twins · holy-agents

Three independent auditors run in parallel. Disagreements are logged, not hidden.

Previous Failure → Current Pass

9 consensus failures repaired via repentance cycle. Each finding was diagnosed, repaired, and re-audited.

1. WORM Race Condition

FAIL PASS

Before

readEntries() → modify → writeEntries() rewrote entire file. Concurrent appends overwrite each other.

src/worm.ts — writeEntries()

After

appendLine() using fs.appendFileSync(). Single-line atomic append, no full-file rewrite.

src/worm.ts — appendLine()

2. Path Traversal Vulnerability

FAIL PASS

Before

serveStatic() joined paths with no containment check. /docs/../../src/server.ts served arbitrary files.

src/server.ts — path.join()

After

isPathSafe() resolves full path, checks it starts with DOCS_DIR. Returns 403 on escape.

src/server.ts — isPathSafe()

3. RTRUST Enforcement Incomplete

FAIL PASS

Before

checkActionAgainstRules() checked 3 of 7 principles: truthfulness, love, justice. Autonomy, accountability, attribution unenforced.

src/rtrust.ts — switch (principle)

After

Added autonomy (consent), accountability (witnessed), attribution (cited). All 7 principles enforced.

src/rtrust.ts — 7 cases

4. Reverse Proof Not Integrated

FAIL PASS

Before

reverseProof hardcoded to { allVerified: true, orphanArtifacts: [] }. buildReverseProof() never called.

src/server.ts — /query endpoint

After

buildReverseProof() called with actual artifact maps. Article III of Second Trust Deed enforced.

src/server.ts — /query, /audit

5. Unsafe JSON.parse

FAIL PASS

Before

JSON.parse without try/catch in worm.ts, rtrust.ts, server.ts. Corrupted data crashes the system.

src/worm.ts, rtrust.ts, server.ts

After

All JSON.parse calls wrapped in try/catch. Corrupt lines skipped gracefully. POST handlers return 400.

src/worm.ts, rtrust.ts, server.ts

6. Missing Request Validation

FAIL PASS

Before

POST endpoints accept arbitrary JSON. body.query as string — no type checks.

src/server.ts — POST /query, /action

After

validateQueryBody() and validateActionBody() type guards. Returns 400 for missing/invalid fields.

src/server.ts — validators

7. Sync I/O Hot Paths

FAIL PASS

Before

loadRTRUST() reads constitution from disk on every request. No caching.

src/rtrust.ts — loadRTRUST()

After

Module-level cachedRules with clearRTRUSTCache(). Loaded once, cached for subsequent requests.

src/rtrust.ts — cachedRules

8. FORBIDDEN_ACTIONS Incomplete

FAIL PASS

Before

unmerciful_judgment, cruelty, vengeance from RTRUST-006 missing. 21 of 24.

src/validation.ts — FORBIDDEN_ACTIONS

After

Added 3 missing actions. Total now 24. All RTRUST-006 violations covered.

src/validation.ts — 24 items

9. Sentinel Skips RTRUST

FAIL PASS

Before

sentinelCheck() only calls validateAction and checkForbidden. RTRUST rule violations ignored.

src/agents/sentinel.ts — sentinelCheck()

After

Now imports and calls checkActionAgainstRules() from rtrust.ts. RTRUST violations added to violations array.

src/agents/sentinel.ts — RTRUST check

Re-Audit Summary 0/3 FAIL

Before — All Twins

TWIN-A (Security): FAIL 0.88
TWIN-B (Logic): FAIL 0.42
TWIN-C (Performance): FAIL 0.45

After — All Twins

TWIN-A (Security): PASS 0.92
TWIN-B (Logic): PASS 0.85
TWIN-C (Performance): PASS 0.88

Digital Twin Audit

⚡ Disagreements

Previous Failure → Current Pass