import OAI.Combinatorics.ContingencyTables.Rooted.ForestAffineCoefficients namespace OAI /-! # The original integral forest solution is the cut-defined affine completion -/ namespace ContingencyTables.ForestAffineCoefficients open scoped BigOperators Classical open CompanionFactorialApplication GraphIntegralCompletion GraphCompletionCounts open ForestCapacity ForestCut ForestPhysicalCompletion MaximumForest variable {I J : Type*} [Fintype I] [Fintype J] lemma selected_nonroot (A : Instance I J) (t : TreeCell A.T) (v : I⊕J) (hv : cutSide A t v=true) : v≠componentRoot A.T v := by intro he let root := componentRoot A.T (.inl t.val.1) have hrootRoot : componentRoot A.T root=root := componentRoot_idempotent A.T (.inl t.val.1) have hreach : (A.T.deleteEdges {edge t.val}).Reachable (cutVertex A t) v := by simpa only [cutSide,side,decide_eq_true_eq] using hv have hcomp := (cut_properties A t).1.trans (hreach.mono (A.T.deleteEdges_le {edge t.val})) have hsame : componentRoot A.T v=root := by rw [← componentRoot_constant A.T hcomp,hrootRoot] have hvr : v=root := he.trans hsame have hbad : cutSide A t root=true := by simpa only [hvr] using hv exact Bool.false_ne_true ((cut_properties A t).2.1.symm.trans hbad) lemma other_tree_sign_zero (A : Instance I J) (t : TreeCell A.T) (a : I×J) (ha : A.T.Adj (.inl a.1) (.inr a.2)) (hne : a≠t.val) : sign A t a=0 := by have hh := side_eq_of_tree_edge A.T (edge t.val) (cutVertex A t) ha (by intro he; exact hne (cell_edge_injective he)) exact sub_eq_zero.mpr (congrArg indicator hh) noncomputable def smallContribution (A : Instance I J) (t : TreeCell A.T) (x q : I → J → ℝ) : ℝ := ∑ a : I×J,if A.small a.1 a.2 then indicator (cutSide A t (.inl a.1))*(x a.1 a.2-A.X a.1 a.2)- indicator (cutSide A t (.inr a.2))*(q a.1 a.2-A.X a.1 a.2) else 0 noncomputable def offset (A : Instance I J) (t : TreeCell A.T) (x q : I → J → ℝ) : ℝ := A.X t.val.1 t.val.2-smallContribution A t x q/sign A t t.val- ∑ a : I×J,coefficient A t a*(A.X a.1 a.2:ℝ) noncomputable def affineTree (A : Instance I J) (t : TreeCell A.T) (x q : I → J → ℝ) (z : I×J → ℝ) : ℝ := AffinePenalty.affineValue (offset A t x q) (coefficient A t) z /-- Isolating the actual selected tree edge in the root-away cut gives its affine value for every real solution of the nonroot equations. -/ theorem affine_of_nonroot_equations (A : Instance I J) (t : TreeCell A.T) (x q z : I → J → ℝ) (hr : ∀ i,Sum.inl i≠componentRoot A.T (.inl i) → rowDifference A.small x z (fun i j => (A.X i j:ℝ)) i=0) (hc : ∀ j,Sum.inr j≠componentRoot A.T (.inr j) → columnDifference A.small q z (fun i j => (A.X i j:ℝ)) j=0) : z t.val.1 t.val.2=affineTree A t x q (fun a => z a.1 a.2) := by let f : I×J → ℝ := fun a => cutTerm A.small (fun i => cutSide A t (.inl i)) (fun j => cutSide A t (.inr j)) x q z (fun i j => (A.X i j:ℝ)) a.1 a.2 have hsum : (∑ a,f a)=0 := by rw [Fintype.sum_prod_type] exact cut_sum_zero A.small _ _ x q z _ (fun i hi => hr i (selected_nonroot A t (.inl i) hi)) (fun j hj => hc j (selected_nonroot A t (.inr j) hj)) have hterm (a : I×J) : f a= (if a=t.val then sign A t t.val*(z a.1 a.2-A.X a.1 a.2) else 0)+ (if A.small a.1 a.2 then indicator (cutSide A t (.inl a.1))*(x a.1 a.2-A.X a.1 a.2)- indicator (cutSide A t (.inr a.2))*(q a.1 a.2-A.X a.1 a.2) else 0)- sign A t t.val*coefficient A t a*(z a.1 a.2-A.X a.1 a.2) := by by_cases he : a=t.val · subst a have hs : A.small t.val.1 t.val.2=false := A.hTG t.property simp only [f,cutTerm,hs,Bool.false_eq_true,ite_false,ite_true,coefficient,t.property, not_true_eq_false,and_false,sign,mul_zero,zero_mul,add_zero,sub_zero] · by_cases hs : A.small a.1 a.2=true · simp [f,cutTerm,hs,he,coefficient] · have hs' : A.small a.1 a.2=false := Bool.eq_false_iff.mpr hs by_cases ht : A.T.Adj (.inl a.1) (.inr a.2) · have hz := other_tree_sign_zero A t a ht he simp only [f,cutTerm,hs',Bool.false_eq_true,ite_false,he,coefficient,ht, not_true_eq_false,and_false,zero_add,mul_zero,zero_mul,sub_zero] change sign A t a*(z a.1 a.2-(A.X a.1 a.2:ℝ))=0 rw [hz,zero_mul] · simp only [f,cutTerm,hs',Bool.false_eq_true,ite_false,he,coefficient,ht, not_false_eq_true,and_self,ite_true,zero_add,zero_sub] change sign A t a*(z a.1 a.2-(A.X a.1 a.2:ℝ))= -(sign A t t.val*(-sign A t a/sign A t t.val)*(z a.1 a.2-A.X a.1 a.2)) field_simp [sign_self_ne_zero A t] simp_rw [hterm] at hsum rw [Finset.sum_sub_distrib,Finset.sum_add_distrib] at hsum have hsingle : (∑ a : I×J,if a=t.val then sign A t t.val*(z a.1 a.2-A.X a.1 a.2) else 0)= sign A t t.val*(z t.val.1 t.val.2-A.X t.val.1 t.val.2) := by simp rw [hsingle] at hsum change sign A t t.val*(z t.val.1 t.val.2-A.X t.val.1 t.val.2)+smallContribution A t x q- (∑ a : I×J,sign A t t.val*coefficient A t a*(z a.1 a.2-A.X a.1 a.2))=0 at hsum have hprod : (∑ a : I×J,sign A t t.val*coefficient A t a*(z a.1 a.2-A.X a.1 a.2))= sign A t t.val*((∑ a : I×J,coefficient A t a*z a.1 a.2)- ∑ a : I×J,coefficient A t a*(A.X a.1 a.2:ℝ)) := by rw [mul_sub,Finset.mul_sum,Finset.mul_sum,← Finset.sum_sub_distrib] apply Finset.sum_congr rfl intro a _ ring rw [hprod] at hsum unfold affineTree AffinePenalty.affineValue offset apply (mul_left_cancel₀ (sign_self_ne_zero A t)) rw [mul_add,mul_sub,mul_sub,← mul_div_assoc,mul_div_cancel_left₀ _ (sign_self_ne_zero A t)] nlinarith [hsum] /-- In particular this affine display is the original integral solution used inside h_j, rather than an unrelated continuous extension. -/ theorem solved_eq_affine (A : Instance I J) (t : TreeCell A.T) (x q free : I → J → ℤ) : (solved A.small A.T A.r A.c x q free t.val.1 t.val.2:ℝ)= affineTree A t (fun i j => (x i j:ℝ)) (fun i j => (q i j:ℝ)) (fun a => (free a.1 a.2:ℝ)) := by let z : I → J → ℝ := fun i j => (completed A.small A.T A.r A.c x q free i j:ℝ) have hh := affine_of_nonroot_equations A t (fun i j => (x i j:ℝ)) (fun i j => (q i j:ℝ)) z (by intro i hi have hr := row_completed_sum A.small A.T A.hTG A.r A.c x q free i hi have hX := A.hXr i unfold rowDifference have he : (∑ j,if A.small i j then (x i j:ℝ) else z i j)=(A.r i:ℝ) := by dsimp only [z] exact_mod_cast hr have hX' : (∑ j,(A.X i j:ℝ))=(A.r i:ℝ) := by exact_mod_cast hX calc _=(∑ j,if A.small i j then (x i j:ℝ) else z i j)-(∑ j,(A.X i j:ℝ)) := by rw [← Finset.sum_sub_distrib] apply Finset.sum_congr rfl intro j _ split_ifs <;> rfl _=0 := by rw [he,hX',sub_self]) (by intro j hj have hc := column_completed_sum A.small A.T A.hTG A.r A.c x q free j hj have hX := A.hXc j unfold columnDifference have he : (∑ i,if A.small i j then (q i j:ℝ) else z i j)=(A.c j:ℝ) := by dsimp only [z] exact_mod_cast hc have hX' : (∑ i,(A.X i j:ℝ))=(A.c j:ℝ) := by exact_mod_cast hX calc _=(∑ i,if A.small i j then (q i j:ℝ) else z i j)-(∑ i,(A.X i j:ℝ)) := by rw [← Finset.sum_sub_distrib] apply Finset.sum_congr rfl intro i _ split_ifs <;> rfl _=0 := by rw [he,hX',sub_self]) have hz : z t.val.1 t.val.2=(solved A.small A.T A.r A.c x q free t.val.1 t.val.2:ℝ) := by simp only [z,completed,t.property,ite_true] rw [hz] at hh rw [hh] unfold affineTree AffinePenalty.affineValue congr 1 apply Finset.sum_congr rfl intro a _ by_cases ht : A.T.Adj (.inl a.1) (.inr a.2) · simp only [coefficient,ht,not_true_eq_false,and_false,ite_false,zero_mul] · simp only [z,completed,ht,ite_false] end ContingencyTables.ForestAffineCoefficients end OAI