{
 "what": "the old set's retained effect at 2,034 B, and the 16 constructs behind it",
 "reference": "pretrain_iter_0484865",
 "old_set_from": "pretrain_iter_0020000",
 "n_constructs": 16,
 "statistic": "the ratio of MEDIANS, signed; not the median of per-construct ratios",
 "why_signed": "current_over_random_in_sd is positive for 14 of 16 and negative for 2; drifted for 11 and 5. Absolute values flip the negatives and inflate the numerator: abs gives 40.2%, signed gives 28.4%.",
 "retention_control_units": {
  "ratio_of_medians": 0.2839668518337327,
  "ci95": [
   -0.015239138331254435,
   1.184806310365205
  ],
  "median_old": 1.4640538922107489,
  "median_current": 5.155721108842579
 },
 "retention_nats": {
  "ratio_of_medians": 0.2787241114560848,
  "ci95": [
   -0.048112513975422946,
   0.8515762706908967
  ],
  "median_old": 0.10930539089628605,
  "median_current": 0.3921633845212132
 },
 "overlap": {
  "median": 0.13834260138342602,
  "ci95": [
   0.1345449613454496,
   0.1510918215109182
  ]
 },
 "draft_says": "about 45% of the effect with 14% of the members",
 "verdict": "the 14% reproduces (13.8%); the 45% does not under any definition tried",
 "rows": [
  {
   "construct": "AsyncFor",
   "baseline_nats": 1.7177573043949665,
   "current_nats": -0.28349481836519597,
   "old_nats": -0.046018336537248405,
   "random_mean_nats": -0.021886220500839326,
   "random_sd_nats": 0.08663960944973288,
   "current_over_random_sd": -3.0195034295040117,
   "old_over_random_sd": -0.278534450809248,
   "ratio_sd": 0.09224511821634211,
   "ratio_nats": 0.0922451182163421,
   "overlap_share": 0.12491523124915231,
   "drifted_from": "pretrain_iter_0020000"
  },
  {
   "construct": "AsyncWith",
   "baseline_nats": 1.7975515466756546,
   "current_nats": 0.4033340231443827,
   "old_nats": 0.1525754706504252,
   "random_mean_nats": 0.04635338235753937,
   "random_sd_nats": 0.05705115455653731,
   "current_over_random_sd": 6.2572027430764425,
   "old_over_random_sd": 1.861874472454724,
   "ratio_sd": 0.29755699933406776,
   "ratio_nats": 0.29755699933406776,
   "overlap_share": 0.12491523124915231,
   "drifted_from": "pretrain_iter_0020000"
  },
  {
   "construct": "DictComp",
   "baseline_nats": 3.13880877494812,
   "current_nats": 0.33314869160554883,
   "old_nats": 0.22630855404600814,
   "random_mean_nats": 0.06604088245605952,
   "random_sd_nats": 0.06928856228348648,
   "current_over_random_sd": 3.855005795280428,
   "old_over_random_sd": 2.313046573750963,
   "ratio_sd": 0.60001117938208,
   "ratio_nats": 0.60001117938208,
   "overlap_share": 0.13400244134002443,
   "drifted_from": "pretrain_iter_0020000"
  },
  {
   "construct": "For",
   "baseline_nats": 1.5330227254447057,
   "current_nats": 0.10947780882247238,
   "old_nats": 0.016702145681601,
   "random_mean_nats": -0.003808520626953071,
   "random_sd_nats": 0.06758535475428776,
   "current_over_random_sd": 1.6761964165356154,
   "old_over_random_sd": 0.30347797068051685,
   "ratio_sd": 0.1810515567786197,
   "ratio_nats": 0.18105155677861973,
   "overlap_share": 0.15421131154211312,
   "drifted_from": "pretrain_iter_0020000"
  },
  {
   "construct": "GeneratorExp",
   "baseline_nats": 4.272434534760296,
   "current_nats": 0.5844476452938796,
   "old_nats": 0.4551018119463457,
   "random_mean_nats": 0.04197604081352337,
   "random_sd_nats": 0.07418860680916287,
   "current_over_random_sd": 7.3120608111130725,
   "old_over_random_sd": 5.568587804802909,
   "ratio_sd": 0.7615620204278957,
   "ratio_nats": 0.7615620204278956,
   "overlap_share": 0.136986301369863,
   "drifted_from": "pretrain_iter_0020000"
  },
  {
   "construct": "If",
   "baseline_nats": 0.43536454965562926,
   "current_nats": 0.35956109269265674,
   "old_nats": -0.0030725273047236823,
   "random_mean_nats": 0.015485003797094438,
   "random_sd_nats": 0.046005811021083885,
   "current_over_random_sd": 7.478970183524784,
   "old_over_random_sd": -0.4033736323725156,
   "ratio_sd": -0.053934381669430397,
   "ratio_nats": -0.053934381669430397,
   "overlap_share": 0.153261901532619,
   "drifted_from": "pretrain_iter_0020000"
  },
  {
   "construct": "IfExp",
   "baseline_nats": 2.8865630788107715,
   "current_nats": 1.6695803925395007,
   "old_nats": 0.8262225513656931,
   "random_mean_nats": 0.08384006731988225,
   "random_sd_nats": 0.06061609217184038,
   "current_over_random_sd": 26.160385277299103,
   "old_over_random_sd": 12.247283806109325,
   "ratio_sd": 0.4681614462588596,
   "ratio_nats": 0.4681614462588595,
   "overlap_share": 0.14010579140105792,
   "drifted_from": "pretrain_iter_0020000"
  },
  {
   "construct": "Import",
   "baseline_nats": 10.614081199352558,
   "current_nats": 0.6679911613464355,
   "old_nats": 0.04502850312453077,
   "random_mean_nats": 0.09570915699005109,
   "random_sd_nats": 0.39017769635716026,
   "current_over_random_sd": 1.4667214699851265,
   "old_over_random_sd": -0.1298912119751928,
   "ratio_sd": -0.08855888090089113,
   "ratio_nats": -0.08855888090089115,
   "overlap_share": 0.13644378136443783,
   "drifted_from": "pretrain_iter_0020000"
  },
  {
   "construct": "ImportFrom",
   "baseline_nats": 8.474074510427622,
   "current_nats": 0.39929918142465404,
   "old_nats": 0.17609676947960473,
   "random_mean_nats": 0.2151030705525323,
   "random_sd_nats": 0.6452753084105308,
   "current_over_random_sd": 0.28545352421099346,
   "old_over_random_sd": -0.06044908361519292,
   "ratio_sd": -0.21176506327002598,
   "ratio_nats": -0.21176506327002595,
   "overlap_share": 0.15583887155838871,
   "drifted_from": "pretrain_iter_0020000"
  },
  {
   "construct": "Lambda",
   "baseline_nats": 1.4006468326163788,
   "current_nats": 4.991929735212277,
   "old_nats": 3.5500454863843824,
   "random_mean_nats": 0.0015523214242421867,
   "random_sd_nats": 0.2231387042939841,
   "current_over_random_sd": 22.364463527641703,
   "old_over_random_sd": 15.902634086666644,
   "ratio_sd": 0.7110670938746882,
   "ratio_nats": 0.7110670938746882,
   "overlap_share": 0.14281839142818392,
   "drifted_from": "pretrain_iter_0020000"
  },
  {
   "construct": "ListComp",
   "baseline_nats": 2.9893448994244416,
   "current_nats": 1.0094922351353057,
   "old_nats": 0.15053607848695094,
   "random_mean_nats": 0.055314624975175454,
   "random_sd_nats": 0.0962619249827259,
   "current_over_random_sd": 9.912305517797991,
   "old_over_random_sd": 0.9891912459558947,
   "ratio_sd": 0.09979426523726062,
   "ratio_nats": 0.09979426523726061,
   "overlap_share": 0.1368506713685067,
   "drifted_from": "pretrain_iter_0020000"
  },
  {
   "construct": "NamedExpr",
   "baseline_nats": 4.141563288676433,
   "current_nats": 0.06876956193875117,
   "old_nats": 0.36871654788653085,
   "random_mean_nats": 0.08547144757631545,
   "random_sd_nats": 0.10460070304145316,
   "current_over_random_sd": -0.1596727856689963,
   "old_over_random_sd": 2.707869948043902,
   "ratio_sd": -16.95886958255586,
   "ratio_nats": -16.95886958255586,
   "overlap_share": 0.15828021158280212,
   "drifted_from": "pretrain_iter_0020000"
  },
  {
   "construct": "SetComp",
   "baseline_nats": 3.5675482096405804,
   "current_nats": 0.48361611850370645,
   "old_nats": 0.16865868374780968,
   "random_mean_nats": 0.0562699902481234,
   "random_sd_nats": 0.10540722395211431,
   "current_over_random_sd": 4.054239474608715,
   "old_over_random_sd": 1.0662333119667737,
   "ratio_sd": 0.2629921884596318,
   "ratio_nats": 0.2629921884596318,
   "overlap_share": 0.13332429133324292,
   "drifted_from": "pretrain_iter_0020000"
  },
  {
   "construct": "Try",
   "baseline_nats": 0.08751399916410446,
   "current_nats": 6.004058102428913,
   "old_nats": 4.19116915589571,
   "random_mean_nats": 0.053691648389026514,
   "random_sd_nats": 0.07322830215000725,
   "current_over_random_sd": 81.25774160174622,
   "old_over_random_sd": 56.501071116343965,
   "ratio_sd": 0.695331546294535,
   "ratio_nats": 0.695331546294535,
   "overlap_share": 0.1510918215109182,
   "drifted_from": "pretrain_iter_0020000"
  },
  {
   "construct": "While",
   "baseline_nats": 0.42444318232186345,
   "current_nats": 0.10473492604876872,
   "old_nats": 0.29686423732873496,
   "random_mean_nats": 0.04802278357156371,
   "random_sd_nats": 0.05736038078925194,
   "current_over_random_sd": 0.9886988492208825,
   "old_over_random_sd": 4.338211328677208,
   "ratio_sd": 4.387798501126829,
   "ratio_nats": 4.387798501126828,
   "overlap_share": 0.139698901396989,
   "drifted_from": "pretrain_iter_0020000"
  },
  {
   "construct": "With",
   "baseline_nats": 1.9418676218816213,
   "current_nats": 0.5767353416553564,
   "old_nats": -0.11006864053862442,
   "random_mean_nats": 0.020682645176670268,
   "random_sd_nats": 0.05731747550348927,
   "current_over_random_sd": 9.701276819926163,
   "old_over_random_sd": -2.2811766318517472,
   "ratio_sd": -0.2351418967002644,
   "ratio_nats": -0.23514189670026436,
   "overlap_share": 0.1345449613454496,
   "drifted_from": "pretrain_iter_0020000"
  }
 ],
 "minutes": 0.004329013824462891,
 "provenance": {
  "inputs": [
   "_abl_dl/validation/ablation/FULL_pretrain_iter_0484865.json"
  ],
  "reference": null,
  "battery_prompt_hash": "570b42db13f8fe5772b8d1a9ad7d55d6fa1279dae5948ad94e8363789bcbc1ad",
  "code_commit": "3325b25",
  "design": "9-Paper-1/2610-18Oct_PAPER-1-Design.md sha256 47f6a664\u2026"
 }
}