import OAI.AlgebraicGeometry.SurfaceCones.CartierGluing namespace OAI private local instance factorizationSectionModule {Z : AlgebraicGeometry.Scheme.{0}} (M : Z.Modules) (U : Z.Opensᵒᵖ) : Module (Z.sheaf.obj.obj U) (M.val.obj U) := (M.val.obj U).isModule private local instance factorizationCoherentSectionModule {Z : AlgebraicGeometry.Scheme.{0}} (M : CoherentGlobal.Coh Z) (U : Z.Opensᵒᵖ) : Module (Z.sheaf.obj.obj U) (M.obj.val.obj U) := (M.obj.val.obj U).isModule private noncomputable local instance factorizationFreeSectionModule (Z : AlgebraicGeometry.Scheme.{0}) (I : Type) (U : Z.Opensᵒᵖ) : Module (Z.sheaf.obj.obj U) ((SheafOfModules.free (R := Z.ringCatSheaf) I).val.obj U) := ((SheafOfModules.free (R := Z.ringCatSheaf) I).val.obj U).isModule /-! # Cartier lattices on completed surface cones This development accompanies *A Complete Local Domain without a Small Cohen–Macaulay Module* (OpenAI, 2026). -/ noncomputable section open CategoryTheory CategoryTheory.Limits _root_.AlgebraicGeometry _root_.OAI.AlgebraicGeometry namespace ActualCartier open ActualSheafTensor CartierImageFiltration CoherentGlobal Scheme.Modules variable {X Y : Scheme.{0}} [IsLocallyNoetherian Y] (g : X ⟶ Y) [IsClosedImmersion g] [CompactSpace Y] (d : LineTrivialization Y.sheaf (idealSheaf g)) include d /-- The two cleared maps are inverse up to the indicated ideal power. Torsion freeness extends the equality from the puncture to the whole scheme. -/ lemma global_power_sandwich_factorization (n : ℕ) {M N : Y.Modules} [N.IsFinitePresentation] (hN : ∀ U, Module.IsTorsionFree (Y.sheaf.obj.obj U) (N.val.obj U)) (e : M.over (ActualOpenSupport.complement g) ≅ N.over (ActualOpenSupport.complement g)) (f : (power (tensorLeft Y.sheaf (idealSheaf g)) n).obj M ⟶ N) (a : (power (tensorLeft Y.sheaf (idealSheaf g)) n).obj N ⟶ M) (hf : f.over (ActualOpenSupport.complement g) = ((powerAction (tensorLeft Y.sheaf (idealSheaf g)) (idealAction Y.sheaf (idealι g)) n).app M).over (ActualOpenSupport.complement g) ≫ e.hom) (ha : a.over (ActualOpenSupport.complement g) = ((powerAction (tensorLeft Y.sheaf (idealSheaf g)) (idealAction Y.sheaf (idealι g)) n).app N).over (ActualOpenSupport.complement g) ≫ e.inv) : (powerAddIso (tensorLeft Y.sheaf (idealSheaf g)) n n N).hom ≫ (power (tensorLeft Y.sheaf (idealSheaf g)) n).map a ≫ f = (powerAction (tensorLeft Y.sheaf (idealSheaf g)) (idealAction Y.sheaf (idealι g)) (n + n)).app N := by let T := tensorLeft Y.sheaf (idealSheaf g) let act := idealAction Y.sheaf (idealι g) let U := ActualOpenSupport.complement g let A : Coh Y := ⟨(power T (n + n)).obj N, coherent_power_tensor_line (idealSheaf g) d (n + n) N⟩ let B : Coh Y := ⟨N, inferInstance⟩ let p : A ⟶ B := ObjectProperty.homMk ((powerAddIso T n n N).hom ≫ (power T n).map a ≫ f) let q : A ⟶ B := ObjectProperty.homMk ((powerAction T act (n + n)).app N) have hpq : p = q := by apply hom_ext_of_puncture g d p q hN have hh : p.hom.over U = q.hom.over U := power_sandwich_map T act (SheafOfModules.overFunctor Y.ringCatSheaf U) n e f a hf ha have : Epi ((overFunctorEquiv U).hom.app A.obj) := @IsIso.epi_of_iso _ _ _ _ _ ((overFunctorEquiv U).app A.obj).isIso_hom apply (cancel_epi ((overFunctorEquiv U).hom.app A.obj)).mp calc _ = (overEquiv U).functor.map (p.hom.over U) ≫ (overFunctorEquiv U).hom.app B.obj := ((overFunctorEquiv U).hom.naturality p.hom).symm _ = (overEquiv U).functor.map (q.hom.over U) ≫ (overFunctorEquiv U).hom.app B.obj := by rw [hh] _ = _ := (overFunctorEquiv U).hom.naturality q.hom exact congrArg (fun k : A ⟶ B => k.hom) hpq end ActualCartier end noncomputable section open CategoryTheory CategoryTheory.Limits _root_.AlgebraicGeometry _root_.OAI.AlgebraicGeometry namespace ActualCartier open ActualSheafTensor CartierImageFiltration CoherentGlobal CoherentK0 Scheme.Modules variable {X Y : Scheme.{0}} [IsLocallyNoetherian X] [IsLocallyNoetherian Y] (g : X ⟶ Y) [IsClosedImmersion g] [CompactSpace Y] (d : LineTrivialization Y.sheaf (idealSheaf g)) omit [IsLocallyNoetherian X] [IsClosedImmersion g] [CompactSpace Y] in /-- An ideal-power factorization annihilates the coherent quotient by the same exponent. -/ lemma idealMultiple_isZero_of_raw_factorization {S : ShortComplex (Coh Y)} (hS : S.ShortExact) (n : ℕ) (a : (power (tensorLeft Y.sheaf (idealSheaf g)) n).obj S.X₂.obj ⟶ S.X₁.obj) (ha : a ≫ S.f.hom = (powerAction (tensorLeft Y.sheaf (idealSheaf g)) (idealAction Y.sheaf (idealι g)) n).app S.X₂.obj) : IsZero (idealMultiple g d n S.X₃) := by let T := coherentTensorLine (idealSheaf g) d let V : Y.Modules ⥤ Y.Modules := tensorLeft Y.sheaf (idealSheaf g) have : PreservesColimits V := CoherentDual.tensorLeft_preservesColimits _ _ have : V.PreservesEpimorphisms := preservesEpimorphisms_of_preservesColimitsOfShape V let F := cohInclusion Y let c : T ⋙ F ≅ F ⋙ V := Iso.refl _ have : Mono S.f := hS.mono_f have : Epi S.g := hS.epi_g apply iterated_isZero_of_powerAction_zero apply F.map_injective rw [Functor.map_zero] apply map_powerAction_zero_of_comparison T V F c (action g d) (idealAction Y.sheaf (idealι g)) (fun _ => Category.id_comp _) n S.X₃ exact powerAction_quotient_zero V (idealAction Y.sheaf (idealι g)) (hS.map F) n a ha /-- The coherent lattice construction with the twice-clearing exponent, conormal-layer epimorphisms and divisor Grothendieck identity. -/ lemma exists_cleared_lattice_twice_bound (M N : Y.Modules) [M.IsFinitePresentation] [N.IsFinitePresentation] (hM : ∀ U, Module.IsTorsionFree (Y.sheaf.obj.obj U) (M.val.obj U)) (hN : ∀ U, Module.IsTorsionFree (Y.sheaf.obj.obj U) (N.val.obj U)) (e : M.over (ActualOpenSupport.complement g) ≅ N.over (ActualOpenSupport.complement g)) : let L : Coh Y := ⟨N, inferInstance⟩ ∃ k : ℕ, ∀ n : ℕ, k ≤ n → ∃ a : clearedLattice g d n M ⟶ L, Mono a ∧ ((cohInclusion Y).map a).over (ActualOpenSupport.complement g) = ((powerAction (tensorLeft Y.sheaf (idealSheaf g)) (idealAction Y.sheaf (idealι g)) n).app M).over (ActualOpenSupport.complement g) ≫ e.hom ∧ IsZero (idealMultiple g d (n + n) (cokernel a)) ∧ cls ((restriction g d).obj (clearedLattice g d n M)) = cls ((restriction g d).obj L) + ((idealLayers g d (n + n) (cokernel a)).map fun Q => cls (conormalTensor g d Q) - cls Q).sum ∧ ∀ j : ℕ, Epi (twistedLayerQuotient g d (cokernel.π a) j) := by dsimp only let L : Coh Y := ⟨N, inferInstance⟩ obtain ⟨k, hk⟩ := exists_global_power_sandwich g d M N hM hN e refine ⟨k, fun n hn => ?_⟩ obtain ⟨a, b, ha, hb, hae, hbe, hai, hbi⟩ := hk n hn let := ha let a' : clearedLattice g d n M ⟶ L := ObjectProperty.homMk a have ha' : Mono a' := (cohInclusion Y).mono_of_mono_map (f := a') (by change Mono a infer_instance) let S : ShortComplex (Coh Y) := ShortComplex.mk a' (cokernel.π a') (cokernel.condition a') have hS : S.ShortExact := { exact := ShortComplex.exact_cokernel a' } have hnil : IsZero (idealMultiple g d (n + n) (cokernel a')) := by apply idealMultiple_isZero_of_raw_factorization g d hS (n + n) ((powerAddIso (tensorLeft Y.sheaf (idealSheaf g)) n n N).hom ≫ (power (tensorLeft Y.sheaf (idealSheaf g)) n).map b) exact (Category.assoc _ _ _).trans (global_power_sandwich_factorization g d n hN e a b hae hbe) refine ⟨a', ha', hae, hnil, ?_, fun _ => inferInstance⟩ apply lattice_nilpotent_identity g d hS _ hN (n + n) hnil exact SheafTorsion.subobject ((cohInclusion Y).map a') hN end ActualCartier end noncomputable section open CategoryTheory CategoryTheory.Limits _root_.AlgebraicGeometry _root_.OAI.AlgebraicGeometry namespace ActualCartier open ActualSheafTensor CartierImageFiltration CoherentGlobal CoherentK0 Scheme.Modules /-- The finite free coherent module sheaf. -/ def coherentFree (Y : Scheme.{0}) (I : Type) [Finite I] : Coh Y := ⟨SheafOfModules.free (R := Y.ringCatSheaf) I, CoherentLocality.finitePresentation_free Y.ringCatSheaf I⟩ /-- On an integral scheme, the finite free sheaf is sectionwise torsion free, including empty opens. -/ lemma free_sections_torsionFree (Y : Scheme.{0}) [IsIntegral Y] (I : Type) [Finite I] (U : Y.Opensᵒᵖ) : Module.IsTorsionFree (Y.sheaf.obj.obj U) ((SheafOfModules.free (R := Y.ringCatSheaf) I).val.obj U) := by let e := CoherentDual.dualFiniteFreeIso Y.sheaf I have hm : Mono e.inv := @IsIso.mono_of_iso _ _ _ _ _ e.isIso_inv exact @SheafTorsion.subobject _ _ _ e.inv hm (fun V => CoherentDual.dual_sections_torsionFree _ V.unop) U variable {X Y : Scheme.{0}} [IsLocallyNoetherian X] [IsLocallyNoetherian Y] (g : X ⟶ Y) [IsClosedImmersion g] (d : LineTrivialization Y.sheaf (idealSheaf g)) /-- The coherent restriction used by the Cartier resolution sends the finite free sheaf to the same finite free sheaf on the divisor. -/ def restriction_freeIso (I : Type) [Finite I] : (restriction g d).obj (coherentFree Y I) ≅ coherentFree X I := by let : (SheafOfModules.pushforward g.toRingCatSheafHom).IsRightAdjoint := (Scheme.Modules.pullbackPushforwardAdjunction g).isRightAdjoint let F := TopologicalSpace.Opens.map g.base let : F.Final := Functor.final_of_exists_of_isFiltered F (fun U => ⟨⊤, ⟨homOfLE (by change U ≤ ⊤; exact le_top)⟩⟩) (fun {U V} s t => ⟨V, 𝟙 _, Subsingleton.elim _ _⟩) exact ObjectProperty.isoMk _ ((restrictionPullbackIso g d (coherentFree Y I)).symm ≪≫ SheafOfModules.pullbackObjFreeIso g.toRingCatSheafHom I) /-- The quotient map from the jth conormal twist of O_D^N to the jth quotient layer. -/ def freeTwistedLayerQuotient {Q : Coh Y} {I : Type} [Finite I] (q : coherentFree Y I ⟶ Q) (j : ℕ) : (power (conormalFunctor g d) j).obj (coherentFree X I) ⟶ layer g d j Q := (power (conormalFunctor g d) j).map (restriction_freeIso g d I).inv ≫ twistedLayerQuotient g d q j instance freeTwistedLayerQuotient_epi {Q : Coh Y} {I : Type} [Finite I] (q : coherentFree Y I ⟶ Q) [Epi q] (j : ℕ) : Epi (freeTwistedLayerQuotient g d q j) := by dsimp only [freeTwistedLayerQuotient] infer_instance /-- The sheaf-theoretic content of the divisor lattice construction for the finite free ambient lattice: a fixed puncture trivialization constructs the embedding, the finite twice-bound filtration, the divisor K₀ identity, and all the required quotients of conormal-twisted free sheaves. -/ lemma exists_free_cleared_lattice [CompactSpace Y] [IsIntegral Y] (M : Y.Modules) [M.IsFinitePresentation] (hM : ∀ U, Module.IsTorsionFree (Y.sheaf.obj.obj U) (M.val.obj U)) (N : ℕ) (e : M.over (ActualOpenSupport.complement g) ≅ (SheafOfModules.free (R := Y.ringCatSheaf) (Fin N)).over (ActualOpenSupport.complement g)) : ∃ k : ℕ, ∀ n : ℕ, k ≤ n → ∃ a : clearedLattice g d n M ⟶ coherentFree Y (Fin N), Mono a ∧ ((cohInclusion Y).map a).over (ActualOpenSupport.complement g) = ((powerAction (tensorLeft Y.sheaf (idealSheaf g)) (idealAction Y.sheaf (idealι g)) n).app M).over (ActualOpenSupport.complement g) ≫ e.hom ∧ IsZero (idealMultiple g d (n + n) (cokernel a)) ∧ cls ((restriction g d).obj (clearedLattice g d n M)) = cls (coherentFree X (Fin N)) + ((idealLayers g d (n + n) (cokernel a)).map fun Q => cls (conormalTensor g d Q) - cls Q).sum ∧ ∀ j : ℕ, Epi (freeTwistedLayerQuotient g d (cokernel.π a) j) := by let L := SheafOfModules.free (R := Y.ringCatSheaf) (Fin N) let : L.IsFinitePresentation := CoherentLocality.finitePresentation_free Y.ringCatSheaf (Fin N) obtain ⟨k, hk⟩ := exists_cleared_lattice_twice_bound g d M L hM (free_sections_torsionFree Y (Fin N)) e refine ⟨k, fun n hn => ?_⟩ obtain ⟨a, ha, hae, hnil, heq, hepi⟩ := hk n hn refine ⟨a, ha, hae, hnil, ?_, fun j => ?_⟩ · exact heq.trans (congrArg (fun z => z + _) (cls_iso (restriction_freeIso g d (Fin N)))) · have hπ : Epi (cokernel.π a) := inferInstanceAs (Epi (cokernel.π (C := Coh Y) a)) exact @freeTwistedLayerQuotient_epi X Y _ _ g _ d _ _ _ (cokernel.π a) hπ j end ActualCartier end /-! The framed open is the complement of the completed exceptional plane. -/ noncomputable section open CategoryTheory CategoryTheory.Limits _root_.AlgebraicGeometry _root_.OAI.AlgebraicGeometry Scheme.Modules namespace SourceZeroSections open KummerSourceModel SourceConeMorphism lemma seriesOrigin_kernel : RingHom.ker (MvPowerSeries.constantCoeff : A →+* ℂ) = Ideal.span (Set.range (MvPowerSeries.X : Fin 3 → A)) := by apply le_antisymm · intro a ha exact mvPowerSeries_constantCoeff_zero_mem_vars a ha · apply Ideal.span_le.mpr rintro _ ⟨i, rfl⟩ exact MvPowerSeries.constantCoeff_X i lemma seriesOrigin_range_compl : (Set.range seriesOrigin)ᶜ = (seriesPuncture : Set (Spec (.of A))) := by change (Set.range (PrimeSpectrum.comap (MvPowerSeries.constantCoeff : A →+* ℂ)))ᶜ = _ rw [range_comap_of_surjective ℂ _ (fun a => ⟨MvPowerSeries.C a, MvPowerSeries.constantCoeff_C a⟩), seriesOrigin_kernel, PrimeSpectrum.zeroLocus_span] ext q simp only [Set.mem_compl_iff, PrimeSpectrum.mem_zeroLocus, Set.range_subset_iff, SetLike.mem_coe, seriesPuncture] simp only [not_forall] erw [TopologicalSpace.Opens.mem_iSup] rfl lemma completedPlaneZero_range : Set.range completedPlaneZero = completedBlowdown ⁻¹' Set.range seriesOrigin := by have he : Set.range completedPlaneZero = Set.range (pullback.fst completedBlowdown seriesOrigin) := by let e := completedPlaneZero_isPullback.isoPullback ext x constructor · rintro ⟨y, rfl⟩ refine ⟨e.hom y, ?_⟩ change (e.hom ≫ pullback.fst completedBlowdown seriesOrigin) y = _ rw [IsPullback.isoPullback_hom_fst] · rintro ⟨y, rfl⟩ refine ⟨e.inv y, ?_⟩ change (e.inv ≫ completedPlaneZero) y = _ rw [IsPullback.isoPullback_inv_fst] rw [he, Scheme.Pullback.range_fst] lemma planeComplement_eq : ActualOpenSupport.complement completedPlaneZero = baseModelPuncture := by apply TopologicalSpace.Opens.ext change (Set.range completedPlaneZero)ᶜ = completedBlowdown ⁻¹' (seriesPuncture : Set (Spec (.of A))) rw [completedPlaneZero_range, ← Set.preimage_compl, seriesOrigin_range_compl] end SourceZeroSections namespace SourceConeMorphism open KummerSourceModel SourcePullbackChart SourceZeroSections variable (M : ModuleCat.{0} ExplicitCone.completedRing) [Module.Finite ExplicitCone.completedRing M] [Nontrivial M] (hdepth : SmallCM.localDepth ExplicitCone.completedRing M = 3) def modelPushforwardComplementFreeIso : (restrictFunctor (ActualOpenSupport.complement completedPlaneZero).ι).obj (modelPushforward M) ≅ SheafOfModules.free (basisIndex M hdepth) := by rw [planeComplement_eq] exact modelPushforwardFreeIso M hdepth /-- The slice-site framing for the generic lattice construction. -/ def modelPushforwardOverFreeIso : (modelPushforward M).over (ActualOpenSupport.complement completedPlaneZero) ≅ (SheafOfModules.free (R := V.ringCatSheaf) (basisIndex M hdepth)).over (ActualOpenSupport.complement completedPlaneZero) := by let U := ActualOpenSupport.complement completedPlaneZero exact (overEquiv U).functor.preimageIso ((overFunctorEquiv U).app (modelPushforward M) ≪≫ modelPushforwardComplementFreeIso M hdepth ≪≫ (IsoPuncturePushforward.restrictFreeIso U.ι _).symm ≪≫ ((overFunctorEquiv U).app (SheafOfModules.free (R := V.ringCatSheaf) (basisIndex M hdepth))).symm) end SourceConeMorphism end /-! The kernel ideal of the completed plane zero section is invertible. -/ noncomputable section open _root_.AlgebraicGeometry _root_.OAI.AlgebraicGeometry CategoryTheory CategoryTheory.Limits Opposite namespace SourceZeroSections open KummerSourceModel SourcePullbackChart Scheme.Modules ActualCartier ActualSheafTensor attribute [local instance] originChartCommRing originChartSemiring originPlaneCommRing originPlaneSemiring chartBaseAlgebra planeOriginAlgebra baseChartModule baseChartAction baseChartSMul baseChartTower planeOriginModule completedBlowupCommRing completedBlowupSemiring completedBlowupAlgebra def planeIdealChartIso (i : Fin 3) : (restrictFunctor (completedBlowupIota i)).obj (idealSheaf completedPlaneZero) ≅ SheafOfModules.unit (Spec (.of (completedBlowupChart i))).ringCatSheaf := chartAffinePrincipalIdealUnitIso completedPlaneZero (CommRingCat.ofHom (completedPlaneEvaluation i)) (planeIota i) (completedBlowupIota i) (planeIota_completedPlaneZero i) (by simpa only [Scheme.Hom.image_top_eq_opensRange] using (planeZero_chart_preimage i).symm) (completedBlowupFiber i) (completedBlowupFiber_regular i) (completedPlaneEvaluation_kernel i) def planeIdealLine : LineTrivialization V.sheaf (idealSheaf completedPlaneZero) := lineTrivializationOfCharts _ (fun i => Spec (.of (completedBlowupChart i))) completedBlowupIota completedBlowupCover planeIdealChartIso lemma planeIdeal_coherent : (idealSheaf completedPlaneZero).IsFinitePresentation := idealSheaf_coherent _ end SourceZeroSections end /-! Coherent lattices for full-depth modules on the completed cone, with their conormal layers and Cartier restriction identity. -/ noncomputable section open CategoryTheory CategoryTheory.Limits _root_.AlgebraicGeometry _root_.OAI.AlgebraicGeometry Scheme.Modules namespace SourceConeMorphism open KummerSourceModel SourcePullbackChart SourceZeroSections ActualCartier ActualSheafTensor CartierImageFiltration CoherentK0 CoherentGlobal attribute [local instance] originPlaneCommRing originPlaneSemiring local instance planeChart_noetherian (i : Fin 3) : IsNoetherianRing (planeChart i) := isNoetherianRing_of_surjective KummerSourceModel.S (planeChart i) (SectionCompletion.polynomialChartDehom i).toRingHom (polynomialChartDehom_surjective i) instance sourcePlane_noetherian : IsLocallyNoetherian ExplicitCone.plane := by have (i : planeCover.I₀) : IsLocallyNoetherian (planeCover.X i) := by change Fin 3 at i change IsLocallyNoetherian (Spec (.of (planeChart i))) infer_instance exact (isLocallyNoetherian_iff_openCover planeCover).mpr (fun i => inferInstance) instance sourceV_compact : CompactSpace V := QuasiCompact.compactSpace_of_compactSpace completedBlowdown variable (M : ModuleCat.{0} ExplicitCone.completedRing) [Module.Finite ExplicitCone.completedRing M] [Nontrivial M] (hdepth : SmallCM.localDepth ExplicitCone.completedRing M = 3) local instance pushforward_coherent : (modelPushforward M).IsFinitePresentation := modelPushforward_coherent M noncomputable instance basisIndex_fintype : Fintype (basisIndex M hdepth) := Fintype.ofFinite _ abbrev sourceFreeRank : ℕ := Fintype.card (basisIndex M hdepth) lemma sourceFreeRank_pos : 0 < sourceFreeRank M hdepth := by let := parameterModule_free M hdepth let : Nontrivial (parameterModule M) := show Nontrivial M from inferInstance have : Nonempty (basisIndex M hdepth) := (Module.Free.chooseBasis A (parameterModule M)).index_nonempty exact Fintype.card_pos_iff.mpr this def modelPushforwardOverFinIso : (modelPushforward M).over (ActualOpenSupport.complement completedPlaneZero) ≅ (SheafOfModules.free (R := V.ringCatSheaf) (Fin (sourceFreeRank M hdepth))).over (ActualOpenSupport.complement completedPlaneZero) := modelPushforwardOverFreeIso M hdepth ≪≫ (SheafOfModules.overFunctor V.ringCatSheaf (ActualOpenSupport.complement completedPlaneZero)).mapIso (SheafOfModules.freeFunctor.mapIso (Fintype.equivFin (basisIndex M hdepth)).toIso) /-- Coherent lattice, finite conormal layers, K₀ identity, and quotients of conormal-twisted free sheaves for the finite pushforward. Every premise of the reused lattice theorem is supplied by the source. -/ theorem exists_source_free_lattice : ∃ k : ℕ, ∀ n : ℕ, k ≤ n → ∃ a : clearedLattice completedPlaneZero planeIdealLine n (modelPushforward M) ⟶ coherentFree V (Fin (sourceFreeRank M hdepth)), Mono a ∧ ((cohInclusion V).map a).over (ActualOpenSupport.complement completedPlaneZero) = ((powerAction (tensorLeft V.sheaf (idealSheaf completedPlaneZero)) (idealAction V.sheaf (idealι completedPlaneZero)) n).app (modelPushforward M)).over (ActualOpenSupport.complement completedPlaneZero) ≫ (modelPushforwardOverFinIso M hdepth).hom ∧ IsZero (idealMultiple completedPlaneZero planeIdealLine (n + n) (cokernel a)) ∧ cls ((restriction completedPlaneZero planeIdealLine).obj (clearedLattice completedPlaneZero planeIdealLine n (modelPushforward M))) = cls (coherentFree ExplicitCone.plane (Fin (sourceFreeRank M hdepth))) + ((idealLayers completedPlaneZero planeIdealLine (n + n) (cokernel a)).map fun Q => cls (conormalTensor completedPlaneZero planeIdealLine Q) - cls Q).sum ∧ ∀ j : ℕ, Epi (freeTwistedLayerQuotient completedPlaneZero planeIdealLine (cokernel.π a) j) := by let := modelPushforward_coherent M exact exists_free_cleared_lattice completedPlaneZero planeIdealLine (modelPushforward M) (modelPushforward_torsionFree M) (sourceFreeRank M hdepth) (modelPushforwardOverFinIso M hdepth) end SourceConeMorphism end /-! Elementary transformations along the exceptional divisor of the completed model. -/ noncomputable section open CategoryTheory CategoryTheory.Limits _root_.AlgebraicGeometry _root_.OAI.AlgebraicGeometry Opposite namespace SourceConeMorphism open KummerSourceModel SourceZeroSections CoherentGlobal ActualCartier ActualSheafTensor Scheme.Modules instance sourceSurface_noetherian : IsLocallyNoetherian ExplicitCone.projectiveSurface := LocallyOfFiniteType.isLocallyNoetherian completedSourceZero abbrev sourceRestriction := restriction completedSourceZero sourceIdealLine abbrev coherentModel (M : ModuleCat ExplicitCone.completedRing) [Module.Finite ExplicitCone.completedRing M] : Coh W := ⟨E M, E_coherent M⟩ def sourceRestrictionIso (B : Coh W) : (Scheme.Modules.pullback completedSourceZero).obj B.obj ≅ (sourceRestriction.obj B).obj := restrictionPullbackIso completedSourceZero sourceIdealLine B lemma modelRestriction_torsionFree (M : ModuleCat ExplicitCone.completedRing) [Module.Finite ExplicitCone.completedRing M] (U : ExplicitCone.projectiveSurface.Opensᵒᵖ) : Module.IsTorsionFree (ExplicitCone.projectiveSurface.sheaf.obj.obj U) ((sourceRestriction.obj (coherentModel M)).obj.val.obj U) := @SheafTorsion.subobject _ _ _ (sourceRestrictionIso (coherentModel M)).inv (@IsIso.mono_of_iso _ _ _ _ _ (sourceRestrictionIso (coherentModel M)).isIso_inv) (fun V => SourceExceptionalRestriction.P_torsionFree M V.unop) U abbrev elementaryTransform {B : Coh W} {G : Coh ExplicitCone.projectiveSurface} (q : sourceRestriction.obj B ⟶ G) : Coh W := kernel (modificationMap completedSourceZero sourceIdealLine q) lemma elementaryTransform_torsionFree {B : Coh W} {G : Coh ExplicitCone.projectiveSurface} (q : sourceRestriction.obj B ⟶ G) (hB : ∀ U, Module.IsTorsionFree (W.sheaf.obj.obj U) (B.obj.val.obj U)) (U : W.Opensᵒᵖ) : Module.IsTorsionFree (W.sheaf.obj.obj U) ((elementaryTransform q).obj.val.obj U) := SheafTorsion.subobject ((cohInclusion W).map (kernel.ι (modificationMap completedSourceZero sourceIdealLine q))) hB U /-- The divisor restriction of an elementary transform is torsion-free when the chosen quotient is torsion-free. -/ lemma elementaryTransform_restriction_torsionFree {B : Coh W} {G : Coh ExplicitCone.projectiveSurface} (q : sourceRestriction.obj B ⟶ G) [Epi q] (hB : ∀ U, Module.IsTorsionFree (W.sheaf.obj.obj U) (B.obj.val.obj U)) (hP : ∀ U, Module.IsTorsionFree (ExplicitCone.projectiveSurface.sheaf.obj.obj U) ((sourceRestriction.obj B).obj.val.obj U)) (hG : ∀ U, Module.IsTorsionFree (ExplicitCone.projectiveSurface.sheaf.obj.obj U) (G.obj.val.obj U)) (U : ExplicitCone.projectiveSurface.Opensᵒᵖ) : Module.IsTorsionFree (ExplicitCone.projectiveSurface.sheaf.obj.obj U) ((sourceRestriction.obj (elementaryTransform q)).obj.val.obj U) := by let S := transformSequence completedSourceZero sourceIdealLine q have hs := transformSequence_shortExact completedSourceZero sourceIdealLine q hB have : Mono S.f := hs.mono_f apply SheafTorsion.coherent_extension S hs.exact · intro V exact SheafTorsion.tensor_line _ _ (sourceIdealLine.pullback completedSourceZero _) hG V · intro V exact SheafTorsion.subobject ((cohInclusion ExplicitCone.projectiveSurface).map (kernel.ι q)) hP V lemma elementaryTransform_puncture {B : Coh W} {G : Coh ExplicitCone.projectiveSurface} (q : sourceRestriction.obj B ⟶ G) [Epi q] : IsIso ((restrictFunctor (ActualOpenSupport.complement completedSourceZero).ι).map ((cohInclusion W).map (kernel.ι (modificationMap completedSourceZero sourceIdealLine q)))) := by apply modification_puncture_isIso completedSourceZero sourceIdealLine q exact ActualCartier.preimage_complement _ end SourceConeMorphism end /-! Extensions obtained by successive elementary transformations in the balancing argument. -/ noncomputable section open CategoryTheory CategoryTheory.Limits _root_.AlgebraicGeometry _root_.OAI.AlgebraicGeometry Opposite namespace SourceConeMorphism open KummerSourceModel SourceZeroSections SourcePullbackChart CoherentGlobal ActualCartier ActualSheafTensor Scheme.Modules abbrev sourceFramedOpen : W.Opens := g ⁻¹ᵁ ActualOpenSupport.complement completedPlaneZero lemma sourceZero_preimage_framed : completedSourceZero ⁻¹ᵁ sourceFramedOpen = ⊥ := by change completedSourceZero ⁻¹ᵁ (g ⁻¹ᵁ ActualOpenSupport.complement completedPlaneZero) = ⊥ rw [← Scheme.Hom.comp_preimage, completedSourceZero_isPullback.w, Scheme.Hom.comp_preimage, ActualCartier.preimage_complement, Scheme.Hom.preimage_bot] structure ExtensionState (M : ModuleCat ExplicitCone.completedRing) where sheaf : Coh W ambient_tf : ∀ U, Module.IsTorsionFree (W.sheaf.obj.obj U) (sheaf.obj.val.obj U) divisor_tf : ∀ U, Module.IsTorsionFree (ExplicitCone.projectiveSurface.sheaf.obj.obj U) ((sourceRestriction.obj sheaf).obj.val.obj U) punctureIso : (restrictFunctor sourceFramedOpen.ι).obj sheaf.obj ≅ (restrictFunctor sourceFramedOpen.ι).obj (E M) namespace ExtensionState variable {M : ModuleCat ExplicitCone.completedRing} def initial [Module.Finite ExplicitCone.completedRing M] : ExtensionState M where sheaf := coherentModel M ambient_tf U := E_torsionFree M U.unop divisor_tf := modelRestriction_torsionFree M punctureIso := Iso.refl _ /-- The elementary transform constructs another admissible extension and preserves its punctured framing. -/ def transform (B : ExtensionState M) {G : Coh ExplicitCone.projectiveSurface} (q : sourceRestriction.obj B.sheaf ⟶ G) [Epi q] (hG : ∀ U, Module.IsTorsionFree (ExplicitCone.projectiveSurface.sheaf.obj.obj U) (G.obj.val.obj U)) : ExtensionState M where sheaf := elementaryTransform q ambient_tf := elementaryTransform_torsionFree q B.ambient_tf divisor_tf := elementaryTransform_restriction_torsionFree q B.ambient_tf B.divisor_tf hG punctureIso := by have := modification_puncture_isIso completedSourceZero sourceIdealLine q sourceFramedOpen sourceZero_preimage_framed exact asIso ((restrictFunctor sourceFramedOpen.ι).map ((cohInclusion W).map (kernel.ι (modificationMap completedSourceZero sourceIdealLine q)))) ≪≫ B.punctureIso def pushforward (B : ExtensionState M) : Coh V := (cohPushforward g).obj B.sheaf lemma pushforward_torsionFree (B : ExtensionState M) (U : V.Opensᵒᵖ) : Module.IsTorsionFree (V.sheaf.obj.obj U) (B.pushforward.obj.val.obj U) := SheafTorsion.pushforward g B.sheaf.obj B.ambient_tf U variable [Module.Finite ExplicitCone.completedRing M] [Nontrivial M] (hdepth : SmallCM.localDepth ExplicitCone.completedRing M = 3) def pushforwardFraming (B : ExtensionState M) : (restrictFunctor (ActualOpenSupport.complement completedPlaneZero).ι).obj B.pushforward.obj ≅ SheafOfModules.free (basisIndex M hdepth) := CoherentBaseChange.pushforwardRestrictIso g _ B.sheaf.obj ≪≫ (Scheme.Modules.pushforward (g ∣_ ActualOpenSupport.complement completedPlaneZero)).mapIso B.punctureIso ≪≫ (CoherentBaseChange.pushforwardRestrictIso g _ (E M)).symm ≪≫ modelPushforwardComplementFreeIso M hdepth def pushforwardOverFinIso (B : ExtensionState M) : B.pushforward.obj.over (ActualOpenSupport.complement completedPlaneZero) ≅ (SheafOfModules.free (R := V.ringCatSheaf) (Fin (sourceFreeRank M hdepth))).over (ActualOpenSupport.complement completedPlaneZero) := by let U := ActualOpenSupport.complement completedPlaneZero exact (overEquiv U).functor.preimageIso ((overFunctorEquiv U).app B.pushforward.obj ≪≫ B.pushforwardFraming hdepth ≪≫ SheafOfModules.freeFunctor.mapIso (Fintype.equivFin (basisIndex M hdepth)).toIso ≪≫ (IsoPuncturePushforward.restrictFreeIso U.ι _).symm ≪≫ ((overFunctorEquiv U).app (SheafOfModules.free (R := V.ringCatSheaf) (Fin (sourceFreeRank M hdepth)))).symm) end ExtensionState end SourceConeMorphism end /-! Lattices associated to extensions obtained by elementary transformations. -/ noncomputable section open CategoryTheory CategoryTheory.Limits _root_.AlgebraicGeometry _root_.OAI.AlgebraicGeometry Scheme.Modules namespace SourceConeMorphism.ExtensionState open KummerSourceModel SourceZeroSections ActualCartier ActualSheafTensor CoherentGlobal CartierImageFiltration CoherentK0 variable {M : ModuleCat.{0} ExplicitCone.completedRing} [Module.Finite ExplicitCone.completedRing M] [Nontrivial M] (hdepth : SmallCM.localDepth ExplicitCone.completedRing M = 3) local instance (B : ExtensionState M) : B.pushforward.obj.IsFinitePresentation := B.pushforward.property /-- The exact coherent K₀ statement and conormal-twisted quotient layers needed by the lattice inequality, for any constructed extension. -/ theorem exists_free_lattice (B : ExtensionState M) : ∃ k : ℕ, ∀ n : ℕ, k ≤ n → ∃ a : clearedLattice completedPlaneZero planeIdealLine n B.pushforward.obj ⟶ coherentFree V (Fin (sourceFreeRank M hdepth)), Mono a ∧ ((cohInclusion V).map a).over (ActualOpenSupport.complement completedPlaneZero) = ((powerAction (tensorLeft V.sheaf (idealSheaf completedPlaneZero)) (idealAction V.sheaf (idealι completedPlaneZero)) n).app B.pushforward.obj).over (ActualOpenSupport.complement completedPlaneZero) ≫ (B.pushforwardOverFinIso hdepth).hom ∧ IsZero (idealMultiple completedPlaneZero planeIdealLine (n + n) (cokernel a)) ∧ cls ((restriction completedPlaneZero planeIdealLine).obj (clearedLattice completedPlaneZero planeIdealLine n B.pushforward.obj)) = cls (coherentFree ExplicitCone.plane (Fin (sourceFreeRank M hdepth))) + ((idealLayers completedPlaneZero planeIdealLine (n + n) (cokernel a)).map fun Q => cls (conormalTensor completedPlaneZero planeIdealLine Q) - cls Q).sum ∧ ∀ j : ℕ, Epi (freeTwistedLayerQuotient completedPlaneZero planeIdealLine (cokernel.π a) j) := by exact exists_free_cleared_lattice completedPlaneZero planeIdealLine B.pushforward.obj B.pushforward_torsionFree (sourceFreeRank M hdepth) (B.pushforwardOverFinIso hdepth) end SourceConeMorphism.ExtensionState end /-! Finite pushforward commutes with restriction for every admissible extension, identifying the restricted lattice with the pushforward of the exceptional sheaf. -/ noncomputable section open CategoryTheory CategoryTheory.Limits _root_.AlgebraicGeometry _root_.OAI.AlgebraicGeometry Scheme.Modules namespace SourceConeMorphism.ExtensionState open KummerSourceModel SourceZeroSections SourcePullbackChart CoherentGlobal ActualCartier CoherentK0 attribute [local instance] ExplicitCone.projectiveNormalization_finite variable {M : ModuleCat ExplicitCone.completedRing} (B : ExtensionState M) def restrictionPushforwardIso : (restriction completedPlaneZero planeIdealLine).obj B.pushforward ≅ (cohPushforward ExplicitCone.projectiveNormalization).obj (sourceRestriction.obj B.sheaf) := by have := B.sheaf.property exact ObjectProperty.isoMk _ ((restrictionPullbackIso completedPlaneZero planeIdealLine B.pushforward).symm ≪≫ actualClosedBaseChangeIso B.sheaf.obj ≪≫ (Scheme.Modules.pushforward ExplicitCone.projectiveNormalization).mapIso (sourceRestrictionIso B.sheaf)) lemma restrictionPushforward_class : cls ((restriction completedPlaneZero planeIdealLine).obj B.pushforward) = cls ((cohPushforward ExplicitCone.projectiveNormalization).obj (sourceRestriction.obj B.sheaf)) := cls_iso (restrictionPushforwardIso B) end SourceConeMorphism.ExtensionState end /-! Compatibility of canonical mates with object maps in a Cartier base-change square. -/ noncomputable section open CategoryTheory namespace ActualMateUnit universe v₁ v₂ v₃ v₄ u₁ u₂ u₃ u₄ variable {C₁ : Type u₁} {D₁ : Type u₂} {C₂ : Type u₃} {D₂ : Type u₄} [Category.{v₁} C₁] [Category.{v₂} D₁] [Category.{v₃} C₂] [Category.{v₄} D₂] {L₁ : C₁ ⥤ D₁} {R₁ : D₁ ⥤ C₁} {L₂ : C₂ ⥤ D₂} {R₂ : D₂ ⥤ C₂} (a₁ : L₁ ⊣ R₁) (a₂ : L₂ ⊣ R₂) {T : C₁ ⥤ C₂} {B : D₁ ⥤ D₂} (δ : R₁ ⋙ T ⟶ B ⋙ R₂) lemma chosen_units {M : C₁} {N : C₂} {P : D₁} {Q : D₂} (a : N ⟶ T.obj M) (b : Q ⟶ B.obj P) (e₁ : L₁.obj M ⟶ P) (e₂ : L₂.obj N ⟶ Q) (h : a ≫ T.map (a₁.unit.app M ≫ R₁.map e₁) ≫ δ.app P = (a₂.unit.app N ≫ R₂.map e₂) ≫ R₂.map b) : L₂.map a ≫ (((mateEquiv a₁ a₂).symm (TwoSquare.mk _ _ _ _ δ)).natTrans.app M) ≫ B.map e₁ = e₂ ≫ b := by apply (a₂.homEquiv _ _).injective simp only [Adjunction.homEquiv_unit, Functor.map_comp] rw [a₂.unit_naturality_assoc a] rw [← reassoc_of% (unit_mateEquiv_symm a₁ a₂ (TwoSquare.mk _ _ _ _ δ) M)] change a ≫ T.map (a₁.unit.app M) ≫ δ.app (L₁.obj M) ≫ R₂.map (B.map e₁) = _ erw [← δ.naturality e₁] simp only [Functor.comp_map] rw [← reassoc_of% (T.map_comp (a₁.unit.app M) (R₁.map e₁))] simpa only [Category.assoc] using h lemma three_iso_chain {C : Type*} [Category C] {A B D E F G : C} (s : A ⟶ B) (t : B ⟶ D) (e : D ≅ E) (k : E ≅ F) (l : G ≅ F) (u : A ⟶ G) (x : A ⟶ E) (y : A ⟶ F) (hc : s ≫ t ≫ e.hom = x) (hk : x ≫ k.hom = y) (hl : u ≫ l.hom = y) : s ≫ t ≫ (e.hom ≫ k.hom ≫ l.inv) = u := by apply (cancel_mono l.hom).mp simp only [Category.assoc, l.inv_hom_id, Category.comp_id] rw [← Category.assoc t, ← Category.assoc s, hc, hk, hl] end ActualMateUnit end /-! The base-change mate respects the structure-sheaf maps, identifying the source Cartier ideal with the pullback of the base Cartier ideal. -/ noncomputable section open _root_.AlgebraicGeometry _root_.OAI.AlgebraicGeometry CategoryTheory CategoryTheory.Limits Opposite namespace ActualCartier open Scheme.Modules ActualSheafTensor ActualSheafBaseChange variable {B C D E : Scheme.{0}} lemma structure_comp (f : C ⟶ B) (w : E ⟶ C) : structureMap f ≫ (pushforward f).map (structureMap w) ≫ (pushforwardComp w f).hom.app (SheafOfModules.unit _) = structureMap (w ≫ f) := by apply Scheme.Modules.hom_ext intro U apply AddCommGrpCat.ext intro r rfl lemma structure_congr {f g : C ⟶ B} (h : f = g) : structureMap f ≫ (pushforwardCongr h).hom.app (SheafOfModules.unit _) = structureMap g := by subst g apply Scheme.Modules.hom_ext intro U apply AddCommGrpCat.ext intro r change C.presheaf.map (eqToHom (rfl : f ⁻¹ᵁ U = f ⁻¹ᵁ U)).op (f.app U r) = f.app U r simp lemma structure_square (f : C ⟶ B) (z : D ⟶ B) (w : E ⟶ C) (q : E ⟶ D) (h : w ≫ f = q ≫ z) : structureMap f ≫ (pushforward f).map (structureMap w) ≫ (rightIso f z w q h).hom.app (SheafOfModules.unit _) = structureMap z ≫ (pushforward z).map (structureMap q) := by exact ActualMateUnit.three_iso_chain (structureMap f) ((pushforward f).map (structureMap w)) ((pushforwardComp w f).app _) ((pushforwardCongr h).app _) ((pushforwardComp q z).app _) (structureMap z ≫ (pushforward z).map (structureMap q)) (structureMap (w ≫ f)) (structureMap (q ≫ z)) (structure_comp f w) (structure_congr h) (by change (structureMap z ≫ (pushforward z).map (structureMap q)) ≫ (pushforwardComp q z).hom.app (SheafOfModules.unit _) = _ exact (Category.assoc _ _ _).trans (structure_comp z q)) lemma pullbackUnit_adj (z : D ⟶ B) : (pullbackPushforwardAdjunction z).unit.app (SheafOfModules.unit _) ≫ (pushforward z).map (sheafPullbackUnitIso z).hom = structureMap z := by apply Scheme.Modules.hom_ext intro U apply AddCommGrpCat.ext intro r exact sheafPullbackUnitIso_unit z U r lemma baseChange_structure (f : C ⟶ B) (z : D ⟶ B) (w : E ⟶ C) (q : E ⟶ D) (h : w ≫ f = q ≫ z) : (Scheme.Modules.pullback z).map (structureMap f) ≫ (mate f z w q h).app (SheafOfModules.unit _) ≫ (pushforward q).map (sheafPullbackUnitIso w).hom = (sheafPullbackUnitIso z).hom ≫ structureMap q := by apply ActualMateUnit.chosen_units (pullbackPushforwardAdjunction w) (pullbackPushforwardAdjunction z) (rightIso f z w q h).hom (structureMap f) (structureMap q) (sheafPullbackUnitIso w).hom (sheafPullbackUnitIso z).hom rw [pullbackUnit_adj, pullbackUnit_adj] exact structure_square f z w q h end ActualCartier end /-! The closed structure map is an epimorphism by the cokernel property of Cartier restriction. -/ noncomputable section open _root_.AlgebraicGeometry _root_.OAI.AlgebraicGeometry CategoryTheory CategoryTheory.Limits namespace ActualCartier open Scheme.Modules CoherentGlobal ActualSheafTensor variable {X Y : Scheme.{0}} [IsLocallyNoetherian Y] (f : X ⟶ Y) [IsClosedImmersion f] (d : LineTrivialization Y.sheaf (idealSheaf f)) lemma restrictionPullbackIso_unit (M : Coh Y) : (pullbackPushforwardAdjunction f).unit.app M.obj ≫ (pushforward f).map (restrictionPullbackIso f d M).hom = ((restrictionUnit f d).app M).hom := by change (pullbackPushforwardAdjunction f).unit.app M.obj ≫ (pushforward f).map (((pullbackPushforwardAdjunction f).homEquiv M.obj _).symm ((restrictionUnit f d).app M).hom) = _ exact ((pullbackPushforwardAdjunction f).homEquiv M.obj _).apply_symm_apply _ include d in lemma coherent_adjUnit_epi (M : Coh Y) : Epi ((pullbackPushforwardAdjunction f).unit.app M.obj) := by have : Epi ((cohInclusion Y).map ((restrictionUnit f d).app M)) := inferInstance have hE : Epi (((restrictionUnit f d).app M).hom) := this have he := restrictionPullbackIso_unit f d M have hI : IsIso ((pushforward f).map (restrictionPullbackIso f d M).hom) := ((pushforward f).mapIso (restrictionPullbackIso f d M)).isIso_hom have hc : Epi ((pullbackPushforwardAdjunction f).unit.app M.obj ≫ (pushforward f).map (restrictionPullbackIso f d M).hom) := he.symm ▸ hE exact (epi_comp_iff_of_isIso _ ((pushforward f).map (restrictionPullbackIso f d M).hom)).mp hc include d in lemma structureMap_epi : Epi (structureMap f) := by let M : Coh Y := ⟨SheafOfModules.unit _, CoherentLocality.finitePresentation_unit _⟩ have hE : Epi ((pullbackPushforwardAdjunction f).unit.app (SheafOfModules.unit _)) := coherent_adjUnit_epi f d M have hI : IsIso ((pushforward f).map (sheafPullbackUnitIso f).hom) := ((pushforward f).mapIso (sheafPullbackUnitIso f)).isIso_hom have hc := epi_comp' hE (@IsIso.epi_of_iso _ _ _ _ _ hI) erw [pullbackUnit_adj] at hc exact hc end ActualCartier end /-! A right-exact pullback induces an epimorphism of kernel ideals when the quotient square is identified. -/ noncomputable section open CategoryTheory CategoryTheory.Limits namespace ActualRightExactIdeal universe v₁ v₂ u₁ u₂ variable {C : Type u₁} {D : Type u₂} [Category.{v₁} C] [Category.{v₂} D] [Abelian C] [Abelian D] (F : C ⥤ D) [F.PreservesZeroMorphisms] [PreservesFiniteColimits F] lemma kernelComparison_epi {X Y : C} (f : X ⟶ Y) [Epi f] : Epi (kernelComparison f F) := by let S := ShortComplex.mk (kernel.ι f) f (kernel.condition f) have hc : IsColimit (CokernelCofork.ofπ S.g S.zero) := (ShortComplex.exact_kernel f).gIsCokernel have he : (S.map F).Exact := ShortComplex.exact_of_g_is_cokernel _ (CokernelCofork.mapIsColimit _ hc F) exact ((S.map F).exact_iff_epi_kernel_lift).mp he def comparison {X Y : C} (f : X ⟶ Y) {X' Y' : D} (g : X' ⟶ Y') (a : F.obj X ≅ X') (b : F.obj Y ≅ Y') (h : F.map f ≫ b.hom = a.hom ≫ g) : F.obj (kernel f) ⟶ kernel g := kernelComparison f F ≫ (kernel.mapIso (F.map f) g a b h).hom instance comparison_epi {X Y : C} (f : X ⟶ Y) [Epi f] {X' Y' : D} (g : X' ⟶ Y') (a : F.obj X ≅ X') (b : F.obj Y ≅ Y') (h : F.map f ≫ b.hom = a.hom ≫ g) : Epi (comparison F f g a b h) := by have := kernelComparison_epi F f dsimp only [comparison] infer_instance omit [PreservesFiniteColimits F] in lemma comparison_ι {X Y : C} (f : X ⟶ Y) {X' Y' : D} (g : X' ⟶ Y') (a : F.obj X ≅ X') (b : F.obj Y ≅ Y') (h : F.map f ≫ b.hom = a.hom ≫ g) : comparison F f g a b h ≫ kernel.ι g = F.map (kernel.ι f) ≫ a.hom := by simp [comparison] end ActualRightExactIdeal end end OAI