{ "status": "complete", "judge_model": "gemini-4-argon", "cases": 10, "models": [ "fibo2-edit-turbo", "qwen-image21", "qwen-image21-turbo", "flux3-klein", "sensenova-u1.5-8b-mot" ], "cases_per_model": 2, "case_ids": { "text": "315_replace", "assets": "asset_144_a02_move" }, "api_calls": 13, "full_benchmark_score": false, "input_policy": "Original full source and exact published native-ROI RGB prediction; no resize/compositing. One text and one asset task per model.", "inputs_unchanged": true, "results": [ { "model": "fibo2-edit-turbo", "track": "assets", "id": "asset_144_a02_move", "instruction": "Move the stretching woman in a purple top and orange trousers in the upper-right area slightly to the right.", "status": "scored", "api_calls": 1, "attempts": [ { "pass": 1, "exit_code": 0, "api_calls": 1 } ], "IF": 1, "IF_rationale": "The stretching woman did not move.", "OA": 3, "OA_rationale": "The woman remains intact at her original position.", "VC": 4, "VC_rationale": "Image quality and rendering remain clean.", "LP": 4, "LP_rationale": "All non-target elements and text are preserved.", "input_unchanged": true }, { "model": "fibo2-edit-turbo", "track": "text", "id": "315_replace", "instruction": "Replace 'Loss overview' with 'Loss summary'.", "status": "scored", "api_calls": 2, "attempts": [ { "pass": 1, "exit_code": 0, "api_calls": 2 } ], "IF": 3, "IF_rationale": "Target text replaced as requested.", "TA": 3, "TA_rationale": "Spelling and case match 'Loss summary'.", "VC": 3, "VC_rationale": "Font and background integration are clean.", "LP": 3, "LP_rationale": "Non-target elements remain unchanged.", "input_unchanged": true }, { "model": "qwen-image21", "track": "assets", "id": "asset_144_a02_move", "instruction": "Move the stretching woman in a purple top and orange trousers in the upper-right area slightly to the right.", "status": "scored", "api_calls": 3, "attempts": [ { "pass": 1, "exit_code": 0, "api_calls": 3 } ], "IF": 2, "IF_rationale": "Woman shifted slightly left and enlarged instead of moving right.", "OA": 3, "OA_rationale": "Target woman retained identity and parts with slight enlargement.", "VC": 4, "VC_rationale": "Clean edges and background repair around the woman.", "LP": 4, "LP_rationale": "All other text, figures, and cards remain intact.", "input_unchanged": true }, { "model": "qwen-image21", "track": "text", "id": "315_replace", "instruction": "Replace 'Loss overview' with 'Loss summary'.", "status": "scored", "api_calls": 1, "attempts": [ { "pass": 1, "exit_code": 0, "api_calls": 1 } ], "IF": 2, "IF_rationale": "Target text replaced with garbled characters instead of 'Loss summary'.", "TA": 2, "TA_rationale": "Replaced word is misspelled and illegible ('oummarv' instead of 'summary').", "VC": 2, "VC_rationale": "Target glyphs are malformed and partially clipped at the bottom.", "LP": 3, "LP_rationale": "Minor global text degradation changes numbers like +1.8 to +1.6.", "input_unchanged": true }, { "model": "qwen-image21-turbo", "track": "assets", "id": "asset_144_a02_move", "instruction": "Move the stretching woman in a purple top and orange trousers in the upper-right area slightly to the right.", "status": "scored", "api_calls": 1, "attempts": [ { "pass": 1, "exit_code": 0, "api_calls": 1 } ], "IF": 2, "IF_rationale": "The stretching woman moved slightly left instead of right.", "OA": 3, "OA_rationale": "Target woman retains identity and proportions.", "VC": 3, "VC_rationale": "Clean rendering and background integration.", "LP": 4, "LP_rationale": "All non-target elements and text remain intact.", "input_unchanged": true }, { "model": "qwen-image21-turbo", "track": "text", "id": "315_replace", "instruction": "Replace 'Loss overview' with 'Loss summary'.", "status": "scored", "api_calls": 1, "attempts": [ { "pass": 1, "exit_code": 0, "api_calls": 1 } ], "IF": 1, "IF_rationale": "The text 'Loss overview' was not replaced.", "TA": 1, "TA_rationale": "Target text remains 'Loss overview' instead of 'Loss summary'.", "VC": 4, "VC_rationale": "Unchanged target text remains legible with minor compression artifacts.", "LP": 2, "LP_rationale": "Many non-target text characters across the image are visibly garbled.", "input_unchanged": true }, { "model": "flux3-klein", "track": "assets", "id": "asset_144_a02_move", "instruction": "Move the stretching woman in a purple top and orange trousers in the upper-right area slightly to the right.", "status": "scored", "api_calls": 1, "attempts": [ { "pass": 1, "exit_code": 0, "api_calls": 1 } ], "IF": 2, "IF_rationale": "The stretching woman in the upper-right moved slightly left instead of right.", "OA": 3, "OA_rationale": "The woman retains her original identity, proportions, and attributes.", "VC": 3, "VC_rationale": "The moved figure integrates cleanly into the background without artifacts.", "LP": 3, "LP_rationale": "All surrounding text, panels, and other figures remain unchanged.", "input_unchanged": true }, { "model": "flux3-klein", "track": "text", "id": "315_replace", "instruction": "Replace 'Loss overview' with 'Loss summary'.", "status": "scored", "api_calls": 1, "attempts": [ { "pass": 1, "exit_code": 0, "api_calls": 1 } ], "IF": 3, "IF_rationale": "Replaced target text, but also overwrote 'NDR stats' above it.", "TA": 3, "TA_rationale": "Target wording 'Loss summary' is spelled accurately.", "VC": 3, "VC_rationale": "Target text is clean and legible.", "LP": 2, "LP_rationale": "Unrelated heading '(E) NDR stats' was replaced with 'Loss summary'.", "input_unchanged": true }, { "model": "sensenova-u1.5-8b-mot", "track": "assets", "id": "asset_144_a02_move", "instruction": "Move the stretching woman in a purple top and orange trousers in the upper-right area slightly to the right.", "status": "scored", "api_calls": 1, "attempts": [ { "pass": 1, "exit_code": 0, "api_calls": 1 } ], "IF": 3, "IF_rationale": "Target moved slightly right with minor horizontal compression.", "OA": 3, "OA_rationale": "Moved woman shows facial distortion and narrower proportions.", "VC": 3, "VC_rationale": "Background clean, but moved figure's face and hands warped.", "LP": 2, "LP_rationale": "Multiple unrelated text typos introduced across lower cards.", "input_unchanged": true }, { "model": "sensenova-u1.5-8b-mot", "track": "text", "id": "315_replace", "instruction": "Replace 'Loss overview' with 'Loss summary'.", "status": "scored", "api_calls": 1, "attempts": [ { "pass": 1, "exit_code": 0, "api_calls": 1 } ], "IF": 4, "IF_rationale": "Target text replaced accurately in the correct location.", "TA": 4, "TA_rationale": "Exact wording 'Loss summary' is present and correct.", "VC": 3, "VC_rationale": "Target text is legible with minor stroke softness.", "LP": 2, "LP_rationale": "Extensive text corruption and garbling across non-target regions.", "input_unchanged": true } ], "request_parameters": { "temperature": 0, "max_tokens": 500 }, "job_id": "12088", "completed_at": "2026-11-08T15:19:41.679973+00:00", "request_error_counts": { "API connection/timeout failure": 1, "Judge returned invalid JSON": 2 }, "returned_model_counts": { "gemini-4-argon": 10 } }