import OAI.Analysis.FactorGeneration.HaarSequences namespace OAI noncomputable section namespace Generator.Tracial /-! Every nonempty reduced word in successive Haar variables has zero trace. The induction eliminates the largest label, retaining centered lower-label gaps. -/ section open UltrapowerBridge Filter variable {H : Type*} [NormedAddCommGroup H] [InnerProductSpace ℂ H] [CompleteSpace H] variable {M : VonNeumannAlgebra H} (τ : TracialRepresentation M) (ω : Ultrafilter ℕ) def unitaryWord {A : Type*} (v : A → unitary (Q τ ω)) (w : List (A × Bool)) : Q τ ω := (w.map (fun x => algebraSignedLetter (v x.1 : Q τ ω) (!x.2))).prod theorem unitaryWord_nil {A : Type*} (v : A → unitary (Q τ ω)) : unitaryWord τ ω v []=1 := rfl theorem unitaryWord_cons {A : Type*} (v : A → unitary (Q τ ω)) (x : A × Bool) (w : List (A × Bool)) : unitaryWord τ ω v (x::w)=algebraSignedLetter (v x.1 : Q τ ω) (!x.2)*unitaryWord τ ω v w := rfl theorem unitaryWord_append {A : Type*} (v : A → unitary (Q τ ω)) (a b : List (A × Bool)) : unitaryWord τ ω v (a++b)=unitaryWord τ ω v a*unitaryWord τ ω v b := by simp [unitaryWord,List.map_append,List.prod_append] theorem unitaryWord_mem {A : Type*} (v : A → unitary (Q τ ω)) (D : StarSubalgebra ℂ (Q τ ω)) (w : List (A × Bool)) (hv : ∀ x ∈ w,(v x.1 : Q τ ω) ∈ D) : unitaryWord τ ω v w ∈ D := by induction w with | nil => exact D.one_mem | cons x w ih => apply D.mul_mem _ (ih (fun y hy => hv y (by simp [hy]))) have hx := hv x (by simp) change algebraSignedLetter (v x.1 : Q τ ω) (!x.2) ∈ D unfold algebraSignedLetter split · exact star_mem hx · exact hx /-- Scan the tail after a maximal label. Empty gaps can only join equal signs. -/ theorem maximal_word_gaps (v : ℕ → unitary (Q τ ω)) (D : StarSubalgebra ℂ (Q τ ω)) (n : ℕ) (hv : ∀ i < n,(v i : Q τ ω) ∈ D) (hzero : ∀ a : List (ℕ × Bool),FreeGroup.IsReduced a → a ≠ [] → (∀ x ∈ a,x.1 < n) → quotientTrace τ ω (unitaryWord τ ω v a)=0) (w : List (ℕ × Bool)) (s : Bool) (hr : FreeGroup.IsReduced ((n,s)::w)) (hn : ∀ x ∈ w,x.1 ≤ n) : ∃ xs b,b ∈ D ∧ SignedReducedGaps τ ω D.toSubalgebra (!s) xs ∧ unitaryWord τ ω v ((n,s)::w)=betweenWord (v n : Q τ ω) (!s) xs b := by classical by_cases hex : ∃ x ∈ w,x.1=n · obtain ⟨a,t,c,he,ha⟩ := word_split_first n w hex have hlt : ∀ x ∈ a,x.1 < n := by intro x hx have := hn x (by rw [he]; simp [hx]) have := ha x hx omega have har : FreeGroup.IsReduced a := reduced_append_left (he ▸ reduced_tail hr) have hcr : FreeGroup.IsReduced ((n,t)::c) := reduced_append_right (he ▸ reduced_tail hr) have hcn : ∀ x ∈ c,x.1 ≤ n := by intro x hx exact hn x (by rw [he]; simp [hx]) obtain ⟨xs,b,hb,hxs,hev⟩ := maximal_word_gaps v D n hv hzero c t hcr hcn have ham : unitaryWord τ ω v a ∈ D := unitaryWord_mem τ ω v D a (fun x hx => hv _ (hlt x hx)) have hac : (!s) ≠ (!t) → quotientTrace τ ω (unitaryWord τ ω v a)=0 := by intro hst apply hzero a har _ hlt intro hempty have hr' : FreeGroup.IsReduced ((n,s)::(n,t)::c) := by simpa only [he,hempty,List.nil_append] using hr have hst' : s=t := (FreeGroup.isReduced_cons_cons.mp hr').1 rfl exact hst (congrArg Bool.not hst') refine ⟨(unitaryWord τ ω v a,!t)::xs,b,hb,⟨ham,hac,hxs⟩,?_⟩ rw [unitaryWord_cons,he,unitaryWord_append,hev] simp only [betweenWord,mul_assoc] · refine ⟨[],unitaryWord τ ω v w,?_,trivial,rfl⟩ apply unitaryWord_mem τ ω v D w intro x hx apply hv have := hn x hx have : x.1 ≠ n := fun he => hex ⟨x,hx,he⟩ omega termination_by w.length decreasing_by simp only [he,List.length_append,List.length_cons]; omega theorem successive_reduced_word_zero (v : ℕ → unitary (Q τ ω)) (D : ℕ → StarSubalgebra ℂ (Q τ ω)) (hv : ∀ i j,i < j → (v i : Q τ ω) ∈ D j) (hep : ∀ j,HaarEndpoints τ ω (D j).toSubalgebra (v j)) (n : ℕ) (w : List (ℕ × Bool)) (hr : FreeGroup.IsReduced w) (hw : w ≠ []) (hn : ∀ x ∈ w,x.1 < n) : quotientTrace τ ω (unitaryWord τ ω v w)=0 := by classical induction n generalizing w with | zero => cases w with | nil => exact (hw rfl).elim | cons x w => have := hn x (by simp); omega | succ n ih => by_cases hex : ∃ x ∈ w,x.1=n · obtain ⟨a,s,b,he,ha⟩ := word_split_first n w hex have halt : ∀ x ∈ a,x.1 < n := by intro x hx have := hn x (by rw [he]; simp [hx]) have := ha x hx omega have hbr : FreeGroup.IsReduced ((n,s)::b) := reduced_append_right (he ▸ hr) have hbn : ∀ x ∈ b,x.1 ≤ n := by intro x hx have := hn x (by rw [he]; simp [hx]) omega obtain ⟨xs,c,hc,hxs,hev⟩ := maximal_word_gaps τ ω v (D n) n (fun i hi => hv i n hi) ih b s hbr hbn rw [he,unitaryWord_append,hev] exact (hep n).signed_gaps τ ω _ (unitaryWord_mem τ ω v (D n) a (fun x hx => hv _ _ (halt x hx))) c hc _ xs hxs · apply ih w hr hw intro x hx have := hn x hx have : x.1 ≠ n := fun he => hex ⟨x,hx,he⟩ omega end /-! The actual free-group representation furnished by successive Haar variables. -/ section open UltrapowerBridge Filter variable {H : Type*} [NormedAddCommGroup H] [InnerProductSpace ℂ H] [CompleteSpace H] variable {N M : VonNeumannAlgebra H} (τ : TracialRepresentation M) (ω : Ultrafilter ℕ) def unitaryRepresentation {A : Type*} (v : A → unitary (Q τ ω)) : FreeGroup A →* unitary (Q τ ω) := FreeGroup.lift v theorem unitaryRepresentation_mk {A : Type*} (v : A → unitary (Q τ ω)) (w : List (A × Bool)) : (unitaryRepresentation τ ω v (FreeGroup.mk w) : Q τ ω)=unitaryWord τ ω v w := by rw [unitaryRepresentation,FreeGroup.lift_mk] induction w with | nil => rfl | cons x w ih => simp only [List.map_cons,List.prod_cons,Submonoid.coe_mul,unitaryWord_cons,ih] cases x.2 <;> rfl theorem successive_freeGroup_trace (v : ℕ → unitary (Q τ ω)) (D : ℕ → StarSubalgebra ℂ (Q τ ω)) (hv : ∀ i j,i < j → (v i : Q τ ω) ∈ D j) (hep : ∀ j,HaarEndpoints τ ω (D j).toSubalgebra (v j)) (g : FreeGroup ℕ) (hg : g ≠ 1) : quotientTrace τ ω (unitaryRepresentation τ ω v g : Q τ ω)=0 := by rw [← FreeGroup.mk_toWord (x := g),unitaryRepresentation_mk] apply successive_reduced_word_zero τ ω v D hv hep (g.toWord.toFinset.sup Prod.fst+1) g.toWord FreeGroup.isReduced_toWord (fun h => hg (FreeGroup.toWord_eq_nil_iff.mp h)) intro x hx have := Finset.le_sup (f := Prod.fst) (List.mem_toFinset.mpr hx) omega /-- Zero nonidentity moments imply faithfulness, since the unit has trace one. -/ theorem unitaryRepresentation_injective {A : Type*} (v : A → unitary (Q τ ω)) (hzero : ∀ g : FreeGroup A,g ≠ 1 → quotientTrace τ ω (unitaryRepresentation τ ω v g : Q τ ω)=0) : Function.Injective (unitaryRepresentation τ ω v) := by apply (injective_iff_map_eq_one (unitaryRepresentation τ ω v)).mpr intro g hg by_contra hne have ht := hzero g hne rw [hg] at ht have : (1 : ℂ)=0 := (quotientTrace_one τ ω).symm.trans ht exact one_ne_zero this theorem unitaryRepresentation_gram {A : Type*} [DecidableEq A] (v : A → unitary (Q τ ω)) (hzero : ∀ g : FreeGroup A,g ≠ 1 → quotientTrace τ ω (unitaryRepresentation τ ω v g : Q τ ω)=0) (g h : FreeGroup A) : quotientTrace τ ω (star (unitaryRepresentation τ ω v g : Q τ ω)* (unitaryRepresentation τ ω v h : Q τ ω))=if g=h then 1 else 0 := by have he : star (unitaryRepresentation τ ω v g : Q τ ω)* (unitaryRepresentation τ ω v h : Q τ ω)= (unitaryRepresentation τ ω v (g⁻¹*h) : Q τ ω) := by exact (congrArg (fun a : unitary (Q τ ω) => (a : Q τ ω)) (((unitaryRepresentation τ ω v).map_mul (g⁻¹) h).trans (congrArg (fun a => a*unitaryRepresentation τ ω v h) ((unitaryRepresentation τ ω v).map_inv g)))).symm apply (congrArg (quotientTrace τ ω) he).trans by_cases hgh : g=h · subst h rw [_root_.inv_mul_cancel,map_one,ite_eq_left rfl] exact quotientTrace_one τ ω · rw [ite_eq_right hgh] exact hzero _ (fun heq => hgh (_root_.inv_mul_eq_one.mp heq)) variable {hNM : N ≤ M} {seed : Set (Q τ ω)} theorem SuccessiveCoordinateHaar.freeGroup_trace (F : SuccessiveCoordinateHaar τ ω hNM seed) (u : unitary (Q τ ω)) (hu : (u : Q τ ω) ∈ seed) (g : FreeGroup ℕ) (hg : g ≠ 1) : quotientTrace τ ω (unitaryRepresentation τ ω (prefixVariable τ ω u (fun k => (F.step k).t)) g : Q τ ω)=0 := successive_freeGroup_trace τ ω _ F.algebra (fun _ _ hij => F.variable_mem τ ω u hu hij) (F.variable_endpoints τ ω u hu) g hg theorem SuccessiveCoordinateHaar.freeGroup_injective (F : SuccessiveCoordinateHaar τ ω hNM seed) (u : unitary (Q τ ω)) (hu : (u : Q τ ω) ∈ seed) : Function.Injective (unitaryRepresentation τ ω (prefixVariable τ ω u (fun k => (F.step k).t))) := unitaryRepresentation_injective τ ω _ (F.freeGroup_trace τ ω u hu) theorem SuccessiveCoordinateHaar.freeGroup_gram (F : SuccessiveCoordinateHaar τ ω hNM seed) (u : unitary (Q τ ω)) (hu : (u : Q τ ω) ∈ seed) (g h : FreeGroup ℕ) : quotientTrace τ ω (star (unitaryRepresentation τ ω (prefixVariable τ ω u (fun k => (F.step k).t)) g : Q τ ω)* (unitaryRepresentation τ ω (prefixVariable τ ω u (fun k => (F.step k).t)) h : Q τ ω))= if g=h then 1 else 0 := unitaryRepresentation_gram τ ω _ (F.freeGroup_trace τ ω u hu) g h end /-! Reduced-word moments for p*y*(star p). Distinct labels have centered ratios; reducedness requires distinct labels precisely at opposite-sign gaps. -/ section open UltrapowerBridge Filter variable {H : Type*} [NormedAddCommGroup H] [InnerProductSpace ℂ H] [CompleteSpace H] variable {M : VonNeumannAlgebra H} (τ : TracialRepresentation M) (ω : Ultrafilter ℕ) variable {A : Type*} def conjugateVariables (p : A → unitary (Q τ ω)) (y : unitary (Q τ ω)) (a : A) : unitary (Q τ ω) := p a*y*star (p a) def conjugateGaps (p : A → unitary (Q τ ω)) (a : A × Bool) : List (A × Bool) → List (Q τ ω × Bool) | [] => [] | b::w => ((↑(star (p a.1)*p b.1) : Q τ ω),!b.2)::conjugateGaps p b w def conjugateEnd (p : A → unitary (Q τ ω)) (a : A × Bool) : List (A × Bool) → Q τ ω | [] => ↑(star (p a.1)) | b::w => conjugateEnd p b w theorem signed_conjugate (p y : unitary (Q τ ω)) (s : Bool) : algebraSignedLetter (↑(p*y*(star p)) : Q τ ω) s= (p : Q τ ω)*algebraSignedLetter (y : Q τ ω) s*↑(star p) := by cases s with | false => rfl | true => change star ((p : Q τ ω)*(y : Q τ ω)*star (p : Q τ ω))= (p : Q τ ω)*star (y : Q τ ω)*star (p : Q τ ω) rw [star_mul,star_mul,star_star,mul_assoc] theorem conjugateWord_formula (p : A → unitary (Q τ ω)) (y : unitary (Q τ ω)) (a : A × Bool) (w : List (A × Bool)) : unitaryWord τ ω (conjugateVariables τ ω p y) (a::w)= (p a.1 : Q τ ω)*betweenWord (y : Q τ ω) (!a.2) (conjugateGaps τ ω p a w) (conjugateEnd τ ω p a w) := by induction w generalizing a with | nil => rw [unitaryWord_cons,unitaryWord_nil,mul_one] change algebraSignedLetter (↑(p a.1*y*star (p a.1)) : Q τ ω) (!a.2)=_ rw [signed_conjugate] exact mul_assoc _ _ _ | cons b w ih => rw [unitaryWord_cons,ih] change algebraSignedLetter (↑(p a.1*y*star (p a.1)) : Q τ ω) (!a.2)*_= _ rw [signed_conjugate] simp only [conjugateGaps,conjugateEnd,betweenWord,Submonoid.coe_mul,mul_assoc] theorem conjugateEnd_mem (p : A → unitary (Q τ ω)) (D : StarSubalgebra ℂ (Q τ ω)) (hp : ∀ a,(p a : Q τ ω) ∈ D) (a : A × Bool) (w : List (A × Bool)) : conjugateEnd τ ω p a w ∈ D := by induction w generalizing a with | nil => exact star_mem (hp a.1) | cons b w ih => exact ih b theorem conjugateGaps_reduced (p : A → unitary (Q τ ω)) (D : StarSubalgebra ℂ (Q τ ω)) (hp : ∀ a,(p a : Q τ ω) ∈ D) (hzero : ∀ a b,a ≠ b → quotientTrace τ ω (↑(star (p a)*p b) : Q τ ω)=0) (a : A × Bool) (w : List (A × Bool)) (hr : FreeGroup.IsReduced (a::w)) : SignedReducedGaps τ ω D.toSubalgebra (!a.2) (conjugateGaps τ ω p a w) := by induction w generalizing a with | nil => trivial | cons b w ih => have ha : star (p a.1 : Q τ ω) ∈ D := star_mem (hp a.1) refine ⟨D.mul_mem ha (hp b.1),?_,ih b (reduced_tail hr)⟩ intro hsign apply hzero intro he exact hsign (congrArg Bool.not ((FreeGroup.isReduced_cons_cons.mp hr).1 he)) theorem conjugate_reduced_word_zero (p : A → unitary (Q τ ω)) (D : StarSubalgebra ℂ (Q τ ω)) (hp : ∀ a,(p a : Q τ ω) ∈ D) (hzero : ∀ a b,a ≠ b → quotientTrace τ ω (↑(star (p a)*p b) : Q τ ω)=0) (y : unitary (Q τ ω)) (hy : HaarEndpoints τ ω D.toSubalgebra y) (w : List (A × Bool)) (hr : FreeGroup.IsReduced w) (hw : w ≠ []) : quotientTrace τ ω (unitaryWord τ ω (conjugateVariables τ ω p y) w)=0 := by cases w with | nil => exact (hw rfl).elim | cons a w => rw [conjugateWord_formula] exact hy.signed_gaps τ ω _ (hp a.1) _ (conjugateEnd_mem τ ω p D hp a w) _ _ (conjugateGaps_reduced τ ω p D hp hzero a w hr) theorem conjugate_freeGroup_trace [DecidableEq A] (p : A → unitary (Q τ ω)) (D : StarSubalgebra ℂ (Q τ ω)) (hp : ∀ a,(p a : Q τ ω) ∈ D) (hzero : ∀ a b,a ≠ b → quotientTrace τ ω (↑(star (p a)*p b) : Q τ ω)=0) (y : unitary (Q τ ω)) (hy : HaarEndpoints τ ω D.toSubalgebra y) (g : FreeGroup A) (hg : g ≠ 1) : quotientTrace τ ω (unitaryRepresentation τ ω (conjugateVariables τ ω p y) g : Q τ ω)=0 := by rw [← FreeGroup.mk_toWord (x := g),unitaryRepresentation_mk] exact conjugate_reduced_word_zero τ ω p D hp hzero y hy g.toWord FreeGroup.isReduced_toWord (fun h => hg (FreeGroup.toWord_eq_nil_iff.mp h)) end /-! Positive and negative conjugate terms in first-order correlation. Same-sign gaps require no centering hypothesis. -/ open UltrapowerBridge Filter variable {H : Type*} [NormedAddCommGroup H] [InnerProductSpace ℂ H] [CompleteSpace H] variable {M : VonNeumannAlgebra H} (τ : TracialRepresentation M) (ω : Ultrafilter ℕ) variable {D : StarSubalgebra ℂ (Q τ ω)} {W : unitary (Q τ ω)} theorem HaarEndpoints.base_correlation (hW : HaarEndpoints τ ω D.toSubalgebra W) (xi : Q τ ω) (hxi : xi ∈ D) : quotientTrace τ ω (star xi*(W : Q τ ω))=0 := by have hstar : star xi ∈ D := star_mem hxi have h := hW.signed_gaps τ ω (star xi) hstar 1 D.one_mem false [] trivial simpa only [betweenWord,algebraSignedLetter,Bool.false_eq_true,ite_false,mul_one] using h theorem HaarEndpoints.positive_conjugate_correlation (hW : HaarEndpoints τ ω D.toSubalgebra W) (xi : Q τ ω) (hxi : xi ∈ D) (p z : unitary (Q τ ω)) (hp : (p : Q τ ω) ∈ D) (hz : (z : Q τ ω) ∈ D) (hcenter : quotientTrace τ ω (star (p : Q τ ω))=0) : quotientTrace τ ω (star xi*(↑(p*(z*star W)*star p) : Q τ ω)*(W : Q τ ω))=0 := by have hstar : star xi ∈ D := star_mem hxi have hpstar : star (p : Q τ ω) ∈ D := star_mem hp have h := hW.signed_gaps τ ω (star xi*(p : Q τ ω)*(z : Q τ ω)) (D.mul_mem (D.mul_mem hstar hp) hz) 1 D.one_mem true [(star (p : Q τ ω),false)] ⟨hpstar,fun _ => hcenter,trivial⟩ change quotientTrace τ ω ((star xi*(p : Q τ ω)*(z : Q τ ω))* (star (W : Q τ ω)*star (p : Q τ ω)*((W : Q τ ω)*1)))=0 at h simpa only [Submonoid.coe_mul,Unitary.coe_star,mul_one,mul_assoc] using h theorem HaarEndpoints.negative_conjugate_correlation (hW : HaarEndpoints τ ω D.toSubalgebra W) (xi : Q τ ω) (hxi : xi ∈ D) (p z : unitary (Q τ ω)) (hp : (p : Q τ ω) ∈ D) (hz : (z : Q τ ω) ∈ D) : quotientTrace τ ω (star xi*star (↑(p*(z*star W)*star p) : Q τ ω)*(W : Q τ ω))=0 := by have hstar : star xi ∈ D := star_mem hxi have hpstar : star (p : Q τ ω) ∈ D := star_mem hp have hzstar : star (z : Q τ ω) ∈ D := star_mem hz have h := hW.signed_gaps τ ω (star xi*(p : Q τ ω)) (D.mul_mem hstar hp) 1 D.one_mem false [(star (z : Q τ ω)*star (p : Q τ ω),false)] ⟨D.mul_mem hzstar hpstar,fun hh => (hh rfl).elim,trivial⟩ change quotientTrace τ ω ((star xi*(p : Q τ ω))* ((W : Q τ ω)*(star (z : Q τ ω)*star (p : Q τ ω))*((W : Q τ ω)*1)))=0 at h simpa only [Submonoid.coe_mul,Unitary.coe_star,star_mul,star_star,mul_one,mul_assoc] using h end Generator.Tracial end end OAI