[ { "ID": 1, "Model": "DeepSeek-R1-0528", "Code Quality": { "General Functionality Correctness": 54.67, "Best Practices": 95.71, "Error Handling": 78.87, "Runtime Console Errors": 95.23, "Static Syntax Checking (Linting)": 97.53 }, "Visual Quality": { "General Visual Experience": 54.36, "Component Style Consistency": 96.53, "Icon Style Consistency": 57.58, "Layout Consistency": 86.69, "Layout Sparsity": 87.82, "Visual Harmony Degree": 70.38 }, "Content Quality": { "Copywriting Quality": 98.6, "Media Quality": 56.66, "Placeholder Quality": 95.99, "Resource Validity": 88.15 }, "Performance Quality": { "General Performance": 97.02 }, "Accessbility": { "Accessibility Core Metrics": 92.94, "Cross-Browser Compatibility": 96.47, "Mobile Device Compatibility": 89.47 }, "Maintainability": { "Code Redundancy Rate": 95.89, "Comment Rate": 78.76 }, "Alignment": { "Functional Alignment": 87.61, "Visual Alignment": 92.7, "Content Alignment": 88.77 } }, { "ID": 2, "Model": "DeepSeek-V3.1", "Code Quality": { "General Functionality Correctness": 53.68, "Best Practices": 95.68, "Error Handling": 78.53, "Runtime Console Errors": 92.44, "Static Syntax Checking (Linting)": 96.72 }, "Visual Quality": { "General Visual Experience": 40.65, "Component Style Consistency": 98.03, "Icon Style Consistency": 77.69, "Layout Consistency": 89.55, "Layout Sparsity": 82.99, "Visual Harmony Degree": 68.86 }, "Content Quality": { "Copywriting Quality": 98.67, "Media Quality": 51.94, "Placeholder Quality": 92.51, "Resource Validity": 69.33 }, "Performance Quality": { "General Performance": 97.6 }, "Accessbility": { "Accessibility Core Metrics": 91.27, "Cross-Browser Compatibility": 95.6, "Mobile Device Compatibility": 82.64 }, "Maintainability": { "Code Redundancy Rate": 96.18, "Comment Rate": 76.3 }, "Alignment": { "Functional Alignment": 89.02, "Visual Alignment": 93.02, "Content Alignment": 87.66 } }, { "ID": 3, "Model": "DeepSeek-V3.1-Terminus", "Code Quality": { "General Functionality Correctness": 56.25, "Best Practices": 95.94, "Error Handling": 76.12, "Runtime Console Errors": 96.5, "Static Syntax Checking (Linting)": 97.56 }, "Visual Quality": { "General Visual Experience": 86.4, "Component Style Consistency": 97.86, "Icon Style Consistency": 66, "Layout Consistency": 89.13, "Layout Sparsity": 87.51, "Visual Harmony Degree": 70.15 }, "Content Quality": { "Copywriting Quality": 98.64, "Media Quality": 38.12, "Placeholder Quality": 93.2, "Resource Validity": 76.44 }, "Performance Quality": { "General Performance": 98.19 }, "Accessbility": { "Accessibility Core Metrics": 92.63, "Cross-Browser Compatibility": 96.43, "Mobile Device Compatibility": 88.99 }, "Maintainability": { "Code Redundancy Rate": 97.33, "Comment Rate": 81.07 }, "Alignment": { "Functional Alignment": 89.77, "Visual Alignment": 92.18, "Content Alignment": 88.35 } }, { "ID": 4, "Model": "DeepSeek-V3.1-Thinking", "Code Quality": { "General Functionality Correctness": 54.03, "Best Practices": 95.65, "Error Handling": 78.74, "Runtime Console Errors": 90.93, "Static Syntax Checking (Linting)": 96.33 }, "Visual Quality": { "General Visual Experience": 41.12, "Component Style Consistency": 97.66, "Icon Style Consistency": 78.38, "Layout Consistency": 90.32, "Layout Sparsity": 83.17, "Visual Harmony Degree": 68.92 }, "Content Quality": { "Copywriting Quality": 98.67, "Media Quality": 57.21, "Placeholder Quality": 92.37, "Resource Validity": 70.44 }, "Performance Quality": { "General Performance": 97.97 }, "Accessbility": { "Accessibility Core Metrics": 91.25, "Cross-Browser Compatibility": 95.83, "Mobile Device Compatibility": 81.76 }, "Maintainability": { "Code Redundancy Rate": 96.46, "Comment Rate": 76.17 }, "Alignment": { "Functional Alignment": 88.82, "Visual Alignment": 91.7, "Content Alignment": 87.31 } }, { "ID": 5, "Model": "GLM-4.5", "Code Quality": { "General Functionality Correctness": 57.73, "Best Practices": 95.84, "Error Handling": 72.89, "Runtime Console Errors": 97.69, "Static Syntax Checking (Linting)": 97.6 }, "Visual Quality": { "General Visual Experience": 87.42, "Component Style Consistency": 98.1, "Icon Style Consistency": 72.42, "Layout Consistency": 89.06, "Layout Sparsity": 86.22, "Visual Harmony Degree": 69.21 }, "Content Quality": { "Copywriting Quality": 98.64, "Media Quality": 77.73, "Placeholder Quality": 100, "Resource Validity": 93.33 }, "Performance Quality": { "General Performance": 97.21 }, "Accessbility": { "Accessibility Core Metrics": 91.64, "Cross-Browser Compatibility": 96.56, "Mobile Device Compatibility": 84.01 }, "Maintainability": { "Code Redundancy Rate": 96.4, "Comment Rate": 77.52 }, "Alignment": { "Functional Alignment": 91.29, "Visual Alignment": 94.12, "Content Alignment": 89.18 } }, { "ID": 6, "Model": "Qwen3-Coder-Plus", "Code Quality": { "General Functionality Correctness": 54.95, "Best Practices": 95.13, "Error Handling": 79.71, "Runtime Console Errors": 96.75, "Static Syntax Checking (Linting)": 97.18 }, "Visual Quality": { "General Visual Experience": 46.27, "Component Style Consistency": 98.69, "Icon Style Consistency": 60, "Layout Consistency": 90.2, "Layout Sparsity": 86.58, "Visual Harmony Degree": 68.88 }, "Content Quality": { "Copywriting Quality": 98.69, "Media Quality": 42.78, "Placeholder Quality": 94.94, "Resource Validity": 79.69 }, "Performance Quality": { "General Performance": 98.54 }, "Accessbility": { "Accessibility Core Metrics": 93.13, "Cross-Browser Compatibility": 96.04, "Mobile Device Compatibility": 88.84 }, "Maintainability": { "Code Redundancy Rate": 98.44, "Comment Rate": 78.28 }, "Alignment": { "Functional Alignment": 86.79, "Visual Alignment": 89.89, "Content Alignment": 86.15 } }, { "ID": 7, "Model": "Qwen3-235B-A22B-Instruct", "Code Quality": { "General Functionality Correctness": 56.41, "Best Practices": 94.68, "Error Handling": 78.67, "Runtime Console Errors": 91.98, "Static Syntax Checking (Linting)": 95.11 }, "Visual Quality": { "General Visual Experience": 73.35, "Component Style Consistency": 98.53, "Icon Style Consistency": 64.29, "Layout Consistency": 92.11, "Layout Sparsity": 81.91, "Visual Harmony Degree": 66.89 }, "Content Quality": { "Copywriting Quality": 98.79, "Media Quality": 52.05, "Placeholder Quality": 95.16, "Resource Validity": 68.09 }, "Performance Quality": { "General Performance": 97.45 }, "Accessbility": { "Accessibility Core Metrics": 91.88, "Cross-Browser Compatibility": 95.77, "Mobile Device Compatibility": 90.46 }, "Maintainability": { "Code Redundancy Rate": 97.36, "Comment Rate": 76.85 }, "Alignment": { "Functional Alignment": 88.95, "Visual Alignment": 92.23, "Content Alignment": 88.77 } }, { "ID": 8, "Model": "MiniMax-M2", "Code Quality": { "General Functionality Correctness": 72.52, "Best Practices": 95.57, "Error Handling": 59.02, "Runtime Console Errors": 93.41, "Static Syntax Checking (Linting)": 90.42 }, "Visual Quality": { "General Visual Experience": 56.47, "Component Style Consistency": 94.14, "Icon Style Consistency": 73.59, "Layout Consistency": 88.97, "Layout Sparsity": 82.76, "Visual Harmony Degree": 69.48 }, "Content Quality": { "Copywriting Quality": 98.73, "Media Quality": 38.17, "Placeholder Quality": 98.55, "Resource Validity": 77.32 }, "Performance Quality": { "General Performance": 97.15 }, "Accessbility": { "Accessibility Core Metrics": 89.8, "Cross-Browser Compatibility": 96.44, "Mobile Device Compatibility": 81.99 }, "Maintainability": { "Code Redundancy Rate": 93.97, "Comment Rate": 82.17 }, "Alignment": { "Functional Alignment": 93.62, "Visual Alignment": 95.6, "Content Alignment": 92.11 } }, { "ID": 9, "Model": "Gemini-2.5-Pro", "Code Quality": { "General Functionality Correctness": 68.28, "Best Practices": 94.82, "Error Handling": 76.22, "Runtime Console Errors": 92.74, "Static Syntax Checking (Linting)": 94.81 }, "Visual Quality": { "General Visual Experience": 78.08, "Component Style Consistency": 96.04, "Icon Style Consistency": 84.82, "Layout Consistency": 85.07, "Layout Sparsity": 80.91, "Visual Harmony Degree": 66.7 }, "Content Quality": { "Copywriting Quality": 98.8, "Media Quality": 46.7, "Placeholder Quality": 98.03, "Resource Validity": 72.08 }, "Performance Quality": { "General Performance": 94.32 }, "Accessbility": { "Accessibility Core Metrics": 92.37, "Cross-Browser Compatibility": 96.4, "Mobile Device Compatibility": 83.86 }, "Maintainability": { "Code Redundancy Rate": 92.8, "Comment Rate": 74.59 }, "Alignment": { "Functional Alignment": 90.33, "Visual Alignment": 94.53, "Content Alignment": 89.03 } }, { "ID": 10, "Model": "GPT-4o-2024-11-20", "Code Quality": { "General Functionality Correctness": 49.42, "Best Practices": 95.58, "Error Handling": 86.32, "Runtime Console Errors": 83.97, "Static Syntax Checking (Linting)": 97.66 }, "Visual Quality": { "General Visual Experience": 59.13, "Component Style Consistency": 100, "Icon Style Consistency": 60, "Layout Consistency": 91.89, "Layout Sparsity": 74.96, "Visual Harmony Degree": 65.16 }, "Content Quality": { "Copywriting Quality": 98.88, "Media Quality": 46.77, "Placeholder Quality": 98.12, "Resource Validity": 55.53 }, "Performance Quality": { "General Performance": 94.07 }, "Accessbility": { "Accessibility Core Metrics": 93.65, "Cross-Browser Compatibility": 94.44, "Mobile Device Compatibility": 90.03 }, "Maintainability": { "Code Redundancy Rate": 94.38, "Comment Rate": 66.34 }, "Alignment": { "Functional Alignment": 73.14, "Visual Alignment": 77.38, "Content Alignment": 74.43 } }, { "ID": 11, "Model": "GPT-5-Codex-High", "Code Quality": { "General Functionality Correctness": 74.82, "Best Practices": 93.12, "Error Handling": 68.51, "Runtime Console Errors": 96.3, "Static Syntax Checking (Linting)": 94.4 }, "Visual Quality": { "General Visual Experience": 93.83, "Component Style Consistency": 97.1, "Icon Style Consistency": 74.49, "Layout Consistency": 80.96, "Layout Sparsity": 87.43, "Visual Harmony Degree": 67.46 }, "Content Quality": { "Copywriting Quality": 98.51, "Media Quality": 46.61, "Placeholder Quality": 98.51, "Resource Validity": 68.17 }, "Performance Quality": { "General Performance": 94.44 }, "Accessbility": { "Accessibility Core Metrics": 93.55, "Cross-Browser Compatibility": 96.29, "Mobile Device Compatibility": 92.42 }, "Maintainability": { "Code Redundancy Rate": 93.07, "Comment Rate": 62.62 }, "Alignment": { "Functional Alignment": 92.04, "Visual Alignment": 96.27, "Content Alignment": 92.93 } }, { "ID": 12, "Model": "GPT-5-High", "Code Quality": { "General Functionality Correctness": 79.18, "Best Practices": 95.66, "Error Handling": 51.17, "Runtime Console Errors": 95.33, "Static Syntax Checking (Linting)": 90.18 }, "Visual Quality": { "General Visual Experience": 90.62, "Component Style Consistency": 94.62, "Icon Style Consistency": 66.67, "Layout Consistency": 81.44, "Layout Sparsity": 84.85, "Visual Harmony Degree": 69.22 }, "Content Quality": { "Copywriting Quality": 98.57, "Media Quality": 37.52, "Placeholder Quality": 98.72, "Resource Validity": 74.75 }, "Performance Quality": { "General Performance": 98.08 }, "Accessbility": { "Accessibility Core Metrics": 88.75, "Cross-Browser Compatibility": 96.58, "Mobile Device Compatibility": 76.57 }, "Maintainability": { "Code Redundancy Rate": 91.09, "Comment Rate": 80.84 }, "Alignment": { "Functional Alignment": 96.94, "Visual Alignment": 97.54, "Content Alignment": 95.1 } }, { "ID": 13, "Model": "Manus", "Code Quality": { "General Functionality Correctness": 65.88, "Best Practices": 95.13, "Error Handling": 66.43, "Runtime Console Errors": 90.47, "Static Syntax Checking (Linting)": 100 }, "Visual Quality": { "General Visual Experience": 54.19, "Component Style Consistency": 100, "Icon Style Consistency": 53.33, "Layout Consistency": 87.8, "Layout Sparsity": 85.06, "Visual Harmony Degree": 67.82 }, "Content Quality": { "Copywriting Quality": 98.65, "Media Quality": 54.27, "Placeholder Quality": 96.08, "Resource Validity": 83.7 }, "Performance Quality": { "General Performance": 95.96 }, "Accessbility": { "Accessibility Core Metrics": 91.64, "Cross-Browser Compatibility": 95.44, "Mobile Device Compatibility": 87.12 }, "Maintainability": { "Code Redundancy Rate": 90.94, "Comment Rate": 82.31 }, "Alignment": { "Functional Alignment": 93.47, "Visual Alignment": 92.32, "Content Alignment": 90.02 } }, { "ID": 14, "Model": "MiniMax Agent", "Code Quality": { "General Functionality Correctness": 59.55, "Best Practices": 95.9, "Error Handling": 63.63, "Runtime Console Errors": 89.68, "Static Syntax Checking (Linting)": 100 }, "Visual Quality": { "General Visual Experience": 51.02, "Component Style Consistency": 91.5, "Icon Style Consistency": 61.33, "Layout Consistency": 88.53, "Layout Sparsity": 83.73, "Visual Harmony Degree": 68.27 }, "Content Quality": { "Copywriting Quality": 98.5, "Media Quality": 88.62, "Placeholder Quality": 100, "Resource Validity": 95.04 }, "Performance Quality": { "General Performance": 95.19 }, "Accessbility": { "Accessibility Core Metrics": 91.7, "Cross-Browser Compatibility": 94.63, "Mobile Device Compatibility": 88.35 }, "Maintainability": { "Code Redundancy Rate": 86.83, "Comment Rate": 83.19 }, "Alignment": { "Functional Alignment": 91.31, "Visual Alignment": 93.86, "Content Alignment": 88.25 } } ]