import OAI.Computability.StarHeight.Height namespace OAI namespace GeneralizedStarHeight universe u universe uS namespace EpisodeAlgebra open scoped Computability variable {Alphabet : Type u} {S : Type uS} def PrefixCode (E : Language Alphabet) : Prop := [] ∉ E ∧ ∀ e ∈ E, ∀ f ∈ E, e <+: f → e = f def AllIn (D : Language Alphabet) (es : List (List Alphabet)) : Prop := ∀ e ∈ es, e ∈ D def updateWord (G : List Alphabet → S → S) (x : S) (es : List (List Alphabet)) : S := es.foldl (fun z e => G e z) x def graph (D : Language Alphabet) (G : List Alphabet → S → S) (x y : S) : Language Alphabet := {w | ∃ es, AllIn D es ∧ es.flatten = w ∧ updateWord G x es = y} lemma AllIn.mono {D E : Language Alphabet} {es : List (List Alphabet)} (h : AllIn D es) (hDE : D ≤ E) : AllIn E es := fun e he => hDE (h e he) lemma AllIn.append {D : Language Alphabet} {es fs : List (List Alphabet)} (he : AllIn D es) (hf : AllIn D fs) : AllIn D (es ++ fs) := by intro e hm rcases List.mem_append.mp hm with hm | hm · exact he e hm · exact hf e hm lemma AllIn.of_append_right {D : Language Alphabet} {es fs : List (List Alphabet)} (h : AllIn D (es ++ fs)) : AllIn D fs := fun e he => h e (List.mem_append_right _ he) @[simp] lemma updateWord_nil (G : List Alphabet → S → S) (x : S) : updateWord G x [] = x := rfl @[simp] lemma updateWord_cons (G : List Alphabet → S → S) (x : S) (e : List Alphabet) (es : List (List Alphabet)) : updateWord G x (e :: es) = updateWord G (G e x) es := rfl lemma updateWord_append (G : List Alphabet → S → S) (x : S) (es fs : List (List Alphabet)) : updateWord G x (es ++ fs) = updateWord G (updateWord G x es) fs := List.foldl_append lemma graph_nil (D : Language Alphabet) (G : List Alphabet → S → S) (x : S) : [] ∈ graph D G x x := ⟨[], by simp [AllIn], rfl, rfl⟩ lemma graph_singleton {D : Language Alphabet} (G : List Alphabet → S → S) (x : S) {e : List Alphabet} (he : e ∈ D) : e ∈ graph D G x (G e x) := ⟨[e], by simpa [AllIn], by simp, rfl⟩ lemma graph_mono {D E : Language Alphabet} (hDE : D ≤ E) (G : List Alphabet → S → S) (x y : S) : graph D G x y ≤ graph E G x y := by rintro w ⟨es, he, hw, hx⟩ exact ⟨es, he.mono hDE, hw, hx⟩ lemma graph_concat {D : Language Alphabet} {G : List Alphabet → S → S} {x y z : S} {u v : List Alphabet} (hu : u ∈ graph D G x y) (hv : v ∈ graph D G y z) : u ++ v ∈ graph D G x z := by obtain ⟨es, he, rfl, hx⟩ := hu obtain ⟨fs, hf, rfl, hy⟩ := hv exact ⟨es ++ fs, he.append hf, List.flatten_append, by rw [updateWord_append, hx, hy]⟩ lemma flatten_prefix {E : Language Alphabet} (hE : PrefixCode E) {es fs : List (List Alphabet)} (he : AllIn E es) (hf : AllIn E fs) (hp : es.flatten <+: fs.flatten) : es <+: fs := by induction es generalizing fs with | nil => exact List.nil_prefix | cons e es ih => have heE : e ∈ E := he e (by simp) cases fs with | nil => obtain ⟨r, hr⟩ := hp have he0 : e = [] := by have hh : e ++ (es.flatten ++ r) = [] := by simpa [List.append_assoc] using hr exact (List.append_eq_nil_iff.mp hh).1 exact False.elim (hE.1 (he0 ▸ heE)) | cons f fs => have hfE : f ∈ E := hf f (by simp) have hePre : e <+: (f :: fs).flatten := (List.prefix_append e es.flatten).trans hp have hfPre : f <+: (f :: fs).flatten := List.prefix_append _ _ have hef : e = f := by rcases List.prefix_or_prefix_of_prefix hePre hfPre with h | h · exact hE.2 e heE f hfE h · exact (hE.2 f hfE e heE h).symm subst f obtain ⟨r, hr⟩ := hp have htail : es.flatten ++ r = fs.flatten := by apply List.append_cancel_left (as := e) simpa only [List.flatten_cons, List.append_assoc] using hr have hrec := ih (fun a ha => he a (by simp [ha])) (fun a ha => hf a (by simp [ha])) ⟨r, htail⟩ obtain ⟨gs, hgs⟩ := hrec exact ⟨gs, by simp [hgs]⟩ lemma consume_graph_prefix {E D D' : Language Alphabet} (hE : PrefixCode E) (hDE : D ≤ E) (hD'D : D' ≤ D) {G : List Alphabet → S → S} {x z : S} {u v : List Alphabet} {es : List (List Alphabet)} (hu : u ∈ graph D' G x z) (hes : AllIn D es) (hword : u ++ v = es.flatten) : ∃ fs, AllIn D fs ∧ fs.flatten = v ∧ updateWord G x es = updateWord G z fs := by obtain ⟨pre, hp, hu, hx⟩ := hu have hpre := flatten_prefix hE (hp.mono (hD'D.trans hDE)) (hes.mono hDE) (show pre.flatten <+: es.flatten from ⟨v, by rw [hu, hword]⟩) obtain ⟨fs, rfl⟩ := hpre refine ⟨fs, hes.of_append_right, ?_, ?_⟩ · apply List.append_cancel_left (as := u) simpa only [List.flatten_append, hu] using hword.symm · rw [updateWord_append, hx] lemma flatten_injective {E : Language Alphabet} (hE : PrefixCode E) {es fs : List (List Alphabet)} (he : AllIn E es) (hf : AllIn E fs) (h : es.flatten = fs.flatten) : es = fs := by have hp := flatten_prefix hE he hf (h ▸ List.prefix_rfl) have hq := flatten_prefix hE hf he (h.symm ▸ List.prefix_rfl) exact hp.sublist.antisymm hq.sublist lemma graph_iff_update {E D : Language Alphabet} (hE : PrefixCode E) (hDE : D ≤ E) (G : List Alphabet → S → S) (x y : S) {es : List (List Alphabet)} (he : AllIn D es) : es.flatten ∈ graph D G x y ↔ updateWord G x es = y := by constructor · rintro ⟨fs, hf, hw, hx⟩ have hfs := flatten_injective hE (hf.mono hDE) (he.mono hDE) hw simpa only [hfs] using hx · exact fun hx => ⟨es, he, rfl, hx⟩ def SplitSound (D : Language Alphabet) (G : List Alphabet → S → S) (P Q : S → Language Alphabet) : Prop := ∀ (x y : S) (es : List (List Alphabet)) (u v : List Alphabet), AllIn D es → u ∈ P x → v ∈ Q y → u ++ v <+: es.flatten → ∃ e fs, es = e :: fs ∧ u ++ v = e ∧ G e x = y def SplitAvailable (D D' : Language Alphabet) (G : List Alphabet → S → S) (P Q : S → Language Alphabet) : Prop := ∀ e ∈ D, e ∉ D' → ∀ x, e ∈ P x * Q (G e x) lemma consume_pair_prefix {D : Language Alphabet} {G : List Alphabet → S → S} {P Q : S → Language Alphabet} (hs : SplitSound D G P Q) {x y : S} {u v r : List Alphabet} {es : List (List Alphabet)} (he : AllIn D es) (hu : u ∈ P x) (hv : v ∈ Q y) (hw : (u ++ v) ++ r = es.flatten) : ∃ fs, AllIn D fs ∧ fs.flatten = r ∧ updateWord G x es = updateWord G y fs := by obtain ⟨e, fs, rfl, huv, hxy⟩ := hs x y es u v he hu hv ⟨r, hw⟩ refine ⟨fs, fun a ha => he a (by simp [ha]), ?_, ?_⟩ · apply List.append_cancel_left (as := e) simpa only [List.flatten_cons, huv] using hw.symm · simp only [updateWord_cons, hxy] def start (W : S → S → Language Alphabet) (P : S → Language Alphabet) (x : S) := ⨆ i, W x i * P i def middle (W : S → S → Language Alphabet) (P Q : S → Language Alphabet) := ⨆ j, ⨆ i, Q j * W j i * P i def finish (W : S → S → Language Alphabet) (Q : S → Language Alphabet) (y : S) := ⨆ l, Q l * W l y def body (W : S → S → Language Alphabet) (P Q : S → Language Alphabet) (x y : S) := W x y + start W P x * (middle W P Q)∗ * finish W Q y lemma mem_start_iff {W : S → S → Language Alphabet} {P : S → Language Alphabet} {x : S} {w : List Alphabet} : w ∈ start W P x ↔ ∃ i u v, u ∈ W x i ∧ v ∈ P i ∧ u ++ v = w := by simp only [start, Language.mem_iSup, Language.mem_mul] aesop lemma mem_middle_iff {W : S → S → Language Alphabet} {P Q : S → Language Alphabet} {w : List Alphabet} : w ∈ middle W P Q ↔ ∃ j i u v p, u ∈ Q j ∧ v ∈ W j i ∧ p ∈ P i ∧ (u ++ v) ++ p = w := by simp only [middle, Language.mem_iSup, Language.mem_mul] constructor · rintro ⟨j, i, a, ⟨u, hu, v, hv, rfl⟩, p, hp, rfl⟩ exact ⟨j, i, u, v, p, hu, hv, hp, rfl⟩ · rintro ⟨j, i, u, v, p, hu, hv, hp, rfl⟩ exact ⟨j, i, u ++ v, ⟨u, hu, v, hv, rfl⟩, p, hp, rfl⟩ lemma mem_finish_iff {W : S → S → Language Alphabet} {Q : S → Language Alphabet} {y : S} {w : List Alphabet} : w ∈ finish W Q y ↔ ∃ j u v, u ∈ Q j ∧ v ∈ W j y ∧ u ++ v = w := by simp only [finish, Language.mem_iSup, Language.mem_mul] aesop lemma mem_body_iff {W : S → S → Language Alphabet} {P Q : S → Language Alphabet} {x y : S} {w : List Alphabet} : w ∈ body W P Q x y ↔ w ∈ W x y ∨ ∃ a ms b, a ∈ start W P x ∧ AllIn (middle W P Q) ms ∧ b ∈ finish W Q y ∧ (a ++ ms.flatten) ++ b = w := by simp only [body, Language.mem_add, Language.mem_mul, Language.mem_kstar] constructor · rintro (h | ⟨c, ⟨a, ha, m, ⟨ms, rfl, hm⟩, rfl⟩, b, hb, rfl⟩) · exact Or.inl h · exact Or.inr ⟨a, ms, b, ha, hm, hb, rfl⟩ · rintro (h | ⟨a, ms, b, ha, hm, hb, rfl⟩) · exact Or.inl h · exact Or.inr ⟨a ++ ms.flatten, ⟨a, ha, ms.flatten, ⟨ms, rfl, hm⟩, rfl⟩, b, hb, rfl⟩ lemma suffix_sound {E D D' : Language Alphabet} (hE : PrefixCode E) (hDE : D ≤ E) (hD'D : D' ≤ D) {G : List Alphabet → S → S} {P Q : S → Language Alphabet} (hs : SplitSound D G P Q) (ms : List (List Alphabet)) (hm : AllIn (middle (graph D' G) P Q) ms) {x y : S} {p b : List Alphabet} {es : List (List Alphabet)} (hp : p ∈ P x) (hb : b ∈ finish (graph D' G) Q y) (he : AllIn D es) (hw : (p ++ ms.flatten) ++ b = es.flatten) : updateWord G x es = y := by induction ms generalizing x p es with | nil => obtain ⟨j, q, w, hq, hwg, rfl⟩ := mem_finish_iff.mp hb have hw' : (p ++ q) ++ w = es.flatten := by simpa [List.append_assoc] using hw obtain ⟨fs, hf, hfw, hxy⟩ := consume_pair_prefix hs he hp hq hw' rw [hxy] apply (graph_iff_update hE hDE G j y hf).mp rw [hfw] exact graph_mono hD'D G j y hwg | cons m ms ih => obtain ⟨j, i, q, w, p', hq, hwg, hp', rfl⟩ := mem_middle_iff.mp (hm m (by simp)) have hw' : (p ++ q) ++ (w ++ ((p' ++ ms.flatten) ++ b)) = es.flatten := by simpa only [List.flatten_cons, List.append_assoc] using hw obtain ⟨fs, hf, hfw, hxy⟩ := consume_pair_prefix hs he hp hq hw' obtain ⟨gs, hg, hgw, hj⟩ := consume_graph_prefix hE hDE hD'D hwg hf hfw.symm rw [hxy, hj] exact ih (fun a ha => hm a (by simp [ha])) hp' hg hgw.symm lemma body_sound {E D D' : Language Alphabet} (hE : PrefixCode E) (hDE : D ≤ E) (hD'D : D' ≤ D) {G : List Alphabet → S → S} {P Q : S → Language Alphabet} (hs : SplitSound D G P Q) {x y : S} {es : List (List Alphabet)} (he : AllIn D es) (hb : es.flatten ∈ body (graph D' G) P Q x y) : updateWord G x es = y := by rcases mem_body_iff.mp hb with hw | ⟨a, ms, b, ha, hm, hb, hword⟩ · exact (graph_iff_update hE hDE G x y he).mp (graph_mono hD'D G x y hw) · obtain ⟨i, w, p, hw, hp, rfl⟩ := mem_start_iff.mp ha have hword' : w ++ ((p ++ ms.flatten) ++ b) = es.flatten := by simpa only [List.append_assoc] using hword obtain ⟨fs, hf, hfw, hxy⟩ := consume_graph_prefix hE hDE hD'D hw he hword' rw [hxy] exact suffix_sound hE hDE hD'D hs ms hm hp hb hf hfw.symm lemma body_prepend_skip {D' : Language Alphabet} {G : List Alphabet → S → S} {P Q : S → Language Alphabet} {x z y : S} {u v : List Alphabet} (hu : u ∈ graph D' G x z) (hv : v ∈ body (graph D' G) P Q z y) : u ++ v ∈ body (graph D' G) P Q x y := by apply mem_body_iff.mpr rcases mem_body_iff.mp hv with hv | ⟨a, ms, b, ha, hm, hb, rfl⟩ · exact Or.inl (graph_concat hu hv) · obtain ⟨i, w, p, hw, hp, rfl⟩ := mem_start_iff.mp ha apply Or.inr refine ⟨(u ++ w) ++ p, ms, b, ?_, hm, hb, ?_⟩ · exact mem_start_iff.mpr ⟨i, u ++ w, p, graph_concat hu hw, hp, rfl⟩ · simp only [List.append_assoc] lemma body_prepend_pair {D' : Language Alphabet} {G : List Alphabet → S → S} {P Q : S → Language Alphabet} {x z y : S} {p q v : List Alphabet} (hp : p ∈ P x) (hq : q ∈ Q z) (hv : v ∈ body (graph D' G) P Q z y) : (p ++ q) ++ v ∈ body (graph D' G) P Q x y := by have hstart : p ∈ start (graph D' G) P x := mem_start_iff.mpr ⟨x, [], p, graph_nil D' G x, hp, by simp⟩ apply mem_body_iff.mpr rcases mem_body_iff.mp hv with hv | ⟨a, ms, b, ha, hm, hb, rfl⟩ · refine Or.inr ⟨p, [], q ++ v, hstart, by simp [AllIn], ?_, ?_⟩ · exact mem_finish_iff.mpr ⟨z, q, v, hq, hv, rfl⟩ · simp [List.append_assoc] · obtain ⟨i, w, r, hw, hr, rfl⟩ := mem_start_iff.mp ha have hmid : (q ++ w) ++ r ∈ middle (graph D' G) P Q := mem_middle_iff.mpr ⟨z, i, q, w, r, hq, hw, hr, rfl⟩ refine Or.inr ⟨p, ((q ++ w) ++ r) :: ms, b, hstart, ?_, hb, ?_⟩ · intro a ha rcases List.mem_cons.mp ha with rfl | ha · exact hmid · exact hm a ha · simp only [List.flatten_cons, List.append_assoc] lemma body_available {D D' : Language Alphabet} {G : List Alphabet → S → S} {P Q : S → Language Alphabet} (ha : SplitAvailable D D' G P Q) (es : List (List Alphabet)) (he : AllIn D es) (x : S) : es.flatten ∈ body (graph D' G) P Q x (updateWord G x es) := by classical induction es generalizing x with | nil => exact mem_body_iff.mpr (Or.inl (graph_nil D' G x)) | cons e es ih => have heD := he e (by simp) have hes : AllIn D es := fun a ha => he a (by simp [ha]) have hind := ih hes (G e x) by_cases he' : e ∈ D' · exact body_prepend_skip (graph_singleton G x he') hind · obtain ⟨p, hp, q, hq, heq⟩ := Language.mem_mul.mp (ha e heD he' x) simpa only [heq, List.flatten_cons, updateWord_cons] using body_prepend_pair hp hq hind theorem split_identity {E D D' : Language Alphabet} (hE : PrefixCode E) (hDE : D ≤ E) (hD'D : D' ≤ D) (G : List Alphabet → S → S) (P Q : S → Language Alphabet) (hs : SplitSound D G P Q) (ha : SplitAvailable D D' G P Q) (x y : S) : graph D G x y = D∗ ⊓ body (graph D' G) P Q x y := by ext w constructor · rintro ⟨es, he, rfl, rfl⟩ exact ⟨Language.join_mem_kstar he, body_available ha es he x⟩ · rintro ⟨⟨es, rfl, he⟩, hb⟩ exact ⟨es, he, rfl, body_sound hE hDE hD'D hs he hb⟩ theorem split_height [Finite S] {E D D' : Language Alphabet} (hE : PrefixCode E) (hDE : D ≤ E) (hD'D : D' ≤ D) (G : List Alphabet → S → S) (P Q : S → Language Alphabet) (hs : SplitSound D G P Q) (ha : SplitAvailable D D' G P Q) (H : ℕ) (hD : HasHeightAtMost D 1) (hP : ∀ x, HasHeightAtMost (P x) 1) (hQ : ∀ y, HasHeightAtMost (Q y) 1) (hW : ∀ x y, HasHeightAtMost (graph D' G x y) H) (x y : S) : HasHeightAtMost (graph D G x y) (max 2 (1 + H)) := by rw [split_identity hE hDE hD'D G P Q hs ha] have hH : H ≤ max 2 (1 + H) := by omega have h1 : 1 ≤ max 1 H := le_max_left _ _ have hh : H ≤ max 1 H := le_max_right _ _ have hm : max 1 H ≤ max 2 (1 + H) := by omega have hstar : 1 + max 1 H ≤ max 2 (1 + H) := by omega apply (hD.star.mono (le_max_left _ _)).inter apply (hW x y |>.mono hH).union apply HasHeightAtMost.concat · apply HasHeightAtMost.concat · exact (HasHeightAtMost.iSup _ (fun i => (hW x i |>.mono hh).concat (hP i |>.mono h1))).mono hm · exact (HasHeightAtMost.iSup _ (fun j => HasHeightAtMost.iSup _ (fun i => ((hQ j |>.mono h1).concat (hW j i |>.mono hh)).concat (hP i |>.mono h1)))).star.mono hstar · exact (HasHeightAtMost.iSup _ (fun l => (hQ l |>.mono h1).concat (hW l y |>.mono hh))).mono hm lemma graph_empty [DecidableEq S] (G : List Alphabet → S → S) (x y : S) : graph (0 : Language Alphabet) G x y = if x = y then 1 else 0 := by classical ext w by_cases h : x = y · subst y simp only [ite_true, Language.mem_one] constructor · rintro ⟨es, he, rfl, _⟩ have hes : es = [] := by cases es with | nil => rfl | cons e es => exact False.elim (he e (by simp)) simp [hes] · rintro rfl exact graph_nil 0 G x · simp only [h, ite_false, Language.notMem_zero, iff_false] rintro ⟨es, he, _, hu⟩ have hes : es = [] := by cases es with | nil => rfl | cons e es => exact False.elim (he e (by simp)) exact h (by simpa [hes] using hu) lemma empty_skip_height (G : List Alphabet → S → S) (x y : S) : HasHeightAtMost (graph (0 : Language Alphabet) G x y) 0 := by classical rw [graph_empty] split · exact HasHeightAtMost.one 0 · exact HasHeightAtMost.zero 0 end EpisodeAlgebra end GeneralizedStarHeight end OAI