{ "generated_utc": "2026-09-30T04:32:55.422663+00:00", "missing": [], "complete_runs": 15, "groups": [ { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "condition_id": "a4615c750f7f36c3", "phase": "development", "hops": 2, "architecture": "c1", "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "parameters": 218240, "effective_depth": 1, "worlds": 1, "runs": 1, "atomic": 1.0, "atomic_world_min": 1.0, "atomic_world_max": 1.0, "atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "id_atomic": 1.0, "id_atomic_world_min": 1.0, "id_atomic_world_max": 1.0, "id_atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "ood_atomic": 1.0, "ood_atomic_world_min": 1.0, "ood_atomic_world_max": 1.0, "ood_atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "train_composite": 1.0, "train_composite_world_min": 1.0, "train_composite_world_max": 1.0, "train_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "test_full_composite": 0.3430493273542601, "test_full_composite_world_min": 0.3430493273542601, "test_full_composite_world_max": 0.3430493273542601, "test_full_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "ood_composite": 0.016666666666666666, "ood_composite_world_min": 0.016666666666666666, "ood_composite_world_max": 0.016666666666666666, "ood_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "autonomous_calls": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_world_min": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_world_max": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "condition_id": "602482e3080366f4", "phase": "development", "hops": 2, "architecture": "c2", "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "parameters": 416512, "effective_depth": 2, "worlds": 1, "runs": 1, "atomic": 1.0, "atomic_world_min": 1.0, "atomic_world_max": 1.0, "atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "id_atomic": 1.0, "id_atomic_world_min": 1.0, "id_atomic_world_max": 1.0, "id_atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "ood_atomic": 1.0, "ood_atomic_world_min": 1.0, "ood_atomic_world_max": 1.0, "ood_atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "train_composite": 1.0, "train_composite_world_min": 1.0, "train_composite_world_max": 1.0, "train_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "test_full_composite": 0.9551569506726457, "test_full_composite_world_min": 0.9551569506726457, "test_full_composite_world_max": 0.9551569506726457, "test_full_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "ood_composite": 0.012962962962962963, "ood_composite_world_min": 0.012962962962962963, "ood_composite_world_max": 0.012962962962962963, "ood_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "autonomous_calls": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_world_min": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_world_max": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "condition_id": "76cf70e81009bf6b", "phase": "development", "hops": 2, "architecture": "cd", "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "parameters": 813056, "effective_depth": 4, "worlds": 1, "runs": 1, "atomic": 1.0, "atomic_world_min": 1.0, "atomic_world_max": 1.0, "atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "id_atomic": 1.0, "id_atomic_world_min": 1.0, "id_atomic_world_max": 1.0, "id_atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "ood_atomic": 1.0, "ood_atomic_world_min": 1.0, "ood_atomic_world_max": 1.0, "ood_atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "train_composite": 1.0, "train_composite_world_min": 1.0, "train_composite_world_max": 1.0, "train_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "test_full_composite": 0.9820627802690582, "test_full_composite_world_min": 0.9820627802690582, "test_full_composite_world_max": 0.9820627802690582, "test_full_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "ood_composite": 0.012962962962962963, "ood_composite_world_min": 0.012962962962962963, "ood_composite_world_max": 0.012962962962962963, "ood_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "autonomous_calls": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_world_min": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_world_max": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "condition_id": "742932b69f8855d9", "phase": "development", "hops": 2, "architecture": "l1", "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "parameters": 218240, "effective_depth": 4, "worlds": 1, "runs": 1, "atomic": 1.0, "atomic_world_min": 1.0, "atomic_world_max": 1.0, "atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "id_atomic": 1.0, "id_atomic_world_min": 1.0, "id_atomic_world_max": 1.0, "id_atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "ood_atomic": 1.0, "ood_atomic_world_min": 1.0, "ood_atomic_world_max": 1.0, "ood_atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "train_composite": 1.0, "train_composite_world_min": 1.0, "train_composite_world_max": 1.0, "train_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "test_full_composite": 1.0, "test_full_composite_world_min": 1.0, "test_full_composite_world_max": 1.0, "test_full_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "ood_composite": 0.03518518518518519, "ood_composite_world_min": 0.03518518518518519, "ood_composite_world_max": 0.03518518518518519, "ood_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "autonomous_calls": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_world_min": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_world_max": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "condition_id": "f3e74cc7add23e73", "phase": "development", "hops": 2, "architecture": "l2", "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "parameters": 416512, "effective_depth": 4, "worlds": 1, "runs": 1, "atomic": 1.0, "atomic_world_min": 1.0, "atomic_world_max": 1.0, "atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "id_atomic": 1.0, "id_atomic_world_min": 1.0, "id_atomic_world_max": 1.0, "id_atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "ood_atomic": 1.0, "ood_atomic_world_min": 1.0, "ood_atomic_world_max": 1.0, "ood_atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "train_composite": 1.0, "train_composite_world_min": 1.0, "train_composite_world_max": 1.0, "train_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "test_full_composite": 1.0, "test_full_composite_world_min": 1.0, "test_full_composite_world_max": 1.0, "test_full_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "ood_composite": 0.06481481481481481, "ood_composite_world_min": 0.06481481481481481, "ood_composite_world_max": 0.06481481481481481, "ood_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "autonomous_calls": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_world_min": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_world_max": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "condition_id": "c717c0be7e6b6da2", "phase": "development", "hops": 3, "architecture": "c1", "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "parameters": 218240, "effective_depth": 1, "worlds": 1, "runs": 1, "atomic": 1.0, "atomic_world_min": 1.0, "atomic_world_max": 1.0, "atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "id_atomic": 1.0, "id_atomic_world_min": 1.0, "id_atomic_world_max": 1.0, "id_atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "ood_atomic": 1.0, "ood_atomic_world_min": 1.0, "ood_atomic_world_max": 1.0, "ood_atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "train_composite": 0.9987521701388888, "train_composite_world_min": 0.9987521701388888, "train_composite_world_max": 0.9987521701388888, "train_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "test_full_composite": 0.5862815884476534, "test_full_composite_world_min": 0.5862815884476534, "test_full_composite_world_max": 0.5862815884476534, "test_full_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "ood_composite": 0.0067226890756302525, "ood_composite_world_min": 0.0067226890756302525, "ood_composite_world_max": 0.0067226890756302525, "ood_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "autonomous_calls": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_world_min": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_world_max": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "condition_id": "a973172f41d4d782", "phase": "development", "hops": 3, "architecture": "c2", "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "parameters": 416512, "effective_depth": 2, "worlds": 1, "runs": 1, "atomic": 1.0, "atomic_world_min": 1.0, "atomic_world_max": 1.0, "atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "id_atomic": 1.0, "id_atomic_world_min": 1.0, "id_atomic_world_max": 1.0, "id_atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "ood_atomic": 1.0, "ood_atomic_world_min": 1.0, "ood_atomic_world_max": 1.0, "ood_atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "train_composite": 1.0, "train_composite_world_min": 1.0, "train_composite_world_max": 1.0, "train_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "test_full_composite": 0.9653429602888086, "test_full_composite_world_min": 0.9653429602888086, "test_full_composite_world_max": 0.9653429602888086, "test_full_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "ood_composite": 0.0058823529411764705, "ood_composite_world_min": 0.0058823529411764705, "ood_composite_world_max": 0.0058823529411764705, "ood_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "autonomous_calls": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_world_min": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_world_max": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "condition_id": "48de6046c8a24197", "phase": "development", "hops": 3, "architecture": "cd", "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "parameters": 813056, "effective_depth": 4, "worlds": 1, "runs": 1, "atomic": 0.9990234375, "atomic_world_min": 0.9990234375, "atomic_world_max": 0.9990234375, "atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "id_atomic": 0.9986979166666666, "id_atomic_world_min": 0.9986979166666666, "id_atomic_world_max": 0.9986979166666666, "id_atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "ood_atomic": 1.0, "ood_atomic_world_min": 1.0, "ood_atomic_world_max": 1.0, "ood_atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "train_composite": 0.9999457465277778, "train_composite_world_min": 0.9999457465277778, "train_composite_world_max": 0.9999457465277778, "train_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "test_full_composite": 0.9902527075812274, "test_full_composite_world_min": 0.9902527075812274, "test_full_composite_world_max": 0.9902527075812274, "test_full_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "ood_composite": 0.0058823529411764705, "ood_composite_world_min": 0.0058823529411764705, "ood_composite_world_max": 0.0058823529411764705, "ood_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "autonomous_calls": 0.9970703125, "autonomous_calls_world_min": 0.9970703125, "autonomous_calls_world_max": 0.9970703125, "autonomous_calls_worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "condition_id": "76de5e5e805d58a3", "phase": "development", "hops": 3, "architecture": "l1", "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "parameters": 218240, "effective_depth": 4, "worlds": 1, "runs": 1, "atomic": 1.0, "atomic_world_min": 1.0, "atomic_world_max": 1.0, "atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "id_atomic": 1.0, "id_atomic_world_min": 1.0, "id_atomic_world_max": 1.0, "id_atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "ood_atomic": 1.0, "ood_atomic_world_min": 1.0, "ood_atomic_world_max": 1.0, "ood_atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "train_composite": 1.0, "train_composite_world_min": 1.0, "train_composite_world_max": 1.0, "train_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "test_full_composite": 1.0, "test_full_composite_world_min": 1.0, "test_full_composite_world_max": 1.0, "test_full_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "ood_composite": 0.005042016806722689, "ood_composite_world_min": 0.005042016806722689, "ood_composite_world_max": 0.005042016806722689, "ood_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "autonomous_calls": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_world_min": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_world_max": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "condition_id": "3bff21339ec73e55", "phase": "development", "hops": 3, "architecture": "l2", "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "parameters": 416512, "effective_depth": 4, "worlds": 1, "runs": 1, "atomic": 1.0, "atomic_world_min": 1.0, "atomic_world_max": 1.0, "atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "id_atomic": 1.0, "id_atomic_world_min": 1.0, "id_atomic_world_max": 1.0, "id_atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "ood_atomic": 1.0, "ood_atomic_world_min": 1.0, "ood_atomic_world_max": 1.0, "ood_atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "train_composite": 1.0, "train_composite_world_min": 1.0, "train_composite_world_max": 1.0, "train_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "test_full_composite": 1.0, "test_full_composite_world_min": 1.0, "test_full_composite_world_max": 1.0, "test_full_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "ood_composite": 0.011764705882352941, "ood_composite_world_min": 0.011764705882352941, "ood_composite_world_max": 0.011764705882352941, "ood_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "autonomous_calls": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_world_min": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_world_max": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "condition_id": "fe55342862cee23c", "phase": "development", "hops": 4, "architecture": "c1", "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "parameters": 218240, "effective_depth": 1, "worlds": 1, "runs": 1, "atomic": 1.0, "atomic_world_min": 1.0, "atomic_world_max": 1.0, "atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "id_atomic": 1.0, "id_atomic_world_min": 1.0, "id_atomic_world_max": 1.0, "id_atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "ood_atomic": 1.0, "ood_atomic_world_min": 1.0, "ood_atomic_world_max": 1.0, "ood_atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "train_composite": 0.6619466145833334, "train_composite_world_min": 0.6619466145833334, "train_composite_world_max": 0.6619466145833334, "train_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "test_full_composite": 0.39707276605830766, "test_full_composite_world_min": 0.39707276605830766, "test_full_composite_world_max": 0.39707276605830766, "test_full_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "ood_composite": 0.005686125852918878, "ood_composite_world_min": 0.005686125852918878, "ood_composite_world_max": 0.005686125852918878, "ood_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "autonomous_calls": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_world_min": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_world_max": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "condition_id": "dfd9e83c411560b8", "phase": "development", "hops": 4, "architecture": "c2", "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "parameters": 416512, "effective_depth": 2, "worlds": 1, "runs": 1, "atomic": 1.0, "atomic_world_min": 1.0, "atomic_world_max": 1.0, "atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "id_atomic": 1.0, "id_atomic_world_min": 1.0, "id_atomic_world_max": 1.0, "id_atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "ood_atomic": 1.0, "ood_atomic_world_min": 1.0, "ood_atomic_world_max": 1.0, "ood_atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "train_composite": 0.9893256293402778, "train_composite_world_min": 0.9893256293402778, "train_composite_world_max": 0.9893256293402778, "train_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "test_full_composite": 0.8653709409812752, "test_full_composite_world_min": 0.8653709409812752, "test_full_composite_world_max": 0.8653709409812752, "test_full_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "ood_composite": 0.0037907505686125853, "ood_composite_world_min": 0.0037907505686125853, "ood_composite_world_max": 0.0037907505686125853, "ood_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "autonomous_calls": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_world_min": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_world_max": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "condition_id": "13ee061cd9edeeea", "phase": "development", "hops": 4, "architecture": "cd", "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "parameters": 1209600, "effective_depth": 6, "worlds": 1, "runs": 1, "atomic": 1.0, "atomic_world_min": 1.0, "atomic_world_max": 1.0, "atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "id_atomic": 1.0, "id_atomic_world_min": 1.0, "id_atomic_world_max": 1.0, "id_atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "ood_atomic": 1.0, "ood_atomic_world_min": 1.0, "ood_atomic_world_max": 1.0, "ood_atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "train_composite": 1.0, "train_composite_world_min": 1.0, "train_composite_world_max": 1.0, "train_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "test_full_composite": 1.0, "test_full_composite_world_min": 1.0, "test_full_composite_world_max": 1.0, "test_full_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "ood_composite": 0.008339651250947688, "ood_composite_world_min": 0.008339651250947688, "ood_composite_world_max": 0.008339651250947688, "ood_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "autonomous_calls": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_world_min": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_world_max": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "condition_id": "b8c6c5380ee8a972", "phase": "development", "hops": 4, "architecture": "l1", "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "parameters": 218240, "effective_depth": 6, "worlds": 1, "runs": 1, "atomic": 1.0, "atomic_world_min": 1.0, "atomic_world_max": 1.0, "atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "id_atomic": 1.0, "id_atomic_world_min": 1.0, "id_atomic_world_max": 1.0, "id_atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "ood_atomic": 1.0, "ood_atomic_world_min": 1.0, "ood_atomic_world_max": 1.0, "ood_atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "train_composite": 0.9999864366319444, "train_composite_world_min": 0.9999864366319444, "train_composite_world_max": 0.9999864366319444, "train_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "test_full_composite": 1.0, "test_full_composite_world_min": 1.0, "test_full_composite_world_max": 1.0, "test_full_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "ood_composite": 0.006065200909780136, "ood_composite_world_min": 0.006065200909780136, "ood_composite_world_max": 0.006065200909780136, "ood_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "autonomous_calls": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_world_min": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_world_max": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "condition_id": "d49177bf03453f8b", "phase": "development", "hops": 4, "architecture": "l2", "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "parameters": 416512, "effective_depth": 6, "worlds": 1, "runs": 1, "atomic": 1.0, "atomic_world_min": 1.0, "atomic_world_max": 1.0, "atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "id_atomic": 1.0, "id_atomic_world_min": 1.0, "id_atomic_world_max": 1.0, "id_atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "ood_atomic": 1.0, "ood_atomic_world_min": 1.0, "ood_atomic_world_max": 1.0, "ood_atomic_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "train_composite": 1.0, "train_composite_world_min": 1.0, "train_composite_world_max": 1.0, "train_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "test_full_composite": 1.0, "test_full_composite_world_min": 1.0, "test_full_composite_world_max": 1.0, "test_full_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "ood_composite": 0.006444275966641395, "ood_composite_world_min": 0.006444275966641395, "ood_composite_world_max": 0.006444275966641395, "ood_composite_worlds_with_denominator": 1, "autonomous_calls": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_world_min": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_world_max": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_worlds_with_denominator": 1 } ], "endpoints": [ { "run": "dev-h2-c1", "condition_id": "a4615c750f7f36c3", "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "phase": "development", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "hops": 2, "architecture": "c1", "unique_layers": 1, "repeats": 1, "effective_depth": 1, "steps": 128000, "parameters": 218240, "training_flops": 162772549632000, "training_seconds": 184.2926154132001, "evaluation_seconds": 2.914384074974805, "atomic_exposures": 4096000, "composite_exposures": 28672000, "atomic": 1.0, "atomic_n": 1024, "id_atomic": 1.0, "id_atomic_n": 768, "ood_atomic": 1.0, "ood_atomic_n": 256, "train_composite": 1.0, "train_composite_n": 4182, "test_composite": 0.3430493273542601, "test_composite_n": 446, "test_full_composite": 0.3430493273542601, "test_full_composite_n": 446, "ood_composite": 0.016666666666666666, "ood_composite_n": 540, "autonomous_calls": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_n": 446, "T90_probe_first_observed_step": null, "T90_probe_first_observed_flops": null, "T90_probe_first_observed_accuracy": null, "T95_probe_first_observed_step": null, "T95_probe_first_observed_flops": null, "T95_probe_first_observed_accuracy": null }, { "run": "dev-h2-c2", "condition_id": "602482e3080366f4", "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "phase": "development", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "hops": 2, "architecture": "c2", "unique_layers": 2, "repeats": 1, "effective_depth": 2, "steps": 128000, "parameters": 416512, "training_flops": 318196678656000, "training_seconds": 243.2509038897697, "evaluation_seconds": 3.048966607777402, "atomic_exposures": 4096000, "composite_exposures": 28672000, "atomic": 1.0, "atomic_n": 1024, "id_atomic": 1.0, "id_atomic_n": 768, "ood_atomic": 1.0, "ood_atomic_n": 256, "train_composite": 1.0, "train_composite_n": 4182, "test_composite": 0.9551569506726457, "test_composite_n": 446, "test_full_composite": 0.9551569506726457, "test_full_composite_n": 446, "ood_composite": 0.012962962962962963, "ood_composite_n": 540, "autonomous_calls": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_n": 446, "T90_probe_first_observed_step": 40000, "T90_probe_first_observed_flops": 99436462080000, "T90_probe_first_observed_accuracy": 0.9125560538116592, "T95_probe_first_observed_step": 80000, "T95_probe_first_observed_flops": 198872924160000, "T95_probe_first_observed_accuracy": 0.9551569506726457 }, { "run": "dev-h2-cd", "condition_id": "76cf70e81009bf6b", "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "phase": "development", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "hops": 2, "architecture": "cd", "unique_layers": 4, "repeats": 1, "effective_depth": 4, "steps": 128000, "parameters": 813056, "training_flops": 629044936704000, "training_seconds": 350.6763046440901, "evaluation_seconds": 3.290558652370237, "atomic_exposures": 4096000, "composite_exposures": 28672000, "atomic": 1.0, "atomic_n": 1024, "id_atomic": 1.0, "id_atomic_n": 768, "ood_atomic": 1.0, "ood_atomic_n": 256, "train_composite": 1.0, "train_composite_n": 4182, "test_composite": 0.9820627802690582, "test_composite_n": 446, "test_full_composite": 0.9820627802690582, "test_full_composite_n": 446, "ood_composite": 0.012962962962962963, "ood_composite_n": 540, "autonomous_calls": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_n": 446, "T90_probe_first_observed_step": 24000, "T90_probe_first_observed_flops": 117945925632000, "T90_probe_first_observed_accuracy": 0.9170403587443946, "T95_probe_first_observed_step": 56000, "T95_probe_first_observed_flops": 275207159808000, "T95_probe_first_observed_accuracy": 0.9596412556053812 }, { "run": "dev-h2-l1", "condition_id": "742932b69f8855d9", "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "phase": "development", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "hops": 2, "architecture": "l1", "unique_layers": 1, "repeats": 4, "effective_depth": 4, "steps": 128000, "parameters": 218240, "training_flops": 629044936704000, "training_seconds": 344.08243403350934, "evaluation_seconds": 3.0297688278369606, "atomic_exposures": 4096000, "composite_exposures": 28672000, "atomic": 1.0, "atomic_n": 1024, "id_atomic": 1.0, "id_atomic_n": 768, "ood_atomic": 1.0, "ood_atomic_n": 256, "train_composite": 1.0, "train_composite_n": 4182, "test_composite": 1.0, "test_composite_n": 446, "test_full_composite": 1.0, "test_full_composite_n": 446, "ood_composite": 0.03518518518518519, "ood_composite_n": 540, "autonomous_calls": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_n": 446, "T90_probe_first_observed_step": 8000, "T90_probe_first_observed_flops": 39315308544000, "T90_probe_first_observed_accuracy": 0.9394618834080718, "T95_probe_first_observed_step": 10000, "T95_probe_first_observed_flops": 49144135680000, "T95_probe_first_observed_accuracy": 0.9730941704035875 }, { "run": "dev-h2-l2", "condition_id": "f3e74cc7add23e73", "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "phase": "development", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "hops": 2, "architecture": "l2", "unique_layers": 2, "repeats": 2, "effective_depth": 4, "steps": 128000, "parameters": 416512, "training_flops": 629044936704000, "training_seconds": 344.27214216801804, "evaluation_seconds": 3.59204867167864, "atomic_exposures": 4096000, "composite_exposures": 28672000, "atomic": 1.0, "atomic_n": 1024, "id_atomic": 1.0, "id_atomic_n": 768, "ood_atomic": 1.0, "ood_atomic_n": 256, "train_composite": 1.0, "train_composite_n": 4182, "test_composite": 1.0, "test_composite_n": 446, "test_full_composite": 1.0, "test_full_composite_n": 446, "ood_composite": 0.06481481481481481, "ood_composite_n": 540, "autonomous_calls": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_n": 446, "T90_probe_first_observed_step": 10000, "T90_probe_first_observed_flops": 49144135680000, "T90_probe_first_observed_accuracy": 0.9282511210762332, "T95_probe_first_observed_step": 12000, "T95_probe_first_observed_flops": 58972962816000, "T95_probe_first_observed_accuracy": 0.968609865470852 }, { "run": "dev-h3-c1", "condition_id": "c717c0be7e6b6da2", "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "phase": "development", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "hops": 3, "architecture": "c1", "unique_layers": 1, "repeats": 1, "effective_depth": 1, "steps": 128000, "parameters": 218240, "training_flops": 201880240128000, "training_seconds": 173.40862517792266, "evaluation_seconds": 7.4474903353257105, "atomic_exposures": 4096000, "composite_exposures": 28672000, "atomic": 1.0, "atomic_n": 1024, "id_atomic": 1.0, "id_atomic_n": 768, "ood_atomic": 1.0, "ood_atomic_n": 256, "train_composite": 0.9987521701388888, "train_composite_n": 18432, "test_composite": 0.55078125, "test_composite_n": 1024, "test_full_composite": 0.5862815884476534, "test_full_composite_n": 2770, "ood_composite": 0.0067226890756302525, "ood_composite_n": 1190, "autonomous_calls": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_n": 1024, "T90_probe_first_observed_step": null, "T90_probe_first_observed_flops": null, "T90_probe_first_observed_accuracy": null, "T95_probe_first_observed_step": null, "T95_probe_first_observed_flops": null, "T95_probe_first_observed_accuracy": null }, { "run": "dev-h3-c2", "condition_id": "a973172f41d4d782", "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "phase": "development", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "hops": 3, "architecture": "c2", "unique_layers": 2, "repeats": 1, "effective_depth": 2, "steps": 128000, "parameters": 416512, "training_flops": 396412059648000, "training_seconds": 236.0812059348682, "evaluation_seconds": 8.028292798670009, "atomic_exposures": 4096000, "composite_exposures": 28672000, "atomic": 1.0, "atomic_n": 1024, "id_atomic": 1.0, "id_atomic_n": 768, "ood_atomic": 1.0, "ood_atomic_n": 256, "train_composite": 1.0, "train_composite_n": 18432, "test_composite": 0.9658203125, "test_composite_n": 1024, "test_full_composite": 0.9653429602888086, "test_full_composite_n": 2770, "ood_composite": 0.0058823529411764705, "ood_composite_n": 1190, "autonomous_calls": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_n": 1024, "T90_probe_first_observed_step": 32000, "T90_probe_first_observed_flops": 99103014912000, "T90_probe_first_observed_accuracy": 0.9091796875, "T95_probe_first_observed_step": 72000, "T95_probe_first_observed_flops": 222981783552000, "T95_probe_first_observed_accuracy": 0.9521484375 }, { "run": "dev-h3-cd", "condition_id": "48de6046c8a24197", "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "phase": "development", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "hops": 3, "architecture": "cd", "unique_layers": 4, "repeats": 1, "effective_depth": 4, "steps": 128000, "parameters": 813056, "training_flops": 785475698688000, "training_seconds": 355.66244074178394, "evaluation_seconds": 8.174604018218815, "atomic_exposures": 4096000, "composite_exposures": 28672000, "atomic": 0.9990234375, "atomic_n": 1024, "id_atomic": 0.9986979166666666, "id_atomic_n": 768, "ood_atomic": 1.0, "ood_atomic_n": 256, "train_composite": 0.9999457465277778, "train_composite_n": 18432, "test_composite": 0.9873046875, "test_composite_n": 1024, "test_full_composite": 0.9902527075812274, "test_full_composite_n": 2770, "ood_composite": 0.0058823529411764705, "ood_composite_n": 1190, "autonomous_calls": 0.9970703125, "autonomous_calls_n": 1024, "T90_probe_first_observed_step": 24000, "T90_probe_first_observed_flops": 147276693504000, "T90_probe_first_observed_accuracy": 0.9453125, "T95_probe_first_observed_step": 32000, "T95_probe_first_observed_flops": 196368924672000, "T95_probe_first_observed_accuracy": 0.9560546875 }, { "run": "dev-h3-l1", "condition_id": "76de5e5e805d58a3", "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "phase": "development", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "hops": 3, "architecture": "l1", "unique_layers": 1, "repeats": 4, "effective_depth": 4, "steps": 128000, "parameters": 218240, "training_flops": 785475698688000, "training_seconds": 318.59010821499396, "evaluation_seconds": 6.552388378651813, "atomic_exposures": 4096000, "composite_exposures": 28672000, "atomic": 1.0, "atomic_n": 1024, "id_atomic": 1.0, "id_atomic_n": 768, "ood_atomic": 1.0, "ood_atomic_n": 256, "train_composite": 1.0, "train_composite_n": 18432, "test_composite": 1.0, "test_composite_n": 1024, "test_full_composite": 1.0, "test_full_composite_n": 2770, "ood_composite": 0.005042016806722689, "ood_composite_n": 1190, "autonomous_calls": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_n": 1024, "T90_probe_first_observed_step": 12000, "T90_probe_first_observed_flops": 73638346752000, "T90_probe_first_observed_accuracy": 0.96875, "T95_probe_first_observed_step": 12000, "T95_probe_first_observed_flops": 73638346752000, "T95_probe_first_observed_accuracy": 0.96875 }, { "run": "dev-h3-l2", "condition_id": "3bff21339ec73e55", "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "phase": "development", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "hops": 3, "architecture": "l2", "unique_layers": 2, "repeats": 2, "effective_depth": 4, "steps": 128000, "parameters": 416512, "training_flops": 785475698688000, "training_seconds": 346.86875476897694, "evaluation_seconds": 8.262606639880687, "atomic_exposures": 4096000, "composite_exposures": 28672000, "atomic": 1.0, "atomic_n": 1024, "id_atomic": 1.0, "id_atomic_n": 768, "ood_atomic": 1.0, "ood_atomic_n": 256, "train_composite": 1.0, "train_composite_n": 18432, "test_composite": 1.0, "test_composite_n": 1024, "test_full_composite": 1.0, "test_full_composite_n": 2770, "ood_composite": 0.011764705882352941, "ood_composite_n": 1190, "autonomous_calls": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_n": 1024, "T90_probe_first_observed_step": 12000, "T90_probe_first_observed_flops": 73638346752000, "T90_probe_first_observed_accuracy": 0.9443359375, "T95_probe_first_observed_step": 14000, "T95_probe_first_observed_flops": 85911404544000, "T95_probe_first_observed_accuracy": 0.9775390625 }, { "run": "dev-h4-c1", "condition_id": "fe55342862cee23c", "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "phase": "development", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "hops": 4, "architecture": "c1", "unique_layers": 1, "repeats": 1, "effective_depth": 1, "steps": 128000, "parameters": 218240, "training_flops": 241088593920000, "training_seconds": 192.4213421937311, "evaluation_seconds": 24.841903114225715, "atomic_exposures": 4096000, "composite_exposures": 28672000, "atomic": 1.0, "atomic_n": 1024, "id_atomic": 1.0, "id_atomic_n": 768, "ood_atomic": 1.0, "ood_atomic_n": 256, "train_composite": 0.6619466145833334, "train_composite_n": 73728, "test_composite": 0.3828125, "test_composite_n": 1024, "test_full_composite": 0.39707276605830766, "test_full_composite_n": 16876, "ood_composite": 0.005686125852918878, "ood_composite_n": 2638, "autonomous_calls": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_n": 1024, "T90_probe_first_observed_step": null, "T90_probe_first_observed_flops": null, "T90_probe_first_observed_accuracy": null, "T95_probe_first_observed_step": null, "T95_probe_first_observed_flops": null, "T95_probe_first_observed_accuracy": null }, { "run": "dev-h4-c2", "condition_id": "dfd9e83c411560b8", "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "phase": "development", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "hops": 4, "architecture": "c2", "unique_layers": 2, "repeats": 1, "effective_depth": 2, "steps": 128000, "parameters": 416512, "training_flops": 474828767232000, "training_seconds": 238.89593142585363, "evaluation_seconds": 24.233616202371195, "atomic_exposures": 4096000, "composite_exposures": 28672000, "atomic": 1.0, "atomic_n": 1024, "id_atomic": 1.0, "id_atomic_n": 768, "ood_atomic": 1.0, "ood_atomic_n": 256, "train_composite": 0.9893256293402778, "train_composite_n": 73728, "test_composite": 0.84375, "test_composite_n": 1024, "test_full_composite": 0.8653709409812752, "test_full_composite_n": 16876, "ood_composite": 0.0037907505686125853, "ood_composite_n": 2638, "autonomous_calls": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_n": 1024, "T90_probe_first_observed_step": null, "T90_probe_first_observed_flops": null, "T90_probe_first_observed_accuracy": null, "T95_probe_first_observed_step": null, "T95_probe_first_observed_flops": null, "T95_probe_first_observed_accuracy": null }, { "run": "dev-h4-cd", "condition_id": "13ee061cd9edeeea", "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "phase": "development", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "hops": 4, "architecture": "cd", "unique_layers": 6, "repeats": 1, "effective_depth": 6, "steps": 128000, "parameters": 1209600, "training_flops": 1409789460480000, "training_seconds": 497.3571648686193, "evaluation_seconds": 21.92456920084078, "atomic_exposures": 4096000, "composite_exposures": 28672000, "atomic": 1.0, "atomic_n": 1024, "id_atomic": 1.0, "id_atomic_n": 768, "ood_atomic": 1.0, "ood_atomic_n": 256, "train_composite": 1.0, "train_composite_n": 73728, "test_composite": 1.0, "test_composite_n": 1024, "test_full_composite": 1.0, "test_full_composite_n": 16876, "ood_composite": 0.008339651250947688, "ood_composite_n": 2638, "autonomous_calls": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_n": 1024, "T90_probe_first_observed_step": 24000, "T90_probe_first_observed_flops": 264335523840000, "T90_probe_first_observed_accuracy": 0.9912109375, "T95_probe_first_observed_step": 24000, "T95_probe_first_observed_flops": 264335523840000, "T95_probe_first_observed_accuracy": 0.9912109375 }, { "run": "dev-h4-l1", "condition_id": "b8c6c5380ee8a972", "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "phase": "development", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "hops": 4, "architecture": "l1", "unique_layers": 1, "repeats": 6, "effective_depth": 6, "steps": 128000, "parameters": 218240, "training_flops": 1409789460480000, "training_seconds": 333.5497827772051, "evaluation_seconds": 17.821375466533937, "atomic_exposures": 4096000, "composite_exposures": 28672000, "atomic": 1.0, "atomic_n": 1024, "id_atomic": 1.0, "id_atomic_n": 768, "ood_atomic": 1.0, "ood_atomic_n": 256, "train_composite": 0.9999864366319444, "train_composite_n": 73728, "test_composite": 1.0, "test_composite_n": 1024, "test_full_composite": 1.0, "test_full_composite_n": 16876, "ood_composite": 0.006065200909780136, "ood_composite_n": 2638, "autonomous_calls": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_n": 1024, "T90_probe_first_observed_step": 14000, "T90_probe_first_observed_flops": 154195722240000, "T90_probe_first_observed_accuracy": 0.9912109375, "T95_probe_first_observed_step": 14000, "T95_probe_first_observed_flops": 154195722240000, "T95_probe_first_observed_accuracy": 0.9912109375 }, { "run": "dev-h4-l2", "condition_id": "d49177bf03453f8b", "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "phase": "development", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "hops": 4, "architecture": "l2", "unique_layers": 2, "repeats": 3, "effective_depth": 6, "steps": 128000, "parameters": 416512, "training_flops": 1409789460480000, "training_seconds": 498.54842900764197, "evaluation_seconds": 24.162046278826892, "atomic_exposures": 4096000, "composite_exposures": 28672000, "atomic": 1.0, "atomic_n": 1024, "id_atomic": 1.0, "id_atomic_n": 768, "ood_atomic": 1.0, "ood_atomic_n": 256, "train_composite": 1.0, "train_composite_n": 73728, "test_composite": 1.0, "test_composite_n": 1024, "test_full_composite": 1.0, "test_full_composite_n": 16876, "ood_composite": 0.006444275966641395, "ood_composite_n": 2638, "autonomous_calls": 1.0, "autonomous_calls_n": 1024, "T90_probe_first_observed_step": 14000, "T90_probe_first_observed_flops": 154195722240000, "T90_probe_first_observed_accuracy": 0.96875, "T95_probe_first_observed_step": 14000, "T95_probe_first_observed_flops": 154195722240000, "T95_probe_first_observed_accuracy": 0.96875 } ], "conditional_subsets": [ { "run": "dev-h2-c1", "condition_id": "a4615c750f7f36c3", "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "phase": "development", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "hops": 2, "architecture": "c1", "unique_layers": 1, "repeats": 1, "effective_depth": 1, "test_full_composite": { "all_atoms_correct_n": 446, "all_atoms_correct_coverage": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_accuracy": 0.3430493273542601, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_n": 378, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_coverage": 0.8475336322869955, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_accuracy": 0.3492063492063492, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_n": 378, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_coverage": 0.8475336322869955, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_accuracy": 0.3492063492063492 }, "ood_composite": { "all_atoms_correct_n": 540, "all_atoms_correct_coverage": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_accuracy": 0.016666666666666666, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_n": 447, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_coverage": 0.8277777777777777, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_accuracy": 0.020134228187919462, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_n": 447, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_coverage": 0.8277777777777777, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_accuracy": 0.020134228187919462 } }, { "run": "dev-h2-c2", "condition_id": "602482e3080366f4", "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "phase": "development", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "hops": 2, "architecture": "c2", "unique_layers": 2, "repeats": 1, "effective_depth": 2, "test_full_composite": { "all_atoms_correct_n": 446, "all_atoms_correct_coverage": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_accuracy": 0.9551569506726457, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_n": 378, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_coverage": 0.8475336322869955, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_accuracy": 0.9523809523809523, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_n": 378, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_coverage": 0.8475336322869955, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_accuracy": 0.9523809523809523 }, "ood_composite": { "all_atoms_correct_n": 540, "all_atoms_correct_coverage": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_accuracy": 0.012962962962962963, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_n": 447, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_coverage": 0.8277777777777777, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_accuracy": 0.013422818791946308, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_n": 447, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_coverage": 0.8277777777777777, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_accuracy": 0.013422818791946308 } }, { "run": "dev-h2-cd", "condition_id": "76cf70e81009bf6b", "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "phase": "development", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "hops": 2, "architecture": "cd", "unique_layers": 4, "repeats": 1, "effective_depth": 4, "test_full_composite": { "all_atoms_correct_n": 446, "all_atoms_correct_coverage": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_accuracy": 0.9820627802690582, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_n": 378, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_coverage": 0.8475336322869955, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_accuracy": 0.9788359788359788, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_n": 378, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_coverage": 0.8475336322869955, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_accuracy": 0.9788359788359788 }, "ood_composite": { "all_atoms_correct_n": 540, "all_atoms_correct_coverage": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_accuracy": 0.012962962962962963, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_n": 447, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_coverage": 0.8277777777777777, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_accuracy": 0.015659955257270694, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_n": 447, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_coverage": 0.8277777777777777, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_accuracy": 0.015659955257270694 } }, { "run": "dev-h2-l1", "condition_id": "742932b69f8855d9", "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "phase": "development", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "hops": 2, "architecture": "l1", "unique_layers": 1, "repeats": 4, "effective_depth": 4, "test_full_composite": { "all_atoms_correct_n": 446, "all_atoms_correct_coverage": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_accuracy": 1.0, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_n": 378, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_coverage": 0.8475336322869955, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_accuracy": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_n": 378, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_coverage": 0.8475336322869955, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_accuracy": 1.0 }, "ood_composite": { "all_atoms_correct_n": 540, "all_atoms_correct_coverage": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_accuracy": 0.03518518518518519, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_n": 447, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_coverage": 0.8277777777777777, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_accuracy": 0.040268456375838924, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_n": 447, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_coverage": 0.8277777777777777, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_accuracy": 0.040268456375838924 } }, { "run": "dev-h2-l2", "condition_id": "f3e74cc7add23e73", "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "phase": "development", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "hops": 2, "architecture": "l2", "unique_layers": 2, "repeats": 2, "effective_depth": 4, "test_full_composite": { "all_atoms_correct_n": 446, "all_atoms_correct_coverage": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_accuracy": 1.0, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_n": 378, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_coverage": 0.8475336322869955, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_accuracy": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_n": 378, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_coverage": 0.8475336322869955, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_accuracy": 1.0 }, "ood_composite": { "all_atoms_correct_n": 540, "all_atoms_correct_coverage": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_accuracy": 0.06481481481481481, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_n": 447, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_coverage": 0.8277777777777777, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_accuracy": 0.06711409395973154, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_n": 447, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_coverage": 0.8277777777777777, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_accuracy": 0.06711409395973154 } }, { "run": "dev-h3-c1", "condition_id": "c717c0be7e6b6da2", "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "phase": "development", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "hops": 3, "architecture": "c1", "unique_layers": 1, "repeats": 1, "effective_depth": 1, "test_full_composite": { "all_atoms_correct_n": 2770, "all_atoms_correct_coverage": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_accuracy": 0.5862815884476534, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_n": 1308, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_coverage": 0.47220216606498194, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_accuracy": 0.5642201834862385, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_n": 1308, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_coverage": 0.47220216606498194, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_accuracy": 0.5642201834862385 }, "ood_composite": { "all_atoms_correct_n": 1190, "all_atoms_correct_coverage": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_accuracy": 0.0067226890756302525, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_n": 253, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_coverage": 0.21260504201680672, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_accuracy": 0.007905138339920948, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_n": 253, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_coverage": 0.21260504201680672, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_accuracy": 0.007905138339920948 } }, { "run": "dev-h3-c2", "condition_id": "a973172f41d4d782", "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "phase": "development", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "hops": 3, "architecture": "c2", "unique_layers": 2, "repeats": 1, "effective_depth": 2, "test_full_composite": { "all_atoms_correct_n": 2770, "all_atoms_correct_coverage": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_accuracy": 0.9653429602888086, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_n": 1308, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_coverage": 0.47220216606498194, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_accuracy": 0.9579510703363915, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_n": 1308, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_coverage": 0.47220216606498194, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_accuracy": 0.9579510703363915 }, "ood_composite": { "all_atoms_correct_n": 1190, "all_atoms_correct_coverage": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_accuracy": 0.0058823529411764705, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_n": 253, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_coverage": 0.21260504201680672, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_accuracy": 0.0, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_n": 253, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_coverage": 0.21260504201680672, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_accuracy": 0.0 } }, { "run": "dev-h3-cd", "condition_id": "48de6046c8a24197", "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "phase": "development", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "hops": 3, "architecture": "cd", "unique_layers": 4, "repeats": 1, "effective_depth": 4, "test_full_composite": { "all_atoms_correct_n": 2761, "all_atoms_correct_coverage": 0.9967509025270758, "all_atoms_correct_accuracy": 0.990220934444042, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_n": 1308, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_coverage": 0.47220216606498194, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_accuracy": 0.9870030581039755, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_n": 1302, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_coverage": 0.4700361010830325, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_accuracy": 0.9869431643625192 }, "ood_composite": { "all_atoms_correct_n": 1190, "all_atoms_correct_coverage": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_accuracy": 0.0058823529411764705, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_n": 253, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_coverage": 0.21260504201680672, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_accuracy": 0.015810276679841896, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_n": 253, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_coverage": 0.21260504201680672, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_accuracy": 0.015810276679841896 } }, { "run": "dev-h3-l1", "condition_id": "76de5e5e805d58a3", "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "phase": "development", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "hops": 3, "architecture": "l1", "unique_layers": 1, "repeats": 4, "effective_depth": 4, "test_full_composite": { "all_atoms_correct_n": 2770, "all_atoms_correct_coverage": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_accuracy": 1.0, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_n": 1308, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_coverage": 0.47220216606498194, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_accuracy": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_n": 1308, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_coverage": 0.47220216606498194, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_accuracy": 1.0 }, "ood_composite": { "all_atoms_correct_n": 1190, "all_atoms_correct_coverage": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_accuracy": 0.005042016806722689, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_n": 253, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_coverage": 0.21260504201680672, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_accuracy": 0.0, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_n": 253, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_coverage": 0.21260504201680672, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_accuracy": 0.0 } }, { "run": "dev-h3-l2", "condition_id": "3bff21339ec73e55", "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "phase": "development", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "hops": 3, "architecture": "l2", "unique_layers": 2, "repeats": 2, "effective_depth": 4, "test_full_composite": { "all_atoms_correct_n": 2770, "all_atoms_correct_coverage": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_accuracy": 1.0, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_n": 1308, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_coverage": 0.47220216606498194, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_accuracy": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_n": 1308, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_coverage": 0.47220216606498194, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_accuracy": 1.0 }, "ood_composite": { "all_atoms_correct_n": 1190, "all_atoms_correct_coverage": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_accuracy": 0.011764705882352941, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_n": 253, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_coverage": 0.21260504201680672, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_accuracy": 0.011857707509881422, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_n": 253, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_coverage": 0.21260504201680672, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_accuracy": 0.011857707509881422 } }, { "run": "dev-h4-c1", "condition_id": "fe55342862cee23c", "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "phase": "development", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "hops": 4, "architecture": "c1", "unique_layers": 1, "repeats": 1, "effective_depth": 1, "test_full_composite": { "all_atoms_correct_n": 16876, "all_atoms_correct_coverage": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_accuracy": 0.39707276605830766, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_n": 3728, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_coverage": 0.22090542782649916, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_accuracy": 0.36105150214592274, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_n": 3728, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_coverage": 0.22090542782649916, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_accuracy": 0.36105150214592274 }, "ood_composite": { "all_atoms_correct_n": 2638, "all_atoms_correct_coverage": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_accuracy": 0.005686125852918878, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_n": 87, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_coverage": 0.032979529946929494, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_accuracy": 0.022988505747126436, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_n": 87, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_coverage": 0.032979529946929494, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_accuracy": 0.022988505747126436 } }, { "run": "dev-h4-c2", "condition_id": "dfd9e83c411560b8", "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "phase": "development", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "hops": 4, "architecture": "c2", "unique_layers": 2, "repeats": 1, "effective_depth": 2, "test_full_composite": { "all_atoms_correct_n": 16876, "all_atoms_correct_coverage": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_accuracy": 0.8653709409812752, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_n": 3728, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_coverage": 0.22090542782649916, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_accuracy": 0.8412017167381974, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_n": 3728, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_coverage": 0.22090542782649916, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_accuracy": 0.8412017167381974 }, "ood_composite": { "all_atoms_correct_n": 2638, "all_atoms_correct_coverage": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_accuracy": 0.0037907505686125853, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_n": 87, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_coverage": 0.032979529946929494, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_accuracy": 0.011494252873563218, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_n": 87, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_coverage": 0.032979529946929494, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_accuracy": 0.011494252873563218 } }, { "run": "dev-h4-cd", "condition_id": "13ee061cd9edeeea", "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "phase": "development", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "hops": 4, "architecture": "cd", "unique_layers": 6, "repeats": 1, "effective_depth": 6, "test_full_composite": { "all_atoms_correct_n": 16876, "all_atoms_correct_coverage": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_accuracy": 1.0, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_n": 3728, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_coverage": 0.22090542782649916, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_accuracy": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_n": 3728, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_coverage": 0.22090542782649916, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_accuracy": 1.0 }, "ood_composite": { "all_atoms_correct_n": 2638, "all_atoms_correct_coverage": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_accuracy": 0.008339651250947688, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_n": 87, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_coverage": 0.032979529946929494, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_accuracy": 0.0, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_n": 87, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_coverage": 0.032979529946929494, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_accuracy": 0.0 } }, { "run": "dev-h4-l1", "condition_id": "b8c6c5380ee8a972", "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "phase": "development", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "hops": 4, "architecture": "l1", "unique_layers": 1, "repeats": 6, "effective_depth": 6, "test_full_composite": { "all_atoms_correct_n": 16876, "all_atoms_correct_coverage": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_accuracy": 1.0, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_n": 3728, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_coverage": 0.22090542782649916, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_accuracy": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_n": 3728, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_coverage": 0.22090542782649916, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_accuracy": 1.0 }, "ood_composite": { "all_atoms_correct_n": 2638, "all_atoms_correct_coverage": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_accuracy": 0.006065200909780136, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_n": 87, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_coverage": 0.032979529946929494, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_accuracy": 0.0, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_n": 87, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_coverage": 0.032979529946929494, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_accuracy": 0.0 } }, { "run": "dev-h4-l2", "condition_id": "d49177bf03453f8b", "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "phase": "development", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "hops": 4, "architecture": "l2", "unique_layers": 2, "repeats": 3, "effective_depth": 6, "test_full_composite": { "all_atoms_correct_n": 16876, "all_atoms_correct_coverage": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_accuracy": 1.0, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_n": 3728, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_coverage": 0.22090542782649916, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_accuracy": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_n": 3728, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_coverage": 0.22090542782649916, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_accuracy": 1.0 }, "ood_composite": { "all_atoms_correct_n": 2638, "all_atoms_correct_coverage": 1.0, "all_atoms_correct_accuracy": 0.006444275966641395, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_n": 87, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_coverage": 0.032979529946929494, "multiple_targets_per_relation_sequence_accuracy": 0.022988505747126436, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_n": 87, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_coverage": 0.032979529946929494, "all_atoms_correct_and_multiple_targets_accuracy": 0.022988505747126436 } } ], "conditional_interpretation": "model-specific known-atom subsets; report coverage; multi-target relation groups are defined descriptively within each evaluation split", "paired_comparisons": { "pairs": [ { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "comparison": "equal_executed_depth", "pair": "l2_minus_cd", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "hops": 2, "phase": "development", "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "dataset_sha256": "5456728cf3e9d76eabe4db3d5917fe4481aa54693b29442fd4cf1e8c5336bf95", "condition": { "batch_size": 256, "degree": 8, "dropout": 0.1, "entities": 128, "evaluation_size": 1024, "heads": 4, "hops": 2, "id_fraction": 0.75, "id_test_fraction": 0.1, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "initialization": 14501, "lr": 0.0001, "n_atomic_per_batch": 32, "nodes": [ 0, 100, 250, 500, 1000, 2000, 4000, 6000, 8000, 10000, 12000, 14000, 16000, 24000, 32000, 40000, 48000, 56000, 64000, 72000, 80000, 88000, 96000, 104000, 112000, 120000, 128000 ], "phase": "development", "phi": 6, "relations": 16, "steps": 128000, "stream_seed": 14500102, "warmup": 2000, "weight_decay": 0.1, "weight_nodes": [ 0, 16000, 64000, 128000 ], "width": 128, "world_seed": 145001, "comparison_depth": 4, "left_unique_layers": 4, "left_repeats": 1, "right_unique_layers": 2, "right_repeats": 2 }, "comparison_depth": 4, "difference_direction": "right loop architecture minus left classic architecture", "common_training_flop_cap": 629044936704000, "endpoint_id_full_difference": 0.017937219730941756, "endpoint_ood_difference": 0.05185185185185185, "common_budget_id_probe_difference": 0.017937219730941756, "common_budget_ood_difference": 0.05185185185185185, "common_budget_id_measurement": "fixed ID probe; endpoint ID uses full reserve", "left": { "run": "dev-h2-cd", "architecture": "cd", "unique_layers": 4, "repeats": 1, "effective_depth": 4, "endpoint_step": 128000, "endpoint_flops": 629044936704000, "endpoint_id_full_accuracy": 0.9820627802690582, "endpoint_id_full_n": 446, "endpoint_ood_accuracy": 0.012962962962962963, "endpoint_ood_n": 540, "common_budget_step": 128000, "common_budget_flops": 629044936704000, "unused_common_flops": 0, "common_budget_id_probe_accuracy": 0.9820627802690582, "common_budget_id_probe_n": 446, "common_budget_ood_accuracy": 0.012962962962962963, "common_budget_ood_n": 540 }, "right": { "run": "dev-h2-l2", "architecture": "l2", "unique_layers": 2, "repeats": 2, "effective_depth": 4, "endpoint_step": 128000, "endpoint_flops": 629044936704000, "endpoint_id_full_accuracy": 1.0, "endpoint_id_full_n": 446, "endpoint_ood_accuracy": 0.06481481481481481, "endpoint_ood_n": 540, "common_budget_step": 128000, "common_budget_flops": 629044936704000, "unused_common_flops": 0, "common_budget_id_probe_accuracy": 1.0, "common_budget_id_probe_n": 446, "common_budget_ood_accuracy": 0.06481481481481481, "common_budget_ood_n": 540 }, "actual_common_budget_flop_difference": 0 }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "comparison": "equal_executed_depth", "pair": "l1_minus_cd", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "hops": 2, "phase": "development", "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "dataset_sha256": "5456728cf3e9d76eabe4db3d5917fe4481aa54693b29442fd4cf1e8c5336bf95", "condition": { "batch_size": 256, "degree": 8, "dropout": 0.1, "entities": 128, "evaluation_size": 1024, "heads": 4, "hops": 2, "id_fraction": 0.75, "id_test_fraction": 0.1, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "initialization": 14501, "lr": 0.0001, "n_atomic_per_batch": 32, "nodes": [ 0, 100, 250, 500, 1000, 2000, 4000, 6000, 8000, 10000, 12000, 14000, 16000, 24000, 32000, 40000, 48000, 56000, 64000, 72000, 80000, 88000, 96000, 104000, 112000, 120000, 128000 ], "phase": "development", "phi": 6, "relations": 16, "steps": 128000, "stream_seed": 14500102, "warmup": 2000, "weight_decay": 0.1, "weight_nodes": [ 0, 16000, 64000, 128000 ], "width": 128, "world_seed": 145001, "comparison_depth": 4, "left_unique_layers": 4, "left_repeats": 1, "right_unique_layers": 1, "right_repeats": 4 }, "comparison_depth": 4, "difference_direction": "right loop architecture minus left classic architecture", "common_training_flop_cap": 629044936704000, "endpoint_id_full_difference": 0.017937219730941756, "endpoint_ood_difference": 0.022222222222222227, "common_budget_id_probe_difference": 0.017937219730941756, "common_budget_ood_difference": 0.022222222222222227, "common_budget_id_measurement": "fixed ID probe; endpoint ID uses full reserve", "left": { "run": "dev-h2-cd", "architecture": "cd", "unique_layers": 4, "repeats": 1, "effective_depth": 4, "endpoint_step": 128000, "endpoint_flops": 629044936704000, "endpoint_id_full_accuracy": 0.9820627802690582, "endpoint_id_full_n": 446, "endpoint_ood_accuracy": 0.012962962962962963, "endpoint_ood_n": 540, "common_budget_step": 128000, "common_budget_flops": 629044936704000, "unused_common_flops": 0, "common_budget_id_probe_accuracy": 0.9820627802690582, "common_budget_id_probe_n": 446, "common_budget_ood_accuracy": 0.012962962962962963, "common_budget_ood_n": 540 }, "right": { "run": "dev-h2-l1", "architecture": "l1", "unique_layers": 1, "repeats": 4, "effective_depth": 4, "endpoint_step": 128000, "endpoint_flops": 629044936704000, "endpoint_id_full_accuracy": 1.0, "endpoint_id_full_n": 446, "endpoint_ood_accuracy": 0.03518518518518519, "endpoint_ood_n": 540, "common_budget_step": 128000, "common_budget_flops": 629044936704000, "unused_common_flops": 0, "common_budget_id_probe_accuracy": 1.0, "common_budget_id_probe_n": 446, "common_budget_ood_accuracy": 0.03518518518518519, "common_budget_ood_n": 540 }, "actual_common_budget_flop_difference": 0 }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "comparison": "equal_parameters", "pair": "l2_minus_c2", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "hops": 2, "phase": "development", "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "dataset_sha256": "5456728cf3e9d76eabe4db3d5917fe4481aa54693b29442fd4cf1e8c5336bf95", "condition": { "batch_size": 256, "degree": 8, "dropout": 0.1, "entities": 128, "evaluation_size": 1024, "heads": 4, "hops": 2, "id_fraction": 0.75, "id_test_fraction": 0.1, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "initialization": 14501, "lr": 0.0001, "n_atomic_per_batch": 32, "nodes": [ 0, 100, 250, 500, 1000, 2000, 4000, 6000, 8000, 10000, 12000, 14000, 16000, 24000, 32000, 40000, 48000, 56000, 64000, 72000, 80000, 88000, 96000, 104000, 112000, 120000, 128000 ], "phase": "development", "phi": 6, "relations": 16, "steps": 128000, "stream_seed": 14500102, "warmup": 2000, "weight_decay": 0.1, "weight_nodes": [ 0, 16000, 64000, 128000 ], "width": 128, "world_seed": 145001, "comparison_depth": 4, "left_unique_layers": 2, "left_repeats": 1, "right_unique_layers": 2, "right_repeats": 2 }, "comparison_depth": 4, "difference_direction": "right loop architecture minus left classic architecture", "common_training_flop_cap": 318196678656000, "endpoint_id_full_difference": 0.04484304932735428, "endpoint_ood_difference": 0.05185185185185185, "common_budget_id_probe_difference": 0.04260089686098656, "common_budget_ood_difference": 0.024074074074074074, "common_budget_id_measurement": "fixed ID probe; endpoint ID uses full reserve", "left": { "run": "dev-h2-c2", "architecture": "c2", "unique_layers": 2, "repeats": 1, "effective_depth": 2, "endpoint_step": 128000, "endpoint_flops": 318196678656000, "endpoint_id_full_accuracy": 0.9551569506726457, "endpoint_id_full_n": 446, "endpoint_ood_accuracy": 0.012962962962962963, "endpoint_ood_n": 540, "common_budget_step": 128000, "common_budget_flops": 318196678656000, "unused_common_flops": 0, "common_budget_id_probe_accuracy": 0.9551569506726457, "common_budget_id_probe_n": 446, "common_budget_ood_accuracy": 0.012962962962962963, "common_budget_ood_n": 540 }, "right": { "run": "dev-h2-l2", "architecture": "l2", "unique_layers": 2, "repeats": 2, "effective_depth": 4, "endpoint_step": 128000, "endpoint_flops": 629044936704000, "endpoint_id_full_accuracy": 1.0, "endpoint_id_full_n": 446, "endpoint_ood_accuracy": 0.06481481481481481, "endpoint_ood_n": 540, "common_budget_step": 64000, "common_budget_flops": 314522468352000, "unused_common_flops": 3674210304000, "common_budget_id_probe_accuracy": 0.9977578475336323, "common_budget_id_probe_n": 446, "common_budget_ood_accuracy": 0.037037037037037035, "common_budget_ood_n": 540 }, "actual_common_budget_flop_difference": -3674210304000 }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "comparison": "equal_parameters", "pair": "l1_minus_c1", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "hops": 2, "phase": "development", "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "dataset_sha256": "5456728cf3e9d76eabe4db3d5917fe4481aa54693b29442fd4cf1e8c5336bf95", "condition": { "batch_size": 256, "degree": 8, "dropout": 0.1, "entities": 128, "evaluation_size": 1024, "heads": 4, "hops": 2, "id_fraction": 0.75, "id_test_fraction": 0.1, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "initialization": 14501, "lr": 0.0001, "n_atomic_per_batch": 32, "nodes": [ 0, 100, 250, 500, 1000, 2000, 4000, 6000, 8000, 10000, 12000, 14000, 16000, 24000, 32000, 40000, 48000, 56000, 64000, 72000, 80000, 88000, 96000, 104000, 112000, 120000, 128000 ], "phase": "development", "phi": 6, "relations": 16, "steps": 128000, "stream_seed": 14500102, "warmup": 2000, "weight_decay": 0.1, "weight_nodes": [ 0, 16000, 64000, 128000 ], "width": 128, "world_seed": 145001, "comparison_depth": 4, "left_unique_layers": 1, "left_repeats": 1, "right_unique_layers": 1, "right_repeats": 4 }, "comparison_depth": 4, "difference_direction": "right loop architecture minus left classic architecture", "common_training_flop_cap": 162772549632000, "endpoint_id_full_difference": 0.6569506726457399, "endpoint_ood_difference": 0.01851851851851852, "common_budget_id_probe_difference": 0.6524663677130045, "common_budget_ood_difference": 0.014814814814814812, "common_budget_id_measurement": "fixed ID probe; endpoint ID uses full reserve", "left": { "run": "dev-h2-c1", "architecture": "c1", "unique_layers": 1, "repeats": 1, "effective_depth": 1, "endpoint_step": 128000, "endpoint_flops": 162772549632000, "endpoint_id_full_accuracy": 0.3430493273542601, "endpoint_id_full_n": 446, "endpoint_ood_accuracy": 0.016666666666666666, "endpoint_ood_n": 540, "common_budget_step": 128000, "common_budget_flops": 162772549632000, "unused_common_flops": 0, "common_budget_id_probe_accuracy": 0.3430493273542601, "common_budget_id_probe_n": 446, "common_budget_ood_accuracy": 0.016666666666666666, "common_budget_ood_n": 540 }, "right": { "run": "dev-h2-l1", "architecture": "l1", "unique_layers": 1, "repeats": 4, "effective_depth": 4, "endpoint_step": 128000, "endpoint_flops": 629044936704000, "endpoint_id_full_accuracy": 1.0, "endpoint_id_full_n": 446, "endpoint_ood_accuracy": 0.03518518518518519, "endpoint_ood_n": 540, "common_budget_step": 32000, "common_budget_flops": 157261234176000, "unused_common_flops": 5511315456000, "common_budget_id_probe_accuracy": 0.9955156950672646, "common_budget_id_probe_n": 446, "common_budget_ood_accuracy": 0.03148148148148148, "common_budget_ood_n": 540 }, "actual_common_budget_flop_difference": -5511315456000 }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "comparison": "equal_executed_depth", "pair": "l2_minus_cd", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "hops": 3, "phase": "development", "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "dataset_sha256": "2335413e1e6439f487d9762b5ca78bc6bae9f3f1312a70b70a48767f055ae7b3", "condition": { "batch_size": 256, "degree": 8, "dropout": 0.1, "entities": 128, "evaluation_size": 1024, "heads": 4, "hops": 3, "id_fraction": 0.75, "id_test_fraction": 0.1, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "initialization": 14501, "lr": 0.0001, "n_atomic_per_batch": 32, "nodes": [ 0, 100, 250, 500, 1000, 2000, 4000, 6000, 8000, 10000, 12000, 14000, 16000, 24000, 32000, 40000, 48000, 56000, 64000, 72000, 80000, 88000, 96000, 104000, 112000, 120000, 128000 ], "phase": "development", "phi": 24, "relations": 16, "steps": 128000, "stream_seed": 14500103, "warmup": 2000, "weight_decay": 0.1, "weight_nodes": [ 0, 16000, 64000, 128000 ], "width": 128, "world_seed": 145001, "comparison_depth": 4, "left_unique_layers": 4, "left_repeats": 1, "right_unique_layers": 2, "right_repeats": 2 }, "comparison_depth": 4, "difference_direction": "right loop architecture minus left classic architecture", "common_training_flop_cap": 785475698688000, "endpoint_id_full_difference": 0.00974729241877259, "endpoint_ood_difference": 0.0058823529411764705, "common_budget_id_probe_difference": 0.0126953125, "common_budget_ood_difference": 0.0058823529411764705, "common_budget_id_measurement": "fixed ID probe; endpoint ID uses full reserve", "left": { "run": "dev-h3-cd", "architecture": "cd", "unique_layers": 4, "repeats": 1, "effective_depth": 4, "endpoint_step": 128000, "endpoint_flops": 785475698688000, "endpoint_id_full_accuracy": 0.9902527075812274, "endpoint_id_full_n": 2770, "endpoint_ood_accuracy": 0.0058823529411764705, "endpoint_ood_n": 1190, "common_budget_step": 128000, "common_budget_flops": 785475698688000, "unused_common_flops": 0, "common_budget_id_probe_accuracy": 0.9873046875, "common_budget_id_probe_n": 1024, "common_budget_ood_accuracy": 0.0058823529411764705, "common_budget_ood_n": 1190 }, "right": { "run": "dev-h3-l2", "architecture": "l2", "unique_layers": 2, "repeats": 2, "effective_depth": 4, "endpoint_step": 128000, "endpoint_flops": 785475698688000, "endpoint_id_full_accuracy": 1.0, "endpoint_id_full_n": 2770, "endpoint_ood_accuracy": 0.011764705882352941, "endpoint_ood_n": 1190, "common_budget_step": 128000, "common_budget_flops": 785475698688000, "unused_common_flops": 0, "common_budget_id_probe_accuracy": 1.0, "common_budget_id_probe_n": 1024, "common_budget_ood_accuracy": 0.011764705882352941, "common_budget_ood_n": 1190 }, "actual_common_budget_flop_difference": 0 }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "comparison": "equal_executed_depth", "pair": "l1_minus_cd", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "hops": 3, "phase": "development", "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "dataset_sha256": "2335413e1e6439f487d9762b5ca78bc6bae9f3f1312a70b70a48767f055ae7b3", "condition": { "batch_size": 256, "degree": 8, "dropout": 0.1, "entities": 128, "evaluation_size": 1024, "heads": 4, "hops": 3, "id_fraction": 0.75, "id_test_fraction": 0.1, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "initialization": 14501, "lr": 0.0001, "n_atomic_per_batch": 32, "nodes": [ 0, 100, 250, 500, 1000, 2000, 4000, 6000, 8000, 10000, 12000, 14000, 16000, 24000, 32000, 40000, 48000, 56000, 64000, 72000, 80000, 88000, 96000, 104000, 112000, 120000, 128000 ], "phase": "development", "phi": 24, "relations": 16, "steps": 128000, "stream_seed": 14500103, "warmup": 2000, "weight_decay": 0.1, "weight_nodes": [ 0, 16000, 64000, 128000 ], "width": 128, "world_seed": 145001, "comparison_depth": 4, "left_unique_layers": 4, "left_repeats": 1, "right_unique_layers": 1, "right_repeats": 4 }, "comparison_depth": 4, "difference_direction": "right loop architecture minus left classic architecture", "common_training_flop_cap": 785475698688000, "endpoint_id_full_difference": 0.00974729241877259, "endpoint_ood_difference": -0.0008403361344537811, "common_budget_id_probe_difference": 0.0126953125, "common_budget_ood_difference": -0.0008403361344537811, "common_budget_id_measurement": "fixed ID probe; endpoint ID uses full reserve", "left": { "run": "dev-h3-cd", "architecture": "cd", "unique_layers": 4, "repeats": 1, "effective_depth": 4, "endpoint_step": 128000, "endpoint_flops": 785475698688000, "endpoint_id_full_accuracy": 0.9902527075812274, "endpoint_id_full_n": 2770, "endpoint_ood_accuracy": 0.0058823529411764705, "endpoint_ood_n": 1190, "common_budget_step": 128000, "common_budget_flops": 785475698688000, "unused_common_flops": 0, "common_budget_id_probe_accuracy": 0.9873046875, "common_budget_id_probe_n": 1024, "common_budget_ood_accuracy": 0.0058823529411764705, "common_budget_ood_n": 1190 }, "right": { "run": "dev-h3-l1", "architecture": "l1", "unique_layers": 1, "repeats": 4, "effective_depth": 4, "endpoint_step": 128000, "endpoint_flops": 785475698688000, "endpoint_id_full_accuracy": 1.0, "endpoint_id_full_n": 2770, "endpoint_ood_accuracy": 0.005042016806722689, "endpoint_ood_n": 1190, "common_budget_step": 128000, "common_budget_flops": 785475698688000, "unused_common_flops": 0, "common_budget_id_probe_accuracy": 1.0, "common_budget_id_probe_n": 1024, "common_budget_ood_accuracy": 0.005042016806722689, "common_budget_ood_n": 1190 }, "actual_common_budget_flop_difference": 0 }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "comparison": "equal_parameters", "pair": "l2_minus_c2", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "hops": 3, "phase": "development", "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "dataset_sha256": "2335413e1e6439f487d9762b5ca78bc6bae9f3f1312a70b70a48767f055ae7b3", "condition": { "batch_size": 256, "degree": 8, "dropout": 0.1, "entities": 128, "evaluation_size": 1024, "heads": 4, "hops": 3, "id_fraction": 0.75, "id_test_fraction": 0.1, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "initialization": 14501, "lr": 0.0001, "n_atomic_per_batch": 32, "nodes": [ 0, 100, 250, 500, 1000, 2000, 4000, 6000, 8000, 10000, 12000, 14000, 16000, 24000, 32000, 40000, 48000, 56000, 64000, 72000, 80000, 88000, 96000, 104000, 112000, 120000, 128000 ], "phase": "development", "phi": 24, "relations": 16, "steps": 128000, "stream_seed": 14500103, "warmup": 2000, "weight_decay": 0.1, "weight_nodes": [ 0, 16000, 64000, 128000 ], "width": 128, "world_seed": 145001, "comparison_depth": 4, "left_unique_layers": 2, "left_repeats": 1, "right_unique_layers": 2, "right_repeats": 2 }, "comparison_depth": 4, "difference_direction": "right loop architecture minus left classic architecture", "common_training_flop_cap": 396412059648000, "endpoint_id_full_difference": 0.034657039711191384, "endpoint_ood_difference": 0.0058823529411764705, "common_budget_id_probe_difference": 0.0341796875, "common_budget_ood_difference": 0.0033613445378151263, "common_budget_id_measurement": "fixed ID probe; endpoint ID uses full reserve", "left": { "run": "dev-h3-c2", "architecture": "c2", "unique_layers": 2, "repeats": 1, "effective_depth": 2, "endpoint_step": 128000, "endpoint_flops": 396412059648000, "endpoint_id_full_accuracy": 0.9653429602888086, "endpoint_id_full_n": 2770, "endpoint_ood_accuracy": 0.0058823529411764705, "endpoint_ood_n": 1190, "common_budget_step": 128000, "common_budget_flops": 396412059648000, "unused_common_flops": 0, "common_budget_id_probe_accuracy": 0.9658203125, "common_budget_id_probe_n": 1024, "common_budget_ood_accuracy": 0.0058823529411764705, "common_budget_ood_n": 1190 }, "right": { "run": "dev-h3-l2", "architecture": "l2", "unique_layers": 2, "repeats": 2, "effective_depth": 4, "endpoint_step": 128000, "endpoint_flops": 785475698688000, "endpoint_id_full_accuracy": 1.0, "endpoint_id_full_n": 2770, "endpoint_ood_accuracy": 0.011764705882352941, "endpoint_ood_n": 1190, "common_budget_step": 64000, "common_budget_flops": 392737849344000, "unused_common_flops": 3674210304000, "common_budget_id_probe_accuracy": 1.0, "common_budget_id_probe_n": 1024, "common_budget_ood_accuracy": 0.009243697478991597, "common_budget_ood_n": 1190 }, "actual_common_budget_flop_difference": -3674210304000 }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "comparison": "equal_parameters", "pair": "l1_minus_c1", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "hops": 3, "phase": "development", "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "dataset_sha256": "2335413e1e6439f487d9762b5ca78bc6bae9f3f1312a70b70a48767f055ae7b3", "condition": { "batch_size": 256, "degree": 8, "dropout": 0.1, "entities": 128, "evaluation_size": 1024, "heads": 4, "hops": 3, "id_fraction": 0.75, "id_test_fraction": 0.1, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "initialization": 14501, "lr": 0.0001, "n_atomic_per_batch": 32, "nodes": [ 0, 100, 250, 500, 1000, 2000, 4000, 6000, 8000, 10000, 12000, 14000, 16000, 24000, 32000, 40000, 48000, 56000, 64000, 72000, 80000, 88000, 96000, 104000, 112000, 120000, 128000 ], "phase": "development", "phi": 24, "relations": 16, "steps": 128000, "stream_seed": 14500103, "warmup": 2000, "weight_decay": 0.1, "weight_nodes": [ 0, 16000, 64000, 128000 ], "width": 128, "world_seed": 145001, "comparison_depth": 4, "left_unique_layers": 1, "left_repeats": 1, "right_unique_layers": 1, "right_repeats": 4 }, "comparison_depth": 4, "difference_direction": "right loop architecture minus left classic architecture", "common_training_flop_cap": 201880240128000, "endpoint_id_full_difference": 0.41371841155234657, "endpoint_ood_difference": -0.0016806722689075631, "common_budget_id_probe_difference": 0.44921875, "common_budget_ood_difference": 0.0033613445378151263, "common_budget_id_measurement": "fixed ID probe; endpoint ID uses full reserve", "left": { "run": "dev-h3-c1", "architecture": "c1", "unique_layers": 1, "repeats": 1, "effective_depth": 1, "endpoint_step": 128000, "endpoint_flops": 201880240128000, "endpoint_id_full_accuracy": 0.5862815884476534, "endpoint_id_full_n": 2770, "endpoint_ood_accuracy": 0.0067226890756302525, "endpoint_ood_n": 1190, "common_budget_step": 128000, "common_budget_flops": 201880240128000, "unused_common_flops": 0, "common_budget_id_probe_accuracy": 0.55078125, "common_budget_id_probe_n": 1024, "common_budget_ood_accuracy": 0.0067226890756302525, "common_budget_ood_n": 1190 }, "right": { "run": "dev-h3-l1", "architecture": "l1", "unique_layers": 1, "repeats": 4, "effective_depth": 4, "endpoint_step": 128000, "endpoint_flops": 785475698688000, "endpoint_id_full_accuracy": 1.0, "endpoint_id_full_n": 2770, "endpoint_ood_accuracy": 0.005042016806722689, "endpoint_ood_n": 1190, "common_budget_step": 32000, "common_budget_flops": 196368924672000, "unused_common_flops": 5511315456000, "common_budget_id_probe_accuracy": 1.0, "common_budget_id_probe_n": 1024, "common_budget_ood_accuracy": 0.010084033613445379, "common_budget_ood_n": 1190 }, "actual_common_budget_flop_difference": -5511315456000 }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "comparison": "equal_executed_depth", "pair": "l2_minus_cd", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "hops": 4, "phase": "development", "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "dataset_sha256": "ededee2a34b6f2ff6ff2c9578e68def349fb946e0a0480c1fae8e9f0b87bf6f0", "condition": { "batch_size": 256, "degree": 8, "dropout": 0.1, "entities": 128, "evaluation_size": 1024, "heads": 4, "hops": 4, "id_fraction": 0.75, "id_test_fraction": 0.1, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "initialization": 14501, "lr": 0.0001, "n_atomic_per_batch": 32, "nodes": [ 0, 100, 250, 500, 1000, 2000, 4000, 6000, 8000, 10000, 12000, 14000, 16000, 24000, 32000, 40000, 48000, 56000, 64000, 72000, 80000, 88000, 96000, 104000, 112000, 120000, 128000 ], "phase": "development", "phi": 96, "relations": 16, "steps": 128000, "stream_seed": 14500104, "warmup": 2000, "weight_decay": 0.1, "weight_nodes": [ 0, 16000, 64000, 128000 ], "width": 128, "world_seed": 145001, "comparison_depth": 6, "left_unique_layers": 6, "left_repeats": 1, "right_unique_layers": 2, "right_repeats": 3 }, "comparison_depth": 6, "difference_direction": "right loop architecture minus left classic architecture", "common_training_flop_cap": 1409789460480000, "endpoint_id_full_difference": 0.0, "endpoint_ood_difference": -0.0018953752843062933, "common_budget_id_probe_difference": 0.0, "common_budget_ood_difference": -0.0018953752843062933, "common_budget_id_measurement": "fixed ID probe; endpoint ID uses full reserve", "left": { "run": "dev-h4-cd", "architecture": "cd", "unique_layers": 6, "repeats": 1, "effective_depth": 6, "endpoint_step": 128000, "endpoint_flops": 1409789460480000, "endpoint_id_full_accuracy": 1.0, "endpoint_id_full_n": 16876, "endpoint_ood_accuracy": 0.008339651250947688, "endpoint_ood_n": 2638, "common_budget_step": 128000, "common_budget_flops": 1409789460480000, "unused_common_flops": 0, "common_budget_id_probe_accuracy": 1.0, "common_budget_id_probe_n": 1024, "common_budget_ood_accuracy": 0.008339651250947688, "common_budget_ood_n": 2638 }, "right": { "run": "dev-h4-l2", "architecture": "l2", "unique_layers": 2, "repeats": 3, "effective_depth": 6, "endpoint_step": 128000, "endpoint_flops": 1409789460480000, "endpoint_id_full_accuracy": 1.0, "endpoint_id_full_n": 16876, "endpoint_ood_accuracy": 0.006444275966641395, "endpoint_ood_n": 2638, "common_budget_step": 128000, "common_budget_flops": 1409789460480000, "unused_common_flops": 0, "common_budget_id_probe_accuracy": 1.0, "common_budget_id_probe_n": 1024, "common_budget_ood_accuracy": 0.006444275966641395, "common_budget_ood_n": 2638 }, "actual_common_budget_flop_difference": 0 }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "comparison": "equal_executed_depth", "pair": "l1_minus_cd", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "hops": 4, "phase": "development", "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "dataset_sha256": "ededee2a34b6f2ff6ff2c9578e68def349fb946e0a0480c1fae8e9f0b87bf6f0", "condition": { "batch_size": 256, "degree": 8, "dropout": 0.1, "entities": 128, "evaluation_size": 1024, "heads": 4, "hops": 4, "id_fraction": 0.75, "id_test_fraction": 0.1, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "initialization": 14501, "lr": 0.0001, "n_atomic_per_batch": 32, "nodes": [ 0, 100, 250, 500, 1000, 2000, 4000, 6000, 8000, 10000, 12000, 14000, 16000, 24000, 32000, 40000, 48000, 56000, 64000, 72000, 80000, 88000, 96000, 104000, 112000, 120000, 128000 ], "phase": "development", "phi": 96, "relations": 16, "steps": 128000, "stream_seed": 14500104, "warmup": 2000, "weight_decay": 0.1, "weight_nodes": [ 0, 16000, 64000, 128000 ], "width": 128, "world_seed": 145001, "comparison_depth": 6, "left_unique_layers": 6, "left_repeats": 1, "right_unique_layers": 1, "right_repeats": 6 }, "comparison_depth": 6, "difference_direction": "right loop architecture minus left classic architecture", "common_training_flop_cap": 1409789460480000, "endpoint_id_full_difference": 0.0, "endpoint_ood_difference": -0.0022744503411675516, "common_budget_id_probe_difference": 0.0, "common_budget_ood_difference": -0.0022744503411675516, "common_budget_id_measurement": "fixed ID probe; endpoint ID uses full reserve", "left": { "run": "dev-h4-cd", "architecture": "cd", "unique_layers": 6, "repeats": 1, "effective_depth": 6, "endpoint_step": 128000, "endpoint_flops": 1409789460480000, "endpoint_id_full_accuracy": 1.0, "endpoint_id_full_n": 16876, "endpoint_ood_accuracy": 0.008339651250947688, "endpoint_ood_n": 2638, "common_budget_step": 128000, "common_budget_flops": 1409789460480000, "unused_common_flops": 0, "common_budget_id_probe_accuracy": 1.0, "common_budget_id_probe_n": 1024, "common_budget_ood_accuracy": 0.008339651250947688, "common_budget_ood_n": 2638 }, "right": { "run": "dev-h4-l1", "architecture": "l1", "unique_layers": 1, "repeats": 6, "effective_depth": 6, "endpoint_step": 128000, "endpoint_flops": 1409789460480000, "endpoint_id_full_accuracy": 1.0, "endpoint_id_full_n": 16876, "endpoint_ood_accuracy": 0.006065200909780136, "endpoint_ood_n": 2638, "common_budget_step": 128000, "common_budget_flops": 1409789460480000, "unused_common_flops": 0, "common_budget_id_probe_accuracy": 1.0, "common_budget_id_probe_n": 1024, "common_budget_ood_accuracy": 0.006065200909780136, "common_budget_ood_n": 2638 }, "actual_common_budget_flop_difference": 0 }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "comparison": "equal_parameters", "pair": "l2_minus_c2", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "hops": 4, "phase": "development", "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "dataset_sha256": "ededee2a34b6f2ff6ff2c9578e68def349fb946e0a0480c1fae8e9f0b87bf6f0", "condition": { "batch_size": 256, "degree": 8, "dropout": 0.1, "entities": 128, "evaluation_size": 1024, "heads": 4, "hops": 4, "id_fraction": 0.75, "id_test_fraction": 0.1, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "initialization": 14501, "lr": 0.0001, "n_atomic_per_batch": 32, "nodes": [ 0, 100, 250, 500, 1000, 2000, 4000, 6000, 8000, 10000, 12000, 14000, 16000, 24000, 32000, 40000, 48000, 56000, 64000, 72000, 80000, 88000, 96000, 104000, 112000, 120000, 128000 ], "phase": "development", "phi": 96, "relations": 16, "steps": 128000, "stream_seed": 14500104, "warmup": 2000, "weight_decay": 0.1, "weight_nodes": [ 0, 16000, 64000, 128000 ], "width": 128, "world_seed": 145001, "comparison_depth": 6, "left_unique_layers": 2, "left_repeats": 1, "right_unique_layers": 2, "right_repeats": 3 }, "comparison_depth": 6, "difference_direction": "right loop architecture minus left classic architecture", "common_training_flop_cap": 474828767232000, "endpoint_id_full_difference": 0.1346290590187248, "endpoint_ood_difference": 0.0026535253980288095, "common_budget_id_probe_difference": 0.15625, "common_budget_ood_difference": 0.0, "common_budget_id_measurement": "fixed ID probe; endpoint ID uses full reserve", "left": { "run": "dev-h4-c2", "architecture": "c2", "unique_layers": 2, "repeats": 1, "effective_depth": 2, "endpoint_step": 128000, "endpoint_flops": 474828767232000, "endpoint_id_full_accuracy": 0.8653709409812752, "endpoint_id_full_n": 16876, "endpoint_ood_accuracy": 0.0037907505686125853, "endpoint_ood_n": 2638, "common_budget_step": 128000, "common_budget_flops": 474828767232000, "unused_common_flops": 0, "common_budget_id_probe_accuracy": 0.84375, "common_budget_id_probe_n": 1024, "common_budget_ood_accuracy": 0.0037907505686125853, "common_budget_ood_n": 2638 }, "right": { "run": "dev-h4-l2", "architecture": "l2", "unique_layers": 2, "repeats": 3, "effective_depth": 6, "endpoint_step": 128000, "endpoint_flops": 1409789460480000, "endpoint_id_full_accuracy": 1.0, "endpoint_id_full_n": 16876, "endpoint_ood_accuracy": 0.006444275966641395, "endpoint_ood_n": 2638, "common_budget_step": 40000, "common_budget_flops": 440559206400000, "unused_common_flops": 34269560832000, "common_budget_id_probe_accuracy": 1.0, "common_budget_id_probe_n": 1024, "common_budget_ood_accuracy": 0.0037907505686125853, "common_budget_ood_n": 2638 }, "actual_common_budget_flop_difference": -34269560832000 }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "comparison": "equal_parameters", "pair": "l1_minus_c1", "world_seed": 145001, "initialization": 14501, "hops": 4, "phase": "development", "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "dataset_sha256": "ededee2a34b6f2ff6ff2c9578e68def349fb946e0a0480c1fae8e9f0b87bf6f0", "condition": { "batch_size": 256, "degree": 8, "dropout": 0.1, "entities": 128, "evaluation_size": 1024, "heads": 4, "hops": 4, "id_fraction": 0.75, "id_test_fraction": 0.1, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "initialization": 14501, "lr": 0.0001, "n_atomic_per_batch": 32, "nodes": [ 0, 100, 250, 500, 1000, 2000, 4000, 6000, 8000, 10000, 12000, 14000, 16000, 24000, 32000, 40000, 48000, 56000, 64000, 72000, 80000, 88000, 96000, 104000, 112000, 120000, 128000 ], "phase": "development", "phi": 96, "relations": 16, "steps": 128000, "stream_seed": 14500104, "warmup": 2000, "weight_decay": 0.1, "weight_nodes": [ 0, 16000, 64000, 128000 ], "width": 128, "world_seed": 145001, "comparison_depth": 6, "left_unique_layers": 1, "left_repeats": 1, "right_unique_layers": 1, "right_repeats": 6 }, "comparison_depth": 6, "difference_direction": "right loop architecture minus left classic architecture", "common_training_flop_cap": 241088593920000, "endpoint_id_full_difference": 0.6029272339416923, "endpoint_ood_difference": 0.0003790750568612583, "common_budget_id_probe_difference": 0.6162109375, "common_budget_ood_difference": -0.001516300227445034, "common_budget_id_measurement": "fixed ID probe; endpoint ID uses full reserve", "left": { "run": "dev-h4-c1", "architecture": "c1", "unique_layers": 1, "repeats": 1, "effective_depth": 1, "endpoint_step": 128000, "endpoint_flops": 241088593920000, "endpoint_id_full_accuracy": 0.39707276605830766, "endpoint_id_full_n": 16876, "endpoint_ood_accuracy": 0.005686125852918878, "endpoint_ood_n": 2638, "common_budget_step": 128000, "common_budget_flops": 241088593920000, "unused_common_flops": 0, "common_budget_id_probe_accuracy": 0.3828125, "common_budget_id_probe_n": 1024, "common_budget_ood_accuracy": 0.005686125852918878, "common_budget_ood_n": 2638 }, "right": { "run": "dev-h4-l1", "architecture": "l1", "unique_layers": 1, "repeats": 6, "effective_depth": 6, "endpoint_step": 128000, "endpoint_flops": 1409789460480000, "endpoint_id_full_accuracy": 1.0, "endpoint_id_full_n": 16876, "endpoint_ood_accuracy": 0.006065200909780136, "endpoint_ood_n": 2638, "common_budget_step": 16000, "common_budget_flops": 176223682560000, "unused_common_flops": 64864911360000, "common_budget_id_probe_accuracy": 0.9990234375, "common_budget_id_probe_n": 1024, "common_budget_ood_accuracy": 0.004169825625473844, "common_budget_ood_n": 2638 }, "actual_common_budget_flop_difference": -64864911360000 } ], "world_summary": [ { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "pair": "l2_minus_cd", "condition": { "batch_size": 256, "comparison_depth": 4, "degree": 8, "dropout": 0.1, "entities": 128, "evaluation_size": 1024, "heads": 4, "hops": 2, "id_fraction": 0.75, "id_test_fraction": 0.1, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "left_repeats": 1, "left_unique_layers": 4, "lr": 0.0001, "n_atomic_per_batch": 32, "nodes": [ 0, 100, 250, 500, 1000, 2000, 4000, 6000, 8000, 10000, 12000, 14000, 16000, 24000, 32000, 40000, 48000, 56000, 64000, 72000, 80000, 88000, 96000, 104000, 112000, 120000, 128000 ], "phase": "development", "phi": 6, "relations": 16, "right_repeats": 2, "right_unique_layers": 2, "steps": 128000, "warmup": 2000, "weight_decay": 0.1, "weight_nodes": [ 0, 16000, 64000, 128000 ], "width": 128 }, "worlds": 1, "paired_runs": 1, "endpoint_id_full_difference": { "mean": 0.017937219730941756, "min": 0.017937219730941756, "max": 0.017937219730941756, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "endpoint_ood_difference": { "mean": 0.05185185185185185, "min": 0.05185185185185185, "max": 0.05185185185185185, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "common_budget_id_probe_difference": { "mean": 0.017937219730941756, "min": 0.017937219730941756, "max": 0.017937219730941756, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "common_budget_ood_difference": { "mean": 0.05185185185185185, "min": 0.05185185185185185, "max": 0.05185185185185185, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 } }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "pair": "l1_minus_cd", "condition": { "batch_size": 256, "comparison_depth": 4, "degree": 8, "dropout": 0.1, "entities": 128, "evaluation_size": 1024, "heads": 4, "hops": 2, "id_fraction": 0.75, "id_test_fraction": 0.1, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "left_repeats": 1, "left_unique_layers": 4, "lr": 0.0001, "n_atomic_per_batch": 32, "nodes": [ 0, 100, 250, 500, 1000, 2000, 4000, 6000, 8000, 10000, 12000, 14000, 16000, 24000, 32000, 40000, 48000, 56000, 64000, 72000, 80000, 88000, 96000, 104000, 112000, 120000, 128000 ], "phase": "development", "phi": 6, "relations": 16, "right_repeats": 4, "right_unique_layers": 1, "steps": 128000, "warmup": 2000, "weight_decay": 0.1, "weight_nodes": [ 0, 16000, 64000, 128000 ], "width": 128 }, "worlds": 1, "paired_runs": 1, "endpoint_id_full_difference": { "mean": 0.017937219730941756, "min": 0.017937219730941756, "max": 0.017937219730941756, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "endpoint_ood_difference": { "mean": 0.022222222222222227, "min": 0.022222222222222227, "max": 0.022222222222222227, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "common_budget_id_probe_difference": { "mean": 0.017937219730941756, "min": 0.017937219730941756, "max": 0.017937219730941756, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "common_budget_ood_difference": { "mean": 0.022222222222222227, "min": 0.022222222222222227, "max": 0.022222222222222227, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 } }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "pair": "l2_minus_c2", "condition": { "batch_size": 256, "comparison_depth": 4, "degree": 8, "dropout": 0.1, "entities": 128, "evaluation_size": 1024, "heads": 4, "hops": 2, "id_fraction": 0.75, "id_test_fraction": 0.1, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "left_repeats": 1, "left_unique_layers": 2, "lr": 0.0001, "n_atomic_per_batch": 32, "nodes": [ 0, 100, 250, 500, 1000, 2000, 4000, 6000, 8000, 10000, 12000, 14000, 16000, 24000, 32000, 40000, 48000, 56000, 64000, 72000, 80000, 88000, 96000, 104000, 112000, 120000, 128000 ], "phase": "development", "phi": 6, "relations": 16, "right_repeats": 2, "right_unique_layers": 2, "steps": 128000, "warmup": 2000, "weight_decay": 0.1, "weight_nodes": [ 0, 16000, 64000, 128000 ], "width": 128 }, "worlds": 1, "paired_runs": 1, "endpoint_id_full_difference": { "mean": 0.04484304932735428, "min": 0.04484304932735428, "max": 0.04484304932735428, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "endpoint_ood_difference": { "mean": 0.05185185185185185, "min": 0.05185185185185185, "max": 0.05185185185185185, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "common_budget_id_probe_difference": { "mean": 0.04260089686098656, "min": 0.04260089686098656, "max": 0.04260089686098656, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "common_budget_ood_difference": { "mean": 0.024074074074074074, "min": 0.024074074074074074, "max": 0.024074074074074074, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 } }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "pair": "l1_minus_c1", "condition": { "batch_size": 256, "comparison_depth": 4, "degree": 8, "dropout": 0.1, "entities": 128, "evaluation_size": 1024, "heads": 4, "hops": 2, "id_fraction": 0.75, "id_test_fraction": 0.1, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "left_repeats": 1, "left_unique_layers": 1, "lr": 0.0001, "n_atomic_per_batch": 32, "nodes": [ 0, 100, 250, 500, 1000, 2000, 4000, 6000, 8000, 10000, 12000, 14000, 16000, 24000, 32000, 40000, 48000, 56000, 64000, 72000, 80000, 88000, 96000, 104000, 112000, 120000, 128000 ], "phase": "development", "phi": 6, "relations": 16, "right_repeats": 4, "right_unique_layers": 1, "steps": 128000, "warmup": 2000, "weight_decay": 0.1, "weight_nodes": [ 0, 16000, 64000, 128000 ], "width": 128 }, "worlds": 1, "paired_runs": 1, "endpoint_id_full_difference": { "mean": 0.6569506726457399, "min": 0.6569506726457399, "max": 0.6569506726457399, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "endpoint_ood_difference": { "mean": 0.01851851851851852, "min": 0.01851851851851852, "max": 0.01851851851851852, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "common_budget_id_probe_difference": { "mean": 0.6524663677130045, "min": 0.6524663677130045, "max": 0.6524663677130045, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "common_budget_ood_difference": { "mean": 0.014814814814814812, "min": 0.014814814814814812, "max": 0.014814814814814812, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 } }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "pair": "l2_minus_cd", "condition": { "batch_size": 256, "comparison_depth": 4, "degree": 8, "dropout": 0.1, "entities": 128, "evaluation_size": 1024, "heads": 4, "hops": 3, "id_fraction": 0.75, "id_test_fraction": 0.1, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "left_repeats": 1, "left_unique_layers": 4, "lr": 0.0001, "n_atomic_per_batch": 32, "nodes": [ 0, 100, 250, 500, 1000, 2000, 4000, 6000, 8000, 10000, 12000, 14000, 16000, 24000, 32000, 40000, 48000, 56000, 64000, 72000, 80000, 88000, 96000, 104000, 112000, 120000, 128000 ], "phase": "development", "phi": 24, "relations": 16, "right_repeats": 2, "right_unique_layers": 2, "steps": 128000, "warmup": 2000, "weight_decay": 0.1, "weight_nodes": [ 0, 16000, 64000, 128000 ], "width": 128 }, "worlds": 1, "paired_runs": 1, "endpoint_id_full_difference": { "mean": 0.00974729241877259, "min": 0.00974729241877259, "max": 0.00974729241877259, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "endpoint_ood_difference": { "mean": 0.0058823529411764705, "min": 0.0058823529411764705, "max": 0.0058823529411764705, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "common_budget_id_probe_difference": { "mean": 0.0126953125, "min": 0.0126953125, "max": 0.0126953125, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "common_budget_ood_difference": { "mean": 0.0058823529411764705, "min": 0.0058823529411764705, "max": 0.0058823529411764705, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 } }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "pair": "l1_minus_cd", "condition": { "batch_size": 256, "comparison_depth": 4, "degree": 8, "dropout": 0.1, "entities": 128, "evaluation_size": 1024, "heads": 4, "hops": 3, "id_fraction": 0.75, "id_test_fraction": 0.1, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "left_repeats": 1, "left_unique_layers": 4, "lr": 0.0001, "n_atomic_per_batch": 32, "nodes": [ 0, 100, 250, 500, 1000, 2000, 4000, 6000, 8000, 10000, 12000, 14000, 16000, 24000, 32000, 40000, 48000, 56000, 64000, 72000, 80000, 88000, 96000, 104000, 112000, 120000, 128000 ], "phase": "development", "phi": 24, "relations": 16, "right_repeats": 4, "right_unique_layers": 1, "steps": 128000, "warmup": 2000, "weight_decay": 0.1, "weight_nodes": [ 0, 16000, 64000, 128000 ], "width": 128 }, "worlds": 1, "paired_runs": 1, "endpoint_id_full_difference": { "mean": 0.00974729241877259, "min": 0.00974729241877259, "max": 0.00974729241877259, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "endpoint_ood_difference": { "mean": -0.0008403361344537811, "min": -0.0008403361344537811, "max": -0.0008403361344537811, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "common_budget_id_probe_difference": { "mean": 0.0126953125, "min": 0.0126953125, "max": 0.0126953125, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "common_budget_ood_difference": { "mean": -0.0008403361344537811, "min": -0.0008403361344537811, "max": -0.0008403361344537811, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 } }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "pair": "l2_minus_c2", "condition": { "batch_size": 256, "comparison_depth": 4, "degree": 8, "dropout": 0.1, "entities": 128, "evaluation_size": 1024, "heads": 4, "hops": 3, "id_fraction": 0.75, "id_test_fraction": 0.1, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "left_repeats": 1, "left_unique_layers": 2, "lr": 0.0001, "n_atomic_per_batch": 32, "nodes": [ 0, 100, 250, 500, 1000, 2000, 4000, 6000, 8000, 10000, 12000, 14000, 16000, 24000, 32000, 40000, 48000, 56000, 64000, 72000, 80000, 88000, 96000, 104000, 112000, 120000, 128000 ], "phase": "development", "phi": 24, "relations": 16, "right_repeats": 2, "right_unique_layers": 2, "steps": 128000, "warmup": 2000, "weight_decay": 0.1, "weight_nodes": [ 0, 16000, 64000, 128000 ], "width": 128 }, "worlds": 1, "paired_runs": 1, "endpoint_id_full_difference": { "mean": 0.034657039711191384, "min": 0.034657039711191384, "max": 0.034657039711191384, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "endpoint_ood_difference": { "mean": 0.0058823529411764705, "min": 0.0058823529411764705, "max": 0.0058823529411764705, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "common_budget_id_probe_difference": { "mean": 0.0341796875, "min": 0.0341796875, "max": 0.0341796875, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "common_budget_ood_difference": { "mean": 0.0033613445378151263, "min": 0.0033613445378151263, "max": 0.0033613445378151263, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 } }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "pair": "l1_minus_c1", "condition": { "batch_size": 256, "comparison_depth": 4, "degree": 8, "dropout": 0.1, "entities": 128, "evaluation_size": 1024, "heads": 4, "hops": 3, "id_fraction": 0.75, "id_test_fraction": 0.1, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "left_repeats": 1, "left_unique_layers": 1, "lr": 0.0001, "n_atomic_per_batch": 32, "nodes": [ 0, 100, 250, 500, 1000, 2000, 4000, 6000, 8000, 10000, 12000, 14000, 16000, 24000, 32000, 40000, 48000, 56000, 64000, 72000, 80000, 88000, 96000, 104000, 112000, 120000, 128000 ], "phase": "development", "phi": 24, "relations": 16, "right_repeats": 4, "right_unique_layers": 1, "steps": 128000, "warmup": 2000, "weight_decay": 0.1, "weight_nodes": [ 0, 16000, 64000, 128000 ], "width": 128 }, "worlds": 1, "paired_runs": 1, "endpoint_id_full_difference": { "mean": 0.41371841155234657, "min": 0.41371841155234657, "max": 0.41371841155234657, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "endpoint_ood_difference": { "mean": -0.0016806722689075631, "min": -0.0016806722689075631, "max": -0.0016806722689075631, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "common_budget_id_probe_difference": { "mean": 0.44921875, "min": 0.44921875, "max": 0.44921875, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "common_budget_ood_difference": { "mean": 0.0033613445378151263, "min": 0.0033613445378151263, "max": 0.0033613445378151263, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 } }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "pair": "l2_minus_cd", "condition": { "batch_size": 256, "comparison_depth": 6, "degree": 8, "dropout": 0.1, "entities": 128, "evaluation_size": 1024, "heads": 4, "hops": 4, "id_fraction": 0.75, "id_test_fraction": 0.1, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "left_repeats": 1, "left_unique_layers": 6, "lr": 0.0001, "n_atomic_per_batch": 32, "nodes": [ 0, 100, 250, 500, 1000, 2000, 4000, 6000, 8000, 10000, 12000, 14000, 16000, 24000, 32000, 40000, 48000, 56000, 64000, 72000, 80000, 88000, 96000, 104000, 112000, 120000, 128000 ], "phase": "development", "phi": 96, "relations": 16, "right_repeats": 3, "right_unique_layers": 2, "steps": 128000, "warmup": 2000, "weight_decay": 0.1, "weight_nodes": [ 0, 16000, 64000, 128000 ], "width": 128 }, "worlds": 1, "paired_runs": 1, "endpoint_id_full_difference": { "mean": 0.0, "min": 0.0, "max": 0.0, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "endpoint_ood_difference": { "mean": -0.0018953752843062933, "min": -0.0018953752843062933, "max": -0.0018953752843062933, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "common_budget_id_probe_difference": { "mean": 0.0, "min": 0.0, "max": 0.0, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "common_budget_ood_difference": { "mean": -0.0018953752843062933, "min": -0.0018953752843062933, "max": -0.0018953752843062933, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 } }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "pair": "l1_minus_cd", "condition": { "batch_size": 256, "comparison_depth": 6, "degree": 8, "dropout": 0.1, "entities": 128, "evaluation_size": 1024, "heads": 4, "hops": 4, "id_fraction": 0.75, "id_test_fraction": 0.1, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "left_repeats": 1, "left_unique_layers": 6, "lr": 0.0001, "n_atomic_per_batch": 32, "nodes": [ 0, 100, 250, 500, 1000, 2000, 4000, 6000, 8000, 10000, 12000, 14000, 16000, 24000, 32000, 40000, 48000, 56000, 64000, 72000, 80000, 88000, 96000, 104000, 112000, 120000, 128000 ], "phase": "development", "phi": 96, "relations": 16, "right_repeats": 6, "right_unique_layers": 1, "steps": 128000, "warmup": 2000, "weight_decay": 0.1, "weight_nodes": [ 0, 16000, 64000, 128000 ], "width": 128 }, "worlds": 1, "paired_runs": 1, "endpoint_id_full_difference": { "mean": 0.0, "min": 0.0, "max": 0.0, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "endpoint_ood_difference": { "mean": -0.0022744503411675516, "min": -0.0022744503411675516, "max": -0.0022744503411675516, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "common_budget_id_probe_difference": { "mean": 0.0, "min": 0.0, "max": 0.0, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "common_budget_ood_difference": { "mean": -0.0022744503411675516, "min": -0.0022744503411675516, "max": -0.0022744503411675516, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 } }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "pair": "l2_minus_c2", "condition": { "batch_size": 256, "comparison_depth": 6, "degree": 8, "dropout": 0.1, "entities": 128, "evaluation_size": 1024, "heads": 4, "hops": 4, "id_fraction": 0.75, "id_test_fraction": 0.1, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "left_repeats": 1, "left_unique_layers": 2, "lr": 0.0001, "n_atomic_per_batch": 32, "nodes": [ 0, 100, 250, 500, 1000, 2000, 4000, 6000, 8000, 10000, 12000, 14000, 16000, 24000, 32000, 40000, 48000, 56000, 64000, 72000, 80000, 88000, 96000, 104000, 112000, 120000, 128000 ], "phase": "development", "phi": 96, "relations": 16, "right_repeats": 3, "right_unique_layers": 2, "steps": 128000, "warmup": 2000, "weight_decay": 0.1, "weight_nodes": [ 0, 16000, 64000, 128000 ], "width": 128 }, "worlds": 1, "paired_runs": 1, "endpoint_id_full_difference": { "mean": 0.1346290590187248, "min": 0.1346290590187248, "max": 0.1346290590187248, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "endpoint_ood_difference": { "mean": 0.0026535253980288095, "min": 0.0026535253980288095, "max": 0.0026535253980288095, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "common_budget_id_probe_difference": { "mean": 0.15625, "min": 0.15625, "max": 0.15625, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "common_budget_ood_difference": { "mean": 0.0, "min": 0.0, "max": 0.0, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 } }, { "config": "configs/grok-loop-development-v1.json", "pair": "l1_minus_c1", "condition": { "batch_size": 256, "comparison_depth": 6, "degree": 8, "dropout": 0.1, "entities": 128, "evaluation_size": 1024, "heads": 4, "hops": 4, "id_fraction": 0.75, "id_test_fraction": 0.1, "init_scheme": "scaled_effective", "left_repeats": 1, "left_unique_layers": 1, "lr": 0.0001, "n_atomic_per_batch": 32, "nodes": [ 0, 100, 250, 500, 1000, 2000, 4000, 6000, 8000, 10000, 12000, 14000, 16000, 24000, 32000, 40000, 48000, 56000, 64000, 72000, 80000, 88000, 96000, 104000, 112000, 120000, 128000 ], "phase": "development", "phi": 96, "relations": 16, "right_repeats": 6, "right_unique_layers": 1, "steps": 128000, "warmup": 2000, "weight_decay": 0.1, "weight_nodes": [ 0, 16000, 64000, 128000 ], "width": 128 }, "worlds": 1, "paired_runs": 1, "endpoint_id_full_difference": { "mean": 0.6029272339416923, "min": 0.6029272339416923, "max": 0.6029272339416923, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "endpoint_ood_difference": { "mean": 0.0003790750568612583, "min": 0.0003790750568612583, "max": 0.0003790750568612583, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "common_budget_id_probe_difference": { "mean": 0.6162109375, "min": 0.6162109375, "max": 0.6162109375, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 }, "common_budget_ood_difference": { "mean": -0.001516300227445034, "min": -0.001516300227445034, "max": -0.001516300227445034, "worlds_with_denominator": 1 } } ] }, "threshold_cost_definition": "first observed checkpoint whose fixed ID probe answer+EOS accuracy reaches 90% or 95%; no interpolation or consecutive-node requirement; null if not reached", "statistical_unit": "world; initialization seeds averaged within each world" }