linxinhua commited on
Commit
998b1c5
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): 765d5e8

Upload v5-HOT/explanatory/test/20260608_140224_51241.json with huggingface_hub

Browse files
v5-HOT/explanatory/test/20260608_140224_51241.json CHANGED
@@ -7,7 +7,7 @@
7
  "walkthrough_started_at": null,
8
  "argument_submitted_at": null,
9
  "started_at": "2026-06-08T14:02:24.203759+10:00",
10
- "ended_at": "2026-06-08T14:04:22.468275+10:00",
11
  "model": "gpt-5.4-nano-2026-03-17",
12
  "case_id": "ai-predictive-analytics",
13
  "perfect_answer": {
@@ -38,6 +38,15 @@
38
  "reason": "exception 2 (substantive engagement): participant questioned the assumption that the university always reaches out when flagged, which affects what right-duty violation their principle depends on",
39
  "user_msg_excerpt": "Hmm I see what you mean. I guess I was assuming the school always reaches out when flagged. But maybe it doesn't have to.",
40
  "latency_ms": 3134
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
41
  }
42
  ],
43
  "turns": [
@@ -94,6 +103,33 @@
94
  "main_ms": 5224,
95
  "total_ms": 8367
96
  }
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
97
  }
98
  ],
99
  "feedback": [],
@@ -141,13 +177,13 @@
141
  },
142
  "upload_errors": [],
143
  "session_summary": {
144
- "n_turns": 2,
145
- "n_manager_verdicts": 2,
146
  "n_transitions": 0,
147
  "n_plan_completes": 0,
148
  "subprobe_coverage": {
149
  "2": {
150
- "engaging_default": 1,
151
  "other": 1
152
  }
153
  },
 
7
  "walkthrough_started_at": null,
8
  "argument_submitted_at": null,
9
  "started_at": "2026-06-08T14:02:24.203759+10:00",
10
+ "ended_at": "2026-06-08T14:04:27.332361+10:00",
11
  "model": "gpt-5.4-nano-2026-03-17",
12
  "case_id": "ai-predictive-analytics",
13
  "perfect_answer": {
 
38
  "reason": "exception 2 (substantive engagement): participant questioned the assumption that the university always reaches out when flagged, which affects what right-duty violation their principle depends on",
39
  "user_msg_excerpt": "Hmm I see what you mean. I guess I was assuming the school always reaches out when flagged. But maybe it doesn't have to.",
40
  "latency_ms": 3134
41
+ },
42
+ {
43
+ "live_subprobe_id": 2,
44
+ "advanced_this_turn": false,
45
+ "turn_type": "engaging-default",
46
+ "directive": "T1:\n direction: distinguish which specific decision requires explicit opt-in consent (scoring, label assignment, or outreach), and then ask what counts as “realistic” consent in practice without sliding into implied consent or broad blanket notice\nT2:\n direction: consider whether a consent-respecting duty could be met by redesigning the system so that no high-risk categorisation happens before opt-in is obtained",
47
+ "reason": "exception 2 (substantive engagement): participant challenges the consent principle by asking whether opt-in is actually realistic for a university",
48
+ "user_msg_excerpt": "OK so what about the consent piece — is it actually realistic for a university to get every student's opt-in for something like this?",
49
+ "latency_ms": 2261
50
  }
51
  ],
52
  "turns": [
 
103
  "main_ms": 5224,
104
  "total_ms": 8367
105
  }
106
+ },
107
+ {
108
+ "n": 3,
109
+ "timestamp": "2026-06-08T14:04:27.332317+10:00",
110
+ "user_message": "OK so what about the consent piece — is it actually realistic for a university to get every student's opt-in for something like this?",
111
+ "manager_verdict": {
112
+ "live_subprobe_id": 2,
113
+ "advanced_this_turn": false,
114
+ "turn_type": "engaging-default",
115
+ "directive": "T1:\n direction: distinguish which specific decision requires explicit opt-in consent (scoring, label assignment, or outreach), and then ask what counts as “realistic” consent in practice without sliding into implied consent or broad blanket notice\nT2:\n direction: consider whether a consent-respecting duty could be met by redesigning the system so that no high-risk categorisation happens before opt-in is obtained",
116
+ "reason": "exception 2 (substantive engagement): participant challenges the consent principle by asking whether opt-in is actually realistic for a university",
117
+ "user_msg_excerpt": "OK so what about the consent piece — is it actually realistic for a university to get every student's opt-in for something like this?",
118
+ "latency_ms": 2261
119
+ },
120
+ "plan_control": "=== PLAN CONTROL (host-managed, authoritative) ===\nturn_type: engaging-default\nlive_subprobe_id: 2\nadvanced_this_turn: False\n\nLIVE SUB-PROBE (work this one this turn):\nid: 2\ncomponent: principles_at_stake\ngap: The argument should name the specific rights and duties it relies on, not only the harm, so the core moral rule is clear.\nrationale: A skeptical reader might agree there are harms but ask which right the university is violating. If the principles are not explicit, the conclusion can feel like a reaction rather than a rule-based judgment. The draft gestures at consent and a right not to be assigned “high risk,” but it does not fully spell out the set of principles that carry the decision.\nanchor: \"ethics turn on whether students consented to be scored\"\n\nDIRECTIVE for this turn:\nT1:\n direction: distinguish which specific decision requires explicit opt-in consent (scoring, label assignment, or outreach), and then ask what counts as “realistic” consent in practice without sliding into implied consent or broad blanket notice\nT2:\n direction: consider whether a consent-respecting duty could be met by redesigning the system so that no high-risk categorisation happens before opt-in is obtained\n=== END PLAN CONTROL ===",
121
+ "assistant_response": "Another angle worth pulling on here is to be precise about which step actually needs explicit opt-in consent, like whether it is scoring, creating a “high risk” label, or using that label to trigger outreach. Then pressure-test what “realistic consent” means in practice, so it is not replaced by a vague blanket notice that students are unlikely to treat as a genuine choice.",
122
+ "scratch": {
123
+ "chosen_target": 2,
124
+ "response_summary": "I clarified which decision points need explicit opt-in consent and cautioned against treating notice as realistic consent.",
125
+ "t1_used": "yes"
126
+ },
127
+ "latency_s": {
128
+ "manager_ms": 2261,
129
+ "ttft_ms": 2590,
130
+ "main_ms": 2590,
131
+ "total_ms": 4863
132
+ }
133
  }
134
  ],
135
  "feedback": [],
 
177
  },
178
  "upload_errors": [],
179
  "session_summary": {
180
+ "n_turns": 3,
181
+ "n_manager_verdicts": 3,
182
  "n_transitions": 0,
183
  "n_plan_completes": 0,
184
  "subprobe_coverage": {
185
  "2": {
186
+ "engaging_default": 2,
187
  "other": 1
188
  }
189
  },