--- pretty_name: "2026.RA.Game-Structure-Generality" tags: - negotiation - multi-agent - cheap-talk - llm-agents configs: - config_name: episodes data_files: - split: train path: episode_rows.parquet --- # 2026.RA.Game-Structure-Generality Does a free-form public message channel matter more for language-model negotiators when coordination is harder? This dataset holds every episode of the game-structure generality experiment (research note 0086 of the `rational_agents` project): tables of Claude Opus 4.8 negotiators with the talk channel open (**talk**) and closed (**mute**, moves only), and tables of a model-free Bayesian negotiator (**bayes**), played on four game structures: | experiment-name | structure | bank | rule | seeds | episodes per role | |---|---|---|---|---|---| | `game-structure-generality-v1/S3` | 3 parties | `banks/instances_n3_private_v1` (24 instances) | unanimity (3 of 3) | talk/mute 0–4, bayes 0–4 | 120 | | `game-structure-generality-v1/S5` | 5 parties | `instances_five_seat_private_v2` (24 instances; in the project repo) | unanimity (5 of 5) | 0–4 | 120 | | `game-structure-generality-v1/S7` | 7 parties | `banks/instances_n7_private_v1` (24 instances) | unanimity (7 of 7) | 0–4 | 120 | | `game-structure-generality-v1/Q4` | 5 parties | bank v2 re-materialized at 4 of 5 (veto seat retained) | 4 of 5 | talk/mute 0–2, bayes 0–4 (table keeps 0–2) | 72 | | `game-structure-generality-v1/V1ctx`, `V1q4ctx` | 5 parties, Bayesian only (context) | `instances_five_seat_private_v1` | unanimity / 4 of 5 | 0–4 | 120 | The `S5` talk and mute rows are derived from the **model-breadth lane's** Opus 4.8 cells (`mutebreadth_opus48_v1__all_llm`, `mutebreadth_opus48_v1__all_llm_moves_only`); their raw episodes are not re-uploaded here. Every other cell's raw episodes are in `runs/`. ## Headline (95% instance-clustered bootstrap, 10,000 draws; E1 = mute − talk deal rate, paired; E2 = talk − Bayesian, paired) | structure | talk | mute | Bayesian | E1 | E2 | |---|---|---|---|---|---| | 3 parties | 0.925 | 0.808 | 0.175 | −0.117 [−0.242, +0.017] | +0.750 [+0.608, +0.858] | | 5 parties (bank v2) | 0.908 | 0.600 | 0.233 | −0.308 [−0.425, −0.192] | +0.675 [+0.558, +0.783] | | 7 parties | 0.817 | 0.467 | 0.267 | −0.350 [−0.483, −0.225] | +0.550 [+0.383, +0.708] | | 4 of 5 (bank v2, seeds 0–2) | 0.958 | 0.875 | 0.431 | −0.083 [−0.167, −0.014] | +0.528 [+0.375, +0.681] | Muting cost difference 7 vs 3 parties (cross-bank): −0.233 [−0.408, −0.058]; 4-of-5 vs unanimity on identical keys (paired difference-in-differences, n=72): +0.194 [+0.083, +0.306]. Full tables, the discovery/coordination census, ICCs and seeds 0–2 estimates are in `analysis/results.md` and `analysis/summary.json`. ## Files - `episode_rows.parquet` — one row per episode (config `episodes`): `experiment-name`, `role` (talk / mute / bayes), `source_run`, `model`, instance and seed keys, deal, normalized score, parties left below threshold by a closed deal, walks, the zone-of-agreement census columns (`zopa_tabled`, `deal_given_tabled`, `failure_type`, ...), voided and fabricated turn counts, published-message count, cost. - `runs/*.tar.zst` — raw run directories (episodes with every turn's exact prompt view and model output, instances, manifest, usage ledger, run.log with the invocation). `*_merged` = source cell plus its fill (missing keys re-run after a budget-guard stop); `*_fill01` and the unmerged source dirs are kept for provenance; `*__s34` = the seeds 3–4 extension cells. Unpack with `tar -I zstd -xf `. - `transcripts/*.jsonl` — per-turn transcript projections of the hosted cells (seeds 0–2). - `banks/` — the 3- and 7-party banks and outcome-blind feasible-set statistics of every bank. - `analysis/` — `results.md`, `summary.json`, the analysis config and log, `preregistration.md` (with amendments A1–A4), `exact_prompts.md` (verbatim first-turn prompts of each hosted cell), `spend.txt`. ## Protocol Hosted seats: `anthropic:claude-opus-4-8`, thinking on (adaptive), 16,384-token turn floor, private score sheets and whole-number thresholds, datacenter framing, canonical prompt scaffold, four rounds with rotating proposer then a forced final vote. Mute = protocol arm `moves_only` (no message is published). Claude Opus 5 and Claude Fable 5 decline this prompt at the provider level (the block was localised to the scratchpad instruction), so the experiment uses Opus 4.8; no reworded prompt was used for any reported result. 0 refused turns and 0 fabricated turns in every hosted cell. ## Regenerate From the project repo (`experiments/rational_agents`), with `PYTHONPATH=libs/interlens/src:.`: ``` # banks python generate_five_seat_bank.py --out instances_n3_private_v1 --n-parties 3 --first-seed 53000 python generate_five_seat_bank.py --out instances_n7_private_v1 --n-parties 7 --first-seed 57000 # one cell (repeat per structure/table; see run_game_structure_cell.sbatch) sbatch --partition=john --cpus-per-task=2 --mem=16G --export=ALL,RUN=gsg_v1__n7__all_llm,TABLE=all_llm,BANK=instances_n7_private_v1,SEEDS="0 1 2",MIN_ACCEPT=7,BUDGET_USD=210,EST_USD=2.0,CONCURRENCY=8 run_game_structure_cell.sbatch # fill a cell stopped by the working-capital guard sbatch --export=ALL,SRC=gsg_v1__n7__all_llm_moves_only,TABLE=all_llm_moves_only,BANK=instances_n7_private_v1,SEEDS="0 1 2",MIN_ACCEPT=7,BUDGET_USD=36,EST_USD=2.0,CONCURRENCY=2 fill_game_structure_cell.sbatch # analysis python analyze_game_structure_generality.py --config game_structure_generality_v1/config_final.json --out game_structure_generality_v1/analysis_final ``` Every cell's exact command is the first line of its `run.log`. Quorum cells use tables `all_llm_quorum_4`, `all_llm_moves_only_quorum_4`, `all_rational_quorum_4` with `MIN_ACCEPT=4`. ## Cluster paths Run dirs: `/nlp/scr/siddharth/ii_mats/rational_agents/gsg_v1__*`; transcripts: `/nlp/scr/siddharth/ii_mats/transcripts/rational_agents/game_structure_generality_v1/`; Slurm logs: `experiments/rational_agents/game_structure_generality_v1/slurm/`. No wandb runs. Total API spend $718.79 (all smokes included). Related: `siddharthmb/2026.RA.Five-Seat-MovesOnly-Control` (the original Opus 5 bank-v1 mute control), `siddharthmb/2026.RA.Quorum-Rounds-Sweep` (Bayesian quorum sweep, bank v2).