diff --git "a/leviathan.json" "b/leviathan.json" new file mode 100644--- /dev/null +++ "b/leviathan.json" @@ -0,0 +1,1386 @@ +{"text":"To My Most Honoured Friend Mr. Francis Godolphin, of Godolphin"} +{"text":"Honoured Sir,"} +{"text":"Your most worthy brother, Mr. Sidney Godolphin, when he lived, wa pleased to think my studies something, and otherwise to oblige me, a you know, with real testimonies of his good opinion, great i themselves, and the greater for the worthiness of his person. For ther is not any virtue that disposeth a man, either to the service of God o to the service of his country, to civil society or private friendship that did not manifestly appear in his conversation, not as acquired b necessity, or affected upon occasion, but inherent, and shining in generous constitution of his nature. Therefore, in honour and gratitud to him, and with devotion to yourself, I humbly dedicate unto you thi my Discourse of Commonwealth. I know not how the world will receive it nor how it may reflect on those that shall seem to favour it. For in way beset with those that contend, on one side for too great liberty and on the other side for too much authority, 'tis hard to pass betwee the points of both unwounded. But yet, methinks, the endeavour t advance the civil power, should not be by the civil power condemned nor private men, by reprehending it, declare they think that power to great. Besides, I speak not of the men, but, in the abstract, of th seat of power (like to those simple and unpartial creatures in th Roman Capitol, that with their noise defended those within it, no because they were they, but there), offending none, I think, but thos without, or such within, if there be any such, as favour them. Tha which perhaps may most offend, are certain texts of Holy Scripture alleged by me to other purpose than ordinarily they use to be b others. But I have done it with due submission, and also, in order t my subject, necessarily; for they are the outworks of the enemy, fro whence they impugn the civil power. If, notwithstanding this, you fin my labour generally decried, you may be pleased to excuse yourself, an say, I am a man that love my own opinions, and think all true I say that I honoured your brother, and honour you, and have presumed o that, to assume the title, without your knowledge, of being, as I am,"} +{"text":"Sir Your most humble, and most obedient servant Thomas Hobbes."} +{"text": Nature, the art whereby God hath made and governs the world, is by th \"art\" of man, as in many other things, so in this also imitated, tha it can make an artificial animal. For seeing life is but a motion o limbs, the beginning whereof is in some principal part within; why ma we not say, that all \"automata\" (engines that move themselves b springs and wheels as doth a watch) have an artificial life? For wha is the \"heart,\" but a \"spring\"; and the \"nerves,\" but so man \"strings\"; and the \"joints,\" but so many \"wheels,\" giving motion to th whole body, such as was intended by the artificer? \"Art\" goes ye further, imitating that rational and most excellent work of nature \"man.\" For by art is created that great \"Leviathan\" called \"Commonwealth,\" or \"State,\" in Latin Civitas, which is but a artificial man; though of greater stature and strength than th natural, for whose protection and defence it was intended; and in whic the \"sovereignty\" is an artificial \"soul,\" as giving life and motion t the whole body; the \"magistrates,\" and other \"officers\" of judicatur and execution, artificial \"joints\"; \"reward\" and \"punishment,\" by whic fastened to the seat of the sovereignty every joint and member is move to perform his duty, are the \"nerves,\" that do the same in the bod natural; the \"wealth\" and \"riches\" of all the particular members, ar the \"strength\"; salus populi, the \"people's safety,\" its \"business\" \"counsellors,\" by whom all things needful for it to know are suggeste unto it, are the \"memory\"; \"equity,\" and \"laws,\" an artificial \"reason\ and \"will\"; \"concord,\" \"health\"; \"sedition,\" \"sickness\"; and \"civi war,\" \"death.\" Lastly, the \"pacts\" and \"covenants,\" by which the part of this body politic were at first made, set together, and united resemble that \"fiat,\" or the \"let us make man,\" pronounced by God i the creation."} +{"text":"To describe the nature of this artificial man, I will consider�--"} +{"text":"First, the \"matter\" thereof, and the \"artificer\"; both which is \"man.\""} +{"text":"Secondly, \"how,\" and by what \"covenants\" it is made; what are th \"rights\" and just \"power\" or \"authority\" of a \"sovereign\"; and what i is that \"preserveth\" or \"dissolveth\" it."} +{"text":"Thirdly, what is a \"Christian commonwealth.\""} +{"text":"Lastly, what is the \"kingdom of darkness.\""} +{"text":"Concerning the first, there is a saying much usurped of late, tha \"wisdom\" is acquired, not by reading of \"books,\" but of \"men.\ Consequently whereunto, those persons, that for the most part can giv no other proof of being wise, take great delight to show what the think they have read in men, by uncharitable censures of one anothe behind their backs. But there is another saying not of late understood by which they might learn truly to read one another, if they would tak the pains; that is, \"nosce teipsum,\" \"read thyself\": which was no meant, as it is now used, to countenance, either the barbarous state o men in power, towards their inferiors; or to encourage men of lo degree, to a saucy behaviour towards their betters; but to teach us that for the similitude of the thoughts and passions of one man, to th thoughts and passions of another, whosoever looketh into himself, an considereth what he doth, when he does \"think,\" \"opine,\" \"reason,\ \"hope,\" \"fear,\" etc., and upon what grounds; he shall thereby read an know what are the thoughts and passions of all other men upon the lik occasions. I say the similitude of \"passions,\" which are the same i all men, \"desire,\" \"fear,\" \"hope,\" etc.; not the similitude of th \"objects\" of the passions, which are the things \"desired,\" \"feared,\ \"hoped,\" etc.: for these the constitution individual, and particula education, do so vary, and they are so easy to be kept from ou knowledge, that the characters of man's heart, blotted and confounde as they are with dissembling, lying, counterfeiting, and erroneou doctrines, are legible only to Him that searcheth hearts. And though b men's actions we do discover their design sometimes; yet to do i without comparing them with our own, and distinguishing al circumstances, by which the case may come to be altered, is to decyphe without a key, and be for the most part deceived, by too much trust, o by too much diffidence; as he that reads, is himself a good or evi man."} +{"text":"But let one man read another by his actions never so perfectly, i serves him only with his acquaintance, which are but few. He that is t govern a whole nation, must read in himself, not this or tha particular man; but mankind: which though it be hard to do, harder tha to learn any language or science; yet when I shall have set down my ow reading orderly, and perspicuously, the pains left another, will b only to consider, if he also find not the same in himself. For thi kind of doctrine admitteth no other demonstration."} +{"text":"Concerning the thoughts of man, I will consider them first singly, an afterwards in train, or dependence upon one another. Singly, they ar every one a \"representation\" or \"appearance\" of some quality, or othe accident of a body without us, which is commonly called an \"object.\ Which object worketh on the eyes, ears, and other parts of a man' body; and by diversity of working, produceth diversity of appearances."} +{"text":"The original of them all, is that which we call \"sense,\" for there i no conception in a man's mind, which hath not at first, totally or b parts, been begotten upon the organs of sense. The rest are derive from that original."} +{"text":"To know the natural cause of sense, is not very necessary to th business now in hand; and I have elsewhere written of the same a large. Nevertheless, to fill each part of my present method, I wil briefly deliver the same in this place."} +{"text":"The cause of sense, is the external body, or object, which presseth th organ proper to each sense, either immediately, as in the taste an touch; or mediately, as in seeing, hearing, and smelling; whic pressure, by the mediation of the nerves, and other strings an membranes of the body, continued inwards to the brain and heart causeth there a resistance, or counterpressure, or endeavour of th heart to deliver itself, which endeavour, because \"outward,\" seemeth t be some matter without. And this \"seeming,\" or \"fancy,\" is that whic men call \"sense\"; and consisteth, as to the eye, in a \"light,\" o \"colour figured\"; to the ear, in a \"sound\"; to the nostril, in a \"odour\"; to the tongue and palate, in a \"savour\"; and to the rest o the body, in \"heat,\" \"cold,\" \"hardness,\" \"softness,\" and such othe qualities as we discern by \"feeling.\" All which qualities calle \"sensible,\" are in the object, that causeth them, but so many severa motions of the matter, by which it presseth our organs diversely Neither in us that are pressed, are they anything else, but diver motions; for motion produceth nothing but motion. But their appearanc to us is fancy, the same waking, that dreaming. And as pressing rubbing, or striking the eye, makes us fancy a light; and pressing th ear, produceth a din; so do the bodies also we see, or hear, produc the same by their strong, though unobserved action. For if thos colours and sounds were in the bodies, or objects that cause them, the could not be severed from them, as by glasses, and in echoes b reflection, we see they are; where we know the thing we see is in on place, the appearance in another. And though at some certain distanc the real and very object seem invested with the fancy it begets in us yet still the object is one thing, the image or fancy is another. S that sense, in all cases, is nothing else but original fancy, caused as I have said, by the pressure, that is, by the motion, of externa things upon our eyes, ears, and other organs thereunto ordained."} +{"text":"But the philosophy schools, through all the universities o Christendom, grounded upon certain texts of Aristotle, teach anothe doctrine, and say, for the cause of \"vision,\" that the thing seen sendeth forth on every side a \"visible species,\" in English, a \"visibl show,\" \"apparition,\" or \"aspect,\" or \"a being seen\"; the receivin whereof into the eye, is \"seeing.\" And for the cause of \"hearing,\" tha the thing heard, sendeth forth an \"audible species,\" that is, a \"audible aspect,\" or \"audible being seen,\" which entering at the ear maketh \"hearing.\" Nay, for the cause of \"understanding\" also, they sa the thing understood, sendeth forth an \"intelligible species,\" that is an \"intelligible being seen,\" which, coming into the understanding makes us understand. I say not this, as disproving the use o universities; but because I am to speak hereafter of their office in commonwealth, I must let you see on all occasions by the way, wha things would be amended in them; amongst which the frequency o insignificant speech is one."} +{"text":"I"} +{"text":"Of Imagination"} +{"text":"That when a thing lies still, unless somewhat else stir it, it will li still forever, is a truth that no man doubts of. But that when a thin is in motion, it will eternally be in motion, unless somewhat else sta it, though the reason be the same, namely, that nothing can chang itself, is not so easily assented to. For men measure, not only othe men, but all other things, by themselves; and because they fin themselves subject after motion to pain, and lassitude, thin everything else grows weary of motion, and seeks repose of its ow accord; little considering, whether it be not some other motion wherein that desire of rest they find in themselves, consisteth. Fro hence it is, that the schools say, heavy bodies fall downwards, out o an appetite to rest, and to conserve their nature in that place whic is most proper for them; ascribing appetite, and knowledge of what i good for their conservation, which is more than man has, to thing inanimate, absurdly."} +{"text":"When a body is once in motion, it moveth, unless something else hinde it, eternally; and whatsoever hindreth it, cannot in an instant, but i time, and by degrees, quite extinguish it; and, as we see in the water though the wind cease, the waves give not over rolling for a long tim after: so also it happeneth in that motion, which is made in th internal parts of a man, then, when he sees, dreams, etc. For after th object is removed, or the eye shut, we still retain an image of th thing seen, though more obscure than when we see it. And this is it the Latins call \"imagination,\" from the image made in seeing; and appl the same, though improperly, to all the other senses. But the Greek call it \"fancy\"; which signifies \"appearance,\" and is as proper to on sense, as to another. \"Imagination,\" therefore, is nothing bu \"decaying sense\"; and is found in men, and many other living creatures as well sleeping, as waking."} +{"text":"The decay of sense in men waking, is not the decay of the motion mad in sense; but an obscuring of it, in such manner as the light of th sun obscureth the light of the stars; which stars do no less exercis their virtue, by which they are visible, in the day than in the night But because amongst many strokes, which our eyes, ears, and othe organs receive from external bodies, the predominant only is sensible therefore, the light of the sun being predominant, we are not affecte with the action of the stars. And any object being removed from ou eyes, though the impression it made in us remain, yet other object more present succeeding, and working on us, the imagination of the pas is obscured and made weak, as the voice of a man is in the noise of th day. From whence it followeth, that the longer the time is, after th sight or sense of any object, the weaker is the imagination. For th continual change of man's body destroys in time the parts which i sense were moved: so that distance of time, and of place, hath one an the same effect in us. For as at a great distance of place, that whic we look at appears dim, and without distinction of the smaller parts and as voices grow weak and inarticulate; so also, after great distanc of time, our imagination of the past is weak; and we lose, for example of cities we have seen, many particular streets, and of actions, man particular circumstances. This \"decaying sense,\" when we would expres the thing itself, I mean \"fancy\" itself, we call \"imagination,\" as said before: but when we would express the decay, and signify that th sense is fading, old, and past, it is called \"memory.\" So tha imagination and memory are but one thing, which for diver considerations hath divers names."} +{"text":"Much memory, or memory of many things, is called \"experience.\" Again imagination being only of those things which have been formerl perceived by sense, either all at once, or by parts at several times the former, which is the imagining the whole object as it was presente to the sense, is \"simple\" imagination, as when one imagineth a man, o horse, which he hath seen before. The other is \"compounded\"; as when from the sight of a man at one time, and of a horse at another, w conceive in our mind a Centaur. So when a man compoundeth the image o his own person with the image of the actions of another man, as when man imagines himself a Hercules or an Alexander, which happeneth ofte to them that are much taken with reading of romances, it is a compoun imagination, and properly but a fiction of the mind. There be als other imaginations that rise in men, though waking, from the grea impression made in sense: as from gazing upon the sun, the impressio leaves an image of the sun before our eyes a long time after; and fro being long and vehemently attent upon geometrical figures, a man shal in the dark, though awake, have the images of lines and angles befor his eyes; which kind of fancy hath no particular name, as being a thin that doth not commonly fall into men's discourse."} +{"text":"The imaginations of them that sleep are those we call \"dreams.\" An these also, as all other imaginations, have been before, either totall or by parcels, in the sense. And because in sense, the brain an nerves, which are the necessary organs of sense, are so benumbed i sleep as not easily to be moved by the action of external objects there can happen in sleep no imagination, and therefore no dream, bu what proceeds from the agitation of the inward parts of man's body which inward parts, for the connection they have with the brain, an other organs, when they be distempered, do keep the same in motion whereby the imaginations there formerly made, appear as if a man wer waking; saving that the organs of sense being now benumbed, so as ther is no new object, which can master and obscure them with a mor vigorous impression, a dream must needs be more clear, in this silenc of sense, than our waking thoughts. And hence it cometh to pass, tha it is a hard matter, and by many thought impossible, to distinguis exactly between sense and dreaming. For my part, when I consider tha in dreams I do not often nor constantly think of the same persons places, objects, and actions, that I do waking; nor remember so long train of coherent thoughts, dreaming, as at other times; and becaus waking I often observe the absurdity of dreams, but never dream of th absurdities of my waking thoughts; I am well satisfied, that, bein awake, I know I dream not, though when I dream I think myself awake."} +{"text":"And seeing dreams are caused by the distemper of some of the inwar parts of the body, divers distempers must needs cause different dreams And hence it is that lying cold breedeth dreams of fear, and raiset the thought and image of some fearful object, the motion from the brai to the inner parts and from the inner parts to the brain bein reciprocal; and that as anger causeth heat in some parts of the bod when we are awake, so when we sleep the overheating of the same part causeth anger, and raiseth up in the brain the imagination of an enemy In the same manner, as natural kindness, when we are awake, causet desire, and desire makes heat in certain other parts of the body; s also too much heat in those parts, while we sleep, raiseth in the brai an imagination of some kindness shown. In sum, our dreams are th reverse of our waking imaginations; the motion when we are awak beginning at one end, and when we dream at another."} +{"text":"The most difficult discerning of a man's dream, from his wakin thoughts, is then, when by some accident we observe not that we hav slept: which is easy to happen to a man full of fearful thoughts, an whose conscience is much troubled; and that sleepeth, without th circumstances of going to bed or putting off his clothes, as one tha noddeth in a chair. For he that taketh pains, and industriously lay himself to sleep, in case any uncouth and exorbitant fancy come unt him, cannot easily think it other than a dream. We read of Marcu Brutus (one that had his life given him by Julius Caesar, and was als his favourite, and notwithstanding murdered him), how at Philippi, th night before he gave battle to Augustus Caesar, he saw a fearfu apparition, which is commonly related by historians as a vision; bu considering the circumstances, one may easily judge to have been but short dream. For sitting in his tent, pensive and troubled with th horror of his rash act, it was not hard for him, slumbering in th cold, to dream of that which most affrighted him; which fear, as b degrees it made him wake, so also it must needs make the apparition b degrees to vanish; and having no assurance that he slept, he could hav no cause to think it a dream, or anything but a vision. And this is n very rare accident; for even they that be perfectly awake, if they b timorous and superstitious, possessed with fearful tales, and alone i the dark, are subject to the like fancies, and believe they see spirit and dead men's ghosts walking in churchyards; whereas it is eithe their fancy only, or else the knavery of such persons as make use o such superstitious fear, to pass disguised in the night, to places the would not be known to haunt."} +{"text":"From this ignorance of how to distinguish dreams, and other stron fancies, from vision and sense, did arise the greatest part of th religion of the Gentiles in time past, that worshipped satyrs, fawns nymphs, and the like; and nowadays the opinion that rude people have o fairies, ghosts, and goblins, and of the power of witches. For as fo witches, I think not that their witchcraft is any real power; but ye that they are justly punished, for the false belief they have that the can do such mischief, joined with their purpose to do it if they can their trade being nearer to a new religion than to a craft or science And for fairies, and walking ghosts, the opinion of them has, I think been on purpose either taught or not confuted, to keep in credit th use of exorcism, of crosses, of holy water, and other such invention of ghostly men. Nevertheless, there is no doubt but God can mak unnatural apparitions; but that He does it so often, as men need t fear such things, more than they fear the stay or change of the cours of nature, which He also can stay, and change, is no point of Christia faith. But evil men, under pretext that God can do anything, are s bold as to say anything when it serves their turn, though they think i untrue; it is the part of a wise man to believe them no farther tha right reason makes that which they say appear credible. If thi superstitious fear of spirits were taken away, and with it, prognostic from dreams, false prophecies, and many other things depending thereon by which crafty ambitious persons abuse the simple people, men would b much more fitted than they are for civil obedience."} +{"text":"And this ought to be the work of the schools: but they rather nouris such doctrine. For, not knowing what imagination or the senses are what they receive, they teach: some saying that imaginations rise o themselves, and have no cause; others that they rise most commonly fro the will; and that good thoughts are blown (inspired) into a man b God, and evil thoughts by the devil; or that good thoughts are poure (infused) into a man by God, and evil ones by the devil. Some say th senses receive the species of things, and deliver them to the commo sense; and the common sense delivers them over to the fancy, and th fancy to the memory, and the memory to the judgment, like handing o things from one to another, with many words making nothing understood."} +{"text":"The imagination that is raised in man, or any other creature indue with the faculty of imagining, by words, or other voluntary signs, i that we generally call \"understanding\"; and is common to man and beast For a dog by custom will understand the call, or the rating of hi master; and so will many other beasts. That understanding which i peculiar to man, is the understanding not only his will, but hi conceptions and thoughts, by the sequel and contexture of the names o things into affirmations, negations, and other forms of speech; and o this kind of understanding I shall speak hereafter."} +{"text":"II"} +{"text":"Of the Consequence or Train of Imaginations"} +{"text":"By \"consequence,\" or \"train\" of thoughts, I understand that successio of one thought to another, which is called, to distinguish it fro discourse in words, \"mental discourse.\""} +{"text":"When a man thinketh on anything whatsoever, his next thought after, i not altogether so casual as it seems to be. Not every thought to ever thought succeeds indifferently. But as we have no imagination, whereo we have not formerly had sense, in whole, or in parts; so we have n transition from one imagination to another, whereof we never had th like before in our senses. The reason whereof is this. All fancies ar motions within us, relics of those made in the sense: and those motion that immediately succeeded one another in the sense, continue als together after sense: insomuch as the former coming again to tak place, and be predominant, the latter followeth, by coherence of th matter moved, in such manner, as water upon a plane table is draw which way any one part of it is guided by the finger. But because i sense, to one and the same thing perceived, sometimes one thing sometimes another succeedeth, it comes to pass in time, that in th imagining of anything, there is no certainty what we shall imagin next; only this is certain, it shall be something that succeeded th same before, at one time or another."} +{"text":"This train of thoughts, or mental discourse, is of two sorts. The firs is \"unguided,\" \"without design,\" and inconstant; wherein there is n passionate thought, to govern and direct those that follow, to itself as the end and scope of some desire, or other passion: in which cas the thoughts are said to wander, and seem impertinent one to another as in a dream. Such are commonly the thoughts of men, that are not onl without company, but also without care of anything; though even the their thoughts are as busy as at other times, but without harmony; a the sound which a lute out of tune would yield to any man; or in tune to one that could not play. And yet in this wild ranging of the mind, man may ofttimes perceive the way of it, and the dependence of on thought upon another. For in a discourse of our present civil war, wha could seem more impertinent, than to ask, as one did, what was th value of a Roman penny? Yet the coherence to me was manifest enough For the thought of the war, introduced the thought of the delivering u the king to his enemies; the thought of that, brought in the thought o the delivering up of Christ; and that again the thought of the thirt pence, which was the price of that treason; and thence easily followe that malicious question; and all this in a moment of time; for though is quick."} +{"text":"The second is more constant; as being \"regulated\" by some desire, an design. For the impression made by such things as we desire, or fear is strong, and permanent, or, if it cease for a time, of quick return so strong it is sometimes, as to hinder and break our sleep. Fro desire, ariseth the thought of some means we have seen produce the lik of that which we aim at; and from the thought of that, the thought o means to that mean; and so continually, till we come to some beginnin within our own power. And because the end, by the greatness of th impression, comes often to mind, in case our thoughts begin to wander they are quickly again reduced into the way: which observed by one o the seven wise men, made him give men this precept, which is now wor out, Respice finem; that is to say, in all your actions, look ofte upon what you would have, as the thing that directs all your thought in the way to attain it."} +{"text":"The train of regulated thoughts is of two kinds; one, when of an effec imagined we seek the causes, or means that produce it: and this i common to man and beast. The other is, when imagining anythin whatsoever, we seek all the possible effects, that can by it b produced; that is to say, we imagine what we can do with it, when w have it. Of which I have not at any time seen any sign, but in ma only; for this is a curiosity hardly incident to the nature of an living creature that has no other passion but sensual, such as ar hunger, thirst, lust, and anger. In sum, the discourse of the mind when it is governed by design, is nothing but \"seeking,\" or the facult of invention, which the Latins called sagacitas, and solertia; hunting out of the causes, of some effect, present or past; or of th effects, of some present or past cause. Sometimes a man seeks what h hath lost; and from that place, and time, wherein he misses it, hi mind runs back, from place to place, and time to time, to find where and when he had it; that is to say, to find some certain, and limite time and place, in which to begin a method of seeking. Again, fro thence, his thoughts run over the same places and times, to find wha action, or other occasion might make him lose it. This we cal \"remembrance,\" or calling to mind: the Latins call it reminiscentia, a it were a \"re-conning\" of our former actions."} +{"text":"Sometimes a man knows a place determinate, within the compass whereo he is to seek; and then his thoughts run over all the parts thereof, i the same manner as one would sweep a room, to find a jewel; or as spaniel ranges the field, till he find a scent; or as a man should ru over the alphabet, to start a rhyme."} +{"text":"Sometimes a man desires to know the event of an action; and then h thinketh of some like action past, and the events thereof one afte another; supposing like events will follow like actions. As he tha foresees what will become of a criminal, reckons what he has see follow on the like crime before; having this order of thoughts, th crime, the officer, the prison, the judge, and the gallows. Which kin of thoughts is called \"foresight,\" and \"prudence,\" or \"providence\"; an sometimes \"wisdom\"; though such conjecture, through the difficulty o observing all circumstances, be very fallacious. But this is certain by how much one man has more experience of things past, than another by so much also he is more prudent, and his expectations the seldome fail him. The \"present\" only has a being in nature; things \"past\" hav a being in the memory only, but things to \"come\" have no being at all the \"future\" being but a fiction of the mind, applying the sequels o actions past, to the actions that are present; which with mos certainty is done by him that has most experience, but not wit certainty enough. And though it be called prudence, when the even answereth our expectation; yet in its own nature, it is bu presumption. For the foresight of things to come, which is providence belongs only to him by whose will they are to come. From him only, an supernaturally, proceeds prophecy. The best prophet naturally is th best guesser; and the best guesser, he that is most versed and studie in the matters he guesses at: for he hath most \"signs\" to guess by."} +{"text":"A \"sign\" is the evident antecedent of the consequent; and contrarily the consequent of the antecedent, when the like consequences have bee observed before: and the oftener they have been observed, the les uncertain is the sign. And therefore he that has most experience in an kind of business, has most signs, whereby to guess at the future time and consequently is the most prudent: and so much more prudent than h that is new in that kind of business, as not to be equalled by an advantage of natural and extemporary wit: though perhaps many young me think the contrary."} +{"text":"Nevertheless it is not prudence that distinguisheth man from beast There be beasts, that at a year old observe more, and pursue that whic is for their good, more prudently, than a child can do at ten."} +{"text":"As prudence is a \"presumption\" of the \"future,\" contracted from th \"experience\" of time \"past\": so there is a presumption of things pas taken from other things, not future, but past also. For he that hat seen by what courses and degrees a flourishing state hath first com into civil war, and then to ruin; upon the sight of the ruins of an other state, will guess, the like war, and the like courses have bee there also. But this conjecture has the same uncertainty almost wit the conjecture of the future; both being grounded only upon experience."} +{"text":"There is no other act of man's mind, that I can remember, naturall planted in him, so as to need no other thing, to the exercise of it but to be born a man, and live with the use of his five senses. Thos other faculties of which I shall speak by and by, and which seem prope to man only, are acquired and increased by study and industry; and o most men learned by instruction, and discipline; and proceed all fro the invention of words, and speech. For besides sense, and thoughts and the train of thoughts, the mind of man has no other motion; thoug by the help of speech, and method, the same faculties may be improve to such a height, as to distinguish men from all other livin creatures."} +{"text":"Whatsoever we imagine is \"finite.\" Therefore there is no idea, o conception of anything we call \"infinite.\" No man can have in his min an image of infinite magnitude; nor conceive infinite swiftness infinite time, or infinite force, or infinite power. When we sa anything is infinite, we signify only that we are not able to conceiv the ends, and bounds of the things named; having no conception of th thing, but of our own inability. And therefore the name of God is used not to make us conceive him, for he is incomprehensible; and hi greatness, and power are unconceivable; but that we may honour him Also because, whatsoever, as I said before, we conceive, has bee perceived first by sense, either all at once, or by parts; a man ca have no thought, representing anything, not subject to sense. No ma therefore can conceive anything, but he must conceive it in some place and indued with some determinate magnitude; and which may be divide into parts; nor that anything is all in this place, and all in anothe place at the same time; nor that two, or more things can be in one, an the same place at once: for none of these things ever have, nor can b incident to sense; but are absurd speeches, taken upon credit, withou any signification at all, from deceived philosophers, and deceived, o deceiving schoolmen."} +{"text":"The invention of \"printing,\" though ingenious, compared with th invention of \"letters,\" is no great matter. But who was the first tha found the use of letters, is not known. He that first brought them int Greece, men say was Cadmus, the son of Agenor, king of Phoenicia. profitable invention for continuing the memory of time past, and th conjunction of mankind, dispersed into so many, and distant regions o the earth; and withal difficult, as proceeding from a watchfu observation of the divers motions of the tongue, palate, lips, an other organs of speech; whereby to make as many differences o characters, to remember them. But the most noble and profitabl invention of all other, was that of \"speech,\" consisting of \"names\" o \"appellations,\" and their connection; whereby men register thei thoughts; recall them when they are past; and also declare them one t another for mutual utility and conversation; without which, there ha been amongst men, neither commonwealth, nor society, nor contract, no peace, no more than amongst lions, bears, and wolves. The first autho of \"speech\" was God himself, that instructed Adam how to name suc creatures as he presented to his sight; for the Scripture goeth n further in this matter. But this was sufficient to direct him to ad more names, as the experience and use of the creatures should give hi occasion; and to join them in such manner by degrees, as to mak himself understood; and so by succession of time, so much languag might be gotten, as he had found use for; though not so copious, as a orator or philosopher has need of: for I do not find anything in th Scripture, out of which, directly or by consequence, can be gathered that Adam was taught the names of all figures, numbers, measures colours, sounds, fancies, relations; much less the names of words an speech, as \"general,\" \"special,\" \"affirmative,\" \"negative,\ \"interrogative,\" \"optative,\" \"infinitive,\" all which are useful; an least of all, of \"entity,\" \"intentionality,\" \"quiddity,\" and othe insignificant words of the school."} +{"text":"But all this language gotten, and augmented by Adam and his posterity was again lost at the Tower of Babel, when, by the hand of God, ever man was stricken, for his rebellion, with an oblivion of his forme language. And being hereby forced to disperse themselves into severa parts of the world, it must needs be, that the diversity of tongue that now is, proceeded by degrees from them, in such manner, as need the mother of all inventions, taught them; and in tract of time gre everywhere more copious."} +{"text":"The general use of speech, is to transfer our mental discourse, int verbal; or the train of our thoughts, into a train of words; and tha for two commodities, whereof one is the registering of the consequence of our thoughts; which being apt to slip out of our memory, and put u to a new labour, may again be recalled, by such words as they wer marked by. So that the first use of names is to serve for \"marks,\" o \"notes\" of remembrance. Another is, when many use the same words, t signify, by their connection and order, one to another, what the conceive, or think of each matter; and also what they desire, fear, o have any other passion for. And for this use they are called \"signs.\ Special uses of speech are these; first, to register, what b cogitation, we find to be the cause of anything, present or past; an what we find things present or past may produce, or effect; which i sum, is acquiring of arts. Secondly, to show to others that knowledg which we have attained, which is, to counsel and teach one another Thirdly, to make known to others our wills and purposes, that we ma have the mutual help of one another. Fourthly, to please and deligh ourselves and others, by playing with our words, for pleasure o ornament, innocently."} +{"text":"To these uses, there are also four correspondent abuses. First, whe men register their thoughts wrong, by the inconstancy of th signification of their words; by which they register for thei conception, that which they never conceived, and so deceive themselves Secondly, when they use words metaphorically; that is, in other sens than that they are ordained for; and thereby deceive others. Thirdly by words, when they declare that to be their will, which is not Fourthly, when they use them to grieve one another; for seeing Natur hath armed living creatures, some with teeth, some with horns, and som with hands, to grieve an enemy, it is but an abuse of speech, to griev him with the tongue, unless it be one whom we are obliged to govern and then it is not to grieve, but to correct and amend."} +{"text":"The manner how speech serveth to the remembrance of the consequence o causes and effects, consisteth in the imposing of \"names,\" and th \"connection\" of them."} +{"text":"Of names, some are \"proper,\" and singular to one only thing, a \"Peter,\" \"John,\" \"this man,\" \"this tree\"; and some are \"common\" to man things, \"man,\" \"horse,\" \"tree\"; every of which, though but one name, i nevertheless the name of divers particular things; in respect of al which together, it is called an \"universal\"; there being nothing in th world universal but names; for the things named are every one of the individual and singular."} +{"text":"One universal name is imposed on many things, for their similitude i some quality, or other accident; and whereas a proper name bringeth t mind one thing only, universals recall any one of those many."} +{"text":"And of names universal, some are of more, and some of less extent; th larger comprehending the less large; and some again of equal extent comprehending each other reciprocally. As for example: the name \"body\ is of larger signification than the word \"man,\" and comprehendeth it and the names \"man\" and \"rational,\" are of equal extent, comprehendin mutually one another. But here we must take notice, that by a name i not always understood, as in grammar, one only word; but sometimes, b circumlocution, many words together. For all these words, \"he that i his actions observeth the laws of his country,\" make but one name equivalent to this one word, \"just.\""} +{"text":"By this imposition of names, some of larger, some of stricte signification, we turn the reckoning of the consequences of thing imagined in the mind, into a reckoning of the consequences o appellations. For example: a man that hath no use of speech at all such as is born and remains perfectly deaf and dumb, if he set befor his eyes a triangle, and by it two right angles, such as are th corners of a square figure, he may, by meditation, compare and find that the three angles of that triangle, are equal to those two righ angles that stand by it. But if another triangle be shown him different in shape from the former, he cannot know, without a ne labour, whether the three angles of that also be equal to the same. Bu he that hath the use of words, when he observes, that such equality wa consequent, not to the length of the sides, nor to any other particula thing in his triangle; but only to this, that the sides were straight and the angles three; and that that was all, for which he named it triangle; will boldly conclude universally, that such equality o angles is in all triangles whatsoever; and register his invention i these general terms, \"every triangle hath its three angles equal to tw right angles.\" And thus the consequence found in one particular, come to be registered and remembered, as a universal rule, and discharge our mental reckoning, of time and place, and delivers us from al labour of the mind, saving the first, and makes that which was foun true \"here,\" and \"now,\" to be true in \"all times\" and \"places.\""} +{"text":"But the use of words in registering our thoughts is in nothing s evident as in numbering. A natural fool that could never learn by hear the order of numeral words, as \"one,\" \"two,\" and \"three,\" may observ every stroke of the clock, and nod to it, or say \"one,\" \"one,\" \"one,\ but can never know what hour it strikes. And it seems, there was a tim when those names of number were not in use; and men were fain to appl their fingers of one or both hands, to those things they desired t keep account of; and that thence it proceeded, that now our numera words are but ten, in any nation, and in some but five; and then the begin again. And he that can tell ten, if he recite them out of order will lose himself, and not know when he has done. Much less will he b able to add, and subtract, and perform all other operations o arithmetic. So that without words there is no possibility of reckonin of numbers; much less of magnitudes, of swiftness, of force, and othe things, the reckonings whereof are necessary to the being, o well-being of mankind."} +{"text":"When two names are joined together into a consequence, or affirmation as thus, \"a man is a living creature\"; or thus, \"if he be a man, he i a living creature\"; if the latter name, \"living creature,\" signify al that the former name \"man\" signifieth, then the affirmation, o consequence, is \"true\"; otherwise \"false.\" For \"true\" and \"false\" ar attributes of speech, not of things. And where speech is not, there i neither \"truth\" nor \"falsehood\"; \"error\" there may be, as when w expect that which shall not be, or suspect what has not been; but i neither case can a man be charged with untruth."} +{"text":"Seeing then that truth consisteth in the right ordering of names in ou affirmations, a man that seeketh precise truth had need to remembe what every name he uses stands for, and to place it accordingly, o else he will find himself entangled in words, as a bird in lime twigs the more he struggles the more belimed. And therefore in geometry which is the only science that it hath pleased God hitherto to besto on mankind, men begin at settling the significations of their words which settling of significations they call \"definitions,\" and plac them in the beginning of their reckoning."} +{"text":"By this it appears how necessary it is for any man that aspires to tru knowledge, to examine the definitions of former authors; and either t correct them, where they are negligently set down, or to make the himself. For the errors of definitions multiply themselves according a the reckoning proceeds, and lead men into absurdities, which at las they see, but cannot avoid, without reckoning anew from the beginning in which lies the foundation of their errors. From whence it happens that they which trust to books do as they that cast up many little sum into a greater, without considering whether those little sums wer rightly cast up or not; and at last finding the error visible, and no mistrusting their first grounds, know not which way to clea themselves, but spend time in fluttering over their books; as bird that entering by the chimney, and finding themselves enclosed in chamber, flutter at the false light of a glass window, for want of wi to consider which way they came in. So that in the right definition o names lies the first use of speech; which is the acquisition o science: and in wrong, or no definitions, lies the first abuse; fro which proceed all false and senseless tenets; which make those men tha take their instruction from the authority of books, and not from thei own meditation, to be as much below the condition of ignorant men, a men endued with true science are above it. For between true science an erroneous doctrines, ignorance is in the middle. Natural sense an imagination are not subject to absurdity. Nature itself cannot err; an as men abound in copiousness of language, so they become more wise, o more mad than ordinary. Nor is it possible without letters for any ma to become either excellently wise, or, unless his memory be hurt b disease or ill constitution of organs, excellently foolish. For word are wise men's counters, they do but reckon by them; but they are th money of fools, that value them by the authority of an Aristotle, Cicero, or a Thomas, or any other doctor whatsoever, if but a man."} +{"text":"\"Subject to names,\" is whatsoever can enter into or be considered in a account, and be added one to another to make a sum, or subtracted on from another and leave a remainder. The Latins called accounts of mone rationes, and accounting ratiocinatio; and that which we in bills o books of account call \"items,\" they call nomina, that is \"names\"; an thence it seems to proceed, that they extended the word \"ratio\" to th faculty of reckoning in all other things. The Greeks have but one word lo'go*s, for both \"speech\" and \"reason\"; not that they thought ther was no speech without reason, but no reasoning without speech: and th act of reasoning they called \"syllogism,\" which signifieth summing u of the consequences of one saying to another. And because the sam thing may enter into account for divers accidents, their names are, t show that diversity, diversely wrested and diversified. This diversit of names may be reduced to four general heads."} +{"text":"First, a thing may enter into account for \"matter\" or \"body\"; a \"living,\" \"sensible,\" \"rational,\" \"hot,\" \"cold,\" \"moved,\" \"quiet\"; wit all which names the word \"matter\" or \"body,\" is understood; all suc being names of matter."} +{"text":"Secondly, it may enter into account, or be considered, for som accident or quality which we conceive to be in it; as for \"bein moved,\" for \"being so long,\" for \"being hot,\" etc.; and then, of th name of the thing itself, by a little change or wresting, we make name for that accident, which we consider; and for \"living\" put int the account \"life\"; for \"moved,\" \"motion\"; for \"hot,\" \"heat\"; fo \"long,\" \"length,\" and the like: and all such names are the names of th accidents and properties by which one matter and body is distinguishe from another. These are called \"names abstract,\" because severed, no from matter, but from the account of matter."} +{"text":"Thirdly, we bring into account the properties of our own bodies whereby we make such distinction; as when anything is seen by us, w reckon not the thing itself, but the sight, the colour, the idea of i in the fancy: and when anything is heard, we reckon it not, but th hearing or sound only, which is our fancy or conception of it by th ear; and such are names of fancies."} +{"text":"Fourthly, we bring into account, consider, and give names, to \"names\ themselves, and to \"speeches\": for \"general,\" \"universal,\" \"special,\ \"equivocal,\" are names of names. And \"affirmation,\" \"interrogation,\ \"commandment,\" \"narration,\" \"syllogism,\" \"sermon,\" \"oration,\" and man other such, are names of speeches. And this is all the variety of name \"positive\"; which are put to mark somewhat which is in Nature, or ma be feigned by the mind of man, as bodies that are, or may be conceive to be; or of bodies, the properties that are, or may be feigned to be or words and speech."} +{"text":"There be also other names, called \"negative,\" which are notes t signify that a word is not the name of the thing in question; as thes words, \"nothing,\" \"no man,\" \"infinite,\" \"indocible,\" \"three want four,\ and the like; which are nevertheless of use in reckoning, or i correcting of reckoning, and call to mind our past cogitations, thoug they be not names of anything, because they make us refuse to admit o names not rightly used."} +{"text":"All other names are but insignificant sounds; and those of two sorts One when they are new, and yet their meaning not explained b definition; whereof there have been abundance coined by schoolmen, an puzzled philosophers."} +{"text":"Another, when men make a name of two names, whose significations ar contradictory and inconsistent; as this name, an \"incorporeal body,\ or, which is all one, an \"incorporeal substance,\" and a great numbe more. For whensoever any affirmation is false, the two names of whic it is composed, put together and made one, signify nothing at all. Fo example, if it be a false affirmation to say \"a quadrangle is round,\ the word \"round quadrangle\" signifies nothing, but is a mere sound. S likewise, if it be false to say that virtue can be poured, or blown u and down, the words \"inpoured virtue,\" \"inblown virtue,\" are as absur and insignificant as a \"round quadrangle.\" And therefore you shal hardly meet with a senseless and insignificant word, that is not mad up of some Latin or Greek names. A Frenchman seldom hears our Saviou called by the name of parole, but by the name of verbe often; yet verb and parole differ no more, but that one is Latin, the other French."} +{"text":"When a man, upon the hearing of any speech, hath those thoughts whic the words of that speech and their connection were ordained an constituted to signify, then he is said to understand it \"understanding\" being nothing else but conception caused by speech. An therefore if speech be peculiar to man, as for aught I know it is, the is understanding peculiar to him also. And therefore of absurd an false affirmations, in case they be universal, there can be n understanding; though many think they understand then, when they do bu repeat the words softly, or con them in their mind."} +{"text":"What kinds of speeches signify the appetites, aversions, and passion of man's mind; and of their use and abuse, I shall speak when I hav spoken of the passions."} +{"text":"The names of such things as affect us, that is, which please an displease us, because all men be not alike affected with the sam thing, nor the same man at all times, are in the common discourses o men of \"inconstant\" signification. For seeing all names are imposed t signify our conceptions, and all our affections are but conceptions when we conceive the same things differently, we can hardly avoi different naming of them. For though the nature of that we conceive, b the same; yet the diversity of our reception of it, in respect o different constitutions of body, and prejudices of opinion, give everything a tincture of our different passions. And therefore i reasoning a man must take heed of words; which besides th signification of what we imagine of their nature, have a significatio also of the nature, disposition, and interest of the speaker; such a are the names of virtues and vices; for one man calleth \"wisdom,\" wha another calleth \"fear\"; and one \"cruelty,\" what another \"justice\"; on \"prodigality,\" what another \"magnanimity\"; and one \"gravity,\" wha another \"stupidity,\" etc. And therefore such names can never be tru grounds of any ratiocination. No more can metaphors, and tropes o speech; but these are less dangerous, because they profess thei inconstancy; which the other do not."} +{"text":""} +{"text":"Of Reason and Science"} +{"text":"When a man \"reasoneth,\" he does nothing else but conceive a sum total from \"addition\" of parcels; or conceive a remainder, from \"subtraction\ of one sum from another; which, if it be done by words, is conceivin of the consequence of the names of all the parts, to the name of th whole; or from the names of the whole and one part, to the name of th other part. And though in some things, as in numbers, besides addin and subtracting, men name other operations, as \"multiplying\" an \"dividing,\" yet they are the same; for multiplication is but addin together of things equal; and division but subtracting of one thing, a often as we can. These operations are not incident to numbers only, bu to all manner of things that can be added together, and taken one ou of another. For as arithmeticians teach to add and subtract i \"numbers,\" so the geometricians teach the same in \"lines,\" \"figures,\ solid and superficial, \"angles,\" \"proportions,\" \"times,\" degrees o \"swiftness,\" \"force,\" \"power,\" and the like; the logicians teach th same in \"consequences of words,\" adding together two \"names\" to make a \"affirmation,\" and two \"affirmations\" to make a \"syllogism\"; and \"man syllogisms\" to make a \"demonstration\"; and from the \"sum,\" o \"conclusion\" of a \"syllogism,\" they subtract one \"proposition\" to fin the other. Writers of politics add together \"pactions\" to find men' \"duties\"; and lawyers \"laws\" and \"facts,\" to find what is \"right\" an \"wrong\" in the actions of private men. In sum, in what matter soeve there is place for \"addition\" and \"subtraction,\" there also is plac for \"reason\"; and where these have no place, there \"reason\" has nothin at all to do."} +{"text":"Out of all which we may define, that is to say determine, what that is which is meant by this word \"reason,\" when we reckon it amongst th faculties of the mind. For \"reason,\" in this sense, is nothing bu \"reckoning,\" that is adding and subtracting, of the consequences o general names agreed upon for the \"marking\" and \"signifying\" of ou thoughts; I say \"marking\" them when we reckon by ourselves, an \"signifying,\" when we demonstrate or approve our reckonings to othe men."} +{"text":"And, as in arithmetic, unpracticed men must, and professors themselve may often, err, and cast up false; so also in any other subject o reasoning, the ablest, most attentive, and most practiced men ma deceive themselves, and infer false conclusions; not but that reaso itself is always right reason, as well as arithmetic is a certain an infallible art: but no one man's reason, nor the reason of any on number of men, makes the certainty; no more than an account i therefore well cast up, because a great many men have unanimousl approved it. And therefore, as when there is a controversy in a account, the parties must by their own accord set up, for right reason the reason of some arbitrator, or judge, to whose sentence they wil both stand, or their controversy must either come to blows, or b undecided, for want of a right reason constituted by Nature; so is i also in all debates of what kind soever. And when men that thin themselves wiser than all others, clamour and demand right reason fo judge, yet seek no more, but that things should be determined by n other men's reason but their own, it is as intolerable in the societ of men, as it is in play after trump is turned, to use for trump o every occasion, that suit whereof they have most in their hand. Fo they do nothing else, that will have every of their passions, as i comes to bear sway in them, to be taken for right reason, and that i their own controversies: bewraying their want of right reason, by th claim they lay to it."} +{"text":"The use and end of reason is not the finding of the sum and truth o one, or a few consequences, remote from the first definitions, an settled significations of names, but to begin at these, and procee from one consequence to another. For there can be no certainty of th last conclusion, without a certainty of all those affirmations an negations on which it was grounded and inferred. As when a master of family, in taking an account, casteth up the sums of all the bills o expense into one sum, and not regarding how each bill is summed up b those that give them in account, nor what it is he pays for, h advantages himself no more than if he allowed the account in gross trusting to every of the accountants' skill and honesty: so also i reasoning of all other things, he that takes up conclusions on th trust of authors, and doth not fetch them from the first items in ever reckoning, which are the significations of names settled b definitions, loses his labour, and does not know anything, but onl believeth."} +{"text":"When a man reckons without the use of words, which may be done i particular things, as when upon the sight of any one thing, w conjecture what was likely to have preceded, or is likely to follo upon it; if that which he thought likely to follow, follows not, o that which he thought likely to have preceded it, hath not preceded it this is called \"error\"; to which even the most prudent men are subject But when we reason in words of general signification, and fall upon general inference which is false, though it be commonly called \"error,\ it is indeed an \"absurdity,\" or senseless speech. For error is but deception, in presuming that somewhat is past, or to come; of which though it were not past, or not to come, yet there was no impossibilit discoverable. But when we make a general assertion, unless it be a tru one, the possibility of it is inconceivable. And words whereby w conceive nothing but the sound, are those we call \"absurd,\ \"insignificant,\" and \"nonsense.\" And therefore if a man should talk t me of a \"round quadrangle\"; or, \"accidents of bread in cheese\"; or \"immaterial substances\"; or of \"a free subject\"; \"a free will\"; or an \"free,\" but free from being hindered by opposition, I should not say h were in an error, but that his words were without meaning, that is t say, absurd."} +{"text":"I have said before, in the second chapter, that a man did excel al other animals in this faculty, that when he conceived anythin whatsoever, he was apt to inquire the consequences of it, and wha effects he could do with it. And now I add this other degree of th same excellence, that he can by words reduce the consequences he find to general rules, called \"theorems,\" or \"aphorisms\"; that is, he ca reason, or reckon, not only in number, but in all other things, whereo one may be added unto, or subtracted from another."} +{"text":"But this privilege is allayed by another; and that is, by the privileg of absurdity; to which no living creature is subject, but man only. An of men, those are of all most subject to it, that profess philosophy For it is most true that Cicero saith of them somewhere; that there ca be nothing so absurd, but may be found in the books of philosophers And the reason is manifest. For there is not one of them that begin his ratiocination from the definitions, or explications of the name they are to use; which is a method that hath been used only i geometry; whose conclusions have thereby been made indisputable 1. The first cause of absurd conclusions I ascribe to the want o method; in that they begin not their ratiocination fro definitions; that is, from settled significations of their words as if they could cast account, without knowing the value of th numeral words \"one,\" \"two,\" and \"three.\ And whereas all bodies enter into account upon diver considerations, which I have mentioned in the precedent chapter these considerations being diversely named, divers absurditie proceed from the confusion, and unfit connection of their name into assertions. And therefore 2. The second cause of absurd assertions, I ascribe to the giving o names of \"bodies\" to \"accidents\"; or of \"accidents\" to \"bodies\"; a they do that say, \"faith is infused,\" or \"inspired\"; when nothin can be \"poured\" or \"breathed\" into anything, but body; and tha \"extension\" is \"body\"; that \"phantasms\" are \"spirits,\" etc 3. The third I ascribe to the giving of the names of the \"accidents\ of \"bodies without us,\" to the \"accidents\" of our \"own bodies\"; a they do that say, \"the colour is in the body\"; \"the sound is in th air,\" etc 4. The fourth, to the giving of the names of \"bodies\" to \"names,\" o \"speeches\"; as they do that say, that \"there be things universal\" that \"a living creature is genus,\" or \"a general thing,\" etc 5. The fifth, to the giving of the names of \"accidents\" to \"names\" an \"speeches\"; as they do that say, \"the nature of a thing is it definition; a man's command is his will\"; and the like 6. The sixth, to the use of metaphors, tropes, and other rhetorica figures, instead of words proper. For though it be lawful to say for example, in common speech, \"the way goeth, or leadeth hither o thither\"; \"the proverb says this or that,\" whereas ways cannot go nor proverbs speak; yet in reckoning, and seeking of truth, suc speeches are not to be admitted 7. The seventh, to names that signify nothing; but are taken up an learned by rote from the schools, as \"hypostatical,\ \"transubstantiate,\" \"consubstantiate,\" \"eternal-now,\" and the lik canting of schoolmen."} +{"text":"To him that can avoid these things it is not easy to fall into an absurdity, unless it be by the length of an account; wherein he ma perhaps forget what went before. For all men by nature reason alike and well, when they have good principles. For who is so stupid, as bot to mistake in geometry, and also to persist in it, when another detect his error to him?"} +{"text":"By this it appears that reason is not, as sense and memory, born wit us; nor gotten by experience only, as prudence is; but attained b industry; first in apt imposing of names; and secondly by getting good and orderly method in proceeding from the elements, which ar names, to assertions made by connection of one of them to another; an so to syllogisms, which are the connections of one assertion t another, till we come to a knowledge of all the consequences of name appertaining to the subject in hand; and that is it, men cal \"science.\" And whereas sense and memory are but knowledge of fact which is a thing past and irrevocable. \"Science\" is the knowledge o consequences, and dependence of one fact upon another: by which, out o that we can presently do, we know how to do something else when w will, or the like another time; because when we see how anything come about, upon what causes, and by what manner; when the like causes com into our power, we see how to make it produce the like effects."} +{"text":"Children therefore are not endued with reason at all, till they hav attained the use of speech; but are called reasonable creatures, fo the possibility apparent of having the use of reason in time to come And the most part of men, though they have the use of reasoning little way, as in numbering to some degree; yet it serves them t little use in common life; in which they govern themselves, som better, some worse, according to their differences of experience quickness of memory, and inclinations to several ends; but speciall according to good or evil fortune, and the errors of one another. Fo as for \"science,\" or certain rules of their actions, they are so fa from it, that they know not what it is. Geometry they have though conjuring: but for other sciences, they who have not been taught th beginnings and some progress in them, that they may see how they b acquired and generated, are in this point like children, that having n thought of generation, are made believe by the women that thei brothers and sisters are not born, but found in the garden."} +{"text":"But yet they that have no \"science,\" are in better and noble condition, with their natural prudence; than men, that b mis-reasoning, or by trusting them that reason wrong, fall upon fals and absurd general rules. For ignorance of causes, and of rules, doe not set men so far out of their way, as relying on false rules, an taking for causes of what they aspire to, those that are not so, bu rather causes of the contrary."} +{"text":"To conclude, the light of human minds is perspicuous words, but b exact definitions first snuffed, and purged from ambiguity; \"reason\" i the \"pace\"; increase of \"science,\" the \"way\"; and the benefit o mankind, the \"end.\" And, on the contrary, metaphors, and senseless an ambiguous words, are like ignes fatui; and reasoning upon them i wandering amongst innumerable absurdities and their end, contention an sedition, or contempt."} +{"text":"As much experience, is \"prudence\"; so, is much science \"sapience.\" Fo though we usually have one name of wisdom for them both, yet the Latin did always distinguish between prudentia and sapientia; ascribing th former to experience, the latter to science. But to make thei difference appear more clearly, let us suppose one man endued with a excellent natural use and dexterity in handling his arms; and anothe to have added to that dexterity, an acquired science, of where he ca offend, or be offended by his adversary, in every possible posture o guard: the ability of the former, would be to the ability of th latter, as prudence to sapience; both useful; but the latte infallible. But they that trusting only to the authority of books follow the blind blindly, are like him that, trusting to the fals rules of a master of fence, ventures presumptuously upon an adversary that either kills or disgraces him."} +{"text":"The signs of science are, some certain and infallible; some, uncertain Certain, when he that pretendeth the science of anything, can teach th same; that is to say, demonstrate the truth thereof perspicuously t another; uncertain, when only some particular events answer to hi pretence, and upon many occasions prove so as he says they must. Sign of prudence are all uncertain; because to observe by experience, an remember all circumstances that may alter the success, is impossible But in any business, whereof a man has not infallible science t proceed by; to forsake his own natural judgment, and be guided b general sentences read in authors, and subject to many exceptions, is sign of folly, and generally scorned by the name of pedantry. And eve of those men themselves, that in councils of the commonwealth love t show their reading of politics and history, very few do it in thei domestic affairs, where their particular interest is concerned; havin prudence enough for their private affairs: but in public they stud more the reputation of their own wit, than the success of another' business."} +{"text":"I"} +{"text":"Of the Interior Beginnings of Voluntary Motions; Commonly Called th Passions; and the Speeches by Which They Are Expressed"} +{"text":"There be in animals, two sorts of \"motions\" peculiar to them: on called \"vital\"; begun in generation, and continued without interruptio through their whole life; such as are the \"course\" of the \"blood,\" th \"pulse,\" the \"breathing,\" the \"concoction, nutrition, excretion,\" etc. to which motions there needs no help of imagination: the other i \"animal motion,\" otherwise called \"voluntary motion\"; as to \"go,\" t \"speak,\" to \"move\" any of our limbs, in such manner as is first fancie in our minds. That sense is motion in the organs and interior parts o man's body, caused by the action of the things we see, hear, etc.; an that fancy is but the relics of the same motion, remaining after sense has been already said in the first and second chapters. And becaus \"going,\" \"speaking,\" and the like voluntary motions, depend always upo a precedent thought of \"whither,\" \"which way,\" and \"what\"; it i evident, that the imagination is the first internal beginning of al voluntary motion. And although unstudied men do not conceive any motio at all to be there, where the thing moved is invisible; or the space i is moved in is, for the shortness of it, insensible; yet that doth no hinder, but that such motions are. For let a space be never so little that which is moved over a greater space, whereof that little one i part, must first be moved over that. These small beginnings of motion within the body of man, before they appear in walking, speaking striking, and other visible actions, are commonly called \"endeavour.\""} +{"text":"This endeavour, when it is toward something which causes it, is calle \"appetite,\" or \"desire\"; the latter, being the general name; and th other oftentimes restrained to signify the desire of food, namel \"hunger\" and \"thirst.\" And when the endeavour is fromward something, i is generally called \"aversion.\" These words, \"appetite\" and \"aversion,\ we have from the Latins; and they both of them signify the motions, on of approaching, the other of retiring. So also do the Greek words fo the same, which are hor�� and afor��. For Nature itself does ofte press upon men those truths, which afterwards, when they look fo somewhat beyond Nature, they stumble at. For the schools find in mer appetite to go, or move, no actual motion at all: but because som motion they must acknowledge, they call it metaphorical motion; whic is but an absurd speech: for though words may be called metaphorical bodies and motions cannot."} +{"text":"That which men desire, they are also said to \"love\": and to \"hate\ those things for which they have aversion. So that desire and love ar the same thing; save that by desire, we always signify the absence o the object; by love most commonly the presence of the same. So also b aversion, we signify the absence; and by hate, the presence of th object."} +{"text":"Of appetites and aversions, some are born with men; as appetite o food, appetite of excretion, and exoneration, which may also and mor properly be called aversions, from somewhat they feel in their bodies and some other appetites, not many. The rest, which are appetites o particular things, proceed from experience, and trial of their effect upon themselves or other men. For of things we know not at all, o believe not to be, we can have no further desire than to taste and try But aversion we have for things, not only which we know have hurt us but also that we do not know whether they will hurt us, or not."} +{"text":"Those things which we neither desire, nor hate, we are said t \"contemn\"; \"contempt\" being nothing else but an immobility, o contumacy of the heart, in resisting the action of certain things; an proceeding from that the heart is already moved otherwise, by othe more potent objects; or from want of experience of them."} +{"text":"And because the constitution of a man's body is in continual mutation it is impossible that all the same things should always cause in hi the same appetites and aversions: much less can all men consent, in th desire of almost any one and the same object."} +{"text":"But whatsoever is the object of any man's appetite or desire, that i it which he for his part calleth \"good\": and the object of his hate an aversion, \"evil\"; and of his contempt, \"vile\" and \"inconsiderable.\" Fo these words of good, evil, and contemptible, are ever used wit relation to the person that useth them: there being nothing simply an absolutely so; nor any common rule of good and evil, to be taken fro the nature of the objects themselves; but from the person of the man where there is no commonwealth; or, in a commonwealth, from the perso that representeth it; or from an arbitrator or judge, whom me disagreeing shall by consent set up, and make his sentence the rul thereof."} +{"text":"The Latin tongue has two words, whose significations approach to thos of good and evil; but are not precisely the same; and those ar pulchrum and turpe. Whereof the former signifies that, which by som apparent signs promiseth good; and the latter, that which promiset evil. But in our tongue we have not so general names to express the by. But for pulchrum we say in some things, \"fair\"; in others \"beautiful,\" or \"handsome,\" or \"gallant,\" or \"honourable,\" or \"comely,\ or \"amiable\"; and for turpe, \"foul,\" \"deformed,\" \"ugly,\" \"base,\ \"nauseous,\" and the like, as the subject shall require; all whic words, in their proper places, signify nothing else but the \"mien,\" o countenance, that promiseth good and evil. So that of good there b three kinds; good in the promise, that is pulchrum; good in effect, a the end desired, which is called jucundum, \"delightful\"; and good a the means, which is called \"utile,\" \"profitable\"; and as many of evil for \"evil\" in promise, is that they call turpe; evil in effect, an end, is molestum, \"unpleasant,\" \"troublesome\"; and evil in the means \"inutile,\" \"unprofitable,\" \"hurtful.\""} +{"text":"As, in sense, that which is really within us, is, as I have sai before, only motion, caused by the action of external objects, but i apparence; to the sight, light and colour; to the ear, sound; to th nostril, odour, etc.: so, when the action of the same object i continued from the eyes, ears, and other organs to the heart, the rea effect there is nothing but motion, or endeavour; which consisteth i appetite, or aversion, to or from the object moving. But the apparence or sense of that motion, is that we either call \"delight,\" or \"troubl of mind.\""} +{"text":"This motion, which is called appetite, and for the apparence of i \"delight,\" and \"pleasure,\" seemeth to be a corroboration of vita motion, and a help thereunto; and therefore such things as cause delight, were not improperly called jucunda, � juvando, from helping o fortifying; and the contrary molesta, \"offensive,\" from hindering, an troubling the motion vital."} +{"text":"\"Pleasure\" therefore, or \"delight,\" is the apparence, or sense of good and \"molestation,\" or \"displeasure,\" the apparence, or sense of evil And consequently all appetite, desire, and love, is accompanied wit some delight more or less; and all hatred and aversion, with more o less displeasure and offence."} +{"text":"Of pleasures or delights, some arise from the sense of an objec present; and those may be called \"pleasure of sense\"; the wor \"sensual,\" as it is used by those only that condemn them, having n place till there be laws. Of this kind are all onerations an exonerations of the body; as also all that is pleasant, in the \"sight,\ \"hearing,\" \"smell,\" \"taste,\" or \"touch.\" Others arise from th expectation, that proceeds from foresight of the end, or consequence o things; whether those things in the sense please or displease. An these are \"pleasures of the mind\" of him that draweth thos consequences, and are generally called \"joy.\" In the like manner displeasures are some in the sense, and called \"pain\"; others in th expectation of consequences, and are called \"grief.\""} +{"text":"These simple passions called \"appetite,\" \"desire,\" \"love,\" \"aversion,\ \"hate,\" \"joy,\" and \"grief,\" have their names for divers consideration diversified. As first, when they one succeed another, they ar diversely called from the opinion men have of the likelihood o attaining what they desire. Secondly, from the object loved or hated Thirdly, from the consideration of many of them together. Fourthly from the alteration or succession itself."} +{"text":"For \"appetite,\" with an opinion of attaining, is called \"hope.\""} +{"text":"The same, without such opinion, \"despair.\""} +{"text":"\"Aversion,\" with opinion of \"hurt\" from the object, \"fear.\""} +{"text":"The same, with hope of avoiding that hurt by resistance, \"courage.\""} +{"text":"Sudden \"courage,\" \"anger.\""} +{"text":"Constant \"hope,\" \"confidence\" of ourselves."} +{"text":"Constant \"despair,\" \"diffidence\" of ourselves."} +{"text":"\"Anger\" for great hurt done to another, when we conceive the same to b done by injury, \"indignation.\""} +{"text":"\"Desire\" of good to another, \"benevolence,\" \"good will,\" \"charity.\" I to man generally, \"good-nature.\""} +{"text":"\"Desire\" of riches, \"covetousness\"; a name used always in significatio of blame; because men contending for them, are displeased with on another attaining them; though the desire in itself, be to be blamed or allowed, according to the means by which these riches are sought."} +{"text":"\"Desire\" of office, or precedence, \"ambition\": a name used also in th worse sense, for the reason before mentioned."} +{"text":"\"Desire\" of things that conduce but a little to our ends, and fear o things that are but of little hindrance, \"pusillanimity.\""} +{"text":"\"Contempt\" of little helps and hindrances, \"magnanimity.\""} +{"text":"\"Magnanimity,\" in danger of death or wounds, \"valour,\" \"fortitude.\""} +{"text":"\"Magnanimity\" in the use of riches, \"liberality.\""} +{"text":"\"Pusillanimity\" in the same, \"wretchedness,\" \"miserableness,\" o \"parsimony\"; as it is liked or disliked."} +{"text":"\"Love\" of persons for society, \"kindness.\""} +{"text":"\"Love\" of persons for pleasing the sense only, \"natural lust.\""} +{"text":"\"Love\" of the same, acquired from rumination, that is, imagination o pleasure past, \"luxury.\""} +{"text":"\"Love\" of one singularly, with desire to be singularly beloved, \"th passion of love.\" The same, with fear that the love is not mutual \"jealousy.\""} +{"text":"\"Desire,\" by doing hurt to another, to make him condemn some fact o his own, \"revengefulness.\""} +{"text":"\"Desire\" to know why, and how, \"curiosity\"; such as is in no livin creature but \"man\": so that man is distinguished, not only by hi reason, but also by this singular passion from other \"animals\"; in who the appetite of food, and other pleasures of sense, by predominance take away the care of knowing causes; which is a lust of the mind, tha by a perseverance of delight in the continual and indefatigabl generation of knowledge, exceedeth the short vehemence of any carna pleasure."} +{"text":"\"Fear\" of power invisible, feigned by the mind, or imagined from tale publicly allowed, \"religion\"; not allowed \"superstition.\" And when th power imagined, is truly such as we imagine, \"true religion.\""} +{"text":"\"Fear,\" without the apprehension of why, or what, \"panic terror,\ called so from the fables that make Pan the author of them; whereas i truth, there is always in him that so feareth, first, some apprehensio of the cause, though the rest run away by example, everyone supposin his fellow to know why. And therefore this passion happens to none bu in a throng, or multitude of people."} +{"text":"\"Joy,\" from apprehension of novelty, \"admiration\"; proper to man because it excites the appetite of knowing the cause."} +{"text":"\"Joy,\" arising from imagination of a man's own power and ability, i that exultation of the mind which is called \"glorying\": which i grounded upon the experience of his own former actions, is the sam with \"confidence\": but if grounded on the flattery of others, or onl supposed by himself, for delight in the consequences of it, is calle \"vainglory\": which name is properly given; because a well-grounde \"confidence\" begetteth attempt; whereas the supposing of power doe not, and is therefore rightly called \"vain.\""} +{"text":"\"Grief,\" from opinion of want of power, is called \"dejection\" of mind."} +{"text":"The \"vainglory\" which consisteth in the feigning or supposing o abilities in ourselves, which we know are not, is most incident t young men, and nourished by the histories or fictions of gallan persons; and is corrected oftentimes by age, and employment."} +{"text":"\"Sudden glory,\" is the passion which maketh those \"grimaces\" calle \"laughter\"; and is caused either by some sudden act of their own, tha pleaseth them; or by the apprehension of some deformed thing i another, by comparison whereof they suddenly applaud themselves. And i is incident most to them, that are conscious of the fewest abilities i themselves; who are forced to keep themselves in their own favour, b observing the imperfections of other men. And therefore much laughte at the defects of others, is a sign of pusillanimity. For of grea minds, one of the proper works is, to help and free others from scorn and compare themselves only with the most able."} +{"text":"On the contrary, \"sudden dejection,\" is the passion that causet \"weeping\"; and is caused by such accidents, as suddenly take away som vehement hope, or some prop of their power: and they are most subjec to it, that rely principally on helps external, such as are women an children. Therefore some weep for the loss of friends; others for thei unkindness; others for the sudden stop made to their thoughts o revenge, by reconciliation. But in all cases, both laughter, an weeping, are sudden motions; custom taking them both away. For no ma laughs at old jests; or weeps for an old calamity."} +{"text":"\"Grief,\" for the discovery of some defect of ability, is \"shame,\" o the passion that discovereth itself in \"blushing\": and consisteth i the apprehension of something dishonourable; and in young men is a sig of the love of good reputation, and commendable: in old men it is sign of the same; but because it comes too late, not commendable."} +{"text":"The \"contempt\" of good reputation is called \"impudence.\""} +{"text":"\"Grief,\" for the calamity of another, is \"pity\"; and ariseth from th imagination that the like calamity may befall himself; and therefore i called also \"compassion,\" and in the phrase of this present time \"fellow-feeling\": and therefore for calamity arriving from grea wickedness, the best men have the least pity; and for the sam calamity, those hate pity, that think themselves least obnoxious to th same."} +{"text":"\"Contempt,\" or little sense of the calamity of others, is that whic men call \"cruelty\"; proceeding from security of their own fortune. For that any man should take pleasure in other men's great harms, withou other end of his own, I do not conceive it possible."} +{"text":"\"Grief,\" for the success of a competitor in wealth, honour, or othe good, if it be joined with endeavour to enforce our own abilities t equal or exceed him, is called \"emulation\"; but joined with endeavou to supplant, or hinder a competitor, \"envy.\""} +{"text":"When in the mind of man, appetites, and aversions, hopes, and fears concerning one and the same thing, arise alternately; and divers goo and evil consequences of the doing, or omitting the thing propounded come successively into our thoughts; so that sometimes we have a appetite to it; sometimes an aversion from it; sometimes hope to b able to do it; sometimes despair, or fear to attempt it; the whole su of desires, aversions, hopes and fears continued till the thing b either done, or thought impossible, is that we call \"deliberation.\""} +{"text":"Therefore of things past, there is no \"deliberation\"; becaus manifestly impossible to be changed: nor of things known to b impossible, or thought so; because men know, or think, suc deliberation vain. But of things impossible, which we think possible we may deliberate; not knowing it is in vain. And it is calle \"deliberation\"; because it is a putting an end to the \"liberty\" we ha of doing or omitting according to our own appetite, or aversion."} +{"text":"This alternate succession of appetites, aversions, hopes and fears, i no less in other living creatures than in man: and therefore beast also deliberate."} +{"text":"Every \"deliberation\" is then said to \"end,\" when that whereof the deliberate, is either done or thought impossible; because till then w retain the liberty of doing or omitting, according to our appetite, o aversion."} +{"text":"In \"deliberation,\" the last appetite, or aversion, immediately adherin to the action, or to the omission thereof, is that we call the \"will\" the act, not the faculty, of \"willing.\" And beasts that hav \"deliberation,\" must necessarily also have \"will.\" The definition o the \"will,\" given commonly by the schools, that it is a \"rationa appetite,\" is not good. For if it were, then could there be n voluntary act against reason. For a \"voluntary act\" is that whic proceedeth from the \"will,\" and no other. But if instead of a rationa appetite, we shall say an appetite resulting from a preceden deliberation, then the definition is the same that I have given here Will, therefore, is the last appetite in deliberating. And though w say in common discourse, a man had a will once to do a thing, tha nevertheless he forbore to do; yet that is properly but an inclination which makes no action voluntary; because the action depends not of it but of the last inclination or appetite. For if the intervenien appetites, make any action voluntary; then by the same reason, al intervenient aversions should make the same action involuntary; and s one and the same action should be both voluntary and involuntary."} +{"text":"By this it is manifest, that not only actions that have their beginnin from covetousness, ambition, lust, or other appetites to the thin propounded; but also those that have their beginning from aversion, o fear of those consequences that follow the omission, are \"voluntar actions.\""} +{"text":"The forms of speech by which the passions are expressed, are partly th same, and partly different from those, by which we express ou thoughts. And first, generally all passions may be expresse \"indicatively\"; as \"I love,\" \"I fear,\" \"I joy,\" \"I deliberate,\" \" will,\" \"I command\": but some of them have particular expressions b themselves, which nevertheless are not affirmations, unless it be whe they serve to make other inferences, besides that of the passion the proceed from. Deliberation is expressed \"subjunctively\"; which is speech proper to signify suppositions, with their consequences: as, \"i this be done, then this will follow\"; and differs not from the languag of reasoning, save that reasoning is in general words; but deliberatio for the most part is of particulars. The language of desire, an aversion, is \"imperative\"; as \"do this,\" \"forbear that\"; which when th party is obliged to do, or forbear, is \"command\"; otherwise \"prayer\" or else \"counsel.\" The language of vainglory, of indignation, pity an revengefulness, \"optative\": but of the desire to know, there is peculiar expression, called \"interrogative\"; as, \"what is it,\" \"whe shall it,\" \"how is it done,\" and \"why so?\" other language of th passions I find none: for cursing, swearing, reviling, and the like, d not signify as speech; but as the actions of a tongue accustomed."} +{"text":"These forms of speech, I say, are expressions, or voluntar significations of our passions: but certain signs they be not; becaus they may be used arbitrarily, whether they that use them have suc passions or not. The best signs of passions present, are either in th countenance, motions of the body, actions, and ends, or aims, which w otherwise know the man to have."} +{"text":"And because in deliberation, the appetites, and aversions, are raise by foresight of the good and evil consequences, and sequels of th action whereof we deliberate; the good or evil effect thereof dependet on the foresight of a long chain of consequences, of which very seldo any man is able to see to the end. But for so far as a man seeth, i the good in those consequences be greater than the evil, the whol chain is that which writers call \"apparent,\" or \"seeming good.\" An contrarily, when the evil exceedeth the good, the whole is \"apparent,\ or \"seeming evil\": so that he who hath by experience, or reason, th greatest and surest prospect of consequences, deliberates best himself and is able when he will, to give the best counsel unto others."} +{"text":"\"Continual success\" in obtaining those things which a man from time t time desireth, that is to say, continual prospering, is that men cal \"felicity\"; I mean the felicity of this life. For there is no suc thing as perpetual tranquility of mind, while we live here; becaus life itself is but motion, and can never be without desire, nor withou fear, no more than without sense. What kind of felicity God hat ordained to them that devoutly honour Him, a man shall no sooner know than enjoy; being joys, that now are as incomprehensible as the word o schoolmen \"beatifical vision\" is unintelligible."} +{"text":"The form of speech whereby men signify their opinion of the goodness o anything, is \"praise.\" That whereby they signify the power an greatness of anything, is \"magnifying.\" And that whereby they signif the opinion they have of a man's felicity, is by the Greeks calle �akaris�o'*s, for which we have no name in our tongue. And thus much i sufficient for the present purpose, to have been said of th \"passions.\""} +{"text":"II"} +{"text":"Of the Ends, or Resolutions of Discourse"} +{"text":"Of all \"discourse,\" governed by desire of knowledge, there is at las an \"end,\" either by attaining, or by giving over. And in the chain o discourse, wheresoever it be interrupted, there is an end for tha time."} +{"text":"If the discourse be merely mental, it consisteth of thoughts that th thing will be, and will not be; or that it has been, and has not been alternately. So that wheresoever you break off the chain of a man' discourse, you leave him in a presumption of \"it will be,\" or, \"it wil not be\"; or, \"it has been,\" or, \"has not been.\" All which is \"opinion.\ And that which is alternate appetite, in deliberating concerning goo and evil; the same is alternate opinion, in the enquiry of the truth o \"past,\" and \"future.\" And as the last appetite in deliberation, i called the \"will,\" so the last opinion in search of the truth of past and future, is called the \"judgment,\" or \"resolute\" and \"fina sentence\" of him that \"discourseth.\" And as the whole chain o appetites alternate, in the question of good, or bad, is calle \"deliberation\"; so the whole chain of opinions alternate, in th question of true, or false, is called \"doubt.\""} +{"text":"No discourse whatsoever can end in absolute knowledge of fact, past o to come. For, as for the knowledge of fact, it is originally sense; an ever after, memory. And for the knowledge of consequence, which I hav said before is called science, it is not absolute, but conditional. N man can know by discourse, that this or that is, has been, or will be which is to know absolutely; but only, that if this be, that is; i this has been, that has been; if this shall be, that shall be; which i to know conditionally; and that not the consequence of one thing t another, but of one name of a thing to another name of the same thing."} +{"text":"And therefore, when the discourse is put into speech, and begins wit the definitions of words, and proceeds by connection of the same int general affirmations, and of these again into syllogisms; the end o last sum is called the conclusion, and the thought of the mind by i signified, is that conditional knowledge, or knowledge of th consequence of words, which is commonly called \"science.\" But if th first ground of such discourse, be not definitions; or if th definitions be not rightly joined together into syllogisms, then th end or conclusion, is again \"opinion,\" namely of the truth of somewha said, though sometimes in absurd and senseless words, withou possibility of being understood. When two or more men know of one an the same fact, they are said to be \"conscious\" of it one to another which is as much as to know it together. And because such are fittes witnesses of the facts of one another, or of a third: it was, and eve will be, reputed a very evil act, for any man to speak against hi \"conscience\": or to corrupt or force another so to do: insomuch tha the plea of conscience has been always hearkened unto very diligentl in all times. Afterwards, men made use of the same word metaphorically for the knowledge of their own secret facts, and secret thoughts; an therefore it is rhetorically said, that the conscience is a thousan witnesses. And last of all, men vehemently in love with their own ne opinions, though never so absurd, and obstinately bent to maintai them, gave those their opinions also that reverenced name o conscience, as if they would have it seem unlawful to change or spea against them; and so pretend to know they are true, when they know a most, but that they think so."} +{"text":"When a man's discourse beginneth not at definitions, it beginnet either at some other contemplation of his own, and then it is stil called opinion; or it beginneth at some saying of another, of whos ability to know the truth, and of whose honesty in not deceiving, h doubteth not: and then the discourse is not so much concerning th thing, as the person; and the resolution is called \"belief,\" an \"faith\": \"faith,\" in the man, \"belief,\" both of the man, and of th truth of what he says. So that in belief are two opinions; one of th saying of the man, the other of his virtue. To \"have faith in,\" o \"trust to,\" or \"believe a man,\" signify the same thing; namely, a opinion of the veracity of the man: but to \"believe what is said,\ signifieth only an opinion of the truth of the saying. But we are t observe that this phrase, \"I believe in,\" as also the Latin, credo in and the Greek, pi*se'uw i*s, are never used but in the writings o divines. Instead of them, in other writings are put, \"I believe him,\ \"I trust him\"; \"I have faith in him\"; \"I rely on him\"; and in Lati credo illi, fido illi: and in Greek, pi*se'uw atw: and that thi singularity of the ecclesiastic use of the word hath raised man disputes about the right object of the Christian faith."} +{"text":"But by \"believing in,\" as it is in the creed, is meant, not trust i the person: but confession and acknowledgment of the doctrine. For no only Christians, but all manner of men do so believe in God, as to hol all for truth they hear him say, whether they understand it or not which is all the faith and trust can possibly be had in any perso whatsoever: but they do not all believe the doctrine of the creed."} +{"text":"From whence we may infer, that when we believe any saying whatsoever i be, to be true, from arguments taken, not from the thing itself, o from the principles of natural reason, but from the authority and goo opinion we have of him that hath said it; then is the speaker, o person we believe in, or trust in, and whose word we take, the objec of our faith, and the honour done in believing, is done to him only And consequently, when we believe that the Scriptures are the word o God, having no immediate revelation from God Himself, our belief faith, and trust is in the Church, whose word we take, and acquiesc therein. And they that believe that which a prophet relates unto the in the name of God, take the word of the prophet, do honour to him, an in him trust, and believe, touching the truth of what he relateth whether he be a true or a false prophet. And so it is also with al other history. For if I should not believe all that is written b historians of the glorious acts of Alexander or Caesar, I do not thin the ghost of Alexander or Caesar had any just cause to be offended, o anybody else, but the historian. If Livy say the gods made once a co speak, and we believe it not, we distrust not God therein, but Livy. S that it is evident, that whatsoever we believe, upon no other reaso than what is drawn from authority of men only, and their writings whether they be sent from God or not, is faith in men only."} +{"text":"III"} +{"text":"Of the Virtues Commonly Called Intellectual, and Their Contrary Defects"} +{"text":"Virtue generally, in all sorts of subjects, is somewhat that is value for eminence, and consisteth in comparison. For if all things wer equal in all men, nothing would be prized. And by \"virtue intellectual,\" are always understood such abilities of the mind as me praise, value, and desire should be in themselves; and go commonl under the name of a \"good wit\"; though the same word \"wit\" be used als to distinguish one certain ability from the rest."} +{"text":"These \"virtues\" are of two sorts, \"natural,\" and \"acquired.\" B natural, I mean not that which a man hath from his birth: for that i nothing else but sense; wherein men differ so little one from another and from brute beasts, as it is not to be reckoned amongst virtues. Bu I mean that \"wit\" which is gotten by use only and experience; withou method, culture, or instruction. This \"natural wit\" consistet principally in two things, \"celerity of imagining,\" that is, swif succession of one thought to another, and steady direction to som approved end. On the contrary, a slow imagination maketh that defect or fault of the mind which is commonly called \"dullness,\" \"stupidity,\ and sometimes by other names that signify slowness of motion, o difficulty to be moved."} +{"text":"And this difference of quickness, is caused by the difference of men' passions; that love and dislike, some one thing, some another: an therefore some men's thoughts run one way, some another; and are hel to, and observe differently the things that pass through thei imagination. And whereas in this succession of men's thoughts, there i nothing to observe in the things they think on, but either in what the be \"like one another,\" or in what they be \"unlike,\" or \"what they serv for,\" or \"how they serve to such a purpose\"; those that observe thei similitudes, in case they be such as are but rarely observed by others are said to have a \"good wit\"; by which, in this occasion, is meant \"good fancy.\" But they that observe their differences an dissimilitudes: which is called \"distinguishing,\" and \"discerning,\" an \"judging\" between thing and thing; in case such discerning be not easy are said to have a \"good judgment\": and particularly in matter o conversation and business; wherein times, places, and persons are to b discerned, this virtue is called \"discretion.\" The former, that is fancy, without the help of judgment, is not commended as a virtue: bu the latter, which is judgment, and discretion, is commended for itself without the help of fancy. Besides the discretion of times, places, an persons, necessary to a good fancy, there is required also an ofte application of his thoughts to their end; that is to say, to some us to be made of them. This done; he that hath this virtue, will be easil fitted with similitudes that will please, not only by illustrations o his discourse, and adorning it with new and apt metaphors; but also, b the rarity of their invention. But without steadiness, and direction t some end, a great fancy is one kind of madness; such as they have, tha entering into any discourse, are snatched from their purpose b everything that comes in their thought, into so many and so lon digressions, and parentheses, that they utterly lose themselves: whic kind of folly I know no particular name for; but the cause of it is sometimes want of experience; whereby that seemeth to a man new an rare, which doth not so to others, sometimes pusillanimity; by whic that seems great to him, which other men think a trifle: and whatsoeve is new, or great, and therefore thought fit to be told, withdraws a ma by degrees from the intended way of his discourse."} +{"text":"In a good poem, whether it be \"epic,\" or \"dramatic\"; as also i \"sonnets,\" \"epigrams,\" and other pieces, both judgment and fancy ar required; but the fancy must be more eminent; because they please fo the extravagancy; but ought not to displease by indiscretion."} +{"text":"In a good history, the judgment must be eminent; because the goodnes consisteth in the method, in the truth, and in the choice of th actions that are most profitable to be known. Fancy has no place, bu only in adorning the style."} +{"text":"In orations of praise, and in invectives, the fancy is predominant because the design is not truth, but to honour or dishonour; which i done by noble or by vile comparisons. The judgment does but sugges what circumstances make an action laudable, or culpable."} +{"text":"In hortatives, and pleadings, as truth or disguise serveth best to th design in hand; so is the judgment or the fancy most required."} +{"text":"In demonstration, in counsel, and all rigorous search of truth judgment does all, except sometimes the understanding have need to b opened by some apt similitude; and then there is so much use of fancy But for metaphors, they are in this case utterly excluded. For seein they openly profess deceit; to admit them into counsel or reasonin were manifest folly."} +{"text":"And in any discourse whatsoever, if the defect of discretion b apparent, how extravagant soever the fancy be, the whole discourse wil be taken for a sign of want of wit; and so will it never when th discretion is manifest, though the fancy be never so ordinary."} +{"text":"The secret thoughts of a man run over all things, holy, profane, clean obscene, grave and light, without shame, or blame; which verba discourse cannot do, farther than the judgment shall approve of th time, place, and persons. An anatomist or a physician may speak, o write his judgment of unclean things; because it is not to please, bu profit: but for another man to write his extravagant and pleasan fancies of the same, is as if a man, from being tumbled into the dirt should come and present himself before good company. And it is the wan of discretion that makes the difference. Again, in professed remissnes of mind, and familiar company, a man may play with the sounds an equivocal significations of words; and that many times with encounter of extraordinary fancy: but in a sermon, or in public, or befor persons unknown, or whom we ought to reverence, there is no gingling o words that will not be accounted folly: and the difference is only i the want of discretion. So that where wit is wanting, it is not fanc that is wanting, but discretion. Judgment therefore without fancy i wit, but fancy without judgment, not."} +{"text":"When the thoughts of a man, that has a design in hand, running over multitude of things, observes how they conduce to that design; or wha design they may conduce unto; if his observations be such as are no easy, or usual, this wit of his is called \"prudence\"; and depends o much experience, and memory of the like things and their consequence heretofore. In which there is not so much difference of men, as ther is in their fancies and judgment; because the experience of men equa in age, is not much unequal as to the quantity; but lies in differen occasions; everyone having his private designs. To govern well a famil and a kingdom, are not different degrees of prudence; but differen sorts of business; no more than to draw a picture in little, or a great, or greater than the life, are different degrees of art. A plai husbandman is more prudent in affairs of his own house, than privy-councillor in the affairs of another man."} +{"text":"To prudence, if you add the use of unjust or dishonest means, such a usually are prompted to men by fear, or want; you have that crooke wisdom which is called \"craft\"; which is a sign of pusillanimity. Fo magnanimity is contempt of unjust or dishonest helps. And that whic the Latins call versutia, translated into English, \"shifting,\" and is putting off of a present danger or incommodity, by engaging into greater, as when a man robs one to pay another, is but shorter-sighted craft, called versutia, from versura, which signifie taking money at usury for the present payment of interest."} +{"text":"As for \"acquired wit,\" I mean acquired by method and instruction, ther is none but reason; which is grounded on the right use of speech, an produceth the sciences. But of reason and science I have alread spoken, in the fifth and sixth chapters."} +{"text":"The causes of this difference of wits, are in the passions; and th difference of passions proceedeth, partly from the differen constitution of the body, and partly from different education. For i the difference proceeded from the temper of the brain, and the organ of sense, either exterior or interior, there would be no les difference of men in their sight, hearing, or other senses, than i their fancies and discretions. It proceeds therefore from the passions which are different, not only from the difference of men's complexions but also from their difference of customs, and education."} +{"text":"The passions that most of all cause the difference of wit, ar principally, the more or less desire of power, of riches, of knowledge and of honour. All which may be reduced to the first, that is, desir of power. For riches, knowledge, and honour, are but several sorts o power."} +{"text":"And therefore, a man who has no great passion for any of these things but is, as men term it, indifferent; though he may be so far a goo man, as to be free from giving offence; yet he cannot possibly hav either a great fancy, or much judgment. For the thoughts are to th desires, as scouts, and spies, to range abroad, and find the way to th things desired: all steadiness of the mind's motion, and all quicknes of the same, proceeding from thence: for as to have no desire, is to b dead: so to have weak passions, is dullness; and to have passion indifferently for everything, \"giddiness,\" and \"distraction\"; and t have stronger and more vehement passions for anything, than i ordinarily seen in others, is that which men call \"madness.\""} +{"text":"Whereof there be almost as many kinds, as of the passions themselves Sometimes the extraordinary and extravagant passion, proceedeth fro the evil constitution of the organs of the body, or harm done them; an sometimes the hurt and indisposition of the organs, is caused by th vehemence, or long continuance of the passion. But in both cases th madness is of one and the same nature."} +{"text":"The passion, whose violence, or continuance, maketh madness, is eithe great \"vainglory\"; which is commonly called \"pride,\" an \"self-conceit\"; or great \"dejection\" of mind."} +{"text":"Pride, subjecteth a man to anger, the excess whereof is the madnes called \"rage\" and \"fury.\" And thus it comes to pass that excessiv desire of revenge, when it becomes habitual, hurteth the organs, an becomes rage: that excessive love, with jealousy, becomes also rage excessive opinion of a man's own self, for divine inspiration, fo wisdom, learning, form and the like, becomes distraction and giddiness the same, joined with envy, rage: vehement opinion of the truth o anything, contradicted by others, rage."} +{"text":"Dejection subjects a man to causeless fears; which is a madness commonly called \"melancholy\"; apparent also in divers manners; as i haunting of solitudes and graves; in superstitious behaviour; and i fearing, some one, some another particular thing. In sum, all passion that produce strange and unusual behaviour, are called by the genera name of madness. But of the several kinds of madness, he that woul take the pains, might enrol a legion. And if the excesses be madness there is no doubt but the passions themselves, when they tend to evil are degrees of the same."} +{"text":"For example, though the effect of folly, in them that are possessed o an opinion of being inspired, be not visible always in one man, by an very extravagant action, that proceedeth from such passion; yet, whe many of them conspire together, the rage of the whole multitude, i visible enough. For what argument of madness can there be greater, tha to clamour, strike, and throw stones at our best friends? Yet this i somewhat less than such a multitude will do. For they will clamour fight against, and destroy those, by whom all their lifetime befor they have been protected, and secured from injury. And if this b madness in the multitude, it is the same in every particular man. Fo as in the midst of the sea, though a man perceive no sound of that par of the water next him, yet he is well assured, that part contributes a much to the roaring of the sea, as any other part of the same quantity so also, though we perceive no great unquietness in one or two men, ye we may be well assured, that their singular passions, are parts of th seditious roaring of a troubled nation. And if there were nothing els that bewrayed their madness, yet that very arrogating such inspiratio to themselves, is argument enough. If some man in Bedlam shoul entertain you with sober discourse; and you desire in taking leave, t know what he were, that you might another time requite his civility and he should tell you, he were God the Father; I think you need expec no extravagant action for argument of his madness."} +{"text":"This opinion of inspiration, called commonly, private spirit, begin very often, from some lucky finding of an error generally held b others; and not knowing, or not remembering, by what conduct of reason they came to so singular a truth (as they think it, though it be man times an untruth they light on) they presently admire themselves, a being in the special grace of God Almighty, who hath revealed the sam to them supernaturally, by his Spirit."} +{"text":"Again, that madness is nothing else, but too much appearing passion may be gathered out of the effects of wine, which are the same wit those of the evil disposition of the organs. For the variety o behaviour in men that have drunk too much, is the same with that o madmen: some of them raging, others loving, others laughing, al extravagantly, but according to their several domineering passions: fo the effect of the wine, does but remove dissimulation, and take fro them the sight of the deformity of their passions. For, I believe, th most sober men, when they walk alone without care and employment of th mind, would be unwilling the vanity and extravagance of their thought at that time should be publicly seen; which is a confession, tha passions unguided, are for the most part mere madness."} +{"text":"The opinions of the world, both in ancient and later ages, concernin the cause of madness, have been two. Some deriving them from th passions; some from demons, or spirits, either good or bad, which the thought might enter into a man, possess him, and move his organs i such strange and uncouth manner, as madmen use to do. The former sort therefore, called such men madmen: but the latter called them sometime \"demoniacs,\" that is, possessed with spirits; sometimes energumeni that is, agitated or moved with spirits; and now in Italy they ar called, not only pazzi, madmen; but also spiritati, men possessed."} +{"text":"There was once a great conflux of people in Abdera, a city of th Greeks, at the acting of the tragedy of \"Andromeda,\" upon an extrem hot day; whereupon, a great many of the spectators falling into fever had this accident from the heat, and from the tragedy together, tha they did nothing but pronounce iambics, with the names of Perseus an Andromeda; which, together with the fever, was cured by the coming o of winter; and this madness was thought to proceed from the passio imprinted by the tragedy. Likewise there reigned a fit of madness i another Grecian city, which seized only the young maidens, and cause many of them to hang themselves. This was by most then thought an ac of the devil. But one that suspected that contempt of life in the might proceed from some passion of the mind, and supposing that the did not contemn also their honour, gave counsel to the magistrates t strip such as so hanged themselves, and let them hang out naked. This the story says, cured that madness. But on the other side, the sam Grecians did often ascribe madness to the operation of Eumenides, o Furies; and sometimes of Ceres, Phoebus, and other gods; so much di men attribute to phantasms, as to think them aerial living bodies, an generally to call them spirits. And as the Romans in this held the sam opinion with the Greeks, so also did the Jews; for they call madme prophets, or, according as they thought the spirits good or bad demoniacs: and some of them called both prophets and demoniacs, madmen and some called the same man both demoniac and madman. But for th Gentiles it is no wonder, because diseases and health, vices an virtues, and many natural accidents, were with them termed an worshipped as demons. So that a man was to understand by demon, as wel sometimes an ague as a devil. But for the Jews to have such opinion i somewhat strange. For neither Moses nor Abraham pretended to prophes by possession of a spirit; but from the voice of God; or by a vision o dream; nor is there anything in his law, moral or ceremonial, by whic they were taught, there was any such enthusiasm, or any possession When God is said (Numb. 11:25) to take from the spirit that was i Moses, and give to the seventy elders, the Spirit of God (taking it fo the substance of God) is not divided. The Scriptures, by the Spirit o God in man, mean a man's spirit, inclined to godliness. And where it i said (Exod. 23:8) \"whom I have filled with the spirit of wisdom to mak garments for Aaron,\" is not meant a spirit put into them that can mak garments, but the wisdom of their own spirits in that kind of work. I the like sense, the spirit of man, when it produceth unclean actions is ordinarily called an unclean spirit, and so other spirits, thoug not always, yet as often as the virtue or vice so styled, i extraordinary and eminent. Neither did the other prophets of the Ol Testament pretend enthusiasm; or, that God spake in them; but to them by voice, vision, or dream; and the \"burden of the Lord\" was no possession, but command. How then could the Jews fall into this opinio of possession? I can imagine no reason, but that which is common to al men, namely, the want of curiosity to search natural causes: and thei placing felicity in the acquisition of the gross pleasures of th senses, and the things that most immediately conduce thereto. For the that see any strange and unusual ability, or defect in a man's mind unless they see withal, from what cause it may probably proceed, ca hardly think it natural; and if not natural, they must needs think i supernatural; and then what can it be, but that either God or the devi is in him? And hence it came to pass, when our Saviour (Mark 3:21) wa compassed about with the multitude, those of the house doubted he wa mad, and went out to hold him: but the Scribes said he had Beelzebub and that was it by which he cast out devils; as if the greater madma had awed the lesser; and that (John 10:20) some said, \"he hath a devil and is mad\"; whereas others holding him for a prophet, said \"these ar not the words of one that hath a devil.\" So in the Old Testament h that came to anoint Jehu (2 Kings 9:11) was a prophet; but some of th company asked Jehu \"what came that madman for?\" So that in sum, it i manifest, that whosoever behaved himself in extraordinary manner, wa thought by the Jews to be possessed either with a good or evil spirit except by the Sadducees, who erred so far on the other hand as not t believe there were at all any spirits, which is very near to direc atheism; and thereby perhaps the more provoked others, to term such me demoniacs, rather than madmen."} +{"text":"But why then does our Saviour proceed in the curing of them, as if the were possessed; and not as if they were mad? To which I can give n other kind of answer, but that which is given to those that urge th Scripture in like manner against the opinion of the motion of th earth. The Scripture was written to show unto men the kingdom of God and to prepare their minds to become his obedient subjects; leaving th world, and the philosophy thereof, to the disputation of men, for th exercising of their natural reason. Whether the earth's or sun's motio make the day, and night; or whether the exorbitant actions of men proceed from passion, or from the devil, so we worship him not, it i all one, as to our obedience, and subjection to God Almighty; which i the thing for which the Scripture was written. As for that our Saviou speaketh to the disease, as to a person; it is the usual phrase of al that cure by words only, as Christ did, and enchanters pretend to do whether they speak to a devil or not. For is not Christ also sai (Matt. 8:26) to have rebuked the winds? Is not He said also (Luke 4:39 to rebuke a fever? Yet this does not argue that a fever is a devil. An whereas many of the devils are said to confess Christ; it is no necessary to interpret those places otherwise, than that those madme confessed Him. And whereas our Saviour (Matt. 12:43) speaketh of a unclean spirit, that having gone out of a man, wandereth through dr places, seeking rest, and finding none, and returning into the sam man, with seven other spirits worse than himself; it is manifestly parable, alluding to a man, that after a little endeavour to quit hi lusts, is vanquished by the strength of them; and becomes seven time worse than he was. So that I see nothing at all in the Scripture, tha requireth a belief that demoniacs were any other thing but madmen."} +{"text":"There is yet another fault in the discourses of some men; which ma also be numbered amongst the sorts of madness; namely, that abuse o words, whereof I have spoken before in the fifth chapter, by the nam of absurdity. And that is, when men speak such words, as put together have in them no signification at all; but are fallen upon by some through misunderstanding of the words they have received, and repeat b rote; by others from intention to deceive by obscurity. And this i incident to none but those, that converse in questions of matter incomprehensible, as the schoolmen; or in questions of abstrus philosophy. The common sort of men seldom speak insignificantly, an are therefore by those other egregious persons counted idiots. But t be assured their words are without anything correspondent to them i the mind, there would need some examples; which if any man require, le him take a schoolman in his hands and see if he can translate any on chapter concerning any difficult point, as the Trinity; the Deity; th nature of Christ; transubstantiation; freewill, etc., into any of th modern tongues, so as to make the same intelligible; or into an tolerable Latin, such as they were acquainted withal, that lived whe the Latin tongue was vulgar. What is the meaning of these words, \"Th first cause does not necessarily inflow anything into the second, b force of the essential subordination of the second causes, by which i may help it to work?\" They are the translation of the title of th sixth chapter of Suarez' first book, Of the Concourse, Motion, and Hel of God. When men write whole volumes of such stuff, are they not mad or intend to make others so? And particularly, in the question o transubstantiation; where after certain words spoken; they that say the whiteness, roundness, magnitude, quality, corruptibility, all whic are incorporeal, etc., go out of the wafer, into the body of ou blessed Saviour, do they not make those \"nesses,\" \"tudes,\" and \"ties,\ to be so many spirits possessing his body? For by spirits, they mea always things, that being incorporeal, are nevertheless movable fro one place to another. So that this kind of absurdity, may rightly b numbered amongst the many sorts of madness; and all the time tha guided by clear thoughts of their worldly lust, they forbear disputing or writing thus, but lucid intervals. And thus much of the virtues an defects intellectual."} +{"text":"X"} +{"text":"Of the Several Subjects of Knowledge"} +{"text":"There are of \"knowledge\" two kinds; whereof one is \"knowledge of fact\" the other \"knowledge of the consequence of one affirmation to another.\ The former is nothing else but sense and memory, and is \"absolut knowledge\"; as when we see a fact doing, or remember it done: and thi is the knowledge required in a witness. The latter is called \"science,\ and is \"conditional\"; as when we know that, \"if the figure shown be circle, then any straight line through the centre shall divide it int two equal parts.\" And this is the knowledge required in a philosopher that is to say, of him that pretends to reasoning."} +{"text":"The register of \"knowledge of fact\" is called \"history.\" Whereof ther be two sorts: one called \"natural history\"; which is the history o such facts, or effects of Nature, as have no dependence on man' \"will\"; such as are the histories of \"metals,\" \"plants,\" \"animals,\ \"regions,\" and the like. The other is \"civil history\"; which is th history of the voluntary actions of men in commonwealths."} +{"text":"The registers of science, are such \"books\" as contain th \"demonstrations\" of consequences of one affirmation to another; and ar commonly called \"books of philosophy\"; whereof the sorts are many according to the diversity of the matter; and may be divided in suc manner as I have divided them in the following table A diagram hierarchically organizing branches of science and philosophy."} +{"text":""} +{"text":"Of Power, Worth, Dignity, Honour, and Worthiness"} +{"text":"The \"power of a man,\" to take it universally, is his present means; t obtain some future apparent good: and is either \"original\" o \"instrumental.\""} +{"text":"\"Natural power,\" is the eminence of the faculties of body or mind; a extraordinary strength, form, prudence, arts, eloquence, liberality nobility. \"Instrumental\" are those powers, which acquired by these, o by fortune, are means and instruments to acquire more: as riches reputation, friends, and the secret working of God, which men call goo luck. For the nature of power is in this point like to fame, increasin as it proceeds; or like the motion of heavy bodies, which the furthe they go, make still the more haste."} +{"text":"The greatest of human powers, is that which is compounded of the power of most men, united by consent, in one person, natural or civil, tha has the use of all their powers depending on his will; such as is th power of a commonwealth: or depending on the wills of each particular such as is the power of a faction or of divers factions leagued Therefore to have servants, is power; to have friends, is power: fo they are strengths united."} +{"text":"Also riches joined with liberality, is power; because it procuret friends, and servants; without liberality, not so; because in this cas they defend not; but expose men to envy, as a prey."} +{"text":"Reputation of power, is power; because it draweth with it the adherenc of those that need protection."} +{"text":"So is reputation of love of a man's country, called popularity, for th same reason."} +{"text":"Also, what quality soever maketh a man beloved, or feared of many; o the reputation of such quality, is power; because it is a means to hav the assistance and service of many."} +{"text":"Good success is power; because it maketh reputation of wisdom, or goo fortune; which makes men either fear him, or rely on him."} +{"text":"Affability of men already in power, is increase of power; because i gaineth love."} +{"text":"Reputation of prudence in the conduct of peace or war, is power because to prudent men, we commit the government of ourselves, mor willingly than to others."} +{"text":"Nobility is power, not in all places, but only in those commonwealth where it has privileges: for in such privileges, consisteth thei power."} +{"text":"Eloquence is power, because it is seeming prudence."} +{"text":"Form is power; because being a promise of good, it recommendeth men t the favour of women and strangers."} +{"text":"The sciences are small power; because not eminent; and therefore, no acknowledged in any man; nor are at all, but in a few, and in them, bu of a few things. For science is of that nature, as none can understan it to be, but such as in a good measure have attained it."} +{"text":"Arts of public use, as fortification, making of engines, and othe instruments of war; because they confer to defence and victory, ar power: and though the true mother of them be science, namely th mathematics; yet, because they are brought into the light by the han of the artificer, they be esteemed, the midwife passing with the vulga for the mother, as his issue."} +{"text":"The \"value,\" or \"worth\" of a man, is as of all other things, his price that is to say, so much as would be given for the use of his power: an therefore is not absolute; but a thing dependent on the need an judgment of another. An able conductor of soldiers, is of great pric in time of war present, or imminent; but in peace not so. A learned an uncorrupt judge, is much worth in time of peace; but not so much i war. And as in other things, so in men, not the seller, but the buye determines the price. For let a man, as most men do, rate themselves a the highest value they can; yet their true value is no more than it i esteemed by others."} +{"text":"The manifestation of the value we set on one another, is that which i commonly called honouring, and dishonouring. To value a man at a hig rate, is to \"honour\" him; at a low rate, is to \"dishonour\" him. Bu high, and low, in this case, is to be understood by comparison to th rate that each man setteth on himself."} +{"text":"The public worth of a man, which is the value set on him by th commonwealth, is that which men commonly call \"dignity.\" And this valu of him by the commonwealth, is understood, by offices of command judicature, public employment; or by names and titles, introduced fo distinction of such value."} +{"text":"To pray to another, for aid of any kind, is \"to honour\"; because a sig we have an opinion he has power to help; and the more difficult the ai is, the more is the honour."} +{"text":"To obey, is to honour, because no man obeys them whom they think hav no power to help, or hurt them. And consequently to disobey, is t \"dishonour.\""} +{"text":"To give great gifts to a man, is to honour him; because it is buying o protection, and acknowledging of power. To give little gifts, is t dishonour; because it is but alms, and signifies an opinion of the nee of small helps."} +{"text":"To be sedulous in promoting another's good, also to flatter, is t honour; as a sign we seek his protection or aid. To neglect, is t dishonour."} +{"text":"To give way or place to another, in any commodity, is to honour; bein a confession of greater power. To arrogate, is to dishonour."} +{"text":"To show any sign of love, or fear of another, is to honour; for both t love, and to fear, is to value. To contemn, or less to love or fea than he expects, is to dishonour; for it is undervaluing."} +{"text":"To praise, magnify, or call happy, is to honour; because nothing bu goodness, power, and felicity is valued. To revile, mock, or pity, i to dishonour."} +{"text":"To speak to another with consideration, to appear before him wit decency, and humility, is to honour him; as signs of fear to offend. T speak to him rashly, to do anything before him obscenely, slovenly impudently, is to dishonour."} +{"text":"To believe, to trust, to rely on another, is to honour him; sign o opinion of his virtue and power. To distrust, or not believe, is t dishonour."} +{"text":"To hearken to a man's counsel, or discourse, of what kind soever, is t honour; as a sign we think him wise, or eloquent, or witty. To sleep or go forth, or talk the while, is to dishonour."} +{"text":"To do those things to another, which he takes for signs of honour, o which the law or custom makes so, is to honour; because in approvin the honour done by others, he acknowledgeth the power which other acknowledge. To refuse to do them, is to dishonour."} +{"text":"To agree with in opinion, is to honour; as being a sign of approvin his judgment and wisdom. To dissent, is dishonour, and an upbraiding o error; and if the dissent be in many things, of folly."} +{"text":"To imitate, is to honour; for it is vehemently to approve. To imitat one's enemy, is to dishonour."} +{"text":"To honour those another honours, is to honour him; as a sign o approbation of his judgment. To honour his enemies, is to dishonou him."} +{"text":"To employ in counsel, or in actions of difficulty, is to honour; as sign of opinion of his wisdom, or other power. To deny employment i the same cases, to those that seek it, is to dishonour."} +{"text":"All these ways of honouring, are natural; and as well within as withou commonwealths. But in commonwealths, where he, or they that have th supreme authority, can make whatsoever they please to stand for sign of honour, there be other honours."} +{"text":"A sovereign doth honour a subject, with whatsoever title, or office, o employment, or action, that he himself will have taken for a sign o his will to honour him."} +{"text":"The king of Persia honoured Mordecai, when he appointed he should b conducted through the streets in the king's garment, upon one of th king's horses, with a crown on his head, and a prince before him proclaiming, \"Thus shall it be done to him that the king will honour.\ And yet another king of Persia, or the same another time, to one tha demanded for some great service, to wear one of the king's robes, gav him leave so to do; but with this addition, that he should wear it a the king's fool; and then it was dishonour. So that of civil honour the fountain is in the person of the commonwealth, and dependeth on th will of the sovereign; and is therefore temporary, and called \"civi honour\"; such as magistracy, offices, titles; and in some places, coat and scutcheons painted: and men honour such as have them, as having s many signs of favour in the commonwealth; which favour is power."} +{"text":"\"Honourable\" is whatsoever possession, action, or quality, is a argument and sign of power."} +{"text":"And therefore to be honoured, loved, or feared of many, is honourable as arguments of power. To be honoured of few or none, \"dishonourable.\""} +{"text":"Dominion and victory is honourable; because acquired by power; an servitude, for need, or fear, is dishonourable."} +{"text":"Good fortune, if lasting, honourable; as a sign of the favour of God Ill fortune, and losses, dishonourable. Riches are honourable; for the are power. Poverty, dishonourable. Magnanimity, liberality, hope courage, confidence, are honourable; for they proceed from th conscience of power. Pusillanimity, parsimony, fear, diffidence, ar dishonourable."} +{"text":"Timely resolution, or determination of what a man is to do, i honourable; as being the contempt of small difficulties and dangers And irresolution, dishonourable; as a sign of too much valuing o little impediments, and little advantages: for when a man has weighe things as long as the time permits, and resolves not, the difference o weight is but little; and therefore if he resolve not, he overvalue little things, which is pusillanimity."} +{"text":"All actions and speeches that proceed, or seem to proceed, from muc experience, science, discretion, or wit, are honourable; for all thes are powers. Actions, or words that proceed from error, ignorance, o folly, dishonourable."} +{"text":"Gravity, as far forth as it seems to proceed from a mind employed o something else, is honourable; because employment is a sign of power But if it seem to proceed from a purpose to appear grave, it i dishonourable. For the gravity of the former, is like the steadiness o a ship laden with merchandize; but of the latter, like the steadines of a ship ballasted with sand, and other trash."} +{"text":"To be conspicuous, that is to say, to be known, for wealth, office great actions, or any eminent good, is honourable; as a sign of th power for which he is conspicuous. On the contrary, obscurity i dishonourable."} +{"text":"To be descended from conspicuous parents, is honourable; because the the more easily attain the aids and friends of their ancestors. On th contrary, to be descended from obscure parentage, is dishonourable."} +{"text":"Actions proceeding from equity, joined with loss, are honourable; a signs of magnanimity: for magnanimity is a sign of power. On th contrary, craft, shifting, neglect of equity, is dishonourable."} +{"text":"Covetousness of great riches, and ambition of great honours, ar honourable; as signs of power to obtain them. Covetousness, an ambition, of little gains or preferments, is dishonourable."} +{"text":"Nor does it alter the case of honour, whether an action, so it be grea and difficult, and consequently a sign of much power, be just o unjust: for honour consisteth only in the opinion of power. Therefor the ancient heathen did not think they dishonoured, but greatl honoured the gods, when they introduced them in their poems, committin rapes, thefts, and other great but unjust, or unclean acts: insomuch a nothing is so much celebrated in Jupiter, as his adulteries; nor i Mercury, as his frauds and thefts: of whose praises, in a hymn o Homer, the greatest is this, that being born in the morning, he ha invented music at noon, and before night, stolen away the cattle o Apollo from his herdsmen."} +{"text":"Also amongst men, till there were constituted great commonwealths, i was thought no dishonour to be a pirate, or a highway thief; but rathe a lawful trade, not only amongst the Greeks, but also amongst all othe nations, as is manifest by the histories of ancient time. And at thi day, in this part of the world, private duels are and always will b honourable, though unlawful, till such time as there shall be honou ordained for them that refuse, and ignominy for them that make th challenge. For duels also are many times effects of courage; and th ground of courage is always strength or skill, which are power; thoug for the most part they be effects of rash speaking, and of the fear o dishonour, in one or both the combatants; who engaged by rashness, ar driven into the lists to avoid disgrace."} +{"text":"Scutcheons, and coats of arms hereditary, where they have any eminen privileges, are honourable; otherwise not: for their power consistet either in such privileges, or in riches, or some such thing as i equally honoured in other men. This kind of honour, commonly calle gentry, hath been derived from the ancient Germans. For there never wa any such thing known, where the German customs were unknown. Nor is i now anywhere in use, where the Germans have not inhabited. The ancien Greek commanders, when they went to war, had their shields painted wit such devices as they pleased; insomuch as an unpainted buckler was sign of poverty, and of a common soldier; but they transmitted not th inheritance of them. The Romans transmitted the marks of thei families: but they were the images, not the devices of their ancestors Amongst the people of Asia, Africa, and America, there is not, nor wa ever, any such thing. The Germans only had that custom; from whom i has been derived into England, France, Spain, and Italy, when in grea numbers they either aided the Romans, or made their own conquests i these western parts of the world."} +{"text":"For Germany, being anciently, as all other countries in thei beginnings, divided amongst an infinite number of little lords, o masters of families, that continually had wars one with another; thos masters, or lords, principally to the end they might, when they wer covered with arms, be known by their followers; and partly fo ornament, both painted their armour, or their scutcheon, or coat, wit the picture of some beast, or other thing, and also put some eminen and visible mark upon the crest of their helmets. And this ornamen both of the arms, and crest, descended by inheritance to thei children; to the eldest pure, and to the rest with some note o diversity, such as the old master, that is to say in Dutch, th \"Here-alt\" thought fit. But when many such families, joined together made a greater monarchy, this duty of the herald, to distinguis scutcheons, was made a private office apart. And the issue of thes lords is the great and ancient gentry; which for the most part bea living creatures, noted for courage and rapine; or castles battlements, belts, weapons, bars, palisadoes, and other notes of war nothing being then in honour but virtue military. Afterwards, not onl kings, but popular commonwealths, gave divers manners of scutcheons, t such as went forth to the war, or returned from it, for encouragement or recompense to their service. All which, by an observing reader, ma be found in such ancient histories, Greek and Latin, as make mention o the German nation and manners in their times."} +{"text":"Titles of \"honour,\" such as are duke, count, marquis, and baron, ar honourable; as signifying the value set upon them by the sovereig power of the commonwealth: which titles, were in old time titles o office and command, derived some from the Romans, some from the German and French: dukes, in Latin duces, being generals in war: counts comites, such as bear the general company out of friendship, and wer left to govern and defend places conquered and pacified: marquises marchiones, were counts that governed the marches, or bounds of th empire. Which titles of duke, count, and marquis, came into the empir about the time of Constantine the Great, from the customs of the Germa \"militia.\" But baron seems to have been a title of the Gauls, an signifies a great man; such as were the king's or prince's men, who they employed in war about their persons; and seems to be derived fro \"vir,\" to \"ber,\" and \"bar,\" that signified the same in the language o the Gauls, that \"vir\" in Latin; and thence to \"bero,\" and \"baro,\" s that such men were called berones, and after barones; and, in Spanish varones. But he that would know more particularly the original o titles of honour, may find it, as I have done this, in Mr. Selden' most excellent treatise of that subject. In process of time thes offices of honour, by occasion of trouble, and for reasons of good an peaceable government, were turned into mere titles; serving for th most part, to distinguish the precedence, place, and order of subject in the commonwealth: and men were made dukes, counts, marquises, an barons of places, wherein they had neither possession nor command: an other titles also were devised to the same end."} +{"text":"\"Worthiness,\" is a thing different from the worth or value of a man and also from his merit, or desert, and consisteth in a particula power, or ability for that, whereof he is said to be worthy: whic particular ability is usually named \"fitness,\" or \"aptitude.\""} +{"text":"For he is worthiest to be a commander, to be a judge, or to have an other charge, that is best fitted, with the qualities required to th well discharging of it; and worthiest of riches, that has the qualitie most requisite for the well using of them: any of which qualities bein absent, one may nevertheless be a worthy man, and valuable fo something else. Again, a man may be worthy of riches, office, an employment, that nevertheless can plead no right to have it befor another; and therefore cannot be said to merit or deserve it. For meri presupposeth a right, and that the thing deserved is due by promise: o which I shall say more hereafter, when I shall speak of contracts."} +{"text":"I"} +{"text":"Of the Difference of Manners"} +{"text":"By manners I mean not here decency of behaviour; as how one shoul salute another, or how a man should wash his mouth, or pick his teet before company, and such other points of the \"small morals\"; but thos qualities of mankind that concern their living together in peace an unity. To which end we are to consider that the felicity of this lif consisteth not in the repose of a mind satisfied. For there is no suc finis ultimus, utmost aim, nor summum bonum, greatest good, as i spoken of in the books of the old moral philosophers. Nor can a man an more live, whose desires are at an end, than he whose senses an imaginations are at a stand. Felicity is a continual progress of th desire, from one object to another, the attaining of the former bein still but the way to the latter. The cause whereof is that the objec of man's desire is not to enjoy once only, and for one instant of time but to assure forever the way of his future desire. And therefore th voluntary actions and inclinations of all men, tend not only to th procuring, but also to the assuring of a contented life; and diffe only in the way which ariseth partly from the diversity of passions i divers men; and partly from the difference of the knowledge or opinio each one has of the causes which produce the effect desired."} +{"text":"So that in the first place, I put for a general inclination of al mankind, a perpetual and restless desire of power after power, tha ceaseth only in death. And the cause of this is not always that a ma hopes for a more intensive delight than he has already attained to, o that he cannot be content with a moderate power; but because he canno assure the power and means to live well, which he hath present, withou the acquisition of more. And from hence it is that kings, whose powe is greatest, turn their endeavours to the assuring it at home by laws or abroad by wars; and when that is done, there succeedeth a ne desire; in some, of fame from new conquest; in others, of ease an sensual pleasure; in others, of admiration, or being flattered fo excellence in some art, or other ability of the mind."} +{"text":"Competition of riches, honour, command, or other power, inclineth t contention, enmity, and war; because the way of one competitor, to th attaining of his desire, is to kill, subdue, supplant, or repel th other. Particularly, competition of praise, inclineth to a reverence o antiquity. For men contend with the living, not with the dead; to thes ascribing more than due, that they may obscure the glory of the other."} +{"text":"Desire of ease, and sensual delight, disposeth men to obey a commo power, because by such desires a man doth abandon the protection tha might be hoped for from his own industry and labour. Fear of death, an wounds, disposeth to the same, and for the same reason. On th contrary, needy men, and hardy, not contented with their presen condition, as also all men that are ambitious of military command, ar inclined to continue the causes of war; and to stir up trouble an sedition, for there is no honour military but by war, nor any such hop to mend an ill game, as by causing a new shuffle."} +{"text":"Desire of knowledge, and arts of peace, inclineth men to obey a commo power: for such desire, containeth a desire of leisure; an consequently protection from some other power than their own."} +{"text":"Desire of praise, disposeth to laudable actions, such as please the whose judgment they value; for of those men whom we contemn, we contem also the praises. Desire of fame after death does the same. And thoug after death, there be no sense of the praise given us on earth, a being joys, that are either swallowed up in the unspeakable joys o Heaven, or extinguished in the extreme torments of hell: yet is no such fame vain; because men have a present delight therein, from th foresight of it, and of the benefit that may redound thereby to thei posterity: which though they now see not, yet they imagine; an anything that is pleasure to the sense, the same also is pleasure i the imagination."} +{"text":"To have received from one, to whom we think ourselves equal, greate benefits than there is hope to requite, disposeth to counterfeit love but really secret hatred; and puts a man into the estate of a desperat debtor, that in declining the sight of his creditor, tacitly wishes hi there, where he might never see him more. For benefits oblige, an obligation is thraldom; and unrequitable obligation perpetual thraldom which is to one's equal, hateful. But to have received benefits fro one, whom we acknowledge for superior, inclines to love; because th obligation is no new depression: and cheerful acceptation, which me call \"gratitude,\" is such an honour done to the obliger, as is take generally for retribution. Also to receive benefits, though from a equal, or inferior, as long as there is hope of requital, disposeth t love: for in the intention of the receiver, the obligation is of ai and service mutual; from whence proceedeth an emulation of who shal exceed in benefiting; the most noble and profitable contentio possible; wherein the victor is pleased with his victory, and the othe revenged by confessing it."} +{"text":"To have done more hurt to a man, than he can or is willing to expiate inclineth the doer to hate the sufferer. For he must expect revenge, o forgiveness; both which are hateful."} +{"text":"Fear of oppression, disposeth a man to anticipate, or to seek aid b society: for there is no other way by which a man can secure his lif and liberty."} +{"text":"Men that distrust their own subtlety, are, in tumult and sedition better disposed for victory, than they that suppose themselves wise, o crafty. For these love to consult, the other, fearing to b circumvented, to strike first. And in sedition, men being always in th precincts of battle, to hold together, and use all advantages of force is a better stratagem, than any that can proceed from subtlety of wit."} +{"text":"Vainglorious men, such as without being conscious to themselves o great sufficiency, delight in supposing themselves gallant men, ar inclined only to ostentation; but not to attempt: because when dange or difficulty appears, they look for nothing but to have thei insufficiency discovered."} +{"text":"Vainglorious men, such as estimate their sufficiency by the flattery o other men, or the fortune of some precedent action, without assure ground of hope from the true knowledge of themselves, are inclined t rash engaging; and in the approach of danger, or difficulty, to retir if they can: because not seeing the way of safety, they will rathe hazard their honour, which may be salved with an excuse; than thei lives, for which no salve is sufficient."} +{"text":"Men that have a strong opinion of their own wisdom in matter o government, are disposed to ambition. Because without public employmen in council or magistracy, the honour of their wisdom is lost. An therefore eloquent speakers are inclined to ambition; for eloquenc seemeth wisdom, both to themselves and others."} +{"text":"Pusillanimity disposeth men to irresolution, and consequently to los the occasions, and fittest opportunities of action. For after men hav been in deliberation till the time of action approach, if it be no then manifest what is best to be done, it is a sign, the difference o motives, the one way and the other, are not great: therefore not t resolve then, is to lose the occasion by weighing of trifles; which i pusillanimity."} +{"text":"Frugality, though in poor men a virtue, maketh a man unapt to achiev such actions as require the strength of many men at once: for i weakeneth their endeavour, which is to be nourished and kept in vigou by reward."} +{"text":"Eloquence, with flattery, disposeth men to confide in them that hav it; because the former is seeming wisdom, the latter seeming kindness Add to them military reputation, and it disposeth men to adhere, an subject themselves to those men that have them. The two former havin given them caution against danger from him; the latter gives the caution against danger from others."} +{"text":"Want of science, that is, ignorance of causes, disposeth, or rathe constraineth a man to rely on the advice and authority of others. Fo all men whom the truth concerns, if they rely not on their own, mus rely on the opinion of some other, whom they think wiser tha themselves, and see not why he should deceive them."} +{"text":"Ignorance of the signification of words, which is want o understanding, disposeth men to take on trust, not only the truth the know not; but also the errors; and which is more, the nonsense of the they trust: for neither error nor nonsense, can without a perfec understanding of words, be detected."} +{"text":"From the same it proceedeth, that men give different names to one an the same thing, from the difference of their own passions: as they tha approve a private opinion, call it opinion; but they that mislike it heresy: and yet heresy signifies no more than private opinion; but ha only a greater tincture of choler."} +{"text":"From the same also it proceedeth, that men cannot distinguish, withou study and great understanding, between one action of many men, and man actions of one multitude; as for example, between one action of all th senators of Rome in killing Cataline, and the many actions of a numbe of senators in killing Caesar; and therefore are disposed to take fo the action of the people, that which is a multitude of actions done b a multitude of men, led perhaps by the persuasion of one."} +{"text":"Ignorance of the causes, and original constitution of right, equity law, and justice, disposeth a man to make custom and example the rul of his actions; in such manner, as to think that unjust which it hat been the custom to punish; and that just, of the impunity an approbation whereof they can produce an example, or, as the lawyer which only use this false measure of justice barbarously call it, precedent; like little children, that have no other rule of good an evil manners, but the correction they receive from their parents an masters; save that children are constant to their rule, whereas, me are not so; because grown old, and stubborn, they appeal from custom t reason, and from reason to custom, as it serves their turn; recedin from custom when their interest requires it, and setting themselve against reason, as oft as reason is against them: which is the cause that the doctrine of right and wrong is perpetually disputed, both b the pen and the sword: whereas the doctrine of lines, and figures, i not so; because men care not, in that subject, what be truth, as thing that crosses no man's ambition, profit or lust. For I doubt not but if it had been a thing contrary to any man's right of dominion, o to the interest of men that have dominion, \"that the three angles of triangle, should be equal to two angles of a square\"; that doctrin should have been, if not disputed, yet by the burning of all books o geometry, suppressed, as far as he whom it concerned was able."} +{"text":"Ignorance of remote causes, disposeth men to attribute all events t the causes immediate, and instrumental; for these are all the cause they perceive. And hence it comes to pass, that in all places, men tha are grieved with payments to the public, discharge their anger upon th publicans, that is to say, farmers, collectors, and other officers o the public revenue; and adhere to such as find fault with the publi government; and thereby, when they have engaged themselves beyond hop of justification, fall also upon the supreme authority, for fear o punishment, or shame of receiving pardon."} +{"text":"Ignorance of natural causes, disposeth a man to credulity, so as t believe many times impossibilities: for such know nothing to th contrary, but that they may be true; being unable to detect th impossibility. And credulity, because men like to be hearkened unto i company, disposeth them to lying: so that ignorance itself withou malice, is able to make a man both to believe lies, and tell them; an sometimes also to invent them."} +{"text":"Anxiety for the future time, disposeth men to inquire into the cause of things: because the knowledge of them maketh men the better able t order the present to their best advantage."} +{"text":"Curiosity, or love of the knowledge of causes, draws a man from th consideration of the effect, to seek the cause; and again, the cause o that cause; till of necessity he must come to this thought at last that there is some cause, whereof there is no former cause, but i eternal; which is it men call God. So that it is impossible to make an profound inquiry into natural causes, without being inclined thereby t believe there is one God eternal; though they cannot have any idea o Him in their mind, answerable to His nature. For as a man that is bor blind, hearing men talk of warming themselves by the fire, and bein brought to warm himself by the same, may easily conceive, and assur himself, there is somewhat there, which men call \"fire,\" and is th cause of the heat he feels; but cannot imagine what it is like; no have an idea of it in his mind, such as they have that see it: so als by the visible things in this world, and their admirable order, a ma may conceive there is a cause of them, which men call God; and yet no have an idea or image of Him in his mind."} +{"text":"And they that make little or no inquiry into the natural causes o things, yet from the fear that proceeds from the ignorance itself, o what it is that hath the power to do them much good or harm, ar inclined to suppose, and feign unto themselves, several kinds of power invisible; and to stand in awe of their own imaginations; and in tim of distress to invoke them; as also in the time of an expected goo success, to give them thanks; making the creatures of their own fancy their gods. By which means it hath come to pass, that from th innumerable variety of fancy, men have created in the world innumerabl sorts of gods. And this fear of things invisible, is the natural see of that, which everyone in himself calleth religion; and in them tha worship, or fear that power otherwise than they do, superstition."} +{"text":"And this seed of religion, having been observed by many; some of thos that have observed it, have been inclined thereby to nourish, dress and form it into laws; and to add to it of their own invention, an opinion of the causes of future events, by which they thought the should be best able to govern others, and make unto themselves th greatest use of their powers."} +{"text":"II"} +{"text":"Of Religion"} +{"text":"Seeing there are no signs, nor fruit of \"religion,\" but in man only there is no cause to doubt, but that the seed of \"religion\" is als only in man; and consisteth in some peculiar quality, or at least i some eminent degree thereof, not to be found in any other livin creatures."} +{"text":"And first, it is peculiar to the nature of man, to be inquisitive int the causes of the events they see, some more, some less; but all men s much, as to be curious in the search of the causes of their own goo and evil fortune."} +{"text":"Secondly, upon the sight of anything that hath a beginning, to thin also it had a cause, which determined the same to begin, then when i did, rather than sooner or later."} +{"text":"Thirdly, whereas there is no other felicity of beasts, but the enjoyin of their quotidian food, ease, and lusts; as having little or n foresight of the time to come, for want of observation, and memory o the order, consequence, and dependence of the things they see; ma observeth how one event hath been produced by another; and rememberet in them antecedence and consequence; and when he cannot assure himsel of the true causes of things, (for the causes of good and evil fortun for the most part are invisible,) he supposes causes of them, eithe such as his own fancy suggesteth; or trusteth the authority of othe men, such as he thinks to be his friends, and wiser than himself."} +{"text":"The two first make anxiety. For being assured that there be causes o all things that have arrived hitherto, or shall arrive hereafter, it i impossible for a man, who continually endeavoureth to secure himsel against the evil he fears, and procure the good he desireth, not to b in a perpetual solicitude of the time to come; so that every man especially those that are over-provident, are in a state like to tha of Prometheus. For as Prometheus, which, interpreted, is \"the pruden man,\" was bound to the hill Caucasus, a place of large prospect, wher an eagle feeding on his liver, devoured in the day, as much as wa repaired in the night: so that man, which looks too far before him i the care of future time, hath his heart all the day long gnawed on b fear of death, poverty, or other calamity, and has no repose, nor paus of his anxiety, but in sleep."} +{"text":"This perpetual fear, always accompanying mankind in the ignorance o causes, as it were in the dark, must needs have for object something And therefore when there is nothing to be seen, there is nothing t accuse, either of their good or evil fortune, but some \"power,\" o agent \"invisible,\" in which sense perhaps it was, that some of the ol poets said, that the gods were at first created by human fear: whic spoken of the gods, that is to say, of the many gods of the Gentiles is very true. But the acknowledging of one God, eternal, infinite, an omnipotent, may more easily be derived, from the desire men have t know the causes of natural bodies, and their several virtues an operations, than from the fear of what was to befall them in time t come. For he that from any effect he seeth come to pass, should reaso to the next and immediate cause thereof, and from thence to the caus of that cause, and plunge himself profoundly in the pursuit of causes shall at last come to this, that there must be, as even the heathe philosophers confessed, one first mover; that is, a first and a eternal cause of all things, which is that which men mean by the nam of God, and all this without thought of their fortune; the solicitud whereof both inclines to fear, and hinders them from the search of th causes of other things, and thereby gives occasion of feigning of a many gods as there be men that feign them."} +{"text":"And for the matter or substance of the invisible agents so fancied they could not by natural cogitation fall upon any other conceit, bu that it was the same with that of the soul of man; and that the soul o man was of the same substance with that which appeareth in a dream t one that sleepeth; or in a looking-glass, to one that is awake; which men not knowing that such apparitions are nothing else but creatures o the fancy, think to be real and external substances, and therefore cal them ghosts: as the Latins called them \"imagines\" and \"umbrae,\" an thought them spirits, that is, thin aerial bodies, and those invisibl agents which they feared to be like them, save that they appear an vanish when they please. But the opinion that such spirits wer incorporeal, or immaterial, could never enter into the mind of any ma by nature; because, though men may put together words of contradictor signification, as \"spirit,\" and \"incorporeal,\" yet they can never hav the imagination of anything answering to them: and therefore, men tha by their own meditation arrive to the acknowledgment of one infinite omnipotent, and eternal God, chose rather to confess He i incomprehensible, and above their understanding, than to define Hi nature by \"spirit incorporeal,\" and then confess their definition to b unintelligible; or, if they give Him such a title, it is no \"dogmatically\" with intention to make the divine nature understood; bu \"piously,\" to honour him with attributes, of significations as remot as they can from the grossness of bodies visible."} +{"text":"Then for the way by which they think these invisible agents wrough their effects; that is to say, what immediate causes they used, i bringing things to pass, men that know not what it is that we cal \"causing,\" that is, almost all men, have no other rule to guess by, bu by observing and remembering what they have seen to precede the lik effect at some other time, or times before, without seeing between th antecedent and subsequent event, any dependence or connection at all and therefore from the like things past, they expect the like things t come; and hope for good or evil luck, superstitiously, from things tha have no part at all in the causing of it: as the Athenians did fo their war at Lepanto, demand another Phormio; the Pompeian faction fo their war in Africa, another Scipio; and others have done in diver other occasions since. In like manner they attribute their fortune to stander-by, to a lucky or unlucky place, to words spoken, especially i the name of God be amongst them; as charming and conjuring, the liturg of witches; insomuch as to believe, they have power to turn a ston into bread, bread into a man, or anything into anything."} +{"text":"Thirdly, for the worship which naturally men exhibit to power invisible, it can be no other, but such expressions of their reverence as they would use towards men; gifts, petitions, thanks, submission o body, considerate addresses, sober behaviour, premeditated words swearing, that is, assuring one another of their promises, by invokin them. Beyond that reason suggesteth nothing; but leaves them either t rest there; or for further ceremonies, to rely on those they believe t be wiser than themselves."} +{"text":"Lastly, concerning how these invisible powers declare to men the thing which shall hereafter come to pass, especially concerning their good o evil fortune in general, or good or ill success in any particula undertaking, men are naturally at a stand; save that using t conjecture of the time to come, by the time past, they are very apt not only to take casual things, after one or two encounters, fo prognostics of the like encounter ever after, but also to believe th like prognostics from other men, of whom they have once conceived good opinion."} +{"text":"And in these four things, opinion of ghosts, ignorance of secon causes, devotion towards what men fear, and taking of things casual fo prognostics, consisteth the natural seed of \"religion\"; which by reaso of the different fancies, judgments, and passions of several men, hat grown up into ceremonies so different, that those which are used by on man, are for the most part ridiculous to another."} +{"text":"For these seeds have received culture from two sorts of men. One sor have been they that have nourished and ordered them, according to thei own invention. The other have done it, by God's commandment an direction: but both sorts have done it, with a purpose to make thos men that relied on them, the more apt to obedience, laws, peace charity, and civil society. So that the religion of the former sort i a part of human politics; and teacheth part of the duty which earthl kings require of their subjects. And the religion of the latter sort i divine politics; and containeth precepts to those that have yielde themselves subjects in the kingdom of God. Of the former sort were al the founders of commonwealths, and the lawgivers of the Gentiles: o the latter sort, were Abraham, Moses, and our blessed Saviour; by who have been derived unto us the laws of the kingdom of God."} +{"text":"And for that part of religion, which consisteth in opinions concernin the nature of powers invisible, there is almost nothing that has name, that has not been esteemed amongst the Gentiles, in one place o another, a god, or devil; or by their poets feigned to be inanimated inhabited, or possessed by some spirit or other."} +{"text":"The unformed matter of the world, was a god by the name of Chaos."} +{"text":"The heaven, the ocean, the planets, the fire, the earth, the winds were so many gods."} +{"text":"Men, women, a bird, a crocodile, a calf, a dog, a snake, an onion, leek, were deified. Besides that, they filled almost all places wit spirits called \"demons\"; the plains, with Pan and Panises, or Satyrs the woods, with Fauns, and Nymphs; the sea, with Tritons, and othe Nymphs; every river and fountain, with a ghost of his name, and wit Nymphs; every house with its \"Lares,\" or familiars; every man with hi \"Genius\"; hell with ghosts, and spiritual officers, as Charon Cerberus, and the Furies; and in the nighttime, all places wit \"larvae,\" \"lemures,\" ghosts of men deceased, and a whole kingdom o fairies and bugbears. They have also ascribed divinity, and buil temples to mere accidents and qualities; such as are time, night, day peace, concord, love, contention, virtue, honour, health, rust, fever and the like; which when they prayed for, or against, they prayed to as if there were ghosts of those names hanging over their heads, an letting fall, or withholding that good or evil, for or against whic they prayed. They invoked also their own wit, by the name of Muses their own ignorance, by the name of Fortune; their own lusts by th name of Cupid; their own rage, by the name of Furies; their own priv members, by the name of Priapus; and attributed their pollutions t Incubi and Succubae: insomuch as there was nothing, which a poet coul introduce as a person in his poem, which they did not make either \"god,\" or a \"devil.\""} +{"text":"The same authors of the religion of the Gentiles, observing the secon ground for religion, which is men's ignorance of causes; and thereb their aptness to attribute their fortune to causes, on which there wa no dependence at all apparent, took occasion to obtrude on thei ignorance, instead of second causes, a kind of second and ministeria gods; ascribing the cause of fecundity to Venus; the cause of arts, t Apollo; of subtlety and craft, to Mercury; of tempests and storms, t Aeolus; and of other effects, to other gods; insomuch as there wa amongst the heathen almost as great variety of gods as of business."} +{"text":"And to the worship, which naturally men conceived fit to be use towards their gods, namely, oblations, prayers, thanks, and the res formerly named; the same legislators of the Gentiles have added thei images, both in picture and sculpture; that the more ignorant sort that is to say, the most part or generality of the people, thinking th gods for whose representation they were made, were really included, an as it were housed within them, might so much the more stand in fear o them: and endowed them with lands, and houses, and officers, an revenues, set apart from all other human uses; that is, consecrated and made holy to those their idols; as caverns, groves, woods mountains, and whole islands; and have attributed to them, not only th shapes, some of men, some of beasts, some of monsters; but also th faculties and passions of men and beasts: as sense, speech, sex, lust generation, and this not only by mixing one with another, to propagat the kind of gods, but also by mixing with men and women, to bege mongrel gods, and but inmates of heaven, as Bacchus, Hercules, an others; besides anger, revenge, and other passions, of livin creatures, and the actions proceeding from them, as fraud, theft adultery, sodomy, and any vice that may be taken for an effect o power, or a cause of pleasure; and all such vices, as amongst men ar taken to be against law, rather than against honour."} +{"text":"Lastly, to the prognostics of time to come; which are naturally bu conjectures upon experience of time past; and supernaturally, divin revelation; the same authors of the religion of the Gentiles, partl upon pretended experience, partly upon pretended revelation, have adde innumerable other superstitious ways of divination; and made me believe they should find their fortunes, sometimes in the ambiguous o senseless answers of the priests at Delphi, Delos, Ammon, and othe famous oracles; which answers were made ambiguous by design, to own th event both ways; or absurd, by the intoxicating vapour of the place which is very frequent in sulphurous caverns: sometimes in the leave of the Sybils; of whose prophecies, like those perhaps of Nostradamu (for the fragments now extant seem to be the invention of later times) there were some books in reputation in the time of the Roman Republic sometimes in the insignificant speeches of madmen, supposed to b possessed with a divine spirit, which possession they calle enthusiasm; and these kinds of foretelling events were accounte theomancy, or prophecy: sometimes in the aspect of the stars at thei nativity; which was called horoscopy, and esteemed a part of judiciar astrology: sometimes in their own hopes and fears, called thumomancy or presage: sometimes in the prediction of witches, that pretende conference with the dead: which is called necromancy, conjuring, an witchcraft; and is but juggling and confederate knavery: sometimes i the casual flight or feeding of birds; called augury: sometimes in th entrails of a sacrificed beast; which was \"aruspicina\": sometimes i dreams; sometimes in croaking of ravens, or chattering of birds sometimes in the lineaments of the face; which was called metoposcopy or by palmistry in the lines of the hand; in casual words, calle \"omina\": sometimes in monsters, or unusual accidents; as eclipses comets, rare meteors, earthquakes, inundations, uncouth births, and th like, which they called \"portenta,\" and \"ostenta,\" because they though them to portend or foreshow some great calamity to come; sometimes, i mere lottery, as cross and pile, counting holes in a sieve; dipping o verses in Homer, and Virgil; and innumerable other such vain conceits So easy are men to be drawn to believe anything, from such men as hav gotten credit with them; and can with gentleness and dexterity tak hold of their fear and ignorance."} +{"text":"And therefore the first founders and legislators of commonwealths amon the Gentiles, whose ends were only to keep the people in obedience an peace, have in all places taken care; first, to imprint in their mind a belief, that those precepts which they gave concerning religion might not be thought to proceed from their own device, but from th dictates of some god, or other spirit; or else that they themselve were of a higher nature than mere mortals, that their laws might th more easily be received: so Numa Pompilius pretended to receive th ceremonies he instituted amongst the Romans, from the nymph Egeria: an the first king and founder of the kingdom of Peru, pretended himsel and his wife to be the children of the Sun; and Muhammad, to set up hi new religion, pretended to have conferences with the Holy Ghost, i form of a dove. Secondly, they have had a care to make it believed that the same things were displeasing to the gods which were forbidde by the laws. Thirdly, to prescribe ceremonies, supplications sacrifices, and festivals, by which they were to believe, the anger o the gods might be appeased; and that ill success in war, grea contagions of sickness, earthquakes, and each man's private misery came from the anger of the gods, and their anger from the neglect o their worship, or the forgetting or mistaking some point of th ceremonies required. And though amongst the ancient Romans, men wer not forbidden to deny that which in the poets is written of the pain and pleasures after this life: which divers of great authority an gravity in that state have in their harangues openly derided; yet tha belief was always more cherished than the contrary."} +{"text":"And by these, and such other institutions, they obtained in order t their end, which was the peace of the commonwealth, that the commo people in their misfortunes, laying the fault on neglect, or error i their ceremonies, or on their own disobedience to the laws, were th less apt to mutiny against their governors; and being entertained wit the pomp and pastime of festivals, and public games, made in honour o the gods, needed nothing else but bread to keep them from discontent murmuring, and commotion against the state. And therefore the Romans that had conquered the greatest part of the then known world, made n scruple of tolerating any religion whatsoever in the city of Rom itself; unless it had something in it that could not consist with thei civil government; nor do we read that any religion was there forbidden but that of the Jews; who, being the peculiar kingdom of God, though it unlawful to acknowledge subjection to any mortal king or stat whatsoever. And thus you see how the religion of the Gentiles was par of their policy."} +{"text":"But where God Himself, by supernatural revelation, planted religion there He also made to Himself a peculiar kingdom; and gave laws no only of behaviour towards Himself, but also towards one another; an thereby in the kingdom of God, the policy, and laws civil, are a par of religion; and therefore the distinction of temporal and spiritua domination, hath there no place. It is true that God is king of all th earth; yet may He be king of a peculiar and chosen nation. For there i no more incongruity therein, than that he that hath the general comman of the whole army, should have withal a peculiar regiment, or compan of his own. God is king of all the earth by His power; but of Hi chosen people He is king by covenant. But to speak more largely of th kingdom of God, both by nature and covenant, I have in the followin discourse assigned another place (chapter XXXV)."} +{"text":"From the propagation of religion, it is not hard to understand th causes of the resolution of the same into its first seeds, o principles; which are only an opinion of a deity, and powers invisibl and supernatural; that can never be so abolished out of human nature but that new religions may again be made to spring out of them, by th culture of such men as for such purpose are in reputation."} +{"text":"For seeing all formed religion, is founded at first upon the fait which a multitude hath in some one person, whom they believe not onl to be a wise man, and to labour to procure their happiness, but also t be a holy man, to whom God Himself vouchsafeth to declare His wil supernaturally; it followeth necessarily, when they that have th government of religion, shall come to have either the wisdom of thos men, their sincerity, or their love suspected; or when they shall b unable to show any probable token of divine revelation; that th religion which they desire to uphold, must be suspected likewise; and without the fear of the civil sword, contradicted and rejected."} +{"text":"That which taketh away the reputation of wisdom, in him that formeth religion, or addeth to it when it is already formed, is the enjoinin of a belief of contradictories; for both parts of a contradictio cannot possibly be true; and therefore to enjoin the belief of them, i an argument of ignorance; which detects the author in that; an discredits him in all things else he shall propound as from revelatio supernatural; which revelation a man may indeed have of many thing above, but of nothing against natural reason."} +{"text":"That which taketh away the reputation of sincerity, is the doing o saying of such things, as appear to be signs, that what they requir other men to believe is not believed by themselves; all which doings o sayings are therefore called scandalous, because they b stumbling-blocks, that make men to fall in the way of religion; a injustice, cruelty, profaneness, avarice, and luxury. For who ca believe that he that doth ordinarily such actions as proceed from an of these roots, believeth there is any such invisible power to b feared, as he affrighteth other men withal for lesser faults?"} +{"text":"That which taketh away the reputation of love, is the being detected o private ends; as when the belief they require of others, conduceth o seemeth to conduce to the acquiring of dominion, riches, dignity, o secure pleasure, to themselves only, or specially. For that which me reap benefit by to themselves, they are thought to do for their ow sakes, and not for love of others."} +{"text":"Lastly, the testimony that men can render of divine calling, can be n other than the operation of miracles; or true prophecy, which also is miracle; or extraordinary felicity. And therefore, to those points o religion, which have been received from them that did such miracles those that are added by such as approve not their calling by som miracle, obtain no greater belief than what the custom and laws of th places, in which they be educated, have wrought into them. For as i natural things, men of judgment require natural signs and arguments; s in supernatural things, they require signs supernatural, which ar miracles, before they consent inwardly, and from their hearts."} +{"text":"All which causes of the weakening of men's faith, do manifestly appea in the examples following. First, we have the example of the childre of Israel; who when Moses, that had approved his calling to them b miracles, and by the happy conduct of them out of Egypt, was absent bu forty days, revolted from the worship of the true God, recommended t them by him; and setting up (Exod. 33:1�-�2) a golden calf for thei god, relapsed into the idolatry of the Egyptians; from whom they ha been so lately delivered. And again, after Moses, Aaron, Joshua, an that generation which had seen the great works of God in Israel (Judge 2:11) were dead; another generation arose, and served Baal. So tha miracles failing, faith also failed."} +{"text":"Again, when the sons of Samuel (1 Sam. 8:3) being constituted by thei father judges in Bersabee, received bribes, and judged unjustly, th people of Israel refused any more to have God to be their king, i other manner than He was king of other people; and therefore cried ou to Samuel, to choose them a king after the manner of the nations. S that justice failing, faith also failed: insomuch, as they depose their God from reigning over them."} +{"text":"And whereas in the planting of Christian religion, the oracles cease in all parts of the Roman empire, and the number of Christian increased wonderfully every day, and in every place, by the preachin of the Apostles and Evangelists; a great part of that success ma reasonably be attributed to the contempt into which the priests of th Gentiles of that time had brought themselves by their uncleanness avarice, and juggling between princes. Also the religion of the Churc of Rome, was partly for the same cause abolished in England, and man other parts of Christendom, insomuch, as the failing of virtue in th pastors, maketh faith fail in the people: and partly from bringing o the philosophy and doctrine of Aristotle into religion, by th schoolmen; from whence there arose so many contradictions an absurdities, as brought the clergy into a reputation both of ignoranc and of fraudulent intention; and inclined people to revolt from them either against the will of their own princes, as in France and Holland or with their will, as in England."} +{"text":"Lastly, amongst the points by the Church of Rome declared necessary fo salvation, there be so many, manifestly to the advantage of the Pope and of his spiritual subjects, residing in the territories of othe Christian princes, that were it not for the mutual emulation of thos princes, they might without war or trouble, exclude all foreig authority, as easily as it has been excluded in England. For who i there that does not see to whose benefit it conduceth, to have i believed that a king hath not his authority from Christ, unless bishop crown him? That a king, if he be a priest, cannot marry? Tha whether a prince be born in lawful marriage, or not, must be judged b authority from Rome? That subjects may be freed from their allegiance if by the Court of Rome the king be judged an heretic? That a king, a Chilperic of France, may be deposed by a pope, as Pope Zachary, for n cause; and his kingdom given to one of his subjects? That the clerg and regulars, in what country soever, shall be exempt from th jurisdiction of their king in cases criminal? Or who does not see, t whose profit redound the fees of private masses, and vales o purgatory; with other signs of private interest, enough to mortify th most lively faith, if, as I said, the civil magistrate and custom di not more sustain it, than any opinion they have of the sanctity wisdom, or probity of their teachers? So that I may attribute all th changes of religion in the world to one and the same cause; and tha is, unpleasing priests; and those not only amongst Catholics, but eve in that Church that hath presumed most of reformation."} +{"text":"III"} +{"text":"Of the Natural Condition of Mankind as Concerning Their Felicity an Misery"} +{"text":"Nature hath made men so equal, in the faculties of the body and mind as that though there be found one man sometimes manifestly stronger i body, or of quicker mind than another, yet when all is reckone together, the difference between man and man, is not so considerable as that one man can thereupon claim to himself any benefit, to whic another may not pretend, as well as he. For as to the strength of body the weakest has strength enough to kill the strongest, either by secre machination, or by confederacy with others, that are in the same dange with himself."} +{"text":"And as to the faculties of the mind, setting aside the arts grounde upon words, and especially that skill of proceeding upon general an infallible rules, called science; which very few have, and but in fe things; as being not a native faculty, born with us; nor attained, a prudence, while we look after somewhat else, I find yet a greate equality amongst men than that of strength. For prudence is bu experience; which equal time, equally bestows on all men, in thos things they equally apply themselves unto. That which may perhaps mak such equality incredible, is but a vain conceit of one's own wisdom which almost all men think they have in a greater degree than th vulgar; that is, than all men but themselves, and a few others, whom b fame or for concurring with themselves, they approve. For such is th nature of men, that howsoever they may acknowledge many others to b more witty, or more eloquent, or more learned; yet they will hardl believe there be many so wise as themselves; for they see their own wi at hand, and other men's at a distance. But this proveth rather tha men are in that point equal, than unequal. For there is not ordinaril a greater sign of the equal distribution of anything, than that ever man is contented with his share."} +{"text":"From this equality of ability, ariseth equality of hope in th attaining of our ends. And therefore if any two men desire the sam thing, which nevertheless they cannot both enjoy, they become enemies and in the way to their end, which is principally their ow conservation, and sometimes their delectation only, endeavour t destroy or subdue one another. And from hence it comes to pass, tha where an invader hath no more to fear than another man's single power if one plant, sow, build, or possess a convenient seat, others ma probably be expected to come prepared with forces united, to disposses and deprive him, not only of the fruit of his labour, but also of hi life or liberty. And the invader again is in the like danger o another."} +{"text":"And from this diffidence of one another, there is no way for any man t secure himself, so reasonable, as anticipation; that is, by force, o wiles, to master the persons of all men he can, so long, till he see n other power great enough to endanger him: and this is no more than hi own conservation requireth, and is generally allowed. Also becaus there be some, that taking pleasure in contemplating their own power i the acts of conquest, which they pursue farther than their securit requires; if others, that otherwise would be glad to be at ease withi modest bounds, should not by invasion increase their power, they woul not be able, long time, by standing only on their defence, to subsist And by consequence, such augmentation of dominion over men bein necessary to a man's conservation, it ought to be allowed him."} +{"text":"Again, men have no pleasure, but on the contrary a great deal of grief in keeping company, where there is no power able to overawe them all For every man looketh that his companion should value him, at the sam rate he sets upon himself: and upon all signs of contempt, o undervaluing, naturally endeavours, as far as he dares, (which amongs them that have no common power to keep them in quiet, is far enough t make them destroy each other,) to extort a greater value from hi contemners, by damage; and from others, by the example."} +{"text":"So that in the nature of man, we find three principal causes o quarrel. First, competition; secondly, diffidence; thirdly, glory."} +{"text":"The first, maketh men invade for gain; the second, for safety; and th third, for reputation. The first use violence, to make themselve masters of other men's persons, wives, children, and cattle; th second, to defend them; the third, for trifles, as a word, a smile, different opinion, and any other sign of undervalue, either direct i their persons, or by reflection in their kindred, their friends, thei nation, their profession, or their name."} +{"text":"Hereby it is manifest, that during the time men live without a commo power to keep them all in awe, they are in that condition which i called war; and such a war, as is of every man, against every man. Fo \"war\" consisteth not in battle only, or the act of fighting; but in tract of time, wherein the will to contend by battle is sufficientl known: and therefore the notion of \"time\" is to be considered in th nature of war, as it is in the nature of weather. For as the nature o foul weather lieth not in a shower or two of rain, but in a inclination thereto of many days together; so the nature of wa consisteth not in actual fighting, but in the known disposition theret during all the time there is no assurance to the contrary. All othe time is \"peace.\""} +{"text":"Whatsoever therefore is consequent to a time of war, where every man i enemy to every man, the same is consequent to the time wherein men liv without other security than what their own strength and their ow invention shall furnish them withal. In such condition there is n place for industry, because the fruit thereof is uncertain, an consequently no culture of the earth; no navigation, nor use of th commodities that may be imported by sea; no commodious building; n instruments of moving and removing such things as require much force no knowledge of the face of the earth; no account of time; no arts; n letters; no society; and, which is worst of all, continual fear an danger of violent death; and the life of man, solitary, poor, nasty brutish, and short."} +{"text":"It may seem strange to some man, that has not well weighed thes things, that Nature should thus dissociate, and render men apt t invade and destroy one another; and he may therefore, not trusting t this inference, made from the passions, desire perhaps to have the sam confirmed by experience. Let him therefore consider with himself, whe taking a journey, he arms himself, and seeks to go well accompanied when going to sleep, he locks his doors; when even in his house, h locks his chests; and this when he knows there be laws, and publi officers, armed, to revenge all injuries shall be done him; wha opinion he has of his fellow-subjects, when he rides armed; of hi fellow-citizens, when he locks his doors; and of his children an servants, when he locks his chests. Does he not there as much accus mankind by his actions as I do by my words? But neither of us accus man's nature in it. The desires and other passions of man are i themselves no sin. No more are the actions that proceed from thos passions, till they know a law that forbids them; which till laws b made they cannot know, nor can any law be made till they have agree upon the person that shall make it."} +{"text":"It may peradventure be thought there was never such a time no condition of war as this; and I believe it was never generally so, ove all the world, but there are many places where they live so now. Fo the savage people in many places of America, except the government o small families, the concord whereof dependeth on natural lust, have n government at all, and live at this day in that brutish manner, as said before. Howsoever, it may be perceived what manner of life ther would be, where there were no common power to fear, by the manner o life which men that have formerly lived under a peaceful government use to degenerate into in a civil war."} +{"text":"But though there had never been any time, wherein particular men wer in a condition of war one against another; yet in all times, kings, an persons of sovereign authority, because of their independency, are i continual jealousies, and in the state and posture of gladiators having their weapons pointing, and their eyes fixed on one another that is, their forts, garrisons, and guns upon the frontiers of thei kingdoms; and continual spies upon their neighbours; which is a postur of war. But because they uphold thereby the industry of their subjects there does not follow from it that misery which accompanies the libert of particular men."} +{"text":"To this war of every man, against every man, this also is consequent that nothing can be unjust. The notions of right and wrong, justice an injustice, have there no place. Where there is no common power, ther is no law: where no law, no injustice. Force and fraud, are in war th two cardinal virtues. Justice and injustice are none of the facultie neither of the body nor mind. If they were, they might be in a man tha were alone in the world, as well as his senses, and passions. They ar qualities that relate to men in society, not in solitude. It i consequent also to the same condition, that there be no propriety, n dominion, no \"mine\" and \"thine\" distinct; but only that to be ever man's, that he can get; and for so long, as he can keep it. And thu much for the ill condition, which man by mere nature is actually place in; though with a possibility to come out of it, consisting partly i the passions, partly in his reason."} +{"text":"The passions that incline men to peace, are fear of death; desire o such things as are necessary to commodious living; and a hope by thei industry to obtain them. And reason suggesteth convenient articles o peace, upon which men may be drawn to agreement. These articles ar they which otherwise are called the Laws of Nature: whereof I shal speak more particularly, in the two following chapters."} +{"text":"IV"} +{"text":"Of the First and Second Natural Laws, and of Contracts"} +{"text":"\"The right of Nature,\" which writers commonly call jus naturale, is th liberty each man hath, to use his own power, as he will himself, fo the preservation of his own nature; that is to say, of his own life and consequently, of doing anything, which in his own judgment an reason he shall conceive to be the aptest means thereunto."} +{"text":"By \"liberty,\" is understood, according to the proper signification o the word, the absence of external impediments: which impediments ma oft take away part of a man's power to do what he would; but canno hinder him from using the power left him, according as his judgment an reason shall dictate to him."} +{"text":"A \"law of Nature,\" lex naturalis, is a precept or general rule, foun out by reason, by which a man is forbidden to do that which i destructive of his life, or taketh away the means of preserving th same; and to omit that, by which he thinketh it may be best preserved For though they that speak of this subject, use to confound \"jus\" an \"lex,\" \"right\" and \"law\": yet they ought to be distinguished; becaus \"right,\" consisteth in liberty to do, or to forbear; whereas \"law,\ determineth and bindeth to one of them; so that law and right differ a much as obligation and liberty; which in one and the same matter ar inconsistent."} +{"text":"And because the condition of man, as hath been declared in th precedent chapter, is a condition of war of everyone against everyone in which case everyone is governed by his own reason; and there i nothing he can make use of, that may not be a help unto him, i preserving his life against his enemies; it followeth, that in such condition, every man has a right to everything; even to one another' body. And therefore, as long as this natural right of every man t everything endureth, there can be no security to any man, how strong o wise soever he be, of living out the time, which Nature ordinaril alloweth men to live. And consequently it is a precept, or general rul of reason, \"that every man ought to endeavour peace, as far as he ha hope of obtaining it; and when he cannot obtain it, that he may seek and use, all helps, and advantages of war.\" The first branch of whic rule, containeth the first, and fundamental law of Nature; which is \"to seek peace, and follow it.\" The second, the sum of the right o Nature: which is, \"by all means we can, to defend ourselves.\""} +{"text":"From this fundamental law of Nature, by which men are commanded t endeavour peace, is derived this second law; \"that a man be willing when others are so too, as far-forth, as for peace, and defence o himself He shall think it necessary, to lay down this right to al things; and be contented with so much liberty against other men, as h would allow other men against himself.\" For as long as every ma holdeth this right, of doing anything he liketh; so long are all men i the condition of war. But if other men will not lay down their right as well as he; then there is no reason for anyone to divest himself o his: for that were to expose himself to prey, which no man is bound to rather than to dispose himself to peace. This is that law of th Gospel; \"whatsoever you require that others should do to you, that d ye to them.\" And that law of all men, quod tibi fieri non vis, alter ne feceris."} +{"text":"To \"lay down\" a man's \"right\" to anything, is to \"divest\" himself o the \"liberty,\" of hindering another of the benefit of his own right t the same. For he that renounceth, or passeth away his right, giveth no to any other man a right which he had not before; because there i nothing to which every man had not right by Nature: but only standet out of his way, that he may enjoy his own original right, withou hindrance from him; not without hindrance from another. So that th effect which redoundeth to one man, by another man's defect of right is but so much diminution of impediments to the use of his own righ original."} +{"text":"Right is laid aside, either by simply renouncing it; or by transferrin it to another. By \"simply renouncing\"; when he cares not to whom th benefit thereof redoundeth. By \"transferring\"; when he intendeth th benefit thereof to some certain person or persons. And when a man hat in either manner abandoned, or granted away his right; then is he sai to be \"obliged,\" or \"bound,\" not to hinder those, to whom such right i granted, or abandoned, from the benefit of it: and that he \"ought,\" an it is his \"duty,\" not to make void that voluntary act of his own: an that such hindrance is \"injustice,\" and \"injury,\" as being sine jure the right being before renounced, or transferred. So that \"injury,\" o \"injustice,\" in the controversies of the world, is somewhat like t that, which in the disputations of scholars is called \"absurdity.\" Fo as it is there called an absurdity, to contradict what one maintaine in the beginning: so in the world it is called injustice and injur voluntarily to undo that from the beginning he had voluntarily done The way by which a man either simply renounceth, or transferreth hi right, is a declaration, or signification, by some voluntary an sufficient sign, or signs, that he doth so renounce, or transfer; o hath so renounced, or transferred the same, to him that accepteth it And these signs are either words only, or actions only; or, as i happeneth most often, both words and actions. And the same are th \"bonds,\" by which men are bound, and obliged: bonds, that have thei strength, not from their own nature, for nothing is more easily broke than a man's word, but from fear of some evil consequence upon th rupture."} +{"text":"Whensoever a man transferreth his right, or renounceth it, it is eithe in consideration of some right reciprocally transferred to himself; o for some other good he hopeth for thereby. For it is a voluntary act and of the voluntary acts of every man, the object is some \"good t himself.\" And therefore there be some rights, which no man can b understood by any words, or other signs, to have abandoned o transferred. As first a man cannot lay down the right of resisting the that assault him by force, to take away his life; because he cannot b understood to aim thereby at any good to himself. The same may be sai of wounds, and chains, and imprisonment; both because there is n benefit consequent to such patience; as there is to the patience o suffering another to be wounded, or imprisoned; as also because a ma cannot tell, when he seeth men proceed against him by violence, whethe they intend his death or not. And lastly the motive and end for whic this renouncing, and transferring of right is introduced, is nothin else but the security of a man's person, in his life, and in the mean of so preserving life, as not to be weary of it. And therefore if a ma by words, or other signs, seem to despoil himself of the end, for whic those signs were intended; he is not to be understood as if he mean it, or that it was his will; but that he was ignorant of how such word and actions were to be interpreted."} +{"text":"The mutual transferring of right, is that which men call \"contract.\""} +{"text":"There is difference between transferring of right to the thing; an transferring, or tradition, that is delivery of the thing itself. Fo the thing may be delivered together with the translation of the right as in buying and selling with ready money; or exchange of goods, o lands; and it may be delivered some time after."} +{"text":"Again, one of the contractors may deliver the thing contracted for o his part, and leave the other to perform his part at some determinat time after, and in the meantime be trusted; and then the contract o his part is called \"pact,\" or \"covenant\": or both parts may contrac now, to perform hereafter; in which cases, he that is to perform i time to come, being trusted, his performance is called \"keeping o promise,\" or faith; and the failing of performance, if it be voluntary \"violation of faith.\""} +{"text":"When the transferring of right, is not mutual: but one of the partie transferreth, in hope to gain thereby friendship, or service fro another, or from his friends; or in hope to gain the reputation o charity, or magnanimity, or to deliver his mind from the pain o compassion; or in hope of reward in heaven; this is not contract, bu \"gift,\" \"free gift,\" \"grace,\" which words signify one and the sam thing."} +{"text":"Signs of contract, are either \"express,\" or \"by inference.\" Express are words spoken with understanding of what they signify; and suc words are either of the time \"present,\" or \"past\"; as, \"I give,\" \" grant,\" \"I have given,\" \"I have granted,\" \"I will that this be yours\" or of the future, as, \"I will give,\" \"I will grant\"; which words of th future are called \"promise.\""} +{"text":"Signs by inference are sometimes the consequence of words; sometime the consequence of silence; sometimes the consequence of actions sometimes the consequence of forbearing an action: and generally a sig by inference, of any contract, is whatsoever sufficiently argues th will of the contractor."} +{"text":"Words alone, if they be of the time to come, and contain a bar promise, are an insufficient sign of a free gift, and therefore no obligatory. For if they be of the time to come, as \"tomorrow I wil give,\" they are a sign I have not given yet, and consequently that m right is not transferred, but remaineth till I transfer it by som other act. But if the words be of the time present, or past, as, \" have given,\" or, \"do give to be delivered tomorrow,\" then is m tomorrow's right given away today; and that by the virtue of the words though there were no other argument of my will. And there is a grea difference in the signification of these words, volo hoc tuum ess cras, and cras dabo; that is, between \"I will that this be thin tomorrow,\" and, \"I will give it thee tomorrow\": for the word \"I will,\ in the former manner of speech, signifies an act of the will present but in the latter, it signifies a promise of an act of the will t come: and therefore the former words, being of the present, transfer future right; the latter, that be of the future, transfer nothing. Bu if there be other signs of the will to transfer a right, besides words then, though the gift be free, yet may the right be understood to pas by words of the future: as if a man propound a prize to him that come first to the end of a race, the gift is free; and though the words b of the future, yet the right passeth: for if he would not have hi words so be understood, he should not have let them run."} +{"text":"In contracts, the right passeth, not only where the words are of th time present, or past, but also where they are of the future: becaus all contract is mutual translation, or change of right; and therefor he that promiseth only, because he hath already received the benefi for which he promiseth, is to be understood as if he intended the righ should pass: for unless he had been content to have his words s understood, the other would not have performed his part first. And fo that cause, in buying and selling, and other acts of contract, promise is equivalent to a covenant; and therefore obligatory."} +{"text":"He that performeth first in the case of a contract, is said to \"merit\ that which he is to receive by the performance of the other; and h hath it as \"due.\" Also when a prize is propounded to many, which is t be given to him only that winneth; or money is thrown amongst many, t be enjoyed by them that catch it; though this be a free gift; yet so t win, or so to catch, is to \"merit,\" and to have it as \"due.\" For th right is transferred in the propounding of the prize, and in throwin down the money; though it be not determined to whom, but by the even of the contention. But there is between these two sorts of merit, thi difference, that in contract, I merit by virtue of my own power, an the contractor's need; but in this case of free gift, I am enabled t merit only by the benignity of the giver: in contract, I merit at th contractor's hand that he should depart with his right; in this case o gift, I merit not that the giver should part with his right; but tha when he has parted with it, it should be mine, rather than another's And this I think to be the meaning of that distinction of the schools between meritum congrui, and meritum condigni. For God Almighty, havin promised Paradise to those men, hoodwinked with carnal desires, tha can walk through this world according to the precepts and limit prescribed by Him; they say, he that shall so walk, shall meri Paradise ex congruo. But because no man can demand a right to it, b his own righteousness, or any other power in himself, but by the fre grace of God only; they say, no man can merit Paradise ex condigno This I say, I think is the meaning of that distinction; but becaus disputers do not agree upon the signification of their own terms o art, longer than it serves their turn; I will not affirm anything o their meaning: only this I say; when a gift is given indefinitely, as prize to be contended for, he that winneth meriteth, and may claim th prize as due."} +{"text":"If a covenant be made, wherein neither of the parties perfor presently, but trust one another; in the condition of mere nature which is a condition of war of every man against every man, upon an reasonable suspicion, it is void; but if there be a common power se over them both, with right and force sufficient to compel performance it is not void. For he that performeth first, has no assurance th other will perform after; because the bonds of words are too weak t bridle men's ambition, avarice, anger, and other passions, without th fear of some coercive power; which in the condition of mere nature where all men are equal, and judges of the justness of their own fears cannot possibly be supposed. And therefore he which performeth first does but betray himself to his enemy; contrary to the right, he ca never abandon, of defending his life and means of living."} +{"text":"But in a civil estate, where there is a power set up to constrain thos that would otherwise violate their faith, that fear is no mor reasonable, and for that cause, he which by the covenant is to perfor first, is obliged so to do."} +{"text":"The cause of fear, which maketh such a covenant invalid, must be alway something arising after the covenant made; as some new fact, or othe sign of the will not to perform: else it cannot make the covenant void For that which could not hinder a man from promising, ought not to b admitted as a hindrance of performing."} +{"text":"He that transferreth any right, transferreth the means of enjoying it as far as lieth in his power. As he that selleth land, is understood t transfer the herbage, and whatsoever grows upon it: nor can he tha sells a mill turn away the stream that drives it. And they that give t a man the right of government in sovereignty, are understood to giv him the right of levying money to maintain soldiers; and of appointin magistrates for the administration of justice."} +{"text":"To make covenants with brute beasts, is impossible; because no understanding our speech, they understand not, nor accept of an translation of right; nor can translate any right to another: an without mutual acceptation, there is no covenant."} +{"text":"To make covenant with God, is impossible, but by mediation of such a God speaketh to, either by revelation supernatural, or by Hi lieutenants that govern under Him, and in His name: for otherwise w know not whether our covenants be accepted, or not. And therefore the that vow anything contrary to any law of Nature, vow in vain; as bein a thing unjust to pay such vow. And if it be a thing commanded by th law of Nature, it is not the vow, but the law that binds them."} +{"text":"The matter, or subject of a covenant, is always something that fallet under deliberation; for to covenant is an act of the will; that is t say, an act, and the last act of deliberation; and is therefore alway understood to be something to come; and which is judged possible fo him that covenanteth to perform."} +{"text":"And therefore, to promise that which is known to be impossible, is n covenant. But if that prove impossible afterwards, which before wa thought possible, the covenant is valid, and bindeth, though not to th thing itself, yet to the value; or, if that also be impossible, to th unfeigned endeavour of performing as much as is possible: for to mor no man can be obliged."} +{"text":"Men are freed of their covenants two ways; by performing, or by bein forgiven. For performance is the natural end of obligation; an forgiveness the restitution of liberty; as being a retransferring o that right, in which the obligation consisted."} +{"text":"Covenants entered into by fear, in the condition of mere nature, ar obligatory. For example, if I covenant to pay a ransom, or service fo my life, to an enemy, I am bound by it, for it is a contract, wherei one receiveth the benefit of life; the other is to receive money, o service for it; and consequently, where no other law, as in th condition of mere nature, forbiddeth the performance, the covenant i valid. Therefore prisoners of war, if trusted with the payment of thei ransom, are obliged to pay it: and if a weaker prince make disadvantageous peace with a stronger, for fear, he is bound to kee it; unless, as hath been said before, there ariseth some new and jus cause of fear, to renew the war. And even in commonwealths, if I b forced to redeem myself from a thief by promising him money, I am boun to pay it, till the civil law discharge me. For whatsoever I ma lawfully do without obligation, the same I may lawfully covenant to d through fear, and what I lawfully covenant, I cannot lawfully break."} +{"text":"A former covenant makes void a later. For a man that hath passed awa his right to one man today, hath it not to pass tomorrow to another and therefore the later promise passeth no right, but is null."} +{"text":"A covenant not to defend myself from force, by force, is always void For, as I have shown before, no man can transfer, or lay down his righ to save himself from death, wounds, and imprisonment, the avoidin whereof is the only end of laying down any right; and therefore th promise of not resisting force, in no covenant transferreth any right nor is obliging. For though a man may covenant thus, \"unless I do so or so, kill me,\" he cannot covenant thus, \"unless I do so, or so, will not resist you when you come to kill me.\" For man by natur chooseth the lesser evil, which is danger of death in resisting, rathe than the greater, which is certain and present death in not resisting And this is granted to be true by all men, in that they lead criminal to execution and prison, with armed men, notwithstanding that suc criminals have consented to the law by which they are condemned."} +{"text":"A covenant to accuse oneself, without assurance of pardon, is likewis invalid. For in the condition of nature, where every man is judge there is no place for accusation: and in the civil state, th accusation is followed with punishment; which being force, a man is no obliged not to resist. The same is also true of the accusation of thos by whose condemnation a man falls into misery; as of a father, wife, o benefactor. For the testimony of such an accuser, if it be no willingly given, is presumed to be corrupted by nature, and therefor not to be received: and where a man's testimony is not to be credited he is not bound to give it. Also accusations upon torture, are not t be reputed as testimonies. For torture is to be used but as means o conjecture and light, in the further examination and search of truth and what is in that case confessed, tendeth to the ease of him that i tortured, not to the informing of the torturers, and therefore ough not to have the credit of a sufficient testimony; for whether h deliver himself by true or false accusation, he does it by the right o preserving his own life."} +{"text":"The force of words being, as I have formerly noted, too weak to hol men to the performance of their covenants; there are in man's natur but two imaginable helps to strengthen it. And those are either a fea of the consequence of breaking their word, or a glory or pride i appearing not to need to break it. This latter is a generosity to rarely found to be presumed on, especially in the pursuers of wealth command, or sensual pleasure, which are the greatest part of mankind The passion to be reckoned upon is fear; whereof there be two ver general objects: one, the power of spirits invisible; the other, th power of those men they shall therein offend. Of these two, though th former be the greater power, yet the fear of the latter is commonly th greater fear. The fear of the former is in every man his own religion which hath place in the nature of man before civil society. The latte hath not so, at least not place enough to keep men to their promises because in the condition of mere nature, the inequality of power is no discerned, but by the event of battle. So that before the time of civi society, or in the interruption thereof by war, there is nothing ca strengthen a covenant of peace agreed on, against the temptations o avarice, ambition, lust, or other strong desire, but the fear of tha invisible power, which they everyone worship as God, and fear as revenger of their perfidy. All therefore that can be done between tw men not subject to civil power, is to put one another to swear by th God he feareth, which \"swearing,\" or \"oath,\" is \"a form of speech added to a promise; by which he that promiseth, signifieth, that unles he perform, he renounceth the mercy of his God, or calleth to Him fo vengeance on himself.\" Such was the heathen form, \"Let Jupiter kill m else, as I kill this beast.\" So is our form, \"I shall do thus, an thus, so help me God.\" And this, with the rites and ceremonies, whic everyone useth in his own religion, that the fear of breaking fait might be the greater."} +{"text":"By this it appears, that an oath taken according to any other form, o rite, than his that sweareth, is in vain; and no oath: and that ther is no swearing by anything which the swearer thinks not God. For thoug men have sometimes used to swear by their kings, for fear, or flattery yet they would have it thereby understood, they attributed to the divine honour. And that swearing unnecessarily by God, is but profanin of His name: and swearing by other things, as men do in commo discourse, is not swearing, but an impious custom, gotten by too muc vehemence of talking."} +{"text":"It appears also, that the oath adds nothing to the obligation. For covenant, if lawful, binds in the sight of God, without the oath, a much as with it: if unlawful, bindeth not at all; though it b confirmed with an oath."} +{"text":"V"} +{"text":"Of Other Laws of Nature"} +{"text":"From that law of Nature, by which we are obliged to transfer t another, such rights, as being retained, hinder the peace of mankind there followeth a third; which is this, \"that men perform thei covenants made\"; without which, covenants are in vain, and but empt words; and the right of all men to all things remaining, we are stil in the condition of war."} +{"text":"And in this law of Nature consisteth the fountain and original o \"justice.\" For where no covenant hath preceded, there hath no righ been transferred, and every man has right to everything; an consequently, no action can be unjust. But when a covenant is made then to break it is \"unjust\": and the definition of \"injustice,\" is n other than \"the not performance of covenant.\" And whatsoever is no unjust, is \"just.\""} +{"text":"But because covenants of mutual trust, where there is a fear of no performance on either part, as hath been said in the former chapter are invalid; though the original of justice be the making of covenants yet injustice actually there can be none, till the cause of such fea be taken away; which while men are in the natural condition of war cannot be done. Therefore before the names of just and unjust can hav place, there must be some coercive power, to compel men equally to th performance of their covenants, by the terror of some punishment greater than the benefit they expect by the breach of their covenant and to make good that propriety, which by mutual contract men acquire in recompense of the universal right they abandon: and such power ther is none before the erection of a commonwealth. And this is also to b gathered out of the ordinary definition of justice in the schools: fo they say, that \"justice is the constant will of giving to every man hi own.\" And therefore where there is no \"own,\" that is no propriety there is no injustice; and where there is no coercive power erected that is, where there is no commonwealth, there is no propriety; all me having right to all things: therefore where there is no commonwealth there nothing is unjust. So that the nature of justice, consisteth i keeping of valid covenants: but the validity of covenants begins no but with the constitution of a civil power, sufficient to compel men t keep them; and then it is also that propriety begins."} +{"text":"The fool hath said in his heart, there is no such thing as justice; an sometimes also with his tongue; seriously alleging, that every man' conservation, and contentment, being committed to his own care, ther could be no reason why every man might not do what he thought conduce thereunto: and therefore also to make, or not make; keep, or not kee covenants, was not against reason, when it conduced to one's benefit He does not therein deny, that there be covenants; and that they ar sometimes broken, sometimes kept; and that such breach of them may b called injustice, and the observance of them justice; but h questioneth, whether injustice, taking away the fear of God, for th same fool hath said in his heart there is no God, may not sometime stand with that reason, which dictateth to every man his own good; an particularly then, when it conduceth to such a benefit, as shall put man in a condition to neglect not only the dispraise, and revilings but also the power of other men. The kingdom of God is gotten b violence; but what if it could be gotten by unjust violence? were i against reason so to get it, when it is impossible to receive hurt b it? and if it be not against reason, it is not against justice; or els justice is not to be approved for good. From such reasoning as this successful wickedness hath obtained the name of virtue; and some tha in all other things have disallowed the violation of faith; yet hav allowed it, when it is for the getting of a kingdom. And the heathe that believed that Saturn was deposed by his son Jupiter, believe nevertheless the same Jupiter to be the avenger of injustice; somewha like to a piece of law in Coke's \"Commentaries on Littleton\"; where h says, if the right heir of the crown be attainted of treason; yet th crown shall descend to him, and eo instante the attainder be void: fro which instances a man will be very prone to infer, that when the hei apparent of a kingdom shall kill him that is in possession, though hi father; you may call it injustice, or by what other name you will; ye it can never be against reason, seeing all the voluntary actions of me tend to the benefit of themselves; and those actions are mos reasonable, that conduce most to their ends. This specious reasoning i nevertheless false."} +{"text":"For the question is not of promises mutual, where there is no securit of performance on either side; as when there is no civil power erecte over the parties promising; for such promises are no covenants: bu either where one of the parties has performed already; or where ther is a power to make him perform; there is the question whether it b against reason, that is, against the benefit of the other to perform or not. And I say it is not against reason. For the manifestatio whereof, we are to consider; first, that when a man doth a thing, whic notwithstanding anything can be foreseen and reckoned on, tendeth t his own destruction, howsoever some accident which he could not expect arriving may turn it to his benefit; yet such events do not make i reasonably or wisely done. Secondly, that in a condition of war wherein every man to every man, for want of a common power to keep the all in awe, is an enemy, there is no man who can hope by his ow strength, or wit, to defend himself from destruction, without the hel of confederates; where everyone expects the same defence by th confederation, that anyone else does: and therefore he which declare he thinks it reason to deceive those that help him, can in reaso expect no other means of safety than what can be had from his ow single power. He therefore that breaketh his covenant, and consequentl declareth that he thinks he may with reason do so, cannot be receive into any society, that unite themselves for peace and defence, but b the error of them that receive him; nor when he is received, b retained in it, without seeing the danger of their error; which error a man cannot reasonably reckon upon as the means of his security; an therefore if he be left, or cast out of society, he perisheth; and i he live in society, it is by the errors of other men, which he coul not foresee, nor reckon upon; and consequently against the reason o his preservation; and so, as all men that contribute not to hi destruction, forbear him only out of ignorance of what is good fo themselves."} +{"text":"As for the instance of gaining the secure and perpetual felicity o heaven, by any way, it is frivolous: there being but one wa imaginable; and that is not breaking, but keeping of covenant."} +{"text":"And for the other instance of attaining sovereignty by rebellion; it i manifest, that though the event follow, yet because it canno reasonably be expected, but rather the contrary; and because by gainin it so, others are taught to gain the same in like manner, the attemp thereof is against reason. Justice therefore, that is to say, keepin of covenant, is a rule of reason, by which we are forbidden to d anything destructive to our life; and consequently a law of Nature."} +{"text":"There be some that proceed further; and will not have the law of Natur to be those rules which conduce to the preservation of man's life o earth; but to the attaining of an eternal felicity after death; t which they think the breach of covenant may conduce; and consequentl be just and reasonable; such are they that think it a work of merit t kill, or depose, or rebel against the sovereign power constituted ove them by their own consent. But because there is no natural knowledge o man's estate after death; much less of the reward that is then to b given to breach of faith; but only a belief grounded upon other men' saying, that they know it supernaturally, or that they know those tha knew them, that knew others, that knew it supernaturally; breach o faith cannot be called a precept of reason, or nature."} +{"text":"Others, that allow for a law of Nature the keeping of faith, d nevertheless make exception of certain persons; as heretics, and suc as use not to perform their covenant to others: and this also i against reason. For if any fault of a man be sufficient to discharg our covenant made; the same ought in reason to have been sufficient t have hindered the making of it."} +{"text":"The names of just, and unjust, when they are attributed to men, signif one thing; and when they are attributed to actions, another. When the are attributed to men, they signify conformity, or inconformity o manners, to reason. But when they are attributed to actions the signify the conformity or inconformity to reason, not of manners o manner of life, but of particular actions. A just man, therefore, is h that taketh all the care he can that his actions may be all just, an an unjust man is he that neglecteth it. And such men are more often i our language styled by the names of righteous and unrighteous than jus and unjust, though the meaning be the same. Therefore, a righteous ma does not lose that title by one or a few unjust actions that procee from sudden passion or mistake of things or persons; nor does a unrighteous man lose his character for such actions as he does, o forbears to do, for fear, because his will is not framed by th justice, but by the apparent benefit of what he is to do. That whic gives to human actions the relish of justice is a certain nobleness o gallantness of courage, rarely found, by which a man scorns to b beholden, for the contentment of his life, to fraud or breach o promise. This justice of the manners is that which is meant, wher justice is called a virtue, and injustice a vice."} +{"text":"But the justice of actions denominates men, not just, but \"guiltless\" and the injustice of the same, which is also called injury, gives the but the name of \"guilty.\""} +{"text":"Again, the injustice of manners is the disposition or aptitude to d injury; and is injustice before it proceeds to act, and withou supposing any individual person injured. But the injustice of a action, that is to say injury, supposeth an individual person injured namely, him to whom the covenant was made; and therefore many times th injury is received by one man when the damage redoundeth to another. A when the master commandeth his servant to give money to a stranger: i it be not done, the injury is done to the master, whom he had befor covenanted to obey; but the damage redoundeth to the stranger, to who he had no obligation, and therefore could not injure him. And so als in commonwealths. Private men may remit to one another their debts, bu not robberies or other violences, whereby they are endamaged, becaus the detaining of debt is an injury to themselves, but robbery an violence are injuries to the person of the commonwealth."} +{"text":"Whatsoever is done to a man, conformable to his own will signified t the doer, is no injury to him. For if he that doeth it, hath not passe away his original right to do what he please, by some anteceden covenant, there is no breach of covenant; and therefore no injury don him. And if he have, then his will to have it done being signified, i a release of that covenant; and so again there is no injury done him."} +{"text":"Justice of actions, is by writers divided into \"commutative,\" an \"distributive\": and the former they say consisteth in proportio arithmetical; the latter in proportion geometrical. Commutative therefore, they place in the equality of value of the things contracte for; and distributive, in the distribution of equal benefit, to men o equal merit. As if it were injustice to sell dearer than we buy; or t give more to a man than he merits. The value of all things contracte for, is measured by the appetite of the contractors: and therefore th just value is that which they be contented to give. And merit, beside that which is by covenant, where the performance on one part, meritet the performance of the other part, and falls under justice commutative not distributive, is not due by justice; but is rewarded of grace only And therefore this distinction, in the sense wherein it useth to b expounded, is not right. To speak properly, commutative justice is th justice of a contractor; that is, a performance of covenant, in buyin and selling; hiring, and letting to hire; lending, and borrowing exchanging, bartering, and other acts of contract."} +{"text":"And distributive justice, the justice of an arbitrator; that is to say the act of defining what is just. Wherein, being trusted by them tha make him arbitrator, if he perform his trust, he is said to distribut to every man his own: and this is indeed just distribution, and may b called, though improperly, distributive justice; but more properl equity; which also is a law of Nature, as shall be shown in due place."} +{"text":"As justice dependeth on antecedent covenant; so does \"gratitude\" depen on antecedent grace; that is to say, antecedent free gift: and is th fourth law of Nature; which may be conceived in this form, \"that a ma which receiveth benefit from another of mere grace, endeavour that h which giveth it, have no reasonable cause to repent him of his goo will.\" For no man giveth, but with intention of good to himself because gift is voluntary; and of all voluntary acts, the object is t every man his own good; of which if men see they shall be frustrated there will be no beginning of benevolence, or trust, nor consequentl of mutual help; nor of reconciliation of one man to another; an therefore they are to remain still in the condition of \"war,\" which i contrary to the first and fundamental law of Nature, which commandet men to \"seek peace.\" The breach of this law, is called \"ingratitude,\ and hath the same relation to grace that injustice hath to obligatio by covenant."} +{"text":"A fifth law of Nature, is \"complaisance\": that is to say, \"that ever man strive to accommodate himself to the rest.\" For the understandin whereof, we may consider, that there is in men's aptness to society, diversity of nature, rising from their diversity of affections; no unlike to that we see in stones brought together for building of a edifice. For as that stone which by the asperity, and irregularity o figure, takes more room from others than itself fills; and for th hardness, cannot be easily made plain, and thereby hindereth th building, is by the builders cast away as unprofitable and troublesome so also, a man that by asperity of nature, will strive to retain thos things which to himself are superfluous, and to others necessary; an for the stubbornness of his passions, cannot be corrected, is to b left, or cast out of society, as cumbersome thereunto. For seeing ever man, not only by right, but also by necessity of nature, is supposed t endeavour all he can, to obtain that which is necessary for hi conservation; he that shall oppose himself against it, for thing superfluous, is guilty of the war that thereupon is to follow; an therefore doth that which is contrary to the fundamental law of Nature which commandeth \"to seek peace.\" The observers of this law, may b called \"sociable,\" the Latins call them commodi; the contrary \"stubborn,\" \"insociable,\" \"froward,\" \"intractable.\""} +{"text":"A sixth law of Nature is this, \"that upon caution of the future time, man ought to pardon the offences past of them that repenting, desir it.\" For \"pardon\" is nothing but granting of peace; which thoug granted to them that persevere in their hostility, be not peace, bu fear; yet not granted to them that give caution of the future time, i sign of an aversion to peace; and therefore contrary to the law o Nature."} +{"text":"A seventh is, \"that in revenges,\" that is, retribution of evil fo evil, \"men look not at the greatness of the evil past, but th greatness of the good to follow.\" Whereby we are forbidden to inflic punishment with any other design, than for correction of the offender or direction of others. For this law is consequent to the next befor it, that commandeth pardon, upon security of the future time. Besides revenge, without respect to the example and profit to come, is triumph or glorying in the hurt of another, tending to no end; for th end is always somewhat to come; and glorying to no end, is vainglory and contrary to reason, and to hurt without reason, tendeth to th introduction of war; which is against the law of Nature; and i commonly styled by the name of \"cruelty.\""} +{"text":"And because all signs of hatred, or contempt, provoke to fight insomuch as most men choose rather to hazard their life than not to b revenged; we may in the eighth place, for a law of Nature, set dow this precept, \"that no man by deed, word, countenance, or gesture declare hatred or contempt of another.\" The breach of which law i commonly called \"contumely.\""} +{"text":"The question who is the better man, has no place in the condition o mere nature; where, as has been shown before, all men are equal. Th inequality that now is, has been introduced by the laws civil. I kno that Aristotle in the first book of his Politics, for a foundation o his doctrine, maketh men by nature, some more worthy to command meaning the wiser sort, such as he thought himself to be for hi philosophy; others to serve, meaning those that had strong bodies, bu were not philosophers as he; as if master and servant were no introduced by consent of men, but by difference of wit; which is no only against reason, but also against experience. For there are ver few so foolish, that had not rather govern themselves than be governe by others: nor when the wise in their own conceit, contend by forc with them who distrust their own wisdom, do they always, or often, o almost at any time, get the victory. If Nature therefore have made me equal, that equality is to be acknowledged: or if Nature have made me unequal; yet because men that think themselves equal, will not ente into conditions of peace, but upon equal terms, such equality must b admitted. And therefore for the ninth law of Nature, I put this, \"tha every man acknowledge another for his equal by nature.\" The breach o this precept is \"pride.\""} +{"text":"On this law dependeth another, \"that at the entrance into conditions o peace, no man require to reserve to himself any right which he is no content should be reserved to every one of the rest.\" As it i necessary for all men that seek peace to lay down certain rights o nature; that is to say, not to have liberty to do all they list: so i it necessary for man's life to retain some, as right to govern thei own bodies; enjoy air, water, motion, ways to go from place to place and all things else, without which a man cannot live, or not live well If in this case, at the making of peace, men require for themselve that which they would not have to be granted to others, they d contrary to the precedent law, that commandeth the acknowledgment o natural equality, and therefore also against the law of Nature. Th observers of this law are those we call \"modest,\" and the breaker \"arrogant\" men. The Greeks call the violation of this law pleoneci'a that is, a desire of more than their share."} +{"text":"Also if \"a man be trusted to judge between man and man,\" it is precept of the law of Nature, \"that he deal equally between them.\" Fo without that, the controversies of men cannot be determined but by war He therefore that is partial in judgment, doth what in him lies, t deter men from the use of judges and arbitrators; and consequently against the fundamental law of Nature, is the cause of war."} +{"text":"The observance of this law, from the equal distribution to each man, o that which in reason belongeth to him, is called \"equity,\" and as have said before, distributive justice: the violation, \"acception o persons,\" proswpolyqi'a."} +{"text":"And from this followeth another law, \"that such things as cannot b divided, be enjoyed in common, if it can be; and if the quantity of th thing permit, without stint; otherwise proportionably to the number o them that have right.\" For otherwise the distribution is unequal, an contrary to equity."} +{"text":"But some things there be that can neither be divided nor enjoyed i common. Then, the law of Nature, which prescribeth equity, requiret \"that the entire right, or else, making the use alternate, the firs possession, be determined by lot.\" For equal distribution is of the la of Nature, and other means of equal distribution cannot be imagined."} +{"text":"Of \"lots\" there be two sorts, \"arbitrary,\" and \"natural.\" Arbitrary i that which is agreed on by the competitors: natural, is eithe \"primogeniture,\" which the Greeks call klyrono�i'a, which signifie \"given by lot,\" or \"first seizure.\""} +{"text":"And therefore those things which cannot be enjoyed in common, no divided, ought to be adjudged to the first possessor; and in some case to the first born, as acquired by lot."} +{"text":"It is also a law of Nature, \"that all men that mediate peace, b allowed safe conduct.\" For the law that commandeth peace, as the end commandeth intercession, as the \"means\"; and to intercession the mean is safe conduct."} +{"text":"And because, though men be never so willing to observe these laws there may nevertheless arise questions concerning a man's action first, whether it were done, or not done; secondly, if done, whethe against the law, or not against the law; the former whereof, is calle a question \"of fact\"; the latter a question \"of right,\" therefor unless the parties to the question covenant mutually to stand to th sentence of another, they are as far from peace as ever. This other t whose sentence they submit is called an \"arbitrator.\" And therefore i is of the law of Nature, \"that they that are at controversy, submi their right to the judgment of an arbitrator.\""} +{"text":"And seeing every man is presumed to do all things in order to his ow benefit, no man is a fit arbitrator in his own cause; and if he wer never so fit; yet equity allowing to each party equal benefit, if on be admitted to be judge, the other is to be admitted also; and so th controversy, that is, the cause of war, remains against the law o Nature."} +{"text":"For the same reason no man in any cause ought to be received fo arbitrator, to whom greater profit, or honour, or pleasure apparentl ariseth out of the victory of one party than of the other: for he hat taken, though an unavoidable bribe, yet a bribe; and no man can b obliged to trust him. And thus also the controversy, and the conditio of war remaineth, contrary to the law of Nature."} +{"text":"And in a controversy of \"fact,\" the judge being to give no more credi to one than to the other, if there be no other arguments, must giv credit to a third; or to a third and fourth; or more: for else th question is undecided, and left to force, contrary to the law o Nature."} +{"text":"These are the laws of Nature, dictating peace, for a means of th conservation of men in multitudes; and which only concern the doctrin of civil society. There be other things tending to the destruction o particular men; as drunkenness, and all other parts of intemperance which may therefore also be reckoned amongst those things which the la of Nature hath forbidden; but are not necessary to be mentioned, no are pertinent enough to this place."} +{"text":"And though this may seem too subtle a deduction of the laws of Nature to be taken notice of by all men; whereof the most part are too busy i getting food, and the rest too negligent to understand; yet to leav all men inexcusable, they have been contracted into one easy sum intelligible even to the meanest capacity; and that is, \"Do not that t another, which thou wouldst not have done to thyself\"; which showet him that he has no more to do in learning the laws of Nature, but whe weighing the actions of other men with his own, they seem too heavy, h put them into the other part of the balance, and his own into thei place, that his own passions and self-love may add nothing to th weight; and then there is none of these laws of Nature that will no appear unto him very reasonable."} +{"text":"The laws of Nature oblige in foro interno; that is to say, they bind t a desire they should take place: but in foro externo; that is, to th putting them in act, not always. For he that should be modest, an tractable, and perform all he promises, in such time and place where n man else should do so, should but make himself a prey to others, an procure his own certain ruin, contrary to the ground of all laws o Nature, which tend to Nature's preservation. And again, he that havin sufficient security, that others shall observe the same laws toward him, observes them not himself, seeketh not peace, but war; an consequently the destruction of his nature by violence."} +{"text":"And whatsoever laws bind in foro interno, may be broken, not only by fact contrary to the law, but also by a fact according to it, in case man think it contrary. For though his action in this case be accordin to the law, yet his purpose was against the law; which, where th obligation is in foro interno, is a breach."} +{"text":"The laws of Nature are immutable and eternal; for injustice ingratitude, arrogance, pride, iniquity, acception of persons, and th rest, can never be made lawful. For it can never be that war shal preserve life, and peace destroy it."} +{"text":"The same laws, because they oblige only to a desire and endeavour, mean an unfeigned and constant endeavour, are easy to be observed. Fo in that they require nothing but endeavour, he that endeavoureth thei performance, fulfilleth them; and he that fulfilleth the law, is just."} +{"text":"And the science of them is the true and only moral philosophy. Fo moral philosophy is nothing else but the science of what is \"good\" an \"evil,\" in the conversation and society of mankind. \"Good\" and \"evil\ are names that signify our appetites, and aversions; which in differen tempers, customs, and doctrines of men, are different: and divers men differ not only in their judgment, on the senses of what is pleasan and unpleasant to the taste, smell, hearing, touch, and sight; but als of what is conformable or disagreeable to reason, in the actions o common life. Nay, the same man, in divers times, differs from himself and one time praiseth, that is, calleth good, what another time h dispraiseth, and calleth evil: from whence arise disputes controversies, and at last war. And therefore so long as a man is i the condition of mere nature, which is a condition of war, as privat appetite is the measure of good and evil: and consequently all me agree on this, that peace is good, and therefore also the way or mean of peace, which, as I have showed before, are \"justice,\" \"gratitude,\ \"modesty,\" \"equity,\" \"mercy,\" and the rest of the laws of Nature, ar good; that is to say, \"moral virtues\"; and their contrary \"vices,\ evil. Now the science of virtue and vice is moral philosophy; an therefore the true doctrine of the laws of Nature, is the true mora philosophy. But the writers of moral philosophy, though the acknowledge the same virtues and vices; yet not seeing wherei consisted their goodness; nor that they come to be praised, as th means of peaceable, sociable, and comfortable living, place them in mediocrity of passions: as if not the cause, but the degree of daring made fortitude; or not the cause, but the quantity of a gift, mad liberality."} +{"text":"These dictates of reason, men used to call by the name of laws, bu improperly: for they are but conclusions, or theorems concerning wha conduceth to the conservation and defence of themselves; whereas law properly, is the word of him that by right hath command over others But yet if we consider the same theorems, as delivered in the word o God, that by right commandeth all things; then are they properly calle laws."} +{"text":"VI"} +{"text":"Of Persons, Authors, and Things Personated"} +{"text":"A person is he, \"whose words or actions are considered, either as hi own, or as representing the words or actions of another man, or of an other thing, to whom they are attributed, whether truly or by fiction.\""} +{"text":"When they are considered as his own, then is he called a \"natura person\": and when they are considered as representing the words an actions of another, then is he a \"feigned\" or \"artificial person.\""} +{"text":"The word person is Latin: instead whereof the Greeks have pro'swpon which signifies the \"face,\" as \"persona\" in Latin signifies th \"disguise,\" or \"outward appearance\" of a man, counterfeited on th stage; and sometimes more particularly that part of it, whic disguiseth the face, as a mask or vizard: and from the stage, hath bee translated to any representer of speech and action, as well i tribunals as theatres. So that a \"person,\" is the same that an \"actor\ is, both on the stage and in common conversation; and to \"personate,\ is to \"act,\" or \"represent\" himself or another; and he that actet another, is said to bear his person, or act in his name; in which sens Cicero useth it where he says, Unus sustineo tres personas; mei adversarii, et judicis: I bear three persons: my own, my adversary's and the judge's; and is called in divers occasions, diversely; as \"representer,\" or \"representative,\" a \"lieutenant,\" a \"vicar,\" a \"attorney,\" a \"deputy,\" a \"procurator,\" an \"actor,\" and the like."} +{"text":"Of persons artificial, some have their words and actions \"owned\" b those whom they represent. And then the person is the \"actor\"; and h that owneth his words and actions, is the \"author\": in which case th actor acteth by authority. For that which in speaking of goods an possessions is called an \"owner,\" and in Latin dominus, in Gree ku%rio*s speaking of actions, is called author. And as the right o possession, is called dominion; so the right of doing any action, i called \"authority.\" So that by authority, is always understood a righ of doing any act; and \"done by authority,\" done by commission, o license from him whose right it is."} +{"text":"From hence it followeth, that when the actor maketh a covenant b authority, he bindeth thereby the author, no less than if he had mad it himself; and no less subjecteth him to all the consequences of th same. And therefore all that hath been said formerly (chap. XIV) of th nature of covenants between man and man in their natural capacity, i true also when they are made by their actors, representers, o procurators, that have authority from them, so far forth as is in thei commission, but no further."} +{"text":"And therefore he that maketh a covenant with the actor or representer not knowing the authority he hath, doth it at his own peril. For no ma is obliged by a covenant whereof he is not author; nor consequently b a covenant made against or beside the authority he gave."} +{"text":"When the actor doth anything against the law of Nature by command o the author, if he be obliged by former covenant to obey him, not he bu the author breaketh the law of Nature; for though the action be agains the law of Nature, yet it is not his: but contrarily, to refuse to d it, is against the law of Nature, that forbiddeth breach of covenant."} +{"text":"And he that maketh a covenant with the author by mediation of th actor, not knowing what authority he hath, but only takes his word, i case such authority be not made manifest unto him upon demand, is n longer obliged, for the covenant made with the author is not vali without his counter-assurance. But if he that so covenanteth kne beforehand he was to expect no other assurance than the actor's word then is the covenant valid, because the actor in this case maket himself the author. And therefore, as when the authority is evident the covenant obligeth the author, not the actor; so when the authorit is feigned, it obligeth the actor only, there being no author bu himself."} +{"text":"There are few things that are incapable of being represented b fiction. Inanimate things, as a church, an hospital, a bridge, may b personated by a rector, master, or overseer. But things inanimat cannot be authors, nor therefore give authority to their actors; ye the actors may have authority to procure their maintenance, given the by those that are owners or governors of those things. And therefor such things cannot be personated before there be some state of civi government."} +{"text":"Likewise children, fools, and madmen, that have no use of reason, ma be personated by guardians or curators; but can be no authors, durin that time, of any action done by them longer than, when they shal recover the use of reason, they shall judge the same reasonable. Ye during the folly, he that hath right of governing them may giv authority to the guardian. But this again has no place but in a stat civil, because before such estate there is no dominion of persons."} +{"text":"An idol, or mere figment of the brain, may be personated, as were th gods of the heathen, which, by such officers as the state appointed were personated, and held possessions, and other goods and rights which men from time to time dedicated and consecrated unto them. Bu idols cannot be authors, for an idol is nothing. The authorit proceeded from the state; and therefore, before introduction of civi government, the gods of the heathen could not be personated."} +{"text":"The true God may be personated. As He was, first, by Moses; wh governed the Israelites, that were not his, but God's people, not i his own name, with hoc dicit Moses; but in God's name, with hoc dici Dominus. Secondly, by the Son of man, His own Son, our blessed Saviou Jesus Christ, that came to reduce the Jews, and induce all nations int the kingdom of His Father, not as of Himself, but as sent from Hi Father. And thirdly, by the Holy Ghost or Comforter, speaking an working in the Apostles; which Holy Ghost was a Comforter that came no of Himself; but was sent, and proceeded from them both."} +{"text":"A multitude of men are made \"one\" person, when they are by one man o one person represented; so that it be done with the consent of ever one of that multitude in particular. For it is the \"unity\" of th representer, not the \"unity\" of the represented, that maketh the perso \"one.\" And it is the representer that beareth the person, and but on person: and \"unity\" cannot otherwise be understood in multitude."} +{"text":"And because the multitude naturally is not \"one,\" but \"many,\" the cannot be understood for one; but many authors, of everything thei representative saith, or doth in their name; every man giving thei common representer authority from himself in particular, and owning al the actions the representer doth, in case they give him authorit without stint: otherwise, when they limit him in what and how far h shall represent them, none of them owneth more than they gave hi commission to act."} +{"text":"And if the representative consist of many men, the voice of the greate number must be considered as the voice of them all. For if the lesse number pronounce, for example, in the affirmative, and the greater i the negative, there will be negatives more than enough to destroy th affirmatives; and thereby the excess of negatives, standin uncontradicted, are the only voice the representative hath."} +{"text":"And a representative of even number, especially when the number is no great, whereby the contradictory voices are oftentimes equal, i therefore oftentimes mute and incapable of action. Yet in some case contradictory voices equal in number may determine a question; as i condemning, or absolving, equality of votes, even in that they condem not, do absolve; but not on the contrary condemn, in that they absolv not. For when a cause is heard, not to condemn is to absolve: but o the contrary, to say that not absolving, is condemning, is not true The like it is in a deliberation of executing presently, or deferrin till another time: for when the voices are equal, the not decreein execution is a decree of dilation."} +{"text":"Or if the number be odd, as three or more, men or assemblies; whereo everyone has by a negative voice authority to take away the effect o all the affirmative voices of the rest, this number is n representative; because by the diversity of opinions, and interests o men, it becomes oftentimes, and in cases of the greatest consequence, mute person, and unapt, as for many things else, so for the governmen of a multitude, especially in time of war."} +{"text":"Of authors there be two sorts. The first simply so called; which I hav before defined to be him, that owneth the action of another simply. Th second is he that owneth an action or covenant of anothe conditionally; that is to say, he undertaketh to do it if the othe doth it not at or before a certain time. And these authors conditional are generally called \"sureties,\" in Latin, fidejussores, and sponsores and particularly for debt, praedes; and for appearance before a judge or magistrate, vades."} +{"text":"t II"} +{"text":"Of Commonwealth"} +{"text":"VII"} +{"text":"Of the Causes, Generation, and Definition of a Commonwealth"} +{"text":"The final cause, end, or design of men, who naturally love liberty, an dominion over others, in the introduction of that restraint upo themselves, in which we see them live in commonwealths, is th foresight of their own preservation, and of a more contented lif thereby; that is to say, of getting themselves out from that miserabl condition of war, which is necessarily consequent, as hath been show in chapter XIII, to the natural passions of men, when there is n visible power to keep them in awe, and tie them by fear of punishmen to the performance of their covenants, and observation of those laws o Nature set down in the fourteenth and fifteenth chapters."} +{"text":"For the laws of Nature, as \"justice,\" \"equity,\" \"modesty,\" \"mercy,\ and, in sum, \"doing to others, as we would be done to,\" of themselves without the terror of some power, to cause them to be observed, ar contrary to our natural passions, that carry us to partiality, pride revenge, and the like. And covenants, without the sword, are but words and of no strength to secure a man at all. Therefore notwithstandin the laws of Nature, which everyone hath then kept, when he has the wil to keep them, when he can do it safely, if there be no power erected or not great enough for our security; every man will, and may lawfull rely on his own strength and art, for caution against all other men And in all places, where men have lived by small families, to rob an spoil one another, has been a trade, and so far from being repute against the law of Nature, that the greater spoils they gained, th greater was their honour; and men observed no other laws therein, bu the laws of honour; that is, to abstain from cruelty, leaving to me their lives, and instruments of husbandry. And as small families di then; so now do cities and kingdoms, which are but greater families for their own security, enlarge their dominions, upon all pretences o danger, and fear of invasion, or assistance that may be given t invaders, and endeavour as much as they can, to subdue, or weaken thei neighbours, by open force and secret arts, for want of other caution justly; and are remembered for it in after ages with honour."} +{"text":"Nor is it the joining together of a small number of men, that give them this security; because in small numbers, small additions on th one side or the other, make the advantage of strength so great, as i sufficient to carry the victory; and therefore gives encouragement t an invasion. The multitude sufficient to confide in for our security is not determined by any certain number, but by comparison with th enemy we fear; and is then sufficient, when the odds of the enemy i not of so visible and conspicuous moment, to determine the event o war, as to move him to attempt."} +{"text":"And be there never so great a multitude; yet if their actions b directed according to their particular judgments and particula appetites, they can expect thereby no defence, nor protection, neithe against a common enemy, nor against the injuries of one another. Fo being distracted in opinions concerning the best use and application o their strength, they do not help but hinder one another; and reduc their strength by mutual opposition to nothing: whereby they ar easily, not only subdued by a very few that agree together; but als when there is no common enemy, they make war upon each other, for thei particular interests. For if we could suppose a great multitude of me to consent in the observation of justice, and other laws of Nature without a common power to keep them all in awe; we might as wel suppose all mankind to do the same; and then there neither would be nor need to be any civil government or commonwealth at all; becaus there would be peace without subjection."} +{"text":"Nor is it enough for the security, which men desire should last all th time of their life, that they be governed and directed by one judgment for a limited time: as in one battle, or one war. For though the obtain a victory by their unanimous endeavour against a foreign enemy yet afterwards, when either they have no common enemy, or he that b one part is held for an enemy, is by another part held for a friend they must needs by the difference of their interests dissolve, and fal again into a war amongst themselves."} +{"text":"It is true that certain living creatures, as bees and ants, liv sociably one with another, which are therefore by Aristotle numbere amongst political creatures; and yet have no other direction, tha their particular judgments and appetites; nor speech, whereby one o them can signify to another, what he thinks expedient for the commo benefit: and therefore some man may perhaps desire to know, why mankin cannot do the same. To which I answer,"} +{"text":"First, that men are continually in competition for honour and dignity which these creatures are not; and consequently amongst men ther ariseth on that ground, envy and hatred, and finally war; but amongs these not so."} +{"text":"Secondly, that amongst these creatures, the common good differeth no from the private; and being by nature inclined to their private, the procure thereby the common benefit. But man, whose joy consisteth i comparing himself with other men, can relish nothing but what i eminent."} +{"text":"Thirdly, that these creatures, having not, as man, the use of reason do not see, nor think they see any fault, in the administration o their common business; whereas amongst men, there are very many tha think themselves wiser, and abler to govern the public, better than th rest; and these strive to reform and innovate, one this way, anothe that way; and thereby bring it into distraction and civil war."} +{"text":"Fourthly, that these creatures, though they have some use of voice, i making known to one another their desires and other affections; ye they want that art of words, by which some men can represent to other that which is good in the likeness of evil; and evil in the likeness o good; and augment or diminish the apparent greatness of good and evil discontenting men, and troubling their peace at their pleasure."} +{"text":"Fifthly, irrational creatures cannot distinguish between \"injury\" an \"damage\"; and therefore as long as they be at ease, they are no offended with their fellows: whereas man is then most troublesome, whe he is most at ease; for then it is that he loves to show his wisdom and control the actions of them that govern the commonwealth."} +{"text":"Lastly, the agreement of these creatures is natural; that of men is b covenant only, which is artificial: and therefore it is no wonder i there be somewhat else required, besides covenant, to make thei agreement constant and lasting; which is a common power, to keep the in awe, and to direct their actions to the common benefit."} +{"text":"The only way to erect such a common power, as may be able to defen them from the invasion of foreigners, and the injuries of one another and thereby to secure them in such sort, as that by their own industry and by the fruits of the earth, they may nourish themselves and liv contentedly, is, to confer all their power and strength upon one man or upon one assembly of men, that may reduce all their wills, b plurality of voices, unto one will: which is as much as to say, t appoint one man, or assembly of men, to bear their person; and everyon to own, and acknowledge himself to be author of whatsoever he that s beareth their person, shall act, or cause to be acted, in those thing which concern the common peace and safety; and therein to submit thei wills, everyone to his will, and their judgments, to his judgment. Thi is more than consent, or concord; it is a real unity of them all, i one and the same person, made by covenant of every man with every man in such manner, as if every man should say to every man, \"I authoriz and give up my right of governing myself, to this man, or to thi assembly of men, on this condition, that thou give up thy right to him and authorize all his actions in like manner.\" This done, the multitud so united in one person is called a \"commonwealth,\" in Latin civitas This is the generation of that great \"leviathan,\" or rather, to spea more reverently, of that \"mortal god,\" to which we owe under th \"immortal God,\" our peace and defence. For by this authority, given hi by every particular man in the commonwealth, he hath the use of so muc power and strength conferred on him, that by terror thereof, he i enabled to perform the wills of them all, to peace at home, and mutua aid against their enemies abroad. And in him consisteth the essence o the commonwealth; which, to define it, is \"one person, of whose acts great multitude, by mutual covenants one with another, have mad themselves everyone the author, to the end he may use the strength an means of them all, as he shall think expedient, for their peace an common defence.\""} +{"text":"And he that carrieth this person is called \"sovereign,\" and said t have \"sovereign power\"; and everyone besides, his \"subject.\""} +{"text":"The attaining to this sovereign power is by two ways. One, by natura force; as when a man maketh his children to submit themselves, an their children, to his government, as being able to destroy them i they refuse; or by war subdueth his enemies to his will, giving the their lives on that condition. The other is, when men agree amongs themselves to submit to some man, or assembly of men, voluntarily, o confidence to be protected by him against all others. This latter ma be called a political commonwealth, or commonwealth by \"institution\" and the former, a commonwealth by \"acquisition.\" And first, I shal speak of a commonwealth by institution."} +{"text":"VIII"} +{"text":"Of the Rights of Sovereigns by Institution"} +{"text":"A \"commonwealth\" is said to be \"instituted,\" when a \"multitude\" of me do agree, and \"covenant, everyone, with everyone,\" that to whatsoeve \"man,\" or \"assembly of men,\" shall be given by the major part, th \"right\" to \"present\" the person of them all, that is to say, to b their \"representative\"; everyone, as well he that \"voted for it,\" as h that \"voted against it,\" shall \"authorize\" all the actions an judgments, of that man, or assembly of men, in the same manner, as i they were his own, to the end, to live peaceably amongst themselves and be protected against other men."} +{"text":"From this institution of a commonwealth are derived all the \"rights\ and \"faculties\" of him, or them, on whom sovereign power is conferre by the consent of the people assembled."} +{"text":"First, because they covenant, it is to be understood, they are no obliged by former covenant to anything repugnant hereunto. An consequently they that have already instituted a commonwealth, bein thereby bound by covenant, to own the actions and judgments of one cannot lawfully make a new covenant, amongst themselves, to be obedien to any other, in anything whatsoever, without his permission. An therefore, they that are subjects to a monarch, cannot without hi leave cast off monarchy, and return to the confusion of a disunite multitude; nor transfer their person from him that beareth it, t another man, or other assembly of men: for they are bound, every man t every man, to own, and be reputed author of all, that he that alread is their sovereign, shall do, and judge fit to be done: so that any on man dissenting, all the rest should break their covenant made to tha man, which is injustice: and they have also every man given th sovereignty to him that beareth their person; and therefore if the depose him, they take from him that which is his own, and so again i is injustice. Besides, if he that attempteth to depose his sovereign be killed, or punished by him for such attempt, he is author of his ow punishment, as being by the institution, author of all his sovereig shall do: and because it is injustice for a man to do anything fo which he may be punished by his own authority, he is also upon tha title unjust. And whereas some men have pretended for thei disobedience to their sovereign, a new covenant, made not with men, bu with God; this also is unjust: for there is no covenant with God but b mediation of somebody that representeth God's person; which none dot but God's lieutenant, who hath the sovereignty under God. But thi pretence of covenant with God, is so evident a lie, even in th pretenders' own consciences, that it is not only an act of an unjust but also of a vile and unmanly disposition."} +{"text":"Secondly, because the right of bearing the person of them all, is give to him they make sovereign, by covenant only of one to another, and no of him to any of them; there can happen no breach of covenant on th part of the sovereign: and consequently none of his subjects, by an pretence of forfeiture, can be freed from his subjection. That he whic is made sovereign maketh no covenant with his subjects beforehand, i manifest; because either he must make it with the whole multitude, a one party to the covenant; or he must make a several covenant wit every man. With the whole, as one party, it is impossible; because a yet they are not one person; and if he make so many several covenant as there be men, those covenants after he hath the sovereignty ar void; because what act soever can be pretended by any one of them fo breach thereof, is the act both of himself and of all the rest, becaus done in the person and by the right of every one of them in particular Besides, if any one or more of them, pretend a breach of the covenan made by the sovereign at his institution; and others, or one other o his subjects, or himself alone, pretend there was no such breach, ther is in this case no judge to decide the controversy; it return therefore to the sword again; and every man recovereth the right o protecting himself by his own strength, contrary to the design they ha in the institution. It is therefore in vain to grant sovereignty by wa of precedent covenant. The opinion that any monarch receiveth his powe by covenant, that is to say, on condition, proceedeth from want o understanding this easy truth, that covenants being but words an breath, have no force to oblige, contain, constrain, or protect an man, but what it has from the public sword; that is, from the untie hands of that man, or assembly of men that hath the sovereignty, an whose actions are avouched by them all, and performed by the strengt of them all, in him united. But when an assembly of men is mad sovereign; then no man imagineth any such covenant to have passed i the institution; for no man is so dull as to say, for example, th people of Rome made a covenant with the Romans, to hold the sovereignt on such or such conditions; which not performed, the Romans migh lawfully depose the Roman people. That men see not the reason to b alike in a monarchy, and in a popular government, proceedeth from th ambition of some, that are kinder to the government of an assembly whereof they may hope to participate, than of monarchy, which the despair to enjoy."} +{"text":"Thirdly, because the major part hath by consenting voices declared sovereign; he that dissented must now consent with the rest; that is be contented to avow all the actions he shall do, or else justly b destroyed by the rest. For if he voluntarily entered into th congregation of them that were assembled, he sufficiently declare thereby his will, and therefore tacitly covenanted to stand to what th major part should ordain: and therefore if he refuse to stand thereto or make protestation against any of their decrees, he does contrary t his covenant, and therefore unjustly. And whether he be of th congregation or not; and whether his consent be asked or not, he mus either submit to their decrees, or be left in the condition of war h was in before; wherein he might without injustice be destroyed by an man whatsoever."} +{"text":"Fourthly, because every subject is by this institution author of al the actions and judgments of the sovereign instituted, it follows, tha whatsoever he doth it can be no injury to any of his subjects, no ought he to be by any of them accused of injustice. For he that dot anything by authority from another doth therein no injury to him b whose authority he acteth: but by this institution of a commonwealt every particular man is author of all the sovereign doth; an consequently, he that complaineth of injury from his sovereig complaineth of that whereof he himself is author, and therefore ough not to accuse any man but himself; no, nor himself of injury; becaus to do injury to one's self is impossible. It is true that they tha have sovereign power may commit iniquity, but not injustice or injur in the proper signification."} +{"text":"Fifthly, and consequently to that which was said last, no man that hat sovereign power can justly be put to death, or otherwise in any manne by his subjects punished. For seeing every subject is author of th actions of his sovereign, he punisheth another for the action committed by himself."} +{"text":"And because the end of this institution is the peace and defence o them all; and whosoever has right to the end has right to the means; i belongeth of right to whatsoever man or assembly that hath th sovereignty to be judge both of the means of peace and defence, an also of the hindrances and disturbances of the same, and to d whatsoever he shall think necessary to be done, both beforehand, fo the preserving of peace and security, by prevention of discord at hom and hostility from abroad; and, when peace and security are lost, fo the recovery of the same. And therefore,"} +{"text":"Sixthly, it is annexed to the sovereignty to be judge of what opinion and doctrines are averse and what conducing to peace; and consequently on what occasions, how far, and what men are to be trusted withal, i speaking to multitudes of people, and who shall examine the doctrine of all books before they be published. For the actions of men procee from their opinions, and in the well governing of opinions consistet the well governing of men's actions, in order to their peace an concord. And though in matter of doctrine nothing ought to be regarde but the truth; yet this is not repugnant to regulating the same b peace. For doctrine repugnant to peace can be no more true than peac and concord can be against the law of Nature. It is true that in commonwealth, where, by the negligence or unskilfulness of governor and teachers, false doctrines are by time generally received; th contrary truths may be generally offensive. Yet the most sudden an rough bursting in of a new truth that can be, does never break th peace, but only sometimes awake the war. For those men that are s remissly governed, that they dare take up arms to defend or introduc an opinion, are still in war; and their condition not peace, but only cessation of arms for fear of one another; and they live, as it were in the precincts of battle continually. It belongeth therefore to hi that hath the sovereign power to be judge, or constitute all judges o opinions and doctrines, as a thing necessary to peace, thereby t prevent discord and civil war."} +{"text":"Seventhly, is annexed to the sovereignty, the whole power o prescribing the rules, whereby every man may know what goods he ma enjoy, and what actions he may do, without being molested by any of hi fellow-subjects; and this is it men call \"propriety.\" For befor constitution of sovereign power, as hath already been shown, all me had right to all things, which necessarily causeth war: and therefor this propriety, being necessary to peace, and depending on sovereig power, is the act of that power, in order to the public peace. Thes rules of propriety, or meum and tuum, and of \"good,\" \"evil,\" \"lawful,\ and \"unlawful\" in the actions of subjects, are the civil laws; that i to say, the laws of each commonwealth in particular; though the name o civil law be now restrained to the ancient civil laws of the city o Rome, which being the head of a great part of the world, her laws a that time were in these parts the civil law."} +{"text":"Eighthly, is annexed to the sovereignty, the right of judicature; tha is to say, of hearing and deciding all controversies, which may aris concerning law, either civil or natural, or concerning fact. Fo without the decision of controversies, there is no protection of on subject against the injuries of another; the laws concerning meum an tuum are in vain, and to every man remaineth, from the natural an necessary appetite of his own conservation, the right of protectin himself by his private strength, which is the condition of war, an contrary to the end for which every commonwealth is instituted."} +{"text":"Ninthly, is annexed to the sovereignty, the right of making war an peace with other nations and commonwealths; that is to say, of judgin when it is for the public good, and how great forces are to b assembled, armed, and paid for that end; and to levy money upon th subjects to defray the expenses thereof. For the power by which th people are to be defended consisteth in their armies, and the strengt of an army, in the union of their strength under one command, whic command the sovereign instituted, therefore hath; because the comman of the \"militia,\" without other institution, maketh him that hath i sovereign. And therefore whosoever is made general of an army, he tha hath the sovereign power is always generalissimo."} +{"text":"Tenthly, is annexed to the sovereignty, the choosing of al counsellors, ministers, magistrates, and officers, both in peace an war. For seeing the sovereign is charged with the end, which is th common peace and defence, he is understood to have power to use suc means as he shall think most fit for his discharge."} +{"text":"Eleventhly, to the sovereign is committed the power of rewarding wit riches or honour, and of punishing with corporal or pecuniar punishment, or with ignominy, every subject according to the law h hath formerly made; or if there be no law made, according as he shal judge most to conduce to the encouraging of men to serve th commonwealth, or deterring of them from doing disservice to the same."} +{"text":"Lastly, considering what value men are naturally apt to set upo themselves; what respect they look for from others; and how little the value other men; from whence continually arise amongst them, emulation quarrels, factions, and at last war, to the destroying of one another and diminution of their strength against a common enemy; it i necessary that there be laws of honour, and a public rate of the wort of such men as have deserved, or are able to deserve well of th commonwealth; and that there be force in the hands of some or other, t put those laws in execution. But it hath already been shown, that no only the whole \"militia,\" or forces of the commonwealth; but also th judicature of all controversies, is annexed to the sovereignty. To th sovereign therefore it belongeth also to give titles of honour; and t appoint what order of place and dignity each man shall hold; and wha signs of respect, in public or private meetings, they shall give to on another."} +{"text":"These are the rights, which make the essence of sovereignty; and whic are the marks whereby a man may discern in what man, or assembly o men, the sovereign power is placed and resideth. For these ar incommunicable, and inseparable. The power to coin money; to dispose o the estate and persons of infant heirs; to have preemption in markets and all other statute prerogatives, may be transferred by th sovereign; and yet the power to protect his subjects be retained. Bu if he transfer the \"militia,\" he retains the judicature in vain, fo want of execution of the laws: or if he grant away the power of raisin money, the \"militia\" is in vain; or if he give away the government o doctrines, men will be frighted into rebellion with the fear o spirits. And so if we consider any one of the said rights, we shal presently see, that the holding of all the rest will produce no effect in the conservation of peace and justice, the end for which al commonwealths are instituted. And this division is it, whereof it i said, \"a kingdom divided in itself cannot stand\": for unless thi division precede, division into opposite armies can never happen. I there had not first been an opinion received of the greatest part o England, that these powers were divided between the King, and th Lords, and the House of Commons, the people had never been divided an fallen into this civil war; first between those that disagreed i politics; and after between the dissenters about the liberty o religion; which have so instructed men in this point of sovereig right, that there be few now in England that do not see that thes rights are inseparable, and will be so generally acknowledged at th next return of peace; and so continue, till their miseries ar forgotten; and no longer, except the vulgar be better taught than the have hitherto been."} +{"text":"And because they are essential and inseparable rights, it follow necessarily, that in whatsoever words any of them seem to be grante away, yet if the sovereign power itself be not in direct term renounced, and the name of sovereign no more given by the grantees t him that grants them, the grant is void: for when he has granted all h can, if we grant back the sovereignty, all is restored, as inseparabl annexed thereunto."} +{"text":"This great authority being indivisible, and inseparably annexed to th sovereignty, there is little ground for the opinion of them that say o sovereign kings, though they be singulis majores, of greater power tha every one of their subjects, yet they be universis minores, of les power than them all together. For if by \"all together,\" they mean no the collective body as one person, then \"all together,\" and \"everyone,\ signify the same; and the speech is absurd. But if by \"all together,\ they understand them as one person, which person the sovereign bears then the power of all together, is the same with the sovereign's power and so again the speech is absurd: which absurdity they see wel enough, when the sovereignty is in an assembly of the people; but in monarch they see it not; and yet the power of sovereignty is the sam in whomsoever it be placed."} +{"text":"And as the power, so also the honour of the sovereign, ought to b greater, than that of any, or all the subjects. For in the sovereignt is the fountain of honour. The dignities of lord, earl, duke, an prince are his creatures. As in the presence of the master, th servants are equal, and without any honour at all; so are the subject in the presence of the sovereign. And though they shine some more, som less, when they are out of his sight; yet in his presence, they shin no more than the stars in the presence of the sun."} +{"text":"But a man may here object, that the condition of subjects is ver miserable; as being obnoxious to the lusts, and other irregula passions of him or them that have so unlimited a power in their hands And commonly they that live under a monarch, think it the fault o monarchy; and they that live under the government of democracy, o other sovereign assembly, attribute all the inconvenience to that for of commonwealth; whereas the power in all forms, if they be perfec enough to protect them, is the same: not considering that the state o man can never be without some incommodity or other; and that th greatest, that in any form of government can possibly happen to th people in general, is scarce sensible, in respect of the miseries, an horrible calamities, that accompany a civil war, or that dissolut condition of masterless men, without subjection to laws, and a coerciv power to tie their hands from rapine and revenge: nor considering tha the greatest pressure of sovereign governors proceedeth not from an delight, or profit they can expect in the damage or weakening of thei subjects, in whose vigour consisteth their own strength and glory; bu in the restiveness of themselves, that unwillingly contributing t their own defence, make it necessary for their governors to draw fro them what they can in time of peace, that they may have means on an emergent occasion, or sudden need, to resist, or take advantage o their enemies. For all men are by nature provided of notabl multiplying glasses, that is their passions and self-love, throug which every little payment appeareth a great grievance; but ar destitute of those prospective glasses, namely, moral and civi science, to see afar off the miseries that hang over them, and canno without such payments be avoided."} +{"text":"IX"} +{"text":"Of the Several Kinds of Commonwealth by Institution, and of Successio to the Sovereign Power"} +{"text":"The difference of commonwealths consisteth in the difference of th sovereign, or the person representative of all and every one of th multitude. And because the sovereignty is either in one man, or in a assembly of more than one; and into that assembly either every man hat right to enter, or not everyone, but certain men distinguished from th rest; it is manifest, there can be but three kinds of commonwealth. Fo the representative must needs be one man, or more: and if more, then i is the assembly of all, or but of a part. When the representative i one man, then is the commonwealth a \"monarchy\": when an assembly of al that will come together, then it is a \"democracy,\" or popula commonwealth: when an assembly of a part only, then it is called a \"aristocracy.\" Other kind of commonwealth there can be none: for eithe one or more, or all, must have the sovereign power, which I have show to be indivisible, entire."} +{"text":"There be other names of government in the histories and books o policy, as \"tyranny,\" and \"oligarchy\": but they are not the names o other forms of government, but of the same forms misliked. For the that are discontented under \"monarchy,\" call it \"tyranny\"; and the that are displeased with \"aristocracy,\" call it \"oligarchy\": so als they which find themselves grieved under a \"democracy,\" call i \"anarchy,\" which signifies want of government; and yet I think no ma believes that want of government is any new kind of government: nor b the same reason ought they to believe that the government is of on kind when they like it, and another when they dislike it, or ar oppressed by the governors."} +{"text":"It is manifest, that men who are in absolute liberty may, if the please, give authority to one man to represent them everyone; as wel as give such authority to any assembly of men whatsoever; an consequently may subject themselves, if they think good, to a monarc as absolutely as to any other representative. Therefore, where there i already erected a sovereign power, there can be no other representativ of the same people, but only to certain particular ends, by th sovereign limited. For that were to erect two sovereigns; and every ma to have his person represented by two actors, that by opposing on another, must needs divide that power, which, if men will live i peace, is indivisible, and thereby reduce the multitude into th condition of war, contrary to the end for which all sovereignty i instituted. And therefore as it is absurd to think that a sovereig assembly, inviting the people of their dominion to send up thei deputies, with power to make known their advice, or desires, shoul therefore hold such deputies rather than themselves, for the absolut representatives of the people: so it is absurd also to think the sam in a monarchy. And I know not how this so manifest a truth should o late be so little observed; that in a monarchy, he that had th sovereignty from a descent of six hundred years, was alone calle sovereign, had the title of Majesty from every one of his subjects, an was unquestionably taken by them for their king, was notwithstandin never considered as their representative; the name withou contradiction passing for the title of those men, which at his comman were sent up by the people to carry their petitions, and give him, i he permitted it, their advice. Which may serve as an admonition, fo those that are the true and absolute representative of a people, t instruct men in the nature of that office, and to take heed how the admit of any other general representation upon any occasion whatsoever if they mean to discharge the trust committed to them."} +{"text":"The difference between these three kinds of commonwealth, consistet not in the difference of power; but in the difference of convenience or aptitude to produce the peace and security of the people; for whic end they were instituted. And to compare monarchy with the other two we may observe; first, that whosoever beareth the person of the people or is one of that assembly that bears it, beareth also his own natura person. And though he be careful in his politic person to procure th common interest; yet he is more or no less careful to procure th private good of himself, his family, kindred, and friends; and for th most part, if the public interest chance to cross the private, h prefers the private: for the passions of men are commonly more poten than their reason. From whence it follows, that where the public an private interest are most closely united, there is the public mos advanced. Now in monarchy, the private interest is the same with th public. The riches, power, and honour of a monarch, arise only from th riches, strength, and reputation of his subjects. For no king can b rich, nor glorious, nor secure, whose subjects are either poor, o contemptible, or too weak through want or dissention, to maintain a wa against their enemies: whereas in a democracy, or aristocracy, th public prosperity confers not so much to the private fortune of on that is corrupt, or ambitious, as doth many times a perfidious advice a treacherous action, or a civil war."} +{"text":"Secondly, that a monarch receiveth counsel of whom, when, and where h pleaseth; and consequently may hear the opinion of men versed in th matter about which he deliberates, of what rank or quality soever, an as long before the time of action, and with as much secrecy, as h will. But when a sovereign assembly has need of counsel, none ar admitted but such as have a right thereto from the beginning; which fo the most part are of those who have been versed more in the acquisitio of wealth than of knowledge; and are to give their advice in lon discourses, which may and do commonly excite men to action, but no govern them in it. For the \"understanding\" is by the flame of th passions, never enlightened, but dazzled. Nor is there any place, o time, wherein an assembly can receive counsel with secrecy, because o their own multitude."} +{"text":"Thirdly, that the resolutions of a monarch, are subject to no othe inconstancy, than that of human nature; but in assemblies, besides tha of Nature, there ariseth an inconstancy from the number. For th absence of a few, that would have the resolution once taken, continu firm, which may happen by security, negligence, or private impediments or the diligent appearance of a few of the contrary opinion, undoe today all that was concluded yesterday."} +{"text":"Fourthly, that a monarch cannot disagree with himself, out of envy o interest; but an assembly may; and that to such a height, as ma produce a civil war."} +{"text":"Fifthly, that in monarchy there is this inconvenience; that an subject, by the power of one man, for the enriching of a favourite o flatterer, may be deprived of all he possesseth; which I confess is great and inevitable inconvenience. But the same may as well happen where the sovereign power is an assembly: for their power is the same and they are as subject to evil counsel, and to be seduced by orators as a monarch by flatterers; and becoming one another's flatterers serve one another's covetousness and ambition by turns. And whereas th favourites of monarchs are few, and they have none else to advance bu their own kindred; the favourites of an assembly are many; and th kindred much more numerous than of any monarch. Besides there is n favourite of a monarch, which cannot as well succour his friends a hurt his enemies; but orators, that is to say, favourites of sovereig assemblies, though they have great power to hurt, have little to save For to accuse, requires less eloquence, such is man's nature, than t excuse; and condemnation, than absolution more resembles justice."} +{"text":"Sixthly, that it is an inconvenience in monarchy, that the sovereignt may descend upon an infant, or one that cannot discern between good an evil: and consisteth in this, that the use of his power, must be in th hand of another man, or of some assembly of men, which are to govern b his right, and in his name; as curators and protectors of his perso and authority. But to say there is inconvenience in putting the use o the sovereign power into the hand of a man, or an assembly of men; i to say that all government is more inconvenient than confusion an civil war. And therefore all the danger that can be pretended, mus arise from the contention of those, that for an office of so grea honour and profit, may become competitors. To make it appear that thi inconvenience proceedeth not from that form of government we cal monarchy, we are to consider that the precedent monarch hath appointe who shall have the tuition of his infant successor, either expressly b testament, or tacitly, by not controlling the custom in that cas received: and then such inconvenience, if it happen, is to b attributed, not to the monarchy, but to the ambition and injustice o the subjects; which in all kinds of government, where the people ar not well instructed in their duty and the rights of sovereignty, is th same. Or else the precedent monarch hath not at all taken order fo such tuition; and then the law of Nature hath provided this sufficien rule, that the tuition shall be in him that hath, by nature, mos interest in the preservation of the authority of the infant, and t whom least benefit can accrue by his death or diminution. For seein every man by nature seeketh his own benefit, and promotion; to put a infant into the power of those that can promote themselves by hi destruction, or damage, is not tuition, but treachery. So tha sufficient provision being taken against all just quarrel about th government under a child, if any contention arise to the disturbance o the public peace, it is not to be attributed to the form of monarchy but to the ambition of subjects, and ignorance of their duty. On th other side, there is no great commonwealth, the sovereignty whereof i in a great assembly, which is not, as to consultations of peace an war, and making of laws, in the same condition as if the governmen were in a child. For as a child wants the judgment to dissent fro counsel given him, and is thereby necessitated to take the advice o them, or him, to whom he is committed: so an assembly wanteth th liberty to dissent from the counsel of the major part, be it good o bad. And as a child has need of a tutor, or protector, to preserve hi person and authority: so also, in great commonwealths, the sovereig assembly, in all great dangers and troubles, have need of custode libertatis; that is of dictators, or protectors of their authority which are as much as temporary monarchs, to whom for a time they ma commit the entire exercise of their power; and have, at the end of tha time, been oftener deprived thereof than infant kings, by thei protectors, regents, or any other tutors."} +{"text":"Though the kinds of sovereignty be, as I have now shown, but three that is to say, monarchy, where one man has it; or democracy, where th general assembly of subjects hath it; or aristocracy, where it is in a assembly of certain persons nominated, or otherwise distinguished fro the rest: yet he that shall consider the particular commonwealths tha have been, and are in the world, will not perhaps easily reduce them t three, and may thereby be inclined to think there be other forms arising from these mingled together. As for example, elective kingdoms where kings have the sovereign power put into their hands for a time or kingdoms wherein the king hath a power limited: which government are nevertheless, by most writers, called monarchy. Likewise if popular, or aristocratical commonwealth subdue an enemy's country, an govern the same, by a president, procurator, or other magistrate: thi may seem perhaps at first sight, to be a democratical, o aristocratical government. But it is not so. For elective kings are no sovereigns, but ministers of the sovereign; nor limited kings sovereigns, but ministers of them that have the sovereign power: no are those provinces which are in subjection to a democracy o aristocracy of another commonwealth, democratically or aristocraticall governed, but monarchically."} +{"text":"And first, concerning an elective king, whose power is limited to hi life, as it is in many places of Christendom at this day; or to certai years or months, as the dictator's power amongst the Romans; if he hav right to appoint his successor, he is no more elective but hereditary But if he have no power to elect his successor, then there is som other man, or assembly known, which after his decease may elect anew or else the commonwealth dieth and dissolveth with him, and returnet to the condition of war. If it be known who have the power to give th sovereignty after his death, it is known also that the sovereignty wa in them before; for none have right to give that which they have no right to possess, and keep to themselves if they think good. But i there be none that can give the sovereignty after the decease of hi that was first elected, then has he power, nay, he is obliged by th law of Nature, to provide, by establishing his successor, to keep thos that had trusted him with the government from relapsing into th miserable condition of civil war. And consequently he was, whe elected, a sovereign absolute."} +{"text":"Secondly, that king whose power is limited, is not superior to him o them that have the power to limit it; and he that is not superior i not supreme, that is to say, not sovereign. The sovereignty therefor was always in that assembly which had the right to limit him; and b consequence the government not monarchy, but either democracy o aristocracy; as of old time in Sparta, where the kings had a privileg to lead their armies; but the sovereignty was in the Ephori."} +{"text":"Thirdly, whereas heretofore the Roman people governed the land o Judea, for example, by a president; yet was not Judea therefore democracy; because they were not governed by any assembly into th which any of them had right to enter; nor an aristocracy; because the were not governed by any assembly, into which any man could enter b their election: but they were governed by one person, which, though a to the people of Rome, was an assembly of the people, or democracy; ye as to the people of Judea, which had no right at all of participatin in the government, was a monarch. For though where the people ar governed by an assembly, chosen by themselves out of their own number the government is called a democracy or aristocracy; yet when they ar governed by an assembly not of their own choosing, it is a monarchy not of \"one\" man, over another man; but of one people, over anothe people."} +{"text":"Of all these forms of government, the matter being mortal, so that no only monarchs but also whole assemblies die, it is necessary, for th conservation of the peace of men, that as there was order taken for a artificial man, so there be order also taken for an artificial eternit of life: without which, men that are governed by an assembly shoul return into the condition of war in every age; and they that ar governed by one man, as soon as their governor dieth. This artificia eternity is that which men call the right of \"succession.\""} +{"text":"There is no perfect form of government where the disposing of th succession is not in the present sovereign. For if it be in any othe particular man or private assembly, it is in a person subject, and ma be assumed by the sovereign at his pleasure; and consequently the righ is in himself. And if it be in no particular man, but left to a ne choice, then is the commonwealth dissolved, and the right is in hi that can get it; contrary to the intention of them that did institut the commonwealth, for their perpetual, and not temporary security."} +{"text":"In a democracy, the whole assembly cannot fail, unless the multitud that are to be governed fail. And therefore questions of the right o succession have in that form of government no place at all."} +{"text":"In an aristocracy, when any of the assembly dieth, the election o another into his room belongeth to the assembly, as the sovereign, t whom belongeth the choosing of all counsellors and officers. For tha which the representative doth, as actor, every one of the subject doth, as author. And though the sovereign assembly may give power t others, to elect new men for supply of their court; yet it is still b their authority that the election is made; and by the same it may, whe the public shall require it, be recalled."} +{"text":"The greatest difficulty about the right of succession is in monarchy and the difficulty ariseth from this, that at first sight, it is no manifest who is to appoint the successor; nor many times, who it i whom he hath appointed. For in both these cases there is required more exact ratiocination, than every man is accustomed to use. As t the question, who shall appoint the successor, of a monarch that hat the sovereign authority; that is to say, who shall determine of th right of inheritance, (for elective kings and princes have not th sovereign power in propriety, but in use only,) we are to consider tha either he that is in possession has right to dispose of the succession or else that right is again in the dissolved multitude. For the deat of him that hath the sovereign power in propriety, leaves the multitud without any sovereign at all; that is, without any representative i whom they should be united, and be capable of doing any one action a all: and therefore they are incapable of election of any new monarch every man having equal right to submit himself to such as he think best able to protect him; or if he can, protect himself by his ow sword; which is a return to confusion, and to the condition of a war o every man against every man, contrary to the end for which monarchy ha its first institution. Therefore it is manifest, that by th institution of monarchy, the disposing of the successor is always lef to the judgment and will of the present possessor."} +{"text":"And for the question which may arise sometimes, who it is that th monarch in possession hath designed to the succession and inheritanc of his power; it is determined by his express words and testament, o by other tacit signs sufficient."} +{"text":"By express words, or testament, when it is declared by him in hi lifetime, viva voce, or by writing, as the first emperors of Rom declared who should be their heirs. For the word heir does not o itself imply the children, or nearest kindred of a man; but whomsoeve a man shall anyway declare he would have to succeed him in his estate If therefore a monarch declare expressly, that such a man shall be hi heir, either by word or writing, then is that man immediately after th decease of his predecessor, invested in the right of being monarch."} +{"text":"But where testament and express words are wanting, other natural sign of the will are to be followed, whereof the one is custom. An therefore where the custom is, that the next of kindred absolutel succeedeth, there also the next of kindred hath right to th succession; for that if the will of him that was in possession had bee otherwise, he might easily have declared the same in his lifetime. An likewise where the custom is, that the next of the male kindre succeedeth, there also the right of succession is in the next of th kindred male, for the same reason. And so it is if the custom were t advance the female. For whatsoever custom a man may by a word control and does not, it is a natural sign he would have that custom stand."} +{"text":"But where neither custom nor testament hath preceded, there it is to b understood, first, that a monarch's will is, that the government remai monarchical; because he hath approved that government in himself Secondly, that a child of his own, male or female, be preferred befor any other; because men are presumed to be more inclined by nature t advance their own children than the children of other men; and of thei own, rather a male than a female; because men are naturally fitter tha women for actions of labour and danger. Thirdly, where his own issu faileth, rather a brother than a stranger; and so still the nearer i blood, rather than the more remote; because it is always presumed tha the nearer of kin is the nearer in affection; and it is evident that man receives always, by reflection, the most honour from the greatnes of his nearest kindred."} +{"text":"But if it be lawful for a monarch to dispose of the succession by word of contract, or testament, men may perhaps object a grea inconvenience; for he may sell, or give his right of governing to stranger; which, because strangers, that is, men not used to live unde the same government, nor speaking the same language, do commonl undervalue one another, may turn to the oppression of his subjects which is indeed a great inconvenience: but it proceedeth no necessarily from the subjection to a stranger's government, but fro the unskilfulness of the governors, ignorant of the true rules o politics. And therefore the Romans when they had subdued many nations to make their government digestible, were wont to take away tha grievance, as much as they thought necessary, by giving sometimes t whole nations, and sometimes to principal men of every nation the conquered, not only the privileges, but also the name of Romans; an took many of them into the senate, and offices of charge, even in th Roman city. And this was it our most wise king, king James, aimed at in endeavouring the union of his two realms of England and Scotland which if he could have obtained, had in all likelihood prevented th civil wars, which make both those kingdoms, at this present, miserable It is not therefore any injury to the people for a monarch to dispos of the succession by will; though by the fault of many princes, it hat been sometimes found inconvenient. Of the lawfulness of it, this als is an argument, that whatsoever inconvenience can arrive by giving kingdom to a stranger, may arrive also by so marrying with strangers as the right of succession may descend upon them: yet this by all me is accounted lawful."} +{"text":"X"} +{"text":"Of Dominion Paternal, and Despotical"} +{"text":"A commonwealth \"by acquisition,\" is that, where the sovereign power i acquired by force; and it is acquired by force when men singly, or man together by plurality of voices, for fear of death, or bonds, d authorize all the actions of that man, or assembly, that hath thei lives and liberty in his power."} +{"text":"And this kind of dominion, or sovereignty, differeth from sovereignt by institution only in this, that men who choose their sovereign do i for fear of one another, and not of him whom they institute: but i this case, they subject themselves to him they are afraid of. In bot cases they do it for fear: which is to be noted by them that hold al such covenants as proceed from fear of death or violence, void: whic if it were true, no man, in any kind of commonwealth, could be oblige to obedience. It is true, that in a commonwealth once instituted, o acquired, promises proceeding from fear of death or violence, are n covenants, nor obliging, when the thing promised is contrary to th laws; but the reason is not because it was made upon fear, but becaus he that promiseth hath no right in the thing promised. Also, when h may lawfully perform, and doth not, it is not the invalidity of th covenant that absolveth him, but the sentence of the sovereign Otherwise, whensoever a man lawfully promiseth, he unlawfully breaketh but when the sovereign, who is the actor, acquitteth him, then he i acquitted by him that extorted the promise, as by the author of suc absolution."} +{"text":"But the rights and consequences of sovereignty, are the same in both His power cannot, without his consent, be transferred to another; h cannot forfeit it: he cannot be accused by any of his subjects o injury: he cannot be punished by them: he is judge of what is necessar for peace; and judge of doctrines: he is sole legislator; and suprem judge of controversies; and of the times, and occasions of war, an peace: to him it belongeth to choose magistrates, counsellors commanders, and all other officers and ministers; and to determine o rewards and punishments, honour, and order. The reasons whereof, ar the same which are alleged in the precedent chapter, for the sam rights and consequences of sovereignty by institution."} +{"text":"Dominion is acquired two ways; by generation and by conquest. The righ of dominion by generation is that, which the parent hath over hi children, and is called \"paternal.\" And is not so derived from th generation, as if therefore the parent had dominion over his chil because he begat him; but from the child's consent, either express, o by other sufficient arguments declared. For as to the generation, Go hath ordained to man a helper; and there be always two that are equall parents: the dominion therefore over the child should belong equally t both; and he be equally subject to both, which is impossible, for n man can obey two masters. And whereas some have attributed the dominio to the man only, as being of the more excellent sex; they misreckon i it. For there is not always that difference of strength or prudenc between the man and the woman, as that the right can be determine without war. In commonwealths, this controversy is decided by the civi law; and for the most part, but not always, the sentence is in favou of the father; because for the most part commonwealths have bee erected by the fathers, not by the mothers of families. But th question lieth now in the state of mere nature; where there ar supposed no laws of matrimony; no laws for the education of children but the law of Nature, and the natural inclination of the sexes, one t another, and to their children. In this condition of mere nature either the parents between themselves dispose of the dominion over th child by contract; or do not dispose thereof at all. If they dispos thereof, the right passeth according to the contract. We find i history that the Amazons contracted with the men of the neighbourin countries, to whom they had recourse for issue, that the issue mal should be sent back, but the female remain with themselves: so that th dominion of the females was in the mother."} +{"text":"If there be no contract, the dominion is in the mother. For in th condition of mere nature, where there are no matrimonial laws, i cannot be known who is the father, unless it be declared by the mother and therefore the right of dominion over the child dependeth on he will, and is consequently hers. Again, seeing the infant is first i the power of the mother, so as she may either nourish or expose it; i she nourish it, it oweth its life to the mother; and is therefor obliged to obey her, rather than any other; and by consequence th dominion over it is hers. But if she expose it, and another find an nourish it, the dominion is in him that nourisheth it. For it ought t obey him by whom it is preserved; because preservation of life bein the end, for which one man becomes subject to another, every man i supposed to promise obedience to him, in whose power it is to save, o destroy him."} +{"text":"If the mother be the father's subject, the child is in the father' power: and if the father be the mother's subject, as when a sovereig queen marrieth one of her subjects, the child is subject to the mother because the father also is her subject."} +{"text":"If a man and woman, monarchs of two several kingdoms, have a child, an contract concerning who shall have the dominion of him, the right o the dominion passeth by the contract. If they contract not, th dominion followeth the dominion of the place of his residence. For th sovereign of each country hath dominion over all that reside therein."} +{"text":"He that hath the dominion over the child, hath dominion also over th children of the child; and over their children's children. For he tha hath dominion over the person of a man, hath dominion over all that i his; without which, dominion were but a title, without the effect."} +{"text":"The right of succession to paternal dominion, proceedeth in the sam manner as doth the right of succession of monarchy; of which I hav already sufficiently spoken in the precedent chapter."} +{"text":"Dominion acquired by conquest, or victory in war, is that which som writers call \"despotical,\" from Despo'ty*s, which signifieth a \"lord,\ or \"master\"; and is the dominion of the master over his servant. An this dominion is then acquired to the victor, when the vanquished, t avoid the present stroke of death, covenanteth either in express words or by other sufficient signs of the will, that so long as his life an the liberty of his body is allowed him, the victor shall have the us thereof, at his pleasure. And after such covenant made, the vanquishe is a \"servant,\" and not before: for by the word \"servant,\" whether i be derived from servire, to serve, or from servare, to save, which leave to grammarians to dispute, is not meant a captive, which is kep in prison or bonds, till the owner of him that took him, or bought hi of one that did, shall consider what to do with him: for such men commonly called slaves, have no obligation at all; but may break thei bonds or the prison; and kill, or carry away captive their master justly: but one, that being taken, hath corporal liberty allowed him and upon promise not to run away, nor to do violence to his master, i trusted by him."} +{"text":"It is not therefore the victory that giveth the right of dominion ove the vanquished, but his own covenant. Nor is he obliged because he i conquered; that is to say, beaten and taken, or put to flight; bu because he cometh in and submitteth to the victor; nor is the victo obliged by an enemy's rendering himself without promise of life, t spare him for this his yielding to discretion, which obliges not th victor longer than in his own discretion he shall think fit."} +{"text":"And that which men do when they demand, as it is now called, \"quarter,\ which the Greeks called Zwgri'a, \"taking alive,\" is to evade th present fury of the victor by submission, and to compound for thei life with ransom, or service; and therefore he that hath quarter, hat not his life given, but deferred till farther deliberation; for it i not a yielding on condition of life, but to discretion. And then onl is his life in security, and his service due, when the victor hat trusted him with his corporal liberty. For slaves that work in prisons or fetters, do it not of duty, but to avoid the cruelty of thei taskmasters."} +{"text":"The master of the servant is master also of all he hath, and may exac the use thereof, that is to say, of his goods, of his labour, of hi servants, and of his children, as often as he shall think fit. For h holdeth his life of his master by the covenant of obedience; that is of owning and authorizing whatsoever the master shall do. And in cas the master, if he refuse, kill him, or cast him into bonds, o otherwise punish him for his disobedience, he is himself the author o the same, and cannot accuse him of injury."} +{"text":"In sum, the rights and consequences of both \"paternal\" and \"despotical\ dominion, are the very same with those of a sovereign by institution and for the same reasons: which reasons are set down in the preceden chapter. So that for a man that is monarch of divers nations, whereo he hath in one the sovereignty by institution of the people assembled and in another by conquest, that is by the submission of eac particular, to avoid death or bonds; to demand of one nation more tha of the other from the title of conquest, as being a conquered nation is an act of ignorance of the rights of sovereignty; for the sovereig is absolute over both alike, or else there is no sovereignty at all and so every man may lawfully protect himself, if he can, with his ow sword, which is the condition of war."} +{"text":"By this it appears that a great family, if it be not part of som commonwealth, is of itself, as to the rights of sovereignty, a littl monarchy; whether that family consist of a man and his children, or o a man and his servants; or of a man, and his children and servant together, wherein the father or master is the sovereign. But yet family is not properly a commonwealth, unless it be of that power b its own number, or by other opportunities, as not to be subdued withou the hazard of war. For where a number of men are manifestly too weak t defend themselves united, everyone may use his own reason in time o danger to save his own life, either by flight or by submission to th enemy, as he shall think best; in the same manner as a very smal company of soldiers, surprised by an army, may cast down their arms an demand quarter, or run away, rather than be put to the sword. And thu much shall suffice concerning what I find by speculation, and deductio of sovereign rights, from the nature, need, and designs of men, i erecting of commonwealths, and putting themselves under monarchs, o assemblies entrusted with power enough for their protection."} +{"text":"Let us now consider what the Scripture teacheth in the same point. T Moses, the children of Israel say thus: \"Speak thou to us, and we wil hear thee; but let not God speak to us, lest we die\" (Exod. 20:19) This is absolute obedience to Moses. Concerning the right of kings, Go Himself by the mouth of Samuel, saith (1 Sam. 8:11�-�12, etc.): \"Thi shall be the right of the king you will have to reign over you. H shall take your sons, and set them to drive his chariots, and to be hi horsemen, and to run before his chariots; and gather in his harvest and to make his engines of war, and instruments of his chariots; an shall take your daughters to make perfumes, to be his cooks, an bakers. He shall take your fields, your vineyards, and your oliv yards, and give them to his servants. He shall take the tithe of you corn and wine, and give it to the men of his chamber, and to his othe servants. He shall take your manservants and your maidservants, and th choice of your youth, and employ them in his business. He shall tak the tithe of your flocks, and you shall be his servants.\" This i absolute power, and summed up in the last words, \"you shall be hi servants.\" Again, when the people heard what power their king was t have, yet they consented thereto, and say thus (verse 10): \"We will b as all other nations, and our king shall judge our causes, and g before us, to conduct our wars.\" Here is confirmed the right tha sovereigns have both to the \"militia\" and to all \"judicature\"; in whic is contained as absolute power as one man can possibly transfer t another. Again, the prayer of king Solomon to God was this (1 King 3:9): \"Give to thy servant understanding, to judge thy people, and t discern between good and evil.\" It belongeth therefore to the sovereig to be \"judge,\" and to prescribe the rules of \"discerning good\" an \"evil\"; which rules are laws; and therefore in him is the legislativ power. Saul sought the life of David; yet when it was in his power t slay Saul, and his servants would have done it, David forbad them saying (1 Sam. 24:6): \"God forbid I should do such an act against m Lord, the anointed of God.\" For obedience of servants St. Paul sait (Col. 3:22): \"Servants obey your masters in all things\"; and (Col 3:20): \"Children obey your parents in all things.\" There is simpl obedience in those that are subject to paternal or despotical dominion Again (Matt. 23:2�-�3): \"The Scribes and Pharisees sit in Moses' chair and therefore all that they shall bid you observe, that observe an do.\" There again is simple obedience. And St. Paul (Titus 3:2): \"War them that they subject themselves to princes, and to those that are i authority, and obey them.\" This obedience is also simple. Lastly, ou Saviour Himself acknowledges, that men ought to pay such taxes as ar by kings imposed, where he says, \"Give to Caesar that which i Caesar's\"; and paid such taxes Himself. And that the king's word i sufficient to take anything from any subject, when there is need; an that the king is judge of that need, for He Himself, as king of th Jews, commanded His disciples to take the ass, and ass's colt, to carr Him into Jerusalem, saying (Matt. 21:2�-�3): \"Go into the village ove against you, and you shall find a she-ass tied, and her colt with her untie them, and bring them to me. And if any man ask you what you mea by it, say the Lord hath need of them: and they will let them go.\" The will not ask whether His necessity be a sufficient title; nor whethe He be judge of that necessity; but acquiesce in the will of the Lord."} +{"text":"To these places may be added also that of Genesis (3:5): \"Ye shall b as gods, knowing good and evil.\" And (verse 11): \"Who told thee tha thou wast naked? hast thou eaten of the tree, of which I commanded the thou shouldest not eat?\" For the cognizance or judicature of \"good\" an \"evil,\" being forbidden by the name of the fruit of the tree o knowledge, as a trial of Adam's obedience; the devil to inflame th ambition of the woman, to whom that fruit already seemed beautiful told her that by tasting it they should be as gods, knowing \"good\" an \"evil.\" Whereupon having both eaten, they did indeed take upon the God's office, which is judicature of good and evil; but acquired no ne ability to distinguish between them aright. And whereas it is said that having eaten, they saw they were naked; no man hath so interprete that place, as if they had been formerly blind, and saw not their ow skins: the meaning is plain, that it was then they first judged thei nakedness, wherein it was God's will to create them, to be uncomely and by being ashamed, did tacitly censure God Himself. And thereupo God saith: \"Hast thou eaten, etc.,\" as if He should say, doest tho that owest me obedience, take upon thee to judge of my commandments Whereby it is clearly, though allegorically, signified that th commands of them that have the right to command, are not by thei subjects to be censured nor disputed."} +{"text":"So that it appeareth plainly, to my understanding, both from reason an Scripture, that the sovereign power, whether placed in one man, as i monarchy, or in one assembly of men, as in popular and aristocratica commonwealths, is as great as possibly men can be imagined to make it And though of so unlimited a power, men may fancy many evi consequences, yet the consequences of the want of it, which i perpetual war of every man against his neighbour, are much worse. Th condition of man in this life shall never be without inconveniences but there happeneth in no commonwealth any great inconvenience but wha proceeds from the subject's disobedience, and breach of thos covenants, from which the commonwealth has its being. And whosoeve thinking sovereign power too great, will seek to make it less, mus subject himself to the power that can limit it; that is to say, to greater."} +{"text":"The greatest objection is, that of the practice; when men ask where an when such power has by subjects been acknowledged. But one may ask the again, when or where has there been a kingdom long free from seditio and civil war. In those nations whose commonwealths have bee long-lived, and not been destroyed but by foreign war, the subject never did dispute of the sovereign power. But howsoever, an argumen from the practice of men, that have not sifted to the bottom, and wit exact reason weighed the causes and nature of commonwealths, and suffe daily those miseries that proceed from the ignorance thereof, i invalid. For though in all places of the world men should lay th foundation of their houses on the sand, it could not thence be inferre that so it ought to be. The skill of making and maintainin commonwealths, consisteth in certain rules, as doth arithmetic an geometry; not, as tennis-play, on practice only: which rules neithe poor men have the leisure, nor men that have had the leisure, hav hitherto had the curiosity, or the method to find out."} +{"text":"XI"} +{"text":"Of the Liberty of Subjects"} +{"text":"Liberty, or \"freedom,\" signifieth, properly, the absence of opposition by opposition, I mean external impediments of motion; and may b applied no less to irrational and inanimate creatures than to rational For whatsoever is so tied, or environed, as it cannot move but within certain space, which space is determined by the opposition of som external body, we say it hath not liberty to go further. And so of al living creatures whilst they are imprisoned, or restrained, with wall or chains; and of the water whilst it is kept in by banks or vessels that otherwise would spread itself into a larger space, we use to say they are not at liberty to move in such manner, as without thos external impediments they would. But when the impediment of motion i in the constitution of the thing itself, we use not to say, it want the liberty, but the power to move; as when a stone lieth still, or man is fastened to his bed by sickness."} +{"text":"And according to this proper and generally received meaning of th word, a \"freeman, is he, that in those things, which by his strengt and wit he is able to do, is not hindered to do what he has a will to.\ But when the words \"free,\" and \"liberty,\" are applied to anything bu \"bodies,\" they are abused; for that which is not subject to motion, i not subject to impediment; and therefore, when it is said for example the way is free, no liberty of the way is signified, but of those tha walk in it without stop. And when we say a gift is free, there is no meant any liberty of the gift, but of the giver, that was not bound b any law or covenant to give it. So when we \"speak freely,\" it is no the liberty of voice, or pronunciation, but of the man, whom no la hath obliged to speak otherwise than he did. Lastly, from the use o the word \"freewill,\" no liberty can be inferred of the will, desire, o inclination, but the liberty of the man; which consisteth in this, tha he finds no stop, in doing what he has the will, desire, or inclinatio to do."} +{"text":"Fear and liberty are consistent; as when a man throweth his goods int the sea for \"fear\" the ship should sink, he doth it nevertheless ver willingly, and may refuse to do it if he will: it is therefore th action of one that was \"free\"; so a man sometimes pays his debt, onl for \"fear\" of imprisonment, which because nobody hindered him fro detaining, was the action of a man at \"liberty.\" And generally al actions which men do in commonwealths, for \"fear\" of the law, ar actions which the doers had \"liberty\" to omit."} +{"text":"\"Liberty\" and \"necessity\" are consistent, as in the water that hath no only \"liberty,\" but a \"necessity\" of descending by the channel; s likewise in the actions which men voluntarily do: which, because the proceed from their will, proceed from \"liberty\"; and yet, because ever act of man's will, and every desire and inclination proceedeth fro some cause, and that from another cause, in a continual chain, whos first link is in the hand of God the first of all causes, proceed fro \"necessity.\" So that to him that could see the connection of thos causes, the \"necessity\" of all men's voluntary actions would appea manifest. And therefore God, that seeth and disposeth all things, seet also that the \"liberty\" of man in doing what he will, is accompanie with the \"necessity\" of doing that which God will, and no more no less. For though men may do many things which God does not command, no is therefore author of them; yet they can have no passion, nor appetit to anything, of which appetite God's will is not the cause. And did no His will assure the \"necessity\" of man's will, and consequently of al that on man's will dependeth, the \"liberty\" of men would be contradiction, and impediment to the omnipotence and \"liberty\" of God And this shall suffice, as to the matter in hand, of that natura \"liberty,\" which only is properly called \"liberty.\""} +{"text":"But as men, for the attaining of peace, and conservation of themselve thereby, have made an artificial man, which we call a commonwealth; s also have they made artificial chains, called \"civil laws,\" which the themselves, by mutual covenants, have fastened at one end, to the lip of that man, or assembly, to whom they have given the sovereign power and at the other end to their own ears. These bonds, in their ow nature but weak, may nevertheless be made to hold, by the danger though not by the difficulty of breaking them."} +{"text":"In relation to these bonds only it is, that I am to speak now, of th \"liberty\" of \"subjects.\" For seeing there is no commonwealth in th world, wherein there be rules enough set down for the regulating of al the actions and words of men, as being a thing impossible; it followet necessarily, that in all kinds of actions by the laws praetermitted men have the liberty of doing what their own reasons shall suggest, fo the most profitable to themselves. For if we take liberty in the prope sense, for corporal liberty; that is to say, freedom from chains an prison; it were very absurd for men to clamour as they do for th liberty they so manifestly enjoy. Again, if we take liberty for a exemption from laws, it is no less absurd for men to demand as they d that liberty by which all other men may be masters of their lives. An yet, as absurd as it is, this is it they demand; not knowing that th laws are of no power to protect them, without a sword in the hands of man, or men, to cause those laws to be put in execution. The liberty o a subject lieth therefore only in those things which in regulatin their actions, the sovereign hath pretermitted: such as is the libert to buy and sell, and otherwise contract with one another; to choos their own abode, their own diet, their own trade of life, and institut their children as they themselves think fit; and the like."} +{"text":"Nevertheless we are not to understand, that by such liberty, th sovereign power of life and death is either abolished or limited. Fo it has been already shown, that nothing the sovereign representativ can do to a subject, on what pretence soever, can properly be calle injustice or injury; because every subject is author of every act th sovereign doth; so that he never wanteth right to anything, otherwis than as he himself is the subject of God, and bound thereby to observ the laws of Nature. And therefore it may, and doth often happen i commonwealths, that a subject may be put to death by the command of th sovereign power; and yet neither do the other wrong: as when Jephth caused his daughter to be sacrificed; in which, and the like cases, h that so dieth, had liberty to do the action, for which he i nevertheless without injury put to death. And the same holdeth also i a sovereign prince that putteth to death an innocent subject. Fo though the action be against the law of Nature, as being contrary t equity, as was the killing of Uriah, by David; yet it was not an injur to Uriah, but to God. Not to Uriah, because the right to do what h pleased was given him by Uriah himself: and yet to God, because Davi was God's subject, and prohibited all iniquity by the law of Nature which distinction, David himself, when he repented the fact, evidentl confirmed, saying, \"To thee only have I sinned.\" In the same manner th people of Athens, when they banished the most potent of thei commonwealth for ten years, thought they committed no injustice; an yet they never questioned what crime he had done; but what hurt h would do: nay they commanded the banishment of they knew not whom; an every citizen bringing his oystershell into the marketplace, writte with the name of him he desired should be banished, without actuall accusing him, sometimes banished an Aristides, for his reputation o justice; and sometimes a scurrilous jester, as Hyperbolus, to make jest of it. And yet a man cannot say, the sovereign people of Athen wanted right to banish them; or an Athenian the liberty to jest, or t be just."} +{"text":"The liberty, whereof there is so frequent and honourable mention in th histories and philosophy of the ancient Greeks and Romans, and in th writings and discourse of those that from them have received all thei learning in the politics, is not the liberty of particular men; but th liberty of the commonwealth: which is the same with that which ever man then should have, if there were no civil laws, nor commonwealth a all. And the effects of it also be the same. For as amongst masterles men there is perpetual war, of every man against his neighbour; n inheritance, to transmit to the son, nor to expect from the father; n propriety of goods, or lands; no security; but a full and absolut liberty in every particular man: so in states and commonwealths no dependent on one another, every commonwealth, not every man, has a absolute liberty to do what it shall judge, that is to say, what tha man, or assembly that representeth it, shall judge most conducing t their benefit. But withal, they live in the condition of a perpetua war, and upon the confines of battle, with their frontiers armed, an cannons planted against their neighbours round about. The Athenians an Romans were free; that is, free commonwealths: not that any particula men had the liberty to resist their own representative; but that thei representative had the liberty to resist, or invade other people. Ther is written on the turrets of the city of Lucca, in great characters, a this day, the word \"Libertas\"; yet no man can thence infer, that particular man has more liberty, or immunity from the service of th commonwealth there, than in Constantinople. Whether a commonwealth b monarchical, or popular, the freedom is still the same."} +{"text":"But it is an easy thing for men to be deceived by the specious name o liberty; and for want of judgment to distinguish, mistake that fo their private inheritance and birthright, which is the right of th public only. And when the same error is confirmed by the authority o men in reputation for their writings on this subject, it is no wonde if it produce sedition, and change of government. In these wester parts of the world, we are made to receive our opinions concerning th institution and rights of commonwealths, from Aristotle, Cicero, an other men, Greeks and Romans, that living under popular states, derive those rights, not from the principles of Nature, but transcribed the into their books, out of the practice of their own commonwealths, whic were popular; as the grammarians describe the rules of language out o the practice of the time; or the rules of poetry out of the poems o Homer and Virgil. And because the Athenians were taught to keep the from desire of changing their government, that they were free men, an all that lived under monarchy were slaves; therefore Aristotle put i down in his Politics (lib. 6, cap. II): \"In democracy, `liberty' is t be supposed: for it is commonly held, that no man is `free' in an other government.\" And as Aristotle, so Cicero and other writers hav grounded their civil doctrine on the opinions of the Romans, who wer taught to hate monarchy, at first, by them that having deposed thei sovereign, shared amongst them the sovereignty of Rome; and afterward by their successors. And by reading of these Greek and Latin authors men from their childhood have gotten a habit, under a false show o liberty, of favouring tumults, and of licentious controlling th actions of their sovereigns, and again of controlling thos controllers; with the effusion of so much blood, as I think I may trul say, there was never anything so dearly bought as these western part have bought the learning of the Greek and Latin tongues."} +{"text":"To come now to the particulars of the true liberty of a subject; tha is to say, what are the things, which though commanded by th sovereign, he may nevertheless, without injustice, refuse to do; we ar to consider what rights we pass away, when we make a commonwealth; or which is all one, what liberty we deny ourselves, by owning all th actions, without exception, of the man, or assembly, we make ou sovereign. For in the act of our \"submission,\" consisteth both ou \"obligation,\" and our \"liberty\"; which must therefore be inferred b arguments taken from thence; there being no obligation on any man which ariseth not from some act of his own; for all men equally, are b Nature free. And because such arguments must either be drawn from th express words, \"I authorize all his actions,\" or from the intention o him that submitteth himself to his power, which intention is to b understood by the end for which he so submitteth; the obligation an liberty of the subject, is to be derived, either from those words, o others equivalent; or else from the end of the institution o sovereignty, namely, the peace of the subjects within themselves, an their defence against a common enemy."} +{"text":"First therefore, seeing sovereignty by institution, is by covenant o everyone to everyone; and sovereignty by acquisition, by covenants o the vanquished to the victor, or child to the parent; it is manifest that every subject has liberty in all those things, the right whereo cannot by covenant be transferred. I have shown before in th fourteenth chapter, that covenants, not to defend a man's own body, ar void. Therefore,"} +{"text":"If the sovereign command a man, though justly condemned, to kill wound, or maim himself; or not to resist those that assault him; or t abstain from the use of food, air, medicine, or any other thing without which he cannot live; yet hath that man the liberty to disobey."} +{"text":"If a man be interrogated by the sovereign, or his authority, concernin a crime done by himself, he is not bound, without assurance of pardon to confess it; because no man, as I have shown in the same chapter, ca be obliged by covenant to accuse himself."} +{"text":"Again, the consent of a subject to sovereign power, is contained i these words, \"I authorize, or take upon me, all his actions\"; in whic there is no restriction at all, of his own former natural liberty: fo by allowing him to \"kill me,\" I am not bound to kill myself when h commands me. It is one thing to say, \"kill me, or my fellow, if yo please\"; another thing to say, \"I will kill myself, or my fellow.\" I followeth therefore, that,"} +{"text":"No man is bound by the words themselves, either to kill himself, or an other man; and consequently, that the obligation a man may sometime have, upon the command of the sovereign to execute any dangerous o dishonourable office, dependeth not on the words of our submission; bu on the intention, which is to be understood by the end thereof. Whe therefore our refusal to obey, frustrates the end for which th sovereignty was ordained; then there is no liberty to refuse: otherwis there is."} +{"text":"Upon this ground, a man that is commanded as a soldier to fight agains the enemy, though his sovereign have right enough to punish his refusa with death, may nevertheless in many cases refuse, without injustice as when he substituteth a sufficient soldier in his place: for in thi case he deserteth not the service of the commonwealth. And there i allowance to be made for natural timorousness; not only to women, o whom no such dangerous duty is expected, but also to men of feminin courage. When armies fight, there is on one side, or both, a runnin away; yet when they do it not out of treachery, but fear, they are no esteemed to do it unjustly, but dishonourably. For the same reason, t avoid battle, is not injustice, but cowardice. But he that enrollet himself a soldier, or taketh impressed money, taketh away the excuse o a timorous nature; and is obliged, not only to go to the battle, bu also not to run from it, without his captain's leave. And when th defence of the commonwealth requireth at once the help of all that ar able to bear arms, everyone is obliged; because otherwise th institution of the commonwealth, which they have not the purpose o courage to preserve, was in vain."} +{"text":"To resist the sword of the commonwealth in defence of another man guilty or innocent, no man hath liberty; because such liberty take away from the sovereign the means of protecting us; and is therefor destructive of the very essence of government. But in case a great man men together have already resisted the sovereign power unjustly, o committed some capital crime for which every one of them expectet death, whether have they not the liberty then to join together, an assist and defend one another? Certainly they have; for they but defen their lives, which the guilty man may as well do as the innocent. Ther was indeed injustice in the first breach of their duty; their bearin of arms subsequent to it, though it be to maintain what they have done is no new unjust act. And if it be only to defend their persons, it i not unjust at all. But the offer of pardon taketh from them to whom i is offered the plea of self-defence, and maketh their perseverance i assisting or defending the rest unlawful."} +{"text":"As for other liberties, they depend on the silence of the law. In case where the sovereign has prescribed no rule, there the subject hath th liberty to do, or forbear, according to his own discretion. An therefore such liberty is in some places more, and in some less; and i some times more, in other times less, according as they that have th sovereignty shall think most convenient. As for example, there was time when, in England, a man might enter into his own land, an dispossess such as wrongfully possessed it, by force. But i aftertimes, that liberty of forcible entry was taken away by a statut made by the king in parliament. And in some places of the world, me have the liberty of many wives; in other places such liberty is no allowed."} +{"text":"If a subject have a controversy with his sovereign, of debt, or o right of possession of lands or goods, or concerning any servic required at his hands, or concerning any penalty, corporal o pecuniary, grounded on a precedent law; he hath the same liberty to su for his right as if it were against a subject, and before such judge as are appointed by the sovereign. For seeing the sovereign demandet by force of a former law, and not by virtue of his power; he declaret thereby that he requireth no more than shall appear to be due by tha law. The suit therefore is not contrary to the will of the sovereign and consequently the subject hath the liberty to demand the hearing o his cause; and sentence, according to that law. But if he demand, o take anything by pretence of his power there lieth, in that case, n action of law; for all that is done by him in virtue of his power, i done by the authority of every subject, and consequently he that bring an action against the sovereign, brings it against himself."} +{"text":"If a monarch, or sovereign assembly, grant a liberty to all or any o his subjects, which grant standing, he is disabled to provide for thei safety, the grant is void, unless he directly renounce or transfer th sovereignty to another. For in that he might openly, if it had been hi will, and in plain terms, have renounced or transferred it, and di not; it is to be understood it was not his will, but that the gran proceeded from ignorance of the repugnancy between such a liberty an the sovereign power, and therefore the sovereignty is still retained and consequently all those powers, which are necessary to th exercising thereof; such as are the power of war and peace, o judicature, of appointing officers and councillors, of levying money and the rest named in the eighteenth chapter."} +{"text":"The obligation of subjects to the sovereign is understood to last a long, and no longer, than the power lasteth by which he is able t protect them. For the right men have by nature to protect themselves when none else can protect them, can by no covenant be relinquished The sovereignty is the soul of the commonwealth, which once departe from the body, the members do no more receive their motion from it. Th end of obedience is protection, which, wheresoever a man seeth it either in his own or in another's sword, nature applieth his obedienc to it, and his endeavour to maintain it. And though sovereignty, in th intention of them that make it, be immortal, yet is it in its ow nature not only subject to violent death by foreign war, but also through the ignorance and passions of men, it hath in it, from the ver institution, many seeds of a natural mortality, by intestine discord."} +{"text":"If a subject be taken prisoner in war, or his person, or his means o life be within the guards of the enemy, and hath his life and corpora liberty given him on condition to be subject to the victor, he hat liberty to accept the condition; and having accepted it, is the subjec of him that took him, because he had no other way to preserve himself The case is the same, if he be detained on the same terms, in a foreig country. But if a man be held in prison, or bonds, or is not truste with the liberty of his body, he cannot be understood to be bound b covenant to subjection; and therefore may, if he can, make his escap by any means whatsoever."} +{"text":"If a monarch shall relinquish the sovereignty, both for himself and hi heirs, his subjects return to the absolute liberty of nature; because though nature may declare who are his sons, and who are the nearest o his kin, yet it dependeth on his own will, as hath been said in th precedent chapter, who shall be his heir. If therefore he will have n heir, there is no sovereignty, nor subjection. The case is the same i he die without known kindred, and without declaration of his heir. Fo then there can no heir be known, and consequently no subjection be due."} +{"text":"If the sovereign banish his subject, during the banishment he is no subject. But he that is sent on a message, or hath leave to travel, i still subject; but it is, by contract between sovereigns, not by virtu of the covenant of subjection. For whosoever entereth into another' dominion, is subject to all the laws thereof, unless he have privilege by the amity of the sovereigns, or by special license."} +{"text":"If a monarch subdued by war render himself subject to the victor, hi subjects are delivered from their former obligation, and become oblige to the victor. But if he be held prisoner, or have not the liberty o his own body, he is not understood to have given away the right o sovereignty; and therefore his subjects are obliged to yield obedienc to the magistrates formerly placed, governing not in their own name but in his. For, his right remaining, the question is only of th administration; that is to say, of the magistrates and officers, which if we have not means to name, he is supposed to approve those which h himself had formerly appointed."} +{"text":"XII"} +{"text":"Of Systems Subject, Political, and Private"} +{"text":"Having spoken of the generation, form, and power of a commonwealth, am in order to speak next of the parts thereof. And first of system which resemble the similar parts, or muscles of a body natural. B \"systems,\" I understand any numbers of men joined in one interest, o one business. Of which, some are \"regular,\" and some \"irregular.\ \"Regular\" are those where one man, or assembly of men, is constitute representative of the whole number. All other are \"irregular.\""} +{"text":"Of regular some are \"absolute\" and \"independent,\" subject to none bu their own representative: such are only commonwealths; of which I hav spoken already in the five last precedent chapters. Others ar dependent; that is to say, subordinate to some sovereign power, t which everyone, as also their representative is \"subject.\""} +{"text":"Of systems subordinate, some are \"political,\" and some \"private.\ \"Political,\" otherwise called \"bodies politic,\" and \"persons in law,\ are those which are made by authority from the sovereign power of th commonwealth. \"Private,\" are those which are constituted by subject amongst themselves, or by authority from a stranger. For no authorit derived from foreign power within the dominion of another, is publi there, but private."} +{"text":"And of private systems, some are \"lawful\": some \"unlawful.\" \"Lawful,\ are those which are allowed by the commonwealth: all other ar \"unlawful.\" \"Irregular\" systems are those which having n representative, consist only in concourse of people: which if no forbidden by the commonwealth, nor made on evil design, such as ar conflux of people to markets, or shows, or any other harmless end, ar lawful. But when the intention is evil, or (if the number b considerable) unknown, they are unlawful."} +{"text":"In bodies politic, the power of the representative is always limited and that which prescribeth the limits thereof, is the power sovereign For power unlimited is absolute sovereignty. And the sovereign in ever commonwealth is the absolute representative of all the subjects; an therefore no other can be representative of any part of them, but s far forth as he shall give leave. And to give leave to a body politi of subjects, to have an absolute representative to all intents an purposes, were to abandon the government of so much of th commonwealth, and to divide the dominion contrary to their peace an defence; which the sovereign cannot be understood to do by any gran that does not plainly and directly discharge them of their subjection For consequences of words, are not the signs of his will, when othe consequences are signs of the contrary; but rather signs of error an misreckoning; to which all mankind is too prone."} +{"text":"The bounds of that power, which is given to the representative of body politic, are to be taken notice of from two things. One is thei writ, or letters from the sovereign: the other is the law of th commonwealth."} +{"text":"For though in the institution or acquisition of a commonwealth, whic is independent, there needs no writing, because the power of th representative has there no other bounds, but such as are set out b the unwritten law of Nature; yet in subordinate bodies, there are suc diversities of limitation necessary concerning their businesses, times and places, as can neither be remembered without letters, nor take notice of, unless such letters be patent, that they may be read t them, and withal sealed, or testified, with the seals, or othe permanent signs of the authority sovereign."} +{"text":"And because such limitation is not always easy, or perhaps possible t be described in writing; the ordinary laws, common to all subjects must determine what the representative may lawfully do in all case where the letters themselves are silent. And therefore,"} +{"text":"In a body politic, if the representative be one man, whatsoever he doe in the person of the body which is not warranted in his letters, nor b the laws, is his own act, and not the act of the body, nor of any othe member thereof besides himself; because further than his letters, o the law's limit, he representeth no man's person, but his own. But wha he does according to these is the act of everyone: for of the act o the sovereign everyone is author, because he is their representativ unlimited; and the act of him that recedes not from the letters of th sovereign, is the act of the sovereign, and therefore every member o the body is author of it."} +{"text":"But if the representative be an assembly, whatsoever that assembl shall decree, not warranted by their letters or the laws, is the act o the assembly or body politic, and the act of everyone by whose vote th decree was made; but not the act of any man that being present voted t the contrary; nor of any man absent, unless he voted it by procuration It is the act of the assembly, because voted by the major part; and i it be a crime, the assembly may be punished, as far forth as it i capable, as by dissolution or forfeiture of their letters (which is t such artificial and fictitious bodies capital), or, if the assembl have a common stock, wherein none of the innocent members hav propriety, by pecuniary mulct. For from corporal penalties Nature hat exempted all bodies politic. But they that gave not their vote ar therefore innocent, because the assembly cannot represent any man i things unwarranted by their letters, and consequently are not involve in their votes."} +{"text":"If the person of the body politic, being in one man, borrow money of stranger, that is, of one that is not of the same body (for no letter need limit borrowing, seeing it is left to men's own inclinations t limit lending), the debt is the representative's. For if he should hav authority from his letters to make the members pay what he borroweth he should have by consequence the sovereignty of them; and therefor the grant were either void, as proceeding from error, commonly inciden to human nature, and an insufficient sign of the will of the granter or if it be avowed by him, then is the representer sovereign, an falleth not under the present question, which is only of bodie subordinate. No member therefore is obliged to pay the debt s borrowed, but the representative himself; because he that lendeth it being a stranger to the letters and to the qualification of the body understandeth those only for his debtors that are engaged; and seein the representer can engage himself and none else, has him only fo debtor, who must therefore pay him out of the common stock, if there b any, or, if there be none, out of his own estate."} +{"text":"If he come into debt by contract or mulct, the case is the same."} +{"text":"But when the representative is an assembly, and the debt to a stranger all they, and only they, are responsible for the debt that gave thei votes to the borrowing of it, or to the contract that made it due, o to the fact for which the mulct was imposed; because every one of thos in voting did engage himself for the payment; for he that is author o the borrowing is obliged to the payment, even of the whole debt, thoug when paid by anyone, he be discharged."} +{"text":"But if the debt be to one of the assembly, the assembly only is oblige to the payment out of their common stock, if they have any: for havin liberty of vote, if he vote the money shall be borrowed, he votes i shall be paid; if he vote it shall not be borrowed, or be absent, ye because in lending he voteth the borrowing, he contradicteth his forme vote, and is obliged by the latter, and becomes both borrower an lender, and consequently cannot demand payment from any particular man but from the common treasure only; which failing he hath no remedy no complaint, but against himself, that being privy to the acts of th assembly, and to their means to pay, and not being enforced, di nevertheless through his own folly lend his money."} +{"text":"It is manifest by this, that in bodies politic subordinate, and subjec to a sovereign power, it is sometimes not only lawful, but expedient for a particular man to make open protestation against the decrees o the representative assembly, and cause their dissent to be registered or to take witness of it; because otherwise they may be obliged to pa debts contracted, and be responsible for crimes committed by other men But in a sovereign assembly, that liberty is taken away, both becaus he that protesteth there denies their sovereignty; and also becaus whatsoever is commanded by the sovereign power, is as to the subject though not so always in the sight of God, justified by the command: fo of such command every subject is the author."} +{"text":"The variety of bodies politic, is almost infinite: for they are no only distinguished by the several affairs, for which they ar constituted, wherein there is an unspeakable diversity; but also by th times, places, and numbers, subject to many limitations. And as t their affairs, some are ordained for government; as first, th government of a province, may be committed to an assembly of men wherein all resolutions shall depend on the votes of the major part and then this assembly is a body politic, and their power limited b commission. This word province signifies a charge, or care of business which he whose business it is, committeth to another man, to b administered for, and under him; and therefore when in one commonwealt there be divers countries, that have their laws distinct one fro another, or are far distant in place, the administration of th government being committed to divers persons, those countries where th sovereign is not resident, but governs by commission, are calle provinces. But of the government of a province, by an assembly residin in the province itself, there be few examples. The Romans, who had th sovereignty of many provinces, yet governed them always by president and praetors; and not by assemblies, as they governed the city of Rome and territories adjacent. In like manner, when there were colonies sen from England, to plant Virginia and Sommer Islands, though th governments of them here were committed to assemblies in London, ye did those assemblies never commit the government under them to an assembly there, but did to each plantation send one governor. Fo though every man, where he can be present by nature, desires t participate of government; yet where they cannot be present, they ar by nature also inclined to commit the government of their commo interest rather to a monarchical than a popular form of government which is also evident in those men that have great private estates; wh when they are unwilling to take the pains of administering the busines that belongs to them, choose rather to trust one servant, than a assembly either of their friends or servants. But howsoever it be i fact, yet we may suppose the government of a province or colon committed to an assembly: and when it is, that which in this place have to say, is this; that whatsoever debt is by that assembl contracted; or whatsoever unlawful act is decreed, is the act only o those that assented, and not of any that dissented, or were absent, fo the reasons before alleged. Also that an assembly residing out of th bounds of that colony whereof they have the government, cannot execut any power over the persons or goods of any of the colony, to seize o them for debt, or other duty, in any place without the colony itself as having no jurisdiction, nor authority elsewhere, but are left to th remedy which the law of the place alloweth them. And though th assembly have right to impose a mulct upon any of their members tha shall break the laws they make; yet out of the colony itself, they hav no right to execute the same. And that which is said here of the right of an assembly, for the government of a province or a colony, i appliable also to an assembly for the government of a town, a university, or a college, or a church, or for any other government ove the persons of men."} +{"text":"And generally, in all bodies politic, if any particular member conceiv himself injured by the body itself, the cognizance of his caus belongeth to the sovereign, and those the sovereign hath ordained fo judges in such causes, or shall ordain for that particular cause; an not to the body itself. For the whole body is in this case hi fellow-subject, which in a sovereign assembly is otherwise: for there if the sovereign be not judge, though in his own cause, there can be n judge at all."} +{"text":"In a body politic, for the well ordering of foreign traffic, the mos commodious representative is an assembly of all the members; that is t say, such a one, as everyone that adventureth his money, may be presen at all the deliberations and resolutions of the body, if they wil themselves. For proof whereof, we are to consider the end, for whic men that are merchants, and may buy and sell, export and import thei merchandize, according to their own discretions, do nevertheless bin themselves up in one corporation. It is true, there be few merchants that with the merchandize they buy at home, can freight a ship, t export it; or with that they buy abroad, to bring it home; and hav therefore need to join together in one society; where every man ma either participate of the gain, according to the proportion of hi adventure; or take his own, and sell what he transports, or imports, a such prices as he thinks fit. But this is no body politic, there bein no common representative to oblige them to any other law than tha which is common to all other subjects. The end of their incorporating is to make their gain the greater; which is done two ways; by sol buying and sole selling, both at home and abroad. So that to grant to company of merchants to be a corporation, or body politic, is to gran them a double monopoly, whereof one is to be sole buyers; another to b sole sellers. For when there is a company incorporate for an particular foreign country, they only export the commodities vendibl in that country; which is sole buying at home and sole selling abroad For at home there is but one buyer and abroad but one that selleth both which is gainful to the merchant, because thereby they buy at hom at lower and sell abroad at higher rates: and abroad there is but on buyer of foreign merchandize and but one that sells them at home; bot which again are gainful to the adventurers."} +{"text":"Of this double monopoly one part is disadvantageous to the people a home, the other to foreigners. For at home by their sole exportatio they set what price they please on the husbandry and handiworks of th people; and by the sole importation, what price they please on al foreign commodities the people have need of; both which are ill for th people. On the contrary, by the sole selling of the native commoditie abroad, and sole buying the foreign commodities upon the place, the raise the price of those, and abate the price of these, to th disadvantage of the foreigner; for where but one selleth, th merchandize is the dearer; and where but one buyeth, the cheaper. Suc corporations therefore are no other than monopolies; though they woul be very profitable for a commonwealth, if being bound up into one bod in foreign markets they were at liberty at home, every man to buy an sell at what price he could."} +{"text":"The end of these bodies of merchants being not a common benefit to th whole body, which have in this case no common stock, but what i deducted out of the particular adventures, for building, buying victualling and manning of ships, but the particular gain of ever adventurer, it is reason that everyone be acquainted with th employment of his own; that is, that everyone be of the assembly, tha shall have the power to order the same; and be acquainted with thei accounts. And therefore the representative of such a body must be a assembly, where every member of the body may be present at th consultations, if he will."} +{"text":"If a body politic of merchants contract a debt to a stranger by the ac of their representative assembly, every member is liable by himself fo the whole. For a stranger can take no notice of their private laws, bu considereth them as so many particular men, obliged everyone to th whole payment, till payment made by one dischargeth all the rest: bu if the debt be to one of the company, the creditor is debtor for th whole to himself, and cannot therefore demand his debt, but only fro the common stock, if there be any."} +{"text":"If the commonwealth impose a tax upon the body, it is understood to b laid upon every member proportionably to his particular adventure i the company. For there is in this case no other common stock, but wha is made of their particular adventures."} +{"text":"If a mulct be laid upon the body for some unlawful act, they only ar liable by whose votes the act was decreed, or by whose assistance i was executed; for in none of the rest is there any other crime bu being of the body; which if a crime, because the body was ordained b the authority of the commonwealth, is not his."} +{"text":"If one of the members be indebted to the body, he may be sued by th body; but his goods cannot be taken, nor his person imprisoned by th authority of the body; but only by authority of the commonwealth: fo if they can do it by their own authority, they can by their ow authority give judgment that the debt is due; which is as much as to b judge in their own cause."} +{"text":"Those bodies made for the government of men, or of traffic, be eithe perpetual, or for a time prescribed by writing. But there be bodie also whose times are limited, and that only by the nature of thei business. For example, if a sovereign monarch, or a sovereign assembly shall think fit to give command to the towns, and other several part of their territory, to send to him their deputies, to inform him of th condition and necessities of the subjects, or to advise with him fo the making of good laws, or for any other cause, as with one perso representing the whole country, such deputies, having a place and tim of meeting assigned them, are there, and at that time, a body politic representing every subject of that dominion; but it is only for suc matters as shall be propounded unto them by that man, or assembly, tha by the sovereign authority sent for them; and when it shall be declare that nothing more shall be propounded, nor debated by them, the body i dissolved. For if they were the absolute representatives of the people then were it the sovereign assembly; and so there would be tw sovereign assemblies, or two sovereigns, over the same people; whic cannot consist with their peace. And therefore where there is once sovereignty, there can be no absolute representation of the people, bu by it. And for the limits of how far such a body shall represent th whole people, they are set forth in the writing by which they were sen for. For the people cannot choose their deputies to other intent tha is in the writing directed to them from their sovereign expressed."} +{"text":"Private bodies regular and lawful, are those that are constitute without letters, or other written authority, saving the laws common t all other subjects. And because they be united in one perso representative, they are held for regular; such as are all families, i which the father or master ordereth the whole family. For he obliget his children and servants, as far as the law permitteth, though no further, because none of them are bound to obedience in those actions which the law hath forbidden to be done. In all other actions, durin the time they are under domestic government, they are subject to thei fathers and masters, as to their immediate sovereigns. For the fathe and master, being before the institution of commonwealth, absolut sovereigns in their own families, they lose afterward no more of thei authority than the law of the commonwealth taketh from them."} +{"text":"Private bodies regular, but unlawful, are those that unite themselve into one person representative, without any public authority at all such as are the corporations of beggars, thieves and gipsies, th better to order their trade of begging and stealing; and th corporations of men, that by authority from any foreign person, unit themselves in another's dominion, for the easier propagation o doctrines, and for making a party against the power of th commonwealth."} +{"text":"Irregular systems, in their nature but leagues, or sometimes mer concourse of people, without union to any particular design, not b obligation of one to another, but proceeding only from a similitude o wills and inclinations, become lawful or unlawful according to th lawfulness or unlawfulness of every particular man's design therein and his design is to be understood by the occasion."} +{"text":"The leagues of subjects, because leagues are commonly made for mutua defence, are in a commonwealth, which is no more than a league of al the subjects together, for the most part unnecessary, and savour o unlawful design; and are for that cause unlawful, and go commonly b the name of factions, or conspiracies. For a league being a connectio of men by covenants, if there be no power given to any one man o assembly, as in the condition of mere nature, to compel them t performance, is so long only valid, as there ariseth no just cause o distrust: and therefore leagues between commonwealths, over whom ther is no human power established, to keep them all in awe, are not onl lawful, but also profitable for the time they last. But leagues of th subjects of one and the same commonwealth, where everyone may obtai his right by means of the sovereign power, are unnecessary to th maintaining of peace and justice, and, in case the design of them b evil or unknown to the commonwealth, unlawful. For all uniting o strength by private men, is, if for evil intent, unjust; if for inten unknown, dangerous to the public, and unjustly concealed."} +{"text":"If the sovereign power be in a great assembly, and a number of men part of the assembly, without authority consult apart, to contrive th guidance of the rest; this is a faction, or conspiracy unlawful, a being a fraudulent seducing of the assembly for their particula interest. But if he, whose private interest is to be debated and judge in the assembly, make as many friends as he can; in him it is n injustice; because in this case he is no part of the assembly. An though he hire such friends with money, unless there be an express la against it, yet it is not injustice. For sometimes, as men's manner are, justice cannot be had without money; and every man may think hi own cause just, till it be heard and judged."} +{"text":"In all commonwealths, if private men entertain more servants than th government of his estate, and lawful employment he has for the requires, it is faction, and unlawful. For having the protection of th commonwealth, he needeth not the defence of private force. And wherea in nations not thoroughly civilized, several numerous families hav lived in continual hostility, and invaded one another with privat force; yet it is evident enough that they have done unjustly, or els they had no commonwealth."} +{"text":"And as factions for kindred, so also factions for government o religion, as of Papists, Protestants, etc., or of state, as patrician and plebeians of old time in Rome, and of aristocraticals an democraticals of old time in Greece, are unjust, as being contrary t the peace and safety of the people, and a taking of the sword out o the hand of the sovereign."} +{"text":"Concourse of people is an irregular system, the lawfulness o unlawfulness whereof dependeth on the occasion, and on the number o them that are assembled. If the occasion be lawful and manifest, th concourse is lawful, as the usual meeting of men at church, or at public show, in usual numbers; for if the numbers be extraordinaril great, the occasion is not evident; and consequently he that canno render a particular and good account of his being amongst them, is t be judged conscious of an unlawful and tumultuous design. It may b lawful for a thousand men to join to a petition to be delivered to judge or magistrate, yet if a thousand men come to present it, it is tumultuous assembly, because there needs but one or two for tha purpose. But in such cases as these, it is not a set number that make the assembly unlawful, but such a number as the present officers ar not able to suppress and bring to justice."} +{"text":"When an unusual number of men assemble against a man whom they accuse the assembly is an unlawful tumult; because they may deliver thei accusation to the magistrate by a few, or by one man. Such was the cas of St. Paul at Ephesus, where Demetrius and a great number of other me brought two of Paul's companions before the magistrate, saying with on voice \"Great is Diana of the Ephesians,\" which was their way o demanding justice against them for teaching the people such doctrine a was against their religion and trade. The occasion here, considerin the laws of that people, was just, yet was their assembly judge unlawful, and the magistrate reprehended them for it in these word (Acts 19:38�-�40): \"If Demetrius and the other workmen can accuse an man of anything, there be pleas and deputies, let them accuse on another. And if you have any other thing to demand, your case may b judged in an assembly lawfully called. For we are in danger to b accused for this day's sedition; because there is no cause by which an man can render any reason of this concourse of people.\" Where h calleth an assembly whereof men can give no just account, a sedition and such as they could not answer for. And this is all I shall sa concerning \"systems\" and assemblies of people, which may be compared as I said, to the similar parts of man's body, such as be lawful, t the muscles; such as are unlawful, to wens, boils, and apostems engendered by the unnatural conflux of evil humours."} +{"text":"XIII"} +{"text":"Of the Public Ministers of Sovereign Power"} +{"text":"In the last chapter I have spoken of the similar parts of commonwealth: in this I shall speak of the parts organical, which ar public ministers."} +{"text":"A \"public minister\" is he that by the sovereign, whether a monarch o an assembly, is employed in any affairs with authority to represent i that employment the person of the commonwealth. And whereas every man or assembly that hath sovereignty, representeth two persons, or, as th more common phrase is, has two capacities, one natural and anothe politic; as a monarch hath the person not only of the commonwealth, bu also of a man, and a sovereign assembly hath the person not only of th commonwealth, but also of the assembly: they that be servants to the in their natural capacity are not public ministers; but those only tha serve them in the administration of the public business. And therefor neither ushers, nor sergeants, nor other officers that wait on th assembly for no other purpose but for the commodity of the me assembled in an aristocracy, or democracy; nor stewards, chamberlains cofferers, or any other officers of the household of a monarch, ar public ministers in a monarchy."} +{"text":"Of public ministers, some have charge committed to them of a genera administration, either of the whole dominion, or of a part thereof. O the whole, as to a protector, or regent, may be committed by th predecessor of an infant king, during his minority, the whol administration of his kingdom. In which case every subject is so fa obliged to obedience, as the ordinances he shall make and the command he shall give be in the king's name, and not inconsistent with hi sovereign power. Of a part, or province; as when either a monarch, or sovereign assembly, shall give the general charge thereof to governor, lieutenant, prefect, or viceroy: and in this case also, ever one of that province is obliged to all he shall do in the name of th sovereign, and that not incompatible with the sovereign's right. Fo such protectors, viceroys, and governors, have no other right, but wha depends on the sovereign's will; and no commission that can be give them, can be interpreted for a declaration of the will to transfer th sovereignty, without express and perspicuous words to that purpose. An this kind of public ministers resembleth the nerves and tendons tha move the several limbs of a body natural."} +{"text":"Others have special administration; that is to say, charges of som special business, either at home or abroad: as at home, first, for th economy of a commonwealth, they that have authority concerning th \"treasure,\" as tributes, impositions, rents, fines, or whatsoeve public revenue, to collect, receive, issue, or take the account thereof, are public ministers: ministers, because they serve the perso representative, and can do nothing against his command, nor without hi authority: public, because they serve him in his political capacity."} +{"text":"Secondly, they that have authority concerning the \"militia\"; to hav the custody of arms, forts, ports; to levy, pay, or conduct soldiers or to provide for any necessary thing for the use of war, either b land or sea, are public ministers. But a soldier without command though he fight for the commonwealth, does not therefore represent th person of it; because there is none to represent it to. For everyon that hath command, represents it to them only whom he commandeth."} +{"text":"They also that have authority to teach, or to enable others to teac the people their duty to the sovereign power, and instruct them in th knowledge of what is just and unjust, thereby to render them more ap to live in godliness, and in peace amongst themselves, and resist th public enemy, are public ministers: ministers in that they do it not b their own authority, but by another's; and public, because they do it or should do it, by no authority but that of the sovereign. Th monarch, or the sovereign assembly only hath immediate authority fro God, to teach and instruct the people; and no man but the sovereig receiveth his power Dei gratia simply; that is to say, from the favou of none but God: all other receive theirs from the favour an providence of God, and their sovereigns; as in a monarchy Dei gratia e regis; or Dei providentia et voluntate regis."} +{"text":"They also to whom jurisdiction is given, are public ministers. For i their seats of justice they represent the person of the sovereign; an their sentence, is his sentence: for, as hath been before declared, al judicature is essentially annexed to the sovereignty; and therefore al other judges are but ministers of him or them that have the sovereig power. And as controversies are of two sorts, namely of \"fact\" and o \"law\"; so are judgments, some of fact, some of law: and consequently i the same controversy there may be two judges, one of fact, another o law."} +{"text":"And in both these controversies there may arise a controversy betwee the party judged and the judge; which because they be both subjects t the sovereign, ought in equity to be judged by men agreed on by consen of both; for no man can be judge in his own cause. But the sovereign i already agreed on for judge by them both, and is therefore either t hear the cause and determine it himself, or appoint for judge such a they shall both agree on. And this agreement is then understood to b made between them divers ways; as first, if the defendant be allowed t except against such of his judges whose interest maketh him suspec them (for as to the complainant, he hath already chosen his own judge) those which he excepteth not against are judges he himself agrees on Secondly, if he appeal to any other judge, he can appeal no further for his appeal is his choice. Thirdly, if he appeal to the sovereig himself, and he by himself, or by delegates which the parties shal agree on, give sentence, that sentence is final; for the defendant i judged by his own judges, that is to say, by himself."} +{"text":"These properties of just and rational judicature considered, I canno forbear to observe the excellent constitution of the courts of justic established both for Common and also for Public Pleas in England. B Common Pleas, I mean those where both the complainant and defendant ar subjects; and by public, which are also called Pleas of the Crown those where the complainant is the sovereign. For whereas there wer two orders of men, whereof one was Lords, the other Commons; the Lord had this privilege, to have for judges in all capital crimes none bu Lords; and of them as many as would be present; which being eve acknowledged as a privilege of favour, their judges were none but suc as they had themselves desired. And in all controversies, every subjec (as also in civil controversies the Lords) had for judges men of th country where the matter in controversy lay; against which he migh make his exceptions, till at last twelve men without exception bein agreed on, they were judged by those twelve. So that having his ow judges, there could be nothing alleged by the party why the sentenc should not be final. These public persons, with authority from th sovereign power, either to instruct or judge the people, are suc members of the commonwealth as may fitly be compared to the organs o voice in a body natural."} +{"text":"Public ministers are also all those that have authority from th sovereign to procure the execution of judgments given; to publish th sovereign's commands; to suppress tumults; to apprehend and impriso malefactors; and other acts tending to the conservation of the peace For every act they do by such authority is the act of the commonwealth and their service, answerable to that of the hands, in a body natural."} +{"text":"Public ministers abroad are those that represent the person of thei own sovereign to foreign states. Such are ambassadors, messengers agents, and heralds, sent by public authority and on public business."} +{"text":"But such as are sent by authority only of some private party of troubled state, though they be received, are neither public nor privat ministers of the commonwealth; because none of their actions have th commonwealth for author. Likewise, an ambassador sent from a prince t congratulate, condole, or to assist at a solemnity; though th authority be public, yet because the business is private, and belongin to him in his natural capacity, is a private person. Also if a man b sent into another country secretly to explore their counsels an strength, though both the authority and the business be public, ye because there is none to take notice of any person in him but his own he is but a private minister; but yet a minister of the commonwealth and may be compared to an eye in the body natural. And those that ar appointed to receive the petitions or other informations of the people and are as it were the public ear, are public ministers, and represen their sovereign in that office."} +{"text":"Neither a councillor, nor a council of state, if we consider it with n authority of judicature or command, but only of giving advice to th sovereign when it is required, or of offering it when it is no required, is a public person. For the advice is addressed to th sovereign only, whose person cannot in his own presence be represente to him by another. But a body of councillors are never without som other authority, either of judicature, or of immediate administration as in a monarchy, they represent the monarch in delivering his command to the public ministers: in a democracy, the council or senat propounds the result of their deliberations to the people, as council; but when they appoint judges, or hear causes, or give audienc to ambassadors, it is in the quality of a minister of the people: an in an aristocracy, the council of state is the sovereign assembl itself; and gives counsel to none but themselves."} +{"text":"XIV"} +{"text":"Of the Nutrition and Procreation of a Commonwealth"} +{"text":"The \"nutrition\" of a commonwealth consisteth in the \"plenty\" an \"distribution\" of \"materials\" conducing to life; in \"concoction,\" o \"preparation\"; and, when concocted, in the \"conveyance\" of it, b convenient conduits, to the public use."} +{"text":"As for the plenty of matter, it is a thing limited by Nature to thos commodities which from the two breasts of our common mother, land an sea, God usually either freely giveth, or for labour selleth t mankind."} +{"text":"For the matter of this nutriment, consisting in animals, vegetals, an minerals, God hath freely laid them before us, in or near to the fac of the earth; so as there needeth no more but the labour and industr of receiving them. Insomuch as plenty dependeth, next to God's favour merely on the labour and industry of men."} +{"text":"This matter, commonly called commodities, is partly \"native,\" an partly \"foreign\"; \"native,\" that which is to be had within th territory of the commonwealth; \"foreign,\" that which is imported fro without. And because there is no territory under the dominion of on commonwealth, except it be of very vast extent, that produceth al things needful for the maintenance and motion of the whole body; an few that produce not something more than necessary; the superfluou commodities to be had within, become no more superfluous, but suppl these wants at home, by importation of that which may be had abroad either by exchange, or by just war, or by labour. For a man's labou also is a commodity exchangeable for benefit, as well as any othe thing; and there have been commonwealths that having no more territor than hath served them for habitation, have nevertheless not onl maintained, but also increased their power, partly by the labour o trading from one place to another, and partly by selling th manufactures whereof the materials were brought in from other places."} +{"text":"The distribution of the materials of this nourishment, is th constitution of \"mine,\" and \"thine,\" and \"his\"; that is to say, in on word \"propriety\"; and belongeth in all kinds of commonwealth to th sovereign power. For where there is no commonwealth there is, as hat been already shown, a perpetual war of every man against his neighbour and therefore everything is his that getteth it, and keepeth it b force; which is neither \"propriety\" nor \"community\"; but \"uncertainty.\ Which is so evident, that even Cicero, a passionate defender o liberty, in a public pleading, attributeth all propriety to the la civil. \"Let the civil law,\" saith he, \"be once abandoned, or bu negligently guarded, not to say oppressed, and there is nothing, tha any man can be sure to receive from his ancestor, or leave to hi children.\" And again, \"Take away the civil law, and no man knows wha is his own, and what another man's.\" Seeing therefore the introductio of \"propriety\" is an effect of commonwealth, which can do nothing bu by the person that represents it, it is the act only of the sovereign and consisteth in the laws, which none can make that have not th sovereign power. And this they well knew of old, who called tha No'�o*s, that is to say, \"distribution,\" which we call law; and define justice, by \"distributing\" to every man \"his own.\""} +{"text":"In this distribution, the first law is for division of the land itself wherein the sovereign assigneth to every man a portion, according a he, and not according as any subject, or any number of them, shal judge agreeable to equity, and the common good. The children of Israe were a commonwealth in the wilderness; but wanted the commodities o the earth, till they were masters of the Land of Promise; whic afterwards was divided amongst them, not by their own discretion, bu by the discretion of Eleazar the Priest and Joshua their General, who when there were twelve tribes, making them thirteen by subdivision o the tribe of Joseph, made nevertheless but twelve portions of the land and ordained for the tribe of Levi no land; but assigned them the tent part of the whole fruits; which division was therefore arbitrary. An though a people coming into possession of a land by war, do not alway exterminate the ancient inhabitants, as did the Jews, but leave t many, or most, or all of them their estates; yet it is manifest the hold them afterwards, as of the victors' distribution; as the people o England held all theirs of William the Conqueror."} +{"text":"From whence we may collect, that the propriety which a subject hath i his lands, consisteth in a right to exclude all other subjects from th use of them; and not to exclude their sovereign, be it an assembly or monarch. For seeing the sovereign, that is to say, the commonwealth whose person he representeth, is understood to do nothing but in orde to the common peace and security, this distribution of lands is to b understood as done in order to the same: and consequently, whatsoeve distribution he shall make in prejudice thereof, is contrary to th will of every subject that committed his peace and safety to hi discretion and conscience; and therefore by the will of every one o them, is to be reputed void. It is true that a sovereign monarch, o the greater part of a sovereign assembly, may ordain the doing of man things in pursuit of their passions, contrary to their own consciences which is a breach of trust and of the law of Nature; but this is no enough to authorize any subject, either to make war upon, or so much a to accuse of injustice, or any way to speak evil of their sovereign because they have authorized all his actions, and in bestowing th sovereign power, made them their own. But in what cases the commands o sovereigns are contrary to equity and the law of Nature, is to b considered hereafter in another place."} +{"text":"In the distribution of land, the commonwealth itself, may be conceive to have a portion, and possess and improve the same by thei representative; and that such portion may be made sufficient to sustai the whole expense to the common peace and defence necessarily required Which were very true, if there could be any representative conceive free from human passions and infirmities. But the nature of men bein as it is, the setting forth of public land, or of any certain revenu for the commonwealth, is in vain; and tendeth to the dissolution o government, and to the condition of mere nature and war, as soon a ever the sovereign power falleth into the hands of a monarch, or of a assembly, that are either too negligent of money, or too hazardous i engaging the public stock into a long or costly war. Commonwealths ca endure no diet: for seeing their expense is not limited by their ow appetite, but by external accidents and the appetites of thei neighbours, the public riches cannot be limited by other limits tha those which the emergent occasions shall require. And whereas i England, there were by the Conqueror divers lands reserved to his ow use, besides forests and chases, either for his recreation, o preservation of woods, and divers services reserved on the land he gav his subjects; yet it seems they were not reserved for his maintenanc in his public, but in his natural capacity. For he and his successor did for all that lay arbitrary taxes on all subjects' land, when the judged it necessary. Or if those public lands and services wer ordained as a sufficient maintenance of the commonwealth, it wa contrary to the scope of the institution; being, as it appeared b those ensuing taxes, insufficient, and, as it appears by the late smal revenue of the crown, subject to alienation and diminution. It i therefore in vain to assign a portion to the commonwealth; which ma sell, or give it away; and does sell and give it away, when it is don by their representative."} +{"text":"As the distribution of lands at home; so also to assign in what places and for what commodities, the subject shall traffic abroad, belonget to the sovereign. For if it did belong to private persons to use thei own discretion therein, some of them would be drawn for gain, both t furnish the enemy with means to hurt the commonwealth and hurt i themselves, by importing such things, as pleasing men's appetites, b nevertheless noxious, or at least unprofitable to them. And therefor it belongeth to the commonwealth, that is, to the sovereign only, t approve or disapprove both of the places and matter of foreign traffic."} +{"text":"Further, seeing it is not enough to the sustentation of a commonwealth that every man have a propriety in a portion of land, or in some fe commodities, or a natural property in some useful art, and there is n art in the world, but is necessary either for the being or well-bein almost of every particular man; it is necessary that men distribut that which they can spare, and transfer their propriety therein mutually one to another by exchange and mutual contract. And therefor it belongeth to the commonwealth, that is to say, to the sovereign, t appoint in what manner all kinds of contract between subjects, a buying, selling, exchanging, borrowing, lending, letting and taking t hire, are to be made; and by what words and signs they shall b understood for valid. And for the matter and distribution of th nourishment, to the several members of the commonwealth, thus much considering the model of the whole work, is sufficient."} +{"text":"By concoction I understand the reducing of all commodities which ar not presently consumed, but reserved for nourishment in time to come to something of equal value, and withal so portable as not to hinde the motion of men from place to place; to the end a man may have i what place soever such nourishment as the place affordeth. And this i nothing else but gold, and silver, and money. For gold and silver being, as it happens, almost in all countries of the world highl valued, is a commodious measure of the value of all things else betwee nations; and money, of what matter soever coined by the sovereign of commonwealth, is a sufficient measure of the value of all things els between the subjects of that commonwealth. By the means of whic measures all commodities, movable and immovable, are made to accompan a man to all places of his resort, within and without the place of hi ordinary residence; and the same passeth from man to man within th commonwealth; and goes round about, nourishing as it passeth every par thereof; insomuch as this concoction is as it were the sanguificatio of the commonwealth; for natural blood is in like manner made of th fruits of the earth, and circulating, nourisheth by the way ever member of the body of man."} +{"text":"And because silver and gold have their value from the matter itself they have first this privilege, that the value of them cannot b altered by the power of one, nor of a few commonwealths, as being common measure of the commodities of all places. But base money ma easily be enhanced or abased. Secondly, they have the privilege to mak commonwealths move, and stretch out their arms, when need is, int foreign countries, and supply, not only private subjects that travel but also whole armies with provision. But that coin, which is no considerable for the matter, but for the stamp of the place, bein unable to endure change of air, hath its effect at home only; wher also it is subject to the change of laws, and thereby to have the valu diminished, to the prejudice many times of those that have it."} +{"text":"The conduits and ways by which it is conveyed to the public use, are o two sorts: one, that conveyeth it to the public coffers; the other that issueth the same out again for public payments. Of the first sort are collectors, receivers, and treasurers; of the second are th treasurers again, and the officers appointed for payment of severa public or private ministers. And in this also, the artificial ma maintains his resemblance with the natural; whose veins receiving th blood from the several parts of the body, carry it to the heart, wher being made vital, the heart by the arteries sends it out again, t enliven, and enable for motion all the members of the same."} +{"text":"The procreation or children of a commonwealth are those we cal \"plantations,\" or \"colonies,\" which are numbers of men sent out fro the commonwealth, under a conductor or governor, to inhabit a foreig country, either formerly void of inhabitants, or made void then by war And when a colony is settled, they are either a commonwealth o themselves, discharged of their subjection to their sovereign that sen them, as hath been done by many commonwealths of ancient time, in whic case the commonwealth from which they went was called their metropoli or mother, and requires no more of them, than fathers require of th children whom they emancipate and make free from their domesti government, which is honour and friendship; or else they remain unite to their metropolis, as were the colonies of the people of Rome; an then they are no commonwealths themselves, but provinces, and parts o the commonwealth that sent them. So that the right of colonies, savin honour and league with their metropolis, dependeth wholly on thei license or letters, by which their sovereign authorized them to plant."} +{"text":"XV"} +{"text":"Of Counsel"} +{"text":"How fallacious it is to judge of the nature of things by the ordinar and inconstant use of words, appeareth in nothing more than in th confusion of counsels and commands, arising from the imperative manne of speaking in them both, and in many other occasions besides. For th words \"do this,\" are the words not only of him that commandeth, bu also of him that giveth counsel, and of him that exhorteth; and ye there are but few that see not that these are very different things, o that cannot distinguish between them when they perceive who it is tha speaketh, and to whom the speech is directed, and upon what occasion But finding those phrases in men's writings, and being not able or no willing to enter into a consideration of the circumstances, the mistake sometimes the precepts of counsellors for the precepts of the that command; and sometimes the contrary, according as it best agreet with the conclusions they would infer, or the actions they approve. T avoid which mistakes, and render to those terms of commanding counselling, and exhorting their proper and distinct significations, define them thus."} +{"text":"\"Command\" is, where a man saith \"do this,\" or \"do not this,\" withou expecting other reason than the will of him that says it. From this i followeth manifestly, that he that commandeth, pretendeth thereby hi own benefit: for the reason of his command is his own will only, an the proper object of every man's will, is some good to himself."} +{"text":"\"Counsel,\" is where a man saith, \"do,\" or \"do not this,\" and deducet his reasons from the benefit that arriveth by it to him to whom h saith it. And from this it is evident, that he that giveth counsel pretendeth only, whatsoever he intendeth, the good of him to whom h giveth it."} +{"text":"Therefore between counsel and command, one great difference is, tha command is directed to a man's own benefit; and counsel to the benefi of another man. And from this ariseth another difference, that a ma may be obliged to do what he is commanded; as when he hath covenante to obey: but he cannot be obliged to do as he is counselled, becaus the hurt of not following it, is his own; or if he should covenant t follow it, then is the counsel turned into the nature of a command. third difference between them is, that no man can pretend a right to b of another man's counsel; because he is not to pretend benefit by it t himself: but to demand right to counsel another, argues a will to kno his designs, or to gain some other good to himself: which, as I sai before, is of every man's will the proper object."} +{"text":"This also is incident to the nature of counsel; that whatsoever it be he that asketh it, cannot in equity accuse or punish it: for to as counsel of another, is to permit him to give such counsel as he shal think best; and consequently, he that giveth counsel to his sovereign whether a monarch, or an assembly, when he asketh it, cannot in equit be punished for it, whether the same be conformable to the opinion o the most, or not, so it be to the proposition in debate. For if th sense of the assembly can be taken notice of, before the debate b ended, they should neither ask nor take any further counsel; for th sense of the assembly is the resolution of the debate, and end of al deliberation. And generally he that demandeth counsel, is author of it and therefore cannot punish it; and what the sovereign cannot, no ma else can. But if one subject giveth counsel to another, to do anythin contrary to the laws, whether that counsel proceed from evil intention or from ignorance only, it is punishable by the commonwealth; becaus ignorance of the law is no good excuse, where every man is bound t take notice of the laws to which he is subject."} +{"text":"\"Exhortation\" and \"dehortation\" is counsel, accompanied with signs i him that giveth it, of vehement desire to have it followed: or to sa it more briefly, \"counsel vehemently pressed.\" For he that exhorteth doth not deduce the consequences of what he adviseth to be done, an tie himself therein to the rigour of true reasoning; but encourages hi he counselleth to action: as he that dehorteth, deterreth him from it And therefore they have in their speeches, a regard to the commo passions and opinions of men, in deducing their reasons; and make us of similitudes, metaphors, examples, and other tools of oratory, t persuade their hearers of the utility, honour, or justice of followin their advice."} +{"text":"From whence may be inferred, first, that exhortation and dehortation i directed to the good of him that giveth the counsel, not of him tha asketh it, which is contrary to the duty of a counsellor; who, by th definition of counsel, ought to regard not his own benefit, but hi whom he adviseth. And that he directeth his counsel to his own benefit is manifest enough, by the long and vehement urging, or by th artificial giving thereof; which being not required of him, an consequently proceeding from his own occasions, is directed principall to his own benefit, and but accidentally to the good of him that i counselled, or not at all."} +{"text":"Secondly, that the use of exhortation and dehortation lieth only wher a man is to speak to a multitude; because when the speech is addresse to one, he may interrupt him, and examine his reasons more rigorousl than can be done in a multitude; which are too many to enter int dispute and dialogue with him that speaketh indifferently to them al at once."} +{"text":"Thirdly, that they that exhort and dehort, where they are required t give counsel, are corrupt counsellors, and as it were bribed by thei own interest. For though the counsel they give be never so good; yet h that gives it, is no more a good counsellor than he that giveth a jus sentence for a reward is a just judge. But where a man may lawfull command, as a father in his family, or a leader in an army, hi exhortations and dehortations are not only lawful, but also necessar and laudable. But then they are no more counsels but commands; whic when they are for execution of sour labour, sometimes necessity an always humanity requireth to be sweetened in the delivery b encouragement, and in the tune and phrase of counsel, rather than i harsher language of command."} +{"text":"Examples of the difference between command and counsel we may take fro the forms of speech that express them in Holy Scripture. \"Have no othe gods but me\"; \"make to thyself no graven image\"; \"take not God's nam in vain\"; \"sanctify the Sabbath\"; \"honour thy parents\"; \"kill not\" \"steal not,\" etc., are commands; because the reason for which we are t obey them is drawn from the will of God our king, whom we are oblige to obey. But these words, \"Sell all thou hast; give it to the poor; an follow me,\" are counsel; because the reason for which we are to do so is drawn from our own benefit; which is this, that we shall hav \"treasure in heaven.\" These words, \"Go into the village over agains you, and you shall find an ass tied, and her colt; loose her, and brin her to me,\" are a command; for the reason of their fact is drawn fro the will of their Master: but these words, \"Repent and be baptized i the name of Jesus,\" are counsel; because the reason why we should s do, tendeth not to any benefit of God Almighty, who shall still be kin in what manner soever we rebel; but of ourselves, who have no othe means of avoiding the punishment hanging over us for our sins."} +{"text":"As the difference of counsel from command hath been now deduced fro the nature of counsel, consisting in a deducing of the benefit, or hur that may arise to him that is to be counselled, by the necessary o probable consequences of the action he propoundeth: so may also th differences between \"apt\" and \"inept\" counsellors be derived from th same. For experience, being but memory of the consequences of lik actions formerly observed, and counsel but the speech whereby tha experience is made known to another; the virtues and defects of counse are the same with the virtues and defects intellectual: and to th person of a commonwealth, his counsellors serve him in the place o memory and mental discourse. But with this resemblance of th commonwealth to a natural man, there is one dissimilitude joined o great importance; which is, that a natural man receiveth his experienc from the natural objects of sense, which work upon him without passio or interest of their own; whereas they that give counsel to th representative person of a commonwealth may have, and have often thei particular ends and passions, that render their counsels alway suspected, and many times unfaithful. And therefore we may set down fo the first condition of a good counsellor, \"that his ends and interest be not inconsistent with the ends and interests of him he counselleth.\""} +{"text":"Secondly, because the office of a counsellor, when an action comes int deliberation, is to make manifest the consequences of it, in suc manner as he that is counselled may be truly and evidently informed; h ought to propound his advice in such form of speech as may make th truth most evidently appear; that is to say, with as fir ratiocination, as significant and proper language, and as briefly a the evidence will permit. And therefore \"rash and uneviden inferences,\" such as are fetched only from examples or authority o books, and are not arguments of what is good or evil, but witnesses o fact or of opinion; \"obscure, confused, and ambiguous expressions, als all metaphorical speeches, tending to the stirring up of passions,\ (because such reasoning and such expressions are useful only t deceive, or to lead him we counsel towards other ends than his own, \"are repugnant to the office of a counsellor.\""} +{"text":"Thirdly, because the ability of counselling proceedeth from experienc and long study; and no man is presumed to have experience in all thos things that to the administration of a great commonwealth are necessar to be known, \"no man is presumed to be a good counsellor, but in suc business as he hath not only been much versed in, but hath also muc meditated on, and considered.\" For seeing the business of commonwealth is this, to preserve the people in peace at home, an defend them against foreign invasion, we shall find it requires grea knowledge of the disposition of mankind, of the rights of government and of the nature of equity, law, justice, and honour, not to b attained without study; and of the strength, commodities, places, bot of their own country, and their neighbours; as also of the inclination and designs of all nations that may any way annoy them. And this is no attained to without much experience. Of which things, not only th whole sum, but every one of the particulars requires the age an observation of a man in years, and of more than ordinary study. The wi required for counsel, as I have said before (chap. VIII), is judgment And the differences of men in that point come from different education of some to one kind of study or business, and of others to another When for the doing of anything there be infallible rules, as in engine and edifices, the rules of geometry, all the experience of the worl cannot equal his counsel that has learnt or found out the rule. An when there is no such rule, he that hath most experience in tha particular kind of business has therein the best judgment, and is th best counsellor."} +{"text":"Fourthly, to be able to give counsel to a commonwealth, in a busines that hath reference to another commonwealth, \"it is necessary to b acquainted with the intelligences, and letters\" that come from thence \"and with all the records of treaties, and other transactions of state\ between them; which none can do, but such as the representative shal think fit. By which we may see, that they who are not called t counsel, can have no good counsel in such cases to obtrude."} +{"text":"Fifthly, supposing the number of counsellors equal, a man is bette counselled by hearing them apart than in an assembly; and that for man causes. First, in hearing them apart you have the advice of every man but in an assembly many of them deliver their advice with \"aye,\" o \"no,\" or with their hands or feet, not moved by their own sense, but b the eloquence of another, or for fear of displeasing some that hav spoken, or the whole assembly, by contradiction; or for fear o appearing duller in apprehension than those that have applauded th contrary opinion. Secondly, in an assembly of many, there cannot choos but be some whose interests are contrary to that of the public; an these their interests make passionate, and passion eloquent, an eloquence draws others into the same advice. For the passions of men which asunder are moderate, as the heat of one brand; in an assembl are like many brands, that inflame one another, especially when the blow one another with orations, to the setting of the commonwealth o fire, under pretence of counselling it. Thirdly, in hearing every ma apart, one may examine, when there is need, the truth or probability o his reasons, and of the grounds of the advice he gives, by frequen interruptions and objections; which cannot be done in an assembly where in every difficult question a man is rather astonied and dazzle with the variety of discourse upon it, than informed of the course h ought to take. Besides, there cannot be an assembly of many calle together for advice, wherein there be not some that have the ambitio to be thought eloquent, and also learned in the politics; and give no their advice with care of the business propounded, but of the applaus of their motley orations, made of the divers coloured threads or shred of authors; which is an impertinence at least, that takes away the tim of serious consultation, and in the secret way of counselling apart, i easily avoided. Fourthly, in deliberations that ought to be kep secret, whereof there be many occasions in public business, th counsels of many, and especially in assemblies, are dangerous; an therefore great assemblies are necessitated to commit such affairs t lesser numbers, and of such persons as are most versed, and in whos fidelity they have most confidence."} +{"text":"To conclude, who is there that so far approves the taking of counse from a great assembly of counsellors, that wisheth for, or would accep of their pains, when there is a question of marrying his children disposing of his lands, governing his household, or managing hi private estate, especially if there be amongst them such as wish no his prosperity? A man that doth his business by the help of many an prudent counsellors, with everyone consulting apart in his prope element, does it best, as he that useth able seconds at tennis-play placed in their proper stations. He does next best that useth his ow judgment only, as he that has no second at all. But he that is carrie up and down to his business in a framed counsel, which cannot move bu by the plurality of consenting opinions, the execution whereof i commonly, out of envy or interest, retarded by the part dissenting does it worst of all, and like one that is carried to the ball, thoug by good players, yet in a wheelbarrow or other frame, heavy of itself and retarded also by the inconcurrent judgments and endeavours of the that drive it; and so much the more, as they be more that set thei hands to it; and most of all, when there is one, or more amongst them that desire to have him lose. And though it be true that many eyes se more than one; yet it is not to be understood of many counsellors, bu then only when the final resolution is in one man. Otherwise, becaus many eyes see the same thing in divers lines, and are apt to loo asquint towards their private benefit; they that desire not to mis their mark, though they look about with two eyes, yet they never ai but with one; and therefore no great popular commonwealth was ever kep up but either by a foreign enemy that united them, or by the reputatio of some eminent man amongst them, or by the secret counsel of a few, o by the mutual fear of equal factions, and not by the open consultation of the assembly. And as for very little commonwealths, be they popula or monarchical, there is no human wisdom can uphold them longer tha the jealousy lasteth of their potent neighbours."} +{"text":"XVI"} +{"text":"Of Civil Laws"} +{"text":"By \"civil laws,\" I understand the laws that men are therefore bound t observe, because they are members, not of this or that commonwealth i particular, but of a commonwealth. For the knowledge of particular law belongeth to them that profess the study of the laws of their severa countries; but the knowledge of civil law in general to any man. Th ancient law of Rome was called their \"civil law,\" from the wor civitas, which signifies a commonwealth: and those countries whic having been under the Roman empire, and governed by that law, retai still such part thereof as they think fit, call that part the civi law, to distinguish it from the rest of their own civil laws. But tha is not it I intend to speak of here; my design being not to show wha is law here and there; but what is law; as Plato, Aristotle, Cicero and divers others have done, without taking upon them the profession o the study of the law."} +{"text":"And first it is manifest, that law in general is not counsel, bu command; nor a command of any man to any man; but only of him, whos command is addressed to one formerly obliged to obey him. And as fo civil law, it addeth only the name of the person commanding, which i persona civitatis, the person of the commonwealth."} +{"text":"Which considered, I define civil law in this manner. \" `Civil law,' i to every subject, those rules, which the commonwealth hath commande him, by word, writing, or other sufficient sign of the will, to mak use of, for the distinction of right and wrong; that is to say, of wha is contrary and what is not contrary to the rule.\""} +{"text":"In which definition, there is nothing that is not at first sigh evident. For every man seeth, that some laws are addressed to all th subjects in general; some to particular provinces; some to particula vocations; and some to particular men; and are therefore laws to ever of those to whom the command is directed, and to none else. As also that laws are the rules of just and unjust; nothing being repute unjust that is not contrary to some law. Likewise, that none can mak laws but the commonwealth; because our subjection is to th commonwealth only: and that commands are to be signified by sufficien signs; because a man knows not otherwise how to obey them. An therefore, whatsoever can from this definition by necessary consequenc be deduced, ought to be acknowledged for truth. Now I deduce from i this that followeth."} +{"text":"1. The legislator in all commonwealths, is only the sovereign, be h one man, as in a monarchy, or one assembly of men, as in a democracy or aristocracy. For the legislator is he that maketh the law. And th commonwealth only prescribes and commandeth the observation of thos rules, which we call law: therefore the commonwealth is the legislator But the commonwealth is no person, nor has capacity to do anything, bu by the representative, that is, the sovereign; and therefore th sovereign is the sole legislator. For the same reason, none ca abrogate a law made, but the sovereign; because a law is not abrogated but by another law, that forbiddeth it to be put in execution."} +{"text":"2. The sovereign of a commonwealth, be it an assembly or one man, i not subject to the civil laws. For having power to make and repea laws, he may when he pleaseth free himself from that subjection, b repealing those laws that trouble him and making of new; an consequently he was free before. For he is free, that can be free whe he will: nor is it possible for any person to be bound to himself because he that can bind, can release; and therefore he that is boun to himself only, is not bound."} +{"text":"3. When long use obtaineth the authority of a law, it is not the lengt of time that maketh the authority, but the will of the sovereig signified by his silence, for silence is sometimes an argument o consent; and it is no longer law, than the sovereign shall be silen therein. And therefore if the sovereign shall have a question of righ grounded, not upon his present will, but upon the laws formerly made the length of time shall bring no prejudice to his right; but th question shall be judged by equity. For many unjust actions and unjus sentences go uncontrolled a longer time than any man can remember. An our lawyers account no customs law but such as are reasonable, and tha evil customs are to be abolished. But the judgment of what i reasonable and of what is to be abolished belongeth to him that maket the law, which is the sovereign assembly or monarch."} +{"text":"4. The law of Nature and the civil law, contain each other, and are o equal extent. For the laws of Nature, which consist in equity, justice gratitude, and other moral virtues on these depending, in the conditio of mere nature, as I have said before in the end of the fifteent chapter, are not properly laws, but qualities that dispose men to peac and obedience. When a commonwealth is once settled, then are the actually laws, and not before; as being then the commands of th commonwealth; and therefore also civil laws: for it is the sovereig power that obliges men to obey them. For in the differences of privat men, to declare what is equity, what is justice, and what is mora virtue, and to make them binding, there is need of the ordinances o sovereign power, and punishments to be ordained for such as shall brea them; which ordinances are therefore part of the civil law. The law o Nature therefore is a part of the civil law in all commonwealths of th world. Reciprocally also, the civil law is a part of the dictates o Nature. For justice, that is to say, performance of covenant, an giving to every man his own, is a dictate of the law of Nature. Bu every subject in a commonwealth hath covenanted to obey the civil law either one with another, as when they assemble to make a commo representative, or with the representative itself one by one, whe subdued by the sword they promise obedience, that they may receiv life; and therefore obedience to the civil law is part also of the la of Nature. Civil and natural law are not different kinds, but differen parts of law; whereof one part being written, is called civil, th other unwritten, natural. But the right of nature, that is, the natura liberty of man, may by the civil law be abridged and restrained: nay the end of making laws is no other but such restraint; without th which there cannot possibly be any peace. And law was brought into th world for nothing else but to limit the natural liberty of particula men, in such manner as they might not hurt, but assist one another, an join together against a common enemy."} +{"text":"5. If the sovereign of one commonwealth subdue a people that have live under other written laws, and afterwards govern them by the same law by which they were governed before; yet those laws are the civil law of the victor, and not of the vanquished commonwealth. For th legislator is he, not by whose authority the laws were first made, bu by whose authority they now continue to be laws. And therefore wher there be divers provinces within the dominion of a commonwealth, and i those provinces diversity of laws, which commonly are called th customs of each several province, we are not to understand that suc customs have their force only from length of time; but that they wer anciently laws written, or otherwise made known, for the constitution and statutes of their sovereigns; and are now laws, not by virtue o the prescription of time, but by the constitutions of their presen sovereigns. But if an unwritten law, in all the provinces of dominion, shall be generally observed, and no iniquity appear in th use thereof; that law can be no other but a law of Nature, equall obliging all mankind."} +{"text":"6. Seeing then all laws, written and unwritten, have their authorit and force from the will of the commonwealth, that is to say, from th will of the representative, which in a monarchy is the monarch, and i other commonwealths the sovereign assembly; a man may wonder fro whence proceed such opinions as are found in the books of lawyers o eminence in several commonwealths, directly or by consequence makin the legislative power depend on private men, or subordinate judges. A for example, \"that the common law hath no controller but th parliament\"; which is true only where a parliament has the sovereig power, and cannot be assembled nor dissolved but by their ow discretion. For if there be a right in any else to dissolve them, ther is a right also to control them, and consequently to control thei controllings. And if there be no such right, then the controller o laws is not parliamentum, but rex in parliamento. And where parliament is sovereign, if it should assemble never so many or so wis men from the countries subject to them, for whatsoever cause; yet ther is no man will believe that such an assembly hath thereby acquired t themselves a legislative power. \"Item\" that the two arms of commonwealth, are \"force and justice; the first whereof is in the king the other deposited in the hands of the parliament.\" As if commonwealth could consist, where the force were in any hand, whic justice had not the authority to command and govern."} +{"text":"7. That law can never be against reason our lawyers are agreed; an that not the letter that is every construction of it, but that which i according to the intention of the legislator, is the law. And it i true, but the doubt is of whose reason it is that shall be received fo law. It is not meant of any private reason, for then there would be a much contradiction in the laws as there is in the schools; nor yet, a Sir Edward Coke makes it, an \"artificial perfection of reason, gotte by long study, observation, and experience,\" as his was. For it i possible long study may increase and confirm erroneous sentences, an where men build on false grounds, the more they build the greater i the ruin: and of those that study and observe with equal time an diligence, the reasons and resolutions are, and must remain discordant, and therefore it is not that juris prudentia or wisdom o subordinate judges; but the reason of this our artificial man th commonwealth, and his command that maketh law: and the commonwealt being in their representative but one person, there cannot easily aris any contradiction in the laws; and when there doth, the same reason i able, by interpretation or alteration, to take it away. In all court of justice, the sovereign, which is the person of the commonwealth, i he that judgeth; the subordinate judge ought to have regard to th reason which moved his sovereign to make such law that his sentence ma be according thereunto, which then is his sovereign's sentence otherwise it is his own, and an unjust one."} +{"text":"8. From this that the law is a command, and a command consisteth i declaration or manifestation of the will of him that commandeth, b voice, writing, or some other sufficient argument of the same, we ma understand that the command of the commonwealth is law only to thos that have means to take notice of it. Over natural fools, children, o madmen, there is no law, no more than over brute beasts, nor are the capable of the title of just or unjust; because they had never power t make any covenant, or to understand the consequences thereof, an consequently never took upon them to authorize the actions of an sovereign, as they must do that make to themselves a commonwealth. An as those from whom nature or accident hath taken away the notice of al laws in general; so also every man from whom any accident, no proceeding from his own default, hath taken away the means to tak notice of any particular law, is excused if he observe it not, and, t speak properly, that law is no law to him. It is therefore necessary t consider in this place what arguments and signs be sufficient for th knowledge of what is the law, that is to say, what is the will of th sovereign as well in monarchies as in other forms of government."} +{"text":"And first, if it be a law that obliges all the subjects withou exception, and is not written, nor otherwise published in such place as they may take notice thereof, it is a law of Nature. For whatsoeve men are to take knowledge of for law, not upon other men's words, bu everyone from his own reason, must be such as is agreeable to th reason of all men; which no law can be, but the law of Nature. The law of Nature therefore need not any publishing, nor proclamation; as bein contained in this one sentence, approved by all the world, \"Do not tha to another, which thou thinkest unreasonable to be done by another t thyself.\""} +{"text":"Secondly, if it be a law that obliges only some condition of men, o one particular man, and be not written, nor published by word, the also it is a law of Nature; and known by the same arguments and sign that distinguish those in such a condition from other subjects. Fo whatsoever law is not written, or some way published by him that make it law, can be known no way, but by the reason of him that is to obe it; and is therefore also a law not only civil, but natural. Fo example, if the sovereign employ a public minister, without writte instructions what to do; he is obliged to take for instructions th dictates of reason; as if he make a judge, the judge is to take notic that his sentence ought to be according to the reason of his sovereign which being always understood to be equity, he is bound to it by th law of Nature: or if an ambassador, he is, in all things not containe in his written instructions, to take for instruction that which reaso dictates to be most conducing to his sovereign's interest; and so o all other ministers of the sovereignty, public and private. All whic instructions of natural reason may be comprehended under one name o \"fidelity\"; which is a branch of natural justice."} +{"text":"The law of Nature excepted, it belongeth to the essence of all othe laws, to be made known, to every man that shall be obliged to obe them, either by word, or writing, or some other act, known to procee from the sovereign authority. For the will of another cannot b understood, but by his own word, or act, or by conjecture taken fro his scope and purpose; which in the person of the commonwealth is to b supposed always consonant to equity and reason. And in ancient time before letters were in common use, the laws were many times put int verse; that the rude people taking pleasure in singing or recitin them, might the more easily retain them in memory. And for the sam reason Solomon (Prov. 7:3) adviseth a man to bind the ten commandment upon his ten fingers. And for the law which Moses gave to the people o Israel at the renewing of the covenant (Deut. 11:19), he biddeth the to teach it their children, by discoursing of it both at home and upo the way; at going to bed, and at rising from bed; and to write it upo the posts and doors of their houses; and (Deut. 31:12) to assemble th people, man, woman, and child, to hear it read."} +{"text":"Nor is it enough the law be written and published; but also that ther be manifest signs that it proceedeth from the will of the sovereign For private men, when they have, or think they have, force enough t secure their unjust designs, and convoy them safely to their ambitiou ends, may publish for laws what they please, without or against th legislative authority. There is therefore requisite, not only declaration of the law, but also sufficient signs of the author an authority. The author or legislator is supposed in every commonwealt to be evident, because he is the sovereign, who having been constitute by the consent of everyone, is supposed by everyone to be sufficientl known. And though the ignorance and security of men be such, for th most part, as that when the memory of the first constitution of thei commonwealth is worn out, they do not consider by whose power they use to be defended against their enemies, and to have their industr protected, and to be righted when injury is done them; yet because n man that considers, can make question of it, no excuse can be derive from the ignorance of where the sovereignty is placed. And it is dictate of natural reason, and consequently an evident law of Nature that no man ought to weaken that power, the protection whereof he hat himself demanded, or wittingly received against others. Therefore o who is sovereign, no man, but by his own fault (whatsoever evil me suggest), can make any doubt. The difficulty consisteth in the evidenc of the authority derived from him; the removing whereof dependeth o the knowledge of the public registers, public counsels, publi ministers, and public seals; by which all laws are sufficientl verified; verified, I say, not authorized: for the verification is bu the testimony and record, not the authority of the law; whic consisteth in the command of the sovereign only."} +{"text":"If therefore a man have a question of injury, depending on the law o Nature; that is to say, on common equity; the sentence of the judge that by commission hath authority to take cognizance of such causes, i a sufficient verification of the law of Nature in that individual case For though the advice of one that professeth the study of the law b useful for the avoiding of contention; yet it is but advice: it is th judge must tell men what is law, upon the hearing of the controversy."} +{"text":"But when the question is of injury, or crime, upon a written law; ever man by recourse to the registers, by himself or others, may, if h will, be sufficiently informed, before he do such injury, or commit th crime, whether it be an injury or not: nay, he ought to do so: for whe a man doubts whether the act he goeth about be just or unjust; and ma inform himself, if he will; the doing is unlawful. In like manner, h that supposeth himself injured, in a case determined by the writte law, which he may, by himself or others, see and consider; if h complain before he consults with the law, he does unjustly, an bewrayeth a disposition rather to vex other men than to demand his ow right."} +{"text":"If the question be of obedience to a public officer; to have seen hi commission, with the public seal, and heard it read; or to have had th means to be informed of it, if a man would, is a sufficien verification of his authority. For every man is obliged to do his bes endeavour to inform himself of all written laws, that may concern hi own future actions."} +{"text":"The legislator known; and the laws, either by writing or by the ligh of Nature, sufficiently published; there wanteth yet another ver material circumstance to make them obligatory. For it is not th letter, but the intendment or meaning, that is to say, the authenti interpretation of the law (which is the sense of the legislator), i which the nature of the law consisteth; and therefore th interpretation of all laws dependeth on the authority sovereign; an the interpreters can be none but those which the sovereign, to who only the subject oweth obedience, shall appoint. For else, by the craf of an interpreter, the law may be made to bear a sense contrary to tha of the sovereign, by which means the interpreter becomes th legislator."} +{"text":"All laws, written and unwritten, have need of interpretation. Th unwritten law of Nature, though it be easy to such as, withou partiality and passion, make use of their natural reason, and therefor leaves the violators thereof without excuse; yet considering there b very few, perhaps none, that in some cases are not blinded by self-lov or some other passion, it is now become of all laws the most obscure and has consequently the greatest need of able interpreters. Th written laws, if they be short, are easily misinterpreted, from th divers significations of a word or two: if long, they be more obscur by the divers significations of many words: insomuch as no written law delivered in few or many words, can be well understood, without perfect understanding of the final causes for which the law was made the knowledge of which final causes is in the legislator. To hi therefore there cannot be any knot in the law insoluble; either b finding out the ends, to undo it by; or else by making what ends h will, as Alexander did with his sword in the Gordian knot, by th legislative power, which no other interpreter can do."} +{"text":"The interpretation of the laws of Nature in a commonwealth dependet not on the books of moral philosophy. The authority of writers, withou the authority of the commonwealth, maketh not their opinions law, b they never so true. That which I have written in this treatis concerning the moral virtues, and of their necessity for the procurin and maintaining peace, though it be evident truth, is not therefor presently law; but because in all commonwealths in the world it is par of the civil law. For though it be naturally reasonable, yet it is b the sovereign power that it is law: otherwise, it were a great error t call the laws of Nature unwritten law; whereof we see so many volume published, and in them so many contradictions of one another and o themselves."} +{"text":"The interpretation of the law of Nature, is the sentence of the judg constituted by the sovereign authority, to hear and determine suc controversies as depend thereon; and consisteth in the application o the law to the present case. For in the act of judicature, the judg doth no more but consider whether the demand of the party be consonan to natural reason and equity; and the sentence he giveth is therefor the interpretation of the law of Nature; which interpretation i authentic; not because it is his private sentence; but because h giveth it by authority of the sovereign, whereby it becomes th sovereign's sentence, which is law for that time, to the partie pleading."} +{"text":"But because there is no judge subordinate, nor sovereign, but may er in a judgment of equity; if afterward in another like case he find i more consonant to equity to give a contrary sentence, he is obliged t do it. No man's error becomes his own law; nor obliges him to persis in it. Neither, for the same reason, becomes it a law to other judges though sworn to follow it. For though a wrong sentence given b authority of the sovereign, if he know and allow it, in such laws a are mutable, be a constitution of a new law, in cases in which ever little circumstance is the same; yet in laws immutable, such as are th laws of Nature, they are no laws to the same or other judges, in th like cases forever after. Princes succeed one another; and one judg passeth, another cometh; nay, heaven and earth shall pass; but not on tittle of the law of Nature shall pass; for it is the eternal law o God. Therefore all the sentences of precedent judges that have eve been, cannot altogether make a law contrary to natural equity: nor an examples of former judges, can warrant an unreasonable sentence, o discharge the present judge of the trouble of studying what is equity in the case he is to judge, from the principles of his own natura reason. For example sake, it is against the law of Nature \"to punis the innocent\"; and innocent is he that acquitteth himself judicially and is acknowledged for innocent by the judge. Put the case now, that man is accused of a capital crime, and seeing the power and malice o some enemy, and the frequent corruption and partiality of judges runneth away for fear of the event, and afterwards is taken, an brought to a legal trial, and maketh it sufficiently appear he was no guilty of the crime, and being thereof acquitted, is nevertheles condemned to lose his goods; this is a manifest condemnation of th innocent. I say therefore that there is no place in the world, wher this can be an interpretation of a law of Nature, or be made a law b the sentences of precedent judges, that had done the same. For he tha judged it first, judged unjustly; and no injustice can be a pattern o judgment to succeeding judges. A written law may forbid innocent men t fly, and they may be punished for flying: but that flying for fear o injury should be taken for presumption of guilt, after a man is alread absolved of the crime judicially, is contrary to the nature of presumption, which hath no place after judgment given. Yet this is se down by a great lawyer for the common law of England. \"If a man,\" sait he, \"that is innocent, be accused of felony, and for fear flyeth fo the same; albeit he judicially acquitteth himself of the felony; yet i it be found that he fled for the felony, he shall notwithstanding hi innocency, forfeit all his goods, chattels, debts, and duties. For a to the forfeiture of them, the law will admit no proof against th presumption in law, grounded upon his flight.\" Here you see \"a innocent man judicially acquitted, notwithstanding his innocency,\" whe no written law forbad him to fly, after his acquittal, \"upon presumption in law,\" condemned to lose all the goods he hath. If th law ground upon his flight a presumption of the fact, which wa capital, the sentence ought to have been capital: if the presumptio were not of the fact, for what then ought he to lose his goods? Thi therefore is no law of England; nor is the condemnation grounded upon presumption of law, but upon the presumption of the judges. It is als against law, to say that no proof shall be admitted against presumption of law. For all judges, sovereign and subordinate, if the refuse to hear proof, refuse to do justice: for though the sentence b just, yet the judges that condemn without hearing the proofs offered are unjust judges; and their presumption is but prejudice; which no ma ought to bring with him to the seat of justice, whatsoever preceden judgments or examples he shall pretend to follow. There be other thing of this nature, wherein men's judgments have been perverted, b trusting to precedents: but this is enough to show, that though th sentence of the judge be a law to the party pleading, yet it is no la to any judge that shall succeed him in that office."} +{"text":"In like manner, when question is of the meaning of written laws, he i not the interpreter of them, that writeth a commentary upon them. Fo commentaries are commonly more subject to cavil than the text; an therefore need other commentaries; and so there will be no end of suc interpretation. And therefore unless there be an interpreter authorize by the sovereign, from which the subordinate judges are not to recede the interpreter can be no other than the ordinary judges, in the sam manner as they are in cases of the unwritten law; and their sentence are to be taken by them that plead for laws in that particular case but not to bind other judges in like cases to give like judgments. Fo a judge may err in the interpretation even of written laws; but n error of a subordinate judge can change the law, which is the genera sentence of the sovereign."} +{"text":"In written laws, men use to make a difference between the letter an the sentence of the law: and when by the letter is meant whatsoever ca be gathered by the bare words, it is well distinguished. For th significations of almost all words are either in themselves, or in th metaphorical use of them, ambiguous; and may be drawn in argument, t make many senses; but there is only one sense of the law. But if by th letter be meant the literal sense, then the letter and the sentence o intention of the law, is all one. For the literal sense is that whic the legislator intended should by the letter of the law be signified Now the intention of the legislator is always supposed to be equity for it were a great contumely for a judge to think otherwise of th sovereign. He ought therefore, if the word of the law do not full authorize a reasonable sentence, to supply it with the law of Nature or if the case be difficult, to respite judgment till he have receive more ample authority. For example, a written law ordaineth that h which is thrust out of his house by force shall be restored by force it happens that a man by negligence leaves his house empty, an returning is kept out by force, in which case there is no special la ordained. It is evident that this case is contained in the same law for else there is no remedy for him at all; which is to be suppose against the intention of the legislator. Again, the word of the la commandeth to judge according to the evidence: a man is accused falsel of a fact, which the judge himself saw done by another, and not by hi that is accused. In this case neither shall the letter of the law b followed to the condemnation of the innocent, nor shall the judge giv sentence against the evidence of the witnesses; because the letter o the law is to the contrary; but procure of the sovereign that anothe be made judge, and himself witness. So that the incommodity tha follows the bare words of a written law may lead him to the intentio of the law, whereby to interpret the same the better; though n incommodity can warrant a sentence against the law. For every judge o right and wrong is not judge of what is commodious or incommodious t the commonwealth."} +{"text":"The abilities required in a good interpreter of the law, that is t say, in a good judge, are not the same with those of an advocate namely, the study of the laws. For a judge, as he ought to take notic of the fact from none but the witnesses; so also he ought to tak notice of the law from nothing but the statutes and constitutions o the sovereign, alleged in the pleading, or declared to him by some tha have authority from the sovereign power to declare them; and need no take care beforehand what he shall judge; for it shall be given hi what he shall say concerning the fact, by witnesses; and what he shal say in point of law, from those that shall in their pleadings show it and by authority interpret it upon the place. The Lords of parliamen in England were judges, and most difficult causes have been heard an determined by them; yet few of them were much versed in the study o the laws, and fewer had made profession of them; and though the consulted with lawyers, that were appointed to be present there fo that purpose, yet they alone had the authority of giving sentence. I like manner, in the ordinary trials of right, twelve men of the commo people are the judges, and give sentence, not only of the fact, but o the right; and pronounce simply for the complainant, or for th defendant; that is to say, are judges, not only of the fact, but als of the right: and in a question of crime, not only determine whethe done, or not done; but also whether it be \"murder,\" \"homicide,\ \"felony,\" \"assault,\" and the like, which are determinations of law: bu because they are not supposed to know the law of themselves, there i one that hath authority to inform them of it, in the particular cas they are to judge of. But yet if they judge not according to that h tells them, they are not subject thereby to any penalty; unless it b made appear that they did it against their consciences, or had bee corrupted by reward."} +{"text":"The things that make a good judge or good interpreter of the laws are first, \"a right understanding\" of that principal law of Nature calle \"equity,\" which depending not on the reading of other men's writings but on the goodness of a man's own natural reason and meditation, i presumed to be in those most that have had most leisure, and had th most inclination to meditate thereon. Secondly, \"contempt o unnecessary riches and preferments.\" Thirdly, \"to be able in judgmen to divest himself of all fear, anger, hatred, love, and compassion.\ Fourthly, and lastly, \"patience to hear, diligent attention in hearing and memory to retain, digest and apply what he hath heard.\""} +{"text":"The difference and division of the laws has been made in diver manners, according to the different methods of those men that hav written of them. For it is a thing that dependeth not on nature, but o the scope of the writer, and is subservient to every man's prope method. In the Institutions of Justinian, we find seven sorts of civi laws."} +{"text":"1. The \"edicts,\" \"constitutions,\" and \"epistles of the prince,\" tha is, of the emperor, because the whole power of the people was in him Like these are the proclamations of the kings of England."} +{"text":"2. \"The decrees of the whole people of Rome,\" comprehending the senate when they were put to the question by the \"senate.\" These were laws a first by the virtue of the sovereign power residing in the people; an such of them as by the emperors were not abrogated, remained laws b the authority imperial. For all laws that bind are understood to b laws by his authority that has power to repeal them. Somewhat like t these laws are the acts of parliament in England."} +{"text":"3. \"The decrees of the common people,\" excluding the senate, when the were put to the question by the \"tribune\" of the people. For such o them as were not abrogated by the emperors remained laws by th authority imperial. Like to these were the orders of the House o Commons in England."} +{"text":"4. Senatus consulta, the \"orders of the senate\"; because when th people of Rome grew so numerous as it was inconvenient to assembl them; it was thought fit by the emperor that men should consult th senate, instead of the people; and these have some resemblance with th acts of council."} +{"text":"5. \"The edicts of praetors,\" and in some cases of \"aediles\"; such a are the chief justices in the courts of England."} +{"text":"6. Responsa prudentum, which were the sentences and opinion of thos lawyers to whom the emperor gave authority to interpret the law, and t give answer to such as in matter of law demanded their advice; whic answers, the judges in giving judgment were obliged by th constitutions of the emperor to observe, and should be like the report of cases judged, if other judges be by the law of England bound t observe them. For the judges of the common law of England are no properly judges, but juris consulti, of whom the judges, who are eithe the Lords, or twelve men of the country, are in point of law to as advice."} +{"text":"7. Also \"unwritten customs,\" which in their own nature are an imitatio of law, by the tacit consent of the emperor, in case they be no contrary to the law of Nature, are very laws."} +{"text":"Another division of laws is into \"natural\" and \"positive.\" \"Natural\ are those which have been laws from all eternity; and are called no only \"natural\" but also \"moral\" laws; consisting in the moral virtues as justice, equity, and all habits of the mind that conduce to peac and charity, of which I have already spoken in the fourteenth an fifteenth chapters."} +{"text":"\"Positive\" are those which have not been from eternity; but have bee made laws by the will of those that have had the sovereign power ove others; and are either written or made known to men by some othe argument of the will of their legislator."} +{"text":"Again, of positive laws some are \"human,\" some \"divine\"; and of huma positive laws some are \"distributive,\" some \"penal.\" \"Distributive\" ar those that determine the rights of the subjects, declaring to every ma what it is by which he acquireth and holdeth a propriety in lands o goods, and a right or liberty of action: and these speak to all th subjects. \"Penal\" are those which declare what penalty shall b inflicted on those that violate the law; and speak to the ministers an officers ordained for execution. For though everyone ought to b informed of the punishments ordained beforehand for thei transgression, nevertheless the command is not addressed to th delinquent, who cannot be supposed will faithfully punish himself, bu to public ministers appointed to see the penalty executed. And thes penal laws are for the most part written together with the law distributive; and are sometimes called judgments. For all laws ar general judgments, or sentences of the legislator; as also ever particular judgment is a law to him whose case is judged."} +{"text":"\"Divine positive laws\" (for natural laws being eternal and universa are all divine) are those which being the commandments of God, not fro all eternity, nor universally addressed to all men, but only to certain people, or to certain persons, are declared for such by thos whom God hath authorized to declare them. But this authority of man t declare what be these positive laws of God, how can it be known? Go may command a man by a supernatural way to deliver laws to other men But because it is of the essence of law, that he who is to be oblige be assured of the authority of him that declareth it, which we canno naturally take notice to be from God, \"how can a man withou supernatural revelation be assured of the revelation received by th declarer?\" and \"how can he be bound to obey them?\" For the firs question, how a man can be assured of the revelation of another without a revelation particularly to himself, it is evidentl impossible. For though a man may be induced to believe such revelatio from the miracles they see him do, or from seeing the extraordinar sanctity of his life, or from seeing the extraordinary wisdom o extraordinary felicity of his actions, all which are marks of God' extraordinary favour; yet they are not assured evidences of specia revelation. Miracles are marvellous works; but that which is marvellou to one, may not be so to another. Sanctity may be feigned; and th visible felicities of this world are most often the work of God b natural and ordinary causes. And therefore no man can infallibly kno by natural reason that another has had a supernatural revelation o God's will, but only a belief; everyone, as the signs thereof shal appear greater or lesser, a firmer or a weaker belief."} +{"text":"But for the second, how can he be bound to obey them; it is not s hard. For if the law declared be not against the law of Nature, whic is undoubtedly God's law, and he undertake to obey it, he is bound b his own act; bound I say to obey it, but not bound to believe it: fo men's belief and interior cogitations are not subject to the commands but only to the operation of God, ordinary or extraordinary. Faith o supernatural law is not a fulfilling, but only an assenting to th same; and not a duty that we exhibit to God, but a gift which Go freely giveth to whom He pleaseth; as also unbelief is not a breach o any of His laws; but a rejection of them all, except the laws natural But this that I say, will be made yet clearer by the examples an testimonies concerning this point in Holy Scripture. The covenant Go made with Abraham, in a supernatural manner, was thus (Gen. 17:10) \"This is the covenant which thou shalt observe between me and thee, an thy seed after thee.\" Abraham's seed had not this revelation, nor wer yet in being; yet they are a party to the covenant, and bound to obe what Abraham should declare to them for God's law; which they could no be, but in virtue of the obedience they owed to their parents; who, i they be subject to no other earthly power, as here in the case o Abraham, have sovereign power over their children and servants. Again where God saith to Abraham, \"In thee shall all nations of the earth b blessed; for I know thou wilt command thy children, and thy house afte thee, to keep the way of the Lord, and to observe righteousness an judgment,\" it is manifest, the obedience of his family, who had n revelation, depended on their former obligation to obey thei sovereign. At Mount Sinai Moses only went up to God; the people wer forbidden to approach on pain of death; yet they were bound to obey al that Moses declared to them for God's law. Upon what ground, but o this submission of their own, \"Speak thou to us and we will hear thee but let not God speak to us, lest we die?\" By which two places i sufficiently appeareth, that in a commonwealth, a subject that has n certain and assured revelation particularly to himself concerning th will of God, is to obey for such the command of the commonwealth: fo if men were at liberty to take for God's commandments their own dream and fancies, or the dreams and fancies of private men; scarce two me would agree upon what is God's commandment; and yet in respect of them every man would despise the commandments of the commonwealth. conclude therefore, that in all things not contrary to the moral law that is to say, to the law of Nature, all subjects are bound to obe that for divine law, which is declared to be so by the laws of th commonwealth. Which also is evident to any man's reason; for whatsoeve is not against the law of Nature, may be made law in the name of the that have the sovereign power; and there is no reason men should be th less obliged by it, when it is propounded in the name of God. Besides there is no place in the world where men are permitted to pretend othe commandments of God than are declared for such by the commonwealth Christian states punish those that revolt from the Christian religion and all other states those that set up any religion by them forbidden For in whatsoever is not regulated by the commonwealth, it is equity which is the law of Nature, and therefore an eternal law of God, tha every man equally enjoy his liberty."} +{"text":"There is also another distinction of laws into \"fundamental\" and \"no fundamental\"; but I could never see in any author what a fundamenta law signifieth. Nevertheless one may very reasonably distinguish law in that manner."} +{"text":"For a fundamental law in every commonwealth is that, which being take away, the commonwealth faileth and is utterly dissolved; as a buildin whose foundation is destroyed. And therefore a fundamental law is that by which subjects are bound to uphold whatsoever power is given to th sovereign, whether a monarch or a sovereign assembly, without which th commonwealth cannot stand; such as is the power of war and peace, o judicature, of election of officers, and of doing whatsoever he shal think necessary for the public good. Not fundamental is that, th abrogating whereof draweth not with it the dissolution of th commonwealth; such as are the laws concerning controversies betwee subject and subject. Thus much of the division of laws."} +{"text":"I find the words lex civilis and jus civile, that is to say \"law\" an \"right civil,\" promiscuously used for the same thing, even in the mos learned authors; which nevertheless ought not to be so. For \"right\" i \"liberty,\" namely that liberty which the civil law leaves us: bu \"civil law\" is an \"obligation,\" and takes from us the liberty which th law of Nature gave us. Nature gave a right to every man to secur himself by his own strength, and to invade a suspected neighbour, b way of prevention: but the civil law takes away that liberty, in al cases where the protection of the law may be safely stayed for Insomuch as \"lex\" and \"jus\" are as different as \"obligation\" an \"liberty.\""} +{"text":"Likewise \"laws\" and \"charters\" are taken promiscuously for the sam thing. Yet charters are donations of the sovereign; and not laws, bu exemptions from law. The phrase of a law is, jubeo, injungo, \" command\" and \"enjoin\": the phrase of a charter is, dedi, concessi, \" have given,\" \"I have granted\": but what is given or granted to a man i not forced upon him by a law. A law may be made to bind all th subjects of a commonwealth: a liberty or charter is only to one man, o some one part of the people. For to say all the people of commonwealth have liberty in any case whatsoever, is to say, that i such case there hath been no law made; or else having been made, is no abrogated."} +{"text":"XVII"} +{"text":"Of Crimes, Excuses, and Extenuations"} +{"text":"A sin, is not only a transgression of a law, but also any contempt o the legislator. For such contempt is a breach of all his laws at once And therefore may consist, not only in the \"commission\" of a fact, o in speaking of words by the laws forbidden, or in the \"omission\" o what the law commandeth, but also in the \"intention,\" or purpose t transgress. For the purpose to break the law is some degree of contemp of him to whom it belongeth to see it executed. To be delighted in th imagination only of being possessed of another man's goods, servants or wife, without any intention to take them from him by force or fraud is no breach of the law, that saith, \"Thou shalt not covet\": nor is th pleasure a man may have in imagining or dreaming of the death of him from whose life he expecteth nothing but damage and displeasure, a sin but the resolving to put some act in execution that tendeth thereto For to be pleased in the fiction of that which would please a man if i were real, is a passion so adherent to the nature both of man and ever other living creature, as to make it a sin, were to make sin of being man. The consideration of this has made me think them too severe, bot to themselves and others, that maintain that the first motions of th mind, though checked with the fear of God, be sins. But I confess it i safer to err on that hand than on the other."} +{"text":"A \"crime,\" is a sin, consisting in the committing, by deed or word, o that which the law forbiddeth, or the omission of what it hat commanded. So that every crime is a sin; but not every sin a crime. T intend to steal, or kill, is a sin, though it never appear in word o fact: for God that seeth the thoughts of man, can lay it to his charge but till it appear by something done, or said, by which the intentio may be argued by a human judge, it hath not the name of crime: whic distinction the Greeks observed in the word ha�a'rty�a, and gkly�a, o aiti'a; whereof the former, which is translated \"sin,\" signifieth an swerving from the law whatsoever; but the two latter, which ar translated \"crime,\" signify that sin only, whereof one man may accus another. But of intentions, which never appear by any outward act there is no place for human accusation. In like manner the Latins b peccatum, which is \"sin,\" signify all manner of deviation from the law but by crimen, which word they derive from cerno, which signifies \"t perceive,\" they mean only such sins as may be made appear before judge; and therefore are not mere intentions."} +{"text":"From this relation of sin to the law, and of crime to the civil law may be inferred, first, that where law ceaseth, sin ceaseth. Bu because the law of Nature is eternal, violation of covenants ingratitude, arrogance, and all facts contrary to any moral virtue, ca never cease to be sin. Secondly, that the civil law ceasing, crime cease: for there being no other law remaining but that of nature, ther is no place for accusation; every man being his own judge, and accuse only by his own conscience, and cleared by the uprightness of his ow intention. When therefore his intention is right, his fact is no sin if otherwise, his fact is sin; but not crime. Thirdly, that when th sovereign power ceaseth, crime also ceaseth; for where there is no suc power, there is no protection to be had from the law; and therefor everyone may protect himself by his own power: for no man in th institution of sovereign power can be supposed to give away the righ of preserving his own body; for the safety whereof all sovereignty wa ordained. But this is to be understood only of those that have no themselves contributed to the taking away of the power that protecte them; for that was a crime from the beginning."} +{"text":"The source of every crime is some defect of the understanding, or som error in reasoning, or some sudden force of the passions. Defect in th understanding is \"ignorance\"; in reasoning, \"erroneous opinion.\" Again ignorance is of three sorts; of the \"law,\" and of the \"sovereign,\" an of the \"penalty.\" Ignorance of the law of Nature excuseth no man because every man that hath attained to the use of reason is suppose to know he ought not to do to another what he would not have done t himself. Therefore into what place soever a man shall come, if he d anything contrary to that law, it is a crime. If a man come from th Indies hither, and persuade men here to receive a new religion, o teach them anything that tendeth to disobedience of the laws of thi country, though he be never so well persuaded of the truth of what h teacheth, he commits a crime, and may be justly punished for the same not only because his doctrine is false, but also because he does tha which he would not approve in another, namely, that coming from hence he should endeavour to alter the religion there. But ignorance of th civil law, shall excuse a man in a strange country till it be declare to him, because till then no civil law is binding."} +{"text":"In the like manner, if the civil law of a man's own country be not s sufficiently declared as he may know it if he will, nor the actio against the law of Nature, the ignorance is a good excuse: in othe cases ignorance of the civil law excuseth not."} +{"text":"Ignorance of the sovereign power in the place of a man's ordinar residence excuseth him not, because he ought to take notice of th power by which he hath been protected there."} +{"text":"Ignorance of the penalty, where the law is declared, excuseth no man for in breaking the law, which, without a fear of penalty to follow were not a law, but vain words, he undergoeth the penalty, though h know not what it is; because whosoever voluntarily doth any action accepteth all the known consequences of it; but punishment is a know consequence of the violation of the laws in every commonwealth, whic punishment, if it be determined already by the law, he is subject t that; if not, then he is subject to arbitrary punishment. For it i reason that he which does injury without other limitation than that o his own will, should suffer punishment without other limitation tha that of his will whose law is thereby violated."} +{"text":"But when a penalty is either annexed to the crime in the law itself, o hath been usually inflicted in the like cases; there the delinquent i excused from a greater penalty. For the punishment foreknown, if no great enough to deter men from the action, is an invitement to it because when men compare the benefit of their injustice with the har of their punishment, by necessity of nature they choose that whic appeareth best for themselves; and therefore when they are punishe more than the law had formerly determined, or more than others wer punished for the same crime; it is the law that tempted and deceivet them."} +{"text":"No law, made after a fact done, can make it a crime: because if th fact be against the law of Nature, the law was before the fact; and positive law cannot be taken notice of, before it be made; an therefore cannot be obligatory. But when the law that forbiddeth fact, is made before the fact be done; yet he that doth the fact, i liable to the penalty ordained after, in case no lesser penalty wer made known before, neither by writing, nor by example, for the reaso immediately before alleged."} +{"text":"From defect in reasoning, that is to say, from error, men are prone t violate the laws three ways. First, by presumption of false principles as when men, from having observed how in all places and in all ages unjust actions have been authorized, by the force and victories o those who have committed them; and that potent men, breaking throug the cobweb laws of their country, the weaker sort and those that hav failed in their enterprises, have been esteemed the only criminals have thereupon taken for principles, and grounds of their reasoning \"that justice is but a vain word: that whatsoever a man can get by hi own industry and hazard, is his own: that the practice of all nation cannot be unjust: that examples of former times are good arguments o doing the like again\"; and many more of that kind; which being granted no act in itself can be a crime, but must be made so, not by the law but by the success of them that commit it; and the same fact b virtuous or vicious, as fortune pleaseth; so that what Marius makes crime, Sylla shall make meritorious, and Caesar, the same law standing, turn again into a crime, to the perpetual disturbance of th peace of the commonwealth."} +{"text":"Secondly, by false teachers, that either misinterpret the law o Nature, making it thereby repugnant to the law civil; or by teachin for laws, such doctrines of their own, or traditions of former times as are inconsistent with the duty of a subject."} +{"text":"Thirdly, by erroneous inferences from true principles; which happen commonly to men that are hasty and precipitate in concluding, an resolving what to do; such as are they, that have both a great opinio of their own understanding, and believe that things of this natur require not time and study, but only common experience, and a goo natural wit; whereof no man thinks himself unprovided: whereas th knowledge of right and wrong, which is no less difficult, there is n man will pretend to, without great and long study. And of those defect in reasoning, there is none that can excuse, though some of them ma extenuate, a crime in any man, that pretendeth to the administration o his own private business; much less in them that undertake a publi charge; because they pretend to the reason, upon the want whereof the would ground their excuse."} +{"text":"Of the passions that most frequently are the causes of crime, one i vainglory, or a foolish overrating of their own worth; as if differenc of worth were an effect of their wit, or riches, or blood, or som other natural quality, not depending on the will of those that have th sovereign authority. From whence proceedeth a presumption that th punishments ordained by the laws, and extended generally to al subjects, ought not to be inflicted on them with the same rigour the are inflicted on poor, obscure, and simple men, comprehended under th name of the \"vulgar.\""} +{"text":"Therefore it happeneth commonly, that such as value themselves by th greatness of their wealth, adventure on crimes, upon hope of escapin punishment, by corrupting public justice, or obtaining pardon by money or other rewards."} +{"text":"And that such as have multitude of potent kindred, and popular men that have gained reputation amongst the multitude, take courage t violate the laws, from a hope of oppressing the power to whom i belongeth to put them in execution."} +{"text":"And that such as have a great and false opinion of their own wisdom take upon them to reprehend the actions and call in question th authority of them that govern, and so to unsettle the laws with thei public discourse, as that nothing shall be a crime, but what their ow designs require should be so. It happeneth also to the same men, to b prone to all such crimes, as consist in craft, and in deceiving o their neighbours; because they think their designs are too subtle to b perceived. These I say are effects of a false presumption of their ow wisdom. For of them that are the first movers in the disturbance o commonwealth, which can never happen without a civil war, very few ar left alive long enough to see their new designs established: so tha the benefit of their crimes redoundeth to posterity, and such as woul least have wished it: which argues they were not so wise as the thought they were. And those that deceive upon hope of not bein observed, do commonly deceive themselves, the darkness in which the believe they lie hidden being nothing else but their own blindness; an are no wiser than children, that think all hid by hiding their ow eyes."} +{"text":"And generally all vainglorious men, unless they be withal timorous, ar subject to anger; as being more prone than others to interpret fo contempt the ordinary liberty of conversation: and there are few crime that may not be produced by anger."} +{"text":"As for the passions of hate, lust, ambition, and covetousness, wha crimes they are apt to produce, is so obvious to every man's experienc and understanding, as there needeth nothing to be said of them, savin that they are infirmities, so annexed to the nature, both of man an all other living creatures, as that their effects cannot be hindere but by extraordinary use of reason, or a constant severity in punishin them. For in those things men hate, they find a continual an unavoidable molestation; whereby either a man's patience must b everlasting, or he must be eased by removing the power of that whic molesteth him. The former is difficult; the latter is many time impossible, without some violation of the law. Ambition an covetousness are passions also that are perpetually incumbent an pressing; whereas reason is not perpetually present to resist them: an therefore whensoever the hope of impunity appears, their effect proceed. And for lust, what it wants in the lasting, it hath in th vehemence, which sufficeth to weigh down the apprehension of all eas or uncertain punishments."} +{"text":"Of all passions, that which inclineth men least to break the laws, i fear. Nay, excepting some generous natures, it is the only thing, whe there is apparence of profit or pleasure by breaking the laws, tha makes men keep them. And yet in many cases a crime may be committe through fear."} +{"text":"For not every fear justifies the action it produceth, but the fear onl of corporeal hurt, which we call \"bodily fear,\" and from which a ma cannot see how to be delivered but by the action. A man is assaulted fears present death, from which he sees not how to escape but b wounding him that assaulteth him: if he wound him to death, this is n crime, because no man is supposed at the making of a commonwealth t have abandoned the defence of his life or limbs, where the law canno arrive time enough to his assistance. But to kill a man, because fro his actions, or his threatenings, I may argue he will kill me when h can, seeing I have time and means to demand protection from th sovereign power, is a crime. Again, a man receives words of disgrace o some little injuries, for which they that made the laws had assigned n punishment, nor thought it worthy of a man that hath the use of reaso to take notice of, and is afraid, unless he revenge it, he shall fal into contempt, and consequently be obnoxious to the like injuries fro others; and to avoid this, breaks the law, and protects himself for th future by the terror of his private revenge. This is a crime; for th hurt is not corporeal, but fantastical, and, though in this corner o the world, made sensible by a custom not many years since begun amongst young and vain men, so light, as a gallant man, and one that i assured of his own courage, cannot take notice of. Also a man may stan in fear of spirits, either through his own superstition, or through to much credit given to other men, that tell him of strange dreams an visions, and thereby be made believe they will hurt him for doing o omitting divers things, which nevertheless to do, or omit, is contrar to the laws; and that which is so done, or omitted, is not to b excused by this fear: but is a crime. For, as I have shown before i the second chapter, dreams be naturally but the fancies remaining i sleep, after the impressions our senses had formerly received waking and when men are by any accident unassured they have slept, seem to b real visions; and therefore he that presumes to break the law upon hi own or another's dream, or pretended vision, or upon other fancy of th power of invisible spirits, than is permitted by the commonwealth leaveth the law of Nature, which is a certain offence, and followet the imagery of his own or another private man's brain, which he ca never know whether it signifieth anything or nothing, nor whether h that tells his dream say true or lie; which if every private man shoul have leave to do, as they must by the law of Nature, if anyone have it there could no law be made to hold, and so all commonwealth would b dissolved."} +{"text":"From these different sources of crimes, it appears already, that al crimes are not, as the Stoics of old time maintained, of the sam allay. There is place, not only for \"excuse,\" by which that whic seemed a crime is proved to be none at all; but also for \"extenuation,\ by which the crime, that seemed great, is made less. For though al crimes do equally deserve the name of injustice, as all deviation fro a straight line is equally crookedness, which the Stoics rightl observed: yet it does not follow that all crimes are equally unjust, n more than that all crooked lines are equally crooked: which the Stoic not observing, held it as great a crime to kill a hen, against the law as to kill one's father."} +{"text":"That which totally excuseth a fact, and takes away from it the natur of a crime, can be none but that which at the same time taketh away th obligation of the law. For the fact committed once against the law, i he that committed it be obliged to the law, can be no other than crime."} +{"text":"The want of means to know the law totally excuseth. For the law whereo a man has no means to inform himself, is not obligatory. But the wan of diligence to inquire shall not be considered as a want of means; no shall any man, that pretendeth to reason enough for the government o his own affairs, be supposed to want means to know the laws of Nature because they are known by the reason he pretends to: only children an madmen are excused from offences against the law natural."} +{"text":"Where a man is captive, or in the power of the enemy (and he is then i the power of the enemy when his person or his means of living is so) if it be without his own fault, the obligation of the law ceaseth because he must obey the enemy or die; and consequently such obedienc is no crime: for no man is obliged, when the protection of the la faileth, not to protect himself by the best means he can."} +{"text":"If a man, by the terror of present death, be compelled to do a fac against the law, he is totally excused; because no law can oblige a ma to abandon his own preservation. And supposing such a law wer obligatory, yet a man would reason thus: \"If I do it not, I di presently; if I do it, I die afterwards; therefore by doing it, ther is time of life gained.\" Nature therefore compels him to the fact."} +{"text":"When a man is destitute of food, or other thing necessary for his life and cannot preserve himself any other way but by some fact against th law; as if in a great famine he take the food by force or stealth which he cannot obtain for money nor charity; or in defence of his lif snatch away another man's sword; he is totally excused, for the reaso next before alleged."} +{"text":"Again, facts done against the law by the authority of another, are b that authority excused against the author; because no man ought t accuse his own fact in another that is but his instrument: but it i not excused against a third person thereby injured; because in th violation of the law, both the author and actor are criminals. Fro hence it followeth that when that man or assembly, that hath th sovereign power, commandeth a man to do that which is contrary to former law, the doing of it is totally excused: for he ought not t condemn it himself, because he is the author; and what cannot justly b condemned by the sovereign, cannot justly be punished by any other Besides, when the sovereign commandeth anything to be done against hi own former law, the command, as to that particular fact, is a abrogation of the law."} +{"text":"If that man, or assembly that hath the sovereign power, disclaim an right essential to the sovereignty, whereby there accrueth to th subject any liberty inconsistent with the sovereign power, that is t say, with the very being of a commonwealth, if the subject shall refus to obey the command in anything contrary to the liberty granted, thi is nevertheless a sin, and contrary to the duty of the subject: for h ought to take notice of what is inconsistent with the sovereignty because it was erected by his own consent and for his own defence; an that such liberty as is inconsistent with it was granted throug ignorance of the evil consequence thereof. But if he not only disobey but also resist a public minister in the execution of it, then it is crime, because he might have been righted, without any breach of th peace, upon complaint."} +{"text":"The degrees of crime are taken on divers scales, and measured, first by the malignity of the source or cause; secondly, by the contagion o the example; thirdly, by the mischief of the effect; and fourthly, b the concurrence of times, places, and persons."} +{"text":"The same fact done against the law, if it proceed from presumption o strength, riches, or friends to resist those that are to execute th law, is a greater crime than if it proceed from hope of not bein discovered, or of escape by flight: for presumption of impunity b force is a root from whence springeth, at all times, and upon al temptations, a contempt of all laws; whereas, in the latter case, th apprehension of danger that makes a man fly, renders him more obedien for the future. A crime which we know to be so, is greater than th same crime proceeding from a false persuasion that it is lawful; for h that committeth it against his own conscience, presumeth on his forc or other power, which encourages him to commit the same again: but h that doth it by error, after the error is shown him, is conformable t the law."} +{"text":"He whose error proceeds from the authority of a teacher, or a interpreter of the law publicly authorized, is not so faulty as h whose error proceedeth from a peremptory pursuit of his own principle and reasoning; for what is taught by one that teacheth by publi authority, the commonwealth teacheth, and hath a resemblance of la till the same authority controlleth it; and in all crimes that contai not in them a denial of the sovereign power, nor are against an eviden law, excuseth totally: whereas he that groundeth his actions on hi private judgment, ought, according to the rectitude or error thereof to stand or fall."} +{"text":"The same fact, if it have been constantly punished in other men, is greater crime than if there have been many precedent examples o impunity. For those examples are so many hopes of impunity, given b the sovereign himself; and because he which furnishes a man with such hope and presumption of mercy, as encourageth him to offend, hath hi part in the offence, he cannot reasonably charge the offender with th whole."} +{"text":"A crime arising from a sudden passion is not so great as when the sam ariseth from long meditation; for in the former case there is a plac for extenuation, in the common infirmity of human nature; but he tha doth it with premeditation, has used circumspection, and cast his ey on the law, on the punishment, and on the consequence thereof to huma society; all which, in committing the crime, he hath contemned an postposed to his own appetite. But there is no suddenness of passio sufficient for a total excuse: for all the time between the firs knowing of the law and the commission of the fact, shall be taken for time of deliberation: because he ought by meditation of the law t rectify the irregularity of his passions."} +{"text":"Where the law is publicly, and with assiduity, before all the peopl read and interpreted, a fact done against it is a greater crime tha where men are left without such instruction, to inquire of it wit difficulty, uncertainty, and interruption of their callings, and b informed by private men; for in this case part of the fault i discharged upon common infirmity; but, in the former, there is apparen negligence, which is not without some contempt of the sovereign power."} +{"text":"Those facts which the law expressly condemneth, but the lawmaker b other manifest signs of his will tacitly approveth, are less crime than the same facts condemned both by the law and lawmaker. For seein the will of the lawmaker is a law, there appear in this case tw contradictory laws; which would totally excuse, if men were bound t take notice of the sovereign's approbation by other arguments than ar expressed by his command. But because there are punishments consequent not only to the transgression of his law, but also to the observing o it, he is in part a cause of the transgression, and therefore canno reasonably impute the whole crime to the delinquent. For example, th law condemneth duels; the punishment is made capital. On the contrar part, he that refuseth duel is subject to contempt and scorn, withou remedy; and sometimes by the sovereign himself thought unworthy to hav any charge or preferment in war. If thereupon he accept duel considering all men lawfully endeavour to obtain the good opinion o them that have the sovereign power, he ought not in reason to b rigorously punished, seeing part of the fault may be discharged on th punisher; which I say, not as wishing liberty of private revenges o any other kind of disobedience, but a care in governors not t countenance anything obliquely which directly they forbid. The example of princes, to those that see them, are, and ever have been, mor potent to govern their actions than the laws themselves. And though i be our duty to do, not what they do, but what they say, yet will tha duty never be performed till it please God to give men an extraordinar and supernatural grace to follow that precept."} +{"text":"Again, if we compare crimes by the mischief of their effects; first the same fact, when it redounds to the damage of many, is greater tha when it redounds to the hurt of few; and therefore, when a fac hurteth, not only in the present, but also, by example, in the future it is a greater crime than if it hurt only in the present: for th former is a fertile crime, and multiplies to the hurt of many; th latter is barren. To maintain doctrines contrary to the religio established in the commonwealth, is a greater fault in an authorize preacher than in a private person; so also is it to live profanely incontinently, or do any irreligious act whatsoever. Likewise in professor of the law, to maintain any point, or do any act that tendet to the weakening of the sovereign power, is a greater crime than i another man. Also in a man that hath such reputation for wisdom as tha his counsels are followed or his actions imitated by many, his fac against the law is a greater crime than the same fact in another: fo such men not only commit crime, but teach it for law to all other men And generally all crimes are the greater by the scandal they give: tha is to say, by becoming stumbling-blocks to the weak, that look not s much upon the way they go in, as upon the light that other men carr before them."} +{"text":"Also facts of hostility against the present state of the commonwealth are greater crimes than the same acts done to private men: for th damage extends itself to all: such are the betraying of the strength or revealing of the secrets of the commonwealth to an enemy; also al attempts upon the representative of the commonwealth, be it a monarc or an assembly; and all endeavours by word, or deed, to diminish th authority of the same, either in the present time or in succession which crimes the Latins understand by crimina laesae majestatis, an consist in design, or act, contrary to a fundamental law."} +{"text":"Likewise those crimes, which render judgments of no effect, are greate crimes than injuries done to one or a few persons; as to receive mone to give false judgment or testimony, is a greater crime than otherwis to deceive a man of the like, or a greater sum; because not only he ha wrong that falls by such judgments; but all judgments are rendere useless, and occasion ministered to force and private revenges."} +{"text":"Also robbery, and depeculation of the public treasure or revenues, is greater crime than the robbing or defrauding of a private man; becaus to rob the public, is to rob many at once."} +{"text":"Also the counterfeit usurpation of public ministry, the counterfeitin of public seals or public coin, than counterfeiting of a private man' person or his seal; because the fraud thereof extendeth to the damag of many."} +{"text":"Of facts against the law, done to private men, the greater crime i that where the damage, in the common opinion of men, is most sensible and therefore�--"} +{"text":"To kill against the law, is a greater crime, than any other injury life preserved."} +{"text":"And to kill with torment, greater than simply to kill."} +{"text":"And mutilation of a limb, greater than the spoiling a man of his goods."} +{"text":"And the spoiling a man of his goods by terror of death or wounds, tha by clandestine surreption."} +{"text":"And by clandestine surreption, than by consent fraudulently obtained."} +{"text":"And the violation of chastity by force, greater than by flattery."} +{"text":"And of a woman married, than of a woman not married."} +{"text":"For all these things are commonly so valued; though some men are more and some less, sensible of the same offence. But the law regardeth no the particular, but the general inclination of mankind."} +{"text":"And therefore the offence men take, from contumely, in words o gesture, when they produce no other harm than the present grief of hi that is reproached, hath been neglected in the laws of the Greeks Romans, and other both ancient and modern commonwealths; supposing th true cause of such grief to consist, not in the contumely, which take no hold upon men conscious of their own virtue, but in th pusillanimity of him that is offended by it."} +{"text":"Also a crime against a private man is much aggravated by the person time, and place. For to kill one's parent, is a greater crime than t kill another: for the parent ought to have the honour of a sovereign though he surrendered his power to the civil law; because he had i originally by nature. And to rob a poor man, is a greater crime than t rob a rich man; because it is to the poor a more sensible damage."} +{"text":"And a crime committed in the time or place appointed for devotion i greater than if committed at another time or place: for it proceed from a greater contempt of the law."} +{"text":"Many other cases of aggravation and extenuation might be added: but b these I have set down, it is obvious to every man to take the altitud of any other crime proposed."} +{"text":"Lastly, because in almost all crimes there is an injury done not onl to some private men, but also to the commonwealth, the same crime, whe the accusation is in the name of the commonwealth, is called publi crime: and when in the name of a private man, a private crime; and th pleas according thereunto called public, judicia publica, Pleas of th Crown, or Private Pleas. As in an accusation of murder, if the accuse be a private man, the plea is a Private Plea; if the accuser be th sovereign, the plea is a Public Plea."} +{"text":"XVIII"} +{"text":"Of Punishments and Rewards"} +{"text":"A punishment \"is an evil inflicted by public authority on him that hat done or omitted that which is judged by the same authority to be transgression of the law; to the end that the will of men may thereb the better be disposed to obedience.\""} +{"text":"Before I infer anything from this definition, there is a question to b answered of much importance; which is, by what door the right o authority of punishing in any case came in. For by that which has bee said before, no man is supposed bound by covenant, not to resis violence; and consequently it cannot be intended that he gave any righ to another to lay violent hands upon his person. In the making of commonwealth, every man giveth away the right of defending another, bu not of defending himself. Also he obligeth himself to assist him tha hath the sovereignty in the punishing of another; but of himself not But to covenant to assist the sovereign in doing hurt to another unless he that so covenanteth have a right to do it himself, is not t give him a right to punish. It is manifest therefore that the righ which the commonwealth, that is, he or they that represent it, hath t punish is not grounded on any concession or gift of the subjects. But have also showed formerly, that before the institution of commonwealt every man had a right to everything, and to do whatsoever he though necessary to his own preservation; subduing, hurting, or killing an man in order thereunto. And this is the foundation of that right o punishing which is exercised in every commonwealth. For the subject did not give the sovereign that right; but only in laying down theirs strengthened him to use his own, as he should think fit, for th preservation of them all: so that it was not given, but left to him and to him only; and (excepting the limits set him by natural law) a entire as in the condition of mere nature, and of war of everyon against his neighbour."} +{"text":"From the definition of punishment, I infer, first, that neither privat revenges, nor injuries of private men, can properly be style punishment; because they proceed not from public authority."} +{"text":"Secondly, that to be neglected, and unpreferred by the public favour is not a punishment; because no new evil is thereby on any ma inflicted; he is only left in the estate he was in before."} +{"text":"Thirdly, that the evil inflicted by public authority, without preceden public condemnation, is not to be styled by the name of punishment, bu of an hostile act; because the fact for which a man is punished, ough first to be judged by public authority, to be a transgression of th law."} +{"text":"Fourthly, that the evil inflicted by usurped power, and judges withou authority from the sovereign, is not punishment, but an act o hostility; because the acts of power usurped have not for author th person condemned, and therefore are not acts of public authority."} +{"text":"Fifthly, that all evil which is inflicted without intention, o possibility of disposing the delinquent, or, by his example, other men to obey the laws, is not punishment, but an act of hostility; becaus without such an end, no hurt done is contained under that name."} +{"text":"Sixthly, whereas to certain actions there be annexed by nature, diver hurtful consequences; as when a man in assaulting another is himsel slain or wounded; or when he falleth into sickness by the doing of som unlawful act; such hurt, though in respect of God, who is the author o nature, it may be said to be inflicted, and therefore a punishmen divine; yet it is not contained in the name of punishment in respect o men, because it is not inflicted by the authority of man."} +{"text":"Seventhly, if the harm inflicted be less than the benefit o contentment that naturally followeth the crime committed, that harm i not within the definition; and is rather the price, or redemption, tha the punishment of a crime: because it is of the nature of punishment t have for end the disposing of men to obey the law; which end, if it b less than the benefit of the transgression, it attaineth not, bu worketh a contrary effect."} +{"text":"Eighthly, if a punishment be determined and prescribed in the la itself, and after the crime committed, there be a greater punishmen inflicted, the excess is not punishment, but an act of hostility. Fo seeing the aim of punishment is not a revenge, but terror; and th terror of a great punishment unknown, is taken away by the declaratio of a less, the unexpected addition is no part of the punishment. Bu where there is no punishment at all determined by the law, ther whatsoever is inflicted hath the nature of punishment. For he that goe about the violation of a law, wherein no penalty is determined expecteth an indeterminate, that is to say, an arbitrary punishment."} +{"text":"Ninthly, harm inflicted for a fact done before there was a law tha forbade it, is not punishment, but an act of hostility: for before th law, there is no transgression of the law: but punishment supposeth fact judged, to have been transgression of the law; therefore har inflicted before the law made, is not punishment, but an act o hostility."} +{"text":"Tenthly, hurt inflicted on the representative of the commonwealth, i not punishment, but an act of hostility; because it is of the nature o punishment to be inflicted by public authority, which is the authorit only of the representative itself."} +{"text":"Lastly, harm inflicted upon one that is a declared enemy, falls no under the name of punishment: because seeing they were either neve subject to the law, and therefore cannot transgress it; or having bee subject to it, and professing to be no longer so, by consequence den they can transgress it, all the harms that can be done them, must b taken as acts of hostility. But in declared hostility, all inflictio of evil is lawful. From whence it followeth, that if a subject shall b fact, or word, wittingly and deliberately deny the authority of th representative of the commonwealth (whatsoever penalty hath bee formerly ordained for treason), he may lawfully be made to suffe whatsoever the representative will. For in denying subjection, h denies such punishment as by the law hath been ordained; and therefor suffers as an enemy of the commonwealth; that is, according to the wil of the representative. For the punishments set down in the law, are t subjects, not to enemies; such as are they, that having been by thei own acts subjects, deliberately revolting, deny the sovereign power."} +{"text":"The first and most general distribution of punishments, is int \"divine\" and \"human.\" Of the former I shall have occasion to speak in more convenient place hereafter."} +{"text":"\"Human,\" are those punishments that be inflicted by the commandment o man; and are either \"corporal,\" or \"pecuniary,\" or \"ignominy,\" o \"imprisonment,\" or \"exile,\" or mixed of these."} +{"text":"\"Corporal punishment\" is that which is inflicted on the body directly and according to the intention of him that inflicteth it: such as ar stripes, or wounds, or deprivation of such pleasures of the body a were before lawfully enjoyed."} +{"text":"And of these, some be \"capital,\" some \"less\" than \"capital.\" Capital is the infliction of death; and that either simply or with torment Less than capital, are stripes, wounds, chains, and any other corpora pain, not in its own nature mortal. For if upon the infliction of punishment death follow not in the intention of the inflictor, th punishment is not to be esteemed capital, though the harm prove morta by an accident not to be foreseen; in which case death is no inflicted, but hastened."} +{"text":"\"Pecuniary punishment,\" is that which consisteth not only in th deprivation of a sum of money, but also of lands, or any other good which are usually bought and sold for money. And in case the law, tha ordaineth such a punishment, be made with design to gather money fro such as shall transgress the same, it is not properly a punishment, bu the price of privilege and exemption from the law, which doth no absolutely forbid the fact, but only to those that are not able to pa the money: except where the law is natural, or part of religion; for i that case it is not an exemption from the law, but a transgression o it. As where a law exacteth a pecuniary mulct, of them that take th name of God in vain, the payment of the mulct is not the price of dispensation to swear, but the punishment of the transgression of a la indispensable. In like manner if the law impose a sum of money to b paid to him that has been injured; this is but a satisfaction for th hurt done him; and extinguisheth the accusation of the party injured not the crime of the offender."} +{"text":"\"Ignominy,\" is the infliction of such evil as is made dishonourable; o the deprivation of such good as is made honourable by the commonwealth For there be some things honourable by nature; as the effects o courage, magnanimity, strength, wisdom, and other abilities of body an mind: others made honourable by the commonwealth; as badges, titles offices, or any other singular mark of the sovereign's favour. Th former, though they may fail by nature or accident, cannot be take away by a law; and therefore the loss of them is not punishment. Bu the latter may be taken away by the public authority that made the honourable, and are properly punishments: such are degrading me condemned of their badges, titles, and offices; or declaring the incapable of the like in time to come."} +{"text":"\"Imprisonment,\" is when a man is by public authority deprived o liberty, and may happen from two divers ends, whereof one is the saf custody of a man accused, the other is the inflicting of pain on a ma condemned. The former is not punishment, because no man is supposed t be punished before he be judicially heard and declared guilty. An therefore whatsoever hurt a man is made to suffer by bonds, o restraint, before his cause be heard, over and above that which i necessary to assure his custody, is against the law of Nature. But th latter is punishment, because evil, and inflicted by public authority for somewhat that has by the same authority been judged a transgressio of the law. Under this word imprisonment, I comprehend all restraint o motion, caused by an external obstacle, be it a house, which is calle by the general name of a prison, or an island, as when men are said t be confined to it, or a place where men are set to work, as in old tim men have been condemned to quarries, and in these times to galleys; o be it a chain or any other such impediment."} +{"text":"\"Exile\" (banishment) is when a man is for a crime condemned to depar out of the dominion of the commonwealth, or out of a certain par thereof, and during a prefixed time, or forever, not to return into it and seemeth not in its own nature, without other circumstances, to be punishment; but rather an escape, or a public commandment to avoi punishment by flight. And Cicero says, there was never any suc punishment ordained in the city of Rome; but calls it a refuge of me in danger. For if a man banished, be nevertheless permitted to enjo his goods, and the revenue of his lands, the mere change of air is n punishment, nor does it tend to that benefit of the commonwealth, fo which all punishments are ordained, that is to say, to the forming o men's wills to the observation of the law; but many times to the damag of the commonwealth. For a banished man is a lawful enemy of th commonwealth that banished him, as being no more a member of the same But if he be withal deprived of his lands or goods, then the punishmen lieth not in the exile, but is to be reckoned amongst punishment pecuniary."} +{"text":"All punishments of innocent subjects, be they great or little, ar against the law of Nature; for punishment is only for transgression o the law, and therefore there can be no punishment of the innocent. I is therefore a violation, first, of that law of Nature which forbiddet all men in their revenges to look at anything but some future good, fo there can arrive no good to the commonwealth by punishing the innocent Secondly, of that which forbiddeth ingratitude: for seeing al sovereign power is originally given by the consent of every one of th subjects, to the end they should as long as they are obedient b protected thereby: the punishment of the innocent is a rendering o evil for good. And thirdly, of the law that commandeth equity, that i to say, an equal distribution of justice, which in punishing th innocent is not observed."} +{"text":"But the infliction of what evil soever, on an innocent man that is no a subject, if it be for the benefit of the commonwealth, and withou violation of any former covenant, is no breach of the law of Nature For all men that are not subjects, are either enemies, or else the have ceased from being so by some precedent covenants. But agains enemies, whom the commonwealth judgeth capable to do them hurt, it i lawful by the original right of Nature to make war; wherein the swor judgeth not, nor doth the victor make distinction of nocent an innocent, as to the time past, nor has other respect of mercy than a it conduceth to the good of his own people. And upon this ground it i that also in subjects who deliberately deny the authority of th commonwealth established, the vengeance is lawfully extended, not onl to the fathers, but also to the third and fourth generation not yet i being, and consequently innocent of the fact for which they ar afflicted: because the nature of this offence consisteth in th renouncing of subjection, which is a relapse into the condition of war commonly called rebellion, and they that so offend, suffer not a subjects, but as enemies. For \"rebellion\" is but war renewed."} +{"text":"\"Reward\" is either of \"gift\" or by \"contract.\" When by contract, it i called \"salary\" and \"wages\"; which is benefit due for service performe or promised. When of gift, it is benefit proceeding from the \"grace\" o them that bestow it, to encourage or enable men to do them service. An therefore when the sovereign of a commonwealth appointeth a salary t any public office, he that receiveth it is bound in justice to perfor his office; otherwise, he is bound only in honour to acknowledgment and an endeavour of requital. For though men have no lawful remedy when they be commanded to quit their private business, to serve th public, without reward or salary; yet they are not bound thereto, b the law of Nature, nor by the institution of the commonwealth, unles the service cannot otherwise be done; because it is supposed th sovereign may make use of all their means, insomuch as the most commo soldier may demand the wages of his warfare as a debt."} +{"text":"The benefit which a sovereign bestoweth on a subject, for fear of som power and ability he hath to do hurt to the commonwealth, are no properly rewards; for they are not salaries; because there is in thi case no contract supposed, every man being obliged already not to d the commonwealth disservice: nor are they graces, because they b extorted by fear, which ought not to be incident to the sovereig power: but are rather sacrifices, which the sovereign, considered i his natural person, and not in the person of the commonwealth, makes for the appeasing the discontent of him he thinks more potent tha himself; and encourage not to obedience, but on the contrary, to th continuance and increasing of further extortion."} +{"text":"And whereas some salaries are certain, and proceed from the publi treasure; and others uncertain and casual, proceeding from th execution of the office for which the salary is ordained; the latter i in some cases hurtful to the commonwealth; as in the case o judicature. For where the benefit of the judges and ministers of court of justice ariseth from the multitude of causes that are brough to their cognizance, there must needs follow two inconveniences: one is the nourishing of suits; for the more suits, the greater benefit and another that depends on that, which is contention abou jurisdiction, each court drawing to itself as many causes as it can But in offices of execution there are not those inconveniences; becaus their employment cannot be increased by any endeavour of their own. An thus much shall suffice for the nature of punishment and reward; whic are, as it were, the nerves and tendons that move the limbs and joint of a commonwealth."} +{"text":"Hitherto I have set forth the nature of man, whose pride and othe passions have compelled him to submit himself to government: togethe with the great power of his governor, whom I compared to \"Leviathan,\ taking that comparison out of the two last verses of th one-and-fortieth of Job; where God, having set forth the great power o \"Leviathan,\" calleth him king of the proud. \"There is nothing,\" sait he, \"on earth to be compared with him. He is made so as not to b afraid. He seeth every high thing below him; and is king of all th children of pride.\" But because he is mortal, and subject to decay, a all other earthly creatures are; and because there is that in heaven though not on earth, that he should stand in fear of, and whose laws h ought to obey; I shall in the next following chapter speak of hi diseases, and the causes of his mortality; and of what laws of Natur he is bound to obey."} +{"text":"XIX"} +{"text":"Of Those Things That Weaken, or Tend to the Dissolution of Commonwealth"} +{"text":"Though nothing can be immortal which mortals make, yet if men had th use of reason they pretend to, their commonwealths might be secured, a least from perishing by internal diseases. For by the nature of thei institution, they are designed to live as long as mankind, or as th laws of Nature or as justice itself, which gives them life. Therefor when they come to be dissolved, not by external violence, but intestin disorder, the fault is not in men, as they are the \"matter\"; but a they are the \"makers,\" and orderers of them. For men, as they become a last weary of irregular jostling and hewing one another, and desir with all their hearts to conform themselves into one firm and lastin edifice: so for want, both of the art of making fit laws, to squar their actions by, and also of humility and patience, to suffer the rud and cumbersome points of their present greatness to be taken off, the cannot without the help of a very able architect, be compiled into an other than a crazy building, such as hardly lasting out their own time must assuredly fall upon the heads of their posterity."} +{"text":"Amongst the \"infirmities\" therefore of a commonwealth, I will reckon i the first place, those that arise from an imperfect institution, an resemble the diseases of a natural body, which proceed from defectuous procreation."} +{"text":"Of which this is one, \"that a man to obtain a kingdom, is sometime content with less power, than to the peace and defence of th commonwealth is necessarily required.\" From whence it cometh to pass that when the exercise of the power laid by is for the public safety t be resumed, it hath the resemblance of an unjust act; which disposet great numbers of men, when occasion is presented, to rebel; in the sam manner as the bodies of children, gotten by diseased parents, ar subject either to untimely death, or to purge the ill quality, derive from their vicious conception, by breaking out into boils and scabs And when kings deny themselves some such necessary power, it is no always, though sometimes, out of ignorance of what is necessary to th office they undertake; but many times out of a hope to recover the sam again at their pleasure. Wherein they reason not well; because such a will hold them to their promises, shall be maintained against them b foreign commonwealths; who in order to the good of their own subject let slip few occasions to \"weaken\" the estate of their neighbours. S was Thomas Becket, Archbishop of Canterbury, supported against Henr the Second, by the Pope; the subjection of ecclesiastics to th commonwealth, having been dispensed with by William the Conqueror a his reception, when he took an oath not to infringe the liberty of th Church. And so were the barons, whose power was by William Rufus, t have their help in transferring the succession from his elder brothe to himself, increased to a degree inconsistent with the sovereig power, maintained in their rebellion against king John, by the French."} +{"text":"Nor does this happen in monarchy only. For whereas the style of th ancient Roman commonwealth was \"the senate and people of Rome,\" neithe senate nor people pretended to the whole power; which first caused th seditions of Tiberius Gracchus, Caius Gracchus, Lucius Saturninus, an others; and afterwards the wars between the senate and the people under Marius and Sylla; and again under Pompey and Caesar, to th extinction of their democracy, and the setting up of monarchy."} +{"text":"The people of Athens bound themselves but from one only action; whic was, that no man on pain of death should propound the renewing of th war for the island of Salamis; and yet thereby, if Solon had not cause to be given out he was mad, and afterwards in gesture and habit of madman, and in verse, propounded it to the people that flocked abou him, they had had an enemy perpetually in readiness, even at the gate of their city; such damage or shifts are all commonwealths forced to that have their power never so little limited."} +{"text":"In the second place, I observe the \"diseases\" of a commonwealth, tha proceed from the poison of seditious doctrines, whereof one is, \"Tha every private man is judge of good and evil actions.\" This is true i the condition of mere nature, where there are no civil laws; and als under civil government, in such cases as are not determined by the law But otherwise, it is manifest, that the measure of good and evi actions, is the civil law; and the judge the legislator, who is alway representative of the commonwealth. From this false doctrine, men ar disposed to debate with themselves and dispute the commands of th commonwealth; and afterwards to obey or disobey them, as in thei private judgments they shall think fit; whereby the commonwealth i distracted and \"weakened.\""} +{"text":"Another doctrine repugnant to civil society, is, that \"whatsoever a ma does against his conscience is sin\"; and it dependeth on th presumption of making himself judge of good and evil. For a man' conscience and his judgment is the same thing, and as the judgment, s also the conscience may be erroneous. Therefore, though he that i subject to no civil law, sinneth in all he does against his conscience because he has no other rule to follow but his own reason; yet it i not so with him that lives in a commonwealth; because the law is th public conscience, by which he hath already undertaken to be guided Otherwise in such diversity, as there is of private consciences, whic are but private opinions, the commonwealth must needs be distracted and no man dare to obey the sovereign power, further than it shall see good in his own eyes."} +{"text":"It hath been also commonly taught, \"that faith and sanctity, are not t be attained by study and reason, but by supernatural inspiration o infusion.\" Which granted, I see not why any man should render a reaso of his faith; or why every Christian should not be also a prophet; o why any man should take the law of his country rather than his ow inspiration for the rule of his action. And thus we fall again in th fault of taking upon us to judge of good and evil; or to make judges o it, such private men as pretend to be supernaturally inspired, to th dissolution of all civil government. Faith comes by hearing, an hearing by those accidents which guide us into the presence of the that speak to us; which accidents are all contrived by God Almighty and yet are not supernatural, but only, for the great number of the that concur to every effect, unobservable. Faith and sanctity ar indeed not very frequent; but yet they are not miracles, but brought t pass by education, discipline, correction, and other natural ways, b which God worketh them in His elect, at such times as He thinketh fit And these three opinions, pernicious to peace and government, have i this part of the world, proceeded chiefly from the tongues and pens o unlearned divines, who joining the words of Holy Scripture together otherwise than is agreeable to reason, do what they can to make me think that sanctity and natural reason cannot stand together."} +{"text":"A fourth opinion, repugnant to the nature of a commonwealth, is this \"that he that hath the sovereign power is subject to the civil laws.\ It is true, that sovereigns are all subject to the laws of Nature because such laws be divine, and cannot by any man or commonwealth b abrogated. But to those laws which the sovereign himself, that is which the commonwealth maketh, he is not subject. For to be subject t laws is to be subject to the commonwealth, that is to the sovereig representative, that is to himself; which is not subjection, bu freedom from the laws. Which error, because it setteth the laws abov the sovereign, setteth also a judge above him and a power to punis him; which is to make a new sovereign; and again for the same reason third, to punish the second; and so continually without end, to th confusion and dissolution of the commonwealth."} +{"text":"A fifth doctrine that tendeth to the dissolution of a commonwealth is \"that every private man has an absolute propriety in his goods; such a excludeth the right of the sovereign.\" Every man has indeed a propriet that excludes the right of every other subject: and he has it only fro the sovereign power; without the protection whereof every other ma should have equal right to the same. But if the right of the sovereig also be excluded, he cannot perform the office they have put him into which is, to defend them both from foreign enemies, and from th injuries of one another; and consequently there is no longer commonwealth."} +{"text":"And if the propriety of subjects exclude not the right of the sovereig representative to their goods; much less to their offices of judicatur or execution, in which they represent the sovereign himself."} +{"text":"There is a sixth doctrine plainly and directly against the essence of commonwealth; and it is this, \"that the sovereign power may b divided.\" For what is it to divide the power of a commonwealth, but t dissolve it; for powers divided mutually destroy each other. And fo these doctrines men are chiefly beholding to some of those that makin profession of the laws, endeavour to make them depend upon their ow learning, and not upon the legislative power."} +{"text":"And as false doctrine, so also oftentimes the example of differen government in a neighbouring nation, disposeth men to alteration of th form already settled. So the people of the Jews were stirred up t reject God, and to call upon the prophet Samuel for a king after th manner of the nations: so also the lesser cities of Greece wer continually disturbed with seditions of the aristocratical an democratical factions; one part of almost every commonwealth desirin to imitate the Lacedemonians; the other the Athenians. And I doubt no but many men have been contented to see the late troubles in Englan out of an imitation of the Low Countries; supposing there needed n more to grow rich than to change, as they had done, the form of thei government. For the constitution of man's nature is of itself subjec to desire novelty. When therefore they are provoked to the same by th neighbourhood also of those that have been enriched by it, it is almos impossible for them not to be content with those that solicit them t change; and love the first beginnings, though they be grieved with th continuance of disorder; like hot bloods, that having gotten the itch tear themselves with their own nails, till they can endure the smart n longer."} +{"text":"And as to rebellion in particular against monarchy; one of the mos frequent causes of it is the reading of the books of policy an histories of the ancient Greeks and Romans; from which young men, an all others that are unprovided of the antidote of solid reason receiving a strong and delightful impression of the great exploits o war, achieved by the conductors of their armies, receive withal pleasing idea of all they have done besides; and imagine their grea prosperity, not to have proceeded from the emulation of particular men but from the virtue of their popular form of government: no considering the frequent seditions, and civil wars, produced by th imperfection of their policy. From the reading, I say, of such books men have undertaken to kill their kings, because the Greek and Lati writers, in their books and discourses of policy, make it lawful an laudable for any man so to do; provided, before he do it, he call hi tyrant. For they say not \"regicide,\" that is, killing a king, bu \"tyrannicide,\" that is, killing of a tyrant is lawful. From the sam books, they that live under a monarch conceive an opinion, that th subjects in a popular commonwealth enjoy liberty; but that in monarchy they are all slaves. I say, they that live under a monarch conceive such an opinion; not they that live under a popula government: for they find no such matter. In sum, I cannot imagine ho anything can be more prejudicial to a monarchy than the allowing o such books to be publicly read, without present applying suc correctives of discreet masters, as are fit to take away their venom which venom I will not doubt to compare to the biting of a mad dog which is a disease the physicians call \"hydrophobia,\" or \"fear o water.\" For as he that is so bitten has a continual torment of thirst and yet abhorreth water; and is in such an estate, as if the poiso endeavoured to convert him into a dog: so when a monarchy is onc bitten to the quick by those democratical writers, that continuall snarl at that estate; it wanteth nothing more than a strong monarch which nevertheless out of a certain \"tyrannophobia,\" or fear of bein strongly governed, when they have him, they abhor."} +{"text":"As there have been doctors that hold there be three souls in a man; s there be also that think there may be more souls, that is, mor sovereigns, than one in a commonwealth; and set up a \"supremacy\ against the \"sovereignty\"; \"canons\" against \"laws\"; and a \"ghostl authority\" against the \"civil\"; working on men's minds with words an distinctions, that of themselves signify nothing, but bewray by thei obscurity; that there walketh, as some think, invisibly anothe kingdom, as it were a kingdom of fairies, in the dark. Now seeing it i manifest that the civil power and the power of the commonwealth is th same thing; and that supremacy, and the power of making canons, an granting faculties, implieth a commonwealth; it followeth that wher one is sovereign, another supreme; where one can make laws, and anothe make canons; there must needs be two commonwealths, of one and the sam subjects; which is a kingdom divided in itself, and cannot stand. Fo notwithstanding the insignificant distinction of \"temporal\" an \"ghostly,\" they are still two kingdoms, and every subject is subject t two masters. For seeing the \"ghostly\" power challengeth the right t declare what is sin, it challengeth by consequence to declare what i law, sin being nothing but the transgression of the law; and again, th civil power challenging to declare what is law, every subject must obe two masters, who both will have their commands be observed as law which is impossible. Or, if it be but one kingdom, either the \"civil,\ which is the power of the commonwealth, must be subordinate to th \"ghostly,\" and then there is no sovereignty but the \"ghostly\"; or th \"ghostly\" must be subordinate to the \"temporal,\" and then there is n \"supremacy\" but the \"temporal.\" When therefore these two powers oppos one another, the commonwealth cannot but be in great danger of civi war and dissolution. For the \"civil\" authority being more visible, an standing in the clearer light of natural reason, cannot choose but dra to it in all times a very considerable part of the people: and th \"spiritual,\" though it stand in the darkness of school distinctions and hard words, yet because the fear of darkness and ghosts is greate than other fears, cannot want a party sufficient to trouble, an sometimes to destroy a commonwealth. And this is a disease which no unfitly may be compared to the epilepsy, or falling sickness, which th Jews took to be one kind of possession by spirits, in the body natural For as in this disease, there is an unnatural spirit, or wind in th head that obstructeth the roots of the nerves, and moving the violently, taketh away the motion which naturally they should have fro the power of the soul in the brain, and thereby causeth violent an irregular motions which men call convulsions in the parts; insomuch a he that is seized therewith, falleth down sometimes into the water, an sometimes into the fire, as a man deprived of his senses; so also i the body politic, when the spiritual power moveth the members of commonwealth, by the terror of punishments and hope of rewards, whic are the nerves of it, otherwise than by the civil power, which is th soul of the commonwealth, they ought to be moved; and by strange an hard words suffocate their understanding, it must needs thereb distract the people, and either overwhelm the commonwealth wit oppression, or cast it into the fire of a civil war."} +{"text":"Sometimes also in the merely civil government, there be more than on soul; as when the power of levying money, which is the nutritiv faculty, has depended on a general assembly; the power of conduct an command, which is the motive faculty, on one man; and the power o making laws, which is the rational faculty, on the accidental consent not only of those two, but also of a third; this endangereth th commonwealth, sometimes for want of consent to good laws, but mos often for want of such nourishment as is necessary to life and motion For although few perceive that such government is not government, bu division of the commonwealth into three factions, and call it mixe monarchy; yet the truth is that it is not one independent commonwealth but three independent factions; nor one representative person, bu three. In the kingdom of God, there may be three persons independent without breach of unity in God that reigneth; but where men reign tha be subject to diversity of opinions, it cannot be so. And therefore i the king bear the person of the people, and the general assembly bea also the person of the people, and another assembly bear the person o a part of the people, they are not one person, nor one sovereign, bu three persons, and three sovereigns."} +{"text":"To what disease in the natural body of man I may exactly compare thi irregularity of a commonwealth, I know not. But I have seen a man, tha had another man growing out of his side, with a head, arms, breast an stomach of his own; if he had had another man growing out of his othe side, the comparison might then have been exact."} +{"text":"Hitherto I have named such diseases of a commonwealth as are of th greatest and most present danger. There be other not so great, whic nevertheless are not unfit to be observed. As first, the difficulty o raising money for the necessary uses of the commonwealth, especially i the approach of war. This difficulty ariseth from the opinion tha every subject hath a propriety in his lands and goods, exclusive of th sovereign's right to the use of the same. From whence it cometh to pas that the sovereign power, which foreseeth the necessities and danger of the commonwealth, finding the passage of money to the publi treasury obstructed by the tenacity of the people, whereas it ought t extend itself to encounter and prevent such dangers in thei beginnings, contracteth itself as long as it can, and when it canno longer, struggles with the people by stratagems of law, to obtai little sums, which not sufficing, he is fain at last violently to ope the way for present supply, or perish; and being put often to thes extremities, at last reduceth the people to their due temper, or els the commonwealth must perish. Insomuch as we may compare this distempe very aptly to an ague, wherein, the fleshy parts being congealed, or b venomous matter obstructed, the veins which by their natural cours empty themselves into the heart, are not, as they ought to be, supplie from the arteries, whereby there succeedeth at first a cold contractio and trembling of the limbs; and afterward a hot and strong endeavour o the heart, to force a passage for the blood; and before it can do that contenteth itself with the small refreshments of such things as coo for a time, till, if nature be strong enough, it break at last th contumacy of the parts obstructed, and dissipateth the venom int sweat; or, if nature be too weak, the patient dieth."} +{"text":"Again, there is sometimes in a commonwealth, a disease which resemblet the pleurisy; and that is, when the treasure of the commonwealth flowing out of its due course, is gathered together in too muc abundance, in one or a few private men, by monopolies or by farms o the public revenues; in the same manner as the blood in a pleurisy getting into the membrane of the breast, breedeth there a inflammation, accompanied with a fever and painful stitches."} +{"text":"Also the popularity of a potent subject, unless the commonwealth hav very good caution of his fidelity, is a dangerous disease; because th people which should receive their motion from the authority of th sovereign, by the flattery and by the reputation of an ambitious ma are drawn away from their obedience to the laws, to follow a man, o whose virtues and designs they have no knowledge. And this is commonl of more danger in a popular government than in a monarchy; because a army is of so great force and multitude, as it may easily be mad believe they are the people. By this means it was that Julius Caesar who was set up by the people against the senate, having won to himsel the affections of his army, made himself master both of senate an people. And this proceeding of popular and ambitious men, is plai rebellion; and may be resembled to the effects of witchcraft."} +{"text":"Another infirmity of a commonwealth is the immoderate greatness of town, when it is able to furnish out of its own circuit the number an expense of a great army: as also the great number of corporations which are as it were many lesser commonwealths in the bowels of greater, like worms in the entrails of a natural man. To which may b added the liberty of disputing against absolute power, by pretenders t political prudence; which though bred for the most part in the lees o the people, yet animated by false doctrines, are perpetually meddlin with the fundamental laws, to the molestation of the commonwealth; lik the little worms, which physicians call \"ascarides.\""} +{"text":"We may further add, the insatiable appetite, or bouli�ia, of enlargin dominion; with the incurable \"wounds\" thereby many times received fro the enemy; and the \"wens\" of ununited conquests, which are many times burden, and with less danger lost than kept: as also the \"lethargy\" o ease and \"consumption\" of riot and vain expense."} +{"text":"Lastly, when in a war, foreign or intestine, the enemies get a fina victory; so as, the forces of the commonwealth keeping the field n longer, there is no further protection of subjects in their loyalty then is the commonwealth \"dissolved,\" and every man at liberty t protect himself by such courses as his own discretion shall sugges unto him. For the sovereign is the public soul, giving life and motio to the commonwealth; which expiring, the members are governed by it n more, than the carcase of a man, by his departed, though immortal soul For though the right of a sovereign monarch cannot be extinguished b the act of another; yet the obligation of the members may. For he tha wants protection may seek it anywhere; and when he hath it, is obliged without fraudulent pretence of having submitted himself out of fear, t protect his protection as long as he is able. But when the power of a assembly is once suppressed, the right of the same perisheth utterly because the assembly itself is extinct; and consequently there is n possibility for the sovereignty to re-enter."} +{"text":"XX"} +{"text":"Of the Office of the Sovereign Representative"} +{"text":"The office of the sovereign, be it a monarch or an assembly, consistet in the end for which he was trusted with the sovereign power, namely the procuration of \"the safety of the people\"; to which he is oblige by the law of Nature, and to render an account thereof to God, th author of that law, and to none but Him. But by safety here, is no meant a bare preservation, but also all other contentments of life which every man by lawful industry, without danger or hurt to th commonwealth, shall acquire to himself."} +{"text":"And this is intended should be done, not by care applied t individuals, further than their protection from injuries when the shall complain; but by a general providence contained in publi instruction, both of doctrine and example; and in the making an executing of good laws, to which individual persons may apply their ow cases."} +{"text":"And because, if the essential rights of sovereignty, specified befor in the eighteenth chapter, be taken away, the commonwealth is thereb dissolved, and every man returneth into the condition and calamity of war with every other man, which is the greatest evil that can happen i this life; it is the office of the sovereign to maintain those right entire; and consequently against his duty, first, to transfer t another, or to lay from himself any of them. For he that deserteth th means, deserteth the ends; and he deserteth the means, that being th sovereign, acknowledgeth himself subject to the civil laws; an renounceth the power of supreme judicature, or of making war or peac by his own authority; or of judging of the necessities of th commonwealth; or of levying money and soldiers, when, and as much as i his own conscience he shall judge necessary; or of making officers, an ministers both of war and peace; or of appointing teachers, an examining what doctrines are conformable or contrary to the defence peace, and good of the people. Secondly, it is against his duty to le the people be ignorant, or misinformed of the grounds and reasons o those his essential rights; because thereby men are easy to be seduced and drawn to resist him, when the commonwealth shall require their us and exercise."} +{"text":"And the grounds of these rights have the rather need to be diligentl and truly taught; because they cannot be maintained by any civil law or terror of legal punishment. For a civil law that shall forbi rebellion, (and such is all resistance to the essential rights of th sovereignty,) is not, as a civil law, any obligation, but by virtu only of the law of Nature, that forbiddeth the violation of faith which natural obligation, if men know not, they cannot know the righ of any law the sovereign maketh. And for the punishment, they take i but for an act of hostility; which when they think they have strengt enough, they will endeavour by acts of hostility to avoid."} +{"text":"As I have heard some say, that justice is but a word, withou substance; and that whatsoever a man can by force or art acquire t himself, not only in the condition of war, but also in a commonwealth is his own, which I have already showed to be false: so there be als that maintain, that there are no grounds, nor principles of reason, t sustain those essential rights which make sovereignty absolute. For i there were, they would have been found out in some place or other whereas we see there has not hitherto been any commonwealth, wher those rights have been acknowledged or challenged. Wherein they argu as ill, as if the savage people of America should deny there were an grounds, or principles of reason, so to build a house as to last a long as the materials, because they never yet saw any so well built Time and industry produce every day new knowledge. And as the art o well building is derived from principles of reason, observed b industrious men, that had long studied the nature of materials, and th divers effects of figure and proportion, long after mankind began though poorly, to build; so, long time after men have begun t constitute commonwealths, imperfect, and apt to relapse into disorder there may principles of reason be found out, by industrious meditation to make their constitution, excepting by external violence everlasting. And such are those which I have in this discourse se forth: which whether they come not into the sight of those that hav power to make use of them, or be neglected by them, or not, concernet my particular interests, at this day, very little. But supposing tha these of mine are not such principles of reason; yet I am sure they ar principles from authority of Scripture; as I shall make it appear, whe I shall come to speak of the kingdom of God, administered by Moses over the Jews, His peculiar people by covenant."} +{"text":"But they say again, that though the principles be right, yet commo people are not of capacity enough to be made to understand them. should be glad that the rich and potent subjects of a kingdom, or thos that are accounted the most learned, were no less incapable than they But all men know that the obstructions to this kind of doctrin proceed, not so much from the difficulty of the matter as from th interest of them that are to learn. Potent men digest hardly anythin that setteth up a power to bridle their affections; and learned me anything that discovereth their errors, and thereby lesseneth thei authority: whereas the common people's minds, unless they be tainte with dependence on the potent, or scribbled over with the opinions o their doctors, are like clean paper, fit to receive whatsoever b public authority shall be imprinted in them. Shall whole nations b brought to \"acquiesce\" in the great mysteries of the Christia religion, which are above reason, and millions of men be made believ that the same body may be in innumerable places at one and the sam time, which is against reason, and shall not men be able, by thei teaching and preaching, protected by the law, to make that receive which is so consonant to reason, that any unprejudicated man needs n more to learn it than to hear it? I conclude therefore that in th instruction of the people in the essential rights which are the natura and fundamental laws of sovereignty there is no difficulty, whilst sovereign has his power entire, but what proceeds from his own fault or the fault of those whom he trusteth in the administration of th commonwealth; and consequently it is his duty to cause them so to b instructed; and not only his duty, but his benefit also, and securit against the danger that may arrive to himself in his natural perso from rebellion."} +{"text":"And to descend to particulars, the people are to be taught, first, tha they ought not to be in love with any form of government they see i their neighbour nations more than with their own, nor whatsoeve present prosperity they behold in nations that are otherwise governe than they, to desire change. For the prosperity of a people ruled by a aristocratical or democratical assembly, cometh not from aristocrac nor from democracy, but from the obedience and concord of the subjects nor do the people flourish in a monarchy because one man has the righ to rule them, but because they obey him. Take away in any kind of stat the obedience, and consequently the concord of the people, and the shall not only not flourish, but in short time be dissolved. And the that go about by disobedience to do no more than reform th commonwealth, shall find they do thereby destroy it; like the foolis daughters of Peleus, in the fable; which desiring to renew the youth o their decrepid father, did by the counsel of Medea cut him in pieces and boil him, together with strange herbs, but made not of him a ne man. This desire of change is like the breach of the first of God' commandments: for there God says, Non habebis Deos alienos; Thou shal not have the gods of other nations; and in another place concernin \"kings,\" that they are \"gods.\""} +{"text":"Secondly, they are to be taught that they ought not to be led wit admiration of the virtue of any of their fellow-subjects, how hig soever he stand, or how conspicuously soever he shine in th commonwealth; nor of any assembly, except the sovereign assembly, so a to defer to them any obedience, or honour, appropriate to the sovereig only, whom, in their particular stations, they represent; nor t receive any influence from them, but such as is conveyed by them fro the sovereign authority. For that sovereign cannot be imagined to lov his people as he ought, that is not jealous of them, but suffers the by the flattery of popular men to be seduced from their loyalty, a they have often been, not only secretly, but openly, so as to proclai marriage with them in facie ecclesiae by preachers, and by publishin the same in the open streets, which may fitly be compared to th violation of the second of the ten commandments."} +{"text":"Thirdly, in consequence to this, they ought to be informed how great fault it is to speak evil of the sovereign representative, whether on man, or an assembly of men; or to argue and dispute his power, or an way to use his name irreverently, whereby he may be brought int contempt with his people, and their obedience, in which the safety o the commonwealth consisteth, slackened. Which doctrine the thir commandment by resemblance pointeth to."} +{"text":"Fourthly, seeing people cannot be taught this, nor when it is taught remember it, nor after one generation past, so much as know in whom th sovereign power is placed, without setting apart from their ordinar labour, some certain times, in which they may attend those that ar appointed to instruct them; it is necessary that some such times b determined, wherein they may assemble together, and, after prayers an praises given to God, the Sovereign of sovereigns, hear those thei duties told them, and the positive laws, such as generally concern the all, read and expounded, and be put in mind of the authority tha maketh them laws. To this end had the Jews every seventh day a sabbath in which the law was read and expounded; and in the solemnity whereo they were put in mind that their king was God; that having created th world in six days, He rested the seventh day; and by their resting o it from their labour, that that God was their king, which redeemed the from their servile and painful labour in Egypt, and gave them a time after they had rejoiced in God, to take joy also in themselves b lawful recreation. So that the first table of the commandments is spen all in setting down the sum of God's absolute power, not only as God but as king by pact in peculiar of the Jews; and may therefore giv light to those that have sovereign power conferred on them by th consent of men, to see what doctrine they ought to teach thei subjects."} +{"text":"And because the first instruction of children dependeth on the care o their parents, it is necessary that they should be obedient to the whilst they are under their tuition; and not only so, but that als afterwards, as gratitude requireth, they acknowledge the benefit o their education by external signs of honour. To which end they are t be taught that originally the father of every man was also hi sovereign lord, with power over him of life and death; and that th fathers of families, when by instituting a commonwealth, they resigne that absolute power, yet it was never intended they should lose th honour due unto them for their education. For to relinquish such righ was not necessary to the institution of sovereign power; nor woul there be any reason why any man should desire to have children, or tak the care to nourish and instruct them, if they were afterwards to hav no other benefit from them than from other men. And this accordeth wit the fifth commandment."} +{"text":"Again, every sovereign ought to cause justice to be taught, which consisting in taking from no man what is his, is as much as to say, t cause men to be taught not to deprive their neighbours, by violence o fraud, of anything which by the sovereign authority is theirs. O things held in propriety, those that are dearest to a man are his ow life and limbs; and in the next degree, in most men, those that concer conjugal affection; and after them, riches and means of living Therefore the people are to be taught to abstain from violence to on another's person, by private revenges; from violation of conjuga honour; and from forcible rapine and fraudulent surreption of on another's goods. For which purpose also it is necessary they be showe the evil consequences of false judgment, by corruption either of judge or witnesses, whereby the distinction of propriety is taken away, an justice becomes of no effect: all which things are intimated in th sixth, seventh, eighth, and ninth commandments."} +{"text":"Lastly, they are to be taught that not only the unjust facts, but th designs and intentions to do them, though by accident hindered, ar injustice; which consisteth in the pravity of the will, as well as i the irregularity of the act. And this is the intention of the tent commandment, and the sum of the second table; which is reduced all t this one commandment of mutual charity, \"thou shalt love thy neighbou as thyself\": as the sum of the first table is reduced to \"the love o God\"; whom they had then newly received as their king."} +{"text":"As for the means and conduits, by which the people may receive thi instruction, we are to search by what means so many opinions, contrar to the peace of mankind, upon weak and false principles, hav nevertheless been so deeply rooted in them. I mean those which I hav in the precedent chapter specified: as that men shall judge of what i lawful and unlawful, not by the law itself, but by their ow consciences; that is to say, by their own private judgments: tha subjects sin in obeying the commands of the commonwealth, unless the themselves have first judged them to be lawful: that their propriety i their riches is such, as to exclude the dominion which the commonwealt hath over the same: that it is lawful for subjects to kill such as the call tyrants: that the sovereign power may be divided, and the like which come to be instilled into the people by this means. They who necessity or covetousness keepeth attent on their trades and labour and they, on the other side, whom superfluity or sloth carrieth afte their sensual pleasures; which two sorts of men take up the greates part of mankind; being diverted from the deep meditation, which th learning of truth, not only in the matter of natural justice, but als of all other sciences necessarily requireth, receive the notions o their duty, chiefly from divines in the pulpit, and partly from such o their neighbours or familiar acquaintance, as having the faculty o discoursing readily and plausibly, seem wiser and better learned i cases of law and conscience, than themselves. And the divines and suc others as make show of learning, derive their knowledge from th universities, and from the schools of law, or from the books, which b men, eminent in those schools and universities, have been published. I is therefore manifest that the instruction of the people dependet wholly on the right teaching of youth in the universities. But are not may some man say, the universities of England learned enough already t do that? or is it you will undertake to teach the universities? Har questions. Yet to the first I doubt not to answer; that till toward the latter end of Henry the Eighth, the power of the Pope was alway upheld against the power of the commonwealth, principally by th universities; and that the doctrines maintained by so many preacher against the sovereign power of the king, and by so many lawyers an others that had their education there, is a sufficient argument, tha though the universities were not authors of those false doctrines, ye they knew not how to plant the true. For in such a contradiction o opinions, it is most certain that they have not been sufficientl instructed; and it is no wonder if they yet retain a relish of tha subtle liquor, wherewith they were first seasoned, against the civi authority. But to the latter question it is not fit nor needful for m to say either aye or no: for any man that sees what I am doing, ma easily perceive what I think."} +{"text":"The safety of the people requireth further, from him or them that hav the sovereign power, that justice be equally administered to al degrees of people; that is, that as well the rich and mighty, as poo and obscure persons, may be righted of the injuries done them; so a the great may have no greater hope of impunity, when they do violence dishonour, or any injury to the meaner sort, than when one of thes does the like to one of them: for in this consisteth equity; to which as being a precept of the law of Nature, a sovereign is as much subjec as any of the meanest of his people. All breaches of the law ar offences against the commonwealth: but there be some that are als against private persons. Those that concern the commonwealth only ma without breach of equity be pardoned, for every man may pardon what i done against himself, according to his own discretion. But an offenc against a private man cannot in equity be pardoned, without the consen of him that is injured, or reasonable satisfaction."} +{"text":"The inequality of subjects proceedeth from the acts of sovereign power and therefore has no more place in the presence of the sovereign, tha is to say, in a court of justice, than the inequality between kings an their subjects, in the presence of the King of kings. The honour o great persons is to be valued for their beneficence and the aids the give to men of inferior rank, or not at all. And the violences oppressions, and injuries they do, are not extenuated, but aggravate by the greatness of their persons; because they have least need t commit them. The consequences of this partiality towards the great proceed in this manner. Impunity maketh insolence; insolence, hatred and hatred, an endeavour to pull down all oppressing and contumeliou greatness, though with the ruin of the commonwealth."} +{"text":"To equal justice appertaineth also the equal imposition of taxes; th equality whereof dependeth not on the equality of riches, but on th equality of the debt that every man oweth to the commonwealth for hi defence. It is not enough for a man to labour for the maintenance o his life; but also to fight, if need be, for the securing of hi labour. They must either do as the Jews did after their return fro captivity, in re-edifying the temple, build with one hand, and hold th sword in the other; or else they must hire others to fight for them For the impositions that are laid on the people by the sovereign power are nothing else but the wages due to them that hold the public swor to defend private men in the exercise of their several trades an callings. Seeing then the benefit that everyone receiveth thereby, i the enjoyment of life, which is equally dear to poor and rich; the deb which a poor man oweth them that defend his life, is the same which rich man oweth for the defence of his; saving that the rich, who hav the service of the poor, may be debtors not only for their own person but for many more. Which considered, the equality of imposition consisteth rather in the equality of that which is consumed than of th riches of the persons that consume the same. For what reason is ther that he which laboureth much, and sparing the fruits of his labour consumeth little, should be more charged than he that living idly getteth little, and spendeth all he gets; seeing the one hath no mor protection from the commonwealth than the other? But when th impositions are laid upon those things which men consume, every ma payeth equally for what he useth: nor is the commonwealth defrauded b the luxurious waste of private men."} +{"text":"And whereas many men, by accident inevitable, become unable to maintai themselves by their labour; they ought not to be left to the charity o private persons; but to be provided for, as far forth as th necessities of nature require by the laws of the commonwealth. For a it is uncharitableness in any man to neglect the impotent; so it is i the sovereign of a commonwealth to expose them to the hazard of suc uncertain charity."} +{"text":"But for such as have strong bodies, the case is otherwise: they are t be forced to work: and to avoid the excuse of not finding employment there ought to be such laws as may encourage all manner of arts, a navigation, agriculture, fishing, and all manner of manufacture tha requires labour. The multitude of poor and yet strong people stil increasing, they are to be transplanted into countries not sufficientl inhabited: where nevertheless, they are not to exterminate those the find there; but constrain them to inhabit closer together, and not t range a great deal of ground to snatch what they find; but to cour each little plot with art and labour, to give them their sustenance i due season. And when all the world is overcharged with inhabitants then the last remedy of all is war; which provideth for every man, b victory or death."} +{"text":"To the care of the sovereign belongeth the making of good laws. Bu what is a good law? By a good law I mean not a just law, for no law ca be unjust. The law is made by the sovereign power, and all that is don by such power is warranted and owned by every one of the people; an that which every man will have so, no man can say is unjust. It is i the laws of a commonwealth as in the laws of gaming: whatsoever th gamesters all agree on, is injustice to none of them. A good law i that which is \"needful\" for the \"good of the people,\" and witha \"perspicuous.\""} +{"text":"For the use of laws, which are but rules authorized, is not to bind th people from all voluntary actions; but to direct and keep them in suc a motion as not to hurt themselves by their own impetuous desires rashness, or indiscretion; as hedges are set, not to stop travellers but to keep them in their way. And therefore a law that is not needful having not the true end of a law, is not good. A law may be conceive to be good, when it is for the benefit of the sovereign; though it b not necessary for the people; but it is not so. For the good of th sovereign and people cannot be separated. It is a weak sovereign tha has weak subjects; and a weak people, whose sovereign wanteth power t rule them at his will. Unnecessary laws are not good laws; but trap for money: which where the right of sovereign power is acknowledged are superfluous; and where it is not acknowledged, insufficient t defend the people."} +{"text":"The perspicuity consisteth not so much in the words of the law itself as in a declaration of the causes and motives for which it was made That is it that shows the meaning of the legislator; and the meaning o the legislator known, the law is more easily understood by few tha many words. For all words are subject to ambiguity; and therefor multiplication of words in the body of the law is multiplication o ambiguity: besides it seems to imply, by too much diligence, tha whosoever can evade the words, is without the compass of the law. An this is a cause of many unnecessary processes. For when I consider ho short were the laws of ancient times, and how they grew by degree still longer, methinks I see a contention between the penners an pleaders of the law; the former seeking to circumscribe the latter, an the latter to evade their circumscriptions, and that the pleaders hav got the victory. It belongeth therefore to the office of a legislato (such as is in all commonwealths the supreme representative, be it on man or an assembly) to make the reason perspicuous why the law wa made; and the body of the law itself as short, but in as proper an significant terms, as may be."} +{"text":"It belongeth also to the office of the sovereign to make a righ application of punishments and rewards. And seeing the end of punishin is not revenge and discharge of choler; but correction either of th offender or of others by his example; the severest punishments are t be inflicted for those crimes that are of most danger to the public such as are those which proceed from malice to the governmen established; those that spring from contempt of justice; those tha provoke indignation in the multitude; and those, which unpunished, see authorized, as when they are committed by sons, servants, or favourite of men in authority. For indignation carrieth men not only against th actors and authors of injustice; but against all power that is likel to protect them; as in the case of Tarquin; when for the insolent ac of one of his sons, he was driven out of Rome, and the monarchy itsel dissolved. But crimes of infirmity, such as are those which procee from great provocation, from great fear, great need, or from ignoranc whether the fact be a great crime or not, there is place many times fo lenity, without prejudice to the commonwealth; and lenity, when ther is such place for it, is required by the law of Nature. The punishmen of the leaders and teachers in a commotion, not the poor seduce people, when they are punished, can profit the commonwealth by thei example. To be severe to the people, is to punish that ignorance whic may in great part be imputed to the sovereign, whose fault it was tha they were no better instructed."} +{"text":"In like manner it belongeth to the office and duty of the sovereign, t apply his rewards always so, as there may arise from them benefit t the commonwealth; wherein consisteth their use and end; and is the done, when they that have well served the commonwealth, are with a little expense of the common treasure as is possible, so wel recompensed as others thereby may be encouraged, both to serve the sam as faithfully as they can, and to study the arts by which they may b enabled to do it better. To buy with money, or preferment, from popular ambitious subject, to be quiet and desist from making il impressions in the minds of the people, has nothing of the nature o reward; (which is ordained not for disservice, but for service past; nor a sign of gratitude, but of fear; nor does it tend to the benefit but to the damage of the public. It is a contention with ambition, lik that of Hercules with the monster Hydra, which having many heads, fo every one that was vanquished, there grew up three. For in like manner when the stubbornness of one popular man is overcome with reward, ther arise many more by the example, that do the same mischief in hope o like benefit: and as all sorts of manufacture, so also malic increaseth by being vendible. And though sometimes a civil war may b deferred by such ways as that, yet the danger grows still the greater and the public ruin more assured. It is therefore against the duty o the sovereign, to whom the public safety is committed, to reward thos that aspire to greatness by disturbing the peace of their country, an not rather to oppose the beginnings of such men with a little danger than after a longer time with greater."} +{"text":"Another business of the sovereign, is to choose good counsellors; mean such, whose advice he is to take in the government of th commonwealth. For this word counsel, consilium, corrupted fro considium, is of a large signification, and comprehendeth al assemblies of men that sit together, not only to deliberate what is t be done hereafter, but also to judge of facts past, and of law for th present. I take it here in the first sense only: and in this sense there is no choice of counsel, neither in a democracy nor aristocracy because the persons counselling are members of the person counselled The choice of counsellors therefore is proper to monarchy; in which the sovereign that endeavoureth not to make choice of those that i every kind are the most able, dischargeth not his office as he ought t do. The most able counsellors are they that have least hope of benefi by giving evil counsel, and most knowledge of those things that conduc to the peace and defence of the commonwealth. It is a hard matter t know who expecteth benefit from public troubles; but the signs tha guide to a just suspicion is the soothing of the people in thei unreasonable or irremediable grievances, by men whose estates are no sufficient to discharge their accustomed expenses, and may easily b observed by anyone whom it concerns to know it. But to know who ha most knowledge of the public affairs, is yet harder; and they that kno them, need them a great deal the less. For to know who knows the rule almost of any art, is a great degree of the knowledge of the same art because no man can be assured of the truth of another's rules, but h that is first taught to understand them. But the best signs o knowledge of any art, are, much conversing in it, and constant goo effects of it. Good counsel comes not by lot, nor by inheritance; an therefore there is no more reason to expect good advice from the ric or noble, in matter of state, than in delineating the dimensions of fortress; unless we shall think there needs no method in the study o the politics, as there does in the study of geometry, but only to b lookers-on; which is not so. For the politics is the harder study o the two. Whereas in these parts of Europe, it hath been taken for right of certain persons, to have place in the highest council of stat by inheritance; it is derived from the conquests of the ancien Germans; wherein many absolute lords joining together to conquer othe nations, would not enter into the confederacy, without such privilege as might be marks of difference in time following, between thei posterity and the posterity of their subjects; which privileges bein inconsistent with the sovereign power, by the favour of the sovereign they may seem to keep; but contending for them as their right, the must needs by degrees let them go, and have at last no further honou than adhereth naturally to their abilities."} +{"text":"And how able soever be the counsellors in any affair, the benefit o their counsel is greater when they give everyone his advice and th reasons of it apart, than when they do it in an assembly, by way o orations; and when they have premeditated, than when they speak on th sudden; both because they have more time to survey the consequences o action, and are less subject to be carried away to contradiction through envy, emulation, or other passions arising from the differenc of opinion."} +{"text":"The best counsel in those things that concern not other nations, bu only the ease and benefit the subjects may enjoy, by laws that loo only inward, is to be taken from the general informations an complaints of the people of each province, who are best acquainted wit their own wants, and ought therefore, when they demand nothing i derogation of the essential rights of sovereignty, to be diligentl taken notice of. For without those essential rights, as I have ofte before said, the commonwealth cannot at all subsist."} +{"text":"A commander of an army in chief, if he be not popular, shall not b beloved nor feared as he ought to be by his army, and consequentl cannot perform that office with good success. He must therefore b industrious, valiant, affable, liberal, and fortunate, that he may gai an opinion both of sufficiency, and of loving his soldiers. This i popularity, and breeds in the soldiers both desire and courage t recommend themselves to his favour, and protects the severity of th general in punishing, when need is, the mutinous or negligent soldiers But this love of soldiers, if caution be not given of the commander' fidelity, is a dangerous thing to sovereign power; especially when i is in the hands of an assembly not popular. It belongeth therefore t the safety of the people, both that they be good conductors an faithful subjects to whom the sovereign commits his armies."} +{"text":"But when the sovereign himself is popular; that is, reverenced an beloved of his people, there is no danger at all from the popularity o a subject. For soldiers are never so generally unjust as to side wit their captain, though they love him, against their sovereign, when the love not only his person, but also his cause. And therefore those wh by violence have at any time suppressed the power of their lawfu sovereign, before they could settle themselves in his place, have bee always put to the trouble of contriving their titles, to save th people from the shame of receiving them. To have a known right t sovereign power is so popular a quality, as he that has it needs n more, for his own part, to turn the hearts of his subjects to him, bu that they see him able absolutely to govern his own family; nor, on th part of his enemies, but a disbanding of their armies. For the greates and most active part of mankind has never hitherto been well contente with the present."} +{"text":"Concerning the offices of one sovereign to another, which ar comprehended in that law, which is commonly called the \"law o nations,\" I need not say anything in this place, because the law o nations, and the law of Nature, is the same thing. And every sovereig hath the same right, in procuring the safety of his people, that an particular man can have in procuring the safety of his own body. An the same law that dictateth to men that have no civil government, wha they ought to do, and what to avoid in regard of one another, dictatet the same to commonwealths, that is, to the consciences of sovereig princes and sovereign assemblies; there being no court of natura justice but in the conscience only: where not man, but God reigneth whose laws, such of them as oblige all mankind in respect of God, as H is the author of Nature, are \"natural\"; and in respect of the same God as He is King of kings, are \"laws.\" But of the kingdom of God, as Kin of kings, and as King also of a peculiar people, I shall speak in th rest of this discourse."} +{"text":"XXI"} +{"text":"Of the Kingdom of God by Nature"} +{"text":"That the condition of mere nature, that is to say, of absolute liberty such as is theirs that neither are sovereigns nor subjects, is anarch and the condition of war: that the precepts by which men are guided t avoid that condition are the laws of Nature: that a commonwealth without sovereign power, is but a word without substance, and canno stand: that subjects owe to sovereigns simple obedience, in all thing wherein their obedience is not repugnant to the laws of God, I hav sufficiently proved in that which I have already written. There want only, for the entire knowledge of civil duty, to know what are thos laws of God. For without that a man knows not, when he is commande anything by the civil power, whether it be contrary to the law of Go or not: and so, either by too much civil obedience, offends the Divin Majesty; or through fear of offending God, transgresses th commandments of the commonwealth. To avoid both these rocks, it i necessary to know what are the laws divine. And seeing the knowledge o all law dependeth on the knowledge of the sovereign power, I shall sa something, in that which followeth, of the \"Kingdom of God.\""} +{"text":"\"God is king, let the earth rejoice,\" saith the Psalmist (97:1). An again (Psalm 99:1): \"God is king, though the nations be angry; and h that sitteth on the cherubims, though the earth be moved.\" Whether me will or not, they must be subject always to the divine power. B denying the existence or providence of God, men may shake off thei ease, but not their yoke. But to call this power of God, whic extendeth itself not only to man, but also to beasts and plants an bodies inanimate, by the name of kingdom, is but a metaphorical use o the word. For he only is properly said to reign that governs hi subjects by his word, and by promise of rewards to those that obey it and by threatening them with punishment that obey it not. Subject therefore in the kingdom of God are not bodies inanimate nor creature irrational; because they understand no precepts as His: nor atheists nor they that believe not that God has any care of the actions o mankind; because they acknowledge no word for His, nor have hope of Hi rewards or fear of His threatenings. They therefore that believe ther is a God that governeth the world, and hath given precepts, an propounded rewards and punishments to mankind, are God's subjects; al the rest are to be understood as enemies."} +{"text":"To rule by words, requires that such words be manifestly made known for else they are no laws: for to the nature of laws belongeth sufficient and clear promulgation, such as may take away the excuse o ignorance; which in the laws of men is but of one only kind, and tha is, proclamation or promulgation by the voice of man. But God declaret His laws three ways: by the dictates of \"natural reason,\" b \"revelation,\" and by the \"voice\" of some \"man,\" to whom by th operation of miracles he procureth credit with the rest. From henc there ariseth a triple word of God, \"rational,\" \"sensible,\" an \"prophetic\": to which correspondeth a triple hearing, \"right reason,\ \"sense supernatural,\" and \"faith.\" As for sense supernatural, whic consisteth in revelation or inspiration, there have not been an universal laws so given, because God speaketh not in that manner but t particular persons, and to divers men divers things."} +{"text":"From the difference between the other two kinds of God's word \"rational\" and \"prophetic,\" there may be attributed to God a twofol kingdom, \"natural\" and \"prophetic\": natural, wherein He governeth a many of mankind as acknowledge His providence by the natural dictate of right reason; and prophetic, wherein having chosen out one peculia nation, the Jews, for His subjects, He governed them, and none bu them, not only by natural reason, but by positive laws, which He gav them by the mouths of His holy prophets. Of the natural kingdom of Go I intend to speak in this chapter."} +{"text":"The right of nature, whereby God reigneth over men, and punisheth thos that break His laws, is to be derived not from His creating them, as i He required obedience as of gratitude for His benefits, but from Hi \"irresistible power.\" I have formerly shown how the sovereign righ ariseth from pact: to show how the same right may arise from nature requires no more but to show in what case it is never taken away Seeing all men by nature had right to all things, they had righ everyone to reign over all the rest. But because this right could no be obtained by force, it concerned the safety of everyone, laying b that right, to set up men, with sovereign authority, by common consent to rule and defend them: whereas if there had been any man of powe irresistible, there had been no reason why he should not by that powe have ruled and defended both himself and them, according to his ow discretion. To those therefore whose power is irresistible, th dominion of all men adhereth naturally by their excellence of power and consequently it is from that power that the kingdom over men, an the right of afflicting men at His pleasure, belongeth naturally to Go Almighty; not as Creator and gracious, but as omnipotent. And thoug punishment be due for sin only, because by that word is understoo affliction for sin; yet the right of afflicting is not always derive from men's sin, but from God's power."} +{"text":"This question, \"why evil men often prosper, and good men suffe adversity,\" has been much disputed by the ancient, and is the same wit this of ours, \"by what right God dispenseth the prosperities an adversities of this life\"; and is of that difficulty, as it hath shake the faith not only of the vulgar, but of philosophers, and which i more, of the saints, concerning the Divine Providence. \"How good,\ saith David (Psalm 73:1�-�3) \"is the God of Israel to those that ar upright in heart; and yet my feet were almost gone, my treadings ha well-nigh slipt: for I was grieved at the wicked, when I saw th ungodly in such prosperity.\" And Job, how earnestly does he expostulat with God for the many afflictions he suffered, notwithstanding hi righteousness? This question in the case of Job is decided by Go Himself, not by arguments derived from Job's sin, but His own power For whereas the friends of Job drew their arguments from his afflictio to his sin, and he defended himself by the conscience of his innocence God Himself taketh up the matter, and having justified the afflictio by arguments drawn from His power, such as this (Job 38:4), \"Where was thou when I laid the foundations of the earth?\" and the like, bot approved Job's innocence, and reproved the erroneous doctrine of hi friends. Conformable to this doctrine is the sentence of our Saviour concerning the man that was born blind, in these words: \"Neither hat this man sinned, nor his fathers: but that the works of God might b made manifest in him.\" And though it be said, \"that death entered int the world by sin\" (by which is meant, that if Adam had never sinned, h had never died, that is, never suffered any separation of his soul fro his body), it follows not thence, that God could not justly hav afflicted him, though he had not sinned, as well as He afflicteth othe living creatures that cannot sin."} +{"text":"Having spoken of the right of God's sovereignty, as grounded only o nature; we are to consider next, what are the Divine laws, or dictate of natural reason; which laws concern either the natural duties of on man to another, or the honour naturally due to our Divine Sovereign The first are the same laws of Nature, of which I have spoken alread in the fourteenth and fifteenth chapters of this treatise; namely equity, justice, mercy, humility, and the rest of the moral virtues. I remaineth therefore that we consider what precepts are dictated to men by their natural reason only, without other word of God, touching th honour and worship of the Divine Majesty."} +{"text":"Honour consisteth in the inward thought and opinion of the power an goodness of another; and therefore to honour God, is to think as highl of His power and goodness as is possible. And of that opinion, th external signs appearing in the words and actions of men are calle \"worship\"; which is one part of that which the Latins understand by th word cultus. For cultus signifieth properly and constantly that labou which a man bestows on anything, with a purpose to make benefit by it Now those things whereof we make benefit, are either subject to us, an the profit they yield followeth the labour we bestow upon them, as natural effect; or they are not subject to us, but answer our labour according to their own wills. In the first sense the labour bestowed o the earth is called \"culture\"; and the education of children, \"culture\" of their minds. In the second sense, where men's wills are t be wrought to our purpose, not by force, but by complaisance, i signifieth as much as courting, that is, a winning of favour by goo offices; as by praises, by acknowledging their power, and by whatsoeve is pleasing to them from whom we look for any benefit. And this i properly \"worship\": in which sense Publicola is understood for worshipper of the people; and cultus Dei, for the worship of God."} +{"text":"From internal honour, consisting in the opinion of power and goodness arise three passions; \"love,\" which hath reference to goodness; an \"hope,\" and \"fear,\" that relate to power: and three parts of externa worship; \"praise,\" \"magnifying,\" and \"blessing\": the subject of prais being goodness; the subject of magnifying and blessing being power, an the effect thereof felicity. Praise and magnifying are signified bot by words and actions: by words, when we say a man is good or great: b actions, when we thank him for his bounty, and obey his power. Th opinion of the happiness of another can only be expressed by words."} +{"text":"There be some signs of honour, both in attributes and actions, that b naturally so; as amongst attributes, \"good,\" \"just,\" \"liberal,\" and th like; and amongst actions, \"prayers,\" \"thanks,\" and \"obedience.\" Other are so by institution, or custom of men; and in some times and place are honourable; in others, dishonourable; in others, indifferent: suc as are the gestures in salutation, prayer, and thanksgiving, i different times and places, differently used. The former is \"natural\" the latter \"arbitrary\" worship."} +{"text":"And of arbitrary worship, there be two differences; for sometimes it i a \"command,\" sometimes \"voluntary\" worship: commanded, when it is suc as he requireth who is worshipped; free, when it is such as th worshipper thinks fit. When it is commanded, not the words, or gesture but the obedience is the worship. But when free, the worship consist in the opinion of the beholders: for if to them the words or actions b which we intend honour, seem ridiculous, and tending to contumely, the are no worship, because no signs of honour; and no signs of honour because a sign is not a sign to him that giveth it, but to him to who it is made, that is, to the spectator."} +{"text":"Again, there is a \"public\" and a \"private\" worship. Public, is th worship that a commonwealth performeth, as one person. Private, is tha which a private person exhibiteth. Public, in respect of the whol commonwealth, is free; but in respect of particular men, it is not so Private, is in secret free; but in the sight of the multitude, it i never without some restraint, either from the laws, or from the opinio of men; which is contrary to the nature of liberty."} +{"text":"The end of worship amongst men is power. For where a man seeth anothe worshipped, he supposeth him powerful, and is the readier to obey him which makes his power greater. But God has no ends: the worship we d Him proceeds from our duty, and is directed according to our capacity by those rules of honour that reason dictateth to be done by the wea to the more potent men, in hope of benefit, for fear of damage, or i thankfulness for good already received from them."} +{"text":"That we may know what worship of God is taught us by the light o Nature, I will begin with His attributes. Where, first, it is manifest we ought to attribute to Him \"existence.\" For no man can have the wil to honour that which he thinks not to have any being."} +{"text":"Secondly, that those philosophers who said the world, or the soul o the world, was God, spake unworthily of Him; and denied His existence For by God is understood the cause of the world; and to say the worl is God is to say there is no cause of it, that is, no God."} +{"text":"Thirdly, to say the world was not created, but eternal, seeing tha which is eternal has no cause, is to deny there is a God."} +{"text":"Fourthly, that they who attributing, as they think, ease to God, tak from Him the care of mankind; take from Him his honour: for it take away men's love, and fear of Him; which is the root of honour."} +{"text":"Fifthly, in those things that signify greatness and power; to say He i \"finite,\" is not to honour Him; for it is not a sign of the will t honour God, to attribute to Him less than we can; and finite, is les than we can; because to finite, it is easy to add more."} +{"text":"Therefore to attribute \"figure\" to Him is not honour; for all figure i finite:"} +{"text":"Nor to say we conceive, and imagine, or have an \"idea\" of Him, in ou mind: for whatsoever we conceive is finite:"} +{"text":"Nor to attribute to Him \"parts,\" or \"totality\"; which are th attributes only of things finite:"} +{"text":"Nor to say He is in this or that \"place\"; for whatsoever is in place is bounded, and finite:"} +{"text":"Nor that He is \"moved,\" or \"resteth\"; for both these attributes ascrib to Him place:"} +{"text":"Nor that there be more gods than one; because it implies them al finite: for there cannot be more than one infinite:"} +{"text":"Nor to ascribe to Him, (unless metaphorically, meaning not the passio but the effect,) passions that partake of grief; as \"repentance,\ \"anger,\" \"mercy\": or of want; as \"appetite,\" \"hope,\" \"desire\"; or o any passive faculty; for passion is power limited by somewhat else."} +{"text":"And therefore when we ascribe to God a \"will,\" it is not to b understood, as that of man, for a \"rational appetite\"; but as the powe by which He effecteth everything."} +{"text":"Likewise when we attribute to Him \"sight,\" and other acts of sense; a also \"knowledge,\" and \"understanding\"; which in us is nothing else bu a tumult of the mind, raised by external things that press th organical parts of man's body; for there is no such thing in God; an being things that depend on natural causes, cannot be attributed t Him."} +{"text":"He that will attribute to God nothing but what is warranted by natura reason, must either use such negative attributes as \"infinite,\ \"eternal,\" \"incomprehensible\"; or superlatives, as \"most high,\" \"mos great,\" and the like; or indefinite, as \"good,\" \"just,\" \"holy,\ \"creator\"; and in such sense, as if He meant not to declare what He is (for that were to circumscribe Him within the limits of our fancy,) bu how much we admire Him, and how ready we would be to obey Him; which i a sign of humility, and of a will to honour Him as much as we can. Fo there is but one name to signify our conception of His nature, and tha is, \"I am\": and but one name of His relation to us, and that is, \"God\" in which is contained Father, King, and Lord."} +{"text":"Concerning the actions of divine worship, it is a most general precep of reason, that they be signs of the intention to honour God; such a are, first, \"prayers.\" For not the carvers, when they made images, wer thought to make them gods; but the people that \"prayed\" to them."} +{"text":"Secondly, \"thanksgiving\"; which differeth from prayer in divin worship, no otherwise than that prayers precede, and thanks succeed th benefit; the end, both of the one and the other, being to acknowledg God for author of all benefits, as well past as future."} +{"text":"Thirdly, \"gifts,\" that is to say \"sacrifices\" and \"oblations,\" if the be of the best, are signs of honour: for they are thanksgivings."} +{"text":"Fourthly, \"not to swear by any but God,\" is naturally a sign of honour for it is a confession that God only knoweth the heart; and that n man's wit or strength can protect a man against God's vengeance on th perjured."} +{"text":"Fifthly, it is a part of rational worship to speak considerately o God; for it argues a fear of Him, and fear is a confession of Hi power. Hence followeth that the name of God is not to be used rashly and to no purpose; for that is as much as in vain: and it is to n purpose, unless it be by way of oath, and by order of the commonwealth to make judgments certain; or between commonwealths, to avoid war. An that disputing of God's nature is contrary to His honour: for it i supposed that in this natural kingdom of God, there is no other way t know anything but by natural reason, that is, from the principles o natural science; which are so far from teaching us anything of God' nature, as they cannot teach us our own nature, nor the nature of th smallest creature living. And therefore, when men out of the principle of natural reason, dispute of the attributes of God, they but dishonou Him: for in the attributes which we give to God, we are not to conside the signification of philosophical truth but the signification of piou intention, to do Him the greatest honour we are able. From the want o which consideration, have proceeded the volumes of disputation abou the nature of God, that tend not to His honour, but to the honour o our own wits and learning; and are nothing else but inconsiderate an vain abuses of His sacred name."} +{"text":"Sixthly, in \"prayers,\" \"thanksgivings,\" \"offerings,\" and \"sacrifices,\ it is a dictate of natural reason that they be everyone in his kind th best, and most significant of honour. As for example, that prayers an thanksgiving, be made in words and phrases, not sudden, nor light, no plebeian; but beautiful, and well composed. For else we do not God a much honour as we can. And therefore the heathens did absurdly, t worship images for gods: but their doing it in verse, and with music both of voice and instruments, was reasonable. Also that the beast they offered in sacrifice, and the gifts they offered, and thei actions in worshipping, were full of submission, and commemorative o benefits received, was according to reason, as proceeding from a intention to honour Him."} +{"text":"Seventhly, reason directeth not only to worship God in secret; bu also, and especially, in public, and in the sight of men. For withou that, that which in honour is most acceptable, the procuring others t honour Him, is lost."} +{"text":"Lastly, obedience to His laws, that is, in this case to the laws o Nature, is the greatest worship of all. For as obedience is mor acceptable to God than sacrifice; so also to set light by Hi commandments, is the greatest of all contumelies. And these are th laws of that divine worship, which natural reason dictateth to privat men."} +{"text":"But seeing a commonwealth is but one person, it ought also to exhibi to God but one worship; which then it doth, when it commandeth it to b exhibited by private men, publicly. And this is public worship; th property whereof is to be \"uniform\": for those actions that are don differently, by different men, cannot be said to be a public worship And therefore, where many sorts of worship be allowed, proceeding fro the different religions of private men, it cannot be said there is an public worship, nor that the commonwealth is of any religion at all."} +{"text":"And because words, and consequently the attributes of God, have thei signification by agreement and constitution of men, those attribute are to be held significative of honour, that men intend shall so be and whatsoever may be done by the wills of particular men, where ther is no law but reason, may be done by the will of the commonwealth, b laws civil. And because a commonwealth hath no will, nor makes no laws but those that are made by the will of him or them that have th sovereign power; it followeth that those attributes which the sovereig ordaineth, in the worship of God, for signs of honour, ought to b taken and used for such, by private men in their public worship."} +{"text":"But because not all actions are signs by constitution, but some ar naturally signs of honour, others of contumely; these latter, which ar those that men are ashamed to do in the sight of them they reverence cannot be made by human power a part of divine worship; nor the former such as are decent, modest, humble behaviour, ever be separated fro it. But whereas there be an infinite number of actions and gestures o an indifferent nature; such of them as the commonwealth shall ordain t be publicly and universally in use, as signs of honour, and part o God's worship, are to be taken and used for such by the subjects. An that which is said in the Scripture, \"It is better to obey God tha man,\" hath place in the kingdom of God by pact, and not by nature."} +{"text":"Having thus briefly spoken of the natural kingdom of God and Hi natural laws, I will add only to this chapter a short declaration o His natural punishments. There is no action of man in this life that i not the beginning of so long a chain of consequences, as no huma providence is high enough to give a man a prospect to the end. And i this chain, there are linked together both pleasing and unpleasin events; in such manner, as he that will do anything for his pleasure must engage himself to suffer all the pains annexed to it; and thes pains are the natural punishments of those actions which are th beginning of more harm than good. And hereby it comes to pass, tha intemperance is naturally punished with diseases; rashness, wit mischances; injustice, with the violence of enemies: pride, with ruin cowardice, with oppression: negligent government of princes, wit rebellion; and rebellion, with slaughter. For seeing punishments ar consequent to the breach of laws; natural punishments must be naturall consequent to the breach of the laws of Nature; and therefore follo them as their natural, not arbitrary effects."} +{"text":"And thus far concerning the constitution, nature, and right o sovereigns, and concerning the duty of subjects, derived from th principles of natural reason. And now, considering how different thi doctrine is from the practice of the greatest part of the world especially of these western parts, that have received their mora learning from Rome and Athens; and how much depth of moral philosoph is required, in them that have the administration of the sovereig power; I am at the point of believing this my labour as useless as th commonwealth of Plato. For he also is of opinion that it is impossibl for the disorders of state, and change of governments by civil war ever to be taken away, till sovereigns be philosophers. But when consider again, that the science of natural justice is the only scienc necessary for sovereigns and their principal ministers; and that the need not be charged with the sciences mathematical, as by Plato the are, farther than by good laws to encourage men to the study of them and that neither Plato, nor any other philosopher hitherto, hath pu into order, and sufficiently or probably proved all the theorems o moral doctrine, that men may learn thereby, both how to govern and ho to obey; I recover some hope, that one time or other, this writing o mine may fall into the hands of a sovereign, who will consider i himself (for it is short, and I think clear), without the help of an interested, or envious interpreter; and by the exercise of entir sovereignty, in protecting the public teaching of it, convert thi truth of speculation into the utility of practice."} +{"text":"t III"} +{"text":"Of a Christian Commonwealth"} +{"text":"XXII"} +{"text":"Of the Principles of Christian Politics"} +{"text":"I have derived the rights of sovereign power, and the duty of subjects hitherto from the principles of Nature only; such as experience ha found true, or consent concerning the use of words has made so, that i to say, from the nature of men, known to us by experience, and fro definitions of such words as are essential to all political reasonin universally agreed on. But in that I am next to handle, which is th nature and rights of a \"Christian Commonwealth,\" whereof ther dependeth much upon supernatural revelations of the will of God; th ground of my discourse must be, not only the natural word of God, bu also the prophetical."} +{"text":"Nevertheless we are not to renounce our senses and experience; nor tha which is the undoubted word of God, our natural reason. For they ar the talents which He hath put into our hands to negotiate, till th coming again of our blessed Saviour; and therefore not to be folded u in the napkin of an implicit faith, but employed in the purchase o justice, peace, and true religion. For though there be many things i God's word above reason; that it is to say, which cannot by natura reason be either demonstrated or confuted; yet there is nothin contrary to it; but when it seemeth so, the fault is either in ou unskilful interpretation, or erroneous ratiocination."} +{"text":"Therefore when anything therein written is too hard for ou examination, we are bidden to captivate our understanding to the words and not to labour in sifting out a philosophical truth by logic of suc mysteries as are not comprehensible, nor fall under any rule of natura science. For it is with the mysteries of our religion as with wholesom pills for the sick, which, swallowed whole, have the virtue to cure but chewed, are for the most part cast up again without effect."} +{"text":"But by the captivity of our understanding, is not meant a submission o the intellectual faculty to the opinion of any other man; but of th will to obedience, where obedience is due. For sense, memory understanding, reason, and opinion are not in our power to change; bu always and necessarily such as the things we see, hear, and conside suggest unto us; and therefore are not effects of our will, but ou will of them. We then captivate our understanding and reason when w forbear contradiction; when we so speak, as by lawful authority we ar commanded, and when we live accordingly, which, in sum, is trust an faith reposed in him that speaketh, though the mind be incapable of an notion at all from the words spoken."} +{"text":"When God speaketh to man, it must be either immediately; or b mediation of another man, to whom He had formerly spoken by himsel immediately. How God speaketh to a man immediately, may be understoo by those well enough, to whom He hath so spoken: but how the sam should be understood by another, is hard, if not impossible to know For if a man pretend to me, that God hath spoken to him supernaturall and immediately, and I make doubt of it, I cannot easily perceive wha argument he can produce to oblige me to believe it. It is true, that i he be my sovereign, he may oblige me to obedience, so as not by act o word to declare I believe him not; but not to think any otherwise tha my reason persuades me. But if one that hath not such authority ove me, should pretend the same, there is nothing that exacteth eithe belief or obedience."} +{"text":"For to say that God hath spoken to him in the Holy Scripture, is not t say God hath spoken to him immediately, but by mediation of th prophets, or of the apostles, or of the church, in such manner as H speaks to all other Christian men. To say He hath spoken to him in dream, is no more than to say he dreamed that God spake to him; whic is not of force to win belief from any man, that knows dreams are fo the most part natural, and may proceed from former thoughts; and suc dreams as that, from self-conceit, and foolish arrogance, and fals opinion of a man's own godliness, or other virtue, by which he think he hath merited the favour of extraordinary revelation. To say he hat seen a vision, or heard a voice, is to say that he hath dreamed betwee sleeping and waking; for in such manner a man doth many times naturall take his dream for a vision as not having well observed his ow slumbering. To say he speaks by supernatural inspiration, is to say h finds an ardent desire to speak, or some strong opinion of himself, fo which he can allege no natural and sufficient reason. So that thoug God Almighty can speak to a man by dreams, visions, voice, an inspiration; yet He obliges no man to believe He hath so done to hi that pretends it; who, being a man, may err, and, which is more, ma lie."} +{"text":"How then can he, to whom God hath never revealed His will immediately saving by the way of natural reason, know when he is to obey or not t obey his word, delivered by him that says he is a prophet? Of fou hundred prophets, of whom the king of Israel asked counsel concernin the war he made against Ramoth Gilead (1 Kings 22), only Micaiah was true one. The prophet that was sent to prophesy against the altar se up by Jeroboam (1 Kings 13), though a true prophet, and that by tw miracles done in his presence, appears to be a prophet sent from God was yet deceived by another old prophet, that persuaded him as from th mouth of God, to eat and drink with him. If one prophet deceiv another, what certainty is there of knowing the will of God, by othe way than that of reason? To which I answer out of the Holy Scripture that there be two marks, by which together, not asunder, a true prophe is to be known. One is the doing of miracles; the other is the no teaching any other religion than that which is already established Asunder, I say, neither of these is sufficient. \"If a prophet ris amongst you, or a dreamer of dreams, and shall pretend the doing of miracle, and the miracle come to pass; if he say, Let us follow strang gods, which thou has not known, thou shalt not hearken to him, etc. Bu that prophet and dreamer of dreams shall be put to death, because h hath spoken to you to revolt from the Lord your God.\" (Deut. 13:1�-�5. In which words two things are to be observed; first, that God will no have miracles alone serve for arguments, to approve the prophet' calling; but, as it is in the third verse, for an experiment of th constancy of our adherence to Himself. For the works of the Egyptia sorcerers, though not so great as those of Moses, yet were grea miracles. Secondly, that how great soever the miracle be, yet if i tend to stir up revolt against the king, or him that governeth by th king's authority, he that doth such miracle is not to be considere otherwise than as sent to make trial of their allegiance. For thes words, \"revolt from the Lord your God,\" are in this place equivalent t \"revolt from your king.\" For they had made God their king by pact a the foot of Mount Sinai; who ruled them by Moses only; for he onl spake with God, and from time to time declared God's commandments t the people. In like manner, after our Saviour Christ had made Hi disciples acknowledge Him for the Messiah, (that is to say, for God' anointed, whom the nation of the Jews daily expected for their king but refused when He came,) He omitted not to advertise them of th danger of miracles. \"There shall arise,\" saith he, \"false Christs, an false prophets, and shalt do great wonders and miracles, even to th seducing, if it were possible, of the very elect.\" (Matt. 24:24.) B which it appears that false prophets may have the power of miracles yet are we not to take their doctrine for God's word. St. Paul say farther to the Galatians (Gal. 1:8), that \"if himself, or an angel fro heaven preach another gospel to them, than he had preached, let him b accursed.\" That gospel was that Christ was King; so that all preachin against the power of the king received, in consequence to these words is by St. Paul accursed. For his speech is addressed to those, who b his preaching had already received Jesus for the Christ, that is t say, for King of the Jews."} +{"text":"And as miracles, without preaching that doctrine which God hat established; so preaching the true doctrine, without the doing o miracles, is an insufficient argument of immediate revelation. For if man that teacheth not false doctrine, should pretend to be a prophe without showing any miracle, he is never the more to be regarded fo his pretence, as is evident by Deut. 18:21�-�22: \"If thou say in th heart, How shall we know that the word (of the prophet) is not tha which the Lord hath spoken? when the prophet shall have spoken in th name of the Lord, that which shall not come to pass, that is the wor which the Lord hath not spoken, but the prophet has spoken it out o the pride of his own heart, fear him not.\" But a man may here agai ask, when the prophet hath foretold a thing, how shall we know whethe it will come to pass or not? For he may foretell it as a thing t arrive after a certain long time, longer than the time of man's life or indefinitely, that it will come to pass one time or other: in whic case this mark of a prophet is unuseful; and therefore the miracle that oblige us to believe a prophet, ought to be confirmed by a immediate, or a not long deferred event. So that it is manifest, tha the teaching of the religion which God hath established, and th showing of a present miracle, joined together, were the only mark whereby the Scripture would have a true prophet, that is to say immediate revelation, to be acknowledged; neither of them being singl sufficient to oblige any other man to regard what he saith."} +{"text":"Seeing therefore miracles now cease, we have no sign left whereby t acknowledge the pretended revelations or inspirations of any privat man; nor obligation to give ear to any doctrine, farther than it i conformable to the Holy Scriptures, which since the time of ou Saviour, supply the place, and sufficiently recompense the want of al other prophecy; and from which, by wise and learned interpretation, an careful ratiocination, all rules and precepts necessary to th knowledge of our duty both to God and man, without enthusiasm o supernatural inspiration, may easily be deduced. And this Scripture i it, out of which I am to take the principles of my discourse concerning the rights of those that are the supreme governors on eart of Christian commonwealths: and of the duty of Christian subject towards their sovereigns. And to that end, I shall speak in the nex chapter, of the books, writers, scope and authority of the Bible."} +{"text":"XXIII"} +{"text":"Of the Number, Antiquity, Scope, Authority, and Interpreters of th Books of Holy Scripture"} +{"text":"By the Books of Holy \"Scripture,\" are understood those which ought t be the \"canon,\" that is to say, the rules of Christian life."} +{"text":"And because all rules of life, which men are in conscience bound t observe, are laws; the question of the Scripture is the question o what is law throughout all Christendom, both natural and civil. Fo though it be not determined in Scripture what laws every Christian kin shall constitute in his own dominions; yet it is determined what law he shall not constitute. Seeing therefore I have already proved tha sovereigns in their own dominions are the sole legislators, those book only are canonical, that is, law, in every nation, which ar established for such by the sovereign authority. It is true, that Go is the sovereign of all sovereigns; and therefore when He speaks to an subject, He ought to be obeyed, whatsoever any earthly potentat command to the contrary. But the question is not of obedience to God but of \"when\" and \"what\" God hath said; which to subjects that have n supernatural revelation, cannot be known, but by that natural reaso which guideth them for the obtaining of peace and justice, to obey th authority of their several commonwealths, that is to say, of thei lawful sovereigns. According to this obligation, I can acknowledge n other books of the Old Testament to be Holy Scripture, but those whic have been commanded to be acknowledged for such by the authority of th Church of England. What books these are, is sufficiently known withou a catalogue of them here; and they are the same that are acknowledge by St. Jerome, who holdeth the rest, namely, the Wisdom of Solomon Ecclesiasticus, Judith, Tobias, the first and the second of Maccabees (though he had seen the first in Hebrew,) and the third and fourth o Esdras, for Apocrypha. Of the canonical, Josephus, a learned Jew, tha wrote in the time of the Emperor Domitian, reckoneth \"twenty-two,\ making the number agree with the Hebrew alphabet. St. Jerome does th same, though they reckon them in different manner. For Josephus number \"five\" Books of Moses, \"thirteen\" of Prophets that writ the history o their own times, (which how it agrees with the prophets' writing contained in the Bible we shall see hereafter,) and \"four\" of \"hymns\ and moral precepts. But St. Jerome reckons \"five\" books of Moses \"eight\" of Prophets, and \"nine\" of other Holy Writ, which he calls o hagio'grafa. The Septuagint, who were seventy learned men of the Jews sent for by Ptolemy, king of Egypt, to translate the Jewish law out o the Hebrew into the Greek, have left us no other for Holy Scripture i the Greek tongue, but the same that are received in the Church o England."} +{"text":"As for the Books of the New Testament, they are equally acknowledge for canon by all Christian churches, and by all sects of Christians that admit any books at all for canonical."} +{"text":"Who were the original writers of the several Books of Holy Scripture has not been made evident by any sufficient testimony of other history which is the only proof of matter of fact; nor can be, by any argumen of natural reason: for reason serves only to convince the truth, not o fact, but of consequence. The light therefore that must guide us i this question, must be that which is held out unto us from the book themselves; and this light, though it show us not the writer of ever book, yet it is not unuseful to give us knowledge of the time wherei they were written."} +{"text":"And first, for the Pentateuch, it is not argument enough that they wer written by Moses, because they are called the five Books of Moses; n more than these titles, the Book of Joshua, the Book of Judges, th Book of Ruth, and the Books of the Kings, are arguments sufficient t prove that they were written by Joshua, by the Judges, by Ruth, and b the Kings. For in titles of books, the subject is marked as often a the writer. The history of Livy denotes the writer, but the history o Scanderberg is denominated from the subject. We read in the las chapter of Deuteronomy (verse 6), concerning the sepulchre of Moses \"that no man knoweth of his sepulchre to this day,\" that is, to the da wherein those words were written. It is therefore manifest, that thos words were written after his interment. For it were a strang interpretation to say Moses spake of his own sepulchre, though b prophecy, that it was not found to that day wherein he was yet living But it may perhaps be alleged, that the last chapter only, not th whole Pentateuch, was written by some other man, but the rest not. Le us therefore consider that which we find in the Book of Genesis (12:6) \"And Abraham passed through the land to the place of Sichem, unto th plains of Moreh, and the Canaanite was then in the land\"; which mus needs be the words of one that wrote when the Canaanite was not in th land; and consequently, not of Moses, who died before he came into it Likewise (Numbers 21:14) the writer citeth another more ancient book entitled, \"The Book of the Wars of the Lord,\" wherein were registere the acts of Moses at the Red Sea and at the brook of Arnon. It i therefore sufficiently evident, that the five Books of Moses wer written after his time, though how long after it be not so manifest."} +{"text":"But though Moses did not compile those books entirely, and in the for we have them, yet he wrote all that which he is there said to hav written: as for example, the Volume of the Law, which is contained, a it seemeth, in the 11th of Deuteronomy, and the following chapters t the 27th, which was also commanded to be written on stones, in thei entry into the land of Canaan. And this also did Moses himself writ (Deut. 31:9�-�10), and delivered to the priests and elders of Israel to be read every seventh year to all Israel, at their assembling in th Feast of Tabernacles. And this is that law which God commanded, tha their kings, when they should have established that form of government should take a copy of from the priests and Levites: and which Mose commanded the priests and Levites to lay in the side of the ark (Deut 31:26); and the same which having been lost, was long time after foun again by Hilkiah, and sent to king Josias (2 Kings 22:8), who causin it to be read to the people (2 Kings 23:1�-�3), renewed the covenan between God and them."} +{"text":"That the Book of Joshua was also written long after the time of Joshua may be gathered out of many places of the book itself. Joshua had se up twelve stones in the midst of Jordan, for a monument of thei passage; of which the writer saith thus: \"They are there unto this day\ (Josh. 4:9); for \"unto this day\" is a phrase that signifieth a tim past, beyond the memory of man. In like manner, upon the saying of th Lord that He had rolled off from the people the reproach of Egypt, th writer saith, \"The place is called Gilgal unto this day\" (Josh. 5:9) which to have said in the time of Joshua had been improper. So also th name of the valley of Achor, from the trouble that Achan raised in th camp, the writer saith, \"remaineth unto this day\" (Josh. 7:26); whic must needs be therefore long after the time of Joshua. Arguments o this kind there be many other, as Josh. 8:29; 13:13; 14:14; 15:63."} +{"text":"The same is manifest by like arguments of the Book of Judges (1:21, 26 6:24; 10:4; 15:19; 17:6), and Ruth (1:1); but especially Judge (18:30), where it is said that \"Jonathan and his sons were priests t the tribe of Dan, until the day of the captivity of the land.\""} +{"text":"That the Books of Samuel were also written after his own time there ar the like arguments (1 Sam. 5:5; 7:13, 15; 27:6; and 30:25), where after David had adjudged equal part of the spoils to them that guarde the ammunition with them that fought, the writer saith, \"He made it statute and an ordinance to Israel to this day.\" Again, when David displeased that the Lord had slain Uzzah, for putting out his hand t sustain the ark, called the place Perez-Uzzah, the writer saith (2 Sam 6:8), it is called so \"to this day\": the time therefore of the writin of that book must be long after the time of the fact; that is, lon after the time of David."} +{"text":"As for the two books of the Kings, and the two books of the Chronicles besides the places which mention such monuments, as the writer saith remained till his own days; such as are 1 Kings 9:13; 9:21; 10:12 12:19; 2 Kings 2:22; 8:22; 10:27; 14:7; 16:6; 17:23; 17:34; 17:41; an 1 Chron. 4:41; 5:26; it is argument sufficient they were written afte the captivity in Babylon, that the history of them is continued til that time. For the facts registered are always more ancient than th register; and much more ancient than such books as make mention of an quote the register; as these books do in divers places, referring th reader to the Chronicles of the Kings of Judah, to the Chronicles o the Kings of Israel, to the Books of the prophet Samuel, of the prophe Nathan, of the prophet Ahijah; to the Vision of Jehdo, to the books o the prophet Serveiah, and of the prophet Addo."} +{"text":"The books of Ezra and Nehemiah were written certainly after thei return from captivity; because their return, the re-edification of th walls and houses of Jerusalem, the renovation of the covenant, an ordination of their policy, are therein contained."} +{"text":"The history of Queen Esther is of the time of the captivity; an therefore the writer must have been of the same time, or after it."} +{"text":"The book of Job hath no mark in it of the time wherein it was written and though it appear sufficiently (Ezekiel 14:14, and James 5:11) tha he was no feigned person; yet the book itself seemeth not to be history, but a treatise concerning a question in ancient time muc disputed, \"why wicked men have often prospered in this world, and goo men have been afflicted\"; and this is the more probable, because fro the beginning to the third verse of the third chapter, where th complaint of Job beginneth, the Hebrew is, as St. Jerome testifies, i prose; and from thence to the sixth verse of the last chapter, i hexameter verses; and the rest of that chapter again in prose. So tha the dispute is all in verse; and the prose is added but as a preface i the beginning, and an epilogue in the end. But verse is no usual styl of such, as either are themselves in great pain, as Job; or of such a come to comfort them, as his friends; but in philosophy, especiall moral philosophy, in ancient time frequent."} +{"text":"The Psalms were written the most part by David, for the use of th choir. To these are added some songs of Moses, and other holy men; an some of them after the return from the captivity, as the 137th and th 126th, whereby it is manifest that the Psalter was compiled, and pu into the form it now hath, after the return of the Jews from Babylon."} +{"text":"The Proverbs, being a collection of wise and godly sayings, partly o Solomon, partly of Agur, the son of Jakeh, and partly of the mother o king Lemuel; cannot probably be thought to have been collected b Solomon, rather than by Agur or the mother of Lemuel; and that, thoug the sentences be theirs, yet the collection or compiling them into thi one book was the work of some other godly man that lived after the all."} +{"text":"The books of Ecclesiastes and the Canticles have nothing that was no Solomon's except it be the titles or inscriptions. For The Words of th Preacher, the son of David, king in Jerusalem; and The Song of Songs which is Solomon's, seem to have been made for distinction's sake then, when the books of Scripture were gathered into one body of th law; to the end, that not the doctrine only, but the authors also migh be extant."} +{"text":"Of the prophets, the most ancient are Zephaniah, Jonah, Amos, Hosea Isaiah, and Michah, who lived in the time of Amaziah, and Azariah otherwise Ozias, kings of Judah. But the book of Jonah is not properl a register of his prophecy; for that is contained in these few words \"Forty days and Nineveh shall be destroyed\"; but a history or narratio of his frowardness and disputing God's commandments; so that there i small probability he should be the author, seeing he is the subject o it. But the book of Amos is his prophecy."} +{"text":"Jeremiah, Obadiah, Nahum, and Habakkuk prophesied in the time o Josiah."} +{"text":"Ezekiel, Daniel, Haggai, and Zechariah, in the captivity."} +{"text":"When Joel and Malachi prophesied, is not evident by their writings. Bu considering the inscriptions, or titles of their books, it is manifes enough that the whole Scripture of the Old Testament was set forth i the form we have it after the return of the Jews from their captivit in Babylon, and before the time of Ptolomaeus Philadelphus, that cause it to be translated into Greek by seventy men, which were sent him ou of Judea for that purpose. And if the books of Apocrypha, which ar recommended to us by the church, though not for canonical, yet fo profitable books for our instruction, may in this point be credited the Scripture was set forth in the form we have it in, by Esdras: a may appear by that which he himself saith, in the second boo (14:21�-�22, etc.), where speaking to God, he saith thus: \"Thy law i burnt; therefore no man knoweth the things which thou hast done, or th works that are to begin. But if I have found grace before thee, sen down the holy spirit into me, and I shall write all that hath been don in the world, since the beginning, which were written in thy law, tha men may find thy path, and that they which will live in the latter day may live.\" And verse 45: \"And it came to pass when the forty days wer fulfilled, that the highest spake, saying, The first that thou has written, publish openly, that the worthy and unworthy may read it; bu keep the seventy last, that thou mayest deliver them only to such as b wise among the people.\" And thus much concerning the time of th writing of the books of the Old Testament."} +{"text":"The writers of the New Testament lived all in less than an age afte Christ's ascension, and had all of them seen our Saviour, or been Hi disciples, except St. Paul and St. Luke; and consequently whatsoeve was written by them is as ancient as the time of the apostles. But th time wherein the books of the New Testament were received an acknowledged by the church to be of their writing, is not altogether s ancient. For, as the books of the Old Testament are derived to us, fro no other time than that of Esdras, who by the direction of God's spiri retrieved them, when they were lost; those of the New Testament, o which the copies were not many, nor could easily be all in any on private man's hand, cannot be derived from a higher time than tha wherein the governors of the church collected, approved, an recommended them to us, as the writings of those apostles an disciples, under whose names they go. The first enumeration of all th books, both of the Old and New Testament, is in the canons of th apostles supposed to be collected by Clement, the first (afte St. Peter) bishop of Rome. But because that is but supposed, and b many questioned, the Council of Laodicea is the first we know tha recommended the Bible to the then Christian churches, for the writing of the prophets and apostles: and this Council was held in the 364t year after Christ. At which time, though ambition had so far prevaile on the great doctors of the church as no more to esteem emperors though Christian, for the shepherds of the people, but for sheep; an emperors not Christian, for wolves; and endeavoured to pass thei doctrine, not for counsel and information as preachers, but for laws a absolute governors; and thought such frauds as tended to make th people the more obedient to Christian doctrine, to be pious; yet I a persuaded they did not therefore falsify the Scriptures, though th copies of the books of the New Testament were in the hands only of th ecclesiastics, because if they had had an intention so to do, the would surely have made them more favourable to their power ove Christian princes and civil sovereignty than they are. I see no therefore any reason to doubt but that the Old and New Testament, as w have them now, are the true registers of those things which were don and said by the prophets and apostles. And so perhaps are some of thos books which are called Apocrypha, and left out of the canon, not fo inconformity of doctrine with the rest, but only because they are no found in the Hebrew. For after the conquest of Asia by Alexander th Great, there were few learned Jews that were not perfect in the Gree tongue. For the seventy interpreters that converted the Bible int Greek, were all of them Hebrews; and we have extant the works of Phil and Josephus, both Jews, written by them eloquently in Greek. But it i not the writer, but the authority of the church that maketh the boo canonical. And although these books were written by divers men, yet i is manifest the writers were all endued with one and the same spirit in that they conspire to one and the same end, which is setting fort of the rights of the kingdom of God, the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost For the book of Genesis deriveth the genealogy of God's people, fro the creation of the world to the going into Egypt; the other four book of Moses contain the election of God for their king, and the laws whic He prescribed for their government; the books of Joshua, Judges, Ruth and Samuel, to the time of Saul, describe the acts of God's people till the time they cast off God's yoke and called for a king, after th manner of their neighbour nations. The rest of the history of the Ol Testament derives the succession of the line of David to the captivity out of which line was to spring the restorer of the kingdom of God even our blessed Saviour God the Son, whose coming was foretold in th books of the prophets, after whom the Evangelists write His life an actions, and His claim to the kingdom, whilst He lived on earth: an lastly, the Acts and Epistles of the Apostles, declare the coming o God, the Holy Ghost, and the authority He left with them and thei successors for the direction of the Jews, and for the invitation of th Gentiles. In sum, the histories and the prophecies of the Ol Testament, and the gospels and epistles of the New Testament, have ha one and the same scope to convert men to the obedience of God: 1, i Moses and the Priests; 2, in the man Christ; and 3, in the Apostles an the successors to apostolical power. For these three at several time did represent the person of God; Moses and his successors, the Hig Priests, and Kings of Judah, in the Old Testament: Christ himself, i the time He lived on earth; and the Apostles, and their successors from the day of Pentecost, when the Holy Ghost descended on them, t this day."} +{"text":"It is a question much disputed between the divers sects of Christia religion, \"from whence the Scriptures derive their authority\"; whic question is also propounded sometimes in other terms, as, \"how we kno them to be the word of God, or why we believe them to be so\": and th difficulty of resolving it, ariseth chiefly from the improperness o the words wherein the question itself is couched. For it is believed o all hands, that the first and original \"author\" of them is God; an consequently the question disputed, is not that. Again, it is manifest that none can know they are God's word (though all true Christian believe it), but those to whom God himself hath revealed i supernaturally; and therefore the question is not rightly moved, of ou \"knowledge\" of it. Lastly, when the question is propounded of ou \"belief\"; because some are moved to believe for one, and others fo other reasons; there can be rendered no one general answer for the all. The question truly stated is, \"by what authority they are mad law.\""} +{"text":"As far as they differ not from the laws of Nature there is no doubt bu they are the law of God, and carry their authority with them, legibl to all men that have the use of natural reason: but this is no othe authority, than that of all other moral doctrine consonant to reason the dictates whereof are laws, not \"made,\" but \"eternal.\""} +{"text":"If they be made law by God himself, they are of the nature of writte law, which are laws to them only to whom God hath so sufficientl published them, as no man can excuse himself, by saying he knew no they were His."} +{"text":"He therefore to whom God hath not supernaturally revealed that they ar His, nor that those that published them were sent by Him, is no obliged to obey them, by any authority, but his, whose commands hav already the force of laws; that is to say, by any other authority tha that of the commonwealth, residing in the sovereign, who only has th legislative power. Again, if it be not the legislative authority of th commonwealth, that giveth them the force of laws, it must be some othe authority derived from God, either private or public: if private, i obliges only him to whom in particular God hath been pleased to revea it. For if every man should be obliged to take for God's law wha particular men, on pretence of private inspiration or revelation should obtrude upon him, in such a number of men, that out of pride an ignorance, take their own dreams, and extravagant fancies, and madness for testimonies of God's spirit; or out of ambition, pretend to suc divine testimonies, falsely, and contrary to their own consciences, i were impossible that any divine law should be acknowledged. If public it is the authority of the \"commonwealth,\" or of the \"church.\" But th church, if it be one person, is the same thing with a commonwealth o Christians; called a \"commonwealth,\" because it consisteth of me united in one person, their sovereign; and a \"church,\" because i consisteth in Christian men, united in one Christian sovereign. But i the church be not one person, then it hath no authority at all: it ca neither command, nor do any action at all; nor is capable of having an power, or right to anything: nor has any will, reason nor voice; fo all these qualities are personal. Now if the whole number of Christian be not contained in one commonwealth, they are not one person; nor i there an universal church that hath any authority over them; an therefore the Scriptures are not made laws, by the universal church: o if it be one commonwealth, then all Christian monarchs and states ar private persons, and subject to be judged, deposed, and punished by a universal sovereign of all Christendom. So that the question of th authority of the Scriptures, is reduced to this, \"whether Christia kings, and the sovereign assemblies in Christian commonwealths, b absolute in their own territories, immediately under God; or subject t one vicar of Christ, constituted of the universal church; to be judged condemned, deposed, and put to death, as he shall think expedient, o necessary for the common good.\""} +{"text":"Which question cannot be resolved without a more particula consideration of the Kingdom of God; from whence also we are to judg of the authority of interpreting the Scripture. For whosoever hath lawful power over any writing, to make it law, hath the power also t approve, or disapprove, the interpretation of the same."} +{"text":"XXIV"} +{"text":"Of the Signification of Spirit, Angel, and Inspiration in the Books o Holy Scripture"} +{"text":"Seeing the foundation of all true ratiocination is the constan signification of words; which in the doctrine following, dependeth not as in natural science, on the will of the writer, nor, as in commo conversation, on vulgar use, but on the sense they carry in th Scripture; it is necessary, before I proceed any further, to determine out of the Bible, the meaning of such words, as by their ambiguity ma render what I am to infer upon them, obscure or disputable. I wil begin with the words \"body\" and \"spirit,\" which in the language of th schools are termed, \"substances,\" \"corporeal,\" and \"incorporeal.\""} +{"text":"The word \"body,\" in the most general acceptation, signifieth that whic filleth or occupieth some certain room, or imagined place; an dependeth not on the imagination, but is a real part of that we cal the \"universe.\" For the \"universe\" being the aggregate of all bodies there is no real part thereof that is not also \"body\"; nor anythin properly a \"body,\" that is not also part of that aggregate of al \"bodies,\" the \"universe.\" The same also, because bodies are subject t change, that is to say, to variety of apparence to the sense of livin creatures, is called \"substance,\" that is to say, \"subject\" to variou accidents: as sometimes to be moved; sometimes to stand still; and t seem to our senses sometimes hot, sometimes cold, sometimes of on colour, smell, taste, or sound, sometimes of another. And thi diversity of seeming, produced by the diversity of the operation o bodies on the organs of our sense, we attribute to alterations of th bodies that operate, and call them \"accidents\" of those bodies. An according to this acceptation of the word, \"substance\" and \"body\ signify the same thing; and therefore \"substance incorporeal\" ar words, which when they are joined together, destroy one another, as i a man should say an \"incorporeal body.\""} +{"text":"But in the sense of common people, not all the universe is called body but only such parts thereof as they can discern by the sense o feeling, to resist their force, or by the sense of their eyes, t hinder them from a farther prospect. Therefore in the common languag of men, \"air\" and \"aerial substances,\" use not to be taken fo \"bodies,\" but (as often as men are sensible of their effects) ar called \"wind,\" or \"breath,\" or (because the same are called in th Latin spiritus) \"spirits\"; as when they call that aerial substance which in the body of any living creature gives it life and motion \"vital\" and \"animal spirits.\" But for those idols of the brain, whic represent bodies to us where they are not, as in a looking-glass, in dream, or to a distempered brain waking, they are, as the apostle sait generally of all idols, nothing; nothing at all, I say, there wher they seem to be; and in the brain itself, nothing but tumult proceeding either from the action of the objects, or from th disorderly agitation of the organs of our sense. And men that ar otherwise employed than to search into their causes, know not o themselves what to call them; and may therefore easily be persuaded, b those whose knowledge they much reverence, some to call them \"bodies,\ and think them made of air compacted by a power supernatural, becaus the sight judges them corporeal; and some to call them \"spirits,\ because the sense of touch discerneth nothing in the place where the appear, to resist their fingers: so that the proper signification o \"spirit\" in common speech, is either a subtle, fluid, and invisibl body, or a ghost, or other idol or phantasm of the imagination. But fo metaphorical significations, there be many: for sometimes it is take for disposition or inclination of the mind; as when for the dispositio to control the sayings of other men, we say \"a spirit o contradiction\"; for a disposition to uncleanness, \"an unclean spirit\" for perverseness, \"a froward spirit\"; for sullenness, \"a dumb spirit\" and for inclination to godliness and God's service, \"the Spirit o God\": sometimes for any eminent ability or extraordinary passion, o disease of the mind, as when \"great wisdom\" is called \"the spirit o wisdom\"; and \"madmen\" are said to be \"possessed with a spirit.\""} +{"text":"Other significations of \"spirit\" I find nowhere any; and where none o these can satisfy the sense of that word in Scripture, the plac falleth not under human understanding; and our faith therein consistet not in our opinion, but in our submission; as in all places where Go is said to be a \"Spirit,\" or where by the \"Spirit of God\" is meant Go himself. For the nature of God is incomprehensible; that is to say, w understand nothing of \"what He is,\" but only \"that He is\"; an therefore the attributes we give Him are not to tell one another \"wha He is,\" nor to signify our opinion of His nature, but our desire t honour Him with such names as we conceive most honourable amongs ourselves."} +{"text":"Gen. 1:2: \"The Spirit of God moved upon the face of the waters.\" Her if by the \"Spirit of God\" be meant God himself, then is \"motion\ attributed to God, and consequently \"place,\" which are intelligibl only of bodies, and not of substances incorporeal; and so the place i above our understanding, that can conceive nothing moved that change not place, or that has not dimension; and whatsoever has dimension i body. But the meaning of those words is best understood by the lik place (Gen. 8:1), where when the earth was covered with waters, as i the beginning, God intending to abate them, and again to discover th dry land, useth the like words, \"I will bring my Spirit upon the earth and the waters shall be diminished,\" in which place, by \"Spirit\" i understood a wind, that is an air or \"spirit moved,\" which might b called, as in the former place, the \"Spirit of God,\" because it wa God's work."} +{"text":"Gen. 41:38: Pharaoh calleth the Wisdom of Joseph, the \"Spirit of God.\ For Joseph having advised him to look out a wise and discreet man, an to set him over the land of Egypt, he saith thus, \"Can we find such man as this is, in whom is the Spirit of God?\" And Exod. 28:3: \"Tho shalt speak,\" saith God, \"to all the wise-hearted, whom I have fille with the spirit of wisdom, to make Aaron garments, to consecrate him\" where extraordinary understanding, though but in making garments, a being the \"gift\" of God, is called the \"Spirit of God.\" The same i found again, Exod. 31:3�-�6; and 35:31. And Isaiah 11:2�-�3, where th prophet, speaking of the Messiah, saith, \"The Spirit of the Lord shal abide upon him, the spirit of wisdom and understanding, the spirit o counsel and fortitude, and the spirit of the fear of the Lord.\" Wher manifestly is meant, not so many ghosts, but so many eminent grace that God would give him."} +{"text":"In the book of Judges, an extraordinary zeal and courage in the defenc of God's people, is called the \"Spirit\" of God; as when it excite Othniel, Gideon, Jephtha, and Samson to deliver them from servitude Judges 3:10; 6:24; 11:29; 13:25; 14:6, 19. And of Saul, upon the new of the insolence of the Ammonites towards the men of Jabesh Gilead, i is said (1 Sam. 11:6) that \"the Spirit of God came upon Saul, and hi anger,\" (or as it is in the Latin, \"his fury\") \"was kindled greatly.\ Where it is not probable was meant a ghost, but an extraordinary \"zeal\ to punish the cruelty of the Ammonites. In like manner by the \"Spirit\ of God, that came upon Saul, when he was amongst the prophets tha praised God in songs and music (1 Sam.19:23), is to be understood, no a ghost, but an unexpected and sudden \"zeal\" to join with them in thei devotion."} +{"text":"The false prophet Zedekiah saith to Micaiah (1 Kings 22:24), \"which wa went the Spirit of the Lord from me to speak to thee?\" Which cannot b understood of a ghost; for Micaiah declared before the kings of Israe and Judah the event of the battle, as from a \"vision,\" and not as fro a \"spirit\" speaking in him."} +{"text":"In the same manner it appeareth in the books of the Prophets, tha though they spake by the \"spirit\" of God, that is to say, by a specia grace of prediction; yet their knowledge of the future was not by ghost within them, but by some supernatural \"dream\" or \"vision.\""} +{"text":"Gen. 2:7, it is said, \"God made man of the dust of the earth, an breathed into his nostrils (spiraculum vitae) the breath of life, an man was made a living soul.\" There the \"breath of life\" inspired by Go signifies no more, but that God gave him life; and (Job 27:3), \"as lon as the Spirit of God is in my nostrils,\" is no more than to say, \"a long as I live.\" So in Ezek. 1:20, \"the spirit of life was in th wheels,\" is equivalent to, \"the wheels were alive.\" And (Ezek. 2:2) \"the Spirit entered into me, and set me on my feet,\" that is, \" recovered my vital strength\"; not that any ghost or incorporea substance entered into, and possessed his body."} +{"text":"In Numbers 11:17, \"I will take,\" saith God, \"of the Spirit, which i upon thee, and will put it upon them, and they shall bear the burden o the people with thee\"; that is, upon the seventy elders: whereupon tw of the seventy are said to prophesy in the camp; of whom som complained, and Joshua desired Moses to forbid them; which Moses woul not do. Whereby it appears, that Joshua knew not that they had receive authority so to do, and prophesied according to the mind of Moses, tha is to say, by a \"spirit,\" or \"authority\" subordinate to his own."} +{"text":"In the like sense we read (Deut. 34:9), that \"Joshua was full of th spirit of wisdom, because Moses had laid his hands upon him\": that is because he was \"ordained\" by Moses to prosecute the work he had himsel begun, namely, the bringing of God's people into the promised land, bu prevented by death, could not finish."} +{"text":"In the like sense it is said (Rom. 8:9), \"If any man have not th Spirit of Christ, he is none of His\"; not meaning thereby the \"ghost\ of Christ, but a \"submission\" to His doctrine. As also (1 John 4:2) \"Hereby you shall know the Spirit of God; every spirit that confesset that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh, is of God\"; by which is mean the spirit of unfeigned Christianity, or \"submission,\" to that mai article of Christian faith, that Jesus is the Christ; which cannot b interpreted of a ghost."} +{"text":"Likewise these words (Luke 4:1), \"And Jesus full of the Holy Ghost,\ (that is, as it is expressed, Matt. 4:1, and Mark 1:12, \"of the Hol Spirit,\") may be understood for \"zeal\" to do the work for which He wa sent by God the Father; but to interpret it of a ghost, is to say tha God himself, for so our Saviour was, was filled with God; which is ver improper and insignificant. How we came to translate \"spirits\" by th word \"ghosts,\" which signifieth nothing, neither in heaven nor earth but the imaginary inhabitants of man's brain, I examine not: but this say, the word \"spirit\" in the text signifieth no such thing, but eithe properly a real \"substance,\" or metaphorically, some extraordinar \"ability\" or \"affection\" of the mind, or of the body."} +{"text":"The disciples of Christ, seeing Him walking upon the sea (Matt. 14:26 and Mark 6:49), supposed Him to be a \"spirit,\" meaning thereby a aerial \"body,\" and not a phantasm; for it is said they all saw Him which cannot be understood of the delusions of the brain, (which ar not common to many at once, as visible bodies are; but singular because of the differences of fancies), but of bodies only. In lik manner, where He was taken for a \"spirit,\" by the same apostles (Luk 24:37): so also (Acts 12:15), when St. Peter was delivered out o prison, it would not be believed; but when the maid said he was at th door, they said it was his \"angel\"; by which must be meant a corporea substance, or we must say, the disciples themselves did follow th common opinion of both Jews and Gentiles, that some such apparition were not imaginary, but real, and such as needed not the fancy of ma for their existence. These the Jews called \"spirits,\" and \"angels,\ good or bad; as the Greeks call the same by the name of \"demons.\" An some such apparitions may be real and substantial; that is to say subtle bodies, which God can form by the same power by which He forme all things, and make use of, as of ministers and messengers, that is t say, angels, to declare His will, and execute the same when H pleaseth, in extraordinary and supernatural manner. But when He hath s formed them, they are substances endued with dimensions, and take u room, and can be moved from place to place, which is peculiar t bodies; and therefore are not ghosts \"incorporeal,\" that is to say ghosts that are in \"no place\"; that is to say, that are \"nowhere\"; tha is to say, that seeming to be \"somewhat,\" are \"nothing.\" But i corporeal be taken in the most vulgar manner, for such substances a are perceptible by our external senses; then is substance incorporeal a thing not imaginary, but real; namely, a thin substance invisible but that hath the same dimensions that are in grosser bodies."} +{"text":"By the name of \"angel,\" is signified generally, a \"messenger\"; and mos often a \"messenger of God\"; and by a messenger of God is signified anything that makes known His extraordinary presence; that is to say the extraordinary manifestation of His power, especially by a dream o vision."} +{"text":"Concerning the creation of \"angels,\" there is nothing delivered in th Scriptures. That they are spirits, is often repeated: but by the nam of spirit, is signified both in Scripture and vulgarly, both amongs Jews and Gentiles, sometimes thin bodies: as the air, the wind, th spirits vital and animal of living creatures; and sometimes the image that rise in the fancy in dreams and visions; which are not rea substances, nor last any longer than the dream or vision they appea in; which apparitions, though no real substances, but accidents of th brain; yet when God raiseth them supernaturally, to signify His will they are not improperly termed God's messengers, that is to say, Hi \"angels.\""} +{"text":"And as the Gentiles did vulgarly conceive the imagery of the brain, fo things really subsistent without them, and not dependent on the fancy and out of them framed their opinions of \"demons,\" good and evil; whic because they seemed to subsist really, they called \"substances\"; and because they could not feel them with their hands, \"incorporeal\": s also the Jews upon the same ground, without anything in the Ol Testament that constrained them thereunto, had generally an opinion except the sect of the Sadducees, that those apparitions which i pleased God sometimes to produce in the fancy of men, for His ow service, and therefore called them His \"angels,\" were substances, no dependent on the fancy, but permanent creatures of God; whereof thos which they thought were good to them, they esteemed the \"angels o God,\" and those they thought would hurt them, they called \"evi angels,\" or evil spirits. Such as was the spirit of Python, and th spirits of madmen, of lunatics, and epileptics, for they esteemed suc as were troubled with such diseases, \"demoniacs.\""} +{"text":"But if we consider the places of the Old Testament where angels ar mentioned, we shall find that in most of them, there can nothing els be understood by the word \"angel,\" but some image raised supernaturally, in the fancy to signify the presence of God in th execution of some supernatural work; and therefore in the rest, wher their nature is not expressed, it may be understood in the same manner."} +{"text":"For we read (Gen. 16) that the same apparition is called, not only a \"angel,\" but \"God,\" where that which (verse 7) is called the \"angel\" o the Lord, in the tenth verse, saith to Agar, \"I will multiply thy see exceedingly\"; that is, speaketh in the person of God. Neither was thi apparition a fancy figured, but a voice. By which it is manifest tha \"angel\" signifieth there nothing but \"God\" himself, that caused Aga supernaturally to apprehend a voice from heaven; or rather, nothin else but a voice supernatural, testifying God's special presence there Why therefore may not the angels that appeared to Lot, and are calle (Gen. 19:12) \"men\"; and to whom, though they were two, Lot speaket (verse 18) as but to one, and that one as God, (for the words are, \"Lo said unto them, Oh, not so, my Lord,\") be understood of images of men supernaturally formed in the fancy, as well as before by angel wa understood a fancied voice? When the angel called to Abraham out o heaven to stay his hand (Gen. 22:11) from slaying Isaac, there was n apparition, but a voice; which nevertheless was called properly enoug a messenger or \"angel\" of God, because it declared God's wil supernaturally, and saves the labour of supposing any permanent ghosts The angels which Jacob saw on the ladder of Heaven (Gen. 28:12) were vision of his sleep, therefore only fancy and a dream; yet bein supernatural, and signs of God's special presence, those apparition are not improperly called \"angels.\" The same is to be understood (Gen 31:11) where Jacob saith thus, \"The Angel of the Lord appeared to me i my sleep.\" For an apparition made to a man in his sleep, is that whic all men call a dream, whether such dream be natural or supernatural and that which there Jacob called an \"angel,\" was God himself, for th same angel saith (verse 13), \"I am the God of Bethel.\""} +{"text":"Also (Exod. 14:19) the angel that went before the army of Israel to th Red Sea, and then came behind it, is (verse 24) the Lord himself; an He appeared, not in the form of a beautiful man, but in form (Exod 13:21), by day, of a \"pillar of cloud,\" and, by night, in form of \"pillar of fire\"; and yet this pillar was all the apparition an \"angel\" promised to Moses (Exod. 33:2) for the army's guide: for thi cloudy pillar (Exod. 33:9) is said to have descended, and stood at th door of the Tabernacle, and to have talked with Moses."} +{"text":"There you see motion and speech, which are commonly attributed t angels, attributed to a cloud, because the cloud served as a sign o God's presence; and was no less an angel, than if it had had the for of a man, or child of never so great beauty; or wings, as usually the are painted, for the false instruction of common people. For it is no the shape; but their use that makes them angels. But their use is to b significations of God's presence in supernatural operations; as whe Moses (Exod. 33:14) had desired God to go along with the camp, as H had done always before the making of the golden calf, God did no answer, \"I will go,\" nor \"I will send an angel in my stead\"; but thus \"My presence shall go with thee.\""} +{"text":"To mention all the places of the Old Testament where the name of ange is found would be too long. Therefore to comprehend them all at once, say, there is no text in that part of the Old Testament, which th Church of England holdeth for canonical, from which we can conclud there is or hath been created, any permanent thing, understood by th name of \"spirit\" or \"angel,\" that hath not quantity; and that may no be by the understanding divided; that is to say, considered by parts so as one part may be in one place, and the next part in the next plac to it; and in sum, which is not (taking body for that which is somewha or somewhere) corporeal; but in every place, the sense will bear th interpretation of angel, for messenger; as John Baptist is called a angel, and Christ the Angel of the Covenant; and as, according to th same analogy, the dove and the fiery tongues, in that they were sign of God's special presence, might also be called angels. Though we fin in Daniel two names of angels, Gabriel and Michael; yet it is clear ou of the text itself (Dan. 12:1) that by Michael is meant Christ, not a an angel, but as a prince: and that Gabriel, as the like apparition made to other holy men in their sleep, was nothing but a supernatura phantasm, by which it seemed to Daniel, in his dream, that two saint being in talk, one of them said to the other, \"Gabriel, let us mak this man understand his vision\": for God needeth not to distinguish Hi celestial servants by names, which are useful only to the shor memories of mortals. Nor in the New Testament is there any place, ou of which it can be proved that angels, except when they are put fo such men as God hath made the messengers and ministers of his word o works, are things permanent, and withal incorporeal. That they ar permanent, may be gathered from the words of our Saviour himself (Matt 25:41), where He saith, it shall be said to the wicked in the last day \"Go ye cursed into everlasting fire prepared for the devil and hi angels\": which place is manifest for the permanence of evil angel (unless we might think the name of devil and his angels may b understood of the Church's adversaries and their ministers); but the it is repugnant to their immateriality; because everlasting fire is n punishment to impatible substances, such as are all things incorporeal Angels therefore are not thence proved to be incorporeal. In lik manner where St. Paul says (1 Cor. 6:3), \"Know ye not that we shal judge the angels?\" and (2 Pet. 2:4), \"For if God spared not the angel that sinned, but cast them down into hell\"; and (Jude 1:6), \"And th angels that kept not their first estate, but left their own habitation He hath reserved in everlasting chains under darkness unto the judgmen of the last day\": though it prove the permanence of angelical nature it confirmeth also their materiality. And (Matt. 12:30), \"In th resurrection men do neither marry nor give in marriage, but are as th angels of God in heaven\": but in the resurrection men shall b permanent and not incorporeal; so therefore also are the angels."} +{"text":"There be divers other places out of which may be drawn the lik conclusion. To men that understand the signification of these words \"substance\" and \"incorporeal\"; as \"incorporeal\" is taken, not fo subtle body, but for \"not body\"; they imply a contradiction: insomuc as to say, an angel or spirit is in that sense an incorporea substance, is to say in effect, there is no angel nor spirit at all Considering therefore the signification of the word \"angel\" in the Ol Testament, and the nature of dreams and visions that happen to men b the ordinary way of nature, I was inclined to this opinion, that angel were nothing but supernatural apparitions of the fancy, raised by th special and extraordinary operation of God, thereby to make Hi presence and commandments known to mankind, and chiefly to His ow people. But the many places of the New Testament, and our Saviour's ow words, and in such texts, wherein is no suspicion of corruption of th Scripture, have extorted from my feeble reason an acknowledgment an belief that there be also angels substantial and permanent. But t believe they be in no place, that is to say, nowhere, that is to say nothing, as they, though indirectly, say that will have the incorporeal, cannot by Scripture be evinced."} +{"text":"On the signification of the word \"spirit,\" dependeth that of the wor \"inspiration\"; which must either be taken properly; and then it i nothing but the blowing into a man some thin and subtle air or wind, i such manner as a man filleth a bladder with his breath; or if spirit be not corporeal, but have their existence only in the fancy, it i nothing but the blowing in of a phantasm; which is improper to say, an impossible; for phantasms are not, but only seem to be, somewhat. Tha word therefore is used in the Scripture metaphorically only: as (Gen 2:7) where it is said that God \"inspired\" into man the breath of life no more is meant than that God gave unto him vital motion. For we ar not to think that God made first a living breath and then blew it int Adam after he was made, whether that breath were real or seeming; bu only as it is (Acts 17:25), \"that He gave him life and breath\"; tha is, made him a living creature. And where it is said (2 Tim. 3:16) \"All Scripture is given by inspiration from God,\" speaking there of th Scripture of the Old Testament, it is an easy metaphor to signify tha God inclined the spirit or mind of those writers to write that whic should be useful, in teaching, reproving, correcting, and instructin men in the way of righteous living. But where St. Peter (2 Pet. 1:21 saith, that \"Prophecy came not in old time by the will of man, but th holy men of God spake as they were moved by the Holy Spirit,\" by th Holy Spirit is meant the voice of God in a dream or visio supernatural, which is not \"inspiration.\" Nor, when our Saviou breathing on His disciples, said, \"Receive the Holy Spirit,\" was tha breath the Spirit, but a sign of the spiritual graces He gave unt them. And though it be said of many, and of our Saviour himself, tha He was full of the Holy Spirit; yet that fullness is not to b understood for \"infusion\" of the substance of God, but for accumulatio of His gifts, such as are the gift of sanctity of life, of tongues, an the like, whether attained supernaturally or by study and industry; fo in all cases they are the gifts of God. So likewise where God say (Joel 2:28), \"I will pour out my Spirit upon all flesh, and your son and your daughters shall prophesy, your old men shall dream dreams, an your young men shall see visions,\" we are not to understand it in th proper sense, as if His Spirit were like water, subject to effusion o infusion; but as if God had promised to give them prophetical dream and visions. For the proper use of the word \"infused,\" in speaking o the graces of God, is an abuse of it; for those graces are virtues, no bodies to be carried hither and thither, and to be poured into men a into barrels."} +{"text":"In the same manner, to take \"inspiration\" in the proper sense, or t say that good \"spirits\" entered into men to make them prophesy, or evi \"spirits\" into those that became phrenetic, lunatic, or epileptic, i not to take the word in the sense of the Scripture; for the Spiri there is taken for the power of God, working by causes to us unknown As also (Acts 2:2) the wind, that is there said to fill the hous wherein the apostles were assembled on the day of Pentecost, is not t be understood for the \"Holy Spirit,\" which is the Deity itself; but fo an external sign of God's special working on their hearts, to effect i them the internal graces and holy virtues He thought requisite for th performance of their apostleship."} +{"text":"XXV"} +{"text":"Of the Signification in Scripture of Kingdom of God, of Holy, Sacred and Sacrament"} +{"text":"The \"Kingdom of God,\" in the writings of divines, and specially i sermons and treatises of devotion, is taken most commonly for eterna felicity, after this life, in the highest heaven, which they also cal the kingdom of glory; and sometimes for the earnest of that felicity sanctification, which they term the kingdom of grace; but never for th monarchy, that is to say, the sovereign power of God over any subject acquired by their own consent, which is the proper signification o kingdom."} +{"text":"To the contrary, I find the \"kingdom of God\" to signify, in most place of Scripture, a \"kingdom properly so named,\" constituted by the vote of the people of Israel in peculiar manner; wherein they chose God fo their king by covenant made with Him, upon God's promising them th possession of the land of Canaan; and but seldom metaphorically; an then it is taken for \"dominion over sin\"; (and only in the Ne Testament;) because such a dominion as that, every subject shall hav in the kingdom of God, and without prejudice to the sovereign."} +{"text":"From the very creation, God not only reigned over all men \"naturally\ by His might; but also had \"peculiar\" subjects, whom He commanded by voice, as one man speaketh to another. In which manner He \"reigned\ over Adam, and gave him commandment to abstain from the tree o cognizance of good and evil; which when he obeyed not, but tastin thereof, took upon him to be as God, judging between good and evil, no by his Creator's commandment, but by his own sense, his punishment wa a privation of the estate of eternal life, wherein God had at firs created him; and afterwards God punished his posterity for their vices all but eight persons, with an universal deluge; and in these eight di consist the then \"kingdom of God.\""} +{"text":"After this it pleased God to speak to Abraham, and (Gen. 17:7�-�8) t make a covenant with him in these words, \"I will establish my covenan between me, and thee, and thy seed after thee in their generations, fo an everlasting covenant, to be a God to thee, and to thy seed afte thee; and I will give unto thee, and to thy seed after thee, the lan wherein thou art a stranger, all the land of Canaan for an everlastin possession.\" In this covenant \"Abraham promiseth for himself and hi posterity, to obey as God, the Lord that spake to him; and God on Hi part promiseth to Abraham the land of Canaan for an everlastin possession.\" And for a memorial, and a token of this covenant, H ordaineth (Gen. 17:11) the \"sacrament of circumcision.\" This is i which is called the \"old covenant\" or \"testament\"; and containeth contract between God and Abraham; by which Abraham obligeth himself and his posterity, in a peculiar manner to be subject to God's positiv law; for to the law moral he was obliged before, as by an oath o allegiance. And though the name of \"King\" be not yet given to God, no of \"kingdom\" to Abraham and his seed: yet the thing is the same namely, an institution by pact, of God's peculiar sovereignty over th seed of Abraham; which in the renewing of the same covenant by Moses at Mount Sinai, is expressly called a peculiar \"kingdom of God\" ove the Jews: and it is of Abraham, not of Moses, St. Paul saith (Rom 4:11) that he is the \"father of the faithful\"; that is, of those tha are loyal, and do not violate their allegiance sworn to God, then b circumcision, and afterwards in the \"new covenant\" by baptism."} +{"text":"This covenant at the foot of Mount Sinai, was renewed by Moses (Exod 19:5), where the Lord commandeth Moses to speak to the people in thi manner: \"If you will obey my voice indeed, and keep my covenant, the ye shall be a peculiar people to me, for all the earth is mine; and y shall be unto me a sacerdotal kingdom, and an holy nation.\" For \"peculiar people,\" the vulgar Latin hath peculium de cunctis populis the English translation, made in the beginning of the reign of Kin James, hath a \"peculiar treasure unto me above all nations\"; and th Geneva French, \"the most precious jewel of all nations.\" But the trues translation is the first, because it is confirmed by St. Paul himsel (Tit. 2:14), where he saith, alluding to that place, that our blesse Saviour \"gave himself for us, that He might purify us to himself peculiar,\" that is, an extraordinary, \"people\"; for the word is in th Greek periou%sio*s, which is opposed commonly to the word piou%sio*s and as this signifieth \"ordinary,\" \"quotidian,\" or, as in the Lord' Prayer, \"of daily use\"; so the other signifieth that which i \"overplus,\" and \"stored up,\" and \"enjoyed in a special manner\"; whic the Latins call peculium: and this meaning of the place is confirmed b the reason God rendereth of it, which followeth immediately, in that H addeth, \"For all the earth is mine,\" as if He should say, \"All th nations of the world are mine; but it is not so that you are mine, bu in a special manner; for they are all mine, by reason of my power; bu you shall be mine, by your own consent and covenant\"; which is a addition to His ordinary title, to all nations."} +{"text":"The same is again confirmed in express words in the same text, \"Y shall be to me a sacerdotal kingdom, and an holy nation.\" The vulga Latin hath it, regnum sacerdotale, to which agreeth the translation o that place (1 Pet. 2:9), Sacerdotium regale, \"a regal priesthood\"; a also the institution itself, by which no man might enter into th \"sanctum sanctorum,\" that is to say, no man might inquire God's wil immediately of God himself, but only the high priest. The Englis translation before mentioned, following that of Geneva, has \"a kingdo of priests\"; which is either meant of the succession of one high pries after another, or else it accordeth not with St. Peter, nor with th exercise of the high priesthood; for there was never any but the hig priest only, that was to inform the people of God's will; nor an convocation of priests ever allowed to enter into the sanctu sanctorum."} +{"text":"Again, the title of a \"holy nation\" confirms the same; for \"holy\ signifies that which is God's by special, not by general right. All th earth, as is said in the text, is God's; but all the earth is no called \"holy,\" but that only which is set apart for His especia service, as was the nation of the Jews. It is therefore manifest enoug by this one place, that by the \"kingdom of God,\" is properly meant commonwealth, instituted by the consent of those which were to b subject thereto, for their civil government, and the regulating o their behaviour, not only towards God their king, but also towards on another in point of justice, and towards other nations both in peac and war; which properly was a kingdom wherein God was king, and th high priest was to be, after the death of Moses, his sole viceroy o lieutenant."} +{"text":"But there be many other places that clearly prove the same. As firs (1 Sam. 8:7), when the Elders of Israel, grieved with the corruption o the sons of Samuel, demanded a king, Samuel displeased therewith prayed unto the Lord, and the Lord answering said unto him, \"Hearke unto the voice of the people, for they have not rejected thee, but the have rejected me, that I should not reign over them.\" Out of which i is evident that God himself was then their king; and Samuel did no command the people, but only delivered to them that which God from tim to time appointed him."} +{"text":"Again (1 Sam. 12:12), where Samuel saith to the people, \"When ye sa that Nahash, king of the children of Ammon, came against you, ye sai unto me, Nay, but a king shall reign over us; when the Lord your Go was your king.\" It is manifest that God was their king, and governe the civil state of their commonwealth."} +{"text":"And after the Israelites had rejected God, the prophets did foretel His restitution; as (Isaiah 24:23), \"Then the moon shall be confounded and the sun ashamed, when the Lord of hosts shall reign in Mount Zio and in Jerusalem\"; where He speaketh expressly of his reign in Zion an Jerusalem; that is, on earth. And (Micah 4:7), \"And the Lord shal reign over them in Mount Zion\"; this Mount Zion is in Jerusalem, upo the earth. And (Ezek. 20:33), \"As I live, saith the Lord God, surel with a mighty hand, and a stretched out arm, and with fury poured out I will rule over you\"; and (verse 37), \"I will cause you to pass unde the rod, and I will bring you into the bond of the covenant\"; that is I will reign over you, and make you to stand to that covenant which yo made with me by Moses, and brake in your rebellion against me in th days of Samuel, and in your election of another king."} +{"text":"And in the New Testament the angel Gabriel saith of our Saviour (Luk 1:32�-�33), \"He shall be great, and be called the Son of the Most High and the Lord shall give unto Him the throne of His father David; and H shall reign over the house of Jacob forever; and of His kingdom ther shall be no end.\" This is also a kingdom upon earth; for the clai whereof, as an enemy to Caesar, He was put to death; the title of Hi cross was, \"Jesus of Nazareth, King of the Jews\"; He was crowned i scorn with a crown of thorns; and for the proclaiming of Him it is sai of the disciples (Acts 17:7), \"That they did all of them contrary t the decrees of Caesar, saying there was another king, one Jesus.\" Th kingdom therefore of God is a real, not a metaphorical kingdom; and s taken, not only in the Old Testament but in the New; when we say, \"Fo thine is the kingdom, the power, and glory,\" it is to be understood o God's kingdom, by force of our covenant, not by the right of God' power; for such a kingdom God always hath; so that it were superfluou to say in our prayer, \"Thy kingdom come,\" unless it be meant of th restoration of that kingdom of God by Christ, which by revolt of th Israelites had been interrupted in the election of Saul. Nor had i been proper to say, \"The kingdom of heaven is at hand\"; or to pray \"Thy kingdom come,\" if it had still continued."} +{"text":"There be so many other places that confirm this interpretation, that i were a wonder there is no greater notice taken of it, but that it give too much light to Christian kings to see their right of ecclesiastica government. This they have observed, that instead of a \"sacerdota kingdom,\" translate, \"a kingdom of priests\"; for they may as wel translate a \"royal priesthood,\" as it is in St. Peter, into \"priesthood of kings.\" And whereas, for a \"peculiar people,\" they put \"precious jewel,\" or \"treasure,\" a man might as well call the specia regiment, or company of a general, the general's precious jewel, or hi treasure."} +{"text":"In short, the kingdom of God is a civil kingdom; which consisted first, in the obligation of the people of Israel to those laws, whic Moses should bring unto them from Mount Sinai; and which afterwards th high priest for the time being, should deliver to them from before th cherubims in the sanctum sanctorum; and which kingdom having been cas off in the election of Saul, the prophets foretold, should be restore by Christ; and the restoration whereof we daily pray for, when we sa in the Lord's Prayer, \"Thy kingdom come\"; and the right whereof w acknowledge, when we add, \"For thine is the kingdom, the power, an glory, forever and ever, Amen\"; and the proclaiming whereof, was th preaching of the apostles; and to which men are prepared, by th teachers of the Gospel; to embrace which Gospel, that is to say, t promise obedience to God's government, is to be in the \"kingdom o grace,\" because God hath gratis given to such the power to be th subjects, that is children, of God hereafter, when Christ shall come i majesty to judge the world, and actually to govern His own people which is called \"the kingdom of glory.\" If the kingdom of God, calle also the kingdom of heaven, from the gloriousness and admirable heigh of that throne, were not a kingdom which God by His lieutenants, o vicars, who deliver His commandments to the people, did exercise o earth; there would not have been so much contention and war about wh it is by whom God speaketh to us; neither would many priests hav troubled themselves with spiritual jurisdiction, nor any king hav denied it them."} +{"text":"Out of this literal interpretation of the \"kingdom of God,\" ariset also the true interpretation of the word \"holy.\" For it is a word which in God's kingdom answereth to that, which men in their kingdom use to call \"public,\" or the \"king's.\""} +{"text":"The king of any country is the \"public\" person, or representative o all his own subjects. And God the king of Israel was the \"Holy One\" o Israel. The nation which is subject to one earthly sovereign, is th nation of that sovereign, that is, of the public person. So the Jews who were God's nation, were called (Exod. 19:6) \"a holy nation.\" For b \"holy,\" is always understood either God himself, or that which is God' in propriety; as by public is always meant, either the person of th commonwealth itself, or something that is so the commonwealth's, as n private person can claim any propriety therein."} +{"text":"Therefore the Sabbath, God's day, is a \"holy day\"; the temple, God' house, \"a holy house\"; sacrifices, tithes, and offerings, God' tribute, \"holy duties\"; priests, prophets, and anointed kings, unde Christ, God's ministers, \"holy men\"; the celestial ministering spirits God's messengers, \"holy angels\"; and the like: and wheresoever the wor \"holy\" is taken properly, there is still something signified o propriety, gotten by consent. In saying, \"Hallowed be thy name,\" we d but pray to God for grace to keep the first commandment, of \"having n other gods but Him.\" Mankind is God's nation in propriety: but the Jew only were a \"holy nation.\" Why, but because they became His propriet by covenant?"} +{"text":"And the word \"profane\" is usually taken in the Scripture for the sam with \"common\"; and consequently their contraries, \"holy\" and \"proper,\ in the kingdom of God, must be the same also. But figuratively, thos men also are called \"holy,\" that led such godly lives, as if they ha forsaken all worldly designs, and wholly devoted and given themselve to God. In the proper sense, that which is made \"holy\" by God' appropriating or separating it to His own use, is said to b \"sanctified\" by God, as the seventh day in the fourth commandment; an as the elect in the New Testament were said to be \"sanctified\" whe they were endued with the spirit of godliness. And that which is mad \"holy\" by the dedication of men, and given to God, so as to be use only in His public service, is called also \"sacred,\" and said to b consecrated, as temples, and other houses of public prayer, and thei utensils, priests, and ministers, victims, offerings, and the externa matter of sacraments."} +{"text":"Of \"holiness\" there be degrees: for of those things that are set apar for the service of God, there may be some set apart again for a neare and more especial service. The whole nation of the Israelites were people holy to God; yet the tribe of Levi was amongst the Israelites holy tribe; and amongst the Levites, the priests were yet more holy and amongst the priests, the high priest was the most holy. So the lan of Judaea was the Holy Land; but the holy city wherein God was to b worshipped, was more holy; and again the Temple more holy than th city, and the sanctum sanctorum more holy than the rest of the Temple."} +{"text":"A \"sacrament,\" is a separation of some visible thing from common use and a consecration of it to God's service, for a sign either of ou admission into the kingdom of God, to be of the number of His peculia people, or for a commemoration of the same. In the Old Testament, th sign of admission was \"circumcision\"; in the New Testament, \"baptism.\ The commemoration of it in the Old Testament was the \"eating,\" at certain time which was anniversary of the \"Paschal Lamb\"; by which the were put in mind of the night wherein they were delivered out of thei bondage in Egypt; and in the New Testament, the celebrating of th \"Lord's Supper\"; by which we are put in mind of our deliverance fro the bondage of sin, by our blessed Saviour's death upon the cross. Th sacraments of \"admission,\" are but once to be used, because there need but one \"admission\"; but because we have need of being often put i mind of our deliverance, and of our allegiance, the sacraments o \"commemoration\" have need to be reiterated. And these are the principa sacraments, and as it were the solemn oaths we make of our allegiance There be also other consecrations, that may be called sacraments, a the word implieth only consecration to God's service; but as it implie an oath, or promise of allegiance to God, there were no other in th Old Testament, but \"circumcision,\" and the \"passover\"; nor are ther any other in the New Testament, but \"baptism\" and the \"Lord's Supper.\""} +{"text":"XXVI"} +{"text":"Of the Word of God, and of Prophets"} +{"text":"When there is mention of the \"word of God,\" or of \"man,\" it doth no signify a part of speech, such as grammarians call a noun or a verb, o any simple voice, without a contexture with other words to make i significative; but a perfect speech or discourse, whereby the speake \"affirmeth,\" \"denieth,\" \"commandeth,\" \"promiseth,\" \"threateneth,\ \"wisheth,\" or \"interrogateth.\" In which sense it is not vocabulum, tha signifies a \"word\"; but sermo (in Greek lo'go*s), that is, som \"speech,\" \"discourse,\" or \"saying.\""} +{"text":"Again, if we say the \"word of God,\" or of \"man,\" it may be understoo sometimes of the speaker; as the words that God hath spoken, or that man hath spoken; in which sense, when we say the Gospel of St. Matthew we understand St. Matthew to be the writer of it, and sometimes of th subject; in which sense when we read in the Bible, \"the words of th days of the kings of Israel, or Judah,\" it is meant that the acts tha were done in those days were the subject of those words; and in th Greek which, in the Scripture, retaineth many Hebraisms, by the word o God is oftentimes meant, not that which is spoken by God, bu concerning God, and His government; that is to say, the doctrine o religion: insomuch as it is all one, to say lo'go*s THeo�, an theologia; which is, that doctrine which we usually call \"divinity,\" a is manifest by the places following (Acts 13:46), \"Then Paul an Barnabas waxed bold, and said, it was necessary that the word of Go should first have been spoken to you, but seeing you put it from you and judge yourselves unworthy of everlasting life, lo, we turn to th Gentiles.\" That which is here called the word of God, was the doctrin of Christian religion; as it appears evidently by that which goe before. And (Acts 5:20) where it is said to the apostles by an angel \"Go stand and speak in the Temple, all the words of this life\"; by th words of this life, is meant the doctrine of the Gospel; as is eviden by what they did in the Temple, and is expressed in the last verse o the same chapter, \"Daily in the Temple, and in every house they cease not to teach and preach Christ Jesus\"; in which place it is manifes that Jesus Christ was the subject of this \"word of life\"; or, which i all one, the subject of the \"words of this life eternal,\" that ou Saviour offered them. So (Acts 15:7) the word of God is called \"th word of the Gospel,\" because it containeth the doctrine of the kingdo of Christ; and the same word (Rom. 10:8�-�9) is called \"the word o faith\"; that is, as is there expressed, the doctrine of Christ come and raised from the dead. Also (Matt. 13:19), \"When anyone heareth th word of the kingdom,\" that is, the doctrine of the kingdom taught b Christ. Again, the same word is said (Acts 12:24) \"to grow and to b multiplied\"; which to understand of the evangelical doctrine is easy but of the voice or speech of God, hard and strange. In the same sens (1 Tim. 4:1) the \"doctrine of devils\" signifieth not the words of an devil, but the doctrine of heathen men concerning \"demons,\" and thos phantasms which they worshipped as gods."} +{"text":"Considering these two significations of the \"word of God,\" as it i taken in Scripture, it is manifest in this latter sense, where it i taken for the doctrine of Christian religion, that the whole Scriptur is the word of God: but in the former sense, not so. For example though these words, \"I am the Lord thy God,\" etc., to the end of th Ten Commandments, were spoken by God to Moses; yet the preface, \"Go spake these words and said,\" is to be understood for the words of hi that wrote the holy history. The \"word of God,\" as it is taken for tha which He hath spoken, is understood sometimes \"properly,\" sometime \"metaphorically.\" \"Properly,\" as the words He hath spoken to Hi prophets: \"metaphorically,\" for His wisdom, power, and eternal decree in making the world; in which sense, those fiats, \"Let there be light,\ \"Let there be a firmament,\" \"Let us make man,\" etc. (Gen. 1), are th word of God. And in the same sense it is said (John 1:3), \"All thing were made by it, and without it was nothing made that was made\": an (Heb. 1:3), \"He upholdeth all things by the word of His power\"; tha is, by the power of His word; that is, by His power: and (Heb. 11:3) \"The worlds were framed by the word of God\"; and many other places t the same sense: as also amongst the Latins, the name of \"fate,\" whic signifieth properly \"the word spoken,\" is taken in the same sense."} +{"text":"Secondly, for the effect of His word; that is to say, for the thin itself, which by His word is affirmed, commanded, threatened, o promised; as (Psalm 105:19) where Joseph is said to have been kept i prison \"till his word was come\"; that is, till that was come to pas which he had foretold to Pharaoh's butler (Gen. 40:13) concerning hi being restored to his office: for there, \"by his word was come,\" i meant, the thing itself was come to pass. So also (1 Kings 18:36 Elijah saith to God, \"I have done all these thy words,\" instead of, \" have done all these things at thy word,\" or commandment; and (Jer 17:15), \"Where is the word of the Lord\" is put for \"Where is the evi he threatened.\" And (Ezek. 12:28), \"There shall none of my words b prolonged any more\": by \"words\" are understood those \"things\" which Go promised to His people. And in the New Testament (Matt. 24:35), \"Heave and earth shall pass away, but my words shall not pass away\"; that is there is nothing that I have promised or foretold that shall not com to pass. And in this sense it is that St. John the Evangelist, and think St. John only, calleth our Saviour himself as in the flesh \"th word of God,\" as (John 1:14) \"the word was made flesh\"; that is to say the word or promise that Christ should come into the world; \"who in th beginning was with God\"; that is to say, it was in the purpose of Go the Father to send God the Son into the world to enlighten men in th way of eternal life; but it was not till then put in execution an actually incarnate. So that our Saviour is there called the \"word,\" no because He was the promise, but the thing promised. They that takin occasion from this place do commonly call Him the verb of God, do bu render the text more obscure. They might as well term Him the noun o God: for as by \"noun,\" so also by \"verb,\" men understand nothing but part of speech, a voice, a sound, that neither affirms, nor denies, no commands, nor promiseth, nor is any substance corporeal or spiritual and therefore it cannot be said to be either God or man; whereas ou Saviour is both. And this \"word,\" which St. John in his gospel sait was with God, is (in his first Epistle, verse 1) called the \"word o life\"; and (verse 2) \"the eternal life, which was with the Father.\" S that He can be in no other sense called the \"word\" than in that wherei He is called eternal life; that is, \"He that hath procured us eterna life\" by His coming in the flesh. So also (Apocalypse 19:13) th apostle, speaking of Christ clothed in a garment dipped in blood saith, His name is \"the word of God\"; which is to be understood as i He had said His name had been \"He that was come, according to th purpose of God from the beginning, and according to His word an promises delivered by the prophets.\" So that there is nothing here o the incarnation of a word, but of the incarnation of God the Son therefore called \"the word,\" because His incarnation was th performance of the promise; in like manner as the Holy Ghost is calle (Acts 1:4; Luke 24:49) \"the promise.\""} +{"text":"There are also places of the Scripture, where, by the \"word of God,\" i signified such words as are consonant to reason and equity, thoug spoken sometimes neither by prophet, nor by a holy man. Fo Pharaoh-Necho was an idolater; yet his words to the good king Josiah in which he advised him by messengers, not to oppose him in his marc against Charchemish, are said to have proceeded from the mouth of God and Josiah, not hearkening to them, was slain in the battle; as is t be read (2 Chron. 35:21�-�23). It is true, that as the same history i related in the first book of Esdras, not Pharaoh, but Jeremiah, spak these words to Josiah, from the mouth of the Lord. But we are to giv credit to the canonical Scripture, whatsoever be written in th Apocrypha."} +{"text":"The \"word of God,\" is then also to be taken for the dictates of reaso and equity, when the same is said in the Scriptures to be written i man's heart; as Psalm 37:31; Jer. 31:33; Deut. 30:11, 14, and man other like places."} +{"text":"The name of \"prophet\" signifieth in Scripture, sometimes \"prolocutor\" that is, he that speaketh from God to man, or from man to God: an sometimes \"predictor,\" or a foreteller of things to come: and sometime one that speaketh incoherently, as men that are distracted. It is mos frequently used in the sense of speaking from God to the people. S Moses, Samuel, Elijah, Isaiah, Jeremiah, and others were \"prophets.\ And in this sense the high priest was a \"prophet,\" for he only wen into the sanctum sanctorum to inquire of God; and was to declare Hi answer to the people. And therefore when Caiaphas said it was expedien that one man should die for the people, St. John saith (11:51) that \"H spake not this of himself, but being high priest that year, h prophesied that one man should die for the nation.\" Also they that i Christian congregations taught the people (1 Cor. 14:3), are said t prophesy. In the like sense it is that God saith to Moses (Exod. 4:16 concerning Aaron, \"He shall be thy spokesman to the people; and h shall be to thee a mouth, and thou shalt be to him instead of God\" that which here is \"spokesman,\" is (Exod. 7:1) interpreted prophet \"See,\" saith God, \"I have made thee a god to Pharaoh, and Aaron th brother shall be thy prophet.\" In the sense of speaking from man t God, Abraham is called a prophet (Gen. 20:7), where God in a drea speaketh to Abimelech in this manner, \"Now therefore restore the ma his wife, for he is a prophet, and shall pray for thee\": whereby may b also gathered that the name of prophet may be given, not unproperly, t them that in Christian churches have a calling to say public prayer for the congregation. In the same sense, the prophets that came dow from the high place, or hill of God, with a psaltery and a tabret, an a pipe, and a harp (1 Sam. 10:5�-�6, 10), Saul amongst them, are sai to prophesy, in that they praised God in that manner publicly. In th like sense is Miriam (Exod. 15:20) called a prophetess. So is it als to be taken (1 Cor. 11:4�-�5), where St. Paul saith, \"Every man tha prayeth or prophesieth with his head covered, etc., and every woma that prayeth or prophesieth with her head uncovered\"; for prophesy i that place signifieth no more but praising God in psalms and hol songs; which women might do in the church, though it were not lawfu for them to speak to the congregation. And in this signification it i that the poets of the heathen, that composed hymns and other sorts o poems in the honour of their gods, were called vates, prophets; as i well enough known by all that are versed in the books of the Gentiles and as is evident (Tit. 1:12), where St. Paul saith of the Cretians that a prophet of their own said they were liars; not that St. Pau held their poets for prophets, but acknowledgeth that the word prophe was commonly used to signify them that celebrated the honour of God i verse."} +{"text":"When by prophesy is meant prediction, or foretelling of futur contingence; not only they were prophets, who were God's spokesmen, an foretold those things to others which God had foretold to them; bu also all those impostors that pretend, by help of familiar spirits, o by superstitious divination of events past, from false causes t foretell the like events in time to come; of which, as I have declare already in the twelfth chapter of this discourse, there be many kinds who gain in the opinion of the common sort of men a greater reputatio of prophesy, by one casual event that may be but wrested to thei purpose, that can be lost again by never so many failings. Prophesy i not an art, nor, when it is taken for prediction, a constant vocation but an extraordinary and temporary employment from God, most often o good men, but sometimes also of the wicked. The woman of Endor, who i said to have had a familiar spirit, and thereby to have raised phantasm of Samuel, and foretold Saul his death, was not therefore prophetess, for neither had she any science, whereby she could rais such a phantasm, nor does it appear that God commanded the raising o it; but only guided that imposture to be a means of Saul's terror an discouragement, and by consequent, of the discomfiture by which h fell. And for incoherent speech it was amongst the Gentiles taken fo one sort of prophecy, because the prophets of their oracles intoxicated with a spirit or vapour from the cave of the Pythian oracl at Delphi, were for the time really mad, and spake like madmen; o whose loose words a sense might be made to fit any event, in such sort as all bodies are said to be made of materia prima. In Scripture I fin it also so taken (1 Sam. 18:10) in these words, \"And the evil spiri came upon Saul, and he prophesied in the midst of the house.\""} +{"text":"And although there be so many significations in Scripture of the wor \"prophet\"; yet is that the most frequent, in which it is taken for him to whom God speaketh immediately that which the prophet is to say fro Him, to some other man, or to the people. And hereupon a question ma be asked, in what manner God speaketh to such a prophet. Can it, ma some say, be properly said that God hath voice and language, when i cannot be properly said He hath a tongue or other organs as a man? Th prophet David argueth thus (Psalm 94:9), \"Shall He that made the eye not see? or He that made the ear, not hear?\" But this may be spoken not as usually, to signify God's nature, but to signify our intentio to honour Him. For to \"see\" and \"hear,\" are honourable attributes, an may be given to God to declare, as far as our capacity can conceive His almighty power. But if it were to be taken in the strict and prope sense, one might argue from His making of all other parts of man' body, that He had also the same use of them which we have; which woul be many of them so uncomely as it would be the greatest contumely i the world to ascribe them to Him. Therefore we are to interpret God' speaking to men immediately, for that way, whatsoever it be, by whic God makes them understand His will. And the ways whereby He doth thi are many, and to be sought only in the Holy Scripture; where thoug many times it be said that God spake to this and that person, withou declaring in what manner; yet there be again many places that delive also the signs by which they were to acknowledge His presence an commandment; and by these may be understood how He spake to many of th rest."} +{"text":"In what manner God spake to Adam, and Eve, and Cain, and Noah, is no expressed: nor how He spake to Abraham, till such time as he came ou of his own country to Sichem, in the land of Canaan; and then (Gen 12:7) God is said to have \"appeared\" to him. So there is one wa whereby God made His presence manifest; that is, by an \"apparition\" o \"vision.\" And again (Gen. 15:1), \"The word of the Lord came to Abraham in a vision,\" that is to say, somewhat as a sign of God's presence appeared as God's messenger to speak to him. Again, the Lord appeare to Abraham (Gen. 18:1) by an apparition of three angels, and t Abimelech (Gen. 20:3) in a dream; to Lot (Gen. 19:1) by an apparitio of two angels; and to Agar (Gen. 21:17) by the apparition of one angel and to Abraham again (Gen. 22:11) by the apparition of a voice fro heaven; and (Gen. 26:24) to Isaac in the night, that is, in his sleep or by dream; and to Jacob (Gen. 28:12) in a dream, that is to say, a are the words of the text, \"Jacob dreamed that he saw a ladder,\" etc. and (Gen. 32:1) in a vision of angels; and to Moses (Exod. 3:2) in th apparition of a flame of fire out of the midst of a bush. And after th time of Moses, where the manner how God spake immediately to man in th Old Testament is expressed, He spake always by a vision, or by a dream as to Gideon, Samuel, Eliah, Elisha, Isaiah, Ezekiel, and the rest o the prophets; and often in the New Testament, as to Joseph, t St. Peter, to St. Paul, and to St. John the Evangelist in th Apocalypse."} +{"text":"Only to Moses He spake in a more extraordinary manner in Mount Sinai and in the Tabernacle; and to the high priest in the Tabernacle, and i the sanctum sanctorum of the Temple. But Moses, and after him the hig priests, were prophets of a more eminent place and degree in God' favour; and God himself in express words declareth, that to othe prophets He spake in dreams and visions, but to His servant Moses, i such a manner as a man speaketh to his friend. The words are thes (Numb. 12:6�-�8), \"If there be a prophet among you, I the Lord wil make myself known to him in a vision, and will speak unto him in dream. My servant Moses is not so, who is faithful in all my house with him I will speak mouth to mouth, even apparently, not in dar speeches; and the similitude of the Lord shall he behold.\" And (Exod 33:11), \"The Lord spake to Moses face to face, as a man speaketh to hi friend.\" And yet this speaking of God to Moses, was by mediation of a angel, or angels, as appears expressly, Acts 7:35, 53, and Gal. 3:19 and was therefore a vision, though a more clear vision than was give to other prophets. And conformable hereunto, where God saith (Deut 13:1), \"If there arise amongst you a prophet, or dreamer of dreams,\ the latter word is but the interpretation of the former. And (Joe 2:28), \"Your sons and your daughters shall prophesy; your old men shal dream dreams, and your young men shall see visions\"; where again th word \"prophesy\" is expounded by \"dream\" and \"vision.\" And in the sam manner it was that God spake to Solomon, promising him wisdom, riches and honour; for the text saith (1 Kings 3:15), \"And Solomon awoke, an behold it was a dream\"; so that generally the prophets extraordinary i the Old Testament took notice of the word of God no otherwise than fro their dreams or visions; that is to say, from the imaginations whic they had in their sleep, or in an extasy: which imaginations in ever true prophet were supernatural; but in false prophets were eithe natural or feigned."} +{"text":"The same prophets were nevertheless said to speak by the spirit; a (Zech. 7:12); where the prophet speaking of the Jews, saith, \"They mad their hearts hard as adamant, lest they should hear the law, and th words which the Lord of hosts hath sent in His Spirit by the forme prophets.\" By which it is manifest, that speaking by the \"spirit,\" o \"inspiration,\" was not a particular manner of God's speaking, differen from vision, when they that were said to speak by the Spirit wer extraordinary prophets, such as for every new message were to have peculiar commission, or which is all one, a new dream or vision."} +{"text":"Of prophets, that were so by a perpetual calling in the Old Testament some were \"supreme,\" and some \"subordinate\": supreme were first Moses and after him the high priests, everyone for his time, as long as th priesthood was royal; and after the people of the Jews had rejecte God, that He should no more reign over them, those kings whic submitted themselves to God's government, were also His chief prophets and the high priest's office became ministerial. And when God was to b consulted, they put on the holy vestments, and inquired of the Lord a the king commanded them, and were deprived of their office when th king thought fit. For king Saul (1 Sam. 13:9) commanded th burnt-offering to be brought, and (1 Sam. 14:18) he commands th priests to bring the ark near him; and (verse 19) again to let i alone, because he saw an advantage upon his enemies. And in the sam chapter (verse 37) Saul asketh counsel of God. In like manner kin David, after his being anointed, though before he had possession of th kingdom, is said to \"inquire of the Lord\" (1 Sam. 23:2) whether h should fight against the Philistines at Keilah: and (verse 9) Davi commandeth the priest to bring him the ephod, to inquire whether h should stay in Keilah or not. And king Solomon (1 Kings 2:27) took th priesthood from Abiathar and gave it (verse 35) to Zadok. Therefor Moses, and the high priests, and the pious kings, who inquired of Go on all extraordinary occasions how they were to carry themselves, o what event they were to have, were all sovereign prophets. But in wha manner God spake unto them is not manifest. To say that when Moses wen up to God in Mount Sinai, it was a dream or vision, such as othe prophets had, is contrary to that distinction which God made betwee Moses and other prophets (Numb. 12:6�-�8). To say God spake or appeare as He is in His own nature, is to deny His infiniteness, invisibility incomprehensibility. To say He spake by inspiration, or infusion of th Holy Spirit, as the Holy Spirit signifieth the Deity, is to make Mose equal with Christ, in whom only the Godhead (as St. Paul speaketh, Col 2:9) dwelleth bodily. And lastly, to say He spake by the Holy Spirit as it signifieth the graces or gifts of the Holy Spirit, is t attribute nothing to Him supernatural. For God disposeth men to piety justice, mercy, truth, faith, and all manner of virtue, both moral an intellectual, by doctrine, example, and by several occasions, natura and ordinary."} +{"text":"And as these ways cannot be applied to God in His speaking to Moses a Mount Sinai; so also they cannot be applied to Him in His speaking t the high priests from the mercy seat. Therefore in what manner Go spake to those sovereign prophets of the Old Testament, whose office i was to inquire of Him, is not intelligible. In the time of the Ne Testament, there was no sovereign prophet but our Saviour, who was bot God that spake, and the prophet to whom He spake."} +{"text":"To subordinate prophets of perpetual calling, I find not any place tha proveth God spake to them supernaturally; but only in such manner a naturally He inclineth men to piety, to belief, to righteousness, an to other virtues all other Christian men. Which way, though it consis in constitution, instruction, education, and the occasions an invitements men have to Christian virtues, yet it is truly attribute to the operation of the Spirit of God, or Holy Spirit, which we in ou language call the Holy Ghost; for there is no good inclination that i not of the operation of God. But these operations are not alway supernatural. When therefore a prophet is said to speak in the spirit or by the Spirit of God, we are to understand no more but that h speaks according to God's will, declared by the supreme prophet. Fo the most common acceptation of the word spirit, is in the significatio of a man's intention, mind, or disposition."} +{"text":"In the time of Moses, there were seventy men besides himself tha \"prophesied\" in the camp of the Israelites. In what manner God spake t them, is declared in Numbers 11:25: \"The Lord came down in a cloud, an spake unto Moses, and took of the spirit that was upon him, and gave i to the seventy elders. And it came to pass, when the spirit rested upo them, they prophesied and did not cease.\" By which it is manifest first, that their prophesying to the people was subservient an subordinate to the prophesying of Moses; for that God took of th spirit of Moses, to put upon them; so that they prophesied as Mose would have them: otherwise they had not been suffered to prophesy a all. For there was (verse 27) a complaint made against them to Moses and Joshua would have Moses to have forbidden them; which he did not but said to Joshua, \"be not jealous in my behalf.\" Secondly, that th spirit of God in that place signifieth nothing but the mind an disposition to obey and assist Moses in the administration of th government. For if it were meant they had the substantial spirit o God; that is, the divine nature, inspired into them, then they had i in no less manner than Christ himself, in whom only the spirit of Go dwelt bodily. It is meant therefore of the gift and grace of God, tha guided them to cooperate with Moses; from whom their spirit wa derived. And it appeareth (Numb. 11:16) that they were such as Mose himself should appoint for elders and officers of the people: for th words are, \"Gather unto me seventy men, whom thou knowest to be elder and officers of the people\": where, \"thou knowest,\" is the same wit \"thou appointest,\" or \"hast appointed to be such.\" For we are tol before (Exod. 18:24) that Moses following the counsel of Jethro, hi father-in-law, did appoint judges and officers over the people, such a feared God; and of these were those seventy, whom God, by putting upo them Moses' spirit, inclined to aid Moses in the administration of th kingdom: and in this sense the spirit of God is said (1 Sam 16:13�-�14) presently upon the anointing of David, to have come upo David, and left Saul; God giving His graces to him He chose to gover His people, and taking them away from him He rejected. So that by th spirit is meant inclination to God's service; and not any supernatura revelation."} +{"text":"God spake also many times by the event of lots; which were ordered b such as He had put in authority over His people. So we read that Go manifested by the lots which Saul caused to be drawn (1 Sam. 14:43) th fault that Jonathan had committed, in eating a honeycomb, contrary t the oath taken by the people. And (Josh. 18:10) God divided the land o Canaan amongst the Israelites, by the \"lots that Joshua did cast befor the Lord in Shiloh.\" In the same manner it seemeth to be, that Go discovered (Joshua 7:16, etc.) the crime of Achan. And these are th ways whereby God declared His will in the Old Testament."} +{"text":"All which ways He used also in the New Testament. To the Virgin Mary by a vision of an angel: to Joseph in a dream: again, to Paul, in th way to Damascus, in a vision of our Saviour: and to Peter in the visio of a sheet let down from heaven, with divers sorts of flesh; of clean and unclean beasts; and in prison, by vision of an angel: and to al the apostles, and writers of the New Testament, by the graces of Hi spirit; and to the apostles again, at the choosing of Matthias in th place of Judas Iscariot, by lot."} +{"text":"Seeing then, all prophecy supposeth vision, or dream (which two, whe they be natural, are the same), or some especial gift of God so rarel observed in mankind as to be admired where observed; and seeing as wel such gifts, as the most extraordinary dreams and visions, may procee from God, not only by his supernatural and immediate, but also by Hi natural operation, and by mediation of second causes; there is need o reason and judgment to discern between natural and supernatural gifts and between natural and supernatural visions or dreams. An consequently men had need to be very circumspect and wary, in obeyin the voice of man, that pretending himself to be a prophet, requires u to obey God in that way, which he in God's name telleth us to be th way to happiness. For he that pretends to teach men the way of so grea felicity, pretends to govern them; that is to say, to rule and reig over them; which is a thing that all men naturally desire, and i therefore worthy to be suspected of ambition and imposture; an consequently, ought to be examined and tried by every man, before h yield them obedience; unless he have yielded it them already, in th institution of a commonwealth; as when the prophet is the civi sovereign, or by the civil sovereign authorized. And if thi examination of prophets and spirits were not allowed to every one o the people, it had been to no purpose to set out the marks by whic every man might be able to distinguish between those whom they ought and those whom they ought not to follow. Seeing therefore such mark are set out (Deut. 13:1, etc.) to know a prophet by; and (1 John 4:1 etc.) to know a spirit by: and seeing there is so much prophesying i the Old Testament, and so much preaching in the New Testament, agains prophets; and so much greater a number ordinarily of false prophets than of true; everyone is to beware of obeying their directions, a their own peril. And first, that there were many more false than tru prophets, appears by this, that when Ahab (1 Kings 22) consulted fou hundred prophets, they were all false impostors, but only one Micaiah And a little before the time of the captivity, the prophets wer generally liars. \"The prophets (saith the Lord, by Jeremiah, 14:14 prophesy lies in my name. I sent them not, neither have I commande them, nor spake unto them; they prophesy to you a false vision, a thin of nought, and the deceit of their heart.\" Insomuch as God commande the people by the mouth of the prophet Jeremiah (23:16) not to obe them: \"Thus saith the Lord of hosts, hearken not unto the words of th prophets, that prophesy to you. They make you vain, they speak a visio of their own heart, and not out of the mouth of the Lord.\""} +{"text":"Seeing then there was in the time of the Old Testament such quarrel amongst the visionary prophets, one contesting with another, an asking, \"When departed the Spirit from me to go to thee?\" as betwee Micaiah and the rest of the four hundred; and such giving of the lie t one another (as in Jerem. 14:14), and such controversies in the Ne Testament at this day, amongst the spiritual prophets; every man the was and now is bound to make use of his natural reason, to apply to al prophecy those rules which God hath given us to discern the true fro false. Of which rules, in the Old Testament, one was, conformabl doctrine to that which Moses the sovereign prophet had taught them; an the other, the miraculous power of foretelling what God would bring t pass, as I have already showed out of Deut. 13:1, etc. And in the Ne Testament there was but one only mark; and that was the preaching o this doctrine, \"that Jesus is the Christ,\" that is, king of the Jews promised in the Old Testament. Whosoever denied that article, he was false prophet, whatsoever miracles he might seem to work; and he tha taught it was a true prophet. For St. John (1 Epist. 4:2, etc.) speaking expressly of the means to examine spirits, whether they be o God, or not; after he had told them that there would arise fals prophets, saith thus: \"Hereby know ye the Spirit of God. Every spiri that confesseth that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh, is of God\" that is, is approved and allowed as a prophet of God: not that he is godly man, or one of the elect, for this, that he confesseth professeth, or preacheth Jesus to be the Christ; but for that he is prophet avowed. For God sometimes speaketh by prophets, whose person He hath not accepted; as He did by Balaam; and as He foretold Saul o his death, by the Witch of Endor. Again in the next verse, \"Ever spirit that confesseth not that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh, i not of Christ; and this is the spirit of Antichrist.\" So that the rul is perfect on both sides; that he is a true prophet, which preachet the Messiah already come, in the person of Jesus; and he a false on that denieth Him come, and looketh for Him in some future impostor that shall take upon him that honour falsely, whom the apostle ther properly calleth Antichrist. Every man therefore ought to consider wh is the sovereign prophet; that is to say, who it is that is God' vicegerent on earth; and hath next under God, the authority o governing Christian men; and to observe for a rule that doctrine, whic in the name of God, He hath commanded to be taught; and thereby t examine and try out the truth of those doctrines which pretende prophets, with miracle, or without, shall at any time advance: and i they find it contrary to that rule, to do as they did that came t Moses and complained that there were some that prophesied in the camp whose authority so to do they doubted of; and leave to the sovereign as they did to Moses, to uphold or to forbid them, as he should se cause; and if he disavow them, then no more to obey their voice; or i he approve them, then to obey them, as men to whom God hath given part of the spirit of their sovereign. For when Christian men take no their Christian sovereign for God's prophet, they must either tak their own dreams for the prophecy they mean to be governed by, and th tumour of their own hearts for the Spirit of God, or they must suffe themselves to be led by some strange prince; or by some of thei fellow-subjects, that can bewitch them, by slander of the government into rebellion, without other miracle to confirm their calling tha sometimes an extraordinary success and impunity; and by this mean destroying all laws, both divine and human, reduce all order government, and society to the first chaos of violence and civil war."} +{"text":"XXVII"} +{"text":"Of Miracles, and Their Use"} +{"text":"By \"miracles\" are signified the admirable works of God: and therefor they are also called \"wonders.\" And because they are for the most par done for a signification of His commandment, in such occasions, a without them, men are apt to doubt, (following their private natura reasoning,) what He hath commanded, and whatnot, they are commonly, i Holy Scripture, called \"signs,\" in the same sense as they are called b the Latins ostenta and portenta, from showing and fore-signifying tha which the Almighty is about to bring to pass."} +{"text":"To understand therefore what is a miracle, we must first understan what works they are which men wonder at and call admirable. And ther be but two things which make men wonder at any event: the one is, if i be strange, that is to say, such as the like of it hath never, or ver rarely, been produced: the other is, if when it is produced, we canno imagine it to have been done by natural means, but only by th immediate hand of God. But when we see some possible, natural cause o it, how rarely soever the like has been done, or if the like have bee often done, how impossible soever it be to imagine a natural mean thereof, we no more wonder nor esteem it for a miracle."} +{"text":"Therefore, if a horse or cow should speak, it were a miracle; becaus both the thing is strange, and the natural cause difficult to imagine So also were it to see a strange deviation of Nature, in the productio of some new shape of a living creature. But when a man, or othe animal, engenders his like, though we know no more how this is don than the other; yet because it is usual, it is no miracle. In lik manner, if a man be metamorphosed into a stone, or into a pillar, it i a miracle; because strange: but if a piece of wood be so changed because we see it often, it is no miracle; and yet, we know no more b what operation of God the one is brought to pass than the other."} +{"text":"The first rainbow that was seen in the world was a miracle, because th first; and consequently strange; and served for a sign from God, place in heaven, to assure His people there should be no more any universa destruction of the world by water. But at this day, because they ar frequent, they are not miracles, neither to them that know thei natural causes, nor to them who know them not. Again, there be man rare works produced by the art of man: yet when we know they are done because thereby we know also the means how they are done, we count the not for miracles, because not wrought by the immediate hand of God, bu of human industry."} +{"text":"Furthermore, seeing admiration and wonder are consequent to th knowledge and experience wherewith men are endued, some more, som less; it followeth that the same thing may be a miracle to one and no to another. And thence it is that ignorant and superstitious men mak great wonders of those works which other men, knowing to proceed fro Nature (which is not the immediate, but the ordinary work of God) admire not at all: as when eclipses of the sun and moon have been take for supernatural works by the common people; when nevertheless ther were others who could from their natural causes have foretold the ver hour they should arrive: or as when a man, by confederacy and secre intelligence, getting knowledge of the private actions of an ignorant unwary man, thereby tells him what he has done in former times; i seems to him a miraculous thing; but amongst wise and cautelous me such miracles as those cannot easily be done."} +{"text":"Again, it belongeth to the nature of a miracle that it be wrought fo the procuring of credit to God's messengers, ministers, and prophets that thereby men may know they are called, sent, and employed by God and thereby be the better inclined to obey them. And therefore, thoug the creation of the world, and after that the destruction of all livin creatures in the universal deluge, were admirable works; yet becaus they were not done to procure credit to any prophet or other ministe of God, they use not to be called miracles. For how admirable soeve any work be, the admiration consisteth not in that it could be done because men naturally believe the Almighty can do all things; bu because He does it at the prayer or word of a man. But the works of Go in Egypt, by the hand of Moses, were properly miracles; because the were done with intention to make the people of Israel believe tha Moses came unto them, not out of any design of his own interest, but a sent from God. Therefore, after God had commanded him to deliver th Israelites from the Egyptian bondage, when he said (Exod. 4:1), \"The will not believe me, but will say, the Lord hath not appeared unto me,\ God gave him power to turn the rod he had in his hand into a serpent and again to return it into a rod; and by putting his hand into hi bosom, to make it leprous; and again by putting it out, to make i whole; to make the children of Israel believe (as it is verse 5) tha the God of their fathers had appeared unto him: and if that were no enough, He gave him power to turn their waters into blood. And when h had done these miracles before the people, it is said (verse 31) tha \"they believed him.\" Nevertheless, for fear of Pharaoh, they durst no yet obey him. Therefore, the other works which were done to plagu Pharaoh and the Egyptians, tended all to make the Israelites believe i Moses, and were properly miracles. In like manner, if we consider al the miracles done by the hand of Moses, and all the rest of th prophets, till the captivity; and those of our Saviour, and Hi apostles afterwards; we shall find, their end was always to beget o confirm belief, that they came not of their own motion, but were sen by God. We may farther observe in Scripture, that the end of miracle was to beget belief, not universally in all men, elect and reprobate but in the elect only; that is to say, in such as God had determine should become His subjects. For those miraculous plagues of Egypt ha not for their end the conversion of Pharaoh; for God had told Mose before that He would harden the heart of Pharaoh, that he should no let the people go: and when he let them go at last, not the miracle persuaded him, but the plagues forced him to it. So also of ou Saviour, it is written (Matt. 13:58), that He wrought not many miracle in His own country because of their unbelief; and (in Mark 6:5) instea of \"He wrought not many,\" it is \"He could work none.\" It was no because He wanted power, which to say, were blasphemy against God; no that the end of miracles was not to convert incredulous men to Christ for the end of all the miracles of Moses, of the prophets, of ou Saviour, and of His apostles was to add men to the church; but it wa because the end of their miracles was to add to the church, not al men, but such as should be saved; that is to say, such as God ha elected. Seeing therefore our Saviour was sent from His Father, H could not use His power in the conversion of those whom His Father ha rejected. They that expounding this place of St. Mark say that thi word, \"He could not,\" is put for \"He would not,\" do it without exampl in the Greek tongue: where \"would not,\" is put sometimes for \"coul not,\" in things inanimate, that have no will; but \"could not\" fo \"would not\" never: and thereby lay a stumbling-block before wea Christians; as if Christ could do no miracles but amongst th credulous."} +{"text":"From that which I have here set down of the nature and use of miracle, we may define it thus: \"a miracle is a work of God (beside His operation by the way of Nature, ordained in the creation) done, fo the making manifest to His elect the mission of an extraordinar minister for their salvation.\""} +{"text":"And from this definition we may infer: first, that in all miracles th work done is not the effect of any virtue in the prophet, because it i the effect of the immediate hand of God: that is to say, God hath don it, without using the prophet therein as a subordinate cause."} +{"text":"Secondly, that no devil, angel, or other created spirit, can do miracle. For it must either be by virtue of some natural science, or b incantation, that is, by virtue of words. For if the enchanters do i by their own power independent, there is some power that proceedeth no from God, which all men deny; and if they do it by power given them then is the work not from the immediate hand of God, but natural, an consequently no miracle."} +{"text":"There be some texts of Scripture that seem to attribute the power o working wonders equal to some of those immediate miracles wrought b God himself, to certain arts of magic and incantation. As for example when we read that after the rod of Moses being cast on the groun became a serpent (Exod. 7:11), \"the magicians of Egypt did the like b their enchantments\": and that after Moses had turned the waters of th Egyptian streams, rivers, ponds, and pools of water into blood (Exod 7:22), \"the magicians did so likewise with their enchantments\"; an that after Moses had by the power of God brought frogs upon the lan (Exod. 8:7), \"the magicians also did so with their enchantments, an brought up frogs upon the land of Egypt\"; will not a man be apt t attribute miracles to enchantments; that is to say, to the efficacy o the sound of words; and think the same very well proved out of this and other such places? And yet there is no place of Scripture tha telleth us what an enchantment is. If therefore enchantment be not, a many think it, a working of strange effects by spells and words; bu imposture and delusion, wrought by ordinary means, and so far fro supernatural, as the impostors need not the study so much as of natura causes, but the ordinary ignorance, stupidity, and superstition o mankind, to do them; those texts that seem to countenance the power o magic, witchcraft, and enchantment, must needs have another sense tha at first sight they seem to bear."} +{"text":"For it is evident enough that words have no effect but on those tha understand them; and then they have no other but to signify th intentions or passions of them that speak; and thereby produce hope fear, or other passions or conceptions in the hearer. Therefore when rod seemeth a serpent, or the waters blood, or any other miracl seemeth done by enchantment; if it be not to the edification of God' people, not the rod, nor the water, nor any other thing is enchanted that is to say, wrought upon by the words, but the spectator. So tha all the miracle consisteth in this, that the enchanter has deceived man; which is no miracle, but a very easy matter to do."} +{"text":"For such is the ignorance and aptitude to error generally of all men but especially of them that have not much knowledge of natural causes and of the nature and interests of men; as by innumerable and eas tricks to be abused. What opinion of miraculous power, before it wa known there was a science of the course of the stars, might a man hav gained, that should have told the people this hour or day the su should be darkened? A juggler by the handling of his goblets and othe trinkets, if it were not now ordinarily practiced, would be thought t do his wonders by the power at least of the devil. A man that hat practiced to speak by drawing in of his breath (which kind of men i ancient time were called ventriloqui), and so make the weakness of hi voice seem to proceed, not from the weak impulsion of the organs o speech, but from distance of place, is able to make very many me believe it is a voice from Heaven, whatsoever he please to tell them And for a crafty man that hath inquired into the secrets and familia confessions that one man ordinarily maketh to another of his action and adventures past, to tell them him again is no hard matter; and ye there be many that by such means as that obtain the reputation of bein conjurers. But it is too long a business to reckon up the several sort of those men, which the Greeks called thau�atourgoi, that is to say workers of things wonderful: and yet these do all they do by their ow single dexterity. But if we look upon the impostures wrought b confederacy, there is nothing how impossible soever to be done that i impossible to be believed. For two men conspiring, one to seem lame the other to cure him with a charm, will deceive many; but man conspiring, one to seem lame, another so to cure him, and all the res to bear witness, will deceive many more."} +{"text":"In this aptitude of mankind to give too hasty belief to pretende miracles, there can be no better, nor I think any other caution, tha that which God hath prescribed, first by Moses, as I have said befor in the precedent chapter, in the beginning of the 13th and end of th 18th of Deuteronomy; that we take not any for prophets that teach an other religion than that which God's lieutenant, which at that time wa Moses, hath established; nor any, though he teach the same religion whose prediction we do not see come to pass. Moses therefore in hi time, and Aaron and his successors in their times, and the sovereig governor of God's people, next under God himself, that is to say, th head of the Church, in all times, are to be consulted, what doctrine h hath established, before we give credit to a pretended miracle o prophet. And when that is done, the thing they pretend to be a miracle we must both see it done, and use all means possible to consider whether it be really done; and not only so, but whether it be such a no man can do the like by his natural power, but that it requires th immediate hand of God. And in this also we must have recourse to God' lieutenant, to whom in all doubtful cases we have submitted our privat judgments. For example: if a man pretend, after certain words spoke over a piece of bread, that presently God hath made it not bread, but god or a man, or both, and nevertheless it looketh still as like brea as ever it did: there is no reason for any man to think it really done nor consequently to fear him, till he inquire of God, by His vicar o lieutenant, whether it be done or not. If he say not, then followet that which Moses saith (Deut. 18:22), \"he hath spoken i presumptuously, thou shalt not fear him.\" If he say it is done, then h is not to contradict it. So also if we see not, but only hear tell of miracle, we are to consult the lawful Church; that is to say, th lawful head thereof, how far we are to give credit to the relators o it. And this is chiefly the case of men that in these days live unde Christian sovereigns. For in these times I do not know one man tha ever saw any such wondrous work, done by the charm, or at the word, o prayer of a man, that a man endued but with a mediocrity of reaso would think supernatural: and the question is no more whether what w see done be a miracle; whether the miracle we hear or read of were real work, and not the act of a tongue or pen; but in plain terms whether the report be true or a lie. In which question we are no everyone to make our own private reason or conscience, but the publi reason, that is, the reason of God's supreme lieutenant, judge; an indeed we have made him judge already, if we have given him a sovereig power to do all that is necessary for our peace and defence. A privat man has always the liberty, because thought is free, to believe or no believe in his heart those acts that have been given out for miracles according as he shall see what benefit can accrue by men's belief, t those that pretend or countenance them, and thereby conjecture whethe they be miracles or lies. But when it comes to confession of tha faith, the private reason must submit to the public; that is to say, t God's lieutenant. But who is this lieutenant of God, and head of th Church, shall be considered in its proper place hereafter."} +{"text":"XXVIII"} +{"text":"Of the Signification in Scripture of Eternal Life, Hell, Salvation, th World to Come, and Redemption"} +{"text":"The maintenance of civil society depending on justice, and justice o the power of life and death, and other less rewards and punishments residing in them that have the sovereignty of the commonwealth; it i impossible a commonwealth should stand, where any other than th sovereign hath a power of giving greater rewards than life, and o inflicting greater punishments than death. Now seeing \"eternal life\" i a greater reward than the \"life present\"; and \"eternal torment\" greater punishment than the \"death of nature\"; it is a thing worthy t be well considered of all men that desire, by obeying authority, t avoid the calamities of confusion and civil war, what is meant in Hol Scripture by \"life eternal,\" and \"torment eternal\"; and for wha offences and against whom committed, men are to be \"eternall tormented\"; and for what actions they are to obtain \"eternal life.\""} +{"text":"And first we find that Adam was created in such a condition of life, a had he not broken the commandment of God, he had enjoyed it in th paradise of Eden everlastingly. For there was the \"tree of life,\ whereof he was so long allowed to eat, as he should forbear to eat o the tree of knowledge of good and evil; which was not allowed him. An therefore as soon as he had eaten of it, God thrust him out of paradis (Gen. 3:22), \"lest he should put forth his hand, and take also of th tree of life and live forever.\" By which it seemeth to me (wit submission nevertheless both in this, and in all questions whereof th determination dependeth on the Scriptures, to the interpretation of th Bible authorized by the commonwealth, whose subject I am), that Adam if he had not sinned, had had an eternal life on earth, and tha mortality entered upon himself and his posterity by his first sin. No that actual death then entered; for Adam then could never have ha children; whereas he lived long after, and saw a numerous posterity er he died. But where it is said (Gen. 2:17), \"In the day that thou eates thereof, thou shalt surely die,\" it must needs be meant of hi mortality and certitude of death. Seeing then eternal life was lost b Adam's forfeiture in committing sin, he that should cancel tha forfeiture was to recover thereby that life again. Now Jesus Chris hath satisfied for the sins of all that believe in Him; and therefor recovered to all believers that eternal life which was lost by the si of Adam. And in this sense it is that the comparison of St. Pau holdeth (Rom. 5:18�-�19), \"As by the offence of one, judgment came upo all men to condemnation, even so by the righteousness of one the fre gift came upon all men to justification of life\"; which is agai (1 Cor. 15:21�-�22) more perspicuously delivered in these words: \"Fo since by man came death, by man came also the resurrection of the dead For as in Adam all die, even so in Christ shall all be made alive.\""} +{"text":"Concerning the place wherein men shall enjoy that eternal life whic Christ hath obtained for them, the texts next before alleged seem t make it on earth. For if as in Adam all die, that is, have forfeite paradise and eternal life on earth, even so in Christ all shall be mad alive; then all men shall be made to live on earth, for else th comparison were not proper. Hereunto seemeth to agree that of th Psalmist (Psalm 133:3), \"upon Zion God commanded the blessing, eve life for evermore\"; for Zion is in Jerusalem upon earth; as also tha of St. John (Rev. 2:7), \"To him that overcometh I will give to eat o the tree of life, which is in the midst of the paradise of God.\" Thi was the tree of Adam's eternal life; but his life was to have been o earth. The same seemeth to be confirmed again by St. John (Rev. 21:2) where he saith, \"I John saw the holy city, new Jerusalem, coming dow from God out of heaven, prepared as a bride adorned for her husband\" and again (verse 10) to the same effect; as if he should say, the ne \"Jerusalem,\" the paradise of God, at the coming again of Christ, shoul come down to God's people from heaven, and not they go up to it fro earth. And this differs nothing from that which the two men in whit clothing, that is the two angels, said to the apostles that wer looking upon Christ ascending (Acts 1:11), \"This same Jesus, who i taken upon from you into heaven, shall so come as you have seen Him g up into heaven.\" Which soundeth as if they had said He should come dow to govern them under His Father eternally here, and not to take them u to govern them in heaven; and is conformable to the restoration of th kingdom of God instituted under Moses, which was a political governmen of the Jews on earth. Again, that saying of our Saviour (Matt. 22:30) \"that in the resurrection they neither marry, nor are given i marriage, but are as the angels of God in heaven,\" is a description o an eternal life, resembling that which we lost in Adam in the point o marriage. For seeing Adam and Eve, if they had not sinned, had lived o earth eternally in their individual persons; it is manifest they shoul not continually have procreated their kind; for if immortals shoul have generated as mankind doth now, the earth in a small time would no have been able to afford them place to stand on. The Jews that aske our Saviour the question, whose wife the woman that had married man brothers should be in the resurrection, knew not what were th consequences of life eternal: and therefore our Saviour puts them i mind of this consequence of immortality; that there shall be n generation, and consequently no marriage, no more than there i marriage or generation among the angels. The comparison between tha eternal life which Adam lost, and our Saviour by His victory over deat hath recovered, holdeth also in this; that as Adam lost eternal life b his sin, and yet lived after it for a time, so the faithful Christia hath recovered eternal life by Christ's passion, though he die natural death, and remain dead for a time, namely, till th resurrection. For as death is reckoned from the condemnation of Adam not from the execution; so life is reckoned from the absolution, no from the resurrection of them that are elected in Christ."} +{"text":"That the place wherein men are to live eternally, after th resurrection, is the heavens (meaning by heaven, those parts of th world which are the most remote from earth, as where the stars are, o above the stars, in another higher heaven, called coelum empyreum whereof there is no mention in Scripture, nor ground in reason), is no easily to be drawn from any text that I can find. By the Kingdom o Heaven is meant the kingdom of the King that dwelleth in heaven; an His kingdom was the people of Israel, whom He ruled by the prophets His lieutenants; first Moses, and after him Eleazar, and the sovereig priests, till in the days of Samuel they rebelled, and would have mortal man for their king, after the manner of other nations. And whe our Saviour Christ, by the preaching of His ministers, shall hav persuaded the Jews to return, and called the Gentiles to His obedience then shall there be a new kingdom of heaven; because our king shal then be God, whose \"throne\" is heaven: without any necessity evident i the Scripture, that man shall ascend to his happiness any higher tha God's \"footstool\" the earth. On the contrary, we find written (Joh 3:13) that \"no man hath ascended into heaven, but He that came dow from heaven, even the Son of man, that is in heaven.\" Where I observ by the way, that these words are not, as those which go immediatel before, the words of our Saviour, but of St. John himself; for Chris was then not in heaven, but upon the earth. The like is said of Davi (Acts 2:34), where St. Peter, to prove the ascension of Christ, usin the words of the Psalmist (Psalm 16:10), \"Thou wilt not leave my sou in hell, nor suffer thine holy one to see corruption,\" saith they wer spoken not of David but of Christ; and to prove it addeth this reason \"For David is not ascended into heaven.\" But to this a man may easil answer and say, that though their bodies were not to ascend till th general day of judgment, yet their souls were in heaven as soon as the were departed from their bodies; which also seemeth to be confirmed b the words of our Saviour (Luke 20:37�-�38), who proving th resurrection out of the words of Moses, saith thus, \"That the dead ar raised, even Moses showed at the bush, when he calleth the Lord the Go of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob. For He is not God of the dead, but of the living; for they all live to Him.\" But i these words be to be understood only of the immortality of the soul they prove not at all that which our Saviour intended to prove, whic was the resurrection of the body, that is to say, the immortality o the man. Therefore our Saviour meaneth that those patriarchs wer immortal; not by a property consequent to the essence and nature o mankind; but by the will of God, that was pleased of His mere grace t bestow \"eternal life\" upon the faithful. And though at that time th patriarchs and many other faithful men were \"dead,\" yet as it is in th text, they \"lived to God\"; that is, they were written in the Book o Life with them that were absolved of their sins, and ordained to lif eternal at the resurrection. That the soul of man is in its own natur eternal, and a living creature independent on the body, or that an mere man is immortal otherwise than by the resurrection in the las day, except Enoch and Elias, is a doctrine not apparent in Scripture The whole of the 14th chapter of Job, which is the speech not of hi friends, but of himself, is a complaint of this mortality of nature and yet no contradiction of the immortality at the resurrection. \"Ther is hope of a tree,\" saith he (verse 7), \"if it be cast down. Though th root thereof wax old, and the stock thereof die in the ground, yet whe it scenteth the water it will bud, and bring forth boughs like a plant But man dieth and wasteth away, yea, man giveth up the ghost, and wher is he?\" And (verse 12), \"Man lieth down and riseth not, till th heavens be no more.\" But when is it that the heavens shall be no more St. Peter tells us that it is at the general resurrection. For in hi second Epistle, 3:7, he saith that \"the heavens and the earth that ar now, are reserved unto fire against the day of judgment, and perditio of ungodly men\"; and (verse 12), \"looking for, and hasting to th coming of God, wherein the heavens shall be on fire and shall b dissolved, and the elements shall melt with fervent heat. Nevertheles we according to the promise look for new heavens and a new earth wherein dwelleth righteousness.\" Therefore where Job saith \"man riset not till the heavens be no more\"; it is all one as if he had said th immortal life (and soul and life in the Scripture do usually signif the same thing) beginneth not in man till the resurrection and day o judgment; and hath for cause, not his specifical nature and generation but the promise. For St. Peter says, not \"We look for new heavens and new earth from nature,\" but \"from promise.\""} +{"text":"Lastly, seeing it hath been already proved out of divers evident place of Scripture, in chap. XXXV of this book, that the kingdom of God is civil commonwealth, where God himself is sovereign, by virtue first o the \"old,\" and since of the \"new\" covenant, wherein He reigneth by Hi vicar or lieutenant; the same places do therefore also prove, tha after the coming again of our Saviour in His majesty and glory, t reign actually and eternally, the kingdom of God is to be on earth. Bu because this doctrine, though proved out of places of Scripture not fe nor obscure, will appear to most men a novelty, I do but propound it maintaining nothing in this, or any other paradox of religion; bu attending the end of that dispute of the sword, concerning th authority, not yet amongst my countrymen decided, by which all sorts o doctrine are to be approved or rejected; and whose commands, both i speech and writing, whatsoever be the opinions of private men, must b all men, that mean to be protected by their laws, be obeyed. For th points of doctrine concerning the kingdom of God have so grea influence on the kingdom of man, as not to be determined but by the that under God have the sovereign power."} +{"text":"As the kingdom of God, and eternal life, so also God's enemies, an their torments after judgment, appear by the Scripture to have thei place on earth. The name of the place, where all men remain till th resurrection, that were either buried or swallowed up of the earth, i usually called in Scripture by words that signify \"under ground\"; whic the Latins read generally infernus and inferi, and the Greek h`ady*s that is to say, a place where men cannot see; and containeth as wel the grave as any other deeper place. But for the place of the damne after the resurrection, it is not determined, neither in the Old no New Testament, by any note of situation; but only by the company: a that it shall be where such wicked men were, as God in former times, i extraordinary and miraculous manner, had destroyed from off the face o the earth: as for example, that they are in Inferno, in Tartarus, or i the bottomless pit; because Corah, Dathan, and Abiron, were swallowe up alive into the earth. Not that the writers of the Scripture woul have us believe there could be in the globe of the earth, which is no only finite, but also, compared to the height of the stars, of n considerable magnitude, a pit without a bottom, that is, a hole o infinite depth, such as the Greeks in their \"demonology\" (that is t say, in their doctrine concerning \"demons\"), and after them the Romans called Tartarus; of which Virgil (Aen. VI 578, 579) says,"} +{"text":" Bis patet in praeceps tantum, tenditque sub umbras Quantus ad aetherium coeli suspectus Olympum:"} +{"text":"for that is a thing the proportion of earth to heaven cannot bear: bu that we should believe them there, indefinitely, where those men are o whom God inflicted that exemplary punishment."} +{"text":"Again, because those mighty men of the earth, that lived in the time o Noah before the flood, (which the Greeks called \"heroes,\" and th Scripture \"giants,\" and both say were begotten by copulation of th children of God with the children of men,) were for their wicked lif destroyed by the general deluge; the place of the damned is therefor also sometimes marked out by the company of those deceased giants; a Proverbs 21:16, \"The man that wandereth out of the way of understandin shall remain in the congregation of the giants\": and Job 26:5, \"Behol the giants groan under water, and they that dwell with them.\" Here th place of the damned is under the water. And Isaiah 14:9, \"Hell i troubled how to meet thee (that is, the king of Babylon) and wil displace the giants for thee\": and here again the place of the damned if the sense be literal, is to be under water. Thirdly, because th cities of Sodom and Gomorrah, by the extraordinary wrath of God, wer consumed for their wickedness with fire and brimstone, and togethe with them the country about made a stinking bituminous lake: the plac of the damned is sometimes expressed by fire, and a fiery lake, as i the Apocalypse 21:8, \"But the timorous, incredulous, and abominable and murderers, and whoremongers, and sorcerers, and idolaters, and al liars, shall have their part in the lake that burneth with fire an brimstone, which is the second death.\" So that it is manifest, tha hell fire, which is here expressed by metaphor from the real fire o Sodom, signifieth not any certain kind or place of torment; but is t be taken indefinitely for destruction, as it is in Rev. 20:14, where i is said, that \"death and hell were cast into the lake of fire\"; that i to say, were abolished and destroyed; as if after the day of judgmen there shall be no more dying, nor no more going into hell; that is, n more going to Hades, (from which word perhaps our word Hell i derived,) which is the same with no more dying."} +{"text":"Fourthly, from the plague of darkness inflicted on the Egyptians, o which it is written (Exod. 10:23), \"They saw not one another, neithe rose any man from his place for three days; but all the children o Israel had light in their dwellings\"; the place of the wicked afte judgment, is called \"utter darkness,\" or, as it is in the original \"darkness without.\" And so it is expressed (Matt. 22:13) where the kin commanded his servants, \"to bind hand and foot the man that had not o his wedding garment, and to cast him out,\" e�*s t� skoto*s t� cw%teron \"into external darkness,\" or \"darkness without\": which thoug translated \"utter darkness,\" does not signify \"how great,\" but \"where\ that darkness is to be; namely, \"without the habitation\" of God' elect."} +{"text":"Lastly, whereas there was a place near Jerusalem, called the Valley o the Children of Hinnon; in a part whereof, called Tophet, the Jews ha committed most grievous idolatry, sacrificing their children to th idol Moloch; and wherein also God had afflicted his enemies with mos grievous punishments; and wherein Josiah had burned the priests o Moloch upon their own altars, as appeareth at large in the 2nd of King 23; the place served afterwards to receive the filth and garbage whic was carried thither out of the city; and there used to be fires mad from time to time to purify the air, and take away the stench o carrion. From this abominable place, the Jews used ever after to cal the place of the damned by the name of Gehenna, or Valley of Hinnon And this Gehenna is that word which is usually now translated \"hell\" and from the fires from time to time there burning, we have the notio of \"everlasting\" and \"unquenchable fire.\""} +{"text":"Seeing now there is none that so interprets the Scripture, as tha after the day of judgment, the wicked are all eternally to be punishe in the Valley of Hinnon; or that they shall so rise again, as to b ever after under ground or under water; or that after the resurrectio they shall no more see one another, nor stir from one place to another it followeth, methinks, very necessarily, that that which is thus sai concerning hell fire is spoken metaphorically; and that therefore ther is a proper sense to be inquired after (for of all metaphors there i some real ground that may be expressed in proper words), both of th \"place of hell,\" and the nature of \"hellish torments,\" an \"tormentors.\""} +{"text":"And first for the tormentors, we have their nature and properties exactly and properly delivered by the names of the Enemy, or Satan; th Accuser, or Diabolus; the Destroyer, or Abaddon. Which significan names, Satan, Devil, Abaddon, set not forth to us any individua person, as proper names use to do; but only an office, or quality; an are therefore appellatives; which ought not to have been lef untranslated, as they are in the Latin and modern Bibles; becaus thereby they seem to be proper names of \"demons\"; and men are the mor easily seduced to believe the doctrine of devils; which at that tim was the religion of the Gentiles, and contrary to that of Moses and o Christ."} +{"text":"And because by the Enemy, the Accuser, and Destroyer, is meant th enemy of them that shall be in the kingdom of God; therefore if th kingdom of God after the resurrection be upon the earth, as in th former chapter I have shown by Scripture it seems to be, the Enemy an his kingdom must be on earth also. For so also was it, in the tim before the Jews had deposed God. For God's kingdom was in Palestine and the nations round about, were the kingdoms of the Enemy; an consequently by Satan is meant any earthly enemy of the Church."} +{"text":"The torments of hell, are expressed sometimes, by \"weeping and gnashin of teeth,\" as Matt. 8:12. Sometimes by \"the worm of conscience\"; a Isaiah 66:24, and Mark 9:44, 46, 48: sometimes, by fire, as in th place now quoted, \"where the worm dieth not, and the fire is no quenched,\" and many places beside: sometimes by \"shame and contempt,\ as Dan. 12:2, \"And many of them that sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake; some to everlasting life; and some to shame, an everlasting contempt.\" All which places design metaphorically a grie and discontent of mind, from the sight of that eternal felicity i others, which they themselves through their own incredulity an disobedience have lost. And because such felicity in others, is no sensible but by comparison with their own actual miseries; it followet that they are to suffer such bodily pains and calamities, as ar incident to those, who not only live under evil and cruel governors but have also for enemy the eternal king of the saints, God Almighty And amongst these bodily pains, is to be reckoned also to every one o the wicked a second death. For though the Scripture be clear for a universal resurrection; yet we do not read, that to any of th reprobate is promised an eternal life. For whereas St. Paul (1 Cor 15:42�-�43) to the question concerning what bodies men shall rise wit again, saith, that \"The body is sown in corruption, and is raised i incorruption; it is sown in dishonour, it is raised in glory; it i sown in weakness, it is raised in power.\" Glory and power cannot b applied to the bodies of the wicked: nor can the name of \"second death\ be applied to those that can never die but once: and although i metaphorical speech, a calamitous life everlasting may be called a everlasting death, yet it cannot well be understood of a \"secon death.\""} +{"text":"The fire prepared for the wicked, is an everlasting fire: that is t say, the estate wherein no man can be without torture, both of body an mind, after the resurrection, shall endure forever; and in that sens the fire shall be unquenchable, and the torments everlasting: but i cannot thence be inferred, that he who shall be cast into that fire, o be tormented with those torments, shall endure and resist them so as t be eternally burnt and tortured, and yet never be destroyed, nor die And though there be many places that affirm everlasting fire an torments, into which men may be cast successively one after another a long as the world lasts, yet I find none that affirm there shall be a eternal life therein of any individual person; but to the contrary, a everlasting death, which is the second death. (Rev. 20:13�-�14), \"Fo after death and the grave shall have delivered up the dead which wer in them, and every man be judged according to his works; death and th grave shall also be cast into the lake of fire. This is the secon death.\" Whereby it is evident that there is to be a second death o everyone that shall be condemned at the day of judgment, after which h shall die no more."} +{"text":"The joys of life eternal are in Scripture comprehended all under th name \"Salvation,\" or \"being saved.\" To be saved is to be secured either respectively against special evils, or absolutely against al evils, comprehending want, sickness, and death itself. And because ma was created in a condition immortal, not subject to corruption, an consequently to nothing that tendeth to the dissolution of his nature and fell from that happiness by the sin of Adam; it followeth, that t be \"saved\" from sin, is to be saved from all the evil and calamitie that sin hath brought upon us. And therefore in the Holy Scripture remission of sin, and salvation from death and misery, is the sam thing, as it appears by the words of our Saviour, who having cured man sick of the palsy by saying (Matt. 9:2), \"Son be of good cheer, th sins be forgiven thee\"; and knowing that the Scribes took for blasphem that a man should pretend to forgive sins, asked them (verse 5 \"whether it were easier to say, Thy sins be forgiven thee, or, Aris and walk\"; signifying thereby, that it was all one, as to the saving o the sick, to say, \"Thy sins are forgiven,\" and \"Arise and walk\"; an that He used that form of speech only to show He had the power t forgive sins. And it is besides evident in reason, that since death an misery were the punishments of sin, the discharge of sin must also be discharge of death and misery; that is to say, salvation absolute, suc as the faithful are to enjoy after the day of judgment, by the powe and favour of Jesus Christ, who for that cause is called our \"Saviour.\""} +{"text":"Concerning particular salvations, such as are understood (1 Sam 14:39), \"as the Lord liveth that saveth Israel,\" that is, from thei temporary enemies, and (2 Sam. 22:3), \"Thou art my Saviour, thou saves me from violence\"; and (2 Kings 13:5), \"God gave the Israelites Saviour, and so they were delivered from the hand of the Assyrians,\ and the like, I need say nothing; there being neither difficulty no interest to corrupt the interpretation of texts of that kind."} +{"text":"But concerning the general salvation, because it must be in the kingdo of heaven, there is great difficulty concerning the place. On one side by \"kingdom,\" which is an estate ordained by men for their perpetua security against enemies and want, it seemeth that this salvatio should be on earth. For by salvation is set forth unto us a gloriou reign of our king, by conquest; not a safety by escape: and therefor there where we look for salvation, we must look also for triumph; an before triumph, for victory; and before victory, for battle; whic cannot well be supposed shall be in heaven. But how good soever thi reason may be, I will not trust to it, without very evident places o Scripture. The state of salvation is described at large (Isaia 33:20�-�24):"} +{"text":"\"Look upon Zion, the city of our solemnities; thine eyes shall se Jerusalem a quiet habitation, a tabernacle that shall not be take down; not one of the stakes thereof shall ever be removed, neithe shall any of the cords thereof be broken."} +{"text":"\"But there the glorious Lord will be unto us a place of broad river and streams; wherein shall go no galley with oars, neither shal gallant ship pass thereby."} +{"text":"\"For the Lord is our Judge, the Lord is our lawgiver, the Lord is ou king, he will save us."} +{"text":"\"Thy tacklings are loosed; they could not well strengthen their mast they could not spread the sail: then is the prey of a great spoi divided; the lame take the prey:"} +{"text":"\"And the inhabitant shall not say, I am sick; the people that shal dwell therein, shall be forgiven their iniquity.\""} +{"text":"In which words we have the place from whence salvation is to proceed \"Jerusalem, a quiet habitation\"; the eternity of it, \"a tabernacle tha shall not be taken down,\" etc.; the Saviour of it, \"the Lord, thei Judge, their lawgiver, their king, He will save us\"; the salvation \"the Lord shall be to them as a broad moat of swift waters,\" etc.; th condition of their enemies, \"their tacklings are loose, their mast weak, the lame shall take the spoil of them\"; the condition of th saved, \"the inhabitant shall not say, I am sick\": and lastly, all thi is comprehended in forgiveness of sin, \"the people that dwell therei shall be forgiven their iniquity.\" By which it is evident, tha salvation shall be on earth, then, when God shall reign, at the comin again of Christ, in Jerusalem; and from Jerusalem shall proceed th salvation of the Gentiles that shall be received into God's kingdom: a is also more expressly declared by the same prophet (Isaia 66:20�-�21), \"And they (that is the Gentiles who had any Jew i bondage) shall bring all your brethren, for an offering to the Lord out of all nations, upon horses, and in chariots, and in litters, an upon mules, and upon swift beasts, to my holy mountain, Jerusalem saith the Lord, as the children of Israel bring an offering in a clea vessel into the house of the Lord. And I will also take of them fo priests and for Levites, saith the Lord.\" Whereby it is manifest, tha the chief seat of God's kingdom, which is the place from whence th salvation of us that were Gentiles shall proceed, shall be Jerusalem and the same is also confirmed by our Saviour in His discourse with th woman of Samaria, concerning the place of God's worship; to whom H saith (John 4:22), that the Samaritans worshipped they knew not what but the Jews worshipped what they knew, \"for salvation is of the Jews\ (ex Judaeis, that is, begins at the Jews): as if He should say, yo worship God, but know not by whom He will save you, as we do, that kno it shall be by one of the tribe of Judah; a Jew, not a Samaritan. An therefore also the woman not impertinently answered Him again, \"We kno the Messias shall come.\" So that which our Saviour saith, \"Salvation i from the Jews,\" is the same that Paul says (Rom. 1:16�-�17), \"Th gospel is the power of God to salvation to everyone that believeth: t the Jew first, and also to the Greek. For therein is the righteousnes of God revealed from faith to faith\"; from the faith of the Jew to th faith of the Gentile. In the like sense the prophet Joel describing th day of Judgment (2:30�-�31), that God would \"show wonders in heaven and in earth, blood and fire, and pillars of smoke; the sun shall b turned to darkness, and the moon into blood, before the great an terrible day of the Lord come\"; he addeth (verse 32), \"and it shal come to pass that whosoever shall call upon the name of the Lord shal be saved. For in Mount Zion and in Jerusalem shall be salvation.\" An Obadiah (verse 17) saith the same: \"Upon Mount Zion shall b deliverance; and there shall be holiness, and the house of Jacob shal possess their possessions,\" that is the possessions of the \"heathen,\ which \"possessions\" he expresseth more particularly in the followin verses, by the Mount of Esau, the land of the Philistines, the field of Ephraim, of Samaria, Gilead, and the cities of the south; an concludes with these words, \"the kingdom shall be the Lord's.\" Al these places are for salvation and the kingdom of God, after the day o judgment upon earth. On the other side, I have not found any text tha can probably be drawn to prove any ascension of the saints into heaven that is to say, into any coelum empyreum, or other ethereal region saving that it is called the kingdom of Heaven: which name it may have because God, that was King of the Jews, governed them by His commands sent to Moses by angels from heaven; and after the revolt, sent His So from heaven to reduce them to their obedience; and shall send Hi thence again to rule both them and all other faithful men, from the da of judgment, everlasting; or from that, that the throne of this ou great King is in heaven; whereas the earth is but His footstool. Bu that the subjects of God should have any place as high as His throne or higher than His footstool, it seemeth not suitable to the dignity o a king, nor can I find any evident text for it in Holy Scripture."} +{"text":"From this that hath been said of the kingdom of God, and of salvation it is not hard to interpret what is meant by the \"world to come.\" Ther are three worlds mentioned in Scripture, the \"old world,\" the \"presen world,\" and the \"world to come.\" Of the first, St. Peter speaks (2 Pet 2:5), \"If God spared not the old world, but saved Noah, the eight person, a preacher of righteousness, bringing the flood upon the worl of the ungodly,\" etc. So the \"first world\" was from Adam to the genera flood. Of the present world, our Saviour speaks (John 18:36), \"M kingdom is not of this world.\" For He came only to teach men the way o salvation, and to renew the kingdom of His Father, by His doctrine. O the world to come, St. Peter speaks (2 Pet. 3:13), \"Nevertheless w according to His promise look for new heavens, and a new earth.\" Thi is that \"world\" wherein Christ, coming down from heaven in the clouds with great power and glory, shall send His angels, and shall gathe together His elect from the four winds, and from the uttermost parts o the earth, and thenceforth reign over them under His Father everlastingly."} +{"text":"\"Salvation\" of a sinner supposeth a precedent \"redemption\"; for he tha is once guilty of sin is obnoxious to the penalty of the same; and mus pay, or some other for him, such ransom as he that is offended, and ha him in his power, shall require. And seeing the person offended i Almighty God, in whose power are all things; such ransom is to be pai before salvation can be acquired, as God hath been pleased to require By this ransom is not intended a satisfaction for sin equivalent to th offence, which no sinner for himself, nor righteous man, can ever b able to make for another the damage a man does to another, he may mak amends for by restitution or recompense; but sin cannot be taken awa by recompense; for that were to make the liberty to sin a thin vendible. But sins may be pardoned to the repentant, either gratis, o upon such penalty as God is pleased to accept. That which God usuall accepted in the Old Testament was some sacrifice or oblation. T forgive sin is not an act of injustice, though the punishment have bee threatened. Even amongst men, though the promise of good bind th promiser; yet threats, that is to say, promises of evil, bind them not much less shall they bind God, who is infinitely more merciful tha men. Our Saviour Christ therefore to \"redeem\" us, did not in that sens satisfy for the sins of men as that His death, of its own virtue, coul make it unjust in God to punish sinners with eternal death; but di make that sacrifice and oblation of himself at his first coming, whic God was pleased to require for the salvation at His second coming, o such as in the meantime should repent and believe in Him. And thoug this act of our \"redemption\" be not always in Scripture called \"sacrifice,\" and \"oblation,\" but sometimes a \"price\"; yet by \"price\" w are not to understand anything by the value whereof He could clai right to a pardon for us from His offended Father; but that price whic God the Father was pleased in mercy to demand."} +{"text":"XXIX"} +{"text":"Of the Signification in Scripture of the Word Church"} +{"text":"The word Church (Ecclesia) signifieth in the books of Holy Scriptur divers things. Sometimes, though not often, it is taken for \"God' house,\" that is to say, for a temple wherein Christians assembled t perform holy duties publicly, as (1 Cor. 14:34), \"Let your women kee silence in the Churches.\" But this is metaphorically put for th congregation there assembled, and hath been since used for the edific itself, to distinguish between the temples of Christians and idolaters The Temple of Jerusalem was \"God's house,\" and the house of prayer; an so is any edifice dedicated by Christians to the worship of Christ \"Christ's house\"; and therefore the Greek fathers call it Kuriak�, \"th Lord's house\"; and thence in our language it came to be called \"kyrke\ and \"church.\""} +{"text":"Church, when not taken for a house, signifieth the same that ecclesi signified in the Grecian commonwealth, that is to say, a congregatio or an assembly of citizens called forth to hear the magistrate spea unto them; and which in the commonwealth of Rome was called concio; a he that spake was called ecclesiastes and concionator. And when the were called forth by lawful authority (Acts 19:39), it was Ecclesi legitima, a \"lawful Church,\" nno�o*s kklysi'a. But when they wer excited by tumultuous and seditious clamour, then it was a confuse Church, kklysi'a sugkexu�e'ny."} +{"text":"It is taken also sometimes for the men that have right to be of th congregation though not actually assembled, that is to say, for th whole multitude of Christian men, how far soever they be dispersed: a (Acts 8:3), where it is said that \"Saul made havoc of the Church\"; an in this sense is Christ said to be the head of the Church. An sometimes for a certain part of Christians, as (Col. 4:15), \"Salute th Church that is in his house.\" Sometimes also for the elect only, a (Eph. 5:27), \"A glorious Church, without spot, or wrinkle, holy, an without blemish\"; which is meant of the \"Church triumphant\" or \"Churc to come.\" Sometimes, for a congregation assembled of professors o Christianity, whether their profession be true or counterfeit, as it i understood (Matt. 18:17), where it is said, \"Tell it to the Church; an if he neglect to hear the Church, let him be to thee as a Gentile, o publican.\""} +{"text":"And in this last sense only it is that the \"Church\" can be taken fo one person, that is to say, that it can be said to have power to will to pronounce, to command, to be obeyed, to make laws, or to do an other action whatsoever. For without authority from a lawfu congregation, whatsoever act be done in a concourse of people, it i the particular act of every one of those that were present, and gav their aid to the performance of it, and not the act of them all i gross, as of one body, much less the act of them that were absent, or that being present, were not willing it should be done. According t this sense, I define a \"Church\" to be \"a company of men professin Christian religion, united in the person of one sovereign, at whos command they ought to assemble, and without whose authority they ough not to assemble.\" And because in all commonwealths that assembly, whic is without warrant from the civil sovereign, is unlawful, that Churc also which is assembled in any commonwealth that hath forbidden them t assemble, is an unlawful assembly."} +{"text":"It followeth also that there is on earth no such universal Church, a all Christians are bound to obey; because there is no power on earth t which all other commonwealths are subject. There are Christians in th dominions of several princes and states, but every one of them i subject to that commonwealth whereof he is himself a member; an consequently, cannot be subject to the commands of any other person And therefore a Church, such a one as is capable to command, to judge absolve, condemn, or do any other act, is the same thing with a civi commonwealth, consisting of Christian men; and is called a \"civi state,\" for that the subjects of it are \"men\"; and a \"Church,\" for tha the subjects thereof are \"Christians.\" \"Temporal\" and \"spiritual\ government are but two words brought into the world to make men se double, and mistake their \"lawful sovereign.\" It is true that th bodies of the faithful, after the resurrection, shall be not onl spiritual but eternal; but in this life they are gross and corruptible There is therefore no other government in this life, neither of state nor religion, but temporal; nor teaching of any doctrine, lawful to an subject, which the governor both of the state and of the religio forbiddeth to be taught. And that governor must be one; or else ther must needs follow faction and civil war in the commonwealth between th \"Church\" and \"State\"; between \"spiritualists\" and \"temporalists\" between the \"sword of justice,\" and the \"shield of faith\": and, whic is more, in every Christian man's own breast, between the \"Christian\ and the \"man.\" The doctors of the Church are called pastors; so als are civil sovereigns. But if pastors be not subordinate one to another so as that there may be one chief pastor, men will be taught contrar doctrines, whereof both may be, and one must be false. Who that on chief pastor is, according to the law of Nature, hath been alread shown; namely, that it is the civil sovereign; and to whom th Scripture hath assigned that office we shall see in the chapter following."} +{"text":"L"} +{"text":"Of the Rights of the Kingdom of God, in Abraham, Moses, the Hig Priests, and the Kings of Judah"} +{"text":"The father of the faithful, and first in the kingdom of God b covenant, was Abraham. For with him was the covenant first made wherein he obliged himself and his seed after him, to acknowledge an obey the commands of God; not only such as he could take notice of (a moral laws), by the light of Nature, but also such as God should i special manner deliver to him by dreams and visions. For as to th moral law, they were already obliged, and needed not have bee contracted withal by promise of the land of Canaan. Nor was there an contract that could add to or strengthen the obligation by which bot they and all men else were bound naturally to obey God Almighty: an therefore the covenant which Abraham made with God was to take for th commandment of God, that which in the name of God was commanded him i a dream or vision; and to deliver it to his family, and cause them t observe the same."} +{"text":"In this contract of God with Abraham we may observe three points o important consequence in the government of God's people. First, that a the making of this covenant, God spake only to Abraham; and therefor contracted not with any of his family, or seed, otherwise than as thei wills, which make the essence of all covenants, were before th contract involved in the will of Abraham, who was therefore supposed t have had a lawful power to make them perform all that he covenanted fo them. According whereunto (Gen. 18:18�-�19), God saith, \"All th nations of the earth shall be blessed in him; for I know him that h will command his children and his household after him, and they shal keep the way of the Lord.\" From whence may be concluded this firs point, that they to whom God hath not spoken immediately are to receiv the positive commandments of God from their sovereign, as the famil and seed of Abraham did from Abraham their father, and lord, and civi sovereign. And consequently in every commonwealth they who have n supernatural revelation to the contrary, ought to obey the laws o their own sovereign in the external acts and profession of religion. A for the inward \"thought\" and \"belief\" of men, which human governors ca take no notice of (for God only knoweth the heart), they are no voluntary, nor the effect of the laws, but of the unrevealed will an of the power of God, and consequently fall not under obligation."} +{"text":"From whence proceedeth another point, that it was not unlawful fo Abraham, when any of his subjects should pretend private vision o spirit, or other revelation from God, for the countenancing of an doctrine which Abraham should forbid, or when they followed or adhere to any such pretender to punish them: and consequently that it i lawful now for the sovereign to punish any man that shall oppose hi private spirit against the laws: for he hath the same place in th commonwealth that Abraham had in his own family."} +{"text":"There ariseth also from the same a third point; that as none bu Abraham in his family, so none but the sovereign in a Christia commonwealth can take notice what is, or what is not, the word of God For God spake only to Abraham; and it was he only that was able to kno what God said, and to interpret the same to his family; and therefor also they that have the place of Abraham in a commonwealth, are th only interpreters of what God hath spoken."} +{"text":"The same covenant was renewed with Isaac, and afterwards with Jacob but afterwards no more till the Israelites were freed from th Egyptians, and arrived at the foot of Mount Sinai; and then it wa renewed by Moses (as I have said before, chap. XXXV), in such manner a they became from that time forward the peculiar kingdom of God; whos lieutenant was Moses, for his own time; and the succession to tha office was settled upon Aaron, and his heirs after him, to be to God sacerdotal kingdom forever."} +{"text":"By this constitution a kingdom is acquired to God. But seeing Moses ha no authority to govern the Israelites, as a successor to the right o Abraham, because he could not claim it by inheritance; it appeareth no as yet that the people were obliged to take him for God's lieutenan longer than they believed that God spake unto him. And therefore hi authority, notwithstanding the covenant they made with God, depende yet merely upon the opinion they had of his sanctity, and of th reality of his conferences with God, and the verity of his miracles which opinion coming to change, they were no more obliged to tak anything for the law of God, which he propounded to them in God's name We are therefore to consider what other ground there was of thei obligation to obey him. For it could not be the commandment of God tha could oblige them; because God spake not to them immediately, but b the mediation of Moses himself; and our Saviour saith of himself (Joh 5:31), \"If I bear witness of myself, my witness is not true\"; much les if Moses bear witness of himself, especially in a claim of kingly powe over God's people, ought his testimony to be received. His authorit therefore, as the authority of all other princes, must be grounded o the consent of the people, and their promise to obey him. And so i was; for \"the people\" (Exod. 20:18�-�19), \"when they saw th thunderings, and the lightnings, and the noise of the trumpets, and th mountain smoking, removed, and stood afar off. And they said unt Moses, Speak thou with us and we will hear, but let not God speak wit us lest we die.\" Here was their promise of obedience; and by this i was they obliged themselves to obey whatsoever he should deliver unt them for the commandment of God."} +{"text":"And notwithstanding the covenant constituted a sacerdotal kingdom, tha is to say, a kingdom hereditary to Aaron; yet that is to be understoo of the succession after Moses should be dead. For whosoever orderet and establisheth the policy, as first founder of a commonwealth, be i monarchy, aristocracy, or democracy, must needs have sovereign powe over the people all the while he is doing of it. And that Moses ha that power all his own time is evidently affirmed in the Scripture First in the text last before cited, because the people promise obedience, not to Aaron, but to him. Secondly (Exod. 24:1�-�2), \"An God said unto Moses, Come up unto the Lord, thou and Aaron, Nadab an Abihu, and seventy of the elders of Israel. And Moses alone shall com near the Lord, but they shall not come nigh, neither shall the peopl go up with him.\" By which it is plain, that Moses, who was alone calle up to God (and not Aaron, nor the other priests, nor the sevent elders, nor the people who were forbidden to come up), was alone h that represented to the Israelites the person of God, that is to say was their sole sovereign under God. And though afterwards it be sai (verses 9, 10), \"Then went up Moses and Aaron, Nadab and Abihu, an seventy of the elders of Israel, and they saw the God of Israel, an there was under his feet, as it were a paved work of a sapphire stone,\ etc.; yet this was not till after Moses had been with God before, an had brought to the people the words which God had said to him. He onl went for the business of the people; the others as the nobles of hi retinue, were admitted for honour to that special grace, which was no allowed to the people; which was, as in the verse after appeareth, t see God and live, \"God laid not his hand upon them, they saw God an did eat and drink,\" that is, did live: but did not carry an commandment from Him to the people. Again, it is everywhere said \"th Lord spake unto Moses,\" as in all other occasions of government, s also in the ordering of the ceremonies of religion, contained i chapters 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30 and 31 of Exodus, and throughou Leviticus: to Aaron seldom. The calf that Aaron made, Moses threw int the fire. Lastly, the question of the authority of Aaron, by occasio of his and Miriam's mutiny against Moses, was (Numb. 12) judged by Go himself for Moses. So also in the question between Moses and th people, who had the right of governing the people, when Corah, Dathan and Abiram, and two hundred and fifty princes of the assembly \"gathere themselves together (Numb. 16:3) against Moses and against Aaron, an said unto them, ye take too much upon you, seeing all the congregatio are holy, every one of them, and the Lord is amongst them, why lift yo up yourselves above the congregation of the Lord?\" God caused the eart to swallow Corah, Dathan, and Abiram, with their wives and children alive, and consumed those two hundred and fifty princes with fire Therefore neither Aaron, nor the people, nor any aristocracy of th chief princes of the people, but Moses alone had next under God th sovereignty over the Israelites: and that not only in causes of civi policy, but also of religion: for Moses only spake with God, an therefore only could tell the people what it was that God required a their hands. No man upon pain of death might be so presumptuous as t approach the mountain where God talked with Moses. \"Thou shalt se bounds\" (saith the Lord, Exod. 19:12) \"to the people round about, an say, Take heed to yourselves that you go not up into the mount, o touch the border of it; whosoever toucheth the mount shall surely b put to death.\" And again (verse 21), \"Go down, charge the people, les they break through unto the Lord to gaze.\" Out of which we may conclud that whosoever in a Christian commonwealth holdeth the place of Moses is the sole messenger of God, and interpreter of His commandments. An according hereunto, no man ought in the interpretation of the Scriptur to proceed further than the bounds which are set by their severa sovereigns. For the Scriptures, since God now speaketh in them, are th Mount Sinai; the bounds whereof are the laws of them that represen God's person on earth. To look upon them, and therein to behold th wondrous works of God and learn to fear Him, is allowed; but t interpret them, that is, to pry into what God saith to him whom h appointeth to govern under him, and make themselves judges whether h govern as God commandeth him or not, is to transgress the bounds Go hath set us, and to gaze upon God irreverently."} +{"text":"There was no prophet in the time of Moses, nor pretender to the spiri of God, but such as Moses had approved and authorized. For there wer in his time but seventy men that are said to prophesy by the spirit o God, and these were all of Moses his election; concerning whom God sai to Moses (Numb. 11:16), \"Gather to me seventy of the elders of Israel whom thou knowest to be the elders of the people.\" To these Go imparted His spirit; but it was not a different spirit from that o Moses; for it is said (verse 25), \"God came down in a cloud, and too of the spirit that was upon Moses, and gave it to the seventy elders.\ But as I have shown before (chap. XXXVI) by \"spirit\" is understood th \"mind\"; so that the sense of the place is no other than this, that Go endued them with a mind conformable and subordinate to that of Moses that they might prophesy, that is to say, speak to the people in God' name, in such manner, as to set forward, as ministers of Moses and b his authority, such doctrine as was agreeable to Moses his doctrine For they were but ministers; and when two of them prophesied in th camp, it was thought a new and unlawful thing; and as it is in verse 27 and 28 of the same chapter, they were accused of it, and Joshu advised Moses to forbid them, as not knowing that it was by Moses hi spirit that they prophesied. By which it is manifest that no subjec ought to pretend to prophesy, or to the spirit, in opposition to th doctrine established by him whom God hath set in the place of Moses."} +{"text":"Aaron being dead, and after him also Moses, the kingdom, as being sacerdotal kingdom, descended by virtue of the covenant to Aaron's son Eleazar the high priest: and God declared him, next under himself, fo sovereign, at the same time that He appointed Joshua for the general o their army. For thus God saith expressly (Numb. 27:21) concernin Joshua: \"He shall stand before Eleazar the priest, who shall as counsel for him before the Lord; at his word shall they go out, and a his word they shall come in, both he, and all the children of Israe with him.\" Therefore the supreme power of making war and peace was i the priest. The supreme power of judicature belonged also to the hig priest: for the Book of the Law was in their keeping; and the priest and Levites only were the subordinate judges in causes civil, a appears in Deut. 17:8�-�10. And for the manner of God's worship, ther was never doubt made but that the high priest till the time of Saul ha the supreme authority. Therefore the civil and ecclesiastical powe were both joined together in one and the same person, the high priest and ought to be so, in whosoever governeth by divine right, that is, b authority immediate from God."} +{"text":"After the death of Joshua, till the time of Saul, the time between i noted frequently in the Book of Judges, \"That there was in those day no king in Israel\"; and sometimes with this addition, that \"every ma did that which was right in his own eyes.\" By which is to be understoo that where it is said, \"there was no king,\" is meant, \"there was n sovereign power\" in Israel. And so it was, if we consider the act an exercise of such power. For after the death of Joshua and Eleazar \"there arose another generation (Judges 2:10�-�11) that knew not th Lord, nor the works which He had done for Israel, but did evil in th sight of the Lord, and served Baalim.\" And the Jews had that qualit which St. Paul noteth, \"to look for a sign,\" not only before they woul submit themselves to the government of Moses, but also after they ha obliged themselves by their submission. Whereas signs and miracles ha for end to procure faith, not to keep men from violating it, when the have once given it; for to that men are obliged by the law of Nature But if we consider not the exercise, but the right of governing, th sovereign power was still in the high priest. Therefore whatsoeve obedience was yielded to any of the judges, who were men chosen by Go extraordinarily to save His rebellious subjects out of the hands of th enemy, it cannot be drawn into argument against the right the hig priest had to the sovereign power, in all matters both of policy an religion. And neither the judges nor Samuel himself had an ordinary but an extraordinary calling to the government; and were obeyed by th Israelites, not out of duty, but out of reverence to their favour wit God, appearing in their wisdom, courage, or felicity. Hithert therefore the right of regulating both the policy and the religion wer inseparable."} +{"text":"To the judges succeeded kings: and whereas before, all authority, bot in religion and policy, was in the high priest; so now it was all i the king. For the sovereignty over the people, which was before, no only by virtue of the divine power, but also by a particular pact o the Israelites, in God, and next under Him, in the high priest, as Hi vicegerent on earth, was cast off by the people, with the consent o God himself. For when they said to Samuel (1 Sam. 8:5), \"Make us a kin to judge us like all the nations,\" they signified that they would n more be governed by the commands that should be laid upon them by th priest, in the name of God: but by one that should command them in th same manner that all other nations were commanded; and consequently i deposing the high priest of royal authority, they deposed that peculia government of God. And yet God consented to it, saying to Samue (1 Sam. 7:7), \"Hearken unto the voice of the people, in all that the shall say unto thee; for they have not rejected thee, but they hav rejected me, that I should not reign over them.\" Having therefor rejected God, in whose right the priests governed, there was n authority left to the priests, but such as the king was pleased t allow them; which was more or less, according as the kings were good o evil. And for the government of civil affairs, it is manifest it wa all in the hands of the king. For in the same chapter (verse 20) the say, \"they will be like all the nations; that their king shall be thei judge, and go before them, and fight their battles\"; that is, he shal have the whole authority both in peace and war. In which is containe also the ordering of religion: for there was no other word of God i that time, by which to regulate religion but the law of Moses, whic was their civil law. Besides, we read (1 Kings 2:27), that \"Solomo thrust out Abiathar from being priest before the Lord\": he ha therefore authority over the high priest, as over any other subject which is a great mark of supremacy in religion. And we read also ( Kings 8), that he dedicated the temple; that he blessed the people; an that he himself in person made that excellent prayer, used in th consecration of all churches and houses of prayer; which is anothe great mark of supremacy in religion. Again, we read (2 Kings 22), tha when there was question concerning the Book of the Law found in th temple, the same was not decided by the high priest, but Josiah sen both him and others to inquire concerning it of Huldah, the prophetess which is another mark of supremacy in religion. Lastly, we rea (1 Chron. 26:30), that David made Hashabiah and his brethren Hebronites, officers of Israel among them westward, \"in all thei business of the Lord, and in the service of the king.\" Likewise (vers 32) that he made other Hebronites \"rulers over the Reubenites, th Gadites, and the half tribe of Manasseh\" (these were the rest of Israe that dwelt beyond Jordan), \"for every matter pertaining to God, an affairs of the king.\" Is not this full power, both \"temporal\" an \"spiritual,\" as they call it that would divide it? To conclude; fro the first institution of God's kingdom to the captivity, the supremac of religion was in the same hand with that of the civil sovereignty and the priest's office after the election of Saul, was not magisteria but ministerial."} +{"text":"Notwithstanding the government both in policy and religion, wer joined, first in the high priests, and afterwards in the kings, so fa forth as concerned the right; yet it appeareth by the same hol history, that the people understood it not: but there being amongs them a great part, and probably the greatest part, that no longer tha they saw great miracles, or, what is equivalent to a miracle, grea abilities, or great felicity in the enterprises of their governors gave sufficient credit either to the fame of Moses or to the colloquie between God and the priests; they took occasion as oft as thei governors displeased them, by blaming sometimes the policy, sometime the religion, to change the government or revolt from their obedienc at their pleasure: and from thence proceeded from time to time th civil troubles, divisions, and calamities of the nation. As fo example, after the death of Eleazar and Joshua, the next generatio which had not seen the wonders of God, but were left to their own wea reason, not knowing themselves obliged by the covenant of a sacerdota kingdom, regarded no more the commandment of the priest nor any law o Moses, but did every man that which was right in his own eyes, an obeyed in civil affairs such men as from time to time they thought abl to deliver them from the neighbour nations that oppressed them; an consulted not with God, as they ought to do, but with such men or wome as they guessed to be prophets by their predictions of things to come and though they had an idol in their chapel, yet if they had a Levit for their chaplain, they made account they worshipped the God o Israel."} +{"text":"And afterwards when they demanded a king after the manner of th nations; yet it was not with a design to depart from the worship of Go their king; but despairing of the justice of the sons of Samuel, the would have a king to judge them in civil actions; but not that the would allow their king to change the religion which they thought wa recommended to them by Moses. So that they always kept in store pretext, either of justice or religion, to discharge themselves o their obedience, whensoever they had hope to prevail. Samuel wa displeased with the people, for that they desired a king; for God wa their king already, and Samuel had but an authority under Him; yet di Samuel, when Saul observed not his counsel, in destroying Agag as Go had commanded, anoint another king, namely David, to take th succession from his heirs. Rehoboam was no idolater; but when th people thought him an oppressor, that civil pretence carried from hi ten tribes to Jeroboam an idolater. And generally through the whol history of the kings, as well of Judah as of Israel, there wer prophets that always controlled the kings, for transgressing th religion; and sometimes also for errors of state; as Jehosaphat wa reproved (2 Chron. 19:2) by the prophet Jehu, for aiding the king o Israel against the Syrians; and Hezekiah, by Isaiah (39:3�-�7), fo showing his treasures to the ambassadors of Babylon. By all which i appeareth, that though the power both of state and religion were in th kings; yet none of them were uncontrolled in the use of it, but such a were gracious for their own natural abilities or felicities. So tha from the practice of those times, there can no argument be drawn, tha the right of supremacy in religion was not in the kings, unless w place it in the prophets, and conclude that because Hezekiah praying t the Lord before the cherubims, was not answered from thence, nor then but afterwards by the prophet Isaiah, therefore Isaiah was supreme hea of the Church; or because Josiah consulted Huldah the prophetess concerning the Book of the Law, that therefore neither he nor the hig priest, but Huldah the prophetess, had the supreme authority in matte of religion; which I think is not the opinion of any doctor."} +{"text":"During the captivity, the Jews had no commonwealth at all: and afte their return, though they renewed their covenant with God, yet ther was no promise made of obedience, neither to Esdras, nor to any other and presently after, they became subjects to the Greeks, from whos customs and demonology, and from the doctrine of the Cabalists, thei religion became much corrupted: in such sort as nothing can be gathere from their confusion, both in state and religion, concerning th supremacy in either. And therefore so far forth as concerneth the Ol Testament, we may conclude that whosoever had the sovereignty of th commonwealth amongst the Jews, the same had also the supreme authorit in matter of God's external worship, and represented God's person; tha is, the person of God the Father; though he were not called by the nam of Father, till such time as He sent into the world His Son Jesu Christ, to redeem mankind from their sins, and bring them into Hi everlasting kingdom, to be saved for evermore. Of which we are to spea in the chapter following."} +{"text":"LI"} +{"text":"Of the Office of Our Blessed Saviour"} +{"text":"We find in Holy Scripture three parts of the office of the Messiah: th first of a \"Redeemer\" or \"Saviour\"; the second of a \"pastor,\ \"counsellor,\" or \"teacher,\" that is, of a prophet sent from God t convert such as God hath elected to salvation: the third of a \"king,\ an \"eternal king,\" but under His Father, as Moses and the high priest were in their several times. And to these three parts are corresponden three times. For our redemption He wrought at His first coming, by th sacrifice wherein He offered up himself for our sins upon the cross our conversion He wrought partly then in His own person, and partl worketh now by His ministers, and will continue to work till His comin again. And after His coming again, shall begin that His glorious reig over His elect, which is to last eternally."} +{"text":"To the office of a Redeemer, that is, of one that payeth the ransom o sin, which ransom is death, it appertaineth, that He was sacrificed and thereby bare upon His own head and carried away from us ou iniquities, in such sort as God had required. Not that the death of on man, though without sin, can satisfy for the offences of all men, i the rigour of justice, but in the mercy of God, that ordained suc sacrifices for sin, as He was pleased in His mercy to accept. In th old law (as we may read, Levit. 16) the Lord required that ther should, every year once, be made an atonement for the sins of al Israel, both priests and others; for the doing whereof, Aaron alone wa to sacrifice for himself and the priests a young bullock; and for th rest of the people he was to receive from them two young goats, o which he was to \"sacrifice\" one; but as for the other, which was th \"scapegoat,\" he was to lay his hands on the head thereof, and by confession of the iniquities of the people, to lay them all on tha head, and then by some opportune man, to cause the goat to be led int the wilderness, and there to \"escape,\" and carry away with him th iniquities of the people. As the sacrifice of the one goat was sufficient, because an acceptable, price for the ransom of all Israel so the death of the Messiah is a sufficient price for the sins of al mankind, because there was no more required. Our Saviour Christ' sufferings seem to be here figured, as clearly as in the oblation o Isaac, or in any other type of Him in the Old Testament. He was bot the sacrificed goat, and the scapegoat; \"He was oppressed, and He wa afflicted (Isaiah 53:7); He opened not His mouth; He is brought as lamb to the slaughter, and as a sheep is dumb before the shearer, so H opened not His mouth\": here He is the \"sacrificed goat.\" \"He hath born our griefs (verse 4), and carried our sorrows\": and again (verse 6) \"the Lord hath laid upon Him the iniquities of us all\": and so He i the \"scapegoat.\" \"He was cut off from the land of the living (verse 8 for the transgression of my people\": there again He is the \"sacrifice goat.\" And again (verse 11), \"He shall bear their sins\": He is th \"scapegoat.\" Thus is the Lamb of God equivalent to both those goats sacrificed, in that He died; and escaping, in His resurrection; bein raised opportunely by His Father, and removed from the habitation o men in His ascension."} +{"text":"For as much therefore as he that \"redeemeth\" hath no title to th \"thing redeemed,\" before \"the redemption\" and ransom paid; and thi ransom was the death of the Redeemer; it is manifest that our Saviour as man, was not king of those that He redeemed before He suffere death; that is, during that time He conversed bodily on the earth. say, He was not then king in present, by virtue of the pact, which th faithful make with Him in baptism. Nevertheless, by the renewing o their pact with God in baptism, they were obliged to obey Him for king under His Father, whensoever He should be pleased to take the kingdo upon Him. According whereunto, our Saviour himself expressly sait (John 18:36), \"My kingdom is not of this world.\" Now seeing th Scripture maketh mention but of two worlds; this that is now, and shal remain unto the day of judgment, which is therefore also called th \"last day\"; and that which shall be after the day of judgment, whe there shall be a new heaven and a new earth: the kingdom of Christ i not to begin till the general resurrection. And that is it which ou Saviour saith (Matt. 16:27), \"The Son of man shall come in the glory o His Father, with His angels; and then He shall reward every ma according to his works.\" To reward every man according to his works i to execute the office of a king; and this is not to be till He come i the glory of His Father, with His angels. When our Saviour saith (Matt 23:2�-�3), \"The Scribes and Pharisees sit in Moses' seat; all therefor whatsoever they bid you do, that observe and do\"; He declared plainly that He ascribed kingly power, for that time, not to himself, but t them. And so He doth also, where He saith (Luke 12:14), \"Who made me judge or divider over you?\" And (John 12:47), \"I came not to judge th world, but to save the world.\" And yet our Saviour came into this worl that He might be a king and a judge in the world to come: for He wa the Messiah, that is, the Christ, that is, the anointed priest, and th sovereign prophet of God; that is to say, He was to have all the powe that was in Moses the prophet, in the high priests that succeede Moses, and in the kings that succeeded the priests. And St. John say expressly (5:22), \"the Father judgeth no man, but hath committed al judgment to the Son.\" And this is not repugnant to that other place, \" came not to judge the world\": for this is spoken of the world present the other of the world to come; as also where it is said that at th second coming of Christ (Matt. 19:28), \"Ye that have followed me in th regeneration, when the Son of man shall sit in the throne of His glory ye shall also sit on twelve thrones, judging the twelve tribes o Israel.\""} +{"text":"If then Christ, whilst He was on earth, had no kingdom in this world to what end was His first coming? It was to restore unto God by a ne covenant, the kingdom, which being His by the old covenant, had bee cut off by the rebellion of the Israelites in the election of Saul Which to do, He was to preach unto them that He was the Messiah, tha is, the king promised to them by the prophets; and to offer himself i sacrifice for the sins of them that should by faith submit themselve thereto; and in case the nation generally should refuse Him, to call t His obedience such as should believe in Him amongst the Gentiles. S that there are two parts of our Saviour's office during His abode upo the earth: one to proclaim himself the Christ, and another by teachin and by working of miracles, to persuade and prepare men to live so a to be worthy of the immortality believers were to enjoy, at such tim as He should come in majesty to take possession of His Father' kingdom. And therefore it is that the time of His preaching is often b himself called the \"regeneration\"; which is not properly a kingdom, an thereby a warrant to deny obedience to the magistrates that then were for He commanded to obey those that sat then in Moses' chair, and t pay tribute to Caesar, but only an earnest of the kingdom of God tha was to come, to those to whom God had given the grace to be Hi disciples, and to believe in Him; for which cause the godly are said t be already in the \"kingdom of grace,\" as naturalized in that heavenl kingdom."} +{"text":"Hitherto, therefore, there is nothing done or taught by Christ tha tendeth to the diminution of the civil right of the Jews or of Caesar For as touching the commonwealth which then was amongst the Jews, bot they that bare rule amongst them, and they that were governed, did al expect the Messiah and kingdom of God; which they could not have don if their laws had forbidden Him, when He came, to manifest and declar himself. Seeing therefore He did nothing but by preaching and miracle go about to prove himself to be that Messiah, He did therein nothin against their laws. The kingdom He claimed was to be in another world He taught all men to obey in the meantime them that sat in Moses' seat He allowed them to give Caesar his tribute, and refused to take upo himself to be a judge. How then could His words or actions b seditious, or tend to the overthrow of their then civil government? Bu God having determined His sacrifice for the reduction of His elect t their former covenanted obedience, for the means, whereby He woul bring the same to effect, made use of their malice and ingratitude. No was it contrary to the laws of Caesar. For though Pilate himself, t gratify the Jews, delivered Him to be crucified; yet before he did s he pronounced openly that he found no fault in Him: and put for titl of His condemnation, not as the Jews required, \"that He pretended to b king\"; but simply, \"that He was king of the Jews\"; and notwithstandin their clamour, refused to alter it; saying, \"What I have written, have written.\""} +{"text":"As for the third part of His office, which was to be \"king,\" I hav already shown that His kingdom was not to begin till the resurrection But then He shall be king, not only as God, in which sense He is kin already, and ever shall be, of all the earth, in virtue of Hi omnipotence; but also peculiarly of His own elect, by virtue of th pact they make with Him in their baptism. And therefore it is that ou Saviour saith (Matt. 19:28) that His apostles should sit upon twelv thrones, judging the twelve tribes of Israel, \"When the Son of ma shall sit in the throne of His glory\": whereby He signified that H should reign then in His human nature; and Matt. (16:27), \"The Son o man shall come in the glory of His Father, with His angels, and then H shall reward every man according to his works.\" The same we may rea (Mark 13:26, and 14:62); and more expressly for the time (Luk 22:29�-�30), \"I appoint unto you a kingdom, as my Father hath appointe to me, that you may eat and drink at my table in my kingdom, and sit o thrones judging the twelve tribes of Israel.\" By which it is manifes that the kingdom of Christ appointed to Him by His Father is not to b before the Son of man shall come in glory, and make His apostles judge of the twelve tribes of Israel. But a man may here ask, seeing there i no marriage in the kingdom of heaven, whether men shall then eat an drink? What eating therefore is meant in this place? This is expounde by our Saviour (John 6:27), where He saith, \"Labour not for the mea which perisheth, but for that meat which endureth unto everlastin life, which the Son of man shall give you.\" So that by eating a Christ's table is meant the eating of the tree of life; that is to say the enjoying of immortality, in the kingdom of the Son of man. By whic places and many more, it is evident that our Saviour's kingdom is to b exercised by Him in His human nature."} +{"text":"Again, He is to be king then, no otherwise than as subordinate o vicegerent of God the Father, as Moses was in the wilderness; and a the high priests were before the reign of Saul; and as the kings wer after it. For it is one of the prophecies concerning Christ, that H should be like, in office, to Moses: \"I will raise them up a prophet,\ saith the Lord (Deut. 18:18), \"from amongst their brethren, like unt thee, and will put my words into his mouth\"; and this similitude wit Moses is also apparent in the actions of our Saviour himself, whilst H was conversant on earth. For as Moses chose twelve princes of th tribes to govern under him; so did our Saviour choose twelve apostles who shall sit on twelve thrones, and judge the twelve tribes of Israel And as Moses authorized seventy elders to receive the Spirit of God and to prophesy to the people, that is, as I have said before, to spea unto them in the name of God; so our Saviour also ordained sevent disciples to preach His kingdom and salvation to all nations. And a when a complaint was made to Moses against those of the seventy tha prophesied in the camp of Israel, he justified them in it, as bein subservient therein to his government; so also our Saviour, whe St. John complained to Him of a certain man that cast out devils in Hi name, justified him therein, saying (Luke 9:50), \"Forbid him not, fo he that is not against us, is on our part.\""} +{"text":"Again, our Saviour resembled Moses in the institution of \"sacraments,\ both of \"admission\" into the kingdom of God, and of \"commemoration\" o his deliverance of His elect from their miserable condition. As th children of Israel had for sacrament of their reception into th kingdom of God, before the time of Moses, the rite of \"circumcision,\ which rite having been omitted in the wilderness, was again restored a soon as they came into the Land of Promise; so also the Jews, befor the coming of our Saviour, had a rite of \"baptizing,\" that is, o washing with water all those that being Gentiles embraced the God o Israel. This rite St. John the Baptist used in the reception of al them that gave their names to the Christ, whom he preached to b already come into the world; and our Saviour instituted the same for sacrament to be taken by all that believed in Him. From what cause th rite of baptism first proceeded, is not expressed formally in th Scripture; but it may be probably thought to be an imitation of the la of Moses concerning leprosy; wherein the leprous man was commanded t be kept out of the camp of Israel for a certain time; after which tim being judged by the priest to be clean, he was admitted into the cam after a solemn washing. And this may therefore be a type of the washin in baptism; wherein such men as are cleansed of the leprosy of sin b faith, are received into the Church with the solemnity of baptism There is another conjecture, drawn from the ceremonies of the Gentiles in a certain case that rarely happens: and that is, when a man that wa thought dead chanced to recover, other men made scruple to convers with him, as they would do to converse with a ghost, unless he wer received again into the number of men by washing, as children newbor were washed from the uncleanness of their nativity; which was a kind o new birth. This ceremony of the Greeks, in the time that Judaea wa under the dominion of Alexander and the Greeks his successors, ma probably enough have crept into the religion of the Jews. But seeing i is not likely our Saviour would countenance a heathen rite, it is mos likely it proceeded from the legal ceremony of washing after leprosy And for the other sacrament of eating the \"Paschal lamb,\" it i manifestly imitated in the sacrament of the \"Lord's Supper\"; in whic the breaking of the bread, and the pouring out of the wine, do keep i memory our deliverance from the misery of sin, by Christ's passion, a the eating of the Paschal lamb kept in memory the deliverance of th Jews out of the bondage of Egypt. Seeing therefore the authority o Moses was but subordinate, and he but a lieutenant of God; it followet that Christ, whose authority as man was to be like that of Moses, wa no more but subordinate to the authority of his Father. The same i more expressly signified, by that that He teacheth us to pray, \"Ou Father, let thy kingdom come\"; and \"For thine is the kingdom, th power, and the glory\"; and by that it is said, that \"He shall come i the glory of His Father\"; and by that which St. Paul saith (1 Cor 15:24), \"then cometh the end, when He shall have delivered up th kingdom to God, even the Father\"; and by many other most expres places."} +{"text":"Our Saviour, therefore, both in teaching and reigning, representeth, a Moses did, the person of God; which God from that time forward, but no before, is called the Father; and being still one and the sam substance, is one person as represented by Moses, and another person a represented by His Son the Christ. For \"person\" being a relative to \"representer,\" it is consequent to plurality of representers, tha there be a plurality of persons, though of one and the same substance."} +{"text":"LII"} +{"text":"Of Power Ecclesiastical"} +{"text":"For the understanding of \"power ecclesiastical,\" what, and in whom i is, we are to distinguish the time from the ascension of our Saviou into two parts; one before the conversion of kings, and men endued wit sovereign civil power; the other after their conversion. For it wa long after the ascension, before any king or civil sovereign embrace and publicly allowed the teaching of Christian religion."} +{"text":"And for the time between, it is manifest that the \"powe ecclesiastical\" was in the apostles; and after them in such as were b them ordained to preach the Gospel, and to convert men to Christianity and to direct them that were converted in the way of salvation; an after these, the power was delivered again to others by these ordained and this was done by imposition of hands upon such as were ordained; b which was signified the giving of the Holy Spirit, or Spirit of God, t those whom they ordained ministers of God, to advance His kingdom. S that imposition of hands was nothing else but the seal of thei commission to preach Christ, and teach His doctrine; and the giving o the Holy Ghost by that ceremony of imposition of hands, was a imitation of that which Moses did. For Moses used the same ceremony t his minister Joshua, as we read (Deut. 34:9), \"And Joshua the son o Nun was full of the spirit of wisdom, for Moses had laid his hands upo him.\" Our Saviour therefore, between His resurrection and ascension gave His spirit to the apostles; first, by \"breathing on them, an saying\" (John 20:22), \"Receive ye the Holy Spirit\"; and after Hi ascension (Acts 2:2�-�3), by sending down upon them \"a mighty wind, an cloven tongues of fire\"; and not by imposition of hands, as neither di God lay His hands on Moses; and His apostles afterwards transmitted th same spirit by imposition of hands as Moses did to Joshua. So that i is manifest hereby in whom the power ecclesiastical continuall remained, in those first times where there was not any Christia commonwealth; namely, in them that received the same from the apostles by successive laying on of hands."} +{"text":"Here we have the person of God born now the third time. For as Mose and the high priests were God's representative in the Old Testament and our Saviour himself, as man, during his abode on earth; so the Hol Ghost, that is to say, the apostles and their successors, in the offic of preaching and teaching that had received the Holy Spirit, hav represented him ever since. But a person, as I have shown before (chap XIII), is he that is represented, as often as he is represented; an therefore God, who has been represented, that is personated, thrice may properly enough be said to be three persons; though neither th word \"Person,\" nor \"Trinity,\" be ascribed to him in the Bible St. John, indeed (1 Epist. 5:7) saith, \"There be three that bea witness in heaven, the Father, the Word, and the Holy Spirit; and thes three are One.\" But this disagreeth not, but accordeth fitly with thre persons in the proper signification of persons; which is that which i represented by another. For so God the Father, as represented by Moses is one person; and as represented by His Son, another person; and a represented by the apostles, and by the doctors that taught b authority from them derived, is a third person; and yet every perso here, is the person of one and the same God. But a man may here ask what it was whereof these three bear witness. St. John therefore tell us (verse 11) that they bear witness that \"God hath given us eterna life in His Son.\" Again, if it should be asked, wherein that testimon appeareth, the answer is easy; for He hath testified the same by th miracles He wrought, first by Moses; secondly, by His Son himself: an lastly by His apostles that had received the Holy Spirit; all which i their times represented the person of God, and either prophesied o preached Jesus Christ. And as for the apostles, it was the character o the apostleship, in the twelve first and great apostles, to bea witness of His resurrection; as appeareth expressly (Acts 1:21�-�22) where St. Peter, when a new apostle was to be chosen in the place o Judas Iscariot, useth these words, \"Of these men which have companie with us all the time that the Lord Jesus went in and out amongst us beginning at the baptism of John, unto that same day that He was take up from us, must one be ordained to be a witness with us of Hi resurrection\": which words interpret the \"bearing of witness\" mentione by St. John. There is in the same place mentioned another Trinity o witnesses in earth. For (1 John 5:8) he saith, \"there are three tha bear witness in earth, the Spirit, and the water, and the blood, an these three agree in one\": that is to say, the graces of God's spirit and the two sacraments, baptism and the Lord's Supper, which all agre in one testimony to assure the consciences of believers of eterna life; of which testimony he saith (verse 10), \"He that believeth on th Son of man hath the witness in himself.\" In this Trinity on earth, th unity is not of the thing; for the Spirit, the water, and the blood are not the same substance, though they give the same testimony: but i the Trinity of heaven, the persons are the persons of one and the sam God, though represented in three different times and occasions. T conclude, the doctrine of the Trinity, as far as can be gathere directly from the Scripture, is in substance this, that the God who i always one and the same, was the person represented by Moses; th person represented by his Son incarnate; and the person represented b the apostles. As represented by the apostles, the Holy Spirit, by whic they spake, is God; as represented by His Son that was God and man, th Son is that God; as represented by Moses and the high priests, th Father, that is to say, the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, is tha God. From whence we may gather the reason why those names \"Father,\ \"Son,\" and \"Holy Spirit,\" in the signification of the Godhead, ar never used in the Old Testament: for they are persons, that is, the have their names from representing; which could not be, till divers me had represented God's person in ruling or in directing under Him."} +{"text":"Thus we see how the power ecclesiastical was left by our Saviour to th apostles; and how they were, to the end they might the better exercis that power, endued with the Holy Spirit, which is therefore calle sometimes in the New Testament paracletus, which signifieth a \"assister,\" or one called to for help, though it be commonly translate a \"comforter.\" Let us now consider the power itself, what it was, an over whom."} +{"text":"Cardinal Bellarmine, in his third general controversy, hath handled great many questions concerning the ecclesiastical power of the Pope o Rome; and begins with this, whether it ought to be monarchical aristocratical, or democratical: all which sorts of power are sovereig and coercive. If now it should appear that there is no coercive powe left them by our Saviour, but only a power to proclaim the kingdom o Christ, and to persuade men to submit themselves thereunto, and b precepts and good counsel to teach them that have submitted what the are to do that they may be received into the kingdom of God when i comes; and that the apostles and other ministers of the Gospel are ou schoolmasters, and not our commanders, and their precepts not laws bu wholesome counsels: then were all that dispute in vain."} +{"text":"I have shown already, in the last chapter, that the kingdom of Chris is not of this world: therefore neither can His ministers, unless the be kings, require obedience in His name. For if the supreme king hav not his regal power in this world, by what authority can obedience b required to his officers? \"As my Father sent me,\" so saith our Saviou (John 20:21), \"I send you.\" But our Saviour was sent to persuade th Jews to return to, and to invite the Gentiles to receive, the kingdo of His Father, and not to reign in majesty, no not as His Father' lieutenant, till the day of judgment."} +{"text":"The time between the ascension and the general resurrection is called not a reigning, but a regeneration; that is, a preparation of men fo the second and glorious coming of Christ at the day of judgment; a appeareth by the words of our Saviour (Matt. 19:28), \"You that hav followed me in the regeneration, when the Son of man shall sit in th throne of His glory, you shall also sit upon twelve thrones\"; and o St. Paul (Ephes. 6:15), \"Having your feet shod with the preparation o the gospel of peace.\""} +{"text":"And is compared by our Saviour to fishing, that is, to winning men t obedience, not by coercion and punishing, but by persuasion: an therefore He said not to His apostles He would make them so man Nimrods, \"hunters of men\"; but \"fishers of men.\" It is compared also t leaven, to sowing of seed, and to the multiplication of a grain o mustard-seed; by all which compulsion is excluded; and consequentl there can in that time be no actual reigning. The work of Christ' ministers is evangelization; that is, a proclamation of Christ, and preparation for His second coming, as the evangelization of John th Baptist was a preparation to His first coming."} +{"text":"Again, the office of Christ's ministers in this world is to make me believe and have faith in Christ; but faith hath no relation to no dependence at all upon compulsion or commandment; but only upo certainty or probability of arguments drawn from reason, or fro something men believe already. Therefore the ministers of Christ i this world have no power, by that title, to punish any man for no believing or for contradicting what they say; they have, I say, n power by that title of Christ's ministers to punish such; but if the have sovereign civil power by politic institution, then they may indee lawfully punish any contradiction to their laws whatsoever: an St. Paul, of himself and other the then preachers of the Gospel, sait in express words (2 Cor. 1:24), \"We have no dominion over your faith but are helpers of your joy.\""} +{"text":"Another argument, that the ministers of Christ in this present worl have no right of commanding, may be drawn from the lawful authorit which Christ hath left to all princes, as well Christians as infidels St. Paul saith (Col. 3:20), \"Children, obey your parents in all things for this is well pleasing to the Lord\"; and (verse 22), \"Servants, obe in all things your masters according to the flesh; not wit eye-service, as men-pleasers, but in singleness of heart, as fearin the Lord\"; this is spoken to them whose masters were infidels; and ye they are bidden to obey them \"in all things.\" And again, concernin obedience to princes (Rom. 13, the first six verses), exhorting \"to b subject to the higher powers,\" he saith, \"that all power is ordained o God\"; and \"that we ought to be subject to them, not only for fear o incurring their wrath, but also for conscience sake.\" And St. Peter ( Epistle 2:13�-�15), \"Submit yourselves to every ordinance of man, fo the Lord's sake, whether it be to the king, as supreme; or unt governors, as to them that be sent by him for the punishment of evi doers, and for the praise of them that do well; for so is the will o God.\" And again St. Paul (Titus 3:1), \"Put men in mind to be subject t principalities and powers, and to obey magistrates.\" These princes an powers, whereof St. Peter and St. Paul here speak, were all infidels much more therefore we are to observe those Christians, whom God hat ordained to have sovereign power over us. How then can we be obliged t obey any minister of Christ, if he should command us to do anythin contrary to the command of the king, or other sovereign representant o the commonwealth whereof we are members, and by whom we look to b protected? It is therefore manifest that Christ hath not left to Hi ministers in this world, unless they be also endued with civi authority, any authority to command other men."} +{"text":"But what, may some object, if a king, or a senate, or other sovereig person forbid us to believe in Christ? To this I answer that suc forbidding is of no effect; because belief and unbelief never follo men's commands. Faith is a gift of God, which man can neither give no take away by promise of rewards, or menaces of torture. And if it b further asked, what if we be commanded by our lawful prince to say wit our tongue, we believe not; must we obey such command? Profession wit the tongue is but an external thing, and no more than any other gestur whereby we signify our obedience; and wherein a Christian, holdin firmly in his heart the faith of Christ, hath the same liberty whic the prophet Elisha allowed to Naaman the Syrian. Naaman was converte in his heart to the God of Israel; for he saith (2 Kings 5:17�-�18) \"Thy servant will henceforth offer neither burnt-offering nor sacrific unto other gods, but unto the Lord. In this thing the Lord pardon th servant, that when my master goeth into the house of Rimmon to worshi there, and he leaneth on my hand, and I bow myself in the house o Rimmon: when I bow down myself in the house of Rimmon, the Lord pardo thy servant in this thing.\" This the prophet approved, and bid him \"G in peace.\" Here Naaman believed in his heart; but by bowing before th idol Rimmon, he denied the true God in effect, as much as if he ha done it with his lips. But then what shall we answer to our Saviour' saying (Matt. 10:33), \"Whosoever denieth me before men, I will deny hi before my Father which is in heaven?\" This we may say, that whatsoeve a subject, as Naaman was, is compelled to do in obedience to hi sovereign, and doth it not in order to his own mind, but in order t the laws of his country, that action is not his, but his sovereign's nor is it he that in this case denieth Christ before men, but hi governor, and the law of his country. If any man shall accuse thi doctrine, as repugnant to true and unfeigned Christianity, I ask him in case there should be a subject in any Christian commonwealth, tha should be inwardly in his heart of the Mahomedan religion, whether i his sovereign command him to be present at the divine service of th Christian church, and that on pain of death, he think that Mahomeda obliged in conscience to suffer death for that cause, rather than obe that command of his lawful prince. If he say, he ought rather to suffe death, then he authorizeth all private men to disobey their princes i maintenance of their religion, true or false; if he say, he ought to b obedient, then he alloweth to himself that which he denieth to another contrary to the words of our Saviour (Luke 6:31), \"Whatsoever you woul that men should do unto you, that do ye unto them\"; and contrary to th law of Nature, which is the indubitable everlasting law of God, \"Do no to another, that which thou wouldest not he should do unto thee.\""} +{"text":"But what then shall we say of all those martyrs we read of in th history of the Church, that they have needlessly cast away their lives For answer hereunto, we are to distinguish the persons that have bee for that cause put to death: whereof some have received a calling t preach, and profess the kingdom of Christ openly; others have had n such calling, nor more has been required of them than their own faith The former sort, if they have been put to death for bearing witness t this point, that Jesus Christ is risen from the dead, were tru martyrs; for a \"martyr\" is (to give the true definition of the word) witness of the resurrection of Jesus the Messiah; which none can be bu those that conversed with Him on earth, and saw Him after He was risen for a witness must have seen what he testifieth, or else his testimon is not good. And that none but such can properly be called martyrs o Christ, is manifest out of the words of St. Peter (Acts 1:21�-�22) \"Wherefore of these men which have companied with us all the time tha the Lord Jesus went in and out amongst us, beginning from the baptis of John unto that same day He was taken up from us, must one b ordained to be a martyr\" (that is a witness) \"with us of Hi resurrection\": where we may observe, that he which is to be a witnes of the truth of the resurrection of Christ, that is to say, of th truth of this fundamental article of Christian religion, that Jesus wa the Christ, must be some disciple that conversed with Him, and saw Hi before and after His resurrection; and consequently must be one of Hi original disciples: whereas they which were not so, can witness no mor but that their antecessors said it, and are therefore but witnesses o other men's testimony; and are but second martyrs, or martyrs o Christ's witnesses."} +{"text":"He, that to maintain every doctrine which he himself draweth out of th history of our Saviour's life, and of the acts or epistles of th apostles, or which he believeth upon the authority of a private man will oppose the laws and authority of the civil state, is very far fro being a martyr of Christ, or a martyr of His martyrs. It is one articl only, which to die for, meriteth so honourable a name: and that articl is this, that \"Jesus is the Christ\"; that is to say, He that hat redeemed us, and shall come again to give us salvation and eternal lif in His glorious kingdom. To die for every tenet that serveth th ambition or profit of the clergy, is not required; nor is it the deat of the witness, but the testimony itself that makes the martyr: for th word signifieth nothing else but the man that beareth witness, whethe he be put to death for his testimony or not."} +{"text":"Also he that is not sent to preach this fundamental article, but taket it upon him of his private authority, though he be a witness, an consequently a martyr, either primary of Christ, or secondary of Hi apostles, disciples, or their successors; yet is he not obliged t suffer death for that cause; because being not called thereto, it i not required at his hands; nor ought he to complain if he loseth th reward he expecteth from those that never set him on work. Non therefore can be a martyr, neither of the first nor second degree, tha have not a warrant to preach Christ come in the flesh; that is to say none but such as are sent to the conversion of infidels. For no man i a witness to him that already believeth, and therefore needs n witness; but to them that deny, or doubt, or have not heard it. Chris sent His apostles and His seventy disciples, with authority to preach He sent not all that believed. And He sent them to unbelievers; \"I sen you,\" saith He (Matt. 10:16), \"as sheep amongst wolves\"; not as shee to other sheep."} +{"text":"Lastly, the points of their commission, as they are expressly set dow in the Gospel, contain, none of them, any authority over th congregation."} +{"text":"We have first (Matt. 10:6�-�7), that the twelve apostles were sent \"t the lost sheep of the house of Israel,\" and commanded to preach \"tha the kingdom of God was at hand.\" Now preaching, in the original, i that act which a crier, herald, or other officer useth to do publicl in proclaiming of a king. But a crier hath not right to command an man. And (Luke 10:2) the seventy disciples are sent out as \"labourers not as lords of the harvest\"; and are bidden (verse 9) to say, \"Th kingdom of God is come nigh unto you\"; and by kingdom here is meant not the kingdom of grace, but the kingdom of glory; for they are bidde (verses 11, 12) to denounce it to those cities which shall not receiv them, as a threatening, \"that it shall be more tolerable in that da for Sodom than for such a city.\" And (Matt. 20:28) our Saviour tellet His disciples, that sought priority of place, their office was t minister, \"even as the Son of man came, not to be ministered unto, bu to minister.\" Preachers therefore have not magisterial, but ministeria power: \"Be not called masters,\" saith our Saviour (Matt. 23:10), \"fo one is your master, even Christ.\""} +{"text":"Another point of their commission is, to \"Teach all nations\"; as it i in St. Matt. 28:19, or as in St. Mark 16:15, \"Go into all the world and preach the gospel to every creature.\" Teaching therefore an preaching is the same thing. For they that proclaim the coming of king, must withal make known by what right he cometh, if they mean me shall submit themselves unto him: as St. Paul did to the Jews o Thessalonica, when (Acts 17:2�-�3) \"three Sabbath days he reasoned wit them out of the Scriptures, opening and alleging that Christ must need have suffered, and risen again from the dead, and that this Jesus i Christ.\" But to teach out of the Old Testament that Jesus was Christ that is to say, king, and risen from the dead, is not to say that me are bound, after they believe it, to obey those that tell them s against the laws and commands of their sovereigns; but that they shal do wisely to expect the coming of Christ hereafter, in patience an faith, with obedience to their present magistrates."} +{"text":"Another point of their commission is, to \"baptize, in the name of th Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost.\" What is baptism Dipping into water. But what is it to dip a man into the water in th name of anything? The meaning of these words of baptism is this. H that is baptized, is dipped or washed, as a sign of becoming a new man and a loyal subject to that God, whose person was represented in ol time by Moses and the high priests, when He reigned over the Jews; an to Jesus Christ His Son, God and Man, that hath redeemed us, and shal in His human nature represent His Father's person in His eterna kingdom after the resurrection; and to acknowledge the doctrine of th apostles, who, assisted by the Spirit of the Father and of the Son were left for guides to bring us into that kingdom, to be the only an assured way thereunto. This being our promise in baptism; and th authority of earthly sovereigns being not to be put down till the da of judgment; for that is expressly affirmed by St. Paul (1 Cor 15:22�-�24), where he saith, \"As in Adam all die, so in Christ al shall be made alive. But every man in his own order, Christ the firs fruits, afterward they that are Christ's at His coming; then cometh th end, when He shall have delivered up the kingdom to God, even th Father, when He shall have put down all rule, and all authority an power\"; it is manifest that we do not in baptism constitute over u another authority, by which our external actions are to be governed i this life; but promise to take the doctrine of the apostles for ou direction in the way to life eternal."} +{"text":"The power of \"remission and retention of sins,\" called also the powe of \"loosing\" and \"binding,\" and sometimes the \"keys of the kingdom o heaven,\" is a consequence of the authority to baptize, or refuse t baptize. For baptism is the sacrament of allegiance of them that are t be received into the kingdom of God; that is to say, into eternal life that is to say, to remission of sin: for as eternal life was lost b the committing, so it is recovered by the remitting of men's sins. Th end of baptism is remission of sins: and therefore St. Peter, when the that were converted by his sermon on the day of Pentecost, asked wha they were to do, advised them (Acts 2:38) \"to repent, and be baptize in the name of Jesus, for the remission of sins.\" And therefore, seein to baptize is to declare the reception of men into God's kingdom; an to refuse to baptize is to declare their exclusion; it followeth, tha the power to declare them cast out, or retained in it, was given to th same apostles, and their substitutes and successors. And therefor after our Saviour had breathed upon them, saying (John 20:22), \"Receiv the Holy Ghost,\" He addeth in the next verse, \"Whosesoever sins y remit, they are remitted unto them; and whosesoever sins ye retain they are retained.\" By which words, is not granted an authority t forgive or retain sins, simply and absolutely, as God forgiveth o retaineth them, who knoweth the heart of man, and truth of hi penitence and conversion; but conditionally, to the penitent: and thi forgiveness or absolution, in case the absolved have but a feigne repentance, is thereby, without other act or sentence of the absolved made void, and hath no effect at all to salvation, but on the contrar to the aggravation of his sin. Therefore the apostles and thei successors are to follow but the outward marks of repentance; whic appearing, they have no authority to deny absolution; and if the appear not, they have no authority to absolve. The same also is to b observed in baptism: for to a converted Jew, or Gentile, the apostle had not the power to deny baptism; nor to grant it to the unpenitent But seeing no man is able to discern the truth of another man' repentance, further than by external marks, taken from his words an actions, which are subject to hypocrisy; another question will arise who it is that is constituted judge of those marks? And this questio is decided by our Saviour himself; \"If thy brother,\" saith he (Matt 18:15�-�17), \"shall trespass against thee, go and tell him his fault between thee and him alone; if he shall hear thee, thou hast gained th brother. But if he will not hear thee, then take with thee one or tw more. And if he shall neglect to hear them, tell it unto the Church but if he neglect to hear the Church, let him be unto thee as a heathen man and a publican.\" By which it is manifest that the judgmen concerning the truth of repentance, belonged not to any one man, but t the Church, that is, to the assembly of the faithful, or to them tha have authority to be their representant. But besides the judgment there is necessary also the pronouncing of sentence. And this belonge always to the apostle, or some pastor of the Church, as prolocutor; an of this our Saviour speaketh in the 18th verse, \"Whatsoever ye shal bind on earth, shall be bound in heaven; and whatsoever ye shall loos on earth, shall be loosed in heaven.\" And conformable hereunto was th practice of St. Paul (1 Cor. 5:3�-�5), where he saith, \"For I verily as absent in body, but present in spirit, have determined already, a though I were present, concerning him that hath so done this deed; i the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, when ye are gathered together, an my spirit, with the power of our Lord Jesus Christ, to deliver such one to Satan\"; that is to say, to cast him out of the Church, as a ma whose sins are not forgiven. Paul here pronounceth the sentence; bu the assembly was first to hear the cause, for St. Paul was absent, an by consequence to condemn him. But in the same chapter (verses 11, 12) the judgment in such a case is more expressly attributed to th assembly: \"But now I have written unto you, not to keep company, if an man that is called a brother be a fornicator, etc., with such a one, n not to eat. For what have I to do to judge them that are without? D not ye judge them that are within?\" The sentence therefore by which man was put out of the Church, was pronounced by the apostle or pastor but the judgment concerning the merit of the cause, was in the Church that is to say, as the times were before the conversion of kings, an men that had sovereign authority in the commonwealth, the assembly o the Christians dwelling in the same city: as in Corinth, in th assembly of the Christians of Corinth."} +{"text":"This part of the power of the keys, by which men were thrust out fro the kingdom of God, is that which is called \"excommunication\"; and t \"excommunicate,\" is in the original, aposuna'gwgon poien, \"to cast ou of the synagogue\"; that is, out of the place of divine service; a wor drawn from the custom of the Jews, to cast out of their synagogues suc as they thought, in manners or doctrine, contagious, as lepers were b the law of Moses separated from the congregation of Israel, till suc time as they should be by the priest pronounced clean."} +{"text":"The use and effect of excommunication, whilst it was not ye strengthened with the civil power, was no more than that they who wer not excommunicate were to avoid the company of them that were. It wa not enough to repute them as heathen, that never had been Christians for with such they might eat and drink; which with excommunicat persons they might not do; as appeareth by the words of St. Pau (1 Cor. 5:9�-�10, etc.), where he telleth them, he had formerl forbidden them to \"company with fornicators\"; but, because that coul not be without going out of the world, he restraineth it to suc fornicators, and otherwise vicious persons, as were of the brethren \"with such a one,\" he saith, they ought not to keep company, \"no not t eat.\" And this is no more than our Saviour saith (Matt. 18:17), \"Le him be to thee as a heathen, and as a publican.\" For publicans, whic signifieth farmers and receivers of the revenue of the commonwealth were so hated and detested by the Jews that were to pay it, as tha \"publican\" and \"sinner\" were taken amongst them for the same thing insomuch, as when our Saviour accepted the invitation of Zacchaeus publican; though it were to convert him, yet it was objected to Him a a crime. And therefore, when our Saviour to \"heathen\" added \"publican,\ He did forbid them to eat with a man excommunicate."} +{"text":"As for keeping them out of their synagogues, or places of assembly they had no power to do it, but that of the owner of the place, whethe he were Christian or heathen. And because all places are by right i the dominion of the commonwealth; as well he that was excommunicated a he that never was baptized, might enter into them by commission fro the civil magistrate; as Paul before his conversion entered into thei synagogues at Damascus (Acts 9:2), to apprehend Christians, men an women, and to carry them bound to Jerusalem, by commission from th high priest."} +{"text":"By which it appears that upon a Christian that should become a apostate, in a place where the civil power did persecute, or not assis the Church, the effect of excommunication had nothing in it, neither o damage in this world, nor of terror: not of terror, because of thei unbelief; nor of damage, because they are returned thereby into th favour of the world; and in the world to come were to be in no wors estate than they which never had believed. The damage redounded rathe to the Church, by provocation of them they cast out, to a free execution of their malice."} +{"text":"Excommunication therefore had its effect only upon those that believe that Jesus Christ was to come again in glory, to reign over and t judge both the quick and the dead, and should therefore refuse entranc into His kingdom to those whose sins were retained, that is, to thos that were excommunicated by the Church. And thence it is that St. Pau calleth excommunication a delivery of the excommunicate person t Satan. For without the kingdom of Christ, all other kingdoms, afte judgment, are comprehended in the kingdom of Satan. This is it that th faithful stood in fear of as long as they stood excommunicate, that i to say, in an estate wherein their sins were not forgiven. Whereby w may understand that excommunication, in the time that Christia religion was not authorized by the civil power, was used only for correction of manners, not of errors in opinion; for it is a punishmen whereof none could be sensible but such as believed, and expected th coming again of our Saviour to judge the world; and they who s believed needed no other opinion, but only uprightness of life to b saved."} +{"text":"There lieth excommunication for injustice: as (Matt. 18), \"If th brother offend thee, tell it him privately\"; then with witnesses lastly, tell the Church; and then if he obey not, \"Let him be to the as an heathen man and a publican.\" And there lieth excommunication fo a scandalous life, as (1 Cor. 5:11), \"If any man that is called brother, be a fornicator, or covetous, or an idolater, or a drunkard or an extortioner, with such a one ye are not to eat.\" But t excommunicate a man that held this foundation, that \"Jesus was th Christ,\" for difference of opinion in other points, by which tha foundation was not destroyed, there appeareth no authority in th Scripture, nor example in the apostles. There is indeed in St. Pau (Titus 3:10), a text that seemeth to be to the contrary: \"A man that i an heretic, after the first and second admonition, reject.\" For a \"heretic\" is he that being a member of the Church, teachet nevertheless some private opinion, which the Church has forbidden; an such a one, St. Paul adviseth Titus, after the first and secon admonition, to \"reject.\" But to \"reject,\" in this place, is not t \"excommunicate\" the man; but to \"give over admonishing him, to let hi alone, to set by disputing with him,\" as one that is to be convince only by himself. The same apostle saith (2 Tim. 2:23), \"Foolish an unlearned questions avoid\"; the word \"avoid\" in this place, an \"reject\" in the former, is the same in the original, paraito�; bu foolish questions may be set by without excommunication. And agai (Titus 3:9), \"Avoid foolish questions,\" where the original perii3stas (\"set them by\") is equivalent to the former word \"reject.\" There is n other place that can so much as colourably be drawn to countenance th casting out of the Church faithful men, such as believed th foundation, only for a singular superstructure of their own, proceedin perhaps from a good and pious conscience. But on the contrary, all suc places as command avoiding such disputes are written for a lesson t pastors, such as Timothy and Titus were, not to make new articles o faith, by determining every small controversy which oblige men to needless burden of conscience, or provoke them to break the union o the Church. Which lesson the apostles themselves observed well St. Peter and St. Paul, though their controversy were great, as we ma read in Gal. 2:11, yet they did not cast one another out of the Church Nevertheless, during the apostles' times, there were other pastors tha observed it not; as Diotrephes (3 John 9, etc.), who cast out of th Church such as St. John himself thought fit to be received into it, ou of a pride he took in preeminence. So early it was that vainglory an ambition had found entrance into the Church of Christ."} +{"text":"That a man be liable to excommunication, there be many condition requisite; as first, that he be a member of some commonalty, that is t say, of some lawful assembly, that is to say, of some Christian Church that hath power to judge of the cause for which he is to b excommunicated. For where there is no community, there can be n excommunication; nor where there is no power to judge, can there be an power to give sentence."} +{"text":"From hence it followeth that one Church cannot be excommunicated b another: for either they have equal power to excommunicate each other in which case excommunication is not discipline, nor an act o authority, but schism, and dissolution of charity; or one is s subordinate to the other, as that they both have but one voice; an then they be but one Church; and the part excommunicated is no more Church, but a dissolute number of individual persons."} +{"text":"And because the sentence of excommunication importeth an advice not t keep company, nor so much as to eat with him that is excommunicate, i a sovereign prince or assembly be excommunicate, the sentence is of n effect. For all subjects are bound to be in the company and presence o their own sovereign, when he requireth it by the law of Nature; nor ca they lawfully either expel him from any place of his own dominion whether profane or holy; nor go out of his dominion without his leave much less, if he call them to that honour, refuse to eat with him. An as to other princes and states, because they are not parts of one an the same congregation, they need not any other sentence to keep the from keeping company with the state excommunicate: for the ver institution, as it uniteth many men into one community, so i dissociateth one community from another: so that excommunication is no needful for keeping kings and states asunder; nor has any furthe effect than is in the nature of policy itself, unless it be t instigate princes to war upon one another."} +{"text":"Nor is the excommunication of a Christian subject that obeyeth the law of his own sovereign, whether Christian or heathen, of any effect. Fo if he believe that \"Jesus is the Christ, he hath the Spirit of God\" ( John 5:1); \"and God dwelleth in him, and he in God\" (1 John 4:15). Bu he that hath the spirit of God; he that dwelleth in God; he in whom Go dwelleth, can receive no harm by the excommunication of men. Therefore he that believeth Jesus to be the Christ, is free from all the danger threatened to persons excommunicate. He that believeth it not, is n Christian. Therefore a true and unfeigned Christian is not liable t excommunication: nor he also that is a professed Christian, till hi hypocrisy appear in his manners, that is, till his behaviour b contrary to the law of his sovereign, which is the rule of manners, an which Christ and His apostles have commanded us to be subject to. Fo the Church cannot judge of manners but by external actions, whic actions can never be unlawful but when they are against the law of th commonwealth."} +{"text":"If a man's father, or mother, or master be excommunicate, yet are no the children forbidden to keep them company, nor to eat with them: fo that were, for the most part, to oblige them not to eat at all, fo want of means to get food; and to authorize them to disobey thei parents and masters, contrary to the precepts of the apostles."} +{"text":"In sum, the power of excommunication cannot be extended further than t the end for which the apostles and pastors of the Church have thei commission from our Saviour; which is not only to rule by command an coaction, but by teaching and direction of men in the way of salvatio in the world to come. And as a master in any science may abandon hi scholar, when he obstinately neglecteth the practice of his rules; bu not accuse him of injustice, because he was never bound to obey him: s a teacher of Christian doctrine may abandon his disciples tha obstinately continue in an unchristian life; but he cannot say they d him wrong, because they are not obliged to obey him. For to a teache that shall so complain may be applied the answer of God to Samuel i the like place (1 Sam. 8:7), \"They have not rejected thee, but me.\ Excommunication therefore, when it wanteth the assistance of the civi power, as it doth, when a Christian state or prince is excommunicate b a foreign authority, is without effect; and consequently ought to b without terror. The name of Fulmen excommunicationis, that is, \"th thunderbolt of excommunication,\" proceeded from an imagination of th Bishop of Rome, which first used it, that he was king of kings; as th heathen made Jupiter king of the gods, and assigned him, in their poem and pictures, a thunderbolt, wherewith to subdue and punish the giant that should dare to deny his power. Which imagination was grounded o two errors; one, that the kingdom of Christ is of this world, contrar to our Saviour's own words (John 18:36), \"My kingdom is not of thi world\"; the other, that he is Christ's vicar, not only over his ow subjects, but over all the Christians of the world; whereof there is n ground in Scripture, and the contrary shall be proved in its due place."} +{"text":"St. Paul coming to Thessalonica, where was a synagogue of the Jew (Acts 17:2�-�3), \"as his manner was, went in unto them, and thre Sabbath days reasoned with them out of the Scriptures, opening an alleging that Christ must needs have suffered and risen again from th dead; and that this Jesus whom he preached was the Christ.\" Th Scriptures here mentioned were the Scriptures of the Jews, that is, th Old Testament. The men, to whom he was to prove that Jesus was th Christ and risen again from the dead, were also Jews, and did believ already that they were the word of God. Hereupon (as it is in verse 4 some of them believed, and (as it is in verse 5) some believed not What was the reason, when they all believed the Scripture, that the did not all believe alike; but that some approved, others disapprove the interpretation of St. Paul that cited them; and everyon interpreted them to himself? It was this: St. Paul came to them withou any legal commission, and in the manner of one that would not command but persuade; which he must needs do either by miracles, as Moses di to the Israelites in Egypt, that they might see his authority in God' works; or by reasoning from the already received Scripture, that the might see the truth of his doctrine in God's word. But whosoeve persuadeth by reasoning from principles written, maketh him to whom h speaketh judge both of the meaning of those principles, and also of th force of his inferences upon them. If these Jews of Thessalonica wer not, who else was the judge of what St. Paul alleged out of Scripture If St. Paul, what needed he to quote any places to prove his doctrine It had been enough to have said, I find it so in Scripture, that is t say, in your laws, of which I am interpreter, as sent by Christ. Th interpreter therefore of the Scripture, to whose interpretation th Jews of Thessalonica were bound to stand, could be none: everyone migh believe or not believe, according as the allegation seemed to himsel to be agreeable or not agreeable to the meaning of the places alleged And generally in all cases of the world, he that pretendeth any proo maketh judge of his proof him to whom he addresseth his speech. And a to the case of the Jews in particular, they were bound by express word (Deut. 17) to receive the determination of all hard questions from th priests and judges of Israel for the time being. But this is to b understood of the Jews that were yet unconverted."} +{"text":"For the conversion of the Gentiles there was no use of alleging th Scriptures, which they believed not. The apostles therefore laboured b reason to confute their idolatry; and that done, to persuade them t the faith of Christ by their testimony of His life and resurrection. S that there could not yet be any controversy concerning the authority t interpret Scripture, seeing no man was obliged, during his infidelity to follow any man's interpretation of any Scripture, except hi sovereign's interpretation of the laws of his country."} +{"text":"Let us now consider the conversion itself, and see what there wa therein that could be cause of such an obligation. Men were converte to no other thing than to the belief of that which the apostle preached: and the apostles preached nothing but that Jesus was th Christ, that is to say, the king that was to save them, and reign ove them eternally in the world to come; and consequently that He was no dead, but risen again from the dead, and gone up into heaven, an should come again one day to judge the world (which also should ris again to be judged), and reward every man according to his works. Non of them preached that himself, or any other apostle, was such a interpreter of the Scripture, as all that became Christians ought t take their interpretation for law. For to interpret the laws is part o the administration of a present kingdom; which the apostles had not They prayed then, and all other pastors ever since, \"let thy kingdo come\"; and exhorted their converts to obey their then ethnic princes The New Testament was not yet published in one body. Every of th evangelists was interpreter of his own gospel; and every apostle of hi own epistle; and of the Old Testament our Saviour himself saith to th Jews (John 5:39), \"Search the Scriptures; for in them ye think to hav eternal life, and they are they that testify of me.\" If He had no meant they should interpret them, He would not have bidden them tak thence the proof of His being the Christ: He would either hav interpreted them himself, or referred them to the interpretation of th priests."} +{"text":"When a difficulty arose, the apostles and elders of the Churc assembled themselves together, and determined what should be preache and taught, and how they should interpret the Scriptures to the people but took not from the people the liberty to read and interpret them t themselves. The apostles sent divers letters to the Churches, and othe writings for their instruction; which had been in vain if they had no allowed them to interpret, that is, to consider the meaning of them And as it was in the apostles' time, it must be till such time as ther should be pastors that could authorize an interpreter, whos interpretation should generally be stood to: but that could not be til kings were pastors, or pastors kings."} +{"text":"There be two senses, wherein a writing may be said to be \"canonical\" for \"canon\" signifieth a \"rule\"; and a rule is a precept, by which man is guided and directed in any action whatsoever. Such precepts though given by a teacher to his disciple, or a counsellor to hi friend, without power to compel him to observe them, are nevertheles canons; because they are rules. But when they are given by one, whom h that receiveth them is bound to obey, then are those canons, not onl rules, but laws. The question therefore here, is of the power to mak the Scriptures, which are the rules of Christian faith, laws."} +{"text":"That part of the Scripture which was first law, was the Te Commandments written in two tables of stone, and delivered by Go himself to Moses; and by Moses made known to the people. Before tha time there was no written law of God, who as yet having not chosen an people to be His peculiar kingdom, had given no law to men, but the la of Nature, that is to say, the precepts of natural reason written i every man's own heart. Of these two tables, the first containeth th law of sovereignty; 1. That they should not obey nor honour the gods o other nations, in these words: Non habebis deos alienos coram me, tha is, \"thou shalt not have for gods, the gods that other nations worship but only me\"; whereby they were forbidden to obey or honour as thei king and governor, any other god than Him that spake unto them then b Moses, and afterwards by the high priest. 2. That they \"should not mak any image to represent Him,\" that is to say, they were not to choose t themselves, neither in heaven, nor in earth, any representative o their own fancying, but obey Moses and Aaron, whom He had appointed t that office. 3. That \"they should not take the name of God in vain\" that is, they should not speak rashly of their king, nor dispute hi right, nor the commissions of Moses and Aaron, His lieutenants. 4. Tha \"they should every seventh day abstain from their ordinary labour,\" an employ that time in doing Him public honour. The second tabl containeth the duty of one man towards another, as \"to honour parents,\ \"not to kill,\" \"not to commit adultery,\" \"not to steal,\" \"not t corrupt judgment by false witness,\" and finally, \"not so much as t design in their heart the doing of any injury one to another.\" Th question now is, who it was that gave to these written tables th obligatory force of laws. There is no doubt but they were made laws b God himself; but because a law obliges not, nor is law to any, but t them that acknowledge it to be the act of the sovereign; how could th people of Israel, that were forbidden to approach the mountain to hea what God said to Moses, be obliged to obedience to all those laws whic Moses propounded to them? Some of them were indeed the laws of Nature as all the second table; and therefore to be acknowledged for God' laws; not to the Israelites alone, but to all people; but of those tha were peculiar to the Israelites, as those of the first table, th question remains; saving that they had obliged themselves, presentl after the propounding of them to obey Moses, in these words (Exod 20:19), \"Speak thou to us, and we will hear thee; but let not God spea to us, lest we die.\" It was therefore only Moses then, and after hi the high priest, whom, by Moses, God declared should administer thi His peculiar kingdom, that had on earth the power to make this shor Scripture of the Decalogue to be law in the commonwealth of Israel. Bu Moses and Aaron, and the succeeding high priests, were the civi sovereigns. Therefore hitherto, the canonizing or making the Scriptur law, belonged to the civil sovereign."} +{"text":"The judicial law, that is to say, the laws that God prescribed to th magistrates of Israel for the rule of their administration of justice and of the sentences or judgments they should pronounce in plea between man and man; and the Levitical law, that is to say, the rul that God prescribed touching the rites and ceremonies of the priest and Levites, were all delivered to them by Moses only; and therefor also became laws, by virtue of the same promise of obedience to Moses Whether these laws were then written, or not written, but dictated t the people by Moses, after his being forty days with God in the Mount by word of mouth, is not expressed in the text; but they were al positive laws, and equivalent to Holy Scripture, and made canonical b Moses the civil sovereign."} +{"text":"After the Israelites were come into the plains of Moab over agains Jericho, and ready to enter into the Land of Promise, Moses to th former laws added divers others; which therefore are calle Deuteronomy; that is, \"second laws.\" And are (as it is written Deut 29:1), \"the words of a covenant which the Lord commanded Moses to mak with the children of Israel, besides the covenant which He made wit them in Horeb.\" For having explained those former laws, in th beginning of the Book of Deuteronomy, he addeth others, that begin a the 12th chapter, and continue to the end of the 26th of the same book This law (Deut. 27:3) they were commanded to write upon great stone plastered over, at their passing over Jordan: this law also was writte by Moses himself in a book, and delivered into the hands of th \"priests and to the elders of Israel\" (Deut. 31:9), and commande (verse 26), \"to be put in the side of the ark\"; for in the ark itsel was nothing but the \"Ten Commandments.\" This was the law which Mose (Deut. 17:18) commanded the kings of Israel should keep a copy of: an this is the law, which having been long time lost, was found again i the temple in the time of Josiah, and by his authority received for th law of God. But both Moses at the writing, and Josiah at the recover thereof, had both of them the civil sovereignty. Hitherto therefore th power of making Scripture canonical, was in the civil sovereign."} +{"text":"Besides this Book of the Law, there was no other book, from the time o Moses till after the Captivity, received amongst the Jews for the la of God. For the prophets, except a few, lived in the time of th Captivity itself; and the rest lived but a little before it; and wer so far from having their prophecies generally received for laws, a that their persons were persecuted, partly by false prophets, an partly by the kings which were seduced by them. And this book itself which was confirmed by Josiah for the law of God, and with it all th history of the works of God, was lost in the Captivity and sack of th city of Jerusalem, as appears by that of 2 Esdras 14:21, \"thy law i burnt; therefore no man knoweth the things that are done of thee, o the works that shall begin.\" And before the Captivity, between the tim when the law was lost (which is not mentioned in the Scripture, but ma probably be thought to be the time of Rehoboam, when (1 Kings 14:26 Shishak, king of Egypt, took the spoil of the temple), and the time o Josiah when it was found again, they had no written word of God, bu ruled according to their own discretion, or by the direction of such a each of them esteemed prophets."} +{"text":"From hence we may infer that the Scriptures of the Old Testament, whic we have at this day, were not canonical nor a law unto the Jews, til the renovation of their covenant with God at their return from th Captivity, and restoration of their commonwealth under Esdras. But fro that time forward they were accounted the law of the Jews, and for suc translated into Greek by seventy elders of Judea, and put into th library of Ptolemy at Alexandria, and approved for the word of God. No seeing Esdras was the high priest, and the high priest was their civi sovereign, it is manifest that the Scriptures were never made laws, bu by the sovereign civil power."} +{"text":"By the writings of the fathers that lived in the time before that th Christian religion was received, and authorized by Constantine th emperor, we may find that the books we now have of the New Testamen were held by the Christians of that time, except a few (in respect o whose paucity the rest were called the Catholic Church, and other heretics), for the dictates of the Holy Ghost, and consequently for th canon or rule of faith: such was the reverence and opinion they had o their teachers; as generally the reverence that the disciples bear t their first masters in all manner of doctrine they receive from them i not small. Therefore there is no doubt but when St. Paul wrote to th Churches he had converted, or any other apostle or disciple of Christ to those which had then embraced Christ; they received those thei writings for the true Christian doctrine. But in that time, when no the power and authority of the teacher, but the faith of the hearer caused them to receive it, it was not the apostles that made their ow writings canonical, but every convert made them so to himself."} +{"text":"But the question here is not what any Christian made a law or canon t himself, which he might again reject by the same right he received it but what was so made a canon to them, as without injustice they coul not do anything contrary thereunto. That the New Testament should i this sense be canonical, that is to say a law, in any place where th law of the commonwealth had not made it so, is contrary to the natur of a law. For a law, as has been already shown, is the commandment o that man or assembly, to whom we have given sovereign authority to mak such rules for the direction of our actions as he shall think fit, an to punish us when we do anything contrary to the same. When therefor any other man shall offer unto us any other rules, which the sovereig ruler hath not prescribed, they are but counsel and advice; which whether good or bad, he that is counselled may without injustice refus to observe; and when contrary to the laws already established, withou injustice cannot observe how good soever he conceiveth it to be. I sa he cannot in this case observe the same in his actions, nor in hi discourse with other men; though he may without blame believe hi private teachers, and wish he had the liberty to practice their advice and that it were publicly received for law. For internal faith is i its own nature invisible, and consequently exempted from all huma jurisdiction; whereas the words and actions that proceed from it, a breaches of our civil obedience, are injustice both before God and man Seeing then our Saviour hath denied His kingdom to be in this world seeing He had said He came not to judge, but to save the world, He hat not subjected us to other laws than those of the commonwealth; that is the Jews to the law of Moses, which he saith (Matt. 5:17), He came no to destroy, but to fulfil; and other nations to the laws of thei several sovereigns, and all men to the laws of Nature; the observin whereof both He himself and His apostles have in their teachin recommended to us as a necessary condition of being admitted by Him i the last day into His eternal kingdom, wherein shall be protection an life everlasting. Seeing then our Saviour and His apostles left not ne laws to oblige us in this world, but new doctrine to prepare us for th next; the books of the New Testament, which contain that doctrine until obedience to them was commanded by them that God had given powe to on earth to be legislators, were not obligatory canons, that i laws, but only good and safe advice for the direction of sinners in th way to salvation, which every man might take and refuse at his ow peril without injustice."} +{"text":"Again, our Saviour Christ's commission to His apostles and disciple was to proclaim His kingdom, not present, but to come; and to teach al nations, and to baptize them that should believe; and to enter into th houses of them that should receive them, and where they were no received, to shake off the dust of their feet against them; but not t call for fire from heaven to destroy them, nor to compel them t obedience by the sword. In all which there is nothing of power, but o persuasion. He sent them out as sheep unto wolves, not as kings t their subjects. They had not in commission to make laws; but to obey and teach obedience to laws made; and consequently they could not mak their writings obligatory canons without the help of the sovereig civil power. And therefore the Scripture of the New Testament is ther only law where the lawful civil power hath made it so. And there als the king, or sovereign, maketh it a law to himself; by which h subjecteth himself, not to the doctor or apostle that converted him but to God himself and His Son Jesus Christ, as immediately as did th apostles themselves."} +{"text":"That which may seem to give the New Testament, in respect of those tha have embraced Christian doctrine, the force of laws, in the times an places of persecution, is the decrees they made amongst themselves i their synod. For we read (Acts 15:28) the style of the council of th apostles, the elders, and the whole Church, in this manner: \"It seeme good to the Holy Ghost, and to us, to lay upon you no greater burde than these necessary things,\" etc.; which is a style that signifieth power to lay a burden on them that had received their doctrine. Now \"t lay a burden on another,\" seemeth the same as \"to oblige\"; an therefore the acts of that council were laws to the then Christians Nevertheless, they were no more laws than are these other precepts \"repent\"; \"be baptized\"; \"keep the commandments\"; \"believe the gospel\" \"come unto me\"; \"sell all that thou hast\"; \"give it to the poor\"; an \"follow me\"; which are not commands, but invitations and callings o men to Christianity, like that of Isaiah 55:1, \"Ho every man tha thirsteth, come ye to the waters, come, and buy wine and milk withou money.\" For first, the apostles' power was no other than that of ou Saviour, to invite men to embrace the kingdom of God; which the themselves acknowledged for a kingdom, not present, but to come; an they that have no kingdom can make no laws. And secondly, if their act of council were laws, they could not without sin be disobeyed. But w read not anywhere that they who received not the doctrine of Christ di therein sin; but that they died in their sins; that is, that their sin against the laws to which they owed obedience were not pardoned. An those laws were the laws of Nature, and the civil laws of the state whereto every Christian man had by pact submitted himself. An therefore by the burden which the apostles might lay on such as the had converted are not to be understood laws, but conditions proposed t those that sought salvation; which they might accept or refuse at thei own peril, without a new sin, though not without the hazard of bein condemned and excluded out of the kingdom of God for their sins past And therefore of infidels, St. John saith not, the wrath of God shal \"come\" upon them, but (John 3:36) \"the wrath of God remaineth upo them\"; and not that they shall be condemned, but that (John 3:18) \"the are condemned already.\" Nor can it be conceived that the benefit o faith \"is remission of sins,\" unless we conceive withal that the damag of infidelity \"is the retention of the same sins.\""} +{"text":"But to what end is it, may some man ask, that the apostles, and othe pastors of the Church after their time, should meet together to agre upon what doctrine should be taught, both for faith and manners, if n man were obliged to observe their decrees? To this may be answered that the apostles and elders of that council were obliged even by thei entrance into it, to teach the doctrine therein concluded and decree to be taught, so far forth, as no precedent law, to which they wer obliged to yield obedience, was to the contrary; but not that all othe Christians should be obliged to observe what they taught. For thoug they might deliberate what each of them should teach; yet they coul not deliberate what others should do, unless their assembly had had legislative power; which none could have but civil sovereigns. Fo though God be the sovereign of all the world, we are not bound to tak for His law whatsoever is propounded by every man in His name; no anything contrary to the civil law, which God hath expressly commande us to obey."} +{"text":"Seeing then the acts of council of the apostles were then no laws, bu counsels; much less are laws the acts of any other doctors or counci since, if assembled without the authority of the civil sovereign. An consequently, the Books of the New Testament, though most perfect rule of Christian doctrine, could not be made laws by any other authorit than that of kings or sovereign assemblies."} +{"text":"The first council, that made the Scriptures we now have canon, is no extant: for that collection of the canons of the apostles, attribute to Clemens, the first bishop of Rome after St. Peter, is subject t question. For though the canonical books be there reckoned up; ye these words, sint vobis omnibus clericis et laicis libri venerandi etc., contain a distinction of clergy and laity, that was not in use s near St. Peter's time. The first council for settling the canonica Scripture that is extant, is that of Laodicea (Can. LIX), which forbid the reading of other books than those in the Churches; which is mandate that is not addressed to every Christian, but to those onl that had authority to read anything publicly in the Church, that is, t ecclesiastics only."} +{"text":"Of ecclesiastical officers in the time of the apostles, some wer magisterial, some ministerial. Magisterial were the offices of th preaching of the gospel of the kingdom of God to infidels; o administering the sacraments, and divine service; and of teaching th rules of faith and manners to those that were converted. Ministeria was the office of deacons, that is, of them that were appointed to th administration of the secular necessities of the Church, at such tim as they lived upon a common stock of money raised out of the voluntar contributions of the faithful."} +{"text":"Amongst the officers magisterial, the first and principal were th apostles; whereof there were at first but twelve; and these were chose and constituted by our Saviour himself; and their office was not onl to preach, teach, and baptize, but also to be martyrs, witnesses of ou Saviour's resurrection. This testimony was the specifical and essentia mark, whereby the apostleship was distinguished from other magistrac ecclesiastical, as being necessary for an apostle, either to have see our Saviour after His resurrection, or to have conversed with Hi before, and seen His works and other arguments of His divinity, whereb they might be taken for sufficient witnesses. And therefore at th election of a new apostle in the place of Judas Iscariot, St. Pete saith (Acts 1:21�-�22), \"Of these men that have companied with us, al the time that the Lord Jesus went in and out amongst us, beginning fro the baptism of John unto that same day that He was taken up from us must one be ordained to be a witness with us of His resurrection\" where by this word \"must,\" is implied a necessary property of a apostle, to have companied with the first and prime apostles, in th time that our Saviour manifested himself in the flesh."} +{"text":"The first apostle of those which were not constituted by Christ in th time He was upon the earth, was Matthias, chosen in this manner. Ther were assembled together in Jerusalem about one hundred and twent Christians (Acts 1:15). These (verse 23) appointed two, Joseph the Jus and Matthias, and caused lots to be drawn; \"and (verse 26) the lot fel on Matthias, and he was numbered with the apostles.\" So that here w see the ordination of this apostle was the act of the congregation, an not of St. Peter nor of the eleven, otherwise than as members of th assembly."} +{"text":"After him there was never any other apostle ordained, but Paul an Barnabas; which was done as we read (Acts 13:1�-�3) in this manner \"There were in the Church that was at Antioch, certain prophets an teachers; as Barnabas, and Simeon that was called Niger, and Lucius o Cyrene, and Manaen; which had been brought up with Herod the Tetrarch and Saul. As they ministered unto the Lord, and fasted, the Holy Ghos said, Separate me Barnabas and Saul for the work whereunto I hav called them. And when they had fasted and prayed, and laid their hand on them, they sent them away.\""} +{"text":"By which it is manifest that though they were called by the Holy Ghost their calling was declared unto them and their mission authorized b the particular Church of Antioch. And that this their calling was t the apostleship, is apparent by that, that they are both called (Act 14:14) apostles: and that it was by virtue of this act of the Church o Antioch that they were apostles, St. Paul declareth plainly (Rom. 1:1) in that he useth the word, which the Holy Ghost used at his calling for he styleth himself \"An apostle separated unto the gospel of God\" alluding to the words of the Holy Ghost, \"Separate me, Barnabas an Saul,\" etc. But seeing the work of an apostle was to be a witness o the resurrection of Christ, a man may here ask, how St. Paul, tha conversed not with our Saviour before His passion, could know He wa risen? To which is easily answered, that our Saviour himself appeare to him in the way to Damascus, from heaven, after His ascension; \"an chose him for a vessel to bear His name before the Gentiles, and kings and children of Israel\": and consequently, having seen the Lord afte His passion, he was a competent witness of His resurrection. And as fo Barnabas, he was a disciple before the passion. It is therefore eviden that Paul and Barnabas were apostles; and yet chosen and authorized not by the first apostles alone, but by the Church of Antioch; a Matthias was chosen and authorized by the Church of Jerusalem."} +{"text":"\"Bishop,\" a word formed in our language out of the Greek Episkopo*s signifieth an overseer or superintendent of any business, an particularly a pastor or shepherd; and thence by metaphor was taken not only amongst the Jews that were originally shepherds, but als amongst the heathen, to signify the office of a king, or any other rul or guide of people, whether he ruled by laws or doctrine. And so th apostles were the first Christian bishops, instituted by Chris himself: in which sense the apostleship of Judas is called (Acts 1:20 \"his bishopric.\" And afterwards, when there were constituted elders i the Christian Churches, with charge to guide Christ's flock by thei doctrine and advice; these elders were also called bishops. Timothy wa an elder (which word \"elder,\" in the New Testament, is a name o office, as well as of age); yet he was also a bishop. And bishops wer then content with the title of elders. Nay, St. John himself, th apostle beloved of our Lord, beginneth his second Epistle with thes words, \"The elder to the elect lady.\" By which it is evident tha \"bishop,\" \"pastor,\" \"elder,\" \"doctor,\" that is to say, \"teacher,\" wer but so many divers names of the same office in the time of th apostles; for there was then no government by coercion, but only b doctrine and persuading. The kingdom of God was yet to come, in a ne world: so that there could be no authority to compel in any Church till the commonwealth had embraced the Christian faith: an consequently no diversity of authority, though there were diversity o employments."} +{"text":"Besides these magisterial employments in the Church, namely, apostles bishops, elders, pastors, and doctors, whose calling was to proclai Christ to the Jews and infidels, and to direct and to teach those tha believed, we read in the New Testament of no other. For by the names o \"evangelists\" and \"prophets\" is not signified any office, but severa gifts, by which several men were profitable to the Church: a evangelists, by writing the life and acts of our Saviour; such as wer St. Matthew and St. John apostles, and St. Mark and St. Luke disciples and whosoever else wrote of that subject (as St. Thomas an St. Barnabas are said to have done, though the Church have not receive the books that have gone under their names): and as prophets, by th gift of interpreting the Old Testament, and sometimes by declarin their special revelations to the Church. For neither these gifts, no the gifts of languages, nor the gift of casting out devils, nor o curing other diseases, nor anything else, did make an officer in th Church, save only the due calling and election to the charge o teaching."} +{"text":"As the apostles, Matthias, Paul, and Barnabas, were not made by ou Saviour himself, but were elected by the Church, that is, by th assembly of Christians; namely, Matthias by the Church of Jerusalem and Paul and Barnabas by the Church of Antioch; so were also th \"presbyters\" and \"pastors\" in other cities, elected by the Churches o those cities. For proof whereof let us consider, first, how St. Pau proceeded in the ordination of presbyters, in the cities where he ha converted men to the Christian faith, immediately after he and Barnaba had received their apostleship. We read (Acts 14:23) that \"the ordained elders in every Church\"; which at first sight may be taken fo an argument, that they themselves chose, and gave them their authority but if we consider the original text, it will be manifest that the were authorized and chosen by the assembly of the Christians of eac city. For the words there are, xeirotony%sante*s auto*s presbute'rou* kat' kklysi'an, that is, \"when they had ordained them elders by th holding up of hands in every congregation.\" Now it is well enoug known, that in all those cities the manner of choosing magistrates an officers was by plurality of suffrages; and, because the ordinary wa of distinguishing the affirmative votes from the negatives was b holding up of hands, to ordain an officer in any of the cities, was n more but to bring the people together, to elect them by plurality o votes, whether it were by plurality of elevated hands, or by pluralit of voices, or plurality of balls, or beans, or small stones, of whic every man cast in one, into a vessel marked for the affirmative o negative; for divers cities had divers customs in that point. It wa therefore the assembly that elected their own elders: the apostles wer only presidents of the assembly, to call them together for suc election, and to pronounce them elected, and to give them th benediction which now is called consecration. And for this cause, the that were presidents of the assemblies, as in the absence of th apostles the elders were, were called proest�te*s, and in Lati antistites; which words signify the principal person of the assembly whose office was to number the votes, and to declare thereby who wa chosen; and where the votes were equal, to decide the matter i question by adding his own; which is the office of a president i council. And, because all the Churches had their presbyters ordained i the same manner, where the word is \"constitute\" (as Titus 1:5), �n katastysy*s kata po'lin presbute'rou*s, \"For this cause left I thee i Crete, that thou shouldst constitute elders in every city,\" we are t understand the same thing, namely, that he should call the faithfu together, and ordain them presbyters by plurality of suffrages. It ha been a strange thing, if in a town, where men perhaps had never see any magistrate otherwise chosen than by an assembly, those of the tow becoming Christians should so much as have thought on any other way o election of their teachers and guides, that is to say, of thei presbyters (otherwise called bishops), than this of plurality o suffrages, intimated by St. Paul (Acts 14:23) in the wor xeirotony%sante*s. Nor was there ever any choosing of bishops befor the emperors found it necessary to regulate them, in order to th keeping of the peace amongst them, but by the assemblies of th Christians in every several town."} +{"text":"The same is also confirmed by the continual practice, even to this day in the election of the bishops of Rome. For if the bishop of any plac had the right of choosing another to the succession of the pastora office, in any city, at such times as he went from thence to plant th same in another place; much more had he had the right to appoint hi successors in that place in which he last resided and died; and we fin not that ever any bishop of Rome appointed his successor. For they wer a long time chosen by the people, as we may see by the sedition raise about the election between Damasus and Ursicinus, which Ammianu Marcellinus saith was so great, that Juventius the praefect, unable t keep the peace between them, was forced to go out of the city; and tha there were above an hundred men found dead upon that occasion in th church itself. And though they afterwards were chosen, first, by th whole clergy of Rome, and afterwards by the cardinals, yet never an was appointed to the succession by his predecessor. If therefore the pretended no right to appoint their own successors, I think I ma reasonably conclude they had no right to appoint the successors o other bishops without receiving some new power, which none could tak from the Church to bestow on them, but such as had a lawful authority not only to teach, but to command the Church, which none could do bu the civil sovereign."} +{"text":"The word \"minister,\" in the original Dia'kono*s, signifieth one tha voluntarily doth the business of another man, and differeth from servant only in this, that servants are obliged by their condition t do what is commanded them; whereas ministers are obliged only by thei undertaking, and bound therefore to no more than that they hav undertaken; so that both they that teach the word of God, and they tha administer the secular affairs of the Church, are both ministers, bu they are ministers of different persons. For the pastors of the Churc called (Acts 6:4) \"the ministers of the word,\" are ministers of Christ whose word it is; but the ministry of a deacon, which is called (vers 2 of the same chapter) \"serving of tables,\" is a service done to th Church or congregation: so that neither any one man, nor the whol Church, could ever of their pastor say, he was their minister: but of deacon, whether the charge he undertook were to serve tables, o distribute maintenance to the Christians, when they lived in each cit on a common stock or upon collections, as in the first times, or t take a care of the house of prayer, or of the revenue, or other worldl business of the Church, the whole congregation might properly call hi their minister."} +{"text":"For their employment as deacons was to serve the congregation; thoug upon occasion they omitted not to preach the gospel, and maintain th doctrine of Christ, everyone according to his gifts, as St. Stephe did; and both to preach and baptize, as Philip did. For that Philip which (Acts 8:5) preached the gospel at Samaria, and (verse 38 baptized the eunuch, was Philip the deacon, not Philip the apostle. Fo it is manifest (verse 1) that when Philip preached in Samaria, th apostles were at Jerusalem, and (verse 14) \"when they heard tha Samaria had received the word of God, sent Peter and John to them\"; b imposition of whose hands, they that were baptized (verse 15) received, which before by the baptism of Philip they had not received the Holy Ghost. For it was necessary for the conferring of the Hol Ghost, that their baptism should be administered or confirmed by minister of the word, not by a minister of the Church. And therefore t confirm the baptism of those that Philip the deacon had baptized, th apostles sent out of their own number from Jerusalem to Samaria, Pete and John; who conferred on them that before were but baptized, thos graces that were signs of the Holy Spirit, which at that time di accompany all true believers; which what they were may be understood b that which St. Mark saith (16:17), \"these signs follow them tha believe in my name; they shall cast out devils; they shall speak wit new tongues; they shall take up serpents; and if they drink any deadl thing, it shall not hurt them; they shall lay hands on the sick, an they shall recover.\" This to do, was it that Philip could not give; bu the apostles could, and as appears by this place, effectually did t every man that truly believed and was by a minister of Christ himsel baptized: which power either Christ's ministers in this age canno confer, or else there are very few true believers, or Christ hath ver few ministers."} +{"text":"That the first deacons were chosen not by the apostles, but by congregation of the disciples, that is, of Christian men of all sorts is manifest out of Acts 6, where we read that the \"Twelve,\" after th number of disciples was multiplied, called them together, and havin told them that it was not fit that the apostles should leave the wor of God and serve tables, said unto them (verse 3), \"Brethren, look yo out among you seven men of honest report, full of the Holy Ghost and o wisdom, whom we may appoint over this business.\" Here it is manifest that though the apostles declared them elected; yet the congregatio chose them; which also (verse 5) is more expressly said, where it i written, that \"the saying pleased the whole multitude, and they chos seven,\" etc."} +{"text":"Under the Old Testament, the tribe of Levi were only capable of th priesthood, and other inferior offices of the Church. The land wa divided amongst the other tribes, Levi excepted, which by th subdivision of the tribe of Joseph into Ephraim and Manasseh, wer still twelve. To the tribe of Levi were assigned certain cities fo their habitation, with the suburbs for their cattle: but for thei portion, they were to have the tenth of the fruits of the land of thei brethren. Again, the priests for their maintenance had the tenth o that tenth, together with part of the oblations and sacrifices. For Go had said to Aaron (Numb. 18:20), \"Thou shalt have no inheritance i their land; neither shalt thou have any part amongst them; I am th part and thine inheritance amongst the children of Israel.\" For Go being then king, and having constituted the tribe of Levi to be Hi public ministers, He allowed them for their maintenance the publi revenue, that is to say, the part that God had reserved to himself which were tithes and offerings: and that is it which is meant, wher God saith, \"I am thine inheritance.\" And therefore to the Levites migh not unfitly be attributed the name of \"clergy,\" from klro*s, whic signifieth lot or inheritance; not that they were heirs of the kingdo of God more than other; but that God's inheritance was thei maintenance. Now seeing in this time God himself was their king, an Moses, Aaron, and the succeeding high priests were His lieutenants; i is manifest that the right of tithes and offerings was constituted b the civil power."} +{"text":"After their rejection of God in the demanding of a king, they enjoye still the same revenue; but the right thereof was derived from that that the kings did never take it from them: for the public revenue wa at the disposing of him that was the public person; and that, till th Captivity, was the king. And again, after the return from th Captivity, they paid their tithes as before to the priest. Hithert therefore Church livings were determined by the civil sovereign."} +{"text":"Of the maintenance of our Saviour and His apostles, we read only the had a purse, which was carried by Judas Iscariot; and that of th apostles, such as were fishermen did sometimes use their trade; an that when our Saviour sent the twelve apostles to preach, He forba them (Matt. 10:9�-�10) \"to carry gold and silver and brass in thei purses, for that the workman is worthy of his hire.\" By which it i probable, their ordinary maintenance was not unsuitable to thei employment; for their employment was (verse 8) \"freely to give, becaus they had freely received\"; and their maintenance was the \"free gift\" o those that believed the good tiding they carried about of the coming o the Messiah their Saviour. To which we may add, that which wa contributed out of gratitude by such as our Saviour had healed o diseases; of which are mentioned (Luke 8:2�-�3), \"Certain women whic had been healed of evil spirits and infirmities; Mary Magdalen, out o whom went seven devils; and Joanna the wife of Chuza, Herod's steward and Susanna, and many others, which ministered unto Him of thei substance.\""} +{"text":"After our Saviour's ascension, the Christians of every city lived i common (Acts 4:34�-�35) upon the money which was made of the sale o their lands and possessions, and laid down at the feet of the apostles of good will, not of duty; for, \"whilst the land remained,\" sait St. Peter to Ananias (Acts 5:4), \"was it not thine? and after it wa sold, was it not in thy power?\" which showeth he needed not have save his land nor his money by lying, as not being bound to contribut anything at all unless he had pleased. And as in the time of th apostles, so also all the time downward till after Constantine th Great, we shall find that the maintenance of the bishops and pastors o the Christian Church was nothing but the voluntary contribution of the that had embraced their doctrine. There was yet no mention of tithes but such was in the time of Constantine and his sons the affection o Christians to their pastors, as Ammianus Marcellinus saith, describin the sedition of Damasus and Ursicinus about the bishopric, that it wa worth their contention, in that the bishops of those times, by th liberality of their flock, and especially of matrons, lived splendidly were carried in coaches, and were sumptuous in their fare and apparel."} +{"text":"But here may some ask, whether the pastors were then bound to live upo voluntary contribution, as upon alms; \"For who,\" saith St. Paul (1 Cor 9:7), \"goeth to war at his own charges? or who feedeth a flock, an eateth not of the milk of the flock?\" And again (verse 13), \"Do ye no know that they which minister about holy things, live of the things o the temple; and they which wait at the altar, partake with the altar\" that is to say, have part of that which is offered at the altar fo their maintenance? And then he concludeth (verse 14), \"Even so hath th Lord appointed, that they which preach the gospel should live of th gospel.\" From which place may be inferred indeed that the pastors o the Church ought to be maintained by their flocks; but not that th pastors were to determine either the quantity or the kind of their ow allowance, and be, as it were, their own carvers. Their allowance mus needs therefore be determined either by the gratitude and liberality o every particular man of their flock, or by the whole congregation. B the whole congregation it could not be, because their acts were then n laws; therefore the maintenance of pastors before emperors and civi sovereigns had made laws to settle it, was nothing but benevolence They that served at the altar lived on what was offered. So may th pastors also take what is offered them by their flock; but not exac what is not offered. In what court should they sue for it, who had n tribunals? Or, if they had arbitrators amongst themselves, who shoul execute their judgments when they had no power to arm their officers It remaineth, therefore, that there could be no certain maintenanc assigned to any pastors of the Church but by the whole congregation and then only when their decrees should have the force, not only o \"canons,\" but also of \"laws\"; which laws could not be made but b emperors, kings, or other civil sovereigns. The right of tithes i Moses' law could not be applied to the then ministers of the gospel because Moses and the high priests were the civil sovereigns of th people under God, whose kingdom amongst the Jews was present; wherea the kingdom of God by Christ is yet to come."} +{"text":"Hitherto hath been shown what the pastors of the Church are; what ar the points of their commission, as that they were to preach, to teach to baptize, to be presidents in their several congregations; what i ecclesiastical censure, viz., excommunication, that is to say, in thos places where Christianity was forbidden by the civil laws, a putting o themselves out of the company of the excommunicate, and wher Christianity was by the civil law commanded, a putting th excommunicate out of the congregations of Christians; who elected th pastors and ministers of the Church, that it was the congregation; wh consecrated and blessed them, that it was the pastor; what was thei due revenue, that it was none but their own possessions, and their ow labour, and the voluntary contributions of devout and gratefu Christians. We are to consider now what office in the Church thos persons have, who being civil sovereigns, have embraced also th Christian faith."} +{"text":"And first, we are to remember, that the right of judging what doctrine are fit for peace, and to be taught the subjects, is in al commonwealths inseparably annexed, as hath been already proved (chapte XVIII), to the sovereign power civil, whether it be in one man, or i one assembly of men. For it is evident to the meanest capacity tha men's actions are derived from the opinions they have of the good o evil, which from those actions redound unto themselves: an consequently, men that are once possessed of an opinion, that thei obedience to the sovereign power will be more hurtful to them tha their disobedience, will disobey the laws, and thereby overthrow th commonwealth, and introduce confusion and civil war; for the avoidin whereof, all civil government was ordained. And therefore in al commonwealths of the heathen, the sovereigns have had the name o pastors of the people, because there was no subject that could lawfull teach the people, but by their permission and authority."} +{"text":"This right of the heathen kings cannot be thought taken from them b their conversion to the faith of Christ; who never ordained that kings for believing in Him, should be deposed, that is, subjected to any bu himself, or, which is all one, be deprived of the power necessary fo the conservation of peace amongst their subjects, and for their defenc against foreign enemies. And therefore Christian kings are still th supreme pastors of their people, and have power to ordain what pastor they please, to teach the Church, that is, to teach the peopl committed to their charge."} +{"text":"Again, let the right of choosing them be, as before the conversion o kings in the Church; for so it was in the time of the apostle themselves, as hath been shown already in this chapter; even so als the right will be in the civil sovereign, Christian. For in that he i a Christian, he allows the teaching; and in that he is the sovereign which is as much as to say, the Church by representation, the teacher he elects are elected by the Church. And when an assembly of Christian choose their pastor in a Christian commonwealth, it is the sovereig that electeth him, because it is done by his authority; in the sam manner, as when a town choose their mayor, it is the act of him tha hath the sovereign power: for every act done, is the act of him without whose consent it is invalid. And therefore whatsoever example may be drawn out of history concerning the election of pastors by th people, or by the clergy, they are no arguments against the right o any civil sovereign, because they that elected them did it by hi authority."} +{"text":"Seeing then in every Christian commonwealth, the civil sovereign is th supreme pastor, to whose charge the whole flock of his subjects i committed, and consequently that it is by his authority that all othe pastors are made, and have power to teach, and perform all othe pastoral offices; it followeth also, that it is from the civi sovereign that all other pastors derive their right of teaching preaching, and other functions pertaining to that office, and that the are but his ministers; in the same manner as the magistrates of towns judges in courts of justice, and commanders of armies, are all bu ministers of him that is the magistrate of the whole commonwealth judge of all causes, and commander of the whole militia, which i always the civil sovereign. And the reason hereof is not because the that teach, but because they that are to learn, are his subjects. Fo let it be supposed that a Christian king commit the authority o ordaining pastors in his dominions to another king, as divers Christia kings allow that power to the Pope; he doth not thereby constitute pastor over himself, nor a sovereign pastor over his people; for tha were to deprive himself of the civil power; which, depending on th opinion men have of their duty to him and the fear they have o punishment in another world, would depend also on the skill and loyalt of doctors, who are no less subject, not only to ambition, but also t ignorance, than any other sort of men. So that where a stranger hat authority to appoint teachers, it is given him by the sovereign i whose dominions he teacheth. Christian doctors are our schoolmasters t Christianity; but kings are fathers of families, and may receiv schoolmasters for their subjects from the recommendation of a stranger but not from the command; especially when the ill teaching them shal redound to the great and manifest profit of him that recommends them nor can they be obliged to retain them, longer than it is for th public good; the care of which they stand so long charged withal, a they retain any other essential right of the sovereignty."} +{"text":"If a man therefore should ask a pastor, in the execution of his office as the chief priests and elders of the people (Matt. 21:23) asked ou Saviour, \"By what authority doest thou these things, and who gave the this authority?\" he can make no other just answer, but that he doth i by the authority of the commonwealth, given him by the king, o assembly that representeth it. All pastors, except the supreme, execut their charges in the right, that is, by the authority of the civi sovereign, that is, jure civili. But the king, and every othe sovereign, executeth his office of supreme pastor by immediat authority from God, that is to say, in \"God's right\" or jure divino And therefore none but kings can put into their titles a mark of thei submission to God only, Dei gratia rex, etc. Bishops ought to say i the beginning of their mandates, \"By the favour of the King's Majesty bishop of such a diocese\"; or as civil ministers, \"in His Majesty' name.\" For in saying, Divina providentia, which is the same with De gratia, though disguised, they deny to have received their authorit from the civil state; and slyly slip off the collar of their civi subjection, contrary to the unity and defence of the commonwealth."} +{"text":"But if every Christian sovereign be the supreme pastor of his ow subjects, it seemeth that he hath also the authority not only t preach, which perhaps no man will deny, but also to baptize and t administer the sacrament of the Lord's Supper, and to consecrate bot temples and pastors to God's service, which most men deny; partl because they use not to do it, and partly because the administration o sacraments, and consecration of persons and places to holy uses requireth the imposition of such men's hands as by the like impositio successively from the time of the apostles have been ordained to th like ministry. For proof therefore that Christian kings have power t baptize, and to consecrate, I am to render a reason, both why they us not to do it, and how, without the ordinary ceremony of imposition o hands, they are made capable of doing it when they will."} +{"text":"There is no doubt but any king, in case he were skilful in th sciences, might by the same right of his office read lectures of the himself, by which he authorizeth others to read them in th universities. Nevertheless, because the care of the sum of the busines of the commonwealth taketh up his whole time, it were not convenien for him to apply himself in person to that particular. A king may also if he please, sit in judgment to hear and determine all manner o causes, as well as give others authority to do it in his name; but tha the charge that lieth upon him of command and government, constrain hi to be continually at the helm, and to commit the ministerial offices t others under him. In the like manner our Saviour, who surely had powe to baptize, baptized none (John 4:2) himself, but sent His apostles an disciples to baptize. So also St. Paul, by the necessity of preachin in divers and far distant places, baptized few; amongst all th Corinthians he baptized only (1 Cor. 1:14, 16) Crispus, Gaius, an Stephanas, and the reason was (1 Cor. 1:17) because his principa charge was to preach. Whereby it is manifest that the greater charge such as is the government of the Church, is a dispensation for th less. The reason therefore why Christian kings use not to baptize i evident, and the same for which at this day there are few baptized b bishops, and by the Pope fewer."} +{"text":"And as concerning imposition of hands, whether it be needful for th authorizing of a king to baptize and consecrate, we may consider thus:"} +{"text":"Imposition of hands was a most ancient public ceremony amongst th Jews, by which was designed and made certain the person or other thin intended in a man's prayer, blessing, sacrifice, consecration condemnation, or other speech. So Jacob, in blessing the children o Joseph (Gen. 48:14), \"laid his right hand on Ephraim the younger, an his left hand on Manasseh the firstborn\"; and this he did \"wittingly\ (though they were so presented to him by Joseph, as he was forced i doing it to stretch out his arms across), to design to whom he intende the greater blessing. So also in the sacrificing of the burnt-offering Aaron is commanded (Exod. 29:10) \"to lay his hands on the head of th bullock\"; and (verse 15) \"to lay his hand on the head of the ram.\" Th same is also said again (Levit. 1:4, and 8:14). Likewise Moses, when h ordained Joshua to be captain of the Israelites, that is, consecrate him to God's service (Numb. 27:23), \"laid his hands upon him and gav him his charge,\" designing and rendering certain who it was they wer to obey in war. And in the consecration of the Levites (Numb. 8:10) God commanded that \"the children of Israel should put their hands upo the Levites.\" And in the condemnation of him that had blasphemed th Lord (Levit. 24:14), God commanded that \"all that heard him should la their hands on his head, and that all the congregation should ston him.\" And why should they only that heard him lay their hands upon him and not rather a priest, Levite, or other minister of justice, but tha none else were able to design and to demonstrate to the eyes of th congregation who it was that had blasphemed and ought to die? And t design a man or any other thing by the hand to the eye, is less subjec to mistake than when it is done to the ear by a name."} +{"text":"And so much was this ceremony observed, that in blessing the whol congregation at once, which cannot be done by laying on of hands, ye Aaron (Levit. 9:22) \"did lift up his hands toward the people when h blessed them.\" And we read also of the like ceremony of consecration o temples amongst the heathen, as that the priest laid his hands on som post of the temple, all the while he was uttering the words o consecration. So natural it is to design any individual thing, rathe by the hand, to assure the eyes, than by words to inform the ear, i matters of God's public service."} +{"text":"This ceremony was not therefore new in our Saviour's time. For Jairu (Mark 5:23), whose daughter was sick, besought our Saviour not to hea her, but \"to lay His hands upon her that she might be healed.\" An (Matt. 19:13), \"they brought unto Him little children that He shoul put His hands on them and pray.\""} +{"text":"According to this ancient rite, the apostles, and presbyters, and th presbytery itself, laid hands on them whom they ordained pastors, an withal prayed for them that they might receive the Holy Ghost; and tha not only once, but sometimes oftener, when a new occasion wa presented: but the end was still the same, namely a punctual an religious designation of the person, ordained either to the pastora charge in general, or to a particular mission. So (Acts 6:6), \"Th apostles prayed, and laid their hands\" on the seven deacons; which wa done, not to give them the Holy Ghost (for they were full of the Hol Ghost before they were chosen, as appeareth immediately before, vers 3), but to design them to that office. And after Philip the deacon ha converted certain persons in Samaria, Peter and John went down (Act 8:17), \"and laid their hands on them, and they received the Hol Ghost.\" And not only an apostle, but a presbyter had this power: fo St. Paul adviseth Timothy (1 Tim. 5:22), \"Lay hands suddenly on n man\"; that is, design no man rashly to the office of a pastor. Th whole presbytery laid their hands on Timothy, as we read 1 Tim. 4:14 but this is to be understood, as that some did it by the appointment o the presbytery, and most likely their proest�*s, or prolocutor, whic it may be was St. Paul himself. For in his second Epistle to Timothy 1:6, he saith to him, \"Stir up the gift of God, which is in thee by th laying on of my hands\": where note by the way, that by the Holy Ghost is not meant the third person in the Trinity, but the gifts necessar to the pastoral office. We read also, that St. Paul had imposition o hands twice; once from Ananias at Damascus (Acts 9:17�-�18), at th time of his baptism; and again (Acts 13:3) at Antioch, when he wa first sent out to preach. The use then of this ceremony, considered i the ordination of pastors, was to design the person to whom they gav such power. But if there had been then any Christian that had had th power of teaching before; the baptizing of him, that is, the making hi a Christian, had given him no new power, but had only caused him t preach true doctrine, that is, to use his power aright; and therefor the imposition of hands had been unnecessary; baptism itself had bee sufficient. But every sovereign, before Christianity, had the power o teaching, and ordaining teachers; and therefore Christianity gave the no new right, but only directed them in the way of teaching truth; an consequently they needed no imposition of hands, besides that which i done in baptism, to authorize them to exercise any part of the pastora function, as namely, to baptize and consecrate. And in the Ol Testament, though the priest only had right to consecrate, during th time that the sovereignty was in the high priest; yet it was not s when the sovereignty was in the king. For we read (1 Kings 8) tha Solomon blessed the people, consecrated the Temple, and pronounced tha public prayer which is the pattern now for consecration of al Christian churches and chapels: whereby it appears, he had not only th right of ecclesiastical government, but also of exercisin ecclesiastical functions."} +{"text":"From this consolidation of the right politic and ecclesiastic i Christian sovereigns, it is evident, they have all manner of power ove their subjects, that can be given to man, for the government of men' external actions, both in policy and religion; and may make such law as themselves shall judge fittest, for the government of their ow subjects, both as they are the commonwealth, and as they are th Church; for both State and Church are the same men."} +{"text":"If they please, therefore, they may, as many Christian kings now do commit the government of their subjects in matters of religion to th Pope; but then the Pope is in that point subordinate to them, an exerciseth that charge in another's dominion jure civili, in the righ of the civil sovereign; not jure divino, in God's right; and ma therefore be discharged of that office, when the sovereign, for th good of his subjects, shall think it necessary. They may also, if the please, commit the care of religion to one supreme pastor, or to a assembly of pastors; and give them what power over the Church, or on over another, they think most convenient; and what titles of honour, a of archbishops, bishops, priests, or presbyters, they will; and mak such laws for their maintenance, either by tithes or otherwise, as the please, so they do it out of a sincere conscience, of which God only i the judge. It is the civil sovereign that is to appoint judges an interpreters of the canonical Scriptures; for it is he that maketh the laws. It is he also that giveth strength to excommunications; which bu for such laws and punishments, as may humble obstinate libertines, an reduce them to union with the rest of the Church, would be contemned In sum, he hath the supreme power in all causes, as well ecclesiastica as civil, as far as concerneth actions and words, for those only ar known and may be accused; and of that which cannot be accused, there i no judge at all but God, that knoweth the heart. And these rights ar incident to all sovereigns, whether monarchs or assemblies: for the that are the representants of a Christian people, are representants o the Church: for a Church and a commonwealth of Christian people are th same thing."} +{"text":"Though this that I have here said, and in other places of this book seem clear enough for the asserting of the supreme ecclesiastical powe to Christian sovereigns; yet because the Pope of Rome's challenge t that power universally hath been maintained chiefly, and, I think, a strongly as is possible, by Cardinal Bellarmine, in his controversy, D Summo Pontifice; I have thought it necessary, as briefly as I can, t examine the grounds and strength of his discourse."} +{"text":"Of five books he hath written of this subject, the first containet three questions: one, which is simply the best government, \"Monarchy,\ \"Aristocracy,\" or \"Democracy\"; and concludeth for neither, but for government mixed of all three: another, which of these is the bes government of the Church; and concludeth for the mixed, but whic should most participate of monarchy; the third, whether in this mixe monarchy St. Peter had the place of monarch. Concerning his firs conclusion, I have already sufficiently proved (chapter XVIII) that al governments which men are bound to obey are simple and absolute. I monarchy there is but one man supreme; and all other men that have an kind of power in the state have it by his commission, during hi pleasure, and execute it in his name: and in aristocracy and democrac but one supreme assembly, with the same power that in monarch belongeth to the monarch, which is not a mixed but an absolut sovereignty. And of the three sorts which is the best is not to b disputed, where any one of them is already established; but the presen ought always to be preferred, maintained, and accounted best; becaus it is against both the law of Nature and the divine positive law to d anything tending to the subversion thereof. Besides, it maketh nothin to the power of any pastor, unless he have the civil sovereignty, wha kind of government is the best; because their calling is not to gover men by commandment but to teach them, and persuade them by arguments and leave it to them to consider whether they shall embrace or rejec the doctrine taught. For monarchy, aristocracy, and democracy, do mar out unto us three sorts of sovereigns, not of pastors; or, as we ma say, three sorts of masters of families, not three sorts o schoolmasters for their children."} +{"text":"And therefore the second conclusion, concerning the best form o government of the Church, is nothing to the question of the Pope' power without his own dominions. For in all other commonwealths hi power, if he have any at all, is that of the schoolmaster only, and no of the master of the family."} +{"text":"For the third conclusion, which is, that St. Peter was monarch of th Church, he bringeth for his chief argument the place of St. Matthe (16:18�-�19), \"Thou art Peter, and upon this rock I will build m Church,\" etc. \"And I will give thee the keys of heaven; whatsoever tho shalt bind on earth, shall be bound in heaven, and whatsoever tho shalt loose on earth, shall be loosed in heaven.\" Which place, wel considered, proveth no more, but that the Church of Christ hath fo foundation one only article; namely, that which Peter in the name o all the apostles professing, gave occasion to our Saviour to speak th words here cited. Which that we may clearly understand, we are t consider that our Saviour preached by himself, by John the Baptist, an by His apostles, nothing but this article of faith, \"that He was th Christ\"; all other articles requiring faith no otherwise than a founded on that. John began first (Matt. 3:2), preaching only this \"the kingdom of God is at hand.\" Then our Saviour himself (Matt. 4:17 preached the same: and to His twelve apostles, when He gave them thei commission (Matt. 10:7), there is no mention of preaching any othe article but that. This was the fundamental article, that is th foundation of the Church's faith. Afterwards the apostles bein returned to Him, He (Matt. 16:13) asketh them all, not Peter only, \"wh men said He was\"; and they answered that \"some said He was John th Baptist, some Elias, and others Jeremiah, or one of the prophets.\" The (verse 15) He asked them all again, not Peter only, \"Whom say ye that am?\" Therefore St. Peter answered for them all, \"Thou art Christ, th Son of the living God\"; which I said is the foundation of the faith o the whole Church; from which our Saviour takes the occasion of saying \"upon this stone I will build my Church\": by which it is manifest, tha by the foundation-stone of the Church was meant the fundamental articl of the Church's faith. But why then, will some object, doth our Saviou interpose these words, \"thou art Peter?\" If the original of this tex had been rigidly translated, the reason would easily have appeared. W are therefore to consider, that the apostle Simon was surnamed \"Stone,\ which is the signification of the Syriac word \"Cephas,\" and of th Greek word Petro*s. Our Saviour therefore, after the confession of tha fundamental article, alluding to His name, said (as if it were i English) thus, \"Thou art `stone,' and upon this stone I will build m Church\": which is as much as to say, this article, that \"I am th Christ,\" is the foundation of all the faith I require in those that ar to be members of my Church. Neither is this allusion to a name a unusual thing in common speech. But it had been a strange and obscur speech if our Saviour, intending to build His Church on the person o St. Peter, had said, \"Thou art a stone, and upon this stone I wil build my Church\"; when it was so obvious, without ambiguity, to hav said, \"I will build my Church on thee\": and yet there had been stil the same allusion to His name."} +{"text":"And for the following words, \"I will give thee the keys of heaven,\ etc., it is no more than what our Saviour gave also to all the rest o His disciples (Matt. 18:18), \"Whatsoever ye shall bind on earth, shal be bound in heaven: and whatsoever ye shall loose on earth, shall b loosed in heaven.\" But howsoever this be interpreted, there is no doub but the power here granted belongs to all supreme pastors; such as ar all Christian civil sovereigns in their own dominions. Insomuch, as i St. Peter, or our Saviour himself, had converted any of them to believ Him, and to acknowledge His kingdom; yet, because His kingdom is not o this world, He had left the supreme care of converting His subjects t none but him; or else He must have deprived him of the sovereignty, t which the right of teaching is inseparably annexed. And thus much i refutation of his first book, wherein he would prove St. Peter to hav been the monarch universal of the Church, that is to say, of all th Christians in the world."} +{"text":"The second book hath two conclusions: one, that St. Peter was bishop o Rome, and there died; the other, that the Popes of Rome are hi successors. Both which have been disputed by others. But supposing the true; yet if by Bishop of Rome, be understood either the monarch of th Church, or the supreme pastor of it: not Silvester, but Constantine who was the first Christian emperor, was that bishop; and a Constantine, so all other Christian emperors were of right suprem bishops of the Roman empire. I say of the Roman empire, not of al Christendom, for other Christian sovereigns had the same right in thei several territories, as to an office essentially adherent to thei sovereignty. Which shall serve for answer to his second book."} +{"text":"In the third book he handleth the question, whether the Pope b Antichrist? For my part, I see no argument that proves he is so, i that sense the Scripture useth the name; nor will I take any argumen from the quality of Antichrist to contradict the authority h exerciseth, or hath heretofore exercised in the dominions of any othe prince or state."} +{"text":"It is evident that the prophets of the Old Testament foretold, and th Jews expected a Messiah, that is, a Christ, that should reestablis amongst them the kingdom of God, which had been rejected by them in th time of Samuel, when they required a king after the manner of othe nations. This expectation of theirs made them obnoxious to th imposture of all such as had both the ambition to attempt the attainin of the kingdom, and the heart to deceive the people by counterfei miracles, by hypocritical life, or by orations and doctrine plausible Our Saviour, therefore, and His apostles, forewarned men of fals prophets and of false Christs. False Christs are such as pretend to b the \"Christ,\" but are not, and are called properly \"Antichrists\"; i such sense, as when there happeneth a schism in the Church, by th election of two popes, the one calleth the other \"Antipapa,\" or th false Pope. And therefore Antichrist in the proper signification hat two essential marks; one, that he denieth Jesus to be Christ; an another that he professeth himself to be Christ. The first mark is se down by St. John in his first Epistle, 4:3, \"Every spirit tha confesseth not that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh, is not of God and this is the spirit of Antichrist.\" The other mark is expressed i the words of our Saviour (Matt. 24:5), \"many shall come in my name saying, I am Christ\"; and again (verse 23), \"If any man shall say unt you, lo! here is Christ, and there is Christ, believe it not.\" An therefore Antichrist must be a false Christ; that is, some one of the that shall pretend themselves to be Christ. And out of these two marks \"to deny Jesus to be the Christ,\" and \"to affirm himself to be th Christ,\" it followeth, that he must also be an \"adversary of Jesus th true Christ,\" which is another usual signification of the wor Antichrist. But of these many Antichrists, there is one special one, h Anti'xristo*s, \"the Antichrist,\" or \"Antichrist\" definitely, as on certain person, not indefinitely \"an Antichrist.\" Now, seeing the Pop of Rome neither pretendeth himself, nor denieth Jesus to be the Christ I perceive not how he can be called Antichrist; by which word is no meant, one that falsely pretendeth to be \"his lieutenant\" o \"vicar-general,\" but to be \"He.\" There is also some mark of the time o this special Antichrist, as (Matt. 24:15), when that abominabl destroyer spoken of by Daniel (Dan. 9:27) shall stand in the hol place, and such tribulation as was not since the beginning of th world, nor ever shall be again, insomuch as if it were to last lon (Matt. 24:22) \"no flesh could be saved; but for the elect's sake thos days shall be shortened,\" made fewer. But that tribulation is not ye come; for it is to be followed immediately (verse 29) by a darkening o the sun and moon, a falling of the stars, a concussion of the heavens and the glorious coming again of our Saviour in the clouds. An therefore \"the Antichrist\" is not yet come; whereas, many Popes ar both come and gone. It is true, the Pope, in taking upon him to giv laws to all Christian kings and nations, usurpeth a kingdom in thi world, which Christ took not on Him; but he doth it not \"as Christ,\ but as \"for Christ,\" wherein there is nothing of \"the Antichrist.\""} +{"text":"In the fourth book, to prove the Pope to be the supreme judge in al questions of faith and manners, \"which is as much as to be the absolut monarch of all Christians in the world,\" he bringeth thre propositions: the first, that his judgments are infallible: the second that he can make very laws, and punish those that observe them not: th third, that our Saviour conferred all jurisdiction ecclesiastical o the Pope of Rome."} +{"text":"For the infallibility of his judgments, he allegeth the Scriptures: an first, that of Luke 22:31�-�32: \"Simon, Simon, Satan hath desired you that he may sift you as wheat; but I have prayed for thee, that th faith fail not; and when thou art converted, strengthen thy brethren.\ This, according to Bellarmine's exposition, is, that Christ gave her to Simon Peter two privileges: one, that neither his faith should fail nor the faith of any of his successors: the other, that neither he, no any of his successors, should ever define any point concerning faith o manners erroneously, or contrary to the definition of a former Pope which is a strange and very much strained interpretation. But he tha with attention readeth that chapter, shall find there is no place i the whole Scripture that maketh more against the Pope's authority tha this very place. The Priests and Scribes seeking to kill our Saviour a the Passover, and Judas possessed with a resolution to betray Him, an the day of killing the Passover being come, our Saviour celebrated th same with His apostles, which He said, till the kingdom of God was com He would do no more; and withal told them that one of them was t betray Him. Hereupon they questioned which of them it should be; an withal, seeing the next Passover their Master would celebrate should b when He was king, entered into a contention who should then be th greatest man. Our Saviour therefore told them that the kings of th nations had dominion over their subjects, and are called by a name i Hebrew, that signifies bountiful; \"but I cannot be so to you, you mus endeavour to serve one another; I ordain you a kingdom, but it is suc as my Father hath ordained me; a kingdom that I am now to purchase wit my blood, and not to possess till my second coming; then ye shall ea and drink at my table, and sit on thrones judging the twelve tribes o Israel.\" And then addressing himself to St. Peter, He saith: \"Simon Simon, Satan seeks, by suggesting a present domination, to weaken you faith of the future; but I have prayed for thee, that thy faith shal not fail; thou therefore note this, being converted, and understandin my kingdom as of another world, confirm the same faith in th brethren.\" To which St. Peter answered, as one that no more expecte any authority in this world, \"Lord, I am ready to go with thee, no only to prison, but to death.\" Whereby it is manifest St. Peter had no only no jurisdiction given him in this world, but a charge to teach al the other apostles that they also should have none. And for th infallibility of St. Peter's sentence definitive in matter of faith there is no more to be attributed to it out of this text than tha Peter should continue in the belief of this point, namely, that Chris should come again and possess the kingdom at the day of judgment, whic was not given by this text to all his successors; for we see they clai it in the world that now is."} +{"text":"The second place is that of Matt. 16:18, \"Thou art Peter, and upon thi rock I will build my Church, and the gates of hell shall not prevai against it.\" By which, as I have already shown in this chapter, i proved no more, than that the gates of hell shall not prevail agains the confession of Peter, which gave occasion to that speech; namel this, that \"Jesus is Christ the Son of God.\""} +{"text":"The third text is John 21:16�-�17: \"Feed my sheep\"; which contains n more but a commission of teaching. And if we grant the rest of th apostles to be contained in that name of \"sheep\"; then it is th supreme power of teaching: but it was only for the time that there wer no Christian sovereigns already possessed of that supremacy. But I hav already proved that Christian sovereigns are in their own dominions th supreme pastors, and instituted thereto, by virtue of their bein baptized, though without other imposition of hands. For suc imposition, being a ceremony of designing the person, is needless, whe he is already designed to the power of teaching what doctrine he will by his institution to an absolute power over his subjects. For as have proved before, sovereigns are supreme teachers, in general, b their office; and therefore oblige themselves, by their baptism, t teach the doctrine of Christ: and when they suffer others to teac their people, they do it at the peril of their own souls; for it is a the hands of the heads of families that God will require the account o the instruction of His children and servants. It is of Abraham himself not of a hireling, that God saith (Gen. 18:19), \"I know him that h will command his children, and his household after him, that they kee the way of the Lord, and do justice and judgment.\""} +{"text":"The fourth place is that of Exod. 28:30: \"Thou shalt put in th breastplate of judgment, the Urim and the Thummim\": which he saith i interpreted by the Septuagint dy%lwsin k�i aly%theian; that is \"evidence and truth\"; and thence concludeth, God hath given evidenc and truth, which is almost infallibility, to the high priest. But be i evidence and truth itself that was given; or be it but admonition t the priest to endeavour to inform himself clearly, and give judgmen uprightly; yet in that it was given to the high priest, it was given t the civil sovereign; (for such next under God was the high priest i the commonwealth of Israel); and is an argument for evidence and truth that is, for the ecclesiastical supremacy of civil sovereigns ove their own subjects, against the pretended power of the Pope. These ar all the texts he bringeth for the infallibility of the judgment of th Pope in point of faith."} +{"text":"For the infallibility of his judgment concerning manners, he bringet one text, which is that of John 16:13: \"When the Spirit of truth i come, he will lead you into all truth\": where, saith he, by \"al truth,\" is meant, at least \"all truth necessary to salvation.\" But wit this mitigation, he attributeth no more infallibility to the Pope, tha to any man that professeth Christianity and is not to be damned. For i any man err in any point, wherein not to err is necessary to salvation it is impossible he should be saved; for that only is necessary t salvation, without which to be saved is impossible. What points thes are, I shall declare out of the Scripture in the chapter following. I this place I say no more, but that though it were granted, the Pop could not possibly teach any error at all, yet doth not this entitl him to any jurisdiction in the dominions of another prince; unless w shall also say, a man is obliged in conscience to set on work upon al occasions the best workman, even then also when he hath formerl promised his work to another."} +{"text":"Besides the text, he argueth from reason, thus. If the Pope could er in necessaries, then Christ hath not sufficiently provided for th Church's salvation; because He hath commanded her to follow the Pope' directions. But this reason is invalid, unless he show when and wher Christ commanded that, or took at all any notice of a Pope. Nay granting whatsoever was given to St. Peter was given to the Pope; ye seeing there is in the Scripture no command to any man to obe St. Peter, no man can be just that obeyeth him when his commands ar contrary to those of his lawful sovereign."} +{"text":"Lastly, it hath not been declared by the Church, nor by the Pop himself, that he is the civil sovereign of all the Christians in th world; and therefore all Christians are not bound to acknowledge hi jurisdiction in point of manners. For the civil sovereignty, an supreme judicature in controversies of manners, are the same thing: an the makers of civil laws, are not only declarers, but also makers o the justice and injustice of actions; there being nothing in men' manners that makes them righteous or unrighteous, but their conformit with the law of the sovereign. And therefore, when the Pope challenget supremacy in controversies of manners, he teacheth men to disobey th civil sovereign; which is an erroneous doctrine, contrary to the man precepts of our Saviour and His apostles, delivered to us in th Scripture."} +{"text":"To prove the Pope has power to make laws, he allegeth many places; a first (Deut. 17:12), \"The man that will do presumptuously, and will no hearken unto the priest, that standeth to minister there before th Lord thy God, or unto the judge, even that man shall die; and tho shalt put away the evil from Israel.\" For answer whereunto, we are t remember that the high priest, next and immediately under God, was th civil sovereign; and all judges were to be constituted by him. Th words alleged sound therefore thus: \"The man that will presume t disobey the civil sovereign for the time being, or any of his officer in the execution of their places, that man shall die,\" etc.: which i clearly for the civil sovereignty, against the universal power of th Pope."} +{"text":"Secondly, he allegeth that of Matt. 16:19, \"Whatsoever ye shall bind,\ etc., and interpreteth it for such \"binding\" as is attributed (Matt 23:4) to the Scribes and Pharisees, \"They bind heavy burdens, an grievous to be borne, and lay them on men's shoulders\"; by which i meant, he says, making of laws; and concludes thence that the Pope ca make laws. But this also maketh only for the legislative power of civi sovereigns. For the Scribes and Pharisees sat in Moses' chair; bu Moses next under God was sovereign of the people of Israel: an therefore our Saviour commanded them to do all that they should say but not all that they should do: that is, to obey their laws, but no follow their example."} +{"text":"The third place is John 21:16, \"Feed my sheep\"; which is not a power t make laws, but a command to teach. Making laws belongs to the lord o the family; who by his own discretion chooseth his chaplain, as also schoolmaster to teach his children."} +{"text":"The fourth place (John 20:21) is against him. The words are, \"As m Father sent me, so send I you.\" But our Saviour was sent to redeem b His death such as should believe, and by His own and His apostles preaching, to prepare them for their entrance into His kingdom; whic He himself saith, is not of this world, and hath taught us to pray fo the coming of it hereafter, though He refused (Acts 1:6�-�7) to tel His apostles when it should come; and in which, when it comes, th twelve apostles shall sit on twelve thrones, everyone perhaps as hig as that of St. Peter, to judge the twelve tribes of Israel. Seeing the God the Father sent not our Saviour to make laws in this present world we may conclude from the text, that neither did our Saviour sen St. Peter to make laws here, but to persuade men to expect His secon coming with a steadfast faith; and in the meantime, if subjects, t obey their princes; and if princes, both to believe it themselves, an to do their best to make their subjects do the same; which is th office of a bishop. Therefore this place maketh most strongly for th joining of the ecclesiastical supremacy to the civil sovereignty contrary to that which Cardinal Bellarmine allegeth it for."} +{"text":"The fifth place is Acts 15:28�-�29, \"It hath seemed good to the Hol Spirit and to us, to lay upon you no greater burden, than thes necessary things, that ye abstain from meats offered to idols, and fro blood, and from things strangled, and from fornication.\" Here he note the word \"laying of burdens\" for the legislative power. But who i there, that reading this text, can say this style of the apostles ma not as properly be used in giving counsel as in making laws? The styl of a law is, \"we command\": but, \"we think good,\" is the ordinary styl of them that but give advice; and they lay a burden that give advice though it be conditional, that is, if they to whom they give it, wil attain their ends; and such is the burden of abstaining from thing strangled, and from blood; not absolute, but in case they will not err I have shown before (chapter XXV) that law is distinguished fro counsel in this, that the reason of a law is taken from the design an benefit of him that prescribeth it; but the reason of a counsel, fro the design and benefit of him to whom the counsel is given. But her the apostles aim only at the benefit of the converted Gentiles, namely their salvation; not at their own benefit, for having done thei endeavour, they shall have their reward, whether they be obeyed or not And therefore the acts of this council were not laws, but counsels."} +{"text":"The sixth place is that of Rom. 13, \"Let every soul be subject to th higher powers, for there is no power but of God\"; which is meant, h saith, not only of secular, but also of ecclesiastical princes. T which I answer, first, that there are no ecclesiastical princes bu those that are also civil sovereigns; and their principalities excee not the compass of their civil sovereignty; without those bounds though they may be received for doctors, they cannot be acknowledge for princes. For if the apostle had meant we should be subject both t our own princes, and also to the Pope, he had taught us a doctrin which Christ himself hath told us is impossible, namely, \"to serve tw masters.\" And though the apostle says in another place (2 Cor. 13:10) \"I write these things being absent, lest being present I should us sharpness, according to the power which the Lord hath given me\"; it i not, that he challenged a power either to put to death, imprison banish, whip, or fine any of them, which are punishments; but only t excommunicate, which, without the civil power, is no more but a leavin of their company, and having no more to do with them than with heathen man or a publican; which in many occasions might be a greate pain to the excommunicant than to the excommunicate."} +{"text":"The seventh place is 1 Cor. 4:21, \"Shall I come unto you with a rod, o in love, and the spirit of lenity?\" But here again it is not the powe of a magistrate to punish offenders, that is meant by a rod; but onl the power of excommunication, which is not in its own nature punishment, but only a denouncing of punishment, that Christ shal inflict when He shall be in possession of His kingdom, at the day o judgment. Nor then also shall it be properly a punishment, as upon subject that hath broken the law; but a revenge, as upon an enemy o revolter, that denieth the right of our Saviour to the kingdom. An therefore this proveth not the legislative power of any bishop that ha not also the civil power."} +{"text":"The eighth place is 1 Tim. 3:2, \"A bishop must be the husband of bu one wife, vigilant, sober,\" etc.; which he saith was a law. I though that none could make a law in the Church but the monarch of the Church St. Peter. But suppose this precept made by the authority of St. Peter yet I see no reason why to call it a law rather than an advice, seein Timothy was not a subject but a disciple of St. Paul; nor the floc under the charge of Timothy, his subjects in the kingdom, but hi scholars in the school of Christ. If all the precepts he giveth Timoth be laws, why is not this also a law (1 Tim. 5:23), \"Drink no longe water, but use a little wine for thy health's sake?\" And why are no also the precepts of good physicians so many laws, but that it is no the imperative manner of speaking, but an absolute subjection to person, that maketh his precepts laws?"} +{"text":"In like manner, the ninth place (1 Tim. 5:19), \"Against an elde receive not an accusation, but before two or three witnesses,\" is wise precept, but not a law."} +{"text":"The tenth place is Luke 10:16, \"He that heareth you, heareth me; and h that despiseth you, despiseth me.\" And there is no doubt but he tha despiseth the counsel of those that are sent by Christ, despiseth th counsel of Christ himself. But who are those now that are sent b Christ but such as are ordained pastors by lawful authority? And wh are lawfully ordained that are not ordained by the sovereign pastor And who is ordained by the sovereign pastor in a Christian commonwealt that is not ordained by the authority of the sovereign thereof? Out o this place therefore it followeth, that he which heareth his sovereign being a Christian, heareth Christ; and he that despiseth the doctrin which his king, being a Christian, authorizeth, despiseth the doctrin of Christ: which is not that which Bellarmine intendeth here to prove but the contrary. But all this is nothing to a law. Nay more, Christian king, as a pastor and teacher of his subjects, makes no thereby his doctrines laws. He cannot oblige men to believe; though a a civil sovereign he may make laws suitable to his doctrine, which ma oblige men to certain actions, and sometimes to such as they would no otherwise do, and which he ought not to command; and yet when they ar commanded they are laws; and the external actions done in obedience t them, without the inward approbation, are the actions of the sovereign and not of the subject, which is in that case but as an instrument without any motion of his own at all; because God hath commanded t obey them."} +{"text":"The eleventh is every place where the apostle for counsel putteth som word by which men use to signify command; or calleth the following o his counsel by the name of obedience. And therefore they are allege out of 1 Cor. 11:2: \"I commend you for keeping my precepts as delivered them to you.\" The Greek is, \"I commend you for keeping thos things I delivered to you as I delivered them.\" Which is far fro signifying that they were laws, or anything else, but good counsel. An that of 1 Thess. 4:2: \"You know what commandments we gave you\": wher the Greek word is paraggeli'a*s dw%ka�en, equivalent to paredw%ka�en \"what we delivered to you,\" as in the place next before alleged, whic does not prove the traditions of the apostles to be any more tha counsels; though as is said in the 8th verse, \"he that despiseth them despiseth not man, but God.\" For our Saviour himself came not to judge that is, to be king in this world, but to sacrifice himself fo sinners, and leave doctors in His Church to lead, not to drive men t Christ, who never accepteth forced actions (which is all the la produceth), but the inward conversion of the heart; which is not th work of laws, but of counsel and doctrine."} +{"text":"And that of 2 Thess. 3:14, \"If any man obey not our word by thi epistle, note that man, and have no company with him, that he may b ashamed\": where from the word \"obey,\" he would infer that this epistl was a law to the Thessalonians. The epistles of the emperors wer indeed laws. If therefore the epistle of St. Paul were also a law, the were to obey two masters. But the word \"obey,\" as it is in the Gree hupakou%ei, signifieth \"hearkening to\" or \"putting in practice,\" no only that which is commanded by him that has right to punish, but als that which is delivered in a way of counsel for our good; and therefor St. Paul does not bid kill him that disobeys; nor beat, nor imprison nor amerce him, which legislators may all do; but avoid his company that he may be ashamed: whereby it is evident it was not the empire o an apostle, but his reputation amongst the faithful, which th Christians stood in awe of."} +{"text":"The last place is that of Heb. 13:17, \"Obey your leaders, and submi yourselves to them; for they watch for your souls, as they that mus give account\": and here also is intended by obedience a following o their counsel. For the reason of our obedience is not drawn from th will and command of our pastors, but from our own benefit, as being th salvation of our souls they watch for, and not for the exaltation o their own power and authority. If it were meant here, that all the teach were laws, then not only the Pope, but every pastor in hi parish, should have legislative power. Again, they that are bound t obey their pastors, have no power to examine their commands. What the shall we say to St. John, who bids us (1 Epistle 4:1), \"Not to believ every spirit, but to try the spirits whether they are of God; becaus many false prophets are gone out into the world?\" It is therefor manifest that we may dispute the doctrine of our pastors; but no ma can dispute a law. The commands of civil sovereigns are on all side granted to be laws: if any else can make a law besides himself, al commonwealth, and consequently all peace and justice must cease; whic is contrary to all laws both divine and human. Nothing therefore can b drawn from these, or any other places of Scripture, to prove th decrees of the Pope, where he has not also the civil sovereignty, to b laws."} +{"text":"The last point he would prove is this, \"That our Saviour Christ ha committed ecclesiastical jurisdiction immediately to none but th Pope.\" Wherein he handleth not the question of supremacy between th Pope and Christian kings, but between the Pope and other bishops. An first, he says, it is agreed that the jurisdiction of bishops is a least in the general de jure divino, that is, in the right of God; fo which he alleges St. Paul (Eph. 4:11), where he says that Christ, afte His ascension into heaven, \"gave gifts to men, some apostles, som prophets, and some evangelists, and some pastors, and some teachers\" and thence infers they have indeed their jurisdiction in God's right but will not grant they have it immediately from God, but derive through the Pope. But if a man may be said to have his jurisdiction d jure divino, and yet not immediately; what lawful jurisdiction, thoug but civil, is there in a Christian commonwealth that is not also d jure divino? For Christian kings have their civil power from Go immediately; and the magistrates under him exercise their severa charges in virtue of his commission; wherein that which they do is n less de jure divino mediato, than that which the bishops do in virtu of the Pope's ordination. All lawful power is of God, immediately i the supreme governor, and mediately in those that have authority unde him: so that either he must grant every constable in the state to hol his office in the right of God; or he must not hold that any bisho holds his so, besides the Pope himself."} +{"text":"But this whole dispute, whether Christ left the jurisdiction to th Pope only, or to other bishops also, if considered out of those place where the Pope has the civil sovereignty, is a contention de lan caprina: for none of them, where they are not sovereigns, has an jurisdiction at all. For jurisdiction is the power of hearing an determining causes between man and man: and can belong to none but hi that hath the power to prescribe the rules of right and wrong; that is to make laws; and with the sword of justice to compel men to obey hi decisions, pronounced either by himself or by the judges he ordainet thereto; which none can lawfully do but the civil sovereign."} +{"text":"Therefore when he allegeth out of chapter 6 of Luke, that our Saviou called His disciples together, and chose twelve of them, which He name apostles, he proveth that He elected them (all, except Matthias, Paul and Barnabas), and gave them power and command to preach, but not t judge of causes between man and man: for that is a power which H refused to take upon himself, saying, \"Who made me a judge, or divider, amongst you?\" and in another place, \"My kingdom is not of thi world.\" But he that hath not the power to hear and determine cause between man and man, cannot be said to have any jurisdiction at all And yet this hinders not, but that our Saviour gave them power t preach and baptize in all parts of the world, supposing they were no by their own lawful sovereign forbidden: for to our own sovereign Christ himself, and His apostles, have in sundry places expressl commanded us in all things to be obedient."} +{"text":"The arguments by which he would prove that bishops receive thei jurisdiction from the Pope (seeing the Pope in the dominions of othe princes hath no jurisdiction himself) are all in vain. Yet because the prove, on the contrary, that all bishops receive jurisdiction, whe they have it, from their civil sovereigns, I will not omit the recita of them."} +{"text":"The first is from chapter 11 of Numbers, where Moses not being abl alone to undergo the whole burden of administering the affairs of th people of Israel, God commanded him to choose seventy elders, and too part of the spirit of Moses to put it upon those seventy elders: b which is understood, not that God weakened the spirit of Moses; fo that had not eased him at all; but that they had all of them thei authority from him, wherein he doth truly and ingenuously interpre that place. But seeing Moses had the entire sovereignty in th commonwealth of the Jews, it is manifest that it is thereby signifie that they had their authority from the civil sovereign: and therefor that place proveth that bishops in every Christian commonwealth hav their authority from the civil sovereign; and from the Pope in his ow territories only, and not in the territories of any other state."} +{"text":"The second argument, is from the nature of monarchy; wherein al authority is in one man, and in others by derivation from him. But th government of the Church, he says, is monarchical. This also makes fo Christian monarchs. For they are really monarchs of their own people that is, of their own Church; for the Church is the same thing with Christian people; whereas the power of the Pope, though he wer St. Peter, is neither monarchy, nor hath anything of \"archical,\" no \"cratical,\" but only of \"didactical\"; for God accepteth not a forced but a willing obedience."} +{"text":"The third is from that the \"see\" of St. Peter is called by St. Cyprian the \"head,\" the \"source,\" the \"root,\" the \"sun,\" from whence th authority of bishops is derived. But by the law of Nature, which is better principle of right and wrong than the word of any doctor that i but a man, the civil sovereign in every commonwealth is the \"head,\" th \"source,\" the \"root,\" and the \"sun,\" from which all jurisdiction i derived. And therefore the jurisdiction of bishops is derived from th civil sovereign."} +{"text":"The fourth is taken from the inequality of their jurisdictions. For i God, saith he, had given it them immediately, He had given as wel equality of jurisdiction as of order; but we see, some are bishops bu of one town, some of a hundred towns, and some of many whole provinces which differences were not determined by the command of God. Thei jurisdiction therefore is not of God, but of man; and one has greater, another a less, as it pleaseth the Prince of the Church. Whic argument, if he had proved before, that the Pope had an universa jurisdiction over all Christians, had been for his purpose. But seein that hath not been proved, and that it is notoriously known, the larg jurisdiction of the Pope was given him by those that had it, that is by the emperors of Rome (for the patriarch of Constantinople, upon th same title, namely, of being bishop of the capital city of the empire and seat of the emperor, claimed to be equal to him), it followeth that all other bishops have their jurisdiction from the sovereigns o the place wherein they exercise the same. And as for that cause the have not their authority de jure divino; so neither hath the Pope hi de jure divino, except only where he is also the civil sovereign."} +{"text":"His fifth argument is this: \"If bishops have their jurisdictio immediately from God, the Pope could not take it from them, for he ca do nothing contrary to God's ordination,\" and this consequence is good and well proved. \"But,\" saith he, \"the Pope can do this, and has don it.\" This also is granted, so he do it in his own dominions, or in th dominions of any other prince that hath given him that power; but no universally in right of the popedom, for that power belongeth to ever Christian sovereign within the bounds of his own empire, and i inseparable from the sovereignty. Before the people of Israel had, b the commandment of God to Samuel, set over themselves a king, after th manner of other nations, the high priest had the civil government, an none but he could make or depose an inferior priest. But that power wa afterwards in the king, as may be proved by this same argument o Bellarmine; for if the priest be the high priest, or any other had hi jurisdiction immediately from God, then the king could not take it fro him, \"for he could do nothing contrary to God's ordinance.\" But it i certain that king Solomon (1 Kings 2:26�-�27) deprived Abiathar th high priest of his office, and placed Zadok (verse 35) in his room Kings therefore may in like manner ordain and deprive bishops, as the shall think fit for the well-governing of their subjects."} +{"text":"His sixth argument is this: if bishops have their jurisdiction de jur divino, that is, \"immediately from God,\" they that maintain it shoul bring some word of God to prove it; but they can bring none. Th argument is good; I have therefore nothing to say against it. But it i an argument no less good to prove the Pope himself to have n jurisdiction in the dominion of any other prince."} +{"text":"Lastly, he bringeth for argument the testimony of two popes, Innocen and Leo; and I doubt not he might have alleged with as good reason, th testimonies of all the popes almost since St. Peter. For considerin the love of power naturally implanted in mankind, whosoever were mad Pope he would be tempted to uphold the same opinion. Nevertheless, the should therein but do, as Innocent and Leo did, bear witness o themselves, and therefore their witness should not be good."} +{"text":"In the fifth book he hath four conclusions. The first is, \"that th Pope is not lord of all the world\"; the second, \"that the Pope is no the lord of all the Christian world\"; the third, \"that the Pope withou his own territory, has not any temporal jurisdiction `directly.' \ These three conclusions are easily granted. The fourth is, \"that th Pope has, in the dominions of other princes, the supreme temporal powe `indirectly,' \" which is denied; unless he mean by \"indirectly,\" tha he has gotten it by indirect means, then is that also granted. But understand that when he saith he hath it \"indirectly,\" he means tha such temporal jurisdiction belongeth to him of right, but that thi right is but a consequence of his pastoral authority, the which h could not exercise unless he have the other with it; and therefore t the pastoral power, which he calls spiritual, the supreme power civi is necessarily annexed; and that thereby he hath a right to chang kingdoms, giving them to one and taking them from another, when h shall think it conduces to the salvation of souls."} +{"text":"Before I come to consider the arguments by which he would prove thi doctrine, it will not be amiss to lay open the consequences of it; tha princes and states that have the civil sovereignty in their severa commonwealths may bethink themselves, whether it be convenient fo them, and conducing to the good of their subjects, of whom they are t give an account at the day of judgment, to admit the same."} +{"text":"When it is said the Pope hath not, in the territories of other states the supreme civil power \"directly,\" we are to understand he doth no challenge it, as other civil sovereigns do, from the origina submission thereto of those that are to be governed. For it is evident and has already been sufficiently in this treatise demonstrated, tha the right of all sovereigns is derived originally from the consent o every one of those that are to be governed; whether they that choos him do it for their common defence against an enemy, as when they agre amongst themselves to appoint a man or an assembly of men to protec them; or whether they do it to save their lives, by submission to conquering enemy. The Pope therefore when he disclaimeth the suprem civil power over other states \"directly,\" denieth no more, but that hi right cometh to him by that way; he ceaseth not for all that to clai it another way, and that is, without the consent of them that are to b governed, by a right given him by God, which he calleth \"indirectly\" i his assumption to the papacy. But by what way soever he pretend, th power is the same; and he may, if it be granted to be his right, depos princes and states as often as it is for the salvation of souls, tha is, as often as he will: for he claimeth also the sole power to judg whether it be to the salvation of men's souls or not. And this is th doctrine not only that Bellarmine here, and many other doctors teach i their sermons and books, but also that some councils have decreed, an the Popes have accordingly, when the occasion hath served them, put i practice. For the fourth council of Lateran, held under Pope Innocen the Third, in the third chapter De Haereticis, hath this canon: \"If king, at the Pope's admonition, do not purge his kingdom of heretics and being excommunicate for the same, make not satisfaction within year, his subjects are absolved of their obedience.\" And the practic hereof hath been seen on divers occasions; as in the deposing o Chilperic, king of France; in the translation of the Roman empire t Charlemagne; in the oppression of John, king of England; i transferring the kingdom of Navarre; and of late years, in the leagu against Henry the Third of France, and in many more occurrences. think there be few princes that consider not this as unjust an inconvenient; but I wish they would all resolve to be kings o subjects. Men cannot serve two masters. They ought therefore to eas them, either by holding the reins of government wholly in their ow hands; or by wholly delivering them into the hands of the Pope; tha such men as are willing to be obedient, may be protected in thei obedience. For this distinction of temporal and spiritual power is bu words. Power is as really divided and as dangerously to all purposes by sharing with another \"indirect\" power, as with a \"direct\" one. Bu to come now to his arguments."} +{"text":"The first is this, \"The civil power is subject to the spiritual therefore he that hath the supreme power spiritual, hath right t command temporal princes, and dispose of their temporals in order t the spiritual.\" As for the distinction of temporal and spiritual, le us consider in what sense it may be said intelligibly, that th temporal or civil power is subject to the spiritual. There be but tw ways that those words can be made sense. For when we say, one power i subject to another power, the meaning either is, that he which hath th one, is subject to him that hath the other; or that the one power is t the other, as the means to the end. For we cannot understand that on power hath power over another power; or that one power can have righ or command over another. For subjection, command, right, and power, ar accidents, not of powers, but of persons. One power may be subordinat to another, as the art of a saddler to the art of a rider. If then i be granted, that the civil government be ordained as a means to brin us to a spiritual felicity; yet it does not follow, that if a king hav the civil power, and the Pope the spiritual, that therefore the king i bound to obey the Pope, more than every saddler is bound to obey ever rider. Therefore as from subordination of an art, cannot be inferre the subjection of the professor; so from the subordination of government cannot be inferred the subjection of the governor. Whe therefore he saith, the civil power is subject to the spiritual, hi meaning is, that the civil sovereign is subject to the spiritua sovereign. And the argument stands thus, \"The civil sovereign i subject to the spiritual; therefore the spiritual prince may comman temporal princes.\" Where the conclusion is the same with the anteceden he should have proved. But to prove it, he allegeth first, this reason \"Kings and popes, clergy and laity, make but one commonwealth; that i to say, but one Church: and in all bodies the members depend one upo another: but things spiritual depend not on things temporal: therefor temporal depend on spiritual, and therefore are subject to them.\" I which argumentation there be two gross errors: one is, that al Christian kings, popes, clergy, and all other Christian men, make bu one commonwealth. For it is evident that France is one commonwealth Spain another, and Venice a third, etc. And these consist o Christians; and therefore also are several bodies of Christians; tha is to say, several Churches: and their several sovereigns represen them, whereby they are capable of commanding and obeying, of doing an suffering, as a natural man; which no general or universal Church is till it have a representant; which it hath not on earth: for if it had there is no doubt but that all Christendom were one commonwealth, whos sovereign were that representant, both in things spiritual an temporal. And the Pope, to make himself this representant, wantet three things that our Saviour hath not given him, to \"command,\" and t \"judge,\" and to \"punish,\" otherwise than, by excommunication, to ru from those that will not learn of him. For though the Pope wer Christ's only vicar, yet he cannot exercise his government, till ou Saviour's second coming: and then also it is not the Pope, bu St. Peter himself with the other apostles, that are to be judges of th world."} +{"text":"The other error in this his first argument is, that he says, th members of every commonwealth, as of a natural body, depend one o another. It is true, they cohere together, but they depend only on th sovereign, which is the soul of the commonwealth; which failing, th commonwealth is dissolved into a civil war, no one man so much a cohering to another for want of a common dependence on a know sovereign; just as the members of the natural body dissolve into eart for want of a soul to hold them together. Therefore there is nothing i this similitude from whence to infer a dependence of the laity on th clergy, or of the temporal officers on the spiritual; but of both o the civil sovereign; which ought indeed to direct his civil commands t the salvation of souls; but is not therefore subject to any but Go himself. And thus you see the laboured fallacy of the first argument t deceive such men as distinguish not between the subordination o actions in the way to the end; and the subjection of persons one t another in the administration of the means. For to every end the mean are determined by Nature, or by God himself supernaturally; but th power to make men use the means is in every nation resigned by the la of Nature, which forbiddeth men to violate their faith given to th civil sovereign."} +{"text":"His second argument is this: \"Every commonwealth, because it i supposed to be perfect and sufficient in itself, may command any othe commonwealth not subject to it, and force it to change th administration of the government; nay, depose the prince, and se another in his room, if it cannot otherwise defend itself against th injuries he goes about to do them: much more may a spiritua commonwealth command a temporal one to change the administration o their government, and may depose princes, and institute others, whe they cannot otherwise defend the spiritual good.\""} +{"text":"That a commonwealth, to defend itself against injuries, may lawfully d all that he hath here said, is very true; and hath already in tha which hath gone before been sufficiently demonstrated. And if it wer also true, that there is now in this world a spiritual commonwealth distinct from a civil commonwealth, then might the prince thereof, upo injury done him, or upon want of caution that injury be not done him i time to come, repair and secure himself by war; which is, in sum deposing, killing, or subduing, or doing any act of hostility. But b the same reason, it would be no less lawful for a civil sovereign, upo the like injuries done, or feared, to make war upon the spiritua sovereign; which I believe is more than Cardinal Bellarmine would hav inferred from his own proposition."} +{"text":"But spiritual commonwealth there is none in this world: for it is th same thing with the kingdom of Christ, which He himself saith is not o this world; but shall be in the next world at the resurrection, whe they that have lived justly, and believed that He was the Christ shall though they died \"natural\" bodies, rise \"spiritual\" bodies: and then i is that our Saviour shall judge the world, and conquer His adversaries and make a spiritual commonwealth. In the meantime, seeing there are n men on earth whose bodies are spiritual, there can be no spiritua commonwealth amongst men that are yet in the flesh; unless we cal preachers, that have commission to teach, and prepare men for thei reception into the kingdom of Christ at the resurrection, commonwealth; which I have proved already to be none."} +{"text":"The third argument is this: \"It is not lawful for Christians t tolerate an infidel or heretical king, in case he endeavour to dra them to his heresy or infidelity. But to judge whether a king draw hi subjects to heresy or not belongeth to the Pope. Therefore hath th Pope right to determine whether the prince be to be deposed or no deposed.\""} +{"text":"To this I answer, that both these assertions are false. For Christians or men of what religion soever, if they tolerate not their king whatsoever law he maketh, though it be concerning religion, do violat their faith, contrary to the divine law, both \"natural\" and \"positive\" nor is there any judge of heresy amongst subjects, but their own civi sovereign. For \"heresy is nothing else but a private opinio obstinately maintained, contrary to the opinion which the publi person, that is to say, the representant of the commonwealth, hat commanded to be taught.\" By which it is manifest, that an opinio publicly appointed to be taught, cannot be heresy; nor the sovereig princes that authorize them, heretics. For heretics are none bu private men, that stubbornly defend some doctrine prohibited by thei lawful sovereigns."} +{"text":"But to prove that Christians are not to tolerate infidel or heretica kings, he allegeth a place in Deut. 17:15, where God forbiddeth th Jews, when they shall set a king over themselves, to choose a stranger and from thence inferreth that it is unlawful for a Christian to choos a king that is not a Christian. And it is true, that he that is Christian, that is, he that hath already obliged himself to receive ou Saviour, when He shall come, for his king, shall tempt God too much i choosing for king in this world one that he knoweth will endeavour both by terror and persuasion, to make him violate his faith. But i is, saith he, the same danger to choose one that is not a Christian fo king, and not to depose him when he is chosen. To this I say, th question is not of the danger of not deposing, but of the justice o deposing him. To choose him, may in some cases be unjust; but to depos him when he is chosen is in no case just. For it is always violation o faith, and consequently against the law of Nature, which is the eterna law of God. Nor do we read that any such doctrine was accounte Christian in the time of the apostles; nor in the time of the Roma emperors, till the Popes had the civil sovereignty of Rome. But to thi he hath replied, that the Christians of old deposed not Nero, no Diocletian, nor Julian, nor Valens an Arian, for this cause only, tha they wanted temporal forces. Perhaps so. But did our Saviour, who fo calling for might have had twelve legions of immortal, invulnerabl angels to assist Him, want forces to depose Caesar, or at least Pilate that unjustly, without finding fault in Him, delivered Him to the Jew to be crucified? Or if the apostles wanted temporal forces to depos Nero, was it therefore necessary for them, in their epistles to th new-made Christians, to teach them, as they did, to obey the power constituted over them, whereof Nero in that time was one, and that the ought to obey them, not for fear of their wrath, but for conscienc sake? Shall we say they did not only obey, but also teach what the meant not, for want of strength? It is not therefore for want o strength, but for conscience sake, that Christians are to tolerat their heathen princes, or princes (for I cannot call anyone whos doctrine is the public doctrine an heretic) that authorize the teachin of an error. And whereas for the temporal power of the Pope, h allegeth further, that St. Paul (1 Cor. 6) appointed judges under th heathen princes of those times, such as were not ordained by thos princes; it is not true. For St. Paul does but advise them to take som of their brethren to compound their differences as arbitrators, rathe than to go to law one with another before the heathen judges; which i a wholesome precept, and full of charity, fit to be practiced also i the best Christian commonwealths. And for the danger that may arise t religion, by the subjects tolerating of a heathen, or an erring prince it is a point of which a subject is no competent judge; or if he be the Pope's temporal subjects may judge also of the Pope's doctrine. Fo every Christian prince, as I have formerly proved, is no less suprem pastor of his own subjects than the Pope of his."} +{"text":"The fourth argument is taken from the baptism of kings; wherein tha they may be made Christians, they submit their sceptres to Christ; an promise to keep and defend the Christian faith. This is true; fo Christian kings are no more but Christ's subjects: but they may, fo all that, be the Pope's fellows; for they are supreme pastors of thei own subjects: and the Pope is no more but king and pastor, even in Rom itself."} +{"text":"The fifth argument is drawn from the words spoken by our Saviour, \"Fee my sheep\"; by which was given all power necessary for a pastor; as th power to chase away wolves, such as are heretics; the power to shut u rams if they be mad, or push at the other sheep with their horns, suc as are evil, though Christian kings; and power to give the floc convenient food. From whence he inferreth that St. Peter had thes three powers given him by Christ. To which I answer, that the last o these powers is no more than the power, or rather command, to teach For the first, which is to chase away wolves, that is, heretics, th place he quoteth is (Matt. 7:15), \"Beware of false prophets, which com to you in sheep's clothing, but inwardly are ravening wolves.\" Bu neither are heretics false prophets, or at all prophets: nor, admittin heretics for the wolves there meant, were the apostles commanded t kill them, or if they were kings, to depose them; but to beware of fly, and avoid them: nor was it to St. Peter, nor to any of th apostles, but to the multitude of the Jews that followed him into th mountain, men for the most part not yet converted, that he gave thi counsel, to beware of false prophets: which, therefore, if it confer power of chasing away kings, was given, not only to private men, but t men that were not at all Christians. And as to the power of separating and shutting up of furious rams, by which he meaneth Christian king that refuse to submit themselves to the Roman pastor, our Saviou refused to take upon Him that power in this world himself, but advise to let the corn and tares grow up together till the day of judgment much less did He give it to St. Peter, or can St. Peter give it to th Popes. St. Peter and all other pastors are bidden to esteem thos Christians that disobey the Church, that is, that disobey the Christia sovereign, as heathen men, and as publicans. Seeing then, men challeng to the Pope no authority over heathen princes, they ought to challeng none over those that are to be esteemed as heathen."} +{"text":"But from the power to teach only, he inferreth also a coercive power i the Pope, over kings. The pastor, saith he, must give his floc convenient food: therefore the Pope may, and ought to compel kings t do their duty. Out of which it followeth that the Pope as pastor o Christian men, is king of kings: which all Christian kings ought indee either to confess, or else they ought to take upon themselves th supreme pastoral charge, everyone in his own dominion."} +{"text":"His sixth and last argument is from examples. To which I answer, first that examples prove nothing: secondly, that the examples he alleget make not so much as a probability of right. The fact of Jehoiada, i killing Athaliah (2 Kings 11), was either by the authority of kin Joash, or it was a horrible crime in the high priest, which ever afte the election of king Saul was a mere subject. The fact of St. Ambros in excommunicating Theodosius the emperor, if it were true he did so was a capital crime. And for the Popes, Gregory I, Gregory II, Zachary and Leo III, their judgments are void, as given in their own cause; an the acts done by them conformably to this doctrine, are the greates crimes, especially that of Zachary, that are incident to human nature And thus much of Power Ecclesiastical; wherein I had been more brief forbearing to examine these arguments of Bellarmine, if they had bee his as a private man, and not as the champion of the Papacy against al other Christian Princes and States."} +{"text":"LIII"} +{"text":"Of What Is Necessary for a Man's Reception Into the Kingdom of Heaven"} +{"text":"The most frequent pretext of sedition, and civil war, in Christia commonwealths, hath a long time proceeded from a difficulty, not ye sufficiently resolved, of obeying at once both God and man, then whe their commandments are one contrary to the other. It is manifes enough, that when a man receiveth two contrary commands, and knows tha one of them is God's, he ought to obey that, and not the other, thoug it be the command even of his lawful sovereign (whether a monarch, or sovereign assembly), or the command of his father. The difficult therefore consisteth in this, that men, when they are commanded in th name of God, know not in divers cases, whether the command be from God or whether he that commandeth do but abuse God's name for some privat ends of his own. For as there were in the Church of the Jews, man false prophets, that sought reputation with the people, by feigne dreams and visions; so there have been in all times in the Church o Christ, false teachers, that seek reputation with the people, b fantastical and false doctrines; and by such reputation (as is th nature of ambition), to govern them for their private benefit."} +{"text":"But this difficulty of obeying both God and the civil sovereign o earth, to those that can distinguish between what is \"necessary,\" an what is not \"necessary for their reception into the kingdom of God,\" i of no moment. For if the command of the civil sovereign be such, a that it may be obeyed without the forfeiture of life eternal; not t obey it is unjust; and the precept of the apostle takes place \"Servants obey your masters in all things\"; and \"Children obey you parents in all things\"; and the precept of our Saviour, \"The Scribe and Pharisees sit in Moses' chair; all therefore they shall say, tha observe and do.\" But if the command be such as cannot be obeyed without being damned to eternal death; then it were madness to obey it and the counsel of our Saviour takes place (Matt. 10:28), \"Fear no those that kill the body, but cannot kill the soul.\" All men therefor that would avoid, both the punishments that are to be in this worl inflicted, for disobedience to their earthly sovereign, and those tha shall be inflicted in the world to come, for disobedience to God, hav need be taught to distinguish well between what is, and what is no necessary to eternal salvation."} +{"text":"All that is \"necessary to salvation,\" is contained in two virtues \"faith in Christ,\" and \"obedience to laws.\" The latter of these, if i were perfect, were enough to us. But because we are all guilty o disobedience to God's law, not only originally in Adam, but als actually by our own transgressions, there is required at our hands now not only \"obedience\" for the rest of our time, but also a \"remission o sins\" for the time past; which remission is the reward of our faith i Christ. That nothing else is necessarily required to salvation, i manifest from this, that the kingdom of heaven is shut to none but t sinners; that is to say, to the disobedient, or transgressors of th law; nor to them, in case they repent, and believe all the articles o Christian faith necessary to salvation."} +{"text":"The obedience required at our hands by God, that accepteth in all ou actions the will for the deed, is a serious endeavour to obey Him; an is called also by all such names as signify that endeavour. An therefore obedience is sometimes called by the names of \"charity\" an \"love,\" because they imply a will to obey; and our Saviour himsel maketh our love to God, and to one another, a fulfilling of the whol law: and sometimes by the name of \"righteousness\"; for righteousness i but the will to give to everyone his own; that is to say, the will t obey the laws: and sometimes by the name of \"repentance\"; because t repent implieth a turning away from sin, which is the same with th return of the will to obedience. Whosoever therefore unfeignedl desireth to fulfil the commandments of God, or repenteth him truly o his transgressions, or that loveth God with all his heart, and hi neighbour as himself, hath all the obedience necessary to his receptio into the kingdom of God. For if God should require perfect innocence there could no flesh be saved."} +{"text":"But what commandments are those that God hath given us? Are all thos laws which were given to the Jews by the hand of Moses the commandment of God? If they be, why are not Christians taught to obey them? If the be not, what others are so, besides the law of Nature? For our Saviou Christ hath not given us new laws, but counsel to observe those we ar subject to; that is to say, the laws of Nature and the laws of ou several sovereigns: nor did He make any new law to the Jews in Hi sermon on the Mount, but only expounded the law of Moses, to which the were subject before. The laws of God therefore are none but the laws o Nature, whereof the principal is, that we should not violate our faith that is, a commandment to obey our civil sovereigns, which w constituted over us by mutual pact one with another. And this law o God, that commandeth obedience to the law civil, commandeth b consequence obedience to all the precepts of the Bible; which, as have proved in the precedent chapter, is there only law, where th civil sovereign hath made it so; and in other places, but counsel which a man at his own peril may without injustice refuse to obey."} +{"text":"Knowing now what is the obedience necessary to salvation, and to who it is due; we are to consider next concerning faith, whom, and why w believe; and what are the articles or points necessary to be believe by them that shall be saved. And first, for the person whom we believe because it is impossible to believe any person before we know what h saith, it is necessary he be one that we have heard speak. The person therefore, whom Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Moses, and the prophets believed, was God himself that spake unto them supernaturally: and th person whom the apostles and disciples that conversed with Chris believed, was our Saviour himself. But of them, to whom neither God th Father, nor our Saviour, ever spake, it cannot be said that the perso whom they believed was God. They believed the apostles, and after the the pastors and doctors of the Church, that recommended to their fait the history of the Old and New Testament: so that the faith o Christians ever since our Saviour's time hath had for foundation first, the reputation of their pastors, and afterward the authority o those that made the Old and New Testament to be received for the rul of faith; which none could do but Christian sovereigns; who ar therefore the supreme pastors, and the only persons whom Christians no hear speak from God; except such as God speaketh to in these day supernaturally. But because there be many false prophets \"gone out int the world,\" other men are to examine such spirits, as St. John adviset us (1st Epistle 4:1), \"whether they be of God or not.\" And therefore seeing the examination of doctrines belongeth to the supreme pastor the person, which all they that have no special revelation are t believe, is, in every commonwealth, the supreme pastor, that is to say the civil sovereign."} +{"text":"The causes why men believe any Christian doctrine are various. Fo faith is the gift of God; and He worketh it in each several man by suc ways as it seemeth good unto himself. The most ordinary immediate caus of our belief, concerning any point of Christian faith, is, that w believe the Bible to be the word of God. But why we believe the Bibl to be the word of God is much disputed, as all questions must needs be that are not well stated. For they make not the question to be, \"why w believe it,\" but, \"how we know it\"; as if \"believing\" and \"knowing\ were all one. And thence while one side ground their knowledge upon th infallibility of the Church, and the other side, on the testimony o the private spirit, neither side concludeth what it pretends. For ho shall a man know the infallibility of the Church, but by knowing firs the infallibility of the Scripture? Or how shall a man know his ow private spirit to be other than a belief, grounded upon the authorit and arguments of his teachers, or upon a presumption of his own gifts Besides, there is nothing in the Scripture from which can be inferre the infallibility of the Church; much less of any particular Church and least of all, the infallibility of any particular man."} +{"text":"It is manifest therefore that Christian men do not know, but onl believe the Scripture to be the word of God; and that the means o making them believe, which God is pleased to afford men ordinarily, i according to the way of Nature, that is to say, from their teachers. I is the doctrine of St. Paul concerning Christian faith in general (Rom 10:17), \"faith cometh by hearing,\" that is, by hearing our lawfu pastors. He saith also (verses 14, 15, of the same chapter), \"How shal they believe in Him of whom they have not heard? and how shall the hear without a preacher? and how shall they preach, except they b sent?\" Whereby it is evident that the ordinary cause of believing tha the Scriptures are the word of God, is the same with the cause of th believing of all other articles of our faith, namely, the hearing o those that are by the law allowed and appointed to teach us, as ou parents in their houses, and our pastors in the churches. Which also i made more manifest by experience. For what other cause can there b assigned why, in Christian commonwealths, all men either believe, or a least profess the Scripture to be the word of God, and in othe commonwealths scarce any; but that in Christian commonwealths they ar taught it from their infancy; and in other places they are taugh otherwise?"} +{"text":"But if teaching be the cause of faith, why do not all believe? It i certain therefore that faith is the gift of God, and He giveth it t whom He will. Nevertheless, because to them to whom He giveth it, H giveth it by the means of teachers, the immediate cause of faith i hearing. In a school, where many are taught, and some profit, other profit not, the cause of learning in them that profit is the master yet it cannot be thence inferred that learning is not the gift of God All good things proceed from God; yet cannot all that have them sa they are inspired; for that implies a gift supernatural, and th immediate hand of God, which he that pretends to, pretends to be prophet, and is subject to the examination of the Church."} +{"text":"But whether men \"know,\" or \"believe,\" or \"grant\" the Scriptures to b the word of God; if out of such places of them as are without obscurit I shall show what articles of faith are necessary, and only necessar for salvation, those men must needs \"know,\" \"believe,\" or \"grant\" th same."} +{"text":"The unum necessarium, only article of faith, which the Scripture maket simply necessary to salvation, is this, that \"Jesus is the Christ.\" B the name of \"Christ\" is understood the king, which God had befor promised by the prophets of the Old Testament to send into the world to reign (over the Jews, and over such of other nations as shoul believe in Him), under himself eternally; and to give them that eterna life which was lost by the sin of Adam. Which when I have proved out o Scripture, I will further show when and in what sense some othe articles may be also called \"necessary.\""} +{"text":"For proof that the belief of this article, \"Jesus is the Christ,\" i all the faith required to salvation, my first argument shall be fro the scope of the Evangelists, which was by the description of the lif of our Saviour, to establish that one article, \"Jesus is the Christ.\ The sum of St. Matthew's Gospel is this, that Jesus was of the stock o David, born of a Virgin: which are the marks of the true Christ: tha the Magi came to worship Him as King of the Jews: that Herod for th same cause sought to kill Him: that John the Baptist proclaimed Him that He preached by himself and His apostles that He was that king that He taught the law, not as a Scribe, but as a man of authority that He cured diseases by His word only, and did many other miracles which were foretold the Christ should do: that He was saluted king whe He entered into Jerusalem: that He forewarned them to beware of al others that should pretend to be Christ: that He was taken, accused and put to death, for saying He was king: that the cause of Hi condemnation written on the cross was, Jesus of Nazareth, the King o the Jews. All which tend to no other end than this, that men shoul believe that \"Jesus is the Christ.\" Such therefore was the scope o St. Matthew's Gospel. But the scope of all the Evangelists, as ma appear by reading them, was the same. Therefore the scope of the whol gospel was the establishing of that only article. And St. Joh expressly makes it his conclusion (John 20:31), \"These things ar written, that you may know that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of th living God.\""} +{"text":"My second argument is taken from the subjects of the sermons of th apostles, both whilst our Saviour lived on earth, and after Hi ascension. The apostles, in our Saviour's time, were sent (Luke 9:2 \"to preach the kingdom of God.\" For neither there nor Matt. 10:7 givet He any commission to them other than this, \"As ye go, preach, saying the kingdom of heaven is at hand\"; that is, that Jesus is th \"Messiah,\" the \"Christ,\" the \"King\" which was to come. That thei preaching also after His ascension was the same, is manifest out o Acts 17:6�-�7, \"They drew,\" saith St. Luke, \"Jason and certain brethre unto the rulers of the city, crying, these that have turned the worl upside down are come hither also, whom Jason hath received; and thes all do contrary to the decrees of Caesar, saying, that there is anothe King, one Jesus.\" And out of the 2nd and 3rd verses of the sam chapter, where it is said that St. Paul, \"as his manner was, went i unto them; and three Sabbath days reasoned with them out of th Scriptures; opening and alleging that Christ must needs have suffered and risen again from the dead, and that this Jesus, whom he preached is Christ.\""} +{"text":"The third argument is from those places of Scripture, by which all th faith required to salvation is declared to be easy. For if an inwar assent of the mind to all the doctrines concerning Christian faith no taught, whereof the greatest part are disputed, were necessary t salvation, there would be nothing in the world so hard as to be Christian. The thief upon the cross, though repenting, could not hav been saved for saying, \"Lord remember me when thou comest into th kingdom\"; by which he testified no belief of any other article bu this, that \"Jesus was the king.\" Nor could it be said (as it is, Matt 11:30), that \"Christ's yoke is easy, and His burden light\"; nor tha \"little children believe in Him,\" as it is Matt. 18:6. Nor coul St. Paul have said (1 Cor. 1:21), \"It pleased God by the foolishness o preaching, to save them that believe.\" Nor could St. Paul himself hav been saved, much less have been so great a doctor of the Church s suddenly, that never perhaps thought of transubstantiation no purgatory, nor many other articles now obtruded."} +{"text":"The fourth argument is taken from places express, and such as receiv no controversy of interpretation; as first, John 5:39: \"Search th Scriptures, for in them ye think ye have eternal life; and they ar they that testify of me.\" Our Saviour here speaketh of the Scripture only of the Old Testament: for the Jews at that time could not searc the Scriptures of the New Testament, which were not written. But th Old Testament hath nothing of Christ but the marks by which men migh know Him when He came; as that He should descend from David, be born a Bethlehem, and of a Virgin; do great miracles, and the like. Therefor to believe that this Jesus was He, was sufficient to eternal life; bu more than sufficient is not necessary, and consequently no othe article is required. Again (John 11:26), \"Whosoever liveth an believeth in me, shall not die eternally.\" Therefore to believe i Christ is faith sufficient to eternal life; and consequently no mor faith than that is necessary. But to believe in Jesus, and to believ that Jesus is the Christ, is all one, as appeareth in the verse immediately following. For when our Saviour (verse 26) had said t Martha, \"Believest thou this?\" she answereth (verse 27), \"Yea, Lord, believe that thou art the Christ, the Son of God, which should com into the world.\" Therefore this article alone is faith sufficient t life eternal; and more than sufficient is not necessary. Thirdly (Joh 20:31): \"These things are written that ye might believe, that Jesus i the Christ, the Son of God, and that believing ye might have lif through His name.\" There, to believe that \"Jesus is the Christ,\" i faith sufficient to the obtaining of life; and therefore no othe article is necessary. Fourthly (1 John 4:2): \"Every spirit tha confesseth that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh, is of God.\" And ( John 5:1): \"Whosoever believeth that Jesus is the Christ, is born o God.\" And (verse 5): \"Who is he that overcometh the world, but he tha believeth that Jesus is the Son of God?\" Fifthly (Acts 8:36�-�37) \"See,\" saith the eunuch, \"here is water, what doth hinder me to b baptized? And Philip said, If thou believest with all thy heart, tho mayst. And he answered and said, I believe that Jesus Christ is the So of God.\" Therefore this article believed \"Jesus is the Christ,\" i sufficient to baptism, that is to say, to our reception into th kingdom of God, and by consequence, only necessary. And generally i all places where our Saviour saith to any man, \"Thy faith hath save thee,\" the cause He saith it, is some confession, which directly, or b consequence, implieth a belief that \"Jesus is the Christ.\""} +{"text":"The last argument is from the places where this article is made th foundation of faith: for he that holdeth the foundation shall be saved Which places are first, Matt. 24:23�-�24: \"If any man shall say unt you, Lo here is Christ, or there, believe it not; for there shall aris false Christs and false prophets, and shall show great signs an wonders,\" etc. Here we see this article, \"Jesus is the Christ,\" must b held, though he that shall teach the contrary should do great miracles The second place is, Gal. 1:8: \"Though we, or an angel from heaven preach any other gospel unto you, than that we have preached unto you let him be accursed.\" But the gospel which Paul and the other apostle preached, was only this article, that \"Jesus is the Christ\"; therefor for the belief of this article, we are to reject the authority of a angel from heaven; much more of any mortal man, if he teach th contrary. This is therefore the fundamental article of Christian faith A third place is (1 John 4:1�-�2), \"Beloved, believe not every spirit hereby ye shall know the Spirit of God; every spirit that confesset that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh, is of God.\" By which it i evident that this article is the measure and rule by which to estimat and examine all other articles; and is therefore only fundamental. fourth is, Matt. 16:16, 18, where after St. Peter had professed thi article, saying to our Saviour, \"Thou art Christ the Son of the livin God,\" our Saviour answered, \"Thou art Peter, and upon this rock I wil build my Church\"; from whence I infer that this article is that o which all other doctrines of the Church are built, as on thei foundation. A fifth is (1 Cor. 3:11�-�12, etc.), \"Other foundation ca no man lay, than that which is laid, Jesus is the Christ. Now if an man build upon this foundation, gold, silver, precious stones, wood hay, stubble; every man's work shall be made manifest; for the da shall declare it, because it shall be revealed by fire, and the fir shall try every man's work of what sort it is. If any man's work abide which he hath built thereupon, he shall receive a reward. If any man' work shall be burnt, he shall suffer loss; but he himself shall b saved, yet so as by fire.\" Which words, being partly plain and easy t understand, and partly allegorical and difficult; out of that which i plain may be inferred, that pastors that teach this foundation, tha \"Jesus is the Christ,\" though they draw from it false consequences which all men are sometimes subject to, they may nevertheless be saved much more that they may be saved, who being no pastors, but hearers believe that which is by their lawful pastors taught them. Therefor the belief of this article is sufficient; and by consequence, there i no other article of faith necessarily required to salvation."} +{"text":"Now for the part which is allegorical, as \"that the fire shall tr every man's work,\" and that \"they shall be saved, but so as by fire,\ or \"through fire\" (for the original is di� pur�*s), it maketh nothin against this conclusion which I have drawn from the other words, tha are plain. Nevertheless, because upon this place there hath been a argument taken, to prove the fire of purgatory, I will also here offe you my conjecture concerning the meaning of this trial of doctrines and saving of men as by fire. The apostle here seemeth to allude to th words of the prophet Zechariah (13:8�-�9), who speaking of th restoration of the kingdom of God, saith thus: \"Two parts therein shal be cut off, and die, but the third shall be left therein; and I wil bring the third part through the fire, and will refine them as silve is refined, and will try them as gold is tried; they shall call on th name of the Lord, and I will hear them.\" The day of judgment is the da of the restoration of the kingdom of God; and at that day it is, tha St. Peter tells us (2 Pet. 3:7, 10, 12) shall be the conflagration o the world, wherein the wicked shall perish; but the remnant which Go will save, shall pass through that fire unhurt, and be therein (a silver and gold are refined by the fire from their dross) tried, an refined from their idolatry, and be made to call upon the name of th true God. Alluding whereto, St. Paul here saith, that \"the day,\" tha is, the day of judgment, the great day of our Saviour's coming t restore the kingdom of God in Israel, shall try every man's doctrine by judging which are gold, silver, precious stones, wood, hay, stubble and then they that have built false consequences on the tru foundation, shall see their doctrines condemned; nevertheless the themselves shall be saved, and pass unhurt through this universal fire and live eternally, to call upon the name of the true and only God. I which sense there is nothing that accordeth not with the rest of Hol Scripture, or any glimpse of the fire of purgatory."} +{"text":"But a man may here ask, whether it be not as necessary to salvation, t believe, that God is omnipotent; Creator of the world; that Jesu Christ is risen; and that all men else shall rise again from the dea at the last day; as to believe that \"Jesus is the Christ.\" To which answer, they are: and so are many more articles: but they are such a are contained in this one, and may be deduced from it, with more o less difficulty. For who is there that does not see that they wh believe Jesus to be the Son of the God of Israel, and that th Israelites had for God the Omnipotent Creator of all things, do therei also believe that God is the Omnipotent Creator of all things? Or ho can a man believe that Jesus is the king that shall reign eternally unless he believe Him also risen again from the dead? For a dead ma cannot exercise the office of a king. In sum, he that holdeth thi foundation, \"Jesus is the Christ,\" holdeth expressly all that he seet rightly deduced from it, and implicitly all that is consequen thereunto, though he have not skill enough to discern the consequence And therefore it holdeth still good, that the belief of this on article is sufficient faith to obtain remission of sins to th \"penitent,\" and consequently to bring them into the kingdom of heaven."} +{"text":"Now that I have shown that all the obedience required to salvatio consisteth in the will to obey the law of God, that is to say, i repentance; and all the faith required to the same is comprehended i the belief of this article, \"Jesus is the Christ\"; I will furthe allege those places of the Gospel that prove that all that is necessar to salvation is contained in both these joined together. The men t whom St. Peter preached on the day of Pentecost, next after th ascension of our Saviour, asked him and the rest of the apostles saying (Acts 2:37), \"Men and brethren, what shall we do?\" To who St. Peter answered (in the next verse), \"Repent, and be baptized ever one of you, for the remission of sins, and ye shall receive the gift o the Holy Ghost.\" Therefore repentance and baptism, that is, believin that \"Jesus is the Christ,\" is all that is necessary to salvation Again, our Saviour being asked by a certain ruler (Luke 18:18), \"Wha shall I do to inherit eternal life?\" answered (verse 20), \"Thou knowes the commandments, do not commit adultery, do not kill, do not steal, d not bear false witness, honour thy father and thy mother.\" Which whe he said he had observed, our Saviour added (verse 22), \"Sell all tho hast, give it to the poor, and come and follow me\": which was as muc as to say, Rely on me that am the king. Therefore to fulfil the law and to believe that Jesus is the king, is all that is required to brin a man to eternal life. Thirdly, St. Paul saith (Rom. 1:17), \"The jus shall live by faith\"; not everyone, but the \"just\"; therefore \"faith\ and \"justice\" (that is, the \"will to be just,\" or \"repentance\") are al that is necessary to life eternal. And (Mark 1:15) our Saviou preached, saying, \"The time is fulfilled, and the kingdom of God is a hand, repent and believe the evangile,\" that is, the good news that th Christ was come. Therefore, to repent, and to believe that Jesus is th Christ, is all that is required to salvation."} +{"text":"Seeing then it is necessary that faith and obedience, implied in th word repentance, do both concur to our salvation; the question by whic of the two we are justified, is impertinently disputed. Nevertheless it will not be impertinent to make manifest in what manner each of the contributes thereunto; and in what sense it is said, that we are to b justified by the one, and by the other. And first, if by righteousnes be understood the justice of the works themselves, there is no man tha can be saved; for there is none that hath not transgressed the law o God. And therefore when we are said to be justified by works, it is t be understood of the will, which God doth always accept for the wor itself, as well in good as in evil men. And in this sense only it i that a man is called \"just\" or \"unjust\"; and that his justice justifie him, that is, gives him the title, in God's acceptation, of \"just\"; an renders him capable of \"living by his faith,\" which before he was not So that justice justifies in that sense in which to \"justify\" is th same as that to \"denominate a man just\"; and not in the significatio of discharging the law; whereby the punishment of his sins should b unjust."} +{"text":"But a man is then also said to be justified when his plea, though i itself insufficient, is accepted; as when we plead our will, ou endeavour to fulfil the law, and repent us of our failings, and Go accepteth it for the performance itself. And because God accepteth no the will for the deed, but only in the faithful; it is therefore fait that makes good our plea; and in this sense it is that faith onl justifies. So that \"faith\" and \"obedience\" are both necessary t salvation; yet in several senses each of them is said to justify."} +{"text":"Having thus shown what is necessary to salvation, it is not hard t reconcile our obedience to God with our obedience to the civi sovereign; who is either Christian or infidel. If he be a Christian, h alloweth the belief of this article, that \"Jesus is the Christ\"; and o all the articles that are contained in, or are by evident consequenc deduced from it: which is all the faith necessary to salvation. An because he is a sovereign, he requireth obedience to all his own, tha is, to all the civil laws; in which also are contained all the laws o Nature, that is, all the laws of God: for besides the laws of Nature and the laws of the Church, which are part of the civil law (for th Church that can make laws is the commonwealth), there be no other law divine. Whosoever therefore obeyeth his Christian sovereign, is no thereby hindered, neither from believing, nor from obeying God. Bu suppose that a Christian king should from this foundation \"Jesus is th Christ,\" draw some false consequences, that is to say, make som superstructions of hay or stubble, and command the teaching of th same; yet seeing St. Paul says he shall be saved; much more shall he b saved, that teacheth them by his command; and much more yet, he tha teaches not, but only believes his lawful teacher. And in case subject be forbidden by the civil sovereign to profess some of thos his opinions, upon what just ground can he disobey? Christian kings ma err in deducing a consequence, but who shall judge? Shall a private ma judge, when the question is of his own obedience? Or shall any ma judge but he that is appointed thereto by the Church, that is, by th civil sovereign that representeth it? Or if the Pope, or an apostl judge, may he not err in deducing of a consequence? Did not one of th two, St. Peter or St. Paul, err in a superstructure, when St. Pau withstood St. Peter to his face? There can therefore be n contradiction between the laws of God and the laws of a Christia commonwealth."} +{"text":"And when the civil sovereign is an infidel, every one of his ow subjects that resisteth him, sinneth against the laws of God (for suc are the laws of Nature), and rejecteth the counsel of the apostles that admonisheth all Christians to obey their princes, and all childre and servants to obey their parents and masters in all things. And fo their \"faith,\" it is internal and invisible; they have the license tha Naaman had, and need not put themselves into danger for it. But if the do, they ought to expect their reward in heaven, and not complain o their lawful sovereign; much less make war upon him. For he that is no glad of any just occasion of martyrdom, has not the faith h professeth, but pretends it only, to set some colour upon his ow contumacy. But what infidel king is so unreasonable, as knowing he ha a subject, that waiteth for the second coming of Christ, after th present world shall be burnt, and intendeth then to obey him (which i the intent of believing that Jesus is the Christ), and in the meantim thinketh himself bound to obey the laws of that infidel king (which al Christians are obliged in conscience to do), to put to death or t persecute such a subject?"} +{"text":"And thus much shall suffice concerning the kingdom of God and polic ecclesiastical. Wherein I pretend not to advance any position of m own, but only to show what are the consequences that seem to m deducible from the principles of Christian politics (which are the Hol Scriptures), in confirmation of the power of civil sovereigns, and th duty of their subjects. And in the allegation of Scripture I hav endeavoured to avoid such texts as are of obscure or controverte interpretation; and to allege none, but in such sense as is most plai and agreeable to the harmony and scope of the whole Bible; which wa written for the reestablishment of the kingdom of God in Christ. For i is not the bare words, but the scope of the writer, that giveth th true light by which any writing is to be interpreted; and they tha insist upon single texts, without considering the main design, ca derive nothing from them clearly; but rather by casting atoms o Scripture, as dust before men's eyes, make everything more obscure tha it is; an ordinary artifice of those that seek not the truth, but thei own advantage."} +{"text":"t IV"} +{"text":"Of the Kingdom of Darkness"} +{"text":"LIV"} +{"text":"Of Spiritual Darkness, from Misinterpretation of Scripture"} +{"text":"Besides these sovereign powers, \"divine\" and \"human,\" of which I hav hitherto discoursed, there is mention in Scripture of another power namely (Eph. 6:12), that of \"the rulers of the darkness of this world\" (Matt. 12:26), \"the kingdom of Satan\"; and (Matt. 9:34), \"th principality of Beelzebub over demons,\" that is to say, over phantasm that appear in the air: for which cause Satan is also called (Eph 2:2), \"the prince of the power of the air\"; and, because he ruleth i the darkness of this world (John 16:11), \"the prince of this world\" and in consequence hereunto, they who are under his dominion, i opposition to the faithful (who are the \"children of the light\"), ar called the \"children of darkness.\" For seeing Beelzebub is prince o phantasms, inhabitants of his dominion of air and darkness, th children of darkness, and these demons, phantasms, or spirits o illusion, signify allegorically the same thing. This considered, th kingdom of darkness, as it is set forth in these and other places o the Scripture, is nothing else but a \"confederacy of deceivers, that t obtain dominion over men in this present world endeavour by dark an erroneous doctrines to extinguish in them the light both of Nature an of the Gospel, and so to disprepare them for the kingdom of God t come.\""} +{"text":"As men that are utterly deprived from their nativity of the light o the bodily eye have no idea at all of any such light; and no ma conceives in his imagination any greater light than he hath at som time or other perceived by his outward senses: so also is it of th light of the Gospel, and of the light of the understanding, that no ma can conceive there is any greater degree of it than that which he hat already attained unto. And from hence it comes to pass that men have n other means to acknowledge their own darkness but only by reasonin from the unforeseen mischances that befall them in their ways. Th darkest part of the kingdom of Satan is that which is without th Church of God; that is to say, amongst them that believe not in Jesu Christ. But we cannot say that therefore the Church enjoyeth, as th land of Goshen, all the light which to the performance of the wor enjoined us by God is necessary. Whence comes it that in Christendo there has been, almost from the time of the apostles, such justling o one another out of their places, both by foreign and civil war; suc stumbling at every little asperity of their own fortune, and ever little eminence of that of other men, and such diversity of ways i running to the same mark, \"felicity,\" if it be not night amongst us, o at least a mist? We are therefore yet in the dark."} +{"text":"The enemy has been here in the night of our natural ignorance, and sow the tares of spiritual errors; and that, first, by abusing and puttin out the light of the Scriptures: for we err, not knowing th Scriptures. Secondly, by introducing the demonology of the heathe poets, that is to say, their fabulous doctrine concerning demons, whic are but idols, or phantasms of the brain, without any real nature o their own, distinct from human fancy; such as are dead men's ghosts and fairies, and other matter of old wives' tales. Thirdly, by mixin with the Scripture divers relics of the religion, and much of the vai and erroneous philosophy of the Greeks, especially of Aristotle Fourthly, by mingling with both these, false or uncertain traditions and feigned or uncertain history. And so we come to err, \"by givin heed to seducing spirits,\" and the demonology of such \"as speak lies i hypocrisy\"; or as it is in the original (1 Tim. 4:1�-�2), \"of thos that play the part of liars, with a seared conscience,\" that is contrary to their own knowledge. Concerning the first of these, whic is the seducing of men, by abuse of Scripture, I intend to spea briefly in this chapter."} +{"text":"The greatest and main abuse of Scripture, and to which almost all th rest are either consequent or subservient, is the wresting of it, t prove that the kingdom of God, mentioned so often in the Scripture, i the present Church, or multitude of Christian men now living, or tha being dead, are to rise again at the last day: whereas the kingdom o God was first instituted by the ministry of Moses, over the Jews only who were therefore called His peculiar people; and ceased afterward, i the election of Saul, when they refused to be governed by God any more and demanded a king after the manner of the nations; which God himsel consented unto, as I have more at large proved before in chapter XXXV After that time, there was no other kingdom of God in the world, by an pact or otherwise, than He ever was, is, and shall be king of all men and of all creatures, as governing according to His will, by Hi infinite power. Nevertheless, He promised by His prophets to restor this His government to them again, when the time He hath in His secre counsel appointed for it shall be fully come, and when they shall tur unto Him by repentance and amendment of life. And not only so, but H invited the Gentiles to come in and enjoy the happiness of His reign on the same conditions of conversion and repentance; and He promise also to send His Son into the world, to expiate the sins of them all b His death, and to prepare them by His doctrine to receive Him at Hi second coming. Which second coming not yet being, the kingdom of God i not yet come, and we are not now under any other kings by pact, but ou civil sovereigns; saving only, that Christian men are already in th kingdom of grace, inasmuch as they have already the promise of bein received at His coming again."} +{"text":"Consequent to this error, that the present Church is Christ's kingdom there ought to be some one man, or assembly, by whose mouth ou Saviour, now in heaven, speaketh, giveth law, and which representet His person to all Christians: or divers men, or divers assemblies, tha do the same to divers parts of Christendom. This power regal unde Christ, being challenged, universally by the Pope, and in particula commonwealths by assemblies of the pastors of the place (when th Scripture gives it to none but to civil sovereigns), comes to be s passionately disputed, that it putteth out the light of Nature, an causeth so great a darkness in men's understanding, that they see no who it is to whom they have engaged their obedience."} +{"text":"Consequent to this claim of the Pope to be vicar-general of Christ i the present Church (supposed to be that kingdom of His to which we ar addressed in the Gospel), is the doctrine, that it is necessary for Christian king to receive his crown by a bishop; as if it were fro that ceremony that he derives the clause of Dei gratia in his title and that then only he is made king by the favour of God, when he i crowned by the authority of God's universal vicegerent on earth; an that every bishop, whosoever be his sovereign, taketh at hi consecration an oath of absolute obedience to the Pope. Consequent t the same, is the doctrine of the fourth Council of Lateran, held unde Pope Innocent the Third (chap. III. De Haereticis), \"that if a king a the Pope's admonition, do not purge his kingdom of heresies, and bein excommunicate for the same, do not give satisfaction within a year, hi subjects are absolved of the bond of their obedience.\" Where, b heresies are understood all opinions which the Church of Rome hat forbidden to be maintained. And by this means, as often as there is an repugnancy between the political designs of the Pope, and othe Christian princes, as there is very often, there ariseth such a mis amongst their subjects, that they know not a stranger that thrustet himself into the throne of their lawful prince, from him whom they ha themselves placed there; and in this darkness of mind are made to figh one against another, without discerning their enemies from thei friends, under the conduct of another man's ambition."} +{"text":"From the same opinion, that the present Church is the kingdom of God it proceeds that pastors, deacons, and all other ministers of th Church, take the name to themselves of the \"clergy\"; giving to othe Christians the name of \"laity,\" that is, simply \"people.\" For clerg signifies those whose maintenance is that revenue, which God havin reserved to himself during His reign over the Israelites, assigned t the tribe of Levi (who were to be His public ministers, and had n portion of land set them out to live on as their brethren), to be thei inheritance. The Pope therefore, pretending the present Church to be as the realm of Israel, the kingdom of God, challenging to himself an his subordinate ministers the like revenue, as the inheritance of God the name of clergy was suitable to that claim. And thence it is tha tithes and other tributes paid to the Levites, as God's right, amongs the Israelites, have a long time been demanded, and taken o Christians, by ecclesiastics, jure divino, that is, in God's right. B which means the people everywhere were obliged to a double tribute; on to the state, another to the clergy; whereof, that to the clergy, bein the tenth of their revenue, is double to that which a king of Athens and esteemed a tyrant, exacted of his subjects for the defraying of al public charges: for he demanded no more but the twentieth part, and ye abundantly maintained therewith the commonwealth. And in the kingdom o the Jews, during the sacerdotal reign of God, the tithes and offering were the whole public revenue."} +{"text":"From the same mistaking of the present Church for the kingdom of God came in the distinction between the \"civil\" and the \"canon\" laws: th civil law being the acts of \"sovereigns\" in their own dominions, an the canon law being the acts of the Pope in the same dominion. Whic canons, though they were but canons, that is, \"rules propounded,\" an but voluntarily received by Christian princes, till the translation o the empire to Charlemagne; yet afterwards, as the power of the Pop increased, became \"rules commanded,\" and the emperors themselves, t avoid greater mischiefs, which the people blinded might be led into were forced to let them pass for laws."} +{"text":"From hence it is, that in all dominions where the Pope's ecclesiastica power is entirely received, Jews, Turks, and Gentiles, are in the Roma Church tolerated in their religion, as far forth, as in the exercis and profession thereof they offend not against the civil power: wherea in a Christian, though a stranger, not to be of the Roman religion, i capital; because the Pope pretendeth that all Christians are hi subjects. For otherwise it were as much against the law of nations t persecute a Christian stranger, for professing the religion of his ow country, as an infidel; or rather more, inasmuch as they that are no against Christ, are with Him."} +{"text":"From the same it is, that in every Christian state there are certai men that are exempt, by ecclesiastical liberty, from the tributes an from the tribunals of the civil state; for so are the secular clergy besides monks and friars, which in many places bear so great proportion to the common people, as if need were, there might be raise out of them alone an army, sufficient for any war the Church militan should employ them in, against their own or other princes."} +{"text":"A second general abuse of Scripture, is the turning of consecratio into conjuration, or enchantment. To \"consecrate\" is, in Scripture, t offer, give, or dedicate, in pious and decent language and gesture, man, or any other thing to God, by separating of it from common use that is to say, to sanctify, or make it God's, and to be used only b those whom God hath appointed to be His public ministers (as I hav already proved at large in the thirty-fifth chapter), and thereby t change, not the thing consecrated, but only the use of it, from bein profane and common, to be holy, and peculiar to God's service. But whe by such words, the nature or quality of the thing itself is pretende to be changed, it is not consecration, but either an extraordinary wor of God, or a vain and impious conjuration. But seeing, for th frequency of pretending the change of nature in their consecrations, i cannot be esteemed a work extraordinary, it is no other than \"conjuration\" or \"incantation,\" whereby they would have men to believ an alteration of Nature that is not, contrary to the testimony of man' sight, and of all the rest of his senses. As for example, when th priest, instead of consecrating bread and wine to God's peculia service in the sacrament of the Lord's Supper (which is but separation of it from the common use, to signify, that is, to put me in mind of their redemption, by the passion of Christ, whose body wa broken, and blood shed upon the cross for our transgressions) pretends, that by saying of the words of our Saviour, \"This is m body,\" and \"This is my blood,\" the nature of bread is no more there but His very body; notwithstanding there appeareth not to the sight, o other sense of the receiver, anything that appeared not before th consecration. The Egyptian conjurers, that are said to have turne their rods to serpents, and the water into blood, are thought but t have deluded the senses of the spectators by a false show of things yet are esteemed enchanters. But what should we have thought of them if there had appeared in their rods nothing like a serpent, and in th water enchanted nothing like blood, nor like anything else but water but that they had faced down the king, that they were serpents tha looked like rods, and that it was blood that seemed water? That ha been both enchantment and lying. And yet in this daily act of th priest they do the very same, by turning the holy words into the manne of a charm, which produceth nothing new to the sense; but they face u down, that it hath turned the bread into a man; nay more, into a God and require men to worship it, as if it were our Saviour himsel present God and man, and thereby to commit most gross idolatry. For i it be enough to excuse it of idolatry, to say it is no more bread, bu God; why should not the same excuse serve the Egyptians, in case the had the faces to say, the leeks and onions they worshipped were no very leeks and onions, but a divinity under their \"species,\" o likeness. The words, \"This is my body,\" are equivalent to these, \"thi signifies,\" or \"represents my body\"; and it is an ordinary figure o speech: but to take it literally is an abuse; nor though so taken, ca it extend any further than to the bread which Christ himself with Hi own hands consecrated. For He never said that of what bread soever, an priest whatsoever should say, \"This is my body,\" or \"This is Christ' body,\" the same should presently be transubstantiated. Nor did th Church of Rome ever establish this transubstantiation till the time o Innocent the Third; which was not above 500 years ago, when the powe of popes was at the highest, and the darkness of the time grown s great, as men discerned not the bread that was given them to eat especially when it was stamped with the figure of Christ upon th cross, as if they would have men believe it were transubstantiated, no only into the body of Christ, but also into the wood of His cross, an that they did eat both together in the sacrament."} +{"text":"The like incantation, instead of consecration, is used also in th sacrament of baptism: where the abuse of God's name in each severa person, and in the whole Trinity, with the sign of the cross at eac name, maketh up the charm. As first, when they make the holy water, th priest saith, \"I conjure thee, thou creature of water, in the name o God the Father Almighty, and in the name of Jesus Christ His only So our Lord, and in virtue of the Holy Ghost, that thou become conjure water, to drive away all the powers of the enemy, and to eradicate an supplant the enemy,\" etc. And the same in the benediction of the sal to be mingled with it: \"That thou become conjured salt, that al phantasms and knavery of the devil's fraud may fly and depart from th place wherein thou art sprinkled; and every unclean spirit be conjure by Him that shall come to judge the quick and the dead.\" The same i the benediction of the oil: \"That all the power of the enemy, all th host of the devil, all assaults and phantasms of Satan, may be drive away by this creature of oil.\" And for the infant that is to b baptized, he is subject to many charms: first, at the church door th priest blows thrice in the child's face, and says: \"Go out of him unclean spirit, and give place to the Holy Ghost the Comforter.\" As i all children, till blown on by the priest, were demoniacs. Again before his entrance into the church, he saith as before, \"I conjur thee, etc., to go out, and depart from this servant of God.\" And agai the same exorcism is repeated once more before he be baptized. These and some other incantations, are those that are used instead o benedictions and consecrations, in administration of the sacraments o baptism and the Lord's Supper; wherein everything that serveth to thos holy uses, except the unhallowed spittle of the priest, hath some se form of exorcism."} +{"text":"Nor are the other rites, as of marriage, of extreme unction, o visitation of the sick, of consecrating churches and churchyards, an the like, exempt from charms; inasmuch as there is in them the use o enchanted oil and water, with the abuse of the cross, and of the hol word of David, asperges me Domine hyssopo, as things of efficacy t drive away phantasms and imaginary spirits."} +{"text":"Another general error is from the misinterpretation of the word \"eternal life,\" \"everlasting death,\" and the \"second death.\" For thoug we read plainly in Holy Scripture that God created Adam in an estate o living forever, which was conditional, that is to say, if he disobeye not His commandment; which was not essential to human nature, bu consequent to the virtue of the tree of life; whereof he had liberty t eat, as long as he had not sinned; and that he was thrust out o Paradise after he had sinned, lest he should eat thereof, and liv forever; and that Christ's Passion is a discharge of sin to all tha believe on Him; and by consequence, a restitution of eternal life t all the faithful, and to them only: yet the doctrine is now, and hat been a long time far otherwise; namely, that every man hath eternity o life by nature, inasmuch as his soul is immortal. So that the flamin sword at the entrance of Paradise, though it hinder a man from comin to the tree of life, hinders him not from the immortality which Go took from him for his sin; nor makes him to need the sacrificing o Christ, for the recovering of the same; and consequently, not only th faithful and righteous, but also the wicked and the heathen, shal enjoy eternal life, without any death at all; much less a second, an everlasting death. To salve this, it is said, that by second an everlasting death, is meant a second, and everlasting life, but i torments; a figure never used but in this very case."} +{"text":"All which doctrine is founded only on some of the obscurer places o the New Testament; which nevertheless, the whole scope of the Scriptur considered, are clear enough in a different sense, and unnecessary t the Christian faith. For supposing that when a man dies, ther remaineth nothing of him but his carcass; cannot God, that raise inanimated dust and clay into a living creature by His word, as easil raise a dead carcass to life again, and continue him alive forever, o make him die again, by another word? The \"soul\" in Scripture signifieth always, either the life or the living creature; and the bod and soul jointly, the \"body alive.\" In the fifth day of the creation God said: Let the waters produce reptile animae viventis, the creepin thing that hath in it a living soul; the English translate it, \"tha hath life.\" And again, God created whales, et omnem animam viventem which in the English is, \"every living creature.\" And likewise of man God made him of the dust of the earth, and breathed in his face th breath of life, et factus est homo in animam viventem, that is, \"an man was made a living creature.\" And after Noah came out of the ark God saith, He will no more smite omnem animam viventem, that is, \"ever living creature.\" And (Deut. 12:23), \"Eat not the blood, for the bloo is the soul\"; that is, \"the life.\" From which places, if by \"soul\" wer meant a \"substance incorporeal,\" with an existence separated from th body, it might as well be inferred of any other living creature as o man. But that the souls of the faithful, are not of their own nature but by God's special grace, to remain in their bodies, from th resurrection to all eternity, I have already, I think, sufficientl proved out of the Scriptures, in chapter XXXVIII. And for the places o the New Testament, where it is said that any man shall be cast body an soul into hell fire, it is no more than body and life; that is to say they shall be cast alive into the perpetual fire of Gehenna."} +{"text":"This window it is that gives entrance to the dark doctrine, first, o eternal torments; and afterwards of purgatory, and consequently of th walking abroad, especially in places consecrated, solitary, or dark, o the ghosts of men deceased; and thereby to the pretences of exorcis and conjuration of phantasms; as also of invocation of men dead; and t the doctrine of indulgences, that is to say, of exemption for a time or forever, from the fire of purgatory, wherein these incorporea substances are pretended by burning to be cleansed, and made fit fo heaven. For men being generally possessed before the time of ou Saviour, by contagion of the demonology of the Greeks, of an opinio that the souls of men were substances distinct from their bodies, an therefore that when the body was dead, the soul of every man, whethe godly or wicked, must subsist somewhere by virtue of its own nature without acknowledging therein any supernatural gift of God; the doctor of the Church doubted a long time, what was the place which they wer to abide in, till they should be reunited to their bodies in th resurrection; supposing for a while, they lay under the altars; bu afterwards the Church of Rome found it more profitable to build fo them this place of purgatory; which by some other Churches in thi latter age has been demolished."} +{"text":"Let us now consider what texts of Scripture seem most to confirm thes three general errors, I have here touched. As for those which Cardina Bellarmine hath alleged, for the present kingdom of God administered b the Pope, than which there are none that make a better show of proof; have already answered them; and made it evident that the kingdom o God, instituted by Moses, ended in the election of Saul; after whic time the priest of his own authority never deposed any king. That whic the high priest did to Athaliah, was not done in his own right, but i the right of the young king Joash her son; but Solomon in his own righ deposed the high priest Abiathar, and set up another in his place. Th most difficult place to answer, of all those that can be brought t prove the kingdom of God by Christ is already in this world, i alleged, not by Bellarmine, nor any other of the Church of Rome; but b Beza, that will have it to begin from the resurrection of Christ. Bu whether he intend thereby to entitle the presbytery to the suprem power ecclesiastical in the commonwealth of Geneva, and consequently t every presbytery in every other commonwealth, or to princes, and othe civil sovereigns, I do not know. For the presbytery hath challenged th power to excommunicate their own kings, and to be the suprem moderators in religion, in the places where they have that form o Church government, no less than the Pope challengeth it universally."} +{"text":"The words are (Mark 9:1), \"Verily I say unto you, that there be some o them that stand here, which shall not taste of death, till they hav seen the kingdom of God come with power.\" Which words, if take grammatically, make it certain that either some of those men that stoo by Christ at that time, are yet alive; or else, that the kingdom of Go must be now in this present world. And then there is another place mor difficult. For when the apostles, after our Saviour's resurrection, an immediately before His ascension, asked our Saviour, saying (Acts 1:6) \"Wilt thou at this time restore again the kingdom to Israel?\" H answered them, \"It is not for you to know the times and the seasons which the Father hath put in His own power; but ye shall receive powe by the coming of the Holy Ghost upon you, and ye shall be my (martyrs witnesses both in Jerusalem, and in all Judea, and in Samaria, and unt the uttermost part of the earth.\" Which is as much as to say, \"M kingdom is not yet come, nor shall you foreknow when it shall come; fo it shall come as a thief in the night; but I will send you the Hol Ghost, and by Him you shall have power to bear witness to all th world, by your preaching of my resurrection, and the works I have done and the doctrine I have taught, that they may believe in me, and expec eternal life, at my coming again.\" How does this agree with the comin of Christ's kingdom at the resurrection? And that which St. Paul say (1 Thess. 1:9�-�10), \"That they turned from idols, to serve the livin and true God, and to wait for his Son from heaven\"; where to wait fo his Son from heaven, is to wait for His coming to be king in power which were not necessary if His kingdom had been then present. Again if the kingdom of God began, as Beza on that place (Mark 9:1) woul have it, at the resurrection, what reason is there for Christians eve since the resurrection to say in their prayers, \"Let thy kingdom come?\ It is therefore manifest, that the words of St. Mark are not so to b interpreted. There be some of them that stand here, saith our Saviour that shall not taste of death till they have seen the kingdom of Go come in power. If then this kingdom were to come at the resurrection o Christ, why is it said, \"some of them,\" rather than \"all?\" For they al lived till after Christ was risen."} +{"text":"But they that require an exact interpretation of this text, let the interpret first the like words of our Saviour to St. Peter, concernin St. John (21:22), \"If I will that he tarry till I come, what is that t thee?\" upon which was grounded a report that he should not die Nevertheless the truth of that report was neither confirmed, as wel grounded; nor refuted, as ill grounded on those words; but left as saying not understood. The same difficulty is also in the place o St. Mark. And if it be lawful to conjecture at their meaning, by tha which immediately follows, both here and in St. Luke, where the same i again repeated, it is not improbable to say they have relation to th Transfiguration, which is described in the verses immediatel following: where it is said, that \"after six days Jesus taketh with hi Peter, and James, and John\" (not all, but some of His disciples), \"an leadeth them up into a high mountain apart by themselves, and wa transfigured before them: and His raiment became shining, exceedin white as snow; so as no fuller on earth can white them: and ther appeared unto them, Elias with Moses, and they were talking wit Jesus,\" etc. So that they saw Christ in glory and majesty, as He is t come; insomuch as \"they were sore afraid.\" And thus the promise of ou Saviour was accomplished by way of \"vision.\" For it was a vision, a may probably be inferred out of St. Luke, that reciteth the same stor (9:28, etc.), and saith, that Peter and they that were with him, wer heavy with sleep: but most certainly out of Matt. 17:9, where the sam is again related; for our Saviour charged them, saying, \"Tell no ma the vision until the Son of man be risen from the dead.\" Howsoever i be, yet there can from thence be taken no argument to prove that th kingdom of God taketh beginning till the day of judgment."} +{"text":"As for some other texts, to prove the Pope's power over civi sovereigns (besides those of Bellarmine), as that the two swords tha Christ and His apostles had amongst them, were the spiritual and th temporal sword, which they say St. Peter had given him by Christ; an that of the two luminaries, the greater signifies the Pope, and th lesser the king, one might as well infer out of the first verse of th Bible, that by heaven is meant the Pope, and by earth the king. Whic is not arguing from Scripture, but a wanton insulting over princes that came in fashion after the time the Popes were grown so secure o their greatness, as to contemn all Christian kings, and treading on th necks of emperors, to mock both them and the Scripture, in the words o Psalm 91:13, \"Thou shalt tread upon the lion and the adder; the youn lion and the dragon thou shalt trample under thy feet.\""} +{"text":"As for the rights of consecration, though they depend for the most par upon the discretion and judgment of the governors of the Church, an not upon the Scriptures; yet those governors are obliged to suc direction as the nature of the action itself requireth, as that th ceremonies, words, and gestures, be both decent and significant, or a least conformable to the action. When Moses consecrated the tabernacle the altar, and the vessels belonging to them (Exod. 40:9), he anointe them with the oil which God had commanded to be made for that purpose and they were holy; there was nothing exorcised to drive awa phantasms. The same Moses, the civil sovereign of Israel, when h consecrated Aaron, the high priest, and his sons, did wash them wit water, not exorcised water, put their garments upon them, and anointe them with oil; and they were sanctified to minister unto the Lord i the priest's office; which was a simple and decent cleansing, an adorning them, before he presented them to God, to be His servants When king Solomon, the civil sovereign of Israel, consecrated th temple he had built (1 Kings 8), he stood before all the congregatio of Israel, and having blessed them, he gave thanks to God, for puttin into the heart of his father to build it; and for giving to himself th grace to accomplish the same: and then prayed unto Him, first, t accept that house, though it were not suitable to His infinit greatness, and to hear the prayers of His servants that should pra therein; or, if they were absent, towards it; and lastly, he offered sacrifice of peace-offering, and the house was dedicated. Here was n procession; the king stood still in his first place; no exorcise water; no Asperges me, nor other impertinent application of word spoken upon another occasion; but a decent and rational speech, an such as in making to God a present of his new-built house, was mos conformable to the occasion."} +{"text":"We read not that St. John did exorcise the water of Jordan; nor Phili the water of the river wherein he baptized the eunuch; nor that an pastor in the time of the apostles, did take his spittle, and put it t the nose of the person to be baptized, and say, in odorem suavitatis that is, \"for a sweet savour unto the Lord\"; wherein neither th ceremony of spittle, for the uncleanness; nor the application of tha Scripture for the levity, can by any authority of man be justified."} +{"text":"To prove that the soul separated from the body liveth eternally, no only the souls of the elect, by especial grace, and restoration of th eternal life which Adam lost by sin, and our Saviour restored by th sacrifice of himself to the faithful; but also the souls of reprobates as a property naturally consequent to the essence of mankind, withou other grace of God but that which is universally given to all mankind there are divers places, which at the first sight seem sufficiently t serve the turn: but such, as when I compare them with that which I hav before (chapter XXXVIII) alleged out of the 14th of Job, seem to m much more subject to a diverse interpretation than the words of Job."} +{"text":"And first there are the words of Solomon (Eccles. 12:7), \"Then shal the dust return to dust, as it was, and the spirit shall return to Go that gave it.\" Which may bear well enough, if there be no other tex directly against it, this interpretation that God only knows, but ma not, what becomes of a man's spirit when he expireth; and the sam Solomon, in the same book (3:20�-�21), delivereth the same sentence i the same sense I have given it. His words are: \"All go\" (man and beast \"to the same place; all are of the dust, and all turn to dust again who knoweth that the spirit of man goeth upward, and that the spirit o the beast goeth downward to the earth?\" That is, none knows but God nor is it an unusual phrase to say of things we understand not, \"Go knows what,\" and \"God knows where.\" That of (Gen. 5:24) \"Enoch walke with God, and he was not; for God took him\"; which is expounded (Heb 11:5), \"He was translated, that he should not die; and was not found because God had translated him. For before his translation, he had thi testimony, that he pleased God\"; making as much for the immortality o the body as of the soul, proveth that this his translation was peculia to them that please God; not common to them with the wicked, an depending on grace, not on nature. But on the contrary, wha interpretation shall we give besides the literal sense, of the words o Solomon (Eccles. 3:19), \"That which befalleth the sons of men befalleth beasts; even one thing befalleth them; as the one dieth, s doth the other; yea, they have all one breath\" (one spirit); \"so that man hath no preeminence above a beast, for all is vanity.\" By th literal sense, here is no natural immortality of the soul; nor yet an repugnancy with the life eternal which the elect shall enjoy by grace And (Eccles. 4:3), \"Better is he that hath not yet been, than bot they\"; that is than they that live, or have lived; which, if the sou of all them that have lived were immortal, were a hard saying; for the to have an immortal soul, were worse than to have no soul at all. An again (9:5), \"The living know they shall die, but the dead know no anything\"; that is, naturally, and before the resurrection of the body."} +{"text":"Another place which seems to make for a natural immortality of th soul, is that where our Saviour saith that Abraham, Isaac, and Jaco are living: but this is spoken of the promise of God, and of thei certitude to rise again, not of a life then actual; and in the sam sense that God said to Adam, that on the day he should eat of th forbidden fruit, he should certainly die; from that time forward he wa a dead man by sentence; but not by execution, till almost a thousan years after. So Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob were alive by promise, then when Christ spake; but are not actually till the resurrection. And th history of Dives and Lazarus makes nothing against this, if we take it as it is, for a parable."} +{"text":"But there be other places of the New Testament where an immortalit seemeth to be directly attributed to the wicked. For it is evident tha they shall all rise to judgment. And it is said besides in many places that they shall go into \"everlasting fire, everlasting torments everlasting punishments; and that the worm of conscience never dieth\" and all this is comprehended in the word \"everlasting death,\" which i ordinarily interpreted \"everlasting life in torments.\" And yet I ca find nowhere that any man shall live in torments everlastingly. Also it seemeth hard to say, that God, who is the Father of mercies; tha doth in heaven and earth all that He will; that hath the hearts of al men in His disposing; that worketh in men both to do and to will; an without whose free gift a man hath neither inclination to good, no repentance of evil, should punish men's transgressions without any en of time, and with all the extremity of torture that men can imagine and more. We are therefore to consider what the meaning is o \"everlasting fire,\" and other the like phrases of Scripture."} +{"text":"I have showed already that the kingdom of God by Christ beginneth a the day of judgment: that in that day the faithful shall rise again with glorious and spiritual bodies, and be His subjects in that Hi kingdom, which shall be eternal: that they shall neither marry, nor b given in marriage, nor eat and drink, as they did in their natura bodies; but live forever in their individual persons, without th specifical eternity of generation: and that the reprobates also shal rise again, to receive punishments for their sins: as also, that thos of the elect, which shall be alive in their earthly bodies at that day shall have their bodies suddenly changed, and made spiritual an immortal. But that the bodies of the reprobate, who make the kingdom o Satan, shall also be glorious or spiritual bodies, or that they shal be as the angels of God, neither eating, nor drinking, nor engendering or that their life shall be eternal in their individual persons, as th life of every faithful man is, or as the life of Adam had been if h had not sinned, there is no place of Scripture to prove it; save onl these places concerning eternal torments; which may otherwise b interpreted."} +{"text":"From whence may be inferred that as the elect after the resurrectio shall be restored to the estate wherein Adam was before he had sinned so the reprobate shall be in the estate that Adam and his posterit were in after the sin committed; saving that God promised a Redeemer t Adam, and such of his seed as should trust in Him, and repent; but no to them that should die in their sins, as do the reprobate."} +{"text":"These things considered, the texts that mention \"eternal fire,\ \"eternal torments,\" or \"the worm that never dieth,\" contradict not th doctrine of a second and everlasting death, in the proper and natura sense of the word \"death.\" The fire, or torments prepared for th wicked in Gehenna, Tophet, or in what place soever, may continu forever; and there may never want wicked men to be tormented in them though not every nor any one eternally. For the wicked being left i the estate they were in after Adam's sin, may at the resurrection liv as they did, marry, and give in marriage, and have gross an corruptible bodies, as all mankind now have; and consequently ma engender perpetually, after the resurrection, as they did before: fo there is no place in Scripture to the contrary. For St. Paul, speakin of the resurrection (1 Cor. 15) understandeth it only of th resurrection to life eternal; and not the resurrection to punishment And of the first, he saith, that the body is \"sown in corruption raised in incorruption; sown in dishonour, raised in honour; sown i weakness, raised in power; sown a natural body, raised a spiritua body.\" There is no such thing can be said of the bodies of them tha rise to punishment. So also our Saviour, when He speaketh of the natur of man after the resurrection, meaneth the resurrection to lif eternal, not to punishment. The text is (Luke 20:34�-�36) a fertil text: \"The children of this world marry, and are given in marriage; bu they that shall be counted worthy to obtain that world, and th resurrection from the dead, neither marry, nor are given in marriage neither can they die any more; for they are equal to the angels, an are the children of God, being the children of the resurrection.\" Th children of this world, that are in the estate which Adam left them in shall marry, and be given in marriage; that is, corrupt, and generat successively: which is an immortality of the kind, but not of th persons of men: they are not worthy to be counted amongst them tha shall obtain the next world, and an absolute resurrection from th dead; but only a short time, as inmates of that world; and to the en only to receive condign punishment for their contumacy. The elect ar the only children of the resurrection: that is to say, the sole heir of eternal life: they only can die no more, it is they that are equa to the angels, and that are the children of God: and not the reprobate To the reprobate there remaineth after the resurrection a \"second\" an \"eternal\" death: between which resurrection, and their second an eternal death, is but a time of punishment and torment; and to last b succession of sinners thereunto, as long as the kind of man b propagation shall endure; which is eternally."} +{"text":"Upon this doctrine of the natural eternity of separated souls i founded, as I said, the doctrine of purgatory. For supposing eterna life by grace only, there is no life but the life of the body; and n immortality till the resurrection. The texts for purgatory alleged b Bellarmine out of the canonical Scripture of the Old Testament are first, the fasting of David for Saul and Jonathan, mentioned 2 Sam 1:12; and again, 2 Sam. 3:35, for the death of Abner. This fasting o David, he saith, was for the obtaining of something for them at God' hands, after their death: because after he had fasted to procure th recovery of his own child, as soon as he knew it was dead, he calle for meat. Seeing then the soul hath an existence separate from th body, and nothing can be obtained by men's fasting for the souls tha are already either in heaven or hell, it followeth that there be som souls of dead men, that are neither in heaven nor in hell; an therefore they must be in some third place, which must be purgatory And thus with hard straining, he has wrested those places to the proo of a purgatory; whereas it is manifest that the ceremonies of mournin and fasting, when they are used for the death of men, whose life wa not profitable to the mourners, they are used for honour's sake t their persons; and when it is done for the death of them by whose lif the mourners had benefit, it proceeds from their particular damage. An so David honoured Saul and Abner with his fasting; and in the death o his own child, recomforted himself by receiving his ordinary food."} +{"text":"In the other places which he allegeth out of the Old Testament, ther is not so much as any show or colour of proof. He brings in every tex wherein there is the word \"anger,\" or \"fire,\" or \"burning,\" o \"purging,\" or \"cleansing,\" in case any of the fathers have but in sermon rhetorically applied it to the doctrine of purgatory, alread believed. The first verse of Psalm 37: \"O Lord, rebuke me not in th wrath, nor chasten me in thy hot displeasure\"; what were this t purgatory, if Augustine had not applied the \"wrath\" to the fire o hell, and the \"displeasure\" to that of purgatory? And what is it t purgatory, that of Psalm 66:12, \"We went through fire and water, an thou broughtest us to a moist place\"; and other the like texts, wit which the doctors of those times intended to adorn or extend thei sermons, or commentaries, haled to their purposes by force of wit?"} +{"text":"But he allegeth other places of the New Testament, that are not so eas to be answered. And first that of Matt. 12:32: \"Whosoever speaketh word against the Son of man, it shall be forgiven him; but whosoeve speaketh against the Holy Ghost, it shall not be forgiven him, neithe in this world, nor in the world to come\": where he will have purgator to be the world to come, wherein some sins may be forgiven, which i this world were not forgiven: notwithstanding that it is manifest there are but three worlds; one from the creation to the flood, whic was destroyed by water, and is called in Scripture \"the old world\" another from the flood to the day of judgment, which is \"the presen world,\" and shall be destroyed by fire; and the third, which shall b from the day of judgment forward, everlasting, which is called \"th world to come\"; and in which it is agreed by all, there shall be n purgatory, and therefore the world to come and purgatory ar inconsistent. But what then can be the meaning of those our Saviour' words? I confess they are very hardly to be reconciled with all th doctrines now unanimously received: nor is it any shame to confess th profoundness of the Scripture to be too great to be sounded by th shortness of human understanding. Nevertheless, I may propound suc things to the consideration of more learned divines, as the text itsel suggesteth. And first, seeing to speak against the Holy Ghost, as bein the third person of the Trinity, is to speak against the Church, i which the Holy Ghost resideth; it seemeth the comparison is mad between the easiness of our Saviour, in bearing with offences done t Him while He himself taught the world, that is, when He was on earth and the severity of the pastors after Him, against those which shoul deny their authority, which was from the Holy Ghost. As if He shoul say, you that deny my power; nay, you that shall crucify me, shall b pardoned by me, as often as you turn unto me by repentance: but if yo deny the power of them that teach you hereafter, by virtue of the Hol Ghost, they shall be inexorable, and shall not forgive you, bu persecute you in this world, and leave you without absolution (thoug you turn to me, unless you turn also to them), to the punishments, a much as lies in them, of the world to come. And so the words may b taken as a prophecy, or prediction concerning the times, as they hav long been in the Christian Church. Or if this be not the meaning (for am not peremptory in such difficult places), perhaps there may b places left after the resurrection for the repentance of some sinners And there is also another place that seemeth to agree therewith. Fo considering the words of St. Paul (1 Cor. 15:29), \"What shall they d which are baptized for the dead, if the dead rise not at all? why als are they baptized for the dead?\" a man may probably infer, as some hav done, that in St. Paul's time there was a custom, by receiving baptis for the dead (as men that now believe, are sureties and undertakers fo the faith of infants, that are not capable of believing), to undertak for the persons of their deceased friends, that they should be ready t obey, and receive our Saviour for their king, at His coming again; an then the forgiveness of sins in the world to come, has no need of purgatory. But in both these interpretations there is so much o paradox, that I trust not to them; but propound them to those that ar thoroughly versed in the Scripture, to inquire if there be no cleare place that contradicts them. Only of thus much, I see evident Scriptur to persuade me that there is neither the word nor the thing o purgatory, neither in this, nor any other text; nor anything that ca prove a necessity of a place for the soul without the body; neither fo the soul of Lazarus during the four days he was dead; nor for the soul of them which the Roman Church pretend to be tormented now i purgatory. For God, that could give a life to a piece of clay, hath th same power to give life again to a dead man, and renew his inanimat and rotten carcass into a glorious, spiritual, and immortal body."} +{"text":"Another place is that of 1 Cor. 3, where it is said, that they whic build stubble, hay, etc., on the true foundation, their work shal perish; but \"they themselves shall be saved, but as through fire\": thi fire, he will have to be the fire of purgatory. The words, as I hav said before, are an allusion to those of Zech. 13:9, where he saith, \" will bring the third part through the fire, and refine them as silve is refined, and will try them as gold is tried\": which is spoken of th coming of the Messiah in power and glory; that is, at the day o judgment, and conflagration of the present world, wherein the elec shall not be consumed, but be refined; that is, depose their erroneou doctrines and traditions, and have them as it were singed off; an shall afterwards call upon the name of the true God. In like manner the apostle saith of them, that holding this foundation, \"Jesus is th Christ,\" shall build thereon some other doctrines that be erroneous that they shall not be consumed in that fire which reneweth the world but shall pass through it to salvation; but so as to see and relinquis their former errors. The builders, are the \"pastors\"; the foundation that \"Jesus is the Christ\"; the stubble and hay, \"false consequence drawn from it through ignorance, or frailty\"; the gold, silver, an precious stones, are their \"true doctrines\"; and their refining o purging, the \"relinquishing of their errors.\" In all which there is n colour at all for the burning of incorporeal, that is to say, impatibl souls."} +{"text":"A third place is that of 1 Cor. 15:29, before mentioned, concernin baptism for the dead: out of which he concludeth, first, that prayer for the dead are not unprofitable; and out of that, that there is fire of purgatory: but neither of them rightly. For of man interpretations of the word baptism, he approveth this in the firs place, that by baptism is meant, metaphorically, a baptism of penance and that men are in this sense baptized, when they fast, and pray, an give alms: and so, baptism for the dead, and prayer for the dead, i the same thing. But this is a metaphor, of which there is no example neither in the Scripture nor in any other use of language; and which i also discordant to the harmony and scope of the Scripture. The wor baptism is used (Mark 10:38 and Luke 12:50), for being dipped in one' own blood, as Christ was upon the cross, and as most of the apostle were, for giving testimony of Him. But it is hard to say that prayer fasting, and alms have any similitude with dipping. The same is use also Matt. 3:11 (which seemeth to make somewhat for purgatory) for purging with fire. But it is evident the fire and purging her mentioned is the same whereof the prophet Zechariah speaketh (13:9), \" will bring the third part through the fire, and will refine them,\" etc And St. Peter after him (1 Epistle 1:7), \"That the trial of your faith which is much more precious than of gold that perisheth, though it b tried with fire, might be found unto praise, and honour, and glory a the appearing of Jesus Christ\"; and St. Paul (1 Cor. 3:13), \"The fir shall try every man's work of what sort it is.\" But St. Peter an St. Paul speak of the fire that shall be at the second appearing o Christ; and the prophet Zechariah of the day of judgment. And therefor this place of St. Matthew may be interpreted of the same; and the there will be no necessity of the fire of purgatory."} +{"text":"Another interpretation of baptism for the dead is that which I hav before mentioned, which he preferreth to the second place o probability: and thence also he inferreth the utility of prayer for th dead. For if after the resurrection, such as have not heard of Christ or not believed in Him, may be received into Christ's kingdom, it i not in vain, after their death, that their friends should pray fo them, till they should be risen. But granting that God, at the prayer of the faithful, may convert unto Him some of those that have not hear Christ preached, and consequently cannot have rejected Christ, and tha the charity of men in that point cannot be blamed; yet this concludet nothing for purgatory; because to rise from death to life is one thing to rise from purgatory to life is another; as being a rising from lif to life, from a life in torments to a life in joy."} +{"text":"A fourth place is that of Matt. 5:25�-�26: \"Agree with thine adversar quickly, whilst thou art in the way with him, lest at any time th adversary deliver thee to the judge, and the judge deliver thee to th officer, and thou be cast into prison: verily I say unto thee, tho shalt by no means come out thence, till thou hast paid the uttermos farthing.\" In which allegory, the offender is the \"sinner\"; both th adversary and the judge is \"God\"; the way is this \"life\"; the prison i the \"grave\"; the officer, \"death\"; from which the sinner shall not ris again to life eternal, but to a second death, till he have paid th utmost farthing, or Christ pay it for him by His passion, which is full ransom for all manner of sins, as well lesser sins as greate crimes; both being made by the passion of Christ equally venial."} +{"text":"The fifth place is that of Matt. 5:22: \"Whosoever is angry with hi brother without a cause, shall be guilty in judgment: and whosoeve shall say to his brother, Raca, shall be guilty in the council: bu whosoever shall say, thou fool, shall be guilty to hell fire.\" Fro which words he inferreth three sorts of sins and three sorts o punishments; and that none of those sins but the last shall be punishe with hell fire; and consequently, that after this life there i punishment of lesser sins in purgatory. Of which inference there is n colour in any interpretation that hath yet been given of them. Shal there be a distinction after this life of courts of justice, as ther was amongst the Jews in our Saviour's time, to hear and determin divers sorts of crimes, as the judges and the council? Shall not al judicature appertain to Christ and His apostles? To understan therefore this text, we are not to consider it solitarily, but jointl with the words precedent and subsequent. Our Saviour in this chapte interpreteth the law of Moses; which the Jews thought was the fulfilled when they had not transgressed the grammatical sense thereof howsoever they had transgressed against the sentence or meaning of th legislator. Therefore whereas they thought the sixth commandment wa not broken but by killing a man: nor the seventh but when a man la with a woman not his wife; our Saviour tells them the inward anger of man against his brother, if it be without just cause, is homicide. Yo have heard, saith He, the law of Moses, \"Thou shalt not kill,\" and tha \"Whosoever shall kill, shall be condemned before the judges,\" or befor the session of the Seventy: but I say unto you to be angry with one' brother without cause, or to say unto him \"Raca\" or \"Fool,\" i homicide, and shall be punished at the day of judgment and session o Christ and His apostles with hell fire. So that those words were no used to distinguish between divers crimes, and divers courts o justice, and divers punishments; but to tax the distinction between si and sin, which the Jews drew not from the difference of the will i obeying God, but from the difference of their temporal courts o justice; and to show them that he that had the will to hurt hi brother, though the effect appear but in reviling, or not at all, shal be cast into hell fire, by the judges and by the session, which shal be the same, not different, courts at the day of judgment. Thi considered, what can be drawn from this text to maintain purgatory cannot imagine."} +{"text":"The sixth place is Luke 16:9: \"Make ye friends of the unrighteou Mammon; that when ye fail, they may receive you into everlastin tabernacles.\" This he alleges to prove invocation of saints departed But the sense is plain, that we should make friends with our riches o the poor; and thereby obtain their prayers whilst they live. \"He tha giveth to the poor, lendeth to the Lord.\""} +{"text":"The seventh is Luke 23:42: \"Lord, remember me, when thou comest int thy kingdom.\" Therefore, saith he, there is remission of sins afte this life. But the consequence is not good. Our Saviour then forgav him; and at His coming again in glory will remember to raise him agai to life eternal."} +{"text":"The eighth is Acts 2:24, where St. Peter saith of Christ, \"that God ha raised Him up, and loosed the pains of death, because it was no possible He should be holden of it\": which he interprets to be descent of Christ into purgatory, to loose some souls there from thei torments: whereas it is manifest that it was Christ that was loosed; i was He that could not be holden of death or the grave; and not th souls in purgatory. But if that which Beza says, in his notes on thi place, be well observed, there is none that will not see, that instea of \"pains\" it should be \"bands\"; and then there is no further cause t seek for purgatory in this text."} +{"text":"LV"} +{"text":"Of Demonology, and Other Relics of the Religion of the Gentiles"} +{"text":"The impression made on the organs of sight by lucid bodies, either i one direct line or in many lines, reflected from opaque, or refracte in the passage through diaphanous bodies, produceth in livin creatures, in whom God hath placed such organs, an imagination of th object, from whence the impression proceedeth; which imagination i called \"sight\"; and seemeth not to be a mere imagination, but the bod itself without us; in the same manner, as when a man violently presset his eye, there appears to him a light without and before him, which n man perceiveth but himself; because there is indeed no such thin without him, but only a motion in the interior organs, pressing b resistance outward, that makes him think so. And the motion made b this pressure, continuing after the object which caused it is removed is that we call \"imagination\" and \"memory\"; and, in sleep, an sometimes in great distemper of the organs by sickness or violence, \"dream\"; of which things I have already spoken briefly in the secon and third chapters."} +{"text":"This nature of sight having never been discovered by the ancien pretenders to natural knowledge; much less by those that consider no things so remote, as that knowledge is, from their present use; it wa hard for men to conceive of those images in the fancy and in the sense otherwise than of things really without us: which some, because the vanish away, they know not whither nor how, will have to be absolutel incorporeal, that is to say, immaterial, or forms without matter colour and figure, without any coloured or figured body; and that the can put on airy bodies as a garment, to make them visible when the will to our bodily eyes; and others say, are bodies and livin creatures, but made of air, or other more subtle and ethereal matter which is, then, when they will be seen, condensed. But both of the agree on one general appellation of them, \"demons.\" As if the dead o whom they dreamed were not inhabitants of their own brain, but of th air, or of heaven, or hell; not phantasms, but ghosts; with just a much reason as if one should say, he saw his own ghost in looking-glass, or the ghosts of the stars in a river; or call th ordinary apparition of the sun, of the quantity of about a foot, th \"demon,\" or ghost of that great sun that enlighteneth the whole visibl world: and by that means have feared them, as things of an unknown that is, of an unlimited power to do them good or harm; an consequently, given occasion to the governors of the heathe commonwealths to regulate this their fear, by establishing tha \"demonology\" (in which the poets, as principal priests of the heathe religion, were especially employed or reverenced), to the public peace and to the obedience of subjects necessary thereunto, and to make som of them good \"demons,\" and others evil; the one as a spur to th observance, the other as reins to withhold them from violation of th laws."} +{"text":"What kind of things they were, to whom they attributed the name o \"demons,\" appeareth partly in the genealogy of their gods, written b Hesiod, one of the most ancient poets of the Grecians; and partly i other histories; of which I have observed some few before, in th twelfth chapter of this discourse."} +{"text":"The Grecians, by their colonies and conquests, communicated thei language and writings into Asia, Egypt, and Italy; and therein, b necessary consequence their \"demonology,\" or, as St. Paul calls i (1 Tim. 4:1), \"their doctrines of devils.\" And by that means th contagion was derived also to the Jews, both of Judea and Alexandria and other parts, whereinto they were dispersed. But the name of \"demon\ they did not, as the Grecians, attribute to spirits both good and evil but to the evil only: and to the good \"demons\" they gave the name o the spirit of God; and esteemed those into whose bodies they entered t be prophets. In sum, all singularity, if good, they attributed to th spirit of God; and if evil, to some \"demon,\" but a kakoda'i�wn, an evi \"demon,\" that is a \"devil.\" And therefore, they called \"demoniacs,\ that is \"possessed by the devil,\" such as we call madmen or lunatics or such as had the falling sickness, or that spoke anything which they for want of understanding, thought absurd. As also of an unclean perso in a notorious degree, they used to say he had an unclean spirit; of dumb man, that he had a dumb devil; and of John the Baptist (Matt 11:18), for the singularity of his fasting, that he had a devil; and o our Saviour, because He said, he that keepeth His sayings should no see death in aeternum (John 8:52), \"Now we know thou hast a devil Abraham is dead, and the prophets are dead\": and again, because He sai (John 7:20), \"They went about to kill Him,\" the people answered, \"Tho hast a devil; who goeth about to kill thee?\" Whereby it is manifes that the Jews had the same opinions concerning phantasms, namely, tha they were not phantasms, that is, idols of the brain, but things rea and independent on the fancy."} +{"text":"Which doctrine, if it be not true, why, may some say, did not ou Saviour contradict it, and teach the contrary? Nay, why does He use o divers occasions such forms of speech as seem to confirm it? To this answer, that first, where Christ saith (Luke 24:39), \"A spirit hath no flesh and bone,\" though He show that there be spirits, yet He denie not that they are bodies. And where St. Paul says (1 Cor. 15:44), \"w shall rise spiritual bodies,\" he acknowledgeth the nature of spirits but that they are bodily spirits; which is not difficult to understand For air and many other things are bodies, though not flesh and bone, o any other gross body to be discerned by the eye. But when our Saviou speaketh to the devil, and commandeth him to go out of a man, if by th devil He meant a disease, as frenzy, or lunacy, or a corporeal spirit is not the speech improper? Can diseases hear? Or can there be corporeal spirit in a body of flesh and bone, full already of vital an animal spirits? Are there not therefore spirits that neither hav bodies, nor are mere imaginations? To the first I answer, that th addressing of our Saviour's command to the madness or lunacy He cureth is no more improper than was His rebuking of the fever, or of the win and sea; for neither do these hear; or than was the command of God, t the light, to the firmament, to the sun, and stars, when He commande them to be; for they could not hear before they had a being. But thos speeches are not improper, because they signify the power of God' word; no more therefore is it improper to command madness, or lunacy under the appellation of devils by which they were then commonl understood, to depart out of a man's body. To the second, concernin their being incorporeal, I have not yet observed any place o Scripture, from whence it can be gathered that any man was eve possessed with any other corporeal spirit, but that of his own, b which his body is naturally moved."} +{"text":"Our Saviour, immediately after the Holy Ghost descended upon Him in th form of a dove, is said by St. Matthew (4:1) to have been \"led up b the Spirit into the wilderness\"; and the same is recited (Luke 4:1) i these words, \"Jesus being full of the Holy Ghost, was led in the Spiri into the wilderness\"; whereby it is evident that by \"Spirit\" there i meant the Holy Ghost. This cannot be interpreted for a possession; fo Christ and the Holy Ghost are but one and the same substance; which i no possession of one substance or body by another. And whereas in th verses following He is said \"to have been taken up by the devil int the holy city, and set upon a pinnacle of the temple,\" shall w conclude thence that He was possessed of the devil, or carried thithe by violence? And again, \"carried thence by the devil into an exceedin high mountain, who showed Him thence all the kingdoms of the world\" wherein we are not to believe He was either possessed, or forced by th devil; nor that any mountain is high enough, according to the litera sense, to show Him one whole hemisphere. What then can be the meanin of this place, other than that He went of himself into the wilderness and that this carrying of Him up and down from the wilderness to th city, and from thence into a mountain, was a vision? Conformabl whereunto is also the phrase of St. Luke, that He was led into th wilderness, not \"by,\" but \"in,\" the Spirit; whereas, concerning Hi being taken up into the mountain, and unto the pinnacle of the temple he speaketh as St. Matthew doth: which suiteth with the nature of vision."} +{"text":"Again, where St. Luke (22:3�-�4) says of Judas Iscariot, that \"Sata entered into him, and thereupon that he went and communed with th chief priests and captains, how he might betray Christ unto them\"; i may be answered, that by the entering of Satan, that is the \"enemy,\ into him, is meant, the hostile and traitorous intention of selling hi Lord and Master. For as by the Holy Ghost is frequently in Scriptur understood, the graces and good inclinations given by the Holy Ghost so by the entering of Satan may be understood the wicked cogitation and designs of the adversaries of Christ and His disciples. For as i is hard to say that the devil was entered into Judas, before he had an such hostile design; so it is impertinent to say he was first Christ' enemy in his heart, and that the devil entered into him afterwards Therefore the entering of Satan, and his wicked purpose, was one an the same thing."} +{"text":"But if there be no immaterial spirit or any possession of men's bodie by any spirit corporeal, it may again be asked, why our Saviour and Hi apostles did not teach the people so; and in such clear words, as the might no more doubt thereof. But such questions as these are mor curious than necessary for a Christian man's salvation. Men may as wel ask why Christ, that could have given to all men faith, piety, and al manner of moral virtues, gave it to some only, and not to all; and wh He left the search of natural causes and sciences to the natural reaso and industry of men, and did not reveal it to all, or any ma supernaturally; and many other such questions. Of which nevertheles there may be alleged probable and pious reasons. For as God, when H brought the Israelites into the Land of Promise, did not secure the therein, by subduing all the nations round about them; but left many o them, as thorns in their sides, to awaken from time to time their piet and industry: so our Saviour, in conducting us toward His heavenl kingdom, did not destroy all the difficulties of natural questions; bu left them to exercise our industry and reason; the scope of Hi preaching being only to show us this plain and direct way to salvation namely, the belief of this article, \"that He was the Christ, the Son o the living God, sent into the world to sacrifice himself for our sins and at His coming again, gloriously to reign over His elect, and t save them from their enemies eternally.\" To which the opinion o possession by spirits, or phantasms, is no impediment in the way though it be to some an occasion of going out of the way, and to follo their own inventions. If we require of the Scripture an account of al questions which may be raised to trouble us in the performance of God' commands, we may as well complain of Moses for not having set down th time of the creation of such spirits, as well as of the creation of th earth and sea, and of men and beasts. To conclude, I find in Scriptur that there be angels and spirits, good and evil; but not that they ar incorporeal, as are the apparitions men see in the dark, or in a drea or vision: which the Latins call \"spectra,\" and took for \"demons.\" An I find that there are spirits corporeal, though subtle and invisible but not that any man's body was possessed or inhabited by them; an that the bodies of the saints shall be such, namely, spiritual bodies as St. Paul calls them."} +{"text":"Nevertheless, the contrary doctrine, namely, that there be incorporea spirits, hath hitherto so prevailed in the Church, that the use o exorcism, that is to say, of ejection of devils by conjuration, i thereupon built; and, though rarely and faintly practiced, is not ye totally given over. That there were many demoniacs in the primitiv Church, and few madmen, and other such singular diseases; whereas i these times we hear of, and see many madmen, and few demoniacs proceeds not from the change of nature, but of names. But how it come to pass that whereas heretofore the apostles, and after them for a tim the pastors of the Church, did cure those singular diseases, which no they are not seen to do; as likewise, why it is not in the power o every true believer now to do all that the faithful did then, that i to say, as we read (Mark 16:17�-�18), \"in Christ's name to cast ou devils, to speak with new tongues, to take up serpents, to drink deadl poison without harm-taking, and to cure the sick by the laying on o their hands,\" and all this without other words, but \"in the name o Jesus,\" is another question. And it is probable that thos extraordinary gifts were given to the Church, for no longer a time tha men trusted wholly to Christ, and looked for their felicity only in Hi kingdom to come; and consequently that, when they sought authority an riches, and trusted to their own subtlety for a kingdom of this world these supernatural gifts of God were again taken from them."} +{"text":"Another relic of Gentilism is, the \"worship of images,\" neithe instituted by Moses in the Old, nor by Christ in the New Testament; no yet brought in from the Gentiles; but left amongst them after they ha given their names to Christ. Before our Saviour preached, it was th general religion of the Gentiles to worship for gods those apparence that remain in the brain from the impression of external bodies upo the organs of their senses, which are commonly called \"ideas,\" \"idols,\ \"phantasms,\" \"conceits,\" as being representations of those externa bodies which cause them, and have nothing in them of reality, no mor than there is in the things that seem to stand before us in a dream And this is the reason why St. Paul says (1 Cor. 8:4) \"we know that a idol is nothing\"; not that he thought that an image of metal, stone, o wood, was nothing; but that the thing which they honoured or feared i the image, and held for a god, was a mere figment, without place habitation, motion, or existence, but in the motions of the brain. An the worship of these with divine honour, is that which is in th Scripture called idolatry, and rebellion against God. For God bein King of the Jews, and His lieutenant being first Moses, and afterwar the high priest; if the people had been permitted to worship and pra to images, which are representations of their own fancies, they had ha no further dependence on the true God, of whom there can be n similitude; nor on His prime ministers, Moses and the high priests; bu every man had governed himself according to his own appetite, to th utter eversion of the commonwealth, and their own destruction for wan of union. And therefore the first law of God was, \"They should not tak for gods Alienos Deos,\" that is, \"the gods of other nations, but tha only true God, who vouchsafed to commune with Moses, and by him to giv them laws and directions, for their peace, and for their salvation fro their enemies.\" And the second was, that \"they should not make t themselves any image to worship, of their own invention.\" For it is th same deposing of a king, to submit to another king, whether he be se up by a neighbour nation or by ourselves."} +{"text":"The places of Scripture pretended to countenance the setting up o images, to worship them; or to set them up at all in the places wher God is worshipped, are first, two examples; one of the cherubims ove the ark of God; the other of the brazen serpent. Secondly, some text whereby we are commanded to worship certain creatures for thei relation to God; as to worship His footstool. And lastly, some othe texts, by which is authorized a religious honouring of holy things. Bu before I examine the force of those places, to prove that which i pretended, I must first explain what is to be understood b \"worshipping,\" and what by \"images\" and \"idols.\""} +{"text":"I have already shown in the twentieth chapter of this discourse, tha to honour, is to value highly the power of any person: and that suc value is measured by our comparing him with others. But because ther is nothing to be compared with God in power; we honour Him not, bu dishonour Him by any value less than infinite. And thus honour i properly of its own nature, secret and internal in the heart. But th inward thoughts of men, which appear outwardly in their words an actions, are the signs of our honouring, and these go by the name o \"worship\"; in Latin, \"cultus.\" Therefore, to pray to, to swear by, t obey, to be diligent and officious in serving: in sum, all words an actions that betoken fear to offend, or desire to please, is \"worship,\ whether those words and actions be sincere or feigned; and because the appear as signs of honouring, are ordinarily also called \"honour.\""} +{"text":"The worship we exhibit to those we esteem to be but men, as to king and men in authority, is \"civil worship\"; but the worship we exhibit t that which we think to be God, whatsoever the words, ceremonies gestures, or other actions be, is \"divine worship.\" To fall prostrat before a king, in him that thinks him but a man, is but civil worship and he that putteth off his hat in the church for this cause, that h thinketh it the house of God, worshippeth with divine worship. The that seek the distinction of divine and civil worship, not in th intention of the worshipper, but in the words doulei'a and latrei'a deceive themselves. For whereas there be two sorts of servants: tha sort, which is of those that are absolutely in the power of thei masters, as slaves taken in war, and their issue, whose bodies are no in their own power (their lives depending on the will of their masters in such manner as to forfeit them upon the least disobedience), an that are bought and sold as beasts, were called douloi, that is properly slaves, and their service doulei'a: the other, which is o those that serve (for hire, or in hope of benefit from their masters voluntarily, are called thte*s; that is, domestic servants, to whos service the masters have no further right than is contained in th covenants made betwixt them. These two kinds of servants have thus muc common to them both, that their labour is appointed them by another and the word la'tri*s, is the general name of both, signifying him tha worketh for another, whether as a slave or a voluntary servant. So tha latrei'a signifieth generally all service: but doulei'a the service o bondmen only, and the condition of slavery: and both are used i Scripture (to signify our service of God) promiscuously; doulei'a because we are God's slaves; latrei'a, because we serve Him. And in al kinds of service is contained, not only obedience, but also worship that is, such actions, gestures, and words, as signify \"honour.\""} +{"text":"An \"image,\" in the most strict signification of the word, is th resemblance of something visible; in which sense the fantastical forms apparitions, or seemings of visible bodies to the sight, are onl \"images,\" such as are the show of a man, or other thing in the water by reflection or refraction; or of the sun or stars by direct vision i the air; which are nothing real in the things seen, nor in the plac where they seem to be; nor are their magnitudes and figures the sam with that of the object; but changeable, by the variation of the organ of sight, or by glasses, and are present oftentimes in our imaginatio and in our dreams, when the object is absent; or changed into othe colours and shapes, as things that depend only upon the fancy. An these are the \"images\" which are originally and most properly calle \"ideas\" and \"idols,\" and derived from the language of the Grecians with whom the word e�dw signifieth \"to see.\" They also are calle \"phantasms,\" which is in the same language \"apparitions.\" And fro these images it is that one of the faculties of man's nature is calle the \"imagination.\" And from hence it is manifest that there neither is nor can be, any image made of a thing invisible."} +{"text":"It is also evident that there can be no images of a thing infinite: fo all the images and phantasms that are made by the impression of thing visible, are figured; but figure is a quantity every way determined And therefore there can be no image of God; nor of the soul of man; no of spirits; but only of bodies visible; that is, bodies that have ligh in themselves, or are by such enlightened."} +{"text":"And whereas a man can fancy shapes he never saw; making up a figure ou of the parts of divers creatures; as the poets make their centaurs chimeras, and other monsters never seen: so can he also give matter t those shapes, and make them in wood, clay, or metal. And these are als called images, not for the resemblance of any corporeal thing, but fo the resemblance of some fantastical inhabitants of the brain of th maker. But in these idols as they are originally in the brain, and a they are painted, carved, moulded, or moulten in matter, there is similitude of the one to the other, for which the material body made b art may be said to be the image of the fantastical idol made by Nature."} +{"text":"But in a larger use of the word image, is contained also an representation of one thing by another. So an earthly sovereign may b called the image of God: and an inferior magistrate, the image of a earthly sovereign. And many times in the idolatry of the Gentiles ther was little regard to the similitude of their material idol to the ido in their fancy, and yet it was called the image of it. For a ston unhewn has been set up for Neptune, and divers other shapes fa different from the shapes they conceived of their gods. And at this da we see many images of the Virgin Mary, and other Saints, unlike on another, and without correspondence to any one man's fancy; and ye serve well enough for the purpose they were erected for; which was n more but by the names only, to represent the persons mentioned in th history; to which every man applieth a mental image of his own making or none at all. And thus an image in the largest sense, is either th resemblance or the representation of some thing visible; or bot together, as it happeneth for the most part."} +{"text":"But the name of idol is extended yet further in Scripture, to signif also the sun, or a star, or any other creature, visible or invisible when they are worshipped for gods."} +{"text":"Having shown what is \"worship,\" and what an \"image\"; I will now pu them together, and examine what that \"idolatry\" is, which is forbidde in the second commandment, and other places of the Scripture."} +{"text":"To worship an image, is voluntarily to do those external acts which ar signs of honouring either the matter of the image, which is wood stone, metal, or some other visible creature; or the phantasm of th brain, for the resemblance, or representation whereof, the matter wa formed and figured; or both together, as one animate body, composed o the matter and the phantasm, as of a body and soul."} +{"text":"To be uncovered, before a man of power and authority, or before th throne of a prince, or in such other places as he ordaineth to tha purpose in his absence, is to worship that man or prince with civi worship; as being a sign, not of honouring the stool or place, but th person; and is not idolatry. But if he that doth it, should suppose th soul of the prince to be in the stool, or should present a petition t the stool, it were divine worship, and idolatry."} +{"text":"To pray to a king for such things as he is able to do for us, though w prostrate ourselves before him, is but civil worship; because w acknowledge no other power in him but human: but voluntarily to pra unto him for fair weather, or for anything which God only can do fo us, is divine worship and idolatry. On the other side, if a king compe a man to it by the terror of death, or other great corporal punishment it is not idolatry: for the worship which the sovereign commandeth t be done unto himself by the terror of his laws, is not a sign that h that obeyeth him does inwardly honour him as a god, but that he i desirous to save himself from death or from a miserable life; and tha which is not a sign of internal honour, is no worship; and therefore n idolatry. Neither can it be said, that he that does it, scandalizeth o layeth any stumbling-block before his brother; because how wise o learned soever he be that worshippeth in that manner, another ma cannot from thence argue that he approveth it; but that he doth it fo fear; and that it is not his act, but the act of his sovereign."} +{"text":"To worship God, in some peculiar place, or turning a man's face toward an image, or determinate place, is not to worship or honour the plac or image; but to acknowledge it holy, that is to say, to acknowledg the image, or the place to be set apart from common use. For that i the meaning of the word \"holy\"; which implies no new quality in th place or image, but only a new relation by appropriation to God; an therefore is not idolatry; no more than it was idolatry to worship Go before the brazen serpent; or for the Jews, when they were out of thei own country, to turn their faces, when they prayed, towards the templ of Jerusalem; or for Moses to put off his shoes when he was before th flaming bush, the ground appertaining to Mount Sinai, which place Go had chosen to appear in, and to give His laws to the people of Israel and was therefore holy ground, not by inherent sanctity, but b separation to God's use; or for Christians to worship in the churches which are once solemnly dedicated to God for that purpose, by th authority of the king, or other true representant of the Church. But t worship God, as inanimating or inhabiting such image or place; that i to say, in infinite substance in a finite place, is idolatry: for suc finite gods are but idols of the brain, nothing real; and are commonl called in the Scripture by the names of \"vanity,\" and \"lies,\" an \"nothing.\" Also to worship God, not as inanimating or present in th place or image: but to the end to be put in mind of Him, or of som works of His, in case the place or image be dedicated or set up b private authority, and not by the authority of them that are ou sovereign pastors, is idolatry. For the commandment is, \"thou shalt no make to thyself any graven image.\" God commanded Moses to set up th brazen serpent; he did not make it to himself; it was not therefor against the commandment. But the making of the golden calf by Aaron an the people, as being done without authority from God, was idolatry; no only because they held it for God, but also because they made it for religious use, without warrant either from God their sovereign, or fro Moses, that was His lieutenant."} +{"text":"The Gentiles worshipped for gods, Jupiter and others; that living, wer men perhaps that had done great and glorious acts: and for the childre of God, divers men and women, supposing them gotten between an immorta deity and a mortal man. This was idolatry, because they made them so t themselves, having no authority from God, neither in His eternal law o reason, nor in His positive and revealed will. But though our Saviou was a man, whom we also believe to be God immortal and the Son of God yet this is no idolatry: because we build not that belief upon our ow fancy, or judgment, but upon the word of God revealed in th Scriptures. And for the adoration of the Eucharist, if the words o Christ, \"this is my body,\" signify \"that he himself, and the seemin bread in his hand, and not only so, but that all the seeming morsels o bread that have ever since been, and any time hereafter shall b consecrated by priests, be so many Christ's bodies, and yet all of the but one body\"; then is that no idolatry, because it is authorized b our Saviour: but if that text does not signify that (for there is n other that can be alleged for it), then, because it is a worship o human institution, it is idolatry. For it is not enough to say, God ca transubstantiate the bread into Christ's body: for the Gentiles als held God to be omnipotent, and might upon that ground no less excus their idolatry, by pretending as well as others a transubstantiation o their wood and stone into God Almighty."} +{"text":"Whereas there be, that pretend divine inspiration to be th supernatural entering of the Holy Ghost into a man, and not a acquisition of God's graces, by doctrine and study; I think they are i a very dangerous dilemma. For if they worship not the man whom the believe to be so inspired, they fall into impiety; as not adoring God' supernatural presence. And again, if they worship him, they commi idolatry; for the apostles would never permit themselves to be s worshipped. Therefore the safest way is to believe, that by th descending of the dove upon the apostles; and by Christ's breathing o them, when He gave them the Holy Ghost; and by the giving of it b imposition of hands, are understood the signs which God has bee pleased to use, or ordain to be used, of His promise to assist thos persons in their study to preach His kingdom, and in thei conversation, that it might not be scandalous, but edifying to others."} +{"text":"Besides the idolatrous worship of images, there is also a scandalou worship of them; which is also a sin, but not idolatry. For \"idolatry\ is to worship by signs of an internal and real honour; but \"scandalou worship,\" is but seeming worship, and may sometimes be joined with a inward and hearty detestation, both of the image and of the fantastica \"demon\" or idol, to which it is dedicated; and proceed only from th fear of death, or other grievous punishment; and is nevertheless a si in them that so worship, in case they be men whose actions are looke at by others as lights to guide them by; because following their ways they cannot but stumble, and fall in the way of religion; whereas th example of those we regard not, works not on us at all, but leaves u to our own diligence and caution; and consequently are no causes of ou falling."} +{"text":"If therefore a pastor lawfully called to teach and direct others, o any other of whose knowledge there is a great opinion, do externa honour to an idol for fear, unless he make his fear and unwillingnes to it as evident as the worship, he scandalizeth his brother, b seeming to approve idolatry. For his brother arguing from the action o his teacher, or of him whose knowledge he esteemeth great, concludes i to be lawful in itself. And this scandal is sin, and a \"scandal given.\ But if one being no pastor, nor of eminent reputation for knowledge i Christian doctrine, do the same, and another follow him, this is n scandal given; for he had no cause to follow such example, but is pretence of scandal, which he taketh of himself for an excuse befor men. For an unlearned man that is in the power of an idolatrous king o state, if commanded on pain of death to worship before an idol, h detesteth the idol in his heart, he doth well; though if he had th fortitude to suffer death rather than worship it, he should do better But if a pastor, who as Christ's messenger has undertaken to teac Christ's doctrine to all nations, should do the same, it were not onl a sinful scandal in respect of other Christian men's consciences, but perfidious forsaking of his charge."} +{"text":"The sum of that which I have said hitherto concerning the worship o images is this, that he that worshippeth in an image, or any creature either the matter thereof, or any fancy of his own, which he thinket to dwell in it; or both together; or believeth that such things hea his prayers, or see his devotions, without ears or eyes, committet idolatry: and he that counterfeiteth such worship for fear o punishment, if he be a man whose example hath power amongst hi brethren, committeth a sin. But he that worshippeth the Creator of th world before such an image, or in such a place as he hath not made, o chosen of himself, but taken from the commandment of God's word, as th Jews did in worshipping God before the cherubims, and before the braze serpent for a time, and in, or towards the Temple of Jerusalem, whic was also but for a time, committeth not idolatry."} +{"text":"Now for the worship of saints and images, and relics, and other thing at this day practiced in the Church of Rome, I say they are not allowe by the Word of God, nor brought into the Church of Rome from th doctrine there taught; but partly left in it at the first conversion o the Gentiles; and afterwards countenanced and confirmed, and augmente by the bishops of Rome."} +{"text":"As for the proofs alleged out of Scripture, namely, those examples o images appointed by God to be set up; they were not set up for th people or any man to worship, but that they should worship God himsel before them; as before the cherubims over the ark, and the braze serpent. For we read not that the priest or any other did worship th cherubims; but contrarily we read (2 Kings 18:4) that Hezekiah brake i pieces the brazen serpent which Moses had set up, because the peopl burnt incense to it. Besides, those examples are not put for ou imitation, that we also should set up images, under pretence o worshipping God before them; because the words of the secon commandment, \"Thou shalt not make to thyself any graven image,\" etc. distinguish between the images that God commanded to be set up, an those which we set up to ourselves. And therefore from the cherubims o brazen serpent, to the images of man's devising; and from the worshi commanded by God, to the will-worship of men, the argument is not good This also is to be considered, that as Hezekiah brake in pieces th brazen serpent, because the Jews did worship it, to the end they shoul do so no more; so also Christian sovereigns ought to break down th images which their subjects have been accustomed to worship, that ther be no more occasion of such idolatry. For at this day, the ignoran people, where images are worshipped, do really believe there is divine power in the images; and are told by their pastors that some o them have spoken; and have bled; and that miracles have been done b them; which they apprehend as done by the saint, which they thin either is the image itself or in it. The Israelites, when the worshipped the calf, did think they worshipped the God that brough them out of Egypt; and yet it was idolatry, because they thought th calf either was that God, or had him in his belly. And though some ma may think it impossible for people to be so stupid as to think th image to be God, or a saint; or to worship it in that notion; yet it i manifest in Scripture to the contrary; where when the golden calf wa made, the people said (Exod. 32:4), \"These are thy gods, O Israel\"; an where the images of Laban (Gen. 31:30) are called his gods. And we se daily by experience in all sorts of people, that such men as stud nothing but their food and ease, are content to believe any absurdity rather than to trouble themselves to examine it; holding their faith a it were by entail unalienable, except by an express and new law."} +{"text":"But they infer from some other places, that it is lawful to pain angels, and also God himself: as from God's walking in the garden; fro Jacob's seeing God at the top of the ladder; and from other visions and dreams. But visions and dreams, whether natural or supernatural are but phantasms: and he that painteth an image of any of them, maket not an image of God, but of his own phantasm, which is making of a idol. I say not, that to draw a picture after a fancy is a sin; bu when it is drawn, to hold it for a representation of God, is agains the second commandment; and can be of no use but to worship. And th same may be said of the images of angels, and of men dead; unless a monuments of friends, or of men worthy remembrance. For such use of a image is not worship of the image; but a civil honouring of the person not that is, but that was. But when it is done to the image which w make of a saint, for no other reason but that we think he heareth ou prayers, and is pleased with the honour we do him, when dead, an without sense, we attribute to him more than human power; and therefor it is idolatry."} +{"text":"Seeing therefore there is no authority, neither in the law of Moses no in the Gospel, for the religious worship of images, or othe representations of God, which men set up to themselves; or for th worship of the image of any creature in heaven or earth, or under th earth: and whereas Christian kings, who are living representants o God, are not to be worshipped by their subjects, by any act tha signifieth a greater esteem of his power than the nature of mortal ma is capable of; it cannot be imagined that the religious worship now i use was brought into the Church by misunderstanding of the Scripture It resteth therefore, that it was left in it, by not destroying th images themselves, in the conversion of the Gentiles that worshippe them."} +{"text":"The cause whereof, was the immoderate esteem and prices set upon th workmanship of them, which made the owners, though converted fro worshipping them as they had done religiously for demons, to retai them still in their houses, upon pretence of doing it in the honour o Christ, of the Virgin Mary, and of the apostles, and other the pastor of the primitive Church; as being easy, by giving them new names, t make that an image of the Virgin Mary, and of her Son our Saviour which before perhaps was called the image of Venus and Cupid; and so o a Jupiter to make a Barnabas, and of Mercury a Paul, and the like. An as worldly ambition creeping by degrees into the pastors, drew them t an endeavour of pleasing the new-made Christians; and also to a likin of this kind of honour, which they also might hope for after thei decease, as well as those that had already gained it: so th worshipping of the images of Christ and His apostles grew more and mor idolatrous; save that somewhat after the time of Constantine, diver emperors and bishops, and general councils, observed and opposed th unlawfulness thereof; but too late or too weakly."} +{"text":"The canonizing of saints is another relic of Gentilism: it is neither misunderstanding of Scripture, nor a new invention of the Roman Church but a custom as ancient as the commonwealth of Rome itself. The firs that ever was canonized at Rome was Romulus, and that upon th narration of Julius Proculus, that swore before the senate he spak with him after his death, and was assured by him he dwelt in heaven and was there called Quirinus, and would be propitious to the state o their new city: and thereupon the senate gave \"public testimony\" of hi sanctity. Julius Caesar, and other emperors after him, had the lik \"testimony\"; that is, were canonized for saints; for by such testimon is \"canonization\" now defined; and is the same with the apothe'wsi*s o the heathen."} +{"text":"It is also from the Roman heathen that the Popes have received the nam and power of Pontifex Maximus. This was the name of him that in th ancient commonwealth of Rome had the supreme authority under the senat and people, of regulating all ceremonies and doctrines concerning thei religion; and when Augustus Caesar changed the state into a monarchy he took to himself no more but this office, that of tribune of th people, that is to say, the supreme power both in state and religion and the succeeding emperors enjoyed the same. But when the empero Constantine lived, who was the first that professed and authorize Christian religion, it was consonant to his profession, to caus religion to be regulated, under his authority, by the Bishop of Rome though it do not appear they had so soon the name of Pontifex; bu rather, that the succeeding bishops took it of themselves, t countenance the power they exercised over the bishops of the Roma provinces. For it is not any privilege of St. Peter, but the privileg of the city of Rome, which the emperors were always willing to uphold that gave them such authority over other bishops; as may be evidentl seen by that, that the Bishop of Constantinople, when the emperor mad that city the seat of the empire, pretended to be equal to the Bisho of Rome; though at last, not without contention, the Pope carried it and became the Pontifex Maximus; but in right only of the emperor; an not without the bounds of the empire; nor anywhere, after the empero had lost his power in Rome; though it were the Pope himself that too his power from him. From whence we may by the way observe, that ther is no place for the superiority of the Pope over other bishops, excep in the territories whereof he is himself the civil sovereign, and wher the emperor having sovereign power civil, hath expressly chosen th Pope for the chief pastor under himself, of his Christian subjects."} +{"text":"The carrying about of images in \"procession,\" is another relic of th religion of the Greeks and Romans. For they also carried their idol from place to place, in a kind of chariot, which was peculiarl dedicated to that use, which the Latins called thensa, and vehiculu Deorum; and the image was placed in a frame or shrine, which the called ferculum: and that which they called pompa, is the same that no is named \"procession.\" According whereunto, amongst the divine honour which were given to Julius Caesar by the senate, this was one, that i the pomp, or procession, at the Circaean games, he should have thensa et ferculum, a sacred chariot and a shrine; which was as much as to b carried up and down as a god: just as at this day the Popes are carrie by Switzers under a canopy."} +{"text":"To these processions also belonged the bearing of burning torches an candles, before the images of the gods, both amongst the Greeks an Romans. For afterwards the emperors of Rome received the same honour as we read of Caligula, that at his reception to the empire, he wa carried from Misenum to Rome, in the midst of a throng of people, th ways beset with altars, and beasts for sacrifice, and burnin \"torches\": and of Caracalla, that was received into Alexandria wit incense, and with casting of flowers, and dado�xi'ai*s, that is, wit torches; for dado�xoi were they that amongst the Greeks carried torche lighted in the processions of their gods. And in process of time, th devout but ignorant people did many times honour their bishops with th like pomp of wax candles, and the images of our Saviour and the saints constantly, in the church itself. And thus came in the use of wa candles; and was also established by some of the ancient councils."} +{"text":"The heathens had also their aqua lustralis, that is to say, \"hol water.\" The Church of Rome imitates them also in their \"holy days.\ They had their bacchanalia; and we have our \"wakes,\" answering to them they their \"saturnalia,\" and we our \"carnivals,\" and Shrove Tuesday' liberty of servants: they their procession of Priapus; we our fetchin in, erection, and dancing about Maypoles; and dancing is one kind o worship: they had their procession called Ambarvalia; and we ou procession about the fields in the Rogation Week. Nor do I think tha these are all the ceremonies that have been left in the Church, fro the first conversion of the Gentiles; but they are all that I can fo the present call to mind; and if a man would well observe that which i delivered in the histories, concerning the religious rites of th Greeks and Romans, I doubt not but he might find many more of these ol empty bottles of Gentilism, which the doctors of the Roman Church either by negligence or ambition, have filled up again with the ne wine of Christianity, that will not fail in time to break them."} +{"text":"LVI"} +{"text":"Of Darkness from Vain Philosophy and Fabulous Traditions"} +{"text":"By \"Philosophy\" is understood \"the knowledge acquired by reasoning from the manner of the generation of anything, to the properties: o from the properties, to some possible way of generation of the same; t the end to be able to produce, as far as matter and human force permit such effects as human life requireth.\" So the geometrician, from th construction of figures, findeth out many properties thereof; and fro the properties, new ways of their construction, by reasoning; to th end to be able to measure land and water; and for infinite other uses So the astronomer, from the rising, setting, and moving of the sun an stars, in divers parts of the heavens, findeth out the causes of da and night, and of the different seasons of the year; whereby he keepet an account of time; and the like of other sciences."} +{"text":"By which definition it is evident that we are not to account as an part thereof that original knowledge called experience, in whic consisteth prudence; because it is not attained by reasoning, but foun as well in brute beasts as in man; and is but a memory of succession of events in times past, wherein the omission of every littl circumstance altering the effect, frustrateth the expectation of th most prudent: whereas nothing is produced by reasoning aright, bu general, eternal, and immutable truth."} +{"text":"Nor are we therefore to give that name to any false conclusions: for h that reasoneth aright in words he understandeth, can never conclude a error:"} +{"text":"Nor to that which any man knows by supernatural revelation; because i is not acquired by reasoning:"} +{"text":"Nor that which is gotten by reasoning from the authority of books because it is not by reasoning from the cause to the effect, nor fro the effect to the cause; and is not knowledge but faith."} +{"text":"The faculty of reasoning being consequent to the use of speech, it wa not possible but that there should have been some general truths foun out by reasoning, as ancient almost as language itself. The savages o America are not without some good moral sentences; also they have little arithmetic, to add, and divide in numbers not too great: bu they are not, therefore, philosophers. For as there were plants of cor and wine in small quantity dispersed in the fields and woods, befor men knew their virtue, or made use of them for their nourishment, o planted them apart in fields and vineyards; in which time they fed o acorns and drank water; so also there have been divers true, general and profitable speculations from the beginning; as being the natura plants of human reason. But they were at first but few in number; me lived upon gross experience, there was no method; that is to say, n sowing, nor planting of knowledge by itself, apart from the weeds, an common plants of error and conjecture. And the cause of it being th want of leisure from procuring the necessities of life, and defendin themselves against their neighbours, it was impossible, till th erecting of great commonwealths, it should be otherwise. \"Leisure\" i the mother of \"philosophy,\" and \"Commonwealth\" the mother of \"peace\ and \"leisure.\" Where first were great and flourishing cities, there wa first the study of \"philosophy.\" The Gymnosophists of India, the Mag of Persia, and the Priests of Chaldea and Egypt, are counted the mos ancient philosophers; and those countries were the most ancient o kingdoms. \"Philosophy\" was not risen to the Grecians, and other peopl of the west, whose \"commonwealths,\" no greater perhaps than Lucca o Geneva, had never \"peace,\" but when their fears of one another wer equal; nor the \"leisure\" to observe anything but one another. A length, when war had united many of these Grecian lesser cities int fewer and greater, then began \"seven men,\" of several parts of Greece to get the reputation of being \"wise\"; some of them for \"moral\" an \"politic\" sentences, and others for the learning of the Chaldeans an Egyptians, which was \"astronomy\" and \"geometry.\" But we hear not yet o any \"schools\" of \"philosophy.\""} +{"text":"After the Athenians, by the overthrow of the Persian armies, had gotte the dominion of the sea; and thereby of all the islands and maritim cities of the Archipelago, as well of Asia as Europe; and were grow wealthy; they that had no employment, neither at home nor abroad, ha little else to employ themselves in, but either (as St. Luke says, Act 17:21) \"in telling and hearing news,\" or in discoursing of \"philosophy\ publicly to the youth of the city. Every master took some place fo that purpose. Plato, in certain public walks called Academia, from on Academus: Aristotle in the walk of the temple of Pan, called Lyceum others in the Stoa, or covered walk, wherein the merchants' goods wer brought to land: others in other places; where they spent the time o their leisure in teaching or in disputing of their opinions: and som in any place where they could get the youth of the city together t hear them talk. And this was it which Carneades also did at Rome, whe he was ambassador: which caused Cato to advise the senate to dispatc him quickly, for fear of corrupting the manners of the young men, tha delighted to hear him speak, as they thought, fine things."} +{"text":"From this it was that the place where any of them taught and dispute was called schola, which in their tongue signifieth \"leisure\"; an their disputations, diatribae, that is to say, \"passing of the time.\ Also the philosophers themselves had the name of their sects, some o them from these their schools: for they that followed Plato's doctrin were called Academics; the followers of Aristotle Peripatetics, fro the walk he taught in; and those that Zeno taught Stoics, from th Stoa; as if we should denominate men from Moorfields, from Paul' Church, and from the Exchange, because they meet there often to prat and loiter."} +{"text":"Nevertheless, men were so much taken with this custom that in time i spread itself over all Europe and the best part of Africa; so as ther were schools publicly erected and maintained, for lectures an disputations, almost in every commonwealth."} +{"text":"There were also schools, anciently, both before and after the time o our Saviour, amongst the Jews; but they were schools of their law. Fo though they were called \"synagogues,\" that is to say, congregations o the people; yet, inasmuch as the law was every Sabbath-day read expounded, and disputed in them, they differed not in nature, but i name only, from public schools; and were not only in Jerusalem, but i every city of the Gentiles where the Jews inhabited. There was such school at Damascus, whereinto Paul entered to persecute. There wer others at Antioch, Iconium, and Thessalonica, whereinto he entered t dispute: and such was the synagogue of the Libertines, Cyrenians Alexandrians, Cilicians, and those of Asia; that is to say, the schoo of Libertines, and of Jews that were strangers in Jerusalem; and o this school they were that disputed (Acts 6:9) with St. Stephen."} +{"text":"But what has been the utility of those schools? What science is ther at this day acquired by their readings and disputings? That we have o geometry, which is the mother of all natural science, we are no indebted for it to the schools. Plato, that was the best philosopher o the Greeks, forbad entrance into his school to all that were no already in some measure geometricians. There were many that studie that science to the great advantage of mankind: but there is no mentio of their schools; nor was there any sect of geometricians; nor did the then pass under the name of philosophers. The natural philosophy o those schools was rather a dream than science, and set forth i senseless and insignificant language; which cannot be avoided by thos that will teach philosophy without having first attained grea knowledge in geometry. For Nature worketh by motion; the ways an degrees whereof cannot be known, without the knowledge of th proportions and properties of lines and figures. Their moral philosoph is but a description of their own passions. For the rule of manners without civil government, is the law of Nature; and in it the la civil, that determineth what is \"honest\" and \"dishonest,\" what i \"just\" and \"unjust,\" and generally what is \"good\" and \"evil.\" Wherea they make the rules of \"good\" and \"bad\" by their own \"liking\" an \"disliking\": by which means, in so great diversity of taste, there i nothing generally agreed on; but everyone doth, as far as he dares whatsoever seemeth good in his own eyes, to the subversion o commonwealth. Their \"logic,\" which should be the method of reasoning is nothing else but captions of words, and inventions how to puzzl such as should go about to pose them. To conclude, there is nothing s absurd that the old philosophers, as Cicero saith (who was one o them), have not some of them maintained. And I believe that scarc anything can be more absurdly said in natural philosophy than tha which now is called \"Aristotle's Metaphysics\"; nor more repugnant t government than much of that he hath said in his Politics; nor mor ignorantly than a great part of his Ethics."} +{"text":"The school of the Jews was originally a school of the Law of Moses, wh commanded (Deut. 31:10) that at the end of every seventh year, at th Feast of the Tabernacles, it should be read to all the people, tha they might hear and learn it. Therefore the reading of the Law, whic was in use after the Captivity, every Sabbath-day, ought to have had n other end but the acquainting of the people with the Commandments whic they were to obey, and to expound unto them the writings of th prophets. But it is manifest, by the many reprehensions of them by ou Saviour, that they corrupted the text of the Law with their fals commentaries and vain traditions; and so little understood th prophets, that they did neither acknowledge Christ, nor the works H did, of which the prophets prophesied. So that by their lectures an disputations in their synagogues, they turned the doctrine of their La into a fantastical kind of philosophy, concerning the incomprehensibl nature of God and of spirits; which they compounded of the vai philosophy and theology of the Grecians, mingled with their ow fancies, drawn from the obscurer places of the Scripture, and whic might most easily be wrested to their purpose; and from the fabulou traditions of their ancestors."} +{"text":"That which is now called an University, is a joining together, and a incorporation under one government of many public schools in one an the same town or city. In which, the principal schools were ordaine for the three professions, that is to say, of the Roman religion, o the Roman law, and of the art of medicine. And for the study o philosophy, it hath no otherwise place than as a handmaid to the Roma religion: and since the authority of Aristotle is only current there that study is not properly philosophy (the nature whereof dependeth no on authors), but \"Aristotelity.\" And for geometry, till of very lat times it had no place at all; as being subservient to nothing but rigi truth. And if any man, by the ingenuity of his own nature, had attaine to any degree of perfection therein, he was commonly thought magician, and his art diabolical."} +{"text":"Now to descend to the particular tenets of vain philosophy, derived t the Universities, and thence into the Church, partly from Aristotle partly from blindness of understanding; I shall first consider thei principles. There is a certain philosophia prima, on which all othe philosophy ought to depend; and consisteth, principally, in righ limiting of the significations of such appellations or names as are o all others the most universal; which limitations serve to avoi ambiguity and equivocation in reasoning; and are commonly calle definitions; such as are the definitions of body, time, place, matter form, essence, subject, substance, accident, power, act, finite infinite, quantity, quality, motion, action, passion, and diver others, necessary to the explaining of a man's conceptions concernin the nature and generation of bodies. The explication, that is, th settling of the meaning, of which, and the like terms, is commonly i the schools called \"metaphysics\"; as being a part of the philosophy o Aristotle, which hath that for title. But it is in another sense; fo there it signifieth as much as \"books written or placed after hi natural philosophy\": but the schools take them for \"books o supernatural philosophy\"; for the word \"metaphysics\" will bear bot these senses. And indeed that which is there written is for the mos part so far from the possibility of being understood, and so repugnan to natural reason, that whosoever thinketh there is anything to b understood by it, must needs think it supernatural."} +{"text":"From these metaphysics, which are mingled with the Scripture to mak school divinity, we are told there be in the world certain essence separated from bodies, which they call \"abstract essences,\" an \"substantial forms.\" For the interpreting of which jargon, there i need of somewhat more than ordinary attention in this place. Also I as pardon of those that are not used to this kind of discourse, fo applying myself to those that are. The world (I mean not the eart only, that denominates the lovers of it \"worldly men,\" but th \"universe,\" that is, the whole mass of all things that are), i corporeal, that is to say, body; and hath the dimensions of magnitude namely, length, breadth, and depth: also every part of body is likewis body, and hath the like dimensions; and consequently every part of th universe is body, and that which is not body is no part of th universe: and because the universe is all, that which is no part of i is \"nothing\"; and consequently \"nowhere.\" Nor does it follow from henc that spirits are \"nothing\": for they have dimensions, and are therefor really \"bodies\"; though that name in common speech be given to suc bodies only as are visible, or palpable; that is, that have some degre of opacity. But for spirits, they call them incorporeal; which is name of more honour, and may therefore with more piety be attributed t God himself; in whom we consider not what attribute expresseth best Hi nature, which is incomprehensible; but what best expresseth our desir to honour Him."} +{"text":"To know now upon what grounds they say there be \"essences abstract,\" o \"substantial forms,\" we are to consider what those words do properl signify. The use of words is to register to ourselves, and mak manifest to others, the thoughts and conceptions of our minds. Of whic words, some are the names of the things conceived; as the names of al sorts of bodies, that work upon the senses and leave an impression i the imagination. Others are the names of the imaginations themselves that is to say, of those ideas or mental images we have of all thing we see, or remember. And others again are names of names; or o different sorts of speech: as \"universal,\" \"plural,\" \"singular,\" ar the names of names; and \"definition,\" \"affirmation,\" \"negation,\ \"true,\" \"false,\" \"syllogism,\" \"interrogation,\" \"promise,\" \"covenant,\ are the names of certain forms of speech. Others serve to show th consequence or repugnance of one name to another; as when one saith, \" man is a body,\" he intendeth that the name of \"body\" is necessaril consequent to the name of \"man\"; as being but several names of the sam thing, \"man\"; which consequence is signified by coupling them togethe with the word \"is.\" And as we use the verb \"is,\" so the Latins us their verb \"est,\" and the Greeks their sti through all it declinations. Whether all other nations of the world have in thei several languages a word that answereth to it, or not, I cannot tell but I am sure they have not need of it. For the placing of two names i order may serve to signify their consequence, if it were the custo (for custom is it that gives words their force), as well as the word \"is,\" or \"be,\" or \"are,\" and the like."} +{"text":"And if it were so, that there were a language without any ver answerable to \"est,\" or \"is,\" or \"be\"; yet the men that used it woul be not a jot the less capable of inferring, concluding, and of all kin of reasoning, than were the Greeks and Latins. But what then woul become of these terms of \"entity,\" \"essence,\" \"essential,\ \"essentiality,\" that are derived from it, and of many more that depen on these, applied as most commonly they are? They are therefore n names of things; but signs, by which we make known that we conceive th consequence of one name or attribute to another: as when we say, \"a ma is a living body,\" we mean not that the \"man\" is one thing, the \"livin body\" another, and the \"is\" or \"being\" a third; but that the \"man\" an the \"living body\" is the same thing; because the consequence, \"if he b a man, he is a living body,\" is a true consequence, signified by tha word \"is.\" Therefore, \"to be a body,\" \"to walk,\" \"to be speaking,\" \"t live,\" \"to see,\" and the like infinitives; also \"corporeity,\ \"walking,\" \"speaking,\" \"life,\" \"sight,\" and the like, that signify jus the same, are the names of \"nothing\"; as I have elsewhere more ampl expressed."} +{"text":"But to what purpose, may some man say, is such subtlety in a work o this nature, where I pretend to nothing but what is necessary to th doctrine of government and obedience? It is to this purpose that me may no longer suffer themselves to be abused by them that by thi doctrine of \"separated essences,\" built on the vain philosophy o Aristotle, would fright them from obeying the laws of their country with empty names; as men fright birds from the corn with an empt doublet, a hat, and a crooked stick. For it is upon this ground tha when a man is dead and buried, they say his soul, that is his life, ca walk separated from his body, and is seen by night amongst the graves Upon the same ground they say that the figure, and colour, and taste o a piece of bread has a being there where they say there is no bread And upon the same ground they say that faith, and wisdom, and othe virtues, are sometimes \"poured\" into a man, sometimes \"blown\" into hi from heaven, as if the virtuous and their virtues could be asunder; an a great many other things that serve to lessen the dependence o subjects on the sovereign power of their country. For who wil endeavour to obey the laws, if he expect obedience to be poured o blown into him? Or who will not obey a priest that can make God, rathe than his sovereign, nay, than God himself? Or who, that is in fear o ghosts, will not bear great respect to those that can make the hol water that drives them from him? And this shall suffice for an exampl of the errors which are brought into the Church from the \"entities\" an \"essences\" of Aristotle, which it may be he knew to be fals philosophy, but writ it as a thing consonant to and corroborative o their religion, and fearing the fate of Socrates."} +{"text":"Being once fallen into this error of \"separated essences,\" they ar thereby necessarily involved in many other absurdities that follow it For seeing they will have these forms to be real, they are obliged t assign them \"some place.\" But because they hold them incorporeal without all dimension of quantity, and all men know that place i dimension, and not to be filled but by that which is corporeal, the are driven to uphold their credit with a distinction, that they are no indeed anywhere \"circumscriptive,\" but \"definitive,\" which terms bein mere words, and in this occasion insignificant, pass only in Latin that the vanity of them may be concealed. For the circumscription of thing is nothing else but the determination or defining of its place and so both the terms of the distinction are the same. And i particular, of the essence of a man, which, they say, is his soul, the affirm it to be all of it in his little finger, and all of it in ever other part, how small soever, of his body, and yet no more soul in th whole body than in any one of those parts. Can any man think that Go is served with such absurdities? And yet all this is necessary t believe to those that will believe the existence of an incorporeal sou separated from the body."} +{"text":"And when they come to give account how an incorporeal substance can b capable of pain, and be tormented in the fire of hell or purgatory they have nothing at all to answer, but that it cannot be known ho fire can burn souls."} +{"text":"Again, whereas motion is change of place, and incorporeal substance are not capable of place, they are troubled to make it seem possibl how a soul can go hence, without the body, to heaven, hell, o purgatory; and how the ghosts of men, and I may add of their clothe which they appear in, can walk by night in churches, churchyards, an other places of sepulture. To which I know not what they can answer unless they will say they walk \"definitive,\" not \"circumscriptive,\" o \"spiritually,\" not \"temporally,\" for such egregious distinctions ar equally applicable to any difficulty whatsoever."} +{"text":"For the meaning of \"eternity,\" they will not have it to be an endles succession of time, for then they should not be able to render a reaso how God's will, and preordaining of things to come, should not b before His prescience of the same, as the efficient cause before th effect, or agent before the action; nor of many other their bol opinions concerning the incomprehensible nature of God. But they wil teach us that eternity is the standing still of the present time, nunc-stans, as the schools call it; which neither they nor any els understand, no more than they would a hic-stans for an infinit greatness of place."} +{"text":"And whereas men divide a body in their thought, by numbering parts o it and, in numbering those parts, number also the parts of the place i filled; it cannot be, but in making many parts, we make also man places of those parts: whereby there cannot be conceived in the mind o any man, more or fewer parts than there are places for: yet they wil have us believe that by the almighty power of God, one body may be a one and the same time in many places; and many bodies at one and th same time in one place; as if it were an acknowledgment of the Divin Power to say, that which is, is not: or that which has been, has no been. And these are but a small part of the incongruities they ar forced to, from their disputing philosophically, instead of admirin and adoring of the divine and incomprehensible nature; whose attribute cannot signify what He is, but ought to signify our desire to honou Him with the best appellations we can think on. But they that ventur to reason of His nature from these attributes of honour, losing thei understanding in the very first attempt, fall from one inconvenienc into another, without end, and without number; in the same manner, a when a man ignorant of the ceremonies of court, coming into th presence of a greater person than he is used to speak to, and stumblin at his entrance, to save himself from falling, lets slip his cloak; t recover his cloak, lets fall his hat; and with one disorder afte another, discovers his astonishment and rusticity."} +{"text":"Then for \"physics,\" that is, the knowledge of the subordinate an secondary causes of natural events; they render none at all, but empt words. If you desire to know why some kind of bodies sink naturall downwards toward the earth, and others go naturally from it, th schools will tell you out of Aristotle, that the bodies that sin downwards are \"heavy,\" and that this heaviness is it that causes the to descend. But if you ask what they mean by \"heaviness,\" they wil define it to be an endeavour to go to the centre of the earth. So tha the cause why things sink downward, is an endeavour to be below; whic is as much as to say, that bodies descend, or ascend, because they do Or they will tell you the centre of the earth is the place of rest, an conservation for heavy things; and therefore they endeavour to b there: as if stones and metals had a desire, or could discern the plac they would be at, as man does; or loved rest, as man does not; or tha a piece of glass were less safe in the window than falling into th street."} +{"text":"If we would know why the same body seems greater, without adding to it one time than another, they say, when it seems less, it is \"condensed\" when greater, \"rarified.\" What is that \"condensed,\" and \"rarified?\ Condensed is when there is in the very same matter, less quantity tha before, and rarified, when more. As if there could be matter that ha not some determined quantity; when quantity is nothing else but th determination of matter; that is to say, of body, by which we say, on body is greater or lesser than another, by thus or thus much. Or as i a body were made without any quantity at all, and that afterwards mor or less were put into it, according as it is intended the body shoul be more or less dense."} +{"text":"For the cause of the soul of man, they say, creatur infundendo, an creando infunditur: that is, \"it is created by pouring it in,\" an \"poured in by creation.\""} +{"text":"For the cause of sense, an ubiquity of \"species\"; that is, of th \"shows\" or \"apparitions\" of objects; which when they be apparitions t the eye, is \"sight\"; when to the ear, \"hearing\"; to the palate \"taste\"; to the nostril, \"smelling\"; and to the rest of the body \"feeling.\""} +{"text":"For cause of the will, to do any particular action, which is calle volitio, they assign the faculty, that is to say, the capacity i general, that men have to will sometimes one thing, sometimes another which is called voluntas; making the \"power\" the cause of the \"act.\" A if one should assign for cause of the good or evil acts of men, thei ability to do them."} +{"text":"And in many occasions they put for cause of natural events their ow ignorance; but disguised in other words: as when they say, fortune i the cause of things contingent; that is, of things whereof they know n cause: and as when they attribute many effects to \"occult qualities\" that is, qualities not known to them; and therefore also, as the think, to no man else. And to \"sympathy,\" \"antipathy,\ \"antiperistasis,\" \"specifical qualities,\" and other like terms, whic signify neither the agent that produceth them, nor the operation b which they are produced."} +{"text":"If such \"metaphysics\" and \"physics\" as this, be not \"vain philosophy,\ there was never any; nor needed St. Paul to give us warning to avoi it."} +{"text":"And for their moral and civil philosophy, it hath the same, or greate absurdities. If a man do an action of injustice, that is to say, a action contrary to the law, God they say is the prime cause of the law and also the prime cause of that, and all other actions; but no caus at all of the injustice; which is the inconformity of the action to th law. This is vain philosophy. A man might as well say, that one ma maketh both a straight line and a crooked, and another maketh thei incongruity. And such is the philosophy of all men that resolve o their conclusions, before they know their premises; pretending t comprehend that which is incomprehensible; and of attributes of honou to make attributes of nature; as this distinction was made to maintai the doctrine of freewill, that is, of a will of man not subject to th will of God."} +{"text":"Aristotle, and other heathen philosophers, define good and evil by th appetite of men; and well enough, as long as we consider them governe everyone by his own law; for in the condition of men that have no othe law but their own appetites, there can be no general rule of good an evil actions. But in a commonwealth this measure is false: not th appetite of private men, but the law, which is the will and appetite o the state, is the measure. And yet is this doctrine still practiced and men judge the goodness or wickedness of their own, and of othe men's actions, and of the actions of the commonwealth itself, by thei own passions; and no man calleth good or evil, but that which is so i his own eyes, without any regard at all to the public laws; except onl monks and friars, that are bound by vow to that simple obedience t their superior, to which every subject ought to think himself bound b the law of Nature to the civil sovereign. And this private measure o good, is a doctrine, not only vain, but also pernicious to the publi state."} +{"text":"It is also vain and false philosophy, to say the work of marriage i repugnant to chastity, or continence, and by consequence to make the moral vices; as they do, that pretend chastity, and continence, for th ground of denying marriage to the clergy. For they confess it is n more but a constitution of the Church, that requireth in those hol orders that continually attend the altar and administration of th Eucharist, a continual abstinence from women, under the name o continual chastity, continence, and purity. Therefore they call th lawful use of wives, want of chastity and continence; and so mak marriage a sin, or at least a thing so impure and unclean, as to rende a man unfit for the altar. If the law were made because the use o wives is incontinence, and contrary to chastity, then all marriage i vice: if because it is a thing too impure and unclean, for a ma consecrated to God; much more should other natural, necessary, an daily works which all men do, render men unworthy to be priests because they are more unclean."} +{"text":"But the secret foundation of this prohibition of marriage of priests i not likely to have been laid so slightly, as upon such errors in mora philosophy; nor yet upon the preference of single life, to the estat of matrimony; which proceeded from the wisdom of St. Paul, wh perceived how inconvenient a thing it was for those that in those time of persecution were preachers of the Gospel, and forced to fly from on country to another, to be clogged with the care of wife and children but upon the design of the Popes, and priests of after times, to mak themselves the clergy, that is to say, sole heirs of the kingdom of Go in this world; to which it was necessary to take from them the use o marriage; because our Saviour saith, that at the coming of His kingdo the children of God \"shall neither marry, nor be given in marriage, bu shall be as the angels in heaven\"; that is to say, spiritual. Seein then they had taken on them the name of spiritual, to have allowe themselves, when there was no need, the propriety of wives, had been a incongruity."} +{"text":"From Aristotle's civil philosophy, they have learned to call all manne of commonwealths but the popular (such as was at that time the state o Athens), tyranny. All kings they called tyrants; and the aristocracy o the thirty governors set up there by the Lacedemonians that subdue them, the thirty tyrants. As also to call the condition of the peopl under the democracy, \"liberty.\" \"A tyrant\" originally signified no mor simply, but a \"monarch.\" But when afterwards in most part of Greec that kind of government was abolished, the name began to signify, no only the thing it did before, but with it the hatred which the popula states bare towards it. As also the name of king became odious afte the deposing of the kings in Rome, as being a thing natural to all men to conceive some great fault to be signified in any attribute that i given in despite, and to a great enemy. And when the same men shall b displeased with those that have the administration of the democracy, o aristocracy, they are not to seek for disgraceful names to expres their anger in; but call readily the one \"anarchy,\" and the othe \"oligarchy,\" or the \"tyranny of a few.\" And that which offendeth th people is no other thing, but that they are governed, not as every on of them would himself, but as the public representant, be it one man or an assembly of men, thinks fit; that is, by an arbitrary government for which they give evil names to their superiors; never knowing, til perhaps a little after a civil war, that without such arbitrar government such war must be perpetual; and that it is men and arms, no words and promises, that make the force and power of the laws."} +{"text":"And therefore this is another error of Aristotle's politics, that in well-ordered commonwealth, not men should govern, but the laws. Wha man, that has his natural senses, though he can neither write nor read does not find himself governed by them he fears, and believes can kil or hurt him when he obeyeth not? Or that believes the law can hurt him that is, words and paper, without the hands and swords of men? And thi is of the number of pernicious errors: for they induce men, as oft a they like not their governors, to adhere to those that call the tyrants, and to think it lawful to raise war against them: and yet the are many times cherished from the pulpit, by the clergy."} +{"text":"There is another error in their civil philosophy, which they neve learned of Aristotle, nor Cicero, nor any other of the heathen, t extend the power of the law, which is the rule of actions only, to th very thoughts and consciences of men, by examination, and \"inquisition\ of what they hold, notwithstanding the conformity of their speech an actions. By which, men are either punished for answering the truth o their thoughts, or constrained to answer an untruth for fear o punishment. It is true, that the civil magistrate, intending to emplo a minister in the charge of teaching, may inquire of him, if he b content to preach such and such doctrines; and in case of refusal, ma deny him the employment. But to force him to accuse himself o opinions, when his actions are not by law forbidden, is against the la of Nature; and especially in them who teach that a man shall be damne to eternal and extreme torments, if he die in a false opinio concerning an article of the Christian faith. For who is there, tha knowing there is so great danger in an error, whom the natural care o himself compelleth not to hazard his soul upon his own judgment, rathe than that of any other man that is unconcerned in his damnation?"} +{"text":"For a private man, without the authority of the commonwealth, that i to say, without permission from the representant thereof, to interpre the law by his own spirit, is another error in the politics; but no drawn from Aristotle nor from any other of the heathen philosophers For none of them deny, but that in the power of making laws i comprehended also the power of explaining them when there is need. An are not the Scriptures, in all places where they are law, made law b the authority of the commonwealth, and consequently a part of the civi law?"} +{"text":"Of the same kind it is also, when any but the sovereign restraineth i any man that power which the commonwealth hath not restrained; as the do, that impropriate the preaching of the Gospel to one certain orde of men, where the laws have left it free. If the state give me leave t preach, or teach; that is, if it forbid me not, no man can forbid me If I find myself amongst the idolaters of America, shall I that am Christian, though not in orders, think it a sin to preach Jesus Christ till I have received orders from Rome? Or when I have preached, shal not I answer their doubts, and expound the Scriptures to them; that is shall I not teach? But for this may some say, as also for administerin to them the sacraments, the necessity shall be esteemed for sufficient mission; which is true: but this is true also, that fo whatsoever a dispensation is due for the necessity, for the same ther needs no dispensation, when there is no law that forbids it. Therefor to deny these functions to those to whom the civil sovereign hath no denied them, is a taking away of a lawful liberty, which is contrary t the doctrine of civil government."} +{"text":"More examples of vain philosophy, brought into religion by the doctor of school divinity, might be produced; but other men may if they pleas observe them of themselves. I shall only add this, that the writings o school divines, are nothing else for the most part but insignifican trains of strange and barbarous words, or words otherwise used, than i the common use of the Latin tongue; such as would pose Cicero, an Varro, and all the grammarians of ancient Rome. Which if any man woul see proved, let him, as I have said once before, see whether he ca translate any school divine into any of the modern tongues, as French English, or any other copious language: for that which cannot in mos of these be made intelligible, is not intelligible in the Latin. Whic insignificancy of language, though I cannot note it for fals philosophy; yet it hath a quality, not only to hide the truth, but als to make men think they have it, and desist from further search."} +{"text":"Lastly, for the errors brought in from false or uncertain history, wha is all the legend of fictitious miracles, in the lives of the saints and all the histories of apparitions and ghosts, alleged by the doctor of the Roman Church, to make good their doctrines of hell an purgatory, the power of exorcism, and other doctrines which have n warrant, neither in reason, nor Scripture; as also all those tradition which they call the unwritten word of God: but old wives' fables Whereof, though they find dispersed somewhat in the writings of th ancient fathers; yet those fathers were men that might too easil believe false reports; and the producing of their opinions fo testimony of the truth of what they believed, hath no other force wit them that, according to the counsel of St. John (1 Epist. 4:1), examin spirits, than in all things that concern the power of the Roman Churc (the abuse whereof either they suspected not, or had benefit by it), t discredit their testimony, in respect of too rash belief of reports which the most sincere men, without great knowledge of natural causes such as the fathers were, are commonly the most subject to. Fo naturally, the best men are the least suspicious of fraudulen purposes. Gregory the Pope and St. Bernard have somewhat of apparition of ghosts, that said they were in purgatory; and so has our Bede: bu nowhere, I believe, but by report from others. But if they, or an other, relate any such stories of their own knowledge, they shall no thereby confirm the more such vain reports; but discover their ow infirmity, or fraud."} +{"text":"With the introduction of false, we may join also the suppression o true philosophy, by such men, as neither by lawful authority no sufficient study, are competent judges of the truth. Our ow navigations make manifest, and all men learned in human sciences no acknowledge, there are antipodes: and every day it appeareth more an more that years and days are determined by motions of the earth Nevertheless, men that have in their writings but supposed suc doctrine, as an occasion to lay open the reasons for and against it have been punished for it by authority ecclesiastical. But what reaso is there for it? Is it because such opinions are contrary to tru religion? That cannot be, if they be true. Let therefore the truth b first examined by competent judges, or confuted by them that pretend t know the contrary. Is it because they be contrary to the religio established? Let them be silenced by the laws of those to whom th teachers of them are subject; that is, by the laws civil. Fo disobedience may lawfully be punished in them that against the law teach even true philosophy. Is it because they tend to disorder i government, as countenancing rebellion or sedition? Then let them b silenced, and the teachers punished by virtue of his power to whom th care of the public quiet is committed; which is the authority civil For whatsoever power ecclesiastics take upon themselves (in any plac where they are subject to the state), in their own right, though the call it God's right, is but usurpation."} +{"text":"LVII"} +{"text":"Of the Benefit That Proceedeth from Such Darkness, and to Whom I Accrueth"} +{"text":"Cicero maketh honourable mention of one of the Cassii, a severe judg amongst the Romans, for a custom he had, in criminal causes, when th testimony of the witnesses was not sufficient, to ask the accusers, cu bono; that is to say, what profit, honour, or other contentment th accused obtained or expected by the fact. For amongst presumptions there is none that so evidently declareth the author as doth th benefit of the action. By the same rule I intend in this place t examine who they may be that have possessed the people so long in thi part of Christendom with these doctrines, contrary to the peaceabl societies of mankind."} +{"text":"And first, to this error, \"that the present Church, now militant o earth, is the kingdom of God\" (that is, the kingdom of glory, or th land of promise; not the kingdom of grace, which is but a promise o the land), are annexed these worldly benefits; first, that the pastor and teachers of the Church are entitled thereby, as God's publi ministers, to a right of governing the Church; and consequently because the Church and commonwealth are the same persons, to be rector and governors of the commonwealth. By this title it is that the Pop prevailed with the subjects of all Christian princes to believe that t disobey him was to disobey Christ himself; and in all difference between him and other princes (charmed with the word \"powe spiritual\"), to abandon their lawful sovereigns; which is in effect a universal monarchy over all Christendom. For though they were firs invested in the right of being supreme teachers of Christian doctrine by and under Christian emperors, within the limits of the Roman empire as is acknowledged by themselves, by the title of Pontifex Maximus, wh was an officer subject to the civil state; yet, after the empire wa divided and dissolved, it was not hard to obtrude upon the peopl already subjected to them, another title, namely, the right o St. Peter, not only to save entire their pretended power, but also t extend the same over the same Christian provinces, though no mor united in the empire of Rome. This benefit of an universal monarch (considering the desire of men to bear rule), is a sufficien presumption that the Popes that pretended to it, and for a long tim enjoyed it, were the authors of the doctrine by which it was obtained namely, that the Church now on earth is the kingdom of Christ. For tha granted, it must be understood that Christ hath some lieutenant amongs us, by whom we are to be told what are His commandments."} +{"text":"After that certain Churches had renounced this universal power of th Pope, one would expect in reason that the civil sovereigns in all thos Churches should have recovered so much of it, as before they ha unadvisedly let it go, was their own right, and in their own hands. An in England it was so in effect; saving that they, by whom the king administered the government of religion by maintaining their employmen to be in God's right, seemed to usurp, if not a supremacy, yet a independency on the civil power, and they but seemed to usurp it inasmuch as they acknowledged a right in the king to deprive them o the exercise of their functions at his pleasure."} +{"text":"But in those places where the presbytery took that office, though man other doctrines of the Church of Rome were forbidden to be taught, ye this doctrine, that the kingdom of Christ is already come, and that i began at the resurrection of our Saviour, was still retained. But cu bono? What profit did they expect from it? The same which the Pope expected: to have a sovereign power over the people. For what is it fo men to excommunicate their lawful king, but to keep him from all place of God's public service in his own kingdom, and with force to resis him when he with force endeavoureth to correct them? Or what is it without authority from the civil sovereign, to excommunicate an person, but to take from him his lawful liberty, that is, to usurp a unlawful power over their brethren? The authors therefore of thi darkness in religion are the Roman and the presbyterian clergy."} +{"text":"To this head I refer also all those doctrines that serve them to kee the possession of this spiritual sovereignty after it is gotten. A first, that the \"Pope in his public capacity cannot err.\" For who i there, that believing this to be true, will not readily obey him i whatsoever he commands?"} +{"text":"Secondly, that all other bishops, in what commonwealth soever, have no their right, neither immediately from God, nor mediately from thei civil sovereigns, but from the Pope, is a doctrine by which there come to be in every Christian commonwealth many potent men (for so ar bishops), that have their dependence on the Pope, and owe obedience t him, though he be a foreign prince; by which means he is able, as h hath done many times, to raise a civil war against the state tha submits not itself to be governed accordingly to his pleasure an interest."} +{"text":"Thirdly, the exemption of these, and of all other priests, and of al monks and friars, from the power of the civil laws. For by this mean there is a great part of every commonwealth that enjoy the benefit o the laws, and are protected by the power of the civil state, whic nevertheless pay no part of the public expense; nor are liable to th penalties, as other subjects, due to their crimes; and consequently stand not in fear of any man but the Pope; and adhere to him only, t uphold his universal monarchy."} +{"text":"Fourthly, the giving to their priests, which is no more in the Ne Testament but presbyters, that is, elders, the name of sacerdotes, tha is, sacrificers, which was the title of the civil sovereign, and hi public ministers, amongst the Jews, whilst God was their king. Also the making the Lord's Supper a sacrifice, serveth to make the peopl believe the Pope hath the same power over all Christians that Moses an Aaron had over the Jews; that is to say, all power, both civil an ecclesiastical, as the high priest then had."} +{"text":"Fifthly, the teaching that matrimony is a sacrament, giveth to th clergy the judging of the lawfulness of marriages; and thereby, of wha children are legitimate; and consequently, of the right of successio to hereditary kingdoms."} +{"text":"Sixthly, the denial of marriage to priests, serveth to assure thi power of the Pope over kings. For if a king be a priest he canno marry, and transmit his kingdom to his posterity; if he be not priest, then the Pope pretendeth this authority ecclesiastical ove him, and over his people."} +{"text":"Seventhly, from auricular confession, they obtain for the assurance o their power, better intelligence of the designs of princes and grea persons in the civil state, than these can have of the designs of th state ecclesiastical."} +{"text":"Eighthly, by the canonization of saints, and declaring who are martyrs they assure their power, in that they induce simple men into a obstinacy against the laws and commands of their civil sovereigns eve to death, if by the Pope's excommunication they be declared heretics o enemies to the Church; that is, as they interpret it to the Pope."} +{"text":"Ninthly, they assure the same by the power they ascribe to ever priest, of making Christ; and by the power of ordaining penance; and o remitting and retaining of sins."} +{"text":"Tenthly, by the doctrine of purgatory, of justification by externa works, and of indulgences, the clergy is enriched."} +{"text":"Eleventhly, by their demonology, and the use of exorcism, and othe things appertaining thereto, they keep, or think they keep, the peopl more in awe of their power."} +{"text":"Lastly, the metaphysics, ethics, and politics of Aristotle, th frivolous distinctions, barbarous terms, and obscure language of th schoolmen, taught in the universities, which have been all erected an regulated by the Pope's authority, serve them to keep these errors fro being detected, and to make men mistake the ignis fatuus of vai philosophy for the light of the Gospel."} +{"text":"To these, if they sufficed not, might be added other of their dar doctrines, the profit whereof redoundeth manifestly to the setting u of an unlawful power over the lawful sovereigns of Christian people; o for the sustaining of the same, when it is set up; or to the worldl riches, honour, and authority of those that sustain it. And therefor by the aforesaid rule of cui bono we may justly pronounce for th authors of all this spiritual darkness, the Pope and Roman clergy, an all those besides that endeavour to settle in the minds of men thi erroneous doctrine that the Church now on earth is that kingdom of Go mentioned in the Old and New Testament."} +{"text":"But the emperors, and other Christian sovereigns, under whos government these errors, and the like encroachments of ecclesiastic upon their office, at first crept in, to the disturbance of thei possessions and of the tranquillity of their subjects, though the suffered the same for want of foresight of the sequel, and of insigh into the designs of their teachers, may nevertheless be esteeme accessories to their own and the public damage. For without thei authority there could at first no seditious doctrine have been publicl preached. I say they might have hindered the same in the beginning: bu when the people were once possessed by those spiritual men there was n human remedy to be applied, that any man could invent. And for th remedies that God should provide, who never faileth in His good time t destroy all the machinations of men against the truth, we are to atten His good pleasure, that suffereth many times the prosperity of Hi enemies, together with their ambition, to grow to such a height as th violence thereof openeth the eyes, which the wariness of thei predecessors had before sealed up, and makes men by too much graspin let go all, as Peter's net was broken by the struggling of too great multitude of fishes; whereas the impatience of those that strive t resist such encroachment before their subjects' eyes were opened, di but increase the power they resisted. I do not therefore blame th emperor Frederick for holding the stirrup to our countryman Pop Adrian; for such was the disposition of his subjects then, as if he ha not done it, he was not likely to have succeeded in the empire. But blame those that in the beginning, when their power was entire, b suffering such doctrines to be forged in the universities of their ow dominions, have holden the stirrup to all the succeeding Popes, whils they mounted into the thrones of all Christian sovereigns, to ride an tire both them and their people at their pleasure."} +{"text":"But as the inventions of men are woven, so also are they ravelled out the way is the same, but the order is inverted. The web begins at th first elements of power, which are wisdom, humility, sincerity, an other virtues of the Apostles, whom the people, converted, obeyed ou of reverence, not by obligation. Their consciences were free, and thei words and actions subject to none but the civil power. Afterwards th presbyters, as the flocks of Christ increased, assembling to conside what they should teach, and thereby obliging themselves to teac nothing against the decrees of their assemblies, made it to be though the people were thereby obliged to follow their doctrine, and when the refused, refused to keep them company (that was then calle excommunication), not as being infidels, but as being disobedient: an this was the first knot upon their liberty. And the number o presbyters increasing, the presbyters of the chief city or province go themselves an authority over the parochial presbyters, and appropriate to themselves the names of bishops: and this was a second knot o Christian liberty. Lastly, the Bishop of Rome, in regard of th imperial city, took upon him an authority (partly by the wills of th emperors themselves, and by the title of Pontifex Maximus, and at las when the emperors were grown weak by the privileges of St. Peter), ove all other bishops of the empire: which was the third and last knot, an the whole \"synthesis\" and \"construction\" of the pontifical power."} +{"text":"And therefore the \"analysis,\" or \"resolution,\" is by the same way; bu beginneth with the knot that was last tied; as we may see in th dissolution of the praeterpolitical Church government in England First, the power of the Popes was dissolved totally by Queen Elizabeth and the bishops, who before exercised their functions in right of th Pope, did afterwards exercise the same in right of the Queen and he successors; though by retaining the phrase of jure divino, they wer thought to demand it by immediate right from God: and so was untied th third knot. After this, the presbyterians, lately in England obtaine the putting down of episcopacy: and so was the second knot dissolved And almost at the same time the power was taken also from th presbyterians: and so we are reduced to the independency of th primitive Christians, to follow Paul, or Cephas, or Apollo, every ma as he liketh best: which, if it be without contention, and withou measuring the doctrine of Christ, by our affection to the person of Hi minister (the fault which the apostle reprehended in the Corinthians) is perhaps the best. First, because there ought to be no power over th consciences of men, but of the Word itself, working faith in everyone not always according to the purpose of them that plant and water, bu of God himself, that giveth the increase. And secondly, because it i unreasonable in them, who teach there is such danger in every littl error, to require of a man endued with reason of his own, to follow th reason of any other man, or of the most voices of any other men, whic is little better than to venture his salvation at cross and pile. No ought those teachers to be displeased with this loss of their ancien authority. For there is none should know better than they, that powe is preserved by the same virtues by which it is acquired: that is t say, by wisdom, humility, clearness of doctrine, and sincerity o conversation; and not by suppression of the natural sciences, and o the morality of natural reason; nor by obscure language; nor b arrogating to themselves more knowledge than they make appear; nor b pious frauds; nor by such other faults, as in the pastors of God' Church are not only faults, but also scandals, apt to make men stumbl one time or other upon the suppression of their authority."} +{"text":"But after this doctrine, \"that the Church now militant is the kingdo of God spoken of in the Old and New Testament,\" was received in th world; the ambition, and canvassing for the offices that belon thereunto, and especially for that great office of being Christ' lieutenant, and the pomp of them that obtained therein the principa public charges, became by degrees so evident, that they lost the inwar reverence due to the pastoral function: insomuch as the wisest men o them that had any power in the civil state, needed nothing but th authority of their princes to deny them any further obedience. For from the time that the Bishop of Rome had gotten to be acknowledged fo bishop universal, by pretence of succession to St. Peter, their whol hierarchy, or kingdom of darkness, may be compared not unfitly to th \"kingdom of fairies\"; that is, to the old wives' fables in Englan concerning \"ghosts\" and \"spirits,\" and the feats they play in th night. And if a man consider the original of this great ecclesiastica dominion, he will easily perceive that the Papacy is no other than th \"ghost\" of the deceased \"Roman empire,\" sitting crowned upon the grav thereof. For so did the Papacy start up on a sudden out of the ruins o that heathen power."} +{"text":"The \"language\" also which they use, both in the churches and in thei public acts, being Latin, which is not commonly used by any nation no in the world, what is it but the \"ghost\" of the old \"Roman language?\""} +{"text":"The \"fairies,\" in what nation soever they converse, have but on universal king, which some poets of ours call King Oberon; but th Scripture calls Beelzebub, prince of \"demons.\" The \"ecclesiastics\ likewise, in whose dominions soever they be found, acknowledge but on universal king, the Pope."} +{"text":"The \"ecclesiastics\" are \"spiritual\" men and \"ghostly\" fathers. Th fairies are \"spirits\" and \"ghosts.\" \"Fairies\" and \"ghosts\" inhabi darkness, solitudes, and graves. The \"ecclesiastics\" walk in obscurit of doctrine, in monasteries, churches, and churchyards."} +{"text":"The \"ecclesiastics\" have their cathedral churches, which, in what tow soever they be erected, by virtue of holy water and certain charm called exorcisms, have the power to make those towns cities, that is t say, seats of empire. The \"fairies\" also have their enchanted castle and certain gigantic ghosts, that domineer over the regions round abou them."} +{"text":"The \"fairies\" are not to be seized on, and brought to answer for th hurt they do. So also the \"ecclesiastics\" vanish away from th tribunals of civil justice."} +{"text":"The \"ecclesiastics\" take from young men the use of reason, by certai charms compounded of metaphysics, and miracles, and traditions, an abused Scripture, whereby they are good for nothing else but to execut what they command them. The \"fairies\" likewise are said to take youn children out of their cradles, and to change them into natural fools which common people do therefore call \"elves,\" and are apt to mischief."} +{"text":"In what shop, or operatory, the fairies make their enchantment, the ol wives have not determined. But the operatories of the \"clergy\" are wel enough known to be the universities, that received their disciplin from authority pontifical."} +{"text":"When the \"fairies\" are displeased with anybody, they are said to sen their elves to pinch them. The \"ecclesiastics,\" when they ar displeased with any civil state, make also their elves, that is superstitious, enchanted subjects, to pinch their princes, by preachin sedition; or one prince enchanted with promises, to pinch another."} +{"text":"The \"fairies\" marry not; but there be amongst them incubi, that hav copulation with flesh and blood. The \"priests\" also marry not."} +{"text":"The \"ecclesiastics\" take the cream of the land, by donations o ignorant men, that stand in awe of them, and by tithes. So also it i in the fable of \"fairies,\" that they enter into the dairies, and feas upon the cream, which they skim from the milk."} +{"text":"What kind of money is current in the kingdom of \"fairies\" is no recorded in the story. But the \"ecclesiastics\" in their receipts accep of the same money that we do; though when they are to make any payment it is in canonizations, indulgences, and masses."} +{"text":"To this, and suchlike resemblances between the Papacy and the kingdo of \"fairies,\" may be added this, that as the \"fairies\" have n existence but in the fancies of ignorant people, rising from th traditions of old wives, or old poets: so the spiritual power of th Pope, without the bounds of his own civil dominion, consisteth only i the fear that seduced people stand in, of their excommunications; upo hearing of false miracles, false traditions, and false interpretation of the Scripture."} +{"text":"It was not, therefore, a very difficult matter for Henry VIII by hi exorcism; nor for Queen Elizabeth by hers, to cast them out. But wh knows that this spirit of Rome, now gone out, and walking by mission through the dry places of China, Japan, and the Indies, that yield hi little fruit, may not return, or rather an assembly of spirits wors than he, enter, and inhabit this clean swept house, and make the en thereof worse than the beginning? For it is not the Roman clergy only that pretends the kingdom of God to be of this world, and thereby t have a power therein, distinct from that of the civil state. And thi is all I had a design to say concerning the doctrine of the \"politics.\ Which when I have reviewed, I shall willingly expose it to the censur of my country."} +{"text":"eview, and Conclusion"} +{"text":"From the contrariety of some of the natural faculties of the mind, on to another, as also of one passion to another, and from their referenc to conversation, there has been an argument taken, to infer a impossibility that any one man should be sufficiently disposed to al sorts of civil duty. The severity of judgment, they say, makes me censorious, and unapt to pardon the errors and infirmities of othe men: and on the other side, celerity of fancy, makes the thoughts les steady than is necessary to discern exactly between right and wrong Again, in all deliberations, and in all pleadings, the faculty of soli reasoning is necessary; for without it, the resolutions of men ar rash, and their sentences unjust: and yet if there be not powerfu eloquence, which procureth attention and consent, the effect of reaso will belittle. But these are contrary faculties, the former bein grounded upon principles of truth, the other upon opinions alread received, true or false; and upon the passions and interests of men which are different and mutable."} +{"text":"And amongst the passions, \"courage\" (by which I mean the contempt o wounds, and violent death) inclineth men to private revenges, an sometimes to endeavour the unsettling of the public peace; an \"timorousness,\" many times disposeth to the desertion of the publi defence. Both these, they say, cannot stand together in the sam person."} +{"text":"And to consider the contrariety of men's opinions and manners i general, it is, they say, impossible to entertain a constant civi amity with all those with whom the business of the world constrains u to converse; which business consisteth almost in nothing else but perpetual contention for honour, riches, and authority."} +{"text":"To which I answer, that these are indeed great difficulties, but no impossibilities; for by education and discipline, they may be, and ar sometimes reconciled. Judgment and fancy may have place in the sam man; but by turns, as the end which he aimeth at requireth. As th Israelites in Egypt were sometimes fastened to their labour of makin bricks, and other times were ranging abroad to gather straw; so als may the judgment sometimes be fixed upon one certain consideration, an the fancy at another time wandering about the world. So also reason an eloquence, though not perhaps in the natural sciences, yet in th moral, may stand very well together. For wheresoever there is place fo adorning and preferring of error, there is much more place for adornin and preferring of truth, if they have it to adorn. Nor is there an repugnancy between fearing the laws, and not fearing a public enemy nor between abstaining from injury, and pardoning it in others. Ther is therefore no such inconsistence of human nature, with civil duties as some think. I have known clearness of judgment, and largeness o fancy; strength of reason, and graceful elocution; a courage for th war, and a fear for the laws, and all eminently in one man; and tha was my most noble and honoured friend, Mr. Sidney Godolphin; who hatin no man, nor hated of any, was unfortunately slain in the beginning o the late civil war, in the public quarrel, by an undiscerned and a undiscerning hand."} +{"text":"To the Laws of Nature, declared in Chapter XV, I would have this added \"that every man is bound by Nature as much as in him lieth, to protec in war the authority by which he is himself protected in time o peace.\" For he that pretendeth a right of Nature to preserve his ow body, cannot pretend a right of Nature to destroy him, by whos strength he is preserved: it is a manifest contradiction of himself And though this law may be drawn by consequence, from some of thos that are there already mentioned; yet the times require to have i inculcated, and remembered."} +{"text":"And because I find by divers English books lately printed, that th civil wars have not yet sufficiently taught men in what point of tim it is, that a subject becomes obliged to the conqueror; nor what i conquest; nor how it comes about, that it obliges men to obey his laws therefore for further satisfaction of men therein, I say, the point o time, wherein a man becomes subject to a conqueror, is that point wherein having liberty to submit to him, he consenteth, either b express words, or by other sufficient sign, to be his subject. When i is that a man hath the liberty to submit, I have showed before in th end of Chapter XXI.; namely, that for him that hath no obligation t his former sovereign but that of an ordinary subject, it is then, whe the means of his life are within the guards and garrisons of the enemy for it is then that he hath no longer protection from him, but i protected by the adverse party for his contribution. Seeing therefor such contribution is everywhere, as a thing inevitable, notwithstandin it be an assistance to the enemy, esteemed lawful; a total submission which is but an assistance to the enemy, cannot be esteemed unlawful Besides, if a man consider that they who submit, assist the enemy bu with part of their estates, whereas they that refuse, assist him wit the whole, there is no reason to call their submission, or composition an assistance; but rather a detriment to the enemy. But if a man besides the obligation of a subject, hath taken upon him a ne obligation of a soldier, then he hath not the liberty to submit to new power, as long as the old one keeps the field, and giveth him mean of subsistence, either in his armies, or garrisons: for in this case he cannot complain of want of protection and means to live as soldier. But when that also fails, a soldier also may seek hi protection wheresoever he has most hope to have it; and may lawfull submit himself to his new master. And so much for the time when he ma do it lawfully, if he will. If therefore he do it, he is undoubtedl bound to be a true subject: for a contract lawfully made, canno lawfully be broken."} +{"text":"By this also a man may understand, when it is, that men may be said t be conquered; and in what the nature of conquest, and the right of conqueror consisteth: for this submission in itself implieth them all Conquest, is not the victory itself; but the acquisition, by victory of a right over the persons of men. He therefore that is slain, i overcome, but not conquered: he that is taken and put into prison o chains, is not conquered, though overcome; for he is still an enemy and may save himself if he can: but he that upon promise of obedienc hath his life and liberty allowed him, is then conquered, and subject; and not before. The Romans used to say that their general ha \"pacified\" such a \"province,\" that is to say, in English, \"conquered\ it; and that the country was \"pacified\" by victory, when the people o it had promised imperata facere, that is, \"to do what the Roman peopl commanded them\": this was to be conquered. But this promise may b either express or tacit: express, by promise: tacit, by other signs. A for example, a man that hath not been called to make such an expres promise, because he is one whose power perhaps is not considerable; ye if he live under their protection openly, he is understood to submi himself to the government: but if he live there secretly, he is liabl to anything that may be done to a spy and enemy of the state. I say no he does any injustice; for acts of open hostility bear not that name but that he may be justly put to death. Likewise, if a man, when hi country is conquered, be out of it, he is not conquered, nor subject but if at his return he submit to the government, he is bound to obe it. So that \"conquest,\" to define it, is the acquiring of the right o sovereignty by victory. Which right is acquired in the people' submission, by which they contract with the victor, promisin obedience, for life and liberty."} +{"text":"In Chapter XXIX, I have set down for one of the causes of th dissolutions of commonwealths, their imperfect generation, consistin in the want of an absolute and arbitrary legislative power; for wan whereof the civil sovereign is fain to handle the sword of justic unconstantly, and as if it were too hot for him to hold. One reaso whereof, which I have not there mentioned, is this, that they will al of them justify the war, by which their power was at first gotten, an whereon, as they think, their right dependeth, and not on th possession. As if, for example, the right of the kings of England di depend on the goodness of the cause of William the Conqueror, and upo their lineal and directest descent from him; by which means there woul perhaps be no tie of the subjects' obedience to their sovereign at thi day in all the world: wherein, whilst they needlessly think to justif themselves, they justify all the successful rebellions that ambitio shall at any time raise against them and their successors. Therefore put down for one of the most effectual seeds of the death of any state that the conquerors require not only a submission of men's actions t them for the future, but also an approbation of all their actions past when there is scarce a commonwealth in the world, whose beginnings ca in conscience be justified."} +{"text":"And because the name of tyranny signifieth nothing more nor less tha the name of sovereignty, be it in one or many men, saving that the that use the former word are understood to be angry with them they cal tyrants; I think the toleration of a professed hatred of tyranny, is toleration of hatred to commonwealth in general, and another evil seed not differing much from the former. For to the justification of th cause of a conqueror the reproach of the cause of the conquered, is fo the most part necessary: but neither of them necessary for th obligation of the conquered. And thus much I have thought fit to sa upon the review of the first and second part of this discourse."} +{"text":"In Chapter XXXV, I have sufficiently declared out of the Scripture that in the commonwealth of the Jews, God himself was made th sovereign, by pact with the people; who were therefore called Hi \"peculiar people,\" to distinguish them from the rest of the world, ove whom God reigned not by their consent, but by His own power: and tha in this kingdom Moses was God's lieutenant on earth; and that it was h that told them what laws God appointed them to be ruled by. But I hav omitted to set down who were the officers appointed to do execution especially in capital punishments; not then thinking it a matter of s necessary consideration, as I find it since. We know that generally i all commonwealths, the execution of corporal punishments, was eithe put upon the guards, or other soldiers of the sovereign power; or give to those, in whom want of means, contempt of honour, and hardness o heart, concurred, to make them sue for such an office. But amongst th Israelites it was a positive law of God their sovereign, that he tha was convicted of a capital crime, should be stoned to death by th people; and that the witnesses should cast the first stone, and afte the witnesses, then the rest of the people. This was a law tha designed who were to be the executioners; but not that anyone shoul throw a stone at him before conviction and sentence, where th congregation was judge. The witnesses were nevertheless to be hear before they proceeded to execution, unless the fact were committed i the presence of the congregation itself, or in sight of the lawfu judges; for then there needed no other witnesses but the judge themselves. Nevertheless, this manner of proceeding being no thoroughly understood, hath given occasion to a dangerous opinion, tha any man may kill another, in some cases, by a right of zeal; as if th executions done upon offenders in the kingdom of God in old time proceeded not from the sovereign command, but from the authority o private zeal: which, if we consider the texts that seem to favour it is quite contrary."} +{"text":"First, where the Levites fell upon the people, that had made an worshipped the golden calf, and slew three thousand of them; it was b the commandment of Moses, from the mouth of God; as is manifest, Exod 32:27. And when the son of a woman of Israel had blasphemed God, the that heard it, did not kill him, but brought him before Moses, who pu him under custody, till God should give sentence against him; a appears, Levit. 24:11�-�12. Again (Numb. 25:6�-�7), when Phineha killed Zimri and Cosbi, it was not by right of private zeal: thei crime was committed in the sight of the assembly; there needed n witness; the law was known, and he the heir-apparent to th sovereignty; and, which is the principal point, the lawfulness of hi act depended wholly upon a subsequent ratification by Moses, whereof h had no cause to doubt. And this presumption of a future ratification is sometimes necessary to the safety of a commonwealth; as in a sudde rebellion, any man that can suppress it by his own power in the countr where it begins, without express law or commission, may lawfully do it and provide to have it ratified or pardoned, whilst it is in doing, o after it is done. Also (Numb. 35:30), it is expressly said, \"Whosoeve shall kill the murderer, shall kill him upon the word of witnesses\" but witnesses suppose a formal judicature, and consequently condem that pretence of jus zelotarum. The law of Moses concerning him tha enticeth to idolatry, that is to say, in the kingdom of God to renouncing of his allegiance (Deut. 13:8�-�9), forbids to conceal him and commands the accuser to cause him to be put to death, and to cas the first stone at him; but not to kill him before he be condemned. An (Deut. 17:4�-�7) the process against idolatry is exactly set down; fo God there speaketh to the people, as judge, and commandeth them, when man is accused of idolatry, to inquire diligently of the fact, an finding it true, then to stone him; but still the hand of the witnes throweth the first stone. This is not private zeal, but publi condemnation. In like manner, when a father hath a rebellious son, th law is (Deut. 21:18�-�21), that he shall bring him before the judges o the town, and all the people of the town shall stone him. Lastly, b pretence of these laws it was that St. Stephen was stoned, and not b pretence of private zeal: for before he was carried away to executio he had pleaded his cause before the high priest. There is nothing i all this, nor in any other part of the Bible, to countenance execution by private zeal; which being oftentimes but a conjunction of ignoranc and passion, is against both the justice and peace of a commonwealth."} +{"text":"In chapter XXXVI, I have said that it is not declared in what manne God spake supernaturally to Moses: nor that He spake not to hi sometimes by dreams and visions, and by a supernatural voice, as t other prophets: for the manner how He spake unto him from th mercy-seat, is expressly set down (Numb. 7:89) in these words: \"Fro that time forward, when Moses entered into the tabernacle of th congregation to speak with God, he heard a voice which spake unto hi from over the mercy-seat, which is over the ark of the testimony; fro between the cherubims He spake unto him.\" But it is not declared i what consisteth the preeminence of the manner of God's speaking t Moses, above that of His speaking to other prophets, as to Samuel an to Abraham, to whom He also spake by a voice (that is, by vision) unless the difference consist in the clearness of the vision. For \"fac to face,\" and \"mouth to mouth,\" cannot be literally understood of th infiniteness and incomprehensibility of the Divine nature."} +{"text":"And as to the whole doctrine, I see not yet, but the principles of i are true and proper, and the ratiocination solid. For I ground th civil right of sovereigns, and both the duty and liberty of subjects upon the known natural inclinations of mankind, and upon the article of the law of Nature; of which no man, that pretends but reason enoug to govern his private family, ought to be ignorant. And for the powe ecclesiastical of the same sovereigns, I ground it on such texts as ar both evident in themselves and consonant to the scope of the whol Scripture. And therefore am persuaded, that he that shall read it wit a purpose only to be informed, shall be informed by it. But for thos that by writing, or public discourse, or by their eminent actions, hav already engaged themselves to the maintaining of contrary opinions they will not be so easily satisfied. For in such cases, it is natura for men, at one and the same time, both to proceed in reading, and t lose their attention, in the search of objections to that they had rea before. Of which in a time wherein the interests of men are change (seeing much of that doctrine which serveth to the establishing of new government, must needs be contrary to that which conduced to th dissolution of the old), there cannot choose but be very many."} +{"text":"In that part which treateth of a Christian commonwealth there are som new doctrines which, it may be, in a state where the contrary wer already fully determined, were a fault for a subject without leave t divulge, as being an usurpation of the place of a teacher. But in thi time, that men call not only for peace, but also for truth, to offe such doctrines as I think true, and that manifestly tend to peace an loyalty, to the consideration of those that are yet in deliberation, i no more but to offer new wine to be put into new casks, that both ma be preserved together. And I suppose, that then, when novelty can bree no trouble nor disorder in a state, men are not generally so muc inclined to the reverence of antiquity, as to prefer ancient error before new and well-proved truth."} +{"text":"There is nothing I distrust more than my elocution, which nevertheles I am confident, excepting the mischances of the press, is not obscure That I have neglected the ornament of quoting ancient poets, orators and philosophers, contrary to the custom of late time, whether I hav done well or ill in it, proceedeth from my judgment, grounded on man reasons. For first, all truth of doctrine dependeth either upo \"reason\" or upon Scripture, both which give credit to many, but neve receive it from any writer. Secondly, the matters in question are no of \"fact,\" but of \"right,\" wherein there is no place for \"witnesses.\ There is scarce any of those old writers, that contradicteth no sometimes both himself and others; which makes their testimonie insufficient. Fourthly, such opinions as are taken only upon credit o antiquity, are not intrinsically the judgment of those that cite them but words that pass, like gaping, from mouth to mouth. Fifthly, it i many times with a fraudulent design that men stick their corrup doctrine with the cloves of other men's wit. Sixthly, I find not tha the ancients they cite took it for an ornament, to do the like wit those that wrote before them. Seventhly, it is an argument o indigestion, when Greek and Latin sentences unchewed come up again, a they use to do, unchanged. Lastly, though I reverence those men o ancient time, that either have written truth perspicuously, or set u in a better way to find it out ourselves: yet to the antiquity itself think nothing due. For if we will reverence the age, the present is th oldest. If the antiquity of the writer, I am not sure, that generall they to whom such honour is given, were more ancient when they wrot than I am that am writing. But if it be well considered, the praise o ancient authors proceeds not from the reverence of the dead, but fro the competition and mutual envy of the living."} +{"text":"To conclude, there is nothing in this whole discourse, nor in that writ before of the same subject in Latin, as far as I can perceive contrary either to the Word of God, or to good manners; or to th disturbance of the public tranquility. Therefore I think it may b profitably printed, and more profitably taught in the universities, i case they also think so, to whom the judgment of the same belongeth For seeing the universities are the fountains of civil and mora doctrine, from whence the preachers and the gentry, drawing such wate as they find, use to sprinkle the same (both from the pulpit and i their conversation) upon the people, there ought certainly to be grea care taken to have it pure, both from the venom of heathen politicians and from the incantation of deceiving spirits. And by that means th most men, knowing their duties, will be the less subject to serve th ambition of a few discontented persons in their purposes against th state, and be the less grieved with the contributions necessary fo their peace and defence; and the governors themselves have the les cause to maintain at the common charge any greater army than i necessary to make good the public liberty against the invasions an encroachments of foreign enemies."} +{"text":"And thus I have brought to an end my Discourse of Civil an Ecclesiastical Government, occasioned by the disorders of the presen time, without partiality, without application, and without other desig than to set before men's eyes the mutual relation between protectio and obedience; of which the condition of human nature and the law divine, both natural and positive, require an inviolable observation And though in the revolution of states there can be no very goo constellation for truths of this nature to be born under (as having a angry aspect from the dissolvers of an old government, and seeing bu the backs of them that erect a new), yet I cannot think it will b condemned at this time either by the public judge of doctrine, or b any that desires the continuance of public peace. And in this hope return to my interrupted speculation of bodies natural, wherein, if Go give me health to finish it, I hope the novelty will as much please, a in the doctrine of this artificial body it useth to offend. For suc truth as opposeth no man's profit nor pleasure is to all men welcome."}