import Mathlib import OAI.Computability.MaxCut.Games.UpperMobius namespace OAI noncomputable section namespace MaxCutGames.Appendix.A1Reduction open scoped BigOperators open MaxCutGames.Integration.BinaryLinear (F2) open MaxCutGames.Fourier.MatrixFourier MaxCutGames.Fourier.MatrixProducts open MaxCutGames.Appendix.Derivatives attribute [local instance] Classical.propDecidable variable {E F : Type*} [AddCommGroup E] [Module F2 E] [AddCommGroup F] [Module F2 F] [FiniteDimensional F2 E] [FiniteDimensional F2 F] [Finite E] [Finite F] [Fintype (E →ₗ[F2] F)] [Fintype (F →ₗ[F2] E)] [Fintype (Submodule F2 E)] [Fintype (Submodule F2 F)] def weakFourthSum (d : ℕ) (f : (E →ₗ[F2] F) → ℝ) : ℝ := ∑ p : Submodule F2 E × Submodule F2 F, if p ≠ (⊥, ⊤) then (2:ℝ)^(7*d*(Module.finrank F2 p.1 + Module.finrank F2 (F ⧸ p.2))) * (𝔼 M, spectralProjector (fun Y => p.1 ≤ Y.range ∧ Y.ker ≤ p.2) f M^4) else 0 omit [FiniteDimensional F2 E] [FiniteDimensional F2 F] [Finite E] [Finite F] in theorem weakFourthSum_nonneg (d : ℕ) (f : (E →ₗ[F2] F) → ℝ) : 0 ≤ weakFourthSum d f := by apply Finset.sum_nonneg intro p _ split · exact mul_nonneg (by positivity) (Finset.expect_nonneg (fun _ _ => by positivity)) · exact le_rfl omit [Finite E] [Finite F] [Fintype (Submodule F2 E)] [Fintype (Submodule F2 F)] in theorem linearCoeff_weakProjector (A : Submodule F2 E) (B : Submodule F2 F) (f : (E →ₗ[F2] F) → ℝ) (Y : F →ₗ[F2] E) : linearCoeff (spectralProjector (fun Z => A ≤ Z.range ∧ Z.ker ≤ B) f) Y = BadConvolution.filteredCoefficient A B (linearCoeff f) Y := by simp only [linearCoeff_spectralProjector, BadConvolution.filteredCoefficient, BadConvolution.Incidence] rfl omit [Finite E] [Finite F] [Fintype (Submodule F2 E)] [Fintype (Submodule F2 F)] in /-- Actual Parseval/product identity for each signed weakly selected piece. -/ theorem piece_fourth_moment (A : Submodule F2 E) (B : Submodule F2 F) (f : (E →ₗ[F2] F) → ℝ) : (∑ X : F →ₗ[F2] E, BadConvolution.pieceConvolution A B (linearCoeff f) X^2) = 𝔼 M, spectralProjector (fun Y => A ≤ Y.range ∧ Y.ker ≤ B) f M^4 := by rw [expect_fourth_eq_sum_convolution_sq] simp only [coefficientConvolution, BadConvolution.pieceConvolution, linearCoeff_weakProjector] omit [Finite E] [Finite F] [FiniteDimensional F2 F] [Fintype (E →ₗ[F2] F)] [Fintype (F →ₗ[F2] E)] [Fintype (Submodule F2 E)] [Fintype (Submodule F2 F)] in theorem actual_bad_cover (X Y : F →ₗ[F2] E) (hbad : ¬ BadConvolution.Bad X Y) : F1Energy.Good X Y := by apply F1Energy.good_of_trivial_intersections X Y · by_contra hi exact hbad (Or.inl hi) · by_contra hk exact hbad (Or.inr hk) omit [Finite E] [Finite F] [FiniteDimensional F2 E] [Fintype (E →ₗ[F2] F)] [Fintype (Submodule F2 E)] [Fintype (Submodule F2 F)] in theorem badConvolution_zero_of_degree_zero (a : (F →ₗ[F2] E) → ℝ) (ha : ∀ Y, 0 < Module.finrank F2 Y.range → a Y = 0) (X : F →ₗ[F2] E) : BadConvolution.badConvolution a X = 0 := by classical unfold BadConvolution.badConvolution apply Finset.sum_eq_zero intro Y _ by_cases hY : Y = 0 · subst Y by_cases hX : X = 0 · subst X simp [BadConvolution.Bad] · have hz := ha X (DegreeZero.rank_pos_of_ne_zero X hX) simp [hz] · have hz := ha Y (DegreeZero.rank_pos_of_ne_zero Y hY) simp [hz] theorem badConvolution_energy_le_weakFourthSum (f : (E →ₗ[F2] F) → ℝ) (d : ℕ) (hdegree : ∀ Y : F →ₗ[F2] E, d < Module.finrank F2 Y.range → linearCoeff f Y = 0) : (∑ X : F →ₗ[F2] E, BadConvolution.badConvolution (linearCoeff f) X^2) ≤ weakFourthSum d f := by by_cases hd : d = 0 · subst d have hz : ∀ X, BadConvolution.badConvolution (linearCoeff f) X = 0 := badConvolution_zero_of_degree_zero (linearCoeff f) hdegree simpa only [hz, zero_pow, ne_eq, OfNat.ofNat_ne_zero, not_false_eq_true, Finset.sum_const_zero] using weakFourthSum_nonneg 0 f · have h := BadConvolution.badConvolution_sq_sum_le (linearCoeff f) d (by omega) hdegree simpa only [weakFourthSum, piece_fourth_moment] using h theorem fourth_moment_le_two (f : (E →ₗ[F2] F) → ℝ) (d : ℕ) (hdegree : ∀ Y : F →ₗ[F2] E, d < Module.finrank F2 Y.range → linearCoeff f Y = 0) : (𝔼 M, f M^4) ≤ 2 * ((2:ℝ)^(6*d^2) * (𝔼 M, f M^2)^2) + 2 * weakFourthSum d f := by have hcore : (𝔼 M, f M^4) ≤ 2 * ((2:ℝ)^(6*d^2) * (𝔼 M, f M^2)^2) + 2 * ∑ X : F →ₗ[F2] E, BadConvolution.badConvolution (linearCoeff f) X^2 := by simpa only [BadConvolution.badConvolution] using F1Energy.fourth_moment_le_good_bad f d hdegree BadConvolution.Bad actual_bad_cover exact hcore.trans (add_le_add le_rfl (mul_le_mul_of_nonneg_left (badConvolution_energy_le_weakFourthSum f d hdegree) (show (0:ℝ) ≤ 2 by norm_num))) /-- Lemma A.1, Equation (A.6), for every degree d including zero. -/ theorem degree_reduction (f : (E →ₗ[F2] F) → ℝ) (d : ℕ) (hdegree : ∀ Y : F →ₗ[F2] E, d < Module.finrank F2 Y.range → linearCoeff f Y = 0) : (𝔼 M, f M^4) / 162 ≤ (2:ℝ)^(6*d^2) * (𝔼 M, f M^2)^2 + weakFourthSum d f := by have h := fourth_moment_le_two f d hdegree have ha : 0 ≤ (2:ℝ)^(6*d^2) * (𝔼 M, f M^2)^2 := by positivity have hb := weakFourthSum_nonneg d f apply (div_le_iff₀ (show (0:ℝ) < 162 by norm_num)).mpr nlinarith end MaxCutGames.Appendix.A1Reduction open scoped BigOperators open MaxCutGames.Integration.BinaryLinear (F2) open MaxCutGames.Fourier open MaxCutGames.Appendix.Derivatives open MaxCutGames.Appendix.OperatorPartitions open MaxCutGames.Appendix.LinearIdentities namespace MaxCutGames.Appendix.A13Reduction attribute [local instance] Classical.propDecidable /-- The exponent comparison after retaining the total degree loss. -/ theorem exponent_le (d i j t : ℕ) (hi : i ≤ t) (hj : j ≤ t) (ht : t ≤ d) : 7 * d * (i + j) + 3 * i * j ≤ 24 * d * t := by have hs : i + j ≤ 2 * t := by omega have hp : i * j ≤ d * t := (Nat.mul_le_mul hi hj).trans (Nat.mul_le_mul_right t ht) have hfirst := Nat.mul_le_mul_left (7 * d) hs have hsecond := Nat.mul_le_mul_left 3 hp have hdt : 0 ≤ d * t := Nat.zero_le _ nlinarith /-- Degree-forced zero moments allow the same weight bound on every raw triple. -/ theorem weighted_moment_le (d i j t : ℕ) (e : ℝ) (hi : i ≤ t) (hj : j ≤ t) (he : 0 ≤ e) (hz : d < t → e = 0) : (2 : ℝ) ^ (7 * d * (i + j) + 3 * i * j) * e ≤ (2 : ℝ) ^ (24 * d * t) * e := by by_cases ht : t ≤ d · have hn := Nat.pow_le_pow_right (n := 2) (by decide : 0 < 2) (exponent_le d i j t hi hj ht) have hr : (2 : ℝ) ^ (7 * d * (i + j) + 3 * i * j) ≤ (2 : ℝ) ^ (24 * d * t) := by exact_mod_cast hn exact mul_le_mul_of_nonneg_right hr he · rw [hz (Nat.lt_of_not_ge ht)] simp variable {E F : Type*} [AddCommGroup E] [Module F2 E] [AddCommGroup F] [Module F2 F] [FiniteDimensional F2 E] [FiniteDimensional F2 F] [Fintype (E →ₗ[F2] F)] [Fintype (F →ₗ[F2] E)] [Finite E] [Finite F] attribute [local instance] OperatorNorm.quotientFinite OperatorNorm.compressedDualFintype /-- The actual averaged fourth moment attached to a raw derivative triple. -/ def tripleMoment (p : A4Index (K := F2) (W := F) (V := E)) (f : (E →ₗ[F2] F) → ℝ) : ℝ := 𝔼 T, 𝔼 N, mapDerivative p.2.2 (hybridDerivative p.1 p.2.1 T f) N ^ 4 omit [FiniteDimensional F2 E] [FiniteDimensional F2 F] in theorem tripleMoment_nonneg (p : A4Index (K := F2) (W := F) (V := E)) (f : (E →ₗ[F2] F) → ℝ) : 0 ≤ tripleMoment p f := by apply Finset.expect_nonneg intro T _ apply Finset.expect_nonneg intro N _ positivity /-- A.4's native fourth-moment bound with its proved binary index count. -/ theorem weak_fourth_le_counted (A : Submodule F2 E) (B : Submodule F2 F) [Fintype (A4GeometricIndex A B)] (f : (E →ₗ[F2] F) → ℝ) : (𝔼 M, spectralProjector (fun Y => A ≤ Y.range ∧ Y.ker ≤ B) f M ^ 4) ≤ (2 : ℝ) ^ (3 * Module.finrank F2 A * Module.finrank F2 (F ⧸ B)) * ∑ p : A4GeometricIndex A B, tripleMoment p.val f := by have hnat := Nat.pow_le_pow_left (A4IndexCount.card_index_le A B) 3 rw [Nat.card_eq_fintype_card, ← pow_mul] at hnat have he : (Module.finrank F2 A * Module.finrank F2 (F ⧸ B)) * 3 = 3 * Module.finrank F2 A * Module.finrank F2 (F ⧸ B) := by ring rw [he] at hnat have hc : (Fintype.card (A4GeometricIndex A B) : ℝ) ^ 3 ≤ (2 : ℝ) ^ (3 * Module.finrank F2 A * Module.finrank F2 (F ⧸ B)) := by exact_mod_cast hnat have hn : 0 ≤ ∑ p : A4GeometricIndex A B, tripleMoment p.val f := Finset.sum_nonneg fun p _ => tripleMoment_nonneg p.val f exact (OperatorNorm.a4_fourth_average_le A B f).trans (mul_le_mul_of_nonneg_right hc hn) /-- Expand one original weak-pair term, retaining its original dimensions. -/ theorem weighted_weak_fourth_le_counted (d : ℕ) (A : Submodule F2 E) (B : Submodule F2 F) [Fintype (A4GeometricIndex A B)] (f : (E →ₗ[F2] F) → ℝ) : (2 : ℝ) ^ (7 * d * (Module.finrank F2 A + Module.finrank F2 (F ⧸ B))) * (𝔼 M, spectralProjector (fun Y => A ≤ Y.range ∧ Y.ker ≤ B) f M ^ 4) ≤ ∑ p : A4GeometricIndex A B, (2 : ℝ) ^ (7 * d * (Module.finrank F2 A + Module.finrank F2 (F ⧸ B)) + 3 * Module.finrank F2 A * Module.finrank F2 (F ⧸ B)) * tripleMoment p.val f := by calc _ ≤ (2 : ℝ) ^ (7 * d * (Module.finrank F2 A + Module.finrank F2 (F ⧸ B))) * ((2 : ℝ) ^ (3 * Module.finrank F2 A * Module.finrank F2 (F ⧸ B)) * ∑ p : A4GeometricIndex A B, tripleMoment p.val f) := mul_le_mul_of_nonneg_left (weak_fourth_le_counted A B f) (by positivity) _ = _ := by simp only [pow_add, Finset.mul_sum, mul_assoc] theorem tripleMoment_eq_zero_of_lt_size {d : ℕ} (p : A13Index.Triple (E := E) (F := F)) (f : (E →ₗ[F2] F) → ℝ) (hf : DerivativeDegree.DegreeAtMost d f) (h : d < A13Index.size p) : tripleMoment p f = 0 := DerivativeDegree.map_hybridDerivative_fourth_average_eq_zero_of_lt_order_rank p.1 p.2.1 p.2.2 f hf h /-- The weight after relabeling the actual raw derivative triple. -/ def tripleTerm (d : ℕ) (p : A13Index.Triple (E := E) (F := F)) (f : (E →ₗ[F2] F) → ℝ) : ℝ := (2 : ℝ) ^ (24 * d * A13Index.size p) * tripleMoment p f omit [FiniteDimensional F2 E] [FiniteDimensional F2 F] in theorem tripleTerm_nonneg (d : ℕ) (p : A13Index.Triple (E := E) (F := F)) (f : (E →ₗ[F2] F) → ℝ) : 0 ≤ tripleTerm d p f := mul_nonneg (by positivity) (tripleMoment_nonneg p f) theorem tripleTerm_eq_zero_of_lt_size {d : ℕ} (p : A13Index.Triple (E := E) (F := F)) (f : (E →ₗ[F2] F) → ℝ) (hf : DerivativeDegree.DegreeAtMost d f) (h : d < A13Index.size p) : tripleTerm d p f = 0 := by unfold tripleTerm rw [tripleMoment_eq_zero_of_lt_size p f hf h, mul_zero] theorem weighted_geometric_moment_le {d : ℕ} (A : Submodule F2 E) (B : Submodule F2 F) (p : A4GeometricIndex A B) (f : (E →ₗ[F2] F) → ℝ) (hf : DerivativeDegree.DegreeAtMost d f) : (2 : ℝ) ^ (7 * d * (Module.finrank F2 A + Module.finrank F2 (F ⧸ B)) + 3 * Module.finrank F2 A * Module.finrank F2 (F ⧸ B)) * tripleMoment p.val f ≤ tripleTerm d p.val f := by have hi : Module.finrank F2 A ≤ A13Index.size p.val := by have h := A13Index.dim_weakA p unfold A13Index.size MatrixRestrictions.order omega have hj : Module.finrank F2 (F ⧸ B) ≤ A13Index.size p.val := by have h := A13Index.codim_weakB p unfold A13Index.size MatrixRestrictions.order omega exact weighted_moment_le d _ _ _ _ hi hj (tripleMoment_nonneg p.val f) (fun h => tripleMoment_eq_zero_of_lt_size p.val f hf h) variable [Fintype (Submodule F2 E)] [Fintype (Submodule F2 F)] /-- The displayed A.13 sum: its original positive total order is retained. -/ def positiveTripleSum (d : ℕ) (f : (E →ₗ[F2] F) → ℝ) : ℝ := ∑ p : A13Index.PositiveTriple (E := E) (F := F), tripleTerm d p.val f /-- The same sum after the genuine degree-support cutoff. -/ def boundedPositiveTripleSum (d : ℕ) (f : (E →ₗ[F2] F) → ℝ) : ℝ := ∑ p : A13Index.BoundedPositiveTriple (E := E) (F := F) d, tripleTerm d p.val f /-- Apply A.4 and its count, then forget the uniquely reconstructible weak pair. The old nonzero condition is carried by `positiveMap`; no descendant condition is substituted for it. -/ theorem weakFourthSum_le_positiveTripleSum (f : (E →ₗ[F2] F) → ℝ) (d : ℕ) (hf : DerivativeDegree.DegreeAtMost d f) : A1Reduction.weakFourthSum d f ≤ positiveTripleSum d f := by classical have heq : A1Reduction.weakFourthSum d f = ∑ p : A13Index.WeakPositive (E := E) (F := F), (2 : ℝ) ^ (7 * d * (Module.finrank F2 p.val.1 + Module.finrank F2 (F ⧸ p.val.2))) * (𝔼 M, spectralProjector (fun Y => p.val.1 ≤ Y.range ∧ Y.ker ≤ p.val.2) f M ^ 4) := by symm exact F1Gram.sum_subtype_eq (fun p : Submodule F2 E × Submodule F2 F => p ≠ (⊥, ⊤)) (fun p => (2 : ℝ) ^ (7 * d * (Module.finrank F2 p.1 + Module.finrank F2 (F ⧸ p.2))) * (𝔼 M, spectralProjector (fun Y => p.1 ≤ Y.range ∧ Y.ker ≤ p.2) f M ^ 4)) rw [heq] calc _ ≤ ∑ p : A13Index.WeakPositive (E := E) (F := F), ∑ q : A4GeometricIndex p.val.1 p.val.2, tripleTerm d q.val f := by apply Finset.sum_le_sum intro p _ exact (weighted_weak_fourth_le_counted d p.val.1 p.val.2 f).trans (Finset.sum_le_sum fun q _ => weighted_geometric_moment_le p.val.1 p.val.2 q f hf) _ = ∑ w : A13Index.PositiveWitness (E := E) (F := F), tripleTerm d w.2.val f := by simp only [Fintype.sum_sigma] _ ≤ positiveTripleSum d f := F1Gram.sum_comp_le A13Index.positiveMap A13Index.positiveMap_injective (fun q : A13Index.PositiveTriple (E := E) (F := F) => tripleTerm d q.val f) (fun q => tripleTerm_nonneg d q.val f) theorem positiveTripleSum_eq_bounded (f : (E →ₗ[F2] F) → ℝ) (d : ℕ) (hf : DerivativeDegree.DegreeAtMost d f) : positiveTripleSum d f = boundedPositiveTripleSum d f := by classical unfold positiveTripleSum boundedPositiveTripleSum rw [F1Gram.sum_subtype_eq (fun p : A13Index.Triple (E := E) (F := F) => 0 < A13Index.size p) (fun p => tripleTerm d p f), F1Gram.sum_subtype_eq (fun p : A13Index.Triple (E := E) (F := F) => 0 < A13Index.size p ∧ A13Index.size p ≤ d) (fun p => tripleTerm d p f)] apply Finset.sum_congr rfl intro p _ by_cases hp : 0 < A13Index.size p · by_cases ht : A13Index.size p ≤ d · rw [ite_eq_left hp, ite_eq_left ⟨hp, ht⟩] · rw [ite_eq_left hp, ite_eq_right (fun h => ht h.2)] exact tripleTerm_eq_zero_of_lt_size p f hf (Nat.lt_of_not_ge ht) · rw [ite_eq_right hp, ite_eq_right (fun h => hp h.1)] /-- Equation A.13 with the literal positive-triple sum. -/ theorem degree_reduction (f : (E →ₗ[F2] F) → ℝ) (d : ℕ) (hf : DerivativeDegree.DegreeAtMost d f) : (𝔼 M, f M ^ 4) / 162 ≤ (2 : ℝ) ^ (6 * d ^ 2) * (𝔼 M, f M ^ 2) ^ 2 + positiveTripleSum d f := by have hbase := A1Reduction.degree_reduction f d (fun Y hY => hf Y hY) exact hbase.trans (add_le_add le_rfl (weakFourthSum_le_positiveTripleSum f d hf)) /-- Equation A.13 after removing terms whose actual derivative is zero. -/ theorem degree_reduction_truncated (f : (E →ₗ[F2] F) → ℝ) (d : ℕ) (hf : DerivativeDegree.DegreeAtMost d f) : (𝔼 M, f M ^ 4) / 162 ≤ (2 : ℝ) ^ (6 * d ^ 2) * (𝔼 M, f M ^ 2) ^ 2 + boundedPositiveTripleSum d f := by simpa only [positiveTripleSum_eq_bounded f d hf] using degree_reduction f d hf end MaxCutGames.Appendix.A13Reduction end namespace MaxCutGames.Appendix.DerivativeInduction open MaxCutGames.Integration.BinaryLinear open LinearMap variable {B U A C : Type*} variable [AddCommGroup B] [Module F2 B] [AddCommGroup U] [Module F2 U] variable [AddCommGroup A] [Module F2 A] [AddCommGroup C] [Module F2 C] /-- The actual complement conditions after choosing domain/codomain splittings. -/ def IsAntecedent (Z : B →ₗ[F2] C) (X : (B × U) →ₗ[F2] (A × C)) : Prop := (∀ b, (X (b, 0)).2 = Z b) ∧ Disjoint X.range (LinearMap.inl F2 A C).range ∧ (LinearMap.inl F2 B U).range ⊔ X.ker = ⊤ abbrev Antecedent (Z : B →ₗ[F2] C) := { X : (B × U) →ₗ[F2] (A × C) // IsAntecedent Z X } theorem antecedent_image_from_left (Z : B →ₗ[F2] C) (X : (B × U) →ₗ[F2] (A × C)) (hX : IsAntecedent Z X) (p : B × U) : ∃ b : B, X p = X (b, 0) := by have hp : p ∈ (LinearMap.inl F2 B U).range ⊔ X.ker := by rw [hX.2.2] trivial obtain ⟨q, hq, r, hr, he⟩ := Submodule.mem_sup.mp hp obtain ⟨b, rfl⟩ := hq refine ⟨b, ?_⟩ rw [← he, map_add] have hz : X r = 0 := hr simp only [hz, add_zero, LinearMap.inl_apply] theorem antecedent_bottom_mem_range (Z : B →ₗ[F2] C) (X : (B × U) →ₗ[F2] (A × C)) (hX : IsAntecedent Z X) (p : B × U) : (X p).2 ∈ Z.range := by obtain ⟨b, hb⟩ := antecedent_image_from_left Z X hX p exact ⟨b, (hX.1 b).symm.trans (congrArg Prod.snd hb).symm⟩ theorem antecedent_vertical_zero (Z : B →ₗ[F2] C) (X : (B × U) →ₗ[F2] (A × C)) (hX : IsAntecedent Z X) (p : B × U) (hp : (X p).2 = 0) : X p = 0 := by apply Submodule.disjoint_def.mp hX.2.1 (X p) (LinearMap.mem_range_self X p) exact ⟨(X p).1, Prod.ext rfl hp.symm⟩ private theorem antecedent_kernel_le_inline_DerivativeInduction (Z : B →ₗ[F2] C) (X : (B × U) →ₗ[F2] (A × C)) (hX : IsAntecedent Z X) : Z.ker ≤ ((LinearMap.fst F2 A C).comp (X.comp (LinearMap.inl F2 B U))).ker := by intro b hb have hz : Z b = 0 := hb have hx := antecedent_vertical_zero Z X hX (b, 0) ((hX.1 b).trans hz) exact congrArg Prod.fst hx /-- The graph map from the fixed compressed image into the removed summand. -/ noncomputable def graphParameter (Z : B →ₗ[F2] C) (X : Antecedent (U := U) (A := A) Z) : Z.range →ₗ[F2] A := (Z.ker.liftQ ((LinearMap.fst F2 A C).comp (X.val.comp (LinearMap.inl F2 B U))) (antecedent_kernel_le_inline_DerivativeInduction Z X.val X.property)).comp Z.quotKerEquivRange.symm.toLinearMap theorem graphParameter_apply (Z : B →ₗ[F2] C) (X : Antecedent (U := U) (A := A) Z) (b : B) : graphParameter Z X (Z.rangeRestrict b) = (X.val (b, 0)).1 := by rw [show Z.rangeRestrict b = ⟨Z b, LinearMap.mem_range_self Z b⟩ from rfl] simp [graphParameter, LinearMap.quotKerEquivRange_symm_apply_image] /-- Values on the omitted domain complement, compressed into `range Z`. -/ noncomputable def complementParameter (Z : B →ₗ[F2] C) (X : Antecedent (U := U) (A := A) Z) : U →ₗ[F2] Z.range := ((LinearMap.snd F2 A C).comp (X.val.comp (LinearMap.inr F2 B U))).codRestrict Z.range (fun u => antecedent_bottom_mem_range Z X.val X.property (0, u)) @[simp] theorem complementParameter_val (Z : B →ₗ[F2] C) (X : Antecedent (U := U) (A := A) Z) (u : U) : (complementParameter Z X u : C) = (X.val (0, u)).2 := rfl /-- The block matrix `[F Z, F H; Z, H]`. -/ def lift (Z : B →ₗ[F2] C) (F : Z.range →ₗ[F2] A) (H : U →ₗ[F2] Z.range) : (B × U) →ₗ[F2] (A × C) := (F.comp (Z.rangeRestrict.coprod H)).prod (Z.range.subtype.comp (Z.rangeRestrict.coprod H)) @[simp] theorem lift_apply (Z : B →ₗ[F2] C) (F : Z.range →ₗ[F2] A) (H : U →ₗ[F2] Z.range) (p : B × U) : lift Z F H p = (F (Z.rangeRestrict p.1 + H p.2), ((Z.rangeRestrict p.1 + H p.2 : Z.range) : C)) := rfl theorem lift_isAntecedent (Z : B →ₗ[F2] C) (F : Z.range →ₗ[F2] A) (H : U →ₗ[F2] Z.range) : IsAntecedent Z (lift Z F H) := by refine ⟨?_, ?_, ?_⟩ · intro b simp · apply Submodule.disjoint_def.mpr intro v hv hw obtain ⟨p, rfl⟩ := hv obtain ⟨a, ha⟩ := hw have hz : Z.rangeRestrict p.1 + H p.2 = 0 := by apply Subtype.ext exact (congrArg Prod.snd ha).symm simp [hz] · apply top_unique intro p _ obtain ⟨b, hb⟩ := Z.surjective_rangeRestrict (Z.rangeRestrict p.1 + H p.2) have he : lift Z F H p = lift Z F H (b, 0) := by simp [hb] apply Submodule.mem_sup.mpr refine ⟨(b, 0), ⟨b, rfl⟩, p - (b, 0), ?_, ?_⟩ · change lift Z F H (p - (b, 0)) = 0 rw [map_sub, he, sub_self] · simpa only [← add_sub_assoc] using add_sub_cancel_left (b, 0) p def intoAntecedent (Z : B →ₗ[F2] C) (p : (Z.range →ₗ[F2] A) × (U →ₗ[F2] Z.range)) : Antecedent (U := U) (A := A) Z := ⟨lift Z p.1 p.2, lift_isAntecedent Z p.1 p.2⟩ theorem graphParameter_lift (Z : B →ₗ[F2] C) (F : Z.range →ₗ[F2] A) (H : U →ₗ[F2] Z.range) : graphParameter Z (intoAntecedent Z (F, H)) = F := by ext c obtain ⟨b, rfl⟩ := Z.surjective_rangeRestrict c rw [graphParameter_apply] simp [intoAntecedent] theorem complementParameter_lift (Z : B →ₗ[F2] C) (F : Z.range →ₗ[F2] A) (H : U →ₗ[F2] Z.range) : complementParameter Z (intoAntecedent Z (F, H)) = H := by ext u simp [intoAntecedent] theorem lift_parameters (Z : B →ₗ[F2] C) (X : Antecedent (U := U) (A := A) Z) : lift Z (graphParameter Z X) (complementParameter Z X) = X.val := by apply LinearMap.ext intro p have hb : (Z.rangeRestrict p.1 + complementParameter Z X p.2 : C) = (X.val p).2 := by have hp : p = (p.1, 0) + (0, p.2) := by simp conv_rhs => rw [hp, map_add] simp [X.property.1] obtain ⟨b, he⟩ := antecedent_image_from_left Z X.val X.property p have hr : Z.rangeRestrict p.1 + complementParameter Z X p.2 = Z.rangeRestrict b := by apply Subtype.ext exact hb.trans ((congrArg Prod.snd he).trans (X.property.1 b)) apply Prod.ext · change graphParameter Z X (Z.rangeRestrict p.1 + complementParameter Z X p.2) = _ rw [hr, graphParameter_apply] exact (congrArg Prod.fst he).symm · exact hb /-- Exact antecedent bijection; neither direction assumes the desired count. -/ noncomputable def antecedentEquiv (Z : B →ₗ[F2] C) : Antecedent (U := U) (A := A) Z ≃ (Z.range →ₗ[F2] A) × (U →ₗ[F2] Z.range) where toFun X := (graphParameter Z X, complementParameter Z X) invFun := intoAntecedent Z left_inv X := Subtype.ext (lift_parameters Z X) right_inv p := Prod.ext (graphParameter_lift Z p.1 p.2) (complementParameter_lift Z p.1 p.2) /-- The graph of the reconstruction parameter as an injective linear map. -/ def graphEmbedding (Z : B →ₗ[F2] C) (F : Z.range →ₗ[F2] A) : Z.range →ₗ[F2] (A × C) := F.prod Z.range.subtype theorem graphEmbedding_injective (Z : B →ₗ[F2] C) (F : Z.range →ₗ[F2] A) : Function.Injective (graphEmbedding Z F) := by intro c d h exact Subtype.ext (congrArg Prod.snd h) theorem range_lift (Z : B →ₗ[F2] C) (F : Z.range →ₗ[F2] A) (H : U →ₗ[F2] Z.range) : (lift Z F H).range = (graphEmbedding Z F).range := by ext v constructor · rintro ⟨p, rfl⟩ exact ⟨Z.rangeRestrict p.1 + H p.2, rfl⟩ · rintro ⟨c, rfl⟩ obtain ⟨b, hb⟩ := Z.surjective_rangeRestrict c refine ⟨(b, 0), ?_⟩ simp [graphEmbedding, hb] /-- The reconstructed map has exactly the rank of the fixed compression. -/ theorem finrank_range_lift (Z : B →ₗ[F2] C) (F : Z.range →ₗ[F2] A) (H : U →ₗ[F2] Z.range) : Module.finrank F2 (lift Z F H).range = Module.finrank F2 Z.range := by rw [range_lift] exact LinearMap.finrank_range_of_inj (graphEmbedding_injective Z F) /-- The map rank is preserved for every antecedent, without a rank hypothesis. -/ theorem finrank_range_antecedent (Z : B →ₗ[F2] C) (X : Antecedent (U := U) (A := A) Z) : Module.finrank F2 X.val.range = Module.finrank F2 Z.range := by rw [← lift_parameters Z X] exact finrank_range_lift Z (graphParameter Z X) (complementParameter Z X) /-- The sharp cardinality of the antecedents after the outer subspaces are fixed. -/ theorem card_antecedent (Z : B →ₗ[F2] C) [Module.Finite F2 A] [Module.Finite F2 U] [Module.Finite F2 C] : Nat.card (Antecedent (U := U) (A := A) Z) = 2 ^ (Module.finrank F2 Z.range * (Module.finrank F2 A + Module.finrank F2 U)) := by rw [Nat.card_congr (antecedentEquiv (U := U) (A := A) Z), Nat.card_prod, CompressionCount.natCard_linearMap, CompressionCount.natCard_linearMap, ← pow_add] congr 1 ring theorem isAntecedent_iff_pointwise (Z : B →ₗ[F2] C) (X : (B × U) →ₗ[F2] (A × C)) : IsAntecedent Z X ↔ (∀ b, (X (b, 0)).2 = Z b) ∧ (∀ p, (X p).2 = 0 → X p = 0) ∧ (∀ p, ∃ b, X p = X (b, 0)) := by constructor · intro h exact ⟨h.1, antecedent_vertical_zero Z X h, antecedent_image_from_left Z X h⟩ · rintro ⟨hc, hv, hs⟩ refine ⟨hc, Submodule.disjoint_def.mpr ?_, top_unique ?_⟩ · rintro v ⟨p, rfl⟩ ⟨a, ha⟩ exact hv p (congrArg Prod.snd ha).symm · intro p _ obtain ⟨b, hb⟩ := hs p apply Submodule.mem_sup.mpr refine ⟨(b, 0), ⟨b, rfl⟩, p - (b, 0), ?_, ?_⟩ · change X (p - (b, 0)) = 0 rw [map_sub, hb, sub_self] · simpa only [← add_sub_assoc] using add_sub_cancel_left (b, 0) p variable {W V : Type*} [AddCommGroup W] [Module F2 W] [AddCommGroup V] [Module F2 V] theorem disjoint_range_iff_zero (X : W →ₗ[F2] V) (Q : Submodule F2 V) : Disjoint X.range Q ↔ ∀ w, X w ∈ Q → X w = 0 := by constructor · intro h w hw exact Submodule.disjoint_def.mp h (X w) (LinearMap.mem_range_self X w) hw · intro h apply Submodule.disjoint_def.mpr rintro v ⟨w, rfl⟩ hw exact h w hw theorem sup_kernel_iff_image (X : W →ₗ[F2] V) (P : Submodule F2 W) : P ⊔ X.ker = ⊤ ↔ ∀ w, ∃ p : P, X w = X p := by constructor · intro h w have hw : w ∈ P ⊔ X.ker := by rw [h]; trivial obtain ⟨p, hp, r, hr, he⟩ := Submodule.mem_sup.mp hw refine ⟨⟨p, hp⟩, ?_⟩ rw [← he, map_add] have hz : X r = 0 := hr simp [hz] · intro h apply top_unique intro w _ obtain ⟨p, hp⟩ := h w apply Submodule.mem_sup.mpr refine ⟨p, p.property, w - p, ?_, ?_⟩ · change X (w - p) = 0 rw [map_sub, hp, sub_self] · simpa only [← add_sub_assoc] using add_sub_cancel_left (p : W) w /-- Antecedents on arbitrary subspaces. Projection onto the chosen complement is the quotient compression expressed through `quotientEquivOfIsCompl`. -/ def IsSubspaceAntecedent (P : Submodule F2 W) (Q D : Submodule F2 V) (hQ : IsCompl Q D) (Z : P →ₗ[F2] D) (X : W →ₗ[F2] V) : Prop := (∀ p : P, D.projectionOnto Q hQ.symm (X p) = Z p) ∧ Disjoint X.range Q ∧ P ⊔ X.ker = ⊤ abbrev SubspaceAntecedent (P : Submodule F2 W) (Q D : Submodule F2 V) (hQ : IsCompl Q D) (Z : P →ₗ[F2] D) := { X : W →ₗ[F2] V // IsSubspaceAntecedent P Q D hQ Z X } noncomputable def coordinateEquiv (P E : Submodule F2 W) (Q D : Submodule F2 V) (hP : IsCompl P E) (hQ : IsCompl Q D) : (W →ₗ[F2] V) ≃ₗ[F2] ((P × E) →ₗ[F2] (Q × D)) := LinearEquiv.arrowCongr (P.prodEquivOfIsCompl E hP).symm (Q.prodEquivOfIsCompl D hQ).symm @[simp] theorem coordinateEquiv_apply (P E : Submodule F2 W) (Q D : Submodule F2 V) (hP : IsCompl P E) (hQ : IsCompl Q D) (X : W →ₗ[F2] V) (p : P × E) : coordinateEquiv P E Q D hP hQ X p = (Q.prodEquivOfIsCompl D hQ).symm (X ((p.1 : W) + p.2)) := rfl theorem coordinate_antecedent_iff (P E : Submodule F2 W) (Q D : Submodule F2 V) (hP : IsCompl P E) (hQ : IsCompl Q D) (Z : P →ₗ[F2] D) (X : W →ₗ[F2] V) : IsAntecedent Z (coordinateEquiv P E Q D hP hQ X) ↔ IsSubspaceAntecedent P Q D hQ Z X := by rw [isAntecedent_iff_pointwise] unfold IsSubspaceAntecedent rw [disjoint_range_iff_zero, sup_kernel_iff_image] constructor · rintro ⟨hc, hv, hs⟩ refine ⟨?_, ?_, ?_⟩ · intro p simpa using hc p · intro w hw let p := (P.prodEquivOfIsCompl E hP).symm w have hp : (p.1 : W) + p.2 = w := (P.prodEquivOfIsCompl E hP).apply_symm_apply w have hz : (coordinateEquiv P E Q D hP hQ X p).2 = 0 := by rw [coordinateEquiv_apply, hp] exact (Submodule.prodEquivOfIsCompl_symm_apply_snd_eq_zero Q D hQ).mpr hw have hh := congrArg (Q.prodEquivOfIsCompl D hQ) (hv p hz) simpa only [coordinateEquiv_apply, hp, LinearEquiv.apply_symm_apply, map_zero] using hh · intro w let p := (P.prodEquivOfIsCompl E hP).symm w have hp : (p.1 : W) + p.2 = w := (P.prodEquivOfIsCompl E hP).apply_symm_apply w obtain ⟨b, hb⟩ := hs p refine ⟨b, ?_⟩ have hh := congrArg (Q.prodEquivOfIsCompl D hQ) hb simpa only [coordinateEquiv_apply, hp, Submodule.coe_zero, add_zero, LinearEquiv.apply_symm_apply] using hh · rintro ⟨hc, hv, hs⟩ refine ⟨?_, ?_, ?_⟩ · intro p simpa using hc p · intro p hp have hm : X ((p.1 : W) + p.2) ∈ Q := (Submodule.prodEquivOfIsCompl_symm_apply_snd_eq_zero Q D hQ).mp hp have hz := hv ((p.1 : W) + p.2) hm simp [hz] · intro p obtain ⟨b, hb⟩ := hs ((p.1 : W) + p.2) refine ⟨b, ?_⟩ simpa only [coordinateEquiv_apply, Submodule.coe_zero, add_zero] using congrArg (Q.prodEquivOfIsCompl D hQ).symm hb /-- Transport the canonical antecedent count to arbitrary complementary subspaces. -/ noncomputable def subspaceAntecedentEquiv (P E : Submodule F2 W) (Q D : Submodule F2 V) (hP : IsCompl P E) (hQ : IsCompl Q D) (Z : P →ₗ[F2] D) : SubspaceAntecedent P Q D hQ Z ≃ (Z.range →ₗ[F2] Q) × (E →ₗ[F2] Z.range) := (Equiv.subtypeEquiv (coordinateEquiv P E Q D hP hQ).toEquiv (fun X => (coordinate_antecedent_iff P E Q D hP hQ Z X).symm)).trans (antecedentEquiv Z) /-- Exact antecedent cardinality in arbitrary complementary subspaces. -/ theorem card_subspaceAntecedent (P E : Submodule F2 W) (Q D : Submodule F2 V) (hP : IsCompl P E) (hQ : IsCompl Q D) (Z : P →ₗ[F2] D) [Module.Finite F2 W] [Module.Finite F2 V] : Nat.card (SubspaceAntecedent P Q D hQ Z) = 2 ^ (Module.finrank F2 Z.range * (Module.finrank F2 Q + Module.finrank F2 E)) := by rw [Nat.card_congr (subspaceAntecedentEquiv P E Q D hP hQ Z), Nat.card_prod, CompressionCount.natCard_linearMap, CompressionCount.natCard_linearMap, ← pow_add] congr 1 ring end MaxCutGames.Appendix.DerivativeInduction /-! # Exact antecedents of quotient compression This is the reverse-map count used in Proposition A.5. The compressed map is fixed, together with the two removed subspaces; neither a prescribed rank nor an assumed cardinality is part of the antecedent predicate. -/ namespace MaxCutGames.Appendix.AntecedentCount open MaxCutGames.Integration.BinaryLinear open LinearIdentities open scoped BigOperators noncomputable section attribute [local instance] Classical.propDecidable variable {W V : Type*} [AddCommGroup W] [Module F2 W] [AddCommGroup V] [Module F2 V] /-- Actual quotient-compression antecedents with the complement conditions in the passage from (A.15) to (A.16). -/ def IsAntecedent (P : Submodule F2 W) (Q : Submodule F2 V) (Y : P →ₗ[F2] (V ⧸ Q)) (X : W →ₗ[F2] V) : Prop := compress X Q P = Y ∧ Disjoint X.range Q ∧ P ⊔ X.ker = ⊤ abbrev Antecedent (P : Submodule F2 W) (Q : Submodule F2 V) (Y : P →ₗ[F2] (V ⧸ Q)) := {X : W →ₗ[F2] V // IsAntecedent P Q Y X} /-- Maps satisfying the geometric complement conditions, before their compression is fixed. -/ abbrev Admissible (P : Submodule F2 W) (Q : Submodule F2 V) := {X : W →ₗ[F2] V // Disjoint X.range Q ∧ P ⊔ X.ker = ⊤} /-- Reindex the actual maps by their actual compressed frequency. -/ def compressionEquiv (P : Submodule F2 W) (Q : Submodule F2 V) : Admissible P Q ≃ Σ Y : P →ₗ[F2] (V ⧸ Q), Antecedent P Q Y where toFun X := ⟨compress X.val Q P, ⟨X.val, rfl, X.property⟩⟩ invFun X := ⟨X.2.val, X.2.property.2⟩ left_inv X := rfl right_inv X := by rcases X with ⟨Y, ⟨X, hXY, hd, hk⟩⟩ cases hXY rfl /-- Choosing a codomain complement only changes the coordinates of the fixed compressed output. -/ theorem isAntecedent_iff_subspace (P : Submodule F2 W) (Q D : Submodule F2 V) (hQ : IsCompl Q D) (Y : P →ₗ[F2] (V ⧸ Q)) (X : W →ₗ[F2] V) : IsAntecedent P Q Y X ↔ DerivativeInduction.IsSubspaceAntecedent P Q D hQ ((Q.quotientEquivOfIsCompl D hQ).toLinearMap.comp Y) X := by constructor · rintro ⟨hXY, hd, hk⟩ refine ⟨?_, hd, hk⟩ intro p have h := LinearMap.congr_fun hXY p exact congrArg (Q.quotientEquivOfIsCompl D hQ) h · rintro ⟨hXY, hd, hk⟩ refine ⟨?_, hd, hk⟩ ext p apply (Q.quotientEquivOfIsCompl D hQ).injective exact hXY p /-- The quotient antecedents and the graph-coordinate antecedents are the same maps, with equivalent predicates. -/ def subspaceEquiv (P : Submodule F2 W) (Q D : Submodule F2 V) (hQ : IsCompl Q D) (Y : P →ₗ[F2] (V ⧸ Q)) : Antecedent P Q Y ≃ DerivativeInduction.SubspaceAntecedent P Q D hQ ((Q.quotientEquivOfIsCompl D hQ).toLinearMap.comp Y) where toFun X := ⟨X.val, (isAntecedent_iff_subspace P Q D hQ Y X.val).mp X.property⟩ invFun X := ⟨X.val, (isAntecedent_iff_subspace P Q D hQ Y X.val).mpr X.property⟩ left_inv _X := rfl right_inv _X := rfl variable [FiniteDimensional F2 W] [FiniteDimensional F2 V] omit [FiniteDimensional F2 V] in /-- Every admissible antecedent has the rank of its fixed compression. -/ theorem rank_eq (P : Submodule F2 W) (Q : Submodule F2 V) (Y : P →ₗ[F2] (V ⧸ Q)) (X : Antecedent P Q Y) : Module.finrank F2 X.val.range = Module.finrank F2 Y.range := by have h := compress_rank_preserved X.val Q P X.property.2.1.symm X.property.2.2 rw [X.property.1] at h exact h.symm /-- Exact number of antecedents of a fixed quotient compression. The graph and omitted-domain parameters have `rank Y * (dim Q + codim P)` bits. -/ theorem card_antecedent (P : Submodule F2 W) (Q : Submodule F2 V) (Y : P →ₗ[F2] (V ⧸ Q)) : Nat.card (Antecedent P Q Y) = 2 ^ (Module.finrank F2 Y.range * (Module.finrank F2 Q + Module.finrank F2 (W ⧸ P))) := by obtain ⟨E, hP⟩ := P.exists_isCompl obtain ⟨D, hQ⟩ := Q.exists_isCompl rw [Nat.card_congr (subspaceEquiv P Q D hQ Y), DerivativeInduction.card_subspaceAntecedent P E Q D hP hQ] rw [CoordinateTransport.finrank_comp_equiv] rw [← (P.quotientEquivOfIsCompl E hP).finrank_eq] /-- The actual reverse-map multiplicity fits the two graph-parameter budgets used in (A.16). No additional isomorphism factor is needed. -/ theorem card_antecedent_le (P : Submodule F2 W) (Q : Submodule F2 V) (Y : P →ₗ[F2] (V ⧸ Q)) (d k : ℕ) (hY : Module.finrank F2 Y.range ≤ k) (hQ : Module.finrank F2 Q ≤ d) (hP : Module.finrank F2 (W ⧸ P) ≤ d) : Nat.card (Antecedent P Q Y) ≤ 2 ^ (2 * d * k) := by rw [card_antecedent] apply Nat.pow_le_pow_right (by decide : 0 < (2 : ℕ)) calc Module.finrank F2 Y.range * (Module.finrank F2 Q + Module.finrank F2 (W ⧸ P)) ≤ k * (d + d) := Nat.mul_le_mul hY (Nat.add_le_add hQ hP) _ = 2 * d * k := by ring /-- Exact finite-sum reindexing by compressed maps, with the true fiber multiplicity. This holds for signed weights as well as nonnegative energies. -/ theorem sum_compression [Fintype (W →ₗ[F2] V)] (P : Submodule F2 W) (Q : Submodule F2 V) [Fintype (P →ₗ[F2] (V ⧸ Q))] {R : Type*} [Semiring R] (weight : (P →ₗ[F2] (V ⧸ Q)) → R) : (∑ X : Admissible P Q, weight (compress X.val Q P)) = ∑ Y : P →ₗ[F2] (V ⧸ Q), (2 : R) ^ (Module.finrank F2 Y.range * (Module.finrank F2 Q + Module.finrank F2 (W ⧸ P))) * weight Y := by classical calc (∑ X : Admissible P Q, weight (compress X.val Q P)) = ∑ X : Σ Y : P →ₗ[F2] (V ⧸ Q), Antecedent P Q Y, weight X.1 := Fintype.sum_equiv (compressionEquiv P Q) _ _ (fun _ => rfl) _ = _ := by rw [Fintype.sum_sigma] apply Finset.sum_congr rfl intro Y _ simp only [Finset.sum_const, Finset.card_univ, nsmul_eq_mul] rw [← Nat.card_eq_fintype_card, card_antecedent] simp only [Nat.cast_pow, Nat.cast_ofNat] end end MaxCutGames.Appendix.AntecedentCount end OAI