import Mathlib import OAI.Computability.MinUncut.Games.Sampling namespace OAI noncomputable section open scoped BigOperators namespace MinUncut.Outer open MinUncut.Inner attribute [local instance] Classical.propDecidable variable {Name I : Type*} [Fintype I] abbrev HintCoefficients (I : Type*) (q : ℕ) := Fin q → (F₂ × ((I → F₂) × (I → Module.Dual F₂ Triple))) def secondHints {q : ℕ} (V : I → SecondQuestion Name) (c : HintCoefficients I q) : Fin q → Forms (SecondAlphabet V) := fun k => hintGenerator V (c k) def firstHints {q : ℕ} (U : I → Equation Name) (hidden : I → Bool) (pos : I → Fin 3) (c : HintCoefficients I q) : Fin q → Forms (FirstAlphabet U) := fun k => formPullback (projection U hidden pos) (secondHints (secondQuestion U hidden pos) c k) structure HintedStrategy (Name I : Type*) [Fintype I] (q : ℕ) where first : (U : I → Equation Name) → (Fin q → Forms (FirstAlphabet U)) → FirstAlphabet U second : (V : I → SecondQuestion Name) → (Fin q → Forms (SecondAlphabet V)) → SecondAlphabet V def hintedWins {q : ℕ} (strategy : HintedStrategy Name I q) (U : I → Equation Name) (hidden : I → Bool) (pos : I → Fin 3) (c : HintCoefficients I q) : Prop := projection U hidden pos (strategy.first U (firstHints U hidden pos c)) = strategy.second (secondQuestion U hidden pos) (secondHints (secondQuestion U hidden pos) c) def patch {X : Type*} (A : I → Prop) (background : I → X) (active : {i // A i} → X) : I → X := fun i => if h : A i then active ⟨i,h⟩ else background i omit [Fintype I] in @[simp] lemma patch_active {X : Type*} (A : I → Prop) (background : I → X) (active : {i // A i} → X) (i : {i // A i}) : patch A background active i = active i := by simp [patch,i.property] omit [Fintype I] in @[simp] lemma patch_inactive {X : Type*} (A : I → Prop) (background : I → X) (active : {i // A i} → X) (i : I) (hi : ¬A i) : patch A background active i = background i := by simp [patch,hi] omit [Fintype I] in lemma patch_comp {X Y : Type*} (A : I → Prop) (background : I → X) (active : {i // A i} → X) (f : X → Y) : (fun i => f (patch A background active i)) = patch A (fun i => f (background i)) (fun i => f (active i)) := by funext i by_cases h : A i <;> simp [patch,h] def slotZero (v : SecondQuestion Name) : Fin (secondSlotCount v) := ⟨0,by cases v <;> exact Nat.zero_lt_succ _⟩ def readBit (V : I → SecondQuestion Name) (a : SecondAlphabet V) (i : I) : F₂ := a i (slotZero (V i)) omit [Fintype I] in lemma projection_hidden_bit (U : I → Equation Name) (hidden : I → Bool) (pos : I → Fin 3) (a : FirstAlphabet U) (i : I) (hi : hidden i=true) : readBit (secondQuestion U hidden pos) (projection U hidden pos a) i=(a i).val (pos i) := by change (slotProjection (U i) (hidden i) (pos i) (a i)) (slotZero (slotQuestion (U i) (hidden i) (pos i)))=_ rw [hi] rfl lemma firstHints_position_independent {q : ℕ} (U : I → Equation Name) (hidden : I → Bool) (pos pos' : I → Fin 3) (c : HintCoefficients I q) (h : ∀ k j, hidden j=true → pos j≠pos' j → (c k).2.1 j=0) : firstHints U hidden pos c=firstHints U hidden pos' c := by funext k exact pulledHint_independent_active U hidden pos pos' _ _ _ (h k) lemma ordinary_accepts_of_valid_coordinate (E : Equation Name) (a : alphabet E) (p : Fin 3) (b : F₂) (he : a.val p=b) : ordinaryAccepts E (E.names p) a.val b=true := by apply decide_eq_true refine ⟨a.property,?_⟩ intro p' hp' exact (a.property.2 p' p hp').trans he omit [Fintype I] in lemma secondQuestion_patch (A : I → Prop) (hidden : I → Bool) (hA : ∀ i, A i → hidden i=true) (bgU : I → Equation Name) (bgp : I → Fin 3) (U : {i // A i} → Equation Name) (p : {i // A i} → Fin 3) : secondQuestion (patch A bgU U) hidden (patch A bgp p) = patch A (secondQuestion bgU hidden bgp) (fun i => Sum.inl ((U i).names (p i))) := by funext i by_cases hi : A i · simp [patch,secondQuestion,slotQuestion,hA i hi,hi] · simp [patch,secondQuestion,hi] end MinUncut.Outer namespace MinUncut.Outer open MinUncut.Inner attribute [local instance] Classical.propDecidable variable {Name I : Type*} [Fintype I] theorem active_simulation {q : ℕ} (strategy : HintedStrategy Name I q) (A : I → Prop) (hidden : I → Bool) (hA : ∀ i, A i → hidden i=true) (c : HintCoefficients I q) (hzero : ∀ k i, A i → (c k).2.1 i=0) (bgU : I → Equation Name) (bgp : I → Fin 3) : ∃ (a : ({i // A i} → Equation Name) → {i // A i} → Triple) (b : ({i // A i} → Name) → {i // A i} → F₂), ∀ (U : {i // A i} → Equation Name) (p : {i // A i} → Fin 3), hintedWins strategy (patch A bgU U) hidden (patch A bgp p) c → ∀ j, ordinaryAccepts (U j) ((U j).names (p j)) (a U j) (b (fun i => (U i).names (p i)) j)=true := by classical let p₀ : I → Fin 3 := patch A bgp (fun _ => 0) let first (U : {i // A i} → Equation Name) : FirstAlphabet (patch A bgU U) := strategy.first (patch A bgU U) (firstHints (patch A bgU U) hidden p₀ c) let V (y : {i // A i} → Name) : I → SecondQuestion Name := patch A (secondQuestion bgU hidden bgp) (fun i => Sum.inl (y i)) let second (y : {i // A i} → Name) : SecondAlphabet (V y) := strategy.second (V y) (secondHints (V y) c) let a := fun U (j : {i // A i}) => (first U j).val let b := fun y (j : {i // A i}) => readBit (V y) (second y) j refine ⟨a,b,?_⟩ intro U p hwin j have hints : firstHints (patch A bgU U) hidden (patch A bgp p) c = firstHints (patch A bgU U) hidden p₀ c := by apply firstHints_position_independent intro k i _ hdiff apply hzero k i by_contra hi exact hdiff (by simp [p₀,patch,hi]) have hv : secondQuestion (patch A bgU U) hidden (patch A bgp p) = V (fun i => (U i).names (p i)) := secondQuestion_patch A hidden hA bgU bgp U p unfold hintedWins at hwin rw [hints] at hwin have hb := congrArg (fun z => readBit (secondQuestion (patch A bgU U) hidden (patch A bgp p)) z j) hwin rw [projection_hidden_bit _ _ _ _ _ (hA j j.property)] at hb have hcoord : a U j (p j)=b (fun i => (U i).names (p i)) j := by simp only [patch_active] at hb rw [hv] at hb exact hb have hvalid : Valid (U j) (a U j) := by have hv' : Valid (patch A bgU U j) (a U j) := (first U j).property simpa only [patch_active] using hv' apply decide_eq_true refine ⟨hvalid,?_⟩ intro p' hp' exact (hvalid.2 p' (p j) hp').trans hcoord end MinUncut.Outer end end OAI