--- license: mit language: - en pretty_name: MemLoop SFT v5 — proactive callback data tags: - memory - agents - long-term-memory - longmemeval - multi-agent - feedback - sft size_categories: - 10K:` in its input, and every input ends with `Callback budget: N` (1 callback per agent, at most 3 per trajectory). Memory inputs are JSON; the feedback is a `feedback` field there. The answer agent's prompt asks for written-month dates in both `reasoning` and `answer` (ISO dates in those two fields were rewritten). ## Files | Path | Content | |---|---| | `sft/train.jsonl` | 40,320 training rows: `system`, `instruction`, `output`, `metadata` | | `sft/tokenized/` | The same rows tokenized for Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507 (`qwen3_nothink` template, LLaMA-Factory `tokenized_path`), with loss masking applied (`labels == -100`) | | `sft/reserve.jsonl` | Spare v3 rows used only to replace rows dropped for length (none were dropped) | | `sft/report.json` | Per-type counts, row counts by role and source, tokenization checks | | `trajectories/.jsonl.gz` | Raw callback trajectories, one file per generation run; each line is one trajectory (`steps`, per-call `calls` with inputs and responses, `construction` = what was deliberately broken) | | `question-pools/*.jsonl.gz` | Newly written questions (synthetic date / counting / listing / granularity questions; preference questions), each verified by an independent second call | | `quality/sft-v5.jsonl` | Four-check quality review of every callback trajectory | | `manifest.json` | Per run: error type, models, number of trajectories, skipped constructions, sha256 | ### Row metadata - `row_role`: `core`, `episodic`, `semantic`, `procedural` (memory banks), `retrieval`, `answer`. - `source`: `callback-decision` (the call that issued a callback), `callback-redo` (calls after receiving feedback), `hard-negative` (a trap was present, no callback, final answer correct), `v3` (earlier SFT rows converted to this format with `revisit_agent: none`). - `error_type`: 1–16 (below); `run` and `trajectory` point into `trajectories/`. - `loss_from_char`: for `callback-decision` rows, loss starts at this character of `output` (the callback fields). The flawed first output stays visible but is not trained. Other rows are trained on the full output. ## Composition | Role | Rows | Share | |---|---|---| | retrieval | 20,644 | 51.2% | | answer | 9,636 | 23.9% | | memory (core / episodic / semantic / procedural) | 10,040 (2,970 / 2,372 / 2,291 / 2,407) | 24.9% | Sources: callback-decision 4,384, callback-redo 12,313, hard-negative 4,101, v3 19,522. Trained tokens: 7,113,495; longest row 14,568 tokens. ### 16 error types (callback trajectories used, target 300 each) | # | Error type | Stage | Passed rules | Passed review | Used | Hard negatives | |---|---|---|---|---|---|---| | 1 | Memory gap (a session's fact never written) | memory | 810 | 710 | 300 | 115 | | 2 | Value dropped (vague entry, value missing) | memory | 404 | 295 | 295 | 150 | | 3 | Wrong fact in memory (incl. two conflicting values) | memory | 548 | 511 | 300 | 150 | | 4 | Memory self-review with a checklist | memory | 418 | (rule 4) | 280 | 150 | | 5 | Wording mismatch (question words don't retrieve the entry) | memory/retrieval | 233 | 151 | **142** | 150 | | 6 | Stale Core (Core holds an older value) | retrieval/answer | 1,011 | 885 | 300 | 150 | | 7 | Retrieval gap (search stopped too early) | retrieval | 403 | 353 | 300 | 150 | | 8 | Evidence dropped | retrieval | 758 | 719 | 300 | 103 | | 9 | Distractor ranked first | answer | 906 | 772 | 300 | 150 | | 10 | Distractor vs. Core | answer | 788 | 672 | 300 | 150 | | 11 | Wrong granularity (city vs. state) | answer | 26 | 19 | **19** | 150 | | 12 | Date arithmetic / temporal reasoning | answer | 440 | 379 | 300 | 150 | | 13 | Counting | answer | 226 | 171 | **132** | 150 | | 14 | Listing | answer | 501 | 442 | 300 | 150 | | 15 | Unanswerable (false premise) | answer | 404 | 259 | 259 | 9 | | 16 | Preference / advice | answer | 552 | 479 | 300 | 150 | Types 5, 11 and 13 ran out of source questions and stay below 300. ## How it was generated - **Memory**: teacher memory written by Claude Sonnet 4.5 over the LongMemEval SFT split (50 histories), then deliberately broken per error type (drop or change a value, add a distractor entry, move the true fact to Core, add an older value to Core, …) or left intact with a newly written question. - **Agents**: DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash and GLM-5.3-Flash (self-hosted) as retrieval and answer agents. DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash also writes and redoes memory and judges correctness. When an agent fails without calling back, the teacher writes the feedback the agent should have written from the reference answer ("hindsight feedback"), restricted to what that agent could see; the agent then redoes the step. Some types resample the first answer or retrieval at temperature 1.0 to find a natural mistake. - **Filtering**: rule-based filters (callback executed, clean format, final answer correct, memory rewrite verified, feedback does not leak the answer or talk about format, dedup), then a DeepSeek review of every callback trajectory on four checks: cause correct, specific, uses no hidden information, redo follows the feedback. Pass rate on all four checks: 84% for DeepSeek-agent trajectories, 82% for GLM-agent trajectories. ## Source and license Conversations and questions come from LongMemEval ([xiaowu0162/longmemeval-cleaned](https://huggingface.co/datasets/xiaowu0162/longmemeval-cleaned), MIT). This dataset is released under the MIT license.