import OAI.RingTheory.DirectFiniteness.PlanarDiagrams namespace OAI universe u_1 u_2 u_3 u_4 noncomputable section open scoped Classical open scoped BigOperators open Equiv Equiv.Perm namespace KaplanskyCounterexample.Planar open Equiv Equiv.Perm attribute [local simp] SameCycle.rfl universe u variable {α : Type u} {V : Type u_1} {F : Type u_2} {A : Type u_3} {B : Type u_4} [Fintype α] [AddCommGroup A] [AddCommGroup B] variable {R : Ribbon α} {Inc : V → F → Prop} {ι : V → F → (A →+ B)} theorem WeakBalanced.not_genusZero (D : WeakBalanced R Inc ι) (hinj : ∀ v f, Inc v f → Function.Injective (ι v f)) (hind : ∀ v f g, Inc v f → Inc v g → f ≠ g → ∀ a b, ι v f a + ι v g b = 0 → a = 0) (hgirth : 12 ≤ (incidenceGraph Inc).egirth) : ¬ R.GenusZero := by classical intro hR let C : PlanarDiagram.{u} Inc ι := ⟨α, inferInstance, R, D, hR⟩ obtain ⟨M, hmin, hvmin⟩ := C.exists_minimal have hnz : ∀ E : PlanarDiagram.{u} Inc ι, E.edges = M.edges → ∀ a, E.balanced.weight a ≠ 0 := by intro E hE a ha obtain ⟨β, iβ, S, hcard, hS, hD⟩ := E.balanced.exists_smaller E.genusZero a ha let E' : PlanarDiagram.{u} Inc ι := ⟨β, iβ, S, hD.some, hS⟩ have h := hmin E' change M.edges ≤ Fintype.card β at h change Fintype.card E.Edge = M.edges at hE omega have hparallel : ∀ a b : M.Edge, M.ribbon.black.SameCycle a b → M.ribbon.white.SameCycle a b → a = b := by intro a b hb hw by_contra hab let E : PlanarDiagram.{u} Inc ι := ⟨M.Edge, inferInstance, M.ribbon, M.balanced.transfer a b hb hw, M.genusZero⟩ exact hnz E rfl a (transferWeight_zero M.balanced.weight a b hab) let D' := M.balanced.strong (hnz M rfl) have hred : D'.Reduced := by constructor · intro a ha hl have hw : ¬ M.ribbon.white.SameCycle a (M.ribbon.black a) := by intro h exact ha (hparallel a _ SameCycle.rfl.apply_right h).symm let E : PlanarDiagram.{u} Inc ι := ⟨M.Edge, inferInstance, M.ribbon.mergeWhite a, M.balanced.mergeWhite a hw hl, M.ribbon.genusZero_mergeWhite M.genusZero a hw⟩ have h := hvmin E rfl have hn : ¬ M.ribbon.white.SameCycle a (M.ribbon.face a) := by simpa [Ribbon.face] using hw have hc := swap_mul_cycles_card M.ribbon.white a (M.ribbon.face a) hn change Nat.card (Cycles M.ribbon.black) + Nat.card (Cycles M.ribbon.white) ≤ Nat.card (Cycles M.ribbon.black) + Nat.card (Cycles (swap a (M.ribbon.face a) * M.ribbon.white)) at h omega · intro a ha hl have hb : ¬ M.ribbon.black.SameCycle a (M.ribbon.white a) := by intro h exact ha (hparallel a _ h SameCycle.rfl.apply_right).symm let E : PlanarDiagram.{u} Inc ι := ⟨M.Edge, inferInstance, M.ribbon.mergeBlack a, M.balanced.mergeBlack a hb hl, M.ribbon.genusZero_mergeBlack M.genusZero a hb⟩ have h := hvmin E rfl have hn : ¬ M.ribbon.black.SameCycle a (M.ribbon.black (M.ribbon.white a)) := by simpa using hb have hc := swap_mul_cycles_card M.ribbon.black a (M.ribbon.black (M.ribbon.white a)) hn change Nat.card (Cycles M.ribbon.black) + Nat.card (Cycles M.ribbon.white) ≤ Nat.card (Cycles (swap a (M.ribbon.black (M.ribbon.white a)) * M.ribbon.black)) + Nat.card (Cycles M.ribbon.white) at h omega exact D'.not_genusZero hred hinj hind hgirth M.genusZero end KaplanskyCounterexample.Planar end end OAI