diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n64_full_sparse_exponential.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n64_full_sparse_exponential.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..eb7b7a8dbe6125fded0d14f68d65678c03075397 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n64_full_sparse_exponential.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:ef31f494c009afe5b565babf8b70494f9c4bfb4453bef0faf649ad816a147806 +size 61205 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n64_full_sparse_exponential_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n64_full_sparse_exponential_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..32bda98837e6b029754f49bbb1bc4fb092897cf8 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n64_full_sparse_exponential_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +{ + "material": "double_inclusion", + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_sparse_exponential", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 4096, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.0021880619460716844, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 10.803734301938675, + "receiver_output": 0.01978006004355848 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.002346583059988916, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 10.817645939067006, + "receiver_output": 0.020585908787325025 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0022835759446024895, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 10.80961736291647, + "receiver_output": 0.01967177796177566 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.0022835759446024895, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 10.80961736291647, + "receiver_output": 0.01978006004355848, + "total_seconds": 10.831572716822848, + "minimum_total_seconds": 10.825702423928306, + "maximum_total_seconds": 10.84057843091432 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "energy_relative_drift": 1.021405182655144e-14 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562013.9848735, + 1792562046.494778 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..256a14933e0b02afd250d3c581a3302967c53043 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:fa30e600def583ca72aafd9ab5e1b64b58fd497e181ad70812a07ac7fc927c76 +size 61209 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0e8b1349d67aafa45ec02bfba65b92184b0d2b5c --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +{ + "material": "double_inclusion", + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.125, + "dimension": 4096, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.0026569580659270287, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 0.5925028607016429, + "receiver_output": 0.009847117704339325 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0028651789762079716, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 0.5951083439867944, + "receiver_output": 0.009683424490503967 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0029598460532724857, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 0.5840246316511184, + "receiver_output": 0.010088339680805802 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.0028651789762079716, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 0.5925028607016429, + "receiver_output": 0.009847117704339325, + "total_seconds": 0.6050069364719093, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5970728173851967, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.6076569474535063 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "requested_cfl": 0.125, + "actual_cfl": 0.12361454045658996, + "time_step": 0.0009615384615384616, + "substeps_per_output": 13, + "time_steps": 8320, + "sufficient_stability_product": 0.3489019106376078 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562309.0667152, + 1792562310.8772416 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ee13ae10a7f926bc5722ce0ad39149c00c78b8ae --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:7b40efe699340ee246e5f55c02df3810a2cc7699ed55010ef3aed68ee19cff3d +size 61227 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..288721a8140697adc13c844f59532889898864e6 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +{ + "material": "double_inclusion", + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "dimension": 4096, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.0029433039017021656, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 0.31905670021660626, + "receiver_output": 0.009312202222645283 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.002713209018111229, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 0.3101976494072005, + "receiver_output": 0.008664215099997818 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0026580289704725146, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 0.3187872392591089, + "receiver_output": 0.009657941875047982 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.002713209018111229, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 0.3187872392591089, + "receiver_output": 0.009312202222645283, + "total_seconds": 0.3311032101046294, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.32157507352530956, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3313122063409537 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "actual_cfl": 0.22956986084795278, + "time_step": 0.0017857142857142859, + "substeps_per_output": 7, + "time_steps": 4480, + "sufficient_stability_product": 0.6479606911841288 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562308.0793283, + 1792562309.0640876 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n64_rational_krylov_m128.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n64_rational_krylov_m128.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6987127316d78783ca66b8aef95cfefa3a965882 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n64_rational_krylov_m128.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:858c37f2788462b92d76a46c255eee775a4f709e25c5030698269c94c93463ef +size 81621 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n64_rational_krylov_m128_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n64_rational_krylov_m128_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6bbd18ce84fb14d52528b9fed9572bdd0113f084 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n64_rational_krylov_m128_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +{ + "material": "double_inclusion", + "grid": 64, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 320, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.00257952103856951, + "basis": 0.4291838069912046, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.023050539079122245, + "propagation": 0.005006680963560939, + "receiver_output": 0.0009869500063359737 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0028953510336577892, + "basis": 0.43285515101160854, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.02443944406695664, + "propagation": 0.004741205950267613, + "receiver_output": 0.0009505799971520901 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.002732740016654134, + "basis": 0.43661524495109916, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.02490457391832024, + "propagation": 0.005036034970544279, + "receiver_output": 0.0010378320002928376 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.002732740016654134, + "basis": 0.43285515101160854, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.02443944406695664, + "propagation": 0.005006680963560939, + "receiver_output": 0.0009869500063359737, + "total_seconds": 0.4658817320596427, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.4608074980787933, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.47032642585691065 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "iterations": 56, + "distinct_shift_factorizations": 12, + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.3144858834239457e-14, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 7.796110554585733e-16, + "initial_projection_relative_error": 9.023881301842586e-16, + "minimum_eigenvalue_before_clipping": -1.7764411171085234e-14 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562344.6871183, + 1792562346.1204367 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_craig_bampton_m128.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_craig_bampton_m128.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..43ad4ba8e328035885e33e5f8fa4665219a9c036 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_craig_bampton_m128.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:c77158594c6a23bd6be712dbb9dff799eb72cdcf2c12ac195effe8aa5e892bb5 +size 83447 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_craig_bampton_m128_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_craig_bampton_m128_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a21ad305c772664c91717c2d225ae3156b4511f9 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_craig_bampton_m128_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,63 @@ +{ + "material": "double_inclusion", + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 352, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.004416982061229646, + "basis": 0.935168930911459, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.07955915504135191, + "propagation": 0.005856917938217521, + "receiver_output": 0.0011685069184750319 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0044839569600299, + "basis": 0.9232464090455323, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.07712020899634808, + "propagation": 0.005889817955903709, + "receiver_output": 0.001159823965281248 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.004523720010183752, + "basis": 0.9242129219928756, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.078893439960666, + "propagation": 0.005976876011118293, + "receiver_output": 0.001170653966255486 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.0044839569600299, + "basis": 0.9242129219928756, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.078893439960666, + "propagation": 0.005889817955903709, + "receiver_output": 0.0011685069184750319, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.1342521303302872e-14, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 9.041521208018833e-16, + "initial_projection_relative_error": 0.006392631225436432, + "minimum_eigenvalue_before_clipping": 2.7419602637984235e-12 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562346.123793, + 1792562349.2344599 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_craig_bampton_m256.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_craig_bampton_m256.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..09573475452061266e5f098b3ed8652bb83c5e88 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_craig_bampton_m256.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:8518cef7ae85170d19702196bcf84ebe76ffa2e53dc55a2224aa00539910c74d +size 99422 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_craig_bampton_m256_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_craig_bampton_m256_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e5cc3bfb754d6b2083dcc1dd049fa900691e88c9 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_craig_bampton_m256_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,63 @@ +{ + "material": "double_inclusion", + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 256, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 608, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.0044957569334656, + "basis": 2.806831464986317, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.17957529705017805, + "propagation": 0.008841149043291807, + "receiver_output": 0.003394311061128974 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.004561627982184291, + "basis": 2.8835983749013394, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.1745400670915842, + "propagation": 0.009921098011545837, + "receiver_output": 0.003471139003522694 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.004531275015324354, + "basis": 2.854742764029652, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.19403581996448338, + "propagation": 0.009591253008693457, + "receiver_output": 0.003472361946478486 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.004531275015324354, + "basis": 2.854742764029652, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.17957529705017805, + "propagation": 0.009591253008693457, + "receiver_output": 0.003471139003522694, + "total_seconds": 3.0663734739646316, + "minimum_total_seconds": 3.0031379790743813, + "maximum_total_seconds": 3.0760923069901764 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.709788353746316e-14, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 9.143909929934614e-16, + "initial_projection_relative_error": 0.0025643019930644897, + "minimum_eigenvalue_before_clipping": -1.845157678884065e-13 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562353.0292237, + 1792562362.2983701 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_full_chebyshev_bessel.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_full_chebyshev_bessel.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e0d641c2e474b7c7b9ff821fb8baf2017570b7c3 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_full_chebyshev_bessel.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:a1dcc4fc449fcb44a7707ddf322b9c0e52a1f66d7d31d20a6aea220333ac71d9 +size 61237 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_full_chebyshev_bessel_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_full_chebyshev_bessel_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..555b1c6734ec215a491d041cf21ed3a5047b4379 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_full_chebyshev_bessel_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,67 @@ +{ + "material": "double_inclusion", + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_chebyshev_bessel", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 9216, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.004343395004980266, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 3.202674075961113, + "receiver_output": 0.0 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.004033365054056048, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 3.2019667440326884, + "receiver_output": 0.0 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.004465985926799476, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 3.218489926075563, + "receiver_output": 0.0 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.004343395004980266, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 3.202674075961113, + "receiver_output": 0.0, + "total_seconds": 3.2070174709660932, + "minimum_total_seconds": 3.2060001090867445, + "maximum_total_seconds": 3.2229559120023623 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "polynomial_degree": 2279, + "squared_frequency_upper_bound": 296685.82014376944, + "uniform_cosine_tail_bound": 6.473579173286795e-18, + "tail_tolerance": 1e-17, + "setup_seconds": 0.001222429913468659, + "recurrence_and_observation_seconds": 0.455494423978962, + "coefficient_and_output_seconds": 2.7617547790287063, + "total_seconds": 3.218471632921137 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562284.7738998, + 1792562294.4099433 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_full_sparse_exponential.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_full_sparse_exponential.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a84a99dd98177d9e93030d3c20f3a18e42d754ae --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_full_sparse_exponential.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:f1fb0f675a3446b0acd19c41092830d950d6b4e990b636918b5d21d6ce0dbe23 +size 61231 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_full_sparse_exponential_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_full_sparse_exponential_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..76d4b7f495e837ee7c8766cdf4aef3c6cef8b869 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_full_sparse_exponential_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +{ + "material": "double_inclusion", + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_sparse_exponential", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 9216, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.003703178954310715, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 24.840395428123884, + "receiver_output": 0.046580696129240096 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.004183590994216502, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 24.91166813124437, + "receiver_output": 0.04607744386885315 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0040520119946449995, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 24.851099021965638, + "receiver_output": 0.0463468951638788 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.0040520119946449995, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 24.851099021965638, + "receiver_output": 0.0463468951638788, + "total_seconds": 24.90149792912416, + "minimum_total_seconds": 24.890679303207435, + "maximum_total_seconds": 24.96192916610744 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "energy_relative_drift": 1.4099832412739488e-14 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562046.497755, + 1792562121.2786121 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..71ea1b96cf62498de281b3c05f26d46b557df1be --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:5d9bd4024f040c7242de2e254cf81797be19f61c38faf9d2fd12640b7e2ebd7e +size 61211 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5b193403f43afef82bd31bd8add951e7153759d4 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +{ + "material": "double_inclusion", + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.125, + "dimension": 9216, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.004484546952880919, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 2.125659232144244, + "receiver_output": 0.022708069416694343 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.004460877040401101, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 2.1383132679620758, + "receiver_output": 0.021512421779334545 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.004910542047582567, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 2.181802447186783, + "receiver_output": 0.023442118312232196 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.004484546952880919, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 2.1383132679620758, + "receiver_output": 0.022708069416694343, + "total_seconds": 2.1642865667818114, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.1528518485138193, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.2101551075465977 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "requested_cfl": 0.125, + "actual_cfl": 0.12047283252824831, + "time_step": 0.000625, + "substeps_per_output": 20, + "time_steps": 12800, + "sufficient_stability_product": 0.3404304605843296 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562314.2136588, + 1792562320.7421405 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..af0d8b1bd1d357c4e2328ac792afe0c5aee85b08 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:b1af4e90d88f4c577fd93226f16dd0ee071a9eb547df377af4a2c06235cdb834 +size 61207 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..88677635c3cb109db09855414db9bfbedc492379 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +{ + "material": "double_inclusion", + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "dimension": 9216, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.004932345007546246, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 1.0721848610555753, + "receiver_output": 0.0219524959102273 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0048899909015744925, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 1.0916905085323378, + "receiver_output": 0.02161236188840121 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.004509091028012335, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 1.083681556978263, + "receiver_output": 0.02372118621133268 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.0048899909015744925, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 1.083681556978263, + "receiver_output": 0.0219524959102273, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "actual_cfl": 0.24094566505649662, + "time_step": 0.00125, + "substeps_per_output": 10, + "time_steps": 6400, + "sufficient_stability_product": 0.6808609211686592 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562310.8806655, + 1792562314.2109573 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_rational_krylov_m128.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_rational_krylov_m128.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c2e47c42efc773f575d37e4bbcaf6e46f6107acf --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_rational_krylov_m128.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:629af9262bc95e983fa8d906fd0a7963ca642eceee4b4e81a6ad0d89361fc183 +size 83573 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_rational_krylov_m128_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_rational_krylov_m128_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2ca8c40174e7368511ac89aff5e2ec57578a56f4 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_rational_krylov_m128_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +{ + "material": "double_inclusion", + "grid": 96, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 352, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.004418106051161885, + "basis": 1.1304419960360974, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.08240334992296994, + "propagation": 0.005884009995497763, + "receiver_output": 0.0011679430026561022 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.004558402928523719, + "basis": 1.1437894291011617, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.08263393200468272, + "propagation": 0.005984403076581657, + "receiver_output": 0.0011751499259844422 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.004477680078707635, + "basis": 1.1476739299250767, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.08347780408803374, + "propagation": 0.005920554045587778, + "receiver_output": 0.0012166639789938927 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.004477680078707635, + "basis": 1.1437894291011617, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.08263393200468272, + "propagation": 0.005920554045587778, + "receiver_output": 0.0011751499259844422, + "total_seconds": 1.2381413170369342, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.224315405008383, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.2427666321163997 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "iterations": 61, + "distinct_shift_factorizations": 12, + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.2579885860876007e-14, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 8.753841626487768e-16, + "initial_projection_relative_error": 7.993113524362761e-16, + "minimum_eigenvalue_before_clipping": 2.7378864173940367e-14 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562349.2378979, + 1792562353.0257843 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_rational_krylov_m256.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_rational_krylov_m256.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6f9cad34c610503b265cb640d4789d47edf7319c --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_rational_krylov_m256.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:57a8be3404915ee537a1548dde0125550df2b0f57fb4d89afaf4467c7ff1d11a +size 99521 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_rational_krylov_m256_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_rational_krylov_m256_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..33f14eee8bc5b870c80712c9abbd3f3c12d6e689 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/double_inclusion_n96_rational_krylov_m256_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +{ + "material": "double_inclusion", + "grid": 96, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "modes_per_patch": 256, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 608, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.004464389057829976, + "basis": 2.6423881590599194, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.17741822905372828, + "propagation": 0.011395711917430162, + "receiver_output": 0.0035195579985156655 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.004547824035398662, + "basis": 2.5377560070483014, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.178032525931485, + "propagation": 0.010934702935628593, + "receiver_output": 0.0035665149334818125 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.004525121999904513, + "basis": 2.5088269220432267, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.18104743002913892, + "propagation": 0.011279480066150427, + "receiver_output": 0.0035290559753775597 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.004525121999904513, + "basis": 2.5377560070483014, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.178032525931485, + "propagation": 0.011279480066150427, + "receiver_output": 0.0035290559753775597, + "total_seconds": 2.7348375748842955, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.709208010113798, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.8391860470874235 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "iterations": 106, + "distinct_shift_factorizations": 12, + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.7360450882934568e-14, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 9.072458665096686e-16, + "initial_projection_relative_error": 8.46032083613452e-16, + "minimum_eigenvalue_before_clipping": 2.7378864173938688e-14 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562362.3021994, + 1792562370.7074022 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/environment.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/environment.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0d7026dbe78d6f0d2df294da8cb224d23f7ced28 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/environment.json @@ -0,0 +1,27 @@ +{ + "platform": "Linux-5.19.0-051900-generic-x86_64-with-glibc2.35", + "python": "3.12.15", + "numpy": "2.3.5", + "scipy": "1.17.0", + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "cpu_information": "processor\t: 0\nvendor_id\t: GenuineIntel\ncpu family\t: 6\nmodel\t\t: 106\nmodel name\t: Intel(R) Xeon(R) Platinum 8336C CPU @ 2.30GHz\nstepping\t: 6\nmicrocode\t: 0xd000421\ncpu MHz\t\t: 800.013\ncache size\t: 55296 KB\nphysical id\t: 0\nsiblings\t: 64\ncore id\t\t: 0\ncpu cores\t: 32\napicid\t\t: 0\ninitial apicid\t: 0\nfpu\t\t: yes\nfpu_exception\t: yes\ncpuid level\t: 27\nwp\t\t: yes\nflags\t\t: fpu vme de pse tsc msr pae mce cx8 apic sep mtrr pge mca cmov pat pse36 clflush dts acpi mmx fxsr sse sse2 ss ht tm pbe syscall nx pdpe1gb rdtscp lm constant_tsc art arch_perfmon pebs bts rep_good nopl xtopology nonstop_tsc cpuid aperfmperf pni pclmulqdq dtes64 monitor ds_cpl vmx smx est tm2 ssse3 sdbg fma cx16 xtpr pdcm pcid dca sse4_1 sse4_2 x2apic movbe popcnt tsc_deadline_timer aes xsave avx f16c rdrand lahf_lm abm 3dnowprefetch cpuid_fault epb cat_l3 invpcid_single intel_ppin ssbd mba ibrs ibpb stibp ibrs_enhanced tpr_shadow vnmi flexpriority ept vpid ept_ad fsgsbase tsc_adjust bmi1 avx2 smep bmi2 erms invpcid cqm rdt_a avx512f avx512dq rdseed adx smap avx512ifma clflushopt clwb intel_pt avx512cd sha_ni avx512bw avx512vl xsaveopt xsavec xgetbv1 xsaves cqm_llc cqm_occup_llc cqm_mbm_total cqm_mbm_local split_lock_detect wbnoinvd dtherm ida arat pln pts hwp hwp_act_window hwp_epp hwp_pkg_req avx512vbmi umip pku ospke avx512_vbmi2 gfni vaes vpclmulqdq avx512_vnni avx512_bitalg tme avx512_vpopcntdq la57 rdpid fsrm md_clear pconfig flush_l1d arch_capabilities\nvmx flags\t: vnmi preemption_timer posted_intr invvpid ept_x_only ept_ad ept_1gb flexpriority apicv tsc_offset vtpr mtf vapic ept vpid unrestricted_guest vapic_reg vid ple shadow_vmcs pml ept_mode_based_exec tsc_scaling\nbugs\t\t: spectre_v1 spectre_v2 spec_store_bypass swapgs mmio_stale_data\nbogomips\t: 4600.00\nclflush size\t: 64\ncache_alignment\t: 64\naddress sizes\t: 46 bits physical, 57 bits virtual\npower management:", + "thread_environment": { + "OPENBLAS_NUM_THREADS": "2", + "OMP_NUM_THREADS": "2", + "MKL_NUM_THREADS": "2" + }, + "threads": 2, + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "shared_basis_code_sha256": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "kernel_sha256": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454" +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_craig_bampton_m128.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_craig_bampton_m128.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..925c41d5f32e86d79d1e6f86c44d4351245c07da --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_craig_bampton_m128.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:a52e66bf05a94acb37e3cebc939d76a17499f643ae664e91d7cdb08f011677ae +size 85294 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_craig_bampton_m128_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_craig_bampton_m128_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..474e05c2d3ab09cbbccf4156131fc977ce548914 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_craig_bampton_m128_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,63 @@ +{ + "material": "rotated_stripes", + "grid": 128, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 384, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.007529872003942728, + "basis": 1.7008707099594176, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.16118567599914968, + "propagation": 0.006501707015559077, + "receiver_output": 0.0012761829420924187 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.007432356011122465, + "basis": 1.6979784660506994, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.16762280801776797, + "propagation": 0.006565683986991644, + "receiver_output": 0.0013104070676490664 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.008153372094966471, + "basis": 1.693192697945051, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.1676877710269764, + "propagation": 0.006549618090502918, + "receiver_output": 0.001290026935748756 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.007529872003942728, + "basis": 1.6979784660506994, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.16762280801776797, + "propagation": 0.006549618090502918, + "receiver_output": 0.001290026935748756, + "total_seconds": 1.8773641479201615, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.8768734860932454, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.8809097211342305 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.2092289745413427e-14, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 8.409196181363223e-16, + "initial_projection_relative_error": 0.0746950431669916, + "minimum_eigenvalue_before_clipping": -1.462958200135712e-11 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792561954.6745074, + 1792561960.4284384 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_craig_bampton_m256.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_craig_bampton_m256.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b8d31d498360adaea6bc99c77bc21ec2585213e4 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_craig_bampton_m256.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:1ee36d36f35869ed7477c81e5154fbedef413c697502db9cc975e53bc29d6fd9 +size 101273 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_craig_bampton_m256_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_craig_bampton_m256_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c98003d0c45a6af457691ff3789a48dde250a454 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_craig_bampton_m256_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,63 @@ +{ + "material": "rotated_stripes", + "grid": 128, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 256, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 640, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.009559656027704477, + "basis": 4.946659070090391, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.32610180601477623, + "propagation": 0.011923672049306333, + "receiver_output": 0.002085854997858405 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.007676656940020621, + "basis": 4.939624686026946, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.3563733989140019, + "propagation": 0.009287217981182039, + "receiver_output": 0.002089906018227339 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.007310150074772537, + "basis": 4.985507557052188, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.3595311149256304, + "propagation": 0.010443637031130493, + "receiver_output": 0.0021549760131165385 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.007676656940020621, + "basis": 4.946659070090391, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.3563733989140019, + "propagation": 0.010443637031130493, + "receiver_output": 0.002089906018227339, + "total_seconds": 5.315051865880378, + "minimum_total_seconds": 5.296330059180036, + "maximum_total_seconds": 5.364947435096838 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.6898069094112172e-14, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 8.419366507887249e-16, + "initial_projection_relative_error": 0.02254966541986058, + "minimum_eigenvalue_before_clipping": -1.4917965021707597e-11 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792561969.3065374, + 1792561985.5410821 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_full_chebyshev_bessel.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_full_chebyshev_bessel.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..040193ab851f9127f97c2c2a09dcfc6c555bdc4a --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_full_chebyshev_bessel.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:70489e9b0f95ca21d5713db8632d9a3de1c7fa02ff2db74652ea6f237591fa1d +size 61085 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_full_chebyshev_bessel_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_full_chebyshev_bessel_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2463de55ece232c414803fbb15eaa9042b919149 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_full_chebyshev_bessel_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,67 @@ +{ + "material": "rotated_stripes", + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_chebyshev_bessel", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 16384, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.007159889908507466, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 4.311484916950576, + "receiver_output": 0.0 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.006977416924200952, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 4.3381554030347615, + "receiver_output": 0.0 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0073414669604972005, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 4.329404442105442, + "receiver_output": 0.0 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.007159889908507466, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 4.329404442105442, + "receiver_output": 0.0, + "total_seconds": 4.3367459090659395, + "minimum_total_seconds": 4.3186448068590835, + "maximum_total_seconds": 4.3451328199589625 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "polynomial_degree": 2863, + "squared_frequency_upper_bound": 474242.39935555786, + "uniform_cosine_tail_bound": 7.105241677043217e-18, + "tail_tolerance": 1e-17, + "setup_seconds": 0.0017870960291475058, + "recurrence_and_observation_seconds": 0.925962560926564, + "coefficient_and_output_seconds": 3.4016265160171315, + "total_seconds": 4.329376172972843 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792561878.6678007, + 1792561891.6684096 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_full_sparse_exponential.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_full_sparse_exponential.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..36e9d4470a5aa9b37b5f187fbb56e9c6452d7477 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_full_sparse_exponential.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:d217a59113308c31b4217d333f69d85db92b25ac0b1c33ae83c07387d5ee9222 +size 61086 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_full_sparse_exponential_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_full_sparse_exponential_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8c043f3b44b3aafe54f9b627226c939ad603991b --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_full_sparse_exponential_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +{ + "material": "rotated_stripes", + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_sparse_exponential", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 16384, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.008580481982789934, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 68.00218485563528, + "receiver_output": 0.08238121785689145 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.006822820985689759, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 67.72494712902699, + "receiver_output": 0.07634844980202615 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.006828914978541434, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 67.61857643222902, + "receiver_output": 0.07991768792271614 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.006828914978541434, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 67.72494712902699, + "receiver_output": 0.07991768792271614, + "total_seconds": 67.8081183998147, + "minimum_total_seconds": 67.70532303513028, + "maximum_total_seconds": 68.09314655547496 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "energy_relative_drift": 1.709743457922741e-14 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792561656.7291374, + 1792561860.3836272 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..378431f3432e6076ddacc82e81d05ed006e78c89 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:774c6925cc87e697d299795df2e952fe575ae4931527ef272ebdd69e0c271fa2 +size 61070 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..dd7a7dd9c914cac1090012f68f11f35c4119fb69 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +{ + "material": "rotated_stripes", + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.125, + "dimension": 16384, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.0072798579931259155, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 4.569250790402293, + "receiver_output": 0.03372819256037474 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.00793520302977413, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 4.699023356894031, + "receiver_output": 0.03855320659931749 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.00802029692567885, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 4.589362836442888, + "receiver_output": 0.03821149992290884 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.00793520302977413, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 4.589362836442888, + "receiver_output": 0.03821149992290884, + "total_seconds": 4.6355946332914755, + "minimum_total_seconds": 4.610258840955794, + "maximum_total_seconds": 4.745511766523123 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "requested_cfl": 0.125, + "actual_cfl": 0.12180435960051739, + "time_step": 0.0005, + "substeps_per_output": 25, + "time_steps": 16000, + "sufficient_stability_product": 0.3443262985002573 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792561911.5775404, + 1792561925.5702171 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..13eef29842327c74a8d0dd3430a93aa2c1a09a44 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:bd96deaf44f30248806c1d07e193b65743c9c30b7f95d74c2211d05f6bc5dada +size 61070 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..de2c40cc2e36818460f27d2b2e4ec766ffbe7ea2 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +{ + "material": "rotated_stripes", + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "dimension": 16384, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.0074521900387480855, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 2.342635874869302, + "receiver_output": 0.039493680000305176 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.007851602975279093, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 2.3892521269153804, + "receiver_output": 0.03387320472393185 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.007342800963670015, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 2.449192572850734, + "receiver_output": 0.04008089692797512 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.0074521900387480855, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 2.3892521269153804, + "receiver_output": 0.039493680000305176, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "actual_cfl": 0.23423915307791807, + "time_step": 0.0009615384615384616, + "substeps_per_output": 13, + "time_steps": 8320, + "sufficient_stability_product": 0.6621659586543409 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792561904.256299, + 1792561911.5748024 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_rational_krylov_m128.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_rational_krylov_m128.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a0da878b8ac886327fdd7ad922161383d863511e --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_rational_krylov_m128.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:d13410750aa5c7db9ad52f2fd24406ae1905074b7da41df52081e33993da54a5 +size 85325 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_rational_krylov_m128_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_rational_krylov_m128_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2f56bca02a82055656ec58fcd7ff2cd6ad45ac96 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_rational_krylov_m128_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +{ + "material": "rotated_stripes", + "grid": 128, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 384, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.0074536019237712026, + "basis": 2.753368266974576, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.16653843107633293, + "propagation": 0.007682678056880832, + "receiver_output": 0.00235088006593287 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.007381592993624508, + "basis": 2.741015025996603, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.1482184249907732, + "propagation": 0.006118379067629576, + "receiver_output": 0.0013187850126996636 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.009525964967906475, + "basis": 2.73801202501636, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.15291077794972807, + "propagation": 0.0059450570261105895, + "receiver_output": 0.0012877410044893622 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.0074536019237712026, + "basis": 2.741015025996603, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.15291077794972807, + "propagation": 0.006118379067629576, + "receiver_output": 0.0013187850126996636, + "total_seconds": 2.9076815659645945, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.90405220806133, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.9373938580974936 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "iterations": 67, + "distinct_shift_factorizations": 12, + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.181211437172038e-14, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 8.640046227534978e-16, + "initial_projection_relative_error": 7.871655108721138e-16, + "minimum_eigenvalue_before_clipping": -3.693330809191675e-14 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792561960.4325728, + 1792561969.3029397 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_rational_krylov_m256.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_rational_krylov_m256.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8ad435d3ae191b30e0cded2093a24a52f83302be --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_rational_krylov_m256.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:8c5b27b45600c4bf92f1e711f24970518ab97d51e51d2e66f0afbd596311dce7 +size 101109 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_rational_krylov_m256_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_rational_krylov_m256_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b8d9300c4a67d1214c9a42b67d25645d6fb78119 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n128_rational_krylov_m256_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +{ + "material": "rotated_stripes", + "grid": 128, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "modes_per_patch": 256, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 640, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.008093055919744074, + "basis": 5.760295202955604, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.3251405539922416, + "propagation": 0.011938107083551586, + "receiver_output": 0.0035368140088394284 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.007299834047444165, + "basis": 5.642822925932705, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.3271173950051889, + "propagation": 0.011876553995534778, + "receiver_output": 0.0035341898910701275 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.008115351083688438, + "basis": 5.627588605042547, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.32480150600895286, + "propagation": 0.01076666999142617, + "receiver_output": 0.00203127006534487 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.008093055919744074, + "basis": 5.642822925932705, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.3251405539922416, + "propagation": 0.011876553995534778, + "receiver_output": 0.0035341898910701275, + "total_seconds": 5.992650898871943, + "minimum_total_seconds": 5.973303402191959, + "maximum_total_seconds": 6.10900373395998 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "iterations": 111, + "distinct_shift_factorizations": 12, + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.6117631069062755e-14, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 8.804341162882812e-16, + "initial_projection_relative_error": 8.308712187267978e-16, + "minimum_eigenvalue_before_clipping": -3.693330809192464e-14 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792561985.5453465, + 1792562003.8774061 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n32_craig_bampton_m128.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n32_craig_bampton_m128.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ff76f4af2116fc6191410011f95bec8cc7c3e962 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n32_craig_bampton_m128.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:74561898cd0a3fc257a1ad582ea8cc12c72e18fd321cdd70f6b21d47454a2fb0 +size 79454 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n32_craig_bampton_m128_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n32_craig_bampton_m128_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1b7e184800bb09d10ec379d2b04ae995dd38294d --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n32_craig_bampton_m128_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,63 @@ +{ + "material": "rotated_stripes", + "grid": 32, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 288, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.0015194290317595005, + "basis": 0.1577478819526732, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.014518216019496322, + "propagation": 0.004312751931138337, + "receiver_output": 0.0023814579471945763 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0015886059263721108, + "basis": 0.13806484499946237, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.011293555959127843, + "propagation": 0.004442867008037865, + "receiver_output": 0.0010457939933985472 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0016040009213611484, + "basis": 0.13739702908787876, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.011270429939031601, + "propagation": 0.004306300077587366, + "receiver_output": 0.0011155710089951754 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.0015886059263721108, + "basis": 0.13806484499946237, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.011293555959127843, + "propagation": 0.004312751931138337, + "receiver_output": 0.0011155710089951754, + "total_seconds": 0.15643566788639873, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.15569333103485405, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.18047973688226193 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.4799175041894517e-14, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 9.500711640112481e-16, + "initial_projection_relative_error": 0.1154368756001994, + "minimum_eigenvalue_before_clipping": -1.0757734561587084e-12 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792561925.5729487, + 1792561926.071448 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n32_full_chebyshev_bessel.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n32_full_chebyshev_bessel.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..60b7fed0845e821876cfbc03cf53c613764680de --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n32_full_chebyshev_bessel.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:871b720f4749952e9a89087d1a391642cdaf7a22d7147ec6b262e2f02355c539 +size 61035 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n32_full_chebyshev_bessel_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n32_full_chebyshev_bessel_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a23faaf027ef890f63af792dade78742605d489d --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n32_full_chebyshev_bessel_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,67 @@ +{ + "material": "rotated_stripes", + "grid": 32, + "method": "full_chebyshev_bessel", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 1024, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.00179763394407928, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 1.0566272829892114, + "receiver_output": 0.0 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.001558850985020399, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 1.05434847692959, + "receiver_output": 0.0 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0015001530991867185, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 1.0555063280044124, + "receiver_output": 0.0 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.001558850985020399, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 1.0555063280044124, + "receiver_output": 0.0, + "total_seconds": 1.057006481103599, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0559073279146105, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0584249169332907 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "polynomial_degree": 749, + "squared_frequency_upper_bound": 29021.476427488906, + "uniform_cosine_tail_bound": 6.387080472811839e-18, + "tail_tolerance": 1e-17, + "setup_seconds": 0.0004439189797267318, + "recurrence_and_observation_seconds": 0.02004032291006297, + "coefficient_and_output_seconds": 1.0349935190752149, + "total_seconds": 1.0554777609650046 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792561860.3868454, + 1792561863.5582607 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n32_full_sparse_exponential.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n32_full_sparse_exponential.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..987a9cd62ea049b0aa4cf30266a6ceef6d120e11 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n32_full_sparse_exponential.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:c6f06a2a6d7c41913976a115553bdefe39cbda605002534fcc1c7ffc582cb322 +size 61024 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n32_full_sparse_exponential_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n32_full_sparse_exponential_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0bad2e0ac0537a9d4e7455dabf152cc375df1a4c --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n32_full_sparse_exponential_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +{ + "material": "rotated_stripes", + "grid": 32, + "method": "full_sparse_exponential", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 1024, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.0022258490789681673, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 3.6942125007044524, + "receiver_output": 0.00638418598100543 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0018893069354817271, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 2.9606361559126526, + "receiver_output": 0.0033473919611424208 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0015269129071384668, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 2.949131097877398, + "receiver_output": 0.004378844168968499 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.0018893069354817271, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 2.9606361559126526, + "receiver_output": 0.004378844168968499, + "total_seconds": 2.9658728548092768, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.955036854953505, + "maximum_total_seconds": 3.702822535764426 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "energy_relative_drift": 4.551914400963142e-15 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792561514.5979443, + 1792561524.2276592 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n32_rational_krylov_m128.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n32_rational_krylov_m128.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1cddb9f9077ec0cc2e7f62d4a2d91f56f67f0900 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n32_rational_krylov_m128.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:cb0f5637f250017f865cd2e010561e5856829e693cee4a522f0c9870a512a157 +size 79455 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n32_rational_krylov_m128_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n32_rational_krylov_m128_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..00b12825b351c12bb9d482b907ac95bf8880664a --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n32_rational_krylov_m128_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +{ + "material": "rotated_stripes", + "grid": 32, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 288, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.0015530670061707497, + "basis": 0.1026833449723199, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.010579223046079278, + "propagation": 0.004706191946752369, + "receiver_output": 0.0010067770490422845 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.001598111935891211, + "basis": 0.10280084505211562, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.010698579018935561, + "propagation": 0.004801603965461254, + "receiver_output": 0.0012012070510536432 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0016159609658643603, + "basis": 0.10302925703581423, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.010459317942149937, + "propagation": 0.00476797204464674, + "receiver_output": 0.0019028109963983297 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.001598111935891211, + "basis": 0.10280084505211562, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.010579223046079278, + "propagation": 0.00476797204464674, + "receiver_output": 0.0012012070510536432, + "total_seconds": 0.12110034702345729, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.12052860402036458, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.12177531898487359 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "iterations": 50, + "distinct_shift_factorizations": 12, + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.458925602820858e-14, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 7.276332721736985e-16, + "initial_projection_relative_error": 6.685129258278039e-16, + "minimum_eigenvalue_before_clipping": -9.827385834603656e-15 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792561926.0747292, + 1792561926.4464717 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_craig_bampton_m128.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_craig_bampton_m128.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5dbf219a6008813b2639dd31dabe5e28567eadb0 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_craig_bampton_m128.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:dcc22b8a75ab34c776b7e8ef5ea5ab3f20cb220bab8fd98c2a3ee97b5a651d58 +size 81427 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_craig_bampton_m128_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_craig_bampton_m128_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..415f00bc8b62e25de55346586904906c99b58061 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_craig_bampton_m128_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,63 @@ +{ + "material": "rotated_stripes", + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 320, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.0025751020293682814, + "basis": 0.5263657179893926, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.040161201963201165, + "propagation": 0.004736489034257829, + "receiver_output": 0.0011457860236987472 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0031122310319915414, + "basis": 0.5267617799108848, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.03976516891270876, + "propagation": 0.0047850830014795065, + "receiver_output": 0.0010167350992560387 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.003094500978477299, + "basis": 0.49822879303246737, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.04028210195247084, + "propagation": 0.004866514005698264, + "receiver_output": 0.0009990549879148602 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.003094500978477299, + "basis": 0.5263657179893926, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.040161201963201165, + "propagation": 0.0047850830014795065, + "receiver_output": 0.0010167350992560387, + "total_seconds": 0.5749842970399186, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5474709649570286, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.5754409979563206 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.2782944881200817e-14, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 7.285219028660626e-16, + "initial_projection_relative_error": 0.08125641473867626, + "minimum_eigenvalue_before_clipping": -1.5639863863587016e-12 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792561926.449731, + 1792561928.1764026 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_full_chebyshev_bessel.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_full_chebyshev_bessel.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..248325e775a9ddb8019b26b7820aec8a85216f84 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_full_chebyshev_bessel.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:7c61ac822db29d8751bfa78ffb519c4b12ca397a0782292f0bff70692885c51b +size 61057 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_full_chebyshev_bessel_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_full_chebyshev_bessel_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ec1def8d114aa68ff214f00eb571a877e3938767 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_full_chebyshev_bessel_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,67 @@ +{ + "material": "rotated_stripes", + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_chebyshev_bessel", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 4096, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.0027342039393261075, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 1.9813171259593219, + "receiver_output": 0.0 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0028254229109734297, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 1.9746160099748522, + "receiver_output": 0.0 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0024744479451328516, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 1.9763488640310243, + "receiver_output": 0.0 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.0027342039393261075, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 1.9763488640310243, + "receiver_output": 0.0, + "total_seconds": 1.9788233119761571, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.9774414328858256, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.984051329898648 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "polynomial_degree": 1460, + "squared_frequency_upper_bound": 118140.31409755835, + "uniform_cosine_tail_bound": 9.899797133072125e-18, + "tail_tolerance": 1e-17, + "setup_seconds": 0.0007437720196321607, + "recurrence_and_observation_seconds": 0.12247605598531663, + "coefficient_and_output_seconds": 1.8531127150636166, + "total_seconds": 1.9763325430685654 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792561863.5611165, + 1792561869.5015032 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_full_sparse_exponential.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_full_sparse_exponential.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a402fa762f051beea5a0ad94dbf223a9e1ff227f --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_full_sparse_exponential.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:6aec441ee09a9e892bc898a01790246f7b40ced0ee220e1a2cbb868af768b113 +size 61056 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_full_sparse_exponential_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_full_sparse_exponential_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..88de14d4534a01b6f95fcac1a6ab99e220623e04 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_full_sparse_exponential_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +{ + "material": "rotated_stripes", + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_sparse_exponential", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 4096, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.0030030510388314724, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 12.35352984489873, + "receiver_output": 0.021195976645685732 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0029792499262839556, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 12.339970227098092, + "receiver_output": 0.020758344675414264 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.002820492023602128, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 12.347940957755782, + "receiver_output": 0.021208839956671 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.0029792499262839556, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 12.347940957755782, + "receiver_output": 0.021195976645685732, + "total_seconds": 12.371970289736055, + "minimum_total_seconds": 12.36370782169979, + "maximum_total_seconds": 12.377728872583248 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "energy_relative_drift": 9.103828801926284e-15 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792561524.2310708, + 1792561561.3582337 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c86a70fd915684ab9aeebd1527476b8fda67d04d --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:cb55466e2b574d089275a10af0f22182f5003a6b3ed353d74ada21836ea647af +size 61063 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8f3a51359ad96489042f4af4f93964e01bde2cbd --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +{ + "material": "rotated_stripes", + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.125, + "dimension": 4096, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.0030069180065765977, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 0.5934241891372949, + "receiver_output": 0.010141314007341862 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.002966559026390314, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 0.6394100334728137, + "receiver_output": 0.011184144066646695 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0027439419645816088, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 0.5868698502890766, + "receiver_output": 0.009551054681651294 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.002966559026390314, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 0.5934241891372949, + "receiver_output": 0.010141314007341862, + "total_seconds": 0.6065724211512133, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5991648469353095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.6535607365658507 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "requested_cfl": 0.125, + "actual_cfl": 0.11710355196670794, + "time_step": 0.0009615384615384616, + "substeps_per_output": 13, + "time_steps": 8320, + "sufficient_stability_product": 0.33049562993595716 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792561892.6737115, + 1792561894.5337324 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d2905f276c7d4967e86430a697f10b8108261320 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:b6b8acad16f77a37a68b59f1268b0621f008cc8c769c7670893c5edc26965c27 +size 61055 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2d4886877a627e7369f4aeed2199178bf75e9b6d --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +{ + "material": "rotated_stripes", + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "dimension": 4096, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.0030953279929235578, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 0.317150364164263, + "receiver_output": 0.008398470119573176 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.003023158060386777, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 0.3193456509616226, + "receiver_output": 0.009341596974991262 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.003041950985789299, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 0.32675385114271194, + "receiver_output": 0.008750827051699162 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.003041950985789299, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 0.3193456509616226, + "receiver_output": 0.008750827051699162, + "total_seconds": 0.33171040599700063, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.32864416227675974, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3385466291802004 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "actual_cfl": 0.21747802508102904, + "time_step": 0.0017857142857142859, + "substeps_per_output": 7, + "time_steps": 4480, + "sufficient_stability_product": 0.6137775984524919 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792561891.6712437, + 1792561892.6709008 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_rational_krylov_m128.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_rational_krylov_m128.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8f45273023d6312d356cbf29ca896ab603df72d0 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_rational_krylov_m128.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:8eef147cf38ebc134e0ed27606f32815e61496d687f5e4b580f31cbb5ac2e5d5 +size 81443 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_rational_krylov_m128_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_rational_krylov_m128_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a9d69403ca61e78f5a2bce07e801496b01ecd4e8 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n64_rational_krylov_m128_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +{ + "material": "rotated_stripes", + "grid": 64, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 320, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.002969127963297069, + "basis": 0.46040915499906987, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.02906736801378429, + "propagation": 0.004752665059641004, + "receiver_output": 0.0009279720252379775 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0027100519509986043, + "basis": 0.45796552603133023, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.027286430937238038, + "propagation": 0.004937338060699403, + "receiver_output": 0.0009338429663330317 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0027352359611541033, + "basis": 0.4668585089966655, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.029339010012336075, + "propagation": 0.004975361982360482, + "receiver_output": 0.0009339929092675447 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.0027352359611541033, + "basis": 0.46040915499906987, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.02906736801378429, + "propagation": 0.004937338060699403, + "receiver_output": 0.0009338429663330317, + "total_seconds": 0.4981262880610302, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.4938331899465993, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.5048421098617837 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "iterations": 56, + "distinct_shift_factorizations": 12, + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.3470835917345651e-14, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 8.994921783443233e-16, + "initial_projection_relative_error": 7.4650671753389575e-16, + "minimum_eigenvalue_before_clipping": 2.7515067066248604e-15 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792561928.179741, + 1792561929.7142613 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_craig_bampton_m128.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_craig_bampton_m128.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..13493a6d2dc6ab52d5ef735dbbf5c2af0d4b6610 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_craig_bampton_m128.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:d32c9abf9ab142729dcfd29606b1e5f219f597ae51c41ab29430b24f813f05cd +size 83401 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_craig_bampton_m128_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_craig_bampton_m128_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..df89b88a4b853bfa6e67b00f1da2034321caa04d --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_craig_bampton_m128_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,63 @@ +{ + "material": "rotated_stripes", + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 352, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.004616800928488374, + "basis": 0.9349294010316953, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.07980070903431624, + "propagation": 0.0055892979726195335, + "receiver_output": 0.0012269529979676008 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.004595231031998992, + "basis": 0.9212267129914835, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.07943010400049388, + "propagation": 0.005888673942536116, + "receiver_output": 0.001216316013596952 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.004899446037597954, + "basis": 0.9257460540393367, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.07828115008305758, + "propagation": 0.005816846969537437, + "receiver_output": 0.0012141650076955557 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.004616800928488374, + "basis": 0.9257460540393367, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.07943010400049388, + "propagation": 0.005816846969537437, + "receiver_output": 0.001216316013596952, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.1632637979622784e-14, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 9.339214555551724e-16, + "initial_projection_relative_error": 0.07635925497334774, + "minimum_eigenvalue_before_clipping": 4.6020143020070966e-12 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792561929.7177305, + 1792561932.836915 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_craig_bampton_m256.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_craig_bampton_m256.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1f18e25cae87dc1f1e39eab028ca8a6b2d9aa381 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_craig_bampton_m256.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:43a478d23f6a670fe9f73352e0126eb9f8f6a42dc3c8a405f121ced820dd05ce +size 99239 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_craig_bampton_m256_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_craig_bampton_m256_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5cdf3966676de4a496281a6981bce0a639e2bbf1 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_craig_bampton_m256_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,63 @@ +{ + "material": "rotated_stripes", + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 256, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 608, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.004587313043884933, + "basis": 2.869314219104126, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.19363030802924186, + "propagation": 0.00936069805175066, + "receiver_output": 0.00351652002427727 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0049988540122285485, + "basis": 2.814158599008806, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.19614464498590678, + "propagation": 0.008743385085836053, + "receiver_output": 0.003420102992095053 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.004653216921724379, + "basis": 2.8866733299801126, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.1928376379655674, + "propagation": 0.009261292056180537, + "receiver_output": 0.003507746965624392 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.004653216921724379, + "basis": 2.869314219104126, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.19363030802924186, + "propagation": 0.009261292056180537, + "receiver_output": 0.003507746965624392, + "total_seconds": 3.080409058253281, + "minimum_total_seconds": 3.0274655860848725, + "maximum_total_seconds": 3.0969332238892093 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.7732754859188268e-14, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 9.157783333674937e-16, + "initial_projection_relative_error": 0.023888112320529988, + "minimum_eigenvalue_before_clipping": -1.9981696620606826e-12 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792561936.8522084, + 1792561946.1840773 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_full_chebyshev_bessel.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_full_chebyshev_bessel.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a06f4fc72996bd425c1ec87889bbcc2e799965ff --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_full_chebyshev_bessel.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:b39970c74a2d4ad02c49d64fce6c013a1ebe6c99e969f1c60a6df25aab43e637 +size 61075 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_full_chebyshev_bessel_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_full_chebyshev_bessel_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fc49b311255369690990a7a7b22ac11bfb5dd190 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_full_chebyshev_bessel_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,67 @@ +{ + "material": "rotated_stripes", + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_chebyshev_bessel", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 9216, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.004072876065038145, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 3.0537526039406657, + "receiver_output": 0.0 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.005725536961108446, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 3.0507151160854846, + "receiver_output": 0.0 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.004188495920971036, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 3.0418158300453797, + "receiver_output": 0.0 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.004188495920971036, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 3.0507151160854846, + "receiver_output": 0.0, + "total_seconds": 3.056440653046593, + "minimum_total_seconds": 3.0460043259663507, + "maximum_total_seconds": 3.057825480005704 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "polynomial_degree": 2163, + "squared_frequency_upper_bound": 266444.76172087115, + "uniform_cosine_tail_bound": 7.165770110059693e-18, + "tail_tolerance": 1e-17, + "setup_seconds": 0.0011794049059972167, + "recurrence_and_observation_seconds": 0.40600625902879983, + "coefficient_and_output_seconds": 2.6346002629725263, + "total_seconds": 3.0417859269073233 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792561869.5042434, + 1792561878.6646614 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_full_sparse_exponential.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_full_sparse_exponential.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..aecd09cb026e8eabc78633f499bd4ec9079385ea --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_full_sparse_exponential.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:7862b480cf1e87a5f03caa62301827998f674aa05dd8fffb681048bea292c490 +size 61097 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_full_sparse_exponential_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_full_sparse_exponential_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..649a62585b4f4e1f3e7edce92891c38f28f692d3 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_full_sparse_exponential_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +{ + "material": "rotated_stripes", + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_sparse_exponential", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 9216, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.005118075059726834, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 31.719136726111174, + "receiver_output": 0.04949730611406267 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.005644724005833268, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 31.796292301733047, + "receiver_output": 0.04881493025459349 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.00547403609380126, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 31.65599073912017, + "receiver_output": 0.04758255183696747 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.00547403609380126, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 31.719136726111174, + "receiver_output": 0.04881493025459349, + "total_seconds": 31.773752107284963, + "minimum_total_seconds": 31.70904732705094, + "maximum_total_seconds": 31.850751955993474 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "energy_relative_drift": 1.6431300764452317e-14 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792561561.3614743, + 1792561656.7259328 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f05fe5ba04c1705a6262755fe81c573883030e7a --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:5be65289ae55259d8a97680978a619b1c8ffef20a955d6fc00ba2cd298aa2b79 +size 61062 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7ee53b8576cf869584763f48ca9df31e94bb5eb2 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +{ + "material": "rotated_stripes", + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.125, + "dimension": 9216, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.004581170040182769, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 2.0479771438986063, + "receiver_output": 0.024789693299680948 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.005074640968814492, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 2.060403556795791, + "receiver_output": 0.022427599178627133 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.004672708106227219, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 2.153076203656383, + "receiver_output": 0.024215761688537896 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.004672708106227219, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 2.060403556795791, + "receiver_output": 0.024215761688537896, + "total_seconds": 2.0879057969432324, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.07734800723847, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.181964673451148 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "requested_cfl": 0.125, + "actual_cfl": 0.12018148517408712, + "time_step": 0.0006578947368421052, + "substeps_per_output": 19, + "time_steps": 12160, + "sufficient_stability_product": 0.33959399752470304 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792561897.905164, + 1792561904.253561 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..dfd199a22cdf03aaacd807ffc251333e63554f20 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:41325a523f9807318074d401c9a60a349188969cadb8fb79e5bf2b591b4fd354 +size 61043 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e7a9df33b5b1b6808442c0cfc22e22a818815047 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +{ + "material": "rotated_stripes", + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "dimension": 9216, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.0047669700579717755, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 1.0793173759011552, + "receiver_output": 0.022139057400636375 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.00459497794508934, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 1.0904904041672125, + "receiver_output": 0.022905562655068934 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.004598389030434191, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 1.1112721242243424, + "receiver_output": 0.0248871409567073 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.004598389030434191, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 1.0904904041672125, + "receiver_output": 0.022905562655068934, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "actual_cfl": 0.22834482183076554, + "time_step": 0.00125, + "substeps_per_output": 10, + "time_steps": 6400, + "sufficient_stability_product": 0.6452285952969358 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792561894.5364122, + 1792561897.9025173 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_rational_krylov_m128.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_rational_krylov_m128.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f53ee690c0b17602a4c0a65c55e887e96316b731 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_rational_krylov_m128.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:0333aa388d2547df7deb1192a7212ea5a01331820972ef924d3dc9e03fd0b6e5 +size 83423 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_rational_krylov_m128_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_rational_krylov_m128_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..63401ca99c04d70ff3d52c60679697cbc7ab0e72 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_rational_krylov_m128_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +{ + "material": "rotated_stripes", + "grid": 96, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 352, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.004569192999042571, + "basis": 1.2171832259045914, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.08798924193251878, + "propagation": 0.006891089025884867, + "receiver_output": 0.001998630934394896 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.005345726036466658, + "basis": 1.21138859691564, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.08502783603034914, + "propagation": 0.005345968063920736, + "receiver_output": 0.0012115539284422994 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0046363649889826775, + "basis": 1.1995795379625633, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.08361456403508782, + "propagation": 0.005947923986241221, + "receiver_output": 0.001195169985294342 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.0046363649889826775, + "basis": 1.21138859691564, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.08502783603034914, + "propagation": 0.005947923986241221, + "receiver_output": 0.0012115539284422994, + "total_seconds": 1.3083196809748188, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.2949735609581694, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.3186313807964325 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "iterations": 61, + "distinct_shift_factorizations": 12, + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.2490869259951214e-14, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 1.0426673026435902e-15, + "initial_projection_relative_error": 9.263454999646058e-16, + "minimum_eigenvalue_before_clipping": 2.6406475811233747e-14 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792561932.8405354, + 1792561936.8486984 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_rational_krylov_m256.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_rational_krylov_m256.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d806aedde19d960a4115a035d679134c2bd59f60 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_rational_krylov_m256.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:14f55483d9be69923d166b8cde9261d3bf11517a4a79889e56536cb186ffbf30 +size 99164 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_rational_krylov_m256_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_rational_krylov_m256_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..985632058c3a35f95ec8abe0b9169c6d463c9501 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/rotated_stripes_n96_rational_krylov_m256_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +{ + "material": "rotated_stripes", + "grid": 96, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "modes_per_patch": 256, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 608, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.0047647650353610516, + "basis": 2.7877732060151175, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.18584879802074283, + "propagation": 0.010689526912756264, + "receiver_output": 0.0035560060059651732 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.005059870076365769, + "basis": 2.483799156965688, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.17934917390812188, + "propagation": 0.011224498972296715, + "receiver_output": 0.0035120969405397773 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.004698282922618091, + "basis": 2.4837117029819638, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.18011673097498715, + "propagation": 0.010850157006643713, + "receiver_output": 0.003633212996646762 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.0047647650353610516, + "basis": 2.483799156965688, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.18011673097498715, + "propagation": 0.010850157006643713, + "receiver_output": 0.0035560060059651732, + "total_seconds": 2.6830100868828595, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.682944796863012, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.992632301989943 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "iterations": 106, + "distinct_shift_factorizations": 12, + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.7429236390262058e-14, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 1.0797552833618423e-15, + "initial_projection_relative_error": 9.783927525227423e-16, + "minimum_eigenvalue_before_clipping": 2.6406475811233617e-14 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792561946.188411, + 1792561954.670275 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_craig_bampton_m128.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_craig_bampton_m128.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c7c4c2fcedf4ea4747de584dbc6634bf43af94ed --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_craig_bampton_m128.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:48cd7bd6c106fb29ff49dbf6ac5748c0629f46bbfe19c1a6cf7b7412a46998d5 +size 85130 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_craig_bampton_m128_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_craig_bampton_m128_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..87bdb74adfd16a13582ca4f59560b6fe05770a65 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_craig_bampton_m128_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,63 @@ +{ + "material": "smooth_checker", + "grid": 128, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 384, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.007294030045159161, + "basis": 1.6889221639139578, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.1622468309942633, + "propagation": 0.006042376975528896, + "receiver_output": 0.0013110419968143106 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.007258039084263146, + "basis": 1.6855813479050994, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.15949543309397995, + "propagation": 0.006027763010933995, + "receiver_output": 0.0012865470489487052 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.007185162976384163, + "basis": 1.6872057070722803, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.16175845195539296, + "propagation": 0.005967224016785622, + "receiver_output": 0.0012819749535992742 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.007258039084263146, + "basis": 1.6872057070722803, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.16175845195539296, + "propagation": 0.006027763010933995, + "receiver_output": 0.0012865470489487052, + "total_seconds": 1.8633985209744424, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.8596491301432252, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.8658164439257234 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.1446610456167804e-14, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 8.393785386647664e-16, + "initial_projection_relative_error": 0.0521443309657833, + "minimum_eigenvalue_before_clipping": -1.0354796460699184e-11 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562966.1564915, + 1792562971.85947 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_craig_bampton_m256.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_craig_bampton_m256.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0cd9c46c8267297e93dac0f3f50efdb6806ee92b --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_craig_bampton_m256.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:02eba9ca0751882e0ec49f2cdeb0410c9866737157405d05fab9a48a8e7eebf8 +size 101128 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_craig_bampton_m256_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_craig_bampton_m256_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9306bea3dbd432b8df53b32b698ee1c7a255a53b --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_craig_bampton_m256_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,63 @@ +{ + "material": "smooth_checker", + "grid": 128, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 256, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 640, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.009458043030463159, + "basis": 4.943766306969337, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.3600014339899644, + "propagation": 0.011844243970699608, + "receiver_output": 0.002082357998006046 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.007339005940593779, + "basis": 4.936797405942343, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.3545185289112851, + "propagation": 0.009040266973897815, + "receiver_output": 0.0021035249810665846 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0072366970125585794, + "basis": 4.941781921079382, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.35482601693365723, + "propagation": 0.009870626032352448, + "receiver_output": 0.002161812037229538 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.007339005940593779, + "basis": 4.941781921079382, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.35482601693365723, + "propagation": 0.009870626032352448, + "receiver_output": 0.0021035249810665846, + "total_seconds": 5.31587707309518, + "minimum_total_seconds": 5.3097987327491865, + "maximum_total_seconds": 5.32715238595847 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.6416882092182938e-14, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 8.994683412264702e-16, + "initial_projection_relative_error": 0.02052531950775461, + "minimum_eigenvalue_before_clipping": 2.942724476596869e-12 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562980.7102325, + 1792562996.926682 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_full_chebyshev_bessel.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_full_chebyshev_bessel.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7099fcec35ce4bad698547d236d67d1db28f55a9 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_full_chebyshev_bessel.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:6db8ea6220d918793c81f362e2da973b186442731260c6d120373022f8b16291 +size 61099 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_full_chebyshev_bessel_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_full_chebyshev_bessel_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4731addfabda98fb118f2f1669115c246b05d283 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_full_chebyshev_bessel_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,67 @@ +{ + "material": "smooth_checker", + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_chebyshev_bessel", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 16384, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.006731156026944518, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 5.299542448949069, + "receiver_output": 0.0 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.007258659927174449, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 5.3218296529958025, + "receiver_output": 0.0 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.007236601901240647, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 5.279807144077495, + "receiver_output": 0.0 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.007236601901240647, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 5.299542448949069, + "receiver_output": 0.0, + "total_seconds": 5.306273604976013, + "minimum_total_seconds": 5.287043745978735, + "maximum_total_seconds": 5.329088312922977 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "polynomial_degree": 3554, + "squared_frequency_upper_bound": 738418.2688142987, + "uniform_cosine_tail_bound": 7.498676678745863e-18, + "tail_tolerance": 1e-17, + "setup_seconds": 0.0017962839920073748, + "recurrence_and_observation_seconds": 1.1240259100450203, + "coefficient_and_output_seconds": 4.153958696988411, + "total_seconds": 5.279780891025439 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562880.544249, + 1792562896.4667416 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_full_sparse_exponential.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_full_sparse_exponential.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2a10805dd6e074c199630baa2b3a54f7b03cd84b --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_full_sparse_exponential.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:5cf6400739858134b1eff70066abd26a49fb190f7c6f1ad2b879fd97cf301992 +size 61102 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_full_sparse_exponential_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_full_sparse_exponential_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2069aa504fa208f89ed6a567beb81e1a79e6f30d --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_full_sparse_exponential_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +{ + "material": "smooth_checker", + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_sparse_exponential", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 16384, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.006260260008275509, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 93.92903094913345, + "receiver_output": 0.08168591791763902 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.008851021993905306, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 93.89797419693787, + "receiver_output": 0.07964227301999927 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0067260670475661755, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 93.86427499970887, + "receiver_output": 0.07647624483797699 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.0067260670475661755, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 93.89797419693787, + "receiver_output": 0.07964227301999927, + "total_seconds": 93.98646749195177, + "minimum_total_seconds": 93.94747731159441, + "maximum_total_seconds": 94.01697712705936 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "energy_relative_drift": 1.354472090042691e-14 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562576.978038, + 1792562858.9773605 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..34c776875f3a8fcb5e53f6ee27f8e6d06fbe730b --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:26d3766c487b89f93e04752341cd3be6c8e5785b99de05d7f9328a0ae6a05d12 +size 61078 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2f857574930e64e2699f8daaf49d2395e4ba40c0 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +{ + "material": "smooth_checker", + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.125, + "dimension": 16384, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.007937888032756746, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 5.523552472237498, + "receiver_output": 0.038998598232865334 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.007778851082548499, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 5.711836236296222, + "receiver_output": 0.040281180292367935 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.007901872042566538, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 5.671423580497503, + "receiver_output": 0.04077157692518085 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.007901872042566538, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 5.671423580497503, + "receiver_output": 0.040281180292367935, + "total_seconds": 5.720097029465251, + "minimum_total_seconds": 5.57048895850312, + "maximum_total_seconds": 5.759896267671138 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "requested_cfl": 0.125, + "actual_cfl": 0.12358489497085813, + "time_step": 0.0004032258064516129, + "substeps_per_output": 31, + "time_steps": 19840, + "sufficient_stability_product": 0.34649704529139047 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562920.0035806, + 1792562937.0554605 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c801f613637b4e66e57c69660c67e625efc156e8 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:64a73de0234fb1d41280db6e7c79b38de6e47a1ee13fffea6d624366e547000d +size 61086 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9b7fca051345d76ed80ca2928c062724b6915d87 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +{ + "material": "smooth_checker", + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "dimension": 16384, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.007993358070962131, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 2.9363054055720568, + "receiver_output": 0.038479789393022656 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.007890161941759288, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 2.84810200415086, + "receiver_output": 0.04035996412858367 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0072954000206664205, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 2.8842245473060757, + "receiver_output": 0.037492433562874794 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.007890161941759288, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 2.8842245473060757, + "receiver_output": 0.038479789393022656, + "total_seconds": 2.929012380889617, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.896352130221203, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.9827785530360416 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "actual_cfl": 0.23944573400603764, + "time_step": 0.00078125, + "substeps_per_output": 16, + "time_steps": 10240, + "sufficient_stability_product": 0.6713380252520691 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562911.191284, + 1792562920.0007608 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_rational_krylov_m128.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_rational_krylov_m128.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..70fbf9e57cd34aa70f24c120135f446d0f39dc93 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_rational_krylov_m128.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:fba4acb3e52329c5c7ba10dba6e92baaaa68444e71506ca0b01c1f135d405e7c +size 85392 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_rational_krylov_m128_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_rational_krylov_m128_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e601ea2df74e8021d582e3203a93a3a770d751f2 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_rational_krylov_m128_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +{ + "material": "smooth_checker", + "grid": 128, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 384, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.007224736036732793, + "basis": 2.7241468250285834, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.16986317501869053, + "propagation": 0.007707471959292889, + "receiver_output": 0.002272494020871818 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0072860169457271695, + "basis": 2.7489129699533805, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.16494140296708792, + "propagation": 0.007470784010365605, + "receiver_output": 0.0022003280464559793 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.007284921943210065, + "basis": 2.7275452080648392, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.1420858179917559, + "propagation": 0.006179700023494661, + "receiver_output": 0.0013179300585761666 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.007284921943210065, + "basis": 2.7275452080648392, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.16494140296708792, + "propagation": 0.007470784010365605, + "receiver_output": 0.0022003280464559793, + "total_seconds": 2.9112147020641714, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.884413578081876, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.930811501923017 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "iterations": 67, + "distinct_shift_factorizations": 12, + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.2290170289486666e-14, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 6.283256075537966e-16, + "initial_projection_relative_error": 8.862002729695689e-16, + "minimum_eigenvalue_before_clipping": -3.158495530750607e-14 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562971.8630197, + 1792562980.706721 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_rational_krylov_m256.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_rational_krylov_m256.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ceeb402c44fe54b791d87f6d423bcb486be78e34 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_rational_krylov_m256.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:58e8d6e7e1fdd43d81cbcfd36ab07eb68940baab91ab1dac05ecf3f095c77f4f +size 101088 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_rational_krylov_m256_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_rational_krylov_m256_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7401a4d2b255ea7e9addf9495e7f121c34f3f77b --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n128_rational_krylov_m256_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +{ + "material": "smooth_checker", + "grid": 128, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "modes_per_patch": 256, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 640, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.00765794503968209, + "basis": 5.837465853081085, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.32653870596550405, + "propagation": 0.011953489971347153, + "receiver_output": 0.003502404084429145 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.007393958047032356, + "basis": 5.658677865983918, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.3197495930362493, + "propagation": 0.009639763971790671, + "receiver_output": 0.002122505917213857 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.007344630896113813, + "basis": 5.649476421996951, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.32465686299838126, + "propagation": 0.011376786045730114, + "receiver_output": 0.0034882340114563704 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.007393958047032356, + "basis": 5.658677865983918, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.32465686299838126, + "propagation": 0.011376786045730114, + "receiver_output": 0.0034882340114563704, + "total_seconds": 5.9975836869562045, + "minimum_total_seconds": 5.996342935948633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 6.187118398142047 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "iterations": 111, + "distinct_shift_factorizations": 12, + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.6679850072581738e-14, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 6.502517872799999e-16, + "initial_projection_relative_error": 9.367176740936734e-16, + "minimum_eigenvalue_before_clipping": -3.158495530750519e-14 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562996.9309282, + 1792563015.3658736 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n32_craig_bampton_m128.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n32_craig_bampton_m128.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6c09a66141fcc39564c0548a017773f68737e230 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n32_craig_bampton_m128.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:ff55119fbfd2b32f32b6323bbefe8ea3f1d2b32d02c0599789586c9eb490f0d1 +size 79507 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n32_craig_bampton_m128_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n32_craig_bampton_m128_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3026d27e542d272eaa3baf006305cd9b80fbb4cc --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n32_craig_bampton_m128_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,63 @@ +{ + "material": "smooth_checker", + "grid": 32, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 288, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.002148104947991669, + "basis": 0.1530628859763965, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.014172584982588887, + "propagation": 0.003903294913470745, + "receiver_output": 0.0012674059253185987 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0015286910347640514, + "basis": 0.14490137808024883, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.01137926196679473, + "propagation": 0.004010373959317803, + "receiver_output": 0.0008859870722517371 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.001481426996178925, + "basis": 0.13547187694348395, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.01058446301613003, + "propagation": 0.004122836049646139, + "receiver_output": 0.0007580620003864169 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.0015286910347640514, + "basis": 0.14490137808024883, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.01137926196679473, + "propagation": 0.004010373959317803, + "receiver_output": 0.0008859870722517371, + "total_seconds": 0.16270569211337715, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.15241866500582546, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.1745542767457664 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.5511011517924298e-14, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 9.703417313949837e-16, + "initial_projection_relative_error": 0.06838985347738513, + "minimum_eigenvalue_before_clipping": 2.568215006162144e-12 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562937.058737, + 1792562937.5540795 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n32_full_chebyshev_bessel.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n32_full_chebyshev_bessel.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..740a2d86296f26e82fe6000978a2c1cb8d2c576e --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n32_full_chebyshev_bessel.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:f275d4b26c89e206084effe3f8255c17bbbbc6cfe1f3f3a604ceb5c127e6241f +size 61101 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n32_full_chebyshev_bessel_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n32_full_chebyshev_bessel_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8d7668b560eb126111d86add633f0abe360549cb --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n32_full_chebyshev_bessel_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,67 @@ +{ + "material": "smooth_checker", + "grid": 32, + "method": "full_chebyshev_bessel", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 1024, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.0017899100203067064, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 1.1303812559926882, + "receiver_output": 0.0 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.001541278907097876, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 1.1300568119622767, + "receiver_output": 0.0 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0017265640199184418, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 1.130367820034735, + "receiver_output": 0.0 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.0017265640199184418, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 1.130367820034735, + "receiver_output": 0.0, + "total_seconds": 1.1320943840546533, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1315980908693746, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.132171166012995 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "polynomial_degree": 810, + "squared_frequency_upper_bound": 34306.82374256898, + "uniform_cosine_tail_bound": 9.063054334020532e-18, + "tail_tolerance": 1e-17, + "setup_seconds": 0.0004603309789672494, + "recurrence_and_observation_seconds": 0.0216887800488621, + "coefficient_and_output_seconds": 1.1081912060035393, + "total_seconds": 1.1303403170313686 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562858.9805315, + 1792562862.376466 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n32_full_sparse_exponential.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n32_full_sparse_exponential.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..320a60cb0e741f8c551d7cec3c86bc644eb440d9 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n32_full_sparse_exponential.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:b4e94fc9591a4f781dbb5e69f737c21c3d32b9eb4a829856b8a551d09bf5b992 +size 61092 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n32_full_sparse_exponential_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n32_full_sparse_exponential_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f9adc734f29c7fff901a5e5b1d6cbd6c97c99788 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n32_full_sparse_exponential_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +{ + "material": "smooth_checker", + "grid": 32, + "method": "full_sparse_exponential", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 1024, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.0015089740045368671, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 3.7659836430102587, + "receiver_output": 0.0030540659790858626 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0014092259807512164, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 3.7851233929395676, + "receiver_output": 0.0038114235503599048 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0013984229881316423, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 3.7566601425642148, + "receiver_output": 0.003212480922229588 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.0014092259807512164, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 3.7659836430102587, + "receiver_output": 0.003212480922229588, + "total_seconds": 3.7705466829938814, + "minimum_total_seconds": 3.761271046474576, + "maximum_total_seconds": 3.7903440424706787 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "energy_relative_drift": 5.995204332975845e-15 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562420.1669126, + 1792562431.4931424 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n32_rational_krylov_m128.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n32_rational_krylov_m128.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..908b25665b186ef332e0b0978f95bcbcbb760cc6 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n32_rational_krylov_m128.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:c3822a082cb17dafa6a011b1ab6389726b002dabb9426bbf8cba071fa6cb3807 +size 79489 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n32_rational_krylov_m128_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n32_rational_krylov_m128_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..eaa441c027b1a61b7d7b579d257e98af928ad80e --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n32_rational_krylov_m128_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +{ + "material": "smooth_checker", + "grid": 32, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 288, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.0015083859907463193, + "basis": 0.10102381207980216, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.010363409062847495, + "propagation": 0.004301368957385421, + "receiver_output": 0.0008320669876411557 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.00150186603423208, + "basis": 0.10104418091941625, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.010373472003266215, + "propagation": 0.0042700229678303, + "receiver_output": 0.0017510029720142484 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0014853060711175203, + "basis": 0.10085132601670921, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.010406965971924365, + "propagation": 0.004501137998886406, + "receiver_output": 0.0015943660400807858 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.00150186603423208, + "basis": 0.10102381207980216, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.010373472003266215, + "propagation": 0.004301368957385421, + "receiver_output": 0.0015943660400807858, + "total_seconds": 0.11883910209871829, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.11802904307842255, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.11894054489675909 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "iterations": 50, + "distinct_shift_factorizations": 12, + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.4822314843640827e-14, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 6.565968459040012e-16, + "initial_projection_relative_error": 6.55841316497952e-16, + "minimum_eigenvalue_before_clipping": 1.3614752306589082e-15 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562937.5572908, + 1792562937.9203196 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_craig_bampton_m128.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_craig_bampton_m128.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ebec34483a3ecffa007bc2d4c0fbd0e7ad10e562 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_craig_bampton_m128.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:f6a79193a4238eb8e44c2b3bf5b48fa94075f5a1c02e083c02814ab8b23ed1ae +size 81421 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_craig_bampton_m128_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_craig_bampton_m128_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..238129b3284dac0a278ff1795270b0101ac108c0 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_craig_bampton_m128_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,63 @@ +{ + "material": "smooth_checker", + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 320, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.002473224070854485, + "basis": 0.5273918058956042, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.04095751803833991, + "propagation": 0.004724600003100932, + "receiver_output": 0.0010110249277204275 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0026729509700089693, + "basis": 0.5149788960115984, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.03905342204961926, + "propagation": 0.004580879933200777, + "receiver_output": 0.0009388809558004141 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0026140030240640044, + "basis": 0.5019563210662454, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.03972586302552372, + "propagation": 0.004601273103617132, + "receiver_output": 0.0010886540403589606 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.0026140030240640044, + "basis": 0.5149788960115984, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.03972586302552372, + "propagation": 0.004601273103617132, + "receiver_output": 0.0010110249277204275, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.3057719514598152e-14, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 7.785643042623889e-16, + "initial_projection_relative_error": 0.055039370532467505, + "minimum_eigenvalue_before_clipping": 1.9552696292213113e-12 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562937.9235737, + 1792562939.6356668 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_full_chebyshev_bessel.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_full_chebyshev_bessel.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..258ae0e797d99e23245cf4e6c2d3a756e87545e9 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_full_chebyshev_bessel.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:74c8e5708694ba42e08be7dce14d79091f8f9683b7ccfef0370d357b2b5a6f7e +size 61103 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_full_chebyshev_bessel_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_full_chebyshev_bessel_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a65fa28f94612941c2bd68ddaf86b8f36904785d --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_full_chebyshev_bessel_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,67 @@ +{ + "material": "smooth_checker", + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_chebyshev_bessel", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 4096, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.0027093299431726336, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 2.340760395047255, + "receiver_output": 0.0 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0027650550473481417, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 2.330922737950459, + "receiver_output": 0.0 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.002481553005054593, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 2.3329312020214275, + "receiver_output": 0.0 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.0027093299431726336, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 2.3329312020214275, + "receiver_output": 0.0, + "total_seconds": 2.335412755026482, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3336877929978073, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.3434697249904275 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "polynomial_degree": 1757, + "squared_frequency_upper_bound": 173407.5163806516, + "uniform_cosine_tail_bound": 7.389391644593892e-18, + "tail_tolerance": 1e-17, + "setup_seconds": 0.0007621429394930601, + "recurrence_and_observation_seconds": 0.14429615205153823, + "coefficient_and_output_seconds": 2.1878464149776846, + "total_seconds": 2.332904709968716 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562862.3792796, + 1792562869.391928 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_full_sparse_exponential.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_full_sparse_exponential.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b3b625d51d8046675190dd670713294f86133b9a --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_full_sparse_exponential.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:89c46b54b2374ad7de2ff04b3f908abab8e385946effbf794cd470601efffbe8 +size 61095 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_full_sparse_exponential_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_full_sparse_exponential_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a9c5fdf5a40f45a87dd3b092e067a5f06af2aeb9 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_full_sparse_exponential_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +{ + "material": "smooth_checker", + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_sparse_exponential", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 4096, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.0023692119866609573, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 12.63831918896176, + "receiver_output": 0.020078026922419667 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.00226467102766037, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 12.594975799904205, + "receiver_output": 0.020675674895755947 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.002240255009382963, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 12.634311063098721, + "receiver_output": 0.02066307608038187 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.00226467102766037, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 12.634311063098721, + "receiver_output": 0.02066307608038187, + "total_seconds": 12.657214394188486, + "minimum_total_seconds": 12.617916145827621, + "maximum_total_seconds": 12.66076642787084 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "energy_relative_drift": 8.881784197001252e-15 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562431.4959388, + 1792562469.4441109 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..aa4f4750d44c5b745fee6143ff8f261d976a98e2 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:d4b473782225f00bafd43e6631d25759fbc6b2b34636a2832e86b0bc165c541f +size 61097 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..39e419b954319f012ae5e9c1acb041e206a2de11 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +{ + "material": "smooth_checker", + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.125, + "dimension": 4096, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.0028975660679861903, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 0.7161346096545458, + "receiver_output": 0.008418195531703532 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0030047630425542593, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 0.7449197277892381, + "receiver_output": 0.008141518803313375 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0030165989883244038, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 0.720310983248055, + "receiver_output": 0.00847365241497755 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.0030047630425542593, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 0.720310983248055, + "receiver_output": 0.008418195531703532, + "total_seconds": 0.7318012346513569, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.7274503712542355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.7560660096351057 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "requested_cfl": 0.125, + "actual_cfl": 0.11906468508886248, + "time_step": 0.00078125, + "substeps_per_output": 16, + "time_steps": 10240, + "sufficient_stability_product": 0.3253299072820911 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562897.593775, + 1792562899.8099082 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..24c7be8d46508e728cb80cc9e2016312ea3b9a7c --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:881cea39e7e14ba3ca6d2fece112657119b0ae79c0469453212eeeeda52bc75b +size 61075 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..abcb5088e082bd154add8f2c607580611d807959 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +{ + "material": "smooth_checker", + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "dimension": 4096, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.003001153003424406, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 0.3643468504305929, + "receiver_output": 0.00884823000524193 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0027238919865339994, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 0.3504037290113047, + "receiver_output": 0.00914771156385541 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0029025430558249354, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 0.37172633269801736, + "receiver_output": 0.007563416729681194 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.0029025430558249354, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 0.3643468504305929, + "receiver_output": 0.00884823000524193, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "actual_cfl": 0.23812937017772495, + "time_step": 0.0015625, + "substeps_per_output": 8, + "time_steps": 5120, + "sufficient_stability_product": 0.6506598145641822 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562896.46956, + 1792562897.590987 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_rational_krylov_m128.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_rational_krylov_m128.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6f882c3bb449232a8991639eb5e80765e49a3c5d --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_rational_krylov_m128.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:aad972eae6c583f38623e9c0c06367f2a02de9cf7d2711a11bfebfdf07facbc5 +size 81449 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_rational_krylov_m128_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_rational_krylov_m128_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1ae902f16fcd3798718b6b013cfd909281e69f41 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n64_rational_krylov_m128_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +{ + "material": "smooth_checker", + "grid": 64, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 320, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.002683218917809427, + "basis": 0.4578327090712264, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0262264619814232, + "propagation": 0.004768413957208395, + "receiver_output": 0.001058660913258791 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0027226770762354136, + "basis": 0.4624390359967947, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.027538290014490485, + "propagation": 0.00492544996086508, + "receiver_output": 0.0010794419795274734 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0027221549535170197, + "basis": 0.45832470897585154, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.027579798945225775, + "propagation": 0.004808791098184884, + "receiver_output": 0.0009410270722582936 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.0027221549535170197, + "basis": 0.45832470897585154, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.027538290014490485, + "propagation": 0.004808791098184884, + "receiver_output": 0.001058660913258791, + "total_seconds": 0.4943764810450375, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.49256946484092623, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.49870489502791315 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "iterations": 56, + "distinct_shift_factorizations": 12, + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.350427938625787e-14, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 7.386439523790452e-16, + "initial_projection_relative_error": 7.765308543043786e-16, + "minimum_eigenvalue_before_clipping": 5.5451944856273604e-14 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562939.6390462, + 1792562941.1625388 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_craig_bampton_m128.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_craig_bampton_m128.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0e90c277d6067330e632a27c16e9780e707c9b46 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_craig_bampton_m128.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:c44e3f9dff07759883b25d55ca9854e949809b45b384562e2d5fa59616cb3747 +size 83326 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_craig_bampton_m128_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_craig_bampton_m128_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..36cdc032b420b5caef99e5eb85893bd1e32a1e68 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_craig_bampton_m128_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,63 @@ +{ + "material": "smooth_checker", + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 352, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.004380636033602059, + "basis": 0.9229065000545233, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.08168340101838112, + "propagation": 0.005719200009480119, + "receiver_output": 0.001169706112705171 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.004598792060278356, + "basis": 0.9385083169909194, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.07863723207265139, + "propagation": 0.00542672595474869, + "receiver_output": 0.001183781074360013 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.004547217977233231, + "basis": 0.928005127934739, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0784647410036996, + "propagation": 0.005782611086033285, + "receiver_output": 0.00119652203284204 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.004547217977233231, + "basis": 0.928005127934739, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.07863723207265139, + "propagation": 0.005719200009480119, + "receiver_output": 0.001183781074360013, + "total_seconds": 1.0179962200345472, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0158594432286918, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0283548481529579 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.1758112560016067e-14, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 9.294613741551772e-16, + "initial_projection_relative_error": 0.05194826850895303, + "minimum_eigenvalue_before_clipping": 4.533568866652717e-12 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562941.1659272, + 1792562944.291076 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_craig_bampton_m256.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_craig_bampton_m256.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6e609332067dd3d2ce07b393a07f3beca7e9fc75 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_craig_bampton_m256.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:1642e34214e348445801bed4a1412af8aac7901072cc01310e0c661bb8739ae8 +size 99115 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_craig_bampton_m256_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_craig_bampton_m256_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e52341a295e6a6c40dcaad811d9e080a0396e6ba --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_craig_bampton_m256_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,63 @@ +{ + "material": "smooth_checker", + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 256, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 608, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.0045273000141605735, + "basis": 2.8141247099265456, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.1889573629014194, + "propagation": 0.008673436008393764, + "receiver_output": 0.0035035100299865007 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.00464958802331239, + "basis": 2.891860909992829, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.19279750797431916, + "propagation": 0.009893389069475234, + "receiver_output": 0.0034821160370483994 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0046059140004217625, + "basis": 2.8027763220015913, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.18901984998956323, + "propagation": 0.008675151970237494, + "receiver_output": 0.003466843976639211 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.0046059140004217625, + "basis": 2.8141247099265456, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.18901984998956323, + "propagation": 0.008675151970237494, + "receiver_output": 0.0034821160370483994, + "total_seconds": 3.019786318880506, + "minimum_total_seconds": 3.008544081938453, + "maximum_total_seconds": 3.102683511096984 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.7634812470181968e-14, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 9.475576662176245e-16, + "initial_projection_relative_error": 0.02130000885333085, + "minimum_eigenvalue_before_clipping": 2.2564074073315455e-12 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562948.280663, + 1792562957.53962 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_full_chebyshev_bessel.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_full_chebyshev_bessel.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ab1efa88d92ecba6b6d7407668d1be542e697790 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_full_chebyshev_bessel.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:abe9eec6fd2b7c3fa3ec07add9b10a334b7f2162f6dcf0818438502a969014bc +size 61091 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_full_chebyshev_bessel_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_full_chebyshev_bessel_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..33d8758f1fb114f8a835c310ec2aa2f566745a46 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_full_chebyshev_bessel_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,67 @@ +{ + "material": "smooth_checker", + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_chebyshev_bessel", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 9216, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.004420735058374703, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 3.708504400914535, + "receiver_output": 0.0 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0056879069888964295, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 3.71470192191191, + "receiver_output": 0.0 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.004665698972530663, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 3.7077307020081207, + "receiver_output": 0.0 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.004665698972530663, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 3.708504400914535, + "receiver_output": 0.0, + "total_seconds": 3.7129251359729096, + "minimum_total_seconds": 3.7123964009806514, + "maximum_total_seconds": 3.7203898289008066 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "polynomial_degree": 2662, + "squared_frequency_upper_bound": 408609.93696304347, + "uniform_cosine_tail_bound": 9.977611960801328e-18, + "tail_tolerance": 1e-17, + "setup_seconds": 0.0012406620662659407, + "recurrence_and_observation_seconds": 0.5221471289405599, + "coefficient_and_output_seconds": 3.1843171230284497, + "total_seconds": 3.7077049140352756 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562869.3952847, + 1792562880.5411394 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_full_sparse_exponential.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_full_sparse_exponential.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9f8a39cd50a01106fad5cde26d3cca0e31be20c4 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_full_sparse_exponential.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:12c4fa7739f02c877760b40fc8c9e3f66aa25e5b3d2607d1c53052b8e8caaea8 +size 61099 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_full_sparse_exponential_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_full_sparse_exponential_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6fdd2851f75b0fb7d81f816dd220b3ad5f99cfde --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_full_sparse_exponential_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +{ + "material": "smooth_checker", + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_sparse_exponential", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 9216, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.0037190400762483478, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 35.866834074724466, + "receiver_output": 0.04673824494238943 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.003914445987902582, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 35.747313757194206, + "receiver_output": 0.0468965390464291 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.004007595009170473, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 35.73464027896989, + "receiver_output": 0.04671198292635381 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.003914445987902582, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 35.747313757194206, + "receiver_output": 0.04673824494238943, + "total_seconds": 35.79812474222854, + "minimum_total_seconds": 35.785359856905416, + "maximum_total_seconds": 35.9172913597431 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "energy_relative_drift": 1.7319479184152442e-14 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562469.4468427, + 1792562576.9748054 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..bf27a3b0264ab1f1147089403dcc569107245d41 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:cd1bac2f8e8c22c8749f1c3403d6375210344ae6e27e5b053331de5a71fe48e0 +size 61092 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..55a72c4d7ba3f8635757ca11fce8dc8e5b0625a9 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p125_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +{ + "material": "smooth_checker", + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.125, + "dimension": 9216, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.004543020040728152, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 2.448160954983905, + "receiver_output": 0.023876106832176447 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.0050200719852000475, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 2.4450298039009795, + "receiver_output": 0.023042514687404037 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.004615832935087383, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 2.452644369797781, + "receiver_output": 0.023537866189144552 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.004615832935087383, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 2.448160954983905, + "receiver_output": 0.023537866189144552, + "total_seconds": 2.4765800818568096, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.4730923905735835, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.480798068922013 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "requested_cfl": 0.125, + "actual_cfl": 0.12474947376382348, + "time_step": 0.0005434782608695652, + "substeps_per_output": 23, + "time_steps": 14720, + "sufficient_stability_product": 0.3474054593907648 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562903.7567875, + 1792562911.1884494 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..466b3c45f6f1edb9547d2fefc32ac06e9709eb3f --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:cb27b2fb21730ca7e84cb18fcaa4cd98b1976fd64cbeb2344cbd15296ee7d104 +size 61069 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f5a5e25d5a7f6e1035c20a931c63160de1f77b4e --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_full_stormer_verlet_cfl0p25_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +{ + "material": "smooth_checker", + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "dimension": 9216, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.004771686973981559, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 1.2869888363638893, + "receiver_output": 0.02329036360606551 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.00462446897290647, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 1.2862103137886152, + "receiver_output": 0.023287568939849734 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.004560559988021851, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 1.286251725628972, + "receiver_output": 0.020380604662932456 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.00462446897290647, + "basis": 0.0, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.0, + "propagation": 1.286251725628972, + "receiver_output": 0.023287568939849734, + "total_seconds": 1.3141223517013714, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.3111928902799264, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.3150508869439363 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "actual_cfl": 0.2391031580473283, + "time_step": 0.0010416666666666667, + "substeps_per_output": 12, + "time_steps": 7680, + "sufficient_stability_product": 0.6658604638322991 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562899.8126562, + 1792562903.7541409 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_rational_krylov_m128.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_rational_krylov_m128.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ee8cb99fad2d47f4d57f959214cc4c09c9d63a6b --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_rational_krylov_m128.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:dfb860c27dca177de996c5eddbf2e3e460debc12d03c6fa7f489902316231108 +size 83429 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_rational_krylov_m128_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_rational_krylov_m128_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b83c021b00d180fc2715c39d040d05792afc0511 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_rational_krylov_m128_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +{ + "material": "smooth_checker", + "grid": 96, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 352, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.004558391985483468, + "basis": 1.1900381749728695, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.08217068400699645, + "propagation": 0.005975052015855908, + "receiver_output": 0.0011981340358033776 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.004551674937829375, + "basis": 1.2082088249735534, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.08543501095846295, + "propagation": 0.0060031559551134706, + "receiver_output": 0.001211642986163497 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.004575494094751775, + "basis": 1.2113233560230583, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.08368598204106092, + "propagation": 0.006229733000509441, + "receiver_output": 0.001203841995447874 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.004558391985483468, + "basis": 1.2082088249735534, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.08368598204106092, + "propagation": 0.0060031559551134706, + "receiver_output": 0.001203841995447874, + "total_seconds": 1.3054103098111227, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.2839404370170087, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.3070184071548283 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "iterations": 61, + "distinct_shift_factorizations": 12, + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.2627805773807072e-14, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 6.952487326288124e-16, + "initial_projection_relative_error": 8.840206560810853e-16, + "minimum_eigenvalue_before_clipping": 3.813583356305568e-14 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562944.2944915, + 1792562948.2772334 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_rational_krylov_m256.npz b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_rational_krylov_m256.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..db206e6ecf23f1ac830ca2d7d0b91386365d063d --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_rational_krylov_m256.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:c85149464cef3f24d0b1491774466c11d8aca874abdafea37836ade6bdd78c15 +size 99138 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_rational_krylov_m256_timing.json b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_rational_krylov_m256_timing.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fdaadc7678256ccf47007b12723ed44c837f0ecf --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/smooth/smooth_checker_n96_rational_krylov_m256_timing.json @@ -0,0 +1,65 @@ +{ + "material": "smooth_checker", + "grid": 96, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "modes_per_patch": 256, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 608, + "repetitions": [ + { + "assembly": 0.0045126230688765645, + "basis": 2.682134661008604, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.20161047403234988, + "propagation": 0.011454367078840733, + "receiver_output": 0.0035868369741365314 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.00474261399358511, + "basis": 2.678215009975247, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.18558224209118634, + "propagation": 0.01136765896808356, + "receiver_output": 0.0035482499515637755 + }, + { + "assembly": 0.004688134999014437, + "basis": 2.494059769087471, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.18458060803823173, + "propagation": 0.010627237963490188, + "receiver_output": 0.0035384460352361202 + } + ], + "median": { + "assembly": 0.004688134999014437, + "basis": 2.678215009975247, + "projection_eigensolve": 0.18558224209118634, + "propagation": 0.01136765896808356, + "receiver_output": 0.0035482499515637755, + "total_seconds": 2.883455774979666, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.6974941961234435, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.9032989621628076 + }, + "diagnostics": { + "iterations": 106, + "distinct_shift_factorizations": 12, + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.7666589378158556e-14, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 7.31425639270592e-16, + "initial_projection_relative_error": 9.186953130689992e-16, + "minimum_eigenvalue_before_clipping": 3.8135833563056156e-14 + }, + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "config_sha256": "82aa64233079f4fbe10b5ad5bcf23c9d987e12ee1374ebfe42f851d58c79651b", + "code_sha256": "87591df27171eb04e4872ad83190422b27c55201fd4b36927d60f4c219d9ddc6", + "dependency_sha256": { + "acoustic_core.py": "f7d6365682131c1de9b89c3f548ec77945b590c37632810f0bc8bc22efe7d454", + "accuracy_cost/run.py": "7bf6060430dd46f92ecb6c22e5a89c871dc2e8d6569ae1196c211747e8e4d7b5", + "accuracy_cost/config.json": "a44df54373a754f8b41147b37b13d57c41cdf62a1bafedb71f97dda01686addb", + "propagation/chebyshev_reference.py": "212a3bbc5d95295523fc5b85702503a555f49c74564b275f6031c8e9e9deddbb" + }, + "timed_interval_unix": [ + 1792562957.543501, + 1792562966.1526275 + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/summary.json b/total_error_cost/results/summary.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..013f5d9033b41da76d18d7828b253efdf79c7fd6 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/summary.json @@ -0,0 +1,460 @@ +{ + "reference_grid": 512, + "alternative_reference_grid": 384, + "error_windows": [ + 2.0, + 8.0 + ], + "timing_time_end": 8.0, + "norm": "Frobenius norm of three-source, four-receiver traces at all output times, including t=0.", + "reference_scope": "Finite-grid comparison; neither the finest grid nor successive-grid differences certify continuum accuracy.", + "timing_scope": "Fresh receiver-output experiment; independent assembly and reduced basis for each three-source query. No field-output timing is included.", + "complete": true, + "expected_timed_candidates_per_material": 26, + "completed_timed_candidates": { + "rotated_stripes": 26, + "double_inclusion": 26, + "smooth_checker": 26 + }, + "number_error_rows": 312, + "material_rows": { + "rotated_stripes": 104, + "double_inclusion": 104, + "smooth_checker": 104 + }, + "maximum_error_identity_residual": 9.71445146547012e-17, + "selections": [ + { + "material": "rotated_stripes", + "receiver_tolerance": 0.05, + "tested_candidates": 26, + "passing_candidates": 8, + "least_cost_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "dimension": 16384, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "reference_grid_difference": 0.002293040730416934, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379, + "primary_margin": 0.007407831436043656, + "alternative_margin": 0.009539481806832513 + }, + "least_cost_reduced": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 384, + "total_receiver_error": 0.028692121733248043, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.02692184900793251, + "reference_grid_difference": 0.002293040730416934, + "total_seconds": 1.8773641479201615, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.8768734860932454, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.8809097211342305, + "primary_margin": 0.02130787826675196, + "alternative_margin": 0.023078150992067493 + }, + "least_cost_any": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 384, + "total_receiver_error": 0.028692121733248043, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.02692184900793251, + "reference_grid_difference": 0.002293040730416934, + "total_seconds": 1.8773641479201615, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.8768734860932454, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.8809097211342305, + "primary_margin": 0.02130787826675196, + "alternative_margin": 0.023078150992067493 + }, + "least_cost_any_alternative_reference": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 384, + "total_receiver_error": 0.028692121733248043, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.02692184900793251, + "reference_grid_difference": 0.002293040730416934, + "total_seconds": 1.8773641479201615, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.8768734860932454, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.8809097211342305, + "primary_margin": 0.02130787826675196, + "alternative_margin": 0.023078150992067493 + }, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true, + "candidates_changing_threshold_classification": 0, + "speedup_over_least_cost_passing_full": 1.2948883344276867, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.2704393613678513, + "slowest_full_over_fastest_reduced": 1.3301995522027126, + "timing_ranges_separated_in_favor_of_reduced": true + }, + { + "material": "rotated_stripes", + "receiver_tolerance": 0.1, + "tested_candidates": 26, + "passing_candidates": 16, + "least_cost_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "dimension": 9216, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "reference_grid_difference": 0.002293040730416934, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484, + "primary_margin": 0.02534665531969882, + "alternative_margin": 0.027257420760248507 + }, + "least_cost_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 352, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "reference_grid_difference": 0.002293040730416934, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087, + "primary_margin": 0.03913826639233871, + "alternative_margin": 0.04111521048392789 + }, + "least_cost_any": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 352, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "reference_grid_difference": 0.002293040730416934, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087, + "primary_margin": 0.03913826639233871, + "alternative_margin": 0.04111521048392789 + }, + "least_cost_any_alternative_reference": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 352, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "reference_grid_difference": 0.002293040730416934, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087, + "primary_margin": 0.03913826639233871, + "alternative_margin": 0.04111521048392789 + }, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true, + "candidates_changing_threshold_classification": 0, + "speedup_over_least_cost_passing_full": 1.100430644339551, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.0780190172110273, + "slowest_full_over_fastest_reduced": 1.1268333319315524, + "timing_ranges_separated_in_favor_of_reduced": true + }, + { + "material": "double_inclusion", + "receiver_tolerance": 0.05, + "tested_candidates": 26, + "passing_candidates": 8, + "least_cost_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "dimension": 16384, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "reference_grid_difference": 0.0020215697514913444, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726, + "primary_margin": 0.011647132522322731, + "alternative_margin": 0.013641030337145414 + }, + "least_cost_reduced": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 384, + "total_receiver_error": 0.025925649049562165, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.02435135574390486, + "reference_grid_difference": 0.0020215697514913444, + "total_seconds": 1.8647517159115523, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.8503011669963598, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.866754246992059, + "primary_margin": 0.024074350950437837, + "alternative_margin": 0.025648644256095143 + }, + "least_cost_any": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 384, + "total_receiver_error": 0.025925649049562165, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.02435135574390486, + "reference_grid_difference": 0.0020215697514913444, + "total_seconds": 1.8647517159115523, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.8503011669963598, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.866754246992059, + "primary_margin": 0.024074350950437837, + "alternative_margin": 0.025648644256095143 + }, + "least_cost_any_alternative_reference": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 384, + "total_receiver_error": 0.025925649049562165, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.02435135574390486, + "reference_grid_difference": 0.0020215697514913444, + "total_seconds": 1.8647517159115523, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.8503011669963598, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.866754246992059, + "primary_margin": 0.024074350950437837, + "alternative_margin": 0.025648644256095143 + }, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true, + "candidates_changing_threshold_classification": 0, + "speedup_over_least_cost_passing_full": 1.2765681765107892, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.2659331591205356, + "slowest_full_over_fastest_reduced": 1.3222812362251184, + "timing_ranges_separated_in_favor_of_reduced": true + }, + { + "material": "double_inclusion", + "receiver_tolerance": 0.1, + "tested_candidates": 26, + "passing_candidates": 16, + "least_cost_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "dimension": 9216, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "reference_grid_difference": 0.0020215697514913444, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135, + "primary_margin": 0.03031158820073178, + "alternative_margin": 0.032247225981922034 + }, + "least_cost_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 352, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "reference_grid_difference": 0.0020215697514913444, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331, + "primary_margin": 0.044473235375689694, + "alternative_margin": 0.04635874115245533 + }, + "least_cost_any": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 352, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "reference_grid_difference": 0.0020215697514913444, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331, + "primary_margin": 0.044473235375689694, + "alternative_margin": 0.04635874115245533 + }, + "least_cost_any_alternative_reference": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 352, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "reference_grid_difference": 0.0020215697514913444, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331, + "primary_margin": 0.044473235375689694, + "alternative_margin": 0.04635874115245533 + }, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true, + "candidates_changing_threshold_classification": 0, + "speedup_over_least_cost_passing_full": 1.0957197134953611, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.0710400558280317, + "slowest_full_over_fastest_reduced": 1.1050426145004932, + "timing_ranges_separated_in_favor_of_reduced": true + }, + { + "material": "smooth_checker", + "receiver_tolerance": 0.05, + "tested_candidates": 26, + "passing_candidates": 16, + "least_cost_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "dimension": 9216, + "total_receiver_error": 0.044935848571036587, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04370730851521943, + "reference_grid_difference": 0.0013149765202111567, + "total_seconds": 1.3141223517013714, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.3111928902799264, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.3150508869439363, + "primary_margin": 0.005064151428963416, + "alternative_margin": 0.006292691484780573 + }, + "least_cost_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 352, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03902036900814143, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03778413248391995, + "reference_grid_difference": 0.0013149765202111567, + "total_seconds": 1.0179962200345472, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0158594432286918, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0283548481529579, + "primary_margin": 0.010979630991858572, + "alternative_margin": 0.012215867516080052 + }, + "least_cost_any": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 352, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03902036900814143, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03778413248391995, + "reference_grid_difference": 0.0013149765202111567, + "total_seconds": 1.0179962200345472, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0158594432286918, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0283548481529579, + "primary_margin": 0.010979630991858572, + "alternative_margin": 0.012215867516080052 + }, + "least_cost_any_alternative_reference": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 352, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03902036900814143, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03778413248391995, + "reference_grid_difference": 0.0013149765202111567, + "total_seconds": 1.0179962200345472, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0158594432286918, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0283548481529579, + "primary_margin": 0.010979630991858572, + "alternative_margin": 0.012215867516080052 + }, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true, + "candidates_changing_threshold_classification": 0, + "speedup_over_least_cost_passing_full": 1.290891189808912, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.2750393433112877, + "slowest_full_over_fastest_reduced": 1.294520512369633, + "timing_ranges_separated_in_favor_of_reduced": true + }, + { + "material": "smooth_checker", + "receiver_tolerance": 0.1, + "tested_candidates": 26, + "passing_candidates": 22, + "least_cost_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "dimension": 4096, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "reference_grid_difference": 0.0013149765202111567, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235, + "primary_margin": 0.002160883184336368, + "alternative_margin": 0.0032661666302474246 + }, + "least_cost_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "dimension": 320, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09836542367031906, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0972612760342237, + "reference_grid_difference": 0.0013149765202111567, + "total_seconds": 0.4943764810450375, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.49256946484092623, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.49870489502791315, + "primary_margin": 0.001634576329680948, + "alternative_margin": 0.0027387239657763046 + }, + "least_cost_any": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "dimension": 4096, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "reference_grid_difference": 0.0013149765202111567, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235, + "primary_margin": 0.002160883184336368, + "alternative_margin": 0.0032661666302474246 + }, + "least_cost_any_alternative_reference": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "dimension": 4096, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "reference_grid_difference": 0.0013149765202111567, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235, + "primary_margin": 0.002160883184336368, + "alternative_margin": 0.0032661666302474246 + }, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true, + "candidates_changing_threshold_classification": 0, + "speedup_over_least_cost_passing_full": 0.7609509106178292, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 0.7264322772316423, + "slowest_full_over_fastest_reduced": 0.7759155200717757, + "timing_ranges_separated_in_favor_of_reduced": false + } + ] +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/tolerance_cost_envelope.json b/total_error_cost/results/tolerance_cost_envelope.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..879c7a93740960a81a00ae278151bd71a83ab83c --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/tolerance_cost_envelope.json @@ -0,0 +1,5625 @@ +{ + "range": [ + 0.05, + 0.1 + ], + "interpretation": "Descriptive lower envelopes of the complete tested candidate set. Breakpoints are all candidate errors within the prespecified range, using both propagation references. These intervals do not constitute additional independently tested tolerances.", + "cost": "Median complete receiver-output cost; uncertainty columns give the observed three-run minima and maxima, not confidence intervals.", + "materials": { + "rotated_stripes": { + "breakpoints": [ + 0.05, + 0.058884789516072115, + 0.0608617336076613, + 0.06906655217725774, + 0.07100160777003457, + 0.0727425792397515, + 0.07322958776028375, + 0.07324314035485299, + 0.07336566293479141, + 0.07341596332132123, + 0.07341596332132161, + 0.07465334468030119, + 0.07513712797062325, + 0.075153766448841, + 0.07527332339895759, + 0.07532227220263055, + 0.07532227220263102, + 0.1 + ], + "intervals": [ + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.05, + "upper_tolerance": 0.058884789516072115, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 384, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.028692121733248043, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.02692184900793251, + "total_seconds": 1.8773641479201615, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.8768734860932454, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.8809097211342305 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 384, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.028692121733248043, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.02692184900793251, + "total_seconds": 1.8773641479201615, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.8768734860932454, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.8809097211342305 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.2948883344276867, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.2704393613678513, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.058884789516072115, + "upper_tolerance": 0.0608617336076613, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 384, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.028692121733248043, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.02692184900793251, + "total_seconds": 1.8773641479201615, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.8768734860932454, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.8809097211342305 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.2948883344276867, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.2704393613678513, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.0608617336076613, + "upper_tolerance": 0.06906655217725774, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.3927935436804053, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.328656721931376, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.06906655217725774, + "upper_tolerance": 0.07100160777003457, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.3927935436804053, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.328656721931376, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.07100160777003457, + "upper_tolerance": 0.0727425792397515, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.3927935436804053, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.328656721931376, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.0727425792397515, + "upper_tolerance": 0.07322958776028375, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.3927935436804053, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.328656721931376, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.07322958776028375, + "upper_tolerance": 0.07324314035485299, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.3927935436804053, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.328656721931376, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.07324314035485299, + "upper_tolerance": 0.07336566293479141, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.3927935436804053, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.328656721931376, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.07336566293479141, + "upper_tolerance": 0.07341596332132123, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.3927935436804053, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.328656721931376, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.07341596332132123, + "upper_tolerance": 0.07341596332132161, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.3927935436804053, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.328656721931376, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.07341596332132161, + "upper_tolerance": 0.07465334468030119, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.3927935436804053, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.328656721931376, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.07465334468030119, + "upper_tolerance": 0.07513712797062325, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.100430644339551, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.0780190172110273, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.07513712797062325, + "upper_tolerance": 0.075153766448841, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.100430644339551, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.0780190172110273, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.075153766448841, + "upper_tolerance": 0.07527332339895759, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.100430644339551, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.0780190172110273, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.07527332339895759, + "upper_tolerance": 0.07532227220263055, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.100430644339551, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.0780190172110273, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.07532227220263055, + "upper_tolerance": 0.07532227220263102, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.100430644339551, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.0780190172110273, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.07532227220263102, + "upper_tolerance": 0.1, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.100430644339551, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.0780190172110273, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + } + ], + "endpoint": { + "tolerance": 0.1, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.100430644339551, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.0780190172110273, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + "points": [ + { + "tolerance": 0.05, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 384, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.028692121733248043, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.02692184900793251, + "total_seconds": 1.8773641479201615, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.8768734860932454, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.8809097211342305 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 384, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.028692121733248043, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.02692184900793251, + "total_seconds": 1.8773641479201615, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.8768734860932454, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.8809097211342305 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.2948883344276867, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.2704393613678513, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.058884789516072115, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 384, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.028692121733248043, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.02692184900793251, + "total_seconds": 1.8773641479201615, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.8768734860932454, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.8809097211342305 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.2948883344276867, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.2704393613678513, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.0608617336076613, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.3927935436804053, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.328656721931376, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.06906655217725774, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.3927935436804053, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.328656721931376, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.07100160777003457, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.3927935436804053, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.328656721931376, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.0727425792397515, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.3927935436804053, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.328656721931376, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.07322958776028375, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.3927935436804053, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.328656721931376, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.07324314035485299, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.3927935436804053, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.328656721931376, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.07336566293479141, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.3927935436804053, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.328656721931376, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.07341596332132123, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.3927935436804053, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.328656721931376, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.07341596332132161, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, + "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.3927935436804053, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.328656721931376, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.07465334468030119, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.100430644339551, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.0780190172110273, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.07513712797062325, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.100430644339551, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.0780190172110273, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.075153766448841, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.100430644339551, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.0780190172110273, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.07527332339895759, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.100430644339551, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.0780190172110273, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.07532227220263055, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.100430644339551, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.0780190172110273, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.07532227220263102, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.100430644339551, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.0780190172110273, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.1, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, + "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, + "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.100430644339551, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.0780190172110273, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + } + ] + }, + "double_inclusion": { + "breakpoints": [ + 0.05, + 0.05364125884754468, + 0.05552676462431031, + 0.06359891819300921, + 0.06553728572364939, + 0.06775277401807797, + 0.0684267426397161, + 0.06865081077777506, + 0.06865138809571814, + 0.06865138809572542, + 0.06865362294730532, + 0.06968841179926823, + 0.07036111538948042, + 0.07058476654107904, + 0.07058533485073136, + 0.0705853348507386, + 0.07058776689175697, + 0.1 + ], + "intervals": [ + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.05, + "upper_tolerance": 0.05364125884754468, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 384, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.025925649049562165, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.02435135574390486, + "total_seconds": 1.8647517159115523, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.8503011669963598, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.866754246992059 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 384, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.025925649049562165, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.02435135574390486, + "total_seconds": 1.8647517159115523, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.8503011669963598, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.866754246992059 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.2765681765107892, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.2659331591205356, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.05364125884754468, + "upper_tolerance": 0.05552676462431031, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 384, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.025925649049562165, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.02435135574390486, + "total_seconds": 1.8647517159115523, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.8503011669963598, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.866754246992059 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.2765681765107892, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.2659331591205356, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.05552676462431031, + "upper_tolerance": 0.06359891819300921, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.345817122505405, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.3029176122432364, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.06359891819300921, + "upper_tolerance": 0.06553728572364939, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.345817122505405, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.3029176122432364, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.06553728572364939, + "upper_tolerance": 0.06775277401807797, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.345817122505405, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.3029176122432364, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.06775277401807797, + "upper_tolerance": 0.0684267426397161, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.345817122505405, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.3029176122432364, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.0684267426397161, + "upper_tolerance": 0.06865081077777506, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.345817122505405, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.3029176122432364, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.06865081077777506, + "upper_tolerance": 0.06865138809571814, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.345817122505405, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.3029176122432364, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.06865138809571814, + "upper_tolerance": 0.06865138809572542, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.345817122505405, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.3029176122432364, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.06865138809572542, + "upper_tolerance": 0.06865362294730532, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.345817122505405, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.3029176122432364, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.06865362294730532, + "upper_tolerance": 0.06968841179926823, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.345817122505405, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.3029176122432364, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.06968841179926823, + "upper_tolerance": 0.07036111538948042, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.0957197134953611, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.0710400558280317, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.07036111538948042, + "upper_tolerance": 0.07058476654107904, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.0957197134953611, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.0710400558280317, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.07058476654107904, + "upper_tolerance": 0.07058533485073136, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.0957197134953611, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.0710400558280317, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.07058533485073136, + "upper_tolerance": 0.0705853348507386, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.0957197134953611, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.0710400558280317, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.0705853348507386, + "upper_tolerance": 0.07058776689175697, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.0957197134953611, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.0710400558280317, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.07058776689175697, + "upper_tolerance": 0.1, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.0957197134953611, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.0710400558280317, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + } + ], + "endpoint": { + "tolerance": 0.1, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.0957197134953611, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.0710400558280317, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + "points": [ + { + "tolerance": 0.05, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 384, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.025925649049562165, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.02435135574390486, + "total_seconds": 1.8647517159115523, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.8503011669963598, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.866754246992059 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 384, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.025925649049562165, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.02435135574390486, + "total_seconds": 1.8647517159115523, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.8503011669963598, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.866754246992059 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.2765681765107892, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.2659331591205356, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.05364125884754468, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 384, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.025925649049562165, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.02435135574390486, + "total_seconds": 1.8647517159115523, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.8503011669963598, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.866754246992059 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.2765681765107892, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.2659331591205356, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.05552676462431031, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.345817122505405, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.3029176122432364, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.06359891819300921, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.345817122505405, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.3029176122432364, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.06553728572364939, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.345817122505405, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.3029176122432364, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.06775277401807797, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.345817122505405, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.3029176122432364, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.0684267426397161, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.345817122505405, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.3029176122432364, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.06865081077777506, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.345817122505405, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.3029176122432364, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.06865138809571814, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.345817122505405, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.3029176122432364, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.06865138809572542, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.345817122505405, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.3029176122432364, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.06865362294730532, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 16384, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, + "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, + "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, + "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.345817122505405, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.3029176122432364, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.06968841179926823, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.0957197134953611, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.0710400558280317, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.07036111538948042, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.0957197134953611, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.0710400558280317, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.07058476654107904, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.0957197134953611, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.0710400558280317, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.07058533485073136, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.0957197134953611, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.0710400558280317, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.0705853348507386, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.0957197134953611, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.0710400558280317, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.07058776689175697, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.0957197134953611, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.0710400558280317, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.1, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, + "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, + "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.0957197134953611, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.0710400558280317, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + } + ] + }, + "smooth_checker": { + "breakpoints": [ + 0.05, + 0.09331944567215684, + 0.09443277997273378, + 0.09673383336975258, + 0.09712204979068051, + 0.0972513928210519, + 0.0972513928210566, + 0.0972612760342237, + 0.09783911681566364, + 0.09822656967471333, + 0.09835565876028571, + 0.09835565876029047, + 0.09836542367031906, + 0.1 + ], + "intervals": [ + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.05, + "upper_tolerance": 0.09331944567215684, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.044935848571036587, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04370730851521943, + "total_seconds": 1.3141223517013714, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.3111928902799264, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.3150508869439363 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03902036900814143, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03778413248391995, + "total_seconds": 1.0179962200345472, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0158594432286918, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0283548481529579 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.044935848571036587, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04370730851521943, + "total_seconds": 1.3141223517013714, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.3111928902799264, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.3150508869439363 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03902036900814143, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03778413248391995, + "total_seconds": 1.0179962200345472, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0158594432286918, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0283548481529579 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.290891189808912, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.2750393433112877, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.09331944567215684, + "upper_tolerance": 0.09443277997273378, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.044935848571036587, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04370730851521943, + "total_seconds": 1.3141223517013714, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.3111928902799264, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.3150508869439363 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03902036900814143, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03778413248391995, + "total_seconds": 1.0179962200345472, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0158594432286918, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0283548481529579 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.044935848571036587, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04370730851521943, + "total_seconds": 1.3141223517013714, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.3111928902799264, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.3150508869439363 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09443277997273378, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09331944567215684, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.290891189808912, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.2750393433112877, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.09443277997273378, + "upper_tolerance": 0.09673383336975258, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.044935848571036587, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04370730851521943, + "total_seconds": 1.3141223517013714, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.3111928902799264, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.3150508869439363 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09443277997273378, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09331944567215684, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.044935848571036587, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04370730851521943, + "total_seconds": 1.3141223517013714, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.3111928902799264, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.3150508869439363 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09443277997273378, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09331944567215684, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.33736009918987, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.274172757978296, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.09673383336975258, + "upper_tolerance": 0.09712204979068051, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.044935848571036587, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04370730851521943, + "total_seconds": 1.3141223517013714, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.3111928902799264, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.3150508869439363 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09443277997273378, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09331944567215684, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09443277997273378, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09331944567215684, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.33736009918987, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.274172757978296, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.09712204979068051, + "upper_tolerance": 0.0972513928210519, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.044935848571036587, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04370730851521943, + "total_seconds": 1.3141223517013714, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.3111928902799264, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.3150508869439363 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09443277997273378, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09331944567215684, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09443277997273378, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09331944567215684, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.33736009918987, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.274172757978296, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.0972513928210519, + "upper_tolerance": 0.0972513928210566, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.044935848571036587, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04370730851521943, + "total_seconds": 1.3141223517013714, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.3111928902799264, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.3150508869439363 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09443277997273378, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09331944567215684, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09443277997273378, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09331944567215684, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.33736009918987, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.274172757978296, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.0972513928210566, + "upper_tolerance": 0.0972612760342237, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.044935848571036587, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04370730851521943, + "total_seconds": 1.3141223517013714, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.3111928902799264, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.3150508869439363 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09443277997273378, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09331944567215684, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09443277997273378, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09331944567215684, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.33736009918987, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.274172757978296, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.0972612760342237, + "upper_tolerance": 0.09783911681566364, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.044935848571036587, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04370730851521943, + "total_seconds": 1.3141223517013714, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.3111928902799264, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.3150508869439363 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09443277997273378, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09331944567215684, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09836542367031906, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0972612760342237, + "total_seconds": 0.4943764810450375, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.49256946484092623, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.49870489502791315 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.33736009918987, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.274172757978296, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.09783911681566364, + "upper_tolerance": 0.09822656967471333, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09443277997273378, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09331944567215684, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09836542367031906, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0972612760342237, + "total_seconds": 0.4943764810450375, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.49256946484092623, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.49870489502791315 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 0.6691203938263589, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 0.6283413358224075, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.09822656967471333, + "upper_tolerance": 0.09835565876028571, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09443277997273378, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09331944567215684, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09836542367031906, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0972612760342237, + "total_seconds": 0.4943764810450375, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.49256946484092623, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.49870489502791315 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 0.6691203938263589, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 0.6283413358224075, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.09835565876028571, + "upper_tolerance": 0.09835565876029047, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09443277997273378, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09331944567215684, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09836542367031906, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0972612760342237, + "total_seconds": 0.4943764810450375, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.49256946484092623, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.49870489502791315 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 0.6691203938263589, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 0.6283413358224075, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.09835565876029047, + "upper_tolerance": 0.09836542367031906, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09443277997273378, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09331944567215684, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09836542367031906, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0972612760342237, + "total_seconds": 0.4943764810450375, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.49256946484092623, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.49870489502791315 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 0.6691203938263589, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 0.6283413358224075, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "lower_tolerance": 0.09836542367031906, + "upper_tolerance": 0.1, + "lower_closed": true, + "upper_closed": false, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09836542367031906, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0972612760342237, + "total_seconds": 0.4943764810450375, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.49256946484092623, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.49870489502791315 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09836542367031906, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0972612760342237, + "total_seconds": 0.4943764810450375, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.49256946484092623, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.49870489502791315 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 0.7609509106178292, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 0.7264322772316423, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + } + ], + "endpoint": { + "tolerance": 0.1, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09836542367031906, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0972612760342237, + "total_seconds": 0.4943764810450375, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.49256946484092623, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.49870489502791315 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09836542367031906, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0972612760342237, + "total_seconds": 0.4943764810450375, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.49256946484092623, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.49870489502791315 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 0.7609509106178292, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 0.7264322772316423, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + "points": [ + { + "tolerance": 0.05, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.044935848571036587, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04370730851521943, + "total_seconds": 1.3141223517013714, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.3111928902799264, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.3150508869439363 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03902036900814143, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03778413248391995, + "total_seconds": 1.0179962200345472, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0158594432286918, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0283548481529579 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.044935848571036587, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04370730851521943, + "total_seconds": 1.3141223517013714, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.3111928902799264, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.3150508869439363 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03902036900814143, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03778413248391995, + "total_seconds": 1.0179962200345472, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0158594432286918, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0283548481529579 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.290891189808912, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.2750393433112877, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.09331944567215684, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.044935848571036587, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04370730851521943, + "total_seconds": 1.3141223517013714, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.3111928902799264, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.3150508869439363 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 352, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.03902036900814143, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03778413248391995, + "total_seconds": 1.0179962200345472, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0158594432286918, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0283548481529579 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.044935848571036587, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04370730851521943, + "total_seconds": 1.3141223517013714, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.3111928902799264, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.3150508869439363 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09443277997273378, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09331944567215684, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 1.290891189808912, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.2750393433112877, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.09443277997273378, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.044935848571036587, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04370730851521943, + "total_seconds": 1.3141223517013714, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.3111928902799264, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.3150508869439363 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09443277997273378, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09331944567215684, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.044935848571036587, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04370730851521943, + "total_seconds": 1.3141223517013714, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.3111928902799264, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.3150508869439363 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09443277997273378, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09331944567215684, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.33736009918987, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.274172757978296, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.09673383336975258, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.044935848571036587, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04370730851521943, + "total_seconds": 1.3141223517013714, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.3111928902799264, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.3150508869439363 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09443277997273378, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09331944567215684, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09443277997273378, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09331944567215684, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.33736009918987, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.274172757978296, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.09712204979068051, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.044935848571036587, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04370730851521943, + "total_seconds": 1.3141223517013714, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.3111928902799264, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.3150508869439363 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09443277997273378, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09331944567215684, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09443277997273378, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09331944567215684, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.33736009918987, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.274172757978296, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.0972513928210519, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.044935848571036587, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04370730851521943, + "total_seconds": 1.3141223517013714, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.3111928902799264, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.3150508869439363 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09443277997273378, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09331944567215684, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09443277997273378, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09331944567215684, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.33736009918987, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.274172757978296, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.0972513928210566, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.044935848571036587, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04370730851521943, + "total_seconds": 1.3141223517013714, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.3111928902799264, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.3150508869439363 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09443277997273378, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09331944567215684, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09443277997273378, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09331944567215684, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.33736009918987, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.274172757978296, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.0972612760342237, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 96, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 9216, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.044935848571036587, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04370730851521943, + "total_seconds": 1.3141223517013714, + "minimum_total_seconds": 1.3111928902799264, + "maximum_total_seconds": 1.3150508869439363 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09443277997273378, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09331944567215684, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09836542367031906, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0972612760342237, + "total_seconds": 0.4943764810450375, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.49256946484092623, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.49870489502791315 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 2.33736009918987, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 2.274172757978296, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.09783911681566364, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09443277997273378, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09331944567215684, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09836542367031906, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0972612760342237, + "total_seconds": 0.4943764810450375, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.49256946484092623, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.49870489502791315 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 0.6691203938263589, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 0.6283413358224075, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.09822656967471333, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09443277997273378, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09331944567215684, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09836542367031906, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0972612760342237, + "total_seconds": 0.4943764810450375, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.49256946484092623, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.49870489502791315 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 0.6691203938263589, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 0.6283413358224075, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.09835565876028571, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09443277997273378, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09331944567215684, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09836542367031906, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0972612760342237, + "total_seconds": 0.4943764810450375, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.49256946484092623, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.49870489502791315 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 0.6691203938263589, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 0.6283413358224075, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.09835565876029047, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09443277997273378, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09331944567215684, + "total_seconds": 0.5622250299202278, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.5499861142598093, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.57655817293562 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09836542367031906, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0972612760342237, + "total_seconds": 0.4943764810450375, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.49256946484092623, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.49870489502791315 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 0.6691203938263589, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 0.6283413358224075, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": false + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.09836542367031906, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09836542367031906, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0972612760342237, + "total_seconds": 0.4943764810450375, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.49256946484092623, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.49870489502791315 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09836542367031906, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0972612760342237, + "total_seconds": 0.4943764810450375, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.49256946484092623, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.49870489502791315 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 0.7609509106178292, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 0.7264322772316423, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + }, + { + "tolerance": 0.1, + "primary_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "primary_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09836542367031906, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0972612760342237, + "total_seconds": 0.4943764810450375, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.49256946484092623, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.49870489502791315 + }, + "alternative_full": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_stormer_verlet", + "dimension": 4096, + "modes_per_patch": null, + "requested_cfl": 0.25, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, + "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235 + }, + "alternative_reduced": { + "grid": 64, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "dimension": 320, + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "requested_cfl": null, + "total_receiver_error": 0.09836542367031906, + "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0972612760342237, + "total_seconds": 0.4943764810450375, + "minimum_total_seconds": 0.49256946484092623, + "maximum_total_seconds": 0.49870489502791315 + }, + "median_full_over_reduced": 0.7609509106178292, + "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 0.7264322772316423, + "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true + } + ] + } + } +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/tolerance_cost_intervals.csv b/total_error_cost/results/tolerance_cost_intervals.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6deb0719c67078a2f2106a547d23e1d58690a887 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/tolerance_cost_intervals.csv @@ -0,0 +1,48 @@ +material,lower_tolerance,upper_tolerance,lower_closed,upper_closed,median_full_over_reduced,fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced,selection_unchanged_by_reference,primary_full_grid,primary_full_method,primary_full_dimension,primary_full_modes_per_patch,primary_full_requested_cfl,primary_full_total_receiver_error,primary_full_alternative_reference_total_receiver_error,primary_full_total_seconds,primary_full_minimum_total_seconds,primary_full_maximum_total_seconds,primary_reduced_grid,primary_reduced_method,primary_reduced_dimension,primary_reduced_modes_per_patch,primary_reduced_requested_cfl,primary_reduced_total_receiver_error,primary_reduced_alternative_reference_total_receiver_error,primary_reduced_total_seconds,primary_reduced_minimum_total_seconds,primary_reduced_maximum_total_seconds,alternative_full_grid,alternative_full_method,alternative_full_dimension,alternative_full_modes_per_patch,alternative_full_requested_cfl,alternative_full_total_receiver_error,alternative_full_alternative_reference_total_receiver_error,alternative_full_total_seconds,alternative_full_minimum_total_seconds,alternative_full_maximum_total_seconds,alternative_reduced_grid,alternative_reduced_method,alternative_reduced_dimension,alternative_reduced_modes_per_patch,alternative_reduced_requested_cfl,alternative_reduced_total_receiver_error,alternative_reduced_alternative_reference_total_receiver_error,alternative_reduced_total_seconds,alternative_reduced_minimum_total_seconds,alternative_reduced_maximum_total_seconds +rotated_stripes,0.05,0.058884789516072115,True,False,1.2948883344276867,1.2704393613678513,True,128,full_stormer_verlet,16384,,0.25,0.04259216856395635,0.04046051819316749,2.4309769346145913,2.389581744908355,2.496616270742379,128,craig_bampton,384,128,,0.028692121733248043,0.02692184900793251,1.8773641479201615,1.8768734860932454,1.8809097211342305,128,full_stormer_verlet,16384,,0.25,0.04259216856395635,0.04046051819316749,2.4309769346145913,2.389581744908355,2.496616270742379,128,craig_bampton,384,128,,0.028692121733248043,0.02692184900793251,1.8773641479201615,1.8768734860932454,1.8809097211342305 +rotated_stripes,0.058884789516072115,0.0608617336076613,True,False,1.2948883344276867,1.2704393613678513,False,128,full_stormer_verlet,16384,,0.25,0.04259216856395635,0.04046051819316749,2.4309769346145913,2.389581744908355,2.496616270742379,128,craig_bampton,384,128,,0.028692121733248043,0.02692184900793251,1.8773641479201615,1.8768734860932454,1.8809097211342305,128,full_stormer_verlet,16384,,0.25,0.04259216856395635,0.04046051819316749,2.4309769346145913,2.389581744908355,2.496616270742379,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.0608617336076613,0.058884789516072115,1.0159576621372253,1.0123570379801095,1.026163161965087 +rotated_stripes,0.0608617336076613,0.06906655217725774,True,False,2.3927935436804053,2.328656721931376,True,128,full_stormer_verlet,16384,,0.25,0.04259216856395635,0.04046051819316749,2.4309769346145913,2.389581744908355,2.496616270742379,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.0608617336076613,0.058884789516072115,1.0159576621372253,1.0123570379801095,1.026163161965087,128,full_stormer_verlet,16384,,0.25,0.04259216856395635,0.04046051819316749,2.4309769346145913,2.389581744908355,2.496616270742379,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.0608617336076613,0.058884789516072115,1.0159576621372253,1.0123570379801095,1.026163161965087 +rotated_stripes,0.06906655217725774,0.07100160777003457,True,False,2.3927935436804053,2.328656721931376,True,128,full_stormer_verlet,16384,,0.25,0.04259216856395635,0.04046051819316749,2.4309769346145913,2.389581744908355,2.496616270742379,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.0608617336076613,0.058884789516072115,1.0159576621372253,1.0123570379801095,1.026163161965087,128,full_stormer_verlet,16384,,0.25,0.04259216856395635,0.04046051819316749,2.4309769346145913,2.389581744908355,2.496616270742379,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.0608617336076613,0.058884789516072115,1.0159576621372253,1.0123570379801095,1.026163161965087 +rotated_stripes,0.07100160777003457,0.0727425792397515,True,False,2.3927935436804053,2.328656721931376,True,128,full_stormer_verlet,16384,,0.25,0.04259216856395635,0.04046051819316749,2.4309769346145913,2.389581744908355,2.496616270742379,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.0608617336076613,0.058884789516072115,1.0159576621372253,1.0123570379801095,1.026163161965087,128,full_stormer_verlet,16384,,0.25,0.04259216856395635,0.04046051819316749,2.4309769346145913,2.389581744908355,2.496616270742379,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.0608617336076613,0.058884789516072115,1.0159576621372253,1.0123570379801095,1.026163161965087 +rotated_stripes,0.0727425792397515,0.07322958776028375,True,False,2.3927935436804053,2.328656721931376,False,128,full_stormer_verlet,16384,,0.25,0.04259216856395635,0.04046051819316749,2.4309769346145913,2.389581744908355,2.496616270742379,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.0608617336076613,0.058884789516072115,1.0159576621372253,1.0123570379801095,1.026163161965087,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.07465334468030119,0.0727425792397515,1.1179909447673708,1.1062234033597633,1.140757654211484,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.0608617336076613,0.058884789516072115,1.0159576621372253,1.0123570379801095,1.026163161965087 +rotated_stripes,0.07322958776028375,0.07324314035485299,True,False,2.3927935436804053,2.328656721931376,False,128,full_stormer_verlet,16384,,0.25,0.04259216856395635,0.04046051819316749,2.4309769346145913,2.389581744908355,2.496616270742379,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.0608617336076613,0.058884789516072115,1.0159576621372253,1.0123570379801095,1.026163161965087,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.07465334468030119,0.0727425792397515,1.1179909447673708,1.1062234033597633,1.140757654211484,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.0608617336076613,0.058884789516072115,1.0159576621372253,1.0123570379801095,1.026163161965087 +rotated_stripes,0.07324314035485299,0.07336566293479141,True,False,2.3927935436804053,2.328656721931376,False,128,full_stormer_verlet,16384,,0.25,0.04259216856395635,0.04046051819316749,2.4309769346145913,2.389581744908355,2.496616270742379,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.0608617336076613,0.058884789516072115,1.0159576621372253,1.0123570379801095,1.026163161965087,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.07465334468030119,0.0727425792397515,1.1179909447673708,1.1062234033597633,1.140757654211484,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.0608617336076613,0.058884789516072115,1.0159576621372253,1.0123570379801095,1.026163161965087 +rotated_stripes,0.07336566293479141,0.07341596332132123,True,False,2.3927935436804053,2.328656721931376,False,128,full_stormer_verlet,16384,,0.25,0.04259216856395635,0.04046051819316749,2.4309769346145913,2.389581744908355,2.496616270742379,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.0608617336076613,0.058884789516072115,1.0159576621372253,1.0123570379801095,1.026163161965087,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.07465334468030119,0.0727425792397515,1.1179909447673708,1.1062234033597633,1.140757654211484,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.0608617336076613,0.058884789516072115,1.0159576621372253,1.0123570379801095,1.026163161965087 +rotated_stripes,0.07341596332132123,0.07341596332132161,True,False,2.3927935436804053,2.328656721931376,False,128,full_stormer_verlet,16384,,0.25,0.04259216856395635,0.04046051819316749,2.4309769346145913,2.389581744908355,2.496616270742379,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.0608617336076613,0.058884789516072115,1.0159576621372253,1.0123570379801095,1.026163161965087,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.07465334468030119,0.0727425792397515,1.1179909447673708,1.1062234033597633,1.140757654211484,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.0608617336076613,0.058884789516072115,1.0159576621372253,1.0123570379801095,1.026163161965087 +rotated_stripes,0.07341596332132161,0.07465334468030119,True,False,2.3927935436804053,2.328656721931376,False,128,full_stormer_verlet,16384,,0.25,0.04259216856395635,0.04046051819316749,2.4309769346145913,2.389581744908355,2.496616270742379,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.0608617336076613,0.058884789516072115,1.0159576621372253,1.0123570379801095,1.026163161965087,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.07465334468030119,0.0727425792397515,1.1179909447673708,1.1062234033597633,1.140757654211484,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.0608617336076613,0.058884789516072115,1.0159576621372253,1.0123570379801095,1.026163161965087 +rotated_stripes,0.07465334468030119,0.07513712797062325,True,False,1.100430644339551,1.0780190172110273,True,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.07465334468030119,0.0727425792397515,1.1179909447673708,1.1062234033597633,1.140757654211484,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.0608617336076613,0.058884789516072115,1.0159576621372253,1.0123570379801095,1.026163161965087,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.07465334468030119,0.0727425792397515,1.1179909447673708,1.1062234033597633,1.140757654211484,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.0608617336076613,0.058884789516072115,1.0159576621372253,1.0123570379801095,1.026163161965087 +rotated_stripes,0.07513712797062325,0.075153766448841,True,False,1.100430644339551,1.0780190172110273,True,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.07465334468030119,0.0727425792397515,1.1179909447673708,1.1062234033597633,1.140757654211484,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.0608617336076613,0.058884789516072115,1.0159576621372253,1.0123570379801095,1.026163161965087,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.07465334468030119,0.0727425792397515,1.1179909447673708,1.1062234033597633,1.140757654211484,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.0608617336076613,0.058884789516072115,1.0159576621372253,1.0123570379801095,1.026163161965087 +rotated_stripes,0.075153766448841,0.07527332339895759,True,False,1.100430644339551,1.0780190172110273,True,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.07465334468030119,0.0727425792397515,1.1179909447673708,1.1062234033597633,1.140757654211484,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.0608617336076613,0.058884789516072115,1.0159576621372253,1.0123570379801095,1.026163161965087,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.07465334468030119,0.0727425792397515,1.1179909447673708,1.1062234033597633,1.140757654211484,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.0608617336076613,0.058884789516072115,1.0159576621372253,1.0123570379801095,1.026163161965087 +rotated_stripes,0.07527332339895759,0.07532227220263055,True,False,1.100430644339551,1.0780190172110273,True,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.07465334468030119,0.0727425792397515,1.1179909447673708,1.1062234033597633,1.140757654211484,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.0608617336076613,0.058884789516072115,1.0159576621372253,1.0123570379801095,1.026163161965087,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.07465334468030119,0.0727425792397515,1.1179909447673708,1.1062234033597633,1.140757654211484,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.0608617336076613,0.058884789516072115,1.0159576621372253,1.0123570379801095,1.026163161965087 +rotated_stripes,0.07532227220263055,0.07532227220263102,True,False,1.100430644339551,1.0780190172110273,True,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.07465334468030119,0.0727425792397515,1.1179909447673708,1.1062234033597633,1.140757654211484,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.0608617336076613,0.058884789516072115,1.0159576621372253,1.0123570379801095,1.026163161965087,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.07465334468030119,0.0727425792397515,1.1179909447673708,1.1062234033597633,1.140757654211484,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.0608617336076613,0.058884789516072115,1.0159576621372253,1.0123570379801095,1.026163161965087 +rotated_stripes,0.07532227220263102,0.1,True,False,1.100430644339551,1.0780190172110273,True,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.07465334468030119,0.0727425792397515,1.1179909447673708,1.1062234033597633,1.140757654211484,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.0608617336076613,0.058884789516072115,1.0159576621372253,1.0123570379801095,1.026163161965087,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.07465334468030119,0.0727425792397515,1.1179909447673708,1.1062234033597633,1.140757654211484,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.0608617336076613,0.058884789516072115,1.0159576621372253,1.0123570379801095,1.026163161965087 +double_inclusion,0.05,0.05364125884754468,True,False,1.2765681765107892,1.2659331591205356,True,128,full_stormer_verlet,16384,,0.25,0.03835286747767727,0.03635896966285459,2.380482697626576,2.3631861011963338,2.446618514484726,128,craig_bampton,384,128,,0.025925649049562165,0.02435135574390486,1.8647517159115523,1.8503011669963598,1.866754246992059,128,full_stormer_verlet,16384,,0.25,0.03835286747767727,0.03635896966285459,2.380482697626576,2.3631861011963338,2.446618514484726,128,craig_bampton,384,128,,0.025925649049562165,0.02435135574390486,1.8647517159115523,1.8503011669963598,1.866754246992059 +double_inclusion,0.05364125884754468,0.05552676462431031,True,False,1.2765681765107892,1.2659331591205356,False,128,full_stormer_verlet,16384,,0.25,0.03835286747767727,0.03635896966285459,2.380482697626576,2.3631861011963338,2.446618514484726,128,craig_bampton,384,128,,0.025925649049562165,0.02435135574390486,1.8647517159115523,1.8503011669963598,1.866754246992059,128,full_stormer_verlet,16384,,0.25,0.03835286747767727,0.03635896966285459,2.380482697626576,2.3631861011963338,2.446618514484726,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.05552676462431031,0.05364125884754468,1.0147776119410992,1.0119002169230953,1.0261704928707331 +double_inclusion,0.05552676462431031,0.06359891819300921,True,False,2.345817122505405,2.3029176122432364,True,128,full_stormer_verlet,16384,,0.25,0.03835286747767727,0.03635896966285459,2.380482697626576,2.3631861011963338,2.446618514484726,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.05552676462431031,0.05364125884754468,1.0147776119410992,1.0119002169230953,1.0261704928707331,128,full_stormer_verlet,16384,,0.25,0.03835286747767727,0.03635896966285459,2.380482697626576,2.3631861011963338,2.446618514484726,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.05552676462431031,0.05364125884754468,1.0147776119410992,1.0119002169230953,1.0261704928707331 +double_inclusion,0.06359891819300921,0.06553728572364939,True,False,2.345817122505405,2.3029176122432364,True,128,full_stormer_verlet,16384,,0.25,0.03835286747767727,0.03635896966285459,2.380482697626576,2.3631861011963338,2.446618514484726,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.05552676462431031,0.05364125884754468,1.0147776119410992,1.0119002169230953,1.0261704928707331,128,full_stormer_verlet,16384,,0.25,0.03835286747767727,0.03635896966285459,2.380482697626576,2.3631861011963338,2.446618514484726,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.05552676462431031,0.05364125884754468,1.0147776119410992,1.0119002169230953,1.0261704928707331 +double_inclusion,0.06553728572364939,0.06775277401807797,True,False,2.345817122505405,2.3029176122432364,True,128,full_stormer_verlet,16384,,0.25,0.03835286747767727,0.03635896966285459,2.380482697626576,2.3631861011963338,2.446618514484726,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.05552676462431031,0.05364125884754468,1.0147776119410992,1.0119002169230953,1.0261704928707331,128,full_stormer_verlet,16384,,0.25,0.03835286747767727,0.03635896966285459,2.380482697626576,2.3631861011963338,2.446618514484726,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.05552676462431031,0.05364125884754468,1.0147776119410992,1.0119002169230953,1.0261704928707331 +double_inclusion,0.06775277401807797,0.0684267426397161,True,False,2.345817122505405,2.3029176122432364,False,128,full_stormer_verlet,16384,,0.25,0.03835286747767727,0.03635896966285459,2.380482697626576,2.3631861011963338,2.446618514484726,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.05552676462431031,0.05364125884754468,1.0147776119410992,1.0119002169230953,1.0261704928707331,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.06968841179926823,0.06775277401807797,1.111911834217608,1.0990697019733489,1.1181928613223135,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.05552676462431031,0.05364125884754468,1.0147776119410992,1.0119002169230953,1.0261704928707331 +double_inclusion,0.0684267426397161,0.06865081077777506,True,False,2.345817122505405,2.3029176122432364,False,128,full_stormer_verlet,16384,,0.25,0.03835286747767727,0.03635896966285459,2.380482697626576,2.3631861011963338,2.446618514484726,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.05552676462431031,0.05364125884754468,1.0147776119410992,1.0119002169230953,1.0261704928707331,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.06968841179926823,0.06775277401807797,1.111911834217608,1.0990697019733489,1.1181928613223135,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.05552676462431031,0.05364125884754468,1.0147776119410992,1.0119002169230953,1.0261704928707331 +double_inclusion,0.06865081077777506,0.06865138809571814,True,False,2.345817122505405,2.3029176122432364,False,128,full_stormer_verlet,16384,,0.25,0.03835286747767727,0.03635896966285459,2.380482697626576,2.3631861011963338,2.446618514484726,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.05552676462431031,0.05364125884754468,1.0147776119410992,1.0119002169230953,1.0261704928707331,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.06968841179926823,0.06775277401807797,1.111911834217608,1.0990697019733489,1.1181928613223135,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.05552676462431031,0.05364125884754468,1.0147776119410992,1.0119002169230953,1.0261704928707331 +double_inclusion,0.06865138809571814,0.06865138809572542,True,False,2.345817122505405,2.3029176122432364,False,128,full_stormer_verlet,16384,,0.25,0.03835286747767727,0.03635896966285459,2.380482697626576,2.3631861011963338,2.446618514484726,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.05552676462431031,0.05364125884754468,1.0147776119410992,1.0119002169230953,1.0261704928707331,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.06968841179926823,0.06775277401807797,1.111911834217608,1.0990697019733489,1.1181928613223135,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.05552676462431031,0.05364125884754468,1.0147776119410992,1.0119002169230953,1.0261704928707331 +double_inclusion,0.06865138809572542,0.06865362294730532,True,False,2.345817122505405,2.3029176122432364,False,128,full_stormer_verlet,16384,,0.25,0.03835286747767727,0.03635896966285459,2.380482697626576,2.3631861011963338,2.446618514484726,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.05552676462431031,0.05364125884754468,1.0147776119410992,1.0119002169230953,1.0261704928707331,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.06968841179926823,0.06775277401807797,1.111911834217608,1.0990697019733489,1.1181928613223135,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.05552676462431031,0.05364125884754468,1.0147776119410992,1.0119002169230953,1.0261704928707331 +double_inclusion,0.06865362294730532,0.06968841179926823,True,False,2.345817122505405,2.3029176122432364,False,128,full_stormer_verlet,16384,,0.25,0.03835286747767727,0.03635896966285459,2.380482697626576,2.3631861011963338,2.446618514484726,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.05552676462431031,0.05364125884754468,1.0147776119410992,1.0119002169230953,1.0261704928707331,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.06968841179926823,0.06775277401807797,1.111911834217608,1.0990697019733489,1.1181928613223135,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.05552676462431031,0.05364125884754468,1.0147776119410992,1.0119002169230953,1.0261704928707331 +double_inclusion,0.06968841179926823,0.07036111538948042,True,False,1.0957197134953611,1.0710400558280317,True,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.06968841179926823,0.06775277401807797,1.111911834217608,1.0990697019733489,1.1181928613223135,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.05552676462431031,0.05364125884754468,1.0147776119410992,1.0119002169230953,1.0261704928707331,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.06968841179926823,0.06775277401807797,1.111911834217608,1.0990697019733489,1.1181928613223135,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.05552676462431031,0.05364125884754468,1.0147776119410992,1.0119002169230953,1.0261704928707331 +double_inclusion,0.07036111538948042,0.07058476654107904,True,False,1.0957197134953611,1.0710400558280317,True,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.06968841179926823,0.06775277401807797,1.111911834217608,1.0990697019733489,1.1181928613223135,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.05552676462431031,0.05364125884754468,1.0147776119410992,1.0119002169230953,1.0261704928707331,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.06968841179926823,0.06775277401807797,1.111911834217608,1.0990697019733489,1.1181928613223135,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.05552676462431031,0.05364125884754468,1.0147776119410992,1.0119002169230953,1.0261704928707331 +double_inclusion,0.07058476654107904,0.07058533485073136,True,False,1.0957197134953611,1.0710400558280317,True,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.06968841179926823,0.06775277401807797,1.111911834217608,1.0990697019733489,1.1181928613223135,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.05552676462431031,0.05364125884754468,1.0147776119410992,1.0119002169230953,1.0261704928707331,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.06968841179926823,0.06775277401807797,1.111911834217608,1.0990697019733489,1.1181928613223135,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.05552676462431031,0.05364125884754468,1.0147776119410992,1.0119002169230953,1.0261704928707331 +double_inclusion,0.07058533485073136,0.0705853348507386,True,False,1.0957197134953611,1.0710400558280317,True,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.06968841179926823,0.06775277401807797,1.111911834217608,1.0990697019733489,1.1181928613223135,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.05552676462431031,0.05364125884754468,1.0147776119410992,1.0119002169230953,1.0261704928707331,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.06968841179926823,0.06775277401807797,1.111911834217608,1.0990697019733489,1.1181928613223135,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.05552676462431031,0.05364125884754468,1.0147776119410992,1.0119002169230953,1.0261704928707331 +double_inclusion,0.0705853348507386,0.07058776689175697,True,False,1.0957197134953611,1.0710400558280317,True,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.06968841179926823,0.06775277401807797,1.111911834217608,1.0990697019733489,1.1181928613223135,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.05552676462431031,0.05364125884754468,1.0147776119410992,1.0119002169230953,1.0261704928707331,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.06968841179926823,0.06775277401807797,1.111911834217608,1.0990697019733489,1.1181928613223135,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.05552676462431031,0.05364125884754468,1.0147776119410992,1.0119002169230953,1.0261704928707331 +double_inclusion,0.07058776689175697,0.1,True,False,1.0957197134953611,1.0710400558280317,True,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.06968841179926823,0.06775277401807797,1.111911834217608,1.0990697019733489,1.1181928613223135,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.05552676462431031,0.05364125884754468,1.0147776119410992,1.0119002169230953,1.0261704928707331,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.06968841179926823,0.06775277401807797,1.111911834217608,1.0990697019733489,1.1181928613223135,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.05552676462431031,0.05364125884754468,1.0147776119410992,1.0119002169230953,1.0261704928707331 +smooth_checker,0.05,0.09331944567215684,True,False,1.290891189808912,1.2750393433112877,True,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.044935848571036587,0.04370730851521943,1.3141223517013714,1.3111928902799264,1.3150508869439363,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.03902036900814143,0.03778413248391995,1.0179962200345472,1.0158594432286918,1.0283548481529579,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.044935848571036587,0.04370730851521943,1.3141223517013714,1.3111928902799264,1.3150508869439363,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.03902036900814143,0.03778413248391995,1.0179962200345472,1.0158594432286918,1.0283548481529579 +smooth_checker,0.09331944567215684,0.09443277997273378,True,False,1.290891189808912,1.2750393433112877,False,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.044935848571036587,0.04370730851521943,1.3141223517013714,1.3111928902799264,1.3150508869439363,96,craig_bampton,352,128,,0.03902036900814143,0.03778413248391995,1.0179962200345472,1.0158594432286918,1.0283548481529579,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.044935848571036587,0.04370730851521943,1.3141223517013714,1.3111928902799264,1.3150508869439363,64,craig_bampton,320,128,,0.09443277997273378,0.09331944567215684,0.5622250299202278,0.5499861142598093,0.57655817293562 +smooth_checker,0.09443277997273378,0.09673383336975258,True,False,2.33736009918987,2.274172757978296,True,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.044935848571036587,0.04370730851521943,1.3141223517013714,1.3111928902799264,1.3150508869439363,64,craig_bampton,320,128,,0.09443277997273378,0.09331944567215684,0.5622250299202278,0.5499861142598093,0.57655817293562,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.044935848571036587,0.04370730851521943,1.3141223517013714,1.3111928902799264,1.3150508869439363,64,craig_bampton,320,128,,0.09443277997273378,0.09331944567215684,0.5622250299202278,0.5499861142598093,0.57655817293562 +smooth_checker,0.09673383336975258,0.09712204979068051,True,False,2.33736009918987,2.274172757978296,False,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.044935848571036587,0.04370730851521943,1.3141223517013714,1.3111928902799264,1.3150508869439363,64,craig_bampton,320,128,,0.09443277997273378,0.09331944567215684,0.5622250299202278,0.5499861142598093,0.57655817293562,64,full_stormer_verlet,4096,,0.25,0.09783911681566364,0.09673383336975258,0.37619623343925923,0.3622753325616941,0.3821922924835235,64,craig_bampton,320,128,,0.09443277997273378,0.09331944567215684,0.5622250299202278,0.5499861142598093,0.57655817293562 +smooth_checker,0.09712204979068051,0.0972513928210519,True,False,2.33736009918987,2.274172757978296,False,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.044935848571036587,0.04370730851521943,1.3141223517013714,1.3111928902799264,1.3150508869439363,64,craig_bampton,320,128,,0.09443277997273378,0.09331944567215684,0.5622250299202278,0.5499861142598093,0.57655817293562,64,full_stormer_verlet,4096,,0.25,0.09783911681566364,0.09673383336975258,0.37619623343925923,0.3622753325616941,0.3821922924835235,64,craig_bampton,320,128,,0.09443277997273378,0.09331944567215684,0.5622250299202278,0.5499861142598093,0.57655817293562 +smooth_checker,0.0972513928210519,0.0972513928210566,True,False,2.33736009918987,2.274172757978296,False,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.044935848571036587,0.04370730851521943,1.3141223517013714,1.3111928902799264,1.3150508869439363,64,craig_bampton,320,128,,0.09443277997273378,0.09331944567215684,0.5622250299202278,0.5499861142598093,0.57655817293562,64,full_stormer_verlet,4096,,0.25,0.09783911681566364,0.09673383336975258,0.37619623343925923,0.3622753325616941,0.3821922924835235,64,craig_bampton,320,128,,0.09443277997273378,0.09331944567215684,0.5622250299202278,0.5499861142598093,0.57655817293562 +smooth_checker,0.0972513928210566,0.0972612760342237,True,False,2.33736009918987,2.274172757978296,False,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.044935848571036587,0.04370730851521943,1.3141223517013714,1.3111928902799264,1.3150508869439363,64,craig_bampton,320,128,,0.09443277997273378,0.09331944567215684,0.5622250299202278,0.5499861142598093,0.57655817293562,64,full_stormer_verlet,4096,,0.25,0.09783911681566364,0.09673383336975258,0.37619623343925923,0.3622753325616941,0.3821922924835235,64,craig_bampton,320,128,,0.09443277997273378,0.09331944567215684,0.5622250299202278,0.5499861142598093,0.57655817293562 +smooth_checker,0.0972612760342237,0.09783911681566364,True,False,2.33736009918987,2.274172757978296,False,96,full_stormer_verlet,9216,,0.25,0.044935848571036587,0.04370730851521943,1.3141223517013714,1.3111928902799264,1.3150508869439363,64,craig_bampton,320,128,,0.09443277997273378,0.09331944567215684,0.5622250299202278,0.5499861142598093,0.57655817293562,64,full_stormer_verlet,4096,,0.25,0.09783911681566364,0.09673383336975258,0.37619623343925923,0.3622753325616941,0.3821922924835235,64,rational_krylov,320,128,,0.09836542367031906,0.0972612760342237,0.4943764810450375,0.49256946484092623,0.49870489502791315 +smooth_checker,0.09783911681566364,0.09822656967471333,True,False,0.6691203938263589,0.6283413358224075,False,64,full_stormer_verlet,4096,,0.25,0.09783911681566364,0.09673383336975258,0.37619623343925923,0.3622753325616941,0.3821922924835235,64,craig_bampton,320,128,,0.09443277997273378,0.09331944567215684,0.5622250299202278,0.5499861142598093,0.57655817293562,64,full_stormer_verlet,4096,,0.25,0.09783911681566364,0.09673383336975258,0.37619623343925923,0.3622753325616941,0.3821922924835235,64,rational_krylov,320,128,,0.09836542367031906,0.0972612760342237,0.4943764810450375,0.49256946484092623,0.49870489502791315 +smooth_checker,0.09822656967471333,0.09835565876028571,True,False,0.6691203938263589,0.6283413358224075,False,64,full_stormer_verlet,4096,,0.25,0.09783911681566364,0.09673383336975258,0.37619623343925923,0.3622753325616941,0.3821922924835235,64,craig_bampton,320,128,,0.09443277997273378,0.09331944567215684,0.5622250299202278,0.5499861142598093,0.57655817293562,64,full_stormer_verlet,4096,,0.25,0.09783911681566364,0.09673383336975258,0.37619623343925923,0.3622753325616941,0.3821922924835235,64,rational_krylov,320,128,,0.09836542367031906,0.0972612760342237,0.4943764810450375,0.49256946484092623,0.49870489502791315 +smooth_checker,0.09835565876028571,0.09835565876029047,True,False,0.6691203938263589,0.6283413358224075,False,64,full_stormer_verlet,4096,,0.25,0.09783911681566364,0.09673383336975258,0.37619623343925923,0.3622753325616941,0.3821922924835235,64,craig_bampton,320,128,,0.09443277997273378,0.09331944567215684,0.5622250299202278,0.5499861142598093,0.57655817293562,64,full_stormer_verlet,4096,,0.25,0.09783911681566364,0.09673383336975258,0.37619623343925923,0.3622753325616941,0.3821922924835235,64,rational_krylov,320,128,,0.09836542367031906,0.0972612760342237,0.4943764810450375,0.49256946484092623,0.49870489502791315 +smooth_checker,0.09835565876029047,0.09836542367031906,True,False,0.6691203938263589,0.6283413358224075,False,64,full_stormer_verlet,4096,,0.25,0.09783911681566364,0.09673383336975258,0.37619623343925923,0.3622753325616941,0.3821922924835235,64,craig_bampton,320,128,,0.09443277997273378,0.09331944567215684,0.5622250299202278,0.5499861142598093,0.57655817293562,64,full_stormer_verlet,4096,,0.25,0.09783911681566364,0.09673383336975258,0.37619623343925923,0.3622753325616941,0.3821922924835235,64,rational_krylov,320,128,,0.09836542367031906,0.0972612760342237,0.4943764810450375,0.49256946484092623,0.49870489502791315 +smooth_checker,0.09836542367031906,0.1,True,False,0.7609509106178292,0.7264322772316423,True,64,full_stormer_verlet,4096,,0.25,0.09783911681566364,0.09673383336975258,0.37619623343925923,0.3622753325616941,0.3821922924835235,64,rational_krylov,320,128,,0.09836542367031906,0.0972612760342237,0.4943764810450375,0.49256946484092623,0.49870489502791315,64,full_stormer_verlet,4096,,0.25,0.09783911681566364,0.09673383336975258,0.37619623343925923,0.3622753325616941,0.3821922924835235,64,rational_krylov,320,128,,0.09836542367031906,0.0972612760342237,0.4943764810450375,0.49256946484092623,0.49870489502791315 diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/total_receiver_errors.csv b/total_error_cost/results/total_receiver_errors.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b6141b3e4c49c447ee3f4b08c558ded413973636 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/total_receiver_errors.csv @@ -0,0 +1,313 @@ +material,grid,method,modes_per_patch,dimension,source,time_end,total_receiver_error,alternative_reference_total_receiver_error,grid_receiver_error,same_grid_receiver_error,same_denominator_non_grid_error,cross_term,error_vector_cosine,error_identity_absolute_residual,reference_grid_difference,worst_source_total_receiver_error,per_source_total_receiver_error,requested_cfl,total_seconds,minimum_total_seconds,maximum_total_seconds,time_repetitions +rotated_stripes,32,full_sparse_exponential,,1024,propagation,2.0,0.1697762313142698,0.16949014391184383,0.1697762313142698,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,3.469446951953614e-18,0.0006308271049904619,0.2727614595453359,"[0.06666787960650072, 0.1556788386326187, 0.2727614595453359]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,32,full_sparse_exponential,,1024,propagation,8.0,0.43734666259452687,0.43646955864398984,0.43734666259452687,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.002293040730416934,0.5533823599160272,"[0.32801959866155395, 0.4392254603290812, 0.5533823599160272]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,48,full_sparse_exponential,,2304,propagation,2.0,0.088975066539379,0.08848988626674853,0.088975066539379,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0006308271049904619,0.14850305034153144,"[0.03040249373953443, 0.07352277255444792, 0.14850305034153144]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,48,full_sparse_exponential,,2304,propagation,8.0,0.2452970058337071,0.24403848861591493,0.2452970058337071,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.3877787807814457e-17,0.002293040730416934,0.32193520040581225,"[0.15995363598697696, 0.2579337700599451, 0.32193520040581225]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,64,full_sparse_exponential,,4096,propagation,2.0,0.05094467648594595,0.050371376509943055,0.05094467648594595,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0006308271049904619,0.08482571390956777,"[0.01703215303832893, 0.04284325385175546, 0.08482571390956777]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,64,full_sparse_exponential,,4096,propagation,8.0,0.15410282909435277,0.15258923390324744,0.15410282909435277,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.002293040730416934,0.20363099086319153,"[0.09317716693008563, 0.16801422013933587, 0.20363099086319153]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,96,full_sparse_exponential,,9216,propagation,2.0,0.022307554470205014,0.02169337896942711,0.022307554470205014,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0842021724855044e-19,0.0006308271049904619,0.036941951682094826,"[0.007417684105324557, 0.019230782377756883, 0.036941951682094826]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,96,full_sparse_exponential,,9216,propagation,8.0,0.07532227220263102,0.07341596332132161,0.07532227220263102,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,8.673617379884035e-19,0.002293040730416934,0.1005022732021246,"[0.04166064461439748, 0.08444420619183104, 0.1005022732021246]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,128,full_sparse_exponential,,16384,propagation,2.0,0.012199897864511417,0.01157436819340243,0.012199897864511417,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0006308271049904619,0.02014989499143937,"[0.004050646593009625, 0.010636118896427458, 0.02014989499143937]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,128,full_sparse_exponential,,16384,propagation,8.0,0.04303394082386547,0.04090519249772245,0.04303394082386547,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,6.505213034913027e-19,0.002293040730416934,0.0579382874839315,"[0.022930775546255017, 0.04819792737570051, 0.0579382874839315]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,192,full_sparse_exponential,,36864,propagation,2.0,0.004964214874657458,0.004334208083729091,0.004964214874657458,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0006308271049904619,0.008182189610110203,"[0.0016488367338850952, 0.004363262400092423, 0.008182189610110203]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,192,full_sparse_exponential,,36864,propagation,8.0,0.017927183407417436,0.015666726860527877,0.017927183407417436,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,5.421010862427522e-20,0.002293040730416934,0.024273908087440132,"[0.009369917652098193, 0.02001271337090247, 0.024273908087440132]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,256,full_sparse_exponential,,65536,propagation,2.0,0.002434954660308413,0.0018042950073459125,0.002434954660308413,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,8.470329472543003e-22,0.0006308271049904619,0.004010446537636592,"[0.0008091479562927083, 0.002146056843073073, 0.004010446537636592]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,256,full_sparse_exponential,,65536,propagation,8.0,0.008834685479935468,0.006548799364313484,0.008834685479935468,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,2.710505431213761e-20,0.002293040730416934,0.011980234023936472,"[0.00460159670135696, 0.009846629374649933, 0.011980234023936472]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,384,full_sparse_exponential,,147456,propagation,2.0,0.0006308271049904619,0.0,0.0006308271049904619,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0587911840678754e-22,0.0006308271049904619,0.001038446420156339,"[0.00020972415158106646, 0.0005570544857261471, 0.001038446420156339]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,384,full_sparse_exponential,,147456,propagation,8.0,0.002293040730416934,0.0,0.002293040730416934,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,8.470329472543003e-22,0.002293040730416934,0.003111776730730817,"[0.0011930714604199148, 0.002552900162362457, 0.003111776730730817]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,32,craig_bampton,128,288,same_grid_study,2.0,0.16737327834476554,0.16707866421197323,0.1697762313142698,0.011529165925606554,0.011538984435581478,-0.0009433025772066918,-0.24075568382737705,4.336808689942018e-19,0.0006308271049904619,0.2683655669663388,"[0.06605725792167567, 0.15425171951863068, 0.2683655669663388]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,32,craig_bampton,128,288,same_grid_study,8.0,0.43310878470314984,0.4322116168835195,0.43734666259452687,0.022762757385986102,0.022701794534433377,-0.004204255370615108,-0.21172546067889675,3.209238430557093e-17,0.002293040730416934,0.5490778469774674,"[0.32418795588609645, 0.4340451017948613, 0.5490778469774674]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,32,craig_bampton,16,64,same_grid_study,2.0,0.3376246253870271,0.3375777137006891,0.1697762313142698,0.3320459617820397,0.3323287399646877,-0.025275972458063133,-0.2239922993678222,1.0408340855860843e-17,0.0006308271049904619,0.45392674736290844,"[0.16940037369849067, 0.45392674736290844, 0.420797170856637]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,32,craig_bampton,16,64,same_grid_study,8.0,0.35682106507077105,0.35669423704310066,0.43734666259452687,0.4122896426128354,0.4111854551080823,-0.23302430929677226,-0.6478995421008562,8.326672684688674e-17,0.002293040730416934,0.4197907643715296,"[0.292156715277939, 0.4197907643715296, 0.3882432571999055]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,32,craig_bampton,32,96,same_grid_study,2.0,0.15039098457990469,0.15025192841730597,0.1697762313142698,0.1380828144396372,0.1382004090253765,-0.02530587353114469,-0.5392685838007277,0.0,0.0006308271049904619,0.19549958712226792,"[0.07608055963902408, 0.1929777607680307, 0.19549958712226792]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,32,craig_bampton,32,96,same_grid_study,8.0,0.36627985077247427,0.3652740009747476,0.43734666259452687,0.16359372746879272,0.16315559337310637,-0.08373092184959542,-0.5867162180654125,1.3877787807814457e-17,0.002293040730416934,0.46603228916220785,"[0.27604516392631, 0.36129681934516955, 0.46603228916220785]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,32,craig_bampton,64,160,same_grid_study,2.0,0.1460161158004229,0.1456845731953593,0.1697762313142698,0.05884165178858782,0.05889176272885489,-0.010971502363145692,-0.5486617226786791,3.469446951953614e-18,0.0006308271049904619,0.22481660547648555,"[0.06552754574131828, 0.14505991709956334, 0.22481660547648555]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,32,craig_bampton,64,160,same_grid_study,8.0,0.418860063752323,0.4179022762481711,0.43734666259452687,0.07257356303230499,0.07237919768039404,-0.02106709853282841,-0.33276309073071764,1.0408340855860843e-17,0.002293040730416934,0.5277745240414056,"[0.31509268125034745, 0.42319642253366785, 0.5277745240414056]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,32,full_sparse_exponential,,1024,same_grid_study,2.0,0.1697762313142698,0.16949014391184383,0.1697762313142698,4.636666410471254e-16,4.640615105085883e-16,3.938445179589682e-18,0.024994380149309776,7.407892131543295e-18,0.0006308271049904619,0.272761459545336,"[0.06666787960650071, 0.1556788386326187, 0.272761459545336]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,32,full_sparse_exponential,,1024,same_grid_study,8.0,0.43734666259452687,0.43646955864398984,0.43734666259452687,4.81387126316954e-16,4.800978830401653e-16,5.902127325926146e-18,0.014054745012405546,5.902127325926146e-18,0.002293040730416934,0.5533823599160272,"[0.32801959866155395, 0.4392254603290813, 0.5533823599160272]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,32,rational_krylov,128,288,same_grid_study,2.0,0.16964064920002983,0.16935431173601748,0.1697762313142698,0.004361250647654647,0.0043649647917014455,-6.50717759016517e-05,-0.04390409504420883,3.604972223514302e-18,0.0006308271049904619,0.2724659613344356,"[0.06666381157417575, 0.15566690943629938, 0.2724659613344356]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,32,rational_krylov,128,288,same_grid_study,8.0,0.43732042589306885,0.4364471602272902,0.43734666259452687,0.011709209372279913,0.011677849955639048,-0.0001593205588622221,-0.01559743260870914,2.7376104855258987e-18,0.002293040730416934,0.5532368087626843,"[0.3280163296903467, 0.439373910940587, 0.5532368087626843]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,32,rational_krylov,16,64,same_grid_study,2.0,0.30311301697083354,0.30300822432157687,0.1697762313142698,0.2875375946211179,0.28778246842718247,-0.01976521679615787,-0.2022694829665098,2.0816681711721685e-17,0.0006308271049904619,0.4686110029224959,"[0.144126616673406, 0.4686110029224959, 0.3146844509974558]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,32,rational_krylov,16,64,same_grid_study,8.0,0.6129375016493677,0.6126826153916705,0.43734666259452687,0.5668858336806274,0.5653676091377919,-0.1352202558165854,-0.2734355750849212,8.326672684688674e-17,0.002293040730416934,0.742385998242669,"[0.4665641319584116, 0.742385998242669, 0.6855866568573542]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,32,rational_krylov,32,96,same_grid_study,2.0,0.15226433332110378,0.15201172861160225,0.1697762313142698,0.09696068394665874,0.09704325795493035,-0.015056935432063406,-0.4569454267733786,3.469446951953614e-18,0.0006308271049904619,0.22825608334409006,"[0.0710304503999671, 0.15928584725553963, 0.22825608334409006]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,32,rational_krylov,32,96,same_grid_study,8.0,0.41957802794133836,0.418770428321976,0.43734666259452687,0.1831202415952569,0.18262981190278285,-0.04858002994707427,-0.3041097148154877,2.0816681711721685e-17,0.002293040730416934,0.5291097533432358,"[0.31813585725477916, 0.41949872726638326, 0.5291097533432358]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,32,rational_krylov,64,160,same_grid_study,2.0,0.16970363123884447,0.1694227564719091,0.1697762313142698,0.01518269361111489,0.01519562355154847,-0.00025555323874710775,-0.049528591626459624,3.2526065174565133e-18,0.0006308271049904619,0.2741736849881895,"[0.06644545528478817, 0.1527303735643696, 0.2741736849881895]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,32,rational_krylov,64,160,same_grid_study,8.0,0.43443529503543155,0.4335448213003815,0.43734666259452687,0.04871006538907828,0.048579610873613205,-0.004898056302680196,-0.11526937245974204,2.6020852139652106e-18,0.002293040730416934,0.5475193376966375,"[0.32832161514279284, 0.4365177368628926, 0.5475193376966375]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,64,craig_bampton,128,320,same_grid_study,2.0,0.04500329137853361,0.044432036190874255,0.05094467648594595,0.010991232514176726,0.010992388349494422,-0.0006908964289825975,-0.616867770807121,1.0842021724855044e-19,0.0006308271049904619,0.07323125765348883,"[0.017224848272430808, 0.039761646536112805, 0.07323125765348883]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,64,craig_bampton,128,320,same_grid_study,8.0,0.1441874901285791,0.1426328456519666,0.15410282909435277,0.022059266850334033,0.02204472408296921,-0.0034436194851984485,-0.5068388322477472,8.673617379884035e-19,0.002293040730416934,0.1925165173211326,"[0.08636979640296022, 0.15465698070338002, 0.1925165173211326]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,64,craig_bampton,16,96,same_grid_study,2.0,0.31507336948365217,0.31506684053407774,0.05094467648594595,0.3152488915825282,0.31528204307871266,-0.0027268985923628434,-0.0848869534453409,1.5178830414797062e-17,0.0006308271049904619,0.4188414120605458,"[0.16270093645463277, 0.39090728641768674, 0.4188414120605458]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,64,craig_bampton,16,96,same_grid_study,8.0,0.3832175009749977,0.38360753172066236,0.15410282909435277,0.4172875172332612,0.4170124167356544,-0.05079138459307201,-0.3951850057755608,7.632783294297951e-17,0.002293040730416934,0.44670496529723863,"[0.3042047162536768, 0.4227495460558795, 0.44670496529723863]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,64,craig_bampton,32,128,same_grid_study,2.0,0.13074815698390835,0.1308121993465622,0.05094467648594595,0.1386835343463096,0.13869811827279588,-0.004737447519983421,-0.33523166853731345,2.6020852139652106e-18,0.0006308271049904619,0.18795976702040373,"[0.05357519662714604, 0.15425464722530455, 0.18795976702040373]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,64,craig_bampton,32,128,same_grid_study,8.0,0.1319837167318152,0.13176926857671495,0.15410282909435277,0.16291343632073418,0.16280603419259046,-0.0328337852220582,-0.6543496103353763,6.938893903907228e-18,0.002293040730416934,0.1708815740970078,"[0.06779444852183951, 0.1708815740970078, 0.16378752751552697]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,64,craig_bampton,64,192,same_grid_study,2.0,0.05583004528498888,0.05562007680872026,0.05094467648594595,0.051315743614656066,0.05132113996567922,-0.002112225513110623,-0.40393844118642,1.734723475976807e-18,0.0006308271049904619,0.0934753642194219,"[0.01966089506141428, 0.044987455663574455, 0.0934753642194219]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,64,craig_bampton,64,192,same_grid_study,8.0,0.11860819796624258,0.11704137948230268,0.15410282909435277,0.07148748345603087,0.07144035469837763,-0.014783501589513921,-0.6714181897086708,1.734723475976807e-18,0.002293040730416934,0.16249373404054537,"[0.06975387535602776, 0.12115869556845223, 0.16249373404054537]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,64,full_sparse_exponential,,4096,same_grid_study,2.0,0.05094467648594595,0.050371376509943055,0.05094467648594595,3.914280158743582e-17,3.9146917834858474e-17,2.212543628107188e-22,5.547093221244205e-05,2.212543628107188e-22,0.0006308271049904619,0.08482571390956777,"[0.01703215303832893, 0.04284325385175546, 0.08482571390956777]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,64,full_sparse_exponential,,4096,same_grid_study,8.0,0.15410282909435277,0.15258923390324744,0.15410282909435277,1.9333003220939124e-17,1.9320257767057404e-17,5.3891779881391e-23,9.050425617949738e-06,5.3891779881391e-23,0.002293040730416934,0.20363099086319153,"[0.09317716693008563, 0.16801422013933587, 0.20363099086319153]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,64,rational_krylov,128,320,same_grid_study,2.0,0.05071263137424936,0.050142008301850116,0.05094467648594595,0.0056915721956828464,0.005692170720020176,-5.598988886304821e-05,-0.09653901961298161,1.6263032587282567e-19,0.0006308271049904619,0.08445043483351403,"[0.016994149538364405, 0.042593373386582305, 0.08445043483351403]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,64,rational_krylov,128,320,same_grid_study,8.0,0.15416879507950618,0.15265376292304797,0.15410282909435277,0.006821934289404659,0.00681743686870514,-2.6142004075312548e-05,-0.012441626099793518,2.879912020664621e-19,0.002293040730416934,0.20382269937779326,"[0.09317606402596267, 0.16795244285834723, 0.20382269937779326]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,64,rational_krylov,16,96,same_grid_study,2.0,0.08883284073140983,0.08866922439167867,0.05094467648594595,0.08477313371151916,0.08478204843348588,-0.0018920822064236154,-0.21903186029684993,1.3010426069826053e-18,0.0006308271049904619,0.12137865630864277,"[0.025077351851941716, 0.11865913544542414, 0.12137865630864277]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,64,rational_krylov,16,96,same_grid_study,8.0,0.18977508674491486,0.1889760845738648,0.15410282909435277,0.15502403771817388,0.1549218367460479,-0.01173387388661245,-0.24574696979455218,5.204170427930421e-18,0.002293040730416934,0.24409482109717925,"[0.09746598765132049, 0.2336496085550228, 0.24409482109717925]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,64,rational_krylov,32,128,same_grid_study,2.0,0.058391986817698936,0.05790243513922572,0.05094467648594595,0.026487425892773475,0.02649021130398939,0.00011253276733062501,0.04169315612679247,3.6591823321385775e-19,0.0006308271049904619,0.10128256997448987,"[0.016909210352411157, 0.04110633262707578, 0.10128256997448987]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,64,rational_krylov,32,128,same_grid_study,8.0,0.15776268588612685,0.15626352432813392,0.15410282909435277,0.06136770233225142,0.061327245130079346,-0.002619647872123412,-0.1385954122256325,8.673617379884035e-19,0.002293040730416934,0.2065771061418785,"[0.09621697412688407, 0.1742931781318831, 0.2065771061418785]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,64,rational_krylov,64,192,same_grid_study,2.0,0.056259999136259044,0.055733356758592735,0.05094467648594595,0.016928969885718032,0.016930750132042625,0.0002831771405205136,0.1641546491826129,5.421010862427522e-20,0.0006308271049904619,0.09643061136862227,"[0.01681146328580636, 0.0422720031177289, 0.09643061136862227]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,64,rational_krylov,64,192,same_grid_study,8.0,0.1537933782398969,0.15227217553862815,0.15410282909435277,0.02472078461317996,0.024704487216618935,-0.0007055904330793985,-0.0926693746706329,7.589415207398531e-19,0.002293040730416934,0.2043122837045061,"[0.09303238609740501, 0.16576011940039737, 0.2043122837045061]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,128,craig_bampton,128,384,total_error_study,2.0,0.010283347756322416,0.009990336585735504,0.012199897864511417,0.011155828203441824,0.011155798906330339,-0.00016754211606553017,-0.6155128565232802,0.0,0.0006308271049904619,0.013891696738786955,"[0.005430213488691844, 0.012388131518576645, 0.013891696738786955]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,128,craig_bampton,128,384,total_error_study,8.0,0.028692121733248043,0.02692184900793251,0.04303394082386547,0.02522919658591384,0.025225300873156088,-0.0016649980174176797,-0.7668956100852944,6.505213034913027e-19,0.002293040730416934,0.04033191206272795,"[0.015028873337284877, 0.029313342502857203, 0.04033191206272795]",,1.8773641479201615,1.8768734860932454,1.8809097211342305,"[1.8773641479201615, 1.8809097211342305, 1.8768734860932454]" +rotated_stripes,128,craig_bampton,256,640,total_error_study,2.0,0.010511339583916295,0.009903179197301827,0.012199897864511417,0.003080234262837117,0.0030802261736155054,-4.783704133673066e-05,-0.6364957583541722,2.0328790734103208e-20,0.0006308271049904619,0.01692960044273069,"[0.00421013858651157, 0.009486232753627779, 0.01692960044273069]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,128,craig_bampton,256,640,total_error_study,8.0,0.03785082545182693,0.035697863958150645,0.04303394082386547,0.007723554644086635,0.007722362027815257,-0.0004788699507359288,-0.7204872737153262,0.0,0.002293040730416934,0.05145868995554799,"[0.020169901691921014, 0.0415376841483701, 0.05145868995554799]",,5.315051865880378,5.296330059180036,5.364947435096838,"[5.296330059180036, 5.315051865880378, 5.364947435096838]" +rotated_stripes,128,full_chebyshev_bessel,,16384,total_error_study,2.0,0.012199897864505281,0.011574368193396273,0.012199897864511417,6.894930565789316e-14,6.894912458523248e-14,-1.4968182450416053e-16,-0.08897215734325922,3.4819646848782214e-20,0.0006308271049904619,0.020149894991433857,"[0.004050646593006454, 0.010636118896413114, 0.020149894991433857]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,128,full_chebyshev_bessel,,16384,total_error_study,8.0,0.04303394082386281,0.040905192497719754,0.04303394082386547,3.1540141829572357e-13,3.153527162562082e-13,-2.289675751416603e-16,-0.008435994632180923,4.496045562724555e-19,0.002293040730416934,0.057938287483936236,"[0.02293077554624692, 0.048197927375689696, 0.057938287483936236]",,4.3367459090659395,4.3186448068590835,4.3451328199589625,"[4.3186448068590835, 4.3451328199589625, 4.3367459090659395]" +rotated_stripes,128,full_sparse_exponential,,16384,total_error_study,2.0,0.012199897864511417,0.01157436819340243,0.012199897864511417,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0006308271049904619,0.02014989499143937,"[0.004050646593009625, 0.010636118896427458, 0.02014989499143937]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,128,full_sparse_exponential,,16384,total_error_study,8.0,0.04303394082386547,0.04090519249772245,0.04303394082386547,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,6.505213034913027e-19,0.002293040730416934,0.0579382874839315,"[0.022930775546255017, 0.04819792737570051, 0.0579382874839315]",,67.8081183998147,67.70532303513028,68.09314655547496,"[68.09314655547496, 67.8081183998147, 67.70532303513028]" +rotated_stripes,128,full_stormer_verlet,,16384,total_error_study,2.0,0.012163283331923755,0.011537711040529643,0.012199897864511417,3.7866970439400964e-05,3.786687099426481e-05,-8.934803917748964e-07,-0.9670288154759962,1.3976043629695956e-20,0.0006308271049904619,0.02009065207287216,"[0.004038922874751089, 0.010601265348332495, 0.02009065207287216]",0.125,,,, +rotated_stripes,128,full_stormer_verlet,,16384,total_error_study,8.0,0.04291454351003634,0.04078500915320624,0.04303394082386547,0.00013056200908308316,0.00013054184862800364,-1.0279059331395829e-05,-0.9148765591941652,6.098637220230962e-20,0.002293040730416934,0.057780358646767074,"[0.022864617777391013, 0.04806179377816105, 0.057780358646767074]",0.125,4.6355946332914755,4.610258840955794,4.745511766523123,"[4.610258840955794, 4.745511766523123, 4.6355946332914755]" +rotated_stripes,128,full_stormer_verlet,,16384,total_error_study,2.0,0.012064492952752852,0.011438807200060113,0.012199897864511417,0.00014004843361962018,0.00014004806582849805,-3.305131158229299e-06,-0.9672202770133979,5.929230630780102e-21,0.0006308271049904619,0.019930793742722372,"[0.004007294515413218, 0.010507248099962067, 0.019930793742722372]",0.25,,,, +rotated_stripes,128,full_stormer_verlet,,16384,total_error_study,8.0,0.04259216856395635,0.04046051819316749,0.04303394082386547,0.00048287358320756675,0.0004827990213097244,-3.806033474646091e-05,-0.9159359572164404,2.439454888092385e-19,0.002293040730416934,0.05735389149538943,"[0.0226860946286646, 0.047694226216510045, 0.05735389149538943]",0.25,2.4309769346145913,2.389581744908355,2.496616270742379,"[2.389581744908355, 2.4309769346145913, 2.496616270742379]" +rotated_stripes,128,rational_krylov,128,384,total_error_study,2.0,0.012283508675682876,0.011675100840307559,0.012199897864511417,0.002706184926798094,0.0027061778198939667,-5.276320911819753e-06,-0.07990770934485682,1.0164395367051604e-20,0.0006308271049904619,0.020361676710046003,"[0.004068423675663921, 0.010558310447860337, 0.020361676710046003]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,128,rational_krylov,128,384,total_error_study,8.0,0.04263720855890929,0.04052390384698601,0.04303394082386547,0.005442493191360953,0.005441652800344641,-6.360009433552607e-05,-0.13579563719110238,3.2526065174565133e-19,0.002293040730416934,0.05723670125407896,"[0.022905449340182075, 0.04786244691040005, 0.05723670125407896]",,2.9076815659645945,2.90405220806133,2.9373938580974936,"[2.9373938580974936, 2.90405220806133, 2.9076815659645945]" +rotated_stripes,128,rational_krylov,256,640,total_error_study,2.0,0.012182784543664182,0.01155869996032343,0.012199897864511417,0.0005196131408930854,0.0005196117763001712,-6.87265065237143e-07,-0.05420746435137353,2.0434669852509996e-20,0.0006308271049904619,0.020125125038341195,"[0.004050528867811195, 0.010609715855093226, 0.020125125038341195]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,128,rational_krylov,256,640,total_error_study,8.0,0.04298043430957717,0.04084858408676297,0.04303394082386547,0.0010760003903993252,0.001075834242086439,-5.759748708522665e-06,-0.062203820431685125,1.7787691892340307e-19,0.002293040730416934,0.05781769723443661,"[0.022928834225523005, 0.04819522620882311, 0.05781769723443661]",,5.992650898871943,5.973303402191959,6.10900373395998,"[6.10900373395998, 5.992650898871943, 5.973303402191959]" +rotated_stripes,32,craig_bampton,128,288,total_error_study,2.0,0.16737327834476554,0.16707866421197323,0.1697762313142698,0.011529165925606554,0.011538984435581478,-0.0009433025772066918,-0.24075568382737705,4.336808689942018e-19,0.0006308271049904619,0.2683655669663388,"[0.06605725792167567, 0.15425171951863068, 0.2683655669663388]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,32,craig_bampton,128,288,total_error_study,8.0,0.43310878470314984,0.4322116168835195,0.43734666259452687,0.022762757385986102,0.022701794534433377,-0.004204255370615108,-0.21172546067889675,3.209238430557093e-17,0.002293040730416934,0.5490778469774674,"[0.32418795588609645, 0.4340451017948613, 0.5490778469774674]",,0.15643566788639873,0.15569333103485405,0.18047973688226193,"[0.18047973688226193, 0.15643566788639873, 0.15569333103485405]" +rotated_stripes,32,full_chebyshev_bessel,,1024,total_error_study,2.0,0.16977623131426992,0.16949014391184394,0.1697762313142698,1.3453705278984394e-14,1.346516277212256e-14,4.728707453139426e-17,0.01034246248966747,2.1842641559972755e-18,0.0006308271049904619,0.2727614595453372,"[0.06666787960649849, 0.15567883863261855, 0.2727614595453372]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,32,full_chebyshev_bessel,,1024,total_error_study,8.0,0.4373466625945256,0.4364695586439886,0.43734666259452687,7.813309063213627e-14,7.792383584262229e-14,-1.0864487815761644e-15,-0.015939809326047504,3.981332566636732e-18,0.002293040730416934,0.5533823599160248,"[0.32801959866155506, 0.4392254603290786, 0.5533823599160248]",,1.057006481103599,1.0559073279146105,1.0584249169332907,"[1.0584249169332907, 1.0559073279146105, 1.057006481103599]" +rotated_stripes,32,full_sparse_exponential,,1024,total_error_study,2.0,0.1697762313142698,0.16949014391184383,0.1697762313142698,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,3.469446951953614e-18,0.0006308271049904619,0.2727614595453359,"[0.06666787960650072, 0.1556788386326187, 0.2727614595453359]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,32,full_sparse_exponential,,1024,total_error_study,8.0,0.43734666259452687,0.43646955864398984,0.43734666259452687,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.002293040730416934,0.5533823599160272,"[0.32801959866155395, 0.4392254603290812, 0.5533823599160272]",,2.9658728548092768,2.955036854953505,3.702822535764426,"[3.702822535764426, 2.9658728548092768, 2.955036854953505]" +rotated_stripes,32,rational_krylov,128,288,total_error_study,2.0,0.16964064920002983,0.16935431173601748,0.1697762313142698,0.004361250647654647,0.0043649647917014455,-6.50717759016517e-05,-0.04390409504420883,3.604972223514302e-18,0.0006308271049904619,0.2724659613344356,"[0.06666381157417575, 0.15566690943629938, 0.2724659613344356]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,32,rational_krylov,128,288,total_error_study,8.0,0.43732042589306885,0.4364471602272902,0.43734666259452687,0.011709209372279913,0.011677849955639048,-0.0001593205588622221,-0.01559743260870914,2.7376104855258987e-18,0.002293040730416934,0.5532368087626843,"[0.3280163296903467, 0.439373910940587, 0.5532368087626843]",,0.12110034702345729,0.12052860402036458,0.12177531898487359,"[0.12052860402036458, 0.12110034702345729, 0.12177531898487359]" +rotated_stripes,64,craig_bampton,128,320,total_error_study,2.0,0.04500329137853361,0.044432036190874255,0.05094467648594595,0.010991232514176726,0.010992388349494422,-0.0006908964289825975,-0.616867770807121,1.0842021724855044e-19,0.0006308271049904619,0.07323125765348883,"[0.017224848272430808, 0.039761646536112805, 0.07323125765348883]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,64,craig_bampton,128,320,total_error_study,8.0,0.1441874901285791,0.1426328456519666,0.15410282909435277,0.022059266850334033,0.02204472408296921,-0.0034436194851984485,-0.5068388322477472,8.673617379884035e-19,0.002293040730416934,0.1925165173211326,"[0.08636979640296022, 0.15465698070338002, 0.1925165173211326]",,0.5749842970399186,0.5474709649570286,0.5754409979563206,"[0.5749842970399186, 0.5754409979563206, 0.5474709649570286]" +rotated_stripes,64,full_chebyshev_bessel,,4096,total_error_study,2.0,0.05094467648594499,0.050371376509942084,0.05094467648594595,3.040535457332501e-14,3.040855199296085e-14,-1.0028241027500095e-16,-0.03236683389568924,1.0212953734034178e-19,0.0006308271049904619,0.0848257139095666,"[0.017032153038328314, 0.04284325385175378, 0.0848257139095666]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,64,full_chebyshev_bessel,,4096,total_error_study,8.0,0.15410282909435402,0.15258923390324874,0.15410282909435277,1.5606385001149568e-13,1.5596096353389085e-13,3.899840330047039e-16,0.008113165012989058,4.875421337852706e-18,0.002293040730416934,0.20363099086319678,"[0.09317716693008304, 0.16801422013933479, 0.20363099086319678]",,1.9788233119761571,1.9774414328858256,1.984051329898648,"[1.984051329898648, 1.9774414328858256, 1.9788233119761571]" +rotated_stripes,64,full_sparse_exponential,,4096,total_error_study,2.0,0.05094467648594595,0.050371376509943055,0.05094467648594595,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0006308271049904619,0.08482571390956777,"[0.01703215303832893, 0.04284325385175546, 0.08482571390956777]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,64,full_sparse_exponential,,4096,total_error_study,8.0,0.15410282909435277,0.15258923390324744,0.15410282909435277,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.002293040730416934,0.20363099086319153,"[0.09317716693008563, 0.16801422013933587, 0.20363099086319153]",,12.371970289736055,12.36370782169979,12.377728872583248,"[12.377728872583248, 12.36370782169979, 12.371970289736055]" +rotated_stripes,64,full_stormer_verlet,,4096,total_error_study,2.0,0.05081847941113937,0.05024493744386385,0.05094467648594595,0.00014522404167275428,0.0001452393133973882,-1.2863307055454238e-05,-0.8692398839274332,7.199780051661553e-19,0.0006308271049904619,0.08462184772831711,"[0.01698964442519304, 0.04272346136313498, 0.08462184772831711]",0.125,,,, +rotated_stripes,64,full_stormer_verlet,,4096,total_error_study,8.0,0.15378566242107494,0.15227087683159846,0.15410282909435277,0.00048602556872617397,0.0004857051520583266,-9.78878780892011e-05,-0.6539064132398072,1.1655173354219173e-18,0.002293040730416934,0.2032186311011317,"[0.09295362108116767, 0.1676912747123495, 0.2032186311011317]",0.125,0.6065724211512133,0.5991648469353095,0.6535607365658507,"[0.6065724211512133, 0.6535607365658507, 0.5991648469353095]" +rotated_stripes,64,full_stormer_verlet,,4096,total_error_study,2.0,0.050509221561797865,0.04993508943584556,0.05094467648594595,0.0005009418107654389,0.000500994489683499,-4.442959495760089e-05,-0.8703834018552672,0.0,0.0006308271049904619,0.08412215682427111,"[0.016885534349013097, 0.04243004595603746, 0.08412215682427111]",0.25,,,, +rotated_stripes,64,full_stormer_verlet,,4096,total_error_study,8.0,0.15300775396789584,0.15149004553080975,0.15410282909435277,0.0016764610766403813,0.0016753558548032652,-0.00033911597782337584,-0.6567507499308054,2.927345865710862e-18,0.002293040730416934,0.20220717103882763,"[0.09240583165808701, 0.16689871649665955, 0.20220717103882763]",0.25,0.33171040599700063,0.32864416227675974,0.3385466291802004,"[0.32864416227675974, 0.33171040599700063, 0.3385466291802004]" +rotated_stripes,64,rational_krylov,128,320,total_error_study,2.0,0.05071263137424936,0.050142008301850116,0.05094467648594595,0.0056915721956828464,0.005692170720020176,-5.598988886304821e-05,-0.09653901961298161,1.6263032587282567e-19,0.0006308271049904619,0.08445043483351403,"[0.016994149538364405, 0.042593373386582305, 0.08445043483351403]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,64,rational_krylov,128,320,total_error_study,8.0,0.15416879507950618,0.15265376292304797,0.15410282909435277,0.006821934289404659,0.00681743686870514,-2.6142004075312548e-05,-0.012441626099793518,2.879912020664621e-19,0.002293040730416934,0.20382269937779326,"[0.09317606402596267, 0.16795244285834723, 0.20382269937779326]",,0.4981262880610302,0.4938331899465993,0.5048421098617837,"[0.4981262880610302, 0.4938331899465993, 0.5048421098617837]" +rotated_stripes,96,craig_bampton,128,352,total_error_study,2.0,0.017631539948265603,0.0171052250380054,0.022307554470205014,0.01095344349812332,0.010953568899475907,-0.0003067364571294436,-0.6276648306700235,5.421010862427522e-20,0.0006308271049904619,0.026858012132276406,"[0.008218046960484225, 0.01774534502906023, 0.026858012132276406]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,96,craig_bampton,128,352,total_error_study,8.0,0.0608617336076613,0.058884789516072115,0.07532227220263102,0.024414208668880895,0.024406001819565173,-0.0025649469968539295,-0.6976351392100679,1.734723475976807e-18,0.002293040730416934,0.08321805829971411,"[0.033569058519767166, 0.06483681855541257, 0.08321805829971411]",,1.0159576621372253,1.0123570379801095,1.026163161965087,"[1.026163161965087, 1.0123570379801095, 1.0159576621372253]" +rotated_stripes,96,craig_bampton,256,608,total_error_study,2.0,0.020580034188615544,0.01996636024303551,0.022307554470205014,0.002963167817512523,0.0029632017415704977,-8.286974379782545e-05,-0.6268343943373932,2.710505431213761e-20,0.0006308271049904619,0.03370759600224575,"[0.0074815862168220075, 0.018047510092412036, 0.03370759600224575]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,96,craig_bampton,256,608,total_error_study,8.0,0.07100160777003457,0.06906655217725774,0.07532227220263102,0.00725000363090121,0.007247566538298939,-0.0006847436045644778,-0.6271657961954444,3.2526065174565133e-19,0.002293040730416934,0.09539589187545099,"[0.03912406172477586, 0.07863086427087229, 0.09539589187545099]",,3.080409058253281,3.0274655860848725,3.0969332238892093,"[3.080409058253281, 3.0274655860848725, 3.0969332238892093]" +rotated_stripes,96,full_chebyshev_bessel,,9216,total_error_study,2.0,0.022307554470202804,0.021693378969424918,0.022307554470205014,4.8656552834444236e-14,4.865710988278603e-14,-9.851297356329268e-17,-0.04538006996760202,4.100391563967662e-20,0.0006308271049904619,0.03694195168209379,"[0.007417684105315255, 0.01923078237775564, 0.03694195168209379]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,96,full_chebyshev_bessel,,9216,total_error_study,8.0,0.07532227220263055,0.07341596332132123,0.07532227220263102,2.382985546566773e-13,2.382184504699414e-13,-6.95017052562409e-17,-0.0019367191938234566,7.545955208197854e-19,0.002293040730416934,0.10050227320212281,"[0.04166064461439213, 0.08444420619183737, 0.10050227320212281]",,3.056440653046593,3.0460043259663507,3.057825480005704,"[3.057825480005704, 3.056440653046593, 3.0460043259663507]" +rotated_stripes,96,full_sparse_exponential,,9216,total_error_study,2.0,0.022307554470205014,0.02169337896942711,0.022307554470205014,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0842021724855044e-19,0.0006308271049904619,0.036941951682094826,"[0.007417684105324557, 0.019230782377756883, 0.036941951682094826]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,96,full_sparse_exponential,,9216,total_error_study,8.0,0.07532227220263102,0.07341596332132161,0.07532227220263102,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,8.673617379884035e-19,0.002293040730416934,0.1005022732021246,"[0.04166064461439748, 0.08444420619183104, 0.1005022732021246]",,31.773752107284963,31.70904732705094,31.850751955993474,"[31.773752107284963, 31.850751955993474, 31.70904732705094]" +rotated_stripes,96,full_stormer_verlet,,9216,total_error_study,2.0,0.022245295727174336,0.0216310226423922,0.022307554470205014,6.596193027238368e-05,6.596268544268941e-05,-2.7781555275934703e-06,-0.9440092916845306,9.317362419797304e-20,0.0006308271049904619,0.03684115158954006,"[0.007397459328011459, 0.019171796933654887, 0.03684115158954006]",0.125,,,, +rotated_stripes,96,full_stormer_verlet,,9216,total_error_study,8.0,0.07513712797062325,0.07322958776028375,0.07532227220263102,0.00022597451655570605,0.0002258985551009762,-2.7907720250622977e-05,-0.8200824151808823,1.8634724839594607e-19,0.002293040730416934,0.1002628914945587,"[0.04154848393480276, 0.08423322650074333, 0.1002628914945587]",0.125,2.0879057969432324,2.07734800723847,2.181964673451148,"[2.07734800723847, 2.0879057969432324, 2.181964673451148]" +rotated_stripes,96,full_stormer_verlet,,9216,total_error_study,2.0,0.0220827827194964,0.021468256151140314,0.022307554470205014,0.00023813666867316037,0.00023813939499939347,-1.0034404176125412e-05,-0.9444487285470361,6.437450399132683e-20,0.0006308271049904619,0.036578008257474245,"[0.007344677492163071, 0.01901786884189706, 0.036578008257474245]",0.25,,,, +rotated_stripes,96,full_stormer_verlet,,9216,total_error_study,8.0,0.07465334468030119,0.0727425792397515,0.07532227220263102,0.0008158154876123183,0.0008155412507993594,-0.00010098792534314103,-0.8219967663428414,1.6534083130403943e-18,0.002293040730416934,0.0996372368029743,"[0.04125568076397122, 0.08368190455996587, 0.0996372368029743]",0.25,1.1179909447673708,1.1062234033597633,1.140757654211484,"[1.1062234033597633, 1.1179909447673708, 1.140757654211484]" +rotated_stripes,96,rational_krylov,128,352,total_error_study,2.0,0.022383882400389334,0.02177815175336187,0.022307554470205014,0.0024001764186090606,0.002400203897216075,-2.3497738749154256e-06,-0.021942998660552205,1.2705494208814505e-19,0.0006308271049904619,0.03702761995128406,"[0.007443393536712252, 0.019383876262280237, 0.03702761995128406]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,96,rational_krylov,128,352,total_error_study,8.0,0.075153766448841,0.07324314035485299,0.07532227220263102,0.005635937434333928,0.005634042910947824,-5.70985178427021e-05,-0.06727462355751528,1.734723475976807e-18,0.002293040730416934,0.1000685744924604,"[0.04164448420346303, 0.08452934702859108, 0.1000685744924604]",,1.3083196809748188,1.2949735609581694,1.3186313807964325,"[1.3186313807964325, 1.3083196809748188, 1.2949735609581694]" +rotated_stripes,96,rational_krylov,256,608,total_error_study,2.0,0.022283126573983285,0.021669387484104324,0.022307554470205014,0.0005083999698750428,0.0005084057903317683,-1.3477329766464704e-06,-0.05941709422777107,9.698527246061739e-20,0.0006308271049904619,0.03688668485042988,"[0.0074178837771509696, 0.019235492327629205, 0.03688668485042988]",,,,, +rotated_stripes,96,rational_krylov,256,608,total_error_study,8.0,0.07527332339895759,0.07336566293479141,0.07532227220263102,0.0009735116579950968,0.0009731844115300313,-8.318562142031262e-06,-0.05674135637250432,6.606856988583543e-19,0.002293040730416934,0.10039408841127587,"[0.041659986968424566, 0.08443553597425282, 0.10039408841127587]",,2.6830100868828595,2.682944796863012,2.992632301989943,"[2.992632301989943, 2.682944796863012, 2.6830100868828595]" +double_inclusion,32,full_sparse_exponential,,1024,propagation,2.0,0.1489180150870123,0.148511156379793,0.1489180150870123,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,3.469446951953614e-18,0.000477141718842877,0.1943626819834432,"[0.11032266988861344, 0.1943626819834432, 0.14129334294173457]",,,,, +double_inclusion,32,full_sparse_exponential,,1024,propagation,8.0,0.49101100800098363,0.48998485968561295,0.49101100800098363,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,2.7755575615628914e-17,0.0020215697514913444,0.5403304389013015,"[0.46972012822379394, 0.5403304389013015, 0.4737920490092771]",,,,, +double_inclusion,48,full_sparse_exponential,,2304,propagation,2.0,0.06947094431320627,0.06901065867001523,0.06947094431320627,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.734723475976807e-18,0.000477141718842877,0.09422725309744141,"[0.052551667537902795, 0.09422725309744141, 0.06122618564934666]",,,,, +double_inclusion,48,full_sparse_exponential,,2304,propagation,8.0,0.25918936948717214,0.2577114831814384,0.25918936948717214,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0020215697514913444,0.28908248961218425,"[0.24254408101546715, 0.28908248961218425, 0.2520416086119838]",,,,, +double_inclusion,64,full_sparse_exponential,,4096,propagation,2.0,0.03887091752262599,0.0383996257972731,0.03887091752262599,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,2.168404344971009e-19,0.000477141718842877,0.05276353311940649,"[0.029801318814248776, 0.05276353311940649, 0.03388621134251081]",,,,, +double_inclusion,64,full_sparse_exponential,,4096,propagation,8.0,0.1551418250637821,0.1534424677060284,0.1551418250637821,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,6.938893903907228e-18,0.0020215697514913444,0.17520061886793065,"[0.14160285167883824, 0.17520061886793065, 0.15234898533746585]",,,,, +double_inclusion,96,full_sparse_exponential,,9216,propagation,2.0,0.016903283989153393,0.01642742979674582,0.016903283989153393,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.000477141718842877,0.022941229914937224,"[0.013040284240012278, 0.022941229914937224, 0.014672226615650551]",,,,, +double_inclusion,96,full_sparse_exponential,,9216,propagation,8.0,0.0705853348507386,0.06865138809572542,0.0705853348507386,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,8.673617379884035e-19,0.0020215697514913444,0.0816118005829029,"[0.06307871170142527, 0.0816118005829029, 0.06892849665283818]",,,,, +double_inclusion,128,full_sparse_exponential,,16384,propagation,2.0,0.009223313644436576,0.008746599663873082,0.009223313644436576,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.3552527156068805e-20,0.000477141718842877,0.012509675640380271,"[0.007130073753995115, 0.012509675640380271, 0.008003319088995955]",,,,, +double_inclusion,128,full_sparse_exponential,,16384,propagation,8.0,0.03889825936833396,0.03690499840544872,0.03889825936833396,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,4.336808689942018e-19,0.0020215697514913444,0.04534050507741961,"[0.03461085148447354, 0.04534050507741961, 0.037806781707756136]",,,,, +double_inclusion,192,full_sparse_exponential,,36864,propagation,2.0,0.0037524014125966706,0.0032753493437271556,0.0037524014125966706,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,3.3881317890172014e-21,0.000477141718842877,0.005086433618970467,"[0.0029047424973971695, 0.005086433618970467, 0.003256224444951792]",,,,, +double_inclusion,192,full_sparse_exponential,,36864,propagation,8.0,0.015887360031421854,0.013870261399189779,0.015887360031421854,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0020215697514913444,0.018599568840271075,"[0.014120531532328553, 0.018599568840271075, 0.015385777260749068]",,,,, +double_inclusion,256,full_sparse_exponential,,65536,propagation,2.0,0.0018411179673775567,0.0013640032772636417,0.0018411179673775567,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,4.235164736271502e-22,0.000477141718842877,0.0024950907893890265,"[0.0014258664284047791, 0.0024950907893890265, 0.0015977849290711272]",,,,, +double_inclusion,256,full_sparse_exponential,,65536,propagation,8.0,0.0077995337374295575,0.005778869269544947,0.0077995337374295575,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.3552527156068805e-20,0.0020215697514913444,0.00913972668748201,"[0.006933541356363277, 0.00913972668748201, 0.007544539577808138]",,,,, +double_inclusion,384,full_sparse_exponential,,147456,propagation,2.0,0.000477141718842877,0.0,0.000477141718842877,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,7.940933880509066e-23,0.000477141718842877,0.0006465132899476964,"[0.0003696450656057606, 0.0006465132899476964, 0.0004141089525673735]",,,,, +double_inclusion,384,full_sparse_exponential,,147456,propagation,8.0,0.0020215697514913444,0.0,0.0020215697514913444,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,8.470329472543003e-22,0.0020215697514913444,0.002370038142752545,"[0.0017977285700239028, 0.002370038142752545, 0.001953975840731073]",,,,, +double_inclusion,32,craig_bampton,128,288,same_grid_study,2.0,0.14762631053738745,0.14721915658009307,0.1489180150870123,0.005535057028608958,0.005528198911211128,-0.00041360863777638155,-0.2512052457819194,5.366800753803247e-18,0.000477141718842877,0.19218027752636463,"[0.10968451106849071, 0.19218027752636463, 0.14034126146432588]",,,,, +double_inclusion,32,craig_bampton,128,288,same_grid_study,8.0,0.48618146982840765,0.485151173526971,0.49101100800098363,0.013050241460802326,0.013092128834198505,-0.004890792211042388,-0.3804063143414956,6.071532165918825e-17,0.0020215697514913444,0.5344482570268249,"[0.46524234959692595, 0.5344482570268249, 0.46945786556991204]",,,,, +double_inclusion,32,craig_bampton,16,64,same_grid_study,2.0,0.4723652259165975,0.47241474721568494,0.1489180150870123,0.48756723025904286,0.486963118451853,-0.03618074729457092,-0.24946190141379032,6.938893903907228e-17,0.000477141718842877,0.5906022295847415,"[0.32675674568001195, 0.5906022295847415, 0.4887942918033047]",,,,, +double_inclusion,32,craig_bampton,16,64,same_grid_study,8.0,0.529785537509417,0.5298492348861236,0.49101100800098363,0.6126006649068592,0.6145669298890646,-0.3381116055372705,-0.5602342638016738,0.0,0.0020215697514913444,0.6363697084580773,"[0.5115133935067346, 0.6363697084580773, 0.45848523729669]",,,,, +double_inclusion,32,craig_bampton,32,96,same_grid_study,2.0,0.1916268447793765,0.19141869892058147,0.1489180150870123,0.1662584946069836,0.16605249487319443,-0.013029158630968624,-0.2634472878966436,6.938893903907228e-18,0.000477141718842877,0.24440688295142043,"[0.14219268604801183, 0.24440688295142043, 0.18733495952483042]",,,,, +double_inclusion,32,craig_bampton,32,96,same_grid_study,8.0,0.40329519439084505,0.4022752274670639,0.49101100800098363,0.26653561672568293,0.2673911163679465,-0.14994280527188927,-0.5710280379248742,8.326672684688674e-17,0.0020215697514913444,0.4341953397399984,"[0.378719780047549, 0.4341953397399984, 0.40335705093199314]",,,,, +double_inclusion,32,craig_bampton,64,160,same_grid_study,2.0,0.1493140002237461,0.1489262339920184,0.1489180150870123,0.04947772343338365,0.0494164189094863,-0.0023238870124766137,-0.15789431893893804,0.0,0.000477141718842877,0.20114129251122978,"[0.11021806050788215, 0.20114129251122978, 0.13529764429198085]",,,,, +double_inclusion,32,craig_bampton,64,160,same_grid_study,8.0,0.46937378182953937,0.46831934827500254,0.49101100800098363,0.07219635983101545,0.07242808856118262,-0.026025890921804556,-0.3659125936890851,3.8163916471489756e-17,0.0020215697514913444,0.5127301446038182,"[0.44760648198470715, 0.5127301446038182, 0.4573204452527643]",,,,, +double_inclusion,32,full_sparse_exponential,,1024,same_grid_study,2.0,0.14891801508701227,0.14851115637979298,0.1489180150870123,5.130547419440914e-16,5.124190502730607e-16,-1.2039449206938231e-17,-0.07888675959302609,1.6311083510773887e-18,0.000477141718842877,0.19436268198344314,"[0.1103226698886134, 0.19436268198344314, 0.1412933429417345]",,,,, +double_inclusion,32,full_sparse_exponential,,1024,same_grid_study,8.0,0.49101100800098363,0.48998485968561295,0.49101100800098363,5.044392554931052e-16,5.060583546886254e-16,3.799934180973068e-18,0.0076463513624871245,7.946679266591367e-17,0.0020215697514913444,0.5403304389013015,"[0.46972012822379394, 0.5403304389013015, 0.4737920490092771]",,,,, +double_inclusion,32,rational_krylov,128,288,same_grid_study,2.0,0.14892109349478294,0.14851426050708633,0.1489180150870123,0.000279514304095675,0.00027916797669526105,8.3893546704447e-07,0.010089873504438752,2.638295872460332e-18,0.000477141718842877,0.1943724137417249,"[0.1103194453502121, 0.1943724137417249, 0.14129445021364662]",,,,, +double_inclusion,32,rational_krylov,128,288,same_grid_study,8.0,0.4910135840069314,0.48998730665587104,0.49101100800098363,0.0013881955208405827,0.0013926512134270382,5.902237875688559e-07,0.00043157186302920567,5.322363287807918e-17,0.0020215697514913444,0.5403309759437367,"[0.4697208834838465, 0.5403309759437367, 0.4737980420680843]",,,,, +double_inclusion,32,rational_krylov,16,64,same_grid_study,2.0,0.2667384587948529,0.26652216464979817,0.1489180150870123,0.21150533841911934,0.21124327636020124,0.004349108375405464,0.06912578888914626,1.6479873021779667e-17,0.000477141718842877,0.3714978623593861,"[0.21232066116494064, 0.3714978623593861, 0.21413917506395702]",,,,, +double_inclusion,32,rational_krylov,16,64,same_grid_study,8.0,0.5562331814826977,0.5556736571316253,0.49101100800098363,0.4183111165829884,0.41965377020274813,-0.10780574464115915,-0.2615950670389263,4.163336342344337e-17,0.0020215697514913444,0.660722096721022,"[0.4689612789363467, 0.660722096721022, 0.5521351854185093]",,,,, +double_inclusion,32,rational_krylov,32,96,same_grid_study,2.0,0.14536839702217078,0.14501422601990052,0.1489180150870123,0.06562736613253592,0.0655460516710731,-0.005340889254327135,-0.2735834375921268,8.673617379884035e-19,0.000477141718842877,0.17660287984456707,"[0.11880791589035182, 0.17660287984456707, 0.14226175053341295]",,,,, +double_inclusion,32,rational_krylov,32,96,same_grid_study,8.0,0.48298864632174343,0.4819666172219552,0.49101100800098363,0.12218913119157017,0.12258132177122719,-0.022839957949612907,-0.18973601533422063,2.42861286636753e-17,0.0020215697514913444,0.530553152649637,"[0.4579891577639671, 0.530553152649637, 0.47066428992728476]",,,,, +double_inclusion,32,rational_krylov,64,160,same_grid_study,2.0,0.14880874851375048,0.14840253791186947,0.1489180150870123,0.004022921525251433,0.00401793699339208,-4.867540090985433e-05,-0.04067515162148814,1.0909784360635388e-18,0.000477141718842877,0.19392740142000733,"[0.11002764183543547, 0.19392740142000733, 0.14164564975779567]",,,,, +double_inclusion,32,rational_krylov,64,160,same_grid_study,8.0,0.49127767160631386,0.490252450573306,0.49101100800098363,0.018384417349212704,0.018443425832426648,-7.821931565708564e-05,-0.004318681676132581,9.461019207651633e-17,0.0020215697514913444,0.540640671432316,"[0.46991114032143344, 0.540640671432316, 0.4740969814102327]",,,,, +double_inclusion,64,craig_bampton,128,320,same_grid_study,2.0,0.036348502727784025,0.035886309743080234,0.03887091752262599,0.008395072118500782,0.008386906370933058,-0.00026007477697386605,-0.3988794408595307,3.7947076036992655e-19,0.000477141718842877,0.04799847080289056,"[0.029179958643192266, 0.04799847080289056, 0.032107965464155466]",,,,, +double_inclusion,64,craig_bampton,128,320,same_grid_study,8.0,0.14168680461168148,0.13996058979911088,0.1551418250637821,0.02114500547322616,0.02115812586576903,-0.004441501573204096,-0.6765403942474626,3.469446951953614e-18,0.0020215697514913444,0.15926300023640308,"[0.12912109137757788, 0.15926300023640308, 0.1399231637364022]",,,,, +double_inclusion,64,craig_bampton,16,96,same_grid_study,2.0,0.49246284336381096,0.49251444432263153,0.03887091752262599,0.4968535629412145,0.4963702817119608,-0.0053747527018926855,-0.13928294058622487,7.806255641895632e-18,0.000477141718842877,0.6134005631966719,"[0.3372276886551976, 0.6134005631966719, 0.5138128212542147]",,,,, +double_inclusion,64,craig_bampton,16,96,same_grid_study,8.0,0.5844403700404568,0.5846478722610147,0.1551418250637821,0.6032449223316666,0.6036192334279917,-0.046854618715291355,-0.2501672455806604,9.71445146547012e-17,0.0020215697514913444,0.7356756871918896,"[0.5183931791537875, 0.7356756871918896, 0.5188243727509552]",,,,, +double_inclusion,64,craig_bampton,32,128,same_grid_study,2.0,0.15128328445057743,0.15129549442161622,0.03887091752262599,0.15604292518206084,0.15589114481391392,-0.002926365106289151,-0.24146393602334748,7.37257477290143e-18,0.000477141718842877,0.1974103857028135,"[0.1031495230925362, 0.1974103857028135, 0.14973629454827808]",,,,, +double_inclusion,64,craig_bampton,32,128,same_grid_study,8.0,0.20461140767454689,0.2048702959082239,0.1551418250637821,0.2542382280921238,0.25439598191045204,-0.04692047334574455,-0.5944197701653655,2.7755575615628914e-17,0.0020215697514913444,0.26527678166018487,"[0.14845544882431647, 0.26527678166018487, 0.20155708061275315]",,,,, +double_inclusion,64,craig_bampton,64,192,same_grid_study,2.0,0.05237272331877215,0.05211036453712492,0.03887091752262599,0.04414704887397068,0.04410410777091924,-0.0007132184034949908,-0.20801215465929196,7.589415207398531e-19,0.000477141718842877,0.07026679102842115,"[0.036755496441201206, 0.07026679102842115, 0.0491630136056001]",,,,, +double_inclusion,64,craig_bampton,64,192,same_grid_study,8.0,0.11767632219201174,0.11614333455081186,0.1551418250637821,0.07835548159687689,0.07840410086433171,-0.01636847211182731,-0.6728379397376764,6.938893903907228e-18,0.0020215697514913444,0.13437811783161815,"[0.10580097450057739, 0.13437811783161815, 0.11575830657748921]",,,,, +double_inclusion,64,full_sparse_exponential,,4096,same_grid_study,2.0,0.03887091752262599,0.0383996257972731,0.03887091752262599,7.694730636794247e-17,7.687246099783156e-17,-6.511872963679821e-22,-0.00010896332497429466,2.161892472007329e-19,0.000477141718842877,0.05276353311940649,"[0.029801318814248776, 0.05276353311940649, 0.03388621134251081]",,,,, +double_inclusion,64,full_sparse_exponential,,4096,same_grid_study,8.0,0.1551418250637821,0.1534424677060284,0.1551418250637821,3.659350642729798e-17,3.6616212553785105e-17,-1.477444551810623e-22,-1.3004057424839443e-05,6.93904164836241e-18,0.0020215697514913444,0.17520061886793065,"[0.14160285167883824, 0.17520061886793065, 0.15234898533746585]",,,,, +double_inclusion,64,rational_krylov,128,320,same_grid_study,2.0,0.038879138415275634,0.03840792882057933,0.03887091752262599,0.0005079400788828545,0.0005074460139832157,3.816734062625454e-07,0.009674917440103245,3.332545251853638e-19,0.000477141718842877,0.052768393185792954,"[0.0298004827644537, 0.052768393185792954, 0.03390658441983643]",,,,, +double_inclusion,64,rational_krylov,128,320,same_grid_study,8.0,0.15514341624353142,0.15344418988368858,0.1551418250637821,0.0010762911358686842,0.0010769589702757686,-6.661210311680739e-07,-0.00199340294681761,3.955326226322362e-18,0.0020215697514913444,0.175211997661902,"[0.14160044053128104, 0.175211997661902, 0.15234613789423776]",,,,, +double_inclusion,64,rational_krylov,16,96,same_grid_study,2.0,0.04758823186012499,0.04728262999024588,0.03887091752262599,0.03602134492249428,0.035986307557057146,-0.0005413227490688848,-0.19349253020115828,9.75781955236954e-19,0.000477141718842877,0.05886221420028079,"[0.04095714832798649, 0.05886221420028079, 0.04384906167854375]",,,,, +double_inclusion,64,rational_krylov,16,96,same_grid_study,8.0,0.18295218739165306,0.18178895532844153,0.1551418250637821,0.12738042818654005,0.1274594672400982,-0.006843398801860303,-0.17303774976895264,8.673617379884035e-18,0.0020215697514913444,0.21255386791972117,"[0.16119471348172537, 0.21255386791972117, 0.17980470478048416]",,,,, +double_inclusion,64,rational_krylov,32,128,same_grid_study,2.0,0.03881190553266217,0.03835031313987021,0.03887091752262599,0.008478148383497315,0.008469901829022962,-7.632345496778572e-05,-0.11591105460945014,2.710505431213761e-19,0.000477141718842877,0.05194084629425374,"[0.030536049497271615, 0.05194084629425374, 0.03403596811235047]",,,,, +double_inclusion,64,rational_krylov,32,128,same_grid_study,8.0,0.1528486354238423,0.15113947402718536,0.1551418250637821,0.029616607414983284,0.029634984403136094,-0.001584512833764629,-0.1723186034840208,1.0842021724855044e-18,0.0020215697514913444,0.16998917195682814,"[0.14023035380541432, 0.16998917195682814, 0.1515800860352942]",,,,, +double_inclusion,64,rational_krylov,64,192,same_grid_study,2.0,0.038917031184421705,0.03844607876360763,0.03887091752262599,0.001328689179655075,0.0013273967857025419,1.8251049317664127e-06,0.017686108677104063,4.417276819931176e-19,0.000477141718842877,0.05281738996319737,"[0.02982095760707947, 0.05281738996319737, 0.033949531282110576]",,,,, +double_inclusion,64,rational_krylov,64,192,same_grid_study,8.0,0.15506223623274168,0.15336103962708106,0.1551418250637821,0.003511693959545811,0.003513872951804669,-3.7036081744012386e-05,-0.033968790783407796,4.2825985813177425e-18,0.0020215697514913444,0.1749900705680488,"[0.14157043606491662, 0.1749900705680488, 0.15233386698307744]",,,,, +double_inclusion,128,craig_bampton,128,384,total_error_study,2.0,0.009945897742544419,0.009693026313415285,0.009223313644436576,0.009161657966099617,0.009159421415191282,-7.004363333956445e-05,-0.4145564265218103,1.3552527156068805e-20,0.000477141718842877,0.012100980569339066,"[0.008079514840938638, 0.012100980569339066, 0.009755087046282777]",,,,, +double_inclusion,128,craig_bampton,128,384,total_error_study,8.0,0.025925649049562165,0.02435135574390486,0.03889825936833396,0.02377098310922861,0.023773128996892247,-0.0014060969655479958,-0.7602715876005469,2.168404344971009e-19,0.0020215697514913444,0.029389210746034837,"[0.023304478086013266, 0.029389210746034837, 0.025685317540226696]",,1.8647517159115523,1.8503011669963598,1.866754246992059,"[1.866754246992059, 1.8503011669963598, 1.8647517159115523]" +double_inclusion,128,craig_bampton,256,640,total_error_study,2.0,0.00842076581193507,0.007968274182251786,0.009223313644436576,0.002873873152136291,0.0028731715800373718,-2.241533265252988e-05,-0.42292820915109924,1.3552527156068805e-20,0.000477141718842877,0.010855187972229608,"[0.006982029251036447, 0.010855187972229608, 0.007535959429585417]",,,,, +double_inclusion,128,craig_bampton,256,640,total_error_study,8.0,0.03360167598287914,0.03162506356143462,0.03889825936833396,0.0074822019312469745,0.00748287737511681,-0.00043999540683881886,-0.7558216904248843,3.7947076036992655e-19,0.0020215697514913444,0.03840382942711426,"[0.030114172478087405, 0.03840382942711426, 0.03311153861461666]",,5.433097510016523,5.375958552933298,5.446739818784408,"[5.433097510016523, 5.375958552933298, 5.446739818784408]" +double_inclusion,128,full_chebyshev_bessel,,16384,total_error_study,2.0,0.009223313644434013,0.008746599663870518,0.009223313644436576,7.977520940928633e-14,7.975573462451187e-14,-4.726574051476821e-17,-0.03212680769941469,8.07832155628716e-21,0.000477141718842877,0.012509675640383001,"[0.007130073753989852, 0.012509675640383001, 0.008003319088989254]",,,,, +double_inclusion,128,full_chebyshev_bessel,,16384,total_error_study,8.0,0.038898259368320254,0.03690499840543496,0.03889825936833396,3.602809246372548e-13,3.6031344842426307e-13,-1.0657113649072927e-15,-0.03801884872629318,4.930515149523229e-19,0.0020215697514913444,0.0453405050774134,"[0.034610851484468366, 0.0453405050774134, 0.03780678170772827]",,4.555397795047611,4.551345726009458,4.557032314012758,"[4.551345726009458, 4.555397795047611, 4.557032314012758]" +double_inclusion,128,full_sparse_exponential,,16384,total_error_study,2.0,0.009223313644436576,0.008746599663873082,0.009223313644436576,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.3552527156068805e-20,0.000477141718842877,0.012509675640380271,"[0.007130073753995115, 0.012509675640380271, 0.008003319088995955]",,,,, +double_inclusion,128,full_sparse_exponential,,16384,total_error_study,8.0,0.03889825936833396,0.03690499840544872,0.03889825936833396,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,4.336808689942018e-19,0.0020215697514913444,0.04534050507741961,"[0.03461085148447354, 0.04534050507741961, 0.037806781707756136]",,51.284732521278784,51.21852530981414,51.3857603619108,"[51.284732521278784, 51.3857603619108, 51.21852530981414]" +double_inclusion,128,full_stormer_verlet,,16384,total_error_study,2.0,0.009191138569987746,0.00871442253484723,0.009223313644436576,3.537931745991959e-05,3.537068063404222e-05,-5.93737455982032e-07,-0.9099846307161061,3.5998900258307764e-21,0.000477141718842877,0.012470027534139238,"[0.007104520221828315, 0.012470027534139238, 0.007971320857581973]",0.125,,,, +double_inclusion,128,full_stormer_verlet,,16384,total_error_study,8.0,0.03876188874107803,0.03676846546698791,0.03889825936833396,0.00014195717710874784,0.00014196999206695643,-1.0610718589116474e-05,-0.960700629016804,2.1175823681357508e-19,0.0020215697514913444,0.04518628915688505,"[0.034494342612220244, 0.04518628915688505, 0.03766590672042284]",0.125,4.681569554028101,4.673742941929959,4.8093410490546376,"[4.673742941929959, 4.8093410490546376, 4.681569554028101]" +double_inclusion,128,full_stormer_verlet,,16384,total_error_study,2.0,0.009094751822378042,0.008618037489479683,0.009223313644436576,0.0001415203137041775,0.00014148576565759747,-2.3750220948848975e-06,-0.9099927491829047,1.4823076576950256e-20,0.000477141718842877,0.012351236440287735,"[0.007027985362403772, 0.012351236440287735, 0.007875448926901701]",0.25,,,, +double_inclusion,128,full_stormer_verlet,,16384,total_error_study,8.0,0.03835286747767727,0.03635896966285459,0.03889825936833396,0.000567841778472176,0.0005678930394848872,-4.245464063020109e-05,-0.9609448417173215,2.846030702774449e-19,0.0020215697514913444,0.04472373392854671,"[0.034144903106263405, 0.04472373392854671, 0.03724335788066242]",0.25,2.380482697626576,2.3631861011963338,2.446618514484726,"[2.3631861011963338, 2.380482697626576, 2.446618514484726]" +double_inclusion,128,rational_krylov,128,384,total_error_study,2.0,0.00923471023533933,0.008758425956199715,0.009223313644436576,0.00032818325497087526,0.00032810313862515253,1.0270687745542426e-07,0.016969621978781147,3.282252670610414e-21,0.000477141718842877,0.012541722660283076,"[0.007130267295402275, 0.012541722660283076, 0.008001083418711787]",,,,, +double_inclusion,128,rational_krylov,128,384,total_error_study,8.0,0.038900205974785225,0.03690677565487412,0.03889825936833396,0.00047837236416724033,0.00047841554847098466,-7.743844248263451e-08,-0.0020806122933937467,4.425614800505711e-19,0.0020215697514913444,0.04536156057778433,"[0.03461005090931253, 0.04536156057778433, 0.03779480445174338]",,2.903360537835397,2.8958723570685834,2.9367987100267783,"[2.8958723570685834, 2.9367987100267783, 2.903360537835397]" +double_inclusion,128,rational_krylov,256,640,total_error_study,2.0,0.009222695876499192,0.008745981512189017,0.009223313644436576,2.8515962225209637e-05,2.8509000886830395e-05,-1.2208116386255752e-08,-0.02321398451925148,2.3323184551545168e-20,0.000477141718842877,0.012508552942959715,"[0.0071300987187467345, 0.012508552942959715, 0.008002693660248625]",,,,, +double_inclusion,128,rational_krylov,256,640,total_error_study,8.0,0.03889754503316053,0.03690424757657837,0.03889825936833396,5.349440536260739e-05,5.349923448490383e-05,-5.8434447518799547e-08,-0.014039809367895334,4.387035096736238e-19,0.0020215697514913444,0.04533991484628405,"[0.03461076567266714, 0.04533991484628405, 0.03780539402523271]",,6.017363922088407,5.981442059041001,6.126989899086766,"[6.126989899086766, 6.017363922088407, 5.981442059041001]" +double_inclusion,32,craig_bampton,128,288,total_error_study,2.0,0.14762631053738745,0.14721915658009307,0.1489180150870123,0.005535057028608958,0.005528198911211128,-0.00041360863777638155,-0.2512052457819194,5.366800753803247e-18,0.000477141718842877,0.19218027752636463,"[0.10968451106849071, 0.19218027752636463, 0.14034126146432588]",,,,, +double_inclusion,32,craig_bampton,128,288,total_error_study,8.0,0.48618146982840765,0.485151173526971,0.49101100800098363,0.013050241460802326,0.013092128834198505,-0.004890792211042388,-0.3804063143414956,6.071532165918825e-17,0.0020215697514913444,0.5344482570268249,"[0.46524234959692595, 0.5344482570268249, 0.46945786556991204]",,0.1657112940447405,0.15897564601618797,0.17164605809375644,"[0.17164605809375644, 0.1657112940447405, 0.15897564601618797]" +double_inclusion,32,full_chebyshev_bessel,,1024,total_error_study,2.0,0.1489180150870122,0.1485111563797929,0.1489180150870123,1.5943309650234558e-14,1.5923555366091483e-14,-3.07702475006925e-17,-0.006488042897423512,3.0146718850635867e-18,0.000477141718842877,0.19436268198344311,"[0.11032266988861318, 0.19436268198344311, 0.1412933429417345]",,,,, +double_inclusion,32,full_chebyshev_bessel,,1024,total_error_study,8.0,0.4910110080009813,0.4899848596856107,0.49101100800098363,8.289417332521536e-14,8.316023883832253e-14,-2.2435981559115287e-15,-0.02747312878864779,5.090768227684456e-17,0.0020215697514913444,0.540330438901301,"[0.46972012822379033, 0.540330438901301, 0.4737920490092746]",,1.106581045081839,1.105206920998171,1.1082116471370682,"[1.1082116471370682, 1.106581045081839, 1.105206920998171]" +double_inclusion,32,full_sparse_exponential,,1024,total_error_study,2.0,0.1489180150870123,0.148511156379793,0.1489180150870123,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,3.469446951953614e-18,0.000477141718842877,0.1943626819834432,"[0.11032266988861344, 0.1943626819834432, 0.14129334294173457]",,,,, +double_inclusion,32,full_sparse_exponential,,1024,total_error_study,8.0,0.4910110080009835,0.48998485968561295,0.49101100800098363,3.6232221734676425e-16,3.634851633392442e-16,-2.3611540845351118e-17,-0.06614795408492954,5.1367116460980034e-17,0.0020215697514913444,0.5403304389013015,"[0.46972012822379383, 0.5403304389013015, 0.4737920490092771]",,3.3569601493654773,3.337191199650988,3.402428924338892,"[3.337191199650988, 3.402428924338892, 3.3569601493654773]" +double_inclusion,32,rational_krylov,128,288,total_error_study,2.0,0.14892109349478294,0.14851426050708633,0.1489180150870123,0.000279514304095675,0.00027916797669526105,8.3893546704447e-07,0.010089873504438752,2.638295872460332e-18,0.000477141718842877,0.1943724137417249,"[0.1103194453502121, 0.1943724137417249, 0.14129445021364662]",,,,, +double_inclusion,32,rational_krylov,128,288,total_error_study,8.0,0.4910135840069314,0.48998730665587104,0.49101100800098363,0.0013881955208405827,0.0013926512134270382,5.902237875688559e-07,0.00043157186302920567,5.322363287807918e-17,0.0020215697514913444,0.5403309759437367,"[0.4697208834838465, 0.5403309759437367, 0.4737980420680843]",,0.11522103613242507,0.11393537907861173,0.1153868829132989,"[0.11522103613242507, 0.1153868829132989, 0.11393537907861173]" +double_inclusion,64,craig_bampton,128,320,total_error_study,2.0,0.036348502727784025,0.035886309743080234,0.03887091752262599,0.008395072118500782,0.008386906370933058,-0.00026007477697386605,-0.3988794408595307,3.7947076036992655e-19,0.000477141718842877,0.04799847080289056,"[0.029179958643192266, 0.04799847080289056, 0.032107965464155466]",,,,, +double_inclusion,64,craig_bampton,128,320,total_error_study,8.0,0.14168680461168148,0.13996058979911088,0.1551418250637821,0.02114500547322616,0.02115812586576903,-0.004441501573204096,-0.6765403942474626,3.469446951953614e-18,0.0020215697514913444,0.15926300023640308,"[0.12912109137757788, 0.15926300023640308, 0.1399231637364022]",,0.5634980609174818,0.5601421769242734,0.568744602962397,"[0.568744602962397, 0.5634980609174818, 0.5601421769242734]" +double_inclusion,64,full_chebyshev_bessel,,4096,total_error_study,2.0,0.03887091752262192,0.03839962579726904,0.03887091752262599,3.6942638328208176e-14,3.6906704835938456e-14,-3.1539113687106834e-16,-0.10992321586083413,1.1169532221344773e-19,0.000477141718842877,0.05276353311939962,"[0.029801318814247246, 0.05276353311939962, 0.03388621134250757]",,,,, +double_inclusion,64,full_chebyshev_bessel,,4096,total_error_study,8.0,0.15514182506378113,0.15344246770602737,0.1551418250637821,1.5924419174286397e-13,1.5934300213610242e-13,-3.0492778053347726e-16,-0.006167442448959131,6.555342665466437e-18,0.0020215697514913444,0.17520061886793148,"[0.14160285167884062, 0.17520061886793148, 0.15234898533746039]",,2.0758543570991606,2.0725245209177956,2.0776753320824355,"[2.0776753320824355, 2.0758543570991606, 2.0725245209177956]" +double_inclusion,64,full_sparse_exponential,,4096,total_error_study,2.0,0.03887091752262599,0.0383996257972731,0.03887091752262599,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,2.168404344971009e-19,0.000477141718842877,0.05276353311940649,"[0.029801318814248776, 0.05276353311940649, 0.03388621134251081]",,,,, +double_inclusion,64,full_sparse_exponential,,4096,total_error_study,8.0,0.1551418250637821,0.1534424677060284,0.1551418250637821,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,6.938893903907228e-18,0.0020215697514913444,0.17520061886793065,"[0.14160285167883824, 0.17520061886793065, 0.15234898533746585]",,10.831572716822848,10.825702423928306,10.84057843091432,"[10.825702423928306, 10.84057843091432, 10.831572716822848]" +double_inclusion,64,full_stormer_verlet,,4096,total_error_study,2.0,0.03874449507184816,0.03827317735090892,0.03887091752262599,0.00014069309057413416,0.00014055624073580823,-9.832086735135021e-06,-0.8997892086166268,3.1170812458958252e-19,0.000477141718842877,0.052607655060171454,"[0.029702484826393538, 0.052607655060171454, 0.0337593291660104]",0.125,,,, +double_inclusion,64,full_stormer_verlet,,4096,total_error_study,8.0,0.15466882360242212,0.15296837158680174,0.1551418250637821,0.0005626265785107397,0.0005629756860848408,-0.00014685783118712625,-0.8407145807680299,6.884683795282953e-18,0.0020215697514913444,0.17469435241345674,"[0.14117363783762815, 0.17469435241345674, 0.1518593233418428]",0.125,0.6050069364719093,0.5970728173851967,0.6076569474535063,"[0.6050069364719093, 0.6076569474535063, 0.5970728173851967]" +double_inclusion,64,full_stormer_verlet,,4096,total_error_study,2.0,0.03843519897575752,0.0379638225830447,0.03887091752262599,0.00048529156089128004,0.0004848195258298715,-3.391875871734563e-05,-0.8999223967335773,4.472333961502706e-19,0.000477141718842877,0.05222622292915484,"[0.02946073774240995, 0.05222622292915484, 0.03344888932101032]",0.25,,,, +double_inclusion,64,full_stormer_verlet,,4096,total_error_study,8.0,0.15350950835641908,0.1518063725444983,0.1551418250637821,0.0019406745037563234,0.0019418786846357968,-0.0005075876211175081,-0.8424226511471102,3.144186300207963e-18,0.0020215697514913444,0.173453555925756,"[0.14012201847869346, 0.173453555925756, 0.15065876318704002]",0.25,0.3311032101046294,0.32157507352530956,0.3313122063409537,"[0.3313122063409537, 0.32157507352530956, 0.3311032101046294]" +double_inclusion,64,rational_krylov,128,320,total_error_study,2.0,0.038879138415275634,0.03840792882057933,0.03887091752262599,0.0005079400788828545,0.0005074460139832157,3.816734062625454e-07,0.009674917440103245,3.332545251853638e-19,0.000477141718842877,0.052768393185792954,"[0.0298004827644537, 0.052768393185792954, 0.03390658441983643]",,,,, +double_inclusion,64,rational_krylov,128,320,total_error_study,8.0,0.15514341624353142,0.15344418988368858,0.1551418250637821,0.0010762911358686842,0.0010769589702757686,-6.661210311680739e-07,-0.00199340294681761,3.955326226322362e-18,0.0020215697514913444,0.175211997661902,"[0.14160044053128104, 0.175211997661902, 0.15234613789423776]",,0.4658817320596427,0.4608074980787933,0.47032642585691065,"[0.4608074980787933, 0.4658817320596427, 0.47032642585691065]" +double_inclusion,96,craig_bampton,128,352,total_error_study,2.0,0.015530266229146746,0.015125183684619355,0.016903283989153393,0.00890864344178935,0.008904662430879852,-0.00012382485347771664,-0.4113289516924587,5.421010862427522e-20,0.000477141718842877,0.01953874517685934,"[0.012998088193160812, 0.01953874517685934, 0.01429681909527139]",,,,, +double_inclusion,96,craig_bampton,128,352,total_error_study,8.0,0.05552676462431031,0.05364125884754468,0.0705853348507386,0.02294217311912089,0.022946784433364457,-0.0024256228221786317,-0.7487846957530649,8.673617379884035e-19,0.0020215697514913444,0.06270312827691348,"[0.050074638810779275, 0.06270312827691348, 0.05506743308685547]",,1.0147776119410992,1.0119002169230953,1.0261704928707331,"[1.0261704928707331, 1.0119002169230953, 1.0147776119410992]" +double_inclusion,96,craig_bampton,256,608,total_error_study,2.0,0.015976822990755517,0.015506422640057528,0.016903283989153393,0.0027314468574954386,0.0027302262541780585,-3.7916272139038525e-05,-0.4107957193486485,2.710505431213761e-20,0.000477141718842877,0.02116999379241887,"[0.012828564566901408, 0.02116999379241887, 0.014029555325324766]",,,,, +double_inclusion,96,craig_bampton,256,608,total_error_study,8.0,0.06553728572364939,0.06359891819300921,0.0705853348507386,0.007065180274625976,0.007066600356597487,-0.0007370905165674982,-0.7388662301923844,7.589415207398531e-19,0.0020215697514913444,0.07517152835465428,"[0.05870319642617715, 0.07517152835465428, 0.06438653651043222]",,3.0663734739646316,3.0031379790743813,3.0760923069901764,"[3.0031379790743813, 3.0760923069901764, 3.0663734739646316]" +double_inclusion,96,full_chebyshev_bessel,,9216,total_error_study,2.0,0.016903283989151408,0.016427429796743824,0.016903283989153393,6.037033549646486e-14,6.034335776794851e-14,-6.714321741529348e-17,-0.03291331240280103,2.310717018352298e-20,0.000477141718842877,0.02294122991493786,"[0.013040284240009374, 0.02294122991493786, 0.014672226615646095]",,,,, +double_inclusion,96,full_chebyshev_bessel,,9216,total_error_study,8.0,0.07058533485073136,0.06865138809571814,0.0705853348507386,2.5028741875703685e-13,2.5033772584578154e-13,-1.021545622889884e-15,-0.028905932864200647,2.0650446045532547e-19,0.0020215697514913444,0.08161180058289486,"[0.06307871170141006, 0.08161180058289486, 0.06892849665283857]",,3.2070174709660932,3.2060001090867445,3.2229559120023623,"[3.2070174709660932, 3.2060001090867445, 3.2229559120023623]" +double_inclusion,96,full_sparse_exponential,,9216,total_error_study,2.0,0.016903283989153393,0.01642742979674582,0.016903283989153393,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.000477141718842877,0.022941229914937224,"[0.013040284240012278, 0.022941229914937224, 0.014672226615650551]",,,,, +double_inclusion,96,full_sparse_exponential,,9216,total_error_study,8.0,0.0705853348507386,0.06865138809572542,0.0705853348507386,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,8.673617379884035e-19,0.0020215697514913444,0.0816118005829029,"[0.06307871170142527, 0.0816118005829029, 0.06892849665283818]",,24.90149792912416,24.890679303207435,24.96192916610744,"[24.890679303207435, 24.96192916610744, 24.90149792912416]" +double_inclusion,96,full_stormer_verlet,,9216,total_error_study,2.0,0.01684906695266364,0.01637320679245251,0.016903283989153393,5.972881898534556e-05,5.970212793170245e-05,-1.833516786707099e-06,-0.9084352881799612,4.5528020914918643e-20,0.000477141718842877,0.022874341087853686,"[0.012997392089208705, 0.022874341087853686, 0.014618255438902784]",0.125,,,, +double_inclusion,96,full_stormer_verlet,,9216,total_error_study,8.0,0.07036111538948042,0.0684267426397161,0.0705853348507386,0.00023950224812166012,0.00023955038742051355,-3.166032152722972e-05,-0.9362114935130084,1.531435568635775e-18,0.0020215697514913444,0.08136217399749224,"[0.06288466247101802, 0.08136217399749224, 0.0686958144116077]",0.125,2.1642865667818114,2.1528518485138193,2.2101551075465977,"[2.1528518485138193, 2.1642865667818114, 2.2101551075465977]" +double_inclusion,96,full_stormer_verlet,,9216,total_error_study,2.0,0.01668662489329588,0.016210753377048467,0.016903283989153393,0.0002389248489649933,0.000238818080472518,-7.334593363968216e-06,-0.9084640671713909,4.912791094074942e-20,0.000477141718842877,0.02267390285398232,"[0.012868906985849504, 0.02267390285398232, 0.014456528780995457]",0.25,,,, +double_inclusion,96,full_stormer_verlet,,9216,total_error_study,8.0,0.06968841179926823,0.06775277401807797,0.0705853348507386,0.0009580347625154715,0.0009582273248905909,-0.0001267329564926751,-0.9368639770146919,8.131516293641283e-19,0.0020215697514913444,0.08061318580385957,"[0.06230256542723335, 0.08061318580385957, 0.06799766469212734]",0.25,1.111911834217608,1.0990697019733489,1.1181928613223135,"[1.0990697019733489, 1.1181928613223135, 1.111911834217608]" +double_inclusion,96,rational_krylov,128,352,total_error_study,2.0,0.01690232913249087,0.016426488211879493,0.016903283989153393,0.00022489279447517453,0.00022479229649541776,-8.281109148354068e-08,-0.010896976166682743,2.2962533804472048e-20,0.000477141718842877,0.022936813220086887,"[0.013039257384678062, 0.022936813220086887, 0.014675274576576329]",,,,, +double_inclusion,96,rational_krylov,128,352,total_error_study,8.0,0.07058776689175697,0.06865362294730532,0.0705853348507386,0.0004233238812214375,0.00042340896816734193,1.6406361980246626e-07,0.002744781398652746,7.850407234271262e-19,0.0020215697514913444,0.08162187084488745,"[0.06307853834039828, 0.08162187084488745, 0.068926801995373]",,1.2381413170369342,1.224315405008383,1.2427666321163997,"[1.224315405008383, 1.2381413170369342, 1.2427666321163997]" +double_inclusion,96,rational_krylov,256,608,total_error_study,2.0,0.01690375133357615,0.01642790127281807,0.016903283989153393,4.739428874794524e-05,4.737310963332624e-05,1.3555317891827254e-08,0.008464020953805102,1.6991944143064294e-20,0.000477141718842877,0.022942070501482986,"[0.013040212263282258, 0.022942070501482986, 0.014672753444310469]",,,,, +double_inclusion,96,rational_krylov,256,608,total_error_study,8.0,0.07058476654107904,0.06865081077777506,0.0705853348507386,8.218344182840735e-05,8.219996047613618e-05,-8.69851657667566e-08,-0.007495991954373552,1.487508969386759e-18,0.0020215697514913444,0.08161028412740855,"[0.06307856750214805, 0.08161028412740855, 0.06892834768160759]",,2.7348375748842955,2.709208010113798,2.8391860470874235,"[2.8391860470874235, 2.7348375748842955, 2.709208010113798]" +smooth_checker,32,full_sparse_exponential,,1024,propagation,2.0,0.10435995128922666,0.104092648977057,0.10435995128922666,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0003366295116029839,0.11261023106246383,"[0.09925418767623352, 0.0995876611165644, 0.11261023106246383]",,,,, +smooth_checker,32,full_sparse_exponential,,1024,propagation,8.0,0.31904032896439644,0.31824435155736314,0.31904032896439644,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0013149765202111567,0.3337028659735457,"[0.3099225809721224, 0.3337028659735457, 0.3223957823285693]",,,,, +smooth_checker,48,full_sparse_exponential,,2304,propagation,2.0,0.048572628584646095,0.04826720861356661,0.048572628584646095,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,4.336808689942018e-19,0.0003366295116029839,0.05117446792682494,"[0.04694968625821784, 0.047202831915210214, 0.05117446792682494]",,,,, +smooth_checker,48,full_sparse_exponential,,2304,propagation,8.0,0.1646385953266441,0.163667146938283,0.1646385953266441,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.3877787807814457e-17,0.0013149765202111567,0.1711695160894127,"[0.15713100722896575, 0.1689419358198728, 0.1711695160894127]",,,,, +smooth_checker,64,full_sparse_exponential,,4096,propagation,2.0,0.027426969571022378,0.027105896685355704,0.027426969571022378,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0842021724855044e-19,0.0003366295116029839,0.02870943394942374,"[0.026692000172819804, 0.02661588057798837, 0.02870943394942374]",,,,, +smooth_checker,64,full_sparse_exponential,,4096,propagation,8.0,0.09835565876029047,0.0972513928210566,0.09835565876029047,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,3.469446951953614e-18,0.0013149765202111567,0.1038753809345151,"[0.09304981277671413, 0.0994248488500526, 0.1038753809345151]",,,,, +smooth_checker,96,full_sparse_exponential,,9216,propagation,2.0,0.011954614525194324,0.011622191983781968,0.011954614525194324,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,2.710505431213761e-20,0.0003366295116029839,0.012484777912130193,"[0.011664592550654931, 0.011589347849493371, 0.012484777912130193]",,,,, +smooth_checker,96,full_sparse_exponential,,9216,propagation,8.0,0.0451942712615943,0.043966358944965755,0.0451942712615943,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0013149765202111567,0.04808735220579569,"[0.042606111161791055, 0.0452689557176059, 0.04808735220579569]",,,,, +smooth_checker,128,full_sparse_exponential,,16384,propagation,2.0,0.006520576109636293,0.006185353055300392,0.006520576109636293,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0003366295116029839,0.006807954960862065,"[0.006360033423545822, 0.006330430446466872, 0.006807954960862065]",,,,, +smooth_checker,128,full_sparse_exponential,,16384,propagation,8.0,0.025111019975537496,0.023835311435648026,0.025111019975537496,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,3.2526065174565133e-19,0.0013149765202111567,0.026749039537710517,"[0.023697968823523076, 0.02502957734880334, 0.026749039537710517]",,,,, +smooth_checker,192,full_sparse_exponential,,36864,propagation,2.0,0.0026500225816656607,0.0023136247239977357,0.0026500225816656607,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.6940658945086007e-21,0.0003366295116029839,0.002766977404646386,"[0.002582685670687752, 0.0025772534465991954, 0.002766977404646386]",,,,, +smooth_checker,192,full_sparse_exponential,,36864,propagation,8.0,0.010315497066429227,0.00900958563531671,0.010315497066429227,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.3552527156068805e-20,0.0013149765202111567,0.01099665056224572,"[0.00974160608942038, 0.010249031755325707, 0.01099665056224572]",,,,, +smooth_checker,256,full_sparse_exponential,,65536,propagation,2.0,0.0012995185130735042,0.0009629351170488085,0.0012995185130735042,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,2.117582368135751e-22,0.0003366295116029839,0.00135699017598773,"[0.001266100359796903, 0.0012645103059888826, 0.00135699017598773]",,,,, +smooth_checker,256,full_sparse_exponential,,65536,propagation,8.0,0.005071040521750918,0.0037582503515234183,0.005071040521750918,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,3.3881317890172014e-21,0.0013149765202111567,0.005407714722339369,"[0.00478938138327286, 0.005033349735122387, 0.005407714722339369]",,,,, +smooth_checker,384,full_sparse_exponential,,147456,propagation,2.0,0.0003366295116029839,0.0,0.0003366295116029839,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,2.6469779601696886e-23,0.0003366295116029839,0.000351548770492963,"[0.000327894152995712, 0.0003276783432041655, 0.000351548770492963]",,,,, +smooth_checker,384,full_sparse_exponential,,147456,propagation,8.0,0.0013149765202111567,0.0,0.0013149765202111567,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,4.235164736271502e-22,0.0013149765202111567,0.0014024169606416447,"[0.001242056014316043, 0.001304635776468944, 0.0014024169606416447]",,,,, +smooth_checker,32,craig_bampton,128,288,same_grid_study,2.0,0.10401531117384533,0.1037475021402385,0.10435995128922666,0.002762053272108312,0.002765229609783041,-7.946096929270648e-05,-0.13767617651137956,1.4094628242311558e-18,0.0003366295116029839,0.11237726855319045,"[0.09881968775918906, 0.09920790658804121, 0.11237726855319045]",,,,, +smooth_checker,32,craig_bampton,128,288,same_grid_study,8.0,0.31809239469361084,0.31729328829211584,0.31904032896439644,0.005472916052777814,0.00546786061341819,-0.0006338574434821666,-0.1816764267780547,3.0357660829594124e-17,0.0013149765202111567,0.33307257242622634,"[0.30917788371815785, 0.33307257242622634, 0.321048623109941]",,,,, +smooth_checker,32,craig_bampton,16,64,same_grid_study,2.0,0.18076439200761787,0.18071550739158462,0.10435995128922666,0.17694013238894557,0.17714361203010742,-0.00959509329827923,-0.25951343293430346,3.469446951953614e-18,0.0003366295116029839,0.21126587089167415,"[0.16161151929829268, 0.15900457363231552, 0.21126587089167415]",,,,, +smooth_checker,32,craig_bampton,16,64,same_grid_study,8.0,0.27929022621657745,0.27876479369066376,0.31904032896439644,0.24146161022815463,0.24123856742676436,-0.08197974745972084,-0.5325792665590603,1.3877787807814457e-17,0.0013149765202111567,0.2999707237411028,"[0.2752714369974686, 0.2999707237411028, 0.2733978438669985]",,,,, +smooth_checker,32,craig_bampton,32,96,same_grid_study,2.0,0.10592068484703973,0.10572553541845904,0.10435995128922666,0.06480078196200995,0.06487530230786147,-0.003880612804160266,-0.2865873748467755,4.336808689942018e-19,0.0003366295116029839,0.12719553926977975,"[0.08631764993172036, 0.10280607354662603, 0.12719553926977975]",,,,, +smooth_checker,32,craig_bampton,32,96,same_grid_study,8.0,0.29576952398964723,0.29493758971731465,0.31904032896439644,0.08174023106187918,0.08166472601532082,-0.020976247659805183,-0.4025480363783588,3.469446951953614e-18,0.0013149765202111567,0.3187277535988159,"[0.2867622834892446, 0.3187277535988159, 0.294613841956288]",,,,, +smooth_checker,32,craig_bampton,64,160,same_grid_study,2.0,0.10211864005583213,0.10184574007780445,0.10435995128922666,0.011816470684758336,0.011830059525132032,-0.0006027330946053281,-0.2441036340373697,1.6263032587282567e-18,0.0003366295116029839,0.1101069887246148,"[0.09709673606503343, 0.09768804539669215, 0.1101069887246148]",,,,, +smooth_checker,32,craig_bampton,64,160,same_grid_study,8.0,0.31468100653919506,0.3138757586276521,0.31904032896439644,0.021729357923736984,0.021709286091783478,-0.0032338887318042343,-0.23345541456508276,1.214306433183765e-17,0.0013149765202111567,0.3303557087421178,"[0.3061501492203603, 0.3303557087421178, 0.31683068800665437]",,,,, +smooth_checker,32,full_sparse_exponential,,1024,same_grid_study,2.0,0.10435995128922668,0.10409264897705701,0.10435995128922666,4.990800233617443e-16,4.996539611264197e-16,1.2761578039890402e-18,0.012236893562114522,2.193289147964574e-18,0.0003366295116029839,0.11261023106246386,"[0.09925418767623352, 0.09958766111656438, 0.11261023106246386]",,,,, +smooth_checker,32,full_sparse_exponential,,1024,same_grid_study,8.0,0.31904032896439644,0.31824435155736314,0.31904032896439644,4.883095895996117e-16,4.878585285025407e-16,5.417787049561359e-18,0.017404135231168752,1.9295574857375815e-17,0.0013149765202111567,0.3337028659735457,"[0.3099225809721224, 0.3337028659735457, 0.32239578232856936]",,,,, +smooth_checker,32,rational_krylov,128,288,same_grid_study,2.0,0.10436414080217425,0.10409689110000404,0.10435995128922666,0.0007239042772112371,0.0007247367609478191,3.492089136160341e-07,0.0023085600006118603,1.4567378505997864e-18,0.0003366295116029839,0.11261515242484879,"[0.09925234313779203, 0.0996041918490526, 0.11261515242484879]",,,,, +smooth_checker,32,rational_krylov,128,288,same_grid_study,8.0,0.3190359497990555,0.3182398445916682,0.31904032896439644,0.0019673914861051936,0.001965574168196655,-6.657723335529819e-06,-0.005308364398618044,7.671577403282198e-18,0.0013149765202111567,0.33371098774736824,"[0.3099215105578856, 0.33371098774736824, 0.3223811619838012]",,,,, +smooth_checker,32,rational_krylov,16,64,same_grid_study,2.0,0.14428438829287477,0.1441164135841065,0.10435995128922666,0.11089495979806355,0.11102248805477791,-0.0023990075819139978,-0.10352775617042749,3.469446951953614e-18,0.0003366295116029839,0.2125684307789545,"[0.1111302018912792, 0.2125684307789545, 0.13504887513655608]",,,,, +smooth_checker,32,rational_krylov,16,64,same_grid_study,8.0,0.3555536683407814,0.35492849928318415,0.31904032896439644,0.19310502601062016,0.19292665112973018,-0.012589013151256514,-0.10226426030266045,3.469446951953614e-18,0.0013149765202111567,0.43040250313652895,"[0.31995340224565655, 0.43040250313652895, 0.35521951194778917]",,,,, +smooth_checker,32,rational_krylov,32,96,same_grid_study,2.0,0.10438369655598242,0.10412481142674454,0.10435995128922666,0.023333666993268883,0.023360500511039425,-0.0005407563105246214,-0.11090613976599374,1.0842021724855044e-19,0.0003366295116029839,0.10807395805930263,"[0.10378935072442388, 0.09851683830765491, 0.10807395805930263]",,,,, +smooth_checker,32,rational_krylov,32,96,same_grid_study,8.0,0.32012043531437995,0.3193231281103961,0.31904032896439644,0.05496280515123525,0.05491203493554085,-0.0023249699806042324,-0.06635508831512159,1.431146867680866e-17,0.0013149765202111567,0.33468125384760283,"[0.31046300575692365, 0.33468125384760283, 0.3241517948225152]",,,,, +smooth_checker,32,rational_krylov,64,160,same_grid_study,2.0,0.10437868792388115,0.10411115623701825,0.10435995128922666,0.0042519954066586,0.004256885165063815,-1.4210011687333741e-05,-0.015993320375877133,1.472143262327974e-18,0.0003366295116029839,0.11258190777586252,"[0.09932887575773441, 0.09957817599663846, 0.11258190777586252]",,,,, +smooth_checker,32,rational_krylov,64,160,same_grid_study,8.0,0.31897512400913264,0.3181801835476903,0.31904032896439644,0.013315022130752672,0.013302722784973397,-0.00021856420256256647,-0.025749150858719663,1.8973538018496328e-18,0.0013149765202111567,0.3335401624323233,"[0.30980293364859973, 0.3335401624323233, 0.3224434094539596]",,,,, +smooth_checker,64,craig_bampton,128,320,same_grid_study,2.0,0.02615191892064664,0.02582958216501775,0.027426969571022378,0.003589915749802211,0.0035912372831997216,-8.121278184195539e-05,-0.4122612022810113,1.7618285302889447e-19,0.0003366295116029839,0.027707340224707482,"[0.025005307768932908, 0.025718205197560535, 0.027707340224707482]",,,,, +smooth_checker,64,craig_bampton,128,320,same_grid_study,8.0,0.09443277997273378,0.09331944567215684,0.09835565876029047,0.007993465146536833,0.007992813738413705,-0.0008201707482489279,-0.5216452249603761,3.903127820947816e-18,0.0013149765202111567,0.09891391956211844,"[0.08956054143311193, 0.09666545962005749, 0.09891391956211844]",,,,, +smooth_checker,64,craig_bampton,16,96,same_grid_study,2.0,0.18346081930742456,0.18346561484102036,0.027426969571022378,0.18447487003087717,0.18454277961949653,-0.001150403948588378,-0.1136437315543075,2.168404344971009e-18,0.0003366295116029839,0.2100410213108914,"[0.16311080841931389, 0.17385382467736957, 0.2100410213108914]",,,,, +smooth_checker,64,craig_bampton,16,96,same_grid_study,8.0,0.2332927744022361,0.23351690110593104,0.09835565876029047,0.2605026704410853,0.260481441405553,-0.023098898338592622,-0.4508012730908012,3.469446951953614e-18,0.0013149765202111567,0.2682467223314414,"[0.20146175872808125, 0.22940182817018784, 0.2682467223314414]",,,,, +smooth_checker,64,craig_bampton,32,128,same_grid_study,2.0,0.06472160804111528,0.06467401318822033,0.027426969571022378,0.06479038445760853,0.06481423533959732,-0.0007642372150787352,-0.21495619210778888,1.0842021724855044e-19,0.0003366295116029839,0.08109360806700054,"[0.050864775054206376, 0.058195882361208456, 0.08109360806700054]",,,,, +smooth_checker,64,craig_bampton,32,128,same_grid_study,8.0,0.08660433456635093,0.08623384808838468,0.09835565876029047,0.0989577033252949,0.09894963900642811,-0.011964555903992698,-0.614685575597031,1.734723475976807e-18,0.0013149765202111567,0.09859767381389398,"[0.07608899817308773, 0.08466878899915774, 0.09859767381389398]",,,,, +smooth_checker,64,craig_bampton,64,192,same_grid_study,2.0,0.02608899305564989,0.0258413928894796,0.027426969571022378,0.016765443346303217,0.0167716151048765,-0.0003528901744181609,-0.3835807985101816,2.168404344971009e-19,0.0003366295116029839,0.03012317304583315,"[0.022080455098715736, 0.026434644938396555, 0.03012317304583315]",,,,, +smooth_checker,64,craig_bampton,64,192,same_grid_study,8.0,0.08213810812698326,0.08101757133376698,0.09835565876029047,0.03016576293547128,0.03016330464952691,-0.0038369917508708786,-0.6466698272574625,4.7704895589362195e-18,0.0013149765202111567,0.08688070122782952,"[0.07831846285424368, 0.08688070122782952, 0.08418043136581545]",,,,, +smooth_checker,64,full_sparse_exponential,,4096,same_grid_study,2.0,0.027426969571022378,0.027105896685355704,0.027426969571022378,2.2000885042933383e-17,2.200898409215498e-17,-3.8580694479025006e-23,-3.195672196113729e-05,1.0845879794302946e-19,0.0003366295116029839,0.02870943394942374,"[0.026692000172819804, 0.02661588057798837, 0.02870943394942374]",,,,, +smooth_checker,64,full_sparse_exponential,,4096,same_grid_study,8.0,0.09835565876029047,0.0972513928210566,0.09835565876029047,1.0585839478259529e-17,1.0584976810855612e-17,-8.923800852158562e-24,-4.28578728139633e-06,3.4694380281527622e-18,0.0013149765202111567,0.1038753809345151,"[0.09304981277671413, 0.0994248488500526, 0.1038753809345151]",,,,, +smooth_checker,64,rational_krylov,128,320,same_grid_study,2.0,0.027421795463621532,0.027100498111414663,0.027426969571022378,0.0006220325816934886,0.0006222615666859896,-6.71002858467511e-07,-0.01965819197072565,1.231374147070939e-19,0.0003366295116029839,0.02870440265280466,"[0.026681119741579596, 0.02662358061699272, 0.02870440265280466]",,,,, +smooth_checker,64,rational_krylov,128,320,same_grid_study,8.0,0.09836542367031906,0.0972612760342237,0.09835565876029047,0.001814237489360891,0.0018140896424614316,-1.3699575602233723e-06,-0.0038390080473088752,3.247736078009801e-18,0.0013149765202111567,0.1039031092968858,"[0.09304514233332051, 0.09942957941047434, 0.1039031092968858]",,,,, +smooth_checker,64,rational_krylov,16,96,same_grid_study,2.0,0.03141474742507367,0.031180236855436628,0.027426969571022378,0.021117391063745716,0.021125164877813796,-0.0002116248951834319,-0.18262441107556276,1.3552527156068805e-19,0.0003366295116029839,0.03247850075200068,"[0.031397864867069816, 0.03247850075200068, 0.030855622885244925]",,,,, +smooth_checker,64,rational_krylov,16,96,same_grid_study,8.0,0.10433380674809709,0.10346623395518466,0.09835565876029047,0.058755250531927365,0.05875046241478776,-0.002239909213572823,-0.1938160684908291,1.3010426069826053e-18,0.0013149765202111567,0.11338059490349658,"[0.09283200884629997, 0.11141427642153173, 0.11338059490349658]",,,,, +smooth_checker,64,rational_krylov,32,128,same_grid_study,2.0,0.02775146506698122,0.027446164777970482,0.027426969571022378,0.0073277585499254595,0.007330456072187131,-3.5830432712173805e-05,-0.08910729027170868,5.421010862427522e-20,0.0003366295116029839,0.028789334628526193,"[0.026861818236454237, 0.02777881599975296, 0.028789334628526193]",,,,, +smooth_checker,64,rational_krylov,32,128,same_grid_study,8.0,0.09809333764426786,0.09701317221262458,0.09835565876029047,0.01814413136993947,0.01814265275780508,-0.00038068856906865885,-0.10666936280553717,3.686287386450715e-18,0.0013149765202111567,0.10408339392368551,"[0.09221347037384743, 0.09946550233606441, 0.10408339392368551]",,,,, +smooth_checker,64,rational_krylov,64,192,same_grid_study,2.0,0.027350763232332532,0.027031812536905328,0.027426969571022378,0.0036169601452487416,0.0036182916343316467,-1.7266444809748805e-05,-0.08699444792302931,4.404571325722362e-20,0.0003366295116029839,0.02871996163715657,"[0.026486159705273717, 0.026661595905935632, 0.02871996163715657]",,,,, +smooth_checker,64,rational_krylov,64,192,same_grid_study,8.0,0.09845196175004042,0.09734755175958909,0.09835565876029047,0.005734756734955979,0.005734289394815898,-1.3928912602773678e-05,-0.012348330914623888,2.5139937874507634e-18,0.0013149765202111567,0.10399342748639465,"[0.09309209882922777, 0.09959855116610491, 0.10399342748639465]",,,,, +smooth_checker,128,craig_bampton,128,384,total_error_study,2.0,0.005952473520069296,0.00572071978021889,0.006520576109636293,0.004740403966348273,0.004740805682416058,-2.9561210312861795e-05,-0.47813891578992257,1.3552527156068805e-20,0.0003366295116029839,0.006943488233654477,"[0.004959977034552855, 0.006027997171256133, 0.006943488233654477]",,,,, +smooth_checker,128,craig_bampton,128,384,total_error_study,8.0,0.018642743239759434,0.017457365642931013,0.025111019975537496,0.010771928743943783,0.010771921323124154,-0.0003990457376998238,-0.7376241963315221,3.7947076036992655e-19,0.0013149765202111567,0.01964796975775982,"[0.01778902048766894, 0.01964796975775982, 0.01912782922369165]",,1.8633985209744424,1.8596491301432252,1.8658164439257234,"[1.8658164439257234, 1.8596491301432252, 1.8633985209744424]" +smooth_checker,128,craig_bampton,256,640,total_error_study,2.0,0.005985992061982426,0.005657226149117639,0.006520576109636293,0.001347469183624227,0.0013475833722093665,-8.501792780498118e-06,-0.48376997184839005,3.3881317890172014e-21,0.0003366295116029839,0.006455098076540697,"[0.005628322710054376, 0.005866918136648113, 0.006455098076540697]",,,,, +smooth_checker,128,craig_bampton,256,640,total_error_study,8.0,0.022940293072062797,0.021662159171056655,0.025111019975537496,0.0032787312939195393,0.0032787290351900095,-0.00011505634206590848,-0.698732086151548,3.1170812458958252e-19,0.0013149765202111567,0.024157275164517773,"[0.0217454232581411, 0.023240926557723078, 0.024157275164517773]",,5.31587707309518,5.3097987327491865,5.32715238595847,"[5.32715238595847, 5.3097987327491865, 5.31587707309518]" +smooth_checker,128,full_chebyshev_bessel,,16384,total_error_study,2.0,0.006520576109628831,0.006185353055292912,0.006520576109636293,9.793950955618137e-14,9.794780924433853e-14,-9.73017377614616e-17,-0.07617455147718288,5.407219112417719e-21,0.0003366295116029839,0.00680795496085922,"[0.006360033423536482, 0.0063304304464543975, 0.00680795496085922]",,,,, +smooth_checker,128,full_chebyshev_bessel,,16384,total_error_study,8.0,0.02511101997553497,0.023835311435645466,0.025111019975537496,4.219117651686346e-13,4.2191147451213435e-13,-1.2664665846892157e-16,-0.00597692834857506,4.2183614637955016e-19,0.0013149765202111567,0.026749039537712935,"[0.023697968823516248, 0.025029577348800035, 0.026749039537712935]",,5.306273604976013,5.287043745978735,5.329088312922977,"[5.306273604976013, 5.329088312922977, 5.287043745978735]" +smooth_checker,128,full_sparse_exponential,,16384,total_error_study,2.0,0.006520576109636293,0.006185353055300392,0.006520576109636293,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0003366295116029839,0.006807954960862065,"[0.006360033423545822, 0.006330430446466872, 0.006807954960862065]",,,,, +smooth_checker,128,full_sparse_exponential,,16384,total_error_study,8.0,0.025111019975537496,0.023835311435648026,0.025111019975537496,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,3.2526065174565133e-19,0.0013149765202111567,0.026749039537710517,"[0.023697968823523076, 0.02502957734880334, 0.026749039537710517]",,93.98646749195177,93.94747731159441,94.01697712705936,"[94.01697712705936, 93.98646749195177, 93.94747731159441]" +smooth_checker,128,full_stormer_verlet,,16384,total_error_study,2.0,0.006509963845685686,0.006174737369617481,0.006520576109636293,1.0846456699267933e-05,1.0847375860581096e-05,-1.3840119498786002e-07,-0.9783611235839289,1.0587911840678754e-22,0.0003366295116029839,0.006796092326709961,"[0.006350399730856633, 0.006320050958854531, 0.006796092326709961]",0.125,,,, +smooth_checker,128,full_stormer_verlet,,16384,total_error_study,8.0,0.025070655572095236,0.02379485945421664,0.025111019975537496,4.19586933724078e-05,4.195866446691624e-05,-2.0273139267368454e-06,-0.9620662916520234,4.476569126238977e-19,0.0013149765202111567,0.026705632511616888,"[0.023660193540243932, 0.024989497329815948, 0.026705632511616888]",0.125,5.720097029465251,5.57048895850312,5.759896267671138,"[5.57048895850312, 5.759896267671138, 5.720097029465251]" +smooth_checker,128,full_stormer_verlet,,16384,total_error_study,2.0,0.006480741052214743,0.006145505355183827,0.006520576109636293,4.0716970328988865e-05,4.07204208073297e-05,-5.195663683688334e-07,-0.9783918127655203,2.8587361969832636e-21,0.0003366295116029839,0.006763426030700067,"[0.006323870403070531, 0.0062914707973690445, 0.006763426030700067]",0.25,,,, +smooth_checker,128,full_stormer_verlet,,16384,total_error_study,8.0,0.024959483000966464,0.02368344607547753,0.025111019975537496,0.00015751305548315512,0.00015751294697185673,-7.612342864772683e-06,-0.9622939044334208,3.9641141931501256e-19,0.0013149765202111567,0.02658607780645292,"[0.02355615149488515, 0.024879113482636415, 0.02658607780645292]",0.25,2.929012380889617,2.896352130221203,2.9827785530360416,"[2.9827785530360416, 2.896352130221203, 2.929012380889617]" +smooth_checker,128,rational_krylov,128,384,total_error_study,2.0,0.00652815496972936,0.006195743918002435,0.006520576109636293,0.0007809455043301101,0.0007810116839973664,-5.110847432978349e-07,-0.050178701842821624,4.235164736271502e-21,0.0003366295116029839,0.006851845812766505,"[0.006344493665766961, 0.006317740861787485, 0.006851845812766505]",,,,, +smooth_checker,128,rational_krylov,128,384,total_error_study,8.0,0.02508557271088371,0.02380733534417897,0.025111019975537496,0.0014006413106751054,0.001400640345768376,-3.2391593570037232e-06,-0.046048059476553764,3.646476837929763e-19,0.0013149765202111567,0.02672647980643915,"[0.02366415419494431, 0.02501690794898616, 0.02672647980643915]",,2.9112147020641714,2.884413578081876,2.930811501923017,"[2.9112147020641714, 2.930811501923017, 2.884413578081876]" +smooth_checker,128,rational_krylov,256,640,total_error_study,2.0,0.00652121188549941,0.0061861080997901935,0.006520576109636293,0.00018111767415820762,0.00018113302261382145,-2.4517517862036637e-08,-0.010379176610076975,1.766857788413267e-21,0.0003366295116029839,0.006809396071308102,"[0.006360963152460467, 0.006328757216957072, 0.006809396071308102]",,,,, +smooth_checker,128,rational_krylov,256,640,total_error_study,8.0,0.025107689338127015,0.02383181828245366,0.025111019975537496,0.0002548862375381993,0.00025488606194617303,-2.322272165201685e-07,-0.018141478572327716,3.5326567856424664e-19,0.0013149765202111567,0.026744063228491224,"[0.02369491847119376, 0.025029124511091627, 0.026744063228491224]",,5.9975836869562045,5.996342935948633,6.187118398142047,"[6.187118398142047, 5.9975836869562045, 5.996342935948633]" +smooth_checker,32,craig_bampton,128,288,total_error_study,2.0,0.10401531117384533,0.1037475021402385,0.10435995128922666,0.002762053272108312,0.002765229609783041,-7.946096929270648e-05,-0.13767617651137956,1.4094628242311558e-18,0.0003366295116029839,0.11237726855319045,"[0.09881968775918906, 0.09920790658804121, 0.11237726855319045]",,,,, +smooth_checker,32,craig_bampton,128,288,total_error_study,8.0,0.31809239469361084,0.31729328829211584,0.31904032896439644,0.005472916052777814,0.00546786061341819,-0.0006338574434821666,-0.1816764267780547,3.0357660829594124e-17,0.0013149765202111567,0.33307257242622634,"[0.30917788371815785, 0.33307257242622634, 0.321048623109941]",,0.16270569211337715,0.15241866500582546,0.1745542767457664,"[0.1745542767457664, 0.16270569211337715, 0.15241866500582546]" +smooth_checker,32,full_chebyshev_bessel,,1024,total_error_study,2.0,0.10435995128922403,0.10409264897705439,0.10435995128922666,1.9136463528388526e-14,1.9158470298018967e-14,-5.475552520439869e-16,-0.13693146530856937,1.1173571112926237e-18,0.0003366295116029839,0.112610231062461,"[0.099254187676231, 0.09958766111656199, 0.112610231062461]",,,,, +smooth_checker,32,full_chebyshev_bessel,,1024,total_error_study,8.0,0.3190403289643942,0.3182443515573609,0.31904032896439644,8.528220389539529e-14,8.52034270594105e-14,-1.4005116734682452e-15,-0.02576048821994155,1.5022682928829428e-17,0.0013149765202111567,0.3337028659735468,"[0.30992258097212017, 0.3337028659735468, 0.3223957823285655]",,1.1320943840546533,1.1315980908693746,1.132171166012995,"[1.132171166012995, 1.1315980908693746, 1.1320943840546533]" +smooth_checker,32,full_sparse_exponential,,1024,total_error_study,2.0,0.10435995128922666,0.104092648977057,0.10435995128922666,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0003366295116029839,0.11261023106246383,"[0.09925418767623352, 0.0995876611165644, 0.11261023106246383]",,,,, +smooth_checker,32,full_sparse_exponential,,1024,total_error_study,8.0,0.31904032896439644,0.31824435155736314,0.31904032896439644,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0013149765202111567,0.3337028659735457,"[0.3099225809721224, 0.3337028659735457, 0.3223957823285693]",,3.7705466829938814,3.761271046474576,3.7903440424706787,"[3.7705466829938814, 3.7903440424706787, 3.761271046474576]" +smooth_checker,32,rational_krylov,128,288,total_error_study,2.0,0.10436414080217425,0.10409689110000404,0.10435995128922666,0.0007239042772112371,0.0007247367609478191,3.492089136160341e-07,0.0023085600006118603,1.4567378505997864e-18,0.0003366295116029839,0.11261515242484879,"[0.09925234313779203, 0.0996041918490526, 0.11261515242484879]",,,,, +smooth_checker,32,rational_krylov,128,288,total_error_study,8.0,0.3190359497990555,0.3182398445916682,0.31904032896439644,0.0019673914861051936,0.001965574168196655,-6.657723335529819e-06,-0.005308364398618044,7.671577403282198e-18,0.0013149765202111567,0.33371098774736824,"[0.3099215105578856, 0.33371098774736824, 0.3223811619838012]",,0.11883910209871829,0.11802904307842255,0.11894054489675909,"[0.11802904307842255, 0.11894054489675909, 0.11883910209871829]" +smooth_checker,64,craig_bampton,128,320,total_error_study,2.0,0.02615191892064664,0.02582958216501775,0.027426969571022378,0.003589915749802211,0.0035912372831997216,-8.121278184195539e-05,-0.4122612022810113,1.7618285302889447e-19,0.0003366295116029839,0.027707340224707482,"[0.025005307768932908, 0.025718205197560535, 0.027707340224707482]",,,,, +smooth_checker,64,craig_bampton,128,320,total_error_study,8.0,0.09443277997273378,0.09331944567215684,0.09835565876029047,0.007993465146536833,0.007992813738413705,-0.0008201707482489279,-0.5216452249603761,3.903127820947816e-18,0.0013149765202111567,0.09891391956211844,"[0.08956054143311193, 0.09666545962005749, 0.09891391956211844]",,0.5622250299202278,0.5499861142598093,0.57655817293562,"[0.57655817293562, 0.5622250299202278, 0.5499861142598093]" +smooth_checker,64,full_chebyshev_bessel,,4096,total_error_study,2.0,0.027426969571018575,0.027105896685351894,0.027426969571022378,4.1986722136094034e-14,4.20021784474456e-14,-2.088649916681905e-16,-0.09065380072878525,6.076696976621057e-20,0.0003366295116029839,0.028709433949419754,"[0.026692000172816328, 0.026615880577984138, 0.028709433949419754]",,,,, +smooth_checker,64,full_chebyshev_bessel,,4096,total_error_study,8.0,0.09835565876028571,0.0972513928210519,0.09835565876029047,1.8370385522666383e-13,1.8368888472496637e-13,-9.298343723618454e-16,-0.02573317490233279,3.446857713676841e-18,0.0013149765202111567,0.10387538093451203,"[0.09304981277671014, 0.09942484885004264, 0.10387538093451203]",,2.335412755026482,2.3336877929978073,2.3434697249904275,"[2.3434697249904275, 2.3336877929978073, 2.335412755026482]" +smooth_checker,64,full_sparse_exponential,,4096,total_error_study,2.0,0.027426969571022378,0.027105896685355704,0.027426969571022378,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,1.0842021724855044e-19,0.0003366295116029839,0.02870943394942374,"[0.026692000172819804, 0.02661588057798837, 0.02870943394942374]",,,,, +smooth_checker,64,full_sparse_exponential,,4096,total_error_study,8.0,0.09835565876029047,0.0972513928210566,0.09835565876029047,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,3.469446951953614e-18,0.0013149765202111567,0.1038753809345151,"[0.09304981277671413, 0.0994248488500526, 0.1038753809345151]",,12.657214394188486,12.617916145827621,12.66076642787084,"[12.66076642787084, 12.617916145827621, 12.657214394188486]" +smooth_checker,64,full_stormer_verlet,,4096,total_error_study,2.0,0.027388472456811204,0.027067379285075653,0.027426969571022378,4.088058059307856e-05,4.0895629707411216e-05,-2.111908784810668e-06,-0.9414352089317178,7.199780051661553e-20,0.0003366295116029839,0.028666082913988363,"[0.026657469203291644, 0.026577939218920897, 0.028666082913988363]",0.125,,,, +smooth_checker,64,full_stormer_verlet,,4096,total_error_study,8.0,0.09822656967471333,0.09712204979068051,0.09835565876029047,0.0001542252274811324,0.0001542126592689577,-2.5400401653667425e-05,-0.8373195100719607,1.3078188705606397e-18,0.0013149765202111567,0.10374022569537601,"[0.09292692185709395, 0.09929361063932274, 0.10374022569537601]",0.125,0.7318012346513569,0.7274503712542355,0.7560660096351057,"[0.7274503712542355, 0.7560660096351057, 0.7318012346513569]" +smooth_checker,64,full_stormer_verlet,,4096,total_error_study,2.0,0.027272973132124703,0.026951819243970106,0.027426969571022378,0.00016353018075254764,0.00016359038010273498,-8.450358196653887e-06,-0.9416934214698551,1.6940658945086007e-21,0.0003366295116029839,0.028536022647639814,"[0.02655386042460374, 0.026464115135382195, 0.028536022647639814]",0.25,,,, +smooth_checker,64,full_stormer_verlet,,4096,total_error_study,8.0,0.09783911681566364,0.09673383336975258,0.09835565876029047,0.0006169314230117823,0.0006168811476764933,-0.00010172337325198076,-0.8382815507094185,2.1277467635028025e-18,0.0013149765202111567,0.10333450773120492,"[0.09255810403266308, 0.09889975734184397, 0.10333450773120492]",0.25,0.37619623343925923,0.3622753325616941,0.3821922924835235,"[0.37619623343925923, 0.3622753325616941, 0.3821922924835235]" +smooth_checker,64,rational_krylov,128,320,total_error_study,2.0,0.027421795463621532,0.027100498111414663,0.027426969571022378,0.0006220325816934886,0.0006222615666859896,-6.71002858467511e-07,-0.01965819197072565,1.231374147070939e-19,0.0003366295116029839,0.02870440265280466,"[0.026681119741579596, 0.02662358061699272, 0.02870440265280466]",,,,, +smooth_checker,64,rational_krylov,128,320,total_error_study,8.0,0.09836542367031906,0.0972612760342237,0.09835565876029047,0.001814237489360891,0.0018140896424614316,-1.3699575602233723e-06,-0.0038390080473088752,3.247736078009801e-18,0.0013149765202111567,0.1039031092968858,"[0.09304514233332051, 0.09942957941047434, 0.1039031092968858]",,0.4943764810450375,0.49256946484092623,0.49870489502791315,"[0.49256946484092623, 0.49870489502791315, 0.4943764810450375]" +smooth_checker,96,craig_bampton,128,352,total_error_study,2.0,0.01058563034478311,0.010277673531087737,0.011954614525194324,0.004406663632063847,0.004407366048965306,-5.0282114139166194e-05,-0.47716527950601967,1.3552527156068805e-20,0.0003366295116029839,0.011723075294482962,"[0.009610998030548434, 0.010471804996069497, 0.011723075294482962]",,,,, +smooth_checker,96,craig_bampton,128,352,total_error_study,8.0,0.03902036900814143,0.03778413248391995,0.0451942712615943,0.009988630563750787,0.009988499556021158,-0.0006197030807156795,-0.6863885289190673,2.168404344971009e-19,0.0013149765202111567,0.040610251720533334,"[0.0371264312448428, 0.04021217387847003, 0.040610251720533334]",,1.0179962200345472,1.0158594432286918,1.0283548481529579,"[1.0158594432286918, 1.0283548481529579, 1.0179962200345472]" +smooth_checker,96,craig_bampton,256,608,total_error_study,2.0,0.011501668322732382,0.011169638762903339,0.011954614525194324,0.001115474069213807,0.0011156518744435172,-1.186911334479098e-05,-0.4449631081483202,2.541098841762901e-20,0.0003366295116029839,0.01215791347997719,"[0.011058793722224687, 0.011229030592525854, 0.01215791347997719]",,,,, +smooth_checker,96,craig_bampton,256,608,total_error_study,8.0,0.043546790942778614,0.042314573691268745,0.0451942712615943,0.0027581053834080395,0.002758069208967304,-0.00015380609921395743,-0.616957168008579,4.607859233063394e-19,0.0013149765202111567,0.0460905484675699,"[0.04111758253345462, 0.04399089572146728, 0.0460905484675699]",,3.019786318880506,3.008544081938453,3.102683511096984,"[3.019786318880506, 3.102683511096984, 3.008544081938453]" +smooth_checker,96,full_chebyshev_bessel,,9216,total_error_study,2.0,0.011954614525193977,0.011622191983781635,0.011954614525194324,6.470101087925976e-14,6.471132414284819e-14,-8.326614873601961e-18,-0.005381738838459716,5.36319977571429e-21,0.0003366295116029839,0.012484777912130204,"[0.011664592550654973, 0.011589347849491392, 0.012484777912130204]",,,,, +smooth_checker,96,full_chebyshev_bessel,,9216,total_error_study,8.0,0.04519427126158228,0.04396635894495374,0.0451942712615943,3.2234841111600766e-13,3.223441832958655e-13,-1.0887095634200256e-15,-0.03736618988608362,6.042631135733217e-19,0.0013149765202111567,0.048087352205779026,"[0.042606111161784574, 0.04526895571759096, 0.048087352205779026]",,3.7129251359729096,3.7123964009806514,3.7203898289008066,"[3.7129251359729096, 3.7203898289008066, 3.7123964009806514]" +smooth_checker,96,full_sparse_exponential,,9216,total_error_study,2.0,0.011954614525194324,0.011622191983781968,0.011954614525194324,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,2.710505431213761e-20,0.0003366295116029839,0.012484777912130193,"[0.011664592550654931, 0.011589347849493371, 0.012484777912130193]",,,,, +smooth_checker,96,full_sparse_exponential,,9216,total_error_study,8.0,0.0451942712615943,0.043966358944965755,0.0451942712615943,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0,0.0013149765202111567,0.04808735220579569,"[0.042606111161791055, 0.0452689557176059, 0.04808735220579569]",,35.79812474222854,35.785359856905416,35.9172913597431,"[35.9172913597431, 35.79812474222854, 35.785359856905416]" +smooth_checker,96,full_stormer_verlet,,9216,total_error_study,2.0,0.011935449192114027,0.011603017608022617,0.011954614525194324,1.973530334872683e-05,1.9738449132427385e-05,-4.5825063482598904e-07,-0.9710117291700293,2.541098841762901e-21,0.0003366295116029839,0.012463322378120202,"[0.011647228400370298, 0.011570588680895362, 0.012463322378120202]",0.125,,,, +smooth_checker,96,full_stormer_verlet,,9216,total_error_study,8.0,0.045123938667660034,0.04389585543893949,0.0451942712615943,7.582980703489287e-05,7.58288124750486e-05,-6.358063992625603e-06,-0.9276352775972911,8.91078660511524e-19,0.0013149765202111567,0.04801202086392347,"[0.042540240693776134, 0.045198579213060454, 0.04801202086392347]",0.125,2.4765800818568096,2.4730923905735835,2.480798068922013,"[2.4765800818568096, 2.4730923905735835, 2.480798068922013]" +smooth_checker,96,full_stormer_verlet,,9216,total_error_study,2.0,0.011884210793662146,0.011551755230540414,0.011954614525194324,7.250085207203508e-05,7.251240862096137e-05,-1.6836003071953745e-06,-0.9710936014411248,1.9269999550035333e-20,0.0003366295116029839,0.012405961068662144,"[0.011600802687664639, 0.011520439288109332, 0.012405961068662144]",0.25,,,, +smooth_checker,96,full_stormer_verlet,,9216,total_error_study,8.0,0.044935848571036587,0.04370730851521943,0.0451942712615943,0.0002785788763675094,0.000278575222614787,-2.3369272222092696e-05,-0.9280883426412727,9.147955830346444e-20,0.0013149765202111567,0.04781055247802112,"[0.042364089831936194, 0.04501037922136201, 0.04781055247802112]",0.25,1.3141223517013714,1.3111928902799264,1.3150508869439363,"[1.3150508869439363, 1.3141223517013714, 1.3111928902799264]" +smooth_checker,96,rational_krylov,128,352,total_error_study,2.0,0.01195856260427497,0.011626388601680856,0.011954614525194324,0.00040635377881581005,0.0004064185511211286,-7.07649243188091e-08,-0.007282474132912195,2.6919765854925733e-20,0.0003366295116029839,0.012498524888269677,"[0.01166649684129314, 0.011578164749202084, 0.012498524888269677]",,,,, +smooth_checker,96,rational_krylov,128,352,total_error_study,8.0,0.045201893848281535,0.04397432508010687,0.0451942712615943,0.0013774906731578412,0.0013774726064244161,-1.20837817670643e-06,-0.009705245348399281,3.951408698941311e-19,0.0013149765202111567,0.04809822011072898,"[0.04261642305823596, 0.04526353962671027, 0.04809822011072898]",,1.3054103098111227,1.2839404370170087,1.3070184071548283,"[1.2839404370170087, 1.3054103098111227, 1.3070184071548283]" +smooth_checker,96,rational_krylov,256,608,total_error_study,2.0,0.011949352228200694,0.011616876515564672,0.011954614525194324,0.00020393137124152471,0.00020396387765768398,-1.6739103577143244e-07,-0.03432522274256706,4.200754022789296e-20,0.0003366295116029839,0.012477841404138061,"[0.011661343075336865, 0.01158279475921876, 0.012477841404138061]",,,,, +smooth_checker,96,rational_krylov,256,608,total_error_study,8.0,0.04519473149965312,0.04396705415049488,0.0451942712615943,0.00044954248270054396,0.00044953658664305596,-1.6048268356225614e-07,-0.003949569411008394,3.823824361261132e-19,0.0013149765202111567,0.048088168828783376,"[0.042606779028916394, 0.04526818155836899, 0.048088168828783376]",,2.883455774979666,2.6974941961234435,2.9032989621628076,"[2.9032989621628076, 2.883455774979666, 2.6974941961234435]" diff --git a/total_error_cost/results/verification.json b/total_error_cost/results/verification.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8af035b5b61f1ea07de8e7e73a9435f0626a9421 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/results/verification.json @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +{ + "full_modal_difference": 6.65937867454793e-14, + "energy_relative_drift": 8.881784197001252e-16, + "reduced_matches": { + "craig_bampton": { + "full_field_implementation_difference": 0.0, + "stored_receiver_representation_difference": 1.1058514235385321e-16, + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.6087414900224748e-15 + }, + "rational_krylov": { + "full_field_implementation_difference": 0.0, + "stored_receiver_representation_difference": 1.2037719106015945e-16, + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.425837644119189e-15 + } + }, + "chebyshev_modal_difference": 6.669693426240704e-14, + "chebyshev_tail_bound": 2.5926452883977684e-19, + "stormer_verlet": [ + { + "cfl": 0.25, + "time_step": 0.0125, + "modal_discrete_difference": 6.814204089942183e-14, + "same_grid_time_error": 0.0016951003299135246, + "sufficient_stability_product": 0.4563396238693052 + }, + { + "cfl": 0.125, + "time_step": 0.00625, + "modal_discrete_difference": 7.125936454130608e-14, + "same_grid_time_error": 0.0004224809977673223, + "sufficient_stability_product": 0.2281698119346526 + } + ], + "status": "pass" +} diff --git a/total_error_cost/run.py b/total_error_cost/run.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f49ce9dcdc9126b01f62c62b10c37acee3030362 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/run.py @@ -0,0 +1,283 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +"""Receiver-output cost, including independent construction of each reduced model.""" +import os +for _key in ('OPENBLAS_NUM_THREADS', 'OMP_NUM_THREADS', 'MKL_NUM_THREADS', 'NUMEXPR_NUM_THREADS'): + os.environ[_key] = '2' +import argparse +import hashlib +import importlib.util +import json +import platform +import sys +import time +from pathlib import Path +import numpy as np +import scipy +from scipy import linalg +from scipy.sparse.linalg import expm_multiply + +HERE = Path(__file__).resolve().parent +ROOT = HERE.parent +sys.path.insert(0, str(ROOT)) +STAGES = ['assembly', 'basis', 'projection_eigensolve', 'propagation', 'receiver_output'] + + +def load_module(name, path): + if name in sys.modules: + return sys.modules[name] + spec = importlib.util.spec_from_file_location(name, path) + module = importlib.util.module_from_spec(spec) + sys.modules[name] = module + spec.loader.exec_module(module) + return module + + +BASE = load_module('same_grid_cost', ROOT / 'accuracy_cost' / 'run.py') + + +def dependency_hashes(): + paths = [ROOT/'acoustic_core.py', ROOT/'accuracy_cost'/'run.py', ROOT/'accuracy_cost'/'config.json', + ROOT/'propagation'/'chebyshev_reference.py'] + return {str(path.relative_to(ROOT)): hashlib.sha256(path.read_bytes()).hexdigest() for path in paths} + + +def dump(path, value): + path.write_text(json.dumps(value, indent=2, allow_nan=False) + '\n') + + +def assemble(n, name, stiffness=True): + if name == 'impedance_interface': + interface = load_module('impedance_kernel_cost', ROOT / 'interface_case' / 'kernel.py') + return interface.assembly(n, need_stiffness=stiffness) + return BASE.assembly(n, name, need_stiffness=stiffness) + + +def full_receiver(n, name, times, chunk_duration): + stages = {key: 0.0 for key in STAGES} + start = time.perf_counter() + mass, A, J, B, R, rho, bulk = assemble(n, name, stiffness=False) + stages['assembly'] = time.perf_counter() - start + start = time.perf_counter() + state = np.zeros((J.shape[0], B.shape[1])) + state[:n*n] = B + Y = np.empty((len(times), R.shape[1], B.shape[1])) + stages['propagation'] = time.perf_counter() - start + start = time.perf_counter() + Y[0] = R.T @ B + stages['receiver_output'] = time.perf_counter() - start + steps_per_chunk = max(1, int(round(chunk_duration / (times[1] - times[0])))) + energy0 = np.sum(state * state, axis=0) + max_energy_drift = 0.0 + for index in range(0, len(times)-1, steps_per_chunk): + steps = min(steps_per_chunk, len(times)-1-index) + start = time.perf_counter() + block = expm_multiply(J, state, start=0.0, stop=steps*(times[1]-times[0]), + num=steps+1, traceA=0.0) + state = block[-1].copy() + stages['propagation'] += time.perf_counter() - start + start = time.perf_counter() + Y[index+1:index+steps+1] = np.einsum('ir,tis->trs', R, block[1:, :n*n], optimize=True) + stages['receiver_output'] += time.perf_counter() - start + # Diagnostic calculations do not contribute to output-production cost. + max_energy_drift = max(max_energy_drift, float(np.max(np.abs(np.sum(state*state, axis=0)/energy0-1)))) + return {'time': times, 'receiver_pressure': Y}, stages, {'energy_relative_drift': max_energy_drift} + + + +def chebyshev_receiver(n, name, times, tolerance): + stages = {key: 0.0 for key in STAGES} + started = time.perf_counter() + mass, A, J, B, R, rho, bulk = assemble(n, name, stiffness=True) + stages['assembly'] = time.perf_counter()-started + chebyshev = load_module('chebyshev_cost', ROOT/'propagation'/'chebyshev_reference.py') + started = time.perf_counter() + Y, diagnostics = chebyshev.receiver_action(A, B, R, times, tail_tolerance=tolerance) + stages['propagation'] = time.perf_counter()-started + return {'time': times, 'receiver_pressure': Y}, stages, diagnostics + + +def explicit_receiver(n, name, cfl, times): + stages = {key: 0.0 for key in STAGES} + start = time.perf_counter() + mass, A, J, B, R, rho, bulk = assemble(n, name, stiffness=True) + speed = float(np.sqrt(bulk / rho).max()) + output_dt = float(times[1] - times[0]) + substeps = max(1, int(np.ceil(output_dt * speed * n / cfl))) + dt = output_dt / substeps + # Gershgorin gives a sufficient central-difference stability bound. + maximum_row_sum = float(np.max(np.asarray(np.abs(A).sum(axis=1)))) + if dt * np.sqrt(maximum_row_sum) >= 2: + raise RuntimeError('Explicit time step violates the sufficient spectral stability bound') + stages['assembly'] = time.perf_counter() - start + start = time.perf_counter() + previous = B.copy() + current = B - .5 * dt * dt * (A @ B) + Y = np.empty((len(times), R.shape[1], B.shape[1])) + stages['propagation'] = time.perf_counter() - start + start = time.perf_counter() + Y[0] = R.T @ B + stages['receiver_output'] = time.perf_counter() - start + step = 1 + for output_index in range(1, len(times)): + target_step = output_index * substeps + start = time.perf_counter() + while step < target_step: + following = 2 * current - previous - dt * dt * (A @ current) + previous, current = current, following + step += 1 + stages['propagation'] += time.perf_counter() - start + start = time.perf_counter() + Y[output_index] = R.T @ current + stages['receiver_output'] += time.perf_counter() - start + return {'time': times, 'receiver_pressure': Y}, stages, { + 'requested_cfl': cfl, 'actual_cfl': dt * speed * n, + 'time_step': dt, 'substeps_per_output': substeps, 'time_steps': step, + 'sufficient_stability_product': dt * np.sqrt(maximum_row_sum)} + + +def reduced_receiver(n, name, m, method, times, return_spatial=False): + stages = {key: 0.0 for key in STAGES} + start = time.perf_counter() + mass, A, J, B, R, rho, bulk = assemble(n, name) + stages['assembly'] = time.perf_counter() - start + start = time.perf_counter() + details = {} + if method == 'craig_bampton': + Q = BASE.cb_basis(n, mass, A, m) + elif method == 'rational_krylov': + Q, details = BASE.rational_basis(mass, A, B, n+2*m) + else: + raise ValueError(method) + stages['basis'] = time.perf_counter() - start + start = time.perf_counter() + Ar = Q.T @ (A @ Q) + Ar = (Ar + Ar.T) / 2 + lam, V = linalg.eigh(Ar, check_finite=False, driver='evd') + minimum = float(lam[0]) + if minimum < -1e-9*max(lam[-1], 1.0): + raise RuntimeError('Projected stiffness is indefinite') + lam[lam < 1e-10] = 0.0 + coefficients = V.T @ (Q.T @ B) + receiver_modes = (R.T @ Q) @ V + stages['projection_eigensolve'] = time.perf_counter() - start + start = time.perf_counter() + modal = np.cos(times[:, None] * np.sqrt(lam)[None, :])[:, :, None] * coefficients[None, :, :] + stages['propagation'] = time.perf_counter() - start + start = time.perf_counter() + Y = np.einsum('ir,trs->tis', receiver_modes, modal, optimize=True) + stages['receiver_output'] = time.perf_counter() - start + # The receiver representation reconstructs all saved traces without storing an N by r basis. + raw = {'time': times, 'receiver_pressure': Y, 'reduced_eigenvalues': lam, + 'receiver_modal_matrix': receiver_modes, 'initial_modal_coefficients': coefficients} + constant = np.sqrt(mass) + constant /= np.linalg.norm(constant) + details.update({'orthonormality_frobenius': float(np.linalg.norm(Q.T @ Q - np.eye(Q.shape[1]))), + 'constant_mode_projection_error': float(np.linalg.norm(constant - Q @ (Q.T @ constant))), + 'initial_projection_relative_error': float(np.linalg.norm(B-Q@(Q.T@B))/np.linalg.norm(B)), + 'minimum_eigenvalue_before_clipping': minimum}) + if return_spatial: + raw['_orthonormal_basis'] = Q + raw['_reduced_eigenvectors'] = V + raw['_mass'] = mass + return raw, stages, details + + +def summarize(repetitions): + result = {key: float(np.median([row[key] for row in repetitions])) for key in STAGES} + totals = [sum(row.values()) for row in repetitions] + result.update(total_seconds=float(np.median(totals)), + minimum_total_seconds=float(min(totals)), maximum_total_seconds=float(max(totals))) + return result + + +def execute(cfg, materials, cpus, dry_run=False): + out = HERE / 'results' / 'smooth' + out.mkdir(exist_ok=True, parents=True) + used = None + if hasattr(os, 'sched_getaffinity'): + available = set(os.sched_getaffinity(0)) + chosen = set(cpus) & available + if not chosen: + chosen = set(sorted(available)[:cfg['threads']]) + os.sched_setaffinity(0, chosen) + used = sorted(os.sched_getaffinity(0)) + config_digest = hashlib.sha256((HERE/'config.json').read_bytes()).hexdigest() + code_digest = hashlib.sha256(Path(__file__).read_bytes()).hexdigest() + dependencies = dependency_hashes() + times = np.linspace(0, cfg['timing_time_end'], cfg['samples']) + cases = [] + for name in materials: + for n in cfg['smooth_full_grids']: + cases.append((name, n, None, 'full_sparse_exponential')) + for n in cfg['chebyshev_full_grids']: + cases.append((name, n, None, 'full_chebyshev_bessel')) + for n in cfg['explicit_full_grids']: + for cfl in cfg['explicit_cfl_values']: + cases.append((name, n, cfl, 'full_stormer_verlet')) + for n, ranks in cfg['smooth_reduced_modes'].items(): + for m in ranks: + for method in ('craig_bampton', 'rational_krylov'): + cases.append((name, int(n), m, method)) + if dry_run: + print(json.dumps({'settings': len(cases), 'repetitions': cfg['repetitions'], 'cases': cases}, indent=2)) + return + for previous in out.glob('*_timing.json'): + record = json.loads(previous.read_text()) + if record['config_sha256'] != config_digest or record['code_sha256'] != code_digest or record.get('dependency_sha256') != dependencies: + raise RuntimeError('Existing timings use a different configuration or implementation') + if record['cpu_affinity'] != used: + raise RuntimeError('Existing timings use different CPU affinity') + dump(out/'environment.json', {'platform': platform.platform(), 'python': platform.python_version(), + 'numpy': np.__version__, 'scipy': scipy.__version__, 'cpu_affinity': used, + 'cpu_information': Path('/proc/cpuinfo').read_text().split('\n\n')[0] if Path('/proc/cpuinfo').exists() else platform.processor(), + 'thread_environment': {key: os.environ.get(key) for key in ('OPENBLAS_NUM_THREADS','OMP_NUM_THREADS','MKL_NUM_THREADS')}, + 'threads': cfg['threads'], 'config_sha256': config_digest, 'code_sha256': code_digest, 'dependency_sha256': dependencies, + 'shared_basis_code_sha256': hashlib.sha256((ROOT/'accuracy_cost'/'run.py').read_bytes()).hexdigest(), + 'kernel_sha256': hashlib.sha256((ROOT/'acoustic_core.py').read_bytes()).hexdigest()}) + full_receiver(8, 'rotated_stripes', np.linspace(0, .2, 17), .1) + for method in ('craig_bampton', 'rational_krylov'): + reduced_receiver(8, 'rotated_stripes', 4, method, np.linspace(0, .2, 17)) + explicit_receiver(8, 'rotated_stripes', .25, np.linspace(0, .2, 17)) + chebyshev_receiver(8, 'rotated_stripes', np.linspace(0,.2,17), cfg['chebyshev_tail_tolerance']) + for name, n, m, method in cases: + parameter_suffix = f'_cfl{str(m).replace(".", "p")}' if method == 'full_stormer_verlet' else (f'_m{m}' if m is not None else '') + stem = f'{name}_n{n}_{method}' + parameter_suffix + target = out/f'{stem}_timing.json' + if target.exists(): + continue + interval_start = time.time() + repetitions = [] + for _ in range(cfg['repetitions']): + if method == 'full_chebyshev_bessel': + raw, stages, diagnostics = chebyshev_receiver(n, name, times, cfg['chebyshev_tail_tolerance']) + elif method == 'full_stormer_verlet': + raw, stages, diagnostics = explicit_receiver(n, name, m, times) + elif m is None: + raw, stages, diagnostics = full_receiver(n, name, times, cfg['chunk_duration']) + else: + raw, stages, diagnostics = reduced_receiver(n, name, m, method, times) + repetitions.append(stages) + interval_end = time.time() + np.savez_compressed(out/f'{stem}.npz', **raw) + record = {'material': name, 'grid': n, 'method': method, 'modes_per_patch': m if not method.startswith('full_') else None, + 'requested_cfl': m if method == 'full_stormer_verlet' else None, + 'dimension': n*n if method.startswith('full_') else n+2*m, 'repetitions': repetitions, + 'median': summarize(repetitions), 'diagnostics': diagnostics, + 'cpu_affinity': used, 'config_sha256': config_digest, 'code_sha256': code_digest, 'dependency_sha256': dependencies, + 'timed_interval_unix': [interval_start, interval_end]} + dump(target, record) + print(json.dumps({'case': stem, **record['median']}), flush=True) + + +def main(): + parser = argparse.ArgumentParser() + parser.add_argument('--materials', nargs='+') + parser.add_argument('--cpus', type=int, nargs='+') + parser.add_argument('--dry-run', action='store_true') + args = parser.parse_args() + cfg = json.loads((HERE/'config.json').read_text()) + execute(cfg, args.materials or cfg['smooth_materials'], args.cpus or cfg['cpu_affinity'], args.dry_run) + + +if __name__ == '__main__': + main() diff --git a/total_error_cost/run_interface.py b/total_error_cost/run_interface.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fc34ffa977a4672fd566f9699a34b5911e7d809c --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/run_interface.py @@ -0,0 +1,203 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +"""Cost and continuum error in the interface-aligned impedance benchmark.""" +import argparse +import hashlib +import json +import os +from pathlib import Path +import time +import run +import numpy as np + +HERE = Path(__file__).resolve().parent +KERNEL = run.load_module('impedance_kernel_cost', HERE.parent/'interface_case'/'kernel.py') + + +def field_metrics(n, times, pressure_blocks, mass): + """Compute continuum L2 errors of the piecewise-constant physical pressure.""" + sums = {end: {'difference': np.zeros(3), 'continuum_norm': np.zeros(3), + 'cell_average_norm': np.zeros(3), 'projection_loss': np.zeros(3)} for end in (2.,8.)} + minimum_projection_loss = float("inf") + for indices, physical in pressure_blocks: + tt = times[indices] + exact = KERNEL.exact_mass_weighted_pressure(n, tt) + discrete = physical * np.sqrt(mass)[None, :, None] + difference = np.sum((discrete-exact)**2, axis=1) + cell_average_norm = np.sum(exact**2, axis=1) + continuum_norm = KERNEL.exact_pressure_norm_squared(tt) + projection_loss = continuum_norm-cell_average_norm + minimum_projection_loss = min(minimum_projection_loss, float(projection_loss.min())) + if minimum_projection_loss < -1e-10: + raise RuntimeError('Cell averaging increased the exact L2 norm') + projection_loss = np.maximum(projection_loss, 0) + for end, accumulator in sums.items(): + keep = tt <= end+1e-12 + for key, values in [('difference',difference),('continuum_norm',continuum_norm), + ('cell_average_norm',cell_average_norm),('projection_loss',projection_loss)]: + accumulator[key] += values[keep].sum(axis=0) + rows = [] + for end, value in sums.items(): + numerator = value['difference']+value['projection_loss'] + rows.append({'time_end': end, + 'continuous_field_error': float(np.sqrt(numerator.sum()/value['continuum_norm'].sum())), + 'cell_average_field_error': float(np.sqrt(value['difference'].sum()/value['cell_average_norm'].sum())), + 'projection_floor': float(np.sqrt(value['projection_loss'].sum()/value['continuum_norm'].sum())), + 'continuous_field_error_per_source': np.sqrt(numerator/value['continuum_norm']).tolist()}) + return rows, minimum_projection_loss + + +def full_run(n, times, chunk, evaluate_errors, keep_model=False): + stages = {key: 0.0 for key in run.STAGES+['field_reconstruction']} + started = time.perf_counter() + model = KERNEL.separable_setup(n) + stages['assembly'] = time.perf_counter()-started + started = time.perf_counter() + y = KERNEL.separable_receiver(model, times) + stages['receiver_output'] = time.perf_counter()-started + mass = model['mass'] + def blocks(): + for index in range(0, len(times), chunk): + ids = np.arange(index, min(index+chunk, len(times))) + started = time.perf_counter() + physical = KERNEL.separable_pressure(model, times[ids])/np.sqrt(mass)[None,:,None] + stages['field_reconstruction'] += time.perf_counter()-started + yield ids, physical + if evaluate_errors: + errors, minimum_projection_loss = field_metrics(n, times, blocks(), mass) + else: + for ids, physical in blocks(): + pass + errors, minimum_projection_loss = [], 0.0 + raw = {'time': times, 'receiver_pressure': y} + if keep_model: + raw['_separable_model'] = model + return raw, stages, errors, {'minimum_projection_loss': minimum_projection_loss} + + +def reduced_run(n, m, method, times, chunk, evaluate_errors, keep_model=False): + raw, stages, diagnostics = run.reduced_receiver(n, 'impedance_interface', m, method, times, return_spatial=True) + Q = raw.pop('_orthonormal_basis') + V = raw.pop('_reduced_eigenvectors') + mass = raw.pop('_mass') + started = time.perf_counter() + spatial_modes = (Q@V)/np.sqrt(mass[:,None]) + stages['field_reconstruction'] = time.perf_counter()-started + def blocks(): + for index in range(0, len(times), chunk): + ids = np.arange(index, min(index+chunk, len(times))) + started = time.perf_counter() + modal = np.cos(times[ids,None]*np.sqrt(raw['reduced_eigenvalues'])[None,:])[:,:,None]*raw['initial_modal_coefficients'][None,:,:] + physical = np.einsum('ir,trs->tis', spatial_modes, modal, optimize=True) + stages['field_reconstruction'] += time.perf_counter()-started + yield ids, physical + if evaluate_errors: + errors, minimum_projection_loss = field_metrics(n, times, blocks(), mass) + else: + for ids, physical in blocks(): + pass + errors, minimum_projection_loss = [], 0.0 + diagnostics['minimum_projection_loss'] = minimum_projection_loss + if keep_model: + raw['_physical_spatial_modes'] = spatial_modes + raw['_mass'] = mass + return raw, stages, errors, diagnostics + + +def evaluate_fields(n, times, raw, chunk): + model = raw.pop('_separable_model', None) + spatial = raw.pop('_physical_spatial_modes', None) + mass = model['mass'] if model is not None else raw.pop('_mass') + def blocks(): + for index in range(0,len(times),chunk): + ids = np.arange(index,min(index+chunk,len(times))) + if model is not None: + pressure = KERNEL.separable_pressure(model,times[ids])/np.sqrt(mass)[None,:,None] + else: + modal = np.cos(times[ids,None]*np.sqrt(raw['reduced_eigenvalues'])[None,:])[:,:,None]*raw['initial_modal_coefficients'][None,:,:] + pressure = np.einsum('ir,trs->tis',spatial,modal,optimize=True) + yield ids,pressure + return field_metrics(n,times,blocks(),mass) + + +def summary(repetitions): + result = {key: float(np.median([row[key] for row in repetitions])) for key in run.STAGES+['field_reconstruction']} + for name, keys in [('receiver_total_seconds', run.STAGES), ('both_total_seconds', run.STAGES+['field_reconstruction'])]: + totals = [sum(row[key] for key in keys) for row in repetitions] + result[name] = float(np.median(totals)) + result[name.replace('_seconds','_minimum_seconds')] = float(min(totals)) + result[name.replace('_seconds','_maximum_seconds')] = float(max(totals)) + return result + + +def main(): + parser = argparse.ArgumentParser() + parser.add_argument('--cpus', type=int, nargs='+') + parser.add_argument('--dry-run', action='store_true') + args = parser.parse_args() + cfg = json.loads((HERE/'config.json').read_text()) + requested = args.cpus or cfg['cpu_affinity'] + if hasattr(os, 'sched_getaffinity'): + available = os.sched_getaffinity(0) + chosen = set(requested)&available or set(sorted(available)[:cfg['threads']]) + os.sched_setaffinity(0, chosen) + affinity = sorted(os.sched_getaffinity(0)) + else: + affinity = None + cases = [(n,None,'full_separable') for n in cfg['interface_full_grids']] + cases += [(n,m,method) for n in cfg['interface_reduced_grids'] for m in cfg['interface_modes_per_patch'] + for method in ('craig_bampton','rational_krylov')] + if args.dry_run: + print(json.dumps({'settings':len(cases),'cases':cases},indent=2)) + return + out = HERE/'results'/'interface' + out.mkdir(exist_ok=True, parents=True) + digest = hashlib.sha256((HERE/'config.json').read_bytes()).hexdigest() + code = {p.name: hashlib.sha256(p.read_bytes()).hexdigest() for p in [HERE/'run.py',Path(__file__),HERE.parent/'interface_case'/'kernel.py']} + dependencies = run.dependency_hashes() + dependencies['interface_case/config.json'] = hashlib.sha256((HERE.parent/'interface_case'/'config.json').read_bytes()).hexdigest() + for path in out.glob('*_timing.json'): + record = json.loads(path.read_text()) + if record['config_sha256'] != digest or record['code_sha256'] != code or record.get('dependency_sha256') != dependencies or record['cpu_affinity'] != affinity: + raise RuntimeError('Existing measurements use a different implementation or configuration') + times = np.linspace(0,cfg['timing_time_end'],cfg['samples']) + # All methods use the same prescribed initial modal coefficients. + KERNEL.analytic_data() + exact_receiver = KERNEL.exact_receiver(times) + warm_times = np.linspace(0,.2,17) + full_run(8,warm_times,8,False) + for method in ('craig_bampton','rational_krylov'): + reduced_run(8,4,method,warm_times,8,False) + for n,m,method in cases: + stem = f'impedance_interface_n{n}_{method}'+(f'_m{m}' if m is not None else '') + target = out/f'{stem}_timing.json' + if target.exists(): + continue + repetitions=[] + interval_start=time.time() + for repeat in range(cfg['repetitions']): + keep_model = repeat == cfg['repetitions']-1 + if m is None: + raw,stages,errors,diagnostics=full_run(n,times,cfg['field_chunk_samples'],False,keep_model=keep_model) + else: + raw,stages,errors,diagnostics=reduced_run(n,m,method,times,cfg['field_chunk_samples'],False,keep_model=keep_model) + repetitions.append(stages) + interval_end=time.time() + # Evaluate reference errors outside the timed repetitions. + errors, minimum_projection_loss = evaluate_fields(n,times,raw,cfg['field_chunk_samples']) + diagnostics['minimum_projection_loss'] = minimum_projection_loss + for row in errors: + keep=times<=row['time_end']+1e-12 + y,ref=raw['receiver_pressure'][keep],exact_receiver[keep] + row['receiver_error']=float(np.linalg.norm(y-ref)/np.linalg.norm(ref)) + row['receiver_error_per_source']=[float(np.linalg.norm(y[:,:,s]-ref[:,:,s])/np.linalg.norm(ref[:,:,s])) for s in range(3)] + np.savez_compressed(out/f'{stem}.npz',**raw) + record={'material':'impedance_interface','grid':n,'modes_per_patch':m,'method':method, + 'dimension':n*n if m is None else n+2*m,'repetitions':repetitions,'median':summary(repetitions), + 'errors':errors,'diagnostics':diagnostics,'config_sha256':digest,'code_sha256':code,'dependency_sha256':dependencies, + 'cpu_affinity':affinity,'timed_interval_unix':[interval_start,interval_end]} + run.dump(target,record) + print(json.dumps({'case':stem,'cost':record['median'],'errors':errors}),flush=True) + + +if __name__=='__main__': + main() diff --git a/total_error_cost/verify.py b/total_error_cost/verify.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7a6e6561391011c898e857d024e4650642c1faba --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/verify.py @@ -0,0 +1,68 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +"""Small-grid equality of the receiver-only and full-field implementations.""" +import os +for key in ('OPENBLAS_NUM_THREADS', 'OMP_NUM_THREADS', 'MKL_NUM_THREADS'): + os.environ[key] = '1' +if hasattr(os, 'sched_setaffinity'): + available = os.sched_getaffinity(0) + if 8 in available: + os.sched_setaffinity(0, {8}) +import json +from pathlib import Path +import numpy as np +from scipy.linalg import eigh +from threadpoolctl import threadpool_limits +import run + + +def relative(a, b): + return float(np.linalg.norm(a-b)/np.linalg.norm(b)) + + +def main(): + with threadpool_limits(limits=1): + times = np.linspace(0, .4, 33) + full, stages, checks = run.full_receiver(8, 'rotated_stripes', times, .1) + mass, A, J, B, R, rho, bulk = run.assemble(8, 'rotated_stripes') + lam, V = eigh(A.toarray()) + lam = np.maximum(lam, 0) + exact = np.einsum('ir,tr,rs->tis', R.T@V, + np.cos(times[:,None]*np.sqrt(lam)[None,:]), V.T@B, optimize=True) + result = {'full_modal_difference': relative(full['receiver_pressure'], exact), + 'energy_relative_drift': checks['energy_relative_drift'], 'reduced_matches': {}} + for method in ('craig_bampton','rational_krylov'): + raw, stages, diag = run.reduced_receiver(8, 'rotated_stripes', 4, method, times) + old, U, old_stages, old_diag = run.BASE.reduced_run(8, 'rotated_stripes', 4, method, times) + reconstructed = np.einsum('ir,tr,rs->tis', raw['receiver_modal_matrix'], + np.cos(times[:,None]*np.sqrt(raw['reduced_eigenvalues'])[None,:]), + raw['initial_modal_coefficients'], optimize=True) + result['reduced_matches'][method] = { + 'full_field_implementation_difference': relative(raw['receiver_pressure'], old['receiver_pressure']), + 'stored_receiver_representation_difference': relative(raw['receiver_pressure'], reconstructed), + 'orthonormality_frobenius': diag['orthonormality_frobenius']} + cheb, stages, checks = run.chebyshev_receiver(8, 'rotated_stripes', times, 1e-17) + result['chebyshev_modal_difference'] = relative(cheb['receiver_pressure'], exact) + result['chebyshev_tail_bound'] = checks['uniform_cosine_tail_bound'] + leapfrog = [] + for cfl in (.25, .125): + explicit, stages, diag = run.explicit_receiver(8, 'rotated_stripes', cfl, times) + dt = diag['time_step'] + angle = np.arccos(np.clip(1-.5*dt*dt*lam, -1, 1)) + modal_explicit = np.einsum('ir,tr,rs->tis', R.T@V, + np.cos(np.rint(times[:,None]/dt)*angle[None,:]), V.T@B, optimize=True) + leapfrog.append({'cfl': cfl, 'time_step': dt, + 'modal_discrete_difference': relative(explicit['receiver_pressure'], modal_explicit), + 'same_grid_time_error': relative(explicit['receiver_pressure'], exact), + 'sufficient_stability_product': diag['sufficient_stability_product']}) + result['stormer_verlet'] = leapfrog + result['status'] = 'pass' if result['full_modal_difference'] < 1e-10 and result['chebyshev_modal_difference'] < 1e-10 and max(v['modal_discrete_difference'] for v in leapfrog)<1e-10 and all( + v['full_field_implementation_difference']<1e-10 and v['stored_receiver_representation_difference']<1e-10 + for v in result['reduced_matches'].values()) else 'fail' + (Path(__file__).resolve().parent/'results'/'verification.json').write_text(json.dumps(result,indent=2)+'\n') + print(json.dumps(result, indent=2)) + if result['status']!='pass': + raise SystemExit(1) + + +if __name__=='__main__': + main() diff --git a/total_error_cost/verify_interface.py b/total_error_cost/verify_interface.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b05c0d9afc8587ff03345ac7dab3da13cfebcce6 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/verify_interface.py @@ -0,0 +1,44 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +"""Check the continuum pressure norm and the streamed output-cost implementation.""" +import os +for key in ('OPENBLAS_NUM_THREADS','OMP_NUM_THREADS','MKL_NUM_THREADS'): + os.environ[key]='1' +if hasattr(os,'sched_getaffinity') and 8 in os.sched_getaffinity(0): + os.sched_setaffinity(0,{8}) +import json +from pathlib import Path +import run_interface as experiment +import numpy as np +from threadpoolctl import threadpool_limits + + +def main(): + with threadpool_limits(limits=1): + n=8;times=np.linspace(0,.4,33) + raw,stages,errors,diagnostics=experiment.full_run(n,times,7,True) + model=experiment.KERNEL.separable_setup(n) + u=experiment.KERNEL.separable_pressure(model,times) + u_exact=experiment.KERNEL.exact_mass_weighted_pressure(n,times) + norm=experiment.KERNEL.exact_pressure_norm_squared(times) + residual=np.sum((u-u_exact)**2)+np.sum(norm)-np.sum(u_exact**2) + direct=float(np.sqrt(residual/np.sum(norm))) + result={'streamed_continuum_norm_difference':abs(direct-errors[0]['continuous_field_error']), + 'minimum_projection_loss':diagnostics['minimum_projection_loss'],'reduced':{}} + for method in ('craig_bampton','rational_krylov'): + reduced,timing,field_error,diagnostic=experiment.reduced_run(n,4,method,times,7,True) + reconstructed=np.einsum('ir,tr,rs->tis',reduced['receiver_modal_matrix'], + np.cos(times[:,None]*np.sqrt(reduced['reduced_eigenvalues'])[None,:]), + reduced['initial_modal_coefficients'],optimize=True) + result['reduced'][method]={'receiver_reconstruction_relative_difference':float(np.linalg.norm(reconstructed-reduced['receiver_pressure'])/np.linalg.norm(reconstructed)), + 'continuous_field_error':field_error[0]['continuous_field_error'], + 'cell_average_field_error':field_error[0]['cell_average_field_error'], + 'all_stages_nonnegative':all(value>=0 for value in timing.values())} + result['status']='pass' if result['streamed_continuum_norm_difference']<1e-12 and all( + row['receiver_reconstruction_relative_difference']<1e-12 and row['all_stages_nonnegative'] for row in result['reduced'].values()) else 'fail' + path=Path(__file__).resolve().parent/'results'/'interface_verification.json' + path.write_text(json.dumps(result,indent=2)+'\n') + print(json.dumps(result,indent=2)) + if result['status']!='pass':raise SystemExit(1) + + +if __name__=='__main__':main() diff --git a/total_error_cost/verify_outputs.py b/total_error_cost/verify_outputs.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..52c8eb59e1a8b65fe515f33a7717b5ce71278b60 --- /dev/null +++ b/total_error_cost/verify_outputs.py @@ -0,0 +1,88 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +"""Check the computed candidate set, hashes, recorded costs and receiver arrays.""" +import os +for key in ('OPENBLAS_NUM_THREADS','OMP_NUM_THREADS','MKL_NUM_THREADS'): + os.environ[key]='1' +import hashlib +import json +from pathlib import Path +import numpy as np + +HERE=Path(__file__).resolve().parent +ROOT=HERE.parent + + +def digest(path): + return hashlib.sha256(path.read_bytes()).hexdigest() + + +def main(): + cfg=json.loads((HERE/'config.json').read_text()) + config_hash=digest(HERE/'config.json') + expected_smooth=len(cfg['smooth_materials'])*(len(cfg['smooth_full_grids'])+len(cfg['chebyshev_full_grids'])+ + len(cfg['explicit_full_grids'])*len(cfg['explicit_cfl_values'])+2*sum(len(v) for v in cfg['smooth_reduced_modes'].values())) + expected_interface=len(cfg['interface_full_grids'])+2*len(cfg['interface_reduced_grids'])*len(cfg['interface_modes_per_patch']) + maximum_reconstruction=0.0 + maximum_total_difference=0.0 + counts={} + intervals=[] + for group,expected in [('smooth',expected_smooth),('interface',expected_interface)]: + paths=sorted((HERE/'results'/group).glob('*_timing.json')) + if len(paths)!=expected: + raise RuntimeError(f'{group}: expected {expected}, found {len(paths)} settings') + counts[group]=len(paths) + for path in paths: + record=json.loads(path.read_text()) + if record['config_sha256']!=config_hash: + raise RuntimeError(f'Changed configuration: {path.name}') + if group=='smooth': + if record['code_sha256']!=digest(HERE/'run.py'): + raise RuntimeError('Smooth timing implementation changed') + else: + sources={'run.py':HERE/'run.py','run_interface.py':HERE/'run_interface.py','kernel.py':ROOT/'interface_case'/'kernel.py'} + if record['code_sha256']!={name:digest(source) for name,source in sources.items()}: + raise RuntimeError('Interface timing implementation changed') + for relative,recorded in record['dependency_sha256'].items(): + if recorded!=digest(ROOT/relative): + raise RuntimeError(f'Changed dependency: {relative}') + repetitions=record['repetitions'] + if len(repetitions)!=cfg['repetitions']: + raise RuntimeError('Incomplete repetitions') + if any(value<0 or not np.isfinite(value) for rep in repetitions for value in rep.values()): + raise RuntimeError('Invalid timing') + if group=='smooth': + total=float(np.median([sum(rep.values()) for rep in repetitions])) + maximum_total_difference=max(maximum_total_difference,abs(total-record['median']['total_seconds'])) + else: + both=float(np.median([sum(rep.values()) for rep in repetitions])) + receivers=float(np.median([sum(value for key,value in rep.items() if key!='field_reconstruction') for rep in repetitions])) + maximum_total_difference=max(maximum_total_difference,abs(both-record['median']['both_total_seconds']),abs(receivers-record['median']['receiver_total_seconds'])) + if record['method']=='full_stormer_verlet' and not record['diagnostics']['sufficient_stability_product']<2: + raise RuntimeError('Explicit stability test failed') + raw_path=path.with_name(path.name.replace('_timing.json','.npz')) + with np.load(raw_path) as data: + times=data['time'];y=data['receiver_pressure'] + np.testing.assert_array_equal(times,np.linspace(0,cfg['timing_time_end'],cfg['samples'])) + if y.shape!=(cfg['samples'],4,3) or not np.isfinite(y).all(): + raise RuntimeError('Invalid receiver array') + if 'reduced_eigenvalues' in data: + reconstructed=np.einsum('ir,tr,rs->tis',data['receiver_modal_matrix'], + np.cos(times[:,None]*np.sqrt(data['reduced_eigenvalues'])[None,:]),data['initial_modal_coefficients'],optimize=True) + maximum_reconstruction=max(maximum_reconstruction,float(np.linalg.norm(reconstructed-y)/np.linalg.norm(y))) + intervals.append(record['timed_interval_unix']) + intervals.sort() + nonoverlap=all(second[0]>=first[1] for first,second in zip(intervals[:-1],intervals[1:])) + summaries=[json.loads((HERE/'results'/name).read_text()) for name in ('summary.json','interface_summary.json')] + if not all(summary['complete'] for summary in summaries): + raise RuntimeError('Final summary is incomplete') + result={'status':'pass' if maximum_total_difference<1e-12 and maximum_reconstruction<1e-12 and nonoverlap else 'fail', + 'settings':counts,'repetitions_per_setting':cfg['repetitions'],'configuration_and_all_recorded_code_hashes_match':True, + 'maximum_receiver_reconstruction_difference':maximum_reconstruction, + 'maximum_recorded_median_total_difference':maximum_total_difference, + 'timed_setting_intervals_do_not_overlap':nonoverlap} + (HERE/'results'/'output_verification.json').write_text(json.dumps(result,indent=2)+'\n') + print(json.dumps(result,indent=2)) + if result['status']!='pass':raise SystemExit(1) + + +if __name__=='__main__':main() diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/analyze.py b/unequal_speed_interface/analyze.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a71aa1b820f85a5dc8ebb04a667001168f422e50 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/analyze.py @@ -0,0 +1,78 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +"""Summarize unequal-speed interface errors and record numerical outputs.""" +import os +for key in ("OPENBLAS_NUM_THREADS", "OMP_NUM_THREADS", "MKL_NUM_THREADS", "NUMEXPR_NUM_THREADS"): + os.environ[key] = "2" +import csv +import hashlib +import json +from pathlib import Path +import sys +import numpy as np + +HERE = Path(__file__).resolve().parent +sys.path.insert(0, str(HERE.parent)) +from unequal_speed_interface.kernel import CFG +OUT = HERE/"results" + + +def write_csv(path, rows): + with path.open("w", newline="") as handle: + writer = csv.DictWriter(handle, fieldnames=list(rows[0])) + writer.writeheader() + writer.writerows(rows) + + +def refresh_summaries(): + """Recompute window-specific error cosines from saved receiver trajectories.""" + reference = np.load(OUT/"continuous_reference.npz") + times, yf = reference["time"], reference["receiver_pressure"] + rows = [] + for path in sorted(OUT.glob("n*_*.json")): + record = json.loads(path.read_text()) + if record["method"] != "full_separable": + raw = np.load(path.with_suffix(".npz"))["receiver_pressure"] + full = np.load(OUT/f"n{record['grid']}_full_receiver.npz")["receiver_pressure"] + record["receiver_reduction_grid_error_cosine"] = {} + for end in (2,8): + active = times <= end+1e-12 + local, grid = raw[active]-full[active], full[active]-yf[active] + record["receiver_reduction_grid_error_cosine"][f"T{end}"] = float(np.sum(local*grid)/max(np.linalg.norm(local)*np.linalg.norm(grid), 1e-300)) + path.write_text(json.dumps(record, indent=2, allow_nan=False)+"\n") + for end in (2,8): + window = f"T{end}" + rows.append({"grid": record["grid"], "method": record["method"], + "modes_per_patch": record.get("modes_per_patch", ""), "dimension": record["dimension"], "time_end": end, + "receiver_total_error": record["receiver_total_error"][window]["relative_error"], + "continuous_pressure_total_error": record["pressure_total_error"][window]["relative_error"], + "receiver_same_grid_error": record.get("receiver_same_grid_error", {}).get(window, {}).get("relative_error", ""), + "pressure_same_grid_error": record.get("pressure_same_grid_error", {}).get(window, {}).get("relative_error", ""), + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": record["pressure_cell_projection_floor"][window]["relative_error"], + "receiver_error_vector_cosine": record.get("receiver_reduction_grid_error_cosine", {}).get(window, "")}) + write_csv(OUT/"summary.csv", rows) + (OUT/"summary.json").write_text(json.dumps({"configuration": CFG, "rows": rows}, indent=2, allow_nan=False)+"\n") + return rows + + +def main(): + rows = refresh_summaries() + manifest = { + "run_scope": "Three grids, nine CB models, two n=32 RK controls; modal attribution at n=32.", + "reference_scope": CFG["initial_condition"], + "verification_passed": json.loads((OUT/"verification.json").read_text())["passed"], + "modal_validation_passed": json.loads((OUT/"modal_validation.json").read_text())["passed"], + "source_hashes": {str(p.relative_to(HERE)): hashlib.sha256(p.read_bytes()).hexdigest() + for p in list(HERE.glob("*.py")) + [HERE/"config.json"]}, + } + paths = list(OUT.glob("n*.npz")) + list(OUT.glob("n*.json")) + list(OUT.glob("*.csv")) + [ + OUT/"continuous_reference.npz", OUT/"continuous_catalogue.npz", OUT/"modal_summary.json", + OUT/"modal_validation.json", OUT/"summary.json", OUT/"verification.json"] + paths += list(OUT.glob("*_decomposition.npz")) + manifest["artifact_hashes"] = {str(p.relative_to(HERE)): hashlib.sha256(p.read_bytes()).hexdigest() + for p in paths} + (OUT/"output_manifest.json").write_text(json.dumps(manifest, indent=2) + "\n") + print(json.dumps({"summary_rows": len(rows), "numeric_outputs": len(paths)}, indent=2)) + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + main() diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/config.json b/unequal_speed_interface/config.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c7a03faac10e08455df3d58e7f7b1334bb69e0b9 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/config.json @@ -0,0 +1,74 @@ +{ + "material": "aligned_unequal_speed_interface", + "interface_x": 0.5, + "density": [ + 1.0, + 5.333333333333333 + ], + "bulk_modulus": [ + 1.0, + 12.0 + ], + "grids": [ + 32, + 64, + 128 + ], + "modes_per_patch": [ + 32, + 64, + 128 + ], + "rational_krylov_modes_per_patch": [ + 32, + 128 + ], + "source_centres": [ + [ + 0.19, + 0.76 + ], + [ + 0.54, + 0.47 + ], + [ + 0.81, + 0.22 + ] + ], + "receiver_centres": [ + [ + 0.22, + 0.21 + ], + [ + 0.79, + 0.77 + ], + [ + 0.28, + 0.69 + ], + [ + 0.68, + 0.33 + ] + ], + "sigma": 0.07, + "max_x_mode": 20, + "max_y_mode": 16, + "initial_energy": 1.0, + "quadrature_order": 192, + "root_scan_step": 0.02, + "time_end": 8.0, + "samples": 641, + "threads": 2, + "modal_grid": 32, + "mac_threshold": 0.9, + "relative_frequency_gap": 0.005, + "error_sampling": "641 equally weighted times including t=0 and all three sources.", + "initial_condition": "For each transverse index 0<=l<=16, retain the first 21 continuous Sturm-Liouville modes m=0,...,20. Project the Gaussian pressure in the beta inner product, remove only the global constant mode, and normalize to unit initial acoustic energy. The resulting finite expansion defines the initial pressure independently of the propagation grid; initial velocity is zero.", + "field_reference": "Continuous beta-weighted L2 error of piecewise-constant pressure reconstruction, including the exact subcell projection term.", + "timing_scope": "This study measures mechanism and accuracy; comparative costs are computed separately by the timing experiments." +} diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/io.py b/unequal_speed_interface/io.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3c332578633480db68f51f839dbeef2e9cd361d1 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/io.py @@ -0,0 +1,32 @@ +"""Complete in-memory encoding followed by atomic artifact replacement.""" +from io import BytesIO +import os +from pathlib import Path +import zipfile +import numpy as np + + +def atomic_write(path, payload): + path = Path(path) + temporary = path.with_name(path.name+f".{os.getpid()}.partial") + try: + with temporary.open("wb") as stream: + stream.write(payload) + stream.flush() + os.fsync(stream.fileno()) + if temporary.stat().st_size != len(payload): + raise IOError("Incomplete temporary artifact write") + temporary.replace(path) + finally: + if temporary.exists(): + temporary.unlink() + + +def save_arrays(path, **arrays): + buffer = BytesIO() + np.savez_compressed(buffer, **arrays) + payload = buffer.getvalue() + with zipfile.ZipFile(BytesIO(payload)) as archive: + if set(archive.namelist()) != {key+".npy" for key in arrays}: + raise IOError("Incomplete NPZ encoding") + atomic_write(path, payload) diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/kernel.py b/unequal_speed_interface/kernel.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..023b5967f3c542d701119d6d57af567c94c21114 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/kernel.py @@ -0,0 +1,321 @@ +"""Exact piecewise acoustic modes for a planar unequal-speed interface. + +The finite continuous modal initial field is fixed before grid projection. +Continuous roots, full discrete modes, and reduced modes are constructed +independently. The separated solvers evaluate modal responses without time stepping. +""" +from functools import lru_cache +from pathlib import Path +import json +import numpy as np +from numpy.polynomial.legendre import leggauss +from scipy import linalg, sparse, special +from scipy.optimize import brentq + +HERE = Path(__file__).resolve().parent +CFG = json.loads((HERE / "config.json").read_text()) + + +def gauss_interval(order, a, b): + x, w = leggauss(order) + return (a+b)/2 + (b-a)*x/2, (b-a)*w/2 + + +def cosine_q(q2, d): + q2, d = np.broadcast_arrays(np.asarray(q2, dtype=float), np.asarray(d, dtype=float)) + ans = np.empty(q2.shape) + positive = q2 >= 0 + ans[positive] = np.cos(np.sqrt(q2[positive]) * d[positive]) + ans[~positive] = np.cosh(np.sqrt(-q2[~positive]) * d[~positive]) + return ans + + +def q_sine(q2, d): + q2, d = np.broadcast_arrays(np.asarray(q2, dtype=float), np.asarray(d, dtype=float)) + ans = np.empty(q2.shape) + positive = q2 >= 0 + qq = np.sqrt(q2[positive]) + ans[positive] = qq * np.sin(qq * d[positive]) + qq = np.sqrt(-q2[~positive]) + ans[~positive] = -qq * np.sinh(qq * d[~positive]) + return ans + + +def mean_cosine(q2, centre, width): + q2, centre = np.broadcast_arrays(np.asarray(q2, dtype=float), np.asarray(centre, dtype=float)) + answer = cosine_q(q2, centre) + positive = q2 >= 0 + answer[positive] *= np.sinc(np.sqrt(q2[positive]) * width / (2*np.pi)) + z = np.sqrt(-q2[~positive]) * width/2 + answer[~positive] *= np.sinh(z)/z + return answer + + +def integral_cosine_squared(q2, length): + if q2 >= 0: + return length/2 * (1 + np.sinc(2*np.sqrt(q2)*length/np.pi)) + z = 2*np.sqrt(-q2)*length + return length/2 * (1 + np.sinh(z)/z) + + +def material_parameters(density=None, bulk=None): + rho = np.asarray(CFG["density"] if density is None else density, dtype=float) + kk = np.asarray(CFG["bulk_modulus"] if bulk is None else bulk, dtype=float) + return rho, kk, kk/rho + + +def characteristic(omega, ell, density=None, bulk=None, interface=None): + rho, kk, c2 = material_parameters(density, bulk) + a = CFG["interface_x"] if interface is None else interface + omega = np.asarray(omega) + qq = omega[..., None]**2/c2 - (ell*np.pi)**2 + cc = cosine_q(qq, [a, 1-a]) + ss = q_sine(qq, [a, 1-a])/rho + return cc[..., 0]*ss[..., 1] + cc[..., 1]*ss[..., 0] + + +@lru_cache(maxsize=256) +def roots(ell, count, density=None, bulk=None, scan_step=None): + rho, kk, c2 = material_parameters(density, bulk) + step = CFG["root_scan_step"] if scan_step is None else scan_step + lower = np.sqrt(c2.min()) * ell*np.pi + upper = np.sqrt(c2.max()) * np.pi*np.sqrt((count+2)**2 + ell**2) + exact_lowest = ell == 0 or np.isclose(c2[0], c2[1], rtol=1e-14, atol=0.) + first = lower+1e-8 if exact_lowest else lower + grid = np.linspace(first, upper, int(np.ceil((upper-lower)/step))+1) + value = characteristic(grid, ell, tuple(rho), tuple(kk)) + indices = np.flatnonzero(np.signbit(value[:-1]) != np.signbit(value[1:])) + found = [float(lower)] if exact_lowest else [] + for j in indices: + root = brentq(characteristic, grid[j], grid[j+1], + args=(ell, tuple(rho), tuple(kk)), xtol=5e-13, rtol=2e-14) + if not found or root-found[-1] > 1e-7: + found.append(root) + if len(found) == count: + break + if len(found) != count: + raise RuntimeError(f"Root count failed for ell={ell}: {len(found)} instead of {count}") + return np.asarray(found) + + +def mode_parameters(omega, ell, density=None, bulk=None): + rho, kk, c2 = material_parameters(density, bulk) + a = CFG["interface_x"] + q2 = omega**2/c2 - (ell*np.pi)**2 + cc = cosine_q(q2, [a, 1-a]) + ss = q_sine(q2, [a, 1-a])/rho + matrix = np.array([[cc[0], -cc[1]], [ss[0], ss[1]]]) + # Scale the flux equation by a physical wavenumber, rather than normalizing + # each row to unit norm: both sine values vanish at some exact roots, and + # amplifying that roundoff-sized row would corrupt the pressure condition. + flux_scale = max(1., np.sqrt(omega**2/c2.min()+(ell*np.pi)**2)/rho.min()) + scaled = matrix.copy() + scaled[1] /= flux_scale + _, _, vh = linalg.svd(scaled, check_finite=False) + amplitude = vh[-1] + if amplitude[0] < 0: + amplitude = -amplitude + norm2 = sum(amplitude[i]**2/kk[i] * integral_cosine_squared(q2[i], d) + for i, d in enumerate((a, 1-a))) + amplitude /= np.sqrt(norm2) + return q2, amplitude + + +def x_values(x, q2, amplitude, average_width=None): + x = np.asarray(x) + left = x < CFG["interface_x"] + ans = np.empty((len(x), len(q2))) + for side, active, distance in ((0, left, x[left]), (1, ~left, 1-x[~left])): + if average_width is None: + vals = cosine_q(q2[None, :, side], distance[:, None]) + else: + vals = mean_cosine(q2[None, :, side], distance[:, None], average_width) + ans[active] = vals * amplitude[None, :, side] + return ans + + +def y_values(y, maximum): + ll = np.arange(maximum+1) + return np.cos(np.pi*np.asarray(y)[:, None]*ll) * np.where(ll == 0, 1., np.sqrt(2.)) + + +def gaussian_integrals(edges, centre): + z = (np.asarray(edges)-centre)/(np.sqrt(2.)*CFG["sigma"]) + return np.sqrt(np.pi/2)*CFG["sigma"]*np.diff(special.erf(z)) + + +@lru_cache(maxsize=8) +def continuous_data(order=None, scan_step=None): + order = CFG["quadrature_order"] if order is None else order + rho, kk, c2 = material_parameters() + nx = CFG["max_x_mode"]+1 + nl = CFG["max_y_mode"]+1 + omega = np.stack([roots(l, nx, scan_step=scan_step) for l in range(nl)]) + q2 = np.empty((nl, nx, 2)) + amplitudes = np.empty_like(q2) + for l in range(nl): + for m in range(nx): + q2[l, m], amplitudes[l, m] = mode_parameters(omega[l, m], l) + a = CFG["interface_x"] + xl, wl = gauss_interval(order, 0., a) + xr, wr = gauss_interval(order, a, 1.) + x, wx = np.r_[xl, xr], np.r_[wl, wr] + beta = np.r_[np.full(order, 1/kk[0]), np.full(order, 1/kk[1])] + y, wy = gauss_interval(order, 0., 1.) + xx = np.stack([x_values(x, q2[l], amplitudes[l]) for l in range(nl)]) + yy = y_values(y, nl-1) + coefficients = np.empty((nl, nx, 3)) + receiver_modes = np.empty((nl, nx, 4)) + gram = np.stack([xx[l].T @ ((wx*beta)[:, None]*xx[l]) for l in range(nl)]) + for s, (cx, cy) in enumerate(CFG["source_centres"]): + gx = np.exp(-.5*((x-cx)/CFG["sigma"])**2) + gy = np.exp(-.5*((y-cy)/CFG["sigma"])**2) + sx = np.einsum("lim,i->lm", xx, wx*beta*gx) + sy = yy.T @ (wy*gy) + coeff = sx*sy[:, None] + coeff[0, 0] = 0. + coefficients[:, :, s] = coeff*np.sqrt(2*CFG["initial_energy"])/np.linalg.norm(coeff) + for r, (cx, cy) in enumerate(CFG["receiver_centres"]): + gx = np.exp(-.5*((x-cx)/CFG["sigma"])**2) + gy = np.exp(-.5*((y-cy)/CFG["sigma"])**2) + rx = np.einsum("lim,i->lm", xx, wx*gx)/gaussian_integrals([0., 1.], cx)[0] + ry = (yy.T @ (wy*gy))/gaussian_integrals([0., 1.], cy)[0] + receiver_modes[:, :, r] = rx*ry[:, None] + return {"omega": omega, "q_squared": q2, "amplitudes": amplitudes, + "coefficients": coefficients, "receiver_modes": receiver_modes, + "x_gram": gram, "y_gram": yy.T @ (wy[:, None]*yy)} + + +def exact_receiver(times, order=None, scan_step=None): + data = continuous_data(order, scan_step) + phase = np.cos(np.asarray(times)[:, None, None]*data["omega"][None]) + return np.einsum("tlm,lms,lmr->trs", phase, data["coefficients"], + data["receiver_modes"], optimize=True) + + +def exact_pressure_norm_squared(times): + data = continuous_data() + phase = np.cos(np.asarray(times)[:, None, None]*data["omega"][None]) + return np.einsum("tlm,lms->ts", phase**2, data["coefficients"]**2, optimize=True) + + +@lru_cache(maxsize=8) +def averaged_modes(n): + if n % 2: + raise ValueError("The interface requires an even grid") + data = continuous_data() + x = (np.arange(n)+.5)/n + xx = np.stack([x_values(x, data["q_squared"][l], data["amplitudes"][l], 1/n) + for l in range(CFG["max_y_mode"]+1)]) + ll = np.arange(CFG["max_y_mode"]+1) + yy = y_values(x, CFG["max_y_mode"])*np.sinc(ll/(2*n))[None, :] + return xx, yy + + +def mass_vector(n): + x = (np.arange(n)+.5)/n + bulk = np.where(x < CFG["interface_x"], *CFG["bulk_modulus"]) + return np.repeat(1/bulk, n)/n**2 + + +def synthesize(x_modes, y_modes, omega, coefficients, times): + """Return physical or normalized pressure for factorized modal vectors. + + x_modes has shape (l,i,m), y_modes (j,l), omega (l,m). + """ + times = np.asarray(times) + modal = np.cos(times[:, None, None]*omega[None])[:, :, :, None]*coefficients[None] + nt, nl, nm, ns = modal.shape + temporary = x_modes @ modal.transpose(1, 2, 0, 3).reshape(nl, nm, nt*ns) + temporary = temporary.reshape(nl, len(x_modes[0]), nt, ns).transpose(2, 1, 0, 3) + return np.einsum("tils,jl->tijs", temporary, y_modes, optimize=True).reshape(nt, -1, ns) + + +def exact_mass_weighted_pressure(n, times): + data = continuous_data() + xx, yy = averaged_modes(n) + return synthesize(xx, yy, data["omega"], data["coefficients"], times)*np.sqrt(mass_vector(n))[None, :, None] + + +def source_receiver(n, mass): + B = exact_mass_weighted_pressure(n, [0.])[0] + edges = np.linspace(0., 1., n+1) + windows = [] + for cx, cy in CFG["receiver_centres"]: + gx, gy = gaussian_integrals(edges, cx), gaussian_integrals(edges, cy) + windows.append(np.outer(gx/gx.sum(), gy/gy.sum()).ravel()/np.sqrt(mass)) + return B, np.stack(windows, axis=-1) + + +def assembly(n): + if n % 2: + raise ValueError("The interface requires an even grid") + x = (np.arange(n)+.5)/n + X, Y = np.meshgrid(x, x, indexing="ij") + rho = np.where(X < CFG["interface_x"], *CFG["density"]) + bulk = np.where(X < CFG["interface_x"], *CFG["bulk_modulus"]) + idx = np.arange(n*n).reshape(n, n) + a = np.r_[idx[:-1].ravel(), idx[:, :-1].ravel()] + b = np.r_[idx[1:].ravel(), idx[:, 1:].ravel()] + faces = np.arange(len(a)) + face_rho = .5*(rho.ravel()[a]+rho.ravel()[b]) + D = sparse.coo_matrix((np.r_[np.ones(len(a)), -np.ones(len(a))], + (np.r_[a, b], np.r_[faces, faces])), shape=(n*n, len(a))).tocsr() + mass = (1/(n*n*bulk)).ravel() + C = sparse.diags(1/np.sqrt(mass)) @ D @ sparse.diags(1/np.sqrt(face_rho)) + J = sparse.bmat([[None, -C], [C.T, None]], format="csr") + B, R = source_receiver(n, mass) + return mass, (C@C.T).tocsr(), J, B, R, rho, bulk + + +def x_tridiagonal(n, density=None, bulk=None): + rho, kk, c2 = material_parameters(density, bulk) + x = (np.arange(n)+.5)/n + rr = np.where(x < CFG["interface_x"], *rho) + bb = np.where(x < CFG["interface_x"], *kk) + inv = 2/(rr[:-1]+rr[1:]) + diagonal = n*n*bb*np.r_[inv[0], inv[:-1]+inv[1:], inv[-1]] + off = -n*n*np.sqrt(bb[:-1]*bb[1:])*inv + return diagonal, off, bb/rr + + +def separable_setup(n): + dx, ex, speed2 = x_tridiagonal(n) + dy = np.r_[1., np.full(n-2, 2.), 1.]*n*n + ly, Vy = linalg.eigh_tridiagonal(dy, np.full(n-1, -n*n, dtype=float)) + ly[np.abs(ly) < 1e-8] = 0. + lam = np.empty((n, n)) + Vx = np.empty((n, n, n)) + for ell in range(n): + lam[ell], Vx[ell] = linalg.eigh_tridiagonal(dx+speed2*ly[ell], ex) + lam[np.abs(lam) < 1e-8] = 0. + if np.min(lam) < 0: + raise RuntimeError("Indefinite separated stiffness") + mass = mass_vector(n) + B, R = source_receiver(n, mass) + By = np.einsum("ijs,jl->lis", B.reshape(n, n, 3), Vy, optimize=True) + Ry = np.einsum("ijr,jl->lir", R.reshape(n, n, 4), Vy, optimize=True) + coeff = np.matmul(Vx.transpose(0, 2, 1), By) + observation = np.matmul(Vx.transpose(0, 2, 1), Ry) + return {"omega": np.sqrt(lam), "x_eigenvectors": Vx, "y_eigenvectors": Vy, + "initial_modal_coefficients": coeff, "receiver_modes": observation, "mass": mass} + + +def separable_receiver(model, times): + phase = np.cos(np.asarray(times)[:, None, None]*model["omega"][None]) + return np.einsum("tlm,lms,lmr->trs", phase, model["initial_modal_coefficients"], + model["receiver_modes"], optimize=True) + + +def separable_pressure(model, times): + return synthesize(model["x_eigenvectors"], model["y_eigenvectors"], + model["omega"], model["initial_modal_coefficients"], times) + + +def full_eigenvectors(model): + n = len(model["mass"])**.5 + n = int(n) + vectors = np.einsum("lim,jl->ijlm", model["x_eigenvectors"], model["y_eigenvectors"], + optimize=True).reshape(n*n, n*n) + order = np.argsort(model["omega"].ravel()) + return model["omega"].ravel()[order], vectors[:, order], order diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/modal.py b/unequal_speed_interface/modal.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..72efe57e0bd4438755fddf360d47ecd132bc8b15 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/modal.py @@ -0,0 +1,245 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +"""Pair reduced/FV/continuous modes and retain exact unmatched responses.""" +import os +for key in ("OPENBLAS_NUM_THREADS", "OMP_NUM_THREADS", "MKL_NUM_THREADS", "NUMEXPR_NUM_THREADS"): + os.environ[key] = "2" +import csv +import json +from pathlib import Path +import sys +import numpy as np +from scipy import linalg +from scipy.optimize import linear_sum_assignment + +HERE = Path(__file__).resolve().parent +sys.path.insert(0, str(HERE.parent)) +from unequal_speed_interface.kernel import (CFG, continuous_data, roots, + mode_parameters, x_values, y_values, gauss_interval, gaussian_integrals, x_tridiagonal) +from unequal_speed_interface.io import save_arrays +OUT = HERE/"results" + + +def dump(path, data): + path.write_text(json.dumps(data, indent=2, allow_nan=False)+"\n") + + +def csv_write(path, rows): + with path.open("w", newline="") as handle: + writer = csv.DictWriter(handle, fieldnames=list(rows[0])) + writer.writeheader() + writer.writerows(rows) + + +def residue(b, c): + return np.einsum("rj,js->jrs", c, b) + + +def response(times, omega, weight): + return np.einsum("tj,jrs->trs", np.cos(times[:, None]*omega[None]), weight, optimize=True) + + +def gap(omega): + return np.minimum(np.r_[np.inf, np.diff(omega)], np.r_[np.diff(omega), np.inf])/np.maximum(omega, 1e-100) + + +def match(left, right, omega_left, omega_right, gap_right=None): + overlap = left.T@right + il, ir = linear_sum_assignment(-overlap**2) + mac = overlap[il, ir]**2 + right_gap = gap(omega_right) if gap_right is None else gap_right + accepted = ((mac >= CFG["mac_threshold"]) & + (gap(omega_left)[il] >= CFG["relative_frequency_gap"]) & + (right_gap[ir] >= CFG["relative_frequency_gap"]) & + (omega_left[il] > 1e-7) & (omega_right[ir] > 1e-7)) + return il, ir, mac, np.sign(overlap[il, ir]), accepted + + +def continuum_catalogue(n, mass): + data = continuous_data() + active_max = float(data["omega"].max()) + halo_max = active_max+np.pi*np.sqrt(max(np.asarray(CFG["bulk_modulus"])/np.asarray(CFG["density"]))) + limit = int(np.floor(halo_max/np.pi))+2 + catalogue = [] + for ell in range(limit): + for m, omega in enumerate(roots(ell, limit+1)): + if omega <= halo_max: + qq, aa = mode_parameters(omega, ell) + catalogue.append((omega, m, ell, qq, aa)) + catalogue.sort(key=lambda row: row[0]) + omega = np.asarray([r[0] for r in catalogue]) + mm = np.asarray([r[1] for r in catalogue], dtype=int) + ll = np.asarray([r[2] for r in catalogue], dtype=int) + q2 = np.stack([r[3] for r in catalogue]) + amp = np.stack([r[4] for r in catalogue]) + xx = (np.arange(n)+.5)/n + xavg = x_values(xx, q2, amp, 1/n) + yavg = y_values(xx, ll.max())[:, ll]*np.sinc(ll/(2*n))[None] + vectors = np.einsum("ik,jk->ijk", xavg, yavg, optimize=True).reshape(n*n, len(omega))*np.sqrt(mass)[:, None] + norms = np.linalg.norm(vectors, axis=0) + vectors /= np.maximum(norms, 1e-300)[None] + b = np.zeros((len(omega), 3)) + for j, (m, ell) in enumerate(zip(mm, ll)): + if m <= CFG["max_x_mode"] and ell <= CFG["max_y_mode"]: + b[j] = data["coefficients"][ell, m] + order = CFG["quadrature_order"] + xl, wl = gauss_interval(order, 0., .5) + xr, wr = gauss_interval(order, .5, 1.) + x, wx = np.r_[xl, xr], np.r_[wl, wr] + y, wy = gauss_interval(order, 0., 1.) + X = x_values(x, q2, amp) + Y = y_values(y, ll.max())[:, ll] + c = np.empty((4, len(omega))) + for r, (cx, cy) in enumerate(CFG["receiver_centres"]): + gx = np.exp(-.5*((x-cx)/CFG["sigma"])**2) + gy = np.exp(-.5*((y-cy)/CFG["sigma"])**2) + c[r] = (X.T@(wx*gx))*(Y.T@(wy*gy))/(gaussian_integrals([0., 1.], cx)[0]*gaussian_integrals([0., 1.], cy)[0]) + return {"omega": omega, "m": mm, "ell": ll, "V": vectors, "b": b, "c": c, + "norms": norms, "active_max": active_max, "halo_max": halo_max, + "q_squared": q2, "amplitudes": amp} + + +def norm(x): + return float(np.linalg.norm(x)) + + +def cosine(a, b): + return float(np.sum(a*b)/max(norm(a)*norm(b), 1e-300)) + + +def main(): + n = CFG["modal_grid"] + coarse = np.load(OUT/f"n{n}_full_spectrum.npz") + t = np.load(OUT/"continuous_reference.npz")["time"] + yf = np.load(OUT/"continuous_reference.npz")["receiver_pressure"] + yc = np.load(OUT/f"n{n}_full_receiver.npz")["receiver_pressure"] + print("Constructing complete continuous frequency catalogue and halo", flush=True) + fine = continuum_catalogue(n, coarse["mass"]) + # Check every catalogue index against an independently converging 1-D FV + # spectrum, including modes outside the finite initial-pressure expansion. + catalogue_root_checks = [] + for nc in (1024, 2048): + dx, ex, speed2 = x_tridiagonal(nc) + for ell in np.unique(fine["ell"]): + selected = np.flatnonzero(fine["ell"] == ell) + selected = selected[np.argsort(fine["m"][selected])] + mm = fine["m"][selected] + if not np.array_equal(mm, np.arange(len(mm))): + raise RuntimeError("Continuous catalogue omits an internal longitudinal index") + lv = linalg.eigh_tridiagonal(dx+speed2*(ell*np.pi)**2, ex, + eigvals_only=True, select="i", select_range=(0, len(mm)-1)) + if ell == 0: + lv[0] = 0. + ow = fine["omega"][selected] + dif = np.abs(np.sqrt(np.maximum(lv, 0.))-ow) + gaps = np.minimum(np.r_[np.inf,np.diff(ow)],np.r_[np.diff(ow),np.inf]) + catalogue_root_checks.append({"transverse_index":int(ell),"cells":nc,"roots":len(mm), + "frequency_relative_max_error":float(np.max(dif/np.maximum(ow,1.))), + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max":float(np.max(dif/gaps))}) + candidate = np.flatnonzero(fine["norms"] > 1e-8) + il, ir, mac, sign, accept = match(coarse["eigenvectors"], fine["V"][:, candidate], + coarse["omega"], fine["omega"][candidate], gap_right=gap(fine["omega"])[candidate]) + ir = candidate[ir] + accept &= fine["omega"][ir] <= fine["active_max"]+1e-9 + cf = {int(i): (int(j), float(ma), float(si)) for i, j, ma, si, ok in zip(il, ir, mac, sign, accept) if ok} + yf_catalogue = response(t, fine["omega"], residue(fine["b"], fine["c"])) + save_arrays(OUT/"continuous_catalogue.npz", **{k:v for k,v in fine.items() if k != "V"}) + validation = {"catalogue_modes_including_halo": len(fine["omega"]), + "initial_max_angular_frequency": fine["active_max"], "catalogue_max_angular_frequency": fine["halo_max"], + "catalogue_receiver_reconstruction_relative_error": norm(yf_catalogue-yf)/norm(yf), + "accepted_coarse_continuous_pairs": len(cf), + "catalogue_independent_root_checks": catalogue_root_checks, + "gap_definition": "min(omega[j]-omega[j-1],omega[j+1]-omega[j])/omega[j], evaluated on the complete frequency catalogue including its upper halo.", + "matching": "Maximum-sum squared modal overlap; continuous physical modes are averaged to the coarse cells, multiplied by sqrt(M), and normalized only for matching."} + pair_rows, summary, windows, gram_rows = [], [], [], [] + for path in sorted(OUT.glob(f"n{n}_*m*.npz")): + raw = np.load(path) + name = path.stem.split("_", 1)[1] + if "eigenvectors" not in raw or "receiver_pressure" not in raw: + continue + wr = raw["omega"] + Vr = raw["eigenvectors"] + br = Vr.T@coarse["B"] + cr = coarse["R"].T@Vr + yr = raw["receiver_pressure"] + ri0, ci0, mac_rc, signs_rc, accepted_rc = match(Vr, coarse["eigenvectors"], wr, coarse["omega"]) + chain = [(int(i), int(j), cf[int(j)][0], float(ma), cf[int(j)][1], float(si), cf[int(j)][2]) + for i,j,ma,si,ok in zip(ri0, ci0, mac_rc, signs_rc, accepted_rc) if ok and int(j) in cf] + ri = np.asarray([r[0] for r in chain], dtype=int) + ci = np.asarray([r[1] for r in chain], dtype=int) + fi = np.asarray([r[2] for r in chain], dtype=int) + sr = np.asarray([r[5] for r in chain]) + sf = np.asarray([r[6] for r in chain]) + b_r, c_r = br[ri]*sr[:, None], cr[:, ri]*sr[None] + b_f, c_f = fine["b"][fi]*sf[:, None], fine["c"][:, fi]*sf[None] + Hr, Hf = residue(b_r, c_r), residue(b_f, c_f) + ritz = response(t, wr[ri], Hr)-response(t, coarse["omega"][ci], Hr) + grid = response(t, coarse["omega"][ci], Hr)-response(t, fine["omega"][fi], Hr) + source = response(t, fine["omega"][fi], residue(b_r-b_f, (c_r+c_f)/2)) + receiver = response(t, fine["omega"][fi], residue((b_r+b_f)/2, c_r-c_f)) + remainder = yr-yf-ritz-grid-source-receiver + replacement_coarse = yr-ritz + replacement_continuous = yr-ritz-grid + total = yr-yf + weights = np.linalg.norm(Hf, axis=(1,2)) + wg = weights/max(weights.sum(), 1e-300) + dg = (coarse["omega"][ci]-fine["omega"][fi])/fine["omega"][fi] + dr = (wr[ri]-coarse["omega"][ci])/fine["omega"][fi] + for j, match_row in enumerate(chain): + pair_rows.append({"model": name, "dimension": len(wr), "rom_mode": int(ri[j]), + "coarse_mode": int(ci[j]), "continuous_mode": int(fi[j]), + "continuous_x_index": int(fine["m"][fi[j]]), "continuous_y_index": int(fine["ell"][fi[j]]), + "mac_rom_coarse": match_row[3], "mac_coarse_continuous": match_row[4], + "sign_rom_to_coarse": match_row[5], "sign_continuous_to_coarse": match_row[6], + "omega_rom": float(wr[ri[j]]), "omega_coarse": float(coarse["omega"][ci[j]]), + "omega_continuous": float(fine["omega"][fi[j]]), "relative_grid_shift": float(dg[j]), + "relative_ritz_shift": float(dr[j]), "continuous_residue_norm": float(weights[j])}) + components = {"ritz_frequency": ritz, "grid_frequency": grid, "source_coupling": source, + "receiver_coupling": receiver, "unmatched": remainder} + for aname, aa in components.items(): + for bname, bb in components.items(): + gram_rows.append({"model": name, "component_a": aname, "component_b": bname, + "normalized_inner_product": float(np.sum(aa*bb)/norm(yf)**2)}) + row = {"model": name, "dimension": len(wr), "accepted_triples": len(chain), + "same_grid_error": norm(yr-yc)/norm(yc), "total_error": norm(total)/norm(yf), + "coarse_frequency_replacement_error": norm(replacement_coarse-yf)/norm(yf), + "continuous_frequency_replacement_error": norm(replacement_continuous-yf)/norm(yf), + "ritz_grid_cosine": cosine(ritz, grid), + "weighted_relative_grid_shift": float(wg@dg), "weighted_relative_ritz_shift": float(wg@dr), + "weighted_shift_compensation_ratio": float(-(wg@dr)/(wg@dg)), + "matched_continuous_response_omission": norm(yf-response(t, fine["omega"][fi], Hf))/norm(yf), + "decomposition_relative_defect": norm(total-sum(components.values()))/norm(total), + "stored_receiver_reconstruction_error": norm(yr-response(t, wr, residue(br, cr)))/norm(yr)} + row.update({key+"_relative_norm": norm(value)/norm(yf) for key, value in components.items()}) + summary.append(row) + windows_to_check = [("cumulative", 0., end) for end in (2.,4.,6.,8.)]+[("successive", start, start+2) for start in (0.,2.,4.,6.)] + for kind, start, end in windows_to_check: + mask = (t >= start-1e-12)&(t <= end+1e-12) + for rr in range(4): + for ss in range(3): + ref = yf[mask, rr, ss] + original_error = norm(yr[mask, rr, ss]-ref)/norm(ref) + replaced_error = norm(replacement_coarse[mask, rr, ss]-ref)/norm(ref) + windows.append({"model": name, "window_type": kind, "start": start, "end": end, + "source": ss+1, "receiver": rr+1, "original_error": original_error, + "coarse_replacement_error": replaced_error, + "coarse_replacement_change_percentage_points": 100*(replaced_error-original_error), + "reference_squared_norm": norm(ref)**2}) + save_arrays(OUT/f"{name}_decomposition.npz", time=t, rom_response=yr, + coarse_response=yc, continuous_response=yf, no_ritz_frequency_response=replacement_coarse, + continuous_frequency_response=replacement_continuous, **components) + print(json.dumps(row), flush=True) + csv_write(OUT/"modal_pairs.csv", pair_rows) + csv_write(OUT/"modal_summary.csv", summary) + csv_write(OUT/"modal_component_gram.csv", gram_rows) + csv_write(OUT/"receiver_time_windows.csv", windows) + validation["passed"] = (validation["catalogue_receiver_reconstruction_relative_error"] < 1e-9 + and all(r["decomposition_relative_defect"] < 1e-11 for r in summary) + and max(r["frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max"] for r in catalogue_root_checks if r["cells"]==2048) < .1) + dump(OUT/"modal_validation.json", validation) + dump(OUT/"modal_summary.json", {"models": summary}) + if not validation["passed"]: + raise RuntimeError("Modal validation failed") + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + main() diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/continuous_catalogue.npz b/unequal_speed_interface/results/continuous_catalogue.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fd7c054d6d6f9ddc3d0649b57c7e069a1551596c --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/continuous_catalogue.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:fac59c08a2901e19fe665cb1932a855b7049cb4be2d6c2f33421198e0fa1a246 +size 60147 diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/continuous_reference.npz b/unequal_speed_interface/results/continuous_reference.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..55fd6623a6eebda702581ddd741165a163258c3b --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/continuous_reference.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:ebf590c18039b353f5196be0cb49eaf114aa02a7f1005267403732c983010281 +size 153680 diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/craig_bampton_m128_decomposition.npz b/unequal_speed_interface/results/craig_bampton_m128_decomposition.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7cd42572dfc95e4b90c3d61c9e769ca1c0d02153 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/craig_bampton_m128_decomposition.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:fabe0253451e7d88475d0d2995ea2b4b8d496628d675131d6e40aad361a78fca +size 592022 diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/craig_bampton_m32_decomposition.npz b/unequal_speed_interface/results/craig_bampton_m32_decomposition.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a7c498c02ea8a520b9b238003a1cf7380a8f806f --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/craig_bampton_m32_decomposition.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:79e164d5bf6753536dd48ebd54977235cf68d12377e9261ba356d3603866b76a +size 594214 diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/craig_bampton_m64_decomposition.npz b/unequal_speed_interface/results/craig_bampton_m64_decomposition.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e8a4d5ec729dc1710faaea5e471971c55092570a --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/craig_bampton_m64_decomposition.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:56c41d6d42041ce4da4848ef3d104613ea2074401d521b9d7ab28689ad568e9d +size 593669 diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/environment.json b/unequal_speed_interface/results/environment.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..10a882b28a069cfd443ad27e6e1d1c32d1ed3790 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/environment.json @@ -0,0 +1,169 @@ +{ + "python": "3.12.15 | packaged by Anaconda, Inc. | (main, Oct 1 2026, 20:20:25) [GCC 14.3.0]", + "platform": "Linux-5.19.0-051900-generic-x86_64-with-glibc2.35", + "numpy": "2.3.5", + "scipy": "1.17.0", + "threadpools": [ + { + "user_api": "blas", + "internal_api": "openblas", + "num_threads": 2, + "prefix": "libscipy_openblas", + "filepath": "/home/chenxiaoliang/anaconda3/envs/acous/lib/python3.12/site-packages/numpy.libs/libscipy_openblas64_-fdde5778.so", + "version": "0.3.30", + "threading_layer": "pthreads", + "architecture": "SkylakeX" + }, + { + "user_api": "blas", + "internal_api": "openblas", + "num_threads": 2, + "prefix": "libscipy_openblas", + "filepath": "/home/chenxiaoliang/anaconda3/envs/acous/lib/python3.12/site-packages/scipy.libs/libscipy_openblas-6cdc3b4a.so", + "version": "0.3.30", + "threading_layer": "pthreads", + "architecture": "SkylakeX" + } + ], + "cpu_affinity": [ + 0, + 1, + 2, + 3, + 4, + 5, + 6, + 7, + 8, + 9, + 10, + 11, + 12, + 13, + 14, + 15, + 16, + 17, + 18, + 19, + 20, + 21, + 22, + 23, + 24, + 25, + 26, + 27, + 28, + 29, + 30, + 31, + 32, + 33, + 34, + 35, + 36, + 37, + 38, + 39, + 40, + 41, + 42, + 43, + 44, + 45, + 46, + 47, + 48, + 49, + 50, + 51, + 52, + 53, + 54, + 55, + 56, + 57, + 58, + 59, + 60, + 61, + 62, + 63, + 64, + 65, + 66, + 67, + 68, + 69, + 70, + 71, + 72, + 73, + 74, + 75, + 76, + 77, + 78, + 79, + 80, + 81, + 82, + 83, + 84, + 85, + 86, + 87, + 88, + 89, + 90, + 91, + 92, + 93, + 94, + 95, + 96, + 97, + 98, + 99, + 100, + 101, + 102, + 103, + 104, + 105, + 106, + 107, + 108, + 109, + 110, + 111, + 112, + 113, + 114, + 115, + 116, + 117, + 118, + 119, + 120, + 121, + 122, + 123, + 124, + 125, + 126, + 127 + ], + "timing_scope": "This study measures mechanism and accuracy; comparative costs are computed separately by the timing experiments.", + "config_sha256": "0ad770a71f1b04bf823f6d98e48e0458974b1c81fb43f49a6b863f12173be883", + "code_sha256": { + "verify_outputs.py": "40c267025561dd351f857317ffb6ec61c72629bf3257fb542f77fa5342d1d5fd", + "modal.py": "19aeef09aa5a83f04de20e9dad0a6be716662419323d3bfa16df4627af65721d", + "analyze.py": "c1e71be0b500ac809b712b3d5dbabf2588592b265c074c517b497c458c89dcd4", + "verify.py": "1fb4f971f73de3ce50cd9f5956df7bfad95b9773628bd3bb53b182abc2cfe517", + "io.py": "9c0fcc08fdc766599d3ba8020e0794b5006af48c0dfea3d2e6951d6500be815e", + "kernel.py": "2cf14b5caaba8adb20d5b9732a8648a4bfc23aa53553f51535a5a93d826036bc", + "run.py": "54e9509b36ea1fcd821ead8be545ad513da7f5a5474abf0a3dacee9f5bf3e73c" + } +} diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/modal_component_gram.csv b/unequal_speed_interface/results/modal_component_gram.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..52f48eb62acb61b7d36c0fdd47eb2a0e098afddf --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/modal_component_gram.csv @@ -0,0 +1,126 @@ +model,component_a,component_b,normalized_inner_product +craig_bampton_m128,ritz_frequency,ritz_frequency,2.4467488065687554e-05 +craig_bampton_m128,ritz_frequency,grid_frequency,-0.0007483721627927635 +craig_bampton_m128,ritz_frequency,source_coupling,-1.1956370786860288e-05 +craig_bampton_m128,ritz_frequency,receiver_coupling,-7.015392539803233e-06 +craig_bampton_m128,ritz_frequency,unmatched,-7.495133189559724e-05 +craig_bampton_m128,grid_frequency,ritz_frequency,-0.0007483721627927635 +craig_bampton_m128,grid_frequency,grid_frequency,0.15767059425554814 +craig_bampton_m128,grid_frequency,source_coupling,0.0012416712260119572 +craig_bampton_m128,grid_frequency,receiver_coupling,0.0014874974564423442 +craig_bampton_m128,grid_frequency,unmatched,-0.001254887923111578 +craig_bampton_m128,source_coupling,ritz_frequency,-1.1956370786860288e-05 +craig_bampton_m128,source_coupling,grid_frequency,0.0012416712260119572 +craig_bampton_m128,source_coupling,source_coupling,0.0001172196994291202 +craig_bampton_m128,source_coupling,receiver_coupling,4.4855777078080245e-05 +craig_bampton_m128,source_coupling,unmatched,0.0008256092307794003 +craig_bampton_m128,receiver_coupling,ritz_frequency,-7.015392539803233e-06 +craig_bampton_m128,receiver_coupling,grid_frequency,0.0014874974564423442 +craig_bampton_m128,receiver_coupling,source_coupling,4.4855777078080245e-05 +craig_bampton_m128,receiver_coupling,receiver_coupling,0.00016880091116827493 +craig_bampton_m128,receiver_coupling,unmatched,0.0007848389793879373 +craig_bampton_m128,unmatched,ritz_frequency,-7.495133189559724e-05 +craig_bampton_m128,unmatched,grid_frequency,-0.001254887923111578 +craig_bampton_m128,unmatched,source_coupling,0.0008256092307794003 +craig_bampton_m128,unmatched,receiver_coupling,0.0007848389793879373 +craig_bampton_m128,unmatched,unmatched,0.1469233288532549 +craig_bampton_m32,ritz_frequency,ritz_frequency,0.013664140980529102 +craig_bampton_m32,ritz_frequency,grid_frequency,-0.021200808236573106 +craig_bampton_m32,ritz_frequency,source_coupling,-0.0003176151070343892 +craig_bampton_m32,ritz_frequency,receiver_coupling,0.0001699204958838185 +craig_bampton_m32,ritz_frequency,unmatched,-0.001166226562214942 +craig_bampton_m32,grid_frequency,ritz_frequency,-0.021200808236573106 +craig_bampton_m32,grid_frequency,grid_frequency,0.10738085547285406 +craig_bampton_m32,grid_frequency,source_coupling,0.0004161226638692066 +craig_bampton_m32,grid_frequency,receiver_coupling,-0.00015781857217718868 +craig_bampton_m32,grid_frequency,unmatched,0.022123659801992896 +craig_bampton_m32,source_coupling,ritz_frequency,-0.0003176151070343892 +craig_bampton_m32,source_coupling,grid_frequency,0.0004161226638692066 +craig_bampton_m32,source_coupling,source_coupling,0.00011238998650913702 +craig_bampton_m32,source_coupling,receiver_coupling,-6.013575540622877e-07 +craig_bampton_m32,source_coupling,unmatched,-6.081985524137119e-05 +craig_bampton_m32,receiver_coupling,ritz_frequency,0.0001699204958838185 +craig_bampton_m32,receiver_coupling,grid_frequency,-0.00015781857217718868 +craig_bampton_m32,receiver_coupling,source_coupling,-6.013575540622877e-07 +craig_bampton_m32,receiver_coupling,receiver_coupling,0.00010806320086490191 +craig_bampton_m32,receiver_coupling,unmatched,-0.00010334093787531254 +craig_bampton_m32,unmatched,ritz_frequency,-0.001166226562214942 +craig_bampton_m32,unmatched,grid_frequency,0.022123659801992896 +craig_bampton_m32,unmatched,source_coupling,-6.081985524137119e-05 +craig_bampton_m32,unmatched,receiver_coupling,-0.00010334093787531254 +craig_bampton_m32,unmatched,unmatched,0.13601630370843878 +craig_bampton_m64,ritz_frequency,ritz_frequency,0.00090985909736288 +craig_bampton_m64,ritz_frequency,grid_frequency,-0.004786225451234044 +craig_bampton_m64,ritz_frequency,source_coupling,-8.829919227232008e-05 +craig_bampton_m64,ritz_frequency,receiver_coupling,-4.7032750975318436e-05 +craig_bampton_m64,ritz_frequency,unmatched,-0.00029822159326930563 +craig_bampton_m64,grid_frequency,ritz_frequency,-0.004786225451234044 +craig_bampton_m64,grid_frequency,grid_frequency,0.15959371809783526 +craig_bampton_m64,grid_frequency,source_coupling,0.0010617252254145398 +craig_bampton_m64,grid_frequency,receiver_coupling,0.0012025225477736259 +craig_bampton_m64,grid_frequency,unmatched,7.2890547693157205e-06 +craig_bampton_m64,source_coupling,ritz_frequency,-8.829919227232008e-05 +craig_bampton_m64,source_coupling,grid_frequency,0.0010617252254145398 +craig_bampton_m64,source_coupling,source_coupling,8.952289321718023e-05 +craig_bampton_m64,source_coupling,receiver_coupling,3.328347112953617e-05 +craig_bampton_m64,source_coupling,unmatched,0.0006570140829123245 +craig_bampton_m64,receiver_coupling,ritz_frequency,-4.7032750975318436e-05 +craig_bampton_m64,receiver_coupling,grid_frequency,0.0012025225477736259 +craig_bampton_m64,receiver_coupling,source_coupling,3.328347112953617e-05 +craig_bampton_m64,receiver_coupling,receiver_coupling,9.578090919648024e-05 +craig_bampton_m64,receiver_coupling,unmatched,0.0006256156978968261 +craig_bampton_m64,unmatched,ritz_frequency,-0.00029822159326930563 +craig_bampton_m64,unmatched,grid_frequency,7.2890547693157205e-06 +craig_bampton_m64,unmatched,source_coupling,0.0006570140829123245 +craig_bampton_m64,unmatched,receiver_coupling,0.0006256156978968261 +craig_bampton_m64,unmatched,unmatched,0.14150215421581552 +rational_krylov_m128,ritz_frequency,ritz_frequency,1.285499448608412e-14 +rational_krylov_m128,ritz_frequency,grid_frequency,1.1226181301994113e-09 +rational_krylov_m128,ritz_frequency,source_coupling,-1.1123387506983262e-10 +rational_krylov_m128,ritz_frequency,receiver_coupling,-3.3163142336935055e-11 +rational_krylov_m128,ritz_frequency,unmatched,6.446093802360248e-10 +rational_krylov_m128,grid_frequency,ritz_frequency,1.1226181301994113e-09 +rational_krylov_m128,grid_frequency,grid_frequency,0.15780677233283458 +rational_krylov_m128,grid_frequency,source_coupling,0.0012242661636522258 +rational_krylov_m128,grid_frequency,receiver_coupling,0.001531543472063833 +rational_krylov_m128,grid_frequency,unmatched,-0.0016143966053355024 +rational_krylov_m128,source_coupling,ritz_frequency,-1.1123387506983262e-10 +rational_krylov_m128,source_coupling,grid_frequency,0.0012242661636522258 +rational_krylov_m128,source_coupling,source_coupling,0.00014584571670014273 +rational_krylov_m128,source_coupling,receiver_coupling,5.1116178556742664e-05 +rational_krylov_m128,source_coupling,unmatched,0.0008569963017322031 +rational_krylov_m128,receiver_coupling,ritz_frequency,-3.3163142336935055e-11 +rational_krylov_m128,receiver_coupling,grid_frequency,0.001531543472063833 +rational_krylov_m128,receiver_coupling,source_coupling,5.1116178556742664e-05 +rational_krylov_m128,receiver_coupling,receiver_coupling,0.0001917103280658761 +rational_krylov_m128,receiver_coupling,unmatched,0.0008472289306245805 +rational_krylov_m128,unmatched,ritz_frequency,6.446093802360248e-10 +rational_krylov_m128,unmatched,grid_frequency,-0.0016143966053355024 +rational_krylov_m128,unmatched,source_coupling,0.0008569963017322031 +rational_krylov_m128,unmatched,receiver_coupling,0.0008472289306245805 +rational_krylov_m128,unmatched,unmatched,0.14755861546813864 +rational_krylov_m32,ritz_frequency,ritz_frequency,3.0300151808129143e-06 +rational_krylov_m32,ritz_frequency,grid_frequency,-2.8007281118285925e-05 +rational_krylov_m32,ritz_frequency,source_coupling,-5.856261834747509e-07 +rational_krylov_m32,ritz_frequency,receiver_coupling,-5.559855016382021e-07 +rational_krylov_m32,ritz_frequency,unmatched,2.616734236157553e-05 +rational_krylov_m32,grid_frequency,ritz_frequency,-2.8007281118285925e-05 +rational_krylov_m32,grid_frequency,grid_frequency,0.1567365619882872 +rational_krylov_m32,grid_frequency,source_coupling,0.0012582684305692251 +rational_krylov_m32,grid_frequency,receiver_coupling,0.0015252178992874903 +rational_krylov_m32,grid_frequency,unmatched,-0.0018906396062909024 +rational_krylov_m32,source_coupling,ritz_frequency,-5.856261834747509e-07 +rational_krylov_m32,source_coupling,grid_frequency,0.0012582684305692251 +rational_krylov_m32,source_coupling,source_coupling,0.00012577502708919946 +rational_krylov_m32,source_coupling,receiver_coupling,4.808477507455519e-05 +rational_krylov_m32,source_coupling,unmatched,0.0008017257335690643 +rational_krylov_m32,receiver_coupling,ritz_frequency,-5.559855016382021e-07 +rational_krylov_m32,receiver_coupling,grid_frequency,0.0015252178992874903 +rational_krylov_m32,receiver_coupling,source_coupling,4.808477507455519e-05 +rational_krylov_m32,receiver_coupling,receiver_coupling,0.0002036253647115046 +rational_krylov_m32,receiver_coupling,unmatched,0.0007563797691841063 +rational_krylov_m32,unmatched,ritz_frequency,2.616734236157553e-05 +rational_krylov_m32,unmatched,grid_frequency,-0.0018906396062909024 +rational_krylov_m32,unmatched,source_coupling,0.0008017257335690643 +rational_krylov_m32,unmatched,receiver_coupling,0.0007563797691841063 +rational_krylov_m32,unmatched,unmatched,0.1448819300559137 diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/modal_pairs.csv b/unequal_speed_interface/results/modal_pairs.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7383a12400a86dbfd9db41442d576356999d8494 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/modal_pairs.csv @@ -0,0 +1,161 @@ +model,dimension,rom_mode,coarse_mode,continuous_mode,continuous_x_index,continuous_y_index,mac_rom_coarse,mac_coarse_continuous,sign_rom_to_coarse,sign_continuous_to_coarse,omega_rom,omega_coarse,omega_continuous,relative_grid_shift,relative_ritz_shift,continuous_residue_norm +craig_bampton_m128,288,1,1,1,0,1,0.9999999748659337,0.9999999852627233,1.0,1.0,3.2431430427015218,3.2431301922335627,3.2444865806016683,-0.000418059478567501,3.960709233904751e-06,1.1667748128133835 +craig_bampton_m128,288,2,2,2,1,0,0.9999999861065638,0.9999997234479352,-1.0,-1.0,4.4294779959607835,4.429472872924839,4.431201040150618,-0.00038999973373363643,1.1561280786809724e-06,3.4838524777757622 +craig_bampton_m128,288,3,3,3,1,1,0.999999774470053,0.999994576770218,-1.0,-1.0,6.250896826106619,6.250839651658554,6.253875546029509,-0.0004854420828508802,9.142242701192761e-06,2.8219268370844524 +craig_bampton_m128,288,4,4,4,0,2,0.9999996646014621,0.9999998824255637,1.0,1.0,6.389667956077121,6.389582460104551,6.399955732667184,-0.0016208350488559164,1.3358838114085679e-05,0.31836447562393755 +craig_bampton_m128,288,5,5,5,2,0,0.9999991645724531,0.9999993717631094,1.0,-1.0,6.607775151068513,6.607568255154526,6.6189343079446745,-0.001717202839814604,3.125819117731361e-05,0.8474096457078506 +craig_bampton_m128,288,6,6,6,2,1,0.9999989236086005,0.999997376276662,-1.0,-1.0,7.493006820903651,7.492774460989624,7.503213919667834,-0.0013913316066926289,3.0968051359692885e-05,1.0887281320441038 +craig_bampton_m128,288,7,7,7,1,2,0.9999969638681073,0.9999963359844661,1.0,-1.0,8.933658302385398,8.933107682173542,8.948016192381203,-0.0016661246344586431,6.153545098907257e-05,0.5197493553868278 +craig_bampton_m128,288,8,8,8,0,3,0.9999985327532088,0.9999993811568664,1.0,-1.0,9.502596511829925,9.502354279520839,9.536875193362729,-0.003619730062726935,2.539954693487077e-05,0.7072765718349947 +craig_bampton_m128,288,9,9,9,2,2,0.999999851882892,0.9999988527771209,1.0,-1.0,10.568369213208435,10.568347716541107,10.583867605579961,-0.0014663721823836944,2.031078631090118e-06,0.29949877990329166 +craig_bampton_m128,288,10,10,10,1,3,0.9999915918398904,0.9999972520203746,1.0,1.0,11.464906723991286,11.463740847013154,11.500243977939505,-0.0031741179575296833,0.00010137845600213067,0.21279281926197482 +craig_bampton_m128,288,11,11,11,3,0,0.9999906875973216,0.9998707226649475,-1.0,1.0,12.167720538788835,12.166530479926795,12.23062161359409,-0.005240218828784576,9.730158446870818e-05,1.322121804102217 +craig_bampton_m128,288,14,14,14,3,2,0.9999811515971831,0.9999335128736672,1.0,1.0,13.922982702361228,13.92088228268694,13.99137978883389,-0.005038638591114043,0.0001501224115126178,0.4369276448836397 +craig_bampton_m128,288,15,15,15,1,4,0.9999808840865154,0.9999941570576399,-1.0,-1.0,14.178018922006542,14.175946007629392,14.256496758641395,-0.005650108324345429,0.00014540138522415048,0.206178627471279 +craig_bampton_m128,288,16,16,16,4,0,0.9999966995613342,0.9999132145267013,-1.0,1.0,14.346451610593952,14.346113715980714,14.418354881388142,-0.005010361168227335,2.3435032361063694e-05,1.2601122054803107 +craig_bampton_m128,288,17,17,17,2,3,0.9999981895148983,0.9999386278715006,-1.0,-1.0,14.7794545403847,14.779312062470105,14.829474908634083,-0.0033826447984865752,9.607751823523028e-06,1.6374084668942335 +craig_bampton_m128,288,18,18,18,4,1,0.9999977184811418,0.9999151712625906,-1.0,1.0,15.014185206649733,15.013964414068123,15.081135952192254,-0.004454010515989409,1.4640315047202412e-05,0.9307339400995335 +craig_bampton_m128,288,23,23,23,2,4,0.9999490252244299,0.9999733211340914,-1.0,1.0,17.740089406993757,17.735788192777147,17.85299445583491,-0.006565075867116335,0.0002409239652905841,0.7703773967223772 +craig_bampton_m128,288,26,26,26,5,1,0.9999264147159092,0.9998503650617395,1.0,-1.0,18.882083266293495,18.87648822159038,19.134252009834462,-0.013471328176904806,0.00029240989928626306,0.42890090546472537 +craig_bampton_m128,288,27,27,27,3,4,0.9999992241712977,0.9999954848040737,-1.0,1.0,19.324647961368438,19.324597330664687,19.443356195484476,-0.006107940605818318,2.6040105031970373e-06,2.6439941947626138 +craig_bampton_m128,288,30,30,30,1,6,0.9998510488882892,0.9999711235408968,1.0,-1.0,19.837692303109318,19.829359400495278,20.096431099935455,-0.01328950887409229,0.0004146458927260225,0.07270550853947962 +craig_bampton_m128,288,31,31,31,2,5,0.9999160121097355,0.9999795249838465,-1.0,1.0,20.08842772729813,20.082349108262,20.26277516222492,-0.008904311108346077,0.0002999894628184912,0.26571830163004007 +craig_bampton_m128,288,32,32,32,5,3,0.9998977969188317,0.9989337541700809,-1.0,1.0,21.10376557500277,21.097074285921167,21.337281997575754,-0.011257652763921799,0.00031359613105198277,0.5455358340350002 +craig_bampton_m128,288,33,33,33,0,7,0.9999284327151602,0.9999691022776517,1.0,-1.0,21.65222999771609,21.649636338137988,22.080964042026313,-0.019533916321198046,0.00011746133788211631,0.07426005625261681 +craig_bampton_m128,288,34,34,34,4,4,0.9998834019336967,0.9970404103566166,1.0,-1.0,22.24484967211802,22.237897457136892,22.47018740387549,-0.010337695123029235,0.0003093972852192251,0.45664800141988693 +craig_bampton_m128,288,35,35,35,2,6,0.999717383842593,0.9999699629351796,1.0,1.0,22.56738652303648,22.553119552548292,22.833796408974365,-0.012292167776172274,0.0006248181525600127,0.15398319081594122 +craig_bampton_m128,288,36,36,36,1,7,0.9997497354525188,0.9999431542074695,1.0,1.0,22.68744106992835,22.676274090953505,23.100298382458767,-0.01835579283370838,0.00048341275900250176,0.027125074223392432 +craig_bampton_m128,288,37,37,37,6,0,0.9999897091259595,0.9964976027680151,-1.0,-1.0,22.99315366501779,22.99266040019376,23.280756961689374,-0.012374879475341084,2.1187662619458884e-05,1.2776701720251187 +craig_bampton_m128,288,40,40,40,3,5,0.9999667902092085,0.9989991099222729,1.0,-1.0,23.74748170415032,23.74679676333017,23.982200232858837,-0.009815757822175633,2.8560382846437015e-05,1.5320105765991998 +craig_bampton_m128,288,41,41,41,4,5,0.9998032507182516,0.9991951899801313,-1.0,-1.0,24.312942214955694,24.303090175890603,24.607289166751126,-0.0123621496378216,0.00040037075999427887,0.21917589447236027 +craig_bampton_m128,288,47,47,47,1,8,0.9996082371590462,0.9998973456726756,-1.0,-1.0,25.516161953937097,25.502037115587274,26.134966919768544,-0.024217738867789437,0.0005404574795592413,0.0021129669810288606 +craig_bampton_m128,288,50,50,50,3,6,0.9994306115102272,0.9999134807329498,-1.0,-1.0,26.374707261694212,26.351346919926524,26.742503707784415,-0.014626782597922217,0.0008735285978809938,0.07844817180866334 +craig_bampton_m128,288,51,51,51,5,5,0.9999999191347339,0.9991281516677764,1.0,-1.0,27.20095386406896,27.20095082832395,27.445972656673014,-0.008927423757725367,1.1060803156852732e-07,0.22668023688168729 +craig_bampton_m128,288,59,59,59,6,5,0.9995666569641597,0.9986394679347786,-1.0,1.0,29.094682329573583,29.07640615096568,29.679364474482103,-0.020315742408663663,0.000615787397456424,0.08526429904533216 +craig_bampton_m128,288,70,70,70,8,3,0.99923492912854,0.9951383982354496,-1.0,1.0,31.59825617350173,31.572308595486145,32.70264248095159,-0.03456399237840895,0.000793439797126479,0.0666714375357033 +craig_bampton_m128,288,83,83,83,4,8,0.9981294532397582,0.9997957591277119,-1.0,1.0,34.75817693301453,34.70969437981523,35.62925117985701,-0.02580904087486538,0.0013607513936949992,0.004822277214006857 +craig_bampton_m32,96,1,1,1,0,1,0.9999980625181749,0.9999999852627233,-1.0,1.0,3.2434349010614056,3.2431301922335627,3.2444865806016683,-0.000418059478567501,9.391588477041614e-05,1.1667748128133835 +craig_bampton_m32,96,2,2,2,1,0,0.9999988201361977,0.9999997234479352,1.0,-1.0,4.429597487334493,4.429472872924839,4.431201040150618,-0.00038999973373363643,2.8122039267720104e-05,3.4838524777757622 +craig_bampton_m32,96,3,3,3,1,1,0.999977864698032,0.999994576770218,-1.0,-1.0,6.252219756318082,6.250839651658554,6.253875546029509,-0.0004854420828508802,0.00022067990470397538,2.8219268370844524 +craig_bampton_m32,96,4,4,4,0,2,0.9999725750368842,0.9999998824255637,1.0,1.0,6.391532894059919,6.389582460104551,6.399955732667184,-0.0016208350488559164,0.0003047574134634804,0.31836447562393755 +craig_bampton_m32,96,5,5,5,2,0,0.9999306809603496,0.9999993717631094,1.0,-1.0,6.612700910604508,6.607568255154526,6.6189343079446745,-0.001717202839814604,0.0007754504292059948,0.8474096457078506 +craig_bampton_m32,96,6,6,6,2,1,0.9999056182903427,0.999997376276662,-1.0,-1.0,7.498481978439466,7.492774460989624,7.503213919667834,-0.0013913316066926289,0.0007606763596172245,1.0887281320441038 +craig_bampton_m32,96,7,7,7,1,2,0.9997470226808842,0.9999963359844661,1.0,-1.0,8.946070784626135,8.933107682173542,8.948016192381203,-0.0016661246344586431,0.0014487124490935297,0.5197493553868278 +craig_bampton_m32,96,8,8,8,0,3,0.9998678964644018,0.9999993811568664,-1.0,-1.0,9.507533688983257,9.502354279520839,9.536875193362729,-0.003619730062726935,0.0005430929269182897,0.7072765718349947 +craig_bampton_m32,96,9,9,9,2,2,0.9999838306793906,0.9999988527771209,-1.0,-1.0,10.568867812693513,10.568347716541107,10.583867605579961,-0.0014663721823836944,4.914046280516373e-05,0.29949877990329166 +craig_bampton_m32,96,10,10,10,1,3,0.9992806453475349,0.9999972520203746,1.0,1.0,11.489673864464622,11.463740847013154,11.500243977939505,-0.0031741179575296833,0.002254997154948572,0.21279281926197482 +craig_bampton_m32,96,11,11,11,3,0,0.9989777870085276,0.9998707226649475,-1.0,1.0,12.198813766878786,12.166530479926795,12.23062161359409,-0.005240218828784576,0.00263954588506838,1.322121804102217 +craig_bampton_m32,96,14,14,14,3,2,0.9980272346120137,0.9999335128736672,-1.0,1.0,13.975662844452517,13.92088228268694,13.99137978883389,-0.005038638591114043,0.003915308039118198,0.4369276448836397 +craig_bampton_m32,96,15,15,15,1,4,0.9982973589972571,0.9999941570576399,-1.0,-1.0,14.218655414824322,14.175946007629392,14.256496758641395,-0.005650108324345429,0.0029957855648543377,0.206178627471279 +craig_bampton_m32,96,16,16,16,4,0,0.9995074977816846,0.9999132145267013,1.0,1.0,14.355894288072093,14.346113715980714,14.418354881388142,-0.005010361168227335,0.0006783417506254424,1.2601122054803107 +craig_bampton_m32,96,17,17,17,2,3,0.9996386812987874,0.9999386278715006,-1.0,-1.0,14.782537769371741,14.779312062470105,14.829474908634083,-0.0033826447984865752,0.0002175199675990069,1.6374084668942335 +craig_bampton_m32,96,18,18,18,4,1,0.9996475307949604,0.9999151712625906,1.0,1.0,15.020322896716836,15.013964414068123,15.081135952192254,-0.004454010515989409,0.0004216182831896256,0.9307339400995335 +craig_bampton_m32,96,23,23,23,2,4,0.9946483086334384,0.9999733211340914,-1.0,1.0,17.834646116504963,17.735788192777147,17.85299445583491,-0.006565075867116335,0.00553733010853576,0.7703773967223772 +craig_bampton_m32,96,26,26,26,5,1,0.9862588659017559,0.9998503650617395,1.0,-1.0,19.071870531893268,18.87648822159038,19.134252009834462,-0.013471328176904806,0.010211128723634718,0.42890090546472537 +craig_bampton_m32,96,27,27,27,3,4,0.9998515335419778,0.9999954848040737,1.0,1.0,19.32586912742679,19.324597330664687,19.443356195484476,-0.006107940605818318,6.541035144949295e-05,2.6439941947626138 +craig_bampton_m32,96,31,31,31,2,5,0.99127404754933,0.9999795249838465,-1.0,1.0,20.210987655342812,20.082349108262,20.26277516222492,-0.008904311108346077,0.006348515741349539,0.26571830163004007 +craig_bampton_m32,96,32,32,32,5,3,0.9798609790427475,0.9989337541700809,1.0,1.0,21.314281125388234,21.097074285921167,21.337281997575754,-0.011257652763921799,0.010179686404845073,0.5455358340350002 +craig_bampton_m32,96,33,33,33,0,7,0.9916496146968826,0.9999691022776517,-1.0,-1.0,21.68381316839304,21.649636338137988,22.080964042026313,-0.019533916321198046,0.0015477961102606085,0.07426005625261681 +craig_bampton_m32,96,34,34,34,4,4,0.9755786490613605,0.9970404103566166,1.0,-1.0,22.433673053964508,22.237897457136892,22.47018740387549,-0.010337695123029235,0.008712681977625612,0.45664800141988693 +craig_bampton_m32,96,37,37,37,6,0,0.9933293052826013,0.9964976027680151,1.0,-1.0,23.01386871479135,22.99266040019376,23.280756961689374,-0.012374879475341084,0.0009109804561978182,1.2776701720251187 +craig_bampton_m32,96,49,51,51,5,5,0.9999662328266713,0.9991281516677764,1.0,-1.0,27.201046278251546,27.20095082832395,27.445972656673014,-0.008927423757725367,3.4777389305739954e-06,0.22668023688168729 +craig_bampton_m64,160,1,1,1,0,1,0.9999997489163439,0.9999999852627233,-1.0,1.0,3.243205265106733,3.2431301922335627,3.2444865806016683,-0.000418059478567501,2.3138598759903777e-05,1.1667748128133835 +craig_bampton_m64,160,2,2,2,1,0,0.9999998564227053,0.9999997234479352,1.0,-1.0,4.429503041109649,4.429472872924839,4.431201040150618,-0.00038999973373363643,6.808128211148358e-06,3.4838524777757622 +craig_bampton_m64,160,3,3,3,1,1,0.999997524025663,0.999994576770218,1.0,-1.0,6.251175601542754,6.250839651658554,6.253875546029509,-0.0004854420828508802,5.3718671202798585e-05,2.8219268370844524 +craig_bampton_m64,160,4,4,4,0,2,0.9999965535032638,0.9999998824255637,-1.0,1.0,6.390076047163017,6.389582460104551,6.399955732667184,-0.0016208350488559164,7.712351133101632e-05,0.31836447562393755 +craig_bampton_m64,160,5,5,5,2,0,0.9999914721016817,0.9999993717631094,-1.0,-1.0,6.608793720176795,6.607568255154526,6.6189343079446745,-0.001717202839814604,0.0001851453671021436,0.8474096457078506 +craig_bampton_m64,160,6,6,6,2,1,0.9999887610873393,0.999997376276662,1.0,-1.0,7.494146427112521,7.492774460989624,7.503213919667834,-0.0013913316066926289,0.0001828504608272937,1.0887281320441038 +craig_bampton_m64,160,7,7,7,1,2,0.9999687686354286,0.9999963359844661,-1.0,-1.0,8.936316564472337,8.933107682173542,8.948016192381203,-0.0016661246344586431,0.0003586138234223354,0.5197493553868278 +craig_bampton_m64,160,8,8,8,0,3,0.9999840641783242,0.9999993811568664,-1.0,-1.0,9.503725052943675,9.502354279520839,9.536875193362729,-0.003619730062726935,0.0001437340213690263,0.7072765718349947 +craig_bampton_m64,160,9,9,9,2,2,0.9999982992821973,0.9999988527771209,-1.0,-1.0,10.568473998526358,10.568347716541107,10.583867605579961,-0.0014663721823836944,1.1931553753036382e-05,0.29949877990329166 +craig_bampton_m64,160,10,10,10,1,3,0.9999117610797819,0.9999972520203746,-1.0,1.0,11.47041410673095,11.463740847013154,11.500243977939505,-0.0031741179575296833,0.0005802711429945352,0.21279281926197482 +craig_bampton_m64,160,11,11,11,3,0,0.999896053615525,0.9998707226649475,1.0,1.0,12.173762435210607,12.166530479926795,12.23062161359409,-0.005240218828784576,0.0005912990780267348,1.322121804102217 +craig_bampton_m64,160,14,14,14,3,2,0.9997924913858179,0.9999335128736672,1.0,1.0,13.93348296911331,13.92088228268694,13.99137978883389,-0.005038638591114043,0.0009006035585158682,0.4369276448836397 +craig_bampton_m64,160,15,15,15,1,4,0.9997920056049777,0.9999941570576399,-1.0,-1.0,14.187521331959994,14.175946007629392,14.256496758641395,-0.005650108324345429,0.0008119332909458143,0.206178627471279 +craig_bampton_m64,160,16,16,16,4,0,0.9999587920150388,0.9999132145267013,-1.0,1.0,14.348202048923229,14.346113715980714,14.418354881388142,-0.005010361168227335,0.00014483850340032167,1.2601122054803107 +craig_bampton_m64,160,17,17,17,2,3,0.9999702493939879,0.9999386278715006,1.0,-1.0,14.780135347053266,14.779312062470105,14.829474908634083,-0.0033826447984865752,5.5516772389676335e-05,1.6374084668942335 +craig_bampton_m64,160,18,18,18,4,1,0.9999710774179743,0.9999151712625906,-1.0,1.0,15.015326701508961,15.013964414068123,15.081135952192254,-0.004454010515989409,9.033055899477083e-05,0.9307339400995335 +craig_bampton_m64,160,23,23,23,2,4,0.99942473233448,0.9999733211340914,1.0,1.0,17.76055906793631,17.735788192777147,17.85299445583491,-0.006565075867116335,0.0013874913376824137,0.7703773967223772 +craig_bampton_m64,160,26,26,26,5,1,0.9990594493159669,0.9998503650617395,-1.0,-1.0,18.912516547617855,18.87648822159038,19.134252009834462,-0.013471328176904806,0.0018829231479211143,0.42890090546472537 +craig_bampton_m64,160,27,27,27,3,4,0.9999884350705049,0.9999954848040737,1.0,1.0,19.32489548055193,19.324597330664687,19.443356195484476,-0.006107940605818318,1.5334280987570108e-05,2.6439941947626138 +craig_bampton_m64,160,30,30,30,1,6,0.9978819510676057,0.9999711235408968,1.0,-1.0,19.873669688683524,19.829359400495278,20.096431099935455,-0.01328950887409229,0.0022048834426321756,0.07270550853947962 +craig_bampton_m64,160,31,31,31,2,5,0.9990356566220261,0.9999795249838465,-1.0,1.0,20.11640047031037,20.082349108262,20.26277516222492,-0.008904311108346077,0.0016804885695938813,0.26571830163004007 +craig_bampton_m64,160,32,32,32,5,3,0.9986379230003329,0.9989337541700809,1.0,1.0,21.139114717505983,21.097074285921167,21.337281997575754,-0.011257652763921799,0.0019702805441476757,0.5455358340350002 +craig_bampton_m64,160,33,33,33,0,7,0.9988857852768231,0.9999691022776517,-1.0,-1.0,21.661983856008415,21.649636338137988,22.080964042026313,-0.019533916321198046,0.0005591928797550108,0.07426005625261681 +craig_bampton_m64,160,34,34,34,4,4,0.9983713643579648,0.9970404103566166,1.0,-1.0,22.280039179353476,22.237897457136892,22.47018740387549,-0.010337695123029235,0.0018754504116559353,0.45664800141988693 +craig_bampton_m64,160,37,37,37,6,0,0.9997936068673942,0.9964976027680151,1.0,-1.0,22.99599251553772,22.99266040019376,23.280756961689374,-0.012374879475341084,0.00014312744853795008,1.2776701720251187 +craig_bampton_m64,160,40,40,40,3,5,0.9992181531058556,0.9989991099222729,1.0,-1.0,23.75052909780379,23.74679676333017,23.982200232858837,-0.009815757822175633,0.00015562935999942918,1.5320105765991998 +craig_bampton_m64,160,41,41,41,4,5,0.9971043649741059,0.9991951899801313,1.0,-1.0,24.36203527113549,24.303090175890603,24.607289166751126,-0.0123621496378216,0.0023954322983505446,0.21917589447236027 +craig_bampton_m64,160,47,47,47,1,8,0.9946118067470399,0.9998973456726756,1.0,-1.0,25.568928969391223,25.502037115587274,26.134966919768544,-0.024217738867789437,0.0025594772707881763,0.0021129669810288606 +craig_bampton_m64,160,50,50,50,3,6,0.9900082263025405,0.9999134807329498,-1.0,-1.0,26.49828820048091,26.351346919926524,26.742503707784415,-0.014626782597922217,0.005494671783914309,0.07844817180866334 +craig_bampton_m64,160,51,51,51,5,5,0.9999984689923986,0.9991281516677764,1.0,-1.0,27.20096946500614,27.20095082832395,27.445972656673014,-0.008927423757725367,6.790315803972252e-07,0.22668023688168729 +craig_bampton_m64,160,59,59,59,6,5,0.9930720555304673,0.9986394679347786,1.0,1.0,29.197962123769372,29.07640615096568,29.679364474482103,-0.020315742408663663,0.00409563934255408,0.08526429904533216 +craig_bampton_m64,160,70,70,70,8,3,0.9802602110219505,0.9951383982354496,-1.0,1.0,31.799837994669645,31.572308595486145,32.70264248095159,-0.03456399237840895,0.006957523365765595,0.0666714375357033 +rational_krylov_m128,288,1,1,1,0,1,1.0000000000000004,0.9999999852627233,-1.0,1.0,3.243130192233278,3.2431301922335627,3.2444865806016683,-0.000418059478567501,-8.7736896560411e-14,1.1667748128133835 +rational_krylov_m128,288,2,2,2,1,0,1.0000000000000004,0.9999997234479352,1.0,-1.0,4.429472872924977,4.429472872924839,4.431201040150618,-0.00038999973373363643,3.126823455261465e-14,3.4838524777757622 +rational_krylov_m128,288,3,3,3,1,1,1.0000000000000009,0.999994576770218,1.0,-1.0,6.2508396516584375,6.250839651658554,6.253875546029509,-0.0004854420828508802,-1.8604683147969925e-14,2.8219268370844524 +rational_krylov_m128,288,4,4,4,0,2,0.9999999999999987,0.9999998824255637,-1.0,1.0,6.389582460104402,6.389582460104551,6.399955732667184,-0.0016208350488559164,-2.3314844780564764e-14,0.31836447562393755 +rational_krylov_m128,288,5,5,5,2,0,1.0000000000000009,0.9999993717631094,-1.0,-1.0,6.607568255154483,6.607568255154526,6.6189343079446745,-0.001717202839814604,-6.441001249163986e-15,0.8474096457078506 +rational_krylov_m128,288,6,6,6,2,1,1.0000000000000004,0.999997376276662,-1.0,-1.0,7.4927744609895335,7.492774460989624,7.503213919667834,-0.0013913316066926289,-1.207405250328027e-14,1.0887281320441038 +rational_krylov_m128,288,7,7,7,1,2,0.9999999999999996,0.9999963359844661,1.0,-1.0,8.93310768217349,8.933107682173542,8.948016192381203,-0.0016661246344586431,-5.75706919109838e-15,0.5197493553868278 +rational_krylov_m128,288,8,8,8,0,3,1.0,0.9999993811568664,1.0,-1.0,9.502354279520702,9.502354279520839,9.536875193362729,-0.003619730062726935,-1.4342169092137448e-14,0.7072765718349947 +rational_krylov_m128,288,9,9,9,2,2,1.0000000000000004,0.9999988527771209,-1.0,-1.0,10.568347716541124,10.568347716541107,10.583867605579961,-0.0014663721823836944,1.6783626795026524e-15,0.29949877990329166 +rational_krylov_m128,288,10,10,10,1,3,0.9999999999999991,0.9999972520203746,1.0,1.0,11.463740847013083,11.463740847013154,11.500243977939505,-0.0031741179575296833,-6.1785014050406944e-15,0.21279281926197482 +rational_krylov_m128,288,11,11,11,3,0,1.0000000000000018,0.9998707226649475,1.0,1.0,12.166530479926713,12.166530479926795,12.23062161359409,-0.005240218828784576,-6.680969879862019e-15,1.322121804102217 +rational_krylov_m128,288,14,14,14,3,2,1.0,0.9999335128736672,1.0,1.0,13.920882282686904,13.92088228268694,13.99137978883389,-0.005038638591114043,-2.539216097640218e-15,0.4369276448836397 +rational_krylov_m128,288,15,15,15,1,4,0.9999999999999976,0.9999941570576399,-1.0,-1.0,14.17594600762941,14.175946007629392,14.256496758641395,-0.005650108324345429,1.2459981364801518e-15,0.206178627471279 +rational_krylov_m128,288,16,16,16,4,0,0.9999999999999978,0.9999132145267013,1.0,1.0,14.346113715981014,14.346113715980714,14.418354881388142,-0.005010361168227335,2.0820981889283324e-14,1.2601122054803107 +rational_krylov_m128,288,17,17,17,2,3,0.9999999999999809,0.9999386278715006,-1.0,-1.0,14.779312062472934,14.779312062470105,14.829474908634083,-0.0033826447984865752,1.9081838450780595e-13,1.6374084668942335 +rational_krylov_m128,288,18,18,18,4,1,0.999999999999909,0.9999151712625906,1.0,1.0,15.013964414082283,15.013964414068123,15.081135952192254,-0.004454010515989409,9.388775760489805e-13,0.9307339400995335 +rational_krylov_m128,288,23,23,23,2,4,0.9999999999999958,0.9999733211340914,1.0,1.0,17.735788192777566,17.735788192777147,17.85299445583491,-0.006565075867116335,2.3481787054577e-14,0.7703773967223772 +rational_krylov_m128,288,26,26,26,5,1,0.9999999999972744,0.9998503650617395,1.0,-1.0,18.876488221908687,18.87648822159038,19.134252009834462,-0.013471328176904806,1.6635371055452334e-11,0.42890090546472537 +rational_krylov_m128,288,27,27,27,3,4,0.9999999999986502,0.9999954848040737,-1.0,1.0,19.324597330817788,19.324597330664687,19.443356195484476,-0.006107940605818318,7.874188063775989e-12,2.6439941947626138 +rational_krylov_m128,288,30,30,30,1,6,0.9999999999967366,0.9999711235408968,-1.0,-1.0,19.829359400853964,19.829359400495278,20.096431099935455,-0.01328950887409229,1.7848220111407213e-11,0.07270550853947962 +rational_krylov_m128,288,31,31,31,2,5,0.9999999999986697,0.9999795249838465,-1.0,1.0,20.08234910840599,20.082349108262,20.26277516222492,-0.008904311108346077,7.106032196248046e-12,0.26571830163004007 +rational_krylov_m128,288,32,32,32,5,3,0.9999999999995202,0.9989337541700809,1.0,1.0,21.097074285969907,21.097074285921167,21.337281997575754,-0.011257652763921799,2.284249651150585e-12,0.5455358340350002 +rational_krylov_m128,288,33,33,33,0,7,0.9999999999995781,0.9999691022776517,1.0,-1.0,21.64963633817962,21.649636338137988,22.080964042026313,-0.019533916321198046,1.885366001636038e-12,0.07426005625261681 +rational_krylov_m128,288,34,34,34,4,4,0.9999999999992528,0.9970404103566166,1.0,-1.0,22.23789745720776,22.237897457136892,22.47018740387549,-0.010337695123029235,3.1539359770755338e-12,0.45664800141988693 +rational_krylov_m128,288,35,35,35,2,6,0.9999999999885065,0.9999699629351796,-1.0,1.0,22.55311955362014,22.553119552548292,22.833796408974365,-0.012292167776172274,4.6941235363099134e-11,0.15398319081594122 +rational_krylov_m128,288,36,36,36,1,7,0.9999999999998985,0.9999431542074695,1.0,1.0,22.67627409096301,22.676274090953505,23.100298382458767,-0.01835579283370838,4.1140200587226345e-13,0.027125074223392432 +rational_krylov_m128,288,37,37,37,6,0,0.9999999999927689,0.9964976027680151,1.0,-1.0,22.992660400850937,22.99266040019376,23.280756961689374,-0.012374879475341084,2.8228352912763263e-11,1.2776701720251187 +rational_krylov_m128,288,40,40,40,3,5,0.999999999999863,0.9989991099222729,1.0,-1.0,23.74679676334208,23.74679676333017,23.982200232858837,-0.009815757822175633,4.965639572562139e-13,1.5320105765991998 +rational_krylov_m128,288,41,41,41,4,5,0.9999999999980667,0.9991951899801313,1.0,-1.0,24.303090176053466,24.303090175890603,24.607289166751126,-0.0123621496378216,6.618506384832932e-12,0.21917589447236027 +rational_krylov_m128,288,47,47,47,1,8,0.9999999999860334,0.9998973456726756,-1.0,-1.0,25.502037116686207,25.502037115587274,26.134966919768544,-0.024217738867789437,4.2048360111858177e-11,0.0021129669810288606 +rational_krylov_m128,288,50,50,50,3,6,0.9999999999917284,0.9999134807329498,1.0,-1.0,26.351346920546664,26.351346919926524,26.742503707784415,-0.014626782597922217,2.3189316537659387e-11,0.07844817180866334 +rational_krylov_m128,288,51,51,51,5,5,0.9999999999817861,0.9991281516677764,1.0,-1.0,27.20095082962577,27.20095082832395,27.445972656673014,-0.008927423757725367,4.743212746028705e-11,0.22668023688168729 +rational_krylov_m128,288,59,59,59,6,5,0.9999999997948796,0.9986394679347786,1.0,1.0,29.076406164152154,29.07640615096568,29.679364474482103,-0.020315742408663663,4.442976658014887e-10,0.08526429904533216 +rational_krylov_m128,288,70,70,70,8,3,0.9999999986495582,0.9951383982354496,1.0,1.0,31.57230867068989,31.572308595486145,32.70264248095159,-0.03456399237840895,2.2996228430369248e-09,0.0666714375357033 +rational_krylov_m128,288,83,83,83,4,8,0.9999999999971725,0.9997957591277119,1.0,1.0,34.709694379945084,34.70969437981523,35.62925117985701,-0.02580904087486538,3.644524671727312e-12,0.004822277214006857 +rational_krylov_m128,288,94,94,89,8,6,0.9999999610144622,0.9196736926704274,1.0,-1.0,36.51914539748757,36.519143812844696,37.27011305332035,-0.02014936846049497,4.2517790905050327e-08,0.08411203482112817 +rational_krylov_m32,96,1,1,1,0,1,1.0000000000000004,0.9999999852627233,1.0,1.0,3.243130192233541,3.2431301922335627,3.2444865806016683,-0.000418059478567501,-6.706876648143742e-15,1.1667748128133835 +rational_krylov_m32,96,2,2,2,1,0,1.0,0.9999997234479352,-1.0,-1.0,4.429472872924806,4.429472872924839,4.431201040150618,-0.00038999973373363643,-7.416183836197065e-15,3.4838524777757622 +rational_krylov_m32,96,3,3,3,1,1,1.0000000000000027,0.999994576770218,1.0,-1.0,6.2508396516584845,6.250839651658554,6.253875546029509,-0.0004854420828508802,-1.1077597599554611e-14,2.8219268370844524 +rational_krylov_m32,96,4,4,4,0,2,0.9999999999999996,0.9999998824255637,-1.0,1.0,6.389582460104466,6.389582460104551,6.399955732667184,-0.0016208350488559164,-1.3183989608057455e-14,0.31836447562393755 +rational_krylov_m32,96,5,5,5,2,0,1.0000000000000018,0.9999993717631094,-1.0,-1.0,6.60756825515447,6.607568255154526,6.6189343079446745,-0.001717202839814604,-8.453814139527732e-15,0.8474096457078506 +rational_krylov_m32,96,6,6,6,2,1,1.0000000000000013,0.999997376276662,1.0,-1.0,7.492774460989615,7.492774460989624,7.503213919667834,-0.0013913316066926289,-1.183730637576497e-15,1.0887281320441038 +rational_krylov_m32,96,7,7,7,1,2,0.9999999999999984,0.9999963359844661,-1.0,-1.0,8.933107682173457,8.933107682173542,8.948016192381203,-0.0016661246344586431,-9.528942109404215e-15,0.5197493553868278 +rational_krylov_m32,96,8,8,8,0,3,1.0000000000000004,0.9999993811568664,-1.0,-1.0,9.502354279520794,9.502354279520839,9.536875193362729,-0.003619730062726935,-4.656548406538133e-15,0.7072765718349947 +rational_krylov_m32,96,9,9,9,2,2,1.0000000000000004,0.9999988527771209,-1.0,-1.0,10.568347716541084,10.568347716541107,10.583867605579961,-0.0014663721823836944,-2.181871483353448e-15,0.29949877990329166 +rational_krylov_m32,96,10,10,10,1,3,0.9999999999999989,0.9999972520203746,1.0,1.0,11.463740847013133,11.463740847013154,11.500243977939505,-0.0031741179575296833,-1.8535504215122083e-15,0.21279281926197482 +rational_krylov_m32,96,11,11,11,3,0,1.0000000000000013,0.9998707226649475,1.0,1.0,12.166530479926784,12.166530479926795,12.23062161359409,-0.005240218828784576,-8.71430853895046e-16,1.322121804102217 +rational_krylov_m32,96,14,14,14,3,2,1.0000000000000004,0.9999335128736672,-1.0,1.0,13.920882282686913,13.92088228268694,13.99137978883389,-0.005038638591114043,-1.9044120732301635e-15,0.4369276448836397 +rational_krylov_m32,96,15,15,15,1,4,0.9999999999999993,0.9999941570576399,1.0,-1.0,14.17594600762942,14.175946007629392,14.256496758641395,-0.005650108324345429,1.9935970183682432e-15,0.206178627471279 +rational_krylov_m32,96,16,16,16,4,0,0.9999999999999969,0.9999132145267013,-1.0,1.0,14.346113715981113,14.346113715980714,14.418354881388142,-0.005010361168227335,2.772024216028845e-14,1.2601122054803107 +rational_krylov_m32,96,17,17,17,2,3,0.999999999999968,0.9999386278715006,-1.0,-1.0,14.779312062473869,14.779312062470105,14.829474908634083,-0.0033826447984865752,2.5382558491653533e-13,1.6374084668942335 +rational_krylov_m32,96,18,18,18,4,1,0.9999999999998361,0.9999151712625906,-1.0,1.0,15.01396441408708,15.013964414068123,15.081135952192254,-0.004454010515989409,1.2570193817080315e-12,0.9307339400995335 +rational_krylov_m32,96,23,23,23,2,4,0.9999999999999918,0.9999733211340914,-1.0,1.0,17.735788192777765,17.735788192777147,17.85299445583491,-0.006565075867116335,3.462568599573218e-14,0.7703773967223772 +rational_krylov_m32,96,26,26,26,5,1,0.9999999999947435,0.9998503650617395,-1.0,-1.0,18.876488222027152,18.87648822159038,19.134252009834462,-0.013471328176904806,2.2826636727019477e-11,0.42890090546472537 +rational_krylov_m32,96,27,27,27,3,4,0.9999999999968914,0.9999954848040737,1.0,1.0,19.32459733088482,19.324597330664687,19.443356195484476,-0.006107940605818318,1.1321771959151803e-11,2.6439941947626138 +rational_krylov_m32,96,30,30,30,1,6,0.9999999988418906,0.9999711235408968,-1.0,-1.0,19.829359421883545,19.829359400495278,20.096431099935455,-0.01328950887409229,1.0642818643272216e-09,0.07270550853947962 +rational_krylov_m32,96,31,31,31,2,5,0.9999999999615812,0.9999795249838465,1.0,1.0,20.082349109084376,20.082349108262,20.26277516222492,-0.008904311108346077,4.058550965291779e-11,0.26571830163004007 +rational_krylov_m32,96,32,32,32,5,3,0.999999999888016,0.9989337541700809,-1.0,1.0,21.097074287568567,21.097074285921167,21.337281997575754,-0.011257652763921799,7.720760490836275e-11,0.5455358340350002 +rational_krylov_m32,96,33,33,33,0,7,0.9999999945517468,0.9999691022776517,1.0,-1.0,21.649636407338555,21.649636338137988,22.080964042026313,-0.019533916321198046,3.1339468205594055e-09,0.07426005625261681 +rational_krylov_m32,96,34,34,34,4,4,0.9999999226103696,0.9970404103566166,1.0,-1.0,22.237898296944113,22.237897457136892,22.47018740387549,-0.010337695123029235,3.737428647137831e-08,0.45664800141988693 +rational_krylov_m32,96,35,35,35,2,6,0.9999995557203094,0.9999699629351796,1.0,1.0,22.553124889304268,22.553119552548292,22.833796408974365,-0.012292167776172274,2.3372179904813828e-07,0.15398319081594122 +rational_krylov_m32,96,36,36,36,1,7,0.999997405153062,0.9999431542074695,-1.0,1.0,22.676306482672544,22.676274090953505,23.100298382458767,-0.01835579283370838,1.4022208069471558e-06,0.027125074223392432 +rational_krylov_m32,96,37,37,37,6,0,0.9999995506863232,0.9964976027680151,1.0,-1.0,22.99266431255176,22.99266040019376,23.280756961689374,-0.012374879475341084,1.6805115085705834e-07,1.2776701720251187 +rational_krylov_m32,96,40,40,40,3,5,0.9999998000284973,0.9989991099222729,-1.0,-1.0,23.746798359655948,23.74679676333017,23.982200232858837,-0.009815757822175633,6.656294092461807e-08,1.5320105765991998 +rational_krylov_m32,96,41,41,41,4,5,0.9999986598018032,0.9991951899801313,-1.0,-1.0,24.303100008065552,24.303090175890603,24.607289166751126,-0.0123621496378216,3.9956351482427127e-07,0.21917589447236027 +rational_krylov_m32,96,47,47,47,1,8,0.9038777026354691,0.9998973456726756,1.0,-1.0,25.595331724640133,25.502037115587274,26.134966919768544,-0.024217738867789437,0.003569723632681926,0.0021129669810288606 +rational_krylov_m32,96,49,50,50,3,6,0.9871202964108741,0.9999134807329498,-1.0,-1.0,26.351725710170946,26.351346919926524,26.742503707784415,-0.014626782597922217,1.4164352319490275e-05,0.07844817180866334 +rational_krylov_m32,96,50,51,51,5,5,0.9984173158060275,0.9991281516677764,-1.0,-1.0,27.206118594845268,27.20095082832395,27.445972656673014,-0.008927423757725367,0.0001882887003482174,0.22668023688168729 diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/modal_summary.csv b/unequal_speed_interface/results/modal_summary.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7e718809fc38bf7fb13450c08638c639cd0fc598 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/modal_summary.csv @@ -0,0 +1,6 @@ +model,dimension,accepted_triples,same_grid_error,total_error,coarse_frequency_replacement_error,continuous_frequency_replacement_error,ritz_grid_cosine,weighted_relative_grid_shift,weighted_relative_ritz_shift,weighted_shift_compensation_ratio,matched_continuous_response_omission,decomposition_relative_defect,stored_receiver_reconstruction_error,ritz_frequency_relative_norm,grid_frequency_relative_norm,source_coupling_relative_norm,receiver_coupling_relative_norm,unmatched_relative_norm +craig_bampton_m128,288,35,0.011627519452205927,0.5563083589023378,0.5577984521425069,0.38796901608033485,-0.38101983082501134,-0.004715104158102126,6.309370490165575e-05,0.013381190061992513,0.3500216737084068,8.971010116615209e-17,0.0,0.004946462176716562,0.3970775670515122,0.010826804673084308,0.01299234048077077,0.38330579026836376 +craig_bampton_m32,96,25,0.3320725211306784,0.5066425742230385,0.5367047753231707,0.3686559813626673,-0.5534747603957425,-0.004051579282225442,0.0013688194892631244,0.33784837810486146,0.4260335359713155,8.499902602702418e-17,0.0,0.11689371659986306,0.32769018214291074,0.010601414363618517,0.010395345153716729,0.36880388244762125 +craig_bampton_m64,160,32,0.077345796096904,0.5467416002077375,0.5553882212253486,0.3798937805783434,-0.397189889154047,-0.004652100850738153,0.0003610995810972068,0.07762075515622384,0.3507314248239277,9.268485500049619e-17,0.0,0.030163870729116974,0.39949182481977685,0.009461653830973749,0.009786772154110885,0.37616772085841643 +rational_krylov_m128,288,36,0.0009439909339414469,0.5581186755287812,0.55811867262109,0.38911033696720476,0.024924892037148223,-0.004764510603659504,1.4693047928801783e-10,3.083852498411151e-08,0.34979778473897394,8.81559658009707e-17,0.0,1.1337986808108448e-07,0.3972490054522913,0.012076659997703949,0.01384594987950903,0.384133590653224 +rational_krylov_m32,96,32,0.06565225776685694,0.5540243977958785,0.554027044862242,0.3852579798049222,-0.040640906860970806,-0.004583668018672619,1.990803078177659e-06,0.00043432531982413815,0.3508818265611439,8.568376116999103e-17,0.0,0.0017406938791220338,0.3958996867746769,0.01121494659323884,0.014269735972032018,0.38063359028850013 diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/modal_summary.json b/unequal_speed_interface/results/modal_summary.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..936952c0a5a48c855a594d81920bbd6c17abf5ba --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/modal_summary.json @@ -0,0 +1,109 @@ +{ + "models": [ + { + "model": "craig_bampton_m128", + "dimension": 288, + "accepted_triples": 35, + "same_grid_error": 0.011627519452205927, + "total_error": 0.5563083589023378, + "coarse_frequency_replacement_error": 0.5577984521425069, + "continuous_frequency_replacement_error": 0.38796901608033485, + "ritz_grid_cosine": -0.38101983082501134, + "weighted_relative_grid_shift": -0.004715104158102126, + "weighted_relative_ritz_shift": 6.309370490165575e-05, + "weighted_shift_compensation_ratio": 0.013381190061992513, + "matched_continuous_response_omission": 0.3500216737084068, + "decomposition_relative_defect": 8.971010116615209e-17, + "stored_receiver_reconstruction_error": 0.0, + "ritz_frequency_relative_norm": 0.004946462176716562, + "grid_frequency_relative_norm": 0.3970775670515122, + "source_coupling_relative_norm": 0.010826804673084308, + "receiver_coupling_relative_norm": 0.01299234048077077, + "unmatched_relative_norm": 0.38330579026836376 + }, + { + "model": "craig_bampton_m32", + "dimension": 96, + "accepted_triples": 25, + "same_grid_error": 0.3320725211306784, + "total_error": 0.5066425742230385, + "coarse_frequency_replacement_error": 0.5367047753231707, + "continuous_frequency_replacement_error": 0.3686559813626673, + "ritz_grid_cosine": -0.5534747603957425, + "weighted_relative_grid_shift": -0.004051579282225442, + "weighted_relative_ritz_shift": 0.0013688194892631244, + "weighted_shift_compensation_ratio": 0.33784837810486146, + "matched_continuous_response_omission": 0.4260335359713155, + "decomposition_relative_defect": 8.499902602702418e-17, + "stored_receiver_reconstruction_error": 0.0, + "ritz_frequency_relative_norm": 0.11689371659986306, + "grid_frequency_relative_norm": 0.32769018214291074, + "source_coupling_relative_norm": 0.010601414363618517, + "receiver_coupling_relative_norm": 0.010395345153716729, + "unmatched_relative_norm": 0.36880388244762125 + }, + { + "model": "craig_bampton_m64", + "dimension": 160, + "accepted_triples": 32, + "same_grid_error": 0.077345796096904, + "total_error": 0.5467416002077375, + "coarse_frequency_replacement_error": 0.5553882212253486, + "continuous_frequency_replacement_error": 0.3798937805783434, + "ritz_grid_cosine": -0.397189889154047, + "weighted_relative_grid_shift": -0.004652100850738153, + "weighted_relative_ritz_shift": 0.0003610995810972068, + "weighted_shift_compensation_ratio": 0.07762075515622384, + "matched_continuous_response_omission": 0.3507314248239277, + "decomposition_relative_defect": 9.268485500049619e-17, + "stored_receiver_reconstruction_error": 0.0, + "ritz_frequency_relative_norm": 0.030163870729116974, + "grid_frequency_relative_norm": 0.39949182481977685, + "source_coupling_relative_norm": 0.009461653830973749, + "receiver_coupling_relative_norm": 0.009786772154110885, + "unmatched_relative_norm": 0.37616772085841643 + }, + { + "model": "rational_krylov_m128", + "dimension": 288, + "accepted_triples": 36, + "same_grid_error": 0.0009439909339414469, + "total_error": 0.5581186755287812, + "coarse_frequency_replacement_error": 0.55811867262109, + "continuous_frequency_replacement_error": 0.38911033696720476, + "ritz_grid_cosine": 0.024924892037148223, + "weighted_relative_grid_shift": -0.004764510603659504, + "weighted_relative_ritz_shift": 1.4693047928801783e-10, + "weighted_shift_compensation_ratio": 3.083852498411151e-08, + "matched_continuous_response_omission": 0.34979778473897394, + "decomposition_relative_defect": 8.81559658009707e-17, + "stored_receiver_reconstruction_error": 0.0, + "ritz_frequency_relative_norm": 1.1337986808108448e-07, + "grid_frequency_relative_norm": 0.3972490054522913, + "source_coupling_relative_norm": 0.012076659997703949, + "receiver_coupling_relative_norm": 0.01384594987950903, + "unmatched_relative_norm": 0.384133590653224 + }, + { + "model": "rational_krylov_m32", + "dimension": 96, + "accepted_triples": 32, + "same_grid_error": 0.06565225776685694, + "total_error": 0.5540243977958785, + "coarse_frequency_replacement_error": 0.554027044862242, + "continuous_frequency_replacement_error": 0.3852579798049222, + "ritz_grid_cosine": -0.040640906860970806, + "weighted_relative_grid_shift": -0.004583668018672619, + "weighted_relative_ritz_shift": 1.990803078177659e-06, + "weighted_shift_compensation_ratio": 0.00043432531982413815, + "matched_continuous_response_omission": 0.3508818265611439, + "decomposition_relative_defect": 8.568376116999103e-17, + "stored_receiver_reconstruction_error": 0.0, + "ritz_frequency_relative_norm": 0.0017406938791220338, + "grid_frequency_relative_norm": 0.3958996867746769, + "source_coupling_relative_norm": 0.01121494659323884, + "receiver_coupling_relative_norm": 0.014269735972032018, + "unmatched_relative_norm": 0.38063359028850013 + } + ] +} diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/modal_validation.json b/unequal_speed_interface/results/modal_validation.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..eafd74426cd48616cdc8fb5d9daad3e5a710c61e --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/modal_validation.json @@ -0,0 +1,474 @@ +{ + "catalogue_modes_including_halo": 630, + "initial_max_angular_frequency": 97.31079261287712, + "catalogue_max_angular_frequency": 102.02318159326181, + "catalogue_receiver_reconstruction_relative_error": 1.296176327033293e-13, + "accepted_coarse_continuous_pairs": 36, + "catalogue_independent_root_checks": [ + { + "transverse_index": 0, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 28, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 0.00036381106811651234, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.01677372075803703 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 1, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 28, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 0.00036197607789728196, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.016993914342626083 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 2, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 28, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 0.0003559677971199932, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.017631601640747046 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 3, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 28, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 0.0003440666147217536, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.01854701700363223 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 4, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 28, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 0.0003309314060318135, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.019212287942999787 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 5, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 27, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 0.00032543923479396374, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.009986702386615415 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 6, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 27, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 0.00031599237051609276, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.011866783890102357 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 7, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 26, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 0.00029724535182948044, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.014469125402288185 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 8, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 26, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 0.0002686705367910403, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.015926551122418607 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 9, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 26, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 0.0002536408621655838, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.015258700088340129 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 10, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 26, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 0.00028438585021340457, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.013192583486301543 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 11, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 25, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 0.00029150316696425295, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.012406231156809519 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 12, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 25, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 0.0002875815055278739, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.010305637480410662 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 13, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 24, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 0.00023820728518459492, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.008260022779635992 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 14, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 23, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 0.00022242349970190908, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.011127601172423545 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 15, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 23, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 0.00016099844620043782, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.012494306714530232 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 16, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 22, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 0.00021104422446736111, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.027805394724597355 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 17, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 21, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 0.00017256699482433156, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.00938798739854554 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 18, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 20, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 0.000112077765181413, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.017318976140650193 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 19, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 19, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 0.00016019561843395795, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.012801382743360533 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 20, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 17, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 0.00012286196811418107, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.011449600198296134 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 21, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 16, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 0.00010419279840917632, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.031646301452254326 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 22, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 12, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 9.511548742582594e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.002161237432640107 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 23, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 12, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 9.122497821426448e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.0021700305428954633 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 24, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 11, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 6.540652390300306e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.0016582951188929844 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 25, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 11, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 6.247989640653503e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.0016648651192535027 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 26, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 10, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 4.270932571527148e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.0012428484837136355 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 27, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 9, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 2.77880049142116e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.0009042890724419121 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 28, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 9, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 2.6478774592091582e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.0009103584323184919 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 29, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 8, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 1.634179003649452e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.0006474164578032864 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 30, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 7, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 9.58189499123081e-06, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.00045212132071666914 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 31, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 5, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 3.0959072147069727e-06, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.00022434221991889894 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 32, + "cells": 1024, + "roots": 3, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 1.0150782027886465e-06, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.00016072642867198127 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 0, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 28, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 9.100466724722821e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.004195823079231387 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 1, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 28, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 9.0548678591524e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.004251044700967774 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 2, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 28, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 8.905572506237546e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.004411059317251666 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 3, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 28, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 8.60982328057873e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.004641151798825373 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 4, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 28, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 8.274175804984523e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.004809553929271122 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 5, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 27, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 8.137339569369088e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.0024970925386291385 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 6, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 27, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 7.902176801087114e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.0029675850782955996 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 7, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 26, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 7.436060896005792e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.003619679733968788 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 8, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 26, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 6.717727040229979e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.0039879442368332225 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 9, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 26, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 6.343625138397671e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.003809257379142881 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 10, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 26, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 7.106422183019795e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.0033031540050526198 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 11, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 25, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 7.286961618561239e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.0030980365241830995 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 12, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 25, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 7.19021359741292e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.0025724550653610763 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 13, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 24, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 5.955503869699765e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.0020629827535526674 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 14, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 23, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 5.563439948966191e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.0027833273454375383 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 15, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 23, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 4.03071696747934e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.0031130390302492464 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 16, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 22, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 5.274523461687757e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.006970931513571864 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 17, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 21, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 4.314760771117765e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.0023491724547577463 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 18, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 20, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 2.7964681355209167e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.004328942075387135 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 19, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 19, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 4.0049398066554005e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.003200972068754836 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 20, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 17, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 3.0722054260524576e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.0028630115889602637 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 21, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 16, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 2.6163836907443378e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.007946697685083477 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 22, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 12, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 2.3780566373739486e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.0005403478613973164 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 23, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 12, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 2.280796137666383e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.0005425484749614487 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 24, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 11, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 1.6352781116035736e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.00041460293999513953 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 25, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 11, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 1.56211127984073e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.0004162466219978016 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 26, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 10, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 1.067806348863393e-05, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.00031073342399084644 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 27, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 9, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 6.94747645562166e-06, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.00022608773315183433 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 28, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 9, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 6.620175414570616e-06, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.0002276061715439782 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 29, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 8, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 4.0857916007638695e-06, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.00016186774640854386 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 30, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 7, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 2.3957510581319763e-06, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 0.0001130434150554025 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 31, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 5, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 7.741852250250996e-07, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 5.610065805120784e-05 + }, + { + "transverse_index": 32, + "cells": 2048, + "roots": 3, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 2.538833285995058e-07, + "frequency_error_to_longitudinal_gap_max": 4.0199622642916676e-05 + } + ], + "gap_definition": "min(omega[j]-omega[j-1],omega[j+1]-omega[j])/omega[j], evaluated on the complete frequency catalogue including its upper halo.", + "matching": "Maximum-sum squared modal overlap; continuous physical modes are averaged to the coarse cells, multiplied by sqrt(M), and normalized only for matching.", + "passed": true +} diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/n128_craig_bampton_m128.json b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n128_craig_bampton_m128.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..aac0e72e541006c2ea4c917bc9beacffb5f4f3d1 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n128_craig_bampton_m128.json @@ -0,0 +1,106 @@ +{ + "grid": 128, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "dimension": 384, + "config_sha256": "0ad770a71f1b04bf823f6d98e48e0458974b1c81fb43f49a6b863f12173be883", + "receiver_total_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.010512313207252917, + "per_source": [ + 0.0044233236859891325, + 0.011564832566395889, + 0.011486303505227828 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.036844514705871384, + "per_source": [ + 0.016280548261691244, + 0.03904731345884989, + 0.04095398860934949 + ] + } + }, + "receiver_same_grid_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.008664281907214076, + "per_source": [ + 0.007749336940107572, + 0.01718268325083713, + 0.006425172028328521 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.031224702593957356, + "per_source": [ + 0.030157954460387354, + 0.07095971510255475, + 0.020708356843613145 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_total_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.06365509348769038, + "per_source": [ + 0.037142939325581124, + 0.08421778496375625, + 0.06090835878834251 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.10142313174789423, + "per_source": [ + 0.05506464458102452, + 0.12111077443026677, + 0.1148472382684376 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_same_grid_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.05774517021207568, + "per_source": [ + 0.022945767732140916, + 0.08333233168143332, + 0.05059575313735207 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.1297370427289736, + "per_source": [ + 0.07270644217951967, + 0.17343966346637296, + 0.1232519130642249 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.03653997549208263, + "per_source": [ + 0.03291929363747601, + 0.03931445460351672, + 0.03713375445680004 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.03649779593648991, + "per_source": [ + 0.03282577186673638, + 0.03923955551988175, + 0.037150110141456284 + ] + } + }, + "receiver_reduction_grid_error_cosine": { + "T2": -0.35375948045352723, + "T8": -0.6246940483694357 + }, + "structure": { + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.1120168188184131e-14, + "initial_pressure_projection_error": 0.01775023171363693, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 1.633843037076916e-15 + } +} diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/n128_craig_bampton_m128.npz b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n128_craig_bampton_m128.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ccfed953053e87a9586dccfe6904b63eb65ed554 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n128_craig_bampton_m128.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:6cfa63714fa30b47cc21c51977cb8099bb5cdd5ad46158f037c76f647b332284 +size 85430 diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/n128_craig_bampton_m32.json b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n128_craig_bampton_m32.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9a9c812cc4f3b2e12acac4d861725d0b27558413 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n128_craig_bampton_m32.json @@ -0,0 +1,106 @@ +{ + "grid": 128, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 32, + "dimension": 192, + "config_sha256": "0ad770a71f1b04bf823f6d98e48e0458974b1c81fb43f49a6b863f12173be883", + "receiver_total_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.27727145849686385, + "per_source": [ + 0.10254608072921209, + 0.5058188693697732, + 0.2540749961585469 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.3792036773811914, + "per_source": [ + 0.31183839349790604, + 0.6485081734958352, + 0.3460630179122963 + ] + } + }, + "receiver_same_grid_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.2739790425337621, + "per_source": [ + 0.1071133574591572, + 0.5025437689887519, + 0.24944688178103333 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.38893743189472996, + "per_source": [ + 0.3304385370109862, + 0.6550524053099198, + 0.3546022183027889 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_total_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.452165726683949, + "per_source": [ + 0.23614432562865714, + 0.5526372108209258, + 0.5038564511649265 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.6280850283187381, + "per_source": [ + 0.48771181682959946, + 0.7352275197248497, + 0.6370088095005164 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_same_grid_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.4520687618495759, + "per_source": [ + 0.23835791096951986, + 0.5534462503489879, + 0.501652793742374 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.6426556175552302, + "per_source": [ + 0.5089177857678636, + 0.7512213258933604, + 0.6453522212928502 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.03653997549208263, + "per_source": [ + 0.03291929363747601, + 0.03931445460351672, + 0.03713375445680004 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.03649779593648991, + "per_source": [ + 0.03282577186673638, + 0.03923955551988175, + 0.037150110141456284 + ] + } + }, + "receiver_reduction_grid_error_cosine": { + "T2": 0.33479198989992237, + "T8": -0.2510250968599448 + }, + "structure": { + "orthonormality_frobenius": 7.717615572483886e-15, + "initial_pressure_projection_error": 0.15098423443313747, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 1.6746792658219467e-15 + } +} diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/n128_craig_bampton_m32.npz b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n128_craig_bampton_m32.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e874403f1589c1c21d1c46f2aed04328adca276a --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n128_craig_bampton_m32.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:81fe487d13285fd7ae41e5d0a5efc4a4257208b0cddb08f22eb896e323c0a232 +size 73646 diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/n128_craig_bampton_m64.json b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n128_craig_bampton_m64.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0e96ae90fbf839c32ffe78d5e3d910731ab36644 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n128_craig_bampton_m64.json @@ -0,0 +1,106 @@ +{ + "grid": 128, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 64, + "dimension": 256, + "config_sha256": "0ad770a71f1b04bf823f6d98e48e0458974b1c81fb43f49a6b863f12173be883", + "receiver_total_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.04138151776684589, + "per_source": [ + 0.02245348654800106, + 0.08300129938016185, + 0.034014289712684845 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.10253096101252937, + "per_source": [ + 0.07853451470741199, + 0.23916145429659844, + 0.07318968573524884 + ] + } + }, + "receiver_same_grid_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.04260111169173862, + "per_source": [ + 0.028296384864556788, + 0.08874955658313623, + 0.03244423794477413 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.11674487307127594, + "per_source": [ + 0.10099726793040041, + 0.2750844223376105, + 0.07777390789612114 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_total_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.18787739213498278, + "per_source": [ + 0.08127254566396415, + 0.26099920955088907, + 0.17733611346233225 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.3167833894907057, + "per_source": [ + 0.19222312253075755, + 0.40882696793452994, + 0.3118880783561302 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_same_grid_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.18962823024395578, + "per_source": [ + 0.08263247797271482, + 0.2628372678428982, + 0.1796087637406214 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.3477636146382894, + "per_source": [ + 0.2232444893483496, + 0.44820882541369156, + 0.33537543983262363 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.03653997549208263, + "per_source": [ + 0.03291929363747601, + 0.03931445460351672, + 0.03713375445680004 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.03649779593648991, + "per_source": [ + 0.03282577186673638, + 0.03923955551988175, + 0.037150110141456284 + ] + } + }, + "receiver_reduction_grid_error_cosine": { + "T2": -0.23577139774290262, + "T8": -0.48171030883409477 + }, + "structure": { + "orthonormality_frobenius": 9.583104577037163e-15, + "initial_pressure_projection_error": 0.03585737542188278, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 1.6788513906869152e-15 + } +} diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/n128_craig_bampton_m64.npz b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n128_craig_bampton_m64.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..501f3c7f79f706b587d2a7ad2faed1df2b1f86e2 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n128_craig_bampton_m64.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:a6faf04acddd72bef513b4fd91a2ca918ad881d760ab7d9c6b92411c8d0b6564 +size 77542 diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/n128_full.json b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n128_full.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ae5bdbbb39d4a9a46de5729a815e201b66f50ff9 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n128_full.json @@ -0,0 +1,61 @@ +{ + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_separable", + "dimension": 16384, + "config_sha256": "0ad770a71f1b04bf823f6d98e48e0458974b1c81fb43f49a6b863f12173be883", + "receiver_total_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.00976403981031125, + "per_source": [ + 0.007641145245272228, + 0.014354148969020009, + 0.0093040673672873 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.047131977586243594, + "per_source": [ + 0.02932672472432673, + 0.06778719557371861, + 0.0481394650324032 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_total_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.047884747781743384, + "per_source": [ + 0.03672421191937821, + 0.055704690651791615, + 0.049368874195589385 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.11897939802071243, + "per_source": [ + 0.07204476118427022, + 0.140055863440793, + 0.13303828902778514 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.03653997549208263, + "per_source": [ + 0.03291929363747601, + 0.03931445460351672, + 0.03713375445680004 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.03649779593648991, + "per_source": [ + 0.03282577186673638, + 0.03923955551988175, + 0.037150110141456284 + ] + } + }, + "minimum_subcell_squared_norm": 0.00039838031357086745 +} diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/n128_full_receiver.npz b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n128_full_receiver.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2182f9eaec90d88e9e1d6efa3312a16cd6b882a3 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n128_full_receiver.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:bcd910ad0b1b2b0e3256f3b002d24a09d1083c437bda6783f7e13207652dd656 +size 60983 diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_craig_bampton_m128.json b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_craig_bampton_m128.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..44f8a270c5779ce464665d0b42f535be1d30f373 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_craig_bampton_m128.json @@ -0,0 +1,106 @@ +{ + "grid": 32, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "dimension": 288, + "config_sha256": "0ad770a71f1b04bf823f6d98e48e0458974b1c81fb43f49a6b863f12173be883", + "receiver_total_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.14298181431812496, + "per_source": [ + 0.11465020382448401, + 0.20801897340659256, + 0.1361825345637211 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.5563083589023377, + "per_source": [ + 0.4038913712241515, + 0.610492103747423, + 0.5887332626338145 + ] + } + }, + "receiver_same_grid_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.0029036168607291754, + "per_source": [ + 0.002550872666973952, + 0.006107299670015926, + 0.002012452758018795 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.011627519452205928, + "per_source": [ + 0.010070956150118158, + 0.023520360283429305, + 0.009300842396862343 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_total_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.3621795738793046, + "per_source": [ + 0.26203983549351056, + 0.39987896419475516, + 0.40707089337184704 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.7673081983833899, + "per_source": [ + 0.6196875326955945, + 0.7728368846754392, + 0.8863680786795459 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_same_grid_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.030592289497545274, + "per_source": [ + 0.01091396010942068, + 0.041337433090411255, + 0.03146973147432259 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.06810667990717972, + "per_source": [ + 0.029633867186880523, + 0.08067612528675179, + 0.08091263710705777 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.1447972914664671, + "per_source": [ + 0.13082904892148192, + 0.15556879885091535, + 0.147045422126639 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.14462819580723923, + "per_source": [ + 0.13046429632888445, + 0.1552832704275592, + 0.14709029866057055 + ] + } + }, + "receiver_reduction_grid_error_cosine": { + "T2": -0.2938452598027473, + "T8": -0.17012044710622207 + }, + "structure": { + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.7424198676839705e-14, + "initial_pressure_projection_error": 0.010168278763518494, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 8.911549879611726e-16 + } +} diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_craig_bampton_m128.npz b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_craig_bampton_m128.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3d7d41a01b688bb6783aa19fcadc06c4932d4a43 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_craig_bampton_m128.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:cad5c056b0d489e8cecffbf646e72b4cc3c14f8aa23973fb5a1d7b49daeb3163 +size 1886299 diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_craig_bampton_m32.json b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_craig_bampton_m32.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fa088b48e95472eaf079d7587291c2671eda9b1d --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_craig_bampton_m32.json @@ -0,0 +1,106 @@ +{ + "grid": 32, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 32, + "dimension": 96, + "config_sha256": "0ad770a71f1b04bf823f6d98e48e0458974b1c81fb43f49a6b863f12173be883", + "receiver_total_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.24695100879317763, + "per_source": [ + 0.07388707502226935, + 0.3699137075169392, + 0.2518427675571916 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.5066425742230385, + "per_source": [ + 0.23064381570781214, + 0.5363854985946228, + 0.5623652763273976 + ] + } + }, + "receiver_same_grid_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.23849680684474817, + "per_source": [ + 0.07883319535032346, + 0.41626317067231733, + 0.22604957463668898 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.33207252113067837, + "per_source": [ + 0.26302511384508037, + 0.5350584077879074, + 0.313746847300576 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_total_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.4052762870757868, + "per_source": [ + 0.2546357199100234, + 0.47618732898251154, + 0.44977093443365335 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.6262419698670132, + "per_source": [ + 0.4072783838713957, + 0.5949061330756577, + 0.8107958754621639 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_same_grid_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.42065834902515287, + "per_source": [ + 0.21529922506499877, + 0.5038350782795675, + 0.481868774069337 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.5822636955791397, + "per_source": [ + 0.4171136082403834, + 0.660578955571457, + 0.6384868394916142 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.1447972914664671, + "per_source": [ + 0.13082904892148192, + 0.15556879885091535, + 0.147045422126639 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.14462819580723923, + "per_source": [ + 0.13046429632888445, + 0.1552832704275592, + 0.14709029866057055 + ] + } + }, + "receiver_reduction_grid_error_cosine": { + "T2": -0.23284899011288382, + "T8": -0.4413894117706257 + }, + "structure": { + "orthonormality_frobenius": 8.379841437607773e-15, + "initial_pressure_projection_error": 0.1495783558175724, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 7.487144928883596e-16 + } +} diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_craig_bampton_m32.npz b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_craig_bampton_m32.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..14c36384ca970be760556fb393cdda8b47c091fa --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_craig_bampton_m32.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:b930bb8d22bd1dbf1517a4fbc0f1d70e78ea5136604afd6ac56d41c025776c96 +size 617154 diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_craig_bampton_m64.json b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_craig_bampton_m64.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6a7f2b3ef637878368cae45b4b0d37d0e691c00d --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_craig_bampton_m64.json @@ -0,0 +1,106 @@ +{ + "grid": 32, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 64, + "dimension": 160, + "config_sha256": "0ad770a71f1b04bf823f6d98e48e0458974b1c81fb43f49a6b863f12173be883", + "receiver_total_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.13982297376801736, + "per_source": [ + 0.10440859977998805, + 0.19123132612072274, + 0.13795844221255793 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.5467416002077377, + "per_source": [ + 0.37199106762444717, + 0.5709526595144027, + 0.5878462557683611 + ] + } + }, + "receiver_same_grid_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.02669116497917258, + "per_source": [ + 0.01593579234450898, + 0.055127477352272726, + 0.021055748495021648 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.07734579609690397, + "per_source": [ + 0.0627518404580579, + 0.16530633415779203, + 0.05999408291941858 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_total_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.331470495325301, + "per_source": [ + 0.24236136709881342, + 0.3516288424202217, + 0.38455719001201605 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.7351700594856369, + "per_source": [ + 0.5786670583971387, + 0.7228372870914676, + 0.8744637243413346 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_same_grid_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.13780838765044212, + "per_source": [ + 0.05945175246961578, + 0.19222743867772035, + 0.12922257845518417 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.253629045770627, + "per_source": [ + 0.15330459791845807, + 0.32475301670100887, + 0.25374268945633216 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.1447972914664671, + "per_source": [ + 0.13082904892148192, + 0.15556879885091535, + 0.147045422126639 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.14462819580723923, + "per_source": [ + 0.13046429632888445, + 0.1552832704275592, + 0.14709029866057055 + ] + } + }, + "receiver_reduction_grid_error_cosine": { + "T2": -0.24020167337725365, + "T8": -0.21710890848852468 + }, + "structure": { + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.252707676666908e-14, + "initial_pressure_projection_error": 0.031278508422811546, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 8.137746368140481e-16 + } +} diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_craig_bampton_m64.npz b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_craig_bampton_m64.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4deba617a32cd10dc7e5bad23f9bebf9f4a57907 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_craig_bampton_m64.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:8e2a012d1e49949a0097cf68858c0b273b8e188ca7fca7ddbece4e67d6a08c9c +size 1009597 diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_full.json b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_full.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b2ee878f725656e5c71b2889158d96a113e7dadd --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_full.json @@ -0,0 +1,61 @@ +{ + "grid": 32, + "method": "full_separable", + "dimension": 1024, + "config_sha256": "0ad770a71f1b04bf823f6d98e48e0458974b1c81fb43f49a6b863f12173be883", + "receiver_total_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.1438031376064089, + "per_source": [ + 0.11671791107710532, + 0.21039641761493427, + 0.13631681180888722 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.5581207492488209, + "per_source": [ + 0.4102342378584386, + 0.6153738908581777, + 0.5891397070740954 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_total_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.36574816769977747, + "per_source": [ + 0.26589341397279287, + 0.4049732419760213, + 0.4091061234788725 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.7727777776267758, + "per_source": [ + 0.6274106521269114, + 0.7812994044129351, + 0.8877724420268202 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.1447972914664671, + "per_source": [ + 0.13082904892148192, + 0.15556879885091535, + 0.147045422126639 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.14462819580723923, + "per_source": [ + 0.13046429632888445, + 0.1552832704275592, + 0.14709029866057055 + ] + } + }, + "minimum_subcell_squared_norm": 0.006277023652617286 +} diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_full_receiver.npz b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_full_receiver.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..bb2de208d3fa0ee3c4e5b8d82b9c71b61fd75d71 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_full_receiver.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:d1dac1d07c4f5e28ed19dbfce3df42242fd2a947991bb6b9210a4f726e2d98ed +size 60993 diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_full_spectrum.npz b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_full_spectrum.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ad23c0109c94843fc46d787114871a38dca1d7e3 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_full_spectrum.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:c4cebbc0e2c040cb18740b73aaae9e2d6a89c1c1f5a20e56e9bdf82bf65ba7a4 +size 4927782 diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_rational_krylov_m128.json b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_rational_krylov_m128.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..955392bf16740a9fac8c5cc579b74b478c127696 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_rational_krylov_m128.json @@ -0,0 +1,108 @@ +{ + "grid": 32, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "dimension": 288, + "config_sha256": "0ad770a71f1b04bf823f6d98e48e0458974b1c81fb43f49a6b863f12173be883", + "receiver_total_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.1438032906814237, + "per_source": [ + 0.11671801259213138, + 0.21039502978551194, + 0.13631739168277093 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.5581186755287815, + "per_source": [ + 0.41023404261713525, + 0.6153578196560663, + 0.5891392384306925 + ] + } + }, + "receiver_same_grid_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 4.167702632436727e-05, + "per_source": [ + 5.508647386954302e-06, + 0.00010112569003567727, + 2.7649938593936855e-05 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.000943990933941447, + "per_source": [ + 4.158441545594296e-05, + 0.001981355736255059, + 0.0008634002466127744 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_total_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.3657458975380163, + "per_source": [ + 0.2658934556156724, + 0.40496764222117404, + 0.4091055346628183 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.772789957184767, + "per_source": [ + 0.6274106777653033, + 0.7813518992273994, + 0.8877581212431342 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_same_grid_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.0044194815736991605, + "per_source": [ + 0.0001718589715579761, + 0.0074063153773772546, + 0.0020048355633091094 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.028404505184990755, + "per_source": [ + 0.0015252596279821601, + 0.037588827228459604, + 0.03179276950356076 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.1447972914664671, + "per_source": [ + 0.13082904892148192, + 0.15556879885091535, + 0.147045422126639 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.14462819580723923, + "per_source": [ + 0.13046429632888445, + 0.1552832704275592, + 0.14709029866057055 + ] + } + }, + "receiver_reduction_grid_error_cosine": { + "T2": 0.0035517639597581674, + "T8": -0.0030810361582888335 + }, + "structure": { + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.457727222308856e-14, + "initial_pressure_projection_error": 6.313017842920001e-16, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 6.719430761812626e-15, + "iterations": 50, + "distinct_shift_factorizations": 12 + } +} diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_rational_krylov_m128.npz b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_rational_krylov_m128.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1b9c3f44f7d65925d38b31c3493c5836a5ffcdcf --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_rational_krylov_m128.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:1fa73557e12a4b6c85251c79847715b5c95f1034801c60602b85d7f7294e8e69 +size 2325828 diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_rational_krylov_m32.json b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_rational_krylov_m32.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2fefc7507cb437124cd3c5d9b053baa0eaa50330 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_rational_krylov_m32.json @@ -0,0 +1,108 @@ +{ + "grid": 32, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "modes_per_patch": 32, + "dimension": 96, + "config_sha256": "0ad770a71f1b04bf823f6d98e48e0458974b1c81fb43f49a6b863f12173be883", + "receiver_total_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.14326569336048547, + "per_source": [ + 0.11672401713399215, + 0.21960958907811434, + 0.132943966575728 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.5540243977958785, + "per_source": [ + 0.41149124811924476, + 0.6081845793619582, + 0.5842663540202705 + ] + } + }, + "receiver_same_grid_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.031880217458453715, + "per_source": [ + 0.00949194421571582, + 0.05514794764388196, + 0.03046566019973976 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.06565225776685694, + "per_source": [ + 0.027101692464106486, + 0.11122105713131053, + 0.06568789304557793 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_total_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.35991322857649954, + "per_source": [ + 0.2648664434135751, + 0.39514059241602817, + 0.40378161059547657 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.7685692416368883, + "per_source": [ + 0.6264277238974959, + 0.7761207645895403, + 0.8820194020809368 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_same_grid_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.15194501941812516, + "per_source": [ + 0.033075467928710425, + 0.1743093922436484, + 0.19500088424565074 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.24019074527357517, + "per_source": [ + 0.09760886992979366, + 0.285410267575503, + 0.28691208512849764 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.1447972914664671, + "per_source": [ + 0.13082904892148192, + 0.15556879885091535, + 0.147045422126639 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.14462819580723923, + "per_source": [ + 0.13046429632888445, + 0.1552832704275592, + 0.14709029866057055 + ] + } + }, + "receiver_reduction_grid_error_cosine": { + "T2": -0.127091868193705, + "T8": -0.12112038560821135 + }, + "structure": { + "orthonormality_frobenius": 7.355854255362048e-15, + "initial_pressure_projection_error": 4.4256603346013004e-16, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 6.6718353788011854e-15, + "iterations": 17, + "distinct_shift_factorizations": 12 + } +} diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_rational_krylov_m32.npz b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_rational_krylov_m32.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3199ea49d209621adc0025cbac820c8d2e9bbc84 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n32_rational_krylov_m32.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:375298d1483b0c4625ac27b176f8f2afab2646d585a97bc6907cbf96be93e1d7 +size 795900 diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/n64_craig_bampton_m128.json b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n64_craig_bampton_m128.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..79fe3f847c18674fdcdb86d479dd1f7999460514 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n64_craig_bampton_m128.json @@ -0,0 +1,106 @@ +{ + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "dimension": 320, + "config_sha256": "0ad770a71f1b04bf823f6d98e48e0458974b1c81fb43f49a6b863f12173be883", + "receiver_total_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.03648395575881618, + "per_source": [ + 0.02518251638314019, + 0.04778078223168211, + 0.036901537663673066 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.16668995523789423, + "per_source": [ + 0.09567027006956237, + 0.20008655166286168, + 0.17867824215990752 + ] + } + }, + "receiver_same_grid_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.007383244876723025, + "per_source": [ + 0.006396036688453257, + 0.014611772305958323, + 0.0055605627015699 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.025374988097779827, + "per_source": [ + 0.025515855984826672, + 0.05417005954000364, + 0.017975451280599207 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_total_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.12131392838291599, + "per_source": [ + 0.08475395815615017, + 0.13633623132015107, + 0.135903497618664 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.3138574623328249, + "per_source": [ + 0.2065120584989883, + 0.3340683547456003, + 0.3761202113139949 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_same_grid_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.05354995021055477, + "per_source": [ + 0.019840526680352983, + 0.0761147898180393, + 0.04942301268513637 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.11134141589581142, + "per_source": [ + 0.06167414039140214, + 0.1476696734137708, + 0.10787749988954067 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.0729420040698602, + "per_source": [ + 0.06575323032430258, + 0.07845741921253732, + 0.07411683845582737 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.07285759245275009, + "per_source": [ + 0.06556712996016423, + 0.07830905589037153, + 0.07414742094681469 + ] + } + }, + "receiver_reduction_grid_error_cosine": { + "T2": -0.3551047215661291, + "T8": -0.5645134693328314 + }, + "structure": { + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.3889126557209942e-14, + "initial_pressure_projection_error": 0.01608323650344019, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 2.1572873886031787e-15 + } +} diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/n64_craig_bampton_m128.npz b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n64_craig_bampton_m128.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c5e52ed9a7dd269714ad9cabe178b1143a69da1c --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n64_craig_bampton_m128.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:4a4089662219c97e4ee6228f16c2166bd28183754794359e5a3943fadf96c850 +size 81447 diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/n64_craig_bampton_m32.json b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n64_craig_bampton_m32.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ae5acf776c02497607b65be1d9d7eb2d152daeb7 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n64_craig_bampton_m32.json @@ -0,0 +1,106 @@ +{ + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 32, + "dimension": 128, + "config_sha256": "0ad770a71f1b04bf823f6d98e48e0458974b1c81fb43f49a6b863f12173be883", + "receiver_total_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.3051890352277107, + "per_source": [ + 0.08055772172423419, + 0.5324265552518879, + 0.2907369494484924 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.35654839778590985, + "per_source": [ + 0.24176084764851993, + 0.6161572551943769, + 0.3367865230250964 + ] + } + }, + "receiver_same_grid_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.29292377738212433, + "per_source": [ + 0.09823503845039401, + 0.5180037411081249, + 0.2749951698983142 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.36697608041219193, + "per_source": [ + 0.31671290775757993, + 0.6607852943641999, + 0.32182011114238557 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_total_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.4623643507229158, + "per_source": [ + 0.22697135569750743, + 0.5387869474384657, + 0.5490740630944106 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.5850600438848421, + "per_source": [ + 0.41072984954063513, + 0.6664299260316406, + 0.6440245736612991 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_same_grid_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.46246706758666445, + "per_source": [ + 0.23223435216208727, + 0.5422034041657525, + 0.5436894359716031 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.6281840463972442, + "per_source": [ + 0.48810252817476807, + 0.7343328274593617, + 0.6381978908250769 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.0729420040698602, + "per_source": [ + 0.06575323032430258, + 0.07845741921253732, + 0.07411683845582737 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.07285759245275009, + "per_source": [ + 0.06556712996016423, + 0.07830905589037153, + 0.07414742094681469 + ] + } + }, + "receiver_reduction_grid_error_cosine": { + "T2": 0.27404345614731107, + "T8": -0.2907527318992064 + }, + "structure": { + "orthonormality_frobenius": 8.767792418701268e-15, + "initial_pressure_projection_error": 0.1510567573458609, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 1.4857276164109663e-15 + } +} diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/n64_craig_bampton_m32.npz b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n64_craig_bampton_m32.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..da024354eeb557ca02c1f6293ac677d3315972d9 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n64_craig_bampton_m32.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:cdc235dd0e95af362d9915054a213b175fc1ea0f0a9153a8f6f7177cfc240501 +size 69719 diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/n64_craig_bampton_m64.json b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n64_craig_bampton_m64.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4eabd6327eb0e3d8928c7e0890ae58ec7dbbb012 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n64_craig_bampton_m64.json @@ -0,0 +1,106 @@ +{ + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 64, + "dimension": 192, + "config_sha256": "0ad770a71f1b04bf823f6d98e48e0458974b1c81fb43f49a6b863f12173be883", + "receiver_total_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.045574705666799956, + "per_source": [ + 0.017205570918439838, + 0.07360365951197233, + 0.04470692539407724 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.14776960566595224, + "per_source": [ + 0.058443794126019084, + 0.14638699475197325, + 0.1663641585638416 + ] + } + }, + "receiver_same_grid_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.03829238439723997, + "per_source": [ + 0.02513907710812743, + 0.08084042141607987, + 0.028740393111761138 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.10407901138983204, + "per_source": [ + 0.09211140459564125, + 0.2315559611951526, + 0.07501154556933423 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_total_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.18829846966068872, + "per_source": [ + 0.09172974067117076, + 0.2554712213304719, + 0.18154019475897806 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.2726969329064572, + "per_source": [ + 0.1617782014754543, + 0.295211482518923, + 0.33157235256197 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_same_grid_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.18337550974339023, + "per_source": [ + 0.07798720016901332, + 0.2603116289059545, + 0.16532864792656762 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.328370469666599, + "per_source": [ + 0.20825245704958817, + 0.4205071738374531, + 0.3220356413568922 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.0729420040698602, + "per_source": [ + 0.06575323032430258, + 0.07845741921253732, + 0.07411683845582737 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.07285759245275009, + "per_source": [ + 0.06556712996016423, + 0.07830905589037153, + 0.07414742094681469 + ] + } + }, + "receiver_reduction_grid_error_cosine": { + "T2": -0.29331178715547773, + "T8": -0.5685407138813241 + }, + "structure": { + "orthonormality_frobenius": 1.097022709186426e-14, + "initial_pressure_projection_error": 0.03465158551373023, + "constant_mode_projection_error": 1.7302020985173071e-15 + } +} diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/n64_craig_bampton_m64.npz b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n64_craig_bampton_m64.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f20c0273ff2fe393e0cc0e10fb22925896235dfe --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n64_craig_bampton_m64.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:063d471fefb73cc6f47e422b71ae2a0e7985f03b2e6a1c249c3d2444de21e037 +size 73556 diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/n64_full.json b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n64_full.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8232f3996c50f19f02c233d6139af1f30954d451 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n64_full.json @@ -0,0 +1,61 @@ +{ + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_separable", + "dimension": 4096, + "config_sha256": "0ad770a71f1b04bf823f6d98e48e0458974b1c81fb43f49a6b863f12173be883", + "receiver_total_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.03844467800718734, + "per_source": [ + 0.03033416961471965, + 0.05695449464329157, + 0.036459189189687304 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.1796183654246856, + "per_source": [ + 0.11602154381937523, + 0.23469156344483952, + 0.18702994739099238 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_total_error": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.1336076247371244, + "per_source": [ + 0.09184157913300431, + 0.1557533322336232, + 0.14479458349595312 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.35678824566693035, + "per_source": [ + 0.24436673532019693, + 0.39279174452769866, + 0.41005907200561525 + ] + } + }, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": { + "T2": { + "relative_error": 0.0729420040698602, + "per_source": [ + 0.06575323032430258, + 0.07845741921253732, + 0.07411683845582737 + ] + }, + "T8": { + "relative_error": 0.07285759245275009, + "per_source": [ + 0.06556712996016423, + 0.07830905589037153, + 0.07414742094681469 + ] + } + }, + "minimum_subcell_squared_norm": 0.001588601272219492 +} diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/n64_full_receiver.npz b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n64_full_receiver.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7e4de115265477a4babe871c7070e8dbfb8f3f17 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/n64_full_receiver.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:6153ab003587a12ea8836f82faf322cbc995cef642ba314d72357d98579dc5b3 +size 60983 diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/output_manifest.json b/unequal_speed_interface/results/output_manifest.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4bf66c6d2760a398ec4e6ee22cbecac966c2c452 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/output_manifest.json @@ -0,0 +1,63 @@ +{ + "run_scope": "Three grids, nine CB models, two n=32 RK controls; modal attribution at n=32.", + "reference_scope": "For each transverse index 0<=l<=16, retain the first 21 continuous Sturm-Liouville modes m=0,...,20. Project the Gaussian pressure in the beta inner product, remove only the global constant mode, and normalize to unit initial acoustic energy. The resulting finite expansion defines the initial pressure independently of the propagation grid; initial velocity is zero.", + "verification_passed": true, + "modal_validation_passed": true, + "source_hashes": { + "verify_outputs.py": "40c267025561dd351f857317ffb6ec61c72629bf3257fb542f77fa5342d1d5fd", + "modal.py": "19aeef09aa5a83f04de20e9dad0a6be716662419323d3bfa16df4627af65721d", + "analyze.py": "c1e71be0b500ac809b712b3d5dbabf2588592b265c074c517b497c458c89dcd4", + "verify.py": "1fb4f971f73de3ce50cd9f5956df7bfad95b9773628bd3bb53b182abc2cfe517", + "io.py": "9c0fcc08fdc766599d3ba8020e0794b5006af48c0dfea3d2e6951d6500be815e", + "kernel.py": "2cf14b5caaba8adb20d5b9732a8648a4bfc23aa53553f51535a5a93d826036bc", + "run.py": "54e9509b36ea1fcd821ead8be545ad513da7f5a5474abf0a3dacee9f5bf3e73c", + "config.json": "0ad770a71f1b04bf823f6d98e48e0458974b1c81fb43f49a6b863f12173be883" + }, + "artifact_hashes": { + "results/n32_full_spectrum.npz": "c4cebbc0e2c040cb18740b73aaae9e2d6a89c1c1f5a20e56e9bdf82bf65ba7a4", + "results/n128_full_receiver.npz": "bcd910ad0b1b2b0e3256f3b002d24a09d1083c437bda6783f7e13207652dd656", + "results/n32_full_receiver.npz": "d1dac1d07c4f5e28ed19dbfce3df42242fd2a947991bb6b9210a4f726e2d98ed", + "results/n128_craig_bampton_m64.npz": "a6faf04acddd72bef513b4fd91a2ca918ad881d760ab7d9c6b92411c8d0b6564", + "results/n64_full_receiver.npz": "6153ab003587a12ea8836f82faf322cbc995cef642ba314d72357d98579dc5b3", + "results/n128_craig_bampton_m128.npz": "6cfa63714fa30b47cc21c51977cb8099bb5cdd5ad46158f037c76f647b332284", + "results/n64_craig_bampton_m64.npz": "063d471fefb73cc6f47e422b71ae2a0e7985f03b2e6a1c249c3d2444de21e037", + "results/n32_rational_krylov_m32.npz": "375298d1483b0c4625ac27b176f8f2afab2646d585a97bc6907cbf96be93e1d7", + "results/n64_craig_bampton_m32.npz": "cdc235dd0e95af362d9915054a213b175fc1ea0f0a9153a8f6f7177cfc240501", + "results/n64_craig_bampton_m128.npz": "4a4089662219c97e4ee6228f16c2166bd28183754794359e5a3943fadf96c850", + "results/n32_craig_bampton_m32.npz": "b930bb8d22bd1dbf1517a4fbc0f1d70e78ea5136604afd6ac56d41c025776c96", + "results/n32_craig_bampton_m128.npz": "cad5c056b0d489e8cecffbf646e72b4cc3c14f8aa23973fb5a1d7b49daeb3163", + "results/n32_rational_krylov_m128.npz": "1fa73557e12a4b6c85251c79847715b5c95f1034801c60602b85d7f7294e8e69", + "results/n32_craig_bampton_m64.npz": "8e2a012d1e49949a0097cf68858c0b273b8e188ca7fca7ddbece4e67d6a08c9c", + "results/n128_craig_bampton_m32.npz": "81fe487d13285fd7ae41e5d0a5efc4a4257208b0cddb08f22eb896e323c0a232", + "results/n64_craig_bampton_m64.json": "dcb774d0a1d26e7f3432aef915b0ad61722b59c6739746a022ae006c9fe260a7", + "results/n128_craig_bampton_m128.json": "06abf03ffec5fd0ca93ed716e0deb6ecf368c97e6759c7307361c4e20bda281f", + "results/n128_craig_bampton_m64.json": "97b8e9c65ac5b7de01ef426ac863b8c52034c0565c8383cf2c387a5d7372c7ec", + "results/n32_rational_krylov_m128.json": "0790bd55bf8130b045e322e1eefd48aa97ac2b61c68e41ff072c1cdf4a4b1d6e", + "results/n32_craig_bampton_m128.json": "8cd869864e9145a9ddc76ebef1e669066d0a94efaa1a91919fd82f6f053fe905", + "results/n32_craig_bampton_m64.json": "edad7d9c21ba6f118412be6cc57fc5211dab59ac71781740e2fffbfed0d071ad", + "results/n32_rational_krylov_m32.json": "9443adf2a3833e6f5aabbd710fac4cfe49e4da2888ed2debedb746ab55c0559f", + "results/n32_craig_bampton_m32.json": "7c92b32454540b8226972b963797376319439fd6b2b82a2baa0152f1a648dc78", + "results/n128_full.json": "7d5a2b6208a3c4da44efed6bc390d4f66a9bc393e15ee2d76c8c2af49a86e85f", + "results/n64_craig_bampton_m128.json": "9120bffc9db8bb95c03b741327f823c771a744a991667af439bfd11016ad1b35", + "results/n32_full.json": "ee8591e3b582401f23288ce9965a2a48df2d94c5029a88006cea9819e4e22d44", + "results/n128_craig_bampton_m32.json": "e11fc6c75bc303f6220d3a242ca8fbf23107b5bb474377c539d10ea6805f58e6", + "results/n64_craig_bampton_m32.json": "f73931e98c1fa0e0f887741dadb809c5adc47c66e772819e17f39f8be378fa97", + "results/n64_full.json": "50d5ed36b9156799054104a53a6e33d7e47681861df1730f984d181a33cdb56c", + "results/modal_component_gram.csv": "2db1c5a2c2dc7dffae79d34a8f09e48a63560e5254151b7e73555a55ac354ebe", + "results/receiver_time_windows.csv": "5a4c98ecb7a1aa2bc79f7cdaf7c024a2ca1e7f1f91322589055caa86d90960ea", + "results/summary.csv": "9bf7a1fba6cf59612fae9ed00ac52ad4e16b02ab490647494a90fad62baa296f", + "results/modal_summary.csv": "5fedc5cb99e08d77b274876bb9a14604b5d2e595d4f87f5b6f110556da191629", + "results/modal_pairs.csv": "091a9bba4ca9c25cd6f2b90df12c5a35ff7d9fce48639c6632bc5f96957fbae1", + "results/continuous_reference.npz": "ebf590c18039b353f5196be0cb49eaf114aa02a7f1005267403732c983010281", + "results/continuous_catalogue.npz": "fac59c08a2901e19fe665cb1932a855b7049cb4be2d6c2f33421198e0fa1a246", + "results/modal_summary.json": "0aade9b536266c853fc8e919ecb5a1c3c7a7f404d6e59efcbff9d82863263b76", + "results/modal_validation.json": "e91907f4f593681a361175aab471f7c4c91adf5da7366bccb80c7f8a47691ac6", + "results/summary.json": "e436cb1439b211ce4790b7097ca889baccab729fca03ef036983dc500fb0f8a3", + "results/verification.json": "9f9995fae516e00e0810ed1cfff75a44f6170208dc31b6b4bf846661bfe006ec", + "results/rational_krylov_m128_decomposition.npz": "eb469674a6852e8d7665dcdefa5f01316fcc7427ccbd7a5de7ede35fe172b7c4", + "results/craig_bampton_m128_decomposition.npz": "fabe0253451e7d88475d0d2995ea2b4b8d496628d675131d6e40aad361a78fca", + "results/craig_bampton_m32_decomposition.npz": "79e164d5bf6753536dd48ebd54977235cf68d12377e9261ba356d3603866b76a", + "results/rational_krylov_m32_decomposition.npz": "1e5a0dcd63b36a6bbf272a5fd4c44080e8d01fc0253b31e3d6c0105f4f1c1185", + "results/craig_bampton_m64_decomposition.npz": "56c41d6d42041ce4da4848ef3d104613ea2074401d521b9d7ab28689ad568e9d" + } +} diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/output_verification.json b/unequal_speed_interface/results/output_verification.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..871e8bc26ca7d6fa80c12214bd0e97128b5f16d8 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/output_verification.json @@ -0,0 +1,31 @@ +{ + "scope": "Independent checks from receiver traces and modal factors; no CB basis rebuild and no rerun of large-grid pressure histories.", + "expected_model_count": 14, + "model_count": 14, + "summary_csv_rows": 28, + "summary_json_rows": 28, + "modal_model_count": 5, + "matched_triples": { + "craig_bampton_m128": 35, + "craig_bampton_m32": 25, + "craig_bampton_m64": 32, + "rational_krylov_m128": 36, + "rational_krylov_m32": 32 + }, + "receiver_window_rows": 480, + "expected_receiver_window_rows": 480, + "source_hashes_checked": 8, + "artifact_hashes_checked": 45, + "hash_mismatches": [], + "receiver_total_statistic_max_absolute_defect": 0.0, + "receiver_same_grid_statistic_max_absolute_defect": 0.0, + "receiver_per_source_statistic_max_absolute_defect": 0.0, + "window_error_cosine_max_absolute_defect": 0.0, + "modal_budget_max_relative_defect": 9.268485500049619e-17, + "frequency_terms_reconstructed_max_normalized_defect": 3.398204241727135e-16, + "counterfactual_reconstructed_max_normalized_defect": 3.557281557227375e-16, + "modal_statistics_max_absolute_defect": 1.6653345369377348e-16, + "component_gram_max_absolute_defect": 2.7755575615628914e-17, + "receiver_window_statistics_max_absolute_defect": 0.0, + "passed": true +} diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/rational_krylov_m128_decomposition.npz b/unequal_speed_interface/results/rational_krylov_m128_decomposition.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..70d5cf031d38b1f65fca2466dd0cd66840428d33 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/rational_krylov_m128_decomposition.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:eb469674a6852e8d7665dcdefa5f01316fcc7427ccbd7a5de7ede35fe172b7c4 +size 575496 diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/rational_krylov_m32_decomposition.npz b/unequal_speed_interface/results/rational_krylov_m32_decomposition.npz new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7ac241a4acb1f59733002d92432955ef533c226b --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/rational_krylov_m32_decomposition.npz @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:1e5a0dcd63b36a6bbf272a5fd4c44080e8d01fc0253b31e3d6c0105f4f1c1185 +size 590738 diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/receiver_time_windows.csv b/unequal_speed_interface/results/receiver_time_windows.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ef563960fb0e8b4798f17b0696e38a69e349791c --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/receiver_time_windows.csv @@ -0,0 +1,481 @@ +model,window_type,start,end,source,receiver,original_error,coarse_replacement_error,coarse_replacement_change_percentage_points,reference_squared_norm +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,2.0,1,1,0.1283322768175279,0.13061129360599463,0.22790167884667312,145.36404191772687 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,2.0,2,1,0.1298449579903871,0.13204289328487318,0.21979352944860864,79.1821087227972 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,2.0,3,1,0.22804234443274074,0.22789070378228446,-0.015164065045628061,10.443931721361103 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,2.0,1,2,0.108461055904724,0.10981619527696873,0.13551393722447264,200.3506097672743 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,2.0,2,2,0.22480537739201073,0.2250896887248808,0.028431133287007415,162.17036326825183 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,2.0,3,2,0.1559917099938463,0.15625849276207268,0.026678276822639235,1695.9755455201557 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,2.0,1,3,0.0877815230908725,0.08823373905948984,0.045221596861733104,172.40780056855291 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,2.0,2,3,0.11580421406058011,0.11830036691207055,0.24961528514904352,67.56351414347115 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,2.0,3,3,0.14053047641793046,0.14072666837230463,0.019619195437417525,6.728799547400598 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,2.0,1,4,0.12720789259110302,0.12899663025455052,0.17887376634475038,240.7277545777776 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,2.0,2,4,0.24832976135131726,0.24943133114657448,0.11015697952572179,159.31078762376222 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,2.0,3,4,0.09149759267597683,0.0916439551840643,0.014636250808747198,999.9510095642174 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,4.0,1,1,0.16255878327899564,0.16365436983956133,0.10955865605656867,253.67180461894017 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,4.0,2,1,0.23459352563264216,0.2375949756863107,0.30014500536685307,113.65018352505747 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,4.0,3,1,0.2824930208260531,0.28354269258511877,0.10496717590656734,29.437431906287554 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,4.0,1,2,0.1894243979054265,0.19153697704128372,0.21125791358572177,532.8963522387351 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,4.0,2,2,0.3624167852148772,0.36266611187361397,0.02493266587367815,269.6705203622069 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,4.0,3,2,0.4465833599650174,0.44725099788052236,0.06676379155049483,3786.255909354872 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,4.0,1,3,0.1954402257066748,0.1975996966088491,0.21594709021743042,359.4033894116711 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,4.0,2,3,0.2594769667933506,0.2646812405838556,0.5204273790505032,132.98275793048046 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,4.0,3,3,0.2730247692219511,0.2742781960804537,0.12534268585025488,17.4540658068878 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,4.0,1,4,0.2519645963602426,0.2553634809157495,0.3398884555506909,486.4477960629689 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,4.0,2,4,0.3826513821754053,0.3833928834433435,0.07415012679382049,270.29468666776506 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,4.0,3,4,0.24092290822505236,0.24112436872216714,0.020146049711478042,1862.6893956197134 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,6.0,1,1,0.29347067150213546,0.2965592585717543,0.3088587069618842,366.45210699047067 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,6.0,2,1,0.37479466017262947,0.3823989103567277,0.7604250184098216,153.0916117298096 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,6.0,3,1,0.5444884798618664,0.5470604990578771,0.25720191960106886,37.86061435144624 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,6.0,1,2,0.38001162666679594,0.3854065361828556,0.5394909516059643,680.6977791585563 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,6.0,2,2,0.6376212697382145,0.6393907184587048,0.17694487204902298,424.2871178397254 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,6.0,3,2,0.5246762363052507,0.5252534835257384,0.05772472204876866,6526.37378535195 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,6.0,1,3,0.2555326602215531,0.2579115993811174,0.23789391595643306,463.63748898957897 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,6.0,2,3,0.360274380152048,0.3653152799399334,0.5040899787885411,172.72482588374487 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,6.0,3,3,0.5022137519396517,0.5029914996708034,0.077774773115169,28.3599909356418 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,6.0,1,4,0.33690642889028877,0.3410476938028063,0.41412649125175394,935.6561469785913 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,6.0,2,4,0.5349544703849265,0.5390239554120562,0.4069485027129671,452.4378414100233 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,6.0,3,4,0.2864578361225079,0.28649786139599226,0.004002527348434537,2328.3305885148125 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,8.0,1,1,0.4404803790568847,0.44535770284484416,0.48773237879594644,494.69428041273386 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,8.0,2,1,0.5205517985926893,0.5286238223072872,0.807202371459792,178.72327852524703 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,8.0,3,1,0.47685482023363773,0.4792915634217851,0.243674318814735,61.37735588186157 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,8.0,1,2,0.3836260460324595,0.38899003839620766,0.5363992363748182,1186.859962414774 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,8.0,2,2,0.7255454973987209,0.7276910272301791,0.2145529831458215,566.8492940774136 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,8.0,3,2,0.6519684539601349,0.6525255866277351,0.055713266760015756,8382.145509381835 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,8.0,1,3,0.29789798954236785,0.30078634562562023,0.2888356083252386,561.2536955901165 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,8.0,2,3,0.4082252447661519,0.41546176495098125,0.7236520184829343,208.2216404581095 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,8.0,3,3,0.6813908206582372,0.6817425554435101,0.03517347852729502,34.93069631518288 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,8.0,1,4,0.44345952788561993,0.4479132348498719,0.4453706964251958,1354.292680262663 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,8.0,2,4,0.5765245637637723,0.5806404425290892,0.4115878765316938,646.0333572693044 +craig_bampton_m128,cumulative,0.0,8.0,3,4,0.35600132823239083,0.3561854468738848,0.018411864149397994,2976.411780513511 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,0.0,2.0,1,1,0.1283322768175279,0.13061129360599463,0.22790167884667312,145.36404191772687 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,0.0,2.0,2,1,0.1298449579903871,0.13204289328487318,0.21979352944860864,79.1821087227972 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,0.0,2.0,3,1,0.22804234443274074,0.22789070378228446,-0.015164065045628061,10.443931721361103 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,0.0,2.0,1,2,0.108461055904724,0.10981619527696873,0.13551393722447264,200.3506097672743 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,0.0,2.0,2,2,0.22480537739201073,0.2250896887248808,0.028431133287007415,162.17036326825183 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,0.0,2.0,3,2,0.1559917099938463,0.15625849276207268,0.026678276822639235,1695.9755455201557 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,0.0,2.0,1,3,0.0877815230908725,0.08823373905948984,0.045221596861733104,172.40780056855291 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,0.0,2.0,2,3,0.11580421406058011,0.11830036691207055,0.24961528514904352,67.56351414347115 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,0.0,2.0,3,3,0.14053047641793046,0.14072666837230463,0.019619195437417525,6.728799547400598 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,0.0,2.0,1,4,0.12720789259110302,0.12899663025455052,0.17887376634475038,240.7277545777776 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,0.0,2.0,2,4,0.24832976135131726,0.24943133114657448,0.11015697952572179,159.31078762376222 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,0.0,2.0,3,4,0.09149759267597683,0.0916439551840643,0.014636250808747198,999.9510095642174 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,2.0,4.0,1,1,0.19845788923127025,0.1985797395819642,0.012185035069395278,109.63181516227553 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,2.0,4.0,2,1,0.3711124370563773,0.37545133707269124,0.4338900016313929,35.73701162313534 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,2.0,4.0,3,1,0.3088055025071751,0.3103593689976737,0.1553866490498601,19.032432468094193 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,2.0,4.0,1,2,0.2252823992895818,0.22776581392833425,0.2483414638752457,332.6255027237516 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,2.0,4.0,2,2,0.5024961093988254,0.5027498396398408,0.02537302410153819,108.42193903259285 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,2.0,4.0,3,2,0.5841443661685336,0.5850107362636319,0.08663700950982678,2092.099443124436 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,2.0,4.0,1,3,0.25428034719772924,0.25725250374845715,0.29721565507279113,191.7964176201063 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,2.0,4.0,2,3,0.35072719353836534,0.357704101329369,0.6976907791003628,65.43033131435551 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,2.0,4.0,3,3,0.3283655804180184,0.32999273596353473,0.16271555455163456,10.834376530427265 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,2.0,4.0,1,4,0.3316035642373288,0.3360491525761778,0.4445588338849005,245.8883277270492 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,2.0,4.0,2,4,0.5177917282995079,0.5183773766838193,0.05856483843114102,111.0535128739926 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,2.0,4.0,3,4,0.3400444263121017,0.3403093440084145,0.026491769631281636,862.8754423088498 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,4.0,6.0,1,1,0.466322923831631,0.47172808437816843,0.5405160546537446,114.38074528327584 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,4.0,6.0,2,1,0.6211869390772405,0.6356804175148233,1.4493478437582752,39.52671804127072 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,4.0,6.0,3,1,1.0273840286338192,1.0324217587432856,0.5037730109466398,8.48487256644457 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,4.0,6.0,1,2,0.7296770004342195,0.7405460665008091,1.086906606658966,148.8683048904344 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,4.0,6.0,2,2,0.9422639066418436,0.945361147055562,0.3097240413718394,154.61713320452222 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,4.0,6.0,3,2,0.6159641877754328,0.6164656957624185,0.0501507986985672,2745.0454487645356 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,4.0,6.0,1,3,0.3926266936800322,0.39570570584738873,0.30790121673565096,107.43060184629043 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,4.0,6.0,2,3,0.5800620339932676,0.5859689027028772,0.5906868709609547,40.53405130257632 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,4.0,6.0,3,3,0.7307124111792295,0.7313446632385393,0.06322520593098346,10.960614901788274 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,4.0,6.0,1,4,0.4131668365863216,0.41804228222412937,0.4875445637807785,449.2228297809578 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,4.0,6.0,2,4,0.702511393889366,0.7096061057546802,0.7094711865314185,182.1614527819628 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,4.0,6.0,3,4,0.4221341783717869,0.4218110746634979,-0.03231037082890298,465.67477613311735 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,6.0,8.0,1,1,0.7123981254345995,0.7205069285960618,0.8108803161462341,128.58500365932827 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,6.0,8.0,2,1,1.0251693265129298,1.0371551646095212,1.1985838096591372,25.63177965913173 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,6.0,8.0,3,1,0.3413153912388818,0.3436066051603967,0.22912139215148786,23.567125413197505 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,6.0,8.0,1,2,0.3889034476981161,0.3942484172772973,0.5344969579181236,507.2408954781128 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,6.0,8.0,2,2,0.9414529069260383,0.9444514427407159,0.2998535814677572,142.5695922878412 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,6.0,8.0,3,2,0.9712430501220102,0.9718309149199553,0.05878647979451479,1872.594578074092 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,6.0,8.0,1,3,0.4398500485615601,0.4443699823475713,0.45199337860111766,100.97117162918848 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,6.0,8.0,2,3,0.5879092749621824,0.6023218256919466,1.4412550729764217,35.540667292636265 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,6.0,8.0,3,3,1.1802099680975744,1.1798749824004873,-0.03349856970871201,6.571486110460263 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,6.0,8.0,1,4,0.6214761423929323,0.6268355189034027,0.535937651047047,418.64770184341813 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,6.0,8.0,2,4,0.6641929450561905,0.6685262035215588,0.43332584653682504,193.616366707088 +craig_bampton_m128,successive,6.0,8.0,3,4,0.5357333996233934,0.5362138626354592,0.048046301206583486,648.8845214469409 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,2.0,1,1,0.08356243532769697,0.12519088280440022,4.1628447476703245,145.36404191772687 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,2.0,2,1,0.08219378367319115,0.12519723583503986,4.300345216184871,79.1821087227972 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,2.0,3,1,0.2604537091889586,0.2642214712115923,0.37677620226336805,10.443931721361103 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,2.0,1,2,0.07365136689963167,0.09852177988827143,2.4870412988639763,200.3506097672743 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,2.0,2,2,0.445422242009072,0.4490599504082514,0.3637708399179429,162.17036326825183 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,2.0,3,2,0.2910388355310029,0.2903461875865953,-0.06926479444075984,1695.9755455201557 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,2.0,1,3,0.060419672120337074,0.07203847368960423,1.1618801569267152,172.40780056855291 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,2.0,2,3,0.07928782827055217,0.09712748850464964,1.783966023409747,67.56351414347115 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,2.0,3,3,0.19416246050170072,0.1935944957497676,-0.0567964751933131,6.728799547400598 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,2.0,1,4,0.07657526487227614,0.11087695361582872,3.4301688743552576,240.7277545777776 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,2.0,2,4,0.4406652987858355,0.4465285528188629,0.5863254033027399,159.31078762376222 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,2.0,3,4,0.1657156707336411,0.16919885292411646,0.3483182190475359,999.9510095642174 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,4.0,1,1,0.1441595530390177,0.170732360903641,2.657280786462329,253.67180461894017 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,4.0,2,1,0.17324234033545763,0.20263451442091573,2.9392174085458107,113.65018352505747 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,4.0,3,1,0.28057034956457605,0.28386986310576007,0.3299513541184018,29.437431906287554 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,4.0,1,2,0.11419637223779648,0.14683414453720006,3.263777229940358,532.8963522387351 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,4.0,2,2,0.6423471644553322,0.6436126827033121,0.12655182479798244,269.6705203622069 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,4.0,3,2,0.4644345609542146,0.47090368387803827,0.6469122923823678,3786.255909354872 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,4.0,1,3,0.1051527182055186,0.1512161473575175,4.606342915199892,359.4033894116711 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,4.0,2,3,0.14070320317032428,0.20378941332557945,6.308621015525517,132.98275793048046 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,4.0,3,3,0.2811145592871397,0.30755600069347455,2.6441441406334865,17.4540658068878 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,4.0,1,4,0.15310789984322265,0.23965065006145725,8.65427502182346,486.4477960629689 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,4.0,2,4,0.4242949672715771,0.4490371881051456,2.4742220833568473,270.29468666776506 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,4.0,3,4,0.2484077378892837,0.2565936406197326,0.8185902730448918,1862.6893956197134 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,6.0,1,1,0.1991327236937058,0.2633485891018577,6.421586540815191,366.45210699047067 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,6.0,2,1,0.21453452150331265,0.32649092475220043,11.195640324888778,153.0916117298096 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,6.0,3,1,0.38925817022401293,0.4300416725946522,4.078350237063927,37.86061435144624 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,6.0,1,2,0.17339150948285625,0.30944486402603594,13.605335454317968,680.6977791585563 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,6.0,2,2,0.6951675359403635,0.7018125120486802,0.6644976108316714,424.2871178397254 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,6.0,3,2,0.5462302124510053,0.5603674226385247,1.4137210187519345,6526.37378535195 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,6.0,1,3,0.14549720102380231,0.20670988868446624,6.121268766066393,463.63748898957897 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,6.0,2,3,0.1813775170528736,0.24020042752913207,5.882291047625846,172.72482588374487 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,6.0,3,3,0.4080574393258945,0.43372169532655286,2.566425600065836,28.3599909356418 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,6.0,1,4,0.1931252587222498,0.32767804638918546,13.455278766693565,935.6561469785913 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,6.0,2,4,0.4300586521847561,0.5232239482936494,9.31652961088933,452.4378414100233 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,6.0,3,4,0.2938452310700764,0.2971014782227003,0.32562471526239034,2328.3305885148125 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,8.0,1,1,0.27588856970669756,0.3770084634505919,10.111989374389434,494.69428041273386 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,8.0,2,1,0.27242809366824583,0.44957602490563886,17.7147931237393,178.72327852524703 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,8.0,3,1,0.34349742690496693,0.3826692379659008,3.9171811060933868,61.37735588186157 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,8.0,1,2,0.19063725937167697,0.31590196551254773,12.526470614087076,1186.859962414774 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,8.0,2,2,0.7296350310362839,0.7577725756657672,2.8137544629483258,566.8492940774136 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,8.0,3,2,0.6217044255670579,0.6362319174184895,1.452749185143165,8382.145509381835 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,8.0,1,3,0.1862149450547146,0.269939213545088,8.372426849037339,561.2536955901165 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,8.0,2,3,0.21276532683037633,0.3074033186170485,9.463799178667218,208.2216404581095 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,8.0,3,3,0.5442166748971392,0.5803807684552451,3.6164093558105903,34.93069631518288 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,8.0,1,4,0.25936626615491676,0.3909409394747635,13.157467331984673,1354.292680262663 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,8.0,2,4,0.45852112157928626,0.5486046188854186,9.00834973061323,646.0333572693044 +craig_bampton_m32,cumulative,0.0,8.0,3,4,0.3502977049794607,0.3527897160358842,0.24920110564234932,2976.411780513511 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,0.0,2.0,1,1,0.08356243532769697,0.12519088280440022,4.1628447476703245,145.36404191772687 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,0.0,2.0,2,1,0.08219378367319115,0.12519723583503986,4.300345216184871,79.1821087227972 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,0.0,2.0,3,1,0.2604537091889586,0.2642214712115923,0.37677620226336805,10.443931721361103 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,0.0,2.0,1,2,0.07365136689963167,0.09852177988827143,2.4870412988639763,200.3506097672743 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,0.0,2.0,2,2,0.445422242009072,0.4490599504082514,0.3637708399179429,162.17036326825183 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,0.0,2.0,3,2,0.2910388355310029,0.2903461875865953,-0.06926479444075984,1695.9755455201557 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,0.0,2.0,1,3,0.060419672120337074,0.07203847368960423,1.1618801569267152,172.40780056855291 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,0.0,2.0,2,3,0.07928782827055217,0.09712748850464964,1.783966023409747,67.56351414347115 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,0.0,2.0,3,3,0.19416246050170072,0.1935944957497676,-0.0567964751933131,6.728799547400598 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,0.0,2.0,1,4,0.07657526487227614,0.11087695361582872,3.4301688743552576,240.7277545777776 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,0.0,2.0,2,4,0.4406652987858355,0.4465285528188629,0.5863254033027399,159.31078762376222 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,0.0,2.0,3,4,0.1657156707336411,0.16919885292411646,0.3483182190475359,999.9510095642174 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,2.0,4.0,1,1,0.1970999969604061,0.2164386437447614,1.9338646784355318,109.63181516227553 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,2.0,4.0,2,1,0.28369300910748196,0.30971122208598606,2.6018212978504094,35.73701162313534 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,2.0,4.0,3,1,0.29102662604315127,0.294026974070239,0.3000348027087707,19.032432468094193 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,2.0,4.0,1,2,0.13333208032197114,0.17035945481004455,3.7027374488073415,332.6255027237516 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,2.0,4.0,2,2,0.854461782667391,0.8540622992533647,-0.03994834140262915,108.42193903259285 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,2.0,4.0,3,2,0.5695451194536654,0.5794686893347384,0.9923569881073013,2092.099443124436 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,2.0,4.0,1,3,0.1320540335625858,0.19545937363963323,6.3405340077047425,191.7964176201063 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,2.0,4.0,2,3,0.18374082604917505,0.2732516368147285,8.951081076555347,65.43033131435551 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,2.0,4.0,3,3,0.3226796333540722,0.35946897210346906,3.6789338749396885,10.834376530427265 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,2.0,4.0,1,4,0.20170002100016668,0.3188551625571127,11.715514155694603,245.8883277270492 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,2.0,4.0,2,4,0.3995016781541985,0.4524720921679824,5.297041401378388,111.0535128739926 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,2.0,4.0,3,4,0.31862401023438097,0.33020174028957555,1.157773005519458,862.8754423088498 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,4.0,6.0,1,1,0.2846020132691065,0.39710342708924506,11.250141382013856,114.38074528327584 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,4.0,6.0,2,1,0.303258059662265,0.5429716498854829,23.971359022321785,39.52671804127072 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,4.0,6.0,3,1,0.6367446277993896,0.7396971173816951,10.295248958230552,8.48487256644457 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,4.0,6.0,1,2,0.3013322668173037,0.600574246998582,29.92419801812783,148.8683048904344 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,4.0,6.0,2,2,0.7864383433098604,0.7990307213843921,1.259237807453173,154.61713320452222 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,4.0,6.0,3,2,0.6421774273260449,0.6643014236270223,2.212399630097739,2745.0454487645356 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,4.0,6.0,1,3,0.23318103483003352,0.328492595209302,9.53115603792685,107.43060184629043 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,4.0,6.0,2,3,0.2742905674489589,0.3326938867938863,5.840331934492737,40.53405130257632 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,4.0,6.0,3,3,0.5531374581022712,0.5801736693031259,2.7036211200854643,10.960614901788274 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,4.0,6.0,1,4,0.23137668220007848,0.4052123066168116,17.383562441673313,449.2228297809578 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,4.0,6.0,2,4,0.43846545730710756,0.6179262981403391,17.94608408332315,182.1614527819628 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,4.0,6.0,3,4,0.4300024001865745,0.42187553836966374,-0.8126861816910746,465.67477613311735 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,6.0,8.0,1,1,0.42510166415898354,0.5935461432660304,16.844447910704684,128.58500365932827 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,6.0,8.0,2,1,0.49255152633568716,0.8793681696261642,38.6816643290477,25.63177965913173 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,6.0,8.0,3,1,0.2542850126257436,0.29269819654054263,3.841318391479903,23.567125413197505 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,6.0,8.0,1,2,0.21224787819445431,0.3256829393020251,11.343506110757076,507.2408954781128 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,6.0,8.0,2,2,0.8241941679891528,0.9044124064827596,8.021823849360675,142.5695922878412 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,6.0,8.0,3,2,0.8308899593317063,0.8470938668988908,1.6203907567184483,1872.594578074092 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,6.0,8.0,1,3,0.3091397672607931,0.45789815179516885,14.875838453437574,100.97117162918848 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,6.0,8.0,2,3,0.32455876601046085,0.5231184327751547,19.855966676469382,35.540667292636265 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,6.0,8.0,3,3,0.9256073144925168,0.990948761401755,6.534144690923826,6.571486110460263 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,6.0,8.0,1,4,0.36649375169253723,0.507043328570167,14.054957687762975,418.64770184341813 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,6.0,8.0,2,4,0.5198358666633243,0.6074984581596551,8.766259149633083,193.616366707088 +craig_bampton_m32,successive,6.0,8.0,3,4,0.5030296933467611,0.5042679033533475,0.12382100065864154,648.8845214469409 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,2.0,1,1,0.11617573071937343,0.12855379389504584,1.2378063175672416,145.36404191772687 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,2.0,2,1,0.11405627919366425,0.12398392497764216,0.992764578397791,79.1821087227972 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,2.0,3,1,0.20684228322256015,0.20586678570218458,-0.09754975203755678,10.443931721361103 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,2.0,1,2,0.10068162323539499,0.10978475832487358,0.9103135089478589,200.3506097672743 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,2.0,2,2,0.21553299101324205,0.21750061296063938,0.196762194739733,162.17036326825183 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,2.0,3,2,0.15587356443823114,0.15725535819266548,0.13817937544343406,1695.9755455201557 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,2.0,1,3,0.08089223132819048,0.08326952225466218,0.23772909264716952,172.40780056855291 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,2.0,2,3,0.1001380230593783,0.10845237748687282,0.8314354427494521,67.56351414347115 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,2.0,3,3,0.12499059788533419,0.12743261625620228,0.24420183708680904,6.728799547400598 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,2.0,1,4,0.11441511401611727,0.1257556756862781,1.134056167016083,240.7277545777776 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,2.0,2,4,0.22242656952672063,0.22963952603278012,0.7212956506059492,159.31078762376222 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,2.0,3,4,0.09939464280929912,0.10015087839891129,0.07562355896121725,999.9510095642174 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,4.0,1,1,0.15567312787873985,0.16164941071003394,0.5976282831294089,253.67180461894017 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,4.0,2,1,0.21138423508997636,0.21781872156542756,0.6434486475451195,113.65018352505747 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,4.0,3,1,0.25997679186226474,0.2657144670936863,0.5737675231421546,29.437431906287554 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,4.0,1,2,0.17367204416926785,0.18712058408501603,1.344853991574818,532.8963522387351 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,4.0,2,2,0.3409784706992086,0.34296940834103506,0.19909376418264513,269.6705203622069 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,4.0,3,2,0.44172350155594875,0.44556983872421174,0.3846337168262992,3786.255909354872 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,4.0,1,3,0.176742550954562,0.18847621028413247,1.1733659329570463,359.4033894116711 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,4.0,2,3,0.22622494156399311,0.2450964000064127,1.887145844241958,132.98275793048046 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,4.0,3,3,0.2529428892975337,0.260329569260579,0.7386679963045262,17.4540658068878 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,4.0,1,4,0.23160327469893924,0.2524301099747221,2.082683527578286,486.4477960629689 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,4.0,2,4,0.353735877833101,0.3547453135274559,0.10094356943549099,270.29468666776506 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,4.0,3,4,0.2371319934329537,0.2383541370944398,0.1222143661486097,1862.6893956197134 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,6.0,1,1,0.2729687132571392,0.2908108684392322,1.7842155182093034,366.45210699047067 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,6.0,2,1,0.3315309694992204,0.36496752070454924,3.3436551205328846,153.0916117298096 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,6.0,3,1,0.505246540581644,0.5212776347706288,1.6031094188984851,37.86061435144624 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,6.0,1,2,0.3473225089018989,0.3808527321930155,3.35302232911166,680.6977791585563 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,6.0,2,2,0.5949432923566614,0.6057209890275504,1.0777696670889014,424.2871178397254 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,6.0,3,2,0.5226157563602472,0.5267274065960168,0.4111650235769648,6526.37378535195 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,6.0,1,3,0.23384034799856404,0.24610907083406394,1.2268722835499901,463.63748898957897 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,6.0,2,3,0.3179087652602365,0.33311137502316224,1.5202609762925756,172.72482588374487 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,6.0,3,3,0.4671587379235161,0.4711744681663915,0.4015730242875437,28.3599909356418 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,6.0,1,4,0.3094838614784575,0.33498286737704897,2.5499005898591443,935.6561469785913 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,6.0,2,4,0.4983233622288912,0.5213930887575379,2.3069726528646695,452.4378414100233 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,6.0,3,4,0.280801376719132,0.2809529777787777,0.01516010596456785,2328.3305885148125 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,8.0,1,1,0.4046287539494207,0.4323266585680514,2.76979046186307,494.69428041273386 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,8.0,2,1,0.4652281740690815,0.5029685185699595,3.7740344500877985,178.72327852524703 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,8.0,3,1,0.4487397104262318,0.4637453062204186,1.500559579418681,61.37735588186157 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,8.0,1,2,0.3507308078959477,0.38455039189486767,3.3819583998919986,1186.859962414774 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,8.0,2,2,0.6951411607136114,0.7050917221677088,0.995056145409734,566.8492940774136 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,8.0,3,2,0.652722187462917,0.6560747558198124,0.3352568356895458,8382.145509381835 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,8.0,1,3,0.27587598241749,0.29319378994368356,1.7317807526193552,561.2536955901165 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,8.0,2,3,0.3586527783635387,0.391004809836915,3.2352031473376286,208.2216404581095 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,8.0,3,3,0.6690221419820207,0.6706380871582448,0.16159451762240984,34.93069631518288 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,8.0,1,4,0.41035404630980293,0.43810102360213465,2.7746977292331723,1354.292680262663 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,8.0,2,4,0.5309807069878573,0.55483407572609,2.385336873823274,646.0333572693044 +craig_bampton_m64,cumulative,0.0,8.0,3,4,0.3473956100988795,0.35046936487344366,0.30737547745641747,2976.411780513511 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,0.0,2.0,1,1,0.11617573071937343,0.12855379389504584,1.2378063175672416,145.36404191772687 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,0.0,2.0,2,1,0.11405627919366425,0.12398392497764216,0.992764578397791,79.1821087227972 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,0.0,2.0,3,1,0.20684228322256015,0.20586678570218458,-0.09754975203755678,10.443931721361103 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,0.0,2.0,1,2,0.10068162323539499,0.10978475832487358,0.9103135089478589,200.3506097672743 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,0.0,2.0,2,2,0.21553299101324205,0.21750061296063938,0.196762194739733,162.17036326825183 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,0.0,2.0,3,2,0.15587356443823114,0.15725535819266548,0.13817937544343406,1695.9755455201557 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,0.0,2.0,1,3,0.08089223132819048,0.08326952225466218,0.23772909264716952,172.40780056855291 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,0.0,2.0,2,3,0.1001380230593783,0.10845237748687282,0.8314354427494521,67.56351414347115 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,0.0,2.0,3,3,0.12499059788533419,0.12743261625620228,0.24420183708680904,6.728799547400598 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,0.0,2.0,1,4,0.11441511401611727,0.1257556756862781,1.134056167016083,240.7277545777776 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,0.0,2.0,2,4,0.22242656952672063,0.22963952603278012,0.7212956506059492,159.31078762376222 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,0.0,2.0,3,4,0.09939464280929912,0.10015087839891129,0.07562355896121725,999.9510095642174 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,2.0,4.0,1,1,0.19556001327943112,0.19657870848433262,0.10186952049014986,109.63181516227553 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,2.0,4.0,2,1,0.3365956246015076,0.341834878969231,0.5239254367723378,35.73701162313534 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,2.0,4.0,3,1,0.2853794332963041,0.29384822900217994,0.8468795705875831,19.032432468094193 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,2.0,4.0,1,2,0.20620400520935797,0.22184270504896936,1.5638699839611387,332.6255027237516 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,2.0,4.0,2,2,0.4699571005643125,0.4722231086852749,0.22660081209623928,108.42193903259285 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,2.0,4.0,3,2,0.5774729488623181,0.5824984230384854,0.5025474176167277,2092.099443124436 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,2.0,4.0,1,3,0.229476014736149,0.2456514893041589,1.6175474568009884,191.7964176201063 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,2.0,4.0,2,3,0.30606204606299686,0.3315926122097403,2.5530566146743428,65.43033131435551 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,2.0,4.0,3,3,0.305582969467317,0.31480617453237597,0.922320506505897,10.834376530427265 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,2.0,4.0,1,4,0.30573223037845526,0.33285423949742626,2.7122009118971,245.8883277270492 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,2.0,4.0,2,4,0.48330493760024124,0.480268355036999,-0.30365825632422405,111.0535128739926 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,2.0,4.0,3,4,0.3315779375867813,0.3332112149627761,0.1633277375994835,862.8754423088498 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,4.0,6.0,1,1,0.43021233069718184,0.4617774353596572,3.1565104662475365,114.38074528327584 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,4.0,6.0,2,1,0.5454345964029768,0.6162303090506387,7.0795712647661935,39.52671804127072 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,4.0,6.0,3,1,0.9564458434719271,0.988594521680656,3.214867820872891,8.48487256644457 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,4.0,6.0,1,2,0.6663993013486933,0.7336575759809183,6.7258274632225,148.8683048904344 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,4.0,6.0,2,2,0.8772175138017,0.8957925495859476,1.8575035784247573,154.61713320452222 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,4.0,6.0,3,2,0.6166309321323887,0.6211158888667817,0.4484956734392975,2745.0454487645356 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,4.0,6.0,1,3,0.3628265789553971,0.3777523859049189,1.492580694952178,107.43060184629043 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,4.0,6.0,2,3,0.5157838307644934,0.5289185793752008,1.3134748610707403,40.53405130257632 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,4.0,6.0,3,3,0.6805010432404849,0.6831406266417059,0.26395834012210573,10.960614901788274 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,4.0,6.0,1,4,0.3796941967522453,0.4096617890430714,2.996759229082607,449.2228297809578 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,4.0,6.0,2,4,0.6565850059573259,0.6989468217446366,4.236181578731069,182.1614527819628 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,4.0,6.0,3,4,0.4116968509780877,0.4093793401148175,-0.23175108632702002,465.67477613311735 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,6.0,8.0,1,1,0.6501212726922685,0.6958362266478355,4.571495395556702,128.58500365932827 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,6.0,8.0,2,1,0.92362211201281,0.9843713683846657,6.074925637185569,25.63177965913173 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,6.0,8.0,3,1,0.33884624528555884,0.3523063715446783,1.3460126259119465,23.567125413197505 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,6.0,8.0,1,2,0.3558113941342283,0.3901782869820548,3.436689284782651,507.2408954781128 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,6.0,8.0,2,2,0.9329588470110466,0.9419444337101349,0.8985586699088333,142.5695922878412 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,6.0,8.0,3,2,0.9773530244571291,0.9797101179280936,0.23570934709644664,1872.594578074092 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,6.0,8.0,1,3,0.4147220188716244,0.4468866909750669,3.2164672103442484,100.97117162918848 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,6.0,8.0,2,3,0.5124295290533522,0.5973298706349549,8.490034158160276,35.540667292636265 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,6.0,8.0,3,3,1.2025075018237017,1.2007310399301248,-0.17764618935769416,6.571486110460263 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,6.0,8.0,1,4,0.5776011688088464,0.6113305550616812,3.3729386252834836,418.64770184341813 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,6.0,8.0,2,4,0.6005159469176338,0.6265346605538975,2.6018713636263735,193.616366707088 +craig_bampton_m64,successive,6.0,8.0,3,4,0.5202605138149754,0.5293381926444594,0.9077678829483959,648.8845214469409 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,2.0,1,1,0.1309668316475871,0.13096683167401138,2.6424279431225273e-09,145.36404191772687 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,2.0,2,1,0.13314394173631178,0.13314394177339914,3.7087360960086357e-09,79.1821087227972 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,2.0,3,1,0.23117755280559216,0.23117755173908971,-1.0665024419154179e-07,10.443931721361103 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,2.0,1,2,0.11001402166364013,0.11001402136116971,-3.0247042370756816e-08,200.3506097672743 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,2.0,2,2,0.22619052673821252,0.22619053504102146,8.302808940374717e-07,162.17036326825183 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,2.0,3,2,0.15596197847133417,0.15596198220508456,3.733750392198587e-07,1695.9755455201557 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,2.0,1,3,0.08922076152212056,0.08922076154698588,2.4865318137834436e-09,172.40780056855291 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,2.0,2,3,0.1194639451913537,0.11946394525869204,6.733834323480181e-09,67.56351414347115 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,2.0,3,3,0.14320361369163265,0.14320361523917519,1.5475425385602648e-07,6.728799547400598 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,2.0,1,4,0.1296636258340787,0.12966362629978956,4.657108587657888e-08,240.7277545777776 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,2.0,2,4,0.25131124429987023,0.25131123622296364,-8.07690658799487e-07,159.31078762376222 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,2.0,3,4,0.09201688088147564,0.0920168793431872,-1.5382884410719555e-07,999.9510095642174 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,4.0,1,1,0.164161788309484,0.16416178830696831,-2.515682107073758e-10,253.67180461894017 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,4.0,2,1,0.23918115692238692,0.23918115716727795,2.4489102412594832e-08,113.65018352505747 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,4.0,3,1,0.28615477668193406,0.28615477599882944,-6.831046284183628e-08,29.437431906287554 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,4.0,1,2,0.19234924547386978,0.1923492454933089,1.943911698276679e-09,532.8963522387351 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,4.0,2,2,0.36560194358791315,0.3656019399696202,-3.618292943041723e-07,269.6705203622069 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,4.0,3,2,0.4468252794405447,0.4468252720599252,-7.380619448937864e-07,3786.255909354872 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,4.0,1,3,0.1992482600693431,0.19924826005311408,-1.6229018129365613e-09,359.4033894116711 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,4.0,2,3,0.2662358536865687,0.26623585387764676,1.9107804227758152e-08,132.98275793048046 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,4.0,3,3,0.2765828073161412,0.27658280746530073,1.4915951807026318e-08,17.4540658068878 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,4.0,1,4,0.256156143632593,0.2561561439538571,3.212641264127569e-08,486.4477960629689 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,4.0,2,4,0.38599027293647425,0.3859902640826486,-8.853825672616722e-07,270.29468666776506 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,4.0,3,4,0.2426315906440701,0.24263160770004677,1.7055976658797434e-06,1862.6893956197134 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,6.0,1,1,0.29775150382922105,0.29775150382113125,-8.089806602384897e-10,366.45210699047067 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,6.0,2,1,0.3838841865373757,0.3838841867511878,2.1381207915283085e-08,153.0916117298096 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,6.0,3,1,0.551144897703032,0.5511448976531796,-4.98523444747434e-09,37.86061435144624 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,6.0,1,2,0.38635881096037744,0.38635881094550606,-1.487138190370274e-09,680.6977791585563 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,6.0,2,2,0.6437555465451633,0.6437555386395123,-7.905651022710458e-07,424.2871178397254 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,6.0,3,2,0.5250594883850377,0.5250594838985073,-4.4865303694408e-07,6526.37378535195 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,6.0,1,3,0.25989987694049943,0.2598998769340243,-6.4751537465213e-10,463.63748898957897 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,6.0,2,3,0.3688799658091562,0.36887996591683264,1.0767642333320282e-08,172.72482588374487 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,6.0,3,3,0.5075221890257987,0.5075221879432267,-1.0825720320184473e-07,28.3599909356418 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,6.0,1,4,0.3421843141738702,0.342184314555926,3.820558314160394e-08,935.6561469785913 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,6.0,2,4,0.5401206367466502,0.5401206384725089,1.7258586781920826e-07,452.4378414100233 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,6.0,3,4,0.2879262949686227,0.28792631277624703,1.7807624319576831e-06,2328.3305885148125 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,8.0,1,1,0.4479873163288279,0.44798731636099304,3.216515942483511e-09,494.69428041273386 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,8.0,2,1,0.5318445714381828,0.5318445713087694,-1.294133689100363e-08,178.72327852524703 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,8.0,3,1,0.4821651643929628,0.4821651638494462,-5.435166205991493e-08,61.37735588186157 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,8.0,1,2,0.39002541137165075,0.3900254115367513,1.6510054434704102e-08,1186.859962414774 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,8.0,2,2,0.7291856997145701,0.7291856895178618,-1.0196708366549956e-06,566.8492940774136 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,8.0,3,2,0.6521057662768127,0.6521057639255821,-2.351230654618064e-07,8382.145509381835 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,8.0,1,3,0.302440872361339,0.30244087238347533,2.2136348309942377e-09,561.2536955901165 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,8.0,2,3,0.4182091094163887,0.4182091093447721,-7.161660153798266e-09,208.2216404581095 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,8.0,3,3,0.6832354310035377,0.6832354328226332,1.8190955408670106e-07,34.93069631518288 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,8.0,1,4,0.4499625130285828,0.44996251297493556,-5.364725330636588e-09,1354.292680262663 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,8.0,2,4,0.5801359294671564,0.5801359391810724,9.713916004905343e-07,646.0333572693044 +rational_krylov_m128,cumulative,0.0,8.0,3,4,0.35768482198312784,0.35768480915167766,-1.2831450180161852e-06,2976.411780513511 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,0.0,2.0,1,1,0.1309668316475871,0.13096683167401138,2.6424279431225273e-09,145.36404191772687 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,0.0,2.0,2,1,0.13314394173631178,0.13314394177339914,3.7087360960086357e-09,79.1821087227972 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,0.0,2.0,3,1,0.23117755280559216,0.23117755173908971,-1.0665024419154179e-07,10.443931721361103 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,0.0,2.0,1,2,0.11001402166364013,0.11001402136116971,-3.0247042370756816e-08,200.3506097672743 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,0.0,2.0,2,2,0.22619052673821252,0.22619053504102146,8.302808940374717e-07,162.17036326825183 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,0.0,2.0,3,2,0.15596197847133417,0.15596198220508456,3.733750392198587e-07,1695.9755455201557 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,0.0,2.0,1,3,0.08922076152212056,0.08922076154698588,2.4865318137834436e-09,172.40780056855291 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,0.0,2.0,2,3,0.1194639451913537,0.11946394525869204,6.733834323480181e-09,67.56351414347115 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,0.0,2.0,3,3,0.14320361369163265,0.14320361523917519,1.5475425385602648e-07,6.728799547400598 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,0.0,2.0,1,4,0.1296636258340787,0.12966362629978956,4.657108587657888e-08,240.7277545777776 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,0.0,2.0,2,4,0.25131124429987023,0.25131123622296364,-8.07690658799487e-07,159.31078762376222 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,0.0,2.0,3,4,0.09201688088147564,0.0920168793431872,-1.5382884410719555e-07,999.9510095642174 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,2.0,4.0,1,1,0.1992325033402775,0.19923250331330195,-2.6975560674102894e-09,109.63181516227553 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,2.0,4.0,2,1,0.37779355319397895,0.3777935536642273,4.702483402674318e-08,35.73701162313534 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,2.0,4.0,3,1,0.3127288949704752,0.31272889448050917,-4.89966012207077e-08,19.032432468094193 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,2.0,4.0,1,2,0.22879206867035273,0.2287920687990593,1.287065731769843e-08,332.6255027237516 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,2.0,4.0,2,2,0.5073152806820116,0.5073152682935742,-1.2388437387045315e-06,108.42193903259285 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,2.0,4.0,3,2,0.5844839254830876,0.5844839144436142,-1.1039473335472394e-06,2092.099443124436 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,2.0,4.0,1,3,0.2593197009066487,0.2593197008760279,-3.0620783686430286e-09,191.7964176201063 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,2.0,4.0,2,3,0.3596416917710807,0.35964169203218443,2.6110374973242756e-08,65.43033131435551 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,2.0,4.0,3,3,0.33242221366744445,0.33242221346433837,-2.03106087504068e-08,10.834376530427265 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,2.0,4.0,1,4,0.3369946825049663,0.33699468280651146,3.0154517771663336e-08,245.8883277270492 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,2.0,4.0,2,4,0.5217425026087017,0.5217424921165295,-1.0492172242138054e-06,111.0535128739926 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,2.0,4.0,3,4,0.3425089846969588,0.34250901136779655,2.6670837760534027e-06,862.8754423088498 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,4.0,6.0,1,1,0.4737172911357482,0.47371729112129474,-1.44534384460826e-09,114.38074528327584 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,4.0,6.0,2,1,0.6374242146545824,0.6374242148919235,2.373410357137118e-08,39.52671804127072 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,4.0,6.0,3,1,1.0396125296325889,1.039612529862235,2.2964607993003483e-08,8.48487256644457 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,4.0,6.0,1,2,0.7420923694179609,0.7420923693300174,-8.794343031581775e-09,148.8683048904344 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,4.0,6.0,2,2,0.9514961740529126,0.951496161346086,-1.2706826701958107e-06,154.61713320452222 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,4.0,6.0,3,2,0.6164974698904743,0.616497468165928,-1.7245462835546732e-07,2745.0454487645356 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,4.0,6.0,1,3,0.39854517752478275,0.3985451775315909,6.808165142757616e-10,107.43060184629043 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,4.0,6.0,2,3,0.5930618847222254,0.5930618848285799,1.0635448077778165e-08,40.53405130257632 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,4.0,6.0,3,3,0.7380201849441492,0.7380201828897666,-2.054382663985166e-07,10.960614901788274 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,4.0,6.0,1,4,0.4194586991959654,0.4194586995298344,3.338689880116874e-08,449.2228297809578 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,4.0,6.0,2,4,0.7095928739813676,0.7095928844604512,1.0479083600856143e-06,182.1614527819628 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,4.0,6.0,3,4,0.4232204491601317,0.4232204711274375,2.1967305807724102e-06,465.67477613311735 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,6.0,8.0,1,1,0.7253779068645231,0.7253779069630004,9.84773373957637e-09,128.58500365932827 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,6.0,8.0,2,1,1.0453076087078994,1.0453076077678576,-9.400418221616746e-08,25.63177965913173 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,6.0,8.0,3,1,0.3436012493130854,0.3436012473066256,-2.0064597761049185e-07,23.567125413197505 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,6.0,8.0,1,2,0.39534693323692605,0.39534693361722156,3.8029551729934497e-08,507.2408954781128 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,6.0,8.0,2,2,0.9402126328160441,0.9402126166570663,-1.615897771145569e-06,142.5695922878412 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,6.0,8.0,3,2,0.9709422996813236,0.9709423011764209,1.4950972682115093e-07,1872.594578074092 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,6.0,8.0,1,3,0.44529396395915455,0.4452939640583008,9.914624676810035e-09,100.97117162918848 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,6.0,8.0,2,3,0.6029068163453389,0.6029068157079293,-6.37409680592782e-08,35.540667292636265 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,6.0,8.0,3,3,1.176362802476451,1.176362809324099,6.847648004182361e-07,6.571486110460263 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,6.0,8.0,1,4,0.6302487443443557,0.6302487437553118,-5.890439247480117e-08,418.64770184341813 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,6.0,8.0,2,4,0.664903944453222,0.6649039689738986,2.452067660030366e-06,193.616366707088 +rational_krylov_m128,successive,6.0,8.0,3,4,0.538045814275846,0.5380457413575515,-7.291829451361309e-06,648.8845214469409 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,2.0,1,1,0.13086533317114007,0.13089065164437302,0.0025318473232949223,145.36404191772687 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,2.0,2,1,0.13266045266918497,0.13256179586286307,-0.009865680632190066,79.1821087227972 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,2.0,3,1,0.2369989291846533,0.23704175387057452,0.004282468592123334,10.443931721361103 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,2.0,1,2,0.11052748784372225,0.11046284495922275,-0.006464288449950506,200.3506097672743 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,2.0,2,2,0.22733948057484682,0.2274847849301324,0.014530435528559149,162.17036326825183 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,2.0,3,2,0.1517460396835747,0.15176923019782387,0.0023190514249177285,1695.9755455201557 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,2.0,1,3,0.08962043547613363,0.08952645784038149,-0.009397763575214046,172.40780056855291 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,2.0,2,3,0.12031452643397737,0.12037666921048479,0.0062142776507415065,67.56351414347115 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,2.0,3,3,0.1333755369139699,0.1332012057649188,-0.017433114905107683,6.728799547400598 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,2.0,1,4,0.12918081578439425,0.1293059838115312,0.012516802713694042,240.7277545777776 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,2.0,2,4,0.2724881631322919,0.27319875474923744,0.07105916169455329,159.31078762376222 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,2.0,3,4,0.09051338888030006,0.09050875924888352,-0.0004629631416536162,999.9510095642174 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,4.0,1,1,0.16412403720828544,0.164113798045844,-0.0010239162441444405,253.67180461894017 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,4.0,2,1,0.23496828148707763,0.23490245063516052,-0.0065830851917109134,113.65018352505747 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,4.0,3,1,0.28231582306432074,0.2824494288608863,0.013360579656557237,29.437431906287554 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,4.0,1,2,0.1941338966719826,0.19430859978209022,0.017470311010761574,532.8963522387351 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,4.0,2,2,0.34163599978121967,0.34090621326786813,-0.0729786513351538,269.6705203622069 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,4.0,3,2,0.44508848789299854,0.4451179997461812,0.0029511853182673242,3786.255909354872 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,4.0,1,3,0.19966443938158823,0.1996218118029651,-0.004262757862313893,359.4033894116711 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,4.0,2,3,0.2663121184650094,0.26550631002543046,-0.08058084395789478,132.98275793048046 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,4.0,3,3,0.2788659652319674,0.27893648712173835,0.007052188977096918,17.4540658068878 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,4.0,1,4,0.2559447910052213,0.25595702713910995,0.0012236133888676726,486.4477960629689 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,4.0,2,4,0.37662996631669143,0.37705623013409617,0.04262638174047373,270.29468666776506 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,4.0,3,4,0.23828408699689319,0.2383023087585463,0.0018221761653114399,1862.6893956197134 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,6.0,1,1,0.29759441751556903,0.29751577504087506,-0.007864247469396846,366.45210699047067 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,6.0,2,1,0.3816708401087022,0.3817032095147521,0.003236940604989247,153.0916117298096 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,6.0,3,1,0.5430239609187986,0.543076220617224,0.005225969842548306,37.86061435144624 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,6.0,1,2,0.3899037188973536,0.38986767519398147,-0.0036043703372123925,680.6977791585563 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,6.0,2,2,0.6226137295701244,0.6236616320991014,0.10479025289770183,424.2871178397254 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,6.0,3,2,0.5194782610260457,0.5194918965847036,0.0013635558657965063,6526.37378535195 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,6.0,1,3,0.26030912906284953,0.2602593944902312,-0.00497345726183096,463.63748898957897 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,6.0,2,3,0.3698487673770752,0.36946675945313945,-0.038200792393577876,172.72482588374487 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,6.0,3,3,0.5037122640859533,0.5041887068932707,0.047644280731740096,28.3599909356418 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,6.0,1,4,0.34118888248200124,0.34138927360843646,0.02003911264352176,935.6561469785913 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,6.0,2,4,0.5608340642112646,0.5610988451112274,0.02647808999628465,452.4378414100233 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,6.0,3,4,0.2888483242377835,0.2888626794145785,0.0014355176794988989,2328.3305885148125 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,8.0,1,1,0.4484345295290299,0.4483928250144602,-0.004170451456969593,494.69428041273386 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,8.0,2,1,0.526468632170999,0.5267087356648369,0.0240103493837851,178.72327852524703 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,8.0,3,1,0.47470525942469344,0.47478490282115765,0.007964339646421292,61.37735588186157 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,8.0,1,2,0.3935210638420791,0.3935403656350903,0.0019301793011239354,1186.859962414774 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,8.0,2,2,0.7162453135067256,0.717074272150691,0.08289586439653718,566.8492940774136 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,8.0,3,2,0.646273324166735,0.6462887569725543,0.001543280581928208,8382.145509381835 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,8.0,1,3,0.30284636100251616,0.302802219423357,-0.004414157915916261,561.2536955901165 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,8.0,2,3,0.42046592592271453,0.42056731540252745,0.01013894798129189,208.2216404581095 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,8.0,3,3,0.6845387843458208,0.6849415530118472,0.04027686660263985,34.93069631518288 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,8.0,1,4,0.4500685063678411,0.45012229330633047,0.005378693848934191,1354.292680262663 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,8.0,2,4,0.5763669036095946,0.5757180020836069,-0.06489015259877329,646.0333572693044 +rational_krylov_m32,cumulative,0.0,8.0,3,4,0.3569109701761689,0.35670105513444583,-0.02099150417230744,2976.411780513511 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,0.0,2.0,1,1,0.13086533317114007,0.13089065164437302,0.0025318473232949223,145.36404191772687 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,0.0,2.0,2,1,0.13266045266918497,0.13256179586286307,-0.009865680632190066,79.1821087227972 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,0.0,2.0,3,1,0.2369989291846533,0.23704175387057452,0.004282468592123334,10.443931721361103 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,0.0,2.0,1,2,0.11052748784372225,0.11046284495922275,-0.006464288449950506,200.3506097672743 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,0.0,2.0,2,2,0.22733948057484682,0.2274847849301324,0.014530435528559149,162.17036326825183 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,0.0,2.0,3,2,0.1517460396835747,0.15176923019782387,0.0023190514249177285,1695.9755455201557 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,0.0,2.0,1,3,0.08962043547613363,0.08952645784038149,-0.009397763575214046,172.40780056855291 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,0.0,2.0,2,3,0.12031452643397737,0.12037666921048479,0.0062142776507415065,67.56351414347115 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,0.0,2.0,3,3,0.1333755369139699,0.1332012057649188,-0.017433114905107683,6.728799547400598 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,0.0,2.0,1,4,0.12918081578439425,0.1293059838115312,0.012516802713694042,240.7277545777776 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,0.0,2.0,2,4,0.2724881631322919,0.27319875474923744,0.07105916169455329,159.31078762376222 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,0.0,2.0,3,4,0.09051338888030006,0.09050875924888352,-0.0004629631416536162,999.9510095642174 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,2.0,4.0,1,1,0.19924314578306118,0.1992008199103538,-0.00423258727073883,109.63181516227553 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,2.0,4.0,2,1,0.3696422727046277,0.3695891788953862,-0.005309380924151119,35.73701162313534 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,2.0,4.0,3,1,0.30494324761590236,0.30511656426295863,0.017331664705627636,19.032432468094193 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,2.0,4.0,1,2,0.23086982782508592,0.2311275675437498,0.025773971866388523,332.6255027237516 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,2.0,4.0,2,2,0.4633759744273431,0.4619534527147985,-0.14225217125445888,108.42193903259285 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,2.0,4.0,3,2,0.5830266821285321,0.5830629227274761,0.003624059894391518,2092.099443124436 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,2.0,4.0,1,3,0.25979352837825215,0.2597616711402417,-0.003185723801046869,191.7964176201063 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,2.0,4.0,2,3,0.35945651212830776,0.3582230786607697,-0.12334334675380698,65.43033131435551 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,2.0,4.0,3,3,0.33798349760674384,0.3381199826272896,0.013648502054575129,10.834376530427265 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,2.0,4.0,1,4,0.3368672628465505,0.3368355413448558,-0.003172150169467036,245.8883277270492 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,2.0,4.0,2,4,0.4886266714034582,0.48886035424223756,0.02336828387793366,111.0535128739926 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,2.0,4.0,3,4,0.3362668862227878,0.33629616678417884,0.0029280561391065163,862.8754423088498 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,4.0,6.0,1,1,0.47343312529390225,0.4732837659686673,-0.014935932523496565,114.38074528327584 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,4.0,6.0,2,1,0.6367627272292985,0.6369070503906814,0.01443231613829088,39.52671804127072 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,4.0,6.0,3,1,1.0237061432906842,1.023707123183903,9.798932187887743e-05,8.48487256644457 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,4.0,6.0,1,2,0.7490007692679159,0.7487580082874051,-0.02427609805107922,148.8683048904344 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,4.0,6.0,2,2,0.9281904385519164,0.9305709989523567,0.23805604004403236,154.61713320452222 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,4.0,6.0,3,2,0.6069382231656918,0.6069364285026722,-0.00017946630196385982,2745.0454487645356 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,4.0,6.0,1,3,0.3990686040179836,0.39899556464126945,-0.007303937671415683,107.43060184629043 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,4.0,6.0,2,3,0.5961128065579517,0.596350934121709,0.02381275637572955,40.53405130257632 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,4.0,6.0,3,3,0.7298638894351664,0.730671025330379,0.08071358952125296,10.960614901788274 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,4.0,6.0,1,4,0.4175651072796444,0.41790973679525373,0.03446295156093182,449.2228297809578 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,4.0,6.0,2,4,0.7556862960698765,0.7558683499193758,0.018205384949931958,182.1614527819628 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,4.0,6.0,3,4,0.4359408619489484,0.43594887956874606,0.000801761979768445,465.67477613311735 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,6.0,8.0,1,1,0.7265888912910637,0.7265773132645305,-0.0011578026533287655,128.58500365932827 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,6.0,8.0,2,1,1.0311767398024432,1.0319536997120677,0.07769599096245638,25.63177965913173 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,6.0,8.0,3,1,0.33708751575631357,0.33724321653146766,0.015570077515408842,23.567125413197505 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,6.0,8.0,1,2,0.3986609199470639,0.39874749644045454,0.008657649339066653,507.2408954781128 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,6.0,8.0,2,2,0.9426663902893696,0.943135348732296,0.046895844292638156,142.5695922878412 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,6.0,8.0,3,2,0.9639186436071016,0.9639391611147922,0.002051750769060945,1872.594578074092 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,6.0,8.0,1,3,0.44573552324367277,0.4457011815145326,-0.003434172914018596,100.97117162918848 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,6.0,8.0,2,3,0.6091279707148105,0.6106695522667706,0.15415815519600473,35.540667292636265 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,6.0,8.0,3,3,1.1862650903722216,1.1866366840189566,0.03715936467350023,6.571486110460263 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,6.0,8.0,1,4,0.6318719883346736,0.6317651932721564,-0.01067950625172065,418.64770184341813 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,6.0,8.0,2,4,0.6117469841434309,0.6091569595336117,-0.25900246098191637,193.616366707088 +rational_krylov_m32,successive,6.0,8.0,3,4,0.5339127605829878,0.5332400600335886,-0.06727005493991634,648.8845214469409 diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/summary.csv b/unequal_speed_interface/results/summary.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8f3a443085100345ed25bc01c3a7b96f715d58ba --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/summary.csv @@ -0,0 +1,29 @@ +grid,method,modes_per_patch,dimension,time_end,receiver_total_error,continuous_pressure_total_error,receiver_same_grid_error,pressure_same_grid_error,pressure_cell_projection_floor,receiver_error_vector_cosine +128,craig_bampton,128,384,2,0.010512313207252917,0.06365509348769038,0.008664281907214076,0.05774517021207568,0.03653997549208263,-0.35375948045352723 +128,craig_bampton,128,384,8,0.036844514705871384,0.10142313174789423,0.031224702593957356,0.1297370427289736,0.03649779593648991,-0.6246940483694357 +128,craig_bampton,32,192,2,0.27727145849686385,0.452165726683949,0.2739790425337621,0.4520687618495759,0.03653997549208263,0.33479198989992237 +128,craig_bampton,32,192,8,0.3792036773811914,0.6280850283187381,0.38893743189472996,0.6426556175552302,0.03649779593648991,-0.2510250968599448 +128,craig_bampton,64,256,2,0.04138151776684589,0.18787739213498278,0.04260111169173862,0.18962823024395578,0.03653997549208263,-0.23577139774290262 +128,craig_bampton,64,256,8,0.10253096101252937,0.3167833894907057,0.11674487307127594,0.3477636146382894,0.03649779593648991,-0.48171030883409477 +128,full_separable,,16384,2,0.00976403981031125,0.047884747781743384,,,0.03653997549208263, +128,full_separable,,16384,8,0.047131977586243594,0.11897939802071243,,,0.03649779593648991, +32,craig_bampton,128,288,2,0.14298181431812496,0.3621795738793046,0.0029036168607291754,0.030592289497545274,0.1447972914664671,-0.2938452598027473 +32,craig_bampton,128,288,8,0.5563083589023377,0.7673081983833899,0.011627519452205928,0.06810667990717972,0.14462819580723923,-0.17012044710622207 +32,craig_bampton,32,96,2,0.24695100879317763,0.4052762870757868,0.23849680684474817,0.42065834902515287,0.1447972914664671,-0.23284899011288382 +32,craig_bampton,32,96,8,0.5066425742230385,0.6262419698670132,0.33207252113067837,0.5822636955791397,0.14462819580723923,-0.4413894117706257 +32,craig_bampton,64,160,2,0.13982297376801736,0.331470495325301,0.02669116497917258,0.13780838765044212,0.1447972914664671,-0.24020167337725365 +32,craig_bampton,64,160,8,0.5467416002077377,0.7351700594856369,0.07734579609690397,0.253629045770627,0.14462819580723923,-0.21710890848852468 +32,full_separable,,1024,2,0.1438031376064089,0.36574816769977747,,,0.1447972914664671, +32,full_separable,,1024,8,0.5581207492488209,0.7727777776267758,,,0.14462819580723923, +32,rational_krylov,128,288,2,0.1438032906814237,0.3657458975380163,4.167702632436727e-05,0.0044194815736991605,0.1447972914664671,0.0035517639597581674 +32,rational_krylov,128,288,8,0.5581186755287815,0.772789957184767,0.000943990933941447,0.028404505184990755,0.14462819580723923,-0.0030810361582888335 +32,rational_krylov,32,96,2,0.14326569336048547,0.35991322857649954,0.031880217458453715,0.15194501941812516,0.1447972914664671,-0.127091868193705 +32,rational_krylov,32,96,8,0.5540243977958785,0.7685692416368883,0.06565225776685694,0.24019074527357517,0.14462819580723923,-0.12112038560821135 +64,craig_bampton,128,320,2,0.03648395575881618,0.12131392838291599,0.007383244876723025,0.05354995021055477,0.0729420040698602,-0.3551047215661291 +64,craig_bampton,128,320,8,0.16668995523789423,0.3138574623328249,0.025374988097779827,0.11134141589581142,0.07285759245275009,-0.5645134693328314 +64,craig_bampton,32,128,2,0.3051890352277107,0.4623643507229158,0.29292377738212433,0.46246706758666445,0.0729420040698602,0.27404345614731107 +64,craig_bampton,32,128,8,0.35654839778590985,0.5850600438848421,0.36697608041219193,0.6281840463972442,0.07285759245275009,-0.2907527318992064 +64,craig_bampton,64,192,2,0.045574705666799956,0.18829846966068872,0.03829238439723997,0.18337550974339023,0.0729420040698602,-0.29331178715547773 +64,craig_bampton,64,192,8,0.14776960566595224,0.2726969329064572,0.10407901138983204,0.328370469666599,0.07285759245275009,-0.5685407138813241 +64,full_separable,,4096,2,0.03844467800718734,0.1336076247371244,,,0.0729420040698602, +64,full_separable,,4096,8,0.1796183654246856,0.35678824566693035,,,0.07285759245275009, diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/summary.json b/unequal_speed_interface/results/summary.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..377f945746629ccafdb9ee449da10c408ae2175d --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/summary.json @@ -0,0 +1,442 @@ +{ + "configuration": { + "material": "aligned_unequal_speed_interface", + "interface_x": 0.5, + "density": [ + 1.0, + 5.333333333333333 + ], + "bulk_modulus": [ + 1.0, + 12.0 + ], + "grids": [ + 32, + 64, + 128 + ], + "modes_per_patch": [ + 32, + 64, + 128 + ], + "rational_krylov_modes_per_patch": [ + 32, + 128 + ], + "source_centres": [ + [ + 0.19, + 0.76 + ], + [ + 0.54, + 0.47 + ], + [ + 0.81, + 0.22 + ] + ], + "receiver_centres": [ + [ + 0.22, + 0.21 + ], + [ + 0.79, + 0.77 + ], + [ + 0.28, + 0.69 + ], + [ + 0.68, + 0.33 + ] + ], + "sigma": 0.07, + "max_x_mode": 20, + "max_y_mode": 16, + "initial_energy": 1.0, + "quadrature_order": 192, + "root_scan_step": 0.02, + "time_end": 8.0, + "samples": 641, + "threads": 2, + "modal_grid": 32, + "mac_threshold": 0.9, + "relative_frequency_gap": 0.005, + "error_sampling": "641 equally weighted times including t=0 and all three sources.", + "initial_condition": "For each transverse index 0<=l<=16, retain the first 21 continuous Sturm-Liouville modes m=0,...,20. Project the Gaussian pressure in the beta inner product, remove only the global constant mode, and normalize to unit initial acoustic energy. The resulting finite expansion defines the initial pressure independently of the propagation grid; initial velocity is zero.", + "field_reference": "Continuous beta-weighted L2 error of piecewise-constant pressure reconstruction, including the exact subcell projection term.", + "timing_scope": "This study measures mechanism and accuracy; comparative costs are computed separately by the timing experiments." + }, + "rows": [ + { + "grid": 128, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "dimension": 384, + "time_end": 2, + "receiver_total_error": 0.010512313207252917, + "continuous_pressure_total_error": 0.06365509348769038, + "receiver_same_grid_error": 0.008664281907214076, + "pressure_same_grid_error": 0.05774517021207568, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": 0.03653997549208263, + "receiver_error_vector_cosine": -0.35375948045352723 + }, + { + "grid": 128, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "dimension": 384, + "time_end": 8, + "receiver_total_error": 0.036844514705871384, + "continuous_pressure_total_error": 0.10142313174789423, + "receiver_same_grid_error": 0.031224702593957356, + "pressure_same_grid_error": 0.1297370427289736, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": 0.03649779593648991, + "receiver_error_vector_cosine": -0.6246940483694357 + }, + { + "grid": 128, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 32, + "dimension": 192, + "time_end": 2, + "receiver_total_error": 0.27727145849686385, + "continuous_pressure_total_error": 0.452165726683949, + "receiver_same_grid_error": 0.2739790425337621, + "pressure_same_grid_error": 0.4520687618495759, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": 0.03653997549208263, + "receiver_error_vector_cosine": 0.33479198989992237 + }, + { + "grid": 128, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 32, + "dimension": 192, + "time_end": 8, + "receiver_total_error": 0.3792036773811914, + "continuous_pressure_total_error": 0.6280850283187381, + "receiver_same_grid_error": 0.38893743189472996, + "pressure_same_grid_error": 0.6426556175552302, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": 0.03649779593648991, + "receiver_error_vector_cosine": -0.2510250968599448 + }, + { + "grid": 128, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 64, + "dimension": 256, + "time_end": 2, + "receiver_total_error": 0.04138151776684589, + "continuous_pressure_total_error": 0.18787739213498278, + "receiver_same_grid_error": 0.04260111169173862, + "pressure_same_grid_error": 0.18962823024395578, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": 0.03653997549208263, + "receiver_error_vector_cosine": -0.23577139774290262 + }, + { + "grid": 128, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 64, + "dimension": 256, + "time_end": 8, + "receiver_total_error": 0.10253096101252937, + "continuous_pressure_total_error": 0.3167833894907057, + "receiver_same_grid_error": 0.11674487307127594, + "pressure_same_grid_error": 0.3477636146382894, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": 0.03649779593648991, + "receiver_error_vector_cosine": -0.48171030883409477 + }, + { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_separable", + "modes_per_patch": "", + "dimension": 16384, + "time_end": 2, + "receiver_total_error": 0.00976403981031125, + "continuous_pressure_total_error": 0.047884747781743384, + "receiver_same_grid_error": "", + "pressure_same_grid_error": "", + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": 0.03653997549208263, + "receiver_error_vector_cosine": "" + }, + { + "grid": 128, + "method": "full_separable", + "modes_per_patch": "", + "dimension": 16384, + "time_end": 8, + "receiver_total_error": 0.047131977586243594, + "continuous_pressure_total_error": 0.11897939802071243, + "receiver_same_grid_error": "", + "pressure_same_grid_error": "", + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": 0.03649779593648991, + "receiver_error_vector_cosine": "" + }, + { + "grid": 32, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "dimension": 288, + "time_end": 2, + "receiver_total_error": 0.14298181431812496, + "continuous_pressure_total_error": 0.3621795738793046, + "receiver_same_grid_error": 0.0029036168607291754, + "pressure_same_grid_error": 0.030592289497545274, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": 0.1447972914664671, + "receiver_error_vector_cosine": -0.2938452598027473 + }, + { + "grid": 32, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "dimension": 288, + "time_end": 8, + "receiver_total_error": 0.5563083589023377, + "continuous_pressure_total_error": 0.7673081983833899, + "receiver_same_grid_error": 0.011627519452205928, + "pressure_same_grid_error": 0.06810667990717972, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": 0.14462819580723923, + "receiver_error_vector_cosine": -0.17012044710622207 + }, + { + "grid": 32, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 32, + "dimension": 96, + "time_end": 2, + "receiver_total_error": 0.24695100879317763, + "continuous_pressure_total_error": 0.4052762870757868, + "receiver_same_grid_error": 0.23849680684474817, + "pressure_same_grid_error": 0.42065834902515287, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": 0.1447972914664671, + "receiver_error_vector_cosine": -0.23284899011288382 + }, + { + "grid": 32, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 32, + "dimension": 96, + "time_end": 8, + "receiver_total_error": 0.5066425742230385, + "continuous_pressure_total_error": 0.6262419698670132, + "receiver_same_grid_error": 0.33207252113067837, + "pressure_same_grid_error": 0.5822636955791397, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": 0.14462819580723923, + "receiver_error_vector_cosine": -0.4413894117706257 + }, + { + "grid": 32, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 64, + "dimension": 160, + "time_end": 2, + "receiver_total_error": 0.13982297376801736, + "continuous_pressure_total_error": 0.331470495325301, + "receiver_same_grid_error": 0.02669116497917258, + "pressure_same_grid_error": 0.13780838765044212, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": 0.1447972914664671, + "receiver_error_vector_cosine": -0.24020167337725365 + }, + { + "grid": 32, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 64, + "dimension": 160, + "time_end": 8, + "receiver_total_error": 0.5467416002077377, + "continuous_pressure_total_error": 0.7351700594856369, + "receiver_same_grid_error": 0.07734579609690397, + "pressure_same_grid_error": 0.253629045770627, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": 0.14462819580723923, + "receiver_error_vector_cosine": -0.21710890848852468 + }, + { + "grid": 32, + "method": "full_separable", + "modes_per_patch": "", + "dimension": 1024, + "time_end": 2, + "receiver_total_error": 0.1438031376064089, + "continuous_pressure_total_error": 0.36574816769977747, + "receiver_same_grid_error": "", + "pressure_same_grid_error": "", + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": 0.1447972914664671, + "receiver_error_vector_cosine": "" + }, + { + "grid": 32, + "method": "full_separable", + "modes_per_patch": "", + "dimension": 1024, + "time_end": 8, + "receiver_total_error": 0.5581207492488209, + "continuous_pressure_total_error": 0.7727777776267758, + "receiver_same_grid_error": "", + "pressure_same_grid_error": "", + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": 0.14462819580723923, + "receiver_error_vector_cosine": "" + }, + { + "grid": 32, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "dimension": 288, + "time_end": 2, + "receiver_total_error": 0.1438032906814237, + "continuous_pressure_total_error": 0.3657458975380163, + "receiver_same_grid_error": 4.167702632436727e-05, + "pressure_same_grid_error": 0.0044194815736991605, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": 0.1447972914664671, + "receiver_error_vector_cosine": 0.0035517639597581674 + }, + { + "grid": 32, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "dimension": 288, + "time_end": 8, + "receiver_total_error": 0.5581186755287815, + "continuous_pressure_total_error": 0.772789957184767, + "receiver_same_grid_error": 0.000943990933941447, + "pressure_same_grid_error": 0.028404505184990755, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": 0.14462819580723923, + "receiver_error_vector_cosine": -0.0030810361582888335 + }, + { + "grid": 32, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "modes_per_patch": 32, + "dimension": 96, + "time_end": 2, + "receiver_total_error": 0.14326569336048547, + "continuous_pressure_total_error": 0.35991322857649954, + "receiver_same_grid_error": 0.031880217458453715, + "pressure_same_grid_error": 0.15194501941812516, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": 0.1447972914664671, + "receiver_error_vector_cosine": -0.127091868193705 + }, + { + "grid": 32, + "method": "rational_krylov", + "modes_per_patch": 32, + "dimension": 96, + "time_end": 8, + "receiver_total_error": 0.5540243977958785, + "continuous_pressure_total_error": 0.7685692416368883, + "receiver_same_grid_error": 0.06565225776685694, + "pressure_same_grid_error": 0.24019074527357517, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": 0.14462819580723923, + "receiver_error_vector_cosine": -0.12112038560821135 + }, + { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "dimension": 320, + "time_end": 2, + "receiver_total_error": 0.03648395575881618, + "continuous_pressure_total_error": 0.12131392838291599, + "receiver_same_grid_error": 0.007383244876723025, + "pressure_same_grid_error": 0.05354995021055477, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": 0.0729420040698602, + "receiver_error_vector_cosine": -0.3551047215661291 + }, + { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 128, + "dimension": 320, + "time_end": 8, + "receiver_total_error": 0.16668995523789423, + "continuous_pressure_total_error": 0.3138574623328249, + "receiver_same_grid_error": 0.025374988097779827, + "pressure_same_grid_error": 0.11134141589581142, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": 0.07285759245275009, + "receiver_error_vector_cosine": -0.5645134693328314 + }, + { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 32, + "dimension": 128, + "time_end": 2, + "receiver_total_error": 0.3051890352277107, + "continuous_pressure_total_error": 0.4623643507229158, + "receiver_same_grid_error": 0.29292377738212433, + "pressure_same_grid_error": 0.46246706758666445, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": 0.0729420040698602, + "receiver_error_vector_cosine": 0.27404345614731107 + }, + { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 32, + "dimension": 128, + "time_end": 8, + "receiver_total_error": 0.35654839778590985, + "continuous_pressure_total_error": 0.5850600438848421, + "receiver_same_grid_error": 0.36697608041219193, + "pressure_same_grid_error": 0.6281840463972442, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": 0.07285759245275009, + "receiver_error_vector_cosine": -0.2907527318992064 + }, + { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 64, + "dimension": 192, + "time_end": 2, + "receiver_total_error": 0.045574705666799956, + "continuous_pressure_total_error": 0.18829846966068872, + "receiver_same_grid_error": 0.03829238439723997, + "pressure_same_grid_error": 0.18337550974339023, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": 0.0729420040698602, + "receiver_error_vector_cosine": -0.29331178715547773 + }, + { + "grid": 64, + "method": "craig_bampton", + "modes_per_patch": 64, + "dimension": 192, + "time_end": 8, + "receiver_total_error": 0.14776960566595224, + "continuous_pressure_total_error": 0.2726969329064572, + "receiver_same_grid_error": 0.10407901138983204, + "pressure_same_grid_error": 0.328370469666599, + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": 0.07285759245275009, + "receiver_error_vector_cosine": -0.5685407138813241 + }, + { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_separable", + "modes_per_patch": "", + "dimension": 4096, + "time_end": 2, + "receiver_total_error": 0.03844467800718734, + "continuous_pressure_total_error": 0.1336076247371244, + "receiver_same_grid_error": "", + "pressure_same_grid_error": "", + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": 0.0729420040698602, + "receiver_error_vector_cosine": "" + }, + { + "grid": 64, + "method": "full_separable", + "modes_per_patch": "", + "dimension": 4096, + "time_end": 8, + "receiver_total_error": 0.1796183654246856, + "continuous_pressure_total_error": 0.35678824566693035, + "receiver_same_grid_error": "", + "pressure_same_grid_error": "", + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": 0.07285759245275009, + "receiver_error_vector_cosine": "" + } + ] +} diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/results/verification.json b/unequal_speed_interface/results/verification.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f5da65cc4b081cfefe39175b5b00f87df9478ccc --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/results/verification.json @@ -0,0 +1,104 @@ +{ + "sound_speeds": [ + 1.0, + 1.5 + ], + "impedances": [ + 1.0, + 8.0 + ], + "pressure_jump_scaled_max": 1.3047132818577722e-12, + "normal_flux_jump_scaled_max": 9.768347007438449e-12, + "x_beta_gram_max_error": 1.907372138878141e-12, + "y_gram_max_error": 2.208177942271148e-14, + "initial_acoustic_energy": [ + 0.9999999999999994, + 1.0, + 1.0000000000000009 + ], + "zero_mode_coefficients": [ + 0.0, + 0.0, + 0.0 + ], + "source_quadrature_relative_change_192_384": 8.893710772771995e-14, + "receiver_quadrature_relative_change_192_384": 5.269164177108303e-14, + "root_scan_relative_change_002_001": 1.574500481237869e-15, + "receiver_root_scan_relative_change_002_001": 3.0392701537645236e-13, + "number_of_finite_initial_modes": 356, + "evanescent_segments_in_initial_modes": 84, + "time_propagation": "Exact modal cosine propagation; no time-stepping error.", + "equal_speed_spectrum_relative_max_error": 6.785183320455502e-15, + "independent_1d_root_checks": [ + { + "ell": 0, + "cells": 512, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 0.0008648503583013407 + }, + { + "ell": 0, + "cells": 1024, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 0.0002162359082690869 + }, + { + "ell": 0, + "cells": 2048, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 5.406041782461651e-05 + }, + { + "ell": 4, + "cells": 512, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 0.000837063967165335 + }, + { + "ell": 4, + "cells": 1024, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 0.0002093274167447407 + }, + { + "ell": 4, + "cells": 2048, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 5.233566410672216e-05 + }, + { + "ell": 8, + "cells": 512, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 0.0006256889513582543 + }, + { + "ell": 8, + "cells": 1024, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 0.0001559147610141906 + }, + { + "ell": 8, + "cells": 2048, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 3.894673440042951e-05 + }, + { + "ell": 16, + "cells": 512, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 0.0006614095431139285 + }, + { + "ell": 16, + "cells": 1024, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 0.0001648510381295746 + }, + { + "ell": 16, + "cells": 2048, + "frequency_relative_max_error": 4.11805053292703e-05 + } + ], + "independent_1d_finest_root_relative_max_error": 5.406041782461651e-05, + "separated_eigensystem_relative_residual": 6.495366575789996e-16, + "separated_eigensystem_orthogonality_error": 4.218847493575595e-15, + "separated_vs_sparse_pressure_relative_error": 4.092190442520776e-14, + "separated_vs_sparse_receiver_relative_error": 4.653017187114314e-14, + "energy_drift": 8.659739592076221e-15, + "generator_skew_defect": 0.0, + "continuous_field_identity_relative_error": 9.570109312955561e-14, + "norm_definition": "Continuous beta-weighted pressure norm, including orthogonal unresolved subcell contribution.", + "passed": true +} diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/run.py b/unequal_speed_interface/run.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5af8787ebf9dd70c02e4e09e492b87720e040029 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/run.py @@ -0,0 +1,205 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +"""Three-grid full/CB accuracy study against continuous interface modes.""" +import os +for key in ("OPENBLAS_NUM_THREADS", "OMP_NUM_THREADS", "MKL_NUM_THREADS", "NUMEXPR_NUM_THREADS"): + os.environ[key] = "2" +import argparse +import csv +import hashlib +import json +import platform +import sys +import time +from pathlib import Path +import numpy as np +import scipy +from scipy import linalg +from threadpoolctl import threadpool_info + +HERE = Path(__file__).resolve().parent +sys.path.insert(0, str(HERE.parent)) +from accuracy_cost.run import cb_basis, rational_basis +from unequal_speed_interface.io import save_arrays +from unequal_speed_interface.kernel import (CFG, continuous_data, assembly, + exact_receiver, exact_pressure_norm_squared, exact_mass_weighted_pressure, + separable_setup, separable_pressure, separable_receiver, full_eigenvectors) +OUT = HERE/"results" + + +def dump(path, record): + path.write_text(json.dumps(record, indent=2, allow_nan=False)+"\n") + + +def relative(a, b): + return float(np.linalg.norm(a-b)/np.linalg.norm(b)) + + +def receiver_errors(actual, reference, times): + return {f"T{end}": {"relative_error": relative(actual[times <= end+1e-12], reference[times <= end+1e-12]), + "per_source": [relative(actual[times <= end+1e-12, :, s], reference[times <= end+1e-12, :, s]) for s in range(3)]} + for end in (2, 8)} + + +def reduced_pressure(model, times): + modal = np.cos(np.asarray(times)[:, None]*model["omega"][None])[:, :, None]*model["coefficients"][None] + return (model["vectors"] @ modal.transpose(1, 0, 2).reshape(len(model["omega"]), -1)).reshape(-1, len(times), 3).transpose(1, 0, 2) + + +def field_summary(numerator, denominator): + return {f"T{end}": {"relative_error": float(np.sqrt(numerator[j].sum()/denominator[j].sum())), + "per_source": np.sqrt(numerator[j]/denominator[j]).tolist()} + for j, end in enumerate((2, 8))} + + +def field_errors(n, full, models, times): + arrays = {"denominator_continuous": np.zeros((2, 3)), + "denominator_discrete": np.zeros((2, 3)), "projection_floor": np.zeros((2, 3)), + "full": np.zeros((2, 3))} + for name in models: + arrays[name+"_continuous"] = np.zeros((2, 3)) + arrays[name+"_discrete"] = np.zeros((2, 3)) + subcell_min = np.inf + for start in range(0, len(times), 16): + tt = times[start:start+16] + exact = exact_mass_weighted_pressure(n, tt) + discrete = separable_pressure(full, tt) + continuous_norm = exact_pressure_norm_squared(tt) + unresolved = continuous_norm-np.sum(exact**2, axis=1) + subcell_min = min(subcell_min, float(unresolved.min())) + if unresolved.min() < -1e-9: + raise RuntimeError("Cell averages are not an orthogonal projection") + unresolved = np.maximum(unresolved, 0.) + contributions = { + "denominator_continuous": continuous_norm, + "denominator_discrete": np.sum(discrete**2, axis=1), + "projection_floor": unresolved, + "full": np.sum((discrete-exact)**2, axis=1)+unresolved} + for name, model in models.items(): + reduced = reduced_pressure(model, tt) + contributions[name+"_continuous"] = np.sum((reduced-exact)**2, axis=1)+unresolved + contributions[name+"_discrete"] = np.sum((reduced-discrete)**2, axis=1) + for j, end in enumerate((2, 8)): + active = tt <= end+1e-12 + for key, value in contributions.items(): + arrays[key][j] += value[active].sum(axis=0) + answer = {"full": field_summary(arrays["full"], arrays["denominator_continuous"]), + "projection_floor": field_summary(arrays["projection_floor"], arrays["denominator_continuous"]), + "minimum_subcell_squared_norm": subcell_min} + for name in models: + answer[name] = { + "total": field_summary(arrays[name+"_continuous"], arrays["denominator_continuous"]), + "same_grid": field_summary(arrays[name+"_discrete"], arrays["denominator_discrete"])} + return answer + + +def main(): + parser = argparse.ArgumentParser() + parser.add_argument("--grids", type=int, nargs="+", default=CFG["grids"]) + parser.add_argument("--no-rk", action="store_true") + args = parser.parse_args() + OUT.mkdir(exist_ok=True) + digest = hashlib.sha256((HERE/"config.json").read_bytes()).hexdigest() + verification = json.loads((OUT/"verification.json").read_text()) + if not verification["passed"]: + raise RuntimeError("Run verify.py successfully before the accuracy experiment") + times = np.linspace(0., CFG["time_end"], CFG["samples"]) + reference = exact_receiver(times) + save_arrays(OUT/"continuous_reference.npz", time=times, + receiver_pressure=reference, **continuous_data()) + dump(OUT/"environment.json", {"python": sys.version, "platform": platform.platform(), + "numpy": np.__version__, "scipy": scipy.__version__, "threadpools": threadpool_info(), + "cpu_affinity": sorted(os.sched_getaffinity(0)) if hasattr(os, "sched_getaffinity") else None, + "timing_scope": CFG["timing_scope"], "config_sha256": digest, + "code_sha256": {f.name: hashlib.sha256(f.read_bytes()).hexdigest() for f in HERE.glob("*.py")}}) + for n in args.grids: + started = time.perf_counter() + print(f"Building full discrete spectrum n={n}", flush=True) + full = separable_setup(n) + full_receiver = separable_receiver(full, times) + mass, A, J, B, R, rho, bulk = assembly(n) + models = {} + choices = [("craig_bampton", m) for m in CFG["modes_per_patch"]] + if n == CFG["modal_grid"] and not args.no_rk: + choices.extend(("rational_krylov", m) for m in CFG["rational_krylov_modes_per_patch"]) + for method, m in choices: + name = f"{method}_m{m}" + print(f"Building n={n}, {name}", flush=True) + details = {} + if method == "craig_bampton": + Q = cb_basis(n, mass, A, m) + else: + Q, details = rational_basis(mass, A, B, n+2*m) + Ar = Q.T @ (A@Q) + lam, V = linalg.eigh((Ar+Ar.T)/2, check_finite=False, driver="evd") + if lam[0] < -1e-9*max(lam[-1], 1.): + raise RuntimeError("Reduced stiffness is indefinite") + lam[lam < 1e-9] = 0. + W = Q@V + coeff = W.T@B + observation = R.T@W + omega = np.sqrt(lam) + yy = np.einsum("ir,tr,rs->tis", observation, np.cos(times[:, None]*omega[None]), coeff, optimize=True) + models[name] = {"omega": omega, "vectors": W, "coefficients": coeff, + "observation": observation, "receiver": yy, "method": method, "m": m, + "structure": {"orthonormality_frobenius": float(np.linalg.norm(Q.T@Q-np.eye(Q.shape[1]))), + "initial_pressure_projection_error": relative(Q@(Q.T@B), B), + "constant_mode_projection_error": relative(Q@(Q.T@np.sqrt(mass)), np.sqrt(mass)), **details}} + arrays = {"time": times, "omega": omega, "coefficients": coeff, + "observation": observation, "receiver_pressure": yy} + if n == CFG["modal_grid"]: + arrays["eigenvectors"] = W + save_arrays(OUT/f"n{n}_{name}.npz", **arrays) + print(f"Evaluating continuous pressure errors n={n}", flush=True) + field = field_errors(n, full, models, times) + full_record = {"grid": n, "method": "full_separable", "dimension": n*n, + "config_sha256": digest, "receiver_total_error": receiver_errors(full_receiver, reference, times), + "pressure_total_error": field["full"], "pressure_cell_projection_floor": field["projection_floor"], + "minimum_subcell_squared_norm": field["minimum_subcell_squared_norm"]} + dump(OUT/f"n{n}_full.json", full_record) + save_arrays(OUT/f"n{n}_full_receiver.npz", time=times, receiver_pressure=full_receiver) + if n == CFG["modal_grid"]: + omega, vectors, order = full_eigenvectors(full) + save_arrays(OUT/f"n{n}_full_spectrum.npz", omega=omega, eigenvectors=vectors, + mass=mass, source_coupling=vectors.T@B, receiver_coupling=R.T@vectors, B=B, R=R) + print(f"n={n} full: receiver {100*full_record['receiver_total_error']['T8']['relative_error']:.6f}%, field {100*field['full']['T8']['relative_error']:.6f}%", flush=True) + for name, model in models.items(): + reduction_error = model["receiver"]-full_receiver + grid_error = full_receiver-reference + cosine = {} + for end in (2, 8): + active = times <= end+1e-12 + er, eg = reduction_error[active], grid_error[active] + cosine[f"T{end}"] = float(np.sum(er*eg)/max(np.linalg.norm(er)*np.linalg.norm(eg), 1e-300)) + record = {"grid": n, "method": model["method"], "modes_per_patch": model["m"], + "dimension": len(model["omega"]), "config_sha256": digest, + "receiver_total_error": receiver_errors(model["receiver"], reference, times), + "receiver_same_grid_error": receiver_errors(model["receiver"], full_receiver, times), + "pressure_total_error": field[name]["total"], + "pressure_same_grid_error": field[name]["same_grid"], + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": field["projection_floor"], + "receiver_reduction_grid_error_cosine": cosine, "structure": model["structure"]} + dump(OUT/f"n{n}_{name}.json", record) + print(f"n={n} {name}: receiver total {100*record['receiver_total_error']['T8']['relative_error']:.6f}%, same grid {100*record['receiver_same_grid_error']['T8']['relative_error']:.6f}%", flush=True) + print(f"Completed accuracy grid n={n} in {time.perf_counter()-started:.2f} s (execution log, not a timing benchmark).", flush=True) + rows = [] + for file in sorted(OUT.glob("n*_*.json")): + rec = json.loads(file.read_text()) + for end in (2, 8): + window = f"T{end}" + rows.append({"grid": rec["grid"], "method": rec["method"], "modes_per_patch": rec.get("modes_per_patch", ""), + "dimension": rec["dimension"], "time_end": end, + "receiver_total_error": rec["receiver_total_error"][window]["relative_error"], + "continuous_pressure_total_error": rec["pressure_total_error"][window]["relative_error"], + "receiver_same_grid_error": rec.get("receiver_same_grid_error", {}).get(window, {}).get("relative_error", ""), + "pressure_same_grid_error": rec.get("pressure_same_grid_error", {}).get(window, {}).get("relative_error", ""), + "pressure_cell_projection_floor": rec["pressure_cell_projection_floor"][window]["relative_error"], + "receiver_error_vector_cosine": rec.get("receiver_reduction_grid_error_cosine", {}).get(window, "")}) + with (OUT/"summary.csv").open("w", newline="") as handle: + writer = csv.DictWriter(handle, fieldnames=list(rows[0])) + writer.writeheader() + writer.writerows(rows) + dump(OUT/"summary.json", {"configuration": CFG, "rows": rows}) + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + main() diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/verify.py b/unequal_speed_interface/verify.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..86e7b541d8883b534be1436403ecc6c69996ce90 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/verify.py @@ -0,0 +1,144 @@ +#!/usr/bin/env python3 +"""Independent accuracy and structural checks for the unequal-speed case.""" +import os +for key in ("OPENBLAS_NUM_THREADS", "OMP_NUM_THREADS", "MKL_NUM_THREADS", "NUMEXPR_NUM_THREADS"): + os.environ[key] = "2" +import json +from pathlib import Path +import sys +import numpy as np +from scipy import linalg +from scipy.sparse.linalg import expm_multiply + +HERE = Path(__file__).resolve().parent +sys.path.insert(0, str(HERE.parent)) +from unequal_speed_interface.kernel import ( + CFG, continuous_data, exact_receiver, roots, cosine_q, q_sine, characteristic, + assembly, separable_setup, separable_pressure, separable_receiver, + full_eigenvectors, x_tridiagonal, exact_mass_weighted_pressure, + exact_pressure_norm_squared, gauss_interval, x_values, y_values, +) + + +def relative(a, b): + return float(np.linalg.norm(a-b)/np.linalg.norm(b)) + + +def main(): + (HERE/"results").mkdir(exist_ok=True) + tt = np.linspace(0., CFG["time_end"], CFG["samples"]) + data = continuous_data(192) + fine = continuous_data(384) + finer_roots = continuous_data(192, .01) + rho = np.asarray(CFG["density"]) + kk = np.asarray(CFG["bulk_modulus"]) + q2 = data["q_squared"] + amp = data["amplitudes"] + cc = cosine_q(q2, [.5, .5]) + ss = q_sine(q2, [.5, .5])/rho + pressure_jump = amp[..., 0]*cc[..., 0]-amp[..., 1]*cc[..., 1] + flux_jump = amp[..., 0]*ss[..., 0]+amp[..., 1]*ss[..., 1] + flux_scale = np.maximum(np.linalg.norm(amp*ss, axis=-1), 1.) + pressure_scale = np.maximum(np.linalg.norm(amp*cc, axis=-1), 1.) + values = { + "sound_speeds": np.sqrt(kk/rho).tolist(), "impedances": np.sqrt(kk*rho).tolist(), + "pressure_jump_scaled_max": float(np.max(np.abs(pressure_jump)/pressure_scale)), + "normal_flux_jump_scaled_max": float(np.max(np.abs(flux_jump)/flux_scale)), + "x_beta_gram_max_error": float(np.max(np.abs(data["x_gram"]-np.eye(21)[None]))), + "y_gram_max_error": float(np.max(np.abs(data["y_gram"]-np.eye(17)))), + "initial_acoustic_energy": (.5*np.sum(data["coefficients"]**2, axis=(0, 1))).tolist(), + "zero_mode_coefficients": data["coefficients"][0, 0].tolist(), + "source_quadrature_relative_change_192_384": relative(data["coefficients"], fine["coefficients"]), + "receiver_quadrature_relative_change_192_384": relative(exact_receiver(tt, 192), exact_receiver(tt, 384)), + "root_scan_relative_change_002_001": relative(data["omega"], finer_roots["omega"]), + "receiver_root_scan_relative_change_002_001": relative(exact_receiver(tt), exact_receiver(tt, 192, .01)), + "number_of_finite_initial_modes": int(data["omega"].size-1), + "evanescent_segments_in_initial_modes": int(np.sum(q2 < 0)), + "time_propagation": "Exact modal cosine propagation; no time-stepping error.", + } + # The equal-speed spectrum supplies an independent regression target. + equal_errors = [] + for ell in (0, 1, 4, 8, 16): + computed = roots(ell, 21, (1., 8.), (1., 8.)) + exact = np.pi*np.sqrt(np.arange(21)**2+ell**2) + equal_errors.append(float(np.max(np.abs(computed-exact)/np.maximum(exact, 1.)))) + values["equal_speed_spectrum_relative_max_error"] = max(equal_errors) + # Check the continuous root ordering against converging independent 1-D + # FV eigenvalues. These FV spectra never define the continuous solution. + root_checks = [] + for ell in (0, 4, 8, 16): + omega = data["omega"][ell] + for n in (512, 1024, 2048): + d, e, speed2 = x_tridiagonal(n) + lam = linalg.eigh_tridiagonal(d+speed2*(ell*np.pi)**2, e, + eigvals_only=True, select="i", select_range=(0, 20)) + if ell == 0: + lam[0] = 0. + estimate = np.sqrt(np.maximum(lam, 0.)) + root_checks.append({"ell": ell, "cells": n, + "frequency_relative_max_error": float(np.max(np.abs(estimate-omega)/np.maximum(omega, 1.)))}) + values["independent_1d_root_checks"] = root_checks + values["independent_1d_finest_root_relative_max_error"] = max(r["frequency_relative_max_error"] for r in root_checks if r["cells"] == 2048) + n = 16 + mass, A, J, B, R, _, _ = assembly(n) + full = separable_setup(n) + omega, vectors, _ = full_eigenvectors(full) + values["separated_eigensystem_relative_residual"] = relative(A@vectors, vectors*omega[None]**2) + values["separated_eigensystem_orthogonality_error"] = float(np.max(np.abs(vectors.T@vectors-np.eye(n*n)))) + initial = np.zeros((J.shape[0], 3)) + initial[:n*n] = B + short_times = np.linspace(0., 8., 33) + state = expm_multiply(J, initial, start=0., stop=8., num=33, traceA=0.) + values["separated_vs_sparse_pressure_relative_error"] = relative(separable_pressure(full, short_times), state[:, :n*n]) + yy = np.einsum("ir,tis->trs", R, state[:, :n*n], optimize=True) + values["separated_vs_sparse_receiver_relative_error"] = relative(separable_receiver(full, short_times), yy) + values["energy_drift"] = float(np.max(np.abs(np.sum(state**2, axis=1)/np.sum(initial**2, axis=0)-1))) + values["generator_skew_defect"] = float(np.max(np.abs((J+J.T).data), initial=0.)) + # Direct in-cell quadrature verifies the continuous reconstruction identity. + nq = 10 + nodes, weights = np.polynomial.legendre.leggauss(nq) + x = ((np.arange(n)[:, None]+.5)/n+nodes[None]/(2*n)).ravel() + weight = np.tile(weights/(2*n), n) + beta = np.where(x < .5, 1/kk[0], 1/kk[1]) + y = y_values(x, 16) + time = .37 + exact = np.zeros((len(x), len(x))) + for ell in range(17): + xx = x_values(x, q2[ell], amp[ell]) + value = xx @ (data["coefficients"][ell, :, 0]*np.cos(data["omega"][ell]*time)) + exact += value[:, None]*y[:, ell][None] + numerical = separable_pressure(full, [time])[0, :, 0] + p0 = numerical/np.sqrt(mass) + reconstructed = np.repeat(np.repeat(p0.reshape(n, n), nq, axis=0), nq, axis=1) + direct = float(np.einsum("ij,i,j->", (reconstructed-exact)**2, weight*beta, weight)) + projected = exact_mass_weighted_pressure(n, [time])[0, :, 0] + identity = float(np.sum((numerical-projected)**2)+exact_pressure_norm_squared([time])[0, 0]-np.sum(projected**2)) + values["continuous_field_identity_relative_error"] = abs(identity-direct)/direct + values["norm_definition"] = "Continuous beta-weighted pressure norm, including orthogonal unresolved subcell contribution." + numerical_keys = [k for k in values if k.endswith(("max_error", "scaled_max", "relative_error", "relative_residual", "orthogonality_error"))] + # The independent FV-to-continuum convergence has O(h^2), not roundoff, error. + precise_keys = [k for k in numerical_keys if not k.startswith("independent_1d")] + precision_checks = precise_keys+[ + "source_quadrature_relative_change_192_384", "receiver_quadrature_relative_change_192_384", + "root_scan_relative_change_002_001", "receiver_root_scan_relative_change_002_001", "energy_drift"] + values["passed"] = (all(values[k] < 2e-9 for k in precision_checks) + and values["independent_1d_finest_root_relative_max_error"] < 2e-4 + and max(abs(v-1.) for v in values["initial_acoustic_energy"]) < 1e-11 + and max(abs(v) for v in values["zero_mode_coefficients"]) < 1e-13) + (HERE/"results"/"verification.json").write_text(json.dumps(values, indent=2, allow_nan=False)+"\n") + print(json.dumps(values, indent=2), flush=True) + if not values["passed"]: + raise RuntimeError("Unequal-speed verification failed") + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + import argparse + parser = argparse.ArgumentParser() + parser.add_argument("--results", action="store_true", + help="Verify saved trajectories, modal budgets, window statistics, and output hashes") + arguments = parser.parse_args() + if arguments.results: + from unequal_speed_interface.verify_outputs import main as verify_outputs_main + verify_outputs_main() + else: + main() diff --git a/unequal_speed_interface/verify_outputs.py b/unequal_speed_interface/verify_outputs.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4f937faaf4d1cd290fa8cbd2563dd01b32a73247 --- /dev/null +++ b/unequal_speed_interface/verify_outputs.py @@ -0,0 +1,161 @@ +"""Independently validate the saved numerical outputs without CB solves.""" +import csv +import hashlib +import json +from pathlib import Path +import numpy as np + +HERE = Path(__file__).resolve().parent +OUT = HERE/"results" + + +def norm(array): + return float(np.linalg.norm(array)) + + +def read_csv(name): + return list(csv.DictReader((OUT/name).open())) + + +def main(): + config = json.loads((HERE/"config.json").read_text()) + manifest = json.loads((OUT/"output_manifest.json").read_text()) + mismatches = [] + for family in ("source_hashes", "artifact_hashes"): + for name, expected in manifest[family].items(): + path = HERE/name + if not path.exists() or hashlib.sha256(path.read_bytes()).hexdigest() != expected: + mismatches.append(name) + reference = np.load(OUT/"continuous_reference.npz") + times, yf = reference["time"], reference["receiver_pressure"] + config_hash = hashlib.sha256((HERE/"config.json").read_bytes()).hexdigest() + rows = read_csv("summary.csv") + records = json.loads((OUT/"summary.json").read_text())["rows"] + expected_models = len(config["grids"])*(1+len(config["modes_per_patch"]))+len(config["rational_krylov_modes_per_patch"]) + total_error_defects, local_error_defects, cosine_defects, per_source_defects = [], [], [], [] + scalar_checks = [] + for row, json_row in zip(rows, records): + n, end = int(row["grid"]), int(row["time_end"]) + active = times <= end+1e-12 + full = np.load(OUT/f"n{n}_full_receiver.npz")["receiver_pressure"] + if row["method"] == "full_separable": + filename = OUT/f"n{n}_full.json" + observed = full + else: + stem = f"n{n}_{row['method']}_m{int(row['modes_per_patch'])}" + filename = OUT/f"{stem}.json" + observed = np.load(OUT/f"{stem}.npz")["receiver_pressure"] + stored = json.loads(filename.read_text()) + scalar_checks.append(stored["config_sha256"] == config_hash) + scalar_checks.append(int(json_row["grid"])==n and int(json_row["time_end"])==end and json_row["method"]==row["method"]) + error = norm(observed[active]-yf[active])/norm(yf[active]) + total_error_defects.extend((abs(error-float(row["receiver_total_error"])), + abs(error-stored["receiver_total_error"][f"T{end}"]["relative_error"]), + abs(error-json_row["receiver_total_error"]))) + for s in range(3): + per_source = norm(observed[active,:,s]-yf[active,:,s])/norm(yf[active,:,s]) + per_source_defects.append(abs(per_source-stored["receiver_total_error"][f"T{end}"]["per_source"][s])) + if row["method"] != "full_separable": + er, eg = observed[active]-full[active], full[active]-yf[active] + local_error = norm(er)/norm(full[active]) + cosine = float(np.sum(er*eg)/max(norm(er)*norm(eg),1e-300)) + local_error_defects.extend((abs(local_error-float(row["receiver_same_grid_error"])), + abs(local_error-stored["receiver_same_grid_error"][f"T{end}"]["relative_error"]))) + cosine_defects.extend((abs(cosine-float(row["receiver_error_vector_cosine"])), + abs(cosine-stored["receiver_reduction_grid_error_cosine"][f"T{end}"]), + abs(cosine-json_row["receiver_error_vector_cosine"]))) + pairs = read_csv("modal_pairs.csv") + modal_rows = json.loads((OUT/"modal_summary.json").read_text())["models"] + fine = np.load(OUT/"continuous_catalogue.npz") + coarse = np.load(OUT/f"n{config['modal_grid']}_full_spectrum.npz") + decompositions = {} + budget_defects, frequency_term_defects, counterfactual_defects, modal_stat_defects = [], [], [], [] + match_counts = {} + component_names = ("ritz_frequency", "grid_frequency", "source_coupling", "receiver_coupling", "unmatched") + for row in modal_rows: + name = row["model"] + paired = [p for p in pairs if p["model"]==name] + match_counts[name] = len(paired) + scalar_checks.append(len(paired)==row["accepted_triples"]) + ri = np.asarray([int(p["rom_mode"]) for p in paired]) + ci = np.asarray([int(p["coarse_mode"]) for p in paired]) + fi = np.asarray([int(p["continuous_mode"]) for p in paired]) + raw = np.load(OUT/f"n{config['modal_grid']}_{name}.npz") + data = dict(np.load(OUT/f"{name}_decomposition.npz")) + decompositions[name] = data + Hr = np.einsum("rj,js->jrs", raw["observation"][:,ri], raw["coefficients"][ri]) + Hf = np.einsum("rj,js->jrs", fine["c"][:,fi], fine["b"][fi]) + cos_r = np.cos(times[:,None]*raw["omega"][ri][None]) + cos_h = np.cos(times[:,None]*coarse["omega"][ci][None]) + cos_f = np.cos(times[:,None]*fine["omega"][fi][None]) + ritz = np.einsum("tj,jrs->trs",cos_r-cos_h,Hr,optimize=True) + grid = np.einsum("tj,jrs->trs",cos_h-cos_f,Hr,optimize=True) + coupling = np.einsum("tj,jrs->trs",cos_f,Hr-Hf,optimize=True) + frequency_term_defects.extend((norm(ritz-data["ritz_frequency"])/norm(yf), + norm(grid-data["grid_frequency"])/norm(yf), + norm(coupling-data["source_coupling"]-data["receiver_coupling"])/norm(yf))) + error = data["rom_response"]-yf + budget_defects.append(norm(error-sum(data[key] for key in component_names))/norm(error)) + counterfactual_defects.extend((norm(data["no_ritz_frequency_response"]-(raw["receiver_pressure"]-ritz))/norm(yf), + norm(data["continuous_frequency_response"]-(raw["receiver_pressure"]-ritz-grid))/norm(yf))) + for key,array in (("total_error",error), + ("coarse_frequency_replacement_error",data["no_ritz_frequency_response"]-yf), + ("continuous_frequency_replacement_error",data["continuous_frequency_response"]-yf)): + modal_stat_defects.append(abs(norm(array)/norm(yf)-row[key])) + for key in component_names: + modal_stat_defects.append(abs(norm(data[key])/norm(yf)-row[key+"_relative_norm"])) + wg = np.linalg.norm(Hf,axis=(1,2)) + wg /= wg.sum() + dg = (coarse["omega"][ci]-fine["omega"][fi])/fine["omega"][fi] + dr = (raw["omega"][ri]-coarse["omega"][ci])/fine["omega"][fi] + modal_stat_defects.extend((abs(float(wg@dg)-row["weighted_relative_grid_shift"]), + abs(float(wg@dr)-row["weighted_relative_ritz_shift"]))) + gram_defects = [] + for row in read_csv("modal_component_gram.csv"): + d = decompositions[row["model"]] + val = float(np.sum(d[row["component_a"]]*d[row["component_b"]])/norm(yf)**2) + gram_defects.append(abs(val-float(row["normalized_inner_product"]))) + windows = read_csv("receiver_time_windows.csv") + window_defects = [] + for row in windows: + active = (times >= float(row["start"])-1e-12)&(times <= float(row["end"])+1e-12) + r, s = int(row["receiver"])-1, int(row["source"])-1 + data = decompositions[row["model"]] + ref = yf[active,r,s] + original = norm(data["rom_response"][active,r,s]-ref)/norm(ref) + replaced = norm(data["no_ritz_frequency_response"][active,r,s]-ref)/norm(ref) + window_defects.extend((abs(original-float(row["original_error"])), + abs(replaced-float(row["coarse_replacement_error"])), + abs(100*(replaced-original)-float(row["coarse_replacement_change_percentage_points"])))) + report = { + "scope": "Independent checks from receiver traces and modal factors; no CB basis rebuild and no rerun of large-grid pressure histories.", + "expected_model_count":expected_models,"model_count":len(rows)//2, + "summary_csv_rows":len(rows),"summary_json_rows":len(records), + "modal_model_count":len(modal_rows),"matched_triples":match_counts, + "receiver_window_rows":len(windows),"expected_receiver_window_rows":len(modal_rows)*8*12, + "source_hashes_checked":len(manifest["source_hashes"]), + "artifact_hashes_checked":len(manifest["artifact_hashes"]),"hash_mismatches":mismatches, + "receiver_total_statistic_max_absolute_defect":max(total_error_defects,default=0.), + "receiver_same_grid_statistic_max_absolute_defect":max(local_error_defects,default=0.), + "receiver_per_source_statistic_max_absolute_defect":max(per_source_defects,default=0.), + "window_error_cosine_max_absolute_defect":max(cosine_defects,default=0.), + "modal_budget_max_relative_defect":max(budget_defects,default=0.), + "frequency_terms_reconstructed_max_normalized_defect":max(frequency_term_defects,default=0.), + "counterfactual_reconstructed_max_normalized_defect":max(counterfactual_defects,default=0.), + "modal_statistics_max_absolute_defect":max(modal_stat_defects,default=0.), + "component_gram_max_absolute_defect":max(gram_defects,default=0.), + "receiver_window_statistics_max_absolute_defect":max(window_defects,default=0.), + } + defect_keys = [k for k in report if "defect" in k] + report["passed"] = (not mismatches and all(scalar_checks) + and len(rows)==len(records)==2*expected_models + and len(windows)==report["expected_receiver_window_rows"] + and all(report[k] < 2e-10 for k in defect_keys)) + (OUT/"output_verification.json").write_text(json.dumps(report,indent=2,allow_nan=False)+"\n") + print(json.dumps(report,indent=2)) + if not report["passed"]: + raise RuntimeError("Unequal-speed output verification failed") + + +if __name__ == "__main__": + main()