{ "what": "Manchego v3's release read: v3, Manchego v2.1 and the untrained Qwen3.5-4B scored in one runtime (bf16, one RTX 5090, padded batches of up to 8,192 tokens, the adapters applied to the base unmerged) on identical rows; aggregates only. JevBench numbers here are OUR runs on its 231 public decisions, not official JevBench scores.", "names": { "frozen (served)": "untrained Qwen3.5-4B under Manchego v2.1's served prompt policy (short prompt up to 26 options, state-first beyond)", "frozen (SemIf)": "untrained Qwen3.5-4B under the SemIf prompt (state-first beyond 16 options)", "Manchego v2.1 (served)": "Manchego v2.1 under its served prompt policy", "v3m100b (SemIf)": "Manchego v3 (its adapter on the base, bf16) under the SemIf prompt (state-first beyond 16 options)" }, "runtime_check_passed": true, "runtime_check": "v2.1 and the untrained base reproduced their archived records on the three card suites (tolerance |accuracy| <= 0.01, |cross-entropy| <= 0.02)", "intervals": "paired 95% percentile bootstraps; the resampling unit is named per suite ('interval')", "card": { "jevbench_public": { "rows": 231, "interval": "scenario groups resampled", "systems": { "frozen (served)": { "n": 231, "accuracy": 0.7748917748917749, "cross_entropy": 0.49286616487181245, "brier": 0.2866513305940945, "ece": 0.06231002798067052, "mean_confidence": 0.8204758784756144, "refused": 0 }, "frozen (SemIf)": { "n": 231, "accuracy": 0.8008658008658008, "cross_entropy": 0.4852084330739462, "brier": 0.25419321047505944, "ece": 0.0588310701620669, "mean_confidence": 0.8366482323997403, "refused": 0 }, "Manchego v2.1 (served)": { "n": 231, "accuracy": 0.8051948051948052, "cross_entropy": 0.4232890730630488, "brier": 0.24566343385005784, "ece": 0.07188272887054453, "mean_confidence": 0.8538814495170696, "refused": 0 }, "v3m100b (SemIf)": { "n": 231, "accuracy": 0.8571428571428571, "cross_entropy": 0.3260731101395454, "brier": 0.18328252671634565, "ece": 0.05534072233865077, "mean_confidence": 0.8536973872249488, "refused": 0 } }, "v3_minus_v21": { "accuracy": { "mean": 0.05194805194805195, "ci95": [ 0.004201680672268907, 0.10222222222222223 ] }, "cross_entropy": { "mean": -0.09721596292350353, "ci95": [ -0.17117279532265608, -0.03245969447592095 ] } }, "v3_minus_frozen_served": { "accuracy": { "mean": 0.08225108225108226, "ci95": [ 0.021645021645021644, 0.14347826086956522 ] }, "cross_entropy": { "mean": -0.16679305473226716, "ci95": [ -0.2671700196376057, -0.07280825498368075 ] } } }, "public8": { "rows": 1600, "interval": "items resampled within dataset", "systems": { "frozen (served)": { "n": 1600, "accuracy": 0.68625, "cross_entropy": 0.8430894766320378, "brier": 0.42806658962520244, "ece": 0.12246943241697027, "mean_confidence": 0.8087194324169702, "refused": 0 }, "frozen (SemIf)": { "n": 1600, "accuracy": 0.725, "cross_entropy": 0.8471491321273774, "brier": 0.3999620136837791, "ece": 0.12153813578564186, "mean_confidence": 0.8439632063936646, "refused": 0 }, "Manchego v2.1 (served)": { "n": 1600, "accuracy": 0.731875, "cross_entropy": 0.6837753863639332, "brier": 0.3671370658953875, "ece": 0.05316138522715013, "mean_confidence": 0.7847182733650019, "refused": 0 }, "v3m100b (SemIf)": { "n": 1600, "accuracy": 0.753125, "cross_entropy": 0.6085345175694903, "brier": 0.3268992227572392, "ece": 0.05543283372305037, "mean_confidence": 0.8085578337230505, "refused": 0 } }, "v3_minus_v21": { "accuracy": { "mean": 0.02125, "ci95": [ 0.001875, 0.039375 ] }, "cross_entropy": { "mean": -0.07524086879444299, "ci95": [ -0.10700733270210035, -0.04398069430837902 ] } }, "v3_minus_frozen_served": { "accuracy": { "mean": 0.066875, "ci95": [ 0.04625, 0.08625 ] }, "cross_entropy": { "mean": -0.23455495906254767, "ci95": [ -0.27699129955904445, -0.19314965712030813 ] } } }, "transfer": { "rows": 1561, "interval": "the 27 source-clean tasks (v2.1 card), tasks resampled", "systems": { "frozen (served)": { "n": 1561, "accuracy": 0.6777706598334401, "cross_entropy": 0.9189782184185465, "brier": 0.43554421632973334, "ece": 0.10705508985338476, "mean_confidence": 0.7840551579972183, "refused": 0 }, "frozen (SemIf)": { "n": 1561, "accuracy": 0.6777706598334401, "cross_entropy": 1.055959778577908, "brier": 0.46561897696066334, "ece": 0.11924407258759004, "mean_confidence": 0.7967923988846295, "refused": 0 }, "Manchego v2.1 (served)": { "n": 1561, "accuracy": 0.7014734144778988, "cross_entropy": 0.9285998666239199, "brier": 0.42428692850163635, "ece": 0.08289752004742494, "mean_confidence": 0.7837359571214004, "refused": 0 }, "v3m100b (SemIf)": { "n": 1561, "accuracy": 0.7085201793721974, "cross_entropy": 0.9408154991498171, "brier": 0.4318082093390665, "ece": 0.12920627298362403, "mean_confidence": 0.8292848345361473, "refused": 0 } }, "v3_minus_v21": { "accuracy": { "mean": 0.007046764894298526, "ci95": [ -0.01585288522511097, 0.03132992327365729 ] }, "cross_entropy": { "mean": 0.012215632525897134, "ci95": [ -0.20211863222827312, 0.15664732848488094 ] } }, "v3_minus_frozen_served": { "accuracy": { "mean": 0.03074951953875721, "ci95": [ 0.0019157088122605363, 0.06482670089858793 ] }, "cross_entropy": { "mean": 0.02183728073127055, "ci95": [ -0.08835037289694243, 0.15047515066869643 ] } } } }, "sealed": { "confirm_b": { "what": "24 Natural Instructions tasks from 13 source clusters no Manchego model trained on, read once; the contrast is the mean over tasks of the per-task accuracy difference, source clusters resampled; 'systems' are pooled over rows", "claim": { "v3_minus_v21": { "tasks": 24, "clusters": 13, "rows": 5397, "accuracy": { "mean": 0.04227827381234498, "ci95": [ -0.017932316870179994, 0.1068637823646576 ] }, "cross_entropy": { "mean": 0.0024332706544883936, "ci95": [ -0.10795744285557755, 0.1274440740433659 ] } }, "v3_minus_frozen_served": { "tasks": 24, "clusters": 13, "rows": 5397, "accuracy": { "mean": 0.05955055602143098, "ci95": [ -0.019663513011422513, 0.14306252573617587 ] }, "cross_entropy": { "mean": -0.055827519937997915, "ci95": [ -0.15976968646042974, 0.07125067495963548 ] } }, "systems": { "frozen (served)": { "n": 5397, "accuracy": 0.6409116175653141, "cross_entropy": 0.9178368709979563, "brier": 0.48264586072708016, "ece": 0.15134806828254388, "mean_confidence": 0.7922596858478579, "refused": 0 }, "frozen (SemIf)": { "n": 5397, "accuracy": 0.6740781915879193, "cross_entropy": 0.9107246561067318, "brier": 0.46026264250869503, "ece": 0.1475488337401401, "mean_confidence": 0.8213640799547319, "refused": 0 }, "Manchego v2.1 (served)": { "n": 5397, "accuracy": 0.6588845654993515, "cross_entropy": 0.8486214459422593, "brier": 0.46015495267198037, "ece": 0.09823534911045727, "mean_confidence": 0.7571199146098088, "refused": 0 }, "v3m100b (SemIf)": { "n": 5397, "accuracy": 0.6950157494904576, "cross_entropy": 0.8607399041168844, "brier": 0.44547195424681324, "ece": 0.14094955334255857, "mean_confidence": 0.8359653028330162, "refused": 0 } } } }, "rep_sealed": { "what": "fresh out-of-distribution draws of four of the project's own computed families (policy decisions, lookup chains, temporal, answer adequacy), 400 instances, read once; instances resampled", "rows": 1193, "instances": 400, "systems": { "frozen (served)": { "n": 1193, "accuracy": 0.4450963956412406, "cross_entropy": 1.1611160039257353, "brier": 0.6460967922428869, "ece": 0.1405380034173992, "mean_confidence": 0.583342473485591, "refused": 0 }, "frozen (SemIf)": { "n": 1193, "accuracy": 0.5079631181894384, "cross_entropy": 1.0912352055652879, "brier": 0.5978876795541787, "ece": 0.07519011377082045, "mean_confidence": 0.5831532319602589, "refused": 0 }, "Manchego v2.1 (served)": { "n": 1193, "accuracy": 0.7946353730092205, "cross_entropy": 0.4659314334385817, "brier": 0.2733922531947281, "ece": 0.051271641242572615, "mean_confidence": 0.8437516230506135, "refused": 0 }, "v3m100b (SemIf)": { "n": 1193, "accuracy": 0.7619446772841576, "cross_entropy": 0.5777628650382641, "brier": 0.3190441194412629, "ece": 0.0495448301892173, "mean_confidence": 0.8004757787551626, "refused": 0 } }, "v3_minus_v21": { "accuracy": { "mean": -0.03269069572506287, "ci95": [ -0.060085836909871244, -0.005106382978723404 ] }, "cross_entropy": { "mean": 0.11183143159968244, "ci95": [ 0.04482470675698149, 0.18231048096005373 ] } }, "v3_minus_frozen_served": { "accuracy": { "mean": 0.316848281642917, "ci95": [ 0.2802013422818792, 0.35313807531380753 ] }, "cross_entropy": { "mean": -0.5833531388874713, "ci95": [ -0.6449727284665607, -0.519783716913897 ] } } } }, "flags": { "runtime_check_passed": true, "jevbench_v3_below_v21_point": false, "resolved_below_v21": [ "rep_sealed" ] } }