{ "calibration": { "a": 0.32936498522758484, "b": 0.13781841099262238, "accept_token": 10330, "escalate_token": 81082 }, "verifier": { "val": { "all": { "n": 1480, "answers_wrong": 0.1757, "auroc": 0.8839, "false_accept_rate": 0.4231, "false_escalate_rate": 0.0131, "ece": 0.0173, "brier": 0.0723 }, "uncalibrated_ece": 0.0724, "glm-5.3-flash": { "n": 740, "answers_wrong": 0.123, "auroc": 0.8637, "false_accept_rate": 0.5604, "false_escalate_rate": 0.0046, "ece": 0.0223, "brier": 0.0629 }, "kimi-vl": { "n": 370, "answers_wrong": 0.3243, "auroc": 0.9005, "false_accept_rate": 0.2583, "false_escalate_rate": 0.04, "ece": 0.0632, "brier": 0.0928 }, "qwen3.8-27b": { "n": 370, "answers_wrong": 0.1324, "auroc": 0.8666, "false_accept_rate": 0.5714, "false_escalate_rate": 0.0093, "ece": 0.0299, "brier": 0.0704 }, "source:aqua": { "n": 212, "answers_wrong": 0.184, "auroc": 0.8519, "false_accept_rate": 0.4359, "false_escalate_rate": 0.0058, "ece": 0.0353, "brier": 0.0735 }, "source:arc": { "n": 160, "answers_wrong": 0.0625, "auroc": 0.742, "false_accept_rate": 1.0, "false_escalate_rate": 0.0067, "ece": 0.0419, "brier": 0.0556 }, "source:csqa": { "n": 116, "answers_wrong": 0.25, "auroc": 0.4935, "false_accept_rate": 0.931, "false_escalate_rate": 0.023, "ece": 0.1432, "brier": 0.203 }, "source:gsm8k": { "n": 264, "answers_wrong": 0.0417, "auroc": 0.9677, "false_accept_rate": 0.2727, "false_escalate_rate": 0.004, "ece": 0.0499, "brier": 0.0147 }, "source:humaneval": { "n": 36, "answers_wrong": 0.0278, "auroc": 1.0, "false_accept_rate": 0.0, "false_escalate_rate": 0.0, "ece": 0.0512, "brier": 0.0055 }, "source:math": { "n": 248, "answers_wrong": 0.3024, "auroc": 0.9272, "false_accept_rate": 0.1467, "false_escalate_rate": 0.0173, "ece": 0.0534, "brier": 0.0539 }, "source:mbpp": { "n": 168, "answers_wrong": 0.131, "auroc": 0.9692, "false_accept_rate": 0.2273, "false_escalate_rate": 0.0274, "ece": 0.0483, "brier": 0.0449 }, "source:mmlu_pro": { "n": 276, "answers_wrong": 0.2645, "auroc": 0.8385, "false_accept_rate": 0.5068, "false_escalate_rate": 0.0197, "ece": 0.0517, "brier": 0.1229 }, "reliability": [ { "bin": "0.0-0.1", "n": 104, "confidence": 0.029, "accuracy": 0.0 }, { "bin": "0.1-0.2", "n": 20, "confidence": 0.13, "accuracy": 0.1 }, { "bin": "0.2-0.3", "n": 17, "confidence": 0.263, "accuracy": 0.176 }, { "bin": "0.3-0.4", "n": 11, "confidence": 0.355, "accuracy": 0.273 }, { "bin": "0.4-0.5", "n": 14, "confidence": 0.464, "accuracy": 0.571 }, { "bin": "0.5-0.6", "n": 23, "confidence": 0.563, "accuracy": 0.696 }, { "bin": "0.6-0.7", "n": 36, "confidence": 0.66, "accuracy": 0.778 }, { "bin": "0.7-0.8", "n": 84, "confidence": 0.762, "accuracy": 0.81 }, { "bin": "0.8-0.9", "n": 252, "confidence": 0.858, "accuracy": 0.857 }, { "bin": "0.9-1.0", "n": 919, "confidence": 0.96, "accuracy": 0.953 } ] }, "test": { "all": { "n": 2532, "answers_wrong": 0.1761, "auroc": 0.9195, "false_accept_rate": 0.3587, "false_escalate_rate": 0.0187, "ece": 0.017, "brier": 0.0631 }, "uncalibrated_ece": 0.0614, "glm-5.3-flash": { "n": 1266, "answers_wrong": 0.1177, "auroc": 0.9102, "false_accept_rate": 0.4161, "false_escalate_rate": 0.0063, "ece": 0.0106, "brier": 0.0458 }, "kimi-vl": { "n": 633, "answers_wrong": 0.346, "auroc": 0.896, "false_accept_rate": 0.2694, "false_escalate_rate": 0.0507, "ece": 0.0418, "brier": 0.1013 }, "qwen3.8-27b": { "n": 633, "answers_wrong": 0.1232, "auroc": 0.9152, "false_accept_rate": 0.5, "false_escalate_rate": 0.0198, "ece": 0.0248, "brier": 0.0595 }, "source:aqua": { "n": 316, "answers_wrong": 0.1677, "auroc": 0.8961, "false_accept_rate": 0.3019, "false_escalate_rate": 0.0304, "ece": 0.0288, "brier": 0.0627 }, "source:arc": { "n": 300, "answers_wrong": 0.04, "auroc": 0.8423, "false_accept_rate": 0.9167, "false_escalate_rate": 0.0069, "ece": 0.0286, "brier": 0.0392 }, "source:csqa": { "n": 252, "answers_wrong": 0.1825, "auroc": 0.5933, "false_accept_rate": 0.8913, "false_escalate_rate": 0.0583, "ece": 0.087, "brier": 0.1548 }, "source:gsm8k": { "n": 420, "answers_wrong": 0.0619, "auroc": 0.8544, "false_accept_rate": 0.5385, "false_escalate_rate": 0.0025, "ece": 0.0175, "brier": 0.0335 }, "source:humaneval": { "n": 72, "answers_wrong": 0.0972, "auroc": 0.9912, "false_accept_rate": 0.1429, "false_escalate_rate": 0.0, "ece": 0.0366, "brier": 0.0148 }, "source:math": { "n": 424, "answers_wrong": 0.3184, "auroc": 0.9625, "false_accept_rate": 0.1407, "false_escalate_rate": 0.0035, "ece": 0.033, "brier": 0.0427 }, "source:mbpp": { "n": 268, "answers_wrong": 0.097, "auroc": 0.9545, "false_accept_rate": 0.3846, "false_escalate_rate": 0.0124, "ece": 0.041, "brier": 0.0411 }, "source:mmlu_pro": { "n": 480, "answers_wrong": 0.2937, "auroc": 0.9275, "false_accept_rate": 0.3404, "false_escalate_rate": 0.0354, "ece": 0.0448, "brier": 0.0935 }, "reliability": [ { "bin": "0.0-0.1", "n": 204, "confidence": 0.03, "accuracy": 0.005 }, { "bin": "0.1-0.2", "n": 32, "confidence": 0.143, "accuracy": 0.156 }, { "bin": "0.2-0.3", "n": 40, "confidence": 0.248, "accuracy": 0.175 }, { "bin": "0.3-0.4", "n": 23, "confidence": 0.359, "accuracy": 0.478 }, { "bin": "0.4-0.5", "n": 26, "confidence": 0.454, "accuracy": 0.577 }, { "bin": "0.5-0.6", "n": 33, "confidence": 0.553, "accuracy": 0.636 }, { "bin": "0.6-0.7", "n": 71, "confidence": 0.657, "accuracy": 0.746 }, { "bin": "0.7-0.8", "n": 153, "confidence": 0.758, "accuracy": 0.771 }, { "bin": "0.8-0.9", "n": 360, "confidence": 0.86, "accuracy": 0.878 }, { "bin": "0.9-1.0", "n": 1590, "confidence": 0.961, "accuracy": 0.968 } ] }, "ood": { "all": { "n": 3240, "answers_wrong": 0.1877, "auroc": 0.72, "false_accept_rate": 0.7023, "false_escalate_rate": 0.0672, "ece": 0.0602, "brier": 0.1398 }, "uncalibrated_ece": 0.1358, "glm-5.3-flash": { "n": 1620, "answers_wrong": 0.0963, "auroc": 0.6469, "false_accept_rate": 0.9487, "false_escalate_rate": 0.0342, "ece": 0.0679, "brier": 0.1001 }, "kimi-vl": { "n": 810, "answers_wrong": 0.4642, "auroc": 0.6174, "false_accept_rate": 0.5851, "false_escalate_rate": 0.1797, "ece": 0.119, "brier": 0.2476 }, "qwen3.8-27b": { "n": 810, "answers_wrong": 0.0938, "auroc": 0.6742, "false_accept_rate": 0.7763, "false_escalate_rate": 0.0668, "ece": 0.1386, "brier": 0.1115 }, "source:bbh": { "n": 3240, "answers_wrong": 0.1877, "auroc": 0.72, "false_accept_rate": 0.7023, "false_escalate_rate": 0.0672, "ece": 0.0602, "brier": 0.1398 }, "reliability": [ { "bin": "0.0-0.1", "n": 30, "confidence": 0.066, "accuracy": 0.033 }, { "bin": "0.1-0.2", "n": 56, "confidence": 0.149, "accuracy": 0.125 }, { "bin": "0.2-0.3", "n": 73, "confidence": 0.254, "accuracy": 0.589 }, { "bin": "0.3-0.4", "n": 82, "confidence": 0.357, "accuracy": 0.598 }, { "bin": "0.4-0.5", "n": 117, "confidence": 0.449, "accuracy": 0.658 }, { "bin": "0.5-0.6", "n": 199, "confidence": 0.553, "accuracy": 0.734 }, { "bin": "0.6-0.7", "n": 375, "confidence": 0.654, "accuracy": 0.773 }, { "bin": "0.7-0.8", "n": 525, "confidence": 0.755, "accuracy": 0.794 }, { "bin": "0.8-0.9", "n": 906, "confidence": 0.854, "accuracy": 0.87 }, { "bin": "0.9-1.0", "n": 877, "confidence": 0.939, "accuracy": 0.928 } ] } }, "ladder": [ "glm-5.3-flash", "qwen3.8-27b", "nemotron-ultra" ], "n_ladder_tasks": 491, "policies": { "always:glm-5.3-flash": { "accuracy": 0.888, "relative_cost": 0.1146, "silent_failure_rate": 0.0, "calls_per_task": 1.0, "extra_agent_latency_s": 0.0 }, "always:qwen3.8-27b": { "accuracy": 0.8737, "relative_cost": 0.4208, "silent_failure_rate": 0.0, "calls_per_task": 1.0, "extra_agent_latency_s": 0.0 }, "always:nemotron-ultra": { "accuracy": 0.8473, "relative_cost": 1.0, "silent_failure_rate": 0.0, "calls_per_task": 1.0, "extra_agent_latency_s": 0.0 }, "ladder:format-check": { "accuracy": 0.8982, "relative_cost": 0.4058, "silent_failure_rate": 0.0733, "calls_per_task": 1.073, "extra_agent_latency_s": 10.95 }, "ladder:self-consistency": { "accuracy": 0.9043, "relative_cost": 0.5535, "silent_failure_rate": 0.0652, "calls_per_task": 1.141, "extra_agent_latency_s": 15.29 }, "ladder:oracle": { "accuracy": 0.9328, "relative_cost": 0.473, "silent_failure_rate": 0.0, "calls_per_task": 1.185, "extra_agent_latency_s": 15.89 }, "shaktimaan-v1.0": { "accuracy": 0.8493, "relative_cost": 0.3226 } }, "jedi_curve": [ { "threshold": 0.05, "accuracy": 0.9104, "relative_cost": 0.2441, "silent_failure_rate": 0.0754, "calls_per_task": 1.086, "extra_agent_latency_s": 8.94 }, { "threshold": 0.1, "accuracy": 0.9145, "relative_cost": 0.2634, "silent_failure_rate": 0.0652, "calls_per_task": 1.096, "extra_agent_latency_s": 9.49 }, { "threshold": 0.2, "accuracy": 0.9124, "relative_cost": 0.2746, "silent_failure_rate": 0.0652, "calls_per_task": 1.098, "extra_agent_latency_s": 9.69 }, { "threshold": 0.3, "accuracy": 0.9145, "relative_cost": 0.3229, "silent_failure_rate": 0.055, "calls_per_task": 1.108, "extra_agent_latency_s": 10.73 }, { "threshold": 0.4, "accuracy": 0.9145, "relative_cost": 0.3551, "silent_failure_rate": 0.0509, "calls_per_task": 1.114, "extra_agent_latency_s": 11.42 }, { "threshold": 0.5, "accuracy": 0.9165, "relative_cost": 0.3865, "silent_failure_rate": 0.0448, "calls_per_task": 1.122, "extra_agent_latency_s": 12.08 }, { "threshold": 0.6, "accuracy": 0.9165, "relative_cost": 0.4313, "silent_failure_rate": 0.0387, "calls_per_task": 1.13, "extra_agent_latency_s": 13.14 }, { "threshold": 0.7, "accuracy": 0.9185, "relative_cost": 0.4538, "silent_failure_rate": 0.0285, "calls_per_task": 1.147, "extra_agent_latency_s": 14.32 }, { "threshold": 0.8, "accuracy": 0.9104, "relative_cost": 0.5055, "silent_failure_rate": 0.0285, "calls_per_task": 1.196, "extra_agent_latency_s": 16.37 }, { "threshold": 0.85, "accuracy": 0.9084, "relative_cost": 0.5408, "silent_failure_rate": 0.0224, "calls_per_task": 1.238, "extra_agent_latency_s": 17.9 }, { "threshold": 0.9, "accuracy": 0.9022, "relative_cost": 0.6093, "silent_failure_rate": 0.0163, "calls_per_task": 1.316, "extra_agent_latency_s": 20.84 }, { "threshold": 0.95, "accuracy": 0.8697, "relative_cost": 0.8913, "silent_failure_rate": 0.0143, "calls_per_task": 1.654, "extra_agent_latency_s": 34.46 }, { "threshold": 0.98, "accuracy": 0.8615, "relative_cost": 1.2413, "silent_failure_rate": 0.0, "calls_per_task": 2.393, "extra_agent_latency_s": 55.17 } ], "two_rung": { "new-domains (aqua, csqa)": { "n_tasks": 142, "always:glm-5.3-flash": { "accuracy": 0.8521, "cost_vs_always_mid": 0.2999, "silent_failure_rate": 0.0 }, "always:qwen3.8-27b": { "accuracy": 0.8873, "cost_vs_always_mid": 1.0, "silent_failure_rate": 0.0 }, "oracle": { "accuracy": 0.9225, "cost_vs_always_mid": 0.7111, "silent_failure_rate": 0.0 }, "self-consistency": { "accuracy": 0.8873, "cost_vs_always_mid": 1.0475, "silent_failure_rate": 0.0704 }, "jedi@0.5": { "accuracy": 0.8873, "cost_vs_always_mid": 0.6761, "silent_failure_rate": 0.0845 }, "jedi@0.7": { "accuracy": 0.8732, "cost_vs_always_mid": 0.7191, "silent_failure_rate": 0.0845 }, "jedi@0.9": { "accuracy": 0.8873, "cost_vs_always_mid": 0.8953, "silent_failure_rate": 0.0493 } }, "ood: bbh": { "n_tasks": 810, "always:glm-5.3-flash": { "accuracy": 0.9012, "cost_vs_always_mid": 0.1436, "silent_failure_rate": 0.0 }, "always:qwen3.8-27b": { "accuracy": 0.9062, "cost_vs_always_mid": 1.0, "silent_failure_rate": 0.0 }, "oracle": { "accuracy": 0.9457, "cost_vs_always_mid": 0.3743, "silent_failure_rate": 0.0 }, "self-consistency": { "accuracy": 0.9136, "cost_vs_always_mid": 0.5322, "silent_failure_rate": 0.0605 }, "jedi@0.5": { "accuracy": 0.9049, "cost_vs_always_mid": 0.178, "silent_failure_rate": 0.0938 }, "jedi@0.7": { "accuracy": 0.9111, "cost_vs_always_mid": 0.2665, "silent_failure_rate": 0.0778 }, "jedi@0.9": { "accuracy": 0.9198, "cost_vs_always_mid": 0.6854, "silent_failure_rate": 0.0222 } } }, "overhead": { "jedi_ms_per_check_batch1": 55.6, "jedi_input_tokens_mean": 451, "jedi_output_tokens": 1 } }