import Mathlib import OAI.Computability.MaxCut.PCP.CayleySampling namespace OAI /-! # Walsh diagonalization of actual Boolean-cube Cayley graphs Every port is an indexed generator. The rotation keeps the port and adds its generator by pointwise xor, so loops and repeated generators keep their full multiplicity. The Fourier multiplier and energy estimate are proved for this actual averaging operator; no Fourier/operator compatibility is assumed. -/ noncomputable section namespace MaxCutGames.Foundations.PCP.CayleySpectral open scoped BigOperators open Finset open MaxCutGames.Foundations.Hastad open PoweringWalks variable {I D : Type*} def zeroFrequency : Cube I := fun _ => false theorem cubeXor_cancel_right (x y : Cube I) : cubeXor (cubeXor x y) y = x := by funext i cases hx : x i <;> cases hy : y i <;> simp [cubeXor, hx, hy] theorem cubeXor_assoc (x y z : Cube I) : cubeXor (cubeXor x y) z = cubeXor x (cubeXor y z) := by funext i cases hx : x i <;> cases hy : y i <;> cases hz : z i <;> simp [cubeXor, hx, hy, hz] @[simp] theorem cubeXor_zeroFrequency (x : Cube I) : cubeXor x zeroFrequency = x := by funext i cases hx : x i <;> simp [cubeXor, zeroFrequency, hx] /-- Uniform cube measure is invariant under this explicit xor translation. -/ def xorTranslation (y : Cube I) : Cube I ≃ Cube I where toFun x := cubeXor x y invFun x := cubeXor x y left_inv x := cubeXor_cancel_right x y right_inv x := cubeXor_cancel_right x y def rotate (g : D → Cube I) (p : Cube I × D) : Cube I × D := (cubeXor p.1 (g p.2), p.2) theorem rotate_involutive (g : D → Cube I) : Function.Involutive (rotate g) := by rintro ⟨x, d⟩ change (cubeXor (cubeXor x (g d)) (g d), d) = (x, d) rw [cubeXor_cancel_right] /-- The undirected regular port graph generated by the indexed cube vectors. -/ def cayleyGraph (g : D → Cube I) : PortGraph (Cube I) D where rot := { toFun := rotate g invFun := rotate g left_inv := rotate_involutive g right_inv := rotate_involutive g } rot_involutive := rotate_involutive g @[simp] theorem cayleyGraph_rot (g : D → Cube I) (x : Cube I) (d : D) : (cayleyGraph g).rot (x, d) = (cubeXor x (g d), d) := rfl /-- Expose the first actual port in a finite port word. -/ def splitPortWord (n : Nat) : (Fin (n + 1) → D) ≃ D × (Fin n → D) where toFun p := (p 0, fun j => p j.succ) invFun z := Fin.cases z.1 z.2 left_inv p := by funext j exact Fin.cases rfl (fun _ => rfl) j right_inv z := rfl /-- The generator of a powered port is the xor of its original port word. -/ def powerGenerators (g : D → Cube I) : (n : Nat) → (Fin n → D) → Cube I | 0, _ => zeroFrequency | n + 1, p => cubeXor (g (p 0)) (powerGenerators g n (fun j => p j.succ)) /-- These are actual walk displacements, including repeated vertices and ports. -/ theorem wordEnd_eq_powerGenerators (g : D → Cube I) (n : Nat) (x : Cube I) (p : Fin n → D) : wordEnd (cayleyGraph g) n x p = cubeXor x (powerGenerators g n p) := by induction n generalizing x with | zero => simp [wordEnd, powerGenerators] | succ n ih => change wordEnd (cayleyGraph g) n (cubeXor x (g (p 0))) (fun j => p j.succ) = cubeXor x (cubeXor (g (p 0)) (powerGenerators g n (fun j => p j.succ))) rw [ih, cubeXor_assoc] variable [Fintype I] [DecidableEq I] [Fintype D] /-- Average along the actual outgoing ports of the Cayley graph. -/ def cayleyAverage (g : D → Cube I) (f : Cube I → ℝ) (x : Cube I) : ℝ := 𝔼 d, f ((cayleyGraph g).rot (x, d)).1 /-- The eigenvalue is the empirical bias of the generator characters. -/ def eigenvalue (g : D → Cube I) (s : Cube I) : ℝ := 𝔼 d, walsh s (g d) omit [Fintype I] [DecidableEq I] in @[simp] theorem averagingOperator_cayleyGraph (g : D → Cube I) (f : Cube I → ℝ) : SpectralReturn.averagingOperator (cayleyGraph g) f = cayleyAverage g f := rfl @[simp] theorem coefficient_zeroFrequency (f : Cube I → ℝ) : coefficient f zeroFrequency = 𝔼 x, f x := by simp [coefficient, zeroFrequency, walsh, bitSign] /-- Change «variables» through xor translation in the actual Fourier average. -/ theorem coefficient_xorTranslation (f : Cube I → ℝ) (s v : Cube I) : coefficient (fun x => f (cubeXor x v)) s = walsh s v * coefficient f s := by calc coefficient (fun x => f (cubeXor x v)) s = 𝔼 x, f x * walsh s (cubeXor x v) := by unfold coefficient apply Fintype.expect_equiv (xorTranslation v) intro x change f (cubeXor x v) * walsh s x = f (cubeXor x v) * walsh s (cubeXor (cubeXor x v) v) rw [cubeXor_cancel_right] _ = 𝔼 x, (f x * walsh s x) * walsh s v := by apply Finset.expect_congr rfl intro x _ rw [walsh_xor] ring _ = coefficient f s * walsh s v := by rw [← Finset.expect_mul] rfl _ = walsh s v * coefficient f s := mul_comm _ _ /-- Each Walsh character is an eigenvector of the actual Cayley averaging. -/ theorem cayleyAverage_walsh (g : D → Cube I) (s x : Cube I) : cayleyAverage g (walsh s) x = eigenvalue g s * walsh s x := by unfold cayleyAverage simp only [cayleyGraph_rot, walsh_xor] rw [← Finset.mul_expect] rw [mul_comm] rfl /-- Full Walsh diagonalization, obtained by swapping the two finite averages. -/ theorem coefficient_cayleyAverage (g : D → Cube I) (f : Cube I → ℝ) (s : Cube I) : coefficient (cayleyAverage g f) s = eigenvalue g s * coefficient f s := by calc coefficient (cayleyAverage g f) s = 𝔼 x, 𝔼 d, f (cubeXor x (g d)) * walsh s x := by unfold coefficient cayleyAverage simp only [cayleyGraph_rot, Finset.expect_mul] _ = 𝔼 d, 𝔼 x, f (cubeXor x (g d)) * walsh s x := by rw [Finset.expect_comm] _ = 𝔼 d, walsh s (g d) * coefficient f s := by apply Finset.expect_congr rfl intro d _ exact coefficient_xorTranslation f s (g d) _ = eigenvalue g s * coefficient f s := by rw [← Finset.expect_mul] rfl /-- Uniform finite port-word splitting multiplies the actual eigenvalues. -/ theorem eigenvalue_powerGenerators (g : D → Cube I) (n : Nat) (s : Cube I) : eigenvalue (powerGenerators g n) s = eigenvalue g s ^ n := by induction n with | zero => let : Nonempty (Fin 0 → D) := ⟨fun i => Fin.elim0 i⟩ simp [eigenvalue, powerGenerators, zeroFrequency, walsh, bitSign] | succ n ih => calc eigenvalue (powerGenerators g (n + 1)) s = 𝔼 z : D × (Fin n → D), walsh s (cubeXor (g z.1) (powerGenerators g n z.2)) := by unfold eigenvalue apply Fintype.expect_equiv (splitPortWord n) intro p rfl _ = 𝔼 d, 𝔼 p : Fin n → D, walsh s (cubeXor (g d) (powerGenerators g n p)) := by exact SpectralReturn.mean_prod _ _ = eigenvalue g s * eigenvalue (powerGenerators g n) s := by simp_rw [walsh_xor, ← Finset.mul_expect] rw [← Finset.expect_mul] rfl _ = eigenvalue g s ^ (n + 1) := by rw [ih, pow_succ, mul_comm] /-- The port degree of the powered graph is the exact number of port words. -/ theorem power_port_card (n : Nat) : Fintype.card (Fin n → D) = Fintype.card D ^ n := by simp only [Fintype.card_fun, Fintype.card_fin] theorem seven_power_port_card : Fintype.card (Fin 7 → Fin (2 ^ 16)) = (2 ^ 16) ^ 7 := by simp only [Fintype.card_fun, Fintype.card_fin] /-- A bias bound on all nonconstant generator characters contracts the actual mean-zero function energy. The constant coefficient is eliminated by its exact identification with the mean, and every other coefficient is bounded termwise. -/ theorem cayley_energy_contraction (g : D → Cube I) (lambda : ℝ) (_hlambda : 0 ≤ lambda) (hbias : ∀ s : Cube I, s ≠ zeroFrequency → |eigenvalue g s| ≤ lambda) (f : Cube I → ℝ) (hmean : (𝔼 x, f x) = 0) : (𝔼 x, cayleyAverage g f x ^ 2) ≤ lambda ^ 2 * (𝔼 x, f x ^ 2) := by classical have hzero : coefficient f zeroFrequency = 0 := by rw [coefficient_zeroFrequency] exact hmean calc (𝔼 x, cayleyAverage g f x ^ 2) = ∑ s, coefficient (cayleyAverage g f) s ^ 2 := (walsh_parseval _).symm _ = ∑ s, (eigenvalue g s * coefficient f s) ^ 2 := by simp only [coefficient_cayleyAverage] _ ≤ ∑ s, lambda ^ 2 * coefficient f s ^ 2 := by apply Finset.sum_le_sum intro s _ by_cases hs : s = zeroFrequency · subst s simp [hzero] · have hb := hbias s hs have hlo : -lambda ≤ eigenvalue g s := (abs_le.mp hb).1 have hhi : eigenvalue g s ≤ lambda := (abs_le.mp hb).2 have hprod : 0 ≤ (lambda - eigenvalue g s) * (lambda + eigenvalue g s) := mul_nonneg (sub_nonneg.mpr hhi) (by linarith) have hsq : eigenvalue g s ^ 2 ≤ lambda ^ 2 := by nlinarith calc (eigenvalue g s * coefficient f s) ^ 2 = eigenvalue g s ^ 2 * coefficient f s ^ 2 := by rw [mul_pow] _ ≤ lambda ^ 2 * coefficient f s ^ 2 := mul_le_mul_of_nonneg_right hsq (sq_nonneg _) _ = lambda ^ 2 * (𝔼 x, f x ^ 2) := by rw [← Finset.mul_sum, walsh_parseval] /-- The Fourier proof supplies the graph certificate used in return bounds. -/ theorem cayley_spectralCertificate (g : D → Cube I) (lambda : ℝ) (hlambda : 0 ≤ lambda) (hlambdaone : lambda < 1) (hbias : ∀ s : Cube I, s ≠ zeroFrequency → |eigenvalue g s| ≤ lambda) : SpectralReturn.SpectralCertificate (cayleyGraph g) lambda where nonnegative := hlambda lt_one := hlambdaone contraction := by intro f hf change (𝔼 x, cayleyAverage g f x ^ 2) ≤ lambda ^ 2 * (𝔼 x, f x ^ 2) exact cayley_energy_contraction g lambda hlambda hbias f hf theorem power_eigenvalue_bound (g : D → Cube I) (lambda : ℝ) (hlambda : 0 ≤ lambda) (hbias : ∀ s : Cube I, s ≠ zeroFrequency → |eigenvalue g s| ≤ lambda) (n : Nat) (s : Cube I) (hs : s ≠ zeroFrequency) : |eigenvalue (powerGenerators g n) s| ≤ lambda ^ n := by rw [eigenvalue_powerGenerators, abs_pow] induction n with | zero => simp | succ n ih => rw [pow_succ, pow_succ] exact mul_le_mul ih (hbias s hs) (abs_nonneg _) (pow_nonneg hlambda _) /-- Seven actual generator steps turn one-half character bias into `2⁻⁷`. -/ theorem sevenStep_halfCertificate (g : D → Cube I) (hbias : ∀ s : Cube I, s ≠ zeroFrequency → |eigenvalue g s| ≤ (1 / 2 : ℝ)) : SpectralReturn.SpectralCertificate (cayleyGraph (powerGenerators g 7)) ((1 / 2 : ℝ) ^ 7) := by apply cayley_spectralCertificate · norm_num · norm_num · intro s hs exact power_eigenvalue_bound g (1 / 2) (by norm_num) hbias 7 s hs end MaxCutGames.Foundations.PCP.CayleySpectral end /-! # Finite existence of the Cayley expander base The sample space is the actual finite type of indexed Boolean-cube generators. For each nonzero character, the checked sign sampling equivalence supplies its uniform word law. A finite union bound then selects a generator family whose nonconstant character biases are small. There is no random-graph hypothesis. The fixed numbers below are manipulated symbolically; no enumeration of the generator sample space is executed. The subsequent square-and-zigzag family is a separate construction. -/ noncomputable section namespace MaxCutGames.Foundations.PCP.Expanders open scoped BigOperators open MaxCutGames.Foundations.Hastad open CayleySpectral abbrev Generators (n m : Nat) := Fin (4 * m) → Cube (Fin n) /-- The zero character is excluded from the bad-event count. -/ def badFrequency {n m : Nat} (g : Generators n m) (s : Cube (Fin n)) : ℝ := if s = zeroFrequency then 0 else if CayleyTailCount.badWord m (fun d => AssignmentTester.parity s (g d)) then 1 else 0 def badMass {n m : Nat} (g : Generators n m) : ℝ := ∑ s : Cube (Fin n), badFrequency g s theorem badFrequency_nonnegative {n m : Nat} (g : Generators n m) (s : Cube (Fin n)) : 0 ≤ badFrequency g s := by unfold badFrequency split_ifs <;> norm_num theorem mean_badFrequency_le {n m : Nat} (s : Cube (Fin n)) : (𝔼 g : Generators n m, badFrequency g s) ≤ 2 * (2 / 3 : ℝ) ^ m := by classical by_cases hs : s = zeroFrequency · simp only [badFrequency, ite_eq_left hs, Finset.expect_const_zero] positivity · have hs' : s ≠ (fun _ => false) := hs simp only [badFrequency, ite_eq_right hs] rw [CayleySampling.expect_parity_samples s hs' (fun w : Fin (4 * m) → Bool => if CayleyTailCount.badWord m w then (1 : ℝ) else 0)] exact CayleyTailCount.twoTail_probability m (by simp) theorem mean_badMass_le (n m : Nat) (hm : 3 * (n + 2) ≤ m) : (𝔼 g : Generators n m, badMass g) ≤ 1 / 2 := by calc _ = ∑ s : Cube (Fin n), 𝔼 g : Generators n m, badFrequency g s := by unfold badMass rw [Finset.expect_sum_comm] _ ≤ ∑ _s : Cube (Fin n), 2 * (2 / 3 : ℝ) ^ m := Finset.sum_le_sum (fun s _ => mean_badFrequency_le s) _ = (2 : ℝ) ^ n * (2 * (2 / 3 : ℝ) ^ m) := by simp [Cube] _ ≤ 1 / 2 := CayleyTailCount.union_bound_le_half n m hm /-- Actual finite generators with a simultaneous bound for every nonconstant Walsh character. The proof selects a point with bad-event count less than one. -/ theorem exists_generators (n m : Nat) (hm : 3 * (n + 2) ≤ m) : ∃ g : Generators n m, ∀ s : Cube (Fin n), s ≠ zeroFrequency → |eigenvalue g s| ≤ (1 / 2 : ℝ) := by classical have hmpos : 0 < m := by omega let : Nonempty (Fin (4 * m)) := ⟨⟨0, by omega⟩⟩ have havg : (𝔼 g : Generators n m, badMass g) < (1 : ℝ) := lt_of_le_of_lt (mean_badMass_le n m hm) (by norm_num) obtain ⟨g, _, hg⟩ := Finset.exists_lt_of_expect_lt Finset.univ_nonempty havg refine ⟨g, fun s hs => ?_⟩ have hgood : ¬ CayleyTailCount.badWord m (fun d => AssignmentTester.parity s (g d)) := by intro hbad have hsingle : badFrequency g s ≤ badMass g := Finset.single_le_sum (fun t _ => badFrequency_nonnegative g t) (Finset.mem_univ s) simp only [badFrequency, ite_eq_right hs, ite_eq_left hbad] at hsingle exact (not_le_of_gt hg) hsingle unfold eigenvalue simp_rw [← AssignmentTester.bitSign_parity] exact CayleyTailCount.not_badWord_bias m (by simp) hmpos _ hgood def baseDimension : Nat := 448 def initialDegree : Nat := 2 ^ 16 def initialQuarterDegree : Nat := 2 ^ 14 def basePower : Nat := 7 theorem base_arithmetic : 4 * initialQuarterDegree = initialDegree ∧ 3 * (baseDimension + 2) ≤ initialQuarterDegree ∧ (2 : Nat) ^ baseDimension = (initialDegree ^ basePower) ^ 4 ∧ (1 / 2 : ℝ) ^ basePower ≤ 1 / 100 := by refine ⟨?_, ?_, ?_, ?_⟩ · norm_num [initialDegree, initialQuarterDegree] · norm_num [baseDimension, initialQuarterDegree] · dsimp only [baseDimension, initialDegree, basePower] rw [← pow_mul, ← pow_mul] · norm_num [basePower] theorem exists_initial_generators : ∃ g : Generators baseDimension initialQuarterDegree, ∀ s : Cube (Fin baseDimension), s ≠ zeroFrequency → |eigenvalue g s| ≤ (1 / 2 : ℝ) := exists_generators _ _ base_arithmetic.2.1 abbrev BaseVertex := Cube (Fin baseDimension) abbrev BasePort := Fin basePower → Fin (4 * initialQuarterDegree) def baseDegree : Nat := initialDegree ^ basePower theorem card_basePort : Fintype.card BasePort = baseDegree := by simp only [BasePort, Fintype.card_fun, Fintype.card_fin] rw [base_arithmetic.1] rfl theorem card_baseVertex : Fintype.card BaseVertex = baseDegree ^ 4 := by simpa only [BaseVertex, Cube, Fintype.card_fun, Fintype.card_bool, Fintype.card_fin, baseDegree] using base_arithmetic.2.2.1 /-- A genuine finite regular graph with the exact degree/size relation needed for zigzag. Its spectral certificate follows from the actual generator witness. -/ theorem exists_baseGraph : ∃ H : PoweringWalks.PortGraph BaseVertex BasePort, SpectralReturn.SpectralCertificate H (1 / 100 : ℝ) := by obtain ⟨g, hg⟩ := exists_initial_generators refine ⟨cayleyGraph (powerGenerators g basePower), ?_⟩ apply cayley_spectralCertificate · norm_num · norm_num · intro s hs exact (power_eigenvalue_bound g (1 / 2) (by norm_num) hg basePower s hs).trans base_arithmetic.2.2.2 end MaxCutGames.Foundations.PCP.Expanders end /-! Exact changes of finite vertex and port coordinates. The graph rotation and its normalized averaging operator are transported by the same equivalences. -/ namespace MaxCutGames.Foundations.PCP.GraphTransport open PoweringWalks SpectralReturn variable {V W D E : Type*} def reindex (G : PortGraph V D) (vertices : V ≃ W) (ports : D ≃ E) : PortGraph W E where rot := (Equiv.prodCongr vertices ports).symm.trans (G.rot.trans (Equiv.prodCongr vertices ports)) rot_involutive := by intro x change (Equiv.prodCongr vertices ports) (G.rot ((Equiv.prodCongr vertices ports).symm ((Equiv.prodCongr vertices ports) (G.rot ((Equiv.prodCongr vertices ports).symm x))))) = x rw [Equiv.symm_apply_apply, G.rot_involutive, Equiv.apply_symm_apply] @[simp] theorem reindex_rot (G : PortGraph V D) (vertices : V ≃ W) (ports : D ≃ E) (v : V) (d : D) : (reindex G vertices ports).rot (vertices v, ports d) = (vertices (G.rot (v, d)).1, ports (G.rot (v, d)).2) := by simp [reindex, Equiv.trans_apply, Prod.map] variable [Fintype V] [Fintype W] [Fintype D] [Fintype E] omit [Fintype V] [Fintype W] in theorem operator_reindex (G : PortGraph V D) (vertices : V ≃ W) (ports : D ≃ E) (f : W → ℝ) (w : W) : averagingOperator (reindex G vertices ports) f w = averagingOperator G (fun v => f (vertices v)) (vertices.symm w) := by unfold averagingOperator apply Fintype.expect_equiv ports.symm intro e rfl theorem energy_reindex (vertices : V ≃ W) (f : W → ℝ) : energy (fun v => f (vertices v)) = energy f := mean_equiv vertices (fun w => f w ^ 2) /-- A coordinate change preserves the actual spectral certificate, including the uniform measure on the port alphabet. -/ theorem reindex_spectralCertificate (G : PortGraph V D) (vertices : V ≃ W) (ports : D ≃ E) (lambda : ℝ) (certificate : SpectralCertificate G lambda) : SpectralCertificate (reindex G vertices ports) lambda where nonnegative := certificate.nonnegative lt_one := certificate.lt_one contraction := by intro f hf have hf' : mean (fun v => f (vertices v)) = 0 := (mean_equiv vertices f).trans hf have h := certificate.contraction (fun v => f (vertices v)) hf' have hout : energy (averagingOperator (reindex G vertices ports) f) = energy (averagingOperator G (fun v => f (vertices v))) := by rw [← energy_reindex vertices] congr 1 funext v rw [operator_reindex, vertices.symm_apply_apply] rw [hout, ← energy_reindex vertices f] exact h end MaxCutGames.Foundations.PCP.GraphTransport /-! # Actual graph squares and zigzag products Rotations operate on actual vertex-port pairs. All returned ports are retained, including ports belonging to loops and parallel edges. Each construction is a palindrome of involutions and hence defines a reversible regular port graph. -/ namespace MaxCutGames.Foundations.PCP.ZigzagGraphs open PoweringWalks variable {V D E : Type*} /-- Regard a checked involution as a permutation with the same inverse. -/ def involutionEquiv {A : Type*} (f : A → A) (hf : Function.Involutive f) : A ≃ A where toFun := f invFun := f left_inv := hf right_inv := hf /-- A palindrome of two involutions is itself an involution. -/ theorem palindrome_involutive {A : Type*} (B P : A ≃ A) (hB : Function.Involutive B) (hP : Function.Involutive P) : Function.Involutive (B.trans (P.trans B)) := by intro x change B (P (B (B (P (B x))))) = x rw [hB, hP, hB] /-- Cross an original edge using the first port; retain its return port. -/ def squareFirst (G : PortGraph V D) (s : V × (D × D)) : V × (D × D) := let step := G.rot (s.1, s.2.1) (step.1, (step.2, s.2.2)) theorem squareFirst_involutive (G : PortGraph V D) : Function.Involutive (squareFirst G) := by rintro ⟨v, d₁, d₂⟩ change ((G.rot (G.rot (v, d₁))).1, ((G.rot (G.rot (v, d₁))).2, d₂)) = (v, (d₁, d₂)) rw [G.rot_involutive] def squareSwap (s : V × (D × D)) : V × (D × D) := (s.1, (s.2.2, s.2.1)) theorem squareSwap_involutive : Function.Involutive (squareSwap (V := V) (D := D)) := by rintro ⟨v, d₁, d₂⟩ rfl /-- The actual graph square. The two return ports appear in reverse order. -/ def square (G : PortGraph V D) : PortGraph V (D × D) := by let B := involutionEquiv (squareFirst G) (squareFirst_involutive G) let P := involutionEquiv (squareSwap (V := V) (D := D)) squareSwap_involutive exact { rot := B.trans (P.trans B) rot_involutive := palindrome_involutive B P (squareFirst_involutive G) squareSwap_involutive } @[simp] theorem square_rot_apply (G : PortGraph V D) (v : V) (d₁ d₂ : D) : (square G).rot (v, (d₁, d₂)) = let first := G.rot (v, d₁) let second := G.rot (first.1, d₂) (second.1, (second.2, first.2)) := rfl @[simp] theorem square_next (G : PortGraph V D) (v : V) (d₁ d₂ : D) : next (square G) v (d₁, d₂) = next G (next G v d₁) d₂ := rfl /-- One inner step in a cloud, retaining its return port and the unused port. -/ def cloudFirst (H : PortGraph D E) (s : (V × D) × (E × E)) : (V × D) × (E × E) := let step := H.rot (s.1.2, s.2.1) ((s.1.1, step.1), (step.2, s.2.2)) theorem cloudFirst_involutive (H : PortGraph D E) : Function.Involutive (cloudFirst (V := V) H) := by rintro ⟨⟨v, d⟩, ⟨e₁, e₂⟩⟩ change ((v, (H.rot (H.rot (d, e₁))).1), ((H.rot (H.rot (d, e₁))).2, e₂)) = ((v, d), (e₁, e₂)) rw [H.rot_involutive] /-- Cross the outer graph edge and swap the two inner ports. -/ def crossCloud (G : PortGraph V D) (s : (V × D) × (E × E)) : (V × D) × (E × E) := (G.rot s.1, (s.2.2, s.2.1)) theorem crossCloud_involutive (G : PortGraph V D) : Function.Involutive (crossCloud (E := E) G) := by rintro ⟨x, e₁, e₂⟩ change (G.rot (G.rot x), (e₁, e₂)) = (x, (e₁, e₂)) rw [G.rot_involutive] /-- The actual zigzag product: inner step, outer edge, inner step. -/ def zigzag (G : PortGraph V D) (H : PortGraph D E) : PortGraph (V × D) (E × E) := by let B := involutionEquiv (cloudFirst (V := V) H) (cloudFirst_involutive H) let P := involutionEquiv (crossCloud (E := E) G) (crossCloud_involutive G) exact { rot := B.trans (P.trans B) rot_involutive := palindrome_involutive B P (cloudFirst_involutive H) (crossCloud_involutive G) } @[simp] theorem zigzag_rot_apply (G : PortGraph V D) (H : PortGraph D E) (v : V) (d : D) (e₁ e₂ : E) : (zigzag G H).rot ((v, d), (e₁, e₂)) = let first := H.rot (d, e₁) let middle := G.rot (v, first.1) let last := H.rot (middle.2, e₂) ((middle.1, last.1), (last.2, first.2)) := rfl theorem natCard_square_ports : Nat.card (D × D) = Nat.card D ^ 2 := by simp [Nat.card_prod, pow_two] theorem natCard_square_edges : Nat.card (Edge V (D × D)) = Nat.card V * Nat.card D ^ 2 := by simp [Edge, Nat.card_prod, pow_two] theorem natCard_zigzag_vertices : Nat.card (V × D) = Nat.card V * Nat.card D := Nat.card_prod V D theorem natCard_zigzag_ports : Nat.card (E × E) = Nat.card E ^ 2 := by simp [Nat.card_prod, pow_two] theorem natCard_zigzag_edges : Nat.card (Edge (V × D) (E × E)) = Nat.card V * Nat.card D * Nat.card E ^ 2 := by simp [Edge, Nat.card_prod, pow_two] /-! ## Exact averaging operators -/ noncomputable section /-- Average only the inner cloud coordinate, keeping the outer vertex fixed. -/ def cloudOperator [Fintype E] (H : PortGraph D E) (f : V × D → ℝ) (x : V × D) : ℝ := SpectralReturn.mean (fun e => f (x.1, (H.rot (x.2, e)).1)) /-- The permutation on cloud vertices induced by the actual outer rotation. -/ def graphPermutation (G : PortGraph V D) (f : V × D → ℝ) (x : V × D) : ℝ := f (G.rot x) /-- Uniform averaging on the graph square is two original averaging steps. -/ theorem averagingOperator_square [Fintype D] (G : PortGraph V D) (f : V → ℝ) : SpectralReturn.averagingOperator (square G) f = SpectralReturn.averagingOperator G (SpectralReturn.averagingOperator G f) := by funext v let w : D × D → ℝ := fun ds => f (G.rot ((G.rot (v, ds.1)).1, ds.2)).1 change SpectralReturn.mean w = SpectralReturn.mean (fun d₁ => SpectralReturn.mean (fun d₂ => w (d₁, d₂))) exact SpectralReturn.mean_prod w /-- The zigzag operator is precisely inner average, outer permutation, inner average. This factorization follows from the actual rotation formula. -/ theorem averagingOperator_zigzag [Fintype E] (G : PortGraph V D) (H : PortGraph D E) (f : V × D → ℝ) : SpectralReturn.averagingOperator (zigzag G H) f = cloudOperator H (graphPermutation G (cloudOperator H f)) := by funext x rcases x with ⟨v, d⟩ let w : E × E → ℝ := fun es => let first := H.rot (d, es.1) let middle := G.rot (v, first.1) let last := H.rot (middle.2, es.2) f (middle.1, last.1) change SpectralReturn.mean w = SpectralReturn.mean (fun e₁ => SpectralReturn.mean (fun e₂ => w (e₁, e₂))) exact SpectralReturn.mean_prod w end end MaxCutGames.Foundations.PCP.ZigzagGraphs /-! # Energy contraction for the actual zigzag graph The proof splits a function into its cloud average and its cloud-centered part. All operators are the actual graph averages from `ZigzagGraphs`. -/ namespace MaxCutGames.Foundations.PCP.ZigzagSpectral open PoweringWalks SpectralReturn ZigzagGraphs noncomputable section variable {V D E : Type*} def cloudMean [Fintype D] (f : V × D → ℝ) (v : V) : ℝ := mean (fun d => f (v, d)) def liftCloud (f : V → ℝ) (x : V × D) : ℝ := f x.1 def projection [Fintype D] (f : V × D → ℝ) : V × D → ℝ := liftCloud (cloudMean f) def centered [Fintype D] (f : V × D → ℝ) : V × D → ℝ := f - projection f theorem mean_liftCloud [Fintype V] [Fintype D] [Nonempty D] (f : V → ℝ) : mean (liftCloud (D := D) f) = mean f := by change mean (fun x : V × D => f x.1) = mean f rw [mean_prod] simp only [mean_const] theorem energy_liftCloud [Fintype V] [Fintype D] [Nonempty D] (f : V → ℝ) : energy (liftCloud (D := D) f) = energy f := mean_liftCloud (D := D) (fun v => f v ^ 2) theorem mean_cloudMean [Fintype V] [Fintype D] (f : V × D → ℝ) : mean (cloudMean f) = mean f := (mean_prod f).symm theorem energy_prod [Fintype V] [Fintype D] (f : V × D → ℝ) : energy f = mean (fun v => energy (fun d => f (v, d))) := mean_prod (fun x => f x ^ 2) theorem cloudMean_centered_zero [Fintype D] [Nonempty D] (f : V × D → ℝ) (v : V) : cloudMean (centered f) v = 0 := by change mean (fun d => f (v, d) - cloudMean f v) = 0 rw [mean_sub, mean_const] exact sub_self _ theorem energy_centered_eq_sub [Fintype V] [Fintype D] [Nonempty D] (f : V × D → ℝ) : energy (centered f) = energy f - energy (projection f) := by have hpoint (v : V) : energy (fun d => centered f (v, d)) = energy (fun d => f (v, d)) - (cloudMean f v) ^ 2 := by change energy (fun d => f (v, d) - cloudMean f v) = _ rw [energy_sub_const] change energy (fun d => f (v, d)) - 2 * cloudMean f v * cloudMean f v + (cloudMean f v) ^ 2 = _ ring have hproj : energy (projection f) = energy (cloudMean f) := energy_liftCloud _ calc energy (centered f) = mean (fun v => energy (fun d => centered f (v, d))) := energy_prod _ _ = mean (fun v => energy (fun d => f (v, d)) - (cloudMean f v) ^ 2) := by congr 1 funext v exact hpoint v _ = mean (fun v => energy (fun d => f (v, d))) - mean (fun v => (cloudMean f v) ^ 2) := mean_sub _ _ _ = energy f - energy (projection f) := by rw [← energy_prod f, hproj] rfl theorem projection_energy_decomposition [Fintype V] [Fintype D] [Nonempty D] (f : V × D → ℝ) : energy f = energy (projection f) + energy (centered f) := by rw [energy_centered_eq_sub] ring theorem energy_projection_le [Fintype V] [Fintype D] [Nonempty D] (f : V × D → ℝ) : energy (projection f) ≤ energy f := by have h := projection_energy_decomposition f have hn := energy_nonnegative (centered f) linarith theorem energy_centered_le [Fintype V] [Fintype D] [Nonempty D] (f : V × D → ℝ) : energy (centered f) ≤ energy f := by rw [energy_centered_eq_sub] exact sub_le_self _ (energy_nonnegative _) /-- Squared normalized mean is bounded by normalized squared energy. -/ theorem mean_sq_le_energy {A : Type*} [Fintype A] [Nonempty A] (f : A → ℝ) : mean f ^ 2 ≤ energy f := by have h := correlation_sq_le f (fun _ => 1) simpa [correlation, energy] using h /-- Every actual reversible regular graph average is an energy contraction. -/ theorem averaging_energy_le [Fintype V] [Fintype D] [Nonempty V] [Nonempty D] (G : PortGraph V D) (f : V → ℝ) : energy (averagingOperator G f) ≤ energy f := by calc energy (averagingOperator G f) ≤ mean (averagingOperator G (fun v => f v ^ 2)) := by apply mean_mono intro v exact mean_sq_le_energy (fun d => f (G.rot (v, d)).1) _ = energy f := mean_operator G _ theorem cloudOperator_add [Fintype E] (H : PortGraph D E) (f g : V × D → ℝ) : cloudOperator H (f + g) = cloudOperator H f + cloudOperator H g := by funext x exact mean_add _ _ theorem cloudOperator_sub [Fintype E] (H : PortGraph D E) (f g : V × D → ℝ) : cloudOperator H (f - g) = cloudOperator H f - cloudOperator H g := by funext x exact mean_sub _ _ theorem cloudOperator_projection [Fintype D] [Fintype E] [Nonempty E] (H : PortGraph D E) (f : V × D → ℝ) : cloudOperator H (projection f) = projection f := by funext x change mean (fun _ : E => cloudMean f x.1) = cloudMean f x.1 exact mean_const _ theorem cloudOperator_centered [Fintype D] [Fintype E] [Nonempty E] (H : PortGraph D E) (f : V × D → ℝ) : cloudOperator H (centered f) = cloudOperator H f - projection f := by unfold centered rw [cloudOperator_sub, cloudOperator_projection] theorem graphPermutation_energy [Fintype V] [Fintype D] (G : PortGraph V D) (f : V × D → ℝ) : energy (graphPermutation G f) = energy f := mean_equiv G.rot (fun x => f x ^ 2) theorem cloud_energy_le [Fintype V] [Fintype D] [Fintype E] [Nonempty D] [Nonempty E] (H : PortGraph D E) (f : V × D → ℝ) : energy (cloudOperator H f) ≤ energy f := by calc energy (cloudOperator H f) = mean (fun v => energy (averagingOperator H (fun d => f (v, d)))) := energy_prod _ _ ≤ mean (fun v => energy (fun d => f (v, d))) := mean_mono (fun v => averaging_energy_le H _) _ = energy f := (energy_prod f).symm theorem cloud_centered_contraction [Fintype V] [Fintype D] [Fintype E] (H : PortGraph D E) (lambda : ℝ) (hH : SpectralCertificate H lambda) (f : V × D → ℝ) (hzero : ∀ v, cloudMean f v = 0) : energy (cloudOperator H f) ≤ lambda ^ 2 * energy f := by calc energy (cloudOperator H f) = mean (fun v => energy (averagingOperator H (fun d => f (v, d)))) := energy_prod _ _ ≤ mean (fun v => lambda ^ 2 * energy (fun d => f (v, d))) := mean_mono (fun v => hH.contraction _ (hzero v)) _ = lambda ^ 2 * mean (fun v => energy (fun d => f (v, d))) := mean_mul_left _ _ _ = lambda ^ 2 * energy f := by rw [← energy_prod f] theorem cloud_residual_bound [Fintype V] [Fintype D] [Fintype E] [Nonempty D] [Nonempty E] (H : PortGraph D E) (lambda : ℝ) (hH : SpectralCertificate H lambda) (f : V × D → ℝ) : energy (cloudOperator H f - projection f) ≤ lambda ^ 2 * energy f := by rw [← cloudOperator_centered H f] exact (cloud_centered_contraction H lambda hH (centered f) (cloudMean_centered_zero f)).trans (mul_le_mul_of_nonneg_left (energy_centered_le f) (sq_nonneg lambda)) /-- Cloud projection of the outer permutation is the genuine outer graph average when its input is constant on each cloud. -/ theorem projection_graphPermutation_projection [Fintype D] (G : PortGraph V D) (f : V × D → ℝ) : projection (graphPermutation G (projection f)) = liftCloud (averagingOperator G (cloudMean f)) := rfl theorem projected_outer_bound [Fintype V] [Fintype D] [Nonempty D] (G : PortGraph V D) (lambda : ℝ) (hG : SpectralCertificate G lambda) (f : V × D → ℝ) (hf : mean f = 0) : energy (projection (graphPermutation G (projection f))) ≤ lambda ^ 2 * energy (projection f) := by have hzero : mean (cloudMean f) = 0 := (mean_cloudMean f).trans hf have hleft : energy (projection (graphPermutation G (projection f))) = energy (averagingOperator G (cloudMean f)) := by rw [projection_graphPermutation_projection] exact energy_liftCloud _ have hright : energy (projection f) = energy (cloudMean f) := energy_liftCloud _ rw [hleft, hright] exact hG.contraction _ hzero theorem energy_add_three_le {A : Type*} [Fintype A] (a b c : A → ℝ) : energy (a + b + c) ≤ 3 * (energy a + energy b + energy c) := by calc energy (a + b + c) ≤ mean (fun x => 3 * (a x ^ 2 + b x ^ 2 + c x ^ 2)) := by apply mean_mono intro x change (a x + b x + c x) ^ 2 ≤ 3 * (a x ^ 2 + b x ^ 2 + c x ^ 2) nlinarith [sq_nonneg (a x - b x), sq_nonneg (a x - c x), sq_nonneg (b x - c x)] _ = 3 * (energy a + energy b + energy c) := by rw [mean_mul_left, mean_add, mean_add] rfl /-- A deliberately loose bound sufficient for the expander iteration. -/ theorem zigzag_energy_bound [Fintype V] [Fintype D] [Fintype E] [Nonempty D] [Nonempty E] (G : PortGraph V D) (H : PortGraph D E) (lambdaG lambdaH : ℝ) (hG : SpectralCertificate G lambdaG) (hH : SpectralCertificate H lambdaH) (f : V × D → ℝ) (hf : mean f = 0) : energy (averagingOperator (zigzag G H) f) ≤ 3 * (lambdaG ^ 2 + lambdaH ^ 2) * energy f := by let u := projection f let v := centered f let a := projection (graphPermutation G u) let b := cloudOperator H (graphPermutation G u) - a let c := cloudOperator H (graphPermutation G (cloudOperator H v)) have hfactor : averagingOperator (zigzag G H) f = a + b + c := by rw [averagingOperator_zigzag] have hf' : f = u + v := by funext x change f x = projection f x + (f x - projection f x) ring have hbu : cloudOperator H u = u := cloudOperator_projection H f have hbf : cloudOperator H f = u + cloudOperator H v := by rw [hf', cloudOperator_add, hbu] rw [hbf] have hp : graphPermutation G (u + cloudOperator H v) = graphPermutation G u + graphPermutation G (cloudOperator H v) := rfl rw [hp, cloudOperator_add] change cloudOperator H (graphPermutation G u) + c = a + (cloudOperator H (graphPermutation G u) - a) + c funext x change cloudOperator H (graphPermutation G u) x + c x = a x + (cloudOperator H (graphPermutation G u) x - a x) + c x ring have ha : energy a ≤ lambdaG ^ 2 * energy u := projected_outer_bound G lambdaG hG f hf have hb : energy b ≤ lambdaH ^ 2 * energy u := by have h := cloud_residual_bound H lambdaH hH (graphPermutation G u) simpa only [graphPermutation_energy] using h have hc : energy c ≤ lambdaH ^ 2 * energy v := by calc energy c ≤ energy (graphPermutation G (cloudOperator H v)) := cloud_energy_le H _ _ = energy (cloudOperator H v) := graphPermutation_energy G _ _ ≤ lambdaH ^ 2 * energy v := cloud_centered_contraction H lambdaH hH v (cloudMean_centered_zero f) rw [hfactor] calc energy (a + b + c) ≤ 3 * (energy a + energy b + energy c) := energy_add_three_le _ _ _ _ ≤ 3 * (lambdaG ^ 2 * energy u + lambdaH ^ 2 * energy u + lambdaH ^ 2 * energy v) := mul_le_mul_of_nonneg_left (add_le_add (add_le_add ha hb) hc) (by norm_num) _ ≤ 3 * (lambdaG ^ 2 + lambdaH ^ 2) * energy f := by have hdecomp : energy f = energy u + energy v := projection_energy_decomposition f rw [hdecomp] have hn := mul_nonneg (sq_nonneg lambdaG) (energy_nonnegative v) nlinarith theorem square_certificate [Fintype V] [Fintype D] [Nonempty V] [Nonempty D] (G : PortGraph V D) (lambda : ℝ) (hG : SpectralCertificate G lambda) : SpectralCertificate (square G) (lambda ^ 2) where nonnegative := sq_nonneg lambda lt_one := by have hprod := mul_pos (sub_pos.mpr hG.lt_one) (show 0 < 1 + lambda by linarith [hG.nonnegative]) nlinarith contraction f hf := by rw [averagingOperator_square] calc energy (averagingOperator G (averagingOperator G f)) ≤ lambda ^ 2 * energy (averagingOperator G f) := hG.contraction _ ((mean_operator G f).trans hf) _ ≤ lambda ^ 2 * (lambda ^ 2 * energy f) := mul_le_mul_of_nonneg_left (hG.contraction f hf) (sq_nonneg lambda) _ = (lambda ^ 2) ^ 2 * energy f := by ring /-- Squaring an outer graph with certificate `1/2`, then zigzagging with an inner graph with certificate `1/100`, again has certificate `1/2`. -/ theorem square_zigzag_halfCertificate [Fintype V] [Fintype D] [Fintype E] [Nonempty V] [Nonempty D] [Nonempty E] (G : PortGraph V D) (H : PortGraph (D × D) E) (hG : SpectralCertificate G (1 / 2)) (hH : SpectralCertificate H (1 / 100)) : SpectralCertificate (zigzag (square G) H) (1 / 2) where nonnegative := by norm_num lt_one := by norm_num contraction f hf := by have h := zigzag_energy_bound (square G) H ((1 / 2 : ℝ) ^ 2) (1 / 100) (square_certificate G (1 / 2) hG) hH f hf have hcoef : 3 * (((1 / 2 : ℝ) ^ 2) ^ 2 + (1 / 100) ^ 2) ≤ (1 / 2 : ℝ) ^ 2 := by norm_num exact h.trans (mul_le_mul_of_nonneg_right hcoef (energy_nonnegative f)) end end MaxCutGames.Foundations.PCP.ZigzagSpectral end OAI