formal-mas / tests /test_lean_runner_process.py

Formal-MAS source code

dfe1826 verified about 19 hours ago

13.5 kB

"""LeanRunner process handling with a fake REPL (tests/fake_repl.py): timeout, restart,
memory limit, crashes and the file fallback. No Lean needed."""

from __future__ import annotations

import json
import sys
import time
from pathlib import Path

import pytest

from formal_mas.lean.runner import LeanResult, LeanRunner, probe_lines

FAKE = str(Path(__file__).with_name("fake_repl.py"))
CODE = "import Mathlib\n\ntheorem t : True := trivial\n"


def make_runner(*flags: str, **cfg) -> LeanRunner:
    base = {"timeout_s": 3, "startup_timeout_s": 10, "memory_poll_s": 0.1, "restart_memory_mb": 1e9,
            "kill_memory_mb": 1e9, "base_imports": ["Mathlib", "Aesop"], "cache_size": 0, **cfg}
    runner = LeanRunner({"lean": base}, repl_cmd=[sys.executable, "-u", FAKE, *flags])
    runner._verify_file = lambda *args: LeanResult("finished", "file", detail="fallback")
    return runner


@pytest.fixture
def runner():
    r = make_runner()
    yield r
    r.close()


def test_verify_uses_env_zero_and_reads_axioms(runner):
    res = runner.verify(CODE, theorem="t")
    assert (res.status, res.backend, res.axioms) == ("finished", "repl", ["propext"])
    assert res.messages == []  # the #print axioms answer is taken out of the messages
    assert runner.starts == 1
    runner.verify(CODE, theorem="t")
    assert runner.starts == 1  # Mathlib is not loaded again


def test_timeout_kills_and_restarts(runner):
    res = runner.verify(CODE + "-- HANG\n", timeout=1)
    assert res.status == "timeout" and res.backend == "repl"
    assert any(w["reason"] == "repl_timeout" for w in runner.warnings)
    res = runner.verify(CODE, theorem="t")  # a new REPL answers
    assert res.status == "finished" and runner.starts == 2


def test_dead_repl_is_a_crash_then_restarts(runner):
    assert runner.verify(CODE + "-- DIE\n").status == "crash"
    assert runner.verify(CODE, theorem="t").axioms == ["propext"]
    assert runner.starts == 2


def test_protocol_error_is_a_crash(runner):
    res = runner.verify(CODE + "-- PROTOCOL\n")
    assert res.status == "crash" and "Unknown environment" in res.detail


def test_memory_limit_kills_the_command():
    r = make_runner(kill_memory_mb=250, timeout_s=20)
    try:
        res = r.verify(CODE + "-- BIGMEM\n")
        assert res.status == "memory_limit"
        assert r.verify(CODE, theorem="t").status == "finished" and r.starts == 2
    finally:
        r.close()


def test_preventive_restart_every_n_commands():
    r = make_runner(restart_every=3)
    try:
        for _ in range(7):
            assert r.verify(CODE).status == "finished"
        assert r.starts == 3  # verifications 1-3, 4-6, 7
    finally:
        r.close()


def test_preventive_restart_on_memory():
    r = make_runner(restart_memory_mb=1)  # any process is above 1 MB
    try:
        r.verify(CODE)
        r.verify(CODE)
        assert r.starts == 2
    finally:
        r.close()


def test_fallback_when_repl_does_not_start():
    r = make_runner("--fail-start")
    res = r.verify(CODE)
    assert res.backend == "file" and res.detail == "fallback"
    # a process that dies at start-up is tried once more (2026-11-03), then the file back-end
    assert r.warnings[0]["reason"] == "repl_start_failed" and r.warnings[0]["action"] == "restart"
    assert r.warnings[1]["reason"] == "repl_start_failed" and r.warnings[1]["fallback"] == "file"
    r.verify(CODE)
    assert len(r.warnings) == 2  # the REPL is not retried on every call


def test_fallback_on_startup_timeout():
    r = make_runner("--slow-start", "30", startup_timeout_s=1)
    assert r.verify(CODE).backend == "file"
    assert "ReplTimeout" in r.warnings[0]["error"]


def test_out_of_sequence_reply_is_a_crash(runner):
    runner.verify(CODE)
    res = runner.verify(CODE + "-- DESYNC\n")
    assert res.status == "crash" and runner.warnings[-1]["reason"] == "repl_desync"
    assert runner.verify(CODE, theorem="t").status == "finished" and runner.starts == 2


def test_fallback_when_imports_fail():
    r = make_runner(base_imports=["Broken"])
    assert r.verify("import Broken\n\ntheorem t : True := trivial").backend == "file"
    assert r.warnings[0]["reason"] == "repl_import_failed"


def test_fallback_when_binary_missing(tmp_path):
    r = LeanRunner({"lean": {"repl_dir": "nowhere"}}, root=tmp_path)
    r._verify_file = lambda *args: LeanResult("finished", "file")
    assert r.verify(CODE).backend == "file"
    assert r.warnings[0]["reason"] == "repl_not_built"


@pytest.mark.parametrize("header", ["import Mathlib\nimport SomethingElse\n", "import Aesop\n", ""])
def test_imports_that_do_not_match_env0_go_to_file_backend(runner, header):
    # env 0 holds Mathlib: code without it (or with more) would see other declarations
    res = runner.verify(header + "\ntheorem t : True := trivial\n")
    assert res.backend == "file"
    assert runner.warnings[0]["reason"] == "imports_not_in_base"
    assert runner.starts == 0  # the REPL was not even needed


def test_mathlib_with_aesop_uses_repl(runner):
    assert runner.verify("import Mathlib\nimport Aesop\n\ntheorem t : True := trivial\n").backend == "repl"


def test_file_backend_config_skips_repl():
    r = make_runner(backend="file")
    assert r.verify(CODE).backend == "file" and r.starts == 0


# -- cache ----------------------------------------------------------------------


def test_identical_verifications_hit_the_cache():
    r = make_runner(cache_size=8)
    try:
        first = r.verify(CODE, theorem="t")
        second = r.verify(CODE, theorem="t")
        assert not first.cached and second.cached and r.cache_hits == 1
        assert second.axioms == first.axioms and second.declarations == ["t"]
        assert r.verify(CODE, theorem="t", timeout=5).cached is False  # the timeout is part of the key
    finally:
        r.close()


def test_unfinished_results_are_not_cached():
    r = make_runner(cache_size=8)
    try:
        assert r.verify(CODE + "-- HANG\n", timeout=1).status == "timeout"
        assert r.verify(CODE + "-- HANG\n", timeout=1).cached is False
    finally:
        r.close()


# -- plan B (file back-end) ----------------------------------------------------------


def check_answers(code: str, error: bool = False) -> str:
    """`lean --json` lines answering each `#check @X` of the code (an error with `error`)."""
    out = []
    for i, line in enumerate(code.split("\n"), start=1):
        if line.startswith("#check @"):
            name = line.split("@", 1)[1].strip()
            out.append(json.dumps({"severity": "error" if error else "information", "pos": {"line": i, "column": 0},
                                   "data": f"Unknown constant `{name}`" if error else f"{name} : Prop"}))
    return "\n".join(out)


def file_runner(**cfg) -> tuple[LeanRunner, list[tuple[str, float]]]:
    """Runner on the file back-end with `lake env lean` replaced by a recorder."""
    calls: list[tuple[str, float]] = []

    def fake_run(code: str, timeout: float):
        calls.append((code, timeout))
        if "theorem" not in code:
            time.sleep(0.2)  # the measured import
        return "finished", 0, check_answers(code), ""

    r = LeanRunner({"lean": {"backend": "file", "timeout_s": 3, "startup_timeout_s": 999,
                             "base_imports": ["Mathlib", "Aesop"], "cache_size": 0, **cfg}})
    r._run_file = fake_run
    return r, calls


def test_file_timeout_is_timeout_plus_measured_import():
    r, calls = file_runner()
    r.verify("import Mathlib\nimport Aesop\n\ntheorem t : True := trivial\n", theorem="t")
    r.verify("import Mathlib\nimport Aesop\n\ntheorem u : True := trivial\n", theorem="u")
    imports, first, second = calls  # the import is measured once, not per verification
    assert "theorem" not in imports[0] and imports[1] == 999  # measured under startup_timeout_s
    measured = r.file_import_s["Mathlib\nAesop"]
    assert 0.2 <= measured < 2
    assert first[1] == second[1] == pytest.approx(3 + measured)  # not timeout + startup_timeout_s


def test_file_backend_marks_the_run_degraded():
    r, _ = file_runner()
    r.verify(CODE)
    info = r.run_info()
    assert info["degraded"] is True and info["file_verifications"] == 1
    assert make_runner().run_info()["degraded"] is False


def test_file_import_failure_is_a_crash():
    r, _ = file_runner()
    r._run_file = lambda code, timeout: ("finished", 1, "", "unknown module prefix")
    res = r.verify(CODE)
    assert res.status == "crash" and r.warnings[-1]["reason"] == "file_import_failed"


def test_repl_timeout_is_final(runner):
    used = []
    runner._verify_file = lambda *args: used.append(args) or LeanResult("finished", "file")
    assert runner.verify(CODE + "-- HANG\n", timeout=1).status == "timeout"
    assert used == []  # never retried with the file back-end


def test_failed_import_measurement_is_remembered():
    r, calls = file_runner()
    r._run_file = lambda code, timeout: calls.append(code) or ("finished", 1, "", "unknown module prefix")
    r.verify(CODE)
    r.verify(CODE.replace("trivial", "True.intro"))
    assert len(calls) == 1  # the import is not retried on every verification


def test_cache_returns_independent_copies():
    r = make_runner(cache_size=8)
    try:
        first = r.verify(CODE, theorem="t")
        first.axioms.append("cheat")
        first.messages.append(None)
        again = r.verify(CODE, theorem="t")
        assert again.cached and again.axioms == ["propext"] and again.messages == []
    finally:
        r.close()


# -- start-up probes (2026-11-03: an import answered without Mathlib) ------------------------


def test_repl_without_mathlib_is_not_accepted():
    r = make_runner("--no-mathlib")
    try:
        res = r.verify(CODE, theorem="t")
        assert res.backend == "file" and r.starts == 0  # never used as a REPL
        first, last = r.warnings[0], r.warnings[-1]
        assert first["reason"] == "repl_probe_failed" and first["action"] == "restart" and first["attempt"] == 1
        assert "Unknown constant `Real.sqrt`" in first["detail"]
        assert last["reason"] == "repl_probe_failed" and last["attempts"] == 2 and last["fallback"] == "file"
    finally:
        r.close()


def test_probe_without_answer_is_not_accepted():
    r = make_runner("--silent-probe")
    try:
        assert r.verify(CODE).backend == "file"
        assert "no answer for `#check @Real.sqrt`" in r.warnings[0]["detail"]
    finally:
        r.close()


def test_failed_probe_restarts_once(tmp_path):
    r = make_runner("--no-mathlib-once", str(tmp_path / "marker"))
    try:
        res = r.verify(CODE, theorem="t")
        assert (res.backend, res.axioms, r.starts) == ("repl", ["propext"], 1)
        assert [w["reason"] for w in r.warnings] == ["repl_probe_failed"]
    finally:
        r.close()


def test_probe_runs_on_every_restart():
    r = make_runner()
    try:
        assert r.verify(CODE, theorem="t").backend == "repl"
        r.repl_cmd = [*r.repl_cmd, "--no-mathlib"]  # the next process imports without Mathlib
        assert r.verify(CODE + "-- DIE\n").status == "crash"
        assert r.verify(CODE, theorem="t").backend == "file"
        assert [w["reason"] for w in r.warnings][-2:] == ["repl_probe_failed", "repl_probe_failed"]
    finally:
        r.close()


def test_probe_counts_neither_for_restart_every():
    r = make_runner(restart_every=2)
    try:
        for _ in range(4):
            r.verify(CODE)
        assert r.starts == 2
    finally:
        r.close()


def test_probe_requires_the_primary_import_to_have_one():
    r = make_runner(probes={"Aesop": "Aesop.BuiltinRules.not_intro"})
    try:
        assert r.verify(CODE).backend == "file"
        assert "no probe configured for 'Mathlib'" in r.warnings[0]["detail"]
    finally:
        r.close()


def test_ensure_available():
    r = make_runner()
    try:
        assert r.ensure_available() and r.available and r.starts == 1
    finally:
        r.close()
    # REPL without Mathlib, file back-end fine → available (degraded)
    r, calls = file_runner()
    r.backend, r._repl_failed = "repl", True
    assert r.ensure_available() and r.available and "#check @Real.sqrt" in calls[0][0]
    # neither back-end loads Mathlib → not available, and the result is remembered
    r, _ = file_runner()
    r._run_file = lambda code, timeout: ("finished", 0, check_answers(code, error=True), "")
    assert r.ensure_available() is False and r.available is False
    assert r.warnings[-1]["reason"] == "file_import_failed" and "Unknown constant" in r.warnings[-1]["detail"]
    assert r.verify(CODE).status == "crash"


def test_file_backend_probe_must_answer():
    r, _ = file_runner()
    r._run_file = lambda code, timeout: ("finished", 0, "", "")  # exit 0, no messages at all
    assert r.verify(CODE).status == "crash" and "no answer" in r.warnings[-1]["detail"]


def test_a_module_may_have_several_probes():
    text, lines = probe_lines(["Mathlib", "Aesop"], {"Mathlib": ["Real.sqrt", "Finset.sum_range_succ"], "Aesop": "A.b"})
    assert text == "#check @Real.sqrt\n#check @Finset.sum_range_succ\n#check @A.b\n"
    assert lines == {1: "Real.sqrt", 2: "Finset.sum_range_succ", 3: "A.b"}
    r = make_runner()
    try:
        assert r.ensure_available()
        info = r.run_info()
        assert info["available"] is True and info["repl_given_up"] is False and "Mathlib" in info["probes"]
    finally:
        r.close()

	"""LeanRunner process handling with a fake REPL (tests/fake_repl.py): timeout, restart,
	memory limit, crashes and the file fallback. No Lean needed."""

	from __future__ import annotations

	import json
	import sys
	import time
	from pathlib import Path

	import pytest

	from formal_mas.lean.runner import LeanResult, LeanRunner, probe_lines

	FAKE = str(Path(__file__).with_name("fake_repl.py"))
	CODE = "import Mathlib\n\ntheorem t : True := trivial\n"


	def make_runner(flags: str, *cfg) -> LeanRunner:
	base = {"timeout_s": 3, "startup_timeout_s": 10, "memory_poll_s": 0.1, "restart_memory_mb": 1e9,
	"kill_memory_mb": 1e9, "base_imports": ["Mathlib", "Aesop"], "cache_size": 0, **cfg}
	runner = LeanRunner({"lean": base}, repl_cmd=[sys.executable, "-u", FAKE, *flags])
	runner._verify_file = lambda *args: LeanResult("finished", "file", detail="fallback")
	return runner


	@pytest.fixture
	def runner():
	r = make_runner()
	yield r
	r.close()


	def test_verify_uses_env_zero_and_reads_axioms(runner):
	res = runner.verify(CODE, theorem="t")
	assert (res.status, res.backend, res.axioms) == ("finished", "repl", ["propext"])
	assert res.messages == [] # the #print axioms answer is taken out of the messages
	assert runner.starts == 1
	runner.verify(CODE, theorem="t")
	assert runner.starts == 1 # Mathlib is not loaded again


	def test_timeout_kills_and_restarts(runner):
	res = runner.verify(CODE + "-- HANG\n", timeout=1)
	assert res.status == "timeout" and res.backend == "repl"
	assert any(w["reason"] == "repl_timeout" for w in runner.warnings)
	res = runner.verify(CODE, theorem="t") # a new REPL answers
	assert res.status == "finished" and runner.starts == 2


	def test_dead_repl_is_a_crash_then_restarts(runner):
	assert runner.verify(CODE + "-- DIE\n").status == "crash"
	assert runner.verify(CODE, theorem="t").axioms == ["propext"]
	assert runner.starts == 2


	def test_protocol_error_is_a_crash(runner):
	res = runner.verify(CODE + "-- PROTOCOL\n")
	assert res.status == "crash" and "Unknown environment" in res.detail


	def test_memory_limit_kills_the_command():
	r = make_runner(kill_memory_mb=250, timeout_s=20)
	try:
	res = r.verify(CODE + "-- BIGMEM\n")
	assert res.status == "memory_limit"
	assert r.verify(CODE, theorem="t").status == "finished" and r.starts == 2
	finally:
	r.close()


	def test_preventive_restart_every_n_commands():
	r = make_runner(restart_every=3)
	try:
	for _ in range(7):
	assert r.verify(CODE).status == "finished"
	assert r.starts == 3 # verifications 1-3, 4-6, 7
	finally:
	r.close()


	def test_preventive_restart_on_memory():
	r = make_runner(restart_memory_mb=1) # any process is above 1 MB
	try:
	r.verify(CODE)
	r.verify(CODE)
	assert r.starts == 2
	finally:
	r.close()


	def test_fallback_when_repl_does_not_start():
	r = make_runner("--fail-start")
	res = r.verify(CODE)
	assert res.backend == "file" and res.detail == "fallback"
	# a process that dies at start-up is tried once more (2026-11-03), then the file back-end
	assert r.warnings[0]["reason"] == "repl_start_failed" and r.warnings[0]["action"] == "restart"
	assert r.warnings[1]["reason"] == "repl_start_failed" and r.warnings[1]["fallback"] == "file"
	r.verify(CODE)
	assert len(r.warnings) == 2 # the REPL is not retried on every call


	def test_fallback_on_startup_timeout():
	r = make_runner("--slow-start", "30", startup_timeout_s=1)
	assert r.verify(CODE).backend == "file"
	assert "ReplTimeout" in r.warnings[0]["error"]


	def test_out_of_sequence_reply_is_a_crash(runner):
	runner.verify(CODE)
	res = runner.verify(CODE + "-- DESYNC\n")
	assert res.status == "crash" and runner.warnings[-1]["reason"] == "repl_desync"
	assert runner.verify(CODE, theorem="t").status == "finished" and runner.starts == 2


	def test_fallback_when_imports_fail():
	r = make_runner(base_imports=["Broken"])
	assert r.verify("import Broken\n\ntheorem t : True := trivial").backend == "file"
	assert r.warnings[0]["reason"] == "repl_import_failed"


	def test_fallback_when_binary_missing(tmp_path):
	r = LeanRunner({"lean": {"repl_dir": "nowhere"}}, root=tmp_path)
	r._verify_file = lambda *args: LeanResult("finished", "file")
	assert r.verify(CODE).backend == "file"
	assert r.warnings[0]["reason"] == "repl_not_built"


	@pytest.mark.parametrize("header", ["import Mathlib\nimport SomethingElse\n", "import Aesop\n", ""])
	def test_imports_that_do_not_match_env0_go_to_file_backend(runner, header):
	# env 0 holds Mathlib: code without it (or with more) would see other declarations
	res = runner.verify(header + "\ntheorem t : True := trivial\n")
	assert res.backend == "file"
	assert runner.warnings[0]["reason"] == "imports_not_in_base"
	assert runner.starts == 0 # the REPL was not even needed


	def test_mathlib_with_aesop_uses_repl(runner):
	assert runner.verify("import Mathlib\nimport Aesop\n\ntheorem t : True := trivial\n").backend == "repl"


	def test_file_backend_config_skips_repl():
	r = make_runner(backend="file")
	assert r.verify(CODE).backend == "file" and r.starts == 0


	# -- cache ----------------------------------------------------------------------


	def test_identical_verifications_hit_the_cache():
	r = make_runner(cache_size=8)
	try:
	first = r.verify(CODE, theorem="t")
	second = r.verify(CODE, theorem="t")
	assert not first.cached and second.cached and r.cache_hits == 1
	assert second.axioms == first.axioms and second.declarations == ["t"]
	assert r.verify(CODE, theorem="t", timeout=5).cached is False # the timeout is part of the key
	finally:
	r.close()


	def test_unfinished_results_are_not_cached():
	r = make_runner(cache_size=8)
	try:
	assert r.verify(CODE + "-- HANG\n", timeout=1).status == "timeout"
	assert r.verify(CODE + "-- HANG\n", timeout=1).cached is False
	finally:
	r.close()


	# -- plan B (file back-end) ----------------------------------------------------------


	def check_answers(code: str, error: bool = False) -> str:
	"""`lean --json` lines answering each `#check @X` of the code (an error with `error`)."""
	out = []
	for i, line in enumerate(code.split("\n"), start=1):
	if line.startswith("#check @"):
	name = line.split("@", 1)[1].strip()
	out.append(json.dumps({"severity": "error" if error else "information", "pos": {"line": i, "column": 0},
	"data": f"Unknown constant `{name}`" if error else f"{name} : Prop"}))
	return "\n".join(out)


	def file_runner(**cfg) -> tuple[LeanRunner, list[tuple[str, float]]]:
	"""Runner on the file back-end with `lake env lean` replaced by a recorder."""
	calls: list[tuple[str, float]] = []

	def fake_run(code: str, timeout: float):
	calls.append((code, timeout))
	if "theorem" not in code:
	time.sleep(0.2) # the measured import
	return "finished", 0, check_answers(code), ""

	r = LeanRunner({"lean": {"backend": "file", "timeout_s": 3, "startup_timeout_s": 999,
	"base_imports": ["Mathlib", "Aesop"], "cache_size": 0, **cfg}})
	r._run_file = fake_run
	return r, calls


	def test_file_timeout_is_timeout_plus_measured_import():
	r, calls = file_runner()
	r.verify("import Mathlib\nimport Aesop\n\ntheorem t : True := trivial\n", theorem="t")
	r.verify("import Mathlib\nimport Aesop\n\ntheorem u : True := trivial\n", theorem="u")
	imports, first, second = calls # the import is measured once, not per verification
	assert "theorem" not in imports[0] and imports[1] == 999 # measured under startup_timeout_s
	measured = r.file_import_s["Mathlib\nAesop"]
	assert 0.2 <= measured < 2
	assert first[1] == second[1] == pytest.approx(3 + measured) # not timeout + startup_timeout_s


	def test_file_backend_marks_the_run_degraded():
	r, _ = file_runner()
	r.verify(CODE)
	info = r.run_info()
	assert info["degraded"] is True and info["file_verifications"] == 1
	assert make_runner().run_info()["degraded"] is False


	def test_file_import_failure_is_a_crash():
	r, _ = file_runner()
	r._run_file = lambda code, timeout: ("finished", 1, "", "unknown module prefix")
	res = r.verify(CODE)
	assert res.status == "crash" and r.warnings[-1]["reason"] == "file_import_failed"


	def test_repl_timeout_is_final(runner):
	used = []
	runner._verify_file = lambda *args: used.append(args) or LeanResult("finished", "file")
	assert runner.verify(CODE + "-- HANG\n", timeout=1).status == "timeout"
	assert used == [] # never retried with the file back-end


	def test_failed_import_measurement_is_remembered():
	r, calls = file_runner()
	r._run_file = lambda code, timeout: calls.append(code) or ("finished", 1, "", "unknown module prefix")
	r.verify(CODE)
	r.verify(CODE.replace("trivial", "True.intro"))
	assert len(calls) == 1 # the import is not retried on every verification


	def test_cache_returns_independent_copies():
	r = make_runner(cache_size=8)
	try:
	first = r.verify(CODE, theorem="t")
	first.axioms.append("cheat")
	first.messages.append(None)
	again = r.verify(CODE, theorem="t")
	assert again.cached and again.axioms == ["propext"] and again.messages == []
	finally:
	r.close()


	# -- start-up probes (2026-11-03: an import answered without Mathlib) ------------------------


	def test_repl_without_mathlib_is_not_accepted():
	r = make_runner("--no-mathlib")
	try:
	res = r.verify(CODE, theorem="t")
	assert res.backend == "file" and r.starts == 0 # never used as a REPL
	first, last = r.warnings[0], r.warnings[-1]
	assert first["reason"] == "repl_probe_failed" and first["action"] == "restart" and first["attempt"] == 1
	assert "Unknown constant `Real.sqrt`" in first["detail"]
	assert last["reason"] == "repl_probe_failed" and last["attempts"] == 2 and last["fallback"] == "file"
	finally:
	r.close()


	def test_probe_without_answer_is_not_accepted():
	r = make_runner("--silent-probe")
	try:
	assert r.verify(CODE).backend == "file"
	assert "no answer for `#check @Real.sqrt`" in r.warnings[0]["detail"]
	finally:
	r.close()


	def test_failed_probe_restarts_once(tmp_path):
	r = make_runner("--no-mathlib-once", str(tmp_path / "marker"))
	try:
	res = r.verify(CODE, theorem="t")
	assert (res.backend, res.axioms, r.starts) == ("repl", ["propext"], 1)
	assert [w["reason"] for w in r.warnings] == ["repl_probe_failed"]
	finally:
	r.close()


	def test_probe_runs_on_every_restart():
	r = make_runner()
	try:
	assert r.verify(CODE, theorem="t").backend == "repl"
	r.repl_cmd = [*r.repl_cmd, "--no-mathlib"] # the next process imports without Mathlib
	assert r.verify(CODE + "-- DIE\n").status == "crash"
	assert r.verify(CODE, theorem="t").backend == "file"
	assert [w["reason"] for w in r.warnings][-2:] == ["repl_probe_failed", "repl_probe_failed"]
	finally:
	r.close()


	def test_probe_counts_neither_for_restart_every():
	r = make_runner(restart_every=2)
	try:
	for _ in range(4):
	r.verify(CODE)
	assert r.starts == 2
	finally:
	r.close()


	def test_probe_requires_the_primary_import_to_have_one():
	r = make_runner(probes={"Aesop": "Aesop.BuiltinRules.not_intro"})
	try:
	assert r.verify(CODE).backend == "file"
	assert "no probe configured for 'Mathlib'" in r.warnings[0]["detail"]
	finally:
	r.close()


	def test_ensure_available():
	r = make_runner()
	try:
	assert r.ensure_available() and r.available and r.starts == 1
	finally:
	r.close()
	# REPL without Mathlib, file back-end fine → available (degraded)
	r, calls = file_runner()
	r.backend, r._repl_failed = "repl", True
	assert r.ensure_available() and r.available and "#check @Real.sqrt" in calls[0][0]
	# neither back-end loads Mathlib → not available, and the result is remembered
	r, _ = file_runner()
	r._run_file = lambda code, timeout: ("finished", 0, check_answers(code, error=True), "")
	assert r.ensure_available() is False and r.available is False
	assert r.warnings[-1]["reason"] == "file_import_failed" and "Unknown constant" in r.warnings[-1]["detail"]
	assert r.verify(CODE).status == "crash"


	def test_file_backend_probe_must_answer():
	r, _ = file_runner()
	r._run_file = lambda code, timeout: ("finished", 0, "", "") # exit 0, no messages at all
	assert r.verify(CODE).status == "crash" and "no answer" in r.warnings[-1]["detail"]


	def test_a_module_may_have_several_probes():
	text, lines = probe_lines(["Mathlib", "Aesop"], {"Mathlib": ["Real.sqrt", "Finset.sum_range_succ"], "Aesop": "A.b"})
	assert text == "#check @Real.sqrt\n#check @Finset.sum_range_succ\n#check @A.b\n"
	assert lines == {1: "Real.sqrt", 2: "Finset.sum_range_succ", 3: "A.b"}
	r = make_runner()
	try:
	assert r.ensure_available()
	info = r.run_info()
	assert info["available"] is True and info["repl_given_up"] is False and "Mathlib" in info["probes"]
	finally:
	r.close()