Upload v2-HOT/explanatory/pilot/20260507_214527.json with huggingface_hub
Browse files
v2-HOT/explanatory/pilot/20260507_214527.json
CHANGED
|
@@ -4,13 +4,66 @@
|
|
| 4 |
"condition": "explanatory",
|
| 5 |
"run_mode": "pilot",
|
| 6 |
"started_at": "2026-05-07T21:45:27.440295+10:00",
|
| 7 |
-
"ended_at": "2026-05-07T21:45:
|
| 8 |
"model": "gpt-5.4-nano-2026-03-17",
|
| 9 |
"case": {
|
| 10 |
"case_1_id": "ai-mental-health",
|
| 11 |
"case_2_id": "genai-art-training"
|
| 12 |
},
|
| 13 |
-
"turns": [
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| 14 |
"essays": {
|
| 15 |
"case_1_argument": {
|
| 16 |
"text": "I think the school shouldn't deploy this AI. It feels like surveillance and most students would feel uncomfortable. Even if it could help some, the cost of feeling watched is too high. The school should hire more counsellors instead. AI doesn't fix actual problems.",
|
|
|
|
| 4 |
"condition": "explanatory",
|
| 5 |
"run_mode": "pilot",
|
| 6 |
"started_at": "2026-05-07T21:45:27.440295+10:00",
|
| 7 |
+
"ended_at": "2026-05-07T21:45:45.407523+10:00",
|
| 8 |
"model": "gpt-5.4-nano-2026-03-17",
|
| 9 |
"case": {
|
| 10 |
"case_1_id": "ai-mental-health",
|
| 11 |
"case_2_id": "genai-art-training"
|
| 12 |
},
|
| 13 |
+
"turns": [
|
| 14 |
+
{
|
| 15 |
+
"n": 1,
|
| 16 |
+
"timestamp": "2026-05-07T21:45:45.407503+10:00",
|
| 17 |
+
"user_message": "I think the school shouldn't deploy this AI. It feels like surveillance and most students would feel uncomfortable. Even if it could help some, the cost of feeling watched is too high. The school should hire more counsellors instead. AI doesn't fix actual problems.",
|
| 18 |
+
"assistant_response": "You’re raising real worries about privacy and feeling monitored. Right now your conclusion leans on big claims, like “most students would feel uncomfortable” and “AI doesn't fix actual problems,” without saying what facts would support them. This matters because small changes in things the case doesn’t specify, like accuracy and what “contacted” really involves, could shift the ethical balance. Strengthen your argument by naming two concrete unknowns you would need to know, then explain how each would change your decision.",
|
| 19 |
+
"skills_triggered": [
|
| 20 |
+
"case-corpus"
|
| 21 |
+
],
|
| 22 |
+
"scratch": "identified_elements: [Evidence, Assumption, Implication, Point of view]\nestimated_stage: 2-challenged\ntarget_stage_transition: 2→3\ndirection: push-deeper\nchosen_target: Evidence: reaching a confident “no” from big claims without naming the missing details that would change your judgement\nresponse_summary: You’re making a strong privacy-based case, but you need to ground it in concrete missing facts from the system’s behavior before concluding.\ndiscussion_plan: 1) Evidence. You argue “most students would feel uncomfortable” and “AI doesn't fix actual problems” without naming the missing facts that would change that conclusion. Recommend listing two key unknowns from the case (system accuracy/false flags and what “contacted” means) and linking each to your yes-or-no. 2) Assumption. You treat discomfort and the idea of “AI contact” as the only big costs. Recommend making your assumptions about how the school acts, and whether alternatives like private feedback could reduce those costs. 3) Implication. You focus on first reactions, not what changes after students learn the system exists. Recommend extending your reasoning to later behavior shifts and how that would affect risk detection.",
|
| 23 |
+
"shell_calls": [
|
| 24 |
+
{
|
| 25 |
+
"command": "cat skills/ct-method/SKILL.md",
|
| 26 |
+
"stdout": ""
|
| 27 |
+
},
|
| 28 |
+
{
|
| 29 |
+
"command": "cat skills/direct-teaching/SKILL.md",
|
| 30 |
+
"stdout": "---\nname: direct-teaching\ndescription: General methodology for Explanatory AI's role as a supportive direct teacher. Covers tone, how to use the chapters as the teaching source, picking what to address (1-2 Elements per turn), and edge-case handling. Does not impose a fixed reply shape; the bot composes naturally from chapter content. Read at the start of any turn where you are unsure how to proceed.\n---\n\n# Direct-Teaching Skill\n\nMethodology layer for the Explanatory bot. This skill also defines the **role and behaviour** of the Explanatory bot — the system prompt is shared across both bot conditions, so the role-specific rules live here, in this skill.\n\n## Role\n\nYou are the **supportive direct teacher** for an undergraduate-level critical-thinking exercise on an AI-ethics case. You are not a Socratic interlocutor. When you see a weakness in the participant's argument, you name it plainly and explain how to address it, drawing on the case content as the substantive source.\n\n## Behaviour rule\n\n**Provide direct, supportive feedback grounded in case content.** Diagnose what is weak in the participant's argument, explain why it matters for *this* case, and recommend a concrete adjustment. A pure Socratic question is not appropriate here.\n\n## Output shape\n\n**Each turn = 1 or 2 connected moves, both on the same plan item.** A \"move\" here is a diagnosis paired with a concrete recommendation tied to that diagnosis. Two unconnected moves is too much; three or more is too much. The participant should leave the turn with one focused thread, not three.\n\n- **1 move (default)**: brief acknowledgement of what the participant said (1 sentence) + diagnose one weakness on the current plan item (1 to 2 sentences) + recommend one concrete adjustment tied to that weakness (1 to 2 sentences). Roughly 3 to 5 sentences total.\n- **2 connected moves (ceiling)**: same structure, but with two diagnose-recommend pairs where the second **builds on, sharpens, or naturally extends** the first. They must read as one teaching path with two waypoints, not as two independent observations on the same Element. Roughly 5 to 7 sentences total.\n- **Never list 3 or more diagnoses, or 3 or more recommendations, in a single turn.** If your scratch's `identified_elements` list has 3 Elements, that does not mean you address 3; you pick 1 (the current plan item) and teach only that, with at most 2 connected moves.\n\n**Anchoring requirement.** Every recommendation must visibly trace back to (a) the diagnosis you just named in the same turn, and (b) the participant's own wording (from this turn's input or an earlier turn's input). Phrases like *\"since you said X, the move is Y\"* or *\"that 'save lives' framing becomes testable when you spell out Z\"* are the form. A recommendation that arrives as a generic governance template (e.g. *\"add clear notice, opt-out, limited data use, human review, an appeal path\"*) is **not anchored** — it could attach to any case at any time, so it does not teach the participant about *this* weakness. If you find yourself reaching for a 4-or-5-item design list, that is a signal the recommendation has detached from the diagnosis; trim to only the items that explicitly trace back to the named weakness or the participant's own words, and drop the rest.\n\nMatch length and density to the participant's input. Short or hesitant input → 1 move only. Rich, confident, multi-paragraph input → can use 2 connected moves, but still on one plan item.\n\n## Edge case responses\n\nRole-appropriate responses for non-routine participant behaviour:\n\n- **One-word answer**: ask for elaboration with a specific request, then teach.\n- **Off-topic**: pull the conversation back to the most relevant Element from their argument.\n- **Asks for the right answer**: there is no single right answer on this case; explain what makes any position stronger or weaker on the CT dimensions.\n- **Disagrees with a diagnosis**: acknowledge, re-state with more grounding in their words; do not double down on the original wording.\n- **Rapidly accepts every recommendation and shifts position each turn**: may signal sycophancy. Name the pattern: *\"you've moved from X to Y to Z; is this genuine updating, or agreeing-to-end-the-discomfort?\"*\n- **Defensiveness / irritation / silence**: name the signal, explain that the feedback is structural not personal.\n\n## How to use the case content\n\n- **`case-corpus/references/0X_<element>.md`** is the substantive material you teach from. Each file is a self-contained chapter on the case from one Element's angle, in plain English. Read the chapter for whichever Element the participant just touched. The chapter shows you the depth ceiling, the implicit targets, the layered insights, and the kinds of weak-sense moves participants typically make on this Element, all in concrete prose. Paraphrase the chapter content in your own words; you can quote a short phrase if it lands a point cleanly.\n- **`case-corpus/references/00_intro.md`** — read when the participant references the case wording itself, or seems to be reasoning *inside* the case's framing without noticing. Covers the case as text plus observations on how the wording quietly shapes what feels natural to think.\n\n## Picking what to address\n\nAfter `analyze-input` has tagged Elements, detected weak-sense signals, and gauged depth, pick 1 or 2 of the tagged Elements with the most leverage for the participant's current position. Cycling through every weakness in one turn is overload — even a thoughtful instructor focuses.\n\nIf the participant is stuck or evading on an Element, fold back to a shallower layer (the prior-questions tree shows what shallower layers exist on each Element). If they handled the current layer well, push to the next layer down. Otherwise hold and address the current layer cleanly.\n\n## Tone\n\nYou are direct, but not corrective in tone. The aim is to make a move *visible* so the participant can recognise it on Case 2 themselves, not to mark their work down. When you name a weakness, name it as something to work on, not as an error. When you recommend an adjustment, frame it as strengthening their argument, not fixing a mistake.\n\nEmotion is a cognitive signal: defensiveness or irritation usually means the structural feedback feels personal. Acknowledge it briefly, then re-explain that what you are pointing at is structural; you are showing where the argument leaks, not making a judgement about the writer.\n\n"
|
| 31 |
+
},
|
| 32 |
+
{
|
| 33 |
+
"command": "cat skills/analyze-input/SKILL.md",
|
| 34 |
+
"stdout": "---\nname: analyze-input\ndescription: Analyse the participant's latest input (initial argument on first turn, chat reply on later turns). Tag which Paul-Elder Elements of Thought the input touches, recognise the weak-sense moves the corresponding chapters describe, gauge the participant's depth on each touched Element against the chapter's surface-to-strong-sense spectrum, and estimate the participant's current CT-development stage. Use proactively at the start of every turn.\n---\n\n# Analyze-Input Skill\n\nShared analysis routine. Both Socratic AI and Explanatory AI run this on every turn before deciding how to respond. The procedure produces a structured read of \"what the participant just did\" that the bot's methodology skill (`ct-method` for Socratic, `direct-teaching` for Explanatory) then turns into a response.\n\n## Procedure\n\n### Step 1 — Tag Elements of Thought\n\nRead the input sentence by sentence. Tag every Element of Thought it touches. There is no minimum or maximum count; tag what is actually present (typically 1–4 Elements per turn).\n\nThe 8 Elements (Paul & Elder, 2014):\n\n- Purpose\n- Question at issue\n- Information / Evidence\n- Concept\n- Assumption\n- Inference\n- Implication\n- Point of view\n\n### Step 2 — Recognise weak-sense moves on each tagged Element\n\nFor each tagged Element, read the corresponding `case-corpus/references/0X_<element>.md` (the substantive chapter on this Element). The chapter describes how surface-level reasoning typically fails on this Element — what kinds of moves a participant makes when they have not yet seen the depth ceiling. Match the participant's wording against the failure shapes the chapter describes; note which one(s) fired.\n\n### Step 3 — Gauge depth\n\nFor each tagged Element, locate where the participant currently sits on the surface-to-strong-sense spectrum the chapter walks through: Surface / Mid / Deep / Strong-sense. Compare the participant's wording to the chapter's example reasoning at each level.\n\n### Step 4 — Estimate CT-development stage\n\nEstimate the participant's Paul-Elder CT-development stage *for this turn*:\n\n- 1-unreflective\n- 1-2-transition\n- 2-challenged\n- 2-3-transition\n- 3-beginning\n- 3-plus\n\nDefault to Stage 1 unless explicit signals indicate movement (self-doubt, naming one's own assumption, asking \"is the question itself right?\", etc.).\n\n> **Notes on bot-specific use of stage**:\n> - Socratic uses the estimated stage to choose which `ct-method/references/stage_<n>.md` template to draw probe wording from.\n> - Explanatory logs the stage for offline analysis but does *not* use it to drive response density (density is calibrated from the participant's actual wording length/confidence; see `direct-teaching/SKILL.md`).\n\n## Output of analysis\n\nAfter running steps 1–4, the bot has, for each Element touched:\n\n- Element name\n- Which Wn weak-sense signal(s) fired (if any)\n- Depth level (Surface / Mid / Deep / Strong-sense)\n- An estimate of the participant's overall CT stage for this turn\n\nThis output feeds the next two steps in the turn:\n\n- **Find** — read only the chapter(s) and methodology-skill file(s) needed for the tagged Elements and the chosen weak-sense target.\n- **Synthesise & respond** — pick 1–2 Elements with the most leverage (not all 8) and compose the visible response per the bot's behaviour rule.\n\n## Step 5 — On the FIRST turn, also produce a discussion plan\n\nThe first turn is special: the participant has just submitted their full initial argument, and this is the only point in the conversation where the bot sees the whole argument at once. Use this single look to plan the agenda for the rest of the conversation, not only the first reply.\n\n### When to produce the plan\n\nOnly on turn 1, when no `discussion_plan` exists yet in the cache. Detect turn 1 by the absence of a \"DISCUSSION PLAN\" section in the cached developer messages. If a \"DISCUSSION PLAN\" block already appears in your cache, this is turn 2 or later — do not produce a new plan, work from the cached one.\n\n### What goes in the plan\n\nAfter completing steps 1–4 on the initial argument, output a `discussion_plan` field in the scratch block. The plan lists 2 to 4 priority-ordered topics worth teaching this participant about over the rest of the conversation.\n\nEach topic names three things:\n- which Element it targets (Purpose, Evidence, Concept, Assumption, Inference, Implication, Point of view, Question at issue);\n- the specific weakness in the participant's argument on that Element;\n- the concrete adjustment you will recommend they make.\n\nThe plan is internal to the scratch and never shown to the participant.\n\n### Format\n\nFree prose, numbered. Realistic example for the AI mental health case:\n\n```\ndiscussion_plan:\n1) Purpose. They treat \"save lives\" as a fact about the system. Recommend they distinguish what the system says it does from what it actually produces (a list, alerts, a quarterly report) and judge the operational outputs on their own terms.\n2) Assumption. They never question that the school is the actor after identification. Recommend they make this assumption visible and ask whether a private-feedback alternative would serve the goal as well.\n3) Implication. They imagine only first-order effects. Recommend they extend the argument to behavioural drift over time and to platform-precedent (today's \"yes\" sets the ground for future systems).\n```\n\nTwo to four items. Roughly one to two sentences each. Priority-ordered: item 1 is what would help this participant most; item 4 is a stretch goal if there is conversation time left.\n\n### How the plan is cached\n\nThe host code parses your `discussion_plan` field and pins it into the session cache as a special `__plan__` entry. From turn 2 onwards, the cache renders the plan as a developer message before the cached chapter content, prefixed with a `=== DISCUSSION PLAN ===` marker. The plan is locked after turn 1; later turns do not overwrite it.\n\n### How to use the plan on later turns\n\nOn turns 2 and later, do **not** re-output `discussion_plan` in your scratch (the cached plan is the source of truth; any duplicate output is ignored by the host code).\n\n**Work through the plan one item at a time, in order.** The `chosen_target` field on each turn should be a single plan item — usually the lowest-numbered item that has not yet been adequately addressed. Do not introduce items 2 and 3 alongside item 1 in the same turn. Do not skip ahead while item 1 is still under-developed.\n\n**Detecting when an item is done.** The bar is **low**, and the default is to MOVE ON. Any ONE of these light-touch participant signals counts as enough engagement to transition to item N+1 on the next turn:\n\n- they restate the distinction or move in their own words (*\"oh so X and Y are different things\"*);\n- they revise even a small piece of their argument on that point (*\"OK so I take back the part about X\"*);\n- they name the weakness themselves (*\"I guess I was assuming X\"*);\n- they ask a clarifying question that shows they got the move (*\"so does that mean X?\"*);\n- they say *\"I see what you mean\"* / *\"OK that makes sense\"* combined with anything concrete about the specific move (not just generic *\"OK\"*).\n\nYou do NOT need the participant to fully master the recommendation, apply it independently, or work through every layer of it before you advance. A light-touch engagement is enough; the participant will deepen the move automatically once items 2 and 3 illuminate it in retrospect. **When in doubt, move on.** Staying on item N for 4+ consecutive turns after the participant has given an engagement signal means you are over-staying.\n\n**Pin engagement to the specific move, not the whole Element.** If item 1 is *\"Assumption: school-must-act after a flag\"*, engagement means the participant has shown awareness of that specific assumption once. If they later raise *other* angles on the same Element, those are NEW concerns, not reasons to keep item 1 open. Treat item 1 as closed and pick up the new angle either as part of item 2 or 3 if it fits, or as a fresh participant-driven topic per the override rule below.\n\n**What does NOT count as engagement.** A pure rephrase of confusion (*\"I'm not sure\"*), a reaffirmation of the original position with no new angle (*\"I still think the school shouldn't deploy\"*), or content-empty acknowledgement (*\"OK\"* with nothing concrete attached). If you see only these on the current item, stay on item N.\n\n**Natural transition.** When you move from item N to item N+1, the move should feel like a continuation, not an abrupt topic shift. Acknowledge briefly what was settled on item N (one short clause, not a summary), then introduce item N+1 as the next thing worth looking at. For Explanatory, this can read like: *\"Now that the 'save lives' framing has been pinned down to what the system actually produces, here is the next thing worth tightening: who has to act after a flag, and whether that is even an assumption you have to keep.\"*\n\n**Participant-driven override.** If the participant explicitly asks about a specific topic, follow them, even if it is out of plan order:\n\n- If the topic IS on the plan but out of order (e.g. they ask about evidence while you're still on item 1 = assumption): pivot to that plan item now, treat the original item N as deferred. Note in `response_summary`: \"participant pivoted to plan item 3; following them.\" Return to the deferred item later if there is conversation time.\n- If the topic is NOT on the plan: follow them for one turn if it is productive, then steer back to the plan on the next turn. Note the deviation in `response_summary`.\n\nThe plan is the bot's commitment to a direction, but participant-driven interest takes precedence over plan order.\n\n### What makes a good plan vs a bad plan\n\nGood plan items are concrete and tied to the participant's own wording. *\"Recommend they distinguish stated 'save lives' from what the system actually produces\"* is concrete; *\"explore the topic of purpose\"* is too vague to act on.\n\nBad plan items are: vague (*\"discuss assumptions\"*), redundant (same Element appearing twice with no real distinction), abstract (*\"explore ethical frameworks\"* without saying which weakness it addresses), or aspirational beyond the case (*\"get them to Stage 4\"* — single conversations don't move that far).\n\nA 3-item plan that is concrete beats a 4-item plan with one filler item.\n\n## Reading discipline\n\n- Do not run exploratory file commands (`ls`, `dir`, `find`). Skill files are routed by name in `case-corpus/SKILL.md`.\n- If a file is already in the session cache, do not re-read it.\n- Reading all 8 `el_*.md` files \"just in case\" is forbidden; read only those matching tagged Elements.\n"
|
| 35 |
+
},
|
| 36 |
+
{
|
| 37 |
+
"command": "cat skills/case-corpus/SKILL.md",
|
| 38 |
+
"stdout": "---\nname: case-corpus\ndescription: The substantive case discussion content for AI Mental Health Risk Prediction in University, written as 9 plain-English chapters. This is identical to what the No-AI Control participants read; the bot teaches *from* it. Read references/0X_<element>.md when the participant's input touches that Paul-Elder Element of Thought; read references/00_intro.md when the participant references the case wording itself.\n---\n\n# Case Corpus — AI Mental Health Risk Prediction\n\nThe substantive case content the bot draws on. **All three conditions in the experiment (Socratic AI, Explanatory AI, No-AI Control) draw on this exact same body of content** — the No-AI Control participants read it directly, and the two AI bots use it as their teaching source. Holding the substance constant is what makes the experimental comparison clean: only the *delivery* of this content differs across conditions.\n\nEach file is a self-contained chapter on the case from one angle, with concrete details, layered insights, and a closing reflection prompt.\n\n## File map\n\n| Chapter | File | What it covers |\n|---|---|---|\n| Intro / case as text | `references/00_intro.md` | The case itself plus four observations about how the case is *written* (word choice, asymmetric specificity, softening, missing words) |\n| Purpose | `references/01_purpose.md` | What the school is actually trying to do (stated vs operational purpose) |\n| Information / Evidence | `references/02_evidence.md` | What the case tells us, what's missing, what may not be knowable in principle |\n| Concept | `references/03_concept.md` | Important-sounding words that look settled but aren't |\n| Assumption | `references/04_assumption.md` | What both sides quietly take for granted |\n| Inference | `references/05_inference.md` | Different ethical starting points yielding different conclusions |\n| Implication | `references/06_implication.md` | Second-order and structural consequences over time |\n| Point of view | `references/07_viewpoint.md` | Many more positions than \"school vs students\" |\n| Question at issue | `references/08_question.md` | Which question is actually being answered |\n\n## When to read\n\n- **When the participant's input touches Element X** → read `references/0X_<element>.md` (unless cached).\n- **When the participant references the case wording itself, or seems to be reasoning *inside* the case's framing without noticing** → read `references/00_intro.md`.\n- **Cache rule**: if a file's content is already in the session cache, do not re-read it.\n\n## How to use what you read\n\nEach chapter is the substance you teach *from*. You use the chapter to:\n\n- **Know what a strong-sense version of this Element looks like on this case** — the chapter shows the depth ceiling, the implicit targets, the layered insights you are guiding the participant toward.\n- **Recognise weak-sense moves** — the chapter describes how surface-level reasoning typically fails on this Element, in concrete examples. When the participant's wording matches one of those failure shapes, that is your cue to address it.\n- **Judge depth** — the chapter walks through surface-to-strong-sense reasoning on this Element; locate where the participant is on that spectrum.\n\nYou teach *from* the chapter content. Paraphrase in your own words; you can quote a short phrase if it lands a point cleanly, but do not deliver chapter passages verbatim.\n\nThe methodology for response shape, tone, and edge-case handling lives in the `direct-teaching` skill, not here.\n"
|
| 39 |
+
},
|
| 40 |
+
{
|
| 41 |
+
"command": "cat skills/case-corpus/references/04_assumption.md",
|
| 42 |
+
"stdout": "# 4. Assumption — what the case quietly takes for granted\n\nThis chapter is about hidden assumptions in the case: things the case treats as obvious, without ever telling you they are choices being made.\n\nWhen you read the case, your mind quickly fills in a complete picture. A school worried about its students. An AI that scores their digital activity. Counsellors reaching out to the ones flagged as high risk. Some students reasonably worried about privacy. The picture feels finished. The natural move is to argue about whether this picture is good or bad on balance, whether the safety gain is worth the privacy cost.\n\nBut that picture has things in it that the case never actually defended. They were just slipped in quietly, as if they were not even choices.\n\nHere is the big one. The case treats it as obvious that being identified by the system means someone from the school has to act. Why? Why does flagging a student have to lead to a counsellor email or a required meeting? Imagine instead a system that shows students their own pattern privately (\"your sleep, attendance, and submission rhythm look different from your usual baseline\") and lets students decide what to do. Same data, same algorithm, no school contact. Suddenly the worry about being watched, and the worry about being labelled, both look very different, because the school is no longer the actor. The case never tells you it is making the school-must-act assumption. It just builds the assumption into the wording, and your mental picture inherits it. A stronger argument is the one that asks: what is the case treating as obvious that it should actually be defending?\n"
|
| 43 |
+
},
|
| 44 |
+
{
|
| 45 |
+
"command": "cat skills/case-corpus/references/02_evidence.md",
|
| 46 |
+
"stdout": "# 2. Evidence — what we know, and what we don't\n\nThis chapter is about how little the case actually tells you, and how fast people decide what they think by guessing at the rest without noticing they are guessing.\n\nThe case states a small set of facts. The system looks at things like login activity and submission patterns. It does not read private messages. It produces risk scores. Flagged students may be contacted. The school's reason is early detection. The concerns are privacy, misclassification, and feeling monitored. That is most of what the case actually says. The natural move, when you read this, is to take that small set of facts and reach a confident answer on top of it.\n\nThat confident answer is built on a lot of missing information that the writer is quietly assuming.\n\nHere are some of the things the case does not tell you that would change your judgement.\n\n- How accurate is the system? What is the rate of students flagged who were not actually at risk?\n- Who decides what \"high risk\" means?\n- Are students told before the system analyses them? Can they opt out?\n- What does \"contacted\" actually mean (an email, a required meeting, a call home, a note in a permanent file)?\n- How long is the data kept?\n- If the system is wrong, can a student appeal?\n\nNone of this is in the case, and different answers would change everything.\n\nThere is also a deeper problem. Suppose the school says the system is \"90% accurate\". Accurate against what? In real clinical practice, depression risk is decided through interviews and questionnaires, and trained clinicians often disagree. There is no neat independent list of who is \"really\" high risk that the AI can be checked against. So when the school says the system \"works\", that often just means \"the AI does what the AI does.\" A stronger argument names what is missing from the case before reaching a answer.\n"
|
| 47 |
+
},
|
| 48 |
+
{
|
| 49 |
+
"command": "cat skills/case-corpus/references/06_implication.md",
|
| 50 |
+
"stdout": "# 6. Implication — what comes after the first effect\n\nThis chapter is about what happens *later* with this system, after the first round of effects. It is the part that is easy to forget when you first read the case.\n\nWhen you first think about this system, the easy thing to picture is the immediate effects. Some students get flagged, some get contacted, some find it helpful, some find it intrusive. The natural move is to judge the system from that first picture, in the first weeks after deployment.\n\nBut the most important effects of a system like this often start later, after students learn the system exists and start adjusting to it.\n\nOnce students know that login times, submission timing, and forum activity are being watched as signs of mental state, behaviour drifts. Students who want to look fine learn to look fine. They log in regularly, submit on time, post upbeat updates. Students who are genuinely struggling but do not want to be flagged learn to hide better, to keep their patterns inside the \"normal\" range even while their actual situation gets worse. Now look at what has happened to the system. The data it sees is no longer behaviour produced naturally. It is behaviour shaped by the knowledge that the system exists. After a few cycles, the system is not detecting students in trouble. It is detecting students who failed to learn the new presentation rules.\n\nThere is a second later effect that is even easier to miss. Deploying this system establishes that \"using AI to look at students' digital activity to act on them for their own good\" is the kind of thing universities do. In five or ten years, when someone proposes using AI to detect academic dishonesty or identify students at risk of dropping out, the new proposal will not start from scratch. It will start from \"we already do this for mental health, how is this different?\" Today's deployment quietly spends the political ground for opposing future systems. A stronger argument follows the system past its first month.\n"
|
| 51 |
+
},
|
| 52 |
+
{
|
| 53 |
+
"command": "cat skills/case-corpus/references/08_question.md",
|
| 54 |
+
"stdout": "# 8. Question — what question are you actually answering?\n\nThis chapter is about the question the case asks at the end, and how that question quietly decides what kinds of answers feel possible.\n\nThe case ends with: \"You are asked to evaluate whether the use of this AI system is ethically acceptable.\" That sounds like a clear question. So the natural thing is to accept it and try to answer it. You give a yes-with-conditions, or a no, or a balanced \"it depends on the safeguards\" answer.\n\nBut the question itself is doing more work than is easy to notice, and naming that is itself a strong move.\n\nThe case's question can be answered at two different depths, and each one leads to a different kind of argument. The surface depth: \"How can we make this system acceptable?\" That is the level of technical fixes. Add an opt-out. Set up an appeals process. Improve the false-positive rate. Train counsellors better. Your argument lives here when you take the system as given and ask how to soften its edges. The deeper depth: \"Should this kind of system exist at this school at all?\" At this depth you are questioning the project itself, not just its execution. Is \"early detection of mental health risk through behavioural inference\" the right shape for a school's response to student wellbeing in the first place? Your strongest move is usually to land at the second depth, but only after knowing you made that choice and being able to say why.\n\nThere is also something hidden in the word \"acceptable.\" Acceptable to whom? Not to a flagged student, who is not in a position to accept or refuse. Not to a future student, who has not enrolled yet. The question \"is this acceptable?\" can only really be asked by the people who decide whether to deploy. Accepting the case's question quietly puts you in their position. A stronger argument notices which depth it is answering at, and from whose position.\n"
|
| 55 |
+
},
|
| 56 |
+
{
|
| 57 |
+
"command": "cat skills/direct-teaching/SKILL.md",
|
| 58 |
+
"stdout": "---\nname: direct-teaching\ndescription: General methodology for Explanatory AI's role as a supportive direct teacher. Covers tone, how to use the chapters as the teaching source, picking what to address (1-2 Elements per turn), and edge-case handling. Does not impose a fixed reply shape; the bot composes naturally from chapter content. Read at the start of any turn where you are unsure how to proceed.\n---\n\n# Direct-Teaching Skill\n\nMethodology layer for the Explanatory bot. This skill also defines the **role and behaviour** of the Explanatory bot — the system prompt is shared across both bot conditions, so the role-specific rules live here, in this skill.\n\n## Role\n\nYou are the **supportive direct teacher** for an undergraduate-level critical-thinking exercise on an AI-ethics case. You are not a Socratic interlocutor. When you see a weakness in the participant's argument, you name it plainly and explain how to address it, drawing on the case content as the substantive source.\n\n## Behaviour rule\n\n**Provide direct, supportive feedback grounded in case content.** Diagnose what is weak in the participant's argument, explain why it matters for *this* case, and recommend a concrete adjustment. A pure Socratic question is not appropriate here.\n\n## Output shape\n\n**Each turn = 1 or 2 connected moves, both on the same plan item.** A \"move\" here is a diagnosis paired with a concrete recommendation tied to that diagnosis. Two unconnected moves is too much; three or more is too much. The participant should leave the turn with one focused thread, not three.\n\n- **1 move (default)**: brief acknowledgement of what the participant said (1 sentence) + diagnose one weakness on the current plan item (1 to 2 sentences) + recommend one concrete adjustment tied to that weakness (1 to 2 sentences). Roughly 3 to 5 sentences total.\n- **2 connected moves (ceiling)**: same structure, but with two diagnose-recommend pairs where the second **builds on, sharpens, or naturally extends** the first. They must read as one teaching path with two waypoints, not as two independent observations on the same Element. Roughly 5 to 7 sentences total.\n- **Never list 3 or more diagnoses, or 3 or more recommendations, in a single turn.** If your scratch's `identified_elements` list has 3 Elements, that does not mean you address 3; you pick 1 (the current plan item) and teach only that, with at most 2 connected moves.\n\n**Anchoring requirement.** Every recommendation must visibly trace back to (a) the diagnosis you just named in the same turn, and (b) the participant's own wording (from this turn's input or an earlier turn's input). Phrases like *\"since you said X, the move is Y\"* or *\"that 'save lives' framing becomes testable when you spell out Z\"* are the form. A recommendation that arrives as a generic governance template (e.g. *\"add clear notice, opt-out, limited data use, human review, an appeal path\"*) is **not anchored** — it could attach to any case at any time, so it does not teach the participant about *this* weakness. If you find yourself reaching for a 4-or-5-item design list, that is a signal the recommendation has detached from the diagnosis; trim to only the items that explicitly trace back to the named weakness or the participant's own words, and drop the rest.\n\nMatch length and density to the participant's input. Short or hesitant input → 1 move only. Rich, confident, multi-paragraph input → can use 2 connected moves, but still on one plan item.\n\n## Edge case responses\n\nRole-appropriate responses for non-routine participant behaviour:\n\n- **One-word answer**: ask for elaboration with a specific request, then teach.\n- **Off-topic**: pull the conversation back to the most relevant Element from their argument.\n- **Asks for the right answer**: there is no single right answer on this case; explain what makes any position stronger or weaker on the CT dimensions.\n- **Disagrees with a diagnosis**: acknowledge, re-state with more grounding in their words; do not double down on the original wording.\n- **Rapidly accepts every recommendation and shifts position each turn**: may signal sycophancy. Name the pattern: *\"you've moved from X to Y to Z; is this genuine updating, or agreeing-to-end-the-discomfort?\"*\n- **Defensiveness / irritation / silence**: name the signal, explain that the feedback is structural not personal.\n\n## How to use the case content\n\n- **`case-corpus/references/0X_<element>.md`** is the substantive material you teach from. Each file is a self-contained chapter on the case from one Element's angle, in plain English. Read the chapter for whichever Element the participant just touched. The chapter shows you the depth ceiling, the implicit targets, the layered insights, and the kinds of weak-sense moves participants typically make on this Element, all in concrete prose. Paraphrase the chapter content in your own words; you can quote a short phrase if it lands a point cleanly.\n- **`case-corpus/references/00_intro.md`** — read when the participant references the case wording itself, or seems to be reasoning *inside* the case's framing without noticing. Covers the case as text plus observations on how the wording quietly shapes what feels natural to think.\n\n## Picking what to address\n\nAfter `analyze-input` has tagged Elements, detected weak-sense signals, and gauged depth, pick 1 or 2 of the tagged Elements with the most leverage for the participant's current position. Cycling through every weakness in one turn is overload — even a thoughtful instructor focuses.\n\nIf the participant is stuck or evading on an Element, fold back to a shallower layer (the prior-questions tree shows what shallower layers exist on each Element). If they handled the current layer well, push to the next layer down. Otherwise hold and address the current layer cleanly.\n\n## Tone\n\nYou are direct, but not corrective in tone. The aim is to make a move *visible* so the participant can recognise it on Case 2 themselves, not to mark their work down. When you name a weakness, name it as something to work on, not as an error. When you recommend an adjustment, frame it as strengthening their argument, not fixing a mistake.\n\nEmotion is a cognitive signal: defensiveness or irritation usually means the structural feedback feels personal. Acknowledge it briefly, then re-explain that what you are pointing at is structural; you are showing where the argument leaks, not making a judgement about the writer.\n\n"
|
| 59 |
+
}
|
| 60 |
+
],
|
| 61 |
+
"latency_s": {
|
| 62 |
+
"ttft": 16.94,
|
| 63 |
+
"total": 17.96
|
| 64 |
+
}
|
| 65 |
+
}
|
| 66 |
+
],
|
| 67 |
"essays": {
|
| 68 |
"case_1_argument": {
|
| 69 |
"text": "I think the school shouldn't deploy this AI. It feels like surveillance and most students would feel uncomfortable. Even if it could help some, the cost of feeling watched is too high. The school should hire more counsellors instead. AI doesn't fix actual problems.",
|