{ "Well tuned (DC motor, val #0)": "DC motor position control (QUBE-Servo 3 with inertia disc) under PID control (Kp=6.959, Ki=24.953, Kd=0.192). Requirements: settle within 840 ms with at most 15% overshoot, no more than 2 oscillation cycles, at most 2% error at the end and control ripple of at most 0.5%. Measured step response: peak overshoot of 6%, rise time 34 ms, 2% settling time 470 ms, 1 oscillation cycle, control ripple 0.0%, error at the end of the recording 0.0%, actuator never at its limit.", "Kp too high (DC motor, val #10)": "I am tuning a PID controller for DC motor position control (QUBE-Servo 3 with inertia disc). Requirements: settle within 1.30 s with at most 15% overshoot, no more than 2 oscillation cycles, at most 2% error at the end and control ripple of at most 0.6%. Gains are Kp=16.109, Ki=15.659, Kd=0.213. The step response shows 26% overshoot, 10-90% rise time 32 ms, control-signal ripple 0.2% of full scale, actuator saturated for 60 ms (2% of the recording), 2 oscillation cycles, error at the end of the recording 0.0%, settling time 328 ms. What is wrong?", "Overall gain too low (DC motor, val #20)": "System: DC motor position control (QUBE-Servo 3 with inertia disc)\nRequirements: settle within 1.30 s with at most 15% overshoot, no more than 2 oscillation cycles, at most 2% error at the end and control ripple of at most 0.3%\nPID gains: Kp=0.425, Ki=1.51, Kd=0.017\nObserved: overshoot 6%, 10-90% rise time 324 ms, actuator never at its limit, settling time 1.39 s, error at the end of the recording 0.5%, no oscillation, control-signal ripple 0.0% of full scale\nDiagnose the tuning.", "Ki too low (DC motor, val #28)": "System: DC motor position control (QUBE-Servo 3 with inertia disc)\nRequirements: settle within 1.70 s with at most 15% overshoot, no more than 2 oscillation cycles, at most 2% error at the end and control ripple of at most 0.3%\nPID gains: Kp=2.806, Ki=0.027, Kd=0.125\nObserved: overshoot 0%, rise time 102 ms, did not settle within the 5.10 s recording, error at the end of the recording 4.2%, no oscillation, actuator never at its limit, control ripple 0.0%\nDiagnose the tuning.", "Ki too high (DC motor, val #38)": "DC motor position control (QUBE-Servo 3 with inertia disc) under PID control (Kp=3.023, Ki=118, Kd=0.138). Requirements: settle within 310 ms with at most 15% overshoot, no more than 2 oscillation cycles, at most 2% error at the end and control ripple of at most 0.3%. Measured step response: overshoot 92%, rise time 36 ms, error at the end of the recording 1.4%, 2% settling time 1.18 s, actuator never at its limit, control-signal ripple 0.3% of full scale, 5 oscillation cycles.", "Kd too high (second-order, val #48)": "Plant: a second-order system (like a mass-spring-damper).\nRequirements: overshoot at most 15%, settling time at most 3.80 s, at most 2 oscillation cycles, error at most 2% at the end, control ripple at most 5.0%.\nGains: Kp=5.371, Ki=7.611, Kd=2.864.\nStep response: 15% overshoot, 10-90% rise time 838 ms, actuator never at its limit, 0.0% error left at the end of the recording, 1 oscillation cycle, control ripple 5.2%, 2% settling time 3.66 s.", "Actuator saturation (DC motor, val #53)": "System: DC motor position control (QUBE-Servo 3 with inertia disc)\nRequirements: overshoot at most 15%, settling time at most 1.00 s, at most 2 oscillation cycles, error at most 2% at the end, control ripple at most 0.8%\nPID gains: Kp=5.869, Ki=23.193, Kd=0.253\nObserved: peak overshoot of 39%, 10-90% rise time 142 ms, control-signal ripple 0.0% of full scale, error at the end of the recording 0.0%, actuator saturated for 230 ms (8% of the recording), settling time 956 ms, no oscillation\nDiagnose the tuning." }