"""Ceiling test + measurements for the strict Lean verifier (Track L / P1). House rule (paid for twice: a perfect policy scored 0/100 through a broken extractor, and mprm's PPO runs measured the grader): ceiling-test every instrument before trusting any number it produces. For a VERIFIER the ceiling has two sides, and both are checked: * known-good : proofs that independently compile under the pinned toolchain must be ACCEPTED (>= 98%): a strict gate that rejects honest proofs starves RL. * adversarial : hand-built exploits must ALL be REJECTED (0% accepted): a lax gate is exactly what a policy under RL finds. The criteria, the case tables (frozen, SHA-256 pinned) and the pass thresholds are pre-registered in docs/LEAN_VERIFIER.md BEFORE the registered run. `--verify-prereg` checks that the tables in this checkout hash to the registered value; the run refuses to start otherwise (override: --allow-unregistered, recorded in the output). Known-good sources 1. Goedel-LM/Lean-workbook-proofs (public, proofs verified by Goedel-Prover-V1 under the same Lean 4.9 / Mathlib environment as DeepSeek-Prover-V1.5 and Goedel-Prover-V2): 6 contiguous slices of 25 rows at fixed offsets, fetched over HTTP from the HF datasets-server (never the full dataset). 2. 30 hand-restated Mathlib-style theorems with proofs (scripts/lean_ceiling_cases.py). Each is first run through an INDEPENDENT compile-only pass (same REPL, no strictness at all: no error message, no `sorry` warning). Items that fail it are version-incompatible with the pin and are excluded and listed; the strict verdict is scored on the rest. Host rules (/apps/CLAUDE.md): `apply_resource_guards(heavy=True)` runs the preflight and takes the exclusive heavy-job flock; scratch lives under align/.tmp/; nothing touches / or /tmp; every blocking call has a timeout; the process has a global wall-clock watchdog. python scripts/lean_ceiling_test.py --workers 8 python scripts/lean_ceiling_test.py --verify-prereg python scripts/lean_ceiling_test.py --measure-only """ from __future__ import annotations import argparse import hashlib import json import math import os import re import statistics import subprocess import sys import threading import time import urllib.parse import urllib.request from pathlib import Path REPO = Path(__file__).resolve().parent.parent sys.path.insert(0, str(REPO)) import importlib.util # noqa: E402 # Loaded by path (not `import lean_ceiling_cases`): scripts/ is not a package, and the # dependency firewall (rightly) rejects an import it cannot place in stdlib/allowed/align. _spec = importlib.util.spec_from_file_location("lean_ceiling_cases", Path(__file__).with_name("lean_ceiling_cases.py")) C = importlib.util.module_from_spec(_spec) sys.modules["lean_ceiling_cases"] = C _spec.loader.exec_module(C) DOC = REPO / "docs" / "LEAN_VERIFIER.md" DATASET = "Goedel-LM/Lean-workbook-proofs" SLICE_OFFSETS = (0, 5000, 10000, 15000, 20000, 25000) SLICE_LEN = 25 KNOWN_GOOD_FLOOR = 0.98 MIN_KNOWN_GOOD = 50 MIN_ADVERSARIAL = 30 # ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- prereg def registered_hash() -> str | None: if not DOC.exists(): return None m = re.search(r"PREREG_TABLE_SHA256:\s*`?([0-9a-f]{64})`?", DOC.read_text()) return m.group(1) if m else None def verify_prereg() -> bool: reg, cur = registered_hash(), C.table_hash() print(f"registered : {reg}\ncurrent : {cur}\nmatch : {reg == cur}") return reg == cur # ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- verdict def empty_known_good_entry(candidates: int, excluded: int) -> dict: """Report entry for a run in which NO known-good proof reached the strict stage (toolchain broken, REPL crashing, header mismatch: every candidate failed the independent compile-only filter). That is the absence of the ceiling's first side, i.e. a FAILURE: a verifier that rejects everything would otherwise sail through the adversarial side (accepted == 0 is trivially true).""" return {"n": 0, "accepted": 0, "rate": float("nan"), "floor": KNOWN_GOOD_FLOOR, "pass": False, "why": f"no known-good proof survived the compile-only filter ({excluded}/{candidates} excluded)", "rejected": []} def ceiling_ok(report: dict, only: str | None) -> bool: """Exit-status verdict. Both sides must be PRESENT and passing in a full run; `--only` runs need the side they ran. A missing side is never a pass (the old `all(v.get('pass', True) ...)` read absence as success).""" need = {None: ("known_good", "adversarial"), "good": ("known_good",), "adversarial": ("adversarial",)}[only] if any(not isinstance(report.get(k), dict) or not report[k].get("pass") for k in need): return False return all(v.get("pass", True) for v in report.values() if isinstance(v, dict)) # ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- statistics def wilson(k: int, n: int, z: float = 1.96) -> tuple[float, float]: """Wilson score interval for a binomial proportion (exact-ish at k=n or k=0).""" if n == 0: return (float("nan"), float("nan")) p = k / n d = 1 + z * z / n c = (p + z * z / (2 * n)) / d h = z * math.sqrt(p * (1 - p) / n + z * z / (4 * n * n)) / d return (max(0.0, c - h), min(1.0, c + h)) def pctl(xs: list[float], q: float) -> float: if not xs: return float("nan") s = sorted(xs) return s[min(len(s) - 1, int(q * len(s)))] # ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- data def http_json(url: str, timeout: float = 60.0, retries: int = 4) -> dict: last = None for i in range(retries): try: req = urllib.request.Request(url, headers={"User-Agent": "align-lean-ceiling/1"}) with urllib.request.urlopen(req, timeout=timeout) as r: return json.loads(r.read().decode("utf-8")) except Exception as e: # noqa: BLE001 last = e time.sleep(2 * (i + 1)) raise RuntimeError(f"GET {url} failed: {last!r}") def fetch_known_good(out_dir: Path) -> tuple[list[dict], dict]: rows: list[dict] = [] for off in SLICE_OFFSETS: q = urllib.parse.urlencode( {"dataset": DATASET, "config": "default", "split": "train", "offset": off, "length": SLICE_LEN} ) d = http_json(f"https://datasets-server.huggingface.co/rows?{q}") for r in d["rows"]: rows.append({"problem_id": r["row"]["problem_id"], "full_proof": r["row"]["full_proof"], "row_idx": r["row_idx"]}) raw = out_dir / "known_good_raw.jsonl" with open(raw, "w") as f: for r in rows: f.write(json.dumps(r, ensure_ascii=False) + "\n") meta = {"dataset": DATASET, "offsets": list(SLICE_OFFSETS), "slice_len": SLICE_LEN, "n_rows": len(rows), "raw_sha256": hashlib.sha256(raw.read_bytes()).hexdigest()} try: info = http_json(f"https://huggingface.co/api/datasets/{DATASET}") meta["dataset_revision"] = info.get("sha") except Exception as e: # noqa: BLE001 meta["dataset_revision"] = f"unavailable: {e!r}" return rows, meta def derive_statement(code: str): """(statement, target_name) from a full proof file: header + the LAST theorem/lemma's signature (cut at the signature-ending `:=`, via the verifier's own scanner) + `sorry`.""" from align.verify.lean.strict import find_sig_end, lex lx = lex(code) toks = lx.toks if lx.broken: return None first = next((i for i, t in enumerate(toks) if t.kind == "id" and t.text in ("theorem", "lemma", "def", "abbrev", "instance", "example", "structure", "inductive")), None) thm = [i for i, t in enumerate(toks) if t.kind == "id" and t.text in ("theorem", "lemma")] if first is None or not thm: return None k = thm[-1] e = find_sig_end(toks, k + 2) if e is None or k + 1 >= len(toks): return None name = toks[k + 1].text header = code[: toks[first - 1].end] if first > 0 else "" sig = code[toks[k + 2].start : toks[e].start] return header + "\n\n" + f"theorem {name} {sig} := by\n sorry\n", name def as_completion(code: str) -> str: return "I will state a plan and then give the proof.\n\n```lean4\n" + code.rstrip("\n") + "\n```\n" # ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- compile-only def compile_only(w, statement: str, code: str, timeout: float = 120.0) -> dict: """The NAIVE grader: elaborate the candidate and look at nothing but error messages. Used (a) as the independent reference compile that defines "known-good", and (b) to show how many adversarial cases a compile-only reward would pay.""" from align.verify.lean.repl_pool import ReplError from align.verify.lean.strict import lex, parse_statement ref = parse_statement(statement) if not ref.ok: return {"ok": False, "why": "unsupported_statement"} lx = lex(code) nh = len(ref.header_toks) if lx.broken or tuple(t.text for t in lx.toks[:nh]) != ref.header_toks: return {"ok": False, "why": "header"} body = code[lx.toks[nh - 1].end :] if nh else code try: env = w.header_env(ref.header_text) resp = w.command(body, env, timeout) except ReplError as e: return {"ok": False, "why": e.code} msgs = [m for m in resp.get("messages", []) if isinstance(m, dict)] err = [m for m in msgs if m.get("severity") == "error"] sorry = bool(resp.get("sorries")) or any("sorry" in str(m.get("data", "")) for m in msgs) return {"ok": not err, "clean": (not err) and (not sorry), "why": "error" if err else ("sorry" if sorry else "")} def naive_fresh(w, code: str, timeout: float = 120.0) -> dict: """Compile-only on the candidate's OWN header (fresh import, no cache) -- for the adversarial cases whose header is the attack. Each case gets a FRESH process: a second `import Mathlib` in a live REPL costs +3.9GiB anonymous (see `split_imports`).""" from align.verify.lean.repl_pool import ReplError w.discard() try: proc = w.ensure() resp = proc.request({"cmd": code}, timeout) except ReplError as e: w.discard() return {"ok": False, "why": e.code} w.discard() err = [m for m in resp.get("messages", []) if isinstance(m, dict) and m.get("severity") == "error"] return {"ok": not err, "why": "error" if err else ""} # ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- measurement def dir_bytes(p: Path) -> int: out = subprocess.run(["du", "-sb", str(p)], capture_output=True, text=True, timeout=300) return int(out.stdout.split()[0]) if out.returncode == 0 and out.stdout else -1 def evict_page_cache(tc) -> dict: """Drop the page cache for every .olean/.ilean under the install (POSIX_FADV_DONTNEED works unprivileged for clean, unmapped pages) so the next import is a COLD read.""" n = tot = 0 roots = [tc.workspace / ".lake" / "packages", tc.root / "elan" / "toolchains"] for r in roots: for dp, _dn, fns in os.walk(r): for fn in fns: if fn.endswith((".olean", ".ilean", ".so")): fp = os.path.join(dp, fn) try: fd = os.open(fp, os.O_RDONLY) try: tot += os.fstat(fd).st_size os.posix_fadvise(fd, 0, 0, os.POSIX_FADV_DONTNEED) n += 1 finally: os.close(fd) except OSError: pass return {"files": n, "bytes": tot} def cached_fraction(tc) -> float | None: """Fraction of the Mathlib .olean bytes resident in page cache, via `fincore` if present.""" import shutil f = shutil.which("fincore") if not f: return None lib = tc.workspace / ".lake" / "packages" / "mathlib" / ".lake" / "build" / "lib" / "Mathlib" files = [str(p) for p in lib.rglob("*.olean")][:4000] try: out = subprocess.run([f, "--bytes", "--raw", "--noheadings", *files], capture_output=True, text=True, timeout=120) res = tot = 0 for line in out.stdout.splitlines(): parts = line.split() if len(parts) >= 3 and parts[0].isdigit(): res += int(parts[0]) tot += int(parts[1]) return res / tot if tot else None except Exception: # noqa: BLE001 return None def measure_install(tc, workers: int, out: dict) -> None: from align.verify.lean.repl_pool import ReplLimits, ReplPool, ReplProcess m: dict = {} m["disk_bytes"] = { "total": dir_bytes(tc.root), "elan_toolchain": dir_bytes(tc.root / "elan"), "workspace": dir_bytes(tc.workspace), "mathlib_package": dir_bytes(tc.workspace / ".lake" / "packages" / "mathlib"), "repl": dir_bytes(tc.root / "repl"), } hdr = C.HEADER.rstrip("\n") def one_import() -> tuple[float, dict | None]: p = ReplProcess(tc.argv(), tc.child_env, cwd=tc.cwd, limits=ReplLimits()) p.start() t = time.monotonic() r = p.request({"cmd": hdr}, 900) dt = time.monotonic() - t assert "env" in r and not r.get("messages"), r mem = p.memory() p.kill() return dt, mem ev = evict_page_cache(tc) m["evicted"] = ev m["cached_fraction_after_evict"] = cached_fraction(tc) cold, cold_mem = one_import() m["cached_fraction_after_cold_import"] = cached_fraction(tc) warm = [one_import()[0] for _ in range(3)] m["import_s"] = {"cold": cold, "warm": warm, "warm_median": statistics.median(warm)} m["single_repl_after_import_mib"] = cold_mem # N workers concurrently warm: per-process PSS (RSS double-counts the shared oleans) pool = ReplPool.from_toolchain(tc, n_workers=workers, scratch_dir=str(tc.root / "tmp" / "measure")) try: t = time.monotonic() errs = pool.warm(hdr) m["pool_warm_s"] = time.monotonic() - t assert not any(errs), errs rep = pool.memory_report() m["n_workers"] = workers m["per_worker_mib"] = rep pss = [r["pss"] for r in rep if r] m["pss_mib"] = {"min": min(pss), "mean": statistics.mean(pss), "max": max(pss), "sum": sum(pss)} m["pss_anon_mib"] = {"mean": statistics.mean(r["pss_anon"] for r in rep if r)} m["rss_sum_mib"] = sum(r["rss"] for r in rep if r) finally: pool.close() out["install"] = m # ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- confusion def confusion(good_acc: list[bool], bad_acc: list[bool]) -> dict: tp = sum(good_acc) fn = len(good_acc) - tp fp = sum(bad_acc) tn = len(bad_acc) - fp return {"TP": tp, "FN": fn, "FP": fp, "TN": tn, "n_good": len(good_acc), "n_bad": len(bad_acc)} def render_confusion(c: dict) -> str: return ( " verdict ACCEPT verdict REJECT total\n" f"truth GOOD proofs {c['TP']:>14} {c['FN']:>14} {c['n_good']:>5}\n" f"truth BAD proofs {c['FP']:>14} {c['TN']:>14} {c['n_bad']:>5}\n" ) # ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- main def sample_memory(pool, stop: threading.Event, rows: list) -> None: while not stop.is_set(): try: rep = pool.memory_report() with open("/proc/meminfo") as f: avail = next(int(l.split()[1]) for l in f if l.startswith("MemAvailable:")) / 1024**2 rows.append({"t": time.time(), "workers": rep, "mem_available_gb": avail}) except Exception: # noqa: BLE001 pass stop.wait(0.5) def main() -> int: ap = argparse.ArgumentParser() ap.add_argument("--workers", type=int, default=None) ap.add_argument("--out", default=None) ap.add_argument("--verify-prereg", action="store_true") ap.add_argument("--allow-unregistered", action="store_true") ap.add_argument("--measure-only", action="store_true") ap.add_argument("--skip-measure", action="store_true") ap.add_argument("--max-wall-s", type=float, default=3600.0) ap.add_argument("--no-semantic-pass", action="store_true") ap.add_argument("--no-naive-pass", action="store_true") ap.add_argument("--only", choices=("good", "adversarial"), default=None) ap.add_argument("--exploratory", action="store_true", help="debug run: <=2 workers, no heavy-job lock (a registered run always takes it)") ap.add_argument("--lock-wait-s", type=float, default=7200.0) ap.add_argument("--no-kernel-recheck", action="store_true", help="known-good pass without the kernel recheck (default: on, as in the shipped config)") ap.add_argument("--kg-limit", type=int, default=0, help="exploratory only: keep the first N rows of each fetched slice (0 = all)") args = ap.parse_args() if args.verify_prereg: return 0 if verify_prereg() else 2 registered = registered_hash() == C.table_hash() if not registered and not args.allow_unregistered and not args.measure_only: print("REFUSING: case tables do not match the registered hash (see --verify-prereg); " "pass --allow-unregistered for an exploratory run", file=sys.stderr) return 2 os.environ.setdefault("HF_HOME", "/apps/development/rlhf/hf_cache") os.environ.setdefault("HF_HUB_DISABLE_XET", "1") from align.utils.guard import apply_resource_guards apply_resource_guards(cpu_threads=8, heavy=False, label="lean_ceiling_test") if not args.exploratory: # A Lean pool is a heavy job (research report, section 7A): same preflight + the same # exclusive flock as the trainers. If a GPU job holds it, WAIT -- never overlap. from align.exit_codes import PreflightRefused from align.utils.guard import acquire_heavy_job_lock, preflight_host_check t_wait = time.monotonic() while True: try: preflight_host_check(strict=True) acquire_heavy_job_lock("lean_ceiling_test") break except PreflightRefused as e: if time.monotonic() - t_wait > args.lock_wait_s: print(f"gave up waiting for the host: {e}", file=sys.stderr) return 83 print(f"host busy ({str(e)[:120]}...); retrying in 30s", flush=True) time.sleep(30) elif (args.workers or 2) > 2: print("--exploratory caps workers at 2", file=sys.stderr) args.workers = 2 from align.verify.lean import ( LeanAccuracy, ReplLimits, ReplPool, StrictConfig, StrictVerifier, default_workers, find_toolchain, ) from align.verify.lean.repl_pool import meminfo_available_gb, plan_workers tc = find_toolchain() limits = ReplLimits() n = args.workers or default_workers() n = plan_workers(n, limits.anon_cap_gb, 4.0, meminfo_available_gb()) stamp = time.strftime("%Y%m%d_%H%M%S") out_dir = Path(args.out or REPO / ".tmp" / "lean_ceiling" / stamp) out_dir.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True) pools: list = [] def watchdog() -> None: time.sleep(args.max_wall_s) print(f"WATCHDOG: {args.max_wall_s}s exceeded; killing pools", file=sys.stderr, flush=True) for p in pools: try: p.close() except Exception: # noqa: BLE001 pass os._exit(124) threading.Thread(target=watchdog, daemon=True).start() def on_signal(signum, _frame): print(f"signal {signum}: closing pools", file=sys.stderr, flush=True) for p in pools: try: p.close() except Exception: # noqa: BLE001 pass os._exit(128 + signum) import signal signal.signal(signal.SIGTERM, on_signal) signal.signal(signal.SIGINT, on_signal) result: dict = { "started": stamp, "toolchain": tc.describe(), "pins": tc.pins, "workers": n, "limits": limits.__dict__, "prereg_registered": registered, "table_sha256": C.table_hash(), "cores": os.cpu_count(), } def new_pool(workers: int, lim: ReplLimits = limits, label: str = "pool") -> ReplPool: p = ReplPool.from_toolchain(tc, n_workers=workers, limits=lim, scratch_dir=str(tc.root / "tmp" / label)) pools.append(p) return p # -------------------------------------------------- install measurements if not args.skip_measure and args.only is None: print("== measuring install ==", flush=True) measure_install(tc, n, result) print(json.dumps(result["install"], indent=1, default=str)[:3000], flush=True) if args.measure_only: (out_dir / "result.json").write_text(json.dumps(result, indent=1, default=str)) return 0 # -------------------------------------------------- known-good good_items: list[dict] = [] if args.only in (None, "good"): print("== known-good: fetching ==", flush=True) rows, meta = fetch_known_good(out_dir) if args.kg_limit: if not args.exploratory: print("--kg-limit is for exploratory runs only", file=sys.stderr) return 2 rows = [r for i, r in enumerate(rows) if i % SLICE_LEN < args.kg_limit] meta["kg_limit"] = args.kg_limit result["known_good_source"] = meta cands = [] for r in rows: code = r["full_proof"] ds = derive_statement(code) if ds is None: cands.append({"id": r["problem_id"], "source": "lean-workbook-proofs", "code": code, "statement": None}) else: cands.append({"id": r["problem_id"], "source": "lean-workbook-proofs", "code": code, "statement": ds[0]}) for rs in C.RESTATED: code = C.HEADER + rs["code"] ds = derive_statement(code) cands.append({"id": rs["id"], "source": "restated", "code": code, "statement": ds[0] if ds else None}) result["known_good_candidates"] = len(cands) print("== known-good: independent compile-only filter ==", flush=True) pool = new_pool(n, label="kg_compile") t0 = time.monotonic() refs = pool.map( lambda w, it: compile_only(w, it["statement"], it["code"]) if it["statement"] else {"ok": False, "clean": False, "why": "no_statement"}, cands, ) pool.close() excluded = [] for it, r in zip(cands, refs): if isinstance(r, Exception): r = {"ok": False, "clean": False, "why": repr(r)} it["ref"] = r if r.get("clean"): good_items.append(it) else: excluded.append({"id": it["id"], "source": it["source"], "why": r.get("why")}) result["known_good_excluded"] = excluded result["known_good_filter_s"] = time.monotonic() - t0 print(f"compile-clean: {len(good_items)}/{len(cands)} excluded: {len(excluded)}", flush=True) # -------------------------------------------------- known-good: strict good_results: list[dict] = [] if good_items: print("== known-good: strict verification ==", flush=True) pool = new_pool(n, label="kg_strict") acc = LeanAccuracy(StrictVerifier(pool, StrictConfig(kernel_recheck=not args.no_kernel_recheck))) from align.verify.lean.strict import AUDIT_PRELUDE, static_check plan, _, _ = static_check(good_items[0]["statement"], good_items[0]["code"]) t = time.monotonic() pool.warm(plan.header if plan else C.HEADER, AUDIT_PRELUDE) result["strict_warm_s"] = time.monotonic() - t result["warm_memory_mib"] = pool.memory_report() stop, mem_rows = threading.Event(), [] th = threading.Thread(target=sample_memory, args=(pool, stop, mem_rows), daemon=True) th.start() t = time.monotonic() def prog(ix, r): print(f" [{ix:3d}] {good_items[ix]['id']:34s} {'ACCEPT' if r.accepted else 'REJECT'} {r.elapsed_s:7.2f}s {list(r.reasons)}", flush=True) accs, res = acc.accuracy_batch([g["statement"] for g in good_items], [as_completion(g["code"]) for g in good_items], progress=prog) wall = time.monotonic() - t stop.set() th.join(5) for g, a, r in zip(good_items, accs, res): good_results.append({"id": g["id"], "source": g["source"], "accepted": bool(a), "reasons": list(r.reasons), "diag": r.diagnostics, "elapsed_s": r.elapsed_s}) lat = [r.elapsed_s for r in res] result["throughput"] = { "n_proofs": len(res), "wall_s": wall, "proofs_per_s": len(res) / wall, "workers": n, "latency_s": {"p50": pctl(lat, 0.5), "p90": pctl(lat, 0.9), "p99": pctl(lat, 0.99), "max": max(lat), "mean": statistics.mean(lat)}, "note": "unique statement per proof (no reference-env reuse across proofs); warm workers", } # per-worker PSS during the run per_w: dict[int, list] = {} for row in mem_rows: for i, m in enumerate(row["workers"]): if m: per_w.setdefault(i, []).append(m) result["pss_during_run_mib"] = { str(i): {"pss_mean": statistics.mean(m["pss"] for m in ms), "pss_max": max(m["pss"] for m in ms), "pss_anon_max": max(m["pss_anon"] for m in ms), "rss_max": max(m["rss"] for m in ms), "samples": len(ms)} for i, ms in sorted(per_w.items()) } result["host_during_run"] = {"min_mem_available_gb": min((r["mem_available_gb"] for r in mem_rows), default=None)} result["pool_stats"] = pool.stats.__dict__ # repeat-G run: GRPO shape (same statement x8, reference env reused) on the 12 # MEDIAN-latency statements of the pass above (the heavy tail would swamp a 96-proof run) order = sorted(range(len(good_items)), key=lambda i: res[i].elapsed_s) mid = max(0, len(order) // 2 - 6) rep = [good_items[i] for i in order[mid : mid + 12]] * 8 t = time.monotonic() accs2, _ = acc.accuracy_batch([g["statement"] for g in rep], [as_completion(g["code"]) for g in rep]) w2 = time.monotonic() - t result["throughput_grpo_shape"] = {"n_proofs": len(rep), "wall_s": w2, "proofs_per_s": len(rep) / w2, "accepted": int(sum(accs2)), "shape": "12 median-latency statements x 8 identical samples"} pool.close() # -------------------------------------------------- adversarial adv_results: list[dict] = [] if args.only in (None, "adversarial"): print("== adversarial: strict ==", flush=True) def completion_for(case) -> tuple[str, str | None]: stmt = C.HEADER + C.STATEMENTS[case["statement"]] if case["completion"] is not None: return stmt, case["completion"] hdr = C.HEADER if case["raw_header"] is None else case["raw_header"] return stmt, as_completion(hdr + case["code"]) main_cases = [c for c in C.ADVERSARIAL if c["pool"] == "main"] bomb_cases = [c for c in C.ADVERSARIAL if c["pool"] == "bomb"] pool = new_pool(n, label="adv_strict") acc = LeanAccuracy(StrictVerifier(pool, StrictConfig(proof_timeout_s=120)), min_batch=10**9) pairs = [completion_for(c) for c in main_cases] _, rs = acc.accuracy_batch([p[0] for p in pairs], [p[1] for p in pairs]) pool.close() by_id = {} for c, r in zip(main_cases, rs): by_id[c["id"]] = {"id": c["id"], "category": c["category"], "accepted": r.accepted, "reasons": list(r.reasons), "stage": r.stage, "diag": r.diagnostics, "elapsed_s": r.elapsed_s, "pool": "main"} # bombs: 1 worker, 1 GiB anon cap, 30 s budget so they terminate promptly (same code paths) blim = ReplLimits(anon_cap_gb=1.0) bpool = new_pool(1, blim, label="adv_bomb") bacc = LeanAccuracy(StrictVerifier(bpool, StrictConfig(proof_timeout_s=30)), min_batch=10**9) for c in bomb_cases: stmt, comp = completion_for(c) sc = bacc.score(stmt, comp) by_id[c["id"]] = {"id": c["id"], "category": c["category"], "accepted": sc.result.accepted, "reasons": list(sc.result.reasons), "stage": sc.result.stage, "diag": sc.result.diagnostics, "elapsed_s": sc.result.elapsed_s, "pool": "bomb(1w,1GiB,30s)"} bpool.close() adv_results = [by_id[c["id"]] for c in C.ADVERSARIAL] # naive compile-only on each case's own text (what a compile-only reward would pay) if not args.no_naive_pass: print("== adversarial: naive compile-only (liveness) ==", flush=True) npool = new_pool(n, label="adv_naive") live_cases = [c for c in main_cases if c["completion"] is None and c["code"]] texts = [(c["raw_header"] if c["raw_header"] is not None else C.HEADER) + c["code"] for c in live_cases] nv = npool.map(lambda w, t: naive_fresh(w, t, 120.0), texts) npool.close() naive = {c["id"]: (v if not isinstance(v, Exception) else {"ok": False, "why": repr(v)}) for c, v in zip(live_cases, nv)} for r in adv_results: r["naive_compile_ok"] = naive.get(r["id"], {}).get("ok") # semantic layer alone (lexical gate OFF): how much does the Lean-side audit catch by itself? if not args.no_semantic_pass: print("== adversarial: semantic layer only (lexical gate off) ==", flush=True) spool = new_pool(n, label="adv_sem") sv = StrictVerifier(spool, StrictConfig(lexical_gate=False, kernel_recheck=True, proof_timeout_s=120)) sem_cases = [c for c in main_cases if c["completion"] is None and c["code"]] from align.verify.lean.reward import extract_lean_code sem_items = [] for c in sem_cases: stmt, comp = completion_for(c) sem_items.append((stmt, extract_lean_code(comp))) sres = sv.verify_batch(sem_items) spool.close() sem = {c["id"]: (r.accepted, list(r.reasons)) for c, r in zip(sem_cases, sres)} for r in adv_results: if r["id"] in sem: r["semantic_only_accepted"], r["semantic_only_reasons"] = sem[r["id"]] # -------------------------------------------------- report report = {} if not good_results and args.only in (None, "good"): report["known_good"] = empty_known_good_entry( result.get("known_good_candidates", 0), len(result.get("known_good_excluded", [])) ) if good_results: acc_good = [g["accepted"] for g in good_results] lo, hi = wilson(sum(acc_good), len(acc_good)) report["known_good"] = {"n": len(acc_good), "accepted": sum(acc_good), "rate": sum(acc_good) / len(acc_good), "wilson95": [lo, hi], "floor": KNOWN_GOOD_FLOOR, "pass": (sum(acc_good) / len(acc_good) >= KNOWN_GOOD_FLOOR and len(acc_good) >= MIN_KNOWN_GOOD), "rejected": [g for g in good_results if not g["accepted"]]} if adv_results: acc_bad = [a["accepted"] for a in adv_results] by_cat: dict[str, list] = {} for a in adv_results: by_cat.setdefault(a["category"], []).append(a["accepted"]) report["adversarial"] = {"n": len(acc_bad), "accepted": sum(acc_bad), "pass": (sum(acc_bad) == 0 and len(acc_bad) >= MIN_ADVERSARIAL), "by_category": {k: {"n": len(v), "accepted": sum(v)} for k, v in sorted(by_cat.items())}, "accepted_cases": [a for a in adv_results if a["accepted"]]} live = [a for a in adv_results if a.get("naive_compile_ok")] report["adversarial"]["naive_compile_only_would_accept"] = len(live) if any("semantic_only_accepted" in a for a in adv_results): sem_acc = [a for a in adv_results if a.get("semantic_only_accepted")] report["adversarial"]["semantic_only_would_accept"] = [a["id"] for a in sem_acc] if good_results and adv_results: report["confusion"] = confusion([g["accepted"] for g in good_results], [a["accepted"] for a in adv_results]) result["report"] = report result["good_results"] = good_results result["adversarial_results"] = adv_results (out_dir / "result.json").write_text(json.dumps(result, indent=1, default=str, ensure_ascii=False)) print("\n================ RESULT ================") if "confusion" in report: print(render_confusion(report["confusion"])) if report.get("known_good", {}).get("n"): k = report["known_good"] print(f"known-good accepted {k['accepted']}/{k['n']} = {k['rate']:.4f} Wilson95 [{k['wilson95'][0]:.4f}, {k['wilson95'][1]:.4f}] floor {k['floor']} PASS={k['pass']}") for g in k["rejected"]: print(" REJECTED known-good:", g["id"], g["reasons"], g["diag"]) if "adversarial" in report: a = report["adversarial"] print(f"adversarial accepted {a['accepted']}/{a['n']} PASS={a['pass']} (naive compile-only would accept {a['naive_compile_only_would_accept']})") for c in a["accepted_cases"]: print(" ACCEPTED adversarial:", c["id"], c["reasons"]) if "throughput" in result: print("throughput:", json.dumps(result["throughput"])) print(f"results: {out_dir/'result.json'}") if "known_good" in report and not report["known_good"]["n"]: print(f"known-good: NO EVIDENCE -- {report['known_good']['why']} PASS=False") return 0 if ceiling_ok(report, args.only) else 1 if __name__ == "__main__": sys.exit(main())