{
 "what": "the ablation effect in nats, the unit the papers' bodies now use",
 "why_not_control_units": "at 83.9 B and 2,034 B the control SD is ~2.2x its own mean and still rising with the mask count while the mean is flat, so the unit's denominator has not converged; the same ratio is 1.04 at 4.19 B. Measured on the 200-mask run's nested prefixes (50/100/200).",
 "definition": {
  "rise_over_random_nats": "PRIMARY. (loss rise with the carrier set zeroed) minus (mean loss rise over the size-matched random sets), in nats, at the construct's own positions. Signed; no absolute value is taken anywhere.",
  "ratio_rise_to_random": "the carriers' rise divided by the random sets' mean rise. Reported as a RATIO OF MEDIANS over the constructs, because per construct the denominator runs down to and below zero at the later references. Per-construct ratios are given only where the control mean is > 0.",
  "sign_test": "count of constructs with rise_over_random_nats > 0, one-sided binomial against p = 0.5, over the 16 constructs at that reference.",
  "interval": "construct bootstrap, 10000 resamples of the 16 constructs with replacement, 95% percentile interval, seed 20261023. It describes the spread over constructs, not over control masks.",
  "old_set_at_the_end": "the 84 B carrier set removed at the end of pretraining, under the SAME masks as the current set: against the random sets (drifted - random mean) and against the current set (drifted - current).",
  "control_units": "retained ONLY in Table D.1, with each cell's mask count and stability flag."
 },
 "fixed_before_computing": true,
 "n_bootstrap": 10000,
 "seed": 20261023,
 "nested_prefixes": [
  50,
  100,
  200
 ],
 "per_reference": {
  "pretrain_iter_0001000": {
   "tokens_b": 4.19,
   "n_constructs": 16,
   "median_rise_over_random_nats": {
    "point": 0.06004436395484443,
    "lo": 0.024286819103405632,
    "hi": 0.13978772430179226,
    "n": 16
   },
   "ratio_of_medians_rise_to_random": {
    "point": 1.8061572238751271,
    "lo": 0.9761315558087134,
    "hi": 3.0569293693446005,
    "n": 16,
    "n_bootstrap_draws_usable": 10000
   },
   "sign_test_rise_over_random": {
    "n_above_zero": 12,
    "n": 16,
    "p": 0.0384063720703125
   },
   "median_carrier_rise_nats": 0.1390074489264248,
   "median_control_mean_nats": 0.07696309440225975,
   "per_construct_ratio": {
    "median_where_control_mean_positive": 1.8952659247256178,
    "n_used": 15,
    "n_excluded_control_mean_not_positive": 1,
    "excluded": [
     "ImportFrom"
    ]
   },
   "old_set": {
    "n_constructs_with_an_old_set": 0,
    "n_without": 16,
    "without": [
     "AsyncFor",
     "AsyncWith",
     "DictComp",
     "For",
     "GeneratorExp",
     "If",
     "IfExp",
     "Import",
     "ImportFrom",
     "Lambda",
     "ListComp",
     "NamedExpr",
     "SetComp",
     "Try",
     "While",
     "With"
    ],
    "median_vs_random_nats": {
     "point": null,
     "lo": null,
     "hi": null,
     "n": 0
    },
    "sign_test_vs_random": {
     "n_above_zero": null,
     "n": 0,
     "p": null
    },
    "median_vs_current_nats": {
     "point": null,
     "lo": null,
     "hi": null,
     "n": 0
    },
    "sign_test_vs_current": {
     "n_above_zero": null,
     "n": 0,
     "p": null
    },
    "n_old_below_current": 0
   },
   "per_construct": {
    "AsyncFor": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.06137299656953882,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.1417616092162448,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.08038861264670599,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 1.7634538593079407,
     "old_set_rise_nats": null,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": null,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": null
    },
    "AsyncWith": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.13978772430179226,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.20135072762003325,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.06156300331824099,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 3.270644977782841,
     "old_set_rise_nats": null,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": null,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": null
    },
    "DictComp": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.047933189323970546,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.10147391727992527,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.05354072795595473,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 1.8952659247256178,
     "old_set_rise_nats": null,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": null,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": null
    },
    "For": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.09263123321000709,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.18285812355942976,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.09022689034942268,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 2.0266477416130946,
     "old_set_rise_nats": null,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": null,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": null
    },
    "GeneratorExp": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.07569352252834317,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.15341256596715258,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.07771904343880941,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 1.9739379073539294,
     "old_set_rise_nats": null,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": null,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": null
    },
    "If": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": -0.04876296739883557,
     "carrier_rise_nats": -0.007977972562978164,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.04078499483585741,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": -0.19561048358804936,
     "old_set_rise_nats": null,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": null,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": null
    },
    "IfExp": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.05871573134015004,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.1362532886366048,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.07753755729645476,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 1.7572553661402832,
     "old_set_rise_nats": null,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": null,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": null
    },
    "Import": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.22105402579674288,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.27605540935809714,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.05500138356135427,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 5.019063003208932,
     "old_set_rise_nats": null,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": null,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": null
    },
    "ImportFrom": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": -0.00778127230130736,
     "carrier_rise_nats": -0.12070604471059987,
     "control_mean_nats": -0.11292477240929251,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": null,
     "old_set_rise_nats": null,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": null,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": null
    },
    "Lambda": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.6315083511220289,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.7078969826300936,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.07638863150806474,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 9.267046269252216,
     "old_set_rise_nats": null,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": null,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": null
    },
    "ListComp": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.024286819103405632,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.1092176328455734,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.08493081374216777,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 1.2859600424545012,
     "old_set_rise_nats": null,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": null,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": null
    },
    "NamedExpr": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": -0.14858770022025558,
     "carrier_rise_nats": -0.06559552901830479,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.08299217120195078,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": -0.7903821296431263,
     "old_set_rise_nats": null,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": null,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": null
    },
    "SetComp": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.0414091395061026,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.11136166093313093,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.06995252142702833,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 1.5919606421806962,
     "old_set_rise_nats": null,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": null,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": null
    },
    "Try": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 1.2425026400511898,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 1.3229805639758707,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.08047792392468081,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 16.43904936233254,
     "old_set_rise_nats": null,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": null,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": null
    },
    "While": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": -0.039820757364221936,
     "carrier_rise_nats": -0.014500070499991025,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.02532068686423091,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": -0.5726570759213664,
     "old_set_rise_nats": null,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": null,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": null
    },
    "With": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.17854971480688853,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.28541309173618057,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.10686337692929204,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 2.670822314786374,
     "old_set_rise_nats": null,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": null,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": null
    }
   }
  },
  "pretrain_iter_0020000": {
   "tokens_b": 83.9,
   "n_constructs": 16,
   "median_rise_over_random_nats": {
    "point": 0.25268668652530085,
    "lo": 0.02602596914825126,
    "hi": 0.6588617618729049,
    "n": 16
   },
   "ratio_of_medians_rise_to_random": {
    "point": 11.174771508709787,
    "lo": 1.7271411001670052,
    "hi": 52.5190763881226,
    "n": 16,
    "n_bootstrap_draws_usable": 10000
   },
   "sign_test_rise_over_random": {
    "n_above_zero": 14,
    "n": 16,
    "p": 0.0020904541015625
   },
   "median_carrier_rise_nats": 0.32930909617916604,
   "median_control_mean_nats": 0.029468978038834845,
   "per_construct_ratio": {
    "median_where_control_mean_positive": 6.7413528930959385,
    "n_used": 15,
    "n_excluded_control_mean_not_positive": 1,
    "excluded": [
     "For"
    ]
   },
   "old_set": {
    "n_constructs_with_an_old_set": 16,
    "n_without": 0,
    "without": [],
    "median_vs_random_nats": {
     "point": 0.02434357676988906,
     "lo": -0.026207095711364536,
     "hi": 0.08764601776602574,
     "n": 16
    },
    "sign_test_vs_random": {
     "n_above_zero": 10,
     "n": 16,
     "p": 0.2272491455078125
    },
    "median_vs_current_nats": {
     "point": -0.2898017259744501,
     "lo": -0.6723527702583278,
     "hi": -0.05500254704468488,
     "n": 16
    },
    "sign_test_vs_current": {
     "n_above_zero": 4,
     "n": 16,
     "p": 0.9893646240234375
    },
    "n_old_below_current": 12
   },
   "per_construct": {
    "AsyncFor": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.02602596914825126,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.03523392910916123,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.009207959960909973,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 3.826464196058391,
     "old_set_rise_nats": -0.09800286217450394,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": -0.10721082213541391,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": -0.13323679128366517
    },
    "AsyncWith": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.03217448555944999,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.0490670496454606,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.016892564086010614,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 2.9046537515340805,
     "old_set_rise_nats": 0.18220664636017014,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": 0.16531408227415953,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": 0.13313959671470954
    },
    "DictComp": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.4281601395923266,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.48711215427943655,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.05895201468710992,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 8.262858476759497,
     "old_set_rise_nats": 0.00564692798925881,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": -0.05330508669785111,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": -0.48146522629017774
    },
    "For": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.08465567316752604,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.0788237883653009,
     "control_mean_nats": -0.005831884802225122,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": null,
     "old_set_rise_nats": -0.01794954477366506,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": -0.012117659971439938,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": -0.09677333313896597
    },
    "GeneratorExp": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.8970058238627341,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.9429304660274287,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.045924642164694635,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 20.532124401664316,
     "old_set_rise_nats": 0.18608261485995303,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": 0.1401579726952584,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": -0.7568478511674757
    },
    "If": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.05960959234939671,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.06999209164169384,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.010382499292297138,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 6.7413528930959385,
     "old_set_rise_nats": 0.014989544597008964,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": 0.004607045304711826,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": -0.05500254704468488
    },
    "IfExp": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 1.0731419517282241,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 1.1635968880727887,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.0904549363445646,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 12.863829605057356,
     "old_set_rise_nats": 0.16443624813109636,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": 0.07398131178653176,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": -0.9991606399416924
    },
    "Import": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.022428884689625284,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.17150603807889553,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.14907715338927024,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 1.15045152244797,
     "old_set_rise_nats": -0.11024042276235768,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": -0.2593175761516279,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": -0.2817464608412532
    },
    "ImportFrom": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": -0.43918748562152554,
     "carrier_rise_nats": -0.2848721650930557,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.15431532052846986,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": -1.8460394218634903,
     "old_set_rise_nats": -0.1401679699237537,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": -0.29448329045222355,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": 0.144704195169302
    },
    "Lambda": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 3.8369725854773424,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 3.844317145878449,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.00734456040110672,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 523.4237225823844,
     "old_set_rise_nats": 0.05142466863617301,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": 0.04408010823506629,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": -3.792892477242276
    },
    "ListComp": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.5197241099806604,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.565710187563436,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.04598607758277563,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 12.301770824988264,
     "old_set_rise_nats": 0.09841740433939838,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": 0.05243132675662276,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": -0.46729278322403767
    },
    "NamedExpr": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.42071769988307567,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.5067045245415125,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.08598682465843681,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 5.8928158651547085,
     "old_set_rise_nats": 0.20884753343386553,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": 0.12286070877542872,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": -0.29785699110764696
    },
    "SetComp": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.6461456745469634,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.6881910665386224,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.042045391991659076,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 16.367811879959284,
     "old_set_rise_nats": 0.01583829628029454,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": -0.026207095711364536,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": -0.6723527702583278
    },
    "Try": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 3.4988873004364223,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 3.5069999124854805,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.008112612049058087,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 432.2898582205296,
     "old_set_rise_nats": 0.09140870977938177,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": 0.08329609773032369,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": -3.4155912027060986
    },
    "While": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": -0.07366901902332387,
     "carrier_rise_nats": -0.06427306234153035,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.009395956681793527,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": -6.840502198788525,
     "old_set_rise_nats": 0.012056895694054603,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": 0.002660939012261077,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": 0.07632995803558495
    },
    "With": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.001406819300193686,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.013242842895643925,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.011836023595450239,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 1.1188591158887573,
     "old_set_rise_nats": 0.15001671867711197,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": 0.13818069508166173,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": 0.13677387578146805
    }
   }
  },
  "pretrain_iter_0484865": {
   "tokens_b": 2034.0,
   "n_constructs": 16,
   "median_rise_over_random_nats": {
    "point": 0.39888110736894633,
    "lo": 0.09934602462474562,
    "hi": 0.6977292483455034,
    "n": 16
   },
   "ratio_of_medians_rise_to_random": {
    "point": 9.944733243336401,
    "lo": 5.084409255049531,
    "hi": 18.656260036453425,
    "n": 16,
    "n_bootstrap_draws_usable": 10000
   },
   "sign_test_rise_over_random": {
    "n_above_zero": 14,
    "n": 16,
    "p": 0.0020904541015625
   },
   "median_carrier_rise_nats": 0.4434750708240446,
   "median_control_mean_nats": 0.04459396345509829,
   "per_construct_ratio": {
    "median_where_control_mean_positive": 10.805383009148146,
    "n_used": 15,
    "n_excluded_control_mean_not_positive": 1,
    "excluded": [
     "AsyncFor"
    ]
   },
   "old_set": {
    "n_constructs_with_an_old_set": 14,
    "n_without": 2,
    "without": [
     "For",
     "If"
    ],
    "median_vs_random_nats": {
     "point": 0.1381389299737911,
     "lo": -0.014188191741530347,
     "hi": 0.41911791138237475,
     "n": 14
    },
    "sign_test_vs_random": {
     "n_above_zero": 10,
     "n": 14,
     "p": 0.08978271484375
    },
    "median_vs_current_nats": {
     "point": -0.28285799362492714,
     "lo": -0.7728800694211678,
     "hi": -0.1068401375595407,
     "n": 14
    },
    "sign_test_vs_current": {
     "n_above_zero": 3,
     "n": 14,
     "p": 0.9935302734375
    },
    "n_old_below_current": 11
   },
   "per_construct": {
    "AsyncFor": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": -0.2793529407997275,
     "carrier_rise_nats": -0.28349481836519597,
     "control_mean_nats": -0.004141877565468466,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": null,
     "old_set_rise_nats": -0.046018336537248405,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": -0.04187645897177994,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": 0.23747648182794756
    },
    "AsyncWith": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.36211711238765243,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.4033340231443827,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.04121691075673031,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 9.78564418679831,
     "old_set_rise_nats": 0.1525754706504252,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": 0.11135855989369489,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": -0.2507585524939575
    },
    "DictComp": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.2624303299127795,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.33314869160554883,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.07071836169276936,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 4.710922080645595,
     "old_set_rise_nats": 0.22630855404600814,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": 0.1555901923532388,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": -0.1068401375595407
    },
    "For": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.09934602462474562,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.10947780882247238,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.010131784197726756,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 10.805383009148146,
     "old_set_rise_nats": null,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": null,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": null
    },
    "GeneratorExp": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.5484637447299087,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.5844476452938796,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.035983900563970946,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 16.241920306968073,
     "old_set_rise_nats": 0.4551018119463457,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": 0.41911791138237475,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": -0.1293458333475339
    },
    "If": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.3449590033573854,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.35956109269265674,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.014602089335271335,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 24.623948288286197,
     "old_set_rise_nats": null,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": null,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": null
    },
    "IfExp": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 1.5715097992933198,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 1.6695803925395007,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.09807059324618102,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 17.024271366937164,
     "old_set_rise_nats": 0.8262225513656931,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": 0.728151958119512,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": -0.8433578411738076
    },
    "Import": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.46120921006569526,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.6679911613464355,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.2067819512807403,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 3.2304132793462634,
     "old_set_rise_nats": 0.04502850312453077,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": -0.16175344815620954,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": -0.6229626582219048
    },
    "ImportFrom": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.09396879076957676,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.39929918142465404,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.3053303906550773,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 1.3077610144472338,
     "old_set_rise_nats": 0.17609676947960473,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": -0.12923362117547255,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": -0.2232024119450493
    },
    "Lambda": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 4.989185355374357,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 4.991929735212277,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.0027443798379197183,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 1818.9645858192266,
     "old_set_rise_nats": 3.5500454863843824,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": 3.547301106546463,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": -1.4418842488278942
    },
    "ListComp": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.9598133943407666,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 1.0094922351353057,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.04967884079453909,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 20.320366155690845,
     "old_set_rise_nats": 0.15053607848695094,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": 0.10085723769241185,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": -0.8589561566483548
    },
    "NamedExpr": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": -0.05719311390263118,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.06876956193875117,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.12596267584138235,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 0.5459518978887744,
     "old_set_rise_nats": 0.36871654788653085,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": 0.2427538720451485,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": 0.2999469859477797
    },
    "SetComp": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.4356451023502402,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.48361611850370645,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.047971016153466266,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 10.081423269345558,
     "old_set_rise_nats": 0.16865868374780968,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": 0.1206876675943434,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": -0.31495743475589677
    },
    "Try": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 5.952905459320899,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 6.004058102428913,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.05115264310801402,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 117.37532486348228,
     "old_set_rise_nats": 4.19116915589571,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": 4.140016512787696,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": -1.812888946533203
    },
    "While": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.07536396214123299,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.10473492604876872,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.02937096390753573,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 3.565934246437748,
     "old_set_rise_nats": 0.29686423732873496,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": 0.2674932734211992,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": 0.19212931127996624
    },
    "With": {
     "rise_over_random_nats": 0.545586879988467,
     "carrier_rise_nats": 0.5767353416553564,
     "control_mean_nats": 0.0311484616668894,
     "ratio_rise_to_random": 18.515692615036013,
     "old_set_rise_nats": -0.11006864053862442,
     "old_set_over_random_nats": -0.1412171022055138,
     "old_set_minus_current_nats": -0.6868039821939809
    }
   }
  }
 },
 "minutes": 0.009780418872833253,
 "provenance": {
  "inputs": [
   "validation/paper2/ABLATION_STABLE.json"
  ],
  "reference": null,
  "battery_prompt_hash": "570b42db13f8fe5772b8d1a9ad7d55d6fa1279dae5948ad94e8363789bcbc1ad",
  "code_commit": "f7c2832",
  "design": "9-Paper-1/2610-18Oct_PAPER-1-Design.md sha256 47f6a664\u2026"
 }
}