diff --git "a/validation/meta_reference.json" "b/validation/meta_reference.json" deleted file mode 100644--- "a/validation/meta_reference.json" +++ /dev/null @@ -1,9200 +0,0 @@ -[ - { - "unit_id": "MA-001", - "review_pmid": "41507873", - "result_file": "41507873_Alzheimer.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 23, - "source_figure": "Figure 3", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-001", - "review_pmid": "41507873", - "result_file": "41507873_Alzheimer.csv", - "outcome": "Alzheimer", - "analysis_type": "dichotomous", - "effect_measure": "OR", - "pooled_effect": "0.86", - "ci_lower": "0.77", - "ci_upper": "0.94", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "67.4", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "0.86", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 23, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "0.77", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 23, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "0.94", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 23, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "67.4", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 23, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "unit_id": "MA-001", - "effect_measure": "OR", - "model": "DerSimonian-Laird random effects (DL)", - "pooled_effect": "0.86", - "ci_lower": "0.77", - "ci_upper": "0.94", - "i2": "67.4", - "tau2": null, - "heterogeneity_p": "0.046", - "overall_effect_p": null, - "source_page": 23, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "tau2_status": "not_reported", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported", - "overall_effect_p_status": "not_reported", - "field_provenance": { - "effect_measure": { - "page": 23, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "model": { - "page": 23, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "pooled_effect": { - "page": 23, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_lower": { - "page": 23, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_upper": { - "page": 23, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "i2": { - "page": 23, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "heterogeneity_p": { - "page": 23, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "notes": "All three study OR/CI triplets and years match Figure 3. Plot pooled 0.86 [0.77,0.94] is compatible with prose/current target 0.856 [0.769,0.943]; changes are precision alignment to the plot, not substantive numerical errors." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-002", - "review_pmid": "41507873", - "result_file": "41507873_Depression.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 23, - "source_figure": "Figure 4", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-002", - "review_pmid": "41507873", - "result_file": "41507873_Depression.csv", - "outcome": "Depression", - "analysis_type": "dichotomous", - "effect_measure": "OR", - "pooled_effect": "0.72", - "ci_lower": "0.55", - "ci_upper": "0.90", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "98.2", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "0.72", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 23, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "0.55", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 23, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "0.90", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 23, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "98.2", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 23, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "unit_id": "MA-002", - "effect_measure": "OR", - "model": "DerSimonian-Laird random effects (DL)", - "pooled_effect": "0.72", - "ci_lower": "0.55", - "ci_upper": "0.90", - "i2": "98.2", - "tau2": null, - "heterogeneity_p": "<0.001", - "overall_effect_p": null, - "source_page": 23, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "tau2_status": "not_reported", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported", - "overall_effect_p_status": "not_reported", - "field_provenance": { - "effect_measure": { - "page": 23, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "model": { - "page": 23, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "pooled_effect": { - "page": 23, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_lower": { - "page": 23, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_upper": { - "page": 23, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "i2": { - "page": 23, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "heterogeneity_p": { - "page": 23, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "notes": "All three study OR/CI triplets and years match Figure 4. N values 249405,249405,2424 match Table 2 pp17-18. Plot pooled 0.72 [0.55,0.90] is compatible with prose/current 0.724 [0.549,0.900]; precision alignment only. Substantive source conflict: Figure 4 overall I2 is 98.2%; same-page prose says 99.5%. Select 98.2 under forest-source precedence and retain both as a documented source discrepancy." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-003", - "review_pmid": "41617837", - "result_file": "41617837_Anxiety.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 10, - "source_figure": "Figure 4: Anxiety", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-003", - "review_pmid": "41617837", - "result_file": "41617837_Anxiety.csv", - "outcome": "Anxiety", - "analysis_type": "dichotomous", - "effect_measure": "RR", - "pooled_effect": "1.14", - "ci_lower": "0.85", - "ci_upper": "1.53", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "40", - "tau2": "0.03" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "1.14", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 4: Anxiety", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "0.85", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 4: Anxiety", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "1.53", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 4: Anxiety", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "40", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 4: Anxiety", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "0.03", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 4: Anxiety", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "RR", - "model": "Hartung-Knapp-Sidik-Jonkman random-effects (stated in p9 Discussion)", - "pooled_effect": "1.14", - "ci_lower": "0.85", - "ci_upper": "1.53", - "i2": "40", - "tau2": "0.03", - "tau2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": null, - "heterogeneity_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": null, - "overall_effect_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Discussion" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 4: Anxiety" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 4: Anxiety" - }, - "tau2_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 4: Anxiety" - } - }, - "notes": "All study RR/CI cells and geographical settings match; study years embedded in Study labels also match. Duplicate Niu 2023 and da Silva 2020 rows, when present, were mapped by displayed order and effect values, not deduplicated. Model comes from p9 Discussion; the forest plot does not print a model caption." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-004", - "review_pmid": "41617837", - "result_file": "41617837_CompositeMentalIllnesses.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 10, - "source_figure": "Figure 4: Composite mental health illnesses", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-004", - "review_pmid": "41617837", - "result_file": "41617837_CompositeMentalIllnesses.csv", - "outcome": "CompositeMentalIllnesses", - "analysis_type": "dichotomous", - "effect_measure": "RR", - "pooled_effect": "1.12", - "ci_lower": "1.06", - "ci_upper": "1.18", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "83", - "tau2": "0.01" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "1.12", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 4: Composite mental health illnesses", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "1.06", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 4: Composite mental health illnesses", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "1.18", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 4: Composite mental health illnesses", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "83", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 4: Composite mental health illnesses", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "0.01", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 4: Composite mental health illnesses", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "RR", - "model": "Hartung-Knapp-Sidik-Jonkman random-effects (stated in p9 Discussion)", - "pooled_effect": "1.12", - "ci_lower": "1.06", - "ci_upper": "1.18", - "i2": "83", - "tau2": "0.01", - "tau2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": null, - "heterogeneity_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": null, - "overall_effect_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Discussion" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 4: Composite mental health illnesses" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 4: Composite mental health illnesses" - }, - "tau2_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 4: Composite mental health illnesses" - } - }, - "notes": "All study RR/CI cells and geographical settings match; study years embedded in Study labels also match. Duplicate Niu 2023 and da Silva 2020 rows, when present, were mapped by displayed order and effect values, not deduplicated. Model comes from p9 Discussion; the forest plot does not print a model caption." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-005", - "review_pmid": "41617837", - "result_file": "41617837_Depression.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 10, - "source_figure": "Figure 4: Depression", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-005", - "review_pmid": "41617837", - "result_file": "41617837_Depression.csv", - "outcome": "Depression", - "analysis_type": "dichotomous", - "effect_measure": "RR", - "pooled_effect": "1.18", - "ci_lower": "1.03", - "ci_upper": "1.34", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "63", - "tau2": "0.01" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "1.18", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 4: Depression", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "1.03", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 4: Depression", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "1.34", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 4: Depression", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "63", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 4: Depression", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "0.01", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 4: Depression", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "RR", - "model": "Hartung-Knapp-Sidik-Jonkman random-effects (stated in p9 Discussion)", - "pooled_effect": "1.18", - "ci_lower": "1.03", - "ci_upper": "1.34", - "i2": "63", - "tau2": "0.01", - "tau2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": null, - "heterogeneity_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": null, - "overall_effect_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Discussion" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 4: Depression" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 4: Depression" - }, - "tau2_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 4: Depression" - } - }, - "notes": "All study RR/CI cells and geographical settings match; study years embedded in Study labels also match. Duplicate Niu 2023 and da Silva 2020 rows, when present, were mapped by displayed order and effect values, not deduplicated. Model comes from p9 Discussion; the forest plot does not print a model caption." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-006", - "review_pmid": "41617837", - "result_file": "41617837_MentalHealthDisorders.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 9, - "source_figure": "Figure 3", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-006", - "review_pmid": "41617837", - "result_file": "41617837_MentalHealthDisorders.csv", - "outcome": "MentalHealthDisorders", - "analysis_type": "dichotomous", - "effect_measure": "RR", - "pooled_effect": "1.13", - "ci_lower": "1.08", - "ci_upper": "1.19", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "68", - "tau2": "0.00" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "1.13", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "1.08", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "1.19", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "68", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "0.00", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "RR", - "model": "Hartung-Knapp-Sidik-Jonkman random-effects (stated in p9 Discussion)", - "pooled_effect": "1.13", - "ci_lower": "1.08", - "ci_upper": "1.19", - "i2": "68", - "tau2": "0.00", - "tau2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": null, - "heterogeneity_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": null, - "overall_effect_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Discussion" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Figure 3" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Figure 3" - }, - "tau2_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Figure 3" - } - }, - "notes": "All study RR/CI cells and geographical settings match; study years embedded in Study labels also match. Duplicate Niu 2023 and da Silva 2020 rows, when present, were mapped by displayed order and effect values, not deduplicated. Model comes from p9 Discussion; the forest plot does not print a model caption." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-007", - "review_pmid": "41617837", - "result_file": "41617837_SchizophreniaPsychoticDisorders.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 10, - "source_figure": "Figure 4: Schizophrenia or psychotic disorders", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-007", - "review_pmid": "41617837", - "result_file": "41617837_SchizophreniaPsychoticDisorders.csv", - "outcome": "SchizophreniaPsychoticDisorders", - "analysis_type": "dichotomous", - "effect_measure": "RR", - "pooled_effect": "1.14", - "ci_lower": "1.01", - "ci_upper": "1.28", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "76", - "tau2": "0.01" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "1.14", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 4: Schizophrenia or psychotic disorders", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "1.01", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 4: Schizophrenia or psychotic disorders", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "1.28", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 4: Schizophrenia or psychotic disorders", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "76", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 4: Schizophrenia or psychotic disorders", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "0.01", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 4: Schizophrenia or psychotic disorders", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "RR", - "model": "Hartung-Knapp-Sidik-Jonkman random-effects (stated in p9 Discussion)", - "pooled_effect": "1.14", - "ci_lower": "1.01", - "ci_upper": "1.28", - "i2": "76", - "tau2": "0.01", - "tau2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": null, - "heterogeneity_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": null, - "overall_effect_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Discussion" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 4: Schizophrenia or psychotic disorders" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 4: Schizophrenia or psychotic disorders" - }, - "tau2_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 4: Schizophrenia or psychotic disorders" - } - }, - "notes": "All study RR/CI cells and geographical settings match; study years embedded in Study labels also match. Duplicate Niu 2023 and da Silva 2020 rows, when present, were mapped by displayed order and effect values, not deduplicated. Model comes from p9 Discussion; the forest plot does not print a model caption." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-008", - "review_pmid": "41617837", - "result_file": "41617837_Suicide.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 10, - "source_figure": "Figure 4: Suicide", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-008", - "review_pmid": "41617837", - "result_file": "41617837_Suicide.csv", - "outcome": "Suicide", - "analysis_type": "dichotomous", - "effect_measure": "RR", - "pooled_effect": "1.01", - "ci_lower": "1.01", - "ci_upper": "1.02", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "83", - "tau2": "0.00" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "1.01", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 4: Suicide", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "1.01", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 4: Suicide", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "1.02", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 4: Suicide", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "83", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 4: Suicide", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "0.00", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 4: Suicide", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "RR", - "model": "Hartung-Knapp-Sidik-Jonkman random-effects (stated in p9 Discussion)", - "pooled_effect": "1.01", - "ci_lower": "1.01", - "ci_upper": "1.02", - "i2": "83", - "tau2": "0.00", - "tau2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": null, - "heterogeneity_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": null, - "overall_effect_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Discussion" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 4: Suicide" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 4: Suicide" - }, - "tau2_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 4: Suicide" - } - }, - "notes": "All study RR/CI cells and geographical settings match; study years embedded in Study labels also match. Duplicate Niu 2023 and da Silva 2020 rows, when present, were mapped by displayed order and effect values, not deduplicated. Model comes from p9 Discussion; the forest plot does not print a model caption." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-009", - "review_pmid": "41639651", - "result_file": "41639651_DBP.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 6, - "source_figure": "Figure 2B", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-009", - "review_pmid": "41639651", - "result_file": "41639651_DBP.csv", - "outcome": "DBP", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "beta", - "pooled_effect": "0.38", - "ci_lower": "-0.18", - "ci_upper": "0.94", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "99.7", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "0.38", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 6, - "figure": "Figure 2B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-0.18", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 6, - "figure": "Figure 2B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "0.94", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 6, - "figure": "Figure 2B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "99.7", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 6, - "figure": "Figure 2B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "beta (mmHg per 10 micrograms/m3 PM2.5)", - "model": "Random effects", - "pooled_effect": "0.38", - "ci_lower": "-0.18", - "ci_upper": "0.94", - "i2": "99.7", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": null, - "overall_effect_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 6, - "source": "Figure 2B" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 6, - "source": "Figure 2B" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 6, - "source": "Figure 2B" - }, - "tau2_source": null - }, - "notes": "All 10 study effect/CI rows and forest year labels match numerically. Tau-squared is not reported in the main figure or main-PDF text. Source table has year discrepancies (Wu 2013 vs forest Wu 2012; Guo 2023 vs forest Guo 2022) and Baccarelli SBP -1.01 vs forest -0.01; the extraction correctly follows the forest." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-010", - "review_pmid": "41639651", - "result_file": "41639651_SBP.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 6, - "source_figure": "Figure 2A", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-010", - "review_pmid": "41639651", - "result_file": "41639651_SBP.csv", - "outcome": "SBP", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "beta", - "pooled_effect": "1.13", - "ci_lower": "0.08", - "ci_upper": "2.19", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "99.6", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "1.13", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 6, - "figure": "Figure 2A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "0.08", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 6, - "figure": "Figure 2A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "2.19", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 6, - "figure": "Figure 2A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "99.6", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 6, - "figure": "Figure 2A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "beta (mmHg per 10 micrograms/m3 PM2.5)", - "model": "Random effects", - "pooled_effect": "1.13", - "ci_lower": "0.08", - "ci_upper": "2.19", - "i2": "99.6", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": null, - "overall_effect_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 6, - "source": "Figure 2A" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 6, - "source": "Figure 2A" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 6, - "source": "Figure 2A" - }, - "tau2_source": null - }, - "notes": "All 10 study effect/CI rows and forest year labels match numerically. Tau-squared is not reported in the main figure or main-PDF text. Source table has year discrepancies (Wu 2013 vs forest Wu 2012; Guo 2023 vs forest Guo 2022) and Baccarelli SBP -1.01 vs forest -0.01; the extraction correctly follows the forest. All 10 Sample Size values match Table 1 (p5), with comma separators normalized; they are study characteristics, not printed forest data. Ren 2019 upper CI displays -0.00 in the forest and 0.00 in Table 1; signed-zero display correction is recorded separately." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-011", - "review_pmid": "41566983", - "result_file": "41566983_InfectionLongTerm.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 7, - "source_figure": "Figure 2B", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-011", - "review_pmid": "41566983", - "result_file": "41566983_InfectionLongTerm.csv", - "outcome": "InfectionLongTerm", - "analysis_type": "dichotomous", - "effect_measure": "RR", - "pooled_effect": "1.41", - "ci_lower": "1.28", - "ci_upper": "1.56", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "99.27", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "1.41", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "1.28", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "1.56", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "99.27", - "status": "verified_nonforest", - "source": { - "page": 4, - "figure": "Results: corresponding PM2.5 association", - "source_type": "nonforest_text" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "unit_id": "MA-011", - "effect_measure": "RR", - "model": "Random effects (RE model)", - "pooled_effect": "1.41", - "ci_lower": "1.28", - "ci_upper": "1.56", - "i2": "99.27", - "tau2": null, - "heterogeneity_p": null, - "overall_effect_p": "<0.001", - "source_page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2B", - "tau2_status": "not_reported", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "not_reported", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported", - "field_provenance": { - "effect_measure": { - "page": 4, - "figure": "Results: corresponding PM2.5 association", - "source_type": "nonforest_text" - }, - "model": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "pooled_effect": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_lower": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_upper": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "i2": { - "page": 4, - "figure": "Results: corresponding PM2.5 association", - "source_type": "nonforest_text" - }, - "overall_effect_p": { - "page": 4, - "figure": "Results: corresponding PM2.5 association", - "source_type": "nonforest_text" - } - } - }, - "notes": "All five effect/CI triplets and years match Figure 2B. First three Jiang 2020 rows map in order to Wuhan, XiaoGan, Huanggang; these location disambiguators are not represented in the current CSV schema. Figure labels Wu 2020, while Table 1 p5 says Wu 2021. Retain figure year. Do not reinterpret unusually large or small estimates: these are the published forest values. Plot uses generic Estimate/Effect size; results p4 identifies the pooled measure as RR and provides I2=99.27%; tau2 not reported." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-012", - "review_pmid": "41566983", - "result_file": "41566983_InfectionShortTerm.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 7, - "source_figure": "Figure 2A", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-012", - "review_pmid": "41566983", - "result_file": "41566983_InfectionShortTerm.csv", - "outcome": "InfectionShortTerm", - "analysis_type": "dichotomous", - "effect_measure": "RR", - "pooled_effect": "1.12", - "ci_lower": "1.07", - "ci_upper": "1.18", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "76.49", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "1.12", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "1.07", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "1.18", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "76.49", - "status": "verified_nonforest", - "source": { - "page": 4, - "figure": "Results: corresponding PM2.5 association", - "source_type": "nonforest_text" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "unit_id": "MA-012", - "effect_measure": "RR", - "model": "Random effects (RE model)", - "pooled_effect": "1.12", - "ci_lower": "1.07", - "ci_upper": "1.18", - "i2": "76.49", - "tau2": null, - "heterogeneity_p": null, - "overall_effect_p": "<0.001", - "source_page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2A", - "tau2_status": "not_reported", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "not_reported", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported", - "field_provenance": { - "effect_measure": { - "page": 4, - "figure": "Results: corresponding PM2.5 association", - "source_type": "nonforest_text" - }, - "model": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "pooled_effect": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_lower": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_upper": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "i2": { - "page": 4, - "figure": "Results: corresponding PM2.5 association", - "source_type": "nonforest_text" - }, - "overall_effect_p": { - "page": 4, - "figure": "Results: corresponding PM2.5 association", - "source_type": "nonforest_text" - } - } - }, - "notes": "All 16 effect/CI triplets and years match Figure 2A. All Location labels verified against plot and Table 1 pp5-6 (including numeric city/state counts). Figure labels Singh 2021, while Table 1 p5 says Singh 2022. Retain figure year. Plot uses generic Estimate/Effect size; results p4 identifies pooled RR and I2=76.49%; tau2 not reported." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-013", - "review_pmid": "41566983", - "result_file": "41566983_MortalityShortTerm.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 8, - "source_figure": "Figure 3", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-013", - "review_pmid": "41566983", - "result_file": "41566983_MortalityShortTerm.csv", - "outcome": "MortalityShortTerm", - "analysis_type": "dichotomous", - "effect_measure": "RR", - "pooled_effect": "1.37", - "ci_lower": "0.80", - "ci_upper": "2.33", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "1.37", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "0.80", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "2.33", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "supplemental_reported_value": "89.72", - "supplemental_source": { - "page": 4, - "figure": "Results: corresponding PM2.5 association", - "source_type": "nonforest_text" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "unit_id": "MA-013", - "effect_measure": "RR", - "model": "Random effects (RE model)", - "pooled_effect": "1.37", - "ci_lower": "0.80", - "ci_upper": "2.33", - "i2": "89.72", - "tau2": null, - "heterogeneity_p": null, - "overall_effect_p": null, - "source_page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "tau2_status": "not_reported", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "not_reported", - "overall_effect_p_status": "not_reported", - "field_provenance": { - "effect_measure": { - "page": 4, - "figure": "Results: corresponding PM2.5 association", - "source_type": "nonforest_text" - }, - "model": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "pooled_effect": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_lower": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_upper": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "i2": { - "page": 4, - "figure": "Results: corresponding PM2.5 association", - "source_type": "nonforest_text" - } - } - }, - "notes": "All five effect/CI triplets and years match Figure 3. Locations verified against plot and Table 1 p5. Figure labels Singh 2021 while Table 1 p5 says 2022; retain forest year. I2=89.72% is explicitly reported in Results p4, but missing from target; it is not printed inside Figure 3. RR measure also confirmed in Results p4. Tau2 and numerical overall-effect p are not reported." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-014", - "review_pmid": "41835126", - "result_file": "41835126_HRISymptoms.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 7, - "source_figure": "Figure 2", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-014", - "review_pmid": "41835126", - "result_file": "41835126_HRISymptoms.csv", - "outcome": "HRISymptoms", - "analysis_type": "proportion", - "effect_measure": "Proportion", - "pooled_effect": "0.40", - "ci_lower": "0.24", - "ci_upper": "0.58", - "direction": "not_applicable", - "i2": "98.7", - "tau2": "1.2602" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "0.40", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "0.24", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "0.58", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "98.7", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "1.2602", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "Proportion", - "model": "random effects (logit-scale prevalence)", - "pooled_effect": "0.40", - "ci_lower": "0.24", - "ci_upper": "0.58", - "i2": "98.7", - "tau2": "1.2602", - "tau2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "<0.0001", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_p": null, - "overall_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "notes": "All 12 study rows verified in Figure 2. Sample Size is from Table 2 and is intentionally distinct from forest Total for rows 1 (165 vs 569), 10 (90 vs 168), and 12 (61 vs 1165). Both columns match their respective published sources; do not overwrite one using the other. Forest also shows common-effect overall proportion 0.35 [0.33,0.36], total 4430. Benchmark correctly selects random-effects 0.40 [0.24,0.58]. Single-group prevalence has no treatment/control comparator; direction is not_applicable and is excluded from treatment-effect direction scoring." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-015", - "review_pmid": "41970007", - "result_file": "41970007_DBP.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 27, - "source_figure": "Supplementary Figure S16, subgroup 2.2.2", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-015", - "review_pmid": "41970007", - "result_file": "41970007_DBP.csv", - "outcome": "DBP", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "SMD", - "pooled_effect": "0.04", - "ci_lower": "-0.12", - "ci_upper": "0.20", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "0.04", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 27, - "figure": "Supplementary Figure S16, subgroup 2.2.2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-0.12", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 27, - "figure": "Supplementary Figure S16, subgroup 2.2.2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "0.20", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 27, - "figure": "Supplementary Figure S16, subgroup 2.2.2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 27, - "figure": "Supplementary Figure S16, subgroup 2.2.2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "unit_id": "MA-015", - "source_page": 27, - "source_figure": "Supplementary Figure S16, subgroup 2.2.2", - "source_effect_measure": "SMD", - "model": "fixed_effects", - "pooled_effect": "0.04", - "ci_lower": "-0.12", - "ci_upper": "0.20", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": null, - "p_overall": "0.64", - "p_heterogeneity": "0.63", - "q": "5.27", - "df": "7", - "z": "0.46", - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "notes": "" - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-016", - "review_pmid": "41970007", - "result_file": "41970007_Ozone.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 9, - "source_figure": "Figure 3, subgroup 1.7.4", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-016", - "review_pmid": "41970007", - "result_file": "41970007_Ozone.csv", - "outcome": "Ozone", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "-0.66", - "ci_lower": "-2.52", - "ci_upper": "1.20", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "58", - "tau2": "1.17" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-0.66", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3, subgroup 1.7.4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-2.52", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3, subgroup 1.7.4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "1.20", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3, subgroup 1.7.4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "58", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3, subgroup 1.7.4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "1.17", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3, subgroup 1.7.4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "unit_id": "MA-016", - "source_page": 9, - "source_figure": "Figure 3, subgroup 1.7.4", - "source_effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "random_effects", - "pooled_effect": "-0.66", - "ci_lower": "-2.52", - "ci_upper": "1.20", - "i2": "58", - "tau2": "1.17", - "p_overall": "0.49", - "p_heterogeneity": "0.12", - "q": "2.38", - "df": "1", - "z": "0.70", - "tau2_status": "reported" - }, - "notes": "" - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-017", - "review_pmid": "41970007", - "result_file": "41970007_PM1.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 9, - "source_figure": "Figure 3, subgroup 1.7.1", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-017", - "review_pmid": "41970007", - "result_file": "41970007_PM1.csv", - "outcome": "PM1", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "-18.27", - "ci_lower": "-21.50", - "ci_upper": "-15.04", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "63", - "tau2": "5.81" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-18.27", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3, subgroup 1.7.1", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-21.50", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3, subgroup 1.7.1", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "-15.04", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3, subgroup 1.7.1", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "63", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3, subgroup 1.7.1", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "5.81", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3, subgroup 1.7.1", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "unit_id": "MA-017", - "source_page": 9, - "source_figure": "Figure 3, subgroup 1.7.1", - "source_effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "random_effects", - "pooled_effect": "-18.27", - "ci_lower": "-21.50", - "ci_upper": "-15.04", - "i2": "63", - "tau2": "5.81", - "p_overall": "<0.00001", - "p_heterogeneity": "0.04", - "q": "8.16", - "df": "3", - "z": "11.08", - "tau2_status": "reported" - }, - "notes": "" - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-018", - "review_pmid": "41970007", - "result_file": "41970007_PM10.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 9, - "source_figure": "Figure 3, subgroup 1.7.3", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-018", - "review_pmid": "41970007", - "result_file": "41970007_PM10.csv", - "outcome": "PM10", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "-38.14", - "ci_lower": "-51.56", - "ci_upper": "-24.73", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "89", - "tau2": "124.69" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-38.14", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3, subgroup 1.7.3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-51.56", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3, subgroup 1.7.3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "-24.73", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3, subgroup 1.7.3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "89", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3, subgroup 1.7.3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "124.69", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3, subgroup 1.7.3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "unit_id": "MA-018", - "source_page": 9, - "source_figure": "Figure 3, subgroup 1.7.3", - "source_effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "random_effects", - "pooled_effect": "-38.14", - "ci_lower": "-51.56", - "ci_upper": "-24.73", - "i2": "89", - "tau2": "124.69", - "p_overall": "<0.00001", - "p_heterogeneity": "<0.00001", - "q": "26.75", - "df": "3", - "z": "5.57", - "tau2_status": "reported" - }, - "notes": "" - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-019", - "review_pmid": "41970007", - "result_file": "41970007_PM25.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 9, - "source_figure": "Figure 3, subgroup 1.7.2", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-019", - "review_pmid": "41970007", - "result_file": "41970007_PM25.csv", - "outcome": "PM25", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "-24.49", - "ci_lower": "-32.06", - "ci_upper": "-16.93", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "97", - "tau2": "148.61" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-24.49", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3, subgroup 1.7.2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-32.06", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3, subgroup 1.7.2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "-16.93", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3, subgroup 1.7.2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "97", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3, subgroup 1.7.2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "148.61", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3, subgroup 1.7.2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "unit_id": "MA-019", - "source_page": 9, - "source_figure": "Figure 3, subgroup 1.7.2", - "source_effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "random_effects", - "pooled_effect": "-24.49", - "ci_lower": "-32.06", - "ci_upper": "-16.93", - "i2": "97", - "tau2": "148.61", - "p_overall": "<0.00001", - "p_heterogeneity": "<0.00001", - "q": "329.96", - "df": "10", - "z": "6.35", - "tau2_status": "reported" - }, - "notes": "" - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-020", - "review_pmid": "41970007", - "result_file": "41970007_RespiratorySymptoms.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 9, - "source_figure": "Figure 2", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-020", - "review_pmid": "41970007", - "result_file": "41970007_RespiratorySymptoms.csv", - "outcome": "RespiratorySymptoms", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "SMD", - "pooled_effect": "-0.18", - "ci_lower": "-0.45", - "ci_upper": "0.09", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "60", - "tau2": "0.10" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-0.18", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-0.45", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "0.09", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "60", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "0.10", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "unit_id": "MA-020", - "source_page": 9, - "source_figure": "Figure 2", - "source_effect_measure": "SMD", - "model": "random_effects", - "pooled_effect": "-0.18", - "ci_lower": "-0.45", - "ci_upper": "0.09", - "i2": "60", - "tau2": "0.10", - "p_overall": "0.19", - "p_heterogeneity": "0.008", - "q": "22.32", - "df": "9", - "z": "1.31", - "tau2_status": "reported" - }, - "notes": "" - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-021", - "review_pmid": "41970007", - "result_file": "41970007_SBP.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 27, - "source_figure": "Supplementary Figure S16, subgroup 2.2.1", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-021", - "review_pmid": "41970007", - "result_file": "41970007_SBP.csv", - "outcome": "SBP", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "SMD", - "pooled_effect": "-0.00", - "ci_lower": "-0.16", - "ci_upper": "0.16", - "direction": "null", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-0.00", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 27, - "figure": "Supplementary Figure S16, subgroup 2.2.1", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-0.16", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 27, - "figure": "Supplementary Figure S16, subgroup 2.2.1", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "0.16", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 27, - "figure": "Supplementary Figure S16, subgroup 2.2.1", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 27, - "figure": "Supplementary Figure S16, subgroup 2.2.1", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "unit_id": "MA-021", - "source_page": 27, - "source_figure": "Supplementary Figure S16, subgroup 2.2.1", - "source_effect_measure": "SMD", - "model": "fixed_effects", - "pooled_effect": "-0.00", - "ci_lower": "-0.16", - "ci_upper": "0.16", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": null, - "p_overall": "0.99", - "p_heterogeneity": "0.88", - "q": "3.03", - "df": "7", - "z": "0.02", - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "notes": "" - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-022", - "review_pmid": "41830012", - "result_file": "41830012_AllCauseMortality.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 7, - "source_figure": "Figure 2A", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-022", - "review_pmid": "41830012", - "result_file": "41830012_AllCauseMortality.csv", - "outcome": "AllCauseMortality", - "analysis_type": "dichotomous", - "effect_measure": "RR", - "pooled_effect": "1.01", - "ci_lower": "0.96", - "ci_upper": "1.06", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "5.9", - "tau2": "0" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "1.01", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "0.96", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "1.06", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "5.9", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "RR", - "model": "random effects", - "pooled_effect": "1.01", - "ci_lower": "0.96", - "ci_upper": "1.06", - "i2": "5.9", - "tau2": "0", - "tau2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.3871", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_p": null, - "overall_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "notes": "Forest upper CI 1.06 agrees with benchmark. Results prose above figure says 1.07; forest is used." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-023", - "review_pmid": "41830012", - "result_file": "41830012_CardiovascularDeath.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 8, - "source_figure": "Figure 2D", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-023", - "review_pmid": "41830012", - "result_file": "41830012_CardiovascularDeath.csv", - "outcome": "CardiovascularDeath", - "analysis_type": "dichotomous", - "effect_measure": "RR", - "pooled_effect": "0.97", - "ci_lower": "0.88", - "ci_upper": "1.07", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "17.0", - "tau2": "0.0053" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "0.97", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 2D", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "0.88", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 2D", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "1.07", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 2D", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "17.0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 2D", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "0.0053", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 2D", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "RR", - "model": "random effects", - "pooled_effect": "0.97", - "ci_lower": "0.88", - "ci_upper": "1.07", - "i2": "17.0", - "tau2": "0.0053", - "tau2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.2998", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_p": null, - "overall_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "notes": "" - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-024", - "review_pmid": "41830012", - "result_file": "41830012_MACE.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 9, - "source_figure": "Figure 2E", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-024", - "review_pmid": "41830012", - "result_file": "41830012_MACE.csv", - "outcome": "MACE", - "analysis_type": "dichotomous", - "effect_measure": "RR", - "pooled_effect": "0.93", - "ci_lower": "0.86", - "ci_upper": "1.01", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "28.9", - "tau2": "0.0030" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "0.93", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2E", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "0.86", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2E", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "1.01", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2E", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "28.9", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2E", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "0.0030", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2E", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "RR", - "model": "random effects", - "pooled_effect": "0.93", - "ci_lower": "0.86", - "ci_upper": "1.01", - "i2": "28.9", - "tau2": "0.0030", - "tau2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.2074", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_p": null, - "overall_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "notes": "" - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-025", - "review_pmid": "41830012", - "result_file": "41830012_MI.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 8, - "source_figure": "Figure 2C", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-025", - "review_pmid": "41830012", - "result_file": "41830012_MI.csv", - "outcome": "MI", - "analysis_type": "dichotomous", - "effect_measure": "RR", - "pooled_effect": "0.97", - "ci_lower": "0.91", - "ci_upper": "1.03", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "0.0", - "tau2": "0" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "0.97", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 2C", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "0.91", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 2C", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "1.03", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 2C", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "0.0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 2C", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 2C", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "RR", - "model": "random effects", - "pooled_effect": "0.97", - "ci_lower": "0.91", - "ci_upper": "1.03", - "i2": "0.0", - "tau2": "0", - "tau2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.9249", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_p": null, - "overall_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "notes": "" - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-026", - "review_pmid": "41830012", - "result_file": "41830012_Stroke.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 7, - "source_figure": "Figure 2B", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-026", - "review_pmid": "41830012", - "result_file": "41830012_Stroke.csv", - "outcome": "Stroke", - "analysis_type": "dichotomous", - "effect_measure": "RR", - "pooled_effect": "0.91", - "ci_lower": "0.81", - "ci_upper": "1.04", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "41.0", - "tau2": "0.0082" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "0.91", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "0.81", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "1.04", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "41.0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "0.0082", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "RR", - "model": "random effects", - "pooled_effect": "0.91", - "ci_lower": "0.81", - "ci_upper": "1.04", - "i2": "41.0", - "tau2": "0.0082", - "tau2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.0755", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_p": null, - "overall_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "notes": "" - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-027", - "review_pmid": "40325863", - "result_file": "40325863.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 10, - "source_figure": "Figure 2", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-027", - "review_pmid": "40325863", - "result_file": "40325863.csv", - "outcome": "40325863", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "SMD", - "pooled_effect": "1.68", - "ci_lower": "0.71", - "ci_upper": "2.65", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "91.002", - "tau2": "1.731" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "1.68", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "0.71", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "2.65", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "91.002", - "status": "verified_nonforest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Results section 3.5", - "source_type": "nonforest_text" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "1.731", - "status": "verified_nonforest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Results section 3.5", - "source_type": "nonforest_text" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "unit_id": "MA-027", - "effect_measure": "SMD", - "model": "Random effects; estimator not stated in figure", - "pooled_effect": "1.68", - "ci_lower": "0.71", - "ci_upper": "2.65", - "i2": "91.002", - "tau2": "1.731", - "heterogeneity_p": "<0.001", - "overall_effect_p": "0.00", - "Q": "77.796", - "df": "7", - "source_page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "tau2_status": "reported", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported", - "field_provenance": { - "effect_measure": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "model": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Results section 3.5", - "source_type": "nonforest_text" - }, - "pooled_effect": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_lower": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_upper": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "i2": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Results section 3.5", - "source_type": "nonforest_text" - }, - "tau2": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Results section 3.5", - "source_type": "nonforest_text" - }, - "heterogeneity_p": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Results section 3.5", - "source_type": "nonforest_text" - }, - "overall_effect_p": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "notes": "For all eight studies, the five plotted numeric fields (effect, lower CI, upper CI, Z, p) match exactly after comma decimal separator normalization. Source p=0.00 is rounded published text, not a mathematical zero. Sample Size (N) verified in Table 1 pp5-8; these are numbers enrolled in each study, not necessarily the analyzed two-arm N for the plotted effect. Figure labels Ozdogar 2022 and Siengsukon 2021; Table 1 labels these studies 2023 and 2020b. Retain forest labels under forest-source precedence; record source inconsistency. I2=91.002%, tau2=1.731, Q=77.796, heterogeneity p<0.001, and random-effects model reported in same-page results text, not inside Figure 2. Figure pooled p=0.00; prose says p<0.001." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-028", - "review_pmid": "41761990", - "result_file": "41761990_Albumin.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 7, - "source_figure": "Figure 3E", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-028", - "review_pmid": "41761990", - "result_file": "41761990_Albumin.csv", - "outcome": "Albumin", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "WMD", - "pooled_effect": "0.07", - "ci_lower": "-0.02", - "ci_upper": "0.17", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "0.0", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "0.07", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3E", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-0.02", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3E", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "0.17", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3E", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "0.0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3E", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "WMD", - "model": "DerSimonian-Laird random effects", - "pooled_effect": "0.07", - "ci_lower": "-0.02", - "ci_upper": "0.17", - "i2": "0.0", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.450", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_p": null, - "overall_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "notes": "" - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-029", - "review_pmid": "41761990", - "result_file": "41761990_BUN.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 7, - "source_figure": "Figure 3B", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-029", - "review_pmid": "41761990", - "result_file": "41761990_BUN.csv", - "outcome": "BUN", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "WMD", - "pooled_effect": "-0.41", - "ci_lower": "-3.16", - "ci_upper": "2.33", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "76.4", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-0.41", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-3.16", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "2.33", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "76.4", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "WMD", - "model": "DerSimonian-Laird random effects", - "pooled_effect": "-0.41", - "ci_lower": "-3.16", - "ci_upper": "2.33", - "i2": "76.4", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.005", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_p": null, - "overall_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "notes": "Forest pooled lower CI is -3.16; Table 2 p8 and results prose report -3.15. Correction follows requested forest-plot truth; retain source-discrepancy flag." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-030", - "review_pmid": "41761990", - "result_file": "41761990_Creatinine.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 7, - "source_figure": "Figure 3A", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-030", - "review_pmid": "41761990", - "result_file": "41761990_Creatinine.csv", - "outcome": "Creatinine", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "WMD", - "pooled_effect": "-0.01", - "ci_lower": "-0.03", - "ci_upper": "0.01", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "25.1", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-0.01", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-0.03", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "0.01", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "25.1", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "WMD", - "model": "DerSimonian-Laird random effects", - "pooled_effect": "-0.01", - "ci_lower": "-0.03", - "ci_upper": "0.01", - "i2": "25.1", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.198", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_p": null, - "overall_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "notes": "" - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-031", - "review_pmid": "41761990", - "result_file": "41761990_Urea.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 7, - "source_figure": "Figure 3D", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-031", - "review_pmid": "41761990", - "result_file": "41761990_Urea.csv", - "outcome": "Urea", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "WMD", - "pooled_effect": "-2.53", - "ci_lower": "-4.09", - "ci_upper": "-0.96", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "0.0", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-2.53", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3D", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-4.09", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3D", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "-0.96", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3D", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "0.0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3D", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "WMD", - "model": "DerSimonian-Laird random effects", - "pooled_effect": "-2.53", - "ci_lower": "-4.09", - "ci_upper": "-0.96", - "i2": "0.0", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.630", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_p": null, - "overall_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "notes": "" - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-032", - "review_pmid": "41761990", - "result_file": "41761990_UricAcid.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 7, - "source_figure": "Figure 3C", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-032", - "review_pmid": "41761990", - "result_file": "41761990_UricAcid.csv", - "outcome": "UricAcid", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "WMD", - "pooled_effect": "-1.46", - "ci_lower": "-2.93", - "ci_upper": "0.02", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "97.6", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-1.46", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3C", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-2.93", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3C", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "0.02", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3C", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "97.6", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3C", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "WMD", - "model": "DerSimonian-Laird random effects", - "pooled_effect": "-1.46", - "ci_lower": "-2.93", - "ci_upper": "0.02", - "i2": "97.6", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "<0.000", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_p": null, - "overall_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "notes": "The forest literally prints heterogeneity p < 0.000; this is preserved as a reported string rather than interpreted as an exact probability." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-033", - "review_pmid": "41938012", - "result_file": "41938012_CO.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 17, - "source_figure": "Figure 4A", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-033", - "review_pmid": "41938012", - "result_file": "41938012_CO.csv", - "outcome": "CO", - "analysis_type": "dichotomous", - "effect_measure": "OR", - "pooled_effect": "1.48", - "ci_lower": "1.06", - "ci_upper": "2.06", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "92.1", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "1.48", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 17, - "figure": "Figure 4A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "1.06", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 17, - "figure": "Figure 4A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "2.06", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 17, - "figure": "Figure 4A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "92.1", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 17, - "figure": "Figure 4A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "OR", - "model": "REML random effects", - "pooled_effect": "1.48", - "ci_lower": "1.06", - "ci_upper": "2.06", - "i2": "92.1", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.000", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_p": null, - "overall_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "notes": "Thimonier row 2 point estimate 1.98 and CI [1.49,2.54] both match the printed plot; retained exactly without deriving a different value from CI." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-034", - "review_pmid": "41938012", - "result_file": "41938012_HighTemperature.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 19, - "source_figure": "Figure 6", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-034", - "review_pmid": "41938012", - "result_file": "41938012_HighTemperature.csv", - "outcome": "HighTemperature", - "analysis_type": "dichotomous", - "effect_measure": "OR", - "pooled_effect": "1.39", - "ci_lower": "1.07", - "ci_upper": "1.79", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "98.5", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "1.39", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 19, - "figure": "Figure 6", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "1.07", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 19, - "figure": "Figure 6", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "1.79", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 19, - "figure": "Figure 6", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "98.5", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 19, - "figure": "Figure 6", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "OR", - "model": "REML random effects", - "pooled_effect": "1.39", - "ci_lower": "1.07", - "ci_upper": "1.79", - "i2": "98.5", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.000", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_p": null, - "overall_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "notes": "Forest I2 is 98.5%, not the 89.0% in MA-034; 89.0% belongs to the particulate-matter forest." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-035", - "review_pmid": "41938012", - "result_file": "41938012_NO2.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 17, - "source_figure": "Figure 4B", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-035", - "review_pmid": "41938012", - "result_file": "41938012_NO2.csv", - "outcome": "NO2", - "analysis_type": "dichotomous", - "effect_measure": "OR", - "pooled_effect": "1.17", - "ci_lower": "1.00", - "ci_upper": "1.38", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "80.3", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "1.17", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 17, - "figure": "Figure 4B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "1.00", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 17, - "figure": "Figure 4B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "1.38", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 17, - "figure": "Figure 4B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "80.3", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 17, - "figure": "Figure 4B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "OR", - "model": "REML random effects", - "pooled_effect": "1.17", - "ci_lower": "1.00", - "ci_upper": "1.38", - "i2": "80.3", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.000", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_p": null, - "overall_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "notes": "" - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-036", - "review_pmid": "41938012", - "result_file": "41938012_Ozone.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 16, - "source_figure": "Figure 3B", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-036", - "review_pmid": "41938012", - "result_file": "41938012_Ozone.csv", - "outcome": "Ozone", - "analysis_type": "dichotomous", - "effect_measure": "OR", - "pooled_effect": "1.27", - "ci_lower": "1.01", - "ci_upper": "1.60", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "96.2", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "1.27", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 16, - "figure": "Figure 3B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "1.01", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 16, - "figure": "Figure 3B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "1.60", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 16, - "figure": "Figure 3B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "96.2", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 16, - "figure": "Figure 3B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "OR", - "model": "REML random effects", - "pooled_effect": "1.27", - "ci_lower": "1.01", - "ci_upper": "1.60", - "i2": "96.2", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.000", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_p": null, - "overall_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "notes": "" - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-037", - "review_pmid": "41938012", - "result_file": "41938012_ParticulateMatter.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 18, - "source_figure": "Figure 5", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-037", - "review_pmid": "41938012", - "result_file": "41938012_ParticulateMatter.csv", - "outcome": "ParticulateMatter", - "analysis_type": "dichotomous", - "effect_measure": "OR", - "pooled_effect": "1.15", - "ci_lower": "1.06", - "ci_upper": "1.24", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "89.0", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "1.15", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 18, - "figure": "Figure 5", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "1.06", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 18, - "figure": "Figure 5", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "1.24", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 18, - "figure": "Figure 5", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "89.0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 18, - "figure": "Figure 5", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "OR", - "model": "REML random effects", - "pooled_effect": "1.15", - "ci_lower": "1.06", - "ci_upper": "1.24", - "i2": "89.0", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.000", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_p": null, - "overall_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "notes": "" - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-038", - "review_pmid": "41938012", - "result_file": "41938012_SO2.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 16, - "source_figure": "Figure 3A", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-038", - "review_pmid": "41938012", - "result_file": "41938012_SO2.csv", - "outcome": "SO2", - "analysis_type": "dichotomous", - "effect_measure": "OR", - "pooled_effect": "1.60", - "ci_lower": "1.20", - "ci_upper": "2.13", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "97.7", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "1.60", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 16, - "figure": "Figure 3A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "1.20", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 16, - "figure": "Figure 3A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "2.13", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 16, - "figure": "Figure 3A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "97.7", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 16, - "figure": "Figure 3A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "OR", - "model": "REML random effects", - "pooled_effect": "1.60", - "ci_lower": "1.20", - "ci_upper": "2.13", - "i2": "97.7", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.000", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_p": null, - "overall_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "notes": "" - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-039", - "review_pmid": "41388744", - "result_file": "41388744_DBP.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 8, - "source_figure": "Figure 3B", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-039", - "review_pmid": "41388744", - "result_file": "41388744_DBP.csv", - "outcome": "DBP", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "WMD", - "pooled_effect": "-1.20", - "ci_lower": "-2.84", - "ci_upper": "0.44", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "84.3", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-1.20", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-2.84", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "0.44", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "84.3", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "unit_id": "MA-039", - "effect_measure": "WMD", - "model": "DerSimonian-Laird random effects (DL)", - "pooled_effect": "-1.20", - "ci_lower": "-2.84", - "ci_upper": "0.44", - "i2": "84.3", - "tau2": null, - "heterogeneity_p": "<0.000", - "overall_effect_p": "0.15", - "source_page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3B", - "tau2_status": "not_reported", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported", - "field_provenance": { - "effect_measure": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "model": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "pooled_effect": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_lower": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_upper": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "i2": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "heterogeneity_p": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "overall_effect_p": { - "page": 6, - "figure": "Results sections 3.4.1/3.4.2", - "source_type": "nonforest_text" - } - } - }, - "notes": "All 16 WMD/CI triplets and years match Figure 3B. Figure caption explicitly calls this weighted mean difference (WMD), while extraction column uses generic Mean Difference (mmHg). Figure heterogeneity p is printed as p<0.000; preserve verbatim in metadata and flag it as a source formatting anomaly. Same-page model note says random effects. Overall-effect p=0.15 is from p6 text, not the forest heterogeneity test." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-040", - "review_pmid": "41388744", - "result_file": "41388744_SBP.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 8, - "source_figure": "Figure 3A", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-040", - "review_pmid": "41388744", - "result_file": "41388744_SBP.csv", - "outcome": "SBP", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "WMD", - "pooled_effect": "-2.69", - "ci_lower": "-3.83", - "ci_upper": "-1.55", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "30.1", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-2.69", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-3.83", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "-1.55", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "30.1", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "unit_id": "MA-040", - "effect_measure": "WMD", - "model": "DerSimonian-Laird random effects (DL)", - "pooled_effect": "-2.69", - "ci_lower": "-3.83", - "ci_upper": "-1.55", - "i2": "30.1", - "tau2": null, - "heterogeneity_p": "0.123", - "overall_effect_p": "<0.001", - "source_page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3A", - "tau2_status": "not_reported", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported", - "field_provenance": { - "effect_measure": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "model": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "pooled_effect": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_lower": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_upper": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "i2": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "heterogeneity_p": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "overall_effect_p": { - "page": 6, - "figure": "Results sections 3.4.1/3.4.2", - "source_type": "nonforest_text" - } - } - }, - "notes": "All 16 study WMD/CI triplets and years match Figure 3A; all 80 extra numeric characteristics match Table 1 pp5-6. Source conflict: Figure 3A pooled lower CI is -3.83; abstract and results text pp6-7 and Table 2 p9 say -3.84. Figure value selected because this is a forest-source benchmark. Overall-effect p<0.001 is from p6 prose; heterogeneity p=0.123 is from the plot." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-041", - "review_pmid": "41888952", - "result_file": "41888952_HDL-C.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 38, - "source_figure": "Figure 4", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-041", - "review_pmid": "41888952", - "result_file": "41888952_HDL-C.csv", - "outcome": "HDL-C", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "WMD", - "pooled_effect": "-1.17", - "ci_lower": "-1.93", - "ci_upper": "-0.41", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "0.0", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-1.17", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 38, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-1.93", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 38, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "-0.41", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 38, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "0.0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 38, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "WMD", - "model": "DerSimonian-Laird random effects", - "pooled_effect": "-1.17", - "ci_lower": "-1.93", - "ci_upper": "-0.41", - "i2": "0.0", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.483", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_p": null, - "overall_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "notes": "Forest pooled row is -1.17 [-1.93,-0.41]; article abstract/results prose reports -1.16 [-1.92,-0.40]. Follow forest." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-042", - "review_pmid": "41888952", - "result_file": "41888952_LDL-C.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 36, - "source_figure": "Figure 5", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-042", - "review_pmid": "41888952", - "result_file": "41888952_LDL-C.csv", - "outcome": "LDL-C", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "WMD", - "pooled_effect": "-3.21", - "ci_lower": "-6.32", - "ci_upper": "-0.10", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "0.0", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-3.21", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 36, - "figure": "Figure 5", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-6.32", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 36, - "figure": "Figure 5", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "-0.10", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 36, - "figure": "Figure 5", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "0.0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 36, - "figure": "Figure 5", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "WMD", - "model": "DerSimonian-Laird random effects", - "pooled_effect": "-3.21", - "ci_lower": "-6.32", - "ci_upper": "-0.10", - "i2": "0.0", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.554", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_p": null, - "overall_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "notes": "Forest lower CI is -6.32; article abstract/results prose reports -6.31. Follow forest." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-043", - "review_pmid": "41888952", - "result_file": "41888952_TC.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 37, - "source_figure": "Figure 3", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-043", - "review_pmid": "41888952", - "result_file": "41888952_TC.csv", - "outcome": "TC", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "WMD", - "pooled_effect": "-6.72", - "ci_lower": "-10.39", - "ci_upper": "-3.05", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "10.3", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-6.72", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 37, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-10.39", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 37, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "-3.05", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 37, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "10.3", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 37, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "WMD", - "model": "DerSimonian-Laird random effects", - "pooled_effect": "-6.72", - "ci_lower": "-10.39", - "ci_upper": "-3.05", - "i2": "10.3", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.342", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_p": null, - "overall_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "notes": "Forest pooled row is -6.72 [-10.39,-3.05]; article abstract/results prose reports -6.71 [-10.38,-3.04]. Follow forest. Preserve row 5 WMD -0.00 exactly as printed." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-044", - "review_pmid": "41888952", - "result_file": "41888952_TG.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 35, - "source_figure": "Figure 2", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-044", - "review_pmid": "41888952", - "result_file": "41888952_TG.csv", - "outcome": "TG", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "WMD", - "pooled_effect": "-4.21", - "ci_lower": "-17.75", - "ci_upper": "9.33", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "68.0", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-4.21", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 35, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-17.75", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 35, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "9.33", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 35, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "68.0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 35, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "WMD", - "model": "DerSimonian-Laird random effects", - "pooled_effect": "-4.21", - "ci_lower": "-17.75", - "ci_upper": "9.33", - "i2": "68.0", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.000", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_p": null, - "overall_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "notes": "Forest upper CI is 9.33; article abstract/results prose reports 9.32. Follow forest." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-045", - "review_pmid": "41901064", - "result_file": "41901064_DBP.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 8, - "source_figure": "Figure 3B", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-045", - "review_pmid": "41901064", - "result_file": "41901064_DBP.csv", - "outcome": "DBP", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "WMD", - "pooled_effect": "-2.15", - "ci_lower": "-3.68", - "ci_upper": "-0.61", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "0.0", - "tau2": "0" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-2.15", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-3.68", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "-0.61", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "0.0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3B", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "common effect (random effects identical)", - "pooled_effect": "-2.15", - "ci_lower": "-3.68", - "ci_upper": "-0.61", - "i2": "0.0", - "tau2": "0", - "tau2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "article_effect_measure": "WMD", - "alternative_models": [ - { - "model": "random effects", - "pooled_effect": "-2.15", - "ci_lower": "-3.68", - "ci_upper": "-0.61" - } - ], - "heterogeneity_p": "0.9735", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_p": null, - "overall_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "notes": "Forest measure label is MD (Mean Difference); the article calls pooled differences WMD. They are synonymous here; no unit effect_measure correction recommended. Both common and random effects rows have identical published numeric values. Selected pooled result uses the common-effect row. tau2 is the forest-reported between-study heterogeneity estimate; it was not used to weight the selected common-effect pooled estimate." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-046", - "review_pmid": "41901064", - "result_file": "41901064_SBP.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 8, - "source_figure": "Figure 3A", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-046", - "review_pmid": "41901064", - "result_file": "41901064_SBP.csv", - "outcome": "SBP", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "WMD", - "pooled_effect": "-1.58", - "ci_lower": "-3.69", - "ci_upper": "0.53", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "15.5", - "tau2": "2.5933" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-1.58", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-3.69", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "0.53", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "15.5", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "2.5933", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 3A", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "common effect", - "pooled_effect": "-1.58", - "ci_lower": "-3.69", - "ci_upper": "0.53", - "i2": "15.5", - "tau2": "2.5933", - "tau2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "article_effect_measure": "WMD", - "alternative_models": [ - { - "model": "random effects", - "pooled_effect": "-1.23", - "ci_lower": "-3.68", - "ci_upper": "1.23" - } - ], - "heterogeneity_p": "0.2967", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_p": null, - "overall_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "notes": "Forest measure label is MD (Mean Difference); the article calls pooled differences WMD. They are synonymous here; no unit effect_measure correction recommended. Benchmark matches the common-effect pooled row. Random-effects pooled row is -1.23 [-3.68,1.23] and must not be substituted without changing the selected model. Selected pooled result uses the common-effect row. tau2 is the forest-reported between-study heterogeneity estimate; it was not used to weight the selected common-effect pooled estimate." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-047", - "review_pmid": "42003421", - "result_file": "42003421_DBP.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 8, - "source_figure": "Figure 4", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-047", - "review_pmid": "42003421", - "result_file": "42003421_DBP.csv", - "outcome": "DBP", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "-1.31", - "ci_lower": "-2.98", - "ci_upper": "0.36", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "70.9", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-1.31", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-2.98", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "0.36", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "70.9", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "unit_id": "MA-047", - "source_page": 8, - "source_figure": "Figure 4", - "source_effect_measure": "WMD", - "model": "random_effects", - "pooled_effect": "-1.31", - "ci_lower": "-2.98", - "ci_upper": "0.36", - "i2": "70.9", - "tau2": null, - "p_overall": null, - "p_heterogeneity": "0.000", - "q": null, - "df": null, - "z": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "notes": "units.csv uses MD; the source forest says WMD. WMD is a weighted MD and the existing normalized measure is retained; source label preserved in reference metadata." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-048", - "review_pmid": "42003421", - "result_file": "42003421_SBP.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 6, - "source_figure": "Figure 2", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-048", - "review_pmid": "42003421", - "result_file": "42003421_SBP.csv", - "outcome": "SBP", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "-1.31", - "ci_lower": "-3.32", - "ci_upper": "0.69", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "54.0", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-1.31", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 6, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-3.32", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 6, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "0.69", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 6, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "54.0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 6, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "unit_id": "MA-048", - "source_page": 6, - "source_figure": "Figure 2", - "source_effect_measure": "WMD", - "model": "random_effects", - "pooled_effect": "-1.31", - "ci_lower": "-3.32", - "ci_upper": "0.69", - "i2": "54.0", - "tau2": null, - "p_overall": null, - "p_heterogeneity": "0.013", - "q": null, - "df": null, - "z": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "notes": "These characteristic fields match the review table, not the forest plot: Baseline BMI (kg/m2), Duration (week), Sample Size. units.csv uses MD; the source forest says WMD. WMD is a weighted MD and the existing normalized measure is retained; source label preserved in reference metadata. Forest upper CI is 0.69; article narrative and existing benchmark show 0.96. Forest value takes precedence. The p=0.013 printed on the overall row is heterogeneity p, not effect p." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-049", - "review_pmid": "42032055", - "result_file": "42032055_Dyspareunia.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 7, - "source_figure": "Figure 2, subgroup 2.1.2", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-049", - "review_pmid": "42032055", - "result_file": "42032055_Dyspareunia.csv", - "outcome": "Dyspareunia", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "SMD", - "pooled_effect": "-0.54", - "ci_lower": "-1.32", - "ci_upper": "0.23", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "91", - "tau2": "0.56" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-0.54", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2, subgroup 2.1.2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-1.32", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2, subgroup 2.1.2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "0.23", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2, subgroup 2.1.2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "91", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2, subgroup 2.1.2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "0.56", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2, subgroup 2.1.2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "unit_id": "MA-049", - "source_page": 7, - "source_figure": "Figure 2, subgroup 2.1.2", - "source_effect_measure": "SMD", - "model": "random_effects", - "pooled_effect": "-0.54", - "ci_lower": "-1.32", - "ci_upper": "0.23", - "i2": "91", - "tau2": "0.56", - "p_overall": "0.17", - "p_heterogeneity": "<0.00001", - "q": "34.56", - "df": "3", - "z": "1.38", - "tau2_status": "reported" - }, - "notes": "Unusual Mucci SD=0.0286, control SD=24.6586 and Tedeschi means=4.6702/6.3762 are faithfully printed in the original forest; preserved without inference." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-050", - "review_pmid": "42032055", - "result_file": "42032055_VaginalDryness.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 7, - "source_figure": "Figure 2, subgroup 2.1.1", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-050", - "review_pmid": "42032055", - "result_file": "42032055_VaginalDryness.csv", - "outcome": "VaginalDryness", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "SMD", - "pooled_effect": "-1.88", - "ci_lower": "-3.24", - "ci_upper": "-0.53", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "97", - "tau2": "3.11" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-1.88", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2, subgroup 2.1.1", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-3.24", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2, subgroup 2.1.1", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "-0.53", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2, subgroup 2.1.1", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "97", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2, subgroup 2.1.1", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "3.11", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 2, subgroup 2.1.1", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "unit_id": "MA-050", - "source_page": 7, - "source_figure": "Figure 2, subgroup 2.1.1", - "source_effect_measure": "SMD", - "model": "random_effects", - "pooled_effect": "-1.88", - "ci_lower": "-3.24", - "ci_upper": "-0.53", - "i2": "97", - "tau2": "3.11", - "p_overall": "0.006", - "p_heterogeneity": "<0.00001", - "q": "200.85", - "df": "6", - "z": "2.73", - "tau2_status": "reported" - }, - "notes": "These characteristic fields match the review table, not the forest plot: Sample Size. Sample Size is the Table 1 study-level N, not the forest outcome arm sum. Table N vs forest arm sums: Carmignani 60 vs40; Manonai60 vs36; Mucci89 vs58; Ribeiro60 vs38; Tedeschi186 vs189. Keep both reported values with their distinct sources; do not replace arm Ns with Sample Size. Tedeschi table/figure discrepancy remains a source limitation." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-051", - "review_pmid": "42015424", - "result_file": "42015424_ESelectin.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 9, - "source_figure": "Figure 4", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-051", - "review_pmid": "42015424", - "result_file": "42015424_ESelectin.csv", - "outcome": "ESelectin", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "WMD", - "pooled_effect": "-3.95", - "ci_lower": "-6.42", - "ci_upper": "-1.47", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "0.0", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-3.95", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-6.42", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "-1.47", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "0.0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "unit_id": "MA-051", - "source_page": 9, - "source_figure": "Figure 4", - "source_effect_measure": "WMD", - "model": "random_effects", - "pooled_effect": "-3.95", - "ci_lower": "-6.42", - "ci_upper": "-1.47", - "i2": "0.0", - "tau2": null, - "p_overall": null, - "p_heterogeneity": "0.731", - "q": null, - "df": null, - "z": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "notes": "" - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-052", - "review_pmid": "42015424", - "result_file": "42015424_ICAM.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 8, - "source_figure": "Figure 2", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-052", - "review_pmid": "42015424", - "result_file": "42015424_ICAM.csv", - "outcome": "ICAM", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "WMD", - "pooled_effect": "-14.37", - "ci_lower": "-32.64", - "ci_upper": "3.90", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "0.0", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-14.37", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-32.64", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "3.90", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "0.0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "unit_id": "MA-052", - "source_page": 8, - "source_figure": "Figure 2", - "source_effect_measure": "WMD", - "model": "random_effects", - "pooled_effect": "-14.37", - "ci_lower": "-32.64", - "ci_upper": "3.90", - "i2": "0.0", - "tau2": null, - "p_overall": null, - "p_heterogeneity": "0.484", - "q": null, - "df": null, - "z": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "notes": "These characteristic fields match the review table, not the forest plot: Duration (week), Sample Size. Francois year is 2017 in the forest but 2018 in Table 1. Year retains forest label; Table 1 duration/N attach by study identity." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-053", - "review_pmid": "42015424", - "result_file": "42015424_VCAM.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 9, - "source_figure": "Figure 3", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-053", - "review_pmid": "42015424", - "result_file": "42015424_VCAM.csv", - "outcome": "VCAM", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "WMD", - "pooled_effect": "-1.51", - "ci_lower": "-44.52", - "ci_upper": "41.50", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "0.0", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-1.51", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-44.52", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "41.50", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "0.0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "unit_id": "MA-053", - "source_page": 9, - "source_figure": "Figure 3", - "source_effect_measure": "WMD", - "model": "random_effects", - "pooled_effect": "-1.51", - "ci_lower": "-44.52", - "ci_upper": "41.50", - "i2": "0.0", - "tau2": null, - "p_overall": null, - "p_heterogeneity": "0.985", - "q": null, - "df": null, - "z": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "notes": "" - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-054", - "review_pmid": "39952828", - "result_file": "39952828.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 7, - "source_figure": "Figure 3a", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-054", - "review_pmid": "39952828", - "result_file": "39952828.csv", - "outcome": "39952828", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "SMD", - "pooled_effect": "-0.66", - "ci_lower": "-0.89", - "ci_upper": "-0.43", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "60.7", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-0.66", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3a", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-0.89", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3a", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "-0.43", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3a", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "60.7", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3a", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "unit_id": "MA-054", - "effect_measure": "SMD", - "model": "DerSimonian-Laird random effects (DL)", - "pooled_effect": "-0.66", - "ci_lower": "-0.89", - "ci_upper": "-0.43", - "i2": "60.7", - "tau2": null, - "heterogeneity_p": "0.002", - "overall_effect_p": null, - "source_page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3a", - "tau2_status": "not_reported", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported", - "overall_effect_p_status": "not_reported", - "field_provenance": { - "effect_measure": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Results/discussion text adjacent to Figure 3", - "source_type": "nonforest_text" - }, - "model": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3a", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "pooled_effect": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3a", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_lower": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3a", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_upper": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3a", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "i2": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3a", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "heterogeneity_p": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3a", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "notes": "All 13 study SMD/CI triplets match Figure 3a; figure omits Mortazavi year, confirmed as 2012 in reference 36 on PDF p9. Table 1 p4 is the source for all CG/IG sample sizes. Tsutsumi (reference 50) control group is 12, not CSV 10. IG 24 is the combined size of two explicitly reported 12-person exercise arms; it is not printed as a single 24 cell. Titles are bibliographic labels outside the numeric audit; not certified as verbatim. Study identities/reference mapping checked using bibliography pp9-10. Cunha is 2022 in Figure 3a and reference 14; Figure 3b labels the same study 2021. Current 2022 agrees with the selected overall analysis." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-055", - "review_pmid": "41065407", - "result_file": "41065407_Disability.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 10, - "source_figure": "Figure 3", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-055", - "review_pmid": "41065407", - "result_file": "41065407_Disability.csv", - "outcome": "Disability", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "SMD", - "pooled_effect": "-2.29", - "ci_lower": "-3.23", - "ci_upper": "-1.35", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "94", - "tau2": "2.62" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-2.29", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-3.23", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "-1.35", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "94", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "2.62", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "unit_id": "MA-055", - "effect_measure": "SMD", - "model": "Inverse variance, random effects", - "pooled_effect": "-2.29", - "ci_lower": "-3.23", - "ci_upper": "-1.35", - "i2": "94", - "tau2": "2.62", - "heterogeneity_p": "<0.00001", - "overall_effect_p": "<0.00001", - "Q": "191.21", - "df": "12", - "source_page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "tau2_status": "reported", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported", - "field_provenance": { - "effect_measure": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "model": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "pooled_effect": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_lower": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_upper": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "i2": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "tau2": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "heterogeneity_p": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "overall_effect_p": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "notes": "All 13 study triplets match Figure 3. The overall diamond is -2.29 [-3.23,-1.35], consistently repeated in p9 prose; current MA-055 values -2.76 [-3.90,-1.62] are incorrect." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-056", - "review_pmid": "41065407", - "result_file": "41065407_PainIntensity.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 8, - "source_figure": "Figure 1", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-056", - "review_pmid": "41065407", - "result_file": "41065407_PainIntensity.csv", - "outcome": "PainIntensity", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "SMD", - "pooled_effect": "-1.15", - "ci_lower": "-1.67", - "ci_upper": "-0.62", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "78", - "tau2": "0.52" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-1.15", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 1", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-1.67", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 1", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "-0.62", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 1", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "78", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 1", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "0.52", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 1", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "unit_id": "MA-056", - "effect_measure": "SMD", - "model": "Inverse variance, random effects", - "pooled_effect": "-1.15", - "ci_lower": "-1.67", - "ci_upper": "-0.62", - "i2": "78", - "tau2": "0.52", - "heterogeneity_p": "<0.00001", - "overall_effect_p": "<0.0001", - "Q": "40.78", - "df": "9", - "source_page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 1", - "tau2_status": "reported", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported", - "field_provenance": { - "effect_measure": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 1", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "model": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 1", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "pooled_effect": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 1", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_lower": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 1", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_upper": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 1", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "i2": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 1", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "tau2": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 1", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "heterogeneity_p": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 1", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "overall_effect_p": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 1", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "notes": "All ten effect/CI triplets and years match Figure 1. CSV row 3 study arm is mislabeled (1); source says Bruce-Low 2012 (2 x week). Correct the label to distinguish it from row 4 (1 x week). Plotted effect/CI columns are rounded to two decimals; more precise SMD and SE columns also exist in the figure but are not substituted." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-057", - "review_pmid": "41065407", - "result_file": "41065407_QoL.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 9, - "source_figure": "Figure 2", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-057", - "review_pmid": "41065407", - "result_file": "41065407_QoL.csv", - "outcome": "QoL", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "SMD", - "pooled_effect": "0.82", - "ci_lower": "0.19", - "ci_upper": "1.46", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "74", - "tau2": "0.45" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "0.82", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "0.19", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "1.46", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "74", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "0.45", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "unit_id": "MA-057", - "effect_measure": "SMD", - "model": "Inverse variance, random effects", - "pooled_effect": "0.82", - "ci_lower": "0.19", - "ci_upper": "1.46", - "i2": "74", - "tau2": "0.45", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.002", - "overall_effect_p": "0.01", - "Q": "19.05", - "df": "5", - "source_page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "tau2_status": "reported", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported", - "field_provenance": { - "effect_measure": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "model": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "pooled_effect": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_lower": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_upper": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "i2": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "tau2": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "heterogeneity_p": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "overall_effect_p": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "notes": "All six study triplets match Figure 2; I2=74% and tau2=0.45 are printed under the overall diamond and were missing from target." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-058", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_30CST.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 9, - "source_figure": "Figure 2b", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-058", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_30CST.csv", - "outcome": "30CST", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "4.24", - "ci_lower": "2.89", - "ci_upper": "5.60", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "4.24", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2b", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "2.89", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2b", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "5.60", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2b", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2b", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "IV, Fixed", - "pooled_effect": "4.24", - "ci_lower": "2.89", - "ci_upper": "5.60", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.41", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": "<0.00001", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Figure 2b" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Figure 2b" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Figure 2b" - }, - "tau2_source": null - }, - "notes": "All study rows, year labels, and existing numeric fields match the displayed forest plot. Main original PDF contains this complete forest panel, including all arm means/SDs/N; no supplementary file or Table 2 substitution was required. For fixed-effect plots tau2 is not displayed and is not treated as zero." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-059", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_ArmCircumference.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 11, - "source_figure": "Figure 4f", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-059", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_ArmCircumference.csv", - "outcome": "ArmCircumference", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "0.06", - "ci_lower": "-0.79", - "ci_upper": "0.90", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "0.06", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 4f", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-0.79", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 4f", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "0.90", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 4f", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 4f", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "IV, Fixed", - "pooled_effect": "0.06", - "ci_lower": "-0.79", - "ci_upper": "0.90", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.97", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": "0.90", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 4f" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 4f" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 4f" - }, - "tau2_source": null - }, - "notes": "All study rows, year labels, and existing numeric fields match the displayed forest plot. Main original PDF contains this complete forest panel, including all arm means/SDs/N; no supplementary file or Table 2 substitution was required. For fixed-effect plots tau2 is not displayed and is not treated as zero. Correct Figure 4 panel mapping is e=Waist-to-hip ratio, f=Arm circumference, g=Thigh circumference; previous evidence map interchanged e and g." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-060", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_ArmCurlTest.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 9, - "source_figure": "Figure 2c", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-060", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_ArmCurlTest.csv", - "outcome": "ArmCurlTest", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "3.82", - "ci_lower": "1.33", - "ci_upper": "6.30", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "51", - "tau2": "3.77" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "3.82", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2c", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "1.33", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2c", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "6.30", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2c", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "51", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2c", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "3.77", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2c", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "IV, Random", - "pooled_effect": "3.82", - "ci_lower": "1.33", - "ci_upper": "6.30", - "i2": "51", - "tau2": "3.77", - "tau2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.09", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": "0.003", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Figure 2c" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Figure 2c" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Figure 2c" - }, - "tau2_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Figure 2c" - } - }, - "notes": "All study rows, year labels, and existing numeric fields match the displayed forest plot. Main original PDF contains this complete forest panel, including all arm means/SDs/N; no supplementary file or Table 2 substitution was required. For fixed-effect plots tau2 is not displayed and is not treated as zero." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-061", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_BMI.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 11, - "source_figure": "Figure 4b", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-061", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_BMI.csv", - "outcome": "BMI", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "-0.16", - "ci_lower": "-0.81", - "ci_upper": "0.48", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-0.16", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 4b", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-0.81", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 4b", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "0.48", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 4b", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 4b", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "IV, Fixed", - "pooled_effect": "-0.16", - "ci_lower": "-0.81", - "ci_upper": "0.48", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.99", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": "0.62", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 4b" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 4b" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 4b" - }, - "tau2_source": null - }, - "notes": "All study rows, year labels, and existing numeric fields match the displayed forest plot. Main original PDF contains this complete forest panel, including all arm means/SDs/N; no supplementary file or Table 2 substitution was required. For fixed-effect plots tau2 is not displayed and is not treated as zero." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-062", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_BackScratch.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 10, - "source_figure": "Figure 3f", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-062", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_BackScratch.csv", - "outcome": "BackScratch", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "2.84", - "ci_lower": "1.94", - "ci_upper": "3.74", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "2.84", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3f", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "1.94", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3f", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "3.74", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3f", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3f", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "IV, Fixed", - "pooled_effect": "2.84", - "ci_lower": "1.94", - "ci_upper": "3.74", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.50", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": "<0.00001", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 3f" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 3f" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 3f" - }, - "tau2_source": null - }, - "notes": "All study rows, year labels, and existing numeric fields match the displayed forest plot. Main original PDF contains this complete forest panel, including all arm means/SDs/N; no supplementary file or Table 2 substitution was required. For fixed-effect plots tau2 is not displayed and is not treated as zero." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-063", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_BodyFatMass.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 9, - "source_figure": "Figure 2d", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-063", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_BodyFatMass.csv", - "outcome": "BodyFatMass", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "-1.35", - "ci_lower": "-2.90", - "ci_upper": "0.20", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-1.35", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2d", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-2.90", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2d", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "0.20", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2d", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2d", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "IV, Fixed", - "pooled_effect": "-1.35", - "ci_lower": "-2.90", - "ci_upper": "0.20", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.54", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": "0.09", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Figure 2d" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Figure 2d" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Figure 2d" - }, - "tau2_source": null - }, - "notes": "All study rows, year labels, and existing numeric fields match the displayed forest plot. Main original PDF contains this complete forest panel, including all arm means/SDs/N; no supplementary file or Table 2 substitution was required. For fixed-effect plots tau2 is not displayed and is not treated as zero." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-064", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_BodyFatPercentage.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 9, - "source_figure": "Figure 2e", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-064", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_BodyFatPercentage.csv", - "outcome": "BodyFatPercentage", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "-1.69", - "ci_lower": "-2.26", - "ci_upper": "-1.13", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "4", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-1.69", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2e", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-2.26", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2e", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "-1.13", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2e", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "4", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2e", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "IV, Fixed", - "pooled_effect": "-1.69", - "ci_lower": "-2.26", - "ci_upper": "-1.13", - "i2": "4", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.39", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": "<0.00001", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Figure 2e" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Figure 2e" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Figure 2e" - }, - "tau2_source": null - }, - "notes": "All study rows, year labels, and existing numeric fields match the displayed forest plot. Main original PDF contains this complete forest panel, including all arm means/SDs/N; no supplementary file or Table 2 substitution was required. For fixed-effect plots tau2 is not displayed and is not treated as zero." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-065", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_BodyWeight.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 11, - "source_figure": "Figure 4a", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-065", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_BodyWeight.csv", - "outcome": "BodyWeight", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "-0.74", - "ci_lower": "-2.08", - "ci_upper": "0.60", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-0.74", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 4a", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-2.08", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 4a", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "0.60", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 4a", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 4a", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "IV, Fixed", - "pooled_effect": "-0.74", - "ci_lower": "-2.08", - "ci_upper": "0.60", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.76", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": "0.28", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 4a" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 4a" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 4a" - }, - "tau2_source": null - }, - "notes": "All study rows, year labels, and existing numeric fields match the displayed forest plot. Main original PDF contains this complete forest panel, including all arm means/SDs/N; no supplementary file or Table 2 substitution was required. For fixed-effect plots tau2 is not displayed and is not treated as zero." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-066", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_HDL-C.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 10, - "source_figure": "Figure 3b", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-066", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_HDL-C.csv", - "outcome": "HDL-C", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "0.03", - "ci_lower": "-0.06", - "ci_upper": "0.12", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "0.03", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3b", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-0.06", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3b", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "0.12", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3b", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3b", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "IV, Fixed", - "pooled_effect": "0.03", - "ci_lower": "-0.06", - "ci_upper": "0.12", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.65", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": "0.48", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 3b" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 3b" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 3b" - }, - "tau2_source": null - }, - "notes": "All study rows, year labels, and existing numeric fields match the displayed forest plot. Main original PDF contains this complete forest panel, including all arm means/SDs/N; no supplementary file or Table 2 substitution was required. For fixed-effect plots tau2 is not displayed and is not treated as zero." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-067", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_HandGripTest.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 9, - "source_figure": "Figure 2a", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-067", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_HandGripTest.csv", - "outcome": "HandGripTest", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "2.64", - "ci_lower": "0.02", - "ci_upper": "5.26", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "38", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "2.64", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2a", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "0.02", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2a", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "5.26", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2a", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "38", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 2a", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "IV, Fixed", - "pooled_effect": "2.64", - "ci_lower": "0.02", - "ci_upper": "5.26", - "i2": "38", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.18", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": "0.05", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Figure 2a" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Figure 2a" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Figure 2a" - }, - "tau2_source": null - }, - "notes": "All study rows, year labels, and existing numeric fields match the displayed forest plot. Main original PDF contains this complete forest panel, including all arm means/SDs/N; no supplementary file or Table 2 substitution was required. For fixed-effect plots tau2 is not displayed and is not treated as zero." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-068", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_HipCircumference.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 11, - "source_figure": "Figure 4d", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-068", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_HipCircumference.csv", - "outcome": "HipCircumference", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "-0.96", - "ci_lower": "-3.59", - "ci_upper": "1.67", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-0.96", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 4d", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-3.59", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 4d", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "1.67", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 4d", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 4d", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "IV, Fixed", - "pooled_effect": "-0.96", - "ci_lower": "-3.59", - "ci_upper": "1.67", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.98", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": "0.47", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 4d" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 4d" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 4d" - }, - "tau2_source": null - }, - "notes": "All study rows, year labels, and existing numeric fields match the displayed forest plot. Main original PDF contains this complete forest panel, including all arm means/SDs/N; no supplementary file or Table 2 substitution was required. For fixed-effect plots tau2 is not displayed and is not treated as zero." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-069", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_LDL-C.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 10, - "source_figure": "Figure 3c", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-069", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_LDL-C.csv", - "outcome": "LDL-C", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "-0.18", - "ci_lower": "-0.44", - "ci_upper": "0.09", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-0.18", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3c", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-0.44", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3c", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "0.09", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3c", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3c", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "IV, Fixed", - "pooled_effect": "-0.18", - "ci_lower": "-0.44", - "ci_upper": "0.09", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.65", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": "0.19", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 3c" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 3c" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 3c" - }, - "tau2_source": null - }, - "notes": "All study rows, year labels, and existing numeric fields match the displayed forest plot. Main original PDF contains this complete forest panel, including all arm means/SDs/N; no supplementary file or Table 2 substitution was required. For fixed-effect plots tau2 is not displayed and is not treated as zero." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-070", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_SitAndReach.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 10, - "source_figure": "Figure 3e", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-070", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_SitAndReach.csv", - "outcome": "SitAndReach", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "3.54", - "ci_lower": "0.43", - "ci_upper": "6.66", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "81", - "tau2": "10.10" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "3.54", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3e", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "0.43", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3e", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "6.66", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3e", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "81", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3e", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "10.10", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3e", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "IV, Random", - "pooled_effect": "3.54", - "ci_lower": "0.43", - "ci_upper": "6.66", - "i2": "81", - "tau2": "10.10", - "tau2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "<0.0001", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": "0.03", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 3e" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 3e" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 3e" - }, - "tau2_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 3e" - } - }, - "notes": "All study rows, year labels, and existing numeric fields match the displayed forest plot. Main original PDF contains this complete forest panel, including all arm means/SDs/N; no supplementary file or Table 2 substitution was required. For fixed-effect plots tau2 is not displayed and is not treated as zero." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-071", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_TUG.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 10, - "source_figure": "Figure 3g", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-071", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_TUG.csv", - "outcome": "TUG", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "-1.09", - "ci_lower": "-1.59", - "ci_upper": "-0.60", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "69", - "tau2": "0.12" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-1.09", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3g", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-1.59", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3g", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "-0.60", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3g", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "69", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3g", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "0.12", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3g", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "IV, Random", - "pooled_effect": "-1.09", - "ci_lower": "-1.59", - "ci_upper": "-0.60", - "i2": "69", - "tau2": "0.12", - "tau2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.04", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": "<0.0001", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 3g" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 3g" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 3g" - }, - "tau2_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 3g" - } - }, - "notes": "All study rows, year labels, and existing numeric fields match the displayed forest plot. Main original PDF contains this complete forest panel, including all arm means/SDs/N; no supplementary file or Table 2 substitution was required. For fixed-effect plots tau2 is not displayed and is not treated as zero." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-072", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_ThighCircumference.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 11, - "source_figure": "Figure 4g", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-072", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_ThighCircumference.csv", - "outcome": "ThighCircumference", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "0.04", - "ci_lower": "-1.31", - "ci_upper": "1.39", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "0.04", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 4g", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-1.31", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 4g", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "1.39", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 4g", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 4g", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "IV, Fixed", - "pooled_effect": "0.04", - "ci_lower": "-1.31", - "ci_upper": "1.39", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.96", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": "0.96", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 4g" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 4g" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 4g" - }, - "tau2_source": null - }, - "notes": "All study rows, year labels, and existing numeric fields match the displayed forest plot. Main original PDF contains this complete forest panel, including all arm means/SDs/N; no supplementary file or Table 2 substitution was required. For fixed-effect plots tau2 is not displayed and is not treated as zero. Correct Figure 4 panel mapping is e=Waist-to-hip ratio, f=Arm circumference, g=Thigh circumference; previous evidence map interchanged e and g." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-073", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_TotalCholesterol.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 10, - "source_figure": "Figure 3a", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-073", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_TotalCholesterol.csv", - "outcome": "TotalCholesterol", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "-0.29", - "ci_lower": "-0.56", - "ci_upper": "-0.02", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-0.29", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3a", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-0.56", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3a", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "-0.02", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3a", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3a", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "IV, Fixed", - "pooled_effect": "-0.29", - "ci_lower": "-0.56", - "ci_upper": "-0.02", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.68", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": "0.04", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 3a" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 3a" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 3a" - }, - "tau2_source": null - }, - "notes": "All study rows, year labels, and existing numeric fields match the displayed forest plot. Main original PDF contains this complete forest panel, including all arm means/SDs/N; no supplementary file or Table 2 substitution was required. For fixed-effect plots tau2 is not displayed and is not treated as zero." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-074", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_Triglycerides.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 10, - "source_figure": "Figure 3d", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-074", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_Triglycerides.csv", - "outcome": "Triglycerides", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "-0.09", - "ci_lower": "-0.33", - "ci_upper": "0.16", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "64", - "tau2": "0.04" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-0.09", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3d", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-0.33", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3d", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "0.16", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3d", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "64", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3d", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "0.04", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 3d", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "IV, Random", - "pooled_effect": "-0.09", - "ci_lower": "-0.33", - "ci_upper": "0.16", - "i2": "64", - "tau2": "0.04", - "tau2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.04", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": "0.49", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 3d" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 3d" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 3d" - }, - "tau2_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 3d" - } - }, - "notes": "All study rows, year labels, and existing numeric fields match the displayed forest plot. Main original PDF contains this complete forest panel, including all arm means/SDs/N; no supplementary file or Table 2 substitution was required. For fixed-effect plots tau2 is not displayed and is not treated as zero." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-075", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_WaistCircumference.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 11, - "source_figure": "Figure 4c", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-075", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_WaistCircumference.csv", - "outcome": "WaistCircumference", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "-1.56", - "ci_lower": "-4.80", - "ci_upper": "1.68", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-1.56", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 4c", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-4.80", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 4c", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "1.68", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 4c", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 4c", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "IV, Fixed", - "pooled_effect": "-1.56", - "ci_lower": "-4.80", - "ci_upper": "1.68", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.86", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": "0.35", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 4c" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 4c" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 4c" - }, - "tau2_source": null - }, - "notes": "All study rows, year labels, and existing numeric fields match the displayed forest plot. Main original PDF contains this complete forest panel, including all arm means/SDs/N; no supplementary file or Table 2 substitution was required. For fixed-effect plots tau2 is not displayed and is not treated as zero." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-076", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_WaistToHipRatio.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 11, - "source_figure": "Figure 4e", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-076", - "review_pmid": "41743679", - "result_file": "41743679_WaistToHipRatio.csv", - "outcome": "WaistToHipRatio", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "0.00", - "ci_lower": "-0.02", - "ci_upper": "0.03", - "direction": "null", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "0.00", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 4e", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-0.02", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 4e", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "0.03", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 4e", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 4e", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "IV, Fixed", - "pooled_effect": "0.00", - "ci_lower": "-0.02", - "ci_upper": "0.03", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.90", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": "0.76", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 4e" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 4e" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 4e" - }, - "tau2_source": null - }, - "notes": "All study rows, year labels, and existing numeric fields match the displayed forest plot. Main original PDF contains this complete forest panel, including all arm means/SDs/N; no supplementary file or Table 2 substitution was required. For fixed-effect plots tau2 is not displayed and is not treated as zero. Correct Figure 4 panel mapping is e=Waist-to-hip ratio, f=Arm circumference, g=Thigh circumference; previous evidence map interchanged e and g." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-077", - "review_pmid": "41601519", - "result_file": "41601519_DepressiveSymptoms.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 10, - "source_figure": "Figure 5", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-077", - "review_pmid": "41601519", - "result_file": "41601519_DepressiveSymptoms.csv", - "outcome": "DepressiveSymptoms", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "SMD", - "pooled_effect": "-0.63", - "ci_lower": "-0.81", - "ci_upper": "-0.46", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "90.13", - "tau2": "0.10" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-0.63", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 5", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-0.81", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 5", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "-0.46", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 5", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "90.13", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 5", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "0.10", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 5", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "Hedges's g (SMD)", - "model": "Random-effects REML", - "pooled_effect": "-0.63", - "ci_lower": "-0.81", - "ci_upper": "-0.46", - "i2": "90.13", - "tau2": "0.10", - "tau2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.00", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": "0.00", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 5" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 5" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 5" - }, - "tau2_source": { - "page": 10, - "source": "Figure 5" - } - }, - "notes": "All study rows, year labels, and existing numeric fields match the displayed forest plot." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-078", - "review_pmid": "41601519", - "result_file": "41601519_InsomniaSeverity.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 9, - "source_figure": "Figure 3", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-078", - "review_pmid": "41601519", - "result_file": "41601519_InsomniaSeverity.csv", - "outcome": "InsomniaSeverity", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "SMD", - "pooled_effect": "-0.94", - "ci_lower": "-1.40", - "ci_upper": "-0.48", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "98.63", - "tau2": "0.84" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-0.94", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-1.40", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "-0.48", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "98.63", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "0.84", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 3", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "Hedges's g (SMD)", - "model": "Random-effects REML", - "pooled_effect": "-0.94", - "ci_lower": "-1.40", - "ci_upper": "-0.48", - "i2": "98.63", - "tau2": "0.84", - "tau2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.00", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": "0.00", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Figure 3" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Figure 3" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Figure 3" - }, - "tau2_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Figure 3" - } - }, - "notes": "All study rows, year labels, and existing numeric fields match the displayed forest plot. Henry 2020 has positive g 0.78 in the original plot, despite the remaining studies mostly favoring dCBT-I; retained as published. Figures contain the same arm means/SDs as the CSV, so no sign reversal was inferred." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-079", - "review_pmid": "41601519", - "result_file": "41601519_SleepEfficiency.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 9, - "source_figure": "Figure 4", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-079", - "review_pmid": "41601519", - "result_file": "41601519_SleepEfficiency.csv", - "outcome": "SleepEfficiency", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "SMD", - "pooled_effect": "0.59", - "ci_lower": "0.37", - "ci_upper": "0.81", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "67.00", - "tau2": "0.05" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "0.59", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "0.37", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "0.81", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "67.00", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "0.05", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "Hedges's g (SMD)", - "model": "Random-effects REML", - "pooled_effect": "0.59", - "ci_lower": "0.37", - "ci_upper": "0.81", - "i2": "67.00", - "tau2": "0.05", - "tau2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.02", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": "0.00", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Figure 4" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Figure 4" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Figure 4" - }, - "tau2_source": { - "page": 9, - "source": "Figure 4" - } - }, - "notes": "All study rows, year labels, and existing numeric fields match the displayed forest plot." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-080", - "review_pmid": "41656984", - "result_file": "41656984_Anxiety.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 11, - "source_figure": "Figure 3a", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-080", - "review_pmid": "41656984", - "result_file": "41656984_Anxiety.csv", - "outcome": "Anxiety", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "SMD", - "pooled_effect": "-0.09", - "ci_lower": "-0.15", - "ci_upper": "-0.04", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-0.09", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 3a", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-0.15", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 3a", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "-0.04", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 3a", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 3a", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "SMD", - "model": "IV, Fixed", - "pooled_effect": "-0.09", - "ci_lower": "-0.15", - "ci_upper": "-0.04", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.52", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": "0.0004", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 3a" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 3a" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 3a" - }, - "tau2_source": null - }, - "notes": "All study rows, year labels, and existing numeric fields match the displayed forest plot." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-081", - "review_pmid": "41656984", - "result_file": "41656984_Depression.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 11, - "source_figure": "Figure 3b", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-081", - "review_pmid": "41656984", - "result_file": "41656984_Depression.csv", - "outcome": "Depression", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "SMD", - "pooled_effect": "-0.26", - "ci_lower": "-0.64", - "ci_upper": "0.12", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "98", - "tau2": "0.47" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-0.26", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 3b", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-0.64", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 3b", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "0.12", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 3b", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "98", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 3b", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "0.47", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 3b", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "SMD", - "model": "IV, Random", - "pooled_effect": "-0.26", - "ci_lower": "-0.64", - "ci_upper": "0.12", - "i2": "98", - "tau2": "0.47", - "tau2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "<0.00001", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": "0.18", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 3b" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 3b" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 3b" - }, - "tau2_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 3b" - } - }, - "notes": "All study rows, year labels, and existing numeric fields match the displayed forest plot. All 13 Sample Size values match original Table 2 pp5–8. These are whole-study enrollment figures and differ legitimately from experimental/control analysis totals; do not substitute their sums. All six arm-summary numeric fields, SMD/CI and Year were separately checked in Figure 3b." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-082", - "review_pmid": "41656984", - "result_file": "41656984_QualityOfLife.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 11, - "source_figure": "Figure 3c", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-082", - "review_pmid": "41656984", - "result_file": "41656984_QualityOfLife.csv", - "outcome": "QualityOfLife", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "SMD", - "pooled_effect": "0.22", - "ci_lower": "0.05", - "ci_upper": "0.39", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "76", - "tau2": "0.06" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "0.22", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 3c", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "0.05", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 3c", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "0.39", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 3c", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "76", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 3c", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "0.06", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 3c", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "SMD", - "model": "IV, Random", - "pooled_effect": "0.22", - "ci_lower": "0.05", - "ci_upper": "0.39", - "i2": "76", - "tau2": "0.06", - "tau2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "<0.00001", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": "0.01", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 3c" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 3c" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 3c" - }, - "tau2_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 3c" - } - }, - "notes": "All study rows, year labels, and existing numeric fields match the displayed forest plot." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-083", - "review_pmid": "41656984", - "result_file": "41656984_SelfEfficacy.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 11, - "source_figure": "Figure 3e", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-083", - "review_pmid": "41656984", - "result_file": "41656984_SelfEfficacy.csv", - "outcome": "SelfEfficacy", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "SMD", - "pooled_effect": "0.18", - "ci_lower": "0.02", - "ci_upper": "0.33", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "69", - "tau2": "0.04" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "0.18", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 3e", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "0.02", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 3e", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "0.33", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 3e", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "69", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 3e", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "0.04", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 3e", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "SMD", - "model": "IV, Random", - "pooled_effect": "0.18", - "ci_lower": "0.02", - "ci_upper": "0.33", - "i2": "69", - "tau2": "0.04", - "tau2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.0005", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": "0.03", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 3e" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 3e" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 3e" - }, - "tau2_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 3e" - } - }, - "notes": "All study rows, year labels, and existing numeric fields match the displayed forest plot. Figure 3e explicitly reports IV, Random; tau2=0.04 and I2=69% are reported in the same panel." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-084", - "review_pmid": "41656984", - "result_file": "41656984_SelfManagementBehavior.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 11, - "source_figure": "Figure 3d", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-084", - "review_pmid": "41656984", - "result_file": "41656984_SelfManagementBehavior.csv", - "outcome": "SelfManagementBehavior", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "SMD", - "pooled_effect": "1.15", - "ci_lower": "0.45", - "ci_upper": "1.86", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "95", - "tau2": "0.60" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "1.15", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 3d", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "0.45", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 3d", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "1.86", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 3d", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "95", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 3d", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "0.60", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 3d", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "SMD", - "model": "IV, Random", - "pooled_effect": "1.15", - "ci_lower": "0.45", - "ci_upper": "1.86", - "i2": "95", - "tau2": "0.60", - "tau2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": "<0.00001", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": "0.001", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "model_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 3d" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 3d" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 3d" - }, - "tau2_source": { - "page": 11, - "source": "Figure 3d" - } - }, - "notes": "All study rows, year labels, and existing numeric fields match the displayed forest plot." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-085", - "review_pmid": "41561801", - "result_file": "41561801_Adiponectin.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 11, - "source_figure": "Figure 8", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-085", - "review_pmid": "41561801", - "result_file": "41561801_Adiponectin.csv", - "outcome": "Adiponectin", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "0.15", - "ci_lower": "-0.43", - "ci_upper": "0.72", - "direction": "positive", - "i2": "37", - "tau2": "0.12" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "0.15", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 8", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-0.43", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 8", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "0.72", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 8", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "37", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 8", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "0.12", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 8", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "unit_id": "MA-085", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "Inverse variance, random effects", - "pooled_effect": "0.15", - "ci_lower": "-0.43", - "ci_upper": "0.72", - "i2": "37", - "tau2": "0.12", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.19", - "overall_effect_p": "0.61", - "Q": "4.73", - "df": "3", - "experimental_N": "169", - "control_N": "162", - "source_page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 8", - "tau2_status": "reported", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported", - "field_provenance": { - "effect_measure": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 8", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "model": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 8", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "pooled_effect": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 8", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_lower": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 8", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_upper": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 8", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "i2": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 8", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "tau2": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 8", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "heterogeneity_p": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 8", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "overall_effect_p": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 8", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "notes": "" - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-086", - "review_pmid": "41561801", - "result_file": "41561801_BMI.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 9, - "source_figure": "Figure 5", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-086", - "review_pmid": "41561801", - "result_file": "41561801_BMI.csv", - "outcome": "BMI", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "-0.49", - "ci_lower": "-0.70", - "ci_upper": "-0.27", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-0.49", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 5", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-0.70", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 5", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "-0.27", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 5", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "0", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 5", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "unit_id": "MA-086", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "Inverse variance, fixed effect", - "pooled_effect": "-0.49", - "ci_lower": "-0.70", - "ci_upper": "-0.27", - "i2": "0", - "tau2": null, - "heterogeneity_p": "0.64", - "overall_effect_p": "<0.00001", - "Q": "7.85", - "df": "10", - "experimental_N": "309", - "control_N": "283", - "source_page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 5", - "tau2_status": "not_reported", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported", - "field_provenance": { - "effect_measure": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 5", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "model": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 5", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "pooled_effect": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 5", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_lower": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 5", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_upper": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 5", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "i2": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 5", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "heterogeneity_p": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 5", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "overall_effect_p": { - "page": 9, - "figure": "Figure 5", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "notes": "All 11 study MD/CI triplets and years match Figure 5. Model is fixed effect; tau2 is not reported and must not be imputed as zero." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-087", - "review_pmid": "41561801", - "result_file": "41561801_CRP.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 10, - "source_figure": "Figure 6", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-087", - "review_pmid": "41561801", - "result_file": "41561801_CRP.csv", - "outcome": "CRP", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "-0.07", - "ci_lower": "-0.13", - "ci_upper": "-0.02", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "80", - "tau2": "0.00" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-0.07", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 6", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-0.13", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 6", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "-0.02", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 6", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "80", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 6", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "0.00", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 6", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "unit_id": "MA-087", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "Inverse variance, random effects", - "pooled_effect": "-0.07", - "ci_lower": "-0.13", - "ci_upper": "-0.02", - "i2": "80", - "tau2": "0.00", - "heterogeneity_p": "<0.00001", - "overall_effect_p": "0.006", - "Q": "56.02", - "df": "11", - "experimental_N": "348", - "control_N": "318", - "source_page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 6", - "tau2_status": "reported", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported", - "field_provenance": { - "effect_measure": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 6", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "model": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 6", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "pooled_effect": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 6", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_lower": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 6", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_upper": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 6", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "i2": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 6", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "tau2": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 6", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "heterogeneity_p": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 6", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "overall_effect_p": { - "page": 10, - "figure": "Figure 6", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "notes": "All 12 study MD/CI triplets and years match Figure 6, including row 5 upper CI printed -0.00. Overall tau2 is explicitly printed 0.00 and should replace the missing target value." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-088", - "review_pmid": "41561801", - "result_file": "41561801_IL-6.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 12, - "source_figure": "Figure 9", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-088", - "review_pmid": "41561801", - "result_file": "41561801_IL-6.csv", - "outcome": "IL-6", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "-0.33", - "ci_lower": "-0.60", - "ci_upper": "-0.05", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "89", - "tau2": "0.08" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-0.33", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 12, - "figure": "Figure 9", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-0.60", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 12, - "figure": "Figure 9", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "-0.05", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 12, - "figure": "Figure 9", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "89", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 12, - "figure": "Figure 9", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "0.08", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 12, - "figure": "Figure 9", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "unit_id": "MA-088", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "Inverse variance, random effects", - "pooled_effect": "-0.33", - "ci_lower": "-0.60", - "ci_upper": "-0.05", - "i2": "89", - "tau2": "0.08", - "heterogeneity_p": "<0.00001", - "overall_effect_p": "0.02", - "Q": "73.23", - "df": "8", - "experimental_N": "297", - "control_N": "272", - "source_page": 12, - "figure": "Figure 9", - "tau2_status": "reported", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported", - "field_provenance": { - "effect_measure": { - "page": 12, - "figure": "Figure 9", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "model": { - "page": 12, - "figure": "Figure 9", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "pooled_effect": { - "page": 12, - "figure": "Figure 9", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_lower": { - "page": 12, - "figure": "Figure 9", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_upper": { - "page": 12, - "figure": "Figure 9", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "i2": { - "page": 12, - "figure": "Figure 9", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "tau2": { - "page": 12, - "figure": "Figure 9", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "heterogeneity_p": { - "page": 12, - "figure": "Figure 9", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "overall_effect_p": { - "page": 12, - "figure": "Figure 9", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "notes": "All nine study MD/CI triplets and years match Figure 9. Forest pooled CI upper endpoint is -0.05; p11 prose omits that minus sign (0.05). The target already correctly follows the forest." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-089", - "review_pmid": "41561801", - "result_file": "41561801_TNF-alpha.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 11, - "source_figure": "Figure 7", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-089", - "review_pmid": "41561801", - "result_file": "41561801_TNF-alpha.csv", - "outcome": "TNF-alpha", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "-0.66", - "ci_lower": "-1.07", - "ci_upper": "-0.25", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "93", - "tau2": "0.30" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-0.66", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 7", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-1.07", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 7", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "-0.25", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 7", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "93", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 7", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "0.30", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 7", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "unit_id": "MA-089", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "Inverse variance, random effects", - "pooled_effect": "-0.66", - "ci_lower": "-1.07", - "ci_upper": "-0.25", - "i2": "93", - "tau2": "0.30", - "heterogeneity_p": "<0.00001", - "overall_effect_p": "0.002", - "Q": "144.82", - "df": "10", - "experimental_N": "237", - "control_N": "217", - "source_page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 7", - "tau2_status": "reported", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported", - "field_provenance": { - "effect_measure": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 7", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "model": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 7", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "pooled_effect": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 7", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_lower": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 7", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_upper": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 7", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "i2": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 7", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "tau2": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 7", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "heterogeneity_p": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 7", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "overall_effect_p": { - "page": 11, - "figure": "Figure 7", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "notes": "" - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-090", - "review_pmid": "41561801", - "result_file": "41561801_WC.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 8, - "source_figure": "Figure 4", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-090", - "review_pmid": "41561801", - "result_file": "41561801_WC.csv", - "outcome": "WC", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "-2.03", - "ci_lower": "-4.06", - "ci_upper": "-0.01", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "42", - "tau2": "3.30" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-2.03", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-4.06", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "-0.01", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "42", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "3.30", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "unit_id": "MA-090", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "Inverse variance, random effects", - "pooled_effect": "-2.03", - "ci_lower": "-4.06", - "ci_upper": "-0.01", - "i2": "42", - "tau2": "3.30", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.10", - "overall_effect_p": "0.05", - "Q": "12.14", - "df": "7", - "experimental_N": "218", - "control_N": "199", - "source_page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "tau2_status": "reported", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported", - "field_provenance": { - "effect_measure": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "model": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "pooled_effect": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_lower": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "ci_upper": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "i2": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "tau2": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "heterogeneity_p": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - }, - "overall_effect_p": { - "page": 8, - "figure": "Figure 4", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - } - }, - "notes": "" - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-091", - "review_pmid": "41639864", - "result_file": "41639864_VEGF.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 6, - "source_figure": "Figure 2", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-091", - "review_pmid": "41639864", - "result_file": "41639864_VEGF.csv", - "outcome": "VEGF", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "SMD", - "pooled_effect": "-0.08", - "ci_lower": "-0.25", - "ci_upper": "0.10", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "32.9", - "tau2": "0.030" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-0.08", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 6, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-0.25", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 6, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "0.10", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 6, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "32.9", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 6, - "figure": "Figure 2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "0.030", - "status": "verified_nonforest", - "source": { - "page": 1, - "figure": "Abstract, Results", - "source_type": "nonforest_text" - } - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "SMD", - "model": "DerSimonian-Laird random-effects (Overall, DL)", - "pooled_effect": "-0.08", - "ci_lower": "-0.25", - "ci_upper": "0.10", - "i2": "32.9", - "tau2": "0.030", - "tau2_status": "reported_in_nonforest_abstract_p1", - "heterogeneity_p": "0.112", - "heterogeneity_p_status": "reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": "0.390", - "overall_effect_p_status": "reported_in_nonforest_abstract_p1_and_table2_p6", - "i2_status": "reported_in_forest", - "table2_effect": { - "pooled_effect": "-0.075", - "ci_lower": "-0.246", - "ci_upper": "0.096" - }, - "model_source": { - "page": 6, - "source": "Figure 2" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 6, - "source": "Figure 2" - }, - "i2_source": { - "page": 6, - "source": "Figure 2" - }, - "tau2_source": { - "page": 1, - "source": "Abstract" - } - }, - "notes": "All 14 study rows (including both Duggan 2016 comparisons) match. Plot pooled SMD -0.08 [-0.25, 0.10] is a rounded display of Table 2 and abstract -0.075 [-0.246, 0.096]. Target contains the valid higher-precision table values; listed pooled/CI changes only enforce forest display precision. Tau2 = 0.030 and overall p = 0.390 were visually verified in p1 Abstract, not the plot." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-092", - "review_pmid": "41652340", - "result_file": "41652340_CCL2.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 7, - "source_figure": "Figure 3: CCL2", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-092", - "review_pmid": "41652340", - "result_file": "41652340_CCL2.csv", - "outcome": "CCL2", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "-3.29", - "ci_lower": "-25.91", - "ci_upper": "15.59", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-3.29", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3: CCL2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-25.91", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3: CCL2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "15.59", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3: CCL2", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "Bayesian random-effects (Methods p3; bayesmeta)", - "pooled_effect": "-3.29", - "ci_lower": "-25.91", - "ci_upper": "15.59", - "i2": null, - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": null, - "heterogeneity_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": null, - "overall_effect_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "tau": "3.207", - "tau_source": { - "page": 5, - "source": "Results text", - "reported_symbol": "tau, not tau squared" - }, - "prediction": { - "effect": "-3.25", - "ci_lower": "-36.83", - "ci_upper": "26.33" - }, - "table2_effect": { - "pooled_effect": "-3.639", - "ci_lower": "-25.91", - "ci_upper": "15.594" - }, - "model_source": { - "page": 3, - "source": "Methods, Data analysis" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 7, - "source": "Figure 3: CCL2" - }, - "i2_source": null, - "tau2_source": null - }, - "notes": "Both study rows, study years and MD/CI values match original Figure 3. Figure explicitly labels pooled row \"mean effect (mu)\" and a separate prediction row. I2 and tau2 are not reported. Main text p5 reports tau (heterogeneity SD), not tau2. Current tau2 must be cleared and tau retained separately; do not square a posterior summary to invent tau2. Forest pooled point differs from Table 2 beyond rounding. The paper does not establish whether this is a different posterior summary (e.g. mean/median); no such assumption was made. Use forest value only when enforcing the requested forest-source convention, and retain source-conflict annotation." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-093", - "review_pmid": "41652340", - "result_file": "41652340_IL-6.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 7, - "source_figure": "Figure 3: IL-6", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-093", - "review_pmid": "41652340", - "result_file": "41652340_IL-6.csv", - "outcome": "IL-6", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "-0.04", - "ci_lower": "-0.97", - "ci_upper": "0.91", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-0.04", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3: IL-6", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-0.97", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3: IL-6", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "0.91", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3: IL-6", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "Bayesian random-effects (Methods p3; bayesmeta)", - "pooled_effect": "-0.04", - "ci_lower": "-0.97", - "ci_upper": "0.91", - "i2": null, - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": null, - "heterogeneity_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": null, - "overall_effect_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "tau": "0.142", - "tau_source": { - "page": 5, - "source": "Results text", - "reported_symbol": "tau, not tau squared" - }, - "prediction": { - "effect": "-0.04", - "ci_lower": "-1.65", - "ci_upper": "1.59" - }, - "table2_effect": { - "pooled_effect": "-0.036", - "ci_lower": "-0.968", - "ci_upper": "0.908" - }, - "model_source": { - "page": 3, - "source": "Methods, Data analysis" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 7, - "source": "Figure 3: IL-6" - }, - "i2_source": null, - "tau2_source": null - }, - "notes": "Both study rows, study years and MD/CI values match original Figure 3. Figure explicitly labels pooled row \"mean effect (mu)\" and a separate prediction row. I2 and tau2 are not reported. Main text p5 reports tau (heterogeneity SD), not tau2. Current tau2 must be cleared and tau retained separately; do not square a posterior summary to invent tau2." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-094", - "review_pmid": "41652340", - "result_file": "41652340_IL-8.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 7, - "source_figure": "Figure 3: IL-8", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-094", - "review_pmid": "41652340", - "result_file": "41652340_IL-8.csv", - "outcome": "IL-8", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "-0.25", - "ci_lower": "-3.54", - "ci_upper": "2.88", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-0.25", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3: IL-8", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-3.54", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3: IL-8", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "2.88", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3: IL-8", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "Bayesian random-effects (Methods p3; bayesmeta)", - "pooled_effect": "-0.25", - "ci_lower": "-3.54", - "ci_upper": "2.88", - "i2": null, - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": null, - "heterogeneity_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": null, - "overall_effect_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "tau": "0.507", - "tau_source": { - "page": 5, - "source": "Results text", - "reported_symbol": "tau, not tau squared" - }, - "prediction": { - "effect": "-0.24", - "ci_lower": "-5.89", - "ci_upper": "5.22" - }, - "table2_effect": { - "pooled_effect": "-0.284", - "ci_lower": "-3.543", - "ci_upper": "2.877" - }, - "model_source": { - "page": 3, - "source": "Methods, Data analysis" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 7, - "source": "Figure 3: IL-8" - }, - "i2_source": null, - "tau2_source": null - }, - "notes": "Both study rows, study years and MD/CI values match original Figure 3. Figure explicitly labels pooled row \"mean effect (mu)\" and a separate prediction row. I2 and tau2 are not reported. Main text p5 reports tau (heterogeneity SD), not tau2. Current tau2 must be cleared and tau retained separately; do not square a posterior summary to invent tau2. Forest pooled point differs from Table 2 beyond rounding. The paper does not establish whether this is a different posterior summary (e.g. mean/median); no such assumption was made. Use forest value only when enforcing the requested forest-source convention, and retain source-conflict annotation." - }, - { - "unit_id": "MA-095", - "review_pmid": "41652340", - "result_file": "41652340_TNF-alpha.csv", - "source_pdf_page": 7, - "source_figure": "Figure 3: TNF-alpha", - "expected_unit": { - "unit_id": "MA-095", - "review_pmid": "41652340", - "result_file": "41652340_TNF-alpha.csv", - "outcome": "TNF-alpha", - "analysis_type": "continuous", - "effect_measure": "MD", - "pooled_effect": "-0.03", - "ci_lower": "-1.44", - "ci_upper": "1.38", - "direction": "negative", - "i2": "", - "tau2": "" - }, - "numeric_fields": { - "pooled_effect": { - "value": "-0.03", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3: TNF-alpha", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_lower": { - "value": "-1.44", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3: TNF-alpha", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "ci_upper": { - "value": "1.38", - "status": "verified_forest", - "source": { - "page": 7, - "figure": "Figure 3: TNF-alpha", - "source_type": "forest_plot" - } - }, - "i2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - }, - "tau2": { - "value": "", - "status": "not_reported_in_forest" - } - }, - "reported_details": { - "effect_measure": "MD", - "model": "Bayesian random-effects (Methods p3; bayesmeta)", - "pooled_effect": "-0.03", - "ci_lower": "-1.44", - "ci_upper": "1.38", - "i2": null, - "tau2": null, - "tau2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "heterogeneity_p": null, - "heterogeneity_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "overall_effect_p": null, - "overall_effect_p_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "i2_status": "not_reported_in_forest", - "tau": "0.219", - "tau_source": { - "page": 5, - "source": "Results text", - "reported_symbol": "tau, not tau squared" - }, - "prediction": { - "effect": "-0.03", - "ci_lower": "-2.46", - "ci_upper": "2.40" - }, - "table2_effect": { - "pooled_effect": "-0.03", - "ci_lower": "-1.437", - "ci_upper": "1.377" - }, - "model_source": { - "page": 3, - "source": "Methods, Data analysis" - }, - "pooled_source": { - "page": 7, - "source": "Figure 3: TNF-alpha" - }, - "i2_source": null, - "tau2_source": null - }, - "notes": "Both study rows, study years and MD/CI values match original Figure 3. Figure explicitly labels pooled row \"mean effect (mu)\" and a separate prediction row. I2 and tau2 are not reported. Main text p5 reports tau (heterogeneity SD), not tau2. Current tau2 must be cleared and tau retained separately; do not square a posterior summary to invent tau2." - } -]