{ "version": "v2", "arms": { "RAW": "RAW (baseline)", "V0_CHANNEL_ONLY": "v0 Channel-only", "V2_CHANNEL_ONLY": "v2 Channel-only", "V0_RAW_ADD": "v0 RAW+ADD", "V2_RAW_ADD": "v2 RAW+ADD" }, "protocol": "rev-3 ยง7", "split_manifest_sha256": "36aea05770a9ae346e3fccc9b5968e85690fa4699c6cd93406495a2a93e449bb", "personas": "P_val (18)", "sealed_never_touched": { "P_test": 12, "Q_test": 8 }, "bootstrap_draws": 10000, "metric": "pair-mean exact purchase accuracy over 2 byte-identical runs", "results": { "Q_dev (seen, 20)|wave3|RAW (baseline)": { "accuracy": 0.6541666666666667, "n_cells": 360, "repeat_disagreement": 0.1527777777777778 }, "Q_dev (seen, 20)|wave3|v0 Channel-only": { "accuracy": 0.6361111111111111, "n_cells": 360, "repeat_disagreement": 0.15555555555555556, "gain": -0.01805555555555555, "ci_low": -0.07361111111111113, "ci_high": 0.03472222222222223, "improved": 7, "tied": 1, "harmed": 10, "n_personas": 18 }, "Q_dev (seen, 20)|wave3|v2 Channel-only": { "accuracy": 0.5916666666666667, "n_cells": 360, "repeat_disagreement": 0.16111111111111112, "gain": -0.06250000000000001, "ci_low": -0.11944444444444446, "ci_high": 0.0013888888888888948, "improved": 4, "tied": 1, "harmed": 13, "n_personas": 18 }, "Q_dev (seen, 20)|wave3|v0 RAW+ADD": { "accuracy": 0.7013888888888888, "n_cells": 360, "repeat_disagreement": 0.13055555555555556, "gain": 0.047222222222222214, "ci_low": -0.0013888888888888885, "ci_high": 0.09305555555555554, "improved": 12, "tied": 1, "harmed": 5, "n_personas": 18 }, "Q_dev (seen, 20)|wave3|v2 RAW+ADD": { "accuracy": 0.6736111111111112, "n_cells": 360, "repeat_disagreement": 0.1638888888888889, "gain": 0.019444444444444445, "ci_low": -0.023611111111111107, "ci_high": 0.05972222222222222, "improved": 11, "tied": 1, "harmed": 6, "n_personas": 18 }, "Q_dev (seen, 20)|wave4|RAW (baseline)": { "accuracy": 0.6347222222222222, "n_cells": 360, "repeat_disagreement": 0.1527777777777778 }, "Q_dev (seen, 20)|wave4|v0 Channel-only": { "accuracy": 0.6472222222222223, "n_cells": 360, "repeat_disagreement": 0.15555555555555556, "gain": 0.012499999999999999, "ci_low": -0.044444444444444446, "ci_high": 0.06388888888888891, "improved": 9, "tied": 1, "harmed": 8, "n_personas": 18 }, "Q_dev (seen, 20)|wave4|v2 Channel-only": { "accuracy": 0.5972222222222222, "n_cells": 360, "repeat_disagreement": 0.16111111111111112, "gain": -0.0375, "ci_low": -0.09166666666666667, "ci_high": 0.020833333333333336, "improved": 5, "tied": 2, "harmed": 11, "n_personas": 18 }, "Q_dev (seen, 20)|wave4|v0 RAW+ADD": { "accuracy": 0.6819444444444445, "n_cells": 360, "repeat_disagreement": 0.13055555555555556, "gain": 0.04722222222222223, "ci_low": 0.013888888888888892, "ci_high": 0.07916666666666668, "improved": 12, "tied": 1, "harmed": 5, "n_personas": 18 }, "Q_dev (seen, 20)|wave4|v2 RAW+ADD": { "accuracy": 0.6513888888888889, "n_cells": 360, "repeat_disagreement": 0.1638888888888889, "gain": 0.016666666666666673, "ci_low": -0.02361111111111111, "ci_high": 0.058333333333333334, "improved": 11, "tied": 0, "harmed": 7, "n_personas": 18 }, "Q_val (unseen, 12)|wave3|RAW (baseline)": { "accuracy": 0.5995370370370371, "n_cells": 216, "repeat_disagreement": 0.125 }, "Q_val (unseen, 12)|wave3|v0 Channel-only": { "accuracy": 0.6319444444444444, "n_cells": 216, "repeat_disagreement": 0.1527777777777778, "gain": 0.03240740740740741, "ci_low": -0.02314814814814815, "ci_high": 0.09027777777777779, "improved": 8, "tied": 4, "harmed": 6, "n_personas": 18 }, "Q_val (unseen, 12)|wave3|v2 Channel-only": { "accuracy": 0.5694444444444444, "n_cells": 216, "repeat_disagreement": 0.16666666666666666, "gain": -0.03009259259259259, "ci_low": -0.10185185185185183, "ci_high": 0.03703703703703704, "improved": 8, "tied": 1, "harmed": 9, "n_personas": 18 }, "Q_val (unseen, 12)|wave3|v0 RAW+ADD": { "accuracy": 0.6412037037037037, "n_cells": 216, "repeat_disagreement": 0.16203703703703703, "gain": 0.04166666666666667, "ci_low": -0.002314814814814813, "ci_high": 0.09027777777777778, "improved": 10, "tied": 3, "harmed": 5, "n_personas": 18 }, "Q_val (unseen, 12)|wave3|v2 RAW+ADD": { "accuracy": 0.6041666666666666, "n_cells": 216, "repeat_disagreement": 0.14351851851851852, "gain": 0.004629629629629625, "ci_low": -0.04629629629629631, "ci_high": 0.05092592592592592, "improved": 8, "tied": 4, "harmed": 6, "n_personas": 18 }, "Q_val (unseen, 12)|wave4|RAW (baseline)": { "accuracy": 0.5717592592592593, "n_cells": 216, "repeat_disagreement": 0.125 }, "Q_val (unseen, 12)|wave4|v0 Channel-only": { "accuracy": 0.5995370370370371, "n_cells": 216, "repeat_disagreement": 0.1527777777777778, "gain": 0.027777777777777776, "ci_low": -0.020833333333333336, "ci_high": 0.08333333333333333, "improved": 8, "tied": 3, "harmed": 7, "n_personas": 18 }, "Q_val (unseen, 12)|wave4|v2 Channel-only": { "accuracy": 0.5370370370370371, "n_cells": 216, "repeat_disagreement": 0.16666666666666666, "gain": -0.03472222222222224, "ci_low": -0.1111111111111111, "ci_high": 0.03935185185185185, "improved": 8, "tied": 0, "harmed": 10, "n_personas": 18 }, "Q_val (unseen, 12)|wave4|v0 RAW+ADD": { "accuracy": 0.6226851851851852, "n_cells": 216, "repeat_disagreement": 0.16203703703703703, "gain": 0.05092592592592592, "ci_low": 0.0023148148148148125, "ci_high": 0.10185185185185185, "improved": 11, "tied": 4, "harmed": 3, "n_personas": 18 }, "Q_val (unseen, 12)|wave4|v2 RAW+ADD": { "accuracy": 0.5856481481481481, "n_cells": 216, "repeat_disagreement": 0.14351851851851852, "gain": 0.013888888888888883, "ci_low": -0.03935185185185185, "ci_high": 0.0625, "improved": 9, "tied": 2, "harmed": 7, "n_personas": 18 } } }