{ "schema_version": 1, "updated_at": "2026-11-08T14:28:39.702386+00:00", "status": "pixel_only_complete", "scoring": "pixel-only", "mllm_enabled": false, "mllm_status": "not_requested", "api_calls_planned": 0, "full_evaluation_complete": false, "model_configuration_notices": { "joyai-image-edit-plus": "Official default bucket output,30steps,CFG4. Original source input without padding; omit width/height. Raw output is preserved. Pixel references/masks are mapped to the official output geometry. These pixel scores use a different resolution protocol from the other five models; report separately." }, "requested_scope_complete": true, "image_generation_complete": true, "pixel_complete": true, "models": [ "fibo2-edit-turbo", "joyai-image-edit-plus", "qwen-image21", "qwen-image21-turbo", "flux3-klein", "sensenova-u1.5-8b-mot" ], "cases_per_model": 200, "expected_images": 1200, "generated": 1200, "generation_errors": 0, "generation_pending": 0, "pixel_valid": 1200, "pixel_errors": 0, "pixel_pending": 0, "results": [ { "track": "text", "model": "fibo2-edit-turbo", "expected": 100, "status": "pixel_only_complete", "scoring": "pixel-only", "mllm_status": "not_requested", "mllm_executed": false, "full_evaluation_complete": false, "requested_scope_complete": true, "image_generation_complete": true, "pixel_complete": true, "generated": 100, "generation_errors": 0, "generation_pending": 0, "generation_coverage": 1.0, "generation_status": "complete", "generation_current": null, "pixel_valid": 100, "pixel_errors": 0, "pixel_pending": 0, "pixel_coverage": { "mse": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "psnr": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "ssim": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "lpips": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true } }, "metrics": { "mse": 63.72510300000001, "psnr": 32.614881, "ssim": 0.9887519747018814, "lpips": 0.009714508228935301 }, "progress_error": null, "validation_errors": [], "run_dir": "experiment/output/run3/text/fibo2-edit-turbo" }, { "track": "text", "model": "joyai-image-edit-plus", "expected": 100, "status": "pixel_only_complete", "scoring": "pixel-only", "mllm_status": "not_requested", "mllm_executed": false, "full_evaluation_complete": false, "requested_scope_complete": true, "image_generation_complete": true, "pixel_complete": true, "generated": 100, "generation_errors": 0, "generation_pending": 0, "generation_coverage": 1.0, "generation_status": "complete", "generation_current": null, "pixel_valid": 100, "pixel_errors": 0, "pixel_pending": 0, "pixel_coverage": { "mse": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "psnr": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "ssim": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "lpips": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true } }, "metrics": { "mse": 637.828666, "psnr": 23.2513, "ssim": 0.8378133726119995, "lpips": 0.056653072657063604 }, "progress_error": null, "validation_errors": [], "run_dir": "experiment/output/run3/text/joyai-image-edit-plus" }, { "track": "text", "model": "qwen-image21", "expected": 100, "status": "pixel_only_complete", "scoring": "pixel-only", "mllm_status": "not_requested", "mllm_executed": false, "full_evaluation_complete": false, "requested_scope_complete": true, "image_generation_complete": true, "pixel_complete": true, "generated": 100, "generation_errors": 0, "generation_pending": 0, "generation_coverage": 1.0, "generation_status": "complete", "generation_current": null, "pixel_valid": 100, "pixel_errors": 0, "pixel_pending": 0, "pixel_coverage": { "mse": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "psnr": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "ssim": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "lpips": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true } }, "metrics": { "mse": 563.82357, "psnr": 21.997068000000002, "ssim": 0.8156222856044769, "lpips": 0.05000474449247122 }, "progress_error": null, "validation_errors": [], "run_dir": "experiment/output/run3/text/qwen-image21" }, { "track": "text", "model": "qwen-image21-turbo", "expected": 100, "status": "pixel_only_complete", "scoring": "pixel-only", "mllm_status": "not_requested", "mllm_executed": false, "full_evaluation_complete": false, "requested_scope_complete": true, "image_generation_complete": true, "pixel_complete": true, "generated": 100, "generation_errors": 0, "generation_pending": 0, "generation_coverage": 1.0, "generation_status": "complete", "generation_current": null, "pixel_valid": 100, "pixel_errors": 0, "pixel_pending": 0, "pixel_coverage": { "mse": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "psnr": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "ssim": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "lpips": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true } }, "metrics": { "mse": 525.303749, "psnr": 22.352313, "ssim": 0.8266854047775268, "lpips": 0.04349691824987531 }, "progress_error": null, "validation_errors": [], "run_dir": "experiment/output/run3/text/qwen-image21-turbo" }, { "track": "text", "model": "flux3-klein", "expected": 100, "status": "pixel_only_complete", "scoring": "pixel-only", "mllm_status": "not_requested", "mllm_executed": false, "full_evaluation_complete": false, "requested_scope_complete": true, "image_generation_complete": true, "pixel_complete": true, "generated": 100, "generation_errors": 0, "generation_pending": 0, "generation_coverage": 1.0, "generation_status": "complete", "generation_current": null, "pixel_valid": 100, "pixel_errors": 0, "pixel_pending": 0, "pixel_coverage": { "mse": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "psnr": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "ssim": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "lpips": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true } }, "metrics": { "mse": 239.68090900000004, "psnr": 27.698175000000006, "ssim": 0.9418588787317276, "lpips": 0.0269296191399917 }, "progress_error": null, "validation_errors": [], "run_dir": "experiment/output/run3/text/flux3-klein" }, { "track": "text", "model": "sensenova-u1.5-8b-mot", "expected": 100, "status": "pixel_only_complete", "scoring": "pixel-only", "mllm_status": "not_requested", "mllm_executed": false, "full_evaluation_complete": false, "requested_scope_complete": true, "image_generation_complete": true, "pixel_complete": true, "generated": 100, "generation_errors": 0, "generation_pending": 0, "generation_coverage": 1.0, "generation_status": "complete", "generation_current": null, "pixel_valid": 100, "pixel_errors": 0, "pixel_pending": 0, "pixel_coverage": { "mse": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "psnr": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "ssim": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "lpips": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true } }, "metrics": { "mse": 236.01342200000002, "psnr": 25.889854999999997, "ssim": 0.9430283892154694, "lpips": 0.06245536979287863 }, "progress_error": null, "validation_errors": [], "run_dir": "experiment/output/run3/text/sensenova-u1.5-8b-mot" }, { "track": "assets", "model": "fibo2-edit-turbo", "expected": 100, "status": "pixel_only_complete", "scoring": "pixel-only", "mllm_status": "not_requested", "mllm_executed": false, "full_evaluation_complete": false, "requested_scope_complete": true, "image_generation_complete": true, "pixel_complete": true, "generated": 100, "generation_errors": 0, "generation_pending": 0, "generation_coverage": 1.0, "generation_status": "complete", "generation_current": null, "pixel_valid": 100, "pixel_errors": 0, "pixel_pending": 0, "pixel_coverage": { "mse": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "psnr": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "ssim": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "lpips": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true } }, "metrics": { "mse": 137.656984, "psnr": 30.427176999999993, "ssim": 0.9824707931280137, "lpips": 0.014146714485250414 }, "progress_error": null, "validation_errors": [], "run_dir": "experiment/output/run3/assets/fibo2-edit-turbo" }, { "track": "assets", "model": "joyai-image-edit-plus", "expected": 100, "status": "pixel_only_complete", "scoring": "pixel-only", "mllm_status": "not_requested", "mllm_executed": false, "full_evaluation_complete": false, "requested_scope_complete": true, "image_generation_complete": true, "pixel_complete": true, "generated": 100, "generation_errors": 0, "generation_pending": 0, "generation_coverage": 1.0, "generation_status": "complete", "generation_current": null, "pixel_valid": 100, "pixel_errors": 0, "pixel_pending": 0, "pixel_coverage": { "mse": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "psnr": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "ssim": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "lpips": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true } }, "metrics": { "mse": 899.8612939999999, "psnr": 21.741083, "ssim": 0.8341417843103409, "lpips": 0.06435771550051868 }, "progress_error": null, "validation_errors": [], "run_dir": "experiment/output/run3/assets/joyai-image-edit-plus" }, { "track": "assets", "model": "qwen-image21", "expected": 100, "status": "pixel_only_complete", "scoring": "pixel-only", "mllm_status": "not_requested", "mllm_executed": false, "full_evaluation_complete": false, "requested_scope_complete": true, "image_generation_complete": true, "pixel_complete": true, "generated": 100, "generation_errors": 0, "generation_pending": 0, "generation_coverage": 1.0, "generation_status": "complete", "generation_current": null, "pixel_valid": 100, "pixel_errors": 0, "pixel_pending": 0, "pixel_coverage": { "mse": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "psnr": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "ssim": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "lpips": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true } }, "metrics": { "mse": 534.1776450000001, "psnr": 22.309214, "ssim": 0.8343086391687393, "lpips": 0.04932361725717783 }, "progress_error": null, "validation_errors": [], "run_dir": "experiment/output/run3/assets/qwen-image21" }, { "track": "assets", "model": "qwen-image21-turbo", "expected": 100, "status": "pixel_only_complete", "scoring": "pixel-only", "mllm_status": "not_requested", "mllm_executed": false, "full_evaluation_complete": false, "requested_scope_complete": true, "image_generation_complete": true, "pixel_complete": true, "generated": 100, "generation_errors": 0, "generation_pending": 0, "generation_coverage": 1.0, "generation_status": "complete", "generation_current": null, "pixel_valid": 100, "pixel_errors": 0, "pixel_pending": 0, "pixel_coverage": { "mse": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "psnr": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "ssim": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "lpips": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true } }, "metrics": { "mse": 425.05327400000004, "psnr": 23.320222999999995, "ssim": 0.845193647146225, "lpips": 0.042895335722714666 }, "progress_error": null, "validation_errors": [], "run_dir": "experiment/output/run3/assets/qwen-image21-turbo" }, { "track": "assets", "model": "flux3-klein", "expected": 100, "status": "pixel_only_complete", "scoring": "pixel-only", "mllm_status": "not_requested", "mllm_executed": false, "full_evaluation_complete": false, "requested_scope_complete": true, "image_generation_complete": true, "pixel_complete": true, "generated": 100, "generation_errors": 0, "generation_pending": 0, "generation_coverage": 1.0, "generation_status": "complete", "generation_current": null, "pixel_valid": 100, "pixel_errors": 0, "pixel_pending": 0, "pixel_coverage": { "mse": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "psnr": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "ssim": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "lpips": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true } }, "metrics": { "mse": 228.00660699999997, "psnr": 28.060954000000002, "ssim": 0.9503952342271805, "lpips": 0.021453658305108547 }, "progress_error": null, "validation_errors": [], "run_dir": "experiment/output/run3/assets/flux3-klein" }, { "track": "assets", "model": "sensenova-u1.5-8b-mot", "expected": 100, "status": "pixel_only_complete", "scoring": "pixel-only", "mllm_status": "not_requested", "mllm_executed": false, "full_evaluation_complete": false, "requested_scope_complete": true, "image_generation_complete": true, "pixel_complete": true, "generated": 100, "generation_errors": 0, "generation_pending": 0, "generation_coverage": 1.0, "generation_status": "complete", "generation_current": null, "pixel_valid": 100, "pixel_errors": 0, "pixel_pending": 0, "pixel_coverage": { "mse": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "psnr": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "ssim": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true }, "lpips": { "expected": 100, "valid": 100, "failed": 0, "pending": 0, "coverage": 1.0, "complete": true, "validated_by_formal_report": true } }, "metrics": { "mse": 308.93107399999997, "psnr": 24.930902999999994, "ssim": 0.9300889307260514, "lpips": 0.06769868858158588 }, "progress_error": null, "validation_errors": [], "run_dir": "experiment/output/run3/assets/sensenova-u1.5-8b-mot" } ], "note": "This run generates images and evaluates pixel preservation only. MLLM judging was not requested or executed; semantic scores and joint qualification are unavailable. Completion refers only to all planned images and pixel metrics, never to full semantic benchmark evaluation." }