import Mathlib import OAI.SetTheory.PartitionConsistency.Construction.ConservativeCells namespace OAI /-! ## CellRestriction -/ /-! Reflecting a scheduled operation to a conservative subobject that contains its literal countable parameter set. -/ namespace PartitionConsistency.ConservativeMonoids universe u open DiagramOrder DiagramForcing noncomputable section namespace Probe variable {M N : Object.{u}} @[ext] theorem ext {d c : Probe M} (ha : d.a = c.a) (hb : d.b = c.b) (he : d.e = c.e) (hn : d.path.node = c.path.node) : d = c := by cases d with | mk a b e hb' he' p => cases c with | mk a' b' e' hb'' he'' q => dsimp only at ha hb he hn subst a'; subst b'; subst e' cases p; cases q congr /-- No closure-of-path assertion is presumed: divisibility is reflected by conservation, and the actual countably many nodes are pulled back. -/ theorem exists_preimage (d : Probe N) (f : M ⟶ N) (h : d.parameters ⊆ Set.range f) : ∃ c : Probe M, c.map f = d := by classical obtain ⟨a,ha⟩ := h (show d.a ∈ d.parameters from Or.inl (by simp)) obtain ⟨b,hb⟩ := h (show d.b ∈ d.parameters from Or.inl (by simp)) obtain ⟨e,he⟩ := h (show d.e ∈ d.parameters from Or.inl (by simp)) have hn : ∀ i, ∃ n, f n = d.path.node i := fun i => h (Or.inr ⟨i,rfl⟩) choose n hn using hn have hzero : n 0 = 1 := f.injective (by rw [hn,d.path.zero,f.map_one]) have hinc {i j : ℕ} (hij : i ≤ j) : n i ∣ n j := (f.conservative.dvd_iff _ _).mp (by rw [hn,hn]; exact d.path.increasing hij) have hbound (i : ℕ) : n i ∣ a := (f.conservative.dvd_iff _ _).mp (by rw [hn,ha]; exact d.path.bounded i) have hb' : b ≠ 1 := by intro hh; apply d.b_ne_one; rw [← hb,hh,f.map_one] have he' : e ≠ 1 := by intro hh; apply d.e_ne_one; rw [← he,hh,f.map_one] let c : Probe M := ⟨a,b,e,hb',he',⟨n,hzero,hinc,hbound⟩⟩ exact ⟨c,ext ha hb he (funext hn)⟩ end Probe namespace Merger variable {M N : Object.{u}} /-- The finite presentation uses only the displayed starts. Every validity clause is reflected along the conservative inclusion, not added as a new hypothesis on the selected prescription. -/ theorem exists_preimage (d : Merger N) (f : M ⟶ N) (h : d.parameters ⊆ Set.range f) : ∃ c : Merger M, c.map f = d := by classical have hs : ∀ i j a b, d.prescription.start i j = some (a,b) → ∃ x y, f x = a ∧ f y = b := by intro i j a b hab obtain ⟨x,hx⟩ := h ⟨i,j,a,b,hab,Or.inl rfl⟩ obtain ⟨y,hy⟩ := h ⟨i,j,a,b,hab,Or.inr rfl⟩ exact ⟨x,y,hx,hy⟩ let start (i j : Fin d.n) : Option (M × M) := match he : d.prescription.start i j with | none => none | some (a,b) => some ((hs i j a b he).choose,(hs i j a b he).choose_spec.choose) let P : OverlapPrescription M d.n := ⟨start⟩ have hm : P.map f.toMonoidHom = d.prescription := by have heq : (P.map f.toMonoidHom).start = d.prescription.start := by funext i j change (start i j).map _ = d.prescription.start i j dsimp only [start] split · rename_i he simp only [Option.map_none,he] · rename_i a b he simp only [he,Option.map_some,Option.some.injEq] exact Prod.ext (hs i j a b he).choose_spec.choose_spec.1 (hs i j a b he).choose_spec.choose_spec.2 exact congrArg OverlapPrescription.mk heq have hp : P.Valid := P.valid_of_map f.conservative (hm ▸ d.valid) let c : Merger M := ⟨d.n,P,hp⟩ refine ⟨c,?_⟩ have heq : Merger.mk d.n (P.map f.toMonoidHom) (P.valid_map hp M.joins f.conservative) = Merger.mk d.n d.prescription d.valid := by congr 1 exact heq.trans (by cases d; rfl) end Merger namespace Cell variable {M N : Object.{u}} theorem exists_preimage (d : Cell N) (f : M ⟶ N) (h : d.parameters ⊆ Set.range f) : ∃ c : Cell M, c.map f = d := by cases d with | inl d => obtain ⟨c,hc⟩ := d.exists_preimage f h exact ⟨.inl c,congrArg Sum.inl hc⟩ | inr d => obtain ⟨c,hc⟩ := d.exists_preimage f h exact ⟨.inr c,congrArg Sum.inr hc⟩ /-- In particular, every parameter-containing conservative subobject admits the same actual operation. -/ theorem exists_restriction (d : Cell M) (S : Subobject M) (h : d.parameters ⊆ S.submonoid) : ∃ c : Cell S.object, c.map S.inclusion = d := d.exists_preimage S.inclusion (fun x hx => ⟨⟨x,h hx⟩,rfl⟩) end Cell end end PartitionConsistency.ConservativeMonoids /-! ## CellularTower -/ /-! Cellular towers inside their actual terminal monoid. The countable hull retains literal generators and finite old coefficients. -/ namespace PartitionConsistency.DiagramOrder.Conservative universe u v variable {M : Type u} {N : Type v} [LeftCancelMonoid M] [IsConical M] [LeftCancelMonoid N] [IsConical N] omit [IsConical M] [IsConical N] in /-- A monoid isomorphism preserves all four conservation conditions. -/ theorem of_mulEquiv (e : M ≃* N) : Conservative e.toMonoidHom where injective := e.injective factors x y z _ := ⟨e.symm z,e.apply_symm_apply z⟩ intersections x y j h z := by obtain ⟨w,rfl⟩ := e.surjective z change (e x ∣ e w ∧ e y ∣ e w ↔ e j ∣ e w) simpa only [map_dvd_iff] using h w common x y h := by obtain ⟨z,hx,hy⟩ := h obtain ⟨w,rfl⟩ := e.surjective z exact ⟨w, (map_dvd_iff e).mp hx, (map_dvd_iff e).mp hy⟩ end PartitionConsistency.DiagramOrder.Conservative namespace PartitionConsistency.ConservativeMonoids universe u open DiagramOrder DiagramOrder.ConservativeHull CategoryTheory MonoidPushout noncomputable section open scoped Classical def ofMulEquiv {M N : Object.{u}} (e : M ≃* N) : M ⟶ N := ⟨e.toMonoidHom,Conservative.of_mulEquiv e⟩ namespace Subobject variable {T : Object.{u}} @[ext] theorem ext {S R : Subobject T} (h : S.submonoid = R.submonoid) : S = R := by cases S; cases R; cases h; rfl def top : Subobject T where submonoid := ⊤ factors := by intros; trivial joins := by intros; trivial def hom {S R : Subobject T} (h : S.submonoid ≤ R.submonoid) : S.object ⟶ R.object := ⟨Submonoid.inclusion h,Conservative.of_comp R.inclusion.conservative (show Conservative (R.inclusion.toMonoidHom.comp (Submonoid.inclusion h)) from S.inclusion.conservative)⟩ @[simp] theorem hom_apply {S R : Subobject T} (h : S.submonoid ≤ R.submonoid) (x : S.object) : (hom h x).val = x.val := rfl end Subobject /-- An actual presentation cell, identified with a subobject of the very same terminal monoid. The identification fixes every old element. -/ structure Attachment {T : Object.{u}} (S R : Subobject T) where cell : Cell S.object equiv : cell.extension ≃* R.object old : ∀ x : S.object, (equiv (cell.inclusion x)).val = x.val namespace Attachment variable {T : Object.{u}} {S R : Subobject T} (d : Attachment S R) def embedding : d.cell.extension ⟶ T := R.inclusion.comp (ofMulEquiv d.equiv) def generator (i : d.cell.Generators) : T := d.embedding (d.cell.generator i) def parameters : Set T := S.inclusion '' d.cell.parameters @[simp] theorem embedding_old (x : S.object) : d.embedding (d.cell.inclusion x) = x.val := d.old x theorem parameters_countable : d.parameters.Countable := d.cell.parameters_countable.image _ include d in theorem old_le : S.submonoid ≤ R.submonoid := by intro x hx have hh := (d.equiv (d.cell.inclusion ⟨x,hx⟩)).property change d.embedding (d.cell.inclusion ⟨x,hx⟩) ∈ R.submonoid at hh erw [d.embedding_old] at hh exact hh /-- A retained word has a finite list of old coefficients, even in a countably presented cell. -/ theorem finite_coefficients (x : R.object) : ∃ s : Finset S.object, x.val ∈ Submonoid.closure (S.inclusion '' (s : Set S.object) ∪ Set.range d.generator) := by obtain ⟨s,hs⟩ := d.cell.finite_coefficients (d.equiv.symm x) refine ⟨s,?_⟩ let Q := Submonoid.closure (S.inclusion '' (s : Set S.object) ∪ Set.range d.generator) have h : Submonoid.closure (d.cell.inclusion '' (s : Set S.object) ∪ Set.range d.cell.generator) ≤ Q.comap d.embedding.toMonoidHom := by apply Submonoid.closure_le.mpr rintro z (⟨y,hy,rfl⟩ | ⟨i,rfl⟩) · change d.embedding (d.cell.inclusion y) ∈ Q rw [d.embedding_old] exact Submonoid.subset_closure (Or.inl ⟨y,hy,rfl⟩) · exact Submonoid.subset_closure (Or.inr ⟨i,rfl⟩) have hh := h hs change (d.equiv (d.equiv.symm x)).val ∈ Q at hh simpa only [d.equiv.apply_symm_apply] using hh end Attachment variable (T : Object.{u}) (J : Type u) [LinearOrder J] [OrderBot J] [OrderTop J] [SuccOrder J] [WellFoundedLT J] /-- The original construction as a continuous tower of literal cells. Identity steps are allowed, so a selected or an omitted subconstruction can keep the same index order without compressing its limit cuts. -/ structure CellTower where stage : J → Subobject T mono : Monotone (fun i => (stage i).submonoid) terminal : (stage ⊤).submonoid = ⊤ continuous : ∀ i, Order.IsSuccLimit i → ∀ x, x ∈ (stage i).submonoid → ∃ j < i, x ∈ (stage j).submonoid step : ∀ i, (stage i).submonoid = (stage (Order.succ i)).submonoid ∨ Nonempty (Attachment (stage i) (stage (Order.succ i))) namespace CellTower variable {T J} (D : CellTower T J) /-- The unique original successor where an element first appears. -/ def NewAt (i : J) (x : T) : Prop := x ∈ (D.stage (Order.succ i)).submonoid ∧ x ∉ (D.stage i).submonoid omit [OrderBot J] [WellFoundedLT J] in theorem NewAt.not_isMax {i : J} {x : T} (h : D.NewAt i x) : ¬ IsMax i := by intro hi exact h.2 ((show Order.succ i = i from Order.succ_eq_iff_isMax.mpr hi) ▸ h.1) omit [OrderBot J] [WellFoundedLT J] in theorem NewAt.neq {i : J} {x : T} (h : D.NewAt i x) : (D.stage i).submonoid ≠ (D.stage (Order.succ i)).submonoid := by intro he exact h.2 (he ▸ h.1) omit [OrderBot J] [WellFoundedLT J] in theorem NewAt.unique {i j : J} {x : T} (hi : D.NewAt i x) (hj : D.NewAt j x) : i = j := by apply le_antisymm · by_contra h have hd := (Order.succ_le_iff_of_not_isMax (hj.not_isMax D)).mpr (lt_of_not_ge h) exact hi.2 (D.mono hd hj.1) · by_contra h have hd := (Order.succ_le_iff_of_not_isMax (hi.not_isMax D)).mpr (lt_of_not_ge h) exact hj.2 (D.mono hd hi.1) theorem exists_newAt {x : T} (hx : x ∉ (D.stage ⊥).submonoid) : ∃ i, D.NewAt i x := by have hex : {i | x ∈ (D.stage i).submonoid}.Nonempty := ⟨⊤,by change x ∈ (D.stage ⊤).submonoid; rw [D.terminal]; trivial⟩ let b := wellFounded_lt.min _ hex have hb : x ∈ (D.stage b).submonoid := wellFounded_lt.min_mem _ hex have hmin : ∀ j < b, x ∉ (D.stage j).submonoid := by intro j hj hm exact (not_lt_of_ge (WellFoundedLT.min_le (show j ∈ {i | x ∈ (D.stage i).submonoid} from hm))) hj have key (b : J) : x ∈ (D.stage b).submonoid → (∀ j < b, x ∉ (D.stage j).submonoid) → ∃ i, D.NewAt i x := by induction b using SuccOrder.limitRecOn with | isMin i hi => intro hb _; exact (hx (hi.eq_bot ▸ hb)).elim | succ i hi _ => intro hb hmin; exact ⟨i,hb,hmin i (Order.lt_succ_of_not_isMax hi)⟩ | isSuccLimit i hi _ => intro hb hmin obtain ⟨j,hj,hm⟩ := D.continuous i hi x hb exact (hmin j hj hm).elim exact key b hb hmin omit [WellFoundedLT J] def newIndex (x : T) : J := if h : ∃ i, D.NewAt i x then h.choose else ⊥ theorem newIndex_eq {x : T} {i : J} (h : D.NewAt i x) : D.newIndex x = i := by have he : ∃ j, D.NewAt j x := ⟨i,h⟩ rw [newIndex,dite_eq_left he] exact NewAt.unique D he.choose_spec h /-- The chosen cell at an active stage is independent of the queried word. -/ def stepCell (i : J) (h : (D.stage i).submonoid ≠ (D.stage (Order.succ i)).submonoid) : Attachment (D.stage i) (D.stage (Order.succ i)) := ((D.step i).resolve_left h).some def coefficients (i : J) (h : (D.stage i).submonoid ≠ (D.stage (Order.succ i)).submonoid) (x : (D.stage (Order.succ i)).object) : Finset (D.stage i).object := ((D.stepCell i h).finite_coefficients x).choose def dependencies (x : T) : Set T := if h : D.NewAt (D.newIndex x) x then (D.stepCell (D.newIndex x) (h.neq D)).parameters ∪ Set.range (D.stepCell (D.newIndex x) (h.neq D)).generator ∪ (D.stage (D.newIndex x)).inclusion '' (D.coefficients (D.newIndex x) (h.neq D) ⟨x,h.1⟩ : Set (D.stage (D.newIndex x)).object) else ∅ theorem dependencies_countable (x : T) : (D.dependencies x).Countable := by classical rw [dependencies] split · exact ((Attachment.parameters_countable _).union (Set.countable_range _)).union (Set.Countable.image (Finset.countable_toSet _) _) · exact Set.countable_empty theorem dependencies_at {i : J} {x : T} (h : D.NewAt i x) : D.dependencies x = (D.stepCell i (h.neq D)).parameters ∪ Set.range (D.stepCell i (h.neq D)).generator ∪ (D.stage i).inclusion '' (D.coefficients i (h.neq D) ⟨x,h.1⟩ : Set (D.stage i).object) := by have hi := D.newIndex_eq h subst i rw [dependencies,dite_eq_left h] /-- Close under dependencies as well as factors and actual conditional joins. This is a submonoid of the terminal monoid, not a substitute monoid. -/ def hull (s : Set T) : Subobject T where submonoid := ConservativeHull.submonoid (s ∪ (D.stage ⊥).submonoid) D.dependencies factors _ hx _ hy := CountableHull.closed _ _ hx hy (Or.inl (Set.mem_insert_of_mem _ (Set.mem_insert _ _))) joins _ hx _ hy := CountableHull.closed _ _ hx hy (Or.inl (Set.mem_insert_of_mem _ (Set.mem_insert_of_mem _ (Set.mem_singleton _)))) theorem hull_countable {s : Set T} (hs : s.Countable) (hb : ((D.stage ⊥).submonoid : Set T).Countable) : ((D.hull s).submonoid : Set T).Countable := ConservativeHull.countable _ _ (hs.union hb) D.dependencies_countable theorem subset_hull (s : Set T) : s ⊆ (D.hull s).submonoid := fun _ hx => ConservativeHull.contains _ _ (Or.inl hx) theorem bottom_le_hull (s : Set T) : (D.stage ⊥).submonoid ≤ (D.hull s).submonoid := fun _ hx => ConservativeHull.contains _ _ (Or.inr hx) theorem hull_closed {s : Set T} {x : T} (hx : x ∈ (D.hull s).submonoid) : D.dependencies x ⊆ (D.hull s).submonoid := ConservativeHull.closed_deps _ _ hx end CellTower end end PartitionConsistency.ConservativeMonoids end OAI