{ "reference_grid": 512, "alternative_reference_grid": 384, "error_windows": [ 2.0, 8.0 ], "timing_time_end": 8.0, "norm": "Frobenius norm of three-source, four-receiver traces at all output times, including t=0.", "reference_scope": "Finite-grid comparison; neither the finest grid nor successive-grid differences certify continuum accuracy.", "timing_scope": "Fresh receiver-output experiment; independent assembly and reduced basis for each three-source query. No field-output timing is included.", "complete": true, "expected_timed_candidates_per_material": 26, "completed_timed_candidates": { "rotated_stripes": 26, "double_inclusion": 26, "smooth_checker": 26 }, "number_error_rows": 312, "material_rows": { "rotated_stripes": 104, "double_inclusion": 104, "smooth_checker": 104 }, "maximum_error_identity_residual": 9.71445146547012e-17, "selections": [ { "material": "rotated_stripes", "receiver_tolerance": 0.05, "tested_candidates": 26, "passing_candidates": 8, "least_cost_full": { "grid": 128, "method": "full_stormer_verlet", "modes_per_patch": null, "requested_cfl": 0.25, "dimension": 16384, "total_receiver_error": 0.04259216856395635, "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04046051819316749, "reference_grid_difference": 0.002293040730416934, "total_seconds": 2.4309769346145913, "minimum_total_seconds": 2.389581744908355, "maximum_total_seconds": 2.496616270742379, "primary_margin": 0.007407831436043656, "alternative_margin": 0.009539481806832513 }, "least_cost_reduced": { "grid": 128, "method": "craig_bampton", "modes_per_patch": 128, "requested_cfl": null, "dimension": 384, "total_receiver_error": 0.028692121733248043, "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.02692184900793251, "reference_grid_difference": 0.002293040730416934, "total_seconds": 1.8773641479201615, "minimum_total_seconds": 1.8768734860932454, "maximum_total_seconds": 1.8809097211342305, "primary_margin": 0.02130787826675196, "alternative_margin": 0.023078150992067493 }, "least_cost_any": { "grid": 128, "method": "craig_bampton", "modes_per_patch": 128, "requested_cfl": null, "dimension": 384, "total_receiver_error": 0.028692121733248043, "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.02692184900793251, "reference_grid_difference": 0.002293040730416934, "total_seconds": 1.8773641479201615, "minimum_total_seconds": 1.8768734860932454, "maximum_total_seconds": 1.8809097211342305, "primary_margin": 0.02130787826675196, "alternative_margin": 0.023078150992067493 }, "least_cost_any_alternative_reference": { "grid": 128, "method": "craig_bampton", "modes_per_patch": 128, "requested_cfl": null, "dimension": 384, "total_receiver_error": 0.028692121733248043, "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.02692184900793251, "reference_grid_difference": 0.002293040730416934, "total_seconds": 1.8773641479201615, "minimum_total_seconds": 1.8768734860932454, "maximum_total_seconds": 1.8809097211342305, "primary_margin": 0.02130787826675196, "alternative_margin": 0.023078150992067493 }, "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true, "candidates_changing_threshold_classification": 0, "speedup_over_least_cost_passing_full": 1.2948883344276867, "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.2704393613678513, "slowest_full_over_fastest_reduced": 1.3301995522027126, "timing_ranges_separated_in_favor_of_reduced": true }, { "material": "rotated_stripes", "receiver_tolerance": 0.1, "tested_candidates": 26, "passing_candidates": 16, "least_cost_full": { "grid": 96, "method": "full_stormer_verlet", "modes_per_patch": null, "requested_cfl": 0.25, "dimension": 9216, "total_receiver_error": 0.07465334468030119, "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0727425792397515, "reference_grid_difference": 0.002293040730416934, "total_seconds": 1.1179909447673708, "minimum_total_seconds": 1.1062234033597633, "maximum_total_seconds": 1.140757654211484, "primary_margin": 0.02534665531969882, "alternative_margin": 0.027257420760248507 }, "least_cost_reduced": { "grid": 96, "method": "craig_bampton", "modes_per_patch": 128, "requested_cfl": null, "dimension": 352, "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, "reference_grid_difference": 0.002293040730416934, "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087, "primary_margin": 0.03913826639233871, "alternative_margin": 0.04111521048392789 }, "least_cost_any": { "grid": 96, "method": "craig_bampton", "modes_per_patch": 128, "requested_cfl": null, "dimension": 352, "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, "reference_grid_difference": 0.002293040730416934, "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087, "primary_margin": 0.03913826639233871, "alternative_margin": 0.04111521048392789 }, "least_cost_any_alternative_reference": { "grid": 96, "method": "craig_bampton", "modes_per_patch": 128, "requested_cfl": null, "dimension": 352, "total_receiver_error": 0.0608617336076613, "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.058884789516072115, "reference_grid_difference": 0.002293040730416934, "total_seconds": 1.0159576621372253, "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0123570379801095, "maximum_total_seconds": 1.026163161965087, "primary_margin": 0.03913826639233871, "alternative_margin": 0.04111521048392789 }, "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true, "candidates_changing_threshold_classification": 0, "speedup_over_least_cost_passing_full": 1.100430644339551, "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.0780190172110273, "slowest_full_over_fastest_reduced": 1.1268333319315524, "timing_ranges_separated_in_favor_of_reduced": true }, { "material": "double_inclusion", "receiver_tolerance": 0.05, "tested_candidates": 26, "passing_candidates": 8, "least_cost_full": { "grid": 128, "method": "full_stormer_verlet", "modes_per_patch": null, "requested_cfl": 0.25, "dimension": 16384, "total_receiver_error": 0.03835286747767727, "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03635896966285459, "reference_grid_difference": 0.0020215697514913444, "total_seconds": 2.380482697626576, "minimum_total_seconds": 2.3631861011963338, "maximum_total_seconds": 2.446618514484726, "primary_margin": 0.011647132522322731, "alternative_margin": 0.013641030337145414 }, "least_cost_reduced": { "grid": 128, "method": "craig_bampton", "modes_per_patch": 128, "requested_cfl": null, "dimension": 384, "total_receiver_error": 0.025925649049562165, "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.02435135574390486, "reference_grid_difference": 0.0020215697514913444, "total_seconds": 1.8647517159115523, "minimum_total_seconds": 1.8503011669963598, "maximum_total_seconds": 1.866754246992059, "primary_margin": 0.024074350950437837, "alternative_margin": 0.025648644256095143 }, "least_cost_any": { "grid": 128, "method": "craig_bampton", "modes_per_patch": 128, "requested_cfl": null, "dimension": 384, "total_receiver_error": 0.025925649049562165, "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.02435135574390486, "reference_grid_difference": 0.0020215697514913444, "total_seconds": 1.8647517159115523, "minimum_total_seconds": 1.8503011669963598, "maximum_total_seconds": 1.866754246992059, "primary_margin": 0.024074350950437837, "alternative_margin": 0.025648644256095143 }, "least_cost_any_alternative_reference": { "grid": 128, "method": "craig_bampton", "modes_per_patch": 128, "requested_cfl": null, "dimension": 384, "total_receiver_error": 0.025925649049562165, "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.02435135574390486, "reference_grid_difference": 0.0020215697514913444, "total_seconds": 1.8647517159115523, "minimum_total_seconds": 1.8503011669963598, "maximum_total_seconds": 1.866754246992059, "primary_margin": 0.024074350950437837, "alternative_margin": 0.025648644256095143 }, "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true, "candidates_changing_threshold_classification": 0, "speedup_over_least_cost_passing_full": 1.2765681765107892, "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.2659331591205356, "slowest_full_over_fastest_reduced": 1.3222812362251184, "timing_ranges_separated_in_favor_of_reduced": true }, { "material": "double_inclusion", "receiver_tolerance": 0.1, "tested_candidates": 26, "passing_candidates": 16, "least_cost_full": { "grid": 96, "method": "full_stormer_verlet", "modes_per_patch": null, "requested_cfl": 0.25, "dimension": 9216, "total_receiver_error": 0.06968841179926823, "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.06775277401807797, "reference_grid_difference": 0.0020215697514913444, "total_seconds": 1.111911834217608, "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0990697019733489, "maximum_total_seconds": 1.1181928613223135, "primary_margin": 0.03031158820073178, "alternative_margin": 0.032247225981922034 }, "least_cost_reduced": { "grid": 96, "method": "craig_bampton", "modes_per_patch": 128, "requested_cfl": null, "dimension": 352, "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, "reference_grid_difference": 0.0020215697514913444, "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331, "primary_margin": 0.044473235375689694, "alternative_margin": 0.04635874115245533 }, "least_cost_any": { "grid": 96, "method": "craig_bampton", "modes_per_patch": 128, "requested_cfl": null, "dimension": 352, "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, "reference_grid_difference": 0.0020215697514913444, "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331, "primary_margin": 0.044473235375689694, "alternative_margin": 0.04635874115245533 }, "least_cost_any_alternative_reference": { "grid": 96, "method": "craig_bampton", "modes_per_patch": 128, "requested_cfl": null, "dimension": 352, "total_receiver_error": 0.05552676462431031, "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.05364125884754468, "reference_grid_difference": 0.0020215697514913444, "total_seconds": 1.0147776119410992, "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0119002169230953, "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0261704928707331, "primary_margin": 0.044473235375689694, "alternative_margin": 0.04635874115245533 }, "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true, "candidates_changing_threshold_classification": 0, "speedup_over_least_cost_passing_full": 1.0957197134953611, "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.0710400558280317, "slowest_full_over_fastest_reduced": 1.1050426145004932, "timing_ranges_separated_in_favor_of_reduced": true }, { "material": "smooth_checker", "receiver_tolerance": 0.05, "tested_candidates": 26, "passing_candidates": 16, "least_cost_full": { "grid": 96, "method": "full_stormer_verlet", "modes_per_patch": null, "requested_cfl": 0.25, "dimension": 9216, "total_receiver_error": 0.044935848571036587, "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.04370730851521943, "reference_grid_difference": 0.0013149765202111567, "total_seconds": 1.3141223517013714, "minimum_total_seconds": 1.3111928902799264, "maximum_total_seconds": 1.3150508869439363, "primary_margin": 0.005064151428963416, "alternative_margin": 0.006292691484780573 }, "least_cost_reduced": { "grid": 96, "method": "craig_bampton", "modes_per_patch": 128, "requested_cfl": null, "dimension": 352, "total_receiver_error": 0.03902036900814143, "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03778413248391995, "reference_grid_difference": 0.0013149765202111567, "total_seconds": 1.0179962200345472, "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0158594432286918, "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0283548481529579, "primary_margin": 0.010979630991858572, "alternative_margin": 0.012215867516080052 }, "least_cost_any": { "grid": 96, "method": "craig_bampton", "modes_per_patch": 128, "requested_cfl": null, "dimension": 352, "total_receiver_error": 0.03902036900814143, "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03778413248391995, "reference_grid_difference": 0.0013149765202111567, "total_seconds": 1.0179962200345472, "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0158594432286918, "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0283548481529579, "primary_margin": 0.010979630991858572, "alternative_margin": 0.012215867516080052 }, "least_cost_any_alternative_reference": { "grid": 96, "method": "craig_bampton", "modes_per_patch": 128, "requested_cfl": null, "dimension": 352, "total_receiver_error": 0.03902036900814143, "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.03778413248391995, "reference_grid_difference": 0.0013149765202111567, "total_seconds": 1.0179962200345472, "minimum_total_seconds": 1.0158594432286918, "maximum_total_seconds": 1.0283548481529579, "primary_margin": 0.010979630991858572, "alternative_margin": 0.012215867516080052 }, "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true, "candidates_changing_threshold_classification": 0, "speedup_over_least_cost_passing_full": 1.290891189808912, "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 1.2750393433112877, "slowest_full_over_fastest_reduced": 1.294520512369633, "timing_ranges_separated_in_favor_of_reduced": true }, { "material": "smooth_checker", "receiver_tolerance": 0.1, "tested_candidates": 26, "passing_candidates": 22, "least_cost_full": { "grid": 64, "method": "full_stormer_verlet", "modes_per_patch": null, "requested_cfl": 0.25, "dimension": 4096, "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, "reference_grid_difference": 0.0013149765202111567, "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235, "primary_margin": 0.002160883184336368, "alternative_margin": 0.0032661666302474246 }, "least_cost_reduced": { "grid": 64, "method": "rational_krylov", "modes_per_patch": 128, "requested_cfl": null, "dimension": 320, "total_receiver_error": 0.09836542367031906, "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.0972612760342237, "reference_grid_difference": 0.0013149765202111567, "total_seconds": 0.4943764810450375, "minimum_total_seconds": 0.49256946484092623, "maximum_total_seconds": 0.49870489502791315, "primary_margin": 0.001634576329680948, "alternative_margin": 0.0027387239657763046 }, "least_cost_any": { "grid": 64, "method": "full_stormer_verlet", "modes_per_patch": null, "requested_cfl": 0.25, "dimension": 4096, "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, "reference_grid_difference": 0.0013149765202111567, "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235, "primary_margin": 0.002160883184336368, "alternative_margin": 0.0032661666302474246 }, "least_cost_any_alternative_reference": { "grid": 64, "method": "full_stormer_verlet", "modes_per_patch": null, "requested_cfl": 0.25, "dimension": 4096, "total_receiver_error": 0.09783911681566364, "alternative_reference_total_receiver_error": 0.09673383336975258, "reference_grid_difference": 0.0013149765202111567, "total_seconds": 0.37619623343925923, "minimum_total_seconds": 0.3622753325616941, "maximum_total_seconds": 0.3821922924835235, "primary_margin": 0.002160883184336368, "alternative_margin": 0.0032661666302474246 }, "selection_unchanged_by_reference": true, "candidates_changing_threshold_classification": 0, "speedup_over_least_cost_passing_full": 0.7609509106178292, "fastest_full_over_slowest_reduced": 0.7264322772316423, "slowest_full_over_fastest_reduced": 0.7759155200717757, "timing_ranges_separated_in_favor_of_reduced": false } ] }