PerfectWin commited on
Commit
edf6287
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): 310857f

v0.8: layer separation (colour plate + ink classes) before segmentation

Browse files
.gitattributes CHANGED
@@ -42,3 +42,4 @@ figures/naming_region.png filter=lfs diff=lfs merge=lfs -text
42
  figures/naming_zoom.png filter=lfs diff=lfs merge=lfs -text
43
  figures/method_geometry.png filter=lfs diff=lfs merge=lfs -text
44
  figures/method_naming.png filter=lfs diff=lfs merge=lfs -text
 
 
42
  figures/naming_zoom.png filter=lfs diff=lfs merge=lfs -text
43
  figures/method_geometry.png filter=lfs diff=lfs merge=lfs -text
44
  figures/method_naming.png filter=lfs diff=lfs merge=lfs -text
45
+ figures/layers_brgm.png filter=lfs diff=lfs merge=lfs -text
README.md CHANGED
@@ -15,7 +15,7 @@ tags:
15
 
16
  # GeoRas2Vec model – scanned geological map → GIS polygons, faults and unit names
17
 
18
- **Research preview (v0.7).** **Code, installation and documentation: [GeoRas2Vec on GitHub](https://github.com/PerfectWin7777/georas2vec).**
19
 
20
  GeoRas2Vec turns a scanned or rasterised geological map into a GeoPackage that opens directly in QGIS or ArcGIS. The GeoPackage holds three things:
21
 
@@ -32,7 +32,7 @@ This repository holds the model files. The command-line tool downloads them auto
32
  ## Files
33
  | file | role |
34
  |---|---|
35
- | `best_fp16.pt` | segmentation network (U-Net++ / EfficientNet-B4, RGB + Lab): 10 pixel affinities + fault map |
36
  | `naming_model.pkl` | scores (text read on the map, polygon) pairs |
37
  | `legend_ranker.pkl` | ranks the candidate codes of each polygon (text evidence, leader lines, legend swatch) |
38
  | `prop_model.pkl` | decides when a code read on the map can be propagated to polygons of the same colour |
@@ -54,14 +54,28 @@ python scripts/vectorize.py my_map.tif my_legend.csv my_map.gpkg
54
  See the [GitHub README](https://github.com/PerfectWin7777/georas2vec#quick-start) for the legend CSV format.
55
 
56
  ## Results (never seen during training)
57
- ![Official test split](https://huggingface.co/PerfectWin/georas2vec-model/resolve/main/figures/results_test_scores.png)
 
 
 
 
 
58
 
59
- | official test split | large units | small units | map area in the correct polygon |
60
- |---|---|---|---|
61
- | real scans (78 tiles, USGS GMNA 300 dpi) | **94.5 %** | **77.0 %** | **98.5 %** |
62
- | synthetic maps, 4 continents (60 tiles) | 85.2 % | 73.6 % | 90.4 % |
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
63
 
64
- Faults: line-level F1 at 2 px is **0.80** on the real-scan test split and **0.85** on a held-out region.
65
 
66
  ![Four continents](https://huggingface.co/PerfectWin/georas2vec-model/resolve/main/figures/results_continents.png)
67
 
@@ -97,11 +111,15 @@ of the southern sheet, models trained on the northern sheet only.
97
  on realistic renderings of official vector maps.
98
  * On sea and ice areas the map prints many texts that are not the unit's code: there GeoRas2Vec gives the right code as first suggestion instead of guessing.
99
  * On large maps, unnamed areas can show straight cuts at the 2048 px block edges.
 
 
 
100
 
101
  ## Versions
102
  | version | change |
103
  |---|---|
104
- | **v0.7** | automatic legend reading (swatch boxes + codes), geological code reader (56/60 real legend boxes vs 26/60 with generic OCR), learned swatch comparator, ranker trained with real printed legends |
 
105
  | v0.6 | English attribute table by default (`--lang fr` for French), age shown once, fragments < 200 px merged into their neighbours (3× fewer polygons), no colour propagation onto white paper / ice |
106
  | v0.5 | two-scale mutex watershed; fault lines split at junctions; topological contours (no gap, no overlap); water detection; OCR restricted to the legend alphabet; decoding of age prefixes, Ʀ, Є and superscripts; colour propagation over the whole map; block processing of large maps |
107
  | v0.2 | first public release (`revision="v0.2"`) |
 
15
 
16
  # GeoRas2Vec model – scanned geological map → GIS polygons, faults and unit names
17
 
18
+ **Research preview (v0.8).** **Code, installation and documentation: [GeoRas2Vec on GitHub](https://github.com/PerfectWin7777/georas2vec).**
19
 
20
  GeoRas2Vec turns a scanned or rasterised geological map into a GeoPackage that opens directly in QGIS or ArcGIS. The GeoPackage holds three things:
21
 
 
32
  ## Files
33
  | file | role |
34
  |---|---|
35
+ | `best_fp16.pt` | v0.8: layer separator (U-Net / ResNet-34: colour plate + 7 ink classes) and segmentation network (U-Net++ / EfficientNet-B4, RGB + Lab + layers): 10 pixel affinities + fault map |
36
  | `naming_model.pkl` | scores (text read on the map, polygon) pairs |
37
  | `legend_ranker.pkl` | ranks the candidate codes of each polygon (text evidence, leader lines, legend swatch) |
38
  | `prop_model.pkl` | decides when a code read on the map can be propagated to polygons of the same colour |
 
54
  See the [GitHub README](https://github.com/PerfectWin7777/georas2vec#quick-start) for the legend CSV format.
55
 
56
  ## Results (never seen during training)
57
+ | test (large units / small units / area in the correct polygon / fault F1) | v0.7 | **v0.8** |
58
+ |---|---|---|
59
+ | real scans, USGS GMNA 300 dpi (78 tiles, official test split) | **94.5** / 77.0 / **98.5** / 0.78 | 93.0 / **77.4** / 98.0 / 0.78 |
60
+ | same scans with a topographic background printed over them | 85.5 / 73.0 / 73.7 / 0.44 | **89.1** / **75.2** / **96.9** / **0.78** |
61
+ | BRGM 1:50 000 sheet, Calvados (map series never seen in training) | **83.1** / **63.4** / 70.4 / 0.07 | 82.9 / 42.7 / **90.0** / **0.45** |
62
+ | synthetic maps, 4 continents (530 tiles) | 87.5 / 76.2 / 91.2 / 0.98 | **88.0** / **76.6** / **91.8** / 0.97 |
63
 
64
+ <sub>IoU ≥ 0.5; small = &lt; 1000 px; fault F1 at 2 px. Protocols and every training run, including the failed
65
+ ones: [docs/EXPERIMENTS.md on GitHub](https://github.com/PerfectWin7777/georas2vec/blob/main/docs/EXPERIMENTS.md).</sub>
66
+
67
+ ### New in v0.8: maps printed over a topographic base
68
+
69
+ Detailed maps (e.g. French 1:50 000 sheets) print the geology over contour lines, roads and field boundaries. Up to
70
+ v0.7 the network relied on the shortcut *thin black line = unit boundary*, true on small-scale maps but false on
71
+ detailed ones. Training one network on both kinds of maps cost 2 to 4 points on small-scale scans, even with
72
+ rebalanced data or a network conditioned on the map style. v0.8 instead **separates the printed layers first**:
73
+ a separator predicts the colour plate (map without ink) and the kind of ink on every pixel, and the segmentation
74
+ network reads the image together with these layers. It starts from v0.7 weights. On maps with a topographic
75
+ background the area in the correct polygon rises from 73.7 % to 96.9 %; the price is 1.5 points on large units of
76
+ clean scans. Use `revision="v0.7"` for the previous model.
77
 
78
+ ![Layer separation on a BRGM sheet](https://huggingface.co/PerfectWin/georas2vec-model/resolve/main/figures/layers_brgm.png)
79
 
80
  ![Four continents](https://huggingface.co/PerfectWin/georas2vec-model/resolve/main/figures/results_continents.png)
81
 
 
111
  on realistic renderings of official vector maps.
112
  * On sea and ice areas the map prints many texts that are not the unit's code: there GeoRas2Vec gives the right code as first suggestion instead of guessing.
113
  * On large maps, unnamed areas can show straight cuts at the 2048 px block edges.
114
+ * Detailed maps with a topographic background: small units are often merged (42.7 % recovered on the French test
115
+ sheet vs 63.4 % with v0.7), and the separator still labels many roads as faults on real sheets.
116
+ * The naming results above were measured with the v0.7 segmentation network.
117
 
118
  ## Versions
119
  | version | change |
120
  |---|---|
121
+ | **v0.8** | layer separation before segmentation (colour plate + 7 ink classes): robust to topographic base maps, faults detected on French 1:50 000 sheets |
122
+ | v0.7 | automatic legend reading (swatch boxes + codes), geological code reader (56/60 real legend boxes vs 26/60 with generic OCR), learned swatch comparator, ranker trained with real printed legends |
123
  | v0.6 | English attribute table by default (`--lang fr` for French), age shown once, fragments < 200 px merged into their neighbours (3× fewer polygons), no colour propagation onto white paper / ice |
124
  | v0.5 | two-scale mutex watershed; fault lines split at junctions; topological contours (no gap, no overlap); water detection; OCR restricted to the legend alphabet; decoding of age prefixes, Ʀ, Є and superscripts; colour propagation over the whole map; block processing of large maps |
125
  | v0.2 | first public release (`revision="v0.2"`) |
best_fp16.pt CHANGED
@@ -1,3 +1,3 @@
1
  version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
2
- oid sha256:fe12b55b0b460bafe50628b32372c857b3d446b6a5b329a2ad0274b2b0bb5f54
3
- size 42158475
 
1
  version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
2
+ oid sha256:2372a44946bbff7a50035472063d2511fd4a5baa9ec68fe44305c9bdf170d1c5
3
+ size 91172097
figures/layers_brgm.png ADDED

Git LFS Details

  • SHA256: d4fccf7f4c902dc8730da5f524d2a0f214a9df0c9a0a6bd32d52bf69978cf419
  • Pointer size: 132 Bytes
  • Size of remote file: 1.58 MB
training/v0.8/history.csv ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,9 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ step,loss,heures,modele_score,modele_reel,modele_synth,meilleur,ema_score,ema_reel,ema_synth
2
+ 2500,0.7154660440564156,1.24,0.08204887501762081,0.05205817378573897,0.11203957624950267,ema,0.07850958571485984,0.04677064077515888,0.1102485306545608
3
+ 5000,0.691128010737896,1.79,0.07865927065232332,0.04792626898096005,0.10939227232368659,,0.07871562792559383,0.0468937479860099,0.11053750786517776
4
+ 7500,0.6835786717057228,2.34,0.07597521601377022,0.05008050776863225,0.10186992425890817,modele,0.07959509787023923,0.04946425209015247,0.109725943650326
5
+ 10000,0.6747275333285332,2.88,0.07450312302617934,0.04659467867239357,0.10241156737996511,modele,0.07743297435999716,0.04743463793002789,0.10743131078996644
6
+ 12500,0.6710859683036804,3.43,0.07746846829117007,0.049868209859521194,0.10506872672281896,,0.07550114371605977,0.04828007367063503,0.10272221376148451
7
+ 15000,0.6661567495465278,3.98,0.07771220143283196,0.04933374534695209,0.10609065751871183,,0.07837112128068843,0.05050647629489115,0.10623576626648572
8
+ 17500,0.6586158741235733,4.52,0.07595049465585083,0.04855999935642912,0.10334098995527254,,0.07640218282653927,0.048853154051914226,0.10395121160116431
9
+ 20000,0.6567949496746063,5.07,0.07547126947633316,0.04850230238691251,0.10244023656575381,,0.07539654798573334,0.04846927762533615,0.10232381834613054
training/v0.8/metrics.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,272 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "cfg": {
3
+ "arch": "unetpp",
4
+ "encoder": "efficientnet-b4",
5
+ "input": "rgb+lab",
6
+ "offsets": [
7
+ [
8
+ 1,
9
+ 0
10
+ ],
11
+ [
12
+ 0,
13
+ 1
14
+ ],
15
+ [
16
+ 3,
17
+ 0
18
+ ],
19
+ [
20
+ 0,
21
+ 3
22
+ ],
23
+ [
24
+ 9,
25
+ 0
26
+ ],
27
+ [
28
+ 0,
29
+ 9
30
+ ],
31
+ [
32
+ 9,
33
+ 9
34
+ ],
35
+ [
36
+ 9,
37
+ -9
38
+ ],
39
+ [
40
+ 27,
41
+ 0
42
+ ],
43
+ [
44
+ 0,
45
+ 27
46
+ ]
47
+ ],
48
+ "n_short": 2,
49
+ "mws_stride": 1,
50
+ "mws_min_size": 40,
51
+ "tile": 512,
52
+ "sep": true,
53
+ "small_w": false,
54
+ "ohem": false,
55
+ "tta": false
56
+ },
57
+ "steps": 10000,
58
+ "val_score": 0.07450312302617934,
59
+ "test": [
60
+ {
61
+ "groupe": "Africa",
62
+ "tuiles": 70,
63
+ "ARAND": 0.0277,
64
+ "sur_decoupage": 0.1428,
65
+ "fusion": 0.1006,
66
+ "rappel_petites": 0.8858,
67
+ "rappel_grandes": 0.9823,
68
+ "rappel_40_200": 0.8,
69
+ "rappel_200_1000": 0.9321,
70
+ "rappel_tous": 0.945,
71
+ "surface_correcte": 0.9933,
72
+ "F1_failles": NaN
73
+ },
74
+ {
75
+ "groupe": "Europe",
76
+ "tuiles": 184,
77
+ "ARAND": 0.1035,
78
+ "sur_decoupage": 0.4981,
79
+ "fusion": 0.3232,
80
+ "rappel_petites": 0.8187,
81
+ "rappel_grandes": 0.8905,
82
+ "rappel_40_200": 0.7788,
83
+ "rappel_200_1000": 0.8851,
84
+ "rappel_tous": 0.8363,
85
+ "surface_correcte": 0.9233,
86
+ "F1_failles": 0.0243
87
+ },
88
+ {
89
+ "groupe": "North America",
90
+ "tuiles": 268,
91
+ "ARAND": 0.09,
92
+ "sur_decoupage": 0.4352,
93
+ "fusion": 0.2824,
94
+ "rappel_petites": 0.7289,
95
+ "rappel_grandes": 0.9029,
96
+ "rappel_40_200": 0.6656,
97
+ "rappel_200_1000": 0.797,
98
+ "rappel_tous": 0.7702,
99
+ "surface_correcte": 0.95,
100
+ "F1_failles": 0.9473
101
+ },
102
+ {
103
+ "groupe": "Oceania",
104
+ "tuiles": 150,
105
+ "ARAND": 0.171,
106
+ "sur_decoupage": 0.9302,
107
+ "fusion": 0.4689,
108
+ "rappel_petites": 0.6476,
109
+ "rappel_grandes": 0.765,
110
+ "rappel_40_200": 0.6163,
111
+ "rappel_200_1000": 0.6949,
112
+ "rappel_tous": 0.6657,
113
+ "surface_correcte": 0.8421,
114
+ "F1_failles": 0.9871
115
+ },
116
+ {
117
+ "groupe": "BRGM-50k / real",
118
+ "tuiles": 64,
119
+ "ARAND": 0.1231,
120
+ "sur_decoupage": 0.3039,
121
+ "fusion": 0.422,
122
+ "rappel_petites": 0.4577,
123
+ "rappel_grandes": 0.8234,
124
+ "rappel_40_200": 0.2041,
125
+ "rappel_200_1000": 0.5914,
126
+ "rappel_tous": 0.7624,
127
+ "surface_correcte": 0.9059,
128
+ "F1_failles": 0.0243
129
+ },
130
+ {
131
+ "groupe": "GA-Australia / synthetic",
132
+ "tuiles": 150,
133
+ "ARAND": 0.171,
134
+ "sur_decoupage": 0.9302,
135
+ "fusion": 0.4689,
136
+ "rappel_petites": 0.6476,
137
+ "rappel_grandes": 0.765,
138
+ "rappel_40_200": 0.6163,
139
+ "rappel_200_1000": 0.6949,
140
+ "rappel_tous": 0.6657,
141
+ "surface_correcte": 0.8421,
142
+ "F1_failles": 0.9871
143
+ },
144
+ {
145
+ "groupe": "GEO-LiM / synthetic",
146
+ "tuiles": 120,
147
+ "ARAND": 0.0931,
148
+ "sur_decoupage": 0.6017,
149
+ "fusion": 0.2705,
150
+ "rappel_petites": 0.8245,
151
+ "rappel_grandes": 0.9123,
152
+ "rappel_40_200": 0.7839,
153
+ "rappel_200_1000": 0.8935,
154
+ "rappel_tous": 0.842,
155
+ "surface_correcte": 0.9332,
156
+ "F1_failles": NaN
157
+ },
158
+ {
159
+ "groupe": "GMNA / real",
160
+ "tuiles": 78,
161
+ "ARAND": 0.0535,
162
+ "sur_decoupage": 0.225,
163
+ "fusion": 0.2433,
164
+ "rappel_petites": 0.7484,
165
+ "rappel_grandes": 0.9124,
166
+ "rappel_40_200": 0.5242,
167
+ "rappel_200_1000": 0.8539,
168
+ "rappel_tous": 0.8245,
169
+ "surface_correcte": 0.9758,
170
+ "F1_failles": 0.6355
171
+ },
172
+ {
173
+ "groupe": "GMNA / synthetic",
174
+ "tuiles": 60,
175
+ "ARAND": 0.0223,
176
+ "sur_decoupage": 0.1294,
177
+ "fusion": 0.1246,
178
+ "rappel_petites": 0.8943,
179
+ "rappel_grandes": 0.9739,
180
+ "rappel_40_200": 0.8065,
181
+ "rappel_200_1000": 0.9366,
182
+ "rappel_tous": 0.929,
183
+ "surface_correcte": 0.9909,
184
+ "F1_failles": 0.9708
185
+ },
186
+ {
187
+ "groupe": "UNESCO-Ethiopia / synthetic",
188
+ "tuiles": 70,
189
+ "ARAND": 0.0277,
190
+ "sur_decoupage": 0.1428,
191
+ "fusion": 0.1006,
192
+ "rappel_petites": 0.8858,
193
+ "rappel_grandes": 0.9823,
194
+ "rappel_40_200": 0.8,
195
+ "rappel_200_1000": 0.9321,
196
+ "rappel_tous": 0.945,
197
+ "surface_correcte": 0.9933,
198
+ "F1_failles": NaN
199
+ },
200
+ {
201
+ "groupe": "USGS-California / synthetic",
202
+ "tuiles": 70,
203
+ "ARAND": 0.0761,
204
+ "sur_decoupage": 0.5069,
205
+ "fusion": 0.3483,
206
+ "rappel_petites": 0.7503,
207
+ "rappel_grandes": 0.8986,
208
+ "rappel_40_200": 0.6966,
209
+ "rappel_200_1000": 0.7996,
210
+ "rappel_tous": 0.7841,
211
+ "surface_correcte": 0.9489,
212
+ "F1_failles": 0.9689
213
+ },
214
+ {
215
+ "groupe": "USGS-Nevada / synthetic",
216
+ "tuiles": 60,
217
+ "ARAND": 0.2212,
218
+ "sur_decoupage": 0.9305,
219
+ "fusion": 0.4142,
220
+ "rappel_petites": 0.6914,
221
+ "rappel_grandes": 0.8679,
222
+ "rappel_40_200": 0.6483,
223
+ "rappel_200_1000": 0.7544,
224
+ "rappel_tous": 0.7204,
225
+ "surface_correcte": 0.8795,
226
+ "F1_failles": 0.9468
227
+ },
228
+ {
229
+ "groupe": "TEST COMPLET",
230
+ "tuiles": 672,
231
+ "ARAND": 0.1053,
232
+ "sur_decoupage": 0.5324,
233
+ "fusion": 0.3163,
234
+ "rappel_petites": 0.7096,
235
+ "rappel_grandes": 0.8632,
236
+ "rappel_40_200": 0.6645,
237
+ "rappel_200_1000": 0.7699,
238
+ "rappel_tous": 0.7421,
239
+ "surface_correcte": 0.9229,
240
+ "F1_failles": 0.9624
241
+ },
242
+ {
243
+ "groupe": "PIÈGE unités de même couleur",
244
+ "tuiles": 48,
245
+ "ARAND": 0.164,
246
+ "sur_decoupage": 0.5749,
247
+ "fusion": 0.5494,
248
+ "rappel_petites": 0.6101,
249
+ "rappel_grandes": 0.741,
250
+ "rappel_40_200": 0.5677,
251
+ "rappel_200_1000": 0.6596,
252
+ "rappel_tous": 0.6404,
253
+ "surface_correcte": 0.8339,
254
+ "F1_failles": 0.9711
255
+ },
256
+ {
257
+ "groupe": "PIÈGE unités à motifs",
258
+ "tuiles": 48,
259
+ "ARAND": 0.0929,
260
+ "sur_decoupage": 0.48,
261
+ "fusion": 0.2884,
262
+ "rappel_petites": 0.7466,
263
+ "rappel_grandes": 0.901,
264
+ "rappel_40_200": 0.6976,
265
+ "rappel_200_1000": 0.8011,
266
+ "rappel_tous": 0.7834,
267
+ "surface_correcte": 0.9435,
268
+ "F1_failles": 0.9771
269
+ }
270
+ ],
271
+ "train_hours": 5.23
272
+ }
training/v0.8/separator_metrics.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
 
 
1
+ {"plate_err_raw": 81.95002736141336, "plate_err": 13.90600299835205, "iou": [0.8818230283938705, 0.5564695664286939, 0.318674142871791, 0.6345497138853331, 0.4833100426534778, 0.21626427395051015, 0.6380145011186716]}
training/v0.8/test_metrics.csv ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,16 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ groupe,tuiles,ARAND,sur_decoupage,fusion,rappel_petites,rappel_grandes,rappel_40_200,rappel_200_1000,rappel_tous,surface_correcte,F1_failles
2
+ Africa,70,0.0277,0.1428,0.1006,0.8858,0.9823,0.8,0.9321,0.945,0.9933,
3
+ Europe,184,0.1035,0.4981,0.3232,0.8187,0.8905,0.7788,0.8851,0.8363,0.9233,0.0243
4
+ North America,268,0.09,0.4352,0.2824,0.7289,0.9029,0.6656,0.797,0.7702,0.95,0.9473
5
+ Oceania,150,0.171,0.9302,0.4689,0.6476,0.765,0.6163,0.6949,0.6657,0.8421,0.9871
6
+ BRGM-50k / real,64,0.1231,0.3039,0.422,0.4577,0.8234,0.2041,0.5914,0.7624,0.9059,0.0243
7
+ GA-Australia / synthetic,150,0.171,0.9302,0.4689,0.6476,0.765,0.6163,0.6949,0.6657,0.8421,0.9871
8
+ GEO-LiM / synthetic,120,0.0931,0.6017,0.2705,0.8245,0.9123,0.7839,0.8935,0.842,0.9332,
9
+ GMNA / real,78,0.0535,0.225,0.2433,0.7484,0.9124,0.5242,0.8539,0.8245,0.9758,0.6355
10
+ GMNA / synthetic,60,0.0223,0.1294,0.1246,0.8943,0.9739,0.8065,0.9366,0.929,0.9909,0.9708
11
+ UNESCO-Ethiopia / synthetic,70,0.0277,0.1428,0.1006,0.8858,0.9823,0.8,0.9321,0.945,0.9933,
12
+ USGS-California / synthetic,70,0.0761,0.5069,0.3483,0.7503,0.8986,0.6966,0.7996,0.7841,0.9489,0.9689
13
+ USGS-Nevada / synthetic,60,0.2212,0.9305,0.4142,0.6914,0.8679,0.6483,0.7544,0.7204,0.8795,0.9468
14
+ TEST COMPLET,672,0.1053,0.5324,0.3163,0.7096,0.8632,0.6645,0.7699,0.7421,0.9229,0.9624
15
+ PIÈGE unités de même couleur,48,0.164,0.5749,0.5494,0.6101,0.741,0.5677,0.6596,0.6404,0.8339,0.9711
16
+ PIÈGE unités à motifs,48,0.0929,0.48,0.2884,0.7466,0.901,0.6976,0.8011,0.7834,0.9435,0.9771