Instructions to use XXXpilar/Fastfill-test with libraries, inference providers, notebooks, and local apps. Follow these links to get started.
- Libraries
- PEFT
How to use XXXpilar/Fastfill-test with PEFT:
Task type is invalid.
- Notebooks
- Google Colab
- Kaggle
File size: 52,895 Bytes
e6f80f3 | 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 158 159 160 161 162 163 164 165 166 167 168 169 170 171 172 173 174 175 176 177 178 179 180 181 182 183 184 185 186 187 188 189 190 191 192 193 194 195 196 197 198 199 200 201 202 203 204 205 206 207 208 209 210 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 218 219 220 221 222 223 224 225 226 227 228 229 230 231 232 233 234 235 236 237 238 239 240 241 242 243 244 245 246 247 248 249 250 251 252 253 254 255 256 257 258 259 260 261 262 263 264 265 266 267 268 269 270 271 272 273 274 275 276 277 278 279 280 281 282 283 284 285 286 287 288 289 290 291 292 293 294 295 296 297 298 299 300 301 302 303 304 305 306 307 308 309 310 311 312 313 314 315 316 317 318 319 320 321 322 323 324 325 326 327 328 329 330 331 332 333 334 335 336 337 338 339 340 341 342 343 344 345 346 347 348 349 350 351 352 353 354 355 356 357 358 359 360 361 362 363 364 365 366 367 368 369 370 371 372 373 374 375 376 377 378 379 380 381 382 383 384 385 386 387 388 389 390 391 392 393 394 395 396 397 398 399 400 401 402 403 404 405 406 407 408 409 410 411 412 413 414 415 416 417 418 419 420 421 422 423 424 425 426 427 428 429 430 431 432 433 434 435 436 437 438 439 440 441 442 443 444 445 446 447 448 449 450 451 452 453 454 455 456 457 458 459 460 461 462 463 464 465 466 467 468 469 470 471 472 473 474 475 476 477 478 479 480 481 482 483 484 485 486 487 488 489 490 491 492 493 494 495 496 497 498 499 500 501 502 503 504 505 506 507 508 509 510 511 512 513 514 515 516 517 518 519 520 521 522 523 524 525 526 527 528 529 530 531 532 533 534 535 536 537 538 539 540 541 542 543 544 545 546 547 548 549 550 551 552 553 554 555 556 557 558 559 560 561 562 563 564 565 566 567 568 569 570 571 572 573 574 575 576 577 578 579 580 581 582 583 584 585 586 587 588 589 590 591 592 593 594 595 596 597 598 599 600 601 602 603 604 605 606 607 608 609 610 611 612 613 614 615 616 617 618 619 620 621 622 623 624 625 626 627 628 629 630 631 632 633 634 635 636 637 638 639 640 | """One self-contained HTML report (Simplified Chinese, tables only, no external resources) from the analysis JSONs.
python report.py --out report.html [--inputs inputs.json] --summary "最终臂=runs/autorun-X/SUMMARY.md" ... \
--val-run "基线·三字段·spread=S.json" ... --val-compare "最终 vs 基线·三字段·spread·全部对象=C.json" ... \
[--val-control "最终 vs 对照·三字段·spread·全部对象=C.json" ...] --val-decode "最终·三字段:spread vs argmax=C.json" ... \
[--test-run ... --test-compare ... --test-control ... --test-decode ...] [--llm L.json] \
[--ablation "最终=ablation/report.json" ... --ablation-sample sample.json] \
[--selection-cohort "最终(select2)=validation-X-all.jsonl" ...] [--reference "最终=DIR" ...] \
[--walltime walltime.tsv] [--notes NOTES.md]
Inputs: stratify.py / compare.py / llm_compare.py outputs, diag_ablation.py report.json, roomgenbench --reference-check
JSONs (one directory per checkpoint), the autopilot SUMMARY.md files (``[LABEL=]PATH``), run_plan's walltime.tsv and
isambard_inputs.py's inputs.json (the two arms, which one is final and why, data / model provenance, missing LLM modes).
Every number and every "all / none" statement shown is read from these files.
Decisions come ONLY from the validation comparisons (``--val-compare``: final vs baseline; ``--val-control``: final vs
control, the evidence for the choice of the final arm; ``--val-decode``: spread vs argmax). Test, LLM, ablation and
RoomGenBench sections are labelled report-only and never feed a decision. Significance:
primary = paired room-bootstrap 95% CI of the mean per-room difference (direction from it); robustness = Holm-corrected
sign test; disagreements are flagged; pooled object-weighted differences are descriptive only. A final-vs-baseline
comparison whose two sides carry the same checkpoint is flagged as a placeholder (and "differences are 0" when both
sides are also the same evaluate output). A ``--selection-cohort`` label starts with 最终 or 基线, the checkpoint that
cohort selected; the selection-bias note names a direction only when one checkpoint's cohorts hold the validation
scenes and the other's were given and do not.
"""
from __future__ import annotations
import argparse
from collections import Counter
import html
import json
import math
from pathlib import Path
import re
NAMES = {"bottom_center_error_m": "位置误差 (m) ↓", "log_size_error": "log 尺寸误差 ↓", "yaw_error_rad": "朝向误差 (rad) ↓",
"bev_iou": "BEV IoU ↑", "log_size_error_plain_convention": "log 尺寸误差·原约定 ↓",
"yaw_error_rad_plain_convention": "朝向误差·原约定 (rad) ↓", "object_collision_rate": "物体碰撞率 ↓",
"object_hard_violation_rate": "物体硬约束违例率 ↓", "gt_object_collision_rate": "真值物体碰撞率",
"room_clean_rate": "洁净房间率(有布局)↑", "room_collision_rate": "有碰撞房间率 ↓", "gt_room_clean_rate": "真值洁净房间率",
"gt_room_collision_rate": "真值有碰撞房间率", "interface_pass_rate": "接口通过率 ↑", "strict_ok_rate": "严格几何通过率 ↑",
"clean_room_rate_incl_failures": "洁净房间率(失败计不洁净)↑",
"baseline:room_center_position": "基线·房间中心 (m)", "baseline:category_mean_position": "基线·类别均值位置 (m)",
"baseline:category_median_size": "基线·类别中位尺寸", "baseline:uniform_yaw": "基线·均匀随机朝向 (rad)",
"cell_ce": "格子交叉熵 ↓", "cell_entropy": "预测格子熵", "p_gt": "p(真值格子) ↑", "argmax_hit": "argmax 命中率 ↑",
"xy_err_m": "argmax XY 误差 (m) ↓", "size_err": "尺寸误差 ↓", "yaw_ce": "朝向分类交叉熵 ↓", "yaw_err_rad": "朝向误差 (rad) ↓",
"gt_rank": "真值格子名次 ↓", "cell_tv_vs_a": "格子分布 TV 距离(相对 a)", "yaw_tv_vs_a": "朝向分布 TV 距离(相对 a)"}
KINDS = {"rule": "目标选择规则", "place": "声明位置", "family": "来源族", "objects": "物体数分箱", "all": "全部"}
RULE_NAMES = {"frozen_prep": "frozen_prep(旧对象)", "wall_anchor": "wall_anchor(新·墙面)",
"support_inside_parent": "support_inside_parent(新·内层)", "support_on_added_parent": "support_on_added_parent(新·新增父物体上)"}
ABLATION = {"b": "b 房间尺寸换成另一房间的", "c": "c 房间类型换成另一房间的", "d": "d 描述换成类别名", "e": "e 请求顺序打乱"}
MODES = {"prompt": "单次询问", "harness": "修复循环(校验后带问题清单重问)", "structured": "单次询问(结构化提示)",
"structured-harness": "修复循环(结构化提示,校验后重问)"}
CAUSES = {"IncompleteRead": "中继传输错误(HTTP 响应体读取不完整,IncompleteRead):传输层失败,不是模型给出的无效布局",
"over_capacity": "超出模型容量 max_objects", "other": "其他推理失败"}
VERDICT = {"a_better": ("A 更好", "good"), "a_worse": ("A 更差", "bad"), None: ("无显著差异", "")}
CSS = """
:root{--bg:#fbfbfa;--fg:#1d1d1f;--muted:#6b6b70;--line:#e2e2e0;--card:#fff;--accent:#2f5d9e;--good:#1f7a4d;--bad:#a8322d;--warn:#8a5a00;--warnbg:#fff6e0}
@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){:root:not([data-theme="light"]){--bg:#151517;--fg:#ececee;--muted:#a0a0a8;--line:#333338;--card:#1d1d20;--accent:#8fb3ec;--good:#6cc79a;--bad:#ef8b85;--warn:#e7c06a;--warnbg:#2b2416}}
:root[data-theme="dark"]{--bg:#151517;--fg:#ececee;--muted:#a0a0a8;--line:#333338;--card:#1d1d20;--accent:#8fb3ec;--good:#6cc79a;--bad:#ef8b85;--warn:#e7c06a;--warnbg:#2b2416}
*{box-sizing:border-box}body{margin:0;background:var(--bg);color:var(--fg);font:15px/1.6 -apple-system,"PingFang SC","Hiragino Sans GB","Microsoft YaHei","Noto Sans CJK SC",sans-serif}
main{max-width:1100px;margin:0 auto;padding:24px 16px 64px}h1{font-size:1.6em;margin:.2em 0}h2{font-size:1.25em;margin-top:2.2em;border-bottom:1px solid var(--line);padding-bottom:.3em}
h3{font-size:1.05em;margin-top:1.6em}p,li{max-width:80ch}.muted{color:var(--muted)}code{font-size:.9em;background:var(--card);border:1px solid var(--line);border-radius:4px;padding:0 .3em;word-break:break-all}
.wrap{overflow-x:auto;margin:.6em 0 1.2em;border:1px solid var(--line);border-radius:8px;background:var(--card)}
table{border-collapse:collapse;width:100%;font-size:.88em;font-variant-numeric:tabular-nums}th,td{padding:.45em .7em;border-bottom:1px solid var(--line);text-align:right;white-space:nowrap}
th:first-child,td:first-child{text-align:left}thead th{background:var(--bg);font-weight:600}tr:last-child td{border-bottom:0}
.ci{color:var(--muted);font-size:.85em}.good{color:var(--good);font-weight:600}.bad{color:var(--bad);font-weight:600}
.flag{background:var(--warnbg);color:var(--warn);border-left:3px solid var(--warn);padding:.6em .9em;border-radius:4px;margin:1em 0}
.tag{display:inline-block;font-size:.75em;font-weight:600;padding:.05em .5em;border-radius:4px;border:1px solid currentColor;margin-left:.5em;vertical-align:middle}
details{margin:.8em 0}summary{cursor:pointer;color:var(--accent)}nav a{color:var(--accent);margin-right:1em;text-decoration:none}
"""
REPORT_ONLY = "<span class='tag muted'>仅报告,不参与决策</span>"
DECISION = "<span class='tag good'>决策依据:验证集</span>"
def esc(value):
return html.escape(str(value))
def num(x, digits=3):
if x is None or (isinstance(x, float) and not math.isfinite(x)):
return "—"
return f"{x:.{digits}g}" if abs(x) and abs(x) < 1e-3 else f"{x:.{digits}f}"
def cell(stat, digits=3):
"""mean [lo, hi] from {"mean", "ci95"} or [mean, lo, hi, ...]."""
if stat is None:
return "—"
mean, lo, hi = (stat["mean"], *stat["ci95"]) if isinstance(stat, dict) else stat[:3]
return f'{num(mean, digits)} <span class="ci">[{num(lo, digits)}, {num(hi, digits)}]</span>'
def pval(p):
return "—" if p is None else "<1e-300" if p == 0 else f"{p:.2g}"
def table(head, rows):
out = "<div class='wrap'><table><thead><tr>" + "".join(f"<th>{h}</th>" for h in head) + "</tr></thead><tbody>"
return out + "".join("<tr>" + "".join(f"<td>{c}</td>" for c in row) + "</tr>" for row in rows) + "</tbody></table></div>"
def markdown(text):
"""The subset SUMMARY.md uses: headings, pipe tables, bullets, paragraphs, `code`, **bold**."""
inline = lambda s: re.sub(r"\*\*(.+?)\*\*", r"<b>\1</b>", re.sub(r"`([^`]+)`", r"<code>\1</code>", esc(s)))
out, lines, i = [], text.splitlines(), 0
while i < len(lines):
line = lines[i]
if line.startswith("#"):
level = min(len(line) - len(line.lstrip("#")) + 2, 6)
out.append(f"<h{level}>{inline(line.lstrip('#').strip())}</h{level}>")
elif line.startswith("|"):
block = []
while i < len(lines) and lines[i].startswith("|"):
block.append([c.strip() for c in lines[i].strip().strip("|").split("|")])
i += 1
body = [r for r in block[1:] if not all(set(c) <= set("-: ") for c in r)]
out.append(table([inline(c) for c in block[0]], [[inline(c) for c in r] for r in body]))
continue
elif line.startswith("- "):
items = []
while i < len(lines) and lines[i].startswith("- "):
items.append(f"<li>{inline(lines[i][2:])}</li>")
i += 1
out.append("<ul>" + "".join(items) + "</ul>")
continue
elif line.strip():
out.append(f"<p>{inline(line)}</p>")
i += 1
return "\n".join(out)
def load(spec):
label, _, path = spec.rpartition("=") # labels may hold "=", paths do not
return label, json.loads(Path(path).read_text()), path
def short_ckpt(path):
return f"{Path(path).parent.name}/{Path(path).name}" if path else "—"
def rows_info(path, _cache={}):
"""(scene ids, objects whose selection_rule is not frozen_prep) of a rows JSONL file."""
if path not in _cache:
ids, new = set(), 0
with open(path) as stream:
for line in stream:
if line.strip():
prov = json.loads(line)["provenance"]
ids.add(prov.get("scene_id"))
new += sum(((e or {}).get("selection_rule") or "frozen_prep") != "frozen_prep" for e in prov.get("field_evidence") or [])
_cache[path] = ids, new
return _cache[path]
def scene_ids(path):
return rows_info(path)[0]
def overlaps(ids, cohorts):
"""(label, path, scenes of `ids` in the cohort) for every cohort holding any of them."""
return [(label, path, len(ids & scene_ids(path))) for label, path in cohorts if ids & scene_ids(path)]
def cohort_flags(what, ids, cohorts):
return "".join(f"<div class='flag'><b>选择队列重叠:</b>{esc(what)} {len(ids)} 个场景中有 {k} 个在「{esc(label)}」的检查点选择队列 "
f"<code>{esc(Path(path).name)}</code>({len(scene_ids(path))} 个场景,非 frozen_prep 规则物体 {rows_info(path)[1]} 个)内:"
"这些行参与了挑选该检查点,该检查点在这些行上不是留出评测。</div>" for label, path, k in overlaps(ids, cohorts))
ROLES = ("最终", "基线") # a --selection-cohort label starts with the checkpoint it selected
def bias_note(what, ids, cohorts):
"""Selection-bias statement for the scenes `ids`, from each checkpoint's cohorts: a direction only when one
checkpoint's cohorts hold these scenes and the other's were given and do not."""
given = {r: [(l, p) for l, p in cohorts if l.startswith(r)] for r in ROLES}
hit = {r: overlaps(ids, given[r]) for r in ROLES}
cover = lambda r: "、".join(f"「{esc(l)}」{k}/{len(ids)}" for l, _, k in hit[r])
if all(hit.values()):
version = {r: {m.group(1) for _, p, _ in hit[r] if (m := re.match(r"validation-([0-9a-f]{12})-", Path(p).name))} for r in ROLES}
saw = [r for r in ROLES if any(rows_info(p)[1] for _, p, _ in hit[r])]
return (f"{esc(what)}:两个检查点都在这些场景上被选择过(最终 {cover('最终')};基线 {cover('基线')}"
+ (f";不同数据版本:源验证文件 sha256 前缀 最终 {'/'.join(sorted(version['最终']))},基线 {'/'.join(sorted(version['基线']))}"
if all(version.values()) and not version["最终"] & version["基线"] else "")
+ "),选择偏差的方向无法确定。选择队列中的新对象(非 frozen_prep 规则):"
+ ";".join(f"「{esc(l)}」{rows_info(p)[1]} 个" for r in ROLES for l, p, _ in hit[r])
+ (f":只有{saw[0]}的选择见过新对象。" if len(saw) == 1 else "。"))
for r, o in (ROLES, ROLES[::-1]):
if hit[r]:
return (f"{esc(what)}:只有{r}的选择队列含这些场景({cover(r)};{o}的选择队列 0/{len(ids)}):这些行对{r}不是留出评测,比较可能偏向{r}。"
if given[o] else f"{esc(what)}:{r}的选择队列含这些场景({cover(r)});未提供{o}的选择队列,选择偏差的方向无法判断。")
return ""
def run_rows(runs):
rows = []
for split, label, s in runs:
m, c = s["meta"], s["checks"]
rows.append([split, esc(label), f"<code>{esc(short_ckpt(m['checkpoint']))}</code>",
f"<code>{esc(Path(m['rows']).parent.name)}/{esc(Path(m['rows']).name)}</code>", esc(m["projection"]),
esc(m.get("grid_decode") or "—"), "头输出重解码" if m.get("head_outputs") else esc(m.get("baseline") or "—"),
f"<code>{esc((m.get('data_sha256') or '')[:12])}</code>",
f"<code>{esc((m.get('forward_implementation_sha256') or '—')[:12])}</code>",
f"<code>{esc((m.get('implementation_sha256') or '—')[:12])}</code>",
f"{c['requests_with_layout']}/{c['requests']}",
'<span class="good">是</span>' if c["reproduces_report_exactly"] else '<span class="bad">否</span>',
str(c["rooms_validation_differs_from_stored"])])
return table(["集合", "运行", "检查点", "数据", "投影", "解码", "来源", "数据 sha256", "前向代码", "解码/评分代码",
"有布局/请求", "逐位复现 report.json", "校验器漂移房间"], rows)
def overall(s, metric):
return s["strata"]["all"]["all"]["metrics"].get(metric)
def placeholder(c):
"""A final-vs-baseline comparison whose two sides carry the same checkpoint."""
return c["meta"]["a"].get("checkpoint") == c["meta"]["b"].get("checkpoint")
def same_output(c):
"""Both sides are the same evaluate output: every difference is 0."""
return all(c["meta"]["a"].get(k) == c["meta"]["b"].get(k) for k in ("eval_dir", "outcomes"))
def verdict_cell(v, a="A"):
text, cls = VERDICT[v["verdict"]["primary"]]
return f'<span class="{cls}">{text.replace("A", esc(a))}</span>' if cls else text
def compare_table(c, final_vs_baseline=False):
a, b = c["meta"]["a"]["label"], c["meta"]["b"]["label"]
rows = []
for metric, v in c["metrics"].items():
st, lo, hi = v["sign_test"], *v["room_mean_diff_ci95"]
robust = VERDICT[v["verdict"]["sign_test"]][0]
rows.append([NAMES.get(metric, metric), num(v["a"]), num(v["b"]), num(v.get("a_room_mean")), num(v.get("b_room_mean")),
f"{num(v['room_mean_diff'], 4)} <span class='ci'>[{num(lo, 4)}, {num(hi, 4)}]</span>", verdict_cell(v),
f"{st['a_greater']}/{st['b_greater']}/{st['ties']}", pval(st["p_holm"]),
robust if v["verdict"]["agree"] else f"<span class='bad'>⚠ 不一致:{robust}</span>",
f"{num(v['pooled_diff'], 4)} <span class='ci'>[{num(v['pooled_diff_ci95'][0], 4)}, {num(v['pooled_diff_ci95'][1], 4)}]</span>",
str(v["rooms"])])
r, where = c["rooms"], c["meta"].get("where") or {}
note = (f"<p class='muted'>A = {esc(a)},B = {esc(b)};差值 = A − B;合并 = 物体加权均值,房间均值 = 先在房间内平均再对房间平均"
f"(A、B 房间均值之差即主判据的房间均值差)。房间 {r['compared']}"
+ (f"(另有 {r['excluded_by_room_filter']} 个房间因物体数 > {c['meta']['max_objects']} 被排除)" if c["meta"].get("max_objects") else "")
+ f":两者都有布局 {r['layout_both']},仅 A 有布局 {r['layout_only_a']},仅 B 有布局 {r['layout_only_b']},都没有 {r['layout_neither']};"
"配对指标只在两者都有布局的房间上计算" + (f";筛选 {esc(where)}" if where else "") + f";bootstrap {c['meta']['boot']} 次(房间为单位,配对)。</p>")
if final_vs_baseline and placeholder(c):
note += (f"<p class='bad'>占位:A、B 是同一个检查点 <code>{esc(short_ckpt(c['meta']['a'].get('checkpoint')))}</code>,差值不说明最终模型"
+ (";A 与 B 也是同一个评测输出:差值必为 0" if same_output(c) else "") + "。</p>")
elif same_output(c):
note += "<p class='muted'>A 与 B 是同一个评测输出:差值必为 0。</p>"
if not rows:
return note + "<p class='muted'>没有符合筛选条件的物体(例如旧数据没有新增对象),无可比较的指标。</p>"
return note + table(["指标", "A(合并,物体加权)", "B(合并,物体加权)", "A 房间均值", "B 房间均值", "房间均值差 [95% CI](主判据)",
"结论(主判据)", "符号检验 A>B/A<B/平", "p (Holm)", "稳健性:符号检验", "合并差值 [95% CI](物体加权,仅描述)",
"房间"], rows)
def strata_tables(s, metrics):
out = []
for kind in ("rule", "place", "family", "objects"):
entries = s["strata"].get(kind, {})
rows = [[esc(RULE_NAMES.get(v, v)), str(e["rooms"]), str(e.get("rooms_with_layout", "—")), str(e["objects"])]
+ [cell(e["metrics"].get(m)) for m in metrics] for v, e in entries.items()]
out.append(f"<h3>按{KINDS[kind]}</h3>" + table([KINDS[kind], "房间", "有布局房间", "物体"] + [NAMES[m] for m in metrics], rows))
return "".join(out)
STRATA_METRICS = ("bottom_center_error_m", "baseline:room_center_position", "log_size_error", "yaw_error_rad",
"object_collision_rate", "room_clean_rate")
def results_table(runs):
"""Model metrics per run next to the trivial baselines of the first run's objects."""
pairs = (("bottom_center_error_m", ("baseline:room_center_position", "baseline:category_mean_position")),
("log_size_error", ("baseline:category_median_size",)), ("yaw_error_rad", ("baseline:uniform_yaw",)), ("bev_iou", ()),
("object_collision_rate", ()), ("room_clean_rate", ()))
first = runs[0]
rows = [[NAMES[metric]] + [cell(overall(s, metric)) for _, s in runs]
+ ["<br>".join(f"{NAMES[b]}:{cell(overall(first[1], b))}" for b in baselines) or "—"] for metric, baselines in pairs]
return table(["指标"] + [esc(label) for label, _ in runs] + [f"平凡基线({esc(first[0])} 的同一批物体)"], rows)
def full_set_table(runs):
"""Every room of each run, including those beyond the baseline's max_objects (not paired; room sets differ)."""
rows = []
for label, s in runs:
big = s["strata"].get("objects", {}).get("129+", {})
rows.append([esc(label), f"{s['checks']['requests_with_layout']}/{s['checks']['requests']}", str(s["checks"]["over_capacity_requests"]),
f"{big.get('rooms_with_layout', 0)}/{big.get('rooms', 0)}"]
+ [cell(overall(s, m)) for m in ("bottom_center_error_m", "log_size_error", "yaw_error_rad", "object_collision_rate", "room_clean_rate")])
return table(["运行", "有布局/请求", "超出容量", ">128 物体房间:有布局/总数", NAMES["bottom_center_error_m"], NAMES["log_size_error"],
NAMES["yaw_error_rad"], NAMES["object_collision_rate"], NAMES["room_clean_rate"]], rows)
def decision_table(compares, final_vs_baseline):
rows = []
for label, c, _ in compares:
by = {key: [NAMES.get(m, m) for m, v in c["metrics"].items() if v["verdict"]["primary"] == key] for key in ("a_better", "a_worse", None)}
disagree = [f"{NAMES.get(m, m)}(符号检验:{VERDICT[v['verdict']['sign_test']][0]})" for m, v in c["metrics"].items() if not v["verdict"]["agree"]]
rows.append([esc(label) + ("<br><span class='bad'>占位:A、B 同一检查点</span>" if final_vs_baseline and placeholder(c) else ""),
f"{esc(c['meta']['a']['label'])} / {esc(c['meta']['b']['label'])}", str(c["rooms"]["layout_both"]),
f"<span class='good'>{'、'.join(by['a_better'])}</span>" if by["a_better"] else "—",
f"<span class='bad'>{'、'.join(by['a_worse'])}</span>" if by["a_worse"] else "—", str(len(by[None])),
f"<span class='bad'>⚠ {';'.join(disagree)}</span>" if disagree else "无"])
return table(["验证集比较", "A / B", "配对房间", "A 显著更好(主判据)", "A 显著更差(主判据)", "无显著差异的指标数", "与符号检验不一致"], rows)
def section_reference(refs):
out = []
for label, directory in refs:
rows, check_rows, versions = [], [], set()
for path in sorted(Path(directory).glob("*.json")):
r = json.loads(path.read_text())
versions.add(r["schema_version"])
for place in ("all", "floor", "wall", "on_object"):
e = r["errors"].get(place)
if e: # box_equivalent_* exist in schema v1 and v2; v2 adds matching (by_id = unmatched) and a per-place yaw baseline
rows.append([esc(r["scene_key"]) if place == "all" else "", {"all": "全部", "floor": "地面", "wall": "墙面", "on_object": "物体上"}[place],
str(e["objects"]), num(e["position_error_m"]), num(e.get("position_error_m_by_id")),
num(e["room_center_position_error_m"]), num(e["box_equivalent_log_size_error"]),
num(e["box_equivalent_yaw_error_rad"]), num(e.get("uniform_yaw_baseline_error_rad", r["uniform_yaw_baseline_error_rad"]))])
f, g = r["checks"]["fastfill"], r["checks"]["ground_truth"]
coll = lambda x: x["by_code"].get("collision", {}).get("violation", 0)
check_rows.append([esc(r["scene_key"]), str(r["objects"]), "通过" if f["ok"] else "未通过", str(f["counts"]["violation"]), str(coll(f)),
"通过" if g["ok"] else "未通过", str(g["counts"]["violation"]), str(coll(g)), str(r.get("ground_truth_tilted_objects", "—"))])
out.append(f"<h3>{esc(label)} <span class='muted'>({esc(directory)};{esc(', '.join(sorted(versions)))})</span></h3>"
+ table(["房间", "真值位置", "物体", "位置误差 (m)", "位置误差·按 ID (m)", "房间中心基线 (m)", "log 尺寸(盒等价)",
"朝向(盒等价, rad)", "均匀随机朝向基线 (rad)"], rows)
+ table(["房间", "物体", "FastFill 校验", "违例", "碰撞对", "真值校验", "真值违例", "真值碰撞对", "真值倾斜物体"], check_rows))
return "".join(out)
def sample_name(path, s):
return f"消融样本({Path(path).parent.name},抽自 {Path(s['new']).parent.name}/{Path(s['new']).name})"
def section_ablation(ablations, sample, s, cohorts):
out = []
if s and cohorts:
out.append(cohort_flags(sample_name(sample, s), set(s["scene_ids"]), cohorts))
keys = ("cell_ce", "p_gt", "argmax_hit", "xy_err_m", "size_err", "yaw_err_rad")
for label, a, path in ablations:
summary, diffs, prior = a["summary_mean_ci95_count"], a["diff_vs_a_mean_ci95"], a["model_a_minus_prior_cell_ce"]
best = max(prior.items(), key=lambda kv: kv[1][0]) # the prior closest to the model: the largest difference
rows = [["a 原始输入"] + [cell(summary["a"].get(k)) for k in keys]]
rows += [[ABLATION[v]] + [cell(summary[v].get(k)) for k in keys] for v in "bcde"]
drows = [[ABLATION[v[0]]] + [cell(diffs[v].get(k), 4) for k in keys] for v in diffs]
prior_a = summary["a"]
out.append(f"<h3>{esc(label)}</h3><p class='muted'>检查点 <code>{esc(a['checkpoint'])}</code>;{a['rows']} 个验证房间"
f"({prior_a['cell_ce'][3]} 个位置可评物体);改变的房间 b={a['changed_rooms']['b']} c={a['changed_rooms']['c']};"
f"判据交叉核对最大相对误差 {num(a['criterion_crosscheck_max_rel_err'], 2)};均匀分布交叉熵 {num(a['prior']['uniform_ce'])}。</p>"
+ table(["变体"] + [NAMES[k] for k in keys], rows)
+ "<p>变体减 a(95% CI,房间 bootstrap):</p>" + table(["变体"] + [NAMES[k] for k in keys], drows)
+ f"<p>模型格子交叉熵减输入无关先验(训练集频率,{a['prior']['train_rows']} 行):最接近模型的先验 <code>{esc(best[0])}</code>"
f" 差值 {cell(best[1], 4)};负值 = 模型优于该先验。{len(prior)} 种先验中差值的 CI 上界最大为 "
f"{num(max(v[2] for v in prior.values()), 4)}。</p>")
return "".join(out)
def section_llm(llm):
out = []
for c in llm["selection_cohort"]:
out.append(f"<div class='flag'><b>选择队列重叠:</b>这 {c['rows']} 行中有 {c['rows_in_cohort']} 行的场景出现在检查点选择队列"
f" <code>{esc(Path(c['file']).name)}</code>({c['cohort_rows']} 个场景)里:用该队列选出的 FastFill 检查点在这些行上不是留出评测,LLM 智能体不受影响。</div>")
cost = {c["method"]: c for c in llm["cost"]}
shown = {}
for m, c in cost.items():
loop = c.get("mode") and "harness" in c["mode"]
shown[m] = m + (f"(修复循环,{c['calls_per_room']:.2f} 次调用/房间)" if loop else "")
failures = []
for m, c in cost.items():
fr = c.get("failed_rooms")
if not fr:
continue
p = fr["p_all_in_largest_if_size_independent"]
sizes = "、".join(f"{x['objects']}(第 {x['rank']} 名)" for x in sorted(fr["rooms"], key=lambda x: x["rank"]))
failures.append(f"{esc(m)}:{len(fr['rooms'])} 个房间无布局——" + ";".join(f"{esc(CAUSES.get(k, k))} ×{n}" for k, n in c["failure_causes"].items())
+ f"。这些房间的物体数({fr['of_rows']} 行中按物体数从多到少的名次):{sizes};全部落在物体数最多的 {fr['largest_rooms_holding_all']} 个房间内,"
f"若失败与房间大小无关,{len(fr['rooms'])} 个失败全落在其中的概率为 {pval(p)}"
+ (":失败集中在最大的房间" + (",可能是与房间规模相关的中继超时(传输被截断,而非模型给出无效布局)" if "IncompleteRead" in c["failure_causes"] else "")
if p < .05 else "") + "。")
if failures:
out.append("<p><b>无布局的房间及原因</b>(LLM 取自 predictions.jsonl 的 error 字段;名次 1 = 物体最多,并列取同一名次):</p><ul>"
+ "".join(f"<li>{x}</li>" for x in failures) + "</ul>")
rows = []
for m, c in cost.items():
tokens = c.get("tokens")
rows.append([esc(m), esc(c.get("model") or "本地 Qwen3-8B + 几何头"), esc(MODES.get(c.get("mode"), "一次前向 + 解码")),
esc(c.get("reasoning_effort") or "—"), str(llm["layouts"][m]), num(c["calls_per_room"], 2), num(c.get("mean_latency_s"), 2),
num(c.get("p95_latency_s"), 2), num(c.get("mean_latency_s_layout_rooms"), 2) + f" <span class='ci'>({c.get('latency_rooms_layout', '—')} 房间)</span>",
"—" if not tokens else f"{tokens['total_tokens']:,}", "—" if not tokens else f"{c['tokens_per_room']:,.0f}"])
no_tokens = [m for m, c in cost.items() if c["kind"] == "llm" and not c.get("tokens")]
source = lambda c: ("本运行" if c["latency_source"] == "this run" else f"在线运行 <code>{esc(Path(c['latency_source']).name)}</code>") \
+ f"({esc(c.get('latency_grid_decode') or '—')} 解码)"
out.append("<h3>成本</h3>" + table(["方法", "模型", "模式", "推理强度", "有布局房间", "调用/房间", "平均延迟 (s)", "p95 延迟 (s)",
"平均延迟·仅有布局房间 (s)", "总 tokens", "tokens/房间"], rows)
+ "<p class='muted'>LLM 延迟取自 predictions.jsonl 的逐房间 latency_s(全部房间的均值即 summary.json 的 mean_latency_s):"
"每房间全部 API 调用的墙钟时间,含客户端限速等待、重试与退避(修复循环还含修复调用)。FastFill 延迟为在线评测记录的 fastfill_latency_ms"
"(一次 GPU 前向 + 解码):" + ";".join(f"{esc(m)} 取自{source(c)}" for m, c in cost.items() if c["kind"] == "fastfill")
+ "。“仅有布局房间”只平均给出布局的房间。" + (f"summary 未记录 token 用量的方法:{esc('、'.join(no_tokens))}。" if no_tokens else "") + "</p>")
meta = llm["meta"]["methods"]
sha = lambda x: f"<code>{esc((x or '—')[:12])}</code>"
out.append("<details><summary>复现检查与代码哈希(llm_compare 拒绝数据或 FastFill 解码/评分代码不同的方法)</summary>"
+ table(["方法", "评测目录", "检查点", "解码", "来源", "数据 sha256", "前向代码", "解码/评分代码", "逐位复现 report.json"],
[[esc(m), f"<code>{esc(Path(x['eval_dir']).name)}</code>", f"<code>{esc(short_ckpt(x.get('checkpoint')))}</code>",
esc(x.get("grid_decode") or "—"), esc(x.get("baseline") or "—"), sha(x.get("data_sha256")),
sha(x.get("forward_implementation_sha256")), sha(x.get("implementation_sha256")),
'<span class="good">是</span>' if llm["checks"][m] else '<span class="bad">否</span>'] for m, x in meta.items()])
+ "</details>")
views = (("common", f"口径一·共同房间:只看每种方法都给出布局的房间({llm['rows'] - llm['common_rooms']} 个房间因任一方法无布局而对所有方法排除)"),
("failures_as_failures", "口径二·失败计入:全部房间,无布局的房间按下方退化规则计分"))
for name, title in views:
sc = llm["scenarios"][name]
metrics = list(next(iter(sc["methods"].values())))
out.append(f"<h3>{esc(title)}:{sc['rooms']} 个房间</h3>"
+ table(["方法"] + [NAMES[m] for m in metrics], [[esc(shown[k])] + [cell(v.get(m)) for m in metrics] for k, v in sc["methods"].items()]))
rows = []
for pair, stats in sc["pairs"].items():
for metric, v in stats.items():
lo, hi = v["room_mean_diff_ci95"]
robust = VERDICT[v["verdict"]["sign_test"]][0].replace("A", "LLM")
rows.append([esc(pair), NAMES[metric], f"{num(v['room_mean_diff'], 4)} <span class='ci'>[{num(lo, 4)}, {num(hi, 4)}]</span>",
verdict_cell(v, "LLM"), f"{v['sign_test']['a_greater']}/{v['sign_test']['b_greater']}", pval(v["sign_test"]["p_holm"]),
robust if v["verdict"]["agree"] else f"<span class='bad'>⚠ 不一致:{robust}</span>"])
out.append("<details><summary>配对比较(差值 = LLM − FastFill;主判据 = 房间均值差的配对 bootstrap CI;Holm 校正在每一对内的指标间)</summary>"
+ table(["配对", "指标", "房间均值差 [95% CI]", "结论(主判据)", "符号检验 LLM>/<", "p (Holm)", "稳健性:符号检验"], rows) + "</details>")
out.append(f"<p class='muted'>退化规则(口径二):{esc(llm['meta']['fallback'])}。</p>")
return "".join(out)
def section_arms(inp):
"""The two autopilot arms, which one is final and why, and where data and models come from (isambard_inputs.py)."""
out = ("<div class='flag'><b>演练(DRYRUN):</b>未下载;基线、数据与队列文件的固定 sha256 只记录未强制"
f"({len(inp['pins']['mismatches'])} 处不符),本报告的数字不说明任何真实模型。</div>" if inp["dry_run"] else "")
rows = [["<b>最终</b>" if x["role"] == "final" else "对照", f"<code>{esc(x['dir'])}</code>", f"<code>{esc(x['run'])}</code>",
num(x["yaw_cls"], 2), str(x["max_objects"]), str(x["global_batch"]), f"{x['steps']}({num(x['epochs_supervised'])} 轮)",
esc(x["phase"]), esc(";".join(x["failures"]) or "无"), f"<code>{esc(short_ckpt(x['best_checkpoint']))}</code>",
f"{x['best_step']}({num(x['best_epochs'])} 轮)", num(x["best_score"], 4), f"<code>{esc(x['select2_cohort_sha256'][:12])}</code>",
f"<code>{esc(x['select2_implementation_sha256'][:12])}</code>", esc(x.get("uploaded_model") or "—")]
for x in inp["arms"]]
ranking = "".join(f"<li>{'最终' if x['role'] == 'final' else '对照'}:" + ";".join(f"<code>{esc(short_ckpt(c))}</code> {num(s, 4)}"
for c, s in x["select2_ranking"]) + "</li>" for x in inp["arms"])
return (out + "<h3>1.1 两臂与最终臂的选择</h3>"
+ table(["角色", "autopilot 目录", "运行", "yaw_cls", "max_objects", "全局批量", "整个运行的步数(配置;按有效样本的轮数)", "阶段",
"失败项", "select2 最优检查点", "该检查点的步数(轮数)", "select2 分数 ↓", "select2 队列 sha256",
"select2 评测代码 sha256", "上传"], rows)
+ f"<p><b>规则:</b>{esc(inp['rule'])}</p><details><summary>两臂的 select2 排名(分数越低越好)</summary><ul>{ranking}</ul></details>"
+ "<h3>1.2 数据与模型来源</h3>" + table(["项目", "来源与校验"], [[esc(k), esc(v)] for k, v in inp["provenance"]]))
def missing_llm(inp):
missing = (inp or {}).get("llm", {}).get("missing") or []
return "、".join(f"{m}({MODES.get(m, m)})" for m in missing)
def walltime_table(path):
rows = [line.rstrip("\n").split("\t") for line in Path(path).read_text().splitlines() if line.strip()]
return table(["步骤", "卡", "开始 (UTC)", "结束 (UTC)", "墙钟 (min)", "退出码"],
[[esc(r[0]), esc(r[5] if len(r) > 5 else "—"), esc(r[1]), esc(r[2]), num(int(r[3]) / 60, 1), esc(r[4])] for r in rows])
def main(argv=None):
p = argparse.ArgumentParser(description=__doc__, formatter_class=argparse.RawDescriptionHelpFormatter)
p.add_argument("--out", required=True, type=Path)
p.add_argument("--title", default="FastFill v2 评测报告")
p.add_argument("--summary", action="append", default=[], metavar="[LABEL=]SUMMARY.md")
p.add_argument("--inputs", type=Path, help="isambard_inputs.py inputs.json: arms, final-arm rule, provenance")
for split in ("val", "test"):
for kind in ("run", "compare", "control", "decode"):
p.add_argument(f"--{split}-{kind}", action="append", default=[], metavar="LABEL=JSON")
p.add_argument("--llm")
p.add_argument("--ablation", action="append", default=[])
p.add_argument("--ablation-sample", type=Path, help="sample_validation.py sample.json of the ablation rows")
p.add_argument("--selection-cohort", action="append", default=[], metavar="LABEL=ROWS_JSONL")
p.add_argument("--reference", action="append", default=[])
p.add_argument("--walltime", type=Path)
p.add_argument("--notes", type=Path)
a = p.parse_args(argv)
val_runs, test_runs = [load(x) for x in a.val_run], [load(x) for x in a.test_run]
val_compare, val_decode = [load(x) for x in a.val_compare], [load(x) for x in a.val_decode]
test_compare, test_decode = [load(x) for x in a.test_compare], [load(x) for x in a.test_decode]
val_control, test_control = [load(x) for x in a.val_control], [load(x) for x in a.test_control]
inp = json.loads(a.inputs.read_text()) if a.inputs else None
ablations, refs = [load(x) for x in a.ablation], [tuple(x.rsplit("=", 1)) for x in a.reference]
cohorts = [tuple(x.rsplit("=", 1)) for x in a.selection_cohort]
llm = json.loads(Path(a.llm).read_text()) if a.llm else None
runs = [("验证集", l, s) for l, s, _ in val_runs] + [("测试集", l, s) for l, s, _ in test_runs]
sample = json.loads(a.ablation_sample.read_text()) if a.ablation_sample else None
val_ph, test_ph = [c for _, c, _ in val_compare if placeholder(c)], [c for _, c, _ in test_compare if placeholder(c)]
parts = []
if val_ph or test_ph:
where = (["3.1 节比较表", "8.1 节决策表"] if val_ph else []) + (["第 4 节比较表"] if test_ph else [])
parts.append(f"<div class='flag'><b>占位:</b>{len(val_ph) + len(test_ph)} 个“最终 vs 基线”比较(验证集 {len(val_ph)},测试集 {len(test_ph)})"
f"的两侧是同一个检查点({'、'.join(where)}逐个标出),其中 {sum(map(same_output, val_ph + test_ph))} 个两侧还是同一个评测输出"
"(差值必为 0):这些差值不说明最终模型,只用于检验流程。</div>")
# 1 setup
rules = {split: Counter() for split in ("验证集", "测试集")}
for split, _, s in runs:
if not rules[split]:
rules[split].update({r: e["objects"] for r, e in s["strata"].get("rule", {}).items()})
fits = sorted({s["meta"]["baseline_fit"] for _, _, s in runs})
online = [f"{split}·{l}" for split, l, s in runs if not s["meta"].get("head_outputs")]
heads_note = (f"{len(runs) - len(online)}/{len(runs)} 个运行由保存的头输出在 CPU 上用同一份代码重解码(evaluate --from-head-outputs,spread 与 argmax 各一次)"
+ (f";其余为在线解码的报告:{esc('、'.join(online))}。" if online else "。"))
val_rows = sorted({s["meta"]["rows"] for _, s, _ in val_runs})
rows_name = lambda r: f"验证集行({Path(r).parent.name}/{Path(r).name})"
bias = "".join(f"<p>{x}</p>" for r in val_rows if (x := bias_note(rows_name(r), scene_ids(r), cohorts)))
boots = sorted({s["meta"]["boot"] for _, _, s in runs})
parts.append("<h2 id='s1'>1 设置与协议</h2>" + (section_arms(inp) + "<h3>1.3 各运行</h3>" if inp else "") + run_rows(runs) + f"""
<ul><li><b>两种解码:</b>argmax = 模型原始输出(每物体取最高分格子);spread = 防碰撞后处理解码(每个物体取留在房间内、不与已放物体重叠的最可能格子,并服从支撑声明)。两者用同一次前向的头输出,只差解码;第 3、5、8 节的 spread / argmax 均指此义。</li>
<li><b>决策只读验证集:</b>“是否以最终替代基线”和“默认解码 spread / argmax”两项决策只读第 3 节的验证集配对比较;第 4–7 节(测试集、LLM、消融、RoomGenBench)仅报告,不参与任何决策。</li>
<li><b>相同解码代码:</b>{heads_note}compare.py 拒绝解码/评分代码(implementation_sha256)、来源或前向代码不同的两侧;上表“前向代码”“解码/评分代码”两列即这两个哈希。</li>
<li><b>显著性:</b>主判据为逐房间差值均值的配对房间 bootstrap 95% CI(不含 0 即显著,方向取其符号),<b>按指标逐个判断,未做多重比较校正</b>;
稳健性列为逐房间差值的精确双侧符号检验(同一比较内跨指标 Holm 校正)。两者不一致时显式标出:不一致可能来自多重比较(主判据未校正、符号检验已校正),
也可能来自偏态分布(符号检验只看差值的方向/中位数,主判据看的是均值)。合并(物体加权)差值只作描述。</li>
<li><b>最终 vs 基线的主比较</b>只在两模型都能回答的房间上(物体数 ≤ 128,基线的 max_objects),配对指标只用两者都给出布局的房间;仅一方有布局的房间数在每张表上方列出。最终模型在全部房间(含 > 128 物体)上的结果单列于 3.{4 if val_control else 3}。</li>
<li>误差定义与 <code>evaluate.reference_metrics</code> 相同(合法对应匹配、盒等价尺寸/朝向);逐物体数值由 stratify.py 用评测自身的函数重算,并逐请求、逐位核对 outcomes 与 report.json(上表“逐位复现”)。
平凡基线拟合来源:{esc('、'.join(fits))}。分层置信区间:房间为单位的百分位 bootstrap({esc('/'.join(map(str, boots)))} 次)。</li>
<li>归属:误差与基线归于标签物体(匹配目标),校验器标记归于检查点名的预测物体;声明位置取完整行的支撑声明(三字段投影不向模型显示);
选择规则取 <code>provenance.field_evidence[i].selection_rule</code>(缺失记为 frozen_prep)。各集合的规则分布(物体数):"""
+ ";".join(f"{split}:" + "、".join(f"{esc(r)} {n}" for r, n in c.items()) for split, c in rules.items() if c) + """。</li>
<li>校验器:<code>validation.validate_scene</code>(当前代码),模型布局与标签各跑一次;“洁净房间”= 无硬约束违例(unknown 不计违例)。</li></ul>""")
if cohorts and val_rows:
parts.append("".join(cohort_flags(rows_name(r), scene_ids(r), cohorts) for r in val_rows)
+ (f"<div class='flag'><b>选择偏差:</b>{bias}</div>" if bias else ""))
for label, _, path in (x.rpartition("=") for x in a.summary):
if Path(path).is_file():
parts.append(f"<details><summary>autopilot SUMMARY.md(原文{':' + esc(label) if label else ''})</summary>"
+ markdown(Path(path).read_text()) + "</details>")
if a.walltime and a.walltime.is_file():
parts.append("<details><summary>GPU / CPU 步骤墙钟时间(run_plan 记录)</summary>" + walltime_table(a.walltime) + "</details>")
# 2 interface vs geometry
metrics = ("interface_pass_rate", "strict_ok_rate", "room_clean_rate", "clean_room_rate_incl_failures", "gt_room_clean_rate",
"object_collision_rate", "gt_object_collision_rate", "room_collision_rate")
parts.append("<h2 id='s2'>2 接口通过率 vs 几何通过率</h2><p>接口通过 = 返回了每个请求 ID 恰好一次、尺寸为正的布局;几何通过分两级:"
"严格(所有硬检查 pass,unknown 也算不通过)与洁净(无硬违例)。真值列是同一校验器对标签本身的结果:是同一校验器下的参照,"
"不是上限(模型可能比标签更洁净)。</p>"
+ table(["集合", "运行"] + [NAMES[m] for m in metrics], [[split, esc(l)] + [cell(overall(s, m)) for m in metrics] for split, l, s in runs]))
# 3 validation: the decisions' basis
sec = f"<h2 id='s3'>3 验证集 {DECISION}</h2>"
if not (val_compare or val_decode):
sec += "<p class='muted'>(未提供验证集比较:本报告不作决策)</p>"
sec += "<h3>3.1 最终 vs 基线(两模型都能回答的房间)</h3>" + ("".join(f"<h3>{esc(l)}</h3>" + compare_table(c, True) for l, c, _ in val_compare) or "<p class='muted'>(未提供)</p>")
sec += "<h3>3.2 默认解码:spread vs argmax</h3>" + ("".join(f"<h3>{esc(l)}</h3>" + compare_table(c) for l, c, _ in val_decode) or "<p class='muted'>(未提供)</p>")
if val_control:
sec += ("<h3>3.3 最终 vs 对照(同一数据与配置,只差 yaw_cls;选择最终臂的配对证据)</h3>"
+ "".join(f"<h3>{esc(l)}</h3>" + compare_table(c) for l, c, _ in val_control))
if val_runs:
sec += (f"<h3>3.{4 if val_control else 3} 各运行在全部房间上的结果(含 > 128 物体房间;房间集合不同,非配对,仅描述)</h3>" + full_set_table([(l, s) for l, s, _ in val_runs])
+ results_table([(l, s) for l, s, _ in val_runs])
+ "".join(f"<details><summary>分层结果({esc(l)})</summary>" + strata_tables(s, STRATA_METRICS) + "</details>" for l, s, _ in val_runs))
parts.append(sec)
# 4 test: report only
sec = f"<h2 id='s4'>4 测试集结果 {REPORT_ONLY}</h2><p class='muted'>平凡基线在同一批有布局的房间、同一批物体上计算。argmax = 模型原始输出;spread = 防碰撞后处理解码。</p>"
if test_runs:
sec += (full_set_table([(l, s) for l, s, _ in test_runs]) + results_table([(l, s) for l, s, _ in test_runs])
+ "".join(f"<details><summary>分层结果({esc(l)})</summary>" + strata_tables(s, STRATA_METRICS) + "</details>" for l, s, _ in test_runs))
sec += "".join(f"<h3>{esc(l)}</h3>" + compare_table(c, True) for l, c, _ in test_compare)
sec += "".join(f"<h3>{esc(l)}</h3>" + compare_table(c) for l, c, _ in test_control)
sec += "".join(f"<h3>{esc(l)}</h3>" + compare_table(c) for l, c, _ in test_decode)
parts.append(sec if test_runs or test_compare or test_control or test_decode else sec + "<p class='muted'>(未提供)</p>")
# 5 LLM, 6 ablation, 7 RoomGenBench: report only
n_llm = sum(c["kind"] == "llm" for c in llm["cost"]) if llm else 0
missing = ("<div class='flag'><b>缺失的 LLM 模式:</b>" + esc(missing_llm(inp)) + ":其答案在无法访问的旧服务器上,本节不含它们。"
"其余 LLM 答案是已有的预测,由当前评测器重新评分,未调用任何 API。</div>" if missing_llm(inp) else "")
parts.append(f"<h2 id='s5'>5 FastFill vs {n_llm} 种 LLM 智能体(冻结的 LLM 行){REPORT_ONLY}</h2>" + missing
+ (section_llm(llm) if llm else "<p class='muted'>(未提供)</p>"))
parts.append(f"<h2 id='s6'>6 模型是否使用输入:消融 + 输入无关先验 {REPORT_ONLY}</h2><p>同一批验证房间(三字段投影)上改动一个输入、其余不变,看格子分布与误差是否随之变化;"
"再与只看类别(及房间类型)的训练集频率先验比较格子交叉熵。</p>"
+ (section_ablation(ablations, a.ablation_sample, sample, cohorts) or "<p class='muted'>(未提供)</p>"))
parts.append(f"<h2 id='s7'>7 RoomGenBench 五个房间 vs 真值 {REPORT_ONLY}</h2><p class='muted'>五个房间、单次预测:没有统计功效,只看量级与失败模式;"
"同一校验器也跑在真值上作为参照。</p>" + (section_reference(refs) or "<p class='muted'>(未提供)</p>"))
# 8 limitations and decisions
lim, seen = [], set()
for split, label, s in runs:
c, key = s["checks"], (s["meta"]["eval_dir"], s["meta"]["outcomes"])
if key in seen:
continue
seen.add(key)
if not c["reproduces_report_exactly"]:
lim.append(f"{split}·{esc(label)}:逐物体重算未逐位复现 report.json,该运行的数字不可直接与报告对照。")
if c["rooms_validation_differs_from_stored"]:
lim.append(f"{split}·{esc(label)}:{c['rooms_validation_differs_from_stored']} 个房间的当前校验器结果与评测时存储的不同(校验器代码已变);本报告用当前校验器。")
if c["requests"] - c["requests_with_layout"]:
lim.append(f"{split}·{esc(label)}:{c['requests'] - c['requests_with_layout']} 个请求没有布局(其中 {c['over_capacity_requests']} 个超出模型容量 "
"max_objects),误差只在有布局的房间上计算;接口通过率中计为失败。")
if any(s["meta"]["projection"] == "minimal" for _, _, s in runs):
lim.append("三字段投影不向模型显示支撑声明;“声明位置”分层用的是完整行的声明,作为真值位置标签。")
if missing_llm(inp):
lim.append(f"第 5 节缺少 LLM 模式 {esc(missing_llm(inp))}(答案不可得):LLM 对比只含已有答案的模式。")
if llm:
lim += [f"LLM 行与检查点选择队列 {esc(Path(c['file']).name)} 重叠 {c['rows_in_cohort']}/{c['rows']}:用该队列选出的 FastFill 检查点在这些行上不是留出评测。"
for c in llm["selection_cohort"] if c["rows_in_cohort"]]
lim += [f"第 5 节 {esc(m)}:逐物体重算未逐位复现 report.json,该方法的数字不可直接与其报告对照。" for m, ok in llm["checks"].items() if not ok]
lim += [f"第 5 节 {esc(c['method'])}:predictions.jsonl 逐房间延迟的均值 {num(c['mean_latency_s'], 4)} s 与 summary.json 的 mean_latency_s "
f"{num(c['summary_mean_latency_s'], 4)} s 不一致。" for c in llm["cost"]
if c["kind"] == "llm" and abs(c["mean_latency_s"] - c["summary_mean_latency_s"]) > 1e-6]
if ablations and sample and (hits := overlaps(set(sample["scene_ids"]), cohorts)):
lim.append(f"{esc(sample_name(a.ablation_sample, sample))}与检查点选择队列重叠:"
+ "、".join(f"「{esc(l)}」{k}/{len(sample['scene_ids'])}" for l, _, k in hits) + ":这些场景对相应检查点不是留出数据。")
family_rows = []
for split, label, s in runs:
fam = s["strata"].get("family", {})
worse = [f for f, e in fam.items() if (e["metrics"].get("bottom_center_error_m") or {}).get("mean") is not None
and e["metrics"]["bottom_center_error_m"]["mean"] > (e["metrics"].get("baseline:room_center_position") or {}).get("mean", math.inf)]
family_rows.append([split, esc(label), f"{len(worse)}/{len(fam)}", esc("、".join(worse)) or "—"])
parts.append("<h2 id='s8'>8 已知局限与决策清单</h2><h3>已知局限</h3><ul>" + "".join(f"<li>{x}</li>" for x in lim) + "</ul>"
+ "<p>位置误差(点估计)高于房间中心平凡基线的来源族:</p>" + table(["集合", "运行", "来源族数", "这些来源族"], family_rows)
+ f"<h3>决策 {DECISION}</h3><p>以下两项只读第 3 节验证集比较(主判据 = 房间均值差的配对 bootstrap 95% CI 不含 0,按指标逐个判断,"
"未做多重比较校正;稳健性 = Holm 校正的符号检验,只看差值方向/中位数而非均值,与主判据不一致可能来自多重比较或偏态分布)。"
"测试集与其它各节不进入此处。</p>" + (f"<div class='flag'><b>选择偏差:</b>{bias}</div>" if bias else "")
+ "<h3>8.1 是否以最终替代基线(判据:旧对象 frozen_prep 不应显著变差;新对象应显著变好)</h3>"
+ (decision_table(val_compare, True) if val_compare else "<p class='muted'>(未提供验证集比较:不作决策)</p>")
+ "<h3>8.2 默认解码 spread 还是 argmax(spread 以碰撞率换取可能的位置/朝向代价)</h3>"
+ (decision_table(val_decode, False) if val_decode else "<p class='muted'>(未提供验证集比较:不作决策)</p>")
+ ("<h3>8.3 最终臂 vs 对照臂(最终臂按 select2 分数选出;此处为验证集配对证据)</h3>"
+ (f"<p>{esc(inp['rule'])}</p>" if inp else "") + decision_table(val_control, False) if val_control else "")
+ (f"<h3>附注</h3>" + markdown(a.notes.read_text()) if a.notes and a.notes.is_file() else ""))
nav = "".join(f"<a href='#s{i}'>{i}</a>" for i in range(1, 9))
page = (f"<!doctype html><html lang='zh-CN'><head><meta charset='utf-8'><meta name='viewport' content='width=device-width,initial-scale=1'>"
f"<title>{esc(a.title)}</title><style>{CSS}</style></head><body><main><h1>{esc(a.title)}</h1>"
f"<nav>{nav}</nav>" + "\n".join(parts) + "</main></body></html>")
a.out.parent.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True)
a.out.write_text(page)
print(a.out, len(page))
if __name__ == "__main__":
main()
|