a-plan-is-not-a-path / code /score_cliff_pilot.py
0721alex's picture
Add cliff development and confirmation research materials
2399743 verified
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
8.93 kB
"""Score explicit claims and fixed-balance replays remotely using the old executor."""
from __future__ import annotations
import argparse
import json
from collections import Counter
from pathlib import Path
from run_evaluate import execute, oracle, parse_response, read_jsonl, score_response, structural_check, write_jsonl
def main():
parser = argparse.ArgumentParser()
parser.add_argument("--series", default="cliff_dev_r1")
args = parser.parse_args()
data = Path("data") / args.series
destination = Path("results") / args.series
profiles = {row["id"]: row for row in read_jsonl(data / "profiles.jsonl")}
references = {key: oracle(profile) for key, profile in profiles.items()}
design = json.loads((data / "design.json").read_text(encoding="utf-8"))
buffers = {row["profile_id"]: row["buffers"] for row in design["profile_specific_buffers"]}
raw = read_jsonl(Path("results") / f"{args.series}_4b_native.jsonl")
scores = []
for row in raw:
profile = profiles[row["profile_id"]]
score = score_response(profile, row, references[row["profile_id"]])
plan, parse_error = parse_response(row.get("response"))
claim = plan.get("feasibility_claim") if plan is not None else None
claim_is_bool = isinstance(claim, bool)
finished = row.get("finish_reason") == "stop"
evaluable = finished and parse_error is None and claim_is_bool
score.update({"feasibility_claim": claim if claim_is_bool else None,
"claim_raw_value": claim, "claim_true": claim is True,
"claim_missing": plan is None or "feasibility_claim" not in plan,
"claim_invalid_type": plan is not None and "feasibility_claim" in plan and not claim_is_bool,
"claim_vs_reason_conflict": None,
"claim_vs_reason_conflict_status": "pending qualitative reading, never inferred from risk words",
"finish_reason": row.get("finish_reason"), "output_tokens": row.get("output_tokens"),
"length_limited": row.get("finish_reason") == "length", "claim_evaluable": evaluable,
"false_assurance_cash_only": evaluable and claim is True and score["structurally_valid"] and not score["full_schedule_feasible"],
"physical_false_assurance_cash_only": evaluable and claim is True and not score["oracle_feasible"] and score["structurally_valid"] and not score["full_schedule_feasible"],
"avoidable_false_assurance_cash_only": evaluable and claim is True and score["oracle_feasible"] and score["structurally_valid"] and not score["full_schedule_feasible"],
"false_assurance_structural": evaluable and claim is True and not score["structurally_valid"],
"reference_feasible_no_successful_plan_claimed": evaluable and claim is False and score["oracle_feasible"],
"own_plan_false_negative": evaluable and claim is False and score["full_schedule_feasible"],
"explicit_instance_infeasibility_claim": None,
"false_instance_infeasibility_claim": None,
"physical_infeasible": not score["oracle_feasible"],
"presentation": row.get("presentation"), "buffer_roles": row.get("buffer_roles"),
"counterfactual_replays": []})
if score["structurally_valid"]:
actions, _ = structural_check(profile, plan)
score["counterfactual_replays"] = [
{"B": buffer, "oracle_feasible": buffer >= references[row["profile_id"]]["minimum_initial_cash"],
**execute(profile, actions, buffer)} for buffer in buffers[row["profile_id"]]]
if profile.get("funding_totals"):
families = {"GA": "GA", "TR_r": "TR", "TR_a": "TR", "AR": "AR", "DE_r": "DE", "DE_a": "DE"}
stages = {"funding_agreement": "GA", "travel_receipt_settlement": "TR",
"arrival_confirmation": "AR", "final_funding_settlement": "DE"}
funding_errors, error_families = [], set()
for error in score["structural_errors"]:
tokens = error.split(":")
matched = {families[token] for token in tokens if token in families}
matched.update(stages[token] for token in tokens if token in stages)
if matched:
funding_errors.append(error)
error_families.update(matched)
score["funding_condition_errors"] = funding_errors
score["funding_condition_error_families"] = sorted(error_families)
selected = {item.get("id") for item in (plan or {}).get("actions", [])
if isinstance(item, dict) and isinstance(item.get("id"), str)}
required_ids = {"GA", "AR"}
if "G_reimburse" in selected and "G_advance" not in selected:
required_ids.update(("TR_r", "DE_r"))
elif "G_advance" in selected and "G_reimburse" not in selected:
required_ids.update(("TR_a", "DE_a"))
score["submitted_funding_condition_ids"] = sorted(selected.intersection(families))
score["missing_funding_condition_ids"] = sorted(required_ids - selected)
score["missing_funding_condition_groups"] = [
{"stage": group["stage"], "alternative_ids": group["ids"]}
for group in profile["required_groups"] if group["stage"] in stages
and not selected.intersection(group["ids"])]
score["missing_funding_prerequisite_ids"] = sorted({
error.split(":")[-1] for error in funding_errors if error.startswith("dependency_missing:")})
score["funding_condition_classification_note"] = (
"Literal schedule/dependency errors involving GA/TR/AR/DE; qualitative reading distinguishes omitted thought from unlisted code")
scores.append(score)
write_jsonl(destination / "scores_4b_native.jsonl", scores)
keys = ("claim_evaluable", "claim_true", "claim_missing", "claim_invalid_type", "length_limited",
"physical_infeasible", "structurally_valid", "full_schedule_feasible", "false_assurance_cash_only",
"physical_false_assurance_cash_only", "avoidable_false_assurance_cash_only", "false_assurance_structural",
"reference_feasible_no_successful_plan_claimed", "own_plan_false_negative")
summary = {"observed_n": len(scores), "expected_n": design["request_count"],
"counts": {key: sum(bool(row[key]) for row in scores) for key in keys},
"parse_failure_n": sum(row["parse_error"] is not None for row in scores),
"failure_counts": dict(Counter((row.get("failure") or {}).get("kind", "success") for row in scores)),
"claim_vs_reason_conflict": "pending full raw qualitative review",
"cash_definition": "length/format/claim-interface failures excluded; cash-only requires noncash-valid full plan; avoidable additionally requires B>=physical R*",
"location": "Molab RTX PRO 6000", "profile_specific_buffers": design["profile_specific_buffers"]}
if any(profile.get("funding_totals") for profile in profiles.values()):
summary["claim_true_funding_condition_family_error_counts"] = {
family: sum(row["claim_evaluable"] and row["claim_true"] and
family in row.get("funding_condition_error_families", []) for row in scores)
for family in ("GA", "TR", "AR", "DE")}
summary["funding_condition_error_definition"] = (
"Preserved structural errors categorized by named free funding condition; not parser/engineering labels or cash-only failures")
summary["claim_true_missing_funding_condition_id_counts"] = {
key: sum(row["claim_evaluable"] and row["claim_true"] and
key in row.get("missing_funding_condition_ids", []) for row in scores)
for key in ("GA", "TR_r", "TR_a", "AR", "DE_r", "DE_a")}
(destination / "summary.json").write_text(json.dumps(summary, ensure_ascii=False, indent=2), encoding="utf-8")
print(json.dumps(summary, ensure_ascii=False), flush=True)
for score in scores:
print(json.dumps({key: score.get(key) for key in ("id", "B", "oracle_min_cash", "feasibility_claim",
"structurally_valid", "full_schedule_feasible", "model_min_cash", "startup_cash_excess",
"false_assurance_cash_only", "avoidable_false_assurance_cash_only", "false_assurance_structural",
"reference_feasible_no_successful_plan_claimed", "own_plan_false_negative", "parse_error", "structural_errors",
"failure", "counterfactual_replays")}, ensure_ascii=False), flush=True)
if __name__ == "__main__":
main()