"""End-to-end grading of built tasks with the real promtool/amtool (ยง12.1 behaviors).""" import copy import hashlib import json import os import random import subprocess import sys from alertforge import render, solutions from alertforge.grader.grade import KEYS, Grader from conftest import needs_tools def grade(m, state, grader=None): files, am, extra = state return render.grade_state(m["world"], m["spec"], m["hidden_dir"], m["static"], files, am, grader, extra) def req_of(m, kind): return next(r for r in m["world"].reqs if r.kind == kind) @needs_tools def test_oracle_null_partial(easy_task): ko, _ = grade(easy_task, solutions.oracle(easy_task["world"])) kn, _ = grade(easy_task, solutions.null(easy_task["world"])) kp, _ = grade(easy_task, solutions.partial(easy_task["world"])) assert set(ko) == set(KEYS) assert ko["reward"] == 1.0 and ko["solved"] == 1.0 and ko["preservation"] == 1.0 assert kn["reward"] == 0.0 and kn["progress"] == 0.0 and kn["preservation"] == 1.0 assert kp["outcome"] == 0.0 and 0.05 < kp["reward"] < 0.4 @needs_tools def test_hard_task_oracle_is_one(hard_task): ko, det = grade(hard_task, solutions.oracle(hard_task["world"])) assert ko["reward"] == 1.0, det["requirements"] @needs_tools def test_duplicate_definition_costs_twenty_percent_not_everything(easy_task): """S4: a duplicate (fixed copy next to the broken one) keeps most of the credit.""" w = easy_task["world"] files, am, _ = solutions.oracle(w) a = req_of(easy_task, "new_alert").alert rule = copy.deepcopy(next(x for _, x in solutions._alert_rules(files, a.name))) files["scratch"] = [{"name": "scratch", "rules": [rule]}] k, det = grade(easy_task, (files, am, {})) q = det["requirements"][a.req_id]["q"] assert 0.75 <= q < 1.0 and k["outcome"] == 0.0 @needs_tools def test_missing_continue_gets_jaccard_credit(easy_task): """S6: a route that reaches PagerDuty but not Slack earns partial credit, not zero.""" w = easy_task["world"] files, am, _ = solutions.oracle(w) team = req_of(easy_task, "route").route["team"] for rt in am["route"]["routes"]: if rt.get("matchers") == [f'team="{team}"']: rt["routes"][0].pop("continue") _, det = grade(easy_task, (files, am, {})) s = det["requirements"][req_of(easy_task, "route").id]["s"] assert 0.2 < s < 1.0 @needs_tools def test_stray_files_are_ignored_and_yaml_error_costs_at_most_half(easy_task): """S5: scratch files never zero the reward; one unparsable file keeps >= half of progress.""" w = easy_task["world"] files, am, _ = solutions.oracle(w) k, _ = grade(easy_task, (files, am, {"notes/todo.md": "x", "scratch.yml": "groups: [["})) assert k["reward"] == 1.0 stem = "fleet" k2, det = grade(easy_task, (files, am, {f"rules/{stem}.yml": solutions.break_indent})) assert k2["syntax_ok"] == 0.0 and k2["outcome"] == 0.0 and k2["tamper"] == 0.0 assert k2["progress"] > 0.4 @needs_tools def test_label_error_costs_label_family_only(easy_task): """S3b: a wrong severity keeps Fire/Silent credit (probes select only alertname/alertstate/service).""" w = easy_task["world"] files, am, _ = solutions.oracle(w) a = req_of(easy_task, "new_alert").alert for _, x in solutions._alert_rules(files, a.name): x["labels"]["severity"] = "warning" _, det = grade(easy_task, (files, am, {})) fams = det["requirements"][a.req_id]["families"]["integrated"] assert fams["fire"] == 1.0 and fams["silent"] == 1.0 and fams["label_annot"] < 1.0 assert 0.7 <= det["requirements"][a.req_id]["q"] < 1.0 @needs_tools def test_decoupled_pass_gives_half_credit_when_sli_is_broken(easy_task): """S3a: a correct burn alert on top of broken SLI recording rules keeps about half its credit.""" w = easy_task["world"] files, am, _ = solutions.oracle(w) for g in files["slo-recording"]: for x in g["rules"]: x["expr"] = x["expr"].replace("sum by (service) ", "sum ") _, det = grade(easy_task, (files, am, {})) a = req_of(easy_task, "new_alert").alert assert det["requirements"][a.req_id]["families"]["decoupled"]["fire"] == 1.0 assert 0.4 <= det["requirements"][a.req_id]["q"] <= 0.6 @needs_tools def test_tamper_adversaries_zero_everything(easy_task): w = easy_task["world"] for name in ("A-alerts-inject", "A-shadow-series", "A-group-interval"): k, _ = grade(easy_task, solutions.adversary(w, name)) assert k["tamper"] == 1.0 and k["reward"] == 0.0, name @needs_tools def test_always_fire_and_rename_score_zero_on_alert_requirements(easy_task): w = easy_task["world"] for name in ("A-fire", "A-silent"): k, _ = grade(easy_task, solutions.adversary(w, name)) assert k["req_alerts"] <= 0.05 and k["req_repairs"] <= 0.05 and k["outcome"] == 0.0, name @needs_tools def test_receiver_null_and_over_inhibit_block_outcome(easy_task): w = easy_task["world"] k, _ = grade(easy_task, solutions.adversary(w, "A-receiver-null")) assert k["outcome"] == 0.0 and k["preservation"] < 1.0 k, _ = grade(easy_task, solutions.adversary(w, "A-inhibit-all")) assert k["req_inhibit"] <= 0.05 @needs_tools def test_pmut_is_interior(easy_task): rng = random.Random(3) g = Grader(easy_task["spec"], easy_task["hidden_dir"]) xs = [grade(easy_task, solutions.pmut(easy_task["world"], rng)[0], g)[0]["reward"] for _ in range(6)] assert all(0.0 <= x <= 1.0 for x in xs) and max(xs) > 0.05 @needs_tools def test_grader_cli_writes_all_keys(easy_task, tmp_path): """tests/grade.py (the copied grader) produces the same keys as the library.""" task_dir = os.path.dirname(os.path.dirname(easy_task["hidden_dir"])) ws = os.path.join(task_dir, "environment", "workspace", "monitoring") out = tmp_path / "reward.json" subprocess.run([sys.executable, "-I", os.path.join(task_dir, "tests", "grade.py"), "--workspace", ws, "--spec", os.path.join(task_dir, "tests", "spec.json"), "--hidden", os.path.join(task_dir, "tests", "hidden"), "--out", str(out)], check=True, env={**os.environ}, capture_output=True) keys = json.loads(out.read_text()) assert set(keys) == set(KEYS) and keys["reward"] == 0.0 def _tree_hash(root): h = hashlib.sha256() for dp, _, fns in sorted(os.walk(root)): for fn in sorted(fns): p = os.path.join(dp, fn) h.update(os.path.relpath(p, root).encode()) with open(p, "rb") as fh: h.update(fh.read()) return h.hexdigest() @needs_tools def test_build_is_deterministic(tmp_path): a = render.build_task("alert-storm-cleanup", "medium", 2, str(tmp_path / "a"), "t", 7) b = render.build_task("alert-storm-cleanup", "medium", 2, str(tmp_path / "b"), "t", 7) assert _tree_hash(os.path.join(tmp_path, "a", "t")) == _tree_hash(os.path.join(tmp_path, "b", "t")) assert a["n_checks"] == b["n_checks"] @needs_tools def test_checksums_and_solution_scripts(easy_task): task_dir = os.path.dirname(os.path.dirname(easy_task["hidden_dir"])) r = subprocess.run(["shasum", "-a", "256", "-c", "checksums.sha256"], cwd=os.path.join(task_dir, "tests"), capture_output=True, text=True) assert r.returncode == 0, r.stdout + r.stderr solve = open(os.path.join(task_dir, "solution", "solve.sh")).read() assert solve.startswith("#!/bin/bash") and "AF_EOF" in solve @needs_tools def test_grading_is_deterministic_across_fresh_graders(hard_task): """M10: promtool group order is pinned (group_eval_order), so repeated grades are bit-identical.""" st = solutions.partial(hard_task["world"]) vals = {grade(hard_task, st)[0]["reward"] for _ in range(3)} assert len(vals) == 1