import OAI.Computability.PerfectCompleteness.Foundations.TupleIndexEmitterLemmas import OAI.Computability.PerfectCompleteness.Reduction.CompletionSoundness import OAI.Computability.UniqueGames.Games.FinishBoundsLemmas namespace OAI namespace PerfectCompleteness.DependentPredictionDifference noncomputable section open scoped Classical open UniqueGamesTheorem.Foundations.Games variable {O : Type*} abbrev Sample (Ω A : O → Type*) := (o : O) × (Ω o × A o) abbrev Observation (P A : O → Type*) := (o : O) × (P o × A o) variable [Fintype O] {Ω P A : O → Type*} [∀ o, Fintype (Ω o)] [∀ o, Fintype (P o)] [∀ o, Fintype (A o)] def law (outer : FiniteDistribution O) (original : ∀ o, FiniteDistribution (Ω o)) (advice : ∀ o, FiniteDistribution (A o)) : FiniteDistribution (Sample Ω A) := CompletionSoundness.sigmaLaw outer (fun o => (original o).product (advice o)) def observe (p : ∀ o, Ω o → P o) (x : Sample Ω A) : Observation P A := ⟨x.1, (p x.1 x.2.1, x.2.2)⟩ theorem original_usefulness_predicts (outer : FiniteDistribution O) (original : ∀ o, FiniteDistribution (Ω o)) (advice : ∀ o, FiniteDistribution (A o)) (p : ∀ o, Ω o → P o) (lower : ∀ o, Ω o → Bool) (I : Observation P A → Bool) (prediction : Sample Ω A → Bool) (κ : ℝ) (hmarked : ∀ o z a, I ⟨o, (z, a)⟩ = true → UsefulMark.useful (original o) (p o) (lower o) κ z = true) (hprediction : ∀ o x a, lower o x = true → I ⟨o, (p o x, a)⟩ = true → prediction ⟨o, (x, a)⟩ = true) : κ * (law outer original advice).probability (fun x => I (observe p x)) ≤ (law outer original advice).probability prediction := by unfold law rw [CompletionSoundness.sigmaLaw_probability, CompletionSoundness.sigmaLaw_probability, ← SmallBiasSlice.expectation_const_mul] apply SmallBias.expectation_mono intro o exact UsefulAdvice.independent_advice_predicts (original o) (advice o) (p o) (lower o) κ (fun z => I ⟨o, z⟩) (fun x => prediction ⟨o, x⟩) (hmarked o) (hprediction o) theorem of_original_usefulness {Γ : Type*} [Fintype Γ] (outer : FiniteDistribution O) (original : ∀ o, FiniteDistribution (Ω o)) (advice : ∀ o, FiniteDistribution (A o)) (reference : FiniteDistribution Γ) (p : ∀ o, Ω o → P o) (referenceObserve : Γ → Observation P A) (lower : ∀ o, Ω o → Bool) (I J : Observation P A → Bool) (prediction : Sample Ω A → Bool) (κ ρ q₀ v : ℝ) (hκ : 0 ≤ κ) (hρ : 0 ≤ ρ) (hρ1 : ρ ≤ 1) (hq₀ : 0 ≤ q₀) (hv : 0 ≤ v) (hsmall : v ≤ ρ * q₀ / 16) (hmarked : ∀ o z a, I ⟨o, (z, a)⟩ = true → UsefulMark.useful (original o) (p o) (lower o) κ z = true) (hprediction : ∀ o x a, lower o x = true → I ⟨o, (p o x, a)⟩ = true → prediction ⟨o, (x, a)⟩ = true) (hvariation : ((law outer original advice).pushforward (observe p)).totalVariation (reference.pushforward referenceObserve) ≤ v) (hmass : q₀ ≤ reference.probability (fun x => J (referenceObserve x))) (hdensity : ρ * reference.probability (fun x => J (referenceObserve x)) ≤ reference.probability (fun x => I (referenceObserve x))) : κ * ρ * q₀ / 4 ≤ (law outer original advice).probability prediction - (κ * ρ / 4) * (law outer original advice).probability (fun x => J (observe p x)) := by apply PredictionDifference.of_observed_variation (law outer original advice) reference (observe p) referenceObserve I J prediction κ ρ q₀ v hκ hρ hρ1 hq₀ hv hsmall hvariation hmass hdensity exact original_usefulness_predicts outer original advice p lower I prediction κ hmarked hprediction end end PerfectCompleteness.DependentPredictionDifference namespace PerfectCompleteness.LegalEnumeration open scoped Classical open UniqueGamesTheorem.Foundations.Games CompletionSoundness noncomputable section section Reindex variable {E E' Q₁ Q₂ Q₁' Q₂' : Type*} {L : Q₁ → Type*} {R : Q₂ → Type*} {L' : Q₁' → Type*} {R' : Q₂' → Type*} [Fintype E] [Fintype E'] (G : LegalProjectionGame E Q₁ Q₂ L R) (ee : E ≃ E') (el : Q₁ ≃ Q₁') (er : Q₂ ≃ Q₂') (al : ∀ x, L x ≃ L' (el x)) (ar : ∀ y, R y ≃ R' (er y)) def reindex : LegalProjectionGame E' Q₁' Q₂' L' R' where occurrences := G.occurrences.transport ee left i := el (G.left (ee.symm i)) right i := er (G.right (ee.symm i)) projection i a := ar (G.right (ee.symm i)) (G.projection (ee.symm i) ((al (G.left (ee.symm i))).symm a)) def strategies : LegalStrategy L R ≃ LegalStrategy L' R' := (el.piCongr al).prodCongr (er.piCongr ar) theorem reindex_wins (s : LegalStrategy L R) (e : E) : (reindex G ee el er al ar).wins (strategies el er al ar s) (ee e) = G.wins s e := by simp only [LegalProjectionGame.wins, reindex] apply decide_eq_decide.mpr change ar (G.right (ee.symm (ee e))) (G.projection (ee.symm (ee e)) ((al (G.left (ee.symm (ee e)))).symm ((el.piCongr al) s.1 (el (G.left (ee.symm (ee e))))))) = (er.piCongr ar) s.2 (er (G.right (ee.symm (ee e)))) ↔ G.projection e (s.1 (G.left e)) = s.2 (G.right e) rw [ee.symm_apply_apply e] rw [Equiv.piCongr_apply_apply, Equiv.piCongr_apply_apply, Equiv.symm_apply_apply] exact (ar (G.right e)).injective.eq_iff theorem reindex_success (s : LegalStrategy L R) : (reindex G ee el er al ar).success (strategies el er al ar s) = G.success s := by unfold LegalProjectionGame.success change (G.occurrences.transport ee).probability _ = _ rw [FiniteDistribution.probability_transport] congr 1 funext e exact reindex_wins G ee el er al ar s e section Fibers variable [∀ x, Fintype (L x)] [∀ x, Fintype (L' x)] theorem reindex_fiber_card (i : E') (b : R' ((reindex G ee el er al ar).right i)) : Fintype.card {a : L' ((reindex G ee el er al ar).left i) // (reindex G ee el er al ar).projection i a = b} = Fintype.card {a : L (G.left (ee.symm i)) // G.projection (ee.symm i) a = (ar (G.right (ee.symm i))).symm b} := by apply Fintype.card_congr apply (al (G.left (ee.symm i))).symm.subtypeEquiv intro a change ar (G.right (ee.symm i)) (G.projection (ee.symm i) ((al (G.left (ee.symm i))).symm a)) = b ↔ _ constructor · intro h have h' := congrArg (ar (G.right (ee.symm i))).symm h simpa only [Equiv.symm_apply_apply] using h' · intro h have h' := congrArg (ar (G.right (ee.symm i))) h exact h'.trans ((ar (G.right (ee.symm i))).apply_symm_apply b) theorem reindex_at_most_two (hsmall : ∀ e b, Fintype.card {a : L (G.left e) // G.projection e a = b} ≤ 2) (i : E') (b : R' ((reindex G ee el er al ar).right i)) : Fintype.card {a : L' ((reindex G ee el er al ar).left i) // (reindex G ee el er al ar).projection i a = b} ≤ 2 := by rw [reindex_fiber_card] exact hsmall _ _ end Fibers variable [Fintype Q₁] [Fintype Q₂] [Fintype Q₁'] [Fintype Q₂'] [∀ x, Fintype (L x)] [∀ y, Fintype (R y)] [∀ x, Fintype (L' x)] [∀ y, Fintype (R' y)] [∀ x, Nonempty (L x)] [∀ y, Nonempty (R y)] [∀ x, Nonempty (L' x)] [∀ y, Nonempty (R' y)] theorem reindex_value : (reindex G ee el er al ar).value = G.value := by apply le_antisymm · obtain ⟨s, hs⟩ := (reindex G ee el er al ar).exists_optimal_strategy have h := reindex_success G ee el er al ar ((strategies el er al ar).symm s) rw [Equiv.apply_symm_apply] at h rw [← hs, h] exact G.success_le_value _ · obtain ⟨s, hs⟩ := G.exists_optimal_strategy rw [← hs, ← reindex_success G ee el er al ar s] exact (reindex G ee el er al ar).success_le_value _ end Reindex variable {E Q₁ Q₂ : Type*} [Fintype E] [Fintype Q₁] [Fintype Q₂] {L : Q₁ → Type*} {R : Q₂ → Type*} abbrev NumberedLabels (P : Q₁ → Type*) (i : Fin (Fintype.card Q₁)) := P ((Fintype.equivFin Q₁).symm i) def numberedLabelEquiv (P : Q₁ → Type*) (x : Q₁) : P x ≃ NumberedLabels P (Fintype.equivFin Q₁ x) := Equiv.cast (congrArg P ((Fintype.equivFin Q₁).symm_apply_apply x).symm) def numbered (G : LegalProjectionGame E Q₁ Q₂ L R) : LegalProjectionGame (Fin (Fintype.card E)) (Fin (Fintype.card Q₁)) (Fin (Fintype.card Q₂)) (NumberedLabels L) (NumberedLabels R) := reindex G (Fintype.equivFin E) (Fintype.equivFin Q₁) (Fintype.equivFin Q₂) (numberedLabelEquiv L) (numberedLabelEquiv R) theorem numbered_at_most_two [∀ x, Fintype (L x)] (G : LegalProjectionGame E Q₁ Q₂ L R) (hsmall : ∀ e b, Fintype.card {a : L (G.left e) // G.projection e a = b} ≤ 2) (i : Fin (Fintype.card E)) (b : NumberedLabels R ((numbered G).right i)) : Fintype.card {a : NumberedLabels L ((numbered G).left i) // (numbered G).projection i a = b} ≤ 2 := reindex_at_most_two G (Fintype.equivFin E) (Fintype.equivFin Q₁) (Fintype.equivFin Q₂) (numberedLabelEquiv L) (numberedLabelEquiv R) hsmall i b theorem numbered_value [∀ x, Fintype (L x)] [∀ y, Fintype (R y)] [∀ x, Nonempty (L x)] [∀ y, Nonempty (R y)] (G : LegalProjectionGame E Q₁ Q₂ L R) : (numbered G).value = G.value := reindex_value G (Fintype.equivFin E) (Fintype.equivFin Q₁) (Fintype.equivFin Q₂) (numberedLabelEquiv L) (numberedLabelEquiv R) end end PerfectCompleteness.LegalEnumeration namespace PerfectCompleteness.SigmaObservation open UniqueGamesTheorem.Foundations.Games CompletionSoundness noncomputable section theorem eq_of_probability_eq {X : Type*} [Fintype X] (μ ν : FiniteDistribution X) (h : ∀ event : X → Bool, μ.probability event = ν.probability event) : μ = ν := by classical apply FiniteDistribution.eq_of_weight_eq intro x simpa [FiniteDistribution.probability] using h (fun y => decide (y = x)) theorem pushforward_fiber {S : Type*} [Fintype S] {X Y : S → Type*} [∀ s, Fintype (X s)] [∀ s, Fintype (Y s)] (μ : FiniteDistribution S) (P : (s : S) → FiniteDistribution (X s)) (f : (s : S) → X s → Y s) : (sigmaLaw μ P).pushforward (fun x => (⟨x.1, f x.1 x.2⟩ : Σ s, Y s)) = sigmaLaw μ (fun s => (P s).pushforward (f s)) := by apply eq_of_probability_eq intro event rw [FiniteDistribution.probability_pushforward, sigmaLaw_probability, sigmaLaw_probability] apply FiniteDistribution.expectation_congr intro s rw [FiniteDistribution.probability_pushforward] end end PerfectCompleteness.SigmaObservation end OAI