import OAI.Computability.WeisfeilerLeman.Circuits namespace OAI universe uJ namespace WLTime structure OneTape where states : ℕ symbols : ℕ states_ge : 3 ≤ states symbols_ge : 3 ≤ symbols transition : Fin states → Fin symbols → Fin states × Fin symbols × Move namespace OneTape variable (M : OneTape) open scoped Classical abbrev Cell := Fin M.symbols × Option (Fin M.states) def action (q : Fin M.states) (s : Fin M.symbols) : Fin M.states × Fin M.symbols × Move := if q.val=1 ∨ q.val=2 then (q,s,.stay) else M.transition q s structure Config (J : Type uJ) where state : Fin M.states head : J tape : J → Fin M.symbols def moveAt {J : Type uJ} (shift : Equiv.Perm J) : Move → J → J | .left => shift.symm | .stay => id | .right => shift open scoped Classical in noncomputable def step {J : Type uJ} (shift : Equiv.Perm J) (C : M.Config J) : M.Config J := let a := M.action C.state (C.tape C.head) { state := a.1 head := moveAt shift a.2.2 C.head tape := Function.update C.tape C.head a.2.1 } open scoped Classical in noncomputable def snapshot {J : Type uJ} (C : M.Config J) (j : J) : M.Cell := (C.tape j,if j=C.head then some C.state else none) def written (c : M.Cell) : Fin M.symbols := match c.2 with | none => c.1 | some q => (M.action q c.1).2.1 def arrival (d : Move) (c : M.Cell) : Option (Fin M.states) := match c.2 with | none => none | some q => if (M.action q c.1).2.2=d then some (M.action q c.1).1 else none def localRule (l c r : M.Cell) : M.Cell := (M.written c,(M.arrival .stay c).or (M.arrival .right l) |>.or (M.arrival .left r)) variable {J : Type uJ} theorem written_snapshot (C : M.Config J) (j : J) : M.written (M.snapshot C j) = if j=C.head then (M.action C.state (C.tape C.head)).2.1 else C.tape j := by classical by_cases hj : j=C.head <;> simp [written,snapshot,hj] theorem arrival_snapshot (C : M.Config J) (j : J) (d : Move) : M.arrival d (M.snapshot C j) = if j=C.head ∧ (M.action C.state (C.tape C.head)).2.2=d then some (M.action C.state (C.tape C.head)).1 else none := by classical by_cases hj : j=C.head <;> simp [arrival,snapshot,hj] theorem moveAt_eq_iff (shift : Equiv.Perm J) (d : Move) (h j : J) : j=moveAt shift d h ↔ (j=h ∧ d=.stay) ∨ (shift.symm j=h ∧ d=.right) ∨ (shift j=h ∧ d=.left) := by cases d with | left => simp [moveAt,Equiv.eq_symm_apply] | stay => simp [moveAt] | right => simp [moveAt,Equiv.symm_apply_eq] theorem snapshot_step (shift : Equiv.Perm J) (C : M.Config J) (j : J) : M.snapshot (M.step shift C) j = M.localRule (M.snapshot C (shift.symm j)) (M.snapshot C j) (M.snapshot C (shift j)) := by classical apply Prod.ext · change (Function.update C.tape C.head (M.action C.state (C.tape C.head)).2.1) j = M.written (M.snapshot C j) rw [M.written_snapshot] exact Function.update_apply _ _ _ _ · change (if j=moveAt shift (M.action C.state (C.tape C.head)).2.2 C.head then some (M.action C.state (C.tape C.head)).1 else none) = ((M.arrival .stay (M.snapshot C j)).or (M.arrival .right (M.snapshot C (shift.symm j)))).or (M.arrival .left (M.snapshot C (shift j))) simp only [M.arrival_snapshot,moveAt_eq_iff] by_cases h0 : j=C.head ∧ (M.action C.state (C.tape C.head)).2.2=.stay <;> by_cases h1 : shift.symm j=C.head ∧ (M.action C.state (C.tape C.head)).2.2=.right <;> by_cases h2 : shift j=C.head ∧ (M.action C.state (C.tape C.head)).2.2=.left <;> simp [h0,h1,h2] noncomputable def run {J : Type uJ} (shift : Equiv.Perm J) (C : M.Config J) (t : ℕ) : M.Config J := (M.step shift)^[t] C theorem run_snapshot (shift : Equiv.Perm J) (C : M.Config J) (t : ℕ) : M.snapshot (M.run shift C t) = CircuitEncoding.Tableau.run M.localRule shift (M.snapshot C) t := by induction t with | zero => rfl | succ t ih => funext j rw [CircuitEncoding.Tableau.run_succ] change M.snapshot ((M.step shift)^[t+1] C) j = _ rw [Function.iterate_succ_apply'] change M.snapshot (M.step shift (M.run shift C t)) j = _ rw [M.snapshot_step,ih] def toTM : TM where tapes := 1 states := M.states symbols := M.symbols tapes_pos := by decide states_ge := M.states_ge symbols_ge := M.symbols_ge transition q a := let b := M.transition q (a 0) (b.1,fun _ => b.2.1,fun _ => b.2.2) def embed (C : M.Config ℤ) : M.toTM.Config where state := C.state head := fun _ => C.head tape := fun _ => C.tape def lineShift : Equiv.Perm ℤ := Equiv.addRight 1 theorem moveAt_line (d : Move) (h : ℤ) : moveAt lineShift d h = h+d.displacement := by cases d <;> simp [moveAt,lineShift,Move.displacement ] theorem embed_step (C : M.Config ℤ) : M.embed (M.step lineShift C) = M.toTM.step (M.embed C) := by classical by_cases hh : C.state.val=1 ∨ C.state.val=2 · have hc : M.step lineShift C=C := by cases C simp_all [step,action,moveAt,Function.update_eq_self] rw [hc] simp [TM.step,TM.halted,embed,hh] · simp only [TM.step,TM.halted,embed,hh,ite_false] simp only [step,action,hh,ite_false,toTM,moveAt_line] congr funext a z simp only [Function.update_apply] split <;> rename_i hz <;> simp only [hz,ite_true,ite_false] def initial (w : List Bool) : M.Config ℤ where state := ⟨0,by have := M.states_ge; omega⟩ head := 0 tape z := if 0 ≤ z ∧ z.toNat< w.length then M.toTM.symbol (w.getD z.toNat false) else ⟨0,by have := M.symbols_ge; omega⟩ @[simp] theorem embed_initial (w : List Bool) : M.embed (M.initial w)=M.toTM.initial w := by unfold embed initial TM.initial congr 1 funext a z have ha : a.val=0 := Fin.eq_zero a ▸ rfl simp only [ha,true_and] split <;> rename_i hz <;> simp [hz] <;> rfl theorem embed_run (w : List Bool) (t : ℕ) : M.embed (M.run lineShift (M.initial w) t)=M.toTM.run w t := by induction t with | zero => exact M.embed_initial w | succ t ih => change M.embed ((M.step lineShift)^[t+1] (M.initial w)) = M.toTM.step^[t+1] (M.toTM.initial w) rw [Function.iterate_succ_apply',Function.iterate_succ_apply'] rw [M.embed_step] exact congrArg M.toTM.step ih theorem step_halted {J : Type uJ} (shift : Equiv.Perm J) (C : M.Config J) (hh : C.state.val=1 ∨ C.state.val=2) : M.step shift C=C := by cases C simp_all [step,action,moveAt,Function.update_eq_self] theorem run_halted {J : Type uJ} (shift : Equiv.Perm J) (C : M.Config J) (hh : C.state.val=1 ∨ C.state.val=2) (t : ℕ) : M.run shift C t=C := by unfold run exact Function.iterate_fixed (M.step_halted shift C hh) t theorem line_head_step (C : M.Config ℤ) : C.head-1 ≤ (M.step lineShift C).head ∧ (M.step lineShift C).head ≤ C.head+1 := by change C.head-1 ≤ moveAt lineShift (M.action C.state (C.tape C.head)).2.2 C.head ∧ moveAt lineShift (M.action C.state (C.tape C.head)).2.2 C.head ≤ C.head+1 rw [moveAt_line] cases (M.action C.state (C.tape C.head)).2.2 <;> simp [Move.displacement] omega theorem line_head_run (w : List Bool) (t : ℕ) : -(t:ℤ) ≤ (M.run lineShift (M.initial w) t).head ∧ (M.run lineShift (M.initial w) t).head ≤ (t:ℤ) := by induction t with | zero => simp [run,initial] | succ t ih => have hs := M.line_head_step (M.run lineShift (M.initial w) t) change -(↑(t+1):ℤ) ≤ ((M.step lineShift)^[t+1] (M.initial w)).head ∧ ((M.step lineShift)^[t+1] (M.initial w)).head ≤ (↑(t+1):ℤ) rw [Function.iterate_succ_apply'] change -(↑(t+1):ℤ) ≤ (M.step lineShift (M.run lineShift (M.initial w) t)).head ∧ (M.step lineShift (M.run lineShift (M.initial w) t)).head ≤ (↑(t+1):ℤ) push_cast omega def Agrees {J : Type uJ} (π : ℤ → J) (I : Set ℤ) (C : M.Config ℤ) (D : M.Config J) : Prop := D.state=C.state ∧ D.head=π C.head ∧ ∀ z∈I,D.tape (π z)=C.tape z theorem agrees_step {J : Type uJ} (shift : Equiv.Perm J) (π : ℤ → J) (I : Set ℤ) (hπ : ∀ z,π (z+1)=shift (π z)) (hinj : Set.InjOn π I) (C : M.Config ℤ) (D : M.Config J) (ha : M.Agrees π I C D) (hh : C.head∈I) : M.Agrees π I (M.step lineShift C) (M.step shift D) := by classical obtain ⟨hs,hd,ht⟩ := ha have scanned : D.tape D.head=C.tape C.head := by rw [hd]; exact ht _ hh have moved (d : Move) : moveAt shift d (π C.head)=π (moveAt lineShift d C.head) := by rw [moveAt_line] cases d with | stay => simp [moveAt,Move.displacement] | right => exact (hπ C.head).symm | left => change shift.symm (π C.head)=π (C.head+(-1)) apply shift.injective rw [shift.apply_symm_apply,← hπ] congr 1 omega refine ⟨?_,?_,?_⟩ · simp only [step,hs,scanned] · simp only [step,hs,hd,ht _ hh,moved] · intro z hz simp only [step] rw [hs,scanned,hd] have he : π z=π C.head ↔ z=C.head := ⟨hinj hz hh,congrArg π⟩ simp only [Function.update_apply,he] split <;> first | rfl | exact ht z hz theorem agrees_run {J : Type uJ} (shift : Equiv.Perm J) (π : ℤ → J) (I : Set ℤ) (hπ : ∀ z,π (z+1)=shift (π z)) (hinj : Set.InjOn π I) (w : List Bool) (D : M.Config J) (ha : M.Agrees π I (M.initial w) D) (T : ℕ) (hI : ∀ z : ℤ, -(T:ℤ) ≤ z → z ≤ T → z∈I) : ∀ t ≤ T, M.Agrees π I (M.run lineShift (M.initial w) t) (M.run shift D t) := by intro t induction t with | zero => intro _; exact ha | succ t ih => intro ht have hl := M.line_head_run w t have hi : (M.run lineShift (M.initial w) t).head∈I := hI _ (by omega) (by omega) have hc := M.agrees_step shift π I hπ hinj _ _ (ih (by omega)) hi simpa only [run,Function.iterate_succ_apply'] using hc theorem run_frozen_after {J : Type uJ} (shift : Equiv.Perm J) (C : M.Config J) (t : ℕ) (hh : (M.run shift C t).state.val=1 ∨ (M.run shift C t).state.val=2) (s : ℕ) (hts : t ≤ s) : M.run shift C s=M.run shift C t := by obtain ⟨u,rfl⟩ := Nat.exists_eq_add_of_le hts change (M.step shift)^[t+u] C = _ rw [Nat.add_comm,Function.iterate_add_apply] exact M.run_halted shift (M.run shift C t) hh u theorem accepts_iff_state (w : List Bool) (T : ℕ) (hh : (M.run lineShift (M.initial w) T).state.val=1 ∨ (M.run lineShift (M.initial w) T).state.val=2) : M.toTM.accepts w ↔ (M.run lineShift (M.initial w) T).state.val=1 := by constructor · rintro ⟨s,hs⟩ have hs' : (M.run lineShift (M.initial w) s).state.val=1 := by have he := congrArg (fun C : M.toTM.Config => C.state.val) (M.embed_run w s) exact he.trans hs rcases le_total s T with hst | hts · rw [M.run_frozen_after lineShift (M.initial w) s (Or.inl hs') T hst] exact hs' · rw [M.run_frozen_after lineShift (M.initial w) T hh s hts] at hs' exact hs' · intro hs refine ⟨T,?_⟩ have he := congrArg (fun C : M.toTM.Config => C.state.val) (M.embed_run w T) exact he.symm.trans hs def protectedInterval (m T : ℕ) : Set ℤ := Set.Icc (-(T:ℤ)-1) ((m:ℤ)+T) theorem protectedInterval_injective (m T L : ℕ) (hL : 2*T+m+2< L) : Set.InjOn (fun z : ℤ => (z : ZMod L)) (protectedInterval m T) := by intro x hx y hy he have hd := (ZMod.intCast_eq_intCast_iff_dvd_sub x y L).mp he have hL' : (2*(T:ℤ)+m+2)< L := by exact_mod_cast hL change -(T:ℤ)-1 ≤ x ∧ x ≤ (m:ℤ)+T at hx change -(T:ℤ)-1 ≤ y ∧ y ≤ (m:ℤ)+T at hy rcases le_total x y with hxy | hyx · have hz : y-x=0 := Int.eq_zero_of_dvd_of_nonneg_of_lt (by omega) (by omega) hd omega · have hd' : (L:ℤ)∣x-y := by simpa only [neg_sub] using (dvd_neg.mpr hd) have hz : x-y=0 := Int.eq_zero_of_dvd_of_nonneg_of_lt (by omega) (by omega) hd' omega def ringShift (L : ℕ) : Equiv.Perm (ZMod L) := Equiv.addRight 1 noncomputable def ringInitial (L : ℕ) (w : List Bool) : M.Config (ZMod L) where state := ⟨0,by have := M.states_ge; omega⟩ head := 0 tape j := if j.val< w.length then M.toTM.symbol (w.getD j.val false) else ⟨0,by have := M.symbols_ge; omega⟩ theorem ring_initial_agrees (w : List Bool) (T L : ℕ) (hL : 2*T+w.length+2< L) : M.Agrees (fun z : ℤ => (z : ZMod L)) (protectedInterval w.length T) (M.initial w) (M.ringInitial L w) := by classical have hp : 0< L := by omega let : NeZero L := ⟨Nat.ne_of_gt hp⟩ refine ⟨rfl,by simp [ringInitial,initial],?_⟩ intro z hz have hinj := protectedInterval_injective w.length T L hL have input_mem (i : ℕ) (hi : i< w.length) : (i:ℤ)∈protectedInterval w.length T := by change -(T:ℤ)-1 ≤ i ∧ (i:ℤ) ≤ (w.length:ℤ)+T constructor <;> omega have hi : (z : ZMod L).val< w.length ↔ 0 ≤ z ∧ z.toNat< w.length := by constructor · intro h have he : ((z : ZMod L).val : ℤ)=z := hinj (input_mem _ h) hz (by simp) rw [← he] simp only [Int.natCast_nonneg,Int.toNat_natCast,true_and] exact h · rintro ⟨hz0,hzlen⟩ have he : (((z.toNat:ℕ):ℤ):ZMod L)=(z:ZMod L) := by rw [Int.toNat_of_nonneg hz0] have hsmall : z.toNat< L := by omega rw [← he] simpa only [Int.cast_natCast,ZMod.val_natCast,Nat.mod_eq_of_lt hsmall] using hzlen have hv (h : (z : ZMod L).val< w.length) : (z : ZMod L).val=z.toNat := by have he : ((z : ZMod L).val : ℤ)=z := hinj (input_mem _ h) hz (by simp) simpa only [Int.toNat_natCast] using congrArg Int.toNat he simp only [ringInitial,initial] by_cases hr : (z : ZMod L).val< w.length · simp [hi.mp hr,hv hr] rfl · simp [hr,show ¬(0 ≤ z ∧ z.toNat< w.length) from fun h => hr (hi.mpr h)] theorem ring_run_agrees (w : List Bool) (T L : ℕ) (hL : 2*T+w.length+2< L) : ∀ t ≤ T,M.Agrees (fun z : ℤ => (z : ZMod L)) (protectedInterval w.length T) (M.run lineShift (M.initial w) t) (M.run (ringShift L) (M.ringInitial L w) t) := by apply M.agrees_run · intro z change ((z+1:ℤ):ZMod L)=(z:ZMod L)+1 push_cast rfl · exact protectedInterval_injective w.length T L hL · exact M.ring_initial_agrees w T L hL · intro z hz0 hz1 change -(T:ℤ)-1 ≤ z ∧ z ≤ (w.length:ℤ)+T constructor <;> omega def letterAccepting (c : M.Cell) : Prop := ∃ q,c.2=some q ∧ q.val=1 theorem accepting_snapshot {J : Type uJ} (C : M.Config J) : (∃ j,M.letterAccepting (M.snapshot C j)) ↔ C.state.val=1 := by classical constructor · rintro ⟨j,q,hq,hv⟩ by_cases hj : j=C.head · simp only [snapshot,hj,ite_true,Option.some.injEq] at hq exact hq ▸ hv · simp [snapshot,hj] at hq · intro hv exact ⟨C.head,C.state,by simp [snapshot],hv⟩ theorem ring_accepts_iff (w : List Bool) (T L S : ℕ) (hL : 2*T+w.length+2< L) (hTS : T ≤ S) (hh : (M.run lineShift (M.initial w) T).state.val=1 ∨ (M.run lineShift (M.initial w) T).state.val=2) : (∃ j,M.letterAccepting (CircuitEncoding.Tableau.run M.localRule (ringShift L) (M.snapshot (M.ringInitial L w)) S j)) ↔ M.toTM.accepts w := by rw [← M.run_snapshot,M.accepting_snapshot,M.accepts_iff_state w T hh] have hA := M.ring_run_agrees w T L hL T le_rfl have hR : (M.run (ringShift L) (M.ringInitial L w) T).state.val=1 ∨ (M.run (ringShift L) (M.ringInitial L w) T).state.val=2 := by rw [hA.1]; exact hh rw [M.run_frozen_after (ringShift L) (M.ringInitial L w) T hR S hTS,hA.1] end OneTape end WLTime namespace WLTime.TM variable (M : TM) theorem run_add (w : List Bool) (a b : ℕ) : M.run w (a+b)=M.step^[a] (M.run w b) := Function.iterate_add_apply _ _ _ _ theorem run_succ (w : List Bool) (t : ℕ) : M.run w (t+1)=M.step (M.run w t) := Function.iterate_succ_apply' _ _ _ theorem step_frozen (C : M.Config) (h : M.halted C) : M.step C=C := by rw [step,ite_eq_left h] theorem run_frozen (w : List Bool) {t u : ℕ} (hh : M.halted (M.run w t)) (hu : t ≤ u) : M.run w u=M.run w t := by obtain ⟨a,rfl⟩ := Nat.exists_eq_add_of_le hu rw [Nat.add_comm,M.run_add] exact Function.iterate_fixed (M.step_frozen _ hh) a theorem time_halted (w : List Bool) (h : M.halts w) : M.halted (M.run w (M.time w)) := by simp only [time,dite_eq_left h] exact Nat.find_spec h theorem time_le_of_halted (w : List Bool) {t : ℕ} (h : M.halted (M.run w t)) : M.time w ≤ t := by have hh : M.halts w := ⟨t,h⟩ simp only [time,dite_eq_left hh] exact Nat.find_min' hh h theorem accepts_iff_at_halt (w : List Bool) {t : ℕ} (h : M.halted (M.run w t)) : M.accepts w ↔ (M.run w t).state.val=1 := by constructor · rintro ⟨s,hs⟩ have hx := M.run_frozen w h (Nat.le_max_right s t) have hy := M.run_frozen w (Or.inl hs) (Nat.le_max_left s t) rw [hx] at hy exact congrArg (fun C : M.Config => C.state.val) hy |>.trans hs · intro ht; exact ⟨t,ht⟩ end WLTime.TM end OAI