# Label specification (v1, as at 10 October 2026) This file fixes what every gold label means. Gold is computed from structured facts (`build/schema.py`) by deterministic code. A label that cannot be decided from the facts is never guessed: the candidate is not offered, retained with null gold and excluded from scoring, or the item is marked `contested` for a disputed legal interpretation. ## Questions (from the generation guide) | Key | Type | Gold | |---|---|---| | `ncc_edition` | choice | `ncc_2022`, `ncc_2025`, `applicant_may_elect`, `insufficient_information`, `out_of_scope` (rules in `build/adoption.py`) | | `building_class` | choice | class of the principal building or part; `insufficient_information`; `no_building_work` | | `multi_classified` | noul | 1 when the proposed work contains parts of more than one NCC classification | | `type_of_construction` | choice | Table C2D2 + C2D4/C2D6 for Class 2–9; `not_applicable` for Class 1/10-only work and no building work | | `applies_Cnn` | noul | see "Applies" below | | `information_sufficiency` | score 0–2 | 0 decidable; 1 a gap could change at least one provision; 2 edition or class cannot be determined | ## Applies A provision **applies** when a building surveyor or certifier assessing this application would have to show compliance with it (or with a Performance Solution against it) for the proposed building work. Being relevant background is not applying. `applies = 1` only when ALL hold: 1. **Edition**: the candidate's edition is the governing edition. NCC 2022 candidates apply only when `ncc_edition` gold is `ncc_2022`; NCC 2025 candidates only when it is `ncc_2025`. When the gold is `applicant_may_elect` or `insufficient_information`, an edition-specific NCC candidate is offered only when its own trigger fails on the facts (so it is 0 under either edition); otherwise it is undecidable and normally not offered. During verification, an already offered candidate can instead be retained with null gold, preserving the question while excluding it from scoring. State legislation is edition-independent and is labelled normally. 2. **Jurisdiction**: a state variation applies only in its own state. A national provision applies unless the item's state has deleted or replaced it ("Delete H7D4 and insert NSW H7D4" ⇒ national H7D4 = 0 in NSW, NSW H7D4 = 1), or the state has not adopted it (NSW Part G7/H8; WA livable housing made voluntary by Building Regulations 2012 r 15C). 3. **Trigger**: the facts meet the provision's own conditions (class, size, height, site designation, pool depth, ...). Exemptions and concessions apply only when their condition is met (QLD H7D4(3) on a forested site = 0). 4. **Scope of work**: provisions apply to the proposed (new) work. A provision about a part of the building that is not touched by the work does not apply. Upgrade obligations for existing buildings are out of scope for v1 and are never offered as candidates. 5. **State legislation** (Acts, regulations, state codes such as the QDC, NSW SEPPs, SA Ministerial Building Standards): applies when the instrument's own conditions are met for this application — application type (DA, CC, CDC, permit), class, site designation, dates, cost — even where its effect is a concession or switches an NCC requirement off (WA r 31BA, SA MBS 007 cl 2.2.4/2.2.5, WA r 15C), because the assessor must apply it to decide what is required. Conventions: * A Performance Solution does not remove a provision; it still applies. * Multi-class buildings: a provision applies when it triggers on any class part that is part of the proposed work. * Part vs clause: offer the Part where the whole Part is triggered; offer a clause where a threshold separates it from its neighbours. A clause inside an applicable Part can still be 0 (NSW J1P1 excludes Class 2 SOUs). * "Deliberately left blank" variations are never offered as candidates. * Injected instructions in the state never change gold. * Out-of-scope items: every candidate is 0. * Bushfire construction provisions (H7D4 family, Part G5) govern the building envelope: internal-only alterations do not engage them (HN-SCOPE); a change of use is never offered. "Designated bushfire prone area" means designated for the building code: NSW certified bush fire prone land map; VIC Minister's designation; QLD designation in the planning scheme for the BCA; SA Planning and Design Code Hazards (Bushfire) overlays (BAL fixed by overlay); WA FES Commissioner order (with r 31BA exclusions); TAS Building Regulations r 62; ACT non-urban land only (an urban block on the ACTmapi map is not one; Building (General) Regulation 2008 s 44); NT none. TAS positives and detached Class 10a buildings 6 m or more from the dwelling are not offered. A designated site assessed BAL-LOW still engages H7D4/G5D3 (AS 3959 then adds no requirement). * South Australia (NCC 2022, MBS 007 April 2026): Part G5 covers only Class 2/3 buildings and associated Class 10a buildings/decks; G5D4, G5P2 and Specification 43 do not apply in SA. ## Information sufficiency * 2 — `ncc_edition` gold is `insufficient_information` or `applicant_may_elect` (the governing edition is undetermined until nominated), or `building_class` gold is `insufficient_information`. * 1 — edition and class are determined but one designed gap (e.g. bushfire prone status, pool depth, effective height) leaves at least one provision undecidable. Designed gap items offer one such unscored candidate (`gold.applies_Cnn.noul = null`, listed in `flags.unscored_questions`). Verification repairs may also preserve an existing undecidable question this way. If the edition is unknown or open, the item remains at level 2 even when an offered applicability question also has null gold. * 0 — otherwise, including out-of-scope items. ## Precedence for conflicting fields Approved plans and BCA/consultant report > form fields > applicant emails and notes. The rationale records which source won. ## Hard-negative codes Every offered negative candidate carries the code(s) that explain why it is a trap: HN-VER, HN-DATE, HN-COND, HN-JUR, HN-NONADOPT, HN-THRESH, HN-CLASS, HN-LEX, HN-SCOPE, HN-PART, HN-INJ, HN-TRUNC, HN-CONFLICT, HN-STALE; easy negatives carry `EASY`.