"""Step 5 of the ARIMA experiments: ACF/PACF identification on the 6 EDA cities (window 1969-2018). Each series is made stationary two ways, matching the two hypotheses of Step 4: * detrended: residual of an OLS line on year (trend-stationary, d=0 + trend) * differenced: first difference (difference-stationary, d=1) ACF and PACF (lags 1..10) are drawn with ±1.96/√N bands. Course rule: a PACF cut-off after lag p suggests AR(p); an ACF cut-off after lag q suggests MA(q); both decaying suggests ARMA. The suggestion below is mechanical (number of leading significant lags, capped at 2) and only proposes candidates; the backtest decides. Outputs: results/arima_eda/acf_pacf_.png and results/arima_acf_pacf.csv Run: python code/arima_identify.py """ import matplotlib matplotlib.use("Agg") import matplotlib.pyplot as plt import numpy as np import pandas as pd from statsmodels.tsa.stattools import acf, pacf from arima_prep import EDA_CITIES, prepare from common import CUTOFF_YEAR, METRICS, ROOT, load_annual, long_valid START = 1969 NLAGS = 10 OUT = ROOT / "results" / "arima_eda" def leading(sig): """Number of consecutive significant lags starting at lag 1.""" n = 0 for s in sig: if not s: break n += 1 return n def suggest(acf_sig, pacf_sig): """(p, q) from the course rule; both capped at 2.""" la, lp = leading(acf_sig), leading(pacf_sig) if la == 0 and lp == 0: return 0, 0, "white noise" late_a, late_p = acf_sig[la + 1:].sum(), pacf_sig[lp + 1:].sum() if lp and late_p == 0 and (la > lp or la == 0 or late_a > 0): return min(lp, 2), 0, "PACF cuts off -> AR" if la and late_a == 0 and (lp > la or lp == 0 or late_p > 0): return 0, min(la, 2), "ACF cuts off -> MA" return min(max(lp, 1), 2), min(max(la, 1), 2), "both decay -> ARMA" def transforms(y, years): b = np.polyfit(years, y, 1) return {"detrended": y - np.polyval(b, years), "differenced": np.diff(y)} def main(): lv = long_valid(load_annual()) prep = {m: prepare(lv, m, CUTOFF_YEAR, START) for m in METRICS} rows = [] for cid, name in EDA_CITIES.items(): fig, ax = plt.subplots(4, 4, figsize=(16, 12)) fig.suptitle(f"{name} ({cid}), {START}-{CUTOFF_YEAR}: ACF / PACF of the stationary series (band ±1.96/√N)") for i, m in enumerate(METRICS): s = prep[m][cid] for j, (tname, z) in enumerate(transforms(s.y, s.years.astype(float)).items()): band = 1.96 / np.sqrt(len(z)) a = acf(z, nlags=NLAGS, fft=False)[1:] p = pacf(z, nlags=NLAGS, method="ywm")[1:] for k, (vals, lab) in enumerate([(a, "ACF"), (p, "PACF")]): axx = ax[i, 2 * j + k] axx.bar(range(1, NLAGS + 1), vals, width=0.4, color=np.where(np.abs(vals) > band, "C3", "C0")) axx.axhline(band, ls="--", c="r", lw=0.8); axx.axhline(-band, ls="--", c="r", lw=0.8) axx.axhline(0, c="k", lw=0.5); axx.set_ylim(-0.8, 0.8) axx.set_title(f"{m} | {tname} | {lab}", fontsize=9) sa, sp = np.abs(a) > band, np.abs(p) > band pq = suggest(sa, sp) rows.append(dict(city=name, ID=cid, metric=m, transform=tname, n=len(z), acf_sig_lags=",".join(str(l + 1) for l in np.where(sa)[0]) or "-", pacf_sig_lags=",".join(str(l + 1) for l in np.where(sp)[0]) or "-", acf1=round(a[0], 2), pacf1=round(p[0], 2), p=pq[0], q=pq[1], pattern=pq[2], suggested=f"ARIMA({pq[0]},{0 if tname == 'detrended' else 1},{pq[1]})" + (" + trend" if tname == "detrended" else ""))) fig.tight_layout() fig.savefig(OUT / f"acf_pacf_{name.lower()}.png", dpi=100) plt.close(fig) t = pd.DataFrame(rows) t.to_csv(ROOT / "results" / "arima_acf_pacf.csv", index=False) pd.set_option("display.width", 250) print(t.drop(columns=["ID"]).to_string(index=False)) print("\nSuggested orders, count over 6 cities x 4 metrics:") print(t.groupby(["transform", "suggested"]).size().to_string()) if __name__ == "__main__": main()