{ "what": "rank correlation and cosine of the full profile between the checkpoint pairs the turnover curve uses, at two spacings", "why": "whether 'identity never settles' holds beyond the 5% cut", "pairs": { "1000_steps|pretrain_iter_0001000|pretrain_iter_0002000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0001000", "pretrain_iter_0002000" ], "spacing": "1000_steps", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.48942749145079356, "cosine_q1": 0.46246508084803317, "cosine_q3": 0.5115876302681298, "spearman_median": 0.42409853433444616, "start_iter": 1000, "gap_steps": 1000, "seconds": 187.07419085502625 }, "1000_steps|pretrain_iter_0002000|pretrain_iter_0003000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0002000", "pretrain_iter_0003000" ], "spacing": "1000_steps", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.6762590384272051, "cosine_q1": 0.644232743672844, "cosine_q3": 0.6961454045483575, "spearman_median": 0.5934760316790375, "start_iter": 2000, "gap_steps": 1000, "seconds": 94.03488612174988 }, "1000_steps|pretrain_iter_0003000|pretrain_iter_0004000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0003000", "pretrain_iter_0004000" ], "spacing": "1000_steps", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.7674510500768417, "cosine_q1": 0.7456609763881956, "cosine_q3": 0.7840697442054547, "spearman_median": 0.7006740908038582, "start_iter": 3000, "gap_steps": 1000, "seconds": 106.48627424240112 }, "1000_steps|pretrain_iter_0004000|pretrain_iter_0005000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0004000", "pretrain_iter_0005000" ], "spacing": "1000_steps", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.8040297757127138, "cosine_q1": 0.7851648627214047, "cosine_q3": 0.8180454790538494, "spearman_median": 0.7391918982302598, "start_iter": 4000, "gap_steps": 1000, "seconds": 106.03576183319092 }, "1000_steps|pretrain_iter_0005000|pretrain_iter_0006000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0005000", "pretrain_iter_0006000" ], "spacing": "1000_steps", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.8235332305718789, "cosine_q1": 0.8080059802609721, "cosine_q3": 0.8368693210128372, "spearman_median": 0.7634483322737606, "start_iter": 5000, "gap_steps": 1000, "seconds": 305.0325198173523 }, "1000_steps|pretrain_iter_0006000|pretrain_iter_0007000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0006000", "pretrain_iter_0007000" ], "spacing": "1000_steps", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.838299474052172, "cosine_q1": 0.819598482331474, "cosine_q3": 0.8513474854880819, "spearman_median": 0.7809595696695968, "start_iter": 6000, "gap_steps": 1000, "seconds": 110.45385909080505 }, "1000_steps|pretrain_iter_0007000|pretrain_iter_0008000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0007000", "pretrain_iter_0008000" ], "spacing": "1000_steps", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.8467655346760151, "cosine_q1": 0.8318354536965901, "cosine_q3": 0.861554767750627, "spearman_median": 0.7890872769770638, "start_iter": 7000, "gap_steps": 1000, "seconds": 106.50146317481995 }, "1000_steps|pretrain_iter_0008000|pretrain_iter_0009000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0008000", "pretrain_iter_0009000" ], "spacing": "1000_steps", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.8550795545549741, "cosine_q1": 0.8368336987966989, "cosine_q3": 0.8659278285840936, "spearman_median": 0.7986349247845556, "start_iter": 8000, "gap_steps": 1000, "seconds": 107.19754886627197 }, "1000_steps|pretrain_iter_0009000|pretrain_iter_0010000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0009000", "pretrain_iter_0010000" ], "spacing": "1000_steps", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.8578195774286926, "cosine_q1": 0.8413788340092354, "cosine_q3": 0.8698994264830775, "spearman_median": 0.8028357173114992, "start_iter": 9000, "gap_steps": 1000, "seconds": 103.77549433708191 }, "1000_steps|pretrain_iter_0010000|pretrain_iter_0011000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0010000", "pretrain_iter_0011000" ], "spacing": "1000_steps", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.8638838280225619, "cosine_q1": 0.8477454388177856, "cosine_q3": 0.8752756636107326, "spearman_median": 0.809318029123952, "start_iter": 10000, "gap_steps": 1000, "seconds": 107.29857778549194 }, "1000_steps|pretrain_iter_0011000|pretrain_iter_0012000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0011000", "pretrain_iter_0012000" ], "spacing": "1000_steps", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.8677139983238744, "cosine_q1": 0.8549990841269997, "cosine_q3": 0.8792880234563857, "spearman_median": 0.8158351532873395, "start_iter": 11000, "gap_steps": 1000, "seconds": 106.1564929485321 }, "1000_steps|pretrain_iter_0012000|pretrain_iter_0013000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0012000", "pretrain_iter_0013000" ], "spacing": "1000_steps", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.8711259295040532, "cosine_q1": 0.8583213775812834, "cosine_q3": 0.8821006106193763, "spearman_median": 0.8174362196089971, "start_iter": 12000, "gap_steps": 1000, "seconds": 105.80073714256287 }, "1000_steps|pretrain_iter_0013000|pretrain_iter_0014000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0013000", "pretrain_iter_0014000" ], "spacing": "1000_steps", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.8756648725993573, "cosine_q1": 0.8620978172982875, "cosine_q3": 0.8852808982581976, "spearman_median": 0.8232333131016188, "start_iter": 13000, "gap_steps": 1000, "seconds": 107.77378296852112 }, "1000_steps|pretrain_iter_0014000|pretrain_iter_0015000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0014000", "pretrain_iter_0015000" ], "spacing": "1000_steps", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.8766591581408588, "cosine_q1": 0.8649807216123289, "cosine_q3": 0.8869637284062235, "spearman_median": 0.8249507076020118, "start_iter": 14000, "gap_steps": 1000, "seconds": 105.37118887901306 }, "1000_steps|pretrain_iter_0015000|pretrain_iter_0016000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0015000", "pretrain_iter_0016000" ], "spacing": "1000_steps", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.8773545556446287, "cosine_q1": 0.8661501476871274, "cosine_q3": 0.8889981536754119, "spearman_median": 0.8280691254396072, "start_iter": 15000, "gap_steps": 1000, "seconds": 108.48856806755066 }, "1000_steps|pretrain_iter_0016000|pretrain_iter_0017000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0016000", "pretrain_iter_0017000" ], "spacing": "1000_steps", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.8799373509212491, "cosine_q1": 0.8674164987973891, "cosine_q3": 0.8912211421925408, "spearman_median": 0.8286805927796463, "start_iter": 16000, "gap_steps": 1000, "seconds": 107.1411190032959 }, "1000_steps|pretrain_iter_0017000|pretrain_iter_0018000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0017000", "pretrain_iter_0018000" ], "spacing": "1000_steps", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.8838860522893355, "cosine_q1": 0.8714035467699234, "cosine_q3": 0.8944142088034371, "spearman_median": 0.8341017558902462, "start_iter": 17000, "gap_steps": 1000, "seconds": 109.29617810249329 }, "1000_steps|pretrain_iter_0018000|pretrain_iter_0019000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0018000", "pretrain_iter_0019000" ], "spacing": "1000_steps", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.8842698412606156, "cosine_q1": 0.8739493919138807, "cosine_q3": 0.8954850819219448, "spearman_median": 0.8351245274347883, "start_iter": 18000, "gap_steps": 1000, "seconds": 98.19101214408875 }, "1000_steps|pretrain_iter_0019000|pretrain_iter_0020000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0019000", "pretrain_iter_0020000" ], "spacing": "1000_steps", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.8864295413714981, "cosine_q1": 0.875149213221136, "cosine_q3": 0.8967203135248931, "spearman_median": 0.838032517965532, "start_iter": 19000, "gap_steps": 1000, "seconds": 95.33753395080566 }, "x1.5|pretrain_iter_0002000|pretrain_iter_0003000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0002000", "pretrain_iter_0003000" ], "spacing": "x1.5", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.6762590384272051, "cosine_q1": 0.644232743672844, "cosine_q3": 0.6961454045483575, "spearman_median": 0.5934760316790375, "start_iter": 2000, "gap_steps": 1000, "seconds": 184.73858094215393 }, "x1.5|pretrain_iter_0003000|pretrain_iter_0004000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0003000", "pretrain_iter_0004000" ], "spacing": "x1.5", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.7674510500768417, "cosine_q1": 0.7456609763881956, "cosine_q3": 0.7840697442054547, "spearman_median": 0.7006740908038582, "start_iter": 3000, "gap_steps": 1000, "seconds": 94.78317070007324 }, "x1.5|pretrain_iter_0004000|pretrain_iter_0006000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0004000", "pretrain_iter_0006000" ], "spacing": "x1.5", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.7277392438354687, "cosine_q1": 0.7000844114038005, "cosine_q3": 0.7469657297044641, "spearman_median": 0.6555119661151192, "start_iter": 4000, "gap_steps": 2000, "seconds": 93.29307007789612 }, "x1.5|pretrain_iter_0005000|pretrain_iter_0007000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0005000", "pretrain_iter_0007000" ], "spacing": "x1.5", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.7676904489298525, "cosine_q1": 0.7423624678030727, "cosine_q3": 0.783059301068223, "spearman_median": 0.70084679500726, "start_iter": 5000, "gap_steps": 2000, "seconds": 186.30091500282288 }, "x1.5|pretrain_iter_0006000|pretrain_iter_0009000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0006000", "pretrain_iter_0009000" ], "spacing": "x1.5", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.7466842063922686, "cosine_q1": 0.7226915309158318, "cosine_q3": 0.7663781719118972, "spearman_median": 0.6724280647303404, "start_iter": 6000, "gap_steps": 3000, "seconds": 183.48642301559448 }, "x1.5|pretrain_iter_0007000|pretrain_iter_0010000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0007000", "pretrain_iter_0010000" ], "spacing": "x1.5", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.7654034475638684, "cosine_q1": 0.7414256039144004, "cosine_q3": 0.7872231253054192, "spearman_median": 0.697978146231843, "start_iter": 7000, "gap_steps": 3000, "seconds": 185.12865686416626 }, "x1.5|pretrain_iter_0008000|pretrain_iter_0012000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0008000", "pretrain_iter_0012000" ], "spacing": "x1.5", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.7548376935713285, "cosine_q1": 0.7317493601738464, "cosine_q3": 0.7722758488844691, "spearman_median": 0.6784030106492512, "start_iter": 8000, "gap_steps": 4000, "seconds": 218.7393159866333 }, "x1.5|pretrain_iter_0009000|pretrain_iter_0013000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0009000", "pretrain_iter_0013000" ], "spacing": "x1.5", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.7669324761389174, "cosine_q1": 0.746137832367997, "cosine_q3": 0.7843724440395973, "spearman_median": 0.6913530945822102, "start_iter": 9000, "gap_steps": 4000, "seconds": 186.0584728717804 }, "x1.5|pretrain_iter_0010000|pretrain_iter_0015000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0010000", "pretrain_iter_0015000" ], "spacing": "x1.5", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.7553844708605876, "cosine_q1": 0.7351103859705206, "cosine_q3": 0.7767914705696277, "spearman_median": 0.680846955369697, "start_iter": 10000, "gap_steps": 5000, "seconds": 184.22142004966736 }, "x1.5|pretrain_iter_0011000|pretrain_iter_0016000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0011000", "pretrain_iter_0016000" ], "spacing": "x1.5", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.7655949905631609, "cosine_q1": 0.7469863383475214, "cosine_q3": 0.7869155807912503, "spearman_median": 0.690627240621771, "start_iter": 11000, "gap_steps": 5000, "seconds": 184.21578311920166 }, "x1.5|pretrain_iter_0012000|pretrain_iter_0018000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0012000", "pretrain_iter_0018000" ], "spacing": "x1.5", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.7589487227496748, "cosine_q1": 0.7399301919345799, "cosine_q3": 0.7817896448974708, "spearman_median": 0.6833319780755547, "start_iter": 12000, "gap_steps": 6000, "seconds": 182.6543369293213 }, "x1.5|pretrain_iter_0013000|pretrain_iter_0019000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0013000", "pretrain_iter_0019000" ], "spacing": "x1.5", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.768355653110013, "cosine_q1": 0.7498876656519898, "cosine_q3": 0.7918827544220395, "spearman_median": 0.6884521852882097, "start_iter": 13000, "gap_steps": 6000, "seconds": 184.75581073760986 }, "x1.5|pretrain_iter_0014000|pretrain_iter_0020000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0014000", "pretrain_iter_0020000" ], "spacing": "x1.5", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.7744255545810848, "cosine_q1": 0.7602141395606798, "cosine_q3": 0.7954839086153506, "spearman_median": 0.6977997087731789, "start_iter": 14000, "gap_steps": 6000, "seconds": 184.84328603744507 }, "x1.5|pretrain_iter_0015000|pretrain_iter_0020000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0015000", "pretrain_iter_0020000" ], "spacing": "x1.5", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.7963947911781061, "cosine_q1": 0.7811010288182892, "cosine_q3": 0.8162220555660537, "spearman_median": 0.7244595628111152, "start_iter": 15000, "gap_steps": 5000, "seconds": 94.08555006980896 }, "x1.5|pretrain_iter_0016000|pretrain_iter_0025000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0016000", "pretrain_iter_0025000" ], "spacing": "x1.5", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.7476507145440769, "cosine_q1": 0.7259930865473637, "cosine_q3": 0.7708815523720371, "spearman_median": 0.6642847548514412, "start_iter": 16000, "gap_steps": 9000, "seconds": 211.06604623794556 }, "x1.5|pretrain_iter_0017000|pretrain_iter_0025000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0017000", "pretrain_iter_0025000" ], "spacing": "x1.5", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.7688659365823548, "cosine_q1": 0.7487528755820407, "cosine_q3": 0.7918067878447373, "spearman_median": 0.6882413517256122, "start_iter": 17000, "gap_steps": 8000, "seconds": 95.83168196678162 }, "x1.5|pretrain_iter_0018000|pretrain_iter_0025000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0018000", "pretrain_iter_0025000" ], "spacing": "x1.5", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.7890266732895961, "cosine_q1": 0.7712056247047198, "cosine_q3": 0.8077362412971714, "spearman_median": 0.7108054055781433, "start_iter": 18000, "gap_steps": 7000, "seconds": 187.6421661376953 }, "x1.5|pretrain_iter_0019000|pretrain_iter_0031000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0019000", "pretrain_iter_0031000" ], "spacing": "x1.5", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.7350972801663228, "cosine_q1": 0.7136489276517795, "cosine_q3": 0.7590710500553727, "spearman_median": 0.6485463367537616, "start_iter": 19000, "gap_steps": 12000, "seconds": 204.80199193954468 }, "x1.5|pretrain_iter_0020000|pretrain_iter_0031000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0020000", "pretrain_iter_0031000" ], "spacing": "x1.5", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.7477885563663049, "cosine_q1": 0.7313460507374927, "cosine_q3": 0.7706600578228695, "spearman_median": 0.6648654334348303, "start_iter": 20000, "gap_steps": 11000, "seconds": 98.01850008964539 }, "x1.5|pretrain_iter_0025000|pretrain_iter_0039000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0025000", "pretrain_iter_0039000" ], "spacing": "x1.5", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.7462099214014934, "cosine_q1": 0.7235222647050717, "cosine_q3": 0.7695807805049726, "spearman_median": 0.6579064805169738, "start_iter": 25000, "gap_steps": 14000, "seconds": 222.29041409492493 }, "x1.5|pretrain_iter_0031000|pretrain_iter_0049000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0031000", "pretrain_iter_0049000" ], "spacing": "x1.5", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.7363511068561567, "cosine_q1": 0.7130363748513858, "cosine_q3": 0.7609967361813593, "spearman_median": 0.6406932116408597, "start_iter": 31000, "gap_steps": 18000, "seconds": 199.88967776298523 }, "x1.5|pretrain_iter_0039000|pretrain_iter_0061000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0039000", "pretrain_iter_0061000" ], "spacing": "x1.5", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.7349745276584916, "cosine_q1": 0.7120224085381572, "cosine_q3": 0.7563830780874427, "spearman_median": 0.6360712861599381, "start_iter": 39000, "gap_steps": 22000, "seconds": 200.10924196243286 }, "x1.5|pretrain_iter_0049000|pretrain_iter_0076000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0049000", "pretrain_iter_0076000" ], "spacing": "x1.5", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.7253654601528879, "cosine_q1": 0.7025751671363497, "cosine_q3": 0.7522364486398134, "spearman_median": 0.6243308401645413, "start_iter": 49000, "gap_steps": 27000, "seconds": 201.39715123176575 }, "x1.5|pretrain_iter_0061000|pretrain_iter_0095000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0061000", "pretrain_iter_0095000" ], "spacing": "x1.5", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.7086910607913434, "cosine_q1": 0.6860247678755995, "cosine_q3": 0.73567633122693, "spearman_median": 0.6052935663230063, "start_iter": 61000, "gap_steps": 34000, "seconds": 211.35249423980713 }, "x1.5|pretrain_iter_0076000|pretrain_iter_0119000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0076000", "pretrain_iter_0119000" ], "spacing": "x1.5", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.7004931747304188, "cosine_q1": 0.6756622175973742, "cosine_q3": 0.724363852873315, "spearman_median": 0.5894241623269298, "start_iter": 76000, "gap_steps": 43000, "seconds": 200.30011081695557 }, "x1.5|pretrain_iter_0095000|pretrain_iter_0149000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0095000", "pretrain_iter_0149000" ], "spacing": "x1.5", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.6845379913807329, "cosine_q1": 0.6639561815596132, "cosine_q3": 0.7108492748876108, "spearman_median": 0.5703363101661969, "start_iter": 95000, "gap_steps": 54000, "seconds": 198.99894499778748 }, "x1.5|pretrain_iter_0119000|pretrain_iter_0186000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0119000", "pretrain_iter_0186000" ], "spacing": "x1.5", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.6720388603244777, "cosine_q1": 0.6499198007615219, "cosine_q3": 0.6963150361699559, "spearman_median": 0.5542082763473353, "start_iter": 119000, "gap_steps": 67000, "seconds": 200.2552671432495 }, "x1.5|pretrain_iter_0149000|pretrain_iter_0233000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0149000", "pretrain_iter_0233000" ], "spacing": "x1.5", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.6570931302326279, "cosine_q1": 0.635515244638057, "cosine_q3": 0.6839300339072807, "spearman_median": 0.5372001573942565, "start_iter": 149000, "gap_steps": 84000, "seconds": 199.3675022125244 }, "x1.5|pretrain_iter_0186000|pretrain_iter_0291000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0186000", "pretrain_iter_0291000" ], "spacing": "x1.5", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.6431931180316905, "cosine_q1": 0.6162273098937695, "cosine_q3": 0.674028676871993, "spearman_median": 0.5200657276015018, "start_iter": 186000, "gap_steps": 105000, "seconds": 199.68063926696777 }, "x1.5|pretrain_iter_0233000|pretrain_iter_0364000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0233000", "pretrain_iter_0364000" ], "spacing": "x1.5", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.6381060244170351, "cosine_q1": 0.6109100030923571, "cosine_q3": 0.6622863798350788, "spearman_median": 0.5060328217291323, "start_iter": 233000, "gap_steps": 131000, "seconds": 202.68866109848022 }, "x1.5|pretrain_iter_0291000|pretrain_iter_0455000": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0291000", "pretrain_iter_0455000" ], "spacing": "x1.5", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.6254031816034246, "cosine_q1": 0.6024552818339153, "cosine_q3": 0.653622262276502, "spearman_median": 0.4921319010362919, "start_iter": 291000, "gap_steps": 164000, "seconds": 195.7776849269867 }, "x1.5|pretrain_iter_0364000|pretrain_iter_0484865": { "pair": [ "pretrain_iter_0364000", "pretrain_iter_0484865" ], "spacing": "x1.5", "n_constructs": 169, "cosine_median": 0.6929109477455643, "cosine_q1": 0.6648259802414965, "cosine_q3": 0.7120373796154762, "spearman_median": 0.565454342089917, "start_iter": 364000, "gap_steps": 120865, "seconds": 200.22308707237244 } }, "minutes": 134.24214491844177, "provenance": { "inputs": [ "profiles//twin1/.npz via the dataset-only resolver" ], "reference": null, "battery_prompt_hash": "570b42db13f8fe5772b8d1a9ad7d55d6fa1279dae5948ad94e8363789bcbc1ad", "code_commit": "1d8310f", "design": "9-Paper-1/2610-18Oct_PAPER-1-Design.md sha256 47f6a664\u2026" } }