |
There are few methods like Copeland-Antikarov, Herath-Park, Cobb-Charnes etc. to compute project volatility, however these methods compute upward biased volatility.
What is the best method I could use to compute project volatility for real option valuation?
|
Consider the following strategies:
a stat arb strategy with no overnight exposure, but significant market exposure intraday.
a market timing model which is always long or short the market.
etc
is it meaningful to consider the betas of strategies like these? Or should we ignore beta when the portfolio returns have low... |
Assume we decompose the daily (log) returns of a stock as beta times market movement plus an idiosyncratic part. If this is done ex-ante, what proportion of the variance is explained by the market component vs. the idiosyncratic part? I am looking more for rule of thumb/experience of others, based on, say, U.S. equitie... |
I'm currently using IB's Java API and getting feeds through them. However the real-time feed is updated only every 250ms and the historical feed only every second.
I'm primarily looking for ES data and other index futures and ETFs. I'm not looking at FX since that data is the most subjective since there is no exchange.... |
What is the theoretical/mathematical basis for the valuation of [C]MBS and other structured finance products? Is the methodology mostly consistent across different products?
|
It appears that the log 'returns' of the VIX index have a (negative) correlation to the log 'returns' of e.g. the S&P 500 index. The r-squared is on the order of 0.7. I thought VIX was supposed to be a measure of volatility, both up and down. However, it appears to spike up when the market spikes down, and has a fairly... |
Is there a standard model for market impact? I am interested in the case of high-volume equities sold in the US, during market hours, but would be interested in any pointers.
|
One of the main problems when trying to apply mean-variance portfolio optimization in practice is its high input sensitivity. As can be seen in (Chopra, 1993) using historical values to estimate returns expected in the future is a no-go, as the whole process tends to become error maximization rather than portfolio opti... |
A potential issue with automated trading systems, that are based on Machine Learning (ML) and/or Artificial Intelligence (AI), is the difficulty of assessing the risk of a trade. An ML/AI algorithm may analyze thousands of parameters in order to come up with a trading decision and applying standard risk management prac... |
I want to create a lognormal distribution of future stock prices. Using a monte carlo simulation I came up with the standard deviation as being $\sqrt{(days/252)}$ $*volatility*mean*$ $\log(mean)$. Is this correct?
|
I would like to take advantage of a volatile market by selling highs and buying lows. As we all know the RSI indicator is very bad and I want to create a superior strategy for this purpose.
I have tried to model the price using a time varying ARMA process, with no success for now.
Any other ideas?
|
Explain pair trading to a layman. What is it, why would you want to do it, and what are the risks? Provide a real life example.
|
There are all kinds of tools for backtesting linear instruments (like stocks or stock indices). It is a completely different story when it comes to option strategies. Most of the tools used are bespoke software not publicly available. Part of the reason for that seems to be the higher complexity involved, the deluge of... |
Naively, it seems that Bayesian modeling, structural models particularly, would be quite useful in finance because of their ability to incorporate market idiosyncrasies and produce accurate probabilistic estimates.
The down-side of course, is model-brittleness and extremely slow computational speed. Has the Quant comm... |
Are the prices of e-minis such as S&P 500, Russell 2000, EUROSTOXX, etc. manipulated? That is, are there traders who trade large enough positions to make the price go in the direction they want, taking unfair advantage of the rest of the traders in that market?
If so, what implication does this have for designing any t... |
Mean-reversion and trend-following strategies have some kind of a theory behind them that explains why they might work, if implemented well. Pattern-recognition, on the other hand, seems like nothing more than data mining and overfitting. Could patterns possibly have any predictive value? In other words, is there any ... |
I heard about MetaTrader from http://www.metaquotes.net. Is there any other framework or program available? Do you use different software for backtracking and running your trading algorithms?
Thank you guys for your great answers. I will check out the posted applications.
|
I know the derivation of the Black-Scholes differential equation and I understand (most of) the solution of the diffusion equation. What I am missing is the transformation from the Black-Scholes differential equation to the diffusion equation (with all the conditions) and back to the original problem.
All the transfor... |
Back in the mid 90's I used the Black-Scholes Model and the Cox-Ross-Rubenstein (Binomial) Model's to price Options. That was nearly 15 years ago and I was wondering if there are any new models being used to price Options?
|
What is a coherent risk measure, and why do we care? Can you give a simple example of a coherent risk measure as opposed to a non-coherent one, and the problems that a coherent measure addresses in portfolio choice?
|
I've struggled for a long time to understand this - What is this? And how does it affect you?
Yes I mean risk neutral pricing - Wilmott Forums was not clear about that.
|
Any recommendations on the best schools and overall education choices for quantitative finance?
|
I am not very sure, if this question fits in here.
I have recently begun, reading and learning about machine learning. Can someone throw some light onto how to go about it or rather can anyone share their experience and few basic pointers about how to go about it or atleast start applying it to see some results from da... |
How do I price OANDA box options without using their slow and
machine-unfriendly user interface?:
http://fxtrade.oanda.com (free demo account) sells "box options":
If you already know what a box option is (or visit
http://fxtrade.oanda.com/trade-forex/fxtrade/box-options or signup
for a free demo account), you c... |
Since Mandelbrot, Fama and others have performed seminal work on the topic, it has been suspected that stock price fluctuations can be more appropriately modeled using Lévy alpha-stable distrbutions other than the normal distribution law. Yet, the subject is somewhat controversial, there is a lot of literature in defen... |
Suppose you have two sources of covariance forecasts on a fixed set of $n$ assets, method A and method B (you can think of them as black box forecasts, from two vendors, say), which are known to be based on data available at a given point in time. Suppose you also observe the returns on those $n$ assets for a following... |
I am currently trading futures products on some contracts that have low volumes. More accurately, the volumes of working orders in the book are fairly light. I am trying to execute a relatively large order that could move the market. I would like to break the order up to prevent this but I am unsure of the best algorit... |
Weak schemes, such as Ninomiya-Victoir or Ninomiya-Ninomiya, are typically used for discretization of stochastic volatility models such as the Heston Model.
Can anyone familiar with Cubature on Wiener Spaces explain why (i.e. with a detailed proof or a reference) these weak schemes can be seen as a Cubature scheme over... |
The sensitivity of the option value $V$ to volatility $\sigma$ (a.k.a. vega) is different from the other greeks. It is a derivative with respect to a parameter and not a variable. To quote from Paul Wilmott On Quantitative Finance (Wiley, 2nd edition, p. 127):
It’s not even Greek. Among other things it is an American ... |
One cannot directly buy and sell the VIX index. Theoretically, however, one could approximate the index by purchasing an at-the-money straddle on the SP500, then delta-hedging the straddle.
Does anyone have experience with such a "synthetic" replication of the index? It might be very useful for betting on volatility or... |
Are there common procedures prior or posterior backtesting to ensure that a quantitative trading strategy has real predictive power and is not just one of the thing that has worked in the past by pure luck? Surely if we search long enough for working strategies we will end up finding one. Even in a walk forward approac... |
What sources of financial and economic data are available online? Which ones are free or cheap? What has your experience been like with these data sources?
|
Prompted in part by this question on data snooping, I would be interested to know:
What are the key risks that should be considered when developing a quantitative strategy based on: (a) historical data or (b) simulated data?
|
I work with practical, day-to-day trading: just making money. One of my small clients recently hired a smart, new MFE. We discussed potential trading strategies for a long time. Finally, he expressed surprise that I never mentioned (much less used) stochastic calculus, which he spent many long hours studying in his MFE... |
When faced with a black box trading strategy with extensive historical data available, how would one select/construct a representative benchmark?
As a trivial example, when a strategy historically consists only of long trades on tech stock, the Nasdaq Composite index might be a suitable benchmark.
What about benchmar... |
There are a few things that form the common canon of education in (quantitative) finance, yet everybody knows they are not exactly true, useful, well-behaved, or empirically supported.
So here is the question: which is the single worst idea still actively propagated?
Please make it one suggestion per post.
|
I'd like to get a feel for the operating parameters of official market makers. I'm looking more for discerning characteristics, rather than exact numbers or an exhaustive list of each MM.
Examples: what is their working capital? How much leverage do they use intraday? What returns do they achieve? What is their contri... |
Wikipedia lists three of them:
Extreme event: hypothesize the portfolio's return given the recurrence of a historical event. Current positions and risk exposures are combined with the historical factor returns.
Risk factor shock: shock any factor in the chosen risk model by a user-specified amount. The factor exposure... |
Usually even good performing quant trading strategies work for a while and then return start to shrink. I see two reasons for that which would probably give rise to different analysis:
The Strategy got known by too many traders and has been arbitraged away.
Market conditions have changed (will or will not revert).
|
Let's say I have a brand new fancy model on some asset class (calibration porcedure included over a set of vanilla options) in which I truly believe I made a step forward comparing to existing literature (a phantasmatic situation I recognize).
Which criteria should be in order so I can claim that I am in a position to... |
Let's say you want to calculate a VaR for a portfolio of 1000 stocks. You're really only interested in the left tail, so do you use the whole set of returns to estimate mean, variance, skew, and shape (let's also assume a skewed generalized error distribution - SGED)? Or would you just use the left tail (let's say the ... |
If I design a trading model, I might want to know the model's half life. Unfortunately, it doesn't seem possible to predict alpha longevity without a meta-model of the market. Intuitively, such a meta-model does not exist, but has that ever been proven? This sounds like a Russell's paradox or Gödel's incompleteness the... |
The practice of using Gaussian copulas in modeling credit derivatives has come under a lot of criticism in the past few years. What are the major arguments against using the copula method in this respect?
|
How do you explain what a stationary process is? In the first place, what is meant by process, and then what does the process have to be like so it can be called stationary?
|
In order to use Real Option Valuation (ROV), using Black-Scholes equation, I must know the volatility of the economic returns for T years. Knowing this information what could be the appropriate measure of computing volatility of the economic returns from my reservoir?
The distribution of PV for any particular year is ... |
I have several measures:
1. Profit and loss (PNL).
2. Win to loss ratio (W2L).
3. Avg gain to drawdown ratio (AG2AD).
4. Max gain to maximum drawdown ratio (MG2MD).
5. Number of consecutive gains to consecutive losses ratio (NCG2NCL).
If there were only 3 measures (A, B, C), then I could represent the "total" me... |
I notice that, on the surface, there are some similarities between quantitative sports betting and quantitative finance. Both have the concept of arbitraging, etc.
What are the applications of quantitative finance that lend themselves readily to sports betting?
|
In Paul Wilmott on Quantitative Finance Sec. Ed. in vol. 3 on p. 784 and p. 809 the following stochastic differential equation: $$dS=\mu\ S\ dt\ +\sigma \ S\ dX$$ is approximated in discrete time by $$\delta S=\mu\ S\ \delta t\ +\sigma \ S\ \phi \ (\delta t)^{1/2}$$ where $\phi$ is drawn from a standardized normal dist... |
There are many corporate actions that will affect the stock price, like dividend, stock split and rights.
Given a large series of historical price data, how do we adjust the data to filter out the effect of the corporate action?
|
I've asked this question here at Physics SE, but I figured that some parts would be more appropriate to ask here. So I'm rephrasing the question again.
We know that for option value calculation, path integral is one way to solve it. But the solution I get from the Black-Scholes formula (derived from the above question)... |
Everyone seems to agree that the option prices predicted by the Black-Merton-Scholes model are inconsistent with what is observed in reality. Still, many people rely on the model by using "the wrong number in the wrong formula to get the right price".
Question. What are some of the most important contradictions that o... |
What is the intuition behind cointegration? What does the Dickey-Fuller test do to test for it? Ideally, a non-technical explanation would be appreciated.
Say you need to explain it to an investor and justify why your pairs trading strategy should make him rich!
|
How do volatility and variance differ in finance and what do both imply about the movement of an underlying?
|
For a vanilla option, I know that the probability of the option expiring in the money is simply the delta of the option... but how would I calculate the probability, without doing monte carlo, of the underlying touching the strike at some time at or before maturity?
|
How can I use a binomial tree to price a European option that's based on a portfolio of equity products? I have volatility and correlation matrix of all underlying products?
Looking for a formula based solution so that I use in Matlab. Thanks.
|
I've always wondered about this.
If you have a series of options, with the expires spaced let's say one week between them, and you search for each expiration date the option with the smallest premium, would the series of strikes represent the current market predicted path of the asset?
Can you use that information to s... |
For the Black-Scholes model my feeling is that the volatility parameter is like sweeping stuff under the rug.
Are there models which improve on the volatility aspect of Black-Scholes by adding other parameters (I'm guessing things like the distribution of past returns, or perhaps some measure of debt load held by the c... |
Does the debt load of a company have an impact on the stock price of a company and its volatility? Also, how does the market react to the announcement of a company issuing bonds?
|
Forward volatility implied by SPX options, and that of VIX futures get out of line. If there existed VIX SQUARED futures they could easily be replicated (and arbitraged) with a strip of SPX options. However replicating VIX futures would theoretically require dynamic trading in options (all strikes) and is also would de... |
The model assumption of the Black-Scholes formula has two parameters for the geometric Brownian motion, the volatility $\sigma$ and the expected growth $\mu$ (which disappears in the option formulae). How can this parameter $\mu$ be estimated?
|
How much is QuantLib used in industry and how much street cred does it have?
|
Can Someone Explain to me what this term means, and how it's used?
|
Many times, we want to calculate VaR using some parametric approach (delta-normal approximation for instance) when historical simulation or monte carlo are simply to slow. This is fine as long as only the deltas are needed and the instruments are reasonably linear.
But when the approach is extended to use both deltas a... |
It was pointed in an other question that ensemble methods can help to reduce curve fitting.
What are your experience with these and which one seems the most appropriate? If I had two forecasters that give reasonably good results. Would it be better to use both and invest half in each (diversification) or use one of th... |
What is the difference between the two?
Today in the FT I see that UBS is the second biggest 'wealth manager' after BOA whilst I was always under the impression that Blackrock was the largest asset manager.
|
This is a bit of a subjective question and relates primarily to the UK market
There are a number of banks who are lending at BOE + 1.49% (ie: 1.99 %) whilst at the same time accepting deposits paying 2.75%
Granted the 2.75 is a bonus rate but I just cannot understand how writing these kind of mortgages are beneficial ... |
This sentence in the following paper got me thinking:
"Some traders [...] trade every pattern whether proven or not, expecting
authentic ones to produce positive results, whilst the profits and losses of
fake patterns cancel each other out."
http://www.seasonalcharts.com/img/ZUTEXTEN/saisonalitaet_e.pdf
Then I got my h... |
Are there any papers about possible trading strategies you can apply when you know where a large cluster of orders is located in the order-book?
These seem to fall in the liquidity-provisioning/hunting range of strategies, is this correct?
|
On average, how much slippage (measured in lost % return potential) is typical for an operating quant fund that trades in, say, major U.S. equities?
|
What are some trading strategies for stocks (just stocks, no derivatives) using freely available online data sources?
|
What are the main categories of systematic trading strategies (e.g. momentum, mean reversion), as might be considered by an index or fund-of-fund analyst?
Are there any common sub-strategies?
|
I don't quite understand how anyone would invest in VXX (asides from short-term trades)... Since the VIX term structure is generally in contango, the VXX is doomed to bleed to death.
Therefore, how exactly does this type of structure work (ETN)? Eventually, the capital raised by selling these notes will run out - what... |
I'm curious about high performance computing and consider algo/program trading as an interesting source of information about what are performant technologies that are used to trade the markets.
Is scala being used out there? Is it a viable language for a startup prop shop? Would it be considered an advantageous languag... |
Similar to this other question about Scala, I'm interested in knowing whether F# is used to any measurable degree in financial circles. Have there been any successful shops using it, any research on performance and viability?
|
What programming languages are the most common in quantitative finance, and why are these languages used?
Note: I do not mean, what languages are used to develop the accounting system at a hedge fund: this is specifically related to aspects of valuation and trading.
|
How many trades per second are we talking about?
What kind of strategies are used in this time frame?
Can the small guy play the game?
|
By HFT here I mean anything with holding period less than 5 to 10 minutes.
Any empirical/anecdotal evidence of using it successfully on even higher frequencies?
|
Are there ways to measure the risk aversion of a representative investor, based on publicly available market data? Public available data could include asset price, volume, and flow data, and may be aggregated according to some criterion (asset class and contract type being the most obvious). Pointers to any existing l... |
Some of the largest funds in the world are entirely macro-based: Soros, Brevan Howard, Bridgewater. They trade across asset classes, and seemingly with very concentrated allocations. What type of risk management framework do they adopt?
|
Is there any published research of decent quality linking news or unstructured information to asset returns? I know that Thomson Reuters offers its Machine Readable news (MRN), so somebody must use it. But I can't find much in the public domain.
|
Mean-variance optimization (MVO) is a 50+ year concept, and perhaps the first seminal idea of quantitative finance. Still, as far as I know, less than 25% of AUM in the US is quantitatively managed. While a small minority of fundamental managers use MVO, that is counterbalanced by statistical arbitrage and HF strategie... |
What is a martingale and how it compares with a random walk in the context of the Efficient Market Hypothesis?
|
I often hear people talking about the skew of the volatility surface, model, etc... but it appears to me that there isn't a clear standard definition unanimously used by practitioners.
So here is my question: Does anyone have a clear and unifying definition that can be stated in mathematical terms of what skew is in th... |
Common wisdom holds it that a moving average approach is more successful than buy-and-hold. There is quantitative evidence for that across different asset classes (see e.g. this book, or this paper from the same author Mebane Faber).
My question takes a different turn: I am trying to generalize these empirical findings... |
In the interest of having "canonical questions" on this site ... What is a Quant?
|
The fascinating thing about volatility pumping (or optimal growth portfolio, see e.g. here) is that here volatility is not the same as risk, rather it represents opportunity. Additionally it is a generic mechanical strategy that is independent of asset classes.
My question:
Do you know examples where volatility pumping... |
I am starting to work with options data from optionmetrics. I use data frames, but it seems like xts or zoo objects are the way to go for features and speed. I can't figure out the best work-around to get 1 row per date. Should I be doing a list of xts objects with one object per optionid?
Here's my current approach: I... |
In the spirit of canonical questions please state here versions of the FTAP in the following form (please only one theorem by answer) :
Necessary definitions (or a direct link to definitions)
Hypothesys and Context (such as existence or not of transaction costs, discrete time setting, etc...)
Statement of the The... |
People "on the Street" distinguish between quants and structurers. Who are the structurers? what do they do?
|
I need to model MBS coupon stack prices. It would not be difficult to create something from scratch, but I don't want to re-invent the wheel (and explain why I did) if a somewhat standard model already exists. By "somewhat standard", I mean models like those for the term structure (e.g. Nelson-Siegel / Nelson–Siegel–... |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.