{ "selected_step": 4153, "mixture_test": { "test_completed": true, "calibration_completed": true, "raw": { "overall": { "count": 3693, "soft_ce": 0.7085598693044783, "kl": 0.3931482496012985, "brier": 0.09769070277607729, "argmax_agreement": 0.7733549959382616, "hard_count": 2134, "hard_ece": 0.042129272019540774, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.1280767528435369, "reference_agreement": 0.0 }, { "count": 18, "confidence": 0.18404859928386386, "reference_agreement": 0.2222222222222222 }, { "count": 23, "confidence": 0.23661101358223402, "reference_agreement": 0.2608695652173913 }, { "count": 37, "confidence": 0.30428753988952256, "reference_agreement": 0.1891891891891892 }, { "count": 36, "confidence": 0.36932558263805926, "reference_agreement": 0.3888888888888889 }, { "count": 57, "confidence": 0.43265722650360866, "reference_agreement": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "count": 71, "confidence": 0.5035452847115158, "reference_agreement": 0.5070422535211268 }, { "count": 93, "confidence": 0.5702882440958308, "reference_agreement": 0.5053763440860215 }, { "count": 113, "confidence": 0.6289013423061501, "reference_agreement": 0.5398230088495575 }, { "count": 88, "confidence": 0.7035225652548067, "reference_agreement": 0.5909090909090909 }, { "count": 97, "confidence": 0.7663997989026462, "reference_agreement": 0.6804123711340206 }, { "count": 133, "confidence": 0.8331041320580328, "reference_agreement": 0.7218045112781954 }, { "count": 213, "confidence": 0.9010564345576307, "reference_agreement": 0.812206572769953 }, { "count": 1154, "confidence": 0.9892346259941478, "reference_agreement": 0.9809358752166378 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.1280767528435369, "reference_agreement": 0.0 }, { "count": 22, "confidence": 0.18189946160649148, "reference_agreement": 0.253859649122807 }, { "count": 52, "confidence": 0.24099144225648178, "reference_agreement": 0.2604555167055167 }, { "count": 105, "confidence": 0.30435695062773516, "reference_agreement": 0.2666363084654525 }, { "count": 151, "confidence": 0.36784610221152053, "reference_agreement": 0.38072070275124964 }, { "count": 219, "confidence": 0.4348046806054027, "reference_agreement": 0.4029960976805746 }, { "count": 268, "confidence": 0.5012982178117764, "reference_agreement": 0.4966141654778031 }, { "count": 287, "confidence": 0.5665963085542071, "reference_agreement": 0.5549424985680554 }, { "count": 284, "confidence": 0.6310971171485777, "reference_agreement": 0.600541924578161 }, { "count": 280, "confidence": 0.7030994468429518, "reference_agreement": 0.6497546304223978 }, { "count": 218, "confidence": 0.7682645359325981, "reference_agreement": 0.7226513752826121 }, { "count": 230, "confidence": 0.8322149342184884, "reference_agreement": 0.7612036827968656 }, { "count": 324, "confidence": 0.8996811349428281, "reference_agreement": 0.8247895057612304 }, { "count": 1252, "confidence": 0.9876585496182678, "reference_agreement": 0.9778121922719432 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.4570759707537796 }, "type": { "choice": { "count": 2526, "soft_ce": 0.6822833143719118, "kl": 0.4189869815862902, "brier": 0.10139614023942027, "argmax_agreement": 0.7862232779097387, "hard_count": 1737, "hard_ece": 0.04277428653676444, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.1280767528435369, "reference_agreement": 0.0 }, { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.17932821619602474, "reference_agreement": 0.4 }, { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.2380902472918557, "reference_agreement": 0.25 }, { "count": 14, "confidence": 0.3081997411534075, "reference_agreement": 0.2857142857142857 }, { "count": 24, "confidence": 0.3697200232466156, "reference_agreement": 0.4166666666666667 }, { "count": 40, "confidence": 0.43214316524587604, "reference_agreement": 0.3 }, { "count": 58, "confidence": 0.5047682692169494, "reference_agreement": 0.5344827586206896 }, { "count": 76, "confidence": 0.5702475474241634, "reference_agreement": 0.5131578947368421 }, { "count": 85, "confidence": 0.6294861640993207, "reference_agreement": 0.5411764705882353 }, { "count": 61, "confidence": 0.7034878822257229, "reference_agreement": 0.6229508196721312 }, { "count": 73, "confidence": 0.7662886786794736, "reference_agreement": 0.6712328767123288 }, { "count": 109, "confidence": 0.8327800034747108, "reference_agreement": 0.7155963302752294 }, { "count": 163, "confidence": 0.9005930750387896, "reference_agreement": 0.7852760736196319 }, { "count": 1024, "confidence": 0.9905297995078783, "reference_agreement": 0.9814453125 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.1280767528435369, "reference_agreement": 0.0 }, { "count": 9, "confidence": 0.1761727165792652, "reference_agreement": 0.39832358674463936 }, { "count": 20, "confidence": 0.23727536848341457, "reference_agreement": 0.23968434343434342 }, { "count": 56, "confidence": 0.30649961126616326, "reference_agreement": 0.2928895108131916 }, { "count": 112, "confidence": 0.36821444135421544, "reference_agreement": 0.393456101968026 }, { "count": 148, "confidence": 0.43446487817770657, "reference_agreement": 0.4016674390496405 }, { "count": 173, "confidence": 0.4989247303895505, "reference_agreement": 0.5024153201745094 }, { "count": 161, "confidence": 0.5682084517346793, "reference_agreement": 0.5282341373438668 }, { "count": 170, "confidence": 0.6297812369278754, "reference_agreement": 0.5908322297566935 }, { "count": 148, "confidence": 0.700524650342172, "reference_agreement": 0.6783159155834284 }, { "count": 123, "confidence": 0.7663341138612425, "reference_agreement": 0.708765336806816 }, { "count": 150, "confidence": 0.8331362507431996, "reference_agreement": 0.7423155758796159 }, { "count": 207, "confidence": 0.8989791587743893, "reference_agreement": 0.7958650265103496 }, { "count": 1048, "confidence": 0.9898586616987579, "reference_agreement": 0.9796660513168818 } ] }, "noul": { "count": 582, "soft_ce": 0.485984791408039, "kl": 0.1677006591643438, "brier": 0.056889637384882515, "argmax_agreement": 0.8316151202749141, "hard_count": 154, "hard_ece": 0.05817309278238439, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.5156046866868782, "reference_agreement": 0.5 }, { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.5744020664194579, "reference_agreement": 0.8 }, { "count": 15, "confidence": 0.6251505169037502, "reference_agreement": 0.4666666666666667 }, { "count": 15, "confidence": 0.7097643525488307, "reference_agreement": 0.5333333333333333 }, { "count": 11, "confidence": 0.7837242799754484, "reference_agreement": 0.7272727272727273 }, { "count": 10, "confidence": 0.833779143408664, "reference_agreement": 0.9 }, { "count": 22, "confidence": 0.9027589227901665, "reference_agreement": 0.9090909090909091 }, { "count": 74, "confidence": 0.9777466873130052, "reference_agreement": 0.9594594594594594 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 34, "confidence": 0.5192844401029223, "reference_agreement": 0.502892126954275 }, { "count": 55, "confidence": 0.5665664402627255, "reference_agreement": 0.6365357818181818 }, { "count": 72, "confidence": 0.6353817301417451, "reference_agreement": 0.617865484172874 }, { "count": 84, "confidence": 0.7075900367197564, "reference_agreement": 0.6229389882371539 }, { "count": 58, "confidence": 0.7769928207174944, "reference_agreement": 0.7633095172413793 }, { "count": 55, "confidence": 0.829995783859167, "reference_agreement": 0.8141728722666914 }, { "count": 83, "confidence": 0.9004798674802651, "reference_agreement": 0.8669205460521514 }, { "count": 141, "confidence": 0.975388672803986, "reference_agreement": 0.9554196875487998 } ] }, "score": { "count": 585, "soft_ce": 1.043454353228223, "kl": 0.5058693789008174, "brier": 0.12228264299021577, "argmax_agreement": 0.6598290598290598, "hard_count": 243, "hard_ece": 0.07115621447701632, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.18586413124072504, "reference_agreement": 0.15384615384615385 }, { "count": 19, "confidence": 0.2362995959591558, "reference_agreement": 0.2631578947368421 }, { "count": 23, "confidence": 0.3019061999897666, "reference_agreement": 0.13043478260869565 }, { "count": 12, "confidence": 0.3685367014209464, "reference_agreement": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "count": 17, "confidence": 0.4338667824041559, "reference_agreement": 0.4117647058823529 }, { "count": 11, "confidence": 0.49490420241461824, "reference_agreement": 0.36363636363636365 }, { "count": 12, "confidence": 0.5688318970482136, "reference_agreement": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.6294053829689576, "reference_agreement": 0.6153846153846154 }, { "count": 12, "confidence": 0.6958966365351196, "reference_agreement": 0.5 }, { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.7523646054019367, "reference_agreement": 0.6923076923076923 }, { "count": 14, "confidence": 0.8351455536348746, "reference_agreement": 0.6428571428571429 }, { "count": 28, "confidence": 0.9024161795738924, "reference_agreement": 0.8928571428571429 }, { "count": 56, "confidence": 0.9807319435717284, "reference_agreement": 1.0 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.18586413124072504, "reference_agreement": 0.15384615384615385 }, { "count": 32, "confidence": 0.24331398836464874, "reference_agreement": 0.2734375 }, { "count": 49, "confidence": 0.3019081956123887, "reference_agreement": 0.23663264863946495 }, { "count": 39, "confidence": 0.3667883077504478, "reference_agreement": 0.34414724859025103 }, { "count": 71, "confidence": 0.43551300115891045, "reference_agreement": 0.4057656959535077 }, { "count": 61, "confidence": 0.49800447627318833, "reference_agreement": 0.47666251871173404 }, { "count": 71, "confidence": 0.5629637410045656, "reference_agreement": 0.5523004644601318 }, { "count": 42, "confidence": 0.6290782481488474, "reference_agreement": 0.610145539550307 }, { "count": 48, "confidence": 0.7031798704359478, "reference_agreement": 0.6086180416667305 }, { "count": 37, "confidence": 0.7609997088313216, "reference_agreement": 0.7050786860640831 }, { "count": 25, "confidence": 0.8315691658607272, "reference_agreement": 0.7580001074667474 }, { "count": 34, "confidence": 0.9020050839504612, "reference_agreement": 0.8980392369608144 }, { "count": 63, "confidence": 0.978521012641448, "reference_agreement": 0.9970899523809524 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.4570759707537796 } }, "category": { "engineering": { "count": 500, "soft_ce": 0.0170732927832887, "kl": 0.0170732927832887, "brier": 0.004504996059548485, "argmax_agreement": 0.996, "hard_count": 500, "hard_ece": 0.005887712376320884, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.48051708584209724, "reference_agreement": 1.0 }, { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.5901215718541692, "reference_agreement": 1.0 }, { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.659498582567833, "reference_agreement": 1.0 }, { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.7592606819949799, "reference_agreement": 0.75 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.809986801374795, "reference_agreement": 1.0 }, { "count": 6, "confidence": 0.9033714425633134, "reference_agreement": 0.8333333333333334 }, { "count": 485, "confidence": 0.9982748543344034, "reference_agreement": 1.0 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.48051708584209724, "reference_agreement": 1.0 }, { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.5901215718541692, "reference_agreement": 1.0 }, { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.659498582567833, "reference_agreement": 1.0 }, { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.7592606819949799, "reference_agreement": 0.75 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.809986801374795, "reference_agreement": 1.0 }, { "count": 6, "confidence": 0.9033714425633134, "reference_agreement": 0.8333333333333334 }, { "count": 485, "confidence": 0.9982748543344034, "reference_agreement": 1.0 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.36947776287918127 }, "data_analytics": { "count": 500, "soft_ce": 0.63641646085155, "kl": 0.6331406095589392, "brier": 0.15179326704736298, "argmax_agreement": 0.76, "hard_count": 497, "hard_ece": 0.05635174490474885, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.18512452516415256, "reference_agreement": 0.125 }, { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.23685294357226974, "reference_agreement": 0.23076923076923078 }, { "count": 16, "confidence": 0.310619358628449, "reference_agreement": 0.125 }, { "count": 15, "confidence": 0.36840624755576634, "reference_agreement": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.4338411624493362, "reference_agreement": 0.3076923076923077 }, { "count": 14, "confidence": 0.49562565013910687, "reference_agreement": 0.42857142857142855 }, { "count": 19, "confidence": 0.5716282587437927, "reference_agreement": 0.47368421052631576 }, { "count": 18, "confidence": 0.6307835105473234, "reference_agreement": 0.4444444444444444 }, { "count": 15, "confidence": 0.7034512348597252, "reference_agreement": 0.5333333333333333 }, { "count": 25, "confidence": 0.7610956537573322, "reference_agreement": 0.64 }, { "count": 27, "confidence": 0.8287917395783113, "reference_agreement": 0.7037037037037037 }, { "count": 60, "confidence": 0.9017458338366022, "reference_agreement": 0.8 }, { "count": 254, "confidence": 0.9885657799728477, "reference_agreement": 0.984251968503937 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.18512452516415256, "reference_agreement": 0.125 }, { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.23685294357226974, "reference_agreement": 0.23076923076923078 }, { "count": 16, "confidence": 0.310619358628449, "reference_agreement": 0.125 }, { "count": 15, "confidence": 0.36840624755576634, "reference_agreement": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.4338411624493362, "reference_agreement": 0.3076923076923077 }, { "count": 14, "confidence": 0.49562565013910687, "reference_agreement": 0.42857142857142855 }, { "count": 22, "confidence": 0.5710235531343882, "reference_agreement": 0.4762625909090909 }, { "count": 18, "confidence": 0.6307835105473234, "reference_agreement": 0.4444444444444444 }, { "count": 15, "confidence": 0.7034512348597252, "reference_agreement": 0.5333333333333333 }, { "count": 25, "confidence": 0.7610956537573322, "reference_agreement": 0.64 }, { "count": 27, "confidence": 0.8287917395783113, "reference_agreement": 0.7037037037037037 }, { "count": 60, "confidence": 0.9017458338366022, "reference_agreement": 0.8 }, { "count": 254, "confidence": 0.9885657799728477, "reference_agreement": 0.984251968503937 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.8379162320369495 }, "finance": { "count": 500, "soft_ce": 0.8325307227564824, "kl": 0.21741036887290283, "brier": 0.05805591006171185, "argmax_agreement": 0.766, "hard_count": 52, "hard_ece": 0.12560551004414863, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.42545552219647026, "reference_agreement": 0.0 }, { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.5063873523524167, "reference_agreement": 1.0 }, { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.5575393887409873, "reference_agreement": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.6185993089535619, "reference_agreement": 0.6666666666666666 }, { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.7072795840269844, "reference_agreement": 0.5 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.7583805784749291, "reference_agreement": 0.0 }, { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.8432613843014515, "reference_agreement": 0.6 }, { "count": 10, "confidence": 0.8980962253086776, "reference_agreement": 0.9 }, { "count": 21, "confidence": 0.9891833973182879, "reference_agreement": 1.0 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 11, "confidence": 0.32509882113799443, "reference_agreement": 0.44772725303034394 }, { "count": 31, "confidence": 0.36165303383874403, "reference_agreement": 0.32344085419356344 }, { "count": 56, "confidence": 0.433194585459043, "reference_agreement": 0.39091664392857783 }, { "count": 52, "confidence": 0.49251118240718983, "reference_agreement": 0.5019289031468974 }, { "count": 50, "confidence": 0.5634722409257146, "reference_agreement": 0.6018555810889367 }, { "count": 65, "confidence": 0.6301825914444824, "reference_agreement": 0.6561282074359387 }, { "count": 68, "confidence": 0.7056494781490086, "reference_agreement": 0.627431364951034 }, { "count": 37, "confidence": 0.7683118932263894, "reference_agreement": 0.6799459059550426 }, { "count": 34, "confidence": 0.8290161206378067, "reference_agreement": 0.7909373143137849 }, { "count": 35, "confidence": 0.8969496853528575, "reference_agreement": 0.9005142873333625 }, { "count": 61, "confidence": 0.9760249311137575, "reference_agreement": 0.9830546393442623 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.28921449751489353 }, "trust_safety": { "count": 500, "soft_ce": 0.6965650575760396, "kl": 0.3262561593110357, "brier": 0.09241847396917179, "argmax_agreement": 0.734, "hard_count": 222, "hard_ece": 0.06416689376484794, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.37375993751238135, "reference_agreement": 0.0 }, { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.43472235444626844, "reference_agreement": 0.4 }, { "count": 10, "confidence": 0.502873413716155, "reference_agreement": 0.5 }, { "count": 11, "confidence": 0.5716600619610657, "reference_agreement": 0.8181818181818182 }, { "count": 14, "confidence": 0.6273743231263287, "reference_agreement": 0.5714285714285714 }, { "count": 14, "confidence": 0.7048754950230958, "reference_agreement": 0.6428571428571429 }, { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.772673527518938, "reference_agreement": 0.625 }, { "count": 23, "confidence": 0.8352234500546492, "reference_agreement": 0.6956521739130435 }, { "count": 22, "confidence": 0.9039014670840353, "reference_agreement": 0.8181818181818182 }, { "count": 113, "confidence": 0.9792441416955855, "reference_agreement": 0.9557522123893806 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 6, "confidence": 0.23458907659811615, "reference_agreement": 0.2075 }, { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.29972115715656333, "reference_agreement": 0.255416625 }, { "count": 17, "confidence": 0.36836999088901834, "reference_agreement": 0.33265160656977494 }, { "count": 24, "confidence": 0.4353651177707092, "reference_agreement": 0.40927912136242695 }, { "count": 42, "confidence": 0.5034541101303811, "reference_agreement": 0.4637698182486976 }, { "count": 44, "confidence": 0.5639370342777291, "reference_agreement": 0.5822456558441558 }, { "count": 43, "confidence": 0.6301712982399027, "reference_agreement": 0.5623823154308876 }, { "count": 45, "confidence": 0.7009662006930144, "reference_agreement": 0.625547008811918 }, { "count": 25, "confidence": 0.7682502104322542, "reference_agreement": 0.6588631578947368 }, { "count": 42, "confidence": 0.8340236494740164, "reference_agreement": 0.7355623967695999 }, { "count": 53, "confidence": 0.9011086418913816, "reference_agreement": 0.8135774190795747 }, { "count": 151, "confidence": 0.9780184864854932, "reference_agreement": 0.9430664742453473 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.3245526679121535 }, "documents_meetings": { "count": 500, "soft_ce": 0.9479271825455599, "kl": 0.27931837942071347, "brier": 0.06632900701852151, "argmax_agreement": 0.754, "hard_count": 111, "hard_ece": 0.07985648898540725, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.5112290740361165, "reference_agreement": 1.0 }, { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.5755079266886977, "reference_agreement": 0.625 }, { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.6215870747073032, "reference_agreement": 0.75 }, { "count": 7, "confidence": 0.7132942799377675, "reference_agreement": 0.5714285714285714 }, { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.7689218976142511, "reference_agreement": 0.5 }, { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.8325792906268336, "reference_agreement": 0.7692307692307693 }, { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.894684750793525, "reference_agreement": 0.8461538461538461 }, { "count": 54, "confidence": 0.980788268448271, "reference_agreement": 0.9444444444444444 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 16, "confidence": 0.2529896903034424, "reference_agreement": 0.2572032828282828 }, { "count": 26, "confidence": 0.30085803531102356, "reference_agreement": 0.2784615384615385 }, { "count": 37, "confidence": 0.3672361246048308, "reference_agreement": 0.373009828009828 }, { "count": 42, "confidence": 0.43667169969021885, "reference_agreement": 0.49312530062530063 }, { "count": 64, "confidence": 0.5041356739419488, "reference_agreement": 0.576640625 }, { "count": 57, "confidence": 0.5696819547588704, "reference_agreement": 0.6160136452241716 }, { "count": 52, "confidence": 0.6318176118679493, "reference_agreement": 0.6767307692307691 }, { "count": 51, "confidence": 0.7024724227358164, "reference_agreement": 0.7055555555555556 }, { "count": 38, "confidence": 0.7733050801429199, "reference_agreement": 0.7889473684210526 }, { "count": 33, "confidence": 0.8353726880577852, "reference_agreement": 0.8224242424242424 }, { "count": 30, "confidence": 0.8930073021992985, "reference_agreement": 0.8578333333333333 }, { "count": 54, "confidence": 0.980788268448271, "reference_agreement": 0.9444444444444444 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.3935315866553138 }, "customer_support": { "count": 500, "soft_ce": 1.1372885709258729, "kl": 0.5544979078550764, "brier": 0.11033544189723725, "argmax_agreement": 0.706, "hard_count": 142, "hard_ece": 0.14171122927377042, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.1280767528435369, "reference_agreement": 0.0 }, { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.17932821619602474, "reference_agreement": 0.4 }, { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.22071972996391087, "reference_agreement": 0.0 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.3112827985653901, "reference_agreement": 0.0 }, { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.37505887333787874, "reference_agreement": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.4293526333096114, "reference_agreement": 0.25 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.49253722456655336, "reference_agreement": 0.5 }, { "count": 11, "confidence": 0.5647034564825082, "reference_agreement": 0.18181818181818182 }, { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.6399711185141979, "reference_agreement": 0.75 }, { "count": 7, "confidence": 0.6905290585463988, "reference_agreement": 0.5714285714285714 }, { "count": 10, "confidence": 0.7733585610196265, "reference_agreement": 0.6 }, { "count": 17, "confidence": 0.8359032378172329, "reference_agreement": 0.7647058823529411 }, { "count": 20, "confidence": 0.9086037470245399, "reference_agreement": 0.6 }, { "count": 51, "confidence": 0.9778779954883188, "reference_agreement": 0.9411764705882353 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.1280767528435369, "reference_agreement": 0.0 }, { "count": 9, "confidence": 0.1761727165792652, "reference_agreement": 0.39832358674463936 }, { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.23185648880822557, "reference_agreement": 0.2729292929292929 }, { "count": 25, "confidence": 0.3010096491709431, "reference_agreement": 0.27153918422154916 }, { "count": 33, "confidence": 0.3716936308219563, "reference_agreement": 0.43249653598146726 }, { "count": 46, "confidence": 0.43566624910724644, "reference_agreement": 0.3784143440302738 }, { "count": 49, "confidence": 0.5004958652365038, "reference_agreement": 0.464408579758434 }, { "count": 64, "confidence": 0.5647801490500414, "reference_agreement": 0.4939270455676706 }, { "count": 35, "confidence": 0.6338884106064454, "reference_agreement": 0.6524762 }, { "count": 49, "confidence": 0.7014723835777643, "reference_agreement": 0.6855101955782364 }, { "count": 34, "confidence": 0.7717612201235851, "reference_agreement": 0.7027941176470588 }, { "count": 37, "confidence": 0.8313773086286068, "reference_agreement": 0.763963945945946 }, { "count": 47, "confidence": 0.9031494358129605, "reference_agreement": 0.7396099361702129 }, { "count": 63, "confidence": 0.9737046850235944, "reference_agreement": 0.9396507939418092 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.33143847468388904 }, "ai_agents_evals": { "count": 500, "soft_ce": 0.765946732434316, "kl": 0.6764210789434673, "brier": 0.18685146874516365, "argmax_agreement": 0.68, "hard_count": 417, "hard_ece": 0.06936429979471131, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.187047500963241, "reference_agreement": 0.2 }, { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.23585635105072375, "reference_agreement": 0.25 }, { "count": 19, "confidence": 0.2982191389855985, "reference_agreement": 0.2631578947368421 }, { "count": 14, "confidence": 0.36932960679831744, "reference_agreement": 0.5714285714285714 }, { "count": 27, "confidence": 0.43134028318033907, "reference_agreement": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "count": 32, "confidence": 0.5068791830358712, "reference_agreement": 0.4375 }, { "count": 33, "confidence": 0.5698085895150488, "reference_agreement": 0.5151515151515151 }, { "count": 53, "confidence": 0.6282809191581149, "reference_agreement": 0.49056603773584906 }, { "count": 34, "confidence": 0.7055160692185535, "reference_agreement": 0.6176470588235294 }, { "count": 33, "confidence": 0.765969600593059, "reference_agreement": 0.8181818181818182 }, { "count": 28, "confidence": 0.8332225392168197, "reference_agreement": 0.7857142857142857 }, { "count": 54, "confidence": 0.8969179427292381, "reference_agreement": 0.8703703703703703 }, { "count": 77, "confidence": 0.9715351814332892, "reference_agreement": 0.922077922077922 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.187047500963241, "reference_agreement": 0.2 }, { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.23585635105072375, "reference_agreement": 0.25 }, { "count": 19, "confidence": 0.2982191389855985, "reference_agreement": 0.2631578947368421 }, { "count": 16, "confidence": 0.3728244454729145, "reference_agreement": 0.5458333125 }, { "count": 35, "confidence": 0.43292344830072604, "reference_agreement": 0.35496548479120027 }, { "count": 41, "confidence": 0.5085266662477907, "reference_agreement": 0.45982781975131765 }, { "count": 42, "confidence": 0.5678684243563111, "reference_agreement": 0.5322624638888933 }, { "count": 58, "confidence": 0.6299378167372339, "reference_agreement": 0.5120080436781644 }, { "count": 45, "confidence": 0.7054146769488767, "reference_agreement": 0.6565114530755077 }, { "count": 44, "confidence": 0.7651372249377204, "reference_agreement": 0.8189414169069195 }, { "count": 37, "confidence": 0.833874270098686, "reference_agreement": 0.8076943700618164 }, { "count": 65, "confidence": 0.8966887344775478, "reference_agreement": 0.8630389169038999 }, { "count": 85, "confidence": 0.9707936989016759, "reference_agreement": 0.9253352246481347 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.8450261299297381 }, "legal": { "count": 122, "soft_ce": 0.5668266819917146, "kl": 0.5668266819917146, "brier": 0.13410281322654918, "argmax_agreement": 0.819672131147541, "hard_count": 122, "hard_ece": 0.07370299961080379, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.25539450758217525, "reference_agreement": 1.0 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.3631581357093971, "reference_agreement": 0.0 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.4544914341376851, "reference_agreement": 0.5 }, { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.503085478379179, "reference_agreement": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.5760999183430778, "reference_agreement": 0.4 }, { "count": 6, "confidence": 0.6285356936618459, "reference_agreement": 0.6666666666666666 }, { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.6943533513117489, "reference_agreement": 0.6666666666666666 }, { "count": 9, "confidence": 0.7758294858466038, "reference_agreement": 0.6666666666666666 }, { "count": 7, "confidence": 0.8221451030950648, "reference_agreement": 0.42857142857142855 }, { "count": 12, "confidence": 0.9086579271812519, "reference_agreement": 0.75 }, { "count": 72, "confidence": 0.9849048761433361, "reference_agreement": 0.9861111111111112 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.25539450758217525, "reference_agreement": 1.0 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.3631581357093971, "reference_agreement": 0.0 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.4544914341376851, "reference_agreement": 0.5 }, { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.503085478379179, "reference_agreement": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.5760999183430778, "reference_agreement": 0.4 }, { "count": 6, "confidence": 0.6285356936618459, "reference_agreement": 0.6666666666666666 }, { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.6943533513117489, "reference_agreement": 0.6666666666666666 }, { "count": 9, "confidence": 0.7758294858466038, "reference_agreement": 0.6666666666666666 }, { "count": 7, "confidence": 0.8221451030950648, "reference_agreement": 0.42857142857142855 }, { "count": 12, "confidence": 0.9086579271812519, "reference_agreement": 0.75 }, { "count": 72, "confidence": 0.9849048761433361, "reference_agreement": 0.9861111111111112 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.05627741100384848 }, "sales_commerce": { "count": 71, "soft_ce": 0.43217932678724524, "kl": 0.43217932678724524, "brier": 0.13052027801486862, "argmax_agreement": 0.8169014084507042, "hard_count": 71, "hard_ece": 0.07210090880407366, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.43246792381509247, "reference_agreement": 1.0 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.5125808974731219, "reference_agreement": 0.5 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.5624424423010923, "reference_agreement": 0.5 }, { "count": 6, "confidence": 0.6350879180799406, "reference_agreement": 0.5 }, { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.6908680440851511, "reference_agreement": 0.5 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.7547308258492205, "reference_agreement": 0.5 }, { "count": 11, "confidence": 0.8418109162556351, "reference_agreement": 0.7272727272727273 }, { "count": 16, "confidence": 0.8995504132439553, "reference_agreement": 0.875 }, { "count": 27, "confidence": 0.9753556391806691, "reference_agreement": 1.0 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.43246792381509247, "reference_agreement": 1.0 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.5125808974731219, "reference_agreement": 0.5 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.5624424423010923, "reference_agreement": 0.5 }, { "count": 6, "confidence": 0.6350879180799406, "reference_agreement": 0.5 }, { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.6908680440851511, "reference_agreement": 0.5 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.7547308258492205, "reference_agreement": 0.5 }, { "count": 11, "confidence": 0.8418109162556351, "reference_agreement": 0.7272727272727273 }, { "count": 16, "confidence": 0.8995504132439553, "reference_agreement": 0.875 }, { "count": 27, "confidence": 0.9753556391806691, "reference_agreement": 1.0 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.3227189172274408 } } }, "calibrated": { "overall": { "count": 3693, "soft_ce": 0.7041168734088186, "kl": 0.3887052537056387, "brier": 0.09690042536340486, "argmax_agreement": 0.7733549959382616, "hard_count": 2134, "hard_ece": 0.022770969448581948, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.11589315469434829, "reference_agreement": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "count": 17, "confidence": 0.17569618187345318, "reference_agreement": 0.17647058823529413 }, { "count": 26, "confidence": 0.23574174336686576, "reference_agreement": 0.23076923076923078 }, { "count": 43, "confidence": 0.30201610783522903, "reference_agreement": 0.23255813953488372 }, { "count": 51, "confidence": 0.3728587574318181, "reference_agreement": 0.35294117647058826 }, { "count": 55, "confidence": 0.43468960041354515, "reference_agreement": 0.36363636363636365 }, { "count": 78, "confidence": 0.5068967125125762, "reference_agreement": 0.47435897435897434 }, { "count": 116, "confidence": 0.5692509240339776, "reference_agreement": 0.5689655172413793 }, { "count": 92, "confidence": 0.6274691893699693, "reference_agreement": 0.5760869565217391 }, { "count": 113, "confidence": 0.6976255782232683, "reference_agreement": 0.584070796460177 }, { "count": 125, "confidence": 0.7655885050647548, "reference_agreement": 0.72 }, { "count": 153, "confidence": 0.8348620973385892, "reference_agreement": 0.7777777777777778 }, { "count": 193, "confidence": 0.9005488041523733, "reference_agreement": 0.8860103626943006 }, { "count": 1069, "confidence": 0.9873898699630395, "reference_agreement": 0.9850327408793265 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.11589315469434829, "reference_agreement": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "count": 23, "confidence": 0.1712254393277906, "reference_agreement": 0.22601507061461293 }, { "count": 65, "confidence": 0.241401549839449, "reference_agreement": 0.27101087801087803 }, { "count": 136, "confidence": 0.3047942264115045, "reference_agreement": 0.30327285409683113 }, { "count": 180, "confidence": 0.3704360020830201, "reference_agreement": 0.3727716890584122 }, { "count": 239, "confidence": 0.4341484282824121, "reference_agreement": 0.4200372081322403 }, { "count": 268, "confidence": 0.5028656676116453, "reference_agreement": 0.5155282699000787 }, { "count": 335, "confidence": 0.5660902452493901, "reference_agreement": 0.600639823533436 }, { "count": 269, "confidence": 0.631949793983103, "reference_agreement": 0.6359665011640041 }, { "count": 261, "confidence": 0.6984239785753936, "reference_agreement": 0.6471423835974844 }, { "count": 249, "confidence": 0.7657109724234291, "reference_agreement": 0.7478915785725628 }, { "count": 253, "confidence": 0.8344639775274048, "reference_agreement": 0.8022606606356278 }, { "count": 261, "confidence": 0.8995167793570855, "reference_agreement": 0.8815173885724905 }, { "count": 1151, "confidence": 0.9856462873311037, "reference_agreement": 0.9822842533704442 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.4584616360574015 }, "type": { "choice": { "count": 2526, "soft_ce": 0.6766963060796009, "kl": 0.4133999732939792, "brier": 0.10042181389472693, "argmax_agreement": 0.7862232779097387, "hard_count": 1737, "hard_ece": 0.024066863233766642, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.11589315469434829, "reference_agreement": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.1466965963178435, "reference_agreement": 0.25 }, { "count": 7, "confidence": 0.23979741242633804, "reference_agreement": 0.14285714285714285 }, { "count": 20, "confidence": 0.30543179732871933, "reference_agreement": 0.35 }, { "count": 39, "confidence": 0.3752333136919975, "reference_agreement": 0.358974358974359 }, { "count": 37, "confidence": 0.43632325318545506, "reference_agreement": 0.35135135135135137 }, { "count": 64, "confidence": 0.5078595631087047, "reference_agreement": 0.484375 }, { "count": 91, "confidence": 0.5663438578130047, "reference_agreement": 0.6043956043956044 }, { "count": 72, "confidence": 0.6259376203313807, "reference_agreement": 0.5555555555555556 }, { "count": 87, "confidence": 0.6985076075501826, "reference_agreement": 0.6091954022988506 }, { "count": 98, "confidence": 0.7672216909611733, "reference_agreement": 0.7142857142857143 }, { "count": 126, "confidence": 0.835107717990711, "reference_agreement": 0.7777777777777778 }, { "count": 140, "confidence": 0.8998423906655577, "reference_agreement": 0.8857142857142857 }, { "count": 949, "confidence": 0.988617468252103, "reference_agreement": 0.9852476290832455 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.11589315469434829, "reference_agreement": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "count": 10, "confidence": 0.15381363979618545, "reference_agreement": 0.3198346624136098 }, { "count": 31, "confidence": 0.2398905686918626, "reference_agreement": 0.2732486151840991 }, { "count": 88, "confidence": 0.3066439829194413, "reference_agreement": 0.33710350424812785 }, { "count": 140, "confidence": 0.37159211827431626, "reference_agreement": 0.3838011523963886 }, { "count": 167, "confidence": 0.4341350320260209, "reference_agreement": 0.42457801395752337 }, { "count": 166, "confidence": 0.5007513721327872, "reference_agreement": 0.5253523924620044 }, { "count": 197, "confidence": 0.565477477433576, "reference_agreement": 0.619517122506086 }, { "count": 158, "confidence": 0.6298800441075835, "reference_agreement": 0.6306406317730678 }, { "count": 141, "confidence": 0.6982422404036815, "reference_agreement": 0.6697869686413617 }, { "count": 136, "confidence": 0.7667611071607225, "reference_agreement": 0.7399642556669485 }, { "count": 165, "confidence": 0.8340530433682095, "reference_agreement": 0.7888326080745547 }, { "count": 164, "confidence": 0.899220153771901, "reference_agreement": 0.8851424152139722 }, { "count": 960, "confidence": 0.988268968121057, "reference_agreement": 0.9841545132135424 } ] }, "noul": { "count": 582, "soft_ce": 0.4827658039249084, "kl": 0.16448167168121322, "brier": 0.05629811292264301, "argmax_agreement": 0.8316151202749141, "hard_count": 154, "hard_ece": 0.03838079417551199, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.51409214953238, "reference_agreement": 0.5 }, { "count": 12, "confidence": 0.5848970391247416, "reference_agreement": 0.5833333333333334 }, { "count": 10, "confidence": 0.6345947956878246, "reference_agreement": 0.6 }, { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.6959874383006549, "reference_agreement": 0.46153846153846156 }, { "count": 14, "confidence": 0.7675695442215852, "reference_agreement": 0.7857142857142857 }, { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.8339093290833637, "reference_agreement": 0.9230769230769231 }, { "count": 25, "confidence": 0.9051654333633907, "reference_agreement": 0.88 }, { "count": 65, "confidence": 0.9758087375812551, "reference_agreement": 0.9692307692307692 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 34, "confidence": 0.5174138851791591, "reference_agreement": 0.502892126954275 }, { "count": 71, "confidence": 0.5685861678053349, "reference_agreement": 0.6089361690140845 }, { "count": 72, "confidence": 0.6374148978709203, "reference_agreement": 0.6503378173406389 }, { "count": 72, "confidence": 0.6973135426818078, "reference_agreement": 0.6177620419978036 }, { "count": 76, "confidence": 0.7668883954141004, "reference_agreement": 0.7746528812652387 }, { "count": 63, "confidence": 0.8361374834836659, "reference_agreement": 0.8580618729922205 }, { "count": 65, "confidence": 0.899478685155311, "reference_agreement": 0.8626053588050548 }, { "count": 129, "confidence": 0.9701079851807889, "reference_agreement": 0.9612726817393857 } ] }, "score": { "count": 585, "soft_ce": 1.0427334127476895, "kl": 0.505148438420284, "brier": 0.12208934572306966, "argmax_agreement": 0.6598290598290598, "hard_count": 243, "hard_ece": 0.0736454437457963, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.18461913127517923, "reference_agreement": 0.15384615384615385 }, { "count": 19, "confidence": 0.23424754950284965, "reference_agreement": 0.2631578947368421 }, { "count": 23, "confidence": 0.299045943058281, "reference_agreement": 0.13043478260869565 }, { "count": 12, "confidence": 0.365141449586235, "reference_agreement": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "count": 18, "confidence": 0.43133153638239685, "reference_agreement": 0.3888888888888889 }, { "count": 12, "confidence": 0.5005622698299229, "reference_agreement": 0.4166666666666667 }, { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.5751578198046974, "reference_agreement": 0.3076923076923077 }, { "count": 10, "confidence": 0.6313708801299527, "reference_agreement": 0.7 }, { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.6933609064965334, "reference_agreement": 0.5384615384615384 }, { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.7511433692151679, "reference_agreement": 0.6923076923076923 }, { "count": 14, "confidence": 0.8335362248493442, "reference_agreement": 0.6428571428571429 }, { "count": 28, "confidence": 0.8999588812194718, "reference_agreement": 0.8928571428571429 }, { "count": 55, "confidence": 0.9798950122993066, "reference_agreement": 1.0 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.18461913127517923, "reference_agreement": 0.15384615384615385 }, { "count": 34, "confidence": 0.24277920912107187, "reference_agreement": 0.26897058823529413 }, { "count": 48, "confidence": 0.30140300614695376, "reference_agreement": 0.24124999548612047 }, { "count": 40, "confidence": 0.3663895954134836, "reference_agreement": 0.3341685673754948 }, { "count": 72, "confidence": 0.4341795001548752, "reference_agreement": 0.40950506128748676 }, { "count": 68, "confidence": 0.5007529272027481, "reference_agreement": 0.49786392453063255 }, { "count": 67, "confidence": 0.5652470326858571, "reference_agreement": 0.5363432798507779 }, { "count": 39, "confidence": 0.6302455119423146, "reference_agreement": 0.6310114396011891 }, { "count": 48, "confidence": 0.7006234882951765, "reference_agreement": 0.6246944274306163 }, { "count": 37, "confidence": 0.759432527246053, "reference_agreement": 0.7220606842622975 }, { "count": 25, "confidence": 0.8329589079683152, "reference_agreement": 0.7502667524000977 }, { "count": 32, "confidence": 0.9011143643285106, "reference_agreement": 0.9013541875 }, { "count": 62, "confidence": 0.9773667295736088, "reference_agreement": 0.9970430161290323 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.4584616360574015 } }, "category": { "engineering": { "count": 500, "soft_ce": 0.018681013106648606, "kl": 0.018681013106648606, "brier": 0.004596240452886235, "argmax_agreement": 0.996, "hard_count": 500, "hard_ece": 0.010272557015768891, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.4716738957978698, "reference_agreement": 1.0 }, { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.5539038973137703, "reference_agreement": 1.0 }, { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.655163400891637, "reference_agreement": 1.0 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.7052527420032781, "reference_agreement": 0.5 }, { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.7571008671839193, "reference_agreement": 1.0 }, { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.8521442972732137, "reference_agreement": 0.6666666666666666 }, { "count": 9, "confidence": 0.9071717975027496, "reference_agreement": 1.0 }, { "count": 479, "confidence": 0.9978224823124803, "reference_agreement": 1.0 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.4716738957978698, "reference_agreement": 1.0 }, { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.5539038973137703, "reference_agreement": 1.0 }, { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.655163400891637, "reference_agreement": 1.0 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.7052527420032781, "reference_agreement": 0.5 }, { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.7571008671839193, "reference_agreement": 1.0 }, { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.8521442972732137, "reference_agreement": 0.6666666666666666 }, { "count": 9, "confidence": 0.9071717975027496, "reference_agreement": 1.0 }, { "count": 479, "confidence": 0.9978224823124803, "reference_agreement": 1.0 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.3754904932299786 }, "data_analytics": { "count": 500, "soft_ce": 0.6222487807440032, "kl": 0.6189729294513925, "brier": 0.1492023277961967, "argmax_agreement": 0.76, "hard_count": 497, "hard_ece": 0.04324263356987873, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.1836431426040265, "reference_agreement": 0.125 }, { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.2326095606931366, "reference_agreement": 0.23076923076923078 }, { "count": 21, "confidence": 0.3080856226638128, "reference_agreement": 0.19047619047619047 }, { "count": 11, "confidence": 0.37224859620757544, "reference_agreement": 0.36363636363636365 }, { "count": 18, "confidence": 0.43216064330256254, "reference_agreement": 0.2777777777777778 }, { "count": 16, "confidence": 0.49955516847278475, "reference_agreement": 0.375 }, { "count": 20, "confidence": 0.5648218776742052, "reference_agreement": 0.5 }, { "count": 14, "confidence": 0.6284579234052629, "reference_agreement": 0.5 }, { "count": 29, "confidence": 0.7007100933753049, "reference_agreement": 0.5517241379310345 }, { "count": 25, "confidence": 0.7611781134778828, "reference_agreement": 0.68 }, { "count": 42, "confidence": 0.8391754153900324, "reference_agreement": 0.7857142857142857 }, { "count": 45, "confidence": 0.9013655316115832, "reference_agreement": 0.8888888888888888 }, { "count": 235, "confidence": 0.9854872248925048, "reference_agreement": 0.9914893617021276 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.1836431426040265, "reference_agreement": 0.125 }, { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.2326095606931366, "reference_agreement": 0.23076923076923078 }, { "count": 21, "confidence": 0.3080856226638128, "reference_agreement": 0.19047619047619047 }, { "count": 11, "confidence": 0.37224859620757544, "reference_agreement": 0.36363636363636365 }, { "count": 18, "confidence": 0.43216064330256254, "reference_agreement": 0.2777777777777778 }, { "count": 16, "confidence": 0.49955516847278475, "reference_agreement": 0.375 }, { "count": 23, "confidence": 0.56429092950471, "reference_agreement": 0.49903378260869563 }, { "count": 14, "confidence": 0.6284579234052629, "reference_agreement": 0.5 }, { "count": 29, "confidence": 0.7007100933753049, "reference_agreement": 0.5517241379310345 }, { "count": 25, "confidence": 0.7611781134778828, "reference_agreement": 0.68 }, { "count": 42, "confidence": 0.8391754153900324, "reference_agreement": 0.7857142857142857 }, { "count": 45, "confidence": 0.9013655316115832, "reference_agreement": 0.8888888888888888 }, { "count": 235, "confidence": 0.9854872248925048, "reference_agreement": 0.9914893617021276 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.8394948703521851 }, "finance": { "count": 500, "soft_ce": 0.8372534729882183, "kl": 0.22213311910463876, "brier": 0.05824555646969622, "argmax_agreement": 0.766, "hard_count": 52, "hard_ece": 0.11310128402928836, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.3723071041294397, "reference_agreement": 0.0 }, { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.50016902311118, "reference_agreement": 0.6 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.5753408310146032, "reference_agreement": 0.5 }, { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.6182583123935925, "reference_agreement": 1.0 }, { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.6819092006332838, "reference_agreement": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.7665259528880326, "reference_agreement": 0.4 }, { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.838982843566272, "reference_agreement": 0.75 }, { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.881833000901765, "reference_agreement": 0.875 }, { "count": 21, "confidence": 0.9797645091294379, "reference_agreement": 1.0 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 16, "confidence": 0.3226339567135692, "reference_agreement": 0.3984374629166975 }, { "count": 41, "confidence": 0.36674248561146494, "reference_agreement": 0.33682928918700217 }, { "count": 62, "confidence": 0.4340519346364484, "reference_agreement": 0.4111594596595161 }, { "count": 48, "confidence": 0.49924896849347133, "reference_agreement": 0.5386290065109846 }, { "count": 70, "confidence": 0.5686484601862719, "reference_agreement": 0.655761905714329 }, { "count": 50, "confidence": 0.6308002075172696, "reference_agreement": 0.6414333730000463 }, { "count": 54, "confidence": 0.6999272500653496, "reference_agreement": 0.6493579925926575 }, { "count": 46, "confidence": 0.7648365922391855, "reference_agreement": 0.7116637471812303 }, { "count": 32, "confidence": 0.8315695075811502, "reference_agreement": 0.8268750565625763 }, { "count": 22, "confidence": 0.8916310587032179, "reference_agreement": 0.9127121363636364 }, { "count": 59, "confidence": 0.9675218038967256, "reference_agreement": 0.9836666610169491 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.29112017853517996 }, "trust_safety": { "count": 500, "soft_ce": 0.6856993182154376, "kl": 0.31539041995043376, "brier": 0.09066598215826954, "argmax_agreement": 0.734, "hard_count": 222, "hard_ece": 0.06329846877237999, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.3683034743483865, "reference_agreement": 0.0 }, { "count": 7, "confidence": 0.43137594222756087, "reference_agreement": 0.2857142857142857 }, { "count": 9, "confidence": 0.505779039854673, "reference_agreement": 0.6666666666666666 }, { "count": 16, "confidence": 0.569920504948867, "reference_agreement": 0.75 }, { "count": 14, "confidence": 0.6316407404385947, "reference_agreement": 0.6428571428571429 }, { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.6972827104351492, "reference_agreement": 0.5 }, { "count": 18, "confidence": 0.7672982199470547, "reference_agreement": 0.6666666666666666 }, { "count": 19, "confidence": 0.826724451152989, "reference_agreement": 0.6842105263157895 }, { "count": 25, "confidence": 0.9010283785718083, "reference_agreement": 0.84 }, { "count": 104, "confidence": 0.9729483427736801, "reference_agreement": 0.9711538461538461 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 9, "confidence": 0.2361890508436565, "reference_agreement": 0.27388888888888885 }, { "count": 7, "confidence": 0.30342299595800304, "reference_agreement": 0.2961904285714286 }, { "count": 18, "confidence": 0.3674761849264621, "reference_agreement": 0.3014857858344078 }, { "count": 33, "confidence": 0.4359383368744807, "reference_agreement": 0.3778090549302529 }, { "count": 35, "confidence": 0.5047182741304667, "reference_agreement": 0.517333303803201 }, { "count": 55, "confidence": 0.5629326069104805, "reference_agreement": 0.5935795651642476 }, { "count": 49, "confidence": 0.6337639434256919, "reference_agreement": 0.6102933127493159 }, { "count": 29, "confidence": 0.693334781004934, "reference_agreement": 0.5768357275211178 }, { "count": 40, "confidence": 0.7684317409650803, "reference_agreement": 0.7117894730881641 }, { "count": 42, "confidence": 0.8344109799487145, "reference_agreement": 0.7692592592237804 }, { "count": 44, "confidence": 0.8999478793240552, "reference_agreement": 0.8112662345983765 }, { "count": 139, "confidence": 0.9715298963628789, "reference_agreement": 0.9553096231010606 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.3249617918461017 }, "documents_meetings": { "count": 500, "soft_ce": 0.9505308054596932, "kl": 0.2819220023348468, "brier": 0.06778096624550085, "argmax_agreement": 0.754, "hard_count": 111, "hard_ece": 0.0745149993383762, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 7, "confidence": 0.5130857536757218, "reference_agreement": 0.8571428571428571 }, { "count": 9, "confidence": 0.5759649564141678, "reference_agreement": 0.6666666666666666 }, { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.631365854228681, "reference_agreement": 0.8 }, { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.7057283821613531, "reference_agreement": 0.375 }, { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.7734135275347481, "reference_agreement": 0.75 }, { "count": 14, "confidence": 0.8276341762810223, "reference_agreement": 0.7857142857142857 }, { "count": 11, "confidence": 0.9061937668671157, "reference_agreement": 0.9090909090909091 }, { "count": 49, "confidence": 0.974518301452977, "reference_agreement": 0.9591836734693877 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 20, "confidence": 0.2507030605824935, "reference_agreement": 0.2815126262626263 }, { "count": 38, "confidence": 0.3027780535641847, "reference_agreement": 0.30187799043062197 }, { "count": 37, "confidence": 0.36910116911685614, "reference_agreement": 0.4304395304395305 }, { "count": 46, "confidence": 0.43197305120456336, "reference_agreement": 0.5305434782608696 }, { "count": 70, "confidence": 0.4998801989425534, "reference_agreement": 0.5903253968253969 }, { "count": 63, "confidence": 0.564395576933704, "reference_agreement": 0.65 }, { "count": 52, "confidence": 0.6360817173907356, "reference_agreement": 0.7249679487179487 }, { "count": 41, "confidence": 0.6999872254915769, "reference_agreement": 0.672560975609756 }, { "count": 34, "confidence": 0.769121243337486, "reference_agreement": 0.8225 }, { "count": 34, "confidence": 0.8294780729236917, "reference_agreement": 0.8451470588235294 }, { "count": 16, "confidence": 0.9032976162782315, "reference_agreement": 0.8896875 }, { "count": 49, "confidence": 0.974518301452977, "reference_agreement": 0.9591836734693877 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.39489489482681317 }, "customer_support": { "count": 500, "soft_ce": 1.1285135288404535, "kl": 0.545722865769657, "brier": 0.108362788973766, "argmax_agreement": 0.706, "hard_count": 142, "hard_ece": 0.11241881164831904, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.11589315469434829, "reference_agreement": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.1466965963178435, "reference_agreement": 0.25 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.23363389271036505, "reference_agreement": 0.0 }, { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.3018620938804334, "reference_agreement": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "count": 9, "confidence": 0.37797570812443015, "reference_agreement": 0.2222222222222222 }, { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.4272157242978048, "reference_agreement": 0.0 }, { "count": 7, "confidence": 0.5005016740966861, "reference_agreement": 0.14285714285714285 }, { "count": 7, "confidence": 0.5675968327842555, "reference_agreement": 0.8571428571428571 }, { "count": 7, "confidence": 0.6248700358768576, "reference_agreement": 0.5714285714285714 }, { "count": 9, "confidence": 0.7018524259315515, "reference_agreement": 0.5555555555555556 }, { "count": 18, "confidence": 0.763652193538776, "reference_agreement": 0.7222222222222222 }, { "count": 15, "confidence": 0.8335790279408464, "reference_agreement": 0.6666666666666666 }, { "count": 16, "confidence": 0.9023386004425975, "reference_agreement": 0.8125 }, { "count": 39, "confidence": 0.9678176556415846, "reference_agreement": 0.9487179487179487 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.11589315469434829, "reference_agreement": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "count": 10, "confidence": 0.15381363979618545, "reference_agreement": 0.3198346624136098 }, { "count": 12, "confidence": 0.24077671068363551, "reference_agreement": 0.29337121212121214 }, { "count": 35, "confidence": 0.3022639463465406, "reference_agreement": 0.3521546318325211 }, { "count": 42, "confidence": 0.37365140372838623, "reference_agreement": 0.35323562863250324 }, { "count": 45, "confidence": 0.4350034398300646, "reference_agreement": 0.36927072142944645 }, { "count": 55, "confidence": 0.5024000185598814, "reference_agreement": 0.4825757636363636 }, { "count": 55, "confidence": 0.5652814585293939, "reference_agreement": 0.631175707569653 }, { "count": 47, "confidence": 0.6319760416224046, "reference_agreement": 0.6904964592198635 }, { "count": 40, "confidence": 0.7024876007617367, "reference_agreement": 0.669458325 }, { "count": 43, "confidence": 0.766737205353825, "reference_agreement": 0.7386433953488373 }, { "count": 33, "confidence": 0.83741488958767, "reference_agreement": 0.7505555454545454 }, { "count": 37, "confidence": 0.8973418194210278, "reference_agreement": 0.8589099459459459 }, { "count": 43, "confidence": 0.965788577174672, "reference_agreement": 0.9501550236821856 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.33319003384682117 }, "ai_agents_evals": { "count": 500, "soft_ce": 0.7625932921761905, "kl": 0.6730676386853419, "brier": 0.18645192181998924, "argmax_agreement": 0.68, "hard_count": 417, "hard_ece": 0.052463098512104685, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.18618071314902357, "reference_agreement": 0.2 }, { "count": 10, "confidence": 0.23838633417547514, "reference_agreement": 0.2 }, { "count": 18, "confidence": 0.295781111577869, "reference_agreement": 0.2777777777777778 }, { "count": 26, "confidence": 0.37139215520169777, "reference_agreement": 0.4230769230769231 }, { "count": 22, "confidence": 0.43633042832674923, "reference_agreement": 0.45454545454545453 }, { "count": 29, "confidence": 0.5119118632329336, "reference_agreement": 0.4482758620689655 }, { "count": 51, "confidence": 0.5699148465657553, "reference_agreement": 0.47058823529411764 }, { "count": 38, "confidence": 0.6258474222785992, "reference_agreement": 0.5263157894736842 }, { "count": 42, "confidence": 0.692690594223072, "reference_agreement": 0.7380952380952381 }, { "count": 35, "confidence": 0.7681140161954323, "reference_agreement": 0.7714285714285715 }, { "count": 40, "confidence": 0.8344200795661016, "reference_agreement": 0.85 }, { "count": 46, "confidence": 0.9006389466100536, "reference_agreement": 0.9347826086956522 }, { "count": 55, "confidence": 0.9717353590779876, "reference_agreement": 0.8909090909090909 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.18618071314902357, "reference_agreement": 0.2 }, { "count": 10, "confidence": 0.23838633417547514, "reference_agreement": 0.2 }, { "count": 18, "confidence": 0.295781111577869, "reference_agreement": 0.2777777777777778 }, { "count": 29, "confidence": 0.3733951639465118, "reference_agreement": 0.41724137931034483 }, { "count": 30, "confidence": 0.4336998105448617, "reference_agreement": 0.44690416558973367 }, { "count": 39, "confidence": 0.5120708414698647, "reference_agreement": 0.4701608617898467 }, { "count": 58, "confidence": 0.5690122989604566, "reference_agreement": 0.4917532841954055 }, { "count": 46, "confidence": 0.6283615036372431, "reference_agreement": 0.5640713243854648 }, { "count": 54, "confidence": 0.6932351995199476, "reference_agreement": 0.7547641003856951 }, { "count": 45, "confidence": 0.7641095557632885, "reference_agreement": 0.7842272393489996 }, { "count": 51, "confidence": 0.8318454353186426, "reference_agreement": 0.8372494792826007 }, { "count": 55, "confidence": 0.9002777292404353, "reference_agreement": 0.9324725290016627 }, { "count": 60, "confidence": 0.9709295090707568, "reference_agreement": 0.8988023166666667 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.8456565717140646 }, "legal": { "count": 122, "soft_ce": 0.5436294554804777, "kl": 0.5436294554804777, "brier": 0.1304449623060641, "argmax_agreement": 0.819672131147541, "hard_count": 122, "hard_ece": 0.08307026110171992, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.2542299113522521, "reference_agreement": 1.0 }, { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.28724827093183936, "reference_agreement": 0.0 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.377085304774584, "reference_agreement": 0.5 }, { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.4441052741464433, "reference_agreement": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.5174342366971163, "reference_agreement": 0.0 }, { "count": 7, "confidence": 0.5644377124854338, "reference_agreement": 0.5714285714285714 }, { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.6251477859811808, "reference_agreement": 0.8 }, { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.7044969749942575, "reference_agreement": 0.25 }, { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.7587080210898536, "reference_agreement": 0.75 }, { "count": 6, "confidence": 0.8354103639312468, "reference_agreement": 1.0 }, { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.8963652039349991, "reference_agreement": 0.7692307692307693 }, { "count": 66, "confidence": 0.9815239804604637, "reference_agreement": 0.9848484848484849 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.2542299113522521, "reference_agreement": 1.0 }, { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.28724827093183936, "reference_agreement": 0.0 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.377085304774584, "reference_agreement": 0.5 }, { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.4441052741464433, "reference_agreement": 0.3333333333333333 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.5174342366971163, "reference_agreement": 0.0 }, { "count": 7, "confidence": 0.5644377124854338, "reference_agreement": 0.5714285714285714 }, { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.6251477859811808, "reference_agreement": 0.8 }, { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.7044969749942575, "reference_agreement": 0.25 }, { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.7587080210898536, "reference_agreement": 0.75 }, { "count": 6, "confidence": 0.8354103639312468, "reference_agreement": 1.0 }, { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.8963652039349991, "reference_agreement": 0.7692307692307693 }, { "count": 66, "confidence": 0.9815239804604637, "reference_agreement": 0.9848484848484849 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.05800823336689319 }, "sales_commerce": { "count": 71, "soft_ce": 0.43972836851867453, "kl": 0.43972836851867453, "brier": 0.13079004940228145, "argmax_agreement": 0.8169014084507042, "hard_count": 71, "hard_ece": 0.08143885493164209, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.4480862145923521, "reference_agreement": 1.0 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.5225530044071978, "reference_agreement": 0.5 }, { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.5799241321545268, "reference_agreement": 0.6666666666666666 }, { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.6273970582753347, "reference_agreement": 0.2 }, { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.6962808034900051, "reference_agreement": 0.75 }, { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.7775016660973879, "reference_agreement": 0.75 }, { "count": 10, "confidence": 0.8388575355152714, "reference_agreement": 0.7 }, { "count": 20, "confidence": 0.9005931196007729, "reference_agreement": 0.9 }, { "count": 21, "confidence": 0.9756813796187571, "reference_agreement": 1.0 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.4480862145923521, "reference_agreement": 1.0 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.5225530044071978, "reference_agreement": 0.5 }, { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.5799241321545268, "reference_agreement": 0.6666666666666666 }, { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.6273970582753347, "reference_agreement": 0.2 }, { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.6962808034900051, "reference_agreement": 0.75 }, { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.7775016660973879, "reference_agreement": 0.75 }, { "count": 10, "confidence": 0.8388575355152714, "reference_agreement": 0.7 }, { "count": 20, "confidence": 0.9005931196007729, "reference_agreement": 0.9 }, { "count": 21, "confidence": 0.9756813796187571, "reference_agreement": 1.0 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.3234410160549905 } } }, "permutation": { "count": 256, "completed": true, "mean_total_variation": 0.061152504018688186, "answer_flip_rate": 0.0625 } }, "typed_decisions": { "dataset": "LocalLLaMA/typed-decisions", "revision": "7189f46b02248bd2569df7325c9df8e3b24e90a7", "config": "all", "split": "test", "cases": 400, "decisions": 2000, "errors": 0, "raw": { "overall": { "count": 2000, "soft_ce": 0.8982348703026427, "kl": 0.13087631467831382, "brier": 0.03733508375955404, "argmax_agreement": 0.7055, "hard_count": 2, "hard_ece": 0.02813636220158644, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.9718636377984136, "reference_agreement": 1.0 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 24, "confidence": 0.31520772849577633, "reference_agreement": 0.3355554526389121 }, { "count": 171, "confidence": 0.3746159687360105, "reference_agreement": 0.38106237192013953 }, { "count": 368, "confidence": 0.43486926682677546, "reference_agreement": 0.41427729467341934 }, { "count": 330, "confidence": 0.5005758970577506, "reference_agreement": 0.4898888885960213 }, { "count": 259, "confidence": 0.5661637493278858, "reference_agreement": 0.5401029315058599 }, { "count": 208, "confidence": 0.6334207148716826, "reference_agreement": 0.5813301291346679 }, { "count": 176, "confidence": 0.6976026942523854, "reference_agreement": 0.6650378634451258 }, { "count": 117, "confidence": 0.765488790351476, "reference_agreement": 0.6715926028234322 }, { "count": 95, "confidence": 0.8268994900267613, "reference_agreement": 0.7595845223159148 }, { "count": 90, "confidence": 0.8962419341009388, "reference_agreement": 0.9119985310000607 }, { "count": 162, "confidence": 0.9675863551773324, "reference_agreement": 0.9661111104013173 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.2689357269785638, "gold_label_correct": 1409, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.7045, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.10329466050980009, "full_vector_brier": 0.07467016751910809 }, "type": { "choice": { "count": 600, "soft_ce": 1.0297958099292934, "kl": 0.1660012130824713, "brier": 0.041920794479682215, "argmax_agreement": 0.6883333333333334, "hard_count": 1, "hard_ece": 0.023186746014468573, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.9768132539855314, "reference_agreement": 1.0 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 14, "confidence": 0.3173165797051884, "reference_agreement": 0.39047612547625926 }, { "count": 114, "confidence": 0.3727881473417713, "reference_agreement": 0.3832163580409846 }, { "count": 160, "confidence": 0.4341875923805457, "reference_agreement": 0.4184011179583752 }, { "count": 92, "confidence": 0.4936694315907819, "reference_agreement": 0.511159424456586 }, { "count": 48, "confidence": 0.5673671375615373, "reference_agreement": 0.5801388408334563 }, { "count": 31, "confidence": 0.6339963551108706, "reference_agreement": 0.6433333275269537 }, { "count": 28, "confidence": 0.6907448914335091, "reference_agreement": 0.7217737262976213 }, { "count": 22, "confidence": 0.764159840829608, "reference_agreement": 0.6959089121213682 }, { "count": 32, "confidence": 0.8290876216067908, "reference_agreement": 0.7640788558334829 }, { "count": 33, "confidence": 0.8944038265429061, "reference_agreement": 0.9230363914142908 }, { "count": 26, "confidence": 0.9583538062949253, "reference_agreement": 0.955179537115826 } ], "gold_label_correct": 413, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.6883333333333334, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.1452815073319075, "full_vector_brier": 0.08384158895936443 }, "noul": { "count": 600, "soft_ce": 0.5376753319725679, "kl": 0.08395308862000342, "brier": 0.034802117110535095, "argmax_agreement": 0.7666666666666667, "hard_count": 1, "hard_ece": 0.033085978388704196, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.9669140216112958, "reference_agreement": 1.0 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 59, "confidence": 0.5179912574843223, "reference_agreement": 0.48372877966101696 }, { "count": 86, "confidence": 0.5678122996718532, "reference_agreement": 0.525968976744186 }, { "count": 85, "confidence": 0.6369483441744728, "reference_agreement": 0.5698431176470588 }, { "count": 85, "confidence": 0.6995096580475858, "reference_agreement": 0.6567059176470588 }, { "count": 63, "confidence": 0.7673512554565463, "reference_agreement": 0.6198413174603175 }, { "count": 47, "confidence": 0.8295192389350612, "reference_agreement": 0.740141914893617 }, { "count": 54, "confidence": 0.8971869226053684, "reference_agreement": 0.9035740740740741 }, { "count": 121, "confidence": 0.9707946773144384, "reference_agreement": 0.9677850826446281 } ], "gold_label_correct": 459, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.765, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.037528508953695645, "full_vector_brier": 0.06960423422107019 }, "score": { "count": 800, "soft_ce": 1.0699838193302107, "kl": 0.1397250604189285, "brier": 0.03579552570622214, "argmax_agreement": 0.6725, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 10, "confidence": 0.3122553368025993, "reference_agreement": 0.25866651066662605 }, { "count": 57, "confidence": 0.3782716115244891, "reference_agreement": 0.3767543996784493 }, { "count": 208, "confidence": 0.4353936317854138, "reference_agreement": 0.41110512291576096 }, { "count": 179, "confidence": 0.4983853303415126, "reference_agreement": 0.4809869731099504 }, { "count": 125, "confidence": 0.564567445609514, "reference_agreement": 0.5344533032000944 }, { "count": 92, "confidence": 0.6299675264135088, "reference_agreement": 0.5710507468116885 }, { "count": 63, "confidence": 0.6980777189561393, "reference_agreement": 0.6510634385715672 }, { "count": 32, "confidence": 0.7627357149721534, "reference_agreement": 0.7567604832397332 }, { "count": 16, "confidence": 0.8148277144485708, "reference_agreement": 0.8077085145837775 }, { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.8994513241595642, "reference_agreement": 0.9422222911112911 }, { "count": 15, "confidence": 0.9577089746675174, "reference_agreement": 0.9715557946667946 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.2689357269785638, "gold_label_correct": 537, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.67125, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.13471575955048368, "full_vector_brier": 0.07159105141244428 } }, "category": { "agent_trace_observability": { "count": 500, "soft_ce": 0.97776378147771, "kl": 0.09929350853248653, "brier": 0.029319985421551766, "argmax_agreement": 0.666, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.3271961322725437, "reference_agreement": 0.333333 }, { "count": 35, "confidence": 0.3798205422614706, "reference_agreement": 0.40077146666672475 }, { "count": 132, "confidence": 0.43641602107268646, "reference_agreement": 0.4047222168687381 }, { "count": 117, "confidence": 0.5006302500044424, "reference_agreement": 0.47911679880348107 }, { "count": 76, "confidence": 0.5690619634091041, "reference_agreement": 0.5512718920614565 }, { "count": 45, "confidence": 0.6338679776529896, "reference_agreement": 0.6111852223703935 }, { "count": 25, "confidence": 0.6938113959359317, "reference_agreement": 0.6235998789334686 }, { "count": 14, "confidence": 0.7711383973508009, "reference_agreement": 0.6864285047620653 }, { "count": 32, "confidence": 0.823789261655095, "reference_agreement": 0.7322917248959386 }, { "count": 23, "confidence": 0.8940903067075735, "reference_agreement": 0.8727536086956522 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.20094214035170185, "gold_label_correct": 335, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.67, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.11802699803796707, "full_vector_brier": 0.05863997084310353 }, "customer_service": { "count": 500, "soft_ce": 0.9356140291801783, "kl": 0.19845939117069544, "brier": 0.054488558914342955, "argmax_agreement": 0.694, "hard_count": 1, "hard_ece": 0.023186746014468573, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.9768132539855314, "reference_agreement": 1.0 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 10, "confidence": 0.31477128374516633, "reference_agreement": 0.4056665940000813 }, { "count": 39, "confidence": 0.3723859508926986, "reference_agreement": 0.45632472794882123 }, { "count": 73, "confidence": 0.4380748853548461, "reference_agreement": 0.3939339658448251 }, { "count": 81, "confidence": 0.5011240542197034, "reference_agreement": 0.5185185261729083 }, { "count": 80, "confidence": 0.5649588987676203, "reference_agreement": 0.5116249845417362 }, { "count": 69, "confidence": 0.6279948891492104, "reference_agreement": 0.5734783022222739 }, { "count": 46, "confidence": 0.6947774859534929, "reference_agreement": 0.7216593691232294 }, { "count": 33, "confidence": 0.7624282639003352, "reference_agreement": 0.6597979875758164 }, { "count": 22, "confidence": 0.8310417874707298, "reference_agreement": 0.8232055630304752 }, { "count": 21, "confidence": 0.8956622165551549, "reference_agreement": 0.913333472222457 }, { "count": 26, "confidence": 0.9583538062949253, "reference_agreement": 0.955179537115826 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.3528748230925414, "gold_label_correct": 347, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.694, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.09884340864299247, "full_vector_brier": 0.10897711782868591 }, "invoice_processing": { "count": 500, "soft_ce": 0.6654727615892404, "kl": 0.09052528592434582, "brier": 0.02417431701033401, "argmax_agreement": 0.84, "hard_count": 1, "hard_ece": 0.033085978388704196, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.9669140216112958, "reference_agreement": 1.0 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.3278949544267834, "reference_agreement": 0.5716665 }, { "count": 37, "confidence": 0.36518717835723197, "reference_agreement": 0.3640449954955256 }, { "count": 44, "confidence": 0.43272176571282106, "reference_agreement": 0.4239439440863979 }, { "count": 47, "confidence": 0.4990750370635605, "reference_agreement": 0.4812765950355347 }, { "count": 40, "confidence": 0.5636676327793726, "reference_agreement": 0.5589167148334007 }, { "count": 44, "confidence": 0.6359292707198466, "reference_agreement": 0.618181796969778 }, { "count": 53, "confidence": 0.6993117889365471, "reference_agreement": 0.6881194986793073 }, { "count": 34, "confidence": 0.7613192737634586, "reference_agreement": 0.7343039374609032 }, { "count": 21, "confidence": 0.8299096395763272, "reference_agreement": 0.8130160017462573 }, { "count": 43, "confidence": 0.8979274834748605, "reference_agreement": 0.9520123691472993 }, { "count": 135, "confidence": 0.9695963375504574, "reference_agreement": 0.9691999920000142 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.21560838991268416, "gold_label_correct": 417, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.834, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.11985107384860202, "full_vector_brier": 0.04834863402066802 }, "security_incidents": { "count": 500, "soft_ce": 1.0140889089634417, "kl": 0.13522707308572743, "brier": 0.041357473691987466, "argmax_agreement": 0.622, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 11, "confidence": 0.31220787321098703, "reference_agreement": 0.2290908112120979 }, { "count": 60, "confidence": 0.37884389984455846, "reference_agreement": 0.33113891736116685 }, { "count": 119, "confidence": 0.4319811015831166, "reference_agreement": 0.43378150224093404 }, { "count": 85, "confidence": 0.5008086075853485, "reference_agreement": 0.48219608458828284 }, { "count": 63, "confidence": 0.5657822959404127, "reference_agreement": 0.550846477883684 }, { "count": 50, "confidence": 0.6382982887191337, "reference_agreement": 0.5328665986667214 }, { "count": 52, "confidence": 0.7001826946639205, "reference_agreement": 0.6113462035256458 }, { "count": 36, "confidence": 0.7700350803206342, "reference_agreement": 0.6174074444444444 }, { "count": 20, "confidence": 0.8241586712060176, "reference_agreement": 0.6771668 }, { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.8926362259110124, "reference_agreement": 0.63 }, { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.9362850057480346, "reference_agreement": 0.833333 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.3063175545573279, "gold_label_correct": 310, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.62, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.11599525503936776, "full_vector_brier": 0.08271494738397493 } }, "question": { "agent_trace_observability/action": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 1.1235396454195041, "kl": 0.08949577063715862, "brier": 0.023420285987952504, "argmax_agreement": 0.66, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.3271961322725437, "reference_agreement": 0.333333 }, { "count": 28, "confidence": 0.37758519376271876, "reference_agreement": 0.4010834071429083 }, { "count": 34, "confidence": 0.42300368726206095, "reference_agreement": 0.40872541411767294 }, { "count": 14, "confidence": 0.508725847017595, "reference_agreement": 0.6019047511905369 }, { "count": 23, "confidence": 0.5700440548082534, "reference_agreement": 0.6007246056522724 } ], "gold_label_correct": 66, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.66, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.21139510221170185, "full_vector_brier": 0.04684057197590501 }, "agent_trace_observability/needs_review": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 0.5772198756410069, "kl": 0.06175400802011981, "brier": 0.026948573243994925, "argmax_agreement": 0.78, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 17, "confidence": 0.522037312516128, "reference_agreement": 0.48039217647058824 }, { "count": 27, "confidence": 0.5740099433811946, "reference_agreement": 0.5532098148148148 }, { "count": 19, "confidence": 0.6307027904464286, "reference_agreement": 0.6412281052631579 }, { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.679178699175393, "reference_agreement": 0.766667 }, { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.831497587641693, "reference_agreement": 0.8541025384615385 }, { "count": 23, "confidence": 0.8940903067075735, "reference_agreement": 0.8727536086956522 } ], "gold_label_correct": 78, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.78, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.09591019804659835, "full_vector_brier": 0.05389714648798985 }, "agent_trace_observability/outcome": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 1.0935064791897204, "kl": 0.16872011458553096, "brier": 0.04551726407182359, "argmax_agreement": 0.62, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.39948630465030277, "reference_agreement": 0.233333 }, { "count": 36, "confidence": 0.44371195558609283, "reference_agreement": 0.36223152500002964 }, { "count": 29, "confidence": 0.4869204497761252, "reference_agreement": 0.42333332505753857 }, { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.5457545962932366, "reference_agreement": 0.75 }, { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.6334661880424128, "reference_agreement": 0.8091667499999999 }, { "count": 6, "confidence": 0.68759444755407, "reference_agreement": 0.6505555205556461 }, { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.7680981282943802, "reference_agreement": 0.6516665095834904 }, { "count": 15, "confidence": 0.820754732086627, "reference_agreement": 0.6195556666667333 } ], "gold_label_correct": 60, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.6, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.08832517707815522, "full_vector_brier": 0.09103452814364718 }, "agent_trace_observability/risk": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 0.9829069466566531, "kl": 0.09053683824790124, "brier": 0.027227209135250532, "argmax_agreement": 0.67, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 6, "confidence": 0.3869745415241738, "reference_agreement": 0.4272221555556555 }, { "count": 15, "confidence": 0.4430243807991401, "reference_agreement": 0.4377777200001155 }, { "count": 20, "confidence": 0.5064388102385512, "reference_agreement": 0.552666578333445 }, { "count": 22, "confidence": 0.5633028160410002, "reference_agreement": 0.5042424242424954 }, { "count": 15, "confidence": 0.6350598264314197, "reference_agreement": 0.5333333022222356 }, { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.6937211677482574, "reference_agreement": 0.5712818941026444 }, { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.780801733899054, "reference_agreement": 0.7526666713334713 }, { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.810116688080407, "reference_agreement": 0.7591667991672592 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.1887612567569762, "gold_label_correct": 69, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.69, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.14607924787983295, "full_vector_brier": 0.054454418270501063 }, "agent_trace_observability/urgency": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 1.111645960481666, "kl": 0.08596081117172201, "brier": 0.023486594668737287, "argmax_agreement": 0.6, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 47, "confidence": 0.43842113407655536, "reference_agreement": 0.42382272014190947 }, { "count": 37, "confidence": 0.49533713057352974, "reference_agreement": 0.4360360527027635 }, { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.5670036460048613, "reference_agreement": 0.43333317777784447 }, { "count": 7, "confidence": 0.6401348324659201, "reference_agreement": 0.5833334961905962 }, { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.7044328666342266, "reference_agreement": 0.6986664453336919 }, { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.7471438670609017, "reference_agreement": 0.6333336333336334 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.21312302394642757, "gold_label_correct": 62, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.62, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.12615469901673237, "full_vector_brier": 0.046973189337474575 }, "customer_service/action": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 1.241760340801668, "kl": 0.275902444840478, "brier": 0.06755224071529659, "argmax_agreement": 0.6, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 9, "confidence": 0.31273256683149947, "reference_agreement": 0.3525925488889793 }, { "count": 34, "confidence": 0.37221056069924124, "reference_agreement": 0.4573528766667779 }, { "count": 25, "confidence": 0.4324976531209652, "reference_agreement": 0.4009538457334028 }, { "count": 20, "confidence": 0.49707265548386304, "reference_agreement": 0.5388333921667305 }, { "count": 9, "confidence": 0.5563524243492388, "reference_agreement": 0.6407407485186634 }, { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.6089655400408842, "reference_agreement": 0.35 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.705852717684706, "reference_agreement": 0.7800003916668916 } ], "gold_label_correct": 61, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.61, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.18966441682569232, "full_vector_brier": 0.13510448143059317 }, "customer_service/category": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 0.5646570684297757, "kl": 0.15423518549593282, "brier": 0.03216723408432829, "argmax_agreement": 0.93, "hard_count": 1, "hard_ece": 0.023186746014468573, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.9768132539855314, "reference_agreement": 1.0 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.4430349798534358, "reference_agreement": 0.6166666055560389 }, { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.5046243895746633, "reference_agreement": 0.635333516000116 }, { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.5798365858143383, "reference_agreement": 0.5683333691670058 }, { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.6384560218456447, "reference_agreement": 0.6099999795834395 }, { "count": 9, "confidence": 0.6915068535481631, "reference_agreement": 0.8281108069998411 }, { "count": 9, "confidence": 0.7596657412667888, "reference_agreement": 0.6937035451853623 }, { "count": 15, "confidence": 0.8332816589849125, "reference_agreement": 0.8847014257780302 }, { "count": 21, "confidence": 0.8956622165551549, "reference_agreement": 0.913333472222457 }, { "count": 26, "confidence": 0.9583538062949253, "reference_agreement": 0.955179537115826 } ], "gold_label_correct": 94, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.94, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.1407358753162401, "full_vector_brier": 0.06433446816865658 }, "customer_service/churn_risk": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 1.0723716037197997, "kl": 0.18195307128399665, "brier": 0.05156803196362559, "argmax_agreement": 0.71, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.3331197359681683, "reference_agreement": 0.883333 }, { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.3735786042082082, "reference_agreement": 0.4493333166667167 }, { "count": 31, "confidence": 0.4406830914886085, "reference_agreement": 0.388172083225866 }, { "count": 26, "confidence": 0.5011742997082412, "reference_agreement": 0.578589826794943 }, { "count": 18, "confidence": 0.5633032673902467, "reference_agreement": 0.5179629694445509 }, { "count": 17, "confidence": 0.6284474784336418, "reference_agreement": 0.6143137843137941 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.6870135499018379, "reference_agreement": 0.6716668416668417 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.3151828379933619, "gold_label_correct": 71, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.71, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.19910186568229626, "full_vector_brier": 0.10313606392725118 }, "customer_service/needs_human": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 0.6761560528212277, "kl": 0.12704364399222592, "brier": 0.05613679930099221, "argmax_agreement": 0.66, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.517557176152255, "reference_agreement": 0.482499875 }, { "count": 22, "confidence": 0.5656107740630231, "reference_agreement": 0.5101515 }, { "count": 20, "confidence": 0.6310079557436046, "reference_agreement": 0.5293334 }, { "count": 20, "confidence": 0.7003291402466889, "reference_agreement": 0.7098333 }, { "count": 23, "confidence": 0.7643885662708242, "reference_agreement": 0.6455073043478261 }, { "count": 7, "confidence": 0.8262420627974808, "reference_agreement": 0.6914287142857143 } ], "gold_label_correct": 65, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.65, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.08754395103445267, "full_vector_brier": 0.11227359860198442 }, "customer_service/urgency": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 1.1231250801284207, "kl": 0.25316261024084386, "brier": 0.06501848850747206, "argmax_agreement": 0.57, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 14, "confidence": 0.4411960376551762, "reference_agreement": 0.34642849761908573 }, { "count": 22, "confidence": 0.4979765514824134, "reference_agreement": 0.41560594090917574 }, { "count": 27, "confidence": 0.5661962183925248, "reference_agreement": 0.45716044814818446 }, { "count": 23, "confidence": 0.6222290168802378, "reference_agreement": 0.5786956818841255 }, { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.6879913332169492, "reference_agreement": 0.664871788461732 }, { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.7422040130810093, "reference_agreement": 0.6833336833336833 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.39056680819172096, "gold_label_correct": 56, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.56, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.12422167823236911, "full_vector_brier": 0.13003697701494413 }, "invoice_processing/discrepancy_severity": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 0.7813166885573835, "kl": 0.13707332422163884, "brier": 0.03045788400272809, "argmax_agreement": 0.83, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 10, "confidence": 0.36318909440456576, "reference_agreement": 0.452666601666755 }, { "count": 15, "confidence": 0.41585765000740066, "reference_agreement": 0.4002355722088945 }, { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.5029107001361107, "reference_agreement": 0.46666675555575554 }, { "count": 7, "confidence": 0.554937459938247, "reference_agreement": 0.5833334000001142 }, { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.6405068280987012, "reference_agreement": 0.7933334066669266 }, { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.7045803972407967, "reference_agreement": 0.7338461728206614 }, { "count": 18, "confidence": 0.7675469747476337, "reference_agreement": 0.7801667003890337 }, { "count": 11, "confidence": 0.8164401230878163, "reference_agreement": 0.8336366139397898 }, { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.8994513241595642, "reference_agreement": 0.9422222911112911 }, { "count": 15, "confidence": 0.9577089746675174, "reference_agreement": 0.9715557946667946 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.27761394944700535, "gold_label_correct": 83, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.83, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.1551419518932857, "full_vector_brier": 0.06091576800545618 }, "invoice_processing/disposition": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 0.9672103205660691, "kl": 0.14375101661084821, "brier": 0.03838214719887722, "argmax_agreement": 0.74, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.3278949544267834, "reference_agreement": 0.5716665 }, { "count": 24, "confidence": 0.3638647878856312, "reference_agreement": 0.3302638513888964 }, { "count": 16, "confidence": 0.4371119558468517, "reference_agreement": 0.42291669833338374 }, { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.48657462908745097, "reference_agreement": 0.5753333066666932 }, { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.5743529947838498, "reference_agreement": 0.39799984333333 }, { "count": 18, "confidence": 0.6335226967478499, "reference_agreement": 0.637592573148225 }, { "count": 11, "confidence": 0.6890930143191779, "reference_agreement": 0.6630302878788333 }, { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.7659479600990471, "reference_agreement": 0.7706664166667834 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.8601290126721075, "reference_agreement": 0.9433335 }, { "count": 12, "confidence": 0.8922016440214707, "reference_agreement": 0.9400165 } ], "gold_label_correct": 74, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.74, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.20816706463754298, "full_vector_brier": 0.07676429439775444 }, "invoice_processing/duplicate": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 0.2334091092156495, "kl": 0.02585605705240466, "brier": 0.007688562652478144, "argmax_agreement": 0.94, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 9, "confidence": 0.5190740869546441, "reference_agreement": 0.5159257777777778 }, { "count": 6, "confidence": 0.5672429607854125, "reference_agreement": 0.5161113333333334 }, { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.6224593312018546, "reference_agreement": 0.046667 }, { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.679178699175393, "reference_agreement": 0.75 }, { "count": 7, "confidence": 0.9192141605617763, "reference_agreement": 0.9795238571428572 }, { "count": 76, "confidence": 0.973002201351445, "reference_agreement": 0.9698990789473684 } ], "gold_label_correct": 94, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.94, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.05485489658079937, "full_vector_brier": 0.015377125304956288 }, "invoice_processing/matches_order": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 0.3306428558838697, "kl": 0.07295218240515576, "brier": 0.025035670669917, "argmax_agreement": 0.91, "hard_count": 1, "hard_ece": 0.033085978388704196, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.9669140216112958, "reference_agreement": 1.0 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.5, "reference_agreement": 0.25 }, { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.5467381519846138, "reference_agreement": 0.05 }, { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.6494972618666175, "reference_agreement": 0.742916625 }, { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.6945122010594892, "reference_agreement": 0.7448718461538462 }, { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.7602322944976581, "reference_agreement": 0.49416675 }, { "count": 7, "confidence": 0.8444382467004503, "reference_agreement": 0.7571428571428571 }, { "count": 21, "confidence": 0.8938861411785824, "reference_agreement": 0.951095238095238 }, { "count": 44, "confidence": 0.9677659919679358, "reference_agreement": 0.9671893636363635 } ], "gold_label_correct": 91, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.91, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.10098650283026388, "full_vector_brier": 0.050071341339834 }, "invoice_processing/urgency": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 1.0147848337232301, "kl": 0.07299384933168163, "brier": 0.01930732052766958, "argmax_agreement": 0.78, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.38242658197225876, "reference_agreement": 0.33888879444446113 }, { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.44677704982334543, "reference_agreement": 0.4525640602564577 }, { "count": 28, "confidence": 0.49440195405535564, "reference_agreement": 0.47142861309533574 }, { "count": 21, "confidence": 0.5638182000471827, "reference_agreement": 0.6255555988889798 }, { "count": 12, "confidence": 0.629708983631971, "reference_agreement": 0.4805554763889625 }, { "count": 15, "confidence": 0.7077412786031287, "reference_agreement": 0.6135777344445011 }, { "count": 7, "confidence": 0.7426201120020457, "reference_agreement": 0.7276191690477404 }, { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.8159353248895248, "reference_agreement": 0.7166662833337166 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.15360283037836298, "gold_label_correct": 75, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.75, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.1846883809213806, "full_vector_brier": 0.03861464105533916 }, "security_incidents/credential_compromise": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 0.7435202424681325, "kl": 0.13032283941349765, "brier": 0.056534706032330906, "argmax_agreement": 0.56, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.5180136079658565, "reference_agreement": 0.5041024615384615 }, { "count": 16, "confidence": 0.5611483436625656, "reference_agreement": 0.5185416875 }, { "count": 18, "confidence": 0.6424031158653717, "reference_agreement": 0.4575924444444444 }, { "count": 24, "confidence": 0.7033728698546223, "reference_agreement": 0.54125 }, { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.7727795187245017, "reference_agreement": 0.5805127692307692 }, { "count": 12, "confidence": 0.8229402454540159, "reference_agreement": 0.61611125 }, { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.8926362259110124, "reference_agreement": 0.63 }, { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.9362850057480346, "reference_agreement": 0.833333 } ], "gold_label_correct": 56, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.56, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.12394694920782158, "full_vector_brier": 0.11306941206466181 }, "security_incidents/disposition": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 1.1881010051690235, "kl": 0.1639027463248791, "brier": 0.04448559481981512, "argmax_agreement": 0.58, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.32242648663151624, "reference_agreement": 0.4083334083334083 }, { "count": 27, "confidence": 0.3754838182935608, "reference_agreement": 0.32395059913580926 }, { "count": 46, "confidence": 0.43432437938573537, "reference_agreement": 0.46449275565219045 }, { "count": 19, "confidence": 0.4882781369268498, "reference_agreement": 0.49964906052637453 }, { "count": 6, "confidence": 0.5630952682918294, "reference_agreement": 0.5416665000001667 } ], "gold_label_correct": 58, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.58, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.2085843245755816, "full_vector_brier": 0.08897118963963024 }, "security_incidents/severity": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 1.315743899027136, "kl": 0.16019039234495527, "brier": 0.03374204583723859, "argmax_agreement": 0.62, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 9, "confidence": 0.30993707022864725, "reference_agreement": 0.1892591229629178 }, { "count": 11, "confidence": 0.37361903832007515, "reference_agreement": 0.35666686181831636 }, { "count": 29, "confidence": 0.4358135451699136, "reference_agreement": 0.367356292413834 }, { "count": 26, "confidence": 0.4949142252274759, "reference_agreement": 0.4523077201282927 }, { "count": 16, "confidence": 0.5669241476967354, "reference_agreement": 0.5614581968751906 }, { "count": 9, "confidence": 0.629883142448191, "reference_agreement": 0.5296296370372297 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.3280770725235342, "gold_label_correct": 61, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.61, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.17433526899513643, "full_vector_brier": 0.06748409167447718 }, "security_incidents/true_positive": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 0.6651038558055207, "kl": 0.08578980083661669, "brier": 0.03646839076349738, "argmax_agreement": 0.75, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 10, "confidence": 0.5140548783434865, "reference_agreement": 0.4816668 }, { "count": 14, "confidence": 0.5686844897001768, "reference_agreement": 0.5449999285714285 }, { "count": 19, "confidence": 0.6397580847244457, "reference_agreement": 0.6021052105263158 }, { "count": 26, "confidence": 0.699375893864459, "reference_agreement": 0.6705129230769231 }, { "count": 23, "confidence": 0.7684838760054046, "reference_agreement": 0.6382609565217391 }, { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.8259863098340201, "reference_agreement": 0.768750125 } ], "gold_label_correct": 75, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.75, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.0755676945059552, "full_vector_brier": 0.07293678152699476 }, "security_incidents/urgency": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 1.1579755423473963, "kl": 0.13592958650868842, "brier": 0.035556631007055334, "argmax_agreement": 0.6, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 22, "confidence": 0.3855800670557517, "reference_agreement": 0.327196972045531 }, { "count": 44, "confidence": 0.42700538242544434, "reference_agreement": 0.44545453469702745 }, { "count": 17, "confidence": 0.5028795000140648, "reference_agreement": 0.49196084215690095 }, { "count": 11, "confidence": 0.5686336651767027, "reference_agreement": 0.5948483596970949 }, { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.6318266146454532, "reference_agreement": 0.55000005000025 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.6723890027684984, "reference_agreement": 0.6833332916667916 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.2845580365911216, "gold_label_correct": 60, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.6, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.19018518367205345, "full_vector_brier": 0.07111326201411067 } } }, "calibrated": { "overall": { "count": 2000, "soft_ce": 0.8996057207086053, "kl": 0.13224716508427645, "brier": 0.0371886634007063, "argmax_agreement": 0.7055, "hard_count": 2, "hard_ece": 0.04532655734322799, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.954673442656772, "reference_agreement": 1.0 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.26431766017833624, "reference_agreement": 0.6433336433336433 }, { "count": 40, "confidence": 0.3177876741133899, "reference_agreement": 0.3488332323333685 }, { "count": 214, "confidence": 0.3738574970766125, "reference_agreement": 0.39616281869943265 }, { "count": 379, "confidence": 0.4335478747419467, "reference_agreement": 0.421979419893986 }, { "count": 296, "confidence": 0.5011488512826869, "reference_agreement": 0.5069932456870009 }, { "count": 266, "confidence": 0.5645507022164814, "reference_agreement": 0.5461152577318915 }, { "count": 223, "confidence": 0.633536195077047, "reference_agreement": 0.5981748920314267 }, { "count": 156, "confidence": 0.6977244202652548, "reference_agreement": 0.6617542448932456 }, { "count": 130, "confidence": 0.7643242189776432, "reference_agreement": 0.6995359706949515 }, { "count": 92, "confidence": 0.8331337292292074, "reference_agreement": 0.8546781770653425 }, { "count": 68, "confidence": 0.9005759800850643, "reference_agreement": 0.9235195591667292 }, { "count": 135, "confidence": 0.9612556801725451, "reference_agreement": 0.9694123619383392 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.26946470447726134, "gold_label_correct": 1409, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.7045, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.11873688877234255, "full_vector_brier": 0.0743773268014126 }, "type": { "choice": { "count": 600, "soft_ce": 1.0381506231326942, "kl": 0.17435602628587193, "brier": 0.042938132074843774, "argmax_agreement": 0.6883333333333334, "hard_count": 1, "hard_ece": 0.04531176280353044, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.9546882371964696, "reference_agreement": 1.0 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.26431766017833624, "reference_agreement": 0.6433336433336433 }, { "count": 28, "confidence": 0.3194104476415337, "reference_agreement": 0.3671427644048106 }, { "count": 151, "confidence": 0.37119215731679844, "reference_agreement": 0.40550005966892083 }, { "count": 171, "confidence": 0.43196031154385833, "reference_agreement": 0.43263354161798406 }, { "count": 56, "confidence": 0.4968234850515549, "reference_agreement": 0.5974404757738895 }, { "count": 41, "confidence": 0.5598861924502044, "reference_agreement": 0.5814633723578526 }, { "count": 38, "confidence": 0.6300906961195497, "reference_agreement": 0.7054297802543781 }, { "count": 20, "confidence": 0.7021830670140048, "reference_agreement": 0.6884998090001994 }, { "count": 30, "confidence": 0.7641036360974187, "reference_agreement": 0.7616667017779263 }, { "count": 32, "confidence": 0.8347770460980283, "reference_agreement": 0.9085641953126645 }, { "count": 21, "confidence": 0.90318181459874, "reference_agreement": 0.9307778106351233 }, { "count": 11, "confidence": 0.949274918346995, "reference_agreement": 0.972878994697626 } ], "gold_label_correct": 413, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.6883333333333334, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.1767793119406733, "full_vector_brier": 0.08587626414968755 }, "noul": { "count": 600, "soft_ce": 0.5343593764491412, "kl": 0.08063713309657684, "brier": 0.03351564472605923, "argmax_agreement": 0.7666666666666667, "hard_count": 1, "hard_ece": 0.04534135188292543, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.9546586481170746, "reference_agreement": 1.0 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 59, "confidence": 0.5162463602685387, "reference_agreement": 0.48372877966101696 }, { "count": 102, "confidence": 0.566982612511053, "reference_agreement": 0.5379411666666667 }, { "count": 92, "confidence": 0.638635665544844, "reference_agreement": 0.5872825978260869 }, { "count": 76, "confidence": 0.6952965001408001, "reference_agreement": 0.6477193421052632 }, { "count": 69, "confidence": 0.7631561753342164, "reference_agreement": 0.6479227681159421 }, { "count": 48, "confidence": 0.8360191336961122, "reference_agreement": 0.8227708958333334 }, { "count": 44, "confidence": 0.8983448122025038, "reference_agreement": 0.91658325 }, { "count": 110, "confidence": 0.9631203976587833, "reference_agreement": 0.9687787545454546 } ], "gold_label_correct": 459, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.765, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.03628697257339877, "full_vector_brier": 0.06703128945211846 }, "score": { "count": 800, "soft_ce": 1.0696318020851365, "kl": 0.13937304317385457, "brier": 0.03563132590108849, "argmax_agreement": 0.6725, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 12, "confidence": 0.31400120254772085, "reference_agreement": 0.306110990833337 }, { "count": 63, "confidence": 0.38024585110410336, "reference_agreement": 0.3737830824074847 }, { "count": 208, "confidence": 0.43485303487114435, "reference_agreement": 0.41322050251512227 }, { "count": 181, "confidence": 0.49756579867925116, "reference_agreement": 0.48659301701665447 }, { "count": 123, "confidence": 0.5640888327073031, "reference_agreement": 0.5411110673984649 }, { "count": 93, "confidence": 0.6298993959087413, "reference_agreement": 0.5651254868101266 }, { "count": 60, "confidence": 0.6993135701733142, "reference_agreement": 0.670616600389039 }, { "count": 31, "confidence": 0.7671375253583909, "reference_agreement": 0.7542904560324492 }, { "count": 12, "confidence": 0.8172099330447323, "reference_agreement": 0.8386112533338538 }, { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.9150589341002214, "reference_agreement": 0.9744443333333334 }, { "count": 14, "confidence": 0.9560177842150351, "reference_agreement": 0.9716669228572801 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.26946470447726134, "gold_label_correct": 537, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.67125, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.1383301153500044, "full_vector_brier": 0.07126265180217697 } }, "category": { "agent_trace_observability": { "count": 500, "soft_ce": 0.9784239666090253, "kl": 0.09995369366380179, "brier": 0.02902756320294822, "argmax_agreement": 0.666, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.320696328577158, "reference_agreement": 0.333333 }, { "count": 56, "confidence": 0.3777104214271337, "reference_agreement": 0.4022678604167104 }, { "count": 142, "confidence": 0.4351345221705775, "reference_agreement": 0.4108685441315153 }, { "count": 101, "confidence": 0.5017886292643352, "reference_agreement": 0.5098679828713507 }, { "count": 69, "confidence": 0.5647063184371532, "reference_agreement": 0.5609178477778174 }, { "count": 46, "confidence": 0.6323688610153608, "reference_agreement": 0.6025362419565561 }, { "count": 25, "confidence": 0.7011952059687334, "reference_agreement": 0.6249331570668304 }, { "count": 25, "confidence": 0.7712895410262108, "reference_agreement": 0.684133418933419 }, { "count": 21, "confidence": 0.8322538044396943, "reference_agreement": 0.8557143673016929 }, { "count": 14, "confidence": 0.8840899517188067, "reference_agreement": 0.8664284285714287 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.20048818990062078, "gold_label_correct": 335, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.67, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.13395749510739433, "full_vector_brier": 0.05805512640589644 }, "customer_service": { "count": 500, "soft_ce": 0.9395046654141255, "kl": 0.20235002740464264, "brier": 0.054900227765937, "argmax_agreement": 0.694, "hard_count": 1, "hard_ece": 0.04531176280353044, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.9546882371964696, "reference_agreement": 1.0 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.26431766017833624, "reference_agreement": 0.6433336433336433 }, { "count": 16, "confidence": 0.3153945397919026, "reference_agreement": 0.4254165366667425 }, { "count": 43, "confidence": 0.3676812200975334, "reference_agreement": 0.4629575986047603 }, { "count": 81, "confidence": 0.43653206317486204, "reference_agreement": 0.40526751485604134 }, { "count": 73, "confidence": 0.5004255499809467, "reference_agreement": 0.5462557171690167 }, { "count": 85, "confidence": 0.5652857404557898, "reference_agreement": 0.5123529096471258 }, { "count": 71, "confidence": 0.6289827242548214, "reference_agreement": 0.5991033191502455 }, { "count": 40, "confidence": 0.6933075112774083, "reference_agreement": 0.6937499738334586 }, { "count": 35, "confidence": 0.757544894325504, "reference_agreement": 0.7550476496191563 }, { "count": 24, "confidence": 0.8298230320463706, "reference_agreement": 0.858494010416886 }, { "count": 20, "confidence": 0.9042490371859675, "reference_agreement": 0.9288167011668795 }, { "count": 11, "confidence": 0.949274918346995, "reference_agreement": 0.972878994697626 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.3540890427112495, "gold_label_correct": 347, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.694, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.11718544849042345, "full_vector_brier": 0.109800455531874 }, "invoice_processing": { "count": 500, "soft_ce": 0.6684132719468862, "kl": 0.09346579628199163, "brier": 0.024514530073744333, "argmax_agreement": 0.84, "hard_count": 1, "hard_ece": 0.04534135188292543, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.9546586481170746, "reference_agreement": 1.0 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 10, "confidence": 0.3284781191962668, "reference_agreement": 0.39399997833337835 }, { "count": 38, "confidence": 0.3695643829541523, "reference_agreement": 0.35955257149123854 }, { "count": 38, "confidence": 0.43180381052982364, "reference_agreement": 0.45737369490706775 }, { "count": 49, "confidence": 0.4995394302233789, "reference_agreement": 0.4748979573470118 }, { "count": 48, "confidence": 0.5630772128542549, "reference_agreement": 0.5724305864584053 }, { "count": 48, "confidence": 0.633751143134781, "reference_agreement": 0.6486805458333972 }, { "count": 46, "confidence": 0.7006481123389033, "reference_agreement": 0.71297823347834 }, { "count": 30, "confidence": 0.7644638654220844, "reference_agreement": 0.7463223660112589 }, { "count": 37, "confidence": 0.8368844632918799, "reference_agreement": 0.8846810628829918 }, { "count": 32, "confidence": 0.905262180250512, "reference_agreement": 0.961760375 }, { "count": 124, "confidence": 0.9623184896893279, "reference_agreement": 0.9691048380645316 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.2172820819264362, "gold_label_correct": 417, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.834, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.1349665198192152, "full_vector_brier": 0.049029060147488666 }, "security_incidents": { "count": 500, "soft_ce": 1.012080978864384, "kl": 0.13321914298666976, "brier": 0.04031233256019564, "argmax_agreement": 0.622, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.31228590825579433, "reference_agreement": 0.2210255325640828 }, { "count": 77, "confidence": 0.3766231397145957, "reference_agreement": 0.372489202099624 }, { "count": 118, "confidence": 0.4301516988277852, "reference_agreement": 0.43542370985879325 }, { "count": 73, "confidence": 0.5020672766359284, "reference_agreement": 0.48529681082197323 }, { "count": 64, "confidence": 0.5645118228386581, "reference_agreement": 0.5552603373438221 }, { "count": 58, "confidence": 0.6398582000502253, "reference_agreement": 0.5517815850575183 }, { "count": 45, "confidence": 0.6967336842994563, "reference_agreement": 0.601407457407413 }, { "count": 40, "confidence": 0.7657980669345792, "reference_agreement": 0.6255000500000001 }, { "count": 10, "confidence": 0.8290495284941051, "reference_agreement": 0.7323335 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.9042684049926732, "reference_agreement": 0.6583330000000001 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.30599950337073883, "gold_label_correct": 310, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.62, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.10104896950536107, "full_vector_brier": 0.08062466512039128 } }, "question": { "agent_trace_observability/action": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 1.1300319363326001, "kl": 0.09598806155025466, "brier": 0.02483876810455199, "argmax_agreement": 0.66, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.320696328577158, "reference_agreement": 0.333333 }, { "count": 45, "confidence": 0.37494667517257485, "reference_agreement": 0.4043777937037419 }, { "count": 20, "confidence": 0.42036053533497303, "reference_agreement": 0.4256666106667256 }, { "count": 22, "confidence": 0.5017129711343226, "reference_agreement": 0.6168181568182417 }, { "count": 12, "confidence": 0.5458754881908042, "reference_agreement": 0.5908332955556567 } ], "gold_label_correct": 66, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.66, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.23452694015867082, "full_vector_brier": 0.04967753620910398 }, "agent_trace_observability/needs_review": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 0.5772502686786852, "kl": 0.061784401057798144, "brier": 0.027046496253035113, "argmax_agreement": 0.78, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 17, "confidence": 0.5199000755681038, "reference_agreement": 0.48039217647058824 }, { "count": 32, "confidence": 0.5717013250980697, "reference_agreement": 0.57124996875 }, { "count": 15, "confidence": 0.6285397565767751, "reference_agreement": 0.6404444666666667 }, { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.7878123338263531, "reference_agreement": 0.9075 }, { "count": 18, "confidence": 0.8368480740637315, "reference_agreement": 0.8564815555555555 }, { "count": 14, "confidence": 0.8840899517188067, "reference_agreement": 0.8664284285714287 } ], "gold_label_correct": 78, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.78, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.10847385971036504, "full_vector_brier": 0.05409299250607023 }, "agent_trace_observability/outcome": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 1.0909319011321876, "kl": 0.1661455365279982, "brier": 0.04300572982539011, "argmax_agreement": 0.62, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.3938691946389984, "reference_agreement": 0.3533333066666934 }, { "count": 58, "confidence": 0.4374378411470648, "reference_agreement": 0.38236207597705485 }, { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.4803700853513563, "reference_agreement": 0.58916684666676 }, { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.5793429761885015, "reference_agreement": 0.7744446666666667 }, { "count": 7, "confidence": 0.635342607275984, "reference_agreement": 0.6880951604762682 }, { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.7121878766387506, "reference_agreement": 0.6516665095834904 }, { "count": 15, "confidence": 0.7635113875345624, "reference_agreement": 0.6195556666667333 } ], "gold_label_correct": 60, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.6, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.10083659412693492, "full_vector_brier": 0.08601145965078022 }, "agent_trace_observability/risk": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 0.9828391693041487, "kl": 0.09046906089539679, "brier": 0.026974569027456388, "argmax_agreement": 0.67, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 6, "confidence": 0.3849728739931042, "reference_agreement": 0.4272221555556555 }, { "count": 15, "confidence": 0.44017390916712973, "reference_agreement": 0.4377777200001155 }, { "count": 22, "confidence": 0.5047424360225681, "reference_agreement": 0.541060543181922 }, { "count": 20, "confidence": 0.5613336073178117, "reference_agreement": 0.5121666475000758 }, { "count": 17, "confidence": 0.6336701385816399, "reference_agreement": 0.5417646784313843 }, { "count": 12, "confidence": 0.6951222762738744, "reference_agreement": 0.5763887186111981 }, { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.7875525659292162, "reference_agreement": 0.7093333680001679 }, { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.8046881866954707, "reference_agreement": 0.8511112377785178 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.18766299038600726, "gold_label_correct": 69, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.69, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.12744205611487303, "full_vector_brier": 0.053949138054912776 }, "agent_trace_observability/urgency": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 1.1110665575975052, "kl": 0.08538140828756115, "brier": 0.023272252804307492, "argmax_agreement": 0.6, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 49, "confidence": 0.43689567382624167, "reference_agreement": 0.4303333642177499 }, { "count": 36, "confidence": 0.4938569714495298, "reference_agreement": 0.43055556898154956 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.5775433179069762, "reference_agreement": 0.38333300000000003 }, { "count": 7, "confidence": 0.6344400930336004, "reference_agreement": 0.5833334961905962 }, { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.6981819641643676, "reference_agreement": 0.6986664453336919 }, { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.740555547685341, "reference_agreement": 0.6333336333336334 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.2133133894152343, "gold_label_correct": 62, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.62, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.13295801626402656, "full_vector_brier": 0.046544505608614985 }, "customer_service/action": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 1.2561721269415909, "kl": 0.290314230980401, "brier": 0.06932695222424835, "argmax_agreement": 0.6, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.26431766017833624, "reference_agreement": 0.6433336433336433 }, { "count": 15, "confidence": 0.3143181069990199, "reference_agreement": 0.3948887724445253 }, { "count": 38, "confidence": 0.3671960078421094, "reference_agreement": 0.46475026728081864 }, { "count": 27, "confidence": 0.43092514659511294, "reference_agreement": 0.4196297262963243 }, { "count": 15, "confidence": 0.49345382078770295, "reference_agreement": 0.6222222582223413 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.5467833623082197, "reference_agreement": 0.37499980000020006 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.6432513672126315, "reference_agreement": 0.7800003916668916 } ], "gold_label_correct": 61, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.61, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.20837740157143791, "full_vector_brier": 0.1386539044484967 }, "customer_service/category": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 0.5762908772818797, "kl": 0.16586899434803676, "brier": 0.034944317406019984, "argmax_agreement": 0.93, "hard_count": 1, "hard_ece": 0.04531176280353044, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.9546882371964696, "reference_agreement": 1.0 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.4322684416135483, "reference_agreement": 0.6660000793337393 }, { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.4905168094943096, "reference_agreement": 0.5655556666666667 }, { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.5612844306710459, "reference_agreement": 0.6383332712502996 }, { "count": 12, "confidence": 0.6268957032862555, "reference_agreement": 0.7177498577498188 }, { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.6937005013196476, "reference_agreement": 0.7020831275002684 }, { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.7640632842535814, "reference_agreement": 0.8997435425643682 }, { "count": 20, "confidence": 0.8328563184532323, "reference_agreement": 0.8911928125002632 }, { "count": 20, "confidence": 0.9042490371859675, "reference_agreement": 0.9288167011668795 }, { "count": 11, "confidence": 0.949274918346995, "reference_agreement": 0.972878994697626 } ], "gold_label_correct": 94, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.94, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.1768752555819122, "full_vector_brier": 0.06988863481203997 }, "customer_service/churn_risk": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 1.0730591179793425, "kl": 0.18264058554353962, "brier": 0.051583714603065454, "argmax_agreement": 0.71, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.3315410316851427, "reference_agreement": 0.883333 }, { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.3713688332387563, "reference_agreement": 0.4493333166667167 }, { "count": 31, "confidence": 0.4375064676665284, "reference_agreement": 0.388172083225866 }, { "count": 27, "confidence": 0.49821156690152874, "reference_agreement": 0.5818519443210562 }, { "count": 19, "confidence": 0.5633747625283594, "reference_agreement": 0.5187718885966044 }, { "count": 15, "confidence": 0.6252985881937501, "reference_agreement": 0.6162223266667289 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.6801812993683634, "reference_agreement": 0.6716668416668417 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.31676493780927045, "gold_label_correct": 71, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.71, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.20353240088435612, "full_vector_brier": 0.10316742920613091 }, "customer_service/needs_human": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 0.6710381093325837, "kl": 0.12192570050358188, "brier": 0.054199941449838425, "argmax_agreement": 0.66, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.5158550697220626, "reference_agreement": 0.482499875 }, { "count": 28, "confidence": 0.5674903989336381, "reference_agreement": 0.5160714285714285 }, { "count": 18, "confidence": 0.6357804167556367, "reference_agreement": 0.5612963333333334 }, { "count": 21, "confidence": 0.6961004807233757, "reference_agreement": 0.6815873333333333 }, { "count": 21, "confidence": 0.7545551168362051, "reference_agreement": 0.6688889523809524 }, { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.8146566000120619, "reference_agreement": 0.695 } ], "gold_label_correct": 65, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.65, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.058501302775174596, "full_vector_brier": 0.10839988289967685 }, "customer_service/urgency": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 1.1209630955352308, "kl": 0.251000625647654, "brier": 0.06444621314651275, "argmax_agreement": 0.57, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 18, "confidence": 0.44444863629809206, "reference_agreement": 0.3407406175926695 }, { "count": 20, "confidence": 0.5039577272096432, "reference_agreement": 0.4638332491667292 }, { "count": 28, "confidence": 0.5668426468063085, "reference_agreement": 0.4780952023809791 }, { "count": 24, "confidence": 0.6260414968218451, "reference_agreement": 0.5423611534722869 }, { "count": 9, "confidence": 0.6893581940679483, "reference_agreement": 0.7196295833336129 }, { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.7355911525357738, "reference_agreement": 0.6833336833336833 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.39141314761322865, "gold_label_correct": 56, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.56, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.09986013285263563, "full_vector_brier": 0.1288924262930255 }, "invoice_processing/discrepancy_severity": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 0.7824188222345687, "kl": 0.13817545789882418, "brier": 0.030670028432809596, "argmax_agreement": 0.83, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.33286669301517746, "reference_agreement": 0.5433333916668917 }, { "count": 11, "confidence": 0.37626617164243364, "reference_agreement": 0.40454538484852426 }, { "count": 12, "confidence": 0.4158789751689152, "reference_agreement": 0.41612779859445137 }, { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.511693219926803, "reference_agreement": 0.43666665333345334 }, { "count": 5, "confidence": 0.5577624108377157, "reference_agreement": 0.66000016000016 }, { "count": 7, "confidence": 0.6424516556670419, "reference_agreement": 0.7361905761906619 }, { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.7078300926213531, "reference_agreement": 0.7558974338463236 }, { "count": 20, "confidence": 0.770513839139187, "reference_agreement": 0.7909834398501792 }, { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.8229931371292696, "reference_agreement": 0.8491668804171221 }, { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.9150589341002214, "reference_agreement": 0.9744443333333334 }, { "count": 14, "confidence": 0.9560177842150351, "reference_agreement": 0.9716669228572801 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.28116763438747877, "gold_label_correct": 83, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.83, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.16034912415177363, "full_vector_brier": 0.06134005686561919 }, "invoice_processing/disposition": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 0.9782701754641571, "kl": 0.15481087150893616, "brier": 0.03951271603036011, "argmax_agreement": 0.74, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.3273809757415391, "reference_agreement": 0.356666625 }, { "count": 24, "confidence": 0.3651080883483308, "reference_agreement": 0.3415138374999964 }, { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.43382661018637136, "reference_agreement": 0.5002564646154775 }, { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.4948415192095376, "reference_agreement": 0.5124999458333042 }, { "count": 15, "confidence": 0.5688883847973131, "reference_agreement": 0.5368888311111845 }, { "count": 17, "confidence": 0.6286351192794514, "reference_agreement": 0.6950980264706401 }, { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.6991385791532274, "reference_agreement": 0.7349997708334792 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.7688077873037844, "reference_agreement": 0.9299999999999999 }, { "count": 12, "confidence": 0.837978258839355, "reference_agreement": 0.9375165 }, { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.8818373628541912, "reference_agreement": 0.97 } ], "gold_label_correct": 74, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.74, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.21745472516454098, "full_vector_brier": 0.07902543206072021 }, "invoice_processing/duplicate": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 0.23439542363249471, "kl": 0.02684237146924989, "brier": 0.007817390201271179, "argmax_agreement": 0.94, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 9, "confidence": 0.5172249840934735, "reference_agreement": 0.5159257777777778 }, { "count": 6, "confidence": 0.560787712375488, "reference_agreement": 0.5161113333333334 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.6370394155634268, "reference_agreement": 0.3983335 }, { "count": 12, "confidence": 0.9117582796855447, "reference_agreement": 0.9755277499999999 }, { "count": 71, "confidence": 0.9649128351065898, "reference_agreement": 0.969896676056338 } ], "gold_label_correct": 94, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.94, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.05804417051238259, "full_vector_brier": 0.015634780402542358 }, "invoice_processing/matches_order": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 0.33281042566388214, "kl": 0.0751197521851682, "brier": 0.025450911444578592, "argmax_agreement": 0.91, "hard_count": 1, "hard_ece": 0.04534135188292543, "hard_reliability": [ { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.9546586481170746, "reference_agreement": 1.0 } ], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.5, "reference_agreement": 0.25 }, { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.5422205310594118, "reference_agreement": 0.05 }, { "count": 11, "confidence": 0.643209342515234, "reference_agreement": 0.7396969090909091 }, { "count": 11, "confidence": 0.6853901959758365, "reference_agreement": 0.7666667272727273 }, { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.7572366579530104, "reference_agreement": 0.50250025 }, { "count": 16, "confidence": 0.8447832124548076, "reference_agreement": 0.8733124999999999 }, { "count": 16, "confidence": 0.900017265414687, "reference_agreement": 0.9485416249999999 }, { "count": 39, "confidence": 0.9598572423050843, "reference_agreement": 0.966743564102564 } ], "gold_label_correct": 91, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.91, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.11605332143659476, "full_vector_brier": 0.050901822889157185 }, "invoice_processing/urgency": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 1.0141715127393283, "kl": 0.07238052834777972, "brier": 0.019121604259702194, "argmax_agreement": 0.78, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 3, "confidence": 0.38064151461035944, "reference_agreement": 0.33888879444446113 }, { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.44448085889873, "reference_agreement": 0.4525640602564577 }, { "count": 29, "confidence": 0.49257155336662545, "reference_agreement": 0.4790805124138998 }, { "count": 21, "confidence": 0.561839123121125, "reference_agreement": 0.617936518254042 }, { "count": 11, "confidence": 0.626064968568645, "reference_agreement": 0.47575751969705 }, { "count": 18, "confidence": 0.7051208606202697, "reference_agreement": 0.6442777231481954 }, { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.7392692433647956, "reference_agreement": 0.6750002958335458 }, { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.8085095394162195, "reference_agreement": 0.7166662833337166 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.15339652946539362, "gold_label_correct": 75, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.75, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.18936000086676474, "full_vector_brier": 0.03824320851940439 }, "security_incidents/credential_compromise": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 0.7303544474693316, "kl": 0.11715704441469675, "brier": 0.051873219306088056, "argmax_agreement": 0.56, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 13, "confidence": 0.5162662097600973, "reference_agreement": 0.5041024615384615 }, { "count": 17, "confidence": 0.5577534464386459, "reference_agreement": 0.5229411764705882 }, { "count": 21, "confidence": 0.6372227885501143, "reference_agreement": 0.47063480952380954 }, { "count": 21, "confidence": 0.691688303154376, "reference_agreement": 0.5293650952380953 }, { "count": 20, "confidence": 0.7677754511149539, "reference_agreement": 0.5835 }, { "count": 6, "confidence": 0.8359302010758386, "reference_agreement": 0.7183335 }, { "count": 2, "confidence": 0.9042684049926732, "reference_agreement": 0.6583330000000001 } ], "gold_label_correct": 56, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.56, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.11893490648195507, "full_vector_brier": 0.10374643861217611 }, "security_incidents/disposition": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 1.1972067216437494, "kl": 0.17300846279960486, "brier": 0.04600030885849212, "argmax_agreement": 0.58, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.32224419861704345, "reference_agreement": 0.29249995416670416 }, { "count": 39, "confidence": 0.3715904353978362, "reference_agreement": 0.39512819239318403 }, { "count": 48, "confidence": 0.4302195975460818, "reference_agreement": 0.46097220729168575 }, { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.501278204923741, "reference_agreement": 0.5562498937501396 }, { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.5496311616587236, "reference_agreement": 0.5166664833335167 } ], "gold_label_correct": 58, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.58, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.17586552330691987, "full_vector_brier": 0.09200061771698424 }, "security_incidents/severity": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 1.3148165106977874, "kl": 0.15926300401560653, "brier": 0.033456273290858624, "argmax_agreement": 0.62, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 9, "confidence": 0.3078600014285725, "reference_agreement": 0.1892591229629178 }, { "count": 12, "confidence": 0.3727428250841209, "reference_agreement": 0.36388904000012334 }, { "count": 29, "confidence": 0.433631983234007, "reference_agreement": 0.3698850510345237 }, { "count": 26, "confidence": 0.4919768669037995, "reference_agreement": 0.45679487397444657 }, { "count": 16, "confidence": 0.5652997260041271, "reference_agreement": 0.5520831968751906 }, { "count": 8, "confidence": 0.6261899107804109, "reference_agreement": 0.5354167166668834 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.32567749172139204, "gold_label_correct": 61, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.61, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.1787678515625339, "full_vector_brier": 0.06691254658171725 }, "security_incidents/true_positive": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 0.6603075839178701, "kl": 0.08099352894896619, "brier": 0.034705909701544004, "argmax_agreement": 0.75, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 10, "confidence": 0.5126907829686985, "reference_agreement": 0.4816668 }, { "count": 18, "confidence": 0.5699609726709991, "reference_agreement": 0.5612962222222222 }, { "count": 25, "confidence": 0.6460510888610294, "reference_agreement": 0.6201333600000001 }, { "count": 23, "confidence": 0.7025946692840792, "reference_agreement": 0.6679710869565217 }, { "count": 20, "confidence": 0.7638206827542047, "reference_agreement": 0.6675001 }, { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.8187285196215046, "reference_agreement": 0.7533335 } ], "gold_label_correct": 75, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.75, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.09523922989135299, "full_vector_brier": 0.06941181940308801 }, "security_incidents/urgency": { "count": 100, "soft_ce": 1.1577196305931823, "kl": 0.13567367475447445, "brier": 0.0355259516439954, "argmax_agreement": 0.6, "hard_count": 0, "hard_ece": null, "hard_reliability": [], "soft_reliability": [ { "count": 26, "confidence": 0.38596311063456945, "reference_agreement": 0.34250002224366877 }, { "count": 41, "confidence": 0.42761054306537855, "reference_agreement": 0.45186988617891466 }, { "count": 16, "confidence": 0.5006824036853632, "reference_agreement": 0.4831250822917073 }, { "count": 12, "confidence": 0.5661019822011998, "reference_agreement": 0.599444329722337 }, { "count": 4, "confidence": 0.642325133897913, "reference_agreement": 0.58333330000025 }, { "count": 1, "confidence": 0.6678840336998128, "reference_agreement": 0.5833335833335833 } ], "expected_score_mae": 0.2863215150200857, "gold_label_correct": 60, "gold_label_accuracy": 0.6, "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions": 0.1646168179614661, "full_vector_brier": 0.0710519032879908 } } }, "metric_notes": { "accuracy": "Main accuracy compares original option key with stored gold.label; argmax_agreement separately uses first maximum of rounded target distribution in input option order", "soft_ce": "Mean natural-log cross-entropy against full normalized gold distribution", "kl": "Mean KL(gold || prediction)", "brier": "Existing metric field brier is half-vector Brier; full_vector_brier is twice it", "ece": "gold_label_ece_15bin_all_decisions uses top probability vs stored-label accuracy on all examples; hard_ece uses one-hot references only; exact leaderboard scorer parity is not claimed", "overlap": "Normalized exact state and source-ID checks; paraphrase and pretraining exposure not assessed" } }, "sysone_bench": { "dataset_version": "2.1.0", "upstream_revision": "93afcfe1bd450dc052b21768e2b95b20316ebb68", "manifest_sha256": "0d21a64c6b61b6be7b49050dbd89f89f934912a7b586734e475308e9c9422ea2", "raw": { "evaluation_cases": 952, "evaluation_decisions": 1240, "correct": 953, "accuracy": 0.7685483870967742, "suites": { "triage": { "accuracy": 0.9270833333333334, "cases": 48, "decisions": 192, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.03883962416667922, "p50_seconds": 0.03841860600016389, "p95_seconds": 0.04178968690000602 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": 0.8541666666666666, "macro_f1": 0.820875420875421, "balanced_accuracy": 0.8444444444444444, "per_class_recall": { "billing_question": 0.2222222222222222, "cancellation": 1.0, "information": 1.0, "refund": 1.0, "technical_help": 1.0 }, "brier": 0.13697967505778072, "nll": 0.2506294304217651, "ece_raw": 0.033931114278253044, "ece_fitted": 0.039914814482762906 }, "noul": { "accuracy": 0.9513888888888888, "balanced_accuracy": 0.912037037037037, "auroc": 0.9890689300411523, "auprc": 0.9701626578233637, "brier": 0.04911263462874029, "nll": 0.1906247610132196, "ece_raw": 0.01181868597485985, "ece_fitted": 0.012443502260767868 }, "score": { "mae": null, "rmse": null, "nearest_level_accuracy": null, "within_one_accuracy": null, "raw_equality_rate": null, "spearman": null, "ordinal_confusion": null } }, "correct": 178 }, "guardrails": { "accuracy": 0.8125, "cases": 48, "decisions": 96, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.037130780229148286, "p50_seconds": 0.03704196349997346, "p95_seconds": 0.03867655395000611 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": null, "macro_f1": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "per_class_recall": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "noul": { "accuracy": 0.8125, "balanced_accuracy": 0.8676470588235294, "auroc": 0.9803046218487395, "auprc": 0.9910730108125466, "brier": 0.14491041421218856, "nll": 0.4276831543302518, "ece_raw": 0.02432198575945292, "ece_fitted": 0.026983405418465858 }, "score": { "mae": null, "rmse": null, "nearest_level_accuracy": null, "within_one_accuracy": null, "raw_equality_rate": null, "spearman": null, "ordinal_confusion": null } }, "correct": 78 }, "moderation": { "accuracy": 0.9166666666666666, "cases": 48, "decisions": 144, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.03827599806249301, "p50_seconds": 0.037934129999939614, "p95_seconds": 0.041699429449965915 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": null, "macro_f1": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "per_class_recall": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "noul": { "accuracy": 0.9166666666666666, "balanced_accuracy": 0.9106227106227107, "auroc": 0.978021978021978, "auprc": 0.944990138816365, "brier": 0.06061711079669634, "nll": 0.2023230253736832, "ece_raw": 0.010916557094938821, "ece_fitted": 0.011697905217155507 }, "score": { "mae": null, "rmse": null, "nearest_level_accuracy": null, "within_one_accuracy": null, "raw_equality_rate": null, "spearman": null, "ordinal_confusion": null } }, "correct": 132 }, "agnews": { "accuracy": 0.8125, "cases": 160, "decisions": 160, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.038758980293738435, "p50_seconds": 0.0382035000001224, "p95_seconds": 0.042714876549950986 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": 0.8125, "macro_f1": 0.8064558008777994, "balanced_accuracy": 0.8125, "per_class_recall": { "business": 0.85, "scitech": 0.55, "sports": 0.975, "world": 0.875 }, "brier": 0.30172771335742954, "nll": 0.6319382379388891, "ece_raw": 0.0052000811604517765, "ece_fitted": 0.007738817523861061 }, "noul": { "accuracy": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "auroc": null, "auprc": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "score": { "mae": null, "rmse": null, "nearest_level_accuracy": null, "within_one_accuracy": null, "raw_equality_rate": null, "spearman": null, "ordinal_confusion": null } }, "correct": 130 }, "emotion": { "accuracy": 0.7239583333333334, "cases": 192, "decisions": 192, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.038396373302075425, "p50_seconds": 0.03797906949989738, "p95_seconds": 0.0415361116498957 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": 0.7239583333333334, "macro_f1": 0.6913006811212603, "balanced_accuracy": 0.6854851048438465, "per_class_recall": { "anger": 0.5714285714285714, "fear": 0.9259259259259259, "joy": 0.7142857142857143, "love": 0.6, "sadness": 0.8275862068965517, "surprise": 0.47368421052631576 }, "brier": 0.39443242180284094, "nll": 0.7806033322263032, "ece_raw": 0.0032102610291140795, "ece_fitted": 0.003416953263655513 }, "noul": { "accuracy": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "auroc": null, "auprc": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "score": { "mae": null, "rmse": null, "nearest_level_accuracy": null, "within_one_accuracy": null, "raw_equality_rate": null, "spearman": null, "ordinal_confusion": null } }, "correct": 139 }, "banking77_12": { "accuracy": 0.8020833333333334, "cases": 96, "decisions": 96, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.03918704791666509, "p50_seconds": 0.038639419499986616, "p95_seconds": 0.04271133699995744 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": 0.8020833333333334, "macro_f1": 0.7940683880389763, "balanced_accuracy": 0.8020833333333334, "per_class_recall": { "card_arrival": 0.625, "card_linking": 0.25, "exchange_rate": 1.0, "lost_or_stolen_card": 1.0, "order_physical_card": 0.875, "pin_blocked": 0.875, "refund_not_showing_up": 0.875, "request_refund": 0.875, "terminate_account": 1.0, "top_up_failed": 0.875, "topping_up_by_card": 0.5, "transaction_charged_twice": 0.875 }, "brier": 0.29183460550386847, "nll": 0.774193924200847, "ece_raw": 0.01661891915597873, "ece_fitted": 0.016552925317361755 }, "noul": { "accuracy": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "auroc": null, "auprc": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "score": { "mae": null, "rmse": null, "nearest_level_accuracy": null, "within_one_accuracy": null, "raw_equality_rate": null, "spearman": null, "ordinal_confusion": null } }, "correct": 77 }, "mnli": { "accuracy": 0.5416666666666666, "cases": 120, "decisions": 120, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.0384311384083181, "p50_seconds": 0.03797633499982567, "p95_seconds": 0.04150163254993231 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": 0.5416666666666666, "macro_f1": 0.531705418323941, "balanced_accuracy": 0.5416666666666666, "per_class_recall": { "contradiction": 0.575, "entailment": 0.725, "neutral": 0.325 }, "brier": 0.5619903249840926, "nll": 0.952791383586364, "ece_raw": 0.0067628751799769776, "ece_fitted": 0.00836092388336822 }, "noul": { "accuracy": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "auroc": null, "auprc": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "score": { "mae": null, "rmse": null, "nearest_level_accuracy": null, "within_one_accuracy": null, "raw_equality_rate": null, "spearman": null, "ordinal_confusion": null } }, "correct": 65 }, "sst5": { "accuracy": 0.3333333333333333, "cases": 120, "decisions": 120, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.038905105700003634, "p50_seconds": 0.03851513350002733, "p95_seconds": 0.041932194849789536 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": null, "macro_f1": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "per_class_recall": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "noul": { "accuracy": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "auroc": null, "auprc": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "score": { "mae": 0.8020032497743765, "rmse": 0.9909589189089723, "nearest_level_accuracy": 0.3333333333333333, "within_one_accuracy": 0.875, "raw_equality_rate": 0.0, "spearman": 0.737594189458718, "ordinal_confusion": { "labels": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "matrix": [ [ 0, 19, 4, 1, 0 ], [ 2, 10, 12, 0, 0 ], [ 0, 6, 17, 1, 0 ], [ 0, 1, 11, 12, 0 ], [ 0, 1, 8, 14, 1 ] ] } } }, "correct": 40 }, "multilingual_intent": { "accuracy": 0.95, "cases": 120, "decisions": 120, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.039158464716655315, "p50_seconds": 0.03864724799996111, "p95_seconds": 0.04240460730002269 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": 0.95, "macro_f1": 0.8159019343229869, "balanced_accuracy": 0.9650000000000001, "per_class_recall": { "billing_question": 0.95, "cancellation": 1.0, "information": 0.875, "other": null, "refund": 1.0, "technical_help": 1.0 }, "brier": 0.12235859002542863, "nll": 0.24005612544914204, "ece_raw": 0.008839931130203269, "ece_fitted": 0.0071500889173673875 }, "noul": { "accuracy": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "auroc": null, "auprc": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "score": { "mae": null, "rmse": null, "nearest_level_accuracy": null, "within_one_accuracy": null, "raw_equality_rate": null, "spearman": null, "ordinal_confusion": null } }, "correct": 114 } }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": 0.7690217391304348, "macro_f1": 0.748753245465977, "balanced_accuracy": 0.7745682853365854, "per_class_recall": { "anger": 0.5714285714285714, "billing_question": 0.7241379310344828, "business": 0.85, "cancellation": 1.0, "card_arrival": 0.625, "card_linking": 0.25, "contradiction": 0.575, "entailment": 0.725, "exchange_rate": 1.0, "fear": 0.9259259259259259, "information": 0.9, "joy": 0.7142857142857143, "lost_or_stolen_card": 1.0, "love": 0.6, "neutral": 0.325, "order_physical_card": 0.875, "other": null, "pin_blocked": 0.875, "refund": 1.0, "refund_not_showing_up": 0.875, "request_refund": 0.875, "sadness": 0.8275862068965517, "scitech": 0.55, "sports": 0.975, "surprise": 0.47368421052631576, "technical_help": 1.0, "terminate_account": 1.0, "top_up_failed": 0.875, "topping_up_by_card": 0.5, "transaction_charged_twice": 0.875, "world": 0.875 }, "brier": 0.3270658633907902, "nll": 0.6528267504422001, "ece_raw": 0.0007309538327833588, "ece_fitted": 0.0004591988587776608 }, "noul": { "accuracy": 0.9036458333333334, "balanced_accuracy": 0.8834257029277777, "auroc": 0.972521254678931, "auprc": 0.9503028848436744, "brier": 0.07737625808758589, "nll": 0.2542762084776515, "ece_raw": 0.004463339661746162, "ece_fitted": 0.0049155860343304296 }, "score": { "mae": 0.8020032497743765, "rmse": 0.9909589189089723, "nearest_level_accuracy": 0.3333333333333333, "within_one_accuracy": 0.875, "raw_equality_rate": 0.0, "spearman": 0.737594189458718, "ordinal_confusion": { "labels": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "matrix": [ [ 0, 19, 4, 1, 0 ], [ 2, 10, 12, 0, 0 ], [ 0, 6, 17, 1, 0 ], [ 0, 1, 11, 12, 0 ], [ 0, 1, 8, 14, 1 ] ] } } } }, "calibrated": { "evaluation_cases": 952, "evaluation_decisions": 1240, "correct": 953, "accuracy": 0.7685483870967742, "suites": { "triage": { "accuracy": 0.9270833333333334, "cases": 48, "decisions": 192, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.03883962416667922, "p50_seconds": 0.03841860600016389, "p95_seconds": 0.04178968690000602 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": 0.8541666666666666, "macro_f1": 0.820875420875421, "balanced_accuracy": 0.8444444444444444, "per_class_recall": { "billing_question": 0.2222222222222222, "cancellation": 1.0, "information": 1.0, "refund": 1.0, "technical_help": 1.0 }, "brier": 0.14243087345916075, "nll": 0.2813106462197595, "ece_raw": 0.028952845660412414, "ece_fitted": 0.03991474162123874 }, "noul": { "accuracy": 0.9513888888888888, "balanced_accuracy": 0.912037037037037, "auroc": 0.9886831275720165, "auprc": 0.9700223660164052, "brier": 0.052313952030937215, "nll": 0.20641514576135578, "ece_raw": 0.010566808507195363, "ece_fitted": 0.012443507589047501 }, "score": { "mae": null, "rmse": null, "nearest_level_accuracy": null, "within_one_accuracy": null, "raw_equality_rate": null, "spearman": null, "ordinal_confusion": null } }, "correct": 178 }, "guardrails": { "accuracy": 0.8125, "cases": 48, "decisions": 96, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.037130780229148286, "p50_seconds": 0.03704196349997346, "p95_seconds": 0.03867655395000611 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": null, "macro_f1": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "per_class_recall": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "noul": { "accuracy": 0.8125, "balanced_accuracy": 0.8676470588235294, "auroc": 0.9803046218487395, "auprc": 0.9910196723104415, "brier": 0.14399152528197112, "nll": 0.4301690068230142, "ece_raw": 0.027843129969293463, "ece_fitted": 0.02698340407756053 }, "score": { "mae": null, "rmse": null, "nearest_level_accuracy": null, "within_one_accuracy": null, "raw_equality_rate": null, "spearman": null, "ordinal_confusion": null } }, "correct": 78 }, "moderation": { "accuracy": 0.9166666666666666, "cases": 48, "decisions": 144, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.03827599806249301, "p50_seconds": 0.037934129999939614, "p95_seconds": 0.041699429449965915 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": null, "macro_f1": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "per_class_recall": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "noul": { "accuracy": 0.9166666666666666, "balanced_accuracy": 0.9106227106227107, "auroc": 0.978021978021978, "auprc": 0.944990138816365, "brier": 0.06164195701639249, "nll": 0.21176174396122044, "ece_raw": 0.014191582921902587, "ece_fitted": 0.01169790659953756 }, "score": { "mae": null, "rmse": null, "nearest_level_accuracy": null, "within_one_accuracy": null, "raw_equality_rate": null, "spearman": null, "ordinal_confusion": null } }, "correct": 132 }, "agnews": { "accuracy": 0.8125, "cases": 160, "decisions": 160, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.038758980293738435, "p50_seconds": 0.0382035000001224, "p95_seconds": 0.042714876549950986 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": 0.8125, "macro_f1": 0.8064558008777994, "balanced_accuracy": 0.8125, "per_class_recall": { "business": 0.85, "scitech": 0.55, "sports": 0.975, "world": 0.875 }, "brier": 0.2965232296874367, "nll": 0.5908707062914559, "ece_raw": 0.004136447508252946, "ece_fitted": 0.007738817845546403 }, "noul": { "accuracy": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "auroc": null, "auprc": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "score": { "mae": null, "rmse": null, "nearest_level_accuracy": null, "within_one_accuracy": null, "raw_equality_rate": null, "spearman": null, "ordinal_confusion": null } }, "correct": 130 }, "emotion": { "accuracy": 0.7239583333333334, "cases": 192, "decisions": 192, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.038396373302075425, "p50_seconds": 0.03797906949989738, "p95_seconds": 0.0415361116498957 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": 0.7239583333333334, "macro_f1": 0.6913006811212603, "balanced_accuracy": 0.6854851048438465, "per_class_recall": { "anger": 0.5714285714285714, "fear": 0.9259259259259259, "joy": 0.7142857142857143, "love": 0.6, "sadness": 0.8275862068965517, "surprise": 0.47368421052631576 }, "brier": 0.39805364003393406, "nll": 0.7908805977682863, "ece_raw": 0.004164112978894893, "ece_fitted": 0.0034169522756447193 }, "noul": { "accuracy": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "auroc": null, "auprc": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "score": { "mae": null, "rmse": null, "nearest_level_accuracy": null, "within_one_accuracy": null, "raw_equality_rate": null, "spearman": null, "ordinal_confusion": null } }, "correct": 139 }, "banking77_12": { "accuracy": 0.8020833333333334, "cases": 96, "decisions": 96, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.03918704791666509, "p50_seconds": 0.038639419499986616, "p95_seconds": 0.04271133699995744 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": 0.8020833333333334, "macro_f1": 0.7940683880389763, "balanced_accuracy": 0.8020833333333334, "per_class_recall": { "card_arrival": 0.625, "card_linking": 0.25, "exchange_rate": 1.0, "lost_or_stolen_card": 1.0, "order_physical_card": 0.875, "pin_blocked": 0.875, "refund_not_showing_up": 0.875, "request_refund": 0.875, "terminate_account": 1.0, "top_up_failed": 0.875, "topping_up_by_card": 0.5, "transaction_charged_twice": 0.875 }, "brier": 0.2841311372982186, "nll": 0.7256759563838567, "ece_raw": 0.014651013888121192, "ece_fitted": 0.0165529263424545 }, "noul": { "accuracy": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "auroc": null, "auprc": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "score": { "mae": null, "rmse": null, "nearest_level_accuracy": null, "within_one_accuracy": null, "raw_equality_rate": null, "spearman": null, "ordinal_confusion": null } }, "correct": 77 }, "mnli": { "accuracy": 0.5416666666666666, "cases": 120, "decisions": 120, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.0384311384083181, "p50_seconds": 0.03797633499982567, "p95_seconds": 0.04150163254993231 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": 0.5416666666666666, "macro_f1": 0.531705418323941, "balanced_accuracy": 0.5416666666666666, "per_class_recall": { "contradiction": 0.575, "entailment": 0.725, "neutral": 0.325 }, "brier": 0.5534738375592544, "nll": 0.9317788432632266, "ece_raw": 0.005991485962656614, "ece_fitted": 0.008360924461080638 }, "noul": { "accuracy": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "auroc": null, "auprc": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "score": { "mae": null, "rmse": null, "nearest_level_accuracy": null, "within_one_accuracy": null, "raw_equality_rate": null, "spearman": null, "ordinal_confusion": null } }, "correct": 65 }, "sst5": { "accuracy": 0.3333333333333333, "cases": 120, "decisions": 120, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.038905105700003634, "p50_seconds": 0.03851513350002733, "p95_seconds": 0.041932194849789536 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": null, "macro_f1": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "per_class_recall": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "noul": { "accuracy": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "auroc": null, "auprc": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "score": { "mae": 0.8023576299349467, "rmse": 0.9908613116687078, "nearest_level_accuracy": 0.3333333333333333, "within_one_accuracy": 0.875, "raw_equality_rate": 0.0, "spearman": 0.7382746269028682, "ordinal_confusion": { "labels": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "matrix": [ [ 0, 19, 4, 1, 0 ], [ 2, 10, 12, 0, 0 ], [ 0, 6, 17, 1, 0 ], [ 0, 1, 11, 12, 0 ], [ 0, 1, 8, 14, 1 ] ] } } }, "correct": 40 }, "multilingual_intent": { "accuracy": 0.95, "cases": 120, "decisions": 120, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.039158464716655315, "p50_seconds": 0.03864724799996111, "p95_seconds": 0.04240460730002269 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": 0.95, "macro_f1": 0.8159019343229869, "balanced_accuracy": 0.9650000000000001, "per_class_recall": { "billing_question": 0.95, "cancellation": 1.0, "information": 0.875, "other": null, "refund": 1.0, "technical_help": 1.0 }, "brier": 0.13506004724959844, "nll": 0.2766243432861846, "ece_raw": 0.01098334737043859, "ece_fitted": 0.007150088729354088 }, "noul": { "accuracy": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "auroc": null, "auprc": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "score": { "mae": null, "rmse": null, "nearest_level_accuracy": null, "within_one_accuracy": null, "raw_equality_rate": null, "spearman": null, "ordinal_confusion": null } }, "correct": 114 } }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": 0.7690217391304348, "macro_f1": 0.748753245465977, "balanced_accuracy": 0.7745682853365854, "per_class_recall": { "anger": 0.5714285714285714, "billing_question": 0.7241379310344828, "business": 0.85, "cancellation": 1.0, "card_arrival": 0.625, "card_linking": 0.25, "contradiction": 0.575, "entailment": 0.725, "exchange_rate": 1.0, "fear": 0.9259259259259259, "information": 0.9, "joy": 0.7142857142857143, "lost_or_stolen_card": 1.0, "love": 0.6, "neutral": 0.325, "order_physical_card": 0.875, "other": null, "pin_blocked": 0.875, "refund": 1.0, "refund_not_showing_up": 0.875, "request_refund": 0.875, "sadness": 0.8275862068965517, "scitech": 0.55, "sports": 0.975, "surprise": 0.47368421052631576, "technical_help": 1.0, "terminate_account": 1.0, "top_up_failed": 0.875, "topping_up_by_card": 0.5, "transaction_charged_twice": 0.875, "world": 0.875 }, "brier": 0.32691216429379927, "nll": 0.6447888220047173, "ece_raw": 0.000757314816236097, "ece_fitted": 0.00045919887827611055 }, "noul": { "accuracy": 0.9036458333333334, "balanced_accuracy": 0.8834257029277777, "auroc": 0.972492238052404, "auprc": 0.950340531508563, "brier": 0.07873134721324142, "nll": 0.26435858535171963, "ece_raw": 0.004409246207057182, "ece_fitted": 0.004915585951212646 }, "score": { "mae": 0.8023576299349467, "rmse": 0.9908613116687078, "nearest_level_accuracy": 0.3333333333333333, "within_one_accuracy": 0.875, "raw_equality_rate": 0.0, "spearman": 0.7382746269028682, "ordinal_confusion": { "labels": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "matrix": [ [ 0, 19, 4, 1, 0 ], [ 2, 10, 12, 0, 0 ], [ 0, 6, 17, 1, 0 ], [ 0, 1, 11, 12, 0 ], [ 0, 1, 8, 14, 1 ] ] } } } }, "flagged_phrase_excluded": { "excluded_cases": [ "banking77_12-0084" ], "raw": { "evaluation_cases": 951, "evaluation_decisions": 1239, "correct": 952, "accuracy": 0.768361581920904, "suites": { "triage": { "accuracy": 0.9270833333333334, "cases": 48, "decisions": 192, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.03883962416667922, "p50_seconds": 0.03841860600016389, "p95_seconds": 0.04178968690000602 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": 0.8541666666666666, "macro_f1": 0.820875420875421, "balanced_accuracy": 0.8444444444444444, "per_class_recall": { "billing_question": 0.2222222222222222, "cancellation": 1.0, "information": 1.0, "refund": 1.0, "technical_help": 1.0 }, "brier": 0.13697967505778072, "nll": 0.2506294304217651, "ece_raw": 0.033931114278253044, "ece_fitted": 0.039914814482762906 }, "noul": { "accuracy": 0.9513888888888888, "balanced_accuracy": 0.912037037037037, "auroc": 0.9890689300411523, "auprc": 0.9701626578233637, "brier": 0.04911263462874029, "nll": 0.1906247610132196, "ece_raw": 0.01181868597485985, "ece_fitted": 0.012443502260767868 }, "score": { "mae": null, "rmse": null, "nearest_level_accuracy": null, "within_one_accuracy": null, "raw_equality_rate": null, "spearman": null, "ordinal_confusion": null } }, "correct": 178 }, "guardrails": { "accuracy": 0.8125, "cases": 48, "decisions": 96, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.037130780229148286, "p50_seconds": 0.03704196349997346, "p95_seconds": 0.03867655395000611 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": null, "macro_f1": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "per_class_recall": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "noul": { "accuracy": 0.8125, "balanced_accuracy": 0.8676470588235294, "auroc": 0.9803046218487395, "auprc": 0.9910730108125466, "brier": 0.14491041421218856, "nll": 0.4276831543302518, "ece_raw": 0.02432198575945292, "ece_fitted": 0.026983405418465858 }, "score": { "mae": null, "rmse": null, "nearest_level_accuracy": null, "within_one_accuracy": null, "raw_equality_rate": null, "spearman": null, "ordinal_confusion": null } }, "correct": 78 }, "moderation": { "accuracy": 0.9166666666666666, "cases": 48, "decisions": 144, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.03827599806249301, "p50_seconds": 0.037934129999939614, "p95_seconds": 0.041699429449965915 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": null, "macro_f1": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "per_class_recall": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "noul": { "accuracy": 0.9166666666666666, "balanced_accuracy": 0.9106227106227107, "auroc": 0.978021978021978, "auprc": 0.944990138816365, "brier": 0.06061711079669634, "nll": 0.2023230253736832, "ece_raw": 0.010916557094938821, "ece_fitted": 0.011697905217155507 }, "score": { "mae": null, "rmse": null, "nearest_level_accuracy": null, "within_one_accuracy": null, "raw_equality_rate": null, "spearman": null, "ordinal_confusion": null } }, "correct": 132 }, "agnews": { "accuracy": 0.8125, "cases": 160, "decisions": 160, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.038758980293738435, "p50_seconds": 0.0382035000001224, "p95_seconds": 0.042714876549950986 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": 0.8125, "macro_f1": 0.8064558008777994, "balanced_accuracy": 0.8125, "per_class_recall": { "business": 0.85, "scitech": 0.55, "sports": 0.975, "world": 0.875 }, "brier": 0.30172771335742954, "nll": 0.6319382379388891, "ece_raw": 0.0052000811604517765, "ece_fitted": 0.007738817523861061 }, "noul": { "accuracy": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "auroc": null, "auprc": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "score": { "mae": null, "rmse": null, "nearest_level_accuracy": null, "within_one_accuracy": null, "raw_equality_rate": null, "spearman": null, "ordinal_confusion": null } }, "correct": 130 }, "emotion": { "accuracy": 0.7239583333333334, "cases": 192, "decisions": 192, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.038396373302075425, "p50_seconds": 0.03797906949989738, "p95_seconds": 0.0415361116498957 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": 0.7239583333333334, "macro_f1": 0.6913006811212603, "balanced_accuracy": 0.6854851048438465, "per_class_recall": { "anger": 0.5714285714285714, "fear": 0.9259259259259259, "joy": 0.7142857142857143, "love": 0.6, "sadness": 0.8275862068965517, "surprise": 0.47368421052631576 }, "brier": 0.39443242180284094, "nll": 0.7806033322263032, "ece_raw": 0.0032102610291140795, "ece_fitted": 0.003416953263655513 }, "noul": { "accuracy": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "auroc": null, "auprc": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "score": { "mae": null, "rmse": null, "nearest_level_accuracy": null, "within_one_accuracy": null, "raw_equality_rate": null, "spearman": null, "ordinal_confusion": null } }, "correct": 139 }, "banking77_12": { "accuracy": 0.8, "cases": 95, "decisions": 95, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.03918948851578773, "p50_seconds": 0.03858194800000092, "p95_seconds": 0.04271281379994889 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": 0.8, "macro_f1": 0.7934147932677345, "balanced_accuracy": 0.8020833333333334, "per_class_recall": { "card_arrival": 0.625, "card_linking": 0.25, "exchange_rate": 1.0, "lost_or_stolen_card": 1.0, "order_physical_card": 0.875, "pin_blocked": 0.875, "refund_not_showing_up": 0.875, "request_refund": 0.875, "terminate_account": 1.0, "top_up_failed": 0.875, "topping_up_by_card": 0.5, "transaction_charged_twice": 0.875 }, "brier": 0.29490650156145987, "nll": 0.782323559878833, "ece_raw": 0.01680271757873975, "ece_fitted": 0.016734122969269134 }, "noul": { "accuracy": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "auroc": null, "auprc": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "score": { "mae": null, "rmse": null, "nearest_level_accuracy": null, "within_one_accuracy": null, "raw_equality_rate": null, "spearman": null, "ordinal_confusion": null } }, "correct": 76 }, "mnli": { "accuracy": 0.5416666666666666, "cases": 120, "decisions": 120, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.0384311384083181, "p50_seconds": 0.03797633499982567, "p95_seconds": 0.04150163254993231 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": 0.5416666666666666, "macro_f1": 0.531705418323941, "balanced_accuracy": 0.5416666666666666, "per_class_recall": { "contradiction": 0.575, "entailment": 0.725, "neutral": 0.325 }, "brier": 0.5619903249840926, "nll": 0.952791383586364, "ece_raw": 0.0067628751799769776, "ece_fitted": 0.00836092388336822 }, "noul": { "accuracy": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "auroc": null, "auprc": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "score": { "mae": null, "rmse": null, "nearest_level_accuracy": null, "within_one_accuracy": null, "raw_equality_rate": null, "spearman": null, "ordinal_confusion": null } }, "correct": 65 }, "sst5": { "accuracy": 0.3333333333333333, "cases": 120, "decisions": 120, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.038905105700003634, "p50_seconds": 0.03851513350002733, "p95_seconds": 0.041932194849789536 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": null, "macro_f1": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "per_class_recall": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "noul": { "accuracy": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "auroc": null, "auprc": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "score": { "mae": 0.8020032497743765, "rmse": 0.9909589189089723, "nearest_level_accuracy": 0.3333333333333333, "within_one_accuracy": 0.875, "raw_equality_rate": 0.0, "spearman": 0.737594189458718, "ordinal_confusion": { "labels": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "matrix": [ [ 0, 19, 4, 1, 0 ], [ 2, 10, 12, 0, 0 ], [ 0, 6, 17, 1, 0 ], [ 0, 1, 11, 12, 0 ], [ 0, 1, 8, 14, 1 ] ] } } }, "correct": 40 }, "multilingual_intent": { "accuracy": 0.95, "cases": 120, "decisions": 120, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.039158464716655315, "p50_seconds": 0.03864724799996111, "p95_seconds": 0.04240460730002269 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": 0.95, "macro_f1": 0.8159019343229869, "balanced_accuracy": 0.9650000000000001, "per_class_recall": { "billing_question": 0.95, "cancellation": 1.0, "information": 0.875, "other": null, "refund": 1.0, "technical_help": 1.0 }, "brier": 0.12235859002542863, "nll": 0.24005612544914204, "ece_raw": 0.008839931130203269, "ece_fitted": 0.0071500889173673875 }, "noul": { "accuracy": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "auroc": null, "auprc": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "score": { "mae": null, "rmse": null, "nearest_level_accuracy": null, "within_one_accuracy": null, "raw_equality_rate": null, "spearman": null, "ordinal_confusion": null } }, "correct": 114 } }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": 0.7687074829931972, "macro_f1": 0.7485002410383995, "balanced_accuracy": 0.7745682853365854, "per_class_recall": { "anger": 0.5714285714285714, "billing_question": 0.7241379310344828, "business": 0.85, "cancellation": 1.0, "card_arrival": 0.625, "card_linking": 0.25, "contradiction": 0.575, "entailment": 0.725, "exchange_rate": 1.0, "fear": 0.9259259259259259, "information": 0.9, "joy": 0.7142857142857143, "lost_or_stolen_card": 1.0, "love": 0.6, "neutral": 0.325, "order_physical_card": 0.875, "other": null, "pin_blocked": 0.875, "refund": 1.0, "refund_not_showing_up": 0.875, "request_refund": 0.875, "sadness": 0.8275862068965517, "scitech": 0.55, "sports": 0.975, "surprise": 0.47368421052631576, "technical_help": 1.0, "terminate_account": 1.0, "top_up_failed": 0.875, "topping_up_by_card": 0.5, "transaction_charged_twice": 0.875, "world": 0.875 }, "brier": 0.3275108448647468, "nll": 0.6537123942730164, "ece_raw": 0.000732155258879059, "ece_fitted": 0.00045994712310874536 }, "noul": { "accuracy": 0.9036458333333334, "balanced_accuracy": 0.8834257029277777, "auroc": 0.972521254678931, "auprc": 0.9503028848436744, "brier": 0.07737625808758589, "nll": 0.2542762084776515, "ece_raw": 0.004463339661746162, "ece_fitted": 0.0049155860343304296 }, "score": { "mae": 0.8020032497743765, "rmse": 0.9909589189089723, "nearest_level_accuracy": 0.3333333333333333, "within_one_accuracy": 0.875, "raw_equality_rate": 0.0, "spearman": 0.737594189458718, "ordinal_confusion": { "labels": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "matrix": [ [ 0, 19, 4, 1, 0 ], [ 2, 10, 12, 0, 0 ], [ 0, 6, 17, 1, 0 ], [ 0, 1, 11, 12, 0 ], [ 0, 1, 8, 14, 1 ] ] } } } }, "calibrated": { "evaluation_cases": 951, "evaluation_decisions": 1239, "correct": 952, "accuracy": 0.768361581920904, "suites": { "triage": { "accuracy": 0.9270833333333334, "cases": 48, "decisions": 192, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.03883962416667922, "p50_seconds": 0.03841860600016389, "p95_seconds": 0.04178968690000602 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": 0.8541666666666666, "macro_f1": 0.820875420875421, "balanced_accuracy": 0.8444444444444444, "per_class_recall": { "billing_question": 0.2222222222222222, "cancellation": 1.0, "information": 1.0, "refund": 1.0, "technical_help": 1.0 }, "brier": 0.14243087345916075, "nll": 0.2813106462197595, "ece_raw": 0.028952845660412414, "ece_fitted": 0.03991474162123874 }, "noul": { "accuracy": 0.9513888888888888, "balanced_accuracy": 0.912037037037037, "auroc": 0.9886831275720165, "auprc": 0.9700223660164052, "brier": 0.052313952030937215, "nll": 0.20641514576135578, "ece_raw": 0.010566808507195363, "ece_fitted": 0.012443507589047501 }, "score": { "mae": null, "rmse": null, "nearest_level_accuracy": null, "within_one_accuracy": null, "raw_equality_rate": null, "spearman": null, "ordinal_confusion": null } }, "correct": 178 }, "guardrails": { "accuracy": 0.8125, "cases": 48, "decisions": 96, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.037130780229148286, "p50_seconds": 0.03704196349997346, "p95_seconds": 0.03867655395000611 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": null, "macro_f1": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "per_class_recall": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "noul": { "accuracy": 0.8125, "balanced_accuracy": 0.8676470588235294, "auroc": 0.9803046218487395, "auprc": 0.9910196723104415, "brier": 0.14399152528197112, "nll": 0.4301690068230142, "ece_raw": 0.027843129969293463, "ece_fitted": 0.02698340407756053 }, "score": { "mae": null, "rmse": null, "nearest_level_accuracy": null, "within_one_accuracy": null, "raw_equality_rate": null, "spearman": null, "ordinal_confusion": null } }, "correct": 78 }, "moderation": { "accuracy": 0.9166666666666666, "cases": 48, "decisions": 144, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.03827599806249301, "p50_seconds": 0.037934129999939614, "p95_seconds": 0.041699429449965915 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": null, "macro_f1": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "per_class_recall": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "noul": { "accuracy": 0.9166666666666666, "balanced_accuracy": 0.9106227106227107, "auroc": 0.978021978021978, "auprc": 0.944990138816365, "brier": 0.06164195701639249, "nll": 0.21176174396122044, "ece_raw": 0.014191582921902587, "ece_fitted": 0.01169790659953756 }, "score": { "mae": null, "rmse": null, "nearest_level_accuracy": null, "within_one_accuracy": null, "raw_equality_rate": null, "spearman": null, "ordinal_confusion": null } }, "correct": 132 }, "agnews": { "accuracy": 0.8125, "cases": 160, "decisions": 160, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.038758980293738435, "p50_seconds": 0.0382035000001224, "p95_seconds": 0.042714876549950986 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": 0.8125, "macro_f1": 0.8064558008777994, "balanced_accuracy": 0.8125, "per_class_recall": { "business": 0.85, "scitech": 0.55, "sports": 0.975, "world": 0.875 }, "brier": 0.2965232296874367, "nll": 0.5908707062914559, "ece_raw": 0.004136447508252946, "ece_fitted": 0.007738817845546403 }, "noul": { "accuracy": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "auroc": null, "auprc": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "score": { "mae": null, "rmse": null, "nearest_level_accuracy": null, "within_one_accuracy": null, "raw_equality_rate": null, "spearman": null, "ordinal_confusion": null } }, "correct": 130 }, "emotion": { "accuracy": 0.7239583333333334, "cases": 192, "decisions": 192, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.038396373302075425, "p50_seconds": 0.03797906949989738, "p95_seconds": 0.0415361116498957 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": 0.7239583333333334, "macro_f1": 0.6913006811212603, "balanced_accuracy": 0.6854851048438465, "per_class_recall": { "anger": 0.5714285714285714, "fear": 0.9259259259259259, "joy": 0.7142857142857143, "love": 0.6, "sadness": 0.8275862068965517, "surprise": 0.47368421052631576 }, "brier": 0.39805364003393406, "nll": 0.7908805977682863, "ece_raw": 0.004164112978894893, "ece_fitted": 0.0034169522756447193 }, "noul": { "accuracy": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "auroc": null, "auprc": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "score": { "mae": null, "rmse": null, "nearest_level_accuracy": null, "within_one_accuracy": null, "raw_equality_rate": null, "spearman": null, "ordinal_confusion": null } }, "correct": 139 }, "banking77_12": { "accuracy": 0.8, "cases": 95, "decisions": 95, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.03918948851578773, "p50_seconds": 0.03858194800000092, "p95_seconds": 0.04271281379994889 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": 0.8, "macro_f1": 0.7934147932677345, "balanced_accuracy": 0.8020833333333334, "per_class_recall": { "card_arrival": 0.625, "card_linking": 0.25, "exchange_rate": 1.0, "lost_or_stolen_card": 1.0, "order_physical_card": 0.875, "pin_blocked": 0.875, "refund_not_showing_up": 0.875, "request_refund": 0.875, "terminate_account": 1.0, "top_up_failed": 0.875, "topping_up_by_card": 0.5, "transaction_charged_twice": 0.875 }, "brier": 0.2871215913829621, "nll": 0.7332560464140869, "ece_raw": 0.014809638592014682, "ece_fitted": 0.01673412400480368 }, "noul": { "accuracy": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "auroc": null, "auprc": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "score": { "mae": null, "rmse": null, "nearest_level_accuracy": null, "within_one_accuracy": null, "raw_equality_rate": null, "spearman": null, "ordinal_confusion": null } }, "correct": 76 }, "mnli": { "accuracy": 0.5416666666666666, "cases": 120, "decisions": 120, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.0384311384083181, "p50_seconds": 0.03797633499982567, "p95_seconds": 0.04150163254993231 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": 0.5416666666666666, "macro_f1": 0.531705418323941, "balanced_accuracy": 0.5416666666666666, "per_class_recall": { "contradiction": 0.575, "entailment": 0.725, "neutral": 0.325 }, "brier": 0.5534738375592544, "nll": 0.9317788432632266, "ece_raw": 0.005991485962656614, "ece_fitted": 0.008360924461080638 }, "noul": { "accuracy": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "auroc": null, "auprc": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "score": { "mae": null, "rmse": null, "nearest_level_accuracy": null, "within_one_accuracy": null, "raw_equality_rate": null, "spearman": null, "ordinal_confusion": null } }, "correct": 65 }, "sst5": { "accuracy": 0.3333333333333333, "cases": 120, "decisions": 120, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.038905105700003634, "p50_seconds": 0.03851513350002733, "p95_seconds": 0.041932194849789536 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": null, "macro_f1": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "per_class_recall": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "noul": { "accuracy": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "auroc": null, "auprc": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "score": { "mae": 0.8023576299349467, "rmse": 0.9908613116687078, "nearest_level_accuracy": 0.3333333333333333, "within_one_accuracy": 0.875, "raw_equality_rate": 0.0, "spearman": 0.7382746269028682, "ordinal_confusion": { "labels": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "matrix": [ [ 0, 19, 4, 1, 0 ], [ 2, 10, 12, 0, 0 ], [ 0, 6, 17, 1, 0 ], [ 0, 1, 11, 12, 0 ], [ 0, 1, 8, 14, 1 ] ] } } }, "correct": 40 }, "multilingual_intent": { "accuracy": 0.95, "cases": 120, "decisions": 120, "latency": { "mean_seconds": 0.039158464716655315, "p50_seconds": 0.03864724799996111, "p95_seconds": 0.04240460730002269 }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": 0.95, "macro_f1": 0.8159019343229869, "balanced_accuracy": 0.9650000000000001, "per_class_recall": { "billing_question": 0.95, "cancellation": 1.0, "information": 0.875, "other": null, "refund": 1.0, "technical_help": 1.0 }, "brier": 0.13506004724959844, "nll": 0.2766243432861846, "ece_raw": 0.01098334737043859, "ece_fitted": 0.007150088729354088 }, "noul": { "accuracy": null, "balanced_accuracy": null, "auroc": null, "auprc": null, "brier": null, "nll": null, "ece_raw": null, "ece_fitted": null }, "score": { "mae": null, "rmse": null, "nearest_level_accuracy": null, "within_one_accuracy": null, "raw_equality_rate": null, "spearman": null, "ordinal_confusion": null } }, "correct": 114 } }, "primitive_metrics": { "choice": { "accuracy": 0.7687074829931972, "macro_f1": 0.7485002410383995, "balanced_accuracy": 0.7745682853365854, "per_class_recall": { "anger": 0.5714285714285714, "billing_question": 0.7241379310344828, "business": 0.85, "cancellation": 1.0, "card_arrival": 0.625, "card_linking": 0.25, "contradiction": 0.575, "entailment": 0.725, "exchange_rate": 1.0, "fear": 0.9259259259259259, "information": 0.9, "joy": 0.7142857142857143, "lost_or_stolen_card": 1.0, "love": 0.6, "neutral": 0.325, "order_physical_card": 0.875, "other": null, "pin_blocked": 0.875, "refund": 1.0, "refund_not_showing_up": 0.875, "request_refund": 0.875, "sadness": 0.8275862068965517, "scitech": 0.55, "sports": 0.975, "surprise": 0.47368421052631576, "technical_help": 1.0, "terminate_account": 1.0, "top_up_failed": 0.875, "topping_up_by_card": 0.5, "transaction_charged_twice": 0.875, "world": 0.875 }, "brier": 0.3273568910489642, "nll": 0.6456585110094694, "ece_raw": 0.0007584697829628141, "ece_fitted": 0.0004599471426753296 }, "noul": { "accuracy": 0.9036458333333334, "balanced_accuracy": 0.8834257029277777, "auroc": 0.972492238052404, "auprc": 0.950340531508563, "brier": 0.07873134721324142, "nll": 0.26435858535171963, "ece_raw": 0.004409246207057182, "ece_fitted": 0.004915585951212646 }, "score": { "mae": 0.8023576299349467, "rmse": 0.9908613116687078, "nearest_level_accuracy": 0.3333333333333333, "within_one_accuracy": 0.875, "raw_equality_rate": 0.0, "spearman": 0.7382746269028682, "ordinal_confusion": { "labels": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "matrix": [ [ 0, 19, 4, 1, 0 ], [ 2, 10, 12, 0, 0 ], [ 0, 6, 17, 1, 0 ], [ 0, 1, 11, 12, 0 ], [ 0, 1, 8, 14, 1 ] ] } } } } }, "score_rule": "Expected level index passed as scalar score; official floor(score+0.5) correctness, not modal-level accuracy", "label_note": "Original v2 labels were single-review AI-assisted. Corrected v2.1.0 adopts source labels for AGNews, Banking77, MNLI and SST5 and a reviewed emotion decision set. No independent double-review claim is made.", "official_submission": false }, "protocol_and_overlap_notes": "See README.md. The metrics have different denominators and definitions." }