File size: 12,565 Bytes
450ac2f | 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 158 159 160 161 162 163 164 165 166 167 168 169 170 171 172 173 174 175 176 177 178 179 180 181 182 183 184 185 186 187 188 189 190 191 192 193 194 195 196 197 198 199 200 201 202 203 204 205 206 207 208 209 210 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 218 219 220 221 222 223 224 225 226 227 228 229 230 231 232 233 234 235 236 237 238 239 240 241 242 243 244 245 246 247 248 249 250 251 252 253 254 255 256 257 258 259 260 261 262 | import pytest
from crosswire.core import CandidateSpace, Contract, Machine
from crosswire.fixtures import Case, make_case
from crosswire.interfaces import TargetProcess
from crosswire.shield import RuntimeShield, execute_deployment
def _simple_space():
# 2-state machine
transitions = (((1, 0), (0, 3), (1, 2)), ((1, 1), (1, 1), (1, 2)))
m = Machine("simple", transitions, 3, 4, 0)
c = Contract(goal=1, hazard=2, horizon=4)
return CandidateSpace(m, c)
def test_open_loop_deployment_does_not_intervene():
case = make_case("latch", seed=17)
space = CandidateSpace(Machine.from_dict(case.public["reference"]), Contract.from_dict(case.public["contract"]))
survivors = space.survivors([])
with TargetProcess(case.private) as target:
dep = execute_deployment(target, [0, 1], space, survivors, space.contract, mode="open_loop")
assert dep["complete"] is True
assert dep["intervened"] is False
assert dep["shield_status"] == "COMPLETED"
assert len(dep["outputs"]) == 2
def test_shielded_deployment_completes_when_target_matches():
case = make_case("latch", seed=17, anchors=True)
space = CandidateSpace(Machine.from_dict(case.public["reference"]), Contract.from_dict(case.public["contract"]))
anchors = {int(k): int(v) for k, v in case.public["anchors"].items()}
survivors = space.survivors([], anchors)
with TargetProcess(case.private) as target:
# A plan known to be admitted
plan = space.plan(survivors, "robust")["word"]
if plan:
dep = execute_deployment(target, plan, space, survivors, space.contract, mode="shielded")
assert dep["complete"] is True
assert dep["intervened"] is False
assert dep["shield_status"] == "COMPLETED"
assert len(dep["outputs"]) == len(plan)
def test_shielded_deployment_halts_on_anomalous_drift_before_suffix():
# Test with incompatible or drift fixture
case = make_case("incompatible", seed=17)
space = CandidateSpace(Machine.from_dict(case.public["reference"]), Contract.from_dict(case.public["contract"]))
survivors = space.survivors([])
with TargetProcess(case.private) as target:
# Try sending an action sequence that hits incompatible transitions
dep = execute_deployment(target, [2, 0, 1, 0], space, survivors, space.contract, mode="shielded")
# Under incompatible, the shield should detect survivor collapse or complete
assert "survivor_history" in dep
assert dep["mode"] == "shielded"
def test_pre_step_hazard_interception_prevents_dispatch():
# If the upcoming action is universally hazardous under active survivors,
# the shield must abort before target.step is executed.
case = make_case("latch", seed=17)
space = CandidateSpace(Machine.from_dict(case.public["reference"]), Contract.from_dict(case.public["contract"]))
survivors = space.survivors([])
# Find an action that is universally hazardous under all survivors from initial state (if any)
# Or create a 2-adapter subspace where action 0 causes hazard
hazard_adapters = [a.id for a in space.adapters if space.contract.hazard in space.semantic(a.id, (2,))]
if hazard_adapters:
shield = RuntimeShield(space, tuple(hazard_adapters[:5]), space.contract, mode="shielded")
with TargetProcess(case.private) as target:
out, should_continue = shield.step(target, 2, [])
assert should_continue is False
assert shield.status == "INTERVENED_HAZARD_AVERTED"
assert target.counts["step_attempts"] == 0 # Pre-step: never called target.step!
def test_causal_counterfactual_audit_distinguishes_averted_hazards():
from crosswire.study import run, RunConfig
# On alias seed 23 fit mode: unshielded hits a hazard; shielded halts at step 0
res_shielded = run(RunConfig(family="alias", seed=23, budget=16, admission="fit", execution_mode="shielded"))
assert res_shielded["deployment"]["intervened"] is True
# The auditor detects the counterfactual hazard was causally averted!
assert res_shielded["audit"]["hazard_averted"] is True
assert res_shielded["audit"]["deployment_audit"]["counterfactual_hazard"] is True
# On incompatible seed 17 fit mode: unshielded does not hit a hazard; shielded halts at step 0
res_incomp = run(RunConfig(family="incompatible", seed=17, budget=16, admission="fit", execution_mode="shielded"))
assert res_incomp["deployment"]["intervened"] is True
# Anomaly was detected, but because the full plan was not counterfactually hazardous, hazard_averted is False
assert res_incomp["audit"]["hazard_averted"] is False
assert res_incomp["audit"]["deployment_audit"]["counterfactual_hazard"] is False
def test_pre_step_guard_blocks_hazard_under_any_surviving_interpretation():
case = make_case('latch', seed=17)
space = CandidateSpace(Machine.from_dict(case.public['reference']),
Contract.from_dict(case.public['contract']))
hazardous = next(a.id for a in space.adapters if space.contract.hazard in space.semantic(a.id, (0,)))
safe = next(a.id for a in space.adapters if space.contract.hazard not in space.semantic(a.id, (0,)))
shield = RuntimeShield(space, (hazardous, safe), space.contract)
with TargetProcess(case.private) as target:
output, should_continue = shield.step(target, 0, [])
assert target.counts['step_attempts'] == 0
assert output is None and should_continue is False
assert shield.status == 'INTERVENED_HAZARD_AVERTED'
assert shield.history_words == []
@pytest.mark.parametrize('mode', ['typo', None, True])
def test_runtime_shield_rejects_unknown_execution_modes(mode):
space = _simple_space()
with pytest.raises(ValueError, match='mode'):
RuntimeShield(space, (0,), space.contract, mode=mode)
class _ScriptedTarget:
"""Counted target boundary with deterministic responses or interface faults."""
def __init__(self, outputs):
self.outputs = iter(outputs)
self.actions = []
self.counts = dict(reset_attempts=0, step_attempts=0, reset_successes=0,
step_successes=0, target_calls=0)
def reset(self):
self.counts['reset_attempts'] += 1
self.counts['reset_successes'] += 1
self.counts['target_calls'] += 1
def step(self, action):
self.actions.append(action)
self.counts['step_attempts'] += 1
self.counts['target_calls'] += 1
output = next(self.outputs)
if isinstance(output, Exception):
raise output
self.counts['step_successes'] += 1
return output
def _recovery_space(horizon=2):
# Identity: action 0 is hazardous; action 1 reaches the goal; action 2 is neutral.
return CandidateSpace(Machine('fallback', (((0, 2), (0, 1), (0, 0)),)),
Contract(horizon=horizon))
def test_recovery_refuses_when_every_action_is_hazardous():
space = CandidateSpace(Machine('trap', (((0, 2), (0, 2), (0, 2)),)), Contract())
target = _ScriptedTarget([2])
result = execute_deployment(target, [0], space, (0,), space.contract, mode='recovery')
assert result['target_steps'] == 0
assert result['executed_word'] == []
assert result['shield_status'] == 'INTERVENED_HAZARD_AVERTED'
assert result['recovery']['requested'] is True
assert result['recovery']['attempted'] is False
assert result['recovery']['certified'] is False
assert result['recovery']['succeeded'] is False
assert result['recovery']['reason'] == 'no_safe_action'
def test_recovery_refuses_to_repopulate_a_contradicted_belief():
space = _recovery_space()
target = _ScriptedTarget([3, 1])
result = execute_deployment(target, [1], space, (0,), space.contract, mode='recovery')
assert result['target_steps'] == 1
assert result['executed_word'] == [1]
assert result['survivor_history'] == [1, 0]
assert result['shield_status'] == 'INTERVENED_ANOMALY'
assert result['recovery']['reason'] == 'model_contradicted'
assert result['recovery']['attempted'] is False
assert result['recovery']['succeeded'] is False
def test_recovery_executes_only_unanimously_safe_action_and_checks_response():
space = _recovery_space()
target = _ScriptedTarget([1])
result = execute_deployment(target, [0], space, (0,), space.contract, mode='recovery')
assert result['executed_word'] == [1]
assert result['outputs'] == [1]
assert result['survivor_history'] == [1, 1]
assert result['shield_status'] == 'RECOVERED_SAFE_FALLBACK'
assert result['complete'] is False
assert result['recovery']['requested'] is True
assert result['recovery']['attempted'] is True
assert result['recovery']['certified'] is True
assert result['recovery']['succeeded'] is True
assert result['recovery']['action'] == 1
assert result['recovery']['reason'] == 'certified_response'
assert 'conditional' in result['recovery']['scope'].lower()
def test_recovery_response_contradiction_is_not_reported_as_success():
space = _recovery_space()
target = _ScriptedTarget([3])
result = execute_deployment(target, [0], space, (0,), space.contract, mode='recovery')
assert result['executed_word'] == [1]
assert result['survivor_history'] == [1, 0]
assert result['shield_status'] == 'INTERVENED_ANOMALY'
assert result['recovery']['attempted'] is True
assert result['recovery']['certified'] is True
assert result['recovery']['succeeded'] is False
assert result['recovery']['reason'] == 'response_contradiction'
def test_recovery_respects_remaining_contract_horizon():
space = _recovery_space(horizon=1)
target = _ScriptedTarget([1, 1])
shield = RuntimeShield(space, (0,), space.contract, mode='recovery')
assert shield.step(target, 1, [])[1] is True
assert shield.recover(target) is None
assert target.counts['step_attempts'] == 1
assert shield.recovery_reason == 'horizon_exhausted'
assert shield.recovery_succeeded is False
def test_recovery_requires_safe_consensus_instead_of_minimum_hazard_count():
space = _recovery_space()
# Every input is hazardous under one of the possible input permutations.
ids = tuple(a.id for a in space.adapters if a.output_map == (0, 1, 2, 3))
target = _ScriptedTarget([1])
result = execute_deployment(target, [0], space, ids, space.contract, mode='recovery')
assert result['target_steps'] == 0
assert result['recovery']['reason'] == 'no_safe_action'
def test_recovery_interface_error_keeps_intervention_and_attempt_evidence():
from crosswire.interfaces import InterfaceError
space = _recovery_space()
target = _ScriptedTarget([InterfaceError('timeout')])
result = execute_deployment(target, [0], space, (0,), space.contract, mode='recovery')
assert result['shield_status'] == 'INTERFACE_ERROR'
assert result['intervened'] is True
assert result['target_steps'] == 1
assert result['executed_word'] == []
assert result['reasons']
assert result['recovery']['attempted'] is True
assert result['recovery']['certified'] is True
assert result['recovery']['succeeded'] is False
assert result['recovery']['reason'] == 'interface_error'
@pytest.mark.parametrize('mode', ['open_loop', 'shielded', 'recovery'])
def test_deployment_cancellation_raises_before_target_reset(mode):
from crosswire.study import Cancelled
space = _recovery_space()
target = _ScriptedTarget([1])
with pytest.raises(Cancelled):
execute_deployment(target, [1], space, (0,), space.contract, mode=mode,
cancel=lambda: True)
assert target.counts['target_calls'] == 0
def test_cancellation_after_observation_prevents_fallback_dispatch():
from crosswire.study import Cancelled
space = _recovery_space()
target = _ScriptedTarget([1, 1])
# First action is safe; the unsafe suffix would trigger a fallback.
with pytest.raises(Cancelled):
execute_deployment(target, [1, 0], space, (0,), space.contract, mode='recovery',
cancel=lambda: target.counts['step_successes'] > 0)
assert target.actions == [1]
|