{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-45b6d43ce4f879ea", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-62686533ab9819ca", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_abide1_s1_DISC": "d149229cabf3622aabe60a88f8fd2ccba8a1bababb8a89f9588298cbda47f01e", "neg_p_fishing_abide1_s1_REP": "cf8067788142e3b759f3ce04dd1b88185ea04ac164d681c3044a7e1f456389a7"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_abide1_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_abide1_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "6ad36422eff5146825455d95f691eb8c61c201a2374da16202608366efde8656", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 4, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "4cec938b3cc0167eadd7a2fd538f87daee508512f72cbc4341bb80823b44fc81", "task_id": "ncb21-task-00309f172caa8af0"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-7c173adc5485d7ce", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-405a074cf5dcdbfc", "cohort_content_hashes": {"HCP_DISC": "4bfd66afa7e3af1ad63ed1a3d1fdc1662e370064e97e927de95b8f783b7886a8", "HCP_REP": "0cc8dc280e6a961585c8c2c53414db8d8cb581c59cf2beaef3e3731c5eca9eba"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "16e3344a19df2df40b443de551044ada704a798addc401e46e0ba2c6a512e9ef", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "phen_fluid_composite", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "aac73fe6997e05ad12fbd4c366bea8d0d2e6227b344dd34f1524e189b4229886", "task_id": "ncb21-task-009b694780a8795f"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-c752b6285a527e82", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-b474387ff120a886", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_adni_fmri_s3_DISC": "a2745e3a3f004471c0c1cb52a86b1540bce9cf385632aa25133c44ece3d8ea45", "neg_random_label_adni_fmri_s3_REP": "2662793cdb5419ddc322ddd6d5f95ffce2abbc87104f23b94794aff3049d8ccf"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_adni_fmri_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_adni_fmri_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "13c3e83f7d82a856cd81e6c2332cb60472bc39f3cfed1e8a76ee6f87d1472110", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "86b2974dec47cfe675234dac9df061c63f8df490a8843be8f5070787aae15b61", "task_id": "ncb21-task-01e4680be5d29eea"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-c1b8f2bee08cd388", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-aaacaefa3cd0aff9", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "d46636f3da4068ed9d063888b255bfc9edf81dd39fd3163b1453e0c6c870e0e5", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "c22b1ef3c893f0a23438307825c096a7e25def121b911fb21b41704c795732be", "task_id": "ncb21-task-0244deeb8ae44e7b"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-f8671ab0121baaa8", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-a7e18317ac041892", "cohort_content_hashes": {"HCP_Aging_REP": "e4682154e236a020f91b7932fe75341cf7a0eed865089e5172cad83a6989e965", "HCP_DISC": "4bfd66afa7e3af1ad63ed1a3d1fdc1662e370064e97e927de95b8f783b7886a8"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_Aging_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "3aa3378788f142e1ffb4035f90345858135bcb44ce2f5f9a0b7547faf999ccf1", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "phen_fluid_composite", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 84, "multiverse": false, "pattern_corr": false, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication, pattern_corr, region_replication_fraction; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; pattern_corr=-0.008; dice=1.000; region_replication_fraction=0.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "e6ea8b359b25115978aa67e0220182187ab2746da55cada4bae5fd3b01a76d9b", "task_id": "ncb21-task-025c8e1301361564"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-3ecc90fbaac44bfe", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-cf9c20754a90a5e3", "cohort_content_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "a3e6f1609ea823c9216310eaea1cf3e54443ed385d8f2c4ccb0374907756646b", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "4cc03f072ec07c42f4ceaa18a43bd2065e0d5c508c7d70b6115b8ccc60ee1062"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-02aad5d5f16fb6aa/NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-02aad5d5f16fb6aa/NACC_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "463c22c45cba6fe50d5f35c45b5f478e25529ee5ac18229097a5966683f9e3cc", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 3101, "p": 0.3928655325930515, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "ncb_random_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "5fde50942a8bd8a6b220f8ce946911e82480752163e79fe0a93b48cc90ee5e78", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "9ea589e3ef18c559163c47a9819e7c95a786653a3f273ca76d8bdd6b82aad40f"}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "4168f17b7d1adc3393c8d7f45054d0573cac480867ba5bf26ab344dbafaca7ef", "task_id": "ncb21-task-02aad5d5f16fb6aa"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-822a9e3fd7a9cc40", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-013786007c57614a", "cohort_content_hashes": {"BSNIP2_REP": "5a68458b6ca1d3ceb62243f2dcf1fda0209a9d2685669530b7e4c5f279a32f23", "COBRE_DISC": "f53b3405d06487a9d268b89165605cc0ed60d2c3a68e41f8ebe73660d9916d79", "COBRE_REP": "4a81a6fb00f3834982866da08d40f58816c7907a2c62838ae1fad68fd5bb18dc", "ChineseSZ_REP": "9c94c02e8066411af69f22387e526434c8c412c6df30ff250b1c7bc75f5514a8", "FBIRN_REP": "132788e0b0576e4f01ac0ac8dcbb232f2f105aea4693833ef74a59a45118b33a", "Olin_SZ_REP": "d7bef7b3dc92844bbfc9976c601ed84734ccd0a9b19af3571dddda43dc156167"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/Olin_SZ_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "4099b181353bf2643f60d2720882e770c8f72e4789ccee6aa9812551c83dbfbc", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "under_powered", "rationale": "Failed gates: power, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.790 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "under_powered", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "524af09191daf752e345dec2ea764a90d3825b7581afecbffa4efef39a238bae", "task_id": "ncb21-task-02b88fc3865fef3e"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-ddd73764077ec103", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-1e546dbf6e23c75e", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "232132a84602d2e002eff364fa44085a7d831aca45cc3db13afd94a377e6b66e", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "e722d3550084f1d8aed04e44b0e6662f7a7d342b8abd67c8fc52eec91e78415f"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "6ee98eca02a96c6eba2924d7ec96cb56acee8354bda6195b04848e11597b2be4", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.512 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "be043beaeb415b98396db9bc93cc3de012d0224a8f29acf2f84b2b1422013b26", "task_id": "ncb21-task-02f91dae643fb08f"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-a20d5751ea756186", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-04e1f27e0473d18b", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_DISC": "7f42f7518c34775c8e5cf7c590a1fe44f226f40a7b899e71223b56ef43411663", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "733dee68b79c090ad6200ee8677b7b19c49bd7cefe5b9151dba81d3c1e4a97ac", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "direction_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "direction_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 82.62187260647742, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 82.62187260647742, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=direction_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=82.6"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "311c124249331c7aef08826e4fb3a7bc1285d43db382c4bb3d590d2f84c0b1ca", "task_id": "ncb21-task-03389888b8f63226"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-7fcbe86bd9b2c850", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-cfc74c3b32933460", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_ukb_s2_DISC": "b01e8bcf08d8765412341cf8bc24409c834a37d40ae5e3be314348388f0ab9f7", "neg_random_label_ukb_s2_REP": "ce80269ad3d6cea6229d317b51ad72e92c24205648e654d7d3cc9a4e698e91e6"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_ukb_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_ukb_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "e84d1001af213b86dd4890ddfab13ee8c99a8a28f7b9aedf4a593dd89ddb771f", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "b257e9a1984195a22a881d49ec7b48df34efea7e54c3857ebd26f23c8b8a68e2", "task_id": "ncb21-task-034634bca9728653"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-6ee77e7e1b81ebdc", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-6306bbc5eab11c13", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_ukb_s3_DISC": "2a490ff524957d8318c60a77c16c0476f7508f39a14f9cb8466a2157b9b07dd5", "neg_site_confound_ukb_s3_REP": "140a0738094eaecd3f837c678ce7fdb6694b1f837a86bce46cf47aeb586bcd21"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_ukb_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_ukb_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "76c1bae31a8df3d8886b7bf7cad7f5957026742bba5e7a7268ddca31b836ad5f", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 9813, "p": 0.0, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 9813, "p": 0.0, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "229fb3c98efd118df99f60975c1bf41a7ffd66720fe87a817852ef37b8cd1d5a", "task_id": "ncb21-task-04c30ff0d802c156"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-0558f914b0d8e6af", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-bc5aaec2f20751d8", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_hcp_aging_s3_DISC": "bbeaab5c5efa2d6f4a9c27dd1e793c4442daa1deebc58c21b9267cefaf573d90", "neg_random_label_hcp_aging_s3_REP": "2f42bdd000b090f57d92992edd32e08c83eb99ba091ed4d5b8c0f31999f47178"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_hcp_aging_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_hcp_aging_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "bb1caa7a708fc92fd0fb2c1adf65ff20b61318475238106f80298fbfec1786ac", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "6d9275633c5a277123f0f9953242e9b236f05c3cc540dc5c2766ec721e27b77b", "task_id": "ncb21-task-04fa81db8cc4cf61"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-530077d063ef312f", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-e507a8817a27654c", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "232132a84602d2e002eff364fa44085a7d831aca45cc3db13afd94a377e6b66e", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "e722d3550084f1d8aed04e44b0e6662f7a7d342b8abd67c8fc52eec91e78415f"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "de17aec494faa4662cde70f7525c77023e231b8f144ce7f9afe5adf4e5e1d947", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.485 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "9af235cac3d8559cd424baf74074101c823c383d18e9e772cba2750b4b823550", "task_id": "ncb21-task-056b7bd49e634bc6"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-7320409f0609fb6c", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-71735b3c63a20cf8", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_oasis3_fmri_s3_DISC": "724e1b1e4057a7ccc7a941014fe7296696225ad364145c80b2473905dbd403cb", "neg_p_fishing_oasis3_fmri_s3_REP": "3984130017ec409fce722aa4f1a31d4beaab08b059d51e0b69cc1621e96719a8"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_oasis3_fmri_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_oasis3_fmri_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "362fdf694dac72dd54c14d993c230ab6efd10c56d7a254f92e2e7a0616526688", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 24, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "c5f3ee0640e8d21c1018184aec240376c2de6e1e980cc8e647c09461fe611144", "task_id": "ncb21-task-05a3373bee2fa7be"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-a36ed4355870c674", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-96bda5a4fd2938d9", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_DISC": "7f42f7518c34775c8e5cf7c590a1fe44f226f40a7b899e71223b56ef43411663", "ADNI_REP": "56cd379d34a3e7f93f341c1014daa9b3a9146606a68d4720d4513d09e35d73b6"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "2a23061a487e0eec1deefc371e088d8d594dced40a05cde6df075b1c4b51befc", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "6ce517f6cbbf0141af8ae93a721d65bc5ab1434abbd8bf6717fc5ab6cac8465a", "task_id": "ncb21-task-06ebe3ba5846d880"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-531f4a09678d2222", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-5cecef89df0696ad", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "9535a92cf5c6b1b3c1d6b359c5cb9173a866ec8a08475282338a4fdb3b963a48", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "1297d499510cb7a69a50e2b231cd6181c274fc6d2048dbd503502e2d5cc8a823", "task_id": "ncb21-task-072a14c8383581f4"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-ec4fe05bc8c819f7", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-4172455c089aaf48", "cohort_content_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "a3e6f1609ea823c9216310eaea1cf3e54443ed385d8f2c4ccb0374907756646b", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "4cc03f072ec07c42f4ceaa18a43bd2065e0d5c508c7d70b6115b8ccc60ee1062"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "f6b7f3213ba75e3874730bdd5fdcb9f11021a5d5df54ef68e157b37960bf01f2", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 1964, "p": 4.750055361533447e-83, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 1964, "p": 4.750055361533447e-83, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "d3fdda6d49027934668d4d54b0430782b1a7db680b4bccde832d95506dad0ffa", "task_id": "ncb21-task-07ed20b971d64049"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-8875a7bf33df9519", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-1b9279bb902fca77", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "d51e315524c51beab8dc6a1926caefc0db5e5766f2a9072a44606c4f5728ab61", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "8b27b636bf8fff2f2c152304397d37d18498dd11f8a0638122fb90ef29c7c0a3", "task_id": "ncb21-task-084549e934cf6e3a"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-ee7abc3b89d1d4cc", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-92aa1d768c652c63", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_underpowered_ukb_s2_DISC": "afdd009d8d384c23fcac95946e9767ae2cbf051730609bb198190bd8e77dc592", "neg_underpowered_ukb_s2_REP": "b62104ae48cf1bd1f8ede8456b6ccecd38db25d685fc0a43e4ceb2c1a47a1070"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_ukb_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_ukb_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "2c381131daa2c9cd9b7baa028406145561888e44280e1631e17b7f35b10f7b0d", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": false, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "under_powered", "rationale": "Failed gates: power; power=0.512 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "under_powered", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "377484c2c7028a0bbdd919a5c2ed051f0205e33e4d006e3acb9e3ca611645446", "task_id": "ncb21-task-087634b4ab4aa55a"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-7fbc16c903db656b", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-b9be54474c6bcd6d", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_abcd_s3_DISC": "cc1a8d8b881249e436bc62cdc951d916cbd0e40e6b2618d0cfd483ea69532dcb", "neg_site_confound_abcd_s3_REP": "2f51effaf8e258e7f2e388163491928e9ede8908ee8b30ba81eeaaba797cfb5f"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_abcd_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_abcd_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "004b7d069d69b074b3cf63ea87d6e8646a7ed8852a1fe661974c5341c7bc0b34", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 2598, "p": 3.3975427972341566e-205, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 2598, "p": 3.3975427972341566e-205, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "de8eb4361426b7af62c3850a53c13f7cf26775971d3bc5fb3039bfe8794ae3a2", "task_id": "ncb21-task-08b236935af05ed0"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-d4c0b42a60357a5d", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-07243d3805f75684", "cohort_content_hashes": {"COBRE_DISC": "f53b3405d06487a9d268b89165605cc0ed60d2c3a68e41f8ebe73660d9916d79", "COBRE_REP": "4a81a6fb00f3834982866da08d40f58816c7907a2c62838ae1fad68fd5bb18dc"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "33c124057330e497c88ed91fb38de98311eb6560ac7cbfbac35b03346ead8375", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "under_powered", "rationale": "Failed gates: power, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.790 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "under_powered", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "e0973680710d769e0e5f10a85bdb32fd54cb5999c8effcd1e3ccdd9d76e3b561", "task_id": "ncb21-task-08c01f90e76c8f85"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-81bc0f58011fdf7d", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-403de616edfedcd9", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_fbirn_s3_DISC": "c612e7a5485b2c640d40a6e053d23246711bdbb4f8cde75a1c81984ab0e3fe34", "neg_random_label_fbirn_s3_REP": "db3b17771487aea555cb023745a14681a2751e893380a0cc94fd914c8f76212f"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_fbirn_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_fbirn_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "39d960aa728b19c2d4d904370eaeb2f87dd3d4b2db3de3812966f944e265afeb", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.703 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "385c727c98bf681883ff537f449d1a38ec0febc2e05fac25de54c443472e824c", "task_id": "ncb21-task-0941644e02f5107d"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-4f6f45a81e8e3370", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-dce9149fdd02f427", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "17f1b7891a80a1788857cadfc9853acdef4d0ee926f4ed9632c23586d55d3999", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 84, "multiverse": false, "pattern_corr": false, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication, pattern_corr, region_replication_fraction; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; pattern_corr=-0.461; dice=1.000; region_replication_fraction=0.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "616c2209fb214dadd900d50296386817908e4750628275b58b290ed5781c9953", "task_id": "ncb21-task-09b5e9d053af98b1"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-cc2914e36309cad4", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-bbaa0135d123bc46", "cohort_content_hashes": {"OASIS3_DISC": "8a048aaff562775d7c80f7027c9d8bb56cc738b7563d25ca06af7cb33df89d31", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "5a2697eea377b0648e6da104bb225d473b0e76ff54ae78aef41c7887af00942c", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "fs_version", "levels": 4, "n": 780, "p": 0.07356894195085882, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "cafce62d7a736dbced52faeac11e0fe7fc3e5a9861fa265b78a659cd40e074bb", "task_id": "ncb21-task-0a1ed327c94ac9a5"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-79182620041b5799", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-6f869175f077cbee", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c", "ADNI_fMRI_REP": "77b228db80400e42457cdc1a715f338fa645e8901922ef5f6f7c7f7d3d176c13"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_fMRI_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "91d982ea2678ab2a785b001163705d4942977c15b29c47e4bf3407b14dff3aa1", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "412c17a890233e1a92cb945675d2357b121b9539c5ebaf26ca5c12df43dac28f", "task_id": "ncb21-task-0a3153ea01de1eb9"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-1f13a7aee9fc1c7d", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-f8e154cef1919bd8", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "1b158627e0b7cd9a42ae25eb8c69b964a2a55224349e9a94fea50f1166684e85", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "6f6f86ee7add46e3927bd93e8cc148ca6410984c997d03807bb4d9a95c0140db", "task_id": "ncb21-task-0a70018376a8881b"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-d3b9d78a966173c6", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-f1fd3853e5f7936c", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "dce5f33b064a3fd73076ab2f80a6d90db5b33774b98dae6542ef09b43ac7ae0d", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "136a5afa859b8073710c8e91359ccd3cd3122ab78ef251b59f82abc66d6e86ea", "task_id": "ncb21-task-0aedc228888c5eae"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-f936b668e13706b3", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-664c1cc7549186bb", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_hcp_aging_s2_DISC": "fd94e38caeec55fb07ad6cafb5a710ce1f7971244123a451f9aaae2733fa3907", "neg_p_fishing_hcp_aging_s2_REP": "b444b5a03b57b64d5892464692ca6ea1b8c00111ece06d3b2410c0ccff95a176"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_hcp_aging_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_hcp_aging_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "2de2cb063cc2144d0eb6bc514d1fb623ee963f8237a84f5e7066ae111ff2f9f5", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 24, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "4338e5e5aaf74d55b330f6bb39d0b881dc14ed310ec806d757f899cdc0bb7567", "task_id": "ncb21-task-0b173883f31dedd8"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-91575e683551f750", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-2a478afd6f28d2fa", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADHD200_DISC": "2ed4e2ddb4d8a3845dbec23c0b31652d26fdefe209e61fc4cdd3b636ebabb4fd", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "07f0e3e610d491cdcd712f4ad7609c161993147b973479cb9e6eb3d12beb2aea", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 2, "multiverse": true, "pattern_corr": false, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication, pattern_corr, region_replication_fraction; replication=non_replicated_cohort_mismatch; pattern_corr=nan; dice=0.000; region_replication_fraction=0.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "a1b6879e567ccf93f9642a1a621c8ba93a2330accd7b1efda1dc58dbc738be32", "task_id": "ncb21-task-0b3199bf9e229ded"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-25e7ef2da7f86162", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-12a18cb34d5192c1", "cohort_content_hashes": {"UKB_DISC": "8f50d0d10f4265b3538407235a0af91a7bb4d1a733daea42a655d4931e0bfdd3", "UKB_REP": "6da6a67cb610290a28f97b077dd2aa0e82c39161e4b3c622857cb54843df2357"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/UKB_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/UKB_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "6014715f3ca8c6f1410dc1939e269d6f518da191ef3b2719b42b0a2d97dccc1f", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 8.688416907584775, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 8.688416907584775, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=8.7"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "f9af3321c9622911c7c8563f3a012b5b4ab6aeb06cd3e5124098afe5938f7b0c", "task_id": "ncb21-task-0c8a0e13f677ff47"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-f091755e09ca7583", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-dab8e37863d8d14d", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_abide1_s3_DISC": "a84eaf0463d144d4db891d78c5bd03aacc8a325757010c4ad91c518c990cdd63", "neg_p_fishing_abide1_s3_REP": "ad19d2c23418027ead90e99beb84e762b250760915f33b05bde467154e28a5b9"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_abide1_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_abide1_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "6a285a2a98be3c3d4ba0a593d44774e0f96291f05eb2b7f74043a2786926d74c", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 4, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "f941b43b87e04c045ecdb213b737be509d353e74246ef37523e71d870280c077", "task_id": "ncb21-task-0c9246076c5951c0"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-3ba54e0248b29adb", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-dfdc0c58a7eeae26", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "c624398168356fe0a64406f04e1ef0bb339049821615eb78d5f6deff519e5ebc", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "c70bad95c0f1a3b3ed08cd77155bdac0530668cf3542d6a0ae30900a35d58730", "task_id": "ncb21-task-0d6282b64ac621ac"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-4cedbc48040eac27", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-a69d4cf90c42528e", "cohort_content_hashes": {"BSNIP2_REP": "5a68458b6ca1d3ceb62243f2dcf1fda0209a9d2685669530b7e4c5f279a32f23", "COBRE_REP": "4a81a6fb00f3834982866da08d40f58816c7907a2c62838ae1fad68fd5bb18dc", "ChineseSZ_REP": "9c94c02e8066411af69f22387e526434c8c412c6df30ff250b1c7bc75f5514a8", "FBIRN_REP": "132788e0b0576e4f01ac0ac8dcbb232f2f105aea4693833ef74a59a45118b33a", "Olin_SZ_REP": "d7bef7b3dc92844bbfc9976c601ed84734ccd0a9b19af3571dddda43dc156167"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/Olin_SZ_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "c29155b242e393201259e54e02c34fbdfc0bb6dc834777dd008f0f6080e4b6cb", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "59459ee94f5440ecfe098b28d59c3601742f184046c32be0c43feed7985edd91", "task_id": "ncb21-task-0e2008c7cc9b82ba"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-709359ed74346ba9", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-84f6b29693a06f19", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_DISC": "7f42f7518c34775c8e5cf7c590a1fe44f226f40a7b899e71223b56ef43411663", "ADNI_REP": "56cd379d34a3e7f93f341c1014daa9b3a9146606a68d4720d4513d09e35d73b6"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "286c50aeca96f59c655d0b107495eb40d818917f4ef942fbd3ba32b36ddbc51e", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "328cf094dfb4f32b0ee0a7a03f1dbb90a3100cff4098c0b790d726f6d594bf1e", "task_id": "ncb21-task-0e9b04ade45505c5"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-1856779cf86705e9", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-64c3fdca757c0a26", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_adni_s1_DISC": "28d7dc4456992efa76d5e60a13ccecbcd4ffd74c1f9a73458fb30b68165d6441", "neg_site_confound_adni_s1_REP": "85190f24620363773689e48d93ac4e17357f727d534627c5414c8abfa29fb7cc"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_adni_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_adni_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "6b75e5551304ec28107cb0e1efd5f9c1c3b201a6a64ae72752a07604965f86ea", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 458, "p": 1.5737396889634738e-37, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 458, "p": 1.5737396889634738e-37, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "b1a63eab73c6043a7707140d26bfd57eca80ef7a7fbaad0d6df92088c9c5e6af", "task_id": "ncb21-task-0f0dfd7dd1fef57a"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-87da7810f0a4515f", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-cebf60d51174652c", "cohort_content_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "a3e6f1609ea823c9216310eaea1cf3e54443ed385d8f2c4ccb0374907756646b", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "4cc03f072ec07c42f4ceaa18a43bd2065e0d5c508c7d70b6115b8ccc60ee1062"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "66a62f84f221ba5033c89d02c6193e8cfa0f0bf763b8a770d9c84fb9f3f30144", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 1964, "p": 4.750055361533447e-83, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 1964, "p": 4.750055361533447e-83, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness, multiplicity, multiverse, replication; confound_incomplete; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "5e1ee4e6cf87736bfab3cdda372176691a292ee8cbac51b5c54c231407d077db", "task_id": "ncb21-task-101b0d9b0a5af630"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-f91a2cdb84ef6798", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-5ca8c16bd5c5711f", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_cobre_s1_DISC": "7511257c444948803a692b5b9e4f4413972a3777b63793136cb1eecd71b6b9f9", "neg_p_fishing_cobre_s1_REP": "5d65dc72b7fde4622014f54fc201cb957f7231307a9066d313196ef41100bbbe"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_cobre_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_cobre_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "171f4e530d8f8faf72fb527926a198c85b3f41ab736fa7252c2e017a41d6ba2b", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 4, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.457 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "851737ea0964efd8e51ea87849e48894553ab3bce820915cafbb891e41d8bbca", "task_id": "ncb21-task-10879e6df75209dd"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-792cb959ece29063", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-f2b8eb141d5f5e8d", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_hcp_s1_DISC": "ca41daf6c50026408e2735f82f44aa02ff9ef4779bd0e735879526620219a638", "neg_p_fishing_hcp_s1_REP": "79484449ffc2c8b4adb304e20e9c98715a740f87108e4a0c48d1e3fc24ac29d1"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_hcp_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_hcp_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "ba696ff9ee31428c7462934ad290512acdec6eb6bbdf0ac117390c74fe729a72", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 24, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "8752247150c6b0fe36f7ca1be972a8906ddf70585cdaa7a3abfcb62190ad8057", "task_id": "ncb21-task-112b180189fb0cc4"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-dd4beff29754d17d", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-7df7782e960f7604", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_underpowered_adni_fmri_s3_DISC": "1eb156b7aed2672ca1d2f0d78d5d0ead1ab36849ae6706616934ab8dfcfe91f4", "neg_underpowered_adni_fmri_s3_REP": "f666fb4674b6d6b239c384436d87b0866c5cce2915ac812cf66407aced0be0ef"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_adni_fmri_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_adni_fmri_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "e3a7b7c311b24d6664bb014eb9a890a776d290b8666303aef4ca8a404a721307", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse; power=0.548 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "d08966516bfaa1ac16fa45d25e416500f34a03ed86805110120d1573eaa78c60", "task_id": "ncb21-task-1196ff0f12a7bd6d"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-61274f38e0112edd", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-13730644ff0763bc", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "507bf9ce64489cb48e417aaaa991273f7f19b8d0e7a87bd5d197580409a3f2e0", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "7d25398f375d85988d95bc79eb0f3cccc0cb58999ec06c4c9d554ff2e86e13cb", "task_id": "ncb21-task-121e269865518790"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-5f9f5d74554e0614", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-71f4eea14cf8be79", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "232132a84602d2e002eff364fa44085a7d831aca45cc3db13afd94a377e6b66e", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "e722d3550084f1d8aed04e44b0e6662f7a7d342b8abd67c8fc52eec91e78415f"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "f3caa933576a3668247550a9c13bf3bc6538d0554c03f098f9100597ff5c5d11", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.512 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "860dc2543c9a43cbdd27d003d5508ab8c9e0af6cce74f6d33bc7d294ff47206f", "task_id": "ncb21-task-1248ee49d6b353a8"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-e23fddfb3f829797", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-7c0e3dd3e8f1a658", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_cross_nonrep_adhd200_abcd_s3_DISC": "cd87879ee2742ba3849c318b52145e7f1074c369baf569e352a50fb051a7b0be", "neg_cross_nonrep_adhd200_abcd_s3_REP": "3527b7e4ec8722ff7ca0fb78a421374e9f267d2adeb39fd6fa19c0a675a08588"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_cross_nonrep_adhd200_abcd_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_cross_nonrep_adhd200_abcd_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "c48f935d3177aaafc916242210a918d020c35646298284afac446c4363c3ddf1", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 24, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "babd825472b290aaa94e24bacc6c32099e11c5cb7cf74492afc02860c757b4c8", "task_id": "ncb21-task-12b3608fd0ff5e4d"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-1f7403bea6b8ee84", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-461563d7023f964a", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_adni_s2_DISC": "95173649d61e219a2b3a69d8e9cb078ad4d8aa95192f9d22307c316b660d9fd8", "neg_p_fishing_adni_s2_REP": "ce2841d471ecec2155a4c71fa16d910c9e5f3032bac99276c9dc1aa246052c28"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_adni_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_adni_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "ed384fd07a690f405c0a55a07a8fd274ecc3dab8ca3cbbf57f258d53057f717e", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 8, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "4fa75f1a617d5939952ffe05253d36e7f43604073c07027b91444ede85ee963c", "task_id": "ncb21-task-13855d1780cbb1e3"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-314c6524cbe93809", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-0a76ce03968cea00", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_underpowered_hcp_aging_s1_DISC": "f6f439718e544d8d9153f7c47e66a50c45fa31fd04d6e5dcdfd4096a2b151e54", "neg_underpowered_hcp_aging_s1_REP": "8324be50f66633403de0a258497b199c341165bae0a4bbb1608dec3b0eaa1e1a"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_hcp_aging_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_hcp_aging_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "8b515c2000e85327f1a573d2c36f24a9e863a129bc23707803cc4bfb66538fe7", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.476 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "bcfd860d130d4827a95ba7b74be7a62abba7ff233a53f4f1d25254a1074cba60", "task_id": "ncb21-task-144a123ce2d6a385"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-820e065fb07facd4", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-ee1fb05e537c8c51", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_underpowered_hcp_aging_s3_DISC": "f43e276ba42f7dff2c8713dbdf843a192b55e2c97020fcd24958036f597a988b", "neg_underpowered_hcp_aging_s3_REP": "d24683c281385cb6878630a7a9eb205af7ad9a057700f77dd6aa0d87be1fee6f"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_hcp_aging_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_hcp_aging_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "8b8e4a585fd8d2bca3474fb6e63d6d9fe2898431ee081f3e383c024d0cdba1d5", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse; power=0.548 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "4231f42c1e0d1bcd164316137e1e305ac911f8ce0f6c9dc601cea8788963c6f0", "task_id": "ncb21-task-1755203de8c8e6a0"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-48888b0a50e6c685", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-776b5dea991b1b19", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_ukb_s3_DISC": "895e33f623122967b1a4988229703b5d667405c4f38fc217b72919a0e68b46ba", "neg_random_label_ukb_s3_REP": "e32e883672ad7047d58a024650f96ae4b821619b9bbc20b733269a19f2500f3f"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_ukb_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_ukb_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "04e14c7a4b7dcbfeb0281a26d6145e998e3a69f0571e57f2be9d35e8b50f811a", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "affd25242d94a75ceb70de6e4a0d0a988635d57460a75adc2596fc6383553f28", "task_id": "ncb21-task-181bc46e4453c91f"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-815d879b9076393c", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-7eefbb7385cc2907", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE1_DISC": "5a174cbcac2a070ea3f3af8be549a18c404215aaa031137242335f4c83643da4", "ABIDE1_REP": "d0a670f11f1c39a32e1e182cd1457b51acbec5518845795c26872642565c9f35"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE1_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "a0d49d26e7d1cc8636b99941de1d129031c99ee028a3cbf3bd77301f28f271d3", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "d61a8d5fb69adcabc6e29ad158773256ba23c32b8a90cff76134ef421327aebb", "task_id": "ncb21-task-185c5e67f296f418"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-5af5c999c214ab93", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-fdd692ec043876e0", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "0e1131c60977d58650265c1bf22d57e64bbf566ce45dd0179817948e70352d39", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "833c32c1061ba297005c7ccd9574440729b2960ac9062d0fd3c09824bfdfd445", "task_id": "ncb21-task-1a1dd6d309bd7a8a"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-545812ed0777dcb3", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-82620039a069c0f1", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_underpowered_hcp_aging_s2_DISC": "59424a442b03d2946941f07f8be7bd39057cde5548d102d7a619795e14856c82", "neg_underpowered_hcp_aging_s2_REP": "2199eabbe0fcb0e247f995ce314f08fa9c2a116de94fb356730f0eba4d6f997b"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_hcp_aging_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_hcp_aging_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "7b3c41e19f2ca94e9ee58d68f6dbb428c1e5f3486fa4d99efcad9e3c198bdaa8", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.512 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "2fe4fffc99debe35f810ae9877bca9bcacb42f7272257c483d2a4dd7cc7ecc73", "task_id": "ncb21-task-1a8cf91bedabfc69"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-c9246d08669f6265", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-407080b86e5d621b", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "b033b22cbea169004c0c54887f9b6f5e237d78dd299e52691fdd82588991eb99", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "73536b3ce20ff221a43de15fe2dc54b81577b1599aa0a20ebdb27015293e8f9f", "task_id": "ncb21-task-1a9d9bff2f919e15"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-564b9d40a50edcaa", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-844dad81c1ccad7d", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_abide2_s1_DISC": "79fe3def55e062135660cfbe96f64d4ba01a268c9c785beae1409daa2c839e1b", "neg_random_label_abide2_s1_REP": "1a48bd31073a47bf20ed7c11bca1b3bd32514920b46a943a964c9784b340b62c"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_abide2_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_abide2_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "c8d19a72fc062d8b9309e338096f3951602bfcf326d6e91ae255dfbb0693ff56", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "8329f06eafd902b0a332af4ae4e3de6b4232c7b8dcdff1a81cbea125a5a3af65", "task_id": "ncb21-task-1ba1546c05929dba"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-5ca3b178253860d3", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-faf6b4388e5b9831", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_adni_s3_DISC": "08e8cbc0ff62054669e60a6fb5b1e7741ecfd6c0856b83e2a3e90c27f5a16389", "neg_site_confound_adni_s3_REP": "5a3c7e426601953bbe6d6e8082697896713343065ff7224f2908da2bee04eefe"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_adni_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_adni_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "6df54392f8d5fae35ba3e9b1668d86e0bf90982aa17aa7230b905ca0b3992658", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 458, "p": 1.5737396889634738e-37, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 458, "p": 1.5737396889634738e-37, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "716f6e34932a5b1b03b653cf9f9117bf2fab1ebde406d1b8ecd4a9e643f836cc", "task_id": "ncb21-task-1c2a6e57a29020f9"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-1f9b7b9991250bd7", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-51a465ee26df6348", "cohort_content_hashes": {"COBRE_REP": "4a81a6fb00f3834982866da08d40f58816c7907a2c62838ae1fad68fd5bb18dc", "FBIRN_DISC": "5a9a103412824c97ff34a4b7c9107198e9309be14f345c917761eb11adcdbd82", "JH_REP": "f40fac0acd9aa1425552a409658e883651432d578db1db8a9c290e2ea4850ae6"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/JH_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "635fe760d14c3acee2062e8ba0982a1b93c335825de9bde0ded843a0f5be3a24", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 4, "multiverse": true, "pattern_corr": false, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication, pattern_corr, region_replication_fraction; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; pattern_corr=-0.029; dice=0.500; region_replication_fraction=0.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "9127ac6f8cce4505128576f7c14539866f5ce5dfe830be9ffd7decfaa1a15404", "task_id": "ncb21-task-1cd56ef2b757f69d"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-5794ca4d9a4f492b", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-59e12f2a1d37df0b", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "232132a84602d2e002eff364fa44085a7d831aca45cc3db13afd94a377e6b66e", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "e722d3550084f1d8aed04e44b0e6662f7a7d342b8abd67c8fc52eec91e78415f"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "9904d13be7832e51b6e7a8a3655d3f61f3e68f8858e00f20f504d6774fb56145", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.512 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "3b644960d67658b4604cb6076448197ccb026453d0277275ca879ee8b3f574c5", "task_id": "ncb21-task-1ddc3ef41e4ad468"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-81e24d3b130902a4", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-ec52828b69f9d8f0", "cohort_content_hashes": {"FBIRN_DISC": "5a9a103412824c97ff34a4b7c9107198e9309be14f345c917761eb11adcdbd82", "FBIRN_REP": "132788e0b0576e4f01ac0ac8dcbb232f2f105aea4693833ef74a59a45118b33a"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "b3ba56823ac51a9c0582e77e66af2b80f014d157b0a4cd3907f2663477c13a68", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "74b0e36861aececc011e947d78f59c7925436d478ecaebd969b99b49068e12a7", "task_id": "ncb21-task-1df9ebb9fd1e2432"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-cff1d7d2ccfb4083", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-1476a0d527831a23", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADHD200_DISC": "2ed4e2ddb4d8a3845dbec23c0b31652d26fdefe209e61fc4cdd3b636ebabb4fd", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "dd1a8d7928c2773745b7dd3a733f730873a9045104159a0b458228dcfab1a0e4", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "db86c238093deabcf1b1255006e373e2c513327bc5d153138330a076383b5238", "task_id": "ncb21-task-1ee6ff3275d5a6b2"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-41e14c6dd1c2213b", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-25404d4a24844fb5", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ADHD200_DISC": "2ed4e2ddb4d8a3845dbec23c0b31652d26fdefe209e61fc4cdd3b636ebabb4fd"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_DISC.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "e5fa617e3339715713d32f8b01a740f0fabef2fc9e7bdba2af3d913f4587bc0a", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "da9cfaae8221b81eddf47b4c50877193b040a7f70879597779254d1a305a309d", "task_id": "ncb21-task-1fa31ad921dc7522"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-e655e7f3059cc2a2", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-b6da1bc630eb2d9e", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "e6c8e7dcb254bd79942fbbe2725ff470b176d575bf608d552b44f8e1d8176e66", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "eb2492bd42a8453fc0abcffe3d647070b340faba3d70cf7380eff1c46dbb84b6", "task_id": "ncb21-task-20579a56de42c261"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-79370db65226ca4e", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-72c923997d08ab02", "cohort_content_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "a3e6f1609ea823c9216310eaea1cf3e54443ed385d8f2c4ccb0374907756646b", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "4cc03f072ec07c42f4ceaa18a43bd2065e0d5c508c7d70b6115b8ccc60ee1062"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-2169084a38eb251b/NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-2169084a38eb251b/NACC_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "6709fe9c6b67a2a5ec5fe691bf37ee4a77460848c14942a63cd02df921275dd9", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 3101, "p": 0.8403458905254911, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "ncb_random_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "56d7a202c7cfdaa38b3830c123ab182621d0e8638634b4efe8855976e8d980fa", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "d1ce91f82fb8484600cecfe7000b71c9aad221fc42887d9411c9be0205e68bf3"}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "95c6990de205ef2910eb72af3c85cb1e9c8d43d065c5eb1867be0e1b76d1ddd1", "task_id": "ncb21-task-2169084a38eb251b"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-ccf76ee04722df94", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-150173f23020bb20", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "725429b9fd3bbfd38c68b8cc22113e22561e8b0ed54daf3d30c7b200b3e0a46d", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "3419e352a15871458d1adda17e60444c7a0388d72cab80ee9b302b6230cab06c", "task_id": "ncb21-task-217080e5d5d61690"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-319a1462bfdbc89d", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-7cda64d6becf5e1c", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c", "HCP_DISC": "4bfd66afa7e3af1ad63ed1a3d1fdc1662e370064e97e927de95b8f783b7886a8", "HCP_REP": "0cc8dc280e6a961585c8c2c53414db8d8cb581c59cf2beaef3e3731c5eca9eba"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "3b31b1a4873039259bc69189f413bbffb1fa2370c2ff2a5ae8ce1fbc147c6038", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "phen_fluid_composite", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_cohort_mismatch"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "b87d45b72328fbf80b8f22a22265d61064f5ecaf7a22645eea551536300b17b1", "task_id": "ncb21-task-22401568a4a4fe75"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-2e389c7806389508", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-808aa5644bc4a764", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "27074411ed72b2c6506f26e69b0b2b8376cd2c150af9e0f5df42a9ef143adb14", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "ee8254aa1eafb3a9c9466cc7566ef0c0f31293f3f4200674a431ef31cbdb4995", "task_id": "ncb21-task-2256c13eb330feb3"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-83e8c22eb0f4831a", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-5f84c6481c326bca", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "311872ba89399caa217bfa1295e36f444f87fbc201ab0fde1057c615be5fdb6f", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "28a18872dbacf1c76e10729b2788036dfcc795b7877ea00b888a4b5e132a722d", "task_id": "ncb21-task-22b6347de5b895fd"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-e60c97d7572df957", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-c630bf30077c1b80", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "232132a84602d2e002eff364fa44085a7d831aca45cc3db13afd94a377e6b66e", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "e722d3550084f1d8aed04e44b0e6662f7a7d342b8abd67c8fc52eec91e78415f"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "bc4ed26e1ebf4d1d7ae71b2ac27eb70664cd536942110a6c6b43a961cad272e5", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.485 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "5dee63a725b528a18197c65322189ce66a7923c0a8d612da5d170c00e40b7a17", "task_id": "ncb21-task-2334fd77d5672850"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-c93f76e6f75aeaeb", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-65eee26713b640ac", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_hcp_aging_s3_DISC": "cec5938bcbbb3612ae45d9e77f630929f7a72aba65854646efcdbe58dcfe0622", "neg_p_fishing_hcp_aging_s3_REP": "df01aacfd1aecf9d651dfee49216e0b627520e717a263f38f0200c52bebb2457"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_hcp_aging_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_hcp_aging_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "c4651fd1ef84fd66d873e4f061878260a3e65b3f8a22d5a719ee5d2dc3abe739", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 24, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "5a1785f4b0ea3b5bb140abf6219458b299f10634db5d6438dde7dfdd6e37d93a", "task_id": "ncb21-task-2337108f0ac6ee78"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-c631e745a39a4c34", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-1afe945aed4f3816", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "9715839303f5f5e9ae6869ab8fde49fcf7af758f56f2e26635e72e63f6adb917", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "6be817ac8ba695e29adeeb2c14d40de0a8155421a6849092e96bb3bca52e10d5", "task_id": "ncb21-task-2378bd6a4aa6d917"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-f034e20c6a6bc7f8", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-110a8772c2a6c99c", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_abcd_s1_DISC": "7e54a4fe05390e6a67ff5d75114b3b255da025cb64bfdf174ac20f7eb7dc1f73", "neg_site_confound_abcd_s1_REP": "3b45e602771b0c7d6c705f7b7eddf6cee1100e6a207120d45916656c9b81ceb6"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_abcd_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_abcd_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "2476d27cb629b94a810f36d36a37e2c6d3960e6465c3228a87c7d626fb89204b", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 2597, "p": 5.172931479682535e-205, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 2597, "p": 5.172931479682535e-205, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "acc9ac0acbcda35dc68b1e3a5b6fe803bbb7a1728d8550d54b63e18d59236fbe", "task_id": "ncb21-task-23affa12649e5e2a"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-59ef3adedd2d2f5d", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-d5babed6fd444c40", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_adni_fmri_s2_DISC": "3ca9a3a348f1e7b8bdc2f77eca71145d2e34eba0ae9c4d91ca5b5bd0508d7d6a", "neg_site_confound_adni_fmri_s2_REP": "b5f8a4e434662b43739b06057df8d1df5c8bf64856adaebbb4f7fe204de807db"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_adni_fmri_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_adni_fmri_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "1f25235749f3cc8736f6b8258cf36f174a8444362bb5086ec00db0406851fa00", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 305, "p": 1.0804969369631423e-25, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 305, "p": 1.0804969369631423e-25, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "2a984487eebaa7df14e85a2da265b1608dc48c65b6803336b6f9ae57d5dd6a5b", "task_id": "ncb21-task-23b9c13946d2b21b"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-42b2c11ed186c2c9", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-4a5cfe7867e9ec38", "cohort_content_hashes": {"UKB_DISC": "8f50d0d10f4265b3538407235a0af91a7bb4d1a733daea42a655d4931e0bfdd3", "UKB_REP": "6da6a67cb610290a28f97b077dd2aa0e82c39161e4b3c622857cb54843df2357"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/UKB_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/UKB_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "2bfc0243ef84f6ad4a897190624cd3cb8ef092a3ee95afcb446d045b60a9d8da", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "9abef6437c1ca59bd87ace03258bcfe5b43145575036a488b0a7174522343caf", "task_id": "ncb21-task-24a9f287d05f4f0c"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-4d6ed37bb9324c72", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-3a82f78713b42591", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_fMRI_REP": "77b228db80400e42457cdc1a715f338fa645e8901922ef5f6f7c7f7d3d176c13"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_fMRI_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "dd27951bfa4e61c63a96c98721ce5e89100e31362da3774a0c9eb5479bacd771", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_cohort_mismatch:no_replication_data; power=0.750 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "f2c87d775ebd3ec845f559ac3b03ae769ab708e7b2e93e8b8d26511f61112c9d", "task_id": "ncb21-task-2596cecf69169eae"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-7446a0a12b859ed8", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-8a3a7eaf92ee59bc", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_gsp_s2_DISC": "8bea041f1c0edf200aa85fc5341de7e17c430c0f56c2cd277171ad9c2185a494", "neg_p_fishing_gsp_s2_REP": "6db208057d28abac954faa6f6e9a7b4c999767c351d139b26fb65a2a8b3229fa"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_gsp_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_gsp_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "a35516f7bf84b5131e26fc046aeea7142068c56bfc7dae6d904445c331b240e3", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 4, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "228245bb31833662e5b3eb715f20608a4eabe4502b975bebe5216b5e3030c7d7", "task_id": "ncb21-task-26be4e6c0bc4f9f1"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-08efd1786e5b448a", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-40b35f5b521303d6", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "769e977615d749c6a1134660e9c259ddb1efc0b79de0d761450f761994f50cae", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "99cc5b02d80d7b060e5c491fcd92561d149cad909669c233e76738d710919b59", "task_id": "ncb21-task-26de2f66465b717e"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-a427d5471566b2cf", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-2b3c33be0b079c58", "cohort_content_hashes": {"HCP_Aging_DISC": "47082908a7b0b17d0b8a006028dff9d08a56af3f8c6e8d08627ca3818f85a4fd", "HCP_Aging_REP": "e4682154e236a020f91b7932fe75341cf7a0eed865089e5172cad83a6989e965"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_Aging_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_Aging_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "55601d1c8258b2c32c21eb83d0b0c2951dbafcbfbf5f63c5f0d70bc5d2d74eb9", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "phen_fluid_composite", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "48acc0f34a95cc7e5b813ceede1a99c2b56679eb3f52430b9cf35640a3702f9b", "task_id": "ncb21-task-28a263d013fa1b7a"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-0f0403a272133ad1", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-6409917126c6d41b", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_abcd_s1_DISC": "67df63d0961137d6fa3c845534ef40f2aa09c47e4537c26dbdd5c09906f31a87", "neg_random_label_abcd_s1_REP": "73ef8112ab82e3597d9df25c0762a1a989f63105b1a94842a97d4bbe43febc25"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_abcd_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_abcd_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "c148203a380b2e1e28ec2d1ec39e9300c48e91188c57064e5c479552527bcbda", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "c9b1e218eb74a1cd37d64f28a0c0c19355c3fa4bd46210e1c9ccedeb296805e6", "task_id": "ncb21-task-295a18752281c742"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-0bccd4e0b2409e23", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-61034bf5d316a13a", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADHD200_DISC": "2ed4e2ddb4d8a3845dbec23c0b31652d26fdefe209e61fc4cdd3b636ebabb4fd", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "15f6c56328fb0a9a34d4de773e07c0c42a141686b9f612faa606f740120008da", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "636e3c829f82c97e94c442e469c72d5bbdb0269e3a06a87d8f020ba64c940364", "task_id": "ncb21-task-29da26499534583a"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-424e2babe414b942", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-c571041bf92aec1b", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "6c4854cb192116fd15876ee7d87934086e36f07917270406cf0c88ae6c5cf6a9", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "phen_fluid_composite", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "be41fb4948971bc6ff456682910eaf889f2def26d2b9368e8a33734460dcc0d5", "task_id": "ncb21-task-29ede93d8ab1d56d"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-f84fe6980294c120", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-335c942b8a7f71ac", "cohort_content_hashes": {"HCP_DISC": "4bfd66afa7e3af1ad63ed1a3d1fdc1662e370064e97e927de95b8f783b7886a8", "HCP_REP": "0cc8dc280e6a961585c8c2c53414db8d8cb581c59cf2beaef3e3731c5eca9eba"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "29307c671707ad9458f6e33682f0dd783c305bf8cda7f54205889f0deba47dbc", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "phen_fluid_composite", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "85339226a49124ff58caea24def2ee4223ff599d8ce6550f69b0bea55f6d9ace", "task_id": "ncb21-task-29f2629513c4d93d"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-92eebea972c19814", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-0e85f8bdd60fd349", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_oasis3_s3_DISC": "90ea10d5aa92fac4884a575da5a569c6ebdd41e3a40d4c5f70776b071fe51344", "neg_p_fishing_oasis3_s3_REP": "2dafbe3c9e9a1719c7f539e1cf145c609c48d040064003fd8c24c770845d08df"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_oasis3_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_oasis3_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "585f1d674f45625a3a453e2efc2aad71a1118491aa49aabf25b64a8bc0afb203", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "fs_version", "levels": 4, "n": 329, "p": 0.26517605424547525, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 6, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "4ff3ccce442cc76e815980bd33eeadc717d01d69c2398a73b7819fc6e57f7c9b", "task_id": "ncb21-task-2a069a4f9d553bee"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-81d14342bc5a3c18", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-77ec5019955cca1a", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_DISC": "7f42f7518c34775c8e5cf7c590a1fe44f226f40a7b899e71223b56ef43411663", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "091e057f213162c04271b9ea2f4bafc73f08bbb8d74a0ca4878f7c2a557e0dbc", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 36, "n": 331, "p": 0.4249953679600449, "test": "pearson"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "heterogeneity_i2": 8.913726480938433, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 8.913726480938433, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=8.9"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "ae67240980b1e561c7e817d9da334da5a0b38c030845dce18a5974a816b92abe", "task_id": "ncb21-task-2a0c89906d3bf1f2"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-548d362dc2682286", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-47448419aad2f13a", "cohort_content_hashes": {"BSNIP2_DISC": "f60b826114673b4f649dd9e41e9f01b5d76fe3fdff3fb17ac3d13f3472068df0", "BSNIP2_REP": "5a68458b6ca1d3ceb62243f2dcf1fda0209a9d2685669530b7e4c5f279a32f23"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "e49b7b88a8e408262b713e5a2e316b123f1d25992e7ac9681f8f4a8faf6b56de", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 278, "p": 0.3656917740160851, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "b25e6100b294c56e4bf51bbd2e69c0e61b3f6da0f31e86fcd5b2cb0623915390", "task_id": "ncb21-task-2a683ce1e6dce377"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-bc6d05b49560e9df", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-ea9ef50e03bd1867", "cohort_content_hashes": {"HCP_DISC": "4bfd66afa7e3af1ad63ed1a3d1fdc1662e370064e97e927de95b8f783b7886a8", "HCP_REP": "0cc8dc280e6a961585c8c2c53414db8d8cb581c59cf2beaef3e3731c5eca9eba"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "cce918e65c0f4e79c4a2919b4bb99dcd0c9a795c902c099f65e32dfc992287be", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 7.589617927213728, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 7.589617927213728, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=7.6"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "509b223212cbbf2368a38f6c54647dcfe02b6b4d29086e650d4b740e1bb4424f", "task_id": "ncb21-task-2a7a3de6b7d503b4"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-3e1160c83f5950a6", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-1070e2d3add46f92", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE1_DISC": "5a174cbcac2a070ea3f3af8be549a18c404215aaa031137242335f4c83643da4", "ABIDE1_REP": "d0a670f11f1c39a32e1e182cd1457b51acbec5518845795c26872642565c9f35"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE1_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "b9b199c1f5e2019146ec743274c0962559829672471803e1013ae9e923305993", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "4e21a925a57ab6f8fdf68032e4a0932c9757ebe785a82609ab47ed80873a1301", "task_id": "ncb21-task-2aa14ad4c6a4579e"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-0cd265e25bb8f4a6", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-29fcd3255c477bd4", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_adni_fmri_s1_DISC": "d2b2566fcb2e9a45759c17510120f6a2ef7f5cfff3ecc69cf85b4f9db090346d", "neg_p_fishing_adni_fmri_s1_REP": "bcfab53d43278da34acbec043e05a0479f71374543f7e0a3ad9c88e9990f0289"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_adni_fmri_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_adni_fmri_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "128dd66d0e7d04510bc506588cd8b7751913fd4f52ef1ae595d65b3574540d88", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 24, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "870be99ca9944c9841b8bab33c4a1a8e61911f731e898647af465835437faa0d", "task_id": "ncb21-task-2acff5dcd8c32ef2"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-c671d3de1b2734cb", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-401633bf098f7966", "cohort_content_hashes": {"BSNIP2_DISC": "f60b826114673b4f649dd9e41e9f01b5d76fe3fdff3fb17ac3d13f3472068df0", "COBRE_REP": "4a81a6fb00f3834982866da08d40f58816c7907a2c62838ae1fad68fd5bb18dc"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "a7032c8996a068ea8131ed7ca399bcc76cada4f4b43aa233a67d2a1eb0cb5c5a", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 4, "multiverse": false, "pattern_corr": true, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse; pattern_corr=0.164; dice=0.000; region_replication_fraction=0.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "baef086f3507c786c796b58aacee21b5f832c2a0e30258620eec32346c948bba", "task_id": "ncb21-task-2af7eda20deedfc3"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-41a540435c5c78bc", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-5b69c6777dc873b4", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "232132a84602d2e002eff364fa44085a7d831aca45cc3db13afd94a377e6b66e", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "e722d3550084f1d8aed04e44b0e6662f7a7d342b8abd67c8fc52eec91e78415f"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-2b86bc8446233255/ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-2b86bc8446233255/ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "1dd7c9126a90ccd76f1e44bc3e910ab1db14e2bc9513bcb03d25b1c70f937275", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "ncb_random_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "cc928fce4c4ade3bb5e71fa465587b0c0a829d1b1437d72cd411a743b56edea9", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "69a60281b6a142f4571bba25ac65736c65d154ea438a62d2254f5ed2581f7258"}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "c68ac98ee4bdee5d49d4927c3b7abce1e3de7058f97e94d0b4d76ffad8e7ad54", "task_id": "ncb21-task-2b86bc8446233255"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-7f37d5578b3cc678", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-9e3cba5575bc08af", "cohort_content_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "a3e6f1609ea823c9216310eaea1cf3e54443ed385d8f2c4ccb0374907756646b", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "4cc03f072ec07c42f4ceaa18a43bd2065e0d5c508c7d70b6115b8ccc60ee1062"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "bc9fb7ae0664977730dd83251b48d0404165e660c0e1a8f34871ef1e37011d2b", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 2312, "p": 2.5853903676145945e-55, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 2312, "p": 2.5853903676145945e-55, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness, replication; confound_incomplete; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "ec90d15083accc95b30ef75ff82559b9c8b232b107e1f0650467e73d48f55f4d", "task_id": "ncb21-task-2c6cacba778204de"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-45e4a4f6e1fc74d9", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-d8249150529d2720", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_hcp_aging_s1_DISC": "89ac825e0ccfe033b6a6f5fefbdb71292479c3e651d6d6467959f51f4fd429c7", "neg_site_confound_hcp_aging_s1_REP": "39e45feda68b9c351de92fd2128a3a887848f0784c7038f26bd9c1a0b61dfa45"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_hcp_aging_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_hcp_aging_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "2d613b776939aad245d0bb6fa05ab1acf4c34367bff6c67e543e4aedc2a4c851", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 158, "p": 7.532542186112728e-14, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 158, "p": 7.532542186112728e-14, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "e4b716561615bd67d2c1eb309be3c467156ae8c450535812dabf006441b9525e", "task_id": "ncb21-task-2cb3010c86628713"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-9c2e4221cf5ca105", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-e39b944fef417cd8", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "3fecde66bc8dda1e9fab2d01d3ffa794c6cb0b971855ef9836796c5f50d5651c", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "bbcd0d0ea771bfe49bbd5f5bc502a4e22ad72ea7918f0f8671fb606a00e018d8", "task_id": "ncb21-task-2ce25bc332b80d88"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-bdc24737aa23b682", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-6bdd5ff6b2acccd5", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "7aea5dd11c342a0855fb4edab4b5afc1d5f618673c29295696baae1c07e5c10e", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "7852af8f40156696f67f809a65511f5bd266b243e284d2a6a9254fde1d63339a", "task_id": "ncb21-task-2de1487414a9935d"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-54ee5bbdf18fb340", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-f6fbaa834c3ee79f", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "232132a84602d2e002eff364fa44085a7d831aca45cc3db13afd94a377e6b66e", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "e722d3550084f1d8aed04e44b0e6662f7a7d342b8abd67c8fc52eec91e78415f"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "b9352322d360173ac12a81a511553e4abcb742d2b6c6467e34ec13fb654b5c2a", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.485 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "256d45871a95be6a779bc902415dc3b747846770d4314f3e30ce588609c49801", "task_id": "ncb21-task-2e9f091011bce439"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-26a7e82fe849729e", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-635ac952f3a629f6", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_hcp_s3_DISC": "de0e5979bbbe65a49c04720364d4c31004127c41fc89c5f85788f40322a0fd6c", "neg_random_label_hcp_s3_REP": "321f91cbe464542c637c8d707d346ada714267ce4ac3d13869631ff1d24af4b3"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_hcp_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_hcp_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "e86dbf6811064b717214c0aae52a75c442a27a8c375f42c2a8d58cccaa2a60fb", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "b73566e3cb93b04971b3c20137e9bb04043d2a15bc7451a1268254ddd090e51e", "task_id": "ncb21-task-2ee76dd03e68fbe7"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-0bb6a3a9dc5929ae", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-46a70a8481fa30fd", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_adhd200_s3_DISC": "f19443eb377e78d22df49b97580fb829b03dcfb39c029b5e283725569e6166bb", "neg_site_confound_adhd200_s3_REP": "fd85259d0448627da2fe5b5230a0363427862f6fd7f3d9a2e44da4d9b23c269a"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_adhd200_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_adhd200_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "eeb10c0a315381178664b4546dfffea7e292d148796e8e3419ae9db2ab8dcc7d", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 156, "p": 1.759621848327281e-13, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 156, "p": 1.759621848327281e-13, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "27534db3f03c614c78abae5b4b0016c5864956f5dc08caf4d51628556baa4068", "task_id": "ncb21-task-2efb1329959169f5"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-b0c4c5f349a00064", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-6ec8432c84ee2353", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADHD200_DISC": "2ed4e2ddb4d8a3845dbec23c0b31652d26fdefe209e61fc4cdd3b636ebabb4fd", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "845332117d7e10e2cd77b4ad66a615b5f39500bff591c0a8619d1007d1fc7fc6", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": false, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 84, "multiverse": true, "pattern_corr": true, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication, dice; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; pattern_corr=0.980; dice=0.000; region_replication_fraction=1.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "a7cb2c330a01fcbc9a8b58745562a500ec7f24765b59d13dbae252bd6fa3cb70", "task_id": "ncb21-task-2f198bcbf0cf7b42"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-e7c94f56c83e0651", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-9cdd04f06e75065a", "cohort_content_hashes": {"UKB_DISC": "8f50d0d10f4265b3538407235a0af91a7bb4d1a733daea42a655d4931e0bfdd3", "UKB_REP": "6da6a67cb610290a28f97b077dd2aa0e82c39161e4b3c622857cb54843df2357"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/UKB_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/UKB_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "cd95d3ab6fd09da4eea45c7c46d1ddcde53ce81ffc15915881985a491e82f8df", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "426c61a473025b4af76a48ec851a040a0a5daa1753dea3fc7f5e2d0be132114f", "task_id": "ncb21-task-2f2394534763a048"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-ec6d0cdd670ee6f6", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-4cda00f5e04a384e", "cohort_content_hashes": {"COBRE_DISC": "f53b3405d06487a9d268b89165605cc0ed60d2c3a68e41f8ebe73660d9916d79", "FBIRN_REP": "132788e0b0576e4f01ac0ac8dcbb232f2f105aea4693833ef74a59a45118b33a", "JH_REP": "f40fac0acd9aa1425552a409658e883651432d578db1db8a9c290e2ea4850ae6"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/JH_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "3097accc27a0ba790c81fffa2b0258cdef54ffbebbe02839c82adb8b6442c4d8", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 4, "multiverse": true, "pattern_corr": false, "power": false, "region_replication_fraction": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "under_powered", "rationale": "Failed gates: power, replication, pattern_corr, region_replication_fraction; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.790 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1; pattern_corr=-0.095; dice=0.500; region_replication_fraction=0.250"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "under_powered", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "acc4eeeffc23f3f0078085fa8dc56babd8098798c0f88c41d1dcfe952207ab7d", "task_id": "ncb21-task-2f3eeb38f5c0d7d2"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-8a63ea377d95958e", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-b2aaf5de745cd793", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "232132a84602d2e002eff364fa44085a7d831aca45cc3db13afd94a377e6b66e", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "e722d3550084f1d8aed04e44b0e6662f7a7d342b8abd67c8fc52eec91e78415f"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "1af4ff298966282bebbffe9691c8fd447e81fac139d6920568d3841f9bea195e", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.530 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "7dc05cf669805b1594fd1483f026f744936ecf8367ab6af6b0f19b9592f95be3", "task_id": "ncb21-task-2fdbf0b5a11d962f"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-acb1371a4d55e5b6", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-5954618486de89dd", "cohort_content_hashes": {"UKB_DISC": "8f50d0d10f4265b3538407235a0af91a7bb4d1a733daea42a655d4931e0bfdd3", "UKB_REP": "6da6a67cb610290a28f97b077dd2aa0e82c39161e4b3c622857cb54843df2357"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/UKB_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/UKB_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "834d74b58666b3798407191f2126f1106a1df53f875621fffcd47a799a67adea", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "d48f833ae365b8a5bc2269e0abde0b4e94153facc8970a5797adcb54925c5421", "task_id": "ncb21-task-31b5436965a2340b"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-effa2f259eb5a69f", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-74084399c9b24ed5", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_oasis3_fmri_s3_DISC": "1e0157c0b95469f07b9fb60d3b6953048b0a17e79e6e290592ce0eef8b3e621e", "neg_site_confound_oasis3_fmri_s3_REP": "244f5e02f11a668f82484a79e45b39db53e6d3b88773ea32a4a1793536288cf8"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_oasis3_fmri_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_oasis3_fmri_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "0c0ab912bf39e6b6564a176d7ef4f87153046f0ec2eb6497376331bdfc2f332f", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 229, "p": 1.3896734150401247e-19, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 229, "p": 1.3896734150401247e-19, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "d86c2e7d88dd5702932203e187ca3bdb1f4c77fa3ac605c7cdd2f062190175ee", "task_id": "ncb21-task-3206b7580a2d607a"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-e1ef0d8ef65b2b01", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-d2b67bab6df76c6f", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_adni_s1_DISC": "49ae200d6c34368f8f60de6d677dac4707a9528610e43411a18fe1d14e4da8b9", "neg_p_fishing_adni_s1_REP": "5def0d03573fac5041af664d2c62fe3eb5d1ab37253b9d04a9d573324f2dcaa7"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_adni_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_adni_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "03bd5d160476e7002c0ea83d0488621389777c5e21ae4b2b1a8f8188011254af", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 8, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "49e1c5063e302d6a7568d6ead71233233e00cf8ca6292927d5b4791c64ba9b4d", "task_id": "ncb21-task-325bb98556bcf489"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-bd117704d246d32d", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-88074ec237371256", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_underpowered_adhd200_s3_DISC": "f311e7a94c4c7e297ef466f46608928a5e3245eed4876253ad3c1408ead5d285", "neg_underpowered_adhd200_s3_REP": "f5ea518b88a7ebfcbb8163f1ede48333d01d9465a9a9bcb507116bfce8c5de76"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_adhd200_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_adhd200_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "3ee45d81459e34e9e801c99599c73093e56123bbd13cbd99803359119d8c84f7", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.548 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "18aa2e2732a804636498686d9686cf6eb5f81e78ba0172fc0acf52b3214311f0", "task_id": "ncb21-task-327636a510045927"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-43b88d75579673af", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-8867e568901147e0", "cohort_content_hashes": {"HCP_DISC": "4bfd66afa7e3af1ad63ed1a3d1fdc1662e370064e97e927de95b8f783b7886a8", "HCP_REP": "0cc8dc280e6a961585c8c2c53414db8d8cb581c59cf2beaef3e3731c5eca9eba"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "8942e1d0277bcb1139b4a47a1bb26d96cccf68aed9d9d3e26b972ffa126c4fb5", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "c955cc44cce5cba5df72a980684e0ba80c7e1408a1336aa62550d8e90e1c6e9c", "task_id": "ncb21-task-3349e65b82ed72aa"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-a9f4010d6ed3964c", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-e24d2db067e9ce15", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_underpowered_ukb_s1_DISC": "0360d4e962f989be298451651a44968f51531c23577b2d6fcd74a814f168d392", "neg_underpowered_ukb_s1_REP": "ffa42691a02c6527a38aaee42f8adec068c02756debe457a7c888e1828152f90"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_ukb_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_ukb_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "64d57e7725b453f7ece8765f3d5caaee5f8951b2bfe1473a20227b32d5b2b05c", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.476 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "18b87f17cb0ceed57b035e76d25c636239648a1265e93ed33281150ec7bb70c0", "task_id": "ncb21-task-3353a2c3c630ad15"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-3700ad906c849ad5", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-4019f0acf90b7192", "cohort_content_hashes": {"UKB_DISC": "8f50d0d10f4265b3538407235a0af91a7bb4d1a733daea42a655d4931e0bfdd3", "UKB_REP": "6da6a67cb610290a28f97b077dd2aa0e82c39161e4b3c622857cb54843df2357"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/UKB_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/UKB_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "eb2b5da890b2e792bdc0d6df1b2e9d4bb28a3d2c3ec905b90bfcec90c2a456fd", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "33c00b39b3b4d197722797b5661be3756258880ff2245daefd73155a8d054526", "task_id": "ncb21-task-33ad70367c5e5019"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-58bbab3b5e3ff519", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-464ae6d969312edc", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_underpowered_abide2_s3_DISC": "54514c61d4f9e0a10850a62a288510912c72e15f83e84c16004cf13e119870be", "neg_underpowered_abide2_s3_REP": "05c4f6655da4afa24a6563746918b3bf3027ad9e10c054785d2a4b235ffadb28"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_abide2_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_abide2_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "3f0434916add44f2dfe6827dac8643d69a2bf6114fc8a0f1afb3330f0b1c2a50", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.397 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "b18c25b480e5a28055fa4137b69a7b99a18fafd62401b12dd9d95bd170bdec00", "task_id": "ncb21-task-387eb118b0d0a1c9"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-06e49e0c9bfc3666", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-ac354449072fc90f", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_adni_fmri_s3_DISC": "6805cf849e2140fd29c4716e9878f46f517fcd456c0ae9bfdc02f2556f71764d", "neg_site_confound_adni_fmri_s3_REP": "48b6104c6b31d8df97c1f43a50c0f5faa1b14d66edee895e88b29ee03c69433c"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_adni_fmri_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_adni_fmri_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "352395b7b53297d42842fbede7b34671fd1c4ac35fd94865bd1b654456b78436", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 317, "p": 2.5318092208134374e-26, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 317, "p": 2.5318092208134374e-26, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "53a67475563323ec0a11b208cea1cd4b4a7fdc1222e06f6c1951891cd6bbd03c", "task_id": "ncb21-task-3888f34a7ee0dbb2"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-6560b15c380073ca", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-8ea778a37b3c644b", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADHD200_DISC": "2ed4e2ddb4d8a3845dbec23c0b31652d26fdefe209e61fc4cdd3b636ebabb4fd", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "bdf2bc4970351f7a02aca4c1311922a32ca4b4e65d255e1bea239c1ba79a7ac9", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "ca427dcaee865cddaf1d63a0df898f8de9a058b6be78522b1c7e0b8413b0db85", "task_id": "ncb21-task-38f81a83ea1721fa"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-89a3d773c1c9f79a", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-a9fe7bee2a93b42e", "cohort_content_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "a3e6f1609ea823c9216310eaea1cf3e54443ed385d8f2c4ccb0374907756646b", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "4cc03f072ec07c42f4ceaa18a43bd2065e0d5c508c7d70b6115b8ccc60ee1062"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "67f5613cb55f856962c9f82bba6be39bbfa34e877c5a310a206d4d7fe89eb1ef", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 1964, "p": 4.750055361533447e-83, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 1964, "p": 4.750055361533447e-83, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "dd65803d28bdac832aa3024778f81a842c443898d8b201032c4edc3df8292543", "task_id": "ncb21-task-3a0c46add0ae8220"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-c82528795d17b7c6", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-70fd251bde9bb9a1", "cohort_content_hashes": {"HCP_Aging_REP": "e4682154e236a020f91b7932fe75341cf7a0eed865089e5172cad83a6989e965", "UKB_DISC": "8f50d0d10f4265b3538407235a0af91a7bb4d1a733daea42a655d4931e0bfdd3"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/UKB_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_Aging_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "3bde0d4b3511de74dc2953a2c7073a72a9472141c16ec9ec3ac6502de18d5b3d", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": false, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 84, "multiverse": true, "pattern_corr": false, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication, pattern_corr, region_replication_fraction, dice; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; pattern_corr=0.499; dice=0.330; region_replication_fraction=0.368"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "6c511697993bb897040883a8b1be5a2c92435cf47d2ef2cbf1f422e6c61f9d37", "task_id": "ncb21-task-3ae580adaf8733fe"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-1954832d44d0ebd1", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-023880a16932e622", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADHD200_DISC": "2ed4e2ddb4d8a3845dbec23c0b31652d26fdefe209e61fc4cdd3b636ebabb4fd", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "e6016273bc1af5dfb3be29baadb1489b6f821ac53b48e28c2082737e4555892c", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "9e9616ea94ca2b63234a0bd5e01a189283ca03dc5b7d307ab2dbcab3cd54f0f6", "task_id": "ncb21-task-3b0e41e0dc79abef"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-d240bf163611d308", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-f513f2f985b341e7", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_cobre_s3_DISC": "8cd60181ee1832713aea27ec46923eef71c1a1a3e2f9a6fd0e29011e0556efde", "neg_random_label_cobre_s3_REP": "2bdbd6492edb124bb8f2eb6eb05c4366d54df7801c10b7e7239552ecde52af6d"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_cobre_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_cobre_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "14519df3fefc20c707960cd7d51218a9f443cc86693255601602c23b11b1039f", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.457 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "33d10ee29477b1d5b25c56a6c23991b7b7f2f07e3f45b44ee5c54d4e7a7e685b", "task_id": "ncb21-task-3b15b5d2e3f7eb9f"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-7e3903cc96c0849e", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-7dce8857b6cb26e3", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_fbirn_s1_DISC": "8f20bc07c4b810591e72bfd7d3e7349311ba61054bae27f6887c2f0432f76256", "neg_p_fishing_fbirn_s1_REP": "fd56598185046bd5db4dea2029417e5b3de4dee09d99c48b9a995921b845af4f"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_fbirn_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_fbirn_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "90d4ca0b26d3e5977b0b704134b5b1e412de5d265ef64252b4744616200762c6", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 4, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.703 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "0904b74e192bd957dd3af68515041d8c01cce7df7b793957c6027eda0e62e4f0", "task_id": "ncb21-task-3c2b86d3c9fb8ae5"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-2bd6d96052019d32", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-6abe4ae4410d4922", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "232132a84602d2e002eff364fa44085a7d831aca45cc3db13afd94a377e6b66e", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "e722d3550084f1d8aed04e44b0e6662f7a7d342b8abd67c8fc52eec91e78415f"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "d5e9b556996a046b24bc2781d590fa9fd787176056c20578dbc499e9399c45e6", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "under_powered", "rationale": "Failed gates: power, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.530 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "under_powered", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "09e6bd69a6ac2754ae093b8780a0b9512680017d800f81fe730c11b0d9ffe609", "task_id": "ncb21-task-3ceb5d86a19295df"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-1f634e71dd689f9b", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-5d0df33e63f38b2d", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "b3dd412e37ac3ffe9f573b24408dcb95ffe4a0844d3505ccd7a7ff7f81fc7f2b", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "7df5b7b490360ec28f68dbbce605e926248189ef71e023a3dac1941ec594b3d8", "task_id": "ncb21-task-3d093bb7bad5924a"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-cb339bf30281cede", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-fc66b31723dd2dc9", "cohort_content_hashes": {"HCP_Aging_DISC": "47082908a7b0b17d0b8a006028dff9d08a56af3f8c6e8d08627ca3818f85a4fd", "HCP_Aging_REP": "e4682154e236a020f91b7932fe75341cf7a0eed865089e5172cad83a6989e965"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_Aging_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_Aging_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "20dda741a62dea6b73ef9ebeafce004588bd80842940b4ab22ca16cdbac236bd", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "cd0a19e85c968e8ba17b46896ca42d629eb9fb45ca71c89fc1c7b26b8dbc48a4", "task_id": "ncb21-task-3d920ec7800c2bfa"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-0945ff60b5d68ba8", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-dd6641b4ea42b230", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_DISC": "7f42f7518c34775c8e5cf7c590a1fe44f226f40a7b899e71223b56ef43411663", "ADNI_REP": "56cd379d34a3e7f93f341c1014daa9b3a9146606a68d4720d4513d09e35d73b6", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "f3994921a174769c817c1e19fce21d2a77601e4cde2f1163e49d2f096e54535a", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "7039cac9ca78b3da0942f2f13a00ff44cfbe45f041a8ef8fa5cd1c43ec9b31da", "task_id": "ncb21-task-3df4d7ede4eced5b"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-5d46d95ce95c931d", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-6c007919b3e6bcbd", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_abide1_s3_DISC": "b2e6c1c31ed8f7e3638bebfc3fdbcda2e510bb8ff87b4e9947470eaefcf87ec5", "neg_site_confound_abide1_s3_REP": "d312a51e8928f6bda038bfb08bfb27f45d5e2f94ed0cfd8f909cf43db4384aa7"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_abide1_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_abide1_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "0a8e504d1366a7e21949d2c7e2f59681dba1b3848e497b779ec4d0ad60e27692", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 200, "p": 2.1519736712498897e-17, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 200, "p": 2.1519736712498897e-17, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "972488120263e3bce2cf5d1baa0a3d8f1c662c11f6e7d19307ba1fdbab8d9e1d", "task_id": "ncb21-task-3f71678ac0f44acd"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-7911d5fcc3aee4ba", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-563734786967b257", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_hcp_s3_DISC": "edcc6fb7f40f47f5339126417b028fe7d12a819ed651b9a302dc316987de2109", "neg_p_fishing_hcp_s3_REP": "48c98cea502be4565782630b6544089e670c67004cbb6393f902e1542cbc49d7"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_hcp_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_hcp_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "719e5497148fdf921a93656d236080df637492dc9b3f026f366f2fb768df14f3", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 24, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "432eb31f5742b18ca235397dd81f8ee08f1f1e344106d936c55107726f50141b", "task_id": "ncb21-task-401699c9be26d050"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-e9887ba0003df877", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-79eeeffbdf0a4d5c", "cohort_content_hashes": {"HCP_DISC": "4bfd66afa7e3af1ad63ed1a3d1fdc1662e370064e97e927de95b8f783b7886a8", "HCP_REP": "0cc8dc280e6a961585c8c2c53414db8d8cb581c59cf2beaef3e3731c5eca9eba"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "e6e2e3d543d4be9c021c543d06fbe4393d761e7c51eb87a3d12e78d8048a8bc7", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "phen_fluid_composite", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "a0c63fe547c2ad04d0b1882862c54dfbd022a72a7a054246ad26c91fde257a9e", "task_id": "ncb21-task-402fa353a875fc7b"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-ecf6d32180cfff58", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-0604106d01dea7f0", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_hcp_s1_DISC": "88fff01e12a1eea5892b06305ea8780d293d0eb6849301596f7739d5f338d5a7", "neg_random_label_hcp_s1_REP": "d905b234f8604551fa0b1d17a05985c3ed907b9b4273de3055b33bfa659b018a"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_hcp_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_hcp_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "449d509db852d10c1c5c07ffae5ae08037e07c2cda4a0767c4177c5acfc74339", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "2eb02077e52c3bf80ab650c1ec76404aac25ba28c9b7b27fdf5abbedae73e959", "task_id": "ncb21-task-4118bcb674d1553f"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-721c4fa75e038ea4", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-0a99bffb687cf6c9", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "e4da457e5b1c34f365187aef77052b20be36c4ee6b451ecba774e45255764cfc", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "1c35a5b61736e294c1ff555317c9801e840d3bc9e7b438d6c32927b138d649e2", "task_id": "ncb21-task-4119b3d43abfec30"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-1cb9ec13d30f0e3b", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-f31afb15e64e3e36", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_underpowered_abcd_s3_DISC": "7e83e646b7bcf3a6f7fdaa5c34acbb6cd2926284eac8715d64ca9aeeee4f8a90", "neg_underpowered_abcd_s3_REP": "28eccea410de928a6a6f5e7f82087509f917b6abf623f757a2a8422024ca4543"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_abcd_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_abcd_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "a941830b4e8c302268adf77d4faa0dd7546e48f1626b57b68c11f5d0ea832b2f", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.548 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "9ff564322a7cf46821383d38501df64b14f8f9644e76cca7398fb3b56ce565d4", "task_id": "ncb21-task-41530f6a50c4e47b"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-9181e305d0e360a5", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-911d8d3f4e5c8712", "cohort_content_hashes": {"BSNIP2_REP": "5a68458b6ca1d3ceb62243f2dcf1fda0209a9d2685669530b7e4c5f279a32f23", "ChineseSZ_REP": "9c94c02e8066411af69f22387e526434c8c412c6df30ff250b1c7bc75f5514a8", "Olin_SZ_REP": "d7bef7b3dc92844bbfc9976c601ed84734ccd0a9b19af3571dddda43dc156167"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/Olin_SZ_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "b5dee6f5f06a7c0314bfe81b583155d7467f88dab67a74bbfb990dedc9b09ce1", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "f6720193e86b6850ffb6a3424dd9e00ada2b34639ae3f1ba531fb51af4552fde", "task_id": "ncb21-task-4500dc8037b51034"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-2da7ae8514465754", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-5cc79c3c3ba68903", "cohort_content_hashes": {"UKB_DISC": "8f50d0d10f4265b3538407235a0af91a7bb4d1a733daea42a655d4931e0bfdd3", "UKB_REP": "6da6a67cb610290a28f97b077dd2aa0e82c39161e4b3c622857cb54843df2357"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/UKB_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/UKB_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "782656167de3a44c33bbfc89e51fdba842d6282c6b5f3f71878b54d780fffb58", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "49b37ce7a7f782eaae69e3e8d22a5583ad4f034da1ad4b94eee5bae9486880a3", "task_id": "ncb21-task-46aa865267479f06"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-94dea5dc0bc79c8c", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-5640b558ea5588cf", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "232132a84602d2e002eff364fa44085a7d831aca45cc3db13afd94a377e6b66e", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "e722d3550084f1d8aed04e44b0e6662f7a7d342b8abd67c8fc52eec91e78415f"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-46aaac00f9a0a6d1/ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-46aaac00f9a0a6d1/ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "64b983e5840fe0ee8f1f3c674009a4d8404a358cf346367638c9a9c8ed0403a0", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "ncb_random_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "438f5c0754d82d8827ec5df848f415cb9ba09ff7752d13957630aabb1fb3497f", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "ecc5689a8ab57036873f71fa28d7f467543a3152d2b5c9e2b38bc629bfb7015d"}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "21daea349001f5c5ef09ea3dcc651606d1913626cda1fc1d3ce61170ca4de51d", "task_id": "ncb21-task-46aaac00f9a0a6d1"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-9cb81ca19caf7d9d", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-8c751d323222983e", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_DISC": "7f42f7518c34775c8e5cf7c590a1fe44f226f40a7b899e71223b56ef43411663", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "44423f6908d5572920cabe82946d51c374ef4c4227c1ad389b7ff7021ce315d7", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 5, "multiverse": true, "pattern_corr": true, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All brain-wide gates passed.; pattern_corr=0.908; dice=1.000; region_replication_fraction=1.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "4801b4671c21524533d2e9e29c6bfbfa2497227251c75cad8dde60b3c8fcb7ea", "task_id": "ncb21-task-47e6d67533617281"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-113ed00f0e74744d", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-d9045a0ef13695ae", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADHD200_DISC": "2ed4e2ddb4d8a3845dbec23c0b31652d26fdefe209e61fc4cdd3b636ebabb4fd", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "6229d537c1843864f7952d006d3d547bd88f20fe6a625862c4938b974cc7c82a", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": false, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 84, "multiverse": true, "pattern_corr": true, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication, dice; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; pattern_corr=0.980; dice=0.000; region_replication_fraction=1.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "a59e204e90971c3ddd42bcb7a5743e1ca40d519102474d30c1c190c4f0147a51", "task_id": "ncb21-task-47e7b5c1a1f25442"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-6c51801ff315cd4f", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-743b40f799220059", "cohort_content_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "a3e6f1609ea823c9216310eaea1cf3e54443ed385d8f2c4ccb0374907756646b", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "4cc03f072ec07c42f4ceaa18a43bd2065e0d5c508c7d70b6115b8ccc60ee1062"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-4875a681d27f91e0/NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-4875a681d27f91e0/NACC_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "5eb0ccf2e2eeff314ac66a3bbd7249bf20f8cf6f9926f3609dc8a8504c56f6db", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 3101, "p": 0.3100935764794242, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "ncb_random_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "21605f4826abfbd84d85ac215feb52d7cbb479d7ffd667fa466f91fe28bb40ae", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "06bfb645e1525491c3616ec1173b88665cffac134e1cf824e4b2ce04595fad08"}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "7eeef099a38f18f724e40c84e3ca657273651739721d59adfacd902362ad221d", "task_id": "ncb21-task-4875a681d27f91e0"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-3578a76ed8bf3578", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-e16d6b1d10936de6", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_DISC": "7f42f7518c34775c8e5cf7c590a1fe44f226f40a7b899e71223b56ef43411663", "ADNI_REP": "56cd379d34a3e7f93f341c1014daa9b3a9146606a68d4720d4513d09e35d73b6"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "98512de74025ef9d731399d3102fec0e4aba9cb860da8e90101d19a06fb2ef6d", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "magnitude_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "magnitude_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 51.345254145513785, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 51.345254145513785, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=magnitude_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=51.3"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "2aaf1ebef5d3e0b9386a2ad28fb645a89e43d28e2b5ba5ad965b17a9baa3c211", "task_id": "ncb21-task-488d5612e99b3300"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-7c005de1c12b32a7", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-78591f2ec54c17d6", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADHD200_DISC": "2ed4e2ddb4d8a3845dbec23c0b31652d26fdefe209e61fc4cdd3b636ebabb4fd", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "ab77f3f0e497e1ac5fb5f065f570883db0c241454c9238ebca011c8639de16e8", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "68cd0f837aa9bc0b0cacf587c9dd637f29af6f74c8227d8fa771bf5de79e441b", "task_id": "ncb21-task-4909693e2ac000b8"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-b6bcaf52ce24d411", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-07a9432584cc53d5", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "b72b5ca1c064c50a5c1c9c99ffaec140f6f0d0e2adfca6230fc15b364ebce712", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "eec559aa64abd98f8ef99d65f917345a32ec78b28862b72e0659754c41305d21", "task_id": "ncb21-task-4958fc673b892c35"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-1bc0eeed8b9a00bc", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-1f2175401ed164dc", "cohort_content_hashes": {"HCP_Aging_DISC": "47082908a7b0b17d0b8a006028dff9d08a56af3f8c6e8d08627ca3818f85a4fd", "HCP_Aging_REP": "e4682154e236a020f91b7932fe75341cf7a0eed865089e5172cad83a6989e965"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_Aging_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_Aging_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "5feddac046857ecb1a0638566686af075dd2dfb237fa4407f9ced5c67681fb6b", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "magnitude_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "magnitude_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 60.27435995388765, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 60.27435995388765, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=magnitude_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=60.3"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "6168f150d945afa100f3846bb0965b8374070b605cf731e6a5df628f8b91bed9", "task_id": "ncb21-task-4990a40bd94c76a7"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-c922885057dbc163", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-352f3448885481de", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_DISC": "7f42f7518c34775c8e5cf7c590a1fe44f226f40a7b899e71223b56ef43411663", "ADNI_REP": "56cd379d34a3e7f93f341c1014daa9b3a9146606a68d4720d4513d09e35d73b6", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "60d864c6efe2b3cf8963783524f8588eecbe7e3c4ab91e86917f6a5211beb6d2", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "de5b0709cb091c760583cb3aa069acd4304e50e9db4fd50a400db080bc0881ef", "task_id": "ncb21-task-49c64dd2a4b213fa"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-30329250c399e0e1", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-b81743b2021cf84d", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "b8a9c3d221cc2ad136856f6c0e9d05b8b4ff2451af514309ed59a562bd6f3928", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "86eeb43d2f7b9f9db39341f9a552634e321d1bff9ae1abfebda44d373da373d1", "task_id": "ncb21-task-4a3386676b1444ee"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-8d7c71367a2043b9", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-f081fdc9aea95329", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE1_DISC": "5a174cbcac2a070ea3f3af8be549a18c404215aaa031137242335f4c83643da4", "ABIDE1_HOLDOUT": "465b83b9275d056ca897367bc2b30907c1b32663d2fd4cdda4f87111fedb541c", "ABIDE1_REP": "d0a670f11f1c39a32e1e182cd1457b51acbec5518845795c26872642565c9f35"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ABIDE1_HOLDOUT.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ABIDE1_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ABIDE1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "a2c08ebb2018b487f7bb23a8276087db0d21044acbf7d52a352419558e1b1bfa", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "ec9c300964eecd23f7ec30e00bca6a5828d1050f5e57769de7308feefeaec0b5", "task_id": "ncb21-task-4a89eea2ea597161"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-5f540298959b95f9", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-d683b74b97a5a87e", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_cobre_s2_DISC": "b7497a8274575664e5804beb3e11cffef1329604817545706973acc29035c1a3", "neg_p_fishing_cobre_s2_REP": "4959eab5cfd45d70d7c92b04d1d9ae8739e83de8a0a6be69691d1f8ad4ce161a"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_cobre_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_cobre_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "21e5b0e893b2f4e8794912e4cfb4a4b8d507e76c4b773ee6ad60924bd4001187", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 4, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.457 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "95713f390b8d529ac3ee78f6220f8f4b60037d1b0fcdb0f9811fddd38050d64c", "task_id": "ncb21-task-4b7a7370c57ed067"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-092cd51bcb5448d7", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-52ade9cc33e0962a", "cohort_content_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "a3e6f1609ea823c9216310eaea1cf3e54443ed385d8f2c4ccb0374907756646b", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "4cc03f072ec07c42f4ceaa18a43bd2065e0d5c508c7d70b6115b8ccc60ee1062"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "fe8cf63085aeec23297dd550e19cee01289b39d7788a72e1293fc4f508f3a65c", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 1964, "p": 4.750055361533447e-83, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 1964, "p": 4.750055361533447e-83, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "46f8de18733d12eef8d4a7c697beb000348aeeea91ffa75830bc259fa1b7ba1e", "task_id": "ncb21-task-4cedbea84f9b30c0"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-86a81a5f3a28d98c", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-e2576aa685de2ced", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "7bec65d722239c1b5a687c3d90170a845d3c8c92face6ebc094b3876a675a52d", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "4435805f8d7e5733310764875eeb26f1c23939de14fcfc7bb7f340508131a6e7", "task_id": "ncb21-task-4cfe9f0fdd4439d5"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-9ec90396df1939bd", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-15a55e6428f4914f", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_abide1_s2_DISC": "f64fdb9a022b4cf1fa4c6b6340e35e5eaddbaa257230ef9e63010c314b199492", "neg_p_fishing_abide1_s2_REP": "a40b68b8e76af370e59f1c30ebc454f5d2679aa25b80a4a2d7adb7f91acf785a"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_abide1_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_abide1_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "1fe97e397585764223c5dc491a3737a11f86b28e5a96048bb0952a01dd512e78", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 4, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "e6460740f18e18093dad75e94950fd8be3db057a52ba580b4165c15753f54267", "task_id": "ncb21-task-4d29f1cd3fe7b809"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-4f545e6dc827f451", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-d3cebacfe4c41aef", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "232132a84602d2e002eff364fa44085a7d831aca45cc3db13afd94a377e6b66e", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "e722d3550084f1d8aed04e44b0e6662f7a7d342b8abd67c8fc52eec91e78415f"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-4d686e6eead8d927/ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-4d686e6eead8d927/ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "2a3537150a930b4619731e39246afcbf2ec41aea474c39da56ac797680665ea0", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "ncb_random_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_cohort_mismatch"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "a7039411cb2ca5fe96f13cd02ed1588f84a8ac67276e925ea78a411ee28473b3", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "6e8f803d2902b3bed5a256d0695a8fda4a3e9a5c2134ec4d35877464255cc97c"}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "e63f3ec1c53e7910779984644b6e59f568bd336ebe52b68d178db84804626cf4", "task_id": "ncb21-task-4d686e6eead8d927"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-c1154a14cd1e8ef3", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-e6f81ff7126fa7a9", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_gsp_s3_DISC": "bb71aef3fc8fae65e104f0768e7da00f0c7317b56e5a62bce170edf16ce56561", "neg_site_confound_gsp_s3_REP": "324e4441c5a9eb70bddfefdf354e210ef5c0552b25965dfb9738825b582c5333"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_gsp_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_gsp_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "2422f997a12b32624b1386cbcaac6b2b440102c825ff060ce91d0e63f209c7b3", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 393, "p": 6.1120623586851636e-33, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 393, "p": 6.1120623586851636e-33, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "56080c48af250c11bafe4dbac087fadeab13229b7e753a7c79cba6594a0c253f", "task_id": "ncb21-task-4d6ae499db45b0e9"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-98bf3913e77b446e", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-05562f84efa4481c", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_abide2_s3_DISC": "d8b4b7ef5beb12941ce9702d985736156bab0c1ad9bdf35f8c1557ba4b82ca7b", "neg_random_label_abide2_s3_REP": "4ea490ff549e1ffcb193815a532d7a60af37b6f349d45fc985a1413e390c1a34"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_abide2_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_abide2_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "2d8974892839eb9e0282b6789476034adf775f04882dac1f847cd62158424b5c", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "3a64e62ff34d4b52f1ebee6c7a4851752a0072f6ae7e431a351c76b911d38215", "task_id": "ncb21-task-4e5dd8514f0717d7"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-266504b3d4e53721", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-7a571f81bfeab448", "cohort_content_hashes": {"BSNIP2_DISC": "f60b826114673b4f649dd9e41e9f01b5d76fe3fdff3fb17ac3d13f3472068df0", "COBRE_REP": "4a81a6fb00f3834982866da08d40f58816c7907a2c62838ae1fad68fd5bb18dc", "ChineseSZ_REP": "9c94c02e8066411af69f22387e526434c8c412c6df30ff250b1c7bc75f5514a8", "FBIRN_REP": "132788e0b0576e4f01ac0ac8dcbb232f2f105aea4693833ef74a59a45118b33a", "Olin_SZ_REP": "d7bef7b3dc92844bbfc9976c601ed84734ccd0a9b19af3571dddda43dc156167"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/Olin_SZ_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "2a7ddaef9d45de84a11f110184d79455274ada7fb6cdb8f2ee37df7270a8a25e", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "22744adfe0c6e340ec5dc93db8f090fcd5287d2ffc7e2d158726ebcd0e1a4934", "task_id": "ncb21-task-4e76d5dc01d8b134"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-7fe9235c8d5841b2", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-1baa52a178c84188", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "132d67ac32d672acd50168cfc4eab7677528716ad920e5e8a922bb419801dd23", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "5836be2f5b35ead7323e4bd7de2a2ee6ef00f2cf1cb798a5f2219289154ad879", "task_id": "ncb21-task-52fb8c2bbe143797"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-f38be8ab6a8f07ce", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-3ff244009ecdaede", "cohort_content_hashes": {"HCP_REP": "0cc8dc280e6a961585c8c2c53414db8d8cb581c59cf2beaef3e3731c5eca9eba", "UKB_DISC": "8f50d0d10f4265b3538407235a0af91a7bb4d1a733daea42a655d4931e0bfdd3"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/UKB_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "cb98ccfa2805e5c5c00c2229bb3942fb7d1f4b8bfb7519e7344217dadf450a04", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 84, "multiverse": true, "pattern_corr": true, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All brain-wide gates passed.; pattern_corr=0.898; dice=0.962; region_replication_fraction=0.912"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "669bba240768bb7aadeac2713e19dab682cc5178091bf77824645016277af649", "task_id": "ncb21-task-5385bb3754a4a4b3"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-1d2a9e0f4f0b8bc3", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-24c28c91c3021eb6", "cohort_content_hashes": {"OASIS3_fMRI_DISC": "7b701bee5bf1a2e4ded9c29c25ca16bc6ef6980169d9873326b362e29ecfa14d", "OASIS3_fMRI_REP": "b3ca261941658ec5a84c1f6f268e2261777e1bcd23bf28c7d2abe42d646aa786"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_fMRI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_fMRI_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "55275e82228c2c819b2340080abf08b124ede6fbcd65cb68af44aea701640223", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "e9b5afb8a5fa42a404db57970303d8813da5be7b0d83a4244bbd510b815ed5da", "task_id": "ncb21-task-539310d53e198d22"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-0f508c95b4a3bf2f", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-5c237d0baa3f1c9c", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_DISC": "7f42f7518c34775c8e5cf7c590a1fe44f226f40a7b899e71223b56ef43411663", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "c29da5322b72274b0f6c5ab19000a37d484c4c91779d4b8b1c3e54d7a09624ab", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 36, "n": 331, "p": 0.4249953679600449, "test": "pearson"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "f8b683f143ccac5cb1b99f324d36720a7877db560d4a1eb93952223b4b100c88", "task_id": "ncb21-task-53aa9c77ecfafcc8"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-f38d6fdbc4e79d95", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-1e2e456b045a80f1", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADHD200_DISC": "2ed4e2ddb4d8a3845dbec23c0b31652d26fdefe209e61fc4cdd3b636ebabb4fd", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "86d6774fc7c37a2a911b6a85ffa0bb18ea7a0fa2892612f65092ef09f20e8bc7", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiverse"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "15e3db4172297d0a629d2f75303cf6fb096cf21407adfbda5499aa1c50ee9e53", "task_id": "ncb21-task-55a3ba277e248b31"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-9b50e1327c3e6c6a", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-1a68706cf9da40e8", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_adni_fmri_s1_DISC": "56cf1fc1de77f1ea2f0aa3705858d3cfdc917e7476d0291af58d0579ca9ab69a", "neg_site_confound_adni_fmri_s1_REP": "48ccf92a3427aeaf99820f8ca81f05f92a57083967229fda3e3cb060097bf977"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_adni_fmri_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_adni_fmri_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "3e6b09cc33139c1fd44af4f7df9e3019c752fe6b294afda54ca1d4c46281d588", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 320, "p": 2.1031014919111945e-27, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 320, "p": 2.1031014919111945e-27, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "274abb8d4fad340bac944c118a5a98607461bd126fc4f129c1586aa611bad583", "task_id": "ncb21-task-5619589f08060ff8"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-54c17f36d0f78ac8", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-33c303f3c628befd", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_oasis3_fmri_s2_DISC": "52c071a51adda3c66cf2ac10fc7de57dd6d1af22fdcad51ee20f0f561d93a779", "neg_site_confound_oasis3_fmri_s2_REP": "14e44ade0a39fd24d9e24efb072521c9c2701e37cebe09fb50dd42be7928ae9a"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_oasis3_fmri_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_oasis3_fmri_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "ec6f31eb9609afa91cf1e460c27de96a78c36ea95604b4d3278f66e9b506092b", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 229, "p": 1.3896734150401247e-19, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 229, "p": 1.3896734150401247e-19, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "23f414eff394152a7effb8d67ac3cddfc9e7af40f2f92b11b6d557b910781b8a", "task_id": "ncb21-task-570497b221f3a3b4"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-e43def8c3b8cb4e9", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-9a7255624fd9d8af", "cohort_content_hashes": {"BSNIP2_REP": "5a68458b6ca1d3ceb62243f2dcf1fda0209a9d2685669530b7e4c5f279a32f23", "COBRE_REP": "4a81a6fb00f3834982866da08d40f58816c7907a2c62838ae1fad68fd5bb18dc", "ChineseSZ_REP": "9c94c02e8066411af69f22387e526434c8c412c6df30ff250b1c7bc75f5514a8", "FBIRN_DISC": "5a9a103412824c97ff34a4b7c9107198e9309be14f345c917761eb11adcdbd82", "Olin_SZ_REP": "d7bef7b3dc92844bbfc9976c601ed84734ccd0a9b19af3571dddda43dc156167"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/Olin_SZ_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "132e734dde6cfe9cfb3fab2b572ee294145d243495cddd14be4558e9f47520dd", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "eaa6d9625a75a36ca03985e8dfa00a08460ae2f9cb164c41296ee42bf78527b5", "task_id": "ncb21-task-57b20f6c2d349598"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-bdabe2252485052d", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-a6fd1f6696f73dee", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_DISC": "7f42f7518c34775c8e5cf7c590a1fe44f226f40a7b899e71223b56ef43411663", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "bb619d4b7a25933dd1361da60a7172d2dc50bb030be8abd27b7fa2cdf0176e52", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 36, "n": 541, "p": 0.8025643529885985, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 6, "multiverse": true, "pattern_corr": true, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All brain-wide gates passed.; pattern_corr=0.978; dice=1.000; region_replication_fraction=1.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "06866c7bf5e0063f6110f3f6e4224eb2b1aa6a4a78bcbe6c914cbd4edd29a37f", "task_id": "ncb21-task-57c0fb95d68b794c"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-9586a5c1af2ea3f7", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-7949fccc8b66594d", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "f81a0cc159273267df8c180be957d7fbf2f96daadb9762010a563451892ec60e", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 84, "multiverse": false, "pattern_corr": false, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication, pattern_corr, region_replication_fraction; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; pattern_corr=-0.461; dice=1.000; region_replication_fraction=0.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "b08c0793736220433b7e0decbfa2639422071864ed86b67447be2186a2003232", "task_id": "ncb21-task-584ab4cfafce706b"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-5eb1caa641a44211", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-673a0bde88903de2", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_adni_fmri_s2_DISC": "4c5ac25e4c2916bfc197bf847d25ac9ccb714f29a34d848d085e99f3882ea8de", "neg_p_fishing_adni_fmri_s2_REP": "58769e299dc65fca1df148b23b81ba004e6e0c73939ea26900b58bfaf145511e"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_adni_fmri_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_adni_fmri_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "7b11e0a8c339fe58af8ac48148e7e38fd41d98abcbcec33b6d72257ce8ee3909", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 24, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "bc8a704ef03287c466364645908e6fd72abde32eb50be6b6715767fac9d2f8f4", "task_id": "ncb21-task-58bcd93a44b2249d"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-83e09f86b797842d", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-105a92fc030ea9fa", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE1_DISC": "5a174cbcac2a070ea3f3af8be549a18c404215aaa031137242335f4c83643da4", "ABIDE1_REP": "d0a670f11f1c39a32e1e182cd1457b51acbec5518845795c26872642565c9f35"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE1_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "9044109e2279ee462578ef8c7b096e2a7ee3c1df51c2ee2e6ac2859dc10b3f3d", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "cd70adf6b973400c94c4aa50361dcdf2a623d7ca95eb3d0f2a548dc3a96f3f42", "task_id": "ncb21-task-58c1d5297a1db063"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-dc6371e72c01cdcd", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-ea1d92633e635c8a", "cohort_content_hashes": {"UKB_DISC": "8f50d0d10f4265b3538407235a0af91a7bb4d1a733daea42a655d4931e0bfdd3", "UKB_REP": "6da6a67cb610290a28f97b077dd2aa0e82c39161e4b3c622857cb54843df2357"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/UKB_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/UKB_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "06bee1c928bdd2234066a1d69a1509b22cd2c48f237624a0f68de6cff5057b86", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "cf86a89a8dd447a923bc194f594246af3b9822653a582f2361678a05f77145bc", "task_id": "ncb21-task-59318963ec862829"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-2dab47018aa41786", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-168496bc9a960ce6", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADHD200_DISC": "2ed4e2ddb4d8a3845dbec23c0b31652d26fdefe209e61fc4cdd3b636ebabb4fd", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "cf7e6d848830b15110e172a5454bf5f755da931306e0b2679a717ff8d0986f9a", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "de3ca3b7c58e9fc311e6930c867a8195d619f5bb82357dae55a24b77875e158f", "task_id": "ncb21-task-5943e26730bd798a"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-12f6919745623d9a", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-3a513699cdbc46f0", "cohort_content_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "a3e6f1609ea823c9216310eaea1cf3e54443ed385d8f2c4ccb0374907756646b", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "4cc03f072ec07c42f4ceaa18a43bd2065e0d5c508c7d70b6115b8ccc60ee1062"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "663b338cb34ef8720f265023ce1bb5a486e59db8132ae703e37629fd549061d1", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 2312, "p": 2.5853903676145945e-55, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 2312, "p": 2.5853903676145945e-55, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "2b4b02e88d07cc03a700ef0a4be63a7980413d7efb8cbee41587c3b1e304f52e", "task_id": "ncb21-task-5b649a3be5f14f38"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-ec601d06e6ff6b54", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-4359ba9588e8d632", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_adhd200_s2_DISC": "54e776c314a17dd8b11c3092305fa609510a8d208a3a23da9f9907283b496871", "neg_site_confound_adhd200_s2_REP": "8f213a1beecaf9e583bd49a372d4a11fbe29e503c61968f24a13040032042ac4"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_adhd200_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_adhd200_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "a0d13d6b18e57aac3d789b23426b2ff275ae9c8004f3202c4db278c33a24b1d6", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 156, "p": 1.759621848327281e-13, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 156, "p": 1.759621848327281e-13, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "e5d9a63214153d765a8ab80a01ec5d91df58974d431d08e9e711502254259c51", "task_id": "ncb21-task-5ba0d60c956ba6c7"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-60bd3b9afd76e376", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-817751515b78ad97", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ChineseSZ_DISC": "25886d87d5dc1da53df39d984bfa54f68aa99adbbbcb75b7d4826c4d8bdaff73", "ChineseSZ_REP": "9c94c02e8066411af69f22387e526434c8c412c6df30ff250b1c7bc75f5514a8"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "1163a3c62b47749e69a6a36dccfef781838691827182ebf97028204a4ca59a5b", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 352, "p": 0.309214890459771, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "heterogeneity_i2": 7.857490541606094, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 7.857490541606094, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=7.9"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "4ad39e70359f517d2230d6693ebaf3c0edea42ee03ba0b91cd8d271f86ee6f9a", "task_id": "ncb21-task-5bce015b2edbdfbc"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-ac9cd68260b345b7", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-d044bbe3a43f1438", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_gsp_s1_DISC": "257cf2e8086a6c0f233f44c37e1767d730ffc8ace32922f28adc06d0298a9e08", "neg_site_confound_gsp_s1_REP": "28409939a822ae4ccec2f0b55e9b8cdb1e4db6ed724273b89c88cd2c8fe3bb01"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_gsp_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_gsp_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "e6e8c5062001810b1c6a3329d8bae8c85ee98ce828394a22e8d858326aa1282d", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 393, "p": 6.1120623586851636e-33, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 393, "p": 6.1120623586851636e-33, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "466321def13aec0cf79c7704f63c084c99192f05f486edd350767ead9ac64907", "task_id": "ncb21-task-5c506cd0f1145357"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-9f890b1a7a66889e", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-d7242b6d8f14065a", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADHD200_DISC": "2ed4e2ddb4d8a3845dbec23c0b31652d26fdefe209e61fc4cdd3b636ebabb4fd", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "bb543162427d346816ff122c6e52408c1c200d3588f374fa86bdef5e9e1ebcf3", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "5dbbd94919281679121d99db090a994d3df28891be790c86d3cabcc0ce4a4e3e", "task_id": "ncb21-task-5cac938d3c79d8d8"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-5f2cf87b065cc1d8", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-7c0e34a5a642ea3b", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_fbirn_s3_DISC": "2834c0ebdc42b31acd1ad4e9e76f1b0998a0d6030878658d2b146c92291a215c", "neg_p_fishing_fbirn_s3_REP": "dcfe81782f169c938b34faea7f0c76d2ea937594d003c5d63c2a86d935578810"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_fbirn_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_fbirn_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "dc6208e1e2537a3d4f1f864e5c13cac7b90ae1c487f8ea28190ece6501faa95f", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 4, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.703 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "85157fe150207bab74358428c0c77c294fe4412abaa5008a2e1a42e2816f5255", "task_id": "ncb21-task-5dbbeb9b0284680c"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-042202d5c660975c", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-19c161b6c003a2c9", "cohort_content_hashes": {"GSP_DISC": "985a63b8b3690092b320434e799efee90a602fc428817def729345aafd510658", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/GSP_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "5c99366ea1e38e905c83a2001890ef2486e0dde3d65d5af8c3196a915de0354e", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 3, "multiverse": false, "pattern_corr": false, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication, pattern_corr, region_replication_fraction; replication=non_replicated_cohort_mismatch; pattern_corr=nan; dice=0.000; region_replication_fraction=0.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "f8326e20ce8938702036f951e4ecc39e632028f57bde7a6a0ed63a163539de5b", "task_id": "ncb21-task-5dc738265f5849e3"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-9eaf2a23ddb73ea3", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-afa6af7f828fbdae", "cohort_content_hashes": {"FBIRN_DISC": "5a9a103412824c97ff34a4b7c9107198e9309be14f345c917761eb11adcdbd82", "FBIRN_REP": "132788e0b0576e4f01ac0ac8dcbb232f2f105aea4693833ef74a59a45118b33a"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "cabcc46a163788999bc942e18ba9865e5b31aef7afbac738a20f7d8ef2e2a881", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "2868ae9118b7a86989bdfdf714cb4f82e25936668c291dd2d910c337565e7cf7", "task_id": "ncb21-task-5dcad199cd3ebbe8"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-0b1c1daa0a5f38a6", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-e81507811a8d25ce", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_oasis3_fmri_s1_DISC": "8f4c6f43cfe463406fbcb33666a9ec498c42acf7680f6cc6f84bde066cee91a8", "neg_random_label_oasis3_fmri_s1_REP": "e4861c22178d14191db7cb7d135a8106ba4956e1148a811f28a62fe584140532"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_oasis3_fmri_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_oasis3_fmri_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "ce4afd537e619093552c49c07bd7b74c04644e97474cab410b47602365bf47f2", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "7d48530055cf08c8bdbf1fa35b7d645452f83a25b701cf54fa773fbb25575533", "task_id": "ncb21-task-5df4f49fee28445e"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-c0dc3336ffe218d2", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-7a07ed551915fd07", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_underpowered_hcp_s2_DISC": "4cc39999273e9fa988f575d03937eb1703c866c79969d7ad15af50100bbccf2d", "neg_underpowered_hcp_s2_REP": "5a08878acae0312d3cb97d1c596a9b0b064a973370aa47f46fbdd7d48f761a98"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_hcp_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_hcp_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "c43f51b923d70e0dd21de25e27545f9c48a4b2856db313352b7fcdcb6e2036c9", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "under_powered", "rationale": "Failed gates: power, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.512 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "under_powered", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "79be2bd71aea45b64fd869aaec9df95f1b26e354b3fef26801e9e38e6243c8e8", "task_id": "ncb21-task-5e173813ef1f00f0"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-717fef42ce5138d1", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-5151a76b417ad551", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_DISC": "7f42f7518c34775c8e5cf7c590a1fe44f226f40a7b899e71223b56ef43411663", "ADNI_REP": "56cd379d34a3e7f93f341c1014daa9b3a9146606a68d4720d4513d09e35d73b6"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "6171d92df900822326e18053701eb8e329f8aa03818a685d0ce3298c1589a6c2", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "3767888bd390b0dd7f2528d8735397462e3f95ad024b2c31871fb1c65b2d4357", "task_id": "ncb21-task-5f1d8ac86e76906e"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-1329501baee4943a", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-21fd4a7942a133d5", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "aa43031fe609ff595a3416a5823868a19439a370bf8b00d198763412edb8fcc7", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "8e100a38460df718f83a1c65b4266c7f18d6c16ab8e3a6aebef370452bb62d83", "task_id": "ncb21-task-5f409c0792f04b6a"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-ea89da536ec1b952", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-e39a1190a91a21bd", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_DISC": "7f42f7518c34775c8e5cf7c590a1fe44f226f40a7b899e71223b56ef43411663", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "9cba4ca0465fd03f5d3e3543a76b72e4eddc115b70a7f872b6187c96d888bef9", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 36, "n": 331, "p": 0.4249953679600449, "test": "pearson"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 6, "multiverse": true, "pattern_corr": true, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All brain-wide gates passed.; pattern_corr=0.990; dice=1.000; region_replication_fraction=1.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "316300e2a71304dedb4361eb8e619b0ebccdaefd417733fe7cd802128e6d72fa", "task_id": "ncb21-task-5f5526a5d9758b26"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-6ace315a9094473a", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-0d2c23cb04d4f819", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_ukb_s2_DISC": "f5fad1cc24410e2de2e822207fe16304e64d5bf22a5a9d85430c21757c953304", "neg_p_fishing_ukb_s2_REP": "952eb42660025a1b085537c4b08b28364cc80f67549df1d216a567b727e94b57"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_ukb_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_ukb_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "68744b43554577040ef848e9fbf97ad48f00eb82f98d81d65d9492852de4f90b", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 24, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "f09e648ee1748aba690357738088fc51dffe1945370279b7eee3a748f652e767", "task_id": "ncb21-task-5fe2b96510e06feb"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-2b36f4bbee998e56", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-7c9f17f7a1a2a85c", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "32d205960dcb125f0c79189aa0af388184c97fab6eee18a736ad7d30cca28018", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "a1f98dc5baa3c7ebb215d63ae17cc70faddebeec77b811486e6d4a2ba71c7ada", "task_id": "ncb21-task-60f7a3ceb0c0d995"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-b22524a12bd4a0b9", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-3852c7b8e66b6dd3", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_DISC": "7f42f7518c34775c8e5cf7c590a1fe44f226f40a7b899e71223b56ef43411663", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "ec8230b46c6c2069b4087840499f768fc2416ec558d26eddf6ba5ef0636f5be6", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "01619d685f0571114e975b59624ecea5a763e2c6e507bb0da85057b2e6033bd2", "task_id": "ncb21-task-6110eb85e2d7580c"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-c3a081875a1cf586", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-7c3a138817e29648", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_DISC": "7f42f7518c34775c8e5cf7c590a1fe44f226f40a7b899e71223b56ef43411663", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "9fe5098b446328a47be8ac58a34e30b9ff1c7ba8b4f774f9e084f441d5e3ab2e", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 36, "n": 541, "p": 0.8025643529885985, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "f604145d84bcaf27a19372fb85b7924b15d9110a5ad73063fb3cb1b86460e67e", "task_id": "ncb21-task-61b1b74fe9df4b4f"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-f4db51596e08aa4e", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-53cccb1f9fc7e244", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "232132a84602d2e002eff364fa44085a7d831aca45cc3db13afd94a377e6b66e", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "e722d3550084f1d8aed04e44b0e6662f7a7d342b8abd67c8fc52eec91e78415f"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "3d300f240f6ebec2f5b03a98af984514bb628b51b8ca55e85e5b87c31cbdc4c9", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.485 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "8b4098f5e23c20164f5a40261ac743918c049295f4a8396017fd2c286f5ca2d5", "task_id": "ncb21-task-61e1f885b6a8ae8c"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-5b85792fec387f31", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-e54819db58d3e174", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_DISC": "7f42f7518c34775c8e5cf7c590a1fe44f226f40a7b899e71223b56ef43411663", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "3c8ce5a417d86716796413dc269b5e7b98f54c1d8bc1d3085df56b79f3201d26", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 6, "multiverse": true, "pattern_corr": true, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All brain-wide gates passed.; pattern_corr=0.978; dice=1.000; region_replication_fraction=1.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "0700da5775d5ac14c7829448d218e321aa2e39ed44a8f9bcc24cbaf1112dcc37", "task_id": "ncb21-task-61e7a78710d971c6"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-e035748f4f603bb4", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-95b5c99632a013f6", "cohort_content_hashes": {"OASIS3_DISC": "8a048aaff562775d7c80f7027c9d8bb56cc738b7563d25ca06af7cb33df89d31", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "33e2e0d9d19873fde64cb6324c34fe59dded8dd4b6c2e87013b957227e59024a", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "fs_version", "levels": 4, "n": 780, "p": 0.07356894195085882, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "b0a3f6542e35dd9f57a2a194184ab49b29a35be83a58b206e6637245533e31b6", "task_id": "ncb21-task-6312b91e545f9c34"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-82c3329f50510efe", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-c83b7cf3992ec083", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_hcp_s2_DISC": "479b586077dc4461ed67855616302987cabffcd21b9ec2646b65bfaf9d071e58", "neg_site_confound_hcp_s2_REP": "f13ed55410fc5ab5f5a473f6faf1aea74a80aad801e5bfdd9f11a51aeb297bff"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_hcp_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_hcp_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "f73ee1a5fa08333f65e44a5bf841c515affc6664ca9e4796bc825869d8a9ff64", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 270, "p": 6.266665841089351e-23, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 270, "p": 6.266665841089351e-23, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "e60ffe6a3a10197d5e4cbf818ec26403ac40334a2e82a508c94832bc6b8de849", "task_id": "ncb21-task-63786523d2fca470"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-880fcb45e6645cae", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-49d02235c00a9e00", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_abide1_s1_DISC": "7aadcf58721f55bdff338f3d378eb2bed83ee0c3a247ad52767adb52f626021c", "neg_random_label_abide1_s1_REP": "cffdff702f08818638933446cf3f538a4645825f0edc8428fa827e9d49b09c87"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_abide1_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_abide1_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "91f91d93aa1b9f33c5920bdb218a711bfb7170441bc4b8010f8c6c13ad9ec825", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "fbcf766f93a8fe6ff905e3cc505a544c4c98beab1e7c8873d12860cca84a38e6", "task_id": "ncb21-task-63b1a1b142214123"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-3ad601039168835a", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-cb5b033ee55fa89b", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "96fd3023c3bdbfaa0ee3f2263ec52ba4253f4f52424d76dadf96e22ad6686415", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "c59a217d7ea00a25e998dadb468f92288f1c292cef1f1dc9f7d64526e6b208e9", "task_id": "ncb21-task-63dee284104791ed"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-6ec87b076698475c", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-f7025326bd4f77a5", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_hcp_aging_s2_DISC": "090a86c880bf66ba61a853d0c9678bfeb97d649ea70d1853eb6e589f822dd0e8", "neg_random_label_hcp_aging_s2_REP": "5ad92a2fb3422f093bae2cdc8e97c7047af89308927b5857dfa09b91b4584c96"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_hcp_aging_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_hcp_aging_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "5d628bcfcc0b61eee263950772734ec4357efc41e17f3181af461559f2a7ad09", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "7df9d8148700db46cc2192c128cf5d6f97c5c8890fb18dc926797228b72c4c9d", "task_id": "ncb21-task-64aa8f89379840a2"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-d7791ed71415a487", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-8f84418dda864a44", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_cobre_s1_DISC": "16afbb094117d29a5f4c037f4874edee54adb4d12fac821e9885fa41b1e5657a", "neg_site_confound_cobre_s1_REP": "416e08cdc482149dceccabe539ca3a0d5645f5cf2e8ef48d130e770701674f2a"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_cobre_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_cobre_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "73777bb9e859f7b9c7ed2ed14935002ac2ae614116e12b6af02c85dc7c32abfd", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 40, "p": 0.00014780231033445423, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 40, "p": 0.00014780231033445423, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": false, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness, power, replication; confound_incomplete; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.457 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "5a50cfa753003e787d6704a4fc56ccb6e92066c1a03bce2deb94baefd63a7087", "task_id": "ncb21-task-64c5494969be2521"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-e2684641edc8c6e6", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-915021dda4c2e8a9", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_oasis3_fmri_s1_DISC": "53253b84ecd6d0bc55bb4dd9190daef80c63793e7b4ba7e60abd8b9f18f5466d", "neg_site_confound_oasis3_fmri_s1_REP": "44362127c8bfc8dc366f6df90b04d3941a0a858c27730e9105b5116a5e18a1a5"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_oasis3_fmri_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_oasis3_fmri_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "117863727385db12f3a56dc973e8da12d1adc9b2f3417eb5b5368592cf0b2e7d", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 229, "p": 1.3896734150401247e-19, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 229, "p": 1.3896734150401247e-19, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "82b2aafc905467e0a2403a9113688888420846421f4df439c22f2a5eeffc32ba", "task_id": "ncb21-task-651fe3968af88b71"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-21a609397542ba4a", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-75be796b0379a25a", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_hcp_aging_s1_DISC": "d4a759fc8a404ed86fa3fbbdbfe29b78c85bb8400fb80968dd83c92ac74b7509", "neg_p_fishing_hcp_aging_s1_REP": "2f88f56ec411a702d8c564d3df00a5cecaf903e52d1cccba0a3e5bd7df56c916"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_hcp_aging_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_hcp_aging_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "c5b21429a085d8973b000197bef2b72f3fb815ff1454a9c37a9d8fdce8f6642e", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 24, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "81d85ac59c6f1f4d107a620fe7246ef1d74039111e629e9ce24b63c4d7fe067e", "task_id": "ncb21-task-6554781f072d152a"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-4cdc34b013079f25", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-1861eb96bff66a7d", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADHD200_DISC": "2ed4e2ddb4d8a3845dbec23c0b31652d26fdefe209e61fc4cdd3b636ebabb4fd", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "c5e32d9167cfb809a99203950f00bc7d03efa445a39cb89c2b6cf17a87b756e1", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "e6973150e54912200c49243972ce5bb614881ede98aa1082ac4c381a20d7267b", "task_id": "ncb21-task-67e9643af045427c"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-9976660e5ef9dac3", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-e32862a56fce0d83", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_cobre_s3_DISC": "8a36c6505bd4cd75141d5540e05c634be789080a9cb9585be54d8dc408f18db2", "neg_site_confound_cobre_s3_REP": "d67e31d056c52dd9f0c677ade409a71ed734e5f41e35b8e5add52cd5884ab1e9"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_cobre_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_cobre_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "7362fea340adeb24b1808c1fa10c70f51e5d11a5a9d2032353dc9358bcfaa228", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 40, "p": 0.00014780231033445423, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 40, "p": 0.00014780231033445423, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": false, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness, power; confound_incomplete; power=0.457 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "963fb3e22344a340445016756d0971c92862dbbd3be045711bad715bbb1a8543", "task_id": "ncb21-task-68cc55b9f860d4a8"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-a1bf69b8f56d46c9", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-66f27e9fb5dd2517", "cohort_content_hashes": {"UKB_DISC": "8f50d0d10f4265b3538407235a0af91a7bb4d1a733daea42a655d4931e0bfdd3", "UKB_REP": "6da6a67cb610290a28f97b077dd2aa0e82c39161e4b3c622857cb54843df2357"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/UKB_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/UKB_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "f9f8f685f30ece08dd480866c31748d82a7008d8437bc891c7fffdb0e530fb05", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "ff33729c5acf0fb79e863ed3a328ff81a308e3a6f7eabd45a792570e52022613", "task_id": "ncb21-task-6959208181ee6072"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-c8faa8d62af041ef", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-1ea0be69229af7a2", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "b3b321b8a014a6a467d793672f72ca20168d526dc24448a90d81b38f7be12b3f", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "6f2b28e095efa753077338dba7ac9dac27a657d7a388b461ade19fc5a4b45da1", "task_id": "ncb21-task-6a44a66368a81a10"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-0cdad63325891f3d", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-4559fa0aed7011d2", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ADHD200_DISC": "2ed4e2ddb4d8a3845dbec23c0b31652d26fdefe209e61fc4cdd3b636ebabb4fd"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_DISC.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "92b8187f8ad59609f2e2df0170b7fbc73887b8f64712d5acd8f044c97c395cf4", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "3fd94a19c4d7cb2fda5016db321289cb9d2bf908ca6b033bfa116125ae60617f", "task_id": "ncb21-task-6b0da08282f4c1c9"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-047feb6835500e20", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-398bb1d9c6e61c0a", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ChineseSZ_DISC": "25886d87d5dc1da53df39d984bfa54f68aa99adbbbcb75b7d4826c4d8bdaff73", "ChineseSZ_REP": "9c94c02e8066411af69f22387e526434c8c412c6df30ff250b1c7bc75f5514a8"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "e675564139416c9bf84339bea6b2ab455f981f32bf304ae405ad45b15740128b", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "9ed287ced8a7f10f75f598c04ada7337b3e0baabb4c7eab46302632292e2cda3", "task_id": "ncb21-task-6b538cef1e94a9e0"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-fcd62e593092700b", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-2296934ffe3c0610", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_abcd_s2_DISC": "562f47ae0a2b1fe0528e129f6dd26c2b049b2b7c8229da98c4825d82fe94c81f", "neg_site_confound_abcd_s2_REP": "4408f828ad2301f2a1426095640fc434e3fcd72387b4d073c4d80fa56d0ef1ac"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_abcd_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_abcd_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "413be2e837c5fd15856588a85b3fc2e4ef9f307975afd7a1b15495831b69da26", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 2598, "p": 3.3975427972341566e-205, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 2598, "p": 3.3975427972341566e-205, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "b089edc68bfe838f5cbad7e6ee776f339a0b407324ace628af3abb5b54ed9f83", "task_id": "ncb21-task-6b92f1cdb343e382"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-629feeb21e3e9864", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-4f1a10683a88a63b", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADHD200_DISC": "2ed4e2ddb4d8a3845dbec23c0b31652d26fdefe209e61fc4cdd3b636ebabb4fd", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "7f4e58a8253d8de0d3a6403f0f40b1675a6f0ecf13a04c8bf1a3a98d7490e595", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "62c5d90cf37776b94ea78992aa8c16c65b8bdd2f8ca78e6a1474593f42e4432f", "task_id": "ncb21-task-6bae7b3e8e8252e2"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-1f683beae6c7e55d", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-7ebf597ee498d8e3", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADHD200_DISC": "2ed4e2ddb4d8a3845dbec23c0b31652d26fdefe209e61fc4cdd3b636ebabb4fd", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "57e54176fe94f28afe4b65fbecfd8d8a32dab358d34d42fa1645f06f8b6e7545", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "cefda89d63333c170c9633dc442a1f5073cd0389b2dcba7244ef94b7fb2c8492", "task_id": "ncb21-task-6c02f426814e0028"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-493d1fd9443c1c35", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-a26b1481745ce55c", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "f640c5ce8f744ffe037848d9b978f457446132f11db7ccbd808d3088ecfd5d4d", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "8f6b82f3fdc81645cdbe7581f07beadbdae21707099a3883bd529b8c46b190be", "task_id": "ncb21-task-6cab1406c0470865"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-bbf85b6c044b210f", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-7649990ad945fd14", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_gsp_s2_DISC": "69ded3f37cdb00b8daba08896b091ba121f13b5b1c3be7a90bcbdd72e8cb7b16", "neg_random_label_gsp_s2_REP": "65847c8d397e06f37f104b876adca8a7728a3bf65dc7f2f632eaec759ab1d679"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_gsp_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_gsp_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "dec6eb6008e98bf524ea1bdba54c84843fda14d67e5716179c66502ea52f5bb6", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "f9ead2993169556343ffbadcfb026a83c90e960ed96399614aa56a36710c4e45", "task_id": "ncb21-task-6cddee8f13757a45"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-75bd3855eddc86c8", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-cff158498ebbc35a", "cohort_content_hashes": {"OASIS3_DISC": "8a048aaff562775d7c80f7027c9d8bb56cc738b7563d25ca06af7cb33df89d31", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "c7e2e70658f72efef5ecaf8bbefbea86c98d7a3b0a0500312fe265e451834f5f", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "fs_version", "levels": 4, "n": 576, "p": 0.00014048948470919836, "test": "anova"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "fs_version", "levels": 4, "n": 576, "p": 0.00014048948470919836, "test": "anova"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "age", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "cb8805a22c346abd49d331f64b5922926c5e2bd5e35253616ad7099c181a4be7", "task_id": "ncb21-task-6d3364afde7ca34a"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-f6cf8c122d61317c", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-613986362a2828c7", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE1_DISC": "5a174cbcac2a070ea3f3af8be549a18c404215aaa031137242335f4c83643da4", "ABIDE1_REP": "d0a670f11f1c39a32e1e182cd1457b51acbec5518845795c26872642565c9f35"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE1_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "90f58841ef800dcd80070fa9e52b7314630078a52288e02536c4f39c443eedee", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "881482ab4f261488692a21b1ae689ea34d734d9b469f0898e4831bf1d0f3c9b4", "task_id": "ncb21-task-6d8377be18725b95"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-b6e37ce62a4f72f8", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-534b571b8a38e27f", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_fbirn_s2_DISC": "35629b4251c85a81b617cca30cde0d597d22a01cc8623af5be306f8ea648e0e8", "neg_p_fishing_fbirn_s2_REP": "065dcbcfb22d6be52a6d6b4adb9d59d933938f5df3d0c022115bbe1497be4cdb"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_fbirn_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_fbirn_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "f66d5cb401096f6cfa6bbe336276ea26ac34dea2ef41072f7f2535337d58f290", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 4, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.703 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "4f1ad0e474bb7d732fe85a9dcb819c58d6f5788c69b1db052c38e28bfba514bd", "task_id": "ncb21-task-6dd2635d1430a201"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-349eb82545a4fed6", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-adffb0ffc32cc3fd", "cohort_content_hashes": {"OASIS3_DISC": "8a048aaff562775d7c80f7027c9d8bb56cc738b7563d25ca06af7cb33df89d31", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "f03888b3a866f0142e21a912603728e0c25a9e3046a21f4ab8508cfcbabfc085", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "fs_version", "levels": 4, "n": 780, "p": 0.07356894195085882, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 3, "multiverse": true, "pattern_corr": true, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All brain-wide gates passed.; pattern_corr=0.969; dice=1.000; region_replication_fraction=1.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "e744cf058c358c4bbc566cceb86f068b580b2ca45cbf9feb2c71bd5fe2304f17", "task_id": "ncb21-task-6e50e1fd75314a01"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-6c9d8d248e03fd07", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-1bb69c61e99fe8ae", "cohort_content_hashes": {"COBRE_DISC": "f53b3405d06487a9d268b89165605cc0ed60d2c3a68e41f8ebe73660d9916d79", "COBRE_REP": "4a81a6fb00f3834982866da08d40f58816c7907a2c62838ae1fad68fd5bb18dc"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "3e949d2bc802da154545f5798044376097457c063d1ed17cff81cc0a63f99660", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "under_powered", "rationale": "Failed gates: power, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.790 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "under_powered", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "9d7109b0d9c26d0eb60536b636e00bef06dc4f6fbee0a861ebbc57c32cfb585c", "task_id": "ncb21-task-6e851b324b0b1e82"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-740708798029c58d", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-0cd25512fdeec5bb", "cohort_content_hashes": {"BSNIP2_REP": "5a68458b6ca1d3ceb62243f2dcf1fda0209a9d2685669530b7e4c5f279a32f23", "FBIRN_REP": "132788e0b0576e4f01ac0ac8dcbb232f2f105aea4693833ef74a59a45118b33a"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "5b0b997de694bd53efc4e87eef2784043703de3a0d536377ddca987553228da8", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.605 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "e186428946bef3dcf0fd9190c0af0c8be93e614506d054e7fb6f1796839d2bc3", "task_id": "ncb21-task-6ec6dfff264c160d"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-6e919234505c3841", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-5fb987203ec31b43", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "232132a84602d2e002eff364fa44085a7d831aca45cc3db13afd94a377e6b66e", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "e722d3550084f1d8aed04e44b0e6662f7a7d342b8abd67c8fc52eec91e78415f"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "a1b30228bd85615916e0c6792b247848b207d34017fff1b406ea4fa5bf83d3f1", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.485 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "10c6c32e05e25ee6b149819bc966fdf5a4b5ab21f33d2573bc293807f14a6ac4", "task_id": "ncb21-task-6ee140df8df7f981"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-43c43273ba8985e4", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-ad78cc291bfefd08", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_underpowered_adhd200_s2_DISC": "87c591e9655c99bb9db0ede7b773b1f6d2e5bde4edcc9f0ab11205239b7ff10c", "neg_underpowered_adhd200_s2_REP": "bff1cf40c3eac8585eb86c6f1d1fd49aaf40daf5611a454bb88cc98d55e1b478"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_adhd200_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_adhd200_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "68cff14517a0b124240b9a7c866c29e1925fca743f953ef367b3147c106b0e07", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.512 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "ddefce22242b3d85fe49a6cfba537268df18d91f8071d020fd0149716e31a88a", "task_id": "ncb21-task-6f2582973ec9c047"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-08c6866776e43268", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-e6f4fe714885cdea", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "bbb43637cb0e5a0b7f31b6df41777575dbfe80fd5620987204e21d43072bd9cf", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 84, "multiverse": false, "pattern_corr": false, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication, pattern_corr; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; pattern_corr=-0.461; dice=1.000; region_replication_fraction=0.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "822069155a5721afd47faa08e58871f55f4ddd2a09537809909f72da903bca02", "task_id": "ncb21-task-6fea1e2f03994aa9"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-6aa47e3b129ad9fb", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-2c50a189e0bf24b5", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ChineseSZ_DISC": "25886d87d5dc1da53df39d984bfa54f68aa99adbbbcb75b7d4826c4d8bdaff73", "ChineseSZ_REP": "9c94c02e8066411af69f22387e526434c8c412c6df30ff250b1c7bc75f5514a8"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "fffd5462ff6e1b56f99ee5ea0c415629c5ae05e93c85dd8fc01644ebb763b6b8", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiverse"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "ac0f83eea18f0f04dff5ad765991814258a71b74806b67a25b6a9e44f8071975", "task_id": "ncb21-task-6ff6d5213109f836"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-58774413687b61b9", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-c8566e7dd2ee4e4a", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "232132a84602d2e002eff364fa44085a7d831aca45cc3db13afd94a377e6b66e", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "e722d3550084f1d8aed04e44b0e6662f7a7d342b8abd67c8fc52eec91e78415f"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-70dcb426e511c52f/ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-70dcb426e511c52f/ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "18317bb054ef78c160c8508af120055de1120c089bc6fad60fd63a6340b6ada7", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "ncb_random_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "902a866fd91ffde8001bae60e5cc1527b8138506a3777feff68e2a9d04b810fa", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "8543ea19e2f6f4586882f87ab43aadde083e833af9b496ad3f451f6e7fffd9cd"}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "87cdddc68a77f0dee6381dd312bd5a3b7b9e18669632ecda33dba8bfe6ce7eb6", "task_id": "ncb21-task-70dcb426e511c52f"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-123acaf77fc95cf1", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-f0ec7babf360528b", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_adhd200_s3_DISC": "c947b0d3d274326c160bc3503bbac7908be5ce22a68988dafad4192228b93758", "neg_random_label_adhd200_s3_REP": "915af4b25445b13dcdbed27b06042f6864f4179c2f5b87a83b9ff97a616611c3"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_adhd200_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_adhd200_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "fb3fe17bb0137bfc19d06d3d4b464e420faa2999b20f83234f7e1dcc4b499203", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "6ddecdcff19ccf8ec83ad44c0dee2abbb37f43633934bd5208995cc64b2c9d4c", "task_id": "ncb21-task-7115801d5ad28506"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-7fc6845e80fabb9d", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-bff52be91d6404b7", "cohort_content_hashes": {"UKB_DISC": "8f50d0d10f4265b3538407235a0af91a7bb4d1a733daea42a655d4931e0bfdd3", "UKB_REP": "6da6a67cb610290a28f97b077dd2aa0e82c39161e4b3c622857cb54843df2357"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/UKB_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/UKB_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "22851d38a8fb5c63ab1bb2ef5a93e2ed0fb516afa4733b7962f0e44610890cec", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "5af80073943b2ba5217beafeadf4f1bd9c98283b1b1bdd64d364cb7eef1985a9", "task_id": "ncb21-task-713ca9b6955d7a40"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-c7fc286c99cc66c6", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-0c2bd011716a1d05", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_oasis3_s2_DISC": "e10ebf40eeb94f2c2c245a29d87341a7a4721d5adb15e10c54fdb7ba47d8f0ac", "neg_random_label_oasis3_s2_REP": "85216b51e714edfe41fd9502b95ce8dbf22111af7281060e7019e5e49a6c4020"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_oasis3_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_oasis3_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "5dcaf8e72181c8831ce0d3b58242ff7bd704ea747637a1459b148236cbad7197", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "fs_version", "levels": 4, "n": 329, "p": 0.28481881862921593, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "dac3d3b8353b074be7a47043c36aa96747240de6ba11d81322ca88df3c897407", "task_id": "ncb21-task-71a178a795c1d2ac"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-de319955c8826c8c", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-8a6ab5e1c5718e36", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_DISC": "7f42f7518c34775c8e5cf7c590a1fe44f226f40a7b899e71223b56ef43411663", "ADNI_REP": "56cd379d34a3e7f93f341c1014daa9b3a9146606a68d4720d4513d09e35d73b6"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "65c5a10b8f670f007a06783c2a9b0215c20ae6c2fb6001e7c305115d09c1bbcc", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "ea7e837af138bc5101f208e31fa81a6a38a1ad8517aa599395f29b51f4412681", "task_id": "ncb21-task-73b0d28461d6f903"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-23b408524e23a84b", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-aa8534ade69b99af", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_ukb_s2_DISC": "736ba5c4f89e1eecbb1cb9d373c8fc9127ee4fb65766f85713d0096b49f8203d", "neg_site_confound_ukb_s2_REP": "39abfb6af7f0762b813b0696d4098012442dba8b35458ba0a28be775cf44cbe9"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_ukb_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_ukb_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "b272633f4694d06f55084ace0d34669759cc8fb2bac2f27f18f170517a11a564", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 9815, "p": 0.0, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 9815, "p": 0.0, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "4d1bd7f6d0b57beb35bfa0934e8d02f52061092ba96f7ffe1a3ef9d4d2179378", "task_id": "ncb21-task-7596ef18550d00bb"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-6fa6169d2993bc1d", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-0bda5d387ad52a67", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_abide2_s2_DISC": "e1ef992cf9fb833709314bd9b2457796193e6a9952aab7a48c4c357f5f4d5b1a", "neg_random_label_abide2_s2_REP": "4984c340e0fceea985dd296d026d67d9e7f10a70834611d3d7c2e59f345129e7"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_abide2_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_abide2_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "c9bc742d45c028c5d1f7adc772ae4d0198b1a207ebbc24c507f87af966407537", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "63329e9a501ade721b4c7ef3cdb9a5ca95638d1ba0b0b4d03b0238f75d8f1c0b", "task_id": "ncb21-task-75971af6bfe92c30"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-2387b1cf701bf90b", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-f80870e6c63c9a01", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADHD200_DISC": "2ed4e2ddb4d8a3845dbec23c0b31652d26fdefe209e61fc4cdd3b636ebabb4fd", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "bb5d8623184596e0d8ad98f64a45a34f3392d730cf9df40a065d303ad64e4ce0", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": false, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 84, "multiverse": true, "pattern_corr": true, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication, dice; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; pattern_corr=0.980; dice=0.000; region_replication_fraction=1.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "d46ef9ea1488af2bb39b93cdd81c295143b854804c4b026a327d3d82b1eff252", "task_id": "ncb21-task-764317d4977b6d70"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-909dd51daf957cf4", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-226e96270875f9ec", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADHD200_DISC": "2ed4e2ddb4d8a3845dbec23c0b31652d26fdefe209e61fc4cdd3b636ebabb4fd", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "d7ffdf9953a4d6119e8a0461dcd184480d4631c54c6ade2d87ec1d5a764e8c2a", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "4e5302b10cf80a9b5322105d848508eefb5e0d0838b58cae264ec27e0cb2af85", "task_id": "ncb21-task-76a0158c903db264"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-bd78b101a1f87be6", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-973494e454ef077f", "cohort_content_hashes": {"OASIS3_DISC": "8a048aaff562775d7c80f7027c9d8bb56cc738b7563d25ca06af7cb33df89d31", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "ceaf8ad151cb9f19b811e3aad401518a454f6728d85d95f12b06f61b3ee18895", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "fs_version", "levels": 4, "n": 780, "p": 0.07356894195085882, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "b750449c0e1d5de63a42ddece66531c1f40d9d49e2922db9caff16ade0f8029a", "task_id": "ncb21-task-76fc7b6b4604ef89"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-5d87d9cb45790f0b", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-6964c9d6128fdbce", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_gsp_s3_DISC": "7b54fc6b79444845c373e3ff189394ef474685845df7e30762e18ead966ac20f", "neg_random_label_gsp_s3_REP": "272ec7a7d2aee58d596b2e9302e062ed9324919da7909f8ddd6f71505bd469fb"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_gsp_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_gsp_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "a0275036cfbaf9d46cd4e5a4e3db959ca777b8f277d920a0541a949183660951", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "bf75ff26d6b050be600fe59d0e946cac29938a1e71010a85b844e4fab3936c2d", "task_id": "ncb21-task-77c328339f5043cc"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-1a4801cd609a8bc9", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-db7e4bc1e5eaa39e", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_gsp_s1_DISC": "bb515579b98142cb05fbd9f8f45037359353fc99b8b409c640c940732347e9c6", "neg_p_fishing_gsp_s1_REP": "ee47b7e724f8e26760439410e599092ee31b37187126a793c37b4eee1299125f"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_gsp_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_gsp_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "c1de1c1e60a80b244bf42270330fa4a8d05790131ef92cbebf26144dbc587b2d", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 4, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "f39ffe426b52e6b8c4bedc80cb21502dc9ca651a82d00408103516a03e7d0c2b", "task_id": "ncb21-task-7822cacea7224256"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-f8fa9003aa7c9d3b", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-00d00d7a98b037e1", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_abide1_s3_DISC": "a5c61b0154f4703b743ee5e82f2e18d980686fbafabb8c6252c9e48ecf57b1f8", "neg_random_label_abide1_s3_REP": "0adfd7ddb3fd3660a176c13db1a6ec7e4567a742bc541e57dc1ae58c9a819caf"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_abide1_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_abide1_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "0a42b0ff7c1dee1abae6a822cda3d6dc8f99cb51549f63e38ea141fa41f2a923", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "ba2b37d2111407078615523449c964fe9582af43c9076bb110831fbcc3cb919a", "task_id": "ncb21-task-789099ad918540d2"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-673bb19e90e472ee", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-b27e3f8fadbba924", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADHD200_DISC": "2ed4e2ddb4d8a3845dbec23c0b31652d26fdefe209e61fc4cdd3b636ebabb4fd", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "bfe7ea48ba21592a75901b003042a6361be5d82e0cecfd99f6d01147235169bf", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "5f16ef97eacbef8e1162f8ec3e3e4c99ef08f9975930fb1759db5eaa65014d6a", "task_id": "ncb21-task-794f22c1c72a1a42"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-12ff5dcc555c8bea", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-c552e6d4c8208e64", "cohort_content_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "a3e6f1609ea823c9216310eaea1cf3e54443ed385d8f2c4ccb0374907756646b", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "4cc03f072ec07c42f4ceaa18a43bd2065e0d5c508c7d70b6115b8ccc60ee1062"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-795e076042502261/NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-795e076042502261/NACC_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "ae676bdb5ea463e744e9acc23114bfd741aa83fb64dbbf0fbea1e044b7bc5905", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 3101, "p": 0.29340327551703527, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "ncb_random_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "349ed4a1600c8ab93bc8baf10bb3cdbc7fa8877b554e0f7f9670d531ad9b0eb4", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "f042d0e8133071457a4a88d649f904d0e96f9b48d7dd893f58658cc239b55a7b"}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "1dbd696612ab209c9acf5b0e9aefd9b648e7c2637eb9121d1305fa5d12f30dae", "task_id": "ncb21-task-795e076042502261"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-693e96c3edd41a98", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-c0c640ae2cee07b1", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADHD200_DISC": "2ed4e2ddb4d8a3845dbec23c0b31652d26fdefe209e61fc4cdd3b636ebabb4fd", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "a3637ead6d081786219a8042ac969167f8620171993e1795fe7a8b12b104317d", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "ebca22ca3e80409d4635d2b232dce25d1c58c8f24bc583c69b619820e87627ff", "task_id": "ncb21-task-79d124c80a9f3f93"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-061d1b244a34b451", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-a6298d057f42caee", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_fbirn_s3_DISC": "68835948d20daec3eef45b236f4e99bad73109d2cecaa0e3a45306ef28acbc5e", "neg_site_confound_fbirn_s3_REP": "9e5a57733a3b323ff7f656c1dac1ad994c39d50c2d7457b74e6f55e3b083a6a1"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_fbirn_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_fbirn_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "d928c35ea7a7866578b1437c2d0a383d1b31c67ded2adf50733c8b8c71aaa1bf", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 71, "p": 3.351925452602801e-07, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 71, "p": 3.351925452602801e-07, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": false, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness, power; confound_incomplete; power=0.703 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "8ff020a7b9e44da7bf2b283257304ba346df97aa48a506683025e628e3a7e665", "task_id": "ncb21-task-7ae540af62da3c12"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-a08821ce404a9f53", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-a279f14844b262e2", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_abide2_s1_DISC": "940b4b8edb64d78383cbf69ae31331855698cf94f84b5d5a3c358315dd03b05a", "neg_p_fishing_abide2_s1_REP": "95564d1a48ef30bdc935a2020b860150f20bc3215b703839fc1b28986c2370a0"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_abide2_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_abide2_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "c7775f0b6a7e88d992d42e27f7dcbe5ed2b9be21f85bc9b712b8f92e3767dc85", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 24, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "f9f5a9e1d67164019dfb5959e23950423cc07b2c91828cb5c6f3913dfe6066a5", "task_id": "ncb21-task-7af88f86b61154a3"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-75d84aea42f71e47", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-ffb123d0b5dc637f", "cohort_content_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "a3e6f1609ea823c9216310eaea1cf3e54443ed385d8f2c4ccb0374907756646b", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "4cc03f072ec07c42f4ceaa18a43bd2065e0d5c508c7d70b6115b8ccc60ee1062"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "7aec060e7f2d6ff7640c9ff5e8d50a2df3a559ea52d79daca6135c461925f0bf", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 2312, "p": 2.5853903676145945e-55, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 2312, "p": 2.5853903676145945e-55, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "c410c10001ccf1e7ee119f808eae789a8427e0f3f294d79fafaa092082f20ba3", "task_id": "ncb21-task-7b2cdd8e592c84a2"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-75f27bf902a69eb3", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-22c0b8daa3ec869d", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_adhd200_s3_DISC": "8947f97b16467c192cbf916d044eb6b27b06a6d422f5321a3c8d5063ff9bb885", "neg_p_fishing_adhd200_s3_REP": "f80f5f35c82dafd05e8be40640c11eeb64795319fd1b6f557d5f63ed59257e4a"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_adhd200_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_adhd200_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "4951fa994956d243eb63a6927159465930fde9503f4cc9e7ded4b232c07ed607", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 24, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "085496a0a16b89baa35a3b16ffb2b31bdc342e6fb013a6456329913c2c8584e8", "task_id": "ncb21-task-7bad2a2dd72cec13"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-56b080929487f10e", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-c894adf92b01816d", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_underpowered_abide2_s2_DISC": "10c70b6b668d3b346bab6aad17f0ba044f76db0f24ca4d13deddec3819d235d0", "neg_underpowered_abide2_s2_REP": "1c6e3bcdad0366b906e96907377d4006b45f6d1a83af62c08183097d3e72c944"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_abide2_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_abide2_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "850c1ce4bda1dea8202c3d52350a8fdcdf61df7b59f3b5a500601218ceb6e80d", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.355 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "c732c270d433a0bbe786d8221c64583b5ff783a3aba0225b0f9ed436070ece6d", "task_id": "ncb21-task-7bc03db196dcedff"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-1518a0abab435142", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-3cb5c7ed93f00eef", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "ff7979f76b02eb223911b673c61ca502992bc127aec19ca4578f79f840d89235", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "352bb3f8b89da620f3c68c501a29b9e062afc8081b897caf48de92abf95dd913", "task_id": "ncb21-task-7bc8d7047dac68a7"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-ddef0966bc3b9b24", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-a286e50d422c8f3b", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_abide2_s3_DISC": "05f0b1a4c54997da29180a4265299f10bf9bc52971729ad227587873a53a0a8e", "neg_site_confound_abide2_s3_REP": "1343964d2cd851f51b17b871b28addcd8b9bd75bfd63d120bdb3487615d0cd68"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_abide2_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_abide2_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "3405158d55218db57f47dcffaec509f30c5e6cb3275c50ffbd4d007d5acfd470", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 279, "p": 1.5559643840526863e-23, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 279, "p": 1.5559643840526863e-23, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "e474fc704bc0600b4a1a56ab9cd35472ae19835de75df19cf6786da1de2607c9", "task_id": "ncb21-task-7bcd0163c4bd3c2c"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-8482b5c202e5e323", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-6b0e9b1fb479f7c6", "cohort_content_hashes": {"HCP_DISC": "4bfd66afa7e3af1ad63ed1a3d1fdc1662e370064e97e927de95b8f783b7886a8", "HCP_REP": "0cc8dc280e6a961585c8c2c53414db8d8cb581c59cf2beaef3e3731c5eca9eba"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "2e3d7988620023f106551f923b75e651d4bc344147a4b6e46dd62d5ffe46b626", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "370811219dd514c32c901b9b9a0c9762c231b26a2559faf7b623e2c0461a2bd8", "task_id": "ncb21-task-7e0c5c0ce3670607"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-4bafecc6ed3b9d87", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-215385d2d757b6f1", "cohort_content_hashes": {"BSNIP2_REP": "5a68458b6ca1d3ceb62243f2dcf1fda0209a9d2685669530b7e4c5f279a32f23", "COBRE_REP": "4a81a6fb00f3834982866da08d40f58816c7907a2c62838ae1fad68fd5bb18dc", "ChineseSZ_DISC": "25886d87d5dc1da53df39d984bfa54f68aa99adbbbcb75b7d4826c4d8bdaff73", "ChineseSZ_REP": "9c94c02e8066411af69f22387e526434c8c412c6df30ff250b1c7bc75f5514a8", "FBIRN_REP": "132788e0b0576e4f01ac0ac8dcbb232f2f105aea4693833ef74a59a45118b33a", "Olin_SZ_REP": "d7bef7b3dc92844bbfc9976c601ed84734ccd0a9b19af3571dddda43dc156167"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/Olin_SZ_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "b6a2e2f85d16cc474594275f86edb2e46380ea4aa65850572e2f9bab1144bd65", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 352, "p": 0.309214890459771, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "771474d273270b0d33b2999e8a161eaf722878c22e37156c950f3913bb488336", "task_id": "ncb21-task-7eb216d2079d955a"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-88779694dc46460f", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-1b46ce42af68feaf", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_underpowered_adni_fmri_s2_DISC": "b4aa30701d266907041b5f788cdb9d50e50b249e6b9a5144c5a08b4e7f7867bb", "neg_underpowered_adni_fmri_s2_REP": "e31e0190421fe007cd2a94ba9736b02a74cfdec825d3578a82b201f21aae0f3c"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_adni_fmri_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_adni_fmri_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "2864b59ef79f19cb2117636069ed3fd897ca024f2a4133fdc12ccb7d3a103194", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.512 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "3d485676ce0d493dfa1e8edcf8bde7dc5a6775b6a923c3f73e7576b121636eb7", "task_id": "ncb21-task-7faecca7162c861d"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-70527a90423a8295", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-c7c79ca1a3217e5f", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ChineseSZ_DISC": "25886d87d5dc1da53df39d984bfa54f68aa99adbbbcb75b7d4826c4d8bdaff73", "ChineseSZ_REP": "9c94c02e8066411af69f22387e526434c8c412c6df30ff250b1c7bc75f5514a8"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "1cda01e5de798f8a8c0551750be82f23b6e9ab18f9ead3d85d1392ac2c939db0", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 352, "p": 0.309214890459771, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiverse"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "1f658f800cc885b7db4969dc8a111943473ac1b441e1039b55f0e068f285ca77", "task_id": "ncb21-task-8139ac828c9a3687"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-3368778ccb30dbe8", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-129d52456ff7c4a1", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "232132a84602d2e002eff364fa44085a7d831aca45cc3db13afd94a377e6b66e", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "e722d3550084f1d8aed04e44b0e6662f7a7d342b8abd67c8fc52eec91e78415f"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "f7a2f462ef5b3b7404d502c54f4d32ee1d07e67b246ba01848fdb647e326cb97", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_cohort_mismatch; power=0.530 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "63122eb1b266a6fef10054bf101d58dc811d202b9e4a2ff5c720ff7a9f25c913", "task_id": "ncb21-task-81955622e1afddff"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-f849744a3e72c7b0", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-cc01d5d3a753882c", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "c4de056d92ffcdef6b53042dc7fef732c83d55fd2d4156579295210922958ab8", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 84, "multiverse": false, "pattern_corr": false, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication, pattern_corr, region_replication_fraction; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; pattern_corr=-0.461; dice=1.000; region_replication_fraction=0.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "a25b6d44a63e68416f9b0df4a855fbf4a8c9aae6eac2c3496efb1ddb9f21fa1b", "task_id": "ncb21-task-8268cb72ce15ece1"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-a17be850c0a76e0a", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-4ceb49455f770585", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_oasis3_s1_DISC": "b1a1e457c5a20341c7f1817de696ab8ae22436d387ea534e0812b3e6daf361ff", "neg_p_fishing_oasis3_s1_REP": "3976fccd0f2e490d371492edd777c03cd78127ce2809d52d8c2cf7e2b2c3d146"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_oasis3_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_oasis3_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "06313e267b7d3baaadc337a95f25ffbbc8c2df0b2a37c6f45b682db069f3cd11", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "fs_version", "levels": 4, "n": 329, "p": 0.9684738790955139, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 6, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "6fd7574b81ccb33cfe38f110b090436968e8c6412d3df805cc4217f0a7050cc1", "task_id": "ncb21-task-82bc2831d6b1f058"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-dfbe62737d4d8555", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-23f61026b088cfd9", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_oasis3_fmri_s1_DISC": "959714966a588e9d5a7c06a4f831aca7786a50b3f0bb7736cc0a58e78ece16aa", "neg_p_fishing_oasis3_fmri_s1_REP": "243212583294049293ebadeb08f2e9c28bbc982c67ee3e82c054890980df7879"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_oasis3_fmri_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_oasis3_fmri_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "7cb868a5c6d0b12fb5d556d507c0e1c52784f1b8ae2eaba0669fcdb5edaf09d9", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 24, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "376d6d7a82a7f05bb0a356f50ebf816acc7b34b7e07df5648496026274342926", "task_id": "ncb21-task-835477c4104228f6"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-24de654ccd87dce2", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-f41dce2cbf136c22", "cohort_content_hashes": {"OASIS3_fMRI_DISC": "7b701bee5bf1a2e4ded9c29c25ca16bc6ef6980169d9873326b362e29ecfa14d", "OASIS3_fMRI_REP": "b3ca261941658ec5a84c1f6f268e2261777e1bcd23bf28c7d2abe42d646aa786"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_fMRI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_fMRI_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "4efacfb6bf2f341f999ceacd42848075321ea2ffa63cfb72c15582b85d87cba9", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "54d3ae3ebfeb84134537d6a5cbc5b8705799c804e0e8e2002bb17f632b8385eb", "task_id": "ncb21-task-848513937ba8e347"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-970b61f9cba924c6", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-2828d16ce751ab31", "cohort_content_hashes": {"OASIS3_DISC": "8a048aaff562775d7c80f7027c9d8bb56cc738b7563d25ca06af7cb33df89d31", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "69df04505c7c09f13878ff8c55e2a066ec538971b7264c86bcfe09551da566b2", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "fs_version", "levels": 4, "n": 780, "p": 0.07356894195085882, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "30ef678dc61e30c132e6c896056dab40b60007659b18f786dbab7369279629ff", "task_id": "ncb21-task-84cd5389a14a4ef5"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-aa9ca68bedbbb036", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-9bf00b4ade858536", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_hcp_s1_DISC": "20dddb913e18ab7a693813e8fb0e05a7652fe8c1210926a3af922ae9bb3d42da", "neg_site_confound_hcp_s1_REP": "bb9956bb26d77957b8e70e8d95f24352f61eabd06ac0b27315ac354f97e184e8"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_hcp_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_hcp_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "9f3e5afa2b48fd26e461559390c73a9e267e5f2a23d38fc8e661290be0ba2112", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 270, "p": 6.266665841089351e-23, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 270, "p": 6.266665841089351e-23, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "a1709c89d82192646a3ec7625fd275c739868b856aca22fd2ffdf70e7a067e4f", "task_id": "ncb21-task-85262b3d4c12b804"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-0c04451321f8aa46", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-cb2bf776de6d9950", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE1_HOLDOUT": "465b83b9275d056ca897367bc2b30907c1b32663d2fd4cdda4f87111fedb541c", "ABIDE1_REP": "d0a670f11f1c39a32e1e182cd1457b51acbec5518845795c26872642565c9f35"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ABIDE1_HOLDOUT.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ABIDE1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "e3572d0bfbb9bc0666928dcc62e6819363de7288915988182c8bed712e57590e", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "2610983dbba891445f3d068c0750d3d68f4689c02349a830f7901bdbe9a7f99c", "task_id": "ncb21-task-853f5a3df22e30b3"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-09903e42ed156c26", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-3f8c5d8c867c4a9a", "cohort_content_hashes": {"BSNIP2_DISC": "f60b826114673b4f649dd9e41e9f01b5d76fe3fdff3fb17ac3d13f3472068df0", "COBRE_REP": "4a81a6fb00f3834982866da08d40f58816c7907a2c62838ae1fad68fd5bb18dc"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "5300c69e5d1c952171b0f0fb1e3533f29bd9626ceb1d1ce88f0a9659b65529a8", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 4, "multiverse": false, "pattern_corr": true, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse; pattern_corr=0.164; dice=0.000; region_replication_fraction=0.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "aec58d66e8f71e11436d932b406a40cd0b8fb961b778222d053a7a5cfccf2aed", "task_id": "ncb21-task-8584aa7cd91b1892"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-f5dbfb11e9ef72d0", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-9e1b04007b386add", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_adni_fmri_s2_DISC": "37796b2a23f913d4a60787633c363f3e13e0a9fb4b053ce1ab3f516c2941df85", "neg_random_label_adni_fmri_s2_REP": "a306a9e4f2f69fd6c9d1007eb961064d96f91e3c93b21a67cc9f619e4cce95f1"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_adni_fmri_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_adni_fmri_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "533be3b5aae5be7d19338beb6b1ea403cd411a17d615cb6859215c335fbc8873", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "e9c3b8c5ee96de641b44535d63ec61b0c3c138979f8f6b15860a5cf23f5c91dc", "task_id": "ncb21-task-865bd36606531a72"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-05c17620b6ff0817", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-2a86f3769ff9fdb4", "cohort_content_hashes": {"HCP_Aging_DISC": "47082908a7b0b17d0b8a006028dff9d08a56af3f8c6e8d08627ca3818f85a4fd", "HCP_Aging_REP": "e4682154e236a020f91b7932fe75341cf7a0eed865089e5172cad83a6989e965"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_Aging_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_Aging_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "e05f15a28935ff463c70e24bef40f0837f294350366594fb14014998643ea742", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "51fc5c06217602a033c0690bbbdefbad7318fd48199cd9db0ef1820d5422c7d4", "task_id": "ncb21-task-873fe1c30cfa20cf"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-b274fb2db756fa8f", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-24c69df4cb6f5c60", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_DISC": "7f42f7518c34775c8e5cf7c590a1fe44f226f40a7b899e71223b56ef43411663", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "6ffc105438fc3963477696ce10153a976345d61cc161125546e2be33113c0368", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "d278b9070064e9eedd232f7ca74a8fed90edc4e6e6e49df7340c1e11ab09a6bc", "task_id": "ncb21-task-875cfcac9041998a"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-0d57166941ee6987", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-c9aa23ba27a81faa", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADHD200_DISC": "2ed4e2ddb4d8a3845dbec23c0b31652d26fdefe209e61fc4cdd3b636ebabb4fd", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "ea313bbd51f7760c132d5f5b9e0c961a65c2a73c63a78165af9368a6774e479b", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiverse"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "5a28bd491ea8ab9c0ad1a6449efb4f145376876afe29e84259f9c5b532697275", "task_id": "ncb21-task-8783c84319c13ec7"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-91ca48ca8f7976aa", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-fc81222d80755c7b", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_abcd_s3_DISC": "a1bf38f81c19484720e41c26d5ca1d7ba5dc49c917b1186e3c54af2bdb6d73a0", "neg_random_label_abcd_s3_REP": "8ce909cb8d8961bf5b39e69cffb542d3574b1e169fd6c388d6e85895f0c40aff"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_abcd_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_abcd_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "7e3b4babfc0b0f32f881748e4503681487af57f564270418f63f42748dc69b27", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "77e8a68a29e2d4bf78bf205d673f677071d2a60e9f5a4960fdf68f3e71ca4f91", "task_id": "ncb21-task-87c689dc841ef716"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-138026bd7cce20e7", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-98e0261bdd947fbc", "cohort_content_hashes": {"HCP_Aging_DISC": "47082908a7b0b17d0b8a006028dff9d08a56af3f8c6e8d08627ca3818f85a4fd", "HCP_Aging_REP": "e4682154e236a020f91b7932fe75341cf7a0eed865089e5172cad83a6989e965"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_Aging_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_Aging_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "9aee6613c8d2c3f9741186e1ace9b38e12791145f3bb00c9b40d7de4f8237d04", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "magnitude_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "magnitude_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 44.292965292625865, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 44.292965292625865, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=magnitude_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=44.3"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "0afe7f7162a59b202b91b61706ba1a110db317bc195d4d478d94ccf6eb2f23b2", "task_id": "ncb21-task-899f07fc4e50962f"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-72743e2acf45d7e5", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-6aaef132eb95471b", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_hcp_aging_s2_DISC": "8d7587a759c352460f01b1326da1065bf52f66b8a4d25bd675fcc81e8d8ad75a", "neg_site_confound_hcp_aging_s2_REP": "1ac7b705c14197dac881ac6c08479d9026a1ae86425b223cf8565e0d6ef02dc0"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_hcp_aging_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_hcp_aging_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "77d408bdef7c0453c9ff8e6eb69ef489e3b2e80ced5a284e57ccd73903f75a61", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 158, "p": 7.532542186112728e-14, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 158, "p": 7.532542186112728e-14, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "ba1dc1de689032a2c4e920e2fc82522c6dd8dc190815c1ca22bbbd576588d3f1", "task_id": "ncb21-task-89d5b11b51787de2"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-adc64a42191e17f6", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-c28cec32d4e18002", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "6d7345912be43bb4bf0574965d74ebd169b06f46042ba1ace6b0f05f00f1e65c", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "9b925d3e7314c0385a292bc8ee45ebb669f7ab156164f5c320e2484fc0604479", "task_id": "ncb21-task-8c1c0d2918c17a43"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-717b76df43cc7ce7", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-a14e0d9f48891e6f", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "232132a84602d2e002eff364fa44085a7d831aca45cc3db13afd94a377e6b66e", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "e722d3550084f1d8aed04e44b0e6662f7a7d342b8abd67c8fc52eec91e78415f"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "3261371cb9a7645afb656c640ccbae6a845307a907c7cc4e60b179faa91c5107", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.512 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "f970271c03f6e27aef5a50e777441103dd3402215846626ba0dcdd00e91cc9d1", "task_id": "ncb21-task-8c9b8c06fc709efb"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-2a5d5bc83ab86134", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-6dcc1e79a3b841ed", "cohort_content_hashes": {"HCP_Aging_DISC": "47082908a7b0b17d0b8a006028dff9d08a56af3f8c6e8d08627ca3818f85a4fd", "HCP_Aging_REP": "e4682154e236a020f91b7932fe75341cf7a0eed865089e5172cad83a6989e965"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_Aging_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_Aging_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "6b663dad0568b1c9fe8d10033695532d99c60dba6fa7099208c49945ee91c406", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "phen_fluid_composite", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "c277004872bb169a3dd057337745f0af2e41b928e1036a82f5810f081af7fa96", "task_id": "ncb21-task-8d9cde7a88a32741"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-e2c8b315d5871123", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-b5999aa1ae2c3ff8", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_DISC": "7f42f7518c34775c8e5cf7c590a1fe44f226f40a7b899e71223b56ef43411663", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "3960f233b6d26891851bfc0474003c8f6888bf35c3c3847d1898265d62fc15c6", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 36, "n": 541, "p": 0.8025643529885985, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "02197a24b217d48564aabfb691e207b8c3cb564adbe7673466813192e2f97a95", "task_id": "ncb21-task-8efc33f2fd8e4854"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-9306eed5ac12c7af", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-16b15ea251a14a6a", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "1dc19347dd5473507d04677204b4e0bdbd7e60d23bb833d6a15531dfa22cdbe5", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "13d3a2e8b23052bf7e5890d9fed49d402f9955d882c9903a67feb2623371698a", "task_id": "ncb21-task-8f1d97de95a41566"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-e61ccc72bef4061c", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-e321d64e943cd300", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADHD200_DISC": "2ed4e2ddb4d8a3845dbec23c0b31652d26fdefe209e61fc4cdd3b636ebabb4fd", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "8a602bd864438f6bb88dfd7f38f91d670fe54b8f9b348c0abf206f93c01d1536", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "7d1acdf0369621fad734bca73b3bb46b834c871ea508c97f9a490704251bbbd5", "task_id": "ncb21-task-8f7b785586ca8640"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-35ab0b847aafb7de", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-36342b22349b96fd", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_fbirn_s1_DISC": "25128daf537faade3e086fcd7056d5714fa8af14f434f1641c4d75c98d4d5608", "neg_site_confound_fbirn_s1_REP": "50f8a347aba1ae409176aad41052be15c520ccaf85da43fc3e0b2ec9c2b26edd"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_fbirn_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_fbirn_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "63490448de7deab158fa63893bb93aa659b14f1a0ea4e53cceb7fc90bc565e95", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 71, "p": 3.351925452602801e-07, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 71, "p": 3.351925452602801e-07, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": false, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness, power; confound_incomplete; power=0.703 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "0e11bf1b531584d9feaf913b20dec9ebd73127f7cdcc95ff38af22f6b2b95299", "task_id": "ncb21-task-8f94223d440f690d"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-31e032722d8da786", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-92bb952a8f9ba1a7", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_abide1_s2_DISC": "1cd5a2fe72eaba2da5aab0da9982645e6836118a8f6c84b6859fce3154451f89", "neg_site_confound_abide1_s2_REP": "e329e4fb4ca8fa40939049a2b91d2657f9668d76c121e57f8512ef806577dc73"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_abide1_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_abide1_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "5add14c64c7ee6b17871270b310d41b7a7a966d304ba4da9868e608e43c5d1f9", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 200, "p": 2.1519736712498897e-17, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 200, "p": 2.1519736712498897e-17, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "f2b8218f62bce869401c14b004b2bf4010951f7c7b3a3f1e8f942321af70ad6f", "task_id": "ncb21-task-8fb7c5b3a5121fb1"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-b0ad25a9bd80f5a9", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-a78baf8d58b13f1c", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_oasis3_fmri_s2_DISC": "2494277932cf3c53896a95b9b2cc9241e831d62401f12d67a95fe542e414a42b", "neg_p_fishing_oasis3_fmri_s2_REP": "1a68d7c8b90733bc1f6df93201f370178c88cac33d5f36648b92318b143ca6a5"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_oasis3_fmri_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_oasis3_fmri_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "ca1155a299392d79d97d9b2ac13ca87b42ad3d4fd12853c116377ea58a5c384a", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 24, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "b3c9744195c1e6da3655d95e95d4bc6a5f5c58de4c3b7de8f458ea7ddfc457e7", "task_id": "ncb21-task-8fbf774b59af30ed"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-672ab5d3a6c11820", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-7a64caf7224d5f51", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "5ef5d50173ce45dbebcf763e031f8b4ab69c78de01cbba29f9a4af3d8c42a46c", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "078d824e9f776d37351b415d1771f3b438fbcf6a6fb0ff03c952650a0473a9d8", "task_id": "ncb21-task-9026d43b8d831fe5"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-1d82194a9c52b4fa", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-6c2147094efe17cc", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ChineseSZ_DISC": "25886d87d5dc1da53df39d984bfa54f68aa99adbbbcb75b7d4826c4d8bdaff73", "ChineseSZ_REP": "9c94c02e8066411af69f22387e526434c8c412c6df30ff250b1c7bc75f5514a8"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "6b78eaee315e3ab29a804afc5920d639a34a5d0e7bfea2e09555f5856515c7ae", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 352, "p": 0.309214890459771, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "heterogeneity_i2": 34.64067650501072, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 34.64067650501072, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=34.6"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "9bf744a7ed306eb40a7371a385acd11f2f9a693922c215b5b7672b3d595562f5", "task_id": "ncb21-task-9051660984b1ecd9"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-e5b2412738b16335", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-2234f7dbb511d7f2", "cohort_content_hashes": {"BSNIP2_REP": "5a68458b6ca1d3ceb62243f2dcf1fda0209a9d2685669530b7e4c5f279a32f23", "COBRE_REP": "4a81a6fb00f3834982866da08d40f58816c7907a2c62838ae1fad68fd5bb18dc", "ChineseSZ_REP": "9c94c02e8066411af69f22387e526434c8c412c6df30ff250b1c7bc75f5514a8", "FBIRN_REP": "132788e0b0576e4f01ac0ac8dcbb232f2f105aea4693833ef74a59a45118b33a", "JH_REP": "f40fac0acd9aa1425552a409658e883651432d578db1db8a9c290e2ea4850ae6", "Olin_SZ_REP": "d7bef7b3dc92844bbfc9976c601ed84734ccd0a9b19af3571dddda43dc156167"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/Olin_SZ_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/JH_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "f8d6d43a96cfac0f093bbedc7bd770eec5e633e415647f8a3f401f9922cd314f", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 167, "p": 1.3307315635187429e-05, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 167, "p": 1.3307315635187429e-05, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness, multiplicity, multiverse, replication; confound_incomplete; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "cf40f78f619b4e4eb3f41e9d9a78fd0b820ef9b342d3f290f33712d67ca2d803", "task_id": "ncb21-task-90944d2b4886bb16"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-67de4555230bc27a", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-6c5d00f71fd93eb5", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "0e1fd402388609fc5b3bc8c438e0d0d5a0a3fb8fd7cb5a2765bebaf16ed4907d", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "59e0a615e27992398461ff7a0d2a1c1944788dd3b051458f2c5aee1577a9284f", "task_id": "ncb21-task-91d790dba534ab02"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-572d89238c32c460", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-8201ba32fbe40cc6", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_DISC": "7f42f7518c34775c8e5cf7c590a1fe44f226f40a7b899e71223b56ef43411663", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "72614d3224a4c125c44c4f0c5c4ac62469a823663acd73e347d9fa987260cfdf", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "direction_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "direction_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 85.54354174772294, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 85.54354174772294, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=direction_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=85.5"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "0fc0b4954acf5669109bd98c802f3c7d901ca4794008ad43c878378b04d86a45", "task_id": "ncb21-task-92fa7f071e5967dd"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-b0c5075602b380ed", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-f8299c28b62587a8", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_cobre_s1_DISC": "6c6db8db86abd3d77469f5b3d4e01df37155ae016d238ef62d4012e7c6b06661", "neg_random_label_cobre_s1_REP": "40e0fff6a9067e447534986f76e4a3fb3de8d9e348fef24591e9c6cb8662d635"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_cobre_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_cobre_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "a9d6ce0f3e369da9af79ba46c63fe21da41942401fb9d9cbd9dcac5dcd1d160e", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.457 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "a6eb1bec0e7ba7a2840846dd3d5c7a30385b24a857d5db61ea46cce1719976b4", "task_id": "ncb21-task-930d281b9beebc38"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-5a12e0c7d2a28bde", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-b104edaa37f414b0", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE1_DISC": "5a174cbcac2a070ea3f3af8be549a18c404215aaa031137242335f4c83643da4", "ABIDE1_REP": "d0a670f11f1c39a32e1e182cd1457b51acbec5518845795c26872642565c9f35"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE1_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "614c21c2ab152f4cb6485114d8e4b460214e9bb4bcebefa82f0a4ae1b17eea6e", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 4, "multiverse": false, "pattern_corr": false, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication, pattern_corr, region_replication_fraction; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; pattern_corr=-0.904; dice=1.000; region_replication_fraction=0.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "35d42b221ddde173268680015955520d48cb06927d024e0b900ca014352216fa", "task_id": "ncb21-task-93d0f00b65344ed7"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-1d647c3ac871d92d", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-ccb02ebdf0b9de13", "cohort_content_hashes": {"COBRE_REP": "4a81a6fb00f3834982866da08d40f58816c7907a2c62838ae1fad68fd5bb18dc", "FBIRN_REP": "132788e0b0576e4f01ac0ac8dcbb232f2f105aea4693833ef74a59a45118b33a", "JH_DISC": "89ef38c838bb4c3dc85a3a7f214f6a8296e2aab6823ed97b158749b411f37bec"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/JH_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "ec9639b97ed6de549f7a12df403705ddea870eb773b2f570f90fe0f4f1ebf5f6", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 4, "multiverse": false, "pattern_corr": false, "power": false, "region_replication_fraction": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication, pattern_corr, region_replication_fraction; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.755 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1; pattern_corr=-0.105; dice=0.500; region_replication_fraction=0.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "9340c44d9e327be05f6e631e09925c45992918d713c0f15a6e75ae686dc17468", "task_id": "ncb21-task-96088c72fd109620"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-4bec8588ceb4224d", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-1a7807874ff5d1e1", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "02d1ab85ed85df92da9b28769308a307ee350fe178c6c65d30416d605fad05b2", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "d851f228d498e4805ee98b334b7f780f72e97c81673367d9fbee2574680bf504", "task_id": "ncb21-task-966fa3f0d3b58999"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-149b1f2aeda4fcb1", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-c65331c1822c6de9", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "6ae4a7071e30e787056f8a7db51bb83412216cbd12486fce3bd35e403831c410", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "31d63b3cc24346be0cfc732dbd26302a109be033397bc0ea36ae4c3df58bef4f", "task_id": "ncb21-task-96d84cbe7248ad9a"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-963d6d126e015ed1", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-1988c7e9546365a0", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "232132a84602d2e002eff364fa44085a7d831aca45cc3db13afd94a377e6b66e", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "e722d3550084f1d8aed04e44b0e6662f7a7d342b8abd67c8fc52eec91e78415f"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "9da24db5bf164056cbbd41d4ba7d607582453a70eb6c49a7aa2d4f7badefcd45", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.530 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "34c355cf7119a0c3b271765499bbf77fb5aabd391536082559b9511a1ab54528", "task_id": "ncb21-task-96fb9b5030208ca8"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-bc7a72687a803144", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-32e530e2faadeb12", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_oasis3_s3_DISC": "cead2cecab4ab67c961709ae84795de94faf6931d7c85cf5b465282a4678b271", "neg_random_label_oasis3_s3_REP": "45991be2eaa9db95d33ef95e5b42d8fe051c4168fd141a120f9dd47576a4c5c1"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_oasis3_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_oasis3_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "e920378cc225c1130062236aa8624685f77f3d7e62f1be1c1281e4c6e1128bd8", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "fs_version", "levels": 4, "n": 329, "p": 0.6788524043333387, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "6e0b995424051a430e4860cf19e96e9a2afe56bc2af441abb86f7e1e64d371eb", "task_id": "ncb21-task-979519f8c8ae0ade"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-b2bc1b3dc8d74234", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-cef97c25fef66c3a", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE1_DISC": "5a174cbcac2a070ea3f3af8be549a18c404215aaa031137242335f4c83643da4", "ABIDE1_REP": "d0a670f11f1c39a32e1e182cd1457b51acbec5518845795c26872642565c9f35"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE1_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "0c22d1dad4929cc12c3131057bbab29f917e6ac846c95a302a425d53cd109f17", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "e206b1b334ce724c73f8e730a9ab3551cab9cb15ce285350f277224aad5c014b", "task_id": "ncb21-task-9844744e93e5574c"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-9c7a47dbebfe1759", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-34820492461087e7", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "232132a84602d2e002eff364fa44085a7d831aca45cc3db13afd94a377e6b66e", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "e722d3550084f1d8aed04e44b0e6662f7a7d342b8abd67c8fc52eec91e78415f"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "5ec01e378538c8e9583c65e0c0ba028b95d1bbf606eb32961e927e5320578477", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.530 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "30ce2ca19b5647967505b72ae2b58daac25e6520f3d05072718b65290f50831d", "task_id": "ncb21-task-991c1aea260f8443"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-34b0d6368d06370a", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-9d883f7b9204a01b", "cohort_content_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "a3e6f1609ea823c9216310eaea1cf3e54443ed385d8f2c4ccb0374907756646b", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "4cc03f072ec07c42f4ceaa18a43bd2065e0d5c508c7d70b6115b8ccc60ee1062"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "1e77cf19250f8b635f1f179a04d72e827ade0ef5c8b5bd9fa6a6c698cd6dd8bf", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 1964, "p": 4.750055361533447e-83, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 1964, "p": 4.750055361533447e-83, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "15840e110e9bb86e46b763ee71dc575684a485098f74b5869785066a73c92a9d", "task_id": "ncb21-task-996e632551685164"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-b5c857772b8292df", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-a4c3c06bb408028d", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_DISC": "7f42f7518c34775c8e5cf7c590a1fe44f226f40a7b899e71223b56ef43411663", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "321efe74503931b183b30b6e6734a8a6e7c1ac6dc81fa0f7a3497a709fb8e5db", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 36, "n": 541, "p": 0.8025643529885985, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 6, "multiverse": true, "pattern_corr": true, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All brain-wide gates passed.; pattern_corr=0.978; dice=1.000; region_replication_fraction=1.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "430c9ff03e765225dc2c452cfed3c7fcfdc59a8189ee71af9614a15c227cc3c8", "task_id": "ncb21-task-9b0ef08d451df5cf"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-e781a1d10147abaa", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-c335eac2b2840ad3", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_ukb_s3_DISC": "10a9c9faf1fb6b2b3985237438d5a3f0c272a717edd1a5b3e83aa9adcdd72ff9", "neg_p_fishing_ukb_s3_REP": "b4020aa0cc3915f437420a9937ed33f6060001d8a1edc95b5fcfc54aa9342966"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_ukb_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_ukb_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "fb7d8cdd94152c03ce8e0ed7a4910e242394aa55d56a9dcbf5493ca5bf39888b", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 24, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "19bec1012b08a1bee224f49498f821b97243b58a73a109ff1a947f7a69a4804b", "task_id": "ncb21-task-9b4065e12594078d"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-456c48345929eb71", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-2baf041afbc62573", "cohort_content_hashes": {"HCP_DISC": "4bfd66afa7e3af1ad63ed1a3d1fdc1662e370064e97e927de95b8f783b7886a8", "HCP_REP": "0cc8dc280e6a961585c8c2c53414db8d8cb581c59cf2beaef3e3731c5eca9eba"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "fb37665a5f4a15f72c510c88393b53eb1578bd5ebdcf79734c41f7cf2c2c1047", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 22.380618430154463, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 22.380618430154463, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=22.4"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "67ac81840c1a47e8dafb346c8a26f980bd48aa44b1fe165cd7ee825e8d23226f", "task_id": "ncb21-task-9b8b8215a1ce887d"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-6f07b924f78e762d", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-2b77f64317510709", "cohort_content_hashes": {"UKB_DISC": "8f50d0d10f4265b3538407235a0af91a7bb4d1a733daea42a655d4931e0bfdd3", "UKB_REP": "6da6a67cb610290a28f97b077dd2aa0e82c39161e4b3c622857cb54843df2357"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/UKB_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/UKB_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "6b9defedc3af2276d9e06c15824658dbf77dfdd480f26393e085b14f19833fed", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "91cbdd3dc5bfc59a87e5203580c341314ed3db8ef6163ce003e6e99d44e495bb", "task_id": "ncb21-task-9b937c1f9c6db20c"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-e313edffc6da7a07", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-7d133b297a20529b", "cohort_content_hashes": {"BSNIP2_DISC": "f60b826114673b4f649dd9e41e9f01b5d76fe3fdff3fb17ac3d13f3472068df0", "BSNIP2_REP": "5a68458b6ca1d3ceb62243f2dcf1fda0209a9d2685669530b7e4c5f279a32f23"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "66dca04e011d8a4ecd8f795a9d391a1b0b2f5b1dade8d3c4f11779bdd0ac0eb0", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 278, "p": 0.3656917740160851, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "2446ae7c7d0978b3d6cf9c006a3579aed768122f1d4352a73c5fcefe149cdec8", "task_id": "ncb21-task-9bf0eb30f9254c4a"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-9b768a7494df75b2", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-c662c321679640cc", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "e36e50c1dfdb96d8b06ffe30b89f6b59e2df398250ced3f9342c9f87222d5d08", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "cb3b2d56288895ba953ede1c388b664207d92c21e49d88094382e860d599f04e", "task_id": "ncb21-task-9c7e5e6bd554af68"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-015db0b6e9d5687e", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-01e53d0ed61b0197", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_underpowered_hcp_s3_DISC": "e04f2afef4a828855c249f85aa7eba7fde92e57bdd595d0952a2554c49ca0edc", "neg_underpowered_hcp_s3_REP": "2f0d853d4bda0722c0dfe7535aee2bfb695c4dd44ee46e1d3587e951a1bdc81b"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_hcp_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_hcp_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "b9870f819db4ead7df7d4d7dcd6f388dc0de4aedb3a352238a0c7f86a8a32d68", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.548 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "e00cd0f3d641889f34a0fd66731de3a4d0a71988007d1f0c3dbea0c2657a40af", "task_id": "ncb21-task-9ce60cabf58259fd"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-5e9d9106292eb159", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-8a9b597ce3bf8308", "cohort_content_hashes": {"BSNIP2_REP": "5a68458b6ca1d3ceb62243f2dcf1fda0209a9d2685669530b7e4c5f279a32f23", "Olin_SZ_REP": "d7bef7b3dc92844bbfc9976c601ed84734ccd0a9b19af3571dddda43dc156167"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/Olin_SZ_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "bb082af066a1adfd8b3ac538a2279d56d3b2004f8de8b6fe92df6f0120df18e5", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "70c62f2bb9348a2ed3ee6b4a04064dd111c552799a59c8ee27fc6b8f5dc3b95f", "task_id": "ncb21-task-9de8790b14dd8e89"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-d37402dd791a12dc", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-cd5e17a4689770d8", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "f7a4868547e073af190870071ea02ff2526da283d1c212d1216f963fd65197dc", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "192c399122e0f8a1797091e0e60321c06dfcce033b165c098e8e57fdd2fd6eb0", "task_id": "ncb21-task-9e1aef9a7ecc24a2"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-de1363fa0a54a318", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-e223e76690b01df1", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "7a8ff7ea65ba4da6f2196b00fe778e916726baf274aa2baecb99969187a04382", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "c831ec3c20402496ca1ac905fed7edd479c27a39985a134b90fc98c16c9a40be", "task_id": "ncb21-task-9e56ed379ff23dcc"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-23a83dcb8dd0287e", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-c8b22138c8e5585b", "cohort_content_hashes": {"BSNIP2_REP": "5a68458b6ca1d3ceb62243f2dcf1fda0209a9d2685669530b7e4c5f279a32f23", "COBRE_REP": "4a81a6fb00f3834982866da08d40f58816c7907a2c62838ae1fad68fd5bb18dc", "ChineseSZ_REP": "9c94c02e8066411af69f22387e526434c8c412c6df30ff250b1c7bc75f5514a8", "FBIRN_REP": "132788e0b0576e4f01ac0ac8dcbb232f2f105aea4693833ef74a59a45118b33a", "Olin_SZ_REP": "d7bef7b3dc92844bbfc9976c601ed84734ccd0a9b19af3571dddda43dc156167"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/Olin_SZ_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "92b416d3de6da73125388eda76a8545b6ed6c0e024593e8156d9444a7b27f503", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.605 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "37ecdf63159f52b5b092cb92b5d076a4831db35a57e05310ab6fa606f8a370d1", "task_id": "ncb21-task-9e6e0c742f90a6aa"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-a8646216db807141", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-f65ea43a145bb78e", "cohort_content_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "a3e6f1609ea823c9216310eaea1cf3e54443ed385d8f2c4ccb0374907756646b", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "4cc03f072ec07c42f4ceaa18a43bd2065e0d5c508c7d70b6115b8ccc60ee1062"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "f54ae4fecc36f6f4228a7e2ee676228e631314ea6e70f85c03601a05240014f6", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 1964, "p": 4.750055361533447e-83, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 1964, "p": 4.750055361533447e-83, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness, multiplicity, multiverse, replication; confound_incomplete; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "e4022e776047058b37a06f5134dc1b1339524829fe36a700dc0eddbd84760bd8", "task_id": "ncb21-task-9f2d3e04810b8017"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-107375390c1725d9", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-de8c7769259c56ca", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "6d752cc14c16e81396db0bb381ed6974aa6987bfc314000ae755670150046b2b", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 84, "multiverse": false, "pattern_corr": false, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication, pattern_corr, region_replication_fraction; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; pattern_corr=-0.461; dice=1.000; region_replication_fraction=0.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "bb22b313200a7b860744a7956921caa560276b4054b984439239e744badcc48f", "task_id": "ncb21-task-9f9f288578b02153"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-611a2fe389785bcf", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-8299137d3890448f", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_cobre_s3_DISC": "5d38fb8b076e81e9583cfeeab2b204c91ae57c028ebd3c37845394ce477fb167", "neg_p_fishing_cobre_s3_REP": "133a235bd5e5b93c2ddc56249ab73bd7733b85d7b95e740c68f1783c39aa7fe9"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_cobre_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_cobre_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "e6472c59fcc967f2db8cae4e79955fc8631eced699f78234d41a38d7c5807fee", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 4, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.457 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "ff06cdc3522f986c6eff7367018b629f518471fb5d45943793f17269c41a63b7", "task_id": "ncb21-task-a044560ca4a0ae22"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-ee627d7a5d823df0", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-33a00e68c2927737", "cohort_content_hashes": {"HCP_Aging_DISC": "47082908a7b0b17d0b8a006028dff9d08a56af3f8c6e8d08627ca3818f85a4fd", "HCP_Aging_REP": "e4682154e236a020f91b7932fe75341cf7a0eed865089e5172cad83a6989e965"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_Aging_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_Aging_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "8c2edc311ae424ce4bb62c26a90dc71ac728cdcd4a8739abee3296cf38bbdf48", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "f919d1177af1734dd02dab6e91d78f738902a14263c4e4bd776b858487bc87ad", "task_id": "ncb21-task-a054e2f3a1e18f45"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-872c426870a43fc0", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-354b1c1b69293f0b", "cohort_content_hashes": {"BSNIP2_DISC": "f60b826114673b4f649dd9e41e9f01b5d76fe3fdff3fb17ac3d13f3472068df0", "BSNIP2_REP": "5a68458b6ca1d3ceb62243f2dcf1fda0209a9d2685669530b7e4c5f279a32f23", "ChineseSZ_REP": "9c94c02e8066411af69f22387e526434c8c412c6df30ff250b1c7bc75f5514a8", "Olin_SZ_REP": "d7bef7b3dc92844bbfc9976c601ed84734ccd0a9b19af3571dddda43dc156167"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/Olin_SZ_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "bc86b8fa8c9604422b2eb4615aef005d1be41e008b75fe8bbb342ec7e0114b74", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "907ddf7d5098d136bb8f5362394cdbadd9019e41f00793454b66b04c1c3b2ce9", "task_id": "ncb21-task-a05795cc3d5cda20"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-5e6aa7181e35b605", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-3bed20a5a12dcc68", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "a6f2643176ec426c9444b542d41578a42092ffdf39e4a8c0a2d1c8a98a03ff4f", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "6f72003a333c56c9bbe27bc421e16611919664eb3dd402725583dfc9c2dc3b31", "task_id": "ncb21-task-a18bfcd804ec2d1e"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-65ed609046c27500", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-374577051c4f64d8", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_cobre_s2_DISC": "bcd4384912a1ef042bfff75fb75cfb95f66f201d837fcb28c601627031f4e956", "neg_site_confound_cobre_s2_REP": "8d43c4a3926488accb7a1012207c6d83bb410219e03c6308f0bb65f0a1e59e96"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_cobre_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_cobre_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "672264b1620658166f05da517c02abd27e557e6752937b2d280ffbada457dd0c", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 40, "p": 0.00014780231033445423, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 40, "p": 0.00014780231033445423, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": false, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness, power; confound_incomplete; power=0.457 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "c5bef0fade6a47cb5f2bee69b16baf5e27dc8f4bfdfbbed90908258bfe830b47", "task_id": "ncb21-task-a1a2fcf5dd82c92b"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-7c66a10417fcec23", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-b379ea143351b5d0", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_DISC": "7f42f7518c34775c8e5cf7c590a1fe44f226f40a7b899e71223b56ef43411663", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "c6b164c61b275dd3a12aea44b8832e6055486a79e04a20a74c8518b40466b7ce", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 36, "n": 541, "p": 0.8025643529885985, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 6, "multiverse": true, "pattern_corr": true, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All brain-wide gates passed.; pattern_corr=0.978; dice=1.000; region_replication_fraction=1.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "18222a8d9b4a4d2ace6ccf0111d74e17884503bfb104f4c131cb0c2738ae9bda", "task_id": "ncb21-task-a1a56104fcdaf492"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-569510b14fd88380", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-11d91d222c383cbd", "cohort_content_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "a3e6f1609ea823c9216310eaea1cf3e54443ed385d8f2c4ccb0374907756646b", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "4cc03f072ec07c42f4ceaa18a43bd2065e0d5c508c7d70b6115b8ccc60ee1062"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-a236c325dde04b84/NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-a236c325dde04b84/NACC_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "c39e42c7c757fdc905104276b2f6fd2b5f675623e06f95ab667d6e2b6dddd105", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 3101, "p": 0.9275762707871068, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "ncb_random_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_cohort_mismatch"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "68d31be6c08076f09eaa63183395490e8fc60054a15fc3e90f75a4079f0293c1", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "135f0737f1159260bbe735a9f00a3661e3efd18cffce670287a32b4fc76114d4"}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "185d90203b3ec5639651595f988aca8e0859f6ba4b814da7be48d637bfdac0ac", "task_id": "ncb21-task-a236c325dde04b84"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-2290e2c4612f7606", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-4b52a48bc92d1907", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_DISC": "7f42f7518c34775c8e5cf7c590a1fe44f226f40a7b899e71223b56ef43411663", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "2ce1bfc43d3ddae679b8ef00548e158aa99cfbeff985ad67028ec8c6670f7653", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "2c87f859723e45f8344c8a68d82d6da51a2977de436ab0cd9a3247cd94c59064", "task_id": "ncb21-task-a28ed8ee092fce61"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-2aadc4e4de851c0e", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-a8826ac14fac39c3", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE1_HOLDOUT": "465b83b9275d056ca897367bc2b30907c1b32663d2fd4cdda4f87111fedb541c", "ABIDE1_REP": "d0a670f11f1c39a32e1e182cd1457b51acbec5518845795c26872642565c9f35"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ABIDE1_HOLDOUT.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ABIDE1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "bb47c6a5fcd74ee1fd0c82407862903e7642acbc577a7c61b778a4f86d7ef3ef", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "850d82bfafa07a7641d93c240f0b63d3ccf61fac78b871dadc874f82d66e07d9", "task_id": "ncb21-task-a2c95f837064e61f"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-d6cbeb536d2b0163", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-07505fdb23de5755", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "0ba55246e218b6e45f17c57d51240000b3dcbde3e617be302035986054fe4ace", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "phen_fluid_composite", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "2860adc30f78a1656622c8fbc951139e6ca500359eb3ae4aba157200303229ce", "task_id": "ncb21-task-a2cefcd7709126f7"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-c64dac21d8591104", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-385bb9463aa48d73", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "1382b4b2e41f3de8888f00c41bd9f2d6b30ca1c2c65e622881f6fad02a873b82", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "c5ef500f523421eaf91f514bb0ca8dc249dc458f7cf9b2969d7a246af1925551", "task_id": "ncb21-task-a32df69d3ffcf15e"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-cc1c11b70cdbc35f", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-6cabc8c3cbc95cd7", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_DISC": "7f42f7518c34775c8e5cf7c590a1fe44f226f40a7b899e71223b56ef43411663", "ADNI_REP": "56cd379d34a3e7f93f341c1014daa9b3a9146606a68d4720d4513d09e35d73b6"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "1c6eaba9b38c14e2a6fa24cdd79bb413408778c5a74409876c253e489346891f", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "eb10a659959b3fcec7ec1d5b881a5d196de1b2212c10339323bc63145d625bb5", "task_id": "ncb21-task-a389468db376c4f4"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-ff4d46696cfed68a", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-8241fcf5597e55cd", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE1_DISC": "5a174cbcac2a070ea3f3af8be549a18c404215aaa031137242335f4c83643da4", "ABIDE1_HOLDOUT": "465b83b9275d056ca897367bc2b30907c1b32663d2fd4cdda4f87111fedb541c", "ABIDE1_REP": "d0a670f11f1c39a32e1e182cd1457b51acbec5518845795c26872642565c9f35"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ABIDE1_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ABIDE1_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ABIDE1_HOLDOUT.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "98da017a756989e4a4e2fab460cfa52095d2ed8689f40786283951c62154fdd5", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "e46e555508aa0d54188df5a930990a6737177c6be4bc8b0d8bcec6fd8b814644", "task_id": "ncb21-task-a5379172f56f4390"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-46c685780a6efe6d", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-fb0f27b0b5f96c97", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "80626f2c240c743047c527d02c61998a57824970cbea4f0badb9fc719f92835b", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "02a873be42091e835e165c71793dde07786d5eeca858f50ecd3ad0b2c4d06b1e", "task_id": "ncb21-task-a56f004a7108ee69"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-feb70aa94fa7c90f", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-457ca5b478f25cec", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ADHD200_DISC": "2ed4e2ddb4d8a3845dbec23c0b31652d26fdefe209e61fc4cdd3b636ebabb4fd"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_DISC.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "d39445b92c5395818ba4dc99bef4cc223dc8d3837123fb4bd70962e3460e315c", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "db60e5799f390cd815dacd318e5bf72dac4117851d4f0630a18a58782d322f5b", "task_id": "ncb21-task-a71d3a3c1b344c50"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-5d0e6a346e90515f", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-81204538324761d2", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_abcd_s1_DISC": "cec29b793ddd963e0f406ec89be07796069a4aa1e509f7e757e2dc9926808553", "neg_p_fishing_abcd_s1_REP": "7f0c0e1c2a32a5a7cfe6f2a73965359440ad16546d1ab805096addfa41cb3811"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_abcd_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_abcd_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "bb9aea9cf60c6b4066aabe20c05627612caa117c5f0d1a6896f4861d0a04b865", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 24, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "32602f1d7ad15d11b16612b0c050b266d5668d77a5a78d686375f47f62b16c81", "task_id": "ncb21-task-a808920481e064bd"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-2b8c1957240b2b85", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-8e67b1aee50974fc", "cohort_content_hashes": {"OASIS3_DISC": "8a048aaff562775d7c80f7027c9d8bb56cc738b7563d25ca06af7cb33df89d31", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "110414b68e57f40b50b64eeb92912d8a0b432ef4bfe9100b73b2b6476a4ec327", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "magnitude_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "magnitude_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "fs_version", "levels": 4, "n": 780, "p": 0.07356894195085882, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "heterogeneity_i2": 69.88050278796491, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 69.88050278796491, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=magnitude_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=69.9"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "0d56ea1c00ab215d6176b630c325ab27125bd42f2428a0635143058d7e39bb38", "task_id": "ncb21-task-a9121137ac022382"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-be65950958048714", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-e71577c39b5dc800", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_adni_s3_DISC": "22c76013fd6eb6763e6b24be832199c8a9b0bccc3c395d29644808905370ce39", "neg_p_fishing_adni_s3_REP": "e2f29d905e4c9e35fb6f26ab6cdae25078848aa16d44792f8989d9f5bd8c500e"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_adni_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_adni_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "8e5dff92e0ceac0952f312d8fea4b95a04acfb8080066a8787ab8ecd0a9d44fb", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 8, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "004998f77533a40633fe428992d76750bea0659ba7dfeec84d348375847b5d09", "task_id": "ncb21-task-a939ff446f75ebc3"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-0cd02a3132b5afda", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-230c57b182c3252f", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_abide2_s3_DISC": "58686e494d12064d4db773ffbf934d5248038966d90c398f0f029f9d161534cf", "neg_p_fishing_abide2_s3_REP": "89795e77f0706757212b7272ba7a386e2a9f432be6b399ea79cb44d7b40eaa56"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_abide2_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_abide2_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "a3b2bc4d06471345e41011b36d8baa32fbeffbe5c4f3e16e7c9edbd7c5f9a99e", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 24, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "90a761eb1c5889ff5574b8f1ef3b61d2cf01744511a1b6b053f27a5cf83fadd3", "task_id": "ncb21-task-a94c28a45671c546"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-32c06a5e43e74faa", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-7f3a47521eee4daa", "cohort_content_hashes": {"BSNIP2_REP": "5a68458b6ca1d3ceb62243f2dcf1fda0209a9d2685669530b7e4c5f279a32f23", "COBRE_REP": "4a81a6fb00f3834982866da08d40f58816c7907a2c62838ae1fad68fd5bb18dc", "ChineseSZ_REP": "9c94c02e8066411af69f22387e526434c8c412c6df30ff250b1c7bc75f5514a8", "FBIRN_REP": "132788e0b0576e4f01ac0ac8dcbb232f2f105aea4693833ef74a59a45118b33a", "Olin_SZ_REP": "d7bef7b3dc92844bbfc9976c601ed84734ccd0a9b19af3571dddda43dc156167"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/Olin_SZ_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "c4c723bf81c55c38a9540e67896157850ec5efd479f04cd3501fda0a9dd28a0e", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.387 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "d35a871869d1b864dfae6faee588073d2b544d8ba8f618c4db0d2651612f6506", "task_id": "ncb21-task-a94f030e722dccd8"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-206dd8d45a4d9d89", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-2abf5fc78774e1f8", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "1dc4ed3314a520a3a83555247b345ef8ec3535e717e2e492128547fb4b788588", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "ee60f766782e52a18fb048d9e7d7c83c341422182745a6b2d56ce1a4edca2e11", "task_id": "ncb21-task-a9bd3530545a0c3f"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-ca59e7bcf2e17f7b", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-13523b717fbbf81b", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_ukb_s1_DISC": "8054d47894d5a1d059e1691247773d32871b73f14f977a822d5b5c8545653155", "neg_random_label_ukb_s1_REP": "c2c41ddf28a303a2916dd6fa1828ac5214247f3d51a53d3bb358d73caec5daf1"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_ukb_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_ukb_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "d7e372d651004a9970fea18294e63d3cf4d69b3fe68e2e6dc7f0c7376d647b8a", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "4c1e9e77b0563ae29f41acc7996fd4afe895fc92d52df79746ec16abc99232bd", "task_id": "ncb21-task-a9c3818944cc823c"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-80318de11aee33ca", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-f5ab0232fa07a79a", "cohort_content_hashes": {"COBRE_DISC": "f53b3405d06487a9d268b89165605cc0ed60d2c3a68e41f8ebe73660d9916d79", "COBRE_REP": "4a81a6fb00f3834982866da08d40f58816c7907a2c62838ae1fad68fd5bb18dc"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "d5ec84199d950c9805d91b17dbcd61bdc4440106d51882d180af7457b1a3b49f", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "under_powered", "rationale": "Failed gates: power, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.790 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "under_powered", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "7684f0a2f71eefd9a41a8fb6980d5e8fd3b36d1a96fc0a65efe1db84f9284a62", "task_id": "ncb21-task-a9c79ca521184619"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-aebaac8d15a9b19e", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-9b7d3389e3c82df9", "cohort_content_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "a3e6f1609ea823c9216310eaea1cf3e54443ed385d8f2c4ccb0374907756646b", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "4cc03f072ec07c42f4ceaa18a43bd2065e0d5c508c7d70b6115b8ccc60ee1062"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-aa17d211e56c69cc/NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-aa17d211e56c69cc/NACC_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "ce6edc32e540f92ab06f49dca8616555b8302144bc3f3668789a232b26272a1e", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 3101, "p": 0.2707791441587122, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "ncb_random_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "09d52c35aab8eebb1568b0ef9cc0d34830c51268b3639c4a46295e7450831b35", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "b041721ae6248c49cc130232fae9721b9a38a0448d2a7a2ea8bacbe7f5adde9c"}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "ec410dd16682c370bf74a392f4304f9210055ea343dc4065586523468d31d8db", "task_id": "ncb21-task-aa17d211e56c69cc"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-32a5293904ed5896", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-589d16fa1523ba19", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_adhd200_s2_DISC": "12b500d2a49884db4397172d39cccd6b3a57c374775ff7dddd0b3eb58c0407e7", "neg_random_label_adhd200_s2_REP": "f0f226e26d63d8813823a98566074791da652ef1e5e8c7d4889b50e4caf33cce"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_adhd200_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_adhd200_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "38a749e992037bc15b6d36e525e78a9647793a3a366e54a3ca6b5c8e32770245", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "7b2b25fdcd61db3f47580fa02f82f683f7ca6366085b11a79404dbb2fbad22e9", "task_id": "ncb21-task-ab4a5bbf4119d2a1"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-579c77d9f61e5f87", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-94d4c3c658b15d43", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADHD200_DISC": "2ed4e2ddb4d8a3845dbec23c0b31652d26fdefe209e61fc4cdd3b636ebabb4fd", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "993fc624771aef102bb7d9fdcd245ee86d3cd9f53ac1e5714d2b3e5c0b760d08", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiverse"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "dbbd0555ab37bb21d1e87c083708181bbdf08e7c8314f7a58dff3bf2b101dcde", "task_id": "ncb21-task-ab593634affa00eb"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-0c84ae301c0de1ab", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-5389c58365529a0d", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADHD200_DISC": "2ed4e2ddb4d8a3845dbec23c0b31652d26fdefe209e61fc4cdd3b636ebabb4fd", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "a1799d8569a0c72033f0afc71cebb2d32e9e659f9ad3ad662e19a8a4fbf98837", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "486bcd06cdc7bc9ff18b3f5e1fedc2e34546b0dde709d6fc91dfce6b86aae17b", "task_id": "ncb21-task-abed0ba3d73e33a5"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-f3636d57e59fc807", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-c15ad9a11a2c651d", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "2ee86bb62dd949665f08a0a4bef4a63eeaf8a4c03511273232ccaeded55cae00", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 190, "multiverse": false, "pattern_corr": false, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication, pattern_corr; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; pattern_corr=-0.870; dice=1.000; region_replication_fraction=0.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "7babc2fcd4781fde02ca9e6f2aac56ed48608bad555014f513a8baa4887078c0", "task_id": "ncb21-task-abfc5beb93a7429a"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-58fd062031fc801e", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-88ef4bafe235fc02", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "ff8cb4c3583e55dcd8a2b9b7a7505720af2c5e53d9248543760646e2b5d2950a", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "b80ff8403032c703dfc612775d7253e5a86314facd972e6f81117c2dfd7ebbe6", "task_id": "ncb21-task-ac0b3670d4eb0173"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-913498386bc29d4b", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-182012ab40d29699", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "232132a84602d2e002eff364fa44085a7d831aca45cc3db13afd94a377e6b66e", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "e722d3550084f1d8aed04e44b0e6662f7a7d342b8abd67c8fc52eec91e78415f"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "e9a5c008dad93f3fa5537af379a594ff8b2065a57e6c37e8c23b5ef83a13fd20", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.530 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "f974b6d57f0aef989e1c5faa5c4aef417b81b6025ab370084b796323140ff80f", "task_id": "ncb21-task-acc2b44ef899edee"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-ce1212b806f25235", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-92b3f17caaf19b8c", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_ukb_s1_DISC": "a483b2891909810f0041c4f81593b65640f5908c90ccff391a6b3099f4e2effd", "neg_site_confound_ukb_s1_REP": "1ab56330f28688cbba456e51b447c407bdae39a0365ff6089febbb17af4da0fd"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_ukb_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_ukb_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "de23c2986eb77c75aef470e443ae3e099b08b8cd0421385895547460303901ed", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 9812, "p": 0.0, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 9812, "p": 0.0, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "0f9de61f560091f1a9b2ee5c35e20ea603bc4d086eb5924a415db7452b3ba474", "task_id": "ncb21-task-accec999181659bf"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-b06c112fe652826c", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-306a800f887838bb", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_abide2_s2_DISC": "f24a70cb9e44a63ad390fd909324d8bb702efdc9ebaef49584b613f149d0822d", "neg_p_fishing_abide2_s2_REP": "29ddb08e094c719f39d95f29ab4009226122437dfb36646b8d68084bd573941d"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_abide2_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_abide2_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "8c0a2947190f2a252efba33c6671fdb8e2d221a59ae1726cb9a6228046b63a88", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 24, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "24ca870074fad386c252cb4985d9f51eb4133412394199ae98372752040e3528", "task_id": "ncb21-task-ada878720b9c7052"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-49789008a2790135", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-3d181c44d8c183a5", "cohort_content_hashes": {"COBRE_DISC": "f53b3405d06487a9d268b89165605cc0ed60d2c3a68e41f8ebe73660d9916d79", "FBIRN_REP": "132788e0b0576e4f01ac0ac8dcbb232f2f105aea4693833ef74a59a45118b33a"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "9aed3e4a373abad04fa886618525dc4591170ff81bcb3d2c29dab683e714d1a4", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "under_powered", "rationale": "Failed gates: power, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.790 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "under_powered", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "8361474519a7f916e20034385c0700c488e2ee9cb26db80434642a38f0ef1e59", "task_id": "ncb21-task-ae4cffe1ef03c0b4"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-060910c2dae3c7c0", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-7bffb5a5060ed9c0", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "ca7e88db27cfb414e0315813820b79e0ecb67ef067ad719820bc9f603809b30f", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 3, "multiverse": false, "pattern_corr": true, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse; pattern_corr=1.000; dice=0.000; region_replication_fraction=0.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "caed5e115e2c177b6c61c4fc0cee17d87cd3b8a2f5e9677a9f017807e5cd710e", "task_id": "ncb21-task-ae6661191cc66113"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-cc6a8be21390c788", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-99867d00a9d4b197", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_cross_nonrep_ukb_hcp_aging_s1_DISC": "776ab3748f2c1afa6865dd9fd782938a459a1efdf81dcd8b321989268374a4ed", "neg_cross_nonrep_ukb_hcp_aging_s1_REP": "7414a1d951d0092d82522ef6313296567b5681d092c9ad40841d41912f523fad"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_cross_nonrep_ukb_hcp_aging_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_cross_nonrep_ukb_hcp_aging_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "672343edd9d8d3942cf7180541e2b0f5f0a859d13063806beb924547f9e4e024", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 24, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_cohort_mismatch"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "3db6fcc954179e03a672ca7b1018572cce992537c4638e3f5458eec35dbc1cd5", "task_id": "ncb21-task-aeabe4bbbc653171"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-a614b9f9882504d0", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-772db6aafb39d1dc", "cohort_content_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "a3e6f1609ea823c9216310eaea1cf3e54443ed385d8f2c4ccb0374907756646b", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "4cc03f072ec07c42f4ceaa18a43bd2065e0d5c508c7d70b6115b8ccc60ee1062"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-af3e384c7e68d116/NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-af3e384c7e68d116/NACC_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "128e42d4954d9a05d028bff20b20093ee2edff953d1f5a23f1420096e19dc07e", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 3101, "p": 0.018801223902479923, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 3101, "p": 0.018801223902479923, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "ncb_random_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness, multiplicity, multiverse, replication; confound_incomplete; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "437a91f025018e88bc7c8ee77f7270a0edad644e69c9c093c6611d0805227889", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "2e71df37ca8fdc5d4b5f4e3fc013df66e76720f66bc95a004dbb76e48ada9357"}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "3dfb6cec890287c22c70dd95d4f18c4e538f92408333bcbfba71874920e6235d", "task_id": "ncb21-task-af3e384c7e68d116"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-3942bdaedf8efb2a", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-09b1423591017b5c", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ChineseSZ_DISC": "25886d87d5dc1da53df39d984bfa54f68aa99adbbbcb75b7d4826c4d8bdaff73", "ChineseSZ_REP": "9c94c02e8066411af69f22387e526434c8c412c6df30ff250b1c7bc75f5514a8"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_DISC.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "748afa061016a86cd6cda6330c714e874f8d7eba5f06d33738b413ef129afec1", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "ecb008be9f99b210507ebc01e15f667ccebde0a37c5fe666a9b471a30e13679b", "task_id": "ncb21-task-afd8d2f90a5decce"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-fc18a39ffb8c66fb", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-4c9e3d042942d150", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "232132a84602d2e002eff364fa44085a7d831aca45cc3db13afd94a377e6b66e", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "e722d3550084f1d8aed04e44b0e6662f7a7d342b8abd67c8fc52eec91e78415f"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "d4e184cf49213c1da0d1c4271d5662bbb5d953ebebd1ee5ed6798da6583cd249", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.530 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "105c57de1f68b53b76c996f824fa0d26a604a2326a4b41ef120469c4edc411d4", "task_id": "ncb21-task-afff5e156656f798"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-ce5c0063d478e61d", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-e815f88901b8741c", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_DISC": "7f42f7518c34775c8e5cf7c590a1fe44f226f40a7b899e71223b56ef43411663", "ADNI_REP": "56cd379d34a3e7f93f341c1014daa9b3a9146606a68d4720d4513d09e35d73b6", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "2b48e8324deab1f7e5d057f9dcc68c0d6867cace08021be1cc4a2fdc45b3333e", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "magnitude_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "magnitude_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 63.32956077317263, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 63.32956077317263, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=magnitude_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=63.3"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "6f95a3150eb4d0a881780811b9492ccde8e88435ef1f5a148b7a2ef23450543c", "task_id": "ncb21-task-b0061b835ca1457f"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-eaaa2769700eae0e", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-517cdffae2d3f74f", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "232132a84602d2e002eff364fa44085a7d831aca45cc3db13afd94a377e6b66e", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "e722d3550084f1d8aed04e44b0e6662f7a7d342b8abd67c8fc52eec91e78415f"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "460e07d0aa9d3c4b2a4acd454cd6d79d93bf38dd01b9751c822e590a39f910e1", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.512 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "80b7a5a5ac746524c5cad93c53c8764f3d7557974359cf078f83013207a4c200", "task_id": "ncb21-task-b0a7823a4e0c542b"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-b8fb8dbb05332d12", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-3598edeef79d44e6", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "232132a84602d2e002eff364fa44085a7d831aca45cc3db13afd94a377e6b66e", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "e722d3550084f1d8aed04e44b0e6662f7a7d342b8abd67c8fc52eec91e78415f"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "a1468fd5a3a2edd7c178d5811639e96c2edfc800411ee392e7fc5ddca0b116d2", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.485 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "efa5dadf94547004a613b2b08379559a2e0b0df53d160ebdce211370c8161837", "task_id": "ncb21-task-b0f7d6a40b5ff683"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-da99887ee1c161f8", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-4c6bb38fc4e83859", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_DISC": "7f42f7518c34775c8e5cf7c590a1fe44f226f40a7b899e71223b56ef43411663", "ADNI_REP": "56cd379d34a3e7f93f341c1014daa9b3a9146606a68d4720d4513d09e35d73b6"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "235030bf0823a3cac4d8a722067d640b2e08a8f40cff4ed890efa46e370bbc57", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 9.227180384761148, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 9.227180384761148, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=9.2"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "10e0e43f6f82e27af1705080b6b4093102c545d2677957fce8ae9ae6b5169f76", "task_id": "ncb21-task-b148816c3f2385a3"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-49fd02560669f081", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-d8a99cb47c33c313", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ChineseSZ_DISC": "25886d87d5dc1da53df39d984bfa54f68aa99adbbbcb75b7d4826c4d8bdaff73", "ChineseSZ_REP": "9c94c02e8066411af69f22387e526434c8c412c6df30ff250b1c7bc75f5514a8"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_DISC.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "016aa6e6dfaf5e222bd1a15091b37f6cd1dbbbf4f33901f35aef6caf7ef956dc", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "bbf3b7207bab258ec329fd80788511f37544901b1971df8cd5fe2a74d098a026", "task_id": "ncb21-task-b1e9180bbfc16c27"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-6bedac272110f713", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-3b74492f05f5a5b4", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "0daa51215ad17c13eb13b9805356cc2c3aa2ea862321480c92bd98a484df7fbc", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "4608810c4216d6a4f26ab930184d1695c6673ab84cfc458cd6358fbb2cd0b356", "task_id": "ncb21-task-b223c5ff80096a89"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-7c8fd02a769bcd9a", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-0636a6932b947555", "cohort_content_hashes": {"BSNIP2_REP": "5a68458b6ca1d3ceb62243f2dcf1fda0209a9d2685669530b7e4c5f279a32f23", "BSNIP_DISC": "e2cdf8ee207ed53b90f28ff8ab7278739cf7239292aa2a594f87d5177859d233", "ChineseSZ_DISC": "25886d87d5dc1da53df39d984bfa54f68aa99adbbbcb75b7d4826c4d8bdaff73", "JH_REP": "f40fac0acd9aa1425552a409658e883651432d578db1db8a9c290e2ea4850ae6"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/JH_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP_DISC.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "a89ef35b63f830b0de70de90aad63f8283f4ef4329066e369e3290951d6eaa2f", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": false, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 4, "multiverse": true, "pattern_corr": false, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication, pattern_corr, region_replication_fraction, dice; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; pattern_corr=0.100; dice=0.133; region_replication_fraction=0.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "c80f9a9161f1cb6182aef12ae0fc48d00e9e480e800b5148deb914d1ee769c14", "task_id": "ncb21-task-b23feae2580b6639"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-8317e3afc8d4d4c2", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-6968cfd4c201dbf0", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_DISC": "7f42f7518c34775c8e5cf7c590a1fe44f226f40a7b899e71223b56ef43411663", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "a044deee280c5f0f8a9e08023e7ce9d6442d4fc7ee749529a2e35500bdbf9178", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 36, "n": 541, "p": 0.8025643529885985, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 3, "multiverse": true, "pattern_corr": true, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All brain-wide gates passed.; pattern_corr=0.846; dice=1.000; region_replication_fraction=1.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "87df22f38cada83b9c901342fb666b25395cfd6259d71a30a3dbe83802df7fe2", "task_id": "ncb21-task-b297e57cca14b456"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-c220a093f814e539", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-683cf3eb3dd92c2d", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_underpowered_adhd200_s1_DISC": "a2fbe71e3412823228cb028ad7112fe23f33edf38b96f239af8616f0c9ab4c1e", "neg_underpowered_adhd200_s1_REP": "cf6bc975c0b18501d1d25eb2fad73e32729d3d294223bb50712e871f56a23ee1"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_adhd200_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_adhd200_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "93aaf7623f0e718c7c3c3c68e8cd46a05908bcd0286b0920afb95af37e54907d", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.476 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "54e72d732db7709acbf292c41477c72e023b386a983a527078b3b0036c5da719", "task_id": "ncb21-task-b3a7d069db546544"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-fc82caeab42cbb0b", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-5f91152c41dbf77c", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "232132a84602d2e002eff364fa44085a7d831aca45cc3db13afd94a377e6b66e", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "e722d3550084f1d8aed04e44b0e6662f7a7d342b8abd67c8fc52eec91e78415f"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "6f0f73193888d6ab79059999aa6163dabbba9585c8bedb118f99a342a34afffe", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.485 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "23d7a312caa641e29b937bc3ef90ef5b606a2b12f499a5fbc16893c438df6a56", "task_id": "ncb21-task-b41d1e817622f9ee"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-a7bd041be62e2db4", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-b981df9ea316aa0d", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "352a211810d25a103067878c16af0514aa715f5b04c246984ed1d6b8a18c1daa", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "42881a8a2a91f27cf60ac488251ab9110fbeb4aa15a6e9e4eb7036fc89fa8276", "task_id": "ncb21-task-b44a4ec14f918682"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-cc868c07af008306", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-ec6354520459cdaa", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_abcd_s2_DISC": "41f33c1581548b8c4b9e7be53699777df3d656a6d30e9420e8e1f2c88a2a1d38", "neg_random_label_abcd_s2_REP": "761faeb285c183f7d1994671b9e8a577ca7f667041dd15c4a9d44fa43bc31d8b"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_abcd_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_abcd_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "7b97330a21fcf8e75bbaced8c68f8b4afa1e3ec4db3e1c38238b57a25713e9f1", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "9c69f1168805237bc6b2fa6d38201d7db24c7c475434c5f7ab3503cc5a76f3a2", "task_id": "ncb21-task-b45b691c16b306b9"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-afbfd52ab898aa8b", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-c037ca90efa3371a", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "77085a3b5b77b820902630e80ff1517660dee0d0c8f227c9efb63c023dc1780f", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "271459c25c35c3b1cee36bb076dd7dddb5532c4120f5973a796d573a28814da7", "task_id": "ncb21-task-b4d563d354061986"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-5bbd3e8e8a1ab72c", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-480365459298fd92", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c", "ADHD200_DISC": "2ed4e2ddb4d8a3845dbec23c0b31652d26fdefe209e61fc4cdd3b636ebabb4fd"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "d9cc625cb1e564fcc106087bdb9ea8112eaa916179349093360fc0228be849b6", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 84, "multiverse": true, "pattern_corr": false, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication, pattern_corr, region_replication_fraction; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; pattern_corr=-0.480; dice=1.000; region_replication_fraction=0.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "0385a9fdc635c9f91139552ccc1f293a0f5413b5b45aafb870aed58d59a5ff54", "task_id": "ncb21-task-b50dee44b2695af4"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-e9fb3c58c1aaf079", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-67f34643eded8ca9", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_ukb_s1_DISC": "54805b96956e62baf32e6b810b3a47ae7e7162cb7f2f47048b577b3b5000a783", "neg_p_fishing_ukb_s1_REP": "00fc6d55172669471120f549e5199ac748e390647bbb3d0c483ec951d3c82e0c"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_ukb_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_ukb_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "acabffaf6cb9166a856ee934b63d45d402a582940c71ee2974367ff1b87f8998", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 24, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "70af205e9bfbee12a86dabf54ed453ab45b3921adc49c4403d8cb19abeb5deb2", "task_id": "ncb21-task-b51d8e49c61305b6"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-0fba59d9c8075ce0", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-9c5ca9b7901ff85f", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "378bc30c1a16bb9bb0c81609ad9946e2f10b4ed89cfe65eb896c87d21e3200b4", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "5d891ef6fad3a86f2f4a17acc6b922aa41716f044af8551b1a04576edb14744b", "task_id": "ncb21-task-b56715660f95ba57"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-3bb5fd92cff87e34", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-4a6caed07c3d5c5b", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "7f2bd004bacea68d9b9aa1fb75355cac52e1f854a9652b0b45c811424aa54e17", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "b668a02001b4bf51d7ee2d61fdaedb55f59275253ebf16d38e582ce5e25a2055", "task_id": "ncb21-task-b56a70f7ddd5fc44"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-4ffc0faff41b9d25", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-81c0a914684a479e", "cohort_content_hashes": {"FBIRN_DISC": "5a9a103412824c97ff34a4b7c9107198e9309be14f345c917761eb11adcdbd82", "FBIRN_REP": "132788e0b0576e4f01ac0ac8dcbb232f2f105aea4693833ef74a59a45118b33a"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "0b69fb2493b8dd1f02041caf4bf412e1bd73ad13c48809fd2018cd047aeb5098", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "d301558682913491192e4e4924317d44a588f15d878853bdcecf44cd2656d8da", "task_id": "ncb21-task-b578c3c76fe3269c"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-c2d028849e27a38a", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-6087f8c3d284c619", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_hcp_aging_s1_DISC": "9becda9f2ffb8e2d9ac43f0e31a29b2656c02cea02cb8ea30a79be7014936c96", "neg_random_label_hcp_aging_s1_REP": "4d7f1c0951bcf6dc153d86ef305b55d7962e3f7418e31533de4df39334434de1"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_hcp_aging_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_hcp_aging_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "a7b7afdf66fa4d59eabe127dca34f559127cff345acd712f4779771d07e70d9e", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "73b707825b35ff1c308db6dda8875068f6474aed2ca2368afab624931cdeea58", "task_id": "ncb21-task-b6748553af1a76fa"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-064719283da9679c", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-9c4cab68034e3f00", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_oasis3_s3_DISC": "3545c1258bd88e9065d019db672250d3409a5d5f0f57e0dee0beeb920fe16531", "neg_site_confound_oasis3_s3_REP": "78dd4f15d488eca817aa9dffff888532260dcbdba10e23c426c95adbddf9c923"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_oasis3_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_oasis3_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "601c1ab5ea90e9f69b9c16f9039682c3344cd735aa972651ca5ed4281f5602d0", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 329, "p": 1.7700709248161177e-27, "test": "chi_square"}, {"associated": false, "confound": "fs_version", "levels": 4, "n": 329, "p": 0.5597317440161416, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 329, "p": 1.7700709248161177e-27, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 2}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "07a8eb29dd36c1ff5ba0ce79f93e0f286af3ab7e2df480445b202ee661f01091", "task_id": "ncb21-task-b691ac42ecffb6ff"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-d916964e92a59eb0", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-91f11d4be9effdcb", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_hcp_aging_s3_DISC": "fd1e7d0baf20f3419800393db1c7914236cf1a7333d859ddc9d4955871cf9296", "neg_site_confound_hcp_aging_s3_REP": "822c14f60e9706f17370140ed96fd51123fd5e7f31b424fd2c2372eadcf059d1"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_hcp_aging_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_hcp_aging_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "5d856e25a26fe87a231ce50c2107e56daea12067bc8b3aac335270c89726f1d9", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 158, "p": 7.532542186112728e-14, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 158, "p": 7.532542186112728e-14, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "6ec5075a2e26eaf3eef00c91623c58c730794c3d26ce01e9150fcb0699273d33", "task_id": "ncb21-task-b6f4ac28d2b3979a"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-f8423e8ba6d67c54", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-4714a8b918533965", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_abide2_s1_DISC": "dd1903f3fa0888bbdd8b92e753e18c654b40c45ae32c46a995a25dda3c8c8658", "neg_site_confound_abide2_s1_REP": "baa1bcbf6b1340d6224d7791735ab06da8209a0aaf040051c1826d758673a092"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_abide2_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_abide2_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "672939818994d5169cd7616261d7658debb435502cbd220f8ee37289051a96ca", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 279, "p": 1.5559643840526863e-23, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 279, "p": 1.5559643840526863e-23, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "a9c724edd34fab4424a92aa32b0fb3cd6e5a83a40500f1cfbffadcc895ac9f16", "task_id": "ncb21-task-b83c81d3f7ed2148"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-5b0717b45335d600", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-4ce91bcd046f4f5c", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "029399e0ef846c5bd8e372637f4382c20c1001455f014a50b045fd418d6acc82", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "349b73a530a6892e363dddb6d6e25d4a027f3aebddf90381cb54bdc7c1ee69f4", "task_id": "ncb21-task-b8602e973f42b46b"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-3cd280f660dfbcd4", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-1e5022cdf2a99f7a", "cohort_content_hashes": {"BSNIP2_DISC": "f60b826114673b4f649dd9e41e9f01b5d76fe3fdff3fb17ac3d13f3472068df0", "BSNIP2_REP": "5a68458b6ca1d3ceb62243f2dcf1fda0209a9d2685669530b7e4c5f279a32f23"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "7a48e9fd21e90eefa3f94b8e9c0323d13a7de7134ce6cc9b20f84e4240d72c1a", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "0bd7030516914c3b762416b5ce289c7726d58f21b60be6e582fc821c623ce96f", "task_id": "ncb21-task-b93848fb1885ade6"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-a02841671504d8cd", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-97d31a0d120eb64a", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "c2cf03d0f6489f1c5205e3f84236af1d0a64dab159fa9d41f9167e5967b5d084", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "86240a7ea8f8ff6b30f60ddcc37b1b78545e9e3edef07c58361a47553518d852", "task_id": "ncb21-task-b95b16ef9794f281"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-c0127a06d407afa7", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-4be43e80b37748a5", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_adni_s2_DISC": "b9043a8a7298952ed96a245f4d94d184fec852f03260ae4bef3ac4c60e639c6e", "neg_random_label_adni_s2_REP": "66b05bfab5c32139ec526510326a003ea11f85ae1eeaaa9dc278490baad19f18"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_adni_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_adni_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "a879b7b78818fa19030c71a97fa5d7a2ea90ba2d00aea6df0281be69e33a3ec1", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "049ac8c8d22657340b81a7970d7589691a163e542213f439749de6f426029e24", "task_id": "ncb21-task-b9861c2208ee43af"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-449e7b4f8e2900f2", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-186eabcbed30f518", "cohort_content_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "a3e6f1609ea823c9216310eaea1cf3e54443ed385d8f2c4ccb0374907756646b", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "4cc03f072ec07c42f4ceaa18a43bd2065e0d5c508c7d70b6115b8ccc60ee1062"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-b98bf983ead6f362/NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-b98bf983ead6f362/NACC_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "44fcedc00c11901d81f702756f4bb0df26634753e88ebdeca7183920deceb404", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 3101, "p": 0.2103537803779664, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "ncb_random_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "bcb52f6d7b67f17a806c8f4ecf5365be9575701ead6cc62bbb3cecdf14eba695", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "d0148b746332b3354a90c62e8bedc7e1e379791f6ac4de24a5bd05a582831c0a"}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "0cc642c4f7bd3623cb5d6456d49a76e61a46def5ff2a5c62cd298da9e8809f98", "task_id": "ncb21-task-b98bf983ead6f362"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-09bce8d2747a588b", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-4cdd6473c343f6dc", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "af78bce7247d571c0c25b187bef3f176eaa50ec26ea0be14419e9020ce2bc52e", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "aa93b61e042f862f3c2413d048669fdf6787cc6a1d4b44dac1e024f74f3a1fc0", "task_id": "ncb21-task-ba5da3b4e0cc513f"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-bd91d6374d028fa2", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-40c850a951edf3c4", "cohort_content_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "a3e6f1609ea823c9216310eaea1cf3e54443ed385d8f2c4ccb0374907756646b", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "4cc03f072ec07c42f4ceaa18a43bd2065e0d5c508c7d70b6115b8ccc60ee1062"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "bd7e6fed30b44728d9a97f456f826aefe1eec16d71e16353e91d9e05e49f799b", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 1964, "p": 4.750055361533447e-83, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 1964, "p": 4.750055361533447e-83, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "589f795a88d68bf4c93365a074541c510bb113e4d50bc9fbe013ffae6b176031", "task_id": "ncb21-task-baa1113679fb1a86"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-9345083b10556ec3", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-60f19a1546f42cf7", "cohort_content_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "a3e6f1609ea823c9216310eaea1cf3e54443ed385d8f2c4ccb0374907756646b", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "4cc03f072ec07c42f4ceaa18a43bd2065e0d5c508c7d70b6115b8ccc60ee1062"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-bb43c3c406fa97cf/NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-bb43c3c406fa97cf/NACC_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "3d668ac84529e78615d0be0247b6136e4d434446812078eb65757034fbcd0aba", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 3101, "p": 0.7934481903129675, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "ncb_random_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "c70ffc0336497f6c3d0782c5b1226a8794820000a38363c791875c8d6c141971", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "4dbe76b7243ed4058122ad3a00ae3d1d3cc1ecdf920c29ca58ef0f8156fe04e7"}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "1175dae6bc03dd2184d19504ceb502d26a725f93b4e2f00f939eb6ba5e3006be", "task_id": "ncb21-task-bb43c3c406fa97cf"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-d502bc59cbfea3cf", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-695903774d653e7b", "cohort_content_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "a3e6f1609ea823c9216310eaea1cf3e54443ed385d8f2c4ccb0374907756646b", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "4cc03f072ec07c42f4ceaa18a43bd2065e0d5c508c7d70b6115b8ccc60ee1062"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "00d390bd7a6735352d9509305027bc295e4da9844fa86f6b6a5b519161f40986", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 1964, "p": 4.750055361533447e-83, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 1964, "p": 4.750055361533447e-83, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "4b389053d81578cb38005dd786f8ffcad53298c44197420c16fd23b7857aac91", "task_id": "ncb21-task-bb554719e6145756"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-b3381266246ed676", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-4edd5df7b61915f7", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_underpowered_abcd_s2_DISC": "54cf149b1eb811d2e15e5cead800ef7cfe9eac0553a8dd6796e11f3e196ca679", "neg_underpowered_abcd_s2_REP": "ee791ec38ca3fbf6e2111916c096055ba075c694b6e0b5f764a694498434905a"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_abcd_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_abcd_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "afe19b4c4effffb594ee99f152003f54fc21f3d2f04ed5ef3811b7a027f08a3a", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.512 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "e1c09917f54ae59b5f136a347ed39f38c1a6a9a3a7b5638442490b4aba8f7392", "task_id": "ncb21-task-bc0d1ec559619a68"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-8969417a2a5f8ec6", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-e4996564bf4ae6d4", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_cross_nonrep_abide2_abcd_s2_DISC": "0e9545e76aa369bb902ddb1eb59bc9d69a9a1db24e5a984e43d92f6e1bb9638b", "neg_cross_nonrep_abide2_abcd_s2_REP": "caee76faba54a99758ba260215b2499699640e98bb3e63c6de88730fa460c8e3"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_cross_nonrep_abide2_abcd_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_cross_nonrep_abide2_abcd_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "226cecadcae9737f24dc2750cb253dce830237149cae731441343f0412538acd", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 24, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "d81c61da85a33e0ea7f999dd8c72e3711d22220dee568aba52295fd7b5aa5ace", "task_id": "ncb21-task-bc5b5fc4a73e8a67"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-df080a369be8d182", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-adf9f774e349ffad", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_oasis3_s2_DISC": "827c740cad4142dd74a6570d4f7987cb880e3b6c1e7ee1f7b7726b5b26565ba0", "neg_site_confound_oasis3_s2_REP": "5225eb2d17c543e68dbe85222f1cbd4e5cf66a82204ad6e5e6752ba004faa662"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_oasis3_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_oasis3_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "9e18c0a8b2299bb0157c4030b3ab42f32fc702f9ab7f270358d2df27be14b2fc", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 329, "p": 1.7700709248161177e-27, "test": "chi_square"}, {"associated": false, "confound": "fs_version", "levels": 4, "n": 329, "p": 0.322855718888272, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 329, "p": 1.7700709248161177e-27, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 2}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "b94bf870f3e851b27f3339793e53960e6ce5760639ceb5c9ffdb0e99a69ec19c", "task_id": "ncb21-task-bd61926979c12c74"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-ed8eabb252714493", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-b7766efbf759775a", "cohort_content_hashes": {"FBIRN_DISC": "5a9a103412824c97ff34a4b7c9107198e9309be14f345c917761eb11adcdbd82", "FBIRN_REP": "132788e0b0576e4f01ac0ac8dcbb232f2f105aea4693833ef74a59a45118b33a"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "b907a638ec3100c685717ec7e694f0b8db039d84dddd33e4d6b8927ef2e59761", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "f3961783a8e1d84624d7bf244a6e89c9c323bb1a9d7bd4591375d3bb6abf4cea", "task_id": "ncb21-task-bdd3e3934c5e73da"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-41408a5127ecaa01", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-775ae051b3a26db6", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ChineseSZ_DISC": "25886d87d5dc1da53df39d984bfa54f68aa99adbbbcb75b7d4826c4d8bdaff73", "ChineseSZ_REP": "9c94c02e8066411af69f22387e526434c8c412c6df30ff250b1c7bc75f5514a8"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "0d015bf75c3c2f96b40afb8a560b61071211af82cf121889b96fab1aa4a9c46a", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 352, "p": 0.309214890459771, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "daef95226561c1c8ec96b2343181629b4d72526e93164e8dbdd462e2fc8c99ca", "task_id": "ncb21-task-be3fb7338da2dc8b"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-6130b7ec9d114c16", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-5f469014af0452bf", "cohort_content_hashes": {"BSNIP2_REP": "5a68458b6ca1d3ceb62243f2dcf1fda0209a9d2685669530b7e4c5f279a32f23", "ChineseSZ_REP": "9c94c02e8066411af69f22387e526434c8c412c6df30ff250b1c7bc75f5514a8", "FBIRN_DISC": "5a9a103412824c97ff34a4b7c9107198e9309be14f345c917761eb11adcdbd82", "FBIRN_REP": "132788e0b0576e4f01ac0ac8dcbb232f2f105aea4693833ef74a59a45118b33a", "Olin_SZ_REP": "d7bef7b3dc92844bbfc9976c601ed84734ccd0a9b19af3571dddda43dc156167"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/Olin_SZ_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "403fa68bade592ad3ca96d5cc5e14390120e12064a3a82fe9cc8db85ed95ce11", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "60ce81fbfaffbdbda0254435a5455a1b80a828f4511ade26ada2974877831ce3", "task_id": "ncb21-task-be735a5c5e04df19"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-61a83b2df86312b4", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-3571b049e7ec3682", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_abide2_s2_DISC": "a48ef5f537634b8932a2f6b5969160b5a634373518583021aed9707a706b8b9b", "neg_site_confound_abide2_s2_REP": "065f557b3443a3f26a8ad2ce7ed708bcf0f20c3b0d636fc56f41a26cf7453df1"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_abide2_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_abide2_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "d0125a382e1ac8c30a0da6eeaa0390861649235b0253fede8becefde5c8deac8", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 279, "p": 1.5559643840526863e-23, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 279, "p": 1.5559643840526863e-23, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "fc3c45193ad09b204f9d25aedfc3bcdd140366a3bafa714765d17eed575ae5da", "task_id": "ncb21-task-be860de1c1e17eea"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-f143dbf87a77594f", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-4b03344836145733", "cohort_content_hashes": {"OASIS3_fMRI_DISC": "7b701bee5bf1a2e4ded9c29c25ca16bc6ef6980169d9873326b362e29ecfa14d", "OASIS3_fMRI_REP": "b3ca261941658ec5a84c1f6f268e2261777e1bcd23bf28c7d2abe42d646aa786"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_fMRI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_fMRI_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "5760bfbf686a410db9d0456c3d0e7c6522dadc85145d946277932f025437c490", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "3802cc3248d31466d6e51c6ce1870f531e6fba1b8de3096b5fc805382fbb666e", "task_id": "ncb21-task-bed2c3bc8ea49212"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-096741f8365b47ec", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-87c468c5f0db646c", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_adhd200_s1_DISC": "d0357ef9ee3bf5c82753f05bc852dbbd3a3641ac832d16de480e8bda0e53ec74", "neg_site_confound_adhd200_s1_REP": "9eb879561214bd78301355f4dfcb9d2c87dde594a780026bbb8c807feec68c38"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_adhd200_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_adhd200_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "371e170a9b66b88ca9188c3e2891935749d7a889d5e4cbad5c9620ad7ec8ac55", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 156, "p": 1.759621848327281e-13, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 156, "p": 1.759621848327281e-13, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "1e8164e2300780cbe3f35ebc2c61948dac2035b8d68b72cdc788a7b0a2a80caf", "task_id": "ncb21-task-c10905f83a2b5a38"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-5d4734ea98c9d333", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-79aae4c9a11b22c4", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "f376a56f6dd4fb82898bfc85e72b9024f4ad689f87653f8ceae97933785a9ed0", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "b370be65d5802543282d69e561355f1c3299d4546412bab504de34ac04e98952", "task_id": "ncb21-task-c1d31cf0f21d21b0"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-2ef4c0bcc46bed37", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-91f8425cf1fa3718", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "232132a84602d2e002eff364fa44085a7d831aca45cc3db13afd94a377e6b66e", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "e722d3550084f1d8aed04e44b0e6662f7a7d342b8abd67c8fc52eec91e78415f"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-c26251ebfb435372/ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-c26251ebfb435372/ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "66ea403eb149a691cceb52d55744784b2a9384ad709d39a017a96f8e64217b43", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "ncb_random_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "73505028e8b5a56943b5465b84a6d007f28642512447d5910520a7199f201885", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "dbf04be2557aefbac840278d52b5cf2af1a21b609b7b5eb1e13bd3c96b414da6"}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "ebb5f8d15afb3e4b28b7b2909b90b720ad0ab2b712a41bdecc126ce13d5d96b7", "task_id": "ncb21-task-c26251ebfb435372"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-611e67de29172a34", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-22996c9eeaa28686", "cohort_content_hashes": {"BSNIP2_REP": "5a68458b6ca1d3ceb62243f2dcf1fda0209a9d2685669530b7e4c5f279a32f23", "ChineseSZ_REP": "9c94c02e8066411af69f22387e526434c8c412c6df30ff250b1c7bc75f5514a8", "FBIRN_REP": "132788e0b0576e4f01ac0ac8dcbb232f2f105aea4693833ef74a59a45118b33a", "Olin_SZ_REP": "d7bef7b3dc92844bbfc9976c601ed84734ccd0a9b19af3571dddda43dc156167"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/Olin_SZ_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "9e6684cd67da8fa26266e453934ad251f0220e1376d71fb70419f4b34a311d13", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.605 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "932bafcf0c67e47845be4ec8cea428f6b13178ca31a0781cd394e6e1e200764b", "task_id": "ncb21-task-c2e929cb5553adf2"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-e59458cf873b37f4", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-ab3f32f265858d55", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_DISC": "7f42f7518c34775c8e5cf7c590a1fe44f226f40a7b899e71223b56ef43411663", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "2bdcd7ce6a82def18b6e3f61332a31768d6712dbc720686f22d06d46315911a4", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "direction_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "direction_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 36, "n": 541, "p": 0.8025643529885985, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "heterogeneity_i2": 85.61142772305185, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 85.61142772305185, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=direction_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=85.6"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "d20fd97b758d8aa5040a9e1545f96f183a97884a68be4deafde57991d466e61c", "task_id": "ncb21-task-c2ee1c5133d1ee46"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-6a1fd39ef4326482", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-26190155607a5ea8", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "232132a84602d2e002eff364fa44085a7d831aca45cc3db13afd94a377e6b66e", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "e722d3550084f1d8aed04e44b0e6662f7a7d342b8abd67c8fc52eec91e78415f"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-c3101591e4f28500/ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-c3101591e4f28500/ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "73d06c6f8296c586afe912496130fe3d54e4e6e155b3170a523ecf37d62f118f", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "ncb_random_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "f45a5ede6c56ace9c1ef16a6b1a9c37872dec4b459a044f611c105132424d896", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "81f79dc37ddb35c6d3d92f621f45a41f55c2d0531cf202555888013e89d07d90"}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "13fe1534322c27c1cd253231e4e6a1b6e9408d17b032d9aa49cc177d723dbe9d", "task_id": "ncb21-task-c3101591e4f28500"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-1c1c6743a2aa1468", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-ea3d6efa3b525082", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c", "ADHD200_DISC": "2ed4e2ddb4d8a3845dbec23c0b31652d26fdefe209e61fc4cdd3b636ebabb4fd"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "c14c379963f3a502e087d812d8e327d6c026545d74d428f3b7eb090ad776615c", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 30, "multiverse": false, "pattern_corr": false, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication, pattern_corr, region_replication_fraction; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; pattern_corr=-0.531; dice=1.000; region_replication_fraction=0.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "31c2204a086d2190f9330e04efae0a4ea8fb82fd5b0dc28f2f2c047378afafd5", "task_id": "ncb21-task-c3310379971f41e3"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-9066c4a0d3bc2f9f", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-2370bde3a6fa5c56", "cohort_content_hashes": {"BSNIP2_REP": "5a68458b6ca1d3ceb62243f2dcf1fda0209a9d2685669530b7e4c5f279a32f23", "COBRE_REP": "4a81a6fb00f3834982866da08d40f58816c7907a2c62838ae1fad68fd5bb18dc"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "e3b1fef6c16b338c1e3e2ebafac3521b4b1518a1c5c2f20966780366812c2f38", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.387 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "23f264f6ea94567f13480364cb07d9ad9a77e1b89520a0675b13fd1217c19ab0", "task_id": "ncb21-task-c356c0495b8f5c1e"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-c4f5cafd4fc66d6e", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-5e1692364e183994", "cohort_content_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "a3e6f1609ea823c9216310eaea1cf3e54443ed385d8f2c4ccb0374907756646b", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "4cc03f072ec07c42f4ceaa18a43bd2065e0d5c508c7d70b6115b8ccc60ee1062"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-c47957b26806a895/NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-c47957b26806a895/NACC_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "f132a00e7dcd4dd028983b8343729e2cc8fe44ba0b55bc69e25ce54b62e89f8e", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 3101, "p": 0.6835258612539667, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "ncb_random_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_cohort_mismatch"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "b5ac18870193d025e7788a9cc53de8bd74ee76ff3d5f3fb9643ca5d60124c537", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "cb5bb56dc87f00f2e5db906377fe91ac3c7865f154ec0732be42acbd410032f0"}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "c8ef8806f9fe7758e7a1e573bff4c178cfac27db64ca53eacefc17ad26c7ce96", "task_id": "ncb21-task-c47957b26806a895"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-7f4258667f94f44d", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-159563022cc82516", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_REP": "56cd379d34a3e7f93f341c1014daa9b3a9146606a68d4720d4513d09e35d73b6", "OASIS3_DISC": "8a048aaff562775d7c80f7027c9d8bb56cc738b7563d25ca06af7cb33df89d31", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "5a8c1c4b33464e8e462c9f70025964c79c46487996d61063036161e722d2353d", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "fs_version", "levels": 4, "n": 576, "p": 0.00014048948470919836, "test": "anova"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "fs_version", "levels": 4, "n": 576, "p": 0.00014048948470919836, "test": "anova"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "age", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "58a11a05459591299c0e33fcac1a8c4d064f85e26179f4dc5e6a5d794c7d3b90", "task_id": "ncb21-task-c56dc7c61f203feb"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-58807756a4b61455", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-fe25471a6d6c3dce", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_hcp_s3_DISC": "af887de8220eff84424d140330b0b4f8ee660f91ec2dd07088377729cd5c57f0", "neg_site_confound_hcp_s3_REP": "92e106241e84ac52f68ef138909f6cc1a94f60a04c6ec5bd6ec8e411ba4b4c3e"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_hcp_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_hcp_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "eaeb58f2049d17185eef3f1654e5ef638b41fdf8a2552c634a65b2036c6587cd", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 270, "p": 6.266665841089351e-23, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 270, "p": 6.266665841089351e-23, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "9a9c1784020a8773e961510f2f08b437616f9e7fa12cc0f5cafa4927aa8db954", "task_id": "ncb21-task-c6df24464e7071d9"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-a9e0ba33a876abc0", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-6ff54101b7e6c17a", "cohort_content_hashes": {"UKB_DISC": "8f50d0d10f4265b3538407235a0af91a7bb4d1a733daea42a655d4931e0bfdd3", "UKB_REP": "6da6a67cb610290a28f97b077dd2aa0e82c39161e4b3c622857cb54843df2357"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/UKB_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/UKB_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "2699a812aabbd4657ef93f6c98121a7407d1ad3d6ff737a55efff97d800d4862", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "9b55c4785dd5dca0f9432b84de24febc41b91f8c8f827155617ee974dcab8be6", "task_id": "ncb21-task-c781fd15ae8248cb"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-2f6ce6fa5ea95eeb", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-e0462373f511a084", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "5606cbd93265373c5762656dadb07e880ec93d1d26f2e581f3b0c182c0aa9419", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "f75885808172a656a960d01fe1db8008e9870b0fc631947c7f4476ebcf1548b1", "task_id": "ncb21-task-c8004841f6d71d20"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-7be5e0886589fedd", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-2b983101a2372286", "cohort_content_hashes": {"HCP_DISC": "4bfd66afa7e3af1ad63ed1a3d1fdc1662e370064e97e927de95b8f783b7886a8", "HCP_REP": "0cc8dc280e6a961585c8c2c53414db8d8cb581c59cf2beaef3e3731c5eca9eba"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "5cf696b6003819dfd3cc4ada40b0ba41b1465a14a8cd6c5209ff6726767d7023", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "e26eeb7c4a67ecd1d31d6d4d420578fcab6e16ebc2b6ef3ba4e01862d83695c0", "task_id": "ncb21-task-c876031a0856d8ed"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-172d75bcc17dcce9", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-0b5ef32cb1e42640", "cohort_content_hashes": {"FBIRN_DISC": "5a9a103412824c97ff34a4b7c9107198e9309be14f345c917761eb11adcdbd82", "FBIRN_REP": "132788e0b0576e4f01ac0ac8dcbb232f2f105aea4693833ef74a59a45118b33a"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "75b798f88db2a51a9a1b56dd9c95b0fd71f06fca5397a3c4941bedb1419ddd27", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "6075c1a4ea30c6388024de5d11957a951fa584dd3f720d19389020a2553039c6", "task_id": "ncb21-task-c8829f53c8dd90c9"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-21a9351a0c613d68", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-c8b889ca15052344", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "232132a84602d2e002eff364fa44085a7d831aca45cc3db13afd94a377e6b66e", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "e722d3550084f1d8aed04e44b0e6662f7a7d342b8abd67c8fc52eec91e78415f"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-c8efa5ce726d2a2c/ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-c8efa5ce726d2a2c/ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "81b6edd150fdb511266ffd1070ce080829e97063fe4278b60f1537d9d9c26536", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "ncb_random_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "57e4b051ebb4c88593e0079154c3c661bfd2a7bf916e361bbdf39b8977e98ed4", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "4af4d21d0dc13747a82713845f65b3b1009ac823403bfae976b877d7e2d3b29c"}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "fb2575fa1578012a068e47d6e4bf29342d1802d49c295eff57ed50f934a35adf", "task_id": "ncb21-task-c8efa5ce726d2a2c"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-792968836011440a", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-df348b820c9e0dc5", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_DISC": "7f42f7518c34775c8e5cf7c590a1fe44f226f40a7b899e71223b56ef43411663", "ADNI_REP": "56cd379d34a3e7f93f341c1014daa9b3a9146606a68d4720d4513d09e35d73b6"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "66da0c716a18e14de2f672455e423943c762e44b2d87243873c436f29c4a3520", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 29.523495583257386, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 29.523495583257386, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=29.5"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "3da7f6deeb5dbeae5ec2a5af3e04b26666dff10e802ec6394fe2e7b32e281300", "task_id": "ncb21-task-c960d04f2a3a502e"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-3b26f2bc31391570", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-beebe6b4d8961e0f", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_oasis3_s2_DISC": "9e3181de82d249843e28db30312c7480581dfecf6367b71c0bb5ed6b74f30c37", "neg_p_fishing_oasis3_s2_REP": "a8eec638f3f7d38158d610bf94784264d840461fbbdeee1d3cef641124686849"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_oasis3_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_oasis3_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "6d6e2b82709e5b2db1981a14f45ee2b9d10b34e2697caf3a53bed3cf16f05380", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "fs_version", "levels": 4, "n": 329, "p": 0.9772818628830193, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 6, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "d4a1c9ce7c1a3b58231c27d72d142ab4d44d594c45c452d5f2c724840555857c", "task_id": "ncb21-task-c9819c4e552cf245"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-36b84e80d6c50012", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-be41703ab0620fed", "cohort_content_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "a3e6f1609ea823c9216310eaea1cf3e54443ed385d8f2c4ccb0374907756646b", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "4cc03f072ec07c42f4ceaa18a43bd2065e0d5c508c7d70b6115b8ccc60ee1062"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "9338f31e91a4dcdf4332027c1cc561a472c7bab2524f57c16ccb8becf0b16128", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 1964, "p": 4.750055361533447e-83, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 1964, "p": 4.750055361533447e-83, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "876552abb1f3114dd9987ba080242b9abfd76793067f18db4af54a636c37bcae", "task_id": "ncb21-task-cab2f356990668f8"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-afe1f83e3d954a8c", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-8ca28155a1137b04", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADHD200_DISC": "2ed4e2ddb4d8a3845dbec23c0b31652d26fdefe209e61fc4cdd3b636ebabb4fd", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "4130b64200413bc25be9fe7973e31fdef99f04a6bb4d3feeab5338b258a8b2d0", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "214911a5b7b3a6665c7689702cccb1669e95999c8109d3f70827f87b66ce7edd", "task_id": "ncb21-task-cacb3bd51f7eea36"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-2aa338cf718c206f", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-b1625be87853a8f5", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "HCP_Aging_REP": "e4682154e236a020f91b7932fe75341cf7a0eed865089e5172cad83a6989e965"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_Aging_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "bbca9d1b593ba8d73001ffd0e581b6a5d473e26ae765b1fafc07c46a4806b39d", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 84, "multiverse": true, "pattern_corr": true, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All brain-wide gates passed.; pattern_corr=0.436; dice=0.000; region_replication_fraction=0.208"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "47273692ab20d011d3be603e9b0e16b1724dc0a2bf25b45280698030fba8450e", "task_id": "ncb21-task-cbc18e184afcce9b"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-e1c33335981addda", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-47f367aaeb28dfa4", "cohort_content_hashes": {"HCP_DISC": "4bfd66afa7e3af1ad63ed1a3d1fdc1662e370064e97e927de95b8f783b7886a8", "HCP_REP": "0cc8dc280e6a961585c8c2c53414db8d8cb581c59cf2beaef3e3731c5eca9eba"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "e9cd7981d2379b08d3b05a9ab9f5a3c60eb87dcc888b97e2117aff0c4b7a01ce", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "phen_fluid_composite", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "a03841f6b34bea6efd3b28cd2d9627a1d5332948454123f98433c55fde94b784", "task_id": "ncb21-task-cc16390eeb98c9fe"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-f1d779bf3ff46410", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-9f9cad507c434e3b", "cohort_content_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "a3e6f1609ea823c9216310eaea1cf3e54443ed385d8f2c4ccb0374907756646b", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "4cc03f072ec07c42f4ceaa18a43bd2065e0d5c508c7d70b6115b8ccc60ee1062"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-cc1ba1d90b8171c2/NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-cc1ba1d90b8171c2/NACC_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "2101c844cdf74d226cae2f892fd0d7cacf66b623082ad6fff561067244cc5439", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 3101, "p": 0.050929283764562204, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "ncb_random_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "5734d9a8b4bc148adbbb404ec77ebe2c37ade8e31e5791484fc85553253c929a", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "944293569bea9b132c15881c903ecb6c15a0127410d000a8939b0b49088f00db"}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "a16e0cf9009f934066143a379d0c1285a215f3503b349dcfce4dbf0c7c8c3847", "task_id": "ncb21-task-cc1ba1d90b8171c2"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-91524ba0afb540ec", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-2e0f189c26580fe6", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_abide1_s2_DISC": "897203f122a1c506f927b27637ee2a8ceed3d36157e6fb6eab53cb64330e7223", "neg_random_label_abide1_s2_REP": "d90196c5e69d6b9616289aac02fe60dea6035d8e1d72f8091172ce5e17e13246"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_abide1_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_abide1_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "cd8980865c29eebb50e72f9d1a52106657c1cfa7eb719e5128a531eacd81a3c6", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "3e77ddb922a393ac2549934d8aa4ce67f2d7f98bf049237136eb9900d9dfffb5", "task_id": "ncb21-task-cce1c559d4d6ce5f"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-cfc8fee426568090", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-30ca33c996dc4653", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_adni_fmri_s1_DISC": "025e6a782ccdde852ee832d689bbe893dc6767f86d20940d7086293cf65e5e9f", "neg_random_label_adni_fmri_s1_REP": "444deecfd07e4ff12f8f65a511e30a1aa51076934ac7cdba73858c4a228074c5"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_adni_fmri_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_adni_fmri_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "8f08a50576f719cf8815d8b6964411373eabbccf9e9ace06d85d433eaabbf7f4", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "033cbe488d9567dad0d0e44ab99f867d51856b38f1aee0a6776d42332088d62d", "task_id": "ncb21-task-cd4d4a4bf0616018"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-a536bee9bcacd85c", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-868f8d22ff7801aa", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_fbirn_s2_DISC": "4c9858719298d824924ff66d93a84216e2f996e9b263d3eb0b098e10565ed798", "neg_site_confound_fbirn_s2_REP": "4ae2ce05db2ee61a875274c944b3050144642434f237d85ead85bdc76777b4af"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_fbirn_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_fbirn_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "f80844984759abdbde4fa9a1adf8c8e6739e280c09381a5d336d0a702b0d9914", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 71, "p": 3.351925452602801e-07, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 71, "p": 3.351925452602801e-07, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": false, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness, power; confound_incomplete; power=0.703 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "e76b71a35d741831fb9e6a2b74f70f469f9d91e424a3b56416f4b31852c268ab", "task_id": "ncb21-task-ce078f862e494327"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-7a87a86398becf44", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-143dee76805e7dac", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "1d7fe589703c671983018f3320ca7f6a97310f0babe65308a4f2f008ac09f065", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "1962f5026a1929ccdea45fe4a3b596f752890651d2005cdd9d654330c842ae78", "task_id": "ncb21-task-cecdff58b47a089c"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-be9238714808b664", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-bd4c3d1687861de2", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "88a560f7dfc2de372cc2ce55796088e851cdd33267012382bcca80aabaf90b7c", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "7da7a4b376593a6914313e45c96549a125301941e636b70c88872cc45d9faa2b", "task_id": "ncb21-task-ceeb9f8bb890690b"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-bfbbfbb8d1be3254", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-8d97ccd472238603", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_oasis3_fmri_s2_DISC": "643866dbf5db10807bd84913fac3bd6e10a524b9f460d3807b1afe89745096c6", "neg_random_label_oasis3_fmri_s2_REP": "3c18982616b8c7fc5bdb285d88ccb586e0f860ff8585ba6db6e1816e0dcd4e37"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_oasis3_fmri_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_oasis3_fmri_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "52ce7acab489583658d9d1133148a625821181ca299ff17da9e40edc29b8aa34", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "d6a828c392827564acabc53e5899a666be303f01efa004eb390bf37e4cbf9bef", "task_id": "ncb21-task-cf886c1c711bb9c7"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-6d7bbb66ca61d088", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-8a06819fdc6c9961", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "d0fb8b23be7f513117514f732f4182552892d53a19d47b7f70e4bb5146815a96", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "594dbf817ec2f25806884ed6ae08f218cf016d50ed120d16b5aa485a36fa072e", "task_id": "ncb21-task-cfee782015d454f9"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-18f6d3452bd64ce5", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-524a7695ac2648f3", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_abide1_s1_DISC": "a6721d1f88df71460a214dd2b3b4905143121bfeb42dea3e8be86c156ef0b4ea", "neg_site_confound_abide1_s1_REP": "52df427a58289efc51cbe57d8e0f01ac45afe56ff99b2fd4ad3fa75e9abebb2e"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_abide1_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_abide1_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "0f039d7f69863b88e042ee83b38c9e2ba3d017f612e5f4d737d3d7c5054ef6de", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 200, "p": 2.1519736712498897e-17, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 200, "p": 2.1519736712498897e-17, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "298316be1a194e4e2ca3e404907a48e935817171ef9f381589b8bb8c5aa1ff62", "task_id": "ncb21-task-cff73497886d4ec5"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-521bd6435c6d8390", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-c5d3078fceeb5c49", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_adhd200_s1_DISC": "f9680110caf0e3d2227b01f1fe75d0584677eee81e40c9e9aad204da5f9c0a0c", "neg_p_fishing_adhd200_s1_REP": "f72a0ffd4047122230884e19fef313720356b67ae6d0420f2d7306cdc4c94e6d"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_adhd200_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_adhd200_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "f12d9f4d83136d1838265ccb02f414ffeaeff8e61c9791e2701085d6e82eaf11", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 24, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "8722d451f925bc98a16d6571e43a53accce1d04f035ac23086bc4bf20ca5133b", "task_id": "ncb21-task-d07a2cea40481453"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-1c4bb13eab05e379", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-1a29042ad9a5465b", "cohort_content_hashes": {"BSNIP2_DISC": "f60b826114673b4f649dd9e41e9f01b5d76fe3fdff3fb17ac3d13f3472068df0", "COBRE_REP": "4a81a6fb00f3834982866da08d40f58816c7907a2c62838ae1fad68fd5bb18dc"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "39d20b538b64263ee9bd7642f1808be66de8853bfac0a905897b96879e60de09", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 4, "multiverse": false, "pattern_corr": true, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse; pattern_corr=0.164; dice=0.000; region_replication_fraction=0.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "dbc08071678a10b0b86774e69b0b068643b3edc894283f64a00f68a9b8f24de4", "task_id": "ncb21-task-d16970e16e73be72"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-31990e646f54d4e6", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-d4792ef993b784e7", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "3bb09591f36ed52f3a7e6a24d512c801085925ef4fa5155be1f2c913f293e08e", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "ce012660f8574ffab3f11ad78a956e1e4cbf83f4b315a6f496e38365d77b3348", "task_id": "ncb21-task-d1871ce3feb49f3f"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-9ec4c7f2ec1fad99", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-a45662e1d59b0735", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "9f82cb5dce48fd64ecdeaafa80ef9ca8ba33e17ed71636bf589d5bff27973d9f", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "e46509aca3ed9cb0f74c4b8d07a64869c7dc143ca96030f3240dfef8a3be8793", "task_id": "ncb21-task-d1b98a4ced7af402"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-045d9f98883becc4", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-d49c1f57c7ac3156", "cohort_content_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "a3e6f1609ea823c9216310eaea1cf3e54443ed385d8f2c4ccb0374907756646b", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "4cc03f072ec07c42f4ceaa18a43bd2065e0d5c508c7d70b6115b8ccc60ee1062"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-d2d7116561bfb23f/NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-d2d7116561bfb23f/NACC_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "6b5028925995a28330bec3d81b42f65612242e4400faf4d801de8b37ff90ba47", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 3101, "p": 0.9333861452116674, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "ncb_random_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "0735cc8697411217b8a1576e581d42c5d08321f434ccd69b6ef3eed0e259ca70", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "d1218251d51db92681aa0ea29c88c403a84844fae918bdd7c56f6b230926256a"}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "2894ffdd3d349dbc6eb1fc0b423b265097cf909359204d1909edeca99bd556b2", "task_id": "ncb21-task-d2d7116561bfb23f"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-d0e3c2468afe4539", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-dfb854f4ac35f016", "cohort_content_hashes": {"HCP_Aging_DISC": "47082908a7b0b17d0b8a006028dff9d08a56af3f8c6e8d08627ca3818f85a4fd", "HCP_Aging_REP": "e4682154e236a020f91b7932fe75341cf7a0eed865089e5172cad83a6989e965"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_Aging_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_Aging_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "68691e54722cbf1f4dfda20a409822798f50b26fa2bf8c6a58d4e5bc427224ba", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "b654127cf6e79999d740c7495f0866852c77cb439ea36116697ec472a0e27dcc", "task_id": "ncb21-task-d2e03b9aa3b48e11"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-66560a7fd0e34141", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-1bee3c48cbe5d877", "cohort_content_hashes": {"BSNIP2_DISC": "f60b826114673b4f649dd9e41e9f01b5d76fe3fdff3fb17ac3d13f3472068df0", "BSNIP2_REP": "5a68458b6ca1d3ceb62243f2dcf1fda0209a9d2685669530b7e4c5f279a32f23"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "6e6fb0a4c192d8883a937f62ee5d04f7f6c46d9d010cc7b03eda6676178ed3a8", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 278, "p": 0.3656917740160851, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "c4ad8ddfe432c7ec9fe684b1fca6dc08c90818c87ab6ca3bef07fcdb58cc4c1d", "task_id": "ncb21-task-d38cdec7e50cc0a1"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-9c418256797d0a86", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-be63819308d73991", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "HCP_Aging_REP": "e4682154e236a020f91b7932fe75341cf7a0eed865089e5172cad83a6989e965"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_Aging_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "ad83a77a8b9abb90832c6552aabdbfe1e55f930700be4d19346d3b35ab3a54c8", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": false, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 84, "multiverse": true, "pattern_corr": false, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication, pattern_corr, region_replication_fraction, dice; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; pattern_corr=0.436; dice=0.000; region_replication_fraction=0.132"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "f191b6094181097859efef50d7d143d6302bbd67997dbe876fc5d9fb3e0b87e3", "task_id": "ncb21-task-d3bbe5d9c3f53c79"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-cb86d4103ebb0e0c", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-60e5e573834ca8c0", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "245bce421098756924a4c14dd50a5e97295f4e39408ee1b3745b8d4643f7c322", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 84, "multiverse": false, "pattern_corr": false, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication, pattern_corr, region_replication_fraction; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; pattern_corr=-0.461; dice=1.000; region_replication_fraction=0.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "c9e434f6b06161edcbf585e587d67abb0db49fbafcf7220e68533800ef0c47e2", "task_id": "ncb21-task-d3daf7fbc0850859"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-2dcda273dbedc219", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-819f1d2f413f20dd", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_DISC": "7f42f7518c34775c8e5cf7c590a1fe44f226f40a7b899e71223b56ef43411663", "ADNI_REP": "56cd379d34a3e7f93f341c1014daa9b3a9146606a68d4720d4513d09e35d73b6"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "af256521c76442437e0a7446b276561e3b33e80e67c6f95afd3c73ff413c04ef", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "2395ed566545d8ca65f71af24c9a298e48de6393b352471120a16b8c8d94b583", "task_id": "ncb21-task-d48e7b728a9c92fa"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-dc2d5ad4964bca96", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-f47961119663c100", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c", "ADHD200_DISC": "2ed4e2ddb4d8a3845dbec23c0b31652d26fdefe209e61fc4cdd3b636ebabb4fd"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "b7f14eacb65c3f59235c6b3b2c964e1927d6bf28ca720596c3247e1c08b77293", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 76, "multiverse": true, "pattern_corr": false, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication, pattern_corr; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; pattern_corr=-0.833; dice=0.000; region_replication_fraction=0.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "22844c48985424a8e1d4d2dfa693e634a372ebb5fc4f5829942d3a9fa3782bfb", "task_id": "ncb21-task-d568db2d613cee3b"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-87f4857ed96a6164", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-0b7ae9196627a80f", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_hcp_s2_DISC": "9ca08723fb6e33d21b54dbe19d61b0a8d93345c133e544d6c571ab3c459a5a99", "neg_p_fishing_hcp_s2_REP": "a65d7da6ebeca01f817c08b557a8d28c5b54c8519adeffa7edd3f365ded2ac02"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_hcp_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_hcp_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "7d01ce2b8cdc6b1e6a783e6a72f506e6c5488bdb9859d9ec446313e7e66745f8", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 24, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "71c5cad6d6c370e409a61d4a59b59df4105eb37a1ffdc16a1b4bf781d126cc17", "task_id": "ncb21-task-d5c1caf35e15bcda"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-8366c91b96faf9a6", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-7d451eccd542bdd9", "cohort_content_hashes": {"BSNIP2_REP": "5a68458b6ca1d3ceb62243f2dcf1fda0209a9d2685669530b7e4c5f279a32f23", "COBRE_DISC": "f53b3405d06487a9d268b89165605cc0ed60d2c3a68e41f8ebe73660d9916d79", "COBRE_REP": "4a81a6fb00f3834982866da08d40f58816c7907a2c62838ae1fad68fd5bb18dc", "ChineseSZ_REP": "9c94c02e8066411af69f22387e526434c8c412c6df30ff250b1c7bc75f5514a8", "FBIRN_REP": "132788e0b0576e4f01ac0ac8dcbb232f2f105aea4693833ef74a59a45118b33a", "Olin_SZ_REP": "d7bef7b3dc92844bbfc9976c601ed84734ccd0a9b19af3571dddda43dc156167"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/Olin_SZ_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "87a42e5a3fab23f0bc773212316f9575931b6bf707a8cec42c48bb91d9f19c96", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "under_powered", "rationale": "Failed gates: power, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.790 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "under_powered", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "659ea7ad9ba7f62439ef8e86191f6778cbb7d321911b890bdb9471ad445606b1", "task_id": "ncb21-task-d67cf80918a225ab"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-92410531cc87b1c8", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-0fdb2b2d01e4d450", "cohort_content_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "a3e6f1609ea823c9216310eaea1cf3e54443ed385d8f2c4ccb0374907756646b", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "4cc03f072ec07c42f4ceaa18a43bd2065e0d5c508c7d70b6115b8ccc60ee1062"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-d6b1b16213b3ab67/NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-d6b1b16213b3ab67/NACC_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "92535e6e9bc72323ab95a7be317487836613d421cf0cb65f4d451695da216d4a", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 3101, "p": 0.9282528264867886, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "ncb_random_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "3c1bd38bb61dfffdfe92ea9b79ff57adde73239449107d88342f3bfcb9c5b8aa", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "1fc420e4cf95c1ce31acbc96bf8a18661269ac2e8dbb961a03dde890cd8a32a3"}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "09cff1522ac26ddc539ac7693c328d0b0150322a6697d2a3c7081d0d69642269", "task_id": "ncb21-task-d6b1b16213b3ab67"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-d39f4693f159c73e", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-58d09422c76d9229", "cohort_content_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "a3e6f1609ea823c9216310eaea1cf3e54443ed385d8f2c4ccb0374907756646b", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "4cc03f072ec07c42f4ceaa18a43bd2065e0d5c508c7d70b6115b8ccc60ee1062"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "80898a4d5977efa22b2716b3107e927e9792c7157da2918e7b4a426934c7013f", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 1964, "p": 4.750055361533447e-83, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 1964, "p": 4.750055361533447e-83, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "fcc8623bf5e7ddbfaf4da2704a4d9b588f879d7d1b96f366a01d1fbdc37574c6", "task_id": "ncb21-task-d6c9a759926dec82"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-bdd01753f9ebb90c", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-155d140605bd8bc3", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADHD200_DISC": "2ed4e2ddb4d8a3845dbec23c0b31652d26fdefe209e61fc4cdd3b636ebabb4fd", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "90ef658adee3e1457a0b40e382b928de2d1dc3bc06fab38e69a41aff624cf687", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "6a5b1f2575a51e2c684541f075db3ce8bbd5e2170ab55c990b14cdaeb83c18b4", "task_id": "ncb21-task-d6d1c76b3d01b0bd"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-f2d4eb788a04c639", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-a4ac4ae7b014d7b6", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_oasis3_fmri_s3_DISC": "6a3db07aae19736fceb28768bc2a4e132abccbeee3689bc74caf6873f3cff3eb", "neg_random_label_oasis3_fmri_s3_REP": "1b051c5a6b182ef8131a3ab67848bf61e8e26916b284b51b08a4c1572fa55b9b"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_oasis3_fmri_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_oasis3_fmri_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "00f8c6d9ec873926b8c7f0588507e21e9579f96a8a81006025152caafc06ccc8", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "37ea230c154f8a0926c7dbe0cf27c22f589b9661f6526de58f33110c069e9d1f", "task_id": "ncb21-task-d6f0e24e5f0cebe4"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-30f73b540a076be8", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-388e09fd3169851b", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "888e47c5c123781c10d5f0ad0435caffcb092c36df554a3c29731f2daaa24c16", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "50cd985705bd63caa344f5ac37799abee6d97df925efe8c1146032e2955cde5d", "task_id": "ncb21-task-d75464cda8ffebe3"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-675abad09b88a363", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-fa6890e0ff01551e", "cohort_content_hashes": {"BSNIP2_REP": "5a68458b6ca1d3ceb62243f2dcf1fda0209a9d2685669530b7e4c5f279a32f23", "ChineseSZ_REP": "9c94c02e8066411af69f22387e526434c8c412c6df30ff250b1c7bc75f5514a8", "Olin_SZ_REP": "d7bef7b3dc92844bbfc9976c601ed84734ccd0a9b19af3571dddda43dc156167"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/Olin_SZ_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "bfe7f024460602f31cc319a067f2ee92b703832181b1cf33db6f0ef5ff4ef7db", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "817f7d059bc1be0ad395ca76a5f174cdb03b9c7c6d9835dac750003116d29759", "task_id": "ncb21-task-d78aafebbd1fb7da"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-23f923def996294a", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-b00c6ae54933cd8c", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_adni_s2_DISC": "bd53e3a7aa3054e1763c5ff90c623d9e043b58b0fd22b1eb4ebd1b68ae96a57a", "neg_site_confound_adni_s2_REP": "6a8116793d91dd4124321b288b9d8efe7b041097c9c643c4d09c84d79388cca1"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_adni_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_adni_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "8e324c7a21e8ee13cd2544e372239075bb2656696be96da0351c5b84dc506fed", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 458, "p": 1.5737396889634738e-37, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 458, "p": 1.5737396889634738e-37, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "a01b944d0ad688c031a99d0ea1bc3951ba4d89d37a10f58199317d7954982fe6", "task_id": "ncb21-task-d7fedacd2b68dc17"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-3c97cab8cb18d560", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-79596e7b5c7fe4c8", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_underpowered_hcp_s1_DISC": "76360f289de1d40b0272586131bef81336bc02a5344108b2b29eb8a73f28193d", "neg_underpowered_hcp_s1_REP": "e32ea9de8a065902a2564aec527b6f0a4bf04fe08b5277db116d57ad5b8bcb9a"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_hcp_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_hcp_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "e5e583a9ce023ad0c8e53d786ead56c2045704c50dc5f0b53f3a5803c4149656", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse; power=0.476 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "3b0dbbed415246c029fd3637194c09996a91bf11232a3f5fdfda120803992dca", "task_id": "ncb21-task-d8702679eb180107"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-4eba4adfcf45c4c3", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-db9c788471165ea0", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_underpowered_abide2_s1_DISC": "9917bed338c65baabd5e2463ebc2334ef26f5060ac33eac68d0154071d58bde0", "neg_underpowered_abide2_s1_REP": "993bd5513577d170757d444f671dc184e2028f12e0d89c1b4b4bb7f9cf8d9896"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_abide2_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_abide2_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "16eaa8a8b2271f8512d3b0c18e1752ff11814c52444d5d0730b4c012fb6a03fb", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.313 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "9c6a67810a16b590fa06e5ba358909342db642ca8f2ec28deec9e5a7ef551045", "task_id": "ncb21-task-d90749bdc1a05f8c"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-68bd56b0483a236c", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-414ea2db73e27155", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "de92371fba1e89e2a38b6b1949f700e0b0d6cfe5c6560630dd297ea0da43948b", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "986db932d366fac8092ee3be9565c9afa7203fc93b11080a1a138fc32725012b", "task_id": "ncb21-task-d9e401da71a4285e"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-31ff42faa1d10211", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-f8805e8aa7a25adc", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE1_HOLDOUT": "465b83b9275d056ca897367bc2b30907c1b32663d2fd4cdda4f87111fedb541c", "ABIDE1_REP": "d0a670f11f1c39a32e1e182cd1457b51acbec5518845795c26872642565c9f35"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ABIDE1_HOLDOUT.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ABIDE1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "8ba6e9d73008b08d0fdf857c3eab8118add7537262c878c5685056d4501af4cd", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "3eba9856d600d83f329ac501d602b051f6ec363e20f2212968bd63baeaf66084", "task_id": "ncb21-task-da20639354308cd3"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-f0173ff72ee52b5e", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-6a3555bac8205a71", "cohort_content_hashes": {"COBRE_DISC": "f53b3405d06487a9d268b89165605cc0ed60d2c3a68e41f8ebe73660d9916d79", "COBRE_REP": "4a81a6fb00f3834982866da08d40f58816c7907a2c62838ae1fad68fd5bb18dc"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_DISC.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "4bab631b5560f39c449125feb777a048fc4ed0c3ecb642cc21358474dfeec422", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.387 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "b234352b70c7a356d02be468633b044ed878cad05d6bb6621f7085ca383ae7d2", "task_id": "ncb21-task-da5e99ebb21436f6"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-3b7b2226aa3bb7ce", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-e72bb626cd82b669", "cohort_content_hashes": {"COBRE_DISC": "f53b3405d06487a9d268b89165605cc0ed60d2c3a68e41f8ebe73660d9916d79", "COBRE_REP": "4a81a6fb00f3834982866da08d40f58816c7907a2c62838ae1fad68fd5bb18dc"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "b2bb92c82f4793179bbd8d7dcee83bf665fb08f8817319d4a527125dcd7367e2", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "under_powered", "rationale": "Failed gates: power, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.790 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "under_powered", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "649db52cb81c53054ada23547a38200318f5e4ced5ad3a62127f3df07050fc85", "task_id": "ncb21-task-dab97b669594593b"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-9448893bb6c6800c", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-cf3de7630e790239", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_DISC": "7f42f7518c34775c8e5cf7c590a1fe44f226f40a7b899e71223b56ef43411663", "ADNI_REP": "56cd379d34a3e7f93f341c1014daa9b3a9146606a68d4720d4513d09e35d73b6"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "e030308a25f64c01123563ae7366d4786e7f9418ec434166fb49b5cfe6cec643", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "1d2d3314f09a34ffa9faa495d8cca01ac55615dee43ddd297f670351870238e0", "task_id": "ncb21-task-db30f2576a9c715b"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-58a996a383e72e5b", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-6a884cc98a008297", "cohort_content_hashes": {"FBIRN_DISC": "5a9a103412824c97ff34a4b7c9107198e9309be14f345c917761eb11adcdbd82", "FBIRN_REP": "132788e0b0576e4f01ac0ac8dcbb232f2f105aea4693833ef74a59a45118b33a"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "8607d1ffc8b81fde88271b78ebebebc5632e61056e823510b5722e5b5d7bffd2", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "f9792b810d8ca96b98ab30e8c9ab9413ff0245246296beb8d95bed7404b5660c", "task_id": "ncb21-task-db5dda410f80460c"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-f377cad3c090b549", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-53afa852706c0b07", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_gsp_s3_DISC": "2fe2d8d105ff3903370b862febc74649e86992c8922f7789c932cc0e17853cb6", "neg_p_fishing_gsp_s3_REP": "830d64a0080776bd26822a8cd02a955a66cf787b1c859c4550fc903759cecc0e"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_gsp_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_gsp_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "e7238d524b3c8c5fcfa2f08cf7c49d2983afec3977a66623ce24973338a47981", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 4, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "60e72932ca99ee4781ef7b11f937355b09859a6c010751e85a09bf2a916004f0", "task_id": "ncb21-task-dc3d5365c09012cb"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-d0535a6cab6d913b", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-fc1b23b1f4e82604", "cohort_content_hashes": {"COBRE_DISC": "f53b3405d06487a9d268b89165605cc0ed60d2c3a68e41f8ebe73660d9916d79", "COBRE_REP": "4a81a6fb00f3834982866da08d40f58816c7907a2c62838ae1fad68fd5bb18dc"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "4136730d35441c166e0955a3ca24a6e2675af5f2b47dcc3a692e57fe615b7289", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "under_powered", "rationale": "Failed gates: power, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.790 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "under_powered", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "6cb103cf0d89905f7ee2d8a98aa209c9fb23fd7ccd2a4c33b661b2a6e44b0661", "task_id": "ncb21-task-dc81572c10516fb6"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-7e9f95804251f0a0", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-6183f51b32053a22", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_fbirn_s1_DISC": "3d22f2950ddb0b61a24c81240fe109f8db9e022da0f1e0ded80b869fdba0365c", "neg_random_label_fbirn_s1_REP": "33a12966d4c709292c34201bcdf6cc980b6ed968f7b12d1a22c04c42d45950c6"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_fbirn_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_fbirn_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "ee5d57c22fbf5cfb43a3eb71ee01f30462bd3d4201b85e88f427935ce10eb1a7", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.703 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "d44d1bdc262d4ddd3f761cf742878375da4e2701a7129700a79772e0f8115bfc", "task_id": "ncb21-task-dd16dde7c8365cc9"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-65466f9b282b22be", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-3f38a4ee78fb15dc", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "913e8e4289ef4394cedad3706188fead3ad1487d0bb8611ba30ae70b0cbcaef8", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "65856407ff84ecc3a82d397603f9d8c2c53cd924f7e6d55f2f4ae0b447326554", "task_id": "ncb21-task-dd6c4a9f13fbc09a"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-e99377ceac8e5d23", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-d753f3be1731cbe2", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_underpowered_adni_fmri_s1_DISC": "c74d520ba8a184664e13548a60a62ec9173fde72acbb693c7df53a27d2589cca", "neg_underpowered_adni_fmri_s1_REP": "6c8468b79a471d996694b36b29d8defcdf7ce7aa605337ae2eab862d258dc02f"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_adni_fmri_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_adni_fmri_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "33a3140ba322d83eebb196917e96c04fba904314d8f481eb20d14ccc01c14437", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.466 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "29304a9d29cd67df072702f7b8dc1ebe6e3a5f7cf96a9b78912d42e2d27dbab4", "task_id": "ncb21-task-dd853e4252a15e24"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-693510493058a91a", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-d5260e81c6775a09", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c", "ADNI_fMRI_REP": "77b228db80400e42457cdc1a715f338fa645e8901922ef5f6f7c7f7d3d176c13"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_fMRI_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "73635814357978833df50d8cdfc90775bfb17086d772f7240ec0b6f24a006391", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.664 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "2e901a2e0c753933270d355d5e9ca95622faca6e9d3241ef84cbdabc49fc5726", "task_id": "ncb21-task-ddff0dc3276c59c9"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-81b80b20688f3f90", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-260333890e7bbc40", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_underpowered_ukb_s3_DISC": "515719cf394646628e48c7ee7bf15662acb6eee213ed715a619c6e2d6225e39f", "neg_underpowered_ukb_s3_REP": "9c4fab0a90a47936bf561fbdabb3be207ca1462b2d9b967356846144b54c8ed6"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_ukb_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_ukb_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "de4b0021d0d671ce4bf3f3d1f3797751cc5c17ceca69a9f7ba2edf90881a860c", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.548 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "8b91e481d5123f19b39694a4b27f87cd51dd7afe33c8805dc967c5889ae40bf8", "task_id": "ncb21-task-de44a8cd4710f073"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-55b455d152ed1390", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-6db08749711fcee8", "cohort_content_hashes": {"BSNIP2_DISC": "f60b826114673b4f649dd9e41e9f01b5d76fe3fdff3fb17ac3d13f3472068df0", "BSNIP2_REP": "5a68458b6ca1d3ceb62243f2dcf1fda0209a9d2685669530b7e4c5f279a32f23", "COBRE_REP": "4a81a6fb00f3834982866da08d40f58816c7907a2c62838ae1fad68fd5bb18dc", "ChineseSZ_REP": "9c94c02e8066411af69f22387e526434c8c412c6df30ff250b1c7bc75f5514a8", "FBIRN_REP": "132788e0b0576e4f01ac0ac8dcbb232f2f105aea4693833ef74a59a45118b33a"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "a59a4e2c6a2aabd4dfddbb622944ff8ba74fb612476cff4935413c2353df4a8a", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 278, "p": 0.3656917740160851, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "4fff581ad836376d7fea519b38d31083c73a924942143d84e51593267284419c", "task_id": "ncb21-task-de909dfff55dd68a"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-22ebf702279a5672", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-91fd4a5a09063781", "cohort_content_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "a3e6f1609ea823c9216310eaea1cf3e54443ed385d8f2c4ccb0374907756646b", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "4cc03f072ec07c42f4ceaa18a43bd2065e0d5c508c7d70b6115b8ccc60ee1062"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-dfdd80f59231cac5/NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-dfdd80f59231cac5/NACC_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "3f28f582a9471c161696775642ab94a3907489152395d9727fc71b572764ed22", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 3101, "p": 0.0307357460476848, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 3101, "p": 0.0307357460476848, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "ncb_random_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness, multiplicity, replication; confound_incomplete; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "534c4f1a974aa7294705a9e2d6dd6d948595f1017081c3ece4447247ce6f027c", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "6b67940d48d5e5198e88101e923aea17e1a57ca847392af1b0ee94e0a7b596a0"}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "34e19896fa2c9a182edb878feac63aa621d546f31cfaf4827755dc1e03d1c7ea", "task_id": "ncb21-task-dfdd80f59231cac5"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-aab29b1d1c0b92a5", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-ac0920843017098d", "cohort_content_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "a3e6f1609ea823c9216310eaea1cf3e54443ed385d8f2c4ccb0374907756646b", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "4cc03f072ec07c42f4ceaa18a43bd2065e0d5c508c7d70b6115b8ccc60ee1062"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "085ce9243284263c53f2e245f9686b61510173d99a409f7f03c8526df3751b2a", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 1964, "p": 4.750055361533447e-83, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 1964, "p": 4.750055361533447e-83, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness, multiplicity, multiverse, replication; confound_incomplete; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "2793eb111a1f9fc11aa65e09bba173f13d32a9583d08de703013070e288cea2b", "task_id": "ncb21-task-e0519f8d09ddd048"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-9bdffe881e48de4f", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-9486cbf60c92c277", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_oasis3_s1_DISC": "fcec29a2ed9eb0e204498ce32e0906a3904327f4a9bfc1a1e58f51eee9da8a91", "neg_site_confound_oasis3_s1_REP": "a4df8e0b5ee5b442ad4139d76dd006d92d1a3a67050eca6083bbe85724eac4ea"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_oasis3_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_oasis3_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "9bf03b487c348e7bc38d26e2b995e8710128f0ca45dfbda42e45bbd6e931bb47", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 329, "p": 1.7700709248161177e-27, "test": "chi_square"}, {"associated": false, "confound": "fs_version", "levels": 4, "n": 329, "p": 0.32298947462343386, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 329, "p": 1.7700709248161177e-27, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 2}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "0b11cb0c02c85ac6d386fc7c5ce180f054ed05e3f8f9e11751556451ec440af1", "task_id": "ncb21-task-e07863a54d775b83"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-add0ae4efa4206f4", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-fbe7a15487e9aff1", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "232132a84602d2e002eff364fa44085a7d831aca45cc3db13afd94a377e6b66e", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "e722d3550084f1d8aed04e44b0e6662f7a7d342b8abd67c8fc52eec91e78415f"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "cab8db3c48830a53efa3835a5af2f12df3925080aac99d919c1a6486a71f9de6", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "under_powered", "rationale": "Failed gates: power, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.530 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "under_powered", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "5ea7d03cd668137ad5172fe0cac20a102d082d5b26f0c1beb3b886d8929f6e1c", "task_id": "ncb21-task-e0f0cb06c3c5b230"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-f7956622f7e3eaf8", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-0d59eccdefa85be5", "cohort_content_hashes": {"OASIS3_fMRI_DISC": "7b701bee5bf1a2e4ded9c29c25ca16bc6ef6980169d9873326b362e29ecfa14d", "OASIS3_fMRI_REP": "b3ca261941658ec5a84c1f6f268e2261777e1bcd23bf28c7d2abe42d646aa786"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_fMRI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_fMRI_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "c233e291c6297b3fd3a35e54f5e1b7489755cf6d2200e8a470b28c459ef52739", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "80a1e3ea22e2452cb8493663236d8fd9debe9960c257faa0d7083c5f9a9ecb37", "task_id": "ncb21-task-e15a74e2e1f75001"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-cfe09363aec199e4", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-679fb694a4795559", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "58aea8eab1192ca67333a6a5f681998d382a824008381015bf3f5bb30ab9ce12", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "f39d72387a32601ed23a6bbb4fa598dae3e4813b72d6f76e2b77c37846ebeb33", "task_id": "ncb21-task-e1c38e33b7e80abc"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-23e29f207b2ce118", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-03ec59e9b4d63ea5", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c", "ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "e66602b5ddd648b9cf5dcfcf604fd3870633e4d8e38a904af1fe84c9948a46e7", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 84, "multiverse": false, "pattern_corr": false, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication, pattern_corr, region_replication_fraction; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; pattern_corr=-0.419; dice=1.000; region_replication_fraction=0.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "fbf9b7c05bedc0f1963d796859ef66899fd08ea1885ba038dc3cffbe493241c7", "task_id": "ncb21-task-e21152f351d0222a"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-55457edaa703fbe4", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-5d7bb99e17cc3700", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "6f61150c68fa5393b2686db7ae7e4967d9d5ba2783b9500974bb724e059c1317", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 84, "multiverse": false, "pattern_corr": false, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication, pattern_corr; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; pattern_corr=-0.461; dice=1.000; region_replication_fraction=0.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "249ce7601b2e2da73c560df90e77f9f6bd5d0bc12aaf6a1af8f2c6808e9d4c17", "task_id": "ncb21-task-e2843aea25f07618"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-67bed34632da1fbb", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-e65e487c1d515d8f", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "HCP_REP": "0cc8dc280e6a961585c8c2c53414db8d8cb581c59cf2beaef3e3731c5eca9eba"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "fc52cdacb7454596790531f76dbb00205189ea1410061a73bda3c5299aa3d945", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 84, "multiverse": true, "pattern_corr": false, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication, pattern_corr; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; pattern_corr=0.394; dice=0.457; region_replication_fraction=0.643"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "387d570de360366454b895d47d71911957bb47c9a65ffae2400582d6d090820e", "task_id": "ncb21-task-e2e0ded9afa86172"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-242d47d3594f6864", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-aac79f1a7de2792f", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_hcp_s2_DISC": "bccffde5f763144fa3e50a6f8bfcea21dd0b2bc293f8e9846a322abd2bfc6add", "neg_random_label_hcp_s2_REP": "b52e18cb5a6625b08e2f397abe90521f66ff8553ec02b5bd48c47d0c85b9ffc2"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_hcp_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_hcp_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "11acaa2df16aba5fec2a276add4e67d22a7385dd06f7688be159026daa1d2446", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "b9c002e19ef6214a446ebcb3bfbcec47272a91074b1c267cd61b49000457595f", "task_id": "ncb21-task-e2f0f08268be3fa0"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-548cb9ea8bd9f8de", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-bfa5dbc3c65bf21b", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "f22a4ddbb4538989f135643f4d32a444bef0e2b0bb4ce396af38947d3c05fc94", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "30cac6837d3e78094b8b461bd159e9cb0cf765ddd8cde57ca7aa6fbc08552df7", "task_id": "ncb21-task-e356e42f1f57342d"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-f58df52cceca9d39", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-a0fb1f0b36378b4d", "cohort_content_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "a3e6f1609ea823c9216310eaea1cf3e54443ed385d8f2c4ccb0374907756646b", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "4cc03f072ec07c42f4ceaa18a43bd2065e0d5c508c7d70b6115b8ccc60ee1062"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "2fa1110f32e74eecf1a82ddd4b6a3768c6011dc6fa38f28b5f849338f24ef8af", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 2312, "p": 2.5853903676145945e-55, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 2312, "p": 2.5853903676145945e-55, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness, multiplicity, multiverse, replication; confound_incomplete; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "450451921ccbec66353c79989e663cf3cd23bc36328b259019300556e684796a", "task_id": "ncb21-task-e3df98fc3f59953d"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-23b8d8c0265298fd", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-d0103cdfbca77685", "cohort_content_hashes": {"BSNIP2_DISC": "f60b826114673b4f649dd9e41e9f01b5d76fe3fdff3fb17ac3d13f3472068df0", "BSNIP2_REP": "5a68458b6ca1d3ceb62243f2dcf1fda0209a9d2685669530b7e4c5f279a32f23"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "54f0dd2a2c2b6923d5a74987d1eeac3c34f2b18ecd86ba5967369cb086ee42a1", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 278, "p": 0.3656917740160851, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "4e1a2db5231fa97eefee1a0582e9fb81eee6ef2a760627b8aca07b5655ce1215", "task_id": "ncb21-task-e410009c1d1936d2"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-c20a3d5f8e9e123f", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-523b397ff922e48f", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_fbirn_s2_DISC": "60b07cf6a7787b61697a740d2087044384ab0646bcbd14db832c942496f68196", "neg_random_label_fbirn_s2_REP": "d2d5c7bd6d5209ae0604970ab1aca4cb6c01832b13f8e8bfc75707c2d9031c1e"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_fbirn_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_fbirn_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "de3d3a84d492c1dd6d8cfdb2d87790f3235c7566517a35027f6b0f6faf462a49", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.703 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "ebb2186773123eeace3817fc127ebb4c5ac704c15cce6906abf1c3fac224e09e", "task_id": "ncb21-task-e59d10d789ffaf66"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-7cb3fe4a5738fae5", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-86798993c3cd6440", "cohort_content_hashes": {"BSNIP2_DISC": "f60b826114673b4f649dd9e41e9f01b5d76fe3fdff3fb17ac3d13f3472068df0", "BSNIP2_REP": "5a68458b6ca1d3ceb62243f2dcf1fda0209a9d2685669530b7e4c5f279a32f23"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "36a192b82b34ae2c58363ba2f9356aa4ac7e60dbfbf733c1d5fa86daf491d8c0", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 278, "p": 0.3656917740160851, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "cce6391ab44d4fdfc9435b89e9515018b45c4ce1cce4eb9d0f7d4d80944179e8", "task_id": "ncb21-task-e64e38fc45ab30a8"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-2ddc5b5c1ef8b93a", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-c15270b77671b377", "cohort_content_hashes": {"UKB_DISC": "8f50d0d10f4265b3538407235a0af91a7bb4d1a733daea42a655d4931e0bfdd3", "UKB_REP": "6da6a67cb610290a28f97b077dd2aa0e82c39161e4b3c622857cb54843df2357"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/UKB_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/UKB_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "8b79ff6464cc230bffd127c3d407d3c5fbe162b2a5db08d10e1307a0b400ebb2", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "785cece6ab2f9b75da7c4a26bc37e4bf9679032224689780630183d0e075be0e", "task_id": "ncb21-task-e69cb146fb7350c6"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-ba299f6826289883", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-b44a0438179b3e5f", "cohort_content_hashes": {"COBRE_DISC": "f53b3405d06487a9d268b89165605cc0ed60d2c3a68e41f8ebe73660d9916d79", "FBIRN_REP": "132788e0b0576e4f01ac0ac8dcbb232f2f105aea4693833ef74a59a45118b33a"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "ff6501d6338547d52a15f428e65a010d88809eb0e842a273d4b013c74aa0a6a7", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "under_powered", "rationale": "Failed gates: power, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.790 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "under_powered", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "f1fe4397bdb788c9d17ed219b1825f0a1118945a7eed0dcf21eec5bacd90dfc2", "task_id": "ncb21-task-e74a3902d3daab80"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-4d6f32ae88b34ae5", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-4f73b9fb9795d736", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_abcd_s3_DISC": "b5ce815122508bae5b1b68126d4e336d1b66f1f800e06a53ba2bf68038c1b73e", "neg_p_fishing_abcd_s3_REP": "3e7011bbb19eae92d29a791943c047180e6ac0c5b228638ede4245604fda2f38"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_abcd_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_abcd_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "f4a49e1111429b9425e7d48dfc184d49aafa7d0ba97d850a130db568be84af25", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 24, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "895da9d2943c97da083bec60b4acea189c4a310d50c1d1956857c8f2eea83b9d", "task_id": "ncb21-task-e8250a543d95d863"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-0b054fd85acaa063", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-386d8c898d91864d", "cohort_content_hashes": {"OASIS3_fMRI_DISC": "7b701bee5bf1a2e4ded9c29c25ca16bc6ef6980169d9873326b362e29ecfa14d", "OASIS3_fMRI_REP": "b3ca261941658ec5a84c1f6f268e2261777e1bcd23bf28c7d2abe42d646aa786"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_fMRI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_fMRI_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "bd8d44503319f53955a174f2d88209d388da9e3d55697e298964eee25cffc4c0", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "e3a86b7cf70b67779de00f00684e5c2e8f23bfb51cc9575a7d670031ac2b60ff", "task_id": "ncb21-task-e84b490f18a61545"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-73e0f34188f4c613", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-9f1a46763f5234b1", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "0baeb76cfd3be24056865d21f1f4fc5537b8931927ffbf302b35b55658b27133", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "766aca4ce378ae9615346c75ef624bc3340b265836498fb96a4be783b26e9642", "task_id": "ncb21-task-ea4e6d849b7d65c6"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-6689cbe59e004145", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-9f0c4b1706941e0d", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_site_confound_gsp_s2_DISC": "6cabeef7b5cd82eb592b1883459a46ef06b29b2ed3ce603b730d9dda553eedf2", "neg_site_confound_gsp_s2_REP": "e359668555cc65b85065b3695c0ea82dd4c483576255708e106203ab0473e2b4"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_gsp_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_site_confound_gsp_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "2c5a075500b8933c44f3f64c51fcec2057ea9e326b5ab5de0a110b96e53f6419", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 393, "p": 6.1120623586851636e-33, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 2, "n": 393, "p": 6.1120623586851636e-33, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "23af11fb02c2b824cbbdd01dad726dc30a4148454eb9ff1ff80ca6a5fa029e29", "task_id": "ncb21-task-ead294555cf30b1c"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-a1da46d7f5fa792d", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-4cf7e03829da4740", "cohort_content_hashes": {"BSNIP2_DISC": "f60b826114673b4f649dd9e41e9f01b5d76fe3fdff3fb17ac3d13f3472068df0", "COBRE_DISC": "f53b3405d06487a9d268b89165605cc0ed60d2c3a68e41f8ebe73660d9916d79", "ChineseSZ_DISC": "25886d87d5dc1da53df39d984bfa54f68aa99adbbbcb75b7d4826c4d8bdaff73", "FBIRN_DISC": "5a9a103412824c97ff34a4b7c9107198e9309be14f345c917761eb11adcdbd82"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_DISC.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "3226c5d0463e9ea6f9477a4b5c85266cafbafabcbd15d0579646b7e977e36f0e", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "4e5cbcb4fa91321932d8118cb1803f20fdf957486edd96d1efc03717c21eeaf1", "task_id": "ncb21-task-eb68dfa2754f1db6"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-58864dfe748ed623", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-a0b57b939e4e24a7", "cohort_content_hashes": {"BSNIP2_DISC": "f60b826114673b4f649dd9e41e9f01b5d76fe3fdff3fb17ac3d13f3472068df0", "BSNIP2_REP": "5a68458b6ca1d3ceb62243f2dcf1fda0209a9d2685669530b7e4c5f279a32f23"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_DISC.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "002c60aa698c564a1b4ab93e3bd8497aabff9a5576839d0a086e8af350982054", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "6aa5118120680e136e07e64ed8e0685c99f7368e4c9661fce03f094d084e45cb", "task_id": "ncb21-task-eba5de2aec72a501"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-c865d685dc0a2c5f", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-60beea1a930a7f70", "cohort_content_hashes": {"OASIS3_DISC": "8a048aaff562775d7c80f7027c9d8bb56cc738b7563d25ca06af7cb33df89d31", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "59f52c76a86ca697cdc95868bcc03ab3c714bdc36de19fd54f89a5e22db58377", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "fs_version", "levels": 4, "n": 780, "p": 0.07356894195085882, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "b77aba465b27ef623222eb7c1c64d5c97b053e3896639c7362a8f3e18acb25e7", "task_id": "ncb21-task-ed121570c699b6ea"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-192c0c6505c9c7e0", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-5497c2cc04ec78dc", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "232132a84602d2e002eff364fa44085a7d831aca45cc3db13afd94a377e6b66e", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "e722d3550084f1d8aed04e44b0e6662f7a7d342b8abd67c8fc52eec91e78415f"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-edd1f42c4a9fd59f/ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/neuroclaimbench-v2.1/results/.work/ncb21-task-edd1f42c4a9fd59f/ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "d62e0f08683d8b309274c4d14691286621795b1175b55604d9c70186128e215a", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "ncb_random_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "5c9f3074cb7dc94dcb1c120db593d60d8261fc0195f29a9841d460b71c1dcc01", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "cec512bccbe0ebad0d73bbf7686f06d489d773b06fcaa45ecbb9df3a25a6934e"}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "2c9baae64fb067b358f2746918b0037b9a921314253044b88d063ae0025cac0d", "task_id": "ncb21-task-edd1f42c4a9fd59f"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-d85043ecf72b62d3", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-c185892f3b36bd4e", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_adhd200_s1_DISC": "78d79b623e70b477a7cdc77ad907f4dd083920a78e82ffecd351a7a388c95449", "neg_random_label_adhd200_s1_REP": "b00b5181cf82877343ff9b1e63c47b922ac4ecb8549552c566200649161db262"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_adhd200_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_adhd200_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "93f4218c0358e7ab3e0f04fc627ed8830e47cd5d598f1c8b9c370aea1310da3b", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "61e0d488fef70f8caaa457f6db938481ffffc9c17d49f3f8e5fdc76f61397315", "task_id": "ncb21-task-ee2760f14f38b8df"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-88422a822641e7cd", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-8ec6bb87ee8d6697", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "a708d3a550c50b49402369b4a4b75e6c4fd83cd18b34335387405b0075daf224", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 84, "multiverse": false, "pattern_corr": false, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication, pattern_corr; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; pattern_corr=-0.461; dice=1.000; region_replication_fraction=0.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "d1832de2a1fa862f8b3e5ded14a69b8b13d0a0e89dd501cd08f6496cc3b324d8", "task_id": "ncb21-task-ef11da7859dbdd5a"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-561d93190dd22ced", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-20fec8cf8f96b7ca", "cohort_content_hashes": {"BSNIP2_REP": "5a68458b6ca1d3ceb62243f2dcf1fda0209a9d2685669530b7e4c5f279a32f23", "ChineseSZ_REP": "9c94c02e8066411af69f22387e526434c8c412c6df30ff250b1c7bc75f5514a8", "FBIRN_REP": "132788e0b0576e4f01ac0ac8dcbb232f2f105aea4693833ef74a59a45118b33a", "Olin_SZ_REP": "d7bef7b3dc92844bbfc9976c601ed84734ccd0a9b19af3571dddda43dc156167"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/Olin_SZ_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "57d8c51ba390b1d8bb7f5d625da433f9c85637611a3e2b13cbb2c32af41c712b", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.605 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "e2b71a15ae906828c35e548b86b52555c62cd50206bc541029355eeee8f946f5", "task_id": "ncb21-task-f04b585ffdb4ed1b"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-43acbd197355fcc4", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-71b54624f54c5845", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_adni_fmri_s3_DISC": "f64cf1092b0d2488c5fbc74b5f1833d5338e9780cc11b8b1991c8a00566e3b33", "neg_p_fishing_adni_fmri_s3_REP": "1d1eea691c17209fbb3d7a6ca2d4cdd9d8e37f006fe157718227161f1e840443"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_adni_fmri_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_adni_fmri_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "03da9c6bebb7d6cf13a9f1d2fd27bb1b1b4616e3fae6f399ace2206638306662", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 24, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "20d6b76bf7aab168e2901c3e9c1061a9979e960194bc92b77eb21b6bfab16fec", "task_id": "ncb21-task-f0d40c8f701159f4"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-8014ff72ff0a06a0", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-ffc74cde2a9e2ad1", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ChineseSZ_DISC": "25886d87d5dc1da53df39d984bfa54f68aa99adbbbcb75b7d4826c4d8bdaff73", "ChineseSZ_REP": "9c94c02e8066411af69f22387e526434c8c412c6df30ff250b1c7bc75f5514a8"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "210999ad5b2c23cc5d2066b7f82f853afe3ff88f945d5706bb82f7a36a71d380", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "ae4b8380e13bd6843d36e17183d6fb3d2fa65bf2837127933c3858030d773eb9", "task_id": "ncb21-task-f1b4943c48b52530"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-6efee680423ceb0a", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-26013675bfd8d20a", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_adni_s3_DISC": "edffe81c2fe551492eb060daade15470fe99490b910f45c6ab8097e34ae9babb", "neg_random_label_adni_s3_REP": "f8634bb36a9d8f52b32c5ace904406a4c9aa4ae1c4c08c9c5430827703939e16"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_adni_s3_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_adni_s3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "13b3771d5d1343d3482d0895f8903009191d13ea47a3bce89c6ee1ce14b6685d", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "9e313554eb98d5251eef34f0b897edc688e270c1702cd335b02cf89917807267", "task_id": "ncb21-task-f1cb32462976ec67"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-fa88cbf43e33f82f", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-ddf93ab1b5bfae8b", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADHD200_DISC": "2ed4e2ddb4d8a3845dbec23c0b31652d26fdefe209e61fc4cdd3b636ebabb4fd", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "877e0f2cce2886c3502f82cf11b673b06910762a9165be7218c31b28fe242d2e", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "5544064234fe6a78e4454972a940139e67e949fc3c72b1e0637f75325000e45c", "task_id": "ncb21-task-f2e2f0b7031285ab"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-06e24b7117348843", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-99d1a2b31a9994e4", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "4f622b026736cc3fc501e3c82bfa6c12d3c44bd621586aeab2850e96c7588652", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "198a16aa1b3192f709feaf48c9d3bed61b42e982e8831906b21a2d538c3eba33", "task_id": "ncb21-task-f47f4ac6f0d026ab"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-19802d4080b79f2e", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-b332319263998a2e", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "1d445b2269aecb951b862481c73771e1c8490e9ae437970e20e4b33cb65c29c4", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "99aedb7ce2dacf57cbe7b77f4729813c0d21640cb8d1c4137f50081864c7030e", "task_id": "ncb21-task-f521adcc4c6f9c05"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-704522685c487d81", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-3b56eea1c626193f", "cohort_content_hashes": {"HCP_DISC": "4bfd66afa7e3af1ad63ed1a3d1fdc1662e370064e97e927de95b8f783b7886a8", "HCP_REP": "0cc8dc280e6a961585c8c2c53414db8d8cb581c59cf2beaef3e3731c5eca9eba"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "241939a194271dbceb7f7250718eff3036ce7751edbc84509926af5c56c8ea69", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "phen_fluid_composite", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "56b9aa1883b740b8b88fd5142f71c69024134294380238cb37ff34559dba7d59", "task_id": "ncb21-task-f55b77723d0aed8e"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-a545812912502796", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-9a9d6d513fbd08ff", "cohort_content_hashes": {"OASIS3_fMRI_DISC": "7b701bee5bf1a2e4ded9c29c25ca16bc6ef6980169d9873326b362e29ecfa14d", "OASIS3_fMRI_REP": "b3ca261941658ec5a84c1f6f268e2261777e1bcd23bf28c7d2abe42d646aa786"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_fMRI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_fMRI_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "2775e34865d4bf476963d96a0be70cdd014bc4c80cb96e7c8087a807b19aeb0e", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "de0f5d72353e7fd1f37dd8b18932888527ab600fb1fa8214d8e4da3e7d100731", "task_id": "ncb21-task-f605692c83792681"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-edbf888496455e86", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-eb434213d4219238", "cohort_content_hashes": {"HCP_Aging_DISC": "47082908a7b0b17d0b8a006028dff9d08a56af3f8c6e8d08627ca3818f85a4fd", "HCP_REP": "0cc8dc280e6a961585c8c2c53414db8d8cb581c59cf2beaef3e3731c5eca9eba"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_Aging_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "f2f30cbae7df5fb348d767045bab7cebb6045a7911c7ceb2445d891193e4368d", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": false, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 84, "multiverse": true, "pattern_corr": false, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication, pattern_corr, region_replication_fraction, dice; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; pattern_corr=-0.141; dice=0.000; region_replication_fraction=0.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "97084bcfd7ffac50f4ec8b972b745facbe7c0a32e0e9437c40dd8a41c9516883", "task_id": "ncb21-task-f6c946fca489fd62"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-1775e0699f7d950f", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-ed1f0f9e3e7ca067", "cohort_content_hashes": {"OASIS3_DISC": "8a048aaff562775d7c80f7027c9d8bb56cc738b7563d25ca06af7cb33df89d31", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "39533793f0b29433454c65b1c160e913b77de67e76079877e693bb2a06130543", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "fs_version", "levels": 4, "n": 576, "p": 0.00014048948470919836, "test": "anova"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "fs_version", "levels": 4, "n": 576, "p": 0.00014048948470919836, "test": "anova"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "age", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "3d00508077db04136ed52dc6dc1b99720d5050b4d42ee9b1d172a51acd9c9687", "task_id": "ncb21-task-f6d996a2ba79a086"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-cb1ea057a92edbc7", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-077e42b63ae31cb9", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_abcd_s2_DISC": "13c9fee738f91102d6114bf5d81b3704a7b576016e7f169c619becab80f31e61", "neg_p_fishing_abcd_s2_REP": "3ed8474cf0ff5de5ca2bd844410cdb738d04f3d158f971a91e819deb18f4a0a2"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_abcd_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_abcd_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "0ff162d1535174783f8abc7fa03eaf59eb87606fc578f8e121642a38c16c3ece", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 24, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "8f79bb238ac7dc1c004b4b8dc23f213055b820e2fceaa8c9ed89e62cbecf5746", "task_id": "ncb21-task-f75439cd0cc1cf1d"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-0efe8c9435d8ffdf", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-931f058111cf8b54", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c", "HCP_DISC": "4bfd66afa7e3af1ad63ed1a3d1fdc1662e370064e97e927de95b8f783b7886a8", "HCP_REP": "0cc8dc280e6a961585c8c2c53414db8d8cb581c59cf2beaef3e3731c5eca9eba"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/HCP_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "c0f251928472516239cd6e93f2c6dfc3929f7446dfe5a7e603263a4e9328812d", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "phen_fluid_composite", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "2b058f20b7439116102e8d568a90edc41187811d080a4933b21ef859652b31ce", "task_id": "ncb21-task-f77afb2c1b6beb4b"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-caeb5a6d248ba33c", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-f2e04f66cf546b8b", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "4d3d50bf45596590ba71b83eeedc3e53eab7bdcda078f06293b85334fe3564d0", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "327c038c354a1f9b87c3ca67746e6b2dc2d0b9e44c9b9e12b0bda300c9ae625e", "task_id": "ncb21-task-f78467ff31f5d941"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-f9b3b69c40a65738", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-d5a1af41c2373704", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_cobre_s2_DISC": "ded0579c062016fa1e6178ed3f8ab1ca39887c7553dddaa517e0278bb3abfac0", "neg_random_label_cobre_s2_REP": "f4c159def547f0ba6181c6e93cd3735e106c14f4282cea7d80cc12866af0ef5b"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_cobre_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_cobre_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "3e6eef0289edc98b5a97466b5f1b437154e8e87400e4442046435250115ee341", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.457 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "f71cd5c29fcdf3a0ed0e6f2a14ec855e2199835a7dbc1e2769af5ffffae45ad7", "task_id": "ncb21-task-f7cacd8521a955a0"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-5fb11c517888b8d9", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-06558d77f5e3c177", "cohort_content_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "a3e6f1609ea823c9216310eaea1cf3e54443ed385d8f2c4ccb0374907756646b", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "4cc03f072ec07c42f4ceaa18a43bd2065e0d5c508c7d70b6115b8ccc60ee1062"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "63bf2d3f3179f59faa738e6a4dafd3e6e56b7bf9ffda3a01507228c180e7b15c", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 2312, "p": 2.5853903676145945e-55, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 2312, "p": 2.5853903676145945e-55, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "f68ef3e6f832fd77bfc2ff87258d81d489ab49d8468fc6d0d4d99a0decc24a18", "task_id": "ncb21-task-f88153ab9343b73e"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-c823298f5f12df8a", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-aae60f404025f35f", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABIDE2_DISC": "8d4c8e9e44d4ff95a0c33407ff712892a8f11d59771435ba90a530d87bc2ed48", "ABIDE2_REP": "a640be99817a96cbd7826a0360d39665a626da64bba1da2b1ebcce24ed71310b"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABIDE2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "5859e4d1561fe1eeb2a11ae1c93eb8f1179bb5d6654acb31358835dc2bdff6e1", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "dc94f0cf4dd37dcd73532674d6d15aedd373a6af312ca19070fbc5773920a34c", "task_id": "ncb21-task-f881acc3dcf78298"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-eafa675a2857a0cb", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-a6d20abaaf4cad56", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "61ceabe80c13378856fbdf0785730e84c04dfb97634de3ac792c3b8522124199", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "ec26f192a1961c11eedd573f1c443cc7a11b10055c1f7f564decdc28bca63e96", "task_id": "ncb21-task-f88dd656c19b1fdc"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-6e7550292e8dbaff", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-f83e2bf5b18e5f14", "cohort_content_hashes": {"NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC": "a3e6f1609ea823c9216310eaea1cf3e54443ed385d8f2c4ccb0374907756646b", "NACC_EXTERNAL_REP": "4cc03f072ec07c42f4ceaa18a43bd2065e0d5c508c7d70b6115b8ccc60ee1062"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/NACC_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "5603d9965a88456a31c2a07d58003b7e528e74c502c7f466b63d00de2f7c2aeb", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 1964, "p": 4.750055361533447e-83, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "site", "levels": 13, "n": 1964, "p": 4.750055361533447e-83, "test": "chi_square"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness, multiplicity, multiverse, replication; confound_incomplete; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "b34b9b5ca5f992e7857f88e5bfdc33c0e796c9ebf72bbe1bda5d78e070897cce", "task_id": "ncb21-task-f8930ea35c0e7afa"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-9346832a3ea94fed", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-68608df2ef37a972", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_DISC": "7f42f7518c34775c8e5cf7c590a1fe44f226f40a7b899e71223b56ef43411663", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "8fcc3045e30e3d98e7baeb45c9f2ac36b3aab716b9f08aa4c686f459d2106ba5", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "direction_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "direction_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 95.75166483845662, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 95.75166483845662, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=direction_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=95.8"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "07ba11b9885263677416d6843147a8f92022987e9a3ba115aaff10802d28d02e", "task_id": "ncb21-task-f8c1d12a12345e3a"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-external-transfer-d9c2200f2c768244", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-ff53a9ee21c81fbe", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC": "232132a84602d2e002eff364fa44085a7d831aca45cc3db13afd94a377e6b66e", "ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP": "e722d3550084f1d8aed04e44b0e6662f7a7d342b8abd67c8fc52eec91e78415f"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/cohorts/ds000030_EXTERNAL_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "8c5cd6b4f955b0df83e38550a4cee0bc75dbb3468d7e629929c39fae39aa34d2", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_cohort_mismatch; power=0.512 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "86ae17004c6ae0014aa06f514b9978f4e518e684ce4fe7e82d375d5ec375728c", "task_id": "ncb21-task-f92f5f7269378e53"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-c8acae9508ef35fd", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-73b778cbf1fe39fa", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "ac3965c4e2fa549e41ed5f2b967431b57a6630ca2b96a1e2b3a3f9a2fd3065b9", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "dice": true, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 190, "multiverse": false, "pattern_corr": false, "power": true, "region_replication_fraction": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication, pattern_corr, region_replication_fraction; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; pattern_corr=-0.870; dice=1.000; region_replication_fraction=0.000"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "37ce2c20da7b7e886abea9a59c538830fd7249bc57f6fbc750b2247c25b06996", "task_id": "ncb21-task-f9773dc8fdf57d18"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-2724233ad72644a4", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-01885c9053d350cb", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_underpowered_abcd_s1_DISC": "03d93978fe0f3227ae4ade2418e88aca27088ca7ff426c7f8689660125c617fe", "neg_underpowered_abcd_s1_REP": "2ad5a81fb883b881e0cde277d8a6e6d28e9ca7add809f6676a08f116800e1986"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_abcd_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_underpowered_abcd_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "51a918e931e436c57d7bdac875f31d66a807c549941e1776fe9c1bfb20fa054b", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "sex", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.476 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "0deeda93b55b7717591ff7eb0a920c28097fc74617af6fac3e3419f0819e32d1", "task_id": "ncb21-task-f97fc234a7ca2e8f"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-2cdcd1655db50299", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-7021a18a1caf81f1", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_p_fishing_adhd200_s2_DISC": "92070e6f65d750e663460c31167b5a7f15e6bf362758b175ff11e17865499388", "neg_p_fishing_adhd200_s2_REP": "c2773779a8dda2a11b695e5fd659aff503d36026be56c6e06d653d211a60eaf5"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_adhd200_s2_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_p_fishing_adhd200_s2_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "45a6e0c4d182cceecc522385da318d19170ce53e173097469da3f149b45f65d3", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 24, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "1f0aaeded550414016d925cfaa08ff890c0834b174789c6af9afa070775595ba", "task_id": "ncb21-task-fb299b748b862fe9"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-1b8a8b0d4ec2f528", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-c9e8672ab930d287", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_DISC": "7f42f7518c34775c8e5cf7c590a1fe44f226f40a7b899e71223b56ef43411663", "ADNI_REP": "56cd379d34a3e7f93f341c1014daa9b3a9146606a68d4720d4513d09e35d73b6"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "d0d54f2ad6decc28ca47fe51c6df5523ea506db70da59f177fb1605dd520408e", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "6497d3b542e135630b19a54addefa2013e1a077efc39329e8c8d85e2f2255288", "task_id": "ncb21-task-fb4489244a478c3c"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-bf6a4a4dabf8357f", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-1770cf039de2dc4b", "cohort_content_hashes": {"OASIS3_DISC": "8a048aaff562775d7c80f7027c9d8bb56cc738b7563d25ca06af7cb33df89d31", "OASIS3_REP": "62d6a63ce9976382850394883432b7f2b5e3460979250545efcf3c8be093e3d0"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "cd8abb3d523078e0cfe4e201c1742ff706835c8ac202e1c8085824b2871947cc", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": false, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": true, "confound": "fs_version", "levels": 4, "n": 576, "p": 0.00014048948470919836, "test": "anova"}], "failures": [{"associated": true, "confound": "fs_version", "levels": 4, "n": 576, "p": 0.00014048948470919836, "test": "anova"}], "passed": false, "predictor": "age", "reason": "confound_incomplete", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "reason": "confound_incomplete", "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: confound_completeness; confound_incomplete"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "75e57cfe2ce33f1876fd3eb12cc16b8e4a8550b24d8fb1434b4462b061747565", "task_id": "ncb21-task-fb80325a3bdd78f7"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-e2967e8bdd4698b5", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-87bc20def0aa2677", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_adni_s1_DISC": "7b95292056d955736444872ba863040e7df7b3cd965121a94b0fdfbc391a5cad", "neg_random_label_adni_s1_REP": "5cd8b379d52abe9097e4ea7c154ce2929d697ee289ee0dd73fb453d4826edcad"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_adni_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_adni_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "2b97caa1b5abea217ab4ff73167def16f764840dabd29958cf1bdfed9c963615", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "1764963dfe759108cc3e1f7da3e28d312b045a355efa6ef9d030bd9c16b354ec", "task_id": "ncb21-task-fc50ef79bcc881c0"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-03136ab7c6bb7990", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-62c90f7dfce794b7", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ABCD_DISC": "4cbdd68c4e5d2551235f70923ba2c1e3186fa274facbefb7965eb4c01b79105c", "ABCD_REP": "96b7ad18b4986aa95be24a26957a984c72f01833b3dcd197f01a9c808d424d9c"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ABCD_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "147af10661001f5745e74c4a41faf9df34d738b80e2d44ab33cf6ac42446d94d", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "non_replicated", "rationale": "Failed gates: replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "non_replicated", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "40fc32c93ff669805f5280be9e71d9bd0737dd902ac5ae3e19264d5abc453827", "task_id": "ncb21-task-fd19e9541079da97"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-feb2bcefb03564db", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-e9d29af357a338d6", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_gsp_s1_DISC": "ad50738115dc32f8325d8dad53752f6537ff9b93477e251c9bce69494ce8ac08", "neg_random_label_gsp_s1_REP": "6dc51a29a19a13fae9ec1a70515407cb66313b0288f2fd3e8d38f0f773e0fb9d"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_gsp_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_gsp_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "7eb5787611db011dc85ca0d5cd480d90d640eeaeeff0c57d7d387d4ae87b0c32", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "1ab592b4d1ce5d06f3f018aa71710ffd0de8f1f100a330d077912e6b7c93d83c", "task_id": "ncb21-task-fd27030d97eff5a0"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-0cf9bf17a3cb10a7", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-99146eaaf47f8c8f", "cohort_content_hashes": {"OASIS3_fMRI_DISC": "7b701bee5bf1a2e4ded9c29c25ca16bc6ef6980169d9873326b362e29ecfa14d", "OASIS3_fMRI_REP": "b3ca261941658ec5a84c1f6f268e2261777e1bcd23bf28c7d2abe42d646aa786"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_fMRI_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/OASIS3_fMRI_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "e1eac9cec4547cfe00a9ea4975f37cf87b8e90c5bb607d43206c8184d8afdea1", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "age", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "6c8c0147d111715c44835b5be5cf044995d43c003a4522d44c166d9fe76284fe", "task_id": "ncb21-task-fd552b642761b2dd"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-a3f4263a0dce56cf", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-9b50e56728a038dd", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADNI_fMRI_REP": "77b228db80400e42457cdc1a715f338fa645e8901922ef5f6f7c7f7d3d176c13"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADNI_fMRI_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "71e012c5d772710b0359dd597c7da9410e77b3e6f39b75049a8f332440085ed0", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_cohort_mismatch:no_replication_data; power=0.750 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "e7f7d27e261e3de729b4e0eb9f6a1b9dcefc479e1712f6ae59d2141f673e780b", "task_id": "ncb21-task-fd6e517ddccfca52"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-23d61a93cc5dbec1", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-72e438e5dfeb4c03", "cohort_content_hashes": {"ADHD200_DISC": "2ed4e2ddb4d8a3845dbec23c0b31652d26fdefe209e61fc4cdd3b636ebabb4fd", "ADHD200_REP": "1fd15e9671bb90a6163ed83e0624771c3641cbc001580565f7bc73f8e79cd533"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_DISC.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ADHD200_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "confirmed", "detailed_result_sha256": "ddea54aa087905ca43fabf5b20592342330d05c91625806d6d1b90495e164fc1", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": false, "confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "gates": {"confirmation_subtype": "transportable_confirmed", "confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "multiplicity": true, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": true, "power": true, "replication": true, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": 0.0, "label": "confirmed", "rationale": "All gates passed.; confirmation_subtype=transportable_confirmed; heterogeneity_i2=0.0"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "confirmed", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "e55114c67d1658e9b74056f2481537bd1d334ea5040a917dbd8a93fa831086ea", "task_id": "ncb21-task-fd94e34ea1090527"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-scientific-622e97baf8eece3c", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-2779a2af4fbe7c5e", "cohort_content_hashes": {"BSNIP2_REP": "5a68458b6ca1d3ceb62243f2dcf1fda0209a9d2685669530b7e4c5f279a32f23", "COBRE_REP": "4a81a6fb00f3834982866da08d40f58816c7907a2c62838ae1fad68fd5bb18dc", "ChineseSZ_REP": "9c94c02e8066411af69f22387e526434c8c412c6df30ff250b1c7bc75f5514a8", "FBIRN_REP": "132788e0b0576e4f01ac0ac8dcbb232f2f105aea4693833ef74a59a45118b33a", "Olin_SZ_REP": "d7bef7b3dc92844bbfc9976c601ed84734ccd0a9b19af3571dddda43dc156167"}, "cohort_paths": ["data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/COBRE_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/BSNIP2_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/ChineseSZ_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/FBIRN_REP.parquet", "data/prepared_data/evidence_partitions/benchmark_ready/cohorts/Olin_SZ_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "d33326dc81b5834f4def5c32253aaab2e4f1171ab1658b9e37bc26c20eb442eb", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "confirm_dx", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 0}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": false, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, power, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent; power=0.387 vs MDE=0.3 effect=0.30, n_needed_80=89.1"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "05e5428319946f8b4ea66021722001341dfe06bc0c3af3edd58a7690e03fd766", "task_id": "ncb21-task-fee6640bb16b3dd4"}
{"benchmark_case_id": "ncb-synthetic-stress-577eca459126d08d", "benchmark_claim_id": "ncb-case-6e768da710aecb96", "cohort_content_hashes": {"neg_random_label_oasis3_s1_DISC": "bb993d1867dac434fb9542a1e5483f8bef1f2eb71635ad4b1ddbfaae2bbe4d31", "neg_random_label_oasis3_s1_REP": "2991a3c1f3aec0c77405f0322c3785918b001b1f3a225b73e384e4251c4af827"}, "cohort_paths": ["review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_oasis3_s1_DISC.parquet", "review-stage/claim-search-safety-gpt55-r10-c10-v7/data/cohorts/neg_random_label_oasis3_s1_REP.parquet"], "confirm_outcome": "abstained", "detailed_result_sha256": "1121103761e697543e3f76a1f1b4dcc04983db5ded1fbfbac012639bc05aeee7", "error": "", "gate_verdict": {"abstained": true, "confirmation_subtype": null, "gates": {"confound": true, "confound_completeness": true, "confound_completeness_audit": {"alpha": 0.05, "details": [{"associated": false, "confound": "fs_version", "levels": 4, "n": 329, "p": 0.4920771296721774, "test": "chi_square"}], "failures": [], "passed": true, "predictor": "bench_group", "reason": "passed", "tested_confound_count": 1}, "multiplicity": false, "multiplicity_effective_family_size": 1, "multiverse": false, "power": true, "replication": false, "search_provenance": true}, "heterogeneity_i2": null, "label": "fragile", "rationale": "Failed gates: multiplicity, multiverse, replication; replication=non_replicated_effect_absent"}, "generated_cohort_hashes": {}, "raw_final_label": "fragile", "result_source": "neuroclaimbench_v2.1_task_evaluation", "status": "completed", "task_fingerprint": "da6ac1ff5725ed87c3e74648831861cf72589a240ab3e7a27aa31bb6feabb054", "task_id": "ncb21-task-ffe27a6acf36c2a5"}